the hypoelliptic dirac operator

190
The flat case The hypoelliptic Dirac operator B Y Analytic properties of B 2 Y B 2 Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X The hypoelliptic Quillen metric The hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’ The hypoelliptic Dirac operator Jean-Michel Bismut Universit´ e Paris-Sud, Orsay 11th May 2009 Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Upload: others

Post on 03-Feb-2022

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Jean-Michel Bismut

Universite Paris-Sud, Orsay

11th May 2009

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 2: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 3: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 4: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 5: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 6: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 7: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Develop the philosophy behind the hypoellipticLaplacian.

Construct a hypoelliptic deformation of the classical

Dirac operator DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

DX acts on X, its deformation acts on X total spaceof TX.

Like its de Rham counterpart, this deformationinterpolates between classical Hodge theory and thegeodesic flow.

Construction of hypoelliptic Quillen metric, andcomparison with elliptic case.

Connection with ‘physics’.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 8: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

1 The flat case

2 The hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

3 Analytic properties of B2Y

4 B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

5 The hypoelliptic Quillen metric

6 The hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 9: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

4 identities

1 + 1 = 2.

(a+ b)2 = a2 + 2ab+ b2.∫Re−y

2/2 dy√2π

= 1.∫Re−iyξ−y

2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 10: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

4 identities

1 + 1 = 2.

(a+ b)2 = a2 + 2ab+ b2.∫Re−y

2/2 dy√2π

= 1.∫Re−iyξ−y

2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 11: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

4 identities

1 + 1 = 2.

(a+ b)2 = a2 + 2ab+ b2.

∫Re−y

2/2 dy√2π

= 1.∫Re−iyξ−y

2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 12: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

4 identities

1 + 1 = 2.

(a+ b)2 = a2 + 2ab+ b2.∫Re−y

2/2 dy√2π

= 1.

∫Re−iyξ−y

2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 13: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

4 identities

1 + 1 = 2.

(a+ b)2 = a2 + 2ab+ b2.∫Re−y

2/2 dy√2π

= 1.∫Re−iyξ−y

2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 14: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 15: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 16: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 17: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 18: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 19: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A proof of the last identity

∫R

e−iyξ−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2

∫R

e−(y+iξ)2/2 dy√2π

= e−ξ2/2

∫R

e−y2/2 dy√

2π= e−ξ

2/2.

In the last identity, we made the complex translationy → y − iξ while using analyticity of e−y

2/2.

Fourier + analyticity.

For the hypoelliptic Laplacian, we will use the above ina geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 20: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The harmonic oscillator

H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

.

H self-adjoint, Sp (H) = N.

Ground state =e−y2/2 and eigenfunctions the weighted

Hermite polynomials (=e−y2/2× polynomials).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 21: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The harmonic oscillator

H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

.

H self-adjoint, Sp (H) = N.

Ground state =e−y2/2 and eigenfunctions the weighted

Hermite polynomials (=e−y2/2× polynomials).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 22: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The harmonic oscillator

H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

.

H self-adjoint, Sp (H) = N.

Ground state =e−y2/2 and eigenfunctions the weighted

Hermite polynomials (=e−y2/2× polynomials).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 23: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The harmonic oscillator

H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

.

H self-adjoint, Sp (H) = N.

Ground state =e−y2/2 and eigenfunctions the weighted

Hermite polynomials (=e−y2/2× polynomials).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 24: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 25: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.

Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 26: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 27: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 28: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 29: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 30: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator of Kolmogorov

Operator in 2 = 1 + 1 variables x, y.Kolmogorov operator L = H + y ∂

∂x.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+ y ∂∂x

.

L = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 +(y + ∂

∂x

)2 − 1)− 1

2∂2

∂x2 .

If ∂∂x→ iξ,

L =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ (y + iξ)2 − 1

)+

1

2ξ2.

If y → y − iξ, L becomes L given by

L = H +1

2ξ2.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 31: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A conjugation of L

M = ∂2

∂x∂yhyperbolic.

Conjugation identity

e−MLeM =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ y2 − 1

)− 1

2

∂2

∂x2.

L hypoelliptic (Hormander).

e−MLeM elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 32: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A conjugation of L

M = ∂2

∂x∂yhyperbolic.

