pittsburgh legal ournal - pittsburgh, pennsylvania€¦ · armstrong, jeffrey v. city of...

PITTSBURGH LEGAL JOURNAL

Annual Bound Volume of Opinion Inserts

VOLUME 157

2009

Published byAllegheny County Bar Association

400 Koppers Building436 Seventh Avenue

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219

412-261-6161www.acba.org

Copyright © 2009

Allegheny County Bar Association

All rights reserved. No part of this book, or any other Bound Volume of Pittsburgh Legal JournalOpinion Inserts, may be reproduced by any means, without express written permission from the Editoror Executive Director at the Allegheny County Bar Association. The Allegheny County Bar Association

retains copyright of the material in all previous Bound Volumes of Opinion Inserts despite anyindication to the contrary.

ISSN: 0032-0331

Printed and bound in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

VOLUME 157 - PAGE 3 2009Supplement to The Lawyers Journal

A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud,Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody, individually and asAdministratrix of the Estate of Jerry McCrommon, III,deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard;Penn-America Insurance Company v. ........................................153

Aboud, Nasid, Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver,Beatrice Woody, individually and as Administratrix of theEstate of Jerry McCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler,Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard; Penn-America InsuranceCompany v. A4 Place, Inc., ..........................................................153

Addlespurger, Julie v. Steven Addlespurger v.Donald Addlespurger and Auto Driveway Company ..................34

Adewumi, Biodun and Sam Ashaolu v.Duquesne University, et al. ..........................................................444

(J)Aiken, Donna L. and Thomas W. Aiken, III v.Eric Robert Hasis; Donna L. ........................................................152

AIU Insurance Company; et al.; Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.;Fisher Scientific International, Inc.; Fisher ScientificOperating Company; and Fisher Hamilton, L.L.C. v. ....................4

AIU Insurance Company; et al.; Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.;Fisher Scientific International, Inc.; Fisher ScientificOperating Company; and Fisher Hamilton, L.L.C. v. ....................9

AJNP Development, LLC; Gill Hall Land Co. v. ................................74Albert, James a/k/a James Holland; Commonwealth of

Pennsylvania v. ..............................................................................181Aleppo Township, Appellee; Ross Mendicino, Annunziato

Reilsono and Jessica Reilsono, Appellants v. ..............................57Alexander, Ruth, In Re: Estate of, a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ..110(C)Aliucci, Anthony; Melissa King v. ................................................332Allegheny County a/k/a City of Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition

Authority and Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball Club, Inc.;Connie LeGrand v. The Sports and Exhibition Authority ofPittsburgh and................................................................................292

Allegheny County Housing Authority; Christopher Belajac v. ......459Allegheny County; Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf,

Friends Against Counterproductive Taxation andCharles P. McCullough v. ..............................................................211

Allegheny Demolition, Inc. v. LVI Environmental Services, Inc. ..416Allegheny General Hospital and Marianne Iwankonkiw v.

Bethel Park School District and Nutrition, Inc. andGeorge Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v. JSMS Partners LP,JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.;DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v...........................................................363

Allegheny Specialty Practice Network and The West PennAllegheny Health System v. Joseph J. Colella, M.D. ................370

Allen, Robert Lee; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....................122(J)Allie, Teena M. v. Sandra Smith ....................................................151(J)Altschuler, Eric M., M.D.; Arthur H. Palmer, M.D.; Cynthia

McGuinness and Matthew McGuinness, her husband v.The Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh; Pittsburgh NeurosurgeryAssociates, Ltd.; ............................................................................152

Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85;Port Authority of Allegheny County v. ........................................387

Ambrose, Mark W. and Ronald A. Kramer v.Citizens National Bank of Evans City, Pennsylvania ................483

American Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers, Inc.,Industry Terminal & Salvage Co. and International MarineUnderwriters/One Beacon ............................................................447

(C)Andros, Andrew F. v. Laurie Ann Waltz ......................................322Anthony Crane Rental, Inc., et al. v. Gustine Uniontown, Inc.,

et al., Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. ................492Anthony, Robert Morris; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........206Antonucci, John and Judith A. Antonucci v.

Shawmut Woodworking, et al. ......................................................394Apple, James R.; The Huntington National Bank, Successor by

Merger to Sky Bank, Successor by Merger to PennsylvaniaCapital Bank v. ..............................................................................202

Armstrong, Jeffrey v. City of Pittsburgh, et al.; National RifleAssociation, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese, Richard Haid and ..368

Ashaolu, Sam v. Duquesne University, et al.;Biodun Adewumi and ....................................................................444

Aspinwall, Zoning Hearing Board of and W. Preston Germain,et ux. and Cassique Properties, L.P.; George R. Rhodes andSharon L. Leech v. ........................................................................291

Auto Driveway Company; Julie Addlespurger v. StevenAddlespurger v. Donald Addlespurger and ..................................34

Automobile Insurance Company of Hartford, ConnecticutAutomobile Insurance Company of Hartford v. James Guardino,et al.; Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty InsuranceCompany v. James Dean Guardino d/b/a James DeanAutoworks, Audrey J. D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye, and ..............49

Baich, George; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........................39Baird, David J.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................162(J)Bajek, Justine M. v. Steven J. Eliou ..............................................151Bakth, Omar J.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................182Baldwin, David R.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..................476Ballard, Jennifer Marie; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...........419Barber, James J., et al. v.

Clarendon National Insurance Company, et al. ..........................341Barber, Jason; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........................402Bartholomaei, Mark A. v. Land Rover North America, Inc. ............45Belajac, Christopher v. Allegheny County Housing Authority ......459Betco, Inc. v. B. John Gatesman, Kimberly R. Gatesman,

Gatesman Properties, Inc. and National City Bank ..................454Bethel Park School District and Nutrition, Inc. and

George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v. JSMS Partners LP,JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.;DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospitaland Marianne Iwankonkiw v. ......................................................363

Bey, Anthony Flipping; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............81Birdseye, Scott R., and Automobile Insurance Company of Hartford,

Connecticut Automobile Insurance Company of Hartford v.James Guardino, et al.; Pennsylvania National MutualCasualty Insurance Company v. James Dean Guardinod/b/a James Dean Autoworks, Audrey J. D’Incau,......................49

Bishop, William R., Jr. v. Ted Kaczorowski a/k/aThaddeus Kaczorowski and Mona Kaczorowski a/k/aMona Singer Kaczorowski ............................................................330

Blazczak, Stephen and Fiona v. Township of West Deer ................504

C U M U L AT I V E I N D E X - V O L U M E 1 5 7 - 2 0 0 9This listing is provided according to Plaintiff/Defendant names for your convenience.Under this title is printed a list of all cases reported in the Pittsburgh Legal Journal,a Supplement to the Lawyers Journal (Volume No. 157 - 2009). Subscribers can findin this index immediate reference to any case reported in the PITTSBURGH LEGALJOURNAL. For identification purposes: (C)Capsule Summaries; and (J)Jury Verdicts.

VOLUME 157 - PAGE 4 2009Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal

Boczkowski, Timothy; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............84Bodnar, Kim A. v. State Farm Mutual Insurance Co. ........................78Bogan, Steven and Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v.

Pre-Owned Auto Center of Indiana, PA, Inc. ............................324Bonaroti, Eugene; and Oakland Neurosurgical Associates;

Kirk Rettger and Erik Rettger, Co-Executors of theEstate of Michael Rettger, deceased v. UPMC Shadyside; ......242

Borough Council of the Borough of Oakmont;HHI Trucking Supply, Inc. v.........................................................279

Borough of Franklin Park and Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P.,d/b/a T-Mobile; Richard W. Schomaker v. Zoning HearingBoard of the Borough of Franklin Park and ..............................453

Borough of Versailles; Emerson Fazekas, Mayor, Borough ofVersailles v. Borough Council of the............................................280

Botero Development LLC and City of Pittsburgh; Daniel G. Kamin,et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board of Adjustment of theCity of Pittsburgh and ..................................................................270

(C)Bouzos-Reilly, Marie v. John R. Reilly ........................................438Bowman, John, and PNC Bank, N.A.; Kenneth F. Emmett v.

Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential Securities, Inc.,Louis Dworsky, ................................................................................72

Broaden, Richard; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.......................96Broaden, Richard; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....................425Broadus, Cordell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................147Brown, Gene Leonard; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............229Brownfield, Michael; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............238Bryant, Marlynn; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.......................321Bugarin, Jennifer, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First, An

Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson, EdwinNelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin Square v.Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-Mart StoresEast, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach, ..........................267

Bureaus Investment Group #10, LLC v. Larry Bruce Wilcox ........296

Caiarelli, David H., et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. and DavidAlbertini, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., Edward S. Lampert,Aylwin Lewis, William C. Crowley ..............................................197

Calinger, Dr. Walter M., David W. Johnston, and Allison Kline;E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Boardof School Directors, ......................................................................442

Capo, Frank, Robert Linder, and Robert Linder Services, Inc.;Dale Zegarelli v. ............................................................................328

CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss; Select Medical RehabilitationServices, Inc., d/b/a NW Rehabilitation Associates v.Pennsylvania West Association, a/k/a Penn West Associates,Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursing and Rehabilitation Center;Primus Care, Inc., formerly known as ..........................................15

(C)Carson, Pamela M. v. Sidney Carson............................................438Casey, Sean Connolly, John Graf, Friends Against

Counterproductive Taxation and Charles P. McCullough v.Allegheny County; Kevin Joyce, ..................................................211

Cassique Properties, L.P.; George R. Rhodes and Sharon L.Leech v. Zoning Hearing Board of Aspinwall andW. Preston Germain, et ux. and ..................................................291

Chartiers Country Club; Marc A. Mastro, et al. v. ..........................351Chopra, Sanjay v. Amit Govil, Asit Govil, and Google, Inc. ............317Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473Citizens National Bank of Evans City, Pennsylvania;

Mark W. Ambrose and Ronald A. Kramer v. ..............................483City of Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition Authority and

Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball Club, Inc.; Connie LeGrand v.Sports and Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh andAllegheny County a/k/a ................................................................292

City of Pittsburgh; Daniel G. Kamin, et al., Appellants v.Zoning Board of Adjustment of the City of Pittsburgh andBotero Development LLC and ....................................................270

City of Pittsburgh, et al.; National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka,Curtis Reese, Richard Haid and Jeffrey Armstrong v. ............368

City of Pittsburgh; Reginald and Vermell Plato v. ..........................450City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment v. City of Pittsburgh

v. Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor; Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham,Timothy McVeagh, and Michael Ressler, Appellants v. ..............56

City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment andCity of Pittsburgh; Robert A. Woolhandler v. ............................272

Clarendon National Insurance Company, et al.;James J. Barber, et al. v. ..............................................................341

Clark, Barbara A. v. Richard P. Shannon ..........................................320Cobbs, Jeffrey; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................258Coblitz, Phillip, Intervenor; Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham,

Timothy McVeagh, and Michael Ressler, Appellants v.City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment v.City of Pittsburgh v. ........................................................................56

CoGo’s Co., and NK Mini Mart, Inc.; John G. Yunk v.Joseph B. Tomko, Jr., Janice M. Tomko, ....................................295

Cole, James Edward, Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........497Colella, Joseph J., M.D.; Allegheny Specialty Practice Network

and The West Penn Allegheny Health System v.........................370Collins, Carl; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................407Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Albert

a/k/a James Holland......................................................................181Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Lee Allen......................122Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Morris Anthony ..........206Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George Baich ..............................39Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David J. Baird ..........................162Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Omar J. Bakth ..........................182Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David R. Baldwin ....................476Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jennifer Marie Ballard............419Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jason Barber ............................402Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Flipping Bey................81Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Timothy Boczkowski..................84Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden........................96Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden......................425Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cordell Broadus ......................147Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gene Leonard Brown ..............229Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Brownfield ................238Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marlynn Bryant........................321Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Cobbs............................258Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Edward Cole, Jr. ..........497Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Carl Collins ..............................407Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Davis, Jr. ....................130Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Davis ..........................165Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marquis Dennis........................353Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Driver ........................239Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Darnell Evans ................94Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Matthew Farmer ......................190Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tequilla Fields

a/k/a Tequilla Newsome................................................................478Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dennis Foy ................................143Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Fuller................................127Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Shawn Graham ........................289Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hamin Azeez Gray ....................64Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Pierce Greene ..........................262Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cecil Earl Grow..........................67Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ivan Milton Hale ......................286Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Morris Haley ............................494Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Neal Hall ......................120Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Nancy Hammer ........................354Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Hancock............................224Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rashad Desean Hefflin ..........223Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Holland;

James Albert a/k/a ........................................................................181Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Jackson ......................399


Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al.; JD & RM, Inc. v. ..............415Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Troy Joseph ..............................460Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Julian ..........................142Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Moon Jong Kim ........................231Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Pierre King......................98Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Pierre King....................396Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael R. Lipinski..................192Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Anthony Lipscomb

and Susan Wygant............................................................................91Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Theresa Logsdon ......................141Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Barry Long................................228Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ryan Michael Luterman..........136Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kevin James Mariano................99Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hayden Nathaniel Marshall....138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jayquon Massey ......................439Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rodney Matthews

a/k/a William Taylor......................................................................162Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William George Mayer, III......119Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Benjamin Mayhew ..................475Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William McCray ........................37Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kimberly S. McKaveney ........256Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael McMillan....................409Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. T. Colm McWilliams ................203Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Mendoza ....................397Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Maurice Miles

a/k/a Robert Turner ......................................................................413Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bridget Mitchell ......................474Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leslie Mollett............................114Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James William Moore..............218Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jomar Laniel Mosby ................204Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Edward Nalls ................306Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. a/k/a Tequilla Newsome,

Tequilla Fields................................................................................478Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Parker..........................308Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Phillip Payne

a/k/a Christopher Payne ..............................................................310Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bruce Proctor ..........................288Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Restieri, Jr. ..................423Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John K. Richardson ................227Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Ricks..............................461Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tito Rivera................................303Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Patricia Ann Rodgers ..............358Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Robert Slater ................208Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Tusweet Smith ............62Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Whitney Sumpter ....................149Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. a/k/a William Taylor,

Rodney Matthews ..........................................................................162Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Joshua Richard Thompson ....124Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jesse William Thornton ..........138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Brian Travell Thurmon ..........263Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Todd ..............................65Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Trice ..............................421Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Turner ..............................160Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. a/k/a Robert Turner,

