s02v02p01 - app...forecasting methods - summary of results of all methods studied - 2012$ (000) 2...
TRANSCRIPT
An EDISON INTERNATIONAL® Company
(U 338-E)
2015 General Rate Case APPLICATION
Workpapers
Generation Mountainveiw \SCE-02 Volume 08
N ovem ber 2013
2015 General Rate Case - APPLICATION INDEX OF WORKPAPERS
EXHIBIT SCE-02, Vol 8 / Generation - Mountainview
DOCUMENT PAGE(S)
MOUNTAINVIEW O&M ACCOUNTSAccount 549: Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses 1-20Account 554: Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
21-42
2013 Major Inspections Non-CSA Non-Labor Costs 43-45General Electric Contract Service Agreement 46-47Mountainview Combustion Turbine Operating Hours 2012-2014 47a2013 Major Inspection Overhaul Non-Labor Expense 48Account 554 Forecast Adjustments 49Accounts: 546, 548, 550, 553, 501, 509, 547, 555, 557 50-142
MOUNTIANVIEW CAPITALCapital Expenditures Forecast 144-145Project Detail Worksheets 146-155
Other (relevant pages):CPUC Decision No. 09-03-025 regarding A.07-11-011 157-160CPUC Decision No. 04-07-022 regarding A.02-05-004 161-164CPUC Decision No. 06-05-016 regarding A.04-12-014 165-166Exhibit SCE-01 from A.13-04-011 167-171
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION1
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor Last Recorded Year 3,790 3,790
Non-Labor Last Recorded Year 4,491 4,491
Other N/A 0 0
Total 8,281 8,281
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost o f labor, m aterials used and expenses incurred in the operation o f M ountainview Generating Station which are not specifically provided fo r or are not readily assignable to other Mountainview generating station activities.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in th is activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
2Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activ ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
I Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 22 371 1,229 1,206 1,281
Non-Labor 8,512 3,340 9,879 7,399 5,891
Other 0____________0____________0___________ 0___________ 0
Total 8,534 3,711 11,108 8,605 7,172
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) - see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor 2,806 2,914 2,187 2,190 2,509
N on-Labor (731) 2,648 (5,428) (3,028) (1,400)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2,075 5,562 (3,241) (838) 1,109
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 2,828 3,285 3,416 3,396 3,790
N on-Labor 7,781 5,988 4,451 4,371 4,491
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 10,609 9,273 7,867 7,767 8,281
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
Other 10000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstan t 2012$)
Labor 3,228 3,637 3,655 3,507 3,790
Non-Labor 8,467 6,475 4,737 4,482 4,491
Other____________________________ 0___________ 0____________0___________ 0___________ 0_Total 11,695 10,112 8,392 7,989 8,281
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4.000
2.000
0
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Recorded A d jus ted 2008-2012 (2012$)
I I I2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
3Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecasting Methods - Summary o f Results o f all Methods Studied - 2012$ (000)
2 Recorded Years (2011 -2012):Results of Averaging (A2)
2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,649 3,649 3,649 141 no
Non-Labor 4,486 4,486 4,486 5 no
Other 0 0 0 0 no
Total 8,135 8,135 8,135 n/a n/a
3 Recorded Years (2010 - 2012):Results of Linear Trending (T3) Results of Averaging (A3)
2013 2014 2015 r2* Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,786 3,853 3,920 0.23 no 3,651 3,651 3,651 116 no
Non-Labor 4,324 4,201 4,079 0.72 no 4,570 4,570 4,570 118 no
Other 0 0 0 0.00 no 0 0 0 0 no
Total 8,110 8,054 7,999 n/a n/a 8,221 8,221 8,221 n/a n/a
4 Recorded Years (2009 - 2012):Results of Linear Trending (T4) Results of Averaging (A4)
2013 2014 2015 r2* Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,725 3,757 3,788 0.12 no 3,647 3,647 3,647 100 no
Non-Labor 3,494 2,873 2,253 0.70 no 5,046 5,046 5,046 831 no
Other 0 0 0 0.00 no 0 0 0 0 no
Total 7,219 6,630 6,041 n/a n/a 8,693 8,693 8,693 n/a n/a
5 Recorded Years (2008 - 2012):Results of Linear Trending (T5) Results of Averaging (A5)
2013 2014 2015 r2* Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,862 3,961 4,061 0.55 no 3,563 3,563 3,563 190 no
Non-Labor 2,747 1,752 758 0.82 no 5,730 5,730 5,730 1,557 no
Other 0 0 0 0.00 no 0 0 0 0 no
Total 6,609 5,713 4,819 n/a n/a 9,293 9,293 9,293 n/a n/a
Other Methods:
Last Recorded Year (LRY) Itemized Forecast (IF)
Labor
Non-LaborOther
Total
2013 2014 2015 Chosen 2013 2014 2015 Chosen
3,790 3,790 3,790 yes
4,491 4,491 4,491 yes 0 0 0 no
0 0 0 no
0 0 0 no 0 0 0 no
8,281 8,281 8,281 n/a 0 0 0 n/a
Forecast Adjustm ents:Base Forecast Method Adjustments*'
Labor
Non-LaborOther
Total
Method 2013 2014 2015 2013 2014 2015
LRY 3,790 3,790 3,790
LRY 4,491 4,491 4,491 N/A 0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
8,281 8,281 8,281 0 0 0
* r2 = R Squared (Based on recorded years data)** sd = standard deviation (Based on recorded years data)*** See Appendix B For Additional Detail
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
4Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Results:
Forecasting Results
Method Selected 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | |
Labor Last Recorded Year 3,790 3,790 3,790
Non-Labor Last Recorded Year 4,491 4,491 4,491
Other N/A 0 0 0
Total 8,281 8,281 8,281
Analysis o f Forecasting Methods
Analysis of Linear Trending Method:In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that if costs have shown a trend in a certain direction over three or more years, the last year recorded is an appropriate base estimate. Excluding the 2008 and 2009 maintenance outage years, the 2010-2012 years do not show a trend fo r labor or non-labor. For th is account, labor and non-labor costs fo r 2010-2012 have been relatively stable, so the last year recorded provides our base fo r estimating test year 2015 (see below).
Analysis of Averaging Method:In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that fo r those accounts which have significant fluctuations in recorded expenses from year to year, an average o f recorded expenses is appropriate. During the last three years, the recorded costs in th is account have not fluctuated significantly from year to year, so an average is not an appropriate forecast.
Analysis of Last Recorded Year (2012):In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that if recorded expenses in an account have been relatively stable fo r three or more years, the last recorded year is an appropriate base estimate. Labor and non-labor expenses fo r 2010-2012 have been stable, therefore the use o f the last year recorded provides our base fo r estimating test year 2015.
Analysis of Itemized Forecast Method:Not applicable.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION5
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded 2008-2012 / Forecast 2013-2015 2012$ (000)
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4.000
2.000
0
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Cither (not escl)
I I I I2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Recorded Period$ (000 )
Forecast Expenses (constant 2012$) 2 0 0 8 | 2 0 0 9 | 2 0 1 0 | 2011 | 201 2 2 0 1 3 | 2 0 1 4 | 201 5Labor (standard escalation) 3,228 3,637 3,655 3,507 3,790 3,790 3,790 3,790
Non-Labor (standard escalation) 8,467 6,475 4,737 4,482 4,491 4,491 4,491 4,491
Other (not escalatable) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 11,695 10,112 8,392 7,989 8,281 8,281 8,281 8,281
Labor Prior year Total 3,790 3,790 3,790
Change 0 0 0
Total 3,790 3,790 3,790 3,790
Non-Labor Prior year Total 4,491 4,491 4,491
Change 0 0 0
Total 4,491 4,491 4,491 4,491
Other Prior year Total 0 0 0
Change 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0
Total Change
Labor 0 0 0
Non-Labor 0 0 0
Other 0 0 0
Total N/A 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
6_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION7
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
8Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activity: 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers__________________
•SUMMARY FINANCIAL SERVICES MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred in connection with operation, supervision and engineering not specifically applicable to other operation function activities. Other tasks include annual budget development, coordinate department goal setting and performance tracking, preparing department business plan and long-range maintenance plan, coordinating departmental workforce attrition planning, managing department participation in regulatory proceedings, coordinating departmental regulatory and safety compliance activities, evaluating impacts of potential changes to SCE fossil and hydro generating, maintain department policies, and coordinating departmental participation in company - workers' union activities (e.g., contract negotiations). This final cost center is applicable to Steam, Hydroelectric, Coal and other power generation.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGDirect entries for cost element mapping made by Corporate Regulatory Accounting .
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred for calibration and maintenance of Continuous Emissions Monitoring Systems (CEMS). Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE ADMINISTRATIONBALANCE OF PLANTIncludes payroll, automotive, and other expenses incurred in installing and operating emission control systems for generation. Includes costs for Air Quality Management District permit fees. Includes payroll and other costs incurred in repairing miscellaneous equipment in and about the generation plant which is available for general use. Includes such items such as compressors, cranes, foundations, station maintenance equipment, and ventilation equipment. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT -MAINTENANCE UNIT 4Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred for calibration and maintenance of Continuous Emissions Monitoring Systems (CEMS). Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201240 OPERATIONS SUPPORT 8. PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT - MOUNTAINVIEW 546OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERINGIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred in connection with operation, supervision and engineering not specifically applicable to other operation function activities. Other tasks include annual budget development, coordinating department goal setting and performance tracking, preparing department business plan and long-range maintenance plan, coordinating departmental workforce attrition planning, managing department participation in regulatory proceedings, coordinating departmental regulatory and safety compliance activities, evaluating impacts of potential changes to SCE power generating, maintaining department policies, and coordinating departmental participation in company - workers' union activities (e.g., contract negotiations).
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION9
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activity: 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers___________________
F201306
F201307
F201314
F201316
F201324
F201333
F201336
F201337
MOUNTAINVIEW 548 GENERATION EXPENSE - CONVERSION ONLYIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs in relation to operation of the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG), turbines, generators, and electrical systems and associated equipment; to water/chemistry management; to the air-quality system, including monitoring, and reporting. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - CONVERSION ONLYIncludes the cost of engineering labor and expenses incurred in the general supervision, direction, and support of the maintenance of Department Generating Stations. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 920 ADMINISTRATION & GENERAL SALARIESIncludes the compensation (salaries and other consideration for services) of officers, executives, and other employees of the utility properly chargeable to utility operations and not chargeable directly to a particular operating function. (Discontinued in 2010). Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 550 RENTS - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes all rents of property of others used, occupied, or operated in connection with other power generation.
MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, other costs for general supervision an administration of day to day activities by managers and supervisors. Includes administrative support activities, reporting, and services. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs involved in system operation coordination, equipment operation/monitoring, and operating procedures development in relation to the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) system, the prime mover system, the generator system, and the auxiliary electrical system. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION 8. ENGINEERINGIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs of shift supervisors and operating foreman incurred in connection with supervision of station operation not specifically applicable to other operation activities. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, other costs for general supervision of administrative support activities; repair and purchase of minor tools; and the formal training of operation personnel. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
10Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activity: 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers___________________
F201343
F201344
F201345
F525183
F525417
F525506
F526237
MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATION SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for engineering related to the technical support and analysis of station activities; air-quality monitoring and reporting; effluent water quality control and reporting; and hazardous material control. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 548 GENERATION EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs in relation to water/chemistry management, control, testing and analysis for plant systems. Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs for air-quality monitoring, reporting and record maintenance. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for the administration and support activities for the safety program and development; industrial hygiene; safety training; noise control program; water effluent quality control; and, hazardous material control. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
549 MISCELLANEOUS OTHER POWER GENERATION EXPENSES - EH&SThis account includes the cost of labor, materials and expenses incurred for environmental, health, and safety activities relating to other power generating stations, costs which are not specifically provided for or are not readily assignable to other generation expense accounts.
POWER GENERATIONThis account includes the cost of labor, materials used and expenses incurred in the other operation of power generating stations which are not specifically provided for or are not readily assignable to other generation expense accounts.
MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR AND ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for engineering related to the technical support and analysis of station activities; air-quality monitoring and reporting; effluent water quality control and reporting; and hazardous material control.
BUSINESS PLANNING 8. DEVELOPMENT - MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERINGIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred in connection with operation, supervision and engineering not specifically applicable to other operation function activities. Other tasks include, annual budget development, coordinate department goal setting and performance tracking, prepare department business plan and long-range maintenance plan, coordinate departmental workforce attrition planning, manage department participation in regulatory proceedings, coordinate departmental regulatory and safety compliance activities, evaluate impacts of potential changes to Southern California Edison (SCE) power generating, maintain department policies, and coordinate departmental participation in company - workers union activities (e.g., contract negotiations).
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION11
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activ ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY FINANCIAL SERVICES MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
1,096 460 389 398 447
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
563 0 0 0 0
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - 174 100 105 69 68
•SUMMARY
•SUMMARY
F201240
F201306
F201307
F201314
F201316
F201324
F201333
F201336
F201337
F201343
F201344
F201345
F525183
MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
OPERATIONS SUPPORT & PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT - MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - CONVERSION ONLY
MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - CONVERSION ONLY
MOUNTAINVIEW 920 ADMINISTRATION & GENERAL SALARIES
MOUNTAINVIEW550 RENTS - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATION SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
549 MISCELLANEOUS OTHER POWER GENERATION EXPENSES - EH&S
2,305 2,757
11
114
0
0
183
144
221
205
(17) 17
853 1,017
32
397 116
444 714
1,729
17
0
0
0
4
(1)
878
77
306
4,944 4,249 3,402
459
1,550
0
0
0
3
0
789
179
370
3,087
543
0
1,594
0
0
0
16
0
776
54
250
3,252
589
0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
3 2 2
9 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
12Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activ ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F525417 POWER GENERATION 0 0 46 22 1
F525506 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR AND ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
261 145 0 0 0
F526237 BUSINESS PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT- MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
0 288 971 977 1,232
Total 11,693 10,112 8,391 7,989 8,281
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION13
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
14Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor 2,806 2,914 2,187 2,190 2,509 0 0 0Non-Labor (731) 2,648 (5,428) (3,028) (1,400) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2,075 5,562 (3,241) (838) 1,109 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final cost centers included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because all recorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement Balancing Account (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would be refunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 1,221 715 0 0 0 0 0 0 Non-Labor 2,264 1,480 0 0 0 0 0 0 Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 3,485 2,195 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-JAB-CW-HAZWASTE
This ratemaking adjustment removes hazardous waste expenses (Manufactured Gas Plants, certain FederalSuperfund sites, and certain other non-T&D sites) which are recorded and recovered through the Hazardous WasteBalancing Account.
Labor (10) (1) 0 (2) (3) 0 0 0Non-Labor (7,632) (3,196) (8,939) (6,372) (4,915) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (7,642) (3,197) (8,939) (6,374) (4,918) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 3 GRC-MJP-CW-OTM HAZWASTE
To remove one-time hazardous waste expenses for which SCE is not seeking recovery in the General Rate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (55) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (55) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 549
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 546, 548, and 550 to FERC 549.
Labor 1,594 1,700 2,187 2,192 2,512 0 0 0Non-Labor 5,524 4,364 3,511 3,344 3,515 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 7,118 6,064 5,698 5,536 6,027 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION15
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment corrects an account ing error.
Labor 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ADJST LABOR OUT OF RENT
Labor was incorrectly recorded in activity 550 - Mountainview. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 4 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ADJ EMISSION FEES
There was an accounting conversion error regarding emission fees that were incorrectly recorded. This adjustmentcorrects the error.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (106) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (106) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 5 GBU-CPT-OU-MV HISTORICAL SETTLEMENT ADJ
There was an incorrect settlement issue in last quarter of 2008 that incorrectly recorded costs in activity 549 -Mountainview. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (725) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (725) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
16_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION17
FERC Account:
Activ ity :
Witness:
549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX C
Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
18Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
‘ Summary Final Cost Centers:
FINANCIAL SERVICES MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
F201227 F201228
MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGF900546 F900548 F900549 F900550
MOUNTAINVIEW 548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
F201319 F201330
MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
F201315 F525482
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
F201322 F201323
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION19
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
Activity: 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Individual Final Cost Centers:
F201240 F201306 F201307 F201314 F201316 F201324 F201333 F201336 F201337
F201344 F201345 F525183 F525417 F525506 F526237
F201343
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
20Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 549 Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 549 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION21
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor Last Recorded Year Adj. 3,718 3,945
Non-Labor Itemized Forecast Adj. 6,652 9,852
Other Itemized Forecast 12,409 28,185
Total 22,779 41,982
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost o f labor, materials, used and expenses incurred in maintenance of Mountainview Generating Station plant and the book cost o f which is includible in M iscellaneous Power Plant Equipment.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in this activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
22Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activ ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
I Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 34 260 486 533 560
Non-Labor 59 417 716 2,158 2,417
Other 0___________ 0____________0___________ 0___________0
Total 93 677 1,202 2,691 2,977
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) - see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor 2,905 3,650 3,051 3,076 3,158
N on-Labor 8,066 11,470 7,872 6,397 4,235
O ther 22,648 23,991 10,528 8,328 12,409
Total 33,619 39,111 21,451 17,801 19,802
Recorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 2,939 3,910 3,537 3,609 3,718
N on-Labor 8,125 11,887 8,588 8,555 6,652
O ther 22,648 23,991 10,528 8,328 12,409
Total 33,712 39,788 22,653 20,492 22,779
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
Other 10000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor
N on-Labor
O ther
Total
3,355 4 ,328 3 ,785 3 ,727 3,718
8,841 12,855 9,139 8 ,772 6,652
22,648 23,991 10,528 8 ,328 12,409
34,844 41,174 23,452 20,827 22,779
45.000
40.000
35.000
30.000
25.000
20.000
15.000
10.000
5,000
0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
■■ ■ ■ ■. .