Conjugation identity

e−MLeM =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ y2 − 1

)− 1

2

∂2

∂x2.

L hypoelliptic (Hormander).

e−MLeM elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 33: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A conjugation of L

M = ∂2

∂x∂yhyperbolic.

Conjugation identity

e−MLeM =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ y2 − 1

)− 1

2

∂2

∂x2.

L hypoelliptic (Hormander).

e−MLeM elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 34: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A conjugation of L

M = ∂2

∂x∂yhyperbolic.

Conjugation identity

e−MLeM =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ y2 − 1

)− 1

2

∂2

∂x2.

L hypoelliptic (Hormander).

e−MLeM elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 35: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A conjugation of L

M = ∂2

∂x∂yhyperbolic.

Conjugation identity

e−MLeM =1

2

(− ∂2

∂y2+ y2 − 1

)− 1

2

∂2

∂x2.

L hypoelliptic (Hormander).

e−MLeM elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 36: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Hypoellipticity

∂∂t− L hypoelliptic (existence of heat kernel).

Heisenberg commutation[∂∂y, y]

= 1 . . .

. . . implies hypoellipticity by Hormander[∂

∂y, y

∂x

]=

∂x.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 37: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Hypoellipticity

∂∂t− L hypoelliptic (existence of heat kernel).

Heisenberg commutation[∂∂y, y]

= 1 . . .

. . . implies hypoellipticity by Hormander[∂

∂y, y

∂x

]=

∂x.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 38: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Hypoellipticity

∂∂t− L hypoelliptic (existence of heat kernel).

Heisenberg commutation[∂∂y, y]

= 1 . . .

. . . implies hypoellipticity by Hormander[∂

∂y, y

∂x

]=

∂x.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 39: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Hypoellipticity

∂∂t− L hypoelliptic (existence of heat kernel).

Heisenberg commutation[∂∂y, y]

= 1 . . .

. . . implies hypoellipticity by Hormander[∂

∂y, y

∂x

]=

∂x.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 40: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Conjugation is legitimate

Here (x, y) ∈ S1 ×R.

By analyticity, y → y − iξ acts on the weightedHermite polynomials.

Hypoelliptic non self-adjoint L is isospectral to ellipticself-adjoint e−MLeM .

Sp (L) = N + 2k2π2, k ∈ Z.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 41: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Conjugation is legitimate

Here (x, y) ∈ S1 ×R.

By analyticity, y → y − iξ acts on the weightedHermite polynomials.

Hypoelliptic non self-adjoint L is isospectral to ellipticself-adjoint e−MLeM .

Sp (L) = N + 2k2π2, k ∈ Z.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 42: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Conjugation is legitimate

Here (x, y) ∈ S1 ×R.

By analyticity, y → y − iξ acts on the weightedHermite polynomials.

Hypoelliptic non self-adjoint L is isospectral to ellipticself-adjoint e−MLeM .

Sp (L) = N + 2k2π2, k ∈ Z.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 43: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Conjugation is legitimate

Here (x, y) ∈ S1 ×R.

By analyticity, y → y − iξ acts on the weightedHermite polynomials.

Hypoelliptic non self-adjoint L is isospectral to ellipticself-adjoint e−MLeM .

Sp (L) = N + 2k2π2, k ∈ Z.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 44: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Conjugation is legitimate

Here (x, y) ∈ S1 ×R.

By analyticity, y → y − iξ acts on the weightedHermite polynomials.

Hypoelliptic non self-adjoint L is isospectral to ellipticself-adjoint e−MLeM .

Sp (L) = N + 2k2π2, k ∈ Z.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 45: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 46: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 47: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.

b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 48: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 49: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 50: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The deformation parameter

b > 0, and Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.b→ 0, the resolvent of Lb concentrates on ground state

exp (−y2/2) so that we recover Sp(−1

2∂2

∂x2

).

b→ +∞, after conjugation, Lb ' y2

2+ y ∂

∂x.

y ∂∂x

generator of geodesic flow.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 51: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 52: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 53: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 54: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.

Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 55: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].

Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 56: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Supersymmetry

Witten Laplacian H = 12

(− ∂2

∂y2 + y2 − 1)

+NΛ·(R).

Lb = Hb2

+ 1by ∂∂x

is still hypoelliptic.