Maurice Miles ................................................................................413Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Ryan Webb, Jr. ..........188Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Weinberg......................235Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; William D. White v. ..................178Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Delmingo Williams ..................360Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Russell Wilner ............................38Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Yarudin A. Witherspoon ..........233Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Susan Wygant and

James Anthony Lipscomb ..............................................................91Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. ........237Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. Brian D. Errigo ..........................11

Condemnation(In the Matter of) by the Redevelopment Authority ofAllegheny County of certain land in the Borough of Homestead,Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, being Property of DeBoltUnlimited Travel Services Incorporated, successor bymerger to DeBolt Realty Co., Inc., et al. ....................................428

Conley, Marilyn, Executrix of the Estate of Ethel B. Shaw v.St. Barnabas Nursing Home, Inc., et al.......................................282

Consolidated Freightways Corporation of Delaware; Lynda R. Smithv. Con-Way, Inc., and jointly, severally or separately, ................200

Con-Way, Inc., and jointly, severally or separately, ConsolidatedFreightways Corporation of Delaware; Lynda R. Smith v. ......200

Crawford, Michael, Joan Leach, Jennifer Bugarin, and KamranFarzan; Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by JesseNicholson, Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici,and Franklin Square v. Moon Township Board of Supervisorsand Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and ............................................267

Cuda, Frank v. Paradise Pools and Spas..............................................79

Danzilli, John A., Jr. v. Mayor and Council of the Municipalityof Monroeville, et al.........................................................................31

Dash, Andrew v. Dana Wind and Sherry Kasprzyk;Racquel Underwood, Shauna McInnes and ..............................241

Davis, Charles, Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..................130Davis, Michael; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................165Dean, Robert, M.D.; Lori A. Marasco, Administratrix and/or

Guardian Ad Litem of the Estate of John R. Marasco, Sr. v.Giant Eagle, Inc., Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs,and/or Rite Aid Corporation and ................................................320

DeBolt Unlimited Travel Services Incorporated, successor bymerger to DeBolt Realty Co., Inc., et al.; In the Matter of theCondemnation by the Redevelopment Authority of AlleghenyCounty of certain land in the Borough of Homestead,Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, being Property of..................428

Demarco, Daniel L., Esq., et al.; North Hills School District v.Ross Township Zoning Hearing Board and Ross Townshipand North Hills School District v. ................................................71

Dennis, Marquis; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.......................353Dentici, Joseph, and Franklin Square v. Moon Township Board

of Supervisors and Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and MichaelCrawford, Joan Leach, Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan;Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by JesseNicholson, Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, ..............................267

D’Incau, Audrey J., Scott R. Birdseye, and Automobile InsuranceCompany of Hartford, Connecticut Automobile InsuranceCompany of Hartford v. James Guardino, et al.;Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Company v.James Dean Guardino d/b/a James Dean Autoworks, ................49

Dormont, Borough of; Daniel J. Zangrilli and DorothyM. Zangrilli, Appellants v. Zoning Hearing Board of theBorough of Dormont and the ........................................................55

Drabek, Martin and Douglas Stuhr;Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v. ............................................343

Driver, Anthony; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................239Drotar, Annette F. and Joseph, her husband v.

Daniel W. Pituch, D.M.D., M.D. ..................................................242Duquesne University, et al.; Biodun Adewumi and

Sam Ashaolu v. ..............................................................................444Dworsky, Louis, John Bowman, and PNC Bank, N.A.;

Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC,Prudential Securities, Inc., ............................................................72

E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board of SchoolDirectors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W. Johnston, andAllison Kline ..................................................................................442


Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs, and/or Rite AidCorporation and Robert Dean, M.D.; Lori A. Marasco,Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litem of the Estateof John R. Marasco, Sr. v. Giant Eagle, Inc., ..............................320

Eiler, Kevin A.; Christina M. Mossburger v. ....................................318(J)Eliou, Steven J.; Justine M. Bajek v. ............................................151Emmett, Kenneth F. v. Wachovia Securities, LLC,

Prudential Securities, Inc., Louis Dworsky, John Bowman,and PNC Bank, N.A. ........................................................................72

Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v. Pre-Owned AutoCenter of Indiana, PA, Inc.; Steven Bogan and ..........................324

Errigo, Brian D.; Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. ........................11Evans, Andre Darnell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............94Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.

Martin Drabek and Douglas Stuhr ..............................................343Ezell, Lamar, and Asa Howard; Penn-America Insurance

Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud,Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody, individually and asAdministratrix of the Estate of Jerry McCrommon, III,deceased, Earl C. Troxler, ............................................................153

Farmer, Matthew; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................190Farzan, Kamran; Moon First, An Unincorporated Association

by Jesse Nicholson, Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, JosephDentici, and Franklin Square v. Moon Township Board ofSupervisors and Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and MichaelCrawford, Joan Leach, Jennifer Bugarin, and ..........................267

Fazekas, Emerson, Mayor, Borough of Versailles v.Borough Council of the Borough of Versailles ..........................280

Fears, Leroy; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................23Fetterman, Debra, as Power of Attorney for Barbara J. Mears v.

ManorCare Health Services, Inc., d/b/a ManorCare HealthServices—Monroeville, et al. ........................................................254

Fields, Tequilla a/k/a Tequilla Newsome;Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................................478

Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,Inc.; Fisher Scientific Operating Company; and FisherHamilton, L.L.C. v. AIU Insurance Company; et al. ......................4

Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,Inc.; Fisher Scientific Operating Company; and FisherHamilton, L.L.C. v. AIU Insurance Company; et al. ......................9

Five-R Excavating, Inc. and Western Surety Company v.Seubert & Associates, Inc.; Zavala, Inc. v. ..................................107

Five Star Quality Care, Inc. d/b/a Overlook Green v.Joyce Yablonski and Charles Yablonski ......................................284

Foremost Insurance Company and Sentry Services InsuranceCompany, Inc.; Daniel F. Ross v. ..................................................338

Foy, Dennis; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................143Frank Bryan Inc. v. Pittsburgh Terminal Properties t/d/b/a

Riverwalk Corporate Center ........................................................463Franklin Square v. Moon Township Board of Supervisors and

Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, JoanLeach, Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First,An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson, EdwinNelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and............................267

Friends Against Counterproductive Taxation and Charles P.McCullough v. Allegheny County; Kevin Joyce, SeanConnolly Casey, John Graf, ..........................................................211

Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio Direct NorthCentral, Inc., Mark Gillie and Larry Lange; Roth Cash RegisterCompany, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.:Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Fuller, John; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...............................127

Garcia, Graciela v. Angel C. Garcia andWillis Shaw Express, Inc. ..............................................................37

Garrow, William C. v. Sister Mary D. Thaner, a/k/aSister Mary D. Thawer..................................................................297

Gatesman, B. John, Kimberly R. Gatesman, GatesmanProperties, Inc. and National City Bank; Betco, Inc. v. ............454

Gateway School District and Gateway School District Boardof School Directors; Shelby L. Jones, a Minor, byher Parent and Natural Guardian, David Jones, v. ....................277

Germain, W. Preston, et ux. and Cassique Properties, L.P.;George R. Rhodes and Sharon L. Leech v.Zoning Hearing Board of Aspinwall and ....................................291

Giant Eagle, Inc., Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs,and/or Rite Aid Corporation and Robert Dean, M.D.;Lori A. Marasco, Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litemof the Estate of John R. Marasco, Sr. v. ......................................320

Gill Hall Land Co. v. AJNP Development, LLC..................................74Gillie, Mark and Larry Lange; Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v.

Micros Systems, Inc., Frontier Business Technologies, Inc.,Micros Fidelio Direct North Central, Inc.;Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Gladstone, Richard W., II and Diana L. Hunkele;Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority v. ..................................298

GMAC Insurance Company; Frances Kelly v.MIC General Insurance Corporation, a ....................................273

Goldblatt, Bruce; Sonya Ring v. ........................................................133Gonzales, Orlando v. Housing Authority of the

City of Pittsburgh ..........................................................................327Google, Inc.; Sanjay Chopra v. Amit Govil, Asit Govil, and ............317Govil, Amit, Asit Govil, and Google, Inc.; Sanjay Chopra v. ..........317Graf, John, Friends Against Counterproductive Taxation and

Charles P. McCullough v. Allegheny County; Kevin Joyce,Sean Connolly Casey, ....................................................................211

Grafton, Doris E., Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G.Grafton, deceased, and Doris E. Grafton, in her own right,et al., v. Petroleum Development Corporation, et al. ................300

Graham, Douglas, Timothy McVeagh, and Michael Ressler,Appellants v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment v.City of Pittsburgh v. Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor;Evan Nauman, ..................................................................................56

Graham, Shawn; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................289Gray, Hamin Azeez; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..................64Greene, Pierce; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................262Grow, Cecil Earl; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................67Guardino, James Dean d/b/a James Dean Autoworks, Audrey J.

D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye, and Automobile Insurance Companyof Hartford, Connecticut Automobile Insurance Company ofHartford v. James Guardino, et al.; Pennsylvania NationalMutual Casualty Insurance Company v.........................................49

Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. Anthony CraneRental, Inc., et al. v. Gustine Uniontown, Inc., et al. ................492

GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Company and/or OxfordRealty Services, Inc.; Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L.Pollock Real Estate v. Pittsburgh Opera and PennsylvaniaCommercial Real Estate, Inc. and ..............................................391

Haburjak, George and Donna v. JSMS Partners LP,JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.;DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospitaland Marianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park School Districtand Nutrition, Inc. and ..................................................................363

Haid, Richard and Jeffrey Armstrong v. City of Pittsburgh, et al.;National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese,..........368

Hale, Ivan Milton; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................286


Haley, Morris; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........................494Hall, Andre Neal; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................120Hammer, Nancy; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................354Hampton Council, Township of; James J. and Carol E. Leo v. ....269Hancock, Eric; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...........................224Happy Days Saloon, Paul Kouknas, individually and t/d/b/a

Happy Days Saloon, William Edward Tooks, and Patricia FieldsTucker, Administratrix of the Estate of John Ricky Tucker, Jr.,deceased; Regis Insurance Company v. Paul KouknasEnterprises, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation, t/d/b/a..............193

(J)Hasis, Eric Robert; Donna L. Aiken andThomas W. Aiken, III v. ................................................................152

Hearn, Tonya; Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. ......395Hefflin, Rashad Desean; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........223Henderson Brothers, Inc., Industry Terminal & Salvage Co.

and International Marine Underwriters/One Beacon;American Coal and Minerals Company v. ..................................447

Hennicke, Mark and Chrissanne v. Palmetto Home Builders, Inc.and Pa. National Mutual Casualty Insurance Co. et al.;Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. ....................................................19

Hennigan; In re: Appeal of Steven ....................................................331Heritage Valley, d/b/a Sewickley Valley Hospital, et al.; Dani Jo

McLane and Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities, Inc. ..252HHI Trucking Supply, Inc. v. The Borough Council of the

Borough of Oakmont......................................................................279Holland, James; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.

James Albert a/k/a ......................................................................181Homestead(Borough of), Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, being

Property of DeBolt Unlimited Travel Services Incorporated,successor by merger to DeBolt Realty Co., Inc., et al.;In the Matter of the Condemnation by the RedevelopmentAuthority of Allegheny County of certain land in the ..............428

Hometown Sports, Inc.; Edward Zubik, Admr. of theEstate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v. James W. Miller & ..................245

Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh;Orlando Gonzales v. ......................................................................327

Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. Tonya Hearn ........395Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh; Steve Smith v. ..........459Howard, Asa; Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc.,

Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver,Beatrice Woody, individually and as Administratrix of theEstate of Jerry McCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler,Lamar Ezell, and............................................................................153

Huang, Ding; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................89Hunkele, Diana L.; Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority v.

Richard W. Gladstone, II and ......................................................298Huntington National Bank, The, Successor by Merger to

Sky Bank, Successor by Merger to Pennsylvania CapitalBank v. James R. Apple ................................................................202

(C)Huwe, Janice v. Joseph Huwe ......................................................210

Industry Terminal & Salvage Co. and International MarineUnderwriters/One Beacon; American Coal and MineralsCompany v. Henderson Brothers, Inc., ......................................447

In Re: Appeal of Steven Hennigan ....................................................331In Re: Estate of Ruth Alexander a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ......110In Re: Estate of Carol D. Silliman, Deceased ..................................333In Re: M.M., a minor ............................................................................32(C)In Re: In the Interest of: D.S., a minor Appeal of D.S.,

a minor ............................................................................................452In Re: Petition to Change Boundary Lines of Lot and

Block No. 1572-N-192 ....................................................................507In the Interest of: A.R. ........................................................................131In the Interest of F.C., III, a minor ....................................................439International Marine Underwriters/One Beacon; American

Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers, Inc.,Industry Terminal & Salvage Co. and ........................................447

Iwankonkiw, Marianne v. Bethel Park School District andNutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., KrebsChrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.; DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v.Allegheny General Hospital and..................................................363

Jackson, Charles; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................399Jackson, Floyd Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..................187James Dean Autoworks, Audrey J. D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye,

and Automobile Insurance Company of Hartford, ConnecticutAutomobile Insurance Company of Hartford v. James Guardino,et al.; Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty InsuranceCompany v. James Dean Guardino d/b/a ......................................49

Janosik, George and Lynn; Wells Fargo Bank, NA as Trustee v.....293(C)Janosik, Lynn A. v. George J. Janosik, Jr. ....................................44Jasiewicz, Pamela H.; Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. ................473(J)J.C. Schultz Interiors, Inc., t/d/b/a J.C. Schultz Co. and Oxford

Development Corp., t/d/b/a Oxford Realty Management;Elizabeth Sexton and Thomas J. Sexton, her husband v. ..........151

JD & RM, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al. ................415JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.;

DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospital andMarianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park School District andNutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, ........................................................................363

JKMilne Asset Management; Carolyn Lustfield v.John K. Milne and Milne, LLC, t/d/b/a ......................................247

Johnson and Johnson, Inc., et al.; Daniel J. Selepec, et al. v. ..........59Johnson, Timothy E., Bradley A. Steigerwalt, Carole L. Steigerwalt

and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company;Viking Insurance Company v. Ned Spells, ..................................382

Johnston, David W., and Allison Kline; E.B., a minor,E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Boardof School Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, ..............................442

(J)Jones, Constance and Terry Lee Jones v. Robert Levin,Administrator d.b.n.c.t.a. of the Estate of Howard PhillipLevin, also known as Howard Levin............................................151

