8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

1/30

^rkvotd @didgsd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

2/30

^ocd

6

AlgtdgtsKgtrl`uatklg: ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1^rkvotd `didgsd: ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1^rkvotd `didgad:lfjdat ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 3

@didgad li fl`y og` prlpdrty: salpd '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?>Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad tl aousd `dotb '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6>Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad sblrt li `dotb ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 63

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

3/30

^ocd

1

Kgtrl`uatklg:

Cdgdroeey spdohkgc% `didgads oeelw tbd oaausd` tl ovlk` arkmkgoerdsplgskfkekty' @didgads orksd kg `kiidrdgt woys' Kg lgd woy% tbd `didg`ogtmoy `didg` bkmsdei fy prlvkgc tbot bd `k` glt almmkt tbd arkmd' Ilrdxomped% tohd tbd aosd li og liidg`dr wbl tohds tbd pedo lioekfk' Fy rokskgctbks wbot bd soys ks tbot bd bos glt almmkttd` tbd arkmd' Kg ydt ogltbdrkgstogad% o motdrkoe dedmdgt lr akraumstogad moy glt fd ovokeofed' Kg suabo aosd iokeurd tl dstofeksb tbd akraumstogad prlvk`ds tbd `didgad' Pbdrd ordtwl typds li `didgads: justkikaotlry% og` dxausotlry' Kg tbd ilrmdr tbdoaausd` o`mkts rdsplgskfkekty ilr arkmds fut orcuds tbot% ug`dr tbdakraumstogads% wbot bd `k` wos rkcbt' Kg dxausotlry `didgads% tbd oaausd`o`mkts tbot wbot bd `k` wos wrlgc fut pedo`s% tbot% ug`dr tbdakraumstogads% bd wos glt rdsplgskfed ilr wbot bd `k`'

Lr`kgorkey% tbd fur`dg li prlli ks lg tbd prlsdautklg' Blwdvdr% kg tbd aosdli oiikrmotkvd `didgads wbdrd tbd oaausd` oshs ilr algadssklgoealgsk`drotklg kgaeu`kgc sdei-`didgad% gdadsskty% kgsogkty% oealbleka kgsogktylr `rughdggdss% `urdss dta' tbd fur`dg ioees lg tbd oaausd`' Kt bos tl fdgltd` tbot ki tbd prlsdautklg almds oarlss dvk`dgad aopofed li prlvkgc ogyli tbdsd `didgads% iokrgdss `dmog`s tbot tbd prlsdautklg mohds ktovokeofed tl alurt ilr ckvkgc tbd fdgdikt tl tbd oaausd`'

Dvk`dgad tbot `lds glt edo` tl o pdridat `didgad moy rdsuet kg algvkatklgilr o edssdr liidgad os kg tbd aosd li tbd `didgad li su``dg og` crovd

prlvlaotklg8 tbd mur`dr aborcd ks rd`uad` tl auepofed blmkak`d gltomlugtkgc tl mur`dr'

^rkvotd `didgsd:

Qdei-bdep ks tbd ikrst rued li arkmkgoe eow' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ksofsleutdey gdadssory ilr tbd prltdatklg li lgd#s ekid% ekfdrty og` prlpdrty'Gl `luft% kt ks tbd prkmory `uty li tbd Qtotd tl prltdat ekid og` tbd prlpdrty

li tbd kg`kvk`uoes% fut gl Qtotd% gl mottdr blw eorcd kts rdslurads mkcbtfd% aog `dputd o plekadmog tl wotab tbd oatkvktkds li doab og` dvdrykg`kvk`uoe og` prltdat tbdm ocokgst tbd mksabkdvlus oats li arkmkgoes'

Pbdrd moy fd sktuotklgs wbdrdkg bdep irlm tbd Qtotd outblrktkds aogglt fdlftokgd` kg lr`dr tl rdpde og ugeowiue occrdssklg% dktbdr fdaousd tbdrd ksgl tkmd tl osh ilr suab bdep% lr ilr ogy ltbdr rdoslg' Pl mddt suabdxkcdgakds tbd eow bos ckvdg tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li fl`y og`prlpdrty tl dvdry kg`kvk`uoe'?

? Fdgtbom#s ^rkgakpeds li ^dgoe Eow% p' 69;8 Fdgtbom sok`%Pbd vkckeogad li mockstrotds aog gdvdr mohd up ilr tbd vkckeogad li doab kg`kvk`uoe lg bks lwg fdboei'Pbd idor li tbd eow aog gdvdr rdstrokg fo` mdg os tbd idor li slmd tltoe li kg`kvk`uoe rdskstogad' Pohdowoy tbks rkcbt og` ylu aog fdalmd kg sl `lkgc tbd oaalmpekad% li oee fo` mdg' Qdd Clur Bork Qkgcb%^dgoe Eow li Kg`ko% "??tb D`g'% Yle' K% 6>>>+% pp' 3;3-264'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

4/30

^ocd

0

Kg tbd stotd li goturd kt wos tbd survkvoe li tbd ikttdst% tbd prkgakped li sdei-prdsdrvotklg cuk`kgc muab li bumog fdbovklur' O mog alue` hkee ogltbdrkg sdei-`didgad% tbks fdkgc og kgbdrdgt goturoe rkcbt' Pbks wos oemlst ogugrdstrkatd` rkcbt tbot tbd Eow li Goturd covd tl doab kg`kvk`uoe'

Pbd rkcbt li sdei-`didgad ks lgd wbkab bos almd `lwg irlm tbd ogakdgt eow-ckvdrs' Mogu dgjlkgd` tl rdslrt tl orms kg sdei-`didgad6 og` tbd rllt li tbksalgadpt moy fd ilug` dvdg kg Ogcel-Omdrkaog jurkspru`dgad'1 Kt ks tbus ogkg`didoskfed rkcbt wbkab moy fd oetdrd`% fut aog gdvdr fd ofrlcotd`'Goturd prlmpts o mog wbl ks struah tl rdskst% og` bd ks justkikd` kg uskgcsuab omlugt li ilrad wbkab wkee prdvdgt o rdpdtktklg' Oesl% tbd rkcbt liprkvotd-`didgad fosds ktsdei lg tbd prkgakped tbot ug`dr adrtokgakraumstogads tbd alg`uat li o pdrslg ks justkikd` oetblucb ltbdrwksdarkmkgoe% og` blmkak`d almmkttd` kg suab goturd bos fddg tdrmd` osdxausofed blmkak`d% tbd seoydr bovkgc pdrilrmd` o tosh wbkab tbd stotdwlue` bovd glrmoeey aorrkd` lut' 0 Pbus wbot tbd eow rdqukrds tbd eowpdrmkts' Pbks ks tbd rdoslg wby tbd rkcbt bos fddg aordiueey rdstrkatd` og`oesl soard`ey prltdatd`'

Pl`oy% tbd ekfdroe `dmlarotka stotd stkee rdalcgksds tbks kgoekdgofed rkcbt liog kg`kvk`uoe tl prltdat bkmsdei og` bks prlpdrty kg tbd ioad li `ogcdr'4

Pbks `dports irlm tbd mlglpley lvdr vkledgad wbkab tbd stotd bos rdtokgd`kg tbd sdgsd tbot ug`dr dvdry ltbdr akraumstogad% kt ks tbd stotd oelgd tbot

ks justkikd` kg uskgc ilrad% lr pugksbkgc tbd wrlgc`ldr'9 Pbd eow rdeotkgc tlsdei-`didgad ks tbus o mdrd dxtdgsklg li tbd prkgakped li gdadsskty% tbd tdstilr o rdoslgofed dxdraksd li sdei-`didgad fdkgc o aedor og` prdsdgt `ogcdr%tbd kmmkgdgad li borm tl dktbdr pdrslg lr prlpdrty% og` tbd algsdqudgtgdadsskty tl prltdat tbd sdei lr lgds prlpdrty' Pbks ks kg algslgogad wktb o

foska okm li arkmkgoe eow wbkab ks tl soidcuor` alg`uat tbot ks wktblutiouet irlm alg`dmgotklg os arkmkgoe'3

Pbd tdrms ^rkvotd @didgsd og` Qdei @didgsd ord syglgymlus tl doabltbdr' Kg ioat tbdy aorry lgd og` tbd somd mdogkgc' Eotkg wlr`s% Qd

6Mogu% Ab' YKKK% Ydrsds 102-;'1Joah Elwdry% O Qtotutlry stu`y li sdei - didgad og` `didgad li ltbdrs os og dxausd ilr blmkak`d%Tgkvdrskty li Ielrk`o Eow Vdvkdw% Yle' Y% "?;46+% p' 42'0J'S' Adake Purgdr% Hdggys Lutekgds li Arkmkgoe Eow"?;tbd`'+ "Elg`lg% ?;2>+% p' ?0?'4 Blwdvdr% kg ml`drg slakdty% tbks rkcbt li sdei-`didgad lr prkvotd-`didgad ks glt li og ofsleutd lrugquoekikd` goturd' Oetblucb dvdry `dvdelpd` slakdty rdalcgksds tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% kt oeslrdalcgksds tbd gdd` tl ekmkt og` algtrle kts usd% quoekiykgc kts utkeksotklg wktb tbd gdd` ilr kt tl fd flgo

ik`d og` rdoslgofed kg rdeotklg tl tbd `ogcdr ioad`'9Pbks ks kg tbd iurtbdrogad li tbd prlmltklg li slakoe justkad kg tbd wdeiord stotd wbdrd tbd rdsplgskfkektyks `kvdstd` kg tbd kg`kvk`uoe tl soidcuor` tbd slakoe prladss fy wbkab slakoe justkad ks ekhdey tl fd ottokgd`'Pbks ks dxdmpekikd` kg tbd dxomped tbot dvdry alugtry% blwdvdr rdsluradiue% aogglt oiilr` tl `dputd oplekadmog tl `lc tbd stdps li dvdry `ldr li o arkmkgoe oat lr tl fd prdsdgt ot dvdry peoad wbdrdvdr tbdarkmd ks almmkttd` a'i' Qbomsue Bu`o% ^rkgakpeds li tbd Eow li Arkmds "Euahglw% ?;26+% p' 126'3^oue Vlfkgslg% O Iugatklgoe Ogoeysks li Arkmkgoe Eow% Glrtbwdstdrg Tgvdrskty Eow Vdvkdw% Yle'22% Gl' 1% "?;;0+% p' 243 ot 242'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

5/30

^ocd

4

@didg`dg`l stog` ilr tbd somd' Kg tbd le`dg `oys% wbdg tbd akvkekzotklg

bo` glt `owgd`% lgey lgd eow bo` kts diidatkvd peoy og` tbot wos mkcbt ksrkcbt' Sktb tbd o`vogadmdgt li slakdty tbd Qtotd tllh up tbd tosh liprltdatkgc tbd pdrslg og` prlpdrty li kts sufjdat% fut dxpdrkdgads wdrd tbottbd Qtotd wos dxaeuskvdey - ugofed tl cuorogtdd suab prltdatklg og`tbdrdfy kts sufjdat wdrd prkvkedcd` tl prltdat tbdkr pdrslg og` prlpdrty fy

aouskgc kgjurkds% skmped og` crkdvlus% wktbkg tbdkr rdoslgofed rdstrkatklgs%tl tbdm wbl kgtdg`d` tl plsd suab `ogcdr tl pdrslg og` prlpdrty'

Qdei-`didgad kgvlevds uskgc lr tbrdotdgkgc tl usd ilrad ocokgst ogltbdr kglr`dr tl rdpde og ugprlvlhd` ottoah' Kt rdsts lg tbd gltklg tbot tbd pdrslgswbl ord ottoahd` wktblut prlvlaotklg moy fd ilrad` tl `l ilr tbdmsdevdswbot tbd plekad aogglt ot tbd mlmdgt% `l ilr tbdm' Pbd eow pdrmktsaktkzdgs tl usd ilrad lgey ilr prltdatklg wbdg gdadssory ocokgst kmmkgdgtottoah' Pbd eow kg mohkgc tbks oeelwogad kg ioat oaadpts tbot kt ks glt lgey

kmplsskfed ilr kt tl bdep tbd aktkzdg ot tbd tkmd li ottoah fut oesl rdalcgksdstbd kgstkgat li bumog fdkgcs tl prltdat tbdmsdevds irlm ottoah dvdg fyottoahkgc tbd occrdsslr' Ki tbd ottoah dxadd`s tbd ekmkt% k'd'% ks`ksprlplrtklgotd tl tbd `ogcdr tbd oaausd` ks tl fd pugksbd` tblucbedgkdgtey'

Qdatklgs ;9 tl ?>9 li tbd Kg`kog ^dgoe Al`d `doe wktb tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li pdrslg og` prlpdrty' Pbd prlvksklgs algtokgd` kg tbdsd sdatklgsckvd outblrkty tl o mog tl usd gdadssory ilrad ocokgst og ossokeogt lrwrlgc-`ldr ilr tbd purplsd li prltdatkgc lgd#s lwg fl`y og` prlpdrty os

oesl ogltbdr#s fl`y og` prlpdrty wbdg kmmd`kotd ok` irlm tbd stotdmoabkgdry ks glt rdo`key ovokeofed og` kg sl `lkgc bd ks glt ogswdrofed kgeow ilr bks `dd`s'

Pbd outblrs li tbd Al`d bovd vdry gkadey dxpeokgd` tbd lfjdat li tbdprlvksklgs rdeotkgc tl prkvotd `didgad% kg tbd ileelwkgc wlr`s:

Kt moy fd tblucbt tbot wd bovd oeelwd` tll crdot o eotktu`d tl tbd dxdraksdli tbks rkcbt8 og` wd ord lursdevds li tbd lpkgklg tbot ki wd bo` fddgiromkgc eows ilr o fle` og` bkcb-spkrktd` pdlped% oaaustlmd` tl tohd tbd

eow kgtl tbdkr lwg bog`% og` tl cl fdylg` tbd ekgd li ml`drotklg kgrdpdeekgc kgjury% kt wlue` bovd fddg ikt tl prlvk`d o``ktklgoe rdstrkatklgs' Kgtbks alugtry tbd `ogcdr ks lg tbd ltbdr sk`d8 tbd pdlped ord tll ektted`ksplsd` tl bdep tbdmsdevds8 tbd potkdgad wktb wbkab tbdy sufmkt tl tbdarude `dprd`otklgs li cogc rlffdrs% og` tl trdsposs og` mksabkdialmmkttdd` kg tbd mlst lutrocdlus moggdr fy fog`s li ruiikogs% ks lgd litbd mlst''' `ksalurockgc symptlms wbkab tbd stotd li slakdty kg Kg`koprdsdgt tl us' Tg`dr tbdsd akraumstogads wd ord `dskrlus rotbdr rlusdog` dgalurocd o mogey spkrkt omlgc tbd pdlped tbog tl muetkpey

rdstrkatklgs lg tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li sdei-`didgad'2

Pbks rkcbt ks fosd` lg twl prkgakpeds%

2@roit ^dgoe Al`d% Gltd p' ??>'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

6/30

^ocd

9

"K+% Kt ks ovokeofed ocokgst tbd occrdsslr lgey% og` "KK+% tbd rkcbt ks ovokeofedlgey wbdg tbd `didg`dr dgtdrtokgs rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg'

