the basque case a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

62
“The Basque Case offers a model for 21st Century development, a merger of Keynesian and Schumpeterian approaches; enhanced social change and entrepreneurship.” - Diogo Vasconcelos, Founding Chair of the Social Innovation Exchange “This fascinating Basque case study demonstrates the power of a holistic approach to development, one that simultaneously and creatively engages with economic, social, political, environmental and cultural elements and the potential for them to be aligned to faciltate self-reinforcing positive change.” - Dr. Jacqueline Klopp, Columbia University ´7KHUH KDV EHHQ D ZLGH GLYLVLRQ LQ WKH ÀHOG RI HFRQRPLFV EHWZHHQ WKRVH ZKR VHH WKH ÀQDQFLDO PDUNHWV DV SDUW RI WKH SURGXFWLYH HOHPHQWV RI DQ HFRQRP\ DQG WKRVH ZKR VHH WKLV DV D VHULRXV ÁDZ WKDW KDV EHHQ GHPRQVWUDWHG E\ WKH FXUUHQW FULVLV Dr Ibarretxe!s report comes at a critical moment, offering an alternative model based on a record of success when other experiments have not been as successful.” - Dr. Kenneth Melchin, St. Paul University !"#$"%"&' )#*"%$+,%- .&"#/&0- &%1 2&3,% 4567 89:;<<:;=:99 36&#"%/,>$?@A51@ 36&#A$?@A51@ !"# %&'()# *&'#+ Executive Summary %\ -XDQ -RVp ,EDUUHW[H 0DUNXDUWX , *-./0#"#1'23# 4-5#6 7-0 8)'9&21&:6# ;).&1 <#3#6-/.#19

Upload: gorka-espiau

Post on 19-Jun-2015

1.092 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

“The Basque Case offers a model for 21st Century development, a merger of Keynesian and Schumpeterian approaches; enhanced social change and entrepreneurship.”- Diogo Vasconcelos, Founding Chair of the Social Innovation Exchange

“This fascinating Basque case study demonstrates the power of a holistic approach to development, one that simultaneously and creatively engages with economic, social, political, environmental and cultural elements and the potential for them to be aligned to faciltate self-reinforcing positive change.” - Dr. Jacqueline Klopp, Columbia University

Dr Ibarretxe!s report comes at a critical moment, offering an alternative model based on a record of success when other experiments have not been as successful.”- Dr. Kenneth Melchin, St. Paul University

!"#$"%"&'()#*"%$+,%-(.&"#/&0-(&%1(2&3,%(4567(

(89:;<<:;=:99((((((((((((( ( (36&#"%/,>$?@A51@

36&#A$?@A51@

!"#$%&'()#$*&'#+

Executive Summary

,$*-./0#"#1'23#$4-5#6$7-08)'9&21&:6#$;).&1$<#3#6-/.#19$

Page 2: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%"#&

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

Page 3: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

! "#$! %&'()! '*! #'+! &#$! ,-%./$! 0'1$(23$2&! -24! 5$'56$! 7(-*&$4! -!%&(-&$8)! &'! ($8$2$(-&$! &#$9(! $7'2'3)!'1$(! &#$!2$:&!4$7-4$! ;! -24! &'!4'! %'!+9&#! &#$! %/55'(&! '*! &#$! 1-%&!3-<'(9&)! '*! &#$! ,-%./$! 5$'56$=! 92! %59&$! '*! &#$!!'2>8'928!8/$((966-!7-35-982!'*!?"@!-8-92%&!&#$!A5-29%#!%&-&$!>!9%!7'2&-92$4!92!&#$!*'66'+928!B$5'(&=!+#97#!#-%!&#$!8($-&!-41-2&-8$!'*!C$928!+(9&&$2!C)!'2$!'*!&#$!7#9$*!-(7#9&$7&%!'*!&#$!,-%./$!%&(-&$8)=!&#$!*'(3$(!D$#$4-(-E9=!F(G!H/-2!IC-(($&:$!J-(E/-(&/G!K9&#! 9&%! *'7/%!'2! L&#$! ($-6!$7'2'3)=M!-!7'339&3$2&! &'!8$2/92$!5/C697>5(91-&$!5-(&2$(%#95%=!-2!-77$5&-27$!'*!&#$!2$$4!&'!921'61$!&#$!+'(E!*'(7$!92!56-22928!$7'2'397!5'6979$%=!-24!-!C$69$*!&#-&!8'1$(23$2&!-7&9'2!92!%/55'(&!'*!921$%&3$2&%!92!&$7#2'6'8)=!922'1-&9'2!-24!$4/7-&9'2!+'/64!5-)!

&#$!,-%./$!%&(-&$8)!5('194$%!%'3$!76$-(!-6&$(2-&91$!6$%%'2%!-C'/&!($*'(3!-24!($8$2$(-&9'2!&#-&!4'!2'&!2$7$%%-(96)!927'(5'(-&$!-!L(-7$!&'!&#$!C'&&'3GM!!

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

N#(9%&'5#$(!J9&7#$66

0$'(8$!J-%'2!R291$(%9&)=!S9(8929-

Page 4: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(#)%"

! "#! $%&'! ()*+,-#$! .-! /0-'-#$! -1&(-#*-! )2! 3! '+**-''2+4! ,)(-4! 2)0!

'+'$3&#354-!%+,3#!(-1-4)/,-#$6!.&$%&#!$%-!*)#$-7$!)2!,+4$&8#3$&)#34!')*&-$&-'9!

:!;3'<+-!,)(-4!$%3$!(-,)#'$03$-'!$%3$!'-428=)1-0#,-#$6!$%3$!&'!$%-!*3/3*&$>!)2!

/)4&$&*346!-*)#),&*!3#(!')*&34!'-4280-=+43$&)#6!*3#!5-!3!'>#)#>,!2)0!'+'$3&#354-!

(-1-4)/,-#$9!!?-!)22-0!$%&'!;3'<+-!@3'-!3'!3#!-73,/4-!$)!$%)'-!.%)!'--A!

&##)13$&1-!')4+$&)#'!$)!$%-!*),/4-7!*%344-#=-'!)2!$%-!BC'$!@-#$+0>9!

! D%-!,)(-4! /0-'-#$-(! &'! #)$! )#-! )2! %>/)$%-$&*34! *)#E-*$+0-6! 5+$! 3#!

-73,/4-!$%3$!(03.'!+/)#!$%&0$>!>-30'!)2!-7/-0&-#*-9!!D%&'!.)0A!3&,'!$)!3#34>F-!

$%-! &#&$&3$&1-'! 3#(!/)4&*&-'! $%3$! -#354-(! 3! /0)=0-''&1-! $03#'2)0,3$&)#! )2! $%-!

;3'<+-! @)+#$0>! )1-0! $%-'-! $%0--! (-*3(-'6! .&$%! 3! /30$&*+430! 2)*+'! )#! $%-!

/-0&)(!)2!CGGH!8!BIIH9!!:'!3!%)4&'$&*!,)(-4!)2!'+'$3&#354-!%+,3#!(-1-4)/,-#$!

J&#344>6! .-! '%30-! )+0! -7/-0&-#*-! 3#(! '+==-'$! A->! 4-'')#'! $%3$! ,3>! 3''&'$!

)$%-0'!$)!3(13#*-!&#!$%-&0!).#!-22)0$'!$)!*+4$&13$-!#-.!,)(-4'!)2!(-1-4)/,-#$9

! D%&'!()*+,-#$!&'!.0&$$-#!&#!=03$&$+(-!$)!$%-!;3'<+-!K-)/4-6!)#-!)2!$%-!

,)'$!3#*&-#$!*),,+#&$&-'! &#!L+0)/-! $%3$!%31-!/)'&$&)#-(! $%-,'-41-'!3$! $%-!

*+$$&#=!-(=-!)2!/0)=0-''9!K0)=0-''!$%3$! &'!+#(-0'$))(!#)$!)#4>!3'!-*)#),&*!

=0).$%! )0! $-*%#&*34! &##)13$&)#6! 5+$! 34')! ')*&34! /0)=0-''! 3$! $%-! '-01&*-! )2!

$%-!*),,+#&$>9! !:! 0-'&4&-#$!K-)/4-!.%)!%31-!3*%&-1-(!3! 4-3(&#=!/)'&$&)#! &#!

$%-!M#&$-(!N3$&)#'O!P+,3#!Q-1-4)/,-#$! "#(-76!(-'/&$-!)1-0! $%&0$>! >-30'!)2!

1&)4-#*-!3'')*&3$-(!.&$%!$%-!LD:!$-00)0&'$!=0)+/9!

;>!R+3#8R)'-!"5300-$7-!S30A+30$+6!K%9!Q

T-%-#(3A30&!)2!$%-!:+$)#),)+'!@),,+#&$>!)2!$%-!;3'<+-!@)+#$0>6!

CGGH!8!BIIH

Page 5: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

The Basque Case! !!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()$*&#! !!!!!!!!!+!,-.%/'!0*1*&#! !!!!!!!!!2-%//!,$%.$/3*)!+4/1

Economic Strategy! !!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()$*&#! !!!!!!!!!5/.%#*#3!$&!6&78/$/! !!!!!!!!!5/.%#*#3!$&!6&78/$/!*#!6&&8/%.$*&#! !!!!!!!!!5/.%#*#3!$&!"##&9.$/!*#!6&&8/%.$*&#

Social Cohesion Strategy! !!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()$*&#! !!!!!!!!!:'().$*&#! !!!!!!!!!;/.<$-!.#'!,&)*.<!6.%/! !!!!!!!!!,&)*.<!"#)<(1*&#!! !!!!!!!!!=/#'/%!:>(.<*$?! !!!!!!!!!+!6(<$(%.<!"'/#$*$?!@8/#!$&!$-/!A&%<'

Environmental Strategy ! !!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()$*&#! !!!!!!!!!B/'*(7C$/%7!,$%.$/3*)!D<.##*#3E!FGGF!C!FGFG! !!!!!!!!!H*3-$!+3.*#1$!6<*7.$/!6-.#3/! !!!!!!!!!,(1$.*#.I</!:#/%3?E!2%.#18&%$!.#'!B&I*<*$?

Results! !!!!!!!!"#'*).$&%1!&J!:)&#&7*)!=%&K$-! !!!!!!!!"#'*).$&%1!&J!,&)*.<!6&-/1*&#! !!!!!!!!"#'*).$&%1!&J!:#9*%&#7/#$.<!,(1$.*#.I*<*$?! !!!!!!!!,(77.%?! !!!!!!!!6&#)<(1*&#

Keys to Success! !!!!!!!6&#)/8$*&#!.#'!0*1*&#! !!!!!!!D(I<*)CD%*9.$/!,-.%/'!5/.'/%1-*8! !!!!!!!6&77*$7/#$!$&!$-/!L/.<!:)&#&7?! !!!!!!!+!,&)*.<!,$.$/! !!!!!!!,/<JC=&9/%#7/#$

A Road Map for New Governance! !!!!!!!M/K!=&9/%#.#)/! !!!!!!!M/K!,/<J!=&9/%#7/#$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Conclusion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:#'!M&$/1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N*I<*&3%.8-?

Page 6: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()#$*&'#+,-./0)1-2/,

! "#!$%&!'($%!)&#$*+,!#&-./01&+2/!3-4&/5!-6!4&7&/-83&#$!8+-9/203&4!$%2$!*#6&$$&+&4!:+-;$%!;-*/4!2472#9&!%*32#0$,<!2!+050#:!$04&!;-*/4!/06$!2//!1-2$5

=>!

?%05! /0#&! -6! $%-*:%$! :20#&4! #&2+! *#@*&5$0-#&4! 5*8+&329,! 26$&+! $%&! 62//! -6!$%&!A&+/0#!;2//!2#4!$%&!620/*+&!-6!5-902/053>!B*C*,232!&7&#!;&#$!25!62+!25!$-!8+-9/203!$%2$!;&!%24!+&29%&4!$%&!D&#4!-6!%05$-+,E'>!F-;&7&+G!2$!$%&!42;#!-6!$%&!'=5$!9&#$*+,!0$!05!9/&2+!$%2$!$%&!+&5*/$5!-6!#&-./01&+2/!8-/090&5!%27&!1&&#!62+!6+-3!&@*2/>!!"#!2:+&&3&#$!;0$%!H2/&2#-G!;&!2+:*&!$%2$!$-!42$&!D4&7&/-83&#$!05!2!I-*+#&,!;0$%!3-+&!5%08!;+&9C5!$%2#!520/0#:!1-2$5>EJ

! ?%05! 1&/0&6! $%2$! $%&! 0#70501/&! %2#4! -6! $%&! 32+C&$! ;0//! 2472#9&! -*+!9-//&9$07&!%*32#0$,! 05!;27&+0#:>!?%&! $03&!%25!9-3&! $-!82*5&! 6-+!2!3-3&#$!

$%&!;-+/4!$%2$!2+&!25C0#:!*5!6-+!8+*4&#9&>!!"#!5%-+$!0$!05!#&9&552+,!$-!2#5;&+!@*&5$0-#5!25!5038/&!25!$%&5&K

F27&!;&!9+-55&4!$%&!1-*#42+0&5!-6!$%&!L2+$%M5!+&:&#&+2$07&!928290$,NO-!&9-#-309!:+-;$%!2#4!9-38*/507&!9-#5*3&+053!32C&!*5!%288,N!!P%,!2#4!%-;!404!;&!+&29%!$%05!8-0#$NF-;!92#!;&!:*2+2#$&&!2!1&$$&+!6*$*+&!6-+!$%&!;%-/&!-6!%*32#C0#4NF-;!92#!#2$0-#5!2#4!/-92/!9-33*#0$0&5!8+&5&+7&!$%&!10-/-:092/!407&+50$,!-6!$%&!8/2#&$N!

!

@*-$&4! 0#!%05!2+$09/&! D)&#$+-E! 0#!Q2!)27&+#2K! DP&!;-*/4!5&//!&7&+,$%0#:!,-*!#&&4&4!06!;&!404#M$!8+&6&+!,-*!$-!#&&4!;%2$!;&!%27&!$-!5&//>ER!?%&!+&/&#$/&55!

;2,504&G!05!#-!/-#:&+!&#-*:%>!S-+!05!0$!8-5501/&!$-!$*+#!2!1/0#4!&,&!;%&#!$%&!&#70+-#3&#$2/!12/2#9&!-6!$%&!8/2#&$!05!2$!+05C>!!T5!$%&!:/-12/!&9-#-3,!50$5!2$!$%&!1+0#CG!#-;!05!$%&!$03&!6-+!:&#&+2$07&!9%2#:&!2#4!0##-72$07&!5-/*$0-#5>

Page 7: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

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

!!!!! "'! '()! #%$)! %1! '()! B.&C7)!<.&)! -&! .! '$-83)#'%$! #%0#)4'7.+-=.'-%0! %1!

)0+-*(')02)0'5! '()! -067&'$-.+! $)3%+7'-%0!.'! '()!,)*-00-0*!%1! '()!EF'(!<)0'7$/!2.$:)6!)#%0%2-#!*$%9'(!.&!'()!&/0%0/2!1%$!4$%*$)&&!.06!9)+1.$);!G.')$! -0!'()! #)0'7$/5! .0! -0#$).&-0*! &%#-.+! .9.$)0)&&! -0'$%67#)6! (72.0! 0))6&! .06!#%2270.+!#%()&-%0!'%!'()!4$%*$)&&-3)!+)@-#%0;!!A(-&!#(.0*)!-0!#%0&#-%7&0)&&!

-0!'()!EFHI&!)03-$%02)0'.+!-&&7)&!,)#.2)!.!4$-0#-4.+!#%0#)$0!%1!47,+-#!.06!-0')$0.'-%0.+!6)3)+%42)0'!%$*.0-=.'-%0&;!J0!.66-'-%0!'%!)#%0%2-#!*$%9'(!.06!(72.0! 6)3)+%42)0'5! )03-$%02)0'.+! &7&'.-0.,-+-'/! ,)#.2)! .! :)/! .&4)#'! %1!4$%*$)&&;!!A()!B.&C7)!<.&)!(%+-&'-#.++/!-0')*$.')&!'()&)!4$)3-%7&+/!&)4.$.')!&4()$)&!-0'%!.!'$-4+)8()+-@!%1!&7&'.-0.,+)!(72.0!6)3)+%42)0';

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

Page 8: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()#$*&'#+$,"&-#.$/0'012

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

$ $$$$$$$$$$$$+$31)24-56$ $ $$$$$&4$7#&3#8$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$7-1).$19$04'$-114'$&2.$04'$4-&.04012'8$$ $ $$$$$41:#-&24$&2.$-#'7#349):$41$.0;#-'0458$ $ $$$$$"0<":5$7-1.)340;#8$$ $ $$$$$="03"$31>7#4#'$)'02<$04'$7#17:#8$$ $ $$$$$="1$)'#$4"#0-$3-#&40;045$&2.$4&?#$$ $ $$$$$-#'712'0@0:045$91-$4"#0-$=1-?$$$ $ $$$$$=04"02$4"#$9-&>#=1-?$19$'"&-#.$7-1A#34'8$ $ $$$$$02$&2$17#2$&2.$024#-2&4012&:$'#4402<8$$ $ $$$$$'130&::5$31"#'0;#8$$ $ $$$$$')771-40;#$41$4"#$=1-:.B

Page 9: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()#$*&'#!"+##$,-&-#./0$12#'

! "#$%&%!'(!)!*+),&%!-$*$./0!1#*2)$/)'3&!4#5)/!6&-&3.75&/2! $/! 2+&!8)*9#&!:.#/2,(!$*!&/);2&%!2+,.#<+!2+,&&!%$*2$/;2!7.3$;(!)=&*>!

! 6&-&3.75&/2!.?!2+&!8)*9#&!:.#/2,(!+)*!'&&/!%,$-&/!'(!)/!$/%#*2,$)3!)/%!7,.%#;2$-&!&;./.5(@!!A+&!)=$*!.?!&;./.5$;!<,.B2+!+)*!'&&/!*#*2)$/&%!'(!;./2$/#.#*!$//.-)2$./!)/%!)!;.55$25&/2!2.!;.57&2$2$-&/&**@!C-&,!2+&!7)*2!2+,&&!%&;)%&*!2+&!8)*9#&!".-&,/5&/2!+)*!&/);2&%!*2,)2&<$;!&;./.5$;!73)/*!2+)2!+)-&!*.#<+2!2.! $/2&<,)2&!2+&!8)*9#&!&;./.5(!$/2.!2+&!<3.')3!&;./.5(0!)/%!7,.5.2&!2&;+/.3.<$;)3!%&-&3.75&/2!)/%!$//.-)2$./@

7,.D&;20!,&*7&;2?#3!.?!2+&!,$<+2*!.?!2+&!$/%$-$%#)3!)/%!)77,&;$)2$-&!.?!2+&!-)3#&!

&9#$2)'3&! <,.B2+0! ;./*2,#;2&%! '(! 7&.73&! ?.,! 2+&! 7&.73&@! ! E9#$2)'3&! <,.B2+!$/%$;)2&%! '(! $/;,&)*&%! &9#)3$2(0! *.;$)3! &9#$3$',$#5! )/%! 7&,*./)3! ;#32#,)3!%&-&3.75&/2@! F/! .,%&,! 2.! 5)G&! *.;$)3! 7,.<,&**! 2+&! 8)*9#&! ".-&,/5&/2!

! 6&-&3.75&/2! $/! 2+&! 8)*9#&! :.#/2,(! *&&G*! 2.! &/*#,&! 2+)2! *.;$)3!)/%!&;./.5$;!);2$-$2$&*!),&!*#*2)$/)'3&0!)/%!%.!/.2! D&.7),%$H&!2+&!;)7);$2(!.?! ?#2#,&!<&/&,)2$./*! 2.!5&&2! 2+&$,!.B/!/&&%*@!A+&! 2+$,%!)=$*!.?!1#*2)$/)'3&!4#5)/!6&-&3.75&/2!7.3$;$&*!$/!2+&!8)*9#&!:.#/2,(!$*!?.;#*&%!'(!2+&!%&?&/*&!.?!&/-$,./5&/2)3!*#*2)$/)'$3$2(!)/%!2+&!*2,#<<3&!2.!5$2$<)2&!;3$5)2&!;+)/<&@

! F/!2+&!?.33.B$/<!*&;2$./*!2+$*!%.;#5&/2!B$33!;./*$%&,!$/!<,&)2&,!%&2)$3!2+&!)<&/2*0!*2,#;2#,&*!)/%!7.3$;$&*!.?!2+&*&!)=&*@!!I+$3*2!*2),2$/<!?,.5!2+&!+$*2.,$;!,&;.-&,(! .?! 8)*9#&! *&3?J<.-&,/5&/2! $/! KLMN0! 2+&! %.;#5&/2! B$33! 7,$/;$7)33(!?.;#*!./!2+&!7&,$.%!KLLMJONNM@!

Page 10: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$#%&"'()*+),-./$)*#01")&#$

! "#! $%&'! ()*! +*,-.*+/! -0! 12(-#-3/! ()+-24)! ()*! 5(1(2(*! -0! 62*+#7,1!*#189*:!()*!;1<=2*!>-2#(+/!(-!31?*!()*!,+7(7,19!,)-7,*<!()1(!917:!()*!0-2#:1(7-#<!

82(! 7#<@7+*:!8/! ()*!@+-:2,(7.*! (+1:7(7-#!-0! ()*!;1<=2*!@*-@9*A! (-!,-337(! (-!

2#:*+<(1#:7#4! BC1@*(*+-! 1! (2<! C1@1(-<DA! 97(*+199/A! ,-889*+! (-! /-2+! <)-*<A! -+!(+1#<97(*+1(*:A!<(7,?!(-!E)1(!/-2!?#-EA!E)7,)!8*,13*!()*!427:7#4!@+7#,7@9*!0-+!*,-#-37,!:*.*9-@3*#(F!!

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

! !M7()!1:.1#,*<!7#!,-332#7,1(7-#!(*,)#-9-47*<!()*!E-+9:!)1<!8*,-3*!

()*!81<7<!-0!<-,7*(/F!!M7()-2(!9-<7#4!<74)(!-0!()*!@+*.7-2<!:*,1:*<!*H@*+7*#,*<A!

