supreme court of north carolina petitionsjeremy johnson temporary stay 1. def’s motion for 1....

of 21

SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA

PETITIONS

25 September 2020

16P20 State of North Carolina,

ex rel. Roy Cooper,

Attorney General v.

Kinston Charter

Academy, a North

Carolina Non-Profit

Corporation; Ozie L.

Hall, Jr., Individually

and as Chief Executive

Officer of Kinston

Charter Academy; and

Demyra McDonald Hall,

Individually and as

Board Chair of Kinston

Charter Academy

1. Plts’ PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

2. Def’s (Ozie L. Hall, Jr.)

Pro Se Conditional PDR

Under N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Allowed

3. Def’s (Kinston Charter

Academy) Conditional

PDR Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

3. Allowed

Davis, J.,

recused

27A20 In the Matter of:

K.D.C. and A.N.C.

Guardian ad Litem’s

Motion to Deem Brief

Timely Filed

Allowed

69A06-4 State v. Terraine

Sanchez Byers

1. State’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

1. Allowed

01/15/2019

2. State’s Petition for Writ

of Supersedeas

2. Allowed

01/16/2019

3. State’s Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a Dissent

3. ---

4. State’s Motion to

Amend Record on Appeal

4. Dismissed

as moot

Ervin, J.,

recused

of 21

79P20 State v. Quavis Jerome

Clyde

1. Def’s Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a

Constitutional Question

1. ---

2. Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Denied


Dismiss Appeal

3. Allowed

86A02-2 State v. Bryan

Christopher Bell

1. Def’s Motion to Hold in

Abeyance the Time in

which to File Petition for

Writ of Certiorari

1. Special

Order

01/24/2013

2. Def’s Petition for Writ

of Certiorari to Review

Order of Superior Court,

Onslow County

2.

3. State’s Motion to Hold

Defendant’s Petition for

Writ of Certiorari

Prematurely Filed in

Violation of this Court’s

Order Dated 25 January

2013

3. Special

Order

04/29/2020

4. Def’s Motion for Leave

to File Reply in Support of

Petition for Writ of

Certiorari

4. Denied

08/13/2020

109P17-7 In re:

Olander R. Bynum

Petitioner’s Pro Se Motion

to Dismiss Appeal and

Remand for 400 Dollar

Damage Payment

Dismissed

of 21

128A20 James Rickenbaugh and

Mary Rickenbaugh,

Husband and Wife,

individually and on

behalf of all others

similarly situated v.

Power Home Solar, LLC,

a Delaware Limited

Liability Company

1. Def’s Motion to Admit

Esperanza Segarra Pro

Hac Vice

1. Allowed

09/04/2020

2. Def’s Motion to Admit

David A. Sullivan Pro Hac

Vice

2. Allowed

09/04/2020

140P20 State v. David Jedediah

Nyeplu

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

142P20 State v. Brock Allen

Clark

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

156P20 State v. David Warren

Taylor


Temporary Stay

1. Allowed

04/07/2020


of Supersedeas

2. Allowed

3. State’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Allowed

158P20 State v. Michael Addib

Nazzal


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Denied


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Denied

161P20 State v. Johnny Warren

Speight

1. Def’s Pro Se Motion for

PDR Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Special

Order

2. Def’s Pro Se Motion to

Proceed In Forma

Pauperis

2. Special

Order


Appoint Counsel

3. Special

Order

of 21

165P20 State v. Myleick Shawn

Patterson


PDR

1. Denied


Appropriate Relief

2. Dismissed

without

prejudice


Appoint Counsel

3. Dismissed

as moot

169P20-2 State v. Fernando

Hernandez

Def’s Pro Se Motion to

Dismiss Charges

Dismissed

180A17-2 Kim and Barry Lippard

v. Larry Holleman and

Alan Hix

1. Plts’ Notice of Appeal


1. ---

2. Plts’ Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a


2. ---

3. Plts’ PDR as to

Additional Issues

3. Denied

4. Defs’ Motion to Dismiss

Notice of Appeal Based

Upon a Dissent

4. Allowed


Notice of Appeal Based

Upon a Constitutional

Question

5. Allowed

6. Defs’ Motion to Admit

Seth James Kraus Pro

Hac Vice

6. Allowed

182A20 Ernest Nichols v.

