Volume 204, No. 15 Cooperstown, New York, Thursday, April 12, 2012

RICHFIELD SPRINGS • CHERRY VALLEY • HARTWICK • FLY CREEK • MILFORD • SPRINGFIELD • MIDDLEFIELD

Cooperstown’s Newspaper • F

OUNDED

IN 18

08 B

Y JUDGE WILLIAM

CO

OP

ER

For 204 Years

Newsstand Price $1

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA, OTSEGO COUNTY’S LARGEST PRINT CIRCULATION2010 WINNERS OF The Otsego County Chamber/KEY BANK SMALL BUSINESS AWARD

COOPERSTOWNAND AROUND

For more information visit FarmersMuseum.org • Open Tuesday-Sunday, 10am-4pm (closed Mondays)5775 State Highway 80, Lake Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326 • 888.547.1450

Step back in time!TM

Fun for kids of all ages!Ride the Empire State Carousel! Tour the historic 1840s village andfarm on a horse-drawn wagon! See all sorts of farm animals!

Watch for our 8 NEW summer weekend events!

LEGACYof TRAGEDY

OTSEGO COUNTY & THE TITANIC

Titanic victimArthur Ryerson Sr.

Jim Kevlin/The Freeman’s JournalA flat slate cenotaph – literally, “empty tomb” – was installed in front of a Celtic cross at Cooperstown’s Lakewood Cemetery, memorializing Arthur Ryerson Sr., above, who went down with the Titanic. His body was never recovered.

Ron Jex, general manager, Cooperstown General Store, contemplates family memo-rabilia on William Alexander, his grandmother’s brother and Titanic victim.

Century Later, Victims’ FamiliesRealize Life Was Never The Same

IF YOU GO: The new 3D version of James Cameron’s “Ti-tanic,” with Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet, is playing at 12:10, 4:05 and 8 p.m. daily at the Southside Mall Cinemas over the anniversary weekend.

By JIM KEVLIN

COOPERSTOWN

A century later, and the Titanic disaster still resonates here.

It’s personal for Arthur R. Clarke Jr., great-grandson of Arthur Ryerson Sr., the Chicago lawyer and heir to a steel fortune who disappeared when the un-sinkable ocean liner sank at 2:20 a.m. on Monday, April 15, 1912,

a hundred years ago this Sunday.Clarke’s great-grandmother,

Emily Borie Ryerson, 48, with five children and homes on Philadelphia’s Main Line, Chi-cago and “Ringwood” on Otsego Lake, was bound for a life of domesticity, with family cares and grandchildren in her future.

That changed in a matter of days. On Monday, April 8, 2012, her eldest son, Arthur Jr., 21, was killed in a car crash in Bryn Mawr, Pa. By that

Please See TITANIC, A3

So Far, 2Seek SeatsIn SchoolElections

2% Tax Hike Still In Play,Mayor Says

IF YOU RUN: Only 25 signa-tures needed on petitions available from District Clerk Wendy Lansing. Deadline for submittal is 5 p.m. Monday,

COOPERSTOWN

A Bassett anesthesiologist has joined a Hartwick Seminary businesswoman as new-

comers seeking seats on the Coo-perstown Central School Board of Education in the Tuesday, May 15, elec-tion.

Dr. Jonathan A. Greenberg has joined Marcy S. Birch, a speech therapist who owns Barn-yard Swing, the miniature golf complex, in filing petitions with District Clerk Wendy Lansing for one of the four seats open this year.

The deadline to file petitions, which are available at Lansing’s office at the high school, is 5 p.m. Monday, April 16. Candidates must obtain 25 signatures from district

Please See ELECTION, A6

COOPERSTOWN

A 2 percent tax increase, cur-rently in the village’s pro-posed 2012-13 budget, is

still in play, according to Mayor Jeff Katz.

While he supports an annual tax increase as a prudent way to stay ahead of rising costs, Katz said the 2 percent was one of three unresolved issues that surfaced at a trustees’ budget hearing Monday, April 10.

The other two issues are whether to apply money from the village’s water fund for street repairs that include water-related infrastructure, and whether to add more money to the streets reserve.

On the tax increase, he said “it’s not the annual amount that’s signifi-cant; it’s the cumulative effect that’s the killer.”

Forgoing a 3 percent hike in 2010-11 and 2 percent in 2011-12 cost the

Please See KATZ/From A1

The Freeman’s JournalThe Rev. Betsy Jay, Bas-sett Hospital chaplain, delivers the homily at an ecumenical sunrise Easter service in Lake-front Park. Behind her are John and Peg Odell and daughter Emily.

COOPERSTOWN

The ribbon was cut Tuesday, March 10, on “FENtennial: Fenway

Park’s First 100 Years,” a year-long exhibit at the Na-tional Baseball Hall of Fame on Boston’s fabled ballpark.

The exhibit includes four dozen artifacts, include Carl Yastrzemski’s bat from his 3,000th hit and Ted Wil-liams’ 1960 home jersey.

Hall MarksFenway Park100th Year

HOPS ENJOYED: The Otsego County Historical Association’s first annual “History Today and Tomor-row” festival is 10 a.m.-3:30 p.m. Saturday, June 2, at the Beardslee Homestead Hop Barn, New Berlin. It include hop-house tours, a presentation by hops expert Al Bullard at 1:30 p.m., and a beer-tasting tent.

ARF, ARF! Bark For Life, a 1½-mile dog walk to raise money for the American Cancer Society, is 10 a.m.- 3 p.m. Saturday, April 21, at Glimmerglass State Park.

GOP PRIMARY: Polls will be open in all county districts noon-9 p.m. Tues-day, April 24, for the state’s Republican primary.

AllOTSEGO.dining&entertainmentBEFORE YOU GO OUT, CHECK THE COUNTY’S BEST GUIDE/B2-3

A-2 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

LOCALS

Kara Curpier, a SUNY Cobleskill alumna from Cooperstown, will compete nationally after quali-fying in Alumni Horsemanship at 2012 Intercol-legiate Horse Show Association Western Semi Finals Sunday, March 25, in Findlay, Ohio. She placed third, putting her among the top 12 IHSA Alumni in the nation, and she’ll compete May 3-6 at IHSA Nationals in Raleigh, N.C. Kara is daugh-ter of Kathy and Tony Scalici.

HORSEWOMAN IN NATIONALS

Jim Kevlin/The Freeman’s JournalCooperstown Wine & Spirits changed hands Friday, April 6. Partners Sha-ron Oberriter, her son Andrew and Patrick Shepard bought the Pioneer Street establishment from Ed Landers. From left are Landers, the Oberrit-ers, Shepard and Beth See, who will continue working for the new owners.

Oneonta, NY 3961/2 Chestnut St. • 267-4766Binghamton • Elmira • Rochester

HIGHEST PRICES PAID!

WE BUYGOLD,SILVER,COINS,FLATWARE...& anything ofvalue... Just ask!

Also buying Silver Plate and Gold Fill

We payCASH!

NOW OPEN IN ONEONTA!

WE BUY BROKEN AND UNWANTEDJEWELRY!

COOPERSTOWN WINE & SPIRITS SOLD

Firearms, Fraternal Regalia, Edged Weapons, African Taxidermy

FROM PRIVATE COLLECTIONS TO BE SOLD UNRESERVED

Thursday, April 12 - 4:30 PM Hesse Galleries, 350 Main St., Otego, NY

A printable color order of sale is available at

www.HESSEGALLERIES.com also visit AuctionZip.com auctioneer # 2029.

Plan to attend this sale or bid in absentia, there is no charge for this service.

AUCTIONEERS & APPRAISERS Dedicated to both Seller & Buyer

607-988-2523 All Sales Final 10% B P

Kilbourne, Albany, NY

Plant’s inscribed from Gen. John C. Breckenridge 1864

LATE NOTICE

SENIF HONORED: William P. Senif, Fly Creek, financial adviser with North-western Mutual Financial Network, has qualified for membership in the Mil-lion Dollar Roundtable, an independent association representing the top financial professionals worldwide.

KJOLHEDE HONORS: Hans Kjolhede, Class of 2012, is on the honor roll at the Kent School for the win-ter term. He is son of Dr. Chris Kjolhede of Fly Creek and Dr. Anne Gadomski of Cooperstown.

BAUER ON LIST: Robert Alan Bauer, a senior majoring in cell and de-velopmental biology at the University of Rochester, has been named to the Dean’s List for the fall 2011 semes-ter. The CCS graduate is a son of Michael and Stepha-nie Bauer.

COOPERSTOWN

Eric Pierce was re-elected captain of the Cooperstown Fire De-

partment Emergency Squad for 2012-1013.

Other officers elected are: • First Lt. Donna Hribar• Second Lt. Josh Kantor • Secretary Jim Hogan• Treasurer Tim Dolan

Pierce ReelectedCaptain Of EMS

Jim Kevlin/The Freeman’s Journal

Cooperstown’s Shey Revo-

linsky got to meet the Easter Bunny and Mrs.

Easter Bunny Saturday, April 11, at the Tun-nicliff, follow-ing an Easter parade from

Lakefront Park, sponsored by

the Cooper-stown Chamber

of Commerce.

MEETING THE OTHER MR. EASTER

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL A-3 THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

TITANIC/From A1Wednesday evening, the family was aboard the Titanic, hurrying home from Paris aboard the fastest ship in the world. A week after her son’s death, her husband was lost and she and three of her chil-dren – including Clarke’s grand-mother – Emily like her mother – were aboard Lifeboat #4 in the mid-Atlantic, awaiting rescue.

Independently wealthy, Arthur Ryerson Sr.’s widow eventually remarried, to Forsythe Sherfesee, whom she met in Peking, and the two travelled widely, eventually settling in an apartment in Paris and building a villa on the Riv-iera’s Cape Ferrat, next to “their dear friend” Somerset Maugham. She died on a trip to Uruguay in 1939, age 76.

With her children and grand-children in the U.S., “the centered-ness of family around her dissipat-ed,” said the great-grandson, who lives in Old Greenwich, Conn., but still summers at a family home on the grounds of the Otsego Golf Course.

It’s also personal for Ron Jex, who – like Clarke – was aware of the family’s connection to one of the greatest shipping disasters of all time as long as he can remem-ber.

Jex’s grandmother’s brother, William Alexander, was aboard the Titanic on his first trip to the U.S., hoping to surprise his sister at her new home in western New York, where she had moved with her husband and family five years before from Great Yarmouth, England.

