pursuing law and practicing law are two different things.pdf

8/10/2019 Pursuing law and practicing law are two different things.pdf

1/32Page 1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO.4232 OF 2007

Archana Girish Sabnis Appean! "s#

Vers$s

%ar C&$nci &' In(ia an( &!hers

Resp&n(en!"s#

JUDGMENT

M.Y. Eqbal, J.)

This appea b* specia ea+e is (irec!e( a,ains! !he

-$(,.en! an( &r(er (a!e( /01213004 passe( b* !he Hi,h

C&$r! &' J$(ica!$re a! %&.ba* 5hereb* 6ri! Pe!i!i&n N&14/77

&' 3003 pre'erre( b* !he appean! 5as (is.isse(1

1


2/32Page 2

31 The case &' !he appean! in brie' is !ha! a'!er

c&.pe!i&n &' pr&'essi&na c&$rse i1e1 Licen!ia!e &' !he C&$r!

&' E8a.iners in H&.&e&pa!h* .e(icines "LCEH#9 she !&&:

a(.issi&n !& LL1%1 c&$rse c&n($c!e( b* Uni+ersi!* &'

M$.bai1 I! is s$b.i!!e( b* !he appean! !ha! LCEH is

c&nsi(ere( as e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n (e,ree b* !he

Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* an( s$ch (ecisi&n is e+en

appr&+e( b* !he G&+ern.en! &' In(ia '&r e;$a!in, !he pa*

scaes1

71 The Uni+ersi!* &' M$.bai a(.i!!e( !he appean! !& a5

c&$rse a'!er sa!is'*in, i!se' as re,ar(s !he e;$i+aence &'

!he pr&'essi&na ;$ai'ica!i&n p&ssesse( b* her1 A'!er

c&.pe!i&n &' her LL1%1 (e,ree c&$rse9 !he appean! bein,

(esir&$s &' prac!icin, a5 s$rren(ere( her cer!i'ica!e &'

prac!icin, h&.&e&pa!h*9 5hich 5as ($* accep!e( b*

Maharash!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* &n 3


3/32Page 3

A(+&ca!e an( &n :n&5in, !ha! her case has been re'erre( !&

%ar C&$nci &' In(ia '&r cari'ica!i&n as re,ar(s her ei,ibii!*

!& ,e! enr&e( 5i!h re'erence !& her ,ra($a!i&n ;$ai'ica!i&n9

!he appean! .a(e represen!a!i&n !& !he %ar C&$nci &'

In(ia1 On 371/130039 !he %ar C&$nci &' Maharash!ra an(

G&a in'&r.e( appean! !ha! she cann&! be c&nsi(ere( '&r

enr&.en! as an A(+&ca!e as her ;$ai'ica!i&n LCEH is n&!

rec&n,ni>e( b* %ar C&$nci &' In(ia1

e( as

e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n1 I! has been c&n!en(e( &n beha' &'

!he appean! !ha! !he %ar C&$nci &' Maharash!ra &r %ar

3


4/32


5/32Page 5

'&r !he c&$rses in h&.e&pa!h* c&n($c!e( b* +ari&$s

ins!i!$!i&ns1 Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* a'!er

c&nsi(erin, +ari&$s c&$rses an( n&.enca!$res '&r !he

c&$rses in DMS9 DHMS9 LCEH9 e!c1 (eci(e( !& ha+e &ne

c&..&n n&.enca!$re '&r ,ra($a!i&n c&$rse in

h&.&e&pa!h* i1e1 %HMS1 Pr&'essi&na c&$rse &' LCEH in

h&.&e&pa!h* c&.pe!e( earier b* !he appean! 5as

c&nsi(ere( as e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n (e,ree b* !he

Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h*1 I! is '$r!her pea(e( !ha!