Administrative Office of

the Courts, 7th Judicial

District, Edgecombe

County

Plt’s Pro Se Notice of

Appeal Based Upon a


Dismissed ex

mero motu

of 21

186P17-4 State v. Lenwood Lee

Paige

1. Def’s Pro Se Petition for

Writ of Certiorari to

Review Decision of the

COA

1. Dismissed


Proceed In Forma

Pauperis

2. Allowed

Hudson, J.,

recused

197P20 State v. Jeremy Johnson

1. Def’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

1. Allowed

05/11/2020


of Supersedeas

2. Special

Order


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Special

Order

4. Def’s Motion to Amend

PDR

4. Dismissed

as moot

224A20 In re:

D.A.A.R. and S.A.L.R.

Guardian ad Litem’s

Motion to Strike Section

II and Section III of

Respondent-Mother’s

Reply Brief

Denied

09/22/2020

226P20 Molly Schwarz v. St.

Jude Medical, Inc., St.

Jude Medical S.C., Inc.,

Duke University, Duke

University Health

Systems, Inc., Eric

Delissio, Thomas Weber,

M.D., and Ted Cole

1. Plt’s Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a


1. ---

2. Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Denied

3. Defs’ (St. Jude Medical,

Inc., et al) Motion to

Dismiss Appeal

3. Allowed

4. Plt’s Motion to Amend

Notice of Appeal and PDR

4. Dismissed

as moot

of 21

229P20 State v. Dwight Scott

McClure


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Denied

2. State’s Motion to Deem

Response to PDR Timely

Filed

2. Allowed


A.B.C.

Respondent-Mother’s

Petition for Rehearing

Denied

09/21/2020

239P20 State v. Dwight Edward

White

1. Def’s Pro Se Petition for

Writ of Certiorari to

Review Order of Superior

Court, Cabarrus County

1. Dismissed


Proceed In Forma

Pauperis

2. Allowed


Appoint Counsel

3. Dismissed

as moot

256P20 State v. Perry L. Pitts


Based Upon a


1. ---


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Denied


Dismiss Appeal

3. Allowed

263PA18-2 State v. Cedric Theodis

Hobbs, Jr.

Def’s Motion for

Supplemental Briefing

Allowed

08/26/2020

of 21

272P20 State v. Raul Zamudio

Perez



Order of the COA

1. Denied




Cabarrus County

2. Denied

273P20 Ronald Hoag and Holly

Hoag; Jeremy Gonzalez

and Kristen Gonzalez;

William Harrell and

Kathryn Harrell; Eric

Finical and Sally Finical;

James Lawless and Lisa

Lawless; Sandra Hardee;

Diane Semer; Joe

McDowell and Lynell

McDowell; Scott

Pritchard and Donna

Pritchard; Vincent

Fischer and Patricia

Fischer; Michael

Bowman and Josie

Bowman; John Lowe and

Nelda Lowe; Beech Cove

Subdivision

Homeowner’s

Association, Inc.; Holly

Ridge Homeowner’s

Association; and Moss

Bend Homeowner’s

Association, Inc. v.

County of Pitt; Bill Clark

Homes of Greenville,

LLC; and Umberto G.

Fontana

1. Plts’ (Ronald Hoag,

Holly Hoag, William

Harrell, Kathryn Harrell,

Eric Finical, Sally Finical,

James Lawless, Lisa

Lawless and Diane

Semer) PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Denied

2. Plts’ (Ronald Hoag,

Holly Hoag, William

Harrell, Kathryn Harrell,

Eric Finical, Sally Finical,

James Lawless, Lisa

Lawless and Diane

Semer) Motion to Accept

PDR’s Filing as Timely

2. Dismissed

as moot

Davis, J.,

recused

274P15-8 State v. Robert K.

Stewart

Def’s Pro Se Motion for

Motion of Recusal Be

Heard En Banc

Dismissed

of 21

292A20 State v. Donald Eugene

Hilton



1. ---

2. Def’s PDR as to

Additional Issues

2. Allowed


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Allowed

307P20 Marisa Mucha v. Logan

Wagner


Based Upon a


1. Retained


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Allowed

310P20 State v. Eric Leonard

Spinks

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

312P20 State v. John Lewis

Jackson, Jr.

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

315P20 State v. Vinson Pernell

Lindsey


Declaration in Support of

Racial Injustice by

Guilford Court and

Counsel

Dismissed

318P20 State v. Eric Pittman

Def’s Pro Se Petition for

Writ of Habeas Corpus

Denied

08/21/2020


B.S.

