recent progress of physical modeling based...

10
Proceedings of the 6 th International Conference on the Application of Physical Modelling in Coastal and Port Engineering and Science (Coastlab16) Ottawa, Canada, May 10-13, 2016 Copyright ©: Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 1 RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED ON FIELD INVESTIGATIONS OF TSUNAMIS AND STORM SURGES TOMOYA SHIBAYAMA 1 , TAKAHITO MIKAMI 2 , MIGUEL ESTEBAN 3 1 Waseda University, Japan, E-mail: [email protected] 2 Waseda University, Japan, E-mail: [email protected] 3 University of Tokyo, Japan, E-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT Hydraulic laboratory experiments were conducted to ascertain various phenomena observed during recent field surveys of tsunamis and storm surges. Essentially, the nature of tsunami waves appears to be far more complex than the simple experiments that used to be carried out in previous times. Thus, in order to understand the destruction mechanism of different structures, it is necessary to clarify the physical nature of the wave at each location in order to identify whether a solitary wave, a bore wave, a dam break wave or continuous overflow should be used in the modelling. Such experiments allow not only to clarify the destruction mechanisms of tsunamis but also of bore waves, such as the ones observed during the storm surges due to cyclone Sidr in Bangladesh in 2007 and typhoon Yolanda (Haiyan) in the Philippines in 2013. The present paper will summarise the types of laboratory experiments that can be carried out according to the local geographical conditions and nature of the tsunami waves. For example, it will detail the failure of coastal dykes during the 2011 Tohoku Earthquake Tsunami due to local scour, where the continuous overflow of the tsunami wave resulted in the destruction of many dykes, and which was modelled using pump flow to produce supercritical flows running down the onshore slope of dyke. Also, laboratory experiments to reproduce the behaviour of a tsunami wave around structures to reduce inundation -such as detached breakwaters and artificial waterways constructed along the shoreline- will be detailed, amongst other experiments. KEWORDS: TSUMAMI, STORM SURGE, HYDRAULIC LABORATORY, FIELD WORK, BORE 1 INTRODUCTION In the last twelve years the world has been affected by a number of large coastal disasters. For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004 (affecting mainly Indonesia, Sri Lanka and Thailand), the Java Tsunami in 2005 (Indonesia), Samoan Tsunami in 2009, Chilean Tsunami in 2010, Mentawai Tsunami in 2010 (Indonesia) and Tohoku Tsunami in 2011 (Japan). Regarding storm surges, noteworthy events include the storms surges due to hurricane Katrina in 2005 (U.S.A.), cyclone Sidr in 2007 (Bangladesh), cyclone Nargis in 2008 (Myanmar), hurricane Sandy in 2012 (U.S.A.), typhoon Yolanda (Haiyan) in 2013 (Philippines) and the event in Nemuro in 2014 (Japan). Table 1 summarises these events, providing an estimation of the number of casualties that resulted from each, highlighting the vulnerability of coastal settlements against such disasters and how there is still much to be learnt (as highlighted for example in Shibayama (2015) and a book that details many of these disasters, Esteban et al., 2015). Following each of these events, the authors took part in post disaster surveys and attempted to draw a number of important engineering lessons, as summarised below: 1. The nature of tsunami or storm surge wave behaviour can be classified into four different patterns, namely solitary wave type (Java Tsunami), dam break wave, continuous overflow (Tohoku Tsunami) and bore wave. Bore waves were frequently observed in previous tsunamis but have also now been observed in storm surge events, such as for example during cyclone Sidr (Shibayama et al., 2009) and typhoon Yolanda (Roeber and Bricker, 2015, Nakamura et al., 2016) 2. Coastal dykes failed due to a continuous and prolonged water overflow (for twenty minutes or more, such as during the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami or the storm surge during hurricane Katrina, see Shibayama, 2015). Essentially, these structures are typically not designed for overtopping and can catastrophically fail due to scouring of the landside toe

Upload: dinhthien

Post on 05-Jun-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on the Application

of Physical Modelling in Coastal and Port Engineering and Science

(Coastlab16)

