represents the without any -...

714

Upload: voxuyen

Post on 30-Apr-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates
Page 2: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

THISBOOKREPRESENTSTHEAUTHORSVIEWWITHOUTANYOFFICIALCONNECTIONTOWARRENBUFFETT

INVESTMENTLESSONS

Page 3: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

LEARNTFROMWARRENBUFFETTCENTURY

Page 4: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

EDUCATION

21ST

BYJAMIEMcINTYRE

Page 5: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

INVESTMENTLESSONSLEARNTFROMWARREN

Page 6: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BUFFETT

ByJamieMcIntyreFirstpublishedSeptember2012

Publishedby21stCenturyPublishing

Level9,222KingsWay,SouthMelbourne,Victoria,Australia3205

Page 7: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Phone:1800999270Fax:(03)84565973

NZFreeCall:0800893302FaxNZ:(09)3587340

Email:[email protected]

Web:www.21stcenturyeducation.com.au

www.21stcenturypublishing.com.au

Copyright2012,21stCenturyPublishing

Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthisbookmaybereproducedor

Page 8: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

transmittedinanyformorbyany

means,electronicormechanical,includingphotocopying,recordingorbyanyinformation

storageandretrievalsystem,withoutpriorpermissioninwritingfromthepublisher.

NationalLibraryofAustraliaCataloguing-in-Publicationentry:

McIntyre,Jamie

InvestmentLessonsTheWorldCanLearnFromWarrenBuffett

Page 9: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ISBN978-1-92-458-48-4

PrintedandboundinAustraliabyGriffinPress

ForWholesaleDiscountsorReorderse-mail

[email protected]

21stCenturyEducationHoldingsPtyLtd

Level9,222KingsWay,SouthMelbourneVIC3205

Phone1800999270Fax(07)35039021

Page 10: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Mail:POBox352,TewantinQLD4565

Disclaimer-ImportantInformation

Thisinformationhasbeenpreparedtoprovidegeneralinformationonly.Itisnotintendedto

taketheplaceofprofessionaladviceandyoushouldnottakeactiononspecificissuesrelying

solelyonthisinformation.Inpreparingthisinformation,wedidnottakeintoaccountthe

Page 11: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investmentobjectives,financialsituationorparticularneedsofanyindividualperson.

Beforemakinganinvestmentdecision,youneedtoconsider(withorwithouttheassistance

ofanadviser)whetherthisinformationisappropriatetoyourneeds,objectivesand

circumstances.

OtherbooksbyJamieMcIntyre.

The21stCenturyPublishingrange

Page 12: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ofbooksbyJamieMcIntyreincludes:

WHATIDIDN'TLEARNATSCHOOLBUTWISHIHAD

WHATIDIDN'TLEARNFROMMYFINANCIALPLANNERBUTWISHIHAD

WHATIDIDN'TLEARNFROMGOOGLEBUTWISHIHAD

WHATIDIDN'TLEARNFROMMYFINANCEBROKERBUTWISHIHAD

Page 13: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

THINKANDGROWRICHFORTHE21STCENTURY

TIMERICH-Howtohaveamillionairelifestyleinside12monthswithoutneedingtobecome

one

101LESSONSTHEWORLDCANLEARNFROMSTEVEJOBS

101LESSONSILEARNTFROMRICHARDBRANSON

WHATIDIDN’TLEARNFROM

Page 14: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

MYREALESTATEAGENTBUTWISHIHAD

INVESTMENTLESSONSTHEWORLDCANLEARNFROMWARRENBUFFETT

101WAYSTOIMPROVEAUSTRALIA

Page 15: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ContentsForeword

1.THEORACLEOFOMAHATheUltimateInvestor?BerkshireHathawaySharePriceGeicoBenjaminGraham

Page 16: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buy,notonoptimism,butonarithmeticSomeBuffettWitEthicsPersonalTransportationBuffettandMungeronMathematicsandTheories

2.WOODSTOCKFORCAPITALISTAMessagefromYourChairman

Page 17: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ShoppinginOmahaAnInsider’sImpressionofthe2012WoodstockforCapitalistsbyBerkshireHathawayDirector,BillGates.TheChairman'sLetterSomeBuffettMusingsfromHisChairmen’sLettersandAnnualMeetingsBuffettat5am

Page 18: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

3.THEBUFFETTINVESTMENTSTRATEGYWarrenBuffett'sShareSelectionMethodologyHowBuffettFindsLow-PricedValueBuffettOnIdentifyingGoodCompaniesBuffettonTechnologyCompanies

Page 19: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheImportanceofValuingAShareSomeMoreBuffettWisdomBerkshirevs.GoldBuffettinAustraliaBuffettonPeople

4.BUFFETTDEALSCoca-ColaBuffettonCoca-Cola.

Page 20: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

NebraskaFurnitureMartBuyInAdversityGoldmanSachsGeneralElectricSwissReinsuranceCoTheBuffettBudgetDowChemicalLubrizolCorporationNewspapersBuffett,MarsandWrigleys

Page 21: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BoysToys

5.THEBUFFETTLEGENDBuffettGainsControlofBerkshireHathawayTheWitandWisdomofWarrenBuffettDon'ttrytogetintouchwithmebycellphone

6.THEINVESTMENTPROCESS

Page 22: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheShareMarketSomeGeneralRulesforSuccessfulShareTradingValueInvestingMarkettrendsBullMarketsBearMarketsBearmarkethistoricexamplesStockTraderversusStockInvestor

Page 23: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

IndexFundsGrowthInvestingSociallyResponsibleInvestingMagicFormulaInvestingDartBoardMethodArbitragePricingTheory(APT)ScalpingSwingTradingContrarianInvesting

Page 24: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DowTheoryChartingElliottWavePrincipleSpeculationMarkTwainEffectTheTrader'sWorstEnemy-aoneleggedchairBuffettandShortSellingPersonalityandtheInvestmentProcess

Page 25: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

7.BUFFETTBETSBIGONHOUSINGDidyouknowtheU.S.housingmarkethassuffereditsbiggestcrashever,causingamajorfallindemandandprices?

8.FINALWORDSFROMTHESAGEOFOMAHASuccessionPlansProstateCancer

Page 26: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Conclusion

Page 27: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ForewordIhavehadthegoodfortunetostudy, meet and learn fromsome amazing individuals inmy 20-year search for theanswer to an overridingquestion:

Why is it that people cangrowupinthesamecountry,have the same opportunities,even be from the samefamily, go to similar schools

Page 28: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and live in the sameeconomy-yetsomeexcelandoutperform financially, whileothers, often equally capableand intelligent, failmiserablyinlife?

The search for the answer tothis question has led me toseek out outstanding rolemodelsandfindextraordinarymentors that have helpedshapemylifeandenabledme

Page 29: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

to outperform in many areasofmy life includingbusinessandinvesting.

Modelling a billionairewon'texactly guarantee that youwillbecomeoneyourself,butit could just be enough tomakeyouamillionairemanytimesoverifthatiswhatyoudesire.

I've found that true in myownlife.

Page 30: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Mydesiretoalwayslearnandimprove ledme to study andobserve arguably theworld’smost successful investor ofall time- Warren Buffett,dubbedtheOracleofOmaha,aninvestorwithanincredibleandalmostuncannyabilitytorecognize hidden value andopportunities in businessesthatothersoftenlack.

Buffett is the 81 year old

Page 31: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Chairman and CEO of theconglomerate BerkshireHathaway (NYSE: BRK-A,BRK-B).He’s also the third-richest person in the world,with a fortune that ForbesmagazineestimatedatUS$44billioninMarch2012.

His success with BerkshireHathaway,Geico, CocaColaand American Express andcountless other companies

Page 32: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

has inspired many thousandsof investors to emulate histrading strategies andmethodsandfollowhiseverymove.

At the time of writing this,the share (stock) price ofBerkshire Hathaway Inc.(BRK-A) on the New YorkStockExchange(NYSE)wasanincredible$127,175.00pershare.228sharesweretraded

Page 33: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

that day and share price rose0.03% on the previous day’strading. That doesn’t soundmuch, but that small riserepresentedagainof$375.00pershare.

This gave BerkshireHathaway a marketcapitalization of $210.47billion and a cash hoard thatfluctuates (mostly whenBuffett finds something to

Page 34: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

buy), but was estimatedaround $40 billion in earlyAugust2012.

InAugust1990theBerkshireHathaway share price wasaround$6,400.WhenBuffettstarted buying shares inBerkshire Hathaway in the1960‘s they were trading ataround$12.

Despite his vast wealth,Buffett is a very down to

Page 35: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

earth person with awonderfully droll sense ofhumour and many examplesof his humour is reflected inthis book. Buffett has mademost of his gains since theearly 1970s by continuing todevelop as an investor andembracing growth andbusiness quality. Buffettunderstands and appreciates(with the help of BerkshireHathaway vice-chairman

Page 36: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Charlie Munger) theopportunities thatgrowthcanbring, especially when thatgrowth requires littleadditional capital and isprotected by a sustainablecompetitive advantage,something Buffett likes tocall a business’ ‘moat’.Today,Buffetwouldn’tbe inthe market for a lot ofbusinesses he once singledoutasexamplesofa‘superior

Page 37: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

business’ as theyare just toosmall. That’s where smallinvestorshaveanopportunity– to invest in businesses thatarejust toosmallforBuffett,but have characteristicsBuffett might appreciate.Besides size and a statedasking price (for whole-company acquisitions)Buffett has previously saidthat he looks for businessesthathave:

Page 38: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Demonstrated consistentearning power (futureprojections are of no interestto us, neither are“turnaround” situations).Businesses earning goodreturns on equity whileemploying little or no debt.Management in place (wecan’t supply it). Simplebusinesses (if there’s lots oftechnology, we won’tunderstand it). With this

Page 39: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

book, Investment LessonsLearnt FromWarrenBuffett,my goal is to educate andempower the investor andentrepreneur within you toexcel to greater heights andrecognizeopportunities.

WarmestRegards,

JamieMcIntyre,September2012

CEO21stCenturyEducation

Page 40: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1.THEORACLEOFOMAHAI got interested [inbusiness] when I was

Page 41: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

sevenorthereabouts.Iwastedmytimebeforethat.

WarrenBuffett

Page 42: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheUltimateInvestor?TheOracleofOmaha-WarrenBuffett

Did you ever imagine that aUS$10,000 investment inBerkshireHathaway in1965,the yearWarrenBuffett tookcontrol of it, would grow tobe worth nearly US$44million, as estimated by

Page 43: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Forbes,byearly2012?

Incomparison,US$10,000inthe S&P (Standard & Poors)500 would have grown toonlyaboutUS$500,000.

Whetheryoulikehimornot,Buffett's investment strategyis arguably the mostsuccessful ever. With asustained compound returnthis high for so long, thereisn’t a doubt that Buffett's

Page 44: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

legend has swelled tomythical proportions. Buthow did he do it?Known as‘the Oracle of Omaha’,Buffett is Chairman ofBerkshire Hathaway andarguably thegreatest investorof all time. His wealthfluctuates with theperformance of the market,but for the last few years hehasbeenreportedtobeworthbetween US$30 billion and

Page 45: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

$44 billion, making him thesecond richest man in theworld. Some may think thatBuffett is a lucky investorwith a good touch. Eventhough there is some truth tothat, he and his partnerCharlie Munger take greatcare in carrying out detailedresearch before making anyinvestment.Buffett isavalueinvestor. His companyBerkshire Hathaway is

Page 46: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

basically a holding companyfor his investments. Some ofthemajorholdingshehashadat some point or the otherincludeCoca-Cola,AmericanExpress and Gillette. Criticspredicted an end to hissuccess when hisconservative investing stylemeant missing out on thedotcom bull market. Ofcourse, he had the last laughafter the dotcom crash

Page 47: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

because,onceagain,Buffett'stime tested strategy provedsuccessful. Value investorslookforsecuritieswithpricesthat are unjustifiably lowbasedontheirintrinsicworth.When discussing stocks,determining intrinsic valuecanbeabit trickyas there isno universally accepted wayto obtain that figure.Generally, intrinsic worth isestimated by analysing a

Page 48: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

company's fundamentals.Like bargain hunters, valueinvestors seek underpricedyet beneficial and highquality products. In otherwords, the value investorsearches for stocks that theybelieve are undervalued bythe market. Like the bargainhunter, the value investortries to find valuable itemsthat are not recognized assuchby themajorityofother

Page 49: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

buyers.

Buffett takes this valueinvestingapproachtoanotherlevel. Many value investorsaren't supporters of theefficient market hypothesis,but they do trust that themarketwilleventuallystarttofavour those quality stocksthat were, for a time,undervalued. Buffett,however, doesn't think on

Page 50: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

these terms. He isn'tconcerned with the supplyanddemandintricaciesofthestockmarket.Infact,he'snotreally concerned with theactivities of the stockmarketat all.This implication is theparaphrase of his famousquote: "In the short term themarket is a popularitycontest; in the long term it isa weighing machine."Hechooses stocks solely on the

Page 51: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

basisoftheiroverallpotentialasacompanylookingateachas a whole. Holding thesestocks as a long-term play,Buffett seeks ownership andnot capital gain in qualitycompanies extremely capableofgeneratingearnings.WhenBuffett investsinacompany,he is not concerned withwhether the market willeventually recognize itsworth; he is concerned with

Page 52: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

how well that company canmakemoneyasabusiness.

Warren Buffett is withoutquestion the most successfulinvestor of our time (andpossibly of all times). Hiscompanies employ around260,000 people. Hisincredibly smart dealmakingabilities coupled with hiscreative, cheerful, down toearth and droll personality

Page 53: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

allowed him to achievesuccesslikenoother.Heisalotmorethanashareinvestorwho buys, holds and sellsshares in the hope ofreceiving regular dividendsand subsequently making aprofit by selling those shareswhen their value increases.Some of his incredibly smartand complex deals are theenvyofinvestorsandbankersall over theworld, especially

Page 54: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

hisdealsfollowingtheglobalfinancial crisis where hisinvestmentsproppedupsomemajor US businesses. Thesedeals delivered him hugereturns in just a few yearswith minimal risk at a timewhen other financiers wereducking for cover. Thisreminds me of - andepitomizes - one of Buffett’swell known quotes, “Wesimply attempt to be fearful

Page 55: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

whenothersaregreedyandtobe greedy only when othersare fearful.” His investmenttastes are an affirmation ofthe literal value ofcommonsense. Rule NumberOne is: "Never losemoney".And Rule Number Two?"Never forget Rule NumberOne". He invests incompanieswithbusinessessosimple"evenIcanunderstandthem", with economics and

Page 56: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

management that he likes.That means no dot coms.Buffettcomesoveraslikableandhumble:"I’manaccidentof time and geography".Buffett has simple tastes.Helivesinanunassuminghousein unassuming Omaha. Helikes steak sandwiches, hashbrownsandDairyQueenice-cream.Hegoes to thebarberin the basement of hiscorporate headquarters. He

Page 57: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

drives an old car, carries abatteredbriefcaseanddoesn’tdress expensively because"expensive suits look cheapon me". Buffett is aremarkableman, a legendaryinvestor with a moralcompass and buckets ofhumility,whorealizesthatheand long-time businesspartner Charlie Munger areluckymen."WewereborninAmerica, had terrific parents

Page 58: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

who saw thatwe got a goodeducation,enjoyedwonderfulfamiliesandgreathealth,andcame equipped with a'business'gene that allowsustoprosperinamannerhugelydisproportionate to thatexperienced by many peoplewho contribute as much ormore to our society's well-being."

Despite (or perhaps because

Page 59: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

of ) that grounded approachto life, Buffett has enjoyedstratospheric investmentsuccess. In the 47 years hehas been at the helm ofBerkshire Hathaway, thecompanyhasgrownitsassetsat21.1percentayear,alittlemore than twice the 10.3percent annual gain in theS&P500.

The power of compounding

Page 60: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

means that while the USbenchmark index has grownby 6,840 percent over thatperiod; Berkshire's bookvalue has soared by 400,863percent.Ithasrisenfrom$12a share to $125,175. In 47years, Buffett has failed tobeat the market on only sixoccasions. It was Buffett’sinterest in insurance that ledtotheriseandfinancialfameof himself and Berkshire

Page 61: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathaway. The insuranceindustry is notoriously toughbut under Buffett, thecompany has become notonlyasuccessful

share investor, but a leadingproviderofinsurance.

AtthattimeBuffettstruckupa friendship with Charles TMunger, a lawyer andinvestor. Munger eventuallyjoined Buffett at Berkshire

Page 62: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathaway as his Vice-Chairman, alter ego, andfriend. Buffett is always thefirst to acknowledge thecontribution that CharlieMunger has made toBerkshireHathaway.

Under Buffett and Munger,Berkshire Hathaway hasbecome an investment giantthatwhollyownsanumberofsuccessful companies that

Page 63: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

include, Geico Corporation,Nebraska FurnitureMart andSee’s Candy Shops. WarrenBuffett, the man, is just ashard to define as WarrenBuffett, the investor. Heprojects a homespunfrugality, but one suspectsthat he plays his personalityas close to the chest as hedoes with his investmentsecrets.Healwaysclaimsthatit is his partner, Charlie

Page 64: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Munger, who keeps his feetplanted firmly in the ground.Buffett was a member ofPresident Obama's economicadvisory team during theGlobal Financial Crisis. Hehas become a legend and isgenerally ranked first in astellar cast of Americaninvestors along with mentor,Benjamin Graham. Buffett'sbiggest investments(companieshedoesn'townin

Page 65: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

their entirety) includeAmerican Express, WellsFargo,Procter&GambleandCoca-Cola. These fourbusinesses, he notes, werefounded in 1850, 1852, 1837and1886respectively."Start-upsarenotourgame".

Page 66: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BerkshireHathawaySharePriceOn10August2012theshare(stock) price of BerkshireHathaway Inc. (BRK-A) onthe New York StockExchange (NYSE) was anincredible $127,175.00 pershare.228sharesweretradedthat day and share price rose0.03% on the previous day’strading. Even though it

Page 67: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

doesn’tsoundlikemuch,thatsmall rise represented a gainof $375.00 per share. Thisgave Berkshire Hathaway amarket capitalization of$210.47 billion. In the yearup until then the share pricehad ranged $98,952.00 -$129,040.00. InAugust1990the share price was around$6,400.WhenBuffett startedbuying shares in BerkshireHathawayinthe1960‘s, they

Page 68: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

were trading at around $12.Based on this share price,Berkshire Hathaway had aP/E (price to earnings) of18.03 and earnings per shareof $7,054.51. Buffett hasn'tpaid out a dividend toBerkshire shareholders since1967 as he believes he canreinvest the money and gethigherreturns.“It'snotinthebestinterestofshareholders.”

Page 69: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

GeicoBuffett’s involvement withGeico is a good example ofhis investment methodology.Geico, the overnmentEmployees InsuranceCompany, took life in 1936whenaTexanbythenameofLeo Goodwin saw potentialin providing low costinsurance to governmentemployees who statistically

Page 70: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

had lower claims than thepublic as a whole. Goodwincorrectly calculated thatdirect marketing to potentialcustomers would producemore business at less cost.The venture was successfuland in 1947, BenjaminGraham’s investment trusttooka50percentshareinthebusiness. Grahamsubsequently floated it as apublic company allocating

Page 71: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

shares to investors in histrust. He took shares forhimself and retained hisshareholding until his death.Buffet’s initial interest inGeico sparked in 1943whilehe was still a fledglinginvestment consultant.Apparently, because of hismentor Graham’sinvolvement with Geico,Buffetdecided toconsider it.He visited the company’s

Page 72: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

offices only to find themclosed. The night watchmantold him that there wassomeone still working lateand agreed to takeBuffett intomeethim.Thelateworkerturned out to be LorimarDavidson, who eventuallyended up running thecompany.BuffettinterrogatedDavidson for several hoursandbothmenwereimpressedby each other. Because of

Page 73: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

these discussions, Buffett’sinvestmentpartnershiptookasmallholdinginGeico,whichiteventuallysolddown.

By 1974, Geico was introuble. The government hadbrought in no-liabilityinsurance in some areas, thecompany had extended itsclientele to higher riskcategories,andtherehadbeeninadequate provisions for

Page 74: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

future claims. In 1976, itannounced a loss of $126million and the company’sshares, which had traded ashigh as $42, were down tojust under $5. The 1976AnnualGeneralMeetingwasa near riot with angryshareholders challenging themanagement. By then, theshares were down to about$2. Therewas then a changeincompanymanagementwith

Page 75: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

J. J. Byrnes taking over thekeyrole.Byrnesmadedrasticchanges by cancelling high-risk policies, laying staff offand moving office. Despitethese changes, the regulatoryauthorities were hoveringover the company’s nearcarcass. Buffett had alwayskept his eye on the companyand believed that despite itsproblems,thecompany’scorebusiness was sound. The

Page 76: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

company’s premiums alsoattracted Buffett. Insurancecompanies receive premiumsagainst the possibility thatthey may have to pay outclaimsinthefuture.Providedthe company follows soundactuarialpractices andmakesadequate provision forclaims, this gives it largeamounts of cash to invest inprofit making ventures. Thisis what Buffett calls the

Page 77: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

‘float’. He saw this as anopportunity to provide cashresources to buy businessesandinvestinshares.

BuffettarrangedtomeetwithByrnes through anintermediary, KatherineGraham,theproprietoroftheWashingtonPost.Buffettwasapparently impressed enoughto buy 500,000 shares in thecompany through Berkshire

Page 78: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathaway with a standingorder to buy more. Thecompany started to improve,andmanaged tooffload a lotof its reinsurance risk.Salomon Bros came to theparty with an underwrittenpreferred stock issue (ofwhich Berkshire took 25percent) and Buffettintercededwith the insuranceregulators to ensure thatGeico kept its licenses. Six

Page 79: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

months later, the shares hadrisento$8.Graham,whohadby then retired, must havebeenhappyandproudthathisprotégé had intervened.Overthe years, Geico went fromstrength to strength. Buffettalwaysseizedtheopportunityto increase the Berkshireshareholding. However,businessstartedtodropoffinthe 1980s and by 1994; thesharepricehadfallenagain.

Page 80: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett grabbed his chanceand bought out the othershareholders for a total priceof2.3billiondollars.Geicoisnow a huge and profitableinsurer.ItsvaluetoBerkshirehowever,hasnotmerelybeenits ability to make goodreturns from insuranceactivities. Instead it’s been a‘float’ or ‘cash cow’ toprovide funds that enableBuffett and Berkshire to

Page 81: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

acquire good businesses andshareholdings. According toBuffett, “the Geico expenseratio runs about 17 percent,wecouldrunaslowas11or12 percent if we didn't wantto grow. And manycompanies operate atanywhere from 25 to 30percent. Andwe're also veryefficient because as we getscaleadvantages,weevengetthat in terms of the loss

Page 82: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

adjustmentcostsaswell.It'saveryefficientoperation.”

Page 83: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BenjaminGrahamFor readers who may beunawareofBenjaminGraham(1894-1976), he was aBritish-born Americaneconomist and professionalinvestor. He is considered tobethefirstproponentofvalueinvesting, an investmentapproach he began teachingatColumbiaBusinessSchoolin 1928 and subsequently

Page 84: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

refined with David Doddthrough various editions oftheir famous book SecurityAnalysis.

Buffett, who credits Grahamas grounding him with asound intellectual investmentframework, described him asthe second most influentialperson in his life after hisown father. BenjaminGrahamhadaphilosophythat

Page 85: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investment policy can bereduced to three simplewords: "Margin of Safety" -the price at which a shareinvestment can be boughtwith minimal downside risk.The important point here isthatthemarginofsafetypriceis not the same as the pricethat an investor calculates ashare’sintrinsicworthtobe.

Aninvestormaycalculatethe

Page 86: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

intrinsic value of a share bydiffering methods and willeventually come up with aprice that he or she believesrepresentsgoodbuyingvalue.Graham had his methods ofcalculating intrinsic value,Warren Buffett has his, andother successful investorshave theirs. Grahamacknowledges, however, thatcalculations can sometimesbe wrong, or that external

Page 87: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

events may take place toaffect the value of the share.Itcannotalwaysbepredicted.Forsuchreasons,theinvestormusthaveamarginofsafety-an inbuilt factor that allowsfor these possibilities. ForBenjamin Graham, thebenchmarkforcalculatingthemargin of safety was theinterestratepayableforprimequality bonds. As Grahamwrote in an era when prime

Page 88: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

bonds were much moreprominent,itismorepracticalnow to adopt, the rate ofreturn of government bondsasthebenchmark.ApparentlyBuffet follows that too.Graham then uses acomparative approach. If therisk in two forms ofinvestment is the same, thenit must be better to take theinvestment with the higherreturn. Conversely, an

Page 89: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investment with higher risk,suchasshares,shouldhaveahigher return whencalculating the margin ofsafety. If we modify theexample Benjamin Grahamusesinhisbook,wecantakea share investment that isyielding 10 percent earnings.For example, company A isearning 90 cents per shareandissellinginthemarketat$10. If the rate of return on

Page 90: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

government bonds is 5percent, then the share isyielding annually an excessof5percent.

Over a period of ten years,theexcessyieldwillbeabout50 percent, which, inGraham’s opinion, may beenough, if the shareinvestment is wisely chosenin the first place. Of course,thetotalmarginofsafetywill

Page 91: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

fluctuate depending upon thequality of the shareinvestment. In spite of thatthingscangowrong.Grahambelieveshowever,that,withadiversified portfolio of 20 ormore representative shareinvestments, the margin oferror approach will, overtime, produce satisfactoryresults.

According to Benjamin

Page 92: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Graham, “To have a trueinvestment, there must be atruemargin of safety. And atrue margin of safety is onethat can be demonstrated byfigures, by persuasivereasoning,andbyreferencetoabodyofactualexperience".

