urban drainage modeling for storm water design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 ›...

33
Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using QL2 LIDAR A Los Angeles County Case Study Benjamin H. Houston P.E., PMP, GISP Karen L. Kwasnowski, GISP

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design

Using QL2 LIDAR

A Los Angeles County Case Study

Benjamin H. Houston

P.E., PMP, GISP

Karen L. Kwasnowski, GISP

Page 2: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using
Page 3: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Show the drainage network - where runoff flows over land.

Develop catchments

Derive metrics

Image courtesy of hydrology.usu.edu TauDEM 5.1 Quick Start Guide

Use Elevation data to:

Page 4: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

What’s the Big Deal?

MS4 Permit Compliance

Infrastructure design

Flood response

Catchment Characteristics

Infiltration islands in a parking lot in San Mateo, California, help reduce runoff. (Photo

courtesy of John Kosco) water.epa.gov

Page 5: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

What’s the Big Deal? Currently a very slow, labor intensive process.

Estimate: ~30 Years to complete with current methodology

Page 6: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

LA Pilot Area- Characteristics

Page 7: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Target Deliverables

Page 8: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Point Cloud Resolution

DEM 35cm 70cm 1.4m

1ft n/a n/a

3ft * n/a

5ft

RED is the default standard for 1ft contour development

Table 1. Point Cloud Resolution/DEM Matrix

Page 9: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Point Density

35cm Point spacing 70cm Point spacing

Page 10: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

TIN Surface Model

35cm Point spacing 70cm Point spacing

Page 11: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Drainage Network Analysis

Drainage Network – 35cm post spacing

Page 12: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Drainage Network Analysis

Drainage Network – 70cm post spacing

Page 13: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Drainage Network Analysis

Drainage Network – 35cm green 70cm orange

Page 14: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Software Tools?

Page 15: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Original DEM Fill Sinks Flow Direction Flow

Accumulation

Are breaklines

(still) needed?

Highways Gutters Sink Mask Berms Voids Centerlines

Modified DEM

Begin Modeling

NO

YES

Page 16: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Original DEM Fill Sinks Flow Direction Flow

Accumulation

Are breaklines

(still) needed?

Highways Gutters Sink Mask Berms Voids Centerlines

Modified DEM

Begin Modeling

NO

YES

Page 17: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Surface Prep

Workflow- Modeling

Stream Network Accumulation

Threshold QC

GO BACK to Surface Prep

Catchment Polygons

Pour Point Analysis

QC

Merge Catchments

Pour Point Adjustments

Finish!

Page 18: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Surface Prep

Workflow- Modeling

Stream Network Accumulation

Threshold QC

GO BACK to Surface Prep

Catchment Polygons

Pour Point Analysis

QC

Merge Catchments

Pour Point Adjustments

Finish!

Page 19: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Fill Sinks

Page 20: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Page 21: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Page 22: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow- Surface Prep

Original DEM Fill Sinks Flow Direction Flow

Accumulation

Are breaklines

(still) needed?

Highways Gutters Sink Mask Berms Voids Centerlines

Modified DEM

Begin Modeling

NO

YES

Page 23: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Surface Prep

Workflow- Modeling

Stream Network Accumulation

Threshold QC

GO BACK to Surface Prep

Catchment Polygons

Pour Point Analysis

QC

Merge Catchments

Pour Point Adjustments

Finish!

Page 24: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow - Modeling

Page 25: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using
Page 26: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow - Modeling

Page 27: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Workflow - Modeling

Flow Accum Threshold too low – tiny watershed, surface is correct.

Dark Blue Watershed Too Large – surface prep issue - need a sink mask.

Page 28: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Lessons Learned

Mask the Stadium so that it doesn’t get filled.

Page 29: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Lessons Learned

Page 30: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Lessons Learned

Page 31: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Lessons Learned

Page 32: Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design › uploads › 7 › 7 › 6 › 5 › 7765286 › ppt3_urban... · 2019-12-04 · Urban Drainage Modeling for Storm Water Design Using

Conclusions

• LiDAR for 1’ contours (QL 2) is sufficient • ArcGIS still comes out ahead • Prepare the surface!

– Prepare the surface • Prepare the surface

– Prepare the surface

• Workflow is iterative • Save 20+ years. • Save 70-80% of manual labor.