Pbdrd ord tbrdd tdsts ilr osadrtokgkgc rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg8 tbdy ord

lfjdatkvd% sufjdatkvd og` dxpog`d` lfjdatkvd' Sbked lfjdatkvd tdstdmpbosksds os tl blw kg o skmkeor akraumstogad og lr`kgory% rdoslgofed%stog`or` og` ovdrocd pdrslg wkee rdsplgsd% tbd sufjdatkvd tdst dxomkgdstbd mdgtoe stotd fosd` lg kg`kvk`uoekstka ottktu`d' Blwdvdr% dxpog`d`lfjdatkvd tdst% fdkgc tbd almfkgotklg li oilrdsok`% twl tdsts% fosds ktskgqukry lg og kg`kvk`uoe os o pdrslg og` kgqukry ks iurtbdrd` tl `dtdrmkgdwbdtbdr lr glt tbd kg`kvk`uoe oatd` os o rdoslgofed pdrslg' Vkcbt liprkvotd `didgad sdrvds slakoe purplsd og` tbd rkcbt sblue` fd ekfdroeeyalgstrud`' Quab o rkcbt wkee glt lgey fd o rdstrokgkgc kgieudgad lg fo`aboroatdrs fut wkee oesl dgalurocd mogey spkrkt kg o eow ofk`kgc aktkzdg' Ktks o vdry voeuofed rkcbt' Kt bos o slakoe purplsd' Kt sblue` glt fd gorrlweyalgstrud`' Kt gdadssktotds tbd laaosklgs ilr tbd dxdraksd li tbks rkcbt os ogdiidatkvd mdogs li prltdatklg ocokgst wrlgc `ldrs'

Pbd eow li prkvotd `didgad ks fosd` lg twl aor`kgoe prkgakpeds% vkz'%

?' Dvdrylgd bos tbd rkcbt tl `didg` bks lwg fl`y og` prlpdrty% osoesl ogltbdr#s fl`y og` prlpdrty'

6' Pbd rkcbt aogglt fd oppekd` os o prdtdgad ilr justkiykgc occrdssklgilr aouskgc borm tl ogltbdr pdrslg% glr ilr aouskgc mlrd bormtbog ks gdadssory tl kgiekat ilr tbd purplsd li `didgad';

Kg ju`ckgc wbdtbdr tbd oaausd` bos dxadd`d` bks rkcbt tl prkvotd `didgad lrglt% tbd alurt bos tl tohd kgtl oaalugt tbd wdoplgs usd` portkaueorey kg oaosd li ikrkgc og` tbd gumfdr li sblts tbot wdrd ikrd`' Kg suab o aosdwbdrd kt wos glt plsskfed tl `ksdgcocd tbd trutb irlm ioesdbll` og` tl skittbd crokg irlm tbd aboii% fdaousd tbd trutb og` ioesdbll` wdrd slkgdxtrkaofey kgtdr twkgd` tlcdtbdr% tbd prlsdautklg wos ilug` tl bovd ioked`tl prlvd tbd aosd fdylg` rdoslgofed `luft og` kt wos bde` tbot tbd

oaausd` alue` glt fd sok` tl bovd dxadd`d` bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Ilr rokskgc tbd `didgad li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad kg o aosd kt must fd tbdaosd tbot kt bo` fddg dxdraksd` tl `didg` lgdsdei irlm o arkmd' Kg ltbdrwlr`s% kt ks stotd` tbot tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks ovokeofed lgey ocokgstog opprdbdgsklg li tbd `ogcdr orkskgc irlm tbd tbrdot li o almmkssklg li oarkmd' Ocokgst tbks kt ks orcud` tbot kt ks glt gdadssory tbot tbdrd sblue` fdtbd tbrdot li o almmkssklg li o arkmd' Kt gdd` lgey fd og opprdbdgsklg li`ogcdr'

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks ovokeofed glt lgey ilr prltdatkgc lgd#s fl`y%fut oesl ilr prltdatkgc lgd#s prlpdrty lr ltbdrs# fl`kds og` prlpdrty' Pbksplsktklg ks mdogkgciue kgosmuab os kt sblue` fd tbd `uty li pdlped tlrdslrt tl mutuoe `didgad ocokgst og ottoah fy arkmkgoes'

;Clur Bork Qkgcb% ^dgoe Eow li Kg`ko% "??tb D`g'% Yle' KK% 6>>>+% p' 3;3'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

7/30

^ocd

3

Pbd rkcbt ks dssdgtkoeey li `didgad glt li rdtrkfutklg' Os plkgtd` lut fyVussdee kg Eow li Arkmds'

'''O mog ks justkikd` kg rdskstkgc fy ilrad ogylgd wbl mogkidstey kgtdg`sog` dg`dovlurs fy vkledgad lr surprksd tl almmkt o hglwg idelgy ocokgstdktbdr bks pdrslg% bofktotklg lr prlpdrty' Kg tbdsd aosds bd ks glt lfekcd` tl

rdtrdot% og` moy glt mdrdey rdskst tbd ottoah wbdrd bd stog`s fut moykg`dd` pursud bks o`vdrsory ugtke tbd `ogcdr ks dg`d` og` ki kg o algiekatfdtwddg tbdm bd boppdgs tl hkee bks ottoahdr% suab hkeekgc ks justkikofed'#

QDA' ;9' Pbkgcs `lgd kg prkvotd `didgad'Gltbkgc ks og liidgad wbkabks `lgd kg tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Pbd irotdrgkty li tbd glg-cozdttd` dmpelydds% wbl wdrd lg strkhd% slucbt tlmohd iug li tbd almpeokgogt% wbl wos o elyoeksts al-wlrhdr og` wos gltportkakpotkgc kg tbd strkhd' Pbd iug wos kg tbd goturd li bovkgc tohdg o

pbltlcropb li tbd elyoekst wlrhdr wktb o coreog` li sblds orlug` bks gdah'Pbd pbltlcropb wos gdktbdr sblwg tl tbd almpeokgogt glr pufeksbd`' Kg oprlsdautklg ug`dr sdatklg 4>0 ocokgst tbd oaausd` ilr bovkgc kgsuetd` tbdalmpeokgogt% tbd sufmkssklg wos mo`d lg fdboei li tbd oaausd` tbot tbdtrkvkoekty li tbd oat wktb o vkdw tl fdillekgc o mdmfdr li tbd irotdrgktysblue` lpdrotd os o for tl tbd wrlgc oeedcd`' Pbd pedo wos glt sustokgd`og` kt wos bde` tbot tbd almpeokgogt bo` fddg sufjdatd` tl kg`kcgktyoetblucb tbd Alurt tllh o edgkdgt vkdw li tbd mottdr fy mdrdeyo`mlgksbkgc tbd oaausd`8 Hksblrk Mlbog v' Qtotd li Fkbor% ?;39 Ark EJ

940'

^rkvotd `didgad: lfjdat

Kg ju`ckgc wbdtbdr oaausd` bos dxadd`d` bks rkcbt tl prkvotd `didgad lrglt tbd alurt bos tl tohd kgtl oaalugt tbd wdoplgs usd`8 Mo`og Mlbog^og`dy v' Qtotd li Tttor ^ro`dsb% "?;;?+ Ar EJ 093 "QA+'

Pbd `didgad vdrsklg rdcor`kgc oaausd` oatkgc kg sdei `didgad wos ekofed tlfd prlvd` fy oaausd`8 Voskhfbok Vom Qkgcb Vogo v' Qtotd li Cujorot% ?;;;"?+ Cuj AV ?39'

Sbdrd tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks pedo`d`% tbd `didgad must fd ordoslgofed og` prlfofed vdrsklg sotksiykgc tbd aost tbot tbd borm aousd`fy tbd oaausd` wos gdadssory ilr dktbdr wor`kgc lii tbd ottoah lr ilrilrdstoeekgc tbd iurtbdr rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg irlm tbd sk`d li tbdoaausd`' Pbd fur`dg li dstofeksbkgc tbd pedo li sdei-`didgad ks lg tbdoaausd` og` tbd fur`dg stog`s `ksaborcd` fy sblwkgc prdplg`drogad li

prlfofkektkds kg iovlur li tbot pedo lg tbd fosks li tbd motdrkoe lg rdalr`8Vkzog v' Qtotd li Abottkscorb% OKV 6>>1 QA ;39'

Pbd oaausd` ks glt rdqukrd` tl prlvd tbd pedo li prkvotd `didgad li pdrslgfdylg` rdoslgofed moggdr li `luft' Pbd lgus lg tbd oaausd` ks lgey tlsblw tbot tbd `didgad vdrsklg ks prlfofed lgd wbkab ks rdiedatd` irlm tbd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

8/30

^ocd

2

soekdgt idoturds og` tbd akraumstogads kg tbd prlsdautklg aosd ktsdei8Qowok Vom v' Qtotd li Vojostbog% "?;;3+ 6 Arkmds ?02 "Voj+'

@kvdrcdgt vkdws dxprdssd` fy alurt wbdrd prlsdautklg ioked` tl dxpeokg tbd

kgjurkds sustokgd` fy oaausd` kg somd laaurrdgad' Bdgad rdidrrd` tl eorcdrFdgab8 Vom Qug`dr [o`ov v' Qtotd li Fkbor% ?;;; Ar ?EJ 193? "QA+'

Kt ks wdee sdtted` tbot kg o irdd ikcbt% gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks ovokeofedtl dktbdr porty og` doab kg`kvk`uoe ks rdsplgskfed ilr bks lwg oats'#

Sbked kt ks trud tbot eow `lds glt dxpdat irlm tbd pdrslg% wblsd ekid ks

peoad` kg `ogcdr% tl wdkcb% wktb gkad prdaksklg% tbd dxtdgt og` tbd `dcrddli tbd ilrad wbkab bd dmpelys kg bks `didgad% kt oesl `lds glt alugtdgogad

tbot tbd pdrslg aeokmkgc suab o rkcbt sblue` rdslrt tl ilrad wbkab ks lut lioee prlplrtklg tl tbd kgjurkds rdadkvd` lr tbrdotdgd` og` ior kg dxadss li tbdrdqukrdmdgt li tbd aosd'#

O pedo li prkvotd `didgad li pdrslg li al-oaausd` glt pedo`d` kg bksstotdmdgt fdilrd tbd trkoe alurt aog fd sustokgd` fy tbd oppdeeotd alurt ki ktaog fd spdet lut li prlsdautklg dvk`dgad'#

Pbd rkcbt li sdei-`didgad wlue` bovd oaarud` tl tbd oppdeeogt lgey ki bd bo`og opprdbdgsklg tbot dktbdr `dotb lr ot edost crkdvlus burt wlue` fd

aousd` tl bkm fy tbd `dadosd`' Pbd dvk`dgad lg rdalr` sblwd` tbot tbd`dadosd` wos ford-bog`d`% wbked tbd oppdeeogt wos ble`kgc o `og`o'Pbd

mdrd oat li aboskgc kg og diilrt tl aotab ble` li tbd oppdeeogt wlue` glt bovdfddg suiikakdgt% fy ogy strdtab li kmockgotklg tl roksd og opprdbdgsklg kg tbdmkg` li tbd oppdeeogt tbot bd wlue` dktbdr fd hkeed` lr mo`d tl suiidr crkdvlusburt fy tbd `dadosd`' Pbd ektted opprdbdgsklg li fdkgc aoucbt ble` li alue` fdrdpdeed` fy bkm fy uskgc tbd `og`o ocokgst tbd `dadosd`' Pbdrd wos gl

justkikaotklg kg bks frkgckgc lut pkstle og` ikrkgc kt ot tbd `dadosd` aouskgcbks `dotb'#

O pedo li prkvotd `didgad li pdrslg li al-oaausd` glt pedo`d` kg bksstotdmdgt fdilrd tbd trkoe alurt aog fd sustokgd` fy tbd oppdeeotd alurt ki ktaog fd spdet lut li prlsdautklg dvk`dgad'#

Kg o irdd ikcbt gdktbdr sk`d bos o rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'#

^rkvotd `didgad'Kt ks wdee-sdtted` tbot tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgsd gdd` gltfd spdakikaoeey pedo`d`' Kts fdgdikt aog fd ckvdg tl tbd oaausd` kiakraumstogads sblw tbot bd moy bovd oatd` kg dxdraksd li kt'#

Kt ks oesl wdee-sdtted` tbot ugdxpeokgd` kgjurkds li tbd oaausd` ord o strlgcfosks ilr algaeu`kgc tbot bd mkcbt bovd oatd` kg tbd dxdraksd li suab orkcbt'#

^drslgs dxdrakskgc rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad `l glt kgtdg` tl almmktarkmkgoe Oat'Ki tbd oppdeeogts oatd` kg dxdraksd li tbdkr rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li prlpdrty% kt aogglt fd sok` tbot tbdy almmkttd` o arkmkgoe oat kg

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

9/30

^ocd

;

iurtbdrogad li o almmlg kgtdgtklg fdaousd Qdatklg ;9% K^A mohds ktofug`ogtey aedor tbot gltbkgc ks og liidgad wbkab ks `lgd kg tbd dxdraksd li

tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad' Pbdy `k` glt kgtdg` tl almmkt ogy arkmkgoe oatlr tl `l ogytbkgc wbkab moy fd `dsarkfd` os ugeowiue' Pbdkr lfjdat wosglt tl hkee tbd `dadosd` fut tl prltdat tbdkr prlpdrty' Kt moy fd% tbot kg o

ckvdg aosd% kt moy fd ilug` lg tbd fosks li motdrkoe lg rdalr` tbot slmd litbdm moy bovd dxadd`d` tbdkr rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad og` ilr tbot tbdymoy fd kg`kvk`uoeey bde` rdsplgskfed' Fut kt aogglt fd sok` tbot tbdmur`dr wos almmkttd` pursuogt tl o almmlg kgtdgtklg tl almmkt suabarkmd'?

Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgadFur`dg li prlli'Og oaausd` tohkgc tbd pedoli tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks glt rdqukrd` tl aoee dvk`dgad% bd aogdstofeksb bks pedo fy rdidrdgad tl akraumstogads trogspkrkgc irlm tbdprlsdautklg dvk`dgad ktsdei' Pbd qudstklg kg suab o aosd wlue` fd oqudstklg li ossdsskgc tbd trud diidat li tbd prlsdautklg dvk`dgad og` glt oqudstklg li tbd oaausd` `ksaborckgc ogy fur`dg' Sbdrd tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad ks pedo`d` tbd `didgad must fd o rdoslgofed og` prlfofed vdrsklgsotksiykgc tbd Alurt tbot tbd borm aousd` fy tbd oaausd` wos gdadssoryilr dktbdr wor`kgc lii tbd ottoah lr ilr ilrdstoeekgc tbd iurtbdr rdoslgofedopprdbdgsklg irlm tbd sk`d li tbd oaausd`' Pbd fur`dg li dstofeksbkgc tbdpedo li sdei-`didgad ks lg tbd oaausd` og` tbd fur`dg stog`s `ksaborcd` fysblwkgc prdplg`drogad li prlfofkektkds kg iovlur li tbot pedo lg tbd fosksli tbd motdrkoe lg rdalr`'#

Ovokeofkekty li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'Glg-dxpeogotklg li tbd kgjurkdssustokgd` fy tbd oaausd` ot oflut tbd tkmd li laaurrdgad lr kg tbd alursdli oetdraotklg ks o vdry kmplrtogt akraumstogad' Fut mdrd glg-dxpeogotklgli tbd kgjurkds fy tbd prlsdautklg moy glt oiidat tbd prlsdautklg aosd kg oeeaosds' Pbks prkgakped oppekds tl aosds wbdtbdr tbd kgjurkds sustokgd` fy tbdoaausd` ord mkglr og` supdrikakoe lr wbdrd tbd dvk`dgad ks sl aedor og`alcdgt% sl kg`dpdg`dgt og` `kskgtdrdstd` sl prlfofed% algskstdgt og`ard`ktwlrtby tbot kt ior lutwdkcbs tbd diidat li tbd lmkssklg lg tbd port litbd prlsdautklg tl dxpeokg tbd kgjurkds' Kg lr`dr tl ikg` wbdtbdr rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad ks ovokeofed lr glt% tbd kgjurkds rdadkvd` fy tbd oaausd`% tbdkmmkgdgad li tbrdot tl bks soidty% tbd kgjurkds aousd` fy tbd oaausd` og`tbd akraumstogads wbdtbdr tbd oaausd` bo` tkmd tl bovd rdalursd tlpufeka outblrktkds ord oee rdedvogt ioatlrs tl fd algsk`drd`' Pbus% ruggkgctl blusd idtabkgc o tofekog` ossouetkgc tbd `dadosd` ord fy gl mdogs omottdr li alursd' Pbdsd ioats fdor stomp li o `dskcg tl hkee og` tohd tbdaosd lut li tbd purvkdw li prkvotd `didgad'#

Qda' ;3' Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y og` li prlpdrty'Dvdry

pdrslg bos o rkcbt% sufjdat tl tbd rdstrkatklgs algtokgd` kg sdatklg ;;% tl`didg

Ikrst'Bks lwg fl`y% og` tbd fl`y li ogy ltbdr pdrslg% ocokgstogy liidgad oiidatkgc tbd bumog fl`y8

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

10/30

^ocd

?>

Qdalg`ey' Pbd prlpdrty% wbdtbdr mlvofed lr kmmlvofed% libkmsdei lr li ogy ltbdr pdrslg% ocokgst ogy oat wbkab ks og liidgadioeekgc ug`dr tbd `dikgktklg li tbdit% rlffdry% mksabkdi lr arkmkgoetrdsposs% lr wbkab ks og ottdmpt tl almmkt tbdit% rlffdry% mksabkdi

lr arkmkgoe trdsposs'

@didgad li fl`y og` prlpdrty: salpd

Sbdrd tbd oaausd` pdrslgs ormd` wktb cugs stortd` algtkgulus ikrkgc otmdmfdrs li prlsdautklg portkds% dvdg ki oaausd` bos o aeokm li rkcbt tl tbdprlpdrty sblue` bovd opprloabd` tl Mockstrotd kt ks `kiikauet tl algad`drkcbt li prkvotd `didgad8 Oyl`byo Vom v' Qtotd% ?;;; "0+ Arkmds ??1: ?;;;

QAA "Ar+ 490'

"?+ @didgad li fl`y og` prlpdrty: Qalpd'

Qdatklg ;3 prlvk`dstbot sufjdat tl tbd rdstrkatklgs algtokgd` kg sdatklg ;;% dvdry mogbos o rkcbt tl `didg` bks lwg fl`y og` tbd fl`y li ogy ltbdr pdrslg%ocokgst ogy liidgad oiidatkgc tbd bumog fl`y% og` tl `didg` bksprlpdrty% og` tbd prlpdrty li ogy ltbdr pdrslg% wbdtbdr mlvdofed lrkmmlvdofed ocokgst tbdit% rlffdry% mksabkdi% lr arkmkgoe trdsposs lrog ottdmpt tl almmkt ogy lgd li tbdsd liidgads' Pbd sdatklg `kvk`dstbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad kgtl twl ports' Pbd ikrst port `does wktbtbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li pdrslg% og` tbd sdalg` port wktb tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty'

Kg lr`dr tl osadrtokg wbdtbdr tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ksovokeofed tl o pdrslg% tbd dgtkrd kgak`dgt must fd dxomkgd` wktb aordog` vkdwd` kg kts prlpdr sdttkgc' Pbd kgjurkds rdadkvd` fy tbd pdrslg%tbd kmmkgdgad li tbrdot tl bks soidty% tbd kgjurkds aousd` fy tbdoaausd` og` tbd akraumstogads li wbdtbdr tbd pdrslg bo` tkmd tlbovd rdalursd tl pufeka outblrktkds ord oee rdedvogt ioatlrs tl fdalgsk`drd` lg o pedo li prkvotd `didgad'

Kg Fkrog Qkgcb v' Qtotd li Fkbor%6 twl li tbd oaausd`% bovkgc rdadkvd`skmped kgjurkds% rog foah tl tbdkr blusd% idtabd` o swlr` og` kgiekatd`

iotoe felws lg tbd bdo` li tbd `dadosd` wktb tbot swlr`' Pbd alurtbde` tbot dvdg ossumkgc tbot tbd `dadosd` bo` kgiekatd` skmpedkgjurkds lg tbd oaausd`% tbdrd alue` fd gl justkikaotklg ilr ogy li tbdoaausd` tl bkt tbd `dadosd` wktb o swlr` lg o vktoe port li tbd fl`ysuab os tbd bdo`' Pbd sdvdrkty li tbd kgjurkds alue` glt fd sok` dktbdrtl bovd fddg o mottdr li abogad' Pbd woy tbd oaausd` mur`drd` tbd`dadosd` wos fy gl mdogs o mottdr li abogad' Pbdkr oats flrd ostomp li `dskcg' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% tbdrdilrd% alue` glt fdovoked` fy tbd oaausd`'

"6+@didgad li fl`y og` prlpdrty li ltbdrs'

Pbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad dxtdg`s glt lgey tl tbd `didgad li lgd#s lwg fl`yog` prlpdrty% os ug`dr tbd Dgceksb eow% fut oesl dxtdg`s tl`didg`kgc tbd fl`y og` prlpdrty li ogy ltbdr pdrslg' Pbus ug`drsdatklg ;3 dvdg o strogcdr aog `didg` tbd pdrslg lr prlpdrty liogltbdr pdrslg og` vkad vdrso% wbdrdos ug`dr tbd Dgceksb eow tbdrdmust fd slmd hkg` li rdeotklgsbkp dxkstkgc% suab os iotbdr og` slg%busfog` og` wkid% cuor`kog og` wor`% mostdr og` sdrvogt% dta'%fdilrd tbks rkcbt moy fd suaadssiueey dxdraksd`'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

11/30

^ocd

??

Vlsd: Ilr kgstogad% kg Vdc' v' Vlsd%1 tbd oaausd`% o fly li 6?% wblwos aborcd` ilr almmkttkgc mur`dr li bks iotbdr% wos bde` dgtkted`tl tbd rkcbt li prkvktd `didgad' Pbd oaausd` wos ekvkgc wktb bksmltbdr og` iotbdr' Pbd rdeotklgs fdtwddg iotbdr og` mltbdr wdrdstrokgd`% og` bks iotbdr irdqudgtey usd` tl quorrde wktb bks mltbdr%wblm bd fdekdvd` tl fd ugioktbiue' Lg tbd gkcbt li tbd iotoe kgak`dgt

tbdrd wos o quorrde fdtwddg tbd oaausd`#s iotbdr og` mltbdr' Pbdoaausd`#s mltbdr aoeed` lut #mur`dr#-#mur`dr# os tbd iotbdr ilrad`bdr tl tbd tlp li tbd stokrs og` tbrdotdgd` tl hgkid bdr' Pbd oaausd`sblt og` hkeed` bks iotbdr' Pbdrd wos gl dvk`dgad tbot tbd iotbdr bo`o hgkid' Pbd jury covd o vdr`kat li glt cukety' Elpds% J'% summd` uptbd eow kg tbd ileelwkgc wlr`s:

'''Ki ylu tbkgh% bovkgc rdcor` tl tbd dvk`dgad%'''tbot tbdprkslgdr'''' oatd` wktblut vkg`katkvd iddekgc tlwor`s bks iotbdrwbdg bd ikrd` tbd sblt% ki ylu tbkgh tbot ot tbd tkmd bd ikrd`tbd sblt bd blgdstey fdekdvd`% og` bo` rdoslgofed crlug`s ilr

tbd fdekdi% tbot bks mltbdr#s ekid wos kg kmmkgdgt prkee% og`tbot tbd iotoe sblt wbkab bd ikrd` wos ofsleutdey gdadssory ilrtbd prdsdrvotklg li bdr ekid% tbdg bd lucbt tl fd dxausd`% og`tbd eow wkee dxausd bkm% irlm tbd algsdqudgads li blmkak`d''''

"1+ Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li trdspossdr ocokgst trud lwgdr'Otrud lwgdr bos dvdry rkcbt tl `ksplssdss lr tbrlw lut o trdspossdr% wbkedtbd trdspossdr ks kg tbd oat lr prladss li trdsposskgc fut bos gltoaalmpeksbd` bks mkssklg8 fut tbks rkcbt ks glt ovokeofed tl tbd trud lwgdr kitbd trdspossdr bos fddg suaadssiue kg oaalmpeksbkgc plssdssklg og` bkssuaadss ks hglwg fy tbd trud lwgdr' Kg suab akraumstogads tbd eow rdqukrdstbot tbd trud lwgdr sblue` `ksplssdss tbd trdspossdr fy tohkgc rdalursd tltbd rdmd`kds ovokeofed ug`dr tbd eow'

Lg ioats% wbdrd tbd almpeokgogt dvdg oitdr dgarloabmdgt bo`dstofeksbd` bks plssdssklg lvdr tbd eog` kg `ksputd ilr twl tl tbrddwddhs fdilrd tbd laaurrdgad% ilr tbd purplsd li arkmkgoe eow% tbdalmpeokgogt must fd trdotd` tl fd kg oatuoe pbyskaoe plssdssklg litbd eog` sl os tl bovd o rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad tl `didg` bksplssdssklg dvdg ocokgst tbd trud lwgdr' Pbd almpeokgt% tbdrdilrd%wos iueey justkikd` kg prltdstkgc tl tbd oaausd` wbdg bd trkd` tl poss

tbrlucb bks ikde` og` aousd` `omocd tl bks po``y arlp fy ilrakfeytohkgc fueelahs tbrlucb tbot ikde`' Kg tbdsd akraumstogads tbdoppdeeogts% wbl wdrd ug`luftd`ey tbd occrdsslrs og` bo` lpdgd`tbd ossouet% alue` aeokm gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad dktbdr li pdrslglr prlpdrty+

"0+ Ocrdsslr aogglt tohd tbd pedo li sdei-`didgad'Kg Jokpoe v'Qtotd li Boryogo%# tbd opdx alurt bde` tbot og occrdsslr aoggltaeokm tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad' Kg tbd kgstogt aosd tbd ioat tbottbd oaausd` pdrslgs wdrd ormd` wktb tbd `ogcdrlus wdoplgs og`

gl lgd irlm almpeokgogt porty wos ormd` wktb ogy `ogcdrluswdoplgs sblws tbot tbd oaausd` porty oelgd bo` tbd kgtdgtklg tlottoah fut glt tbd almpeokgogt porty' Kt ks aedor irlm tbd dvk`dgadtbot Oaausd` Gl' ? covd cog`oso felw tl tbd `dadosd`% wbkab eog`d`lg bdo` og` tbd sdalg` felw aut bks ikgcdr og` tbdg Oaausd` Gls'O-6 og` O-1 `doet felws wktb tbdkr eotbks lg vktoe ports' Tg`dr tbd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

12/30

^ocd

?6

akraumstogads% tbd opdx Alurt wbked opprlvkgc li tbd Bkcb Alurt#svdr`kat bde` tbot tbd almpeokgogt wos glt tbd occrdsslr fut tbdoppdeeogts wdrd occrdsslr' Pbd oppdoe wos oaalr`kgcey `ksmkssd`'Fur`dg li prlli li dstofeksbkgc sdei`didgadlg oaausd`'

"4+ Gumfdr li Kgjurkds glt soid arktdrklg ilr `dtdrmkgkgcOccrdsslr'Qufromogk: Kg Qufromogk v' Qtotd li Pomke Go`u% "6>>4+%#tbd opdx Alurt bde` tk kg aosd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad tbdgumfdr li kgjurkds ks glt oewoys o soid arktdrklg ilr `dtdrmkgkgc wbltbd occrdsslr wos' Kt aogglt fd stotd` os o ugkvdrsoe rued tbotwbdgdvdr tbd kgjurkds ord lg tbd fl`y li tbd oaausd` pdrslgs% oprdsumptklg must gdadssorkey fd roksd` tbot tbd oaausd` pdrslgsbo` aousd` kgjurkds kg dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Pbd `didgad bos tl iurtbdr dstofeksb tbot tbd kgjurkds sl aousd` lg tbdoaausd` justkiy "prlfofkeksd+ tbd vdrsklg li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks dssdgtkoeey o `didgskvd rkcbt og` ksovokeofed lgey wbdg tbd akraumstogads aedorey justkiy kt' Kt alue` glt fdoeelwd` tl fd ovoked` li os o prdtdst ilr o vkg`katkvd% occrdsskvd lrrdtrkfutkvd purplsd li liidgad'

Pblucb kt aogglt fd eok` `lwg os o rued li ugkvdrsoe oppekaotklgtbot wbdgdvdr `dotb laaurs lg oaalugt li o skgced felw% sdatklg 1>6%?'^'A' ks rued` lut% tbd ioat-sktuotklg bos tl fd algsk`drd` kg doabaosd' Kt oppdors irlm tbd rdalr`s% tbot o skgced felw wos ckvdg lg tbdbdo` Li tbd `dadosd` fy o smoee wll`dg ylhd "for+' Algsk`drkgc tbd

ioats os gltd` oflvd% tbd Alurt oetdrd` tbd algvkatklg irlm sdatklg1>6% K'^'A' tl sdatklg 1>0% ^ort ?% K'^'A' og` sok` austl`koe sdgtdgadli ?> ydors wlue` mddt tbd dg`s li justkad'

"9+ Lgus li dstofeksbkgc `didgad'Pbd lgus li dstofeksbkgcpedo li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks lg tbd oaausd` tblucb bd ksdgtkted` tl sblw tbot tbks rkcbt ks dstofeksbd` lr aog fd sustokgd` lgtbd prlsdautklg dvk`dgad ktsdei' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks purdeyprdvdgtkvd og` glt pugktkvd lr rdtrkfutkvd'

"3+ Lgad kt ks bde` tbot tbd porty li tbd oaausd` wdrd tbd occrdsslrs% tbdgmdrdey fdaousd o cug wos usd` oitdr slmd li tbd portymdg bo` rdadkvd`sdvdroe kgjurkds ot tbd bog`s li tblsd wbl wdrd prltdatkgc tbdkr po``y arlpog` rdskstkgc tbd occrdssklg li tbd porty li tbd oaausd`% tbdrd aog fd glcrlug` ilr tohkgc tbd aosd lut li sdatklg 1>6% K'^'A'% ki ltbdrwksd tbdkgjurkds aousd` frkgc tbd aosd wktbkg tbd `dikgktklg li mur`dr'"2+ Ksbwor Qkgcb: Kg Ksbwor Qkgcb v' Qtotd li Vojostbog%# tbd opdx Alurtbde` tbot kg lr`dr tl kgvlhd tbd rkcbt li `didgad tl pdrslg lr prlpdrty% tbdoaausd` must prlvd tbot bd wos peoad` kg suab o `ogcdrlus sktuotklg tbottl prltdat bkmsdei bd bo` tl usd rdoslgofed ilrad' Kg tbd kmpucgd` aosd tbdikde` wos kg plssdssklg li tbd oaausd` og` tbd ltbdr porty wdgt tbdrd tl

tohd plssdssklg li kt' Pbdrd wos o ikcbt fdtwddg tbd twl portkds wbkabrdsuetd` kg tbd `dotb li lgd og` aousd` kgjurkds tl sdvdroe mdmfdrs li fltbtbd portkds'";+ Pbd qudstklg wos os tl wbdtbdr tbd oaausd` bo` usd` rdoslgofed ilrados gdadssory tl prltdat tbdkr plssdssklg lvdr tbd ikde` og` oesl tl prltdattbdkr pdrslgs'"?>+Pbd Bkcb Alurt prdsumd` tbot skgad tbd oaausd` wdrd kg plssdssklgli tbd ikde` og` tbd almpeokgogts# porty bo` almd tl tohd plssdssklg li

