ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Highway Termini Location Work Description

TUCSON - ORACLE JCT. - GLOBE HWY. (SR 77) S. OLD TIGER ROAD - MIGUEL ROA PAVEMENT REHABILITATION

TRACS No. Project No. Item County District Gross Length Net Length Prepared By:

CONTRACT # 2017023

TABULATION OF BIDS

077 PN 113 H879101C 077-A-(214)T 12217 PINAL SOUTHCENT 8 Shah Manish

CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTIONINFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 1 of 22

BidRank ContractorBid Amount

Compared ToDepartment

EstimateExtended

Sum of Items

$4,319,273.50FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC.115 S. 48TH ST TEMPE, AZ 85281

1 -3.1% $4,319,273.50

$4,343,939.45SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO.4102 E ILLINOIS ST TUCSON, AZ 85714

2 -2.5% $4,343,939.45

$4,400,000.00FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVING1302 W. Drivers Way Tempe, AZ 85284

3 -1.3% $4,400,000.00

$4,455,972.25DEPARTMENT ESTIMATE+% $4,455,972.25

$4,693,472.00GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY4115 E ILLINOIS ST TUCSON, AZ 85714

4 +5.3% $4,693,472.00

$5,425,000.00K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC.1601 Paseo San Luis Suite 202 Sierra Vista, AZ 85635

5 +21.7% $5,425,000.00

Winning Bidder is 3.1% Under Department Estimate (Difference = ($136,698.75))

Completion Date:120 Working DaysThe proposed project is located in Pinal County on SR 77, north of Mammoth, between mileposts 113.65 and 120.44. The proposed work includes milling the existing asphalticconcrete and replacing it with asphaltic concrete and a double chip seal coat application. Additional work includes removing and replacing guardrail, pipe culverts, sidewalk,driveways, sidewalk ramps, pavement markings, and other related work.

Bid Opening Date : 8/25/2017, Prequalification Required, Engineer Specialist : Shah Manish

BID RESULTS FOR 2017023

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 2 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

2020021 L.FT. REMOVAL OF CONCRETE CURB AND GUTTERBid Rank Department Estimate 940.000 $10.000 $9,400.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12.000 $11,280.00 +20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $10.000 $9,400.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $12.000 $11,280.00 +20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $12.000 $11,280.00 +20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $11.500 $10,810.00 +15.0%

2020025 SQ.FT. REMOVAL OF CONCRETE SIDEWALKS, DRIVEWAYS AND SLABSBid Rank Department Estimate 5,840.000 $3.000 $17,520.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $17,520.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $3.000 $17,520.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $5.500 $32,120.00 +83.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $3.000 $17,520.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.900 $16,936.00 -3.3%

2020029 SQ.YD. REMOVAL OF ASPHALTIC CONCRETE PAVEMENTBid Rank Department Estimate 1,350.000 $20.000 $27,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5.000 $6,750.00 -75.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $5.250 $7,087.50 -73.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $10.000 $13,500.00 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $4.000 $5,400.00 -80.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12.000 $16,200.00 -40.0%

2020041 L.FT. REMOVAL OF PIPEBid Rank Department Estimate 85.000 $30.000 $2,550.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $60.000 $5,100.00 +100.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $40.000 $3,400.00 +33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $50.000 $4,250.00 +66.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $30.000 $2,550.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $47.500 $4,037.50 +58.3%

2020053 EACH REMOVE (GUARD RAIL TERMINAL)(TANGENT TYPE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 4.000 $500.000 $2,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $400.000 $1,600.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $550.000 $2,200.00 +10.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $600.000 $2,400.00 +20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $146.000 $584.00 -70.8%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $175.000 $700.00 -65.0%

2020054 EACH REMOVE (GUARD RAIL, ANCHOR ASSEMBLY)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $500.000 $500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $400.000 $400.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $440.000 $440.00 -12.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 3 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

2020054 EACH REMOVE (GUARD RAIL, ANCHOR ASSEMBLY)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $500.000 $500.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $430.000 $430.00 -14.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $570.000 $570.00 +14.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $175.000 $175.00 -65.0%

2020071 L.FT. REMOVE GUARD RAILBid Rank Department Estimate 225.000 $5.000 $1,125.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $675.00 -40.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $9.000 $2,025.00 +80.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $8.500 $1,912.50 +70.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $4.000 $900.00 -20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.450 $776.25 -31.0%

2020081 SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (1")Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,050.000 $2.000 $2,100.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4.000 $4,200.00 +100.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $4.000 $4,200.00 +100.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.500 $2,625.00 +25.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1.800 $1,890.00 -10.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.850 $2,992.50 +42.5%

2020083 SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (2")Bid Rank Department Estimate 21,200.000 $1.200 $25,440.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $63,600.00 +150.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $4.000 $84,800.00 +233.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.500 $53,000.00 +108.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1.800 $38,160.00 +50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4.800 $101,760.00 +300.0%

