surveying & prospection for archaeology & environmental science spatial sampling & soil...
TRANSCRIPT
Surveying & Prospection for Archaeology & Environmental Science
Spatial sampling & soil properties
Phil Buckland
Contents
• Soil chemistry & physical properties as proxy data sources
• What are (spatial) samples - why are they taken?- how are they taken?- what can they tell us?
• Sample data - examining,- manipulating,- interpreting.
Soil chemistry & properties...
Proxy indicator: a measurable variable that tells us about conditions or changes in the past that we cannot directly measure.
Commonly used in environmental archaeology, quaternary geology, environmental change analysis (& monitoring)
Soil chemistry & properties...
Biological proxies - fossil insects, plant macrofossils, molluscs, tree rings...
Chemical proxies - phosphates, oxygen isotopes, carbon isotopes (14C), other isotopes & ratios
Physical proxies - organic content, magnetic susceptibility, colour (full spectrum), dust, particle size, sedimentation, raised beaches
Soil chemistry & properties...
phosphates (P) - element (phosphorus) - organic and inorganic- measure amount & ratios in sediments (citric acid extraction) using spectrophotometer
organic content = Loss On Ignition (LOI)- ratio of organic:inorganic matter in sediment- measure by burning and calculating weight loss
magnetic susceptibility (MS) - ability of material to sustain an applied magnetic fields.- measure induced magnetic field in sample compared to applied field
Clark, A (1990/2000) ‘Seeing beneath the soil’
Soil chemistry & properties...
phosphates (P) - Phosphate degrees P°
- increased amounts often indicate human activity- linked to decay of organic materials (organisms)- Decay leads to: 1) release of phosphate ions (PO4)
2) ions bind to soil particles
distance
phos
phat
es
Archaeological site?
Background level
e.g. waste, manuring, food storage - past & present (pollution)
Soil chemistry & properties...
organic content = Loss On Ignition (LOI) - %
- increased amounts often indicate human activity- linked to decay of organic materials (organisms)- accumulations of organic matter lead to increase
e.g. waste, manuring, food storage
distance
LOI
Archaeological site? Bog (mire)?
Confirm with macrofossil & insect analyses
Soil chemistry & properties...
- dependent on iron content of soil- heating increases MS due to oxidation of iron- erosion, ploughing etc. can expose different materials
e.g. fire, industry, pollution - past & present
magnetic susceptibility (MS) - SI (no units)
distance
MS
Archaeological site? Road (modern)
Samples
More simply:A sample is that part of reality that we actually measure
’A sample is that part of a population which is actually observed.’
www.wikipedia.org
Sample:
’...a set of potential measurements or values, including not only cases actually observed but those that are potentially observable’
Population:
www.wikipedia.org
Samples
Examples:
Population SampleAll people in Sweden Every 100th person in Sweden
A 10 hectare meadow 100 randomly placed 1m squares in the meadow
Phosphate levels in an area 1km around an archaeological site
Soil samples taken at 20m intervals throughout the area
An infinite number of rolls of two dice 100 rolls of two dice
Fluctuations in heavy metal levels in the water of the Bay of Bothnia
Weekly heavy metal test samples from water 5km East of Holmsund
How well the samples reflect the population requires carefulconsideration - and can result from good project design.
Samples
Examples:
Population SampleAll people in Sweden Every 100th person in Sweden
A 10 hectare meadow 100 randomly placed 1m squares in the meadow
Phosphate levels in an area 1km around an archaeological site
Soil samples taken at 20m intervals throughout the area
An infinite number of rolls of two dice 100 rolls of two dice
Fluctuations in heavy metal levels in the water of the Bay of Bothnia
Weekly heavy metal test samples from water 5km East of Holmsund
How well the samples reflect the population requires carefulconsideration - and can result from good project design.
Samples
Examples:
Population SampleAll people in Sweden Every 100th person in Sweden
A 10 hectare meadow 100 randomly placed 1m squares in the meadow
Phosphate levels in an area 1km around an archaeological site
Soil samples taken at 20m intervals throughout the area
An infinite number of rolls of two dice 100 rolls of two dice
Fluctuations in heavy metal levels in the water of the Bay of Bothnia
Weekly heavy metal test samples from water 5km East of Holmsund
How well the samples reflect the population requires carefulconsideration - and can result from good project design.