!he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia (&es n&! e+en ha+e a (e'ine( p&ic*

as re,ar(s !he e;$i+aen! &' e($ca!i&na ;$ai'ica!i&n !& !he

,ra($a!i&n (e,ree an( !he %ar C&$nci .a:es a (ecisi&n &n

case !& case basis an( s$ch pr&ce($re i!se' is $n'air an(

arbi!rar* 5i!h&$! an* ,$i(eines an( in !ha! case !he (ecisi&n

&' &!her pr&'essi&na b&(* i:e Cen!ra C&$nci &'

H&.&e&pa!h* an( aca(e.ic b&(* i:e Uni+ersi!* &' M$.bai

sh&$( be (ecisi+e1

5


6/32Page 6

B1 Learne( c&$nse '$r!her c&n!en(e( !ha! in !he absence

&' !he (e'ine( p&ic* &' !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia as !& 5hich

e($ca!i&na ;$ai'ica!i&n can be !rea!e( as e;$i+aen! !&

,ra($a!i&n (e,ree9 !here 5as n& n&!ice 5ha!s&e+er !& !he

appean! as re,ar(s !he +ie5 !a:en &r !& be !a:en b* %ar

C&$nci &' In(ia9 an( !here'&re9 i! 5as per'ec!* e,a an(

reas&nabe '&r !he appean! !& ass$.e !ha! !he (ecisi&n

!a:en b* !he Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* an( Uni+ersi!*

&' M$.bai an( G&+ern.en! &' In(ia are e,a* c&rrec!1 In

!he presen! case9 !he appean! (i( n&! ,e! e+en an

&pp&r!$ni!* !& pers$a(e !he %ar C&$nci !& see an( e8a.ine

!he +ie5 p&in! &' !he appean!1 I! is s$b.i!!e( b* !he

appean! !ha! a'!er c&.pe!i&n &' her LL1%1 c&$rse9 she as&

c&.pe!e( LL1M 5i!h sec&n( ran: in Uni+ersi!* &' M$.bai

an( a! presen! she is 5&r:in, as a Me.ber9 Dis!ric!

C&ns$.er F&r$.9 Thane1 Since !he &,ica 'a &$! &' !he

(ecisi&n &' !he %ar C&$nci is +ir!$a* !he re+ersa &' !he

appean!s a(.issi&n !& !he a5 c&$rse9 in!er'erence &' !his

6


7/32Page 7

C&$r! has been s&$,h! b* !he appean! in !he in!eres! &'

-$s!ice1

?1 Mr1 Ar(hen($.a$i $.ar Prasa(9 earne( c&$nse

appearin, '&r !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia s$b.i!!e( !ha! $n(er

!he pr&+isi&ns &' A(+&ca!es Ac! an( R$es 'ra.e(

!here$n(er9 %ar C&$nci &' In(ia is e.p&5ere( !& a* (&5n

s!an(ar(s &' e,a e($ca!i&n an( rec&,ni!i&n &' (e,rees in

a5 '&r !he p$rp&se &' a(.issi&n as a(+&ca!es1 The

;$ai'ica!i&n p&ssesse( b* !he appean! 5as a! n& p&in! &'

!i.e c&nsi(ere( as e;$i+aen! !& a ,ra($a!e (e,ree &' a

$ni+ersi!* b* !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia1 Nei!her appean! n&r

!he Uni+ersi!* .a(e an* en;$ir* 5i!h %ar C&$nci &' In(ia

ab&$! !he ei,ibii!* &' s!$(en!s h&(in, !he LCEH

;$ai'ica!i&n '&r a(.issi&n in !he !hree *ear a5 c&$rse1 The

(ecisi&n &' Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* !rea!in, LCEH as

e;$i+aen! !& (e,ree is n&! bin(in, &n !he %ar C&$nci &'

In(ia1 I! has been c&n!en(e( !ha! !he (ecisi&n &' !he

G&+ern.en! !& !rea! cer!ain c&$rses in H&.e&pa!h* as

7


8/32Page 8

e;$i+aen! !& (e,ree 5as !a:en '&r (e!er.inin, !he pa*

scaes an( a+&i(in, an* (ispari!* in an* scaes &' !h&se

h&(in, (i''eren! ;$ai'ica!i&ns in H&.e&pa!h*1 This cann&!