2020085 SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (3")Bid Rank Department Estimate 119,800.000 $1.400 $167,720.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.800 $215,640.00 +28.6%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1.850 $221,630.00 +32.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.000 $239,600.00 +42.9%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1.500 $179,700.00 +7.1%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.450 $413,310.00 +146.4%

2020086 SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (3 1/2 ")Bid Rank Department Estimate 41,320.000 $1.500 $61,980.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.750 $72,310.00 +16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2.050 $84,706.00 +36.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.200 $90,904.00 +46.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1.500 $61,980.00 +0.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 4 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

2020086 SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (3 1/2 ")Bid Rank Department Estimate 41,320.000 $1.500 $61,980.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.950 $163,214.00 +163.3%

2020115 EACH REMOVE (SCUPPER)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $500.000 $500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $500.000 $500.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $500.000 $500.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1,000.000 $1,000.00 +100.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $400.000 $400.00 -20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $255.000 $255.00 -49.0%

2020120 L.FT. REMOVE (SAFETY RAIL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 85.000 $20.000 $1,700.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $10.000 $850.00 -50.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $9.250 $786.25 -53.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $32.000 $2,720.00 +60.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $10.000 $850.00 -50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $11.500 $977.50 -42.5%

2020152 SQ.YD. REMOVE DETOURBid Rank Department Estimate 1,500.000 $5.000 $7,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.500 $5,250.00 -30.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $11.000 $16,500.00 +120.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $15.000 $22,500.00 +200.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $8.000 $12,000.00 +60.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $14.500 $21,750.00 +190.0%

2030112 L.FT. SHOULDER BUILD-UP (MILLED AC)Bid Rank Department Estimate 21,120.000 $0.250 $5,280.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.800 $16,896.00 +220.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.500 $10,560.00 +100.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.500 $10,560.00 +100.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.160 $3,379.20 -36.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.650 $34,848.00 +560.0%

2030113 HOUR SHOULDER BUILD-UP (COMPACTION)Bid Rank Department Estimate 24.000 $90.000 $2,160.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $90.000 $2,160.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $200.000 $4,800.00 +122.2%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $125.000 $3,000.00 +38.9%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $72.000 $1,728.00 -20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $110.000 $2,640.00 +22.2%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 5 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

2030301 CU.YD. ROADWAY EXCAVATIONBid Rank Department Estimate 1,203.000 $30.000 $36,090.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15.000 $18,045.00 -50.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $20.000 $24,060.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $18.000 $21,654.00 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $45.000 $54,135.00 +50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $13.500 $16,240.50 -55.0%

2030401 CU.YD. DRAINAGE EXCAVATIONBid Rank Department Estimate 316.000 $25.000 $7,900.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $20.000 $6,320.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $7.000 $2,212.00 -72.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $18.000 $5,688.00 -28.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $45.000 $14,220.00 +80.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12.000 $3,792.00 -52.0%

3030022 CU.YD. AGGREGATE BASE, CLASS 2Bid Rank Department Estimate 190.000 $85.000 $16,150.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $125.000 $23,750.00 +47.1%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $62.000 $11,780.00 -27.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $100.000 $19,000.00 +17.6%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $120.000 $22,800.00 +41.2%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $105.000 $19,950.00 +23.5%

4040073 TON EMULSIFIED ASPHALT (CRS-2P)Bid Rank Department Estimate 220.000 $450.000 $99,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $400.000 $88,000.00 -11.1%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $475.000 $104,500.00 +5.6%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $470.000 $103,400.00 +4.4%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $540.000 $118,800.00 +20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $615.000 $135,300.00 +36.7%

4040078 TON EMULSIFIED ASPHALT (FOR FOG COAT) (CSS-1)Bid Rank Department Estimate 65.000 $370.000 $24,050.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $250.000 $16,250.00 -32.4%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $315.000 $20,475.00 -14.9%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $600.000 $39,000.00 +62.2%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $619.000 $40,235.00 +67.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $705.000 $45,825.00 +90.5%

4040111 TON BITUMINOUS TACK COATBid Rank Department Estimate 45.000 $400.000 $18,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $375.000 $16,875.00 -6.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $255.000 $11,475.00 -36.3%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 6 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

4040111 TON BITUMINOUS TACK COATBid Rank Department Estimate 45.000 $400.000 $18,000.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $300.000 $13,500.00 -25.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $200.000 $9,000.00 -50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $430.000 $19,350.00 +7.5%

4040116 HOUR APPLY BITUMINOUS TACK COATBid Rank Department Estimate 135.000 $150.000 $20,250.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $135.000 $18,225.00 -10.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $125.000 $16,875.00 -16.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $125.000 $16,875.00 -16.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $100.000 $13,500.00 -33.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $385.000 $51,975.00 +156.7%

