study guide - security council
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
1/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
2/35
2 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
ContentPage
BackgroundontheSecurityCouncil 4
FunctionandFunctioningoftheCouncil 5
Korea 6
SuccessoftheCommittee 16
NorthKoreasNuclear,SpaceandMissileProgram 17
TheNorthKoreanRocketLaunch 21
SanctionsandEscalationoftheCrisis 22
Countrybycountrystances 25
Bibliography 32
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
3/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 3
DearDelegates,
AsthechairpersonoftheSecurityCouncil,itismypleasuretowelcomeyoutooneofthemost
challengingcommitteessimulatedattheHeritageModelUnitedNationsConference.Asstated
before-themainresponsibilityoftheSecurityCouncilistomaintaininternationalpeaceand
security.UndertheCharterallmemberstatesareobligatedtocomplywithcouncildecisions.
Now,thispurposehasbeenputtotestbythelaunchofNorthKoreanBallisticmissile,forthe
secondtimeonthe12thofDecember,in2012.NorthKoreahadclaimedthatthemainpurpose
ofthislaunchwasforscientificandgeologicalobjectives.WhereasUSA,SouthKoreaand
JapanbelievethatitsacoverfortestingMissileTechnology.
Now,althoughtheotherrespectivecountriesbelievethattherocketlaunchwasformilitary
purposesandtotestmissiletechnology-theyhaveslightlydifferentviewsonhowthesituation
hastobehandled.Therehavebeenpeacetalksbetweenthepowersofthepacificatthe
pentagon,andUSAhasaskedChinatoinfluenceNorthKoreasosuchfurtheractionsdont
impedethepeaceamongstnations.ChinabelievesthatNorthKoreahaseveryrighttodevelop
andexpandtheirspaceprogrammewhereastheyalsoexpressedacertainregretaswell.
IndiahasnodirectdisputewithNorthKorea.IndiasinterestinNorthKoreasnuclearandmissileprogrammescomefromthereportedclandestineco-operationbetweenNorthKorea,
PakistanandIraninthisregard.However,Indiaisapartinternationalcommunityandmust
supportinternationalactionsandcondemnandrestrictcountriesthatactinanunacceptable
mannertotherestoftheworld.JapanisanothercountrythatcondemnsNorthKoreasMissile
Programme,asitisalsoaverycloseallyoftheUS,andJapanandNorthKoreadonot
recognizeeachother,anddonotshareandiplomaticrelationshipswhatsoever.Soeach
countryhastheirrespectiveviewpointandforeignpoliciestolookafter.Thismeansthatthe
eventswhicharementionedintheStudyGuideandtheeventswhichwilltakeplacein
committee,afterthisdatearehypothetical.Thedeadlinefortherealeventsforthe
committeeisthe20thofDecember,2012.Thus,yourresearchshouldonlybelimitedto
realeventsuntiltheaforementioneddate,andeventsthereaftercanonlybestudied
fromthisGuide,andtackledbytheuseofquickthinking.
Astheconferenceapproaches,Ihopethatasdelegates-youhavestartedpreparingforthe
committee,whichwillbeanintensivebalanceforresearchandcreativityofsolutions.
Committeewillbediscussingthisissueingreatdetail,soeveryoneisexpectedtobeverywell
prepared.Hencetheexecutiveboardhasbeenresearchingextensivelytoputtogetherthis
studyguide.However,assaidbefore,pleasedonotlimityourresearchtothestudyguide.
Widenyourmindtoallofthepossibilitiesandinformationatyourdisposal.Alsodelegates
pleasenote,thatthinkingononesfeetandthecapabilitytocomposedistinctive,and
noteworthysolutionstothesituationathandwillstandyouingoodstead.Ifyouhaveany
furtherqueriesorquestions-donothesitatetocontactme,ortherestofyourexecutiveboard.
Goodluckwithyourresearch!Wehopetoseeyouallsoon.
Untilthen,
UpasanaRoy
Chairperson-SecurityCouncil
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
4/35
4 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
TheSecurityCouncil
TheSecurityCouncilhasprimaryresponsibilitiesunderthecharterforthemaintenanceofinternationalpeaceandsecurity.Itisorganizedas
tobeabletofunctioncontinuouslyandarepresentativeofeachofitsmembersmustbepresentatalltimesatUnitedNationsheadquarters.
On31stJanuary1992thefirstevertheministersoftheforeignaffairsoftheremainingtwoconvenedsummitmeetingattheheadquartersattendedbyheadsofstatesandgovernmentof13ofits15membersand.Whenacomplaintconcerningathreattopeaceisbroughtbeforeit,thecouncilsfirstactionisusuallytoadvocatetothepartiestotrytoreachanagreementbyamicablemeans.Insomecases,SecurityCouncilundertakesinvestigationandmediation.Itmaysetforthprinciplesfora
peacefulsettlement.Whenadisputeleadstofighting,thecouncilsfirstconcernistobringittoanendassoonaspossible.
Assaidinarticle33oftheUnitedNationscharter,
Thepartiestoanydispute,thecontinuanceofwhichislikelytoendangerthemaintenanceofinternationalpeaceandsecurity,shall,first
ofall,seekasolutionbynegotiationenquiry,mediation,conciliation,
arbitration,judicialsettlement,resortregionalagenciesorarrangements
orotherpeacefulmeansoftheirownchoice.
TheSecurityCouncilshall,whenitdeemsnecessary,calluponthe
partiestosettletheirdisputebysuchmeans.
Thecouncilcomprises15members,5ofwhomarepermanentmembersandtheremaining10arenon-permanentmembers,10ofthenon-permanentmemberselectedbythegeneralassemblyfortwo-yeartermsandnotillegibleforimmediatere-election.5permanentmembers,ortheP5nations,aretheUnitedStatesofAmerica,UnitedKingdom,France,TheRussianFederation,andthePeoplesRepublicof
China.Eachcouncilmemberhasonevote.Decisionsonproceduralmattersaremadebyanaffirmativevoteofatleast9ofthe15members.Thepermanentmembersenjoyanegativevote,orveto.Theymayabstainfromvotingalso.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
5/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 5
FunctionsandPoweroftheSecurityCouncil
ThefunctionsandthepoweroftheSecurityCouncilhavebeenmentionedinArticles24,25and26oftheCharteroftheUnitedNations.
Article24Responsibilityforthemaintenanceofinternationalpeaceandsecurity
(1) InordertoensurepromptandeffectiveactionbytheUnitedNations,itsMembersconferontheSecurityCouncilprimaryresponsibilitiesforthemaintenanceofinternationalpeaceandsecurity,andagreethatincarryingoutitsdutiesunderthisresponsibilitytheSecurityCouncilactsontheirbehalf.
(2) IndischargingthesedutiestheSecurityCouncilshallactinaccordancewiththePurposesandPrinciplesoftheUnitedNations.ThespecificpowersgrantedtotheSecurityCouncilforthedischargeofthesedutiesarelaiddowninChaptersVI,VII,VIII,andXII.
(3) TheSecurityCouncilshallsubmitannualand,whennecessary,specialreportstotheGeneralAssemblyforitsconsideration.
Article25AgreementtoacceptandcarryoutthedecisionsoftheSecurityCouncil
TheMembersoftheUnitedNationsagreetoacceptandcarryoutthedecisionsoftheSecurityCouncilinaccordancewiththepresentcharter.
Article26Regulationofarmaments
Inordertopromotetheestablishmentandmaintenanceofinternationalpeaceandsecuritywiththeleastdiversionofarmamentsoftheworldshumanandeconomicresources,theSecurityCouncilshallberesponsibleforformulating,withtheassistanceoftheMilitaryStaffCommitteereferredtoinArticle47,planstobesubmittedtothe
MembersoftheUnitedNationsfortheestablishmentofasystemfortheregulationofarmaments.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
6/35
6 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
Korea
DivisionofKorea
In1945,theSecondWorldWarendedwithanalliedvictory.AmongthedefeatedwasJapan,asmostwouldrememberfromthebombingsofHiroshimaandNagasaki,whichbroughtapromptendtothewar.Beforethewar,KoreaasawholewasunderthecolonialruleofJapanforabout35years.So,thealliesdecidedtotemporarilyoccupyKoreaasatrusteeship.TheSovietUnionquicklyinfiltratedandoccupiedthenorth.
ThisactofhasteontheSovietUnionspartthreatenedtheUSAastheyfearedacommunisttakeoverofKoreaandtheywereforcedtoquicklysendtwoyoungofficers(DeanRuskandCharlesBonesteel)toKoreaonAugust10,1945tosettletheboundariesofSovietandAmericanoccupationofKorea.Workingatextremelyshort
noticeandcompletelyunprepared,theyusedaNationalGeographicmaptodecideonthe38thparallel.TheychoseitbecauseitdividedthecountryapproximatelyinhalfbutwouldleavethecapitalSeoulunderAmericancontrol.NoexpertsonKoreawereconsulted.
Thoughelectionswerescheduled,theSovietUnionrefusedtocooperatewithUnitedNationsplanstoholdgeneralandfreeelectionsinthetwoKoreas,andasaresult,aCommuniststatewaspermanentlyestablishedunderSovietauspicesinthenorth,alsoknownastheDPRK,andapro-Westernstatewassetupinthesouth.Thetwosuperpowersbackeddifferentleadersandtwostateswereeffectivelyestablished,eachofwhichclaimedsovereigntyoverthewholeKoreanpeninsula.
