the bolsheviks and workers control

8/3/2019 The Bolsheviks and Workers Control

1/59

----


2/59

592

].]Maurice Brinton ,The Bolsheviks and Workers' Control ,-1970)E.6,123 ; ('' -

,48202,,,9546",]']Red&Black '--1975-1972 ."

, - ,- , ,

. , . ,

( , ,

Left-Wing Communism: An Infantile Disorder , : -

. ).

,[ ] - .

:

. , '- '-- ,'national economy,nation-wide -

."'-', '' ,"'', ''

subcommittee ,''-''- -commissioncommittee-.'-'-

.''- deputy-'- coherent- '.

.' '- ' '- piece work- ' , ' ,''-

''' . ,- (4 ( 1917-1921 :'

.-100 .''-''--agitatoragitation-.''-''--provincedistrict-

: ,

',1921'28-',1918'-46-4837-40- -.

. - -.


3/59

593

' '

' . . ]1970[ ',

. , ,

') (.'' ]1970[ . ) ('

' ' . ].-20[ , ,

,]-labour[ ''- - - ''- -

. .' ' ' ' - -

, , . , , ' '

.

. , .' ',

. , , ) (

, .' ' ,- ,-

.

( . ) ( ,'management'-'control' ,)

. - , --gerencia,kontrolia-gestion,control)controle ,

upravleniye( ]domination[ .. -

) ( . , .

, ).', , ( ( . -]]revocable-

. , , , ) , ',', ' '

' '-. . .) (

, - . ) (

, . , . , , , , ''.

, . .

.- , ,- ,) (

, '-' '',1961. - '', ', ' '-

.-


4/59

594

. , - .- .

. . . ,

.-- , ),,(,- .

. . ,-,

, '-19211917 .

1921-1917".- '- ''

, , ."1 . ,

, ,. (-, . , .

, - )-

( . ' '-' ' ),) (

). (

. . ' ' , ( ,,

' ')' '''- , :' ' , - .

( -- -,)

,

, .2

-. . - , . .

. ),1917-1921( . ,

- - )-(-1917 , ,-,.

--, .-- . ,

- ( 50' - . )

. ,, .'- '-'' )' ,,(''

.' . , ,

- ''' ' , ) (-SPGB.3

, ) (-SPGB

.


5/59

595

, . ,.,,, ', '

- . 1917-1921 - )''('' '''

, , , .

. .''

) ( . -

( . ? ).

? ( ?

? ,) '?' ,

. -

' ' ' ' -- ,,,( .- ).,

,) ( ","? ","? "

' ' ,,. .',"? .' ' )-1921-1920(

) ( ,,. ?

, - ) ( ,. .

. ) , ( '',

: , ' ' . - - .

, , ,-.

.

' ' . - .

. . ' ' , ,

- . . .

, )-,-( .

( - . ) ,

. , , .

.4

. .5 .

- 1917 .

). : ( ) ( . ( .


6/59

596

. . ) .

,,? - - . .

,

. -/- " " ,.

, .- -. ,

- , ' '- . - .' '

-- '' ' , ''- . )( .'

''- , , -. ' '-

. ','- ,

- -''- . , .''

. ,

. , 1917 ,

, , . , - , .

'' .'' ). ( , ,' '

.

? .

-)'' -', ' ', ' '( ,)' ,, (

. -].-20 [ ,

.6 ) (

.

, . ":

--, ,,]]consipracy . - . , , , . ,

, , , . - -, ' ', '. .

'".7

" . -1905 . -

, . - : ,]]Broue".8 ,

" ,

, , ".9 ,


7/59

597

. . .10

.' ' : '' , ''- ,1905 , .

.

.1917 '.11 ' ', ' ,

. ''.-1917 -1905 " " , ?

) ( . ,- ,

", "-". . ,

".12 .

.1917

. . . . .-

. . , ,

. . ,.

. , 1917 - - . - -1917

.-19211918 . ) - (

, .

, - . -

','-''- ,. ,

" - , ,-',' ."

. ,

. ,-1917 ,-

. - . ,,

. - , )- (

- , .- ,

, , . ,

, . . ,

: . ( . ?

, , ) =.

) ( -1917

, , . - . . - , .


8/59

598

. .

' '. , .

, . , , "

, , , ,- ', ' ." .1917 -

. ' '- .

, ,.-19211917 ,. .

, , - .

.'- '

, , ,, , ,

.- , ''-. ,,,,,

- , , .

. , , . . , .

- .

"" , .- -- . ,." ",-,. ) (''-

'' . ,- (

[ ,).'', . ]1970

, 1917 . ,][

.'81;,1960 ,]]The Conscience of the Revolution ,..,]]Daniels1[-]]Coats.,. . 2

Topham[" ' ' - ")(!" ,

] ""]socialized '- ', ." (

).'363;]Kee[,1968]]MacGibbon,]]Industrial Democracy in Great Britain ]Nineteen- - - --- 3

Seventeen[]Voline[, ]Freedom Press[,1954:" , , ., , . .