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION23
FE R C A cco u n t: 5 5 4 M aintenance of M iscellaneous O ther Pow er G eneration Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - M O U N T A IN V IE W
W itness : Anthony J. Kurpakus
Fo re c a s tin g M ethod s - S u m m ary o f R esu lts o f all M ethods S tu d ied - 2012$ (000)
2 R eco rd ed Y ears (2011 -2 0 1 2 ):
Results of Averaging (A2)
2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,723 3,723 3,723 5 no
Non-Labor 7,712 7,712 7,712 1,060 no
Other 10,369 10,369 10,369 2,041 no
Total 21,804 21,804 21,804 n/a n/a
3 R eco rd ed Y ears (2010 - 2012):
Results of Linear Trending (T3) Results of Averaging (A3)
2013 | 2014 | 2015 | r2* | Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,677 3,643 3,610 0.85 no 3,743 3,743 3,743 30 no
Non-Labor 5,701 4,457 3,214 0.86 no 8,188 8,188 8,188 1,096 no
Other 12,303 13,243 14,184 0.21 no 10,422 10,422 10,422 1,668 no
Total 21,681 21,343 21,008 n/a n/a 22,353 22,353 22,353 n/a n/a
4 R eco rd ed Y ears (2009 - 2012):
Results of Linear Trending (T4) Results of Averaging (A4)
Labor
Non-LaborOther
Total
2013 2014 2015 r2* Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
3,417 3,228 3,040 0.69 no
4,611 2,713 816 0.90 110 4,578 883 (2,812) 0.47 no
3,890 3,890 3,890 255 no
9,354 9,354 9,354 2,233 no 13,814 13,814 13,814 6,051 no
12,606 6,824 1,044 n/a n/a 27,058 27,058 27,058 n/a n/a
5 R eco rd ed Y ears (2008 - 2012):
Results of Linear Trending (T5) Results of Averaging (A5)
2013 2014 2015 r2* Chosen 2013 2014 2015 sd** Chosen
Labor 3,820 3,833 3,845 0.00 no 3,783 3,783 3,783 313 no
Non-Labor 6,713 5,867 5,021 0.36 no 9,252 9,252 9,252 2,008 no
Other 4,739 1,124 (2,490) 0.63 no 15,581 15,581 15,581 6,463 no
Total 15,272 10,824 6,376 n/a n/a 28,616 28,616 28,616 n/a n/a
O th er M ethod s:
Last Recorded Year (LRY) Itemized Forecast (IF)
Labor
Non-LaborOther
Total
2013 | 2014 | 2015 | | Chosen 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | | Chosen
3,718 3,718 3,718 yes 0 0 0 no
6,652 6,652 6,652 no 8,351 8,351 8,351 yes12,409 12,409 12,409 no 13,427 15,152 28,185 yes
22,779 22,779 22,779 n/a 21,778 23,503 36,536 n/a
F o recast A d ju stm e n ts :
Base Forecast Method Adjustments*'
Labor
Non-LaborOther
Total
Method 2013 2014 2015 2013 2014 2015
LRY 3,718 3,718 3,718
IF 8,351 8,351 8,351 IF 13,427 15,152 28,185
0 0 227
19,596 0 1,501 0 0 0
25,496 27,221 40,254 19,596 0 1,728
r2 = R Squared (Based on recorded years data) sd = standard deviation (Based on recorded years data) See Appendix B For Additional Detail
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
*
24Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activ ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Results:
Forecasting Results
Method Selected 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | |
Labor Last Recorded Year Adj. 3,718 3,718 3,945
Non-Labor Itemized Forecast Adj. 27,947 8,351 9,852
Other Itemized Forecast 13,427 15,152 28,185
Total 45,092 27,221 41,982
Analysis o f Forecasting Methods
Analysis of Linear Trending Method:In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that if costs have shown a trend in a certain direction over three or more years, the last year recorded is an appropriate base estimate. The 2008-2012 years do not show a trend fo r labor or non-labor. Labor costs fo r 2010-2012 have been relatively stable, so the last year recorded provides our base fo r estimating test year 2015 (see analysis o f last recorded year below). For other expenses, see itemized forecast below.
Analysis of Averaging Method:In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that fo r those accounts which have significant fluctuations in recorded expenses from year to year, an average o f recorded expenses is appropriate. The non-labor recorded costs in th is account have fluctuated significantly from year to year, so an average is an appropriate forecast fo r our base estimate fo r non-labor for the test year 2015. We exclude 2009 from the average because it is a high expense overhaul year, which makes this an Itemized forecast as shown below. To th is base we add adjustm ents fo r maintenance outages in 2013 and 2016. For other expenses, see itemized forecast below.
Analysis of Last Recorded Year (2012):In D. 04-07-022 and D. 89-12-057, the CPUC stated that if recorded expenses in an account have been relatively stable fo r three o r more years, the last recorded year is an appropriate base estimate. Labor expenses fo r 2010-2012 have been stable; therefore the use o f the last year recorded provides our base fo r estimating test year 2015. To th is base we add an adjustment fo r the maintenance outage in 2016. For o ther expenses, see itemized forecast below.
Analysis of Itemized Forecast Method:The appropriate average fo r non-labor is 2008 through 2012, less 2009 because it w as a higher expense overhaul year. M aintenance outages are planned fo r 2013 and 2016. The additional non-labor expense forecasted fo r these outages is added to the base forecast fo r non-labor. For the 2015 test year, expenses are levelized fo r 2015-2017.
M ountainview m aintains a contract Service Agreem ent (CSA) with General E lectric fo r the gas turbines utilized at the power plant. The CSA provides its own escalation and is therefore categorized other expense. The other expenses are forecast from recorded am ounts per a CSA w orkpaper that indicates details fo r 2013-2017. Expenses fo r test year 2015 are levelized from 2015-2017.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION25
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded 2008-2012 / Forecast 2013-2015 2012$ (000)
50.00045.00040.00035.00030.00025.00020.00015.00010.000 5,000
0
□ Labor (std escl) | Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Recorded Period$ (00 0 )
Forecast Expenses (constant 2012$) 2 0 0 8 | 2 0 0 9 | 2 0 1 0 | 2011 | 201 2 2 0 1 3 | 2 0 1 4 | 2 0 1 5Labor (standard escalation) 3,355 4,328 3,785 3,727 3,718 3,718 3,718 3,945
Non-Labor (standard escalation) 8,841 12,855 9,139 8,772 6,652 27,947 8,351 9,852
Other (not escalatable) 22,648 23,991 10,528 8,328 12,409 13,427 15,152 28,185
Total 34,844 41,174 23,452 20,827 22,779 45,092 27,221 41,982
Labor Prior year Total 3,718 3,718 3,718
Change 0 0 227
Total 3,718 3,718 3,718 3,945
Non-Labor Prior year Total 6,652 27,947 8,351
Change 21.295 (19.596) 1.501
Total 6,652 27,947 8,351 9,852
Other Prior year Total 12,409 13,427 15,152
Change 1.018 1.725 13.033
Total 12,409 13,427 15,152 28,185
Total Change
Labor 0 0 227
Non-Labor 21,295 (19,596) 1,501
Other 1,018 1,725 13,033
Total N/A 22,313 (17,871) 14,761
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
26Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
This page shows the changes in Labor, Non-Labor, and Other expenditures forecast during 2013 through 2015, including reasons for the addition of personnel (labor), increased office supplies required due to an increase in activity (non-labor).
2012 -2 0 1 3
Labor: 0
Not applicable.
Non-Labor: 21,295
Major Inspection (Ml) overhaul this Year additional General Electric Contractual Services Agreement (CSA) costs & contracts for balance of plant (BOP) inspection & repairs.
Other: 1,018
Increase in CSA fees for Annual fees and Major Outage fees for Ml overhaul.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION27
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
This page shows the changes in Labor, Non-Labor, and Other expenditures forecast during 2013 through 2015, including reasons for the addition of personnel (labor), increased office supplies required due to an increase in activity (non-labor).
2013 -2014
Labor: 0
Not applicable.
Non-Labor: (19,596)
No major inspection overhaul this year.
Other: 1,725
Increase in CSA fees for annual fees change from Tier 1 to Tier 2 an increase of almost 48%.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
28Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
This page shows the changes in Labor, Non-Labor, and Other expenditures forecast during 2013 through 2015, including reasons for the addition of personnel (labor), increased office supplies required due to an increase in activity (non-labor).
2014 -2015___________________________________________________________________________________
Labor: 227
Increase in expense due to HGPI overhaul, expenses levelized over 2015-2017.
Non-Labor: 1,501
Increase in expense due to HGPI overhaul, expenses levelized over 2015-2017.
Other: 13,033
Increase in CSA fees for annual fees and major outage fees for HGPI overhaul, expenses levelized over 2015-2017.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION29
FERC Account:
Activ ity :
W itness:
554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
30Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activity: 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers__________________
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, AND 550OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGEntries for cost element mapping made by Corporate Regulatory Accounting.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCEOF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for major maintenance, repairs, and improvements of structures, facilities, and grounds, general lighting and ventilation, sump pumps, yard drainage, water supply, hydrants, wells, elevators. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURESIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for major maintenance, repairs, and improvements of structures, facilities, and grounds, general lighting and ventilation, sump pumps, yard drainage, water supply, hydrants, wells, and elevators. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT -MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for repair and maintenance on the fuel gas system and associated equipment; the electrical distribution and auxiliary electrical systems with associated equipment; the Distributed control system and associated Ovation, Mark series turbine controls; and the water treatment system and associated equipment. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT -MAINTENANCE UNIT 3Includes labor, material, contract and other costs for maintenance on the gas turbine and generator system; the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) system; the fuel gas system; the water treatment system; the electrical distribution system; the condensate and feedwater system; the cooling water system; the circulating water system; the auxiliary electrical system; the distributed control system and associated devices; and the air quality control equipment; and overhaul costs for previously stated equipment that cannot be done during regularly scheduled annual outages. Also includes costs associated with vendor contractual agreement covering the gas turbine and steam turbine generators. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT -MAINTENANCE UNIT 4Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs incurred for calibration and maintenance of Continuous Emissions Monitoring Systems (CEMS). Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERALIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for repair and maintenance of service air compressors and equipment associated with the plant air system and the fire protection system equipment and its associated equipment. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION31
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activity: 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers____________________________
F201311 MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERAL AND ELECTRICALIncludes the cost of engineering labor and expenses incurred in the general supervision, direction, and support of the maintenance of the distribution system. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201317 MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE STRUCTURE - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OFPLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs relating to administrative areas in maintenance, repairs, and improvements of structures, facilities, and grounds, general lighting and ventilation. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201318 MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - ADMINISTRATIONBALANCE OF PLANTIncludes material cost of all miscellaneous general materials that cannot otherwise be identified, planned, and recorded to specific activities, relating to the administrative area. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201325 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs of foremen, planners, and maintenance engineers in the direct supervision of routine maintenance of structures, turbines, boilers, and auxiliary equipment not specifically applicable to other maintenance. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201328 MOUNTAINVIEW STATION EXPENSESIncludes payroll, automotive, and other expenses incurred in the management, supervision, general operation, and general maintenance of substation equipment at the Mountainview Generating Station.
F201332 MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - OPERATIONSIncludes labor, materials used and expenses incurred in maintenance of other power generation plant, the book costs of which is includible in account 346.
F201334 MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT -OPERATIONS UNIT 4Includes labor, material, contract, and other costs relating to operation and minor maintenance on the gas turbine, steam turbine, generator systems and associated equipment; the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) system and associated equipment; and the Distributed, Ovation, and Mark service.
F201338 MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE STRUCTURE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs relating to operation and minor maintenance of structures, facilities, and grounds. Relates to costs associated with general lighting, ventilation, sump pumps, yard lighting/drainage, water supply, hydrants, wells. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
F201339 MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING 8. ELECTRICAL - OPERATIONSBALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs relating to the operation and minor maintenance of electrical distribution system and associated equipment; and the water treatment system and associated equipment. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
32Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activity: 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Description of Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers___________________
F201342
F516668
F525486
F525509
F526505
F900553
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING 8. ELECTRICAL - TECHNICALIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for repair and maintenance of water treatment system. Includes potable and service water pumps and tanks, bulk chemical storage tanks and associated equipment; makeup demineralizers and all associated equipment. Expenses recorded under this final cost center have been transferred to/from another activity.
MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE OF MISCELLANEOUS OTHER POWER GENERAL PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs for repair and maintenance of service air compressors. Includes instrument air compressors, air filters, air driers and controls, backup air compressors, and all miscellaneous equipment associated with the plant air system.
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT3Includes labor, material, contract and other costs for maintenance on the gas turbine and generator system; the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) system; the fuel gas system; the water treatment system; the electrical distribution system; the condensate and feedwater system; the cooling water system; the circulating water system; the auxiliary electrical system; the distributed control system and associated devices; and the air quality control equipment; and overhaul costs for previously stated equipment that cannot be done during regularly scheduled annual outages. Also includes costs associated with vendor contractual agreement covering the gas turbine and steam turbine generators.
MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANTIncludes labor, material, contract, and other costs of engineers and technical specialists in the direct supervision and support of routine maintenance of structures, turbines, boilers, and auxiliary equipment not specifically applicable to other maintenance activities.
BARRE MAINTENANCE 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURESInclude the cost of labor, materials used and expenses incurred in the maintenance of facilities used in other power generation.
MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGEntries for cost element mapping made by Corporate Regulatory Accounting.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION33
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, AND 550 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
(244) 0 0 0 0
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
941 821 755 548 440
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
782 1,427 3,010 1,073 547
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF 1,489 2,362 2,320 1,742 1,492
•SUMMARY
•SUMMARY
•SUMMARY
F201311
F201317
F201318
F201325
F201328
GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT- MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF 7,073 26,499GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT- ’ ’MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF 20,443 7,125GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT- MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE 57 0MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERAL 0 0AND ELECTRICAL
MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE 0 0STRUCTURE - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OFPLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE 5 3MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT 274 169AND ENGINEERING
MOUNTAINVIEW STATION EXPENSES 2 927 1 447
9,011
6,704
158
534
7,285
6,769
214
2,200
8,778
8,032
165
2,310
F201332
F201334
F201338
F201339
F201342
MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - OPERATIONS
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT- OPERATIONS UNIT 4
MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE STRUCTURE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING & ELECTRICAL - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING & ELECTRICAL - TECHNICAL
119
825
10
18
45
1,175
18
58
930
20
971
16
986
20
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
1 o 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 4 0 0
0 0
0
34Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F516668 MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE OF MISCELLANEOUS OTHER POWER GENERAL PLANT
14 0 0 0 0
F525486 MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT- MAINTENANCE UNIT3
110 2 0 0 0
F525509 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
80 67 0 0 0
F526505 BARRE MAINTENANCE 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
0 0 5 8 9
F900553 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
(122) 0 0 0 0
Total 34,846 41,173 23,452 20,826 22,779
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION35
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
36Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor 2,905 3,650 3,051 3,076 3,158 0 0 227Non-Labor 8,066 11,470 7,872 6,397 4,235 19,596 0 1,501Other 22,648 23,991 10,528 8,328 12,409 0 0 0
Total 33,619 39,111 21,451 17,801 19,802 19,596 0 1,728
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final cost centers included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because all recorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement Balancing Account (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would be refunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
346 237 0 0 0 0 0LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
2,8180
1,0880
3,164 1,325
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 554
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 551, 552, and 553 to FERC 554.
LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
2,5325,252
22,648
3,41310,38223,991
3,0517,872
10,528
3,0766,3978,328
3,1584,235
12,409
30,432 37,786 21,451 17,801 19,802
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-FYA MV O&M SPECIAL PROJECT MOVED TO NL
This future year adjustment is for maintenance and inspection overhaul balance of plant (BOP) non-labor expenses.
LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
019,596
0
19,596
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GBU-CPT-OU-FYA MV HGP AVG INTO 2015
This future year adjustment is for a HGPI average into 2015 (Labor-682/3yrs, Non-labor-4504/3yrs).
LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
2271,501
0
1,728
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION37
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Organizational Unit Adjustment 4 TDBU-IDP.CPT-OUX-TRANSFER_MOUNTVIEW_COSTS
This adjustment transfers historical Mountainview expenses from FERC 570 (F201328) to FERC 554.