,1#!-#9/!317#(17#!7(N<!,-3@*(7(7.*!*:4*!8/!()*!*#:-4*#-2<!7##-.1(7.*!,1@1,7(/!-0!7(<!@*-@9*F

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

Page 11: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$#%&"'()*+),-./,+*$&$-')#'0#%1,),

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

()>*9>%6%)#?! "! 8(0#()5#! ()840#:(29! ;*9(57! *+! 6(5:*%5*)*6(5! *:(%)#2#(*)! =20!+*:6492#%8! #*! :%F4>%)2#%!%C(0#()'!52;25(#(%0! #$:*4'$! #$%! ()#:*845#(*)!*+!)%=!D)*=9%8'%!2)8!)%=!#%5$)*9*'(%0?!"!:2)'%!*+!;:(>2#%A;4&9(5!;2:#)%:0$(;0!2)8!;*9(57!#**90!=%:%!%0#2&9(0$%8<!()5948()'M!

Basquexport<! #*!;:*6*#%!#$%!%C;*:#0!2)8!#$%! ()#%:)2#(*)29(N2#(*)!*+!12034%!5*6;2)(%0?!

The Technology Park of Zamudio2)8!#$%!#:2)0+%:!2)8!8(00%6()2#(*)!*+!#%5$)*9*'7!2)8!())*>2#(*)?

Society for Industrial Promotion and Reconversion<! 2)! ()0#(#4#(*)!0;%5(29(N()'!()!#$%!;:*6*#(*)!2)8!200%006%)#!*+!#2D%*>%:0<!6%:'%:0<!2)8!#$%!2534(0(#(*)!*+!)%=!#%5$)*9*'7?

The Plan for Exceptional Relaunching<!#*!;:*6*#%!#$%!8%>%9*;6%)#!*+!06299!2)8!6%8(46A0(N%8!&40()%00%0?!

Euskadi Europa<!#*!;:%;2:%!#$%!5*4)#:7!+*:!()#%':2#(*)!()#*!#$%!I4:*;%2)!J)(*)?!

! B$%! 12034%! ;2:28('6! *+! #$%! ,-./0! =20! *)%! *+! :%5*)>%:0(*)! 2)8!:%0#:45#4:()'<!2!;%:(*8!*+!25#(>%! ()840#:(29!2)8!0*5(29!;*9(5(%0!#$2#!%)2&9%8!#$%!12034%!O*4)#:7!#*!9%2:)!#*!5*6;%#%!20!2)!%5*)*67!2)8!20!2!;%*;9%?!B$(0!;$20%!92(8!#$%!+*4)82#(*)0!+*:!8%>%9*;()'!2!5*6;%#(#(>%!2)8!$('$97!%8452#%8!0*5(%#7<!=(#$*4#!=$(5$!(#!=*498!$2>%!&%%)!(6;*00(&9%!#*!#25D9%!#$%!04&0%34%)#!0#2'%0?

Page 12: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$#%&"'()*+),-./#%0,)&)&#$'&$'/##0,*+)&#$

!"#$%&#'(()*#+&,-+.#-,#$%&#/0-"-.10#23+&&.&"$4#5&$6&&"#$%&#78*9:&#

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

80%1&A&# 8# *:??-+$1A&# 8"=# ?+-*?&+-:*# *-01&$<M# $%&# 5&=+-0F# -,# $%&# 78*9:&#;-:"$+<N*#0-.?&$1$1A&#8=A8"$83&*C### O&A&@-?.&"$# 1"# $%&# 78*9:&# ;-:"$+<# %8*# 5&&"# @&=# 5<# 8# *$+8$&310#?:5@10B?+1A8$&# 8@@18"0&M# :"=&+*$--=# 8*# 1"A&*$.&"$# 5<# $%&# ?+1A8$&# *&0$-+# 1"#

P#-,# $%&#&0-"-.<C##

!"# $%&#'(()*E# $%&#78*9:&#&0-"-.<Q

-,#0@:*$&+*(E#,801@1$8$&=#5<#"&$6-+F*#-,#A&*$&=#*$8F&%-@=&+*C#D%1*#$+8"*1$1-"#68*#

%13%@<#0-"$&"$1-:*C#RA&+#$%&#?8*$#=&08=&#8#%13%#@&A&@#-,#3-A&+".&"$#1"$&+A&"$1-"#1"#1"=:*$+<#%8=#@&=#$-#?+1A8$&#*&0$-+#=&?&"=&"0&#-"#$%&#3-A&+".&"$#61$%#+&38+=#$-#*$+8$&310#=&01*1-"B.8F1"3C#D%&#+&58@8"01"3#-,#$%&#?+1A8$&B?:5@10#+&@8$1-"*%1?#68*#&**&"$18@#$-#,-*$&+#8#0-.?&$1$1A&#&0-"-.<C

# !"#-+=&+# $-#*:*$81"# $%&#78*9:&#;-:"$+<N*#0-..1$.&"$# $-#0-.?&$1$1-"#1"A&*$.&"$*#6&+&#.8=&#1"#*01&"0&#8"=#$&0%"-@-3<

')E#$%&#1"$&+"8$1-"8@1G8$1-"#-,#

$%&#78*9:&#&0-"-.<E#8"=#$-#?+-.-$&#:"1A&+*8@#*$8"=8+=*#-,#9:8@1$<C#!"#'((S#$%&#78*9:&#K-A&+".&"$# *&$# :?# $%&#78*9:&#T:8@1$<# U-:"=8$1-"E# /V>W2X!DE#$-# ?+-.-$&# 9:8@1$<E# 1""-A8$1-"# 8"=# &J0&@@&"0&# $%+-:3%-:$# *-01&$<C# !"# '((Y#

78*9:&#;-:"$+<N*#1"$&+"8$1-"8@#1.83&''C#

Page 13: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$#%&"'()*+),-./$$#0+)&#$'&$'1##2,*+)&#$

! "#$!%&'()$!*$+,-$!#&.$!-+/0!1$$/!&''+23&4$5!634#!&/!$/47$,7$/$)73&-!',37348!6#32#!#&'!1$$/!4#$!1&'3'!+9! 4#$37!#3'4+7:!+9!07+64#!&/5!5$.$-+,;$/4<!!=)73/0!4#$!-&4$!>?4#!2$/4)7:!4#$!%&'()$!@+)/47:!$'4&1-3'#$5!34'!7$,)4&43+/!&'!&!,7+.35$7!+9!#30#!()&-34:!,7+5)24'<!A++4$5!3/!4#3'!47&5343+/8!4#$!%&'()$!@+)/47:!

+9!4#$!9+--+63/0!&/&-:'3'!63--!1$!&3;$5!&4!4#$!3/'434)43+/'!&/5!+70&/3B&43+/'!4#&4!537$24-:!4&C$!,&74!3/!4#$!7$'$&72#!&/5!$D,-+7&43+/!,7+2$''$'E><!!F!17+&5$7!.3'3+/!63--!5$4&3-!4#$!7$-$.&/2$!+9!+4#$7!$-$;$/4'!+9!'+23$4:!4+!4#$!3//+.&43+/!,7+2$''

EG<

! H/! >??E8! 4#$! %&'()$! I+.$7/;$/4! 7$2+0/3'$5! 4#$! /$$5! 4+! +/2$!&0&3/!47&/'9+7;8!4+!;+.$!&6&:!97+;!&!;+5$-!5$,$/5$/4!+/!&5+,43/0!9+7$30/!4$2#/+-+0:! &/5! 2+'4! &5.&/4&0$

EJ<! "#$! 2#&--$/0$! +9! $/5+0$/+)'! '+23&-8!

$2+/+;32! 5$.$-+,;$/48! &/5! $''$/43&-! 4+! ;&3/4&3/! &/5! 3;,7+.$! 4#$! '+23&-!6$-9&7$!':'4$;

EK

#&'! +70&/3'$5! 34'! '+23+L$2+/+;32! 9)/243+/'! &7+)/5! 4#$! 97&;$6+7C! +9! &/!3//+.&43+/!':'4$;8!6#32#!3'!,+6$7$5!1:!4#$!#);&/!2&,34&-!+9!34'!,$+,-$<

! "#$! 3//+.&43+/! ':'4$;! 3'! 1&'$5! ),+/! 4#$! 2+/2$,4)&-3B&43+/! +9!C/+6-$50$! 634#! &! -39$! +9! 34'! +6/8! 6#32#! 3'! 2+/'47)24$5! 3/! &/! &22);)-&43.$!&/5!':/$70$432!,7+2$''M!&!'$-9L')'4&3/3/0!2:2-$!+9!$5)2&43+/8! 7$'$&72#8!&/5!3//+.&43+/<! "#$! 3//+.&43+/! ':'4$;! #&'! 1$$/! 1)3-4! ),+/! 4#7$$! ,73/23,-$'! +9!$.+-)43+/&7:!2#&/0$M

@#&/0$! 3'! &! ':'4$;32!,#$/+;$/+/!&/5! 7$()37$'!)'! 4+! /+4! +/-:!1&7$! 3/!;3/5!4#$!1$#&.3+7!+9!$&2#!3/'434)43+/!3/!4#$!':'4$;8!1)4!&-'+!4#$!2+/4$/4!+9!4#$!7$-&43+/'#3,'!1$46$$/!3/'434)43+/'<!!

@#&/0$!;&:!1$!2&4&-:B$5!1:!;)-43,-$!2+0/343.$!'+)72$'8!7$()373/0!)'!4+!;)-43,-:!4#$!+,,+74)/34:!9+7!3/4$7L3/'434)43+/!3/4$7&243+/'<

!

Page 14: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

! "#$!%&'($)*'+,!-.! +#$!/0*12$!3-2&+),!4%56789%:!;<0,*!0!=$,!)-<$! '&!;)->-+'&?!+#$!@0*'A!)$*$0)A#!+#0+!*+'>2<0+$*!'&&-(0+'-&B!!"#)-2?#!+#$!*2;;-)+!-.!+#$!/0*12$!C-($)&>$&+!+#$!%&'($)*'+,D*!)$*$0)A#!'&!+#$!0)$0!-.!8E;$)'>$&+0<!FA'$&A$!?)$G!HIJ!.)->!IKKI!L!IKKMNH

B!!O2)+#$)>-)$P!+#$!/0*12$!C-($)&>$&+NQ

-.! @'-<-?,P! >0+$)'0<! ;#,*'A*P! 0;;<'$R! >0+#$>0+'A*P! 0&R! S$2)-*A'$&A$B! "#$!NM! +-!

! "#)$$! '&*+'+2+'-&*!#0($! +0=$&! <$0R$)*#';! )-<$*! '&! +#$!&$G!*+)0+$?,! +-!A2<+'(0+$P!A0)$!.-)!0&R!0++)0A+!+#$!&$A$**0),!#2>0&!A0;'+0<B!!

Basque Science, Technology and Innovation BoardT! +#$! #'?#$*+!@-R,!-.!;0)+'A';0+'-&P!0**$**>$&+!0&R!<$0R$)*#';!-&!+#$!;-<'A'$*!+#0+!)$(-<($!0)-2&R!*A'$&A$P!+$A#&-<-?,P!)$*$0)A#!0&R!'&&-(0+'-&B!

Ikerbasque !0++)0A+!'&+$)&0+'-&0<!$E;$)+*!+-!A0)),!-2+!+#$')!)$*$0)A#!'&!+#$!)$*$0)A#!A$&+$)*B

Innobasque!U!/0*12$!V&&-(0+'-&!W?$&A,T!+-!A--)R'&0+$!0&R!'>;$<!'&&-(0+'-&!'&! +#$!/0*12$!3-2&+),! '&!0<<! 0)$0*P!G'+#! +#$!0'>!-.! .-*+$)'&?!$&+)$;)$&$2)'0<!*;')'+!0&R!A)$0+'('+,B

! V&&-(0+'-&! '*! &-+! *$$&! 0*! <'>'+$R! +-! +#$! G-)<R! -.! @2*'&$**P! 0&R!$&A-2)0?$R! +#)-2?#-2+! *-A'$+,P! )$0A#'&?! A2<+2)$P! 0)+'*+'A! 0&R! A)$0+'($!'&R2*+)'$*P!$R2A0+'-&P!#$0<+#P!?-($)&0&A$!0&R!;2@<'A!0R>'&'*+)0+'-&B!W!)0&?$!-.!'&'+'0+'($*!#0*!*-2?#+!+-!'&*+'<<!'&&-(0+'-&!'&+-!+#$!/0*12$!*$&*$!-.!*$<.L'R$&+'+,B!!"#$!/0*12$!C-($)&>$&+!0&&-2&A$R!IKKM!0*! +#$!X"#$!Y$0)!-.! V&&-(0+'-&! '&!

*-A'0<!0&R!;-<'+'A0<!-)?0&'Z0+'-&*!+#)-2?#-2+!+#$!A-2&+),B!!

! V&! +#$!/0*12$!3-2&+),! '&&-(0+'-&!#0*!@$A->$! +#$!>-+'(0+'-&! .-)!0&!0<<!-.!*-A'$+,!0;;)-0A#!+-!*2*+0'&0@<$!#2>0&!R$($<-;>$&+B!!O)->!+#'*!;-'&+!-.!('$GP!0!A-2&+),!+#0+!'&A-);-)0+$*!'&&-(0+'-&!0&R!#2>0&'*>!-.!'+*!-)?0&'Z0+'-&*!'&+-!'+*!($),!'R$&+'+,!#0*!0!;-G$).2<!<$($)!.-)!+)0&*.-)>0+'-&B!

Page 15: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/01,-."23#-$",

!""#$%&!#"'!('%')*!&!)%+',%)&#*'#,'-)#"#.!)'/-$-+#0.-"&1'%"/'%'2%(!)')#*"-*(&#"-'&#'.%!"&%!"'%"/'!.0*#$-'&3-'(4(&-.'#,'(#)!%+'5-+,%*-6''73-',8"/%.-"&%+'9-4'&#'&3-'-)#"#.!)'%"/'(#)!%+'&*%"(,#*.%&!#"'#,'&3-':%(;8-'<#8"&*4'3%('2--"'&3-'!"&-"&!#"%+'%"/'0*#=*-((!$-'/-$-+#0.-"&'#,' !&('38.%"')%0!&%+6' '73-*-,#*-1' &#'%)3!-$-'(8(&%!"%2+-'38.%"'/-$-+#0.-"&1'%+#"=(!/-'%"'-)#"#.!)'(&*%&-=41'!&'!('-((-"&!%+'&#')#..!&'&#'%'(#)!%+')#3-(!#"'(&*%&-=46

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

' @#5-$-*1' (8)3' 0*#$!(!#"(' )%""#&' 2-' )#..!&&-/' 5!&3#8&' *-(&*%!"&6'

!"(&*8.-"&'!"'%&&%!"!"='A8(&%!"%2+-'@8.%"'B-$-+#0.-"&6'73-',%!+8*-'&#'%00+4'(8)3'0*!")!0+-('&#'(#)!%+'0#+!)4'!('#2$!#8('53-"'5-'+##9'%&'&3-'(#)!#C-)#"#.!)'0*-/!)%.-"&' #,' )#8"&*!-(' &3%&' !="#*-/' <#",8)!8(D' %/$!)-1' E53-"' 0*#(0-*!&4'%**!$-(1'/#'"#&'8(-'%++'#,'!&6F

' G!"%++41' &3-' )#..!&.-"&' &#' %' /4"%.!)' %"/' =-"-*%&!$-' )#")-0&!#"'#,' )8+&8*-' 3%(' 5!&3#8&' %' /#82&' 2--"' 2-3!"/' &3-' +-$-+' #,' (#)!#C-)#"#.!)'/-$-+#0.-"&'&3%&'&3-':%(;8-'<#8"&*4'3%('*-%)3-/'!"'&3-'+%(&'&3*--'/-)%/-(6''<8+&8*-' )#"&*!28&-(' &#' !"/!$!/8%+' -"*!)3.-"&1' %"/' -")#8*%=-(' !""#$%&!$-'-)#"#.!)'/-$-+#0.-"&6''

"#5'(--9('&#'0*#H-)&'!&('#5"'0-*(#"%+!&4'%"/'!/-"&!&41'"#&'%&')#",*#"&%&!#"'5!&3'#&3-*(1' 28&' )#-?!(&!"=1' ,*!-"/+41'5-+)#.!"=1' -"*!)3-/'24'#&3-*' !/-"&!&!-(' %"/'

)8+&8*-(6

Page 16: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/012#*&&*,#*'3.%$,$,/4'56%7-$,/'7*"7&*'-"'%'/&"8%&$+*6'9".&6

! "#$$%&$'(&! &#! )! $#*'+! #,! *'-'+#.$'(&! /)0'*! #(! %((#-)&%#(! )(*!*%,,'1'(&%)&%#(! 1'23%1'0! &4'! %(&'(0%-'! 30'! )(*! 3.*)&%(5! #,! $)&'1%)+! )(*!43$)(!1'0#316'07!84'!9)023'!"#3(&1:!4)0!$)*'!&4'!23)+%&:!#,!6#$.3+0#1:!'*36)&%#(;! #663.)&%#()+! )(*! 3(%-'10%&:! &1)%(%(5! )! .1%#1%&:<! 0#! )0! &#! .1#*36'!61')&%-';!'(&1'.1'('31%)+!.'#.+'!)/+'!&#!#.'1)&'!%(!)!5+#/)+%0'*!=#1+*7!>(!&4'!?@0&!6'(&31:!.'#.+'!)(*!&4'%1!'*36)&%#(!)1'!&4'!/)0%6!6).%&)+!#,!)!()&%#(7

! A31%(5! &4'! ')1+:! ?BBB0! &4'! ,#++#=%(5! .1%(6%.+'0! ='1'! '0&)/+%04'*! &#!.1#$#&'!23)+%&:!)(*!%((#-)&%#(!%(!&4'!6#$.3+0#1:!'*36)&%#(!0:0&'$C

A school for everyone! D! &4'! 6#(6'.&! #,! )(! %(6+30%-'! '*36)&%#(! .1#6'00!)&&'(&%-'! &#! &4'! (''*0! #,! 0&3*'(&0! &4)&! '$/1)6'0! &4'%1! 63+&31)+! )(*! 0#6%)+!*%-'10%&:;!)(*!.1#$#&'0!5'(*'1!'23)+%&:7

A better school!D!%(-'0&$'(&!%(!&4'!+')*'104%.!)(*!$)()5'$'(&!#,!'*36)&%#(!&#!.1#$#&'!23)+%&:!#,!+')1(%(5;!43$)(!1%54&0!)(*!.')6',3+!6#'E%0&'(6'7!

A school for the 21st century!D!&4'!%(&'51)&%#(!#,!$3+&%F+%(53)+%0$;!%(,#1$)&%#(!

'*36)&%#(;!)(*!030&)%()/+'!*'-'+#.$'(&!%(&#!&4'!+')1(%(5!'(-%1#($'(&7

! >(!@GGH@G!)(*!?BBI?B!&4'!9)023'!"#3(&1:!+)3(64'*!.+)(0!&#!/1')J!&4'!6#(6'.&!#,!&'1$%()+!'*36)&%#(!,#++#='*!/:!)!0'.)1)&'!.1#6'00!#,!'$.+#:$'(&7!!>(0&')*;!#663.)&%#()+!&1)%(%(5!%0!6##1*%()&'*!=%&4!&4'!(''*0!#,!&4'!'$.+#:'1;!)(*!4)0!/''(!%(&'51)&'*!%(&#!&4'!=#1J%(5!'(-%1#($'(&!)0!)(!#(F5#%(5;!+%,'F+#(5!.1#6'007

!!!!!! >(! @GGK?@! )(*! ?BBI??;! &4'! 9)023'! L#-'1($'(&! .)00'*! +'5%0+)&%#(!&#! .1#$#&'! 23)+%&:! %(! 4%54'1! '*36)&%#(;! )(*! '0&)/+%04! )! 0&1)&'5%6! .1#6'00!#,!)*).&)&%#(!&#!/1%(5!&4'!3(%-'10%&%'0!#,! &4'!9)023'!"#3(&1:! %(! +%('!=%&4! &4'!1'23%1'$'(&0!#,!&4'!9#+#5()!0:0&'$7!

!!!!!! 8#! '()/+'! )! *:()$%6;! '*36)&'*!.#.3+)&%#(! 0:0&'$0! #,! &1)%(%(5! )(*!+')1(%(5!04#3+*!)*).&!&4'$0'+-'0!&#!$3+&%.+:!&4'!.#%(&0!#,!)66'00!&#!'*36)&%#(;!)(*!/1#)*'(!&4'!06#.'!#,!.)1&%6%.)&%#(7

Page 17: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/0123."4*2*,-'"5')*%&-)'%,6'-)*'#"".6$,%-$",''"5'-)*'+"#$"7)*%&-)'%.*%

!"#$%&"!'!"!(#$ ")*%+,#$ "-($)./(&"!'($)0$ !1&+(%#!12$ "-($3(%+#$)0$ 4!'!12$ 0+(($ 0+)5$

#6#"%!1%.4($#3#"(57

8%#96($:(%4"-$;4%1$<==<><=?=<@$%1,$"-($A"+%"(2!&$;4%1$0)+$A)&!)>-(%4"-$B%+($

<==C><==DE

F('(4)G$ "%+2("#$ %1,$ #"+%"(2!(#$ )0$ "-($ :(%4"-$ ;4%1$ <==<><=?=$ %"$ %1$$

!1,!'!,6%4H$&)5561!"3$%1,$!1"(+>#(&")+!%4$4('(47$

I6%+%1"(($ %&&(##!.!4!"3$ ")$ %$ 96%4!"3$ -(%4"-&%+($ "-+)62-$ &)1"+%&"!12$$

B)1"+!.6"($ ")$ "-($,('(4)G5(1"$)0$ "-($A)&!)>:(%4"-$J+(%$ !1$&)>)+,!1%"!)1$

*!"-$"-($A)&!%4$A(+'!&(#H$"-($;+)'!1&!%4$B)61&!4#$%1,$"-($K)*1$B)61&!4#7$

L),(+1!M($ %1,$ %,%G"$ N#%O!,("M%$ .3$ !5G+)'!12$ "-($ #)&!%4$ %1,$ -(%4"-$

&%+($!10+%#"+6&"6+($1(&(##%+3$")$5(("$"-($1(*$,(5%1,#$G4%&(,$)1$"-(#($$

#(+'!&(#7$

J&"!'(43$ G%+"!&!G%"($ !1$ "-($ P6#O%,!$ ;4%1$ 0)+$ "-($ Q10)+5%"!)1$ A)&!("3$ .3$$

#3#"(5#7

B)1"+!.6"($ ")$ "-($ 2(1(+%"!)1$ %1,$ %GG4!&%"!)1$ )0$ +(#(%+&-H$ ,('(4)G5(1"H$

%1,$!11)'%"!)1$!1$"-($8%#96($;6.4!&$:(%4"-$A3#"(57

$ K-(#($2)%4#$#((O$")$5(("$"-($,(5)2+%G-!&$&-%44(12(#$)0$%1$%2(!12$

+(4('%1"$G+)0(##!)1%4#$56#"$5(("$ "-($2+)*!12$,(5%1,$ 0)+$#)&!%4$%1,$-(%4"-$

%44)&%"!)1$)0$"-(#($%##("#7$:)*('(+H$!"$56#"$1)"$.($0)+2)""(1$"-%"$"-($G+)'!#!)1$

)0$61!'(+#%4$-(%4"-&%+($!#$%1$(##(1"!%4$&)5G)1(1"$)0$%1$!1&46#!'($#)&!("3H$*-!&-$

(1%.4(#$%44$)0$!"#$&!"!M(1#$")$"%O($%1$%&"!'($+)4($!1$"-($&)55!"5(1"$")$#6#"%!1%.4($

-65%1$,('(4)G5(1"7

Page 18: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/0

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

Quality of Employment:!!"#$!9&1:6$!;+6,*%0!#&1!.&11$'!*#%$$!>,1*(*6*(+,&5!J3.5+03$,*!@5&,1

HK

&55! L+7! 1$$M$%1E! (,)56'(,8!3&%8(,&5(I$'! 1$83$,*1! +-! *#$!.+.65&*(+,! &,'! *#$!)#%+,()&550!6,$3.5+0$'=

Integration of immigrant population: "?+!9&1:6$!>33(8%&*(+,!@5&,1HN!?$%$!

