rhodes v mcdonald - 3 - motion for temporary restraining order by connie rhodes - 03 2009-09-04...

Upload: jack-ryan

Post on 30-May-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    1/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 1

    Orly Taitz, Esq Attorney & Counselor at Law 26302 La Paz, Suite 211Mission Viejo Ca 92691ph. 949-683-5411

    fax 949-586-2082California Bar ID No. 223433(Application for Admission Pro Hac Vice filed)

    UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTMIDDLE DISTRICT OF GEORGIA

    COLUMUS DIVISION120 12th Street P.O. Box 124 Columbus, Georgia 31902

    CAPTAIN CONNIE RHODES, M.D. F.S., Plaintiff, Civil Action No:____________

    v.

    COLONEL THOMAS D. MACDONALD, GARRISON COMMANDER, FORT BENNING, GEORGIA, Rule 65GEORGE STEUBER, DEPUTY Application for Temporary COMMANDER, FORT BENNING, Restraining Order andDR. ROBERT M. GATES, UNITED Preliminary InjunctionSTATES SECRETARY OF DEFENSE, BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA, de facto

    PRESIDENT of the UNITED STATES, Defendants.

    APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY RETRAINING ORDER ANDPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION TO SUSPEND PLAINTIFFS

    DEPLOYMENT, AND ALL FOREIGN DEPLOYMENTS OF OFFICERSPENDING DETERMINATION OF CONSTITUIONALITY OF TITLE 10

    U.S.C. 938 and Army Regulation 27-10

    1. Comes now the Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S., with this Comp

    Application for a Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction.2. Plaintiff Rhodes seeks an immediate temporary restraining order and

    preliminary injunction to suspend her deployment and that of all foreign

    deployments of commissioned officers pending entry of a permanent injunction

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    2/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 2

    and final declaratory judgment.

    3. Plaintiff further that this court restrain the Army from enforcing its orders

    against her until this Court has rendered a final determination that Title 10

    U.S.C. 938 (Article 138 UCMJ), both on its face and as implemented by Army

    Regulation 27-10, are unconstitutional.

    4. 10 U.S.C. 938 states as follows, in full:

    938. Art. 138. Complaints of wrongs Any member of the armed forces who believes himself wronged by his commanding officer, and who, upon due application to thatcommanding officer, is refused redress, may complain to any superior commissioned officer, who shall forward the complaint tothe officer exercising general court-martial jurisdiction over theofficer against whom it is made. The officer exercising generalcourt-martial jurisdiction shall examine into the complaint and takeproper measures for redressing the wrong complained of; and heshall, as soon as possible, send to the Secretary concerned a truestatement of that complaint, with the proceedings had thereon.

    5. Plaintiff alleges that this statute is unconstitutional on its face because it is

    void for vagueness and constitutes an impermissible delegation of plenary federal

    judicial authority to executive branch (administrative) courts over matters of life,

    liberty, and even constitutional interpretation.

    6. Nothing in the constitution allows military courts to engage in

    constitutional interpretation, and previous courts have held that review in federal

    court is available without exhaustion of remedies under 10 USCS 938 where

    serviceman, who has received transfer (e.g. deployment) orders, claims violation

    of constitutional rights if transfer is effected, insufficient time is available to seek

    such remedies as are afforded by army regulations, and likelihood of stay of

    transfer is unclear under army regulations, so that army authorities maybe

    enjoined from transferring serviceman. Cushing v. Tetter, 478 F. Supp.

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    3/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 3

    960 (D.R.I. 1979), see also, regarding waiver of administrative procedures when

    time constraints of less than one week may exist, United States v Wise , 64 MJ

    468, 2007 CAAF LEXIS 538 (CAAF 2007).

    7. Nothing in 938 or the army regulations (27_10) implementing it define or

    suggest rules of decision or criteria or even the standards of pleading, discovery

    of facts, production, and proof of the lawful status of orders, the constitutional

    establishment of a chain-of-command, or determining the liability of an officer

    who innocently or blindly follows UNLAWFUL orders or obeys an

    unconstitutional chain of command, or of an officer who fails properly to identify

    and defend his country against its true enemies, foreign or domestic.

    8. In short, Title 10 U.S.C. 938 and Army Regulation 27_10 are deficient in

    that they do not address that which should be most important: namely the

    enforcement and compliance of officers with their oath.

    9. Most importantly, this statute and regulation are unconstitutional as

    applied because they do NOT even tangentially address the question of army

    determination of the lawful status of orders or the identity of national enemies,

    foreign or domestic.

    10. In short, Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law: if she is forced to comply

    with illegal orders, rendered by an unconstitutional chain of command, in

    violation of her oath and conscience, the damage will be done and irreparable by

    any legal remedy including damages.

    11. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes and all other officers similarly situated

    have no adequate remedy at law because neither the aforementioned statute Title

    10 U.S.C. 938 nor the army regulation implementing it AR 27_10) provide any

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    4/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 4

    procedural means temporarily to stay the execution of orders pending

    determination of legality as req uired by the officers oath. Plaintiff and all other

    officers similarly situated have suffered and will continue to suffer irreparable

    injury from the absence of any certain way of challenging or verifying the lawful

    status of orders or constitutional status of the chain of command nor the identity

    of all enemies foreign and domestic within the present statutory and regulatory

    regime.