The grandmother, Gertrude Jex, raising her family in Lockport, was surprised, but it was by a tele-gram informing her of William’s death, news that left her “deadly sick for four months.” She was so stricken that when a second telegram arrived, she was unable to travel to Nova Scotia to identify the contents of body bag #298, so the family is still unsure if Wil-liam’s remains are among the 150 victims buried in Halifax.

The story was a central part of Jex family lore “as long as I can remember talking,” said Ron, gen-eral manager of the Cooperstown General Store. His aunt, Freda Johnston, kept the family’s story alive; she owned coals from the Titanic, and would give presen-tations on the Titanic at senior centers throughout her life.

But fascination with the mighty ship – more than 1,500 people died that night, from able sea-men to such captains of industry as John Jacob Astor, Benjamin Guggenheim and Ryerson himself,

who inherited his father’s Ryerson Steel Co. – ranges beyond descen-dants, although perhaps stoked here by the local connections.

“The Titanic represented man’s conquest of nature,” said Fred Lemister the other day as he was about decorate the front window of his Rudy’s Liquor Store on a Titanic theme, as he’s done for years now. “That conquest took two hours to sink.”

It was “A Night To Remember,” Walter Lord’s 1955 book, fol-lowed by a movie in 1957, that originally captured the young Lemister’s imagination. (Jack Ryerson, 13 when he escaped a watery death, was silent through his life about that night, except in advising Lord’s research. After that, he’d say, “I told Walter Lord all I know. And I don’t want to talk about it any more.”)

“The irony of this ship of dreams ending up to be a ship of nightmares,” Lemister reflected as he surveyed a cache of memora-bilia – a White Star Line plate, a program of the 1997 play that ran for 800 performances at Broad-way’s Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, and much more – in Rudy’s basement.

He recalls Maury Yeston’s play vividly. The stage was divided into three tiers, first class above, the engine room below. As the audience waited for the play to begin, a crow’s nest was quietly lowered from above the seats. “Iceberg, dead ahead,” the lookout called out, startling the spectators, and the play began.

Lemister’s interest – he reports that God, Coca-Cola and Titanic are the three most recognizable words in the English language, in that order – has made him some-thing of a student of trans-Atlantic shipping.

“There had not been a loss of life in the Atlantic for more than 40 years,” he recounted. “So we got a little cocky.” The previous disaster involved the White Star Line’s Atlantic, which sank on April 1, 1873, off Nova Scotia; 535 died and 371 survived, com-pared to the Titanic’s 1,514 and 700 four decades later.

The Ryersons’ connection to Hyde Hall – the Ryersons’ daugh-ter, Emily, 18 when on the Titanic, later married George Hyde – is also inspiring “Titanic! Emily Ryerson Clarke’s Ill-Fated Voy-age,” an exhibit scheduled to open Saturday, June 2.

The opening will feature a dra-matic reading by Cooperstown’s Flis Blum of a deposition Mrs.

Arthur Ryerson Sr. gave in Coo-perstown, describing her family’s experience. Items on exhibit will include a trunk bearing a White Star Line sticker, a White Star Line plate from first class, and photos of the family, including Emily and George’s 1915 wed-ding, headlined “Titanic Survivor Weds George Hyde Clarke.” It was hard to shake the connection.

The exhibit includes a letter dated May 9, 1912, from Juliette Gordon Low, founder of the Girl Scouts, to her parents: “The Ryerson family … were wonderfully calm & said they did not feel cold at Titanic wreck, & both girls had to row & bail out the boat, because only one able seaman was aboard their life boat. Susanne (sic), who is as strong as a man, threw off her fur coat & got into the icy water to help boost up one man who was too cold to get in. They saved 19 men & two died after they got them in their life boat.”

In recent days, the NYSHA Library also unveiled an exhibit of Titanic memorabilia from its collection.

Still, the most dramatic local memorial to the tragedy is a sim-ple Celtic cross set in a sheltered hillside in Cooperstown’s Lake-wood Cemetery and surrounded by wild rhododendron. In front of it is slate panel – a cenotaph,

literally “empty tomb” – 6 foot by 4, memorializing Arthur Ryerson Sr., “lost on the Titanic April 15, 1912, giving his life for others.” Arthur Ryerson Jr., whose death set the subsequent family tragedy in motion, is buried there.

Suzette, 21 on April 15, 1912, died in 1921, age 30, from appen-dicitis or heart failure – reports conflict. Emily Ryerson, then 18, died in 1960 at age 66. Jack Ryerson, then 13, died in 1986 at age 87.

Victorine Chaudanson, the French maid who accompanied the family, died in Pennsylvania in 1962 at 86. The children’s governess, Grace Scott Bowen, went on to become principal of the Knox School for Girls, which used to occupy The Otesaga during winter months.

Ellen, 17 in 1912, was a stu-dent at St. Timothy’s, a boarding school in Maryland, so missed her family’s European tour that ended in tragedy; she later married Victor Salvatore, who sculpted the James Fenimore Cooper statue in Cooper Park. Their son, Victor Salvatore Jr. – Arthur Ryerson Sr.’s great-grandson – recently turned 90 in West Palm Beach, Fla.

He would have known his great-grandmother, the Titanic survivor, and may be the last family mem-ber who would have. Ellen had seven children with George Hyde Clark, and the final two – Victor Salvatore’s first cousins – passed away just recently: Anne Lo-gan, 85, Cooperstown, Aug. 5, 2010, and – just a few months ago – Arthur Clarke Sr., 85, on Oct. 19 at his son’s home in Old Greenwich.

All of this continues to inspire people like Peter Deysenroth, the Cooperstown funeral director, who after seeing James Cameron’s “Titanic” in 1997, joined the Titanic Historical Society. In the late 1990s, he and his wife, Maria, were among 830,000 people who attended a landmark exhibit on the Titanic at the Florida International Museum, as did Fred Lemister and wife Karen.

Standing at the Ryerson ceno-taph the other afternoon, Deysen-roth recalled one feature of the ex-hibit in particular: A ship’s railing had been set up in a room as cold as it had been on the Titanic that

night. Holding onto the railing, a cold wind blew in their faces at the same strength it blew in the faces of Mrs. Ryerson and her three children that night.

Deysenroth paused, then he said of the continuing fascination: “It was about the rich, and the poor, and everyone in between. It taught everyone a lesson, in the most brutal way, that we are not invincible.”

It was one tragedy that led to another.

Arthur Ryerson Jr., 21, a Yale student, was killed at 11 p.m. Monday, April 8, after the car he was driving hit a rock on a road in Bryn Mawr, Pa., went out of control and sheared off a “Danger, Blow Your Horn,” sign. The classmate he was visiting, John L. Hoffman, also died from injuries.

His family – father Arthur Ryerson Sr., mother Emily Borie Ryerson, and siblings, Suzette, 21, Emily, 18, Jack, 13. (Ellen, 17, was attend-ing St. Timothy’s, a board-ing school in Maryland, and missed the trip) – had been

touring Europe since Febru-ary, along with a French maid and Grace Scott Bowen of Cooperstown, the children’s tutor.

This account comes mostly from a detailed article by Phyllis Ryerse in the summer 1990 edition of The Official Journal of the Titanic Historical Society.

The family received the news in Paris the next morning, Tuesday, April 9, and immediately made arrangements to return to New York. “Normally a strong and capable woman,” Ryerse wrote of Arthur Jr.’s mother, “she moved now as though stunned by a physi-

cal blow.”Wednesday the 10th, they

went by rail to Cherbourg, At 5:30, they boarded the tender Nomadic, which fer-ried them across the English Channel to the Titanic, “the largest moving object ever created by man,” docked off Southampton, which departed that night.

The voyage was unevent-ful. Arthur Sr. engaged in conversation in the smok-ing room with a friend, Archie Butt, President Taft’s military aide, and others of his social set from Phila-delphia’s Main Line and Chicago. Emily, dressed in mourning, remained in

the cabin, except evenings, when her husband insisted she take in fresh air and walk around the deck. Jack frequented the gym. Emily and Suzette played shuffle-board or deck quoits.

Sunday, April 14, was the fateful day. At 2 p.m., the S.S. Baltic cabled reports of “icebergs and large quanti-ties of field ice” 250 miles ahead. At 11:40, lookout Frederick Fleet, in the crow’s nest, rang the bridge: “Iceberg right ahead.” And the ship’s hull was soon tore with a sound some likened to a thousand rolling marbles. A little after mid-night on the 15th – a hun-

dred years ago this Sunday – women and children were ordered to the lifeboats.

In a famous episode, Sec-ond Officer Lightoller tried to block Jack – according to some accounts, he had been promoted from the knickers boys then wore to long pants on the death of his brother – from entering a lifeboat. But Arthur Sr. was insistent. “Momentarily intimidated by the intensity of the reply, Lightoller let the boy pass,” Ryerse reported.

The men who remained on the ship expected to be rescued by passing ships and to rejoin their families; Emily and Suzette smiled

and waved to their father. But at 2:20 a.m., as the lifeboat pulled away, “the stern began to rise out of the water until it stood almost straight up, and everything loose inside the ship began to thunder forward ... Those in the boat could hear the explosions within the ships. They could hear dishes shattering and the screams of people sliding down the decks into the freezing ocean water.”

The lifeboat was rescued by the Carpathia at 8 a.m., but Arthur Ryerson Sr.’s body was never recovered.

– Jim Kevlin

A Week Of Anguish, Mourning For Cooperstown’s Ryerson Family

Titanic’s Legacy of Tragedy Lives On Here

Jim Kevlin/The Freeman’s JournalFamily portraits show Arthur Ryerson Sr., who was lost on the Titanic, and his wife Em-ily Borie Ryerson and their son, Jack, both of whom left the ship on lifeboat #4 and were picked up by the Carpathia at 8 a.m. on Monday, April 15, 1912.

The death of Arthur Ryerson Jr., 21, left, in a car crash in Bryn Mawr, Pa., on April 8, 1912, caused the family to rush home from Europe – on the Titanic. Arthur Clarke Jr., right, is Arthur Ryerson Sr.’s great-grandson – grandson of Arthur Jr.’s sister Emily – and a member of the latest generation to recount the family’s story.

Fred Lemister, with memorabilia that will be displayed this week at Rudy’s Liquor Store, Main Street, Cooperstown, has been enraptured by the Titanic story since Walter Lord’s “Night to Remember” in 1955.

Wayne Wright, associate director of the NYSHA Library, straightens a portrait of Emily Borie Ryerson in an exhibit that went on display in recent days.

THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

PerspectivesA-4 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL

EDITORIAL

SUCCESSOR PUBLICATION TOThe Cherry Valley Gazette • The Hartwick Review

The Milford Tidings • The Morris Chronicle • Oneonta Press The Otsego Farmer • The Richfield Springs Mercury

OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER FOR

Otsego County • Town of Cherry Valley • Town of MiddlefieldCooperstown Central School District

Subscriptions Rates: Otsego County, $45 a year. All other areas, $60 a year.First Class Subscription, $120 a year.

Published Thursdays by Iron String Press, Inc.21 Railroad Ave., Cooperstown NY 13326

Telephone: (607) 547-6103. Fax: (607) 547-6080.E-mail: info@allotsego.com • www.allotsego.com

Contents © Iron String Press, Inc.

Periodicals postage paid at USPS Cooperstown40 Main St., Cooperstown NY 13326-9598

USPS Permit Number 018-449Postmaster Send Address Changes To:

Box 890, Cooperstown NY 13326

Judge Cooper’s portrait, by Gilbert Stuart, is in The Fenimore Art Museum

James C. Kevlin Mary Joan Kevlin Editor & Publisher Associate Publisher

Tara Barnwell Amanda Hoepker Advertising Director Office Manager Jamie Smith, Luisa Fuentes Tom Heitz Sales Associates Consultant

Libby Cudmore Ian Austin Reporter Photographer

Graphics: Scott Buchanan

Cooperstown’s Newspaper

• FOUNDED IN

1808 BY JUDGE WILLIA

M C

OO

PER

For 204 Years

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR WELCOME • E-MAIL THEM TO info@allotsego.com

ALBANY

Did you see “The King’s Speech”? I loved that movie,

which told how King George, the present Queen Elizabeth’s father, overcame a stutter by going to an ec-centric speech pathologist. It was touching, moving and made you like every-one.

I understand that there may be a sequel in the offing: “The New York Governor’s Speech.”

We all know that An-drew Cuomo is one of the shrewdest and most am-bitious politicians in the country. Cuomo will hold

grudges, big-time, but he doesn’t take things person-ally. If he makes a peace offering to anyone who is standing in his way and if that offer is accepted (with all that entails in terms of future fealty) past unhappi-ness will be forgotten.

I know one reporter for Please See CHARTOCK, A7

As went George, so goes Andrew?

‘The Governor’s Speech,’ At Moviehouse Near You

ALAN CHARTOCKCAPITOL CONNECTION

This popular copy of 19th-century map shows, lo and behold, one Oneonta.

Editor’s Note: This is the text of Oneonta Mayor Dick Miller’s Tuesday, April 10, speech to the Oneonta Town Board, encouraging a study of merger’s possible benefits.

First, let me thank you for the opportunity to address you on discus-

sion of the possibility of a city/town merger or consoli-dation. I am well aware of the negative view and pas-sion on this subject on the part of large segments of the population of both the town and the city. If the result of the discussions proposed was to be a mutual decision to go forward, it would be subject to voter approval and probably could not come in the form of separate referendums before the fall of 2014. I am confident that such a referendum would fail in the town today and probably would fail in the city as well, but I am here despite that.

The discussion I have proposed is not a new idea. Let me digress and say that because of the obvious implications of some sort of merger in the county, I believe that any discussion group should include rep-resentatives of the county administration and board.

In 1996, a study was conducted by the SUNY Oneonta Center for Eco-nomic & Community De-velopment. That study was funded by Francis Rowe Trust, Wilber National bank, City of Oneonta, Key Bank, Future for Oneonta Founda-tion, Otsego Redi-Mix, and Dr. Michael MacDowell and

David W. Brenner, Duncan S. Davie, David Martindale, Cheryl Shackelton, and John Insetta provided support to it. Members of the commis-sion that oversaw it included Paul Adamo, Robert Bard, Joseph Bernier, Charles Burnsworth, Jim Catella, Sr., Tim Catella, Frank Gal-lucci, Huemac Garcia, Mi-chael Getman, Robert Har-lem, Jr., Hugh Henderson, Larry Hilts, Susan Hughson, Leon Kalmus, Marie Lusins, Michael MacDowell, Mar-gery Merzig, Robert Moyer, Benjamin Nesbitt, Alda Peinkofer, Virginia Pence, Joe Raymond, Paul Scheele, Kay Stuligross, Bruce Ward, Donald Webster and Robert Wood. One of its recom-mendations specifically was “given the promise that the preemption option offers, the task force recommends that a nine-member joint commission be formed to study the possibility of con-solidation. Two members of this joint commission must

be the mayor of Oneonta and the supervisor of the Town of Oneonta.” I know of no formal decisions made by either the city or town governments to not imple-ment that recommendation.

Completely indepen-dently, the Center for Governmental Research conducted a study for the state Commission on Local Government Efficiency & Competitiveness in 2008 of the communities of Cort-land, Norwich and Oneonta. In 2010, I asked for the original 1996 study to be updated by the state univer-sity center. The facts of all studies are outlined in the “facts about consolidation for subsequent confirmation and discussion” document that I distributed to you on March 28.

I had help preparing that document from Dan Crow-ell, Bob Wood and Tim Hayes. The most important words in it are “for sub-sequent confirmation and

discussion.”It has been suggested

that I view consolidation as a way of “bailing out the city.” Certainly, there could be positive financial consequences for the city, just as there could be for the town, but no such bailout will be necessary. The city has been well managed for a number of years and has per capita greater financial reserves and less debt than any similar city we know of in Upstate New York. We have challenges and we will get through them. Given the fact that all municipalities in the state are in much more serious trouble than Oneon-ta leads one to conclude that Albany will have to address this situation and the city will be a beneficiary when actions are taken.

Certainly it bothers me that we don’t take advantage of opportunities for shared services, as in the asses-sor’s functions, and

Please See SPEECH, A7

ISSUE & DEBATE

County Who’s Who Helped FundOneonta’s Original Merger Study

This editorial had been written and the page sent electronically to

our printer when the word arrived Tuesday evening, April 10, that the Oneonta Town Board had unani-mously voted to create a town-only study group to look into the facts of a pos-sible merger with the City of Oneonta.

That’s a gutsy first step and the absolutely right one for the future of the town, of the city and of Otsego County as a whole.

Town Supervisor Bob Wood and Councilmembers Scott Gravelin, Janet Hur-ley-Quackenbush, David Jones and Bill Mirabito are no push-overs. They are battle-hardened. They are experienced. And they’ve put the potential long-term benefit of their fellow citi-zens above the temporary discomfort of inevitable criticism from some voters.

JFK’s “Profiles In Cour-age” comes to mind, that slender 1955 Pulitzer-win-ning volume. Slender, because it’s rare that elected officials, consensus-seekers by nature, willingly choose short-term pain for them-selves, and some electoral risk, over long-term gain for all.

City Mayor Dick Miller was seeking a 10-person, town-city-county panel when he appeared before the Town Board that eve-ning, but no doubt he was delighted by the outcome. It should also be noted that state Sen. Jim Seward, R-Milford, had written letter to the Town Board suggesting such a sensible first step is warranted, and it is.

Bravo. Well done. Yes, indeed, let the facts decide.

•Let’s go back to the

original editorial, and see if it still makes sense.

In colonial times, we were saying, New England

towns were drawn to be about 10 miles wide, to accommodate worshipers at the local Congregational church on a central green. It was estimated farm families could comfortably walk a maximum of five miles to church and five miles back on a Sunday.

When you think about Ot-sego County, that holds. It’s eight miles from Cooper-stown to Milford, another nine or 10 to Colliersville, 10 miles from Otego to Unadilla, another seven or eight to Sidney.

As town centers devel-oped, in Otsego County as elsewhere, each had a mill,

a general store, eventually a bank, a power company and so on. But over the course of the 20th century, as com-munication and transporta-tion advanced, those com-mercial entities centralized, realizing efficiencies and competitive advantages.

Only the municipalities remained mired in colonial times, and Otsego County is no exception, with 24 towns and nine villages and 12 school districts serving the same number of 60,000 people served during the horse-and-buggy days of the Civil War.

•So Mayor Miller has

– let’s make that had – been paddling against the flow in his efforts to move that town and city of the same name into looking at, then acting on, merger into a single City of Greater Oneonta.

Merging the two munici-palities would make a lot of sense to the city and the town, too. Currently, the Town of Oneonta produces at least 25 percent of the sales tax collected in Otsego County, yet receives only 1.76 percent of that total. A combined entity could ac-cess the full 25 percent.

An opinion from the state

Attorney General’s Office found Greater Oneonta would be able to have two taxing districts – one for areas receiving municipal services, another for rural areas that receive few such services. This may allow property taxes to be almost eliminated in those rural ar-eas, and removes one major obstacle to consolidation.

But a fully thriving Oneonta would serve the in-terests of Otsego County as a whole in many ways. For one, it’s clear that a clean environment is a central val-ue for many of our citizens; yet, per capita income in Otsego County is 13 percent below the national average in an area more expensive than the national average. Today, environmentalism means continued poverty, but that doesn’t have to be.

Greater Oneonta solves that problem. To even more of a degree than today, the city, fully infrastructured, proximate to I-88, can be the county’s hub of business and light industry. Imagine the old D&H yards as a commerce park, downtown as a vibrant housing center, Southside as ever more powerful retail magnet.

Even more than now, people working in Greater

Oneonta could choose to commute to our charm-ing villages and hamlets, with disposable incomes to improve their properties and support additional retail in compact downtowns. Con-versely, people now living in the country towns would have more employment op-tions in the larger city.

•Mayor Miller is pursuing

the lowest-hanging fruit, but it reflects a way of thinking – logical, futuristic, vision-ary – that could be applied in exciting ways in the years ahead.

We in Otsego County are blessed with many advan-tages – scenic beauty, pure water aplenty, proximity to East Coast markets, two col-leges with growing reputa-tions, and a highway runs through it. But, as Senator Seward pointed out in open-ing remarks at his summit, we’ve been under-achievers.

The Oneonta town fathers (and one mother) have now embraced the future. Let hope the study confirms merger would be good for their town, great for ev-eryone, and would begin shifting our county from, frankly, stagnation, to an ex-citing and promising course.

Again, bravo! BRAVO!

The private sector has centralized and gained ef-ficiencies through modern communications and transportation, but local government, in Otsego County and many other places, still lives in a horse-and-buggy age.