Labor 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (4) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
38_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION39
FERC Account:
Activ ity:
Witness:
554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX C
Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
40Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Final Cost Centers included in this activity:
‘ Summary Final Cost Centers:
MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, AND 550 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERINGF900551 F900552 F900554
MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
F201341 F201346 F201347
MOUNTAINVIEW 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
F201326 F525492
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANTF201327 F201340 F525484 F525493 F525494 F527868 F527869 F527882 F527883 F527884
F527885 F527886
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
F201320 F201331 F527870 F527871 F527872 F527873 F527874 F527875
MOUNTAINVIEW 553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
F201322 F201323 F525489 F527876 F527877 F527878 F527879 F527880 F527881
MOUNTAINVIEW 554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL
F201321 F525487
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION41
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
Activity: 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Individual Final Cost Centers:
F201311 F201317 F201318 F201325 F201328 F201332 F201334 F201338 F201339
F516668 F525486 F525509 F526505 F900553
F201342
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
42Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 554 Maintenance of Miscellaneous Other Power Generation Plant
A ctiv ity : 554 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION43
Mountainview Generating Station2013 Major Inspection (Ml) Non-CSA Non-Labor Costs
For Spring Unit 4 M l as o f April 2013
Description of Work U n it4 Ml Costs
S T E A M T U R B IN E G E N E R A T O R Sheet 1 o f 3
1 S T d iap h ra gm N D E and re p a ir 4 84 ,38 5
2 D ia p hrag m m isc m a ch in ing 25 ,000
3 M od ify N2 p ack in g head 15,185
4 S T B ea ring w o rk /re p la c e m e n t 21,867
5 R e p a ir le ft In te rce p t va lve IA W 55 ,0 76
6 R e -lo ca te B u lk H yd rogen S to ra g e T a nk 13,672
7 R e pa ir /te s t Rexro th S team A c tu a to rs 70 ,572
8 O n-s ite re p a ir o f LP ro to r and d ia p h ra g m s - e m e rg e n t issue 115 ,010
SUBTOTAL 800,767GAS TURBINE
9 C o m p re s s o r B ig F o o t R e p a ir - E m e rg en t issue 1 ,585,581
Gas T u rb in e O il change o u t (A d d itio n a l d e ta ils )H yd ra u lic O il C/O 78,991
10 GT - L/O Tank c lean ing 58 ,3 14
11 Rem ove va rn ish fro m 4 A Lube O il skid 5 ,200
12 H ydrau lic S ide S trea m P o lis h e r T e m p .V ive 7 ,900
G en e ra to r W e d g e s /B e lly band - t ig h e n in g /re p a ir4 A R ewedge - Partia l 98 ,309
13 4B Rew edge- Partia l 213 ,237
14 Pull F ie ld on G e n e ra to rs - 4 A & 4B R o to r S tand Rental 39 ,0 00
15 In le t C 0 2 B la s ting - C T In le t C le a n in g 187 ,720
16 Q u a t C lean ing - 4A & 4B 53 ,0 00
17 S pring Board M o d if ic a t io n s - 4A & 4B 55 ,1 00
18 Evap C o o le r M ed ia 72,973
19 D r if t E lim ina to rs 6,834
20 Pre F ilte r u pg rade 57,568
G a s T u rb in e B earing repa irs4 A Bearing Repairs 62 ,000
21 4B Bearing Repairs 68 ,000
SUBTOTAL 2,649,727ELECTRICAL
22 T ra n s fo rm e r w o rk - b ush in gs 4 64 ,22 5
23 R e p a ir o f C p hase iso -p ha se buss E m e rg en t Issue 19,037
24 G en e ra to r B reake r T es ting 10,590
C o nd e nsa te PP M tr 6,392
25 M o to r a nd P um p repa irs - T B D base d on cond ition V a cu u m PP M tr 5 ,246
S w itch ya rd repa irs 7 ,000
26 U p g rade o f the B us 1 and 2 C ross tie 83 ,025
P rogram and Test Buss T ie b re a ke r re la y 4 ,075
27 Insta ll n ew re ve nu e m e ters in sw itch yard (pa rts $9 ,7 92 E D A 12/12) 20 ,000
Insta ll n ew ly repa ired e xc ita tio n tra s fo rm e r 8 ,806
28 E le c tr ica l S u p p o rt fo r O utage 78 ,4 90
In s tru m e n t S u p p o rt fo r O utage 27,508
29 T rip S che m e Inspection 6,075
30 F35 re lay in s ta lla tio n fe e d e r b re ake rs 8,425
SUBTOTAL 748,893COOLING TOWER / CIRCULATING WATER
39 C o n d e n s e r/H o tw e ll/W a te r box in spe c tio n and repa irs 23 ,426
40 C o o ling T o w e r in spe c tio n and repa irs 4 3 ,4 55
42 C o o ling T o w e r b as in /tun ne l/p ip ing in s p e c tio n /re p a ir 59 ,3 50
43 C o n fin e d sp ace fo r c ircu la tin g w a te r system 23,015
44 C o o ling to w e r b as in /tun ne l d ew a te rin g 91 ,457
46 D e luge sys tem and upg rades 4 2 ,0 00
47 C ircu la tin g w a te r trash screen 21,007
48 S R JR E ng in ee ring - Basin, C W S In ta ke /fo re ba y /C on d u it 36 ,0 00
49 H eat E xcha n ge rs (10ea A fla L ava l) - Insta ll & recond ition 135 ,978
50 H eat E xcha n ge rs n e w p la tes 72 ,217
53 V acu u m P um p ove rha u l 90 ,1 56
SUBTOTAL 638,061
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
44Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Mountainview Generating Station2013 Major Inspection (Ml) Non-CSA Non-Labor Costs
For Spring Unit 4 M l as o f April 2013
Description of Work U n it4 Ml Costs
HRSG Sheet 2 o f 3
57 Cold H ange r Insp e c tion /H a n g e r Repairs 4 ,6 0 0
58 High P ressure P ip ing Inspec tion 92 ,0 00
59 FAC Insp e c tion - A tte m p e ra to r line , HRSG Tubes, 72 ,2 00
62 S afe ty V a lve Te s ting &R epa irs 100 ,000
65 Low Pressure E conom ize r B lasting 124 ,400
66 CRH expa ns ion jo in t fo r CTG 4B 28,900
67 Test R e lie f va lves fo r gas c o m p resso r 7 ,620
68 Insta ll s tack doo rs 1 4,850
70
HRH - re p a ir va lve 5 3 4 A & B and ins ta ll 2 b o resope
in spe c tio n w e ld s b eh in d m a in s tea m vvs E m e rg en t Issue 73 ,7 50
71 HP m a in s team iso la tion vv M S -318 E m e rg en t Issue 113,969
72 G rind and re -w e ld on b o th PV-123 va lves E m e rg en t Issue 4 9 ,5 0 0
FAB BEARING MANDRELS 8 ,320
X ray fo r vv 318 E m e rg en t Issue 26,750
SUBTOTAL 716,859LOGISTICS
75
Cranes fo r o u ta g e (4)
e s tim a te s a re fo r 4 0 and 45 days
2 - 40T (1-40D , 1-12D) 91 ,469
2 - 265T (30 Days) 673 ,672
500T (45 Days) 8 62 ,94 4
76E xpe d iting
(Inc ludes Renta l e q u ip m e n t)
R ental E qu ip m e n t 91 ,0 00
Fue l-C a lifo rin ia Fuels 38 ,0 00
12 F la tbed tra ile rs w /
1 tra c to r and D rive r 28,729
T ra ile rs w ith fu rn itu re
1- 20 F t and 3 -4 0 Ft 17,000
77 U n ite d Services (P orta Johns e tc) 24 ,000
78 S ca ffo ld ing 4 19 ,355
79 Insu la tion 109 ,942
80 S te p -d ow n tra n s fo rm e rs (10) fo r p ow e r re q u irem en ts 8,000
81 M ech an ica l S u p p o rt 89 ,315
82 W e ld in g and la b o r su pp o rt 162,221
83 S ecu rity G ua rd - C o rp o ra te S ecu rity 22 ,000
84 C o n su m a b le s M l - m isce lla n e o u s item s 60,000
84 C o n su m a b le s R outine O tg -m is c e lla n e o u s item s 21,600
84 C o n su m a b le s - p a lle ts and p lyw ood 21,600
85 E m iss ion T ra ile r fo rT u n in g 15,000
SUBTOTAL 2,755,847VALVE W ORK LIST
86Valve Repairs
(A d d ito n a l De ta ils )
M o o g Valves 106,997
R epair M S-318 4 6 ,0 00
R epair PV-123 2 05 ,900
V a lve S up p o rt ( labor) 2 19 ,400
SUBTOTAL 578,297MISCELLEANOUS
87 G E A P M w o rk - non C S A 2 84 ,990
SUBTOTAL 284,990
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION45
Mountainview Generating Station2013 Major Inspection (Ml) Non-CSA Non-Labor Costs
For Spring Unit 4 M l as o f April 2013
Description of Work U n it4 Ml Costs
PARTS - NON-SERVICE ITEMS Sheet 3 o f 3
88 G E co n s u m a b le s and Use Tax 23 ,379
89 Flex Hose T e s ting TIL 1585 4 ,4 0 0
90 S TG B o lting 104 ,180
91 P ack ing C a s ing H a rdw are 3 ,016
92 E xha u s t P arts 20,713
93 Cross O ver P ipe T u rb in e G asket 39 ,342
94 D iaphragm A lign H a rd w a re 17,343
95 F ilte r E le m e n t p arts fo r lu be o il m is t e lim in a to r 10,303
96
S T A W D G C O N V 7FH 2S T A T O R W E D G E C O N V 7FH 2 G E Q #5 6 88 41 3 2 7,758
97 P arts fo r M S -318 18,801
98 In le t B leed H eat M od - p arts -T u b ing 2,442
100 R e-H e a t In te rce p t V a lve 10,321
102 STRAWDGCONV 7FH2 RE-WEDGE KIT 18,265
103 O il D e fle c to r ( S T bea ring #1 and #4) 15,638
104 S W IT C H Y A R D R E P A IR P A R TS 1,868
105 V a lve parts 14,561
107 G e n e ra to r S ea l P arts 109 ,908
108 H V -005 35,021
109 O il D e flec to rs fo r 4A 29,958
112 S ta to r p inn in g parts 6,237
114 S T parts 14,469
116 F la t be lt w /p u n ch e d ends 6,216
113 S ta to r V an e s 24 ,214
118 P in ,H ose A s s y 2,084
118 S T bea ring th e rm o c o u p le s 999
115 C T C o up lin g and parts 17,130
110 R e lie f w s fo r g as co m p re s s o r 10,673
111 V acu u m P um p m e ch an ica l sea l 21,307
117 C o lle c to r T e rm ina l 4 ,052
118 T u rn ing G ea r p arts and n y lock bolts 516
118 C o lle c to r S tud 2,543
118 F lex ib le hose 1,099
SUBTOTAL 618 ,757
MISCELLEANOUS119 P2 S lid in g P re ssure e nh an ce m e n t 175 ,000
SUBTOTAL 175,000Cost fo r U n it 4 $9 ,9 67 ,19 8
Cost fo r U n it 3 $9 ,9 67 ,19 8
T o ta l Both U n its in 2013 $19 ,93 4 ,3 97
D e-esca la tion f ro m 2013$ 0.983
N o n-Labor in 2012$ $19 ,59 5 ,5 12
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08 Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
4^
G)
MO
UN
TA
INV
IEW
GE
NE
RA
TIN
G S
TA
TIO
N -
Acc
ou
nt
553.
Oth
erG
EN
ER
AL
EL
EC
TR
IC C
ON
TR
AC
T S
ER
VIC
ES
AG
RE
EM
EN
T f
CS
Al
RE
CO
RD
ED
AN
D F
OR
EC
AS
T C
OS
TS
(P
age
1 o
f 21
Co
sts
are
in N
om
inal
Yea
r D
olla
rs E
xcep
t w
her
e N
ote
d
Line
1 2 3 4 5 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21
22 23 24 25 26
YE
AR
Rec
orde
d /
For
ecas
t M
ajo
r M
ain
ten
ance
dur
ing
Yea
r C
SA
Ann
ual
Esc
alat
ion
Fa
cto
r (1
) C
SA
Cu
mu
lativ
e E
scal
atio
n F
acto
r
AN
NU
AL
FE
ES
Fix
ed F
ee (
2)V
aria
ble
Fee
(3)
Per
form
ance
Fee
(2)
Sub
-Tot
al
Act
ual
Rec
orde
d E
scal
ated
to
£20
12
Fix
ed F
ee
Var
iab
le F
ee
Per
form
ance
Fee
S
ub-T
otal
MA
JOR
OU
TA
GE
FE
ES
Hot
Ga
s P
ath
Add
er
Fee
(4)
Use
Ta
x R
eim
bu
rsem
ent
(5)
Cas
h A
djus
tme
nt F
ee (
61
Sub
-To
tal
Nom
inal
Dol
lars
TO
TA
L C
SA
FE
ES
Act
ual
Rec
orde
d /
For
ecas
t
2006
Rec
orde
d
1.03
111.
0744
2007
Rec
orde
d
1.13
88
2008
Rec
orde
d
1.04
221.
1868
2009
R
ecor
ded
HG
P B
oth
Uni
ts
1.10
65
1.31
32
2010
Rec
orde
d
1.00
251.
3165
2011
Rec
orde
d
1.02
001.
3428
2012
Rec
orde
d
1.02
001.
3697
$12
,98
8,4
94
$9,
355
,52
4
$10
,64
9,8
52
$10
,64
7,1
93
$10
,95
3,7
08
$8,
494
,86
3
$11
,63
5,2
35
2013
F
orec
ast
Ml
Bot
h U
nits
1.
0382
1.
4220
| $
10,6
39,
475
|
$8,
822
,61
7
| $2
2,64
8,22
1 |
$23
,98
9,8
16
| $
10,5
28,
362
|
$8,3
28,2
97
|
$12
,40
9,4
34
| $
12,1
26,
789
|
27 28 29 30 31
(1)
Esc
alat
ion
Per
cen
tag
e R
ate
Fo
reca
st fo
r 2
013-
201
7 is
Bas
ed o
n A
vera
ge
Rec
orde
d d
urin
g 2
008-
201
2 (
i.e.,
5-Y
ear
Ave
).
(2)
Fix
ed F
ee a
nd P
erfo
rman
ce F
ee F
ore
cast
for
201
3-20
17
is B
ased
on
200
8-20
12
Rec
orde
d 5
-Yea
r A
vera
ge,
as
adj
ust
ed f
or
Esc
alat
ion
usin
g F
ore
cast
CS
A E
scal
atio
n F
acto
r.
(3)
Var
iab
le F
ee 2
013
Fo
reca
st b
ased
on
200
8-20
12
Rec
orde
d 5
-Ye
ar
Ave
rag
e a
s a
dju
sted
fo
r E
scal
atio
n us
ing
Fo
reca
st C
SA
Esc
alat
ion
Fac
tor.
V
aria
ble
Fee
201
4-20
17
Fo
reca
st b
ased
on
200
8-20
12
Rec
orde
d 5
-Yea
r A
vera
ge,
as
Adj
uste
d f
or 2
014
Tra
nsi
tion
fro
m T
ier
1 to
T
ier
2 C
SA
Fee
Pric
e; s
ee N
ote
(3)
Cal
cula
tions
.
CO
NF
IDE
NT
IAL
: T
his
do
cum
ent
is p
rovi
ded
su
bje
ct t
o P
ub
lic U
tilit
ies
Co
de
Sec
tio
n 5
83 a
nd
Gen
eral
Ord
er 6
6C.
Pu
blic
dis
clo
sure
is
rest
rict
ed.
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08 Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
MO
UN
TA
INV
IEW
GE
NE
RA
TIN
G S
TA
TIO
N -
Acc
ou
nt
553.
Oth
erG
EN
ER
AL
EL
EC
TR
IC C
ON
TR
AC
T S
ER
VIC
ES
AG
RE
EM
EN
T f
CS
Al
RE
CO
RD
ED
AN
D F
OR
EC
AS
T C
OS
TS
(P
age
2 o
f 21
Co
sts
are
in N
om
inal
Yea
r D
olla
rs E
xcep
t wh
ere
Not
ed
Line
1 2 3 4 5 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
2014
Fo
reca
st
1.03
821.
4764
2015
For
ecas
t
1.03
821.
5329
2016
F
orec
ast
HG
P B
oth
Uni
ts
1.03
82
1.59
15
2017
For
ecas
t
1.03
821.
