;;f\ o`]f o] l`afc YZgml l`gk] ~2,k afl]dd][lmYdk af JYjak( l`]aj ]q]k \jYoflg l`]aj l]d]nakagf k]lk( l`]aj ^Y[]k [Ym_`l Zq Y kead] Yl gf[] Yna\ Yf\cfgoaf_( l`]aj eaf\k Yl ogjc gf l`] d]_alaeYlagf g^ l`]aj hd]Ykmj] Yk l`]qj][g\] l`ak iman]jaf_ egmflYaf g^ Y eYfzaf `ak lafq la_`lk Yf\ m_dq fYad)klm\\]\ Z]dl( na[agmkdq ca[caf_ l`] `]Y\ g^ `ak \gof]\ Y\n]jkYjq gn]j l`]hjgl]klk g^ l`] j]^]j]]zaflg l`] M[Yhaf g^ l`]aj \Yq( l`] _jYf\ ^a_mj] g^Nj]Y[`]jq kljYa_`l gml g^ Y egjYdalq hdYq Yk gd\ Yk l`] Aj]]ck( \g o]aeY_af] <Yjl`]k Yk [Ymk] gj Yk kqehlge: Q`Yl h]jeakkagf \a\ `] _an] ZqkYqaf_( bmkl dac] l`Yl( l`Yl l`]j]~k fgl`af_ nmd_Yj YZgml oj]kldaf_: Cl ak fgegj] a_fgZd] lg Yll]f\ Y oj]kld]\ h]j^gjeYf[] g^ Mm^^]jaf_ l`Yf Y h]j^gj)eYf[] g^ l`] kgjjgok g^ ;;jfgdh`] gj ;;f\jgeYim](| <Yjl`]k `Y\ ojall]f*

;;f\ o`Yl YZgml Ja[Ykkg: >a\ `] f]]\ km[` h]jeakkagf:

Ja[Ykkg( Y^l]j Ydd( oYk l`] _j]Yl kgmj[] g^ `ak gof Yml`gjalq* N`Yl~k o`Yll`]q eYjn]d]\ Yl* N`] ^ja]f\k( l`] \]Yd]jk( l`] h`glg_jYh`]jk( l`] [mjYlgjk(

l`] bgmjfYdaklk( l`] [gdd][lgjk( l`] `Yf_]jk)gf( o`g]n]j `Y\ Z]]f Yddgo]\lg ]fl]j FY =Yda^gjfa] af l`] -­51,k( Yf\ fgo l`] eYkkan] ^Yje`gmk] YlGgm_afk lg o`a[` `] `Y\ j]lj]Yl]\ af l`] ~2,k( l`]q oYl[`]\ ]fl`jYdd]\ YkJa[Ykkg hml gf ^mffq `Ylk Yf\ ^Yc] emklY[`]k Yf\ [Yngjl]\( ZYj])[`]kl]\Yf\ af gmljY_]gmkdq kljah]\ [gfna[l| hYflk( gf l`] l]jjY[]7 Yk Ja[Ykkg[Yj]d]kkdq jgdd]\ Yf\ ^gd\]\ dalld] ha][]k g^ hYh]j gn]j \aff]j kg l`Yl Z]^gj]l`]aj ]q]k ]e]j_]\ Y km[[]kkagf g^ lafq jggkl]jk Yf\ _gYlk Yf\ MhYfak`\Yf[]jk7 Yk Ja[Ykkg( kmjjgmf\]\ Zq Y oad\ emd[` g^ gZb][lkzhad]k g^ ]n]jqaeY_afYZd] caf\ g^ hYh]j( k[Yll]jk g^ Zggck Yf\ d]ll]jk( hjg^mkagfk g^ eYkckYf\ g^ hdYflk( egZad]k g^ k`]]l e]lYd gZb][lk `Yf_af_ ^jge l`] eYklk g^dYehk( klY[ck g^ [YfnYk]k lo]flq \]]h Y_Yafkl l`] oYdd( [dmll]jk g^ []jYea[hglk( MhYfak` k`Yodk( r]ZjY kcafk( [gjja\Y hgkl]jk( h`glg_jYh`kzk]]e]\lg kmj^Y[] ^jge Yegf_kl al Ydd dac] Y ljameh`Yfl Njalgf( oj]Yl`]\ afk]Yo]]\ Yf\ k[Yddgh k`]ddk Yf\ ^gYe7 Yk Ja[Ykkg( l`] ^g[mk g^ ]n]jq _Yr](l`] eY_f]l g^ ]n]jq hYjla[d] g^ Yll]flagf( hdYq]\ oal` `ak [gmjla]jk~ ]eg)lagfk dac] Yf aehmdkan] Jjaf[]( fgo ^Yngjaf_ l`]e oal` Y k`Y^l g^ oak\ge(fgo hmfak`af_ l`]e Zq `ak gZklafYl] kad]f[]* B] `Y\ f]]\]\ fg gf]~kh]jeakkagf Zml `ak gof Y^l]j Ydd lg hml Y Za[q[d] k]Yl lg_]l`]j oal` alk`Yf\d]ZYjk Yf\ j]fYe] al Y Zmdd~k `]Y\( lg \]^gje l`] ^]eYd] Zg\q af Yl`gmkYf\ oYqk( ^jge l`] ^jY[lmj]\ hdYf]k g^ [mZake lg l`] _jYf\ hf]meYla[lme]k[]f[] g^ Y j]afn]fl]\ [dYkka[ake*

N`ak `gmk]( alk]d^ Y [`Ygla[ emk]me g^ alk eYkl]j~k da^]lae] g^ afn]flagfk(oYk( al k]]e]\ lg l`]e( l`] h]j^][l eYfa^]klYlagf g^ Ja[Ykkg~k k]d^)[gflYaf)e]fl( g^ l`] oYq `] \]egfkljYl]\ l`] [gehd]l] Ymlg_]f]kak g^ l`] [j]Ylan]Y[l( g^ l`] oYq hYaflaf_ [ge]k ^jge JYaflaf_( g^ l`] oYq Ga\Yk f]n]j `Y\lg d]Yn] `ak hYdY[] lg lmjf ]n]jql`af_ lg _gd\* N`ak `m_] klgf] `gmk](kmjjgmf\]\ Zq naf]qYj\k Yf\ Yf[a]fl gdan] lj]]k( `mf_ oal` [dgYck g^Zgm_Yafnadd]Y( k]]e]\ dac] Y ^gjlj]kk ]j][l]\ Y_Yafkl l`] ogjd\* ;; [YfYdjmffaf_ Z]dgo ^]\ l`] hggd gflg o`a[` l`] l]jjY[] gh]f]\* Gq M]af](|DY[im]daf] dac]\ lg [Ydd al( j]eaf\af_ `]j dakl]f]jk l`Yl k`] Yf\ Ja[Ykkg `Y\fgl d]^l l`ak kljgf_`gd\ ^gj JYjak ^gj Yl d]Ykl Y \][Y\]*

Mg gf] ogmd\ f]n]j aeY_af] al l`]j] Yk o]dd6 l`] l]d]nakagf k]l( ja\af_ l`][dmll]j g^ l`] eYaf jgge gf alk mfeaklYcYZd] ~1,k h]\]klYd( l`] gf] klgda\]q] l`Yl f]n]j lmjf]\ lgoYj\ l`] eYkl]j*

DY[im]daf] `Yl]\ l`] l]d]nakagf k]l( `Yl]\ Ja[Ykkg~k `gmjk kh]fl oYl[`af_oj]kldaf_( `ak Yna\alq ^gj l`ak l`af_ l`Yl k]]e]\ lg `Yn] fg hdY[] oal`afl`] [Yj]^mddq ZYfc]\ [j]Ylan] hqj]k g^ Hglj] >Ye] \] Pa]* S]l `]j gZ]\a)]f[] f]n]j ^dY__]\ Yf\( Yk `]j _j]Yl ^ja]f\ B]d]f] JYje]daf j]hgjlk( k`]

LgZ]jlg Il]jg( h`glg_jYh` g^ Ja[Ykkg~k danaf_ jgge Yl Hglj] >Ye] \] Pa](

Ggm_afk( ^jge <adWhWd F[USeea(

efa^[V WkW fZSf `WhWd fgd`WV faiSdV fZW _SefWd((( $b(

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( 8SfZWd i[fZ 8WSUZ 8S^^& <gak_]dgmh( ;;m_mkl /,( -­5/.*

HXU cXUUb Re_iQ^Si _V DYSQcc_oc fYcY_^ _V dXU bY`U^Ucc _V XUb Q^Qd_]i "`& *()#

kh]fl `gmjk k[gmjaf_ l`] hjg_jYe _ma\]k lg ^af\ l`] oj]kldaf_ eYl[`]k*Qj]kkaf_(| Ja[Ykkg hjgfgmf[]\ al*

B]d]f] JYje]daf aeY_af]k Ja[Ykkg~k ]fl`mkaYke ^gj l`] kh][lY[d]6 ;;dd l`]k]_mqk o`g o]a_` Y lgf Yf\ q]l egn] da_`ldq l`jgm_` l`] Yaj Yk l`gm_` l`]qo]j] ^dqaf_* Q`g l`jmkl l`]aj ^]]l ]n]jqo`]j]( o`g j]Zgmf\ dac] jmZZ]j*;;f\ ^gmj)eYf oj]kldaf_ N`]k] dalld] e]f o`g [jakk[jgkk khY[] dac] ZYddkYf\ YdoYqk dYf\ gf l`]aj ^]]l: Qal` gj oal`gml al Z]af_ klY_]\( o`g [Yj]k(o`Yl Yl`d]l]k* Q`Yl Y k`go Bgo eYjn]dgmk | Q`a[` ak lg kYq k`] aeY_)af]k Ja[Ykkg j]danaf_ Y hYjl g^ `ak gof Y]kl`]la[ hYkl6 GYja])N`]j]k] Yl l`]Z]Y[`( h]j`Yhk( ^dgYlaf_ YZgn] l`] kYf\k gf l`] k`]]j ZmgqYf[q g^ Ja[Ykkg~knakagf g^ l`] jah]f]kk g^ `]j YfYlgeq* Lakaf_ [mjn]k Zaddgoaf_ Y_Yafkl Y^dYl _jgmf\* N`Yl emkl Z] al*

S]l l`] egj] gf] [gfka\]jk al( l`] egj] l`] hgkkaZadala]k emdlahdq* N`]j]~kfgl`af_ af <Yjl`]k~k YfYdqkak l`Yl ogmd\f~l `Yn] Yhh]Yd]\ lg Ja[Ykkg* N`]fglagf g^ Yf ]pgjZalYfl( Zml [gfl]ehgjYjq( S_]]UTYQ TU\\oQbdU$ ]Y[` [`Yj)Y[l]j YdoYqk ljm] lg lqh]( ]Y[` lqh] [gjhgj]Ydar]\ oal` l`] kYe] ]pY[lalm\]Yk BYjd]imaf gj =gdgeZaf]( l`ak l`]Yl]j ak mf\]jklgg\ Yk klY_af_ Yf\j]klY_af_ l`] egkl hjaealan] g^ egjYdalq hdYqk6 l`] \]eYf\ ^gj j]ljaZmlagf*@ajkl l`]j] ak N`Ymnaf( <Yjl`]k Z]_afk( Y ^a^lq)q]Yj)gd\ oal` Yf gZ]k] Yf\kY__af_ Zg\q( o`gk] lqh] g^ Yk]pmYd `a\]gmkf]kk YdoYqk afkhaj]k ^]eafaf]fa[cfYe]k(| Y ^a_mj] o`g \akhdYqk af `ak ^d]k` l`] [`YjY[l]jk g^ ZYk]f]kk(^gj `ak hYjl ak lg j]hj]k]fl o`Yl( af l`] [dYkka[Yd [gf[]hl g^ l`] cQ\QeT$ l`]ZYklYj\~ $l`] c]q)[gf[]hl g^ Yfq oj]kldaf_)eYl[`%( Yhh]Yjk Yk gj_Yfa[Yddqj]hm_fYfl*| ;;^l]j l`ak cQ\QeT$ l`]j] ak l`] daeh Zdgf\ oal` \ak`]n]d]\ `YajjY\aYlaf_ l`] egnaf_ aeY_] g^ hYkkanalq(| Yf\ l`] kljmllaf_ im]]f o`g[ge]k lg l`] jaf_ af Y ZYZq Zdm] Yf\ hafc \j]kkaf_ _gof( l`] n]jq ha[lmj]g^ l`] naf\a[lan] cQ\_`U$ gj Zal[`*| N`] kh][lY[d] l`]k] [`YjY[l]jk klY_]^jge gf] ege]fl g^ ]pY__]jYl]\ Yf\ [Yj]^mddq eYaflYaf]\ `gd\k| lgYfgl`]j ak l`] _j]Yl l`]Yl]j g^ JYaf( >]^]Yl( Yf\ Dmkla[]* Qj]kldaf_ hj]k]flkeYf~k km^^]jaf_ oal` Ydd l`] Yehda^a[Ylagf g^ ljY_a[ eYkck(| <Yjl`]k kYqk(Y\\af_( <ml o`Yl oj]kldaf_ ak YZgn] Ydd e]Yfl lg hgjljYq ak Y hmj]dq egjYd[gf[]hl6 l`Yl g^ bmkla[]* N`] a\]Y g^ hYqaf_~ ak ]kk]flaYd lg oj]kldaf_( Yf\l`] [jgo\~k Aan] al lg `ae~ e]Yfk YZgn] Ydd ]dk] GYc] `ae hYq*~|

@gj l`] Ja[Ykkg g^ l`] GQ\dY]RQ^aeUc gj l`] HXbUU AecYSYQ^c$ l`ak l]d])k[ghaf_ g^ l`] ljY_a[ Yf\ l`] hghmdYj( l`ak k]fk] g^ l`] [jgo\~k aflaeY[qoal` l`] egjYd dYo Yk l`Yl ak ]fY[l]\ af emka[ `Yddk Yf\ [aj[mk jaf_k( afklj]]l l`]Yl]jk Yf\ ka\]k`gok( l`ak \akhdYq g^ hghmdYj bmkla[] kg [d]Yjdq[Yhlmj]\ Zq `ak Z]dgn]\ =`Yjagl( fgf] g^ l`ak [gmd\ Z] ^gj]a_f*

Ij( Yf\ ]imYddq hdYmkaZdq( ^gj l`] Ja[Ykkg o`g ]fbgq]\ `ak gof [jm]dlqlgoYj\ ^ja]f\k( dgn]jk( Zmkaf]kk Ykkg[aYl]k( o`Yl [gmd\ Z] egj] Yhh]Ydaf_l`Yf l`ak YeYraf_ ]p]j[ak] af af^da[laf_ hYaf( g^ hgmf\af_ gf l`] khaf] g^gf]~k l]ehgjYjadq _jgmf\]\ ghhgf]fl( g^ _jYZZaf_ l`] ^Y[] g^ gf]~k Y\)n]jkYjq Yf\ jmZZaf_ al aflg l`] eYl( g^ ]fl]jaf_ lglYddq aflg l`ak eY[`af]^gj hjg\m[af_ l`] aeY_] g^ lgjlmj] mf\]j l`] [gn]j g^ alk k]d^)\]k[jahlagfYk khgjl*|

Ij( Yf\ o`q fgl( l`]j] ak l`] l]d]nakagf k]l alk]d^( l`ak aehYkkan] ]q] l`Ylfgf]l`]d]kk ]pm\]k Y [gfklYfl nakmYd Z]Yl kaf[] alk aeY_] ak hjg\m[]\ ZqYf ]d][lja[ [mjj]fl k[Yffaf_ mhoYj\ Ydgf_ l`] `mf\j]\k g^ daf]k l`Yl [jgkkl`] k[j]]f( _]f]jYlaf_ Yf aeY_]| l`jgm_` l`] [gflafmYd j]f]oYd g^ alkhmdk]( Z][geaf_ Ydd l`] egj] YhhYj]fl o`]f l`] k]l _g]k gml g^ [YdaZjYlagfYf\ l`] o`gd] aeY_] ak oah]\ mhoYj\ Y_Yaf Yf\ Y_Yaf Yk l`gm_` hmk`]\Zq Yf afkakl]fldq j]Yhh]Yjaf_ ZdY[c( `gjargflYd ZYj* Q`q [gmd\ al fgl Z]kYa\ l`Yl l`] k[j]]f~k ^da[c]j( oalf]kk lg alk Ydegkl aeh]j[]hlaZd] e][`Yfa[Ydhmdk]( hjgna\]k l`] eYljap( l`] ^gjeYd kmhhgjl gj _jgmf\| Y_Yafkl o`a[`l`]k] hgmf\af_( ca[caf_( k[jYl[`af_( _gm_af_ ^a_mj]k| g^ hYaf [Yf Z]Zg\a]\ ^gjl` lg hjgna\] l`]aj ^mdd [gehgf]fl g^ hd]Ykmj]:

S]l al emkl Z] kYa\ l`Yl l`] [gdd][lgjk( l`] bgmjfYdaklk( l`] ^ja]f\k( l`][mjYlgjk ogmd\ jYddq Y_Yafkl l`ak a\]Y* Q`Yl Ja[Ykkg oYk `Yhhq lg o]d[ge]Yl l`] eYfa^]kl d]n]d g^ l`] [gfl]fl gj ^a_mj](| l`]q ogmd\ hgafl gml( `]oYk ]kh][aYddq `gklad] lg Yl l`] dYl]fl d]n]d g^ l`] ^gjeYd kmhhgjl gj_jgmf\*| N`] a[gfg_jYh`q g^ l`] hghmdYjzl`] [dgofk( l`] \jmfck( l`]oYa^k( l`] bm__d]jkzoYk l`] c`USYQ\YdU g^ `ak hYjla[mdYj ]QYc_^& Clk kljm[)lmj]( gf l`] gl`]j `Yf\( l`] j]h]lalan] Z]Yl lg o`a[` l`] Zg\a]k _qjYl]( l`]gf+g^^ ZafYjake g^ l`] Zdafcaf_ ka_fk( l`] e][`Yfa[Yd khYkek g^ l`] YhhY)jYlmk g^ l`] kh][lY[d]zo`ajjaf_( khaffaf_( k`mlldaf_( jYlldaf_z`] ^gmf\afY\eakkaZd]*