Samples
Examples:
Population SampleAll people in Sweden Every 100th person in Sweden
A 10 hectare meadow 100 randomly placed 1m squares in the meadow
Phosphate levels in an area 1km around an archaeological site
Soil samples taken at 20m intervals throughout the area
An infinite number of rolls of two dice 100 rolls of two dice
Fluctuations in heavy metal levels in the water of the Bay of Bothnia
Weekly heavy metal test samples from water 5km East of Holmsund
How well the samples reflect the population requires carefulconsideration - and can result from good project design.
Samples
Examples:
Population SampleAll people in Sweden Every 100th person in Sweden
A 10 hectare meadow 100 randomly placed 1m squares in the meadow
Phosphate levels in an area 1km around an archaeological site
Soil samples taken at 20m intervals throughout the area
An infinite number of rolls of two dice 100 rolls of two dice
Fluctuations in heavy metal levels in the water of the Bay of Bothnia
Weekly heavy metal test samples from water 5km East of Holmsund
How well the samples reflect the population requires carefulconsideration - and can result from good project design.
Samples & variation
The things we measure vary in different ways...
Continuous variables:- Vary continuously- Often MEASURABLE
Discrete variables:- Stepwise, or non-continuous variation- Often COUNTABLE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
0 14
Samples & variation
Discrete sampling of continuous variables.
The things we measure vary in different ways...
low resolution high resolution
Samples & variation & interpolation
The things we measure vary in different ways...
low resolution high resolution
Interpolation allows us to simulate/approximate the original variation
...by assuming things about the real distribution.
Sampling Strategies
Must consider:
• Project aims and how they can be achieved
• Variables to be measured and how they behave in reality
• Scientific theory (& statistical ground rules)
• Avoid bias
• Encompass areas outside of the immediate area of investigation (background/reference samples)
Sampling StrategiesMethod e.g. pro’s con’s
Gridxx x x x x
xx x x x x
xx x x x x
xx x x x x
xx x x x x
Random xx x x xx
x
xx x
xx
x
x xx
xx
x
xx
xx x
x
x
x
xxx
Strategicxx x
xxx
xx x x
x
xxx x xxx
xx
xx
x xxx
xx
xx
Strategic grids
x
x x xx x
xx xx
xx
x
xx
xx x
x
xxx x
x
x
x x
x
x x
• statistically robust(no intentional bias)• stratified sampling is scalable
• can (randomly) miss areas of interest• difficult to implement*
• practical in field• uniform coverage• good statistics
• may miss higherresolution detail
• biased (stat’s unsound)• tends to prove nothing
• can support otherproxies from samples• easy for archaeologists
• can target interest• good compromise between detail and statistical robustness• easy to cover back-ground & features
• can be interpolation problems (worst case =undetected)• some bias possible
*without total station or good GPS
Sampling strategies
Good sampling strategy can allow:
• a good level of realism in models (reconstructions/interpretations)
• measure and control of errors
• valid use of summary and advanced statistics
• results that stand up to rigorous interrogation
• useful models for interpretation
Interpolation
Translating sample point data into continuous surfaces
‘interpolation is a method of constructing new data points from a discrete set of known data points’
www.wikipedia.org
Interpolation
A surface is a 3 dimensional representation of the values of any variable in two dimensional space (at an instance in time).
e.g.
• ground temperatures at a specific time
• phosphate levels in soil
• the ground surface = topography
• the sea surface
… although the two dimensional space does not have to be geographical… e.g. climate space
InterpolationA surface is a 3 dimensional representation of the values of any variable in two dimensional space (at an instance in time). … although the two dimensional space does not have to be geographical…
Climate space mapshowing % of beetle species (in a sample) that tolerate different temperatures.
Sum
mer
tem
pera
ture
Temperature range
Interpolation methods
Numerous methods exist.Deterministic methods: ‘assign values to locations based on
the surrounding measured values and on specified mathematical formulas that determine the smoothness of the resulting surface’ ESRI. E.g.
• Spline• Inverse distance weighted
Geostatistical methods: ‘are based on statistical models that include autocorrelation (the statistical relationship among the measured points)’ ESRI. E.g.