    12. This Court has Jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1331 (Federal

    Question), 1343 (Civil Rights), and 1346 (United States Defendant). Venue is

    proper due to the need to restrain and enjoin Plaintiffs deployment from Fort

    Benning.

    13. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., as an individual Plaintiff, now

    suffers will suffer further irreparable injury due to forced and involuntary

    compliance with unlawful and/or unconstitutionally rendered orders, against her

    conscientious objection and loyalty oath as an officer, if she should be compelled

    to comply with illegal orders to deploy abroad entered without any adequate legal

    means of temporarily suspending the operation of these orders pending a final

    determination of their legality.

    14. Gone are the days, if they ever existed in these United States, when Army

    Officers are entitled to obey all orders, regardless of their apparent legality,

    constitutionality, or service to the nation.

    15. United States public policy favors an army whose corps of commissioned

    officers obeys their oaths to uphold the constitution and defend the nation

    against all enemies foreign and domestic, who have the foresight to look before

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    5/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 5

    they leap, who know that haste makes waste, and that any and every

    substantial doubt concerning the legality or constitutionality of orders to engage

    in potentially fatal and destructive military conflict abroad should always be

    resolved in favor of caution and reticence to refuse to follow those orders.

    16. Public policy since Andersonville during the War Between the States, the

    Massacre at Wounded Knee, My Lai in Vietnam, and most recently Guantanamo

    and Abu Ghraib, as well international law since Nurnberg, Bosnia-Serbia-Kosovo,

    Darfur, Burundi, and Somalia, all favor the notion that responsible military

    officers MUST and SHOULD at all times question the legality and propriety of

    orders which come from doubtful or questionable sources, or under

    circumstances which give rise to an appearance of impropriety or illegitimacy.

    17. This Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., at the time of her original

    induction into service, took the United States, military oath of an enlisted soldier,

    which reads:

    "I, Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., do solemnly swear (oraffirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the UnitedStates against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will beartrue faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the ordersof the President of the United States and the orders of the officersappointed over me, according to the regulations and the UniformCode of Military Justice. So help me God."

    18. Later, however, she took the superceding and superior oath of an

    officer of the United States Armed Forces, as follows:

    "I, Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S., having beenappointed an officer in the Army of the United States, asindicated above in the grade of Captain do solemnly swear(or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitutionof the United States against all enemies, foreign ordomestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to thesame; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    6/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 6

    reservations or purpose of evasion; and that I will welland faithfully discharge the duties of the office upon

    which I am about to enter; So help me God." (DA Form 71,1 August 1959, for officers.)

    19.

    The oath of a military officer is based on 5 U.S.C. 3331: An individual, except the President, elected or appointedto an office of honor or profit in the civil service oruniformed services, shall take the following oath: I, AB,do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support anddefend the Constitution of the United States against allenemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faithand allegiance to the same; that I take this obligationfreely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge theduties of the office on which I am about to enter. So helpme God. This section does not affect other oaths required

    by law.

    See also: http://www.history.army.mil/faq/oaths.htm

    20. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., has never sworn to obey the

    orders of THIS President, the current de facto President of the United States.

    21. But in historical and current legal fact, no commissioned officer ever swears

    (as such) to obey the orders of any President.

    22. Rather, Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes assumed and undertook, and still

    assumes and undertakes the obligation to defend the Constitution against all

    enemies, foreign and domestic.

    23. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., submits that she has severe

    mental reservations about obeying the commands of the current de facto

    President and that she cannot in fact in good conscience do so.

    24. Further Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., asks this Court to

    declare and adjudge that both Title 10 U.S.C. 938 and the Army Regulations

    implementing the same offer (AR 27_10) provide no remedy whatsoever and in

    http://www.history.army.mil/faq/oaths.htmhttp://www.history.army.mil/faq/oaths.htmhttp://www.history.army.mil/faq/oaths.htmhttp://www.history.army.mil/faq/oaths.htm
  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    7/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 7

    fact place an officer in the utterly untenable position of having to act obediently

    against his or her conscience or else to risk Court Martial by disobedience.

    25. The law as currently enacted and implemented offers no simple, direct, or

    reliable administrative (or any other means internal to the army) by which an

    officer can verify the legality either of any particular order or of the legitimacy of

    the officers who purport to render legitimate commands.

    26. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S, submits and charges that the

    current de facto President never provided any evidence of his eligibility and

    Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., submits that she cannot lawfully act under his

    authority, but that she is being forced to do so without ANY opportunity or

    remedial avenue whatsoever.

    27. It is meet and right and our bounden duty: it is lawful, right and proper and

    in fact mandated by her oath that an officer, pursuant to her oath to defend

    against all enemies, foreign and domestic, should have a right and effective

    administrative or judicial means to challenge (within the reality of military time

    and frameworks), and a reasonably speedy and expedient route of appeal any

    denial of a challenge the chain of command originating from a suspected

    Presidential Usurper (and consequently illegitimate Secretary of Defense and an

    illegal Department of Defense hierarchy).

    28. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., demands that this court afford

    her such an opportunity to obey the clear dicatates of her moral conscience in

    compliance with her oath as an officer.

    29. Furthermore, Plaintiff moves and requests this Court to declare and

    adjudge in her favor that such obedience is required of her and all other officers

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    8/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 8

    by their Oath, by the Constitution, and by the public policy of and concerning the

    United States Government, including but not limited to the army.

