s michigan rick snyder department of treasury l …€¦ · this cert which th tangible 1933, as...

180
P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500 855 (Rev. 1-11) RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER May 15, 2013 JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0001, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive Belle River, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $2,978,483. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $2,978,783. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408. Sincerely, Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Upload: others

Post on 21-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0001, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive Belle River, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $2,978,483. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $2,978,783. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 2: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedEast Chcapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appina, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicy of St. Clairal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atn is $2,978,4

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-000

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatr, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 4901 Poin

483.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 29, 1

ol certificate

ion Con01

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 is designed

om the wate

1 of 1994, n control

nte Drive Be

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1999.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Drivd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility proelle River.

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrive Belle Rivated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d

The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Company

ver, Townshy for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 3: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0002, to DTE Electric Company located at 200 Lycaste - Corners Creek Power Plant , in the City of Detroit, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $390,643. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $390,643. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Linda M. Bade, Assessor, City of Detroit Clerk, City of Detroit

Page 4: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCity of Dcapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedthe facilit This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the app

Detroit, Couand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationty entitled to

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicnty of Wayn

al of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at exemption

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-000

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatne, Michiganial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutio200 Lycast

is $390,643

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 5, 19

ol certificate

ion Con02

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 200 Ln, is designeom the wate

1 of 1994, n control te - Corners.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

986.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

Lycaste - Coed and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

s Creek Pow

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriorners Creeated primari with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dwer Plant .

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyek Power Ply for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed in The total co

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as lant ,

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ost of

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 5: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0003, to DTE Electric Company located at 301 Gratiot Boulevard, in the City of Marysville, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $140,156. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $140,156. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Ann M. Ratliff, Assessor, City of Marysville Clerk, City of Marysville

Page 6: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $140,15

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 56.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-000

Public Act 4the facility,ication, locas designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio301 Gratiot

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 12, 1

ol certificate

ion Con03

451 of 1994owned or l

ated at 301 Gand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control t Boulevard

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1987.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DGratiot Boued primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

d . The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriulevard, Citfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dl cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyty of Marystrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

sville, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 7: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0004, to DTE Electric Company located at 1 Belanger Park Drive, in the City of River Rouge, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $886,026. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $886,026. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Philip O. Mastin, III, Assessor, City of River Rouge Clerk, City of River Rouge

Page 8: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $886,02

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 26.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-000

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locatedesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio1 Belanger

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 1

ol certificate

ion Con04

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 1 Belaand operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control r Park Drive

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1984.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by Danger Park d primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

e. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriDrive, City for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof River Ro

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

ouge, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 9: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0022, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $987,381. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $987,381. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 10: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $987,381

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-002

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W 1.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 9, 1969

ol certificate

ion Con22

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

9.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 11: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0273, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $67,600,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $67,600,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 12: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $67,600

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-027

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 12, 199

ol certificate

ion Con73

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

92.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 13: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0274, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $192,009,566. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $192,009,566. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 14: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $192,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at09,566.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-027

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 10, 1

ol certificate

ion Con74

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1988.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 15: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0353, to DTE Gas Company located at N Hamilton Storage Field - Brine Disposal System, in the Township of Frost, Clare County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $75,429. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $75,429. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: James L. Vanwormer, Assessor, Township of Frost Clerk, Township of Frost

Page 16: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedSystem, the contrand with ThereforeCommissapprovedtotal cost This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the appTownship

rol, capture, other provis

e, as providsion herebyd applicationt of the facili

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that proved applicof Frost, Coand remova

sions of the a

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aty entitled to

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-035

Public Act 4the facility

cation, locatounty of Claal of industriaact.

blic Act 451he pollutiot N Hamilto

o exemption

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 1

ol certificate

ion Con53

451 of 1994y, owned oted at N Ha

are, Michiganal waste from

1 of 1994, n control

on Storageis $75,429.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1973.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased bymilton Storn, is designem the water

Part 37, afacility proField - Bri

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE Gasrage Field -ed and oper, complies w

as amendedoperty, as dine Disposa

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company- Brine Disprated primariwith Section

d, the Statedescribed inal System.

control facilim taxation.Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as posal ily for 3703

e Tax n the The

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 17: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0354, to DTE Gas Company located at N Hamilton Storage Field - Brine Disposal System, in the Township of Hayes, Clare County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $45,690. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $45,690. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: James L. Vanwormer, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 18: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedSystem, for the c3703 and ThereforeCommissapprovedtotal cost This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the appTownship

ontrol, captud with other

e, as providsion herebyd applicationt of the facili

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that proved applic

of Hayes, ure, and remprovisions o

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aty entitled to

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-035

Public Act 4the facility

cation, locatCounty of C

moval of indof the act.

blic Act 451he pollutiot N Hamilto

o exemption

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 1

ol certificate

ion Con54

451 of 1994y, owned oted at N Ha

Clare, Michigustrial waste

1 of 1994, n control

on Storageis $45,690.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1973.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased bymilton Storgan, is desige from the w

Part 37, afacility proField - Bri

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE Gasrage Field -gned and owater, comp

as amendedoperty, as dine Disposa

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company- Brine Dispperated prim

plies with Se

d, the Statedescribed inal System.