'$1(8,$'! *+! (,*%+'6)$! *#$! %$&5(*0!+-! (33(8%&*(+,! (,*+! *#$!'&02*+2'&0! *&1M1!+-!.675()! &'3(,(1*%&*(+,=! "#$1$! .+5()($1! #&/$! 7$$,! 86('$'! 70! .%(,)(.5$1! +-!$:6&5(*0E!.&%*()(.&*(+,E!.675()!%$1.+,1(7(5(*0!&,'!)+2%$1.+,1(7(5(*0=!!

Support for families:!O$8(15&*(/$!*++51HP!#&/$!7$$,!'$/(1$'!*+!-+1*$%!%$1.$)*!-+%! *#$! '(/$%1(*0! +-! *#$! -&3(50E! &,'! .%+*$)*! *#$! %(8#*1! +-! &55! -&3(50!3$37$%1=!Q+*&750E! *&M(,8! (,*+! &))+6,*! *#$! 1.$)(&5! )#&%&)*$%(1*()1! &,'! 5$/$5! +-! ,$$'!+-! 7+*#! 5&%8$! &,'! 1(,85$! .&%$,*! -&3(5($1=! ! @%$/$,*(+,! .+5()($1! #&/$! 7$$,!

*%&(,(,8!*+!$,#&,)$'!.%+*$)*(+,!-+%!*#$!/()*(31!+-!'+3$1*()!/(+5$,)$=

Reconciling work and family life:!"#$1$!-&3(50!.5&,1!&51+!1$$M!*+!%$3+/$!*#$!7&%%($%1! *+!$3.5+03$,*!&%(1(,8! -%+3!.&%$,*#++'E!&,'!1(365*&,$+6150!)+%%$)*!*#$! 5(3(*&*(+,1! *#&*! ?+%M(,8! 5(-$! (3.+1$1! +,! -&3(50! 5(-$=! R$&16%$1! (,)56'$! &!

?#+!*&M$!5$&/$!+%!%$'6)*(+,!(,!*#$(%!#+6%1!*+!)&%$!-+%!&'65*!+%!(,-&,*!'$.$,'$,*1=

Social focus of housing policy:! "#$! O&,'! &,'! S%7&,! @5&,,(,8! <)*HT! #&1!7$$,!86('$'!70!&,!+/$%%('(,8!.#(5+1+.#0!+-!&))+33+'&*(+,!&1!&!7&1()!,$$'E!

:6&5(*0E!161*&(,&7(5(*0E!1&-$*0!&,'!(,,+/&*(+,=

Page 19: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/0123%&$-0'4*-5**,'6*,'7'8"9*,:';)*'<"&$-$#%&'<."=*#-'>".'-)*'?@+-'#*,-3.0

!"#!#"$%!$&'()#*&)&""($+#,-%#$.&#/-0($()!01#"-)(!0#!*2#&)-*-3()#)-*"$%4)$(-*#-,#$.&#5!"64&#7-4*$%+8##9*#:;<<#$.&#5!"64&#=-3&*>"#9*"$($4$&1#?3!@4*2&

A<1#B!"#

&"$!C0(".&2#$-#2&"('*1#/0!*1#(3/0&3&*$#!*2#!""&""#!)$(D($(&"#!(3&2#!$#'&*2&%#&64!0($+8##E(*)&#$.&*#,-4%#&64!0($+#/0!*"#.!D&#C&&*#2&D("&2#!*2#(3/0&3&*$&2#C+#$.&#5!"64&#F-D&%*3&*$8##9*#:;;;#$.&#G%2#?64!0($+#H0!*#B!"#)-*"$%4)$&2#$-#/%-3-$&#'&*2&%#3!(*"$%&!3(*'#!*2#$.&#/!%$()(/!$(-*#-,#B-3&*#(*#!00#B!0@"#-,#0(,&8

# 9*# AIIJ# !# ,-4%$.# C(00A;# -*# &64!0($+# C&$B&&*# 3&*# !*2# B-3&*# B!"#

!//%-D&2#C+# $.&#5!"64&#H!%0(!3&*$# $-# $!@&#/-"($(D&#!)$(-*# $-#&%!2()!$&# $.&#340$(/0&# ,-%3"#-,#2(")%(3(*!$(-*#!'!(*"$#B-3&*K# "-)(-L/-0($()!0#/!%$()(/!$(-*M#/-%$%!+!0#(*#)40$4%&#!*2#3&2(!M#!))&""#$-#&24)!$(-*1#&3/0-+3&*$1#!*2#C!"()#"-)(!0#%('.$"M#)-*)(0(!$(-*#-,#/&%"-*!01#,!3(0+#!*2#/%-,&""(-*!0#0(,&M#!*2#D(-0&*)&#!'!(*"$#B-3&*8#N*-$.&%#(3/-%$!*$#!"/&)$#)-D&%&2#C+#$.&#O!B#B!"#$.&#)%&!$(-*#-,# $.&#?64!0($+#P3C42"3!*8# Q.("# ("# !*# (*2&/&*2&*$# C-2+# &*"4%&"# $.!$# $.&#

"&)$-%8

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

# Q.%-4'.# /-0()(&"# -,# 3!(*"$%&!3(*'# !*2# /-"($(D&# !)$(-*# $.&# 5!"64&#7-4*$%+#.!"#"&$#!#C&*).3!%@# ,-%# $.&# ,-%340!$(-*#!*2# (*$&'%!$(-*#-,#&64!0($+#

N0$.-4'.#($#("#/-""(C0&#$-#"4%D(D&#B($.#T4"$#-*&#B(*'1#B&#*&&2#C-$.#B-%@(*'#(*#

Page 20: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(")*+$",'!-.%-*/0''1'#2&-2.%&'$3*,-$-0'"4*,'-"'-)*'5".&3

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

) >")&$/(%"!#!(")(*)#7$)$33$"#!'-)31;2!(#!/)&$-'#!("37!4)2$#,$$")-'"%9'%$)'".)/9-#9&$)#7$)?'389$)=(9"#&1)7'3)'/#!0$-1)/(;;!##$.)!#3$-*)#()#7$).$*$"3$)(*)')/9-#9&'-)!.$"#!#1)(4$")#()#7$),(&-.5)67$)@AAB)?'389$)=9-#9&'-)C-'"

DA)(9#-!"$.)

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

!3) "(#) #7$!&) ("-1) -'"%9'%$5) ) N&$"/7) '".) O4'"!37) '&$) #7$) PQ$&.$&'RS) 3$/(".)-'"%9'%$3)(*)#7$)?'389$)C$(4-$:),7!/7)!")#7$)@T3#)/$"#9&1)'&$)H(!"$.)21)#7!&.)-'"%9'%$3) (*) U"%-!37) '".) J$&;'"5) =("3$89$"#-1) #7$) ?'389$) =(9"#&1) 7'3).$0$-(4$.)')-'"%9'%$)4(-!/1

DT

!3)(*)4$&3("'-)0'-9$:)'".)-!"%9!3#!/)/($L!3#$"/$)!3)'")'33$#)*(&)/(7$3!(")'".)

+'"4(&':) H'-%!)'.!)4-'G'&':) H'-%!)'.!);9".9&'R:)/("#!"9$) #() &$3("'#$),!#7) #7$)4(-!/!$3)#7'#)4&(;(#$)'")(4$")?'389$)/9-#9&'-)!.$"#!#1E))Q?'389$)-'"%9'%$)%()(9#V)J()#()#7$)389'&$V)W4$")1(9&).((&3)#()#7$),(&-.VR)

D@

Page 21: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'(")*+,-)%*)(./0")%&123)$&",

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

% B)*% !667&5!1% &'% ()*%D*/*7!1% E!@% (&% F7&(*<(% ()*% G/5#7&/3*/(% &'% ()*%+!$,-*% ;&-/(79

HH% @!$% !667&5*=% #/% IJJK>% 7*67*$*/(#/8% !% 3#1*$(&/*% #/% ()*%

<&-/(79L$%<&33#(3*/(%(&%*/5#7&/3*/(!1%6&1#<#*$%'&<-$*=%09%$-$(!#/!01*%)-3!/%

!/=% '!-/!% @&-1=% 0*% $-$(!#/!01*:% B)*% E!@% !1$&% <&33#((*=% (&% !% 67&<*$$% &'%

<!6!<#(9%&'%'-(-7*%8*/*7!(#&/$:

% M/%NOOI%()*%$&<#!1%!/=%*<&/&3#<%!"*$%&'%=*5*1&63*/(%@*7*%#/(*87!(*=%@#()% ()*% !"*$% &'% */5#7&/3*/(!1% $-$(!#/!0#1#(9% ()7&-8)% ()*% ;&33#(3*/(% (&%.-$(!#/!0#1#(9%&'%()*%+!$,-*%;&-/(79HP:%B)*%'&11&@#/8%67#/<#61*$%@*7*%*$(!01#$)*=%(&%!1#8/%()*%<&/<*6($%&'%*,-#(!01*%87&@()%@#()%*/5#7&/3*/(!1%$-$(!#/!0#1#(9Q

Ethical code:%R-7%@!9%&'% ()#/A#/8>%5!1-*$>% 1#'*$(91*%!/=%<&/$-36(#&/%)!0#($%

Social cohesion and participation:%S11%$*<(&7$%&'%$&<#*(9%)!5*%!%7&1*%(&%61!9%#/%()*%(7!/$#(#&/%(&@!7=$%$-$(!#/!0#1#(9:

Principle of precaution: T*%3-$(%67&3&(*%!<(#&/%*5*79%(#3*%()*7*%#$%!%()7*!(%&'%=!3!8*%(&%()*%*/5#7&/3*/(:

Comprehensive focus:% B)*%*/5#7&/3*/(% 5!7#!01*% $)&-1=%0*% #/<1-=*=% #/%!11%6&1#<9%$*<(&7$:

B)*7*% 3!9% !/=% 3-$(% 0*% !% 7*=-<(#&/% #/% ()*% -$*% &'% /!(-7!1%7*$&-7<*$>%@)#1*%#/<7*!$#/8%67&=-<(#5#(9:

Strategic planning:%G/5#7&/3*/(!1%&0U*<(#5*$%3-$(%0*%()*%'7-#(%&'%()*%67&<*$$%

Page 22: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'(")*+,-)%*)(./0(1$2'3)(%',-)%*)(.$4,5+*""$".6,7887,3,7878

! "#!$%%$!&'(!)*+,-(!./-#&01!2/334&&(5!4&6+!+(78!&/!*#!(#940/#3(#&*7!

+&0*&(:1;< ;=!8/0!$%$%>!

?-*0*#&((!27(*#!*#5!'(*7&'1!*40@!A*&(0!*#5!7*#5B!

C(+D/#+4E7(!3*#*:(3(#&!/8!#*&-0*7!0(+/-02(+!*#5!A*+&(B!

F0/&(2&4/#!/8!G*&-0(!*#5!)4/549(0+4&1B!

)*7*#2(!&'(!#((5+!/8!D(0+/#*7!3/E474&1!*#5!&0*#+D/0&*&4/#B!

*59*#2(+!*#5!*5*D&4#:!&/!#(A!+4&-*&4/#+!*+!&'(1!*0(!5(&(2&(5H!!I'(!/EJ(2&49(+!

A(0(! E*+(5! /#! &'(! D04#24D7(+! /8! 2*-&4/#! *#5! D0(9(#&49(! *2&4/#@! 2/00(2&4/#!

/8!5*3*:(!D0(8(0*E71!*&! &'(!+/-02(@!*#5!(#940/#3(#&*7! 0(2/9(01H!I/!(#+-0(!

*22/-#&*E474&1! ,-*#&4&*&49(! 9*7-(+! *#5! 5(*574#(+! A(0(! *++4:#(5! 8/0! &'(!

*2'4(9(3(#&!/8!(#940/#3(#&*7!/EJ(2&49(+!*#5!:/*7+H

! I'(!5(9(7/D3(#&!D0/2(++!/8! &'(+(!:/*7+!*#5!/EJ(2&49(+!A*+!E*+(5!

/#! *! 2/334&3(#&! &/! *2&49(! 2//D(0*&4/#! E(&A((#! D-E742! 4#+&4&-&4/#+! *#5!

+/24*7! *:(#&+;K

7(9(7+!/8!:/9(0#3(#&@!*#5!)*+,-(!(2/#/342!*#5!+/24*7!*:(#&+H!

&/!*59*#2(!&/A*05+!+-+&*4#*E474&1!4#!&'(!)*+,-(!./-#&01>

"3D0/9(!(#940/#3(#&*7!7(:4+7*&4/#!*#5!'/A!4&!4+!*DD74(5H

L#2/-0*:(!&'(!3*0M(&!N2/3D*#4(+!*#5!2/#+-3(0+N!&/!*2&!4#!8*9/0!/8!&'(!

(#940/#3(#&H

"#&(:0*&(!&'(!(#940/#3(#&*7!9*04*E7(!4#!*77!/&'(0!D/7424(+H

O*M(!24&4P(#+@!2/3D*#4(+!*#5!4#+&4&-&4/#+!J/4#&71!0(+D/#+4E7(!8/0!!!!!!!!!!

3/54814#:!'*E4&+!4#!8*9/0!/8!+-+&*4#*E474&1H

F0/3/&(!0(+(*02'!2/#2(0#(5!A4&'!&'(!(#940/#3(#&H

L#:*:(!4#!(#940/#3(#&*7!2//D(0*&4/#!/#!*#!4#&(0#*&4/#*7!7(9(7H

Page 23: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'(")*+,-)%*)(./,0$.1),2.*$"3),4+$'*)(,41*".(

! "#$! %$&'%$! ()! *#$! +,,-.! /'.! &#'0'&*$012$%! 34! '! 3((.*! 15! .(&1'6!'/'0$5$..! '5%!7(.1*18$! '&*1(5.! *(! 70$.$08$! *#$! $5810(59$5*! 15! *#$!:'.;<$!=(<5*04>! "#$! )(66(/15?! %$&'%$! #'.! )(&<.$%! (5! *#$! 70(9(*1(5! ()! $))$&*18$!

@5810(59$5*'6!7(61&1$.!'0$!5(/!%$.1?5$%!15!0$&(?51*1(5!()!*#$!(8$0/#$6915?!

(5!&619'*$!&(5%1*1(5.

)(09<6'*$%!'!.$01$.!()!&(991*9$5*.!)(&<.$%!(5!)(<0!'0$'.A!$5$0?4B!*0'5.7(0*B!15%<.*04B!'5%! *#$!&(5.*0<&*1(5!.$&*(0>!"#$!.$&(5%!@5810(59$5*'6!C0'9$/(0D!E0(?0'99$!&'9$!15*(!$))$&*!15!F<5$!G--H!)(0!*#$!7$01(%!G--HIG-+->!J9(5?!1*.!

'?'15.*!&619'*$!&#'5?$!15!*#$!:'.;<$!J<*(5(9(<.!=(99<51*4A

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

! U5!X$&$93$0! G--H! *#$!:'.;<$!E6'5!J?'15.*!=619'*$!=#'5?$RY!/'.!'770(8$%!34!*#$!:'.;<$!Z(8$059$5*! *(!#'09(512$!:'.;<$!&619'*$!&#'5?$!0$6'*$%! 7(61&1$.!/1*#! @<0(7$'5![51(5! ?<1%$615$.>! "#0(<?#! '! &(970$#$5.18$!'770('&#!*#$!7019'04!?('6!/'.!*(!0$%<&$!&'03(5!$91..1(5.!*(!++\P!()!6$8$6.!0$&(0%$%!15!+,,->

Page 24: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'(")*+,-)%*)(./,-01)*$"*2+(,!"(%./3,4%*"15&%),*"6,7&2$+$)/

! "#! $%&'%! ($! )**$+,-./0! (0'! (0.%&! )1./! $2! 34/().#)5-'! 64+)#!

7'8'-$,+'#(9!(0'!:)/;4'!<$4#(%=!%'*$>#.?'&!(0'!#''&!($!(%)#/.(.$#!)@)=!2%$+!

)!+$&'-!$2!,%$&4*(.$#9!/4,,-=!)#&!*$#/4+,(.$#!&','#&'#(!4,$#!0=&%$*)%5$#!

(0./!(%)#/.(.$#!.#!.(/!!ABCDEFGFH!CI

!'#'%>=!/(%)('>=J

!@.(0!)#!).+! ($! %'&4*.#>!'#'%>=!*$#/4+,(.$#! .#!

>-$5)-!('%+/9!)#&!)!%'&4*(.$#!.#!'#'%>=!.#('#/.(=K!!

Increase renewable sources of energy@.#&9!)#&!5.$D24'-/K

Invest in energy infrastructures! ($! .+,%$8'! (0'! /'*4%.(=! $2! (0'! /4,,-=9!

*$+,'(.(.8'#'//! )#&! ;4)-.(=! $2! (0'! '#'%>=! /=/('+K! L.(0! %'>)%&! ($!!

'#8.%$#+'#()--=! /'#/.(.8'! ,%$&4*(.$#! 5=! +')#/! $2! *$+5.#'&! *=*-'! ,$@'%!

/()(.$#/K

Promote research and development!.#!(0'!:)/;4'!'#'%>=!/'*($%!($!.+,%$8'!

! 3.+.-)%-=9! ,$-.*.'/! (0)(! ,%$+$('! /4/().#)5-'! (%)#/,$%()(.$#! )%'! )#!

'//'#(.)-! *$+,$#'#(! $2! (0'! (%)#/.(.$#! )@)=! 2%$+! )! 0=&%$*)%5$#! &','#&'#(!

/$*.'(=K!"#!EFFE!(0'!:)/;4'!M$8'%#+'#(!-)4#*0'&!)!N)/('%!O-)#!2$%!34/().#)5-'!

P%)#/,$%(QF!@.(0!(0'!$5R'*(.8'!$2!&./*$##'*(.#>!(0'!&'+)#&!2$%!(%)#/,$%(!2%$+!

'*$#$+.*!&'8'-$,+'#(K! ! ! P0'!,-)#! /$4>0(! ($! )&&%'//! (0'! $8'%! %'-.)#*'! $#!

,%.8)('!8'0.*-'/!2$%!.#&.8.&4)-!+$5.-.(=!)#&!%$)&!(%)#/,$%(!)/!(0'!+')#/!2$%!(0'!

(%)#/,$%()(.$#!$2!>$$&/K!!P0'!O-)#!'#*$4%)>'&!(0'!4/'!$2!,45-.*!(%)#/,$%(!2$%!

,)//'#>'%/9!)#&!%).-!)#&!#)4(.*)-!(%)#/,$%(!2$%!>$$&/K

$2! +4-(.-'8'-! >$8'%#)#*'! ./! ,)%(.*4-)%-=! /4.()5-'K! "#! $%&'%! ($! )*0.'8'! (0./!

%'5)-)#*'!)(!&.22'%'#(!/*)-'/9!2%$+!-$*)-!)#&!&./(%.*(!-'8'-/!($!(0'!.#('%#)(.$#)-!

-'8'-9!+')/4%'/!+4/(!.#*-4&'!4%5)#!&'8'-$,+'#(9!()1'/9!('*0#$-$>=9!+$5.-.(=!

&'+)#&!+)#)>'+'#(!)#&!)-/$!(0'!*%')(.$#!$2!#'@!.#2%)/(%4*(4%'/K!3$-4(.$#/!

+4/(!5'!2$4#&!(0)(!)&),(!($!(0'!#''&/!$2!(0'!&'+)#&!2$%!+$5.-.(=!)#&!&'+)#&/!

2$%!'#8.%$#+'#()-!/4/().#)5.-.(=K!

Page 25: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&#'()*+,-&./#'.0'1,.).2+,'3/.4&5

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

! U.+1!#0&'&3+0!,%&9-.!.$1!G##'!)#/#')#'-!&'!-.#!6$17*#!4&*'-%(A1!

/#%0#'-$,#!&5!BCD!,#'#%$-#)!G(!-.#!+')*1-%+$8!1#0-&%!%#8$-+E#!-&!-.#!%#1-!&5!-.#!#0&'&3(!.$1!G##'!1*G1-$'-+$88(!.+,.#%!+'!-.#!6$17*#!4&*'-%(!-.$'!G&-.!H/$+'!$')!-.#!L*%&/#$'!O'+&':

! V+-.&*-!)&*G-K!-.+1!0&33+-3#'-K!)#E+1#)!$')!$00&3/8+1.#)!-.%&*,.!1#85! ,&E#%'3#'-K! 9$1! -.#! W#(! -&! -.#! +3/%&E#)! /#%5&%3$'0#! &5! -.#! 6$17*#!#0&'&3(:! U&)$(! -.#! 9&%8)! 1/#$W1! $G&*-! &G1#%E+',! -.#! %#$8! #0&'&3(! -&!

