CIVIL PROCEDUREII – SR - Case Outline

Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Modes of Discovery – Rule 23-29; AM 03-1-09Rule 23

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1RP [PCCG] v. SB GARCIA 90478 Nov 21, 1991Producers Bank v. CA ECHAVEZ 100495 Jan 29, 1998Elena Ong v. Judge Mazo RIZADA 145542 Jun 4, 2004Ayala Land [ALI] v. Judge Tagle QUIBOD 153667 Aug 11, 2005Philippine Computer v. Judge Hernandez NARTATE

Z168776 Jul 17, 2007

Disini v. SB GALAGAR 175730 Jul 5, 2010

Sec. 4 Jonathan Landoil v. Mangudadatu ECHAVEZ 155010 Aug 16, 2004Jowel Sales v. Cyril Sabino RIZADA 133154 Dec 9, 2005Rudencio Tiu v. CA GARCIA 142596 Jul 10. 2006Pajarillaga v. CA CABADIN

G163515 Oct 31, 2008

RP v. SB NARTATEZ

152375 Dec 16, 2011

Sec. 11, 12, 14 Pfeger Dulay v. Rodrigo Dulay TUMANDA

158857 Nov 11, 2005

Sec. 16, 18 Fortune Corporation v. CA DOMINGO

108119 Jan 19, 1994

San Luis v. Judge Rojas DE PERALTA

159127 Mar 3, 2008

Espiritu v Tankiansee QUIBOD 164153 Jun 13, 2011

Rule 24Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 4People v. Webb CHAN 132577 Aug 17, 1999

Rule 26Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 2Briboneria v. CA NUNEZA 101682 Dec 14, 1992Concrete Aggregates v. CA ONTAL 117574 Jan 2, 1997Spouses Bella v. CA FERNANDO 105997 Sep 26, 1997Allied Agri-Business v. Cherry Valley DE CASTRO 118438 Dec 4, 1998DBP v. CA ILUSTRISIM

O153034 Sep 20, 2005

Limos v. Spouses Odones GALAGAR 186979 Aug 11, 2010

Rule 29Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 3,5Santiago Land v. CA ECHAVEZ 103922 Jul 9, 1996Spouses Zepeda v. China Bank GARCIA 172175 Oct 9, 2006Jaravata v. Karolus NARTATE

Z154988 Jun 21, 2007

Solidbank v. Gateway Electronics RIZADA 164805 Apr 30, 2008

Rule 30Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 2Matias v. Judge Plan CABADIN

G98-1159 Aug 3, 1998

Azucar v. Judge Ocampo TUMANDA 02-1396 Mar 15, 2004

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 3Pepsi-cola v. CA DOMING

O122629 Dec 2, 1998

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 4Anama v. CA DE

PERALTA

128609 Jan 29, 2004

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 5RP v. SB QUIBOD 159275 Aug 25, 2010RP v. SB CHAN 152375 Dec 16, 2011

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 8Saludo v. CA NUNEZA 121404 May 3, 2006

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 9Umali-Paco v. Judge Quilala ONTAL 02-1699 Oct 15, 2003Nieva v. Alvarez-Edad FERNAND

O01-1459 Jan 31, 2005

Concerned Lawyers v. Judge Pornillos DE 09-2183 Jul 7, 2009

CASTRO

Rule 31Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1,2Active Wood v. CA ILUSTRISIM

O86603 Feb 5, 1990

People v. Judge Mangrobang GALAGAR 130907 Nov 27, 2001People v. SB ECHAVEZ 14945 Aug 21, 2003Spouses De Vera v. Agloro GARCIA 155673 Jan 14, 2005Philippine Savings Bank v. Manalac RIZADA 145441 Apr 26, 2005PNB v. Gotesco CABADING 183211 Jun 5, 2009Bank of Commerce v. Judge Bernabe TUMANDA 172393 Oct 20, 2010Deutsche Bank v. CA DOMINGO 193065 Feb 27, 2012

Rule 32Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 2,3,9 Manotok Realty v. CLT DE PERALT

A

123346 Dec 14, 2007

Sec. 3,5,10 Aljem’s Corporation v. CA QUIBOD 122216 Mar 28, 2001Sec. 10 Apurillo v. Judge Garciano CHAN L-23683 Jul 30, 1969Sec. 11 Apo Fruits v. CA NUNEZA 164195 Feb 6, 2007

