scale experience from cshgp's expanded impact category_waltensperger_5.1.12

25
Expanded Impact Project Malawi Newborn Health Program USAID/CSHGP 2006-11 (CS-22 Cycle) Karen Z. Waltensperger, Save the Children Thanks to Evelyn Zimba, Joby George, Tanya Guenther

Upload: core-group

Post on 13-Dec-2014

299 views

Category:

Health & Medicine


1 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Expanded Impact Project

Malawi Newborn

Health Program USAID/CSHGP

2006-11 (CS-22 Cycle)

Karen Z. Waltensperger,

Save the ChildrenThanks to Evelyn Zimba, Joby George,

Tanya Guenther

Page 2: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Newborn health in Malawi

• 2000-5 Saving Newborn Lives (SNL)-1 funded by BMGF • Developed community-based newborn care package

with MOH/RHU• Implemented by Save the Children (Mangochi) and

partners (Project Hope, Ekwendeni CCAP Mission Hospital, Kamuzu College of Nursing)

• Collaboration at national level to advance newborn health agenda in context of Safe Motherhood

Page 3: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Opportunities in late 2005

• Strong partnership with MOH/RHU and partners• National-level WILL to incorporate newborn• Uncertainty about Malawi’s inclusion as an SNL-

2 country• Opportunity to submit application to

USAID/CSHGP for CS-22 cycle Expanded Impact Project (EIP) - $2.5m + match

Page 4: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

CSHGP EIP Category• $2.5 million• Extend and build on existing, successful

programs• IMPACT AT SCALE - multi-district, sub-

national, national level• Roles

– Secretariat– Partner coordination– Convener

Page 5: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Approach

• Support for Malawi’s Road Map for Accelerated Reduction of Maternal and Neonatal Mortality

• Catalytic inputs to advance newborn health agenda in Malawi and achieve impact at scale• Technical leadership and support• Limited material assistance• Support for “mainstreamed” training• Assistance with partner coordination

Page 6: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Community Component

• Sub-grant for Ekwendeni CCAP Mission Hospital to document Agogo Approach (Mzimba District)

• Transfer lessons learnt from Institute for Child Health’s Mai Mwana randomized control trial in Mchinji District (funded by SNL-1)

Page 7: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Transition• CSHGP application submitted late 2005• Malawi SNL-2 core country (2006-11)• SNL country planning May 2006 (CBMNC

package with PNC focus, KMC)• CS-22 cooperative agreement awarded in late

June 2006 (Oct 2006-Sep 2011)• CS-22 DIP approved June 2007• CS and SNL work plans merged ($5 million

program)

Page 8: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Points of departure

• National-level indicators (from MICS, DHS)• Conundrum of baseline for Rapid CATCH—

where? • Decided not to hold DIP Workshop• MOH/RHU Deputy Director participated in DIP

Review in US

Page 9: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

SNL-2 “match” / cost share

• Develop and pilot a Community-Based Maternal and Newborn Care (CBMNC) Package

• Delivered by Health Surveillance Assistants (HSAs) in 3 districts)

• MOH, UNICEF, WHO, other partners• UNICEF to fund district-level implementation in

district pilot

Page 10: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Package contents

• ANC (3 visits), birth planning, facility delivery, PPFP, KMC (facility, ambulatory, community)

• Focus on 3 postnatal home visits during first week (days 1,2,8)

• Costing study• Community mobilization component added

(“core” groups using Community Action Cycle)

Page 11: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

PNC home visits

• 3 visits (days 1,3,8) + extra for small neonates

• Check newborn vital signs– weight, temperature, respiration

• Check for danger signs in mother and newborn

• PPFP counseling--LAM• PMTCT

Page 12: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Early lessons

• “Not about us”• “Our timeline isn’t necessarily their

timeline”• “Sometimes lead, sometimes follow—

mostly walk together”• Things happen

Page 13: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

IMNC Package

• MOH/RHU priority• Integrated Maternal & Newborn Care training

package for workers in first-line facilities• ANC, BEmONC, EmMNOC, SBA, immediate &

essential newborn care, PNC• KMC (facility, ambulatory, community)• To be accomplished before roll out of CBMNC

package

Page 14: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Piloting the CBMNC Package• National development workshop• 3 districts selected by MOH (1 per region)• 4 additional districts supported by MCHIP