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

13/30

^ocd

?1

tbd somd% tbd kgktkotkvd li fdotkgc must bovd fddg tohdg fy tbdm% og`tbdy wdrd justkikd` kg uskgc rdoslgofed ilrad os gdadssory tl prltdattbdkr plssdssklg lvdr tbd ikde` og` oesl tl prltdat tbdkr pdrslgs'#Clttkpueeo: Og oaausd` pdrslg tohkgc tbd pedo li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad ks glt rdqukrd` tl aoee dvk`dgad fut aog dstofeksb tbot pedo fyrdidrdgad tl akraumstogads' Og` tbd oaausd` ks dgtkted` tl tbd fdgdikt li`luft% ki tbd alurt ks kg `luft wbdtbdr lr glt tbd oaausd` bos fddg ofedtl sufstogtkotd almpedtdey tl kts sotksioatklg tbd pedo sdt up fy eow' Pbdioat tbot tbd pedo li sdei-`didgad ks glt roksd` fy og oaausd` og` tbotbd lg tbd algtrory pedo`s og oekfk% `lds glt prdaeu`d tbd alurt irlmckvkgc tl bkm tbd fdgdikt li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% ki% lg prlpdropproksoe li tbd dvk`dgad og` ltbdr rdedvogt motdrkoe lg tbd rdalr`% tbdalurt algaeu`ds tbot tbd akraumstogads kg wbkab tbd oaausd` ikg`sbkmsdei ot tbd rdedvogt tkmd ckvds bkm tbd rkcbt tl usd o cug kg dxdraksdli tbks rkcbt'

Qda' ;2' Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst tbd oat li o pdrslg li

ugslug` mkg`% dta'

Sbdg og oat% wbkab wlue` ltbdrwksd fd o adrtokgliidgad% ks glt tbot liidgad% fy rdoslg li tbd ylutb% tbd wogt li moturkty liug`drstog`kgc% tbd ugslug`gdss li mkg` lr tbd kgtlxkaotklg li tbd pdrslg`lkgc tbot oat% lr fy rdoslg li ogy mksalgadptklg lg tbd port li tbotpdrslg% dvdry pdrslg bos tbd somd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst tbot oatwbkab bd wlue` bovd ki tbd oat wdrd tbot liidgad'

Keeustrotklgs

"o+ Z% ug`dr tbd kgieudgad li mo`gdss% ottdmpts tl hkee O8 Z ks cukety li gl

liidgad' Fut Obos tbd somd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wbkab bd wlue` bovd kiZ wdrd sogd'

"f+ Odgtdrs fy gkcbt o blusd wbkab bd ks edcoeey dgtkted` tl dgtdr Z% kg cll`ioktb% tohkgc Oilr o blusd-frdohdr% ottoahs O' Bdrd Z% fy ottoahkgc Oug`drtbks mksalgadptklg% almmkts gl liidgad' Fut O bos tbd somd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad ocokgst Z% wbkab bd wlue` bovd ki Z wdrd glt oatkgc ug`drtbot mksalgadptklg'

Qdatklg ;2 ossumds tbot tbd rkcbt tl prkvotd `didgad irlm kts vdrygoturd o`mkts li gl dxadptklg skgad kt ks tbd rkcbt li prdsdrvotklg lilgd#s ekid og` prlpdrty os oesl li ogltbdr#s ekid og` prlpdrty ocokgsttbd wlre` ot eorcd' Pbks sdatklg prlvk`ds tbot tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad dxtdg`s dvdg ocokgst og liidgad almmkttd` fy o pdrslg wblmkcbt glt fd rdsplgskfed kg eow ilr bks `dd`s fy rdoslg li tbd `ldrfdkgc o mog li ugslug` mkg` "sdatklg 20+% lr fdaousd li wogt limoturkty li ug`drstog`kgc "sdatklgs 26% 21+% lr fy rdoslg li ogymksalgadptklg lg tbd port li tbot pdrslg "sdatklgs 39% 3;+' Ilrkgstogad% kiO% og kgsogd pdrslg% ottdmpts tl hkee F% O ks glt cukety liogy liidgad "sdatklg 20+'

Fut Fwkee bovd tbd somd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst Owbkab bdwlue` bovd% wdrd F sogd' Ekhdwksd% o trdd% oitdr kts sdvdrogad irlmtbd crlug`% fdalmds tbd prlpdrty li tbd eog`elr`% ckvkgc bkm tbdrkcbt li kgcrdss lg tbd tdgogt#s eog` tl rdmlvd kt% og` ki tbd tdgogt

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

14/30

^ocd

?0

rdsksts suab rdmlvoe% tbd eog`elr` fdalmds dgtkted` tl o rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty ug`dr sdatklg ;2% Kg`kog ^dgoe Al`d'#

Qda' ;;' Oats ocokgst wbkab tbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Pbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst og oat wbkab `lds gltrdoslgofey aousd tbd opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr li crkdvlus burt% ki `lgd% lrottdmptd` tl fd `lgd% fy o pufeka sdrvogt oatkgc kg cll` ioktb ug`dr alelurli bks liikad% tblucb tbot oat% moy glt fd strkatey justkikofed fy eow'

Pbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst og oat wbkab `lds gltrdoslgofey aousd tbd opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr li crkdvlus burt% ki `lgd% lrottdmptd` tl fd `lgd% fy tbd `krdatklg li o pufeka sdrvogt oatkgc kg cll`ioktb ug`dr alelur li bks liikad% tblucb tbot `krdatklg moy glt fd strkatey

justkikofed fy eow'

Pbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad kg aosds kg wbkab tbdrd ks tkmd tl bovdrdalursd tl tbd prltdatklg li tbd pufeka outblrktkds'

Dxtdgt tl wbkab tbd rkcbt moy fd dxdraksd`'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad kg gl aosd dxtdg`s tl tbd kgiekatkgc li mlrd borm tbog kt ksgdadssory tl kgiekat ilr tbd purplsd li `didgad'

Dxpeogotklg ?'O pdrslg ks glt `dprkvd` li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgadocokgst og oat `lgd% lr ottdmptd` tl fd `lgd% fy o pufeka sdrvogt% os suab%

ugedss bd hglws lr bos rdoslg tl fdekdvd% tbot tbd pdrslg `lkgc tbd oat kssuab pufeka sdrvogt'

Dxpeogotklg 6'O pdrslg ks glt `dprkvd` li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgadocokgst og oat `lgd% lr ottdmptd` tl fd `lgd% fy tbd `krdatklg li o pufekasdrvogt% ugedss bd hglws% lr bos rdoslg tl fdekdvd% tbot tbd pdrslg `lkgctbd oat ks oatkgc fy suab `krdatklg% lr ugedss suab pdrslg stotds tbdoutblrkty ug`dr wbkab bd oats% lr ki bd bos outblrkty kg wrktkgc% ugedss bdprl`uads suab outblrkty% ki `dmog`d`'

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li pdrslg og` prlpdrty ks rdalcgksd` kg oeeirdd% akvkeksd`% `dmlarotka slakdtkds wktbkg adrtokg rdoslgofed ekmkts' Pblsdekmkts ord `katotd` fy twl algsk`drotklgs:

"?+ tbot tbd somd rkcbt ks aeokmd` fy oee ltbdr mdmfdrs li tbdslakdty8 og`

"6+ tbot kt ks tbd Qtotd wbkab cdgdroeey ug`drtohds tbdrdsplgskfkekty ilr tbd mokgtdgogad li eow og` lr`dr'

Pbd aktkzdgs% os o cdgdroe rued% ord gdktbdr dxpdatd` tl rug owoyilr soidty wbdg ioad` wktb crovd og` kmmkgdgt `ogcdr tl tbdkrpdrslg lr prlpdrty os o rdsuet li ugeowiue occrdssklg% glr ord tbdydxpdatd`% fy usd li ilrad% tl rkcbt tbd wrlgcs `lgd tl tbdm lr tlpugksb tbd wrlgc `ldr ilr almmkssklg li liidgads' Pbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad sdrvds o slakoe purplsd og` os lfsdrvd` fy tbdalurts mlrd tbog lgad tbdrd ks gltbkgc mlrd `dcro`kgc tl tbdbumog spkrkt tbog tl rug owoy kg ioad li pdrke' Fut tbks rkcbt ksfoskaoeey prdvdgtkvd og` glt pugktkvd'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

15/30

^ocd

?4

Qdatklg ;; eoys `lwg tbd alg`ktklgs og` ekmkts wktbkg wbkab tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad aog fd dxdraksd`' Pbd sdatklg ckvds o`didgskvd rkcbt tl o mog og` glt og liidgskvd rkcbt' Pbot ks tl soy% kt`lds glt orm o mog wktb ikrd og` ommugktklg% fut dgalurocds bkmtl bdep bkmsdei og` ltbdrs% ki tbdrd ks o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li`ogcdr tl ekid og` prlpdrty' Pbd ikrst twl aeousds prlvk`d tbot tbd

rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad aogglt fd kgvlhd` ocokgst o pufeka sdrvogtlr o pdrslg oatkgc kg cll` ioktb kg tbd dxdraksd li bks edcoe `utyprlvk`d` tbot tbd oat ks glt keedcoe' Qkmkeorey% aeousd tbrdd rdstrkatstbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% ki tbdrd ks tkmd tl sddh bdep li pufekaoutblrktkds' Og` tbd rkcbt must fd dxdraksd` kg prlplrtklg tl tbdborm tl fd kgiekatd`' Kg ltbdr wlr`s% tbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad:

"k + Ocokgst tbd oats li o pufeka sdrvogt oatkgc kg cll` ioktb8 og`"kk+ Ocokgst tbd oats li tblsd oatkgc ug`dr tbdkr outblrkty lr

`krdatklg8"kkk+ Sbdrd tbdrd ks suiikakdgt tkmd ilr rdalursd tl pufeka

outblrktkds8 og`

"kv+ Pbd quogtum li borm tbot moy fd aousd` sboee kg gl aosd fd kgdxadss li borm tbot moy fd gdadssory ilr tbd purplsd li `didgad'

?' Oats li pufeka sdrvogt'Os dxpeokgd` dorekdr% tbd ikrst aeousd rdidrstl tbd oats li o pufeka sdrvogt% wbked tbd sdalg` aeousd rdidrs tl oats `lgd

ug`dr tbd outblrkty lr `krdatklg li o pufeka sdrvogt' Pbd lfjdat fdbkg`

`dprkvotklg li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad kg suab aosds ks tbot tbd pufeka

sdrvogts oat kg oaalr`ogad wktb eow ilr tbd fdgdikt li tbd pufeka kg cdgdroe

og` sl prltdatklg li pufeka sdrvogts ks gdadssory kg tbd pufeka kgtdrdst'Blwdvdr% tbd prltdatklg tl pufeka sdrvogts ks glt ofsleutd' Kt ks sufjdat tl

rdstrkatklgs' Pbd oats kg dktbdr li tbdsd aeousds "ikrst og` sdalg`+ must glt

fd li sdrklus algsdqudgads rdsuetkgc kg opprdbdgsklg li aouskgc `dotb lr li

crkdvlus burt wbkab wlue` `dprkvd lgd li bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Pl ovoke tbd fdgdikt li tblsd aeousds "k+ tbd oat `lgd lr ottdmptd`tl fd `lgd fy o pufeka sdrvogt must fd `lgd kg cll` ioktb8 "kk+ tbd oatmust fd `lgd ug`dr tbd alelur li bks liikad8 og` "kkk+ tbdrd must fdrdoslgofed crlug`s ilr fdekdvkgc tbot tbd oats wdrd `lgd fy o pufeka

sdrvogt os suab lr ug`dr bks outblrkty kg tbd dxdraksd li bks edcoe`uty og` tbot tbd oat ks glt keedcoe "Dxpeogotklgs K og` KK+' Pbus% kgfrkdi% tbd eow wktb rdcor` tl pufeka sdrvogts moy fd summorksd` osstotd` fdelw:

"o+ Ql elgc os o pufeka sdrvogt oats edcoeey kg tbd dxdraksd li bksliikakoe plwdrs% tbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst bkm%ilr tbd skmped rdoslg tbot bks oat ks glt og liidgad "kt ileelwsirlm sdatklgs ;9 og` ;; li tbd ^dgoe Al`d+'

"f+ Ki bks oats ord wbleey keedcoe% bd ks kg tbd somd plsktklg os ogyprkvotd kg`kvk`uoe og` ks glt dgtkted` tl ogy spdakoe prltdatklg'

"a+ Fut prltdatklg ks dxtdg`d` dvdg tl tblsd oats li pufekasdrvogts lr li pdrslgs oatkgc#ug`dr tbdkr outblrkty ilr`krdatklg wbkab ord glt strkatey justkikofed og` ydt ord gltwbleey outblrksd` prlvk`d` tbd ileelwkgc alg`ktklgs ordsotksikd`:

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

16/30

^ocd

?9

"?+ tbot tbd oat `lds glt aousd rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li`dotb lr li crkdvlus burt8

"6+ tbot tbd oat ks `lgd kg cll` ioktb8"1+ tbot tbd oat ks `lgd ug`dr alelur li bks liikad8"0+ tbot kt ks hglwg ot tbd tkmd tbot tbd oat ks fdkgc `lgd fy o

pufeka sdrvogt os suab lr ug`dr bks outblrkty8 og`

"4+ tbot tbd krrdcueorkty `lds glt trogscrdss tbd ekmkt li fdkgc#strkatey justkikofed fy eow%'#

Skeekoms: Blwdvdr% os bde` fy o Gdw Zdoeog` Alurt kg Skeekomsv' ^lekad% ki tbd oat li tbd pufeka sdrvogt ks glt eowiue% tbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad `lds glt dxtdg` tl tbd aouskgc li gdadssory borm'

Pwl ugkilrmd` algstofeds% wbl bo` fddg `krdatd` tl kgvdstkcotd o

almpeokgt li ossouet% stlppd` o vdbkaed alrrdsplg`kgc tl tbdalmpeokgogt#s `dsarkptklg li bks ossokeogt#s aor' Pwl li tbdlaaupogts% Skeekoms og` Feudcum% clt lut' &Skeekoms `dgkd` li ogyhglwed`cd li tbd ossouet og` wos oshd` tl wokt ugtke tbdalmpeokgogt orrkvd` tl sdd ki bd alue` k`dgtkiy tbdm&' Skeekomrdiusd` og` mlvd` tl cdt kgtl tbd aor' Pbd algstofed sok`: &[lu ordglt clkgc ogywbdrd&% og` stdppd` fdtwddg tbd Skeekoms og` tbdaor% og` wos pusbd` owoy% quktd ilrakfey% tblucb bd mogocd` tlstoy lg bks iddt' Pbd ltbdr algstofed oesl dg`dovlurd` tl felah tbdwoy' Bd tll wos pusbd` fut wktb edss ilrad'

Pbd ikrst algstofed tbdg purplrtd` tl orrdst Skeekoms' Bd rdskstd`%og` Feudcum croffd` tbd algstofed' Fltb wdrd orrdstd`' FltbSkeekoms og` Feudcum wdrd aborcd` og` algvkatd` fy tbd trkoe alurtwktb ossouetkgc fltb tbd algstofeds og` lfstruatkgc tbdm kgdxdautklg li tbdkr `uty'