." . ,]]Les rapports de production en Russie 4

]Chaulieu[,2)-1949( . '',

": )1890]Schmidt) [27 . , . , , - ,

,-(." - )'504-505;


9/59

599

5]Notes pour une analyse ,

de la Revolution Russe (n.d.)[, '.]J. Barrot) [ ' ']Librarie 'La Viellie

Taupe'[,'--']Fosses-St. Jacque[5,,.(6

) , - : ( .-19171901,).,190510)25 .'61;,1947,]]Stalin,.7.'64-65;,.89,,]]Editions de Minuit ,]]Histoire du Parti Bolshevik ,.

.'35;196310

- ", , .

]The Prophet ,.(" -,

Armed[,OUP,1954;'76.(11

. ,.

12.'441', ;,


10/59

5910

1 9 1 7

,. . .1905 , . ,

27

).- ( .-II

,1- - - ,.

.

. . -

, : - , ",* "". ".2

10

. . ''- -8 ,

-8 " ,-14 . ." ,

.

. ,- , -8 , ''-

.

2 .

' , ' , .: 5-7.

"( " ).' , ,,

) ( "

, , , " , "3

. -1919 *-1952.

- ) .-1957 ).

, . , :

.

-,"",".

." "!)(",


11/59

5911

7

.- , ' ' ":8

."

23

, ''- . " "- .

. -

23 ,-, ". , , - ,- ,

".4 ,

23

, , ": )' ' (

-" " - " ."

." 5

," "-" "-

- . ',, , ":." "

, - - ".6 -

1917

. ' ' -,-, , --8 - .''- ,-

.

. '' ,

17

( ( , " ".7 , ,

20

, ": . ,

,-- , . - ."

"- ) (- "- ' ' ".8 "

. ),(

29

. ." " .

, , ".", , "- ".9 ,

.

530

.


12/59

5912

)( 3 ,]]Tauride ". .

- '' , ".10- ,

'- .

.- ', '-' , " . . - , ,." .-

".11 " -- ''- .

.. . , , . .

, , . " ." " "

". , ".12 -

" .' ' , -" ""-

. ( , , .

).

" . ".13 - -

. '' ' '

, " ,-421336 , ." " ."

".14 "-" "-

( . ") - ,

".15

16

. -

20-28

, " ".16 -

." "

" . - "-" , ".17

, ]-[" , .

.

- , - , ' ,' -. ' '

' . - .18 '

,)"( -

.


13/59

5913

. , , . ' '

, . .

.

. ,1917- - )-19 (- .

- - -- ". , ,

. ".19

. , 1917

- , , ,1917 - , ,.*

, :

, , ," .

, .

)( . , . -

) ( ,

, . .

, , -1.5 )(1917 ".-

-1917 , , , , -1905

. ,.- ' '".20 .

-

. -

.

.21 -, -

. ,1922326

[ [.

": ".22

7-12

. ,,

*

' . '' ,-1917 .'

.


14/59

5914

' 0.25% -.23 ',

, . . ' '.' '- , .

, " . " ."

''- " , ,..".24 '".25'-

,!)( , , " " "'.26

." , *. .

. . , , , -

" . "- ."

- "." - !)( , )' ,, ( ' '-."-

" - . ,."-

. ", ." " ." ,

3

. ' ' ,- , ("][ " - -

).1920 -1917

][ -10 "- "- ,5531- ".- - 2000 . . 37

"27 6037 . 11 ,

,- , , " : ,) , (

".28

. . , -"

."

3

, -.

25

,, ":', ' , : . , :

, ,. ,, , , , ,

. . - ,. ,. .

,- , ." - ,- ,

] ;- ,workers and employees [*


15/59

5915

" '15 , , , . , ' ' .

."

, ( : ). , ,

. " . ".29

. . 23''- ".30 ' ' "

28

," "- , ''421 '

)." "( .

, , "-, ".31

.

10

,-4. , .

. ,

. .'' ".

, , ".32

" , , ,".33, , -

. ,

14

' . ' '- . ( 25 , '

.)

26

"." " ."34] [ -

. ,35 100,000 1917,586

. .

1

.? , ".

, ', '


16/59

5916

,* ) ( ." ) ( ,-,-

)' '- (' '- . - "). (

. ''

, , , , ."- , ""," - ,- -"

, , " ".

' '- , . ) - (

) ( - ).', , , , (

. -

,. "

."- ,36

' '- - ) (

. , ) ( , ,

. , , . . ' '.-

10

. . -

13

, , , "- ." , , ,

.- .

. .

, , ". , ,

,- " " .".37

"- . ,

".38 , " . ' '

".39 , , ''- 1917

. ". , , ,

, , , ,, . ."40 . -

*]national [

] [


17/59

5917

. ,

. - , ,

17-22

, - )' '(, "

".41 - ,- ,11",2286 137,

'.42-'-4'',6,8-

,. , , ". ,

. ".43 " - .

".44 -

; " . -": ".45 ,

-- , -- . . , .

