presented on november 12 th, 2015 analysts team: aditi das xuan (lucy) liang zhi cheng (nicole)...

23
Presented on November 12 th , 2015 Analysts Team: Aditi Das Xuan (Lucy) Liang Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low Jordan Peasel Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ: WBA)

Upload: leslie-walters

Post on 18-Jan-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

Presented on November 12th, 2015

Analysts Team: Aditi Das

Xuan (Lucy) Liang

Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low

Jordan Peasel

Yue (Benjamin) Xu

(NASDAQ: WBA)

Page 2: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

AGENDA

Business Overview

Industry Overview

Financial Analysis

DCF Valuation

Comparable Valuation

Stock Analysis

Recommendation

Page 3: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

CURRENT HOLDING

Yahoo! Finance Investment Holding

Capital Gain: $17,046

Date Action

October 6, 1999 Purchased 1000 shares @$25/share (Cost Basis: $25,000)

September 20, 2006

Sold 500 shares @ 49.94

November 22, 2013

Sold 200 Shares @ 60.35

TODAY Current Position: 300 shares trading at $81.82/share (Cost Basis: $24,546)

Page 4: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

BUSINESS SEGMENTATION

• Continues the Legacy of Walgreens• Operation of Retail Drugstores• Convenient Care Clinics• Specialty Pharmacy Services

• Continues the legacy of Alliance Boots• Beauty Retail Operations Comprised of Retail

Drugstores• Optician Stores• Contract Manufacturing Operations

• Continues the Legacy of Alliance Boots• Pharmaceutical Wholesaling and Distribution

Business

Retail Pharmacy USA

Retail Pharmacy

International

Pharmaceutical Wholesale

2015 WBA 10-K Pages 2-3

Page 5: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

FUTURE GOALS

WBA April Annual Report, http://www2.deloitte.com/global/en/pages/life-sciences-and-healthcare/articles/global-health-care-sector-outlook.html,http://www.eiu.com/industry/Healthcare

Seek and Seize

further synergy

opportunities

Boost Organic Growth

Seek to generate and seize relevant M&A and strategic

investment opportunitie

s

Latin America Asia Western Europe North America0.00%

5.00%

10.00%

15.00%

20.00%

25.00%

30.00%

35.00%

40.00%

FORECASTED HEALTH CARE SPENDING AS % OF GDP UP TO FY18

2015 Healthcare Spending Forecasted Growth in Healthcare Spending

Page 6: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

FOOD AND DRUGS STORE

http://clients1.ibisworld.com/reports/us/industry/default.aspx?entid=1054

58.10%

31.00%

10.30%Market Share

CVS

Walgreens Boots Alliance

Rite Aid

4% 2%5%

54%5%

10%

10%

10%

Product BreakdownGroceries and Food ItemsDietary SupplementsPersonal Health SuppliesBranded Prescription DrugsNonprescription MedicinesGeneric DrugsBranded Generic DrugsOther