be c&ns!r$e( as a (ecisi&n rec&,ni>in, !he sai( ;$ai'ica!i&n

'&r '$r!her s!$(ies in !he sa.e s$b-ec! &r in an* &!her

s$b-ec!1 F$r!her.&re9 b* !he i.p$,ne( (ecisi&n9 !he %ar

C&$nci &' In(ia is n&! 5i!h(ra5in, !he LL1%1 (e,ree sec$re(

b* !he appean!9 b$! 5ha! is bein, (enie( !& !he appean! is

!he enr&.en! as an a(+&ca!e1

=1 Learne( c&$nse s$b.i!!e( !ha! e!!er &' !he appean!

(a!e( 30!h March9 3003 5as pace( be'&re !he Le,a

E($ca!i&n C&..i!!ee &' !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia a! i!s

.ee!in,s he( &n 3?!h9 3=!han( 70!hJ$ne9 3003 an( !he Le,a

E($ca!i&n C&..i!!ee c&nsi(ere( !he sa.e an( .a(e !he

'&&5in, rec&..en(a!i&ns)@

Le,a E($ca!i&n c&..i!!ee c&nsi(ere( !he

e!!er recei+e( 'r&. Mrs1 Archana Girish Sabnisre;$es!in, !he c&$nci !& rec&,ni>e L1C1E1H1(e,ree a5ar(e( b* Maharash!ra C&$nci &'H&.e&pa!h* e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n '&ra(.issi&n in !he !hree *ear La5 C&$rse1 A'!er

8


9/32Page 9

c&nsi(era!i&n C&..i!!ee is &' !he +ie5 !ha!since Mrs1 Archana Girish Sabnis has area(*been in'&r.e( !ha! !he L1C1E1H1 De,reea5ar(e( b* Maharash!ra c&$nci &'H&.e&pa!h* is n&! rec&,ni>e( as e;$i+aen! !&

,ra($a!i&n '&r a(.issi&n in !he !hree *ear a5c&$rse b* !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia9 !he ;$es!i&n&' rec&nsi(era!i&n (&es n&! arise1

/01 The ab&+e rec&..en(a!i&n 5as pace( be'&re !he %ar

C&$nci &' In(ia a! i!s .ee!in, he( &n 70 !h J$ne9 3003 an(

!he C&$nci accep!e( !he sai( rec&..en(a!i&n 5hich 5as

($* c&..$nica!e( !& !he appean! +i(e e!!er (a!e(

0?10?130031

//1 I! is s$b.i!!e( &n beha' &' !he C&$nci !ha! since LL1%1

is a pr&'essi&na c&$rse an( !he .ini.$. ;$ai'ica!i&n ai(

(&5n b* !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia is ,ra($a!i&n in an*

(iscipine &r an* &!her ;$ai'ica!i&n rec&,ni>e( as e;$i+aen!

!here!&9 !he %ar C&$nci (i( n&! 'in( i! appr&pria!e !&

rec&,ni>e !he LCEH ;$ai'ica!i&n as e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n

'&r !he p$rp&se &' a(.issi&n in !he !hree@*ear a5 c&$rse

an( !he 'ac! !ha! i! is rec&,ni>e( as e;$i+aen! !& ,ra($a!i&n

9


10/32Page 10

(e,ree b* an* &!her a$!h&ri!* has n& ree+ance an( i! is n&!

bin(in, &n !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia1 The %ar C&$nci &' In(ia

e8a.ines each case in(epen(en!* an( arri+es a! i!s &5n

c&nc$si&n 5i!h&$! bein, in'$ence( b* (ecisi&ns !a:en b*

&!her a$!h&ri!ies in !his re,ar(1

/31 In &r(er !& (eci(e 5he!her %ar C&$nci &' In(ia 5as

-$s!i'ie( in re'$sin, enr&.en! &' !he appean! as an

a(+&ca!e9 5e !hin: i! appr&pria!e !& re'er ree+an!

