phd dissertation lynda grine 2014 - ghent university · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!!...

250
!"#$%&’" )%#* +,-./+,-0 "#$%& ’%()$*+(&, -./01&, 23 4/($%/$+ -1.%5$*+ 6%+&(&0&$ 32* 7(2&$/#%2128, 6%31.99.&(2% :$+$.*/# ;$%&$* 123$) 45 26% 748% 45 9):% ; ;<2%*5%*4<= ’< 9>?/@%$’#2%$ ;<58#&&#2’4< A7;>B C)<$# <#$+(+ +0=9(&&$5 (% >.*&(.1 3013(119$%& 23 &#$ *$?0(*$9$%&+ 32* &#$ 5$8*$$ 23 @2/&2* (% 4/($%/$+A 7(2/#$9(+&*, B 7(2&$/#%2128, C*292&2*A C*23D @*D ;1.05$ E(=$*& ;2F>*292&2*A @*D :22+9.*(G% HD I.%5$%=*20/J$

Upload: others

Post on 06-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

!!!

!"#$%&'"()%#*(+,-./+,-0(

(

("#$%&!'%()$*+(&,!-./01&,!23!4/($%/$+!-1.%5$*+!6%+&(&0&$!32*!7(2&$/#%2128,!6%31.99.&(2%!:$+$.*/#!;$%&$*!

(

123$)(45(26%(748%(45(9):%(;(;<2%*5%*4<=('<(

9>?/@%$'#2%$(;<58#&&#2'4<(

(

A7;>B(C)<$#(

(

(

<#$+(+!+0=9(&&$5!(%!>.*&(.1!3013(119$%&!23!&#$!*$?0(*$9$%&+!32*!&#$!5$8*$$!23!@2/&2*!(%!4/($%/$+A!7(2/#$9(+&*,!B!7(2&$/#%2128,!

C*292&2*A!C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!;2F>*292&2*A!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$

!!

Page 2: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

! !

Page 3: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

123$)(45(26%(748%(45(9):%(;(;<2%*5%*4<=('<(9>?/@%$'#2%$(;<58#&&#2'4<(

!

<#(+!&#$+(+!(+!+0=9(&&$5!(%!>.*&(.1!3013(119$%&!23!&#$!*$?0(*$9$%&+!32*!&#$!5$8*$$!23!@2/&2*!(%!

4/($%/$+A!7(2/#$9(+&*,!B!7(2&$/#%2128,!

!

7,!E,%5.!"*(%$!

!"#$%&'%(%)*+$&*(&,(-./00/)*"(&1!',2&

3%4/5)0%()&"-&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&';%()&<(*=%5$*)9&

,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6&

A%+;("."8*%4/5B&CDE&

6FCGHD&';%()&1IJ*K(//57%2&

!

<#(+!K2*J!K.+!+0>>2*&$5!=,!6L<F-1.%5$*+M!7$18(09!

!

!"#$%&'"()%#*D(+,-./+,-0(

!

E*4&424*D!! ! ! C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

F4/:*4&424*D!! ! @*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

!

@%&G%*=(45(26%(%H#&'<#2'4<("4&&'22%%D(

!

;#.(*9.%! ! ! C*23D!@*D!N2#.%!"*22&$%!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

!

:$.5(%8!;299(&&$$! ! C*23D!@*D!O.)($*!4.$1$%+!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

! ! ! ! C*23D!@*D!N2!E.9=$*&!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

! ! ! ! C*23D!@*D!P%G$!;.0K$1+!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

! ! ! ! @*D!"$$*&*0(!@$%$/J$*!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

! ! ! ! @*D!4&$3.%!E($%$%J1.0+!1?%()%5&-"5&,(-%+)*"(&>%$%/5+;:&'%50/(92&&

!

Q&#$*!9$9=$*+! ! C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02!

! ! ! ! @*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02&

C*23D!@*D!L(9!@$/1$*/?!1';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&6%.8*#02&

& &

Page 4: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

( (

Page 5: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

I#<JK44*$(

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`2%928$1(GJ_!%($&!J$%&!AFV!P1+!(J!%28!9..*!$$%!&($%5$!).%!G20K!$%&#20+(.+9$!)22*!5$!K$&$%+/#.>!#$=!J0%%$%!2)$*J*(G8$%M!R.1!.11$+!(%5$*5..5!928$1(GJ!1(GJ$%!aG.G.M!9$1(8M!9..*!8$$3!&2$M!%0!9.8!(J!K$1!$$%+]VD!@.%J!0!:22+!AFV!C'%<M!5$!3.+#(2%!80*0A!G$!1(GJ&!K$1!5$!K(G+&$!).%!5$! 8.%+$! #22>M! $%! G$! J1$$5&! G$! #$&! =$+&$M! 5.&! (+! R2%5$*! &K(G3$1D! Q9! (%! 5$R$135$! &*$%5! ).%!)$*8$1(GJ(%8$%!&$!=1(G)$%A!.1+!(J!%28!9..*!$$%!&($%5$!).%!0K!J1$5(%8+&(G1!2)$*8$J*$8$%!#$=M!R20!(J! $*! b1&(G5! 82$58$J1$$5! =(G12>$%D! W..*! 5.%! R20! 9(G%! +#2>8$5*.8! #$1$9..1! %($&! 9$$*! &$!+&2>>$%!R(G%]!W..*! &2$8$8$)$%M! (J!)(%5!$$%!/29>1(9$%&!).%! G20!2)$*!9(G%!J1$*$%! &2/#!.1&(G5!31.&&$*$%5!#.#.]!N20!K(1!(J!=$5.%J$%!29!+&$$5+!5$!*0+&!R$1)$!&$!=1(G)$%!(%!92$(1(GJ$!929$%&$%M!$$%! 10(+&$*$%5! 22*!K.%%$$*! (J! >.%(J$$*! 2)$*! 5(%8$%! 5($! R2! &*()(..1! R(G%M! $%! 29! +&$$5+! $$%!#$15$*$!J(GJ!2>!R.J$%!&$!#$==$%D!6J!#$=!)$$1!8$1$$*5!).%!G20M!9..*!)22*.1!29!J.19!&$!=1(G)$%!$%!K..*+/#(G%1(GJ!=$%!(J!5..*29!%$&!%($&!2%&>123&!=(G!#$&!+/#*(G)$%!).%!5$R$!&#$+(+D!Q#M!$%!22J!=$5.%J&!5.&!(J!%($&!.11$$%!=$%!9$&!9(G%!+#2>.110*$+!UFV!!H%!5.%!%0M!145'%(L$MD!W(G%!$)$%!J1$(%!9..&G$!AFV!L(G!#$==$%!X/#&!)$$1!8$1./#$%M!5$+2%5.%J+!2%+!)$1$!929$%&$%!R$13=$J1.8D!Q2J!.1!R(&&$%!5$!1$&&$*+!^30%c!%($&!(%!52/&2*..&M!&2/#!)(%5!(J!5.&!G(G! 5$! `30%_! (%! 52/&2*..&! +&$$J&]! N(G! #$=&!9$! )22*.1! 8$1$$*5! 5.&! .1+! $*! ($&+! (+!9(+8..&! (%! $$%!$d>$*(9$%&M! 5.&! 5.&! K$1$$%+! 2JX! J.%! R(G%M! .+! 12%8! .+! ,20c*$! #.)(%8! 30%]! 4(%5+5($%! K.+!52/&2*$*$%!>($/$!23!/.J$]!e($&!$/#&!%$$M!9..*!#$&!9..J&$!#$&!K$1!R2)$$1!5*..81(GJ$*!UFV!N(G!=$%&!.1!$)$%!$*8!.1+!(JM!9$&!0K!2%1(%$!+#2>8$5*.8M!0K!J(%5$*F)$*+1.)(%8M!0K!90R($JF)$*+1.)(%8M!T!!N20K!)$*&*$J!K.+!$*8!G.99$*!$%!K$!9(++$%!G20M!9..*!K$!+>*$J$%!%28!*$8$19.&(8!.3M!$%!R21.%8!K$! ).%! +#2>>$%M! -*($%5+M! :f3f+M! *299$19.*J&$%! $%! J1.8$%! #205$%M! R($! (J! %28! $$%!1$)$%+1.%8$!)*($%5+/#.>!)22*!9(G]!W$*/(!)22*!5$!929$%&$%!5($! G(G! &23!J2%!9.J$%M!K.%&!5.&!J.%! G(G! .1+! 5$! =$+&$]! g($*=(G! 5$%J! (J! ..%! 2%+! *..*! )$*=1(G3! (%! "$%h)$M! 2>8$+12&$%! (%! $$%!+1..>J.9$*!).%!$$%!R2&&$!9.5.9]!P(%c&!%2!+0%+#(%$]!@#*8'%=(%<(I%8:6'<%N(A#=24<(%<(C%4T!L..*!&$!=$8(%%$%S]!P>.*&!R(G%!G011($!.90+.%&M!$%!&$+.9$%!R(G%!G011($!8.*.%&($!)22*!#(1.*(&$(&D!6J!K$$&!5.&!5.&!J1(%J&! .1+! *$/1.9$!)22*!$$%!)22*+&$11(%8!).%! G011($M! $%! +$*($0+M! ).%! R25*.! (J!5$!9(55$1$%!#$=M! (%)$+&$$*! (J! (%!$$%!+#2K!).%! G011($]!W.*1($+M!9(G%!.11$*$$*+&$!$d>$*(9$%&!K.+!9$&!G20!$%!(J!1$$*5$!5(*$/&!5.&!(J!92$+&!*$%%$%!522*!5$!8.%8$%!29!G$!=(G!&$!=$%$%D!N$!=$%&!$$%!2%8$123$1(GJ!R2&!9$(+G$M!K..*! (J!b1&(G5!>1$R($*!9$$!#$=D!g$&! (+! (99$%+!R.1(8!29!&$!K$&$%!5.&!

Page 6: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

($9.%5!.11$!+/*(>&+!).%!-*($%5+!).%=0(&$%!J$%&!$%!50+!22J!.11$!*$3$*$%&($+!9$&$$%!522*#$$3&D!W..*!=0(&$%!>1$R($*M!J*$$8!(J!22J!)$$1!+&$0%!).%!G20D!L$1(+K..*!9$&!)$$1!2%8$9.JM!8$R($%!(J!%($&!8*..8!J%033$1M!9..*!#$&!=$&$J$%&!)$$1!)22*!9$!5.&!G$!2%8$9.JJ$1(GJ!=1$$3!+&..%!23!R(&&$%!.1+!(J!G$!%25(8!#.5]!H%!.1!(+!#$&!`&#$!$%5!23!.%!$*._M!&2/#!=$%!(J!#$$1!=1(G!5.&!(J!R2c%!)*($%5(%!.1+!G20! #$=! 2)$*8$#205$%]! @$1>#(%$c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g2&-$9.1$W2=($1!%..*!7d1M!>1$8$%!K$!2%R$!/20>!5cX&.&!2>!5$!5.%+=.*$!5$0%&G$+!).%!:f3f+!$%!&2%$%!K$! %$! J$$*! #2$! $33(/($%&! *$8$*$%! J.%A!9$&! $$%! *$/#&)..*5(8$M! 52/#! +&*$%8$! a..%! #$&!)22*#2235V!#.%5!$%!$$%!8$R2%5!+>2*&F>*28*.99.!a$%!%($&!)22*!%($&!)22*!K$*J12R$%M!&++V!$%!K2*5$%! 5$! )0(1%(+R.JJ$%! 2>8$#..15M! 2%8$./#&! #0%! J1$0*]! i2*&29M! 5$! (5$.1$! K$*$15! ).%!E,%5$1]!P1+!0K!)$*+%$11(%8!9..*!%($&!=1(G3&!).+&+&$J$%T!B8'%<M!K(G!R(G%!+.9$%!=$82%%$%!$%!.1+!(J!9$!82$5!#$*(%%$*M!=$82%%$%!K$!2)$*$$%!&$!J29$%!(%!#$&!9(/*2&29($F12J..1&G$!AFV!N$!=$%&!R2!=$#01>R..9!$%!R2!=$8..%!9$&!($5$*$$%M!$/#&!$$%!922($!$(8$%+/#.>M! %($&! JK(G&+>$1$%]!W..*! 5.&! 8..&! 8$>..*5!9$&! =.==$1$%M! $%! (J! J.%!9$! $/#&! %($&!9$$*!#$*(%%$*$%!K..*2)$*!K(G!.1!8$=.==$15!#$==$%D!W..*!(J!2%&#205!)22*.1A!K(G!#$==$%!)XX1!8$=.==$15! UFV!H%!8$R($%!2>! G$! ^.3+/#$(5+cJ..*&G$! +&..&!5.&!.1+! (J!$$%!=.==$1!%25(8!#$=M! (J!#$&!92$&! 1.&$%! K$&$%M! 50+! )$*K./#&! G$! 5$! J29$%5$! 9..%5$%! 9..*! ..%! )$$1! &$1$322%&G$+! $%!.3+>*..JG$+A!K$!R011$%!2%8$&K(G3$15!&2/#!K$$*!5$!0*$%!K$&$%!)21!&$!=.==$1$%]!W$*/(!)22*!2%R$!929$%&$%!$%!(J!J(GJ!0(&!%..*!5($8$$%!5($!%28!92$&$%!J29$%]!14:6'%M!K($!R.1!9(G!%0!.11$*1$(!1$0J$!1(%J+!92$&$%!9.(1$%S!40>$*R.1(8!5.&!2%R$!)*($%5+/#.>!9$&!9.(1&G$+!2%&+>*2&$%!(+A!^*0(J!G(G! 5($! $%$*8,! 5*(%J! 22JS]c!g.#.#.M! 5.&! 8.! (J! &2/#!9(++$%D!W..*! 22J! 5.&!K$! R2)$$1! 5$R$135$!(%&$*$++$+! #$==$%M! K$! 92$&$%! $1J..*! >.>$*+! 2)$*! <e-! $%! .0&2(9900%! R($J&$%! =1(G)$%!522*9.(1$%]!W..*!)22*.1A!!(J!)(%5!5.&!K$!%28!+&$$5+!R2c%!`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j!>.8(%.c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c$*&G$M!9$*/(!29!9$!&$!#$1>$%!(%!5($!1..&+&$!9..%5$%D!6J!=$%!=1(G!G$!%28!&$!1$*$%!J$%%$%!(%!9(G%!1..&+&$!G..*]!"$%($&!).%!5$!9$%+$%!2>!#$&!1.=2M!R$!R(G%!+0>$*!AFV!?'8':(%<(145'%(CM!$dF0/1(c$*+T!g$&!K.+!+0>$*!29!G011($!&$!1$*$%!J$%%$%!$%!$*8!G.99$*!5.&!G011($!.11$=$(!R(G%!)$*&*2JJ$%!.1)2*$%+!9(G%!52/&2*..&!.38$*2%5!K.+D!W..*!0(&!#$&!228!0(&!#$&!#.*&!&$1&!#($*!%($&U!%($&!R21.%8!K$!$1J..*+!$F9.(1.5*$++$%!#$==$%]!-(1(>M!9$*/(!)22*!G$!#01>!`(%!5$%!=$8(%%$_M!$%!1.&$%!K$!5($!)$&$!&0++$%!P.1+&!$%!@$%5$*92%5$!%0!%($&!&0++$%!2%+!J29$%!#XD!H%!423($!EM!.1!(+!#$&!%28!$)$%M!22J!%($&!)$*8$&$%!9(G!0(&!&$!%25(8$%!)22*!G20K!)$*5$5(8(%8!#X]!@4*Q#<%M! 9(G%! 1($3+&$! +&05($8$%22&G$M! K$! J$%%$%! $1J..*! 2%5$*&0++$%! =(G%.! &($%! G..*]! L.&!#$==$%!K(G!.1!%($&!.38$1./#$%]!H%!(J!K$$&!R$J$*!5.&!$*!%28!R2)$$1!9$$*!&$!1./#$%!).1&D!6J!#$=!50(R$%5! #$*(%%$*(%8$%! ..%! R.1(8$! 929$%&$%! a2>&*$5$%+VM! $%! ..%! (**(&.%&$! 929$%&$%!

Page 7: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

a&.%J+&.&(2%!R2$J$%!(%!g211.%5!23!5$!/.9=(2!>.*J$*$%V!9$&! G20!$%!#$&! 1$0J$!(+!5.&!K$!b1&(G5!($&+!)(%5$%!29!9$$!&$!1./#$%D!g$&!(+!$(8$%1(GJ!$$%!10d$!29!R2c%!82$5$!)*($%5(%!.1+!/211$8.!&$!#$==$%!2>!#$&!K$*JM!5.&!8.!(J!$%2*9!9(++$%D!W..*!K(G!=1(G)$%!+2K($+2!)*($%5(%%$%M!K.%&!K$!#$==$%!R2)$$1! *$5$%$%A!90R($J! a2>&*$5$%+!23! R$13!2>&*$5$%! UFVVM! 12>$%M!J2J$%M!T!$%! 1./#$%]!@3*'%8M! K$! K(+&$%! K$1! ).%! $1J..*+! =$+&..%M! 9..*! /2/J&.(1+! $%! $$%! =0+*(&! #$==$%! 2%R$!)*($%5+/#.>! 8$k%(&($$*5D! W$! #.>>,M! K.%&! G(G! )$*5($%&! 8$5$$15$! .0&$0*++/#.>A! $?0.11,!/2%&*(=0&$5! &2!.11! &#$! /29>1.(%(%8]! UFV!Q%R$!>.0R$+!K.*$%!5$!929$%&$%!K..*2>!K$!.11$=$(!J2%5$%!)(&&$%!2>!R.J$%!K..*!%($9.%5!#$&!=$+&..%!).%!.3K(+&!!!295.&!$%J$1!K(G!$*!$*8$*%(+!(%!J0%%$%!R($%]!g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a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c.)$R! .>>*(+! =$.0/20>! 5$! /#2+$+! ?0(!9c2%&!.(5X!>$%5.%&! 1$!52/&2*.&M!$&!)20+!X&($R! &20G20*+! 1b!>20*!9c.(5$*D!W$*/(!>20*! &20&M!9$+!/#$*+!>.*$%&+D!!!g2$!5.%J!(J!5$!=$1.%8*(GJ+&$!>$*+22%!(%!9(G%!1$)$%!)22*!5$!922(+&$!929$%&$%!(%!9(G%!1$)$%S!6J!K$$&!#$&!%($&M!1($3+&$!I'%2%*M!9..*!(J!92$&!#$&!.%&K22*5!)(%5$%M!K.%&!G(G!)$*5($%&!#$&!9$$*!5.%!22(&]! N$!#$=&!9$&!)$$1!8$5015!9(G!8$+&$0%5!29!5(&! &$!)$*K$R$%1(GJ$%M!$%!+&$$5+!9$&!$$%!10(+&$*$%5!22*!%..*!.1!9(G%!3*0+&*.&($+!$%!&K(G3$1+!8$10(+&$*5!a#2$K$1!G$!9$!K..*+/#(G%1(GJ!2>!^90&$c! R$&&$! (%! G$! #2235! UFVVM! $%! G$! #$=&! ($5$*$! K$*J5.8! ).%!9(G! +&$$5+! .38$+12&$%!9$&! $$%!81(91./#D!W..*!.11$!9$1(8#$(5!2>!$$%!+&2JG$U!&2&!(J!#$&!.%&K22*5!)(%5M!).&!(J!#$&!&2&!5.%!+.9$%!9$&A! =$5.%J&! )22*! G20K!2%)22*K..*5$1(GJ$! +&$0%M! &(G5! $%! 8$R$1+/#.>M!9(G%!9.%M!9(G%! =$+&$!)*($%5D!!! !

