trial technology in the courtroom...5/12/2017 2 o.j. simpson was a free man, despite evidence that...
TRANSCRIPT
5/12/2017
1
James Herrity, Litigation Technology Consultant
Background in Computer Science, from SUNY Buffalo
• Over 15 years in the legal industry• Supported over 100 trials• Involved in, and created graphics for over 1,000 cases• Some Notable Cases include:
• Valassis v News America Marketing
($300 Million verdict: Largest in MI State History)
• PNY v Samsung (International Arbitrations in London, UK)
• Tutor v Westgate (6 month trial, Millions of Documents)
• LG v Whirlpool
• Star-Brite v Gold Eagle (Federal False Adv. trial with Berger Singerman)
• FieldTurf v AstroTurf
• USA v Ferguson (AIG Fraud Trial)
5/12/2017
2
O.J. Simpson was a free man, despite evidence that would have convicted almost anyone else in the country. Trial lawyers all over the country took notice and learned an important lesson. If you have complicated evidence that is a crucial part of your case, you had better explain it to the jury in a manner that is clear and easy to understand. To that end, prosecutors and plaintiff attorneys have become much smarter when it comes to using technology to present their cases.
O.J. Simpson was a free man, despite evidence that would have convicted almost anyone else in the country. Trial lawyers all over the country took notice and learned an important lesson. If you have complicated evidence that is a crucial part of your case, you had better explain it to the jury in a manner that is clear and easy to understand. To that end, prosecutors and plaintiff attorneys have become much smarter when it comes to using technology to present their cases.
5/12/2017
3
On February 6, 1995, Judge Lance Ito approved the use of a video marking device for use in his courtroom during the O.J. Simpson trial in Los Angeles. The technology was requested by attorneys when they found that they needed an easy way to focus the judge and jury's attention on video evidence displayed on four monitors, a video projector, and -- with Judge Ito's approval – to the news media for television broadcast.
This was our first taste of trial technology broadcast right to our homes!
5/12/2017
4
More likely than not, your jurors:
• Watch 4 hours of TV per day
• Own a computer• Have access to the internet• Own a Smartphone• Have a Facebook Acct• Use YouTube
• Would embrace technology presentation
Weiss-McGrath Retention Study
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Hear See Hear and See
Retention After 72 Hours
5/12/2017
5
Brings your evidence to life
Enables you to draw their attention to parts of the exhibits you want them to see
Highlighting on the fly enables you to assist the jurors in following along as you read a document
Impeaching with video testimony is much more effective when you see the witness contradicting himself/herself live
Graphics enable you to simplify complex concepts
5/12/2017
6
NYND Courthouse FLMD Courthouse
OHSD CourthouseFairfax Co. Courthouse
5/12/2017
7
2 Laptops (Primary and a Backup) / External Harddrives
Projector (over 3000 lumens) / Projector Screen
Flat Panel Monitors
Document Camera
Printer / Scanner
Wifi / Wireless Access Device
PowerPoint Remote
Laser Pointer
VGA Switcher / VGA Splitter (Distribution Amp)
Power Cords, Power Strips
VGA Cables
Gaffer’s Tape
5/12/2017
8
What is Trial Pad?
• Trial Presentation App for iPad
Where can I get Trial Pad?
• Itunes for $129.99
When should I use it?
• Smaller cases / Hearings• Not many exhibits• No need for flexibility or adding exhibits to your database “on the fly”
What do I need to make it work?
• iPad• VGA-iPad Adapter• Dropbox
5/12/2017
9
How will I present my evidence in trial?
In what electronic format do you want the exhibits from opposing counsel?
Will any witnesses be testifying via video deposition/videoconference?
Will I want impeachment clips created?
What do I want to do for my opening statement presentation?
How is the courtroom set up?
If not set up for technology already, what technology do I want to use?
Will the court allow me to bring in outside equipment?
Who will run the equipment at trial and troubleshoot any A/V issues?
Does the court require an Equipment Order to bring in equipment, phones, etc.?
5/12/2017
10
5/12/2017
11
5/12/2017
12
5/12/2017
13
5/12/2017
14
5/12/2017
15
5/12/2017
16
Jurors retain six times as much information when your presentation combines visual evidence with oral presentation
Proper use of technology can not make a bad case good, but it can make a good case great
Three keys: Preparation, Flexibility and Seamless
Trial attorneys who embrace the use of a multi-media presentation in the courtroom will have a substantial advantage over those that do not.
5/12/2017
17
Trial Technology Podcast
LinkedIn Groups:• Trial Technology• Legal IT Lit Support• Trial Graphic &
Presentation Consulting• ExhibitView• Ligation Support Tech• …And many more
James Herrity
(917) 532-1905