&5! -.#!)#8+G#%$-#!0&'1+)#%$-+&'!&5!$!0&*'-%(A1!#0&'&3+0!1-%*0-*%#! +'!&%)#%! -&!-$0W8#!-.#!0.$',#1K!0.$88#',#1!$')!-%$'15&%3$-+&'1!-.$-!.$E#!-&!G#!5$0#):

! P'!-.#!?<1-!0#'-*%(!#0&'&3+0!,%&9-.!.$1!%#7*+%#)!0&'1-$'-!-#0.'&8&,+0$8!+''&E$-+&'K! -.%&*,.! $! 1-%$-#,+0! /*G8+0M/%+E$-#! 0&33+-3#'-! -&! %#1#$%0.! $')!

5%&3!S=T:?!3+88+&'!L*%&1!I<:<<R!&5!BCDJ!<==>K!-&!<KSXY:Y!3+88+&'!L*%&1!I<:=TRJ!

BCDK!,%&9+',!5$%!18&9#%!5%&3!@:>ZR!+'!<==>!-&!<:SYR!+'!?@@>:

Page 26: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&#'()*+,-&./#'.0'1.,+-%'2.3"#+.)'

! "#!$%&'(!)*'+,%-#./0!,$!&1'!23#&!4'$&-*/!5!1,61./!'(-75&'(!#%7,'&/!15#!8''$!)*'*'9-,#,&'!:%*!,$$%+5&,+'!('+'.%);'$&!,$!&1'!<5#9-'!4%-$&*/=!!>1*%-61!&1'! 2???#! &1'! <5#9-'! 4%-$&*/@#! 7%;).'&,%$! *5&'! %:! 7%;)-.#%*/! '(-75&,%$!*';5,$'(!)5*5..'.!A,&1! &1'!B-*%)'5$!C$,%$!5+'*56'0! *'571,$6!DEF! ,$!2??E=!!

<5#9-'! 4%-$&*/@#! '7%$%;,7! :%7-#! %$! 1,61G&'71! ,$$%+5&,%$! ,&! ,#! ,;)%*&5$&!

577%-$&!:%*!2DF!%:!('6*''#!%8&5,$'(!,$!&1'!<5#9-'!4%-$&*/!,$!2??D0!8/!:5*!&1'!1,61'#&!*5&'!,$!B-*%)'H3=!!

! >1'! '7%$%;,7! #-77'##! %:! &1'! <5#9-'! 4%-$&*/! 15#! &*5$#.5&'(! ,$&%!5! )*%(-7&,+'! #%7,'&/=! ! I*%;! 2???! &%! 2??E! &1'! <5#9-'! 4%-$&*/! *'(-7'(! ,&#!-$';).%/;'$&! *5&'! :*%;! 32=3F! &%! J=HF=! K%&58./0! &1'! <5#9-'! 4%-$&*/! 15#!8''$!58.'! &%! *'(-7'! ,&#! .%$6G&'*;!-$';).%/;'$&! *5&'! :*%;!5! *'.5&,+'./!1,61!*5&'!%:!D=EF!,$!3LLL!&%!?=LF!,$!2??E=!!".&1%-61!&1'!2??E!:';5.'!';).%/;'$&!*5&'!MNE=EFO!A5#!#.,61&./!.%A'*!&15$!&1'!B-*%)'5$!C$,%$!5+'*56'!MNL=3FO0!&1,#!

*5&'!15#!1,#&%*,75../!8''$!1,61'*!&15$!&1'!BC!5+'*56'0!*'571,$6!DJ=3F!,$!2??E!7%;)5*'(!&%!D2=EF=!

! >1,#! #-77'##! 15#! '$58.'(! &1'! <5#9-'! P%+'*$;'$&! &%! 7%;;,&!

I%*!'Q5;).'0!'Q)'$(,&-*'!%$!1%-#,$6!5$(!';'*6'$7/!#-))%*&!,$7*'5#'(!:*%;!JL=2!;,..,%$!B-*%#! ,$! 2???! &%! 2R3=3!;,..,%$!B-*%#! ,$! 2??E=! ! S-8.,7! #)'$(,$6!*'.5&'(!&%!:5;,./!)*%&'7&,%$0!5#!%-&.,$'(!,$!&1'!I5;,./!S.5$0!,$7*'5#'(!:*%;!NNN!;,..,%$!B-*%#!,$!2??H!&%!E2?!;,..,%$!B-*%#!,$!2??E=!!>1'#'!,$+'#&;'$&#!15+'!15(!5!*';5*T58.'!,;)57&!%$!<5#9-'!U%7,'&/=!!V$!2???!&1'!*5&'!%:!&1'!*,#T!%:!)%+'*&/!M3D=3FO!A5#!1,61'*!&15$!&1'!B-*%)'5$!5+'*56'!M3JFO0!/'&!8/!2??D!,&!15(!8''$!*'(-7'(!&%!3H=EF0!8'.%A!&1'!BC!5+'*56'!*5&'!%:!3DF=!

! I-*&1'*;%*'0!&1'!<5#9-'!4%-$&*/!15#!;5('!65,$#!,$!&'*;#!%:!6'$('*!'9-5.,&/!,$!)%.,&,75.!*')*'#'$&5&,%$=!!>1'!<5#9-'!S5*.,5;'$&!15#!,$7*'5#'(!&1'!)*%)%*&,%$!%:!:';5.'!WS#!3LLD!:*%;!,$!2HF!,$!3LLD!&%!NRF!,$!2??E0!5$(!&1'!S*%+,$7,5.!4%-$7,.#!15#! ,$7*'5#'(! :';5.'!;';8'*#1,)! :*%;!3DF! ,$!3LLN! &%!H3F!,$!2??D=

Page 27: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&#'()*+,-&./#'.0'1)2+/.)3")&-%'4$#&-+)-5+%+&6

! "##$%&'!&$!%()*+(!&,(!-.(%-/(!0(.(0!$#!(12''2$3'!&$!4456!$#!4778!0(.(0'!9:!;84;!',$<!12=()!%('*0&'>!!?32&2-00:!(12''2$3'!+0219()!&$!-!@(-A!$#!4;B>C6!23!;88;D!9*&!,-.(!9((3!+$3'(+*&2.(0:!%()*+()!:(-%E$3E:(-%!&$!-!0(.(0!$#!44F>C6!23!;88F>!!G-+%$!-3-0:'2'!$#!(12''2$3!&%(3)'!'*//('&'!&,-&!&,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:!',$*0)!(.(3&*-00:!%(-+,!2&'!/$-0D!9*&!<200!%(I*2%(!)(&(%123()!(##$%&'>!

! K('@2&(!&,(!#-+&!&,-&!&,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:!,-'!+$112&&()!&$!23)*'&%2-0!@%$)*+&2$3!2&!,-'!'*9'&-3&2-00:!%()*+()!&,(!(3(%/:!23&(3'2&:!$#!2&'!(+$3$1:>!!L,(!"*%$@(-3!M32$3!1(-'*%('!&,(!(3(%/:!23&(3'2&:!$#!-3!(+$3$1:!9:!&,(!(I*-&2$3!$#!/%$''!)$1('&2+!(3(%/:!+$3'*1@&2$3!N1(-'*%()!23!A20$/%-1'!$#!(I*2.-0(3&!$20O!)2.2)()!9:!PKQ!@(%!&,$*'-3)!"*%$'>!"3(%/:!23&(3'2&:!23!&,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:!#(00!#%$1!4CB>F!23!477F!&$!45B>R!23!;88FD!#-%!9(0$<!&,(!"*%$@(-3!M32$3!-.(%-/(!

@$'2&2$3'!23!&,2'!@-%&2+*0-%!23)(=>

! ?3! ;88C! &,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:! +-1(!'(+$3)! 23! &,(!"*%$@(-3!M32$3S'!

$#!T@-23!23!&,2%)!@0-+(>!!U(-.23/!3$!)$*9&!23!&,(!I*-02&:!$#!&,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:S'!@$02+2('!+$112&&()!&$!(3.2%$31(3&-0!'*'&-23-9202&:>

! V$<(.(%D!@%2.-&(!+-%!*'-/(D!&,(!1(-3'!$#!&%-3'@$%&!&,-&!(12&'!&,(!1$'&!@(%!+-@2&-!+-%9$3!(12''2$3'!23&$!&,(!-&1$'@,(%(D!,-'!23+%(-'()!#%$1!R5>B6!&$!RF>B6!$#!&$&-0!&%2@'!#%$1!;88R!&$!;88W>!!Q*902+!&%-3'@$%&-&2$3!$.(%!&,(!'-1(!@(%2$)!-0'$!23+%(-'()!#%$1!4R>F6!&$!45>C6!$#!&%2@'D!9*&!23!)(&%21(3&'!$#!&%2@'!9:!#$$&>!!?3!$%)(%!&$!1((&!2&'!(12''2$3'!&-%/(&'!&,(!H-'I*(!J$*3&%:!<200!3(()!&$!1-A(!/%(-&(%!@%$/%(''!23!&,(!)(.(0$@1(3&!$#!'*'&-23-90(!&%-3'@$%&-&2$3>!

! ?3! +$3+0*'2$3D! -+,2(.23/! (3.2%$31(3&-0! '*'&-23-9202&:! %(1-23'! -!

2'!9(23/!1-)(!&,%$*/,!&,(!H-'I*(!Q0-3!X/-23'&!J021-&(!J,-3/(D!-3)!-0&,$*/,!&,(! %('*0&'! %(-+,()!$.(%! %(+(3&!:(-%'!-%(!,(-)23/! 23! &,(! %2/,&!)2%(+&2$3! &,2'!)$('!3$&!/*-%-3&((!&,-&!2&!<200!1((&!2&'!(12''2$3'!&-%/(&'>!

Page 28: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&#'$(()*+

! "#$! $%&'()*&+! &,! )#$!-./0($!1&(+)23! &%$2! )#$! 4./)! )#*2)3! 3$.2/! #./!5$$+!2&&)$6!*+!.+!$)#&/!&,!$7&+&8*7!92&:)#!.)!)#$!/$2%*7$!&,!)#$!7&88(+*)3;!7&84$)*)*%$+$//!*+!/&'*6.2*)3<

! =>?! 4$2! 7.4*).! #./! 92&:+! $@4&+$+)*.''3! /*+7$! )#$! 2$7&%$23! &,!.()&+&83<! ! A+! 4.2.''$'B! .,)$2! *+6(/)2*.'! 2$/)2(7)(2*+9! .+6! 2$7&+%$2/*&+! *+! )#$!CDEF/B! (+$84'&38$+)! #./! 6$7'*+$6! 7&+)*+(&(/'3<! ! "#*/! )2.+/,&28.)*&+! &,!)#$! -./0($!1&(+)23! #.%$! 5$$+! 6$4$+6$+)! &+! .! 42&6(7)*%$! .+6! *++&%.)*%$!$7&+&83B!9(*6$6!53!8*72&G$7&+&8*7!4&'*7*$/!.+6!/(44&2)$6!53!.!7&88*)8$+)!

)#.)! 42&6(7$/! #*9#! 0(.'*)3! 9&&6/! .)! )#$! 7())*+9! $69$! &,! )$7#+&'&93B! .+6! .!7(')(2.''3!6*/)*+7)!/&7*$)3!+(2)(2$6!53!)#$!,2$$!$@7#.+9$!&,!*6$./!.+6!*+,&28.)*&+<

Page 29: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&#'()*%$#+(),

! "#$! %&'()! *$+$,-.'$)/! 0)1$2! 3%*04! 56! (! 67)/#$/58! 5)158(/-9! -:! (!8-&)/97;6!,$+$,!-:!1$+$,-.'$)/<!.9-1&8$1!=7!/#$!>)5/$1!?(/5-)6@!"#$!%*0!56!()!5)158(/-9!/#(/<!5)!-&9!A&1B'$)/<!.9$6$)/6!,5'5/(/5-)6!/-!15(B)-65)B!/#$!1$B9$$!-:!1$+$,-.'$)/!-:!(!8-&)/97!5)!/$9'6!-:!$C&5/(=,$!-9!1$'-89(/58!1$+$,-.'$)/@!!%-D$+$9<!=7!(66$665)B!(BB9$B(/$!6-85(,!5)158(/-96!5)!(115/5-)!/-!E*F!/#$!%*0!

GH<!1$6895=$1!=7!

I/5B,5/JGK!(6!(!)$8$66(97!/9()65/5-)!5)!/#$!8-)8$./&(,5J(/5-)!-:!.9-B9$66!L:9-'!

.9-1&8/5-)! /-!D$,,M=$5)B@N! "#56!D(6! /#$! :&)1('$)/(,! 9$(6-)! :-9! /#$!O(6C&$!E-+$9)'$)/;6! 9$C&$6/! /#(/! /#$! >)5/$1! ?(/5-)6! 5)8-9.-9(/$! /#$! P&/-)-'-&6!Q-''&)5/7!-:!/#$!O(6C&$!Q-&)/97!5)/-!5/6!9$.-9/!-)!/#$!%*0@!0)!/#$!=$,-D!/(=,$!D$!8()!-=6$9+$!/#$!.$9:-9'()8$!-:!/#$!O(6C&$!Q-&)/97!(6!D#-,$<!9565)B!/-!(!,$(15)B!.-65/5-)!5)!/#$!%*0@!

! "#$!O(6C&$!.&=,58!(1'5)56/9(/5-)6!#(+$!B$)$9(,,7!8(995$1!-&/!(!9(/5-)(,!

'-1$,!-:!O(6C&$!6$,:MB-+$9)'$)/<!.(9/58&,(9,7!/#$!R8-)-'58!PB9$$'$)/@!"#56!$/#58(,,7! 195+$)! =&/! (&6/$9$! (..9-(8#! /-! .&=,58! 6.$)15)B! #(6! $)(=,$1! /#$!O(6C&$!Q-&)/97! /-!(8#5$+$!6-'$!-:! /#$! ,-D$6/! ,$+$,6!-:!B9-66!8-)6-,51(/$1!B-+$9)'$)/!1$=/!5)!R&9-.$

GG@!!"#$!O(6C&$!Q-&)/97!)-D!6$$S6!/-!/9()6'5/!/#$!

9$6-&98$6!/-!1$+$,-.!5))-+(/5+$!51$(6@!"#$!8-)8,&65-)!56!/#$9$:-9$!8,$(9T!/#$!

#(6!'$()/!B9$(/$9!D$,,M=$5)B<! ()1! /#(/! /#$9$!(9$! +5(=,$!(,/$9)(/5+$6! /-!)$-M,5=$9(,56'@

Page 30: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'%()**"$$

! "#$%! &'()*+,-! #.%! +*/#.%$0+&! -#.-! -#+!1.%2)+! 3+'/4+! #.5+! 6'-#!*.$,-.$,+&!.!&$%-$,(-!()4-)7.4! $&+,-$-8!.,&!.&./-+&! -'! -#+!(#.,9$,9! -$*+%! -'!6+!.*',9!-#+!:'74&!4+.&+7%!$,!;)%-.$,.64+!<)*.,!=+5+4'/*+,->!"#+!7+%)4-%!(',(4)&+!-#.-!.!('**$-*+,-!-'!.!%8%-+*!'?!$,,'5.-$',!#.%!6++,!?),&.*+,-.4!$,! 7.$%$,9! -#+! %/++&! '?! 97':-#@!:#$4%-!*.$,-.$,$,9! %'($.4! .,&! +,5$7',*+,-.4!6.4.,(+>!

! "#+!/7+5$')%!(#./-+7!7+5$+:+&!&.-.!-#.-!+,&'7%+&!-#+!+A$%-+,(+!'?!.!*'&+4!'?!%)%-.$,.64+!#)*.,!&+5+4'/*+,-!$,!-#+!1.%2)+!B'),-78>!"#+!1.%2)+!B.%+!&+*',%-7.-+%! -#.-!97':-#!%#')4&!,'-!6+!5$+:+&!%$*/48!.%!.!*.--+7!'?!C+(','*$(!7.-$',.4$-8D!6)-!(.,!.4%'!$,(4)&+!%'($.4!'6E+(-$5+%!.,&!+-#$(.4!5.4)+%>!!

6+!.79)+&!-#.-!-#+!?'44':$,9!F+8!&$??+7+,-$.4%!*.&+!-#+!%-7.-+98!'?!;)%-.$,.64+!<)*.,!=+5+4'/*+,-!$,!1.%2)+!%'($+-8!/'%%$64+>

+%,%-'.*"/&0'.%1.2%30$0'.%'4%1%*').&5#

G)7'/+.,$%*@! -#+! 1.%2)+! 3+'/4+! #.5+! (4.$*+&! .(-$5+! /7'-.9',$%*H! -#+$7!':,!/4.(+!.,&!-#+$7!':,!5'$(+>!I+!#.5+!-7$+&!-'!(',-7$6)-+@!#)*648!6)-!:$-#!(',5$(-$',@!:$-#!')7!()4-)7+@!4.,9).9+@!:.8!'?!),&+7%-.,&$,9!:'7F@!+&)(.-$',@!('*/.,$+%@!%.5$,9%@!%'4$&.7$-8@!%'($+-8!.,&@!,':@!.!*'&+4!'?!%)%-.$,.64+!#)*.,!&+5+4'/*+,->!"#+!1.%2)+!*'&+4!#.%!6++,!/'%%$64+!6+(.)%+!.!%#.7+&!5$%$',!'?!.!('),-78!+A$%-+&>

! "#+!1.%2)+!3+'/4+!.%/$7+!-'!.!5$%$',!'?!.!('),-78!'/+,!-'!-#+!:'74&!6)-!:$-#!&++/!()4-)7.4!7''-%>!"#+!.$*!$%!$,-+97.-$',!$,-'!-#+!94'6.4$0+&!:'74&!:#$4%-!

J,,.,KL!:$%+48!/)-! $-@!C:+!(.,! 4'5+!:#.-!:+!.7+@!:$-#')-!#.-$,9!:#.-!:+!.7+!

,'->D!M,!-#+!NO%-!(+,-)78!-#+!1.%2)+!3+'/4+!%++F!-'!6+!+,7$(#+&!68!-#+!:'74&!.,&!(',-7$6)-+! -'! -#+!94'6.4!*P4.,9+!:$-#!')7! ':,!),$2)+!()4-)7+>!Q)7! %+4?!

:+!#.5+!-.F+,>!

Page 31: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!!"#"$%&'()"*(&)('+%,-".%'/01%"-02*,3#-',4&.("-&'.5('+%,-

! "! #$%$&'! &(! )&*'+,-! $%! $'.$%/0'%12304! 5670'! +70,0! $%! '&! #$%$&'4! +70!

/0&/30! /0,$%78! 9,0%$.0'+! :,1';3$'! <=! >&&%0#03+! %1$.! 6$+7! *'.&*2+0.! 0((0)+?@

=!

A$+7&*+! #$%$&'! +70,0! $%! '&! 301.0,%7$/4!2*+!6$+7!1! %71,0.!#$%$&'!&(! )&*'+,-! +70!

B&%+!%*))0%%(*3!&(!301.0,%7$/%!$%!/&%%$230C!301.0,%7$/!%71,0.!20+600'!/*23$)!

1.B$'$%+,1+$&'!1'.!%&)$13!$'$+$1+$#0=!!D71,0.!301.0,%7$/!+71+!0'1230%!+70!)$+$E0',-!

0)&'&B$)!1'.!%&)$13!.0#03&/B0'+=!

! A0!203$0#0!$'!+70!0#&3*+$&'1,-!)71,1)+0,!&(!0)&'&B$)!.-'1B$)%!&#0,!51!

7$%+&,$)138!B0+7&.&3&F$)13!$'.$#$.*13$%B4!/1,+$)*31,3-!+70!'0&)31%%$)13!)&')0/+$&'%!

&(!/0,(0)+!B1,;0+%!1'.!+70!20'0#&30'+!/31''0,?G

=!9&3$+$)134!0)&'&B$)!1'.!%&)$13!

$')0'+$#0%!+71+!F*$.0!+70!1)+$&'!&(!1F0'+%=!A0!$'%$%+!H!/1,1/7,1%$'F!I&,+7!H!+71+!+70!

2-! +70!61-! +71+! $'%+$+*+$&'%!0#&3#0?J

=!A0!1,0!'&+!&'3-!%1-$'F! +71+!1'!0)&'&B-!

)1''&+!(*')+$&'!6$+7&*+!1'!$'%+$+*+$&'13!(,1B06&,;4!2*+!+71+!0)&'&B$)!,0%*3+%!6$33!

.0/0'.4!(*'.1B0'+133-4!&'!+70!)1/1)$+-!+&!),01+0!1'!$'%+$+*+$&'13!(,1B06&,;!+71+!

1)+%!1%!1!.,$#$'F!(&,)0!(&,!#$+13$+-!1'.!),01+$#$+-=

! K'! +7$%! %0'%0! 60! 1,0! ,0)&F'$E$'F! +70! #13*0! &(! +70! 5$'%+$+*+$&'13$%+8!

,0)&BB0'.1+$&'%!+71'!1%!1!2&.-!&(!+7&*F7+!6$+7!0'&*F7!)1/1)$+-!+&!20)&B0!1!

+70&,0+$)13!(,1B06&,;!&(!,0(0,0')0=!"%!1!)&'%0L*0')0!&(!+70!/&3$+$)134!%&)$13!1'.!

0)&'&B$)!+,1'%(&,B1+$&'%!+71+!1,0!+1;$'F!/31)04!+70!%+1+0!71%!1'!0#0,!F,&6$'F!

,&30!$'!F&#0,'$'F!1'!0#0,!B&,0!)&B/30M!,013$+-=!!K'+0,#0'+$&'$%+!1//,&1)70%!)1'!

+1;0!&'!B1'-!(&,B%4!1%!)1'!20!6$+'0%%0.!$'!+70!#1,$0+$0%!&(!0)&'&B$)!%-%+0B%!

6$+7$'! N*,&/0=! "'! 0#&3*+$&'1,-! #$%$&'! &(! 0)&'&B$)! 1)+$#$+-?O

71%! 0'1230.! +70!