    30. Plaintiff submits that the reservations under which she would be forced to

    act if she were forced and required against her will to obey the orders for her to

    serve this President, this Secretary and Department of Defense, would not only

    hinder and impair her ability to act effectively;

    31. Plaintiff contends, that in reality, to force her to serve under this illegitimate

    commander-in-chief, this Secretary and Department of Defense appointed by an

    imposter or ineligible, fraudulently elected, illegitimate usurper would constitute

    involuntary servitude or judicially sanctioned rape of her individual autonomy.

    32. Plaintiff submits that the reservations under which she would be forced to

    act if she were forced and required against her will to obey the orders for her to

    serve this President are neither conjectural nor speculative nor merely based on

    opinion or doubt.

    33. Rather the vast preponderance of the credible evidence, all of the clear and

    convincing evidence, and some facts indicate beyond reasonable doubt that the

    President is an alien, possibly even an unnaturalized or even an unadmitted

    illegal alien (admitted just a few days ago, by United States Representative Diane

    Watson of Californias 33 rd Congressional District to have been born in Kenya),

    without so much as lawful residency in the United States. Some of the relevant

    evidence is shown in Exhibit A (Affidavit of Neal Sankey with attachments) and

    Exhibit B (August 1, 2009 released copy of Kenya Birth Certificate).

    34. This Plaintiff cannot lawfully obey orders from this Commander-in-Chief;

    this Plaintiff cannot in good conscience obey orders originating from a chain of

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    9/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 9

    command from this merely de facto President; this Plaintiff cannot be lawfully

    compelled to obey this de facto Presidents orders.

    35. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., asks this Court to declare and

    adjudge that if it were shown by clear-and-convincing evidence that a person took

    the office under false pretenses of constitutional qualifications), such person is a

    domestic enemy, and constitutes a clear and present danger as an enemy to the

    constitution and laws of the United States of America.

    36. The Founding Fathers had the foresight to protect and secure against a

    situation such as that now facing the United States.

    37. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., asks this Court further to

    declare and adjudge that the officers oath is and sh ould always be, under the

    Constitution, construed as a safeguard to protect the Constitution against a

    corrupt elected government.

    38. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., asks this Court to declare and

    adjudge that Officers have an obligation to defend the Constitution.

    The officer oath does not even mention following the UCMJ laws asdoes the enlisted oath. Further, a card entitled Army Valuesissued by the United States Army (Exhibit D), commands allsoldiers in part as follows: Bear truth fai th and allegiance to theUnited States Constitution, the Army, your unit, and othersoldiers. Put the welfare of the Nation, the army, and your subordinates before your own. Do whats right, legally and morally.

    Face fear, danger, or adversity (physical or moral).

    39. Title 10, Subtitle A, Part II of the United States Code contains the Uniform

    Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). 10 U.S.C. 890 (ART.90), makes it an offence

    subject to court- martial if any military personnel willfully disobeys a lawful

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    10/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 10

    command of his [her] superior commissioned officer," 10 U.S.C. 891 (ART.91)

    "lawful order of a warrant officer", and most importantly, 10 U.S.C. 892

    (ART.92) provides court-martial for any officer who

    (1) violates or fails to obey any lawful general order or regulation;(2) having knowledge of any other lawful order issued by amember of the armed forces, which it is his duty to obey, fails toobey the order; or(3) is derelict in the performance of his duties;

    40. In each case, Plaintiff submits that it is implicit though not expressly stated

    that an officer is and should be subject to court-martial, because s he will be

    derelict in the performance of her duties, if she does not inquire as to

    the lawfulness, the legality, the legitimacy of the orders which she has

    received, whether those orders are specific or general.

    41. Unfortunately the Uniform Code of Military Justice as currently drafted and

    implemented does not provide a means WHATSOEVER for ascertaining the

    legality of orders, and accordingly, this Plaintiff is left with no choice but recourse

    to the ordinary civil courts of the United States to seek a determination of what

    she considers to be a question of paramount constitutional and legal importance:

    the validity of the chain of command under a President whose election, eligibility,

    and constitutional status appear open to serious question.

    42. Accordingly, Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., comes to this

    Court because she cannot afford to breach and must preserve the status quo, and

    that this Court should enable her to comply with an obey her officers oath of

    fealty to the Constitution of the United States of America and obligation to defend

    this Country against all enemies, foreign and domestic, or to prevent irreparable

    injury to her career, and that this Court must immediately intervene and afford

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    11/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 11

    her the Temporary Relief to which she is entitled under the First, Fifth, and Ninth

    Amendments to the Constitution of the United States.

    43. The specific relief sought from this Court is

    44. FIRST, an order suspending her deployment to Iraq (now

    scheduled for September 5, 2009, from Fort Benning within the

    jurisdiction of this Court for the Middle District of Georgia, see

    Exhibit A),

    45. SECOND an order temporarily enjoining the enforcement of 10

    U.S.C. 937-938 according to the provisions of the implementing

    army regulation 27-10, and for injunctive protection from the

    Secretary and Department of Defense, Defense Security Services

    Agency, and the President from engaging in retaliatory conduct for

    Plaintiffs challenge to the Presidents constitutional authority as

    Commander-in-Chief, and

    46. THIRD for a mandatory injunction or other equitable order (e.g.

    Mandamus) that the United States Army amend its procedures for

    challenging the constitutionality and general lawful status of orders

    to afford full due process protection consistent with every

    commissioned officers obligation to uphold her oath.