ThisdivisionofKorea,aftermorethanamillenniumofbeingunified,wasseenasunacceptableandtemporarybybothregimes.From1948untilthestartofthecivilwaronJune25,1950,thearmedforcesofeachsideengagedinaseriesofbloodyconflictsalongtheborder.In1950,theseconflictsescalateddramaticallywhenNorthKoreanforcesinvadedSouthKorea,triggeringtheKoreanWar.TheKoreanArmisticeAgreementwassignedthreeyearslaterendinghostilitiesandeffectivelymakingthedivisionpermanent.Thetwostateswerenowdividedalongthedemarcationlineandthetwosidesagreedtocreateafour-kilometerwidebufferzonebetweenthestates,wherenobodywouldenter.ThisareacametobeknownastheDemilitarizedZoneorDMZ.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
7/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 7
Thedivisioncanbeunderstoodbetterbyexaminingthismap:
RelationBetweenthetwoKoreas
ManystillbelievethattheKoreasarestillinastateofwarandallthemembersin
theinternationalcommunityshouldbeontheirtoes.ThiswasshowntobeespeciallytrueaftertheattackofROKSCheonansinking(TheROKSCheonansinkingoccurredon26March2010,whentheCheonan,aRepublicofKoreaNavyshipcarrying104personnel,sankoffthecountry'swestcoastnearBaengnyeongIslandintheYellowSea,killing46seamen.ASouthKorean-ledofficialinvestigationcarriedoutbyateamofinternationalexpertsfromSouthKorea,theUnitedStates,theUnitedKingdom,Canada,Australia,andSwedenpresentedasummaryofitsinvestigationon20May2010,concludingthatthewarshiphadbeensunkbyaNorthKoreantorpedofiredbyamidgetsubmarine.),theworldhastheireyesonNorthKorea'snextmove,andtwoKoreas'tensionhasflaredsincethen.Theincidentchilledinter-Koreanrelationsandseemedtofreezeallexchangesbetween
thetwoKoreas.AssoonastheinvestigationteamrevealedthatCheonanwassunkbyNorthKorea,PresidentLeeimplementedcountermeasurescalledtheMay24Measures.TheSouthKoreangovernmentsuspendedallinter-KoreanexchangesandcooperationwiththeNorthexceptthebusinessoperationintheGaeseongIndustrialComplexandthepurehumanitarianaidfortheunderprivilegedpeopleinNorthKorea.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
8/35
8 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
ThereislotsofskeptismaboutNorth-SouthKorearelationships.Intheeconomicfield,thereisamisunderstandingofallegationthatSouthisjustgivingawayeverythingtotheNorthwithoutreceivinganythinginreturn.However,eitherincomparisonwiththepreviousSouthKoreangovernmentortheformerWestGermanaidtoEastGermany,theKimDaeJunggovernment'sassistancetoNorth
Koreahasbeenratherminuscule.Forexample,theaidtoNorthKoreaintheyear2000wasonly.017percentofSouthKorea'sGDPwhichislessthanone-fourthoftheformerWestGermany'sannualaidtoEastGermany.
OnJuly7,1988,withtheannouncementofthePresidentialDeclarationforNationalSelf-esteemUnificationandProsperity,SouthandNorthKoreaofficiallypromotedinter-Koreanexchangesandcooperation.Inter-KoreanexchangesandcooperationstoppedtemporarilywhenNorthKoreawithdrewfromtheNPTinMarchof1993,butiteventuallyresumeditscourseandremainsineffectuntilnow.Upuntil1989,onlyonepersoncrossedtheborderbutthatnumberhasincreasedovertheyearsandnowstandsat130,000.Inter-Koreantraderecorded19millionUSdollarsin
1989butitreached1.9billionUSdollarsin2010.Additionally,thetotalamountofhumanitarianaidfrom1995tolate2010equalsapproximately2.9billionUSdollars.
ForeignRelationsofNorthKorea
TheforeignrelationsthatdefinetheplaceofNorthKoreaintheworldcommunitytodayareproductofthetrajectories.Startingwiththe1936nationbuildingprocessNorthKoreahasalliedwithChinaandRussia.HoweverwiththeincreasingprosperityofChinaanditspowerintheinternationalsociety,NorthKoreahaslimitedpowerinChina.
China
SinoNorthKoreanrelationsarebilateralbetweenthePeople'sRepublicofChina(PRC)andtheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKorea(NorthKorea).
ChinaandNorthKoreahavehistoricallyenjoyedclosediplomaticrelations.However,inrecentyearstherehasbeengrowingconcerninChinaoverissuessuchasNorthKorea'snuclearweaponsprogram,theirallegedsinkingoftheROKSCheonanandtheirbombardmentofYeonpyeong.AfterNorthKoreaconducteditsfirstnucleartestin2006,theChinesegovernmentstatedthattheywere"resolutelyopposedtoit"andvotedforUnitedNationssanctionsagainstNorthKorea.
ChinaandNorthKoreasharea1,416-kilometerlongborderthatcorrespondsbroadlyspeakingtothecourseoftheYaluandTumenrivers.Thecountrieshavesixbordercrossingsbetweenthem.InNovember2003,ChinareportedlytransferredresponsibilityforsecuringitsborderwithNorthKoreafromthepolicetoitsarmy.
In2006,Chinabuilta20-kilometerlongfencealongitsborderwithNorthKorea.ItislocatedprimarilyalongareaswheretheYaluRiverdividingthetwocountriesis
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
9/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 9
narrowandtheriverbankslow.MuchofChinastradewiththeDPRKgoesthroughtheportofDandongontheYaluRiver.
InFebruary1997,theaccesstoforeignandChinesetravelersandtouristsoftheTumenRiverBridgeatWonjong-QuanheontheDPRK-Chinaborderwasallowed.Thisledtoaphenomenalincreaseincross-bordertrafficandbusinesswithinoneyear;fromlessthan1,000passengersin1996,toover100,000in1997.
InMay2012,ChinaandNorthKoreasignedanagreementontheconstructionandmanagementofthecross-borderbridgebetweenManpointheJagangProvinceofNorthKoreaandJianinChina.
ChinapermittedtheYanbianKoreanEthnicGroupAutonomousPrefecturetoconductbordertradewiththeDPRKinAugust1954.AbartercontractbetweenChinaandtheDPRKwasofficiallysignedthesameyear.Thecontractstipulatesthefollowing:
1. Thetwosidesshallbarterintheformofmutualexchangeofmaterials.2. ThetwosidesshallsettletheaccountswithChineserenminbi.
3. ThesitesofbartershallbeintheChinesecityofTumenandintheKorean
citiesofNamyang,Hoeryeong,Khyongwon,andMusan.
DuringtheKoreanWarfrom195053,ChinaassistedNorthKorea,sendingasmanyas500,000soldierstosupportNorthKoreanforces.Sincethen,thetwostateshavecloselycooperatedinsecurityanddefenseissues.In1975,KimIlSungvisitedBeijinginafailedattempttosolicitsupportfromChinaforamilitaryinvasionofSouthKorea.OnNovember23,2009,ChineseDefenseMinisterLiangGuanglievisitedPyongyang,thefirstdefensechieftovisitsince2006.
Atimelinewithkeyevents:
In1950,ChinaenteredtheKoreanWarinsupportofNorthKorea.
In1961,thetwocountriessignedtheSino-NorthKoreanMutualAidandCooperationFriendshipTreaty,wherebyChinapledgedtoimmediatelyrendermilitaryandotherassistancebyallmeanstoitsallyagainstanyoutsideattack.Thistreatywasprolongedtwice,in1981and2001,withvaliditytill2021.
Since2003,thePRChasbeenaparticipantinsix-partytalksaimedatresolvingtheissueofNorthKorea'snuclearweaponsprogram.
In2006,whentheDPRKtest-firedaseriesofballisticmissiles,afterChinahadurgeditnottodoso,Chineseauthoritiespubliclyrebukedtheirneighbor,andsupportedtheUNSecurityCouncilResolution1718,whichimposedsanctionsonNorthKorea.Atothertimeshowever,ChinahasblockedUnitedNationsresolutionsthreateningsanctionsagainstNorthKorea.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
10/35
10 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
On1stJanuary2009,ChinesePresidentHuJintaoandNorthKoreanleaderKimJong-Ilexchangedgreetingsanddeclared2009astheyearofChina-DPRKfriendship,marking60yearsofdiplomaticrelationsbetweenthetwocountries.
OnNovember28,2010,aspartoftheUnitedStatesdiplomaticcablesleak,WikiLeaksandmediapartnerssuchasTheGuardianpublisheddetailsofcommunicationsinwhichChineseofficialsreferredtoNorthKoreaasa"spoiledchild"anditsnuclearprogramas"athreattothewholeworld'ssecurity".TwounnamedChineseofficialsalsoallegedlytoldofgrowingsupportinBeijingforKoreanreunificationundertheSouth'sgovernment.
UnitedStatesofAmerica
NorthKoreaUnitedStatesrelationsdevelopedprimarilyduringtheKoreanWar,butinrecentyearshavebeenlargelydefinedbytheUnitedStates'suspicionsregardingNorthKorea'snuclearprogramsandNorthKorea'sstateddesiretonormalizerelationswiththeU.SA,temperedbyastatedperceptionofanimminentU.S.attack.
AlthoughhostilitybetweenthetwocountriesremainslargelyaproductofColdWarpolitics,therewereearlierconflictsandanimositybetweentheU.S.andKorea.Inthemid-19thcenturyKoreacloseditsborderstoWesterntrade.IntheGeneralShermanincident,KoreanforcesattackedaU.S.gunboatsenttonegotiateatradetreatyandkilleditscrew,afterfirefrombothsidesbecauseitdefiedinstructionsfromKoreanofficials.AU.S.retributionattack,theShinmiyangyo,followed.
KoreaandtheU.S.ultimatelyestablishedtraderelationsin1882.RelationssouredagainwhentheU.S.negotiatedpeaceintheRusso-JapaneseWar.Japanpersuaded
theU.S.toacceptKoreaaspartofJapan'ssphereofinfluence,andtheUnitedStatesdidnotprotestwhenJapanannexedKoreafiveyearslater.KoreannationalistsunsuccessfullypetitionedtheUnitedStatestosupporttheircauseattheVersaillesTreatyconferenceunderWoodrowWilson'sprincipleofnationalself-determination.
