social control and deviance original content copyright © holt mcdougal. additions and changes to...

Social Control and Deviance

Original Content Copyright © Holt McDougal. Additions and changes to the original content are the responsibility of the instructor.

Chapter 7: Social Control and Deviance

Case Study: The Saints and the Roughnecks

Section 1: Social Control

Section 2: Deviance

Section 3: Crime

Experiment: Applying What You’ve Learned



A 1973 article explored the different views that townspeople

held of two teenage gangs, one called the Saints and one

called the Roughnecks. The author of the article claimed

that even though both gangs were violent, delinquent, and

disruptive, townspeople agreed that the gang from the

higher social class was not as much trouble as the gang

from the lower social class. While objective observation

concluded that both gangs were equally destructive, the

differing views revealed much about the social

preconceptions that were at work in the town.

Case Study: The Saints and the Roughnecks



Social Control

• People generally follow social norms—and expect others to as well—because they have internalized the norms that they feel are useful and appropriate.

• When a person has not internalized a norm, society uses sanctions to motivate his or her conformity.

• Sanctions can be positive or negative, formal or informal.

• Social control is necessary to ensure that a society functions smoothly.

Section 1 at a Glance



Reading Focus• How do social norms become internalized?

• What are the differences between positive and negative sanctions and between formal and informal sanctions?

• What is social control?

Main Idea

• Norms must be followed for a society to run smoothly, and they are

enforced through internalization and sanctions.

Social Control



What if your every misdeed were posted on a Web site?



• Every society has norms that must be upheld to run smoothly.

• Internalization is the process by which a norm becomes a part of an individual’s personality, thus conditioning that individual to conform to society’s expectations.

• Examples:

– Sitting in a chair instead of on the floor

– Stopping at a red light

Internalization of Norms



Reading Check

Identify Supporting Details

What characteristics describe a norm that is likely to be internalized?

Answer: good, useful, and appropriate



Positive sanctions

• Positive sanction: An action that rewards a particular kind of behavior

• Examples include: a teacher giving good grades, cheers from teammates

Formal sanctions

• Formal sanction: A reward or punishment given by a formal organization or regulatory agency

• Examples include: schools giving high or low grades, a business giving a raise or firing a worker

Negative sanctions

• Negative sanction: A punishment or the threat of punishment used to enforce conformity.

• Examples include: a parking ticket, ridicule

Informal sanctions

• Informal sanction: A spontaneous expression of approval or disapproval given by an individual or group

• Examples include: standing ovations, gossip

Sanctions



Answer: to encourage people to follow social norms

Find the Main Idea

What is the purpose of sanctions?

Reading Check



• Social control is enforcing norms through either internal or external means.

– Primary means is self-control

– Other agents use sanctions

• Police, religious figures, family, peer group, and public opinion

• Behavior that violates society’s basic norms jeopardizes the social order.

Social Control



Answer: for society to function smoothly—social stability

Analyze

Why is social control important to society?

Reading Check



Death Penalty: The Ultimate Sanction

This sanction has been used since ancient times to punish murderers

and other criminals. Its morality is debated today. Many nations have

banned the death penalty, though the United States still allows it.

Current Research in Sociology

• Opposition to the death penalty arose during the Enlightenment, which resulted in limiting its use.

• Venezuela became the first country to ban the practice.

• By 2007, two-thirds of nations had banned the practice.

• Critics claim the practice is immoral and ineffective, and cannot be administered fairly.

• Support for the death penalty remains strong.



Thinking Critically• What does it mean when a country is considered

“abolitionist in practice”?

• Why do you think the death penalty is a focus of such debate in the United States?



Deviance

• Deviance is any behavior that violates significant social norms.

• Deviance can serve positive functions, such as clarifying norms, unifying the group, diffusing tension, promoting social change, and providing jobs.

• Functionalists, conflict theorists, and interactionists offer different theories to explain deviance.




Reading Focus• How do sociologists identify the nature of deviance?

• What are the social functions of deviance?

• How do the theories that have been proposed to explain deviance compare?

Main Idea

Deviance, which is behavior that violates social norms, serves a

purpose in society. Sociologists have many theories to explain deviant

behavior.

Deviance



Why would a teenage boy lock himself in his room and hide from society?



Behavior that violates significant social norms is called

deviance.

• Some norms deal with fairly insignificant behaviors.

• Because there are so many norms, occasional violations are unavoidable.