Oneonta Town Board Takes Gutsy Step To Study Consolidation

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL A-5THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

BOUND VOLUMESCompiled by Tom HeiTz from Freeman’s Journal archives, courtesy of the New York State Historical Association Library

200 YEARS AGO

April 18, 1812

175 YEARS AGOProgress of the Cholera – Of all diseases this is the most

extraordinary. Capricious, yet constant; partial, yet finally universal; slight in some parts of its progress, overwhelm-ing in others; passing through all climates, influenced by none; a winter epidemic in one land, a summer scourge in another; seizing alike on every species of population; sometimes yielding to the most trivial remedy, sometimes baffling the most approved. Utterly defying all systematic care, it remains now, after half a dozen years of its travers-ing through the world, the same mysterious, resistless, perpetual moving calamity.

April 10, 1837

150 YEARS AGOBusiness – The Otsego Brewery in this village is now

under the proprietorship of Mr. R.A. Lesley, who turns out to his customers a superior article of stock, pale and amber ale, made from pure malt and No. 1 hops. It is preferable to most of the imported article which is brought into the coun-try. Mr. E.B. Crandal opened a Book Bindery in this village a year ago. He does a neat job, which the people have found out, and the institution so much needed here has become a fixed fact.

A notice from the Postmaster General informs the public that all letters addressed to officers or soldiers of the Army of the Potomac, whether near Washington or moving South, should be mailed to Washington City. From this city they will be promptly forwarded to their destination in packages with all the facility possible.

April 11, 1862

125 YEARS AGOTo avoid premature old age the following good advice

is given by Dr. Benjamin Ward Richardson. The rules for the prevention of all senile diseases are all personal. They should begin in youth. It should be a rule among grown-up persons never to subject children to mental shocks and un-necessary grieving. When, in the surroundings of child life, some grave calamity has occurred, it is best to make the event as light as possible to the child, and certainly to avoid thrilling it with sights and details which stir it to the utmost, and in the end only leave upon the mind and heart incurable wounds and impressions. Children should never be taken to funerals, nor to sights that cause a sense of fear and dread combined with great grief, nor to sights which call forth pain and agony in man, or in the lower animals.

April 16, 1887

100 YEARS AGOArthur Larned Ryerson, well-known in Cooperstown as

the son of Arthur Ryerson, Esq., the owner of Ringwood, at the head of Otsego Lake, was killed Monday in an auto crash a few miles from Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania. Ryerson was visiting a college friend, Louis Hoffman, for the Easter vacation. Both are Yale students. They were driving in the latter’s car at a fast rate along the main turnpike in Philadel-phia, when Hoffman, who was driving, lost control of the car. Both were thrown from the car when it struck a tele-graph pole. The two men were taken by ambulance to Bryn Mawr Hospital where they died of their injuries within hours. Mr. and Mrs. Ryerson are in Europe, where they have been touring in their automobile. Rev. Ralph Birdsall, rector of Christ Church, received a cablegram from Paris Tuesday stating that Mr. and Mrs. Ryerson will sail on the Titanic Wednesday. The funeral will be held from Christ Church, Cooperstown, after their arrival.

April 10, 1912

75 YEARS AGOWhere Nature Smiles – On April 9, the A.C.C. Gym

Girls’ swimming team held their second meeting. They have resolved to hold a meeting the first Wednesday of every month. The team is now practicing for a meet against Albany Business College for women sometime in May, or the end of April. The girls have named the club the S.O.S. Each girl pledged her honor to withhold the meaning of

the name, which will be faithfully kept for certain definite reasons.

Large flocks of starling birds have been seen in Cooper-stown and vicinity since the coming of spring. The starling, regarded as a pest by many, was brought to this country from abroad to exterminate the Japanese beetle, and has done a good job. Despite their quarrelsome and rather un-tidy habits, the birds cannot be called an economic enemy of man, for they devour enough insects to overbalance any unfavorable characteristics.

April 14, 1937

50 YEARS AGOErnest G. Canadeo has been named full-time pharma-

cist at the Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital, effective April 2. Mr. Canadeo, who is a Fordham University College of Pharmacy graduate, becomes the first hospital employee to serve as a pharmacist in over 20 years. During that period the hospital’s pharmacy needs have been met by Church & Scott, Inc., and a succession of Church & Scott pharma-cists. Mr. Canadeo succeeds William S. Adsit, a Church & Scott pharmacist, who has been at the hospital on a part-time basis since 1955.

April 11, 1962

25 YEARS AGOCooperstown Elementary School second-graders went

to the CCS high school auditorium stage last Friday to visit and tour a giant model of the human brain. There they found the 8-by-12-foot model the sixth grade ETC (Excep-tionally Talented and Creative) students had constructed out of plastic, a 24-inch fan, masking tape, duct tape, crepe pa-per, and hard work. The creators of the model brain are Sara Phillips, Sarah Streek, Melissa Kolski, and Jessica Bordley.

April 15, 1987

10 YEARS AGOTheir machine does much and accomplishes little, but

it earned a Cooperstown Central School team first place honors last weekend at Union College’s Rube Goldberg Machine Contest in competition with nine other entrants. Goldberg is noted for creating intricate drawings of com-plex machines that perform multiple steps in a process that ultimately completes a simple task. The CCS team mem-bers are juniors Dan Brassaw and Sam Stults and seniors Anna Brody and Scott Schaeffer. Their machine performs 23 steps, with nine energy conversions that starts with a falling ball and concludes with the raising of the American flag.

April 12, 2002

For the latest news, go to AllOTSEGO.com

Quality, Comfort, Dignity... Products

For Your Life! 174 Roundhouse Road, Oneonta

www.symphonymedicalsupply.com

607-643-0257

Offering A Full Line of Medical Supplies &

Equipment For All Your Health Care Needs! Medicare

& Medicaid AcceptedLocal Delivery

HAVE YOU EVER CONSIDERED RUNNING FOR SCHOOL BOARD?

IF YOU HAVE THESE QUALITIES*, MAYBE YOU SHOULD☺ EFFEcTIVE cOMMUnIcATOr – Can describe what he or she wants and describe what others want; a good listener☺ cOnSEnSUS BUILDEr – Capable of working toward decisions that all can support and willing to compromise to achieve that goal☺ cOMMUnITY PArTIcIPAnT – Enjoys meeting a variety of people, can identify the community’s key communicators and reaches out to the community☺ DEcISIOn MAkEr – Knows his or her own as well as others’ deci-sion-making styles, can support group decision-making☺ InFOrMATIOn PrOcESSOr – Can organize priorities and schedules to handle lots of verbal and written information☺ LEADEr – Willing to take risks, be supportive of board colleagues, district staff and community ☺ TEAM PLAYEr – Helps promote the board’s vision and goals

* LIST OF QUALITIES PrOVIDED BY nY STATE ScHOOL BOArDS ASSOcIATIOn

FOr THE FIrST TIME In DEcADES, FOUR SEATS OnTHE cOOPErSTOWn cEnTrAL ScHOOL BOArD

– A MAJOrITY – WILL BE FILLED TUESDAY, MAY 15. POLLS WILL BE OPEn 11 A.M.-8 P.M.

TO RUN, YOU nEED ONLY 25 SIGNATURES.PETITIOnS ArE AVAILABLE nOW AT DISTrIcT cLErk WEnDY LAnSInG’S OFFIcE AT THE HIGH ScHOOL, Or CALL HER

AT 547-5364. PETITIOnS ArE DUE In WEnDY’S OFFIcEBY 5 P.M., MOnDAY, APrIL 16.

BROUGHT TO YOU AS A PUBLIC SERVICE BY THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL

A-6 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

ESTABLISHED 1960• SALES • SERVICE • INSTALLATION

Bus.(607) 432-8009 • Fax (607) 263-2492

Barney & Sons Well Drilling INC.COMMERCIAL – RESIDENTIAL – FARMS

www.barneyandsonsdrilling.com

996Co. Hwy. 10,Laurens, NY

13796

Water Wells Drilled Any Size - Any Depth

4-12 Inch

Pansies are READY!Cafe opening SOON!

Open daily 9-6

Gr

eat

Brook So

lar

Bringing Power to the People since 1978.

Think you can’t afford solar? State incentive money, tax credits, drop in panel prices, and leasing options could make the difference!

CALL GREAT BROOK SOLAR AT:607-847-6366

to request a FREE site evaluation and estimate.Installing in ALL of Central New York

www.great-brook-solar.com

MAKE YOUR OWN POWER!

Put our experience to work for you. We will custom design a solar electric, solar thermal, geothermal, or

micro-hydro system to fit your unique needs.

HOME & GARDENSEASON ISHERE!

Melinda’s Garden Barn

& Landscaping

BlueberryPlants are

HERE!

NurseryStock Arriving

Daily

Great selection of unusualgarden accessories!

(315) 858-0955Open Mon - Sat 8-6, Sun 9-5

8442 St. Hwy. 28, Richfield Springs

Potting Soils • Garden Soils • Top Soils • Bulk MulchWE DELIVER!

Jack BurgessPlumbing & Heating

Licensed Master Plumber

Done once,done right

(607) 435-3352plumberone1@gmail.com

Wouldn’t you love a relaxing and beautifying makeover for your hands and feet in

a private and peaceful setting?

If so, call Nancy LeDuc, specializing in manicures, pedicures and shellac.

(607) 434 - 8793 or (607) 263-9702Third door on the left in the

Cottage Day Spa, 93 Chestnut St., OneontaAnd ask about your free gift!

Providing Happy Feet for 20 Years!

Join us at the

Alzheimer’s CafeWednesday, April 18, 4-6 pm

EnjoyJohn Michael Zov

playing the piano & accordion

• Information for individuals with dementia, families & care givers• Share ideas & experiences • Meet new friends

The Plains at Parish HomesteadAlzheimer’s Café

For more information please callBarbara Ann Heegan

Director of Marketing607-267-4013

bheegan@plainsatparish.com163 Heritage Circle, Oneonta , NY 13820

www.plainsatparish.com

INSURANCE

For quotes or inquiries online check out: www.bieritzinsurance.com

We All Need it!!!Why not go to the one Agency

That offers over 20 choices?Your “HOMETOWN” Agency

The BieriTz Agency209 mAin STreeT, cooperSTown • 547-2951

Across from Bruce Hall’s

Bieritz is YOUR Independent Insurance Agency

or in Morris 607-263-5170

22ndYEAR

Celebrating our

1990-2012

CONNELL, DOW & DEYSENROTH, INC.FUNERAL HOME

This year marks the 100th anniversary of the sinking of RMS Titanic April 15, 1912. We honor those that perished in this historic event.