Page 8: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

( (

Page 9: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

13&&#*)(

<e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! >1$(2&*2>(/! /,&2J(%$+! &#.&! .*$! (%)21)$5! (%! +$)$*.1! (%31.99.&2*,!5(+2*5$*+!+0/#!.+!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!<#$!+0//$++!23!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+!+0>>2*&+! &#$! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! <e-! >1.,+! .! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! *21$! (%! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+M!(%31.99.&2*,!=2K$1!5(+$.+$! a67@V!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!<#$!0+$!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! &#$! &*$.&9$%&!23!g$>.&(&(+!7!.%5!;!.%5!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+M!#.+!.1+2!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!7%&("="! (%50/&(2%!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!!6%!&#(+!+&05,M!K$!K$*$!(%&$*$+&$5!(%!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!23!&#$!<e-l<e-:Z!.%5!&,>$!6!6-el6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,+! (%! +$)$*.1! 925$1+D! L$! 320%5! &#.&! <e-! /2015! (%50/$! 2*! =12/J! &#$!>*250/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! 5$>$%5(%8! 2%! &#$! +&(9010+D! '+(%8! 9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! <e-:Z! .%5!6-eP:ZM!K$!320%5!&#.&!=2&#!>.&#K.,+!/2%&*(=0&$!+$>.*.&$1,!.%5!.55(&()$1,!&2!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!.%! $%52&2d(%! 925$1! 23! EC4! .%5! (%! P15.*.F(%50/$5! +J(%! 1$+(2%+D! W2+&! +,9>&29+! K$*$!.9$1(2*.&$5! .%5! J%2/J20&! 9(/$! $d#(=(&$5! 1$++! (%31.99.&2*,! >.*.9$&$*+! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2!K(15!&,>$!/2%&*21!9(/$D!W2*$2)$*M!+(901&.%$20+!5$3(/($%/,!(%!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!*$+01&$5!(%!+0>$*(2*! >#$%2&,>$+! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! +(%81$! J%2/J20&! .%5! K(15! &,>$! 8*20>+D! :$9.*J.=1,M!=2&#!<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!+(8%.1(%8!.33$/&$5! 1(8.%5+!23! &#$! 6EFZm! 3.9(1,! (%!.11! &$+&$5!925$1+D!P%2&#$*! *$9.*J.=1$! 3(%5(%8!K.+! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,! (%! &#$! &2>(/.11,! .>>1($5! P15.*.!925$1! 50$! &2! 2*.1! 0>&.J$D! C*$)$%&(2%! 23! 2*.1! 0>&.J$! 23! P15.*.! .33$/&$5! &#$! +$)$*(&,! 23! &#$!(%50/$5!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!!<#$! 3(%5(%8+! (%! &#(+! 52/&2*.1! &#$+(+! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! /2%&*(=0&$! &2! 20*! 0%5$*+&.%5(%8! 23! &#$!(%&$*>1.,!23!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!./0&$!.%5!/#*2%(/!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+D!!1#&%<M#22'<Q(

<e-! $%! &,>$! 6! 6-e$%! R(G%! 901&(30%/&(2%$1$! /,&2J(%$+! 5($! =$&*2JJ$%! R(G%! =(G! 5()$*+$!2%&+&$J(%8+..%52$%(%8$%! R2.1+! +#2/J! +,%5*29$%! $%! .0&2F(9900%R($J&$%D! g$&! +0//$+! ).%!<e-! .%&.82%(+&$%! 2%5$*+&$0%&! 5.&! <e-! $$%! >*2F(%31.99.&2(*$! *21! +>$$1&! (%! *$09.&2k5$!.*&*(&(+M! (%31.99.&2(*$! 5.*9R($J&$%! $%! >+2*(.+(+D! g$&! 8$=*0(J! ).%! &,>$! 6! 6-e$%! (%! 5$!=$#.%5$1(%8!).%!#$>.&(&(+!7!$%!;!$%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+$M!K2*5&!&$)$%+!8$.++2/($$*5!9$&!7%&("="!2%&K(JJ$1(%8!).%!.0&2F(9900%R($J&$%D!6%! 5$R$! +&05($! K$%+&$%! K$! 5$! (%&$*./&($! ).%! 5$! <e-l<e-:Z! $%! &,>$! 6! 6-e$%l6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(+.&($+!&$!=$+&05$*$%!(%!)$*+/#(11$%5$!925$11$%D!L$!2=+$*)$$*5$%!5.&!5$!>*250/&($!).%!&,>$!6!6-e$%!R2K$1!8$k%50/$$*5!.1+!8$=12JJ$$*5!J0%%$%!K2*5$%!522*!<e-M!.3#.%J$1(GJ!).%!5$!+&(9010+D! P.%! 5$! #.%5! ).%! &*.%+8$%$!90(R$%! 5($! 5$3(/($%&! K.*$%! )22*! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:ZM!)2%5$%! K$! 5.&! =$(5$! +(8%.1(+.&($+! 2>! .3R2%5$*1(GJ$! $%! 8$R.9$%1(GJ$! K(GR$! =(G5*.8$%! ..%!(%31.99.&($! (%! EC4F8$k%50/$$*5$! $%52&2d$9($! 23! #0(51.$+($+! ..%8$=*./#&! 522*! P15.*.D! @$!9$$+&$!+,9>&29$%!)$*=$&$*5$%!K.%%$$*!$$%!).%!5$!*$/$>&2*$%!.3K$R(8!K.+!$%!5$!&*.%+8$%$!90(R$%!)$*&22%5$%!9(%5$*! (%31.99.&2(*$!>.*.9$&$*+! (%!)$*8$1(GJ(%8!9$&!5$!/2%&*21$8*2$>D!72)$%5($%! 1$(55$! 8$1(GJ&(G5(8$! 5$1$&($! ).%! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:Z! &2&! +0>$*($0*$! 3$%2&,>$+! (%!5($R$135$!925$11$%! (%!)$*8$1(GJ(%8!9$&!5$!$%J$1)205(8$!J%2/J20&!$%!K(15! &,>$!8*2$>$%D!g$&!K.+! R$$*! 2>9$*J$1(GJ! 5.&! R2K$1! .3K$R(8#$(5! ).%! <e-:! $%! 6-eP:Z! 5$! >*250/&($! ).%! 6EFZm!3.9(1($1$5$%!(%!.11$!925$11$%!=$k%)12$55$D!H$%!.%5$*$!2>9$*J$1(GJ$!=$)(%5(%8!K.+!5.&!2>!5$!#0(5! ..%8$=*./#&$! P15.*.! 1$(55$! &2&! (%&$+&(%.1$! >$*9$.=(1(&$(&! 522*! 2*.1$! 2>%.9$! ).%! 5$!/*h9$D! I$*#(%5$*(%8! ).%! 2*.1$! 2>%.9$! ).%! P15.*.! #.5! $$%! $33$/&! 2>! 5$! 8$k%50/$$*5$!#0(51.$+($+D!@$! =$)(%5(%8$%! (%! 5(&! >*2$3+/#*(3&! 1$)$*$%! $$%! =$1.%8*(GJ$! =(G5*.8$! ..%! 2%+! =$8*(>! ).%! 5$!(%&$*./&($!).%!<e-!$%!&,>$!6!6-e$%!(%!./0&$!$%!/#*2%(+/#$!2%&+&$J(%8+R($J&$%D!

!

! ! ! !!! !

Page 10: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

( (

Page 11: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

9#G8%(45(F4<2%<2(!C'=2(45(#GG*%M'#2'4<=!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Z!!F6#:2%*(;(/(A%<%*#8(;<2*4$3"2'4<!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!n!Z!<#$!6990%$!+,+&$9!.%5!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!n!j!;,&2J(%$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!o!p!<e-!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZ!pDZ!g(+&2*,!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZ!pDj!;#.*./&$*(+&(/+!.%5!+(8%.1(%8!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zj!pDp!69>1(/.&(2%!(%!5(+$.+$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zq!pDpDZ!<e-!.%5!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zq!pDpDj!<e-!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jZ!

pDn!<e-!(%!&#$*.>($+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jn!pDnDZ!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jr!pDnDj!'+$!23!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jq!pDnDp!C(&3.11+!23!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jo!

pDr!:.&(2%.1$!&2!=12/J!<e-:Z!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!pj!n!<,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!&#$(*!*$/$>&2*+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!pp!nDZ!g(+&2*,!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!pp!nDj!;#.*./&$*(+&(/+!.%5!+(8%.1(%8!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!pn!nDp!69>1(/.&(2%!(%!5(+$.+$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!pq!nDpDZ!<,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!po!nDpDj!<,>$!6!6-e+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!n[!

nDn!<,>$!6!6-e+!(%!&#$*.>($+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nj!nDnDZ!<,>$!6!6-e+!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+!.%5!9.1(8%.%/($+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nj!nDnDj!<,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!&*$.&9$%&!23!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nr!

nDr!:.&(2%.1$!&2!=12/J!6-eP:Z!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nq!r!<#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!20&!23!/2%&*21!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nm!rDZ!4#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nm!rDZDZ!"$%$*.1!.+>$/&+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nm!rDZDj!6%!)()2!925$1+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!nY!rDZDp!:21$!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!rn!

rDj!P0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!rr!rDjDZ!"$%$*.1!.+>$/&+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!rr!rDjDj!C+2*(.+(+!a8$%$*.1V!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!rq!rDjDp!6%!)()2!925$1+!32*!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!qj!

:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!qm!q!:21$!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!om!P%!(%31.99.&2*,!&*(.%81$!(%!>+2*(.+(+A!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!oo!P=+&*./&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!oo!6%&*250/&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!oY!:21$!23!<e-!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Y[!:21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Yj!:21$!23!6EFjpl6EFZm!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Yr!<#$!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Yo!<#$!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!6EFjpl6EFZm!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Z[Z!<#$!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFjpl6EFZm!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Z[p!;2%/10+(2%A!(9>1(/.&(2%+!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&+!23!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!5(+$.+$+!.%5!/0**$%&!.%5!30&0*$!5*08+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Z[q!

:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Z[Y!

Page 12: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

F6#:2%*(;;(/(!'&=!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZq!-2/0+!23!&#$!>*2G$/&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZq!Z!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/J!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZm!j!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!(%!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZo!p!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZo!C.*&!pDZ!6+!&#$*$!.!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+S!DDDDDDDDDD!ZZo!pDj!g2K!$33$/&()$!(+!./&().&(2%!=,!P15.*.M!/2%&.(%(%8!&#$!<E:m!.82%(+&!6WsM!.+!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1!32*!>+2*(.+(+!(%!9(/$S!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZZY!

:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZjZ!!F6#:2%*(;;;(/(7%=382=!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zjp!!"#$%&'()*'+!,-*+%+%#".+/0&1203+4*)2*150&+06+%7$89!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zjr!P=+&*./&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zjr!6%&*250/&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zjq!:$+01&+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zjm!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!1()$*!52$+!%2&!>*292&$!<e-F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZjY!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!.%5!*$+>2%+$!(%!&#$!80&!(+!&(++0$F+>$/(3(/!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZpZ!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!80&!9$5(.&$+!<e-F(%50/$5!5.9.8$M!=0&!%2&!12++!23!=.**($*!(%&$8*(&,!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zpp!4$/*$&(2%!23!6EFZm!(+!9$5(.&$5!=,!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zpn!C*$F&*$.&9$%&!23!6-eP:Z!iQ!K(&#!.%&(F6EFZm!52$+!%2&!>*2&$/&!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zpm!

@(+/0++(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zpo!W.&$*(.1+!.%5!9$&#25+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZnZ!:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Znq!!:0(;3*+'*65)5*&),+5&+!"#+<&'+1,-*+%+%#"+.5=&<35&=+3*<'.+10+*&><&)*'+-201*)150&+5&+

*&'010?*@5<!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZrZ!P=+&*./&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZrZ!6%&*250/&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zrj!:$+01&+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zrn!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!5$3(/($%/,!1$.5+!&2!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!EC4F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,!/29>.*$5!&2!+(%81$!5$3(/($%/($+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zrn!<e-:Z!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!52!%2&!.33$/&!$./#!2&#$*c+!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!(%!+$*09!.3&$*!EC4!/#.11$%8$!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zrq!6-eP:Z!9$5(.&$+!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$M!K#$*$.+!<e-:Z!>*2)2J$+!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zro!@20=1$!5$3(/($%/,!1$.5+!&2!9.*J$51,!*$50/$5!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!/#$92J(%$+!1$)$1+!(%!+$*09!ZrY!

@(+/0++(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZqZ!W.&$*(.1+!.%5!9$&#25+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zqn!:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zqm!!:(<3+%&>5;5150&+06+!"#A8+<&'+%#"BA8+5&+%@5C(5@0'$%&'()*'+D.025<.5602@+4E5&+

%&63<@@<150&+5&+F5)*!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmn!P=+&*./&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmn!6%&*250/&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmr!:$+01&+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmm!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!>.*&(.11,!9$5(.&$+!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmm!40+&.(%$5!<,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zmo!<,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6-eP:Z!/2%&*(=0&$!&2!$>(5$*9.1!&#(/J$%(%8!50*(%8!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZmY!

Page 13: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

@$3(/($%/,!(%!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!1$.5+!&2!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zoj!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!.%5!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!(%!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zoj!

@(+/0++(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!Zon!W.&$*(.1+!.%5!9$&#25+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZoY!:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZYp!!G&5&1*&'*'+5&=*.150&+06+10-5)<3+5@5C(5@0'+5&+*?-*25@*&1<3+-.025<.5.$35E*+.E5&+

5&63<@@<150&+)<&+.E*H+2*.(31.!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZYo!P=+&*./&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!ZYo!<2>(/.11,!.>>1($5!(9(?0(925!(+!2*.11,!(%8$+&$5!50*(%8!$d>$*(9$%&+!.%5!.33$/&+!&#$!80&!DDDDDDDDD!ZYY!W.&$*(.1+!.%5!9$&#25+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!j[j!:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!j[r!;#.>&$*!6I!F!@(+/0++(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!j[m!Z!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/J!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!j[o!j!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!(%!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jZ[!p!'%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!(%!>+2*(.+(+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jZn!pDZ!6+!&#$*$!.!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+S!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jZn!pDj!g2K!$33$/&()$!(+!./&().&(2%!=,!<E:m!.82%(+&!6Ws!.+!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1!32*!>+2*(.+(+!(%!9(/$S!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jZY!

:$3$*$%/$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jjj!!F6#:2%*(L(U(A%<%*#8("4<"83='4<(V(?323*%(E%*=:%"2'M%=!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jjo!<,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&(2%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jjo!<#$*.>$0&(/!*$1$).%/$!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jjo!-0&0*$!C$*+>$/&()$+!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jjY!!S445$=23J(L(U(!8Q%&%%<(G%=83'2(V(94%J4&=2:%*=:%"2'%M%<!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpZ!<,>$!6!6-e$%!$%!<e-F8$9$5($$*5$!(%31.99.&($!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpZ!<#$*.>$0&(+/#$!*$1$).%&($!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpj!<2$J29+&>$*+>$/&($)$%!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpp!!F6#:2%*(L;(U(!$$%<$3&!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpr!;0**(/0109!I(&.$!Lynda Grine!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!jpr!

!

!! (

Page 14: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 1 of 237!

!"#$%&'%())*+,"($"&-#%!.% !

"#! "$%&#'()!

"*"! "+,-&./$!*/0%-',$%,-'1'2&./1!

"00'.&/%&'$!!

"34! ".5%,!6&($,)!&0.7,+&/!!

"1#! "1#5+&$!

"89! "1/$&$,!/+&$'%-/$0:,-/0,!

";<=! ".%&>/%'-!?-'%,&$<=!

";@! "$%&2,$!?-,0,$%&$2!.,11!

"AB! "C<-&.7!,1,+,$%0!!

"D9! "0?/-%/%,!/+&$'-/$0:,-/0,!

"948! "$%&<9EF<&$(5.,(!15?50!

! !

/% !

G8H! @IJG8KH!

GLML! G'$,<+/--'N!(,-&>,(!

+/.-'?7/2,0!

GD"! G'>&$,!0,-5+!/1#5+&$!

! !

0% !

@"AD! @'+?,$0/%'-)!/$%&<

&$:1/++/%'-)!-,0?'$0,!!

@/0?/0,! @)0%,&$,!/0?/-%&.!?-'%,/0,!

@@8! @7,+'6&$,!O*@!+'%&:P!1&2/$(!

@M! @150%,-!':!!(&::,-,$%&/%&'$Q!

.150%,-!':!(,0&2$/%&'$!'-!

.1/00&:&./%&'$!(,%,-+&$/$%!

@M! @-'7$R0!(&0,/0,!

.ME"! .'+?1,+,$%!ME"!

@FA! @/0,!:/%/1&%)!-/%,!

@4"! @'11/2,$<&$(5.,(!/-%7-&%&0!

@8;! @,./1!1&2/%&'$!?5$.%5-,!

@8A! @<%)?,!1,.%&$!-,.,?%'-!

@LS! @)%'+,2/1'>&-50!

@$:$! @'-$&:,1&$!

@ED! @,$%-/1!$,->'50!0)0%,+!

@;M! @7-'$&.!?-'1&:,-/%&>,!

(,-+/%&%&0!

@AM! @)0%,&$,<-&.7!('+/&$0!

@DF! @,-,#-'0?&$/1!:15&(!

! !

1% !

M"L;! M/+/2,!/00'.&/%,(!+'1,.51/-!

?/%%,-$!

M@! M,$(-&%&.!.,11!

MM! M,/%7!('+/&$!

MM0! M,+),1&$/%&$2!(&0'-(,-0!!

M4D@! M,/%7!&$(5.&$2!0&2$/1&$2!

.'+?1,T!!

M3U! M'5#1,!6$'.6'5%!

ML"AM

0!

M&0,/0,<+'(&:)&$2!/$%&<

-7,5+/%&.!(-520!!

MLDU! M&+,%7)1051':&T(,!

ME"! M,'T)-&#'$5.1,&.!/.&(!

MA! M,/%7!-,.,?%'-0!!

MDD! M,T%-/$!0'(&5+!051?7/%,!

! !

2% !

B"B! BT?,-&+,$%/1!/5%'&++5$,!