(JPHIEGO & Save the Children)• Community mobilization component added using

“core” groups and Community Action Cycle• Ad hoc CBMNC TWG formed by Safe

Motherhood Sub-Committee (Sexual and Reproductive Health Technical Working Group)

Page 15: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

15

Some results at national level

• Districts where CBMNC currrently rolled out—17+/29

• Sites offering KMC—123+• First-line facilities with IMNC services

—194+ • HBB in 14 districts (target 20)

Page 16: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

CBMNC baseline & endline

• Timeline:Baseline data collection in November 2007

(Formative research, HH survey, HF survey)Training of >600 HSAs and HF staff in 22

facility catchment areas July 2008 to June 2011

Support activities (supervision, monitoring) ongoing

Endline data collection in May/June 2011 (HH survey and HF survey)

Page 17: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

0

20

40

60

80

100

≥1 ANC visit(skilled)*

≥4 ANCvisits (any)*

Facilitydelivery*

SBA* Babyw eighed at

birth*

PNC checkfor NB in 2

days*

PNC checkfor mom in 2

days*

Baseline (n=713) Endline (n=900)

Coverage of services

Missed opportunity given high facility delivery rate and relatively long duration of stay at health facilities

Page 18: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Knowledge and practices

0

20

40

60

80

100

Completebirth plan*

First bath≥6 hours*

Nothing tocord

Immediatedrying*

ImmediateBF*

ImmediateSTS

Knowledge2+ NB DS

Knowledge2+ PP DS

Baseline (n=713) Endline (n=900)

No

da

ta

No

da

ta

Page 19: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Health services assessment

• 22 health facilities and 110 HSAs interviewed• HSA findings highlight challenges to achieving

coverage of CBMNC within existing system:• Only 47% resided within their catchment area• 54% spent 3 or less days in the community in last week • 27% spent 3 or more days at the health facility in last week• Only 66% had conducted ≥1 pregnancy home visit and only

51% ≥postnatal home visit in past 3 months• Task overload?: ~40 deliveries/year = 5x40 = 200 home visits

per year (17 per month) + CCM + growth monitoring + vaccination support + watsan activities +….

Page 20: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Excerpt from Policy and Program Timeline

Annex 12A: Malawi Newborn Survival Policy and Program Timeline Pre-2000 2000-2002 2003-2004 2005-2006 2007-2008 2009-2010 National context - political, humanitarian, etc.

• Budget support from donors

• Famine/ food insecurity

• Bingu wa Mutharika elected president • Massive flooding ravaged parts of country • Famine/ food insecurity

• SWAp 1 Health Sector • Intro of subsidized farm inputs (e.g. fertilizer, seeds, insecticides)

• Bingu wa Mutharika re-elected

Newborn survival increasingly incorporated at national level in macro policies, strategies, and plans (health sector MNCH - not NEWBORN specific)

Nat

iona

l pol

icies, strat

egie

s, p

lans

, and

mile

ston

es

• Safe Motherhood Initiative (1994) • Safe Motherhood Task Force (est. 1992) • National Strategic Plan to reduce maternal mortality (1995) • Reproductive Health Unit established (1997) • HSAs - government salaried cadre of community health workers linked to health facilities

• National Reproductive Health Policy (2002) • Gov't of Malawi commits to MDGs •Change in policy for Nurse and Midwife Technicians to provide BEmOC • Restructuring of HMIS started (2001) •Transportation improvements • Service Level Agreement (SLA) MOH subsidies CHAM to provide free services for mothers and newborns (2002)

•Essential Health Package launched (2002) funded through SWAp •Drafting of Essential Newborn Care Package (May 2003) • PMTCT introduced (2003) • Motivation training cadre - doubling of intake in training institution • Free ARVs (2004) • Introduction of Emergency Human Resource Programme (2004)