#$%$&'%!/,0%0'+=!D*)7!1'!1//,&1)7!71%!0'1230.!+70!P1%L*0!Q&*'+,-!+&!1.&/+!

1!#$%$&'!+71+!+1;0%!$'+&!1))&*'+!$'%+$+*+$&'13$%+!1%/0)+%!+&!1,+$)*31+04!0M/31$'!1'.!

B1'1F0!&*,!0)&'&B$)!,013$+-4!1%!%00'!$'!+70!P1%L*0!K''&#1+$&'!D-%+0B=!

! K'%+$+*+$&'13!)71'F0!$%!1!(*'.1B0'+13!.,$#$'F!(&,)0!(&,!.0#03&/B0'+4!1'.!$%!

+70!(,*$+!&(!$'+0,1)+$&'!20+600'!$'%+$+*+$&'%!1'.!&,F1'$E1+$&'%!RF,&*/%!&(!$'.$#$.*13%!

*'$+0.!6$+7!1!)&BB&'!/*,/&%0S!$'!1,01%!&(!*')0,+1$'+-!1'.!)&B/0+0')0=!P*+!60!

B*%+!'&+!(&,F0+!+71+!+&!20!0((0)+$#04!$'%+$+*+$&'%!B*%+!20!1))0/+0.!1'.!%&)$133-!

,0)&F'$E0.=!"%!T,$&3!/&$'+%!&*+4! $'%+$+*+$&'13!.0#03&/B0'+!/&3$)$0%! +71+!B0,03-!

Page 32: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'($%")*+%&"+","+-%&*.#-/*-%0*1-%"02"*"-*$%-"30#*1$%%-"*4,$#$%"00*"305*6+((*.,%1"+-%*1-##01"(5

78

9* :%* "3+&* &0%&0;* 0$13* 01-%-/5;* +%1(,<+%4* "30* =$&>,0*

&-1+$(*$%<*01-%-/+1*#0$(+"59*?3$#0<*',@(+1*(0$<0#&3+'*1-//+""0<*"-*'0-'(0*$%<*"30+#**60((A@0+%4;* "-40"30#*6+"3*$%*,%0>,+B-1$(*1-//+"/0%"* "-*@,+(<+%4*$*&"#$"04+1*',@(+1A'#+B$"0* $((+$%10* "-* 40%0#$"0* 60$("3* $%<* '#-4#0&&;* 3$&* 0%$@(0<* "3+&*=$&>,0*C-,%"#5*"-*@-$&"*$*B0#5*'-60#.,(*"#$%&.-#/$"+B0*(0B0#9

!!!"#"$"%&''()'*+)")&"),*"-*./"*%&+&'0

* D%*/$%5* -11$&+-%&* #,%%+%4* $4$+%&"* "30* 4#$+%* $4$+%&"* -.* %0-(+@0#$(*+%"0((01",$(* $%<* '-(+"+1$(* "3-,43"* '#0B$+(+%4* +%* ?'$+%* $%<* E,#-'0* &+%10* "30*FGH8&;*"30*=$&>,0*C-,%"#5*3$&*/$<0*$*&,&"$+%0<*1-//+"/0%"*"-*+%<,&"#5*$%<*"30*'#-<,1"+B0*01-%-/59**

* I0%060<*+%<,&"#+$(+J$"+-%;*1-//+"/0%"*"-*"013%-(-45*$%<*$&&-1+$"0<*

'-(+15;*$%<*&-1+$(*$6$#0%0&&*3$B0*$((*@00%*.-,%<$"+-%&*-%*63+13*"30*&"#$"04+1*<0B0(-'/0%"*-.*"30*=$&>,0*C-,%"5*3$&*@00%*@,+("9**C-%"+%,0<*&,110&&*-.*"30*1-//+"/0%"* "-* "30*#0$(*01-%-/5*3$&*@00%*<0'0%<0%"*-%* "3#00*K05* .$1"-#&L*$1"+B0* +%<,&"#+$(* '-(+15* .-1,&0<* -%* $%* +%%-B$"+B0* 01-%-/5M* 1(,&"0#+J$"+-%* -.*+%<,&"#5* +%* '#-<,1"+B0* 13$+%&M* $%<* "30* #-(0* -.* 4-B0#%/0%"* "-* .$1+(+"$"0* "30*#0($"+-%&3+'*@0"600%*"30*01-%-/5*$%<*&-1+0"59

* N30*<01+<0<*1-//+"/0%"*"-*"30*!#0$(*01-%-/5)*3$&*@00%*"30*<#+B+%4*.-#10* @03+%<* "30* =$&>,0* '-(+"+1$(* $%<* &-1+$(* '#-O01"9* * P,#"30#/-#0;* 630%*

!1"#"2,*"3&%(./"3).)*4"."5)-.)*60"7(),"8*0*5".+9":.%*5;

* N30*&,110&&*-.*"30*=$&>,0*C$&0*6-,(<*%-"*3$B0*@00%*'-&&+@(0*6+"3-,"*',""+%4*'0-'(0*Q*/0%*$%<*6-/0%*"#0$"0<*0>,$((5*Q*$"*"30*10%"0#*-.*"30*'#-O01"9**D%0*-.*"30*4#0$"0&"*.$+(,#0&*-.*%0-A(+@0#$(*01-%-/+1*$%<*'-(+"+1$(*"3-,43"*3$&*@00%*+"&*$@$%<-%/0%"*-.*3,/$%+"5*"-*"30*+/',(&0&*-.*"30*/$#K0"9**R0$<+%4*"-*$*'$#$<+4/*13$#$1"0#+J0<*@5*"30*&,440&"+-%;*!63$"*<-0&*+"*/$""0#*+.*'0-'(0*$#0*3$B+%4*$*3$#<*"+/0;*+.*"30*01-%-/5*+&*<-+%4*60((9)*

Page 33: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

! "#! $%#&'()&*! +,! %-&./.0.#1! &23! .#)&'4/3#&)! %5! )36571%83'#/3#&*! &23!9():43!;%4#&',!$%//.&&3<!&%!/($'%73$%#%/.$!-%6.$.3)!&2(&!<.<!#%&!6%%)3!).12&!%5!.&)!-3%-63=!>)!?&.16.&0@A!-%.#&)!%4&*!BC3836%-/3#&!<%3)!#%&!$%#).)&!%5!236-.#1!(!53D!.#<.8.<4(6)!&%!13&!'.$2!%'!$'3(&3!(!2(#<546!%5!(+)4'<!-'%&3$&3<!.#<4)&'.3)!

)%$.3&.3)*!./-'%8.#1!&23!6.83)!%5!&23!-%%'*!(66%D.#1!383',%#3!&23!%--%'&4#.&,!&%!-'%1'3))!(#<!2(83!($$3))!&%!23(6&2!(#<!3<4$(&.%#=E!F23!<3836%-/3#&!%5!&23!9():43!;%4#&',!2()!+33#!+()3<!4-%#!&23!$%#8.$&.%#!&2(&!&23!D3667+3.#1!%5!&23!-3%-63!.)!(&!&23!23('&!%5!(#,!-%6.&.$(6*!3$%#%/.$!(#<!)%$.(6!-'%G3$&=

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

!"#"$%&'()*+%,-.%-/0"12%-/1/3"4-2"1--*+4/1*-

! ?36571%83'#/3#&*!4#<3')&%%<!()!&23!D.66.#1#3))!&%!/(I3!<3$.).%#)!(#<!&23!$(-($.&,!&%!5($3!4-!&%!&23!'3)-%#).+.6.&,!%5!1%83'#(#$3*!2()!+33#!3))3#&.(6!&%!&23!)4$$3))!%5!)4)&(.#(+63!24/(#!<3836%-/3#&=!!F23!9():43!$()3!-'3)3#&)!

2(83!+33#!('&.$46(&3<!(#<!./-63/3#&3<!5'%/!(!-('&.$46('!$%#$3-&.%#!%5!)36571%83'#/3#&=!

! ?&('&.#1!D.&2!&23!'3$%83',!%5!(4&%#%/,!&2'%412!&23!)&(&4&3!%5!O43'#.$(*!

>1'33/3#&! .#! &23! APPQ)! -'%8.<3<! &23!9():43!;%4#&',!D.&2! &23! $(-($.&,! &%!/(I3!)4+)&(#&.(6!.#83)&/3#&)!.#!(!)%$.(6!)&(&3=!!R#6,!&2'%412!&23)3!&D%!-'.%'!$%//.&/3#&)!D()!&23!9():43!;%4#&',!3#<%D3<!D.&2! &23!&3$2#.$(6!$(-($.&,!

Page 34: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!""#$%&'(")*+

, -$./01"2$%)3$)', !&))"', 3$&), (4".&'("), "%, ()&!'(")+, , 5)$, "/, '6$,

7)8$%4'&)8()1, /%"3,")$,"/, 91.":&.,&))7.4, ."!&.;<, '", '6&',"/, 9."!&.,3"2$4, '6$,

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

Page 35: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'%(")$"*+$,(-+.)/0-1"2$3-+4%45-"

! "#$%&'(#)$**+!,--,.&/!',!'0&!'0&.#.!0&*/!1+!2$+&3!#4!0#.!5&**634,54!5,(3!70&!8,$/!',!9&(:/,%

;<=!,>(!?8,$/!%$-@!)0$('.!$!-$'0!',!-(,.-&(#'+A!!70#.!

B$.C>&!D,>4'(+A

! D,4'($(+!',!4&,6*#1&($*#.%=!'0&!B$.C>&!D,>4'(+!0$.!-(,E&4!'0$'!%,(&!.'$'&=!#4!'0&!:,(%!,:!.&*:6F,E&(4%&4'=!0$.!1&&4!&..&4'#$*!',!#'.!&),4,%#)!$4/!

.,*#/$(#'+GA! !2,5&E&(=! #4! '0&!HI.'!)&4'>(+! '0&!B$.C>&!D,>4'+! #.!1&F#44#4F! ',!#/&4'#:+!'0&!*#%#'$'#,4.!,:!&J#.'#4F!-,*#'#)$*!$4/!*&F$*!$F(&&%&4'.A!!70&!/#::&(&4'!

&.'$1*#.0&(! ,:! (&F>*$'#,4.! $4/! #4:($.'(>)'>(&! ,-&($',(! $(&! ',/$+!%>)0!%,(&!#%-,('$4'! '0$4!'0#('+!+&$(.!$F,

;KA! !70&(&! #.!)*&$(!4&&/!:,(!$!(&.-,4.#1*&!$4/!

&$(4&.'! /#.)>..#,4! ),4)&(4&/! 5#'0! '0&!%,/&(4! )0$**&4F&.! ,:! B$.C>&! .&*:6F,E&(4%&4'A

L>(,-&$4!D,%%#..#,4G.!M0#'&! N$-&(! ,4! L>(,-&$4!O,E&(4$4)&A! 70&! -$-&(!

P4'&F($'#,4A!!70&!-$-&(!$('#)>*$'&.!$!4&5!:,(%!,:!L>(,-&$4!F,E&(4$4)&;Q!'0$'!%$J#%#R&.! )#'#R&4! -$('#)#-$'#,4! $'! $**! *&E&*.! ,:! ->1*#)! $/%#4#.'($'#,4A! N(#E$'&!

)#'#R&4.0#-GA

! 70&!#4'&(&.'!,:!'0&!B$.C>&!#4.'#'>'#,4.!#4!'0&!4&5!%,/&*!,:!L>(,-&$4!

'0&!D,%%>4#'+!,:!'0&!B$.C>&!D,>4'(+;S=!$--(,E&/!1+!$1.,*>'&!%$T,(#'+!#4!'0&!

$4/!F,,/!$/%#4#.'($'#,4@!5#'0!'0&!?-$('#)#-$'#,4!,:!)#E#*!.,)#&'+@!#4!->1*#)!$::$#(.!$.!'0&!&..&4'#$*!&E,*>'#,4!4&)&..$(+!:,(!),%-&'&4'!B$.C>&!.&*:6F,E&(4%&4'A!U'!'0&!/$54!,:!$!4&5!&($=!'0&!B$.C>&!D,>4'(+!(&C>#(&.!F(&$'&(!.&*:6F,E&(4%&4'!',!%&&'!&%&(F#4F!)0$**&4F&.!$4/!.>.'$#4!#'.!$/E$4)&%&4'!',5$(/.!.>.'$#4$1*&!0>%$4!/&E&*,-%&4'A!

Page 36: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&"'%(")$"*+$,(-+.)/"0-1"2-3456$7-+8%89-

! "#$%&'(! &'! )&'*! +,#! -.'-#/+0$1! /$%$*&()! -,$'(#! +,$+! +,#! '#2!30%./#$'! -01+0%#! .4! (.5#%'$'-#

67! %#/%#8#'+89! 2#! /0+! 4.%2$%*! +,#! 4.11.2&'(!

:;! <&5#'! +,#! 4#*#%$1! '$+0%#! .4! +,#! "$8=0#! >.0'+%?9! -.'8.1&*$+&.'! .4! +,#!!&'+#%@!&'8+&+0+&.'$1&8)!.%!-.@/$%+&-&/$+&.'!.4!+,#!+,%##!1#5#18!.4!"$8=0#!&'8+&+0+&.'8!&'!+,#!/1$''&'(9!#A#-0+&.'!$'*!$88#88)#'+!.4!/0B1&-!/.1&-&#8;

C;!D'-%#$8#*!&'+#%'$1!.%!&'+#%@*#/$%+)#'+$1!-..%*&'$+&.'!.4!8#-+.%$1!/.1&-&#8!&'!.%*#%!4.%!(.5#%')#'+!$-+&.'!+.!$-,&#5#!-.)/%#,#'8&5#!+%$'85#%8$1!$-+&.';!

E;!D'+#(%$+&.'!.4!-&+&F#'!&'&+&$+&5#89!+,#!8#$%-,!4.%!-.'8#'808!.%!/%.B1#)!8.15&'(!$//%.$-,#89!$'*!/$%+&-&/$+&.'!.4!-&5&1!8.-&#+?9!#-.'.)&-!$'*!8.-&$1!$(#'+8!&'!+,#!*#8&('!/%.-#88!.4!/0B1&-!/.1&-&#8;

G;! D'8+&+0+&.'$1! 1.?$1+?9!-.!%#8/.'8&B&1&+?!.4!$(#'+8!$'*!-&5&1!8.-&#+?!.%($'&F#*!&'! +,&8! /$%+&-&/$+&5#! *&)#'8&.';! H,&8! 2&11! %#=0&%#! +,#! #A&8+#'-#! .4! &'&+&$+&5#9!-.'801+$+&.'!$'*!*#B$+#!4.%0)8!4.%!8.-&.@#-.'.)&-!$(#'+8!+,$+!./#%$+#!0'*#%!+,#!/%&'-&/1#8!.4!(.5#%'$'-#;

I;!H,&8!%#=0&%#8!/#%4#-+&'(!B$8&-!)#+,.*.1.(?!+.!'.%)$1&F#!<.5#%')#'+!$-+&.'!&'-.%/.%$+&'(!+,#!-.'8+&+0#'+!$8/#-+8!.4!/1$''&'(J!&+8!-$08#!.%!.%&(&'K!/%#/$%$+&.'!.4!/.+#'+&$1!&)/$-+8!$'*!$1+#%'$+&5#!$-+&.'!B$8#*!.'!$'!$'$1?8&8!$'*!*&$('.8&8!.4! +,#! &'&+&$1!8&+0$+&.'!$'*!/%#8#'+!$'*!40+0%#! &'+#%#8+8K!*#-&8&.'!)$L&'(!$8!$!/%.-#88!+.!8#1#-+!$1+#%'$+&5#8!$'*!/%#/$%#!$'*!&)/1#)#'+!8+%$+#(&#8!+.!%#$-,!

/.1&-&#8;

6;! M*./+&.'! .4! )#$80%#8! +,$+! )$L#! &+! /.88&B1#9! B#?.'*!)#+,.*8! +.! %#5&#2!(.5#%')#'+$1! *#-&8&.'8! 4.%#8##'! &'! +,#! 1#($1! -.*#!$'*! 40'-+&.'8! +.! -.'+%.1!N#(&81$+&5#!/.2#%9! +.! #'80%#! +,#!*.0B1#! .BO#-+&5#! .4! -.'801+&'(! -&5&1! 8.-&#+?!$'*!8.-&$1!&'+#%1.-0+.%89!$'*!+.!-$%%?!.0+!80%5#&11$'-#!$'*!4.%!-&+&F#'8!.%!'.'!&'8+&+0+&.'$1!B.*&#8! +.! &'+#%%.($+#! +,#!<.5#%')#'+!$+!$'?!).)#'+9!$B.0+! +,#!$-+&.'8!/1$''#*!+.!B#!#A#-0+#*!$--.%*&'(!+.!/0B1&-!/.1&-&#8;

Page 37: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"# $%&'# (&))# *+,*+'+-.# -/*01)&2&-3# .%+# ,/''&4&)&.5# /6# 7&'81)&2&-3# +19%# 1-:#

&0,*/7+0+-.#,*/9+''+'#./#,84)&9#,/)&9&+';#9/-9+,.&/-#/6#,84)&9#,/)&9&+'<#9%/&9+#

/6# &-'.*80+-.'#1-:#1,,)&91.&/-# .%+*+/6# ./# *+19%# .%+#3/1)'<#9/008-&91.&/-#/6#

,/)&9&+'#./#'/9&+.5<#/,+-#:+41.+#(&.%#'/9&+.5<#+.9"""

="#>-/.%+*#-+9+''1*5#:&0+-'&/-#/6#?1'@8+#3/7+*-1-9+#9/-'&'.'#/6#1:71-9&-3#

&-#.%+#&-.+3*1.&/-#/6#.%+#)+31)#9/:+#/6#.%+#?1'@8+#A/8-.*5#6/*#,84)&9#,/)&9&+'#

.%1.#*+@8&*+#*+38)1.&/-'<#&-.*/:89&-3#&-#.%+#,)1--&-3#/6#B/7+*-0+-.#)+3&')1.&7+#

&-&.&1.&7+'# 1-:# &-# .%+# )+3&')1.&7+# ,*/9+''# &-# 3+-+*1)<# &0,*/7+0+-.'# :&*+9.+:#

1.# 381*1-.++&-3# .%+# 9/**+9.# 9/-9+,.&/-# /6# ,/)&9&+'<# .%+# '+)+9.&/-# /6# &:+1)#

*8)+'"

C"# D-# .%+# '8,*1-1.&/-1)# 6*10+(/*E# (%+*+# .%+# )+3&')1.&7+# 68-9.&/-# /6# .%+#

B/7+*-0+-.# &'# &-'+*.+:# 1-:# (&.%# *+31*:# ./# .%+# 1-.&9&,1.&/-# 1-:# ,*/19.&7&.5#

1:7/91.+:# 6/*# .%+# ,/'&.&/-# /6# .%+# ?1'@8+# A/8-.*5# &-# F8*/,+<# &.# (&))# 4+#

-+9+''1*5#./#+G.+-:#.%+#,)1--&-3#/6#.%+#&-.+*-1)#)+3&')1.&7+#,*/9+''"#>))#.%&'#(&))#

3&7+#1#'/)7+-.#1-:#'8&.14)+#*+',/-'+#&-#.%+#?1'@8+#A/8-.*5#./#.%+#,*/9+''+'#

./# 9/H*+38)1.+# 1-:# 1''+''# .%+# ,/''&4&)&.&+'# /6# '+)6H*+38)1.&/-<# &-9/*,/*1.&-3#

1,,)&914)+#38&:1-9+#./#.%+#I+3&')1.&7+#J*/3*100+#/6#.%+#B/7+*-0+-.#.%1.#.%+#

K%&.+#J1,+*#/-#F8*/,+1-#B/7+*-1-9+#1-:#.%+#I&'4/-#'.*1.+35#&-9/*,/*1.+#./#

.%+#/,+-#0+.%/:#/6#9//*:&-1.&/-"

Page 38: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'("#)

! "#$%! &'%'(&)#! *&+,$-'%! (.! (/&$-0'-! #$%1+&2! +3! 1#'! 4(%56'! 7+6.1&2!%$.)'!1#'!&')6*'&(1$+.!+3!%'8390+,'&.:'.1!(1!1#'!/'0$..$.0!+3!1#'!;<=>%?!(.-!

1#'!'@$%1'.)'!+3!A"#'!4(%56'!7(%'BC!(!)+:*&'#'.%$,'!:+-'8!+3!D6%1($.(/8'!E6:(.! F','8+*:'.1G! ! H6$-'-! /2! '1#$)(8! (.-! -':+)&(1$)! *&$.)$*8'%! 1#'!3+6.-(1$+.%!+3! 1#$%!.'I!:+-'8!I'&'! 8($-!/'1I''.! 1#'!2'(&%!;<<=!(.-!J>>;G!K,'&!1#'!%6/%'56'.1!2'(&%!$1!1++L!%#(*'!/2!:'(.%!+3!1#'!%+)$+9*+8$1$)(898'0(89')+.+:$)!$.$1$(1$,'%!1#(1!I'&'!3+&:(882!*&'%'.1'-?!-'/(1'-!(.-!-':+)&(1$)(882!(**&+,'-!/2!1#'!$.%1&6:'.1%!+3!4(%56'!%'8390+,'&.:'.1G!!M88!+3!I#$)#!8'(-!1+!

I - The “Basque case”: an integral model based on principles ! "#'!A4(%56'!)(%'B!$%!1#'!&'%681!+3!1#'!-','8+*:'.1!+3!(!%+)$+9*+8$1$)(898'0(89')+.+:$)! :+-'8! /6$81! +.! 1#&''! *&$.)$*8'%C! 1#'! '1#$)(8! *&$.)$*8'?! 1#'!

)'.16&2! N! 1#'!4(%56'!*'+*8'! #(,'!:(-'!)+.1$.6+6%! '33+&1%! 1+! /6$8-!O'()'!/(%'-! 6*+.! %+)$(8! P6%1$)'?! (.-! $.-$,$-6(8! (.-! )+88')1$,'! 8$/'&12G! Q&+:! 1#'%'!