6524
20
15
-20
17
2
01
5-2
01
7T
otal
Nom
inal
Ave
rage
Nom
inal
Use
in F
orec
ast
Not
e (3
) C
alcu
latio
ns:
Var
iab
le F
ee F
ore
cast
for
201
4-17
In
crea
se d
ue t
o T
ran
sitio
n d
urin
g 20
14 f
rom
Tie
r 1
to T
ier
2 R
ates
F
ee p
er C
T O
pera
ting
Hou
r T
ier
2 T
ier
1 R
atio
| F
ee A
nnua
l A
vera
ge
200
8-12
in $
2012
$1
2,0
27,
704
2
014-
201
7 F
ore
cast
in $
2012
200
8-12
5-Y
rAve
in $
2012
200
8-12
5-Y
rAve
in $
2015
$
462,
512
See
Not
e (3
) C
alc
ula
tion
s $1
,807
,81
0
|Not
e (4
) C
alcu
latio
ns:
201
5 &
201
6 H
GP
Add
er
Fee
Fo
reca
st
CS
A C
on
tra
ct R
ate,
Esc
alat
ed|C
SA
Co
ntr
act
Rat
e pe
r U
nit
1.5
915
CS
A C
um
ula
tive
Esc
alat
ion
For
ecas
t$1
5,3
28,
868
$1
5,9
15,
059
T
ota
l E
scal
ated
- N
omin
al
$15
,15
1,8
96$
32,4
65,
526
|
$34
,72
8,6
89
| $1
7,3
60,
448
|
| $
84,5
54,
664
|
$28
,18
4,8
88
|
Not
e (5
) C
alcu
latio
ns:
201
5-20
17
Use
Ta
x R
eim
bu
rsem
ent
For
ecas
t20
16 H
ot G
as
Pat
h In
spec
tion
Ove
rhau
lsB
asis
: E
scal
ate
Am
oun
ts p
aid
200
7-20
09
for
200
8 H
GP
Use
Tax
201
5
201
6
2017
07 t
o'1
5 08
to '1
6 09
to
'17
Rec
orde
d C
os
tl-
F
ore
cast
Ye
ar
Esc
Fa
cto
rl
Rec
orde
d Y
ea
r E
sc F
ac
torl
Esc
Fa
cto
r R
ati
o|_
____
____
____
____
____
____
____
____
____
__F
ore
cast
Co
st
$1,
405
,33
9
$2,
081
,59
7
$40
2,9
63
(4)
HG
P A
dd
er
is $
10 M
illio
n pe
r U
nit
per
HG
P w
hic
h i
s th
en
Esc
alat
ed a
t C
on
tra
ct R
ate;
see
Not
e (4
) C
alcu
latio
ns.
(5)
Use
Tax
Re
imb
urs
emen
t F
ee F
ore
cast
for
2015
-20
17
ass
ocia
ted
with
fo
reca
st 2
016
HG
P O
verh
au
ls is
B
ased
on
200
7-20
09
Rec
orde
d U
se T
ax f
or
200
8 H
GP
Ove
rhau
ls;
see
Not
e (5
) C
alcu
latio
ns.
Use
Tax
R
eim
bu
rsem
ent
Fee
Fo
reca
st fo
r 20
13
ass
ocia
ted
with
201
2 M
ajo
r In
spec
tion
Ove
rha
uls
bas
ed o
n D
iscu
ssio
ns
with
GE
.
(6)
201
6 C
ash
Adj
ustm
ent
Fee
Fo
reca
st fo
r 20
16
is B
ased
on
Cas
h A
djus
tme
nt F
ee R
ecor
ded
in 2
009
for
20
09 H
GP
Ove
rha
uls
, a
s E
scal
ated
fo
r C
SA
Co
ntr
act
Esc
alat
ion.
20
06 C
ash
Adj
ustm
ent
Fee
Rec
orde
d to
P
lant
Co
nstr
uctio
n B
udge
t, n
ot to
Pla
nt O
&M
Exp
ense
. C
ash
Adj
ustm
ent
Fee
Fo
reca
st fo
r 20
13
ass
ocia
ted
with
201
2 M
ajor
Ins
pect
ion
Ove
rha
uls
bas
ed o
n D
iscu
ssio
ns w
ith G
E.
CO
NF
IDE
NT
IAL
: T
his
do
cum
ent
is p
rovi
ded
su
bje
ct t
o P
ub
lic U
tilit
ies
Co
de
Sec
tio
n 5
83 a
nd
Gen
eral
Ord
er 6
6C.
Pu
blic
dis
clo
sure
is
rest
rict
ed.
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08 Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
0)
SC
E 2
015
GR
C W
OR
KS
HE
ET
- M
OU
NT
AIN
VIE
W C
OM
BU
STI
ON
TU
RB
INE
OP
ER
AT
ING
HO
UR
SJA
NU
AR
Y 2
012
TH
RO
UG
H J
UN
E 2
013
RE
CO
RD
ED
, A
ND
JU
LY
201
3 T
HR
OU
GH
DE
CE
MB
ER
201
4 FO
RE
CA
ST
CA
SE
A F
OR
EC
AS
TP
rod
uctio
n M
odel
Ope
ratin
g H
ours
For
ecas
tC
um
ula
tive
Ope
ratin
g H
ours
at
End
of
Eac
h Q
uar
ter
sin
ce P
lant
Ent
ered
Ser
vice
in J
an 2
006
BA
SIS
PE
RIO
DC
TG
-3A
CTG
-3B
CT
G-4
AC
TG-4
BH
isto
rical
2011
Q4
42,6
5840
,247
41,8
4539
,930
Pro
duc
tion
Mod
el O
pera
ting
Hou
rs F
orec
ast
His
toric
al20
12 Q
144
,578
42,1
3043
,877
41,9
39H
isto
rical
2012
Q2
46,2
9743
,807
45,5
1343
,533
Rec
orde
d O
pera
ting
Hou
rs d
urin
g 2
012
His
toric
al20
12 Q
348
,566
46,0
9747
,729
45,7
17C
TG
-3A
CTG
-3B
CT
G-4
AC
TG-4
BH
isto
rical
2012
Q4
50,6
1148
,156
49,7
9247
,759
7,95
37,
909
7,94
77,
829
His
toric
al20
13 Q
152
,709
50,2
7650
,532
48,5
27H
isto
rica
l20
13 Q
254
,591
52,1
7951
,780
49,7
40R
ecor
ded
& F
ore
cast
Ope
ratin
g H
ours
dur
ing
2013
For
ecas
t20
13 Q
356
,808
54,3
7653
,955
51,9
11C
TG
-3A
CTG
-3B
CT
G-4
AC
TG-4
BF
orec
ast
2013
Q4
57,5
5255
,120
55,9
5553
,911
6,94
16,
964
6,16
36,
152
For
ecas
t20
14 Q
159
,619
57,1
8758
,022
55,9
78F
orec
ast
2014
Q2
60,7
8658
,354
59,1
8957
,145
Fo
reca
st O
pera
ting
Hou
rs d
urin
g 2
014
For
ecas
t20
14 Q
362
,873
60,4
4161
,276
59,2
32C
TG
-3A
CTG
-3B
CT
G-4
AC
TG-4
BF
orec
ast
2014
Q4
65,0
8162
,649
63,4
8461
,440
7,52
97,
529
7,52
97,
529
CA
SE
B F
OR
EC
AS
TA
lter
nat
e O
pera
ting
Hou
rs F
ore
cast
Bas
ed o
n Ja
n 20
12 t
hru
Jun
e 20
13 A
ctua
l O
pera
ting
Hou
rsO
pera
ting
Hou
rs i
n E
ach
Qua
rter
BA
SIS
PE
RIO
DC
TG-3
AC
TG-3
BC
TG
-4A
CTG
-4B
His
toric
al20
12 Q
11,
920
1,88
32,
032
2,00
9H
isto
rical
2012
Q2
1,71
91,
677
1,63
61,
594
His
toric
al20
12 Q
32,
269
2,29
02,
216
2,18
4C
AS
E B
AL
TE
RN
AT
E F
OR
EC
AS
TH
isto
rical
2012
Q4
2,04
52,
059
2,06
32,
042
Cu
mu
lati
ve O
pera
ting
Hou
rs s
ince
Ent
erin
g S
ervi
ceH
isto
rical
2013
Q1
2,09
82,
120
740
768
CT
G-3
AC
TG
-3B
CT
G-4
AC
TG
-4B
His
tori
cal
2013
Q2
1,88
21,
903
1,24
81,
213
54,5
9152
,179
51,7
8049
,740
2013
Q2
(1)
2013
Q3
1,24
81,
213
1,88
21,
903
55,8
3953
,392
53,6
6251
,643
2013
Q1
(1)
2013
Q4
740
768
2,09
82,
120
56,5
7954
,160
55,7
6053
,763
2012
Q1
2014
Q1
1,92
01,
883
2,03
22,
009
58,4
9956
,043
57,7
9255
,772
2012
Q2
2014
Q2
1,71
91,
677
1,63
61,
594
60,2
1857
,720
59,4
2857
,366
2012
Q3
2014
Q3
2,26
92,
290
2,21
62,
184
62,4
8760
,010
61,6
4459
,550
2012
Q4
2014
Q4
2,04
52,
059
2,06
32,
042
64,5
3262
,069
63,7
0761
,592
(1)
Bas
ed o
n O
ppos
ite U
nit
(i.e.
, us
e U
nit
4 O
p H
rs t
o F
orec
ast
Uni
t 3 O
p H
rs,
and
Vic
e V
ersa
)N
ote
that
Uni
t 4 u
nder
wen
t a
Maj
or O
verh
aul
durin
g th
e fir
st h
alf o
f 201
3, a
nd U
nit
3 w
ill u
nder
go a
Maj
or O
verh
aul
durin
g th
e se
cond
hal
f of 2
013
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION48
2013 M I Overhaul Non-Labor Expense
Major Outage Fees 2012-2013 2011 2012 2013 Total in $2012 Escalation Factor2012 GRC Major Outage Fees - CSA 599 1,683 0 2,294 1.0202015 GRC Major Outage Fees - CSA 0 774 1,250 1,978 1/1.0382
316
2012 Ml Overhaul Cost $2009 $17,250 millionEscalation to $2012 1.0814
2012 Ml Overhaul Cost in $2012 $18,654 millionIncreased Expense from Escalation $1,404 million
2013 Ml Overhaul Cost $2013 $19,934 millionEscalation to $2012 0.983
2013 Ml Overhaul Cost in $2012 $19,596 millionIncreased Forecast Expenses $0,942 millionReduction Due to Lower CSA Major Outage Fees $0,316 million
Total Increase In Expense $0,626 million
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08 Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
CD
Mou
ntai
nvie
w F
ERC
554
For
ecas
t Adj
ustm
ent
FE
RC
554
- M
aint
enan
ce o
f Mis
cella
neou
s O
ther
Pow
er G
ener
atio
n (C
onso
lidat
ion
for
FE
RC
Acc
ount
s 55
1, 5
52,
553,
and
554
)
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Labo
r3,
355
4,32
83,
785
3,72
73,
718
Non
-Lab
or8,
841
12,8
559,
139
8,77
26,
652
Oth
er22
,648
23,9
9110
,528
8,32
812
,409
Tota
l34
,844
41,1
7423
,452
20,8
2722
,779
Rat
iona
le f
or T
Y A
djus
tmen
ts fo
r La
bor
and
Non
-Lab
orA
vg.
08,
10-1
220
09 L
ess
Avg
.A
dj.
for
TYE
st.
Met
hod
GR
C B
ase
Est
.T
Y F
cst.
Labo
r3,
646
682
227
Last
Rec
. Y
r.3,
718
3,94
5N
on-L
abor
8,35
14,
504
1,50
1A
vg.
08,
10-1
28,
351
9,85
2A
vg.
Exp
. In
las
t 5
year
sH
GP
I E
xp.
Incr
.Le
veliz
ed '1
5-'1
7B
ase
Met
hod
Cal
c. B
ase
Est
.B
ase
+ H
GP
I A
dj.
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION50
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N /A 0 0
Non-Labor N /A 0 0
Other N /A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity includes the cost o f labor and expenses incurred in the general supervision and operation of the M ountainview Generating station. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to other activities.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in th is activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
51Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
Activ ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period
$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (N om inal $)Labor 178 836 2,001 2,000 2,267
N on-Labor 192 468 511 533 438
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 370 1,304 2,512 2,533 2,705
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (178) (836) (2,001) (2,000) (2,267)
N on-Labor (192) (468) (511) (533) (438)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (370) (1,304) (2,512) (2,533) (2,705)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
52Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
53Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION54
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
Activ ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY FINANCIAL SERVICES MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F201240 OPERATIONS SUPPORT & PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT - MOUNTAINVIEW 546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F201335 MOUNTAINVIEW554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - OPERATIONS UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201336 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F201342 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING & ELECTRICAL - TECHNICAL
0 0 0 0 0
F201343 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATION SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F525506 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR AND ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F526237 BUSINESS PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT- MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPERVISION & ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F900546 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
55Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION56
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (178) (836) (2,001) (2,000) (2,267) 0 0 0Non-Labor (192) (468) (511) (533) (438) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (370) (1,304) (2,512) (2,533) (2,705) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final cost centers included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because all recorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement Balancing Account (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would be refunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor Non-Labor Other
1,199875
0
720152
0
000
000
000
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2,074 872 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment corrects an account ing error.
Labor 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 A&G FINC-RSL.CPT-OUX-CNTRLS-XFER TO GBU
This adjustment transfers labor recorded in Financial Services Miscellaneous Expenses 930 to FERC accounts 500,535 and 546.
Labor 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GBU-CPT.LMM-OUX-GP&S 557
This adjustment transfers integrated planning expenses from Generation FERC 500, 501, 506, 535 and 546 to FERC557 for historical consistency and where they are being forecast.
Labor (97) (110) (79) (53) 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (27) (38) (45) (23) 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (124) (148) (124) (76) 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
57Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Organizational Unit Adjustment 4 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 549
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 546, 548, and 550 to FERC 549.
Labor (1,394) (1,446) (1,922) (1,948) (2,267) 0 0 0Non-Labor (1,039) (582) (467) (510) (438) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (2,433) (2,028) (2,389) (2,458) (2,705) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION58
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 546 Operation Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 546 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
59Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 548 Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N /A 0 0Non-Labor N /A 0 0Other N /A 0 0Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost of labor, materials used and expenses incurred in operating prime movers, generators and electric equipment in Mountainview Generating station, to the point where electricity leaves for conversion for transmission and distribution. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to other activities.
See Appendix C for Final Cost Centers included in this activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION60
FERC Account: 548 Generation Expenses
Activ ity : 548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period
$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (N om inal $)Labor 2 138 265 244 245
N on-Labor (1) 1,822 3,044 2,834 3,077
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1 1,960 3,309 3,078 3,322
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (2) (138) (265) (244) (245)
N on-Labor 1 (1,822) (3,044) (2,834) (3,077)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1) (1,960) (3,309) (3,078) (3,322)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
61Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
548 Generation Expenses
548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION62
FERC Account: 548 Generation Expenses
Activ ity : 548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
0 0 0 0 0
F201305 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING - CONVERSION ONLY
0 0 0 0 0
F201318 MOUNTAINVIEW554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201321 MOUNTAINVIEW554 MAINTENANCE MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL
0 0 0 0 0
F201322 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201329 MOUNTAINVIEW STATION EXPENSES 0 0 0 0 0
F201333 MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201343 MOUNTAINVIEW546 OPERATION SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201344 MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F900548 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
63Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
548 Generation Expenses
548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION64
FERC Account: 548 Generation Expenses
A ctiv ity : 548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (2) (138) (265) (244) (245) 0 0 0Non-Labor 1 (1,822) (3,044) (2,834) (3,077) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1) (1,960) (3,309) (3,078) (3,322) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final cost centers included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because all recorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement Balancing Account (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would be refunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 199 116 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 4,378 1,961 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 4,577 2,077 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ADJ EMISSION FEES
There was an accounting conversion error regarding emission fees that were incorrectly recorded. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 106 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 106 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 549
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 546, 548, and 550 to FERC 549.
Labor (200) (254) (265) (244) (245) 0 0 0Non-Labor (4,483) (3,781) (3,044) (2,834) (3,077) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (4,683) (4,035) (3,309) (3,078) (3,322) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
65Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
548 Generation Expenses
548 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
66Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
67Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 550 Rents
Activ ity : 550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0Non-Labor N/A 0 0Other N/A 0 0Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include all rents of property of others used, occupied, or operated in connection with Mountainview Generating Station. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to other activities.
Final Cost Centers included in this activity (See Appendix A for additional detail):
F201307 F201315 F201316 F502935 F900550
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION68
FERC Account: 550 Rents
Activ ity : 550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 686 1,000 1,367 845 784
N on-Labor 48 (957) (2,103) (745) (511)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 734 43 (736) 100 273
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (686) (1,000) (1,367) (845) (784)
N on-Labor (48) 957 2,103 745 511
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (734) (43) 736 (100) (273)
Recorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
69Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
550 Rents
550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION70
FERC Account: 550 Rents
Activ ity : 550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F201307 MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - CONVERSION ONLY
0 0 0 0 0
F201315 MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201316 MOUNTAINVIEW 550 RENTS - ADMINISTRATION BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F502935 FINANCIAL SERVICES OVERHEAD RESIDUAL 550 OPERATIONS SUPPORT & ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F900550 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
71Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
550 Rents
550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION72
FERC Account: 550 Rents
A ctiv ity : 550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (686) (1,000) (1,367) (845) (784) 0 0 0Non-Labor (48) 957 2,103 745 511 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (734) (43) 736 (100) (273) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final costcenters included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because allrecorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement BalancingAccount (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would berefunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 5 1 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 5 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJ TO HYDRO
This adjustment moves Engineering & Technical Service expenses from FERC 550 to Hydro FERC 537, 539, and 545.
LaborNon-LaborOther
000
000
(1,367) 2,103
0
(845)745
0
(784)511
0
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 736 (100) (273) 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ADJST LABOR OUT OF RENT
Labor was incorrectly recorded in activity 550 - Mountainview. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 549
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 546, 548, and 550 to FERC 549.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (2) (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (2) (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
73Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 550 Rents
A ctiv ity : 550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Organizational Unit Adjustment 4 GBU-CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment corrects an account ing error.
LaborNon-LaborOther
(200)(51)
0
(1,000) 957
0
000
000
000
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (251) (43) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 5 GBU-CPT-OU-PEAKER MAPPING ADJUSTMEN1
This adjustment corrects an error for costs from FERC 550 to Peaker operations FERC 546, 549, and 553.