Sp (Lb) = Nb2

+ 2π2k2, k ∈ Z.Tr [exp (t∂2/∂x2/2)] = Trs [exp (−tLb)].Proof of Poisson formula by interpolation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 57: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 58: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 59: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 60: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 61: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 62: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Geometrisation of the construction

X Riemannian manifold, X total space of TX.

H → harmonic oscillator H along the fibres of X .

y ∂∂x→ generator of geodesic flow ∇Y .

− ∂2

∂x2 → X Laplacian of X.

Can H +∇Y become a deformed ‘Laplacian’ for anexotic Hodge theory?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 63: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 64: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Dolbeault complex

(X, gTX) compact complex Kahler manifold.

(E, gE) holomorphic Hermitian vector bundle on X.(Ω(0,·) (X,E) , ∂

X)

Dolbeault complex with

cohomology H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 65: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Dolbeault complex

(X, gTX) compact complex Kahler manifold.

(E, gE) holomorphic Hermitian vector bundle on X.(Ω(0,·) (X,E) , ∂

X)

Dolbeault complex with

cohomology H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 66: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Dolbeault complex

(X, gTX) compact complex Kahler manifold.

(E, gE) holomorphic Hermitian vector bundle on X.

(Ω(0,·) (X,E) , ∂

X)

Dolbeault complex with

cohomology H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 67: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Dolbeault complex

(X, gTX) compact complex Kahler manifold.

(E, gE) holomorphic Hermitian vector bundle on X.(Ω(0,·) (X,E) , ∂

X)

Dolbeault complex with

cohomology H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 68: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 69: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 70: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 71: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 72: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 73: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 74: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 75: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic deformation

X total space of tangent bundle, with fibre TX.

Deformation acts on Ω(0,·) (X , π∗ (Λ· (T ∗X)⊗ E)).

Y generator of the geodesic flow, Cartan formula[dX , iY

]= LY .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 76: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic deformation

X total space of tangent bundle, with fibre TX.

Deformation acts on Ω(0,·) (X , π∗ (Λ· (T ∗X)⊗ E)).

Y generator of the geodesic flow, Cartan formula[dX , iY

]= LY .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 77: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic deformation

X total space of tangent bundle, with fibre TX.

Deformation acts on Ω(0,·) (X , π∗ (Λ· (T ∗X)⊗ E)).

Y generator of the geodesic flow, Cartan formula[dX , iY

]= LY .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 78: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic deformation

X total space of tangent bundle, with fibre TX.

Deformation acts on Ω(0,·) (X , π∗ (Λ· (T ∗X)⊗ E)).

Y generator of the geodesic flow, Cartan formula[dX , iY

]= LY .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 79: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 80: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 81: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 82: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 83: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 84: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ∂ operator on X

gdTX Hermitian metric on TX, ∇dTX associated

connection.

∂X∂ operator on X .

∂X

= ∇I′′ + ∂V

.

∇I′′ horizontal ∂ for ∇dTX , ∂V

vertical ∂.

A′′ = ∂X

is a antiholomorphic superconnection suchthat A′′2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 85: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 86: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 87: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 88: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 89: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 90: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The ‘adjoint’ A′ of A′′

A′ = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗, A = A′′ + A′.

Principal symbol of the superconnection Aσ (A) = iξH ∧+ic

(ξV).

σ (A) is nilpotent horizontally, and elliptic vertically.

A2 is a second order elliptic differential operator actingfibrewise along TX.

A2 = −12∆V + . . .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 91: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 92: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 93: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 94: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 95: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 96: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 97: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Koszul resolution

y ∈ TX canonical holomorphic section of TX.

TX ' TX.

Interior multiplication iy acts on π∗Λ· (T ∗X).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 98: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Koszul resolution

y ∈ TX canonical holomorphic section of TX.

TX ' TX.

Interior multiplication iy acts on π∗Λ· (T ∗X).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 99: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Koszul resolution

y ∈ TX canonical holomorphic section of TX.

TX ' TX.

Interior multiplication iy acts on π∗Λ· (T ∗X).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 100: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Koszul resolution

y ∈ TX canonical holomorphic section of TX.

TX ' TX.

Interior multiplication iy acts on π∗Λ· (T ∗X).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 101: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Dolbeault-Koszul operator

A′′Y = ∂X

+ iy.

