the perfect storm - wordpress.com...the perfect storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
ThePerfectStormExplainingtheRiseofISIS
CheriBalounMAIRCapstoneDecember2016
ABSTRACT
Al Qaeda changed the terrorism movement with aspirations of a global jihad.Following the September 11, 2001 attacks in New York, Washington DC, andPennsylvania,alQaedarosetothetopofAmerica’sthreatlist.Aftertheinvasionof Iraq in 2003, al Qaeda responded by expanding its influence into the newlyrestructured Iraq, establishing al Qaeda in Iraq. Differences in organizationalfocusandstrategyledtothesplitofalQaedaandalQaedainIraqin2014.Theorganizationwenowknowasthe IslamicStateof IraqandSyriawasborn. Theentitytransitionedfromaterroristorganizationtoaninsurgencygroup,capturingkey cities, likeMosul innorthern Iraq, anddeclaring the reestablishmentof theIslamic Caliphate, a theological empire. The civil war in Syria facilitated thespreadof thegroup intoSyria. ThewithdrawalofU.S.military forces fromIraqleft the Iraqi government weak, and religiously divided, the government wasunable to support or protect its people. The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria hasarguably become the strongest and richest jihadist organization. Their globalrecruitment showcases the effectiveness of their technological capabilities andskills.ThepurposeofthispaperistoanalyzetheconditionsthatexplaintheriseoftheIslamicStateofIraqandSyria.
![Page 2: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 1
TableofContents
Introduction...........................................................................................................................2
Background............................................................................................................................2TheBeginning..............................................................................................................................................................................2Jamaatal-Tawhidwa-l-Jihad.................................................................................................................................................3MajlisShuraal-Mujahedin......................................................................................................................................................5IslamicStateofIraq...................................................................................................................................................................5IslamicStateofIraqandSyria..............................................................................................................................................6ComparisonofalQaedaandISIS.........................................................................................................................................7ExpertViews...........................................................................................................................8Globalization................................................................................................................................................................................9Incomeinequality......................................................................................................................................................................9SectarianDivide..........................................................................................................................................................................9U.S.MilitaryWithdrawal......................................................................................................................................................11PoliticalInstability..................................................................................................................................................................11IraqiGovernment.....................................................................................................................................................................12SyrianCivilWar........................................................................................................................................................................13
TippingPointTheory............................................................................................................14LawoftheFew.........................................................................................................................................................................15StickinessFactor......................................................................................................................................................................15PowerofContext.....................................................................................................................................................................15
Analysis:ElementsofthePerfectStormandTheTippingPoint.............................................16Figure1:AQI/ISIOperatingAreaComparison...........................................................................................................16
TheTippingPoint....................................................................................................................................................................18Conclusion............................................................................................................................18
Appendix1...........................................................................................................................20Definitions..................................................................................................................................................................................20Insurgency..................................................................................................................................................................................20Terrorism...................................................................................................................................................................................20PerfectStorm............................................................................................................................................................................21CurrentISISDesignations....................................................................................................................................................21TABLE1.HistoryofISISNames........................................................................................................................................21
Bibliography.........................................................................................................................22
![Page 3: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 2
IntroductionTheIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS)isarguablythemostpowerfuland
profitablejihadiorganizationseeninmoderntimes.ISIShasbeenabletoaccomplishwhatotherjihadiorganizationslikealQaeda,foundedinthelate1980s,haveonlydreamedofdoing.Inlessthantenyears,ISIShastransitionedfromterroristgrouptoinsurgentgroup,establishingaself-governingcaliphate,harshlyrulingoverthepeoplelivingintheterritorythegroupcontrols.Afterthe2003U.S.invasionofIraq,SaddamHussein’sgovernmentparty,theminoritySunnis,wereoustedfrompowerandreplacedbythemajorityShia.TheShiathenhadcontrolofIraq’ssecurityforcesandinstitutions.CenturiesofSunni-Shiatensionsweresurfacing.ThesuddenlossofpowerfortheSunnis,afterbeingincontrolformorethan20yearsunderthereignofSaddamwasatoughpilltoswallow.InitialviolenceinIraqduringthistransitionaltimehadsectariandimensions,butafterthe2004-2005appointmentofinterimgovernmentandsubsequentelections,theattacksturnedpolitical.TheSunnisfeltunderrepresented,eventhoughtheyelectedtonotparticipateintheinterimgovernment,whichwasresponsibleforwritingIraq’sconstitution.
ThewithdrawalofU.S.militaryforcesleftapowervacuum.AfterthereelectionofPrimeMinisterMaliki,therepressionofSunnissharplyincreased.SecurityforcesinIraqwereseeminglytargetingSunnis.TheIraqigovernmentappearedtobeunresponsivetotheblatanttargetingandattacksonSunnis,provingMalikiwasnotabletoprotectallofthepeopleofIraq.ThepoliticalsituationandinternalconflictinSyriablossomedintoacivilwar.ISIScapitalizedonthedisarrayinSyria,requisitioningcontroloflargeportionsofthecountryandnamingRaqqaasthecapitalafterthedeclarationofthecaliphateinJune2014.
ThefocusofmyresearchhasbeentothoroughlydescribetheestablishmentofISISbeginningwithitsfounder,AbuMusabalZarqawi.Afterhisdeathin2006,subsequentISISleaderscontinuedwithZarqawi’soriginalvisionforISIS,bestcapturedandcarriedoutbyAbuBakralBaghdadi.IwantedtounderstandwhyISISleadershavebeenabletoachievetheirgoals,surpassingalQaeda,ISIS’“parentorganization,”onallfronts.IchosetoexploretheconditionsexplaintheriseoftheISIS.IexaminedandgatheredcommonlyidentifiedreasonsbehindtheriseofISISinbothscholarlyandnewsarticles.
Ihypothesizedthatthecombinationofpoliticalinstability,inthecontextofthenewIraqigovernmentandtheSyrianCivilWarcoupledwithSunni-Shi’areligioustensionsinIraq,andthewithdrawalofU.S.militaryforcesexplaintheriseofISIS.Inmypaper,Iarguethatthereisnotonecondition,butaculminationofmultipleconditions,a“perfectstorm”ofsorts,thatexplainstheriseofISIS.
Background
TheBeginning AbuMusabalZarqawiwasbornAhmadFadhilNazzalalKbalaylabinZarqa,Jordanin1966.1Bornintoalargefamily,BedouinsfromtheBaniHassantribe,Zarqawigrewup
1Weaver,MaryAnne.2006."InventingAl-Zarqawi.(Coverstory)."Atlantic297,no.6:87-100.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016).87-88.
![Page 4: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 3
modestlyinaroughneighborhoodknownforitsheavyinfluenceofdrugsandguncrime.2Zarqawidroppedoutofschoolwhenhewasseventeen,afterthedeathofhisfather,andbecameviolent,turningtodrugsandalcohol.Knownforbeingabullyandathug,hisfirstprisonstintwasin1984fordrugpossessionandsexualassault.Zarqawiwasreleasedfromprisonin1988andmadehiswaytoAfghanistanin1989,tofightagainsttheinvasionoftheSovietUnion.Showinguptoolatetoparticipateinthefighting,hebecameinvolvedwithAbuMuhammadalMaqdisi,afellowJordanianandwell-knownradicalSalafist.ItisunclearwhereZarqawibeganhispathtoradicalization,prisonorhistimeinAfghanistan,3butMaqdisimagnifiedZarqawi’sradicalbeliefsandbroadenedhisterroristcontacts.TogethertheyformedBayatal-Imam,Zarqawi’sfirstjihadigroup. BothmenreturnedtoJordanin1992andquicklyfoundthemselvesontheradarofJordanianauthoritiesduetotheirpubliccriticismofthekingandthetreatyJordansignedwithIsrael.4ZarqawiandMaqdisiweresentencedtofifteenyearsinprisonin1994afteraraidonZarqawi’shouseproducedaweaponscache.Theyflourishedinprison,MaqdisiplayingthepartofreligiousadviserandZarqawifulfillingtheroleofenforcementandrecruitmentintoBayatal-Imam,whichultimatelyfailedtotakeoffinthewayZarqawihadhoped.Maqdisibeganwritingreligiouspiecesandfamilymemberssmuggledthemfromprisonforpublishing.SoonZarqawiwasalsopublishing.Hisviolent,radicalbeliefsanddeclarationthatanyonewhodisagreedwithhimwasaninfidelcaughttheattentionofOsamabinLaden,alQaeda’sleader,in1998.Zarqawiwasreleasedfromprisonin1999ingeneralamnesty. ZarqawileftJordanalmostimmediately,andultimatelyreturnedtoAfghanistanwherehepurportedlymetwithbinLaden,whodistrustedZarqawiforhisoutwardcriticismofalQaeda’ssupportoftheTaliban,hisintensehatredforShiites5aswellashiscriminalbackground,andhisstanceontargetingeveryone,includingotherMuslims,whodisagreedwithhim.6ItisallegedthatbinLadenaskedforZarqawitojoinalQaeda,butherefused,7anddesiringhisowntrainingcamp,ZarqawicommittedtotrainingotherJordanianprisoners,whowerealsoreleasedingeneralamnesty.WithasmallamountofmoneytostartthecampfrombinLaden,ZarqawisetupshopinwesternAfghanistanin2000.Itwasalsoaroundthistime,Bayatal-ImambegantransitioningitselftoJamaatal-Tawhidwa-l-Jihad(JTWJ).