Respondent-Father’s

Motion to Deem

Appellant’s Brief Timely

Filed

Allowed

08/25/2020

of 21

326P20 Robert E. Monroe, as

Administrator of the

Estate of Naka Hamilton

v. Rex Hospital, Inc.

d/b/a Rex Hospital, Rex

Healthcare, UNC Rex

Hospital, UNC Rex

Healthcare, UNC Rex

Hematology Oncology

Associates, and Henry

Cromartie, III, M.D.

Def’s (Henry Cromartie,

III, M.D.) Motion for

Madeleine M. Pfefferle to

Withdraw as Counsel

Allowed

08/21/2020

333P20 Caymus Construction

Company, Inc., and

Kevin Thomas Quick v.

John J. Janowiak and

Kathleen L. Janowiak

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

337A20 Loretta Nobel v.

Foxmoor Group, LLC,

Mark Griffis, David

Robertson



1. ---

2. Def’s (David Robertson)

PDR Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

2. Denied

3. Plt’s Motion to Stay

Briefing Schedule and Set

Briefing Deadlines

3. Allowed

08/20/2020


M.V.

1. Respondent-Father’s

Motion to Amend

Certificate of Service to

Record on Appeal

1. Dismissed

as moot

08/24/2020


Motion to Withdraw

Appeal

2. Allowed

08/24/2020


Motion to Waive Costs

3. Allowed

08/24/2020

of 21

341P20 State v. Tymik Daijon

Lasenburg



Order of the COA



Decision of District Court,

Wake County


of Habeas Corpus


of Mandamus (or

Prohibition)

5. Def’s Motion to Submit

Treatises


Temporary Stay


of Supersedeas

8. Def’s Motion to

Suspend Appellate Rules

9. Def’s Motion for Leave

of Court to Submit

Transcript and Recording


Certificates of Service


Submit Compact Disc


Substitute Motion to

Suspend the Rules


of Habeas Corpus

1.

2.

3. Denied

07/28/2020

4.

5.

6. Denied

08/18/2020

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

13. Denied

09/15/2020

of 21


Remove Filing From

Electronic Document

Library


Submit Certified

Transcript

14.

15.


J.D.


Leave to View Exhibits

Filed Under Seal

1. Allowed

08/17/2020

2. Def’s Motion to Seal

Oral Argument Recording

2. Allowed

08/17/2020

345P20 State v. David Brandon

Lee


Based Upon a


1. ---


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. Denied


Dismiss Appeal

3. Allowed

346P19 State v. Lamont

Edgerton

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied


K.M.W. and K.L.W.

1. Respondent-Mother’s

Motion Requesting Oral

Argument

1. Allowed

09/11/2020

2. Petitioner’s Motion to

Continue Oral Argument

2. Denied

09/11/2020

3. Petitioner’s Motion in

the Alternative to Decide

the Case Without Oral

Argument

3. Denied

09/11/2020

of 21

357P20 In the Matter of:

Calvin Taylor

Plt’s Pro Se Motion for

Prompt Execution of

Requested Order

Dismissed

360A09 State v. Hasson Jamaal

Bacote

Def’s Motion to Allow

Counsel to Withdraw

Allowed

08/31/2020

361P20 Rachel E. Williams v.

Enterprise Holdings,

Inc., EAN Services, LLC,

EAN Holdings, LLC,

Enterprise Leasing

Company Southeast,

LLC

1. Plt’s Pro Se Notice of

Appeal Based Upon a


1.

2. Plt’s Pro Se PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2.


Appeal

3.

4. Plt’s Pro Se Motion for

Extension of Time to File

Response

4. Allowed

08/28/2020


Extension of Time to

Respond to Motion to

Dismiss

5. Allowed for

14 days up to

and including

7 October

2020

09/22/2020


Court Acceptance of

Documents Under Seal

6. Allowed

09/22/2020

Ervin, J.,

recused

of 21

362P20 Curtis Lambert v. Town

of Sylva


Based Upon a



N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Plt’s Motion for Leave

to File Amended Notice of

Appeal (Constitutional

Question) and PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

4. Plt’s Amended Notice of

Appeal Based Upon a


5. Plt’s Amended PDR

Under N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

6. Def’s Motion to Dismiss

Appeal

1.