Industry Statistics

Revenue 263 Billion

Profit 10.3 Billion

Past Growth 1.3%

Expected Growth

2.9%

Page 7: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

MACROECONOMIC FACTORS

IBIS WORLD

Unemployment Rate Disposable Income

Federal Healthcare SpendingAdults Aged 65 and Older

Page 8: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

ACQUISITION OF RITE AID

WBA 2015 Investor Roadshow

Rite Aid Overview• Perfect Pharmacy

Comparable to WBA• Distributor-McKesson

• 62.2% of COGS• Heavy store concentration

in the New England Area

Transaction Overview• WBA is offering $9 per share

cash• Closing of 1,000 stores if

approved by regulators • Over $1BN of expected

synergies:• Cost Savings• Operational Synergies• Expected to be realize

within 3-4 years of store closures

~4600 Stores

~8200 Stores

Page 9: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

SWOT ANALYSIS

2015 WBA 10-K Part A

• Mail order• CVS looking to expand its

footprint• Lower reimbursement

rate• Federal Trade

Commission regulation

• Synergies of strategic acquisition

• Patent cliff• Increasing aging

population• Health care reform

• High reliance on the third party player

• Simple business model

• 2rd marketplace • Footprint • Strong CRM

initiative • Bargain power

Strength Weakness

ThreatsOpportunity

Page 10: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

KEY RISKS

2015 WBA 10-K Pages 7-22

Product

Third Party

Strategy

Financial

Regulation

• Increasing Outstanding Debt

• Changes in Healthcare Regulatory Environments

• Relationship with pharmacy benefit management companies

• Consolidation and strategic alliances in the healthcare industry

• Uncertainty of the realization of anticipated benefits from the acquisitions

• Private Brand

• A shift in pharmacy mix toward lower margin plans and programs

• Decrease in the introduction of new brand name and generic prescription drugs

• Generic drug inflation

Page 11: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150.00%2.00%4.00%6.00%8.00%

10.00%12.00%14.00%16.00%18.00%20.00%

10.10%

6.98% 7.39%5.58%

8.07%

18.56%

12.86% 13.52%

10.14%

16.48%

PROFITABLITY ANALYSIS

Operating Margin Net Margin

Return on Assets Return on Equity

• Profitability improved after the acquisition of AB.

• WBA consistently beat earnings estimates by more than 8% in the past four quarters.

• Long term debts increased by approximately $11BN. This includes assuming AB’s outstanding debts and notes issuance to finance the Second Step Transactions.

• Efficiency of WBA in collecting its credit sales has declined due to shift in management focus.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150.00%5.00%

10.00%15.00%20.00%25.00%30.00%35.00%40.00%45.00%

0.00x

10.00x

20.00x

30.00x

40.00x

50.00x

60.00x

70.00x

16.19% 22.38%

23.02% 21.91%

42.55%61.48x

39.36x

25.53x23.80x

9.78x

LEVERAGE ANALYSIS

Total Debt/Total Assets LT Debt/EquityEBIT Interest Coverage Fixed Asset Turnover

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 $-

$0.50

$1.00

$1.50

$2.00

$2.50

$3.00

$3.50

$4.00

$4.50

$2.94

$2.42 $2.67

$2.00

$4.00

EPS (DILUTED)

2015 WBA 10-K Pages 49-53

Page 12: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

GREENBLATT & DUPONT ANALYSIS

2015 WBA 10-K Pages 49-53

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150.00%

5.00%

10.00%

15.00%

20.00%

25.00%

30.00%

35.00%

25.29%

20.55%

24.80%

21.54%

28.85%

13.57%

9.16% 8.69%6.24% 5.57%

GREENBLATT RATIOS

EBIT/Tangible Asset (ROIC) EBIT/EV (Earnings Yield)

Page 13: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

• Patent cliff II is expected to continue through FY15

• This will lead to the replacement of branded drugs by generic versions.

• Adopted the conservative method

• This industry is anticipated to grow at an annualized rate of 3.4% from FY15-20.

• Based on the organic growth rate of WBA

• Factor in store closures by reducing the revenue streams by ~5% from FY15-18.

• Boots UK Sales Comps grew 3.5% yoy in FY15.

IBIS WORLD, WBA 4Q & FY2015 Earnings Conference Call

REVENUE PROJECTIONS

Page 14: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

WACC (STANDALONE)

Bloomberg

Up to 11/11/2015pp.348 10K

Yield of US 10-year Treasury BillBloomberg

Risk-Free Rate 2.34%Market Risk Premium 5.81%Beta (5-year) 1.18927

CAPM Cost of Equity 9.25%ROE on past 5 years 14.31%Adjusted Cost of Equity 11.78%

Current Share Price $81.82Average shares outstanding (mil) 1053.9Market Value of Equity $86,230.10