4040162 CU.YD. COVER MATERIALBid Rank Department Estimate 1,250.000 $100.000 $125,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $55.000 $68,750.00 -45.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $65.000 $81,250.00 -35.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $75.000 $93,750.00 -25.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $106.000 $132,500.00 +6.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $110.000 $137,500.00 +10.0%

4040163 TON BLOTTER MATERIALBid Rank Department Estimate 420.000 $30.000 $12,600.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $55.000 $23,100.00 +83.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $55.000 $23,100.00 +83.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $35.000 $14,700.00 +16.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $10.000 $4,200.00 -66.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $81.000 $34,020.00 +170.0%

4040270 TON ASPHALT BINDER (PG 70-10)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,355.000 $450.000 $609,750.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $250.000 $338,750.00 -44.4%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $328.000 $444,440.00 -27.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $270.000 $365,850.00 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $227.000 $307,585.00 -49.6%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $342.600 $464,223.00 -23.9%

4090003 TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (MISCELLANEOUS STRUCTURAL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,180.000 $100.000 $218,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $80.000 $174,400.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $89.000 $194,020.00 -11.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $85.000 $185,300.00 -15.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $90.000 $196,200.00 -10.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 7 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

4090003 TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (MISCELLANEOUS STRUCTURAL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,180.000 $100.000 $218,000.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $105.000 $228,900.00 +5.0%

4160002 TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (3/4" MIX) (END PRODUCT)Bid Rank Department Estimate 27,060.000 $45.000 $1,217,700.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $41.000 $1,109,460.00 -8.9%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $40.500 $1,095,930.00 -10.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $37.550 $1,016,103.00 -16.6%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $38.000 $1,028,280.00 -15.6%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $51.250 $1,386,825.00 +13.9%

4160031 TON MINERAL ADMIXTUREBid Rank Department Estimate 255.000 $90.000 $22,950.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $90.000 $22,950.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $90.000 $22,950.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $90.000 $22,950.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $90.000 $22,950.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $90.000 $22,950.00 +0.0%

5010007 L.FT. PIPE, CORRUGATED METAL, 18"Bid Rank Department Estimate 92.000 $70.000 $6,440.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $100.000 $9,200.00 +42.9%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $67.000 $6,164.00 -4.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $100.000 $9,200.00 +42.9%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $100.000 $9,200.00 +42.9%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $63.500 $5,842.00 -9.3%

5010011 L.FT. PIPE, CORRUGATED METAL, 24"Bid Rank Department Estimate 34.000 $90.000 $3,060.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $125.000 $4,250.00 +38.9%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $178.000 $6,052.00 +97.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $200.000 $6,800.00 +122.2%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $100.000 $3,400.00 +11.1%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $93.500 $3,179.00 +3.9%

5010045 L.FT. PIPE, CORRUGATED METAL, 60"Bid Rank Department Estimate 222.000 $100.000 $22,200.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $300.000 $66,600.00 +200.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $312.000 $69,264.00 +212.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $350.000 $77,700.00 +250.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $375.000 $83,250.00 +275.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $265.000 $58,830.00 +165.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 8 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

6010506 SQ.YD. BRIDGE REPAIR (POLYESTER POLYMER CONCRETE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,850.000 $130.000 $370,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $175.000 $498,750.00 +34.6%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $164.000 $467,400.00 +26.2%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $150.000 $427,500.00 +15.4%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $275.000 $783,750.00 +111.5%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $190.000 $541,500.00 +46.2%

6010731 SQ.YD. CONCRETE SLAB (PROTECTIVE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 21.000 $300.000 $6,300.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $137.000 $2,877.00 -54.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $170.000 $3,570.00 -43.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $350.000 $7,350.00 +16.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $150.000 $3,150.00 -50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $150.000 $3,150.00 -50.0%

6016088 EACH HEADWALL (INLET)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $20,000.000 $20,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $32,000.000 $32,000.00 +60.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $29,000.000 $29,000.00 +45.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $40,000.000 $40,000.00 +100.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $40,000.000 $40,000.00 +100.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $33,800.000 $33,800.00 +69.0%

6016089 EACH HEADWALL (OUTLET)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $25,000.000 $25,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $65,000.000 $65,000.00 +160.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $51,000.000 $51,000.00 +104.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $60,000.000 $60,000.00 +140.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $85,000.000 $85,000.00 +240.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $112,000.000 $112,000.00 +348.0%

6070038 EACH SLIP BASE (Bid Rank Department Estimate 8.000 $200.000 $1,600.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $140.000 $1,120.00 -30.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $306.000 $2,448.00 +53.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $350.000 $2,800.00 +75.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $310.000 $2,480.00 +55.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $160.000 $1,280.00 -20.0%

