polio eradication: beginning of the end, or end of the ... · pdf filepolio eradication:...

74
Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD Adjoint Professor and Director Vaccines and Immunization Center for Global Health University of Colorado Denver, Colorado, Oct 2017

Upload: lengoc

Post on 22-Mar-2018

233 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning?

University of Colorado

Jon Kim Andrus, MDAdjoint Professor and Director Vaccines and ImmunizationCenter for Global HealthUniversity of Colorado

Denver, Colorado, Oct 2017

Page 2: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 3: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 4: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

What is Polio?

4

• Polio is a disease caused by polio-virus, which cripples its victims for life. The virus is mainly transmitted through the fecal-oral route. The disease can be prevented by vaccine.

Page 5: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliomyelitis

5

• First described by Michael Underwood in 1789

• First outbreak described in U.S. in 1843

• More than 21,000 paralytic cases reported in the U.S. in 1952

• 1988 resolution to achieve global eradication within next decade

Page 6: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliovirus

6

• Enterovirus (RNA)• Three serotypes: 1, 2, 3• Minimal heterotypic immunity

between serotypes• Rapidly inactivated by heat,

formaldehyde, chlorine, ultraviolet light

Page 7: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliomyelitis Pathogenesis

7

• Oral entry into the body• Replication in pharynx, GI tract,

local lymphatics• Hematologic spread to lymphatics

and central nervous system• Viral spread along nerve fibers• Destruction of motor neurons

Page 8: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Outcomes of poliovirus infection

8

• Asymptomatic: Up to 95% of infections are inapparentor asymptomatic. Ratio of inapparent to paralytic illness vary from 50:1 to 1,000:1 (usually 200:1). Infected persons without symptoms shed virus in the stool and are able to transmit the virus to others.

• Minor non-CNS: Approximate 4% (up to 8%) of polio infections consist of a minor, nonspecific illness without clinical or laboratory evidence of central nervous system invasion. This clinical presentation is characterized by complete recovery, usually in less than a week.

• Paralytic: <1% of infections result in AFP.• Death

Page 9: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Acute flaccid paralysis

transverse myelitis

traumatic neuritis

Guillain-Barre Syndrome

Other enteroviruses

Coxsackie virus Echovirus

Poliovirus

Page 10: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliovirus Epidemiology

10

• Reservoir: Human• Transmission: Fecal-oral• Communicability: 7-10 days before

onset• Virus present in stool 3 to 6 weeks

Page 11: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio Eradication - Can it be done?

11

What makes it possible?

• No animal reservoir• Effective

vaccine/strategies • No chronic carrier state• Short 1/2 life in

environment• Political commitment with

adequate finance

What makes it difficult?

• Inapparent infections (1000:1 ratio)

• Differential diagnosis• Surveillance challenge• Emergence of cVDPVs

Page 12: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Two Excellent Vaccines

12

Dr Jonas SalkIPV, 12 April 1955

Dr Albert SabinOPV, 1961 & 1962

Page 13: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Oral Polio Vaccine

13

• Highly effective in producing immunity to poliovirus

• Approximately 50% immune after 1 dose

• More than 95% immune after 3 doses

• Immunity probably lifelong

Page 14: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Inactivated Polio Vaccine

14

• Highly effective in producing immunity to poliovirus

• 90% or more immune after 2 doses

• At least 99% immune after 3 doses

• Duration of immunity not known with certainty

Page 15: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Vaccine-Associated Paralytic Polio

15

• Increased risk in persons 18 years and older

• Increased risk in persons with immunodeficiency

• No procedure available for identifying persons at risk of paralytic disease

• 5-10 cases per year in US with exclusive use of OPV

• Most cases in healthy children and their household contacts

Page 16: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Some Key Differences

16

• IPV OPV

• Immunity Humoral Intestinal/humoral

• Cost US dollars US cents

• Delivery Injection Oral

• Herd immunity Limited Substantial

Page 17: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Strategies

17

Strategies always rely on:

• Immunizing susceptible population

• Conducting effective surveillance

• Sustaining the gains

Page 18: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliomyelitis, Cuba, 1946-1980

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

19621952 1972

Source: PAHO & MOH

Page 19: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliomyelitis, Costa Rica, 1950-1980

0

50

100

150

200

250

Campaign OPV

Routine OPV

1952 19781965

Source: PAHO & MOH

Page 20: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 21: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Basic strategies for polio eradication

