shared services in local government - unit4's top tips
TRANSCRIPT
33
The public sector became accustomed to expensive,
multi-year technology implementations that
often went badly wrong.
SALES & MARKETING DIRECTOR (UK & IRELAND) UNIT4 BUSINESS SOFTWARE
D A R R E N H U N T
4
In 2005 the Gershon Review called for “sharing transactional support services to achieve economies of scale through clustering with other central government bodies.”
BUT THERE WAS NO DRIVER TO DO THINGS DIFFERENTLY AND NOT A GREAT DEAL OF ACTION…
7
Buyers in local government faced and continue to face real uncertainty over
future budgets, they have to transform and divert unnecessary back office spend
to frontline services.
MANAGING DIRECTOR UNIT4 BUSINESS SOFTWARE
A N W E N R O B I N S O N
The Comprehensive Spending Review
was a hammer blowThe UK witnessed the biggest cuts since World War 2£81 billion public spending cuts in four years
Even now English councils will face an average spending-power cut of 2.9% in the year 2014-15
88
SHARED SERVICES became important
At least 337 councils across the country
are engaged in 325 shared service arrangements.
L O C A L
G O V E R N M E N T A S S O C I A T I O N
77%i G O V S U R V E Y2 0 1 3 / 1 4
considered shared services a priority to reduce costs
ACTION became imperative
9
There have been
teething problems
Once it did
A GREAT DEAL OF TAXPAYERS' MONEY HAD BEEN SPENT
start to go wrongproper governance or intervention from the Department should have rectified the problems.
enough to adapt in challenging times
and provide the best possible value
Failing to be flexible
for money.
1010
DONE CORRECTLY, SHARED SERVICES WORK.
but…We have compiled some tips to help you develop a thriving shared service; a shared service that does things right, the way Gershon envisaged.
11
GO Shared Services trims £675,000 per year off the cost of ‘back office’ functions.
NHS Camden Procurement Cooperative addresses NHS Reform and saves £2.7M in its first year.
Herefordshire County Council saves £619,000 in first year of shared services.
1212
TIP 1 Get the vision right up front
Make sure you understand why
you are launchinga shared service.This makes the
journey easier for all stakeholders.
13
Many benefits come from standardisation, therefore choose to share services
which are simpler.
We’d recommend the back office first.
Frontline servicesBack office
Simpler More complex
TIP 2 Choose the right services to share
1414
Look at the Return on Investment (RoI) using principles such as
Activity Based Costing
Using comparable service levels, at what price point does it become cost
effective for prospective clients to discard their own infrastructures and
share?
TIP 3 Do the maths
15
GO Shared Services is providing Finance, Procurement, HR and Payroll services to Cotswold District Council, Cheltenham
Borough Council, Forest of Dean District Council and West
Oxfordshire District Council.
Before the project GO Shared Services calculated £3.7M savings
over ten years. Post implementation those numbers have headed north to £675K each
year.
1616
I consider it essential that all agencies quantify both the back-office service levels and the associated costs of their current provision arrangements, and that they use this as the basisfor determining…
…what improvements can be realised through their own efforts.
S I R P E T E R G E R S H O N
17
But it’s not all about the cost
Know the cost of everything, but also know the value.
You want motivated staff… and happy customers
Shared services is an opportunity to pool knowledge, to improve services and to release capacity to enable the introduction of services that were not possible before.
HEAD OF GO SHARED SERVICESJ E N N Y P O O L E
1818
• Get buy-in from the top; political and operational leaders
• Win hearts and minds – Involve stakeholders in the process, hold workshops, implement their ideas (where sensible)
• Communicate – no nasty surprises, no unfounded rumours
• Provide training (new systems, new processes etc.) – to hit the ground running
*This is often the biggest problem for failing initiatives
TIP 4 Manage the shock*
Sharing services is a scary time for everyone, most of all
employees. HERE ARE POINTERS FROM JAMES
BOUCH, HEAD OF PUBLIC SECTOR SALES AT UNIT4:
1
2
3
4
19
TIP 5 Get your governance model in place
Make sure that at every level everybody knows
who makes the decisions.