Labor (485) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (485) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION74
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
550 Rents
550 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
75Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
Activ ity : 551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost o f labor and expenses incurred in the general supervision and direction o f the maintenance o f Mountainview Generating Station. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to other activities.
Final Cost Centers included in this activity (See Appendix A fo r additional detail):
F201308 F201324 F201325 F201345 F201346 F525509 F900551
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION76
FERC Account: 551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
Activ ity : 551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 13 174 364 331 319
N on-Labor 91 221 381 423 286
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 104 395 745 754 605
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (13) (174) (364) (331) (319)
N on-Labor (91) (221) (381) (423) (286)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (104) (395) (745) (754) (605)
Recorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
77Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION78
FERC Account: 551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
Activ ity : 551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F201308 MOUNTAINVIEW 550 RENTS - CONVERSION ONLY
0 0 0 0 0
F201324 MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201325 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F201345 MOUNTAINVIEW 549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201346 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F525509 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F900551 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, AND 550 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
79Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION80
FERC Account: 551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (13) (174) (364) (331) (319) 0 0 0Non-Labor (91) (221) (381) (423) (286) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (104) (395) (745) (754) (605) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final cost centers included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because all recorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement Balancing Account (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would be refunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 209 175 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 462 323 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 671 498 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU--CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment corrects an account ing error.
Labor 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 51 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 151 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 554
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 551, 552, and 553 to FERC 554.
Labor (321) (349) (364) (331) (319) 0 0 0Non-Labor (603) (544) (381) (423) (286) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (924) (893) (745) (754) (605) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
81Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 551 Maintenance Supervision and Engineering
A ctiv ity : 551 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
82Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
83Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 552 Maintenance of Structures
A ctiv ity : 552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N /A 0 0
Non-Labor N /A 0 0
Other N /A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost o f labor, m aterials used and expenses incurred in maintenance o f the M ountainview Generating Station. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to o ther activities.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in th is activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION84
FERC Account: 552 Maintenance of Structures
Activ ity : 552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period
$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (N om inal $)Labor 3 363 509 398 376
N on-Labor (54) 520 2,325 654 180
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (51) 883 2,834 1,052 556
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (3) (363) (509) (398) (376)
N on-Labor 54 (520) (2,325) (654) (180)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 51 (883) (2,834) (1,052) (556)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
85Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
552 Maintenance of Structures
552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION86
FERC Account: 552 Maintenance of Structures
Activ ity : 552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
0 0 0 0 0
F201309 MOUNTAINVIEW551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING - CONVERSION ONLY
0 0 0 0 0
F201325 MOUNTAINVIEW551 MAINTENANCE SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
F201337 MOUNTAINVIEW549 MISCELLANEOUS GENERAL EXPENSE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201338 MOUNTAINVIEW552 MAINTENANCE STRUCTURE - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201340 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201341 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F526505 BARRE MAINTENANCE 552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
0 0 0 0 0
F900552 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, AND 550 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
87Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
552 Maintenance of Structures
552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION88
FERC Account: 552 Maintenance of Structures
A ctiv ity : 552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (3) (363) (509) (398) (376) 0 0 0Non-Labor 54 (520) (2,325) (654) (180) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 51 (883) (2,834) (1,052) (556) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final costcenters included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because allrecorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement BalancingAccount (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would berefunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 23 52 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 567 388 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 590 440 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV HISTORICAL SETTLEMENT ADJ
There was an incorrect settlement issue in last quarter of 2008 that incorrectly recorded costs in activity 549 -Mountainview. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 188 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 188 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 554
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 551, 552, and 553 to FERC 554.
Labor (26) (414) (509) (398) (376) 0 0 0Non-Labor (699) (908) (2,325) (654) (180) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (725) (1,322) (2,834) (1,052) (556) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
89Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
552 Maintenance of Structures
552 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
90Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
91Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
A ctiv ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N /A 0 0
Non-Labor N /A 0 0
Other N /A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity shall include the cost o f labor, m aterials used and expenses incurred in maintenance o f M ountainview Generation Station plant and the book cost which is includible in Prime Movers, Generators, Accessory E lectric Equipment. This activity package has zero dollars; all costs have been transferred to other activities.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in th is activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION92
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
Activ ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period
$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (N om inal $)Labor 11 1,130 2,178 2,347 2,463
N on-Labor 37 24,991 15,690 13,649 16,178
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 48 26,121 17,868 15,996 18,641
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (11) (1,130) (2,178) (2,347) (2,463)
N on-Labor (37) (24,991) (15,690) (13,649) (16,178)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (48) (26,121) (17,868) (15,996) (18,641)
Recorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
93Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION94
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
Activ ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
0 0 0 0 0
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 3
0 0 0 0 0
•SUMMARY MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201310 MOUNTAINVIEW552 MAINTENANCE STRUCTURE - CONVERSION ONLY
0 0 0 0 0
F201326 MOUNTAINVIEW552 MAINTENANCE OF STRUCTURES
0 0 0 0 0
F201333 MOUNTAINVIEW548 GENERATION EXPENSE - MAINTENANCE UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201334 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - OPERATIONS UNIT 4
0 0 0 0 0
F201339 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING & ELECTRICAL - OPERATIONS BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201341 MOUNTAINVIEW 551 MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR & ENGINEER - TECHNICAL BALANCE OF PLANT
0 0 0 0 0
F201342 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE GENERATING & ELECTRICAL - TECHNICAL
0 0 0 0 0
F525486 MOUNTAINVIEW553 MAINTENANCE OF GENERATING AND ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - MAINTENANCE UNIT3
0 0 0 0 0
F900553 MOUNTAINVIEW & PEAKER CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 546, 548, 549, 550 AND 553 OPERATIONS SUPPORT AND ENGINEERING
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
95Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION96
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
A ctiv ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (11) (1,130) (2,178) (2,347) (2,463) 0 0 0Non-Labor (37) (24,991) (15,690) (13,649) (16,178) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (48) (26,121) (17,868) (15,996) (18,641) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-NONUTILCR
This adjustment reverses the non-utility affiliate credits related to expenses recorded in one or more of the final costcenters included in this activity and charged to non-utility affiliates. These adjustments are appropriate because allrecorded non-utility affiliate credits were refunded to customers through the Base Revenue Requirement BalancingAccount (BRRBA) pursuant to D.99-10-057. If these adjustments were not made, non-utility affiliate credits would berefunded to customers twice: (1) through adjustments to the BRRBA; and (2) through reductions to rates.
Labor 2,174 1,021 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 25,799 8,876 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 27,973 9,897 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT-OU-MV HISTORICAL SETTLEMENT ADJ
There was an incorrect settlement issue in last quarter of 2008 that incorrectly recorded costs in activity 549 -Mountainview. This adjustment corrects the error.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 537 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 537 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT-OU-MV CSA ADJUSTMENT
General Electric (GE) Contract Service Agreement (CSA) - This adjustment reflects that the GE CSA costs were lowcompared to annual costs forecast for the life of the plant CSA costs have been forecast for future years, including thecost impact on the CSA of higher forecast production levels. This adjustment also reflects forecast escalation to CSAquarterly payments, consistent with the CSA.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (22,428) (23,991) (10,528) (8,328) (12,409) 0 0 0Other 22,648 23,991 10,528 8,328 12,409 0 0 0
Total 220 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GRC-MJP.CPT-OUX-A&G TO MOUNTAINVIEW
This adjustment transfers expenses related to Mountainview Generation from FERC 920-921.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 5 9 4 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 5 9 4 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
97Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
A ctiv ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Organizational Unit Adjustment 4 GBU-CPT-OU-MV MAPPING ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment corrects an account ing error.
Labor 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (957) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (457) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 5 GBU-CPT-OU-MV ROLL UP TO FERC 554
This adjustment transfers Mountainview costs from FERC 551, 552, and 553 to FERC 554.
Labor (2,185) (2,650) (2,178) (2,347) (2,463) 0 0 0Non-Labor (3,950) (8,930) (5,166) (5,320) (3,769) 0 0 0Other (22,648) (23,991) (10,528) (8,328) (12,409) 0 0 0
Total (28,783) (35,571) (17,872) (15,995) (18,641) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION98
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 553 Maintenance of Generating and Electric Plant
A ctiv ity : 553 - MOUNTAINVIEW
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
99Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 509 Allowances
Activ ity : GAS - ALLOWANCES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity includes the cost o f allowances expensed concurrent with the monthly emission o f su lfur dioxide.
Final Cost Centers included in this activity (See Appendix A fo r additional detail):
F526840
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION100
FERC Account: 509 Allowances
Activ ity : GAS - ALLOWANCES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 (1) 0 0
N on-Labor 0 715 953 1,075 1,060
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 715 952 1,075 1,060
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor 0 0 1 0 0
N on-Labor 0 (715) (953) (1,075) (1,060)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (715) (952) (1,075) (1,060)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.1186 1.1173 1.0861 1.0253 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
101Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
509 Allowances
GAS - ALLOWANCES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION102
FERC Account: 509 Allowances
Activ ity : GAS - ALLOWANCES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F526840 MOUNTAINVIEW RECLAIM TRADING CREDITS
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
103Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
509 Allowances
GAS - ALLOWANCES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION104
FERC Account: 509 Allowances
A ctiv ity : GAS - ALLOWANCES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
LaborNon-LaborOther
000
0(715)
0
1(953)
0
0(1,075)
0
0(1,060)
0
000
000
000
Total 0 (715) (952) (1,075) (1,060) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-MJP-CW-MOUNTAINVIEW RTC
To remove Mountainview reclaim trading credit expenses which are recovered through the Energy Resource RecoveryAccount (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (367) (789) (903) (800) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (367) (789) (903) (800) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-MJP-CW-UNREALIZED GAINS RTC
Adjustment to remove unrealized gains for Reclaim Trading Credits (RTC) expenses
Labor 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (347) (164) (171) (259) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (347) (163) (171) (259) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
105Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
509 Allowances
GAS - ALLOWANCES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
106Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
107Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 501 Fuel
Activ ity : GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity includes the cost o f fuel used in the production o f steam fo r generation o f electricity, including expenses in unloading fuel from the shipping media and handling thereof up to the point where the fuel enters the first boiler plant bunker, hopper, bucket, tank, or holder o f the boiler-house structure. Fuel costs are not included in th is GRC.
Final Cost Centers included in this activity (See Appendix A fo r additional detail):
F502977
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION108
FERC Account: 501 Fuel
Activ ity : GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 87,696 87,792 73,084 87,900 94,099
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 87,696 87,792 73,084 87,900 94,099
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor (87,696) (87,792) (73,084) (87,900) (94,099)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (87,696) (87,792) (73,084) (87,900) (94,099)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.1186 1.1173 1.0861 1.0253 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
109Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
501 Fuel
GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION110
FERC Account: 501 Fuel
Activ ity : GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$) By Final Cost Center$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F502977 FUEL - STEAM GENERATING STATIONS - GAS
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
111Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
501 Fuel
GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION112
FERC Account: 501 Fuel
A ctiv ity : GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (87,696) (87,792) (73,084) (87,900) (94,099) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (87,696) (87,792) (73,084) (87,900) (94,099) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-MJP-CW-FCCOALFUEL
To remove the Four Corners coal fuel expenses which are recovered through the Energy Resources Recovery Account.
LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
0 0 0(87,201) (87,792) (73,084)
0 0 0
0 0 0(87,904) (94,099) 0
0 0 0(87,201) (87,792) (73,084) (87,904) (94,099) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-JAB-CW-FCGASFUEL
This ratemaking adjustment removes the cost of gas fuel burned at the Four Corners generating station. Such costs are recovered through the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) reasonableness proceeding and are not included in the general rate case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (1,012) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1,012) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 3 GRC-KBS-CW-FC FUEL ACCRUAL
This adjustment removes the accrual/reversal of the accrual of fuel expenses.
LaborNon-LaborOtherTotal
0539
___ 0_
539 0 0 5 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 4 GRC-MJP-CW-OTM REGULATORY
This adjustment removes undistributed expenses on a one time basis because these expenses are for accrual of operating expenses. The operating expenses are recovered through other mechanisms which are not included in this GRC.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (21) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (21) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
113Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 501 Fuel
A ctiv ity : GAS - FUEL-RELATED EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
114Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
115Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
Activ ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
Fuel Expenses fo r Catalina, Mountainview and Peakers which are removed from the General Rate Case proceeding.
Final Cost Centers included in this activity (See Appendix A fo r additional detail):
F502976 F502977 F900547
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION116
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
Activ ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 10,137 93,796 202,021 155,073 165,673
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 10,137 93,796 202,021 155,073 165,673
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $) see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor (10,137) (93,796) (202,021) (155,073) (165,673)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (10,137) (93,796) (202,021) (155,073) (165,673)
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
117Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
547 Fuel
547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION118
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
Activ ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
R e co rd e d /A d ju s te d (C o n s ta n t 2012$) B y F ina l C o s t C e n te r
$ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
F502976 CATALINA FUEL EXPENSE 0 0 0 0 0
F502977 FUEL - STEAM GENERATING STATIONS - GAS
0 0 0 0 0
F900547 RELATED FUEL EXPENSE 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
119Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
547 Fuel
547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION120
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
A ctiv ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (10,137) (93,796) (202,021) (155,073) (165,673) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (10,137) (93,796) (202,021) (155,073) (165,673) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-MJP-CW-FERC547FUEL - MOUNTAINVIEW
To remove Mountainview fuel expenses which are recovered through ERRA.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (88,129) (194,494) (146,016) (154,198) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (88,129) (194,494) (146,016) (154,198) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-MJP-CW-FERC547FUEL -PEAKERS
To remove the Peakers fuel expenses which are recovered through the ERRA.
LaborNon-LaborOther
0(1,982)
0
0(518)
0
0(1,192)
0
0(1,077)
0
0(3,285)
0
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1,982) (518) (1,192) (1,077) (3,285) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 3 GRC-MJP-CW-FERC547 FUEL - CATALINA
To remove the Catalina Pebbly Beach fuel expenses which are recovered through ERRA.
LaborNon-LaborOther
0(8,126)
0
0(5,114)
0
0(6,343)
0
0(7,981)
0
0(8,168)
0
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (8,126) (5,114) (6,343) (7,981) (8,168) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 4 GRC-KBS-CW-PEAKER FUELACCRUAL
This adjustment removes the accrual/reversal of the accrual of fuel expenses.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (29) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (29) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
121Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
A ctiv ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 5 GRC-MJP-CW-FERC547-FUEL CELLS
This adjustment removes fuel expense related to the Fuel Cell program that is recovered through the Energy Resources Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 0 0 (23) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 (23) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 6 GRC-MJP-CW-OTM REGULATORY
This adjustment removes undistributed expenses on a one time basis because these expenses are for accrual of operating expenses. The operating expenses are recovered through other mechanisms which are not included in this GRC.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 0 8 1 0 0 0 0Other 0____ 0_________ 0_________ 0_________ 0__________ 0___________0__________ 0 _
Total 0 0 8 1 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT.IDP-OUX-GENOTHERPEBBLY-549
This adjustment transfers dollars which belong to Pebbly Beach from FERC 547 to FERC 549.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (35) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (35) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION122
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 547 Fuel
A ctiv ity : 547.140 - FERC 547 FUEL EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
123Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity includes the cost at point o f receipt by the utility o f e lectricity purchased fo r resale. It includes net settlem ents for exchange o f electricity or power, such as economy energy, off-peak energy fo r on-peak energy, spinning resen/e capacity, etc. In addition, th is activity includes the net settlem ents fo r transactions under pooling or interconnection agreem ents wherein there is a balancing of debits and credits fo r energy, capacity, etc. Purchased power expenses are not included in this GRC.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in this activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION124
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
Activ ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
I Recorded Period$ ( 000 )
2 0 0 8 2 0 0 9 2 0 1 0 2 01 1 2 0 1 2
FERC Form 1 Recorded (Nom inal $)Labor 2 1 0 0 0
Non- Labor 5 ,724,206 2 ,793 ,313 2 ,910,762 3 ,867,813 3 ,668,241
O the r 0______________0______________ 0______________ 0_____________ 0
Total 5,724,208 2,793,314 2 ,910,762 3 ,867,813 3,668,241
A d justm en ts- (Nom inal $) - see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detailLabor (2) (1) 0 0 0
N on-Labor (5 ,724,206) (2 ,793,313) (2 ,910,762) (3 ,867,813) (3 ,668,241)
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (5 ,724,208) (2 ,793,314) (2 ,910,762) (3 ,867,813) (3 ,668,241)
Recorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Escalation:Labor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d jus ted 2008-2012 (2012$)
6 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-2 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-8 , , , ,----------------------2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
125Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
555 Purchased Power
PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION126
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
Activ ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY PURCHASED POWER EXPENSE 0 0 0 0 0
F502973 MOHAVE 555 - CORPORATE REGULATORY ACCOUNTING - BALANCING ACCOUNT INTEREST
0 0 0 0 0
F502984 REGULATORY BUDGET ADJUSTMENT - OTHER EXPENSES
0 0 0 0 0
F516645 SHOP SERVICES AND INSTRUMENTATION DIVISION (SSID) ADMINISTRATION / OPERATIONS
0 0 0 0 0
F516648 555 PURCHASED POWER - OTHER 0 0 0 0 0
F528243 GENERAL FUNCTION-OUT-OF-STATE TRANSMISSION
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
127Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
555 Purchased Power
PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION128
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (2) (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (5,724,206) (2,793,313) (2,910,762) (3,867,813) (3,668,241) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (5,724,208) (2,793,314) (2,910,762) (3,867,813) (3,668,241) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-ESMA
To remove expenses related to FERC refunds and related expenses that are recorded and recovered through the Energy Settlement Memorandum Account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Non-Labor 29,787 40,700 25,445 29,924 5,984 0 0 0 Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 29,787 40,700 25,445 29,924 5,984 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-JAB-CW-ESMASETTLEMENTACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes accruals for energy settlements. SCE is not seeking recovery in the GeneralRate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 26,235 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 26,235 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 3 GRC-JAB-CW-WHEELINGACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes Wheeling Expenses accruals.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 15,376 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 15,376 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 4 GRC-JAB-CW-PURCHASEPOWERACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes accruals for Purchase Power expenses for which SCE is not seeking recovery inthe General Rate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 34,976 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 34,976 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
129Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 5 GRC-JAB-CW-LEASEAMORITIZATION
This ratemaking adjustment removes amortized leases for which SCE is not seeking recovery in the Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 Non-Labor 816 1,367 7,759 6,738 6,352 Other 0 0 0 0 0
General Rate
000
000
000
Total 816 1,367 7,759 6,738 6,352 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 6 GRC-JAB-CW-SETTLEMENTMWS ACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes accruals for the Midway Sunset (MWS) settlement for which SCE is not seekingrecovery in the General Rate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 42,761 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 42,761 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 7 GRC-JAB-CW-SETTLEMENTMWD ACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes accruals for the Metropolitan Water Department (MWD) settlement for whichSCE is not seeking recovery in the General Rate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 1,350 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1,350 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 8 GRC-KBS-CW-COST TYP CORRECTION
This adjustment corrects a credit amount recorded as labor that should have been non-labor.