• Behaviors deemed deviant differ across times, cultures, and situations.

Violating Norms

The Nature of Deviance

• Individuals must be caught committing a deviant act and be stigmatized by society.

• A stigma is a mark of social disgrace that sets the deviant apart from the rest of society.

• Sociologists usually refer to the negative social reactions.

The Label of Deviance



Answer: Some behaviors are considered deviant in some situations and not others, or in one society and not another, or from time period to time period.

Analyze

How does behavior that is considered deviant change based on context?

Reading Check



Deviance has some uses in society

– Helps to clarify norms, unify the group, diffuse tension, and promote social change

– Serves to define the boundaries of acceptable behavior

– Punishment of deviance can prevent others from same deviance

– Draws lines of society and “outsiders”

– Displays of minor deviance diffuse tensions

– Provides legitimate jobs such as lawyers and police

Social Functions of Deviance



Answer: It helps to clarify norms, unify the group, diffuse tension, and promote social change. It also creates jobs, defines the boundaries of acceptable behavior, and draws the line between conforming and nonconforming members of society.

Summarize

How can deviance benefit society?

Reading Check



The three sociological perspectives explain the causes and uses of deviance.

Explaining Deviance

• Strain theory: deviance is the natural outgrowth of the values, norms, and structure of society

• Pressure on individuals to meet standards that they can’t meet

• Anomie: the norms of society are unclear or no longer apply

• Results in confusion over rules for behavior

• Five “modes of adaptation,” or reactions to societal norms

Functionalist Perspective• Conformity: acceptance of goals and

methods of reaching them

• Innovation: acceptance of goals but not means of reaching them

• Ritualism: abandon goals but maintain expected behaviors

• Retreatism: reject both goals and means of reaching them

• Rebellion: seek to substitute new goals and means for existing goals and means



Conflict Perspective

• Sees social life as a struggle between the ruling classes and lower classes

• Says people commit deviant acts to gain or maintain power

• Ruling class deems any behavior that threatens its power as deviant

Interactionist Perspective

• Three major explanations: control theory, cultural transmission theory, and labeling theory

• Control theory: states that deviance is normal and studies why people conform; states that people conform when they have strong ties to the community



• Cultural transmission theory: states that deviance is a learned behavior; deviants are socialized into deviant behavior instead of acceptable behavior; individuals will adopt the behavior and goals of whomever they are in contact with

• Differential association: the relative closeness to deviant and non-deviant individuals

• Labeling theory: focuses on how people come to be labeled “deviant;” suggests there are two types of deviance

• Primary deviance: occasional violation of norms; neither self nor society labels person “deviant”

• Secondary deviance: deviance as a lifestyle; both self and society label person “deviant”



Answer: Some focus on why individuals perform deviant acts, and others focus on how individuals come to be identified as deviants.

Contrast

How do the sociological perspectives view deviance differently?

Reading Check



Crime

• Crime affects everyone in the United States, some as victims, some as criminals, and some as observers.

• Crimes are grouped into five general categories: violent crime, property crime, victimless crime, white-collar crime, and organized crime.

• Crime statistics are gathered and reported by two main sources, the Uniform Crime Reports and the National Crime Victimization Survey.

• The criminal-justice system—made up of the police, the courts, and corrections—deals with crimes that have been committed and reported.




Reading Focus• What are crimes, and who commits them?

• What are the principal types of crime in the United States?

• How are crime statistics gathered and reported?

• What are the characteristics of the criminal-justice system?

Main Idea

There are several different types of crimes. The U.S. criminal-justice

system investigates, prosecutes, and punishes criminals.

Crime



How does the definition of crime change with time and circumstance?



• A crime is any act that is labeled as such by those in authority and is prohibited by law.

• An act that is immoral is not necessarily illegal.

• Criminals can be any age, gender, or race, although people under 35 are more likely to be involved in crime.

Crime and Criminals



Answer: the act is labeled a crime by those in authority and is prohibited by law

Find the Main Idea

What criteria are used to determine if an act is criminal?