Ottawa, Canada, May 10-13, 2016

Copyright ©: Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

1

RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED ON FIELD INVESTIGATIONS

OF TSUNAMIS AND STORM SURGES

TOMOYA SHIBAYAMA1, TAKAHITO MIKAMI2, MIGUEL ESTEBAN3

1 Waseda University, Japan, E-mail: [email protected]

2 Waseda University, Japan, E-mail: [email protected]

3 University of Tokyo, Japan, E-mail: [email protected]

ABSTRACT

Hydraulic laboratory experiments were conducted to ascertain various phenomena observed during recent field surveys

of tsunamis and storm surges. Essentially, the nature of tsunami waves appears to be far more complex than the simple

experiments that used to be carried out in previous times. Thus, in order to understand the destruction mechanism of

different structures, it is necessary to clarify the physical nature of the wave at each location in order to identify whether a

solitary wave, a bore wave, a dam break wave or continuous overflow should be used in the modelling. Such experiments

allow not only to clarify the destruction mechanisms of tsunamis but also of bore waves, such as the ones observed during

the storm surges due to cyclone Sidr in Bangladesh in 2007 and typhoon Yolanda (Haiyan) in the Philippines in 2013. The

present paper will summarise the types of laboratory experiments that can be carried out according to the local geographical

conditions and nature of the tsunami waves. For example, it will detail the failure of coastal dykes during the 2011 Tohoku

Earthquake Tsunami due to local scour, where the continuous overflow of the tsunami wave resulted in the destruction of

many dykes, and which was modelled using pump flow to produce supercritical flows running down the onshore slope of

dyke. Also, laboratory experiments to reproduce the behaviour of a tsunami wave around structures to reduce inundation

-such as detached breakwaters and artificial waterways constructed along the shoreline- will be detailed, amongst other

experiments.

KEWORDS: TSUMAMI, STORM SURGE, HYDRAULIC LABORATORY, FIELD WORK, BORE

1 INTRODUCTION

In the last twelve years the world has been affected by a number of large coastal disasters. For case of tsunamis, major

events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004 (affecting mainly Indonesia, Sri Lanka and Thailand), the Java Tsunami

in 2005 (Indonesia), Samoan Tsunami in 2009, Chilean Tsunami in 2010, Mentawai Tsunami in 2010 (Indonesia) and

Tohoku Tsunami in 2011 (Japan). Regarding storm surges, noteworthy events include the storms surges due to hurricane

Katrina in 2005 (U.S.A.), cyclone Sidr in 2007 (Bangladesh), cyclone Nargis in 2008 (Myanmar), hurricane Sandy in 2012

(U.S.A.), typhoon Yolanda (Haiyan) in 2013 (Philippines) and the event in Nemuro in 2014 (Japan). Table 1 summarises

these events, providing an estimation of the number of casualties that resulted from each, highlighting the vulnerability of

coastal settlements against such disasters and how there is still much to be learnt (as highlighted for example in Shibayama

(2015) and a book that details many of these disasters, Esteban et al., 2015).

Following each of these events, the authors took part in post disaster surveys and attempted to draw a number of

important engineering lessons, as summarised below:

1. The nature of tsunami or storm surge wave behaviour can be classified into four different patterns, namely solitary

wave type (Java Tsunami), dam break wave, continuous overflow (Tohoku Tsunami) and bore wave. Bore waves were

frequently observed in previous tsunamis but have also now been observed in storm surge events, such as for example

during cyclone Sidr (Shibayama et al., 2009) and typhoon Yolanda (Roeber and Bricker, 2015, Nakamura et al., 2016)

2. Coastal dykes failed due to a continuous and prolonged water overflow (for twenty minutes or more, such as during the

2011 Tohoku Tsunami or the storm surge during hurricane Katrina, see Shibayama, 2015). Essentially, these

structures are typically not designed for overtopping and can catastrophically fail due to scouring of the landside toe

Page 2: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

2

and other failure mechanisms (Jayaratne et al., 2015)

3. Coastal forests played an important role to increase water depth behind coastal dykes and prevent the appearance of

supercritical flow over dykes (Tohoku Tsunami, Matsuba et al., 2014).

4. Inundation patterns were strongly influenced by the local topography, (Tohoku Tsunami, Indian Ocean Tsunami, storm

surges due to hurricane Katrina (Shibayama et al., 2005) and the storm in Nemuro). For example, in the case of Tohoku

the existence of artificial waterways constructed along the coastline somewhat influenced the movement of water over

it (Watanabe et al., 2016).