Labor 0 (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 9 GRC-JAB-CW-ERRAFTR
This ratemaking adjustment removes Firm Transmission Rights (FTR) costs recorded in the Energy ResourceRecovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (450) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (450) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION130
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 10 G RC-KBS-CW-P R E PAY
This adjustment removes prepayments of Renewable Energy Credits for 2010 and 2011.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (1,600) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1,600) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 11 GRC-JAB-CW-AES SETTLEMENT
This ratemaking adjustment removes a settlement with AES Corporation recorded in the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (1,840) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (1,840) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 12 GRC-JAB-CW-WECCRECLASS
This ratemaking adjustment reclass dollars from FERC 555 to 557.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 2,403 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2,403 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 13 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCT555IEC
This ratemaking adjustment removes expenses recorded in the Independent Evaluator Costs (IEC) Memorandum Account and Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (403) (740) (716) (1,077) (778) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (403) (740) (716) (1,077) (778) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 14 GRC-KBS-CW-WECC RELIABILITY
This adjustment removes NERC and WECC expenses recovered through the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (3,204) (4,331) (4,676) (4,655) (4,812) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (3,204) (4,331) (4,676) (4,655) (4,812) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
131Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 15 GRC-JAB-CW-MIDWAYSETTLEMENT
This ratemaking adjustment removes a settlement with Midway Sunset recorded in the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 Non-Labor (20,187) Other 0
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
000
000
Total (20,187) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 16 GRC-JAB-CW-ISOREVENUE
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) revenue related charges recorded in theEnergy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (22,366) (38,982) (74,782) (32,715) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (22,366) (38,982) (74,782) (32,715) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 17 GRC-JAB-CW-TRBA ISO CHARGES
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Charges recorded and recovered in theTransmission Revenue Balancing Account (TRBA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (19,441) (3,608) (428) 4,818 (1,774) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (19,441) (3,608) (428) 4,818 (1,774) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 18 G RC-JAB-CW-RS BA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Must Offer Obligations (MBO) and ISOM438 expenses were recorded and recovered through the Reliability Services Balancing Account (RSBA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (11,650) (710) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (11,650) (710) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 19 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCTISOFTR-ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Firm Transmission Rights (FTR) costsrecorded in the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor (2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (50,392) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (50,394) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION132
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 20 GRC-KBS-CW-NEW SYSTEM GEN
This adjustment removes expenses recorded n the New System Generation Balancing Account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (26,694) (25,811) (38,934) (57,342) (58,845) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (26,694) (25,811) (38,934) (57,342) (58,845) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 21 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCT-555-INTERUTILTY CONTRACTS ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Interutility Contracts expenses that are recovered in the Energy ResourceRecovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (7,619) (5,295) (7,864) (8,142) (10,253) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (7,619) (5,295) (7,864) (8,142) (10,253) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 22 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCT-555-PURCHASEPOWEROTHER ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes purchase power expense. SCE is not seeking recovery in the General RateCase.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (743,771) 480,657 51,585 (810,574) 135,806 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (743,771) 480,657 51,585 (810,574) 135,806 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 23 GRC-JAB-CW-ISO COSTS ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Charges recorded and recovered through theEnergy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (318,338) (359,588) (314,304) (271,566) (1,098,523) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (318,338) (359,588) (314,304) (271,566) (1,098,523) 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 24 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCT-PU RCHASE POWER
This ratemaking adjustment removes purchase power expenses recorded and recovered through the Energy ResourceRecovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (2,320,009) (1,150,579) (742,857) (782,894) (912,903) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (2,320,009) (1,150,579) (742,857) (782,894) (912,903) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
133Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 25 GRC-JAB-CW-QF ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Qualifying Facilities costs recorded and recovered through the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (2,326,079) (1 ,769,243) (1 ,846,789) (1 ,898,260) (1 ,695,780) 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (2,326,079) (1,769,243) (1,846,789) (1,898,260) (1,695,780) 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION134
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 555 Purchased Power
A ctiv ity : PURCHASED POWER EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
135Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Beginning of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
A ctiv ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Forecast Method Chosen
2012$ (000)
Recorded2012
Forecast2015
Labor N/A 0 0
Non-Labor N/A 0 0
Other N/A 0 0
Total 0 0
Description of Activity:
This activity includes any production expenses including expenses incurred directly in connection with the purchase of electricity, which are not specifically provided fo r in o ther production expense accounts.
See Appendix C fo r Final Cost Centers included in th is activity.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION136
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
Activ ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
DETERMINATION OF RECORDED/ADJUSTED
Recorded Period
$ (000)
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
FERC Form 1 Recorded (N om inal $)Labor 118 (17) 0 0 0
N on-Labor 69,333 12,635 16 1 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 69,451 12,618 16 1 0
A d jus tm en ts- (Nom inal $)Labor
see A ppend ix B fo r add itiona l detail(118) 17 0 0 0
N on-Labor (69,333) (12,635) (16) (1) 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total (69,451) (12,618) (16) (1) 0
R ecorded/Adjusted (Nom inal $)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
EscalationLabor 1.1414 1.1070 1.0701 1.0327 1.0000
N on-Labor 1.0881 1.0814 1.0642 1.0254 1.0000
O ther 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
R ecorded/Adjusted (C onstant 2012$)
Labor 0 0 0 0 0
N on-Labor 0 0 0 0 0
O ther 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
Recorded A d justed 2008-2012 (2012$)
6
4
2
0
-2
■4
-62008 2009 2010 2011 2012
□ Labor (std escl) ■ Non-Labor (std escl) □ Other (not escl)
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
137Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
557 Other Expenses
OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX A
Detail Description of Final Cost Centers Included in This Activity
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION138
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
Activ ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Recorded/Adjusted (Constant 2012$ By Final Cost Center
$ (000)* See Appendix C for Summary Final Cost Centers 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
•SUMMARY METER SERVICES ORGANIZATION - REPAIR BILLING METERS
0 0 0 0 0
F502983 PURCHASED POWER EXPENSE 0 0 0 0 0
F502984 REGULATORY BUDGET ADJUSTMENT - OTHER EXPENSES
0 0 0 0 0
F503045 TRANSMISSION PARTICIPANT SHARE COSTS 0 0 0 0 0
F516648 555 PURCHASED POWER - OTHER 0 0 0 0 0
F520192 VERNON NON - SPINNING RESERVE 0 0 0 0 0
F520195 BALANCING ACCOUNT 0 0 0 0 0
F900557 CORPORATE ADJUSTMENT - 557 OTHER EXPENSES
0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 0
** Due to rounding, totals may not tie to other workpaper pages.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
139Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account:
A ctiv ity :
W itness:
557 Other Expenses
OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
Anthony J. Kurpakus
APPENDIX B
Detail of Total Company Adjustments to Recorded
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION140
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
A ctiv ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
|A d js - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Labor (118) 17 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (69,333) (12,635) (16) (1) 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (69,451) (12,618) (16) (1) 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 1 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCTISOFTR-ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Firm Transmission Rights (FTR) costsrecorded in the Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) balancing account.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (12,016) 2 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (12,016) 2 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 2 GRC-JAB-CW-GENACCTISOFTR-ERRAAMORITIZATION
This ratemaking adjustment removes amortization for Independent System Operator (ISO) Firm Transmission Rights (FTR). SCE is not seeking recovery in the General Rate Case.
Labor 0 Non-Labor (16,952) Other 0
0(12,620)
0
000
000
000
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (16,952) (12,620) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 3 GRC-JAB-CW-ISO COSTACCRUAL
This ratemaking adjustment removes accruals for Independent System Operator (ISO) expenses for which SCE is notseeking recovery in the General Rate Case.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (2) (9) (13) 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (2) (9) (13) 0 0 0 0 0
Company Wide Adjustment 4 GRC-JAB-CW-ISO COSTS ERRA
This ratemaking adjustment removes Independent System Operator (ISO) Charges recorded and recovered through theEnergy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA).
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (42,753) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (42,753) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
141Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
A ctiv ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
W itness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Detail o f Total Company Adjustm ents to Recorded Expenses
Adjs - (Nominal $) $ (000)2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Company Wide Adjustment 5 GRC-JAB-CW-WECCRECLASS
This ratemaking adjustment reclass dollars from FERC 555 to 557.
Labor Non-Labor Other
02,403
0
o o
o
o o
o
000
000
000
0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2,403 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 1 GBU-CPT.IDP-OUX-GF APS
This adjustment transfers dollars which belong to T&D from FERC 557 to FERC 570.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (2) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (2) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 2 GBU-CPT.RSL-OUX-GF BUDGET ADJUSTMENT
This adjustment transfers Volt contract costs from Other Power Supply Expenses FERC 557 to Financial ServicesFERC 923-930 because these costs were incorrectly mapped to FERC account 557.
Labor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor 0 (2) (3) (1) 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 (2) (3) (1) 0 0 0 0
Organizational Unit Adjustment 3 GBU-CPT.KMM-OUX-REPAIR BILLING METERS
Transfer Repair Billing Meters Expense from the Power Production Department (PPD) to the Customer Service.
Labor (118) 17 0 0 0 0 0 0Non-Labor (13) (4) 0 0 0 0 0 0Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total (131) 13 0 0 0 0 0 0
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION142
End of Workpapers for:
FERC Account: 557 Other Expenses
A ctiv ity : OTHER POWER SUPPLY EXPENSES
Witness: Anthony J. Kurpakus
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
143_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
CAPITAL EXPENDITURES FORECAST
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION144
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
OPERATING UNIT SUMMARY
(Nominal $000)
O perating Unit Sum m ary: GEN - M ountainview
(1) O PERATING UNIT FO RECAST CAPITAL EXPENDITUR ES: 2015 GRC
Item Testim ony DescriptionForecast C apita l Expenditures
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Total
1 Capital Projects O ver $1 Million 9,608 1,271 1,073 895 697 13,544
2 O ffice Furniture and Equipm ent 24 56 58 60 62 260
Total 9,632 1,327 1,131 955 759 13,804
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
145_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
OPERATING UNIT SUMMARY
(Nominal $000)
O pe ra tin g U n it S um m a ry : GEN - M o u n ta in v ie w
(2) O PERATING UNIT RECO RDED A N D AU TH O R IZE D C A P ITA L AND FO RECAST E XPENDITUR ES: 2015 GRC
DescriptionRecorded and Authorized Capital Expenditures Forecast Capita l Expenditures
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Authorized Expenditures 17,800 19,544
Recorded & Forecast Expenditures 6,320 10,093 14,076 3,887 9,192 9,632 1,327 1,131 955 759
Total Expenditure 43,568 13,804
Recorded, Authorized and Forecast Expenditures Graph
20,000 •
15,000 ■
t>,000 ■
5,000 t t2008
1 1 . i2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
I--------h I I f
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION146
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL WORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET
O rgan iza tiona l U n it S um m ary: GEN - M o un ta inv iew
T estim ony S um m ary: SCE-02, V o lum e 8
M ajor P rogram : C apita l P ro jec ts Over $1 M illion
Category:
Detail:
Database ID: 1132 / RO M odel ID: 264
1. W ITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAIL
Program Group
Program
P in#
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
MTNVW CORE BASE
SP E C IF IC -M N TN V IE W
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000107
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
Customer Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Mountainview
8/1/2013
N/A
2015 GRC - C a p ita l E xp en d itu res Forecast
1,500
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 2,865
2014 0
2015 0
2016 0
2017 0
Total 2,865
X
7 (a ). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
MVGS Yucaipa Valley Brine Line Expansion
Mountainview to develop an alternate connection to the SARI line discharge with a project known as the Yucaipa Valley Brine Line Expansion. In 2008 Mountainview purchased the capacity and connection rights to a portion of this line.
Install the 2-mile long pipeline to discharge waste water to as an alternate path to the SARI line utilizing existing SCE transmission line right-of-way.
If the current existing discharge line was ever damaged and the plant could not discharge waste water to the SARI line, the plant would need to shutdown once the waste water tank is full.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
147Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION148
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL WORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET
O rgan iza tiona l U n it S um m ary: GEN - M o un ta inv iew
T estim ony S um m ary: SCE-02, V o lum e 8
M ajor P rogram : C apita l P ro jec ts Over $1 M illion
Category:
Detail:
Database ID: 1133 / RO M odel ID: 265
1. W ITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAIL
Program Group
Program
P in#
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
MTNVW CORE BASE
SP E C IF IC -M N TN V IE W
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000108
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
Customer Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Mountainview
12/1/2013
N/A
2 01 5 GRC - C a p i t a l E x p e n d i t u r e s F o r e c a s t
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 4,180
2014 0
2015 0
2016 0
2017 0
Total 4,180
X
7 (a ). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
MVGS Units 3&4 GT Com pressor Upgrade
Mountainview will upgrade Units 3&4 Gas Turbine Com pressors during the 2013 Major Inspection outage to improve overall reliability. This project once installed will minimize the potential for catastrophic failure.
General Electric (GE) recommended upgrade of all four gas turbine compressors sections during the Major Inspection Overhaul.
GE believes this com pressor upgrade will reduce the failure rate to 1 in 700. Since Mountainview has a CSA with GE we will fo llow their recommendation and maintain a high EAF for Mountainview.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
149Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
150Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
w cdro
WOO) M Ol (O OfOS CO CN t- O CM CO CO t -
05 05 CO CO CO CO 00P c i P P r-~ to cm
'J O C O I f iCO CO CO 00P a i P P
O CO CO CO ' f O)t- lo o
co' rP
h - 05 T f CO CO 00 O "T O "T 05 CN CO 05 T t N CO T-
j O) O 05' CN r-~ h~ CO CN
r-~ cn 05 h -
~ CO CNcn o
co co m
^ CO T- CN CN lO O CN T- "T CO**CN
h- 05 CO
CO CO 05 CN
CO 05 TO h - CO CO CO t-co' c riCN
CO 10 O P CO CO S CO s
CO CO CO O 05 CO 05 CO CO 05' co' CN o m s CO 05 t - CN cri CN
^ CO M T-co co coP CO P Pr-~ co coO CO CN
05 CO h- N" CO S T- fO ^
05 CO . CO s
h - h - CN
CO (O Tt CN 05 lO CO CO CN
co' ■'tf' CO CO 00 05 CO t-^ cd'WCN
3 r-~ coco' CN CNCO CO
co cn 05N- CO O) T - 05 IC5
05' co" 05 O)
CO O CO S CO 05cn r-~ ■«-
^ C O C O t- CO CO 05 ^ O ^ CN 00r-.‘ co' o>" o o m co co
-3- 05 CO N- CN S t- h - 05
co' coco o
co r-- o• COO)CO h- CO
co' PCN CO
t-_ CN C0_co' co' o>" ^ CO o CO CN CN O' I--'4* CN
j co o' o>"CO hO CO
05 CO CO CN CO t- t - 05 T t
If)" COoCO CN
CN CN CN O N CN O' I--'4* CN
J N- (75r-~'m"05 O 05
COCO N O If lP CO P Pr-~ 05 co
r-~ cnN- 05 inCO h- CN
05 CO05PSin “
CO S CO t-
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
151Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET
Organizational Unit Summary: GEN - Mountainview Testimony Summary: SCE-02, Volume 8 Major Program: Capital Projects Over $1 Million Category:Detail:Database ID: 1134 / RO Model ID: 266
1. WITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAILProgram Group
Program
P in #
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
M TNVW CORE BASE
S P E C IF IC -M N TN V IE W
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000110
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
Custom er Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Mountainview
12/1/2013
N/A
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 1,675
2014 0
2015 0
2016 0
2017 0
Total 1,675
X
7(a). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
MVGS Unit 3B Compressor Stub Shaft
During the 2012 spring outage an inspection determined cracks on the R0 blades o f the Unit 3B gas turbine com pressor section. To avoid further damage the R0 blades were removed and replaced. Removal resulted in damage to the stub-shaft, which then would n
Replace the gas turbine CTG-3B stub-shaft during the Major Inspection overhaul in October of 2013.