21

• Strong routine immunization program achieving high coverage

• National Immunization Days (NIDs)• Surveillance of acute flaccid

paralysis with laboratory support• “Mopping-up” immunization - final

stage

Page 22: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Political Will

Page 23: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Strategic plan - Guiding principles

23

• Provides vision for future work• Operationalizes the scientific components• Prioritizes targets• Utilizes lessons learned• Produces results and is product oriented• Develops direction with accountability• Promotes partnerships and collaboration• Remains focused & promotes quality of work• Expect the unexpected• “Disease eradication fights inequities and

creates social justice”

Page 24: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

PAHO Polio Eradication – General Lessons

24

• Acute flaccid paralysis surveillance oversight

• Coordination of the polio lab network of the Americas

• Protocol for the certification of polio eradication

• Better understanding of risks

de Quadros CA, Andrus JK, Olive J-M, de Macedo CG, and Henderson DA: Polio eradication from the Western Hemisphere. Annu Rev PublHealth 1992;13:239-52.

Page 25: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Risk of Vaccine-Associated Paralytic Poliomyelitis Bull WHO 1995;73(1):33-40

Page 26: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Direct detection of wild poliovirus in sewageJID 1993;168

26

Page 27: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

LAST CASE OF POLIO IN THE AMERICASPERU - 1991

27

Page 28: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Lessons Learned and Impact of Polio on Capacity Development

28

• General lessons learned – Political commitment, technical and operational excellence

• Partnerships• Lessons for capacity development

– Positive impact does not happen automatically, people have to look actively for linkages

– Mistakes will happen, is there sufficient capacity to react to extraordinary circumstances?

• Report of the Taylor Commission– Culture of prevention– Increased community awareness– Multi-sectoral coordination

Page 29: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Using the PAHO experience for the global

effort

Page 30: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 31: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 32: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