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as posal marily ection

e Tax n the The

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 19: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0355, to DTE Gas Company located at N Hamilton Storage Field - Brine Disposal System, in the Township of Hamilton, Clare County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $233,569. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $233,569. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Tracy L. Macon, Assessor, Township of Hamilton Clerk, Township of Hamilton

Page 20: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedSystem, primarily Section 3 ThereforeCommissapprovedtotal cost This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the app

Townshipfor the cont

3703 and wit

e, as providsion herebyd applicationt of the facili

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that proved applicp of Hamilttrol, captureth other prov

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aty entitled to

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-035

Public Act 4the facility

cation, locatton, County

e, and removvisions of the

blic Act 451he pollutiot N Hamilto

o exemption

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 1

ol certificate

ion Con55

451 of 1994y, owned oted at N Hay of Clare, val of induste act.

1 of 1994, n control

on Storageis $233,569

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1973.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased bymilton Stor Michigan, trial waste fr

Part 37, afacility proField - Bri

9.

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE Gasrage Field -

is designerom the wate

as amendedoperty, as dine Disposa

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company- Brine Disped and opeer, complies

d, the Statedescribed inal System.

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as posal erated s with

e Tax n the The

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 21: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0358, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $3,223,290. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $3,223,290. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 22: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $3,223,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at,290.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-035

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, le, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 12, 1

ol certificate

ion Con58

451 of 1994owned or located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1987.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D3500 E Frd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriront Streetated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyt, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 23: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0665, to DTE Electric Company located at 755 Huron Avenue, in the City of Harbor Beach, Huron County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $5,223,982. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $5,223,982. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Eric D. Thompson, Assessor, City of Harbor Beach Clerk, City of Harbor Beach

Page 24: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Huron, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $5,223,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, is

waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,982.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-066

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot 755 Huron

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 14, 1

ol certificate

ion Con65

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 755 Hnd operated

complies with

1 of 1994, n control n Avenue.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DHuron Avend primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrinue, City offor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyf Harbor Berol, capture

h other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as each, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 25: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0667, to DTE Electric Company located at 663 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Detroit, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $5,093,200. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $5,093,200. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Linda M. Bade, Assessor, City of Detroit Clerk, City of Detroit

Page 26: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $5,09

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 93,200.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Febr

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-066

Public Act 4the facility,ication, locadesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio663 W Jeff

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ruary 18, 19

ol certificate

ion Con67

451 of 1994owned or l

ated at 663 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control

ferson Aven

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

981.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

nue. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrion Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of De

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

etroit, , and sions

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 27: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0669, to DTE Electric Company located at 200 Lycaste, in the City of Detroit, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $6,654,868. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $6,654,868. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Linda M. Bade, Assessor, City of Detroit Clerk, City of Detroit

Page 28: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedWayne, industria ThereforeCommissapprovedis $6,654 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apMichigan, isl waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application4,868.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

pproved apps designed a

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-066

Public Act 4the facility,

plication, locand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutio200 Lycast

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 5, 19

ol certificate

ion Con69

451 of 1994owned or l

cated at 200ed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control te. The tota

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

986.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D0 Lycaste, for the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

al cost of the

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

City of Detrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as de facility entit

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyetroit, Coun, and remov

visions of the

d, the Statedescribed intled to exem

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the

mption

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 29: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0672, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $2,274,163. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $2,274,163. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 30: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $2,274,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at,163.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Janu

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-067

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

uary 24, 198

ol certificate

ion Con72

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

84.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 31: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0674, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $20,020,533. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $20,020,533. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 32: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $20,020

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a0,533.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-067

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 4901 Poin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 29, 1

ol certificate

ion Con74

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 Pand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control nte Drive.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1994.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Driveed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 33: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0676, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $9,927,743. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $9,927,743. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 34: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $9,927,7

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-067

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W 743.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 12, 1

ol certificate

ion Con76

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1985.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 35: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0677, to DTE Electric Company located at 301 Gratiot Boulevard, in the City of Marysville, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $8,137,238. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $8,137,238. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Ann M. Ratliff, Assessor, City of Marysville Clerk, City of Marysville

Page 36: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $8,137,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at ,238.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-067

Public Act 4the facility,ication, locas designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio301 Gratiot

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 29, 1

ol certificate

ion Con77

451 of 1994owned or l

ated at 301 Gand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control t Boulevard

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1994.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DGratiot Boued primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

d. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriulevard, Citfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyty of Marystrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

sville, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 37: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0678, to DTE Electric Company located at 1 Belanger Park Drive, in the City of River Rouge, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $12,000,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $12,000,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Philip O. Mastin, III, Assessor, City of River Rouge Clerk, City of River Rouge

Page 38: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $12,000

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 0,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-067

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locatedesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio1 Belanger

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 1

ol certificate

ion Con78

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 1 Belaand operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control r Park Drive

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1984.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by Danger Park d primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

e. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriDrive, City for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof River Ro

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

ouge, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 39: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0897, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $7,740,305. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $7,740,305. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

Page 40: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Monroof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appoe, Michiganrial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $7,740,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is designerom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at,305.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-089

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and operer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 14, 1

ol certificate

ion Con97

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 3500 Erated primars with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front Strerily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrieet, City of

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyMonroe, Co

ure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 41: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0898, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $11,476,717. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $11,476,717. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 42: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $11,476

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at6,717.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Febr

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-089

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, le, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ruary 7, 198

ol certificate

ion Con98

451 of 1994owned or located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

89.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D3500 E Frd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriront Streetated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyt, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 43: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0899, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $32,160,004. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $32,160,004. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Catherine A. Cousineau, Assessor, Township of Monroe Clerk, Township of Monroe

Page 44: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Monroe, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $32,160

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0,004.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Aug