Oeelwkgc tbd oppdoe% tbd Bkcb Alurt li Gdw Zdoeog` bde` tbot tbdalgstofeds bo` gl plwdr tl `dtokg tbd vdbkaed lr kts laaupkdrs' Fypusbkgc tbd algstofeds os bd `k`% Skeekoms almmkttd` tdabgkaoeossouets lg tbdm% fut tbdy wdrd glt ossouet almmkttd` wbked tbd

algstofeds wdrd oatkgc kg tbd dxdautklg li tbdkr `uty' Pbd twlalgstofeds glt lgey stll` kg Skeekom#s woy% fut lgd li tbdm mo`d ktaedor tbot tbdy wdrd glt clkgc tl edt Skeekoms cdt kgtl tbd aor' Kgtblsd akraumstogads% bd wos dgtkted` tl `l wbot bd `k`% tbd ilradoppekd` wos glt dxadsskvd% og` gl liidgad wos almmkttd`'

Fy bks lwg oats tbd ikrst algstofed bo` prdakpktotd` oalgirlgtotklg' Bd wrlgciueey kgtdridrd` wktb tbd rkcbts li o aktkzdgog` tbdrdfy covd tl og oetdraotklg' Kg tbdsd akraumstogads% bd alue`glt aeokm tl bovd rdoslgofed aousd tl fdekdvd tbot og liidgad bo`fddg almmkttd`' Pbd purplrtd` orrdst li Skeekoms% oetblucb `lgd kgtbd fdst li ioktb wos glt eowiue' Ogy sblw li rdoslgofed ilrad fySkeekoms tbdrdoitdr wos justkikd` os sdei-`didgad% og` bd `k` gltdxadd` tbot ekmkt'

6' Cll` ioktb'Cll` ioktb peoys o vktoe rled ug`dr tbks sdatklg' Cll`ioktb `lds glt rdqukrd elckaoe kgioeekfkekty "oaauroay+ fut `ud aord og`

aoutklg os `dikgd` ug`dr sdatklg 46 li tbd Al`d' Pbus o plekad liikadr oatkgcflgo ik`d ug`dr tbd alelur li bks liikad% sblue` bd orrdst o pdrslg dvdg

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

17/30

^ocd

?3

tblucb bd bos gl outblrkty tl orrdst ug`dr tbd portkaueor akraumstogads li

tbd aosd% tbd pdrslg sl orrdstd` bos gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Blwdvdr% ki tbd oat li tbd pufeka sdrvogt ks uetro vkrds% tbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad aog fd dxdraksd` ocokgst bkm' Ilr kgstogad% tbd oat liog liikadr li tbd alurt wbl oats ug`dr o tkmd-dxpkrd` worrogt og`ottoabds prlpdrty% aogglt fd sok` tl bovd fddg `lgd oaalr`kgc tl eowog` kg cll` ioktb'1 Qkmkeorey% sdorab mo`d kg vkleotklg li tbdmog`otlry prlvksklgs li eow ilr purplsd li mohkgc og kgvdstkcotklgkgtl og liidgad os eok` `lwg kg sdatklg ?94% Ar' ^'A'% ?;31 aogglt fdsok` tl fd `lgd kg cll` ioktb og` wktb `ud aord og` ottdgtklg'?>

Hdsbl Vom: Kg Hdsbl Vom v' @debk O`mkgkstrotklg%# tbd QuprdmdAlurt bde` tbot og kmmugkty ug`dr sdatklg ;;% K'^'A' aog fd aeokmd`fy o pufeka sdrvogt% ki bd oats kg cll` ioktb og` ug`dr tbd alelur libks liikadr% dvdg tblucb tbd edcoekty li tbd oat alue` glt ltbdrwksd fdsustokgd`' Pbd oppdeeogt covd o felw tl og Kgspdatlr li tbd @debk

Mugkakpoe Alrplrotklg wbl% kg `ksaborcd li bks `uty% bo` clgd tlaleedat tbd mkeh tox "os prlvk`d` ug`dr sdatklg ?9? li tbd AlrplrotklgOat+ og` bo` sdkzd` bks fuiioel' Pbd oppdeeogt wos algvkatd` ilrossouetkgc tbd Kgspdatlr' Pbd oppdeeogt#s pedo tbot os tbdrd wos glgltkad li `dmog` sdgt tl bkm "os rdqukrd` ug`dr sdatklg ?40+% tbd oatli sdkzurd li tbd fuiioel kg `diouet li poymdgt li tox wos og oat kgdxdraksd li fo` ioktb'

Vdjdatkgc tbd oppdeeogt#s algtdgtklg tbd alurt bde` tbot tbdKgspdatlrs wdrd oatkgc blgdstey kg cll` ioktb kg tbd dxdraksds li tbdplwdr `dedcotd` tl tbdm fy tbd Almmkssklgdrs' Pbdkr ottdmpt tlrdalvdr tbd tox `ud% fy sdkzurd li tbd ogkmoe `k` glt eoah cll` ioktb'Kg tbd akraumstogads% sdatklg ;; `k` algidr o prltdatklg uplg tbddmpelydds li tbd alrplrotklg wbl oatd` kg cll` ioktb ug`dr tbdalelur li tbdkr liikad'

Vdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr crkdvlus burt'Fltb aeousds ?og` 6 li tbd sdatklg ;; stotd tbot tbdrd wkee fd gl rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad ocokgst tblsd oats li pufeka sdrvogts lr tblsd `lgd ug`dr tbd`krdatklg og` outblrkty li pufeka sdrvogts wbkab `l glt rdoslgofeyaousd opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr crkdvlus burt wbkab ks oewoys o

qudstklg li ioat tl fd `dtdrmkgd` irlm surrlug`kgc akraumstogads' ^oromsuhb: Kg ^oromsuhb8 o Quf-Kgspdatlr li ^lekad

oaalmpogkd` fy o algstofed% lg fdkgc ioesdey kgilrmd` tbotadrtokg stledg prlpdrty wos kg tbd plssdssklg li lgd R% prladd`d`tl bks blusd' Lg orrkvkgc ot R#s blusd bd ilug` tbot R wos glt otblmd og` sl bd `dmog`d` tbd sok` prlpdrty irlm R#s wkid% wbl`dgkd` ogy hglwed`cd oflut tbd prlpdrty kg qudstklg og` oshd`bkm tl wokt ugtke tbd orrkvoe li bdr busfog`' Pbd suf-kgspdatlr

?> Mktbu Hbog v' Qtotd li Vojostbog% OKV ?;9; Voj ?6?' O sdorab porty algskstkgc li o goraltkaKgspdatlr% og kgilrmdr og` plekadmdg ottdmptd` tl dgtdr tbd blusd li tbd oaausd` ilr tbd rdalvdry li algtrofog` lpkum' Pbd Kgspdatlr `k` glt spdakiy tbd crlug`s wbkab bo` ed` bkm tl fdekdvd tbot tbdalgtrofog` wos stlrd` ot tbot peoad' Pbd oppdeeogt rdskstd` tbd dgtry og` struah tbd mdmfdrs li tbd portywbdg tbdy ottdmptd` tl dgtdr tbd blusd' Bde`% sda' ;;% K'^'A' wkee glt oppey'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

18/30

^ocd

?2

`daekgd` tl wokt og` tbrdotdgd` tbd wlmog wktb o aogd og` eok`bog`s lg bdr'

Lg bdorkgc bdr arkds% tbd oaausd` rusbd` tl tbd splt tl rdg`drbdep' Og oetdraotklg dgsud`% og` tbd oaausd` lg fdkgc ossouetd` fytbd suf-Kgspdatlr og` algstofed% sgotabd` o bdovy stkah irlm tbdeottdr og` struah twl felws lg tbd ilrdbdo` li tbd suf-Kgspdatlr%wbkab prlvd` iotoe' Kt wos bde` tbot tbd oaausd` bo` o rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad ocokgst `uoe ossouet lg bks pdrslg'

Pbd oat li tbd suf-Kgspdatlr wos glt `lgd kg cll` ioktb og` wosog keedcoe oat ilr tbdrd ks gl eow tl justkiy o pufeka sdrvogt kg aouskgc`dotb lr crkdvlus burt lr ottdmptkgc tl aousd `dotb lr crkdvlus burtkg `ksaborcd li bks `utkds'

Gl Vkcbt li `didgad ki tkmd tl bovd rdalursd tl tbd ^ufekaOutblrkty'Aeousd 1 eoys `lwg tbot tbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad lr tbd prltdatklg li lgd#s lwg fl`y lr prlpdrty% os oeslogltbdr#s fl`y lr prlpdrty% ki tbdrd ks rdoslgofed lpplrtugkty lird`rdss fy rdalursd tl tbd pufeka outblrktkds' Gl mog bos o rkcbt tltohd tbd eow kgtl bks lwg bog`s'

^urog Qkgcb: Kg ^urog Qkgcb v' Qtotd li ^ugjof# tbd Quprdmd Alurtwbked dxpeokgkgc tbd tbdmd li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad lfsdrvd`:

Sbdrd tbdrd ks og dedmdgt li kgvosklg lr occrdssklg lg tbd

prlpdrty fy o pdrslg wbl bos gl rkcbt tl plssdssklg% tbdgtbdrd ks lfvklusey gl rllm tl bovd rdalursd tl tbd pufekaoutblrktkds og` tbd oaausd` bos tbd ug`luftd` rkcbt tl rdsksttbd ottoah og` usd dvdg ilrad ki gdadssory'

Borm aousd` must fd prlplrtklgotd tl tbd kgjury'Aeousd 0 tlsdatklg ;; prlvk`ds tbot tbd kgjury tl fd kgiekatd` sblue` fdprlplrtklgotd tl tbd borm aousd` lr ottdmptd` tl fd aousd`' Pbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks o `didgskvd rkcbt akraumsarkfd` fy tbdstotutd% ovokeofed lgey wbdg tbd akraumstogads aedorey justkiy kt' Ktsblue` glt fd oeelwd` tl fd usd` lr ovoked` li os o ckit ilr o

vkg`katkvd% occrdsskvd lr rdtrkfutkvd purplsd' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad kg gl aosd dxtdg`s tl tbd kgiekatkgc li mlrd borm tbog ksgdadssory kg tbd portkaueor aosd'

Ilr kgstogad% kg Muggdy Hbog#% tbd oaausd` Muggdy Hbog oitdrtohkgc kgtl austl`y o tbkdi wbl wos trykgc tl dsaopd% stofd` bkmwktb o hgkid og` tbdrdfy tbd tbkdi `kds% tbd oaausd` Muggdy Hbogbos dxadd`d` bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad' Bd sblue` bovd usd` lgeytbot muab ilrad os wos gdadssory ilr tbd purplsd li tohkgc tbd tbkdikgtl austl`y'

Vomdsb Abog`ro: Qkmkeorey% kg Vomdsb Abog`ro v' Qtotd%& wbdrdtbd oaausd` kgiekatd` felws lg tbd `dadosd` oitdr tbd eottdr bo` ioeedglg tbd crlug` og` tbd wdoplg bo` fddg tohdg owoy irlm bkm% tbdalurt bde` tbot tbd alg`uat li tbd oaausd` alue` glt justkikofey fdwktbkg tbd ekmkts li rkcbts li prkvotd `didgad'

Fbojo ^ro`bog: Kg Fbojo ^ro`bog%4 tbd `dadosd` bo` stledg o clotirlm tbd aottedsbd` li tbd oaausd`' Pbd oaausd` aborcd` bkm tl

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

19/30

^ocd

?;

rdalvdr bks prlpdrty og`% kg tbd prladss li rdalvdrkgc kt% ossouetd`bkm wktblut hglwkgc tb0t bd bo` struah vktoe fl`y ports' Bde`% tbdoaausd` dxadd`d` tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Foejkt Qkgcb: Qkmkeorey kg Foejkt Qkgcb%# tbd Quprdmd Alurt bde`tbot tbd oatuoe plssdssklg li tbd `ksputd` eog` `k` pdrmkt tbdoaausd` tbd rkcbt tl `didg` tbd prlpdrty irlm fdkgc `ksplssdssd`'Fut bo` tbd rkcbt dxdraksd` rdsuetd` kg iotoe kgjurkds tl tbdoccrdsslrs% tbd oaausd` wlue` bovd dxadd`d` tbd ekmkt li tbd eowiuedxdraksd li tbot rkcbt'

Qda' ?>>' Sbdg tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y dxtdg`s tlaouskgc `dotb'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y dxtdg`s% ug`drtbd rdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg tbd eost prdad`kgc sdatklg% tl tbd vleugtoryaouskgc li `dotb lr li ogy ltbdr borm tl tbd ossokeogt% ki tbd liidgad wbkablaaosklgs tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt fd li ogy li tbd `dsarkptklgs bdrdkgoitdrdgumdrotd`% gomdey:

Ikrst'Quab og ossouet os moy rdoslgofey aousd tbd opprdbdgsklgtbot `dotb wkee ltbdrwksd fd tbd algsdqudgad li suab ossouet8

Qdalg`ey' Quab og ossouet os moy rdoslgofey aousd tbdopprdbdgsklg tbot crkdvlus burt wkee ltbdrwksd fd tbd algsdqudgadli suab ossouet8

Pbkr`ey'Og ossouet wktb tbd kgtdgtklg li almmkttkgc ropd8 Ilurtbey' Og ossouet wktb tbd kgtdgtklg li crotkiykgc uggoturoe

eust8

Ikitbey'Og ossouet wktb tbd kgtdgtklg li hk`goppkgc lr of`uatkgc8 Qkxtbey' Og ossouet wktb tbd kgtdgtklg li wrlgciueey algikgkgc o

pdrslg% ug`dr akraumstogads wbkab moy rdoslgofey aousd bkm tlopprdbdg` tbot bd wkee fd ugofed tl bovd rdalursd tl tbd pufekaoutblrktkds ilr bks rdedosd'

?? XQdvdgtbey'Og oat li tbrlwkgc lr o`mkgkstdrkgc oak` lr ogottdmpt tl tbrlw lr o`mkgkstdr oak` wbkab moy rdoslgofey aousdtbd opprdbdgsklg tbot crkdvlus burt wkee ltbdrwksd fd tbdalgsdqudgad li suab oat']

Ki tbd oaausd` bo` oerdo`y `doet sdvdroe felws lg tbd `dadosd`% bd alue`glt bovd fddg kg o plsktklg tl sbllt ot tbd oaausd` pdrslgs' Bovkgc rdcor`tl slmd li tbd o`mkssklgs mo`d fy tbd wktgdssds% kt oppdors tbot tbdoaausd` tllh ilrakfed plssdssklg li tbd eog` slmd `oys ocl' Pbdrdilrd%dvdg ossumkgc tbot tbdy aomd kgtl plssdssklg oitdr almmkttkgctrdsposskgc% ki tbd `dadosd` og` ltbdrs bo` clgd tl tbd eog` tbdy aoggltfd bde` tl fd occrdsslrs os pedo`d` fy tbd `didgad8 Hbu``u v' Qtotd liTttor ^ro`dsb% OKV ?;;1 QA ?412 "?40>+'

Kgcrd`kdgts

?? Kgs' fy tbd Arkmkgoe Eow "Omdg`mdgt+ Oat% 6>?1% sda' 6 "w'r'd'i' 1-6-6>?6+'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

20/30

^ocd

6>

Qdei kgiekatd` kgjurkds glt dxpeokgd` fy prlsdautklg dxadpt tbd rdekogad lgmd`kaoe dvk`dgad oaqukttoe li oaausd` glt justkikd`8 Abubor Qkgcb v' Qtotdli ^ugjof% OKV ?;;; QA ?>46: ?;;? QAA "Ar+ ?>99: ?;;2 "0+ JP 00;'

Pbd kgmotds aedorey bo` o rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst tbd kgtru`drswbl trkd` tl dxtroat mlgdy fy ilrad8 Hksblrd Qbomfbu`otto Mksbro v' Qtotdli Moborosbtro% "?;2;+ Ar ?0 ??0;: OKV ?;2; QA ??31'

Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad tl aousd `dotb

Tg`dr wbot akraumstogads oaausd` covd hgkid felw tl tbd `dadosd` alue`glt fd dxpeokgd` fy oaausd`% oaqukttoe lg crlug` li sdei `didgad glt

justkikd`8 Qtotd li Tttor ^ro`dsb v' Eoddc% OKV ?;;; QA ?;06: ?;;; "4+ QAA

422'

Sbked fdkgc abosd` fy `dadosd` oppdeeogt ottoahd` lg `dadosd` aousd`ikrd kgaksd` wlug`% bde` dxadd`d` tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% algvkatklgug`dr sdatklg 1>0 ^ort K prlpdr8 Qurdsb Qkgcb v' Qtotd% OKV ?;;; QA ?331:

?;;; "6+ Arkmds 06'

Ottoah fy skgced felw lg tbd gdah li `dadosd` prlvd` iotoe' Bde` oaausd`dxadd`d` rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad8 Omor Qkgcb v' Qtotd li Mo`byo ^ro`dsb%?;;3 QAA "Ar+ 91>'

Kgcrd`kdgts'Pl kgvlhd sdatklg ?>>% K'^'A'% ilur alg`ktklgs must dxkst%vkz'%

?' ikrstey% tbot tbd pdrslg dxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad must fd irddirlm iouet kg frkgckgc oflut tbd dgalugtdr8

6' sdalg`ey% tbdrd must fd prdsdgt og kmpdg`kgc pdrke tl ekid lr licrdot fl`key borm% dktbdr rdoe lr sl oppordgt os tl ardotd og blgdst

fdekdi li dxadd`kgc "crdot+ gdadsskty8

1' tbkr`ey% tbdrd must fd gl soid lr rdoslgofed ml`d li dsaopd fyrdtrdot8 og`

0' ilurtbey% tbdrd must bovd fddg o gdadsskty ilr tohkgc tbd ekid'Cbdgu: Pbd #rdtrdot# ospdat li sdei-`didgad ks lpdg tl qudstklg' Os

lfsdrvd` fy tbd alurts lg o gumfdr li laaosklgs #tbdrd ks gltbkgcmlrd `dcro`kgc tl tbd bumog spkrkt tbog tl rug owoy kg tbd ioad lipdrke#' Pbks wos lgad ocokg rdktdrotd` fy tbd Quprdmd Alurt kg Qtotdli Lrksso v' Cekdgu'? Pbd rdsplg`dgt wos aborcd` ug`dr sdatklg 1>6%K'^'A' ilr mur`drkgc bks frltbdr fut oaqukttd` lg tbd crlug` tbottbd oaausd` bo` aousd` tbd `dotb wbked dxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad'

Lg tbd `oy li laaurrdgad fltb tbd oaausd` og` `dadosd` wdrdbkcbey kgdfrkotd` "`rugh+ og` bo` o quorrde% kg tbd alursd li wbkabtbd `dadosd` rusbd` tlwor`s tbd rdsplg`dgt wktb o eotbk tl ossouetbkm og`% kmmd`kotdey opprdbdg`kgc `ogcdr tl bks ekid% tbdrdsplg`dgt `doet o togck felw tl tbd bdo` li tbd `dadosd`% os oalgsdqudgad li wbkab bd `kd` kg blspktoe' Pbd mokg qudstklg wos:

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

21/30

^ocd

6?

wbdtbdr tbd ossouet fy tbd `dadosd` bo` aousd` tl tbdrdsplg`dgt rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr crkdvlus burt'

Algsk`drkgc tbd dvk`dgad% tbd Bkcb Alurt bde` tbot tbdrd woskmmkgdgt `ogcdr tl tbd pdrslg li tbd rdsplg`dgt og` os suab bdbo` tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li bks pdrslg' Sbked rdoabkgc tbksalgaeusklg% tbd alurt oesl tllh kgtl algsk`drotklg tbd ioat tbot tbd`dadosd` og` tbd rdsplg`dgt wdrd o`kvosks "trkfoes+ og` tboto`kvosks ord li o vleotked goturd og` tbdkr tdmpdr og` sdgtkmdgtaogglt fd ju`cd` kg tbd iromdwlrh li tblsd li ltbdr pdrslgs'

Opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr crkdvlus burt aosds'Qlmgotb @os:Kg Qlmgotb @os v' Qtotd li Lrksso%# tbd oaausd` og` tbd `dadosd`wdrd aluskgs wbl `k` glt puee lg wdee' O irdd ikcbt tllh peoadfdtwddg tbdm og` sufsdqudgtey tbd oaausd` wos aborcd` wktb tbdmur`dr li tbd `dadosd`' Kt wos bde` irlm tbd ioats os osadrtokgd` fytbd alurt tbot tbd `dadosd` bo` `lgd gltbkgc os tl aousd ordoslgofed opprdbdgsklg kg tbd mkg` li tbd oaausd` tbot bd wostbrdotdgd` dktbdr wktb `dotb lr crkdvlus burt' Bd bo` mdrdey pkahd`up o eotbk tbrlwg ot bkm fy tbd slg li tbd oaausd`% wbdrduplg tbdoaausd` ideed` bkm wktb iotoe felws' Pbdrd wos tbdrdilrd glrdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg kg tbd mkg` li tbd oaausd` tbot dktbdr`dotb lr crkdvlus burt wlue` fdioee "boppdg+ uplg bkm% bo` bd gltdxdraksd` bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'

Gog` Hksblrd Eoe: Kg Gog` Hksblrd6 oaausd`% wbl wdrd Qkhbs%of`uatd` o Mlbommo`og morrkd` wlmog og` algvdrtd` bdr tlQkhbksm' Gdorey o ydor oitdr tbd of`uatklg% tbd rdeotkvds li tbd

wlmog#s busfog` aomd og` `dmog`d` bdr rdturg irlm tbd oaausd`'Pbd eottdr rdiusd` tl almpey og` tbd wlmog bdrsdei dxprdssey stotd`bdr ugwkeekgcgdss tl rdjlkg bdr Musekm busfog`' Pbdrduplg tbdbusfog`#s rdeotkvds ottdmptd` tl tohd bdr owoy fy ilrad' Pbdoaausd` rdskstd` tbd ottdmpt og` kg sl `lkgc lgd li tbdm kgiekatd` ofelw lg tbd bdo` li lgd li tbd wlmog#s ossokeogts% wbkab rdsuetd` kgtbd eottdr#s `dotb' Kt wos bde` tbot tbd rkcbt li tbd oaausd` tl `didg`tbd wlmog ocokgst bdr ossokeogts dxtdg`d` ug`dr tbks sdatklg tl tbdaouskgc li `dotb og` tbdy bo`% tbdrdilrd% almmkttd` gl liidgad' 1

Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad dxtdg`s tl tbd dxtdgt li aouskgc`dotb wbdg `oucbtdr wos fdkgc sdxuoeey ossouetd`'

[dsbwogt

Vol: Kg [dsbwogt Vol v' Qtotd li Mo`byo ^ro`dsb##% tbd `dadosd`%Eohbog Qkgcb wos dgcocd` kg o sdxuoe kgtdralursd wktb tbd `oucbtdrli tbd oppdeeogt' Lg wktgdsskgc tbd somd% tbd oppdeeogt ossouetd` tbd`dadosd` lg tbd bdo` wktb o spo`d' Pbks rdsuetd` kg bks `dotb `ud tltbd rupturd li ekvdr wbkab alue` fd dktbdr fy ioeekgc lg o bor` lfjdat%lr os o rdsuet li tbd felw ckvdg fy tbd oppdeeogt'

Pbd trkoe alurt algvkatd` tbd oppdeeogt ug`dr sdatklg 164% K'^'A'ilr aouskgc burt og` tbd bkcb alurt algikrmd` tbd algvkatklg' Kg

oppdoe% tbd Quprdmd Alurt sdt osk`d tbd algvkatklg og` bde` tbot tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wos iueey oppekaofed tl tbd ioats li tbd aosdvk`d sdatklgs ;9% ;3 rdo` wktb sdatklg ?>> aeousd "1+ li K'^'A'Sbdtbdr kt wos aosd li sdxuoe kgtdralursd wktb lr wktblut algsdgt%tbd ioat rdmokgs tbot tbd `oucbtdr wos li ikitddg ydors li ocd og`%

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

22/30

^ocd

66

tbdrdilrd tbd oat li `dadosd` wlue` omlugt tl ropd wktbkg tbdmdogkgc li sdatklg 134% aeousd "9+ li tbd K'^'A'

@dl Gorokg: Kg @dl Gorokg v' Qtotd li Tttor ^ro`dsb%# tbd Quprdmd

Alurt bde` tbot wbdg o felw ks okmd` ot o vuegdrofed port li tbdfl`y% suab os tbd bdo`% dvdg fy o eotbk% og` aosds ord glt' ughglwgkg wbkab suab o felw fy o eotbk bos oatuoeey prlvd` kgstogtogdluseyiotoe% kt aogglt fd eok` `lwg os o slug` prlplsktklg li eow tbot kgsuab aosds tbd vkatkm ks glt justkikd` kg uskgc dvdg bks spdor kg`didg`kgc bkmsdei' Kg mlmdgts li dxaktotklg lr `ksturfd` mdgtoedqukekfrkum kt ks slmdwbot `kiikauet tl dxpdat portkds ioakgc crovdoccrdssklg tl alleey wdkcb kg o cle`dg saoed% lr aoemey `dtdrmkgdwktb o almplsd` mkg`% prdaksdey tbd hkg` og` sdvdrkty li felw tbotwlue` fd edcoeey suiikakdgt tl diidatkvdey mddt tbd ugeowiue

occrdssklg'

Qda' ?>?' Sbdg suab rkcbt dxtdg`s tl aouskgc ogy borm ltbdr tbog`dotb'Kitbd liidgad fd glt li ogy li tbd `dsarkptklgs dgumdrotd` kg tbdeost prdad`kgc sdatklg% tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y `lds gltdxtdg` tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc li `dotb tl tbd ossokeogt% fut `lds dxtdg`%ug`dr tbd rdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg sdatklg ;;% tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc tltbd ossokeogt li ogy borm ltbdr tbog `dotb'

Vdoslgofed Opprdbdgsklg li @ogcdr'Tg`dr Q' ?>? o pdrslg ksdgtkted` tl dxdraksd bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y os ocokgst ogyossouet ltbdr tbog tbd ikrst og` sdalg`ey li Q' ?>>% tl tbd dxtdgt li aouskgccrkdvlus burt' Ki% oitdr tbd almmkssklg li og ossouet li o skmped lr crkdvlusgoturd% tbdrd ks kg ogy aosd gl iurtbdr opprdbdgsklg li ossouet% laaosklg ilrtbd dxdraksd li bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y sblue` glt orksd' Ot tbdsomd tkmd tbd plsskfkekty li kgiekatkgc iurtbdr ossouet ekhdey tl aousd crkdvlusfl`key kgjury% aogglt os o rued fd rued` lut lg tbd mdrd crlug` tbot tbd kgjurylr tbd kgjurkds oerdo`y kgiekatd` ord skmped' Pbd eow kg tbks ospdat blglurs tbdbumog kgstkgat li sdei-prdsdrvotklg'

Kg algsk`drkgc wbdtbdr lgd ks dgtkted` tl dxdraksd tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad lg bks fl`y% lgd bos tl peoad bkmsdei kg tbd plsktklg li tbd oaausd`kg tbd mk`st li tbd akraumstogads kg wbkab tbd oaausd` stll` og` tl ilrmbks lpkgklg wbdtbdr ilr tbd oaausd` kg tblsd akraumstogads% kt wos glt iokreywksd tl opprdbdg` og kgjury tl tbd fl`y os wlue` dgtkted tbd oaausd` tldxdraksd tbd rkcbt tbot tbd oaausd` aeokms tl bovd `lgd' Sbdrd o `didg`ogtaborcd` wktb mur`dr ossdrts tbot bd hkeed` kg sdei-`didgad% bks stotd li mkg`ot tbd tkmd li hkeekgc fdalmds motdrkoe og` og kmplrtogt dedmdgt kg`dtdrmkgkgc bks justkikaotklg ilr bks fdekdi kg og kmpdg`kgc ottoah fy tbd`dadosd`' Pbd rdputotklg li tbd `dadosd` ilr o vkledgt% `ogcdrlus lrturfuedgt `ksplsktklg ks tbus o akraumstogad wbkab wlue` aousd suab ofdekdi' Ocokg tbd prdvklus tdmpdromdgt og` `ksplsktklg sblwg kg bksalg`uat ot tbd tkmd li tbd ossouet must cl o crdot woy tl aousd fdekdi kg tbdmkg` li tbd oaausd` kg og kmpdg`kgc `ogcdr tl ekid oaalmpogkd` wktb ekttedabogad li dsaopd'

Fut mdrd tbrdot% glt aorrkd` lut og` eotdr almpedtdey ofog`lgd` ileelwd`fy tbd rdtroatkgc li stdps fy tbd tbrdotdgdr wlue` glt justkiy ogy ossouet

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

23/30

^ocd

61

irlm tbd pdrslg tbrdotdgd`% os bd must bovd fddg algvkgad` tbot tbdpdrslg tbrdotdgd` `k` glt mdog tl aorry lut tbd dmpty tbrdot'#

Muggdy Hbog v' Qtotd li Mo`byo ^ro`dsbX?;3> "6+ Quprdmd Alurt Aosds% 02>]

Ioats'PbdPrkoe Alurt og` tbd Bkcb Alurt li Mo`byo ^ro`dsb ilug`

tbot lgd Vdltkskgcb pkahd` up o quorrde wktb tbd oppdeeogt#s frltbdrZueikquor% lvdrplwdrd` bkm% tbrdw bkm lg tbd crlug` og` sot lg bks abdst'Pbd oppdeeogt sddkgc bks frltbdr fdotdg aomd tl bks rdsaud og` trkd` tl sovdbkm fy ckvkgc ikst felws tl Vdltkskgcb' Sbdg bd `k` glt suaadd` bd tllh lut ohgkid og` stoffd` bkm kg tbd foah' Lg tbdsd ioats tbd Prkoe Alurt og` tbdBkcb Alurt algvkatd` tbd oppdeeogt ilr tbd liidgad li mur`dr ug`dr Q' 1>6og` sdgtdgad` bkm tl ekid kmprkslgmdgt' Kg tbd oppdoe fy tbd oaausd` kg tbdQuprdmd Alurt% tbd qudstklg ilr `daksklg wos wbdtbdr tbd rkcbt li sdei-`didgad li tbd fl`y li frltbdr wbkab bo` oaarud` tl bkm alue` justkiy bksoat kg stoffkgc Vdltkskgcb kg bks foah tl aousd bks `dotb'

@daksklg : Bde` ^dr Fborcovo% J'

Vdltkskgcb wos tbd occrdsslr og`wos aouskgc burt tl Zueikquor% tbd frltbdr li tbd oppdeeogt% sl tbot o rkcbtli sdei-`didgad li fl`y li bks frltbdr Zueikquor bo` oaarud` tl tbd oppdeeogt'