6070055 L.FT. SIGN POST (PERFORATED) (2 1/2 S)Bid Rank Department Estimate 48.000 $11.000 $528.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $11.000 $528.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $6.750 $324.00 -38.6%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 9 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

6070055 L.FT. SIGN POST (PERFORATED) (2 1/2 S)Bid Rank Department Estimate 48.000 $11.000 $528.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $25.000 $1,200.00 +127.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $6.800 $326.40 -38.2%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $13.000 $624.00 +18.2%

6070057 L.FT. SIGN POST (PERFORATED) (2 1/2 T)Bid Rank Department Estimate 66.000 $14.000 $924.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $17.000 $1,122.00 +21.4%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $9.500 $627.00 -32.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $30.000 $1,980.00 +114.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $9.600 $633.60 -31.4%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $19.000 $1,254.00 +35.7%

6070060 EACH FOUNDATION FOR SIGN POST (CONCRETE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 10.000 $200.000 $2,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $225.000 $2,250.00 +12.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $200.000 $2,000.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $200.000 $2,000.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $185.000 $1,850.00 -7.5%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $250.000 $2,500.00 +25.0%

6080005 SQ.FT. WARNING, MARKER, OR REGULATORY SIGN PANELBid Rank Department Estimate 220.000 $24.000 $5,280.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15.000 $3,300.00 -37.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $16.000 $3,520.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $50.000 $11,000.00 +108.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $16.400 $3,608.00 -31.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $16.500 $3,630.00 -31.3%

6080025 SQ.FT. FLAT SHEET ALUMINUM SIGN PANELBid Rank Department Estimate 105.000 $26.000 $2,730.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15.000 $1,575.00 -42.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $18.000 $1,890.00 -30.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $50.000 $5,250.00 +92.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $17.550 $1,842.75 -32.5%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $17.000 $1,785.00 -34.6%

6080101 L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS WORK (SIGNS)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,500.000 $3,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,000.000 $3,000.00 -14.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1,200.000 $1,200.00 -65.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3,100.000 $3,100.00 -11.4%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1,000.000 $1,000.00 -71.4%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 10 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

6080101 L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS WORK (SIGNS)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,500.000 $3,500.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2,900.000 $2,900.00 -17.1%

6110200 L.FT. METAL HANDRAIL (BOTTOM RAIL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,150.000 $15.000 $17,250.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12.000 $13,800.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $11.000 $12,650.00 -26.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $18.000 $20,700.00 +20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $10.000 $11,500.00 -33.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $14.000 $16,100.00 -6.7%

6110202 L.FT. METAL HANDRAIL (SAFETY RAIL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 175.000 $50.000 $8,750.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $38.000 $6,650.00 -24.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $36.000 $6,300.00 -28.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $40.000 $7,000.00 -20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $63.000 $11,025.00 +26.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $45.000 $7,875.00 -10.0%

7015010 L.FT. TEMPORARY CONCRETE BARRIER (INSTALLATION AND REMOVAL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 660.000 $22.000 $14,520.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $19.000 $12,540.00 -13.6%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $20.000 $13,200.00 -9.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $20.000 $13,200.00 -9.1%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $26.000 $17,160.00 +18.2%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $21.000 $13,860.00 -4.5%

7015042 L.FT. TEMPORARY PAINTED MARKING (STRIPE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 118,000.000 $0.120 $14,160.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $11,800.00 -16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.110 $12,980.00 -8.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.120 $14,160.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.120 $14,160.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $17,700.00 +25.0%

7015052 L.FT. OBLITERATE PAVEMENT MARKING (STRIPE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,570.000 $0.700 $1,799.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.400 $1,028.00 -42.9%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.450 $1,156.50 -35.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.450 $1,156.50 -35.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.460 $1,182.20 -34.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.600 $1,542.00 -14.3%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 11 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7015061 EACH TEMPORARY PAVEMENT MARKERS (RAISED) (REFLECTIVE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 47.000 $6.000 $282.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $7.000 $329.00 +16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $6.000 $282.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $141.00 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $5.750 $270.25 -4.2%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $7.550 $354.85 +25.8%

7015069 EACH TEMPORARY PAVEMENT MARKERS (CHIP SEAL)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,300.000 $2.500 $3,250.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.000 $2,600.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2.000 $2,600.00 -20.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $3,900.00 +20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1.150 $1,495.00 -54.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.100 $1,430.00 -56.0%

7015091 SQ.FT. SPECIALTY SIGNSBid Rank Department Estimate 135.000 $26.000 $3,510.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $16.000 $2,160.00 -38.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $20.000 $2,700.00 -23.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $15.000 $2,025.00 -42.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $13.750 $1,856.25 -47.1%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $21.000 $2,835.00 -19.2%

7016020 L.FT./DAY TEMPORARY CONCRETE BARRIER (IN USE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 9,240.000 $0.150 $1,386.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $924.00 -33.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.100 $924.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.090 $831.60 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.250 $2,310.00 +66.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.070 $646.80 -53.3%