5. Detached breakwaters are a common way to protect against wind waves along the shorelines in Japan, though these can

offer some degree of protection against tsunamis.

6. The transportation of debris by flooding water can exacerbate the destruction caused to structures and houses (storm

surge due to hurricane Katrina and typhoon Yolanda, Chilean tsunamis, Tohoku Tsunami, see Chock, 2015)

Essentially, these field surveys and the lessons learnt from them highlight that the nature of tsunami waves appears to

be far more complex than the simple experiments that used to be carried out in previous times. Thus, in order to attempt to

reproduce the findings from field experiments a number of laboratory experiments have been performed at Waseda

University. These experiments make use of novel methodologies to more realistically simulate the effects of tsunami

overtopping waves over a variety of structures, as outlined in the remaining sections of this paper.

Table 1. List of major coastal disasters since the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami.

2 LABORATORY EXPERIMENTS

2.1 Tsunami or Storm Surge Generation in Laboratory

In the past, tsunami waves in the laboratory were often reproduced using solitary waves or dam break flows (Esteban et

al., 2015). However, it is now clear that the behaviour of tsunami and storm surge waves as they attack the coastline is far

more complex than previously thought (Bricker et al., 2015). Judging from video footage of the 2011 Tohoku tsunami these

events result in a complex array of failure mechanisms and inundation patterns, with one of the defining failure modes being

the overtopping effect of the wave. A prolonged overflowing effect generates a very intense current, and many structures

along the Tohoku coastline appeared to have failed due to scour of the landside toe of the structure (Jayaratne et al., 2015).

This has led some researchers (Kato et al., 2012, Sakakiyama, 2012) to state that the main failure mode is directly related to

this overflowing current. As such, the use of solitary waves to simulate tsunamis during laboratory experiments might not

be valid for the case of overflowing tsunamis. This in effect reduces the validity of some research carried out in the past,

highlighting the need for location and structure specific laboratory experiments, and essentially meaning that none of the

tsunami generation methods most commonly employed can alone successfully reproduce all possible failure mechanisms

due to tsunami attack. Figure 1 shows three of the main types of tsunami generation methods that are currently being

employed in Japan and other countries to reproduce the various types of tsunami destruction mechanisms, and the

laboratory researcher must carefully consider which method to use in order to correctly reproduce the failure mechanism he

or she wishes to investigate.

It is also worth noting that it is also now understood that storm surges can also be far more complex than previously

thought. For the case of cyclone Sidr, bore waves were observed by refugees in cyclone shelters, changing the old

perception of a storm surge being a simple change in water level, and highlighting how they could bring about high

Year Disasters Locations Number of

confirmed casualties

(including those still

missing)

Special Remarks

2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami Indonesia/Sri Lanka/Thailand 220,000

2005 Storm Surge by Hurricane Katrina USA 1,200

2006 Java Tsunami Indonesia 668

2007 Storm Surge by Cyclone Sidr Bangladesh 5,100 Construction of Cyclone Shelters

(1970: 400,000 1991: 140,000)

2008 Storm Surge by Cyclone Nargis Myanmar 138,000

2009 Tsunami in Samoa Islands Samoa 183

2010 Chile Tsunami Chile 500

2010 Tsunami in Mentawai Islands Indonesia 500

2011 Tohoku Tsunami Japan Death 15,894

Unknown 2,562

2012 Storm Surge by Hurricane Sandy USA (New York) 147 (USA 72) 2.5-3.0m in Manhattan

Around 4.0m in Staten Island

2013 Storm Surge by Typhoon Yolanda Philippines Death 6,300

Unknown 1,062

2014 Storm Surge in Nemuro Japan -

Page 3: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

3

momentum bore flows (Shibayama et al., 2009). This was corroborated during the storm surge due to typhoon Yolanda,

where bore waves were also created, flooding over land and destroying many houses and structures (Roeber and Bricker,

2015). Thus, it is clearly necessary for those working in laboratory experiments to carefully take into account the local

bathymetry and conditions due to each tsunami or storm surge in order to reproduce what is observed during post disaster

field surveys. A careless approach to take into account such considerations can lead to the formulation of experiments that

do not accurately represent the reality of these types of disasters, and potentially lead to flawed structures that fail to

improve the resilience of coastal communities.