" ."".46 , ,

.- ' ' " .

'' ' . '".47

- " '-'-'' ."

".48 "

25] (]People's Commissars- . (

. -

25

. ": , - . . .

. , , , ".49

".50 "

. , .

3

" .51' -' ,, ,,

-10,000 -5 ."

, , " " ."

."-- , ,

, .

. .- " ")5( .


18/59

5918

). (" " :

.

" ")6( -" "." "

, "- )7( ." ) ( ." "-

) ( -. ?- , '

*. ,,

9

.52 ]]Commissariat

. )( - -9.

' ' "

."- 53

14

- - ).(- )(

. , --,:",

, . " ".54

, . - ."

'' -

"55 , -"- -14)( - .

. -15 - ,)10 24 ( , - " " "

"." ".56

.

: -14.57 8 " " "

" . ." "

- ," " . . ".58- "

" ':5'-21 - ."

,5 - ,5 - ,1 ,2 ,2

-2(-100,000 - , ! - -5)-100,000

.' ',-

, - *.-)1967- - /(


19/59

5919

, - " ".59 ,'',

''- ' - ' , : - ', '

.

.- - ". .

- - '' ".60-,,

- , , , ,,.

: " - ', ,, ,

) ( " ."61. ,

.

- . ."

1917-1918 .

- , ' '-. ,

, . , , ,

.

-. ) (

,-

. , , - .

)' ,( ]]modalities.

. . ,

". , 62 , ,

": ." . ,

) (

."- 63

. , ,

"- "- "- . ".64

' .' '- ''- , ? . '

''-'' . .- -. *

*

',(. , - . ' '- ":)77

."


20/59

5920

1917 " -- .

".65 ,

". ".66

. , - ) (

".67'' .'-'-'-' -

. .

28

. --

.68 - , , " .

":, ,'".

,- . , . . " ". ,

." - .

. - , , . .

". ,- 1918 )1918 .(

. ".69 ' ' - ,

- , ,. .

28

.70

5

( 71 ( " " " ."

.72- , , ). ("- "

- . ,) - (

: .' '- ,

(''-. ( (' '-: . (

". ''- ,,,, .73 -

- '' ','('' - .- (

. . ".74 ",-

".75 ,"

, . ,

( ,4 )( - ) , -.


21/59

5921

. . ,

- . ) (

, , -

). ( . ''- -.''. , ,

, , .

.

. , .''-

, . , . ,

.

.

3 .' ' ''- -, 3 .' '-

- . . - , ,

' '- (,-1918 . )- -- ' '

*.

', '-'' ( ,)

" ,"": - .

, (. .- , , )

":- ." , - ".76 - , 1917 ,

, '', , -

.

)(

). (

.' - ' ,-''- , " ."''-

. ,, .1917 -" .

, -,, "- "." , , ,

- " "77 4 , ,

.' '-''

', '-' ', , *.


22/59

5922

, ": ".78 ,

. 1917 , ( .

. - )

, ,

. , .

'- ' ' '' ) ( .'-

- - , ' ' .''-- .''-', '', '', '', ' '

- -

.

", .

(" ).

:

.- . . .

' ' . ; ": (

)"79 ,

.

, ' ' , - ,

, , , ) ( , .

- , " - .-

: , ." . -

. , .

',' .', ' . .

. , .. -

. ,,

13

.-14 )(*. -

.. . ' '''- *. ','1967


23/59

5923

.5 4 ,

5.- - ,

" 7."- " . ,

." - .

- , 8, . 9.

." , ", . 14

". . ' '

."

' ' ('' '' .

-1917 ).

,, , ][ . - ,

20

') ( , ".'

, ". ."

, , ,"'', ,

".

, , , , , ". "

',, , .- '' .

."

- - .

. . ,-

'. - .''- '

'- (- , .1918 )'

23

. )(-

-14 . - " " "

"." ".80

1

: - .


24/59

5924

2[ ,..,

[,,1923;'9. 1967) '34( ,-

. ;]]Autosugestion3.'12-13,

.'12,45.'62', ; , ,..,

6.'85-86;, ,..,

.'116-117;, - ,..,78.'142;, ,..,

9 ,., -1917] ' . 1917[,

.,)'15;( 10

.'19 ,.,.'19;1112

] ' - [,,1917.