Market value of Debt (mil) $14,383

Equity Weight 85.70%Debt Weight 14.30%

Cost of Debt 4.21%Cost of Equity 11.78%

Tax rate 30.00%

WACC 10.52%

CAPM

Weighted Average Cost of Capital

Page 15: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

DCF VALUATION (STANDALONE)

  Key Rates Assumption

Bussiness Risk Premium 0.50%WACC 10.52%Discount Rate 11.02%Terminal Grow th Rate 3.00%

Value Per Share

(Millions, Excepts Share Price)Enterprise Value 105,754Less: Debt 14,383Market Capitalization 91,371

Share Price $86.70

Upside (dow nside) potential 5.96%

(Millions) 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E Terminal

EBIT 9,057 10,640 12,235 13,688 15,476Less: Taxes (2,523) (2,989) (3,460) (3,892) (4,420)Plus: Depreciation 1,674 1,752 1,817 1,851 1,921Less: Capital Expenditures (1,560) (1,865) (2,174) (2,460) (2,807)

Changes in Net Working CapitalLess: Increses in A/R 1,175 (279) (215) (75) (227)Less: Increases in Inventories 657 (394) (303) (106) (321)Plus: Increases in A/P (1,731) 411 316 110 334

Free Cash Flow 6,749 7,276 8,216 9,117 9,957 127,925

Present Value 6,079 5,904 6,005 6,002 5,904 75,860

Sum of Present Value of FCF $105,754

$86.70 2.00% 2.50% 3.00% 3.50% 4.00%

10.02% 90.08$ 95.43$ 101.54$ 108.60$ 116.82$ 10.52% 83.73$ 88.37$ 93.63$ 99.63$ 106.55$ 11.02% 78.09$ 82.14$ 86.70$ 91.86$ 97.76$ 11.52% 73.05$ 76.61$ 80.59$ 85.06$ 90.13$

12.02% 68.52$ 71.66$ 75.16$ 79.07$ 83.46$

Terminal Growth Rate

Sensitivity Analysis

Discount Rate

Page 16: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

  

Yield of US 10-year Treasury BillBloomberg

Up to 11/11/2015

pp.348 10K

Bloomberg

Bloomberg

Risk-Free Rate 2.34%Market Risk Premium 5.81%Beta (5-year) 1.18927

CAPM Cost of Equity 9.25%ROE on past 5 years 14.31%Adjusted Cost of Equity 11.78%

Current Share Price $81.82Average shares outstanding (mil) 1053.9Market Value of Equity $86,230.10

Market value of Debt in Total (mil) $27,157Market value of Debt of WBA (mil) $14,357Market value of Debt of Rite Aid (mil) $12,800

Equity Weight 76.05%Debt Weight 23.95%

Cost of Debt 4.21%Cost of Equity 11.78%

Tax rate 30.00%

WACC 9.66%

CAPM

Weighted Average Cost of Capital

WACC (WITH RAD)

Page 17: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

  

(Millions) 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E Terminal

EBIT 9,764 10,708 13,359 15,909 18,906Less: Taxes (2,687) (2,959) (3,745) (4,505) (5,394)Plus: Depreciation 1,785 1,984 2,178 2,341 2,556Less: Capital Expenditures (1,560) (1,865) (2,174) (2,460) (2,807)

Changes in Net Working CapitalLess: Increses in A/R (2,290) (425) (353) (184) (379)Less: Increases in Inventories (2,902) (538) (447) (233) (480)Plus: Increases in A/P 3,373 626 519 271 558

Free Cash Flow 5,482 7,531 9,337 11,139 12,960 163,520Present Value 4,932 6,094 6,797 7,294 7,635 96,329

Sum of Present Value of FCF $129,081

Key Rates AssumptionBussiness Risk Premium 1.50%WACC 9.66%Discount Rate 11.16%Terminal Growth Rate 3.00%Value Per Share(Millions, Excepts Share Price)Enterprise Value 129,107Less: Debt 27,183Market Capitalization 101,924

Share Price $96.71

Upside (downside) potential 18.20%

DCF VALUATION (WITH RAD)