Figure 1. Different types of tsunami generation in laboratory (Mikami et al., 2014).

2.2 Coastal Dyke Failure due to Overflow (Mikami et al., 2014)

(1) Velocity and Pressure Field

During the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami many coastal dykes along the Pacific coast of Tohoku were damaged, with field

survey reports indicating that the landward side of structures suffered more severe damage than the seaward side (see

Jayaratne et al., 2015, Mikami et al., 2012 and other papers in the 2012 CEJ special issue on the Tohoku Tsunami). The

mechanisms of failure of the landward sides of damaged coastal dykes included a failure of the covering materials, washout

of the inner soil, and scouring (see Jayaratne et al., 2015, for a more complete description of these mechanisms). Damage

was mainly caused by the overflowing nature of the tsunami, which continued for a long time, as stated earlier.

In order to understand the hydraulic characteristics and damage mechanisms of a prolonged overflowing tsunami on a

coastal dyke laboratory experiments were carried out in a wave flume (dimension: 12m long, 0.4m wide, and 0.6m high) at

Waseda University, Japan. Figure 2 shows the layout of the laboratory experiments, which were carried out on a scale of

1/50. To generate a prolonged overflowing tsunami in the flume, pump flow was used (instead of a solitary wave or a dam

break mechanism). By controlling the initial water depth and the flow rate generated by the pump, three different types of

overflowing tsunamis on the dyke model could be generated, as shown in Figure 3. By changing the downstream

boundary condition, three different overflow patterns appeared (as the downstream water depth increasing flows went from

the a pattern to the c pattern). To understand the basic hydraulic characteristics of each flow type, the velocity field around

the dyke model was visualized and the pressure acting on the dyke model surface was measured.

The velocity field around the dyke for each flow type was analyzed by using a visualization technique, the Particle

Tracer Method) (see the right part of Figure 3). By using laser beams, tracers were visualized, representing water particle

movements. In types (a) and (b) a supercritical flow was generated along the landward side of the dyke model surface.

However, when the downstream depth increased (type c), a supercritical flow was not generated, and the velocity near the

pump

(a) solitary wave

(b) dam break flow

(c) pump flow

Page 4: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

4

landward side of the dyke model surface was lower than the upper flow. These results indicate that the high velocity flow

along the dyke surface observed in type (a) and (b) can cause severe scouring failure, as observed in many dykes during

field surveys of the damage due to the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami (Jayaratne et al., 2015)

Pressure profiles were obtained from instruments placed at 6 points along the dyke surface model. In type (a) and (b),

the on-offshore profiles of pressure distribution were similar, though differed considerably to those of (c). Essentially, for

cases (a) and (b) the pressure on the top of the landward slope the pressure was lower, and on the toe of the landward slope

higher. These results indicate that the non-uniform pressure profile on the landward slope in type (a) and (b) can cause

instability in any existing concrete panels covering the core of the dyke (as was the case in many dykes present in the

Tohoku regions, see Jayaratne et al., 2015, Mikami et al., 2012)

Figure 2. Layout of dyke overflow laboratory experiments.

Figure 3. Flow types of overflowing tsunamis around a coastal dyke.

(2) Scour Behind Coastal Dyke Induced by Overflowing Tsunami

Laboratory experiments were carried out in a newly built tsunami basin physical modelling facility (dimension: 9m

20 cm

200 cm 200 cm

dyke model

pump

10 cm

20 cm 10 cm 20 cm

before generating a flow

during overflowing

10 cm

(a) layout

(b) dyke model

depth

(a)

(b)

(c)

subcriticalflow

supercriticalflow

hydraulic jump

vortex generation

(a)

(b)

(c)

Page 5: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

5

long, 4m wide, and 0.5m high) at Waseda University collaborating with University of East London (Dr. Ravindra Jayaratne).

Tsunami-like waves were generated by chambers with electrically controllable valves on one side of the basin. Wave

heights and waveforms were controlled by the initial water level in the chambers and the valves. The authors designed and

constructed a dyke model and placed behind it a sand section to simulate the ground adjacent to a dyke protecting a beach

section in Tohoku. The dyke was manufactured from stainless steel in order to observe only the scour behind a coastal dyke

induced by an overflowing tsunami, as shown in Figure 4. The experiments were carried out on a scale of 1/50.