6.-'&%1(.-!*&+0&'%%G!M0($.%1! 1#'!*&',($8$.0!I$.-%!+3! .'+98$/'&(8$%:?! (! 12*'!+3!*&+0&'%%!I(%! 3(,+&'-! $.!I#$)#! 1#'!%6/P')1!(.-!36.-(:'.1(8!'.-!I(%! 1#'!(-,(.)':'.1!+3!1#'!*'&%+.!$.!#(&:+.2!I$1#!1#'!'.,$&+.:'.1G

II – The Ethical Principle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

!!!!! "#'&'3+&'?! $1! $%!(!)+.-$1$+.!%$.'!56(!.+.!1#(1!1#'!&'P')1$+.!+3! 1#'!6%'!+3!,$+8'.)'!(%!(.!$.%1&6:'.1!+3!*+8$1$)(8!()1$+.!$%!:(-'!*&$+&!1+!(.2!*&+)'%%!+3!

-$(8+06'-!'.-!1+!,$+8'.)'!:6%1!/'!-'3'.-'-G

Page 39: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

III – The Democratic Principle

!"#$%&'()#$*+),!-.$/)'!$0#$-#1+2,34#56$7"31"$+,8.$%&'()#$'+13#!.$&,5$3!'$9+83!31&8$-#9-#'#,!&!3:#'$1&,$!&1;8#<$="#!"#-$9+83!31&8$&2-##/#,!'$&-#$-#&1"#5$+-$ ,+!6$ !"#$ :3+8#,1#$ +>$ ?@A$/)'!$ 53'&99#&-<$ $ A!$ !"#$ '&/#$ !3/#6$ 7"#!"#-$ +-$,+!$?@A$#B3'!'6$&2-##/#,!'$/)'!$0#$-#&1"#5$>+-$!"#$1+#B3'!#,1#$0#!7##,$!"#$%&'()#$*+),!-.$&,5$!"#$C9&,3'"$C!&!#<

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

$ F-+/$!"#$'!-31!#'!$-#'9#1!$>+-$!"#$5#/+1-&!31$#''#,1#6$!"#$-#1+2,3!3+,$+>$!"#$-32"!$+>$!"#$%&'()#$E#+98#$!+$5#135#$!"#3-$+7,$>)!)-#$&,5$!"#$1+//3!/#,!$!+$#B#-13'#$!"3'$-32"!$!"-+)2"$9&1!$&,5$,#2+!3&!3+,$3'$!"#$;#.$!+$!"#$'+8)!3+,<

IV – Identity and Innovation$ @"#$5#>#,'#$+>$!"#$%&'()#$35#,!3!.6$,+!$3,$+99+'3!3+,$!+$+!"#-$35#,!3!3#'$0)!$3,$9&-!,#-'"39$73!"$!"#/6$3'$0#"3,56$,+!$+,8.$&$8#23!3/&!#$9+83!31&8$18&3/6$0)!$&8'+$&$'+),5$/+5#8$+>$#1+,+/316$'+13&8$&,5$9+83!31&8$5#:#8+9/#,!<$$@"#$8&'!$!"3-!.$.#&-'$"&:#$'"+7,$)'$ !"&!$'#8>D2+:#-,/#,!$ DG0)-)H&0#!4&I$ 3,$%&'()#$J$1&,$0#$&$'.,+,./$>+-$7#88D0#3,2<

$ @"#$ &5:&,1#$ +>$ !"#$ %&'()#$ E#+98#K'$ 35#,!3!.$ 3'$ 3,!-3,'31&88.$ 83,;#5$!+$ &1"3#:3,2$ ')'!&3,&08#$ ")/&,$ 5#:#8+9/#,!6$ !"-+)2"$ !"#$ #B#-13'#$ +>$$'#8>D2+:#-,/#,!<$ %.$ 3,1+-9+-&!3,2$ &$ 9+'3!3:#$ +)!8++;$ +,$ 1"&,2#$ 7#$ "&:#$0##,$&08#$!+$')-:3:#6$&5&9!$&,5$,+7$#:+8:#$!+$/##!$!"#$'+13&8$&,5$#1+,+/31$1"&88#,2#'$+>$!"#$9&'!$!"3-!.$.#&-'<$$@"#$%&'()#$E#+98#$/)'!$8++;$!+$!"#$>)!)-#$73!"+)!$ >+-2#!!3,2$!"#3-$9&'!L$ !"#.$/)'!$1+/9#!#$&,5$3,,+:&!#$0)3853,2$)9+,$!"#3-$5##9$-++!'<$

Page 40: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

V – Self-government and Sustainable Human Development! "#$%&'()#*+,#+-! ./! -0#!1#2! -(!(3*!4(3+-*25/! /-*6-#'27!83.$-! (+!#-0.46$!6+9!9#,(4*6-.4!:*.+4.:$#/;!.-!./!6+!3,<*#$$6!()#*!-0#!*#/-!(%!-0#!#$#,#+-/!-06-!#=:$6.+! -0#! 640.#)#,#+-! (%! /3/-6.+6<$#! 03,6+7! >0#! #).9#+4#! .+! -0./! :6:#*!

()#*!-0#!:#*.(9!?@@A&BCCA!&!/#$%&'()#*+,#+-!06/!<##+!6!/2+(+2,!(%!D#$$!<#.+'!%(*!86/E3#!/(4.#-27!!

! >03/;! .+! :6*6$$#$! -(! -0#! 4(+4#:-! (%! +#D!F3*(:#6+!'()#*+6+4#;! +#D!

-0#! 86/E3#! 4.-.G#+/! 4(+%#*! (+! -0#.*! .+/-.-3-.(+/;! 6*#! #=#*4./#97! H%! F3*(:#6+!'()#*+6+4#! ./! 6+! 6--#,:-! -(! *#/43#! -0#! F3*(:#6+! :*(I#4-;! ,61.+'! .-! ,(*#!9#,(4*6-.4;!-0#+!86/E3#!'()#*+6+4#!#+-6.$/!-0#!*#+6.//6+4#!(%!-0#!%*6,#D(*1!(%!86/E3#!/#$%&'()#*+,#+-7!J!+#D! %*6,#D(*1!D0.40;! .+!(*9#*! -(! *#/:(+9! -(!+#D!406$$#+'#/;!,3/-!4(+-6.+!'*#6-#*!6+9!,(*#!9.%%3/#9!:($.-.46$;!/(4.6$!6+9!#4(+(,.4!:(D#*7

! >0#!*#/3$-/!(%!-0./!6+6$2/./!(%!-0#!86/E3#!46/#!/0(D!-06-!<2!%3*-0#*.+'!/#$%! '()#*+,#+-! .+! 9#%#+/#! (%! -0#! 86/E3#! :($.-.46$;! 43$-3*6$;! 6+9! #4(+(,.4!.9#+-.-2! 6! 3+.E3#! 9#)#$(:,#+-! ,(9#$! (%! 4(,:#-.-.)#+#//! .+! /($.96*.-2! 06/!#,#*'#97!!>0#!86/E3#!,(9#$!(%!/3/-6.+6<$#!03,6+!9#)#$(:!,#+-!06/!<##+!

#4(+(,.4!6+9!/(4.6$!/#$%&'()#*+,#+-7!K3<$.4&:*.)6-#!/06*#9!$#69#*/0.:!./!+(-!:(//.<$#!D.-0(3-!/340!6!9*.).+'!%(*4#7!!L.-0(3-!6!)./.(+;!6!K#(:$#!D.$$!:#*./07

Page 41: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()

!"#$"%&%'("')*+$"+(,-'.+&"*'"+/,-0%$"*1+"-'2%3"')")4++5(046+*"+3'$'(%378""

#**4%9:*+&;"<=>>=?@A"B8C8A"?+&%30*%'$"')"*1+"D4++47"C+44."?0(A"E3*'9+4"FA"!GHF

I"CJ<J@#K#A"C8A"L1+"=$&"')"M%7*'4."0$&"*1+"N07*"K0$A"M04,+4"O+4+$$%0-A"!GGF

F"D#N=#>EA"=8A"L1+"',+$"P+%$7"')"N0*%$"#(+4%30A"K0&4%&A"+&8"Q%2-'"RRSA"ITTUA",8"IIV

V"Q#W#K#DEA"B8A"N0"X0P+4$0A"K0&4%&A"+&8"Q0$*%--0$0A"Q:(0"&+"-+*407A"ITTIA",8"FUF

U"Q#KJ=NQE>A"O8"0$&">EW?M#JQA"Y8A"=3'$'(%37A"Z!H"+&8[A"K0&4%&A"+&8"K3D40\5M%--A"!GGGA",8"F]A"70%&;"^>'\0&0.7A"*10$67"*'"*1+"%$*+--+3*:0-"3'$*4%9:*%'$"')"B'1$"K0.$04&"<+.$+7"0$&"1%7")'--'\+47A"\+"6$'\"1'\"*'"3'$*4'-"*1+"\'47*"+/3+77+7"

H"L1+"#24++(+$*"+7*09-%71+7"*1+"4%21*"')"*1+"S$7*%*:*%'$7"')"*1+"_07`:+"M%7*'4%30-"L+44%*'4%+7"*'"(0%$*0%$A"+7*09-%71A"4+2:-0*+A"-+P."0$&"%$7,+3*"0"*0/0*%'$"7.7*+("\%*1%$"*1+%4"*+44%*'4.8"S$"0&&%*%'$"*'"0"(+310$%7("')"2'P+4$0$3+"*1+"#24++(+$*"%7"0-7'"0$"%$7*4:(+$*")'4"+3'$'(%3",4'24+77A"0$&"*'"%(,4'P+"*1+"`:0-%*."')"-%)+"0$&"\+--59+%$28"""""

]"OEWL=WA"K8A"L1+"X'(,+*%*%P+"#&P0$*02+7"')">0*%'$7A">+\"@'46A"+&8"C4++"O4+77A"!GGT8""S$"3'$*407*"*'"*1+"*40&%*%'$0-")'4(7"')"9:7%$+77"077'3%0*%'$"ZL4:7*A"304*+-7A"

0"7,+3%0-%7+&",4'&:3*%P+",'-+"\%*1"3'(,+*%*%P+"0&P0$*02+78

a"OEWL=WA"K8A"%$""#bJ#A"B8A"X-:7*+4%c04"."2-'90-%c04"-0"+3'$'(d08"^N0"(02%0"&+-",4'3+7'eA"_'2'*fA"+&8"EP+g0">+240A"ITTaA",4'-'2:+A",'%$*7"':*;"^*1+"_07`:+"X':$*4."-0:$31+&"%*7"7*40*+2.")'4"3'(,+*%P+$+77"907+&"'$"3-:7*+47"%$"!GGT8"L1+"^3-:7*+4e",1%-'7',1."107")0P':4+&"*1+"&+7%2$"')"7:33+77%P+"_07`:+"+3'$'(%3",'-%3%+78"L1+"_07`:+"X':$*4."107"+$g'.+&"3'$7%&+409-+"7:33+77A"9+%$2"'$+"')"*1+"

_07`:+"X':$*4."%7"*'&0."0*"*1+"P0$2:04&"')"*1+"\0."')"*1%$6%$2"09':*"1'\"4+2%'$7"0$&"$0*%'$7"71':-&"710,+"0$&"%(,-+(+$*"3-:7*+4%c0*%'$",'-%3%+7e8""

G"_07`:+"X-:7*+47;"#+4'$0:*%3"Z!GG][h"#:&%'P%7:0-"ZITTV[h"#:*'('*%'$"Z!GGF[h"<$'\-+&2+"Z!GGH[h"=-+3*4'&'(+7*%3"Z!GGI[h"=$+42."Z!GGH[h"K031%$+"*''-"Z!GGI[h"=$P%4'$(+$*"Z!GGU[h"O0,+4"Z!GGa[h"K04%*%(+"C'4:("Z!GG][h"O'4*"')"_%-90'"Z!GGV[h"L+-+3'((:$%30*%'$7"Z!GGH[h"L40$7,'4*"0$&"N'2%7*%37"ZITTU[8""

!T"S$"!G]G"+/,+$&%*:4+"%$"4+7+0431"0$&"&+P+-',(+$*"\07"g:7*"T8THG"i"')"*1+"_07`:+"X':$*4.j7"D?OA"9."!GGa"*1%7"10&"4%7+$"*'"!8!!iA"09'P+"*1+"$0*%'$0-"0P+402+"ZT8a]i["9:*"9+-'\"*1+"=:4',+0$"0P+402+"Z!8ai[8

Page 42: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!!"

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`-"

!`"A3:"1J72;?1+",IIa$+"9M"S$(%$QD$(,S+"N"75="EDB,bPa+"S-+"D1@8357?"(553670835")./012/+"R35=35+"D3[0?1=@1+"#KK\-"

!\"(EBDD$*c$+"F-F-"(57[@1:70835");11<>"7/"E7/d[1",3[50:."9:1/8=150-"E7/d[1"97:?872150+"!!0>"F[?."#KK!-"%87:83"=1"/1/8351/-"X(("R1@8/?70[:7-"Qe"\_";7@1"#!-

!L"(EBDD$*c$+"F-"F-+"9:1/15070835"34"0>1"E7/d[1"9:1/8=150"70"0>1")<815<1+"*1<>53?3@."75="(553670835"9?75"#KK!W#KK\+")75")1T7/0875+""!\0>"N7:<>"#KK!-

!f"'9Xg$S'"G#KK^H+"YR7"'5861:/8=7="15"<84:7/Z-"97@1-"!\]-

!]"A[5=70835"E834h/8<7"E8iU787M"%353/087"(501:5708357?"9>./8</",1501:M"N701:87?/"9>./8</",1501:M"E7/d[1",150:1"43:",?82701",>75@1M"E7/d[1",150:1"43:"B;;?81="N70>12708</M"E7/d[1",150:1"35",3@580835+"E:785"75="R75@7@1

!V",(,"T8327C'Q$M",(,"T83C'Q$M"",(,"28<:3C'Q$M"",(,"5753C'Q$M",(,"03[:C'Q$-",(,"27:C'Q$M",(,"151:@8C'Q$-"

!^"EB)&'$"CIX$DQN$Q*+"A8:/0"E7/d[1"9?75"I<<[;708357?"*:78585@+"C361:52150",3[5<8?"##5="B;:8?"!^^]-

#KEB)&'$"CIX$DQN$Q*+")1<35="E7/d[1"9?75"34"I<<[;708357?"*:78585@+"C361:52150",3[5<8?"^0>"Q3612T1:"#KK\-

#!"RBO"!^g!^^V+"#^0>"F[51+"I:=157<8j5"'5861:/807:87"=1"?7"B[035323[/",322[580."34"0>1"E7/d[1",3[50:.+"EI9X"!f0>"F[?."!^^V-

##"EB)&'$"CIX$DQN$Q*+"'5861:/80."9?75"#KKKW#KK`+"C361:52150",3[5<8?"!\0>"Q3612T1:"#KKK-

#`"EB)&'$"CIX$DQN$Q*+"E7/d[1"S17?0>"9?75"#KK#W#K!K+"C361:52150",3[5<8?"^0>"F[?."#KK#+"EI9X"5e"!\^"!L0>"F[?.-

#\""E7/d[1"C361:52150+"`:="(501:W85/080[08357?"$2;?3.2150"9?75"#KK]W#K!K+"!]0>"F[?."#KK]-

Page 43: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#2&0#$%&'()#3//45-%04+.#67%.#!889:!88"1#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#=0>#?)<)/@)-#!889A#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#B!.C#$%&'()#3//45-%04+.#67%.#!88D:!88=1#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#2!0>#E(.)#!88DA

!F#$%&'()#6%-74%/).01#G%H#!I!8891#D0>#J%K1#L)5(7%0+-K#G%H#M+-#;+//+.:G%H#NO+(&)&A##$%&'()#6%-74%/).01#G%H#9I!88"1#2P0>#Q)@-(%-K1#;%-)#%.C#6-+0)<04+.#+M#3.M%.<K#%.C#RC+7)&<).<)A##$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#2&0#3.0)-4.&040(04+.%7#Q%/474)&#H40>#;>47C-).#N(OO+-0#67%.1#&)&&4+.#9-C#E(7K##!882A###$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#B!.C#3.0)-4.&040(04+.%7#Q%/474)&#N(OO+-0#67%.1#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<471#&)&&4+.#!F0>#N)O0)/@)-#!88FA

!D#GRS##!I!88F#GRT?#RT?#UL$RT#6GRTT3T*1#980>#E(.)##!88F1#O(@74&>)C#4.#0>)##$V6W#!80>#E(7K#!88FA

!P#X>)#$%&'()#S+/).Y&#3.&040(0)#Z#[JR\UT?[1#H%&#<-)%0)C#@K#G%H#!I#2=PP#+M#"#Q)@-(%-K#@K#0>)#$%&'()#6%-74%/).0A

!=#G%H#]I!88"1#+M#2P#Q)@-(%-K1#M+-#['(%740K#@)0H)).#J).#%.C#S+/).1#$V6W#]!1#+M#!#J%-<>#!88"A

98#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#$%&'()#;(70(-)#67%.1#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#!2#N)O0)/@)-#!88]A

92#GRS#28I2=P!1#+M#!]#T+,)/@)-1#$RN3;#GRS#VT#X^[#T+-/%74_%04+.#VQ#X^[#UN[#VQ#$RN`U[1#$%&'()#6%-74%/).01#$V6W#.+#2F8#+M#2=P!A

9!#[Xa[6RL[1#$A1#G4.5(%)#,%&<+.(/#O-4/404%)1#$+-C)7)1#Q-%.b+4&##J+-O%4.1#/%40-)#4/O-4/%0)(-1##2"]"A#

99#GRS#9I2==P#+M#0>)#!D#Q)@-(%-K1#*).)-%7#+.#[.,4-+./).0#6-+0)<04+.#4.#0>)#$%&'()#;+(.0-K1#$%&'()#6%-74%/).0A

9]#3$RLL[Xa[#EAEA1#$%&'()#;+(.0-K#;+//40/).0#0+#N(&0%4.%@4740K1#$47@%+#!!#E%.(%-K#!882A

9"#$RN`U[#*VW[LTJ[TX1#$%&'()#[.,4-+./).0%7#N0-%0)5K#+M#N(&0%4.%@7)#?),)7+O/).0#!88!:!8!81#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#+M#]#E(.)#!88!A

9F#$RN`U[#*VW[LTJ[TX1#Q4-&0#Q-%/)H+-c#[.,4-+./).0%7#6-+5-%//)#!88!:!88F1#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#+M#]#E(.)#!88!d##N)<+.C#Q-%/)H+-c#[.,4-+./).0%7#6-+5-%//)#!88D:!8281#*+,)-./).0#;+(.<47#+M#"#E(.)#!88DA#

9D#$RN`U[#*VW[LTJ[TX1#L)O+-0#+.#7+<%7#&(&0%4.%@4740K#4.#0>)#$R;1#!88PA#[e)<(04,)#&(//%-Kd##$RLLUX3R1#EAJfA1#BT)0H+-c#+M#O+74<4)&#0+#C4&&)/4.%0)#0>)#R5).C%#!2#7+<%7#4.#0>)#$%&'()#;+(.0-Kg1#L)&)%-<>#%-04<7)#&(OO+-0)C#@K#0>)#U6WI[^U#h9!A9!2:2"=8PI!88]i#%.C#UT[N;V#M+-#N(&0%4.%@7)#?),)7+O/).0#hU.)&<+#8"I!88Fi

Page 44: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#$23456#7829#2:2;93<#=8;>2<6#=?29:6#@AA"B@AC@1#*DE6F9>69<#=D59G;8#H#I6G6>J6F#@AAKL###

!M#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#$23456#)96F:N#&<F2<6:N#D9#&53<2;92J86#I6E68DO>69<##)!#@AACB@ACA1#$23456#*DE6F9>69<#=D59G;81#I6G6>J6F#@AACL#

HA#$%&'()#*+,)-./).01#0F293ODF<#/23<6F#7829P#=D>>D9#<F293ODF<#OD8;GN#DQ#<?6#$23456#=D59<FN#@AA@B@ACA#*DE6F9>69<1#=D59G;8#CM#.DE6>J6F#@AA@L#

HC#RF29G61#<?6#96S<#?;:?63<#GD59<FN1#2G?;6E6T#D98N#@ALKU#;9#<?6#32>6#N62FL

H@#0?6#V5>29#I6E68DO>69<#W9T6S#XVIWY#;3#2#GD>O2F2<;E6#>6235F6#DQ#8;Q6#6SO6G<29GN1#8;<6F2GN1#6T5G2<;D9#29T#3<29T2FT3#DQ#8;E;9:#QDF#GD59<F;63#ZDF8TZ;T6L

H!#[0?6#=D>>;33;D9#D9#<?6#/6235F6>69<#DQ#)GD9D>;G#76FQDF>29G6#29T#&DG;28#7FD:F633\1#GF62<6T#;9#R6JF52FN#@AA"1#OFDOD36T#JN#<?6#7F63;T69<#DQ#<?6#RF69G?#-6O5J8;G1#/F#&2F]D^N1#59T6F#<?6#7F63;T69GN#DQ#/F#_D36O?#&<;:8;<^#29T#<?6#=DDFT;92<DF#J6;9:#_629#7258#R;<D533;1#GD9G85T63#?;3#F6ODF<1#>2T6#O5J8;G#;9#_596#@ACA1#2>D9:#>29N#D<?6F#<?;9:3#Z;<?#<?6#QD88DZ;9:#F6GD>>69T2<;D9P#

OFDT5G<;D9#<D#>6235F;9:#O6DO86`3#Z688BJ6;9:\L

HH

&6FE;G63#8DZ6F6T#;<3#8D9:B<6F>#;3356F#GF6T;<#F2<;9:#D9#&O2;9a3#%5<D9D>D53#

Hb#%..%.1#cL1#)S#&6GF6<2FN#*696F28#DQ#<?6#(9;<6T#.2<;D93L#&O66G?#>2T6#;9#<?6#.DJ68#7F;^6#%Z2FT#=6F6>D9N1#+38D1#.DFZ2N1#CA#I6G6>J6F#@AACL

Hd#-++&),)e01#RLIL1#W925:5F28#3O66G?#<D#<?6#!@9T#OF63;T69GN#DQ#<?6#(9;<6T#&<2<631#f23?;9:<D91#H#/2FG?#CM!!L

HK#IWgW01#%L1#0?6#/2];9:#DQ#)GD9D>;G#7D8;GNL#%#0F2932G<;D9B=D3<#7D8;<;G3#76F3O6G<;E61#=2>JF;T:61#/W0#7F6331#CMMdL

H"#.+-0V1#IL1#W93<;<5<;D931#;93<;<5<;D928#G?29:6#29T#6GD9D>;G#O6FQDF>29G61#/6S;GD1#RD9TD#T6#=58<5F2#)GD9D>;G1#CMM!1#OL#C!L

