preparing for the thesis/dissertation defencecel.ncu.edu.jm/portals/0/preparing for final oral...
TRANSCRIPT
N . M A U Z A R D
A P R I L 2 0 1 4
Northern Caribbean University Department of Graduate Education &
Leadership
Preparing for the thesis/dissertation defence
N. Mauzard
2
N. Mauzard
3
“A prudent person takes precautions. The simpleton goes blindly on and suffers the consequences” proverbs 27:12
Central points
N. Mauzard
4
Definition
Before the defence
On the day of the defence
After the defence
Definition
N. Mauzard
5
The final defence is an oral examination open to the public, during which the author of a thesis or dissertation demonstrates to his or her committee satisfactory command of all aspects of the work presented and other related subjects, if applicable (University of Hawaii).
The defence is almost an academic formality. Almost.
N. Mauzard
6
Prepare & practice
N. Mauzard
7
Prepare yourself mentally and physically
Prepare your slides. Do not underestimate how long it takes to prepare your slides/talk .
Prepare & practice
N. Mauzard
8
1. Talk about the most important authors/researchers in the study as if they were your friends/mentors.
2. Do the above often, very often.
3. Test your memory (take your eyes off the paper)
4. If you do, 1 & 2 you will be able to pronounce major authors’ names effortlessly.
OUTCH !!!
N. Mauzard
9
Etaugh and Ptasnik (1982) Zhen Wang , Inslicht, Metzler, Henn-Haase, McCasli , Tong and Neyla (2008) Well, practice helps a lot.
Prepare & practice
N. Mauzard
10
Work on the organization and flow of your talk.
Ensure that you give multiple practice talks using your slides/presentation talk to yourself (tape and play back) and to others (groups, pets, siblings, teddy bear).
Always time yourself.
N. Mauzard
11
- Topic
- Synopsis of background
- Problem, purpose, and questions/hypotheses
- Major literature references (models, frameworks, empirical information)
- Data collection and analysis
- Findings and recommendations
Most important points to include on power point
• S c h o l a r s h i p i s e x t r e m e l y i m p o r t a n t i n y o u r p r e s e n t a t i on . Y o u s h o u l d b e s o f a m i l i a r w i t h t h e c u r r e n t r e s e a r c h t h a t y o u w i l l n o t b e c a u g h t u n a w a r e b y a n y t h e o r e t ic a l q u e s t i o n .
• S c h o l a r s h i p m e a n s t h a t y o u e x p e r t l y d r a w o n t h e
l i t e r a t u r e t o s u p p o r t y o u r p o i n t s .
N. Mauzard
12
Scholarship
Scholarship cont’d
N. Mauzard
13
Always ground your comments in the literature, you will sound more credible to your audience.
Remember that your scholarship is even more evident when you inform your audience of the year of publication.
A good structure
N. Mauzard
14
Your slides and talk have to MATCH up. In other words, you can’t have really good slides and a mediocre talk (or vice versa).
Observe others
N. Mauzard
15
Attend other defences often, specially those that are close to your topic.
What made it good or bad?
Were they enthusiastic and sincere about their work?
Did they keep the energy throughout the presentation?
Were there some rough areas of the presentation?
Make note of the questions asked
Materials
N. Mauzard
16
Print and have important items ready for your support
For you:
Models
Important tables
Artefacts (pictures, etc..)
Diagrams
For your committee:
Models
Important tables
Artefacts (pictures, etc..)
Diagrams
Friends/study groups
N. Mauzard
17
Have your friends, classmates, and study group members drill you with questions.
Do not get upset about their grilling; they have your best interest at heart.
Note: their questions are usually harder than the real deal.
Wellness
N. Mauzard
18
• Never underestimate the power of prayer and meditation.
• Get plenty of sleep, keep your diet in check, and take care of yourself.
• Keep your cool, relax.
.
N. Mauzard
19
Work on your confidence
Your advisor/committee chair would not allow you to proceed to the public defence if he/she wasn’t 99% sure you were going to pass.
N. Mauzard
20
Visualize yourself giving your defense each day and think about how good it will feel when it’s over.
N. Mauzard
21
My nerves, my nerves !!
N. Mauzard
22
When nerves are running high, the presentation may not go as expected. You can battle this nervousness by showing up way before time and well-prepared. If you are, the defense truly becomes just a formality.
Don’t let distractions get to you
N. Mauzard
23
• Pending job interviews
• Family matters (upcoming wedding, baby on the way)
• Unfortunate hairdo
• Your last phone call
• Ect… , the list can be long
See to it that you test all electronic equipment way before the starting time.
Prioritize and focus only on your defense
Conduct
N. Mauzard
24
A confident and professional attitude is recommended at your defense.
Do not talk too fast or too slowly.
Speak clearly and audibly throughout.
You may naturally gesture but don’t fidget .
Be respectful of your colleagues and the academic environment .
Avoid arrogance, defensiveness, and dismissiveness.
Formality
N. Mauzard
25
Be formal in how you word things (i.e. say “the data shows that”… vs. “you see here that”…).
Thank the person who has asked you a question, then answer.
Those questions, Hmmm!!
N. Mauzard
26
Keep in mind, this is all just a part of the defense’s hazing process, and in a sense is just to humble you.
N. Mauzard
27
Everyone’s defense is unique and unpredictable. You cannot foretell all the questions that may be asked, but you can answer intelligently when you know your study.
N. Mauzard
28
You wrote a 200 or more page thesis/dissertation, your committee can pick apart an error bar on a graph on page 133.
Stay calm
Acknowledge the error
Indicate that you will make the correction
They can ask you what you meant by a word in a random sentence in any given paragraph.
Give them the meaning
Questions
N. Mauzard
29
Listen carefully to the questions asked.
Academics often formulate questions as they speak, such questions often are not well worded.
1. Repeat the question back to them to make sure that you understand what the person is asking. OR
2. Say “are you asking ….” OR
3. Ask them to rephrase the question
Questions
N. Mauzard
30
If a question has a number of layers of parts, take time to answer the first layer/part first.
You may say “You just raised several issues, let me begin with the first one”
Then go through the others.
Stay calm, it is ok to think before you answer.
Keep a conversational attitude when answering questions. “that is an important issue that you… let me think about that for a moment”
My nerves, my nerves !!
N. Mauzard
31
If a difficult question arises, stay centered, take a moment to gather your thoughts, take a deep breath, and begin to answer.
Appearance/dress for Women
N. Mauzard
32
Conservative (business suits), non-garish colour (mild/earth).
No gym shoes, no very high heel shoes (comfortable and business like).
Appearance/dress for men
N. Mauzard
33
Standard formal attire (Jacket, dress shirt, tie, conservative slacks)
Dress shoes.
N. Mauzard
34
“Preparedness, when properly pursued, is a way of life, not a sudden, spectacular programme.” Spencer, W. Kimball.
Prepare like you might fail, but present your study with the assurance that you will pass.
FOCUS
N. Mauzard
35
Don’t focus on the after-party until you have actually reached the after-party
N. Mauzard
36
AFTER THE DEFENCE
N. Mauzard
37
BREATHE, IT’S OVER. Celebrate !!!
N. Mauzard
38