    47. Plaintiff further and additionally seeks a Prohibitory (Negative)

    Temporary Restraining Order and/or Preliminary Injunction

    forbidding the Department of Defense from taking any retaliatory or

    blacklisting operations against Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes,

    M.D. F.S.

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    12/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 12

    48. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S. submits and contends that she

    has and will continue to have an absolute and unassailable obligation to question

    the legality of her deployment orders until such time as this Court renders a final

    judgment in her favor.

    49. Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D., F.S., further and additionally asks

    that this Court grant her protection from military prosecution or retaliation and

    specifically to grant her CONSCIENTIOUS OBJECTOR STATUS:

    50. And, for this reason, even if for this reason alone, because she obeyed the

    dictates of her well- studied and much beloved Officers O ath and moral

    conscience, this Court should protect Plaintiff Connie Rhodes from any form of

    Department of Defense or other governmental retaliation.

    51. Balance of the Equities: Plaintiff will suffer irreparable, in fact

    incalculable, injury if this preliminary injunction is not granted, but the cost

    of compliance with the TRO and Preliminary Injunction to the Department of

    Defense is minimal (and might actually save expenditure of government funds

    and conserve resources), while the cost to Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D.

    F.S. of Defamation and interference is immense, so that the balance of equities

    favors the granting of this TRO and preliminary injunction without bond.

    52. Finally, because of the outrageous and illegal nature of the

    repressive and retaliatory conduct of the Department of Defense,

    already demonstrated in other related or similar cases, Public Policy

    favors the entry of this Temporary Restraining order and, upon

    hearing a Preliminary Injunction during the pendency of this action.

    CONCLUSION

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    13/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 13

    Plaintiff Captai n Connie Rhodes present Rule 65 Application for TRO and

    Preliminary Injunction presents legal arguments and requested relief, all

    revolving around an officer's duty to uphold the Constitution, his duty

    to question the lawful nature and status of orders according to his

    oath as an officer--and the role of the armed forces as a critical

    element of the balance of power in a constitutional government.

    In the post-Nuremberg era, the era of International Law and the United

    Nations, the army cannot merely be subservient to the President, a mere tool or

    blindly subservient instrument. The United States Army, acting by and through

    its officers, is one of the most powerful forces IN THE WORLD, and for an Army

    NOT to have an independent conscience and capacity to question its role and

    position would be a very dangerous thing---which the founding fathers foresaw

    (and therefore discouraged standing armies). Since we now have a standing

    army, we need to give the officers constitutional status and empower them to use

    their moral consciences wisely, a duty and power their oaths suggest they already

    have, but the exercise of which role has never previously been contoured

    judicially.

    PRAYER FOR RELIEF

    WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that this Court will immediately enter a

    Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction upon full-hearing,

    waiving all bonds or other financial requirements. Specifically, Plaintiff prays

    that this Court

    (1) will declare Title 10 of the United States Code, and 10 U.S.C. 938 in

    particular Unconstitutional on its face, for failure to provide temporary relief or

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    14/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 14

    to allow or provide a ready mechanism or procedural means for the evaluation of

    the lawful or constitutional status of orders or of any other means by which

    officers can confirm or assure compliance with their oath to uphold the

    constitution of the United States and defend against all enemies foreign and

    domestic, and that this Court will further suspend Plaintiffs foreign deployment,

    and suspend or recall all other foreign deployments of commissioned officers

    similarly situated since January 21, 2009, until such time as the executive order

    of January 21, 2009, is repealed, cancelled, rescinded, or judicially voided, and

    until procedures and mechanisms are put in place by which officers can

    effectively and immediately verify or disown the lawful status and constitutional

    validity of orders received, together with preliminary relief from obligation to

    comply with all reasonably challenged orders except under circumstances of

    direct invasion of or visible threat to the security of the domestic borders or

    populations of the United States or their territories generally.

    (2) recognize and respect Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes status, and the

    status of all persons similarly situated in the United States Army and Armed

    Forces Generally (whether certified as a class pursuant to Rule 23 or not), as

    conscientious objectors based on legitimate doubts concerning the constitutional

    qualifications and eligibility of the de facto President and Commander-in-Chief,

    Barack Hussein Obama,

    (3) enjoin Defendants Robert M. Gates, Colonel Thomas D. MacDonald,

    the Deputy Garrison Commander George Steuberat Fort Benning, or anyone in

    the Department of Defense or executive branch of the United States government

    generally, from issuing any order to Plaintiff or any other officers persons

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    15/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 15

    similarly situated to Afghanistan or anywhere on active duty at all this case has

    reached a final determination on the merits,

    (4) that Plaintiff Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S. should be protected

    by injunction and declaratory relief from being wrongfully subjected, by

    institutional action, classification, or by the behavior or on the initiative of

    anyone in the United States Executive Branch or Department of Defense or

    United States Army, to retaliation as a result of her exercise of her First, Fifth and

    Ninth Amendment rights and that

    (5) that Plaintiff have all her attorneys fees and reasonable costs of suit,

    and all such other and further relief as this Court may allow, pursuant to 28

    U.S.C. 2201-2201 and 42 U.S.C. 1983, 1988(a).