7016030 EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE II, VERT.PANEL, TUBULAR MARKER)Bid Rank Department Estimate 6,765.000 $0.200 $1,353.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $1,014.75 -25.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.100 $676.50 -50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $676.50 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.300 $2,029.50 +50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.120 $811.80 -40.0%

7016031 EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE III, HIGH LEVEL FLAG TREES)Bid Rank Department Estimate 160.000 $0.500 $80.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.500 $80.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.250 $40.00 -50.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 12 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7016031 EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE III, HIGH LEVEL FLAG TREES)Bid Rank Department Estimate 160.000 $0.500 $80.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.500 $80.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.250 $40.00 -50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.260 $41.60 -48.0%

7016032 EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (RIGID)Bid Rank Department Estimate 100.000 $0.400 $40.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $35.00 -12.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.110 $11.00 -72.5%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.300 $30.00 -25.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.500 $50.00 +25.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.130 $13.00 -67.5%

7016033 EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (SPRING TYPE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,160.000 $0.500 $1,080.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $756.00 -30.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1.000 $2,160.00 +100.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.300 $648.00 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.750 $1,620.00 +50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.460 $993.60 -8.0%

7016035 EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE A)Bid Rank Department Estimate 6,600.000 $0.150 $990.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $990.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.090 $594.00 -40.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $660.00 -33.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.090 $594.00 -40.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $660.00 -33.3%

7016037 EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE C)Bid Rank Department Estimate 5,365.000 $0.200 $1,073.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $804.75 -25.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.100 $536.50 -50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $536.50 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.350 $1,877.75 +75.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.120 $643.80 -40.0%

7016038 EACH-DAY TRAFFIC CONE (28 INCHES)Bid Rank Department Estimate 7,230.000 $0.200 $1,446.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $2,530.50 +75.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.100 $723.00 -50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.300 $2,169.00 +50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.100 $723.00 -50.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 13 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7016038 EACH-DAY TRAFFIC CONE (28 INCHES)Bid Rank Department Estimate 7,230.000 $0.200 $1,446.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.120 $867.60 -40.0%

7016039 EACH-DAY EMBEDDED SIGN POSTBid Rank Department Estimate 8,560.000 $0.100 $856.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $1,284.00 +50.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.060 $513.60 -40.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $856.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.200 $1,712.00 +100.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.070 $599.20 -30.0%

7016050 EACH-DAY TRUCK MOUNTED ATTENUATORBid Rank Department Estimate 20.000 $400.000 $8,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $100.000 $2,000.00 -75.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $555.000 $11,100.00 +38.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $160.000 $3,200.00 -60.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $530.000 $10,600.00 +32.5%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $130.000 $2,600.00 -67.5%

7016051 EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (LESS THAN 10 S.F.)Bid Rank Department Estimate 155.000 $0.500 $77.50

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.400 $62.00 -20.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.250 $38.75 -50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.300 $46.50 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.500 $77.50 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $31.00 -60.0%

7016052 EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (10 S.F. OR MORE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 6,325.000 $0.600 $3,795.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.400 $2,530.00 -33.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.350 $2,213.75 -41.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.300 $1,897.50 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.750 $4,743.75 +25.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.390 $2,466.75 -35.0%

7016067 EACH-DAY CHANGEABLE MESSAGE BOARD (CONTRACTOR FURNISHED)Bid Rank Department Estimate 511.000 $25.000 $12,775.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $18.000 $9,198.00 -28.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $22.000 $11,242.00 -12.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $15.000 $7,665.00 -40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $22.000 $11,242.00 -12.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $25.000 $12,775.00 +0.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 14 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7016071 HOUR PILOT VEHICLE WITH DRIVERBid Rank Department Estimate 310.000 $50.000 $15,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $50.000 $15,500.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $40.000 $12,400.00 -20.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $50.000 $15,500.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $43.000 $13,330.00 -14.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $44.000 $13,640.00 -12.0%

7016075 HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (CIVILIAN)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,140.000 $30.000 $64,200.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $30.000 $64,200.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $20.000 $42,800.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $25.000 $53,500.00 -16.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $28.000 $59,920.00 -6.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $30.500 $65,270.00 +1.7%

7016078 HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (LOCAL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER)Bid Rank Department Estimate 570.000 $70.000 $39,900.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $65.000 $37,050.00 -7.1%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $61.000 $34,770.00 -12.9%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $66.000 $37,620.00 -5.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $47.000 $26,790.00 -32.9%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $70.500 $40,185.00 +0.7%

7016080 HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (DPS)Bid Rank Department Estimate 600.000 $65.260 $39,156.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $65.260 $39,156.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $65.260 $39,156.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $65.260 $39,156.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $65.260 $39,156.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $65.260 $39,156.00 +0.0%