,$.,?7/1'+),1&%&0!

BGS! B?0%,&$<G/--!>&-50!

B@! B1&V/#,%7/$!.'11/-!

!"#$%&'# !()*+,')*'-#)%&'#

B84D"! B$V)+,<1&$6,(!

&++5$'0'-#,$%!/00/)!

BL! B1,.%-'$!L&.-'0.'?)!

BL"! B5-'?,/$!L,(&.&$,0!"2,$.)!!

BA! B$('?1/0+&.!-,%&.515+!

! !

3% !

F"MM! F/0</00'.&/%,(!(,/%7!('+/&$!!

FM"! F''(!/$(!(-52!/(+&$&0%-/%&'$!

FM@! F'11&.51/-!(,$(-&%&.!.,11!!

F49@! F15'-,0.,&$!&0'%7&'.)/$/%,!

! !

4% !

*"F! 4FEW</.%&>/%,(!:/.%'-!!

*"D! 4FE2/++/!/.%&>/%,(!0&%,!

*L<@DF! *-/$51'.)%,!+/.-'?7/2,!

.'1'$)!0%&+51/%&$2!:/.%'-!

! !

5% !

X@S! X,?/%&%&0!@!>&-50!

XYB! X,+/%'T)1&$!Y!,'0&$!

X4S! X5+/$!&++5$'(,:&.&,$.)!

>&50!

X;S! X5+/$!?/?&11'+/<>&-50!

XD;! X,/%!07'.6!?-'%,&$!

XCL4A

"!

X5+/$!+'$'.1'$/1!/$%&#'()!

&$!-7,5+/%'&(!/-%7-&%&0!

! !

6% !

Page 15: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 2 of 237!

"#$! "%&'())(*+,-!.+/0'!1230(30!

"456! "%*0,70''8'(,!(19032+%!

)+'078'0!

"4:! "%*0%32;0!7(,0!8%2*3!!

"<=! "%*0,&0,+%!

"<=5>?! "%*0,&0,+%@('A9(!,070A*+,!?!

38.8%2*!

"<=5>B! "%*0,&0,+%@('A9(!,070A*+,!B!

38.8%2*!

"C4! "))8%+923*+790)23*,-!

"D! "%*0,'08E2%!

"D@<5#F! "%*03*2%('!&(**-!(721!.2%12%G!

A,+*02%!

"6"$! "))8%0@)012(*01!

2%&'())(*+,-!1230(303!!

"6H! ")2I82)+1!

2JAJ! "%*,(A0,2*+%0('!

"F4! "%*0,&0,+%@K!A,+1872%G!70''!

"><! "<=!,0G8'(*+,-!&(7*+,!

"LM! "<=@3*2)8'(*01!G0%0!

"LM<N! "<=@3*2)8'(*01!G0%0!&(7*+,!N!!

"L>O! "%*0,&0,+%@30%32*2;0!,03A+%30!

0'0)0%*!

2J;J! "%*,(;0%+83!

";'! "%;+'87,2%!

! !

!" !

P5Q! P(%83!E2%(30!

P=Q! 7@P8%!*0,)2%('!E2%(30!

! !

#" !

Q! Q0,(*2%!

Q4! Q0,(*2%+7-*0!7-*+E2%0!

E$(! Q2'+!$('*+%!

Q,*R.! Q0,(*2%R.!

QS! Q%+7E+8*!

! !

$" !

D4! D(%G0,9(%3!70''!

D+,! D+,27,2%!

DFL! D2A+A+'-3(779(,210!

! !

%" !

)! 60).,(%0@.+8%1!

)5.! 6+%+7'+%('!(%*2.+1-!

64F@?! 6+%+7-*0!790)+!(**,(7*(%*!

A,+*02%!?!

6$L4! 6-0'+21@10,2;01!38AA,033+,!

70''!

6C4! 6(T+,!923*+7+)A(*2.2'2*-!

7+)A'0U!

6"F! 6(7,+A9(G0!2%&'())(*+,-!

A,+*02%!

6S<! 68'*2A'0@+,G(%!&(2'8,0!!

)>=5! 60330%G0,!>=5!

6L! 68'*2A'0!37'0,+323!

)V=<! 60).,(%0@.+8%1!V=<!

6VW! 60*9+*,0U(*0!

6X! 6+'078'(,!/02G9*!

6U! 6-U+;2,83!,0323*(%70!!

6-$YY! 6-0'+21!12&&0,0%*2(*2+%!

A,2)(,-@,03A+%30!A,+*02%!YY!!

! !

&" !

=(4'! L+128)!79'+,-10!

=.! =(%+.+1-!

=<@E#! =87'0(,!&(7*+,!E(AA(!#!

="4O! =(*2+%('!"%3*2*8*0!&+,!C0('*9!

(%1!4'2%27('!OUA0,20%70!

=Q! =(*8,('!E2''0,!!

=D>! =S$@'2E0!,070A*+,!

=S! =2*,27!+U210!

! !

'" !

F56F! F(*9+G0%@(33+72(*01!

)+'078'(,!A(**0,%!

F5L"! F3+,2(323!5,0(!L0;0,2*-!"%10U!!

F#L! F9+3A9(*0!.8&&0,01!3('2%0!

F4>! F+'-)0,(30!79(2%!,0(7*2+%!

A$4! F'(3)(7-*+21!10%1,2*27!70''!

FOM! F+'-0*9-'0%0!G'-7+'!

F<5! F(,(&+,)('109-10!

F"NQ! F9+3A9(*21-'2%+32*210!N!E2%(30!

FD<! F0,2*+%0('!'(;(G0!&'821!

F>>! F(**0,%!,07+G%2*2+%!,070A*+,!

F35! F3+,2(*27!(,*9,2*23!

F3Z! F3+,2(323!;8'G(,23!!

! !

(" !

IF4>! H8(%*2*(*2;0!F4>!

I>V@

F4>!

H8(%*2*(*2;0!>0('!V2)0!F4>!

! !

)" !

>5! >908)(*+21!(,*9,2*23!

>#4! >01!.'++1!70''!

Page 16: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 3 of 237!

"#"! "$%&$&'()*!+*,*-./+!

"01! "(2/34,'*(,!5,(6!

"78! "*5,.(9*!/:;<*3!=-*,(*=!

"">8! "*'5-=(3<&+*?(..(3<!>8!

"@! "//?!.*?-*+5.4+*!

! !

!" !

=! 8/'42'*!

8A$B! 8*9*+*!,/?2(3*6!

(??43/6*C(,(*3,;!

8B! 8.5365+6!6*9(5.(/3!

8D>! 8.5365+6!*++/+!/C!?*53!

=%A! 8/'42'*!<453;'5.*!,;,'5=*!!

8$"8! 8;=.*?(,!(3C'5??5./+;!

+*=-/3=*!=;36+/?*!

8#D! 8;=.*?(,!'4-4=!*+;.E*?5./=4=!!

80F! 8(3<'*!34,'*/.(6*!

-/';?/+-E(=?!

88! 8GH<+*3=I!=;36+/?*!!

8@1@! 8(<35'!.+53=64,*+!536!

5,.(95./+!/C!.+53=,+(-.(/3!

! !

#" !

@1AD! @0J&K&,/39*+.(3<!*3L;?*!!

@M! @42*+,4'/=(=!

@A"! @&,*''!+*,*-./+!

@%J! @+53=C/+?(3<!<+/N.E!C5,./+!

@E! @&E*'-*+!

@OB! @0J!E/?/'/<;!6/?5(3!

@#"! @/''&'()*!+*,*-./+!

.?@0J! @+53=?*?2+53*!@0J!

@0J! @4?/+!0*,+/=(=!J5,./+!

@0J"P! @0J!+*,*-./+!P!

@0J"Q! @0J!+*,*-./+!Q!

@F1! @*.+56*,53/;'-E/+2/'&PR&

5,*.5.*!!

@"1J! @0J!+*,*-./+!5==/,(5.*6!

C5,./+=!

@"$J! @$"&6/?5(3&,/3.5(3(3<!

565-./+!-+/.*(3!(364,(3<!$J0S!!

@+*<! "*<4'5./+;!@!,*''!

! !

$" !

TA! T',*+5.(9*!,/'(.(=!

T@"! T3.+53='5.*6!+*<(/3!

TU! T'.+59(/'*.!

! !

%" !

UA1>! U5=,4'5+!,*''!56E*=(/3!

?/'*,4'*!

UD%J! U5=,4'5+!*36/.E*'(5'!<+/N.E!

C5,./+!

! !

&" !

VMA! VE(.*!2'//6!,*''!

V@! V('6!.;-*!

!

Page 17: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 4 of 237

!"#$%&'()(F!!"#"$%&'(#)$*+,-).*#!

-(96%(;&&3<%(=)=2%&(#<$('<58#&&#2'4<(

<#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!(+!.!901&(F1.,$*$5!5$3$%+$!9$/#.%(+9!&#.&!>*2&$/&+!&#$!#2+&+!5.(1,!3*29!

(%&*05$*+! .%5! $d&*$9$! /2%5(&(2%+D! 6&+! /29>2%$%&+M! (990%$! /$11+M! /,&2J(%$+! .%5! .%&(=25($+M!

./&!2%!).*(20+!1$)$1+!&2!$1(/(&!.!*$+>2%+$!&2!>.&#28$%(/!+&(901(D!<#(+!>*2/$++!23!(%31.99.&(2%!

%$$5+!&2!=$!K$11!=.1.%/$5!(%!2*5$*!&2!9(%(9(R$!5.9.8$!&2!&#$!#2+&!&(++0$!=0&!+(901&.%$20+1,!

./&!+&*2%8!$%208#!&2!/1$.*!&#$!#.R.*520+!+&(9010+D!6%31.99.&(2%!(+!.!&(8#&1,!*$801.&$5!>*2/$++!

.%5! (+! /#.*./&$*(+$5! =,! 3()$! /1.++(/.1! +(8%+A! *$5%$++! a5#L"5VM! +K$11(%8! a)#0"5VM! #$.&! a+/."5VM!

>.(%!a7"."5V!.%5!12++!23!30%/&(2%!a-#(+)*"&./%$/VDZ!P+!9$%&(2%$5!.=2)$M!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!(+!

901&(F1.,$*$5!./&(%8!2%!+$)$*.1!1$)$1+!(%!&#$!=25,!.%5!(+!23!50.1!%.&0*$!2%!+$)$*.1!1$)$1+D!(D!6&!

/.%! 5(+&(%80(+#! =$&K$$%! +$13! .%5! %2%F+$13M! .112K(%8! *$/28%(&(2%! 23! 32*$(8%! 921$/01$+! .%5!

&21$*.%/$! 23! &#$! =25,c+! /29>2%$%&+D! ((D! 6&! (+! .=1$! &2! *$+>2%5! 3.+&! 50$! &2! &#$! (%%.&$! (990%$!

+,+&$9M!=0&!/.%!$.+(1,!.5.>&!)(.!&#$!.5.>&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!(((D!@$3$%+$!.%5!/2990%(/.&(2%!

.*$!/.**($5!20&!=,!/$11+M!=0&!.1+2!)(.!&#$!#092*.1!>.&#K.,D! ()D!7.**($*+!+0/#!.+!&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!

1(%(%8!23!+J(%!.%5!80&!./&!.+!>#,+(/.1!.%5!/#$9(/.1!=.**($*+M!>*$)$%&(%8!$%&*.%/$!23!>.&#28$%(/!

+&(901(D!70&!/$11+!23!&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!1(%(%8+!/.%!.1+2!+$/*$&$!.%&(9(/*2=(.1!>*2&$(%+!.%5!5$3$%+()$!

$%R,9$+!2*!*$/*0(&! (990%$!/$11+! &2!./&()$1,! 3(8#&!233! (%&*05$*+!.%5!2&#$*!#.R.*520+!+&(901(D!

<#$+$!>*2/$++$+!.*$!&(8#&1,!*$801.&$5!.%5!&#$*$32*$!./#($)$!.!#(8#!1$)$1!23!/29>1$d(&,!(%!2*5$*!

&2!5$&$/&!.%5!$1(9(%.&$!(%G0*(20+!+&(901(D!g2K$)$*M!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!(+!.1+2!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!

%.&0*.1!#29$2+&.+(+!23!&#$!=25,D!6&!(+!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!/1$.*(%8!5$.5!2*!K2*%!20&!/$11+!+0/#!.+!

*$5!=1225!/$11+!a:7;VM!&#$!(5$%&(3(/.&(2%!.%5!*$92).1!23!.=%2*9.1!/$11+!+0/#!.+!/.%/$*20+!/$11+!

.%5! *$G$/&+! &(++0$+! /$11+! 3*29! 32*$(8%! .%&(8$%+D!L#$%! &#$! (990%$! +,+&$9! 3.(1+! &2! $1(/(&! &#$!

/2**$/&! *$+>2%+$M! &#(+! /.%! *$+01&! (%! +$)$*$! (%3$/&(2%+!2*! /.%/$*D! 6%! /.+$!23! $d./$*=.&(2%M! &#$!

Page 18: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 5 of 237

(%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$!./&+!.8.(%+&! &#$!#2+&D! 6%! /#*2%(/! +(&0.&(2%+M! .0&2(990%(&,!2*!.11$*8,!

5$)$12>+! .%5! &#$! #2+&! .&&./J+! (&+$13M! =0&! (&! /.%! .1+2! 2//0*! 92*$! ./0&$1,! .%5! 1$.5! &2! +#2/J!

+,%5*29$+!+0/#!.+!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!+,%5*29$!a46:4V!2*!+$>+(+D!<#$+$!$)$%&+!

K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!1.&$*!(%!92*$!5$&.(1D!

!

?'Q3*%(-D(I3#8(<#23*%(45(26%(&#&&#8'#<('&&3<%(=)=2%&(

<#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!/2%+(+&+!23!.%!(%%.&$!.%5!.5.>&()$!*$+>2%+$D!<#$!(%%.&$!(990%$!+,+&$9!/.%!=$!/.&$82*(R$5!(%!>.++()$!=.**($*+!.%5!./&()$!(%&$*%.1!5$3$%+$+M!K#$*$.+!&#$!.5.>&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9!/2%+(+&+!23!.!/$1101.*!.%5!#092*.1!5$3$%+$!*$+>2%+$D!!

!<#$!(990%$!+,+&$9c+!50.1!%.&0*$!23!(%%.&$!.%5!.5.>&()$!*$+>2%+$!.112K+!32*!8*$.&!31$d(=(1(&,D!

72&#! 9$/#.%(+9+! 0+$! &#$! 5(+/*(9(%.&(2%! =$&K$$%! +$13! .%5! %2%F+$13D! -(80*$! Z! +#2K+! .!

+/#$9.&(/! *$>*$+$%&.&(2%! 23! =2&#! +,+&$9+! .%5! &#$(*! $33$/&2*+D! <#$! (%%.&$! +,+&$9! 0+$+!

*$/$>&2*+!&#.&!*$/28%(+$!921$/01.*!>.&&$*%+M!&,>(/.1!32*!=./&$*(.!.%5!)(*0+$+M!+0/#!.+!>*2&$(%+!

$d>*$++$5!2%! &#$!/$1101.*!K.11!2*!+(%81$F+&*.%5$5!@eP!2*!:ePM!K#(/#!.*$!%2&!+#.*$5!=,! &#$!

#2+&! =0&! .*$! $++$%&(.1! a.%5! &#0+! *.&#$*! /2%+$*)$5V! 32*! &#$! 1(3$! 23! &#$+$! 9(/*2=$+D! <,>(/.1!

>.&&$*%!*$/28%(&(2%!*$/$>&2*+!aC::+V!(%/105$!<211FE(J$!:$/$>&2*+!a<E:+V!ZFZZM!;F&,>$!E$/&(%!

!"#$%&$'()

*+,')-#,"./,#)

!0%/)!1-2+$#)

3+--%#-,)

4551/#)

,(,'#5)

4//+'#)%551/#)

,(,'#5)

67+"89#)

%551/#)

,(,'#5)

4/'#-/+:)

7#2#/,#)

;#::1:+-)

7#2#/,#)

<15.-+:)

7#2#/,#)

=1$.1,)

5#53-+/#,)

*#9#-)

4/>+55+8./)

6/85%$-.3%+:)

"-.'#%/,)

?)$#::,)

@+/83.7%#,A)

B)$#::,)

Page 19: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 6 of 237

:$/$>&2*+! a;E:+VM! eQ@F1(J$! :$/$>&2*+! aeE:+V! .%5! :6"F6F1(J$! :$/$>&2*! a:E:+VjD! 429$! .*$!

9$9=*.%$F=20%5M! 2&#$*+! *$+(5$! (%! &#$! /,&2>1.+9M! *$.5,! &2! +$%+$! 32*$(8%! .%&(8$%+D! Q%/$!

./&().&$5! &#*208#! (%&$*./&(2%! K(&#! %2%F+$13! 921$/01$+M! &#$+$! *$/$>&2*+! +(8%.1! &#*208#!

/29>1$d! /.+/.5$+M! &*(88$*(%8! .%! (990%$! *$+>2%+$D! -2*&0%.&$1,M! &#$! (%%.&$! +,+&$9! /.%! ./&!

*.>(51,!.%5!&#$*$32*$!9.J$+!0>!&#$!(%(&(.1!#2+&!*$+>2%+$D!g2K$)$*M!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!.1+2!

./&+!>.++()$1,!.%5!/2%&(%020+1,!&#*208#!&#$!0+$!23!>#,+(/.1!=.**($*+D!<#(+!(%/105$+!+$/*$&(2%!

23!90/0+! &2! >*$)$%&! (%).+(2%! 23! 32*$(8%! .%&(8$%+D! '%5$*%$.&#M! .! +$/2%5! =.**($*! (+! >*$+$%&M!

+0/#!.+!&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!1(%(%8!23!2*8.%+!9.5$!0>!=,!&#$!&(8#&!G0%/&(2%+!=$&K$$%!/$11+D!<,>(/.1!32*!

=2&#!=.**($*+!(+!&#$(*!=*($3!$d(+&$%/$M!.+!&#$!90/0+!(+!/2%&(%020+1,!*$%$K$5M!.+!.*$!&#$!/$11+!23!

&#$! $>(&#$1(.1! 1(%(%8+D! P! &#(*5! 9$/#.%(+9! /2%+(+&+! 23! =(2./&()$! 921$/01$+! *$+(5(%8! (%! &#$!

$d&*./$1101.*!9.&*(d!.%5!(%!&#$!/$11+M!K#(/#!K(11!+$/*$&$!&#$+$!0>2%!./&().&(2%D!<#$+$!=(2./&()$!

921$/01$+!.*$!$D8D!/29>1$9$%&!>*2&$(%+M!5$3$%+(%+M!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!/#$92J(%$+!.%5!/.%!.1+2!=$!

320%5!(%!=25(1,! 310(5+!+0/#!.+!&$.*+M!0*(%$!.%5!+.1().D!<#$! (%%.&$! (990%$!+,+&$9!(+!&#0+!&#$!