Jamaatal-Tawhidwa-l-Jihad InresponsetotheSeptember11,2001attacks,theU.S.invadedAfghanistanin
shortlyaftertheattacks,forcingZarqawitorelocate.HefoundhimselfmovingbetweenIran,IraqiKurdistan,Syria,andtheSunniTriangleinIraq.Usingthistohisadvantage,
2Michael,George.2007."TheLegendandLegacyofAbuMusabal-Zarqawi."DefenceStudies7,no.3:338-357.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016),339.3Gambill,Gary.2004.“AbuMusabal-Zarqawi:ABiographicalSketch.”JamestownTerrorismMonitor2,issue24.AccessedNovember11,2016.https://jamestown.org/program/abu-musab-al-zarqawi-a-biographical-sketch/.4Kirdar,M.J.2011.“AlQaedainIraq.”CenterforStrategic&InternationalStudies.AccessedNovember11,2016.https://www.csis.org/analysis/al-qaeda-iraq,2.5Ibid.,2-3.6Zelin,AaronY. "TheWarBetween ISISandal-Qaeda forSupremacyof theGlobal JihadistMovement."WashingtonInstituteForNearEastPolicy:ResearchNotes20,(June10,2014):1.Military&GovernmentCollection,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016),1-2.7StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”MappingMilitantOrganizations:April4,2016.FirstaccessedNovember10,2015.http://web.stanford.edu/group/mappingmilitants/cgi-bin/groups/view/1.
![Page 5: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 4
ZarqawicontinuedtomakeconnectionsandrecruitforJTWJ.8UpuntilColinPowell’sFebruary2003speechtotheUnitedNationsSecurityCouncil,Zarqawiwasanundistinguishedjihadifighter.9Powell’sspeech,meanttomakethecasefortheU.S.invasionofIraqaswellasgarneralliedsupport,launchedZarqawiintothespotlightonaninternationalplatform.ZarqawiwasfalselynamedasthelinkbetweenalQaedaandtheSaddamHusseinregime.10 WiththeinvasionofIraq,Zarqawibecameahouseholdname.JTWJhadrelocatedtonorthernIraqandcontinuedtogrowtheirforces,mostofwhichwereforeignfightersfromJordan,Syria,Afghanistan,Pakistan,andKurdishregions.11Thegrouphadafour-partplanaftertheirrelocation.First,theyworkedtodriveoutU.S.andcoalitionforces.Second,JTWJhinderedthegovernmentaltransitionandIraqisupportofthenewgovernment.Third,theirfocusturnedtostoppingthereconstructionofIraq.JTWJbegankidnappingciviliancontractors,humanitarianaidworkers,andotherforeignersinIraq.SoonbeheadingvideoswerebeingcirculatedacrosstheInternet,apracticeJTWJinitiated,themostinfamousbeingtheexecutionofAmericanNicholasBerginMay2004.ThebeheadingisbelievedtohavebeencarriedoutbyZarqawihimself.AtleasttenothermurdersconductedinasimilarmannerwereposthumouslylinkedtoJTWJ.ThefourthpartofJTWJ’splanwastheplacementofcarbombsoutsideShiitemosquesandreligioussites.Hundredsofworshipperswerekilled.JTWJwasquicklybecomingknownfortheirviolentmethodsandtargetingofnon-combatants,aidworkersandIraqiciviliansforexample.12
InOctober2004,ZarqawipledgedhisallegiancetobinLadenandJTWJchangedtheirnametoalQaedaintheLandofTwoRiversoralQaedainIraq(AQI).ThemergerputZarqawiincontrolofAQIandthustheflowofforeignfightersintoIraq.ThiswouldlaterprovetobeimportantwiththeconflictinSyriaandrepositioningforcestherethroughcontactsandconnectionsZarqawipreviouslymade.13TensionsbetweenAQIandalQaedawerebecomingapparent.AQIcontinuedtoconductextremeandviolentattacks,whichoncegarneredSunnisupport,wasstartingtodissuadecurrentsupportersaswellasalienatepotentialsupporters.14TopalQaedaleaderssentmultipleletterstoZarqawiin2005,remindinghimofalQaeda’slong-termgoalsandaskinghimtoworktowardsfosteringsympatheticrelationshipswithallIraqis.15
Iraq’snationalelectionsin2005andthecreationoftheconstitutionwereseenasfailuresforAQIandotherjihadigroups,whichresultedinanincreaseinsuicideattacksandviolencethroughouttheyear.ManyoftheseattackswereaimedatShiitesandoccupyingcollaborators.SupportforZarqawiwaswaningbecauseoftheindiscriminate,brutaltacticsandtheinfluxofforeignfighters,includingZarqawihimself.AlQaedawarnedZarqawiabouttargetingShiitesandrecommendedminimizingthecollateraldamage.IgnoringalQaeda’sadvicetotonedowntheviolence,AQIorganizedthebombingsofthreehotelsinAmman,JordaninNovember.Jordanian’sprotestedandthebacklashfromthose
8Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,”1-2.9Chambers,Peters.2012."AbuMusabAlZarqawi:TheMakingandUnmakingofanAmericanMonster(inBaghdad)."Alternatives37,no.1:30-51.SocialSciencesCitationIndex,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016).10Weaver,MaryAnne."InventingAl-Zarqawi,”88.11StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”12Gambill,Gary.“AbuMusabal-Zarqawi:ABiographicalSketch.”13Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"2-3.14StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”15Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"3.
![Page 6: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 5
attacksdiminishedZarqawi’ssignificance.16
MajlisShuraal-MujahedinInearly2006,ZarqawibroughttogetheranumberofIraqijihadfactionsunderAQI
administrationandrenamedthecoalitionMajlisShuraal-Mujahedin(MSM),hislastditchefforttoredeemhisstature.However,ZarqawiwaskilledinadroneattackinJune2006,andMSMendedwithZarqawi’sdeath.17AlQaedaimmediatelyreplacedZarqawiwithAbuAyubalMasri(akaAbuHamzaalMuhajir),anEgyptianbombmakerwithtrainingexperienceinAfghanistan.OnOctober15,astatementwasreleasedannouncingtheestablishmentoftheIslamicStateofIraq(ISI),arebrandingafterZarqawi’sfallfromgraceandthegroup’sdecliningfavor.AbuOmaralBaghadiwasnamedthenewleader.
IslamicStateofIraq TherebrandingandrenamingofAQItoISIafterZarqawi’sdeathwasintendedtogathermoresupport,locallyandregionally.Instead,itcreatedsignificantconfusionnotonlyforitsfighters,butintelligenceanalyststrackingthegroup.18LocalIraqiSunniswereincreasinglydissatisfiedwiththesignificantpresenceofforeignfightersandleadership,theorganization’sinsistenceofenforcingtheirownbrandofIslam,anduseofextremeviolence,whichalsoaffectedinnocentcivilians.ByplacinganIraqiintopower,AbuOmaralBaghdadi,Masrihopedtoregainstrengthinnumbers.MasrishiftedtothepositionofISIwarminister,althoughitisbelievedheretainedasignificantamountofcontrolovertheorganization.19 TherebrandingeffortswereineffectiveasISIlostmajorsupportandthegroupbecamerelativelyinoperativefrom2006to2010.Earlyin2007,jihadifighterswereabandoningISIandjoiningforceswithlocaltribestocombatISIintheSahwaorAwakeningMovement.FrustratedbyISIseekingtogoverntheirterritoryandforcingISIrulesuponthem,theAwakeningMovementcoordinatedwithU.S.andcoalitionforcestoconsiderablyreduceISIfightersinthewesternIraq.20“Byearly2008,coalitionandlocalsecurityforceshadkilled2,400AQImembers[AQIandISIwereusedinterchangeablyduetotherebrandingconfusion]andtaken8,800prisoners.Byspring2009,theU.S.wasfundingaround100,000localSunnistofightAQI.”21
BetweenJune2009andAugust2010,themajorityoftheU.S.militarywithdrewfromIraq.22ISIappearedtohavebeendefeatedandIraqwasonitswaytobeingstableandsecure.TheIraqimilitarybegantakingoverandmaintainingsecurityinIraq.IraqiSecurityForces,trainedbyU.S.forces,haddevelopedsignificantly.BetweenAugustandOctober2009,ISIhadregroupedandattackedgovernmentinfrastructures,killinghundredsofcivilians.InApril2010,bothMasriandAbuOmaralBaghdadiwerekilledinanIraqicounterterroroperationandbyJune80percentofISI’s42leaderswerekilledorcaptured.16Kirdar,M.J.“AlQaedainIraq,”3-4.17Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"3.18Kirdar,M.J.“AlQaedainIraq,”5.19StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”20Kirdar,M.J.“AlQaedainIraq,”5.21StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”22Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes.2015."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS)."AARMS:Academic&AppliedResearchInMilitary&PublicManagementScience14,no.4:363-378.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016),367.
