reducing kilowatts - · pdf filesysco case study 100+ food distribution centers (dcs) •...
TRANSCRIPT
Reducing Kilowatts
300,000 Foot View
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Establishing an Effective Distribution Center Energy
Management Strategy
Marcus Wilcox, President
Introduction to Cascade Energy, Inc. • Industrial energy efficiency consulting
– Experts in food processing, pulp & paper, petrochemical, manufacturing, etc. • Refrigeration, compressed air, pumping, fans, controls, process upgrades
– Worked on 700-800 ammonia refrigeration systems – Design and run utility efficiency programs serving >100 electric utilities
• Corporate energy management services for ~350 warehouses – Sysco (all DCs) – Ben E. Keith (all DCs) – SuperValu (all DCs) – Americold (all US & Canada PRWs) – Kroger Logistics, Others……
• We are like Consumer Reports – Don’t sell energy-using products – No brand or contractor preference
• Official EM Service Partner for International Association of Refrigerated Warehouses (IARW)
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Executive Quick Start – 10 Step Program 1. Discuss energy at
executive level 2. Assign an energy
champion or manager 3. Implement tracking
systems and establish KPIs 4. Set a savings goal 5. Set ROI hurdle for energy
projects
6. Leverage utility incentives & tax credits
7. Pursue low and no-cost opportunities
8. Identify, assess and implement capital upgrades
9. Benchmark against other facilities
10. Report progress across organization
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Paths to Reduce Energy Cost 1. Implement Corporate Energy Management Executive
Support, Programs & Systems* 2. Pursue Low-Cost O&M Opportunities*
–Fixing Things –Tuning Things –Changing Your Ways –Commonly called “tune-up”, “commissioning” or “kaizen blitz”
3. Participate in Demand Response* 4. Implement Efficiency into New Construction* 5. Implement Retrofit Capital Projects* 6. Understand & Optimize Utility Rate Schedule *Often eligible for utility training or incentive programs
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Sysco Case Study 100+ food distribution centers (DCs) • Freezers, coolers, dock, and
dry warehouse space
Rolled out program in March, 2006 • Announced by corporate
management • Managed by project
engineering group
Aggressive goals: • 10% after 1st year • 25% after 3rd year • Another 5% by 6th year
Four-Prong approach 1. Corporate goal and
commitment 2. Energy Information Systems 3. Tune-ups at every DC in 18
months 4. Retrofits and high-efficiency
new construction © Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Established Benchmarking System Cubic feet weighted by freezer, cooler/dock, and dry as well as average wet bulb for a normalized “Efficiency Factor” Near real-time monitoring of all major electric meters Entire company can be benchmarked • Rank within company • Rank within benchmark group • Rank within region This report is seen across company Requires monthly collection of 500+ utility bills
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Sample Site Improvement Over Time
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Baseline Companywide Performance Energy Use vs Facility Size - June Utility Bills
- 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000
Weighted Cubic Feet
kWh/
day
2005
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Performance After Tune-Ups Energy Use vs Facility Size - June Utility Bills
- 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000
Weighted Cubic Feet
kWh/
day
2005
2007
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Most Recent Performance
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Energy Use vs Facility Size - June Utility Bills
- 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000
Weighted Cubic Feet
kWh/
day
2005
2007
2010
Year to Year Performance kW
h/da
y/10
00 ft
3
Total Broadline Energy Intensity
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Sysco Results
•Program started in 2006 •Total DC energy intensity (kWh/ft3) reduced by 1/3 •Savings to date = Over 1½ years of free energy!
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Summary • Energy is one of your largest controllable DC expenses
– Refrigeration is the primary driver • Energy efficiency has excellent ROI • Results can be measured and documented
– “You can’t improve what you don’t measure” • Your strategy must be comprehensive to have deep and
lasting impact – Measurement, benchmarking, O&M, retrofit, new constr.
• Energy efficiency is a critical part of any meaningful sustainability or “green” initiatives
© Cascade Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
30,000 Foot View
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Chris Covell, President
Who What Where Why
© Sm
artWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Introduction to
Who: Turnkey Energy Efficiency Services Firm •Americold •US Cold •Price Chopper •Wegman’s
What : Energy Savings for Large Commercial & Industrial Facilities; Administer Utility-Based Energy Efficiency Programs Where: Headquartered in Albany, NY; 8 offices nationwide Why: Help businesses save energy and money; sustainability
© Sm
artWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Eye Level View
Lighting
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
SmartThe right light, at the right place, at the right time.TM
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Light
Fluorescent
LED HID
© Sm
artWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Light
Randy Fletcher VP Logistics & Supply Chain Management
Fluorescent
LED
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Light Energy Savings?
Lumen Output?
Instant On/Off?
Optical Control?
Long Life?
Low Maintenance?
Large Utility Incentives?
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes Yes © SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Fixture Location: spacing & height
Desired Light Levels
The Right Place
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Place
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Albeo
Lusio Lithonia
The Right Place
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Lights on when you need them, off when you don’t.
The Right Time save energy
reduce cooling load longer fixture life
EPAct tax savings
© Sm
artWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Time
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
The Right Time
Randy Fletcher VP Logistics & Supply Chain Management
Occupancy Sensors & Timers in
Offices
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Bryan Genevick, Project Engineer-Mechanical
Advocates Coaches Existing Vendors
© Sm
artWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Beneath the Surface
Mechanical
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
VFDss
VFD Energy Savings
Avg. % Speed Reduction
Potential Energy Savings
10% 22%
50% 83%
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
ECMs
Savings 40-60%
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Logic Based Control Systems
Savings 30%
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Logic Based Control Systems
Gforce NH3 Control System
Randy Fletcher VP Logistics & Supply Chain Management
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Other Mechanical Upgrades
Randy Fletcher VP Logistics & Supply Chain Management
Door Upgrades
Ammonia Refrigeration Upgrades
Boiler Upgrades
Units to Burn Waste
Oil for Heating
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Beneath the Surface
Renewables
Wind
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Solar
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Cogeneration
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved
Chris Covell [email protected]
Bryan Genevick
Marcus Wilcox [email protected]
© SmartWatt Energy 2012, All Rights Reserved