TheUnitedNationsdividedKoreaafterWorldWarIIalongthe38thparallel,intendingitasatemporarymeasure.However,thebreakdownofrelationsbetweentheU.S.andUSSRpreventedareunification.DuringtheU.S.occupationofSouthKorea,relationsbetweentheU.S.andNorthKoreawereconductedthroughtheSovietmilitarygovernmentintheNorth.BecauseofNorthKorea'ssubmissionto
Sovietpressures,andbecauseofmassoppositiontothelenientU.S.occupationofthemortalenemyJapan,NorthKoreansinthisperioddenouncedtheUnitedStatesandbegantoformanegativeviewoftheU.S.However,severalAmericanministersandmissionariesremainedactiveinthisperiod,remindingKoreans,beforetheywereuprootedbythecommunistregime,thatAmericanindividualscouldbeveryhelpfultothecauseofKoreanindependence.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
11/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
1
OnSeptember9,1948,KimIl-sungdeclaredtheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKorea;hepromptlyreceiveddiplomaticrecognitionfromtheSovietUnion,butnottheUnitedStates.TheU.S.didnotextend,andhasneverextended,diplomaticrecognitiontotheDPRK.After1948,thewithdrawalofmostAmericantroopsfromthepeninsulaactuallyintensifiedKimIlSung'santi-Americanrhetoric,often
assertingthattheU.S.wasanimperialistsuccessortoJapan,aviewthecountrystillholdstoday.InDecember1950,theUnitedStatesinitiatedeconomicsanctionsagainsttheDPRKundertheTradingwiththeEnemyAct,whichlasteduntil2008.
NorthKoreanshadtheirclosestencounterwiththeUnitedStatesduringtheUS/UNoccupationofNorthKoreainthetwomonthsaftertheInchonlanding.WithhelpfromtheROKArmy,theUnitedStates'military,underthecommandofGeneralDouglasMacArthur,movedtosetupaciviladministrationforNorthKoreainthewakeofthepresumeddestructionoftheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKorea.MacArthurplannedtofindNorthKoreangenerals,especiallyKimIl-Sung,andtrythemaswarcriminals.
StartinginlateAugust2008,NorthKoreaallegedlyresumeditsnuclearactivitiesattheYongbyonnuclearfacility,apparentlymovingequipmentandnuclearsuppliesbackontothefacilitygrounds.Sincethen,NorthKoreanactivityatthefacilityhassteadilyincreased,withNorthKoreathreateningYongbyon'spossiblereactivation.
NorthKoreahasarguedthattheU.S.hasfailedtofulfillitspromisesinthedisarmamentprocess,havingnotremovedthecountryfromits"StateSponsorsofTerrorism"listorsentthepromisedaidtothecountry.TheU.S.hasrecentlystatedthatitwillnotremovetheNorthfromitslistuntilithasaffirmedthatNorthKoreawillpushforwardwithitscontinueddisarmament.NorthKoreahassincebarredIAEAinspectorsfromtheYongbyonsite,andtheSouthhasclaimedthattheNorthis
pushingforthemanufactureofanuclearwarhead.TheNorthhasrecentlyconductedtestsonshort-rangemissiles.TheU.S.isencouragingtheresumptionofsix-partytalks.
OnOctober11,2008,theU.S.andNorthKoreasecuredanagreementinwhichNorthKoreaagreedtoresumedisarmamentofitsnuclearprogramandonceagainallowedinspectorstoconductforensictestsofitsavailablenuclearmaterials.TheNorthalsoagreedtoprovidefulldetailsonitslong-rumoreduraniumprogram.TheselatestdevelopmentsculminatedinNorthKorea'slong-awaitedremovalfromAmerica's"StateSponsorsofTerrorism"listonthesameday.
OnMay25,2009,American-NorthKoreanrelationsfurtherdeterioratedwhenNorthKoreaconductedyetanothernucleartest,thefirstsincethe2006test.ThetestwasonceagainconductedundergroundandexplodedwithayieldcomparabletotheLittleBoyandFatManbombsthatdestroyedHiroshimaandNagasaki,respectively.TheUnitedStateswasalsopleasedwithChinaandRussia'smove,whocondemnedNorthKorea'sactionseventhoughtheyarebothstrongalliesofNorthKorea.TheU.S.,alongwithallothermembersofthestalledsix-partytalks,stronglycondemnedthetestandsaidthatNorthKoreawould"payapriceforitsactions."
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
12/35
12 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
TheU.S.alsostronglycondemnedthesubsequentseriesofshort-rangemissileteststhathavefollowedthedetonation.
Russia
NorthKoreaandRussiafirstestablisheddiplomaticrelationsonOctober12,1948shortlyaftertheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKoreawasproclaimed.ThoughthetwowereclosealliesduringtheColdWar,relationsbetweenthemhavecooleddownsincethebreakupoftheSovietUnion.Therelationshipgainedsomeimportanceagainduringthe2000s(decade).
Russiahassunkconsiderableamountsofcapitalintonumerouslarge-scale,long-terminternationalinfrastructureprojectsinvolvingtheKoreanpeninsula,suchasoilandgaspipelinesandTrans-KoreanandTrans-Siberianrailroadsjunctions.TheseprojectsareofcrucialimportancetotheeconomicrevitalizationoftheRussianFarEast,andinthecaseofanewKoreanWar,theseprojectsandRussianeconomicinterestswouldbeseverelydamaged.ThetwostatesshareaborderalongthelowerTumenRiver,whichis17kilometers(11mi)longandwasformedonlyin1860whentheTsarboughtlandsfromChina.
Japan
AlegacyofbitternessexistsinJapan'srelationswithNorthKorea,stemmingfromJapanesecolonialruleoverKoreafrom1910to1945.Currently,JapandoesnotrecognizeNorthKorea,andneithercountryhasanydiplomaticrelations.BilaterallyandthroughtheSix-PartyTalks,NorthKoreaandJapancontinuetodiscussissuessurroundingthefateofJapanesecitizensabductedbyNorthKoreainthe1970sand1980s.
Recently,NorthKoreaexpectedtohavepositiverelationshipwithJapanwhenDemocraticPartyofJapanwontheelection.However,primeministerthenHatoyamaYukiomaintainedtheoriginalpositiontowardNorthKorea.Yeonpyeongbombing,ROKSCheonansinkinghavealsocontributedtothecontinuingexacerbationoftherelationship.
UnitedKingdom
FollowinginitialprogressinNorthKoreaSouthKorearelations,NorthKoreaandtheUnitedKingdomestablisheddiplomaticrelationsonDecember12,2000,
openingresidentembassiesinLondonandPyongyang.TheUnitedKingdomprovidesEnglishlanguageandhumanrightstrainingtoDPRKofficials,urgingtheNorthKoreangovernmenttoallowavisitbytheUNSpecialRapporteurforHumanRights,anditoverseesbilateralhumanitarianprojectsinNorthKorea.
TomarkthetenthanniversaryofNorthKorea'srelationswiththeUnitedKingdom,aneditedversionofthe2002filmBendItLikeBeckhamwasbroadcastonNorthKoreanstatetelevisionon26December2010.TheBritishAmbassadortoSouth
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
13/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
3
Korea,MartinUden,postedonTwitterthatitwasthe"1steverWestern-madefilmtoaironTV"inNorthKorea.
Goodrelationsbetweenthetwonationshavebeeninexistenceasfarbackas1966whentheNorthKoreanfootballteamplayedinthe1966WorldCupinEngland.TheNorthKoreanteambecametheadoptedteamofMiddleborough,whichwaswheretheyplayedtheirgroupgamesduringthecompetition.MiddleboroughfanswentontosupporttheNorthKoreanteaminthenextroundofthetournament,withmanytravelingtoLiverpooltowatchtheteamagainstPortugal.In2002,membersoftheNorthKoreanteamreturnedtoMiddleboroughforanofficialvisit.
France
RelationsbetweentheFrenchRepublicandtheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKoreaareofficiallynon-existent.FranceisoneofonlytwoEuropeanUnionmembersnottomaintaindiplomaticrelationswithNorthKorea,theotherbeingEstonia.ThereisnoFrenchembassy,noranyothertypeofFrenchdiplomaticrepresentation,inPyongyang,andnoDPRKembassyinParis,althoughaNorthKoreandiplomaticofficeislocatedinnearbyNeuillysurSeine.
France'sofficialpositionisthatitwillconsiderestablishingdiplomaticrelationswithDPRKifandwhenthelatterabandonsitsnuclearweaponsprogramandimprovesitshumanrightsrecord.
India
IndiawasappointedasChairmanofthe9-memberUNCommissiontoholdelectionsinKoreain1947;AftertheKoreanwarof1950-53,Indiaplayedanimportantrole
astheChairmanoftheNNRC(NeutralNationsRepatriationCommission);ConsularrelationswithDPRKweresetuponMarch1,1962;anddiplomaticrelationsbetweenthetwocountrieswereestablishedonDecember10,1973RelationsbetweenIndiaandDPRKhavebeengenerallycharacterizedbyfriendship,cooperationandunderstanding.AsmembersoftheNon-AlignedMovement,thereisacommonalityofviewsbetweenthetwoonmanyinternationalissues,e.g.Disarmament,South-SouthCooperation,etc.Bothsidescontinuetoworkcloselyattheinternationalforandsupporteachotheronvariousissuesofbilateralandinternationalinterests.IndiahadwelcomedtheSouth-NorthJointDeclarationofJune15,2000andfavorsreductionoftensionintheKoreanpeninsulaandreunificationofthetwoKoreasthroughpeacefulmeansandthroughdirectdialogue
betweenthem.IndiaandDPRKhavebeencooperatingintheUNandotherinternationalorganizations.Regularandmeaningfulexchangeofviewsonbilateralissuesofmutualinterestandconcern,wereconductedthroughmechanismofFOC.InMarch2011,IndiaprovidedNorthKoreawithassistanceinfoodbyprovidingsuppliesworthalmost$1millionthroughtheWorldFoodProgram,whichwasmuchappreciatedbytheGovernmentoftheDemocraticPeople'sRepublicofKorea.ManyNorthKoreannationalsreceivetraininginIndiaincludinginthefieldsofIT
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
14/35
14 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
andscienceandtechnology.IndiahasabilateraltradeofaroundhalfabilliondollarswithNorthKorea.Also,IndiaisincreasinglybeingaskedbytheUSAtomediateintheKoreanpeninsuladuetoitsstrengtheningrelationswithbothNorthKoreaandSouthKorea.
