walter block's rebuttal of objectivist criticism of libertarian ism

25
Reason Papers Vol. 26 Libertarianism vs Objectivism; A Response to Peter Schwartz 1  Walter Block Loyola University New Orleans For many years, Rand and the Randians would not mention libertarianism in print. To do so would be to give sanction to what they regarded as a mischievous and misbegotten political philosophy. Happily, this  profoundly and intellectually source ended with the publication of Schwartz (1986). This was a no holds barred attack on several libertarian thinkers, including myself. It is a pleasure defending the philosophy of libertarianism in the present reply. Schwartz’s article is a vicious attack on libertarianism. When I first read it I cringed, not because of the ideas, which are not really that challenging, but because it is so nasty as to be almost unprecedented in what  passes for scholarly writing. Rand (1964, 1967) criticized authors such as David Hume and Immanuel Kant as “whim-worshippers,” “muscle-mystics,” “Huns,” and “Attillas,” and Schwartz is an apt student of hers in this regard. Such verbiage is hardly welcome in rational discourse. According to Schwartz libertarianism amounts to nihilism. The chief nihilist, as it happens, is Block (1991). It is important that there be a systematic to reply to this document 2 . There have been many criticisms of libertarianism ov er the y ears, from the left. As a result, advocates of this  philosophy are accustomed to dealing with charges that the free enterprise system is heartless and pro poverty. Attacks from the right are a new challenge 3 . Second, a reply gives us an opportunity to further reflect on the essence of libertarianism. Schwartz attacks libertar ianism at its very roots. 1. Too heterogeneous 1 This article is based on two speeches on this sub ject made to the Greater Vancouver Libertarian Association, and to the Laissez Faire Books Supper Club in New York City, both in 1986. I thank Paul Geddes of the G VLA, and the Andrea Rich of LF Books for their support. 2 For other libertarian replies to Schwartz (1986), see Miller and Evoy (1987), Bergland (1986). All otherwise unidentified quotations are from Schwartz (1986). 3 Libertarianism is considered by many to occupy a position on the political economic spectrum of the ex treme right. Thus, there are virtually no critiques of this perspec tive from anyone w ho might be placed on the right side of this spectrum. For a possible exception, see Friedman-Block unpublished letters, 1999.

Upload: maty-aksenton

Post on 09-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 1/24

Page 2: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 2/24

Page 3: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 3/24

Page 4: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 4/24

Page 5: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 5/24

Page 6: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 6/24

Page 7: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 7/24

Page 8: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 8/24

Page 9: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 9/24

Page 10: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 10/24

Page 11: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 11/24

Page 12: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 12/24

Page 13: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 13/24

Page 14: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 14/24

Page 15: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 15/24

Page 16: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 16/24

Page 17: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 17/24

Page 18: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 18/24

Page 19: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 19/24

Page 20: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 20/24

Page 21: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 21/24

Page 22: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 22/24

Page 23: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 23/24

Page 24: Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

8/8/2019 Walter Block's Rebuttal of Objectivist Criticism of Libertarian Ism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/walter-blocks-rebuttal-of-objectivist-criticism-of-libertarian-ism 24/24