7030085 EACH OBJECT MARKER (OM3 PANEL ONLY)Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $200.000 $3,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $110.000 $1,650.00 -45.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $25.000 $375.00 -87.5%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $125.000 $1,875.00 -37.5%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $150.000 $2,250.00 -25.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $120.000 $1,800.00 -40.0%

7040005 L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (WHITE EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 107,000.000 $0.350 $37,450.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $37,450.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.350 $37,450.00 +0.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 15 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7040005 L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (WHITE EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 107,000.000 $0.350 $37,450.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.350 $37,450.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.350 $37,450.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.470 $50,290.00 +34.3%

7040006 L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (YELLOW EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 57,000.000 $0.350 $19,950.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $19,950.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.350 $19,950.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.350 $19,950.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.350 $19,950.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.470 $26,790.00 +34.3%

7040072 L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (TRANSVERSE) (THERMOPLASTIC) (ALKYD) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,060.000 $0.800 $1,648.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.550 $1,133.00 -31.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.560 $1,153.60 -30.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.500 $1,030.00 -37.5%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.570 $1,174.20 -28.8%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.750 $1,545.00 -6.3%

7040073 EACH PAVEMENT LEGEND (EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (ALKYD) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 2.000 $160.000 $320.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $110.000 $220.00 -31.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $115.000 $230.00 -28.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $150.000 $300.00 -6.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $150.000 $300.00 -6.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $150.000 $300.00 -6.3%

7040074 EACH PAVEMENT SYMBOL (EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (ALKYD) (0.090")Bid Rank Department Estimate 6.000 $160.000 $960.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $110.000 $660.00 -31.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $115.000 $690.00 -28.1%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $150.000 $900.00 -6.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $150.000 $900.00 -6.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $150.000 $900.00 -6.3%

7060015 EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RAISED, TYPE DBid Rank Department Estimate 1,050.000 $3.000 $3,150.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.650 $2,782.50 -11.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2.750 $2,887.50 -8.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $3,150.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $2.900 $3,045.00 -3.3%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 16 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7060015 EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RAISED, TYPE DBid Rank Department Estimate 1,050.000 $3.000 $3,150.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.750 $3,937.50 +25.0%

7060018 EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RAISED, TYPE GBid Rank Department Estimate 35.000 $3.000 $105.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.650 $92.75 -11.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2.750 $96.25 -8.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $105.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $2.900 $101.50 -3.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.750 $131.25 +25.0%

7080001 L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (WHITE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 75,000.000 $0.120 $9,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $7,500.00 -16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.080 $6,000.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.120 $9,000.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.080 $6,000.00 -33.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.110 $8,250.00 -8.3%

7080011 L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (YELLOW)Bid Rank Department Estimate 38,000.000 $0.120 $4,560.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $3,800.00 -16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.080 $3,040.00 -33.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.120 $4,560.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.080 $3,040.00 -33.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.110 $4,180.00 -8.3%

7080121 EACH PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED SYMBOL) (ARROW)Bid Rank Department Estimate 6.000 $60.000 $360.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $50.000 $300.00 -16.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $50.000 $300.00 -16.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $75.000 $450.00 +25.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $75.000 $450.00 +25.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $60.500 $363.00 +0.8%

7310260 EACH POLE FOUNDATION (TYPE G) (STANDARD BASE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 3.000 $3,000.000 $9,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,000.000 $9,000.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2,800.000 $8,400.00 -6.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2,700.000 $8,100.00 -10.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $2,800.000 $8,400.00 -6.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,200.000 $9,600.00 +6.7%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 17 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7320050 L.FT. ELECTRICAL CONDUIT (2") (PVC)Bid Rank Department Estimate 200.000 $15.000 $3,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $20.000 $4,000.00 +33.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $15.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $14.500 $2,900.00 -3.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $15.750 $3,150.00 +5.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $18.000 $3,600.00 +20.0%

7320410 EACH PULL BOX (NO. 5)Bid Rank Department Estimate 3.000 $500.000 $1,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $700.000 $2,100.00 +40.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $625.000 $1,875.00 +25.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $600.000 $1,800.00 +20.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $640.000 $1,920.00 +28.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $735.000 $2,205.00 +47.0%

7320650 L.SUM CONDUCTORSBid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $4,000.000 $4,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2,000.000 $2,000.00 -50.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1,650.000 $1,650.00 -58.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1,600.000 $1,600.00 -60.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $1,665.000 $1,665.00 -58.4%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1,900.000 $1,900.00 -52.5%

7350006 EACH LOOP DETECTOR (COUNTER) (FULL REPLACEMENT)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $4,000.000 $4,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,250.000 $3,250.00 -18.8%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $3,450.000 $3,450.00 -13.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3,500.000 $3,500.00 -12.5%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $3,525.000 $3,525.00 -11.9%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4,050.000 $4,050.00 +1.3%