B]d]f] JYje]daf( ]n]j oaddaf_( hdYq]\ l`] [Yl~k)hYo lg `ak egmflaf_ Yf)fgqYf[] af l`] dYl] ~1,k Yf\ l`jgm_`gml l`] -­52,k Yl o`Yl `] [gmd\ gfdqj]_Yj\ Yk l`] af]phda[YZd] Yk[]f\Yf[] g^ GYj[]d >m[`Yeh* N`]j]( l`jgm_`l`] fYjjgo hgjlYd g^ JYaflaf_( oYk fgo hgmjaf_ l`] o`gd] \]ljalmk g^ l`][alqzalk f]gf ka_fk( alk `qkl]ja[Yd kaj]fk( alk [jYodaf_ e]lYdda[ k[jYh `]Yh(alk ]flaj] e][`Yfa[Yd ZYdd]lzYk l`gm_` kge]gf] `Y\ gh]f]\ l`] ^dgg\_Yl]kYf\ ]n]f l`]f l`] \Ye `Y\ Zmjkl* N`] [alq( j]Y\qeY\]( [YdcSX)ja\\]f Yf\egfkljgmk( `Y\ Zj]Y[`]\ l`] khY[] g^ `a_` [mdlmj]* N`]q Yj] jYfkY[caf_>m[`Yeh~k oYj]`gmk] Yf\ [`Yf_af_ l`] hY[cY_af_(| Ja[Ykkg ^me]\ Yl l`]qgmf_]kl _]f]jYlagf* 5bd Q^T 5^dY%5bd oYk B]d]f]~k dalld] ljY[l af l`] k]jna[]g^ l`ak ]pYkh]jYlagf*

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( JZdWW Cge[U[S`e& @gflYaf]Zd]Ym( kmee]j -­5.-­*

HXYc cU^cU _V dXU Sb_gToc Y^dY]QSi gYdX dXU ]_bQ\ \Qg &&& "`& *()#

GYp ?jfkl( 7 B[ff^W =[d^ :dWS_e aX JS][`Y fZW LW[^ -­5/,6 >Yfk egf [gdgeZg\jge]*|

5^T$ Y^UfYdQR\i$ XUb TbUQ] gY\\ RU `e\cQdY\U &&& "`& *(1#

Bghaf_ lg eYl[` \Y\Y~k [ggd oal` kge]l`af_ g^ `]j gof( l`] Zggc ak Yk`jm_ g^ l`] k`gmd\]jk( Y kmj]( IE( l]jja^a[( o`q fgl:| M`] \]k[jaZ]k gf]g^ l`] GYq MYdgfk6 @dqaf_ ZYddggfk Yf\ l`] egkl [gehd]p g^ ]d][lja[Yd_]ge]lja[ dYZqjafl`k* ?fnajgfe]flk e]Yfl ^gj Yj[`al][lmjYd k]llaf_k gj ^gjfgl`af_ Yl Ydd* LmZZ]j \gddk l`Yl ^dgh Yjgmf\ gf l`]aj Z]\k( ljYfkhYj]flhdYkla[ [Y_]k o`]j] af\]l]jeafYl] l`af_k Yj] af eglagf( hYf]dk gf o`a[`]n]jqgf] ak kmeegf]\ lg ojal]( Zalk g^ km_Yj `mf_ gf kljaf_k( Yf\ Ydd l`]ZarYjj]f]kk]k g^ f]gf( fgak]( egn]e]fl*|

Mmj](| k`] kYqk( l]jja^a[( o`q fgl:| ;;k dgf_ Yk l`]q \gf~l [gf^mk] l`akoal` JYaflaf_* ;;k dgf_ Yk l`]q \jgh l`]aj hj]hgkl]jgmk [dYae l`Yl Z][Ymk]g^ l`ak `QY^dY^W ak \]Y\* B]j lYj_]lk( gf] Y^l]j Yfgl`]j( Yj] @gflYfY( ;;jeYf(Id\]fZmj_( <mj]f* ;;f\( g^ [gmjk]( Naf_m]dq*

M`] `Yk j]Y\ af l`] hYh]jk kge]o`]j] l`Yl Naf_m]dq `Yk [ge] ^gjoYj\oal` l`] hjghgkalagf ^gj Y dmfYljY[c*| N`ak( Y[[gj\af_ lg l`] j]hgjl(ogmd\ Z] Y Zmad\af_ .4 e]l]jk oa\] Yf\ -­,, `a_`( o`gddq g^ _dYkk dac]Yfq Ga]k kcqk[jYh]j* =gkl6 -­ Zaddagf gd\ ^jYf[k* <]f]Yl` oadd Z] Y _YjY_](YZgn] Y j]klYmjYfl* NgZg__Yfk( k`gglaf_ _Ydd]ja]k( e]jjq)_g)jgmf\k( ^]jjako`]]dk( oYl]jogjck( \g\_])]e [Yjk( hYjY[`ml]k( kaddq kfY[c klYf\k7 al~k l`]n]jla[Yd [gf[]fljYlagf g^ l`] gd\ FmfY JYjc( ]fdYj_]\ oal` Ydd caf\k g^l][`fgdg_a[Yd _Y\_]ljq* N`] [d]n]j egn] ak l`] ^Y[Y\]k * * * l`]q oadd ]fdan]f.,(,,, kimYj] e]l]jk g^ kmj^Y[] l`Yfck lg Y h]jeYf]fl ^ajaf_ g^ ZjaddaYfl[gdgjk*| IE( ^af](| B]d]f] j]lgjlk* Mg o`Yl~k `gd\af_ l`af_k mh: Cl~dd Z]l]jja^a[ |

M`] k`Yj]k Ja[Ykkg~k \ak\Yaf ^gj >m[`Yeh* M`] dYZ]dk Ydd l`ak klm^^ l`]=gf[gmjk F]haf] g^ Yfla)Yjl*| M`] ak bmkl Yk eqkla^a]\ Zq l`] F_d_bU\YUVc Ykk`] ak Zq l`] kdYk`]\ [YfnYk]k g^ @gflYfY*

<ml gf l`]aj ^Y[]( g^ [gmjk]( l`]j] ak fgl`af_ Yfla)Yjl| YZgml l`] F_d_bU%\YUVc& N`]q hYjla[ahYl] af Yf a[gfg_jYh`q g^ YZkljY[lagf aflg o`a[` [gmd\Z] hdY[]\ l`] Ijh`a[ lgf\gk g^ >]dYmfYq( l`] [gkea[ ^a_mj]k g^ kmhj]eY)lake( l`] H]olgfaYf \akck g^ EmhcY* N`]aj Yfla)Yjl| [ge]k Yl Yfgl`]jd]n]d( l`] gf] o`]j] l`]q eYc] [geegf [Ymk] oal` hghmdYj [mdlmj]~k gof]eZjY[] g^ l`] e]\aY( g^ Ydd ^gjek g^ j]hjg\m[lagf( `]j]( egkl gZnagmkdq(oal` l`] af\mkljq g^ j][gj\af_* N`] F_d_bU\YUVc oal` l`]aj hmdkYlad] q]lkad]fl emka[ ]ngc] l`] dakl]f]j~k ^Yk[afYlagf oal` l`] kh][lY[d] g^ l`] lmjf)lYZd]~k egfglgfgmk khajYd( oal` l`] kYe]f]kk g^ alk `qhfgla[ Z]Yl o`Yl]n]jl`] e]dg\a[ h`jYkaf_* Q`Yl l`] F_d_bU\YUVc l`jgo af l`] ^Y[] g^ ;;jl Yf\g^ JYaflaf_ ak fgl l`] aeY_] g^ Yfgl`]j [mdlmj] Zml Y ^gje( l`Yl g^ Y hmdk]gj Z]Yl( l`Yl l`] eg\]jfakl Yjlakl k]fk]k Ydd lgg o]dd Yk l`] ]f]eq g^ `ak

[jY^l* @gj l`Yl hmdk] ak \]ngdmlagfYjq( \]kljm[lan]( \akkgdnaf_ l`] n]jq [g)

`]j]f[] Yf\ klYZadalq g^ ^gje*

Cf l`ak( >m[`Yeh oYk fgl Ydgf] af l`] ~/,k* N`] Yjlaklk g^ l`] ghla[Ydmf[gfk[agmk| o]j] hYjla[mdYjdq \jYof lg l`ak Z]Yl( Y[cfgod]\_af_ l`] jgd]

al `Y\ Z]_mf lg hdYq af Ydd ^gjek g^ l`] hghmdYj*

:b_] XYc _ed`_cd Y^ dXU 5bTUSXU Qd dXU U^T _V dXU )1*(c$ AQh 9b^cd g_e\T\__[ dXb_eWX XYc `Y\U _V FY HYlmj] TQdY^W Vb_] dXU )00(c Q^T o1(c$fYSQbY_ec\i bU\YfY^W dXU VQcSY^QdY_^ Ydc bUQTUbcXY` XQT XQT gYdX gX_\U bQ^WUc_V _`dYSQ\ TUfYSUcz`bQhY^_cS_`Uc$ j__db_`Uc$ `XQU^Q[YcdYcS_`UckdXb_eWXgXYSX Q^ UQb\i fUbcY_^ _V dXU l]_fYUcm gQc dXU^ RUY^W Y]QWY^UT& HXU d_ic_V SXY\TbU^$ dXU QddbQSdY_^c Qd fY\\QWU VQYbc$ dXU QVdUb%TY^^Ub Q]ecU]U^dc _V]YTT\U S\Qcc VQ]Y\YUc$ dXUcU XQT RUU^ dXU TUfYSUc _V fYceQ\ `bUcdYTYWYdQdY_^2`b_TeSY^W Qcd_^YcXY^W UVVUSdc _V dXbUU%TY]U^cY_^Q\Ydi Q^T _V Y]QWUc Y^]_dY_^& 6ed Qc XU [^Ug Q\\ d__ gU\\$ dXU ]_fU]U^d$ VQb Vb_] RUY^W V\eYT$gQc SQ`dYfU d_ dXU Y^dUb]YddU^SU _V$ V_b UhQ]`\U$ dXU \Ydd\U c\Yd\Y[U _`U^Y^WcQ\_^W dXU Tbe] _V dXU j__db_`U& HXb_eWX UQSX _V dXUcU c\Ydc i_e S_e\T cUUQ^ Y]QWU _^ dXU VQb cYTU _V dXU Tbe]oc Y^^Ub gQ\\$ UQSX _^U Q cY^W\U cdQdY_^Y^ Q cUaeU^SU _V `_cYdY_^c$ dXU Vb_jU^ ]_]U^d Vb_] gYdXY^ Q bUS_bTUTRebcd _V ]_dY_^& ;;k dXU Tbe] deb^UT UQSX ^Ug c\Yd g_e\T e^S_fUb Q^QTTYdY_^Q\ `_cYdY_^$ dXU gX_\U bUf_\edY_^ bUfUQ\Y^W dXU U^dYbU QbS _V QSdYfYdi2Q RYbToc gY^Wc TY``Y^W Qc Ydc ^US[ cdbQY^c V_bgQbT Q^T dXU^ \YVdY^W e`gQbTQc Ydc XUQT bUdbQSdc& l:\YWXd g_e\T dXec RU SQ`debUT Y^ dXU SYbSeYd _V dXUTbe] Q^T WYTTY\i bU\UQcUT V_b dXU _^\__[Ub&

6ed lV\YWXd gQc ^_^UdXU\Ucc ci^S_`QdUT Ri dXU ]QbSX _V dXU \Ydd\U _`U^Y^Wc`QccY^W RUV_bU i_eb VQcSY^QdUT WQjU$ cU`QbQdUT Qc dXUi XQT d_ RU Ri cdbUdSXUc_V R\Q^[^Ucc& C^d_ dXU UVV_bd\Ucc VbUUT_] _V dXU RYbToc V_bgQbT ]_dY_^g_e\T dXec RU `b_ZUSdUT dXU cd_`%Q^T%W_ V\YS[Ub _V dXUcU fYceQ\ Y^dUbbe`%dY_^c& HXYc XYSSe`$ dXYc ZUb[Y^Ucc$ dXYc dgYdSX$ g_e\T U^dUb dXU `b_ZUSdY_^ _VUQb\i VY\]c$ Vb_] ^YS[U\_TU_^c d_ cY\U^dc$ VY^Q\\i d_ RU Y^dUb^Q\YjUT Y^ 7XQ`%\Y^oc fUbi gQ\[$ Qc XYdSXY^W e` XYc `Q^dc Q^T R_e^SY^W XYc SQ^U XU Y]YdQdUTdXU dbU]_b dXQd S_^cdQ^d\i `Q\cYUT dXU fYceQ\ c`QSU _V `bY]YdYfU SY^U]Q$UfUbi_^U cUU]Y^W d_ ]QbSX d_ dXU c_e^T _V Q^ Y^fYcYR\U Tbe]]Ub&

5T_bY^W dXUcU _`dYSQ\ TUfYSUc$ TbQg^ Ri dXU RUQd dXQd S_ebcUT dXb_eWXdXUYb Y\\ecY_^$ XU g_e\T Uh`\_Yd dXU] _VdU^& :_b Q^ Y]`_bdQ^d Y]QWU Y^ XYcS_\\QWU ^_fU\ ;; Falld] Aajd >j]Yek g^ NYcaf_ l`] P]ad XU g_e\T `\QSU XYcXUb_Y^U Qd dXU SU^dUb _V gXQd cXU SQ\\c Q T_fUS_dU Red XYc fYUgUb g_e\TbUS_W^YjU Qc dXU Tbe] _V Q j__db_`U& <U XQT \YVdUT dXU Y]QWU Vb_] dXU`QWUc _V @QHYlmj](gXUbU dXU ]USXQ^Yc] XQT RUU^ TYc`\QiUT Vb_] c\YWXd\i

Tggljgh]( BS DSfgdW $-­444%( h* -­.*

HXU \Ydd\U c\Yd\Y[U _`U^Y^Wc Q\_^W dXU Tbe] _V dXU j__db_`U &&& "`& *(.#

JZW XdalW` _a_W`f Xda_ i[fZ[` S dWUadVWV Tgdef aX _af[a` ((( $b( ,*0%

<jgfr] ^a_mj]k j]hj]k]flaf_ ]d]n]f km[[]kkan] hgkalagfkg^ Y ha_]gf af ^da_`l( BS DSfgdW $-­444%( h* -­.*

QR_fU c_ dXQd i_e S_e\T cUU X_g UQSX _V dXU RYbTc Y^ dXU cUaeU^SU gQc]_e^dUT _^ Q \Ydd\U cdQ^T d_ RbY^W Yd d_ dXU \UfU\ _V dXU c\Ydc Y^ dXU Tbe]&=^ Q TYVVUbU^d Y\\ecdbQdY_^ i_e gUbU cX_g^$ Qc gU\\$ dXU cU`QbQdU ]_TU\c _VRYbTc Y^ V\YWXd dXQd AQbUi XQT XQT cSe\`dUT _^ dXU RQcYc _V XYc SXb_^_`X_%d_WbQ`XYS UfYTU^SU& <UbU$ Y^ dXYc cUbYQ\YjUT `b_WbUccY_^$ gQc dXU lQ^Q\icYcm_V ]_dY_^$ _V gXYSX dXU lci^dXUcYc m S_e\T dXU^ RU `b_TeSUT Ri dXU gXYb\_V dXU j__db_`Uoc Y\\ecY_^&

:b_] dXU `QWUc _V FY HYlmj] Yd gQc `UbVUSd\i UfYTU^d d_ XY] dXQd dXU^Y^UdUU^dX%SU^debi QeTYU^SU _V dXYc ]QWQjY^U _V `_`e\Qb cSYU^SU \Y[UT d_`\Qi gYdX R_dX Q^Q\icYc Q^T ci^dXUcYc Qd dXU cQ]U dY]U$ gYcXY^W d_ RUSQ`dYfQdUT Ri dXU Q``UQbQ^SU _V dXU c`USdQS\U Q^T$ \Y[U dXU SXY\T Y^ Vb_^d_V dXU S\_S[ XU XQc Zecd TYc]Q^d\UT$ gQ^dY^W Q\c_ d_ RU S_^^USdUT d_ YdcY^^Ub g_b[c& HXU ]QWQjY^U XQT SQdUbUT d_ dXYc T_eR\U `\UQcebU& 9b^cd \__[cQd Q^ Y\\ecdbQdY_^ Y^ gXYSX ceSX Q^ QeTYU^SU Yc cX_g^ cYddY^W c`U\\R_e^T Y^Vb_^d _V Q cSbUU^ _^d_ gXYSX Q^ Q^QW\i`XYS Y]QWU Yc RUY^W SQcd Ri ]UQ^c_V Q cdUbU_cS_`YS `b_ZUSd_b& KQYcdS_QdUT$ W_QdUUT$ _b Y^ cdQic Q^T V\_gUbUTXQdc$ UQSX _V dXU fYUgUbc Yc gUQbY^W W\QccUc$ _^U \U^c bUT Q^T dXU _dXUbWbUU^$ Qc XU _b cXU cdQbUc Qd dXU eddUb\i U^dXbQ\\Y^W TYc`\Qi _V Q S_g Y^+%8 TbY^[Y^W Vb_] dXU RQ^[c _V Q cdQbd\Y^W\i S_^fY^SY^W cdbUQ]& :_b dXUbUQTUb$ \__[Y^W _^ Vb_] _edcYTU$ UfUbidXY^W Yc \QRU\UT$ dXU bUT RUQ]$ dXUWbUU^ _^U$ Q^T$ gXUbU dXUi Sb_cc$ dXU U]UbWU^SU _V gXYdU \YWXd&

HXYc R_dX%Qd%_^SU$ dXYc RUY^W SQeWXd Y^cYTU dXU Y\\ecY_^ Q^T dXYc \__[Y^W _^^_^UdXU\Ucc Vb_] gYdX_ed$ g_e\T$ XU e^TUbcd__T$ ceYd XYc `eb`_cUc `Ub%VUSd\i& =d g_e\T ]Q^YVUcd dXQd `USe\YQb VUU\Y^W i_e XQfU gXU^ i_e TbUQ]Q^T UfU^ gXY\U SQ`debUT Ri dXU U]_dY_^c _V Ydc TbQ]Q i_e SQ^ c`UQ[ _Vi_ebcU\V Qc c_]U_^U U\cU2 lM_eobU _^\i TbUQ]Y^W$ i_e [^_g&m G_ Y^ XYcS_\\QWU XU gY\\ ecU dXU j__db_`U Y^ ceSX Q gQi dXQd$ cY]e\dQ^U_ec\i Y^cYTUdXU Y\\ecY_^ Q^T _edcYTU Yd$ dXU \Ydd\U WYb\ gY\\ TbUQ] _V dQ[Y^W dXU fUY\&