![Page 7: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 6
AbuBakralBaghdadipromptlyassumedcontroloftheweakISI,apositionhewassuitedtohandleasco-founderofJayshAhlal-Sunnahwa-l-Jamah,ajihadistgroupthatoperatedinIraqaftertheU.S.invasionofIraqandmergedwithAQIin2004.Asasub-commanderwithintheranksofISIsince2004,BaghdadiwasperfectlyabletotakechargeofISI.Baghdadi’sfirststepsweretoreiteratethegroup’sgoals,focusingonweakeninganddestroyingtheIraqigovernment,andcreatinganIslamiccaliphate. BaghdadithensetouttorestructureISI.Heenvisionedadisciplined,hierarchicalstructure;Baghdadiformedgoverningandpolicymakingbodies,removedforeignersfromleadershippositionsandplacedthemintocombatroles,manyfulfillingoutreach,propaganda,recruitment,anddonationcollectionfunctions.BaghdadisoughtoutmembersofSaddamHussein’sformerBaathistregimetofillISI’smilitaryorsecurityleadershippositions.23U.S.forceslocatedandkilledbinLadeninPakistaninMay2011puttingbinLaden’ssecondincommand,AymanalZawahiri,incontrolofalQaedaanditsaffiliates,whichincludedISI.24
TheoutbreakoftheSyriancivilwaropenedadoorforISImovement.BaghdadisentISIoperativestoSyriatogathersupportandprepareforISIadvancement.ISIwascommittingtofightagainsttheBasharalAssadregime,anAlawite(aShiasect)dominatedgovernmentthatISIviewedasnon-MusliminfidelstryingtosuppressMuslims.25Duringthisexpansiontime,byDecember2011,U.S.andcoalitionforcesweregone,andwithlesspressureandsecurity,ISIattacksincreased,targetingtheIraqigovernmentandIraqiSecurityForces.TheSunniandShiadividedeepenedastheIraqigovernmentmarginalizedtheminoritySunnigroup.26ThegroupofISIoperativesBaghdadisenttoSyriaemergedasJabhatalNusrain2012,effectivelyfightingagainsttheAssadgovernment.ThegroupwasgrowinginpopularityandsupportinSyria,duetothedistributionoffoodandmedicinetowar-tornareas,whichotherSyrianopponentsoftheregimedidnotaccomplish.27
IslamicStateofIraqandSyriaInApril2013,BaghdadiannouncedtheexpansionofISIoperationsinSyriaandthe
mergerofISIwithJabhatalNusra(JN),28analQaedaaffiliateinSyria.29Torecognizetheirexpandedvision,ISIchangedtheirnametoIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS).JNandalQaedaleadershipdisputedtheunificationandZawahiridictatedthatISIS’sinfluenceshouldremaininIraq.RejectingZawahiri’smandate,ISIScontinuedtooperateinSyria,sometimesclashingwithotherIslamistgroups.JNwasandhadbeenwillingtoworktowardsacommongoalandfoughtagainsttheSyriangovernmentwithotherjihadistgroups.ISISleadershipdidnotsharetheirenthusiasmandpreferredtoestablishcontrolofmoreterritory.30
InOctober2013,ZawahiridemandedthatISISdisband,returnoperationstoIraq
23Hashim,AhmedS.2014."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate."MiddleEastPolicy21,no.4:69-83.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober17,2016),72-74.24Humud,CarlaE.2016. "AlQaedaandU.S.Policy:MiddleEastandAfrica."CongressionalResearchService:Report1-22. InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016),1.25Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”77.26StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”27Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”77.28StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”29Holbrook, Donald. 2015. "Al-Qaeda and the Rise of ISIS." Survival (00396338) 57, no. 2: 93-104. International Security & CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016),97.30StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”
![Page 8: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 7
onlyandleaveJNtocommandtheSyrianjihadis.BaghdadiargueditwouldbeasintodissolvetheuniononthebasisofIslamiclawandwasnotwithinthebestinterestsofISIS.HealsorefusedtoaccepttheSykes-PicotboundariescreatedbytheFrenchandBritishafterWorldWarI.31Aftermonthsoffighting,alQaedadisownedISISandofficiallyseveredallconnectionsinFebruary2014.32ISIShaddisobeyedalQaedaleadershiptoomuchandtoooften.ISISwasoperatingunderitsownconditions.33
ComparisonofalQaedaandISIS BinLadenandZarqawicameintotheirrolesduringthewarwiththeSovietsinAfghanistaninthelate1980s,binLadeninhisroleasalQaedaleaderandZarqawi,ajihadifighter,dedicatedtoattackingallinfidelsandnonbelievers,andfutureAQIleader.34AfterthedeathofZarqawi,Masri,andAbuOmaralBaghdadi,AbuBakralBaghdadipickedupwhereZarqawihadleftoffideologically.ThesebeliefsremainedinlinewithalQaedaideology,bothorganizationswishingtospreadIslamoveraslargeofageographicalareaaspossible,removingsecularstateinstitutions.35BothgroupsalsosoughttoestablishacentralIslamicgovernment,theCaliphate,enforcedbySharialawwiththeCaliphgivingordersandleadingthefollowerspoliticallyandreligiously.36However,theirdifferencesweredrastic. AlQaedapioneeredtheglobaljihad,advocatingattacksonallinfidels,particularlyAmericansathomeandabroad.37AlQaedasoughtoutAmericanandEuropeantargetsasthegroup’simmediatepriority.38AlQaedahasclaimedresponsibilityformultipleattacksagainsttheU.S.anditsalliedforcesincluding1998bombingofU.S.embassiesinKenyaandTanzania,theattackontheU.S.S.ColeinYemenin2000,andthemostinfamousattacks,theSeptember11,2001attacksinNewYork,WashingtonD.C.,andPennsylvania.39Byfocusingontargetsoutsideoftheregion,theSeptember11attacksandtheLondonbombingsforexample,alQaedawasabletobringthefightandinflicttheirideologyonpeopleofothercountries,outsidethereimmediatesphereofinfluence.40
ISISontheotherhand,iswagingjihadathome,mostISISattackshaveoccurredinSyria,andIraq.41In2014,ISISaddedapartnerorganizationinLebanon,42andnowisaffiliatedwithmorethan40groupsin16countrieslikeLibya,Nigeria,Egypt,SaudiArabia,Yemen,andAfghanistan.43ISIShastightcentralleadershipanddoesnotcoexistwellwithintheirseizedcommunities,asmostarefearfulofISISmembersandareagainsttheirextremetacticsandviolence.44ISIShasbeenmostlyconcernedwithlocalsectarian
31Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”77-78.32Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,”3and5.33Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”77-78.34Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"1.35Brown,CodyMcClain.2015."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria."PolitickaMisao:CroatianPoliticalScienceReview52,no.4/5:203-214.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober17,2016),204-205.36Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"368-369.37Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”205.38Ibid.,206.39Humud,CarlaE."AlQaedaandU.S.Policy:MiddleEastandAfrica,"1.40Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"369.41Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”206.42Gulmohamad,ZanaKhasraw.2014."TheRiseandFalloftheIslamicStateofIraqandAl-Sham(Levant)ISIS."GlobalSecurityStudies5,no.2:1-11.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016),2.43Boghani,Priyanka."WheretheBlackFlagofISISFlies."WheretheBlackFlagofISISFlies.May13,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://apps.frontline.org/isis-affiliates/.44Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"369.
![Page 9: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 8
fighting.ISISdoesnotseemtohaveplacedparticularemphasisontheglobaljihadinthesamewayalQaedahas.45
UnlikealQaeda,ISISwelcomesforeignfighterstoincreasenumbersinrankandhelpgovernoccupiedterritory.46ISISnowheavilyrecruitsforeignfightersfromaroundtheworldtoestablishthecaliphateastheirreligiousduty.Foreigners,inthethousands,havetraveledtoSyriatotrainandfightwiththeexpectationtheywillreturntotheirrespectivehomelandsandcarryoutjihad.ThishasbeenespeciallyrelevantinEuropewiththeattacksinFranceandBelgium.47MultipleattacksinGermany,theUnitedKingdom,andSpainhavebeenthwarted.48ISIShasalsocapitalizedoninspiringattacksaroundtheworld,callingon“true”Muslimstojointhecaliphateandcarryouthomegrownattacks.ManyMuslimshaveradicalizedthroughpropagandaontheInternet,whichismeanttoinspireindividuals,whocannottraveltoSyriatofight,butwanttodosointhenameofISISandtheCaliphate.TheSanBernardinoandtheOrlandonightclubattacksareexamplesofthis.49
ISISdesirestocreateapureSunnistateandthusmuchoftheirviolencehasbeensectarianinnature,againstprivatepropertyinShiapopulatedareasorreligiouscenters.ZarqawibelievedinordertosavetheIslamiccommunityitwouldneedtobepurged.AlQaedadoesnotsupporttheopinionthatMuslimsaretheproblem,butrecognizetheinstitutionsarewhatneedtobechanged.AlQaedahasmaintainedthatbyalieningthosewhosupportthem,theSunnisonly,thelong-termgoalofglobaljihadwouldbehurt.50
AlQaedahasneverpossessedorattemptedtocreateitsownstateandtheyhavenotcommittedtheorganizationtoadomesticinsurgency,insteadchoosingtorespecttheregimeofthecountrywheretheyarelocated.51InJune2014,BaghdadibeganreferringtoISISastheIslamicState,declaringtheterritoryoccupiedbytheorganizationastheircaliphate.AbuBakralBaghdadiwasnamedthecaliphorrulerandcalledforMuslimsaroundtheworldtojointhecaliphate.AlQaedawasunimpressedwithBaghdadi’sannouncement,assertinghenotonlydidnothavetherighttodeclareacaliphate,butthatthetimingwasnotappropriate.52ISIShasfulfilledZarqawi’sdream,tocreateandgovernastate.ThebiggestdifferencebetweenalQaedaandISISisthis:alQaedahasanetworkapproach,buildingsupportandforcesthroughcommunicativeoutreachversusISIS’sthugtactics,forcingindividualstojointheirranksorbekilled.ThesedifferencesultimatelyledtoalQaedaseveringtieswithISIS.