3(*+&! .%5! +$/2%5! 1(%$! 23! 5$3$%+$M! >*$)$%&(%8! $%&*,! 23! >.&#28$%+! &#*208#! =.**($*+M! =0&! .1+2!

.)2(5(%8!+>*$.5!23!&#$!>.&#28$%D!!

<#$! (%%.&$! (990%$!+,+&$9! (+! (%=2*%!.%5!./&+! *.&#$*!.+>$/(3(/D!Q%/$! &#$!=.**($*!#.+!=*2J$%!

.%5!&#$!>.&#28$%!#.+!+>*$.5M!&#$!#2+&!K(11!$1(/(&!.!92*$!+>$/(3(/!*$+>2%+$M!K#(/#!K(11!*$?0(*$!

92*$!&(9$!=0&!K(11!.1+2!>*2)(5$!12%8&$*9!(990%(&,!.3&$*!$%/20%&$*+M!/.11$5!9$92*,D!<#(+!(+!

&#$! .5.>&()$! (990%$! +,+&$9D! 6&! (+! >*(9.*(1,! ./?0(*$5! .%5! +>$/(3(/M! .%5! /2%+(+&+! 23! 7! /$11+M!

K#(/#!9$5(.&$! &#$!#092*.1!*$+>2%+$M!K#$*$.+!<!/$11+!>$*32*9!&#$!/$11F9$5(.&$5!*$+>2%+$+D!

<#$+$!K(11!5*()$! &.*8$&$5!$33$/&2*!*$+>2%+$+! (%!j!+&.8$+D!P! 32*$(8%!.%&(8$%! (+! 3(*+&!>(/J$5!0>!

.%5!>*$+$%&$5!=,!.%!.%&(8$%F>*$+$%&(%8!/$11!aPC;V!=,!/29>1$d(%8!&#$!.%&(8$%!K(&#!&#$(*!9.G2*!

#(+&2/29>.&(=(1(&,!/29>1$d!aWg;V!2%!&#$!+0*3./$D!<#$+$!/29>1$d$+!.*$!&#$%!*$/28%(R$5!=,!<!

/$11+! .%5! &#$(*!<F/$11! *$/$>&2*! a<;:VD!'+0.11,! &#(+!>*2/$++!23! .%&(8$%F/$11! >*$+$%&.&(2%! &.J$+!

>1./$! (%!.!+>$/(.1(R$5!$%)(*2%9$%&!23! &#$! 1,9>#2(5!&(++0$D!-011!./&().&(2%!23!<!/$11+!*$?0(*$+!

92*$! &#.%! <;:! ./&().&(2%D! <! /$11+! $d>*$++! >*2&$(%+! &#.&! K(11! (%&$*./&! K(&#! 2&#$*!921$/01$+!

Page 20: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 7 of 237

&*.%+9(&&(%8! .! /2F+&(901.&2*,! +(8%.1! &2! &#$! <! /$11! 32*! /29>1$&$! ./&().&(2%D! ;2F+&(901.&2*,!

+(8%.1+! .*$! 8$%$*.&$5! =,! $(&#$*! (%&$*./&(2%! 23! ;@jo! 2%! &#$! <! /$11! K(&#! ;@o[! 2*! ;@oq! a7m!

3.9(1,V!2*!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!<!/$11F*$+(5(%8!;@n[E!K(&#!;@n[!2%!&#$!PC;!1$.5(%8!&2!/$11!

>*(9(%8M! ./&().&(2%! .%5! +0=+$?0$%&1,! &2!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%DpMn!7! /$11+! /.%! .1+2! 8$&! ./&().&$5! (%! .!

+(9(1.*!K.,! .%5!K(11! *$1$.+$! .%&(=25($+! (%&2! &#$! =1225! +&*$.9! &2! 3(8#&! 233! &#$! (%&*05$*D! <#$!

./&().&$5!/$11+!K(11!.1+2!+&.*&!>*21(3$*.&(2%! &2!$%+0*$!.%!.5$?0.&$!%09=$*!23!/$11+! &2!/29=.&!

(%3$/&(2%D! 6%! &#(+! >#.+$! 23! &#$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$M! /#$92J(%$+! .%5! /,&2J(%$+! .*$! .1+2! 0+$5!

)(82*20+1,! =,! /$11+! &2! /2990%(/.&$! .! +&.&$! 23! $9$*8$%/,! .%5! >0+#! &#$! (990%$! +,+&$9! (%!

/$*&.(%! 5(*$/&(2%+D! ;,&2J(%$+! .*$! +210=1$! 3./&2*+! .%5! (%/105$! /#$92J(%$+M! 6%&$*3$*2%+! a6-eVM!

6%&$*1$0J(%+! a6EVM! .%5! 1,9>#2J(%$+D! <#$,! /.%! =$! >*250/$5! =,! .! ).*($&,! 23! /$11+M! (%/105(%8!

(990%$!/$11+!+0/#!.+!9./*2>#.8$+M!%$0&*2>#(1+M!7!.%5!<!1,9>#2/,&$+M!9.+&!/$11+M!$%52&#$1(.1!

/$11+M! 3(=*2=1.+&+! .%5! 9.%,! 2&#$*! /$11! &,>$+D! ;,&2J(%$+! =(%5! &#$(*! *$+>$/&()$! *$/$>&2*!

/29>1$d$+! 2%! &#$! +0*3./$+! 23! &#$! *$/(>($%&! /$11+M! 1$.5(%8! &2! +0=+$?0$%&! /.+/.5$+! 23!

(%&*./$1101.*! +(8%.1(%8D! <#$! $33$/&! 23! .! >.*&(/01.*! /,&2J(%$! 2%! .! /$*&.(%! /$11! &,>$! +&*2%81,!

5$>$%5+!2%!+$)$*.1!.+>$/&+D!(D!<#$!/,&2J(%$!(&+$13!*$>*$+$%&+!.!+&.&$!23!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9M!(&!

9.,! $%#.%/$! 2*! (%#(=(&! (%31.99.&(2%M! =$(%8! >*2F! 2*! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,M! *$+>$/&()$1,U! ((D! <#$!

.=0%5.%/$!23! &#$!/,&2J(%$!9.,!.1&$*! &#$! &*.%+9(&&$5!9$++.8$M!$d/$$5(%8!/$*&.(%! &#*$+#215+!

K(11!=$!23! (9>2*&.%/$!.+!K$11U! (((D!<#$!.=0%5.%/$!23! &#$! *$+>$/&()$! *$/$>&2*!/29>1$d!2%! &#$!

+0*3./$! 23! .! /$11! /.%! .1+2! (%310$%/$! &#$! $33$/&! 23! .! /,&2J(%$U! ()D! 1.+&M! =0&! %2&! 1$.+&M! &#$!

9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&! 23! .! /$11! K(11! .1+2! 5$&$*9(%$! &#$! 3011! *.%8$! 23! &#$! /,&2J(%$c+! $33$/&D!

;,&2J(%$+!>1.,!.!9.G2*!*21$!(%!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!.%5!>*$/(+$!*$801.&(2%!(+!*$?0(*$5!&2!.)2(5!

9.130%/&(2%!23!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!6&!/29$+!.+!%2!+0*>*(+$!&#.&!K#$%!&#(+!*$801.&(2%!#.+!82%$!

.K*,M!/,&2J(%$+!9.,!./&0.11,!9$5(.&$!>.&#2128($+!+0/#!.+!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+M!.11$*8(/!*$./&(2%+!

.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!

Page 21: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 8 of 237

+(F)24J'<%=(

H1.=2*.&$!+&05($+!#.)$!*$)$.1$5!&#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!/,&2J(%$+!.+!9$5(.&2*+!23!>.&#2128($+!.%5!

%09$*20+!/,&2J(%$+!#.)$!.1*$.5,!=$$%!).1(5.&$5!.+!&#$*.>$0&(/!&.*8$&+D!;,&2J(%$+!.*$!+9.11!

>*2&$(%!9$++$%8$*+! .%5! /.%! =$! /1.++(3($5! (%! +0>$*3.9(1($+M! +#.*(%8! +$?0$%/$! +(9(1.*(&,! .%5!

+29$!#292128,!(%!&#$(*!*$/(>*2/.1!*$/$>&2*!/29>1$d$+D!<#$(*!%29$%/1.&0*$!(+!>*(9.*(1,!=.+$5!

2%!&#$(*!30%/&(2%.1!./&()(&,!a$D8D!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!a<e-VVM!&#$!%09$*(/!2*5$*!23!5(+/2)$*,!

a$D8D! 6%&$*1$0J(%! a6EVFZFpqVM! &#$(*! /$11! 23! 2*(8(%! ai$*.&(%2/,&$F5$*()$5! ;#$92J(%$M! %2K.5.,+!

/.11$5!;O;EZV!2*!2%!&#$!+&*0/&0*.1!+$?0$%/$!.+>$/&+!+0/#!.+!;F;!.%5!;FOF;!$1$9$%&+!320%5!(%!

;;E!.%5!;O;ED!!

;,&2J(%$!+(8%.1(%8!/.%!=$!$d$/0&$5!=,!.!).*($&,!23!*$/$>&2*+!+0/#!.+!>*2&$(%!&,*2+(%$!2*!+$*(%$!

J(%.+$!*$/$>&2*+!&#.&!#.)$!(%&*(%+(/!J(%.+$!./&()(&,M!*$/$>&2*+!K(&#20&!(%&*(%+(/!J(%.+$!./&()(&,M!

"F>*2&$(%! /20>1$5! *$/$>&2*+! .%5! (2%F8.&$5! *$/$>&2*+D! g2K$)$*M! &#$! *$/$>&2*+! K(&#20&!

(%&*(%+(/! J(%.+$! ./&()(&,! *$>*$+$%&! &#$! +0>$*3.9(1,! 23! /,&2J(%$! *$/$>&2*+M! K#(/#! (+! .!

#$&$*28$%$20+! 8*20>D! <,>(/.11,M! /,&2J(%$! *$/$>&2*+! .*$! /1.++(3($5! .+! &#$! 32112K(%8A! &,>$! 6!

/,&2J(%$! *$/$>&2*! a6EFjM! pM! nM! rM! qM! mM! YM! ZZM! ZjM! ZpM! ZrM!"WF;4-! .%5!"F;4-VU! &,>$! 66! /,&2J(%$!

*$/$>&2*+! a&,>$! 6! .%5! 66! (%&$*3$*2%+VM! /#$92J(%$! *$/$>&2*+M! <e-! +0>$*3.9(1,! *$/$>&2*+M!

&*.%+32*9(%8! 8*2K&#! 3./&2*! *$/$>&2*+M! .%5! (990%2812=01(%! +0>$*3.9(1,! .%5! .*$! 1(+&$5! (%!

<.=1$! Z!K(&#! &#$(*! 1(8.%5+! .%5! +&*0/&0*$DrMq! <#$!92+&! J%2K%! /,&2J(%$F+(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,! (+!

/.11$5!&#$!N.%0+!J(%.+$!aN.JVF4(8%.1!<*.%+50/$*!.%5!P/&().&2*!23!<*.%+/*(>&(2%!a4&.&V!>.&#K.,!

a-(80*$! jVD! 6%! +#2*&M! &#$! /,&2J(%$! =(%5+! &2! (&+! /28%.&$! *$/$>&2*M! K#(/#!K(11! ./&().&$! &#$! N.J!

>*2&$(%+D!<#$! /,&2>1.+9(/!529.(%!23! &#$! *$/$>&2*! (+!>#2+>#2*,1.&$5! .%5!#$*$=,!>*2)(5$+! .!

52/J(%8! +(&$! 32*! 4&.&! >*2&$(%+D! <#$*$! .*$! +$)$%! 9$9=$*+M! 4&.&ZM! 4&.&jM! 4&.&pM! 4&.&nM! 4&.&r.M!

4&.&r=!.%5!4&.&qD!'>2%!>#2+>#2*,1.&(2%M!&#$+$!K(11!9(8*.&$!&2!&#$!%0/1$0+!.%5!=(%5!&2!@eP!&2!

(%(&(.&$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%Dm!<#$!>*2/$++(%8!23!/,&2J(%$+!2//0*+!(%!&#$!"218(!.%5!&#$,!9.,!&#$*$.3&$*!

=$!*$1$.+$5!.+!+210=1$!3./&2*+!2*!*$9.(%!9$9=*.%$F=20%5!.&!&#$!/$11!+0*3./$D!Q&#$*!K.,+!&2!

Page 22: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 9 of 237

*$./#! &#$(*! 5$+&(%.&(2%! (+! &#*208#! (%&*./$1101.*! &*.33(/! (%! /,&2+21(/! 32*9! 2*! 9(8*.&$! &2! &#$!

%0/1$0+! &2! ./&! .+! &*.%+/*(>&(2%! 3./&2*+D! <#$(*! $d>*$++(2%! (+! *$801.&$5! &#*208#! ).*(20+!

9$/#.%(+9+M! (%/105(%8! /$11F/$11! /2%&./&M! (990%$! /29>1$d$+! (%/105(%8! .0&2.%&(=25($+M!

/29>1$9$%&! ./&().&(2%M! 9(/*2=(.1! +>$/($+! 2*! >.&#28$%F.++2/(.&$5! 921$/01.*! >.&&$*%!

921$/01$+!aCPWC+VM!(%&$*9$5(.&$!32*9+!23!%(&*28$%!.%5!*$./&()$!2d,8$%M!&*.09.M!(+/#$9(.M!!

9#G8%(-D(F8#=='5'"#2'4<(45(")24J'<%(*%"%:24*=(K'26(8'Q#<$=(#<$(=2*3"23*%(

!

M"#5+%N&M*("&6*"."8*+/.&,(+O&P?9)"B*(%&5%+%4)"5&-/0*.9:&$*8(/.*(8&/(7&7*$%/$%&);%5/4%#)*+&)/58%)*(8QR&

!

!"#$$%&'%!()&*+,-%

.-/-0)&.$%12#30"-$% 4).5/)5.-%

!"#$%&%'"()*+,$%

-$.$#()-/%0! 123'45%-$.$#()-%

0! 13'45%-$.$#()-%

0! !"#$%&%&6%-$.$#()-/%

0! 7#)%-$.$#()-%

0! '8!5%-$.$#()-%

0! !9:%-$.$#()-%

0! '$-(;+,%.),/$-<$=%>)(+?/%+,%(@$+-%

$A(-;.$BBCB;-%;>+,)3;.+=%=)>;+,D%

0! 82E%/(-C.(C-$%)?%(@$%B+F;,=%G+,=+,F%

=)>;+,%)?%(@$%.)>>),%G$(;%.@;+,%+,%(@$%

123'45H%&63I%;,=%&63J%-$.$#()-/KD%

'),,$.($=%()%LMN%?;>+B"%)?%("-)/+,$%

*+,;/$/D%

!"#$%&&%'"()*+,$%

-$.$#()-/%0! &583;B#@;%E$.$#()-%

O&58MEP%Q%&58MERK%

0! &583G$(;%E$.$#()-%

0! &583F;>>;%E$.$#()-%

O&581EP%Q%&581ERK%

0! !"#$%&&%&6%E$.$#()-/%

0! '$-(;+,%.),/$-<$=%>)(+?/%+,%(@$+-%

$A(-;.$BBCB;-%;>+,)3;.+=%=)>;+,D%

0! 82E%/(-C.(C-$%)?%(@$%+,($-?$-),%G+,=+,F%

$.()=)>;+,%)?%(@$%@C>;,%+,($-?$-),%

-$.$#()-KD%'),,$.($=%()%LMN%?;>+B"%)?%

("-)/+,$%*+,;/$/D%

'@$>)*+,$%-$.$#()-/%0! ''%'@$>)*+,$%E$.$#()-/%

0! 'S'%'@$>)*+,$%E$.$#()-/%

0! 'SI'%'@$>)*+,$%

E$.$#()-/%

0! S'%'@$>)*+,$%E$.$#()-/%

0! ')>>),%>)(+?%)?%/$<$,%(-;,/>$>G-;,$%

@$B+AD%

0! 82E%/(-C.(C-$%)?%(@$%'S'EI%T+,=+,F%

'@$>)*+,$%&93PU%V%'S'6PUKD%')C#B$%()%

13#-)($+,%?)-%/+F,;B%(-;,/=C.(+),D%

!85%-$.$#()-/%

/C#$-?;>+B"%0! !85E45J%V%'WXU%

0! !85E45Y%V%'WIU%

0! !85E45Z%V%'WRZ%

0! !85E45PM%V%!85EP%V%

'WPRU;%

0! !85E45PT%V%!85ER%V%

'WPRUG%

0! '"/($+,$3-+.@%.)>>),%$.()=)>;+,%)?%

!85ED%

0! '-"/(;B%/(-C.(C-$%)?%(@$%/)BCGB$%@C>;,%

JJ%*=%!85%-$.$#()-%;,=%@C>;,%!853

G$(;%.)>#B$AD%

!153G$(;%-$.$#()-/%0! !153G$(;%E$.$#()-%P%

0! !153G$(;%E$.$#()-%R%

0! 4$-+,$V(@-$),+,$%#-)($+,%*+,;/$D%

0! !-;,/?)->+,F%1-)[(@%5;.()-%T$(;%("#$%

&&%-$.$#()-%B+F;,=%G+,=+,F%=)>;+,D%

&>>C,)FB)GCB+,%

/C#$-?;>+B"%0! &,($-B$C*+,3P%E$.$#()-/%

0! '453PE%

0! 9W15E%O9W15EM%Q%

9W15ETK%

0! 4'5E%

0! 4@;-$%/(-C.(C-;B%@)>)B)F"%[+(@%

+>>C,)FB)GCB+,/%O;,(+G)=+$/K%

0! 4(-C.(C-;B%=$($->+,;,(/%)?%(@$%8\7E5%

+,($-;.(+),%[+(@%G$(;R3ME%;,=%9W15EKD%

Page 23: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 10 of 237

*.5(.&(2%M!01&*.)(21$&!1(8#&!a'IVM!9.99.1(.%!2*!9(/*2=(.1!@eP!.%5!#$.&!+#2/J!>*2&$(%+!ag4C+VD!

Q3&$%! /,&2J(%$+! &#$9+$1)$+! K(11! (%(&(.&$! .%! .0&2/*(%$! 122>! 1$.5(%8! &2! $d>*$++(2%! 23! 2&#$*!

/,&2J(%$+D! <*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! *$801.&(2%! 23! /,&2J(%$+! 23&$%! (%)21)$+! &K2! >()2&.1! &*.%+/*(>&(2%!

3./&2*+A!%0/1$.*! 3./&2*!t!7! ae-Ft7V!.%5!./&().&2*!>*2&$(%FZ!aPCFZVD!g2K$)$*M! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!

*$801.&(2%!&#*208#!&*.%+/*(>&(2%! 3./&2*+! (+!%2&! &#$!2%1,!K.,!&2!*$801.&$!/,&2J(%$!$d>*$++(2%!