Wave heights and waveforms were changed to test the sensitivity of the scour depth and profile caused by the

overflowing waves. The laboratory experiments indeed indicated how an overtopping tsunami can cause significant scour in

the landside toe of a dyke, as shown on Figure 5. This failure mode is quite significant, as during field surveys it was

observed how in many cases this scour probably gradually expanded and undermined the entire landside of the structure,

leading to its ultimate collapse. As a result, most of the rebuilt dykes in Tohoku now have some type of landside toe

protection, which was absent in many structures present before the 2011 Tohoku tsunami. This signals a clear difference in

design philosophy, as the original structures had not been designed for overtopping, but present Japanese disaster

management philosophy allows structures to be overtopped for the case of level 2 tsunamis (see Shibayama et al. 2014, for a

summary of current Japanese philosophy regarding tsunami classification).

Figure 4. Experimental setup.

Figure 5. Example of scour profile.

2.3 A New Disaster Prevention Function for Coastal Forests (Matsuba et al., 2014)

As shown in the previous section, if an overflowing tsunami on a coastal dyke does not generate a supercritical flow in

its landward side, the coastal dyke is more likely survive the overflowing tsunami event (taking into account the

characteristics of the velocity field and pressure around the landward slope). Possible solutions to prevent such supercritical

flow from appearing include the placing of some obstructions or to make the landward slope milder. In fact, prior to the

2011 Tohoku Tsunami, and even at present, in some coastal areas in Tohoku (especially along the Sendai Plain coast)

coastal forests were located behind coastal dykes. Hence, in order to investigate the effect of coastal forests on an

overflowing tsunami around coastal dykes, laboratory experiments were carried out at the wave flume in Waseda University

that was described earlier.

A coastal forest model (scale 1/50) was placed behind the coastal dyke model, with Figure 6 showing a snapshot of the

10 cm

20 cm

15 cm 7.5 cm 20 cm50 cm

sand section dyke section 1/10 slope

8 cm

wave

Page 6: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

6

overflowing tsunami. The experimental results show how indeed a coastal forest can help to reduce the damage to coastal

dykes caused by an overflowing tsunami, by increasing water depth behind the dyke and changing the flow type. Also, it

appears that the length of the coastal forest is an important factor that can contribute to make the structure more resilient,

and thus coastal forests of appropriate length should be considered. Essentially, it would appear that a small forest is

unlikely to significantly alter the flow pattern of the water, and it should be noted that in such cases the rapid flow of water

is likely to damage the trees, which can become floating debris and further contribute to structural damage in areas behind

the forest. Thus, it would appear that for a forest to be considered as an appropriate mitigation measure (both to alleviate

damage to the dyke and any human settlements located behind it) it should be a rather thick large forest, rather than a small

area of isolated trees.

Figure 6. Laboratory experiment of an overflowing tsunami on a dyke with a coastal forest model (Matsuba et al., 2014).

2.4 Influence of Local Topography on Flooding Water (Watanabe et al., 2016)

During the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami there were eyewitness testimonies that the tsunami inundation height was reduced

due to the presence of the Teizan Canal along the coast of the Sendai Plain (the canal is 25 to 45 m wide, 49 km long, and

0.3 to 2 m deep). Field data obtained after the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami confirmed eyewitness accounts, though this effect has

not been studied in the past. Thus, in order to understand the detailed characteristics of an overflowing tsunami over a canal,

laboratory experiments were performed in the tsunami basin and wave flume described earlier. In the tsunami basin, the

amount of flow over the canal model was measured under different wave conditions and for different canal depths. In the

wave flume, the fluid motion over the canal model was visualized by PIV (Particle Image Velocimetry) .

Figure 7 shows the experimental layout of the experiments carried out in the tsunami basin, with Figure 8 showing a

detailed view of the canal model installed at the onshore end on the basin. The offshore water depth was set to 20 cm. An

overflow measurement device was placed behind the canal model, which stored the water that went over the canal model.