A′′2Y = 0.

A′′Y = ∇I′′ + ∂V

+ iy.

A′′Y is not a superconnection.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 102: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Dolbeault-Koszul operator

A′′Y = ∂X

+ iy.

A′′2Y = 0.

A′′Y = ∇I′′ + ∂V

+ iy.

A′′Y is not a superconnection.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 103: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Dolbeault-Koszul operator

A′′Y = ∂X

+ iy.

A′′2Y = 0.

A′′Y = ∇I′′ + ∂V

+ iy.

A′′Y is not a superconnection.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 104: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Dolbeault-Koszul operator

A′′Y = ∂X

+ iy.

A′′2Y = 0.

A′′Y = ∇I′′ + ∂V

+ iy.

A′′Y is not a superconnection.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 105: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Dolbeault-Koszul operator

A′′Y = ∂X

+ iy.

A′′2Y = 0.

A′′Y = ∇I′′ + ∂V

+ iy.

A′′Y is not a superconnection.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 106: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A′Y

A′Y = A′ + iy.

A′Y = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗

+ iy.

A′2Y = 0.

AY = A′′Y + A′Y not good enough.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 107: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A′Y

A′Y = A′ + iy.

A′Y = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗

+ iy.

A′2Y = 0.

AY = A′′Y + A′Y not good enough.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 108: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A′Y

A′Y = A′ + iy.

A′Y = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗

+ iy.

A′2Y = 0.

AY = A′′Y + A′Y not good enough.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 109: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A′Y

A′Y = A′ + iy.

A′Y = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗

+ iy.

A′2Y = 0.

AY = A′′Y + A′Y not good enough.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 110: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A′Y

A′Y = A′ + iy.

A′Y = ∇I′ + ∂V ∗

+ iy.

A′2Y = 0.

AY = A′′Y + A′Y not good enough.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 111: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 112: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 113: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 114: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 115: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 116: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY

gTX = gdTX Kahler metric on TX, with Kahler form

ωX .

B′′Y = A′′Y .

B′Y = eiωXA′Y e

−iωX.

BY = B′′Y +B′Y .

BY = ∇I + ∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 117: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The principal symbol of BY

Principal symbol of BY given by

σ (BY ) = iξH ∧+ic (ξV ) .

The horizontal part of σ (BY ) is nilpotent.

BY not elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 118: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The principal symbol of BY

Principal symbol of BY given by

σ (BY ) = iξH ∧+ic (ξV ) .

The horizontal part of σ (BY ) is nilpotent.

BY not elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 119: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The principal symbol of BY

Principal symbol of BY given by

σ (BY ) = iξH ∧+ic (ξV ) .

The horizontal part of σ (BY ) is nilpotent.

BY not elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 120: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The principal symbol of BY

Principal symbol of BY given by

σ (BY ) = iξH ∧+ic (ξV ) .

The horizontal part of σ (BY ) is nilpotent.

BY not elliptic.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 121: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A formula for B2Y

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] given by

B2Y =

1

2

(−∆V + |Y |2 + c (ei) c (ei)

)+∇Y −∇RTXY

+1

4

⟨RTXei, ej

⟩c (ei) c (ej)

+1

2Tr[RTX

]+RE.

∇Y horizontal covariant differential in direction Y .∂∂t−B2

Y is hypoelliptic (Kolmogorov, Hormander).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 122: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A formula for B2Y

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] given by

B2Y =

1

2

(−∆V + |Y |2 + c (ei) c (ei)

)+∇Y −∇RTXY

+1

4

⟨RTXei, ej

⟩c (ei) c (ej)

+1

2Tr[RTX

]+RE.

∇Y horizontal covariant differential in direction Y .∂∂t−B2

Y is hypoelliptic (Kolmogorov, Hormander).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 123: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A formula for B2Y

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] given by

B2Y =

1

2

(−∆V + |Y |2 + c (ei) c (ei)

)+∇Y −∇RTXY

+1

4

⟨RTXei, ej

⟩c (ei) c (ej)

+1

2Tr[RTX

]+RE.