Graham had become wellknownduringthe1920's.Atatime when the rest of theworld was approaching the

Page 93: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investment arena as a giantgameofroulette,hesearchedfor stocks that were soinexpensive that they werealmost completely devoid ofrisk.OneofhisbestcallswastheNorthernPipeLine,anoiltransportation companymanagedbytheRockefellers.Thestockwas tradingat$65ashare,butafterstudyingthebalance sheet, Grahamrealizedthatthecompanyhad

Page 94: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

bond holdings worth $95 forevery share. The valueinvestor tried to convincemanagement to sell theportfolio, but they refused.Shortlythereafter,hewagedaproxywarandsecuredaspoton the Board of Directors.The company sold its bondsand paid a dividend in theamount of $70 per share.When he was 40-years old,Ben Graham published

Page 95: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Security Analysis, one of thegreatest works ever pennedon the stock market. At thetime, it was risky; investingin equities had become ajoke. The Dow Jones hadfallen from 381.17 to 41.22over the course of three tofouryearsfollowingthecrashof 1929. It was around thistime that Graham came upwith theprincipleof intrinsicbusinessvalue-ameasureof

Page 96: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

a business's true worth thatwas completely and totallyindependent of the stockprice. Using intrinsic value,investorscoulddecidewhatacompany was worth andmake investment decisionsaccordingly. His subsequentbook, The IntelligentInvestor, which Buffett calls"the greatest book oninvesting ever written",introduced the world to Mr.

Page 97: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Market - the best investmentanalogy in history. Throughhis simple yet profoundinvestment principles, BenGraham became an idyllicfigure and mentor to thetwenty-one year old WarrenBuffett.

Page 98: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buy,notonoptimism,butonarithmeticIn many of my books Imention the importance ofhaving a mentor. Even theworld’smostsuccessfulsharetrader,WarrenBuffett,admitshaving Benjamin Graham asamentor.

In The Intelligent Investor,

Page 99: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Graham sums up hisinvestment philosophy bysaying that an intelligentinvestor must be "businesslike"inapproach.Investingincompany shares is just likeowning a share in a businessenterprise. Thus, theinvestment must beapproached as if one werebuying a business or apartnership. According toGraham there are four

Page 100: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

guidingprinciples:

1. Know the business. Theinvestor needs to gainknowledgeaboutthebusinessor businesses conducted bythe company in which theypropose to invest i.e. what itsells,howitoperates,whatisthe competitive environment,what are the threats andopportunities and thestrengthsandweaknesses.An

Page 101: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investor, who bought a fruitshop, or a shoe factory,without investigating theproducts, and just knowingthem, would be foolish. Thesame applies to shareinvestment. An investor whodoes not understand thebusiness should not beinvestinginit.

2. Know who runs thebusiness. An investor, who

Page 102: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

cannot operate the businessforhimselforherself,needsamanager.This is thepositionoftheaverageshareinvestor,who owns a share of anenterprise that is run byothers. The owner of abusiness in this positionwould want a manager whowill manage the businesscompetently, efficiently andhonestly. The share investorshould not be satisfied with

Page 103: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

less. Unless the investorbelieves, through soundresearch, that thecompany ismanaged efficiently,competently and honestly, inthe best interests of theshareholders, the investmentshouldnotbemade.

3. Invest for pro!ts. Aninvestor would not normallybuy a business that did not,onproper research, appear to

Page 104: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

have reasonable expectationsof producing good profitsover time. Share investorsshould take the sameapproachandbuy,asGrahamsays, "not on optimism, butonarithmetic".

4. Have con!dence. Grahamencourages investors toproperly research theirinvestmentsandactonitonlyif they believe their

Page 105: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investment judgment to besound. He cautions investorsin this position againstlistening to others. "You areneither right nor wrong justbecause the crowd disagreeswith you. You are right [orwrong]becauseyourdataandreasoning are right [orwrong]."

Page 106: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SomeBuffettWitWhen asked by oneshareholder,"Howwouldyoulike to be remembered in 50years?"WarrenBuffettdrollyreplied,"Foroldage."

InMay2012onSquawkBoxTV a reporter asked Buffett,“Warren, why don't you joinme and buy some cows? Imean, I like your farmlandbut, you know, you're in

Page 107: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Nebraska, you love steak. Imean, we can have leather,wecanhavemanure,wecanhave milk, and we can havemeat, cheese. We'll employpeople...” The then 81-yearold Buffett drolly replied(after starting the show at5am, the day after theBerkshire AGM) “Well, youcanhavethemanure,I'lltakethe meat.” “Charlie's(Munger) pretty Old

Page 108: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Testament.” “He (CharlieMunger)hasacolourfulwayof expressing himself.Sometimeshedoesthataboutme,too.”“Whenagirlhangsup on me once, I try again.That hasn't been toosuccessful, though,historically.Ihopemybattingaverage is better withcompanies.” “If McDonald'slowers the price ofhamburgers today, the fact I

Page 109: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

paid more for one on Fridaydoesnot,youknow,I'mevenmoreenthusedaboutbuyingahamburgertoday.”

Buffett did an interview inearly 2012 where he wasaskedwithwhomhe had themostdifficulttimetalkingto?He came up with aninteresting answer. “Well, itwas Jackie Kennedy andPrincessDi. Iwas in a room

Page 110: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

alone one timewith PrincessDi at a party. Somehow wefoundourselvesinthislibraryand I, in 15 minutes, I don'tthink I could take it. I hadtrouble remembering myname, I couldn't think ofanything to say, and itwasatotal disaster. “But the moreinterestingthingis,Ionlymether one other time. It was apartyatKayGraham'shouse,which was where the first

Page 111: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

party was, and it was veryshortlybeforeherdeath.

“Theyputmeacrossthetableafter my previous disaster.But she was sitting betweenBarry Diller and TeddyForstmann. And after shedied a few weeks later, allthese papers called and said,`Whatdidshe talkabout thatevening?' I didn't tell them,butIwilltellyoutodaythata

Page 112: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

comment shemade, which hwasabsolutelytrue,andIcansee Barry and Teddy's facesasshesaidit.

“She had been at the WhiteHouse that day and she saidthat Bill Clinton was thesexiest man alive. And Ididn't ask her who the leastsexy guy in the world alivewas. Iwasafraid Imightgetmyplayinthere.“Hehasnot

Page 113: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

heard this before. So he'sprobably having a good daytoday.Inevertoldhimthis.”

Page 114: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

EthicsAt one Berkshire HathawayAGMamoviekickedoff themeeting that included a clipof Buffett testifying during ascandal two decades ago atSalomon Brothers, aninvestment bank inwhich hehad just become ashareholder and boardmember. In it, Buffett said,"Lose money for the firm, I

Page 115: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

will be understanding; lose ashred of reputation for thefirm, I will be ruthless"—arule he said is generallyapplied at Berkshire. ThisparticularAGMcameshortlyafter the fall ofDavidSokol,who left Berkshire abruptly,after admitting to buyingshares in Lubrizol shortlybefore he (successfully)recommended that Buffettbuy it. "Inexplicable" was

Page 116: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett's description ofSokol's behavior, especiallysince early in his Berkshirecareer Mr Sokol hadselflesslygivenachunkofhislikely bonus to a colleaguethat was far bigger than hestood to gain from hisLubrizolshares.

Buffett had identified Sokolas one of his potentialsuccessors, and enthused

Page 117: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

about him recently in thelatestBerkshireannualreport.Buffett said he mishandledthe announcement of Sokol'sdeparture, not just by issuingapoorlywordedpressreleasethat failed to sufficientlycommunicate his "outrage".He also predicted that the"damning facts" providedboth to the public and theSEC will "cause all sorts ofproblems for him in years to

Page 118: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

come"—mentioning "insidertrading" a few times but notmaking any specificallegationagainstSokol,whohassaidhetoldMrBuffettinadvance that he owned someLubrizolshares.

Page 119: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

PersonalTransportationIn 1986, Buffett bought aused Falcon aircraft for$850,000.Ashehadbecomeincreasingly recognizable, itwas no longer comfortablefor him to fly commercially.Adjusting to that idea of theluxurywas hard for him, buthe loved the jet immensely.Partly, his passion for jets

Page 120: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

eventually led him topurchaseExecutiveJet in the90's.

Page 121: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettandMungeronMathematicsandTheoriesThiswhatWarrenBuffettandCharlieMungermadeclearabouttheircompletedisdainfortheuseofhigher-ordermathematicsinfinance:

"Thereissomuchthat'sfalseandnuttyinmoderninvestingpracticeandmodern

Page 122: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investmentbanking,thatifyoujustreducedthenonsense,that'sagoalyoushouldreasonablyhopefor,"Mr.Buffettsaid.Regardingcomplexcalculationsusedtovaluepurchases,hesaid:"Ifyouneedtouseacomputeroracalculatortomakethecalculation,youshouldn'tbuyit."

Mungersaid:"Someofthe

Page 123: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

worstbusinessdecisionsI'veeverseenarethosewithfutureprojectionsanddiscountsback.Itseemslikethehighermathematicswithmorefalseprecisionshouldhelpyou,butitdoesn't.Theyteachthatinbusinessschoolsbecause,well,they'vegottodosomething."

Buffettsaid:"Ifyoustandupinfrontofabusinessclass

Page 124: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

andsayabirdinthehandisworthtwointhebush,youwon'tgettenure....Highermathematicsmaybedangerousandleadyoudownpathwaysthatarebetterleftuntrod."

Page 125: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

2.WOODSTOCKFORCAPITALISTYoushouldinvestinabusiness that even a

Page 126: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

fool can run, becausesomedayafoolwill.

WarrenBuffettEvery year a number ofAustraliansmaketheirwaytoOmaha, Nebraska in the USinwhat isvirtuallyanannualpilgrimage.Peoplewhomakethis trip all have a commonbond-theyarefundmanagersor people employed in the

Page 127: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

finance industry. The reasonthey travel to Nebraska is tolistentotheOracleofOmaha,Warren Buffett, speak at theannualgeneralmeetingofhiscompany, BerkshireHathaway -Woodstock forCapitalists-andenjoyhiswitandwisdom.

AhandfulofAustralianswhotravel there are joined by upto 45,000 other people who

Page 128: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

travel there for the samereason. A few years ago aSydney investment broker,IanDarlingtravelledthereforthe meeting and theproduction of a one-hourdocumentary on the trip thatwas later screened on ABCTV. Darling admits thatBuffett is his hero: a manwho invests successfully,ethically, and with a down-homefolksystyle.

Page 129: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Eachyearthefaithfulfromallover the world make thispilgrimage to Omaha,Nebraska, a small mid-westerntown,anxioustohearthe wisdom of their humbleguru. It is an eventsurrounded by ritual,adulationandafairdegreeofcultworship.Butthisisnotagathering of a religious sect;itisashareholdersmeeting.Itisamillionaire'sconvention-

Page 130: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

probablythelargestgatheringofprivatewealthatonetime,anywhere in the world. Theprice of entry is a stake inBerkshire Hathaway, whichcosts around $127,175 for aclass A share, though meremortalsarenowabletobuyaclassBshareforaround$80.That deeply discounted priceis thanks to the stock splitBuffetthasengineeredofthatshareclasstohelpsmooththe

Page 131: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

logistics of his purchase ofthe Burlington NorthernSantaFerailroadafewyearsago.

Theirguru,WarrenBuffett,isan unassuming man in hisseventies.Healsohappenstobeworthbetween$30billionand $44 billion, making himoneof the richestmen in theworld. His partner, CharlieMunger, also has a heroic

Page 132: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

status amongst thousands ofdevotedfollowers.

The meeting is held in aconcert hall, and theatmosphere is somewherebetween a rock concert andthe Sermon on the Mount.People queue outside from3.15amtobesureofagoodview of Buffett and hisvicechairman, CharlieMunger.

Page 133: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

At the 2012 annual meetingBuffettandMungeransweredquestions from attendees atthe convention centre, threebusinessanalysts,andapanelofthreejournalists.Icounted67 questions for five and ahalf hours. InAustraliamostannual meetings are stagemanaged to avoid questionsand I venture to say therewould not be one AustralianCEO who takes uncensored

Page 134: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

questions for as long asBuffett and Munger arepreparedto.

Many politicians for instancewilltakeonlythreequestionsat a press conference. Thereare quasi-religious overtonesabout much that goes on inOmaha. The audiences hangon their every word, andjostle to be photographedwith their heroes. They

Page 135: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

converge on his favouriterestaurant and ice-creamoutlet. They buy souvenirsfeaturing Buffett’s face, anddisplay dollar–bills bearingBuffett’sautographasthoughthey were holy relics.Woodstock for Capitalistsprovides wonderfulmarketing opportunities forall the companies BerkshireHathaway has a stake in. A28-page booklet is provided

Page 136: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

with maps and informationincludingthetimeswhenstallholdersofferdiscounts.Thesecompanies - around 40 ofthem - set up shop in thefoyertodisplayandselltheirwares. For instance,Berkshire HathawaysubsidiaryBrooksSportssellsa $110pair of running shoesthat feature a cartoon imageofBuffettonthem.

Page 137: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Diamonds from Berkshire'sBorsheims jeweller, foodfrom its Dairy Queen,insurance from Geico, andCherryCoke(oneofBuffett'sfavourites) are just a few ofthe items available amongstothers that include aircraftandhomes.

Page 138: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

AMessagefromYourChairmanThe28-pagebookletprovidedto those attending the AGMalsocontainsamessagefromthe Chairman, WarrenBuffett.“Financialjournalistsfrom organizationsrepresenting newspapers,magazinesandtelevisionwillparticipate in the question-and-answer period, asking

Page 139: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Charlieandmequestionsthatshareholders have submittedbye-mail.

“From the questionssubmitted, each journalistwill choose the dozen or soheorshedecidesarethemostinteresting and important.“This year we are adding asecond panel of threefinancialanalystswhofollowBerkshire. This group will

Page 140: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

bring their own Berkshirespecific questions andalternate with journalists andthe audience. “NeitherCharlienorIwillgetsomuchas a clue about the questionstobeasked.

“Weknowthejournalistsandanalystswillpicksometoughones and that’s the way welike it.“We will have adrawingat8:15ateachofthe

Page 141: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

13 microphones for thoseshareholders wishing to askquestions themselves. At themeeting, I will alternate thequestions asked by thejournalists and analysts withthose from the winningshareholders.”

Page 142: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ShoppinginOmahaAt a TV interview themorning after the 2012Berkshire AGM, aninterviewer said to Buffett,“Thirty-five thousandshareholders descended onOmaha this weekend,Warren, and they did a littlebitofshopping.”

Buffettresponded:“Yeah,it'sinterestingwhenyoumention

Page 143: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

35,000 because our furniturestore in the one weeksurrounding the meeting,whichwillendtoday,willdo$35 million of business. Sowe've done $1,000 ofbusiness for every man,woman, and child thatattended the meeting. Andthat's almost 10 percenthigher than we've donebefore. When a retail storesdoes $35 million in a week,

Page 144: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

that is a lot of business andthe shareholders were outgettingbargains.”

“Thatsaysanawfullotabouttheshareholders,thenumberswhoarecomingin,butitsayssomething about consumers,too,” the interviewer said.“Oh,sure.Youknow,they'reinadifferentmoodthantheywere a few years ago.And Isaw that at the jewellery

Page 145: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

store, too. I sold jewelry fortwoandaquarterhoursandIcouldn't write tickets fastenough.CrazyWarrenwasinhiselement.”

“It's a special thing, though,when people are buying itfrom you. There's a little bitmoreofaclamorthanmaybeeverydaythat theyseethat.”“They get a better price,”Buffettsaidwithasmile.

Page 146: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

AnInsider’sImpressionofthe2012WoodstockforCapitalistsbyBerkshireHathawayDirector,BillGates.Thislastweekend(thefirstinMay 2012, I attended theBerkshire Hathaway annualmeeting in Omaha. Oftencalled Woodstock for

Page 147: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Capitalists, this year’smeeting drew 35,000investors and their families,who came to learn fromWarren Buffett and CharlieMunger and participate in aninstitution unique in theworld of business. I’ve beenon the board of BerkshireHathaway since late 2004,this is my eighth annualmeeting, and I think it wasone of the best. The

Page 148: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

centrepiece of themeeting isthe question-and-answersession that Charlie andWarren host. For five-and-a-half hours, they answeredquestions from attendees atthe convention centre, threebusinessanalysts,andapanelofthreejournalists.Icounted67 questions. By anymeasure, that’s amazing.Theaddition of the panel ofindustry analysts was new

Page 149: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

this year, and I thought itadded a lot to the session.This year seemed to beparticularly substantive intermsof thequestions asked.WarrenandCharlieansweredquestions about successionplanning for Berkshire, theirviews on themanagement ofrisk in their insurancebusiness, taxes and politics,and the outlook for theeconomy.AnytimeI’mlucky

Page 150: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

enough to spend time withWarren, I come awaylearning something, and thisweekend that was certainlythe case. Even though thefundamentalsofhis investingadvice and managementphilosophy haven’t reallychanged, it’s inspiring towatch someone as smart,thoughtful and principled asWarren talk about the worldof business. He is also a

Page 151: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

master at promoting hiscompanies,and thisyearwasno exception. BerkshireHathawayrecentlyboughttheOmaha Herald newspaper,andsoWarreninvitedmetoanewspaper throwingcompetition just before theSaturday meeting. I was apaperboy growing up, but Ididn’t do as well as Warrenas we lobbed Omaha Heraldnewspapers (in front of a

Page 152: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

large gathering of media)onto the porch of a Claytonmodular home (also aBerkshirecompany)setupinthe exhibition centre. I thinkWarrenhadbeenpracticing.

The next day, I faredsomewhat better in a Ping-Pong exhibition with ArielHsing. I met Ariel sevenyears ago, when she was 9andwasbroughtintodestroy

Page 153: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Warrenandme inPing-Pongat his 75th birthday party.She’sbeenplayingpingpongat the Berkshire meetingssince shewas 11.Now she’s16andwillbepartoftheU.S.Olympic Ping-Pong team inLondon.Iheldmyownforawhile, but she creamed mewhen she brought her “real”game.IthinkIdidabitbetterthanWarren. That exhibitionmatchwas placed in front of

Page 154: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Borsheims, the BerkshirejewellerystorewhereWarrenplayedsalespersonlaterintheday.Abigpartof theannualmeeting is catching up withfriends who come out toOmaha for it, and I got achance to spend some timewithBono,whowasthere,aswell. I also got to play somebridge along with otherBerkshire shareholders and Iate at a couple of Warren’s

Page 155: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

favourite restaurants inOmaha. All in all, it was aterrific trip and one I lookforwardtoeveryyear,nolessthan the thousands of otherpeople who make thepilgrimagetoOmahatolearnfromthisremarkablebusinessleaderandteacher.

Page 156: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheChairman'sLetterThe Chairman's Letter inmost annual reports is asdryas dust. That is not the casewithWarren Buffett's annualletter to Berkshire Hathawayshareholders. A typicalBuffett letter is full of wiseand pithy observations onbusiness, investment and lifein general. Here are 10

Page 157: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

insights from the recentBuffettChairman'sLetter:

1.Whenyouknowyou'rethebest, you can afford to tell itlike it is. Buffett says: “Ourinsurance business had anexcellent year... that party isover. It's a certainty thatinsurance-industry profitmargins, including ours, willfall significantly in 2008. Sobe prepared for lower

Page 158: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

insuranceearningsduring thenextfewyears."

2. Only four things reallycount when making aninvestment - "a business youunderstand, favourable long-term economics, able andtrustworthymanagement,anda sensible price tag". That'sinvestment-everything else isspeculation.

3. Invest this way and you

Page 159: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

don't need to constantly lookforthenext"new"thing,withall the risk that it necessarilyentails.

4. Businesses are run bypeopleandthebestpeoplearenot necessarily the oneswiththe flashiest CVs. Buffettsingles out Susan Jacques,chief executive of hisjewellery retailer Borsheims."SusancametoBorsheims25

Page 160: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

years ago as a $4-an-hoursaleswoman.She'ssmart, sheloves the business and sheloves her associates. ThatbeatshavinganMBAdegreeanytime."

5.Evenforasuper-long-terminvestor like Buffett, there'salways a time to sell.Berkshire Hathaway bought1.3 percent of PetroChina in2002 and 2003 for $488

Page 161: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

million, valuing the Chineseoil company at $37 billionwhen Buffett thought it wasprobably worth $100 billion.WhentheChinasharebubbletook itsvalue to$275billionin 2007, way above itsfundamental value, Buffettcashed in his holding for $4billion, an eightfold rise infiveyears.

6. Buffett believes

Page 162: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

‘incentivisation’ of managerson the basis of earnings pershare encouragesdisingenuous, if notdownright dishonest,behaviour. Take theassumptions about futureinvestment returns incorporate pension schemes.The average in America is 8percent,despitethefactthataquarter of pension funds areinbondsandcash(forwhich

Page 163: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

a5percentreturnwouldbeareasonable expectation) andthe rest in equities, whichrosebyjust5.3percentayearon average over the 20thcentury as a whole (aremarkable period of growthfor the US economy).Managersdon'treallybelievethey'll get 8 percent, butpretending they will meansthey can contribute less andboost their reported profits.

Page 164: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

"If they are wrong, thechickenswon'tcomehometoroost until long after theyretire."

7. Between 2002 and 2007,Buffett notes, the euroappreciated from 95 cents to$1.37,yettheUStradedeficitwith Germany widened from$36billionto$45billion,thereverse of what should havehappened. As long as these

Page 165: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

imbalances continue,foreigners will continue tobuyupAmericaonthecheap."This is our doing, not somenefarious plot by foreigngovernments."

8.Buffetthasaneyeforwittyone-liners, which make hisletters a joy to read.Here hequotes John Stumpf, chiefexecutiveofWellsFargo, onthe behaviour of lenders: "It

Page 166: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

isinterestingthattheindustryhas invented new ways tolose money when the oldways seemed to work justfine."

9. He sees the joke, butBuffett also knows that thereis something profoundlywrong at the heart ofcorporateAmerica."Ashouseprices fall, a huge amount offinancial folly is being

Page 167: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

exposed.Youonlylearnwhohas been swimming nakedwhen the tide goes out - andwhat we are witnessing atsome of our largest financialinstitutionsisanuglysight."

10. Investors should berealists but the best areoptimists too. Buffett hastaken premiums worth $4.5billion from investors buyinginsurance from him against

Page 168: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

four major stock marketsbeinglowerin15to20yearsthan they are today. He isconfidentthathewillholdonto thosepremiumsand in themeantimehewillusethecashto make another smallfortune.Whataman,whataninvestor!

Page 169: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SomeBuffettMusingsfromHisChairmen’sLettersandAnnualMeetingsIn 1974: “Never count onmakingagoodsale.Havethepurchase price be soattractive that even amediocre sale gives goodresults.”

1978: “We have tried

Page 170: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

occasionally to buy toads atbargain prices with resultsthat have been chronicled inpast reports. Clearly ourkissesfellflat.Wehavedonewellwithacoupleofprinces—buttheywereprinceswhenpurchased.

Atleastourkissesdidn’tturnthemintotoads.And,finally,we have occasionally beenquitesuccessfulinpurchasing

Page 171: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

fractional interests ineasilyidentifiable princes attoad-likeprices.”

1981:“It’ssimplytosaythatmanagers and investors alikemust understand thataccounting numbers are thebeginning, not the end, ofbusinessvaluation.”

1982: “When returns oncapital are ordinary, an earn-more-by-putting-upmore

Page 172: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

record isnogreatmanagerialachievement.Youcangetthesame result personally whileoperating from your rockingchair. Just quadruple thecapital you commit to asavingsaccountandyouwillquadrupleyourearnings.Youwouldhardlyexpecthosannasfor that particularaccomplishment. Yet,retirement announcementsregularly sing the praises of

Page 173: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

CEOs who have, say,quadrupled earnings of theirwidget company during theirreign-withnooneexaminingwhether this gain wasattributable simply to manyyearsofretainedearningsandthe workings of compoundinterest.”

1985: “Ben Grahams’s Mr.Market allegory may seemout-of-date in today's

Page 174: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investment world, in whichmost professionals andacademicians talkofefficientmarkets, dynamic hedgingand betas. Their interest insuch matters isunderstandable, sincetechniques shrouded inmysteryclearlyhavevaluetothe purveyor of investmentadvice. After all, what witchdoctor has ever achievedfame and fortune by simply

Page 175: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

advising‘Taketwoaspirins?’

1987: “Over the years,Charlie (Munger, BerkshireHathaway Vice Chairman)and I have observed manyaccounting-based frauds ofstaggering size. Few of theperpetrators have beenpunished; many have noteven been censured. It hasbeen far safer to steal largesums with a pen than small

Page 176: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

sumswitha

gun.”

1988:“Infact,whenweownportions of outstandingbusinesses with outstandingmanagements, our favouriteholdingperiodisforever.Forexample:

(1) As if governed byNewton's First Law ofMotion, an institution will

Page 177: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

resist any change in itscurrent direction; (2) Just asworkexpandstofillavailabletime, corporate projects oracquisitions materialize tosoak up available funds; (3)Any business craving theleader, however foolish, willbe quickly supported bydetailed rate-of-return andstrategic studies prepared byhis troops; and (4) Thebehaviourofpeercompanies,

Page 178: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

whether they are expanding,acquiring, setting executivecompensation or whatever,willbe

mindlesslyimitated.”

1989: “The most commoncause of low prices ispessimism -sometimespervasive,sometimes specific to acompany or industry. Wewant to do business in such

Page 179: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

an environment, not becausewe like pessimism butbecause we like the prices itproduces. Optimism is thereal enemy of the rationalbuyer.”

1990: “Our stay-putbehaviour reflects our viewthat the stock market servesas a relocation centre wheremoney is moved from theactivetothepatient.”

Page 180: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1991: “We've long felt thatthe only value of stockforecastersistomakefortunetellers look good. Even now,Charlie and I continue tobelievethatshort-termmarketforecasts are poison andshouldbekeptlockedupinasafe place, away fromchildren and also fromgrown-upswhobehaveinthemarketlikechildren.”