.%5! ./&()(&,D! ;,&2J(%$+! /.%! =$! >2+&F&*.%+/*(>&(2%.11,! *$801.&$5! =,! .33$/&(%8!9:eP! +&.=(1(&,D!

<#$! +&.=(1(&,! 23! /,&2J(%$! 9:eP! 5$>$%5+! 2%! &#$! P'F*(/#! $1$9$%&+! aP:H+V! (%! &#$(*! rc! 2*! pc!

0%&*.%+1.&$5!*$8(2%+!a'<:+VD!P%!(%&*(80(%8!$d.9>1$!23!&#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!&#$+$!P:H+!(+!320%5!

(%! .! &*.%+8$%(/! 920+$! +&*.(%! 1./J(%8! &#$! P:H! (%! <e-U! &#$+$! 9(/$! 5$)$12>! +>2%&.%$20+1,!

.*&#*(&(+M! /./#$d(.M! .%&(F@eP! .%&(=25($+! .%5! (%31.99.&2*,! =2K$1! 5(+$.+$! a67@VDY! 6&! #.+! =$!

320%5! &#.&! &#$!pc!'<:! (%!<e-!9:eP! (+! /*0/(.1! 32*! (&+!52K%*$801.&(2%M!K#(/#!*$+01&+! (%!#(8#!

1$)$1+!23!<e-!(%!&#$+$!9(/$!*$+01&(%8!(%!.%!.0&2(990%$!>#$%2&,>$D!!

!?'Q3*%(+D(1"6%&#2'"(4M%*M'%K(45(P!OW19!9(='Q<#8'<Q(:#26K#)(

W2+&!/,&2J(%$+!0+$!&#$!N.%0+!J(%.+$!aN.JVF4(8%.1!<*.%+50/$*!.%5!P/&().&2*!23!<*.%+/*(>&(2%!a4&.&V!>.&#K.,D! 7(%5(%8! 23! &#$! /,&2J(%$! 1(8.%5! a5(.92%5V! &2! (&+! *$/$>&2*! &*(88$*+! >#2+>#2*,1.&(2%! 23!.++2/(.&$5! N.J! >*2&$(%+! a1(8#&! 8*$,! /(*/1$+V! .%5! *$/*0(&! 4<P<! >*2&$(%! &2! &#$! 52/J(%8! +(&$D!C#2+>#2*,1.&$5! 4<P<! >*2&$(%+! 5(9$*(R$! .%5! +0=+$?0$%&1,! &*.)$1! &2! &#$! %0/1$0+! .%5! ./&! .+!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*+D!!

!

P%2&#$*! 9$/#.%(+9! 23! *$801.&(2%! (+! >2+&F&*.%+1.&(2%.1! 925(3(/.&(2%U! &#(+! /.%! (%/105$!

>*2&$21,&(/!/1$.).8$M!K#(/#!(+!$9>12,$5!=,!6EFZuD!6&!(+!>*250/$5!.+!.%!(%./&()$!/,&2J(%$!/.11$5!

Page 24: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 11 of 237

(99.&0*$! 6EFZu! 2*! >*2F6EFZuU! .%5! (+! ./&().&$5! 0>2%! /1$.).8$! &2! .! +9.11$*! >*2&$(%! >*250/&!

J%2K%!.+!9.&0*$!6EFZuD!<#(+!(+!.%!2*/#$+&*.&$5M!#($*.*/#(/.1!>*2/$++!K(&#!/.+/.5$+!(%+(5$!&#$!

/$11! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$! 8$%$*.&(2%! 23! $%R,9.&(/.11,F./&().&$5! /,&2J(%$+D! P! K$11FJ%2K%! $d.9>1$!

0+(%8!&#(+!9$/#.%(+9!32*!(%31.99.&(2%!(+!&#$!.++$9=1,!23!&#$!(%31.99.+29$!/29>1$d!1$.5(%8!

0>!&2!6EFZu!./&().&(2%DZ[MZZ!g2K$)$*M!&#(+!>*2/$++!23!$%R,9$!/1$.).8$!>.&#K.,+!/.%!.1+2!2//0*!

20&+(5$!&#$!/$11M!(%!&#$!$d&*./$1101.*!9.&*(dD!-2*!$d.9>1$M!<e-!/.%!=$!320%5!9$9=*.%$F=20%5M!

=0&! /.%! .1+2! =$! /1$.)$5! &2! ./&! .+! .! +210=1$! 3./&2*! =,! <e-FvF/2%)$*&(%8! $%R,9$! a<P;HVU!

+(9(1.*1,!&2!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:jDZjwZr!;1$.).8$!23!*$/$>&2*+!*$+01&!(%!&#$(*!+210=1$!

32*9+M! K#(/#! 9.,! .9>1(3,! &#$! /,&2J(%$c+! +(8%.1! 1(J$! +210=1$! 6EFq:v! (%/*$.+(%8! 6EFq!

+(8%.1(%8DZqMZm! 70&! $%R,9.&(/! /1$.).8$! /.%! .1+2! =$! 0+$5! &2! (%./&().&$! &#$! /,&2J(%$! 2*! (&+!

*$/$>&2*a+VD! 4210=1$! *$/$>&2*+! 9.,! ./&! .+! .%&.82%(+&! =,! /.>&0*(%8! &#$! /,&2J(%$M! K(&#20&!

&*.%+9(&&(%8!.%,!+(8%.1!.%5!#$*$=,!+(1$%/(%8!&#$!/,&2J(%$c+!>.&#K.,D!<#$+$!*$/$>&2*+!.*$!.1+2!

/.11$5!5$/2,!*$/$>&2*+!.%5!+210=1$! &,>$! 66! 6EFZ!*$/$>&2*!a+6EFZ:66V!.&&$%0.&$+!$d/$++()$! 6EFZ!

./&()(&,!=,!+$?0$+&$*(%8!&#$!/,&2J(%$DZq!

6&! (+! /1$.*! &#.&! &#$! (990%$!+,+&$9!#.+!$)21)$5! &2!$%+0*$! &(8#&1,! *$801.&$5!>*2/$++$+M!K#(1$!

0+(%8!).*(20+!9$/#.%(+9+! &2!.112K! (%&$*)$%&(2%!.%5!92501.&(2%!.&!$./#! 1$)$1!23! *$801.&(2%D!

<#(+!9.J$+!&#$!>(/&0*$!32*!9.%,!5(+$.+$+!K#$*$!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!(%)21)$5!)$*,!/29>1$d!=0&!.&!

&#$! +.9$! &(9$+! 8()$+! +/($%/$! 9.%,! 2>>2*&0%(&($+! &2! (%&$*)$%$! .%5! (5$%&(3,! .! ).*($&,! 23!

>2&$%&(.1!5*08!&.*8$&+D!!

X(9>?(#<$('2=(*%"%:24*=(

XY-(S'=24*)(

<e-! (+! .! /,&2J(%$! &#.&! K.+! 5(+/2)$*$5! +$)$*.1! &(9$+! (%! #(+&2*,! .%5! 2%1,! +$?0$%/$!

(5$%&(3(/.&(2%!*$)$.1$5!&#.&!(&!#.5!=$$%!9(+&.J$%!32*!+$)$*.1!+210=1$!3./&2*+D!P1*$.5,!(%!Zoq[!(&!

#.5! =$$%! 2=+$*)$5! =,! .! -*$%/#! 52/&2*! &#.&! >.&($%&+! =$.*(%8! &092*+! 5(+>1.,$5! *$8*$++(2%!

Page 25: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 12 of 237

0>2%!=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%D!P%2&#$*!>#,+(/(.%!/.11$5!;21$,!LD!8.(%$5!(%&$*$+&!(%!&#(+!2=+$*).&(2%!

.%5! +&.*&$5! &*$.&(%8! /.%/$*! >.&($%&+! K(&#! =./&$*(.1! $d&*./&+DZo! P1&#208#! (&! *$./#$5! +29$!

+0//$++M!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!K.+!?0(&$!&2d(/M!#$%/$!&#$!%.9$!23!&#$!&*$.&9$%&A!;21$,c+!&2d(%+D!6&!K.+!

2%1,! 0%&(1! &#$! 1.&$! ZYn[+! &#.&! &#$! /2%&$%&! 23! ;21$,c+! &2d(%+! K.+! +&05($5! (%! 92*$! 5$>&#! &2!

(%)$+&(8.&$!(&+!$33$/&+D!6&!K.+!320%5!&#.&!2%$!/29>2%$%&!23!&#$!=./&$*(.1!$d&*./&!K.+!+033(/($%&!

&2! %$/*2&(R$! &092*+U! &#(+! /29>20%5! K.+! 1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$! aEC4VD! EC4! (+! .%! $++$%&(.1!

/29>2%$%&!2%!&#$!/$11!K.11!23!8*.9F%$8.&()$!=./&$*(.D!6&!K.+!.1+2!320%5!&#.&!&#$!%$/*2&(/!$33$/&!

23!;21$,c+!&2d(%+!K$*$!50$!&2!#$92**#.8(/!%$/*2+(+M!=12/J.8$!23!)$%20+!5*.(%.8$!23!.%!2*8.%!

2*! &(++0$D!g2K$)$*M! (&! +&(11! &22J!+29$! (%)$+&(8.&(2%+! (%!ZYmr! &2! 3(%5! &#.&!EC4!2%1,! (%5(*$/&1,!

/.0+$5! *$8*$++(2%! 23! &#$! &092*+D! <#(+! K.+! >0=1(+#$5! =,! ;.*+K$11! .%5! /211.80$+! .%5! &#$,!

&$*9$5!&#$!+0=+&.%/$!`<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*_DZY!EC4! (%50/$+!.%! (%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!=,!

=(%5(%8!2%!.!>.&&$*%F*$/28%(&(2%!*$/$>&2*M!/.11$5!<E:n!.%5!&*(88$*(%8!23!&#(+!*$/$>&2*!*$+01&+!

(%! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! +$)$*.1! /,&2J(%$+M! (%/105(%8! <e-D! 6&!K.+! 2%1,!K#$%! <e-!K.+! >0*(3($5M!

/12%$5!.%5! +$?0$%/$5!=,! +$)$*.1! 8*20>+! &#.&! (&!K.+! (5$%&(3($5! .+! &#$! 3./&2*! *$+>2%+(=1$! 32*!

&092*!%$/*2+(+M!#$%/$!&#$!%.9$D!70&!<e-!#.5!.1+2!=$$%!%.9$5!/./#$/&(%M!K#$%!@*D!P%&#2%,!

;$*.9(c+! 8*20>! (5$%&(3($5! .! =(2./&()$! 921$/01$! &#.&! (%50/$5! /./#$d(.! 2*! K$(8#&! 12++! (%!

/#*2%(/.11,!(%3$/&$5!/.&&1$Dj[!4$?0$%/$!(5$%&(3(/.&(2%!*$)$.1$5!&#.&!=2&#!3./&2*+!K$*$!./&0.11,!

2%$!.%5!&#$!+.9$!/,&2J(%$D!!

XY+(F6#*#"2%*'=2'"=(#<$(='Q<#8'<Q(

<#$! <e-! +0>$*3.9(1,! /2%+(+&+! 23! jm! 1(8.%5+! &#.&! .11! $d#(=(&! .%! $d&*./$1101.*! <e-! #292128,!

529.(%!a<g@VM!K#(/#!(+!%$/$++.*,!&2!32*9!%2%F/2).1$%&!#292&*(9$*+DjZ!W$9=$*+!23!&#$!<e-!

+0>$*3.9(1,!.*$! (%)21)$5! (%! &#$! (990%$!+,+&$9M!92+&1,! &#$! (%50/&(2%!23! /$11!5$.&#! &#*208#!

.>2>&2+(+! (%! &.*8$&$5! /$11+D! <,>(/.11,M! &#$+$! `<e-! *$1.&$5_! >*2&$(%+! .*$! J%2K%! .+! @$.&#!

6%50/(%8!E(8.%5+!a$D8D!<e-M!-.+E!.%5!<:P6EVD!<#$+$!1(8.%5+!=(%5!&2!+2F/.11$5!@$.&#!:$/$>&2*+!

a@:+VM!K#(/#! .*$! /#.*./&$*(+$5! =,! .%! (%&*./$1101.*! #.119.*JM! J%2K%! .+!@$.&#!@29.(%! a@@V!

Page 26: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 13 of 237

&#.&!K(11!&*.%+9(&!&#$!.>2>&2&(/!+(8%.1D!'>2%!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!1(8.%5!.%5!*$/$>&2*M!.!%$K!

/29>1$d! (+! 32*9$5! (D$D!@$.&#! 6%50/(%8!4(8%.1(%8!;29>1$d!a@64;VM!K#(/#!K(11! 32*9!.&! &#$!@@M!

.%5! /2%+(+&+!23! &#$!.5.>&2*!>*2&$(%!-.+F.++2/(.&$5!@$.&#!@29.(%! a-P@@V!.%5!.%! (99.&0*$!

32*9!23!&#$!/,+&$(%$!>*2&$.+$!>*2/.+>.+$FoD!<#$!1.&&$*!K(11!.0&2F>*2&$21,&(/.11,!/1$.)$!&#*208#!

>*2d(9(&,F(%50/$5!./&().&(2%! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$! ./&().&(2%!23! &#$! /.&.1,&(/!>.&#K.,!23! .>2>&2+(+!

9$5(.&$5!=,! /.+>.+$+Djjwjn!g2K$)$*M!9$9=$*+!23! &#$!<e-! +0>$*3.9(1,! /.%! .1+2!>*2)(5$! /2F

+&(901.&2*,! +(8%.1+! 50*(%8! (990%$! *$+>2%+$+D! <#(+! 2//0*+! K#$%! .5.>&2*! >*2&$(%+! 23! <e-!

:$/$>&2*! P++2/(.&$5! -./&2*+! a<:P-+V! .*$! *$/*0(&$5! 0>2%! <e-El<e-:! (%&$*./&(2%D! <#$!

#.119.*J!23!&#(+!<:P-!3.9(1,!(+!.!#(8#1,!/2%+$*)$5!;F&$*9(%.1!529.(%!&*(88$*(%8!32*9.&(2%!23!

&*(9$*+!.%5!(%&$*./&(2%!K(&#!&#$!<e-!:$/$>&2*+D!6&+!eF&$*9(%.1!529.(%!(+!1$++!/2%+$*)$5M!=0&!

9$5(.&$+! 52K%+&*$.9! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! +(8%.1+! .%5! >*2F+0*)().1! +(8%.1(%8! &*.%+50/&(2%!

&#*208#!&#$!e-t7M!C6piM!.%5!Ci7!>.&#K.,+D!!

<#$! J$,! 3$.&0*$! 23! &#$! <e-:! +0>$*3.9(1,! (+! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! $d&*./$1101.*! /,+&$(%$F*(/#!

529.(%+! a;:@V! 32*9$5!=,! &#*$$! 5(+01>#(5$! =2%5+! .*20%5! .! /2*$!92&(3! 23! ;OO;OO;D! 6%! &#(+!

K.,M! .%!$12%8.&$5!921$/01$! (+! 32*9$5!K#(/#!9.J$+! /2%&./&!K(&#! &#$! +0*3./$!23! &#$! 1(8.%5+D!!

<#$!<e-:!+0>$*3.9(1,!(%/105$+!&#$!&K2!/1.++(/.1!*$/$>&2*+!32*!<e-A!&#$!rr!J@.!/$11!9$9=*.%$!

*$/$>&2*! &$*9$5! <e-:Z! a;@Zj[.V! .%5! &#$! mr! J@.! /$11! 9$9=*.%$! *$/$>&2*! /.11$5! <e-:j!

a;@Zj[=VD! Q&#$*! *$/$>&2*+! .*$! -P4M! ;@n[M! ;@jm! .%5! :PeiD! P1&#208#! &#$! <e-! .%5! <e-:!

+0>$*3.9(1,!>2+$!.%!(%&$*$+&(%8!&2>(/M!&#(+!&#$+(+!K(11!2%1,!&*$.&!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!.%5!$33$/&+!23!

<e-!.%5!<e-:ZD!<e-!(+!.!>2&$%&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$!9$5(.&(%8!).*(20+!(%31.99.&2*,!

$)$%&+M! =0&! (+! .1+2! (%)21)$5! (%! #29$2+&.&(/! >*2/$++$+D! 6&! (+! .! &*.%+9$9=*.%$! 81,/2>*2&$(%!

9.5$! &#*208#! #292&*(9$*(/! (%&$*./&(2%+D! 6%(&(.11,M! <e-! (+! >*250/$5! .+! .! jq! J@.! >*2&$(%!

=20%5!&2!&#$!/$11!9$9=*.%$M!=0&!/.%!=$!>*2&$21,&(/.11,!/1$.)$5!=,!<P;HlP@PWZmM!P@PWZ[!

2*!WWCZp! &2! .! +9.11$*! +210=1$! 32*9!9$.+0*(%[email protected]! 6%! &#(+! 32*9M! (&! /.%! +&(11! ./&! (%! .%!

.0&2/*(%$!9.%%$*!2%!&#$!+.9$!/$11!2*!./&! (%!.!>.*./*(%$!9.%%$*!(%!&#$!.5G./$%&!/$11+D! 6&!K.+!

(%(&(.11,!*$>2*&$5!=,!;.*+K$11!$&!.1D!&2!=$!>*250/$5!=,!./&().&$5!9./*2>#.8$+!.+!.%!$%52&2d(%F

Page 27: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 14 of 237

(%50/$5!921$/01$M!=0&!%2K.5.,+!(&!#.+!=$$%!/2%3(*9$5!&#.&!<e-!/.%!=$!>*250/$5!=,!.!).*($&,!

23!/$11!&,>$+!*.%8(%8!3*29!9,$12(5!1(%$.8$M!92%2/,&$+!.%5!9./*2>#.8$+M!<!/$11+M!e.&0*.1!i(11$*!

aeiV! /$11+M! %$0&*2>#(1+! .%5!2&#$*! /$11! &,>$+! +0/#! .+! J$*.&(%2/,&$+D!<e-! (+! *$?0(*$5! (%!9.%,!

>*2/$++$+M! +0/#! .+! (%G0*($+! 2*! (%3$/&(2%+! .%5! ./&+! *.>(51,D! <e-! (+! >*$+$%&! (%! 0%+&.=1$M! ,$&!

.=0%5.%&!+&$.5,!+&.&$!1$)$1+!23!9:ePM!K#(/#!(+!*.>(51,!5$8*.5$5!(%!%2*9.1!/2%5(&(2%+!50$!&2!

&#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! P:H+! (%! &#$! pc'<:! 23! &#$! 9:ePD! g2K$)$*M! K#$%! *.>(51,! %$$5$5M! >2+&F

&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! 925(3(/.&(2%! =,! WPCi! H:ilWij! *$+01&+! (%! +&.=(1(+.&(2%! 23! 9:eP! .%5! (%!

+0=+$?0$%&!0>*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!>*2&$(%!$d>*$++(2%D!<#(+!K.,M!<e-!/.%!=$!>*250/$5!*.>(51,D!