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-089

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locat

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

gust 12, 199

ol certificate

ion Con99

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 3500 and operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front St

ed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electritreet, Townsfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyship of Montrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nroe, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 45: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1099, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $9,381,892. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $9,381,892. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 46: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $9,381,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,892.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-109

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locats designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 1

ol certificate

ion Con99

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4505 and operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1996.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DKing Road

ed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrid, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 47: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1353, to DTE Gas Company located at W.C. Taggart Compressor Station, in the Township of Belvidere, Montcalm County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $322,517. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $322,517. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Melissa Zemla, Assessor, Township of Belvidere Clerk, Township of Belvidere

Page 48: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshthe contrand with ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the aip of Belvidrol, capture, other provis

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that approved apdere, County

and removasions of the a

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aemption is $3

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-135

Public Act 4the facility

pplication, ly of Montcalal of industriaact.

blic Act 451he pollutio

at W.C. Tag322,517.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 11, 198

ol certificate

ion Con53

451 of 1994y, owned olocated atlm, Michiganal waste from

1 of 1994, n control

ggart Comp

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

83.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased byW.C. Tagg

n, is designem the water

Part 37, afacility pro

pressor Sta

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE Gasgart Comped and oper, complies w

as amendedoperty, as dation. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company

pressor Starated primariwith Section

d, the Statedescribed intotal cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ation, ily for 3703

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 49: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1445, to DTE Electric Company located at Wastewater Facilities - Containment Dike, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $7,100,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $7,100,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

Page 50: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCity of control, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedthe facilit This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMonroe, C

capture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationty entitled to

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliounty of Mo removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at exemption

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-144

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatonroe, Michindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutiot Wastewateis $7,100,00

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 1

ol certificate

ion Con45

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at Wasthigan, is deaste from the

1 of 1994, n control er Facilities00.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1984.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by Dtewater Facesigned ande water, com

Part 37, afacility pro

s - Containm

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electricilities - Cod operated mplies with S

as amendedoperty, as dment Dike.

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyntainment primarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed inThe total co

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as Dike,

or the 3 and

e Tax n the ost of

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 51: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1702, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $20,036,050. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $20,036,050. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 52: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $20,036

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a6,050.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-170

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 21, 1

ol certificate

ion Con02

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1989.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 53: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1906, to DTE Gas Company located at 17150 Allen Road, in the City of Melvindale, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $24,436. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $24,436. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Anthony F. Fuoco, Assessor, City of Melvindale Clerk, City of Melvindale

Page 54: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the apof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $24,436

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that pproved appMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a6.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-190

Public Act 4the facility

plication, locdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 17150 All

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 21, 1

ol certificate

ion Con06

451 of 1994y, owned ocated at 17and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control len Road.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1989.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased by

7150 Allend primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE GasRoad, Cityfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company

y of Melvintrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as dale, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 55: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1907, to DTE Gas Company located at Frost 2-21 Section 21, in the Township of Washington, Macomb County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $37,083. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $37,083. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Debra K. Susalla, Assessor, Township of Washington Clerk, Township of Washington

Page 56: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedWashingcapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the apgton, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $37,083

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that pproved apy of Macomal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at3.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-190

Public Act 4the facility

pplication, lomb, Michigan

ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot Frost 2-21

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 11, 1

ol certificate

ion Con07

451 of 1994y, owned oocated at Fn, is designeom the wate

1 of 1994, n control Section 21

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1989.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased by

Frost 2-21ed and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

1. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE GasSection 21

ated primari with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company1, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 57: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Gas Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-1908, to DTE Gas Company located at Waschull 1-22 Section 22, in the Township of Washington, Macomb County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $39,317. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $39,317. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Debra K. Susalla, Assessor, Township of Washington Clerk, Township of Washington

Page 58: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedWashingcapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion herebyd in the apgton, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $39,3

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Py finds that proved appy of Macomal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 317.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-190

Public Act 4the facility

lication, locamb, Michigan

ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioWaschull 1

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 11, 1

ol certificate

ion Con08

451 of 1994y, owned oated at Wa

n, is designeom the wate

1 of 1994, n control -22 Section

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1989.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ar leased byschull 1-22

ed and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

n 22. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedy DTE Gas

2 Section 2ated primari with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the States Company22, Townshly for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 59: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2055, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at Verona Charlton SWD Section 12, in the Township of Charlton, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $35,443. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $35,443. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Charlton Clerk, Township of Charlton

Page 60: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aip of Charltcapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

approved apton, County removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aemption is $3

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-205

Public Act 4the facility, opplication, lof Otsego, industrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutioat Verona C35,443.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

ol certificate

ion Con55

451 of 1994owned or lelocated atMichigan, isaste from the

1 of 1994, n control

Charlton SW

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En

Verona Chs designed ae water, com

Part 37, afacility pro

WD Section

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeharlton SWand operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as dn 12. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

WD Sectiond primarily foSection 3703

d, the Statedescribed intotal cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as n 12, or the 3 and

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 61: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2056, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at Charlton 14 Sections 13 & 14, in the Township of Charlton, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $48,952. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $48,952. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Charlton Clerk, Township of Charlton

Page 62: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCharltoncapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the app

n, County oand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicof Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atn is $48,952.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-205

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locatMichigan, isial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot Charlton 1.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

ol certificate

ion Con56

451 of 1994owned or leed at Charlt

s designed om the wate

1 of 1994, n control 14 Sections

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by Enton 14 Sectand operate

er, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

s 13 & 14.