ExpertViews TherearemanyopinionsbehindthecomebackandexpansionofISIS.Explainedbelow,thislistisbynomeanscomprehensive.Itisnottheintentionofthispapertoclaimtheseperspectivesarerightorwrong,andthattheydidnotcontributetotheriseofISIS,45Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”206.46Mueller,John,andMarkG.Stewart.2016."MisoverestimatingISIS:ComparisonswithAl-Qaeda."PerspectivesOnTerrorism10,no.4:30-39.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016),32.47StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”48Pavlik,Melissa."ISIS'SCampaigninEurope:July16-August18,2016."InstitutefortheStudyofWar.September2,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://understandingwar.org/backgrounder/isiss-campaign-europe-july-16-august-18-2016.49StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”50Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"3.51Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”206.52Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”79.
![Page 10: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 9
butIbelievethreespecificconditions,thesectariandivide,politicalinstabilityinIraqandlaterSyria,aswellasthewithdrawalofU.S.militaryandcoalitionforcesfromIraq,togethercreatedtheidealenvironmentforISIStoflourish.
Globalization Inthearticle“RegionalizationofPoliticalViolence:ArabLevantandRiseofIslamicState”bySaima,A.KayaniRajaQaiserAhmed,andMuhammadShoaib,theauthorsalludetoglobalizationastheconditiongrowingterrorismintheformofnon-stateactorsintheMiddleEast,usingISISastheirexample.Alreadyplaguedwithregionalissues,suchassectariandivisions,authoritarianregimes,poorgovernance,andreligiousextremism,ISIShasbeenabletoriseduetoregionalpolitical,social,andeconomicsituationsinthecontextofglobalization.ByexploitingthesituationsinIraqandSyria,ISISwasabletofillthepowervacuumsandattractingforeignfighterswithdreamsofuninhibitedfreedomandwealth.53
IncomeinequalityAccordingtoanarticlepostedbytheWashingtonPost,ThomasPiketty,authorand
professorattheSchoolforAdvancedStudiesintheSocialSciencesandattheParisSchoolofEconomicsbelievesinequality,specificallyincomeinequality,isthedriverbehindterrorismintheMiddleEast.Intheoriginalarticle,publishedintheFrenchnewspaperLeMonde,PikettystatesWesternnationsaretoblameandtheregionalpoliticalandsocialsystemsarefracturedduetoahighconcentrationofoilwealthwithrelativelysmallpopulations.Theoilwealthissharedwithasmallportionofthepopulationandisalsocontrolledbyfew,askingthedistributionunequal.Pikettycriticizestheunequaldistributioncreatesadistressingeconomicconditions,providingjustificationforjihadifighters.TheregionalwarsperpetratedbytheWesternnationsarealsomentionedasvalidationforjihadistactionsasthesenationssupportthegovernmentscontrollingtheoilwealth.54
SectarianDivideTheSunniandShiadivideisnothingnew.Islamhasbeendividedforfourteen
centuries,SunnisandShiascoexistingpeacefullytogether,forthemostpart.WhiletheirritualsandinterpretationsofIslamiclawmaydiffer,theystillreadfromtheQuranandfollowtheteachingsoftheProphetMohammed.Moderndaysectarianismintheregioncanbepartiallylinkedtothe1979IranianRevolution,whereShiacleric,AyatollahRuhollahKhomeini,implementedanIslamicruledgovernment.KhomeiniencouragedMuslimunitybetweenthesects,butmanycountriesintheregionregardedIran’sShiaruledgovernmentasanopportunitytopushaShiaagenda,especiallySaudiArabia,whobeganassertingWahhabism,apuritanicalbrandofSunniIslamintotheregion.Shiaaretheminority,roughlyfifteenpercentoftheworldsalmosttwobillionMuslims,however,theyarethemajorityinIran.Itisbelievedthatmanyofthegroupsresponsibleforsectarianviolencein
53Kayani,SaimaA.,RajaQaiserAhmed,andMuhammadShoaib.2015."RegionalizationofPoliticalViolence:ArabLevantandRiseofIslamicState."Dialogue(Pakistan)10,no.1:1-21.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016).54https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/30/why-inequality-is-to-blame-for-the-rise-of-the-islamic-state/
![Page 11: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 10
theregionarelinkedtoSaudiandArabiantensions.TheIraq-IranWaroccurredfrom1980-1988.SaudiArabiabackedIraqwithmilitants,whoalsowenttoAfghanistantohelpfightagainsttheinvadingSovietUnion,weresuppressingShiamovementsbackedbyIran.TheseactionsvalidatedSunnisuspicionsofShiaantagonismtowardsthem.55 SaddamHusseinandhisBaathistpartyweremainlySunnis,theminorityinIraq.WiththeoverthrowofSaddamin2003andtheplacementofamajorityShialedgovernmentin2004,theformerlyoppressiveminoritySunnisbecametheoppressed.ThenewIraqiconstitutionprovidedforreligiousfreedom.ThebombingoftheShiiteshrine,AlAskariMosque,inFebruary2006,escalatedthepreviouslypoliticallychargedattacksintosectarianviolence.56Thesectarianconflictbetween2006and2008waspartiallyfueledbyShiitemilitantsrespondingtoSunniattacks.57
AftertheU.S.withdrawalattheendof2011,sectarianviolenceincreasedexponentially.December2011,theIraqigovernmentannouncedanarrestwarrantwasissuedforSunniVicePresidentTariqalHashimiandhissecurityteamamidallegationsofplanstoassassinateMaliki.ThiswasperceivedasamovetoconcentrateallofthepowerwithMaliki.U.S.officialsintervenedwithpoliticalfactionsandaconferencetoreachapoliticalagreementbetweenallfactionswasscheduledforMarch2012.Itneverhappened.InDecember2012,MalikiarrestedthebodyguardsoftheFinanceMinister,RafialIssawi,alsoaSunni.Sunnitriballeadersheldanti-MalikidemonstrationsinSunnicitiesdemandingthereleaseofprisonersarrestedunderantiterrorismandde-BaathificationlawsaswellasimprovedgovernmentservicesinSunnimajorityareas.
ByJanuary2013,smallamountsofforcewerebeingusedagainstSunnidemonstrators.Thisworsenedthediscontent.IraqiSecurityForceskillednineSunniprotestorsonJanuary25th,whichledtoanincreaseofISIattacksonsecurityforces.OnApril23,IraqiSecurityForcesattackedaSunniprotestcamp.Thistime,about40peoplehadbeenkilled.TheIraqigovernmentdidnotrespondpropellingSunnidemonstratorsandtriballeaderstotakeuparms,overthrowingregionalgovernmentbuildings.Sunniparliamentarian,Ahmadal-Alwani,wasorderedtobearrestedbyMaliki,andbytheendof2013,Sunniunresthadsharplyescalated.MoreattacksbyISIfollowed,whichkilled17IraqiSecurityForces.58UnderMaliki’sorder,IraqiSecurityForcesbeganinvadingSunniprotestcampsandwhenIraqiSecurityForcesattemptedtoclearaprotestcampinRamadiattheendof2013,Protestorsrebelled,drivingoutsecurityfromtheregion,providingISItheperfectlocationtotakeoverandgainterritory.ISIfighterswerejoinedbysomeSunniprotesters,59SunniattacksagainstShiitetargetsincreased,doublingtheciviliandeathtollin2013fromwhatitwasin2012.60
“…ThisconflictislessaboutIslamandIslamismthanitisaboutsectariandivisionsbetweenSunniandShiainIraqandSyria.”61TheSyriancivilwartransitionedtoamore
55"TheSunni-ShiaDivide."CouncilonForeignRelations.February2016.AccessedOctober16,2016.http://www.cfr.org/peace-conflict-and-human-rights/sunni-shia-divide/p33176#!/.56Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance."CongressionalResearchService:Report(March9,2016):1-40.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember14,2016),3-4;Kuoti,Yasir."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq,"7-9.57Kuoti,Yasir.2016."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq."JournalOfInternationalAffairs69,no.2:19-28.BusinessSourcePremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember1,2016),16.58Ibid.,22-24.59Ibid.,24.60StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”61Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”204.