13

.'459', ;,.., 14 ,.., ]State Control of Industry in Russia During the

War[,-,1928;'174-175..'83;,1960 ,]]The Conscience of the Revolution ,..,1516

: 20-28 /3-11 1917) . - : 20-28/3-11,1917(

17.6;

.'323;18,, ,]]Soviet Trade Unions ,].] .Deutcher, I,19

.'1-2;1950.'13;2021

-1917] ..-]]Meller.. '

' 1917[;'16,20.- ..]Fleer[, ]' ' [,.'4-7;,1925

221917] (():'(- ' RSDRP)b:(

[,,IMEL,1934;'134.[ : 23 :

[,,1927-1929) (; ,'229,259.. )"- (

24.'190;

'171;2526

." .'25;,.,27.'25;2829

." " .'29; .'36;30[ 31 [,15,1917,'1-2. .32

.'83;,1969,]]P. Owen.,]]The Bolshevik Ideology ,..,33

.'23', ;".'245-246', ; , ,..,34[1917-1921" ,..,35 SSSR,1917-

.'45;,1927 ,]1921.'265-267;,..,3637

;'11' ',]]Syndicalists in the Russian Revolution ,..,.'638

.'5;,.,

.'80', ; ,]]The Bolshevik Revolution ,].] .Carr, E. H.,39.'15-16;,.,40


25/59

5925

41.'11-12;,..,

42.'114', ;"

.'188;4344

.'190; 45.'180;

.'191;4647

' ,.., 1911-1937] 1911-1937[,,1939;'124.48

.'48-49;,.,.'50;4950

.'51;51

.'410-411,' ; ,..,[1917-1918 52 1917-1918[;3,30.53

.1,'77', ;,..,] ,.,54 ' [, ,1918;'10..'73', ;,..,55

56 VTsIK2 ,1918;'60.57

']Lenine et le Controle ' .. -.' "

Ouvrier[ 1967 -]Autosugestion.[58 )251917251918(,,1918;'

171-172..'27-28', ; ,..,5960

.'75;,..,.'17;,.,6162 - ,.., -] ' ' [,,

1918..'54;,.,6364

.'54;[ ,.,65 [, --] [,

.'40,43;1918.'162;,1967,]]The Russian Anarchists ,.',66 .'139-145;,1954 ,]]Nineteen-Seventeen- - ,67

. .'74;,.., 6869

.3,'75', ;,..,70 1917-1918;4,58..83,5;7172

] :1917-1921" SSSR: [,1917-1920..,,1954;'499.

73.'80;,..,

.'215," ;,..,74.'80', ;,..,75.'59;,.,7677

.'92-93,' ; ,..,.'47;7879

. ,1917-4 80

.'82-83', ;,..,


26/59

5926

1 9 1 8

6

', . ,: ,' , - .

" "1.

7-14

- .

: , ? ?

- . ,- - ' '

.

- .

"): --( . -

."2

, , " , ,( (".

".3 "

"- ."4

.. *, , ".5 "

" - " " - ,, ".6

, " . ".7 , ,

- . "".8 , ".

".9 -

" , , , "".10

"11 ,

,)''-( ,*. -

-. .-1915 .-1893 ' . 1918

- . - . . 1921-8 .] [ ] [

. .

. ,] '[( ).,1940 ( .-1950 .

( ''- )Bericht , )1919

uber die Berhandlung des Grundungparteitages der KPD,1919;'16,80(


27/59

5927

-, . - ", " ]coherent[.

? , . ". ." .

".12 - ".

*

" "- ." , , ,, " , ,

. , , -- , - , " ,

".13 , " "''

," , "- - , "

- . (" , -

.(143,000-3,500 ,25 .

. ) (' '- ' , " .

, (".15

1918 ,. .) . 3

.16- , , " "

"- ' '".17 ".19 ]]standardisation "".18

- ". -

' ' ".20 ", , .

,, "".21 , ].''-[

. , -".22

. " " .

- , "".23 ,

,'' .

: - , . , ".

, , , ".24

*- 100,000 --1914." , ,

'(-IWW . -, . ,' -

- , ]).']Industrial Workers of the World .' '-1917 . "

-1919.-10 .1936-1938 .- -1920.'


28/59

5928

.

- " ,

] [ ".25

. ,- ,

, ": . ".26

. - :" ",, - . "

,, .- - , . ".27 -

.

,, -1921 - .

' ', '- ',' ','.'

, - , . ,

.28 ',' ":

, . , ,!)(

"

, , , "

. ,-

." , . -

"29 " , " -

".30 -

", , ."''- ,' --,

.31, , .

( , - . )

' '-''- -' '( ,,). (-

) , ,

.- -

''- , - .

15-21

. -

- " . , " ".32

, : ".33 , ,


29/59

5929

- , - " , ,".34 ) (

. ,

23-31

. -

.

3

.-

. - ). ] (]directors ) (

( ' '- . ' '-

"

"." , ,- ".35

' '- ,, ,1918 ( -19161915. .

)'''', - ( 1917.

. ) ) ( 1918 )

) )( .-' '( ( 1918. ,'',. , 1918."

- ,

." 36

.

) ( )( ). (

. - ''

. , -, ,- . -1918

"- , , ".37

6-8

.][ .- , ,

6-8

. -

),,,(''.38 ''- -

, ''- .

. -


30/59

5930

26

")- ( - - -" - , ."

".39

-"-- "-"- "-

"- 6. "" - " .- , "".40 - " ."

26

,- - ,, ,,. - .

, *. - , - - " ," ".- ,

".41 -

.. , - , ,. 42 -

3

.''-' '-

- " ." -

]piece ." - " rate[" " . " -

",." - " , "

".43

11-12

' ] [ 26 '' ' . .40 .500,

20

. ,,''- ;)Kommunist

. " "- ).