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opetions 13 & 1ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d

The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC14, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 63: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2060, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at Vienna Charlton Wells Section 7, in the Township of Vienna, Montmorency County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $41,269. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $41,269. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Ernest O. Dunham, Assessor, Township of Vienna Clerk, Township of Vienna

Page 64: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Vienncontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appna, County capture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

roved applicof Montmo removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at n is $41,269.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-206

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locateorency, Micindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutioVienna Cha

.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

ol certificate

ion Con60

451 of 1994owned or leed at Viennhigan, is deaste from the

1 of 1994, n control arlton Wells

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by Ena Charltonesigned ande water, com

Part 37, afacility pros Section 7

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest OpeWells Sectd operated mplies with S

as amendedoperty, as d. The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCion 7, Townprimarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as nship or the 3 and

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 65: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2061, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at Vienna Charlton Wells Section 12, in the Township of Charlton, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $49,523. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $49,523. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Charlton Clerk, Township of Charlton

Page 66: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aip of Charltcapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

approved apton, County removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located aemption is $4

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-206

Public Act 4the facility, opplication, lof Otsego, industrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutio

at Vienna C49,523.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

ol certificate

ion Con61

451 of 1994owned or leocated atMichigan, isaste from the

1 of 1994, n control

Charlton We

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En

Vienna Chs designed ae water, com

Part 37, afacility pro

ells Section

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeharlton Weand operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as dn 12. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLClls Sectiond primarily foSection 3703

d, the Statedescribed intotal cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as n 12, or the 3 and

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 67: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2064, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $282,167. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $282,167. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 68: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $282,16

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a67.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Aug

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-206

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 4901 Poin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

gust 12, 199

ol certificate

ion Con64

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 Pand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control nte Drive.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Driveed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 69: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2187, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at Charlton 14 Sections 13 & 14, in the Township of Charlton, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $41,890. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $41,890. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Charlton Clerk, Township of Charlton

Page 70: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCharltoncapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the app

n, County oand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicof Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atn is $41,890.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Sept

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-218

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locatMichigan, isial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot Charlton 1.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

tember 4, 1

ol certificate

ion Con87

451 of 1994owned or leed at Charlt

s designed om the wate

1 of 1994, n control 14 Sections

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

991.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by Enton 14 Sectand operate

er, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

s 13 & 14.

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opetions 13 & 1ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d

The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC14, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 71: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2260, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $67,601. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $67,601. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 72: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $67,601

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at1.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-226

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, le, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 7, 1991

ol certificate

ion Con60

451 of 1994owned or located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D3500 E Frd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriront Streetated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyt, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 73: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2261, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $93,888. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $93,888. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

Page 74: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Monroof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appoe, Michiganrial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $93,888

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is designerom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at8.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-226

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and operer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 7, 1991

ol certificate

ion Con61

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 3500 Erated primars with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front Strerily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrieet, City of

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyMonroe, Co

ure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 75: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2394, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 6C Section 8, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $6,502. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $6,502. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 76: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $6,502.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, oication, loca

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at ASE 6C S

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con94

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEand operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Section 8.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 6C Sectio

d primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 8, Townsfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCship of Chetrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ester, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 77: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2395, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 6B Section 19, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $14,707. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $14,707. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 78: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $14,707

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at7.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locat

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 6B S

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con95

451 of 1994owned or leted at ASE and operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control

Section 19.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En

6B Sectiond primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 19, Townsfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCship of Chetrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ester, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 79: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2396, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5B Section 36, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $25,203. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $25,203. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 80: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $25,203

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appliMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at3.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locat

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 5B S

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con96

451 of 1994owned or leted at ASE and operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control

Section 36.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En

5B Sectiond primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 36, Townsfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCship of Chetrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ester, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 81: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2397, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5-12 Section 12, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $45,249. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $45,249. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 82: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $45,249

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at9.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locates designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 5-12

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con97

451 of 1994owned or leed at ASE 5and operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Section 12.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En5-12 Sectiond primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 12, Townsfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCship of Chetrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ester, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 83: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2398, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 3B Section 4 & Sections 32, 33 & 34, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $126,731. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $126,731. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 84: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedthe facilit This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appip of Chestcapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationty entitled to

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applier, County o removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at exemption

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locatof Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 3B Seis $126,731

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con98

451 of 1994owned or leted at ASE Michigan, is aste from the

1 of 1994, n control ection 4 & S.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En3B Sectiondesigned a

e water, com

Part 37, afacility proSections 32

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 4 & Sectioand operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as d2, 33 & 34.

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCons 32, 33 &d primarily foSection 3703

d, the Statedescribed inThe total co

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as & 34, or the 3 and

e Tax n the ost of

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 85: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2399, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE #2 Sections 27 & 28, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $80,353. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $80,353. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 86: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedChester,capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap, County ofand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $80,3

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appf Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 353.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4the facility, olication, loca

Michigan, is ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioASE #2 Se

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con99

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASE

designed aom the wate

1 of 1994, n control ctions 27 &

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE #2 Sectioand operateer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

& 28. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 27 & 2ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC28, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 87: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2400, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5 Sections 35 & 36, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $190,543. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $190,543. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 88: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedChester,capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap, County ofand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $190

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved appf Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0,543.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oplication, locMichigan, is ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 5 Sec

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con00

451 of 1994owned or lecated at AS

designed aom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ctions 35 &

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnSE 5 Sectioand operateer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro36. The tot

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 35 & 3ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dtal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

36, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 89: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2401, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 3A-25 & ASE 3A-36 Section 25 & 36, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $108,072. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $108,072. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 90: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedthe facilit This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appip of Chestcapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationty entitled to

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applier, County o removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at exemption

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locaof Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 3A-25is $108,072

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con01

451 of 1994owned or leted at ASE Michigan, is aste from the

1 of 1994, n control 5 & ASE 3A.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En

3A-25 & ASdesigned a

e water, com

Part 37, afacility pro

A-36 Section

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest OpeSE 3A-36 S

and operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as dn 25 & 36.