!

?'Q3*%(XD((9>?(='Q<#8'<Q(&%"6#<'=&=(

<e-!(+!>*250/$5!.+!.! &*.%+9$9=*.%$!#292&*(9$*M!=0&!/.%!=$!>*2/$++$5!&2!.!+210=1$! 32*9!=,!<P;HD!72&#!32*9+!/.%!./&().&$!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:jD!4210=1$!<e-!9.(%1,!./&().&$+!<e-:ZD!@$>$%5(%8!2%!/$11!&,>$!.%5!=(2128(/.1!/2%&$d&M!=2&#!*$/$>&2*+!/.%!9$5(.&$!.!).*($&,!23!/$1101.*!*$+>2%+$+D!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!/.%!.1+2!=$!>*2/$++$5!(%&2!+210=1$!*$/$>&2*+!=,!<P;HD!<#(+!.112K+!32*!.!).*($&,!23!(%#(=(&2*+!&2!=$!5$)$12>$5!.%5! (%&$*3$*$!.&!).*(20+! 1$)$1+! (%! &#$!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,D!C(/&0*$!.%5! &$d&!.5.>&$5!.%5!925(3($5!3*29!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!$&!.1Djq!!

!

<e-!$d$*&+!(&+!$33$/&+!&#*208#!&K2!*$/$>&2*!/29>1$d$+M!/.11$5!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:jM!K#(/#!+#.*$!

.! jo\!#292128,! (%! &#$(*! $d&*./$1101.*! 529.(%Djm!<e-:Z! (+! $d>*$++$5!0=(?0(&20+1,! .%5! (%! .!

/2%+&(&0&()$!9.%%$*!K#$*$.+!<e-:j!(+!2%1,!$d>*$++$5!(%!(990%$M!$%52&#$1(.1!.%5!%$0*2%.1!

/$11+Djo! 7.+$5! 2%! &#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+M! (&! /29$+! .+! %2! +0*>*(+$! &#.&! <e-:Z! ./&+! .+! &#$!9.G2*!

9$5(.&2*!23!<e-!+(8%.1(%8D!!

Page 28: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 15 of 237

L#$%! <e-! =(%5+! &2! <e-:ZM! $)$%&+! /.%! =$! 5()(5$5! (%! &K2! >#.+$+D! -(*+&M! .5.>&2*! >*2&$(%+!

<:P@@M! :6CZ! .%5! <:P-j! .*$! *.>(51,! *$/*0(&$5! &2! 32*9! /29>1$dF6M! K#(/#! *$+01&+! (%!

>#2+>#2*,1.&(2%! .%5! 0=(?0(&(%.&(2%! $)$%&+D!WPCi! .%5!e-Ft7! .*$! ./&().&$5M! 1$.5(%8! &2! >*2F

(%31.99.&2*,!.%5!+0*)().1!+(8%.1+D!4$/2%51,M!/29>1$dF66!K(11!=$!32*9$5!=,!-P@@M!<:P@@!.%5!

:6CZ! *$+01&(%8! (%! ./&().&(2%! 23! ;.+>Fo! .%5! >*2F.>2>&2&(/! +(8%.1+D! P+! 9$%&(2%$5! .=2)$M! &#$!

$d>*$++(2%! 23! <e-:j! (+! 1(9(&$5! &2! /$*&.(%! /$11! &,>$+M! (%/105(%8! %$0*2%.1! +0=&,>$+M!

21(825$%5*2/,&$+M! 9(/*281(.M! .+&*2/,&$+M! $%52&#$1(.1! /$11+M! .%5! /$*&.(%! <F/$11! +0=>2>01.&(2%+!

a(%/105(%8! ;@nx! .%5! ;@ox! 1,9>#2/,&$+VM! /.*5(./! 9,2/,&$+M! &#,92/,&$+! .%5! 9$+$%/#,9.1!

+&$9!/$11+Djowpp!'%1(J$!<e-:ZM!<e-:j!52$+!%2&!/2%&.(%!.!@@M!=0&!/.%!5(*$/&1,!.++2/(.&$!K(&#!

./&().&$5!<:P-j!1$.5(%8!&2!&#$!./&().&(2%!23!e-Ft7!.%5!PCFZ!&#*208#!WPCi+D!P1&#208#!<e-:j!

52$+! %2&! 5(*$/&1,! (%(&(.&$! .>2>&2+(+M! (&! /.%! +$%+(&(R$! &#$! /$11+! 32*! .>2>&2+(+!K#$%! /29>$&(%8!

K(&#!<e-:Z!32*!<:P-jM!K#(/#!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!/29>1$dF6D!<#$!$d./&!/*2++!*$801.&(2%!=$&K$$%!

<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225M!=0&!+29$!*$+$.*/#$*+!+>$/01.&$!&#.&!&#$!*.&(2!23!

<e-:Zl<e-:j! 9(8#&! =$! &#$! 3./&2*! 5$&$*9(%(%8! &#$! 20&/29$Dpnwpo! 72&#! *$/$>&2*+! .*$! .1+2!

+0+/$>&(=1$!&2!>*2&$21,&(/!/1$.).8$!=,!<P;HM!*$+01&(%8!(%!+210=1$!32*9+!23!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!

a-(80*$! pVD! 6%&*(80(%81,M! &#(+! .+>$/&! 23!9$9=*.%$F=20%5! 2*! +210=1$! 32*9! .33$/&+! &#$! .33(%(&,!

=$&K$$%! 1(8.%5! .%5! *$/$>&2*M! &#$! $33(/($%/,! 23! ./&().&(2%! .%5! &#$! .).(1.=(1(&,M! >*2)(5(%8!

.%2&#$*! +0=&1$! 1$)$1! 23! *$801.&(2%D! 6%! &#$! /.+$! 23! +210=1$! <e-! a+<e-VM! (&! =(%5+! K(&#! 92*$!

.33(%(&,! &2! <e-:Z! .%5! &2! <e-:j! .%5! #.+! .! #(8#$*!92=(1(&,! .+! (&! /.%! /(*/01.&$! +,+&$9(/.11,D!

W$9=*.%$F=20%5!<e-!a9<e-V!/.%!2%1,!./&! 12/.11,!=0&! (+!92*$!$33(/($%&! (%! &#$!./&().&(2%!23!

<e-:j!&#.%!<e-:ZDpY!P+!32*!/1$.)$5!*$/$>&2*+M!&#$!+210=1$!32*9+!23!&#$!*$/$>&2*+!30%/&(2%!.+!

>#,+(2128(/.1! .&&$%0.&2*+! 23! <e-! ./&()(&,! =12/J(%8! &#$! (%&$*./&(2%! =$&K$$%! <e-! 1(8.%5! .%5!

/$11F=20%5! *$/$>&2*D! Q%! &#$! 2&#$*! #.%5! +210=1$! <e-! *$/$>&2*+! 9.,! 30%/&(2%! .+! +>2%8$+M!

*$&.(%(%8! +<e-! 12%8$*! (%! /(*/01.&(2%D! ! P1&#208#! <e-! +(8%.1(%8! +$$9+! &(8#&1,! *$801.&$5!K(&#!

5(33$*$%&!9$/#.%(+9+M!+29$&(9$+!&#$!+,+&$9!3.(1+!.%5!5(+$.+$+!2//0*D!

Page 29: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 16 of 237

XYX(;&:8'"#2'4<('<($'=%#=%=(

<#208#! <e-! (+! 9.(%1,! J%2K%! .+! .! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$M! (&+! $33$/&+! .*$! /*0/(.1! .%5!

=$%$3(/(.1! 32*! .%! .5$?0.&$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$D! 6&! (+! *$?0(*$5! (%! ).*(20+! >#,+(2128(/.1! $)$%&+!

+0/#!.+!&#$!(%%.&$!(990%$!+,+&$9!.%5!&#$!(%(&(.1!*$+>2%+$!&2!>.&#28$%(/!+&(901(M!>*292&(%8!

<#Z! (990%(&,M! &092*! +0*)$(11.%/$M! +$/2%5.*,! 1,9>#2(5! 2*8.%28$%$+(+! .%5! $%$*8,!

9$&.=21(+9DjrMn[wnY!g2K$)$*M!(3!<e-!>*250/&(2%!2*!+(8%.1(%8!(+!+29$#2K!(%.>>*2>*(.&$M!.!1.*8$!

%09=$*! 23! (%31.99.&2*,! /2%5(&(2%+! /.%!5$)$12>D!Q%$! 23! &#$!9.G2*! *21$+! 23! <e-! (+! &#$! #2+&!

5$3$%/$!&2!=./&$*(.1M! 30%8.1!.%5!)(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+D!'+(%8!&*.%+8$%(/!.%(9.1+M! &#$! (9>2*&.%/$!23!

<e-:Z! (%! ).*(20+!925$1+! 23! (%3$/&(2%+!K.+! .++$++$5D!W(/$!5$3(/($%&! (%!<e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! .*$!

92*$! +$%+(&()$! &2! =./&$*(.1! (%3$/&(2%+! 23! S*$)%5*/& 0"("+9)"8%(%$! .%5! /.%%2&! /1$.*! &#(+!

(%&*./$1101.*! >.&#28$%Dr[! 6%! /2%&*.+&M! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$! +0//09=! &2! 1$&#.1! 52+$+! 23! EC4! .%5!

M)/4;9."+"++#$& /#5%#$! $%&$*2&2d(%! 7M! K#$*$.+! 5$1$&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! *$+01&+! (%! (%/*$.+$5!

>*2&$/&(2%DrZ!g2K$)$*M!(&!90+&!=$!>2(%&$5!20&!&#.&!&#$+$!J%2/J20&!9(/$!+#2K!5$)$12>9$%&.1!

>*2=1$9+! &#.&!9.,! .55! 0>! &2! &#$(*! (990%$! *$+>2%+$+D! 6&! #.+! =$$%! 5(+/2)$*$5! &#.&! <e-! (+!

$++$%&(.1!32*!&#$!32*9.&(2%!.%5!9.(%&$%.%/$!23!8*.%0129.+M!&2!.)2(5!+>*$.5(%8!23!S*$)%5*/!.%5!

!9+"L/+)%5*#0&)#L%5+#."$*$M!.1+2!J%2K%!.+!<7;Drjwrn!70&!<e-!(+!.1+2!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!32*9.&(2%!

23!+$/2%5.*,! 1,9>#2(5!2*8.%+!$)(5$%/$5!=,!9(/$! (9>.(*$5! (%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!0%.=1$! &2! 32*9!

%2*9.1! +>1$%(/! .*/#(&$/&0*$M! 1./J! +>1$%(/! >*(9.*,! 7! /$11! 3211(/1$+! .%5! 52! %2&! 32*9! 8$*9(%.1!

/$%&$*+! .%5! 2*8.%(R$5! 3211(/01.*! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11! a-@;V! %$&K2*J+Drrwro! P! =.1.%/$5! *$+>2%+$! 23!

<e-!(+!&#$*$32*$!/*0/(.1!&2!$1(/(&!.%!.5$?0.&$!*$+>2%+$!&2!>.&#28$%(/!+&(901(!+0/#!.+!9(/*2=(.1!

(%3$/&(2%+D!!

IJIJ8+!"#+<&'+.>0)E+.,&'20@*.+

<e-!#.+!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!./0&$!(%31.99.&(2%!/2%5(&(2%+!+0/#!.+!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+D!P/&0.11,M!

.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!$d28$%20+!<e-! (&+$13! (+! 1$&#.1!.+! (&! (%50/$+!.!+,+&$9(/!+#2/JD!4#2/JM!92*$!

>*$/(+$1,! /(*/01.&2*,! +#2/JM! (+! .! 1(3$F&#*$.&$%(%8! /2%5(&(2%! 50$! &2! .! 5*2>! (%! =1225! >*$++0*$!

Page 30: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 17 of 237

a#,>2)21$9(.VM! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! &./#,/.*5(.! .%5! +,9>&29+! 23! >$*(>#$*.1! +#0&52K%D!

'%32*&0%.&$1,M! &#$! .32*$9$%&(2%$5! /#.*./&$*(+&(/+! .*$! %2&! .1K.,+! >*$+$%&! (%! +#2/J! )(/&(9+M!

K#(/#!9.J$+!5(.8%2+(+!5(33(/01&D!W2*$2)$*M! &#(+! /2%5(&(2%!#.+! .!#(8#!92*&.1(&,! *.&$M! $)$%! (%!

#2+>(&.1(+$5! >.&($%&+! .%5! 2%1,! +0>>2*&()$! &*$.&9$%&+! .*$! /0**$%&1,! .).(1.=1$D! <K2! +#2/J!

/2%5(&(2%+M!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4M!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!92*$!(%&2!5$&.(1!=$12KM!=0&!&#$!*21$!23!<e-!K(11!

=$!=*($31,! $d>1.(%$5! (%! &#(+! +$/&(2%D!W21$/01.*1,M! +$>+(+! .%5!46:4!.*$! /12+$1,! *$1.&$5!.+!=2&#!

/2%5(&(2%+!(%/105$!.!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9D!C*(9.*(1,M!.!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9!(+!&,>(/.11,!.//29>.%($5!K(&#!

#,>$*F! 2*! #,>2&#$*9(.M! +K$11(%8! .%5! *$5%$++M! $d&*$9$! 3.&(80$! .%5! %.0+$.D! 6&! (+! (%! 3./&! .%!

$d.88$*.&$5!(990%$!*$+>2%+$!/2%+(+&(%8!23!.!>2+(&()$!3$$5=./J!122>!=$&K$$%!#(8#1,!$1$).&$5!

1$)$1+!23!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!(990%$!/$11+M!1$.5(%8!&2!.!>2&$%&(.11,!3.&.1!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!C.&($%&+!

$d>$*($%/(%8!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9!2*!#,>$*/,&2J(%$9(.!+033$*! 3*29!&#$!*$1$.+$!23!92*$! &#.%!Zr[!

J%2K%!(%31.99.&2*,!9$5(.&2*+DrY!H1$).&$5!1$)$1+!23!=2&#!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+M!+0/#!.+!

<e-M! 6EFZ! .%5! 6EFqU! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+M! (%/105(%8! 6EFZ[! .%5! 6EFZ! *$/$>&2*!

.%&.82%(+&!a6EFZ:.V!.*$!320%5!(%!&#$!+$*09!23!&#$+$!>.&($%&+Dq[!!

6&!(+!/1$.*!&#.&!<e-!9$5(.&$+!.%!$++$%&(.1!>.*&!23!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!/.+/.5$!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4D!

"$%$&(/!>21,92*>#(+9!.55+!0>!&2!&#$!/29>1$d!*21$!23!<e-!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!I.*(20+!

4(%81$!e0/1$2&(5$!C21,92*>#(+9+!a4eC+V!(%!&#$!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!#.)$!=$$%!+&05($5!&2!

3(%5!.%!.++2/(.&(2%!K(&#!+$>+(+M!=0&!*$+01&+!.*$!*.&#$*!/2%31(/&(%8D!P!>2+(&()$!/2**$1.&(2%!K.+!

320%5! =$&K$$%! (%/*$.+$5! 1$)$1+! 23! +210=1$! <e-! *$/$>&2*+! .%5! 2*8.%! 5,+30%/&(2%M! $+>$/(.11,!

K(&#!*$%.1!3.(10*$M!(%!.!>*2+>$/&()$!901&(/$%&*$!+&05,DqZ!<#$*$!K$*$!%2!+&.&(+&(/.11,!+(8%(3(/.%&!

.++2/(.&(2%+! 320%5! =$&K$$%! +$1$/&$5! >21,92*>#(+9+! (%! <e-! .%5! <e-! *$/$>&2*+! .%5! &#$!

+0+/$>&(=(1(&,M!+$)$*(&,!2*!20&/29$!23!+$>+(+D!!

Page 31: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 18 of 237

9#G8%( +D( ZM%*M'%K( 45( 1>E=( '<( 26%( 9>?( Q%<%( #==4"'#2%$( K'26(

=%:='=(4*(=%:2'"(=64"J(#""4*$'<Q(24(O426#*'(%2(#8Yqj(

!

!

P! 92*$! *$/$%&! +&05,! 320%5! .! 8$%$! >21,92*>#(+9! (%! <e-! 1$.5(%8! &2! #(8#! 1$)$1+! 23! <e-! (%!

/*(&(/.11,!(11!>.&($%&+Dqp!4eC+!(%!&#$!>*292&$*!*$8(2%!23!<e-!.&!>2+(&(2%+!FjpoM!Fp[oM!Fpmq!.%5!(%!

&#$!/25(%8!*$8(2%!xnoY!.*$!5(33$*$%&(.11,!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! (%31.99.&(2%!.%5!<e-!>*250/&(2%M!

1$.5(%8!&2!&#$!#,>2&#$+(+!&#.&!(%5()(50.1!<e-!*$+>2%+$+!.*$!>.*&1,!5$&$*9(%$5!=,!&#$!8$%$&(/!

=./J8*20%5D!<#$(*!3(%5(%8+!.*$!1(+&$5!(%!<.=1$!jD!<#$!5(+&*(=0&(2%+!23!<e-!jpoPPM!p[o"P!.%5!

pmq"P!K$*$!#(8#$*!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/J!>.&($%&+!K#$%!/29>.*$5!&2!&#$!/2%&*21!8*20>D!

6%!.55(&(2%M!.%!(%/*$.+$5!.++2/(.&(2%!23!<e-!noY"P!8$%2&,>$!K.+!.1+2!320%5!(%!+$>+(+!>.&($%&+M!

.1&#208#! &#$*$! (+! 2%1,! 1(&&1$! $)(5$%/$! /2%3(*9(%8! &#(+! 3(%5(%8Dqp! -*29! *(& =*="! $d>$*(9$%&.1!

.%(9.1!5.&.M!K$!J%2K!&#.&!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!<e-!/.%!(%50/$!1$&#.1!+#2/J!.%5!&#.&!.=*28.&$5!

<e-! +(8%.1(%8! 1$.5+! &2! $%#.%/$5! +0*)().1! (%! EC4F(%50/$5! +#2/JD! 6%! ZYomM! .%! .++2/(.&(2%!

=$&K$$%! <e-! +$*09! 1$)$1+! .%5! &#$! 3.&.1! 20&/29$! (%! 9$%(%82/2//.1! (%3$/&$5! >.&($%&+! K.+!

*$>2*&$5!=,!L..8$!.%5!H+>$)(JDqr!Q%$!,$.*!1.&$*M!.!+9.11!+&05,!K.+!>$*32*9$5!(%!#09.%+!=,!

*$+$.*/#$*+! .&! &#$! 7*(8#.9! .%5! L29$%c+! g2+>(&.1D! <K$%&,F2%$! #$.1&#,! 9$%! K$*$!

.59(%(+&$*$5!T$+;%5*+;*/&+".*! $%52&2d(%! .%5! >1.+9.! /2%/$%&*.&(2%+! 23! <e-M! 6EFZu! .%5! 6-ey!