PakistanPakistanmaintainswarmdiplomaticandtraderelationswithNorthKorea.Thestartofrelationsbetweenthetwocountriesemergedsometimeinthe1970sduringtheruleofPakistaniPrimeMinisterZulfikarAliBhutto.NorthKoreamaintainsanembassyinIslamabad.Relationsbetweenthetwocountriesarereportedtobestronginbothcivilianandmilitaryspheres.NorthKoreahassuppliedmissiletechnologytoPakistan.
Vietnam
StudentsfromNorthVietnambegangoingtoNorthKoreatostudyasearlyasthe1960s,evenbeforetheformalestablishmentofKorean-languageeducationintheircountry.TheformerVietnameseambassadortoSouthKoreaisagraduateofNorthKorea'sKimIl-sungUniversity.ThesonofaformerstaffmemberintheVietnameseembassyinPyongyang,whoalsoattendedKimIl-sungUniversitybetween1998and2002,gaveaninterviewin2004withSouthKoreannewspaperTheChosunIlboabouttheexperienceshehadwhilelivingthere.
BothNorthandSouthKorealentmaterialandmanpowersupporttotheirrespectiveideologicalalliesduringtheVietnamWar,thoughthenumberofSouthKoreantroopsonthegroundwaslarger.AsaresultofadecisionoftheKoreanWorkers'PartyinOctober1966,inearly1967NorthKoreasentafightersquadron
toNorthVietnamtobackuptheNorthVietnamese921stand923rdfightersquadronsdefendingHanoi.Theystayedthrough1968;200pilotswerereportedtohaveserved.Inaddition,atleasttwoanti-aircraftartilleryregimentsweresentaswell.NorthKoreaalsosentweapons,ammunitionandtwomillionsetsofuniformstotheircomradesinNorthVietnam.KimIl-sungisreportedtohavetoldhispilotsto"fightinthewarasiftheVietnameseskyweretheirown".
Israel
NorthKoreadoesnotrecognizethestateofIsrael;instead,itrecognizesthesovereigntyofthePalestinianNationalAuthorityovertheterritoryheldbyIsrael.
Overtheyears,NorthKoreahassuppliedmissiletechnologytoIsrael'srivals,includingPakistan,Iran,Syria,Libya,andEgypt.Syria,whichhasahistoryofconfrontationswithIsrael,haslongmaintainedarelationshipwithNorthKoreabasedonthecooperationbetweentheirrespectivenuclearprograms.NorthKoreahascriticizedIsraelforinvadingSyrianairspaceandforitsactionsintheGazaWar.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
15/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
5
Australia
AustraliaandNorthKoreamaintaindiplomaticrelations.
InJanuary2008,NorthKoreacloseditsembassyinCanberra,citingfinancial
difficulties.EmbassyspokesmanPakMyongGukexplained:"Wenowhavetoclose[ourembassy]becauseoffinancialissues.ItisverydifficulttosendmoneyfromNorthKoreatoAustralia."
Ina2003eventdubbedthe"PongSuincident",Australianofficials,strengtheningAustralias,seizedaNorthKoreancargoshipallegedlyattemptingtosmuggleheroinintoAustraliaandtheUnitedStatessuspicionsthatPyongyangengagesininternationaldrugsmuggling.TheNorthKoreangovernmentdeniedanyinvolvement.
Germany
TheformerGermanDemocraticRepublic(GDR)maintaineddiplomaticrelationswithNorthKoreafrom1949onwardsandwasoneofthecountrysmostimportantpartnersintheEasternbloc.AfterGermanreunification,amissiontorepresenttheinterestsoftheFederalRepublicofGermanywasopenedonthepremisesoftheformerGDREmbassyinPyongyangin1991,withSwedenactingasprotectingpower.Atthesametime,theformerNorthKoreanEmbassyinEastBerlinwasturnedintoanofficetosafeguardtheinterestsofNorthKoreaundertheprotectorshipofthePeoplesRepublicofChina.
GermanyandNorthKoreaestablishedfulldiplomaticrelationson1March2001.Accordingtotheagreementreachedinthisconnection,diplomaticrelationsare
aimedatsecuringthenon-proliferationofweaponsofmassdestruction,advancinginner-KoreandialogueandimprovingthehumanrightssituationinNorthKorea.
Iran
Iran-NorthKorearelationsaredescribedasbeingpositivebyofficialnewsagenciesofthetwocountries.IranandNorthKoreahavepledgedcooperationineducational,scientific,andculturalspheres.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
16/35
16 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
SuccessoftheCommitteeTheysuccessofthecommitteeistheultimategoalthathastobeattainedandachieved.Thecrisisathandhastobesolvedpeacefully
withapracticalsolution.PleasedonotcometoanonviableconsensussuchasmakingpeacewiththeideaofNorthKorealaunchingballisticmissiles.Thisishighlyunlikelytohappen-andthedraftdirectiveortheresolutionsthatwillbeintroducedincommitteehavetobepragmaticandsensible.Also,thefactsofthesituationhavetobetakenintoaccount.Suchas-NorthKoreawithdrawingherplanscannotbefeasiblesinceshehasalreadylaunchedaballisticmissileonthe12 thofDecember.Sobasically,thesituationshouldbehandledinapeacefulway,andtheperspectivesofeachcountryshouldbeinculcatedintothepaperworkofthecommittee.TheP-5nationshavetheprivilegeof
usingtheirvetopowerincaseofformalvoting.Itismyourhonestrequestthatyouuseyourdiscretionandvoteinafairmanner,andkeepinmindyourcountrysforeignpoliciesanddiplomaticrelations.
Theultimategoalthathastobeachievedisthattheissueathandisresolvedwithbusinesslikeapproach.Theexecutiveboardlooksforwardtotheinnovativesolutionsthatdelegatesofvariouscountriescomeupwith.Thecommitteemustnotfailunderanycircumstances.Allyourresearchanddebating,isonlytoachievethisfinalgoal-andthatis
thesuccessofthecommittee.Allthebestdelegates.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
17/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
7
NorthKoreasNuclear,SpaceandMissileProgram
NorthKoreahasbeenisolatedfromtheinternationalspherefromquitesometime.
ThemainreasonforthishasbeenthecollapseofCommunisminRussiaandEastEurope.Asaresult,NorthKorealostsignificantallies.Addtothis,itsnemesisSouthKoreaandtheircloserelationshipwithanationarmedwithnuclearweapons,USA,whichNorthKoreaseesasathreat.Fromthis,wecanseewhyNorthKoreafeelstheneedtopossesshort,mediumandlongrangeballisticmissiles,sothatitcantargetitsadversaries,whicharetraditionallyacceptedasUSA,JapanandSouthKorea.
NorthKoreasfirstmissilescamefromtheSovietUnionin1969.Lateron,in1976,EgyptshippedScudmissilestotheNorthKoreans.ScudswereaseriesofmissilesdevelopedbytheSovietUnionandshippedtovariouscountries,Egyptbeingoneofthem.Thereon,NorthKoreabegandevelopingandtestingitsownmissile
technology.Bythemiddleofthedecadefrom1980to1990,NorthKoreawasbuildingitsownshortrangeScuds,theHwasong-5andHwasong-6,witharangeof300and500kilometersrespectively.Italsodevelopedmiddlerangemissiles,theNodong-1andtheNodong-2,whichhavearangeof1000kilometers.TheNodongscouldbeusedasaweaponagainstJapan.ThefactthattheNodongsarenotveryaccurateonlyaddstothefearthattheymightcausedamagetothecivilianpopulationofJapan,eveniftheNorthKoreanswishtotargetUSmilitarybasesinJapan.
Alongwiththesemissiles,theNorthKoreanmilitaryarsenalalsoboatstheMusudan-1.Thisisanintermediateormiddle(theexactrangeofthemissileisunknown,thereforetheclassificationisunclear)rangemissile,whichalsogoesbythenameofTaepodongXorNodong-B.Thismissilehasneverbeentestedsoitsexactrangeremainsunknown.Thelowerlimit,givenbytheIsraeliintelligenceisat2,500kilometers,whileattheupperlimit,byothersourcesisat4,000kilometers.TheUSMissiledefenseAgencygivesarangeof3,200kilometers.Atitsmaximumpredictedrange,thismissilecouldhitislandsinthePacific.
NextinitscollectionareTaepodong1and2missiles.TheTaepodong-1missileismadeupoftwostages(parts),thefirstbeingaHwasong-6andthesecondaNodongmissile.ThismissilewassupposedtoputasatelliteintotheEarthsorbit;howeveritdidnotmanagetoputanysatelliteintospace.Itistobenotedthattheproblemwasonlyinputtingthesatelliteinspace;therocketflewwithoutanyproblemsduringitstestinAugust,1998.Itsrangeisestimatedtobearound2,200kilometresbutitsaccuracyisconsideredtobelesserthanthatoftheNodongs.
Finally,NorthKoreawantedtoaddlong-rangeballisticmissiletoitsarsenalofweapondeliverysystems.Torealisethisambition,ittestedtheTaepodong-2.TheTaepodong-2wastestedthreetimesuntilbeforeDecember2012.Thefirsttimewas
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
18/35
18 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
in2006,whentherocketexplodedwithinaminuteofitslaunch.Twiceafterwards,onein2009andonceearlierinApril2012,themissiletestfailedagain.