# ####

### #

####

##

##

# #

## ###

##

## ##

##

#

##

# ###

#

####

#

# #

##

## ##

#

#

# #

##

#

######

####

##

#

#

###

# ##

###

#

# #

# ###

# ##

#

##

#

###

###

###

### ## ##

####

###

##### ## ##

# #####

## #

##

#

####

####

# ########

#

### ## #

# ## ### ##

##

######

###

## #

####

## ##

#

#####

#

##

###

#

## #

##

##

#

##

#

#

### #

##

#### ##

###

# ###

##

#

#

#

#

##

## #

# #

##

#

####

##

#

#

###

##

##

#####

##

### ###

# ###

####

##

####

###

###

## #

###

###

##

###

#

#

##

###

##

# #

#

#

####

#

##

##

###

#

#

# #

###

#

#

##

#

##

#

#

## #

#

###

## #

# #####

## #

##

#

##

#

# #

#################

##

##

#

# ###

#

###

###

####

#

#

###

#

##

#

##

##

###

#

#

# #

#

##

##

##

# #

##

##

#

#

## #

##

##

#

#

#

#

###

#

# ###

##

##

####

##

##

#

#

##

## ###

#

##

# ####

#

#

##

#

## ##

#

##

# ## #

####

#

##

# #

###

#

## #

#

## ###

##

# ###

#

#

#

###

#

## ##

####

## # ###

# ##

##

###

###

#

#

#

##

#

#

#

#

# #

#

#

#

#

##

##

#

##

##

#

#

#

#

##

##

##

#

##

#

#

##

#

#

#

#

# #

# ##

### ##

#

#

###

##

##

# #

## ##

#

#

##

#

##

############

##

##

####

####

#

## #

###

##

##

###

#

#

###

######

# ### ###

#######

#

##

#

#

### #

##

#

#

#

#

#

###

#

###

###

## #####

#

#

#

#

#

##

### ##

#

### #

####

##########

#

####

#

# ## ###

### ##### #

###

##

##

# ### ### ####

### #

## ###

## #

##

##### #

###### #

# ##

## ##### ## ##

## ### #

## ### #####

##

### ## ####

## #

##

# ### ### #

##

####

####

##

# ##

#

# ### # ### ####

### ######### #

## #

#### ##

## ##

#### ## ##

###

## ###

## ## ### ####

### ##

######

######

#

# ##

##

##

##

###

####

#### ##

# ##

###

## #

#

###

#####

##

#### ##

#

## #

##

##

#

#

#### ##

## ### ###

##

##

## #

#### #

###### #

# ## ######

#####

###

#####

####

# ##

#

###

####

## # #### # ### #####

####### ####

# ####

### #######

###

#### ### ###### # ### #### #

#####

####

### #

# ### # ### ##### # #

# ###

######

##

###### #

## ######

### #

# ####

##

##### ### ### #

###

# ###

# # ## ###

###

# #######

#### # #

###

# # ##

#

# ###

###

#

###

# ###

#

##

## #

#

####

# ##

###

####

# ##

#

####

#

#

#

#

#

####

###

###

#

#

#

# #

## ###

###

##

## # ##

###########

#

#

#

##

#

#### ###

# #####

#

####

#

#

####

##

#

###

#

# ## ###

##

####

#

## #

# #

#

# ###

###

#

#

###

# ####

##

# ##

#

##

#

##

#

###

###

#

#

##

#

####

#

#

#

############## #

#### ###

#

#

#

####

##

## #######

# ########

####

## ### #######

## ####

###

##

########## #

#### ##

### ##

#

####

#### ## #

## #

#

##

#

#### #

#

##

# #

#

####### #

#### ## #

##### #

##

###

##

#

#

#

##

## #

####

#### ##

#

###

## #### # ### ### ####

### ###

###

#

#

#

#

##

### #####

##### ####

#####

##

# ## ######

###

#### ## #

##

# ###

##### #

# ##

###

### ###

##

### ##

### ## ## ### #### # ## ###

# ###

#

###

#

#

#

########

# #

###

##

# ##

#

#

###

##

#

#### ####

##

##### ##### ############# ####

###

###### #

### ##

Wild Poliovirus Cases in Orissa-India, 1998

Total cases 1934Polio Eradication

Page 33: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

##

#

#

#

#

#

##

#

###

#

###

#

##

#

# ## ##

# ####

# ## ##

##

#

###

# ### ##

##

# ## ##

# ###

##

# ## #####

###

####### ## ##

##

### ######

#

##

##

#

###

###

#

####

##

###

# ##

#

#

# #

####

##

#

##

#

##

#

#

#

#

# #

#

#

#

####

#

# ## ##

#

#

#

##

#

#

#

#

#

##

##

#

##

#

#

#

##

#

# #

#

#

#

###

##

##

##

####

#

#

##

#

######

####

## ### ####

#

##### ##

####

###

####

#### #

## ###

###

##

##

### ## ### #

# ##

######

##########

###

##### ##

####

##

#

## ##

###

###

######## ##

###### ## ## ###

## #### ### #

# ## ## #

########## #####

### ##

#

# ### # #### ####

###

#### ### #

###### ###

####

#

### ## ##

# ### ###

###### ## ## ## ##

## ###### ##

## ###

#### ####

### #

# ###

####

# ####

######

##

#

#### #### ##

##

# ##### ## #

# ##### ##

# #

##

#

####

###

###

##

### #

## #

##

### #

###

#

# #

###

# ## #

#

#

####### ##

### #

## ######

###

###

#

#

#

##

## ## ##

###

# ### ## #

##

## #

####

# ##

#

#

## ## #

##

# ####

#

### ##

## #

#

#

### ##

# ##

### ## #####

###### ##

#######

## #

##### ## #

## #####

###

##

#

####

## #

#

##

# #

#

##

#

##

##

##

#

#### #

# ##

###

#

#

##

#

#

##

##

# #

#

###### ## # ## # ##

####

###

#

##

##

## ## ##### ###### ## #### #### ##

### #

##

###

##

## ## #

#### ##

#### ######

##

###

######

#### ## ######

## ##

#### #

# #######

###### # ###

#

### #######

####

#

#####

#

#####

###

#

####

##

##

###

### ## ##### #

### ## #

# #### ## # ### ## #

# ####### #####

# ##

### #

##########

#######

#######

########

#

#

#

## ##

###

## ## #

####

##

#######

## ### ####

####### ######### ####

## ## ###### ########### #######

## #####

#

Impact of Mopping-up operation in Orissa, 1999

Zero case 99/2000Polio Eradication

Page 34: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Mopping-up Operation in Orissa, 1999

Mopping-up operation in 8 Districts immunizing over 1.7 million children

Polio Eradication

Page 35: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

SEAR Polio Eradication, 1993-2000

35

• Successful resource mobilization to implement strategies

• Successful eradication of wild poliovirus transmission in Bangladesh, Nepal, Myanmar, Indonesia, Thailand*

• Creation of high quality surveillance in India and other key countries

• Lowest levels of transmission in India*Andrus JK, Thapa A, Withana N, Fitzsimmons JW, Abeykoon P, Aylward B. A new paradigm of international disease control? Lessons learned from polio eradication in South-East Asia, 1997-2000. Am J Public Health, 2001;91:146-150.