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCSection 25 &d primarily foSection 3703

d, the Statedescribed inThe total co

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as & 36, or the 3 and

e Tax n the ost of

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 91: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2402, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at SCV Sections 2-4, 9-11, 13-16 & 21-23, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $535,030. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $535,030. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 92: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apip of Chestcapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved apper, County o removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atemption is $5

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oplication, locof Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutiot SCV Sectio535,030.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con02

451 of 1994owned or le

cated at SCVMichigan, is aste from the

1 of 1994, n control ons 2-4, 9-1

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnV Sectionsdesigned a

e water, com

Part 37, afacility pro

11, 13-16 &

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opes 2-4, 9-11, and operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as d

21-23. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

13-16 & 2d primarily foSection 3703

d, the Statedescribed ine total cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

21-23, or the 3 and

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 93: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2403, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 4B Sections 6, 7 & 8, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $33,820. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $33,820. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 94: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedHayes, Cand remprovision ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the app

County of Otoval of indu

ns of the act.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $33,8

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appltsego, Michustrial waste.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 820.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, olication, locaigan, is desie from the w

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 4B Se

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con03

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEgned and opwater, comp

1 of 1994, n control

ections 6, 7

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 4B Sectioperated primplies with S

Part 37, afacility pro& 8. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 6, 7 & marily for theSection 3703

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC8, Townsh

e control, cap3 and with

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

hip of pture, other

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 95: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2405, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 4-16 & ASE 4-17 Sections 16 & 17, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $149,363. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $149,363. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 96: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appip of Hayescapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls, County of removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at emption is $1

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oication, locaf Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 4-16 &

149,363.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con05

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASE

Michigan, is daste from the

1 of 1994, n control

& ASE 4-17

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 4-16 & ASdesigned ane water, com

Part 37, afacility proSections 1

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest OpeSE 4-17 Send operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as d6 & 17. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

ections 16 & primarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed ine total cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as & 17, or the 3 and

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 97: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2406, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 1 Sections 22 & 27, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $131,301. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $131,301. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 98: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedHayes, Cand remprovision ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap

County of Otoval of indu

ns of the act.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $131

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved apptsego, Michustrial waste.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at1,301.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oplication, locigan, is desie from the w

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 1 Sec

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con06

451 of 1994owned or lecated at ASgned and opwater, comp

1 of 1994, n control

ctions 22 &

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnSE 1 Sectioperated primplies with S

Part 37, afacility pro27. The tot

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 22 & 2marily for theSection 3703

as amendedoperty, as dtal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

27, Townshe control, cap3 and with

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of pture, other

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 99: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2407, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 7B Section 20, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $23,139. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $23,139. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

Page 100: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedLake, Coand remprovision ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appounty of Otsoval of indu

ns of the act.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $23,139

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applsego, Michigustrial waste.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at9.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oication, locagan, is desige from the w

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 7B S

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con07

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEgned and opwater, comp

1 of 1994, n control

Section 20.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 7B Sectioperated primplies with S

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Open 20, Town

marily for the Section 3703

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCnship of Ot

control, cap3 and with

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as tsego pture, other

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 101: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2408, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at NMAG 2 Section 21, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $23,735. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $23,735. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

Page 102: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedLake, Coand remprovision ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appounty of Otsoval of indu

ns of the act.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $23,735

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applisego, Michigustrial waste.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at5.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oication, locagan, is desige from the w

blic Act 451he pollutiot NMAG 2 S

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con08

451 of 1994owned or le

ated at NMAgned and opwater, comp

1 of 1994, n control

Section 21.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnAG 2 Sectioperated primplies with S

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeon 21, Townmarily for the Section 3703

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCnship of Ot

control, cap3 and with

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as sego pture, other

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 103: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2409, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at NMAG 3 Sections 22 & 23, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $51,972. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $51,972. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

Page 104: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appLake, Counand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applty of Otsegal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $51,972.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4the facility, oication, locao, Michiganial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioat NMAG 3.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con09

451 of 1994owned or leated at NMA, is designeom the wate

1 of 1994, n control Sections 2

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnAG 3 Sectiod and opera

er, complies

Part 37, afacility pro22 & 23. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 22 & 2ated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC23, Townshly for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 105: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2410, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 7 & 7B Sections 18 & 19, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $75,927. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $75,927. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

Page 106: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appLake, Counand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicty of Otsegal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atn is $75,927.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locato, Michiganial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 7 & 7.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con10

451 of 1994owned or leed at ASE 7, is designeom the wate

1 of 1994, n control 7B Sections

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En7 & 7B Sectd and opera

er, complies

Part 37, afacility pros 18 & 19.