5^T$ Y^UfYdQR\i$ XUb TbUQ] gY\\ RU `e\cQdY\U& HXU cebWU _V dXU gY^Wc RUQdY^We` Q^T T_g^ Vb_] gYdXY^ dXU Y\\ecY_^ gY\\ fYceQ\\i bXi]U gYdX dXU V\YS[UbY^WcdQSSQd_ _V dXU j__db_`Uoc ]_dY_^$ Q bXidX] S_^^USdY^W dXU Y^dUbY_b Y]QWUgYdX dXU UhdUbY_b lV_b]&m HXYc Yc dXU bXidX] dXQd gY\\ cY]e\dQ^U_ec\iS_^cdbeSd dXU WUcdQ\d Q^T dXbUQdU^ Yd gYdX TYcc_\edY_^$ gYdX Q RbUQ[e` Y^d_Ydc cU`QbQdU$ Y]`_dU^d VbQW]U^dc& 5^T dXYc Yc dXU bXidX]$ XU [^Ug Qc gU\\$dXQd gY\\ Q\\_g dXU Ub_dYS SebbU^dc _V dXU TbUQ] d_ cebVQSU&

;;dl`gm_` B]d]f] ak kallaf_ gf Y jg[caf_ [`Yajz`ak l`jgf](| Yk `] [Yddkalzk`] j]eYafk [Yj]^mddq eglagfd]kk( Yfq egn]e]fl( k`] j]Ydar]k( l`j]Yl)]faf_ l`ak ^YZmdgmk kladdf]kk( l`ak k]fk] g^ Z]af_ kmkh]f\]\( o]a_`ld]kk( af

Yf aeh]j[]hlaZdq \adYlaf_( dmeafgmk nga\* B]j l`gm_`lk k]]e af^afal]dq lg]phYf\ oal`af l`] jY\aYf[] g^ l`] ]fgjegmk klm\ag( l`]aj afl]fkalq eYl[`)af_ l`Yl g^ l`] ZjaddaYfl Ga\a kmf* ;; kgZ Ydegkl [Yl[`]k af `]j l`jgYl Ykl`] n]jq e]Yfaf_ g^ hYaflaf_ k]]ek lg ^dgg\ `]j ZjYaf* ?n]jql`af_(| k`]l`afck( ak [d]Yj lg e]* C Ye danaf_ gf] g^ l`gk] ege]flk o`]f l`] ogjcaf_kg^ l`] eaf\ Yj] Yl l`]aj c]]f]kl Yf\ gf]~k afl]dd][l j]Y[`]k gml lg e]]l l`][j]Ylgj~k o`a[` ^dgg\k Yf\ _jYla^a]k al*|

M`] ak `Yhhq ^gj gf[] l`Yl Ja[Ykkg akf~l `]j]( ogf~l kh]Yc aflg l`ak kad]f[](ogf~l jmhlmj] l`ak [gf[]fljYlagf( k[Yll]jaf_ al oal` ogj\k fg eYll]j `goZjaddaYfl* M`] l`afck g^ l`] aehgjlYf[] g^ l`ak ZdYraf_ kmf ^gj Ja[Ykkg* M`]l`afck g^ `go `] `Yl]k _jYq o]Yl`]j( jYaf( oaf\* N`] kmf `]j] ak Y kgjlg^ [`Yje(| k`] emk]k( hjgl][laf_ l`] addmeafYl]\ kad]f[] g^ ogjc*|

N`] kad]f[] Yf\ l`] kladdf]kk _g lg_]l`]j( l`] kladdf]kk l`Yl ak hYaflaf_~k`YddeYjc( hYaflaf_~k _]famk* M`] j]e]eZ]jk Ja[Ykkg kYqaf_( @gj e](B]d]f]( l`] jgd] g^ hYaflaf_ ak fgl lg \]ha[l egn]e]fl( lg hml j]Ydalq aflgeglagf* Clk jgd] ak jYl`]j( C l`afc( lg Yjj]kl eglagf* Cf gj\]j lg ^j]]r] l`]aeY_] qgm `Yn] lg gml\aklYf[] eglagf* C^ fgl( qgm Yj] YdoYqk jmffaf_Z]`af\* Ifdq Yl l`Yl n]jq ege]fl(| `] ogmd\ Y\\( \g qgm `Yn] j]Ydalq*|

N`Yl n]jq ege]fl( k`] emk]k( ak Y hYjY\gp* N`Yl n]jq ege]fl afngdn]kl`] YeYraf_ kh]]\ g^ l`] ]q] Yk al gmljmfk eglagf Zq kqfl`]karaf_ al aflgl`] kaf_d] aeY_] g^ alk e]Yfaf_*| J`glg_jYh`q~k ha[lmj] [Yf f]n]j Z]Yfql`af_ Zml ^jgr]f egn]e]fl( l`] _]klmj] \]hjan]\ g^ alk aff]j da^]* JYafl)af_( k`] l`afck( af alk n]jq kladdf]kk( alk [Yj]^mddq kljm[lmj]\ aeegZadalq( akl`] ljm] YfYdg_m] g^ l`] nakmYd [gehd]l]f]kk g^ l`ak eYkl]jq Zq l`] _Yr]*

Mad]f[]( l`] kad]f[] g^ l`]k] klm\agk af o`a[` Ja[Ykkg gZk]kkan]dq ogjck( l`][gehd]l]f]kk g^ l`ak kad]f[]( _mYjYfl]]\ Zq l`ak ZYcaf_( \Yrrdaf_ kmf( ak l`]f][]kkYjq e]\ame oal`af o`a[` l`] ZdY\] l`jmkl g^ l`ak _Yr] o`a[` ak Zgl`da_`lfaf_)ima[c Yf\ lae]d]kkz`Yf_af_ Yk al \g]k af l`] h]jh]lmYd km__]k)lan]f]kk g^ l`ak jY[] Z]lo]]f l`] lgjlgak] Yf\ l`] `Yj]zoadd Z] YZd] lgko]dd lg af^afalq*

M`] l]Yjk `]j ]q]k YoYq ^jge l`] hYaflaf_ egmfl]\ gf alk ]Yk]d lg dggcl`jgm_` l`] \]]h Yj[`]k g^ l`] \ggjoYq)oaf\gok* B]j _Yr] ko]]hk gn]jl`] lghk g^ l`] gdan] lj]]k hYkl l`] kad`gm]ll]k g^ l`] \aklYfl Zmad\af_k lgl`] k]Y dqaf_ af oYal af l`] ZY[c_jgmf\* Of\]j l`] ^dYeaf_ kmf l`] k]Y akegdl]f( Y Zm[cdaf_ k`]]l g^ e]lYd( alk kmj^Y[] jY\aYlaf_ oYn]k g^ `]Yl* M`]`]Yjk l`] [a[Y\Yk~ ^j]frq Yk l`]q ^add l`] Yaj oal` Y [gfklYfl k`ja]c* N`]j]ak l`ak caf\ g^ afnakaZd] [dgYc g^ [jYrq `]Yl(| k`] l`afck( mf\]j o`a[` l`]o`gd] g^ fYlmj] naZjYl]k( l`] Yaj lj]eZd]k(| Yk ]n]f l`] kgmf\ g^ l`]

Ml]j]gk[gha[ hjgb][lagfk( BS DSfgdW $-­45-­%( a' -­2*

M[eZ[`Y fa TW USbf[hSfWV Tk fZW SbbWSdS`UW aX fZW ebWUfSU^W ((( $b( ,*3%

JZ[e TafZ'Sf'a`UW& fZ[e TW[`Y USgYZf [`e[VW fZW [^^ge[a` S`V fZ[e ^aa][`Y a``a`WfZW^Wee Xda_ i[fZagf((( $b( ,*3%

L]qfYm\~k hjgb][lan] hjYpafgk[gh]( BS DSfgdW $-­44.%( h* /13*

`a_`oYq Z]dgozl`ak af[]kkYfl b_^b_^k`] kead]kz[gehd]l]k l`] imYd)alq g^ l`] Ylegkh`]j] af alk Ydegkl `qkl]ja[Yd hmdkaf_( k`aeeqaf_( Z]Ylaf_(Zghhaf_ * * *

M`] dggck ZY[c Yl l`] hYaflaf_ gf l`] ]Yk]d( DY[im]daf] jgqYddq dgmf_af_ gf`]j _j]]f SXQYcU& N`] YZkgdml] kad]f[] g^ l`ak hdY[](| k`] bglk af `]jfgl]Zggc( alk mll]j kladdf]kk( l`ak h]j^][l YeZa]f[] ^gj hYaflaf_~k lae]d]kk(eglagfd]kk _Yr]*|

B]d]f] JYje]daf ak( af l`ak( fgl`af_ a^ fgl gjl`g\gp* M`] Y_j]]k oal` l`]Yjl `aklgjaYf YZgml hYaflaf_~k _]famk( hYaflaf_~k dbedX& M`] Y_j]]k l`Yl l`akak [g]pl]fkan] oal` l`] ljml` g^ l`] l]jek g^ nakagf* N`gk] l]jek( k`][gf[mjk( `Yn] l`]aj ]pakl]f[] af Y khY[] l`Yl `Yk fgl`af_ lg \g oal`k]im]f[]( oal` fYjjYlan]( oal` egn]e]fl l`jgm_` lae]* N`] l]jek g^nakagf~k ljml` Yj] afkl]Y\ Y ^mf[lagf g^ o`Yl `Yhh]fk af l`] loafcdaf_ g^Yf ]q]*

N`] nakmYd hqjYea\ gf o`a[` [dYkka[Yd h]jkh][lan] ak Zmadl ak Y _]ge]ljq(Y^l]j Ydd( Zq o`a[` l`] daf]k g^ ka_`l Yf\ l`] daf]k g^ da_`l Yj] YZkgdml]dq[ggj\afYl]\( Y [ggj\afYlagf l`Yl hjg\m[]k l`] a\]flalq $af eajjgj% Z]lo]]fl`] nYfak`af_ hgafl oal`af l`] ha[lmj] Yf\ l`] na]oaf_ hgafl oal`af l`]]q]* ;;f\ al ak fgl ^gj fgl`af_ l`Yl l`ak _]ge]ljq lmjfk Yjgmf\ l`] YdegklmfaeY_afYZd] daeal g^ af^afalq(| Y hgafl l`Yl ak dal]jYddq j]\m[]\ lg fgl`af_*@Yj ^jge fgl`af_ [geaf_ ^jge fgl`af_( l`] ljml` l`Yl Yjak]k ^jge l`ak?m[da\]Yf e]]laf_ g^ hYjYdd]d daf]k Yl l`Yl hgafl Z]qgf\ l`] daeal g^ ae)Y_afaf_ ak l`] kgda\alq g^ l`] [gfkljm[lagf~k ZYkak af _]ge]lja[Yd dYo* ;;f\l`] af^afal] keYddf]kk g^ l`ak hgafl af l`] ]q] ^jge o`a[` l`] ]flaj] Yj[`a)l][lmj] ak kmkh]f\]\ ak( Yk o]dd( Yf af^afal] jYha\alq* C^( af l`] Yjl `aklgjaYf~kh]jkh][lan] \aY_jYek( l`] ]q] ak YdoYqk ha[lmj]\ gh]f Yf\ ^apYl]\( klYjaf_aflg l`] hqjYea\~k lmff]d( l`Yl~k Z][Ymk] al ak Yf ]q] l`Yl k]]k oal` km[`\Yrrdaf_ ima[cf]kk l`Yl al `Yk fg f]]\ lg Zdafc* Cl k]]k af Y loafcdaf_(Z]^gj] l`] Zdafc* ;;f\ l`ak loafcdaf_( l`ak af^afal] Zj]nalq gj aee]\aY[q g^l`] _Yr]( ak l`] YfYdg_m] ^gj l`] ha[lmj]~k gof [gf\alagf af l`] Ydd)Yl)gf[](^gj hYaflaf_~k gflgdg_a[Yd ljml` Yk hmj] kaemdlYf]alq*

Cl ak af l`ak k]fk] l`Yl hYaflaf_ ak jY\a[Yddq mfYkkaeadYZd] lg lae]* @gj aldan]k af Y h]jh]lmYd fgo*|

C^ l`] L]fYakkYf[] `Y\ \aY_jYee]\ l`] hmf[lmYdalq g^ l`ak na]oaf_ hgafl(al oYk eg\]jfake l`Yl afkakl]\ gf al( mf\]jk[gj]\ al( eY\] l`] akkm] g^ l`akaf\anakaZd] afklYfl g^ k]]af_ k]jn] Yk Y ^mf\Ye]flYd hjaf[ahd] af l`] \g[ljaf] Äg^ alk Y]kl`]la[ ljml`* Gg\]jfake oYk lg YZkgdmlar] l`ak fgo(| lg afkakll`Yl JYaflaf_ ]pakl oal`af l`] af\anakaZd] hj]k]fl g^ l`] ]plj]e]kl hgkkaZd]

h]j[]hlmYd afl]fkalq6 l`] jmk` g^ hmj] [gdgj7 l`] k`g[c g^ da_`l)gf)\Yjc Yk_jgmf\ hmddk d]n]d oal` ^a_mj]7 l`] j]\m[lagf g^ l`] ogjd\ lg hYll]jf*Hgl`af_ oYk lg k]_e]fl g^^ l`] fgo| ^jge alk]d^( fgl l`] [`Yll]j g^fYjjYlan] fgj l`] \akljY[lagf g^ \]k[jahlagf fgj ]n]f l`] k]fk] g^ Y k]hY)jYlagf Z]lo]]f l`] kmj^Y[] da^] g^ l`] aeY_] Yf\ l`] h`qka[Ydalq g^ alkkmhhgjl* N`] kaf_d]f]kk g^ l`] ha[lgjaYd \Ylme oYk lg Z] l`] eajjgj aeY_]g^ l`] ^gje l`jgm_` o`a[` al oYk Yhhj]`]f\]\( al oYk lg Z] l`] n]jqha[lmj] g^ l`] afklYflYf]alq g^ nakagf)af)[gfk[agmkf]kk*

;;f\ ]n]f o`ad] l`] eg\]jfakl Yjlakl `Y\ aflmal]\ l`] f]]\ ^gj l`ak kh]]\(l`ak nakmYdalq g^ l`] afklYfl( Bmkk]jd `Y\ l`]gjar]\ al* J`]fge]fgdg_q `Y\Ydkg f]]\]\ l`ak [gf[]hl g^ hmf[lmYdalq( g^ l`] ^_g Yk cdYW]U& Cf k]]caf_lg ^gmf\ l`] ljml` g^ [gfk[agmkf]kk af hjaegj\aYd aflmalagf( af l`] ^Y[l g^l`] aee]\aYl] k]d^)hj]k]f[] g^ dan]\ ]ph]ja]f[] Yk l`] eg\] g^ []jlalm\]Yf\ YZkgdml] f][]kkalq( Bmkk]jd ^gm_`l l`] a\]Y l`Yl [gfk[agmkf]kk f]]\]\lg l]dd alk]d^ YZgml o`Yl al oYk danaf_* =gfk[agmkf]kk \a\ fgl `Yn] lg Z]j]\gmZd]\ aflg Yf ]ph]ja]f[] Yf\ Y l`gm_`l YZgml( gj Yf YfYdqkak g^( l`Yl]ph]ja]f[] af gj\]j lg Zj]Yl`] e]Yfaf_ aflg al* N`] ]pakl]f[] g^ e]flYdY[lk( Bmkk]jd afkakl]\( \g]k fgl `Yn] lg Z] YfYdqr]\ Zq l`] kmZb][l Z][Ymk]l`]aj ]^^][lk Yj] aee]\aYl]dq hj]k]fl lg `ae af l`] hj]k]fl ege]fl* ;;f\af l`ak aee]\aY[q g^ k]d^)hj]k]f[] l`] hj]k]fl( Yk dan]\ aflmalagf( ak Ydj]Y\q^mddq e]Yfaf_^md*

N`] k]d^)aee]\aYl] ak l`] mfj]\gmZd]\* Cl \g]k fgl kYq fgo qgm Yj] _gaf_* * * (| fgo qgm Yj] \gaf_ * * * (| fgo qgm Yj] l`afcaf_* * * *| N`]j] akfg lae] ^gj l`Yl* C^( Bmkk]jd Yj_m]k( e]flYd Y[lk Yj] fgl Yffgmf[]\ lgl`]ek]dn]k l`jgm_` l`] afl]je]\aYjq g^ YfYdqla[Yd \ak[gmjk]( al ak Z][Ymk]l`]q Yj] dan]\ Zq mk af l`] kYe] afklYfl| "Y] cU\RU^ 5eWU^R\YS[#& N`akafklYfl( l`] afklYfl g^ k]d^)hj]k]f[]( ak af\anakaZd]* Cl ak Yk af\anakaZd] Yk Yloafcdaf_ g^ l`] ]q]*

N`mk l`] af\anakaZadalq g^ k]d^)aee]\aY[q oadd _g `Yf\)af)`Yf\ oal` l`]af\anakaZadalq g^ Y l]ehgjYd hj]k]fl( [`YjY[l]jar]\ Yk fgo*| DY[im]k >]j)ja\Y l`afck YZgml Bmkk]jd~k f]]\ ^gj l`ak [gf[]hl g^ fgo(| l`ak hgafl l`Yl(dac] l`] af^afalq| g^ l`] h]jkh][lan] \aY_jYe( [Yffgl Z] kmZ\ana\]\*

Cl ak Y ^a[lagf( `] l`afck* Cl ak Y eql`* Cl ak Y khYlaYd gj e][`Yfa[Yd e]lYh`gj(Yf af`]jal]\ e]lYh`qka[Yd [gf[]hl*| B] cfgok o`q Bmkk]jd emkl hj]k]jn]l`ak ^a[lagf( l`ak eql` g^ l`] afklYfl Yk Y hgafl* B] cfgok l`Yl a^ h`]fg)e]fgdg_q~k []fljYd [gf[]hl g^ k]d^)hj]k]f[] emkl Z] hjg\m[]\ af l`] mf)\ana\]\ mfalq g^ Y l]ehgjYd hj]k]fl( l`ak ak Z][Ymk] al emkl `Yn] fgl`af_lg j]n]Yd lg alk]d^ Zq o`Yl [Yf gfdq Z] l`] k][gf\`Yf\ Y_]f[q g^ ka_fk* ;;k

Bmkk]jd `Y\ ojall]f af =TUU^$ Z]lo]]f h]j[]hlagf gf l`] gf] `Yf\ Yf\l`] kqeZgda[ j]hj]k]flYlagf Zq e]Yfk g^ aeY_]k gj ka_fk gf l`] gl`]j( l`]j]]paklk Yf afkmjegmflYZd] ]a\]la[ \a^^]j]f[]*|