Peter A. Deysenroth and staff

CooperstownBassett Eyewear Center

607-547-3140Prescriptions filled without appointment

Latest styles & technology

Hours: Monday through Friday 8:00 am - 5:00 pm

Located:Bottom Floor of ClinicCooperstown Campus

ELECTION/From A1residents 18 and older to run.

Three current school board members, board President Tony Scalici, David Borgstrom and Mikal Sky-Shrewsberry have also filed petitions, but Sky-Shrewsberry said she is un-sure she will follow through in seeking a second term.

Greenberg, a 14-year resi-

dent of the district, said he is running to “improve the academics of the school. I think the people of Cooper-stown are realizing the qual-ity of the school has been precipitously going down over the past five years.”

He said he is particularly concerned about the Eng-lish, foreign language and, to a lesser degree, science instruction, and reported

that a family he knows recently bought a home in New Hartford to obtain a better education for their daughter.

It’s a mistake, he said, for a school district to cut back on programs due to short-term economic challenges, since that discourages fami-lies with children from mov-ing here. One idea he would like to pursue, he added, is to ask Cooperstown’s non-profit institutions to make voluntary contributions to closing budget gaps.

He and wife Julia have two children in the local schools, Alexander in eighth grade and Emily in 10th.

Birch is a trained speech therapist with 25 years experiende, with BOCES, individual school districts

and private practice. She said she is running because she was asked to.

Over the years, she and husband Bob, the Coo-perstown lawyer, have hosted 21 children in their Toddsville home – both Rotary Exchange students and foster children. They have two sons of their own, Anthony, a seventh grader, and Jonathan, 21, a junior at McGill in Montreal.”

“The role of the school board is to set policy to help get kids to the next level,” she said. She noted that the school board has “gotten a lot of bad press lately,” but said, “I don’t know the spe-cifics” and “I’m not going to second guess what other people have done.”

KATZ/From A1village about $100,000, and meanwhile mandatory contributions to the employ-ees’ pension fund have risen more than that, he said.

However, Katz noted that Deputy Mayor Walter Franck, who had to leave the meeting where the 2 per-cent was added in, said he would not have voted for the increase.

On the water fund, the vil-lage’s Water Board, on the afternoon of April 10, voted against the idea of transfer-ring the money to streets, Katz said, noting the Water Board has a capital plan for $1.3 million in projects.

They include $175,000 needed to combat the zebra mussel infestation in Ot-sego Lake, and a study into repair to the dam across the Susquehanna at Mill Street.

On the street fund, he

said Trustee Lynne Mebust and others are concerned that devoting as much of the money to street repair as has occurred in the past two years has created holes in other areas, such as the replacement schedule for the highway department’s fleet.

However, Katz said he believes the trustees, which includes two new mem-bers, Cindy Falk and Frank Capozza, will be able to come to a consensus in a couple of hours at the next budget meeting, which will be scheduled for the 18th or the 20th.

2 Newcomers Seek Seats On CCS School Board

2% Tax Hike UnsettledFor Now, Mayor States

Buy From The LargesTgrower in The area

County Route 46, Mt. VisionJust off Rte. 205 Exit 13 off I-88 - 9 mi. north of Oneonta

607-432-1260

OPENING THE LAST WEEKEND OF APRILCome browse our greenhouses filled with: Potted Plants

Hanging Baskets - Bedding Plants - Vegetable Plants Fuchsias & Ivy Geraniums - Herbs - over 50 varieties of perennials

OPEN7 DAYS A WEEK

UNTIL DARK PANSIESwill be ready!

MtVisionGardenCenter.com

LANDSCAPING SERVICEPlant your garden with professional help

Geothermal Energy of Oneonta, Inc.believes in providing customers with a comfortable, clean, reliable, environmentally friendly source of home energy. We offer complete system installation and all loop types. Our experienced and trained staff will walk you through all the steps of selecting the appropriate system for your energy needs.

WHY GEOTHERMAL?• Greenest System Available• Comfort• Reliability• Long-Term Savings• Energy Efficient• Provides Hot Water• Safest• Increases Home Value• Renewable Energy Source

PO Box 519, Oneonta, NY 13820P: (607) 432-8080 F: (607) 263-2492

www.h2ogeo.net

Ken Pym & Son

• Lawn Mowing • Lawn Installation \ Repair

• Grading & Topsoil • Driveways • Crusher Run Installed

• Seal Coating • Small Paving ProjectsStump Grinding & Removal

Bobcat & Dumptruck ServiceHauling:

topsoil / sand / stone / gravel / crusher run /dump runs

(607) 547-9313

HOME & GARDENSEASON ISHERE!

56 Oneida St., Oneonta NY 607-432-0171 • 1-866-413-8500mon-fri 8am-5pm • sat 8am-noon

SPRINGERSINC.COM

OPEN HOUSE!Friday & SaturdayApril 20th & 21st10-5pm

BIG SAVINGS ON PARTS, SERVICE, AND SALES

THE BIGGEST EVENT OF THE YEAR

HU700L Push Mower$35995

455 Rancher Chain Saww/ 18” bar

$39995

YTH26V54 Lawn Mower$199995

128C Trimmer$14995

DOOR PRIZESREFRESHMENTS

RIDE ‘n’ BUY!

LET

IT G

ROW N

URSERY

607 - 264-3247 MiddleField Center Road ( Route 33)

10 miles northeast of Cooperstown on rte 33 - 3 miles southwest of Cherry Valley on rte 166www.letitgrownursery.net

20th YearGrand Opening

Doors Open For Business Officially May 1st

please stop by in person

HuGe seleCtiOn HiGH QuAlitY

open 7 days 9 am till 6 pm

Sciallo’s and Associates• Power Washing• Carpentry & Repairs• Floor Refinishing & Quality Paints• Custom Restorations

Rich Bartlett607-435-2161

Peter Sciallo607-547-2185607-437-4851

Professional Restoration Interior & Exterior Paint Specialists

Paint your Life with Shades of NatureServing Cooperstown, Oneonta and Richfield Springs

Fully Insured EPA Lead Certified

SPEECH/From A4that city taxpayers bear the cost of the Oneonta Police Department providing “first responder” services to the town about three times a month without compensa-

tion. But none of the above is the overriding driver for me on this subject.

Simply stated, what drives me is that I see an opportunity to strengthen our community, improve its

economy and protect and le-verage our significant assets for Oneonta to be a greater force in the region and state.

Whether you live in the city or town, as a member of the Oneonta community, I

believe we all want:• Enhancement of our

pristine environmentally sensitive surroundings

• A food market in the West End

• Success of Foothills and

completion of the Bresee’s project

• The enhanced future of our two colleges and Fox Hospital

• Improvements to the roads, safety, infrastructure, and attractiveness of South-side

• Support of growing businesses like Ioxus and Corning

• Attractiveness, vibrancy and safety of downtown

• Development of the rai-lyards, and renewed contri-bution of the playing fields at the National Soccer Hall of Fame

• The ability of young people to buy homes, par-ticularly in center city

• A school system in which we can continue to take pride

The list could go on.I believe that our history

and the incredibly beauti-ful environment in which we live can be honored and protected more effectively if we address them together as a community.

I do not believe in protecting the status quo. Evidence of decline of the status quo is in our aging population and decreasing disposable income. Declin-ing school age population is a result of our not creat-ing enough decent paying jobs here. Southside jobs are great, but in the extreme they are at minimum wage levels and the average big box employee only stays for two years. Big Box retail owners don’t live here and don’t reinvest their profits in the community in the ways of locally owned businesses.

I believe we have to change and act affirmatively to drive our community’s future. I don’t believe that we should “just let the fu-ture happen.”

Under the discussions I propose, we may be able to achieve the benefits of

acting as one community without merging. Benefits are the objective. Merger is a vehicle, but may not be the only one.

If you believe the better future of the community is something we, as elected officials, have a responsibil-ity for, than we should work together to that end.

If you are prepared to vote yes on the discussions I propose recalling that they were proposed by a very distinguished group of individuals 16 years ago, I urge you to do so, so that together we can get about forming a group and design-ing a process.

If you are inclined to vote no tonight, I urge you to table the subject and appoint one or two individuals to work with representatives of the city and the county to more clearly define the makeup of a potential group and the process that it would follow so that the subject could be brought back to you for action in a month’s time.

Despite my short period of time here, in relative terms in the context of others in this room, I love the Oneonta community. I don’t love the city or the town. How can anyone love a government? I love the Oneonta community

None of us here will live long enough to realize all the benefits of acting more assertively to share our future with or without merg-ing as a community, but certainly we will see signs of progress.

I see us playing offense not defense to change the status quo in positive ways, given the assets we have, and move ahead while the rest of Upstate New York hangs on by its fingernails. We have a chance to dif-ferentiate ourselves and gain competitive advantage over the rest of Upstate. We can be the next Ithaca or Sara-toga.

Discussing that promise can hardly be a bad idea. In my judgment, it is the responsibility of elected of-ficials to do so. I hope that you will join with me to that end.

Wood, Lusins, Otsego Ready-Mix Funded Consolidation Study A-7THURSDAY-FRIDAY, APRIL 12-13, 2012

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL A-8THURSDAY, APRIL 12, 2012

Cricket Keto • Assoc. Broker , 287.8458Lizabeth Rose • Broker, 287.1500John Mitchell • Lic. Assoc. BrokerStephen Baker, Lic. Assoc. Broker

Peter D. Clark, Consultant

Spacious and Bright this four bedroom home features hardwood floors, Chestnut woodwork with beautiful french doors that lead into

the living room, along with some built in book shelves and replacement windows. Located in center city Oneonta, this home is

close to elementary school, parks and downtown.Listing #: 83819, $139,000

locally owned & operatedsingle & multi-family homes, commercial

property & land

oneontarealty.comoffice 441.7312 • fax 432.7580 • 99 Main St Oneonta

Home of the Week

Annual Percentage Rate (APR) accurate as of 3/6/2012 and is subject to change without notice. Subject to credit approval. While other promotional rates are currently being offered, loan must be secured and be in the best credit score pricing tier to receive the best rate. Not available for loans secured by a mobile home, for the refinance of existing Community Bank, N.A. debt, or for debt consolidation for financial relief. Example: A $10,000, 36-month, fixed-rate installment loan requires monthly payments of $293.43 (assuming 30 days to first payment, no insurance was purchased, and no lien protection fees were added). Minimum loan size is $2,000. Smaller payments, longer terms, alternative rates and other unsecured options are available.