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opetions 18 & 1ated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC19, Townshly for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 107: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2411, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at NMAG 1 Sections 14-16, 21 & 22, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $197,170. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $197,170. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

Page 108: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Otsegcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appgo Lake, Ccapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

roved applicCounty of O

removal of s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at n is $197,170

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locate

Otsego, Micindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutioNMAG 1 Se

0.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con11

451 of 1994owned or leed at NMAGhigan, is deaste from the

1 of 1994, n control ections 14-1

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnG 1 Sectionsesigned ande water, com

Part 37, afacility pro16, 21 & 22

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opes 14-16, 21 d operated mplies with S

as amendedoperty, as d. The total c

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC& 22, Townprimarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed incost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as nship or the 3 and

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 109: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2412, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 4C & St. Hayes 1-5 Sections 5, 7 & 18, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $7,267. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $7,267. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 110: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedthe facilit This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appip of Hayescapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationty entitled to

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applics, County of removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at exemption

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility, ocation, locatef Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 4C & Sis $7,267.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con12

451 of 1994owned or leed at ASE 4

Michigan, is daste from the

1 of 1994, n control St. Hayes 1

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by En4C & St. Hadesigned ane water, com

Part 37, afacility pro-5 Sections

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeayes 1-5 Secnd operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as ds 5, 7 & 18.

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCctions 5, 7 & primarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed in The total co

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as & 18, or the 3 and

e Tax n the ost of

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 111: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2413, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5C Sections 12 & 24, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $84,534. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $84,534. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

Page 112: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedChester,capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap, County ofand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $84,5

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applf Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 534.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility, olication, locaMichigan, is ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 5C Se

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con13

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASE

designed aom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ections 12 &

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 5C Sectioand operateer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

& 24. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 12 & 2ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC24, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 113: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2415, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 6 Sections 24 & 25, in the Township of Bagley, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $17,366. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $17,366. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Jason G. Woodcox, Assessor, Township of Bagley Clerk, Township of Bagley

Page 114: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedBagley, capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apCounty of and remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $17,3

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved appOtsego, M

al of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at366.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility, oplication, locMichigan, is

ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 6 Sec

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

ol certificate

ion Con15

451 of 1994owned or lecated at AS

designed aom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ctions 24 &

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnSE 6 Sectioand operateer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro25. The tot

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Opeons 24 & 2ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dtal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

25, Townshfor the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 115: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2416, to DTE Electric Company located at 43230 Elizabeth Road, in the City of Mt. Clemens, Macomb County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $52,385. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $52,385. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Nancy A. Strehl, Assessor, City of Mt. Clemens Clerk, City of Mt. Clemens

Page 116: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Macomb, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $52,385

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, iwaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 5.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio43230 Eliza

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 8, 19

ol certificate

ion Con16

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 43230and operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control abeth Road

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

992.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

0 Elizabeth ed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

d. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriRoad, City for the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof Mt. Clemtrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

mens, e, and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 117: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2417, to DTE Electric Company located at 1901 Wagner Road S, in the Township of Scio, Washtenaw County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $42,236. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $42,236. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Raman A. Patel, Assessor, Township of Scio Clerk, Township of Scio

Page 118: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oand remprovision ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Washtenaoval of indu

ns of the act.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $42,236

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applaw, Michigaustrial waste.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at6.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility,ication, loca

an, is designe from the w

blic Act 451he pollutiot 1901 Wagn

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 1

ol certificate

ion Con17

451 of 1994owned or l

ated at 1901ned and opewater, comp

1 of 1994, n control ner Road S

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1992.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D1 Wagner Rerated primaplies with S

Part 37, afacility pro

S. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriRoad S, Towarily for the

Section 3703

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companywnship of Scontrol, cap

3 and with

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as Scio, pture, other

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 119: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2418, to DTE Electric Company located at 1201 Caniff, in the City of Detroit, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $33,478. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $33,478. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Linda M. Bade, Assessor, City of Detroit Clerk, City of Detroit

Page 120: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedWayne, industria ThereforeCommissapprovedis $33,47 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apMichigan, isl waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application78.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

pproved apps designed a

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility,

plication, locand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutio1201 Canif

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 26, 1992.

ol certificate

ion Con18

451 of 1994owned or l

cated at 12ed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control ff. The total

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

201 Caniff,for the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility prol cost of the

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriCity of De

trol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as d facility entit

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyetroit, Coun, and remov

visions of the

d, the Statedescribed intled to exem

control facilim taxation.Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the

mption

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 121: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2419, to DTE Electric Company located at 2100 Second Avenue, in the City of Detroit, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $30,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $30,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Linda M. Bade, Assessor, City of Detroit Clerk, City of Detroit

Page 122: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $30,000

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

pproved appMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4the facility,

plication, locdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot 2100 Seco

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 26, 1992.

ol certificate

ion Con19

451 of 1994owned or l

cated at 21and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control

ond Avenue

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

100 Secondd primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

e. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrid Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of De

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

etroit, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 123: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2420, to DTE Electric Company located at 1 Belanger Park Drive, in the City of River Rouge, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $16,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $16,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Philip O. Mastin, III, Assessor, City of River Rouge Clerk, City of River Rouge

Page 124: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $16,000

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-242

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locatedesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio1 Belanger

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 26, 1992.

ol certificate

ion Con20

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 1 Belaand operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control r Park Drive

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by Danger Park d primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

e. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriDrive, City for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof River Ro

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

ouge, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 125: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2421, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $27,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $27,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 126: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $27,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-242

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W .

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 26, 1992.

ol certificate

ion Con21

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 127: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2422, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $17,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $17,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 128: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $17,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-242

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W .