<ml l`ak ak Yf ]a\]la[ \a^^]j]f[]( >]jja\Y k]]k( l`Yl Bmkk]jd `aek]d^ ak ^gj[]\lg ]jg\] Yk( ojalaf_ oal` l`] o`gd] g^ faf]l]]fl`)[]flmjq f]mjgh`qkagdg_qYl `ak ZY[c( `] ak d]\ lg ]phYf\ gj \adYl] l`ak fgo(| lg eYc] al [gflafmgmkoal` kge]l`af_ ]dk]* N`]j] [Yf Z] fg dan]\ ]ph]ja]f[]( af ^Y[l( af l`]YZk]f[] g^ e]egjq Yf\ ]ph][lYlagf( gj Yk l`] h`qkagdg_akl ogmd\ l]jel`]e( j]l]fkagfk Yf\ hjgl]fkagfk* Bmkk]jd Y\ealk l`ak* Fakl]f lg `ae kYqaf_(l`] fgo)Yhhj]`]fkagf ak( Yk al o]j]( l`] fm[d]mk g^ Y [ge]l~k lYad g^j]l]fkagfk( Y\\af_ l`Yl Y hmf[lmYd h`Yk] ak Y[lmYddq hj]k]fl Yk fgo YlYfq _an]f ege]fl( o`ad] l`] gl`]jk Yj] [gff][l]\ Yk Y j]l]fkagfYd ljYaf*|Bmkk]jd lja]k lg _]l Yjgmf\ l`] hjgZd]e g^ l`ak j]l]fkagfYd ljYaf Yk kge])l`af_ YhYjl ^jge l`] fgo*| C^ l`] fgo ak hjaegj\aYd ]ph]ja]f[]( j]l]fkagfak k]]f Yk Y caf\ g^ hjaeYjq e]egjq l`Yl Bmkk]jd Ydkg oYflk lg [Yddhjaegj\aYd* Cl ak aee]\aYl] lg l`] fgo|7 fgl k][gf\`Yf\ dac] kge]l`af_j]e]eZ]j]\ dYl]j( Y^l]j l`] ]n]fl*

>]jja\Y d]Yhk gf l`ak ^Y[l g^ j]l]fkagf( l`ak fgfhj]k]fl [Yjja]\ aflg l`]hj]k]fl( l`ak fgl)fgo af^][laf_ l`] fgo* @gj al hgaflk lg l`] n]jq l]ehgj)Ydalq g^ [gfk[agmkf]kk k hmlYlan] hj]k]fl| l`Yl h`]fge]fgdg_q [YffglY[cfgod]\_]* ;;k kggf Yk o] Y\eal l`ak [gflafmalq g^ l`] fgo Yf\ l`]fgl)fgo( h]j[]hlagf Yf\ fgfh]j[]hlagf(| >]jja\Y ojal]k( af l`] rgf] g^hjaegj\aYdalq [geegf lg hjaegj\aYd aehj]kkagf Yf\ hjaegj\aYd j]l]fkagf(o] Y\eal l`] gl`]j aflg l`] k]d^)a\]flalq g^ l`] ;;m_]fZda[c7 fgfhj]k]f[]Yf\ fgf]na\]f[] Yj] Y\eall]\ aflg l`] Zdafc g^ l`] afklYfl* N`]j] ak Y\mjYlagf lg l`] Zdafc( Yf\ al [dgk]k l`] ]q]*|

C^d_ dXU cSbUU^ _V dXQd S\_cUT \YT$ 9b^cd XQT `b_ZUSdUT dXU `e\cQdY_^c _VdXU j__db_`U Qc Q^ U]R\U] _V dU]`_bQ\ TYcdU^cY_^ Q^T _V dXU cU\V%TYfYcY_^_V dXU TbUQ]2 S_^cSY_ec^Ucc Qc TUSYTUT\i ^_d cU\V%`bUcU^d Y^ dXU `bUcU^d$S_^cSY_ec^Ucc SbiY^W _ed d_ YdcU\V Vb_] dXU TU`dXc _V Ydc c`Qc] _V VUQb _b`\UQcebU$ B_g$ dXQd Yc i_e3 Q^T i_e QbU TbUQ]Y^W& m

9b^cdoc TbUQ] cXQbUc gYdX 8eSXQ]`oc `e\cU$ dXU `e\cU _V dXU Lglgj]da]^kQ^T _V dXU gX_\U _V DbUSYcY_^ C`dYSc$ Q^ QddU^dY_^ d_ dXU V_b]c _V ]QccSe\debU$ Zecd Qc Yd cXQbUc Q cU^cU dXQd dXYc `e\cU Yc Ub_dYS& =^TUUT dXU TQ^SUcdQWUT Ri dXU Lglgj]da]^k( Qc dXU Re]` Q^T WbY^T _V dXUYb WibQdY_^c `ecXUcdXU] Vb_] dXU Y\\ecY_^ _V _^U R_Ti `Qbd d_ dXU ^Uhd$ Yc 8eSXQ]`oc fUbcY_^_V Q cUfU^ fUY\c dXQd Yc TUU`\i Uh`\_YdQdYfU _V <eccUb\oc S_]Udoc dQY\$ oo XYcbUdU^cY_^Q\ dbQY^& HXU ^_g o _V <eccUb\oc cU\V%`bUcU^SU ]YWXd RU eddUb\i

TYcY^SQb^QdUTkTUVY^UT Ri dXU QRcU^SU _V dXQd fUbi R_Ti gYdXY^ gXYSXbUdU^cY_^Q\ ]U]_bi S_e\T e^V_\TkZecd Qc dXU TYcU]R_TYUT lUiU _V @U_%^QbT_oc `Ubc`USdYfU TYQWbQ]c Yc `bUcU^dUT Qc Q fYUgY^W l`_Y^d$m TUdQSXUTQ^T QRcdbQSdUT& 8eSXQ]`oc bU\YUVc QbU VYhUT$ Y^cdUQT$ _^ S_b`_bUQ\YjY^W dXUfYceQ\$ _^ bUcd_bY^W d_ dXU UiU "QWQY^cd dXU TYcU]R_TYUT _`dYSQ\Ydi _V ]_T%Ub^Ycd `QY^dY^W# dXQd UiUoc S_^TYdY_^ Qc R_TY\i _bWQ^$ QfQY\QR\U \Y[U Q^i_dXUb `XicYSQ\ j_^U d_ dXU V_bSU _V Ub_dYSYjQdY_^& 8U`U^TU^d _^ dXU S_^%^USdY_^ _V dXU UiU d_ dXU gX_\U ^Udg_b[ _V dXU R_Tioc dYcceU$ dXYc V_bSUgU\\c e` gYdXY^ dXU TU^cYdi Q^T dXYS[^Ucc _V dXU SQb^Q\ RUY^W$ Qc$ dYUT d_dXU S_^TYdY_^c _V ^Ubf_ec \YVU$ Yd Yc Ri TUVY^YdY_^ Q Ve^SdY_^ _V dU]`_bQ\Ydi&:_b dXU \YVU _V ^Ubf_ec dYcceU Yc dXU \YVU _V dY]U$ dXU Q\dUb^QdY^W `e\cU _VcdY]e\QdY_^ Q^T U^UbfQdY_^$ dXU S_]`\Uh VUUTRQS[ bU\Qic _V bUdU^cY_^ Q^T`b_dU^cY_^& G_ dXQd dXU dU]`_bQ\ Yc ]Q``UT _^d_ dXU VYWebQ\ Y^ dXU c`QSU_V DbUSYcY_^ C`dYSc Qc dXU c`USYVYS RUQd _V TUcYbUk_V Q TUcYbU dXQd ]Q[UcQ^T \_cUc Ydc _RZUSd Y^ _^U Q^T dXU cQ]U WUcdebU$ Q WUcdebU dXQd Yc S_^dY^%eQ\\i \_cY^W gXQd Yd XQc V_e^T RUSQecU Yd XQc _^\i V_e^T gXQd Yd XQcQ\bUQTi \_cd&

5^T Yd Yc dY]U Qc gU\\ dXQd ;;YQS_]UddY S_ebdc$ `\QSY^W Yd Y^ dXU SU^dUb _VdXU SQWU _V XYc Mmkh]f\]\ <Ydd( Q\\_gY^W dXU fYceQ\ VbQ]U d_ RU Y^fQTUT RidXU U]_dY_^Q\\i TYcdebRY^W TYcbe`dY_^ _V Q RUQd& ;;k dXU `U^Te\e] _V dXUS\_fU^ RQ\\ cgY^Wc _fUb dXU QddU^TQ^d gUTWU$ dXYc RUQd cUU]c d_ ]UQcebU_ed dXU _cSY\\QdY^W TUdUb]Y^QdY_^c _V WU^YdQ\Ydi& HXU RQS[%Q^T%V_bdX _V dXUg_b[oc bXidX]YS QbS _`UbQdUc Qc Q dU]`_bQ\ Q^Q\_WeU d_ dXU cXYVdY^W e^%TUSYTQRY\Ydi _V Ydc TUVY^YdY_^ _V WU^TUb$ dXU cSe\`debU dXec QccUbdY^W YdcU\V QcQ ]QSXY^U WUQbUT d_ dXU S_\\Q`cU _V cUheQ\ TYVVUbU^SU& 5c ;;YQS_]UddYoc \Ydd\UWeY\\_dY^U _V SQcdbQdY_^ g_b[c _^SU QWQY^ Y^ bU\QdY_^ d_ Q RUQd$ Ydc `e\cUSQ^ RU cUU^ d_ RU _`UbQdY^W Y^ Q gQi dXQd Yc TUU`\i Y^Y]YSQ\ d_ dXU cdQ%RY\Ydi Q^T cU\V%UfYTU^SU _V V_b]$ d_ dXU `Ub]Q^U^SUk\Ud ec cQik_V dXUW__T WUcdQ\d&

@gje oYk o`Yl B]d]f] JYje]daf `Y\ mf\]jklgg\ l`Yl \Yq( Yk l`] e]Yfaf_g^ hYaflaf_ jmk`]\ lg `]j `]Y\ oal` Y [gf[dmkan]f]kk l`Yl d]^l `]j ^Yafl*@gjezl`] _]klYdlzoYk o`Yl `Y\ hj]k]fl]\ alk]d^ lg `]j Yk ^gmf\af_ hjaf)[ahd] af l`] ^a]d\ g^ l`] nakmYd6 Y k]fk] l`Yl hYaflaf_~k e]Yfaf_ oYk lg Z]^gmf\ af l`] kaemdlYf]gmk k]hYjYlagf Yf\ aflY[lf]kk g^ ^a_mj] Yf\ _jgmf\(af l`] _]klYdl~k gh]jYlagf Yk l`] [gf[gj\Yf[] Z]lo]]f YZkgdml] \a^^]j]f[]$^a_mj] n]jkmk _jgmf\% Yf\ [gehd]l] kaemdlYf]alq $fg ^a_mj] oal`gml_jgmf\%* M`] `Y\ cfgof( Ja[Ykkg `Y\ af\]]\ lgd\ `]j( l`Yl l`] ^a]d\ g^_gg\ ^gje `Yk fg f]]\ g^ eglagf7 l`Yl eglagf [ge]k ^jge gmlka\] l`]\geYaf g^ l`] nakmYd* ;;dd l`gk] Z]Ylk l`Yl kmjjgmf\]\ l`] klm\agzl`]b_^b_^ g^ l`] `a_`oYq( l`] ljadd g^ l`] [a[Y\Yk( ]n]f l`] lj]eZdaf_ g^ l`]

`]Yl emkl dg_a[Yddq Z] \aklaf[l ^jge l`ak nakmYd ^a]d\( [Yf Z] fgl`af_ Zmlafl]jdgh]jk ^jge l`] \geYaf g^ l`] l]ehgjYd( l`] Ym\algjq( l`] \ak[mjkan]*Hg( k`] `Y\ l`gm_`l( l`]q [Yffgl Z] l`] eYljap oal`af o`a[` l`] eYkl]jogjck* ;;f\ l`] hmdk] g^ l`] l]d]nakagf~k aeY_] Ydkg emkl Z] gmlka\] l`]nakmYd(| emkl Z] ]pl]jfYd( ][[]flja[ lg l`ak ogjd\ g^ ^gje*

<ml l`ak fglagf g^ gmlka\]f]kk( g^ l`] l]ehgjYd Yk f][]kkYjadq gmlka\] l`]nakmYd( l`ak a\]Y g^ l`] k]hYjYlagf g^ l`] k]fk]k gf o`a[` eg\]jfake~k dg_a[ak Zmadl( al ak bmkl l`ak l`Yl l`] Z]Yl ]phdgal]\ Zq l`] Yjlaklk g^ l`] ghla[Ydmf[gfk[agmk| [gfl]klk* N`] hmdk] l`]q ]ehdgq ak fgl mf\]jklgg\ lg Z]kljm[lmjYddq \aklaf[l ^jge nakagf Zml lg Z] Yl ogjc ^jge \]]h afka\] al* ;;f\^jge l`Yl hdY[]( lg Z] Y ^gj[] l`Yl ak ljYfk_j]kkan] g^ l`gk] n]jq fglagfk g^\aklaf[lf]kk mhgf o`a[` Y eg\]jfakl ghla[Yd dg_a[ \]h]f\k* Cfkg^Yj Ykl`]q afkakl l`Yl al ak fgl l]ehgjYd( l`] Z]Yl l`]q ]ehdgq emkl( af kge]k]fk]( Z] ^a_mjYdzZml g^ Yf gj\]j g^ l`] ^a_mj] l`Yl ak ^Yj YoYq ^jge l`]j]Yde g^ khY[] l`Yl [Yf Z] f]Yldq ghhgk]\ lg l`] eg\Ydalq g^ lae]*

N`] gj\]j g^ l`] ^a_mj]* Gg\]jfake aeY_af]k log km[` gj\]jk* N`] ^ajkl akl`Yl g^ ]ehaja[Yd nakagf( l`] gZb][l Yk al ak k]]f(| l`] gZb][l Zgmf\]\ Zqalk [gflgmjk( l`] gZb][l eg\]jfake khmjfk* N`] k][gf\ ak l`Yl g^ l`] ^gjeYd[gf\alagfk g^ hgkkaZadalq ^gj nakagf alk]d^( l`] d]n]d Yl o`a[` hmj]| ^gjegh]jYl]k Yk Y hjaf[ahd] g^ [ggj\afYlagf( mfalq( kljm[lmj]6 nakaZd] Zml mfk]]f*N`Yl ak l`] d]n]d l`Yl eg\]jfake oYflk lg [`Yjl( lg [Yhlmj]( lg eYkl]j*N`Yl ak l`] ^gjeYd gj\]j g^ l`] _]klYdl l`Yl B]d]f]( \arrq oal` [gehj]`]f)kagf( `Y\ _jYkh]\* <ml l`]j] ak Y l`aj\ gj\]j g^ l`] ^a_mj]( gf] l`Yl D]Yf)@jYf_gak FqglYj\ `Yk \][a\]\ lg [Ydd ]QdbYh$ Zq o`a[` `] e]Yfk Yf gj\]jl`Yl gh]jYl]k Z]qgf\ l`] j]Y[` g^ l`] nakaZd]( Yf gj\]j l`Yl ogjck ]flaj]dqmf\]j_jgmf\( gml g^ ka_`l*

B] `Y\ klYjl]\ g^^( g^ [gmjk]( ^jge l`] hgkalagf g^ Bmkk]jd( Yf\ g^ G]jd]Ym)Jgflq( oal` Y Z]da]^ af Y hjaegj\aYd aflmalagf l`Yl ak fgl af f]]\ g^ [gf)[]hlk| af gj\]j lg _jYkh alk ogjd\* Hgl`af_ [ge]k Z]^gj]| lg k`Yh] l`]Yh]jlmj] l`Yl h]j[]hlagf gh]fk gflg l`] ^a]d\ g^ ]ph]ja]f[]7 fgl`af_ kljm[)lmj]k l`Yl gh]faf_ af Y\nYf[]* N`Yl ak o`q( `] l`afck( h`]fge]fgdg_q~k^gmf\af_ hjaf[ahd] ak fgl afl]flagfYdalq| Zml hYkkanalq* Mmj]( =]rYff]afl]f\]\ Yf ]ph]ja]f[] af o`a[` TU`dX ogmd\ Zmj_]gf ^gjl` ^jge l`]]na\]f[] g^ egmflYafk Yf\ lj]]k7 Zml l`] ZY[c_jgmf\ g^ l`ak afl]flagf(FqglYj\ k]]k( oYk Yf ]plj]e] hYkkanalq( Y ngdmhlmgmk kladdf]kk l`jgm_`o`a[` =]rYff] [gmd\ Yddgo l`ak e]Yfaf_)af)\]hl` lg `Yhh]f* N`Yl hYkkan)alq( `] l`afck( h]jealk l`] Zg\q~k gof \]fkalq lg o]dd mh aflg l`] ^a]d\ g^h]j[]hlagf Yf\ lg [Yjjq Ydgf_ oal` al fgl h`]fge]fgdg_q~k mf[gfk[agmkzY caf\ g^ hjaegj\aYd mfalq l`Yl ak alk]d^ l`] kmZb][l g^ [gfklalmlagfzZml Y

\a^^]j]fl mf[gfk[agmk( l`] gf] l`Yl ak l`] gZb][l g^ j]hj]kkagf* Q`Yl G]j)d]Ym)Jgflq [Yffgl Y\\j]kk( FqglYj\ emk]k( ak =]rYff]~k \]kaj]*

Hg eYll]j( `] l`afck* B] oadd Y\\j]kk al* N`gm_` h`]fge]fgdg_q~k mf[gf)k[agmk ak fgl l`Yl g^ @j]m\( l`] log Yj] [gehYlaZd] af l`]aj Z]da]^ af Yhjaegj\aYd khYlaYdalq* @gj l`] [gflafmgmk ]pl]fkagf oal`af o`a[` l`] Zg\q~k_]klmj] mf^gd\k alk e]Yfaf_ ak( Y^l]j Ydd( l`] kYe] e]\ame af o`a[` l`][gehd]p \Yf[] g^ \akhdY[]e]flk Yf\ [gf\]fkYlagfk g[[mjk( Y [gflafmalq`gklad] lg l`] klY[[Ylg Zj]Yc)mh g^ l`] khYlaYd e]\ame o`a[` ak l`Yl g^kh]][`* N`] ljYfkhYj]fl _ja\ o`]j] ka_fa^a]jk Yj] ^gje]\ l`jgm_` l`] j]_)mdYl]\ Y[lagf g^ khY[af_ ak Yf YZkljY[l( hmj]dq [gf[]hlmYd e]\ame \akbmf[l^jge l`] gf] l`jgm_` o`a[` l`] h]j[]hlmYd ]n]fl mfjgddk gj l`] aehj]kk g^\]kaj] ko]ddk*