    Respectfully submitted,

    WEDNESDAY September 2, 2009

    By:_________________________Orly Taitz, DDS, Esq.

    California Bar ID No. 223433FOR THE PLAINTIFF

    Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S.

    26302 La Paz, Suite 211Mission Viejo Ca 92691

    29839 S. Margarita Pkwy Rancho Santa Margarita Ca 92688

    Phone 949-683-5411

    E-MAIL: [email protected]

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    16/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 16

    CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

    The above-and-foregoing Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction: that 10 U.S.C. 938 and Army Regulation 27_10 be declaredunconstitutional both on their faces and as applied, was served by facsimile

    and/or hand delivery on Wednesday, September 2, 2009, on the followingparties:

    Colonel Thomas D. MacDonaldGarrison Commander, Fort Benning, GeorgiaHugh Randolph Aderhold , Jr.PO Box 1702Macon , GA 31202-1702478-621-2728Email: [email protected]

    Dr. Robert M. Gates, Secretary of Defense,

    President Barack Hussein Obama,

    by and throughMaxwell Wood, United States Attorney for the Middle District of Georgia, at

    Columbus Division 1246 First Avenue SunTrust Building, 3rd FloorColumbus, Georgia 31901 Tel: (706) 649-7700.

    ________________________________ Attorney Orly Taitz, Esquire, for the Plaintiff

    Captain Connie Rhodes, M.D. F.S.

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    17/63

    Rule 65 Application for TRO and Preliminary Injunction 17

    EXHIBIT A:

    Deployment OrderReceived by U.S. Army Major

    Captain Connie Rhodes,M.D. F.S.

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    18/63

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    19/63

    AFFIDAVIT

    The State of California

    ) S.S.

    City of Simi Valley )

    I, Neil SANKEY, of Simi Valley, California, MAKE OATH AND SAY THAT:,

    1. I, Neil Sankey am over the age o f eighteen years.

    If called to do so, I could and would competently testify under oath as follows.

    I am a Licensed Investigator in the State of California License number P.1. 10905. I have

    been so licensed for twenty five years. I am a Naturalized American Citizen.

    I am experienced in all types of Investigation, both Civil and Criminal, having spent

    twenty years in the British Police, serving as a Detective Sergeant at New Scotland

    Yard. In the interest of our Country I have been assisting with research and

    investigation wherever necessary.

    2. During the course of the work that I was doing in the latter part of 2008, regarding theactivities and qualifications of Mr. Obama, I have compiled a record of all of the

    addresses in regards to which I have seen the use of his name. The records and

    databases which I use are many and varied having been accumulated for many

    different reasons but all are Public Record and the documents I have used are available

    to the General Public with, or without the payment of fees.

    3.On January

    2,2009 I forwarded to Doctor Taitz a complete list of my efforts to that

    time. A true and complete copy of that document accompanies this document attached

    and marked "Exhibit A".

    4. On July 6, 2009, I forwarded to Doctor Taitz an updated version of that list, accurate

    as of that date and having been updated, by me, during the weekend of July 4t h and 5 th

    Case 4:09-cv-00082-CDL Document 1-6 Filed 07/09/2009 Page 1 of 3

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    20/63

    2009. A true and complete copy of that document accompanies this document attached

    and marked "Exhibit B"

    SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO

    BEFORE ME, on the

    6th day of July, 2009

    )

    )

    ) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -NOTARY PUBLIC ) Neil SANKEY

    My Commission expires: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ,

    Case 4:09-cv-00082-CDL Document 1-6 Filed 07/09/2009 Page 2 of 3

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    21/63

    CALIFORNIA JURAT WITH AFFIANT STATEMENT , ,

    YSee Attached Document (Notary to cross out lines 1-6 below) _ See Statement Below (Lines 1- 5 to be completed only by document signer[sJ, not Notary)

    - - - ~ . ~ - - - ~ ~ - - - ~ . ~ - - - -..----.NO.1 Signat\J; o O()cument Sigr18f No.2 {If ar'ty)

    State of California( \ . .

    County of . 've,V)'tct /) LL-Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me on this

    L c ' t ~ Jday of _Jv..G i . . ~ - 20cfi , by

    Dale M h Year

    (1

    proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidenceto be the person who appeared before me (.)Y

    ( ~( 2 ) - - - - - - r ' ~ = - - : - : - - _ _ : _ :

    It; Name of S:gr:er

    proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidenceto be ~ W h O~ p p e a r e d~ b e f o r e me,)S i g n a ~ ' . ./

    Place Notary Seal A.bove

    O P T I O N A L - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    RIGHTTHUMBPRINTOF SIGNER #1

    Further Description of Any Attached Document

    Ttle or Type of LJu(;U'!I'ern: ... ~ . . ' . . . l , . , ~ . L L c U . . . " _ " _ " _ ' _ _ _ \ _ - -....... - - - .. - ~ - .... _ _ _ _Document Date: _ _ ........~ _ ' - -.....= . . _ I - ' ' ' ' ' - . . - ' . . - - - - Number 01 Pages ~ l : : : '

    Signer(s) Other Than Nemeo Above: . - - .. - . ' - - " ' + f . . " " - = : . . . ~ . - -....- - - - -

    fraudulent document.