Page 181: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1992: “The strategy we'veadopted precludes ourfollowing standarddiversification dogma. Manypundits would therefore saythe strategy must be riskierthan that employed by moreconventional investors. Wedisagree. We believe that apolicy of portfolioconcentration may welldecreaseriskif it raises,as itshould, both the intensity

Page 182: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

withwhichaninvestorthinksabout a business and thecomfort-level he must feelwith its economiccharacteristics before buyingintoit.Instatingthisopinion,we define risk, usingdictionary terms, as "thepossibilityoflossorinjury."

1993: “In a bull market, onemust avoid the error of thepreening duck that quacks

Page 183: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

boastfully after a torrentialrainstorm, thinking that itspaddlingskillshavecauseditto rise in theworld.A right-thinking duck would insteadcompare itspositionafter thedownpourtothatoftheotherducksonthe

pond.”

1996: “Do not think ofyourself as merely owning apiece of paper whose price

Page 184: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wigglesarounddailyandthatis a candidate for sale whensome economic or politicaleventmakesyounervous.…Insteadvisualizeyourselfasapart ownerof abusiness thatyou expect to stay withindefinitely, much as youmightifyouownedafarmorapartment house inpartnership with members ofyourfamily.”

Page 185: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1996: “We continue tomakemore money when snoringthan when active. … Yousimply want to acquire, at asensibleprice,abusinesswithexcellenteconomicsandable,honest management.Thereafter, you need onlymonitor whether thesequalities are beingpreserved.”

1997: “But now for the final

Page 186: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

exam: If you expect to be anetsaverduringthenextfiveyears, should you hope for ahigher or lower stockmarketduring that period? Manyinvestors get this onewrong.Eventhoughtheyaregoingtobe net buyers of stocks formanyyearstocome,theyareelatedwhen stock prices riseanddepressedwhentheyfall.Ineffect,theyrejoicebecauseprices have risen for the

Page 187: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

"hamburgers" they will soonbe buying. This reactionmakes no sense. Only thosewhowillbesellersofequitiesin the near future should behappy at seeing stocks rise.Prospective purchasersshould much prefer sinkingprices.”

1997: “Our future rates ofgain will fall far short ofthose achieved in the past.

Page 188: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Berkshire's capital base isnowsimplytoolargetoallowus to earn truly outsizedreturns. If you believeotherwise, you shouldconsideracareer in salesbutavoid one in mathematics(bearing in mind that thereare reallyonly threekindsofpeople in the world: thosewhocancountandthosewhocan't).”

Page 189: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1997: “If you're an investor,you're looking on what theasset isgoing todo, ifyou'rea speculator, you'recommonly focusing on whatthe price of the object isgoingtodo,andthat'snotourgame.”

1997: “If you understood abusiness perfectly and thefuture of the business, youwould need very little in the

Page 190: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wayofamarginofsafety.So,the more vulnerable thebusinessis,assumingyoustillwanttoinvestinit,thelargermargin of safety you'd need.If you're driving a truckacross a bridge that says itholds 10,000 pounds andyou've got a 9,800 poundvehicle, if the bridge is 6inches above the crevice itcovers, you may feel okay,but if it's over the Grand

Page 191: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Canyon, you may feel youwant a little largermarginofsafety...”

1998: “Intrinsic value can bedefined simply: It is thediscounted value of the cashthat can be taken out of abusinessduring its remaininglife. The calculation ofintrinsicvalue, though, isnotso simple. As our definitionsuggests, intrinsicvalue isan

Page 192: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

estimate rather thanaprecisefigure, and it is additionallyan estimate that must bechangedifinterestratesmoveor forecasts of future cashflowsarerevised.”

1998: “Investors makingpurchases in an overheatedmarketneedtorecognizethatitmayoftentakeanextendedperiod for the value of evenan outstanding company to

Page 193: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

catch up with the price theypaid.”

1998: “Time is the enemyofthe poor business and thefriendofthegreatbusiness.Ifyou have a business that'searning 20%-25% on equity,time is your friend.But timeisyourenemyifyourmoneyisinalowreturnbusiness.”

1998: “Wedon't get paid foractivity, just for being right.

Page 194: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

As to how long we'll wait,we'llwaitindefinitely.”

1999: “We will rejectinteresting opportunitiesrather than over-leverage ourbalancesheet.”

1999: “The line separatinginvestment and speculation,which is never bright andclear, becomes blurred stillfurther when most marketparticipants have recently

Page 195: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

enjoyed triumphs. Nothingsedates rationality like largedoses of effortless money.After a heady experience ofthat kind, normally sensiblepeople drift into behaviorakin to that of Cinderella atthe ball. They know thatoverstaying the festivities—that is, continuing tospeculate in companies thathave gigantic valuationsrelative to the cash they are

Page 196: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

likelytogenerateinthefuture—will eventually bring onpumpkinsandmice.Buttheynevertheless hate to miss asingleminute of what is onehelluva party. Therefore, thegiddy participants all plan toleave just seconds beforemidnight. There's a problem,though:Theyaredancinginaroom in which the clockshavenohands.”

Page 197: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1999: “We're morecomfortable in that kind ofbusiness. Itmeanswemiss alot of very big winners. Butwe wouldn't know how topickthemoutanyway.Italsomeanswehave very fewbiglosers - and that's quitehelpful over time. We'reperfectly willing to tradeaway a big payoff for acertainpayoff.”

Page 198: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1999:“Thestockmarket isano-called-strike game. Youdon't have to swing ateverything—youcanwait foryour pitch. The problemwhen you're a moneymanager is that your fanskeep yelling, ‘Swing, youbum!’”

2000: “Instead, we try toapplyAesop’s2,600-year-oldequation to opportunities in

Page 199: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

which we have reasonableconfidence as to how manybirds are in the bush andwhen they will emerge (aformulation that mygrandsons would probablyupdate to, ‘A girl in aconvertible is worth five inthephonebook.’).”

2000: “But a pin lies inwaitfor every bubble. And whenthe two eventually meet, a

Page 200: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

newwaveof investors learnssome very old lessons: First,many in Wall Street are acommunity in which qualitycontrol isnotprizedandwillsell investors anything theywillbuy.Second,speculationis most dangerous when itlookseasiest.”

2000: “After all, you onlyfind out who is swimmingnaked when the tide goes

Page 201: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

out.”

2001: “Investors shouldremember that excitementand expenses are theirenemies.Andiftheyinsistontrying to time theirparticipation in equities, theyshould try tobefearfulwhenothers are greedy and greedywhenothersarefearful.”

2001:Onbeingaskedaboutasuccession plan. “When they

Page 202: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

open that envelope, the firstinstructionistotakemypulseagain, after mentioning thatthe instructions of hissuccession are sealed in anenvelopeatheadquarters.”

2004: “If you have a greatmanager, you want to payhimverywell.”

2004: “Long ago, Sir IsaacNewtongaveusthreelawsofmotion,whichwerethework

Page 203: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

of genius. But Sir Isaac'stalents didn't extend toinvesting:Helostabundleinthe South Sea Bubble,explaining later, ‘I cancalculatethemovementofthestars, but not themadness ofmen.’ If he had not beentraumatized by this loss, SirIsaac might well have goneontodiscovertheFourthLawofMotion:For investorsasawhole, returns decrease as

Page 204: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

motionincreases.”

2005: “The worst sort ofbusiness is one that growsrapidly, requires significantcapital to engender thegrowth, and then earns littleor no money. Think airlines.Here a durable competitiveadvantagehasprovenelusiveever since the days of theWrightBrothers. Indeed, if afarsighted capitalist had been

Page 205: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

present at Kitty Hawk, hewould have done hissuccessors a huge favor byshootingOrvilledown.”

2007: “I've reluctantlydiscarded the notion ofcontinuing to manage theportfolio after my death -abandoning my hope to givenew meaning to the term‘thinkingoutsidethebox.’”

2007: “Long ago, Ben

Page 206: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Grahamtaughtmethat‘Priceis what you pay; value iswhatyouget.’Whetherwe’retalkingaboutsocksorstocks,I like buying qualitymerchandise when it ismarkeddown.”

2008: “Putting people intohomes, though a desirablegoal, shouldn’t be ourcountry’s primary objective.Keeping them in theirhomes

Page 207: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

shouldbetheambition.”

2008: “We never want tocount on the kindness ofstrangers in order to meettomorrow’s obligations.Whenforcedtochoose,Iwillnottradeevenanight’ssleepfor the chance of extraprofits.”

2008: “Upon leaving [thederivatives business], ourfeelings about the business

Page 208: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

mirrored a line in a countrysong: ‘I liked you betterbefore I got to know you sowell.’”

Page 209: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffettat5amOntheMondayafterthe2012AGM which was held overthe weekend, during whichBuffett and Munger spentthree and a half hoursanswering 54 questions fromshareholders and financialcommentators, WarrenBuffett then 81-years old,spent three hours answeringquestions on the TV show

Page 210: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SQUAWKBOX,inaspecialpresentation of the show livefrom the Hollywood Dinerjust outside Omaha.Amazingly Buffett was thereand ready to go at 5.00am!These are someof the thingshehadtosayontheshow.“Ibought my first stock in thespringof1942whenIwas11years old.And, at that point,wewerelosingthewarofthePacific to the Japanese.And,

Page 211: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

I mean, if you read theheadlineseveryday, itwouldbekindoffuntogobackandlook at the headlines on theday I bought my first stockbecause, you know, thingswerelookingterribleuntilthebattle of Midway, and Ibought in a few monthsbefore that. So I think it's aterrible mistake. I think theworst mistake you can makein stocks is to buy or sell

Page 212: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

basedoncurrentheadlines.”

Buffett was asked, “Are youtalkingaboutseriousamountsof money that you put intothe market?” He responded,Yeah.Well,Imean,weputasmuch aswe can buywithoutdisturbingtheprice.”

“HowmuchdidyouspendonFriday?” “Well, we probablyspentabout60million.Yeah.We try to buy maybe 10

Page 213: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

percent of what trades orsomething of the sort whenwe're buying a stock. Whenwewere buying IBM, I usedto, day by day, I would justaccount for10percentof thetrading.”

“Wow.But itwas done veryquietly, you kind of movedyourwaythrough?”

“Yeah. I put duct tape overmymouth.”

Page 214: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

3.THEBUFFETTINVESTMENTSTRATEGY

Page 215: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Widediversification isonly required wheninvestors do notunderstand what theyaredoing.

WarrenBuffett

Page 216: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

WarrenBuffett'sShareSelectionMethodologyI personally use WarrenBuffett's share selectionmethodology - he has threebasiccriteria:

1.He never buys a companythat's not making profit.Sounds simplistic but howmanypeoplebuyashareona

Page 217: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

hottipandnevercheckifit'saprofitablecompany?

2.He never buys a companyif he doesn't understand howit makes its money. Why?Well ifhedoesn'tunderstandhow they make money thenhow can he predict theirlikely future? For instanceBuffet didn't buy Enronshares, as he couldn'tunderstand how they were

Page 218: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

making money. Nor couldanyone else for that matter,not even Enron executives.Buffet was criticized formissing out on the dot comboombeforetheboomturnedintothedotcomcrash.

Critics said Buffet is oldschool, is losinghismarbles,he simply doesn't understandthe future, all because herefused to invest in dot com

Page 219: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

companiesdespite theirsharepricesgoingfromafewcentstoupto$100ormoreinlessthen a year. But he stuck byhis threepointcriteriaandasa result he couldn'tunderstand how they weremaking money. Generallythat's because they weren'tand many never did. So heavoided the dot com crashbecause he stuck tofundamentals.Mybelief is if

Page 220: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

it works for Buffet it worksfor me. 3. He never buys acompany that he considersover valued. This can be amoredifficultassessmentandbecomes a judgement call.But ideally he is looking forcompaniesthesharemarketisunder valuing so that he canget abargain.Buffett says tolook at buying a share as ifyou were going to buy theentire company. Some may

Page 221: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

say that's all right for Buffetas he usually is buying theentirecompany,nevertheless,itisstillgoodadvice.

If you were buying anewsagent, corner store orrestaurantyouwouldcheckifis profitable and check if theaccountingisreliableandyouwould want to understandhowitmakesitsmoney.Evenif it is profitable and you

Page 222: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

understand how it makes itsmoney and is only worth$250,000 you aren't going tobuy it at $300,000. But youwouldwantitatsay$200,000or less, being $50,000 belowvalue.Makessense?

Buffet sticks to this simplecriteria and has consequentlybecome a billionaire. ToBuffett, management iseverything. He simply won't

Page 223: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

buyabusinessorastockifhedoesn't have faith in theexecutive suite. Indeed, intermsofinvestmentcriteria,astrong management teamcarries a lot of weight. "Atheadquarters, we're nottraining managers, we'refinding them," explainsMunger, who adds that it'spretty easy to identify talent."If you're standing onEverest,youdon'thave tobe

Page 224: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

a genius to recognize it's ahighmountain."

Page 225: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

HowBuffettFindsLow-PricedValueWewill look at how Buffettfinds low-priced value withsome questions relating towhen he evaluates therelationshipbetweenastock'slevel of excellence and itsprice.Keepinmindthattheseare not the only things heanalyses but rather a briefsummary of what Buffett

Page 226: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

looksfor:

1.Hasthecompanyconsistentlyperformedwell?

Sometimes return on equity(ROE) is referred to as"stockholder's return oninvestment". It reveals therateatwhichshareholdersareearning income on theirshares. Buffett always looksatROEtoseewhetherornot

Page 227: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

a company has consistentlyperformedwellincomparisonto other companies in thesame industry. Looking atjust last year’s ROE is notenough. The investor shouldview the ROE from the pastfiveto10yearstogetagoodidea of historicalperformance.

2.Hasthecompanyavoidedexcessdebt?

Page 228: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

The debt/equity ratio isanother key characteristicBuffett considers carefully.Buffettprefers to seea smallamount of debt so thatearnings growth is beinggenerated from shareholders'equity as opposed toborrowed money. This ratioshows the proportion ofequity and debt the companyis using to finance its assets.Iftheratioishigherthendebt

Page 229: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ratherthanequityisfinancingthecompany.Ahighlevelofdebt compared to equity canresultinvolatileearningsandlarge interest expenses.Foramore stringent test, investorssometimesuseonlylong-termdebtinsteadoftotalliabilitiesinthecalculationabove.

3.Arepro"tmarginshigh?Aretheyincreasing?

The profitability of a

Page 230: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

companydependsnotonlyonhaving a good profit marginbut also on consistentlyincreasing its profit margin.This margin is calculated bydividing net income by netsales. To get a goodindication of historical profitmargins, investors shouldlook back at least five years.A high profit marginindicates that thecompany isexecuting its business well,

Page 231: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

butincreasingmarginsmeansmanagement has beenextremely efficient andsuccessful at controllingexpenses.

4.Howlonghasthecompanybeenpublic?

Buffett typically considersonly companies that havebeen around for at least 10years.Asaresult,mostofthetechnology companies that

Page 232: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

have had their initial publicofferings (IPOs) in the pastdecade wouldn't get onBuffett's radar (not tomention the fact that Buffettwill investonly inabusinessthathefullyunderstands,andhe admittedly does notunderstand what a lot oftoday'stechnologycompaniesactually do). It makes sensethatoneofBuffet'scriteria islongevity: value-investing

Page 233: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

mean looking at companiesthat have stood the test oftime but are currentlyundervalued. Neverunderestimate the value ofhistoricalperformance,whichdemonstrates the company'sability (or inability) toincrease shareholder value.Keep in mind, however, thatthe past performance of astock does not guaranteefuture performance - the job

Page 234: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

of the value investor is todetermine how well thecompany can perform in thefuture as it did in the past.Determiningthisisinherentlytricky, but obviously Buffettisverygoodatit.

5.Dothecompany'sproductsrelyonacommodity?

Initially you might think ofthis question as a radical

Page 235: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

approach to narrowing downacompany.Buffett,however,sees this question as animportant one. He tends toshy away (but not always)from companies whoseproductsareindistinguishablefromthoseofitscompetitors,andthosethatrelysolelyonacommodity such as oil andgas. If a company does notoffer anything different thananother firmwithin the same

Page 236: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

industry, Buffett sees littlethat sets the company apart.Anycharacteristicthatishardto replicate is what Buffettcalls a company's economicmoat, or competitiveadvantage. The wider themoat,thetougher

it is for a competitor to gainmarketshare.

6.Isthestocksellingata25%discounttoitsreal

Page 237: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

value?

This is the kicker. Findingcompaniesthatmeettheotherfive criteria is one thing, butdeterminingwhether theyareundervalued is the mostdifficult part of valueinvesting, and Buffett's mostimportantskill.Tocheckthis,an investor must determinethe intrinsic value of acompany by analysing a

Page 238: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

number of businessfundamentals, includingearnings,revenuesandassets.Acompany'sintrinsicvalueisusually higher (and morecomplicated) than itsliquidation value i.e. what acompanywouldbeworthifitwere broken up and soldtoday. The liquidation valuedoesn't include intangiblessuch as the value of a brandname, which is not directly

Page 239: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

statedonfinancialstatements.Once Buffett determines theintrinsic value of thecompany as a whole, hecompares it to its currentmarket capitalization - thecurrent totalworth (price). Ifhis measurement of intrinsicvalue is at least 25% higherthan the company's marketcapitalization,Buffettseesthecompany to have value.Soundseasy,doesn'tit?Well,

Page 240: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett's success, however,depends on his unmatchedskill in accuratelydetermining this intrinsicvalue.While we can outlinesomeofhis criteria,wehaveno way of knowing exactlyhow he gained such precisemastery of calculating value.It is interesting to note thatvirtually all directors ofpubliccompaniesinAustraliahave indemnity insurance

Page 241: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

paid for by the company.Bycontrast,BerkshireHathawaydoes not carry director’sinsurance. Warren Buffettsays, "If something reallycatastrophic happens on ourdirectors' watch, they areexposedtolossesthatwillfarexceedyours."

Page 242: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettOnIdentifyingGoodCompanies"Wedon'tdoduediligenceorgooutkickingtires.Itdoesn'tmatter. What matters isunderstanding thecompetitive dynamics of abusiness. We can't be takenbyaguywithasalespitch...

“What really counts is the

Page 243: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

presence of a competitiveadvantage. You want abusinesswithabigcastleanda moat around it, and youwantthatmoattowidenovertime. Coke and Kodak bothhad marvellous moats 20 or25 years ago. Kodak's hasnarrowed (it has almostcompletely disappeared),whileCokehasbeenbuildingits moat. We want aneconomiccastle."

Page 244: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“Retail investors should notpayanyattentiontotheday'snews. If they're payingattention to the day's newsand they're trying tobuyandsellstocksbasedontheday'snews, they're never going tobesuccessfulinvestors.

“The idea is to buy a goodbusiness.Imean,it'sthesameway as if you and your, youknow, your brother went out

Page 245: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

tobuyabusiness.You'dlookaround for a company, somelittle business that had goodprospects over time, haddecent and honestmanagement and where thepricemadesense.

“And you wouldn't read thenewspaper before you do it.My partner, CharlieMunger,and I have been workingtogetherforover50years.In

Page 246: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

both buying a $34 billionbusiness like BurlingtonNorthern or buying 100shares of stock, we havenever talked about the day'snews or what's going, youknow,or thatweek'snewsorabout month's news. We'relookingatwherethebusinessis going to be 10 years fromnow because we're going toown it then. That's where itcounts.”

Page 247: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettonTechnologyCompaniesBuffett says while he would"not be at all surprised" ifApple(tradingatover$600ashare in mid-2012) andGoogle (tradingatover$650ashareinmid-2012arewortha "lotmore" in ten years, hesees them as too risky forBerkshiretoinvestin.But,he

Page 248: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

says, "I sure as hellwouldn'tshortthemeither."

Buffett and his partnerCharlie Munger toldshareholders they simplydon't knowenough about thecompanies, their potentialcompetitors, and wheretechnology might be going,for them to see Google andApple as "inevitable"winners.

Page 249: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

They consider Berkshire'srecently acquired $13.1billion stake in IBM(accordingtoBuffett“IBMisreally a branded solutionsprovider at heart), as amuchsaferinvestment,eventhoughitcanalsobecharacterizedasa tech company. “Thechances of being wrong inIBM are probably less, atleast forus, than the chancesofgoingwronginGoogleand

Page 250: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Apple."

“I'm an agnostic on acompany likeFacebook.Anytime you get a trulyextraordinary business, andit's obviously anextraordinary business, butthey're the hardest ones tovaluebecausethequestionis,is whether five or 10 yearsfrom now they will be asextraordinary as they are

Page 251: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

now, even though they maykeep doing more and morewonderful things. So it's justharder to figureout than,oh,we'llsayCoca-Cola.

“Imean,Coca-Cola10yearsfrom now is going to bebiggerandmoreprofitable,inmy view, than it is now, buttherewon'tbesomequantumchangeineitherdirection.Soit's much easier for me to

Page 252: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

figureoutCoca-Cola'sworththanGoogle or Facebook or,youknow,younameit.”Thisis what Charlie Munger hadto say about the technologyindustry.

“Take the rapid training bythe computer geniuses withthe computer algorithms.Those people have all thesocial utility of a bunch ofrats admitted to a granary. I

Page 253: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

neverwouldhaveallowedtherats to get in the granary. Idon'twantthebrilliantyoungmen of America doting theirlives at being rats insomebody else's granary.That'snotmyideaoftherightway to run the republic.Andifyouletmewritethelaws,itwouldn't happen. But ofcourse, nobody's going to dothat.”

Page 254: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheImportanceofValuingAShareWarrenBuffett says that youshould value a share as youwould value a privatebusiness. “In the privatesector,P/E (Price /Earnings)means nothing. In fact,earnings mean nothing. Theonly thing that matters inbuying a private business istheamountofcashthatitcan

Page 255: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

generate-itsfreecashflow.

“When you buy a stock, youarebuyingthecompany’snetworthanda right to thecashthat the company cangenerate in the future.“Earnings and revenue arenumbers reported on thecompany’s tax return andmean nothing to a businessowner or investor.You can’tspend earnings to grow the

Page 256: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

business-youcanonlyspendthe cash thatmakes it to thebank after all expenses arepaid.

“Ifyouknowthenetworthofthecompany(theShareholderEquity) and can reasonablyestimatethefuturecashofthebusiness with a degree ofconfidence- you can quicklycalculate the true value of abusiness.Onceyouknowthe

Page 257: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

value, you should insist onbuyingthestockatadiscounttoitsvalue.

“This discount is a MarginOf Safety so that you stillearn attractive returns if thecompanydoesnotproduceasmuch cash as you hadexpected.

“Onlywhenthestockpriceisat or below your Margin OfSafety should you consider

Page 258: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investing. Investing in thisway can produce amazingresults:

“It would have protectedinvestors in the US from theLucent, Enron, andWorldcom scams becausefreecashflowishardtofake– even when earnings andother tax return numbers aregrowing; and, “It will allowyoutoinvestwithconfidence

Page 259: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and check in on your stocksonce a year. Buyingbusinesses as a businessinvestor gives you theconfidence and comfort toknowthatyouownwonderfulcompaniesatattractivepricesand that you do not need toconcern yourself with thedaily silliness of the stockmarkets because, over time,as your company’s valuegrows, its stock price will

Page 260: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

havetofollow.”

Page 261: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SomeMoreBuffettWisdomWhen asked about whatindicatorofeconomicactivityhe would watch, if he couldonly choose one, Buffettstated that freight car-loadings and truck tonnagemovedwould be the ones hewouldtrack.

“I think cash is probably as

Page 262: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

riskyanassetasyoucanownover time. So you're nottaking risk off when you gointocash.Youaregoingintosomething that is sure todecline in purchasing powerover time. So that is thebiggest risk on trade I knowistoowncash.”

“Success in investing doesn'tcorrelate with I.Q. onceyou'reabovethelevelof125.

Page 263: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Once you have ordinaryintelligence,whatyouneedisthe temperament to controltheurgesthatgetotherpeopleintotroubleininvesting.”

“When you get somebodylike a,Walt Disney or SteveJobsorMark(Zuckerberg)orBill (Gates), what you seewith those people is apassion.And to some extendthey're not thinking solely

Page 264: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

aboutthemoneyinvolved.

“Imean,theyarenotrunningtheir businesses to getextremely rich. They don'tmind getting rich, and youknow they know how to dothat, too, but what reallydrives them is what they'recreating and you saw thatwith Bill, you see it withMarkandwhenyouget that,when you find that and

Page 265: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

they've got big ideas and therest of the world doesn'tnecessarily understand themverywell,butthey'redoingit.Youknow,youcangetsomeamazingachievements.”

“I think equities are veryattractive for the long term.Theymaygetmoreattractivenextweekornextmonth.Butit's the same thing I said inOctober of 2008. I didn't

Page 266: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

know where bottoms weregoing to be or where theyweregoingtobeinayear.

“But equities, producingbusinesses, good producingbusinessesareagreatthingtoown over time, and they'vebeen a great thing to own,you know, for a hundred,several hundred years in thiscountry.

“Theywillbeagreatthingto

Page 267: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

own for the next 100 years.Butwhoknowswhethertheygo up or down in price nextweek. As to the volume,though, there's still way toomuchvolumeinthemarket.Imean, the idea that theownership of a companyshould turn over a hundredpercent in a year, that is notthe way people behave withapartment houses, it's not theway they behave with

Page 268: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

farmland.

“But theyhave thisnotion instocks that they ought to dosomething every day. Thebest thing todowithstock isbuy stock with a goodcompanyanddon'tlookattheprice for five years orsomething.”

“WheneverIreadaboutsomecompany undertaking a cost-cutting program, I know it's

Page 269: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

not a company that reallyknows what costs are about.The really good managerdoes not wake up in themorning and say 'This is theday I'm going to cut costs,'any more than he wakes upand decides to practicebreathing.”

“Myideaofagroupdecisionistolookinthemirror.”

“Youwant tobewitha low-

Page 270: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

cost operator. Now, that's anadvantagethatWal-Marthas,that's an advantage a Costcohas, and you can lookthroughout the field. Peoplethat are low-cost operatorshaveanadvantage.”