∇Y horizontal covariant differential in direction Y .∂∂t−B2

Y is hypoelliptic (Kolmogorov, Hormander).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 124: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A formula for B2Y

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] given by

B2Y =

1

2

(−∆V + |Y |2 + c (ei) c (ei)

)+∇Y −∇RTXY

+1

4

⟨RTXei, ej

⟩c (ei) c (ej)

+1

2Tr[RTX

]+RE.

∇Y horizontal covariant differential in direction Y .

∂∂t−B2

Y is hypoelliptic (Kolmogorov, Hormander).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 125: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A formula for B2Y

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] given by

B2Y =

1

2

(−∆V + |Y |2 + c (ei) c (ei)

)+∇Y −∇RTXY

+1

4

⟨RTXei, ej

⟩c (ei) c (ej)

+1

2Tr[RTX

]+RE.

∇Y horizontal covariant differential in direction Y .∂∂t−B2

Y is hypoelliptic (Kolmogorov, Hormander).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 126: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator B2Y

B2Y essentially the sum of a harmonic oscillator along

TX and of ∇Y .

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] is called a hypoelliptic Laplacian.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 127: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator B2Y

B2Y essentially the sum of a harmonic oscillator along

TX and of ∇Y .

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] is called a hypoelliptic Laplacian.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 128: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator B2Y

B2Y essentially the sum of a harmonic oscillator along

TX and of ∇Y .

B2Y = [B′′Y , B

′Y ] is called a hypoelliptic Laplacian.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 129: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY is ‘self-adjoint’

B′Y is not the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to aHermitian product.

B′Y is the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to a Hermitianform η.

r : (x, y)→ (x,−y).

η (s, s′) =⟨r∗eiΛs, eiΛs′

⟩L2 .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 130: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY is ‘self-adjoint’

B′Y is not the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to aHermitian product.

B′Y is the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to a Hermitianform η.

r : (x, y)→ (x,−y).

η (s, s′) =⟨r∗eiΛs, eiΛs′

⟩L2 .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 131: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY is ‘self-adjoint’

B′Y is not the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to aHermitian product.

B′Y is the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to a Hermitianform η.

r : (x, y)→ (x,−y).

η (s, s′) =⟨r∗eiΛs, eiΛs′

⟩L2 .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 132: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY is ‘self-adjoint’

B′Y is not the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to aHermitian product.

B′Y is the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to a Hermitianform η.

r : (x, y)→ (x,−y).

η (s, s′) =⟨r∗eiΛs, eiΛs′

⟩L2 .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 133: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator BY is ‘self-adjoint’

B′Y is not the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to aHermitian product.

B′Y is the adjoint of B′′Y with respect to a Hermitianform η.

r : (x, y)→ (x,−y).

η (s, s′) =⟨r∗eiΛs, eiΛs′

⟩L2 .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 134: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 135: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 136: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 137: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 138: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 139: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The analysis of the hypoelliptic Laplacian (-,G.

Lebeau)

The operator B2Y has a discrete spectrum, which is

conjugation invariant.

The Hodge theorem almost holds.

Heat kernel is smoothing and trace class.

Heat kernel has a local index theory.

As t→ 0, ‘local supertrace’ converges toTd(TX, gTX

)ch(E, gE

).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 140: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Replacing y by y/b2

Replace y by y/b2.

BY,b ' ∇I + 1b

(∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧)

.

After conjugation,

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

H the horizontal part of BY,b.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 141: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Replacing y by y/b2

Replace y by y/b2.

BY,b ' ∇I + 1b

(∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧)

.

After conjugation,

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

H the horizontal part of BY,b.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 142: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Replacing y by y/b2

Replace y by y/b2.

BY,b ' ∇I + 1b

(∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧)

.

After conjugation,

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

H the horizontal part of BY,b.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 143: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Replacing y by y/b2

Replace y by y/b2.

BY,b ' ∇I + 1b

(∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧)

.

After conjugation,

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

H the horizontal part of BY,b.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 144: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Replacing y by y/b2

Replace y by y/b2.

BY,b ' ∇I + 1b

(∂V

+ ∂V ∗

+ iy+y + y∗∧)

.

After conjugation,

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

H the horizontal part of BY,b.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 145: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The kernel of the vertical part

The vertical part is ∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧.

Fibrewise kernel 1-dimensional, in ‘degree’ 0, spannedby β = exp

(− |Y |2 /2 + iω

).