Rule 33Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1 Radiowealth v. Del Rosario ONTAL 138739 Jul 6, 2000Celino v. Heirs of Santiago FERNANDO 161817 Jul 30, 2004Park v. Choi DE CASTRO 165496 Feb 12, 2007Manila Banking v. University of Baguio ILUSTRISIM

O159189 Feb 21, 2007

RCL of Singapore v. The Netherlands GALAGAR 168151 Sep 4, 2009Uy v. Chua ECHAVEZ 183965 Sep 18, 2009

Rule 34Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1 Asian Construction v. CA GARCIA 160242 May 17, 2005Mongao v. Pryce RIZADA 156474 Aug 16, 2005Meneses v. Secretary of Agrarian CABADIN

G156304 Oct 23, 2006

Reillo v. San Jose TUMANDA 166393 Jun 18, 2009Sunbanon v. Go DOMINGO 163280 Feb 2, 2010

Rule 35Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1, 2, 4 Garcia v. CA DE PERALTA 170320 Jul 27, 2000Evangelista v. Mercator QUIBOD 14886 Aug 21, 2003Wood Technology v. Equitable CHAN 153867 Feb 17, 2005Bitanga v. Pyramid Construction NUNEZA 173526 Aug 28, 2008NPC v. Vda. De Capin ONTAL 175176 Oct 17, 2008De Carlos v. Sandoval FERNANDO 179922 Dec 16, 2008BPI v. Yu DE CASTRO 184122 Jan 20, 2010Atty. Gubat v. NPC ILUSTRISIM

O167415 Feb 26, 2010

Cocofed v. RP GALAGAR 177857 Jan 24, 2012

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 3 Mallilin v. Castillo ECHAVEZ 136803 Jun 16, 2000

Garcia v. Llamas GARCIA 154127 Dec 8, 2003Consunji v.Duvaz RIZADA 155174 Aug 4, 2009Eland v. Garcia CABADIN

G173289 Feb 19, 2010

Ybiernas v. Tanco-Gabaldon TUMANDA 178925 Jun 1, 2011

Rule 36Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1 Borromeo v. CA DOMINGO L-82273 Jun 1, 1990Consolidated Bank v. IAC DE

PERALTA73777 Sep 12, 1990

PCI Bank v. CA QUIBOD 120739 Jul 20, 2000Marchadesch v. De Yepes CHAN 151160 Nov 11, 2004Mocorro v. Ramirez NUNEZA 178366 Jul 28, 2008Dela Pena v. CA ONTAL 177828 Feb 13, 2009Bongcac v. SB FERNAND

O156687 May 31, 2009

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 4 Heirs of Sy Bang v. Rolando Sy DE

CASTRO114217 Oct 13, 2009

Rule 37Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1 Cansino v. CA ILUSTRISIM 125799 Aug 21, 2003

ORP v. Hidalgo GALAGAR 161657 Oct 4, 2007Multi Trans v. Oriental ECHAVEZ 180817 Jun 23, 2009Co v. People GARCIA 160265 Jul 13, 2009

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 2 Estate of Macadangdang v. Gaviola RIZADA 156809 Mar 4, 2009

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 3 RP v. Yang Chi Hao CABADIN

G165332 Oct 2, 2009

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 6 Terana v. Judge Sagun TUMAND

A152131 Apr 29, 2009

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 9 Jaban v. City of Cebu DOMING

O138336 Feb 16, 2004

Datu v. Sy DE PERALTA

143701 Mar 23, 2004

Rule 38Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 1Valencia v. CA QUIBOD 119118 Feb 19, 2001Sy Bang v. Rosauro Sy CHAN 179955 Apr 24, 2009Afdal v. Carlos NUNEZA 173379 Dec 1, 2010

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 2 PCI Bank v. CA ONTAL 120739 Jul 20, 2000

Topic Case Title Citation GR DateSec. 3 Mercury Drug v. CA FERNANDO 138571 Jul 13, 2000

Manipor v. Ricafort ILUSTRISIMO

150159 Jul 25, 2003

Cerezo v. Tuazon GALAGAR 141538 Mar 23, 2004Purcon v. MRM ECHAVEZ 182718 Sep 26, 2008Samonte v. Naguiat GARCIA 165544 Oct 2, 2009