7350021 EACH LOOP DETECTOR (SPEED/CLASSIFICATION)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $15,000.000 $15,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $22,000.000 $22,000.00 +46.7%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $22,775.000 $22,775.00 +51.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $22,000.000 $22,000.00 +46.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $23,260.000 $23,260.00 +55.1%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $26,700.000 $26,700.00 +78.0%

7370452 L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS ELECTRICAL (DETOUR)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $8,000.000 $8,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +87.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $11,700.000 $11,700.00 +46.3%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 18 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

7370452 L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS ELECTRICAL (DETOUR)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $8,000.000 $8,000.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $11,000.000 $11,000.00 +37.5%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $11,910.000 $11,910.00 +48.9%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $13,700.000 $13,700.00 +71.3%

8050003 ACRE SEEDING (CLASS II)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,000.000 $3,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4,000.000 $4,000.00 +33.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $4,300.000 $4,300.00 +43.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $4,000.000 $4,000.00 +33.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $4,300.000 $4,300.00 +43.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4,950.000 $4,950.00 +65.0%

8101021 L.FT. EROSION CONTROL (WATTLES) (9")Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,745.000 $1.750 $3,053.75

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.000 $3,490.00 +14.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1.000 $1,745.00 -42.9%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.000 $3,490.00 +14.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $3.700 $6,456.50 +111.4%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.350 $5,845.75 +91.4%

8101029 CU.YD. EROSION CONTROL (ROCK MULCH) (GRADATION C)Bid Rank Department Estimate 29.000 $55.000 $1,595.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $140.000 $4,060.00 +154.5%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $100.000 $2,900.00 +81.8%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $100.000 $2,900.00 +81.8%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $150.000 $4,350.00 +172.7%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $130.000 $3,770.00 +136.4%

9010001 L.SUM MOBILIZATIONBid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $480,000.000 $480,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $518,000.000 $518,000.00 +7.9%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $477,000.000 $477,000.00 -0.6%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $504,210.900 $504,210.90 +5.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $499,678.650 $499,678.65 +4.1%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $388,278.250 $388,278.25 -19.1%

9050001 L.FT. GUARD RAIL, W-BEAM, SINGLE FACEBid Rank Department Estimate 3,165.000 $18.000 $56,970.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $17.500 $55,387.50 -2.8%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $18.000 $56,970.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $18.000 $56,970.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $21.000 $66,465.00 +16.7%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 19 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

9050001 L.FT. GUARD RAIL, W-BEAM, SINGLE FACEBid Rank Department Estimate 3,165.000 $18.000 $56,970.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $22.500 $71,212.50 +25.0%

9050002 L.FT. GUARD RAIL, W-BEAM, SINGLE FACE, SHOP CURVEDBid Rank Department Estimate 100.000 $20.000 $2,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $22.000 $2,200.00 +10.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $22.000 $2,200.00 +10.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $22.000 $2,200.00 +10.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $26.000 $2,600.00 +30.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $28.000 $2,800.00 +40.0%

9050026 EACH GUARD RAIL TERMINAL (TANGENT TYPE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $2,500.000 $37,500.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2,600.000 $39,000.00 +4.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $2,700.000 $40,500.00 +8.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2,600.000 $39,000.00 +4.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $3,200.000 $48,000.00 +28.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4,900.000 $73,500.00 +96.0%

9050036 EACH GUARD RAIL, ANCHOR ASSEMBLYBid Rank Department Estimate 2.000 $700.000 $1,400.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $650.000 $1,300.00 -7.1%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $1,050.000 $2,100.00 +50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1,100.000 $2,200.00 +57.1%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $800.000 $1,600.00 +14.3%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $815.000 $1,630.00 +16.4%

9060011 EACH CATTLE GUARD (DRAINAGE)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $15,000.000 $15,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $9,000.000 $9,000.00 -40.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $25,000.000 $25,000.00 +66.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $18,000.000 $18,000.00 +20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12,800.000 $12,800.00 -14.7%

9080001 L.FT. CONCRETE CURB (C-05.10) (TYPE A)Bid Rank Department Estimate 510.000 $20.000 $10,200.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $25.600 $13,056.00 +28.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $28.000 $14,280.00 +40.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $47.000 $23,970.00 +135.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $41.000 $20,910.00 +105.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $26.000 $13,260.00 +30.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 20 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

9080085 L.FT. CONCRETE CURB AND GUTTER (C-05.10)(TYPE D)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,000.000 $25.000 $25,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $30.900 $30,900.00 +23.6%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $31.000 $31,000.00 +24.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $46.000 $46,000.00 +84.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $47.000 $47,000.00 +88.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $44.500 $44,500.00 +78.0%