2.

3. Allowed

08/14/2020

4.

5.

6.

365P20 State v. Richard Lee

Deyton


PDR Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Dismissed

08/17/2020


Remand for Evidentiary

Hearing and

Resentencing

2. Dismissed

08/17/2020


Appoint Counsel

3. Dismissed

08/17/2020


Immediate Release

4. Dismissed

08/17/2020

of 21

368A20 Reynolds American Inc.

v. Third Motion Equities

Master Fund LTD,

Magnetar Capital

Master Fund, LTD,

Spectrum Opportunities

Master Fund LTD,

Magnetar Fundamental

Strategies Master Funds

LTD, Magnetar MSW

Master Fund LTD,

Mason Capital Master

Fund, L.P.,

BlueMountain Credit

Alternatives Master

Fund L.P.,

BlueMountain Foinaven

Master Fund L.P.,

BlueMountain

Guadalupe Peak Fund

L.P., BlueMountain

Summit Trading L.P.,

BlueMountain

Montenvers Master

Fund SCA SICAV-SIF,

and Barry W. Blank

Trust and Anton S.

Kawalsky, trustee for the

benefit of Anton S.

Kawalsky Trust UA

9/17/2015, Canyon Blue

Credit Investment Fund

L.P., the Canyon Value

Realization Master

Fund, L.P., Canyon

Value Realization Fund,

L.P., Amundi Absolute

Return Canyon Fund

P.L.C., CanyonSL Value

Fund, L.P., Permal

Canyon IO LTD, Canyon

Value Realization Mac

18 LTD

1. Defs’ (Mason and

BlueMountain) Motion to

Admit Lawrence M.

Rolnick Pro Hac Vice

1. Allowed

09/18/2020



Admit Jennifer A.

Randolph Pro Hac Vice

2. Allowed

09/18/2020



Admit Sheila A. Sadighi

Pro Hac Vice

3. Allowed

09/18/2020

of 21

374P19 North Carolina Farm

Bureau Mutual

Insurance Company, Inc.

v. William Thomas

Dana, Jr., Individually

and as Administrator of

the Estate of Pamela

Marguerite Dana


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

2. North Carolina

Association of Defense

Attorneys’ Conditional

Motion for Leave to File

Amicus Brief

1. Allowed

2. Allowed

Davis, J.,

recused

377P20 State v. Andrew Ellis

Def’s Pro Se Petition for

Writ of Habeas Corpus

Denied

09/04/2020

381P20 State v. Archie Lynn

McNeill


Temporary Stay

1. Allowed

09/03/2020


of Supersedeas

2.

385P20 State v. Mitchell Andrew

Tucker


Temporary Stay

1. Allowed

09/04/2020


of Supersedeas

2.

386P20 North Carolina State

Conference of the

NAACP, et al. v. North

Carolina State Board of

Elections, et al.

1. Plts’ PDR Prior to a

Determination by the

COA

1. Denied

09/11/2020

2. Plts’ Motion to Suspend

the Rules to Allow

Expedited Review

2. Dismissed

09/11/2020

387P13-2 State v. James Gregory

Armistead


PDR

Dismissed

Ervin, J.,

recused

387P18-2 State v. Jashawn A.

Summers


Order to Dismiss/

Averment of Judgment

1. Dismissed

08/28/2020


Dismiss All Charges

2. Dismissed

08/28/2020

of 21

393P20 In the Matter of:

L.N.H.

1. Guardian ad Litem’s

Motion to Withdraw and

Substitute Counsel

1. Allowed

09/17/2020

2. Respondent-Mother’s

Motion for Extension of

Time to File Response

2. Denied

09/21/2020

397P20 State v. Billy Russell

Land


Temporary Stay


of Supersedeas

1. Allowed

09/16/2020

416P15-3 State v. Nijel Ramsey

Lee


PDR Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

Denied

08/20/2020

424P19 State v. Randy Allen

McDonald

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

Denied

of 21

436PA13-4 Lake, et al v. State

Health Plan for

Teachers, et al.