-- ',-'- " " ." , ,

, "." - . .

' '- . ." "." -

": , ,; -

, ".44

' *.1919 ,.


31/59

5931

, ,"- -( ",," "".45 -

) . ?"

": ' ' - ,

- , ,. ) ( ;

, . ".46

".""''- . ; " ".47- "," ')(

." '- ', ,

, . '-'- ".48 "- -

! (-1918, - ).-1921

- .'' , ,

' , . , . )1918(

, , " , . ,

! ".49

28

- " "

. (" " " "" "- . , - - ,

.)

, . , - ()' -' (' '- ,

. - )' '

":. 50

- - -- "- "".

, " " "."

" - ". "

?- ."

- - "("51 - , ,

).

, , ,'-' ,, )-( .

. -


32/59

5932

,, .

":- ,'".52 -

5 "- . -

',''," "," , , . ' ' .

6 ". ,"." -

, ). ' '- ("

- "" "- -

. (" "-" "-1918 .)' '-

, -1918." - ." , , ",

" ." , " : ,53 ."

-, " ."

.54 .

- -1918 - ", ," " ." - - ,

".55 ") (,1918,

"" "- - "- ."] "[

".56

'' - , , , .

''- ) ( .

.). - (

''- , ,, . -

-- . ,,

"' ' () ( - ", ,"". )."

, , ".57 ." "- ' ' .

.58

!-1936 ." " "" "

424

. -


33/59

5933

)-- -150(- 100 ' -'-. , ''- ,

*".59- - "

'- " " '. )(

' ' . ''-. .''-

- .60

-,. " - "- . " ,

." ,, -1890 " " -) .(61

. - - -

, ." " .62

. '' -

1917.63 )(

,, " , ". ."

".64 ,

25

- . ' - - - .

- - (.)

28

, ,- ." - " .

, , , ,, ,,,,,,,

, - ,- - . " "" ".

" ".65 , --

.

. . . ".66 - ,- ".

- . , ' '

.1918 1917

4-10

. -

- ''- 1918 . , .''

.] colourless opinions [*


34/59

5934

,

('' ]-1917[ . ('')

) . ,

' . ''- - ' , '"." - ,-"-191714'

, , . - . .

".67

. ",,"' ' ". ,'', ,. ,

, . , , ,

.- - - , ,

".68

'' .

'- '-' '- - , .

)' ' (''- , ( , -":

- ) ."69

. .''- )?- ('-- '

. .1918

(']['-: , ,- ). ' '-

',' ,. .' ', ,

.,-, - . , ,1918 ".-

, . ".70

.

, - . . -.- '-'

, . . . , ,

) , ( ,. , ,.

)- ( ''- , .

.71

-'- , .'

". ".72 " "-


35/59

5935

, . .73

).'' ( - ,

.' '- - '- '

125- - .

"- .'' ,--

, ', ' ,', ' ,

'".74'

( ( - ) 1918.( .' ).,1918)16 ')

- . )? , , - .

. . - "" ( .

.75 )-

'- '76 -"- . . ,

- ." .77 '- '

1918

- -30 -10)(- ,20

, 9 ).( - . )(-

. 69 - 1918 . -

]department of state.[78 .

- ( , . )

.

28

" - --

,- - ] [- , , ".79

" , .80 "

. ,

6-9

. -

125

- - .


36/59

5936

." "- -. ' '-

. '' , ''- ''-

.

81

. -

10%,400. ''-''--20 ) ( ,38%,9%

. , -43% ''- ." "

, " ." "- - - "".82

".83 ,--

). ('156;,.',12 ] - ' ,7-14 1918[,,

.'193;) - (19183.'212;

.'48;4.'235;56.'168;,.',

.'85; 7.'239;89.'215;

10

.'85; .'85;1112

.'221;.'168-169;,.',13.'12-13;,..,1415

(,1920,]]Die Russischen Gewerkshaften ,..,: ).

16.'374;

.'369-370;17.'369;1819

.'192;.'230;20

.'195;2122

.'369;.'370, -;23'128;,.,2425

.'181;.'11; 26.'80;2728

.'364;.;29.'27;3031

.'367;32

' ,,1918;'8.

.'5;3334

.'30;


37/59

5937

35 , ,1918;'311-315.