The experiments were carried out on a scale of 1/100. The wave height, waveform, and water depth in the canal model were

changed to test their influence on the amount of overflow. The wave heights at three different locations were measured

using wave gauges (KENEK Co., LTD.) with a sampling frequency of 50 Hz. The experiments were repeated for three

different conditions, one with the canal, and the other two for two different canal depths (2cm and 4cm). Three types of

waves were generated. The experiments were performed at least twice for each of the cases, and the final results were the

average of the measurements taken.

In order to investigate the fluid motion of flow in a canal, a different series of laboratory experiments was performed in

the wave flume at Waseda University, using a 1/50 scale. Figure 9 shows the experimental layout. A pump was installed to

produce an overflow over the canal model, where the flow rate could be changed by controlling a handle attached to the

pump. The inflow fluid motion was analyzed using PIV. A tracer (Diaion HP20SS, Mitsubishi Chemical Corp.) was used so

that a laser light (PIV Laser, KATOKOKEN CO., LTD) could visualize the water flowing over the focus area. The

visualized flow image was captured by using a high speed camera (High Speed Camera K4, KATOKOKEN CO., LTD)

Page 7: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

7

with high magnification zoom lens (Nikkor lens 50mm f/1.2, Nikon Corp.). Finally, the images that were taken were

analyzed by using fluid analysis software (FlowExpert2D2C, KATOKOKEN CO., LTD) and the velocity field was

obtained. The experiments were performed for 3 cases of volume flow rate (Q = 0.0109 m3/s, 0.0139 m3/s, and 0.0170 m3/s)

in 500 fps of shatter speed.

The laboratory experiments in the tsunami basin showed that the canal reduced the amount of overflow, and that the

amount of overflow became larger as the water depth in the canal gradually increased. The amount of overflow depended

not only on the height of the wave, but also on the waveform. The experiments in the canal showed that the inflow

characteristics are actually more complicated than initially expected, and more experiments are needed to clarify how a

tsunami wave interacts with a canal.

Figure 7. Experimental layout in a tsunami basin (Watanabe et al., 2016).

Figure 8. Canal model and overflow measurement equipment (Watanabe et al., 2016).

4.5m1m0.15m0.3m

Slope(1/10)

Slope(1/20) 1m

0.5m

Wave generator(Chamber type)

1m

0.2m0.3m

1m1m

Wave

2m

Canal model

Overflow measurement equipment

2m

WG2 WG1WG3

5 cm

15 cmSlope

WaveOverflow

measurementequipment

8cm15cm

WG3

15 cm50 cm

Canal model

30 cm

Page 8: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

8

Figure 9. Experimental layout in a wave flume (Watanabe et al., 2016).

2.5 Effect of Detached Breakwater (Mikami et al., 2015)

Field surveys after the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami indicated that the presence of discontinuous detached breakwaters in

front of coastal dykes greatly affected damage patterns (Mikami et al., 2014). Laboratory experiments were thus carried out

in the tsunami basin detailed earlier (scale 1/50) to clarify such damage patterns, as shown in Figure 10. The field data

obtained from the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami showed that tsunami flow along the coastal dykes was not uniform, due mainly to

the specific arrangement of the discontinuous detached breakwaters in front of the dyke (see Figure 10 to understand a

typical layout). The results from the laboratory experiments showed that the presence of a detached breakwater had a

mitigation effect on the shoreline right behind the main body of each of the sections of the detached breakwater if a given

parameter (namely the distance from the shoreline/length of the opening) was small. On the other hand, the shoreline areas

directly behind the gaps in the detached breakwater suffered the full brunt of the tsunami, as the breakwaters did not

mitigate the impact of the wave. The results obtained from the laboratory experiments agreed well with the field data

obtained after the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami. PIV measurements were also carried out, as shown in Figure 11, though it is clear

that there is still much to learn about the behaviour of the tsunami wave for the case of complex interactions between two

sets of structures, and this should be further investigated in future laboratory experiments.

Figure 10. Experimental set-up in tsunami basin for detached breakwater effect (Mikami et al., 2015).

pump

Canal modelFocus area

20 cm

200 cm 200 cm 45 cm23.5 cm

6 cm60 cmSlope

4 m

9 m

0.5 m1 m

0.5 m

chambers

air valves

4 chambers

4 air valves for each chamber

connected to vacuum pump

slope(1/20)

slope(1/10)

2 m 2 m0.5 m

: Current Meter

shor

elin

e

detached breakwaters

: Wave Gauge

2 m

ld

lo

Page 9: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

9

Figure 11. Velocity field by using PIV for detached breaker case (Mikami et al., 2015) .