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 26, 1992.

ol certificate

ion Con22

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 129: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling Enervest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, Mi Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2557, to Enervest Operating, LLC located at ASE 4D & St. Hayes 11-16 Section 16, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $7,491. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $7,491. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

Page 130: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedTownshcontrol, cwith othe ThereforeCommissapprovedfacility en This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apip of Hayescapture, ander provisions

e, as providsion herebyd applicationntitled to exe

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved apps, County of removal of

s of the act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located atemption is $7

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-255

Public Act 4the facility, oplication, locf Otsego, Mindustrial wa

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 4D & 7,491.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 28, 199

ol certificate

ion Con57

451 of 1994owned or le

cated at ASMichigan, is daste from the

1 of 1994, n control St. Hayes

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

92.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aeased by EnE 4D & Stdesigned ane water, com

Part 37, afacility pro11-16 Secti

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednervest Ope. Hayes 11nd operatedmplies with S

as amendedoperty, as dion 16. The

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC-16 Section primarily fo

Section 3703

d, the Statedescribed ine total cost o

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax C, as n 16, or the 3 and

e Tax n the of the

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 131: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2727, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $22,105,202. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $22,105,202. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 132: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $22,105

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at5,202.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-272

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

ol certificate

ion Con27

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 133: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2744, to DTE Electric Company located at 7000 Kilgore, in the Township of Greenwood, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $27,777. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $27,777. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Lisa C. Griffin, Assessor, Township of Greenwood Clerk, Township of Greenwood

Page 134: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedis $27,77 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd application77.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-274

Public Act 4the facility,

plication, locs designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio7000 Kilgo

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 9, 1994.

ol certificate

ion Con44

451 of 1994owned or lated at 700and operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control re. The tota

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D00 Kilgore,ed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

al cost of the

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

Township for the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as de facility entit

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof Greenw

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed intled to exem

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

wood, , and sions

e Tax n the

mption

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 135: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2745, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $45,690. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $45,690. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

Page 136: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Monroof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appoe, Michiganrial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $45,690

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is designerom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-274

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and operer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 9, 1994.

ol certificate

ion Con45

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 3500 Erated primars with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front Strerily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrieet, City of

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyMonroe, Co

ure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 137: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2783, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $81,550. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $81,550. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 138: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $81,550

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-278

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 9, 1994.

ol certificate

ion Con83

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 139: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2784, to DTE Electric Company located at 6431 Maple Road, in the City of Dearborn, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $54,140. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $54,140. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Gary L. Evanko, Assessor, City of Dearborn Clerk, City of Dearborn

Page 140: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Wayneindustria ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appe, Michigan,l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $54,140

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applic, is designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: May

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-278

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatd and operacomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 6431 Map

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

y 9, 1994.

ol certificate

ion Con84

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 6431 ted primarilyth Section 37

1 of 1994, n control

ple Road.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DMaple Roady for the con703 and with

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrid, City of Dntrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyearborn, Co

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty val of

e act.

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 141: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4234, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $12,300,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $12,300,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 142: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $12,300

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a0,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-423

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con34

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2002.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 143: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4235, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $430,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $430,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 144: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $430,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-423

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, le, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con35

451 of 1994owned or located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2002.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D3500 E Frd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriront Streetated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyt, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 145: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4236, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $3,611,524. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $3,611,524. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 146: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $3,611,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,524.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-423

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 4901 Poin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con36

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 Pand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control nte Drive.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2001.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Driveed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 147: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4240, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $380,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $380,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 148: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $380,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-424

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con40

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2002.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 149: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Company Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4295, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $40,658,304. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $40,658,304. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 150: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $40,658

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at8,304.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-429

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, e, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 6400 Dixie

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con95

451 of 1994owned or l

located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control e Highway.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2002.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D6400 Dixie

d and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 151: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4721, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $200,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $200,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 152: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $200,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-472

Public Act 4the facility,pplication, le, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 30, 2

ol certificate

ion Con21

451 of 1994owned or located at, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2003.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D3500 E Frd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electriront Streetated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyt, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 153: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4759, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $120,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $120,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 154: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $120,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-475

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con59

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 155: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4760, to DTE Electric Company located at 7000 Kilgore Road, in the Township of Greenwood, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $460,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $460,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Lisa C. Griffin, Assessor, Township of Greenwood Clerk, Township of Greenwood

Page 156: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedGreenwocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the aood, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $460,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

approved ay of St. Claial of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,

application, r, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutiot 7000 Kilg

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con60

451 of 1994owned or llocated at

, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control ore Road.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

7000 Kilgd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrigore Roadated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Company

d, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as p of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 157: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4761, to DTE Electric Company located at 755 Huron Avenue, in the City of Harbor Beach, Huron County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $85,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $85,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Eric D. Thompson, Assessor, City of Harbor Beach Clerk, City of Harbor Beach

Page 158: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Huron, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $85,000

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved appliMichigan, is

waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot 755 Huron

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con61

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 755 Hnd operated

complies with

1 of 1994, n control n Avenue.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DHuron Avend primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrinue, City offor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyf Harbor Berol, capture

h other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as each, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 159: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4762, to DTE Electric Company located at 301 Gratiot Avenue, in the City of Marysville, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $30,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $30,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Ann M. Ratliff, Assessor, City of Marysville Clerk, City of Marysville

Page 160: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $30,000

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

pproved appMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at0.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,

plication, locs designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot 301 Gratio

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con62

451 of 1994owned or l

cated at 301and operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control ot Avenue.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D1 Gratiot Aed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

Avenue, Cityfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy of Marystrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

sville, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 161: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4763, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $460,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $460,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