36.'86-87',;,..,

] [3738

] [ 39] [

] [4041

',,,,., ; ",'171-172.42

.'246,,;XLI-1 ,..,43 ,2,1918;'38.[ .,44 [,'1,1918;'3-4.45

] ' [,'1,1918;'8.] [46] [4748

] [.'87;,..,49

)'247-248," ;(" "- 5051

.'332-333,340-342,' ; ,..,.'452.'516-517," ;,..,5354

.'326," ;]. ['366,' ; ,..,55.'100',;,..,5657

. ,..,'24 58

].]Paul Cardan ]]From Bolsheviks to Beaurocracy59

.4-'101',;,..,[ - ,60

'

[,,1918;'61-64..'75;61.'65;6263

'] [,;'477-478..'119-120',;,..,64.'105',;6566

.'92;,..,67 ,. ,.,Wirtscaftsleben und Wirtscaftlicher Aufbau in Soviet Russland 1917-1920,,1920;

).('16368

[ ., [,,1918;'35.;,1920, - , ,.,69

.'654 .'91;,..,70.'1-14;]The Prophet Unarmed[,O.U.P.,1959- ,., 71.'24;,..,-7273

.'89-90;,1948-,1917 ,.,.'191;,.',74.'192-193;7576

. - - .'196-197;,.',7778

.'180',;,..,79

] -- - ' ' [,,.'72;1919

80

,1920;,''83..'183',;,..,81


38/59

5938

82 ] - ' ).[(.;

213.83

.'190',;,..,


39/59

5939

1 9 1 9

16-25

- .

. 1918 , - , , " "".1 , ",

,, ( . ,. ,) -

,". , - ".2 ,

' ,," , ;

, , , ".3 ,

". ,

. . , . ".4 , , ,

, - , - .

, , . . -

.

, , - " " ,,".5 - "- ." . ,

(" , ,.) --''

.

" " ." - " ( ( ,"

" ,.., ".6 .3,500,000 (".7.(819171,500,500 ,2,600,000,1918,

"- . ,, - "" - ".9

.

2-7

) .(

18-23

.


40/59

5940

.* ' , .

.

. .- " ' '-5

, ) ( .-

".10

. " .

,".11 ,

"- '5' 12. - - -

- " ."-." -

) (' ' ; .'-'

. , , .

." " "8." "

'-'- -

. ".13 -

. ''-

, , -. - .

. . .-' '

[ . ,14, . ]

(- ,. )

. , - . , -

- '', '-'

, , . ,, , '- ,'' , , .

-, ',- '-,', , , -,

, -,,- .

": . - (".15 ;

-21-15 !)' ',-1923 , , .

]' , ,[*


41/59

5941

.

. .

). ( .' '-

. " " , .

.- , ] [, ] [ . - , - ,

.' '-. - "*. - .

".16 ..

. '

. ' '

. ' .

2-4

.

( (, ."--

,-- . ', ' ".17

5-9. -

,.18 ).-1918 -1917 ( " ,-''-

" ." , ".19 : ,'

16

- ( - 20 - ,") "

, ,

, ,, . , ). ('' . ,-

- ( . " ', ' "

). ,1920, 12

-- , ".21 " - .22

. ' '

*

,)' '(.-I.S - , , , : "4.' ' 1968

." , ,


42/59

5942

, , .- . . ' '

- ? - .- ?

' '-) (1921 .

-1922) ( .

27

( , , ).

.'25;,.,12, ,Die Bolshevistischen Gewerkshaften,']Jena[,1932;'81-82.

3 ] - " '

'[,, ,1919) - (;,'.'34

4.'103;

.'26;,.,5.'97',; 67.'99;

]:', " ,8 ' ...: [,,IMEL,1933;'188..'127',; 9

10]:', " ' ...: [,,IMEL,1933) -

.,'422,;).'72;1112

.'29;,.,.'31;1314

.'79;,.., 15.'30,168; ,

.,1,444; 16.'33;,.,1718

' , " ,':] ' ...: [,,IMEL,1934) .'72;) -

19.'184;,..,

.'487; ,.,20.'492;2122

.'492;


43/59

5943

1 9 2 0

. , .

,, " ."

, , ,-,,( , -)." "- -".1 , "

12

- .

-602. , - ". -

".2-

10-21

.

, ,, - ) ( " .

, ".3 . .

."-- " - ,.4 -

) ('' "

. "

. . : , , ." ,-

", ," ". ".5

, , . . - , .

, .

- .-

",''- , , " , . . ,"

- , , -

- - ".6

'-, . - . - '

- ", ,-- " ,".7

. -


44/59

5944

. ) ( -

, - - " , ', '-". " , -

".8

429

.

,, ]. -[ - , .

, , ,- ( ). ,

. '-- '-' ' - .

. ,

"."9 ", . , . - " ," "." , ,

" ." - "." ".10 "- ," ","

) ( .' ' . , , . ''

.

", ,"- ". , , ,''

".11 "" ) (

)1918( . ."12 "

,.13- ','- ,

,, "- , ".14

." "

,(' '- ,'.(, , , --

).- ( ,- , -- , ,

. - " ."15 " -" " , ', '- ,.16

-"- ,"-"- (" "- . - )." " "

] [.17 ) ( .' '

,. '-- '- ". ,

. ) ( ,- ".18

. ) --(

. ''- ''-


45/59

5945

"[ ". ]

".20 "- ".19 - "

-- ". , -- ".21

".23"-"-","" ]selection"[.22 "

"." ".24 -

"" - " '' ".25 ,

- , .26" ,

- , , ,, .-1919 '5'

, , ,

.'' ,1783 2051,1920 .