Jones, Shelby L., a Minor, by her Parent and Natural Guardian,David Jones, v. Gateway School District and Gateway SchoolDistrict Board of School Directors ..............................................277

Joseph, Troy; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................460Joyce, Kevin, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against

Counterproductive Taxation and Charles P. McCullough v.Allegheny County ..........................................................................211

JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep,Inc., et al.; DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny GeneralHospital and Marianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park SchoolDistrict and Nutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak andDonna Haburjak v. ........................................................................363

Julian, Thomas; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................142

Kaczorowski, Ted a/k/a Thaddeus Kaczorowski andMona Kaczorowski a/k/a Mona Singer Kaczorowski;William R. Bishop, Jr. v. ................................................................330

Kaelin, William R.; Caulis Negris, LLC v. ........................................105Kamin, Daniel G., et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board of

Adjustment of the City of Pittsburgh and BoteroDevelopment LLC and City of Pittsburgh ..................................270

Kasprzyk, Sherry; Racquel Underwood, Shauna McInnes andAndrew Dash v. Dana Wind and ................................................241

Kelly, Frances v. MIC General Insurance Corporation,a GMAC Insurance Company ......................................................273

Kenny, George R. and Robin S. and North Eastern Uniforms &Equipment, Inc.; R. Charles and Susan B. Richey, et al. v. ........46


Khara, Manjit, Rattan Deep Singh Virk, and Daljit S. Khara;M. Marlin Metz v. ............................................................................53

Kim, Moon Jong; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................231King, David Pierre; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....................98King, David Pierre; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...................396(C)King, Melissa v. Anthony Aliucci..................................................332(C)Kirik, Beverly P. v. Michael J. Kirik, IV ......................................438(C)Klabnik-Libretto, Diane v. Nicholas Libretto ..............................265Kline, Allison; E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and

E.D.B., in his own right v. Woodland Hills School District,Woodland Hills Board of School Directors, Dr. Walter M.Calinger, David W. Johnston, and ................................................442

Kouknas, Paul individually and t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, WilliamEdward Tooks, and Patricia Fields Tucker, Administratrix of theEstate of John Ricky Tucker, Jr., deceased; Regis InsuranceCompany v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., a Pennsylvaniacorporation, t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, ..................................193

Kramer, Ronald A., Mark W. Ambrose and v.Citizens National Bank of Evans City, Pennsylvania ................483

Krauss, Arthur M.; Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc.,d/b/a NW Rehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania WestAssociation, a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a WestwoodNursing and Rehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc.,formerly known as CareFirst, Inc. and ........................................15

Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.; DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v.Allegheny General Hospital and Marianne Iwankonkiw v.Bethel Park School District and Nutrition, Inc. andGeorge Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v. JSMS Partners LP,JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., ............................................................363

(C)Lambing, Lisle E. v. Mary F. Lambing ........................................264Lampert, Edward S., Aylwin Lewis, William C. Crowley;

David H. Caiarelli, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. andDavid Albertini, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., ........................197

Land Rover North America, Inc.; Mark A. Bartholomaei v. ............45Lange, Larry; Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v.

Micros Systems, Inc., Frontier Business Technologies, Inc.,Micros Fidelio Direct North Central, Inc., Mark Gillie and;Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Leach, Joan, Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First,An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson, EdwinNelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin Square v.Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-Mart StoresEast, L.P. and Michael Crawford, ..............................................267

Leech, Sharon L. v. Zoning Hearing Board of Aspinwall andW. Preston Germain, et ux. and Cassique Properties, L.P.;George R. Rhodes and ..................................................................291

LeGrand, Connie v. The Sports and Exhibition Authority ofPittsburgh and Allegheny County a/k/a City of PittsburghSports and Exhibition Authority and Pittsburgh PiratesBaseball Club, Inc. ........................................................................292

Leizerowski, Abraham v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108Lenart, Deborah Ann, M.D., et al.; Dawn Mapel and Michael

Mapel, individually and as co-administrators of the Estateof Andrea Rose Maple, deceased v. ............................................195

Leo, James J. and Carol E. v. Township of Hampton Council ........269Lettieri, Jr., Nicholas A. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC,

Hines Ward, Korry Pitts and Kimberly Pitts, his wife TheLocker Room Bar and Grille, LLC v. Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr.......1

(J)Levin, Robert, Administrator d.b.n.c.t.a. of the Estate ofHoward Phillip Levin, also known as Howard Levin;Constance Jones and Terry Lee Jones v. ....................................151

Lewis, Aylwin, William C. Crowley; David H. Caiarelli, et al. v.Sears, Roebuck & Co. and David Albertini, et al. v.Sears, Roebuck & Co., Edward S. Lampert, ..............................197

(C)Libretto, Nicholas; Diane Klabnik-Libretto v. ............................265Linder, Robert, and Robert Linder Services, Inc.;

Dale Zegarelli v. Frank Capo, ......................................................328Lipinski, Michael R.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............192Lipscomb, James Anthony; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.

Susan Wygant and............................................................................91Logsdon, Theresa; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................141Long, Barry; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...............................228Lupka, Shawn, Curtis Reese, Richard Haid & Jeffrey Armstrong v.

City of Pittsburgh, et al.; National Rifle Association,................368Lustfield, Carolyn v. John K. Milne and Milne, LLC,

t/d/b/a JKMilne Asset Management............................................247Luterman, Ryan Michael; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......136LVI Environmental Services, Inc.; Allegheny Demolition, Inc. v...416

ManorCare Health Services, Inc., d/b/a ManorCare HealthServices—Monroeville, et al.; Debra Fetterman, asPower of Attorney for Barbara J. Mears v. ................................254

Mansions of North Park Homeowners Association v.Mark McCullough ..........................................................................426

Mapel, Dawn and Michael, individually and as co-administratorsof the Estate of Andrea Rose Maple, deceased v.Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., et al. ................................................195

Marasco, Lori A., Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litemof the Estate of John R. Marasco, Sr. v. Giant Eagle, Inc.,Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs, and/or Rite AidCorporation and Robert Dean, M.D.............................................320

Mariano, Kevin James; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...............99Marshall, Hayden Nathaniel; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...138Marshall Township Zoning Hearing Board;

Township of Marshall v. ..................................................................58Massey, Jayquon; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................439Mastro, Marc A., et al. v. Chartiers Country Club ..........................351Matthews, Rodney a/k/a William Taylor; Commonwealth of

Pennsylvania v. ..............................................................................162Mayer, William George, III; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....119Mayhew, Benjamin; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...................475Mayor and Council of the Municipality of Monroeville, et al.;

John A. Danzilli, Jr. v.......................................................................31McCray, William; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................37McCrommon, Estate of Jerry, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler,

Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard; Penn-America InsuranceCompany v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud,Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody, individually and asAdministratrix of the ....................................................................153

McCullough, Charles P. v. Allegheny County; Kevin Joyce,Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends AgainstCounterproductive Taxation and ................................................211

McCullough, Mark; Mansions of North Park HomeownersAssociation v. ..................................................................................426

(J)McGuinness, Cynthia and Matthew McGuinness, herhusband v. The Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh; PittsburghNeurosurgery Associates, Ltd.; Eric M. Altschuler, M.D.;Arthur H. Palmer, M.D. ................................................................152

McInnes, Shauna, and Andrew Dash v. Dana Wind andSherry Kasprzyk; Racquel Underwood,......................................241

McKaveney, Kimberly S.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......256McLane, Dani Jo and Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities,

Inc./Heritage Valley, d/b/a Sewickley Valley Hospital, et al. ..252McMillan, Michael; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...................409McVeagh, Timothy, and Michael Ressler, Appellants v. City of

Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment v. City of Pittsburgh v.Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor; Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, ..56

McWilliams, Colm; Frank R. Zokaites v.Pittsburgh Irish Pubs, LLC and ....................................................47

McWilliams, T. Colm; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............203


Mears, Barbara J. v. ManorCare Health Services, Inc.,d/b/a ManorCare Health Services—Monroeville, et al.;Debra Fetterman, as Power of Attorney for ..............................254

Mellon Bank, N.A.; Abraham Leizerowski v. ....................................108Mellon Financial Corporation; Harvey Pasternack v.......................101Mendicino, Ross, Annunziato Reilsono and Jessica Reilsono,

Appellants v. Aleppo Township, Appellee ....................................57Mendoza, Anthony; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..................397(J)Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh; Pittsburgh Neurosurgery

Associates, Ltd.; Eric M. Altschuler, M.D.; Arthur H. Palmer,M.D.; Cynthia McGuinness and Matthew McGuinness,her husband v. ................................................................................152

Mester, Anthony, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin Square v.Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-Mart StoresEast, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach, Jennifer Bugarin,and Kamran Farzan; Moon First, An UnincorporatedAssociation by Jesse Nicholson, Edwin Nelson, ........................267

Metz, M. Marlin v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk, andDaljit S. Khara ................................................................................53

MIC General Insurance Corporation, a GMAC InsuranceCompany; Frances Kelly v. ..........................................................273

Micros Systems, Inc., Frontier Business Technologies, Inc.,Micros Fidelio Direct North Central, Inc., Mark Gillie andLarry Lange; Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v.;Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Miles, Maurice a/k/a Robert Turner;Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................................413

Miller, James W. & Hometown Sports, Inc.; Edward Zubik,Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v. ............................245

Milne, John K. and Milne, LLC, t/d/b/a JKMilne AssetManagement; Carolyn Lustfield v. ..............................................247

Mitchell, Bridget; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................474Mollett, Leslie; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................114Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,

Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, andFranklin Square v. Moon Township Board of Supervisorsand Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, JoanLeach, Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan ..........................267

Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and FranklinSquare v. Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-MartStores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach, JenniferBugarin, and Kamran Farzan ......................................................268

Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-Mart Stores East,L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach, Jennifer Bugarin,and Kamran Farzan; Moon First, An UnincorporatedAssociation by Jesse Nicholson, Edwin Nelson,Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin Square v. ........267

Moore, James William; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........218Morewood Point Community Association v.

The Port Authority of Allegheny County, et al. ..........................385Mosby, Jomar Laniel; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............204Mossburger, Christina M. v. Kevin A. Eiler......................................318M.P. v. S.B. ............................................................................................434

Nalls, James Edward; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............306National City Bank; Betco, Inc. v. B. John Gatesman,

Kimberly R. Gatesman, Gatesman Properties, Inc. and ..........454National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese, Richard

Haid and Jeffrey Armstrong v. City of Pittsburgh, et al. ..........368Nauman, Evan, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and Michael

Ressler, Appellants v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board ofAdjustment v. City of Pittsburgh v. Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor..56

NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved Floridacorporation, and Madhuben C. Shah ..........................................431

Negris, Caulis, LLC v. William R. Kaelin ..........................................105Nelson, Edwin, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin

Square v. Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-MartStores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach, JenniferBugarin, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First, An UnincorporatedAssociation by Jesse Nicholson, ..................................................267

Newsome, Tequilla; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.Tequilla Fields a/k/a ....................................................................478

Nicely, David R., d/b/a Nicely Contracting v.Win Development, LLC ................................................................103

Nicholson, Jesse, Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici,and Franklin Square v. Moon Township Board of Supervisorsand Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, JoanLeach, Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First,An Unincorporated Association by ............................................267

NK Mini Mart, Inc.; John G. Yunk v. Joseph B. Tomko, Jr.,Janice M. Tomko, CoGo’s Co., and ............................................295

North Eastern Uniforms & Equipment, Inc.; R. Charles and SusanB. Richey, et al. v. George R. and Robin S. Kenny and ..............46

North Hills School District v. Ross Township Zoning HearingBoard and Ross Township and North Hills School District v.Daniel L. Demarco, Esq., et al. ......................................................71

Nutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al.; DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v.Allegheny General Hospital and Marianne Iwankonkiw v.Bethel Park School District and ..................................................363

NW Rehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania West Association,a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursing andRehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc., formerly known asCareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss; Select MedicalRehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a ..............................................15

Oakland Neurosurgical Associates; Kirk Rettger and Erik Rettger,Co-Executors of the Estate of Michael Rettger, deceased v.UPMC Shadyside; Eugene Bonaroti; and ..................................242

Overlook Green v. Joyce Yablonski and Charles Yablonski;Five Star Quality Care, Inc. d/b/a................................................284

Oxford Development Company and/or Oxford Realty Services, Inc.;Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial RealEstate, Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/a ..............................................391

(J)Oxford Development Corp., t/d/b/a Oxford Realty Management;Elizabeth Sexton and Thomas J. Sexton, her husband v.J.C. Schultz Interiors, Inc., t/d/b/a J.C. Schultz Co. and..........151

(J)Palmer, Arthur H., M.D.; Cynthia McGuinness andMatthew McGuinness, her husband v. The Mercy Hospitalof Pittsburgh; Pittsburgh Neurosurgery Associates, Ltd.;Eric M. Altschuler, M.D.; ..............................................................152

Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and Chrissanne Hennicke v.Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. and Pa. National MutualCasualty Insurance Co. et al...........................................................19

Paradise Pools and Spas; Frank Cuda v...............................................79Parker, Jerome; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................308Pasternack, Harvey v. Mellon Financial Corporation......................101Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation,

t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, Paul Kouknas, individually andt/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, William Edward Tooks, andPatricia Fields Tucker, Administratrix of the Estate of JohnRicky Tucker, Jr., deceased; Regis Insurance Company v. ......193

Payne, Charles Phillip a/k/a Christopher Payne;Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................................310

Pelly, Joan M., et al. v. The Pittsburgh Harlequins RugbyFootball Association, et al. ............................................................418


Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud,Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody,individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of JerryMcCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell,and Asa Howard ............................................................................153

Pennsylvania Capital Bank v. James R. Apple; The HuntingtonNational Bank, Successor by Merger to Sky Bank, Successorby Merger to ..................................................................................202

Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate, Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/aOxford Development Company and/or Oxford Realty Services,Inc.; Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.Pittsburgh Opera and ....................................................................391

Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Co. et al.;Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and ChrissanneHennicke v. Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. and ..........................19

Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Company v.James Dean Guardino d/b/a James Dean Autoworks,Audrey J. D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye, and AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford, Connecticut AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford v. James Guardino, et al. ........49

Pennsylvania West Association, a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc.,d/b/a Westwood Nursing and Rehabilitation Center; PrimusCare, Inc., formerly known as CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M.Krauss; Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc.,d/b/a NW Rehabilitation Associates v. ..........................................15

Peters, Kenneth Bradley; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........40Petroleum Development Corporation, et al.; Doris E. Grafton,

Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G. Grafton, deceased,and Doris E. Grafton, in her own right, et al., v. ......................300

(C)Pietrone, Sharon Ruth v. Gregory Paul Pietrone ........................150Pitts, Korry and Kimberly Pitts, his wife The Locker Room Bar and

Grille, LLC v. Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr.; Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr.v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC, Hines Ward,................1

Pittsburgh Harlequins Rugby Football Association, et al.;Joan M. Pelly, et al. v. The ............................................................418

Pittsburgh Irish Pubs, LLC and Colm McWilliams;Frank R. Zokaites v. ........................................................................47

(J)Pittsburgh Neurosurgery Associates, Ltd.; Eric M. Altschuler,M.D.; Arthur H. Palmer, M.D.; Cynthia McGuinness andMatthew McGuinness, her husband v. The Mercy Hospitalof Pittsburgh;..................................................................................152

Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate, Inc.and GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Company and/orOxford Realty Services, Inc.; Sanford L. Pollock d/b/aSanford L. Pollock Real Estate v. ................................................391

Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball Club, Inc.; Connie LeGrand v.Sports and Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh andAllegheny County a/k/a City of Pittsburgh Sports andExhibition Authority and ..............................................................292

Pittsburgh Terminal Properties t/d/b/aRiverwalk Corporate Center; Frank Bryan Inc. v. ....................463

Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority v.Richard W. Gladstone, II and Diana L. Hunkele........................298

Pituch, Daniel W., D.M.D., M.D.; Annette F. Drotar andJoseph Drotar, her husband v. ....................................................242

Plato, Reginald and Vermell v. City of Pittsburgh ..........................450PNC Bank, N.A.; Kenneth F. Emmett v.

Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential Securities, Inc.,Louis Dworsky, John Bowman, and ..............................................72

Pollock, Sanford L. d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate,Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Companyand/or Oxford Realty Services, Inc. ............................................391

Port Authority of Allegheny County v.Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85 ........................................387

Port Authority of Allegheny County, et al.; Morewood PointCommunity Association v. ............................................................385

Pre-Owned Auto Center of Indiana, PA, Inc.; Steven Boganand Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v. ....................324

Primus Care, Inc., formerly known as CareFirst, Inc. andArthur M. Krauss; Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc.,d/b/a NW Rehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania WestAssociation, a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/aWestwood Nursing and Rehabilitation Center; ............................15

Proctor, Bruce; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................288Prudential Securities, Inc., Louis Dworsky, John Bowman, & PNC

Bank, N.A.; Kenneth Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, ......72

Redevelopment Authority of Allegheny County of certain land inthe Borough of Homestead, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania,being Property of DeBolt Unlimited Travel ServicesIncorporated, successor by merger to DeBolt Realty Co.,Inc., et al.; In the Matter of the Condemnation by the ..............428

Reese, Curtis, Richard Haid and Jeffrey Armstrong v. City ofPittsburgh, et al.; National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, ..368

Regis Insurance Company v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., aPennsylvania corporation, t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, PaulKouknas, individually and t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, WilliamEdward Tooks, and Patricia Fields Tucker, Administratrixof the Estate of John Ricky Tucker, Jr., deceased ....................193

(C)Reilly, John R.; Marie Bouzos-Reilly v.........................................438Reilsono, Annunziato and Jessica, Appellants v.

Aleppo Township, Appellee; Ross Mendicino, ............................57Ressler, Michael, Appellants v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of

Adjustment v. City of Pittsburgh v. Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor;Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and..........56

Restieri, Ronald, Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.................423Rettger, Kirk and Erik, Co-Executors of the Estate of Michael

Rettger, deceased v. UPMC Shadyside; Eugene Bonaroti;and Oakland Neurosurgical Associates ......................................242

Rhodes, George R. and Sharon L. Leech v. Zoning HearingBoard of Aspinwall and W. Preston Germain, et ux. andCassique Properties, L.P. ..............................................................291

Richardson, John K.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............227Richey, R. Charles and Susan B. et al. v. George R. and Robin S.

Kenny and North Eastern Uniforms & Equipment, Inc. ............46Ricks, Bobby; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.............................461Ring, Sonya v. Bruce Goldblatt ..........................................................133Rite Aid Corporation and Robert Dean, M.D.; Lori A. Marasco,

Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litem of the Estate ofJohn R. Marasco, Sr. v. Giant Eagle, Inc., Eckerd Corporationd/b/a Eckerd Drugs, and/or..........................................................320

Rivera, Tito; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................303Riverwalk Corporate Center; Frank Bryan Inc. v.

Pittsburgh Terminal Properties t/d/b/a ......................................463Rodgers, Patricia Ann; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............358(C)Rodkey, Joann C. v. Joseph F. Rodkey, Jr.....................................210Ross, Daniel F. v. Foremost Insurance Company and

Sentry Services Insurance Company, Inc. ..................................338Ross Township Zoning Hearing Board and Ross Township and

North Hills School District v. Daniel L. Demarco, Esq., et al.;North Hills School District v. ........................................................71

Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc., Mark Gillie and Larry Lange:Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

S.B.; M.P. v. ..........................................................................................434Schomaker, Richard W. v. Zoning Hearing Board of the

Borough of Franklin Park and Borough of Franklin Parkand Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P., d/b/a T-Mobile ....................453


Sears, Roebuck & Co. and David Albertini, et al. v.Sears, Roebuck & Co., Edward S. Lampert, Aylwin Lewis,William C. Crowley; David H. Caiarelli, et al. v.........................197

Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NWRehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania West Association,a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursing andRehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc., formerly knownas CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss ......................................15

Selective Software, Inc. v. Steve and Dona Worthington, et al. ........51Selepec, Daniel J., et al. v. Johnson and Johnson, Inc., et al. ..........59Sentry Services Insurance Company, Inc.; Daniel F. Ross v.

Foremost Insurance Company and ............................................338Seubert & Associates, Inc.; Zavala, Inc. v.

Five-R Excavating, Inc. and Western Surety Company v. ........107Sewickley Valley Hospital, et al.; Dani Jo McLane and

Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities, Inc./Heritage Valley, d/b/a....................................................................252

(J)Sexton, Elizabeth and Thomas J. Sexton, her husband v. J.C.Schultz Interiors, Inc., t/d/b/a J.C. Schultz Co. and OxfordDevelopment Corp., t/d/b/a Oxford Realty Management ........151

Shaffer, DeLana Lunsford v. Allegheny General Hospital andMarianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park School District andNutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., KrebsChrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al...............................................................363

Shah, Madhuben C.; NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc.a dissolved Florida corporation, and ..........................................431

Shannon, Richard P.; Barbara A. Clark v. ........................................320Shaw, Ethel B. v. St. Barnabas Nursing Home, Inc., et al.;

Marilyn Conley, Executrix of the Estate of ................................282Shawmut Woodworking, et al.; John Antonucci and

Judith A. Antonucci v. ..................................................................394Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,

Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie;Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc., Mark Gillie and Larry Lange ....................498

Silliman, Deceased; In Re: Estate of Carol D. ................................333Simpson-Tuttle, Corey Lea and Alan L. Tuttle v.

Universal Forest Products Eastern Division, Inc. ....................167Sky Bank, Successor by Merger to Pennsylvania Capital Bank v.

James R. Apple; The Huntington National Bank, Successorby Merger to ..................................................................................202

Slater, James Robert; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............208Smith, Anthony Tusweet; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........62Smith, Lynda v. Con-Way, Inc., and jointly, severally or separately,

Consolidated Freightways Corporation of Delaware ................200Smith, Robert and Robert Smith d/b/a Rob Smith Construction and

State Farm Insurance Company; Mark and Susan Wutz v. ......446(J)Smith, Sandra; Teena M. Allie v. ..................................................151Smith, Steve v. Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh ..........459Speer, Doreen v. David Speer ............................................................322Spells, Ned, Timothy E. Johnson, Bradley A. Steigerwalt,

Carole L. Steigerwalt and State Farm Mutual AutomobileInsurance Company; Viking Insurance Company v. ..................382

Sports and Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh and Allegheny Countya/k/a City of Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition Authority andPittsburgh Pirates Baseball Club, Inc.; Connie LeGrand v.......292

Sports Rock Café, Inc.; Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v. ..................................................................178

St. Barnabas Nursing Home, Inc., et al.; Marilyn Conley,Executrix of the Estate of Ethel B. Shaw v.................................282

State Farm Insurance Company; Mark & Susan Wutz v. RobertSmith and Robert Smith d/b/a Rob Smith Construction ..........446

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; VikingInsurance Company v. Ned Spells, Timothy E. Johnson,Bradley A. Steigerwalt, Carole L. Steigerwalt and ....................382

State Farm Mutual Insurance Co.; Kim A. Bodnar v. ........................78Steigerwalt, Bradley A., Carole L. Steigerwalt and State Farm

Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; Viking InsuranceCompany v. Ned Spells, Timothy E. Johnson, ............................382

Stuhr, Douglas; Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.Martin Drabek and ........................................................................343

Sumpter, Whitney; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....................149(C)Swartzfager Tessaro, Stacey A. v. Thomas R. Tessaro ..............265

Taylor, William a/k/a; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.Rodney Matthews ..........................................................................162

(C) Tessaro, Thomas R.; Stacey A. Swartzfager Tessaro v. ............265Thaner, Sister Mary D. a/k/a Sister Mary D. Thawer;

William C. Garrow v. ....................................................................297Thawer, a/k/a Sister Mary D.; William C. Garrow v.

Sister Mary D. Thaner, ................................................................297The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC, Hines Ward, Korry and

Kimberly Pitts, his wife, The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLCv. Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr.; Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr. v.....................1

Thompson, Joshua Richard; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..124Thornton, Jesse William; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........138Thurmon, Brian Travell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........263T-Mobile; Richard W. Schomaker v. Zoning Hearing Board of

the Borough of Franklin Park and Borough of Franklin Parkand Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P., d/b/a......................................453

Todd, Jeffrey; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................65Tolliver, Darnell A., Beatrice Woody, individually and as

Administratrix of the Estate of Jerry McCrommon, III,deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard;Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc.,Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud, ..............................................153

Tomko, Joseph B., Jr., Janice M. Tomko, CoGo’s Co., andNK Mini Mart, Inc.; John G. Yunk v. ..........................................295

Tooks, William Edward and Patricia Fields Tucker, Administratrixof the Estate of John Ricky Tucker, Jr., deceased; RegisInsurance Company v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., aPennsylvania corporation, t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon,Paul Kouknas, individually and t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, ..193

Township of Hampton Council; James J. and Carol E. Leo v. ......269Township of Marshall v. Marshall Township

Zoning Hearing Board ....................................................................58Township of West Deer; Stephen and Fiona Blazczak v. ................504Trice, David; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................421Troxler, Earl C., Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard; Penn-America

Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud, MarianE.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody, individually andas Administratrix of the Estate of Jerry McCrommon, III,deceased, ........................................................................................153

Tucker, Patricia Fields, Administratrix of the Estate of John RickyTucker, Jr., deceased; Regis Insurance Company v. PaulKouknas Enterprises, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation, t/d/b/aHappy Days Saloon, Paul Kouknas, individually and t/d/b/aHappy Days Saloon, William Edward Tooks, and......................193

Turner, Eric; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ............................160Turner, Robert; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.

Maurice Miles a/k/a ......................................................................413Tuttle, Alan L. and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.

Universal Forest Products Eastern Division, Inc. ....................167

Underwood, Racquel, Shauna McInnes and Andrew Dash v.Dana Wind and Sherry Kasprzyk ................................................241

Universal Forest Products Eastern Division, Inc.;Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v. ........................167

UPMC Shadyside; Eugene Bonaroti; and Oakland NeurosurgicalAssociates; Kirk Rettger and Erik Rettger, Co-Executorsof the Estate of Michael Rettger, deceased v. ............................242


Valley Medical Facilities, Inc./Heritage Valley, d/b/aSewickley Valley Hospital, et al.; Dani Jo McLane andCraig McLane v. ............................................................................252

Van Arsdale, Joni v. Waldron Electric Heating, LLC ......................323Viking Insurance Company v. Ned Spells, Timothy E. Johnson,

Bradley A. Steigerwalt, Carole L. Steigerwalt and State FarmMutual Automobile Insurance Company ....................................382

Virk, Rattan Deep Singh, and Daljit S. Khara; M. Marlin Metz v.Manjit Khara, ..................................................................................53

Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P., d/b/a T-Mobile; Richard W.Schomaker v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough ofFranklin Park and Borough of Franklin Park and ....................453

Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved Florida corporation, andMadhuben C. Shah; NC Venture I, L.P. v.....................................431

Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential Securities, Inc.,Louis Dworsky, John Bowman, and PNC Bank, N.A.;Kenneth F. Emmett v. ....................................................................72

Waldron Electric Heating, LLC; Joni Van Arsdale v. ......................323Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach,

Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan; Moon First, AnUnincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson, EdwinNelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and Franklin Square v.Moon Township Board of Supervisors and ................................267

Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.Sports Rock Café, Inc. ..................................................................178

(C)Waltz, Laurie Ann; Andrew F. Andros v. ......................................322Ward, Hines, Korry Pitts and Kimberly Pitts, his wife The Locker

Room Bar and Grille, LLC v. Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr.; NicholasA. Lettieri, Jr. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC, ............1

Washington, Jerome; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............480Webb, Michael Ryan Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v...........188Weinberg, Jeffrey; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.....................235Wells Fargo Bank, NA as Trustee v. George Janosik and

Lynn Janosik ..................................................................................293West Penn Allegheny Health System v. Joseph J. Colella, M.D.;

Allegheny Specialty Practice Network and The ........................370Western Surety Company v. Seubert & Associates, Inc.;

Zavala, Inc. v. Five-R Excavating, Inc. and ................................107Westwood Nursing and Rehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc.,

formerly known as CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss; SelectMedical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NW RehabilitationAssociates v. Pennsylvania West Association, a/k/a Penn WestAssociates, Inc., d/b/a ....................................................................15

White, William D. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania ....................178Wilcox, Larry Bruce; Bureaus Investment Group #10, LLC v. ....296Williams, Delmingo; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ................360Willis Shaw Express, Inc.; Graciela Garcia v.