FqglYj\ l`mk Z]_afk oal` h`]fge]fgdg_q~k \ak\Yaf ^gj \ak[gmjk]( ^gj dYf)_mY_]( ^gj [gf[]hlk( ^gj l`] dYo* ;;f\ lg l`ak `] Y\\k l`Yl g^ hkq[`gYfYdqkak*Cf l`]aj emlmYd ghhgkalagf lg dYf_mY_]( daZa\afYd Yf\ k]fkgjq e]Yfaf_( `]l`afck( k]]e lg eYh gf] gflg l`] gl`]j* <ml al ak af l`] j]Yde g^ l`akdan]\| khY[] g^ ]ph]ja]f[] l`Yl l`]q Ydkg Zj]Yc YhYjl* @gj h`]fge]fgd)g_q~k ogjd\ ak ^gj]n]j l`Yl g^ l`] `QbdUc UhdbQ `QbdUc$ g^ Y khY[] l`Ylmf^gd\k hjg_j]kkan]dq( [gfklYfldq eYcaf_ jgge ^gj l`] Zg\a]k l`Yl ^add al*Cf l`ak al ak Y khY[] l`Yl ak ^mf\Ye]flYddq fYcYR\U$ o`]l`]j alk gj_Yfaraf_hjaf[ahd] Z] k]]f gj fgl* Cl ak l`] khY[] af o`a[` ^gje| oadd [ge] aflgZ]af_7 l`] khY[] g^ _gg\ ^gje( g^ l`] _]klYdl*

Jkq[`gYfYdqkak~k khY[]( l`] khY[] g^ l`] mf[gfk[agmk( `] [ge]k lg j]Ydar](\ak\Yafk l`ak ^mf\Ye]flYd fglagf g^ l`] [ggj\afYl]k g^ l`] j]Yd* Cf \]^aYf[]g^ Ydd hjgZYZadalq al Yddgok log( gj l`j]]( gj ^an] l`af_k lg Z] af l`] kYe]hdY[] Yl l`] kYe] lae]* ;;f\ l`]k] l`af_k Yj] l`]ek]dn]k mll]jdq `]l]jg[dal](fgl nYjaYlagfk gf gf] Yfgl`]j Zml l`af_k af lglYd ghhgkalagf* N`ak khY[]|ak l`]j]^gj] imal] dal]jYddq mfaeY_afYZd]6 Y [gf_]Yd]\ Zdg[c g^ [gfljY\a[)lagfk* Hgl Y ^mf[lagf g^ l`] nakaZd]( al [Yf gfdq Z] aflmal]\ l`jgm_` l`]hjgb][lagf g^ nYjagmk ^a_mj]k| l`Yl kmj^Y[] ^jge l`] \]hl`k g^ l`ak khY[]|6l`] kdah g^ l`] lgf_m]( l`] \Yq\j]Ye( l`] ^YflYkq* Ng l`ak e]\ame( dqaf_Z]dgo l`] d]n]d g^ l`] nakaZd]( `] _an]k l`] fYe] ]QdbYh$ Yf\ `] Z]_afk lg^gddgo alk Y[lanalq( o`a[` `] j][g_far]k Yk l`] hjg\m[lagf fgl g^ l`] _]klYdlZml g^ ZY\ ^gje( l`] Y[lanalq l`jgm_` o`a[` ^gje ak af ^Y[l ljYfk_j]kk]\*

Fggcaf_ ^gj afklYf[]k g^ l`]k] ZY\ ^gjek| af @j]m\~k Y[[gmflk g^ `ak[Yk]k( `] l`afck g^ l`] klgjq g^ l`] qgmf_ ogeYf o`g( af Y ^al g^ hYjYfga\^YflYkq( aeY_af]k `]j dgn]j `Yk h`glg_jYh`]\ `]j dqaf_ oal` `ae gf Y[gm[`* M`] `]Yjk| Y fgak] l`Yl k`] afkaklk ak l`] [da[caf_ g^ Y [Ye]jY~k

k`mll]j* <ml @j]m\ mf\]jklYf\k al gl`]joak]* Cl ak( `] kYqk( Y j]h]lalagf g^l`Yl hjaeYd ^YflYkq( kg [geegf af [`ad\j]f( g^ oYl[`af_ l`]aj hYj]flkeYcaf_ dgn]( Y ^YflYkq o`gk] Ym\algjq [gehgf]fl ak kaemdlYf]gmkdq l`]kgmf\ g^ o`Yl ak `Yhh]faf_ Yf\ Y ^]Yj g^ eYcaf_ Y fgak] l`Yl oadd Z]ljYql`]aj hj]k]f[]* Agaf_ ]n]f ^Yjl`]j l`Yf l`ak( @j]m\ Yj_m]k l`Yl l`] ^YflYkqYddgok l`] qgmf_ ogeYf `]j] lg hdYq l`] jgd] g^ `]j egl`]j( Yf\ `Ynaf_]fl]j]\ gflg l`] klY_] g^ alk k]pmYd Y[lagf( lg hjg\m[] l`] [da[c| g^ l`][Ye]jY Yk Y hYjYfga\ \]faYd g^ l`] hmdk] g^ `]j gof ]p[al]e]fl*

B] dac]k l`] [da[c| Yk Y ^a_mj]* <ml( `] [gf[dm\]k( l`]j] ak fgl ]fgm_` afo`Yl @j]m\ j]dYl]k `]j] lg Z] YZd] lg hdgl l`] ogjcaf_k g^ l`] eYljap*

Mg `] lmjfk lg l`] [Yk] [Ydd]\ ;; =`ad\ Ck <]af_ <]Yl]f*|

Cl ak l`] klgjq g^ Y ^YflYkq l`Yl k]n]jYd hYla]flkz^add]\ oal` l]jjaZd] k`Ye]z[gf^]kk lg @j]m\* ;; [`ad\ ak Z]af_ Z]Yl]f(| l`]q l`afc( Yk l`]q ^af\l`]ek]dn]k k`Ycaf_ oal` hd]Ykmj]* N`] kaf_d] k]fl]f[] ak klYjldaf_ af alkZj]nalq* @j]m\ hjgZ]k* B] \ak[gn]jk o`Yl `] l`afck emkl Z] Yf ]Yjda]jn]jkagf g^ l`] ^YflYkq( gf] o`]j] l`] hYla]flzgf] g^ ^gmj oge]f o`ge(Ydgf_ oal` log e]f( `] `Yk YfYdqr]\zak YZd] lg kYq l`Yl Yf Y\mdl( q]k(mf\gmZl]\dq `]j ^Yl`]j( ak Z]Ylaf_ Yfgl`]j [`ad\7 k`] ak dggcaf_ gf* Mg `]`Yk log k]fl]f[]k6 N`] ^Yl`]j Z]Ylk l`] $gl`]j% [`ad\|7 Yf\ ;; [`ad\ akZ]af_ Z]Yl]f*| Mge]l`af_ `Yk `Yhh]f]\ Z]lo]]f l`] ^ajkl k]fl]f[] Yf\ l`]k][gf\( `] fgla[]k* ;;[lan] `Yk lmjf]\ lg hYkkan]* N`ak d]Y\k `ae lg aeY_af]Yf afl]je]\aYjq klY_] af o`a[` km[` Y ljYfk^gjeYlagf [gmd\ g[[mj* Cl ak YklY_]( `] j]Ydar]k( g^ mlegkl aehgjlYf[] lg l`] gZk]kkagfYd [`YjY[l]j g^ l`]^YflYkq( Z][Ymk] al ak l`Yl ljYfkalagf l`Yl _an]k al alk ]jgla[ khaf* N`] hYla]fl\g]k fgl hjg\m[] l`ak klY_]7 @j]m\ j][gfkljm[lk al( Zq n]fljadgimq( Yk alo]j]* C Ye Z]af_ Z]Yl]f Zq l`] ^Yl`]j(| al _g]k*

Cf `ak j]Z]ddagf Y_Yafkl o`Yl `Yk [ge] lg k]]e lg `ae l`] YZkgdmlake Yf\mZaimalq g^ Yf a\]gdg_q g^ l`] ka_f(| g^ l`] jak] Yf\ ljameh` g^ kljm[lmjYddaf_makla[k( Yf\ g^ k]eagdg_q( FqglYj\ ak ^add]\ oal` Y\eajYlagf ^gj l`akegn]* Mljm[lmjYdake( _jgmf\af_ alk gof ljml` af l`] dYok g^ ghhgkalagfZ]lo]]f ZafYjq hYajk( ak ^gf\ g^ l`] hjaf[ahd] g^ [geemlYZadalq* Cf l`]YZkljY[l( dg_a[Yd khY[] g^ l`] lYZd] af o`a[` M ak [gfljYkl]\ oal` M( al eYc]kfg \a^^]j]f[] a^ M o]j] lg hj][]\] alk ghhgkal]* N`ak [geemlYZadalq ak Yf]imYddq f]mljYd Y^^Yaj ^gj l`] daf_makl( o`g kYqk l`Yl Y ljYfk^gjeYlagf aflgl`] hYkkan] ak [gjj][l a^ al [`Yf_]k fgl`af_ af l`] e]Yfaf_7 l`mk( R Z]YlkY [`ad\| ak l`] kYe] Yk Y [`ad\ ak Z]af_ Z]Yl]f Zq R*| <ml mfdac] l`]daf_makl( l`] YfYdqkl `Yk k]]f \]kaj] kf]Ycaf_ l`jgm_` l`] khY[] g^ l`ak\aY_jYe( ljqaf_ lg ]k[Yh] Yll]flagf Zq( g^ [gmjk]zo`q fgl:z^gddgoaf_

l`] jmd]k* ;;l l`] n]jq afl]jagj g^ l`ak d]_alaeYl] ljYfk^gjeYlagf o`gddq[gflYaf]\ oal`af l`] kqkl]e g^ _``_cYdY_^c$m FqglYj\ eYjn]dk( l`] l`jmklg^ Yf YfYd)kY\akla[ j]_j]kkagf lgoYj\ eYkg[`akla[ hd]Ykmj] ak fgf]l`]d]kkj]hj]k]fl]\*~| N`] YfYdqkl( [Yjaf_ fgl`af_ ^gj l`] dg_a[ g^ [geemlYZadalq~kfg [`Yf_](| `Yk khgll]\ l`] oYq \]kaj] `Yk hml l`] affg[]f[] g^ kqflYplg ogjc kg l`Yl l`] f]mljYd| ^Y[l g^ l`] hYkkan] nga[] ea_`l [Yjjq l`]hkq[`a[ e]Yfaf_ aehda]\ Zq Y j]lj]Yl ^jge Y[lagf* N`] Y[lanalq g^ R Z]Ylkl`] [`ad\| ak _]falYd( l`] ]phj]kkagf g^ I]\ahYd \]kaj]( Yk l`] _ajd a\]fla^a]koal` `]j ^Yl`]j* <ml Yk l`] j]hj]kkagf g^ l`ak \]kaj] Yf\ alk j]d]Yk] g^ _madlljYfkhgjlk l`] oYl[`af_ hYla]fl aflg l`] hdY[] g^ l`] $gl`]j% [`ad\( hYkkan](k`] fgo Ykkme]k l`] jgd] g^ na[lae* S]l l`] eYkg[`ake g^ l`ak hgkalagf`Yk alk gof j]oYj\k( Yk Y khYfcaf_ l`Yl ak Ydkg mf\]jklgg\ Yk Y [Yj]kk`Ykl]fk Y j]_j]kkan] \]ZYk]e]fl af l`] daZa\afYd fYlmj] g^ l`] \jan]* N`]^Yl`]j Z]Ylk l`] [`ad\| `Y\ Z]]f mf\]jklgg\ Yk $N`]j]^gj]% eq ^Yl`]jdgn]k e](| o`a[` oYk e]Yfl af l`] _]falYd k]fk]* Ioaf_ lg j]_j]kkagf(|@j]m\ ojal]k( al ak lmjf]\ aflg Gq ^Yl`]j ak Z]Ylaf_ e] $C Ye Z]af_ Z]Yl]fZq eq ^Yl`]j%*~ N`ak Z]af_ Z]Yl]f ak fgo Y e]]laf_)hdY[] Z]lo]]f l`] k]fk]g^ _madl Yf\ k]pmYd dgn]* =d Yc ^_d _^\i dXU `e^YcX]U^d V_b dXU V_bRYTTU^WU^YdQ\ bU\QdY_^$ Red Q\c_ dXU bUWbUccYfU ceRcdYdedU V_b Yd$ Yf\ ^jge l`ak dYll]jkgmj[] al \]jan]k l`] daZa\afYd ]p[alYlagf o`a[` ak ^jge l`ak lae] ^gjoYj\YllY[`]\ lg al*|

;; =`ad\ Ck <]af_ <]Yl]f| ak ]n]jqo`]j] ^add]\ oal` l`ak dg_a[ g^ Zml Ydkg*|N`Yl ak o`Yl FqglYj\ Y\eaj]k af al* @gj bmkl Yk l`] Z]Ylaf_ ak fgl gfdqhmfak`e]fl ^gj _madl Red Q\c_ Y kgmj[] g^ hd]Ykmj]( ]n]jq gl`]j ]d]e]fl akkaeadYjdq jmd]\ Zq l`ak oad\ YeZanYd]f[]( l`ak kaemdlYf]gmk `gd\af_ g^ logo`gddq [gfljYjq hgkalagfk* N`ak kaemdlYf]alq ak l`] h][mdaYj l]ehgjYdalq g^l`] eYljap( l`] ^Y[l l`Yl oal`af al( gf] klY_]| \g]k fgl hjg_j]kk Z]qgf\Yf\ l`mk kmh]jk]\] Yfgl`]j7 jYl`]j( l`] e]Yfaf_k g^ Ydd l`] klY_]k j]eYafkmkh]f\]\ oal`af al( af l`] ^gje g^ Y Zml Ydkg*| FqglYj\ \][a\]k lg [Yddl`ak Zml Ydkg| Y \a^^]j]f[]| Yf\ lg [Ykl l`ak fglagf g^ TYVVUbU^SU af l`]l]]l` g^ kljm[lmjYdake~k jmd] g^ _``_cYdY_^& Ihhgkalagf ak o`Yl dg_a[Yddq[gfkljm[lk l`] \akljaZmlan] \aklYf[]k oal`af l`] \aY_jYeeYla[ khY[] g^kljm[lmjYdake( `gd\af_ YhYjl gf] l`af_ ^jge Yfgl`]j Yf\ l`]j]^gj] Ylgf] Yf\ l`] kYe] lae] ]klYZdak`af_ l`] ]d]e]flk g^ l`] kqkl]e $o`Yl Fqg)lYj\ [Yddk l`] hjg\m[lk g^ k]hYjYlagf|% Yf\ l`] jmd]k g^ l`]aj ljYfk^gjeY)lagf $l`] hjg\m[lan] k]hYjYlagfk|%* N`] dm[a\alq g^ kljm[lmjYdake~k khY[](l`] h]j^][l ljYfkhYj]f[q g^( ^gj ]pYehd]( l`] Ed]af Ajgmh( ak Y ^mf[lagfg^ l`ak [gflafmYd k]hYjYlagf g^ ghhgkal]k( l`ak eYafl]fYf[] g^ l`] dYo g^fgf[gfljY\a[lagf*

N`] ogjc g^ l`] mf[gfk[agmk( `go]n]j( \g]kf~l j][g_far] l`ak dYo( `Yk fgmk] ^gj f]_Ylagf* Cl l`mk [gmjlk l`] ljYfk^gjeYlagf g^ ]n]jql`af_ aflg alkghhgkal]( `gd\af_ Zgl` g^ l`]k] l`af_k lg_]l`]j Yl gf[]*

Cl Yemk]k FqglYj\ lg [gehYj] l`] eYljap ^a_mj] g^ l`] mf[gfk[agmk lg l`]kljm[lmjYdakl~k kqkl]e( kaf[] Zgl`( Y^l]j Ydd( k`Yj] l`] hjgh]jla]k g^ afnaka)a dlq Yf\ kqf[`jgfq* <ml l`] kljm[lmjYdakl~k afnakaZadalq ak l`Yl g^ Y najlmYdgj\]j ogjcaf_ oal`af l`] kqkl]e lg hjg\m[] alk afl]dda_aZadalq6 l`] kqkl]eYk Y hjg\m[]j g^ e]Yfaf_* Q`ad] l`] eYljap~k afnakaZadalq ak Y ^mf[lagf g^l ] j]hj]kkan] ogjc g^ emlYlaf_ ]n]jql`af_ aflg alk ghhgkal]( l`]j]Zq mf)\]jeafaf_ l`] hjg\m[lan] ogjc g^ kljm[lmj]* N`] ]d]e]flk g^ l`] eYljapFqglYj\ l`afck( \g fgl ^gje Y kqkl]e Zml Y Zdg[c* o>W l`] eYljap ak afnakaZd]~al ak fgl Z][Ymk] al Yjak]k ^jge l`] afl]dda_aZd]( Zml Z][Ymk] al j]ka\]k af QkhY[] l`Yl ak Z]qgf\ l`] afl]dda_aZd]( ak af jY\a[Yd jmhlmj] oal` l`] jmd]k g^ghhgkalagf al ak alk [`YjY[l]jakla[ lg `Yn] eYfq hdY[]k af gf] hdY[](Yf\ l`]q Zdg[c lg_]l`]j o`Yl ak dg_a[Yddq af[gehYlaZd]* N`ak ak l`] k][j]l`W l`] ^a_mjYd6 l`] ljYfk_j]kkagf g^ l`] [gfklalmlan] afl]jnYdk g^ \ak[gmjk]Yf\ l`] ljYfk_j]kkagf g^ l`] [gfklalmlan] \aklYf[] g^ j]hj]k]flYlagf* | ~