HM

G2O;<281#GF6T;<1#;9<6F63<#29T#6GD9D>;G#GNG861#/hS;GD1#RD9TD#T6#=58<5F2#

59T6F3<DDT#DF#2GG82;>6T#59<;8#<?6#36GD9T#?28Q#DQ#<?6#@A<?#G69<5FNL#

bA#+-W+e1#_L1#[-6E;3;D9#GFi<;G2#T6#8D3#2ODF<63#T68#;93<;<5G;D928;3>D#2#82#<6DFi2#29T#82#OFjG<;G2#T68#T632FFD88D\1#-6E;3<2#T6#)GD9D>i2#W93<;<5G;D9281#,D8L#M1#9k#Cd1#7F;>6F#36>63<F61#@AAK1#OL#CH!L

Page 45: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$%&'(&%)*#+,-,*#./0120#3/#456715381936/*#:1;<3;*#$1/93551/1#-;3=36/02#'0/0<1502*#>??>*#@,#A"A,

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

!A#$=GIL1=G0<*#-,],*#$L155#32#701I93HI5#Z"^#-;3936/#"RSA[*#:1;<3;*#%I<20/#$,B,T_0<L1//#\5IL0#0;,*#"RR?,

!Q#:=FE\&-*#F,*#B@@0/;3`,#$L155#32#@6223750*#3/##$=GIL1=G0<*#-,],*#$L155#32#701I93HI5*#:1;<3;*#%I<20/#$,B,T#_0<L1//#\5IL0#0;,*#"RR?*#@2,#>UQ#96#A?U,#

!!#-%a-C&b-#D,:,*#W6/H0<0/=0#KW<3232,#-;I=1936/#1/;#$=30/=0M*#B&W-T&)-B#aac#B//3P0<21<O*#'I440/G03L*#\35716*#d##:1O*##>??R,

!U#_Be-b*#],#B,*#%G0#<61;#96#20<H;6L*#:1;<3;*#0;,#B531/81*#>??>,

!S

6H#9G0#7I23/022#2@3<39#3/#9G0#@I753=#20=96<*#\1<=056/1*#0;,#D13;f2*#"RR!*#####@,#U!*

!d#W6LLI/3=1936/#6H#9G0#W6LL32236/#96#9G0#-I<6@01/#D1<531L0/9*#96#9G0#W6I/=35*#96#9G0#-=6/6L3=#1/;#$6=315#W6LL39900#1/;#9G0#W6LL39900#6H#F0436/2#@I7532G0;#3/#9G0#XEW-#WE:#Z>??"[#Q>d#0/;,

!R#D<6@6215#96#<0H6<L#9G0#D65393=15#$919I90#6H#9G0#W6LLI/39O#6H#9G0#\12gI0#W6I/9<O*#1@@<6P0;#7O#17265I90#L1h6<39O#3/#9G0#D50/1<O#$02236/#6H#9G0#\12gI0#D1<531L0/9#6/#9G0#A?#X0=0L70<#>??Q*#\12gI0#D1<531L0/9#'180990*#c&&#50432519I<0*#/,#"d?*#A#+1/I1<O#>??!#

U?##+B.F-'.&*#',*#X0L6=<1=O#3/#9G0#>"29#=0/9I<Oi#1#/0Y#Y6<5;*#/0Y#P15I02*#Ej190*#&cBD*#Ej190*#>??Q*#@2,#R>#1/;#RA*#291902#9G19#K#'6P0</1/=0#=6/2939I902*#

0/1753/4#9G0#H<00#0`0<=320#6H#@65393=15#Y355#9G<6I4G#=3P3=#670;30/=0#7O#9G0#@06@50,#

G6Y0P0<*#0/=6L@12202#1#LI=G#Y3;0<#90<<396<315#1<01,#]6<#9G32#<0126/*#9G0#;3293/=936/#709Y00/#'6P0</L0/9#1/;#46P0</1/=0#32#@1<93=I51<5O#@0<93/0/9#3/#9G0#=I<<0/9#0<1#6H#456715381936/M,

Page 46: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

!"#$"%&'()*+AGUADO, I., BARRUTIA, J. Mª., & ETXEBARRIA, C., El desarrollo sostenible a lo largo de la his-toria del pensamiento económico / Sustainable Development !roughout the History of Economic !ought, ponencia presentada en X Jornadas de Economía Crítica: ¿Alternativas al capitalismo?, Barcelona, 23 25th March 2006.

ALÁEZ, R., BILBAO, J., CAMINO, V. & LONGÁS, J. C., El sector de automoción: Nuevas tenden-cias en la organización productiva / !e Automotive Sector: New Trends in the Ogranisation of Production, Madrid, ed. Civitas, 1996.

ALESINA, A., & WACZIARG, R., Openess, country size and the Government, National Bureau of Economic Research (6024), Mayo, 1997.

ALESINA, A., & SPOLAORE, E., On the Number and Size of Nations, !e Quarterly Journal of Economics, v. 112, n. 4, noviembre, 1997, ps. 1027-1056.

ALESINA, A., SPOLAORE, E. y WACZIARG, R., Economic Integration and Political Disintegra-tion, American Economic Review, v. 90(5), December, 2000, ps. 1276-1296.

ALESINA, A. Y SPOLAORE, E., !e Size of Nations, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 2005.

ALLI, J. C., Derecho administrativo y globalización / Administrative Law and Globalization, Ma

drid, Civitas ed., 2004.

ANNAN, K., Former Secretary General of the United Nations, Speech at the Ceremony of the Noble Peace Prize, Oslo, Norway, 10th December, 2001.

ARGYLE, M., Sources of Satisfaction in the Good Life, London, CHRISTIE, I., & NASH, L., ed., 1998.

ARRIGHI, G., El largo siglo XX. Dinero y poder en los orígenes de nuestra época / !e Long Twen-tieth Century: Money and Power in the Origins of Our Time. Madrid, ed. Akal, 1999.

AZUA, J., Clusterizar y globalizar la economía: La magia del proceso / A Clustered and Globalized Economy: !e Magic of Process. Bogotá, Ed. Oveja Negra, 2008.

BAIROCH, P., Cities and Economic Development: From the Dawn of History to the present, Chi-cago, University of Chicago, 1991.

BALZAT, M., An economic analysis of innovation. Extending the concept of national innovation systems, Cheltenham, ed. E.E. (Edward Elgar Pub), 2006.

BARBERO, I., Hacia modelos alternativos de ciudadanía: un análisis socio-jurídico del movimiento sin papeles / Towards Alternative Models of Citizenship: A Socio-legal Analysis of the Movement Without Papers, tesis doctoral defendida en la UPV-EHU en el año 2010.

BARRERE, M. A., Discriminación, derecho antidiscriminatorio y acción positiva en favor de las mujeres / Discrimination, Anti-discrimination law and A"rmative Action for Women, Madrid, Civitas, 1997.

Page 47: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

BARRUTIA, J. M., Policy Network for the dissemination of the Local Agenda 21 in Euskadi, Research Paper UPV/EHU (32.321-15908/2004) and UNESCO Chair for Sustainable Development (UNESCO 05/2006).

BARRUTIA, J. M., ECHEBARRIA, C., & AGUADO, I., Una red de políticas para la difusión de la Agenda 21 Local en Euskadi / Policy Network for the dissemination of the Local Agenda 21 in Euskadi, Ekonomiaz , nº 64, 2007, ps. 214-235.

BAUDRILLARD, J., Pantalla total / Total Screen, Barcelona, ed. Anagrama, 2000.

BAUDRILLARD, J., Del antiterrorismo a la guerra. La violencia de la globalización / !e War on Terrorism: !e Violence of Globalisation, Le Monde diplomatique, Madrid, edición española, November 2002, P. 17.

BAZTARRIKA, P., Babel o barbarie, una política lingüística legítima y e"caz / Babel or Barbarism: A Legitimate and E#ective Language Policy, Irun, ed. Alberdania, 2009.

BECK, U., GIDDENS, A. & LASH, S., Modernización re$exiva. Política, tradición y estética en el orden social moderno / Re$ective Modernzation: Politics, Traditions and Aesthetics in the Modern Social Order, Madrid, ed. Alianza, 1997.

BECK, U., ¿Qué es la globalización? Falacias del globalismo, respuestas a la globalización / What is Globalisation? Fallacies of Globalisation, Responses to Globalisation, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1998.

BERGER, P. L., & HUNTINGTON, S. P., Globalizaciones múltiples. La diversidad cultural en el mundo contemporáneo / Multiple Globalisation: Cultural Diversity in the Contemporary World, Barcelona, Ediciones Paidós, 2002.

BLANCHFLOWER, D.G., OSWALD, A. J., “Happiness and the Human Development Index: !e Paradox of Australia”, Australian Economic Review, June 2005, ps. 307-318.

BOBBIO, N., Derecha e izquierda / Right and Le%, Madrid, ed. Taurus, 1998.

BRAINBRIDGE, W.S., Nanoconvergence: the Unity of Nanoscience, Biotechnology, information technology and Cognitive Science”, New Jersey, ed. Prentice Hall, 2007.

BRONOWSKI, J., !e Ascent of Man, Boston, ed. Little, Brown and Co., 1973.

BRUNO, F., & STUTZER, A., Happiness and economics, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 2002.

BUARQUE, C., Un nuevo mundo feliz / A Brave New World, Madrid, Santillana Ediciones Gener-ales, 2010.

CABALLERO HARRIET, F. J., Algunas claves para otra Mundialización / Some Other Keys to Glo-balisation, Santo Domingo, ed. Fundación Global, Democracia y Desarrollo (FUNGLODE), 2009.

CARLSSON, B., JACOBSSON, S., HOLMEN, M., & RICKNE, A., “Innovation Systems: analytical and methodological issues”, Research Policy, nº 31, 2002, ps. 233-245.

CARROL, L., Alicia a través del espejo / Alice !rough the Looking Glass, Madrid, ed. Gaviota/Everest, 2010.

Page 48: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

CASTELLS, M., La era de la Información, v. II El Poder de la Identidad / !e Information Age: !e Power of Identity, Madrid, Alianza Editorial, 2003.

CASTELLS, M., & HIMANEN, P., El Estado de bienestar y la sociedad de la información / !e Welfare State and the Information Society. El modelo "nlandés, Madrid, Alianza Editorial, 2002.

CASTORIADIS, C., De la autonomía en política. El individuo privatizado / Policy Autonomy: !e Individual Privatized, Le Monde Diplomatique, Madrid, edición española, febrero 1998, p-12-27.

CERVANTES SAAVEDRA, M., El ingenioso hidalgo Don Quijote de la Mancha / !e Indigenous Hidalgo Don Quixote of La Mancha. Ed. del IV Centenario, Real Academia Española, Asociación de Academias de la Lengua Española, Alfaguara, Gobierno Vasco, 2005.

CHAKRAVARTY, S. R., “A Generalized Human Development Index”, Review of Development Economics, Manuscript nº 9165, 23 August 2000.

CHANG, M., Cornucopianos los ultraneoliberales / Cornucopians: !e Ultra Neoliberals, en

FOLADORI, G. & PIERRI, N., (coord.), ¿Sustentabilidad? Desacuerdos sobre el desarrollo sustent-able, Universidad Autónoma de Zacatecas, Miguel Ángel Porrúa ed., 2005.

CHOMSKY, N., El bene"cio es lo que cuenta. Neoliberalismo y orden global / Pro"t Over People: Neoliberalism and the Global Order, Barcelona, ed. Crítica, 2000.

CHUA, A., Dayof Empire. How Hyperpowers rise dominance-and wby they fall, New York, Anchor Books, 2009.

COLEMAN, P.T., !e "ve percent: "nding solutions to seemingly impossible con#icts, New York, Public A$airs, 2011.

COOKE, P., HEIDENREICH, M., & BRACZYK, H., Regional Innovation Systems, London, Rout-ledge, 2004.

COSTANTINI, V., MONNI, S., Environment, human development and economic growth, Ecologi-cal Economics 64, 2008, ps. 867-880.

CURRICULUM VASCO: ITINERARIO CULTURAL, Propuesta de los expertos, San Sebastián, Mitxelena Artes Gra"cas, 2004.

DE LA DEHESA, G., Comprender la globalización / Understanding Globalisation, Madrid, Alianza ed., 2002.

DE LUCAS, J., Nuevas estrategias de estigmatización. El Derecho frente a los inmigrantes / New Stratergies of Stigmatization: !e Laws Against Immigrants, en Portilla Contreras, G., Mutaciones

del Leviatán. Legitimación de los nuevos modelos penales, Madrid, ed. Akal, 2005.

DIESENDORF, M., & HAMILTON, C., Human ecology, human economy, Sydney, Allen and Unwin, 1997.

DIEZ INOA, S. A., La globalización neoliberal y el fenómeno migratorio: análisis del modelo hispano-dominicano / Neoliberal Globalisation and Migration: Analysis of the Spanish-Domincan Model, tesis doctoral defendida en la UPV-EHU en el año 2008.

Page 49: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

DIXIT, A., !e Making of Economics Policy. A Transaction-Cost Politics Perspective, Cambridge, MIT Press, 1996.

DODDS, S., “Economic growth and human well-being”, Ecological Economics, v. 23, noviembre 1997. Ps. 95-111.

DOMÈNECH, A., El eclipse de la fraternidad / !e Eclipse of Fraternity, Barcelona, ed. Crítica, 2004.

DORRONSORO, G., El sistema vasco de innovación ante los nuevos retos / !e Basque Innovation System to New Challenges, Revista Madrid + d., Monografía nº 22, 2008.

DRUCKER, P. F., Innovation and Entrepreneurship. Practice and Principles, Nueva York, ed. Harper & Row, 1985.

DUFOUR, D. R., En tiempos del capitalismo total. La nueva servidumbre del hombre liberado / In Times of Total Capital: !e New Slavery of Free Men, Le Monde Diplomatique, edición española,

Madrid, October 2003. P.4.

EDQUIST, C., Systems of innovation: Technologies, Institutions and organisations, London, Pinter, 1997.

EDQUIST, C., Systems of Innovation. Perspectives and challenges en FAGERBERG, J. et AL. (eds), Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005.

EMMONS, R., HORWITZ, J., DIENER, E., “Happiness of the very wealthy”. Social indicators research. Vol. 16, 1985. Ps- 263-274.

ESTEFANÍA, J., Contra el pensamiento único / Against the Single !ought, Madrid, ed. Santillana, 1997.

ETXENIKE, P. M., Comparecencia en el Senado Español para realizar una evaluación de la política cientí"ca del Estado y de la Unión Europea / Appearence in the Spanish State to Conduct an Assessment of the Scienti"c Policy of the State and the European Union, Madrid, Diario de Sesiones del Senado. 18 June 2007.

ETXENIKE, P. M., Conferencia: Crisis. Educación y Ciencia / Crisis, Education and Science, AICE-

IZEA XXV Aniversario, Guggenheim-Bilbao, 8 May 2009.

ETXENIKE, P. M., “Cerca de treinta años de Ley del euskera”, prologo de Babel o barbarie, una política lingüística legítima y e"caz / “Nearly !rity Years of the Euskera Act” Babel or Barabrism Prologue,, Irun, Ed. Alberdania, 2009.

ETXEPARE, B., Linguae vasconum primitiae, (1545), Bilbao, Euskaltzaindia, 1995.

EWING, J. A., Discurso presidencial en la Asamblea de la British Association / Presidential Ad-dress to the Assembly of the British Association, 1932. Versión del Daily Telegraph, Londres, 19 de septiembre de 1932.

Page 50: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

EZEIZABARRENA, X., “Scottish Devolution & Basque Historial titles: 2 legal scopes for cosover-eignty?”, PSA conference on British and comparative politics, Oxford, January 2010.

FAGERBERG, J. et AL. (eds), Systems of Innovation. Perspectives and challenges, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005.

FAGERBERG, J., MOWERY, D. C., y NELSON, R. R., !e Oxford Handbook of Innovation, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005.

FERNANDEZ DE LUCIO, I., El sistema de innovación en Euskadi / !e Innovation System in Euskadi, Ekonomiaz nº 56, 2004. Ps. 296-305.

FIORITO, A. & MURGA, G., Keynes y sus interpretaciones II / Keynes and his Interpretations II, Madrid, Ediciones cooperativas, 2006.

FORAY, D., and FREEMAN, Ch., Technology and the wealth of nations, London, Pinter Pub, 1993.

FORAY, D., L’économie de la connaissance / !e Economy of Knowledge, Paris, La Découverte, 2009.

FOX, R. W., & LEARS, J., El poder de la cultura: ensayos críticos de historia de América / !e Power of Culture: Critical Essays in American History, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1993.

FRIEDMAN, M. & FRIEDMAN, R. D., Libertad de elegir. Hacia un nuevo liberalismo económico / Freedom to Choose: Toward a New Economic Liberalism, Barcelona, ed. Grijalbo, 1980.

FRIEDMAN, M., Capitalism and Freedom, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1982.

FUKUYAMA, F., El "n de la historia y el último hombre / !e End of History and the Last Man, Barcelona, ed. Planeta, 1992.

GALEANO, E., Las venas abiertas de América Latina / Open Veins of Latin America, Madrid, ed. Siglo XXI, 2005.

GANDHI, M., Democracy Real and Deceptive, India, Navajivan Publishing House, 1961.

GELLNER, E., Cultura, Identidad y Política. El nacionalismo y los nuevos cambios sociales, / Cul-ture, Identity and Politics: Nationalism and the New Social Changes Barcelona, ed. Gedisa, 1989.

GEORGE, S., Otro mundo es posible si… / Another World is Possible if…, Barcelona, ed. Icaria, 2004.

GEORGESCU-ROEGEN, N., !e entropy law and the economic process, Cambridge, Massachu-setts, Harvard University Press, 1971.

GIDDENS, A., La tercera vía y sus críticos / !e !ird Way and its Critics, Madrid, ed. Santillana, 2001.

GOETHE, J.W., Fausto / Faust, Madrid, ed. Cátedra, 2005.

GOODLAND, R., “!e Concept of Environmental Sustainability, Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, v. 26, 1995, ps. 1-24.

Page 51: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

GRIMM, M., HARTTGEN, K., KLASEN, S., & MISSELHORN, M., “A Human Development Index by Income Groups”, documento de trabajo nº 15, Instituto Ibero-Americano de Investigaciones Económicas, University of Göttingen, November 15, 2006.

GUIBERNAU, M., Los nacionalismos / Nationalism, Barcelona, ed. Ariel, 1996.

HABERMAS, J., El discurso !losó!co de la modernidad / "e Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, Madrid, ed. Taurus, 1989.

HABERMAS, J., Facticidad y validez. Sobre el derecho y el Estado democrático de derecho en térmi-nos de teoría del discurso / Facility and Validity: On the Right and the Democratic State of Law in Terms of Discourse "eory, Madrid, ed. Trotta, 1998.

HAMILTON, C., El fetiche del crecimiento / "e Growth Fetish, Iruña, ed. Laetori, 2006.

HAYEK, F. A., Derecho, legislación y libertad / Law, Legislation and Liberty, v. II, Madrid, Unión editorial, 1988.

HAYEK, F. A., Camino de servidumbre / "e Road to Serfdom, Madrid, ed. Alianza, 2002.

HEILBRONER, R., & MILBERG, W., La crisis de visión en el pensamiento económico moderno / "e Crisis of Vision in Modern Economic "ought, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1998.

HELD, D., & McGREW, A., Globalización / Antiglobalización. Sobre la reconstrucción del orden mundial / Globalisation / Anti-Globalisation: On the Reconstruction of World Order, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 2003.

HERRERO DE MIÑÓN, M., LLUCH, E., (eds.), Derechos históricos y constitucionalismo útil / Use-ful Historical Rights and Constitutionalism, Madrid, ed. Crítica, 2001.

HERRERO DE MIÑÓN, M., Pactismo y nacionalismo inclusivos / Pacts and Inclusive National-ism, Conciliar la diversidad. Pasado y presente de la vertebración de España, VII y VIII Seminarios Ernest Lluch, Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea-Universidad del País Vasco, 2009.

HICKS, D.A., "e Inequality-Adjusted Human Development Index: A Constructive Proposal, World Development, nº 8, 1997, ps.1283-1298.

HOBBES, T., Leviatán o la Materia, Forma y poder de una República Eclesiástica y Civil / Levia-than or the Matter: Forme and Power of a Common Wealth Ecclesiasticall and Civil, (Primera Edición 1651), Buenos aires, Fondo de Cultura económica, 1994.

HOBSBAWM, E. J. E., Entrevista sobre el siglo XXI / Interview on the Twenty First Century, Barce-lona, ed. Crítica, 2004.

HOLLANDERS, H., TARANTOLA, S., & LOSCHKY, “Regional innovation scoreboard (RIS) 2009”, Programa pro inno Europe, diciembre 2009.

HOLTON, G., Einstein, historias y otras pasiones / Einstein, History and Other Passions, Madrid, Taurus, 1998.

Page 52: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

HUMBOLDT VON, W., Los límites de la acción del Estado, estudio preliminar, traducción y notas de Joaquín Abellán / !e Limits of State Action, Preliminary Study, Translation and Notes by Joaquin Abellan, Madrid, ed. Tecnos, 1988.

HUNTINGTON, S.P., El choque de civilizaciones y la recon"guración del orden mundial / !e Clash of Civilisations and the Remaking of World Order, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1997.

HUNTINGTON, S. P., Who are We?, !e Challenges to America’s National Identity, New York, ed. Simon and Schuster, 2004.

HUTCHINSON, T., Economía Positiva y objetivos de política económica / Positive Economics and Economic Policy Objectives, Barcelona, ed. Vicens Vives, 1971.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso de Investidura como Lehendakari, Parlamento Vasco, Diario de Se-siones, VI Legislatura, nº 4, 29 de diciembre de 1998.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso de Investidura como Lehendakari, Parlamento Vasco, Diario de Se-siones, VII Legislatura, nº 4, 11 de julio de 2001.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso del Pleno monográ"co sobre Paci"cación, sobre Normalización Política y sobre el Diálogo, Parlamento Vasco, Diario de Sesiones, VII Legislatura, nº 6, 28 de septiembre de 2001.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso del Pleno monográ"co sobre Autogobierno, Parlamento Vasco, Diario de Sesiones, VII Legislatura, nº 10, 25 de octubre de 2001.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso de Investidura como Lehendakari, Parlamento Vasco, , Diario de Sesiones, VIII Legislatura, nº 4, 22 de junio de 2005.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Intervención en las Cortes españolas en defensa del Nuevo Estatuto Politico para Euskadi, Congreso de los Diputados, Diario de Sesiones, VIII Legislatura, Pleno y Diputación Permanente, nº 65, 1 de febrero de 2005.