'.27 - '

. ' '- ) ( .

,, , ". -

. ".28 , , - "

-".29 , ,

) -5 ( , .

- .

. " ."30 ,

. -,

6-15

- .

"" " - ?-

"." ,, "" " "." , ,

-, *".31 " .

- -30 .32 , .-,

,. . " - [*] ,


46/59

5946

"-1918 . -- " "33

- .")( ! .

-

. , , 1920 ,,, , -,

''- . .- , , , , " 1920

".34 - ,

" 1919 '' , , .

, '".35,

, , .

. --)- ( .

. .1918 ''-

). ( ,, ''

: ". -".36

- , "".37 - ,

, . , ," - , -

, ,-, . . -

".38 ,-,

." , . " " . . ,

, .,-, . . ,

- ,, - -

."39 , , "

".40

, , , " ,

"41

. - " ,

".42 ,) (

, , - ,"

, -- ,".43


47/59

5947

- , - , ,. -''

-- .' ' , -- .

. ", , ".44

) -.( , - , - ,

. - - .)' '(-".45 , ". .

, , . . ''- , ,

.

22-25

.

'- " . " . - ' ' . '

, ,

. .

- . . ."-- - " " "

"- "" ".46

, , .

- ) ',''( - .

.

2-6

- .

, ][, ( .

(

( .( , "" !*)(' '-. -

14

.- . -

.

] , [*


48/59

5948

, ' '. ) -' '.47 154 124)

8-9

.

, ' ' , - ". -25,-

"" , ).5(" -!)(- " ".48 "-

" .7 8 ".49 -".50-

"51 "," "- .4 10 ,- ,,-- "

".52 . ''-.".53 " .

2, , " , ,

"".54 . - ".55,

", ".56 " - - . -

".57

7

. ." " . . "."-","",""," "

-- "".58 ' '

".60 - "."59

' ' .

".61 ", .- , ,- ,

.' '

- - ,, ( - .1918

( ). - ).

.

.- 22-29

- .

- .

. ": . ,

, .-1917 : .' '-

- -".62 ,


49/59

5949

( , ).

.63 -

30

" ,

.' '- , , , -. ,

:64 )- () (

" ." " , . -- ,"

.- ""- ""- . .

*. 7" -"- . -

- , , ". ".65

. ".

)(: .) . ("

. , !)( .

- .),191720 , , (- - .

. , , .

, ."

"- .' ' ,3,. " ".66 -- "".67

"68

" - "."

." .

. , ') ' ' ( .

. -." " .' '

'" ' " "- "." ") , ")

".69 :

"".70 "- ,- , .

, -", ,"''"?".71 , ".72 -

1917,2.6 1.5 , *.-1921 -7-1920 -1919,4.3 1918,3.5


50/59

5950

.73 ( , ' '

- .( , 1919'5'- ' '".

2 ,

- - , , ". ."

. (" - ". !) -

" - , -

' - '- . .

, .," " ,

, ", ' '".74

: *

, . ,

. -

1 ,1920;'8,49.- - ] '

[,1920) (;,' ,'50-51.2.'493;

.'17," ;, ,..,3.,'193;,..,45[ , [, ;13,'534.

6

.'126;,.., .'542,15; ," 78 : III - ,1922;'28.

.'36; .,9.'126," ;.,1011

.'128; .'269-272; 12.'35;,.,1314

] ., ' [,,1926;'83..'254-255; 15.32,'532;1617

.'123-124;

.75,'571;18.'474,2; - )(" 1920

.1920,12[ 21 [, ;

.,'493:.'532,12;,) ( 22.'26,28;2324

. " ,-1922 - 25

).'607,612',,("- 26

.'96; ,..,

]rewards in kind . [*


51/59

5951

27.'83;,

28.'114;,..,

.'115,117;2930

.'498; ,., 31 ] ": - '

'[,,1920) (;'87-89..'500-507;,.,32: (1920, ,ILP , 33

0824-bb-41.(34

.'107;,..,35 ,..,,,',,1921;,''429..'133;,1961 , ,.,3637

.'146;.'149;38.'135;3940

.'137;.'143;41.'162;4243

.'162-163;.'501-502; ,.,44.'502;4546

.,1920,12 .2,'829; 47.'502-503;,.,4849

.'41; ,.,.'502-503; ,.,50.'30,' ;1924-1926,,..,51.'599-600,' ;1924-1926,,.,52 ,-24 , .'502-503;,.,53

. .'503;5455

.'422-423,15;,.,56

.'29,6;,.,.'503;,.,57.'12,' ; ,..,5859

.'53;.'26;60.'125;,..,6162

] ": - ' : '[,,1921; .'32463

.'271;,1965-,, ,.,- "):'42-52( - " 64

. ', ' , -3."- - ,

- " .' ' - ,)' '( : - ,

." - [ 65 [, ;,,''536-

542..'51; ,.,6667

.'6,' ; ,..,

.'76;68


52/59

5952

69[ , [, ;

.'802,1670

.'35,' ; ,..,.'36;71[ ,..,72 [.73

',' ; , , ,..,40-80.