Angel C. Garcia and ......................................................................37Wilner, Russell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................38Win Development, LLC; David R. Nicely,

d/b/a Nicely Contracting v. ..........................................................103Wind, Dana, and Sherry Kasprzyk; Racquel Underwood,

Shauna McInnes and Andrew Dash v. ........................................241Witherspoon, Yarudin A.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........233Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board of School

Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W. Johnston, andAllison Kline; E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B.,in his own right v. ..........................................................................442

Woody, Beatrice, individually and as Administratrix of theEstate of Jerry McCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler,Lamar Ezell, and Asa Howard; Penn-America InsuranceCompany v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud, Marian E.S. Aboud,Darnell A. Tolliver, ........................................................................153

Woolhandler, Robert A. v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board ofAdjustment and City of Pittsburgh ..............................................272

Worthington, Steve and Dona, et al.; Selective Software, Inc. v. ....51

Wutz, Mark & Susan v. Robert Smith and Robert Smith d/b/a RobSmith Construction and State Farm Insurance Company ........446

Wygant, Susan and James Anthony Lipscomb;Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ................................................91

Yablonski, Joyce and Charles; Five Star Quality Care, Inc.d/b/a Overlook Green v. ................................................................284

Yunk, John G. v. Joseph B. Tomko, Jr., Janice M. Tomko,CoGo’s Co., and NK Mini Mart, Inc. ............................................295

Zangrilli, Daniel J. and Dorothy M. Zangrilli, Appellants v.Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Dormont and theBorough of Dormont........................................................................55

Zavala, Inc. v. Five-R Excavating, Inc. and Western SuretyCompany v. Seubert & Associates, Inc. ......................................107

Zavatchen, Michael F., Jr.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......237Zegarelli, Dale v. Frank Capo, Robert Linder, and

Robert Linder Services, Inc. ........................................................328Zokaites, Frank R. v. Pittsburgh Irish Pubs, LLC and

Colm McWilliams ............................................................................47Zoning Board of Adjustment v. City of Pittsburgh v. Phillip Coblitz,

Intervenor; Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh,and Michael Ressler, Appellants v. City of Pittsburgh ................56

Zoning Board of Adjustment of the City of Pittsburgh and BoteroDevelopment LLC and City of Pittsburgh; Daniel G. Kamin,et al., Appellants v. ......................................................................270

Zoning Hearing Board of Aspinwall and W. Preston Germain, et ux.and Cassique Properties, L.P.; George R. Rhodes andSharon L. Leech v. ........................................................................291

Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Dormont and theBorough of Dormont; Daniel J. Zangrilli and Dorothy M.Zangrilli, Appellants v. ....................................................................55

Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Franklin Park andBorough of Franklin Park and Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P.,d/b/a T-Mobile; Richard W. Schomaker v. ..................................453

Zoning Hearing Board; Township of Marshall v.Marshall Township ........................................................................58

Zubik, Edward, Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v.James W. Miller & Hometown Sports, Inc. ................................245

VOLUME 157 - page 13 2009Supplement to The Lawyers Journal

12 Pa. C.S.A. §5101 et seq.—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

13 Pa.C.S. §§3302, 3502 and 3601—Abraham Leizerowski v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108

18 Pa.C.S. Section 90—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

18 Pa.C.S. Section 2702(a)(1)—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

18 Pa.C.S.A. §110—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Nancy Hammer ........................354

26 U.S.C.S. §6323—In the Matter of the Condemnation by the Redevelopment

Authority of Allegheny County of certain land in theBorough of Homestead, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania,being Property of DeBolt Unlimited Travel ServicesIncorporated, successor by merger toDeBolt Realty Co., Inc., et al. ......................................................428

42 Pa. C.S. §2503—Dale Zegarelli v. Frank Capo, Robert Linder, and

Robert Linder Services, Inc. ........................................................328

42 Pa.C.S.A. Section 4306—NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved

Florida corporation, and Madhuben C. Shah..............................431

42 Pa. C.S.A. Section 5524(7)—Harvey Pasternack v. Mellon Financial Corporation ......................101

42 Pa.C.S. §8371—Mark & Susan Wutz v. Robert Smith & Robert Smith d/b/a

Rob Smith Construction & State Farm Insurance Company ....446

53 P.S. §§1946-1949—Frank Bryan Inc. v. Pittsburgh Terminal Properties

t/d/b/a Riverwalk Corporate Center............................................463

75 Pa.C.S. §3802—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40

61 P.S. §81 Petition—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Albert

a/k/a James Holland......................................................................181

911 Tape—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Fuller................................127

Abuse of Discretion—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden......................425

Accelerated Rent—Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.

Sports Rock Café, Inc. ..................................................................178

Access Ramp Variance—Daniel G. Kamin, et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board of


Accessory Garage—Daniel J. Zangrilli and Dorothy M. Zangrilli, Appellants v.

Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Dormont and theBorough of Dormont........................................................................55

Accomplice Liability—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Parker..........................308Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Phillip Payne

a/k/a Christopher Payne ..............................................................310

Act 44 of 2007—Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against


Adequate Consideration—Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. Brian D. Errigo ..........................11

Administrator’s Fees—In Re: Estate of Carol D. Silliman, Deceased ..................................333

Admissions in Pleadings—Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.


Adverse Possession—Frank Bryan Inc. v. Pittsburgh Terminal Properties


After-Discovered Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Carl Collins ..............................407Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Troy Joseph ..............................460

Aggravated Assault—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

Alimony—(C)Lisle E. Lambing v. Mary F. Lambing ..........................................264(C)Diane Klabnik-Libretto v. Nicholas Libretto ..............................265

Ambiguity in Written Agreement—Gill Hall Land Co. v. AJNP Development, LLC..................................74

C U M U L AT I V E I N D E X - V O L U M E 1 5 7 - 2 0 0 9This listing is provided according to Subject Matter for research purposes.Under this title is printed a list of all cases reported in the Pittsburgh Legal Journal,a Supplement to the Lawyers Journal (Volume No. 157 - 2009). Subscribers can findin this index immediate reference to any case reported in the PITTSBURGH LEGALJOURNAL. For identification purposes: (C)Capsule Summaries; and (J)Jury Verdicts.

VOLUME 157 - page 14 2009Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal

Amendment of Caption—Connie LeGrand v. The Sports and Exhibition Authority of

Pittsburgh and Allegheny County a/k/aCity of Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition Authorityand Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball Club, Inc. ................................292

Amendment of Civil Complaint—DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospital and

Marianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park School District andNutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., KrebsChrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al...............................................................363

Amendment to Subdivision Plan—Ross Mendicino, Annunziato Reilsono and Jessica Reilsono,

Appellants v. Aleppo Township, Appellee ....................................57

Appeal—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480

Appeal from Judgment of Sentence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Moon Jong Kim ........................231

Appeal from Suppression Hearing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Yarudin A. Witherspoon ..........233

Appellate Procedure—Racquel Underwood, Shauna McInnes and Andrew Dash v.

Dana Wind and Sherry Kasprzyk ................................................241

Application for a Use Variance—Robert A. Woolhandler v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of

Adjustment and City of Pittsburgh ..............................................272

Arbitration—Carolyn Lustfield v. John K. Milne and Milne, LLC,

t/d/b/a JKMilne Asset Management............................................247Debra Fetterman, as Power of Attorney for Barbara J. Mears v.


Port Authority of Allegheny County v.Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85 ........................................387

Arbitration Award—Allegheny Demolition, Inc. v. LVI Environmental Services, Inc. ..416

Assault and Battery Exclusion—Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud,

Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody,individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of JerryMcCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell,and Asa Howard ............................................................................153

Attendance at Trial—Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. Anthony Crane

Rental, Inc., et al. v. Gustine Uniontown, Inc., et al. ................492

Attorney-Client Privilege—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444

Attorneys’ Fees—(C)Joann C. Rodkey v. Joseph F. Rodkey, Jr. ....................................210Dale Zegarelli v. Frank Capo, Robert Linder, and

Robert Linder Services, Inc. ........................................................328William R. Bishop, Jr. v. Ted Kaczorowski a/k/a

Thaddeus Kaczorowski and Mona Kaczorowski a/k/aMona Singer Kaczorowski ............................................................330

Auto Repairs—Daniel J. Zangrilli and Dorothy M. Zangrilli, Appellants v.

Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Dormontand the Borough of Dormont..........................................................55

Automobile Accident—Graciela Garcia v. Angel C. Garcia and

Willis Shaw Express, Inc. ..............................................................37

Award of Attorneys Fees—Betco, Inc. v. B. John Gatesman, Kimberly R. Gatesman,

Gatesman Properties, Inc. and National City Bank ..................454

Bad Faith—Mark & Susan Wutz v. Robert Smith & Robert Smith d/b/a Rob

Smith Construction & State Farm Insurance Company ............446

“Bait and Switch”—Steven Bogan and Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v.

Pre-Owned Auto Center of Indiana, PA, Inc. ............................324

Beneficiary Class—In Re: Estate of Ruth Alexander a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ......110

Bid Sheet Unsigned by Parties—Frank Cuda v. Paradise Pools and Spas ..............................................79

Bond—Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC,


Bond Forfeiture—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marlynn Bryant........................321

Borrowed Servant—John Antonucci and Judith A. Antonucci v.

Shawmut Woodworking, et al. ......................................................394

Brady Rule—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Brian Travell Thurmon ..........263

Brady Violation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Morris Anthony ..........206

Breach of Contract—Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,

Inc.; Fisher Scientific Operating Company; and FisherHamilton, L.L.C. v. AIU Insurance Company; et al. ......................4

Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and ChrissanneHennicke v. Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. and Pa.National Mutual Casualty Insurance Co. et al. ............................19

R. Charles and Susan B. Richey, et al. v. George R. and RobinS. Kenny and North Eastern Uniforms & Equipment, Inc. ........46

Selective Software, Inc. v. Steve and Dona Worthington, et al. ........51M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,

and Daljit S. Khara ..........................................................................53David R. Nicely, d/b/a Nicely Contracting v.

Win Development, LLC ................................................................103

Breach of Fiduciary Duty—Harvey Pasternack v. Mellon Financial Corporation ......................101

Brief Stop and Handcuffing Does Not Constitute Arrest—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ivan Milton Hale ......................286


Burden of Proof—(C)Stacey A. Swartzfager Tessaro v. Thomas R. Tessaro................265

Car Rental Tax—Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against


Change of Township Boundary Lines—In re: Petition to Change Boundary Lines of Lot

and Block No. 1572-N-192 ............................................................507

Child Support—Sonya Ring v. Bruce Goldblatt ..........................................................133(C)Janice Huwe v. Joseph Huwe, Bubash, J.....................................210(C)Joann C. Rodkey v. Joseph F. Rodkey, Jr. ....................................210Doreen Speer v. David Speer..............................................................322

Child Support Overpayment—(C)Beverly P. Kirik v. Michael J. Kirik, IV ......................................438

City of Pittsburgh Ordinance No. 2008-0831—National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese, Richard

Haid and Jeffrey Armstrong v. City of Pittsburgh, et al. ..........368

Civil Service—In re: Appeal of Steven Hennigan......................................................331

Class Action Certification—Mark A. Bartholomaei v. Land Rover North America, Inc. ..............45

Common Law Negligence—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential

Securities, Inc., Louis Dworsky, John Bowman, andPNC Bank, N.A.................................................................................72

Concise Statement of Matters Raised on Appeal—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Matthew Farmer ......................190Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David R. Baldwin ....................476

Condemnation—Reginald and Vermell Plato v. City of Pittsburgh ............................450

Conditional Use Application—Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,

Edwin Nelson, Anthony Mester, Joseph Dentici, and FranklinSquare v. Moon Township Board of Supervisors and Wal-MartStores East, L.P. and Michael Crawford, Joan Leach,Jennifer Bugarin, and Kamran Farzan ......................................268

James J. and Carol E. Leo v. Township of Hampton Council ........269HHI Trucking Supply, Inc. v. The Borough Council of the

Borough of Oakmont......................................................................279

Confessed Judgments—Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.


Conflict of Interest—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Ricks..............................461

Conflict of Laws—Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.


Conflicting Superior Court and Commonwealth Court Opinions—John Antonucci and Judith A. Antonucci v.


Connor Objections—Lori A. Marasco, Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litem

of the Estate of John R. Marasco, Sr. v. Giant Eagle, Inc.,Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs, and/or Rite AidCorporation and Robert Dean, M.D.............................................320

Consciousness of Guilt—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Parker..........................308

Consideration of Extrinsic Evidence—Gill Hall Land Co. v. AJNP Development, LLC..................................74

Consideration of Presence of Defendant’s Children During Attack—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

Consideration of Restitution in Sentencing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Theresa Logsdon ......................141

Constitutionality of 71 P.S. 1690.112a (Act 53)—In the Interest of F.C., III, a minor ....................................................439

Constructive Knowledge—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential


Constructive Possession of a Firearm—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Flipping Bey................81

Consumer Protection Law—Kim A. Bodnar v. State Farm Mutual Insurance Co. ........................78Joni Van Arsdale v. Waldron Electric Heating, LLC........................323Steven Bogan and Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v.


Contempt—Christina M. Mossburger v. Kevin A. Eiler ......................................318(C)Melissa King v. Anthony Aliucci ..................................................332(C)Pamela M. Carson v. Sidney Carson ............................................438

Contempt of Legal Custody—(C)Stacey A. Swartzfager Tessaro v. Thomas R. Tessaro................265

Continuation of Insurance Policy—Frances Kelly v. MIC General Insurance Corporation,

a GMAC Insurance Company ......................................................273

Contracts—Betco, Inc. v. B. John Gatesman, Kimberly R. Gatesman,

Gatesman Properties, Inc. and National City Bank ..................454

Contracts of Adhesion—Debra Fetterman, as Power of Attorney for Barbara J. Mears v.