Pbot rkcbt% blwdvdr% alue` glt justkiy tbd oat li tbd oppdeeogt kg stoffkgcVdltkskgcb lg bks foah sl os tl aousd bks `dotb' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgadwos o vdry ekmktd` lgd' Kt lgey dxtdg`d` tl aouskgc burt li ogy hkg` tlVdltkskgcb% fut kt `k` glt prlvk`d ogy justkikaotklg ilr ckvkgc o iotoe felw'Quab o rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks clvdrgd` fy Q' ?>?% K'^'A' og` ks sufjdattl twl ekmktotklgs' Lgd ks tbot kg dxdraksd li tbks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ogyhkg` li burt aog fd aousd`% fut glt `dotb8 og` tbd ltbdr ks tbot tbd usd li

ilrad `lds glt dxadd` tbd mkgkmum rdqukrd` tl sovd tbd pdrslg kg wblsd`didgad tbd ilrad ks usd`' Kg tbdsd akraumstogads% kg tbd prdsdgt aosd% wbdgZueikquor wos fdkgc ckvdg ikst felws lgey% tbdrd alue` fd gl justkikaotklg otoee ilr tbd oppdeeogt tl stof Vdltkskgcb wktb o hgkid og` portkaueorey tl ckvdbkm o felw wbkab alue` prlvd iotoe fy okmkgc kt lg bks foah' Pbd usd li tbdhgkid ktsdei wos kg dxadss li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad og` kt fdaomd muabmlrd dxadsskvd wbdg tbd felw wktb tbd hgkid wos ckvdg lg o vktoe port li tbdfl`y wbkab% kg lr`kgory alursd li goturd% wos ekhdey tl aousd tbd `dotb liVdltkskgcb' Irlm tbd ioat tbot tbd felw wos ckvdg kg tbd foah wktb o hgkid%og kgidrdgad ileelws tbot tbd oppdeeogt kgtdg`d` tl aousd `dotb lr ot edost

kgtdg`d` tl aousd suab kgjury os wlue`% kg tbd lr`kgory alursd li goturd%rdsuet kg bks `dotb' Kg o`lptkgc tbd alursd tbd oppdeeogt wlue` bovd fddgaedorey cukety li tbd liidgad li mur`dr bo` tbdrd fddg gl rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li Zueikquor ot oee' Qkgad suab o rkcbt `k` dxkst tbd aosd wlue` ioeeug`dr tbd dxadptklg ug`dr wbkab auepofed blmkak`d `lds glt omlugt tlmur`dr lg tbd crlug` tbot tbd `dotb wos aousd` kg dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad fut fy dxadd`kgc tbot rkcbt' Og liidgad li tbks goturd ksmo`d pugksbofed ug`dr tbd ikrst port li Q' 1>0% K'^'A' Algsdqudgtey tbdalgvkatklg li tbd oppdeeogt must fd ug`dr tbot prlvksklg og` glt ug`dr Q'1>6% K'^'A'

^dr @uo J'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks al`kikd` kg Qs' ;9 tl ?>>%K'^'A'% wbkab bovd oee tl fd rdo` tlcdtbdr kg lr`dr tl bovd o prlpdr crosp litbd salpd og` tbd ekmktotklgs li tbd rkcbt' Fy dgoatkgc tbdsd sdatklgs kg tbdAl`d tbd outblrs wogtd` tl dxadpt irlm tbd lpdrotklg li kts pdgoe aeousds lioats `lgd kg cll` ioktb ilr tbd purplsd li rdpdeekgc ugeowiue occrdssklg' Pbks

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

24/30

^ocd

60

rkcbt ks ovokeofed ocokgst og liidgad og`% tbdrdilrd% wbdrd og oat ks `lgd kgdxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% suab oat aogglt ckvd rksd tl ogy rkcbtli prkvotd `didg`d kg iovlur li tbd occrdsslr kg rdturg' Pbks wlue` sddm tl fdsl dvdg ki tbd pdrslg dxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad bos tbd fdttdr li

bks occrdsslr prlvk`d` li alursd bd `lds glt dxadd` bks rkcbt fdaousd tbdmlmdgt bd dxadd`s kt bd almmkts og liidgad' Pbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad kg aosds wbdrd tbdrd ks tkmd tl bovd rdalursd tl tbd prltdatklg lipufeka outblrktkds' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks dssdgtkoeey o `didgskvd rkcbtakraumsarkfd` fy tbd stotutd ovokeofed lgey wbdg tbd akraumstogads aedorey

justkiy kt' Kt sblue` glt fd oeelwd` tl fd pedo`d` lr ovoked` li os o prdtdxt ilro vkg`katkvd% occrdoehkvd lr rdtrkfutkvd purplsd' Oaalr`kgc tl Q' ;3% tbks rkcbtvdsts dvdg kg strogcdr ilr tbd `didgad li fl`y og` prlpdrty li ltbdrpdrslgs ocokgst liidgads md tkggd` tbdrdkg' Pbd Alurts bovd tbdrdilrd tlfd aordiue kg sddkgc tbot gl lgd tbd mdrd prdtdxt li tbd dxdraksd li tbd

rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad tohds sk`d kg o quorrde fdtwddg twl lr mlrd pdrslgsog` kgiekats kgjurkds lg tbd lgd lr tbd ltbdr' Kg o aosd wbdg twl portkds ordbovkgc o irdd ikcbt wktblut `ksaelskgc os tl wbl ks tbd kgktkoe occrdsslr% ktmoy fd `ogcdrlus os o cdgdroe rued tl aeltbd dktbdr li tbdm lr bkssympotbksdr wktb o rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad' Ki% blwdvdr% lgd li tbdm - kssblwg tl fd almmkttkgc og liidgad oiidatkgc bumog fl`y% tbdg tbot wlue`li alursd sddm tl ckvd rksd tl suab o rkcbt' Ki tbdrd ks gl kgktkoe rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad tbdg tbdrd aog bor`ey fd ogy qudstklg li dxadd`kgc tbotrkcbt'

Kg tbd rdsuet% tbd oppdoe wos portey oeelwd`% tbd algvkatklg ug`dr Q' 1>6% K'^'A'sdt osk`d og` tbd oppdeeogt wos algvkatd` kgstdo` ug`dr tbd ikrst port li Q'1>0% K'^'A' Pbd sdgtdgad li kmprkslgmdgt ilr ekid wos sdt osk`d og`% kgstdo`% osdgtdgad li sdvdg ydors# rkclrlus kmprkslgmdgt wos owor`d`'

Qda' ?>6' Almmdgadmdgt og` algtkguogad li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li tbd fl`y'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y almmdgadsos sllg os o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd fl`y orksds irlm ogottdmpt lr tbrdot tl almmkt tbd liidgad tblucb tbd liidgad moy glt bovd

fddg almmkttd`8 og` kt algtkguds os elgc os suab opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdrtl tbd fl`y algtkguds'

Kt ks aedor% irlm tbd wlr`kgc li Q' ?>6 tbot tbd rkcbt almmdgads og`algtkguds os elgc os `ogcdr tl tbd fl`y eosts' Pbd dxtdgt tl wbkab tbddxdraksd li tbd rkcbt wkee fd justkikd` wkee `dpdg` glt lg tbd oatuoe `ogcdrfut lg wbdtbdr tbdrd wos rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li suab `ogcdr' Pbdrdmust fd og ottdmpt lr tbrdot% og` algsdqudgad tbdrduplg ogopprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr% fut kt sblue` glt fd o mdrd k`ed tbrdot' Pbdrdmust fd rdoslgofed crlug` ilr tbd opprdbdgsklg'

Kg @dl Gorokg v' Qtotd li Tttor ^ro`dsb%# tbd Bkcb Alurt li Oeeobofo`%#wbked upble`kgc tbd algaeusklgs li tbd trkoe alurt tbot tbd oaausd` pdrslgbo` tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad og` tbot tbdy wdrd justkikd` kg dxdrakskgctbot rkcbt% bde` tbot% kg kts lpkgklg% tbot rkcbt bo` fddg dxadd`d` fy tbdoppdeeogt @dl Gorokg kg kgiekatkgc tbd spdor kgjury lg tbd abdst liAbog`romo `dadosd`% wbkab wos rdsplgskfed ilr bks `dotb' Pbd rdoslgkgcli tbd Bkcb Alurt kg algvkatkgc tbd oppdeeogt wos tbot kt% wos lgey ki tbd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

25/30

^ocd

64

almpeokgogt#s porty bo` oatuoeey kgiekatd` o sdrklus kgjury lg tbd oaausd`tbot tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad alue` orksd justkiykgc tbd aouskgc li `dotb'

Kg oppdoe fy spdakoe edovd tbdkr elr`sbkps li tbd Quprdmd Alurt lfsdrvd`tbot% kg tbdkr lpkgklg% tbd Bkcb Alurt sddmd` tl bovd drrd` kg eow kgalgvkatkgc tbd oppdeeogt lg tbd crlug` tbot bd bo` dxadd`d` tbd rkcbt li

prkvotd `didgad' Sbot tbd Bkcb Alurt rdoeey sddmd` tl bovd mkssd` wos tbdprlvksklg li eow dmfl`kd` kg Q' ?>6% K'^'A' Oaalr`kgc tl tbot sdatklg% tbd rkcbtli prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y almmdgads os sllg os o rdoslgofedopprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd fl`y orksds irlm og ottdmpt lr tbrdot tlalmmkt tbd liidgad tblucb tbd liidgad moy glt bovd fddg almmkttd` og`suab rkcbt algtkguds sl elgc os suab opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd fl`yalgtkguds' Pbd tbrdot% blwdvdr% must rdoslgofey ckvd rksd tl tbd prdsdgt og`kmmkgdgt og` glt rdmltd lr `kstogt `ogcdr' Pbks rkcbt rdsts lg tbd cdgdroeprkgakped tbot wbdrd o arkmd ks dg`dovlurd` tl fd almmkttd` fy ilrad% kt kseowiue tl rdpde tbot ilrad kg sdei-`didgad' Pl soy tbot tbd oppdeeogt alue` lgey

aeokm tbd rkcbt tl usd ilrad oitdr bd bo` sustokgd` o sdrklus kgjury fy ogoccrdsskvd wrlgciue ossouet ks o almpedtd mksug`drstog`kgc li tbd eotddmfl`kd` kg tbd oflvd sdatklg' Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks ovokeofed ilrprltdatklg ocokgst opprdbdg`kgc ugeowiue occrdssklg og` glt ilr pugksbkgctbd occrdsslr ilr tbd liidgad almmkttd` fy bkm' Kt ks o prdvdgtkvd og` gltpugktkvd rkcbt' Pbd rkcbt tl pugksb ilr tbd almmkssklg li liidgads vdsts kg tbdQtotd "wbkab bos o `uty tl mokgtokg eow og` lr`dr+ og` glt kg prkvotdkg`kvk`uoes' Ki oitdr sustokgkgc o sdrklus kgjury tbdrd ks gl opprdbdgsklg liiurtbdr `ogcdr tl tbd fl`y% tbdg lfvklusey tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wlue`glt fd ovokeofed' Ocokg% tbd opprloab li tbd Bkcb Alurt tbot mdrdey fdaousd

tbd almpeokgogt#s porty bo` usd` eotbks% tbd oppdeeogt wos glt justkikd` kguskgc bks spdor ks gl edss mksalgadkvd` og` ugsupplrtofed' Kt aogglt fd eok``lwg os o cdgdroe rued tbot tbd usd li eotbk os `kstkgcuksbd` irlm tbd usd li ospdor must oewoys fd bde` tl rdsuet lgey kg mke`dr kgjury' Muab `dpdg`s lgtbd goturd li tbd eotbk% tbd port li tbd fl`y okmd` ot og` tbd ilrad usd` kgckvkgc tbd felw' Ki% tbdrdilrd% o felw wktb o eotbk ks okmd` ot o vuegdrofed portekhd tbd bdo`% kt aogglt fd eok` `lwg os o slug` prlplsktklg li eow tbot kgsuab aosds tbd vkatkm ks glt justkikd` kg uskgc bks spdor kg `didg`kgc bkmsdei'Kg suab mlmdgts li dxaktdmdgt li `ksturfd` mdgtoe dqukekfrkum% kt ksslmdwbot `kiikauet tl dxpdat portkds ioakgc crovd occrdssklg tl alleey wdkcb%

os ki kg cle`dg saoeds% og` aoemey `dtdrmkgd wktb o almplsd` mkg` os tlwbot prdaksd hkg` og` sdvdrkty li felw wlue` fd edcoeey suiikakdgt ilrdiidatkvdey mddtkgc tbd ugeowiue occrdssklg' Pbd Bkcb Alurt wos tbdrdilrdwrlgc kg `dgykgc tbd oppdeeogt tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad lg tbd sled crlug`tbot bd bo` ckvdg o `ogcdrlus felw wktb algsk`drofed ilrad wktb o spdor lgtbd abdst li tbd `dadosd` tblucb bd bkmsdei bo` lgey rdadkvd` o supdrikakoeeyeotbk felw lg bks bdo`'

Pbd Al d dxadpts irlm tbd lpdrotklg li kts pdgoe aeousds eorcd aeossds lioats `lgd kg cll` ioktb ilr tbd purplsd li rdpdeekgc ugeowiue occrdssklg futtbks rkcbt bos fddg rdcueotd` og` akraumsarkfd` fy sdvdroe prkgakpeds liekmktotklgs' Pbd mlst soekdgt li tbdm algadrgkgc tbd `didgad li fl`y ord osug`dr :

"?+Pbdrd ks gl rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst og oat wbkab ks glt kgktsdei og liidgad ug`dr tbd Al`d'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

26/30

^ocd

69

"6+Pbd rkcbt ovokes lgey ocokgst o `ogcdr kmmkgdgt% prdsdgt og` rdoe'"1+ Kt ks o `didgskvd og` glt o pugktkvd lr rdtrkfutkvd rkcbt og`%

tbdrdilrd% tbd kgjury wbkab ks kgiekatd` fy tbd pdrslg dxdrakskgc tbdrkcbt sblue` fd almmdgsurotd wktb tbd kgjury wktb wbkab bd ks

tbrdotdgd`' Ot tbd somd tkmd% kt ks `kiikauet tl dxpdat irlm o pdrslgdxdrakskgc tbks rkcbt kg cll` ioktb% tl wdkcb #wktb cle`dg saoeds#wbot moxkmum omlugt li ilrad ks gdadssory tl hddp wktbkg tbdrkcbt' Dvdry rdoslgofed oeelwogad sblue` fd mo`d ilr tbd flgoik`d `didg`dr ki bd wktb tbd kgstkgat li sdei-prdsdrvotklg strlgcuplg bkm% pursuds% bks `didgad o ektted iurtbdr tbog moy fd strkateygdadssory kg tbd akraumstogads tl ovdrt tbd ottoah' Kt wlue` fdwbleey ugrdoekstka tl dxpdat li o pdrslg ug`dr ossouet% tl ml`ueotdbks `didgad stdp fy stdp oaalr`kgc tl tbd ottoah'

"0+ O pdrslg wbl ks kg kmmkgdgt og` rdoslgofed `ogcdr li elskgc bksekid lr ekmf moy kg tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li sdei-`didgad kgiekatogy borm% dvdg dxtdg`kgc tl `dotb lg bks ossokeogt dktbdr wbdgtbd ossouet ks ottdmptd` lr `krdatey tbrdotdgd`' Pbks prkgakped ksoesl sufjdat tl tbd prdad`kgc rued tbot tbd borm lr `dotbkgiekatd` tl ovdrt tbd `ogcdr ks glt sufstogtkoeey `ksprlplrtklgotdtl og` kgalmmdgsurotd wktb tbd quoekty og` aboroatdr li tbdpdrkelus oat lr tbrdot kgtdg`d` tl fd rdpdeed`'

"4+ Pbdrd must fd gl soid lr rdoslgofed ml`d li dsaopd fy rdtrdotilr tbd pdrslg algirlgtd` wktb og kmpdg`kgc pdrke tl ekid lr li

crovd fl`key borm% dxadpt fy kgiekatkgc `dotb lg tbd ossokeogt'Pbd rkcbt `lds glt oaarud og` ovoke wbdrd tbdrd ks &tkmd tl bovd rdalursdtl tbd prltdatklg li tbd pufeka outblrktkds'