GE's recommendation is to replace the stub-shaft to maintain high reliability o f the the gas turbine. Our CSA requires us to fo llow GE's recommendation and TIL's.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
152Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET: ROUTINE BUSINESS REPLACEMENT
Organizational Unit Summary: GEN - Mountainview Testimony Summary: SCE-02, Volume 8 Major Program: Capital Projects Over $1 Million Category: BlanketDetail: Routine Business Replacement Database ID: 1129 / RO Model ID: 261
1. WITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAILProgram Group
Program
P in #
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
M TNVW CORE BASE
BLANKET - M NTNVIEW
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000101
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
X
Custom er Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
General Other
Blanket
N/A
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 68
2014 71
2015 73
2016 75
2017 77
2 015 GRC • C a p ita l E xp en d itu res Forecast
Total 364 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
7(a). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
MVGS Tools Blanket (068)
Blanket Orders fo r Furniture & Equipment
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
Blanket work orders are used fo r pre-established capital expenditure accounts to record costs for annually recurring additions and replacements of furniture, office equipment such as computers, tools, s im ilar items, and capital spare parts.
Tools, furniture and equipment are needed support fo r safe and reliable operation of the plant.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
153_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL WORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET
O rgan iza tiona l U n it S um m ary: GEN - M o un ta inv iew
T estim ony S um m ary: SCE-02, V o lum e 8
M ajor P rogram : C apita l P ro jec ts Over $1 M illion
Category: P ro jec t < $1M
Detail:
Database ID: 1131 / RO M odel ID: 263
1. W ITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAIL
Program Group
Program
P in#
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
MTNVW CORE BASE
GENERAL - MNTNVIEW
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000104
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
S e le c t o n e
Customer Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Mountainview
Specific Blanket
N/A
2 01 5 GRC - C a p i t a l E x p e n d i t u r e s F o r e c a s t
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 0
2014 525
2015 0
2016 0
2017 0
Total 525
7 (a ). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
MVGS Various Mountain View Projects
This project connects the current station storm water discharge line into the city of Redlands system.
This project will construct a storm water treatment system, a new concrete headwall, and a connection into the city of Redlands system.
This project provide an alternate route to the Santa Ana river which will prevent overflows at the station.
X
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION154
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET
Organizational Unit Summary: GEN - MountainviewTestimony Summary: SCE-02, Volume 8Major Program: Capital Projects Over $1 MillionCategory: Spare PartsDetail:Database ID: 1130 / RO Model ID: 262
1. WITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAILProgram Group
Program
P in #
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
M TNVW CORE BASE
BLANKET - M NTNVIEW
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000103
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
Custom er Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Mountainview
Blanket
N/A
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 819
2014 675
2015 1,000
2016 820
2017 620
2 015 GRC • C a p ita l E xp en d itu res Forecast
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
0Total 3,934 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
7 (a ). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
MVGS Capital Spare Parts
Mountainview Blanket for Capital Spare Parts
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
Blanket work orders are used for pre-established capital expenditure accounts to record costs for annually recurring additions and replacements of furniture, office equipment such as computers, tools, sim ilar items, and capital spare parts.
Tools, furniture and equipment are needed support for safe and reliable operation of the plant.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
155_________________ Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
Southern California Edison Company
CAPITAL W ORKPAPERS - 2015 GRC
PROJECT DETAIL W ORKSHEET: ROUTINE BUSINESS REPLACEMENT
Organizational Unit Summary: GEN - Mountainview Testimony Summary: SCE-02, Volume 8 Major Program: Office Furniture and Equipment Category: BlanketDetail: Routine Business Replacement Database ID: 1128 / RO Model ID: 260
1. WITNESS
2. PROJECT DETAILProgram Group
Program
P in #
WBS Element
3. PROJECT TYPE
Scott M esser
M TNVW CORE BASE
BLANKET - M NTNVIEW
5456
CG0-00-PP-MV-000100
Select one
Compliance: Safety, Environmental, Licenses
Replacements in Kind
Upgrades
Blanket: FE, Tools, Spare Parts, Lab, Com puter Equip
Select one
X
Custom er Growth
Load Growth
Reliability
Capitalized Software
Various (See Below)
4. ASSET TYPE
5. CLOSE DATE
6. RIIM ELIGIBLE
Furniture & Equipment
Blanket
N/A
7. COST ESTIMATES (NOMINAL $000)
Yr SCE $
2013 24
2014 56
2015 58
2016 60
2017 62
Total 260
7(a). SYSTEM SHORT TEXT
7 (b). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
MVGS F&E Blanket (072)
Blanket Orders fo r Furniture & Equipment
8. SCOPE
9. JUSTIFICATION
Blanket work orders are used fo r pre-established capital expenditure accounts to record costs for annually recurring additions and replacements o f furniture, office equipment such as computers, tools, s im ilar items, and capital spare parts.
Tools, furniture and equipment are needed support fo r safe and reliable operation o f the plant.
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
156Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION___________________
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
157Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
COM/MPl/rbg/hkr Date of Issuance 3/17/2009
Decision 09-03-025 March 12,2009
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Application of SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U338E) for Authority to, Among Other Things,Increase Its Authorized Revenues For Electric Service in 2009, And to Reflect That Increase In Rates.
And Related Matter.
Application 07-11-011 (Filed November 19, 2007)
Investigation 08-01-026
(See Appendix A for a list of appearances.)
ALTERNATE DECISION OF PRESIDENT PEEVEY ON TEST YEAR 2009 GENERAL RATE CASE FOR SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
376795
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION158
A.07-11-011,1.08-01-026 COM/MPl/rbg/hkr
requests a reduction of $23,333 for the Rush Creek Heliport Brush Clearing and
$230,000 for Big Creek Vegetation Management, for a total reduction of $253,333
to SCE's TY 2009 forecast. In response, SCE explains that the project recorded in
FERC Account 539 will involve more than brush clearing. The helicopter landing
site must be moved and a new heliport site constructed, which requires that
vegetation be removed and the site graded and covered with rock. Based on the
information provided by SCE, the amount requested is reasonable.
2.4. Gas-Fired Generation
2.4.1. Mountainview O&M Expenses
Consistent with D.03-12-059, D.04-03-037 and D.04-04-019, SCE acquired
Mountainview Power Company, LLC (MVL) as a wholly-owned SCE subsidiary
and executed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) for cost recovery with MVL
for electricity from MVL's Mountainview Generating Station (Mountainview).70
In this proceeding, SCE asks the Commission for permission to include
Mountainview in rate base and allow recovery of Mountainview's operating
costs through its TY 2009 forecast. In addition, Mountainview's capital costs
would no longer be recovered as purchased power costs, through the operation
of the ERRA, but would instead be recovered in SCE's authorized base
generation revenue requirement and through rates, The fuel costs and
availability and heat rate incentive payments will still be recovered through the
70 Mountainview has a nominal output of 1,050 MW. It went into initial commercial service in December 2005 and full commercial service in January 2006, It also includes two retired units (Units 1 & 2) that SCE plans to decommission in 2009. Mountainview currently recovers capital, and non-fuel O&M expenses and A&G expenses associated with Units 3 & 4 through a FERC approved PPA with SCE. SCE is responsible for dispatching Mountainview, purchasing fuel, and any decommissioning costs.
- 3 1 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
159Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
A.07-11-011,1.08-01-026 COM/MPl/rbg/hkr
annual operation of the ERRA balancing account process. SCE states if the
Commission does not approve of its request now, it will not terminate the PPA
and, instead, continue to recover its Mountainview operating costs through the
FERC-jurisdictional PPA.71 SCE's TY 2009 forecast for Mountainview O&M is
$42,505 million (constant 2006$). SCE made future adjustments totaling
$13,779 million to 2006 recorded costs to compute its TY 2009 forecast.
In response to SCE's request to operate Mountainview as a utility-owned
generation facility, DRA raises various concerns related to SCE's proposed cost
recovery, not to the transfer of ownership. TURN's recommendations for
Mountainview are related to SCE's request for peaker O&M and related capital
and will be addressed in a separate section of this decision.
DRA recommends $41.5 million in O&M expenses for TY 2009 for
Mountainview. DRA reduces SCE's TY 2009 forecast by $1 million to remove
$0,454 million for additional staff and $0.5 million for "Additional Future
Projects (Unforeseen)."72 According to DRA, the Commission should not
increase funding in TY 2009 for retirements that may occur over "the next several
years" and for Additional Future Projects (Unforeseen) that in DRA's view are
an unsupported contingency.
SCE defends the cost of seven additional employees, all of whom SCE
hired in 2008, to address increased workload at Mountainview. Regarding the
amounts forecasted in Additional Future Projects (Unforeseen), SCE says the
funding is needed for projects to address areas of concern that have arisen since
71 A.07-11-011, pp. 4-5.72 Exhibit SCE-2N, p. 42,
- 3 2 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION160
A.07-11-011,1.08-01-026 COM/MPl/rbg/hkr
mid-2007 and would be reflected in recorded cost history if Mountainview were
an older plant.73
We find that SCE has adequately explained and justified the additional
employees and the Unallocated Future O&M projects. Thus, we find SCE's
TY 2009 O&M forecast for Mountainview reasonable. However, we do not
anticipate approving any amounts for Additional Future Projects (Unforeseen) in
SCE's next GRC because historical data should reflect these expenses. In
addition, we approve the transfer of ownership. While the Commission in
D.03-12-059 found "... that unless Edison decides to purchase Mountainview as
utility owned generation, a CPCN is not necessary,"74 we addressed all necessary
CPCN and CEQA matters in A.03-07-032. When finalized, this transfer will place
Mountainview under Commission-jurisdictional ratemaking. However, this
change in ratemaking cannot occur until FERC issues a decision approving
termination of the existing power purchase contract.
2.4.2. Peaker O&M - FERC Accounts 546, 548, 549, 551, 553, 554
SCE proposes O&M expenses of $9.7 million in TY 2009 to operate its
five new peakers (constant 2006$).75 The TY 2009 forecast includes $3,214 million
for labor expense. In total, SCE's TY 2009 forecast for non-labor costs, which
73 Exhibit SCE-16E, p. 6.74 D.03-12-059, p. 22 and p. 57.75 SCE filed a separate application in late 2007, A. 07-12-029. That application is pending and seeks approval and recovery in rates of the initial capital costs for these five new peakers. This separate application also requests recovery of O&M expenses starting from plant commercial operation up to the effective date of a decision in that proceeding. This 2009 GRC considers recovery of (1) the O&M expenses commencing on the effective date of a decision in that proceeding and (2) capital expenditures incurred after start-up.
- 3 3 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
161Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
COM / SKI / hamMAILED 07/16/2004
Decision 04-07-022
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Application of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) For Authority to, Among Other Things, Increase Its Authorized Revenues For Electric Service in 2003, And to Reflect That Increase in Rates.
Investigation on the Commission's Own Motion into the Rates, Operations, Practices, Service and Facilities of Southern California Edison Company.
Application 02-05-004 (Filed May 3,2002)
Investigation 02-06-002 (Filed June 6,2002)
(See Appendix A for a list of appearances.)
OPINION ON BASE RATE REVENUE REQUIREMENT AND OTHER PHASE 1 ISSUES
176721 - 1
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION161a
' - ■< 3 . ' ‘ ‘
A.02-05-004 COM/SKI/ham ' ' ■■ / ' ■ . ■ . ■
this section, we address general principles applicable to forecasts of both
expenses and capital expenditures.8 , .
2.4.1. Averaging and Other Methodologies. Several different methods can be used to calculate test year estimates of
expenses- These include linear trending, averaging, last recorded year, and
budget based estimates. In PG&E's 1999 GRC, the Commission summarized
certain methodological issues as follows:
. The Commission has recognized that there are different valid and acceptable methods for account-by-account forecasting test year costs in a GRC, including using a single recorded year's expenses . . .and using multi-year average recorded costs The question athand is which of these two. methods yields the most accurate and reliable forecast of test year expenses. In PG&E’s test year 1990 GRC . the Commission described the following criteria for developing a base estimate of test year expenses: '
i ■ i► s. ,
If recorded expenses in an account have been relatively stable for ’three or more years, the 1987 recorded expense is an appropriate base estimate for 1990. .
r ' ■
If recorded expenses in an account have shown a trend in a certain ,direction over three or more years, the 1987 level is the most recent point in the trend and is an appropriate base estimate for 1990.
For those accounts which have significant fluctuations in recorded expenses from year to year, or which are influenced by weather or • other external forces beyond the control of the utility, an average of recorded expenses oyer a period of time (typical four years) is a
.8 Unless indicated otherwise, references to Operations and Maintenance (O&M) expenses are in year 2000 dollars and references to capital expenditures and capital plant additions are in nominal dollars. '■ ■
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
161bWorkpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
A.02-05-004 COM/SKI/ham • ' ' ' • ' ' ’
reasonable base expense for the. 1990 test year. (D.89-12rQ57,34 ’ ; .. CPUC 2d 199,231.) ' , . ' . , '
With respect to a particular account in that GRC (Account 588)/ the ■
‘ Commission went on to state: .- 1 i •
Absent a specific explanation of why 1987 Recorded data best reflects the estimated 1990 expenses of an account with fluctuating expense levels and no discernible trends, w eiin d it most appropriate to use a , .four-year average as the base 1990 estimate. (Id., 238.) '
• (Re Pacific Gas arid Electric Co., D.00-02-046, pp. 156-157 (quoting, ■ ■D.89-12-057,34 CPUC 2d 199).)' . ' . '
-While the foregoing passage arose in the context of electric d istr ibu tion s.
expenses/ the principles are consistent with findings the Commission has made, in
the context of other expense categories; For example, the Commission addressed
forecasting methodologies in a 1989 decision on a water utility's request for a rate
increase: , . 1 ■ ' ' ' '
Where it is clear that there is a trend of increasing expenses which cannot be explained by inflation alone, and that such increases are ,. necessarily incurred in providing utility service, less weight should . ,
. be given to the constant dollar averaging method. On the otherhand, where it appears that an expense category is subject to year-to- year variations, constant dollar averaging may be a more . •
’ appropriate method to smooth out such variations. (Re California . Water Service, D.89-04-060,31 CPUC 2d 481,-506.) ■ ' ‘ .
Discussion . .
, The forecasting principles discussed' in D.00-02-046, D.89-12-057, and
D.89-04-06.0, quoted above, are generally appropriate and applicable here. Many
accounts reflect significant spending fluctuations from year to year, and in the
. absence of'information to the contrary (for example/information that expenses
have been stable over time and no discernible upwards or downwards trend
' ' ^ . '
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION162
A.02-05-004 COM/ SKI / ham
DiscussionOver 82% of the capital expenditures planned for Four Corners are focused
on production reliability. Planned expenditures include replacement of turbine
blades, boiler tubes, steam condensers, tubular air preheaters, and other
components that would cause a shutdown if they failed. In its direct testimony,
SCE identified and described 48 separate capital projects with a total cost of
$18,858 million (SCE share). Two projects alone, replacement (retubing) of the
Unit 5 main steam condenser and replacement of the tubular air preheater,
required more than $3.8 million to complete in 2002, In other words, the costs for
just these two projects exceed ORA's entire capital forecast for 2002,
We conclude that a forecast based upon a five-year average is
inappropriate for Four Corners. Because the greatest part of Four Corners'
capital expenditures are for reliability, we are concerned that adoption of ORA's
recommended level of expenditures could, if implemented by the operating
agent, significantly impact production reliability at Four Corners. We will adopt
SCE's project-specific test year forecast for Four Corners capital expenditures.
3.4.2. Four Corners O&M Expenses
Recorded/adjusted Four Corners O&M expenses were $25,727, $20,921,
$19,691, $22,363, and $27,208 million (2000 dollars, SCE share) in the years 1996
through 2000 respectively. SCE explains that while expenses were relatively flat
from 1997 to 1999, they were higher in 1996 and 2000 due to large overhaul
outages. Using five-year averages for all FERC accounts to smooth out the effect
of the outages, SCE forecast test year 2003 O&M expense of $23,182 million for
Four Corners. SCE notes that the 1996-2000 recorded expenses used in its
forecast are among the lowest recorded over the last 21 years of data examined
(using constant 2000 dollars).
- 7 2 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
163Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
A.02-05-004 COM/ SKI/ ham .
ORA accepted SCE's five-year averaging methodology for FERC
operations Accounts 500.15 through 507.15, because their recorded expenditures
were constant. ORA proposes that three-year averages (1997-1999) be used for
FERC maintenance Accounts 510.015 through 514.015 because the year 2000
indicates substantial increases in maintenance costs as a result of a major
overhaul. Since no major overhauls are planned for the test year, and the next
one had been planned for 2006,25 ORA concluded that the test year forecast
should exclude such costs. ORA's method yields a forecast of $9,994 million for
Four Corners O&M, which is $2,384 million less than SCE's forecast of $12,378
million for maintenance accounts.