A loan to make ‘that’ happen.We have a loan for that!

Everyone has that one thing they dream about doing, only if

they had the money. Well we’ve got money to lend. And our

loan comes with an attractive rate and a level of personal

service bound to put a smile on anyone’s face. To learn more

about our personal loans, visit your local branch today. And

Bank Happy.

PERSONAL LOANSSPECIAL

FOR 36 MONTHS3.59%

APR

COB DIL ad_ 9.324 w x6h _non bleed_BW

www.communitybankna.com

locally owned & operatedsingle & multi-family homes, commercial property & land

oneontarealty.com

office 441.7312 • fax 432.758099 Main St Oneonta

OTSEGO LAKE COTTAGEeast side-2 bedroom open livingspace 100 feet shared frontage-winterized-only

$149,000

John Mitchell, Lic. Assoc. Broker

(843) 457-3968

Lovely family home in park-like setting; woods, stream, and pond great

for outdoor activity. Newly constructed two car garage ideal for a shop or to park

your extra toys. Just minutes from

Cooperstown.Listing #: 82914, $349,000

ASHLEY CONNORREALTY

29 Pioneer St., Cooperstown, NY 607-547-4045

Patricia Ashley – Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner

Visit us on the Web at www.ashleyconnorrealty.com • Contact us at info@ashleyconnorrealty.comFor APPoiNtmeNt: Patti Ashley, Broker, 544-1077 • Jack Foster, Sales Agent, 547-5304 •

Nancy Angerer, Sales Agent, 435-3387 Donna Skinner, Associate Broker, 547-8288 • Amy Stack, Licensed Sales Agent, 435-0125

In the hillside above Van Hornesville, just 3 ½ hours from NYC, this early 1960’s home was the first

large commission for well known architect, Willis N. Mills, Jr. and was featured in Record Houses of

1967 as well as July 1965 House Beautiful. Built as a family compound, the property consists of the main house offering open living space with loft

areas over the living and dining rooms, library and large kitchen space with play area at one end. An end wing houses the master suite as well as three

other bedrooms and a full bath. The living room has a cement wall fireplace and vaulted ceiling with an upper “quiet” or reading area. Vertical windows take

in the surrounding countryside and offer perfect light for artists. The entire home is built of wood, block

and glass with hardwood and tiled floors throughout. In excellent condition, little has been changed since its’ 1960’s conception. Behind the house, in its’ own private location, is a guest house. A living room with fireplace as well as a kitchen form the center of this charming bonus house, with two guest wings consisting of two bedrooms with a full bath at either end. An attached two-car garage is off the back

of this building. At the beginning of the private drive is the original barn (red, of course) and a stocked pond with a small dock is perfect for swimming and fishing. At the bottom of the hill is sweet Van Hornesville, in its creek side setting with its’ mill pond center. This property

offers 80+- acres of open fields, yards, deep woods, light woods, apple orchards, and plenty of open lawn space for play and gardens. This is truly a step back into another era in a peaceful, tranquil, get-away setting. Offered Exclusively by Ashley-Connor Realty $549,000

A Most UnUsUAl offering

DOTTIE GEBBIAAssociate Broker

607-547-8927

ROBERT SchnEIDERSales Associate

607-547-1887

AMY TOWnSEnDAssociate Broker

607-547-5862

BARBARA LAMBAssociate Broker

607-547-9445

DOnnA ThOMSOnBroker/Owner 607-547-5023

http://www.lambrealty.net • E-mail: dontho@telenet.net

Out Ahead of the Flock!LAMB REALTY20 Chestnut St., Cooperstown, NY Tel/Fax 607-547-8145

547-1884

DOTTIE GEBBIAAssociate Broker

607-547-8927435-2192547-8145

realestate@lambrealty.net

Incredible views from every window in this three bedroom custom cape

with 435’ of waterfront. This 3000 plus square foot home on one and a half acres was stick built in 2000 and offers large rooms with a great flow for entertaining. Chefs kitchen, with stainless appliances and commercial range, has

granite counter tops and was recently up-dated and expanded, formal living and dining rooms with hardwood floors, large family

room opens to a flagstone patio, two gas fireplaces and large covered veranda facing the lake. There are three outbuildings including a heated two-car garage that does double duty as a

guest house. The grounds are completely landscaped with terraced stone walls and walks leading from the house to the lakefront with it’s 100’ aluminum dock. Suitable

for year-round or summer use, the house has central heat supplied by propane and a full deep basement. Completely insulated with Thermopane windows throughout. Exterior treatments

include vinyl siding and field stone, black top drive, all in excellent condition. Just twenty minuets to Cooperstown. A Lamb Realty exclusive: 695,000. Listing # L-035

“Heron Cove” DramatiC CanaDrago Lakefront Home

CHARTOCK/A7a New York tabloid who did more to destroy Mario Cuomo’s career than anyone else. In fact, it might be said that this guy was largely responsible for the senior Cuomo’s relatively narrow defeat.

Nevertheless, from the moment Papa Cuomo lost and Andrew’s star was in the ascendency, a deal was struck with that very reporter who had politically murdered the father. This story is illus-trative of Andrew’s apparent conviction that political bed fellows change and people can usually be won over.

Many of us don’t know what we sound like. Andrew has a distinct Queens ac-cent. Lots of folks tell me that he sounds exactly like his father. I have always maintained that he doesn’t sound like Mario, but that his style of speaking comes more from his lovely mother, Matilda. That makes sense; Matilda raised Andrew and his siblings while Papa was out doing politics.

In the case of Andrew’s speech, the governor has a defined liability. In New York, Andrew’s speech is, well, acceptable. I was recently talking to Times Union editor Rex Smith, who originally hails from South Dakota. He told me that George McGovern was so conscious of his accent that he took speech lessons.

I believe Andrew’s accent will be a turn off for most of this country. In fact, I suspect that George McGovern’s speech problems would be far less insulting to the ears of Manhattan dwellers than Andrew’s thick Queens brogue would be to the folks in South Dakota.

This is where Andrew’s self-knowledge becomes so important. Clearly, he has enough insight to get it. I have been listening to Andrew’s public utterances and he is beginning to sound more and more like King George. I suspect, but can-not prove, that he is getting speech coaching. He’s still dropping consonants at the end of words, but his words are coming out softer.

Of course, we don’t know who is helping Andrew with his speech. He may be prac-ticing in front of a mirror. Maybe his girlfriend, Sandra Lee, is helping him, or it could be his brother, Chris, the TV news guy. Maybe it’s one of the actors or direc-tors with whom the Cuomo’s hobnob at the 21 Club. We’ll just have to wait for the movie release to find out.

This could be the start of something big. I wonder if Shelly Silver will be next. I hope not, I love his accent.

Alan Chartock is president of WAMC, which broad-

casts locally on 99.3 FM in Oneonta and 97.3 FM in

Cooperstown.

GovernorWorks OnNY Patois

A-9THURSDAY-FRIDAY, APRIL 12-13, 2012

SPRINGFIELD TRACTOR & IMPLEMENT LLCCORNERS RTE. 20 & RTE. 80 • SPRINGFIELD, NY 13468

(315) 858-2578

SERVICE • KNOWLEDGE • SELECTION FINANCING • DELIVERY

You’re Invited To Our

OPEN HOUSEApril 14, 2012

8am - 3pm Fun • Food

Factory Reps

AllOTSEGO.life B-9THURSDAY-FRIDAY, APRIL 12-13, 2012

AllOTSEGO.auto

Steve Scoville Jim Meno

Family of DealershipsOwego • Bainbridge • Sidney • Oneonta

* Payments based upon 3.9% for 72 months with $1,500 downpayment.

MSRP $29,775auto, cruisesapphire, power sliding doors

S-M PRICE$26,999

$439*per mos.

2012 Chrysler T & C Touring

MSRP $37,775sagebrush pearl,remote start,bedliner,bighorn package

S-M PRICE$32,999

$549*per mos.

2012 RAM Quad Cab SLT

MSRP $27,910stock # p2009tungsten grey,3.6L V6

S-M PRICE$24,999

2012 Dodge Charger

2012 Chrysler 200 SMSRP $28,405

Lthr heated seats,sunroof, Black

S-M PRICE$24,499

$399*per mos.

2012 Dodge Caliber SXTMSRP $19,840

stock # c2006auto

S-M PRICE$17,999

$289*per mos.

2009 Chrysler T&C Touring-Lstock #2573A

Certified Pre-Owned,

Lthr. Sts., DVD,Pwr. Liftgate

ONLY$19,999

$319*per mos.

2007 Jeep WranglerJUST ARRIVED!

stock # 25RACertified

Pre-Owned,14k miles, auto,

soft top

ONLY$18,999

$299*per mos.D

rivingSmarter...There’smoneytobesavedat

DrivingSmarter...There’smoneytobesav

ed atDriving Smarter... There’s money to be saved at

DrivingSmarter...

There’smoneytobesavedat

DrivingSmarter...

There’smoneytobesaved

loyalty where applicable - must own ‘99 or newer Chrysler product. Must qualify for payments - $1,500 down plus tax and tag fees.

18 Union St. • Sidney • NY607-561-7500

100’s of PRE-OWNED VEHICLES TO CHOOSE FROM!COME SEE US, WE’RE HERE TO HELP!

taxes & fees extra • facility #7073344

COME & SEE OUR SALES & LEASING PROFESSIONALS TODAY!www.scovillemenohonda.com

OPEN FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE: mon. thues. & thurs. 9am-7:30pm • wed. & fri. 9am-5:30pm • sat. 9am-5pmwww.scovillemeno.com

KevinJones

AnthonyGrigoli

KenLorenz

Service Manager

BobHaywood

COME & SEE OUR SALES & LEASING PROFESSIONALS TODAY!lease signing, tax and tags extra. All traditional finance payments based upon $1500 down for 72 months.