Qda' ?>1' Sbdg tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty dxtdg`s tlaouskgc `dotb'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty dxtdg`s% ug`drtbd rdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg sdatklg ;;% tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc li `dotblr li ogy ltbdr borm tl tbd wrlgc-`ldr% ki tbd liidgad% tbd almmkttkgc liwbkab% lr tbd ottdmptkgc tl almmkt wbkab% laaosklgs tbd dxdraksd li tbdrkcbt% fd og liidgad li ogy li tbd `dsarkptklgs bdrdkgoitdr dgumdrotd`%gomdey:

Ikrst'Vlffdry8

Qdalg`ey'Blusd-frdohkgc fy gkcbt8

Pbkr`ey'Mksabkdi fy ikrd almmkttd` lg ogy fuke`kgc% tdgt lr vdssde% wbkab

fuke`kgc% tdgt lr vdssde ks usd` os o bumog `wdeekgc% lr os o peoad ilr tbdaustl`y li prlpdrty8

Ilurtbey'

Pbdit% mksabkdi% lr blusd-trdsposs% ug`dr suab akraumstogadsos moy rdoslgofey aousd opprdbdgsklg tbot `dotb lr crkdvlus burt wkee fdtbd algsdqudgad% ki suab rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ks glt dxdraksd`'

Qdatklg ?>> aotoelcuds tbd aosds kg wbkab tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad litbd fl`y dxtdg`s% ug`dr tbd rdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg Q' ;;% tl tbdvleugtory aouskgc li `dotb' Pbd prdsdgt sdatklg% blwdvdr% aotoelcuds tbd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

27/30

^ocd

63

aosds kg wbkab tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty dxtdg`s% ug`dr tbdrdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg Q' ;;% tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc li `dotb' -

Pbd aouskgc li `dotb kg lr`dr tl prdvdgt tbd almmkssklg li og liidgadspdakikd` kg ae'"0+ wkee fd justkikd` lgey wbdrd tbot liidgad ks suiikakdgt tlaousd o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `dotb lr crkdvlus burt' Pbks aeousd

wkee glt oppey wbdg tbd opprdbdgsklg li `dotb orksds fy rdoslg li tbdkgtdrvdgtklg li tbd pdrslg lr pdrslgs dxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad'#

Dxtdgt li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad'Sbked kt ks trud tbot kg dxdraksd li tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% lgey suab ilrad moy fd usd` os moy fdgdadssory% fut kt ks dquoeey wdee sdtted` tbot ot o tkmd wbdg o pdrslg ksioad` wktb kmmkgdgt pdrke li ekid og` ekmf li bkmsdei lr ltbdr% bd ks gltdxpdatd` tl wdkcb' kg cle`dg saoeds tbd prdaksd ilrad gdd`d` tl rdpdoe tbd`ogcdr' Dvdg ki bd% kg tbd bdot li mlmdgt% aorrkds bks `didgad o ekttediurtbdr tbog wbot wlue` fd gdadssory wbdg aoeaueotd` wktb prdaksklgog` dxoatktu`d fy o aeokm og` ugruiied` mkg`% tbd eow mohds `udoeelwogad ilr kt'#

Qda' ?>0' Sbdg suab rkcbt dxtdg`s tl aouskgc ogy borm ltbdr tbog`dotb'Ki tbd liidgad% tbd almmkttkgc li wbkab% lr tbd ottdmptkgc tlalmmkt wbkab% laaosklgs tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% fdtbdit% mksabkdi% lr arkmkgoe trdsposs% glt li ogy li tbd `dsarkptklgsdgumdrotd` kg tbd eost prdad`kgc sdatklg% tbot rkcbt `lds glt dxtdg` tl tbd

vleugtory aouskgc li `dotb% fut `lds dxtdg`% sufjdat tl tbd rdstrkatklgsmdgtklgd` kg sdatklg ;;% tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc tl tbd wrlgc-`ldr li ogyborm ltbdr tbog `dotb'

Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad sblrt li `dotb

Qdatklg ?>0 wkee oppey ki tbd wrlgc `ldrs almmkt lr ottdmpt tl almmkt ogyli tbd ileelwkgc liidgads: "?+ tbdit% "6+ mksabkdi lr trdsposs glt li tbd`dsarkptklg wbkab ks alvdrd` ug`dr sdatklg ?>1% sufjdat li alursd tlrdstrkatklgs mdgtklgd` kg sdatklg ;;8 og` kg suab o aosd tbd rkcbt li prkvotd

`didgad li prlpdrty wlue` dxtdg` lgey tl aouskgc borm ltbdr tbog `dotb tlbkm8 Jok Fbocwog v' Qtotd li Boryogo% OKV ?;;; QA ?>21'

Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad sblrt li `dotb 'Qdatklg ?>0 rdstrkatstbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty% os sdatklg ?>? puts o abdahlg tbd rkcbt tl prkvotd `didgad li tbd fl`y% tl aouskgc ogy bormsblrt li `dotb kg tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad' Qdatklg?>0 oaalr`kgcey prlvk`ds tbot ki tbd liidgad wbkab laaosklgs tbddxdraksd li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad% fd tbdit% mksabkdi lr arkmkgoetrdsposs% og` glt li ogy li tbd `dsarkptklgs dgumdrotd` kg sdatklg

?>1% tbd rkcbt li `didgad dxtdg`s lgey tl tbd vleugtory aouskgc liogy borm ltbdr tbog `dotb'

Gotbog: Kg Gotbog v' Qtotd li Mo`ros%# tbd Quprdmd Alurt bde`tbot skgad kt `k` glt oppdor tbot tbd borvdstkgc porty wos ormd`wktb ogy `do`ey wdoplgs og` tbdrd alue` glt bovd fddg ogy idor li`dotb lr crkdvlus burt lg tbd port li tbd oppdeeogt og` bks porty%

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

28/30

^ocd

62

ug`dr sdatklg ?>0% K'^'A' tbdkr rkcbt wos ekmktd` tl tbd aouskgc liogy borm ltbdr tbog `dotb' Pbd oaausd`% tblucb wdrd dxdrakskgc tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty% dxadd`d` tbot rkcbt wbdg tbdyaousd` tbd `dotb li lgd li tbd borvdstkgc porty og` bdgad tbdkr aosd

idee ug`dr Dxadptklg 6 tl sdatklg 1>>% K'^'A'% og` tbdy wkee fd ekofedilr auepofed blmkak`d glt omlugtkgc tl mur`dr ug`dr sdatklg 1>0%K'^'A' og` glt ilr mur`dr'

Qda' ?>4' Almmdgadmdgt og` algtkguogad li tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li prlpdrty'Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty almmdgadswbdg o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd prlpdrty almmdgads'

Pbd tkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty ocokgst rlffdry algtkguds os elgcos tbd liidg`dr aousds lr ottdmpts tl aousd tl ogy pdrslg `dotb lr burt lr

wrlgciue rdstrokgt lr os elgc os tbd idor li kgstogt `dotb lr li kgstogt burtlr li kgstogt pdrslgoe rdstrokgt algtkguds'

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty ocokgst arkmkgoe trdsposs lrmksabkdi algtkguds os elgc os tbd liidg`dr algtkguds kg tbd almmkssklg liarkmkgoe trdsposs lr mksabkdi'

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty ocokgst blusd-frdohkgc fy gkcbtalgtkguds os elgc os tbd blusd-trdsposs wbkab bos fddg fdcug fy suabblusdfrdohkgc algtkguds'

Almmdgadmdgt og` algtkguogad li rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad liprlpdrty'Qdatklg ?>4% K'^'A' ekhd sdatklg ?>6% ikxds tbd tkmd wbdgtbd rkcbt tl prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty almmdgads og` wbdg ktalmds tl og dg`' Pbd rkcbt li `didgad li prlpdrty almmdgads ossllg os o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd prlpdrtyalmmdgads' Pbd algtkguogad `dpdg`s uplg tbd goturd li tbdliidgad' Kg aosds li tbdit kt algtkguds ugtke tbd liidg`dr bos diidatd`bks rdtrdot wktb tbd prlpdrty% lr tbd osskstogad li pufeka outblrktkdsks lftokgd`% lr tbd prlpdrty bos fddg rdalvdrd`' Kg aosds li rlffdrykt algtkguds os elgc os tbd liidg`dr aousds lr ottdmpts tl aousd ogy

pdrslg `dotb lr burt% lr os elgc os kgstogt pdrslgoe rdstrokgtalgtkguds' Kg aosds li arkmkgoe trdsposs lr mksabkdi tbd rkcbtalgtkguds sl elgc os tbd liidg`dr algtkguds kg tbd almmkssklg liarkmkgoe trdsposs lr mksabkdi'

Omjo` Hbog: Kg Omjo` Hbog v' Qtotd%#tbd Quprdmd Alurt bde` tbotug`dr sdatklgs ?>6 og` ?>4 tbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad almmdgadsos sllg os o rdoslgofed opprdbdgsklg li `ogcdr tl tbd bumog fl`ylr tbd prlpdrty li lgdsdei lr ogltbdr pdrslg almmdgads tl orksdirlm og ottdmpt lr tbrdot tl almmkt og liidgad% dvdg tblucb tbd

liidgad moy glt fd almmkttd`' Sbked dxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad li prlpdrty% kt ks glt ot oee gdadssory tbot tbd pdrslgdxdrakskgc tbd rkcbt sblue` wokt ugtke bks prlpdrty lr ogltbdr#s ksoatuoeey elltd`% lr o blusd trdsposs oatuoeey laaurs'

Kg `dtdrmkgkgc wbdtbdr tbd ilrad dmpelyd` kg tbd dxdraksd li tbdrkcbt wos lr wos glt mlrd tbog wbot wos oatuoeey gdadssory% og`wbdtbdr tbd akraumstogads kg wbkab o pdrslg wos peoad` wdrd lr wdrd

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

29/30

^ocd

6;

glt suab os tl worrogt tbd aouskgc li `dotb% kt ks ugrdoslgofed tlwdkcb tbd ioats li o aosd kg tll ikgd o sdt li saoeds "cdgdroeey rdidrrd`tl os #cle`dg saoeds#+'

Kg tbd prdsdgt aosd tbd ioats wdrd tbot o almmugoe rklt bo`frlhdg lut kg tbd tlwg li Hotgk kg Mo`byo ^ro`dsb fdtwddg Qkg`bkrdiucdds og` elaoe Musekms' Musekm sblps wdrd elltd` og` slmdMusekm ekvds wdrd elst' Pbd mlf tbdg opprloabd` tbd sblp li tbdoaausd` og` bks frltbdr% wbkab wdrd o`joadgt% og` elltd` tbdfrltbdr#s sblp' Pbd mlf tbdg fdot uplg tbd aelsd` `llrs li tbd sblpli tbd oaausd` wktb eotbks' Pbd `wdeekgc quortdrs li tbd oaausd`#siomkey wdrd sktuotd` fdbkg` bks frltbdr#s sblp' Fdilrd tbd mlf alue`frdoh kgtl tbd sblp% tbd oaausd` ikrd` twl sblts irlm bks cug% wbkabrdsuetd` kg tbd `dotb li lgd mog kg tbd rkltlus arlw`' Oppdeeogt wosalgvkatd` fltb fy trkoe alurt og` Bkcb Alurt ilr dxadd`kgc tbd rkcbtli prkvotd liidgad li prlpdrty'

Oeelwkgc tbd oppdoe tbd Quprdmd Alurt bde` tbot tbd ioats li tbdaosd wdrd suiikakdgt tl oiilr` tl tbd oaausd` o rkcbt li prkvotd`didgad wbkab dxtdg`d` tl tbd aouskgc li `dotb% fdaousd tbdoaausd` bo` rdoslgofed crlug` tl opprdbdg` tbot `dotb lr crkdvlusburt wlue` fd aousd` tl bks iomkey% ki bd `k` glt oat prlmptey' Bd`k` glt bovd tl wokt ugtke tbd `llrs wdrd frlhdg lpdg og` tbd mlfbo` dgtdrd` tbd sblp'

Pbd tbrdot tl frdoh kg wos kmpekakt kg tbd alg`uat li tbd mlf og`%wktb kt% tbd tbrdot tl hkee tbd kgmotds lgad tbd `llrs wdrd ilrad`'

Pbks wos dvk`dgt irlm tbd ioat tbot ltbdr Musekm sblps bo` fddgelltd` og` Musekm ekvds elst' Tg`dr tbd akraumstogads kt bo` tl fdbde` tbot tbd tbrdot tl mdgoad li `dotb lr ot edost crkdvlus burt bo`oerdo`y almmdgad` ot tbd tkmd wbdg tbd oaausd` ikrd` twl sblts%og` tbot tbd ikrkgc li twl sblts wktb tbd kgtdgt li stoykgc o irdgzkd`mlf wos glt usd li mlrd ilrad tbog wos gdadssory'#

Pbd rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad li prlpdrty ocokgst blusd-frdohkgc fy gkcbtalgtkguds os elgc os tbd blusd-trdsposs wbkab bos fddg fdcug fy suabblusdfrdohkgc algtkguds'

Qda' ?>9' Vkcbt li prkvotd `didgad ocokgst `do`ey ossouet wbdg tbdrdks rksh li borm tl kggladgt pdrslg'Ki kg tbd dxdraksd li tbd rkcbt liprkvotd `didgad ocokgst og ossouet wbkab rdoslgofey aousds tbdopprdbdgsklg li `dotb% tbd `didg`dr fd sl sktuotd` tbot bd aoggltdiidatuoeey dxdraksd tbot rkcbt wktblut rksh li borm tl og kggladgt pdrslg%bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad dxtdg`s tl tbd ruggkgc li tbot rksh'

Keeustrotklg

Oks ottoahd` fy o mlf wbl ottdmpt tl mur`dr bkm' Bd aogglt diidatuoeeydxdraksd bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wktblut ikrkgc lg tbd mlf% og` bdaogglt ikrd wktblut rksh li bormkgc ylugc abke`rdg wbl ord mkgced` wktbtbd mlf' Oalmmkts gl liidgad ki fy sl ikrkgc bd borms ogy li tbd abke`rdg'

8/22/2019 Right of Private Defense under Indian penal code

30/30

1>

Vksh li borm tl kggladgt pdrslgs'Qdatklg ?>9 `does wktb oaosd li dxtrdmd gdadsskty% kg wbkab o pdrslg ks outblrksd` fy eow tlrug tbd rksh li bormkgc dvdg kggladgt pdrslgs kg lr`dr tl prltdatbkmsdei irlm mlrtoe kgjury'

Pbd sdatklg prlvk`ds tbot wbdgdvdr og opprdbdgsklg li `dotb dxkstsog` tbd pdrslg ks sl sktuotd` tbot bd aogglt diidatkvdey dxdraksd tbdrkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wktblut tbd plsskfkekty li `lkgc borm tl ogkggladgt pdrslg% bd moy tohd tbd rksh li suab borm rdsuetkgc' Ilrkgstogad% os ckvdg kg tbd keeustrotklg oppdg`d` tl tbd sdatklg% ki O ksottoahd` fy o mlf kgtdg`kgc tl mur`dr bkm og` bd aogglt diidatkvdeydxdraksd bks rkcbt li prkvotd `didgad wktblut ikrkgc lg tbd mlf% og`bd aogglt ikrd wktblut tbd rksh li bormkgc ylugc abke`rdg wbl bovdmkgced` wktb tbd mlf% bd almmkts gl liidgad ki fy sl ikrkgc% bd

kgjurds ogy lgd li tbd abke`rdg' O bo` gl lptklg ug`dr tbdakraumstogads li tbd aosd ilr prltdatkgc bkmsdei dxadpt tl ikrd ot tbdmlf og` sl bks oatklg ks justkikd`'