This compels individuals and teams to be accountable - no heels will be dragged.
It speeds decision making, and ultimately helps hit deadlines faster.
U N I T 4 T E C H N O L O G Y T I PA virtual common workspace for all stakeholders will guide the flow of work and ideas to the right person at the right time, optimising collective energy and
exposing bottlenecks before they becoming problematic.
2020
TIP 6 Plan, plan, plan
Establishing a shared service is not an extracurricular activity, it’s a major undertaking.Getting the planning right sets the foundation for the future, especially when working across not just organisations and departments, but administrative regions.Get your resourcing right before the project kicks-off, you will need full -time, dedicated professionals from business operations and technology partners to contribute different skills at different times.
With change lies an opportunity to start again with a blank sheet. What does amazing look like to you? If the numbers work, go for it.
MANAGING DIRECTOR UNIT4 BUSINESS SOFTWARE
A N W E N R O B I N S O N
21
TIP 7
KISSKeep It Simple Stupid
Standardise where possible and localise where
necessary.
U N I T 4 T E C H N O L O G Y T I PTo speed up implementations use
technology that has inbuilt good practice for local government
Never in any sector have I seen speed of deployment be more important than it is in local government right now…they want day-one, maximum savings.
VP LOCAL AND DEVOLVED GOVERNMENT
BT GLOBAL SERVICES
P A U L R I N G H A M
2222
My top tip to anyone contemplating establishing a centre would be to keep it simple; make sure that the strategy is focused on the scope in question and isn’t too wide reaching, with tangible goals that are realistic and achievable.
FORMER EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR GOVERNMENT SHARED SERVICES
AT THE CABINET OFFICE
P A U L M A R R I N E R
23
You’re not just selecting a technology, you’re getting
TIP 8 Choose the right technology partners
so choose the right one.
WEDDED TO A PARTNER
2424
U N I T 4 T E C H N O L O G Y T I PChoose flexible technology: make
sure that post-implementation tech can keep pace quickly, cost
effectively and with minimum disruption to customers.
The only certainty is that there is no certainty
25
SILVERLINING
Look for a
U N I T 4 T E C H N O L O G Y T I P
SALES & MARKETING DIRECTOR (UK & IRELAND) UNIT4 BUSINESS SOFTWARE
D A R R E N H U N T Think cloud so that the services can rapidly scale for new customers, the need for ‘big-ticket’ hardware can be removed, resources can be optimised and information can be made readily available on mobile devices.
2626
Some of the most expensive shared-service disasters
stem from a lack of customers.
Change must be carefully and sensitively managed,
but users must be in no doubt that the new way of
working is to be the new way of working.
Think about promoting your shared services to other
organisations to grow members and savings – public relations, case
studies, events, and social media
can all help spread the word.
TIP 9 Mandate & market
27
The initiative for government departments to share back-office functions has suffered from an approach which made participation voluntary and tailored services to meet the differing needs of individual departments. The result was over complexity,reduced flexibility and a failure to cut costs.
HEAD OF THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICEA M Y M O R S E
2828
Don’t go with the flow, swim upstream looking for innovation.
Introduce service levels, a dashboard and a continuous
improvement programme for all processes.
Stockton and Darlington Borough Councils in the north of England for
instance have set up a Continual Service Improvement (CSI) committee
that meets each month to review progress in shared services.
TIP 10 Relentless improvement
29
However in the true spirit of advancement these
approaches will evolve further, would you like to share your experiences of
shared services?
That’s some of the lessons customers,
partners, UNIT4 and other thought leaders have
learnt.
Then use the SlideShare ‘Share’ button above to share and comment. And please do share if you found this
useful.