![Page 12: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 11
sectarianbattleasISIbeganfightingwithotherSunnisupportsagainstBasharalAssad,aAlawaiteShia.62SectariantensionsshapedbyMaliki’smarginalizationofSunnileadersandcitizens,andtheconflictwithISIShascausedlimitationsinreligiousfreedomandfueleddiscriminationinIraq.Iraq’sdomesticpoliticalsituationsawsupportforISIScontributingtoitsgrowthinIraqfrom2012-2014.TheSunni-ShiastrifeinIraqaddsfurtherweighttotheargumentthattheongoingconflictcanbedescribedas“sectariancivilwar.”63
U.S.MilitaryWithdrawalTheinterventionandinvasionofIraqin2003steeredZarqawitowardanalliance
withalQaeda.ManyreligiousandtriballeadersplayedouttheinvasionasanunprovokedattackfromtheWestandanaggressiveattemptagainstallMuslims.ThecalltodefendIraqwassentouttoallmembersoftheMuslimcommunity,encouragingfighterstotravelanddefendtheresistance.ManyoftheseforeignfighterswereabsorbedintoAQIandfellinstepwithZarqawi’sorganizationalgoals. ThedisbandingandbarringofformerSaddamregimemembersfromholdingofficeorgovernmentpositionsencouragedthemtoassistandhouseforeignfighters.However,astheAQIgoalstransitionedtooccupyingterritoryversusfreeingitfromoccupyingforces,localtribesbeganfightingagainstAQI.Zarqawi’sdeathin2006incombinationwiththeAwakeningMovementcollaborationandthesurgeinU.S.troopsinearly2007sawasignificationreductioninISIfighters.64ISI’scapabilitiesdeclined,however,theorganizationwasneverdefeated.65U.S.officialsandpublicsupportforthewarwaswaningandwithIraqiSecurityForcesappearingtoberelativelywelltrainedanddisciplined,andanti-governmentgroups,ISIinparticular,showinglowlevelsofactivitywithsectarianviolencereasonablyundercontrol,althoughslightlyincreased,itwastimetowithdrawandallowIraqtocomeintoitsown.Bytheendof2011,U.S.andcoalitionforcesweregone.66 PrimeMinisterNuriAl-Maliki’sperceivedtargetingofSunnisholdingpositionswithinIraq’sgovernmentwithchargesofassassinationplansorterrorismoffensescausedSunniuprisingsagainstthegovernmentalloverIraq.In2013,theprotestmovementcampnearRamadistimulatedarebellionthatspreadthroughouttheAnbarProvinceinwesternIraqleadingMalikitoremovearmedforcesfromthearea.ThissecurityvacuumpavedthewayforISItoholdterritoryandorganizemajorjihadieffortsallovertheprovince.67
PoliticalInstability ISISholdsthemostterritoryinIraqandSyria,twocountriesplaguedwithinternalconflict.InstabilityevolvedfirstinIraq.SincethecreationofthenewIraqigovernmentafterthe2003invasion,thegovernmenthasexperienceddifficultyinsupportingandprotectingitspeople.ManysecurityforcespersonnelwereeitherpaidverylittleornotatallandsubsequentlysomeofthemleftgovernmentservicestosupportISIS.ThevolatilityinSyriaoriginatedinearly2011fromprotestsandhassinceevolvedintoacivilwar,killing
62Rodgers,Lucy,DavidGritten,JamesOffer,andPatrickAsare."Syria:TheStoryoftheConflict."BBCNews.March11,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-26116868.63Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”208.64Kirdar,M.J.“AlQaedainIraq,”5-9.65Celso,AnthonyN.2015."Zarqawi'sLegacy:AlQaeda'sISIS‘Renegade’."MediterraneanQuarterly26,no.2:21-41.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember12,2016),26.66Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”12.67Celso,AnthonyN.2015."Zarqawi'sLegacy:AlQaeda'sISIS‘Renegade’,”26-28.
![Page 13: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 12
and/ordisplacinghundredsofthousandsofpeople,torefugeecampsinLebanon,Turkey,andJordanaswellasseekingasyluminEurope.
IraqiGovernment In1988,Iraq’sleader,SaddamHussein,usedchemicalweaponsontheKurdishpeopleofnorthernIraq,killingtensofthousandsforaccesstotheoilrichregion,creatingconflictandresentment.HisauthoritarianregimefavoredtheSunniminorityingovernmentappointments,employmentopportunities,andmilitarypositionsoverIraq’sShiamajorityaswellastheKurds.68Insignificantdebtfromtheeight-yearlongIraq-IranWar,SaddaminvadedKuwaitinAugust1990overoildisputes.69TheinvasionledtoU.S.andUnitedNations(UN)imposedsanctions.IraqitroopswereforciblyremovedfromKuwaitbyU.S.militaryforce.ThesanctionswereneverremovedandIraq’sfailuretocomplywithUNenforcedmeasuresaddedtothelaundryoflistofreasonsfortheU.S.invasionofIraqin2003. SaddamandtheSunni-ledgovernmentlostpowerinApril2003.ByMay2003,AmbassadorL.PaulBremerwasappointedbytheBushadministrationastheleaderoftheCoalitionProvisionalAuthority,overseeingIraq’sinternalaffairsuntilanewgovernmentwasappointed.MembersofSaddam’sBaathpartywerebannedfromeverservinginagovernmentpositionandallofthedefenseandinteriorministriesweredisbanded.InJune2004,aninterimgovernmentwithamoderateShiiteleaderwasappointed.70BasedontheagreementbyallIraqifactions,theupcomingelectionswoulddeterminefuturepoliticaloutcomes,endingtheoccupation.ElectionswereheldonJanuary30,2005,whichproduceda275-seattransitionalparliamentandgovernmentmeanttowriteanewconstitutiontobepublicallyvotedonbeforethefull-termelectionswereheld.Withaproportionalelectionsystem,theSunnisboycottedandonlywon17seats.71 Thecommitteeformedtowritetheconstitutionconsistedof55members,themajorityofthembeingShiiteandoneofwhichwasSunni.AftercallsformoreSunniinclusion,fourSunniswereassassinateddaysintothewritingprocess.TheSunnisprotestedtonoavail.ByOctober15,2005,theconstitutionwasapproved72andnationalelectionswereheldonDecember15,2005.Again,theShiitesandKurdswerethemajorityleadersplacingaShiite,NurialMalikiasPrimeMinister.73Withthelossofpowerpolitically,theSunnissoughtauthorityelsewhere,rationalizingtheirviolence,carbombs,politicalassassinations,andelectionviolenceforexample,asawaytodisruptthenewIraqigovernment,whichtheysawasillegitimatesincetheywereunderrepresented.74 InFebruary2006,intheSunni-dominatedcityofSamarra,thebombingoftheShiiteshrine,AlAskariMosque,setoffmajorSunni-Shiiteviolenceaboveandbeyondpoliticalgrievances.Fast-forwardtothenationalelectionsonMarch7,2010.AseriesofappealswerefiledaftertheJusticeandAccountabilityCommissioninvalidatedalmost500candidates.Ultimately,MalikiandtheShiitepartywoneventhoughMaliki’simageasthe
68Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"364-365.69Kuoti,Yasir."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq,"20-21.70Ibid.,21.71Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”3-4.72Kuoti,Yasir."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq,"22.73Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”7.74Kuoti,Yasir."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq,"22-23.
![Page 14: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 13
protectorofIraqwassmearedwithseveralprominentattacksandbombingsin2009.Withthesecondfull-termIraqigovernmentinplace,theU.S.begantowithdrawitstroops.75
Afterthewithdrawal,however,thesegroupsbeganincreasingattacksinoppositionoftheMalikigovernment,resentmentofShiitedominatedgovernment.76The100,000IraqiSunnisfighterswhohadcooperatedwithU.S.andIraqiforcesagainstISIduring2006-2011aspartoftheAwakeningMovementwerepromisedintegrationintotheIraqiSecurityForcesorgovernmentjobsbytheIraqigovernment.Onlyabouttwo-thirdsreceivedthesebenefitsandtherestretainedtheirpositionsatcheckpointsinSunniareas,neverformallybeingindoctrinatedintoIraqiSecurityForcesbythetimeU.S.forceshadleft.ThisallegedlyresultedinsomejoiningtheIslamicStateoffensivesin2014.77
Iraqiswerelosingtrustintheirgovernment,asMalikiappearedtocontinuetobeself-serving,makingfalsepromises.ThevicepresidentandhissecurityteamwereeitherarrestedorhadarrestwarrantsissuedforallegationsofplanstoassassinateMaliki.ThiswasaperceivedpowerplaytoconcentrateallofthepowerwithMaliki.U.S.officialsintervenedwithpoliticalfactionsandaconferencetoreachapoliticalagreement.Theconferencedidnotoccur.LaterinDecember,Malikiarrestedthebodyguardsofthefinanceministercontinuinghissensedbidfordominance.78
FormerPrimeMinisterNurialMaliki’sregimeengagedincampaignsofviolenceandharassmenttowardsIraqiSunnis.Extrajudicialkillings,airstrikes,andtorturehavebeendocumented.79U.S.officialsblamedhimformarginalizingSunnileadersandcitizens,creatingfurthertensionsthroughoutIraqwhilehewasservinginpublicoffice.TheISISoffensiveinMosul,inJune2014,leadingtothecity’scaptureduetoIraqiSecurityForceseithersurrenderingordesertingthecityresultedinMalikilosinghisthirdtermasprimeministertoHaydaral-Abbadi.80
SyrianCivilWar ThecivilwarandoverallpoliticalsituationinSyriahasallowedforISIStoexpandthere.LikeIraq,Syriaisfacingsignificantinternalconflict.81Whatstartedoutasprotestsfollowingthearrestandtortureofteenagersforwritingpoliticalgraffitionaschoolwall,inMarch2011,promptedproteststoeruptinthesoutherncityofDaraa.Whensecurityforcesopenedfireonandkilleddemonstrators,moreprotestorstooktothestreets.DemandingPresidentBasharalAssadstepdown,campaignsagainsttheSyriangovernmentbrokeoutnationally.ByJuly2011,theoppositionsupportershadtakenuparms,escalatingtheviolence,throwingSyriaintocivilwarasbattlesforcontrolofcitiesensuedaroundthecountry.Thefightingreachedthecapital,Damascus,andAleppoby2012.