2.6 Debris Movement due to Flooded Water (Nistor et al., 2016)

In many tsunami events, such as the 2010 Chilean Tsunami (see Mikami, 2011) and the 2011 Tohoku Tsunami, many

port containers were transported by the tsunami and crashed onto structures, clearly highlighting the need for a better

analysis of debris movements under tsunami and storm surges. Figure 12 shows an experimental set-up for container

movements under tsunami overflow in the tsunami basin, which in this case was used to model a port apron. The green

boxes at the front of the photograph represent model containers, whereas the wooden blocks behind them are buildings in

the port area. The experiments were carried out on a scale of 1/40. The experiments tracked the movement of the containers

using a radar system, which were analysed to reveal the fluid motion. The experiments showed that when bore waves broke

at the edge of apron they hit the “containers” and started to move. Also, it was clear that the interaction amongst the

container units were important.

Figure 12. Experimental set-up in tsunami basin for container movement (Nistor et al., 2016).

3 CONCLUSIONS

During the last 12 years intensive field investigations have been performed after each major flooding coastal disasters,

whether it was a tsunami or storm surge. Based on the results of the field surveys it has become clear that there is a need for

far more complex and detailed laboratory experiments that the rather simple approaches used in the past, and to adapt the

type of experimental apparatus employed to the damage mechanism under study. There are different ways of modelling a

tsunami wave or storm surge, including the use of solitary waves, dam break mechanisms, and flows over structures. Each

of these setups can help to reproduce a certain aspect of a tsunami or storm surge, and when designing laboratory

Page 10: RECENT PROGRESS OF PHYSICAL MODELING BASED …rdio.rdc.uottawa.ca/publications/coastlab16/coastlab4.pdf · For case of tsunamis, major events include the Indian Ocean Tsunami in 2004

10

experiments especial care must be given to employ the right methodology to understand the problem being tacked. Success

in doing so can lead to correct designs, which can decrease the risk of failure of disaster management strategies, leading to

an increase in the safety of coastal settlements and a decrease in the human losses suffered during major events.

It is also clear that much is still not well understood about the nature and characteristics of coastal disasters, and that

there is still a need to perform further laboratory experiments of increased precision to improve the understanding of how

these phenomena affect coastal infrastructure.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The studies and laboratory experiments that were detailed in this manuscript were supported by the Japanese Ministry

of Education (MEXT) under the Strategic Research Foundation Grant for Private Universities (No. S1311028).

REFERENCES

Bricker, J. D., Nakayama, A., Takagi, H., Mitsui, J. and Miki, T. (2015), Mechanisms of Damage to Coastal Structures due to the 2011

Great East Japan Tsunami. In Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for Engineers and Planners. Esteban, M., Takagi, H. and

Shibayama, T. (eds.). Butterworth-Heinemann (Elsevier), Oxford, UK

Chock, G. (2015), The ASCE 7 Tsunami Loads and Effects Design Standard for the U.S.. In Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for

Engineers and Planners. Esteban, M., Takagi, H. and Shibayama, T. (eds.). Butterworth-Heinemann (Elsevier), Oxford, UK

Esteban, M., Takagi, H. & Shibayama, T. (eds.) (2015), Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for Engineers and Planners, Elsevier,

ISBN: 978-0-12-801060-0.

Esteban, M., Thao, N. D., Takagi, H., Jayaratne, R., Mikami, T. and Shibayama, T. (2015), Stability of Breakwaters Against Tsunami

Attack, in Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for Engineers and Planners. Esteban, M., Takagi, H. and Shibayama, T. (eds.).

Butterworth-Heinemann (Elsevier), Oxford, UK

Jayaratne, R., Premaratne, B., Mikami, T., Matsuba, S., Shibayama, T., Esteban, M. and Marriott, M. (2015), Destruction of Coastal

Structures After the 2011 Great Eastern Japan Earthquake Tsunami in Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for Engineers and

Planners. Esteban, M., Takagi, H. and Shibayama, T. (eds.). Butterworth-Heinemann (Elsevier), Oxford, UK

Kato, F., Suwa, Y., Watanabe, K., and Hatogai, S. (2012), Mechanism of Coastal Dike Failure Induced by the Great East Japan

Earthquake Tsunami. Proc. of 33rd Int. Conf. on Coastal Engineering, Santander, Spain.