“Whenmanagerswant togetacross the factsofabusinessto you, it can be done withthe rules of accounting.Unfortunately, when they

Page 271: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wanttoplaygames,atleastinsomeindustries,itcanalsobedone with the rules ofaccounting. If you can'trecognizethedifferences,youshouldn't be in the equity-pickingbusiness.”

“I'veoftenfelttheremightbemore to be gained bystudying business failuresthanbusinesssuccesses.”

“The investor of today does

Page 272: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

not profit from yesterday’sgrowth.”

“There are all kinds ofbusinesses that Charlie and Idon’t understand, but thatdoesn’tcauseustostayupatnight.It justmeanswegoonto the next one, and that’swhat the individual investorshoulddo.

1. We enjoy the process farmorethantheproceeds.

Page 273: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

2. We simply attempt to befearful when others aregreedyandtobegreedyonlywhenothersarefearful.

3. We’ve long felt that theonly value of stockforecastersistomakefortunetellers look good. Even now,Charlie and I continue tobelievethatshort-termmarketforecasts are poison andshouldbekeptlockedupina

Page 274: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

safe place, away fromchildren and also fromgrownupswho behave in themarketlikechildren.

4.Whenamanagement teamwith a reputation forbrilliance tackles a businesswith a reputation for badeconomics,itisthereputationof the business that remainsintact.”

“Tobesuccessful,youshould

Page 275: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

concentrate on the world ofcompanies, not arcaneaccountingmathematics.”

“We believe that accordingthe name "investors" toinstitutionsthattradeactivelyis like calling someone whorepeatedly engages in one-nightstandsa"romantic.”

“It's got to be the bestintellectualexerciseoutthere.You're seeing through new

Page 276: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

situations every tenminutes…Inthestockmarketyoudon'tbaseyourdecisionsonwhat themarket is doing,but on what you think isrational….”

“Bridge is about weighinggain/loss ratios.You'redoingcalculationsallthetime.

“Theapproachandstrategiesare very similar in that yougatheralltheinformationyou

Page 277: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

can and then keep adding tothat base of information asthings develop. You dowhatever the probabilitiesindicated based on theknowledge that you have atthat time,butyouarealwayswilling to modify yourbehaviour or your approachasyougetnewinformation.

“In bridge, you behave in away that gets the best from

Page 278: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

yourpartner.Andinbusiness,you behave in the way thatgets the best from yourmanagers and youremployees.”

“Chainsofhabitaretoolightto be felt until they are tooheavytobebroken.”

“Thericharealwaysgoingtosay that, youknow, just giveusmoremoney andwe'll gooutandspendmoreand then

Page 279: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

itwill all trickledown to therest of you. But that has notworkedthelast10years,andIhopetheAmericanpubliciscatchingon.”

“There seems to be someperversehumancharacteristicthatlikestomakeeasythingsdifficult.”

“Allkindsofthingsaregoingtohappen.I'mnottryingtositaround and predict which of

Page 280: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

thosearegoingtohappen,I'mtrying to figure wherebusinesseswill be five or 10years from now. Andwhenever we buy a stock Isay am I happy owning thatstock if the stock marketclosesforacoupleofyears?

“Youknow,ifI'vegotagoodbusiness here and the stockmarketcloses foracoupleofyears, I'm fine.And if I own

Page 281: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

part of a good business I donot need the stockmarket tobeopenforthenextcoupleofyearstodofineininvesting.”

“Berkshire has beenunderpriced sometimesduring the 45-plus years I'vebeen there and has beenoverpriced.Most of the timeit's been inwith the rangeofvalue.Inthenext50yearsit'llbeoverpriced,sometimes it'll

Page 282: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

beunderpriced,it'sthenatureof stocks. That'swhatmakesstock investingsowonderful.I mean, if everything wasperfectly priced all the timethere would be no money inthegame.”

“Iwould love it if they onlyallowed me and a wholebunchofpsychoticdrunks totrade in stocks and I wouldgetveryrich.”

Page 283: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“The real problem in stocksis that people are emotionalabout them. I mean, theproblem isn't with thecompanies; the problem iswith the people that callthemselves investors. If youlook at how Americanbusiness has done overhistory, it's donemagnificently.

“And if you just owned a

Page 284: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

cross-sectionof it, youdidn'tneed to know how to run abusiness or read a balancesheetoranything.

“But the problem is thatpeople get excited aboutgetting rich very quickly ortheygetdepressedwhentheythought they were going togetrichveryquicklyandtheydidn't, and people beatthemselves in the stock

Page 285: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

market. The companies don'tbeat them, the stocks don'tbeat them, they beatthemselves.”

“Therewillbebubblesin thefuture. I mean, people getexcitedaboutthingsthathavegone up in price, and thatvery excitement becomesfurtherproof to themand theriseinprices.

“Imean, it becomes circular,

Page 286: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and it keeps going until itends,andthat'swhenbubblespop.Butwewillhavealotofbubbles,andyoucangetveryrich on bubbles if you takeadvantageofthemratherthanparticipateinthem.”

“If you print enoughmoney,you know, the price ofeverything will go up eventhough thevalueof itdoesn'tgoup,inasense.Andifyou

Page 287: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

mail out a million dollars toevery American family, youknow, you will not have abubble, you'll have inflation.You'll also have a lot ofactivity for a while. But theprinting of money results inthe decline in the value ofmoney.It'sverysimple.”

“Whatwewanttohaveisthenormalgrowththatcomesoutof an economywhere people

Page 288: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

are finding more and morethings to do that please youandme in terms of what webuy.”

“IfyougoonCNBCandsaythatbondsarekindofapoorinvestment,youknowpeopledon't get mad at you; youdon't even hear from theTreasury. I mean, all right,you can knock almost anyinvestment and people may

Page 289: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

geta little irritated,butwhenyou talk about gold - and ofcourse that says somethingabout their motivations forownership-theywantpeopletoagreewiththem.

“They want people -everybody - they wanteverybody to get so scaredthey run toacavewithgold.And caves might be a betterinvestmentthangold.Imean,

Page 290: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

at least they're not producingmore caves all the time. Sothey want people to be asafraid as they are becausethat'swhat'sgoingtoproduceanincreaseinprices.

“Incidentally, they're right tobe afraid of paper money. Imean, they have a very—theirbasicpremisethatpapermoney around the world isgoing to get worth less and

Page 291: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

less and less over time isabsolutelycorrect.”

“The one thing I canguarantee you is not safe, isthedollarinyourpocket,youknow.Thatisgoingtogetorbecome worth less, notworthless,butworthlessovertime.”

“I don't believe in peopletrying to get very rich veryquickly in stocks. They don't

Page 292: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

know how to do it, I don'tknow how to do it, nobodyknowshowtodoit.

“And if you get convincedthat you can, you know,you've made a mistake. Buttherearelots,thereareplentyofgoodbusinessesthatifyoubuy them, you'll have a veryhigh probability they'll beworthmoremoney in fiveor10or20years.

Page 293: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“And Berkshire's one ofthose.Butitisn'tthebestone.Imean,thechancesofgettinga bad result at Berkshire isveryslight,andthereforeyoucan have, in my view, youcanhaveahigherpercentageofyourmoneyinBerkshireifyou're willing to be satisfiedwith a modestly better thanaveragereturn.

“And I havemembers ofmy

Page 294: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

family,youknow,mysistersand cousins that have 80 or90 percent of theirmoney inBerkshire. I'm notuncomfortable with that. Buttheydonot expect to get thekind of results out ofBerkshire in the future thatthey'vegotteninthepast,andtheywon't.”

Page 295: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Berkshirevs.GoldThisiswhatBuffetthadtosayaboutgoldasaninvestmentinMay2012onSquawkBoxTV.“WhenwetookoverBerkshire,Berkshirewassellingat$15ashareandgoldwassellingat$20anounce.Goldisnow1600andBerkshire's120,000.Butyoucantakeabroaderexampleofthat.If

Page 296: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

youbuyanounceofgoldtodayandyouholdit100years,youcangotoiteverydayandyoucouldcootoitandyoucancaressitandyoucanfondleitand100yearsfromnowyou'llhaveoneounceofgoldanditwouldn'thavedoneanythingforyouinbetween.

“Ifyoubuy100acresoffarmland,itwillproducefor

Page 297: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

youeveryyear.Youcanusethatmoneytobuymorefarmland;youcandoallkindsofthings.For100yearsit'llproducethingsforyouandyoustillhave100acresoffarmlandattheendof100years.

“YoucouldbuytheDowJonesindustrialaveragefor66atthestartof1900.Goldwasthen$20.Attheendit

Page 298: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

was11,400.Butyou'dhavegottendividendsfor100years.Soaproductiveassetofanykind,adecentproductiveasset,isgoingtokillanon-productiveassetovertime.Now,inanygivenone-yearperiod,five-yearperiod,anyassetcanoutperformanotherasset.”

Page 299: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettinAustraliaIn its report for the threemonths to June 2012,BerkshireHathaway revealedthat it held Australian bondsas part of the fixed interestsecurities backing itsinsurance businesses,including huge re-insurancearms,andsomeofitsfinanceproducts. It also holds thebonds of four other AAA-

Page 300: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

rated countries includingGermany and the UK. Thebonds of these five countriesmake up 80 percent of theinvestment in foreign fixed-interest securities. OneAustralian media outletgushingly reported, “WarrenBuffett has opted to investheavily in Australia's top-ratedgovernmentbondsasheseeks a stable backstop forBerkshire Hathaway. And

Page 301: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

more purchases may be ontheway.

“Forthefirsttime,oneoftheworld's major insurers,Warren Buffett's BerkshireHathaway,has revealed itselfas a fan of Australiangovernmentbonds,especiallytheirAAAcreditrating.

“With General Re andBerkshire active inAustralia,it's logical they hold

Page 302: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Australiangovernment bondsin their portfolios. But theimportanceof theAAA-ratedholdings to Berkshire hasincreased. It seems even thelegendary Warren Buffettneeds to assure investors,analysts and regulators thathishugeinsurancebusinessisbacked by some of the bestquality government debtaroundtheworld.”

Page 303: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Berkshire Hathaway are bigglobal re-insurers and dealwith Australian companiesincluding Suncorp. Berkshirealso has a 3 percent holdinginanotherglobalre-insurerinSwiss Re. General Re hassignificant operations inAustralia (it earned a lot ofpublicity following the HIHcollapse in the earlyyearsofthe past decade for beingmixedupwithHIHandFAI).

Page 304: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

IfMoody'sfollowsonwithitsthreattocutthecreditratingsof a group of countriesincluding Germany,NetherlandsandLuxembourglaterthisyear,thenitislikelythat Berkshire will be forcedto expand the size of itsAustralianbondsholdings.

Page 305: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettonPeople“Wehave270,000peopleworkingatBerkshire,andit'salittleearlyinthemorning,butIwillguaranteeyouthatduringtherestoftheday,atleast,somepeoplewillbedoingsomethingwrong.Imean,it'sthethingthatscaresthedickensoutofmeastheCEO,becauseyoucan'thave270,000peoplewithout

Page 306: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

somebodydoingsomethingwrong.Peoplearejustnotthatcarefulnomatterwhatinstructionsyougive.

“ThethingIworryaboutatBerkshireisthatwith270,000people,somebody'sdoingsomethingwrong.I'llguaranteeyouthey'redoingsomethingwrongtoday.Imean,wewillprobablyhave10people,maybe20people

Page 307: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

doingsomethingtheyshouldn'tbedoingtodayatBerkshire.

“WhatIhopeisthatwefindoutaboutit,thatit'sminorandIcertainlyhopethatwehearaboutitandgetit,youknow,getitcorrected.Butyoucan'thaveahugeorganization-anybodythatrunsahugeorganization,Idon'tcarewhetherit'sa

Page 308: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

churchoranarmyorapoliticalorganization,agovernmentaldepartment.

“Imean,that'swhathauntsyouisthatdownthelinepeoplearedoingthingsthat,youknow,they'renotsupposedtobedoingandyouhavevariousmethodstotryandkeepthatundercontrol.You'llnever—you'llneversolveit100percent.You

Page 309: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

havetomakesurewhenyoudofindoutaboutit,youdosomethingaboutit.

“Wewanttohavepeoplethatmatchourprinciplesandnotprinciplesthatmatchourpeople”

Page 310: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

4.BUFFETTDEALSWe all are learning,modifying, ordestroyingideasallthetime. Rapid

Page 311: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

destruction of yourideaswhen the time isrightisoneofthemostvaluable qualities youcanacquire.Youmustforce yourself toconsider argumentsontheotherside.

CharlieMunger,

Page 312: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BerkshireHathaway

Page 313: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Coca-ColaIn 1988, Buffett startedbuyingCoca-Colashares.Hisold neighbour, now thePresident of Coca-Cola,noticedsomeonewas loadingup on shares and becameconcerned. After researchingthe transactions, he noticedthe trades were being placedfrom the Midwest. Heimmediately thought of

Page 314: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett and called him.Buffettconfessedtobeingtheculpritandrequestedtheynotspeak of it until he waslegally required to disclosehis holdings at the 5%threshold.

Within a few months,Berkshire owned 7% of thecompany, or $1.02 billiondollarworthof stock.Withinthree years, Buffett's Coca-

Page 315: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Cola stock would be worthmore than theentirevalueofBerkshire when he made theinvestment.

In 1988,Wall Street thoughtCoca-Cola was anunattractive stock to buy.Conversely Warren Buffettthought it was a wonderfulbusinesstoown.

In 1988 Coca-Cola was thecompany in the beverage

Page 316: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

industry, and in theworld. Itdominated the market andhad no serious competition.Even today in Australia,Coca-Cola has more shelfspace than almost any otherproduct on supermarketshelves.

During 1988 and 1989,Buffettacquiredmorethan$1billion worth Coca- Cola(KO) shares. At the time,

Page 317: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Wall Street thought he wasdownright crazy.Wall Streetscrutinized the purchase anddeducedthatBuffetthadpaidway too much for earningsandthestockpricewashigh,having increased by 18% ayearforeightyears.

Wall Street thought Buffettwas crazy. In 1987, Coca-Cola earnings were downnearly 2% from their 1986

Page 318: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

peak,surelynot thesignofagrowing company! With aprice-to-earnings(PE)ratioof14 to 19, the companyseemed fairly valued at best,ifnotovervalued.

Buffett showed the world,again, why Wall Street’searningsmeannothing to thebusiness investor, how toinvest like a business owner,and why you are right when

Page 319: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

your data and reasoning areright thus not depending onwhether the crowd agrees ordisagrees. BerkshireHathawayhas paid a total of$1.3 billion to acquire its8.6% stake in Coke over theyears.Inhindsighttheresultsspeakforthemselves.

Today, Buffett’s stock inCoca-Colaisworthmorethan$10 billion. In 2011, Buffett

Page 320: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

advised, ‘we (BerkshireHathaway) will almostcertainlyreceive$376millionfromCokeindividends.’Notbad, considering how easy itwas to find the value in this“no-brainer” investment.Let’s look at the reasoningbehindBuffett’smostfamouspurchase. The Cash Cow.From 1978 through 1987,Coca-Cola’s Free Cash Flowgrew at a median rate of

Page 321: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

21.8%ayear.Buffetthimselfsays we should not takeyearly results too seriously,so we focus on multi-yearresults. Then again, Coca-Cola’s Free Cash Flow grewquite steadily each year - adefiniteplus!

The NetWorth. Coca-Cola’sShareholder Equity had beengrowing by around 7.8% ayear. Not startling by any

Page 322: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

means, but it was consistentandpredictable-imperativeinthe Buffett approach toinvesting.Thegrowth rateofShareholder Equity becomescritically important onlywhen you expect yourcompany to close up shop inthenexttwentyyears,clearlynot something Coca-Colaintendsondoing.

Management and Money.

Page 323: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Coca-Cola had a medianCash return on investedcapital (CROIC) of 9.3% fortenyears.Foreverydollarofcapital invested in thecompany, Coca-Cola wasgenerating $0.09 of cash.Many investors prefer to seeCROIC above 13%; anylower and the numbersbecomefragile,thoughCoca-Cola was a special situationbecause of its brand and

Page 324: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

moat. In 1988, Coca-Colawasanythingbutfragile.

One of Buffett’s investmentdictums is for businesses tohave a moat. “What reallycounts is the presence of acompetitive advantage. Youwant a business with a bigcastle and a moat around it,and you want that moat towiden over time. Coke hasbeenbuilding itsmoat for20

Page 325: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

or 25 years. We want aneconomiccastle."

In 1988, investors have beenhard pressed to find a morewell-knownnamethanCoca-Cola.Now that ismoat. TheValuation. Assuming thecompany could continue togrow Free Cash Flow at21.8% a year for ten years,and then slowed to 5%thereafter. So, assuming

Page 326: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett wanted a 15% ormore average annual return,youcouldvalueCoca-Colaat$22.3 billion, or $59.16 ashare in 1988. The $22.3billion is made up of $2.09billion of ShareholderEquityand the net present value ofthe estimated $98.89 billionof future cash flow,discounted at 15% for ahandsomereturn.

Page 327: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

The Purchase. Manyinvestors work on the theorythat you shouldn’t pay fullpriceforacompany,evenforoneas solid asCoca-Cola. Ifthe future is a little less rosythan you projected, yourreturns will suffer. So, youneed a discount. Being anindustry leader (the industryleader), Coca-Cola couldhave been purchased with aslittle as a 25% Margin Of

Page 328: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Safety discount. At a 25%discount to value, Coca-Colacouldhavebeenpurchasedatany timeat orbelow$44.37.In1988,thecompany’sstocktraded between $35 and$45.25, giving Buffett adiscount between 24% and41%.

Page 329: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettonCoca-Cola.Fromthe1993BerkshireHathawayShareholderLetter:

“Let me add a lesson fromhistory: Coke went public in1919at$40pershare.Bytheend of 1920 the market,coldly re-evaluating Coke'sfutureprospects,hadbatteredthestockdownbymore than50%, to $19.50. At year end

Page 330: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1993, that single share, withdividends reinvested, wasworthmorethan$2.1million.

“AsBenGrahamsaid:"Intheshort-run, the market is avotingmachine - reflecting avoter-registration test thatrequires only money, notintelligence or emotionalstability-butinthelong-run,the market is a weighingmachine."

Page 331: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Later in the letter, Buffetthighlights a 1938 Fortunearticle. The writer of thearticle implies that it wasalreadytoolate,backin1938,tobenefitfromtheownershipofCoca-Cola'sstock:

“In1938,morethan50yearsafter the introduction ofCoke,andlongafterthedrinkwas firmly established as anAmerican icon, Fortune did

Page 332: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

an excellent story on thecompany. In the secondparagraphthewriterreported:"Several times every year aweighty and serious investorlookslongandwithprofoundrespectatCoca-Cola'srecord,but comes regretfully to theconclusion that he is lookingtoo late. The spectres ofsaturation and competitionrisebeforehim.”

Page 333: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“Yes, competition therewasin1938 and in 1993 aswell.But it's worth noting that in1938TheCoca-ColaCo.sold207 million cases of softdrinks(ifitsgallonagethenisconverted into the 192-ouncecases used for measurementtoday) and in 1993 it soldabout10.7billioncases,a50-fold increase in physicalvolume from a company thatin1938wasalreadydominant

Page 334: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

initsverymajorindustry.

“Nor was the party over in1938foraninvestor:Thoughthe $40 invested in 1919 inonesharehad(withdividendsreinvested)turnedinto$3,277by the end of 1938, a fresh$40 then invested in Coca-Colastockwouldhavegrownto $25,000 by year end1993.” With that in mind,consider how often layers of

Page 335: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

complexity and cost areaddedtotheinvestingprocesswhen a perfectly sound andstraightforwardoptionisrightthereinfrontofyou.

InvestmentMethodology:WhatQuestionsWouldWarren

BuffettAskToValueCoca-Cola(oranyotherbusiness)?

Page 336: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1. Does the company sellbrandnameproducts that arelikelytoendure?

2. Is the business of thecompanyeasilyunderstood?

3. Does the company investin and operate businesseswithinitsareaofexpertise?

4.Doesthecompanyhavetheabilitytomaintainorincreaseprofitabilitybyraisingprices?

Page 337: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

5.Is thecompany, lookingatlong-term debt, and thecurrent position,conservativelyfinanced?

6. Does the company showconsistently high returns onequityandcapital?

7. Have the earnings pershare and sales per share ofthe company shownconsistent growth abovemarketaveragesoveraperiod

Page 338: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ofatleastfiveyears?

8. Has the company beenbuyingbackitsshares,andifso, has it bought themresponsibly?

9. Has management wiselyused retained earnings toincrease the rate of return toshareholders?

10. Is the company likely torequire large capital sums to

Page 339: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ensure continuingprofitability?

Page 340: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

NebraskaFurnitureMartIn1983,accordingtowhatisnowfolklaw,BuffettwalkedintoNebraskaFurnitureMart,the multi-million dollarfurniture retailer built fromscratchbyRoseBlumpkin.

Speaking toMrs. B, as localresidents called her, Buffettasked if she would be

Page 341: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

interested in selling the storeto Berkshire Hathaway.Blumpkin's answer was asimple "yes", to which sherespondedshewouldpart for"$60 million". The deal wassealed on a handshake and aone-page contractwas drawnup. The Russian-bornimmigrant merely folded thecheque without looking at itwhen she received it dayslater.

Page 342: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuyInAdversityWarren Buffett has madesome of his best buys whensolid companies haveexperienced highly-publicized problems. He hascorrectly predicted theywould work through thetrouble, and they ultimatelymade billions when theyrecovered.

ThefirstwastheGreatSalad-

Page 343: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Oil Scandal. In the early1960s, a commodities mogulwas taking out big loanssecured by what he claimedwere giant inventories ofsaladoilstoredinwarehousesowned by American Expressin Bayonne, New Jersey. Asit turned out, the tankscontainedmostlywater,withsalad oil floating on top asdisguise. Shares of AmExplummeted by 50 percent.

Page 344: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

How bad was this problem?To find out,Buffett spent anevening with the cashier atRoss'sSteakHouseinOmahaseeing if people would stopusing their Amex cards. Thescandal didn't seem to giveany customer indigestion, soBuffettseizedtheopportunityto buy 5 percent of thecompanyfor$13million.

Buffett pounced, and

Page 345: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

multiplied his investmentfive-fold in five-years for a$20 million profit. Manyyearslater,Buffettthoughthesawthesamepatterninabigcompany thatmany investorsreviled more than any other:BankofAmerica(BofA).

Buffett asked hisadministrative assistant tofind CEO Brian Moynihan'sphone number. When he

Page 346: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

reached Moynihan at theenvironmentally-friendlyBank of America Tower inmidtown Manhattan, Buffettproposed a deal that wasrelatively light on dividendsand heavy on warrants andwould produce enormousgainsifBofArecovered.

Moynihan, an experienceddealmaker from his daysmakingacquisitionsforFleet,

Page 347: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wantednear-totalsecrecy.Hedeclined to bring ininvestment bankers, didn'tconsult with lieutenants, andinitially discussed the dealonly with his chairman,former DuPont CEO, ChadHolliday.

The board voted by phoneearlyonaThursdaymorningand approved the deal thathad taken just 24 hours. In

Page 348: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

exchange for the Buffettbrand name and $5 billion,the Charlotte, N.C. financialinstitution granted WarrenBuffett the option to buy upto 700 million of its sharesanytimein thenext10yearsfor$7.14.

Buffett earned $357 millioninpaperprofitsthatThursdaysimplyonwarrants related tohis $5billion equity infusion

Page 349: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

into Bank of America. Notbad for a day's work. Fundmanagers andanalysts fearedthatBankofAmericaneededto raise lots of additionalcapital by selling shares, atextremely low prices. Theybelieved the bank lacked thefinancialstrength tocover itsbig exposure to troubledmortgages. The TV talkingheads,disappointedinvestors,and even investment bankers

Page 350: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

within BofA who receivedbonuses in shares and werewatching it collapse, took adim view of its future andMoynihan'sleadership.

Buffett tookadifferentview:Berkshire wouldn't haveinvested inBofAif itneededhis money. The Berkshirechairman reckons that thebankwouldwork through itscurrentproblems,andthatthe

Page 351: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

underlying banking businesswill prove highly profitable.If Moynihan's claim thatBofA will earn as much as$25 billion in a few yearsproves correct, Berkshire'sprofits will exceed $10billion.

Page 352: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

GoldmanSachsBuffetthasahistoryofbeinga lifeline for well-knowncompanies at time offinancialstress.Hemadea$5billion investment inGoldmanSachsinSeptember2008 at the height of thefinancialcrisis.

Buffett’sBerkshireHathawaytookadvantageoftheturmoilin the markets to make a

Page 353: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

shrewd $5 billion investmentwith a strong 10% dividendyield in the beleaguered butbest-run major Wall Streetsecurities firm, GoldmanSachs.

Berkshire also receivedwarrants to buy $5 billion ofGoldman common stock at$115 a share, $10 belowGoldman's share price whenthe deal was announced.

Page 354: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Within a week Goldmanissued another $5 billion incommonstock.Bytheweek'send,Goldmanraiseditspriceto around $137 a share,making Buffett's deal evenmore attractive. Berkshirewas to receive $500 millionin annual dividends on thepreferredshares,whichistax-advantagedforacorporation.Preferredstock,whichpaysafixed dividend but rarely

Page 355: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

fluctuatesmuchinvalue,actsmore like a bond than atypical common stock.Holders of preferred sharesalso are paid off ahead ofcommon-stock holders if acompanyisliquidated.Unlikemost preferred, which arecallable after five years, theGoldman preferred held byBerkshirecanberedeemedatany time at a 10% premium.This gives Goldman

Page 356: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

flexibilitytopayofftheissueifitcanobtainmoreattractivefinancing later in a calmermarket. If the issue is paidoff,Berkshirewillneta$500million profit. Goldmanprobably could have done abetter deal by selling $5billion of convertiblepreferred stock in the openmarket or to a group ofprivate-equityfirms.