TheAssadregimehasbeencriticizedharshlyfortheiruseofforce.TheUNhasdocumentedevidenceofwarcrimes,suchasmurder,torture,rapeandenforceddisappearances,beingcommittedbyothersides.Thegovernmentisbeingaccusedofblockingaccesstofood,waterandhealthservicesasamethodofwar.Capitalizingonthe75Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”7-9.76Ibid.,12.77Ibid.,16.78Ibid.,22-23.79Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”208.80Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”24-25.81Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"364-365.
![Page 15: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 14
chaosinSyria,ISIShastakencontroloflargeportionsofthecountryaspartoftheirdeclarationofacaliphateinJune2014,namingtheSyriancityofRaqqaasitscapital.82Underthispretext,ISIShasbeeninflictingseverepunishmentsonthosewhorefusetoacceptitsrules,includinghundredsofpublicexecutionsandamputations.ISISfightershavealsocarriedoutmasskillingsofrivalarmedgroups,membersofthesecurityforcesandreligiousminorities,andbeheadedhostages.83
TheSyriancivilwarhastakenonsectarianovertonesalthoughitstartedasapoliticaluprising.SyriahasaSunnimajoritywithaShiapresident,fromtheAlawitesect,andtheriseoftheSunnijihadistgroup,ISIS,hasshiftedtheemphasisofthefighting.84ISIShasgrowninsizeandpowerwithitsmilitaryoffensivesinSyriaandIraq.ISISisnotonlyfightingagainstbothgovernments,butwithvariousrebelgroupsinSyriaaswell.85ISIShasfoundasafehavenandaccesstoweaponsinSyria.WhiletheSyriangovernmentisworkingtopushbackandextinguishrebelforcesspecificallyfightingagainstthem,ISIShasbeenfocusingitseffortsonclaimingadditionalterritory,distributingoffoodandmedicineinwartornareasinanefforttogatheradditionalsupport.86
TippingPointTheoryMalcolmGladwellfirstintroducestheideaofthe“tippingpoint”ina1996articlein
theNewYorkermagazine.Inthearticle,Gladwellsuggeststhetippingpointis“thepointatwhichanordinaryandstablephenomenon…canturnintoa…crisis.”87Hearguesthateveryepidemichasatippingpointandtofightit,thatpointneedstobeunderstood.Gladwellstatesthatepidemicsdon’tbehavethewaywethinktheywillandsocialscientistshavebegunrelatingthetheoryofepidemicstohumanbehavior.88Gladwellalsousesthe“brokenwindow”hypothesistoimplythatdisorderinvitesmoredisorderandinthecontextofvandalismorcriminalactivity,abrokenwindowcanbethetippingpoint.Theauthorfinalizeshissuppositionbyindicatingthatitisthe“natureofnonlinearphenomenathatsometimesthemostmodestofchangescanbringaboutenormouseffects”89andintheframeworkofinfectiousdiseaseepidemics,onesmallchangecancausetheepidemicdecreasesignificantly.90
Inhisbook,publishedin2000,hefurtherdevelopstheTippingPointtheorybydescribingitas“momentofcriticalmass,thethreshold,theboilingpoint.”91Gladwellcontinuestousethespreadofinfectiousdiseasestoillustratehistheoryandascertainsanepidemicistippedbecauseofachangeormultiplechanges.WhatGladwellcalls“agentsof
82Rodgers,Lucy,DavidGritten,JamesOffer,andPatrickAsare."Syria:TheStoryoftheConflict.";"SyrianCivilWarFastFacts."CNN.September26,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.cnn.com/2013/08/27/world/meast/syria-civil-war-fast-facts/index.html.83"IslamicStateandtheCrisisinIraqandSyriainMaps."BBCNews.November2,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-27838034.84Rodgers,Lucy,DavidGritten,JamesOffer,andPatrickAsare."Syria:TheStoryoftheConflict."85StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”86"IslamicStateandtheCrisisinIraqandSyriainMaps."BBCNews.87Gladwell,Malcolm."Thetippingpoint."NewYorker72,no.14(June3,1996):32-38.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember8,2016),34.88Ibid.,35-36.89Ibid.,38.90Ibid.,34.91Gladwell,Malcolm.TheTippingPoint:HowLittleThingsCanMakeaBigDifference.NewYork,NY:Little,BrownandCompany,2002.Electronic,11.
![Page 16: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 15
change,”aredefinedasLawoftheFew,theStickinessFactor,andthePowerofContext.92TheseRulesofEpidemicsprovidethebasisforhowtheTippingPointofallepidemicsisreached.93
LawoftheFew TheLawoftheFewrulesuggests“thesuccessofanykindofsocialepidemicisheavilydependentontheinvolvementofpeoplewithaparticularandraresetofsocialgifts.”94Italsosignifiesthattherearecertainpeoplewhoareperfectlypositionedtostartanepidemic:Mavens,Connectors,andSalesmen.95GladwelldescribesConnectorsasthosewhobringtheworldtogetherandlinkustooursocialcircles.96Mavenshavetheabilitytoconnectuswithnewinformation,typicallythroughword-of-mouthinepidemics.97Salesmenarecharismaticallyirresistibleandbydrawingpeoplein,theyascertaingroupagreementwiththetoneoftheconversationbasedupontheircadenceandmood.98
StickinessFactor Gladwellproposesacriticalfactorforthespreadofasocialepidemicisnotthemessengers,butthenatureofthemessageitself.Tobesuccessful,themessageneedstobeofcertainqualitytostick.99TheStickinessFactorsuggeststherearespecificwaysofmakingamessagememorable.Thesimplestchangesinthestructuringandpresentationoftheinformationcanmakeahugedifferenceandimpact.Amemorablemessagewillthenlikelybemorecontagiousandinvokeaction.100
PowerofContext Forepidemics,theconditions,timing,andplacewheretheyoccurmustbeprecise,whichallowsforanepidemictobetransmitted.101“ThePowerofContextsaysthathumanbeingsarealotmoresensitivetotheirenvironmentthantheymayseem.”102Wearealso“powerfullyinfluencedbyoursurroundings,ourimmediatecontext,andthepersonalitiesofthosearoundus.”103Gladwelldetailsthatsizeandcompositionofthegrouporgroupsofpeoplearoundusmatter.UsingtheRuleof150,belowthisnumberpeoplemingleandmeldtogethereasily.Toomanypeopleandpersonalitiestomanageandpeoplebecomealienated,splittingthegroupup.104
Gladwellsaysthe“BrokenWindowstheoryandthePowerofContextareoneandthesame.Theyarebothbasedonthepremisethatanepidemiccanbereversed,canbetipped,bytinkeringwiththesmallestdetailsoftheimmediateenvironment.”105“The
92Ibid.,18.93Ibid.,11.94Ibid.,33.95Ibid.,13.96Ibid.,37.97Ibid.,58-60.98Ibid.,83.99Ibid.,91-92.100Ibid.,25.101Ibid.,138.102Ibid.,28.103Ibid.,258.104Ibid.,181-186.105Ibid.,144.
![Page 17: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 16
paradoxoftheepidemic:thatinordertocreateoncontagiousmovement,youoftenhavetocreatemanysmallmovementsfirst.”106
Analysis:ElementsofthePerfectStormandTheTippingPoint“In2008,it[ISI]wasdescribingitselfasbeinginastateof‘extraordinarycrisis’.”107
Asstatedpreviously,between2006and2010,ISIwasrelativelyinoperative.In2007,theAwakeningMovement,anallianceofapproximately100,000formerISIfightersandlocaltribes,werefightingagainstISI,reducingtheirareaofoperationasseeninFigure1below.
Figure1:AQI/ISIOperatingAreaComparison
http://understandingwar.org/press-media/graphsandstat/al-qaeda-iraq-and-sunni-insurgents-dec-2006-mar-2008
ISIwasbeaten,butnotdefeated.TheUnitedStatesbeganreducingitsforcesin2009,leavingIraqiSecurityForcesinchargeofsecurity,butbytheendoftheyear,ISIwasslowlyreemergingwithattacksagainstthegovernment,meanttoundermineitsinfrastructure
106Ibid.,191.107Hashim,AhmedS."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate,”72.