pr&+isi&ns &' !he A(+&ca!es Ac! an( R$es 'ra.e( b* %ar

c&$nci &' In(ia1

/71 Sec!i&n B &' !he A(+&ca!es Ac!9 /=4/ "in sh&r!9 !he

Ac!# a*s (&5n +ari&$s '$nc!i&ns &' !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia

5hich inc$(es inter alia!& pr&.&!e e,a e($ca!i&n an( !&

a* (&5n s!an(ar( &' s$ch e($ca!i&n in c&ns$!a!i&n 5i!h !he

Uni+ersi!ies in In(ia i.par!in, s$ch e($ca!i&n an( !he S!a!e

%ar C&$ncis1 The %ar C&$nci &' In(ia sha as& rec&,ni>e

Uni+ersi!ies9 5h&se (e,ree in a5 sha be a ;$ai'ica!i&n '&r

10


11/32Page 11

enr&.en! as an a(+&ca!e an( '&r !ha! p$rp&se !& +isi! an(

inspec! Uni+ersi!ies &r ca$se !he S!a!e %ar C&$ncis !& +isi!

an( inspec! Uni+ersi!ies in acc&r(ance 5i!h s$ch (irec!i&ns

as i! .a* ,i+e in !his beha'1

/21 Sec!i&n 32 &' !he Ac! pr&+i(es !ha! a pers&n sha be

;$ai'ie( !& be a(.i!!e( as an A(+&ca!e &n a S!a!e r& i' he

'$'is !he c&n(i!i&ns .en!i&ne( in !ha! Sec!i&n9 5hich rea(s

as $n(er)

321 Pers&ns 5h& .a* be a(.i!!e( asa(+&ca!es &n a S!a!e r&1"/# S$b-ec! !& !he pr&+isi&ns &' !his Ac!9 an(!he r$es .a(e !here$n(er9 a pers&n sha be;$ai'ie( !& be a(.i!!e( as an a(+&ca!e &n aS!a!e r&9 i' he '$'is !he '&&5in, c&n(i!i&ns9na.e*)

"a# he is a ci!i>en &' In(ia)Pr&+i(e( !ha! s$b-ec! !& !he &!her pr&+isi&ns

c&n!aine( in !his Ac!9 a na!i&na &' an* &!herc&$n!r* .a* be a(.i!!e( as an a(+&ca!e &n aS!a!e r&9 i' ci!i>ens &' In(ia9 ($* ;$ai'ie(9 areper.i!!e( !& prac!ise a5 in !ha! &!her c&$n!r*"b# he has c&.pe!e( !he a,e &' !5en!*@&ne

*ears"c# he has &b!aine( a (e,ree in a5"i# be'&re !he /3!h (a* &' March9 /=4B9 'r&.

an* Uni+ersi!* in !he !erri!&r* &' In(ia &r

"ii# be'&re !he /

11


12/32Page 12

"iii# a'!er !he /3!h (a* &' March9 /=4B9 sa+e aspr&+i(e( in s$b@ca$se "iiia#9 a'!er $n(er,&in, a!hree *ear c&$rse &' s!$(* in a5 'r&. an*Uni+ersi!* in In(ia 5hich is rec&,nise( '&r !hep$rp&ses &' !his Ac! b* !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia

&r"iiia# a'!er $n(er,&in, a c&$rse &' s!$(* in a59!he($ra!i&n &' 5hich is n&! ess !han !5& aca(e.ic*ears c&..encin, 'r&. !he aca(e.ic *ear/=4B@4? &r an* earier aca(e.ic *ear 'r&. an*Uni+ersi!* in In(ia 5hich is rec&,nise( '&r !hep$rp&ses &' !his Ac! b* !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia&r"i+# in an* &!her case9 'r&. an* Uni+ersi!*&$!si(e !he !erri!&r* &' In(ia9 i' !he (e,ree is