Page 357: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

For Goldman, the allure ofthis deal was the imprimaturthat comes from WarrenBuffett. With Buffett sayingthatapreferredinvestmentinGoldman is safe, Goldman'slendersandthosewithwhomit trades were surely to bereassured.

This undoubtedly helpedGoldman finance its $1trillion balance sheet, even

Page 358: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

thoughMr.Buffett'spurchaseis expected to reduceGoldman's earnings. Thefive-year Goldman warrantsare very valuable. Berkshiregets an opportunity to buyGoldman stock at half its2007 peak and for a smallpremium to the firm's bookvalue of around $100 pershare. In mid-2011 GoldmanSachs Group Inc announcedthat it would buy back $5

Page 359: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

billion worth of preferredstock from Buffett, ending acostly deal that helped shoreup confidence in the bank atthe height of the financialcrisis.

Goldman paid a 10 percentpremium to buy back theshares, as well as accruedunpaid dividends, and a one-time preferred dividend of$1.64 billion. Buffett

Page 360: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

lamented the likelyredemption of the shares inhis 2011 annual letter toshareholders.

"GoldmanSachshastherightto call our preferred on 30daysnotice,buthasbeenheldback by the Federal Reserve(bless it!), whichunfortunatelywill likely giveGoldman the green lightbeforelong."

Page 361: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

The Buffett transaction alsogrants Berkshire warrants topurchase 43.5 millioncommon shares at $115 pershare through 2013.Followingtheannouncement,Goldman shares rose 2.7percenttocloseat$159.96onthe New York StockExchange.Berkshire'sclassAshares advanced 0.5 percentto $124,700 and its class Bshares rose 0.9 percent to

Page 362: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

$83.48. The preferred sharescarriedanannualdividendof10 percent, thus buying backthe securities will save theinvestment bank about $500million a year. The annualdividend to Berkshiretranslated into $1.4 millionper day, $951.29 per minuteand$15.85persecond.

Page 363: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

GeneralElectricA month after the GoldmanSachs deal Buffett invested$3billion inGeneralElectric(GE) after the stock hadfallen 42 percent in the pastyear.ThedealcostsGEabout$300millioneachyear.Afterannouncing his investmentBuffett praised GeneralElectric.“GEisthesymbolofAmerican business to the

Page 364: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

world,” he said in astatement. “Theyhave strongglobal brands and businesses...IamconfidentthatGEwillcontinue to be successful intheyearstocome.”

Analysts said Buffett’sendorsement will mean asmuch or even more thanBerkshire’s cash. “He’s asmart guy and he wouldn’tget involved if he doesn’t

Page 365: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

think it’s a great company,”said one analyst. “It’s a niceendorsement. He doesn’tmaketoomanymistakes.”

Anotheranalystsaid,“Ithinkthey’re kind of a win-winsituation: great deals forBerkshire and good deals forthe other companies. I thinkinalotofways,Goldmanandcertainly GE, they’re, ineffect, buying Buffett’s

Page 366: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

backing. Companies arewilling to accept his capitalon better terms than capitalfrom anyone else because ofthe market psychology ofhaving Warren Buffettinvestingintheircompany.”

WhenGE paid Buffett back,they owed him 10% morethanhepaid,or$300millionon top of his $3 billionpayback. Plus, Buffett will

Page 367: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

have accumulated $900million in cumulativedividends.Allsaidanddone,Buffett’s $3 billioninvestmentinGEgeneratedatotalprofitof$1.2billion.

Page 368: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SwissReinsuranceCoBuffett made a similarinvestment in SwissReinsurance Co after it raninto financial difficulty.Buffett made the investmentafter Swiss Re’s strategy oftrading securities such ascredit-default swaps led torecordwritedownsandlossesof$8.3billionin2008.Swiss

Page 369: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Re is repaying Berkshireaheadofscheduleafterprofitalmost doubled in the thirdquarter and the reinsureraccumulatedexcesscapitalof$10 billion by the end ofJune. It was announced thatBuffett’s two-year return onhis Swiss Reinsurance Coinvestment in the Zurich-based company may exceed$1.3billion, ormore than40percent of the funds he

Page 370: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

injected, when the reinsurerrepaid Berkshire HathawayInc. in January 2011.Berkshire was to receive a“premium” of 600 millionSwiss francs ($623 million)on the 3 billion francsinjected into the world’ssecond-biggest reinsurer.Interest payments of 12percent a year on theconvertible notes purchasedinFebruary2009addedupto

Page 371: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

about 700 million francs,accordingtoSwissRe.

A10to1,000Bet

In2003,PepsipaidBerkshire$10million to insure againsta contest Pepsi held whichhad a potential $1 billionprize. The prize had a verysmall chance of being wonand it was not won byanyone.

Page 372: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheBuffettBudgetLike every regular person,when Buffet goes shopping,hehas a budget. It's just thatBuffett's budget is $20billion. At the 2012 AGM,Buffett said he recentlyconsidered and then passedon a $22 billion acquisitionbecause he didn't have thecashonhand.

Page 373: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DowChemicalBuffett'sBerkshireHathawaygroup emerged as a leadingshareholder in DowChemical, after backing theglobal combine's near-$19billion acquisition of aspeciality chemical business,Rohm and Haas. The deal,announced in July 2008,markedakeystepintheplanof Dow chief executive

Page 374: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

AndrewLiveris tomove intohigher-margin specialitychemicals, which are lesscyclical than bulk chemicals,where Dow is among theglobal leaders. BerkshireHathawayprovided$3billiontowards the financing whilethe Kuwait InvestmentAuthority was to put up $1billion. The preferred sharespay an 8.5 percent annualdividendtoBuffett,whilethe

Page 375: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

yield is about 4 percentagepoints higher than that onDow’s 30-year notes due in2041.

RohmandHaasmakearangeof special chemicals forconstruction, electronics,paper and water treatment.Dowpaid$78ashare,whichcomparedwithaclosingpriceof $44.83 on the New YorkStock Exchange at the time.

Page 376: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

The offer valued Rohm andHaas' equity at $15.3 billionbut also involved taking on$3.5 billion of Rohm andHaas debt. Stripping out thedebt, the deal was the thirdlargest ever in the chemicalssector.

In addition to the fundingfrom Berkshire and Kuwait,through convertible preferredsecurities, Dow had also

Page 377: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

arranged $13 billion of debtfinance through Citigroup,Morgan Stanley and MerrillLynch. However, by January2009 the deal with Kuwaithad collapsed and Dow’smarketvaluewas$14billion,meaninginvestorsthoughtthecompany was worth at least$1 billion less than the priceitwastopayforRohm.

Meanwhile, Liveris had to

Page 378: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

find $7.5 billion to replacefundsthathadbeenpromisedinDow’snow-collapsedjointventurewithKuwait. In July2012 it was announced thatDow stands to receive $2.16billion from Kuwait aspenalty fees for havingcancelled the agreement tobuyapartoftheDow-ownedplasticsbusinessin2008.

As a result, Buffett and

Page 379: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Berkshire Hathaway, whoown around $3 billion inpreferred shares and another$1 billion that was sold toKuwait, will stand to gainsubstantially. While the fineprint has yet to be workedout, payment is expectedsome time in 2013, completewithinterestandotherfees.

During the Rohm & Hasspurchase, Dow made use of

Page 380: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett’s help to the tune ofsome$16million.Ifitwants,BerkshireHathawaycannowexchange its preferred shareholdings for 72.6 millionshares of Dow’s commonstockworth$41.32pershare.

Page 381: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

LubrizolCorporationIn March 2011, BerkshireHathaway and The LubrizolCorporation announced adefinitive agreement forBerkshire Hathaway toacquire 100% of outstandingLubrizol shares for $135 pershare in an all-cashtransaction. The transaction,which was unanimouslyapproved by the board of

Page 382: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

directorsofeachcompany,isvalued at approximately $9.7billion, making it one of thelargest acquisitions inBerkshire Hathaway history.This transaction wasapproved by Lubrizol’sshareholders and finalized inSeptember2011.

Lubrizol supported the wareffort in the 1940’s, andgovernment authorities

Page 383: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

credited Lubrizol withproducing more than half ofthe engine oil additives andabout 80% of the gearlubricantadditivesrequiredinAlliedmilitaryoperations.

Lubrizol saw an opportunitywith the 1974 petrol crisisand turned its attention toadditives to improve totalvehicle economy and alsointroduced super high

Page 384: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

performance diesel oiladditives and fuel savingmultigradegearoiladditives.

In the 1990s, Lubrizol beganthe supply of lubricantadditivestoChinathroughitsjoint venture facilities inTianjin and Lanzhou.Lubrizol overcame thedifficulties of the GFC in2009 to become one of thefew chemical companies to

Page 385: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

producerecordearnings.

Page 386: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

NewspapersAt the 2012 AGM, Buffettsaid he might turn into anewspaper baron. In 2011hebought the Omaha World-Herald, and says thatacquisition has worked outwell and told the audiencethat he is thinking of buyingmore newspapers.Newspapers, according toBuffett, can be a good

Page 387: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

businessas longasyoudon'tgivethemaway.ShortlyafterthatAGM,Buffett'scompanyBerkshire Hathawayannouncedadealtopurchase63 newspapers from MediaGeneral -- despite Buffettrecently referring to it as a"declining industry withproblems."AttheAGMwhena member of the audienceaskedhimhowtodealwithadeclining industry, Buffett

Page 388: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

replied, "Generally it pays tostay away from decliningbusinesses. [The] newspaperbusiness is a decliningbusiness and we will pay apricetobeinthat.Thatisnotwhere we will make realmoney at Berkshire." Butspeakingaboutthenewspaperindustry in general, Buffettalso said, "I think theeconomicswillworkoutOK.It'snothing like theolddays,

Page 389: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

but I think it will work outOK."

Buffett also said thatnewspapers have "lostprimacy," though he addedthat "theyare stillprimary inagreatmanyareas.Theystilltell me something primarythatIcan'tfindelsewhere."

Berkshire Hathaway said itwill purchasemost ofMediaGeneral's daily and weekly

Page 390: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

newspapers for $142 millionincash.Separately,BerkshireHathaway signed a creditagreement with MediaGeneral for a $400 millionterm loan and a $45 millionrevolving credit line. "Intowns and cities where thereis a strong sense ofcommunity, there is nomoreimportant institution than thelocal paper," said Buffett, aformer paper boy. Berkshire

Page 391: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathawayannouncedanothernewspaper purchase in June2012 saying that they willacquire two Texas dailynewspapers.

Page 392: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett,MarsandWrigleysBuffett's role in Mars' $23billion purchase of chewinggumcompanyWrigley:

In 2008 closely held MarsInc.with $4.4 billion in debtfinancing from Buffett andBerkshireHathawayacquiredU.S.chewinggum iconWm.Wrigley Jr. Company, in a

Page 393: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

deal valued at $23 billion.When the deal closed,Wrigley became a separateMarssubsidiary.

At the time Buffett said,"There's really nothing thatcangowrongwithsomethinglike the Wrigley and Marsbrands. People are eatingmore and more of theirproducts every day." Marspaid $80 per share for

Page 394: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Wrigley in an all-cash deal,which represented a 28%premium over Wrigley's lastclosingpriceof$62.45.Withthe bid from Mars, Wrigleyshares shot up 23%, gaining$14.46 per share on the nexttrading day, thus closing at$76.91.

"It's a great price.Nobody isgoing to paymore than that.Whoisgoingtogoupagainst

Page 395: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Mars and Buffett?"commentatorsobserved.Theyalso noted that in typicalBuffett style there waspossibly a lot more to thedeal. By helping Mars buyWrigley,Buffettmayactuallybe helping himself: As one,big privately held entity, themerged Mars-Wrigley giantwould be much easier forBerkshire to buy outrightshould the secretive family

Page 396: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

that runs the business everdecidetosellit,sourcessaid.The Mars-Wrigley mergerbought together two all-starconfectioners. Wrigley'sbrands include the JuicyFruit, Orbit and Eclipsegums, Life Savers hardcandies and Altoids mints.Mars is vending-machineroyalty in its own right,withbrands suchasM&Ms,TwixandSnickers.

Page 397: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

In addition to providing thedebt financing, Buffett'sBerkshireHathawayInc.wasto make a minorityinvestmentinWrigleyvaluedat $2.1 billion. It wasbelieved that Buffett got adiscount on the Wrigleystake.Once theMars buyoutof Wrigley is concluded,Buffett will own a piece ofthechewing-gummaker.Thefinancing package included

Page 398: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

$4.4 billion in subordinateddebt fromBerkshire, and the$2.1 billion investment fromBerkshire – payable at thetimethedealclosed.

Buffett favours companiesthat have a competitiveadvantage, offering productsorservicesthatcan'teasilybereplicated by rivals.Businesses like Mars andWrigley, which have strong

Page 399: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

consumer brands, fit the bill.This move by Berkshire andBuffettwasjustthelatestinastring of deals around thattime for Buffett. OthersincludeastakeinKraftFoodsand GlaxoSmithKline PLC,Europe's largest drug maker.Buffettalreadyownedahigh-quality confectioner, See’sCandies, a specialty WestCoast chocolate-and-candymaker that was founded in

Page 400: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1921andacquiredbyBuffettin 1972. Sales were $30millionandpre-taxprofitwaslessthan$5millionthatyear.In 2007, the San Francisco-based See's earned $82million on revenue of $383million.

In his most recent letter toBerkshire shareholders,Buffett attributed"extraordinary results" down

Page 401: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

to See's "durable competitiveadvantage." See's isrepresentative of the kind ofcompanies that Buffett likestoownoperationssuchastheNebraska Furniture Mart, orBorsheim's Fine Jewellery,which are highly profitableand display strong growth,yet somehow manage tomaintainthe"feel"oftheold-time sole-proprietorshipshopsthatusedtooccupythe

Page 402: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

downtown "Main Street"business district in everysmalltown.See'sCandiesisareally solid example of thatkindofacquisition.

Page 403: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BoysToysMost young boys loveplaying with a train set andhaveafascinationwithtrains,but would never dream ofowning a railroad. Buffett,who is known for hispreference for oldertechnologies like trains,upstaged any train enthusiastwith his purchase ofBurlingtonNortherninMarch

Page 404: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

2009 when BerkshireHathaway agreed to buyBurlingtonNorthernSantaFeCorp., making a $34 billionbet on the future of theU.S.economy. BurlingtonNorthern,thenation'ssecond-largestrailroad,isthebiggesthauler of food products likecorn, and coal for electricity,making it an indicator of thecountry's economic health.Therailroadalsoshipsalarge

Page 405: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

amount of consumer goods— including items importedfrom Asia — from bigWestern ports like LosAngeles and Seattle. It wasthe biggest acquisition everforBerkshireHathawayatthetime. Analysts said Buffettwas planting both feet in anindustry that is poised togrow as the economy getsback on solid ground.Berkshire Hathaway already

Page 406: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

owned about 22 percent ofBurlington Northern, andpaid$100ashareincashandstock for the rest of thecompany. That was a 31.5percent premium onBurlingtonNorthern'sclosingprice on the day before thedeal.Onthedaythedealwasannounced the stock shot upover 28 percent to $97.66 inafternoon trading.Shareholders had the option

Page 407: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

to convert their stock for acash payment of $100 pershare or receive BerkshireClassA or Class B commonstock.Upto60percentofthedealwascashand40percentwasinstock."Berkshire's$34billioninvestmentinBNSFisa huge bet on that company,CEOMattRoseandhisteam,and the railroad industry,"Buffett said in a statement."Most important of all,

Page 408: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

however, it's an all-in wagerontheeconomicfutureoftheUnited States. I love thesebets,"hesaid.

By February 2012 Buffett’sall-inwagerhadprovedtobeaverygoodbetontheUSoilindustry as well. BurlingtonNorthern Santa Fe’s tracknetwork puts it among thebest situated of its peers tomeet shipping demand for

Page 409: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

frackingsand,pipeandcrudeoilinthenorthernUSBakkenregion, where oil productionhas more than tripled since2008. Gains in mineral andchemical carloads helpedBurlingtonNorthernpaya$1billion distribution toBuffett’sBerkshireHathawayInc. in early 2012. Therailroad is the busiest in theU.S. in 2012 by traffic,positioningittobuildona16

Page 410: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

percent jump in 2011 salesthat helped narrow therevenueleadofUnionPacificCorp.,whichlackstracksintotheBakkenarea.

Oneanalystsaid,“It’skindoflike if somebody discoversgoldinyourbackyardbutnotyour neighbour’s. It’s justgood luck.” Good luck or atypical, well researchedBuffettinvestment?

Page 411: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

5.THEBUFFETTLEGENDI’m a betterbusinessmanbecauseI

Page 412: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

am an investor and abetterinvestorbecauseIamabusinessman.Ifyouhavethementalityof both, it aids you ineachfield.

WarrenBuffettWhen he was only six yearsold, Warren Buffettpurchasedsix-packsofCoca-

Page 413: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Cola from his grandfather'sgrocery store for twenty fivecents and resold each of thebottles for five cents,pocketingafivecentprofit.

At eleven years old, hepurchased three shares ofCities Service Preferred at$38pershareforbothhimselfand his older sister, Doris.Shortly after buying thestock, it fell to just over $27

Page 414: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

per share. A frightened butresilient Buffett held hissharesuntiltheyreboundedto$40.Hepromptlysoldthem-a mistake he would sooncometoregret.CitiesServiceshot up to $200. Theexperience taughthimoneofthebasiclessonsofinvesting:patienceisavirtue.

In 1947, at age seventeenBuffett graduated from High

Page 415: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

School. It was never hisintention togo to college;hehad already made $5,000delivering newspapers,equivalent to around$75,000now.His fatherurgedhim toattend the Wharton BusinessSchool at the University ofPennsylvania. He stayed fortwo years, complaining thathe knew more than hisprofessors. When his fatherwas defeated in the 1948

Page 416: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Congressional race, WarrenreturnedhometoOmahaandtransferred to the Universityof Nebraska-Lincoln.Working full-time, hemanaged to graduate in onlythree years. Buffettapproached graduate studieswith the same resistance hedisplayeda fewyearsearlier.He was finally persuaded toapply to Harvard BusinessSchool, which, in the worst

Page 417: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

admissiondecisioninhistory,rejected him as "too young".Slighted, he applied toColumbia where famedinvestors Ben Graham andDavid Dodd taught - anexperiencethatwouldforeverchange his life. Flyingthrough his graduate studiesatColumbia,Buffettwas theonly student ever to earn anA+ in one of Graham'sclasses.OnedayBenGraham

Page 418: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

called, inviting the youngstockbrokerWarrenBuffetttocome and work for him,providinghimtheopportunityhehadlongwishedfor.

Buffett and hiswife rented ahouse in the suburbs ofNewYork and he spent his daysanalysing S&P reports,searching for investmentopportunities. It was duringthis time that the differences

Page 419: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

between the Graham andBuffettphilosophiesbegan toemerge. Buffett becameinterested in how a companyworked and what made itsuperior to competitors. BenGraham simply wantednumberswhereasBuffettwaspredominately interested in acompany's management as amajorfactorwhendecidingtoinvest.Grahamlookedonlyatthebalancesheetandincome

Page 420: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

statement; he had no interestin corporate leadership.Between 1950 and 1956,Buffett built his personalcapitalupto$140,000fromamere $9,800. With this warchest, he set his sights backon Omaha and beganplanninghisnextmove.

On May 1, 1956, Buffettrounded up seven limitedpartners including his Sister

Page 421: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DorisandAuntAlice,raising$105,000 in the process. Heputin$100himself,officiallycreating the BuffettAssociates,Ltd.

Beforetheendoftheyear,hewas managing around$300,000incapital.Small,tosaytheleast,buthehadmuchbigger plans for that pool ofmoney.Hepurchasedahousefor $31,500, affectionately

Page 422: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

nicknamed "Buffett's Folly",andmanagedhispartnershipsoriginally from the bedroom,and later, a small office. Bythis time, his life had begunto take shape; he had threechildren,abeautifulwife,anda very successful business.Over the course of the nextfive years, the Buffettpartnerships racked up animpressive 251.0% profit,while the Dow was up only

Page 423: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

74.3%. Somewhat of acelebrity in his hometown,Buffett never gave stock tipsdespite constant requestsfrom friends and strangersalike. By 1962, thepartnership had capital inexcess of $7.2 million, ofwhich $1 million wasBuffett's personal stake.Buffettdidn'tchargeafeeforthe partnership, but he wasentitled to 25 percent of the

Page 424: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

profits above 4 percent. Healsohadmorethan90limitedpartners across the UnitedStates. Inonedecisivemove,he melded the partnershipsinto a single entity called"Buffett Partnerships Ltd.",upped the minimuminvestment to $100,000, andopened an office in KiewitPlazaonFarnamstreet.

In 1962, aman by the name

Page 425: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

of Charlie Munger movedback from California to hischildhood home in Omaha.Though somewhat snobbish,Mungerwasbrilliantineverysense of the word, havingattendedHarvardLawSchoolwithoutaBachelor'sDegree.

Introducedbymutualfriends,Buffett and Munger wereimmediately drawn together,providing the roots for a

Page 426: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

friendship and businesscollaboration that wouldendure for forty years andmore. Ten years after itsfounding, the BuffettPartnership assets were upmore than 1,156% comparedto theDow's 122.9%.Actingas the manager over assetsthat had ballooned to $44million dollars, Buffett andhis daughter Susie's personalstakewas$6,849,936.Ashis

Page 427: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

persona of success wasbeginning to be firmlyestablished,Buffettclosedthepartnership to new accounts.TheVietnamWarwasragingin full force and the stockmarket was being driven upby people who hadn'texperienced the depression.WhileBuffettwasvoicinghisconcern for rising stockprices, the partnership pulledits biggest coup in 1968,

Page 428: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

recording a 59.0% gain invalue, catapulting to over$104millioninassets.

Next year in May 1969,Buffett informed his partnersthat he was "unable to findany bargains in the currentmarket" and liquidated thepartnership. He spent theremainder of the yearliquidatingtheportfolio,withthe exception of two

Page 429: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

companies - Berkshire andDiversified Retailing. Theshares of Berkshire weredistributed among thepartners and a letter in May1969 informed them that hewould, in some capacity, beinvolved in the business, butwas under no obligation tothem in the future. Buffettintendedtoholdontohisownstake in the company and bythen he owned 29 percent of

Page 430: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the Berkshire Hathawaystock.

Page 431: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettGainsControlofBerkshireHathawayBuffett's role at BerkshireHathaway had actually beensomewhat defined yearsearlier. On May 10, 1965,after accumulating 49% ofthe common stock, Buffettnamed himself Director.Terrible management hadalmost run the company into

Page 432: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the ground, and he wascertain that with a bit oftweaking, it could run better.He immediately made KenChace President of thecompany, giving himcomplete autonomy over theorganization. Although herefused to award stockoptions on the basis that itwas unfair to shareholders,Buffett agreed to co-sign aloan for $18,000 for his new

Page 433: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

President to purchase 1,000shares of the company'sstock.

Two years later, in 1967,Buffett asked NationalIndemnity's founder andcontrolling shareholder JackRingwalt to his office.Whenasked what he thought thecompany was worth,RingwalttoldBuffett-atleast$50pershare,a$17premium

Page 434: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

aboveitsthen-tradingpriceof$33. Buffett offered to buythe whole company on thespot - a move that cost him$8.6 million dollars. Thatsameyear,Berkshirepaidouta dividend of 10 cents on itsoutstanding stock. It neverhappened again; Buffett saidhe "must have been in thebathroom when the dividendwasdeclared".

Page 435: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

In 1970, Buffett namedhimself Chairman of theBoardofBerkshireHathawayand for the first time, wrotethe letter to the shareholders.That same year, theChairman's capital allocationbegan to display hisprudence; textileprofitswerea pitiful $45,000, whileinsurance and bankingbrought in $2.1 and $2.6milliondollarsrespectively.

Page 436: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Ayearorsolater,Buffettwasoffered the chance to buy acompany by the name ofSee's Candy. The gourmetchocolatemakersold itsownbrand of candies to itscustomers at a premium toregular confectionary treats.The balance sheet reflectedwhatconsumersalreadyknew-theyweremorethanwillingto pay a bit "extra" for thespecial "See's" taste. Buffett

Page 437: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

decided Berkshire would bewilling to purchase thecompany for $25 million incash. See's owners wereholding out for $30 million,butsoonconceded.Itwasthebiggest investment Berkshireor Buffett had ever made upuntil then. Following severalinvestments and an SECinvestigation after causing amerger to fail, Buffett andMunger offered to buy the

Page 438: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

stock of Wesco, the targetcompany,attheinflatedpricesimply because they thoughtitwas"therightthingtodo".Not surprisingly, thegovernment didn't believethem. Buffett began to seeBerkshire's net worth climb.From 1965 to 1975, thecompany's book value rosefrom$20persharetoaround$95. It was also during thisperiod that Buffett made his

Page 439: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

final purchases of Berkshirestock. By then he hadinvested more than $15.4million dollars into thecompany at an average costof $32.45 per share. Thisbroughthisownershiptoover43% of the stock with hiswifeholdinganother3%.HisentirefortunewasplacedintoBerkshire, and with nopersonal holdings, thecompany had become his

Page 440: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

soleinvestmentvehicle.

In 1976, Buffett once againbecame involvedwithGeico.The company had recentlyreported amazingly highlosses and its stock waspummelled down to $2 pershare.Buffettwisely realisedthat the basic business wasstill in tact; most of theproblems were caused by aninept management. Over the

Page 441: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

next few years, Berkshirebuilt up its position in thisailing insurer and reapedmillions in profits. BenjaminGraham, who still held hisfortune in the company, diedin in September of the sameyear, shortly before theturnaround. Years later, theinsurance giant wouldbecome a fully ownedsubsidiaryofBerkshire.

Page 442: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

By late 1970s, Buffett’sreputation had grown to thepoint where a rumour thatWarrenBuffettwasbuyingastockwasenoughtoshootitsprice up by 10 percent.Berkshire Hathaway's stockwas trading at more than$290 a share, and Buffett'spersonal wealth was almost$140 million. The irony wasthat Buffett never sold asingle share of his company,

Page 443: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

meaning his entire availablecash was the $50,000 salaryhereceived.Duringthistime,he made a comment to abroker, "Everything I’ve gotistiedupinBerkshire.I'dlikeafewnickelsoutside."