Contract to Install Swimming Pool Liner—Frank Cuda v. Paradise Pools and Spas ..............................................79

Contracting with Former Employees of a Party—Selective Software, Inc. v. Steve and Dona Worthington, et al. ........51

Contractual Relationship—M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,

and Daljit S. Khara ..........................................................................53


Coordinate Jurisdiction—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bruce Proctor ..........................288Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,

Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc., Mark Gillie and Larry Lange;Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Corpus Delicti Rule—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael McMillan....................409

Costs and Attorney’s Fees—Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NW

Rehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania West Association,a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursingand Rehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc., formerlyknown as CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss..........................15

Counsel Fees—Mark W. Ambrose and Ronald A. Kramer v.

Citizens National Bank of Evans City, Pennsylvania ................483

Counsel’s Obligation in Post-Sentence Motions or Appeal—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cecil Earl Grow..........................67

County Jail—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rodney Matthews a/k/a

William Taylor................................................................................162

Court Interference with Defendant’s Case-in-Chief—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Morris Haley ............................494

Credibility of Eyewitness—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Carl Collins ..............................407

Credit for Time Served—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Todd ..............................65Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187

Criminal Attempt—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Omar J. Bakth ..........................182

Criminal Attempt Homicide—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

Criminal Conspiracy—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Ryan Webb, Jr. ..........188

Criminal Law—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kimberly S. McKaveney ........256Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Cobbs............................258Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Pierce Greene ..........................262(C)In Re: In the Interest of D.S., a minor Appeal of D.S. ..............452

Criminal Record—Steve Smith v. Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh ..........459

Cross-Examination—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cordell Broadus ......................147Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480

Custody—(C)Stacey A. Swartzfager Tessaro v. Thomas R. Tessaro................265Christina M. Mossburger v. Kevin A. Eiler ......................................318M.P. v. S.B. ............................................................................................434(C)Marie Bouzos-Reilly v. John R. Reilly ........................................438

Damages—Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NW


David R. Nicely, d/b/a Nicely Contracting v.Win Development, LLC ................................................................103

William R. Bishop, Jr. v. Ted Kaczorowski a/k/aThaddeus Kaczorowski and Mona Kaczorowski a/k/aMona Singer Kaczorowski ............................................................330

Dead Man’s Act—Edward Zubik, Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v.

James W. Miller & Hometown Sports, Inc. ................................245

Death of Plaintiff Prior to Deposition—John G. Yunk v. Joseph B. Tomko, Jr., Janice M. Tomko,

CoGo’s Co., and NK Mini Mart, Inc. ............................................295

Death of Policyholder—Frances Kelly v. MIC General Insurance Corporation,


Death Penalty—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23

Death Qualification of a Jury—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Timothy Boczkowski..................84

Declaratory Judgment Actions—Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Company v.

James Dean Guardino d/b/a James Dean Autoworks,Audrey J. D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye, and AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford, Connecticut AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford v. James Guardino, et al. ........49

Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud,Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody,individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of JerryMcCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell,and Asa Howard ............................................................................153

Declaratory Relief—Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,


Deemed Approval—North Hills School District v. Ross Township Zoning Hearing

Board and Ross Township and North Hills School District v.Daniel L. Demarco, Esq., et al. ......................................................71

Default Judgment—Bureaus Investment Group #10, LLC v. Larry Bruce Wilcox ........296

Defect on Record—Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.


Defective Design—Daniel J. Selepec, et al. v. Johnson and Johnson, Inc., et al. ............59

Defendant Mentally Ill at Time of Incident—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

Defendant’s Decision to Testify—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Timothy Boczkowski..................84


Definition of “Presence”—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89

Demolition and Reconstruction—Daniel G. Kamin, et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board of


Demurrer—Lynda R. Smith v. Con-Way, Inc., and jointly, severally or separately,

Consolidated Freightways Corporation of Delaware ................200

Denial of Application—In re: Appeal of Steven Hennigan......................................................331

Denial of Due Process—In the Interest of F.C., III, a minor ....................................................439

Denial of Evidentiary Hearing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Albert


Denial of PCRA Petition Without Evidentiary Hearing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cordell Broadus ......................147

Denial of Public Housing Application—Steve Smith v. Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh ..........459

Density Variance—Daniel G. Kamin, et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board of


Dependency Adjudication—In re M.M., a minor ..............................................................................32

Determination of Arbitrability—Carolyn Lustfield v. John K. Milne and Milne, LLC,

t/d/b/a JKMilne Asset Management............................................247

Dimensional Variance—George R. Rhodes and Sharon L. Leech v.

Zoning Hearing Board of Aspinwall and W. PrestonGermain, et ux. and Cassique Properties, L.P. ..........................291

Richard W. Schomaker v. Zoning Hearing Board of theBorough of Franklin Park and Borough of Franklin Parkand Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P., d/b/a T-Mobile ....................453

Disclaimer of Responsibility—Frank Cuda v. Paradise Pools and Spas ..............................................79

Discovery—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444American Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers,

Inc., Industry Terminal & Salvage Co. and InternationalMarine Underwriters/One Beacon ..............................................447

Discovery Rule—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential


Barbara A. Clark v. Richard P. Shannon ..........................................320

Discovery Sanctions—(C)Sharon Ruth Pietrone v. Gregory Paul Pietrone ........................150

Dismissal of Charges—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Weinberg......................235

Disobedience—E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.

Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board ofSchool Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W. Johnston,and Allison Kline ..........................................................................442

Disorderly Conduct—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Weinberg......................235Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Cobbs............................258

Diversion of Company Assets—Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC,


Doctrine of Implied Duty of Good Faith and Fair Dealing—(C)Andrew F. Andros v. Laurie Ann Waltz ........................................322

Double Jeopardy—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Pierre King....................396

Drink Tax—Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against


Driving Under the Influence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kevin James Mariano................99

Drug Possession—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Parker..........................308

Dual Representation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Ricks..............................461

Due Process for Pro Se Litigant—In Re: Estate of Carol D. Silliman, Deceased ..................................333

Duration and Scope—Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. Brian D. Errigo ..........................11

Duty of Care—Doris E. Grafton, Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G.

Grafton, deceased, and Doris E. Grafton, in her own right,et al., v. Petroleum Development Corporation, et al. ................300

Duty of Gas Supplier to Maintain Utilities—Doris E. Grafton, Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G.


Duty to Defend and Indemnify—Regis Insurance Company v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., a

Pennsylvania corporation, t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, PaulKouknas, individually and t/d/b/a Happy Days Saloon, WilliamEdward Tooks, and Patricia Fields Tucker, Administratrixof the Estate of John Ricky Tucker, Jr., deceased ....................193

Duty to Support a Parent—Five Star Quality Care, Inc. d/b/a Overlook Green v.

Joyce Yablonski and Charles Yablonski ......................................284

Easement—Frank Bryan Inc. v. Pittsburgh Terminal Properties t/d/b/a

Riverwalk Corporate Center ........................................................463


Effect of Discharge—Abraham Leizerowski v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108

Electronic Home Monitoring—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187

Employee Handbook—Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.

Martin Drabek and Douglas Stuhr ..............................................343

Employment—Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. Brian D. Errigo ..........................11

Employment Agreement—Allegheny Specialty Practice Network and The West Penn

Allegheny Health System v. Joseph J. Colella, M.D. ................370

Enforceability of Arbitration Agreement—Marilyn Conley, Executrix of the Estate of Ethel B. Shaw v.

St. Barnabas Nursing Home, Inc., et al.......................................282

Enforcement—(C)Andrew F. Andros v. Laurie Ann Waltz ........................................322

Enforcement Notice—Daniel J. Zangrilli and Dorothy M. Zangrilli, Appellants v.

Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Dormont and theBorough of Dormont........................................................................55

Enforcement of Settlement Agreement—Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and Chrissanne Hennicke v.

Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. and Pa. National MutualCasualty Insurance Co. et al...........................................................19

Equitable Distribution—Julie Addlespurger v. Steven Addlespurger v.

Donald Addlespurger and Auto Driveway Company ..................34(C)Sharon Ruth Pietrone v. Gregory Paul Pietrone ........................150(C)Diane Klabnik-Libretto v. Nicholas Libretto ..............................265

Equitable Distribution Offset—(C)Beverly P. Kirik v. Michael J. Kirik, IV ......................................438

Estoppel by Fraudulent Concealment—DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospital and


Eviction—Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. Tonya Hearn ........395

Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Pierce Greene ..........................262

Evidence Insufficient to Support Verdict—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Lee Allen......................122

Evidentiary Hearing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23

Excessiveness of Sentence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tito Rivera................................303

Exculpatory Clause—Graciela Garcia v. Angel C. Garcia and

Willis Shaw Express, Inc. ..............................................................37

Exculpatory Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Todd ..............................65

Execution on Judgments—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

Exemplary Damages and Counsel Fees—Steven Bogan and Environmental Containment Systems, LLC v.


Exhaustion of “Other Insurance”—Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,


Exigent Circumstances—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Flipping Bey................81

Expert Report—Annette F. Drotar and Joseph Drotar, her husband v.

Daniel W. Pituch, D.M.D., M.D. ..................................................242

Expert Testimony—Daniel J. Selepec, et al. v. Johnson and Johnson, Inc., et al. ............59Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Timothy Boczkowski..................84Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ding Huang ................................89Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.


Fact Witness v. Expert Witness—Frank Cuda v. Paradise Pools and Spas ..............................................79

Failure to Charge on Second Degree Murder—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leslie Mollett............................114

False I.D. to Law Enforcement—(C)In Re: In the Interest of: D.S., a minor Appeal of D.S.,

a minor ............................................................................................452

Federal Lien Priority—In the Matter of the Condemnation by the Redevelopment

Authority of Allegheny County of certain land in theBorough of Homestead, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania,being Property of DeBolt Unlimited Travel ServicesIncorporated, successor by merger toDeBolt Realty Co., Inc., et al. ......................................................428

Fiduciary Duties—M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,


Firearm Possession—In the Interest of: A.R. ........................................................................131

First Degree Murder—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leslie Mollett............................114

Foreclosure—Wells Fargo Bank, NA as Trustee v. George Janosik and

Lynn Janosik ..................................................................................293


Foreign Judgment—NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved


Forfeiture Act—JD & RM, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al. ................415

Fraud—Dale Zegarelli v. Frank Capo, Robert Linder, and

Robert Linder Services, Inc. ........................................................328

Fraudulent Transfers—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

Furlough of Police Department—Emerson Fazekas, Mayor, Borough of Versailles v.

Borough Council of the Borough of Versailles ..........................280

Garnishment—Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and Chrissanne Hennicke v.


Gist of the Action Doctrine—James J. Barber, et al. v. Clarendon National Insurance

Company, et al. ..............................................................................341Roth Cash Register Company, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,

Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc., Mark Gillie and Larry Lange;Shenango Systems Solutions, Inc. v. Micros Systems, Inc.,Frontier Business Technologies, Inc., Micros Fidelio DirectNorth Central, Inc. and Mark Gillie ............................................498

Grievance—Port Authority of Allegheny County v.

Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85 ........................................387

Guideline Deviation—(C)Joann C. Rodkey v. Joseph F. Rodkey, Jr. ....................................210

Guilty Plea—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden........................96Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden......................425Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Ricks..............................461

Habitability—Edward Zubik, Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v.


Hearsay—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David J. Baird ..........................162John G. Yunk v. Joseph B. Tomko, Jr., Janice M. Tomko,


Holder in Due Course—Abraham Leizerowski v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108

Home Rule Charter—John A. Danzilli, Jr. v. Mayor and Council of the Municipality

of Monroeville, et al.........................................................................31

Homicide—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Edward Nalls ................306HUD Regulation §982.553(a)(2)(ii)—Christopher Belajac v. Allegheny County Housing Authority ........459

Hung Jury—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Mendoza ....................397

Illegal Search and Seizure—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Driver ........................239

Imposition of Consecutive Sentences—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tito Rivera................................303

Inadvertently Produced Documents—American Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers, Inc.,

Industry Terminal & Salvage Co. and International MarineUnderwriters/One Beacon ............................................................447

In-Court Identification—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Darnell Evans ................94

Indemnification Requirements—Five Star Quality Care, Inc. d/b/a Overlook Green v.


Indemnity Between Joint Venturers—Doris E. Grafton, Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G.


Ineffective Assistance of Counsel—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George Baich ..............................39Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leslie Mollett............................114Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Morris Anthony ..........206Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rashad Desean Hefflin ..........223Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gene Leonard Brown ..............229Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kimberly S. McKaveney ........256Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Phillip Payne

a/k/a Christopher Payne ..............................................................310Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marquis Dennis........................353Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jason Barber ............................402Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tequilla Fields

a/k/a Tequilla Newsome................................................................478

Injunction—Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC,


Injunctive Relief—Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NW


Emerson Fazekas, Mayor, Borough of Versailles v.Borough Council of the Borough of Versailles ..........................280

Insufficient Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jennifer Marie Ballard............419

Insurance—Regis Insurance Company v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., a


Daniel F. Ross v. Foremost Insurance Company andSentry Services Insurance Company, Inc. ..................................338


Insurance Coverage—Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,


Insurance Policy—Viking Insurance Company v. Ned Spells, Timothy E. Johnson,

Bradley A. Steigerwalt, Carole L. Steigerwalt and State FarmMutual Automobile Insurance Company ....................................382

Intent—Port Authority of Allegheny County v.


Interest in Real Property—Wells Fargo Bank, NA as Trustee v. George Janosik and

Lynn Janosik ..................................................................................293

Interpretation of Easement Agreement—Gill Hall Land Co. v. AJNP Development, LLC..................................74

Interpretation of Zoning Ordinance—Township of Marshall v. Marshall Township Zoning

Hearing Board..................................................................................58

Inventory Search—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jennifer Marie Ballard............419

Investigative Detention—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Flipping Bey................81Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Yarudin A. Witherspoon ..........233

Joint Accounts—In Re: Estate of Ruth Alexander a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ......110

Joint Tortfeasor—Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. Anthony Crane


Judgments—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

Jurisdiction—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Tusweet Smith ............62

Jury Conversations—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Pierre King......................98

Jury Instruction—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James William Moore..............218Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Moon Jong Kim ........................231Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marquis Dennis........................353Morewood Point Community Association v.

The Port Authority of Allegheny County, et al. ..........................385

Jury Question—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Robert Slater ................208

Juvenile—(C)In Re: In the Interest of: D.S., a minor Appeal of D.S.,

a minor ............................................................................................452

Juvenile Delinquency—In the Interest of: A.R. ........................................................................131

Kloiber Instruction—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Phillip Payne

a/k/a Christopher Payne ..............................................................310Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marquis Dennis........................353

Lack of Understanding of Appellate Rights—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George Baich ..............................39

Land Development Plan Application—Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,


Landlord/Tenant—Edward Zubik, Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v.