Matsuba, S., Mikami, T., Jayaratne, R. & Shibayama, T. (2014), Analysis of Tsunami Behavior and the Effect of Coastal Forest in

Reducing Tsunami Force around the Coastal Dykes, Proceedings of the 34th ICCE, Seoul, Korea.

Mikami, T., Matsuba, S. & Shibayama, T. (2014), Flow Geometry of Overflowing Tsunamis around Coastal Dykes, Proceedings of the

34th International Conference on Coastal Engineering (ICCE), Seoul, Korea.

Mikami, T., Kinoshita, M., Matsuba, S., Watanabe, S. & Shibayama, T. (2015), Detached Breakwaters Effects on Tsunamis around

Coastal Dykes, Procedia Engineering, 116, 422-427. (Proceeding of the 8th International Conference on Asian and Pacific Coasts

(APAC), IIT Madras, Chennai, India) [doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2015.08.307]

Mikami, T., Shibayama, T., Takewaka, S., Esteban, M., Ohira, K., Aranguiz, R., Villagran, M. & Ayala, A. (2011), Field Survey of

Tsunami Disaster in Chile 2010, Journal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers, Ser. B3 (Ocean Engineering), 67(2), I_529-I_534. (in

Japanese)

Mikami, T., Shibayama, T., Esteban, M. and Matsumaru, R., (2012), Field Survey of the 2011 Tohoku Earthquake and Tsunami in

Miyagi and Fukushima Prefectures, Coastal Engineering Journal (CEJ), Vol. 54, No. 1, pp. 1-26

Nistor, I., Goseberg, N., Mikami, T., Shibayama, T., Stolle, J., Nakamura, R., Matsuba, S. (2016), Experimental Investigation of Debris

Dynamics over a Horizontal Plane, J. of Waterways, Ports, Coastal and Ocean Eng. (ASCE), (under review).

Nakamura, R., Shibayama, T., Esteban, M., & Iwamoto, T. (2016), Future typhoon and storm surges under different global warming

scenarios: case study of typhoon Haiyan (2013), Natural Hazards, in press. [doi:10.1007/s11069-016-2259-3]

Roeber, V. and Bricker, J. (2015), Destructive tsunami-like wave generated by surf beat over a coral reef during Typhoon Haiyan. Nature

Communications 6, doi: 10.1038/ncomms8854

Sakakiyama, T. (2012), Stability of Armour Units of Rubble Mound Breakwater against Tsunamis, Proc. of 32nd Int. Conf. on Coastal

Engineering, Santander, Spain.

Shibayama, T., Tajima, Y., Kakinuma, T., Nobuoka, H., Yasuda, T., Ahsan, Raquib, Rahman, Mizanur, Shariful Islam, M., (2009), Field

survey of storm surge disaster due to Cyclone Sidr in Bangladesh, In: Proc. of Coastal Dynamics 2009, No. 129.

Shibayama, T. (2015), Field Surveys of Recent Storm Surge Disasters, Procedia Engineering, 116, 179-186. (Proceeding of the 8th

International Conference on Asian and Pacific Coasts (APAC), IIT Madras, Chennai, India) [doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2015.08.280]

Shibayama, T. (2015), 2005 Storm Surge by Hurricane Katrina. in Handbook of Coastal Disaster Mitigation for Engineers and Planners.

Esteban, M., Takagi, H. and Shibayama, T. (eds.). Butterworth-Heinemann (Elsevier), Oxford, UK

Shibayama, T., Esteban, M., Nistor, I., Takagi, H., Danh Thao, N., Matsumaru, R., Mikami, T., Aranguiz, R., Jayaratne, R. and Ohira, K.

(2013), Classification of Tsunami and Evacuation Areas, Journal of Natural Hazards, 67 (2), 365-386

Watanabe, S., Mikami, T. & Shibayama, T.(2016) Laboratory Study on Tsunami Reduction Effect of Teizan Canal, submitted to Coastlab.

2016.