ThispromptedBuffetttostartinvestingforhispersonallife.According to RogerLowenstein's "Buffett", hewasfarmorespeculativewith

Page 444: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

his own investments. At onepoint he bought copperfutures, which was anunadulterated speculation. Inashort time,hehadmade$3million dollars. Whenprompted to invest in realestate by a friend, heresponded"WhyshouldIbuyreal estate when the stockmarketissoeasy?"

By 1989, Berkshire

Page 445: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathaway was trading at$8,000 a share. Buffett wasnow, personally, worth morethan $3.8 billion dollars.Within thenext tenyears, hewouldbeworthtentimesthatamount. During theremainder of the 1990's,Berkshire Hathaway stockcatapultedashighas$80,000per share. Even with thisastronomical feat, as thedot-com frenzy began to take

Page 446: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

hold, Buffett was accused of"losinghistouch".

In 1999, when Berkshirereported a net increase of0.5% per share, severalnewspapers ran stories aboutthe demise of the Oracle.Confidentthatthetechnologybubble would burst, WarrenBuffett continued to dowhathe did best: allocate capitalinto great businesses that

Page 447: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

were selling below intrinsicvalue. His efforts did not gounrewarded. When themarkets finally did come totheir senses, Warren Buffettwas once again a star.Berkshire'sstockrecoveredtoits previous levels afterfalling toaround$45,000pershare, and Buffett was onceagain seen as an investmenticon.

Page 448: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheWitandWisdomofWarrenBuffett“Take me as an example. Ihappen to have a talent forallocating capital. But myability to use that talent iscompletely dependent on thesocietyIwasborninto.IfI'dbeen born into a tribe ofhunters, this talent of minewould be pretty worthless. Ican't run very fast. I'm not

Page 449: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

particularly strong. I'dprobablyendupassomewildanimal'sdinner.”

ToBarackObama,quotedinTheAudacityofHope:

ThoughtsonReclaiming

theAmericanDream(2006)

Ifpeoplewanttogivemeties,Iaccept

Buffett was asked by areporter on a TV show,

Page 450: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“Didn't you get a tie fromObama, too? You stole onefrom him, too. I rememberthisstory.Didn'tyouaskhimforone,too?”

Buffett responded, “I didn'task him. I just wore this tiethat looked like it has beenthrough a washing machineand he noticed that threadswere hanging out andeverything and he said, `I

Page 451: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

can't let you leave theWhiteHouse looking like that.' Sohegavemeanothertie.Arichguy never has to pay foranything.”

MoreBuffettcomments

“If I was running $1 milliontoday,or$10millionfor thatmatter, I'd be fully invested.Anyone who says that sizedoes not hurt investmentperformance is selling. The

Page 452: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

highest rates of return I'veever achieved were in the1950s.IkilledtheDow.Yououghttoseethenumbers.ButIwas investingpeanuts then.It's a huge structuraladvantagenottohavealotofmoney. I think I couldmakeyou 50% a year on $1million.No,IknowIcould.Iguaranteethat.”

“Someone's sitting in the

Page 453: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

shadetodaybecausesomeoneplanted a tree a long timeago.”

“Thebusinessschoolsrewarddifficult complex behaviourmore than simple behaviour,butsimplebehaviour ismoreeffective.”

“Americansareinacycleoffearwhichleadstopeoplenotwanting to spend and notwantingtomakeinvestments,

Page 454: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and that leads to more fear.We'llbreakoutof it. It takestime.”

“Beware of geeks bearingformulas.”

“Chainsofhabitaretoolightto be felt until they are tooheavytobebroken.”

“Derivatives are financialweapons of massdestruction.”

Page 455: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“Economicmedicinethatwaspreviously meted out by thecupful has recently beendispensed by the barrel.These once unthinkabledosageswill almost certainlybring on unwelcome after-effects.Theirprecisenatureisanyone's guess, though onelikely consequence is anonslaughtofinflation.”

“I am a huge bull on this

Page 456: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

country. We will not have adouble-dip recession at all. Isee our businesses comingback almost across theboard.”

“I am quite serious when IsaythatIdonotbelievethereare, on the whole earthbesides, so many intensifiedbores as in these UnitedStates. No man can form anadequate idea of the real

Page 457: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

meaningoftheword,withoutcominghere.”

“I don’t buy expensive suits.Theyjustlookcheaponme.”

“Idon't look to jumpover7-footbars:Ilookaroundfor1-footbarsthatIcanstepover.”

“I just think that - when acountry needs more incomeandwedo,we'reonly takingin15percentofGDP,Imean,

Page 458: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

that - that - when a countryneeds more income, theyshouldget it from thepeoplethathaveit.“

“I never attempt to makemoneyonthestockmarket.Ibuy on the assumption thatthey could close the marketthenextdayandnotreopenitforfiveyears.”

“I think the most importantfactor in getting out of the

Page 459: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

recession actually is just theregenerative capacity of - ofAmericancapitalism.”

“If a business does well, thestockeventuallyfollows.”

“If anything, taxes for thelower and middle class andmaybeeventheuppermiddleclassshouldevenprobablybecut further. But I think thatpeople at the high end -peoplelikemyself-shouldbe

Page 460: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

paying a lot more in taxes.We have it better thanwe'veeverhadit.”

“If past history was all therewas to the game, the richestpeoplewouldbelibrarians.”

“In the 20th century, theUnited States endured twoworld wars and othertraumatic and expensivemilitary conflicts; theDepression; a dozen or so

Page 461: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

recessions and financialpanics; oil shocks; a fluepidemic;and theresignationof a disgraced president.Yetthe Dow rose from 66 to11,497.”

“It takes 20 years to build areputationandfiveminutestoruin it. If you think aboutthat, you'll do thingsdifferently.”

“It's better to hang out with

Page 462: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

people better than you. Pickout associates whosebehaviourisbetterthanyoursand you'll drift in thatdirection.”

“It's far better to buy awonderful company at a fairpricethanafaircompanyatawonderfulprice.”

“It'sneverpaidtobetagainstAmerica. We come throughthings, but it’s not always a

Page 463: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

smoothride.”

“Let blockheads read whatblockheadswrote.”

“Look at market fluctuationsas your friend rather thanyourenemy;profitfromfollyratherthanparticipateinit.”

“Of the billionaires I haveknown,moneyjustbringsoutthe basic traits in them. Ifthey were jerks before they

Page 464: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

had money, they are simplyjerkswithabilliondollars.”

“Only buy something thatyou'd be perfectly happy tohold if themarket shutdownfor10years.”

“Onlywhenthetidegoesoutdo you discover who's beenswimmingnaked.”

“Ourfavouriteholdingperiodisforever.”

Page 465: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“Priceiswhatyoupay.Valueiswhatyouget.”

“Risk comes from notknowing what you're doing.RiskisapartofGod'sgame,alikeformenandnations.”

“Rule No.1: Never losemoney. Rule No.2: NeverforgetruleNo.1.”

“The first rule is not to lose.The second rule is not to

Page 466: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

forgetthefirstrule.”

“Should you find yourself ina chronically leaking boat,energy devoted to changingvessels is likely to be moreproductive than energydevotedtopatchingleaks.”

“Thebusinessschoolsrewarddifficult complex behaviourmore than simple behaviour,butsimplebehaviour ismoreeffective.”

Page 467: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

“The investor of today doesnot profit from yesterday'sgrowth.”

“Theonlytimetobuytheseisonadaywithno"y"init.”

“There's class warfare, allright, but it's my class, therich class, that'smakingwar,andwe'rewinning.”

“The 400 of us pay a lowerpart of our income in taxes

Page 468: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

than our receptionists do, orour cleaning ladies, for thatmatter. If you're in theluckiest 1 per cent ofhumanity, you owe it to therest of humanity to thinkabouttheother99percent.”

“I'vegot a lotof letters fromvariouspromoters around thecountry saying, you know,joinmyfundandwe'lldoitinthe fund. But if you look at

Page 469: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the cost of doing it andeverything,it'sgoingtoworkoutfineforthefundmanagerandhow itworksout for theinvestor is a different thing.Youknow,WallStreet has awayofcreatingproducts thatwork out better for it than itdoesfortheinvestor.”

“There aren't lots of bigcompaniesthatyoucanmakeadealonandtherearelotsof

Page 470: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

big companies that I don'tunderstand.Sothey'reoutsidemycircleofcompetence.Andthenthereareothersthathaveno intention of selling, andthenthereareothers thatare,that were, they may havesome intention, but you can'tcome together with them onprice. So big deals are notgoing to happen very often,butoccasionallytheywill.”

Page 471: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Don'ttrytogetintouchwithmebycellphoneCould a lost voicemail havechanged the course offinancial history? It'sconceivable, in the case ofLehmanBrothersandWarrenBuffett. He has revealed thaton theweekend of Lehman'sspectacular collapse in 2008,Barclays' president, Bob

Page 472: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Diamond, rang him to ask ifhe'dbewillingtohelpwitharescue of Lehman. WhenBuffett took the call he washurrying out to anengagement in Edmonton,Alberta. So he askedDiamond to get back to himwith details later. Diamonddid call back and left amessage on the voicemail onBuffet's cellphone. But thenotoriously tech-unsavvy

Page 473: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Buffett was unfamiliar withthe workings of his handsetand didn't notice that therewasamessageonit.Withnooffer forthcoming, Lehmanproceeded to declare itbankrupt. And we all knowthe consequences to thatfiasco. Full 10-months laterBuffett asked his daughter,Susie, about a funny littlesymbol on the screen of hisphone. It turned out to be

Page 474: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Diamond with the lowdownonLehman.There's a simplelesson to the story, Buffetttold a conference: "Don't tryto get in touch with me bycellphone."

Page 475: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

6.THEINVESTMENTPROCESSYou couldn’t advancein a finance

Page 476: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

department in thiscountry unless youthought that theworldwas flat. Why notinvest your assets inthe companies youreally like? As MaeWest said, “Toomuchofagoodthingcanbewonderful”.

Page 477: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

WarrenBuffett

Page 478: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheShareMarketThemarket,whichismadeupofhundredsofthousandsof“independentexperts”isconstantlyplacingavalueoneverycompany.Whilethemarketiscertainlynotalwayscorrect,itservesasausefulandindependentproxyastothevalueofacompany.Itisclearherethatthemarketandtheindependentexpertare

Page 479: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

notofonemind.

Page 480: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SomeGeneralRulesforSuccessfulShareTradingThe first andmost importantthing a tradermust have is atradingplan.Thisisawrittenplan, which you can refer tofromtimetotime.Thereasonforthisisthatitwillkeepyouontrackandontherightpathto becoming a successfulshare trader. It should

Page 481: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

comprise of several stepswhichwillbecomeaconstantguide to each trade that youmake.

1.Objective.Themainideaisto make a Profit. This isregardlessofwhetheryouarea long-term or short-termtrader. Surprisingly enoughquite a few traders do notmakeaprofit.Thisusuallyisbrought about by not

Page 482: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

planning in the first instance.They are actually tradingblindfolded. Not a verydesirable state to be in. Butfunny enough Traders aredoingitallthetime.

2. Risk. There are severaltypes of risks to be alert for.Firstlythereisoverallmarketrisk. What is the currentmood of the market rightnow? Is it a bear or bull

Page 483: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

market? Depending on whattype of market it is, thisshould/could influence youonwhetherornottoenterthemarket now or later. Ifeverything is headingdownwards, a little delaymight mean that youpurchased that stock a littlecheaper.Abitofadvicehere,never try to pick the verybottomor thevery topof themarket.Ifyouhappentoit is

Page 484: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

luck and nothing else. Eventhe so-called experts cannotpredict the toporbottom.Asmuch as theywould have usbelievetheycan.Anotherriskisspeculativerisk;thiscanbefound particularly in theminingoroilsector.Surethestock price can go skywards,but it can go the other wayjust as quick if not quicker.Only put a small proportionof your capital in this area.

Page 485: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Unless of course you arewilling to accept the riskinvolved. Only you candecidewhat levelof riskyouarecomfortablewith.

3.Entry.Thiswhereyouhavedecided what price you aregoing to pay for your share.Whatever you do, do notleave an order in overnight,particularly if the stock isvolatile that is tosay that the

Page 486: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

stock is going up and downlike a yo-yo. You could paymore thanyoubargained for.Ifyoumustleaveinovernightput a limit towhat price youwanttopay.Nota‘atmarketorder.’Atleastyouwon’tgetanynastysurprisesthatway.

4. Timing. A very importantpart of your trading successwill be your timing. If themarketisgoingdownwardsa

Page 487: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

little patience could mean abetter entryprice,whichwillreflect onyour profits.Don’ttry to pick the exact bottomor the top. Waiting to longmight mean the differencebetween a small profit and alarger more desirable one.The best advice is to get thebestpricepossibleatthetimeyoudecidetotrade.

5.Exit.Not enough attention

Page 488: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ispaidtothisarea.Timingisimportant, but a good tip is“have a pre-set exit figurealreadyprepared.Thishastheadvantage of you knowingalreadyhowmuchprofityouare going to make. Don’t begreedy. This is a trap thatmany traders fall into veryregularly.MorethanIcaretomention, small profits takenon a regular basis build veryquickly into quite large

Page 489: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

amounts.

6. Stop/loss. This can meanthe difference betweensuccess and failure. A stoplossisapricethatisseteitherabove or below your shareprice. This has the effect ofstopping a substantial loss orabigone.Agoodguideistohave nomore than 2 percentofyourtotalportfolioatrisk.You can decide what

Page 490: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

percentage you arecomfortable with. A trailingstop/loss is what you placejust behind your rising shareprice;thiseffectivelylocksinthoseprofitssonearanddeartoyouandme.

7. Paper trading. This is awonderful idea to practice,learn and fine-tune yourtrading skills withoutendangeringyourhardearned

Page 491: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

cash; plus it is free which isanother advantage. There arewebsites where you can tryfor yourself and you mightpickupaprize,dependingonyourtradingskill.

Page 492: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ValueInvestingWarren Buffett has madehimselfintooneoftherichestmen in the world, with avalue investing philosophythat millions of investorsfollow. Let’s have a look atthe theory of value investingas well as the theory behindsome other forms ofinvesting. Many differenttypes of stock trading exist

Page 493: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

including day trading, swingtrading, market making,scalping, charting,momentum trading, tradingthe news, arbitrage, technicaland fundamental analysis,Dow Theory, Elliott WaveTheory, Mark Twain effect,January effect, efficientmarket hypothesis, arbitragepricing theory and manyothers, some of which areoutlinedinthischapter.Value

Page 494: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investing is an investmentparadigm that derives fromthe ideas on investment andspeculation set out by BenGraham(regardedbymanytobe the father of valueinvesting)andDavidDoddintheir 1934 text SecurityAnalysis. Although valueinvesting has taken manyforms since its inception, itgenerally involves buyingsecurities whose shares

Page 495: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

appear under-priced by someform(s) of fundamentalanalysis. For example, suchsecurities may be shares inpubliccompaniesthattradeatdiscounts to book value ortangible book value, havehigh dividend yields, havelow price-to-earningmultiples or have low price-to-book ratios. Notableproponents of valueinvesting, including Buffett,

Page 496: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

have argued that the essenceof value investing is buyingstocks at less than theirintrinsic value. The discountof the market price to theintrinsic value is whatBenjamin Graham called the"margin of safety". Theintrinsic value is thediscountedvalueofallfuturedistributions. However, thefuture distributions and theappropriate discount rate can

Page 497: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

only be assumptions. Buffetthas taken the value investingconcept even further as histhinking has evolved to apoint, where over last 30yearsorsohisfocushasbeenon "finding an outstandingcompany at a sensible price"ratherthangenericcompaniesat a bargain price. Thisconcept is important whenyouareactuallybuyingintoabusiness.

Page 498: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

The people who establishedvalue investing, BenjaminGraham and David Dodd,were both professors atColumbia University andteachers of many famousinvestors. In Graham's bookThe Intelligent Investor; headvocated the importantconcept of margin of safety,first introduced in SecurityAnalysis, the 1934 book heco-authored with David

Page 499: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Dodd, which calls for acautious approach toinvesting.Intermsofpickingstocks, he recommendeddefensive investment instocks trading below theirtangible book value as asafeguard to adverse futuredevelopments oftenencountered in the stockmarket.However,theconceptof value (as well as "bookvalue") has evolved

Page 500: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

significantly since the 1970s.Bookvalue ismost useful inindustries where most assetsaretangible.Intangibleassetssuch as patents, software,brands, or goodwill aredifficult toquantify,andmaynot survive thebreak-upofacompany. When an industryis going through fasttechnological advancements,the value of its assets is noteasily estimated. Sometimes,

Page 501: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the production power of anasset can be significantlyreduced due to competitivedisruptive innovation andtherefore its value can sufferpermanent impairment. Onegood example of decreasingasset value is a personalcomputer. An example ofwhere book value does notmeanmuchistheserviceandretail sectors. One modernmodel of calculating value is

Page 502: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the discounted cash flowmodel (DCF). The value ofan asset is the sum of itsfuture cash flows,discountedback to the present.Valueinvesting has proven to be asuccessful investmentstrategy. There are severalways to evaluate its success.One way is to examine theperformance of simple valuestrategies,suchasbuyinglowPEratiostocks, lowprice-to-

Page 503: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

cash-flowratiostocks,orlowprice-to-book ratio stocks.Numerous academics havepublished studiesinvestigating the effects ofbuying value stocks. Thesestudies have consistentlyfound that value stocksoutperformgrowthstocksandthe market as a whole.Another way to examine theperformance of valueinvesting strategies is to

Page 504: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

examine the investingperformance of well-knownvalue investors. Simplyexaminingtheperformanceofthe best known-valueinvestors would not beinstructive, because investorsdo not become well knownunless they are successful.This introduces a selectionbias. A better way toinvestigate the performanceof agroupofvalue investors

Page 505: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wassuggestedbyBuffett,inaspeechinMay1984thatwaspublished as TheSuperinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville.In thisspeech,Buffett examined theperformance of thoseinvestors who worked atGraham-NewmanCorporation and were thusmost influencedbyBenjaminGraham. Buffett's conclusionis identical to that of the

Page 506: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

academic research on simplevalue investing strategies -value investing is, onaverage, successful in thelong run. During a 25-yearperiod (1965-90), publishedresearch and articles inleading journals of the valueilk were few. The mostlasting contribution ofSecurity Analysis, firstpublishedin1934byGrahamand Dodd to the field of

Page 507: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

security analysis was toemphasize the quantifiableaspects of security analysis(such as the evaluations ofearnings and book value)while minimizing theimportance of morequalitativefactorssuchasthequality of a company'smanagement. Graham's mostfamous student was WarrenBuffett, who ran successfulinvesting partnerships before

Page 508: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

closingthemin1969tofocuson running BerkshireHathaway. Charlie Mungerjoined Buffett at BerkshireHathaway in the 1970s andhassinceworkedas theViceChairman of the company.Buffett has credited Mungerforencouraginghim to focuson long-term sustainablegrowth rather thanon simplythe valuation of current cashflows or assets. Another

Page 509: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

famousvalueinvestorisJohnTempleton, who firstachievedinvestingsuccessbybuyingsharesofanumberofcompaniesintheaftermathofthe stock market crash of1929. Martin J. Whitman isanother well-regarded valueinvestor. His approach iscalled safe-and-cheap, whichwas hitherto referred to asfinancial-integrity approach.Whitman focuses on

Page 510: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

acquiring common shares ofcompanieswithanextremelystrong financial position at aprice reflecting meaningfuldiscount to the estimatedNAV of the companyconcerned.Whitmanbelievesit is ill-advised for investorsto pay much attention to thetrend of macro-factors (likeemployment, movement ofinterest rate, GDP, etc.) notbecause they are not

Page 511: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

important but becauseattempts to predict theirmovement are almost alwaysfutile. Joel Greenblattachievedannualreturnsatthehedge fund Gotham Capitalof over 50 percent per yearfor 10 years from 1985 to1995 before closing the fundand returning his investors'money. He is known forinvesting inspecialsituationssuch as spin-offs, mergers,

Page 512: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and divestitures. EdwardLampert, the chief of ESLInvestments, is best knownfor buying large stakes inSears and Kmart and thenmergingthetwocompanies.

Page 513: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

MarkettrendsIn investing, financialmarkets are commonlybelieved to have markettrends that can be classifiedas primary trends, secondarytrends (short-term), andsecular trends (long-term).This belief is generallyconsistentwiththepracticeoftechnicalanalysisandbroadlyinconsistentwiththestandard

Page 514: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

academic view of financialmarkets, the efficient markethypothesis. That marketprices move in trends is oneof the major assumptions oftechnical analysis, and thedescription of market trendsis common to share traders.Market trends are describedas periods when bulls(buyers) consistentlyoutnumber bears (sellers), orvice versa. A bull or bear

Page 515: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

market describes the trendand sentiment driving it, butcan also refer to specificsecurities and sectors("bullish on BHP Billiton","bullish on technologystocks,"or"bearishongold",etc.).

Page 516: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BullMarketsBull Markets are a financialmarket of a certain group ofsecurities inwhichpricesarerisingorareexpectedtorise.The term "bull market" ismostoftenused in respect tothe stock market, but reallycan be applied to anythingthat is traded, suchasbonds,currencies,commodities,etc.

Bull markets are

Page 517: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

characterized by optimism,investor confidence andexpectations that strongresultswill continue.Nobullmarket can last forever ofcourse, and sooner or later abearmarket (in which pricesfall)will come. It is tough ifnot impossible to predictconsistently when the trendsin the market will change.Part of the difficulty is thatpsychological effects and

Page 518: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

speculation can sometimesplayalarge(ifnotdominant)role in the markets. Theextreme on the high end is astock-market bubble, and onthe low end- acrash.The useof "bull" and "bear" todescribemarkets comes fromthewayinwhicheachanimalattacksitsopponents.Thatis,abullthrustsitshornsupintothe air, and a bear swipes itspawsdown.Theseactionsare

Page 519: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

metaphors for the movementofamarket:ifthetrendisup,itisconsideredabullmarket.Andifthetrendisdown,itisconsidered a bear market. Abull market tends to beassociated with increasinginvestor confidence,motivatinginvestorstobuyinanticipation of further capitalgains. The longest and mostfamousbullmarketwasinthe1990s when the U.S. and

Page 520: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

many other global financialmarkets grew at their fastestpace ever. In describingfinancial market behaviour,the largest group of marketparticipants is often referredto,metaphorically, as a herd.This is especially relevant toparticipants in bull marketssince bulls are herdinganimals.Abullmarketisalsodescribed as a bull run.DowTheory attempts to describe

Page 521: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the character of thesemarketmovements.

Page 522: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BearMarketsAbearmarketisdescribedasbeing accompanied bywidespread pessimism.Investors anticipating furtherlosses are motivated to sell,with negative sentimentsfeeding on itself in a viciouscircle.Themost famousbearmarketinhistorywas1930to1932,markingthestartoftheGreat Depression. A milder,

Page 523: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

low-level long-term bearmarket occurred from about1967 to 1983, encompassingthe stagflation economy,energy crises in the 1970s,and high unemployment inthe early 1980s. Pricesfluctuate constantly in theopen market. A bear marketisnota simpledecline,butasubstantial drop in the pricesof a range of issues over adefined period of time. By

Page 524: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

one common definition, abear market is marked by apricedeclineof20percentormore in a key stock marketindexfromarecentpeakovera12-monthperiod.However,no consensual definition of abear market exists to clearlydifferentiateaprimarymarkettrend from a secondarymarket trend. Investorsfrequently confuse bearmarkets with corrections.

Page 525: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Corrections aremuch shorterlived, whereas bear marketsoccur over a longer periodwith typically a greatermagnitudeoflossfromtoptobottom.

Page 526: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BearmarkethistoricexamplesThe Crash of 1929 was anend to the bull market thatexistedthroughoutthe1920's.The Black Monday crash of1987didnotpushthemarketsinto a bear market. It was asharp, dramatic correctionwithin an upward trend. TheOctober 27, 1997 mini-crashis considered a somewhat

Page 527: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

more minor stock marketcorrectionwhen compared toBlack Monday, but, like the1987 crash, it was acorrection during an upwardtrend. The stock marketdownturnof2002sawasharpdrop in stock prices in stockexchanges across the UnitedStates, Canada, Asia, andEurope. After recoveringfrom lows reached followingthe September 11 attacks,

Page 528: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

indices slid steadily startinginMarch2002,withdramaticdeclines in July andSeptember leading to lowslast reached in 1997 and1998.TheUSdollardeclinedsteadily against the euro,reaching a 1-to-1 valuationnot seen since the euro'sintroduction. In May 2006,emerging markets includingIndia witnessed a correction.Indices fell as much as 20

Page 529: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

percent before resuming thesecularBullRun.