;;k al Zdg[ck lg_]l`]j Y[lan] Q^T hYkkan]( _]falYd Q^T YfYd( kY\ake Q^TeYkg[`ake( oYl[`af_ Q^T Z]af_ oYl[`]\( ;; [`ad\ ak Z]af_ Z]Yl]f|zl`][gehd]l]\ ogjc g^ l`] eYljapzgn]jdYqk [gfljY\a[lagf Yf\ [j]Yl]k l`]kaemdlYf]alq g^ dg_a[Yddq af[gehYlaZd] kalmYlagfk* S]k( FqglYj\ l`afck l`]^YflYkq ak l`] h]j^][l eYljap ^a_mj]( Z][Ymk] l`] klYl]e]flk gf] [Yf hjgb][lYk dYq]j]\ oal`af al l`Yl gj_Yfar] l`] _gYd $lg Z]Yl%( l`] kgmj[] $l`] YfYdrgf]%( Yf\ l`] gZb][l $l`] ^Yl`]j% g^ gf] k]fl]f[] Yj] af l`]aj lmjf [gf\]fk]\aflg Y kaf_d] hjg\m[l ^gjemdY);; [`ad\ ak Z]af_ Z]Yl]f~)o`gk] YhhYj]fl[g`]j]f[] Yddgok l`] hkq[`a[ da^] lg [gflYaf af Y kaf_d] eYfa^gd\ Y emdla)hda[alq g^ dg_a[Yddq af[gehYlaZd] k]fl]f[]k*~ N`]k] \g fgl ^gje Y kqkl]eZml Y Zdg[c* N`mk l`] \jan] lg Z] Yf\ lg `Yn] l`] ^Yl`]j ak kaemdlYf]gmk)Yf\ l`] afn]kle]fl ak Zgl` _]falYd)h`Ydda[ Yf\ kY\akla[)YfYd*|

<ml l`]j] ak gf] afnYjaYf[] af Ydd g^ l`ak( gf] [gfklYfl* Cl ak af Y k]fk] l`]eYljap ^a_mj]~k gof e]\ame( l`] gf] l`Yl e]Ykmj]k g^^ Ydd l`] gk[addYlagfkg^ hdY[] Yf\ g^ \aj][lagf( l`] gf] l`Yl l`]f Zdg[ck l`]e lg_]l`]j gf l`]j`ql`e g^ alk hYjla[mdYj Y[lagf* N`Yl Y[lagf ak lg Z]Yl| Yf\ al ak l`ak hmdk]l`Yl j]eYafk mf[`Yf_]\ ^jge klY_] lg klY_]* N`] [gfl]flk g^ l`] ^YflYkqeYq ] af [gflafmYd ^dmp( eYjc]\ Zq Y [gfklYfl afklYZadalq* <ml mf\]jdqaf_l ]k] [gfl]flk ak Y ^gje6 Y j`ql`e( Y hmdk]* Cl ak l`ak ^gje l`Yl ogjck lgk][mj] l`] a\]flalq g^ l`] ^YflYkq km[` l`Yl af ]Y[` g^ alk gZk]kkagfYdj]h]lalagfk al oadd YdoYqk j]lmjf Yk l`] kYe]* N`] ^YflYkeYla[ eYljap |FqglYj\ l`afck( ak ]na\]fldq Y ^gje*~| 1

FqglYj\ ak fgl `Yhhq* Bgo af _]f]jYd(| `] l`afck( [Yf l`Yl o`a[` ak^gje Ydkg Z] ljYfk_j]kkagf: Bgo [Yf o`Yl ak \]naYlagf( \]jg_Ylagf( \])[gfkljm[lagf( Z] Yl l`] kYe] lae] ^gje:| N`ak hmdk]( `] gZb][lk( ak lgg ]Ykqlg YkkaeadYl] lg emka[Yd afl]jnYdk( lg [`jgeYla[ ghhgkalagfk( lg l`] \aY)[`jgfa[ j`ql`ek g^ e]l]j gj ]n]f l`] kqf[`jgfa[ j`ql`e g^ [gdmefk gf Y^Y[Y\]( af k`gjl( lg l`] dYo g^ hjghgjlagfYdalq* ;;dd l`] Jql`Y_gj]Yf JdY)lgfaklk oadd Zmjkl aflg YhhdYmk](| `] ^me]k( a^ o] Yj] ^gj[]\ lg _jYfl l`Yll`] gj\]j g^ l`] ^YflYkq( l`] j]_mdYjalq oal`af o`a[` l`] kmZb][l~k mf[gf)k[agmk ak kg lg kh]Yc [Ym_`l(~ l`] ^gjeYd eYljap g^ alk \j]Yek Yf\ alkkqehlgek( ak gZ]\a]fl lg Y jYlagfYdarYZd] hjghgjlagf*| <me)ZY`( Zme)ZY`( Zme)Zme* N`ak hmdk] ogmd\ k]]e lg j]lmjf mk lg l`] afl]jnYda[( Yf\l`jgm_` _gg\ ^gje| lg dYf_mY_]* ;; caf\ g^ ^mf\Ye]flYd aYeZ(| `]ogjja]k*

N`]f `] l`afck YZgml 6Ui_^T dXU D\UQcebU DbY^SY`\U Yf\ l`] log \a^^]j]flhmdk]k l`Yl @j]m\ o]Yn]k lg_]l`]j l`]j]* If] ak l`] `me g^ [`Yj_] Yf\\ak[`Yj_] Yk l`] hd]Ykmj] hjaf[ahd] gh]jYl]k lgoYj\ l`] j]d]Yk] g^ l]fkagfYf\ l`] eYafl]fYf[] g^ l`] dgo]kl d]n]dk g^ ]p[alYlagf* N`ak j`ql`e( o`a[`ak l`] gf+g^^ l`jgZ g^ ' z ' z ' gj g^ l`] hj]k]f[] Yf\ YZk]f[] g^[gflY[l( [Yf Z] k]]f Yk l`] e]lja[Yd ^a_mj]| g^ d_ RUQd2 alk ^gje* <ml l`]k][gf\ hmdk] ak fgl Y hjaf[ahd] g^ j][mjj]f[] _mYjYfl]]af_ l`Yl Yf gf|oadd YdoYqk ^gddgo Yf g^^|7 al eYhk l`] hjaf[ahd]( afkl]Y\( g^ afl]jjmhlagf*Cl ak Y hmdk] l`Yl ak jYl`]j lg Z] ^a_mj]\ Yk ' ,( o`a[` ak lg kYq ]pakl]f[]^gddgo]\ Zq lglYd ]plaf[lagf* Cl ak l`mk Y Z]Yl| l`Yl \g]k fgl hjgeak] l`]j]lmjf g^ l`] kYe]( Zml kaehdq j])lmjf( l`] [geaf_ g^ fgl`af_* N`ak k][gf\hmdk] ak fgl Y _gg\ ^gje( fgl Y _gg\ _]klYdl* LYl`]j( `] l`afck( al ak Y^gje af o`a[` \]kaj] j]eYafk [Ym_`l( ^gje [Ym_`l Zq ljYfk_j]kkagf7 Zml alak Ydkg l`]( Yl d]Ykl hgl]flaYd( ljYfk_j]kkagf g^ ^gje*| N`] Yfpa]lq l`Yl akhYjl g^ l`] Y^^][l g^ ;; =`ad\ Ck <]af_ <]Yl]f(| [geZafaf_ oal` alk ]jgla[hd]Ykmj]( Yjak]k hj][ak]dq ^jge l`] ^gj[] g^ jmhlmj] l`Yl ak j][mjj]fl af l`]j`ql`e g^ l`] ^a_mj]( Y jmhlmj] l`Yl ak fgl ]ph]ja]f[]\ Yk l`] gfk]l g^ q]lYfgl`]j [gflY[l Zml Yk Yf YZkgdml] Zj]Yc( l`Yl \ak[gflafmalq oal`gml ]f\l`Yl ak \]Yl`* N`mk al ak l`] \]Yl` \jan]( gh]jYlaf_ Z]dgo l`] hd]Ykmj]hjaf[ahd]( FqglYj\ k]]k( l`Yl ljYfk[g\]k l`ak j`ql`ezYk al Z]Ylk oal` l`]Ydl]jfYlagf Z]lo]]f hd]Ykmj] Yf\ ]plaf[lagfzaflg Y [gehmdkagf lg j]h]Yl*N`] eYljap ak l`] ^gje l`Yl ^a_mj]k j][mjj]f[]*

HXU RUQdY^W _V dXU j__db_`U$ SbQ^[Y^W e` d_ c`UUT$ dXU RUQdY^W _V dXU We\\ocgY^Wc gYdXY^ dXU Y]QWY^Qbi c`QSU$ dXU RUQdY^W _V Q\\ dX_cU ]USXQ^YSQ\TUfYSUc dXb_eWX gXYSX dXU bUQ\ Q``UQbc d_ Rebcd Y^d_ \YVU Vb_] dXU cXQbTc_V dXU Y^_bWQ^YS Q^T TUQdX\i cdY\\$ Q^T dXU `QbdYSe\Qb V_b] _V dXU `\UQcebU

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( :W\Wg`Wd egd ?tZWdTW VtSbdWe CS`Wf& -­, Dmdq -­52-­*

HXU fQbYQdY_^ _^ Q dXU]U Yc Q S_]`\UdU dX_eWXd QR_ed Q^_dXUb S_]`\UdUdX_eWXd & & & "`& **-­#

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( :W\Wg`Wd egd ?tZWdTW VtSbdWe CS`Wf& -­/ Dmdq -­52-­*

<e^TbUTc _V `bU`QbQd_bi cdeTYUc Ri ]UQ^c _V gXYSX dXU _bYWY^Q\ S_e\T RUcUU^ d_ RU fQbYUT _fUb dXU dY]U _V XYc SbUQdYfU QddU^dY_^ & & & "`& **.#

S_^^USdUT d_ dXQd bXidX]$ Q\\ dXYc RUSQ]U Q bUc_ebSU V_b Q^ QbdYcdYS `bQSdYSUTYcY^S\Y^UT d_ _RUi dXU ]_TUb^Ycd \Qg _V dXU Y]]_RY\Ydi _V `QY^dY^W& :_%SecUT cY]e\dQ^U_ec\i _^ dXU e^S_^cSY_ec Wb_e^T _V dXQd `\UQcebU Q^T _^Ydc ]UTYQ V_b]$ gXYSX Yc d_ cQi Ydc bU\QdY_^ d_ ]USXQ^YSQ\ bU`b_TeSdY_^$dXU QbdYcdc _V dXU l_`dYSQ\ e^S_^cSY_ecm gUbU S_^SUb^UT gYdX dXU fUXYS\Uc_V ]Qcc Se\debU& =d cUU]UT d_ dXU] dXQd gXQd gQc S_^VYb]UT dXUbU gQc Q^_bTUb Y^ gXYSX dXU ^UQd cU`QbQdY_^ _V dXU cU^cUckc`QSU \_WYSQ\\i cUW]U^dUT_VV Vb_] dY]UkXQT RUU^ TYcc_\fUT$ TUS_^cdbeSdUT& HXQd dXU RUQd ce]%]_^UT Ri dXUcU TUfYSUc S_e\T ^_d RU e^TUbcd__T Qc cdbeSdebQ\\i TYcdY^SdVb_] lfYcY_^m Red Qc _`UbQdY^W Vb_] gYdXY^ Yd& HXUi gU\S_]UT dXYc RUQd$dXU^$ Qc Q V_bSU dXQd S_e\T dbQ^cWbUcc dX_cU fUbi ^_dY_^c _V lTYcdY^Sd^Uccm_^ gXYSX ]_TUb^Yc] bU\YUc& HXU RUQd cUU]UT d_ cSQddUb dXU SUbdQY^di _V QcdQdU]U^d \Y[U DYSQcc_oc2 l:_b ]U$ dXU b_\U _V `QY^dY^W Yc ^_d d_ TU`YSd]_fU]U^d$ d_ `ed bUQ\Ydi Y^d_ ]_dY_^& =dc b_\U Yc bQdXUb$ = dXY^[$ d_ QbbUcd]_dY_^&m

N`] YfYdqkak g^ l`] _]klmj] aflg alk af[j]e]flYd \akhdY[]e]flk( kg l`Yl l`]YfaeYlagf hjg[]kk [Yf h`glg_jYh` l`] k]hYjYl] j]f\]jaf_k g^ l`] kYe]Zg\q ]Y[` lae] ]n]j kg kda_`ldq j][gf^a_mj]\7 l`] e][`Yfa[Yd hjg[]\mj] g^[j]Ylaf_ l`] eafml] nYjaYlagfk l`Yl [Yf kmZk]im]fldq Z] b]jc]\ aflg eglagfZq l`]aj hYkkY_] l`jgm_` l`] [Ye]jY~k _Yl] gj Zq l`] ]n]f [jm\]j ja^^daf_g^ hY_]k af l`] [geegf ^dahZggc6 Ydd l`ak( Yk Y j]kgmj[] g^ l`] Z]Yl( ]paklk(al ogmd\ k]]e( ead]k YoYq ^jge Ja[Ykkg~k klm\ag* N`]j] `ak ogjc oYk\]\a[Yl]\( ^gj l`] dYkl log \][Y\]k g^ `ak da^]( lg Yfgl`]j hjg[]kk ]flaj]dq6l`Yl g^ l`]e] Yf\ nYjaYlagf*

Bgo Yhl l`ak hjg[]\mj] k]]ek lg `ak klja[lmj]k Y_Yafkl l`] Y\eakkagf g^egn]e]fl aflg hYaflaf_* N`] nYjaYlagf gf Y l`]e] ak Y [gehd]l] l`gm_`lYZgml Yfgl`]j [gehd]l] l`gm_`l( ]Y[` o`gddq aeZja[Yl]\ oal`af l`] gl`]j(o`a[` ak lg kYq( oal`af l`] [gf^af]k g^ l`] ha[lgjaYd ^jYe]( Yk f]Yldq Yk a^af Y f]kl g^ =`af]k] Zgp]k* ;;k l`] nYjaYlagf k][mj]k alk gof ha[lgjaYd mfalqZgl` Y_Yafkl Yf\ af j]dYlagf lg l`] mfalq g^ l`] l`]e]( al Z][ge]k Y\][dYjYlagf g^ l`] ]f]j_a]k g^ l`] afn]flagf g^ alk Yml`gj( g^ l`] [gflafmYdmhkmj_] oal`af `ak aeY_afYlagf g^ ]n]j f]o oYqk g^ [gf[]anaf_ l`] gja_afYda\]Y( fg eYll]j `go hgo]j^md* ;; oYjjYfl g^ Y ^mf\ g^ gja_afYdalq l`Ylk]]ek f]n]j lg Z] kh]fl( l`] nYjaYlagf \][dYj]k alk]d^ Y j]kgmj[] g^ ngdmflYjqj]h]lalagf( l`] gmlhgmjaf_ g^ l`] [gfljgdd]\ hdYq g^ \a^^]j]f[]( o`gddqmfdac] l`] ]ehlq j][mjj]f[] g^ l`] e]\aY ^gjek* >]]h aflg l`] dYl]j h`Yk]kg^ l`] Y_] g^ e][`Yfa[Yd j]hjg\m[lagfzl]d]nakagf( \ak[gk( ljYfkaklgj jY)\agkzl`] Ymkl]jalq g^ l`] ha[lgjaYd nYjaYlagf k]]ek k][mj] Y_Yafkl l`] j`ql`)ea[ hmdd g^ l`] Z]Yl*|

N`] :U]]Uc To5\WUb$ l`] AU^Y^Qc$ l`] FQ`XQU\ Q^T dXU :_b^QbY^Q$ l`]8UZUe^Ub ceb =oXUbRU$ Ydd k]jn]\ Yk YjeYlmj]k ^gj l`ak hjg[]kk( l`jgm_`o`a[` l`] eYkl]j khmf gml `mf\j]\k g^ hj]hYjYlgjq klm\a]k Zq e]Yfk g^o`a[` l`] gja_afYd [gmd\ Z] k]]f lg Z] nYja]\ gn]j l`] lae] g^ `ak [j]Ylan]Yll]flagf( ]Y[` klm\q kmklYafaf_ Yf\ ljY[caf_ l`] Zmjklk g^ `ak aeY_afYlan]]f]j_q* ?n]f ^jge oal`af l`] ^mjq g^ ogjc( Ja[Ykkg [Yj]^mddq dg[Yl]\ ]Y[`]d]e]fl af l`] hjg[]kk( j][gj\af_ alk \Yl] Yf\( kaf[] l`] e]j] af\a[Ylagf g^Y \Yq ogmd\ fgl km^^a[] lg \aklaf_mak` l`] af\ana\mYdk af l`ak emdlalm\]( alkfmeZ]j* N`mk al ak hgkkaZd] lg ^gddgo l`]k] [j]Ylan] kljYf\k( lg j]]d mh l`]l`j]Y\ g^ l`ak ^YZmdgmk YZYf\gf( Yf\ lg ljq lg ]fl]j l`] [Yn] g^ l`] eYkl]j~kafkhajYlagf* Cl ak af l`ak n]af l`Yl l`] Yjl `aklgjaYf \ak[mkk]k l`] kc]l[`]kd]Y\af_ lgoYj\ gf] g^ Ja[Ykkg~k n]jkagfk g^ l`]8UZUe^Ub ceb =oXUbRU&

>mjaf_ l`] l`j]] \Yqk ^jge l`] 3l` lg l`] -­,l` g^ Dmdq Ja[Ykkg _Yn]`aek]d^ mh lg Y h]jag\ g^ afl]fk] [j]Ylan] ogjc gf l`] 8UZUe^Ub$m `]j]hgjlk* Cf l`Yl k`gjl lae] `] \j]o fg d]kk l`Yf .4 f]o [gehgkalagfYdklm\a]kz-­4 g^ l`]e af gf] \YqzYf\ ]p][ml]\ Y k][gf\ \]^afalan] nYjaYlagfaf gadk* N`]k] \jYoaf_k j]n]Yd ]n]f egj] l`Yf l`gk] o`a[` hj][]\]\ l`]el`] [gf[]fljYlagf g^ `ak l`gm_`l*| N`] `aklgjaYf \]k[jaZ]k l`] klmll]j oal`o`a[` l`] \jYoaf_k Yffgmf[]\ j]h]Yl]\ keYdd [gjj][lagfk Yf\ j]nakagfk*@jge gf] lg l`] f]pl( l`af_k Yj] [`Yf_]\ Yjgmf\ ]n]j kg kda_`ldq(| `]gZk]jn]k( Yk Yf Yje gj Y d]_ oadd Z] egn]\ ^gj l`] kYc] g^ l`] _]f]jYd\]ka_f*| <ml fg eYll]j `go k]]eaf_dq ljYfkalgjq( l`] \jYoaf_k Yj] \][dYj]\lg Z] eYkl]jdq(| Yf\ oal`af l`]e l`] `aklgjaYf k]]k Ja[Ykkg ogjcaf_oal` l`] ^]jngj Yf\ [gfk[a]flagmkf]kk g^ Y =]rYff]*|