    20G7 National Notary A.ssoclat,on' 9350 De . PO. Box 2402' Chatsworth. CA 91313-2402' v,ww.NatiooaNotary org I,em 45910 Reorder: Call Toll-Free 1800 876 6827

    Case 4:09-cv-00082-CDL Document 1-6 Filed 07/09/2009 Page 3 of 3

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    22/63

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY AGender - Male Street Address - 111 S KING ST City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96813-3504

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 514-03-xxxx Age - 73 Date of Birth - Mar 23, 1918 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Jan 90 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY AGender - Male Street Address -

    City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 514-03-xxxx Age - 73 Date of Birth - Mar 23, 1918 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Feb 92 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY AGender - Male

    Street Address -City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Nov 95 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY A

    Gender - Male Street Address - 1617 S BERETANIA ST APT 100 City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826-1106 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 514-03-xxxx Age - 73 Date of Birth - Mar 23, 1918

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    23/63

    Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Jan 95 - Jan 96 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY AGender - Male

    Street Address - 5578B M APT 37 City, State, Zip - GRAWN MI 49637 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 557-31-xxxx Age - 46 Date of Birth - 1963 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 97 ******************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY ANNGender - Male Street Address - 1512 SPRECKELS ST APT 402 City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96822-4660 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Jan 87 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY ANNGender - Male Street Address - 1617 S BERETANIA ST APT 1008 City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826-1112 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Mar 87 - Jun 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY ANNGender - Male Street Address - C O MADELYN DUNHAM City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    24/63

    Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Oct 95 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY ANNGender - Male Street Address - 8 WEST ST APT 4 City, State, Zip - NEW YORK NY 10004-1001 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes Date Record Verified - Oct 94 - Jan 95

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - DUNHAM, STANLEY ANNGender - Male Street Address - 235 E 40TH ST APT 8F City, State, Zip - NEW YORK NY 10016-1747 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 52 Date of Birth - Nov 29, 1942 Deceased - Yes

    Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - 1512 S City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96822 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -

    Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 90 - Dec 91 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - 1512 SPRECKELS ST STE E402 City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96822-4658

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    25/63

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Dec 92 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - 1617 S BERETANIA ST APT 1008 City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826-1112 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 67 Date of Birth - 1942 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 87 - Aug 07

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - C O MADELYN DUNHAM City, State, Zip - HONOLULU HI 96826 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 67 Date of Birth - 1942 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 95 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - 8 WEST ST APT 4 City, State, Zip - NEW YORK NY 10004-1001 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 67 Date of Birth - 1942 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 94 - Jan 95 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - SUTORO, STAGender - Male Street Address - 235 E 40TH ST City, State, Zip - NEW YORK NY 10016-1744 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-40-xxxx Age - 67 Date of Birth - 1942

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    26/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 93 *********************************************************************************************************

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACStreet Address - 3 MULTIPLE ST City, State, Zip - DENVER CO 80207 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 303-451-8454 - MDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 156-42-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 08 - Sep 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 1 PENNSYLVANNIA City, State, Zip - BEVERLY HILLS CA 90210 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -

    Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 09 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 355 POMELO AVE City, State, Zip - BREA CA 92821-4129 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 537-36-xxxx Age -

    Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 08 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 123 WHITE HOUSE City, State, Zip - IRVINE CA 92618 Probable Current Address - No

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    27/63

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Jun 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 3535 OLIVE ST City, State, Zip - DENVER CO 80207-1523 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 303-222-5673 - MDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 456-73-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Sep 08 - Jan 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 40 TRANSFER ST City, State, Zip - DENVER CO 80207 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 303-545-0199 - MDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 011-23-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Nov 07 - Mar 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 1 WASHINGTON RIDGE RD City, State, Zip - NEW MILFORD CT 06776-2248 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1400 PENNSYLVANIA AVE SE City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20003-3029 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    28/63

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 201-67-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 09 - Jul 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1600 PENN AVE NW City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20007 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08 - Mar 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 10 OHIO AVE City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20059-0001 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 1600 PENNSYLVANIA AVE NW City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20500-0003 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 713 HART SENATE City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20510-0001 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    29/63

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 282-80-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 08 - Nov 08

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 15 A 1A City, State, Zip - MANALAPAN FL 33462 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 08 - May 08

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - APPLE ST City, State, Zip - MELBOURNE FL 32940 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 762-41-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 08 - May 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1603 RUCKER RD City, State, Zip - ALPHARETTA GA 30004-1435 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 579-02-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Aug 08

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - CNN LIVE City, State, Zip - ATLANTA GA 30303 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 189-16-xxxx

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    30/63

    Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1305 LEE RD City, State, Zip - COLUMBUS GA 31904 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 09 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 505 FARR RD APT C City, State, Zip - COLUMBUS GA 31907-6275 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 420-67-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 08 - Mar 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 505 FARR RD APT C City, State, Zip - COLUMBUS GA 31907-6275 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 423-29-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Aug 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 559 W GOLF RD City, State, Zip - ARLINGTON HEIGHTS IL 60005-3904 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    31/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Sep 08 - Jan 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male

    Street Address - 14 W ERIE ST City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60610-5397 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 05 - Jan 06 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Gender - Male Street Address - 5450 1 EAST VIEW PARK S City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 05 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 10131 53RD ST E City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 217-782-5338 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 364-03-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 03 - Jul 03 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 10131 53RD ST E City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 773-363-1996 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 364-03-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    32/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 03 - Jul 03 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 10131/2 53RD ST E