Page 530: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

StockTraderversusStockInvestorA stock trader or a stockinvestor is an individual orfirm who buys and sellsstocksorbonds(andpossiblyother financial assets) in thefinancialmarkets.Individualsorfirmstradingequity(stock)markets as their principalcapacity are called stocktraders. Stock traders usually

Page 531: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

try to profit from short-termprice volatility with tradeslastinganywherefromseveralsecondstoseveralweeks.Thestock trader is usually aprofessional. A person cancallhimselfafullorpart-timestock trader/investor whilemaintaining otherprofessions. On the otherhand, stock investorspurchase stocks with theintention of holding for an

Page 532: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

extended period of time,usually several months toyears.Theyrelyprimarilyonfundamentalanalysisfortheirinvestment decisions andfully recognize stock sharesas part-ownership in thecompany. Many investorsbelieve in the buy and holdstrategy, which as the namesuggests, implies thatinvestorswillhold stocks fora very long term, generally

Page 533: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

measured in years. Thisstrategywasmadepopularinthe equity bullmarket of the1980s and 90s where buy-and-hold investors rode outshort-term market declinesand continued to hold as themarket returned to itsprevious highs and beyond.However, during the 2001-2003 equity bearmarket, thebuy-andhold strategy lostsome followers as broader

Page 534: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

market indexes like theNASDAQ saw their valuesdecline by over 60%.Tradingactivitiesarenotfree.They have a considerablyhighlevelofrisk,uncertaintyand complexity, especiallyforunwiseand inexperiencedstock traders/investorsseeking for an easy way tomake money quickly. Inaddition, stocktraders/investors face several

Page 535: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

costs such as commissions,taxes and fees to be paid forthe brokerage and otherservices, such as thebuying/selling orders placedat the stock exchange.Beyond these costs, theopportunity costs of moneyand time, currency risk,financialrisk,InternetServiceProvider, data and otherexpenses must be added.Although many companies

Page 536: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

offercoursesinstockpicking,and numerous experts reportsuccess through TechnicalAnalysis and FundamentalAnalysis, many economistsand academics state thatbecause of Efficient MarketTheory it isunlikely thatanyamount of analysis can helpan investor make any gainsabovethestockmarketitself.In a normal distribution ofinvestors, many academics

Page 537: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

believe that the richest aresimply outliers in such adistribution(i.e. inagameofchance, they have flippedheadstwentyyearsinarow).For this reason mostacademics and economistsrecommend that investorsinvestinfundsthatfollowanindexinthemarket,i.e.long-term and welldiversifiedinvestments.

Page 538: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

IndexFundsAn index fund or indextracker is a collectiveinvestmentscheme(usuallyamutual fund) that aims toreplicatethemovementsofanindex of a specific financialmarket, or a set of rules ofownership that are heldconstant,regardlessofmarketconditions. Tracking can beachievedbytryingtoholdall

Page 539: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ofthesecuritiesintheindex,inthesameproportionsastheindex.Othermethodsincludestatistically sampling themarket and holding"representative" securities.Many index funds rely on acomputermodelwithlittleorno human input in thedecision as to whichsecuritiestopurchaseandaretherefore a form of passivemanagement. The lack of

Page 540: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

active management (stockpicking and market timing)gives the advantage of lowerfees and lower taxes intaxable accounts. However,the fees will always reducethe return to the investorrelative to the index. Inaddition it is impossible topreciselymirror the index asthe models for sampling andmirroring, by their nature,cannotbe100%accurate.The

Page 541: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

difference between the indexperformance and the fundperformance is known as the'tracking error' or informally'jitter'. Index funds areavailable from manyinvestment managers. Somecommon indices include theAllOrdinaries, theS&P500,the FTSE 100 and the FTSEAll-Share Index. In 1973,BurtonMalkiel published hisbookA RandomWalk Down

Page 542: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Wall Street, which presentedacademicfindingsfor the laypublic. Itwasbecomingwellknown in the lay financialpress thatmostmutual fundswere not beating the marketindices,towhichthestandardreply was made "of course,you can't buy an index."Malkiel said, "It's time thepublic can." The investmentobjectives of index funds areeasy to understand. Once an

Page 543: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investor knows the targetindexof an index fund,whatsecurities the index fundwillhold can be determineddirectly. Managing one'sindex fund holdings may beas easy as rebalancing everysix months or every year.Diversification refers to thenumberofdifferentsecuritiesin a fund.A fundwithmoresecurities is said to be betterdiversified than a fund with

Page 544: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

smaller securities. Owningmany securities reducesvolatility by decreasing theimpact of large price swingsabove or below the averagereturn in a single security.Since some indices, such asthe All Ordinaries, the S&P500 and FTSE 100 aredominated by large companystocks, an index fund mayhaveahighpercentageofthefund concentrated in a few

Page 545: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

large companies. Thisposition represents areductionofdiversityandcanlead to increased volatilityand investment risk for aninvestor who seeks adiversified fund. Assetallocation is the process ofdetermining the mix ofstocks, bonds and otherclassesofinvestableassetstomatch the investor's riskcapacity, which includes

Page 546: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

attitude towards risk, netincome, net worth,knowledge about investingconcepts, and time horizon.Index funds capture assetclasses in a low cost and taxefficientmannerandareusedtodesignbalancedportfolios.

Page 547: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

GrowthInvestingGrowthinvestingisastyleofinvestment strategy. Thosewho follow this style areknown as growth investors.Theyinvestincompaniesthatexhibit signs of above-average growth, even if thesharepriceappearsexpensivein terms of metrics such asprice-to-earning or price-to-book ratios. In typical usage,

Page 548: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

the term "growth investing"contrasts with the strategyknown as value investing.Some notable investors suchasWarrenBuffetthavestatedthat there is no theoreticaldifference between theconceptsofvalueandgrowth("GrowthandValueInvestingare joined at the hip"), inconsideration of the conceptofanasset'sintrinsicvalue.Inaddition, when just investing

Page 549: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

in one style of stocks,diversification can benegatively impacted. Afterthe busting of the dotcombubble,"growthatanyprice"has fallen from favour.Attaching a high price to asecurity in the hope of highgrowthmayberiskybecauseifthegrowthratefailstoliveup to expectations, the priceof the security can plummet.It is often more fashionable

Page 550: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

now to seek out stocks withhigh growth rates that aretrading at reasonablevaluations. There are manyways to execute a growthinvestment strategy. Somegrowth investment vehiclesinclude: emerging markets,recovery shares, blue chips,Internet and technologystock,smallercompaniesandspecialsituations.

Page 551: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SociallyResponsibleInvestingSociallyresponsibleinvesting(SRI)describesaninvestmentstrategy which combines theintentions to maximize bothfinancial return and socialgood. In general, sociallyresponsible investors favourcorporatepracticeswhichareenvironmentally responsible,support workplace diversity,

Page 552: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and increase product safetyand quality. Some (not all)also avoid businessesinvolved in alcohol, tobacco,gambling,weaponsandothermilitary industries, and/orabortion. Modern SRImovement began during theVietnam War. Many peopleliving during the erarememberapicturefromJuneof 1972 of a naked nineyearold girl, Phan Thu Kim

Page 553: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Phúc, running towards aphotographer screaming, herback burning from thenapalm dropped on hervillage. That photographchannelled outrage againstDow Chemical, themanufacturer of napalm, andprompted protests across thecountry against DowChemical and othercompanies profiting from theVietnam War. In the late

Page 554: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

1970s,SRIactivismturneditsattention to nuclear powerand automobile emissionscontrol.

Sociallyresponsibleinvesting(SRI)isaboomingmarketinboththeUSandEurope.Oneoutstanding endorsement of(SRI) policies is theNorwegian GovernmentPension Fund, which ismandated to avoid

Page 555: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

"investmentswhichconstitutean unacceptable risk that theFund may contribute tounethical acts or omissions,such as violations offundamental humanitarianprinciples, serious violationsof human rights, grosscorruption or severeenvironmental damages."Social investors use fourbasic strategies to maximizefinancial return and attempt

Page 556: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

to maximize social good.Screening excludes certainsecurities from investmentconsiderationbasedon socialand/orenvironmentalcriteria.For example, many sociallyresponsible investors screenout tobacco companyinvestments. This is anexampleofa social screenatwork.Divesting is the act ofremoving stocks from aportfolio based on mainly

Page 557: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ethical, non-financialobjections to certainbusinessactivities of a corporation.Shareholder activism effortsattempt to positivelyinfluence corporatebehaviour. These effortsinclude initiatingconversations with corporatemanagement on issues ofconcern, and submitting andvoting proxy resolutions.These activities are

Page 558: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

undertaken with the beliefthatsocial investors,workingco-operatively, can steermanagementonacourse thatwill improve financialperformance over time andenhancethewellbeingofthestockholders, customers,employees, vendors, andcommunities. Positiveinvesting involves makinginvestments in activities andcompaniesbelievedtohavea

Page 559: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

high and positive socialimpact. Positive investingactivities tend to targetunderserved communities. Theseeffortsmay support activitiesdesignedtoprovidemortgageand small business credit tominority and low-incomecommunities. At least oneU.S. mutual fund, the ViceFund (VICEX), was createdspecifically to contrast withthe trend in socially

Page 560: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

responsibleinvesting.VICEXspecializesininvestinginthedefence, alcohol, tobacco,and gambling industries, andhasgreatlyoutperformedboththe S&P 500 and mostsocially responsible mutualfunds.

Page 561: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

MagicFormulaInvestingMagicFormulaInvestingisaterm that refers to aninvestmenttechniqueoutlinedby Joel Greenblatt. MagicFormula Investing is firmlyrooted in the principles ofvalue investing. For the layinvestor, it is claimed that itoffers market-beating returnswithout the complexity

Page 562: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

associated with a discountedcashflowanalysis.Greenblattsuggests purchasing 30 goodcompanies:cheapstockswitha high earnings yield and ahigh return on capital. HetoutsthesuccessofhismagicformulainhisbookTheLittleBook that Beats the Market,citingthatitdoesinfactbeatthe market 96% of the time,and has averaged a 17-yearannual return of 30.8%. The

Page 563: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

comparison index used for"the market" in Greenblatt'sresearchistheS&P500.TheFormula: Establish aminimum marketcapitalization(usuallygreaterthan$50million).

•Excludeutilityandfinancialstocks

•Excludeforeigncompanies

• Determine company's

Page 564: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

earnings yield = EBIT /enterprisevalue.

•Determinecompany'sreturnoncapital=EBIT/(Netfixedassets+workingcapital)

• Rank all companies abovechosen market capitalizationbyhighestearningsyieldandhighest return on capital(rankedaspercentages).

• Invest in 20-30 highest

Page 565: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ranked companies,accumulating 2-3 positionsper month over a 12-monthperiod.

• Rebalance portfolio onceper year, selling losers onedaybeforetheyear-markandwinnersonedayaftertheyearmark.

•Continueoverlong-term(3-5year)period.

Page 566: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DartBoardMethodFinancial journals andnewspapers such as theWallStreet Journal have carriedarticles on stock picking inthe past. One famous articleinvolved a stock pickingcontest between a panel ofWall Street experts, thepublic and a dart board.Onememberwaselectedtothrowdarts at the Journal's stock

Page 567: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

page in order to select aportfolio. At the end of theexperiment, the public andthe dart board both beat theboard ofWall Street experts.Was the dart board moresavvy?

Thedartboard'striumphoverWall Street experts can beattributed to chance (one canalso attribute the dart boardlosing to the experts as a

Page 568: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

coincidenceaswell).

Page 569: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ArbitragePricingTheory(APT)Arbitrage pricing theory infinance,isageneraltheoryofassetpricingthathasbecomeinfluential in the pricing ofshares. APT holds that theexpectedreturnofafinancialasset can be modelled as alinear function of variousmacro-economic factors ortheoretical market indices,

Page 570: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

where sensitivity to changesin each factor is representedby a factorspecific betacoefficient. The model-derived rate of return willthenbeusedtopricetheassetcorrectly - the asset priceshouldequaltheexpectedendof period price discounted atthe rate implied bymodel. Ifthe price diverges, arbitrageshouldbringitbackintoline.The theory was initiated by

Page 571: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

economist Stephen Ross in1976. In economics andfinance, arbitrage is thepractice of taking advantageofapricedifferentialbetweentwo or more markets: acombination of matchingdeals is struck that capitalizeupontheimbalance,theprofitbeing the difference betweenthemarketprices.Whenusedby academics, an arbitrage isatransactionthat involvesno

Page 572: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

negative cash flow at anyprobabilisticortemporalstateandapositivecashflowinatleast one state; in simpleterms- a risk-free profit. Aperson who engages inarbitrage is called anarbitrageur. The term ismainly applied to trading infinancialinstruments,suchasbonds, stocks, derivatives,commodities and currencies.If the market prices do not

Page 573: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

allowforprofitablearbitrage,the prices are said toconstitute an arbitrageequilibrium or arbitrage-freemarket.Arbitrageequilibriumisapreconditionforageneraleconomic equilibrium. Theassumption that there is noarbitrage is used inquantitative finance tocalculateauniqueriskneutralprice for derivatives.Statistical arbitrage is an

Page 574: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

imbalanceinexpectedvalues.A casino has a statisticalarbitrage in almost everygameofchancethatitoffers.Conditions for Arbitrage:Arbitrage is possible whenone of three conditions ismet:

Thesameassetdoesnottradeat the same price on allmarkets ("the law of oneprice").

Page 575: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Two assets with identicalcashflowsdonottradeatthesameprice.

An assetwith a known pricein the future does not todaytrade at its future pricediscounted at the risk-freeinterest rate (or, the assetdoesnothavenegligiblecostsof storage; as such, forexample, thisconditionholdsfor gain but not for

Page 576: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

securities).

Arbitrage is not simply theactofbuyingaproductinonemarket and selling it inanother for a higher price atsome later time. Thetransactions must occursimultaneously to avoidexposure to market risk, orthe risk that prices maychangeononemarketbeforeboth transactions are

Page 577: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

complete. In practical terms,thisisgenerallyonlypossiblewith securities and financialproductswhichcanbetradedelectronically.

In the simplest example, anygood sold in one marketshouldsellforthesamepricein another. Traders may, forexample,findthatthepriceofwheatis lowerinagriculturalregions than in cities thus

Page 578: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

they purchase the good, andtransport it to another regiontosellatahigherprice.

Thistypeofpricearbitrageisthe most common, but thissimple example ignores thecost of transport, storage,risk,andotherfactors."True"arbitrage requires that therebe no market risk involved.Where securities are tradedon more than one exchange,

Page 579: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

arbitrage occurs bysimultaneouslybuyinginoneandsellingontheother.

Page 580: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ScalpingScalping, when used inreference to trading insecurities, commodities andforeign exchange, may referto, a fraudulent form ofmarket manipulation, or, alegitimate method ofarbitrage of small price gapscreatedbythebid-askspread.Scalping in this sense is thepractice of purchasing a

Page 581: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

security for one's ownaccount shortly beforerecommending that securityfor a long-term investmentand then immediately sellingthe security at a profit uponthe rise in the market pricefollowing therecommendation.

Page 582: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SwingTradingSwing trading sits in themiddle of the continuumbetween day trading andtrend following. Swingtradersholdaparticularstockforaperiodoftime,generallybetween a few days and twoor threeweeks, and trade thestockonthebasisofitsintra-week or intra-monthoscillations between

Page 583: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

optimismandpessimism.Thefirst key to successful swingtrading is picking the rightstocks. The best candidatesare large-cap stocks that areamong the most activelytraded stocks on the majorexchanges,forexampleintheU.S., Intel, Microsoft, andCisco Systems. In activemarkets, these stocks willswing betweenbroadlydefined high and low

Page 584: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

extremes, and the swingtrader will ride the wave inone direction for a couple ofdaysorweeks,onlytoswitchto the opposite side of thetradewhenthestockreversesdirection. It should be notedthat in either of the twomarket extremes, thebearmarket environment orbull market, swing tradingproves tobea ratherdifferentchallenge than in a market

Page 585: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

that is between these twoextremes. In these extremes,even the most active stockswill not exhibit the sameupand-down oscillations thatthey would when indices arerelatively stable for a fewweeks or months. In a bearmarket or a bull market,momentum will generallycarrystocksforalongperiodoftimeinonedirectiononly,therebyensuringthatthebest

Page 586: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

strategy will be to trade onthe basis of the longertermdirectionaltrend.

Theswingtrader,therefore,isbestpositionedwhenmarketsare going nowhere - whenindices rise for a couple ofdaysand thendecline for thenext fewdays,only to repeatthe same general patternagain andagain.Acoupleofmonths might pass with

Page 587: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

major stocks and indicesroughly the same as theiroriginal levels, but the swingtrader has had manyopportunities to catch theshort terms movements upand down (sometimes withinachannel).

Page 588: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ContrarianInvestingInfinance,acontrarianisonewho attempts to profit byinvesting in a manner thatdiffers from the conventionalwisdom,when the consensusopinionappears tobewrong.A contrarian believes thatcertain crowd behaviouramong investors can lead toexploitable mispricing insecurities markets. For

Page 589: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

example, widespreadpessimism about a stock candrive a price so low that itoverstates the company'srisks, and understates itsprospects for returning toprofitability. Identifying andpurchasing such distressedstocks,andselling themafterthe company recovers, canlead to above-average gains.Similarly, widespreadoptimism can result in

Page 590: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

unjustifiably high valuationsthat will eventually lead todrops, when those highexpectations don't pan out.Avoiding investments inover-hyped investmentsreduces the risk of suchdrops. These generalprinciples can apply whetherthe investment in question isan individual stock, anindustry sector, or an entiremarket or asset class.

Page 591: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Contrarians are sometimesthought of as perma-bears -market participants who arepermanently biased to a bearmarket view. However, acontrarian does notnecessarily have a negativeview of the overall stockmarket, nor does he believethat it is always overvalued,or that the conventionalwisdom is always wrong.Rather, a contrarian seeks

Page 592: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

opportunities to buy or sellspecificinvestmentswhenthemajority of investors appearto be doing the opposite, tothe point where thatinvestment becomesmispriced.Whilemore"buy"candidates are likely to beidentified during marketdeclines (and vice versa),these opportunities can occurduring periods when theoverall market is generally

Page 593: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

risingorfalling.

Page 594: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DowTheoryDow Theory is a theory onstock price movements thatprovidesabasis for technicalanalysis. The theory wasderivedfrom255WallStreetJournal editorials written byCharles H. Dow (1851–1902),journalist,founderandfirst editorof theWallStreetJournal and co-founder ofDow Jones and Company.

Page 595: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Following Dow's death,William P. Hamilton, RobertRheaandE.GeorgeSchaeferorganized and collectivelyrepresented "Dow Theory,"based on Dow's editorials.However,Dowhimselfneverusedtheterm"DowTheory”.The six basic tenets of DowTheory as summarized byHamilton,Rhea,andSchaeferaredescribedbelow.

Page 596: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SixBasicTenetsofDowTheory

1.MarketsHaveThreeTrends.

Dowdefinedanuptrend(trend1)asatimewhensuccessiveralliesinasecuritypricecloseatlevelshigherthanthoseachievedinpreviousralliesandwhenlowsoccuratlevelshigherthanpreviouslows.

Page 597: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Downtrends(trend2)occurwhenmarketsmakelowerlowsandlowerhighs.ItisthisconceptofDowTheorythatprovidesthebasisoftechnicalanalysis'definitionofapricetrend.Dowdescribedwhathesawasarecurringthemeinthemarket:priceswouldmovesharplyinonedirection,recedebrieflyintheoppositedirection,andthencontinue

Page 598: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

intheiroriginaldirection(trend3).

2.TrendsHaveThreePhases.

Dow Theory asserts thatmajor market trends arecomposedofthreephases:anaccumulation phase, a publicparticipation phase, and adistribution phase. Theaccumulationphase(phase1)is when investors "in the

Page 599: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

know" are actively buying(selling) stock against thegeneralopinionofthemarket.During this phase, the stockprice does not change muchbecausetheseinvestorsareinthe minority absorbing(releasing) stock that themarket at large is supplying(demanding). Eventually, themarket catches on to theseastute investors and a rapidprice change occurs (phase

Page 600: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

2). This is when trendfollowers and othertechnically oriented investorsparticipate. This phasecontinues until rampantspeculation occurs. At thispoint, the astute investorsbegin to distribute theirholdingstothemarket(phase3).

3.TheStockMarketDiscountsAllNews.

Page 601: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Stock prices quicklyincorporate new informationas soon as it becomesavailable. Once news isreleased, stock prices willchange to reflect this newinformation. On this point,DowTheoryagreeswithoneof the premises of theefficientmarkethypothesis.

4.StockMarketAveragesMustCon"rmEachOther

Page 602: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

InDow's time, theUSwasagrowing industrial power.The US had populationcentres but factories werescattered throughout thecountry.Factorieshadtoshiptheirgoodstomarket,usuallyby rail. Dow's first stockaverages were an index ofindustrial (manufacturing)companies and railcompanies. To Dow, a bullmarket in industrials could

Page 603: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

not occur unless the railwayaverage rallied as well(usually first). According tothis logic, if manufacturers'profits are rising, it followsthattheyareproducingmore.If they produce more, thentheyhavetoshipmoregoodsto consumers. Hence, if aninvestor is looking for signsofhealthinmanufacturers,heor she should look at theperformance of the

Page 604: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

companies that ship theoutputtomarket,therailroads.The two averages should bemovinginthesamedirection.When the performances ofthe averages diverge, it is awarning thatchange is in theair. Both Barron's Magazineand the Wall Street Journalstill publish the dailyperformance of the DowJonesTransportationIndexinchart form. The index

Page 605: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

contains major railroads,shipping companies, and airfreightcarriersintheUS.

5.TrendsAreCon"rmedByVolume

Dow believed that volumeconfirmedpricetrends.Whenprices move on low volume,therecouldbemanydifferentexplanations.Forexample,anoverlyaggressivesellercouldbe present. But when price

Page 606: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

movements are accompaniedby high volume, Dowbelieved this represented the"true" market view. If manyparticipants are active in aparticular security, and theprice moves significantly inone direction, Dowmaintained that this was thedirectioninwhichthemarketanticipated continuedmovement. To him, it was asignal that a trend is

Page 607: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

developing.

6.TrendsExistUntilDe"nitiveSignalsProveThatTheyHaveEnded

Dowbelievedthattrendsexisteddespite"marketnoise".Marketsmighttemporarilymoveinthedirectionoppositethetrend,buttheywillsoonresumethepriormove.Thetrendshouldbegiventhebenefitofthe

Page 608: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

doubtduringthesereversals.Determiningwhetherareversalisthestartofanewtrendoratemporarymovementinthecurrenttrendisnoteasy.DowTheoristsoftendisagreeinthisdetermination.Technicalanalysistoolsattempttoclarifythisbuttheycanbeinterpreteddifferentlybydifferentinvestors.

Page 609: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ChartingA point and !gure chart isusedfor technicalanalysisofsecurities. Unlike most otherinvestment charts, point andfigurechartsdonotpresentalinear representation of time.Instead, they show trends inprice. The aim of point andfigurecharting is to filteroutthe "noise" (unimportantprice movement) and focus

Page 610: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

on the main direction of theprice trend. Point and figurecharts are usually used forlonger-termpricemovements.However,theycanbeusedtoday trade by clearlyidentifying the key points ofsupplyanddemand.Theyareveryeffectiveatkeepingyouon the right side of themarket. Point and figurecharts can do a really goodjob tospotverygood trading

Page 611: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

opportunities on a trade andtrendmarket.Pointandfigurecharts are close relatives tothree line break, renko andkagi charts all of which donot have a fixed timeframe.Thismakesyoutradeonlytheimportant moves of themarket. Minor moves arediscarded because of thelimited gain potential. Thereare two typical ways to plotpointandfigurecharts-using

Page 612: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

closing prices, or withhigh/low prices. The mostcommonmethodnowadaysishigh/low prices of a specifictimeframe, normally dailyprices. Point and figurecharting is said to have hadits origins in the US duringthe early1900swith the firstbook appearing by deVilliersin 1933. The Point& FigureMethodofAnticipatingStockPriceMovementsshowedthat

Page 613: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

this charting technique wasalready known by insidersand stock traders. Point andfigure charts where alreadythereinthetradingroomsforthe purpose to record dailytick movements of stockswhen Charles Dow wasbeginning to create hisfamousindex.

Page 614: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ElliottWavePrincipleTheElliottWavePrinciple isa form of technical analysisthat attempts to forecasttrends in the financialmarkets and other collectiveactivities. It is named afterRalph Nelson Elliott (1871–1948), an accountant whodeveloped the concept in the1930s: he proposed that

Page 615: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

market prices unfold inspecific patterns, whichpractitionerstodaycallElliottwaves. Elliott argued thatbecause humans arethemselves rhythmical, theiractivities anddecisions couldbe predicted in rhythms, too.Critics argue the theory isunprovable and inconsistentwith the efficient markethypothesis. The waveprinciplepositsthatcollective

Page 616: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

investor psychology (orcrowd psychology) movesfrom optimism to pessimismandbackagain.Theseswingscreate patterns, as evidencedin the price movements of amarket at every degree oftrend.Elliott'smodelsaysthatmarket prices alternatebetweenfivewavesandthreewavesatalldegreesoftrend,as the illustration shows. Asthese waves develop, the

Page 617: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

largerpricepatternsunfoldinself-similarfractalgeometry.

Page 618: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SpeculationSpeculation, in the narrowsense of using it as financialspeculation, involves thebuying, holding, selling, andshort-sellingofstocks,bonds,commodities, currencies,collectibles, real estate,derivatives, or any valuablefinancial instrument to profitfrom fluctuations in its priceas opposed to buying it for

Page 619: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

use or for income viamethodssuchasdividendsorinterest. Speculation oragiotage represents one offourmarket roles inWesternfinancial markets, distinctfromhedging, long-orshort-term investing, andarbitrage.Convention and especiallysatire sometimes portrayspeculators comically asspeculatinginporkbellies(inwhich a realmarket and real

Page 620: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

speculators exist) and often"losingtheirshirts"ormakinga fortune on small marketchanges.Speculationexistsinmany suchcommodities,but,if measured by value, themost important markets dealin futurescontractsandotherderivatives involvingleverage that can transformasmall market movement intoa huge gain or loss. Mostnon-professional traders lose

Page 621: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

money on speculation, whilethose who do make moneytendtobecomeprofessionals.Occasionally some dramaticeventwill occur, such as theeffortof theHuntbrothers tocornerthesilvermarketorthecurrency speculations ofGeorge Soros or thespeculative trading of NickLeeson, which caused thecollapseofBaringsBank.Bysome definitions, most long-

Page 622: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

term investors, even thosewhobuyandholdfordecadesmay be classified asspeculators, excepting onlythe rare few who are notprimarily motivated byeventually selling at a goodprofit. Some dedicatedspeculators are distinguishedby shorter holding times, theuse of leverage, by beingwillingtotakeshortpositionsas well as long positions (in

Page 623: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

marketswhere thedistinctioncan be reasonably made). Adegree of speculation existsin a wide range of financialdecisions, from the purchaseofahousetoabetonahorse;this is what modern marketeconomists call "ubiquitousspeculation.