Here ω = −iwi ∧ wi.P fibrewise orthogonal projection on kernel.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 146: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The kernel of the vertical part

The vertical part is ∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧.

Fibrewise kernel 1-dimensional, in ‘degree’ 0, spannedby β = exp

(− |Y |2 /2 + iω

).

Here ω = −iwi ∧ wi.P fibrewise orthogonal projection on kernel.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 147: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The kernel of the vertical part

The vertical part is ∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧.

Fibrewise kernel 1-dimensional, in ‘degree’ 0, spannedby β = exp

(− |Y |2 /2 + iω

).

Here ω = −iwi ∧ wi.P fibrewise orthogonal projection on kernel.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 148: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The kernel of the vertical part

The vertical part is ∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧.

Fibrewise kernel 1-dimensional, in ‘degree’ 0, spannedby β = exp

(− |Y |2 /2 + iω

).

Here ω = −iwi ∧ wi.

P fibrewise orthogonal projection on kernel.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 149: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The kernel of the vertical part

The vertical part is ∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧.

Fibrewise kernel 1-dimensional, in ‘degree’ 0, spannedby β = exp

(− |Y |2 /2 + iω

).

Here ω = −iwi ∧ wi.P fibrewise orthogonal projection on kernel.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 150: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The compression of the horizontal part

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

Fundamental identity of operators on Ω(0,·) (X,E),

PHP = ∂X

+ ∂X∗.

H =(wi∧+ iwi

)∇wi

+ (wi ∧ −iwi)∇wi

.

Kahler identities for H = ∂ − ∂∗ + ∂ + ∂∗

give H2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 151: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The compression of the horizontal part

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

Fundamental identity of operators on Ω(0,·) (X,E),

PHP = ∂X

+ ∂X∗.

H =(wi∧+ iwi

)∇wi

+ (wi ∧ −iwi)∇wi

.

Kahler identities for H = ∂ − ∂∗ + ∂ + ∂∗

give H2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 152: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The compression of the horizontal part

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

Fundamental identity of operators on Ω(0,·) (X,E),

PHP = ∂X

+ ∂X∗.

H =(wi∧+ iwi

)∇wi

+ (wi ∧ −iwi)∇wi

.

Kahler identities for H = ∂ − ∂∗ + ∂ + ∂∗

give H2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 153: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The compression of the horizontal part

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

Fundamental identity of operators on Ω(0,·) (X,E),

PHP = ∂X

+ ∂X∗.

H =(wi∧+ iwi

)∇wi

+ (wi ∧ −iwi)∇wi

.

Kahler identities for H = ∂ − ∂∗ + ∂ + ∂∗

give H2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 154: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The compression of the horizontal part

BY,b = H +1

b

(∂V

+ iy + ∂V ∗

+ y∗∧).

Fundamental identity of operators on Ω(0,·) (X,E),

PHP = ∂X

+ ∂X∗.

H =(wi∧+ iwi

)∇wi

+ (wi ∧ −iwi)∇wi

.

Kahler identities for H = ∂ − ∂∗ + ∂ + ∂∗

give H2 = 0.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 155: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 156: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 157: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 158: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 159: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 160: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Convergence of B2Y,b to X (-, Lebeau)

DX,2 = X =[∂X, ∂

X∗].

In every possible sense, as b→ 0, B2Y,b → X .

For t > 0, exp(−tB2

Y,b

)→ P exp

(−tX

)P .

Note that 1b∇Y ultimately produces X .

Illustration of 1 + 1 = 2 ( ∂∂x→ ∂2

∂x2 , Ito calculus).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 161: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The limit b→ +∞

As b→ +∞, after rescaling,

B2Y,b '

1

2|Y |2 +∇Y .

∇Y vector field generating the geodesic flow.

The corresponding traces localize on closed geodesics.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 162: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The limit b→ +∞

As b→ +∞, after rescaling,

B2Y,b '

1

2|Y |2 +∇Y .

∇Y vector field generating the geodesic flow.

The corresponding traces localize on closed geodesics.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 163: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The limit b→ +∞

As b→ +∞, after rescaling,

B2Y,b '

1

2|Y |2 +∇Y .

∇Y vector field generating the geodesic flow.

The corresponding traces localize on closed geodesics.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 164: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The limit b→ +∞

As b→ +∞, after rescaling,

B2Y,b '

1

2|Y |2 +∇Y .