![Page 18: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 17
andstrength.108Early2010,MasriandAbuOmaralBaghdadiwerekilled,leadingtoafurtherreductioninforces.AbuBakralBaghdaditookcontrolofISIandbeganreorganizingthegroup,creatingadisciplined,hierarchicalstructurewithmultiplegoverningbodies.Iraqiswereskepticalofandupsetbythenumberofforeignfighterswithintheorganization,andtocombatthishesitation,Baghdadiremovedforeignfightersfromleadershippositions. OsamabinLadenwaskilledinMay2011,usheringAymanalZawahiriinasalQaedaandit’saffiliates,ISIincluded,newleader.AfterthewithdrawalofU.S.andcoalitionforcesinDecember2011,ISIbeganagradualcomebackwithcalculatedstepstakentoreturntotheirformerglory.SectarianviolencebegantoincreaseinIraqasIraqiPrimeMinisterNurialMaliki,aShiite,startedtargetingandarrestingSunnileadersinhigh-levelpositionsinIraq’sgovernmentdaysafterU.S.andcoalitionforceswereoutofIraq.ThiscreatedapowervacuuminIraq. InMarch2011,justbeforebinLaden’sdeath,protestseruptedinSyria.Theresponseofsecurityforces,killingdemonstratorsprovokedthenationtoorderPresidentBasharalAssadtostepdownfromhispositionaspresident.HisrefusaltoleaveofficeandtheescalationofviolencethrewSyriaintoacivilwar.ThesituationinSyriaalsocreatedapowervacuum.From2012toearly2014,theareaISIScontrolledisfairlyunknown.Inanefforttoremainrelevant,ISISleadershipappearstohaveinflatedthenumberofsupportersandorganizationalgrowth,bothinfightersandterritorycontrolled.
InApril2013,ISIoperationsexpandedintoSyria,capitalizingonthecrisisandchaosthere.ThetransitionintoSyriapromptedthegroupchangedtheirnametoISIS.BytakingcontrolofcitiesinbothnorthernSyriaandwesternIraq,ISIShasbeenabletomaintainofficialbordercrossingsbetweenIraqandSyriaandtheonlybordercrossingbetweenIraqandJordan.109AsanaffiliateofalQaeda,ZawahiriimploredISIStooperateonlyinIraqasotheralQaedaaffiliates,JN,werefunctioningwithinSyria.Disagreementsensued,andintheend,thedifferencesintacticsandapproachledalQaedatodissolvetheirrelationshipwithISISinFebruary2014.
TheShiadominatedIraqigovernmentcontinuedtofuelthesectariandivisionbytargetingmoreSunnileadersandattackingSunniprotestcamps.InJune2014,ISISpushedtheirforcesintoMosul,Iraq.Theywereabletocapturethecityeasilyassecurityforcesquicklysurrenderedordesertedtheirposts.Laterthatmonth,BaghdadibeganreferringtoISISastheIslamicState(seeAppendix1forfurthernameinformation),declaringaCaliphateandalloccupiedterritoryastheirs.110 ISISleadershipdeservescreditfortheiractionsaswell,intheproliferationofthegroup.AfterbeingpushedtoohardbyalQaeda,ISISwasabletocuttieswiththemandreemergeundertheAbuBakralBaghdadiandhisreorganization.ISISwasabletobecomeself-fundingastheycapturedterritoryinoilrichareas.ThereorganizationofISISalsoputtheappropriateindividualsincontrolofrecruitmentandpropagandaviasocialmedia.ThisattentionbroughtadditionalforeignfightersfromallovertheglobetobetrainedandfightwithISISaswellasreturnhometocarryoutattacksinthenameofthegroup.
108Ibid.,72-73.109StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”110Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance,”24.
![Page 19: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 18
TheTippingPoint Gladwell’sTippingPointtheoryassertsthattheculminationofwhatIdeemthe“PerfectStorm,”orthe“momentofcriticalmass”hadtocometogetherinorderforISIStobesupportedinIraqandSyria,andgainthenotorietyandterritoryitdid.IbelievethetippingpointforISISwasinFebruary2014whenalQaedaseveredtieswithISIS.OnceISISwasoperatingontheirownaccord,theywereabletoflourishandexpandinwaysneverthoughtpossible.TheTippingPointTheorybestexpressesmyopinionthatatthepointthetwogroupsseparated,theelementsinvolvingISISbecamesosaturated,thesituation“tipped”toconditionsfavoringISISproliferationwithinIraqandSyria.ZarqawiandAbuBakralBaghdadifallundertheLawoftheFewasthe“epidemic”ofISISwasencouragedbytheiruniquesocialskillspositioningZarqawitocommunicatetheideologyofthegroupandlaterBaghdadi’sabilitytoorganizeandregrowit.
TheStickinessFactor,emphasizingamemorablemessagethatisstructuredandpresentedinawaythatcreatesalastingimpact,wasISIS’slanguageandactionsofradicalization,anduseofviolenceagainstShiaandothernonbelievers.ISISpioneeredtheuseofsocialmediatowidelydisseminatethesemessages,includingcherrypickedpartsoftheQurantosupportandsubstantiateISIS’sactions.
ThePowerofContext,theperfectenvironmentregardingconditions,timing,andlocationforan“epidemic”tospread,wasthemarginalizationandrepressionoftheSunnisinIraqafterPrimeMinisterMaliki’sreelection,thewithdrawalofU.S.militaryforcesandthepowervacuumthisleftafterMalikiprovedhewasnotabletoprotectallofthepeopleofIraq,andtheSyriancivilwar,whichattractedthousandsoffighterstocombattheattacksoftheAssadregime.
SectarianissuesarenotuniquetoonlyIraqandSyria.Itisaregionalconcern.ExploitingthepowervacuumandIraqigovernment’streatmentofSunnis,ISISwasabletotipthescalesintheirfavor,andthriveafterthecaptureofthekeycityofMosulinnorthernIraqin2014.Thesearenottheonlyconditionsthatmattered.Withoutoneoftheminthecombination,ISISwouldnothavebeenabletoproliferateasquicklyandwidelyastheydid.
Conclusion Inmypaper,IhavearguedthatthewithdrawalofU.S.troopsandcoalitionforcesfromIraq,thepoliticalinstabilityinIraqandSyria,andthesectariandivideincombinationhaveallowedforthejihadistorganization,theIslamicStateoftheIraqinSyriatoescalate.Withoutoneoftheconditionsinthecombination,ISISwouldnothavebeenabletoproliferateasquicklyandwidelyastheydid.AsISISlosesterritory,asithasbeensince2015,thegroupanditssupporterswillbacklashandincreasesinattackscanbeexpected. ItisimportanttorecognizewhyunderstandingtheriseofISISisimportant.Ibelieveitisessentialtounderstandthebackgroundofthegrouptodeterminethebestwaystodefeatthembecauseatsomepoint,theyareboundtomakemistakes.Sectarianpartitioninghasresultedinfurtherconflictsandbloodshedlocallyandregionally.GeopoliticaldivisionshavemadethesituationslightlyworseinSyriaasRussiahassidedwithIranandtheAssadregime,whomtheUnitedStatesopposesandinsteadsupportsSunniGulfstatesandTurkey.WithinternationalcollaborationandbyfosteringthecreationofpowersharinginstitutionswithinIraqandSyria,thesectariantensionscouldbe
![Page 20: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 19
diminishedtopre-Iraqinvasionlevels.111CollaborationonagloballevelcouldalsoreducetheterritorymaintainedbyISISandultimatelyeliminatethegroupbyworkingtowardscombatingacommonenemy,ISIS.ISIShasbecomeaninternationalproblemandwillrequireinternationalcoordination,includinghelpingSyriaresolvetheirinternalconflictandassistingtheIraqigovernmentinovercomingtheirweakenedgovernment.AsIresearchedandwrotemyresearchpaper,Ibegantoaskmyselfifthetimingofallaspectsofthe“perfectstorm”andsequenceofspecificeventsplayedaroleinriseofISIS.Thiswouldbeaninterestingtopicforfutureresearch.
111Brown,CodyMcClain."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqandSyria,”213.
![Page 21: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 20
Appendix1
DefinitionsThefollowingtermshavebeenusedtodescribeISISasanorganization,sometimesinterchangeably,inmuchoftheresearchIhaveread.Throughoutmypaper,IattempttousebroadtermstodescribeandexplainISIS,unlesspertinenttoexpressingaspecificpoint.Ibelieveitisimportanttounderstandthetermsbeingused
Insurgency• DepartmentofDefense-inreferencetoaninsurgentgroup:“theorganizeduseof
subversionandviolencetoseize,nullify,orchallengepoliticalcontrolofaregion.Insurgencycanalsorefertothegroupitself.”112
• “Havingamassbaseofsupportandsomanyfightersthattheycanoperateindaylightandcaptureterritorywiththeintentionofholdingandgoverningit.”113
o “Functionsasaquasimilitaryforcethatisabletomusterrecruitsanddeployinformationnotjusttoattack,buttoexerciselastingcontrolovertheterritoryitcaptures.”114
Terrorism• DepartmentofDefense-inreferencetoaterroristgroupororganization:“the
unlawfuluseofviolenceorthreatofviolence,oftenmotivatedbyreligious,political,orotherideologicalbeliefs,toinstillfearandcoercegovernmentsorsocietiesinpursuitofgoalsthatareusuallypolitical.”115
• “Arebynaturemuchsmaller,withoutamassbaseofsupportsuchthattheymustthereforeoperatecovertly,andtheydonotattempttogovernthepeopletheyterrorize.”116
o “Theyhideinsafehouseswheninactiveorplotting,thenrapidlyexecuteanattackonlytoreturnimmediatelybacktotheircovertlocations.”117
• UnitedNationsSecurityCouncil:“Criminalacts,includingagainstcivilians,committedwiththeintenttocausedeathorseriousbodilyinjury,ortakingofhostages,withthepurposetoprovokeastateofterrorinthegeneralpublicorinagroupofpersonsorparticularpersons,intimidateapopulationorcompelagovernmentoraninternationalorganizationtodoortoabstainfromdoinganyact,whichconstituteoffenceswithinthescopeofandasdefinedintheinternationalconventionsandprotocolsrelatingtoterrorism,areundernocircumstancesjustifiablebyconsiderationsofapolitical,philosophical,ideological,racial,ethnic,religiousorothersimilarnature,andcallsuponallStatestopreventsuchactsand,if
112"DepartmentofDefenseDictionaryofMilitaryandAssociatedTerms."DepartmentofDefense.November8,2010.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.dtic.mil/doctrine/new_pubs/jp1_02.pdf.113Gorka,Sebastian.2016."HowAmericaWillBeAttacked."MilitaryReview96,no.5:30-40.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016),33.114Ibid.115"DepartmentofDefenseDictionaryofMilitaryandAssociatedTerms."116Gorka,Sebastian."HowAmericaWillBeAttacked,"33.117Ibid.