=]rYff]( o] j]e]eZ]j( ak l`] n]jq h]jkgfa^a[Ylagf g^ l`] h`]fge]fgdg_akl~kfgo(| l`] Yjlakl o`g oYk YZd] lg gmloYal Yhh]YjYf[]k kg l`Yl l`] e]Yfaf_g^ \]hl` [gmd\ o]dd mh oal`af `ae* B] ak l`] Yjlakl o`g oYk YZd] kgYZkgdml]dq lg kqfl`]kar] l`] lae] g^ l`ak oYalaf_ aflg Y kaf_d]( af]plja[YZd]mfalq l`Yl `] k]]e]\ lg hjgna\] l`] n]jq hjgg^ g^ l`] fglagf g^ l`] _]klYdl*

Ja[Ykkg~k \jYoaf_k( `go]n]j eYkl]jdq(| Yj] fgl kqfl`]k]k af l`ak k]fk]* C^`] oYk YZd] lg hjg\m[] ]a_`l]]f af Y \Yqzkge]l`af_ l`Yl ogmd\ `Yn]Z]]f af[gf[]anYZd] ^gj =]rYff]zal oYk Z][Ymk]( lg Y []jlYaf ]pl]fl( `]`Y\ Y e][`Yfa[Yd( j]hjg\m[lan] ZYkak ^gj `ak hjg[]kk* N`] kc]l[`ZggckJa[Ykkg ^add]\ af l`] log Yf\ Y `Yd^ q]Yjk g^ `ak ogjc gf l`] 8UZUe^Ub Yj]hjg\m[]\ af l`] eYff]j g^ l`] YfaeYlagf ^ade* @gj l`] \jYoaf_ gf ]Y[`hY_]zaf[ak]\ aflg alk kg^l( l`a[c hYh]j oal` k`Yjh h]f[ad]\ daf]kzaf ^Y[l]eZgkk]k alk [gflgmjk aflg l`] hY_] dqaf_ Z]f]Yl` al* N`ak ljY[]( a\]fla[Ydlg l`] ^ajkl( k]jn]k Yk l`] [gflgmj ^gj Y f]o \jYoaf_ Ydegkl l`] loaf g^ l`]gf] gf l`] hY_] YZgn] Zml ^gj l`] ^Y[l l`Yl( Yk l`] Yjl `aklgjaYf `Y\ fgl]\(

),-57 )2.,::7 %030<609 :<9 +109-0 />,890: (,60;; *40;;.1-774 " '<5= !$#! &

$/ )%'4 (.&033(3 ,43 '0/40523 ,/40 4+( 1%*( -6,/* &(/(%4+ , 4 ! ! ! 1! ""#

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( :W\Wg`Wd egd ?tZWdTW VtSbdWe CS`Wf I]WfUZTaa]& 0 Dmdq -­52-­ CC*

lHXY^Wc QbU SXQ^WUT Qb_e^T UfUb c_ c\YWXd\im& & & "`& **1#

l`af_k Yj] [`Yf_]\ Yjgmf\ ]n]j kg kda_`ldq*| Qal` dXYc fgo Yk l`] ZYkak(l`] hjg[]kk l`]f [gflafm]k( Yk l`] f]o hY_] ]l[`]k alk gof [gf^a_mjYlagfaf lmjf aflg l`] km[[]]\af_ d]n]d g^ l`] kc]l[`Zggc( Yf\ kg gf* N`] eg\]g^ hjg\m[lagf Ja[Ykkg [Yf l`mk Z] k]]f lg Y\ghl ak fgl l`Yl g^ l`] km[[]kkan]mhkmj_] g^ j]f]o]\ afkhajYlagf Zml l`Yl g^ l`] e][`Yfa[Yddq j]hjg\m[]\k]ja]k( ]Y[` e]eZ]j g^ o`a[` kmklYafk l`gk] eafml] nYjaYlagfk l`Yl k]]elg YfaeYl] l`] _jgmh Yk Y o`gd]* ;;f\ l`ak YfaeYlagf [Yffgl Z] l`gm_`lg^ Yk Y ^gje g^ Y]kl`]la[ nalYdake7 al ak fgl gf l`] gj\]j g^ l`] gd\ gj_Yfa[e]lYh`gj Yhhda]\ lg [gehgkalagfYd mfala]k* Cl ak Yf YfaeYlagf l`Yl `Yk`meZd]j Ykkg[aYlagfk6 l`] j]dYlan] g^ l`] [gea[k( g^ [Yjlggfk( g^ >akf]q*;;f\ af\]]\ lg ]phdgj] km[[]kkan] dYq]jk g^ l`] k]im]f[]zYk h]]daf_ l`]eZY[c gf] ^jge l`] f]pl o] k]] l`] lafq YfYlgea[Yd k`a^lk Yf\ ko]ddaf_kzak lg `Yn] l`] aehj]kkagf fgl g^ oYl[`af_ Yf a\]Y af \]n]dghe]fl ZmljYl`]j g^ gZk]jnaf_ _]klmj] af eglagf* N`mk imal] mf]ph][l]\dq( Ja[YkkghdY[]k `ak na]o]j af l`] hj]k]f[] g^ Y ^dahZggc*

Hg gf] ]n]j lYdck YZgml l`ak hjg[]kk lg o`a[` l`] kc]l[`Zggck Z]Yj oalf]kk*Hg gf] ]n]j kYqk l`Yl al j]k]eZd]k l`] ^dahZggc* T]jngk j]hjg\m[]k l`]\jYoaf_k af n]jla[Yd [gdmefk( kg l`Yl gf] ogmd\ f]n]j cfgo( gf] ogmd\f]n]j kmkh][l( l`] eYff]j af o`a[` l`]q o]j] af ^Y[l eY\]* Sgm ogmd\gfdq cfgo al a^ qgm `Y\ `]d\ l`]e af qgmj `Yf\k* Sgm ogmd\ `Yn] lg `Yn]Z]]f YZd] lg lmjf l`]aj hY_]k* ;;f\ l`ak qgm [gmd\ gfdq `Yn] \gf] a^ qgm`Y\ Z]]f Y\eall]\ lg `ak klm\ag* ;;f aflaeYl]* Fac] B]d]f] JYje]daf*

Q`Yl ak ^g[mk]\ gf( afkl]Y\( o`]f kh]Ycaf_ g^ l`]k] [gehgkalagfk ZYk]\gf l`] ogjc g^ gl`]jk( ak l`] ^j]]\ge g^ Ja[Ykkg~k j]dYlagf lg l`] gja_afYd(l`] daZ]jlq oal` o`a[` `] ]fl]jk Yf\ d]Yn]k al* ;; hYafl]j g^ _]famk(| al aklqha[Yddq kYa\ g^ `ae( k]]ek lg `Yn] l`] [YhY[alq lg kmjj]f\]j ngdmflYjadqlg afkhajYlagf \]janaf_ ^jge Yfgl`]j ogjc g^ Yjl Yf\ l`]f( ]k[Yhaf_ ^jgeal( ^af\ `ak aeY_afYlan] klj]f_l` j]f]o]\ Yf\ [YhYZd] g^ hjgb][laf_ Yf aeY_]g^ `ak gof*| N`ak \ak[mkkagf g^ kmjj]f\]j Yf\ [Yhlmj] ak afl]j]klaf_* <])[Ymk]( ]n]f l`gm_` al ak YdoYqk [daeYp]\ Zq j]YkkmjYf[]k YZgml l`] Yjlakl~k^j]]\ge( al Z]ljYqk( fgf]l`]d]kk( Y caf\ g^ Yfpa]lq YZgml Ja[Ykkg~k ]fl]j)hjak] af l`]k] ogjck( ]n]f o`ad] al mll]jdq eaklYc]k l`] fYlmj] g^ l`]kmjj]f\]j| afngdn]\* @gj l`] kmjj]f\]j g^ l`] Yjlakl~k aeY_afYlagf( l`]hdY[] af o`a[` al ak [Ym_`l Zq Z]af_ _an]f gn]j lg hd]Ykmj]( ak l`] ^mf[lagfg^ Y e][`Yfa[Yd \]na[]zYf YhhYjYlmk g^ l`] kh][lY[d]zl`] hjg\m[lagf g^Y ngdmhlmgmk hYkkanalq6 l`] e][`Yfake g^ l`] k]jaYd YfaeYlagf g^ l`] ^dah)Zggc~k Z]Yl*

Hgo`]j] ak l`ak ngdmhlmgmk km[[meZaf_ lg l`] mf[gfk[agmk hjg\m[lanalqg^ l`] \]na[] [d]Yj]j l`Yf af l`] kc]l[`Zggc Ja[Ykkg eY\] Yk Y caf\ g^[daeYp lgoYj\ o`a[` Ydd l`] gl`]jk o]j] d]Y\af_( l`] kc]l[`Zggc g^ ;;m_mkl

.( -­52.* B]j] l`] ]jgla[ afn]kle]fl af l`] k[]f] ak eY\] Yk ]phda[al YkhgkkaZd]( Yk l`jgm_` faf] km[[]kkan] hY_]k l`] gj_aYkla[ kmZl]pl g^ l`]8UZUe^Ub ceb =oXUbRU ak ]fY[l]\( l`] aehgjlYfl nYjaYlagfk oal`af l`ak j])h]Yl]\ Yhh]YjYf[] Yf\ \akYhh]YjYf[] g^ l`] k[]f] Z]af_ l`] ea_jYlagf g^l`] Y[lgjk~ _]falYdk lg nYjagmk kal]k gf l`]aj Zg\a]k*

N`] \akhdYq g^ l`] _]falYdk oal`af l`ak eYljap g^ l`] ^dahZggc ^gje [Yf(egj]gn]j( Z] k]]f lg Z] o`Yl em[` g^ l`] hj][]\af_ .,, kc]l[`]k `Y\Z]]f hj]hYjaf_ ^gj* Ja[Ykkg~k dgf_)`]d\ ^Yk[afYlagf oal` l`] ^a_mj] g^ l`]ogeYf Z]f\af_ gn]j Yf\ k]]f ^jge YZgn]zZ]f\af_ lg la] `]j kYf\Yd( lg\jq `]jk]d^( gj Yk af l`] 8UZUe^Ub$ lg ZYl`]z`Y\ Ydj]Y\q Z]]f Yl ogjcoal`af l`ak k]ja]k g^ nYjaYlagfk lg k]pmYdar] l`] aeY_]* N`] ^]eYd] ^a_mj]na]o]\ af l`ak hgkalagf ak nmdf]jYZd] lg Y ljYfkemlYlagf l`Yl Ja[Ykkg j])h]Yl]\dq h]j^gjek gf al( o`]l`]j al g[[mjk af l`] c]]faf_ GY_\Yd]f] ^jgel`] 7beSYVYhY_^ gj l`] ZYl`]j ^jge l`] 8UZUe^Ub& <]fl lg hjgb][l Z]dgo `]jZj]Yklk( l`] ^]eYd] `]Y\ kmZealk Y_Yaf Yf\ Y_Yaf lg l`] kYe] ljYfk^gj)eYlagf( Yk al ak j][Ykl Yk h`Ydda[ ka_fa^a]j( l`] klYf\)afzeYhh]\ gflg l`]fgk] Yf\ `Yaj g^ l`] ^]eYd] ^Y[]z^gj l`] _]falYdk g^ Yf YZk]fl eYd]*

N`Yl Ja[Ykkg k`gmd\ `Yn] hmjkm]\ l`ak aeY_] gn]j eYfq q]Yjk( l`Yl `]k`gmd\ `Yn] `Y\ ^j]im]fl Yf\ kh][lY[mdYj j][gmjk] lg l`] \]ha[lagf g^k]pmYd Y[lk( e]Yfkzgf] [gmd\ gZb][lzl`Yl `] []jlYafdq \a\ fgl ^UUT l`]^dahZggc kljm[lmj] ^gj h]jeakkagf lg n]fl l`] ]jgla[ lmjf g^ `ak aeY_afYlagf*S]l ]n]f o`ad] Y_j]]af_ l`Yl `] \a\ fgl f]]\ al( al ak hgkkaZd] lg l`afc l`YlYk( Yl l`] ]f\ g^ `ak da^]( al Z][Ye] l`] e]\ame g^ `ak Y[lanalq( `] \a\ af\]]\Z][ge] [Ym_`l af alk e][`Yfake( `ak Yjl Z][geaf_ egj] Yf\ egj] Y^mf[lagf g^ Ydc hmdk]* ;;f\ kg l`gm_` `] \a\ fgl f]]\ al `] qa]d\]\ lg al( lgl`] Yhh]Yd g^ hmj] j][mjj]f[]( lg l`] k]\m[lagf Yf\ l`] [gfl]fl g^ Yf]f\d]kk hmdk]* N`] e][`Yfa[Yddq j]h]Yl]\ Yf\ l`] ]jgla[Yddq ]fY[l]\ k]]e]\lg `Yn] ljYhh]\ `ae Yf\ `] [j]Yl]\ l`] e]lYh`gjk g^ l`ak [Yhlmj]* Cf -­520`] eY\] kge] []jYea[ lad]k gf ]Y[` g^ o`a[` Y hjaYha[ kYlqj hmjkm]k Yfqeh` oal` l`] j]h]lalan] ]pY[lalm\] Y l]ehdYl] hjgna\]k* B] oYk k`goaf_B]d]f] JYje]daf l`] \gr]f gj kg ]pYehd]k `] `Y\ eY\] Yf\ `] Ykc]\ `]j(Qgmd\f~l al Z] hj]llq lg `Yn] ]flaj] jggek lad]\ dac] l`Yl:| M`] af[dm\]kl`ak j]eYjc af Y k][lagf g^ `]j Zggc lald]\ Ja[Ykkg( l`] GgjYdakl*|

;;k gYd^Ucc d_ ]eSX _V dXU dXUQdUb _V DYSQcc_oc fQbYQdY_^c$ cXU bU]U]RUbcdXU cUccY_^c Qd ^YWXd Y^ XYc cdeTY_ gXUbU dXUi g_e\T Q\\ WQdXUb d_ ]QbfU\Qd dXU c\YTUc `b_ZUSdUT VYfU dY]Uc$ dU^ dY]Uc \YVU%cYjU _^d_ dXU VQb gQ\\ _V dXUb__]2 D_eccY^oc GYkkY[j] g^ l`] Cffg[]flk Wb_g^ d_ dXYbdi VUUd XYWX38U\QSb_Yhoc ?fljYf[] aflg =gfklYflafghd] Q^ Y]]U^cU R\QjU _V S_\_b& CdXUb`U_`\U ]YWXd W_ d_ dXU ]_fYUc$ cXU g_e\T dXY^[& HXYc Yc _eb c`USdQS\U

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( HSbZSW^ Wf ^S <ad`Sd[`S& 0 M]hl]eZ]j -­524 C*

;;hW` iZ[^W [f gffWd^k _[efS]We fZW `SfgdW aX fZW qegddW`VWdr[`ha^hWV((( $b( ,,3%

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg( :W\Wg`Wd egd ?#TWdTW VtSbdWe CS`Wf I]WfUZTaa]& . ;;m_mkl -­52. C*

HXYc f_\e`de_ec ceSSe]RY^W d_ dXU e^S_^cSY_ec `b_TeSdYfYdi _V dXUTUfYSU &&& "`& **1#

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg(:W\Wg`Wd egd ?tTWdTW V#SbdWe CS`Wf I]WfUZTaa]& . ;;m_mkl -­52. CC*

HXU TYc`\Qi _V dXU WU^YdQ\c gYdXY^ dXYc ]QdbYh _V dXU V\Y`R__[V_b] & & & "`& *+(#

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg(K`f[f^WV& -­1 Hgn]eZ]j -­522 PC*

JZSf F[USeea eZag^V ZShW bgdegWV fZ[e [_SYW ahWd _S`k kWSde ((( $b( ,-­*%

6ed _^U dY]U dXU c`USdQS\U Yc ^_d c_ `\UQcQ^d& =d Yc Q TQi Qd JQefU^QbWeUc7Qcd\U$ ]QccUT Qd dXU V__d _V dXU A_^d GQY^dU JYSd_YbU$ gYdX DYSQcc_oc ]__TQc R\QS[ Qc dXU TQi Yc SbicdQ\\Y^U& B_^UdXU\Ucc XU Y^fYdUc XYc WeUcdc Y^d_ XYccdeTY_$ _VVUbY^W d_ cX_g dXU] XYc _g^ S_\\USdY_^ _V dXU `QY^dY^Wc _V _dXUb]QcdUbc& C^U _V dXU `YSdebUc XU cX_gc dXU] Yc Q 7UjQ^^U _V dXYc fUbi]_e^dQY^$ Q `QY^dY^W ^_ _^U XQc UfUb cUU^ RUV_bU& GXU U^dUbc TUU`\i Y^d_dXU c`QSU _V dXU g_b[3 XUb ]UTYdQdY_^ c_ Y^dU^cU dXQd XYc g_bTc RQbU\ibUQSX XUb& lKXi T_^od i_e WUd i_eb SQ]UbQ$ <U\U^U4m XU Yc Qc[Y^W& lKXiT_ i_e XQfU _^U YV i_e ^UfUb ecU Yd4 KXi QbU i_e cdQ^TY^W Qb_e^T T_Y^W^_dXY^W4 M_e T_^od cUU] d_ bUQ\YjU gXQd Q^ _SSQcY_^ dXYc Yc& M_e cX_e\TRU `X_d_WbQ`XY^W dXU cdeTY_$ `X_d_WbQ`XY^W dXU `YSdebUc&m GXU bYcUc$cde^^UT$ d_ dXU cebVQSU _V XUb cY\U^d S_^SU^dbQdY_^&

GXU WUdc dXU SQ]UbQ Q^T Yd cUU]c d_ XUb dXQd gYdX UQSX lS\YS[ m Q [^YVU YcdXbecd Y^d_ dXU VbUUT_] _V XUb Uh`UbYU^SU _V dXU g_b[$ dXQd Qd UQSX c\Q` _VdXU cXeddUb c_]UdXY^W \YfU XQc Zecd TYUT& GeTTU^\i DYSQcc_ gXUU\c _^ XUb$U^bQWUT dXQd lgYdX_ed XYc `Ub]YccY_^ m cXU XQc `X_d_WbQ`XUT XYc FU^_Yb&<Yc L]fgaj cXU dXY^[c& GXU dUQbc dXU VY\] _ed _V dXU SQ]UbQ Q^T dXb_gc

Yd Y^ XYc VQSU& lB_ _^U dQ\[c d_ ]U \Y[U dXQd$ m cXU cQic&

=^ dXU gUU[c dXQd `Qcc >QSaeU\Y^U dbYUc d_ WUd XUb d_ bUdeb^$ d_ bU\U^d& lM_ecfgo X_g XU Yc m cXU [UU`c bU`UQdY^W& 5^T Yd Yc dbeU& <U\U^U [^_gc`UbVUSd\i gU\\ X_g XU Yc& KXYSX ]Q[Uc XUb _RcdY^Q^SU Q\\ dXU ]_bUY^dUbUcdY^W&