TheTaepodong-2aimstoplaceasatelliteintheorbit,whichNorthKoreaclaimsisforscientificpurposestomonitorweather,cropsandforestation.ThisistheNorthKoreanspaceprogram,whichitreferstoasUnha,theKoreanwordforgalaxy.Japan,SouthKoreaandUSA,however,accuseNorthKoreaoftryingtouseUnhaasacoverfortestingalong-rangemissile.
Thebasictechnologyforspacelaunchesandrocketlaunchesisthesame,withsomeminordifferences.TheTaepodong-2ifusedtodevelopballisticmissiletechnologyisestimatedtohavearangeanywherebetween5,000to15,000kilometres.TheupperlimitplacestheUSAunderitsreach.TheCentreforNon-ProliferationStudiesestimatesthatthisvalueis6,000kilometres.BelowisamapshowingtherangesofthevariousNorthKoreanmissiles.ThemapisfromtheCouncilofForeignRelations,asfoundonwww.bbc.co.uk.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
19/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 1
9
Delegatescanrefertothiskeytoknowabouttheclassificationofmissiles.
Shortrange:1,000kmorless
Mediumrange:1,000-3,000km
Intermediaterange:3,000-5,500km
Intercontinental:Greaterthan5,500km
Delegatesmustunderstandthatthesemissilesareonlydeliverysystems;therealthreatliesintheNorthKoreanstockpileofWeaponsofMassDestruction(WMDs)andconventionalweapons.Theseweaponscanbetransportedtodesiredtargetsusingthesemissiles.Below,delegatesareprovidedwithabriefoutlineofNorthKoreasnuclearweaponsandprograms,whichareitsmostdangerousmilitaryasset.
TheintroductionofnuclearweaponsintotheKoreanpeninsuladatesbackto1957whenPresidentEisenhowerofUSAagreedtodeploynuclearweaponstoSouthKoreainordertoeachthen-rivals,ChinaandtheUSSR.HonestJohnmissilesarmedwithnuclearweaponsand280mmatomiccannonsweredeployedinSouthKoreain1958,followedbytheMatadorCruisemissilesin1959.Thiswasagainstparagraph13(d)oftheKoreanArmisticeAgreement,which,asquotedfromwikisourcereads:
(d) Cease the introduction into Korea of reinforcing combat aircraft, armored vehicles,weapons, and ammunition; provided however, that combat aircraft, armoured vehicles,
weapons, and ammunition which are destroyed, damaged, worn out, or used up duringthe period of the armistice may be replaced on the basis piece-for-piece of the same
effectiveness and the same type. Such combat aircraft, armored vehicles, weapons, and
ammunition shall be introduced into Korea only through the ports of entry enumerated inparagraph 43 hereof. In order to justify the requirements for combat aircraft, armoredvehicles, weapons, and ammunition to be introduced into Korea for replacement
purposes, reports concerning every incoming shipment of these items shall be made tothe MAC and the NNSC; such reports shall include statements regarding the dispositionof the items being replaced. Items to be replace which are removed from Korea shall be
removed only through the ports of entry enumerated in paragraph 43 hereof. The NNSC,
through its Neutral Nations Inspection Teams, shall conduct supervision and inspectionof the replacement of combat aircraft, armoured vehicles, weapons, and ammunition
authorized above, at the ports of entry enumerated in paragraph 43 hereof.
Thisparagraphcanbesummarizedtosaythatnonewkindsofweaponsweretobe
introducedintotheKoreas,whichincludedthenuclearweapons.TheUnitedStateshoweverviolatedthissectionoftheagreementandUSAhadinformedNorthKoreathatitdidnotconsideritselfboundbyparagraph13(d)ofthearmisticeanylonger.
Underthissituation,NorthKoreabeganconsideringobtainingnuclearweaponsitself.NorthKoreawasrefusedhelpbyboththeUSSRandChinatodevelopnuclearweapons,thoughtheUSSRagreedtoprovideNorthKoreaassistancewithaciviliannuclearenergyprogram.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
20/35
20 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
AfterthecollapseoftheUSSR,NorthKoreacameunderincreasingpressuretodevelopamilitaryprogram.TheNorthKoreanauthoritieshoweverdidtrytoengagetheAmericansindiplomacybycallingforbilateraltalksbetweenNorthKoreaandtheUSA,whichtheUSArefusedinfavourofsix-partytalksinvolvingChina,Japan,SouthKoreaandRussia.NorthKoreawouldonlyconsenttobilateral
talks,whiletheAmericansarguedthatNorthKoreahadviolatedbilateralagreementsbeforeandthatNorthKoreasaccountabilitywasnottrustworthy.Thus,thetensionsbetweenthecountriesfurtherincreasedandtherewasadiplomaticimpassebetweenNorthKoreaandtheUSA.
AllthesefactorscanbesaidtohaveledtotheNorthKoreannuclearprogram.TheprogramstartedwithNorthKoreasfirstnucleartest,whichitannouncedon9thOctober,2006.JapanandSouthKoreadetectedseismicmovementswhichwerenotnaturaloccurrences,confirmingthattheNorthKoreanclaimwasindeedtrue.Furthermore,NorthKoreacarriedoutasecondundergroundnucleartestonMay25,2009,whichwasequallycriticizedbytheinternationalcommunity.
Evenitsclosestally,China,criticizedNorthKoreasnucleartestalmostunanimously.TheSecurityCouncilpassedResolution1874againstNorthKoreaon12thJune,2009.Allthe15membersoftheSecurityCouncilagreedupontheResolutionunanimouslyatthattime.
DelegatesareadvisedtokeepacopyoftheResolution1874withthemduring
committeeasitisanimportantdocumentrelatingtothecrisis,andhasgreater
valueattachedtoitbyvirtueofitbeinganofficialUNResolution.Theycanfindthe
resolutionhere:http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2009/sc9679.doc.htm
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
21/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 2
1
TheCrisis
TheNorthKoreanRocketLaunch
12thDecember2012,NorthKoreaconductsarocketlaunch.Therocket,calledUnha-
3(unhaistheKoreanworkforgalaxy),isthesecondattemptbyNorthKoreatoplaceanobjectintoorbitin2012.ThisisaftertheirfirstattempttosendarocketintospacefailedonApril13th.ThesecondrocketlaunchwasaroaringsuccesswiththeUnha-3successfullyplacinganobjectintoorbit.
Priortothelaunch,allmajorcountries,includingChinawhoisakeyallyofNorthKoreashowedconcernovertherocketlaunch.Infact,ChinawasoneofthefirstnationstocomeontheinternationalstageandexpressdeepconcernoverNorthKoreasimpendingrocketlaunch,indicatingthesofteningofChinasstance.ChinaisseentobethenationwiththehighestinfluenceoverNorthKorea.Evenso,ChinadidnothingtostoptherocketlaunchsinceasanallyofNorthKorea;itwasitsduty
tosupportitsviewsandcausenoobstructionsinitsadvancements.
AccordingtoNorthKorea,theobjectplacedinorbitisanEarthobservationsatellite,whichwillbeusedonlyforpurposessuchasweatherforecasts,forestationsurveysandothergeologicalandscientificpurposes.
But,SouthKorea,JapanandUSAconsidertherocketlaunchtobeacoverfortestingmissiletechnology.TheyimmediatelycondemnedtherocketlaunchasaviolationofinternationalsanctionsandUNresolutionsagainstNorthKorea.SouthKorea,Japan,USAandothercountriesbelievethatNorthKoreaistryingtodevelopanintercontinentalballisticmissile(ICBM),whichwouldcompleteitsarsenalof
ballisticmissiles,asitalreadypossessesshort,midandintermediaterangeballisticmissiletechnology.TheybelievethatNorthKoreaultimatelywantstomountanuclearwarheadonanICBMandhaveaveryrealandpotentnuclearweaponintheirhands.
Afterthelaunch,thereisageneraloutcryforstrictactionagainsttheNorthKoreans.Thelaunchdefiedinternationalwarningsandwascalleda"clearviolation"oftheUNresolutionbyUNSecretaryGeneralBanKi-moon.JapansleadingcandidatefortheofficeforPrimeMinister,ShinzoAbecalledontheUnitedNationsSecurityCounciltoadoptaresolution"stronglycriticizing"Pyongyang.AmericacalleditahighlyprovocativeactthatviolatedUnitedNationsresolutions."TheinternationalcommunitymustworkinaconcertedfashiontosendNorthKoreaaclearmessagethatitsviolationsofUnitedNationsSecurityCouncilresolutionshaveconsequences,"theWhiteHousesaidinastatement.AsenioradvisertoSouthKorea'spresidentsaidlastweekitwasunlikelytherewouldbeactionfromtheUnitedNationsandSeoulwouldexpectitsalliestotightensanctionsunilaterally.
TheUSAhasaskedChinatoexertitsinfluenceonNorthKoreasoastopreventanyfurtherdisruptiveactions.TheUnitedStatesraisedNorthKorea'slaunchasan
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
22/35
22 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
issueasLieutenantGeneralQiJianguo,deputychiefofthegeneralstaffofthePeople'sLiberationArmy,visitedthePentagononWednesdayforannualdefensetalksbetweenthePacificpowers.JimMiller,theundersecretaryofdefenseforpolicy,toldQithatNorthKorea'slaunchwasaclearviolationofUNSecurityCouncilresolutions,thePentagonsaidinastatement.HeurgedChinatoworkwith
theUnitedStatesandtheinternationalcommunitytoinsistthatNorthKorealiveuptoitscommitments,adheretoitsinternationalobligationsanddealpeacefullywithitsneighbors.
ChinaontheotherhandinsiststhatNorthKoreahastherighttodevelopaspaceprogrambutexpressesregretoverthelaunch.Theycallformoderateactionbutnothingtooharsh.