∇Y vector field generating the geodesic flow.

The corresponding traces localize on closed geodesics.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 165: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The zeta function

Fix b = 1.

Set λ = detH(0,·) (X,E).

Operator B2Y has zeta function.

By ‘self-adjointness’, there is a ‘hypoelliptic Quillenmetric’ ‖ ‖λ,h on λ, with sign ±1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 166: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The zeta function

Fix b = 1.

Set λ = detH(0,·) (X,E).

Operator B2Y has zeta function.

By ‘self-adjointness’, there is a ‘hypoelliptic Quillenmetric’ ‖ ‖λ,h on λ, with sign ±1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 167: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The zeta function

Fix b = 1.

Set λ = detH(0,·) (X,E).

Operator B2Y has zeta function.

By ‘self-adjointness’, there is a ‘hypoelliptic Quillenmetric’ ‖ ‖λ,h on λ, with sign ±1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 168: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The zeta function

Fix b = 1.

Set λ = detH(0,·) (X,E).

Operator B2Y has zeta function.

By ‘self-adjointness’, there is a ‘hypoelliptic Quillenmetric’ ‖ ‖λ,h on λ, with sign ±1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 169: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The zeta function

Fix b = 1.

Set λ = detH(0,·) (X,E).

Operator B2Y has zeta function.

By ‘self-adjointness’, there is a ‘hypoelliptic Quillenmetric’ ‖ ‖λ,h on λ, with sign ±1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 170: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A comparison formula

‖ ‖λ usual ‘elliptic’ Quillen metric.

Gillet-Soule additive R genus,

R (x) =∑n oddn≥1

(2ζ ′ (−n) +

n∑j=1

1

jζ (−n)

)xn

n!.

Comparison formula

log

(‖ ‖2

λ,h

‖ ‖2λ

)=

∫X

Td (TX)R (TX) ch (E) .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 171: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A comparison formula

‖ ‖λ usual ‘elliptic’ Quillen metric.

Gillet-Soule additive R genus,

R (x) =∑n oddn≥1

(2ζ ′ (−n) +

n∑j=1

1

jζ (−n)

)xn

n!.

Comparison formula

log

(‖ ‖2

λ,h

‖ ‖2λ

)=

∫X

Td (TX)R (TX) ch (E) .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 172: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A comparison formula

‖ ‖λ usual ‘elliptic’ Quillen metric.

Gillet-Soule additive R genus,

R (x) =∑n oddn≥1

(2ζ ′ (−n) +

n∑j=1

1

jζ (−n)

)xn

n!.

Comparison formula

log

(‖ ‖2

λ,h

‖ ‖2λ

)=

∫X

Td (TX)R (TX) ch (E) .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 173: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

A comparison formula

‖ ‖λ usual ‘elliptic’ Quillen metric.

Gillet-Soule additive R genus,

R (x) =∑n oddn≥1

(2ζ ′ (−n) +

n∑j=1

1

jζ (−n)

)xn

n!.

Comparison formula

log

(‖ ‖2

λ,h

‖ ‖2λ

)=

∫X

Td (TX)R (TX) ch (E) .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 174: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Brownian motion and geodesics

Brownian motion x = w observed at microscopic level.

Its calculus, the Ito calculus, is of order 2 = 1 + 1.

Geodesics x = 0 (Hamiltonian dynamics) observed atmacroscopic level.

The number of dots is also 2 = 1 + 1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 175: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Brownian motion and geodesics

Brownian motion x = w observed at microscopic level.

Its calculus, the Ito calculus, is of order 2 = 1 + 1.

Geodesics x = 0 (Hamiltonian dynamics) observed atmacroscopic level.

The number of dots is also 2 = 1 + 1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 176: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Brownian motion and geodesics

Brownian motion x = w observed at microscopic level.

Its calculus, the Ito calculus, is of order 2 = 1 + 1.

Geodesics x = 0 (Hamiltonian dynamics) observed atmacroscopic level.

The number of dots is also 2 = 1 + 1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 177: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Brownian motion and geodesics

Brownian motion x = w observed at microscopic level.

Its calculus, the Ito calculus, is of order 2 = 1 + 1.