1. Amicus Curiae’s (AARP

and AARP Foundation)

Motion to Admit Ali Naini

Pro Hac Vice

1. Dismissed

without

prejudice

09/09/2020



Motion to Reconsider

Motion for Limited

Admission Pro Hac Vice

for Attorney Ali Naini

2. Allowed

09/22/2020



Motion to Amend Original

Motion for Limited





Motion for Limited



5. AARP and AARP

Foundation’s Motion for

Leave to File Amicus

Brief

3. Allowed

09/22/2020

4. Allowed

09/22/2020

5. Allowed

Ervin, J.,

recused

Newby, J.,

recused

of 21

441A98-4 State v. Tilmon Charles

Golphin




Cumberland County

1. Allowed

03/01/2018

2. Def’s Motion to Address

Double Jeopardy as a

Threshold Issue Prior to

Consideration of the

Other Issues Raised in

the Petition for Writ of

Certiorari

2. Dismissed

as moot

3. Motion by North

Carolina Advocates for

Justice for Leave to File

Amicus Curiae Brief

3. Allowed

03/01/2018



Certiorari

4. Allowed

nunc pro tunc

to 1 March

2018

5. Motion of North

Carolina Association of

Black Lawyers to File

Brief as Amicus Curiae

5. Allowed

07/13/2018

6. Motion of North

Carolina State Conference

of the NAACP for Leave

to File Brief as Amicus

Curiae

6. Allowed

07/13/2018

7. Motion for Leave to File

Brief of Amici Curiae

Social Scientists in

Support of Petitioner

7. Allowed

07/13/2018

8. Motion of National

Association for Public

Defense for Leave to File

Brief as Amicus Curiae

8. Allowed

07/13/2018

of 21

9. Motion of Professors

John Charles Boger &

Robert P. Mosteller for

Leave to File Brief as

Amici Curiae

9. Allowed

07/17/2018

10. Amicus Curiae Motion

for Admission of Attorney

Jin Hee Lee, Pro Hac Vice

10. Allowed

07/18/2018

11. Amicus Curiae Motion

for Admission of Attorney

W. Kerrel Murray, Pro

Hac Vice

11. Allowed

07/18/2018

12. Motion of NAACP

Legal Defense and

Educational Fund, Inc. to

Not Require the Payment

of Additional Pro Hac

Vice Fees

12. Denied

07/18/2018

13. Motion of North

Carolina Council of

Churches for Leave to

File Amicus Curiae Brief

13. Allowed

07/17/2018

14. Motion by North

Carolina Advocates for

Justice for Leave to File

Amicus Curiae Brief

14. Allowed

07/17/2018

15. Motion of Former

State and Federal

Prosecutors for Leave to

File Amicus Brief in

Support of Defendant

Appellant

15. Allowed

07/17/2018

of 21

16. Motion of the NAACP

Legal Defense and

Educational Defense

Fund, Inc., for Permission

to File an Amicus Curiae

Brief

16. Allowed

07/17/2018

17. Proposed Amici

Curiae Motion for

Admission of Attorney

Paul F. Khoury, Pro Hac

Vice

17. Allowed

07/20/2018

18. Proposed Amici

Curiae Motion for


Robert L. Walker, Pro

Hac Vice

18. Allowed

07/20/2018

19. Proposed Amici

Curiae Motion for


Madeline J. Cohen, Pro

Hac Vice

19. Allowed

07/20/2018

20. Motion of Amici

Curiae Former State and

Federal Prosecutors Not

to Require the Payment of

Additional Pro Hac Vice

Fees

20. Denied

07/20/2018

21. Motion for

Withdrawal and

Substitution of Counsel

for Amici Curiae Former

State and Federal

Prosecutors

21. Allowed

03/14/2019

Beasley,

C.J.,

recused

of 21

449P11-25 Charles Everette Hinton

v. State of North

Carolina, et al.

1. Petitioner’s Pro Se

Motion for Objections to

Orders; Demand for Trial

and Trial by Jury

1. Dismissed



Mandamus

2. Dismissed


Motion to Proceed In

Forma Pauperis

3. Allowed


Motion to Appoint

Counsel

4. Dismissed

as moot

Ervin, J.,

recused

463A19 Sea Watch at Kure

Beach Homeowners’

Association, Inc. v.

Thomas Fiorentino and

Wife, Leah Fiorentino

1. Defs’ Notice of Appeal


1. ---

2. Defs’ PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31 as to

Additional Issues

2. Denied

3. Plt’s Motion to Dismiss

Appeal

3. Allowed

4. Defs’ Motion for

Extension of Time to File

Response

4. Allowed up

to and

including 9

January 2020

01/02/2020