"Weexpressregretat(NorthKorea's)launchinspiteoftheextensiveconcernsoftheinternationalcommunity,"ForeignMinistryspokesmanHongLeitoldreporters.HeaddedthatChina"believesUNSecurityCouncilreactionshouldbeprudentandmoderateandconducivetomaintainingstabilityandavoidingescalationofthesituation."Mr.Hongsaiddialogueandnegotiationsarethewayforward.
NorthKorea'sForeignMinistryaccusedtheUSofoverreactingtothelaunch"outofhostilefeelings."
"Wehopethatallcountriesconcernedwillusereasonandremaincoolsoastopreventthesituationfromdevelopingtoundesirabledirection,"theofficialKoreanCentralNewsAgencyquotedaministryspokesmanassaying.Thespokesmansaidthecountrywill"continuetoexerciseourlegitimaterighttolaunchsatellites."
ButNorthKoreaalsodefendsitsneedtobuildnuclearweapons,citingtheUS
militarythreatintheregion,androckettestsareseenascrucialtoadvancingitstechnology.
BruceKlingner,aKoreaexpertattheHeritageFoundation,said:"ChinahasbeenthestumblingblocktofirmerU.N.actionandwe'llhavetoseeifthenewleadershipisanydifferentthanitspredecessors."(ReferringtotheChinesecommunistpartyschangeinleadership)
EscalationoftheCrisis
On21stDecember,2012,theUnitedStatesannouncedthatitisconsideringtakingmoreconcreteactionsagainstNorthKoreacitingthefactthatprevioussanctions
againstNorthKoreahaveprovedfutile.TheUSstatementcameinlightofthefactthatsanctionshaveneitherdeterredNorthKoreafromtestingmissiletechnology,norhavetheydissuadedNorthKoreafromitsnuclearprogram.TheUnitedStateshoweverdidnotclarifyastowhatthesemoreconcreteactionscouldbe.
Soonafterwards,theUnitedStatesregionalally,SouthKoreaaffirmeditssupportforanystepthattheUnitedStateswouldtaketohaltcontinuousviolationsof
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
23/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 2
3
UnitedNationsResolutionsandinternationallawbyNorthKorea.TheJapaneseMinistryofForeignAffairslaunchedasimilarstatement.
AftertheJapanese,AmericanandSouthKoreanstatements,theChineseForeignMinister,YangJiechi,inapublicstatementon26thDecember2012urgedtheUnitedStates,SouthKoreaandJapantoconsidertheimplicationsofanyunthought-ofactionontheirpart.Inhisstatement,JiechisaidthatChinawasneitherinfavorofimposingharshersanctionsonNorthKorea,norsupportedanyofthemoreconcreteactionsthattheUnitedStatesandothernationswerespeakingof.HesaidthatanysuchactionwillfurtherisolateNorthKoreafromtheinternationalpoliticalarena,andmaketheresolutionofthecrisisevenmoredifficult.
AsareactiontotheChineseforeignministersstatement,theAmericanSecretaryofState,HillaryClintonissuedapublicstatementsayingthatnoneofUSAsactionswereunthought-of,andthatitisChinasmoralobligationtoensurethatNorthKoreaabandonitsnuclearandmissileprograms.ThismarkedtheriseoftensionsbetweenChinaandtheUnitedStates.
On29thDecember,theJapanesePrimeMinister,YoshihokoNodaandtheSouthKoreanPresident,LeeMyung-BakarrivedinWashingtontomeetwiththeUSPresident,BarrackObamaanddiscussthesituationinlightoftheNorthKoreanrocketlaunchandtheChinesestanceregardingtheissue.ThisisinsharpcontrasttopreviouscrisesregardingNorthKorea,whereNorthKoreaandChinawereincludedinthetalks.
NeitherNorthKorea,norChinalookedupontheirexclusionfromthetalksfavorably.TherewerespeculationsregardingthesubjectofthetrilateraltalksbetweenUSA,theRepublicofKorea(RoK)andJapan,includingthatofjointmilitary
actionagainstNorthKorea.Thepremiersofthesenationsneitherconfirmed,nordeniedanysuchrumorsaftertheirmeeting.
TheSupremeLeaderofNorthKorea,KimJong-un,inastatementdefendingtherocketlaunchsaidthatNorthKoreahadfullrighttolauncharocketforplacingthesatelliteintotheorbitandthiswasdonestrictlyforcivilianpurposes.TheSupremeLeaderaddedthatUSAanditsallies,uptillthisveryday,borehatredforNorthKoreaandthiswasastepfurtherintheAmericandeterminationtodeterNorthKoreaninterests.
ChinasresponsetothetrilateraltalkswassummedupinthePremier,WenJiababosstatement:ChinaseesthismeetingbetweenU.S.A,JapanandSouthKoreaasadeliberateattempttokeepChinaoutofanaffairinwhichitplaysanintegralpart;itseemsthattheUnitedStatesdoesnotacknowledgeChinasimportanceintheregionorintheissue.Chinaalsowarnsnationsnottotakeanysteps,whichmighthurtinternationalpeace.Thisincludescollectivemilitaryaction.ChinafirmlystandsbyitsearliercommitmentofpursuingdiplomacytodissuadeNorthKoreafromitsmissileandnuclearprograms,insteadofresortingtomilitaryaction.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
24/35
24 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
TheAmericanSecretaryofState,HillaryClintonrespondedtotheChinesestatementbysayingthattheUnitedStatesisreadytoworkonlywiththosenationswhoarereadytoprosecuteNorthKoreaforitsrocketlaunchandtheUnitedStatesstandsunitedwithitsalliesintheregion.ThisstatementwasinterpretedbysomesourcestomeanthattheUSdoesnotconsideritselfandChinatobeonthesamesideofthe
argumentanymore.
TheUnitedKingdom,France,IndiaandRussia,ontheotherhandurgedU.S.A,JapanandRoKtoincludeChinaintothetalks,andtoresolvethedeadlock,sothatasolutiontotheNorthKoreancrisiscanbereached.Asaresultoftheirintervention,theUnitedStatesfinallyinvitedChinatojointalksinWashingtononthe20thofJanuary.However,Chinasaidthatithadbeeninsultedenoughandnow,thecrisiswillbediscussedonlyintheSecurityCouncil.
Thisishowthesituationstandsatpresentandnofurtherdevelopmentshavetakenplaceafterthe20thofJanuary,untilthe28th,whentheSecurityCouncilmeetstodiscussthecrisis.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
25/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 2
5
StancesoftheCountries
CommonwealthofAustralia
AustraliaisclassifiedbytheUnitedStatesasamajornon-
NATOally.Furthermore,theupperestimatedrangeoftheTaepodong-2wouldbringAustraliawithinitsrange.TheAustralianforeignminister,BobCarrhasbeenquotedtohavesaid,NorthKoreasnuclearandlong-rangemissileprogramspresentarealandcrediblethreattothesecurityoftheregion,andtoAustralia.
Assuch,AustraliasstanceontheissueisfavourabletowardstheUnitedStates,JapanandRoK.ItislikelytosupporttoughmeasuresincludingmilitaryinterventionagainstNorthKorea.
DemocraticPeoplesRepublicofKorea(NorthKorea) Frombeforetherocketlaunch,NorthKoreacontinuestomaintainthatitisinfullrighttolaunchrocketsandplacesatellitesintotheorbit.Timeandtimeagain,theNorthKoreanauthoritieshaveassuredtheinternationalcommunitythatthepurposeoftherocketlaunchwasnevertotestanymissiletechnologyandthatanyonesuggestingotherwisewasonlytryingtodisreputeNorthKorea.Furthermore,NorthKoreaisoftheopinionthatUSAandherfriendsaremerelyusingtherocketlaunchasanexcusetothreatenNorthKorea,astheyhavealwaystriedto
dobecauseoftheirhostilefeelingstowardstheDPRK.
NorthKoreaissuspiciousofthetrilateraltalksthatwereheldinWashingtonandhasappealedtotheresponsiblenationsoftheworldtocomeforwardandcounterthisbullyingthatRoK,USAandJapanareplanningbehindcloseddoorsinWashington.
Whenaskedaboutfurthermissileandnucleartests,NorthKoreanauthoritiesrespondedthatNorthKoreaisasovereignnationthatisfreetopursueanyprogramthatwillleadtoitsdevelopment.Ofsanctions,NorthKorearequestedallnationsnottosupportthisgrossviolationofNorthKoreasrightsasafreenation.
AtthismomentbeforetheSecurityCouncilmeets,NorthKoreasrelationswithJapan,theUnitedStatesandSouthKoreaareextremelytensed.NorthKoreaisindesperateneedofsupportamongothernations.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
26/35
26 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
FederalRepublicofGermany
GermanyalsoechoestheFrenchpositionwithregardtothecrisis.TheGermangovernmentremainsopposedtotheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch,butnorhasitstronglyspokenin
favorofmilitaryaggressionagainstNorthKorea.
GermanChancellorAngelaMerkel,onastatementonNewYearsDaysaidthatGermanywouldnotpassanyresolutionwhichcallsforexerciseofmilitaryforces,butatthesametime,wouldliketostressthatGermanymostdefinitelydoesnotsupporttherocketlaunchandwouldpasssanctionsagainstNorthKoreatoensurethatitcomplieswithinternationalpressure.
IslamicRepublicofIran
IranandNorthKoreahavetraditionallyhadgoodrelations,andthetwonationstradehasextendedtoarmsandammunitionsaswell.Iran,alongwithNorthKoreawasamemberofagroupofthreenationsthatGeorgeBush,theformerpresidentoftheUnitedStatestermedastheAxisofEvil.IranisoneofthefewnationswhodidnotcondemntherocketlaunchbyNorthKorea.IranisalsoopposedtoanysanctionsoranysortofactionagainstNorthKorea.Iransaysthatasafreenation,NorthKoreaisfreetopursueitsownpolicyregardingrocketlaunches.DelegatesareremindedthatIranhasbeensubjecttoUSandEUledsanctionsitself,regardingitsallegednuclearweaponsprogram.