• Developed “Road Map for Accelerated Reduction of Maternal and Neonatal Mortality and Morbidity” which then linked to EHP • Revised National Reproductive Health Strategy 2006-2010 (newborn incorporated) • New Roles for TBAs assessment completed (August 2006)

• Official launch of Road Map with increased funding (March 2007) • Official role of TBAs shifted to promotion of skilled attendants at delivery (March 2008) fully implemented across Malawi by January 2009 • ANC routine HIV testing (2008) • Community IMCI (2007) •Adopted 5-year plan for ACSD and cIMCI including newborn (2007)

• CBMNC package endorsed by MOH/ RHU for scale up to all districts (2010) • Reproductive Health Policy and Strategy revised • Policy for introduction of ARVs to pregnant women regardless of CD4 count • Emergency Human Resource Programme e.g. Recruitment of 4000 new HSAs • Co-trim prophylaxis as part of PMTCT for exposed infants • Community midwife nurse program initiated by First Lady and Calista Muthalika Foundation (2010). First training of community midwifes (Feb 2011)

Page 21: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Excerpt from Scale upReadiness Benchmarks

No. Benchmark Definition 2000 Ranking

2005 Ranking

2010 Ranking

Year

1 National level NB health needs assessment/ Situational Analysis conducted

Formal assessment of NB health, child health, and safe motherhood programs and strategies conducted in collaboration with MOH and other partners

No Yes Yes 2002

2 NB health services/ packages tested and documented in local settings

Research studies conducted in collaboration with the MOH and/ or partners/ research institutions to test NB health services/ packages in local settings

No No Partial

3 Evidence of NB health interventions/ packages disseminated at provincial/ district and national levels

At least one national level meeting with key partners and stakeholders (dissemination of research findings or strategy) to discuss evidence of at least one priority NB health intervention (thermal care, BF, clean delivery, early home PNC visits)

No No No 2010

4 Technical working/ advocacy group established and advocating for NB health through consensus building OR existing working/ advocacy groups integrated newborn health into terms of reference

National level technical working/ advocacy groups with representation from key stakeholders, partners, donors, and community members established and advocating for NB health through consensus building OR existing working/ advocacy groups integrated newborn health in terms of reference

No No Yes 2007

5 Focal person for NB health established in MOH on NB health

Focal person to provide technical input on newborn health programs established within the MOH

No No Yes 2010

6 National NB policy/ strategy strengthened and adopted by MOH

National policy and/ or strategy on newborn health strengthened and adopted by MOH

No Yes Yes 2005

7 National NB policy/ strategy integrated into existing programs

National NB policy/ strategy integrated into at least one existing national health program (child, maternal, reproductive, IMCI, etc)

No Partial Yes 2005

8 National essential drugs and supply list for newborn care developed and endorsed by MOH

National essential drugs and supply list for newborn care developed and endorsed by MOH

Partial Partial Partial 2001

9 National behavior change communication strategy for NB health established and endorsed by MOH

National behavior change communication strategy for NB health established OR national behavior change communication strategy integrates newborn and endorsed by MOH. Key elements include: BCC messages, BCC materials, Modes of communication, community mobilization; At least 3 messages include: thermal care, early and exclusive breastfeeding, clean delivery, early PNC visits.

No Partial Partial

Page 22: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Health Policy and Planning articlefor upcoming newborn health supplement

Page 23: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Unintended results

• Save the Children partner on 2 of 3 USAID newly launched bilateral projects Support for Service Delivery Integration (SSDI-Services and SSDI-Communication)

• Technical lead for Child Health (includes newborn), Nutrition, Community Approaches on SSDI-Services

• Supports implementation in 6 Southern districts• Lead for Community Mobilization on SSDI-

Communication

Page 24: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Mwayi wa Moyo (“A Chance to Live”)

• Integration key objective of Malawi’s HSSP (2011-2016)

• CS-27 cycle (2011-2016)• Blantrye District • MOH (RHU, IMCI Unit, PHC Unit)• College of Medicine (OR partner)• Purposefully integrated community-package

incorporating CBMNC+CCM+PPFP

Page 25: Scale Experience from CSHGP's Expanded Impact Category_Waltensperger_5.1.12

Thank you!