robust faradayic cnt based coating for scattered light …€¦ · robust faradayic® cnt based...

21
Robust FARADAYIC ® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M. Inman, E. Jennings Taylor, B.T. Skinn, and S.T. Snyder 18th Annual Mirror Technology SBIR/STTR Workshop Raytheon Space and Airborne Systems Event Center El Segundo, CA 11/06/2018

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression

Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M. Inman, E. Jennings Taylor, B.T. Skinn, and S.T. Snyder

18th Annual Mirror Technology SBIR/STTR Workshop

Raytheon Space and Airborne Systems Event Center

El Segundo, CA

11/06/2018

Page 2: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Introduction to Faraday Technology, Inc.

2

Page 3: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Company Overview: FARADAY TECHNOLOGY, INC.

o Electrochemical engineering processes and technologies – founded 1991

• ~32 Issued Patents and ~15 Pending Patents in this area

• www.FaradayTechnology.com

o Subsidiary of Physical Sciences, Inc. (Boston, MA) – acquired 2008

• www.psicorp.com

3

“…to be known as the company that changed the focus of

electrochemical engineering from the art of complex chemistries to the

science of pulse/pulse reverse electric fields…”

~47 Patent Portfolio

Page 4: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Technology development begins conceptually and is demonstrated at the bench-scale

and developed through /-scale validation. IP development with technology.

Bench-Top Feasibility Pilot-Scale Validation Production-Scale Validation

DEM/VAL: α- to β-Scale

4

Page 5: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Business Model: Collaborative Open Innovation

o Establish IP (47 patents issued/know-how)

o Leverage Federal SBIR opportunities as

non-equity technology funding

• Retain IP rights

o Collaborate with university, government

and commercial partners

o Develop electrochemical engineering

solutions based on PC/PRC processes

o Transition technology & competitive

advantage to large companies via

• α-Scale to β-Scale

Demonstration/Validation

• Field-of-use licenses

• Patent acquisition (8)

o Transition technology to government

facilities via

• α-Scale to β-Scale

Demonstration/Validation Development of robust process is

critical!

5

Page 6: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Program Description

6

Page 7: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Background

• Future NASA missions require low reflective surfaces to minimize scattered

light for optical systems, such as beam-splitter, lasercom, and gravitational-

wave application.

• The low reflective surfaces need to withstand space environments with

marginal impact on their adhesion and optical performance in the broad

spectral range (visible-near infrared).

• Low reflective surfaces have been obtained on black surfaces through

anodization, painting, or electrodeposition of Martin black, carbon black,

black chrome, etc.

• The CNT based materials absorb 99.5 of the light, dramatically reducing

light contamination (NASA Goddard Space Flight Center).

7

Page 8: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Objective of Program

• The objective of the Phase I program is to

develop a scalable process for fabrication of

low reflective CNT based black coating that is

able to withstand and increase lifetime in

challenging application environments.

8

Page 9: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Technical Approach

9

+

Conventional EPD process FARADAYIC® process

Utilize combined conventional electrophoretic deposition (EPD)

and pulsed electric fields to induce migration of charged particles

(nanotubes) onto targeted substrates.

Page 10: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Technical Approach

• Carbon nanotubes will be surface charged and dispersed

with the aid of dispersants or functional groups.

• Surface charged CNTs will be deposited on desired

substrates through FARADAYIC® EPD process.

10

Page 11: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

EPD cell Setup

11

A B

C D

The EPD cell setup for CNT coating: 3D representation of (A) EPD cell; (B) Counter

and working electrodes; (C) The EPD cell setup with DC power supply; (D) The EPD

cell with CNT suspension.

Page 12: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

CNT dispersion for EPD Coating

12

• Plating bath development (CNT dispersion approach, dispersant, binders,

solvent, etc. )

CNT bundles

CNT dispersions

The experimental setup for preparing CNT dispersion with aid of sonication

Multi-walled carbon nanotube

(Aldrich)

Page 13: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Results

13

B A

Photograph (A) and diffuse reflectance spectra (B) of Trial CNT39, 40,& 41

Increasing the applied DC voltage leads to reduce

reflectance of CNT films

Page 14: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

14

Results

A B

Photograph (A) and diffuse reflectance spectra (B) of Trial CNT41& 45

Increasing deposition time leads to reduce reflectance

Page 15: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

15

Results

A B

Photographs of CNT coatings formed in (A) DMF (B) EtOH

FARADAYIC® EPD (CNT 32/46) improves deposit uniformity

Page 16: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Discussion

16

• ~3% was the lowest observed diffuse reflection across

visible wavebands that was found with CNT films

consisting of polymer dispersants

• Polymer dispersants absorbed on the CNT surfaces

and block the CNT absorbing the light

• Replacing the polymer dispersants with charged

function groups on CNT sidewalls

Page 17: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

A B

120V

DC 60V

DC 40V

PC

Results

Photograph (A) and diffuse reflectance spectra (B) of Trial CNT45,83& 84

The removal of polymer dispersants from the process enables

the diffuse reflection to be reduced to 1.1%.

Pulse EPD can achieve the same reflectance performance

with much lower applied voltage (lower power).

17

Page 18: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Results

A B

EtOH EtOH IPA

Photograph (A) and diffuse reflectance spectra (B) of Trial CNT83,88& 89

The use of EtOH instead of IPA solvent further decreases

diffuse reflection to 0.8% across visible wavebands.

18

Page 19: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

Summary

• Designed and built electrophoretic deposition (EPD) cell

with adjustable distance between cathode and anode for

CNT coating

• Investigated the effects of solvents, binders, dispersants,

functional groups on the dispersion of CNTs and

reflectance of CNT coatings

• Obtained CNT black coatings on stainless steel substrates

using EPD under both DC and PC

• Initiated pulse waveform EPD and found improved CNT

coating uniformity

• Achieved diffuse reflectance of ~0.8% across the visible

wavebands of the developed CNT coatings.

19

Page 20: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

20

Next Step

• Optimize the PC waveform for lower reflective CNT

coating formation (approaching ~0.1% target)

• Evaluate the effects of diameter and alignment of CNTs

on the reflectance of CNT coatings

• Complete an economic evaluation of the EPD approach

for anti-reflective CNT coatings

Page 21: Robust FARADAYIC CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light …€¦ · Robust FARADAYIC® CNT Based Coating for Scattered Light Suppression Dan Wang, Tim D. Hall, R. Radhakrishnan, M

The financial support of NASA Contract No. 80NNSC18P2062 is acknowledged.

Special thanks to all our team members for their support

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION!

QUESTIONS?

Contact Information: Dan Wang, Tim Hall, M. Inman, or EJ Taylor

Ph: 937-836-7749

Email: [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

18th Annual Mirror Technology SBIR/STTR Workshop

Raytheon Space and Airborne Systems Event Center, El Segundo, CA

5 - 7 November 2018