Lateral Support—Morewood Point Community Association v.


Liability Insurance—Palmetto Home Builders, Inc. v. Mark and Chrissanne Hennicke v.


Limited Liability Company—Frank R. Zokaites v. Pittsburgh Irish Pubs, LLC and

Colm McWilliams ............................................................................47M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,


Loss of Consortium—(J)Donna L. & Thomas W. Aiken, III v. Eric Robert Hasis ............152

Mandatory Minimum Sentence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden......................425

Mandatory Sentencing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden........................96

Manifest Necessity—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.

Susan Wygant and James Anthony Lipscomb ..............................91

MCARE Fund—Dawn Mapel and Michael Mapel, individually and as

co-administrators of the Estate of Andrea Rose Maple,deceased v. Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., et al. ............................195

Medical Insurance Claims—Kim A. Bodnar v. State Farm Mutual Insurance Co. ........................78

Medical Malpractice—(J)Cynthia McGuinness and Matthew McGuinness, her husband

v. The Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh; PittsburghNeurosurgery Associates, Ltd.; Eric M. Altschuler, M.D.;Arthur H. Palmer, M.D. ................................................................152

Meeting Minutes—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444


Minor v. Major Subdivision—Ross Mendicino, Annunziato Reilsono and Jessica Reilsono,

Appellants v. Aleppo Township, Appellee ....................................57

Miranda Rights—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Fuller................................127

Misconduct—E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.

Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board ofSchool Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W. Johnston,and Allison Kline ..........................................................................442

Misidentified Plaintiff—DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospital and


Mistrial—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.

Susan Wygant and James Anthony Lipscomb ..............................91Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Brian Travell Thurmon ..........263

Modification—Allegheny Demolition, Inc. v. LVI Environmental Services, Inc. ..416

Modification of Sentence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Joshua Richard Thompson ....124

Modification Requires Full Evidentiary Hearing—(C)Janice Huwe v. Joseph Huwe, Bubash, J. ........................0

Mortgage Foreclosure—Julie Addlespurger v. Steven Addlespurger v.

Donald Addlespurger and Auto Driveway Company ..................34William R. Bishop, Jr. v. Ted Kaczorowski a/k/a

Thaddeus Kaczorowski and Mona Kaczorowski a/k/aMona Singer Kaczorowski ............................................................330

Motion for Mistrial—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Robert Slater ................208

Motion for Post-Trial Relief—The Mansions of North Park Homeowners Association v.

Mark McCullough ..........................................................................426

Motion for Preliminary Injunction—Selective Software, Inc. v. Steve and Dona Worthington, et al. ........51

Motion for Summary Judgment—Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Company v.

James Dean Guardino d/b/a James Dean Autoworks,Audrey J. D’Incau, Scott R. Birdseye, and AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford, Connecticut AutomobileInsurance Company of Hartford v. James Guardino, et al. ........49

Annette F. Drotar and Joseph Drotar, her husband v.Daniel W. Pituch, D.M.D., M.D. ..................................................242

Motion to Compel—Barbara A. Clark v. Richard P. Shannon ..........................................320Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444

Motion to Compel Discovery—Mark A. Bartholomaei v. Land Rover North America, Inc. ..............45Dani Jo and Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities, Inc./

Heritage Valley, d/b/a Sewickley Valley Hospital, et al. ..........252

Motion to Exempt—Dawn Mapel and Michael Mapel, individually and as


Motion to Present Additional Evidence—Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,


Motion to Reconsider—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Shawn Graham ........................289

Motion to Set Aside Writ of Execution—The Huntington National Bank, Successor by Merger to


Motion to Suppress—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Darnell Evans ................94Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kevin James Mariano................99Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Yarudin A. Witherspoon ..........233Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Driver ........................239Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ivan Milton Hale ......................286Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Jackson ......................399

Motor Vehicle—(J)Teena M. Allie v. Sandra Smith ....................................................151(J)Justine M. Bajek v. Steven J. Eliou ..............................................151(J)Donna L. & Thomas W. Aiken, III v. Eric Robert Hasis ............152

Municipal Police Jurisdiction Act—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Restieri, Jr. ..................423

Mutual Mistake of Fact—(C)Pamela M. Carson v. Sidney Carson ............................................438

Narcotics Possession—In the Interest of: A.R. ........................................................................131

Negligence—(J)Elizabeth Sexton and Thomas J. Sexton, her husband v. J.C.

Schultz Interiors, Inc., t/d/b/a J.C. Schultz Co. and OxfordDevelopment Corp., t/d/b/a Oxford Realty Management ........151

Doris E. Grafton, Administratrix of the Estate of Ronald G.Grafton, deceased, and Doris E. Grafton, in her own right,et al., v. Petroleum Development Corporation, et al. ................300

Negligent Retention and Supervision of Employee—Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.


Negotiable Instruments—Abraham Leizerowski v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108

Negotiated Plea—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jason Barber ............................402

Neighborhood Commercial District—James J. and Carol E. Leo v. Township of Hampton Council ........269


New Trial—William C. Garrow v. Sister Mary D. Thaner,

a/k/a Sister Mary D. Thawer........................................................297

No-Duty Rule for Sports Stadiums—Joan M. Pelly, et al. v. The Pittsburgh Harlequins Rugby

Football Association, et al. ............................................................418

Non-Compete Agreement—Computational Diagnostics, Inc. v. Brian D. Errigo ..........................11Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.

Martin Drabek and Douglas Stuhr ..............................................343Allegheny Specialty Practice Network and The West Penn

Allegheny Health System v. Joseph J. Colella, M.D. ................370

Non-Conforming Use Predates Zoning Ordinances—Stephen and Fiona Blazczak v. Township of West Deer ..................504

Non-Jury Trial—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Ryan Webb, Jr. ..........188

Non-Profit Assessments—Marc A. Mastro, et al. v. Chartiers Country Club ............................351

Notice—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marlynn Bryant........................321

Notice of Non-Payment—Abraham Leizerowski v. Mellon Bank, N.A. ....................................108

Notice of Suit—Connie LeGrand v. The Sports and Exhibition Authority of


Nursing Home Expense Liability—Five Star Quality Care, Inc. d/b/a Overlook Green v.


Occupancy Permit—Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and

Michael Ressler, Appellants v. City of PittsburghZoning Board of Adjustment v. City of Pittsburgh v.Phillip Coblitz, Intervenor ..............................................................56

Online Access to Bank Records—Barbara A. Clark v. Richard P. Shannon ..........................................320

Opening and/or Striking Default Judgment—Sanjay Chopra v. Amit Govil, Asit Govil, and Google, Inc. ............317

Operability of Firearm—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Shawn Graham ........................289

Owner’s Right of Redemption—Caulis Negris, LLC v. William R. Kaelin ..........................................105

Pa. R.A.P. 1925—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Matthew Farmer ......................190

Pa. R.A.P. 1925(b)—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40

Pa. R.C.P. 227.1(g)—Reginald and Vermell Plato v. City of Pittsburgh ............................450

Pa. R.C.P. 1038—The Mansions of North Park Homeowners Association v.

Mark McCullough ..........................................................................426

Pa. R.C.P. 1910.16–2(d)(1)—(C)Lynn A. Janosik v. George J. Janosik, Jr. ......................................44

Pa. R.C.P. 2002—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

Pa. R.C.P. 3118—Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Pamela H. Jasiewicz ..................473

Pa. R.C.P. 4003.3—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444American Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers,


Pa. R.C.P. 4009.1—Barbara A. Clark v. Richard P. Shannon ..........................................320

Pa. R.Crim.P. 114(B)—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40

PA Minimum Wage Act of 1968—David H. Caiarelli, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. and David

Albertini, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., Edward S.Lampert, Aylwin Lewis, William C. Crowley ............................197

PCRA—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Morris Anthony ..........206

Pedestrian—(J)Justine M. Bajek v. Steven J. Eliou ..............................................151

Pennsylvania Non-Profit Corporation Law of 1988—Marc A. Mastro, et al. v. Chartiers Country Club ............................351

Pennsylvania Wage Payment and Collection Law—Mark W. Ambrose and Ronald A. Kramer v.


Permitted Uses—James J. and Carol E. Leo v. Township of Hampton Council ........269

Person Not to Possess Firearms—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Shawn Graham ........................289

Personal Injury—John G. Yunk v. Joseph B. Tomko, Jr., Janice M. Tomko,


Petition for Time Credit—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John K. Richardson ................227

Petition to Intervene—Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,


Petition to Transfer to Juvenile Court—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Hancock............................224


Petition to Vacate Foreign Judgment—NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved


Photo Array—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Fuller................................127

Plain Language—Viking Insurance Company v. Ned Spells, Timothy E. Johnson,

Bradley A. Steigerwalt, Carole L. Steigerwalt and StateFarm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company ..........................382

Plain View Doctrine—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Turner ..............................160

Plea Agreement—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Edward Cole, Jr. ..........497

Possession—Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.


Posting of Bond—Dawn Mapel and Michael Mapel, individually and as


Post-Conviction DNA Testing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dennis Foy ................................143

Post-Conviction Relief Act—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Julian ..........................142Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rashad Desean Hefflin ..........223Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Barry Long................................228Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gene Leonard Brown ..............229Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kimberly S. McKaveney ........256Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Carl Collins ..............................407Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Troy Joseph ..............................460Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Edward Cole, Jr. ..........497

Post-Sentence Motion for a New Trial—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Moon Jong Kim ........................231

Power of Attorney—Marilyn Conley, Executrix of the Estate of Ethel B. Shaw v.

St. Barnabas Nursing Home, Inc., et al.......................................282

Preliminary Injunction—Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against


Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.Martin Drabek and Douglas Stuhr ..............................................343

Allegheny Specialty Practice Network and The West PennAllegheny Health System v. Joseph J. Colella, M.D. ................370

Preliminary Objections—Fisher Scientific Company, L.L.C.; Fisher Scientific International,


Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NWRehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania West Association,a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursing andRehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc., formerly known asCareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss ..........................................15

Joan M. Pelly, et al. v. The Pittsburgh Harlequins RugbyFootball Association, et al. ............................................................418

Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. Anthony CraneRental, Inc., et al. v. Gustine Uniontown, Inc., et al. ................492

Preliminary Objections as “Meritorious Defense”—Sanjay Chopra v. Amit Govil, Asit Govil, and Google, Inc. ............317

Premises Liability Policy—Penn-America Insurance Company v. A4 Place, Inc., Nasid Aboud,

Marian E.S. Aboud, Darnell A. Tolliver, Beatrice Woody,individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of JerryMcCrommon, III, deceased, Earl C. Troxler, Lamar Ezell,and Asa Howard ............................................................................153

Pre-Sentence Withdrawal of Guilty Plea—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William McCray ........................37

Principal and Agent—Daniel F. Ross v. Foremost Insurance Company and

Sentry Services Insurance Company, Inc. ..................................338

Prior Crimes of Violence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Richard Broaden........................96

Prior Inconsistent Statement—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jesse William Thornton ..........138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hayden Nathaniel Marshall....138

Prisoner Medical Care—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Albert


Private Criminal Complaint—William D. White v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania......................178Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. T. Colm McWilliams ................203Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. ........237

Probable Cause for Arrest—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Lee Allen......................122

Probable Cause for a Search Warrant—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Patricia Ann Rodgers ..............358

Probable Cause to Stop Motor Vehicle—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William George Mayer, III......119

Probation Revocation Hearing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David J. Baird ..........................162

Probation Violation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Todd ..............................65Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Neal Hall ......................120

Products Liability—Daniel J. Selepec, et al. v. Johnson and Johnson, Inc., et al. ............59

Professional Negligence—Dani Jo and Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities, Inc./


Promissory Estoppel—M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,


Property Settlement Agreement—(C)Andrew F. Andros v. Laurie Ann Waltz ........................................322


Prosecutorial Misconduct—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Robert Slater ................208Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James William Moore..............218

Public Housing—Christopher Belajac v. Allegheny County Housing Authority ........459

Purchase/Sales Agreement—JD & RM, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al. ................415

Quantum Meruit Relief—Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.

Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate,Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Companyand/or Oxford Realty Services, Inc. ............................................391

Quiet Enjoyment—Edward Zubik, Admr. of the Estate of James R. Zubik, Sr. v.


Racial Intimidation—Port Authority of Allegheny County v.


Rape Shield Law—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael R. Lipinski..................192

Real Estate Commission—Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.

Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate,Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Companyand/or Oxford Realty Services, Inc. ............................................391

Real Estate Exception—Morewood Point Community Association v.


Real Estate Licensing and Registration Act (RELRA) 63 P.S.§455.606a(b)—

Sanford L. Pollock d/b/a Sanford L. Pollock Real Estate v.Pittsburgh Opera and Pennsylvania Commercial Real Estate,Inc. and GVA Oxford f/k/a Oxford Development Companyand/or Oxford Realty Services, Inc. ............................................391

Rear End Collision—(J)Teena M. Allie v. Sandra Smith ....................................................151(J)Donna L. & Thomas W. Aiken, III v. Eric Robert Hasis ............152

Reasonable Due Diligence—Harvey Pasternack v. Mellon Financial Corporation ......................101

Reasonable Efforts to Mitigate Income Loss—(C)Lynn A. Janosik v. George J. Janosik, Jr. ......................................44

Reasonable Suspicion—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hamin Azeez Gray ....................64

Reasonableness—Frank Cuda v. Paradise Pools and Spas ..............................................79

Reasonableness of Conditions—HHI Trucking Supply, Inc. v. The Borough Council of the

Borough of Oakmont......................................................................279

Receivership—Nicholas A. Lettieri, Jr. v. The Locker Room Bar and Grille, LLC,


Select Medical Rehabilitation Services, Inc., d/b/a NWRehabilitation Associates v. Pennsylvania West Association,a/k/a Penn West Associates, Inc., d/b/a Westwood Nursingand Rehabilitation Center; Primus Care, Inc., formerlyknown as CareFirst, Inc. and Arthur M. Krauss..........................15

Recommendation of Guardian Ad Litem—In re M.M., a minor ..............................................................................32

Recusal—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jason Barber ............................402Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jayquon Massey ......................439

Redevelopment Authority—John A. Danzilli, Jr. v. Mayor and Council of the Municipality

of Monroeville, et al.........................................................................31

Reduction of Sentence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rodney Matthews a/k/a

William Taylor................................................................................162

Rehabilitation—Steve Smith v. Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh ..........459

Reinstatement of Appellate Rights—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George Baich ..............................39

Release—Graciela Garcia v. Angel C. Garcia and

Willis Shaw Express, Inc. ..............................................................37Daniel F. Ross v. Foremost Insurance Company and

Sentry Services Insurance Company, Inc. ..................................338

Relocation—M.P. v. S.B. ............................................................................................434

Remand—Mark W. Ambrose and Ronald A. Kramer v.


