s michigan rick snyder department of treasury l€¦ · 1937, pro this cert remain in and remo...

30
P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429 RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER November 18, 2013 Mark Heaphy DTE Electric Company P.O. Box 33017 Detroit, MI 48232 Dear Mr. Heaphy: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0359, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $532,425.00, for a total exemption of $13,205,116.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $13,205,116.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408. Sincerely, Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe 5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Upload: others

Post on 25-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Mark Heaphy DTE Electric Company P.O. Box 33017 Detroit, MI 48232 Dear Mr. Heaphy: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-0359, to DTE Electric Company located at 3500 E Front Street, in the City of Monroe, Monroe County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $532,425.00, for a total exemption of $13,205,116.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $13,205,116.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Samuel J. Guich, Assessor, City of Monroe Clerk, City of Monroe

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 2: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Monroof industact. ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appoe, Michiganrial waste fr

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $13,205

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that

roved applicn, is designerom the wate

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at5,116.00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-035

Public Act 4the facility,

cation, locateed and operer, complies

blic Act 451he pollutiot 3500 E Fr

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 12, 1

certificate is

ion Con59

451 of 1994owned or l

ed at 3500 Erated primars with Sectio

1 of 1994, n control

ront Street.

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1987.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aleased by DE Front Strerily for the con 3703 and

Part 37, afacility pro The total c

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedDTE Electrieet, City of

control, captud with other

as amendedoperty, as dcost of the f

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateic CompanyMonroe, Co

ure, and remprovisions o

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax y, as ounty moval of the

e Tax n the ed to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 3: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2055, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at Summerland C2-12 SWD, in the Township of Charlton, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $143,853.00, for a total exemption of $179,296.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $179,296.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Charlton Clerk, Township of Charlton

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 4: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCharltoncapture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap

n, County oand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $179

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved appof Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 9,296.00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-205

Public Act 4he facility, o

plication, locMichigan, isial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioSummerlan

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

certificate is

ion Con55

451 of 1994owned or lecated at Sus designed om the wate

1 of 1994, n control nd C2-12 SW

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

ummerland and operate

er, complies

Part 37, afacility proWD. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Ope

C2-12 SWDed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCD, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 5: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2060, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at Roby A3-7, Thomas C3-7, Thomas C4-7, Thompson B3-7 & Thompson D3-7, in the Township of Vienna, Montmorency County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $153,589.00, for a total exemption of $194,858.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $194,858.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Ernest O. Dunham, Assessor, Township of Vienna Clerk, Township of Vienna

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 6: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedThompsMichiganwaste fro ThereforeCommissapprovedThomps This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appon B3-7 &

n, is designeom the water

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon D3-7. T

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appl& Thompsoed and operar, complies w

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at he total cost

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Dec

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-206

Public Act 4he facility, oication, loca

on D3-7, Tated primariwith Section

blic Act 451he pollutioRoby A3-7

t of the facili

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ember 31, 1

certificate is

ion Con60

451 of 1994owned or leated at RobTownship oly for the co3703 and w

1 of 1994, n control

7, Thomas Cty entitled to

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1990.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

by A3-7, Thof Vienna, ontrol, captuwith other pro

Part 37, afacility pro

C3-7, Thomao exemption

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opehomas C3-7

County of ure, and removisions of t

as amendedoperty, as das C4-7, This $194,858

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

7, Thomas Cf Montmore

moval of induhe act.

d, the Statedescribed inhompson B38.00.

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as C4-7, ency, ustrial

e Tax n the 3-7 &

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 7: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Sandy Mankowski Ward Lake Energy 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Sir/Madam: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2257, to Ward Lake Energy located at Bennett A1-27, Hall A4-28, Kirbitz B3-28, Kirbitz B4-28 & Newman B1-27, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $201,740.00, for a total exemption of $240,988.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $240,988.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 8: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissin the ap28 & Neoperatedcomplies ThereforeCommissapprovedNewman This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby pproved appewman B1-2d primarily fos with Sectio

e, as providsion herebyd applicationn B1-27. Th

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that thlication, loca27, Townshor the contn 3703 and

ded by Puby certifies thn, located ae total cost

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Febr

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-225

Public Act 4he facility, owated at Ben

hip of Chesrol, capturewith other p

blic Act 451he pollutiot Bennett Aof the facility

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ruary 25, 19

certificate is

ion Con57

451 of 1994wned or leasnett A1-27,

ster, County, and remo

provisions of

1 of 1994, n control

A1-27, Hall y entitled to

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

992.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, ased by Ward, Hall A4-28y of Otsegoval of industhe act.