IBARRETXE, J. J., Discurso de Investidura como Lehendakari, Parlamento Vasco, , Diario de Sesiones, IX Legislatura, nº 4, 5 de mayo de 2009.

JÁUREGUI, G., La democracia en el siglo XXI: un nuevo mundo, unos nuevos valores / Democracy in the Twentry First Century: A New World, New Values, Oñate, IVAP (Herri Arduralaritzaren Euskal Erakundea- Instituto Vasco de Administración Pública), 2004.

JIMENEZ HERRERO, L. M., Desarrollo sostenible. Transición a hacia la coevolución global / Sus-tainable Development: Transition to Global Coevolution, Madrid, ed. Pirámide, 2000.

JUDT, T., Ill Fares the Land, London, ed. Allen Lane, 2010.

JULIÉN, C., Le suicide des démocraties / !e Suicide of Democracies, Paris, Editions Grasset, 1972.

KANT, I., Sobre la paz perpetua / On Perpetual Peace, (Presentación de TRUYOL Y SERRA, A.,), Madrid, ed, Tecnos, 1998.

Page 53: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

KANT, I., Fundamentos de la metafísica de las costumbres / Foundation of the Metaphysics of Mor-als, Barcelona, ed. Ariel, 1999.

KEATING, M., “Self-determination, multinational states and the transnational order”, !e Imple-mentation of the right to self-determination as a contribution to con"ict prevention, Barcelona, ed. Centre UNESCO de Catalunya, 1999.

KEATING, M., “European Integration and the Nationalities Question” en EZEIZABARRENA, X.,

MACCLANCY, J., (eds.), Sub-State entities and co-sovereignty within the UE, Donostia, Eusko Ikaskuntza, 2008.

KEATING, M., !e Independence of Scotland. Self-government and the Shi#ing Politics of Union, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009.

KELLEY, A. C., “!e Human Development Index: “Handle with Care”, Population and Develop-ment Review 17, nº 2, June 1991, ps. 315-324.

KENNEDY, P., Auge y Caída de las Grandes Potencias / Rise and Fall of the Great Powers, Barce-lona, ed. Plaza & Janés, 1994

KEYNES, J. M., Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren, Londres, ed. Macmillan, 1933.

KEYNES, J. M., Teoría general de la ocupación, el interés y el dinero / General !eory of Employ-ment, Interest and Money, México, ed. S.L. Fondo de Cultura Económica de España, 2006.

KIERKEGARD, S., Diario íntimo / Peronal Diary, Barcelona, ed. Planeta, 1993.

KLEIN, N., No logo: el poder de las marcas / No Logo: !e Power of Brands, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 2002

KRIELE, M., Legitimitätsprobleme der Bundesrepublik / Legitimacy Problems of the Federal Repub-lic, Munich, ed. Beck, 1979.

KRUGMAN, P., Vendiendo Prosperidad / Peddling Prosperity, Barcelona, ed. Ariel, 1994.

KRUGMAN, P., El gran engaño. Ine$cacia y deshonestidad: Estados Unidos ante el siglo XXI / !e Great Deception, Ine%ciency and Dishonesty: United States Before the Twenty First Century, Barcelona, ed. Crítica, 2004.

KYMLICKA, W., Estados, Naciones y Culturas / States, Nations and Cultures, Córdoba, ed. Al-muzara, 2004.

LATOUCHE, S., Absurdo del productivismo y el derroche. Por una sociedad de decrecimiento / Absurd Protectionism and Waste: For a Society of Decrease, Le Monde Diplomatique, edición española, Madrid, noviembre, 2003.

LATOUCHE, S., La apuesta por el decrecimiento, ¿cómo salir del imaginario dominante? / Betting on the Decline: How Will the Dominant Imaginary?, Barcelona, ed. Icaria, 2008.

Page 54: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

LOCKE, J., Segundo ensayo sobre el gobierno civil / Second Treaties of Government, Madrid, ed. Aguilar, 1969.

LOPERENA, D., Globalización y desarrollo sostenible / Globalisation and Sustainable Develop-ment, Pamplona, ed. Aranzadi, 2003.

LOPEZ-RODRIGUEZ, J., FAIÑA, J.A., & MONTES SOLLA, P., “Case Study Basque Country” !e Basque Country: Strategy for Economic Development, Editado por Jean Monnet Group on Compe-tition and Regional Development, Harvard, 2009.

LOZANO, S., GUTIÉRREZ, E., “Human Development Index: A Non-Compensatory Assesment”, Cuadernos de Economía, 28(50), 2009, ps. 223-235.

LUNDWALL, B. A., Innovation, Growth and Social Cohesión. !e Danish Model, Edward Elgar, 2002

LUNDVALL, B. A, “National Innovation Systems-Analytical Concept and Development tool”, Industry and Innovation, n. 14, 2007, ps. 95-119.

MAALOUF, A., Identidades asesinas / Murderous Identities , Madrid, ed. Alianza, 1999.

MARITAIN, J., El hombre y el estado, Madrid, ed. Encuentro, 2002.

MARTÍ, F., “Introduction” en !e Implementation of the right to self-determination as a contribu-tion to con"ict prevention, Barcelona, ed. Centre UNESCO de Catalunya, 1999.

MAYOR ZARAGOZA, F., La problemática de la sostenibilidad en un mundo globalizado / !e Issue of Sustainability in a Globalized World. Revista de educación, número extraordinario 14 de abril de 2009, ps. 25-62.

MAYOR ZARAGOZA, F., ¿Más de lo mismo? NO / More of the Same? No!, articulo publicado en su blogspot, el 8 de enero de 2010.

MAYOR ZARAGOZA, F., Los límites del crecimiento / !e Limits of Growth, Temas para el debate, nº 181, diciembre 2009, ps.10-16. McROBIE, R., Apéndice Lo pequeño es posible / Small is Possible, en SCHUMACHER, E.F., Lo pequeño es hermoso, Madrid, ed. Tursen S.A. – Hermann Blume, 1990.

MEADOWS, D., Los límites del crecimiento / !e Limits of Growth, Informe para el Club de Roma, Instituto tecnológico de Massachussets-MIT, 1972.

MEADOWS, D., MEADOWS, D.L., RANDERS, J., Los límites del crecimiento: 30 años después / !e Limits of Growth: 30 Years Later, Chelses Green Publishing Company, 1 de junio de 2004.

MILL, J.S., Principles of Political Economy, with some of their applications to social philosophy, London, Longmans, Green and Co., 1923.

MIRALLES, M., & ARQUÉS, R., Amedo. El Estado contra ETA / Amedo: State v. ETA, Barcelona, ed. Plaza y Janés, 1995.

Page 55: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

MISHAN, E.J., !e cost of Economic Growth, London, Staples Press, 1967.

MISSELHORN, M., “Human Development Index by Income Groups”, Instituto Iberoamericano de Investigaciones Económicas, University of Göttingen, November 15, 2006.

MITXELENA, K., El largo y difícil camino del euskera / !e Long and Di"cult Path of Euskera, El libro blanco del euskera, Bilbao, Euskaltzaindia, 1977.

MONDOLFO, R., Rousseau y la conciencia moderna / Rousseau and the Modern Conscience, Buenos Aires, Ed. Eudeba, 1962.

MONDOLFO, R., Problemas y métodos de investigación en la Historia de la Filosofía / Problems and Methods of Research in the History of Philosophy, Buenos Aires, ed. Eudeba, 1969.

MORIN, E., El método: La naturaleza de la naturaleza / Method: !e Nature of Nature, Madrid, ed. Cátedra, 1981.

MOSO, M., & OLAZARÁN, M., Actores, ideas e instituciones: políticas tecnológicas regionales y creación de un sistema de I+D en la Comunidad Autónoma del País Vasco / Actors, Ideas and In-sistutions: Regional Technology Policies and Creating a System of R&D in the Basque Autonomous Country, en OLAZARÁN, M., y GOMEZ URANGA, M., Sistemas regionales de innovación, Leioa, Servicio editorial de la UPV/EHU, 2001.

MUÑAGORRI, I., Derecho penal intercultural y crisis del principio de soberanía / Intercultural Criminal Law and the Principles of Sovereignty Crisis, en PORTILLA, G., (coord.), Mutaciones de leviatán. Legitimación de los nuevos modelos penales, Madrid, ed. Akal, 2005.

MYERS, D., “Does economic growth improve human morale”, Center for a New American Dream. www.newdream.org , 1997.

NAVARRO, M., y ZUBIAURRE, A.., Los centros tecnológicos y el sistema regional de innovación. El caso del País Vasco / Technology Centers and Regional Innovation System: !e Case of the Basque Country, Documento de trabajo nº 38. Instituto de Análisis industrial y #nanciero, Madrid, Univer-sidad Complutense de Madrid, 2003.

NAVARRO ARANCEGUI, M., Los sistemas regionales de innovación. Una revisión crítica / Re-gional Systems of Innovation: A Critical Review, Revista Ekonomiaz nº 70, Primer cuatrimestre de 2009, ps. 24-59.

NELSON, R., & WINTER, S., An evolutionary theory of economic change, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1982.

NELSON, R. R., National Innovation Systems: A Comparative Analysis, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1993.

NIELSEN, K., “Review of Institutionalism. Approaches in the Social Sciences: Typology, Dialogue, and Future Prospects”. Research papers 7/01, Department of Social Sciences, Roskilde University, 2003.

Page 56: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

NISBET, R., History of the Idee of Progress, London, ed. Einemann, 1980.

NORDSTRÖM, K., & RIDDERSTRÁLE, J., Funky Business, Madrid, ed. Prentice Hall, 2000.

NOORBAKHSH, F., “A Modi!ed Human Development Index”, World Development, vol. 26, nº 3, 1998, ps. 517-528.

NORTH, D., Instituciones, cambio institucional y desempeño económico / Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance, México, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1993.

NOZIK, R., Anarchy, State, and Utopia, New York, Basic Books, 1974.

OLAZARÁN RODRÍGUEZ, M. & GÓMEZ URANGA, M., Sistemas regionales de innovación / Regional Innovation Systems, Leioa, Servicio editorial de la UPV/EHU, 2001..

ORIOL, J., Revisión crítica de los aportes del institucionalismo a la teoría y la práctica del desar-rollo / Critical Review of the Contributions of Institutionalism "eory and Practice of Development, Revista de Economía Institucional, v. 9, nº 16, Primer semestre, 2007, ps. 121-148.

OSBORNE, D., & GAEBLER, T., La reinvención del gobierno. La in#uencia del espíritu empre-sarial en el sector público / "e Reinvention of Government: "e In#uence of Entrepreneurship in the Public Sector, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1995.

PETERS, G., Institutional "eory in Political Science. "e “new institutionalism”, London, Rouledge, 1999.

PETRELLA, R., El bien común. Elogio de la solidaridad / "e Common Good: In Praise of Solidar-ity, Madrid, ed. Debate, 1997.

PI i MARGALL, F., Las Nacionalidades / Nationalities (1876), Madrid, ed. Edicusa, 1973.

PIORE, M. J., & SABEL C. F., La Segunda Ruptura Industrial / "e Second Industrial Divide, Madrid. Alianza ed., 1990.

POLANYI, K., La gran transformación, crítica del liberalismo económico / "e Great Transforma-tion: Criticism of Economic Liberalism, Madrid, ed. La Piqueta, 1989.

POPPER, K. R., La sociedad abierta y sus enemigos / "e Open Society and its Enemies, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1994.

PORTER, M., "e Competitive Advantages of Nations, New York, ed. Free Press, 1990.

PORTILLA CONTRERAS, G., Mutaciones del Leviatan. Legitimación de los nuevos modelos pe-nales / Mutations of Leviathan: Legitimization of the New Criminal Model, Madrid, ed. Akal, 2005.

RAMÓN Y CAJA L, S., Discurso de entrada en la Real Academia de Ciencias Exactas / Input-Speech at the Royal Academy of Sciences, Físicas y Naturales, 1897.

RAMONET, I., et al., Pensamiento Crítico vs. Pensamiento Único / "inking v. Unique "ought, Madrid, ed. Le Monde Diplomatique, 2001.

Page 57: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

REICH, R. B., El trabajo de las naciones. Hacia el capitalismo del siglo XXI / !e Work of Nations: Towards the Twenty First Century Capitalism, Madrid, Javier Vergara ed., 1993.

REINICKE, W. H., Global Public Policy. Governing without Government?, Washington, ed. Brook-ings Institution Press, 1998.

REQUEJO, F., Una democracia plurinacional a medio hacer: el Plan Ibarretxe y el Estado de las Autonomías / A Half Plurinational Democracy: !e Ibarretxe Plan and the State of Autonomy, en Estudios sobre la propuesta política para la convivencia del Lehendakari Ibarretxe, Oñate, Instituto Vasco de Administración Pública, 2003.

RHULEN, M., A guide to worlds languages: Classi"cation, Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1987.

RHULEN, M., On the origin of languages, Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1994.

RIFKIN, J., El "n del trabajo. Nuevas tecnologías contra puestos de trabajo: el nacimiento de una nueva era / !e End of Work, New Technologies Against Jobs: !e Birth of a New Era, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 1996.

RIFKIN, J., La economía del hidrógeno. La creación de la red energética mundial y la redistribución del poder en la tierra / !e Hydrogen Economy: !e Creation of the Global Network and the Redis-tribution of Power in the Land, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 2004.

RIFKIN, J., El sueño europeo. Cómo la visión europea del futuro está eclipsando el sueño ameri-cano / !e European Dream: How Europe’s Vision of the Future is Eclipsing the American Dream, Barcelona, ed. Paidós, 2004.

ROCO, M. C., National Nanotecnological Iniciative-Past, present, future, Handbook on Nanosci-ence, Engineering and Technology, 2nd ed., ed. Taylor and Francis, 2007.

ROOSEVELT, F. D., Discurso inaugural de la 32 presidencia de los Estados Unidos / Inaugural Speech of the 32nd U.S. Presidency, Washington, 4 March 1933.

ROUSSEAU, J. J., Du Contract Social (Primera versión) / !e Social Contract (First Version), O.C., v. 3, Paris, ed. De La Pléiade, 1964.

ROUSSEAU, J. J., Émile, L, IV, O. C., Paris, Editions de la Pléiade / Gallimard, 1969.

ROUSSEAU, J. J., Extrait du Projet de Paix Perpetuélle de Monsieur l’Abbé de Saint Pierre / Extract from the Project for Perpetual Peace of Monsieur l’Abbe de Saint Piere, L.III, O.C., Paris, Editions de la Pléiade /Gallimard, 1969.

RYFF, C., “Happiness Is everything, or is it?”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, v. 57, 1989, ps. 1069-1081.

SAID, E. W., Cultura e imperialismo / Culture and Imperialism, Barcelona, ed. Anagrama, 1996.

SAMPER, E., El salto global. Retos de América Latina ante la globalización / !e Overall Jump: Latin American Challenges to Globalization, Bogotá, ed. Taurus, 2004.

Page 58: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

SAMUELSON, P. & NORDHAUS, W., Economía / Economy, Madrid, ed. McGraw-Hill, 1999.

SÁNCHEZ INAREJOS, J. J., La globalización al desnudo / Globalisation Laid Bare, Madrid, ed. Chaos-Entropy, 2001.

SARAMAGO, J., La caverna / !e Cavern, Madrid, ed. Santillana, Suma de letras, 2002.

SARATXAGA, K. & SALCEDO, J., El éxito fue la con"anza. Una historia real ocurrida en el País Vasco en plena crisis del 2008 / !e Success Was Trust: A True Story that Occured in the Basque Country in the 2008 Crisis, Bilbao, ed. K2K emocionado, 2010.

SCHUMACHER, E. F., “Small is beautiful: Economics as if people mattered”. New York, Perennial Library, 1973.

SCHUMACHER, E. F., Lo pequeño es hermoso / Small is Beautiful, Madrid, ed. Tursen S.A.-Hermann Blume, 1990.

SCHUMPETER, J. A., Teoría del desenvolvimiento económico: una investigación sobre ganancias, capital, crédito, interés y ciclo económico / !eory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into Prof-its, Capital, Credit, Interet and Business Cycle, México, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1967.

SCHUMPETER, J. A., Historia del análisis económico / History of Economic Analysis, Barcelona, ed. Ariel, 1995.

SCOTT, A. J., Regions and the world economy. !e coming shape of global production, competition, and political order, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1998.

SCOTT, A. J., STORPER, M., “Regions, Globalisation, Development“, documento para el grupo de trabajo Globalitation, Regions, and Economic Development sponsored by the Center for Compara-tive and Global Research, International Institute, UCLA, published, Regional Studies, v. 37, 2003.

SEMPERE CARRERAS, J., & TELLO ARAGAY, E., El "nal de la era del petróleo barato / !e End of the Era of Cheap Oil, Barcelona, ed. Icaria, 2007.

SIERRA LUDWIG, V., Desarrollo sostenible: acotaciones conceptuales y revisiones estratégicas / Sustainable Development: Conceptual Dimensions and Strategic Reviews, Boletín Económico de

ICE, nª 2749, 25 de noviembre al 1 de diciembre de 2002, ps. 13-23.

SOROS, G., La crisis del capitalismo global. La sociedad abierta en peligro / !e Crisis of Global Capitalism: !e Open Society Endangered, Madrid, ed. Debate, 1999.

SOTELO, I., El Estado Social. Antecedentes, origen, desarrollo y declive / !e Social State: History, Origin, Development and Decline, Madrid, ed. Trotta, 2010.

STIGLITZ, J. E., El malestar en la globalización / Globalisation and its Discontents, Madrid, Santil-lana Ediciones Generales, 2002.

STORA, B., & TEMIME, E., Immigrances. L`immgration en France au XXe siècle / Immingrant Women#: Immigration in France in the Twenty First Century, Paris, ed. Hachette, 2007.

Page 59: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development
Page 60: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development
Page 61: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development
Page 62: The basque case  a comprehensive model for sustainable human development

=>#?)923#$8)..&0@BC5(D&3E@5(F&35')(F,?G#5C5%3"H5(2,15*(/,#(I@3+&"%&J*5(K@?&%(L5H5*,G?5%+DM(L#A(NANA(OJ&##5+05(2&#7@&#+@

BC"3( 1,6@?5%+( G#535%+3( &%( 5056@+"H5( 3@??&#M( ,/( &( /&#( ?,#5(50+5%3"H5( P,"%+( #535&#6C( G#,P56+( 6,%1@6+51( JM( Q5,#$5( 2&3,%(

N@&%;N,35(OJ&##5+05(2&#7@&#+@A((

6,%3"3+3(,/(35H5%(+5##"+,#"53(6@##5%+*M(&#+"6@*&+51("%(+C#55(1"//5#5%+(G,*"+"6&*(&%1(&1?"%"3+#&+"H5(#5&*"+"53-(1"H"151(J5+R55%(.#&%65(&%1(

.#5%6C(3"15-(+C5#5(&#5(+C#55(D&3E@5(+5##"+,#"53(R"+C,@+(&@+,%,?,@3(

$#,@G51("%(+R,(G,*"+"6&**M(1"//5#5%+"&+51(#5$",%3'(+C5(F,??@%"+M(,/(4&H&##5(&%1(+C5(D&3E@5()@+,%,?,@3(F,??@%"+M-(RC"6C("3(C,?5(+,(8ST(,/(&**(D&3E@53A(U"+C(/5R(5065G+",%3-(+C5(#535&#6C(C5#5"%(#5/5#3(+,(+C5()@+,%,?,@3(F,??@%"+M(,/(+C5(D&3E@5(F,@%+#M(&3(+C5(VD&3E@5(F,@%+#MAW

36&#A$?@A51@

)(?533&$5(/#,?(+C5(&@+C,#'

O(R,@*1(*"75(+,(50G#533(?M($#&+"+@15(+,(H&#",@3("%1"H"1@&*3(&%1("%3+"+@+",%3(+C&+(G*&M51(&(#,*5(

&%1(F,*@?J"&(X%"H5#3"+M(R"+C,@+(RC,?(%,%5(,/(+C"3(R,@*1(C&H5(J55%(G,33"J*5A(

BC&%73( "%( G&#+"6@*&#( +,( )%1#5&( D&#+,*"( /#,?(Q5,#$5(2&3,%(X%"H5#3"+M-( +,(Y5+5#(F,*5?&%(/#,?( F,*@?J"&( X%"H5#3"+M-( +,( ."*"GG,( )11&#"(

3@GG,#+( /,#(?M( #535&#6C(R&3(5335%+"&*A()%1(

&%1( 1"*"$5%+( 6,,#1"%&+,#( ,/( +C"3( #535&#6C(G#,P56+( 1@#"%$( ?M( 3+&M3( "%( U&3C"%$+,%-(Z,%1,%(&%1(45R([,#7(&%1(RC,(C&3(J56,?5(&( $#5&+( /#"5%1( ,/( ?"%5( &%1( ,/( +C5( D&3E@5(F,@%+#MA

BC&%73(?@3+(&*3,($,(+,(+C5(?&%M(&6&15?"63(&%1( +C"#1(356+,#( *5&15#3(RC,(C&H5( *5%+( +C5"#(H&*@&J*5(+"?5(+,(3+@1M"%$(&%1(6,%+#"J@+"%$(+,(+C"3(G#,P56+A()**(,/(+C5?-(RC5+C5#(+C"3(#535&#6C(

C5*G51( +,( 5%#"6C( "+-( R"+C( +C5"#( 6,%+#"J@+",%3(&%1-(&J,H5(&**-(R"+C( +C5"#(6#"+"6"3?3-(?&%M(,/(

1,6@?5%+A((

5H5#MRC5#5(RC,(&#5(3+#@$$*"%$(+,(6C&%$5(&%(@%P@3+(R,#*1-(+C5(,%*M(6&@35(R,#+C(*"H"%$(/,#A((