9080201 SQ.FT. CONCRETE SIDEWALK (C-05.20)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,800.000 $5.000 $14,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4.940 $13,832.00 -1.2%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $6.250 $17,500.00 +25.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $7.000 $19,600.00 +40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $7.500 $21,000.00 +50.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $12.500 $35,000.00 +150.0%

9080246 SQ.FT. CONCRETE (TEMPORARY SCUPPER)(DETAIL G)Bid Rank Department Estimate 20.000 $30.000 $600.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $100.000 $2,000.00 +233.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $16.500 $330.00 -45.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $350.000 $7,000.00 +1066.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $75.000 $1,500.00 +150.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $130.000 $2,600.00 +333.3%

9080295 SQ.FT. CONCRETE SIDEWALK RAMPBid Rank Department Estimate 1,115.000 $15.000 $16,725.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $11.050 $12,320.75 -26.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $9.250 $10,313.75 -38.3%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $9.500 $10,592.50 -36.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $9.000 $10,035.00 -40.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $16.000 $17,840.00 +6.7%

9080301 SQ.FT. CONCRETE DRIVEWAY (C-05.20)Bid Rank Department Estimate 2,440.000 $7.000 $17,080.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $10.800 $26,352.00 +54.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $6.750 $16,470.00 -3.6%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $10.500 $25,620.00 +50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $9.000 $21,960.00 +28.6%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $9.300 $22,692.00 +32.9%

9080515 SQ.FT. SCUPPER (DETAIL G)Bid Rank Department Estimate 255.000 $30.000 $7,650.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $31.000 $7,905.00 +3.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $28.000 $7,140.00 -6.7%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 21 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

9080515 SQ.FT. SCUPPER (DETAIL G)Bid Rank Department Estimate 255.000 $30.000 $7,650.00

3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $130.000 $33,150.00 +333.3%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $27.000 $6,885.00 -10.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $33.500 $8,542.50 +11.7%

9130030 CU.YD. RIPRAP (GABIONS) (DETAIL D01)Bid Rank Department Estimate 150.000 $300.000 $45,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $300.000 $45,000.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $235.000 $35,250.00 -21.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $175.000 $26,250.00 -41.7%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $300.000 $45,000.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $260.000 $39,000.00 -13.3%

9230002 HOUR CONTRACTOR BASED ON-THE-JOB TRAININGBid Rank Department Estimate 1,000.000 $3.000 $3,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $3.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $3.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $3,000.00 +0.0%

9240026 L.SUM FORCE ACCOUNT WORK (BRIDGE DECK REPAIR)Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $15,000.000 $15,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $15,000.000 $15,000.00 +0.0%

9240117 SQ.FT. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (DETECTABLE WARNING STRIP)Bid Rank Department Estimate 100.000 $10.000 $1,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $35.500 $3,550.00 +255.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $32.000 $3,200.00 +220.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $60.000 $6,000.00 +500.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $50.000 $5,000.00 +400.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $76.000 $7,600.00 +660.0%

9240129 SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (PLACE MILLED AC ON TURNOUT)Bid Rank Department Estimate 250.000 $5.000 $1,250.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4.500 $1,125.00 -10.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $6.000 $1,500.00 +20.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $12.000 $3,000.00 +140.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $5.000 $1,250.00 +0.0%

Printed: 9/20/2017 Page 22 of 22

*** Bid Tabs for Proposal Pamphlet 2017023 ***

ItemNumber

Unit ofMeasure Item Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount

Compared ToDept Estimate

9240129 SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (PLACE MILLED AC ON TURNOUT)Bid Rank Department Estimate 250.000 $5.000 $1,250.00

5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $23.500 $5,875.00 +370.0%

9240170 L.SUM CONTRACTOR QUALITY CONTROLBid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $50,000.000 $50,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $56,000.000 $56,000.00 +12.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $40,000.000 $40,000.00 -20.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $70,000.000 $70,000.00 +40.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $60,000.000 $60,000.00 +20.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $47,200.000 $47,200.00 -5.6%

9250001 L.SUM CONSTRUCTION SURVEYING AND LAYOUTBid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $30,000.000 $30,000.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $40,000.000 $40,000.00 +33.3%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $44,000.000 $44,000.00 +46.7%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $45,000.000 $45,000.00 +50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $90,000.000 $90,000.00 +200.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $52,800.000 $52,800.00 +76.0%

9280036 L.FT. GROUND-IN RUMBLE STRIP (8 INCH)Bid Rank Department Estimate 33,700.000 $0.200 $6,740.00

1 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.110 $3,707.00 -45.0%2 SOUTHERN ARIZONA PAVING & CONSTRUCTION, CO. $0.100 $3,370.00 -50.0%3 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $3,370.00 -50.0%4 GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY $0.200 $6,740.00 +0.0%5 K E & G CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.340 $11,458.00 +70.0%