Page 162: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Monroof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appoe, Michiganrial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $460,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is designerom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and operer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con63

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 3500 Erated primars with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front Strerily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrieet, City of

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyMonroe, Co

ure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 163: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4765, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $520,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $520,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 164: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $520,000

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W 0.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con65

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 165: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-4766, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $250,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $250,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 166: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $250,00

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-476

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 4901 Poin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 28, 2

ol certificate

ion Con66

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 Pand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control nte Drive.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2004.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Driveed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 167: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

Paul W. Thompson Graymont Western Lime, Inc. 206 N 6th Avenue West Bend, Wi 53095 Dear Mr. Thompson: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5126, to Graymont Western Lime, Inc. located at 181 W County Road 432, in the Township of Mueller, Schoolcraft County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $363,245. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $363,245. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Thomas W. Kitzman, Assessor, Township of Mueller Clerk, Township of Mueller

Page 168: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissas descrMueller, capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby ribed in the

County of Sand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $363

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that thapproved aSchoolcraftal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 3,245.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-512

Public Act 4he facility, opplication, lot, Michigan, ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutio181 W Cou

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 29, 2

ol certificate

ion Con26

451 of 1994wned or leaocated at 18is designed

om the wate

1 of 1994, n control

unty Road 4

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2006.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by Gra81 W Cound and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

432. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedaymont Wesnty Road 43ated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dtal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Statestern Lime, 32, Townshy for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax Inc.,

hip of ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 169: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5424, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $8,933,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $8,933,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 170: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $8,933,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-542

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 21, 2

ol certificate

ion Con24

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2009.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 171: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5616, to DTE Electric Company located at 6400 N Dixie Highway, in the Township of Frenchtown, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $49,136,626. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $49,136,626. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Vicky L. Bryson, Assessor, Township of Frenchtown Clerk, Township of Frenchtown

Page 172: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedFrenchtocapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apown, Countyand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $49,136

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

pproved apy of Monroeal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 6,626.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-56

Public Act 4the facility,plication, loe, Michigan,ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutio6400 N Dix

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 2

ol certificate

ion Con16

451 of 1994owned or l

ocated at 6, is designedom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

xie Highway

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2010.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

6400 N Dixd and operaer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro

y. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrixie Highwayated primaril with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyy, Townshily for the co

on 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 173: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5692, to DTE Electric Company located at 1 Belanger Park Drive, in the City of River Rouge, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $2,029,200. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $2,029,200. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Philip O. Mastin, III, Assessor, City of River Rouge Clerk, City of River Rouge

Page 174: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $2,029,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at ,200.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-569

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locatedesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio1 Belanger

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 2

ol certificate

ion Con92

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 1 Belaand operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control r Park Drive

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2010.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by Danger Park d primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

e. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriDrive, City for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof River Ro

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as

ouge, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 175: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5693, to DTE Electric Company located at 4695 W Jefferson Avenue, in the City of Trenton, Wayne County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $1,764,272. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $1,764,272. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: John P. Dahlquist, Assessor, City of Trenton Clerk, City of Trenton

Page 176: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedentitled to This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Wayne, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationo exemption

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

proved applicMichigan, is waste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located an is $1,764,2

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-569

Public Act 4the facility,cation, locatdesigned athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4695 W 272.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 20, 2

ol certificate

ion Con93

451 of 1994owned or l

ted at 4695 and operatedcomplies with

1 of 1994, n control Jefferson A

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2010.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DW Jeffersod primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility proAvenue. T

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electri

on Avenue, for the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dThe total co

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyCity of Tren

trol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed inost of the fa

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as nton, , and sions

e Tax n the acility

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 177: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5846, to DTE Electric Company located at 4901 Pointe Drive, in the Township of East China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $3,885,000. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $3,885,000. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of East China Clerk, Township of East China

Page 178: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof St. Clair, of industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $3,885,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,000.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-584

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locates designed the water, c

blic Act 451he pollutio

at 4901 Poin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 31, 201

ol certificate

ion Con46

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4901 Pand operate

complies with

1 of 1994, n control nte Drive.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

11.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DPointe Driveed primarily h Section 37

Part 37, afacility proThe total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrie, Townshipfor the cont

703 and with

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyp of East Ctrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as hina, , and sions

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 179: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

P.O BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7971 www.michigan.gov/treasury (517) 373-0500

855 (Rev. 1-11)

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

ANDY DILLON STATE TREASURER

May 15, 2013

JoAnn Chavez DTE Electric Company One Energy Plaza Detroit, MI 48226-1221 Dear Ms. Chavez: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-5893, to DTE Electric Company located at 4505 King Road, in the Township of China, St. Clair County. This certificate was issued at the May 13, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the amount approved for exemption is $1,467,334. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $1,467,334. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Secretary State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mark A. Miano, Assessor, Township of China Clerk, Township of China

Page 180: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L …€¦ · This cert which th tangible 1933, as 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This am certificate f Treasury to

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof St. Claof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amcertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appair, Michigarial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $1,467,

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollues previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is design

rom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located a,334.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Aug

ution Controy issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-589

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and opeer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutioat 4505 Kin

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

gust 28, 201

ol certificate

ion Con93

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 4505 Krated primar

s with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ng Road. T

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

2.

e is issued

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by D

King Road,rily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility proThe total co

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

on May 13

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE ElectriTownship o

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

3, 2013 and

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic Companyof China, Coure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitle

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

d supersede

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all