Hence,IranisoneoftheclosestalliesofNorthKoreaandisgoingtobeitsstrongestsupporterincommittee.
IslamicRepublicofPakistan
PakistanisinaprecariouspositionwithregardtotheNorthKoreanlaunch.ItisaverycloseallyofChinaanditissupposedtobetheUnitedStatesallyinthelattersWaronTerror.However,therelationshipwiththeUnitedStatesisgrowingweakerduetoseveralreasonsincludingOsamabinLadenbeingfoundonPakistanisoilandNATOforceskillingPakistanitroopsontheAfghanborder.Furthermore,USofficialhaveclaimedthatPakistanhadaidedNorthKoreainacquiringitsnucleartechnology.Ontheotherhand,PakistanandChinasharearatherhealthyrelationship.Theybothhaveacommonrivalintheregion,whichisIndia.Afterthetrilateraltalks,PakistanhadvoicedconcernoverChinasexclusionfromthetalksandaseniorPakistanidiplomatcommented,Americasintentionsdonotseemverygood.Thusthe
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
27/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 2
7
PakistanistancecanbesaidtobesimilartoChinas.PeoplesRepublicofChina
Initially,theChinesestanceonthecrisiswascriticismoftheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch.However,theUnitedStatesand
itsalliesdeemedtheChinesereactiontonotbestrongenoughandsaidtheyweredisappointedinChina.Despitethis,ChinamaintainedthatitdidnotsupportstrictactionagainstNorthKorea.TheChineseargumentwasbasedontheirassumptionthatharsherdiplomacyormilitaryactionwouldfurtherinstigateandisolateNorthKorea.ChinasstancetowardstheJapanese,SouthKoreansandAmericanswasfurtherhardenedduetoitsisolationfromthetrilateraltalksheldinWashingtontodiscussthecrisis.ItseemsthatChinaisundertheimpressionthatJapan,RoKandtheUSAareconsideringforminganalliancetocounterNorthKorea,andbyexcludingChina
fromtheirtalks,theyaretryingtoundermineChineseinfluence.
Oflate,theChinesereactiondoesnotspeakmuchofNorthKoreasrocketlaunch,butrathercriticizesstepsbeingconsideredbyRoK,USAandJapanagainstNorthKorea.ItremainstobeseenastowhatstepstheChineseauthoritiesaresuggestingwithregardtoNorthKoreanow.
RepublicofFrance
TheFrenchForeignMinistry,likemanyotherscondemnedtheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch.ItlabeledtheNorthKoreanactionasa
provocation.Onannouncementoftherocketlaunch,FrancehadsaidthatNorthKoreamustabandonitsplan.
However,onemustrememberthatFrancehaddenouncedtheinvasionofIraqbyheralliesandUSin2003andislikelytogoagainstanymilitaryactionthattheUnitedStatesanditsalliestakemighttakethistime.FrancealsoplayedapivotalroleinconvincingtheUnitedStatestoinviteChinaintothetalks.
Thus,Francesroleisalsoofutmostimportance,asitisnotstronglyalignedtowardsanyofthetwosides.Furthermore,asapermanentmemberoftheSecurityCouncilwiththevetopower,Francesvotehasamajorimpactonthecommitteesdecision.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
28/35
28 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
RepublicofIndia
TheIndianforeignministryissuedastatementsayingthat,Indiaexpressesitsconcernatthelaunchofarocket...inviolationofUnitedNations
SecurityCouncilResolution1874.IndiacallsonDPRKtorefrainfromsuchactions.Hence,theIndiangovernmentdoesnotseemtobeinsupportoftherocketlaunch.Alongwiththat,IndiasrelationswithNorthKoreasallies,ChinaandPakistanarerathertense.
Ontheotherhandhowever,IndiaseemskeentoavoidanymilitaryconfrontationintheKoreanpeninsula.Indiawasoneofthenations,whichpersuadedtheUnitedStatesandtheotherstoinviteChinatojointalksregardingNorthKorea,despiteIndiahavinglong-standingissueswithChina.
ItseemsthatIndiawilloptforthemostpeacefulsolution.Atpresent,nobloccancountIndiasvoteastheirsandasaneutralcountry,Indiawillbeamongthosenationswhodecidethefateofthecommittee.
RepublicofKorea(SouthKorea)
NorthKoreascontinuousmissileandnucleartestshaveledSouthKoreatosuspenditsSunshinePolicy,whichithadadopteduntil2009towardstheNorth.TheSunshinePolicywasapolicy,whichwasbasedonfriendshipbetweenthetwoKoreas.
TheRepublicofKoreaakaSouthKoreaisstronglyopposedtoNorthKoreasrocketlaunch.Itisfullyconvincedthattherocketlaunchwasacoverfortestinglong-rangeballisticmissiletechnologyandisapprehensiveaboutNorthKoreaseverincreasingnuclearandmissilearsenal.SouthKoreaisinfullsupportofallkindsofmeasurestohaltNorthKoreasadvancingmissileprogram.Tothiseffect,itsleadershiphasconfirmedfullsupporttotheUnitedStatesinanyactionittakesagainstNorthKorea.
SouthKoreahasnotdeniedthepossibilityofarmedactionagainstNorthKorea.However,atitspresentcapacitySouthKoreawoulddefinitelyneedUSaidto
achieveanykindofsuccesswithsuchanaction.ThisisbecauseSouthKoreaisnotequippedwithnuclearweapons,somethingthatbothNorthKoreaandtheUnitedStateshave.
SouthKoreaisalsocriticalaboutthesoftstancetakenbytheChineseagainsttheNorthKorea,andtheSouthKoreanPresident,addressingapressconferenceinWashingtonafterthetrilateraltalkssaid,Chinasresponseontheissuehasbeendiscouraging.Wewereexpectingastrongerreaction.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
29/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 2
9
Withthisismind,theSouthKoreanstancecanbesummarizedtosaythatitisinsupportoftheUnitedStatesandJapanandremainsfirmlyopposedtotheNorthKoreanUnha-3.
RussianFederation
Russiaplaysacriticalroleinthecommittee.RussiaisapermanentmemberoftheSecurityCouncilandisnotstronglyalignedtoanyofthetwosides.RussiahadaskedNorthKoreanottogoaheadwithitsrocketlaunchandhadexpresseddeepregretwhenitdidso.However,accordingtoTheGuardian,expertsbelievethatitisunlikelythatRussiawouldallowanyresolutionagainstNorthKorea.Russiawasamemberofthesix-partytalksthatweretakingplacetodiscussthedenuclearizationoftheKoreanpeninsula,butitwasnotincludedinthetrilateral
talks,somethingwhichRussiadidnotlookonattoofavorably.However,RussiadidnotraisethisissueandinsteadrequestedforChinasinclusionintothetalks.
TheRussianFederationclaimsthatitsstanceisneutralatpresent.Aministryspokespersonwasreportedtohavesaid,onJanuary23rd,2013,RussiamostdefinitelydoesnotsupporttheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch,butneitherdoesitsupportanyarmedactionintheKoreanpeninsula.Russiacallsforpeacefulresolutionofthecrisis.
WhenaskedtocommentaboutwhatkindofresolutionsRussiawouldvotefororvetointheSecurityCouncilsessionscheduledforthe28thand29thofJanuary,thespokespersonsaid,Wewilldecidethisonthebasisofthemeritspresentedin
Committee.Ourgovernmentisnotalignedtoanyofthetwosidesintheargument.
SocialistRepublicofVietnam
AsacommunistnationandatraditionallyofNorthKorea,VietnamdidnotcomeoutverystronglyagainsttheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch.TheVietnamesepositionagreeswiththeChineseoneaskingformoderatereactiontothelaunch.VietnamreiteratesthenecessityofstrictlyabidingbytheresolutionsoftheUnitedNationSecurityCouncil
especiallytheResolution1874forregionalandglobalpeaceandstability,saidMr.Ngh,aspokesperson.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
30/35
30 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
StateofIsrael
NorthKoreadoesnotrecognizetheexistenceofthestateofIsrael;instead,itrecognizesPalestineasasovereignnation.Besidesthis,NorthKoreahas
traditionallyhadaverycloserelationshipwithalotofIsraelsrivals,includingPakistanandIran.Ontheotherhand,theUSAhastraditionallybeenaverycloseallyofIsrael.
Withregardtothis,itisonlynaturalthatIsraelopposesNorthKoreasrocketlaunchandislikelytosupportanyactiontheUSAtakeswithregardtoNorthKorea.
StateofJapan
Japan,asthethirdnationinthetrilateraltalksheldinWashingtonisagainopposedtoNorthKoreasrocketlaunch.JapanandtheUnitedStateshavebeenworkingcloselyeversinceWorldWarIIanditseemslikelythatJapanandtheUnitedStateswillfollowasimilarpathofactionwithregardtoNorthKorea.
OnekeydifferencebetweenJapananditssupportersi.e.theUSAandtheRoKisthattheJapaneseConstitutionprohibitstheJapanesestatefromdeclaringwaragainstanynation,whichrulesoutanymilitaryaggressionagainstNorthKorea,onJapans
part.Thisarticlereads:
ARTICLE9:Aspiringsincerelytoaninternationalpeacebasedonjusticeandorder,theJapanesepeopleforeverrenouncewarasasovereignrightofthenationandthethreatoruseofforceasmeansofsettlinginternationaldisputes.(2)Toaccomplishtheaimoftheprecedingparagraph,land,sea,andairforces,aswellasotherwarpotential,willneverbemaintained.Therightofbelligerencyofthestatewillnotbe
recognized.