    City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 217-782-5338 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 364-03-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 03 - Jul 03 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 10131/2 53RD ST E

    City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 773-363-1996 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 364-03-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 03 - Jul 03 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male

    Street Address - 5450 S EAST VIEW PARK APT 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-5916 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 02 - May 05 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Gender - Male Street Address - 5046 S GREENWOOD AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-2806 Probable Current Address - Yes Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    33/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 05 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male

    Street Address - 5046 S GREENWOOD AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-2806 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 773-684-4809 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 05 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Street Address - 6102 W GIDDINGS ST 1W City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60630-2930 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Gender - Male Street Address - 6102 W GIDDINGS ST APT 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60630-2930 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 6102 W GIDDINGS ST 1W City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60630-2930 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    34/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male

    Street Address - 7436 S EUCLID AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60649-3626 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Aug 93 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Street Address - 567 WESTLY N City, State, Zip - MOUNT PROSPECT IL 60056 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 08 - Feb 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Street Address - 610 E OLD WILLOW RD City, State, Zip - PROSPECT HEIGHTS IL 60070-1913 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 06 - Apr 07 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

    Street Address - 56 THORNTON RD City, State, Zip - NEEDHAM MA 02492-4330 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    35/63

    Date Record Verified - Jul 08 - Nov 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 1 MAIN ST

    City, State, Zip - WESTFORD MA 01886-2550 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 3660 RUE FORET APT 191

    City, State, Zip - FLINT MI 48532-2852 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 123 MAIN ST

    City, State, Zip - LANSING MI 48910 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 07 - Jul 07 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 4322 VALLEY DR NW

    City, State, Zip - ROCHESTER MN 55901-6691 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age - 23 Date of Birth - Sep 11, 1985 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    36/63

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 83775 BATES RD City, State, Zip - JACKSON NJ 08527 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 485-40-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Aug 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 5315 GORNIAK DR City, State, Zip - PARLIN NJ 08859-1315 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKGender - Male Street Address - 107 RAVENS CREST DR E City, State, Zip - PLAINSBORO NJ 08536-2488

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 625 WREN CT City, State, Zip - W HEMPSTEAD NY 11552-3815

    Probable Current Address - Yes Telephone - 516-505-2359 - EDT Telephone Accountholder - OBAMA BARACK Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    37/63

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 810 E 13TH AVE City, State, Zip - EUGENE OR 97401-3742 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Aug 08 - Dec 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 218 FLYERS PKWY City, State, Zip - PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 770-404-4044

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 410-00-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 08 - Aug 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 918 BAINBRIDGE ST City, State, Zip - PHILADELPHIA PA 19147 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 07 - Aug 07

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 505 CATHARINE ST City, State, Zip - PHILADELPHIA PA 19147-3009 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    38/63

    Date Record Verified - Apr 07 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 123 MAIN ST City, State, Zip - CHARLESTON SC 29464

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 08 - Sep 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 4034 BRICK CHURCH PIKE City, State, Zip - NASHVILLE TN 37207-1515

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 427-45-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1000 NW 33 AVE City, State, Zip - FORT WORTH TX 76180

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 675-54-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 08 - Oct 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 1000 33RD AVE NW City, State, Zip - FORT WORTH TX 76180

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 08 - Aug 08 *********************************************************************************************************

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    39/63

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    40/63

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - PO BOX 1236 City, State, Zip - PROVO UT 84603-1236 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 901-09-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 07 - Jan 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 111 WHITE HOUSE DR City, State, Zip - SALT LAKE CTY UT 84115 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 111 PENNSYLVANIA AVE City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON UT 84780 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 799-89-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jul 07 - Feb 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACKStreet Address - 8521 MIRANDA LN City, State, Zip - WOODBRIDGE VA 22191 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 08 - Apr 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    41/63

    Street Address - OBAMA LN City, State, Zip - FRANKLIN WI 53132 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -

    Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Jun 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HStreet Address - 1212 RAINTREE DR City, State, Zip - FORT COLLINS CO 80526-1871 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -

    Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 1034 S BROAD ST City, State, Zip - CARLINVILLE IL 62626-2122 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -

    Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 08 - Apr 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 180 N LA SALLE ST APT 2200N City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60601-2501 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 07 - Jun 07 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK H

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    42/63

    Gender - Male Street Address - 1440 E 52ND ST City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-4131 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -

    Social Security -Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 86 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 5450 S EAST VIEW PARK APT 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-5916 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 5450 EASTVIEW PARK S APT 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 5429 S HARPER AVE APT 1N City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-5548

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 86 *********************************************************************************************************

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    43/63

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 5324 S KIMBARK AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-5287 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 88 - Dec 90 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - N 1N City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615

    Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 88 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 54501 SE VW

    City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 000-684-4809 Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male

    Street Address - 5450 E VIEW PARK APT 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    44/63

    Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 54501 SE VIEW PARK

    City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male

    Street Address - 7436 S EUCLID City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60649 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK H

    Gender - Male Street Address - 123 NOWHERE ST City, State, Zip - VALPARAISO IN 46385 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HGender - Male Street Address - 295 HARVARD ST # 1505 City, State, Zip - CAMBRIDGE MA 02139-2382 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    45/63

    Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08 - Mar 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK H

    Gender - Male Street Address - 365 BROADWAY APT B1 City, State, Zip - SOMERVILLE MA 02145-2440 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HStreet Address - 4085 JACOBS LNDG City, State, Zip - SAINT CHARLES MO 63304-7495 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 999-88-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Oct 08 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HStreet Address - 1322 MAIN ST City, State, Zip - TRENTON MO 64683-1825 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HStreet Address - 123 ANYSTREET City, State, Zip - DALLAS TX 75254 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    46/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male

    Street Address - 300 MASSACHUSETTS AVE NW City, State, Zip - WASHINGTON DC 20001-2629 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Sep 05 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEIN

    Gender - Male Street Address - 180 N LA SALLE ST STE 2200 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60601-2610 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 07 - Jun 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - 5450 S EAST VIEW PARK # 1 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-5916 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jul 02 - Jul 06 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - 5046 S GREENWOOD AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-2806 Probable Current Address - Yes Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    47/63

    Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 05 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - 5046 S GREENWOOD AVE City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615-2806 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 773-684-4809 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 05 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - 54501 E VIEW PARK S City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60615 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 97 - Aug 04

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - PO BOX 49798 City, State, Zip - CHICAGO IL 60649 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 773-684-4809 - CDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 47 Date of Birth - Aug 04, 1961 Deceased - No

    Date Record Verified - Sep 99 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEINGender - Male Street Address - 365 BROADWAY APT B1 City, State, Zip - SOMERVILLE MA 02145-2440 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    48/63

    Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 042-68-xxxx Age - 119 Date of Birth - 1890 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK J SRStreet Address - 225 ROBINSON S City, State, Zip - STRATFORD TX 79084 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 09 - Jun 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK OBAMStreet Address - 5131 RFD City, State, Zip - LONG GROVE IL 60047 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 09 - Jul 09

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARACK USSENStreet Address - 1911 52ND AVE City, State, Zip - MOLINE IL 61265-6381 Probable Current Address - Yes Telephone - 309-736-1217 - CDT Telephone Accountholder - OBAMA BARACK USSEN Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1619 S BENTLEY AVE City, State, Zip - LOS ANGELES CA 90025-3586 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    49/63

    Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 08 - Apr 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1009 DIGITAL HWY City, State, Zip - LOS ANGELES CA 90045 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 999-61-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 05 - Apr 06 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1680 VIDEO DR City, State, Zip - LOS ANGELES CA 90045 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 999-99-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 05 - Mar 06 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 3600 ONEIDA ST City, State, Zip - DENVER CO 80207-1532 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 303-698-7659 - MDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 365-98-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08 - Mar 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 40 TRANSFER ST City, State, Zip - DENVER CO 80207 Probable Current Address - No Telephone - 303-231-4876 - MDT Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    50/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 07 - Mar 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 22 SCOTT RD

    City, State, Zip - SOUTHINGTON CT 06489 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 123 SOUTH DR City, State, Zip - MIAMI SPRINGS FL 33166-5921 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 606-34-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Aug 08 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 258 WHITE HOUSE RD City, State, Zip - GERMANTOWN MD 20872 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Nov 08 - Mar 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 348 6TH ST City, State, Zip - SOUTH AMBOY NJ 08879-1251 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    51/63

    Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jun 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAK

    Gender - Male Street Address - 3531 PROSPECT AVE City, State, Zip - SHADYSIDE OH 43947-1143 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 09 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1835 AUGUSTA DR City, State, Zip - JAMISON PA 18929-1085 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age - 18 Date of Birth - Feb 12, 1991 Deceased - No Date Record Verified -*********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 2700 ARDMORE ST City, State, Zip - SWISSVALE PA 15218 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 262-55-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Apr 09 - Jul 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1234 PIPER LN City, State, Zip - MANASSAS VA 20109 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 703-78-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    52/63

    Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 09 - May 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKStreet Address - 1234 HAPPY ST SE

    City, State, Zip - COVINGTON WA 98042 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 535-22-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - May 08 - Sep 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAK HStreet Address - 22 CREEK RD APT 27

    City, State, Zip - IRVINE CA 92604-4760 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 468-56-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Jan 09 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAK HStreet Address - 2 RETRIEVER CT

    City, State, Zip - COLUMBUS GA 31909-4815 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 256-65-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Dec 08 - Jun 09 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAK QUINCYStreet Address - 523 S EDGEWOOD AVE

    City, State, Zip - LA GRANGE IL 60525-6132 Probable Current Address - No Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Aug 04 - Dec 04

  • 8/14/2019 RHODES v McDONALD - 3 - MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order by Connie Rhodes - 03 2009-09-04 Motion for TRO

    53/63

    *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAKEStreet Address - 1313 LANE City, State, Zip - BOCA RATON FL 33433 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security - 123-45-xxxx Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Feb 08 - Aug 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAQ HStreet Address - 14300 NE 18TH ST City, State, Zip - VANCOUVER WA 98684-7807 Probable Current Address - No

    Telephone -Telephone Accountholder -Social Security -Age -Date of Birth -Deceased - No Date Record Verified - Mar 08 - Jul 08 *********************************************************************************************************

    Name - OBAMA, BARAQ HStreet Address - 143NE 18TH ST City, Sta