DrivingSmarter...there’smoneytobesavedatSco

vil

le-M

eno

Driv

ing

Sm

arte

r...

th

ere

’sm

on

ey

tob

e saved at Scoville-Meno Driving Smarter....there’s money to be

sa

ve

da

tSco

ville-M

eno

Driv

ing

Sm

arte

r...th

ere

’sm

on

ey

tob

esa

ve

da

tSco

ville-M

eno

Driv

ing

Sm

arte

r...th

ere

’s

Steve Scoville Jim Meno

65 Oneida St. • Oneonta • NY607-433-1251

100’s of PRE-OWNED VEHICLES TO CHOOSE FROM!COME SEE US, WE’RE HERE TO HELP!

taxes & fees extra • facility #7073344

COME & SEE OUR SALES & LEASING PROFESSIONALS TODAY!www.scovillemenohonda.com

OPEN FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE: mon. tues. & thurs. 9am-7:30pm • wed. & fri. 9am-5:30pm • sat. 9am-5pm

HondaFamily of Dealerships

Owego • Bainbridge • Sidney • Oneonta

39 MPG HWY**

$239*per mos.

36 mos, 36k miles

Lease For:

2012 Honda Civic LX SEDAN

0% Due At Lease SigningFirst PaymentIncluded!

8% Sales TaxIncluded!

Estimated License, Registration, and Acquisition fees

Included!Security Deposit

Waived!MSRP $22,950stock # 12151auto, pwr. eqp., cruise,CD Player

34 MPG HWY**

$249*per mos.

36 mos, 36k miles

Lease For:

2012 Honda Accord LX Sedan

MSRP $29,035stock # 12160auto, 7 pass.,cd player

27 MPG HWY**

$339*per mos.

36 mos, 36k miles

Lease For:

2012 Honda Odyssey LXALL MODELS IN STOCK NOW!

ALL NEW 2012 Honda CRV

MSRP $19,425stock # 12271auto, cruisepwr. eqp.CD Player

READY FOR IMMEDIATE DELIVERY!

IN STOCK NOWALL NEW 2012 Honda Fits

...AND MORE ON THE WAYRESERVE YOURS TODAY!

0.9% up to 36 months

1.9% from 37 to 60 monthsfor all qualifying buyers on Civics, Accords, Crosstours, Odysseys, Pilots and Ridgelines

**Based on 2012 EPA mileage estimates. Use for comparison purposes only. Do not compare to models before 2008. Your actual mileage will vary depending on how you drive and maintain your vehicle

dignity • tradition • continuityTillapaugh Funeral home

(607) 547-257128 pioneer St., CooperStown

Serving AreAFAmilieS Since 1888

George M. Tillapaugh (1888-1913) • Revo & Anna Tillapaugh (1913-1958)

Our new chapelcomfortably seats over 200

Our historic Family room provides additional seating

George G. & Marjorie Tillapaugh (1935-1988) • Martin H. Tillapaugh (1988-Present)

Proud To be Oneonta’s OnlyFamily Owned Funeral Home

~ 51 Dietz Street, Oneonta 607-432-1511 ~ www.lhpfuneralhome.com

“Our family is committed to providing you with a personal as well as professional level of service, and still maintain affordability”

-John & Kathleen Pietrobono

ONEONTA – Mary Crain, 96, formerly of Port-landville and Cooperstown, passed away Monday, April 2, 2012, at Otsego Manor.

She was born May 22, 1915, in Johnstown, Pa., the daughter of Louis and Agnes (Friend) Gorence, who had immigrated from Yugoslavia.

She moved with her family to Cooperstown, and married Leslie H. Crain on Jan. 5, 1935, in Sche-nectady. They had two sons, Leslie and Richard and moved back to Cooperstown in 1964.

She and her husband moved to Portlandville after retirement where she remained until, with failing vision, she lived with her son in Naples, Fla. Mary returned to this area in April 2007.

Ms. Crane was known for her “poteca,” a Slovanian

yeast bread. She was an avid reader and enjoyed knitting, crocheting, and cross stitch. She participated in a bowl-ing league for many years. She was also a member of the Pocahontas club in Coo-perstown.

She was predeceased by her husband, both sons, and

brothers, Robert, John and Frank Gorence.

Survivors include her daughter-in-law, Doris Crain Howard of Cooperstown; grandchildren, great-grand-children and a nephew and niece.

Contributions in Mary’s memory may be made to

the Catskill Area Hospice & Palliative Care, 1 Birch-wood Drive, Oneonta NY 13820.

Services will be private at the convenience of the family.

Arrangements were entrusted to the Ottman Funeral Home.

David M. Hribar, 81, Tended Both St. Mary’s CemeteriesOBITUARIES

COOPERSTOWN – Da-vid Matthew Hribar, 81, a native of the Cooperstown and Fly Creek areas, passed away Friday morning, April 6, 2012, following a long illness.

Born Jan. 6, 1931, in Fly Creek Valley, he was the son of Anton J. and Anna Belle (Pope) Hribar. He he attended a one-room schoolhouse in Taylortown and later went to school in Richfield Springs.

In April 1948, Mr. Hribar enlisted in the Navy and served on the USS Albany during the Korean War. He was honorably discharged in April 1952.

On Oct. 28, 1952, he married Elizabeth Bachanas. They moved to Ilion, where he worked at Remington Arms, returning in 1955 to Fork Shop. Mr. Hribar worked in St. Mary’s Cem-etery, both on Irish Hill and Index, as well as for West-ern Auto and the Leather-stocking Golf Course.

Survivors include his wife of 60 years, Betty; their five children, David M. Hribar, Jr. of Palmer, Alaska, Diane M. Hribar of Fork Shop, Terri Smith and her husband, Victor, of Pierstown, Keith Hribar and his friend, Kim Stahl, Fly Creek Valley, and Melissa

Madaras and her husband, Andy, of Richfield Springs; nine grandchildren, Heather, Jason, Cady and Rebecca Smith, Kody and Kimberly Hribar, Jamie Madaras and Kenneth and Wade Stahl; five great-grandchildren, Emily, Hannah, Bo and Arro Bancroft and Amelia Stokes.

He is also survived by one sister, Carolyn Hopper of Richfield Springs; two brothers, Walter J. Hribar and his wife, Polly, of Rich-field Springs and Dean A. Hribar and his wife, Barb, of Schuyler Lake and many nieces and nephews.

He was predeceased on Feb. 11, 1994, by one grand-

son, Matthew Hribar.A graveside service will

be at 11 a.m. Thursday, April 12, at the Fly Creek Valley Cemetery, with Rev. Betsy Jay, Bassett chaplain, officiating. Military honors will be accorded.

Memorial donations may be made to Catskill Area Hospice & Palliative Care, 1 Birchwood Drive, Oneonta, NY 13820 or the Fly Creek Emergency Squad, Box 218, Fly Creek, NY 13337 or the Cooperstown Emergency Squad, Box 322, Cooper-stown, NY 13326.

Arrangements are entrust-ed to the Connell, Dow & Deysenroth Funeral Home.

Mary Crain, 96, Known For Her ‘Poteca,’ Yugoslavian Bread

A-10 THURSDAY-FRIDAY, APRIL 12-13, 2012

Advertise in AllOTSEGO.

homes CALL AMAndA At 547-6103 the region’s

LArgest reAL-estAte

seCtion.

AllOTSEGO.homes

4914 St. Hwy 28, CooperStown (607) 547-593328 oneida Street, oneonta (607) 433-1020 Available exclusively by RealtyUSA.com

Through The Rain Day Foundation H.E.L.P Program

MLS#83229 - Business opportunity to own piece of Cooperstown. Your very own motel only minutes to the National

Baseball Hall of Fame, Fenimore Art Museum, Farmers Museum, or Dreams Park. Nine renovated & fully furnished units featuring flat screen tv’s, newer carpeting, beds, & bedding. Newer roof, windows and paint as well. Seperate office & laundry room with a complete water filtration system. Great investment potential.

Come take a look. $299,000 Call Chris @ (607) 376-1201

MLS#82430 - Charming Greek Revival home featuring 4 bedrms & 2 ba. This home is located in the Hamlet of Westville. Lrg wood stove located in the den. Gorgeous views from the front

or side porch. Owner is motivated to sell & the furnishings can be negotiated. Beautiful Historic Greek Revival w/lots of rm for

growth. $138,000 Call Jim Vrooman @ (603) 247-0506

MLS#83632 - CLASSIC SEASONAL CAMP...FURNISHED. Knotty pine walls, fieldstone fireplace, lg covered porch overlooking

Canadarago Lake with 15’ right of way. $149,000 Call Rod & Barb @ (315) 520-6512

NEW LISTING-MLS#83535 - A great starter home. New carpeting, beautiful hardwood floors, & newly painted. A lovely sloping back yard that leads to Oaks Creek. What a great place to raise your family. Move your furniture in & take the family on

a picnic right in your own back yard, perfect! $159,900 Call Donna @ 607-267-3232

MLS#83178 - Amazing investment! Over $150k of updates and renovations. Income potential galore! Make your appointment

today! Call David at 607-435-4800 for more information.MLS#83687 - CANADARAGO LAKE RIGHTS, VIEWS & 2+ acres

of peace and tranquility. 2,000sq ft modular home with fireplaces, party barn and lg detached garage. $245,000

Call Rod & Barb @ (315) 520-6512

MLS#83628 - BEAUTIFUL RAISED RANCH WITH CURB APPEAL! CORIAN Countertop, 3 bedroom, 2 bath home. $179,000

Call CAROL OLSEN @ 607-434-7436

MLS#83523 - Year round Lakefront living at a fantastic price! A UNIQUE PROPERTY on Goodyear Lake! 5 acres plus, zoned residential & commercial. This very spacious home has many recent updates & has been tastefully renovated. A great year

round home or a wonderful family retreat. $189,900.00 Call Donna @ 607-267-3232

MLS#81221 - Beautifully maintained 3 bed 2 bath home in beautiful Fly Creek. Full finished walk out lower level, oversized garage with work shop and walk up loft for crafts or hobbies all

on almost 2 acres with a stream out back. $199,000 Call Chris @ (607) 376-1201

MLS #83328 - Location is Everything! 3br,2full baths, hrdwd floors, lrg dining, kitchen. Roof 6 mos old, deck, enclosed porch.

Near both colleges. Make appt. now. $148,000.00 Call Linda (607) 434-2125

MLS#82983 - PRICED TO SELL! 3 bedroom, 2 bath RANCH HOME IS MOVE-IN READY. CLOSE TO ONEONTA, SIDNEY AND HAS IT ALL. $159,900 CALL CAROL OLSEN @ 607-434-7436

MLS#81815 - ENDLESS POSSIBILITIES in beautiful Bovina! 3-bed, 2-bath farmhouse and an historic 3500 square foot,

two-story storefront building - all on over eight acres in a charming hamlet of Delaware County. Call David at

607-435-4800 for more information.