![Page 22: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 21
notprevented,toensurethatsuchactsarepunishedbypenaltiesconsistentwiththeirgravenature.”118
PerfectStorm• “Adetrimentalorcalamitoussituationoreventarisingfromthepowerfulcombined
effectofauniquesetofcircumstances.”119• “Acombinationofeventswhicharenotindividuallydangerous,butoccurring
togetherproduceadisastrousoutcome.”120
CurrentISISDesignationsISISusesandisrecognizedbyavarietyofnames.ThefollowingisalistofcurrentISISnames,whousesthem,andthecontextinwhichtheyareused.121• ISIS:acronymstandsforIslamicStateofIraqandSyria.Theorganizationfirst
announcedthemergerofJabhatalNusraandISIunderthisname,andthemediaandpublicarecurrentlyusingit.
• ISIL:acronymstandsforIslamicStateinLeveant(oralSham).ThenameimpliestheinclusionoftheentiregeographiclocationoftheLevantorJordan,Lebanon,andPalestine.TheObamaAdministrationusesthisname.
• Daesh:ArabicacronymstandsforalDawlaalIslamiyafialIraqwaalShamortheIslamicStateofIraqandSham.ThisnameisusedbyArabStates.
• IslamicState:Thisisthenamethegroupcallsthemselves.ItechoestheirambitionsofanIslamicStatewithoutbordersandinclusionofallMuslims.
TABLE1.HistoryofISISNames122GROUPNAME ACRONYM YEARSINUSEJamaatal-Tawhidwa-l-Jihad JTWJ 1999–2004al-QaedaintheLandofTwoRivers(morecommonlyknownasal-QaedainIraq) AQI 2004–2006MajlisShuraal-Mujahedin MSM 2006IslamicStateofIraq ISI 2006–2013IslamicStateofIraqandal-Sham(TheLevant)(alsoknownasIslamicStateofIraqandSyria) ISIS/ISIL 2013–present
118"Resolution1566(2004)."UnitedNationsSecurityCouncil.October8,2004.AccessedNovember20,2016.http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/RES/1566(2004).119"DepartmentofDefenseDictionaryofMilitaryandAssociatedTerms."120Ibid.121Shamieh,Luna,andZoltánSzenes."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS),"367-68.122Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadistMovement,"1.
![Page 23: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 22
BibliographyBoghani,Priyanka."WheretheBlackFlagofISISFlies."PBS.May13,2016.Accessed
November15,2016.http://apps.frontline.org/isis-affiliates/.Brown,CodyMcClain.2015."MobilizingtheCaliphate:ISISandtheConflictinIraqand
Syria."PolitickaMisao:CroatianPoliticalScienceReview52,no.4/5:203-214.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober17,2016).
Celso,AnthonyN.2015."Zarqawi'sLegacy:AlQaeda'sISIS‘Renegade’."Mediterranean
Quarterly26,no.2:21-41.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember12,2016).
Chambers,Peters.2012."AbuMusabAlZarqawi:TheMakingandUnmakingofan
AmericanMonster(inBaghdad)."Alternatives37,no.1:30-51.SocialSciencesCitationIndex,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016).
"DepartmentofDefenseDictionaryofMilitaryandAssociatedTerms."Departmentof
Defense.November8,2010.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.dtic.mil/doctrine/new_pubs/jp1_02.pdf.
Gambill,Gary.2004.“AbuMusabal-Zarqawi:ABiographicalSketch.”JamestownTerrorism
Monitor2,issue24.AccessedNovember11,2016.https://jamestown.org/program/abu-musab-al-zarqawi-a-biographical-sketch/.
Gladwell,Malcolm."Thetippingpoint."NewYorker72,no.14(June3,1996):32-38.
AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember8,2016).Gladwell,Malcolm.TheTippingPoint:HowLittleThingsCanMakeaBigDifference.New
York,NY:Little,BrownandCompany,2002.Electronic.Gorka,Sebastian.2016."HowAmericaWillBeAttacked."MilitaryReview96,no.5:30-40.
AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016).Gulmohamad,ZanaKhasraw.2014."TheRiseandFalloftheIslamicStateofIraqandAl-
Sham(Levant)ISIS."GlobalSecurityStudies5,no.2:1-11.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016).
Hashim,AhmedS.2014."TheIslamicState:Fromal-QaedaAffiliatetoCaliphate."Middle
EastPolicy21,no.4:69-83.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober17,2016).
Hegghammer,Thomas,andPetterNesser."AssessingtheIslamicState'sCommitmenttoAttacking the West." Perspectives On Terrorism 9, no. 4 (August 2015): 14-30.International Security & Counter TerrorismReference Center, EBSCOhost (accessedNovember14,2016).
![Page 24: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 23
Holbrook,Donald.2015."Al-QaedaandtheRiseofISIS."Survival(00396338)57,no.2:93-104. International Security & Counter Terrorism Reference Center, EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016).
Humud,CarlaE.2016."AlQaedaandU.S.Policy:MiddleEastandAfrica.”Congressional
ResearchService:Report1-22. InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016).
"IslamicStateandtheCrisisinIraqandSyriainMaps."BBCNews.November2,2016.
AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-27838034.
Katzman,Kenneth,andCarlaE.Humud."Iraq:PoliticsandGovernance."Congressional
ResearchService:Report(March9,2016):1-40.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember14,2016).
Kirdar,M.J.2011.“AlQaedainIraq.”CenterforStrategic&InternationalStudies.Accessed
November11,2016.https://www.csis.org/analysis/al-qaeda-iraq.Kuoti,Yasir.2016."ExclusionandViolenceinPost-2003Iraq."JournalOfInternational
Affairs69,no.2:19-28.BusinessSourcePremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember1,2016).
Michael,George.2007."TheLegendandLegacyofAbuMusabal-Zarqawi."DefenceStudies
7,no.3:338-357.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016).
Mueller,John,andMarkG.Stewart.2016."MisoverestimatingISIS:ComparisonswithAl-
Qaeda."PerspectivesOnTerrorism10,no.4:30-39.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016).
Pavlik,Melissa."ISIS'SCampaigninEurope:July16-August18,2016."Instituteforthe
StudyofWar.September2,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://understandingwar.org/backgrounder/isiss-campaign-europe-july-16-august-18-2016.
"Resolution1566(2004)."UnitedNationsSecurityCouncil.October8,2004.Accessed
November20,2016.http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/RES/1566(2004).
Rodgers,Lucy,DavidGritten,JamesOffer,andPatrickAsare."Syria:TheStoryofthe
Conflict."BBCNews.March11,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-26116868.
Shamieh,Luna,andSzenesZoltán.2015."TheRiseofIslamicStateofIraqandSyria(ISIS)."
![Page 25: The Perfect Storm - WordPress.com...The Perfect Storm 3 modestly in a rough neighborhood known for its heavy influence of drugs and gun crime.2 Zarqawi dropped out of school when he](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022081615/5fe05e538d4b502f232a02ee/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
ThePerfectStorm 24
AARMS:Academic&AppliedResearchInMilitary&PublicManagementScience14,no.4:363-378.InternationalSecurity&CounterTerrorismReferenceCenter,EBSCOhost(accessedOctober8,2016).
StanfordUniversity.“TheIslamicState.”MappingMilitantOrganizations:April4,2016.
FirstaccessedNovember10,2015.http://web.stanford.edu/group/mappingmilitants/cgi-bin/groups/view/1.
"SyrianCivilWarFastFacts."CNN.September26,2016.AccessedNovember15,2016.
http://www.cnn.com/2013/08/27/world/meast/syria-civil-war-fast-facts/index.html.
"TheSunni-ShiaDivide."CouncilonForeignRelations.February2016.AccessedOctober
16,2016.http://www.cfr.org/peace-conflict-and-human-rights/sunni-shia-divide/p33176#!/.
Weaver,MaryAnne.2006."InventingAl-Zarqawi.(Coverstory)."Atlantic297,no.6:
87-100.AcademicSearchPremier,EBSCOhost(accessedNovember11,2016).Zelin,AaronY."TheWarBetweenISISandal-QaedaforSupremacyoftheGlobalJihadist
Movement."WashingtonInstituteForNearEastPolicy:ResearchNotes20,(June10,2014):1.Military&GovernmentCollection,EBSCOhost(accessedSeptember25,2016).