Page 36: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Real Progress by the late 1990s: 3 of 6 WHO Regions Certified Polio-Free by

2002

36

1991: Luis Fermín TenorioCortez, last case in the

Americas (Peru)

1997: Mum Chanty, last case in the Western

Pacific Region(Cambodia)

1998: Melik Minas, last case in Europe

(Turkey)

Images from CDC, Rotary

Page 37: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Global progress, as well as setbacks and challenges (2000-present)

Are we repeating the same mistakes?Will the pending ramp down of resources

protect the gains?

Page 38: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Uttar Pradesh outbreak 1600 cases in 2002

Page 39: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Endemic countries

Outbreak countries 2003-2009

International spread of wild polioviruses into previously polio-free areas, 2003-2009

Page 40: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Immunogenicity ofMonovalent OPV1 vs. Trivalent OPV

32%

61%55%

90%

0

20

40

60

80

100

Egypt . India

Perc

enta

ge C

hild

ren

Prot

ecte

d Pe

r Dos

e

tOPV

mOPV1

Randomized Clinical Trials

1 Dose (Birth) 2 Doses (Birth + 30 Days)

40

OPV, Oral Polio Vaccine

Source: WHO 40

Page 41: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Global Polio Cases by Serotype, 2001-2009

mOPV

Source: WHO/Polio database 193 WHO Member States

Number of Cases

mOPV: monovalent Oral Polio Vaccine

Page 42: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Risks of Polio After 'Eradication'

VAPP 2-4/million birth cohort 250-500 stable

iVDPV 19 identified <1 decreases(since 1963)

cVDPV 1* per year 20 increases

IPV sites 1 accident (1990s) <1 decreases

Lab accident 1 investigation NK decreases

Deliberate 0 NK unknown

Frequency Annual Evolution Risk to date burden over time

*Based on current understanding. Source: WHO 42

Page 43: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Areas with Confirmed Polio Cases Hispaniola, 2000 - 2001

= areas confirmed polio cases43

Page 44: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Distribution of iVDPVs* by income level & duration of excretion, 2004

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

LowMiddleHigh

*Individuals with severe primary immunodeficiencies who are known to have excreted a vaccine-derived poliovirus (VDPV) for > 12 months.

Detected Cases

Duration of Execretion in Years

Page 45: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio-Paralyzed Children, 2013International Spread of Polio, 2013

• Egypt, Israel Palestine sewage

• Syria re-infected

• Horn of Africa re-infected

• Cameroon importation

• 2014: EQ Guinea & Iraq

International Spread of Polio, 2014

45

Page 46: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

cVDPV Cases by Type, 2000 - 2014

1Circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus (cVDPV) is associated with 2 or more AFP cases. Niger 2006, Niger 2009, Niger 2010, Chad 2010 cVDPVs are linked to the Nigeria outbreak. Kenya 2012 cVDPVs are linked to the Somalia outbreak. VDPV type 2 cases with greater than or equal to 6nt difference from sabin in VP1; VDPV types 1 and 3 cases with greater than or equal to 10nt difference from sabin in VP1 are reported here. Figures exclude VDPV from non-AFP sources. Nigeria figures include the following cases with WPV1/cVDPV2 mixture: 2005 - 2, 2006 - 1, 2007 - 1, 2008 - 3, 2009 - 1, 2011 - 1; WPV3/cVPDV2 mixture 2007 - 2. 2Figures include multiple emergences and transmission chains. 1 cVDPV2 awaiting country assignment is not represented in the slide. On 22 May a case, with a date of onset of paralysis of 4 May, was reported in Niger from a Nigerian child.