Part 37, afacility proA4-28, Kirbexemption is

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendedd Lake Ener8, Kirbitz B3, Michigan, strial waste

as amendedoperty, as dbitz B3-28, s $240,988.0

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Statergy, as desc3-28, Kirbitzis designedfrom the w

d, the Statedescribed inKirbitz B4-00.

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax cribed z B4-d and water,

e Tax n the -28 &

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 9: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2394, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 6C, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $31,579.00, for a total exemption of $38,081.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $38,081.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 10: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$38,081. This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4he facility, oication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 6C. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con94

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E 6C, Townfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chtrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 11: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2395, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 6B, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $53,639.00, for a total exemption of $68,346.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $68,346.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 12: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$68,346. This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4he facility, oication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 6B. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con95

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E 6B, Townfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chtrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 13: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2396, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5B, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $74,501.00, for a total exemption of $99,704.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $99,704.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 14: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$99,704. This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4he facility, oication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 5B. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con96

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E 5B, Townfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chtrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 15: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2398, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 3B, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $495,889.00, for a total exemption of $622,620.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $622,620.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 16: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$622,620 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application0.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4he facility, oication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 3B. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

certificate is

ion Con98

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E 3B, Townfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chtrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 17: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2399, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE #2, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $675,543.00, for a total exemption of $755,896.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $755,896.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 18: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$755,896 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application6.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved appls designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-239

Public Act 4he facility, oication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE #2. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

certificate is

ion Con99

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E #2, Townsfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chtrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 19: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2400, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 5, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $653,688.00, for a total exemption of $844,231.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $844,231.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 20: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$844,231 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application1.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved apps designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4he facility, olication, locaand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 5. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con00

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control

The total cos

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by EnE 5, Townsfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility prost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opeship of Chetrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCester, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 21: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2401, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 3A-25 & ASE 3A-36, in the Township of Chester, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $675,445.00, for a total exemption of $783,517.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $783,517.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Sally A. Nowak, Assessor, Township of Chester Clerk, Township of Chester

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 22: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedChester,capture, other pro ThereforeCommissapprovedto exemp This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the ap, County ofand remova

ovisions of th

e, as providsion herebyd applicationption is $783

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved appf Otsego, Mal of industrhe act.

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at 3,517.00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4he facility, o

plication, locMichigan, is ial waste fro

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 3A-25

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con01

451 of 1994owned or lecated at AS

designed aom the wate

1 of 1994, n control

5 & ASE 3A-

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

SE 3A-25 &and operateer, complies

Part 37, afacility pro-36. The to

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Ope& ASE 3A-3ed primarily with Sectio

as amendedoperty, as dotal cost of th

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

36, Townshy for the coon 3703 and

d, the Statedescribed inhe facility en

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as ip of

ontrol, d with

e Tax n the ntitled

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 23: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2405, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 4-16 & ASE 4-17, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $538,227.00, for a total exemption of $687,590.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $687,590.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 24: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedexemptio This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd applicationon is $687,59

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at90.00.

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Octo

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4he facility, ocation, locat

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 4-16 &

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

ober 15, 199

certificate is

ion Con05

451 of 1994owned or leted at ASE 4and operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control & ASE 4-17

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

96.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En4-16 & ASEd primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility pro

7. The total

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest OpeE 4-17, Towfor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as d

cost of the

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLC

wnship of Hatrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed infacility entitl

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as ayes, , and sions

e Tax n the led to

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 25: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2406, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 1, in the Township of Hayes, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $520,075.00, for a total exemption of $651,376.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $651,376.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Mary M. Sanders, Assessor, Township of Hayes Clerk, Township of Hayes

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 26: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedOtsego, industria ThereforeCommissapproved$651,376 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the apMichigan, is

l waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application6.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

pproved apps designed

m the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4he facility, o

plication, locand operatecomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot ASE 1. T

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con06

451 of 1994owned or lecated at ASed primarily th Section 37

1 of 1994, n control

The total cos

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

SE 1, Townfor the cont703 and with

Part 37, afacility prost of the fac

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Openship of Hatrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCayes, Coun

e, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempti

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as nty of val of e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 27: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2409, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at NMAG 3, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $236,754.00, for a total exemption of $288,726.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $288,726.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 28: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedof Otsegindustria ThereforeCommissapproved$288,726 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the app

go, Michiganl waste from

e, as providsion herebyd application6.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applicn, is designedm the water, c

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-240

Public Act 4he facility, ocation, located and operacomplies wit

blic Act 451he pollutiot NMAG 3.