rec&,nise( '&r !he p$rp&ses &' !his Ac! b* !he%ar C&$nci &' In(ia &r he is barris!er an( iscae( !& !he %ar &n &r be'&re !he 7/s! (a* &'Dece.ber9 /=B4 2&r has passe( !he ar!icecer:s e8a.ina!i&n &r an* &!her e8a.ina!i&nspeci'ie( b* !he Hi,h C&$r! a! %&.ba* &rCac$!!a '&r enr&.en! as an a!!&rne* &' !ha!Hi,h C&$r! &r has &b!aine( s$ch &!her '&rei,n;$ai'ica!i&n in a5 as is rec&,nise( b* !he %arC&$nci &' In(ia '&r !he p$rp&se &' a(.issi&n asan a(+&ca!e $n(er !his Ac!

KKKKKK"e# he '$'is s$ch &!her c&n(i!i&ns as .a* be

speci'ie( in !he r$es .a(e b* !he S!a!e %arC&$nci $n(er !his Chap!er"'# he has pai(9 in respec! &' !he enr&.en!9s!a.p ($!*9 i' an*9 char,eabe $n(er !he In(ianS!a.p Ac!9 /?== "3 &' /?==#9 an( an enr&.en!'ee pa*abe !& !he S!a!e %ar C&$nci &' si8h$n(re( r$pees an( !& !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia9&ne h$n(re( an( 'i'!* r$pees b* 5a* &' a ban:(ra'! (ra5n in 'a+&$r &' !ha! C&$nci)

Pr&+i(e( !ha! 5here s$ch pers&n is a .e.ber&' !he Sche($e Cas!es &r !he Sche($e Tribesan( pr&($ces a cer!i'ica!e !& !ha! e''ec! 'r&.s$ch a$!h&ri!* as .a* be prescribe(9 !heenr&.en! 'ee pa*abe b* hi. !& !he S!a!e %ar

12


13/32Page 13

C&$nci sha be &ne h$n(re( r$pees an( !& !he%ar C&$nci &'In(ia9 !5en!*@'i+e r$pees1

/


14/32


15/32Page 15

"(# !he s!an(ar(s &' e,a e($ca!i&n !& be&bser+e( b* $ni+ersi!ies in In(ia an( !heinspec!i&n &' $ni+ersi!ies '&r !ha! p$rp&se"e# !he '&rei,n ;$ai'ica!i&ns in a5 &b!aine(

b* pers&ns &!her !han ci!i>ens &' In(ia 5hich

sha be rec&,nise( '&r !he p$rp&se &'a(.issi&n as an a(+&ca!e $n(er !his Ac!"'# !he pr&ce($re !& be '&&5e( b* !he

(iscipinar* c&..i!!ee &' a S!a!e %ar C&$ncian( b* i!s &5n (iscipinar* c&..i!!ee",# !he res!ric!i&ns in !he .a!!er &' prac!ice !&

5hich seni&r a(+&ca!es sha be s$b-ec!",,# !he '&r. &' (resses &r r&bes !& be 5&rn

b* a(+&ca!es9 ha+in, re,ar( !& !he ci.a!icc&n(i!i&ns9 appearin, be'&re an* c&$r! &r!rib$na

"h# !he 'ees 5hich .a* be e+ie( in respec! &'an* .a!!er $n(er !his Ac!"i# ,enera principes '&r ,$i(ance &' S!a!e %arC&$ncis an( !he .anner in 5hich (irec!i&nsiss$e( &r &r(ers .a(e b* !he %ar C&$nci &'In(ia .a* be en'&rce("-# an* &!her .a!!er 5hich .a* be prescribe()Pr&+i(e( !ha! n& r$es .a(e 5i!h re'erence !&ca$se "c# &r ca$se ",,# sha ha+e e''ec!$ness !he* ha+e been appr&+e( b* !he Chie'J$s!ice &' In(ia)