Data in WHO HQ as of 04 November 2014

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Onset of most recent case

Mozambique 2 02-Jun-11Myanmar 1 4 06-Dec-07Indonesia 46 26-Oct-05China 2 11-Nov-04Philippines 3 26-Jul-01DOR/Haiti 12 9 12-Jul-01Total type 1 12 12 0 0 2 46 1 4 0 0 0 2 0 0 0

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Onset of most recent case

Pakistan 16 48 20 16-Sep-14South Sudan 2 12-Sep-14Nigeria 3 22 71 68 155 27 34 8 4 21 12-Sep-14Cameroon 4 12-Aug-13Niger 2 2 1 1 1 11-Jul-13Chad 1 12 4 12-May-13Afghanistan 5 1 9 3 13-Mar-13Somalia 1 6 1 9 1 1 09-Jan-13Kenya 3 29-Aug-12DRCongo 13 5 18 11 17 04-Apr-12China 2 06-Feb-12Yemen 9 05-Oct-11India 15 2 18-Jan-10Ethiopia 3 1 16-Feb-09Madagascar 1 4 3 13-Jul-05Total type 2 0 1 4 0 0 6 24 71 85 184 55 65 68 65 43

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Onset of most recent case

Yemen 3 1 12-Jul-13Ethiopia 1 5 17-May-10Cambodia 1 1 15-Jan-06Total type 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 5 0 3 1 0

CountrycVDPV type 32

Country

CountrycVDPV type 22

cVDPV type 12

Page 47: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Current situation

Page 48: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Pakistan and Afghanistan

Page 49: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Number of WPV from any source, Pakistan, 2013-2017

Data in WHO HQ as of 23 May 2017

• Number of WPV cases has significantly declined in 2017• However, environmental surveillance detection of WPV1 persists

WPV Trend in Pakistan

49Source: WHO

Page 50: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

0

10

20

30

40

Jan

Feb

Mar

Ap

rM

ay Jun

Jul

Au

gSe

pO

ctN

ovD

ec Jan

Feb

Mar

Ap

rM

ay Jun

Jul

Au

gSe

pO

ctN

ovD

ec Jan

Feb

Mar

Ap

rM

ay Jun

Jul

Au

gSe

pO

ctN

ovD

ec Jan

Feb

Mar

2014 2015 2016 2017

Tie

r-4

0

10

20

30

40

Tie

r-1

Quetta BlockKila Abdullah

Karachi

0

10

20

30

40

Tie

r-2

0

10

20

30

40

Tie

r-3

11 districts, 4M target

33 districts, 6.4M target

24 districts, 8.7M target

87 districts, 17.8 M target

* Data as of 30 May 2017

Pakistan: Decreasing transmission in the core reservoirs, outbreaks in tier-4 districts

Peshawar

50Source: WHO

Page 51: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

0

2

4

6

8

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

MarN

o of

cas

es

201620152014

Afghanistan: Recent cases linked to cross-border transmission

02468

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

MarN

o of

cas

es

0

2

4

6

8

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May Jun

Jul

Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

Jan

Feb

MarN

o of

cas

esSouth region

East region

Southeast region

Continued endemic transmission Cross-border transmission

51Source: WHO

Page 52: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Africa

Page 53: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Wild poliovirus update - Nigeria

53

• 4 wild poliovirus type 1 (WPV1) cases confirmed in July 2016 from insecure areas of Borno State in Nigeria

• Ministers of Health from Lake Chad Basin countries declared the outbreak a sub-regional public health emergency

• 5 synchronized outbreak response rounds conducted in in 2016 and 2 rounds in 2017

• Last WPV1 case with onset on 21 August 2017, in Borno State, Nigeria

128

76

17

04

00

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

Year

Wil

d p

olio

viru

s ca

ses

53Source: WHO

Page 54: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Inaccessibility affecting surveillance and vaccination activities, Borno State, Nigeria

54

Inaccessible settlements 6,145 (48%) Inaccessible settlements 5,216 (37%)

• Though 9 months have passed, without WPV cases uncertainty that transmission has been stopped• Using satellite imagery to determine if settlements are inhabited or destroyed• Using military for innovations such as reaching every settlement and reaching inaccessible children

54Source: WHO

Page 55: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Environmental Surveillance, 2016

55

Page 56: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio, type 3 cases

* At 5 March 2013

2013

Nigeria & Pakistan had type 3 last in 2012

Page 57: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliovirus: Decreasing Diversity

57

Page 58: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Status of Polio Eradication

58

• Last case in United States in 1979• Western Hemisphere last case 1991, certified polio

free in 1994• SEAR certified polio free 2015• Last isolate of type 2 poliovirus in India in Oct 1999• No wild type 3 isolated since 2012• The entire African region had not had a WPV case

since Aug 2014, so the recent cases in Nigeria in 2016 are a major set back

• 4 of 6 regions certified polio free• Three countries remain endemic for polio – Nigeria,