" In Security Analysis,Benjamin Graham gave adefinition of speculation in

Page 624: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

relation to investment: "Aninvestment operation is onewhich, upon thoroughanalysis, promises safety ofprincipal and a satisfactoryreturn. Operations notmeeting these requirementsarespeculative."

Page 625: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

MarkTwainEffectIn some U.S. stock markets,theMarkTwain effect is thephenomenon of stock returnsin October being lower thanin other months. The namecomes from the followingquotation attributed to MarkTwain: "October.This is oneof the peculiarly dangerousmonthstospeculateinstocks.The others are July, January,

Page 626: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

September,April,November,May, March, June,December, August, andFebruary." It is interesting tonote both the 1929 and 1987stockmarketcrashesoccurredinOctober.

Page 627: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

TheTrader'sWorstEnemy-aoneleggedchairThinkofa three leggedchairwithonelegrepresenting:

1. Emotional health (family,friends, spiritual needs andpersonalgoals),

2. Physical health (our diets,nutrition, exercise and

Page 628: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

activities),

3.Financialhealth(investing,savings,businessdecisions).

If any one of these legs isbroken, you are going to fallflat on your butt, so try andtake the time to keep theweightspreadoutevenlyoverthemall,andkeepthemallingoodshape.Inthelongrun,itistheonlywayanyofuswillever reach a state of

Page 629: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

"wellbeing" and "happiness"thus developing the state oftruewealthintelligence.

Page 630: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

BuffettandShortSelling"You'll see way more stocksthat are dramaticallyovervalued than dramaticallyundervalued. It'scommonforpromoters tocauseastocktobecome valued at 5-10 timesitstruevalue,butraretofinda stock trading at 10-20%ofits true value. So you mightthinkshortsellingiseasy,but

Page 631: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

it's not. Often stocks areovervaluedbecausethereisapromoteroracrookbehindit.Theycanoftenbootstrapintovalue by using the shares oftheir overvalued stock. Forexample,itit'sworth$10andistradingat$100,theymightbeabletobuildvalueto$50.Then,WallStreetsays,"Hey!Look at all that valuecreation!"and thegamegoeson. [As a short seller,] you

Page 632: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

could run out of moneybefore the promoter runs outof ideas. "Everything we'veever thought about shortingworkedouteventually,butit'svery painful. It's a whole loteasier tomakemoneyon thelongside.Youcan'tmakebigmoney shorting because therisk of big lossesmeans youcan'tmakebigbets."

Page 633: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

PersonalityandtheInvestmentProcessPersonalityisahugefactorintheinvestmentprocess.AttheAustralian InvestorsAssociation Conference onthe Gold Coast in 2012, thefounder of Relate EmpowerDeliver, David Chia, spokeon the subject. Give 10peopleexactlythesamedata,he said, and ask them what

Page 634: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

they think and theywill giveyou10differentanswers.Thedata is the same but ourpersonalities conspire todivine 10 uniqueinterpretations. Personalitiesdictate investment success orfailure,notthedata.Thedatais not the determining factorof success or failure, "You"are. It is well understood inthe texts thathumans arenotgeared to the investment

Page 635: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

process because they aregeared to emotion, likes,dislikes,eventheirtaxstatus,none of which have anybearing on where a shareprice is going to go next butall of which find their wayinto the investment process.For instance, if you findyourselfsaying"IhateXYZ"or "I like ABC" about aparticular stock, you have abias that is preventing a

Page 636: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

clinical decision. Net effect,youshouldbeonthelookoutfor your own bias and forotherpeople'sbias.Themorebias, the less effective theiradvice. Having apredisposition to a particularstock is a dangerous failing.Having a predisposition tooptimisminamarketthathasgonedown9.6percentayearfor five years is a costlyemotional bias. Being

Page 637: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

predisposed to pessimism isthesame.Prideisabias-thedesire not to bewrong - andthere are many ''experts''whose objectivity has beensacrificed to bias based ontheir earlier calls. Themoment they care aboutbeing right or wrong, theyhave lost value. When itcomes to investment, youneedtobecold,dispassionateandunaffected.Onthatbasis,

Page 638: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

who do you trust more:yourself, a guru, or maths,scienceandacomputerchip?

Source: Marcus Padley,author of stock marketNewsletterMarcusToday

Page 639: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

7.BUFFETTBETSBIGONHOUSINGWe simply attempt tobefearfulwhenothers

Page 640: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

are greedy and to begreedy only whenothersarefearful.

WarrenBuffettWhat does Warren Buffettsee thatnooneelsedoes? InJune2012hemadeanoutsizebid on bankrupt mortgagelender ResCap loans-thelatest exampleofhisbet thatthehousingmarketrepresents

Page 641: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

a great investmentopportunity.

Buffett'sBerkshireHathawayplaced bids on a bankruptmortgage lender that it maynot want, in what someinvestors and observers viewas an effort to make moremoneyonBerkshire'sstakeinthe company's bonds.Berkshire hasmade two bidsfor Residential Capital, the

Page 642: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

bankrupt unit of AllyFinancial that makes loansand collects payments onthem.Both bidswere toppedby Nationstar MortgageHoldings, which also makesand services loans. Anauction for the unit was dueto start later in the year.ResCap's parent, AllyFinancial, was previouslyknown as General MotorsAcceptance Corp and was

Page 643: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

once the auto lendingarmofwhat is now GeneralMotorsCo.

ResCap was a majorsubprime lender that becameanalbatrossforGMACwhenlosses ballooned during thefinancialcrisis.Allywantstoshed ResCap's mortgageliabilitiesas it seeks to repaygovernment bailouts. Manybelieve Buffett will buy

Page 644: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ResCap if he has to, butwould rather drive the pricehigherforNationstar.Foronething, Berkshire Hathawaylacks the licenses needed tomake mortgage loans. Foranother, Buffett often shiesawayfromacquiringfinancialcompanies outside of theinsurance business. ButBerkshire Hathaway hasmuch to gain from pushingNationstar to bid more.

Page 645: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Berkshire owned more than$900 million of ResCapjunior secured debt as ofJune, representing more than40 percent of the totaloutstanding for that class.Going into the bankruptcy,whenNationstarwas bidding$2.4 billion, media reportssuggestedthesecuredholderscould get 93 cents on thedollar. But the moreNationstar pays the more

Page 646: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

money Berkshire Hathawaygets. In fact, with the higheroffer from Nationstar,secured bondholders wereexpected to be paid back infull, according to one personinvolved in the restructuring.Even unsecured creditorswere likely to make somerecovery. To outsiders,Buffett's strategy makesperfectsense.

Page 647: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

"The worst-case scenario isheowns itandhe'll justholdonto it," according to oneassetmanagerwho hasmorethan$12millioninBerkshireHathawaystock.

"Thebest-case scenario is heextractsahigherbidand thathelps him on the debt side,"hesaid."Ithinkit'soneofhisbrightermoves."

Page 648: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

DidyouknowtheU.S.housingmarkethassuffereditsbiggestcrashever,causingamajorfallindemandandprices?More than 7 million homeshave been foreclosed -equivalent to the combined

Page 649: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Sydney and Melbournemetropolitan areas. The U.S.economyandhousingmarketare at their absolute lowestpoint in 30 years. Someproperties have plummetedfrom $300,000 to just$40,000. In many instancesAmericans are literallywalking away from theirmortgages. American banksare now extremely cautiousabout lending money for

Page 650: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

houses, while internationalbuyers are snapping upincredible bargains. Butsurprisingly therental returnsonthesepropertieshasstayedthe same. This presents aunique, possibly once in alifetime opportunity forinvestors-anopportunitythathasn’t been seen since thegreatdepressionofthe1930’saccording to somecommentators. This has

Page 651: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

brought on a dramatic swingtowards rentals and, inmanycases, increased rentalreturns. The Aussie dollar isat an all time high - at thetimeofwritingitisalmostatpar with the U.S. dollar.Many readers will painfullyrecall overseas trips in yearsgone by when the Aussiedollar was worth around 50cents!

Page 652: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Recent research shows thatU.S. property prices haverisen for the third monthrunning!

Where else can you investapproximately $50,000 andimmediately star collectingpositivecashflowof15-20%netreturns?

Duetothepotentialofcapitalgrowth, low entry point andhigh rental returns we have

Page 653: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

established that there is alarge demand for UnitedStates property amongstAustralian and New ZealandInvestorsyettherearelimitedservices and resources thatcanassistyouinthisgoal.

For the price the Channel 9show, ‘The Block’, paid forjust oneMelbourne property,you could buy almost fiftycash flow positive properties

Page 654: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

in the U.S. with only 5%deposit!

AsaconsequenceoftheU.S.credit crisis combined withthese conditions internationalinvestors are swooping innow before the U.S. marketbouncesbackup.

Like Warren Buffet, I ambullishabouttheUSHousingmarket and I have been anactivebuyerinthemarketfor

Page 655: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

several years now. No onehas a crystal ball when itcomes to investing but onesavvy investor, Americanhedge fund manager JohnPaulson,was prepared to beton the U.S. property marketcrashing and as aconsequencehemadebillionsof dollars. Paulson became abillionaire by short-sellingsub-primemortgagesin2007,and made $3.5 billion that

Page 656: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

year. In 2010, he beat ahedge-fundrecordbymakingnearly $5 billion. He wasranked39onthe2011Forbeslist of the world's wealthiestpeople with a net worth ofalmost $16 billion. At thetime of writing WarrenBuffet, arguably the mostfamous and respectedinvestor of all time wastaking a contrarian investorstance by investing in U.S.

Page 657: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

housing.Australians arewellknownandrespectedfortheirloveofowningand investingin real estate and manypeople have done very wellfrom real estate in the lasttwentytothirtyyears,thoughatthetimeofwriting,growthprospects have slowed downalittlebutshouldstillprovidestablegrowth.Oneofthekeypoints I like to constantlyremind people attending my

Page 658: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

seminars is that the lessfinancialeducationyouhave,the more money you willneedinordertoretire.Peoplewithafinancialeducationareoften able to do dealswith aminimumdeposit.Becauseofthe slow down in Australianreal estate, as an investor Istarted looking at other areasofpotentialgrowththatmightprovide a higher return thanAustralian real estate. As a

Page 659: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

fan of Buffett’s investmentstrategywhenIheardhewasbullish on the U.S. housingmarket recovery I researchedthe market extensivelyincluding exploring manystreets and suburbs of U.S.cities todiscoverhowtobestprofit fromU.S. housing andestablished an entire team toacquiremeU.S.propertiesonmass.

Page 660: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

8.FINALWORDSFROMTHESAGEOFOMAHA

Page 661: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

In the business world,therear-viewmirror isalwaysclearerthanthewindshield.

WarrenBuffettPersonally, I am nowcomfortable and happy to beinvesting in the U.S. realestatemarket.IhavetravelledtotheU.S.anumberoftimes

Page 662: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

to study and educate myselfand carry out due diligenceon potential opportunities inthe real estate market there.As a result, my initial fears,scepticism andmisconceptions areovercome. Personally I amnowexcitedanddrivenbytheopportunities I found there,and have purchased moreU.S. property. Despite itsoundinglikeatiredcliché,I

Page 663: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

firmly believe the U.S. realestate market currentlypresents a once in a lifetimeopportunity for investors.One of the reasons I amexcited about theseopportunities isbecausewhatwouldtakemillionsofdollarsin Australian real estate toachieve a comfortableretirement position, can beachieved in the U.S. for afractionofthatamount.Asan

Page 664: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

example of the currentopportunitiesatthetopendofthe U.S. property market,former politician Sarah Palinrecently purchased a largehouse in Phoenix for $1.7million. Just a few monthsback an investor hadpurchased it for $800,000. Ipersonally inspected a hugemansion being offered for$960,000 that would sell forat least $5 million in

Page 665: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Australia.

Warren Buffett, the ‘Sage ofOmaha', is generallyconsidered to be the world’smost successful investor andhas inspired countlesscopycats and hangerson. Hisinvestmentvehicle,BerkshireHathaway, is legendary.Investorswouldlovetoknowthe secret of his success - toknow how he became

Page 666: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

America’s second or thirdrichest man, and a livinglegend. For mostshareholders, Buffet can dono wrong. And the evidenceisintheshareprice.Recentlyeach Class A share inBerkshire Hathaway wasworthalmostUS$130,000.Inthe last 40 years,Buffett hasincreased the book value ofthe company by around300,000 percent. Buffett has

Page 667: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

madesomebrilliantmovesinhis career, such as turning a$1 billion investment inWells Fargo into $4 billion;making 500% profits on amassive investment in Geicoand inoneofhisbestknownandmost talked about plays-turning $1 billion into $8billion with Coca-Cola.Buffett is famous for drollquotessuchas

Page 668: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

• “I got interested (inbusiness) when I was sevenor thereabouts. I wasted mytimebeforethat.”

• “Buy businesses that anidiot could run, because onedayonewill.”

• “We really want to buyfrom someone who doesn'twanttosell.”

AsBuffett’s assistantCharlie

Page 669: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Munger tells it, Berkshire istotally out of step withmodern corporate practice. Itbuys firms whosemanagement it admires,keeps that management andleavesthecompaniesalone.Itis worth more than US$100billionandhasonly16peoplein its head office. "Theinteresting thing is how wellit has worked for a greatmany decades, and how few

Page 670: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

peoplecopyit,"Mungersays.BuffettsaysBerkshirehasnoincentives to meet profittargets, believing it mightencourage people to dosomething they wouldn'totherwise do to meet thosetargets. "Businesses don'tneed quarterly expectations,quarterafterquarter,"hesays.Berkshiredoesnotbelieve inasset allocation, a basic tenetof most investment

Page 671: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

companies, whereinvestments are dividedbetween different classes. Itjustlooksforgoodcompaniesat lowprices.Berkshire doesnot believe in "gin rummy"management either, whereonecompanyisdiscardedandanotherbought.Itdoesn'tsellcompanies just because theyarelosingmoney.

Buffett remarks that there is

Page 672: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

no exit from a financialmeltdown. "Think about aburningtheatre.Theonlywayto leave your seat in aburningfinancialmarketistofind someone to take yourseat, which isn't easy."Buffett does not give stocktips, andwhy should he?Hedoes however, from time totime, sound out investmentprinciplesinhisannuallettersto Berkshire Hathaway

Page 673: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

stockholders, in reports toannual meetings and, fromtime to time, in the media.Hisinvestmentsecretscanbegleanedfromthesecommentsand I have researched someof them for this book. Notsurprisingly, they invariablyseem to spell out good,common sense, investmentprinciples.

1. The company should be

Page 674: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

soundly managed. Tests ofgood management include:share buybacks, good use ofretained earnings, sticking towhatyouknow.

2. The company hasdemonstrated earningcapacity with a likelihood ofcontinuation.Testsofearningcapacity include: companygrowth, dealing withinflation, capital expenditure,

Page 675: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

look through earnings, brandnames.

3. The company should haveconsistently high returns.WarrenBuffettwouldlookatboth: Returns on equity andReturnsoncapital.

4. The company should haveaprudentapproachtodebt.

5. The businesses of thecompany should be simple

Page 676: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

and the investor should havean understanding of thecompany.

6. Assuming that all thesethresholds are satisfied, theinvestment should only bemade at a reasonable price,withamarginof safety.Thisis always a matter ofindependentjudgementbytheinvestor but it is relevant toconsider: price/earnings

Page 677: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ratios, earnings and dividendyields, book value,comparativeratesofreturn

7. Investors need to take along term approach. Buffettbelieves, as did BenjaminGraham,thatinvestorsshouldlook upon share investmentasbuyingapartofabusiness.Investors should take thesame approach to buyingshares as they would if they

Page 678: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

were buying a business. Theonlydifferenceisthatinsteadofbuying thewholebusinessor a partnership in thebusiness, they are onlybuyingatinyshare.

A prudent investor neverbuys a business that they donot understand. Similarly, aprudentshare investorshouldnever buy shares in acompany, whose business

Page 679: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

theydonotunderstand.

In 1977, Buffett toldshareholders in BerkshireHathaway that theircompanywould only invest in abusiness that the directorscould understand. He hasrepeated this message manytimes since and expanded onthis theme: ‘We try to stickwith businesses we believewe understand. That means

Page 680: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

theymustberelativelysimpleand stable in character. If abusiness is complex orsubject to constant changewe’re not smart enough topredict future cash flows.Incidentally that shortcomingdoesn’tbotherus.’

Page 681: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

SuccessionPlansInMay2010,Buffett,monthsaway fromhis 80thbirthday,saidhewouldbesucceededatBerkshire Hathaway by ateamconsistingofaCEOandthree or four investmentmanagers; each of the latterwould be responsible for a"significant portion ofBerkshire's investmentportfolio."

Page 682: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Five months later, Berkshireannounced thatToddCombs,manager of the Castle PointCapital hedge fund, wouldjoin them as an investmentmanager. InSeptember2011,Berkshire Hathawayannounced that 50-year-oldTed Weschler, founder ofPeninsula Capital Advisors,will join Berkshire in early2012 as a second investmentmanager. In Berkshire

Page 683: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Hathaway's annual February2012 shareholder letter,Buffettsaidthathissuccessoras CEO had been choseninternally but not namedpublicly. While the intent ofthis message was to bolsterconfidence in the leadershipof a "Buffett-less Berkshire",critics have noted that thisstrategy of choosing asuccessor without a concreteexit strategy for the sitting

Page 684: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

CEO often leaves anorganizationwithfewerlong-term options, while doinglittletocalmshareholderfearin reaction to theannouncement. Oneleadership consultant whospecializes in CEOsuccession, noted, "You seethis more often withsuccessful founder CEOs.Becausethey’resogood,theywant to take the lead in

Page 685: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

choosing their replacement,[but]mostboardstrytoavoidwhatBuffettdid."“Thesafestthing, well, greatest asset toown is your own abilities. Imean, no matter whathappens in the economy orwithcurrency,ifyoudevelopyour own talents, I tell thecollege students that the bestthing to have is your chanceto develop your own talents.The second best thing is to

Page 686: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

buy into other people'stalents. You know, here'sCoca-Cola, and people aregoing to be drinking it 10years or 50 years from now,and they're going to bedrinking more of it, andthey'llmakemoremoney.SoI don't have any idea whatCoca-Cola stock is going todo next week or next monthor next year, but I'm prettydarnsurewherethecompany

Page 687: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

willbein10or20years.Andpeoplebeatthemselvesinthestock market. The stockmarket, literally, in the 20thcentury,wentfrom66ontheDow to 11,400. And you'dsaid,‘Howcouldanybodynothaveagoodexperience?’Butmillions of people don'tbecause they get excited atthewrong time, and they getdepressed at thewrong time.So you've got to put your

Page 688: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

emotionsaside,you'vegot togiveuptheideathatyoucandecide when to buy stocksandwhen to sell stocks. Thetime to buy stocks isconsistentlyovertime.”

Page 689: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ProstateCancerInApril2012WarrenBuffettannouncedthathehasearly-stageprostatecancer,andindicatedhehadnointentionofsteppingdownasheadofhisinvestmentfirmBerkshireHathaway.InalettertoBerkshireshareholders,BuffettsaidhehadbeendiagnosedwithStageIprostatecancerandwould

Page 690: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

undergoradiationtreatmentbeginninginmid-July.Imagingtestsrevealedhehadnocancerinanyotherpartofhisbody,hesaid."ThegoodnewsisthatI'vebeentoldbymydoctorsthatmyconditionisnotremotelylife-threateningorevendebilitatinginanymeaningfulway."Buffettsaidheandhisdoctorshaddecidedonatwo-monthtreatmentofdaily

Page 691: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

radiation,whichwouldrestricthistravel"butwillnototherwisechangemydailyroutine.""Ifeelgreat-asifIwereinmynormalexcellenthealth-andmyenergylevelis100percent,"saidBuffett.Thecancerwasdiscoveredduringaroutinemedicalcheck-upthatshowedanunusuallylargejumpinhisbloodlevelofPSA--aproteinthatisaprostate-

Page 692: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

specificantigenproducedbythecellsoftheprostategland."Iwillletshareholdersknowimmediatelyshouldmyhealthsituationchange.Eventually,ofcourse,itwill;butIbelievethatdayisalongwayoff,"hesaid.

InconclusionItrustyouhavegainednotonlyanincredibleinsightintoarguablytheworldsgreatestinvestorofall

Page 693: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

timebutalsohisdetailedspecificstrategyofinvestmentrules.IamabigbelieverinthepowerofeducationespeciallywhatIcalla‘21stCenturyEducation’.ThatisonetaughtbythosewithaPhDinresultsasopposedtotheeducationofschoolsoruniversitiestaughtbythosegenerallywithaPhDintheory.ThereisnoPhDintheorythatcan

Page 694: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

makeyouamillionaireinvestoronlyonelearntbymodellingsuccessfulpeoplelikeWarrenBuffett.AsImentionedatthestartofthebook,andonnumerousradiointerviews,modellingbillionaireswon’tguaranteeyouwillbecomeone.HoweveritcancertainlyhelpyoubecomeamillionairemodellingpeoplelikeWarrenBuffettandentrepreneurs

Page 695: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

suchasRichardBranson,SteveJobs,MarkZuckerbergandothers.

Formanythoughjustlearninghowtomakeenoughforacomfortableretirementoranicerlifestyleismorethenenoughrewardforlearningandapplyingthesecretsofbillionaireinvestorsandentrepreneurs.Iwishyouwellonyourinvestment

Page 696: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

journeyandIhopeyouhavealsotakensomegreatlifelessons,aswellasinvestmentlessons,fromWarrenBuffetasIhave.AndimportantlyIhopethatyouhaveastrongunderstandingthatsuccesscanberemarkablysimplejustlikeBuffett’sinvestmentstrategyis.Howeversimpledoesn’tcomeeasy.Ittakescouragetoactandtimeandpatienceforresultstooccur.I

Page 697: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

wouldbehappytohearyourfeedback,yourideasandthoughtsorevenquestionsyoumighthaveatamie@21stca.com.au.Orvisitmyblogformorethoughtsandlifelessons:jamiemcintyre.com

Iwishyouwell,

JamieMcIntyre

CEOof21stCentury

Page 698: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Education

September2012

http://www.21stCenturyPublishing.com.auFREECALL(Australia):1800999270FREECALL(NewZealand):0800893302

FAX(Australia):0735039021FAX(NewZealand):093587340

Page 699: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

JAMIEMcINTYRECo-Founderof21stCenturyEducationJamie McIntyre is the founder ofover12companiesthatturnoverinexcess of $40 million dollarsannually.With reach in industriessuch as education, trading,accounting, finance broking, stock

Page 700: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

broking, financial services,recruitment,media,publishingandTV, the 21st Century Group hasgrown to be the largest financialeducationresourceinAustralia.17yearsagoJamierealisedtheworldneededa21stCenturyModerndayeducation rather than the currentout-datededucationsystemcreatedin the industrialisation era of the19th Century. A “21st Century”education that was better thanschooloruniversity and taughtbythose with a PhD in Results, notjust theory. An Education – For

Page 701: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Life! Only 5 years from beingalmostbankrupt,hehadsucceeded- Jamie had become a selfmademillionaire. This incredibleturnaround can be credited toJamie’s extensive research and tothe knowledge he gained fromhissomewhat unconventionalapproach of modeling multi-millionaires, entrepreneurs,investors and success coaches.After producing such outstandingresultsinsomanyareasofhislife,Jamie decided to fulfill a promisehe made to one of his personalmentors and pass on what he had

Page 702: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

learnttoothers.Fromthis,the21stCentury Education and the 21stCentury Group was born. Today,Jamie has educated more than450,000 people worldwide andhelpedthousandsachievefinancialabundance and long-term success.Nominated for ‘Young Australianof the Year’ in 1999 for hisachievements,Jamieisasuccessfulentrepreneur,investor,soughtaftersuccess coach, internationallyrenowned speaker andworldleadingeducator, sharing thestage with some of the world’smost successful entrepreneurs

Page 703: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

(such as Sir Richard Branson,Harry Dent, Tim Ferriss, andmore). He is also the author ofnumerous globally applaudedpublications such as the best-sellingbooks‘WhatIDidn’tLearnAt School But Wish I Had’ and“Think&GrowRichForThe21stCentury”.

http://www.JamieMcIntyre.com

http://www.21stCenturyEducation.com.au

Page 704: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Conclusion

Thank you again fordownloading thisbook!

I hope this book wasabletohelpyouto(fillintheblank).

Page 705: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Thenextstepisto(fillintheblank).

Page 706: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates
Page 707: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Finally,ifyouenjoyedthisbook,thenI’dliketoaskyouforafavor,would you be kindenough to leave areview for this bookon Amazon? It’d be

Page 708: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

greatlyappreciated!

Click here to leave areview for this bookonAmazon!

Thank you and goodluck!

Page 709: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Bonus:SubscribeToTheFreeLifeSuccessTipsandebooks

WhenyousubscribetoLifesuccessviaemail,you will get freeaccess to a vast range

Page 710: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

of exclusivesubscriber-onlyresources. All youhave to do is enteryour email address tothe right to get instantaccess.

These resources willhelpyougetmoreout

Page 711: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

ofyourlife–

To be able to reachyourgoals,

Havemoremotivation,

Beatyourbest,

Makemoneyonline,

Health, Fitness +Muchmore

Page 712: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

live the life you’vealwaysdreamedof.

I’m always addingnew resources to thetoolboxaswell,whichyouwillbenotifiedofas a subscriber. Thesewill help you live lifetothefullest!

Page 713: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates

Click here for lifesuccesstoolkit

Or you can access ithere:http://bit.ly/1pX03Lg

Page 714: REPRESENTS THE WITHOUT ANY - DropPDF1.droppdf.com/files/JV0mV/investment-lessons-learnt-from-warren... · REPRESENTS THE AUTHORS VIEW WITHOUT ANY ... Hathaway Director, Bill Gates