7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

1/11

HI- HI heese Grinder

Concept Selection

Group No.2

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

2/11

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

3/11

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

4/11

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

5/11

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

6/11

Matrix of comparisons of CUTTINGS

C1 C2 C3

C1 1 1/3 1

C2 3 1 3

C3 1 1/3 1

Matrix of comparisons of CUTTINGS

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 1!!! !333 1!!! 2333 !2!!

C2 3!!! 1!!! 3!!! "!!! !#!!C3 1!!! !333 1!!! 2333 !2!!

TOTA$ %!!! 1##" %!!! 11##" 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 !2! !2! !2! !#! !2

C2 !#! !#! !#! 1,! !#

C3 !2! !2! !2! !#! !2

TOTA$ 1 1 1 3 1

Matrix of comparisons of STORAG-S

S1 S2 S3

S1 1 1/2 1/2

S2 2 1 1/2

S3 2 1 1

Matrix of comparisons of STORAG-S

S1 S2 S3ROWSUM AVG

S1 1!!! !%!! !%!! 2!!! !211

S2 2!!! 1!!! !%!! 3%!! !3!!S3 2!!! 1!!! 1!!! .!!! !.21

TOTA$ %!!! 2%!! 2!!! %!! 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

S1 S2 S3

ROW

SUM AVG

S1 !2! !2! !2% !#%!21###

###"

S2 !.! !.! !2% 1!% !3%

S3 !.! !.! !%! 13!!.3333

3333

TOTA$ 1 1 1 3 1

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

7/11

Matrix of comparisons of0OW-RS

C1 C2 C3

C1 1!!! 1!!! !2%!

C2 1!!! 1!!! !2%!

C3 .!!! .!!! 1!!!

Matrix of comparisons of 0OW-RS

C1 C2 C3

ROW

SUM AVGC1 1!!! 1!!! !2%! 22%! !1#"

C2 1!!! 1!!! !2%! 22%! !1#"

C3 .!!! .!!! 1!!! !!! !##"

TOTA$ %!!! 1##" %!!! 13%!! 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 !2!! !#!! !!%! !,%! !1,!

C2 !2!! !#!! !!%! !,%! !1,!

C3 !,!! 2.!! !2!! 3.!! !"1,

TOTA$ !,33 3% !3!! ."33 1!!!

Matrix of comparisons of --OUTS

C1 C2 C3

C1 1 1 1

C2 1 1 1

C3 1 1 1

Matrix of comparisons of --OUTS

C1 C2 C3 ROW SUM AVG

C1 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !333

C2 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !222C3 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !333

TOTA$ 3!!! 3!!! 3!!! !!! 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

C1 C2 C3 ROW SUM AVG

C1 !33 !33 !33 1!!!333333

333

C2 !33 !33 !33 1!!!333333

333

C3 !33 !33 !33 1!!!333333

333

TOTA$ 1 1 1 3 1

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

8/11

Matrix of comparisons of --OUTS

C1 C2 C3

C1 1 1 1

C2 1 1 1

C3 1 1 1

Matrix of comparisons of --OUTS

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !333

C2 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !222

C3 1!!! 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! !333

TOTA$ 3!!! 3!!! 3!!! !!! 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 !33 !33 !33 1!!!33333

3333

C2 !33 !33 !33 1!!!33333

3333

C3 !33 !33 !33 1!!!33333

3333

TOTA$ 1 1 1 3 1

Matrix of comparisons of O$INGS

C1 C2 C3

C1 1 1 3

C2 1 1 1/3

C3 3 3 1

Matrix of comparisons of O$INGS

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 1!!! 1!!! 3!!! %!!! !3.

C2 1!!! 1!!! !333 2333 !2%

C3 3!!! 3!!! 1!!! "!!! !.,,

TOTA$ %!!! %!!! .333 1.333 1!!!

Norma&i'in( t)* +*i()ts

C1 C2 C3ROWSUM AVG

C1 !2! !2! !# 1!!3#.1!

2%#.

C2 !2! !2! !!, !.,!1%,"

.3%

C3 !#! !#! !23 1.3!."#2

3!""

TOTA$ 1 1 1 3 1

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

9/11

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

10/11

O4*ra&& 0riorit5 +*i()ts for *ac) a&t*rnati4*

C6ttin(o&7in( Stora(* **7 In0o+*r

**7O6t A&t*rnati4* W*i()t*7

-4a&6ation89 Attri:6t*W*i()t ; -4a&6ation

Ratin(

Attri:6t*W*i()ts !.3! !!"! !113 !11,

!22! !!.,

A&t*rnati4*

c

7/23/2019 Presentation2 Concept Selection-0ld

11/11

ina& Conc*pt