GXU [UU`c cQiY^W dXQd DYSQcc_ XQT ^_ bYWXd d_ fY_\QdU XUb cY\U^SU$ d_ Y^dUbbe`ddXU S_]`\UdU^Ucc _V XUb S_^^USdY_^ d_ dXU g_b[c$ d_ cSQddUb dXYc d_ dXUgY^Tc Qc dX_eWX Yd gUbU c_ ]eSX dbQcX& GXU S_eSXUc XUb S_]`\QY^dc d_>QSaeU\Y^U gYdXY^ dXU ]_bQ\Yc] _V Q TUVU^cU _V DQY^dY^W$ Q ]_TUb^YcdTUVU^cU&

6ed _V S_ebcU cXU [^_gc DYSQcc_ c_ gU\\3 XQT c_ _VdU^ cUU^ XY] S_^^YfY^W$]Q^Y`e\QdY^W$ S_^db_\\Y^W3 XQT XUbcU\V RUU^ Ydc fYSdY]& G_ Yd gQc ^_d XUgX_ XQT fY_\QdUT XUb cY\U^SU$ `b_f_[Y^W dXU UhdbU]Uc _V dXYc bUQSdY_^& =dXQT RUU^ dXU S\YS[ dXQd XQT db_eR\UT XUb$ Qc Yd SbUQdUT Ydc _g^ bXidX]gYdXY^ dXU Y]]_RY\Ydi _V dXU `YSd_bYQ\ Y]QWU&

K_e\T 8b& :bUeT XQfU XQT c_]UdXY^W d_ cQi QR_ed dXQd S\YS[oc S_^dU^dQck\Y[U dXU `ebU ci^dQh _V dXU `QccYfU f_YSUkYd S_e\T XQfU QSdUT d_c]eWW\U dXU RUQd _V Ub_c `Qcd dXU WQdUc _V bU`bUccY_^4

Ja[Ykkg( l`] GgjYdakl| [gmd\ Z] l`] kmZlald] g^ Ydegkl ]n]jq Zggc gfJa[Ykkg gn]j l`] hYkl ^a^lq q]Yjk( Zjaf_af_ gf] gn]j Yf\ gn]j Y_Yaf l`]

e]kkY_] g^ Yjl~k YkkmjYf[] YZgml ngdmflYjake( afl]flagfYdalq( Yf\ ^j]]\ge*>g]k Yfqgf] dakl]f lg Ja[Ykkg `aek]d^ Yk `] kh]Yck( af Ydd affg[]f[]( g^ l`]oYq `] ak hgkk]kk]\ Zq l`] TYc`_cYdYV `] `Yk [gfkljm[l]\: ;;[cfgod]\_af_l`Yl oal` l`] nYjaYlagfk gf l`] gd\ eYkl]jk UJa[YkkgV kqkl]eYlar]k l`]hjg[]kk7 l`] ogjc ak l`] ]fk]eZd] g^ l`] [YfnYk]k gf l`] kYe] l`]e] Yf\]Y[` gf] ak gfdq Y dafc g^ l`] o`gd]( Y kmkh]f\]\ ege]fl g^ [j]Ylagf(|gf] g^ l`] ojal]jk gf l`ak h`Yk] g^ `ak ogjc imgl]k `ae Yk kYqaf_ l`Ylo`Yl afl]j]klk `ae ak l`] egn]e]fl g^ hYaflaf_( l`] \jYeYla[ hmk` g^ gf]nakagf lg l`] f]pl( ]n]f a^ l`] hmk` ak fgl ^gj[]\ lg alk [gf[dmkagf* *** C`Yn] Yjjan]\ Yl l`] hgafl o`]j] l`] egn]e]fl g^ eq l`gm_`l afl]j]klk e]egj] l`Yf eq l`gm_`l alk]d^*| N`] hYkkanalq g^ l`ak afl]j]kl [ge]k gml afYfgl`]j j]eYjc o`]j] `] kYqk( C eYc] Y `mf\j]\ klm\a]k af k]n]jYd \Yqk(o`ad] Yfgl`]j hYafl]j ea_`l kh]f\ Y `mf\j]\ \Yqk gf Y kaf_d] ha[lmj]* Cf[gflafmaf_( C oadd gh]f oaf\gok* C oadd _]l Z]`af\ l`] [YfnYk Yf\ h]j`Yhkkge]l`af_ oadd `Yhh]f*| Km]dim] [`gk](| `] kYqk( k] hjg\majY* N`]oaf\go oadd gh]f Yf\ kge]l`af_ oadd `Yhh]f Z]^gj] l`] ]q]k g^ l`]hYafl]j o`g ak [Ym_`l l`]j]( ^Yk[afYl]\zdac] l`] Qgd^ GYf ^gj o`ge l`]oaf\go gh]fk gflg l`Yl Z]qgf\ o`]j] kge]l`af_ lYc]k hdY[]( Yk al \ak)hdYqk ^gj `ae l`] eYljap ^a_mj] g^ Y k[]f] af o`a[` `] oadd Z]( ^gj l`] j]klg^ `ak da^]( ]fljYhh]\*

JYZdg Ja[Ykkg(K`f[f^WV& -­0 ;;m_mkl -­52.*

lK_e\T^od Yd RU `bUddi d_ XQfU U^dYbU b__]c dY\UT \Y[U dXQd4m& & & "`& *+(#

Mc]l[` eY\] Zq l`] Qgd^ GYf( ^jge Ma_emf\ @j]m\(@jge l`] Baklgjq g^ Yf Cf^Yflad] H]mjgkak*|

l= gY\\ WUd RUXY^T dXU SQ^fQc Q^T `UbXQ`c c_]UdXY^W gY\\XQ``U^m& & & "`& *+.#

8[T^[aYdSbZ[US^ DafW

LgdYf\ <Yjl`]k~k YfYdqkak ak af N`] Qgjd\ g^ Qj]kldaf_(| l`] l]pl l`Yl gh]fk CkfZa^'aY[We& `ak ]kkYqk gf eYkk)[mdlmjYd h`]fge]fY Yk \]hgdala[ar]\ kh]][`( [gdd][l]\ Yk gf]ngdme] af -­513 $CkfZa^aY[We( ljYfk* ;;ff]ll] FYn]jk UH]o Sgjc6 Badd Yf\ QYf_( -­53.V%*

J`glg_jYh`k g^ l`] l]d]nakagf k]l af Ja[Ykkg~k danaf_ jgge Yl Hglj] >Ye] \] Pa] o]j]hmZdak`]\ af LgZ]jlg Il]jg~k <adWhWd F[USeea $H]o Sgjc6 ;;ZjYek( -­534%* N`] ^YegmkaeY_]k l`jgm_` o`a[` o] cfgo Ja[Ykkg af `ak nYjagmk eada]mp Yj] Zq >Yna\ >gmZdYk>mf[Yf $JZW Fd[hSfW Mad^V aX FST^a F[USeea UH]o Sgjc6 N`] La\_] Jj]kk( -­514V% Yf\?\oYj\ Kmaff $F[USeea ShWU F[USeea UJYjak6 Ja]jj] <gj\Yk( -­543V%*

B]d]f] JYje]daf( oal` `]j `mkZYf\( l`] hYafl]j ?\gmYj\ Ja_fgf( Z][Ye] ^ja]f\k g^Ja[Ykkg~k af l`] dYl] -­50,k Yf\ aflaeYl]k g^ Ja[Ykkg Yf\ DY[im]daf] Lg[im] \mjaf_ l`]lmjZmd]f[] g^ @jYfWgak] Aaddgl~k Zj]Yc oal` Ja[Ykkg* N`] l`j]])ngdme] ogjc ?`f[_SfWIWUdWfe aX S IfgV[a Sf DafdW :S_W VW L[W $H]o Sgjc6 ;;ZjYek( -­522%( F[USeea4 Ma_W`&CagY[`e S`V LSghW`SdYgWe $Fgf\gf6 Q]a\]f^]d\ Yf\ Ha[gdkgf( -­521%( Yf\ JZW 7df[efS`V >[e CaVW^ $H]o Sgjc6 ;;ZjYek( -­521%( Yj] l`] j][gj\ g^ B]d]f] JYje]daf~k Y[[]kklg Ja[Ykkg~k klm\agk( `]j j]^d][lagfk gf o`Yl k`] kYo l`]j]( Yf\ l`] [gfn]jkYlagfk l`Ylk`] ]al`]j `Y\ oal` Ja[Ykkg \aj][ldq gj gn]j`]Yj\ Z]lo]]f Ja[Ykkg Yf\ gl`]jk( eYafdqJa_fgf* N`] [gfn]jkYlagfk( kge]lae]k af \aj][l imglYlagf( kge]lae]k kmeeYjar]\ Zq`]j( o]j] kmZk]im]fldq ]pljY[l]\ ^jge l`]k] ngdme]k Yf\ [gfkgda\Yl]\ af l`] egj]eg\]kl Zggc( F[USeea ISke $Fgf\gf6 A]gj_] ;;dd]f Yf\ Ofoaf( -­525%*

LakSYW W` F[USeea $JYjak6 LgZ]jl FY^gfl( -­54,%( ojall]f Zq JYje]daf Yk Y egj] aflaeYl]hgjljYal g^ Ja[Ykkg( hYjla[mdYjdq \mjaf_ l`] lae] g^ `ak YhhjgY[`af_ \]Yl`( \]k[jaZ]k l`]afl]jagj g^ Hglj] >Ye] \] Pa]( af[dm\af_ l`] l]d]nakagf k]l l`Yl kYl Yl l`] ^ggl g^ Ja[Ykkg~kZ]\ \mjaf_ l`] dYkl q]Yjk $h* .,-­%* M`] Ydkg _an]k Yf Y[[gmfl g^ Ja[Ykkg~k hYkkagf ^gjoYl[`af_ oj]kldaf_zUSfUZ af @j]f[`( o`a[` Ja[Ykkg hjgfgmf[]\ USUZW $h* .,.%* Ja[Ykkg~k[gee]fl( N`]q Yj] jYfkY[caf_ >m[`Yeh~k oYj]`gmk] Yf\ [`Yf_af_ l`] hY[cY_af_(| ak^jge l`ak Zggc $h* 3-­%( Ydl`gm_` JYje]daf~k 7df Wf S`Sdf[e_W $JYjak6 =`jaklaYf <gmj_gak(-­525% ak Y hYeh`d]l)kar]\ ogjc [geeall]\ lg l`ak a\]Y( o`]j] k`] \]k[jaZ]k l`] GYqMYdgfk af JYjak $h* .1%( Naf_m]dq~k dmfYljY[c $h* 1.%( Yf\ l`] =gf[gmjk F]haf] g^ Yfla)Yjl| $h* 10%*

B]d]f]~k Y[[gmfl g^ `]j ]eglagfk Ydgf] af Ja[Ykkg~k klm\agk( Yk l`] e]Yfaf_ g^ Yjl akj]n]Yd]\ lg `]j( ak ^jge Ma_W` aX CagY[`e $h* 3%( Yk Yj] `]j \]k[jahlagfk g^ l`] kmfYf\ `]Yl Z]qgf\ l`] klm\ag $h* -­/%( l`] kmf hjgl][laf_ l`] klm\ag~k kad]f[] $h* .,%( l`]kgmf\ g^ l`] `a_`oYq af l`] \aklYf[] $h* .,%( Yf\ DY[im]daf]~k [Yddaf_ l`] [YfYd eqM]af]| $h* .,%* Ja[Ykkg~k [gee]fl YZgml l`] fqeh` Yf\ kYlqj lad]k ak ^jge JZW FS[`fWdS`V >[e CaVW^ $h* -­1/% Yf\ F[USeea ISke $h* 2-­%* N`] \ak[mkkagf g^ l`] jYha\alq g^ l`]]q] ak ^jge F[USeea ISke $h* 02%( Yk Yj] Ja[Ykkg~k klja[lmj]k Y_Yafkl hYaflaf_~k ljqaf_ lg\]ha[l egn]e]fl $h* /5%* Cf LakSYW W` F[USeea& JYje]daf l]ddk YZgml l`] af[a\]fl YlPYmn]fYj_m]k o`]f Ja[Ykkg [`Yj_]k `]j lg h`glg_jYh` ogjck af `ak [gdd][lagf $hh* /-­z/1%7 YZgml hjgb][laf_ kda\]k gf l`] klm\ag oYddk Yl fa_`l( hYjla[mdYjdq Jgmkkaf~k CSeeSUdWaX fZW ?``aUW`fe $h* 31%7 Yf\ gf[] Y_Yaf l`] ]^^][l gf `]j g^ l`] hmdkaf_ g^ l`] Ga\a `]YlYjgmf\ l`] `gmk]( [gmhd]\ oal` l`] qda`da` g^ l`] ljY^^a[(| Yk k`] lmjfk YoYq ^jge l`]ogjc af l`] klm\agk lg l`] ZjaddaYf[] gmlka\] $h* 33%*

GYp ?jfkl hmZdak`]\ 7 B[ff^W =[d^ :dWS_e aX JS][`Y fZW LW[^ af -­5/,* N`] aeY_] g^ l`]rggljgh] [ge]k ^jge BS DSfgdW $-­444%( h* -­.* N`] JjYpafgk[gh] Y hjgb][lagf| oYk

ha[lmj]\ af BS DSfgdW $-­44.%( h* /137 l`] Jjgb][lagfk kl]j]gk[ghaim]k| af $-­45-­%( h* 057l`] `Yf\k k]jnaf_ Yk l`] ZYkak ^gj l`] [gn]j g^ HWbWf[f[a`e ak ^jge $-­443%( h* -­007 ^gjEWV[bge HWj $-­45-­%( h* .3.7 ^gj 7f fZW <[def 9^WSd MadV $-­44-­%( h* 140* @gj l`] M[`j]Z]j\aY_jYek l`Yl Yhh]Yj af BWe _S^ZWgde VWe [__adfW^e& k]] >ag F]oak( JZW DWi =k_`Se'f[Ue& i[fZ S fdS`e^Sf[a` aX FdaXWeead IUZdWTWdte FS`Yk_`Sef[]a` $<gklgf6 Na[cfgj Yf\@a]d\k( -­42.%*

Gq \ak[mkkagf g^ Bmkk]jd~k hmf[lmYd ege]fl $[_ eW^TW` 7gYW`T^[U]% ^gddgok l`Yl g^DY[im]k >]jja\Y( af IbWWUZ S`V FZW`a_W`S& ljYfk* >Yna\ <* ;;ddakgf $?nYfklgf6 Hgjl`)o]kl]jf Ofan]jkalq Jj]kk( -­53/%( hh* 2,)25*

FqglYj\~k ]pljYgj\afYjq YfYdqkak g^ l`] eYljap ^a_mj]( mkaf_ ;; =`ad\ Ck <]af_ <]Yl]f|Yk alk ]pYehd]( ak ^jge l`] k][lagf @ak[gmjk >a_mj](| af :[eUagde& <[YgdW $JYjak6 Edaf[c)ka][c( -­53-­%( hh* /.3)/106 l`] \ak[mkkagf g^ l`] hYkkan] nga[] $h* /0/%7 l`] [gehYjakgfoal` l`] kljm[lmjYdakl~k kljm[lmj] $h* //5%7 Zdg[caf_ lg_]l`]j g^ dg_a[Yddq af[gehYlaZd]k]fl]f[]k $hh* //4)//5%7 l`] eYljap ^a_mj] Yk ZY\ ^gje| $hh* /05)/1,%7 l`] j]dYlagflg l`] \]Yl` \jan] $hh* /1,)/1/%* @gj `ak \ak[mkkagf g^ =]rYff]~k hYkkanalq( k]] h* .-­*@gj ;; =`ad\ Ck <]af_ <]Yl]f| $-­5-­5%( k]] Ma_emf\ @j]m\( IfS`VSdV ;;V[f[a`& ngd* -­3(hh* -­33).,0*

>gm_dYk =ggh]j~k Y[[gmfl g^ l`] mf^gd\af_ g^ ogjc gf l`] :W\Wg`Wd egd LZWdTW nYjaYlagfkak af =ggh]j( FST^a F[USeea4 BWe :W\Wg`Wde $H]o Sgjc6 BYjjq H* ;;ZjYek( -­52/%( o`]j]`] \]k[jaZ]k `go l`] \jYoaf_k hjg[]]\ $h* -­5%( [gee]flk gf Ja[Ykkg~k ]k[Yh] ^jge l`]af^dm]f[] g^ l`] gd\]j ogjc $h* ./%( Yf\ j]hjg\m[]k em[` g^ l`] ogjc( geallaf_( `go]n]j(l`] kc]l[`Zggc ^jge ;;m_mkl .* N`ak dYll]j gZb][l ak [YlYdg_m]\ Yk fg* -­21 af @W eg[e ^WUSZ[Wd4 JZW I]WfUZTaa]e aX FST^a F[USeea& ]\* ;;jfgd\ Adae[`]j Yf\ GYj[ Adae[`]j$<gklgf6 ;;ldYfla[ Ggfl`dq Jj]kk( -­542%( o`]j] log aeY_]k ^jge l`ak k]im]f[] Yj]addmkljYl]\* N`] aehgjlYf[] g^ l`] ^]eYd] `]Y\ Yf\ Zj]Yklk eYhh]\ gflg l`] eYd] _]falYdkak Zjgm_`l gml Zq LgZ]jl Lgk]fZdme af Ja[Ykkg Yf\ l`] ;;fYlgeq g^ ?jgla[ake(| afIfgV[We [` ;;daf[U 7df& ]\* N`]g\gj] <goa] Yf\ =gjf]daY P* =`jakl]fkgf $H]o Sgjc6<Yka[ <ggck( -­53,%( k]] ^a_mj] -­54*

GYja])FYmj] <]jfY\Y[ $Ja[Ykkg( -­51/)-­53/6 FY h]aflmj] [gee] eg\]d](| BW VWd`[WdF[USeea UJYjak6 Gmk]] HYlagfYd \~;;jl Gg\]jf]( -­544V( h*05%( imgl]k Ja[Ykkg Yk kYqaf_(N`] egn]e]fl g^ eq l`gm_`l afl]j]klk e] egj] l`Yf eq l`gm_`l alk]d^|7 >gm_dYk=ggh]j $BWe :W\Wg`Wde& h* //% imgl]k Ja[Ykkg( Ydl`gm_` lg kmhhgjl Y o`gddq \a^^]j]flYj_me]fl( Yk kYqaf_( C oadd _]l Z]`af\ l`] [YfnYk Yf\ h]j`Yhk kge]l`af_ oadd `Yhh]f*|