74[ , [,.'789-793,2; ,1920-30


53/59

5953

1 9 2 1

. , , ','- . ,

-".1 "

13

".2 " .

".3 - ".4 .

14

' ') , , ,,, , ' , ,

. ).16

".5 "- - ,

21

: ,

- : " ' ' ', '

- . ,." .

".6 " - - )' '(

.*)' '(]-[

24

' ,,. .7 -8 137-62 '

25

.' ' .8 ,

. ' ' ' ' .9

. - ,) ( , --,

.' '

, , : - " .-1921 ' '.

, . ,1920, ".10 -- , ' '

,1921 --

*

, - .' '' ' . ' ' . . ,

!


54/59

5954

]]industrialism ' ' '' - -- .11--

.-1917

- - .

- '' ('' ' -' ) ' ' '']-[

.'-'- ] [

-' . - .- , .'

.''

,,-19. -'' ''- - .1290%

": .-

, ".13 .

17

*.

, , -.14

8-16

.

. .

- . . --

,- . , ','- . ,

.

. ' '- - ",," "

""15 "16 . .

. ".' ' ,

. . -" !" - "."

"

- 200 ''- . ' '

' ' (. ,)

, "".17-

:The Truth about Kronstadt,The Kronstadt Commune) [* ( H5]-Anarchist FAQ


55/59

5955

. - " ,

. , ".18

. ' '

",] ["","","-" ' ' '(".19 - . '

. - ''- .)-"" -": ,. ,

" " ." " ' , '" , .20

)' '( ' ' .21

", ," ". ).-(- - , .

".22

. -.1917 - -,( ''- .

( - . . ,

' '- !) (

.-

.''- , "- "

. ".23- " "- ' '

, * ,"- ."

- , . - - , ],[ "."

".24 - . -

, , ", ," ", . ,,

" . ,,".25- , ""26

(? '' ".27 , , ,)-1902

.- ', ' ,

, , , . . ,''

,''- . '' .

-- ". . ".28 - -

,- ). (

*

]NEP

] /;' ' - ? .

." "]:]Lasalle


56/59

5956

. , , , . - ":

. , . .

." . -" ,-

(" , ".29 , ") .

. - - . , - -1927*

.,,.1936-1938 ' '-''.

]. [ . ''-

,'' ' , -' ,' )(

- "- .30

." - -- 31

, , 3 " ' '

. ".32- - " .

'' '")- .(33 . -18) (50336 , ,

"'.(34 ' ( .-1919

' ' ".35 .

, , , ].]NEP

.]"] ""Tax in kind "-', ' , - . , ,

20,-330 . 10- ! -NEP!36

" . 5-25-19 ."

(- . .(37

( ,' (, , .38 .

, 1921 ". ''-''

." 39

. , ,

1] ., '[, ;'826-827,1.2.'779,6;

.3.'103; ,.,45.'35;9; ,..,

.'57;6

] ',' [*


57/59

5957

7.'79;

8.'7

] /9 ' [ . ,,1930.10

.'127;,.., 11.'371-372; ,

.1921,271213

.. , 1921] '1921'[,,1931;'52.]54 /. [ ''-

14.' 1921-'27

[ 15 [,10,1921..,1921;121617

.'145-146;,..,.,1921;9 18[ 19 [,

.'530',,; 20

.'382-383; 21.'258;

). ,1930)T 3279" ,22. 2324

[' ' ,., ' ' ', ,15,1924;'31]

] ff.,'531,; 25.'28', ;)FLPH(,1958, , ,.,.,2627

.'46;] [28.'540;,2930

.'93;.'140;31.'663;,' ' 3233

.. ;, ..1,'828;34.'156;,..,3536

.'308;,.,.'522-526,; 37.'151-152;,..,3839

.'152;


58/59

5958

-

1921

.-- -

.-1913 .1905 - ' . . .''- ,,.'

-- , -- !).(

. ).40120 ( .1 -- .

. - '- '-

17-25

- .

.-NEP , , ''- ," ,

1500 , . , - 30

": . ,

".2 -- , ,

. ., -- . ,

.- , . - --

, ". ", , ). (" "

. '', ." " -1917? .

! ,1921."

.'323;, .'34;'32,1921, 12.'324-325;, -.'277-278;- ,


59/59

- .

, , . ''- , .

. .' '-' -'-

, - , ,.

,'' - . . ) - (

- 1917' ' .

. - - .- -

. -

"Vae Victis", -390" . " ".

-1918 1923 - ,,. ,

.' ' ,

,( ''- ,]1970,-1960 [ . ,) '

-) ( - .''-

. ,

. 1917 .-19211917 -

- 19681956. . ,

. .

,- ' '- ? ,- ,''- -

. - , .

, - .

' ', ' -' ', '

) ( - :

. ,

. ,- , , .

the bolsheviks and workers control

Documents