However,somepoliticiansoftheLiberalDemocraticParty,whichpolledthemaximumvotesin2012GeneralElections,havesuggestedamendingthisarticle,whichwouldallowJapantotakeamoreaggressivestancetowardsNorthKorea,in
lightofitslaunchofUnha-3on12thDecember.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
31/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 3
1
UnitedKingdom
TheUnitedKingdom,likesitsNATOally,USAremainsstronglyopposedtotheNorthKoreanrocketlaunch.ThoughtheUnitedKingdomdid
notattendthetrilateraltalksatWashington,HerMajestysGovernmenthavesaidthattheyshowsolidarityandsupporttowardstheirally,theUnitedStates.Theirnon-involvementinthetalkswasmainlybecauseonlytheregionalpowersattendedthetalk.
TheUnitedKingdomislikelytosupportstrictsanctionsandifnecessary,militaryinterventionwithregardtoNorthKorea.
UnitedStatesofAmerica
TheAmericanpositiononthecrisisbearsastrongresemblancetotheSouthKoreanpositionbecauseoftheirsimilarityinaims.TheUnitedStateshadtermsthelaunchasprovocativeandsaysitisabreachofUNregulations.TheWhiteHousesaid,TheinternationalcommunitymustworkinaconcertedfashiontosendNorthKoreaaclearmessagethatitsviolationsofUnitedNationsSecurityCouncilresolutionshaveconsequences.
TheU.S.Acameoutinfullsupportofthetrilateraltalks,asisevidentfromtheSecretaryofStatesstatementsayingthattheUnitedStatesisreadytoworkonly
withthosenationswhoarereadytoprosecuteNorthKoreaforitsrocketlaunch.ThisstatementwasinterpretedtobetargetedtowardsChina.TheinvitationsenttoChinalaterontojointhetalkswasunderinternationalpressure,andinanycase,wasrefusedbyChina.ChinasrefusaltojointhetalksfurthertensedtheU.S.-Chinarelations.
Asapossessorofnuclearweapons,theUnitedStateshasthecapacitytocountertheill-equippedNorthKoreanmilitary.However,itremainstobeseenwhethertheUSAisplanningonanykindofmilitaryaction.TheAmericanauthoritiesneitherdenied,norconfirmedanyrumorsregardingthis.
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
32/35
32 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
Bibliography
http://space.skyrocket.de/doc_lau/pekdosan-1.htm
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-17698438
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-17399847
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Korea_and_weapons_of_mass_destructi
on
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Korean_Armistice_Agreement
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/oct/09/northkorea
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/12/12/us-korea-north-rocket-
idUSBRE8BB02K20121212
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/dec/12/north-korea-launches-
rocket
http://www.news.com.au/world/north-koreas-launched-rocket-flew-over-
japan/story-fndir2ev-1226535265147 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/11/north-korea-rocket-launch-
2012_n_2280964.html
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5g_kjkBMPn3NQVy
auVpRxVnj9MvLQ?docId=8f410057954f47868d8abeed9e002d4f
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/northkorea/9739822/
Graphic-North-Korea-successfully-launches-three-stage-rocket.html
http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21568386-kim-jong-uns-
pyrotechnics-although-alarming-world-are-driven-chiefly-domestic
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/12/12/us-korea-north-rocket-
idUSBRE8BB02K20121212
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunshine_policy
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_9_of_the_Japanese_Constitution
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/afp_asiapacific/view/1242447/1
/.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwangmy%C5%8Fngs%C5%8Fng-3#States
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/dec/12/north-korea-rocket-
launch-condemnation
http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter5.shtml
Seth,MichaelJ.(2010).AHistoryofKorea:FromAntiquitytothePresent.Rowman&Littlefield.
Oberdorfer,Don.TheTwoKoreas.BasicBooks,p.6.
KurtM.Campbell,VicePresident,CentreforStrategicandInternational
Studies,andAltonFrye,SeniorFellow,CouncilonForeignRelations
June12,2002.CouncilonForeignRelations
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
33/35
STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL 3
3
Kim,SamualS.TheTwoKoreasandtheGreatPowers.2006Cambridge
UniversityPress.
"ResultofIraniandelegationvisittoNKoreapositive".IRNA.2007-01-23.
Retrieved2007-04-24.
NorthKoreadoesnotrecognizeIsrael.
Haggard,M(1965)."NorthKorea'sInternationalPosition"(inEnglish).
AsianSurvey(California:UniversityofCaliforniaPress)5(8):375388.
ISSN0004-4687.OCLC48536955.
"ChinaresolutelyopposesDPRK'snucleartest".XinhuaNewsAgency.Retrieved1December2010.
"TheChina-NorthKoreaRelationship",CouncilforForeignRelations,June18,2008
"Q&A:China-NorthKoreaRelationship",NewYorkTimes,July13,2006 TreatyofFriendship,Co-operationandMutualAssistancebetweenthePeople's
RepublicofChinaandtheDemocratiPeople'sRepublicofKorea,July11,
1967:ArticleII:IntheeventofoneoftheContractingPartiesbeingsubjectedtothearmedattackbyanystateorseveralstatesjointlyand
thusbeinginvolvedinastateofwar,theotherContractingPartyshall
immediatelyrendermilitaryandotherassistancebyallmeansatits
disposal.Xinhua,Chinese,DPRKleadersexchangecongratulatorymessagesonthelaunchoffriendshipyear,January1,2009.
Tisdall,Simon."WikileakscablesrevealChina'readytoabandonNorthKorea'".TheGuardian.Retrieved1December2010.
"USembassycables:China'wouldaccept'Koreanreunification".TheGuardian.Retrieved1December2010.
Foley,James.ChinaStepsUpSecurityonNorthKoreanBorder,Janes
IntelligenceReview,November1,2003. ChinaErectsMassiveFenceonN.KoreanBorderAfterTest,WorldTribune.com,October25,2006.Schafer,Sarah.ThreateningtheWholeWorld,onChinasBorderwithNorthKorea,LocalVillagersFeartheFalloutfromPyongyangsNuclearAspirations,Newsweek,October12,2006(Internetedition)
Lee,Chang-hak.ChinasTradewithN.K.ViaDandongExceedsUS$200million.KOTRA,February21,2003
RegionalCo-OperationinNortheastAsiaTheTumenRiverAreaDevelopmentProgram,1990-2000:InSearchofamodelforregionaleconomicco-operationinNortheastAsia
"Sino-NorthKoreanBridgeDealSealed",DailyNK,May11,2012. Chae-JinLee,ChinaandKorea:DynamicRelations,Stanford,TheHooverInstitutionforWar,RevolutionandPeace,StanfordUniversity,1996,pp.99-100
ChinO.Chung,PyongyangBetweenPekingandMoscow:NorthKoreasInvolvementintheSino-SovietDispute,1958-1975,TheUniversityofAlabamaPress,1978,p.120
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
34/35
34 STUDYGUIDESECURITYCOUNCIL
MinistryofForeignAffairsofthePeoplesRepublicofChina,Peking,November18th2000
"ForeignCurrencyUnitsPer1U.S.Dollar,1948-2007",WernerAntweiler,UniversityofBritishColumbia,2007
EconomicandSocialImplicationsOfChina-DPRKBordertradefor
China'sNortheast China-NorthKoreaRelations MinistryofCommerceofthePeople'sRepublicofChina "EastGermanDocumentsonKimIlSungsApril1975TriptoBeijing",NKIDPe-DossierNo.7,May2012
AssociatedPress,ChinasDefenseMinisterTravelstoNorthKorea,TheChinaPost,November23,2009
HarryS.Truman,ProclamationNo.2914,December16,1950,15
FederalRegister9029
"UStoeaseNorthKoreasanctions".BBC.2008-06-26.Retrieved2009-10-
12.
"NKoreatocloseitslonelyembassy",TheAustralian,January26,2008
"NKoreanheroinshipsunkbyjet".BBCNews.2006-03-23.Retrieved
2007-08-02.
EmbassiesinNorthKoreaeverything2.com,read2011-04-08
"TheChina-NorthKoreaRelationship",CouncilforForeignRelations,June
18,2008
OfficialwebsiteoftheFrenchNationalAssembly
AddressoftheNorthKoreandiplomaticrepresentationinFrance
http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/kims-death-will-india-north-korea-ties-
improve-159218?pfrom=home-otherstories "ResultofIraniandelegationvisittoNKoreapositive".IRNA.2007-01-23.
Retrieved2007-04-24.
BritishForeign&CommonwealthOffice-NorthKorea
"NorthKoreabendsitlikeBeckhaminUKfilmfirst".BBC.30December
2010.Retrieved30December2010.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2010/jun/08/north-korea-world-cup-
middlesbrough
Le,QuangThiem(February2005)."KoreanStudiesinVietnam".Korea
FoundationNewsletter14(1).Retrieved2007-07-09
Choe,Won-gi(2005-01-27)..JoongAngIlbo.Retrieved2007-07-09
Ku,Su-Jeong(1999-09-02)."ThesecrettragedyofVietnam".The
Hankyoreh.Retrieved2007-03-27
Bennett,RichardM.(2006-08-18)."Missilesandmadness".AsiaTimes.
Retrieved2007-03-27
-
7/30/2019 Study Guide - Security Council
35/35
Pribbenow,Merle(2003)."The'OlogyWar:technologyandideologyin
theVietnamesedefenseofHanoi,1967".JournalofMilitaryHistory67
(1):183.doi:10.1353/jmh.2003.0066
Gluck,Caroline(2001-07-27)."NKoreaadmitsVietnamwarrole".BBC
News.Retrieved2007-03-27
"NorthKoreafoughtinVietnamWar".BBCNews.2000-03-31.Retrieved
2007-03-27
"NorthKoreahonoursVietnamwardead".BBCNews.2001-07-12.
Retrieved2006-10-19
Mark Selden, Alvin Y. So (2004). War and state terrorism: the United States, Japan, and the Asia-Pacific in the long twentieth century. Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 7780. ISBN978-0-7425-2391-3.