K$*$! 9$.+0*$5Dqq! <e-! K.+! &#$! 2%1,! /,&2J(%$! &2! =$! 320%5! $1$).&$5! (%! &#$! =1225! 23! &#$+$!

+0=G$/&+D!6&+!9.d(9.1!1$)$1+!K$*$!.1+2!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!2&#$*!*$+>2%+$+M!+0/#!.+!%.0+$.M!310F1(J$!

+,9>&29+!23! /#(11+M! #$.5./#$+!.%5!9,.18(.+D! -(80*$!n! +#2K+! &#$! (%/*$.+$! (%!>1.+9.!23!<e-!

1$)$1+!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!2&#$*!/,&2J(%$+!(%!+$>+(+Dqn!

!"#$% &'()*+$*,%)-$.% /)012%

!"#$% &&% '()*+*%,-.%*()/+0%*1203%),/+(-/*%

!#4$% 5&% '()*+*%),/+(-/*%

!#67% 5&% '()*+*%),/+(-/*%

89$:% 5&% '()*+*%),/+(-/*%

Page 32: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 19 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(.D(F43*=%(45(9>?('<(=%:='=(

C1.+9.! 1$)$1+! 23! <e-! .*$! (%/*$.+$5! )$*,! $.*1,! 50*(%8!+$>+(+! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2! 2&#$*! /,&2J(%$+! +0/#! .+! 6EFq! .%5!6EFZ[D!P5.>&$5!.%5!925(3($5!3*29!C$5$*+$%!$&!.1Dqn!

!

C*$)(20+! $d>$*(9$%&+! K(&#! .%(9.1! 925$1+! 23! =./&$*(.! .%5! $%52&2d$9(.! #.5! +#2K%!

$%/20*.8(%8!*$+01&+qmwmZ!.%5!&#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+! 1$5!&2!&#$!*.&(2%.1$!&2!%$0&*.1(R$!/(*/01.&(%8!

<e-! (%! +$>&(/! >.&($%&+D! P! 5$/.5$! 1.&$*M! &#$! 3(*+&! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+!K$*$! (%)$+&(8.&$5! (%! /1(%(/.1!

&*(.1+D!P!+210=1$!30+(2%!>*2&$(%!K(&#!&#$!$d&*./$1101.*!>2*&(2%!23!#09.%!<e-:Z!.%5!-/!>2*&(2%!

23!68"Z!K.+!9.%03./&0*$5!&#*208#!*$/29=(%.&(2%M!/.11$5!<e-:A-/D! 6&!/2015!=(%5!&2!<e-!.%5!

%$0&*.1(R$! (&M!#,>2&#$&(/.11,!#.1&(%8! &#$!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9!.%5!*$50/(%8!92*&.1(&,!*.&$! (%!+#2/J!

>.&($%&+D! 6&! K.+! &$+&$5! (%! .! *.%529(R$5M! 520=1$! =1(%5M! >1./$=2F/2%&*211$5! 901&(/$%&$*! &*(.1M!

&$+&$5!2%!ZnZ!>.&($%&+Dmj!g2K$)$*M!&#$!.%&.82%(+&!5(5!%2&!+$$9!&2!*$50/$!92*&.1(&,!.%5!#(8#$*!

52+$+! 23! &#$! 30+(2%! >*2&$(%! K$*$! $)$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! 92*&.1(&,D! P%2&#$*! Z[!

5(+.>>2(%&(%8! /1(%(/.1! &*(.1+! /.9$! &2! &#$! /2%/10+(2%! &#.&! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-! /2015! %2&! *$50/$!

92*&.1(&,!(%!/*(&(/.11,!(11!>.&($%&+!.%5!&#$!$%&#0+(.+9!&2!122J!32*!%2)$1!&#$*.>$0&(/!.>>*2./#$+!

32*!+$>+(+!5(9(%(+#$5D!g2K$)$*M!92*$!(%+(8#&!#.+!=$$%!8.(%$5!2)$*!&#$!,$.*+!.%5!%2K.5.,+!

&#$! (%&$*$+&! (%! &#$! <e-! >.&#K.,! (%! +$>+(+! /2%&(%0$+D! -2*! (%+&.%/$M! 42%8! $&! .1D! 5$+/*(=$5! .!

8$%$&(/!).*(.&(2%!(%!&#$!<e-!8$%$!&#.&!/2015!=$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!&#$!5(+$.+$M!=0&!

%2&! K(&#! &#$! 20&/29$! 4%5& $%:&K#(/#! +088$+&+! &#.&! <e-! 9(8#&! =$! .! 5(.8%2+&(/! 9.*J$*! 32*!

!"#$%

&'()#

(%'$*$')%

Page 33: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 20 of 237

+$>+(+Dmp! 6%5$$5M! .!9$&.F.%.1,+(+! >$*32*9$5! (%! &#$! 8*20>!23!L.%8!>*2>2+$! &2! 0+$!<e-! .+! .!

9.*J$*! (%! &#$! 5(.8%2+(+! 23! %$2%.&.1! +$>+(+M! 2%$! 23! &#$! 9.G2*! /.0+$+! 1$.5(%8! &2! %$2%.&.1!

92*&.1(&,! .%5!92*=(5(&,Dmn! 70&! &#(+! %.&0*.11,! *.(+$+! &#$! ?0$+&(2%M! (3! <e-! (+! %2&! *$?0(*$5! 32*!

1$&#.1(&,!(%!+$>+(+M!&#$%!K#.&!*21$!23!(%31.99.&(2%!(+!9$5(.&$5!=,!<e-S!'+(%8!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$M!

%$0&*.1(R(%8!.%&(=25($+!.%5!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+M!9.%,!.&&$9>&+!K$*$!9.5$!&2!.%+K$*!&#(+!

?0$+&(2%D! E$2%! $&! .1D! (%)$+&(8.&$5! &#$! *21$! 23! <e-:Z! .%5!<e-:j!0+(%8! &*.%+8$%(/!9(/$! (%! .!

925$1! /.11$5! /$/.1! 1(8.&(2%! >0%/&0*$! a;ECVM! .112K(%8! 1$.J.8$! 23! &#$! 80&! 9(/*2312*.! &2!

5(++$9(%.&$!+,+&$9(/.11,!/.0+(%8!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+Dmr!<#(+!925$1!K(11!=$!5$+/*(=$5!30*&#$*!

52K%!(%!&#(+!/#.>&$*D!W(/$!1./J(%8!<e-:Zlj!a#$*$.3&$*!*$3$**$5!&2!.+!<e-:!iQV!K$*$!&$+&$5!

(%!;EC!.%5!92%(&2*$5! 32*! &#$(*!=25,! &$9>$*.&0*$M!=25,!K$(8#&! 12++! a/./#$d(.V!.%5!+0*)().1!

*.&$D! ;EC! (%50/$+! (%(&(.11,! #,>2&#$*9(.M! .1&#208#! &#(+! K.+! 1$++! >*2%20%/$5! (%! <e-:! iQD!

4(9(1.*!K$(8#&! 12++!K.+!2=+$*)$5! (%!=2&#!8*20>+D!<e-:!iQ!9(/$!+#2K$5!$%#.%/$5!+0*)().1!

*.&$!/29>.*$5!&2!&#$!/2%&*21!8*20>D!<#$!.0&#2*+!>*2>2+$!&#.&!<e-!>.*&1,!9$5(.&$+!&#$!(%(&(.1!

#,>2&#$*9(.! .%5! 5$&$*9(%$+! 1$&#.1(&,! 23! +$>+(+D! P!92*$! *$/$%&! +&05,! 0+$5! +(%81$! J%2/J20&!

9(/$! &2! $10/(5.&$! &#$! +$>.*.&$! *21$+! 23! <e-:Z! .%5! <e-:j! (%! ;ECF(%50/$5! (%31.99.&(2%Dmq!

<e-:Z! iQ! #.5! *$50/$5! #,>2&#$*9(.! .%5! >*212%8$5! +0*)().1M! K#$*$.+! <e-:j! iQ! 9(/$!

5$92%+&*.&$5!+#2*&$%$5!+0*)().1!.%5!92*$!+$)$*$!#,>2&#$*9(.!&#.%!/2%&*21!9(/$D!6%!/2%&*.+&M!

g(15$=*.%5!$&!.1D!*$>2*&$5!&#.&!<e-:ZF5$3(/($%&!9(/$!K$*$!%2&!>*2&$/&$5!.8.(%+&!;ECF(%50/$5!

1$&#.1(&,Dmm!e$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!1$5!&2!(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!;ECM!=0&!

&#(+!K.+! *$+/0$5!K#$%! .%&(=(2&(/+!K$*$! .59(%(+&$*$5Dmowo[!Q)$*.11M! &#$+$! *$+01&+! +088$+&! .%!

(9>2*&.%&!>*2&$/&()$!*21$!32*!<e-!(%!;ECF(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,D!g2K$)$*M!2&#$*!925$1+!K$*$!0+$5!

.+!K$11D!Q%$!+&05,!>*2)(5$5!92*$!(%+(8#&!(%!&#$!*21$!23!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!(%!+$>+(+!0+(%8!.!925$1!

23! 1$&#.1! >21,9(/*2=(.1! (%3$/&(2%D! g$*$M! 9(/$! .*$! (%G$/&$5! (%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,! a(D>DV! K(&#! /$/.1!

9(/*2312*.M!(%50/(%8!.!3.&.1!5,+*$801.&$5!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!6%!>.*.11$1!&2!&#$!>*$)(20+!+&05,M!

<e-:Zlj!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!0+$5D!P8.(%M!&#$+$!9(/$!5(+>1.,$5!=$&&$*!+0*)().1!*.&$+!&#.%!&#$!K(15!

&,>$!9(/$M!/2%3(*9(%8!&#$!*21$!23!<e-!(%!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+DoZ!<#$!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$!+#2K$5!

Page 34: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 21 of 237

$%#.%/$5!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&!.%5!=./&$*(.1!/1$.*.%/$! (%!&#$!>$*(&2%$.1!/.)(&,M! 1$.5(%8!&2!

5(9(%(+#$5! 2*8.%! (%G0*,D! 6%5$$5M! +$>+(+! #.+! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! *$50/$5! %$0&*2>#(1!

9(8*.&(2%!&2!(%3$/&(2%!+(&$+!.%5!&#(+!#.+!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!>22*!20&/29$+!(%!+$>+(+Doj!<e-:!

iQ! 9(/$! +#2K$5! 12K$*! (%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$+M! 12/.11,! .%5! +,+&$9(/.11,M! $)(5$%/$5! =,!

*$50/$5!1$)$1+!23!6EFqM!6EFZuM!i;M!.%5!W;CFZ!(%!>$*(&2%$.1!1.).8$!310(5!aCE-V!.%5!+$*09D!<#$!

.0&#2*+!320%5!&#.&!<e-!9$5(.&$5!&#$!5$/*$.+$!23!&#$!/#$92J(%$!*$/$>&2*!;O;:j!$d>*$++(2%M!

.!/*0/(.1!9.*J$*!2%!&#$!+0*3./$!23!/(*/01.&(%8!%$0&*2>#(1+D!;O;:j!#.+!=$$%!+#2K%!&2!9$5(.&$!

*$+>2%+$+! &2! /#$92J(%$+!K(&#! &#$! ;O;!92&(3! (%! >21,92*>#2%0/1$.*! %$0&*2>#(1+D! 6%5$$5M! (%!

r[\!23! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29! +$>+(+M! .! 52K%*$801.&(2%! 23! +0*3./$! $d>*$++(2%! 23! ;O;:j! (+!

2=+$*)$5! 2%! &#$(*! %$0&*2>#(1+D! 6&! +$$9+! &#.&! %$0&*2>#(1+! .*$! *$>*28*.99$5! 50*(%8! +$>+(+M!

.1&$*(%8!&#$!*$/*0(&9$%&!.%5!.//0901.&(2%!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!&2!+(&$+!23!(%3$/&(2%U!$)$%!%$0&*2>#(1!

$33$/&2*! *$+>2%+$+! .*$! 5,+*$801.&$5D! <#$*$! $d(+&! #2K$)$*!9.%,! /2%31(/&(%8! 2=+$*).&(2%+! (%!

*$8.*5!&2!&#$!>*$/(+$!*21$!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!(%!+$>+(+M!K#(/#!(+!+&(11!0%5$*!(%)$+&(8.&(2%Dop!

IJIJK+!"#+<&'+<(105@@(&*+'5.*<.*.+

P1&#208#!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+!5(5!%2&!*$./#!&#$!$d>$/&$5!*$+01&+!(%!./0&$!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!

+0/#!.+! +$>+(+!.%5!46:4M!.!%$K!.>>1(/.&(2%! 3($15!K.+! 320%5! 32*! &#$+$!5*08+D!Hd/$++! 1$)$1+!23!

<e-!.*$! 320%5! (%! /$*&.(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$!#,>2&#$+(+! &#.&!$1$).&$5!<e-!

1$)$1+! .*$! 5$1$&$*(20+! a-(80*$! rVD! <#(+! #,>2&#$+(+! (+! /2%3(*9$5! K#$%! (&! .>>$.*+! &#.&!

2)$*>*250/&(2%!23!<e-!(%!&*.%+8$%(/!.%(9.1!925$1+!*$+01&+! (%!5$)$12>9$%&!23!.0&2(990%$F

1(J$!>#$%2&,>$+DYMon!-2*!(%+&.%/$M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!a:PV!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!12/.1!(%/*$.+$5!

.920%&+!23!<e-!.%5!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!1$.5+!&2!.9$1(2*.&(2%!23!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.*&#*(&(+Dorwom!

6%!&#$!ZYo[FZYY[+M!W.(%(M!-$159.%%!.%5!/211$.80$+!5$92%+&*.&$5!&#.&!2)$*>*250/&(2%!23!<e-!

(+!&#$!5*()(%8!32*/$!23!(%31.99.&(2%!(%31(/&(%8!&#$!&,>(/.1!5.9.8$!2=+$*)$5!(%!G2(%&!5(+$.+$Dom!

<e-!2*/#$+&*.&$+!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!2&#$*!J$,!(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!+0/#!.+!6EFZ!.%5!6EFqM!

K#(/#!K(11!+0=+$?0$%&1,!8()$!+(8%.1!&2!.&&./J!&#$!/.*&(1.8$!.%5!=2%$D!4(901&.%$20+1,M!(990%$!

/$11+!.*$!*$/*0(&$5!.%5!./&().&$5M!1$.5(%8!&2!.!/,/1$!23!(%31.99.&(2%D!6%!$++$%/$M!<e-!52$+!%2&!

Page 35: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 22 of 237

2%1,!2*/#$+&*.&$!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!122>M!=0&!(+!.1+2!*$?0(*$5!&2!9.(%&.(%!(&D!70&!&#$!9$/#.%(+9!

23!<e-F9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$!(+!%2&!+&*.(8#&32*K.*5D!L#$*$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-!(%!2%$!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$! +0/#! .+! :P! 9(8#&! =$! =$%$3(/(.1M! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+! (%!

+,+&$9(/! 10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!a4EHV!/.%!#.)$!5(+.+&*20+!$33$/&+!+0/#!.+!$d./$*=.&(2%!23! &#$!

5(+$.+$!+088$+&(%8!<e-! (+!>1.,(%8!.!>*2&$/&()$!*21$! (%!4EHDoowY[!g$%/$M!.0&2(990%(&,!/.%%2&!

=$! *$50/$5! &2! 2%$! 9$/#.%(+9! $d>1.(%(%8! .11! >#$%2&,>$+D! 6&! (+! /1$.*! #2K$)$*M! &#.&! +$)$*.1!

>.&#K.,+! 3*29!&#$! (990%$!+,+&$9!.*$!2)$*./&().&$5! 1$.5(%8! &2!$d.88$*.&$5!*$+>2%+$+!.%5!

.&&./J(%8! &#$!#2+&M!$+>$/(.11,! &#$!<e-!>.&#K.,D!P+!9$%&(2%$5!.=2)$M!<e-!/.%!+&(901.&$! &#$!

>*250/&(2%!23!2&#$*!(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!&2!$%#.%/$!(%31.99.&(2%M!=0&!(&!(+!.1+2!.=1$!&2!./&!

2%!*$801.&2*,!<!/$11+!a<*$8+VM!K#(/#!.*$!J%2K%!32*!&#$(*!(990%2+0>>*$++()$!*21$DYZwYp!

!

?'Q3*%(0D(I%8%2%*'43=(#"2'4<=(45(9>?(

P/&().&(2%! 23! /$11+! =,! <e-! *$+01&+! (%! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+M! /#$92J(%$+M!.5#$+(2%!921$/01$+! .%5! ).+/01.*! $%52&#$1(.1! 8*2K&#! 3./&2*! aIH"-VM! K#(/#! 1$.5! &2! (%31.99.&(2%M!/$1101.*! (%310d! .%5! .%8(28$%$+(+D! :$801.&2*,! <! /$11+! .*$! (9>.(*$5! 1$.5(%8! &2! 12++! 23! &#$(*!(990%2+0>>*$++()$! 30%/&(2%D! 6%! *$+>2%+$M!<!/$11+!.*$!./&().&$5!.%5!2&#$*!/$11+! +&.*&!>*21(3$*.&(%8D!W2+&!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!.*$!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!5$*$801.&(2%!23!&#$!.32*$9$%&(2%$5!$)$%&+D!

!

<*$8+! /.%! =$! (%50/$5! =,! <*.%+32*9(%8! "*2K&#! -./&2*! a<"-V! wuM! J%2K%! .+! <"-FuF(%50/$5!

<*$8+!a(<*$8+VD!<#(+!/$11!>2>01.&(2%!>1.,+!.%!(9>2*&.%&!*21$! (%!&#$!(990%$!#29$2+&.+(+!.%5!

5,+*$801.&(2%! 23! &#$! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! >*28*.9! 23! (<*$8+! #.+! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! 9.%,!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+YZMYnwYqM!.92%8+&!K#(/#!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!aW4VD!6&!#.+!=$$%!+#2K%!(%!.%!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!.%(9.1!925$1!23!W4M!/.11$5!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.0&2(990%$!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+!aHPHV!

&#.&! &#$+$! (<*$8+! .*$! +$1$/&()$1,! (9>.(*$5! 50*(%8! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! =,! <e-DYZ! <#(+! $33$/&! (+!

!"#$%&'())(*#"+,

-+*#.%&/0,1&'())(2#&,

34/)#.%&/0,

564/0%#&,

)#7/-87/0,3/77,%&97*"(2#&,

:;<=, 5&>%#>/&/0%0,

?@+A/"BA"#7%C/"(2#&,

D,-/77,(-2E(2#&,

F4/8)(2#6,

("*4"%20,

1&'())(*#"+,

G#H/7,6%0/(0/,

!0#"%(0%0,

5&.+7#0%&>,

0A#&6+7%20,

D"/>0,I#00,#C,

%))8&#08AA"/00%#&,

DJ=,

Page 36: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 23 of 237

9$5(.&$5! =,! <e-:j! ./&().&(%8! PJ&Z! >.&#K.,M! K#(/#! (%! &0*%! (%&$*./&+! K(&#! 49.5pD! <#(+!