Reading Check



Property Crime• Burglary, larceny, motor vehicle theft, and arson

• One every three seconds in the United States

• People under 25 commit most crimes

• Many crimes committed by those on drugs

Violent Crime• Murder, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault

• Make up small percentage of total crime rates, but still alarming

• One every 22 seconds in the United States

• Most victims are African Americans

• Majority of murders committed with guns

Types of Crime



Victimless Crime

• Prostitution, illegal gambling, illegal drug use, and vagrancy

• Although classified as “victimless,” often have negative consequences for society

White-Collar Crime

• White-collar crimes include fraud, tax evasion, embezzlement, price-fixing, toxic pollution, insider trading, and political corruption

• Corporations can be charged with crimes, not just individuals

Organized Crime

• Crime syndicate: a large-scale organization of professional criminals that controls some vice or legitimate business through violence

• Legitimate businesses can serve as “fronts” for illegal activities



Answer: Possible answer—victimless crime (prostitution): increased spread of contagious diseases such as STDs, increased health care costs due to sexually transmitted diseases, drug use, and violence on the streets.

Analyze

Pick one type of crime and analyze its cost to society.

Reading Check



• The Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) is published annually by the FBI.

– Uses data from local police departments

– Factors that limit reporting of crimes:

• Not all complaints make it into a formal report.

• People less likely to make a report against friend or family member.

• Police more likely to make an official report when crime is against a high-status person.

• Victims less likely to report some forms of crime.

• The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) is published by the Bureau of Justice Statistics.

– Uses data from crime victims about reported and unreported crimes

– Relies on interviews with representative sample

Crime Statistics



Answer: Individuals are less likely to report a crime if family or friends are involved. The police are more likely to file a formal report if the victim is in a higher social class.

Summarize

What circumstances may limit the filing of formal crime reports?

Reading Check



Police• Control over who is arrested

• Police discretion: the ability to decide who is actually arrested

• Racial profiling: the practice of assuming that nonwhite Americans are more likely to commit crimes

Corrections• Corrections: Imprisonment,

parole, probation, community service

• Functions: retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, social protection

• Recidivism: repeated criminal behavior

Courts• Hold trials to determine guilt or

innocence

• If guilty, assign punishments

• Plea bargaining: the process of legal negotiation that allows a guilty plea in return for a lighter sentence

Juvenile-Justice System• Young offenders cannot be

expected to be as responsible as adults

• New laws ensure juveniles receive fair treatment

• Some places treat young as adults

The Criminal-Justice System



Click on the image below to play the Interactive.



Answer: police—decide whether to arrest those who commit a crime; courts—determine the guilt or innocence of the accused and assign a punishment; corrections—carry out the punishment

Summarize

What role does each component of the criminal-justice system serve?

Reading Check



Identity Theft

Identity theft occurs when a criminal uses another person’s name and

financial standing to buy items or complete financial transactions.

Victims of identity theft often lose their financial standings because of

the crime.

Sociology in Today’s World

• Identity thieves may rent an apartment, get medical services, make large purchases, or use another’s name while being arrested.

• Federal Trade Commission estimates there are more than 9 million cases a year.

• Methods of theft include stealing wallets or phishing.

• Prevention methods include shredding documents and monitoring bank statements.



Thinking Critically• In what category of crime does identity theft belong?

• How might the different theoretical perspectives on deviance explain identity theft?



How to Be an Ethnomethodologist

What role do norms play in your everyday life?

• In this experiment, you will examine the norms you have internalized by choosing one to break.

• Ethnomethodology is the study of how people do things.

• Ethnomethodologists deliberately break norms in order to define them.

1. Introduction

Experiment: Applying What You’ve Learned

• Identify a norm you can break, resulting in unique but harmless behavior that is atypical for you.

• Once you identify a norm, break it. Observe the people around you. If possible, repeat the experiment in different settings.

• Write notes about your experience.

2. Choosing a Norm



3. Record Your Observations

• Using your notes, write a report of your experiment that answers the following questions:

• What norm did you choose?

• What setting did you choose?

• What kind of people witnessed your experiment?

• How did people respond?

• How did you feel while breaking the norm?

4. Role-play Your Experience

• In small groups, create role-playing scripts for one of the group members’ experiment.

• Choose a spokesperson to present the skit and describe the possible effects on society if others broke the same norm.

Experiment (cont.)



5. Discussion

• What did you learn from this experiment? As a group, discuss the following:

• Which norm breaking was most interesting?

• What emotions did you experience?

• Was your behavior seen by an authority figure?

• Did you experience any sanctions for your behavior?

• Did you think of yourself as deviant?

Experiment (cont.)

social control and deviance original content copyright © holt mcdougal. additions and changes to...

Documents