MLS#81458 - Fantastic location for Schools, Parks and Downtown. This cozy three bedroom features new paint and hardwood floors. Easy to maintain Priced right at $124,900

Call Adam Karns 607-244-9633

MLS#79845 - Country Bliss perfect for hunting, recreational use or farmette. Move-in condition 4 bedrm 1 ½ bath home located only 6 miles from

Cooperstown. Home offers a lrg layout downstairs including a grand family rm, an eat-in kitchen w/dining area & a formal dining rm. Warm up & relax in

the living rm w/nice corner wood fireplace. Upstairs a lrg inviting hallway w/3 bedrms a ½ bath. Outside gorgeous views of the pond & apple orchard from a nice sized back deck. Lrg barn for animals or storage. Come view this gorgeous country home on nearly 20 acres. Additional 32+/- acres available across road.

Ask agent for details. $198,000 Call Kristi Ough @ (607) 376-1201

NEW LISTING-MLS#83519 - Home offers privacy of ½ mile road frontage. 4 bedrm, 2 bath home features: lrg kitchen, formal

dining, cozy living rm w/fireplace, bay window & beautiful hardwood flrs throughout. Upstairs 4 bedrms, 1 bedrm has private upstairs play area. Master bedrm w/private balcony

overlooking the inground pool & pond. Bluestone walkway leads to back deck & private fenced in ground pool w/pool house &

½ bath. A picture perfect dollhouse for the kids w/upstairs loft & grapevined gazebo. Pond w/koi fish. Lrg barn offers rm for

animals or storage. $269,900 Call Kristi Ough @ (607) 434-3026

MLS#82197 - Beautiful country setting for relaxed living. Owner financing available, close to Stamford and near Oneonta.

$74,000 Call Adam Karns 607-244-9633

MLS#82720 - Location! 3br, close to school, shopping. Situated on a nice corner lot and with some TLC would make a

great starter home. Owner needs to find suitable housing. Come take a look! $90,000 Call Linda @ (607) 434-2125

MLS#83326 - Located in the center of Schuyler Lake this warm & inviting home has passed the test of time. W/3 bedrms & 2 baths

this well maintained home is in move in condition. The home sits on a lrg level lot w/a 16x30 carriage house & a 42x34 barn. Enjoy your

evening on the lrg covered porch. $139,900 Call Jim Vrooman @ (603) 247-0506

PRICE

REDUCED!

PRICE

REDUCED!

PRICE

REDUCED!

PRICE

REDUCED!

for complete listings visit us at realtyusa.com

Lizabeth Rose, Broker/Owner Cricket Keto, Lic. Assoc.BrokerJohn Mitchell, Lic. Assoc. Broker Stephen Baker,Lic. Assoc. BrokerPeter D. Clark, Consultant

locally owned & operatedsingle & multi-family homes, commercial property & land

oneontarealty.com

office 441.7312 • fax 432.758099 Main St Oneonta • oneontarealty.com

4-BR, 2-BATH village charmer with new roof, thermal windows, pellet stove, enclosed front porch, large yard, more!! $98,900 #83342

MUST SEE!! Well maintained home in city of Oneonta close to schools downtown and parks. This home has 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths with family room, den and room for an office plus the dining and living room. $99,000 #83736

Union Street!

Attractive Oneonta, 4 bedroom, 2 1/2 bath Tudor with lots of living space. The first floor offers formal

living & dining rooms, a sunroom/den & a wonderful kitchen open to the family room. The kitchen has oak

cabinets & corian counters. First floor laundry & a 1/2 bath. Upstairs there are 4 bedrooms & 2 baths including the large master bedroom suite with

walk-in closet and full bath. The basement level has a family room & office. Outside there is a private

patio area & level yard. $179,000. MLS#83650

(607) 547-5740 • (607) 547-6000 (fax)157 Main Street,

Cooperstown, NY 13326E-Mail Address: info@hubbellsrealestate.com

Visit Our Web Site at www.hubbellsrealestate.com

OtsegO Lake Views On 16+ acres(7564) Settle serenely in this secluded 4BR/2BA

Ranch-style with a lake view on property. Touches in this comfortable residence include main-level master

bedroom, modern kitchen with oak cabinets, Light and airy floorplan, private den, vaulted ceilings. Skylight,

hardwood flooring, laundry room, perennial and vegetable gardens. Many charms to cherish!

Cooperstown Schools. Hubbell’s Exclusive. $150,000

OtsegO LakefrOnt Year-rOund!

HUBBELL’S REAL ESTATE

Cooperstown Otsego Lake Lot (7184) Lake View vistas! Last of the lake lots in the Village with 138’ of private lake frontage. Village

water & sewer hook-ups. Good road access. Once in a lifetime opportunity to build the house

of your dreams. Cooperstown Schools.Hubbell’s Exclusive $600,000

(7546) Nearly-new 3BR/2BA with 50’ of lakefront and wide-span views. Enchanting features, including butternut flooring, hand hewn beamed ceilings, ceramic tile baths.

Custom kitchen with oak cabinets, Fireside benefits. Welcoming 1 bedroom separate guest house, Large view deck w/ hot tub, Boat house w/ elec., 300 gal fuel tank, 2 boat lifts, dock for 9 boats, concrete pier. parking for 4 cars. Cooperstown Schools. A gracious setting and so

much more! Hubbell’s Exclusive $675,000

1799 federaL Brick estate(7447) Historic Center Hall Federal brick residence only

6 miles from Cooperstown. Nestled on 16 acres with spectacular valley views. Extensive gardens and small spring fed pond surround this 3-4BR home. Original

smokehouse and carriage barn. Spacious Living room w/ Fireplace and Dining room with built-ins, updated country kitchen, newer furnace, Newer roof. A total

of 3 fireplaces, Library nook, wine cellar, and original millwork complete this unique country estate.

Hubbell’s Exclusive. $499,000

charming near cOOperstOwn(7550) Live comfortably in this well-maintained

4BR/3BA Ranch-type featuring country scenery on 1.80 acres. Offering cathedral beamed ceilings, great

room, finished basement. Spacious floorplan, main-level master bedroom w/jacuzzi. Eat-in Kitchen w/oak cabinets, laundry room. Energy efficient, Two-car

garage, 12x24 workshop, decks. Tiered deck. Be sure to see this delightful home just 2 1/2 miles from

Cooperstown! Cooperstown Schools Hubbell’s Exclusive. $225,000

cOOperstOwn ViLLage hOme(7504) A delightful discovery near Clark Sports Center, shops, & schools. Make a great move to this spotless, tastefully remodeled 3BR/2+BA home. Ideal features

include walk-up attic suite, oak flooring and ceramic tile baths. Secluded den, newer windows, newer kitchen with oak cabinets and cork flooring. Formal dining room. Nice private yard, Newer siding, Deck, Front porch. Reflecting

pride of place! Hubbell’s Exclusive. $299,900

Main Street Cooperstown(6447) Business block on Main Street. Four 2 BR apartments. 2 commercial spaces. 2,500 sq ft total commercial space. New windows, new hot water

furnace. Storage space in cellar. Well-kept stone and brick building. Good income producer.

Hubbell’s Exclusive $595,000

Welcome to Deerfoot Farm! Situated on 96 acres, this colonial farmhouse has the charm of yesteryear with the convenience of today. Two ponds,

stream, open fields and a view from the front patio of Otsego Lake; there

is a second stone patio in the rear of the house. The house features a

generous entry, large living room with a fireplace and a bow window with a window seat that overlooks the lake.

A formal dining room, large kitchen, office space, full bath and a large den with a

woodstove and a wet bar complete the first floor. Upstairs, lovely MBR with full bath,

dressing area, walk-in closets. There is also a one bedroom suite with a

full bath and a second bedroom. Wide pine floors throughout the house. Nestled snugly

in the woods is a writer’s cottage. There is also large, renovated barn with silo and a three car attached garage. Two ponds, fields, woods and views in all directions

complete the picture. The house is located very near to Glimmerglass Opera, the

Cooperstown Theater festival and Route 20. The Village of Cooperstown is but a short drive along the scenic Lake Road. This property is definitely a must see!

Don Olin37 Chestnut st., Cooperstown • phone: 607-547-5622 • Fax: 607-547-5653

www.donolinrealty.com PARKING IS NEVER A PROBLEM

Make yourself at home on our website, www.donolinrealty.com, for listings and information on unique and interesting properties.We'll bring you home!

For Appointment Only Call:M. Margaret Savoie – Broker/Owner – 547-5334Marion King – Associate Broker – 547-5332Don Olin – Associate Broker – 547-8782Eric Hill – Associate Broker – 547-5557Don DuBois – Associate Broker – 547-5105Tim Donahue – Associate Broker – 293-8874Cathy Raddatz – Sales Associate – 547-8958Jacqueline Savoie -Sales Associate -547-4141Carol Hall - Sales Associate -544-4144

Don OlinREALTY

Make yourself at Home on our website http://www.donolinrealty.com for listings and information on unique and interesting properties. We'll bring you Home!

CHOOSE A SKILLED NEGOTIATOROne of the ways in which a real estate professional can help

you in the sale of your home is in handling the delicate negotiations that usually occur when homes change hands. Even more than in other forms of real estate transactions,

personalities can play an important part. Your agent is accustomed to working out the details of negotiations,

serving as a “go-between” in areas that might be difficult for the principals in the transactions to discuss. You are spared from myriad details

which can be time-consuming and confusing. Negotiation is a skill acquired with patience and training; the right agent will have both.

Deerfoot FarmExclusively offered at $875,000.

Real Estate Corner: A Weekly Message

For reliable, honest answers to any of your real estatequestions, Don Olin Realty at 607.547.5622or visit our website www.donlinrealty.com

AUTO • HOME • LIFEBUSINESS

Since 1947, our personal service has

always beenthere when you need

it most. With comprehensive

coverage for all your

insurance needs.

Hours: M-F 8am-5pm Phone: 607-432-2022

22-26 Watkins Ave, Oneonta, NY 13820

KevinKurKowsKi

31 Pioneer Street, Cooperstown(directly next door to Stagecoach Coffee)

Registered Mortgage Broker Matt Schuermann NYS Banking Dept.Loans arranged by a 3rd party lender.

LGROUP@STNY.RR.COM www.leatherstockingmortgage.com

607-547-5007 (Office) 800-547-7948 (Toll Free)

New Purchases and refinances • Debt Consolidation Free Pre-Qualification • Fast Approvals • Low Rates

Thinking of Remodeling?Think of Refinancing!