• Kriging
Most methods can be tuned to application
Interpolation methods - example
Prospection area in Skåne - ca. 600x200m
1 6 2 50 1 6 3 00 1 6 3 50 1 6 4 00 1 6 4 50 1 6 5 00
1 6 0 00
1 6 0 50
1 6 1 00
1 6 1 50
Easting
Nor
thin
g
Sample grid - semi-regular (sub-regular)
Interpolation methods - example
1 62 50 1 63 00 1 63 50 1 64 00 1 64 50 1 65 00
1 60 00
1 60 50
1 61 00
1 61 50
Topography - Interpolation by Ordinary Kriging
Interpolation methods - example
Topography - Interpolation by Inverse distance weighting
1 6 2 50 1 6 3 00 1 6 3 50 1 6 4 00 1 6 4 50 1 6 5 00
1 6 0 00
1 6 0 50
1 6 1 00
1 6 1 50
Interpolation methods - example
Inverse distance weighting
1 6 2 50 1 6 3 00 1 6 3 50 1 6 4 00 1 6 4 50 1 6 5 00
1 6 0 00
1 6 0 50
1 6 1 00
1 6 1 50
1 62 50 1 63 00 1 63 50 1 64 00 1 64 50 1 65 00
1 60 00
1 60 50
1 61 00
1 61 50
Kriging
Appears smoother Appears blotchy, unrealistic?
Ridge vs. mound
Interpolation methods - example
Inverse distance weighting
1 6 2 50 1 6 3 00 1 6 3 50 1 6 4 00 1 6 4 50 1 6 5 00
1 6 0 00
1 6 0 50
1 6 1 00
1 6 1 50
1 62 50 1 63 00 1 63 50 1 64 00 1 64 50 1 65 00
1 60 00
1 60 50
1 61 00
1 61 50
Kriging
Kriging - uses relationship between data values of each point to every other point to construct values for missing points.
Inverse distance weighting - missing values are a simple mathematical function of the value of the nearest point.
More info: ArcGIS help files;Internet; Recommended literature
Kriging identifies a gradient W-E and applies it to the missing values
IDW missing values fall off with distance from known points
Interpolation methods - example
Inverse distance weighting
1 6 2 50 1 6 3 00 1 6 3 50 1 6 4 00 1 6 4 50 1 6 5 00
1 6 0 00
1 6 0 50
1 6 1 00
1 6 1 50
1 62 50 1 63 00 1 63 50 1 64 00 1 64 50 1 65 00
1 60 00
1 60 50
1 61 00
1 61 50
Kriging
• omit (mask) unsampled area• probably use Kriging (but may have to adjust parameters)
Implications?
Interpolation methods - example
Phospates (total phosphates - Ptot)
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
120
125
130
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
Major anomaliesMinor anomalies
Human occupation sites?
Interpolation methods - example
Loss On Ignition (% - weight loss after burning)
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
LO
WH
IGH
High organic content:peat bog (mire)?
Low organic content:erosion?mineral soil?
Interpolation methods - example
Compare proxies... identify similarities in patterns...
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
LO
WH
IGH
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
120
125
130
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
Some similarities in lows & highs:• variables support each other?• or autocorrelation - variables influence each other?
Interpolation methods - example
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
3 5
4 0
4 5
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
Magnetic Susceptibility (MS)
Prehistoric fireplaces?Low values due to bog?(waterlogged - reduced iron)
Interpolation methods - example
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
LO
WH
IGH
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
120
125
130
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
3 5
4 0
4 5
16250 16300 16350 16400 16450 16500
16000
16050
16100
16150
1 62 50 1 63 00 1 63 50 1 64 00 1 64 50 1 65 00
1 60 00
1 60 50
1 61 00
1 61 50
Probable area of past human occupation
Considerations when interpreting
Farm
Bog
Erosion
Deposition
Colluviation - translocation of sediments by gravity
Sediments move with time - so signals may be displaced
Considerations when interpreting
Farm
Bog
Erosion
Deposition
Must be considered wheninterpreting proxy indicators
Sediments move with time - so signals may be displaced
Phosphates
Occupation phase
Present day
Considerations when interpreting
Other considerations:• Ploughing, digging & erosion may expose or mix subsoils
with different properties• Water & wind erosions & associated deposition may cover or
destroy evidence - leaving an incomplete record
Water deposited sediments -> Alluvial depositsWind deposited sediments -> Aeolian depositsGravitationally deposited sediments -> Colluvial deposits
• Proxies may interact - i.e. values may be related by physical & chemical processes - ‘autocorrelation’ in statistics
• Rates of decay, weathering & transportation will vary depending on climate and sediments/bedrocks
• Geostatistics may give false positives if not used properly!
Integration of maps
Integration of maps
Integration of maps
Rockart