Report—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444

Re-Prosecution—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Brian Travell Thurmon ..........263

Request to Open or Strike Judgment—Bureaus Investment Group #10, LLC v. Larry Bruce Wilcox ........296

Requirements for Certificate of Occupancy—Robert A. Woolhandler v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of

Adjustment and City of Pittsburgh ..............................................272

Requirements of Schultz v. Erie Insurance Exchange—Sanjay Chopra v. Amit Govil, Asit Govil, and Google, Inc. ............317

Rescission—(C)Pamela M. Carson v. Sidney Carson ............................................438

Res Ipsa Loquitur—Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.



Resisting Arrest—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Weinberg......................235

Restitution—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Cecil Earl Grow..........................67Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Darnell Evans ................94Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Theresa Logsdon ......................141

Return of Overpayment—(C)Joann C. Rodkey v. Joseph F. Rodkey, Jr. ....................................210

Return of Seized Firearm—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Davis, Jr. ....................130

Reversal of Zoning Board—George R. Rhodes and Sharon L. Leech v.


Review of Water & Sewer Authority Proceedings and Findings—Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority v.

Richard W. Gladstone, II and Diana L. Hunkele........................298

Right Against Double Jeopardy—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rashad Desean Hefflin ..........223

Right of First Refusal—JD & RM, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al. ................415

Right to Counsel—In the Interest of F.C., III, a minor ....................................................439

Right to Natural Expansion—James J. and Carol E. Leo v. Township of Hampton Council ........269

Risks to Child’s Safety—In re M.M., a minor ..............................................................................32

Robbery—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Ryan Webb, Jr. ..........188

School Suspension/Expulsion—E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.

Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board ofSchool Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W.Johnston, and Allison Kline..........................................................442

Scope of Cross Examination—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ryan Michael Luterman..........136

Scope of Review—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Jackson ......................399

Search and Seizure Incident to Motor Vehicle Stop—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Whitney Sumpter ....................149

Search Warrant—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Turner ..............................160

Security Bond—Zavala, Inc. v. Five-R Excavating, Inc. and

Western Surety Company v. Seubert & Associates, Inc.............107

Self-Defense—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael McMillan....................409

E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.Woodland Hills School District, Woodland Hills Board ofSchool Directors, Dr. Walter M. Calinger, David W.Johnston, and Allison Kline..........................................................442

Self-Inflicted Hardship—George R. Rhodes and Sharon L. Leech v.


Sentencing—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Russell Wilner ............................38Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Darnell Evans ................94Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Andre Neal Hall ......................120Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Rodney Matthews

a/k/a William Taylor......................................................................162Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Davis ..........................165Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James William Moore..............218Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Brownfield ................238Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tito Rivera................................303Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480

Sentencing Above Aggravated Range—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Davis ..........................165

Sentencing Errors—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Morris Haley ............................494

Sentencing in Probation Revocation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Delmingo Williams ..................360

Sequestration Violation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Morris Haley ............................494

Service Upon Court Reporter—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40

Setback Requirement—Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and


Settlement—Gustine Uniontown Associates, LTD., et al. v. Anthony Crane


Severance Clause—Debra Fetterman, as Power of Attorney for Barbara J. Mears v.


Sexual Assault—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael R. Lipinski..................192

Sexually Violent Predator—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Omar J. Bakth ..........................182

Shareholder Dispute—R. Charles and Susan B. Richey, et al. v. George R. and Robin S.

Kenny and North Eastern Uniforms & Equipment, Inc. ............46

Sheriff Sale—Caulis Negris, LLC v. William R. Kaelin ..........................................105The Huntington National Bank, Successor by Merger to



Simple Assault—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bridget Mitchell ......................474

Single Criminal Episode—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Nancy Hammer ........................354

Slip and Fall—(J)Constance Jones and Terry Lee Jones v. Robert Levin,

Administrator d.b.n.c.t.a. of the Estate of Howard PhillipLevin, also known as Howard Levin............................................151

Social Security Offset—Doreen Speer v. David Speer..............................................................322

Sovereign Immunity—Morewood Point Community Association v.


Special Relief—(C)Beverly P. Kirik v. Michael J. Kirik, IV ......................................438

Spousal and Child Support—(C)Lynn A. Janosik v. George J. Janosik, Jr. ......................................44

Standard of Review—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. T. Colm McWilliams ................203Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. ........237Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority v.

Richard W. Gladstone, II and Diana L. Hunkele........................298

Standards for Revocation of Probation—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Delmingo Williams ..................360

Standing to Bring Mortgage Foreclosure Action—Wells Fargo Bank, NA as Trustee v. George Janosik and

Lynn Janosik ..................................................................................293

Standing to Challenge Legality of City Ordinance—National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese, Richard


Statute of Limitations—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential


Harvey Pasternack v. Mellon Financial Corporation ......................101Connie LeGrand v. The Sports and Exhibition Authority of


DeLana Lunsford Shaffer v. Allegheny General Hospital andMarianne Iwankonkiw v. Bethel Park School District andNutrition, Inc. and George Haburjak and Donna Haburjak v.JSMS Partners LP, JJK Holdings, Inc., et al., Krebs Chrysler-Jeep, Inc., et al. ..............................................................................363

Statutory Appeal—E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.


Statutory Construction—Kevin Joyce, Sean Connolly Casey, John Graf, Friends Against


Statutory Employee—John Antonucci and Judith A. Antonucci v.


Stay of Execution—Zavala, Inc. v. Five-R Excavating, Inc. and


Steep Slope Provisions—North Hills School District v. Ross Township Zoning Hearing

Board and Ross Township and North Hills School District v.Daniel L. Demarco, Esq., et al. ......................................................71

Storage vs. Display for Sale—Township of Marshall v. Marshall Township Zoning

Hearing Board..................................................................................58

Striking of Judgment—Walnut Capital Partners-1400 Smallman, L.P. v.


Student Expulsion—Shelby L. Jones, a Minor, by her Parent and Natural Guardian,

David Jones, v. Gateway School District and GatewaySchool District Board of School Directors..................................277

Substantial Evidence Rule—E.B., a minor, E.D.B. as parent, and E.D.B., in his own right v.


Sufficiency of Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Fears ................................23Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jesse William Thornton ..........138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hayden Nathaniel Marshall....138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Matthew Farmer ......................190Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jomar Laniel Mosby ................204Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Brownfield ................238Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Maurice Miles

a/k/a Robert Turner ......................................................................413Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Trice ..............................421Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bridget Mitchell ......................474Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480

Sufficient Specificity—Lori A. Marasco, Administratrix and/or Guardian Ad Litem

of the Estate of John R. Marasco, Sr. v. Giant Eagle, Inc.,Eckerd Corporation d/b/a Eckerd Drugs, and/or Rite AidCorporation and Robert Dean, M.D.............................................320

Summary Harrassment—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Russell Wilner ............................38

Summary Judgment—Regis Insurance Company v. Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc., a


David H. Caiarelli, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. and DavidAlbertini, et al. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., Edward S.Lampert, Aylwin Lewis, William C. Crowley ............................197

Daniel F. Ross v. Foremost Insurance Company andSentry Services Insurance Company, Inc. ..................................338

Joan M. Pelly, et al. v. The Pittsburgh Harlequins RugbyFootball Association, et al. ............................................................418


Supersedeas—Zavala, Inc. v. Five-R Excavating, Inc. and


Supersedeas Bond Requirements when more than one Defendant—Racquel Underwood, Shauna McInnes and Andrew Dash v.

Dana Wind and Sherry Kasprzyk ................................................241

Support—(C)Melissa King v. Anthony Aliucci ..................................................332

Suppression of Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jennifer Marie Ballard............419Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Restieri, Jr. ..................423Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Benjamin Mayhew ..................475

Suppression of Statements—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Hancock............................224Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Pierre King....................396

Survival Actions—Kirk Rettger and Erik Rettger, Co-Executors of the Estate of

Michael Rettger, deceased v. UPMC Shadyside; EugeneBonaroti; and Oakland Neurosurgical Associates......................242

Termination—Christopher Belajac v. Allegheny County Housing Authority ........459

Termination of Public Housing Lease—Orlando Gonzales v.

Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh ..............................327

Time for Filing Petition—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Julian ..........................142

Timeliness—Ross Mendicino, Annunziato Reilsono and Jessica Reilsono,

Appellants v. Aleppo Township, Appellee ....................................57Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Floyd Jackson, Jr. ....................187Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Troy Joseph ..............................460

Timeliness of Appeal—Reginald and Vermell Plato v. City of Pittsburgh ............................450

Tortious Interference—M. Marlin Metz v. Manjit Khara, Rattan Deep Singh Virk,


Trade Secrets—Extremity Imaging Partners, Inc. v.

Martin Drabek and Douglas Stuhr ..............................................343

Transcript of Proceedings—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Bradley Peters ............40

Treble Damages and Counsel Fees—Joni Van Arsdale v. Waldron Electric Heating, LLC........................323

Trust Administration—In Re: Estate of Ruth Alexander a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ......110

Two-Year Marriage—(C)Diane Klabnik-Libretto v. Nicholas Libretto ..............................265

UCC—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential


UCCJEA “home state” provision of 23 Pa. C.S.A. §5421(a)—(C)Marie Bouzos-Reilly v. John R. Reilly ........................................438

Underinsured and Uninsured Motorist Coverage—Frances Kelly v. MIC General Insurance Corporation,


Underinsured Motorist Claim—Mark & Susan Wutz v. Robert Smith & Robert Smith d/b/a

Rob Smith Construction & State Farm Insurance Company ....446

Undue Influence—In Re: Estate of Ruth Alexander a/k/a Mary Ruth Alexander ......110

Unemployment and Earning Capacity—(C)Lynn A. Janosik v. George J. Janosik, Jr. ......................................44

Unfair Trade Practices—Joni Van Arsdale v. Waldron Electric Heating, LLC........................323Steven Bogan and Environmental Containment Systems, LLC

v. Pre-Owned Auto Center of Indiana, PA, Inc...........................324

Uniform Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act—NC Venture I, L.P. v. Vora Enterprises, Inc. a dissolved


Uniform Firearms Act—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leslie Mollett............................114National Rifle Association, Shawn Lupka, Curtis Reese, Richard


Unlawful Restraint—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael R. Lipinski..................192

Untimely Appeal—Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and


Vacation of Street—Frank Bryan Inc. v. Pittsburgh Terminal Properties


Variance—Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and


North Hills School District v. Ross Township Zoning HearingBoard and Ross Township and North Hills School District v.Daniel L. Demarco, Esq., et al. ......................................................71

Daniel G. Kamin, et al., Appellants v. Zoning Board ofAdjustment of the City of Pittsburgh and BoteroDevelopment LLC and City of Pittsburgh ..................................270

Stephen and Fiona Blazczak v. Township of West Deer ..................504

Vehicular Stop—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Benjamin Mayhew ..................475

Verdict—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Washington..................480


Verdict Against Weight of Evidence—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Lee Allen......................122

Veto Power of Mayor—Emerson Fazekas, Mayor, Borough of Versailles v.

Borough Council of the Borough of Versailles ..........................280

Victim’s Misidentification of Alleged Co-Conspirator—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ryan Michael Luterman..........136

Violation of §401 of the Pennsylvania Securities Act—Kenneth F. Emmett v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, Prudential


Waiver from Ordinance—Moon First, An Unincorporated Association by Jesse Nicholson,


Waiver of Issues—Alan L. Tuttle and Corey Lea Simpson-Tuttle v.

Universal Forest Products Eastern Division, Inc. ....................167Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David R. Baldwin ....................476

Warrantless Search—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hamin Azeez Gray ....................64Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Anthony Flipping Bey................81Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles Jackson ......................399

Weight of Evidence—In the Interest of: A.R. ........................................................................131Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jesse William ThorntonCommonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hayden Nathaniel Marshall....138Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Ryan Webb, Jr. ..........188Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Matthew Farmer ......................190William C. Garrow v. Sister Mary D. Thaner,

a/k/a Sister Mary D. Thawer........................................................297

Withdrawal of Guilty Plea—Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bruce Proctor ..........................288

Witness Testimony—Dani Jo and Craig McLane v. Valley Medical Facilities, Inc./


Work Product Doctrine—Biodun Adewumi & Sam Ashaolu v. Duquesne University, et al. ..444American Coal and Minerals Company v. Henderson Brothers,


Worker’s Compensation Exclusivity Provision—Lynda Smith v. Con-Way, Inc., and jointly, severally or separately,

Consolidated Freightways Corporation of Delaware ................200

Wrongful Death—Kirk Rettger and Erik Rettger, Co-Executors of the Estate of

Michael Rettger, deceased v. UPMC Shadyside; EugeneBonaroti; and Oakland Neurosurgical Associates......................242

Wrongful Discharge—R. Charles and Susan B. Richey, et al. v. George R. and Robin S.

Kenny and North Eastern Uniforms & Equipment, Inc. ............46

Wrongful Termination—David R. Nicely, d/b/a Nicely Contracting v.

Win Development, LLC ................................................................103

Zero Tolerance Policy—Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. Tonya Hearn ........395

Zoning—Evan Nauman, Douglas Graham, Timothy McVeagh, and


Township of Marshall v. Marshall Township ZoningHearing Board..................................................................................58

HHI Trucking Supply, Inc. v. The Borough Council of theBorough of Oakmont......................................................................279

Richard W. Schomaker v. Zoning Hearing Board of theBorough of Franklin Park and Borough of Franklin Parkand Voicestream Pittsburgh, L.P., d/b/a T-Mobile ....................453

Stephen and Fiona Blazczak v. Township of West Deer ..................504Stephen and Fiona Blazczak v. Township of West Deer ..................504