CASE TITLE: JEROME M. DAABAY vs. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILIPPINES, INC. DATE: August 19, 201PONENTE: J. R!"!sDI#EST BY: J$%& M'(%)!* +',)TOPIC: S!-).)t'$& $/ P$0!.s 1 T%! R$*! $/ t%! Ju,'(')."2ACTS:T%! ()s! st!3s /.$3 )& '**!g)* ,'s3'ss)*, '**!g)* sus-!&s'$& )&, 4LP ($3-*)'&t 5*!, 6" D))6)",).!gu*).!3-*$"!!$/C$()-C$*)/$.7"!).s, )g)'&stt%!($3-)&". A(($.,'&gt$t%!()s!,D))6)"8s !3-*$"3!&t 0)s t!.3'&)t!, $& Ju&! 2009, $& )(($u&t $/ )**!g)t'$&s '& )& ):,)v't/.$3 ) (!.t)'& C!s). S$.'&, t%)t D))6)" 0)s -).t $/ ) ;($&s-'.)("< t%)t )**$0!, t%! -'*/!.)g!$/ ($3-)&" -.$-!.t". Su(% *$ss!s 0!.! ($&5.3!, '& )& '&v!&t$." )&, )u,'t. D))6)" 0)s g'v!&) N$t'(! t$ E=-*)'& 0't% P.!v!&t'v! Sus-!&s'$&, )&, D))6)" ($3-*'!, t$ s)', N$t'(!, ,!&"'&g)&"-).t'('-)t'$&'&t%!)**!g!,;($&s-'.)("!, 6)s's ($&s',!.'&g t%)t D))6)" 0)s ,'s3'ss!, /$.Cust ()us!.As ) .!su*t $/ t%! CA ,!('s'$&, D))6)" )--!)*!, t$ t%! SC. ISS4EES:FON D))6)" 3)" ;.!v'v!< t%! 'ssu! $/ FON %'s ,'s3'ss)* %), /)(tu)* )&, *!g)* 6)s!s ,!s-'t!t%!)ss)'*!,CA,!('s'$&6!'&g($&5&!,$&*"t$t%!'ssu!$/ FOND))6)"0)s!&t't*!,t$.!t'.!3!&t 6!&!5ts )s g.)&t!,. ?This was because Daabay included in his plea to the SC an afrmation of the LAs Decision,withthemodifcationtoinclude: a! hisallowancesandother beneftsor their monetarye"ui#alent in the computation of his bac$wa%es& b! his actual reinstatement& and c!dama%es, attorneys fees and liti%ation e'penses.@HELD:NO. P!t't'$& $/ D))6)" 0)s ,!&'!,.RATIO:T%! C$u.t 5.st t$$> &$t! $/ t%! /)(t t%)t t%! )--!)* 0)s 6.$ug%t t$ t%! CA &$t 6" D))6)", 6ut6" C$()-C$*), )&, 0)s *'3't!, t$ t%! 'ssu! $/ FON .!t'.!3!&t 6!&!5ts 0!.! -.$-!. '& D))6)"8s()s!. T%! ($..!(t&!ss $/ t%! NLRC8s ,!('s'$& $& D))6)"8s ,'s3'ss)* 0)s )*.!)," 6!"$&, t%!)--!**)t! ($u.t8s )ut%$.'t" t$ 3$,'/". C't'&gAndaya#( )L*C,t%!C$u.t !3-%)s'A!,t%)t )-).t"0%$%)s&$t )--!)*!,/.$3),!('s'$& 3)" &$t $6t)'& )&" ):.3)t'v! .!*'!/ /.$3 t%! )--!**)t! ($u.t $t%!. t%)& 0%)t %! %),$6t)'&!, /.$3 t%! *$0!. ($u.t, '/ )&", 0%$s! ,!('s'$& 's 6.$ug%t u- $& )--!)*. A*s$, t%!C$u.t ('t!,+ano#( Sanche,,st)t'&gt%)t t%!!&t.!&(%!,-.$(!,u.)* .u*!'&t%'sCu.'s,'(t'$& 's t%)t ) -).t" 0%$ ,', &$t )--!)* ()&&$t )ss'g& su(% !..$.s )s ).! ,!s'g&!, t$%)v! t%! Cu,g3!&t 3$,'5!,. A** t%)t %! ()& ,$ 's t$ 3)>! ) ($u&t!.-)ss'g&3!&t $/ !..$.s $. t$).gu! $& 'ssu!s .)'s!, 6!*$0 $&*" /$. t%! -u.-$s! $/ sust)'&'&g t%! Cu,g3!&t '& %'s /)v$.. Du! -.$(!ss -.!v!&ts t%! g.)&t $/ ),,'t'$&)* )0).,s t$ -).t'!s 0%$ ,', &$t )--!)*. C$&s',!.'&gt%)tD))6)"%),&$t"!t)--!)*!,/.$3t%!NLRC8sR!s$*ut'$&t$t%!CA, %'s-*!)/$.t%!3$,'5()t'$& $/ t%! NLRC8s 5&,'&gs 0)s t%!& 3's-*)(!,. T%! C$u.t %!*, t%)t '/ 't 0!.! t$ .!v'!0)** 3)tt!.s t%)t ).! .)'s!, '& t%! -!t't'$&, 't 0$u*, 6)s'()**" t$*!.)t! 0%)t D))6)" 0)s 6)..!,t$ ,$ 6!/$.! t%! )--!**)t! ($u.t. D))6)" Cust'5!s %'s -*!) /$. .!*'!/ 6" st)t'&g t%)t %! %)s )*s$ 5*!, ) su6s!Du!&t MR $/ t%!NLRC8s R!s$*ut'$&, 6ut t%! s)3! 0)s &$t )(t!, u-$& 6" t%! NLRC. T%! C$u.t %!*,, %$0!v!.,t%)t t%! )**!g)t'$& 0)s st'** '&su:('!&t t$ )**$0 %'3 t$ '&s!.t %'s -*!) /$. .!*'!/s )*$&gs',! t%!)ss)'*!, CA ,!('s'$&. D))6)" 0)s )*s$ &$t!, t$ %)v! /)'*!, t$ '&s!.t t%! MR 0%'(% %! )**!g!,*"5*!, 0't% t%! NLRC )&, s!!> NLRC8s .!s$*ut'$& $& t%! 3)tt!. !v!& t%$ug% 2 "!).s %)v! -)ss!,0't%$ut t%! MR 6!'&g u&.!s$*v!,. Ev!& g.)&t'&g t%)t t%! MR 0)s 5*!, 0't% t%! NLRC, t%! SC &$t!, t%)t t%! NLRC s%)** 5.st 6!g'v!& t%! $--$.tu&'t" t$ .!v'!0 'ts 5&,'&gs )&, .u*'&gs $& t%! 'ssu! $/ t%! *!g)*'t" $/ D))6)"8s,'s3'ss)*, )&, t%!& ($..!(t t%!3 s%$u*, 't 5&, t%)t 't !..!, '& 'ts ,'s-$s't'$&. T%! SC ()&&$t, 6"t%'s -!t't'$&, -.!-!3-t t%! )(t'$& 0%'(% t%! NLRC, )&, t%! CA '& ()s! $/ )& )--!)*, 3)" t)>!$& t%! 3)tt!.. ?)-T.: / did not discuss the labor retirement! aspect of the case as it was not rele#ant to thetopic at hand( 0lease refer to the full ori%inal case for the SCs discussion on the non1eli%ibilityof Daabay for retirement pay(@