Pr&+i(e( '$r!her !ha! n& r$es .a(e 5i!hre'erence !& ca$se "e# sha ha+e e''ec! $ness!he* ha+e been appr&+e( b* !he Cen!raG&+ern.en!1"3# N&!5i!hs!an(in, an*!hin, c&n!aine( in !he'irs! pr&+is& !& s$b@sec!i&n "/#9 an* r$es .a(e5i!h re'erence !& ca$se "c# &r ca$se ",,# &'!he sai( s$b@sec!i&n an( in '&rce i..e(ia!e*be'&re c&..ence.en! &' !he A(+&ca!es"A.en(.en!# Ac!9 /=B7 "40 &' /=B7#9 shac&n!in$e in '&rce $n!i a!ere( &r repeae( &r

a.en(e( in acc&r(ance 5i!h !he pr&+isi&ns &'!his Ac!1

15


16/32Page 16

/B1 Un(er Sec!i&n 2=A &' !he Ac!9 Cen!ra G&+ern.en! .a*9

b* n&!i'ica!i&n in !he O''icia Ga>e!!e9 .a:e r$es '&r carr*in,

&$! !he p$rp&ses &' !his Ac! inc$(in, r$es 5i!h respec! !&

an* .a!!er '&r 5hich !he %ar C&$nci &' In(ia &r a S!a!e %ar

C&$nci has p&5er !& .a:e r$es9 inc$(in, !he cass &r

ca!e,&r* &' pers&ns en!i!e( !& be enr&e( as a(+&ca!es

$n(er !his Ac!1 I' an* pr&+isi&n &' a r$e .a(e b* a %ar

C&$nci is rep$,nan! !& an* pr&+isi&n &' a r$e .a(e b* !he

Cen!ra G&+ern.en! $n(er !his sec!i&n9 !hen9 !he r$e $n(er

!his sec!i&n9 5he!her .a(e be'&re &r a'!er !he r$e .a(e b*

!he %ar C&$nci9 sha pre+ai an( !he r$e .a(e b* !he %ar

C&$nci sha9 !& !he e8!en! &' !he rep$,nanc*9 be +&i(1

/?1 Firs! &' a 5e 5&$( i:e !& e8a.ine as !& 5he!her !he

pr&'essi&na c&$rses i1e1 Licen!ia!e &' !he C&$r! &' E8a.iners

in H&.&e&pa!h* Me(icines "LCEH#9 5hich !he pe!i!i&ner

&b!aine(9 is a (e,ree &r e;$i+aen! !& a ,ra($a!i&n (e,ree

b* !he Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h*1

16


17/32Page 17

/=1 The H&.&e&pa!h* Cen!ra C&$nci Ac! 5as enac!e( in

!he *ear /=B7 5i!h !he &b-ec! !& pr&+i(e '&r c&ns!i!$!i&n &'

Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* an( !he .ain!enance &' a

Cen!ra Re,is!rar &' H&.&e&pa!h*1 The .ain '$nc!i&n &' !he

Cen!ra C&$nci &' H&.&e&pa!h* 5&$( be !& e+&+e a

$ni'&r. s!an(ar( &' e($ca!i&n in h&.&e&pa!h* an( !he

re,is!ra!i&n &' prac!i!i&ners &' h&.&e&pa!h*1 Sec!i&n /7 &'

!he sai( Ac! is 5&r!h !& be ;$&!e( hereinbe&5)@

!3. R"#$%&'('$& $) *"+'#al qal')'#a('$&-%a&("+ b/ #"(a'& *"+'#al '&-('(('$&- '&I&+'a "/# The .e(ica ;$ai'ica!i&ns ,ran!e( b*an* Uni+ersi!*9 %&ar( &r &!her .e(ica ins!i!$!i&nin In(ia 5hich are inc$(e( in !he Sec&n(

Sche($e sha be rec&,ni>e( .e(ica ;$ai'ica!i&n'&r !he p$rp&ses &' !his Ac!1

"3# An* Uni+ersi!*9 %&ar( &r &!her .e(icains!i!$!i&ns in In(ia 5hich ,ran!s a .e(ica;$ai'ica!i&n n&! inc$(e( in !he Sec&n( Sche($e.a* app* !& !he Cen!ra G&+ern.en! !& ha+e an*s$ch ;$ai'ica!i&n rec&,ni>e(9 an( !he Cen!raG&+ern.en!9 a'!er c&ns$!in, !he Cen!ra c&$nci9.a*9 b* n&!i'ica!i&n in !he O''icia Ga>e!!e9 a.en(!he Sec&n( Sche($e s& as !& inc$(e s$ch