Afghanistan and Pakistan

Page 59: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

59 |

Polio Eradication Nigeria latest WPV1 case - 20 August 2016 in Borno State, Nigeria (n=4);

last cVDPV2 case 27 Oct 2016

Pakistan latest WPV1 10 June 2017 (n=3)

Afghanistan latest WPV1 9 July 2017 (n=6)

9 cVDPV2 cases in DR Congo with latest onset recently in 2017

47 cVDPV2 cases Syria with latest onset August 2017

GPEI-funded human resource ramp-down commenced in 2017

Polio transition planning is underway in priority countries

The major priorities for the PEI are to quickly stop current cVDPVoutbreaks and to strengthen surveillance to avoid missing any poliovirus circulation

Page 60: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Risks Going Forward

Page 61: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Financial Risk

1 billion dollars per year

Page 62: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint
Page 63: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

OPV withdrawal in 3 stages

IMG, IPV Introduction and OPV Withdrawal

Introduction• at least one dose of IPV into routine

immunization

Switch• tOPV to bOPV

Withdrawal• of bOPV &

routine OPV use

Ongoing STRENGTHENING of routine immunization services

2015-2016

2016

2020

Source: WHO

Page 64: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

IPV supply remains tight throughout 2017

Unicef SD data as of 9 June 64Source: WHO

Page 65: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Countries with IPV supply disruptions

The boundaries and names shown and the designations used on this map do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the World Health Organization concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. Dotted lines on maps represent approximate border lines for which there may not yet be full agreement. ©WHO 2016. All rights reserved.

Data source: WHO/IVB Database, as of 11 April 2017Map production Immunization Vaccines and Biologicals (IVB),

World Health OrganizationCountries with delayed resupply (17 countries or 8.8%)

Countries already introduced

Countries with delayed introduction (18 countries or 9.2%)

0 1,900 3,800950 Kil

65

Source: WHO

Page 66: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

66

Page 67: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Conflict-related access limitations

Potential riskMedium risk/partially accessibleHigh risk/inaccessible

67 Source : United Nations Department of Safety and Security , August 2016

Page 68: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio Transition

Page 69: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio Transition Planning

Helps protect a polio-free world Ensures that investments made to

end polio continue protecting and improving health after eradication

Every country with polio eradication resources and infrastructure should prepare for the transition

Should be led by the national government and involve a broad range of stakeholders

Page 70: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

70

>1000 personnel>100 personnel>40 personnel>10 personnel

Note: Philippines, Haiti also have between 1-10 polio funded personnel but are not displayed; no headquarters staff displayedSource: GPEI partner HR databases, 2014

1+ personnel

GPEI presence in over 70 countries, but 95% of personnel footprint in 16 countries

Includes social mobilizers. Does not include national government staff, vaccinators or regional/headquarters personnel.

Country-level Transition Planning | Transition Independent Monitoring Board

M&RI – 6 Gavi priority

Page 71: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Characteristics of the 16 Priority“Polio Transition” Countries

• Most of the world’s unvaccinated and under-vaccinated children (53% of 20.8 million infants who did not receive measles vaccine in

2015 are in the Big 6 priority measles countries)• Most of the world’s measles cases and deaths (88% of deaths)

• Most of the world’s rubella and congenital rubella syndrome(100,000 CRS cases)

Consequences of losing polio assets – risk that EPI progress in these countries and globally will be reversed !!

Page 72: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Polio-Funded Surveillance Officer Responsibilities

Polio

Other VPDs:• Measles/Rubella• Yellow Fever• Neonatal tetanus• Meningitis• Acute encephalitis

syndrome• Diphtheria• Cholera• Pertussis…and so on

Other VPDs

Other Communicable Diseases:• Bloody diarrhea • Neglected tropical diseases• Dengue• Viral hemorrhagic fevers• Rabies• Malaria….and so on

Page 73: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Thank you!

73

Page 74: Polio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the ... · PDF filePolio Eradication: Beginning of the End, or End of the Beginning? University of Colorado Jon Kim Andrus, MD. Adjoint

Poliomyelitis, Chile, 1946-1980

0

200

400

600

800

46 58 70

Routine OPV

Campaign OPV

Source: PAHO & MOH