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con09

451 of 1994owned or leed at NMAG

ated primarilyth Section 37

1 of 1994, n control The total co

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

G 3, Townshy for the con703 and with

Part 37, afacility pro

ost of the fa

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest Opehip of Otsentrol, captureh other prov

as amendedoperty, as dcility entitled

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCgo Lake, Coe, and removvisions of the

d, the Statedescribed ind to exempt

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as ounty val of

e act.

e Tax n the ion is

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all

Page 29: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

P.O. BOX 30471 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909 www.michigan.gov/statetaxcommission (517) 335-3429

RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY LANSING

R. KEVIN CLINTON STATE TREASURER

November 18, 2013

Jeffrey A. Riling EnerVest Operating, LLC 685 E M-32, Suite 201 Gaylord, MI 49735 Dear Mr. Riling: Pursuant to the requirements of Public Act 451 of 1994, Part 37, as amended, the State Tax Commission (Commission) has issued an amended water pollution tax exemption certificate, numbered 2-2410, to EnerVest Operating, LLC located at ASE 7 & 7B, in the Township of Otsego Lake, Otsego County. This certificate was issued at the September 25, 2013 meeting of the Commission and the additional amount approved for exemption is $335,333.00, for a total exemption of $411,260.00. As required by Section 3702(2) of the Act, the exemption amount must annually be reduced by the gross annual commercial or productive value derived from any materials captured by the exempted facility. The current year’s gross annual commercial or productive value recovered by this facility, as reported by your application, is $0. Therefore, the net exemption for the current year for this facility is $411,260.00. As this gross annual commercial or productive value may change yearly, the value must be reported to the assessor on an annual basis to correctly reduce the exemption. The applicant and local assessor have 60 days from the date of this letter to appeal the decision to the Circuit Court. If the application costs were based on estimated figures, the applicant must file final costs figures with our office within 90 days after completion of the project. If you have any questions, please contact the Property Services Division at (517) 373-2408.

Sincerely,

Kelli Sobel, Executive Director State Tax Commission

Enclosure By Certified Mail cc: Fred Lindroth, Assessor, Township of Otsego Lake Clerk, Township of Otsego Lake

5102 (Rev. 11-13)

Page 30: S MICHIGAN RICK SNYDER DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY L€¦ · 1937, pro This cert remain in and remo Certifica This ame certificate f Treasury to the pro ion hereby in the ap, County o

Mich448

higan Department o1 (2-11)

PursuantCommissdescribedCounty oremoval of the ac ThereforeCommissapprovedis $411,2 This certwhich thtangible 1933, as1937, pro This certremain inand remo Certifica This amecertificate

of Treasury

t to the prosion hereby d in the appof Otsego, Mof industrial t.

e, as providsion herebyd application260.00.

tificate providis pollution personal pr

s provided bovided by M

tificate, unlen force as looval of indus

ate Effective

ended Pollutes previousl

WateCertifica

ovisions of Pfinds that t

proved applMichigan, iswaste from

ded by Puby certifies thn, located at

des the authcontrol exe

roperty is alby MCL 205CL 205.91 t

ess revokedng as the fa

strial waste f

e Date: Nov

tion Control y issued.

r Pollutiate No. 2-24

Public Act 4he facility, olication, loca

s designed athe water, c

blic Act 451he pollutioASE 7 & 7B

hority for theemption certlso exempt

5.51 to 205.o 205.111.

d as provideacility is desigfrom the wat

vember 16, 1

certificate is

ion Con10

451 of 1994owned or leated at ASEand operatecomplies with

1 of 1994, n control B. The tota

e assessor ttificate is in from sales 78 and use

ed by Publicgned and opter;

1993.

s issued on S

DouStat

trol Ame

4, Part 37, aased by En

E 7 & 7B, Td primarily fh Section 37

Part 37, afacility prol cost of the

to exempt theffect fromtaxes impo

e taxes impo

c Act 451 operated prim

September

uglas B. Robte Tax Comm

ended C

as amendednerVest OpeTownship ofor the cont703 and with

as amendedoperty, as de facility entit

he pollution cm ad valoremosed under osed under

of 1994, asmarily for the

25, 2013 an

berts, Chairpmission

Certifica

d, the Stateerating, LLCof Otsego Ltrol, captureh other provi

d, the Statedescribed intled to exem

control facilim taxation. Public Act 6Public Act

amended, e control, cap

nd supersed

person

ate

e Tax C, as Lake, , and sions

e Tax n the

mption

ity for The 67 of 94 of

shall pture,

es all