;$ai'ica!i&n !herein an* s$ch n&!i'ica!i&n .a*as& (irec! !ha! an en!r* sha be .a(e in !he as!c&$.n &' !he Sec&n( Sche($e a,ains! s$ch.e(ica ;$ai'ica!i&n &n* 5hen ,ran!e( a'!er aspeci'ie( (a!e1

17


18/32Page 18

301 F&r be!!er apprecia!i&n9 Sec&n( Sche($e &' !he C&$nci

Ac!9 5hich rec&,ni>e( .e(ica ;$ai'ica!i&ns in H&.&e&pa!h*

,ran!e( b* !he Uni+ersi!ies9 %&ar( &r Me(ica Ins!i!$!i&ns in

In(ia9 an(9 s& 'ar as Maharash!ra is c&ncerne(9 is repr&($ce(

hereinbe&5 )@

TE 1ECOND 1CEDULE

1"" -"#('$& !3

R"#$%&'-"+ M"+'#al al')'#a('$&- '& $*$"$5a(6/ Ga&("+ b/U&'"-'('"-, B$a+- $ M"+'#al I&-('(('$&- '& I&+'a

Na.e &' !he Uni+ersi!*9%&ar( &r Me(ica

Ins!i!$!i&n

Rec&,nise( Me(ica;$ai'ica!i&n

Abbre+ia!i&n&' re,is!ra!i&n

Re.ar:s

/ 3 7 2

!!. The C&$r! &'E8a.iners &'H&.&e&pa!hic an(%i&che.ic S*s!e.s &'Me(icines9 %&.ba*

Licen!ia!e &' !he C&$r! &'E8a.iners inH&.&e&pa!h* Dip&.a inH&.&e&pa!h* an(%i&che.is!r*

L1C1E1H1 Fr&. Dece.ber/=4/ &n5ar(s9

!!A. Vi(arbha %&ar( &'H&.&e&pa!hic an(

bi&che.ic Me(icines9Na,p$r1

Dip&.a in H&.&e&pa!h*an( %i&che.is!r*

D1H1%1 Fr&. Oc!&ber/=


19/32Page 19

%i&che.ic S*s!e.s &'Me(icine9 %&.ba*

!!C. P$ne Uni+ersi!* %ache&r inH&.&e&pa!hic Me(icinean( S$r,er*

%1H1M1S1 Fr&. /=?? !&/==0

!!D. %&.ba*Uni+ersi!*

%ache&r inH&.&e&pa!hic Me(icinean( S$r,er*

%1H1M1S1 Fr&. /=?? !&/==0

!!E1 C&$r! &'E8a.iners &'H&.&e&pa!hic an(%i&che.ic S*s!e.s &'Me(icine9 %&.ba*1

Dip&.a in H&.&e&pa!h*Me(icine an( S$r,er*

D1H1M1S1

"CCHRe,$a!i&n&n5ar(s#

Fr&. /=?B

19


20/32Page 20

!!F. Dr1 %abasahebA.be(:ar Mara!h5a(aUni+ersi!*9 A$ran,aba(1

"a# Shri %ha,5an

H&.&e&pa!hicMe(ica C&e,e9A$ran,aba(

"b# S11H&.&e&pa!hicMe(ica C&e,e9%ee(1

%ache&r inH&.&e&pa!hic Me(icinean( S$r,er*1

%ache&r in

H&.&e&pa!hic Me(icinean( S$r,er*1

%ache&r inH&.&e&pa!hic Me(icinean( S$r,er*1

%1H1M1S1

%1H1M1S1

%1H1M1S1

Fr&. /==/ !&/==

pursuing law and practicing law are two different things.pdf

Documents