Discussion
SCE contends that by excluding 1996 and 2000 from the average, ORA's
proposal would not compensate SCE for major overhaul outages such as those
experienced in 1996 and 2000. Although there is no major outage overhauls
planned for Four Corners in 2003, SCE has shown that a major overhaul will
occur in 2004. ORA's use of a three-year average would underfund SCE for an
overhaul in 2004 by inappropriately excluding years in which a major overhaul
occurred. We believe the appropriate forecast is SCE's use of a five-year average
because although there is no major overhaul planned in the test year of 2003,
there is indeed one planned for 2004. We are cognizant that the purpose of this
GRC is to determine the just and reasonable rates for the 2003 test year, yet we do
25 SCE stated in its rebuttal testimony that, in August 2002, it learned that APS was planning a major overhaul of Unit 4 in 2004 See Exhibit 288, p,17, fn, 25. Further, although we do notcondone the use of rebuttal testimony to update utility showings, we will make an exception in this case for consistency with our adoption of updated O&M costs for Palo Verde.
- 7 3 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION164
A.02-05-004 COM/SKI/ham
not want to create the incentive for utilities to schedule major projects for the test
year because we believe this will unnecessarily overfund the utilities in the post
test years before its next GRC.
SCE's methodology for Four Corners maintenance accounts is reasonable
and yields the better forecast. SCE's proposal to use a five-year average to
forecast test year 2003 O&M expense of $23,182 million for Four Corners is
therefore adopted.
3.5. Hydroelectric Generation
SCE operates and maintains 36 hydroelectric (hydro) generating plants
consisting of 79 generating units with an aggregate 1,156 MW of capacity. Some
of the facilities have exceeded 100 years of age, and most were constructed at
least 50 years ago. Initial plant service dates range from 1893 to 1999.
3.5.1. Hydroelectric Capital Expenditures
Using project-specific analysis, SCE forecasts capital expenditures of
$17,691 million in 2002 and $15,121 million in 2003 for its hydro system, a total of
$32,812 million. These forecasted amounts are somewhat lower than the
1996-1999 average annual level of expenditures of $19,670 million.
As with SCE's other generation forecasts, ORA found that in its opinion
SCE failed to provide adequate project-specific information. ORA therefore
recommends a four-year average of historical expenditures as the basis for the
capital expenditures forecast. ORA's approach yields a forecast of
$14,432 million for each of the years 2002 and 2003, or a two-year total of $28,864
million. This represents a forecast that is $3,948 million less than SCE's two-year
forecast of $32,812 million.
- 7 4 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
165Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
ALJ/DKF/avs Mailed 5/17/2006
Decision 06-05-016 May 11,2006
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Application of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) For Authority to, Among Other Things, Increase Its Authorized Revenues For Electric Service in 2006, And to Reflect That Increase in Rates.
Investigation on the Commission's Own Motion into the Rates, Operations, Practices, Service and Facilities of Southern California Edison Company,
Application 04-12-014 (Filed December 21, 2004)
Investigation 05-05-024 (Filed May 26,2005)
(See Appendix A for a List of Appearances.)
OPINION ON SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY’S TEST YEAR 2006 GENERAL RATE INCREASE REQUEST
233335 - 1
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION166
A.04-12-014,1.05-05-024 ALJ/DKF/avs
20. SCE's forecast of O&M expenses and capital related costs associated with
the temporary shutdown of Mohave are reasonable.
21. The sale of Mohave sulfur credits will result in substantial revenues to
SCE.
22. The future operating status of Mohave is unknown at this time, and
consideration of the Coalition's Just Transition Plan is premature.
23. The amount of money at risk related to the anticipated 2008 outage at
Four Corners does not justify establishing a new ratemaking mechanism for
overhaul outages,
24. It is reasonable to spread the forecasted cost of the anticipated 2008
overhaul at Four Corners over three years to normalize the anticipated cost.
25. Regarding project development cost associated with proposed
utility-owned generation opportunities, SCE should be subject to the same cost
recovery risks as faced by independent producers.
26. SCE's proposed Project Development Division provides certain desirable
support functions. It is reasonable to give SCE the opportunity to reflect such
costs in rates.
27. For the purposes of this GRC, the August 13, 2005 MOU provides a
reasonable basis for SCE and CPSD to address General Order 95 and
128 violation issues. It is reasonable for SCE and CPSD to continue to work out
details for establishing and implementing the new maintenance program.
28. The August 29,2005, SCE, DRA and TURN stipulation regarding the
Priority 5 issue is reasonable, consistent with law and in the public interest.
29. SCE's current opportunity maintenance approach to Priority 5
maintenance is compliant with D.04-04-065.
- 353 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
167Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
A pplication No.: Exhibit No,: W itnesses:
A. 13-04-001 SCE-01 D .S n o w T. W atson T. Condit S. M esser R. Hite R. Perez G. H am m ond
V. Nazareth K . Yhip T. Frontino T. Cameron R. Drum mond M. Palm strom G. Flores
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
EDISONA n E D I S O N I N T E R N A T I O N A L ® C o m p an y
(U 338-E) .
Energy Resource Recovery A ccount (ERRA) Review O f Operations, 2012 Chapters I-VIII Public Version
PUBLIC VERSION
B efore the
Public Utilities Com m ission o f the State o f California
Rosem ead, California
April 2, 2013
!
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
]
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
i i
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION168
Fuel is com m only the m ajor operating cost component o f gas turbine-based pow er plants (like
M ountainview ) that burn natural gas and operate for significant time periods during the year. To
encourage fuel efficiency, M ountainview is subject to a fuel efficiency incentive program , The
incentive, w hich the Com mission retained in its decision in SCE’s 2009 General Rate C ase (GRC),
D .09-03-025, specifies that M ountainview shall conduct a test o f its heat rate tw ice a year, directly
follow ing the com pletion o f the spring and fall scheduled outages A The test results are adjusted for
variables beyond the control o f M ountainview personnel, such as weather and expected normal
equipm ent degradation. The adjusted “as tested” heat rate is then com pared to the adjusted “as new ”
heat rate established w hen the plant first entered service in January o f 2006. The incentive provides for
a bonus (or penalty) o f 50% o f the incremental fuel costs w hen the tested heat rate is m ore than a 3%
bandw idth above, or a 3% bandwidth below, the “as new ” heat rate (i.e., a total bandw idth o f 6%).
Specifically, SCE earns a bonus i f the tested heat rate is less than 97% o f the “as new ” heat rate, and
conversely, SCE incurs a penalty if the tested heat rate exceeds 103% o f the “as new ” heat rate .52
Consistent w ith prior years, the two heat rate tests conducting during the R ecord Period showed
that M ountainview continued to operate w ithin the 6% bandwidth. Therefore, during the Record Period,
M ountainview did not earn any heat rate incentive bonuses, and did not pay any heat rate incentive
penalties. This dem onstrates excellent fuel efficiency perform ance, as it is not realistically possible to
achieve a 3% or more fuel efficiency im provem ent com pared to the heat rate target that was established
w hen the plant was new. ■
2. Vloiintaiiivicvv’s Reliability D uring the R ecord Period
Reliable operation is also an im portant objective for M ountainview, To encourage plant
reliability (measured as plant “availability” ), M ountainview is subject to a reliability incentive program.
5h H eat rate is a m easure (in Btu per kW h) o f the average am ount o f natural gas fuel consum ed for each kW h o f electricity produced, over a g iven period o f lime.
52 F or exam ple, if tile test revealed a low er h e a t rate (i.e ., a b e tte r heat rate) that w as 95% o f the “as new ” heat rate, then SC E would receive h a lf o f 2% (97% m inus 95% ) o f its natural gas fuel cost as a bonus for superior heat rate perform ance, This 1 % bonus w ould then be applied to the total cost o f fuel fo r the proceeding w inter. So, if that fuel cost w as $200 m illion, then SCE w ould be aw arded a bonus o f $2.0 million.
-73-
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
I
z
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1 1
12
13
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
This incentive program was retained by the Commission in D .09-03-025. M ountainview availability is
computed for each sum m er and winter season, and is com pared to a target v a lu e d The com putation o f
M ountainview availability is similar' to the computation o f EAF, as discussed above for the SCE
Peakers. Like EAF, the M ountainview availability com putation is based on the hours o f forced outages,
scheduled outages, and derates dining a calendar year . 2
M ountainview ’s summ er availability target is 97% , which is appreciably h igher than the w inter
target because the value o f capacity is generally higher during summer. W ith such a high target, routine
maintenance outages are generally not scheduled for the summer.
The w inter availability target varies between 92% and 79% as shown in Table V-25. The winter
target incorporates expected planned outages for routine annual m aintenance, including ho t gas path
(HOP) inspections and major inspection (M I) overhauls that are periodically conducted on the gas
turbines. During 2012, the winter availability incentive target was 92%, because no H.GP inspections or
MI inspections w ere conducted during this year. ■
Table V-25 SCE Mountainview Availability Targets
Plmuied M ain tenance Km tuner W inter
Base (No M ajor Maint) 97.0 92.0HGP on One Uni t 97.0 88.0HGP on Both Units 97.0 85.0M ajor Overhaul on One Unit 97.0 85.0M aior Overhaul on Both Units 97.0 79.0
^ Summer is defined as June through September, W inter is defined as October through M ay. The availability incentive is adm inistered oil a calendar year basis.
22 Under the PPA, the availability com putation also included M oim tainvicw ’s adherence to the hourly scheduled output requested o f it each day. In D.09-03-025, the Com m ission also approved a revision to the hourly scheduled output com ponent o f the availability calculation formula given that M ountainview is not being used as an hourly block-loaded resource. Rather, M ountainview M W output is routinely ram ped up and down within anti across each clock hour, as part o f SCE’s LCD practices and in conform ance with the current CA1 SO five-m inute RT dispatch m arket structure. In 2 0 12, winter and sum m er availability w ere determ ined in accordance with the revision approved in, D.09-03-025. This practice w as discussed in detail in S C E ’s 2010 Record Period ERRA review proceeding,
-74-
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION170
The sum m er availability annual incentive provides an award/penalty o f $360,000 for each
percentage point o f availability perform ance above/below the 97% ta rg e t.^ The m axim um annual
sum m er availability award/penalty is $1,080,000. To receive the maxim um award SCE m ust attain
perfect sum m er perform ance (i.e., 100% availability), which is 3% higher than the 97% sum m er target,
The 3% is then m ultiplied by the bonus factor o f $360,000 per percentage point, which yields a bonus o f
$1,080,000. Conversely, to receive the maximum penalty, SCE’s perform ance m ust be at least 3%
below the 97% sum m er target (i.e., 94% or lower).
Likewise, the annual w inter availability incentive provides an aw ard/penalty o f $60,000 for
percentage point o f perform ance above/below the target. In theory, M ountainview could achieve a
w inter availability o f 100% in years w here no IiG P or m ajor overhauls w ere perform ed, assum ing no
planned outages were taken that w inter for routine annual maintenance. Achieving a w inter availability
o f 100% would be 8% higher than the 92% w inter target implicit in such a scenario, which equates to a
maxim um w inter bonus o f $480,000 (i.e., 8% multiplied by the $60,000 bonus per percentage point).£l
The availability incentive m echanism was therefore designed so that the m axim um penalty is also
$480,000 per w in ter season (i.e., i f actual w inter availability perform ance is m ore than 8% lower than
the winter target, then the bonus calculation uses a default value that is set at 8% below the target).
As sum m arized in Table V -26, in 2012 M ountainview achieved a sum m er and w inter availability
perform ance tha t exceeded the respective targets. This dem onstrates excellent reliability perform ance.
Specifically, M ountainview achieved a sum m er availability o f 99.59% and a w inter availability o f
Si Unless otherw ise indicated, all heat ra le incentive am ounts in this section are in 2003 dollars. The incentive m echanism includes annua! adjustm ent o f these 2003 dollar amounts to account for inflation.
h i In a best case scenario, it w ould take several days o f outage tim e to conduct either an HOP inspection or a m ajoroverhaul. T hus, it is not possible to achieve 100% w inter availability i f that w ork is conducted during the w inter season. Also, because the summer availability incentive bonus rate is higher than the w inter bonus rale, it is not econom ic to conduct routine m aintenance, including HOP inspections or m ajor overhauls, in sum m er rather than winter.
-75-
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
S
9
10
II'
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
94.40%. This yields an availability incentive bonus paym ent o f $1,322,522 (in $2012) for 2012,
including the inflation adjustm ent.^
Table V-26 SCE Mountainview
2012 Availability
Summer WinterActual Availability 99.59 94.40Target Availability 97,00 92.00Percent Better than Target '2.59 2.40
3. O utage Events
M ountainview experienced 10 outages during the Record Period, as sum m arized in Table V-27.
Table V-27 SCE Mountainview
2012 Outages
P u r p o s eS c h e d u l e d F o r c e d
N u m b e r H o u r s N u m b e r H o u r sS p ring / F a 11Rel iabi l i ly 0 u t a g e s 4 645 0 00 ther E q u i p m e n t R e p a i r s 0 0 6 29
T o t a l = 4 645 6 29
a) Scheduled Outages
M ountainview experienced four scheduled outages during the Record Period, consisting o f two
spring and two fall planned outages (i.e., one spring and one fall outage on each unit). The four planned
outages totaled 645 hours, averaging less than seven days per outage. W ork accom plished during the
spring outage included inspection o f the gas turbine lire protection system s, and borescope inspection of
tire gas turbines. W ork accomplished during the fall maintenance outages included annual inspection of
all four heat recovery steam generators and their associated auxiliary systems.
& In order to financially record the 2 0 12 availability incentive in D ecem ber 2012, the incentive was estim ated at$1,153,200 based on preliminary M icroG ads availability figures. An additional accounting entry was then m ade in 2012 to “true up” the December 2012 estim ate for the actual final com puted incentive o f $1,322,522.19 (in $2012).
-76-
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION172
ALJ/MD2/lil/gd2/jt2 Date of Issuance 12/10/2012
Decision 12-11-051 November 29, 2012
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Application of Southern California Edison Company (U338E) for Authority to, Among Other Things, Increase Its Authorized Revenues For Electric Service in 2012, And to Reflect That Increase In Rates.
Application 10-11-015 (Filed November 23, 2010)
(See Appendix A for Service List)
DECISION ON TEST YEAR 201 2 GENERAL RATE CASE FOR SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
37668274 - 1 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
173Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION
A.10-11-015 ALJ/MD2/lil/gd2/jt2
We agree that the Commission and the public should be able to track the
progress of previously authorized large capital projects. Therefore, we have
directed in Section 2.5 that SCE include an exhibit in future rate cases that
facilitates public tracking of large generation, transmission, and distribution
projects authorized in a prior GRC.
4.4. Generation - Gas-Fired Generation4.4.1. Mountainview
Mountainview Power Plant (Mountainview), located in Redlands
California, has a nominal electrical output of 1,054 MW. Mountainview began
full commercial service in January 2006. It consists of two retired units87 and
two modern combined-cycle operating units (Units 3 and 4) that contain both
natural gas and steam turbines intended for load-following operation.
4.4.1.1. O&M Expenses: FERC 546, 548-554
SCE forecasts TY2012 O&M expenses of $49.042 million for Mountainview,
slightly less than 2009 recorded expenses of $49.211 million. The forecast
includes the annualized costs for NERC reliability standards compliance and
prepayment of expenses for a major overhaul planned for 2015.
DRA recommends a reduction of $ 0.307 million in FERC account 546 for
the 2012 increase in NERC-related Labor expenses which it concludes are
unnecessary. Work activities recorded in this account include general
supervision and operations of Mountainview, and some expenses related to
environmental health and safety.
87 Units 1 and 2 were demolished in 2010.
- 69 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer
Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION174
A.10-11-015 ALJ/MD2/lil/gd2/jt2
For FERC 546, SCE asked for a total of $2.772 million ($1.863 million in
Labor, $0.909 million Non-labor), a 27.4% increase over 2009 expenses, based on
increased labor needs to support compliance with NERC reliability standards.
SCE plans to hire two Program Managers and one Engineer just for
Mountainview. SCE argues that recorded costs do not reflect the full cost of
compliance in the future because NERC standards cover many different
operations and tasks, some of which are performed on cycles greater than
one year.88 DRA contends the work should be absorbed by the remaining
$2.4 million request.
We are not persuaded that SCE needs these three positions, at a cost of
$307,000, in order to maintain NERC compliance. These are new plants and SCE
should be able to enjoy some economies and utility from the significant increases
allowed for NERC compliance throughout this decision. SCE also agreed with
DRA to remove a confidential amount forecast for a Hot Gas Path Inspection
prepayment and tax related to a 2015 overhaul.89
Accordingly, the Commission finds it reasonable to reduce the FERC
546 account by $0.307 million of Labor expense and the normalized portion of the
Hot Path Gas Inspection Fee.
4.4.1.2. Capital Expenditures
Recorded expenditures in 2010 were $14.076 million, $2.7 million less than
forecast. SCE requested capital spending for Mountainview of $4.6 million for
88 SCE-02, Vol. 08 at 30.89 SCE-17, Vol. 08 at 1.
- 70 -
Exhibit No. SCE-02 / Generation / Vol. 08Witnesses: A. Kurpakus and S. Messer