Geodesics x = 0 (Hamiltonian dynamics) observed atmacroscopic level.

The number of dots is also 2 = 1 + 1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 178: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Brownian motion and geodesics

Brownian motion x = w observed at microscopic level.

Its calculus, the Ito calculus, is of order 2 = 1 + 1.

Geodesics x = 0 (Hamiltonian dynamics) observed atmacroscopic level.

The number of dots is also 2 = 1 + 1.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 179: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Langevin equation

Langevin tried to reconcile Newton’s law withBrownian motion (infinite energy).

Langevin equation mx = −x+ w in R4.

For m = 0, x = w, for m = +∞, x = 0.

If we make m = b2, the hypoelliptic Laplacian (withy = x) describes the dynamics of the Langevinequation in a geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 180: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Langevin equation

Langevin tried to reconcile Newton’s law withBrownian motion (infinite energy).

Langevin equation mx = −x+ w in R4.

For m = 0, x = w, for m = +∞, x = 0.

If we make m = b2, the hypoelliptic Laplacian (withy = x) describes the dynamics of the Langevinequation in a geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 181: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Langevin equation

Langevin tried to reconcile Newton’s law withBrownian motion (infinite energy).

Langevin equation mx = −x+ w in R4.

For m = 0, x = w, for m = +∞, x = 0.

If we make m = b2, the hypoelliptic Laplacian (withy = x) describes the dynamics of the Langevinequation in a geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 182: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Langevin equation

Langevin tried to reconcile Newton’s law withBrownian motion (infinite energy).

Langevin equation mx = −x+ w in R4.

For m = 0, x = w, for m = +∞, x = 0.

If we make m = b2, the hypoelliptic Laplacian (withy = x) describes the dynamics of the Langevinequation in a geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 183: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The Langevin equation

Langevin tried to reconcile Newton’s law withBrownian motion (infinite energy).

Langevin equation mx = −x+ w in R4.

For m = 0, x = w, for m = +∞, x = 0.

If we make m = b2, the hypoelliptic Laplacian (withy = x) describes the dynamics of the Langevinequation in a geometric context.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 184: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic Laplacian

The dynamics for the operator Lb is just

b2x = −x+ w.

The parameter b2 is a mass.

The interpolation property is exactly the one suggestedby Langevin equation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 185: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic Laplacian

The dynamics for the operator Lb is just

b2x = −x+ w.

The parameter b2 is a mass.

The interpolation property is exactly the one suggestedby Langevin equation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 186: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic Laplacian

The dynamics for the operator Lb is just

b2x = −x+ w.

The parameter b2 is a mass.

The interpolation property is exactly the one suggestedby Langevin equation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 187: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic Laplacian

The dynamics for the operator Lb is just

b2x = −x+ w.

The parameter b2 is a mass.

The interpolation property is exactly the one suggestedby Langevin equation.

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 188: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The operator A as a local limit of the elliptic

Dirac operator

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

elliptic Dirac operator.

Pt (x, y) heat kernel of exp(−tDX,2

).

Asymptotics of Pt (x, x) via change of coordinates(blowup) at each x.

A2 is the ‘limit’ under a sophisticate rescaling of tDX,2

when t→ 0.

How to make the fibre TX ‘walk again’ along X?

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 189: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

The hypoelliptic deformation

X total space of tangent bundle, with fibre TX.

Deformation acts on Ω(0,·) (X , π∗ (Λ· (T ∗X)⊗ E)).

Y generator of the geodesic flow, Cartan formula[dX , iY

]= LY .

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

Page 190: The hypoelliptic Dirac operator

The flat caseThe hypoelliptic Dirac operator BY

Analytic properties of B2Y

B2Y deformation of usual Laplacian on X

The hypoelliptic Quillen metricThe hypoelliptic Laplacian and ‘physics’

Classical Hodge theory

∂X∗

formal adjoint of ∂X

.

DX = ∂X

+ ∂X∗

.

X = DX,2 =[∂X, ∂

X∗]

Hodge Laplacian.

X elliptic, self-adjoint ≥ 0.

H = ker X = ker ∂X ∩ ker ∂

X∗the harmonic forms.

By Hodge theory, H ∼ H(0,·) (X,E).

Jean-Michel Bismut The hypoelliptic Dirac operator