Page 18: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

Investopedia: What is the Pharmacy Benefit Management Industry, CVS 2014 10-k, WBA 2015 10-k

CVS Health Corporation

Walgreens Boots Alliance

Segments• Pharmacy Services (56.6%)• Retail Pharmacy (44.4%)• Corporate – Loss AdjustmentDistributors• Cardinal Health (27.0%)• McKesson (22.87%)

Segments• Retail Pharmacy USA (76.3%)• Retail Pharmacy Int’l (13.4%)• Pharmaceutical Wholesale (8.4%)Distributors• AmerisourceBergen (61.07%)• Seat on BoD

CVS vs WBA

Page 19: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

CVS 10K, RAD 10K and Bloomberg

• Rite Aid has negative equity

• CVS has higher tax burden

• CVS – highest ROE in 5 years

• CVS is generating more cash

flow from assets

• RAD & WBA – similar cash flow

Comps Ratios

WBA CVS RAD

Tax Burden 80.57% 60.24% 494.16%Interest Burden 89.77% 87.26% 50.63%Operating Profit Margin 4.51% 6.31% 3.18%Asset Turnover 1.95x 1.91x 3.36xLeverage 2.04x 1.92x N/AROE 13.01% 12.16% N/A

WBA CVS RAD

EBIT/Tangible Asset 28.85% 36.80% 17.49%EBIT/EV 5.57% 7.29% 6.35%

Greenblatt Analysis

DuPont Analysis

COMPARABLES ANALYSIS

Page 20: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

CVS 10K, RAD 10K and Bloomberg

Comps Valuation

WBA CVS RADTTM P/E 18.09 21.46 40.67 Forward P/E 18.71 18.94 46.99 Price/Sales 0.81 0.66 0.28 Price/Book Value 2.95 2.92 18.98

Applying CVS WeightTTM P/E 85.93 25.0%Forward P/E 105.79 25.0%Price/Sales 64.37 25.0%Price/Book Value 85.51 25.0%

Weight Average Price 85.40$

Applying CVS WeightTTM P/E 85.93 25.0%Forward P/E 112.67 25.0%Price/Sales 64.37 25.0%Price/Book Value 85.51 25.0%

Weight Average Price 87.12$

Applying Comps Ratios

Valuation (without Rite Aid)

Valuation (with Rite Aid)

COMPARABLES ANALYSIS

Page 21: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

STOCK ANALYSIS

Yahoo! Finance Interactive Graph

WBA Stock Performance to Date

Page 22: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

Yahoo! Finance Interactive Graph

WBA vs. CVS Comparable Performance to Date

Capitalization of Rite Aid: 8.14 B (.1)Capitalization of Walgreens: 89.08B (.9)Price increased on the day of announcement: 6.6%Price increased from Oct 26th 2015 till Nov 11th 2015: -8.2%

STOCK ANALYSIS

Page 23: Presented on November 12 th, 2015 Analysts Team:  Aditi Das  Xuan (Lucy) Liang  Zhi Cheng (Nicole) Low  Jordan Peasel  Yue (Benjamin) Xu (NASDAQ:

Comparable Value of: $85.40

DCF Value of: 86.70

Final WBA Value of: $86.31

Comparable Value of: $87.12

DCF Value of: 96.71

Final WBA Value of:

93.83

Current Holding: 300 Shares trading at $81.82 (20% of portfolio); Dividend Yield of 17%; Last Paid Dividend of $0.36 on Aug 17th, 2015

Without Rite Aid With Rite AidFinal ValuationWithout Rite Aid Estimate WeightDCF 86.70$ 70%Comps 85.40$ 30%

Target 86.31$ 15%

With Rite Aid Estimate WeightDCF 96.71$ 70%Comps 87.12$ 30%

Target 93.83$ 85%

Final Target 92.70$

Upside Potential 13.30%

BUY 100 shares at market price

RECOMMENDATION