(%&$*./&(2%! >*$)$%&+! <"-FuF(%50/$5! >#2+>#2*,1.&(2%! 23! 49.5p! .%5! /2%+$?0$%&1,! *$50/$+!

>#2+>#2*,1.&$5! 49.5p! 1$.5(%8! &2! *$50/$5! -2d>p! 1$)$1+M! .! /*0/(.1! &*.%+/*(>&(2%! 3./&2*! 32*!

<*$8+D!<#(+! (110+&*.&$+! &#.&!<e-!./&+! .&! +$)$*.1! +&.8$+!50*(%8! .0&2(990%(&,M! $%#.%/(%8!>*2F

(%31.99.&2*,!>.&#K.,+!.%5!+(1$%/(%8!(990%2+0>>*$++(%8!>.&#K.,+D!!

"$%$! >21,92*>#(+9+! (%! &#$! <e-! +(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,! #.)$! .1+2! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &#$!

5$)$12>9$%&!23!.0&2(990%(&,D!P+!$)(5$%/$5!=,!&*.%+8$%$&(/+M!5$1$&(2%!23!&#$!P:H!+$?0$%/$!

(%!&#$!pc!'<:!23!&#$!<e-!9:eP!*$+01&+!(%!$1$).&$5!<e-!1$)$1+!.%5!+>2%&.%$20+!(%31.99.&(2%!

(%! &#$! &$*9(%.1! (1$09DY! P+! 32*! &#$! 8$%$&(/! >21,92*>#(+9! 23! <e-! Fp[o! 8$%$! 12/0+M! .%!

$%1(8#&$%(%8!*$)($K!=,!H1.#(!.%5!/211$.80$+!#.+!.%.1,R$5!.!8*$.&!.920%&!23!+&05($+!(%!2*5$*!

&2!.%.1,R$!&#$!.++2/(.&(2%!23!&#(+!12/0+!K(&#!5(+$.+$+DYm!!

C+2*(.+(+M! .! /#*2%(/! /2%5(&(2%M! /.%! >*$+$%&! (&+$13! 9.(%1,! (%! &K2! 32*9+M! J%2K%! .+! >+2*(.+(+!

)018.*(+!aC+IV!K#(/#!9.(%1,!.33$/&+!&#$!+J(%!.%5!.!+$/2%5!32*9!/.11$5!>+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+!aC+PV!

K#$*$!(%!.55(&(2%!&2!&#$!+J(%!.1+2!&#$!G2(%&+!.*$!.33$/&$5D!72&#!32*9+!#.)$!.1+2!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!

K(&#!4eC+!(%!&#$!<e-!8$%$!.&!>2+(&(2%+!Fjpo!.%5!Fp[oM!K#(/#!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!30*&#$*!=$12KD!

70&! &#$! .++2/(.&(2%! (+! *.&#$*! +>$/(3(/U! 9$&.F.%.1,+(+! *$)$.1$5! &#.&! ).*(.%&! 8$%2&,>$+! .%5!

.11$1$+! 23! <e-! Fp[oP"! .*$! 92*$! >*2&$/&()$! .8.(%+&! C+IM! K#$*$.+! <e-! FjpoP"! #.+! .! *(+J!

.++2/(.&(2%D! P+! 32*! C+PM! .! +(8%(3(/.%&! .++2/(.&(2%! K.+! 320%5! =$&K$$%! <e-! FjpoP"! .%5! F

orm<;DYoMYY!P%2&#$*!4eC!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!C+P!(+!.1+2!320%5!(%!&#$!<e-!8$%$M!xnoY!

.%5! (+! /2**$1.&$5! K(&#! +$)$*(&,! 23! .%5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! &2! &#$! 5(+$.+$D! P1&#208#!92+&! 8$%$&(/!

+&05($+!(%)$+&(8.&(%8!&#$!8$%$&(/!.++2/(.&(2%!23!<e-!>21,92*>#(+9+!.*$!0+0.11,!%2&!/2%/10+()$!

$%208#!50$!&2!+9.11!+.9>1$!+(R$!2*!0%.5G0+&$5!$+&(9.&$+M!(&!(+!$9(%$%&1,!/1$.*!&#.&!&#$!8$%$&(/!

=./J8*20%5!23!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!.55+!&2!&#$!$&(2128,!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!g2K$)$*M!

(3! +0/#! +&*2%8! .++2/(.&(2%+! $d(+&! =$&K$$%! 8$%$! >21,92*>#(+9+! .%5! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+M! 2%$! /2015! .+J!K#,! &#$+$! 4eC+! #.)$! %2&! =$$%! $1(9(%.&$5! 2)$*! &(9$S!

I.*(20+!$d>1.%.&(2%+!#.)$!=$$%!>2+&01.&$5M!+0/#!.+!&#$!#,8($%$!#,>2&#$+(+A!20*!/0**$%&F5.,!

Page 37: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 24 of 237

(990%$! +,+&$9! (+! %2&! &*.(%$5! .5$?0.&$1,! .%5! &#$*$32*$! /2%30+$+! +$13!K(&#!%2%F+$13D! C$2>1$!

K(&#! .!92*$! +$%+(&()$! (990%$! +,+&$9!50$! &2! &#$(*! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5M! (D$D! #(8#$*! 1$)$1+! 23!

<e-! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! +&(901(M! .*$! 92*$! >*2%$! &2! $1(/(&! .%! $d.88$*.&$5! (990%$! *$+>2%+$M!

*$+01&(%8! (%! .0&2(990%(&,DZ[[MZ[Z! P%2&#$*! >2&$%&(.1! 9$/#.%(+9! (+! &#$! 8$%$&(/! 3.)2*(+9! 32*!

&#$+$!4eC+!.+!&#$+$!#.)$!>*2)(5$5!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!$>(5$9(/!5(+$.+$+D!6%!&#$!/2%&$d&!23!<e-!

>21,92*>#(+9M! <e-! Fp[o""! $%#.%/$5! *$+(+&.%/$! &2! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$! .%5! Fp[o"! K.+!

+(901&.%$20+1,! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &0=$*/012+(+! a<7VDZ[j! 4(9(1.*1,! &#$! <e-! FjpoP! .11$1$! K.+!

>*2&$/&()$! 32*!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!.%5!.&! &#$!+.9$!&(9$!.!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,! 3./&2*! 32*!<7D!<#$!

#.>12&,>$! Fp[oP! Fjpo"! K.+! /2%+(5$*$5! >*2&$/&()$! .8.(%+&! <7! K#(1+&! /.**($*+! +#2K$5!

(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!:PM!4EH!.%5!>*(9.*,!4Gz8*$%+c!+,%5*29$!a44VD!!

L#.&$)$*! &#$!9$/#.%(+9!<e-!0+$+! &2!9$5(.&$!.0&2(990%(&,M! &#$!+0//$++!23!<e-! (%#(=(&2*+!

+0*$1,!).1(5.&$5!<e-!.+!.!5*08!&.*8$&!.%5!&#$+$!5*08+!.*$!&25.,!&#$!=$+&F+215!=(2128(/.1+D!!

XY.(9>?('<(26%*#:'%=(

P1&#208#!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!3.(1$5!(%!/1(%(/.1!&*(.1+!(%!/*(&(/.11,!(11!>.&($%&+M!(&!5$3(%(&$1,!320%5!.!

%$K!0+$!.+!.!&*$.&9$%&!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!:PM!67@M!>*(9.*,!44M!C+I!.%5!C+PD!P11!

&#$+$! 5(+$.+$+! .*$! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! $d/$++! 1$)$1+! 23! <e-! (%! &#$! *$+>$/&()$! .33$/&$5! 2*8.%+M!

(%5(/.&(%8!<e-!(+!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!9$5(.&2*D!6%5$$5M!9.%,!>.&($%&+!#.)$!$d>$*($%/$5!.!8*$.&!

*$50/&(2%! (%! +,9>&29+! K#$%! &*$.&$5! K(&#! <e-! %$0&*.1(R(%8! .8$%&+D! W.(%(M! -$159.%%! .%5!

L(11(.9+!3(*+&!5$92%+&*.&$5!&#$!+0//$++!23!.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&!(%!ZYYj!.%5!>0=1(+#$5!*$+01&+!

2=&.(%$5! K(&#! =12/J.5$! 23! <e-D! <#$! *$+01&+! K$*$! 2=&.(%$5! (%! 9(/$! K#$*$! .*&#*(&(+! K.+!

(%50/$5!=,!/211.8$%!(%G$/&(2%+M!.!925$1!J%2K%!.+!/211.8$%F(%50/$5!.*&#*(&(+!a;6PVD!<#$,!0+$5!

.! #.9+&$*! 68"Z!92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25,! &2! %$0&*.1(R$!<e-!=$32*$! 2*! .3&$*! &#$! 2%+$&! 23! /1(%(/.1!

5(+$.+$DoqMom! C2+(&()$! *$+01&+! K$*$! 2=&.(%$5! (%! =2&#! /2%5(&(2%+! K(&#! *$50/$5! (%/(5$%/$! 23!

.*&#*(&(+M!>.K!+K$11(%8!.%5!#(+&2128(/.1! +$)$*(&,D!P1&#208#! &#(+!K.+!8*20%5=*$.J(%8!K2*JM! (&!

+&(11! %$$5$5! &2! =$! /2%3(*9$5! (%! #09.%! &*(.1+D! <#$!i$%%$5,! 6%+&(&0&$! (%!Qd32*5!>$*32*9$5! .!

Page 38: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 25 of 237

3(*+&!&*(.1!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!5*08!(%31(d(9.=DZ[p!<#$!&*(.1!K.+!3(*+&!/2%50/&$5!(%!.!+9.11!8*20>!23!:P!

>.&($%&+M!=0&!>2+(&()$!*$+01&+!$%/20*.8$5!&2!32112K!0>!K(&#!.!1.*8$*!&*(.1!(%!H0*2>$D!<#$!.%&(F

(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!.%&(F<e-!*$+01&$5!(%!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!+$)$*.1!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!.%5!.!

5$/.5$! 1.&$*! &#$! 0+$! 23! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+! K.+! .>>*2)$5! 32*! .! *.%8$! 23! (990%$F9$5(.&$5!

(%31.99.&2*,! 5(+$.+$+! a6W6@+V! +0/#! .+! :PM! G0)$%(1$! (5(2>.&#(/! .*&#*(&(+M! >+2*(.&(/! .*&#*(&(+M!

.%J,12+(%8!+>2%5,1(&(+M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!!

IJLJ8+!"#+5&>5;5102.+

;0**$%&1,M! r! .%&(F<e-!5*08+! .*$! .>>*2)$5!=,! &#$!-225! .%5!@*08!P59(%(+&*.&(2%! a-@PV! .%5!

H0*2>$.%! W$5(/(%$+! P8$%/,! aHWPVA! (%31(d(9.=! a:$9(/.5${VM! $&.%$*/$>&! aH%=*$1{VM!

.5.1(909.=! ag09(*.{VM! /$*&21(R09.=! a;(9R(.{VM! "21(909.=! a4(9>2%({VO! P1&#208#! &#$+$!

.*$!.11!J%2K%! &2!=12/J!<e-!./&()(&,M! &#$,!5(33$*! (%!5$+(8%M!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!*20&$!.%5!>.&&$*%M!

.%5! (%! $33$/&! a<.=1$! p! .%5! -(80*$! qVD! P11M! $d/$>&! 32*! $&.%$*/$>&M! .*$!92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25($+!

a9P=+VD!6%31(d(9.=!(+!.!/#(9$*(/!68"Z!921$/01$!.+!(&!#.+!.!/29=(%.&(2%!23!90*(%$!.%5!#09.%!

.9(%2!./(5!+$?0$%/$+M!.)2(5(%8!.%!(990%$!*$./&(2%!&2!&#$!90*(%$!>.*&+!(%!>.&($%&+D!<#$!3(*+&!

3011,!#09.%!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!K.+!.5.1(909.=U!(&!5$*()$5!(&+!&*.5$!%.9$!.+!.%!./*2%,9!

23! `#09.%!92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25,! (%! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+|! ag'W6:PVD! ;$*&21(R09.=! (+! .1+2! .!

#09.%(R$5!.%&(=25,M!=0&!CH",1.&$5D!<#(+!(+!&#$!/2).1$%&!=(%5(%8!23!>21,$&#,1$%$!81,/21!aCH"V!

&2! &#(+!5*08!.112K(%8! (&! &2!=$! `9.+J$5_! 3*29!&#$! (990%$!+,+&$9M!.)2(5(%8! (990%28$%$/(&,!

.%5!.%&(8$%(/(&,D!P&! &#$! +.9$! &(9$M! (&! (%/*$.+$+! &#$! +(R$!23! &#$! &2&.1!921$/01$!>*212%8(%8! (&+!

/(*/01.&2*,! &(9$! =,! *$50/(%8! *$%.1! /1$.*.%/$D! "21(909.=! K.+! 5$)$12>$5! &2! 2)$*/29$! &#$!

1(9(&.&(2%+! 23! &#$! >*$)(20+! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+! +0/#! .+! .33(%(&,M! +&.=(1(&,M! +210=(1(&,! .%5!

(990%28$%(/(&,M! K#(/#! .11! .33$/&$5! &#$! .59(%(+&*.&(2%! *20&$! .%5! 3*$?0$%/,D! "21(909.=! (+!

5$*()$5!3*29!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$!$%8(%$$*$5!&2!$d>*$++!#09.%!68"+D!<#$+$!9(/$!.*$!(990%(+$5!

K(&#! <e-M! 8$%$*.&(%8! .! #(8#1,! +&.=1$! #09.%! .%&(F<e-! .%&(=25,! K(&#! #(8#! .33(%(&,! .%5!

%$0&*.1(R(%8!$33$/&D!

Page 39: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 26 of 237

9#G8%(XD(@#*J%2%$(9>?(#<2#Q4<'=2=(#<$(2*%#2&%<2("6#*#"2%*'=2'"=(

!

!M"#5+%N&>;%#0/)"."89O"58&PU()*FAVWQ&

!

<#(+! .112K+! 821(909.=! &2! =$! 52+$5! 1$++! 3*$?0$%&1,! &#.%! &#$! 2&#$*! .).(1.=1$! <e-!

.%&.82%(+&+DZ[n!<#$!2%1,!%2%F.%&(=25,!(%#(=(&2*!(+!$&.%$*/$>&M!.!30+(2%!>*2&$(%!/29>*(+(%8!&#$!

-/!>2*&(2%!23!68"Z!.%5!&#$!$d&*./$1101.*!529.(%!23!<e-:jD!!

!

?'Q3*%([D(I%='Q<(45(9>?(#<2#Q4<'=2=(

<e-! .%&.82%(+&+! #.)$! $)21)$5! 2)$*! &(9$! (%! &#$(*! 5$+(8%! &2! 2>&(9(R$! &#$(*! $33(/./,! .%5! *$50/$!(990%28$%(/(&,D!P5.>&$5!.%5!925(3($5!3*29!i$,+&2%$!B!L.*$DZ[r!!

IJLJK+G.*+06+!"#+5&>5;5102.+

P+! 5$+/*(=$5! .=2)$M! &#$! .59(%(+&*.&(2%! *20&$! .%5! $33$/&! 23! &#$! ).*(20+! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+! /.%!

5(33$*D!6%!<.=1$!pM!&#$!52+(%8!*$8(9$%!.%5!&(9(%8!32*!$d>$/&$5!*$+01&+!.*$!5$+/*(=$5!32*!.11!3()$!

!"#$% &'#()%*+',-$%".$,/.-% 012.34.*%".'#)4'% 5.46+4".1(4.%-..*.*7%

!"#$%&%'()*+,-'%.(/-*01* !"%2%($$34*5%6-"*(2*27-*.$%"%.*89*(2*("*%":;<%8"*.-"2-9*(<*("*%"29(6-"8;<*

%":;<%8"*+!=1*(2*(*/8<-*8:*>?@*'ABCA*+(..89/%"A*28*)8/3*D-%A721*(2*D--C<*

EF*GF*("/*HI*

J(%"2-"(".-4*!=*%":;<%8"<*-6-93*K?L*D--C<I*M8<-*'(3*)-*%".9-(<-/*28*

@?NE*'ABCAI*

G?>*D--C<* O-<*

P2("-9.-Q2*+P")9-$*01* !"%2%($$34*@E*'A*8".-*(*D--C*89*G@*'A*2D%.-*(*D--C*(<*(*<-$:?

(/'%"%<2-9-/*<;).;2("-8;<*%"R-.2%8"I*

J(%"2-"(".-4*S('-*

N?G*D--C<* T8*

U/($%';'()*+V;'%9(*01* !"%2%($$34*KE*'A*-6-93*827-9*D--C*(<*(*<-$:?(/'%"%<2-9-/*<;).;2("-8;<*

%"R-.2%8"I*

J(%"2-"(".-4*S('-*

G?>*D--C<* S;AA-<2-/F*

"82*9-W;%9-/*

X-928$%Y;'()*+X%'Y%(*01! !"%2%($$34*KEE*'A*8"*D--C*EF*G*("/*K*(<*(*<-$:?(/'%"%<2-9-/*<;).;2("-8;<*

%"R-.2%8"I*

J(%"2-"(".-4*GEE*'A*-6-93*827-9*D--CI*

T82-4*P(.7*KEE*'A*/8<-*<78;$/*)-*(/'%"%<2-9-/*(<*G*%"R-.2%8"<*8:*GEE*

'A*-(.7I*

N?G*D--C<* T8*

58$%';'()*+S%'Q8"%*01* !"%2%($$34*@E*'A*8".-*Q-9*'8"27*(<*(*<-$:?(/'%"%<2-9-/*<;).;2("-8;<*

%"R-.2%8"I*

J(%"2-"(".-4*S('-*

N?G*D--C<* O-<*

Reference: https://www.rheumatology.org/Practice/Clinical/Patients/Medications/Anti-TNF/!Source: Rheumatology.org ‘Anti-TNF’!

Page 40: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 27 of 237

(%#(=(&2*+D! <#$! 1.+&! /2109%! +#2K+! K#$&#$*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! +#2015! =$! /29=(%$5! K(&#!

9$&#2&*$d.&$! aW<OVD! <#$! 1.&&$*! (+! .%! .%&(9$&.=21(&$! .%5! .%&(321.&$! 5*08! 23&$%! 0+$5! (%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!=0&!.1+2!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!/.%/$*!.%5!$/&2>(/!>*$8%.%/($+D!6&+!925$!

23!./&(2%!(+!&#208#&!&2!(%)21)$!&#$!>0*(%$!9$&.=21(+9!1$.5(%8!&2!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<!/$11!./&().&(2%!

50$! &2! .//0901.&$5! .5$%2+(%$D!7$/.0+$!23! (&+! $33$/&()$%$++M!W<O! (+! 23&$%! &#$! 3(*+&! /#2(/$! 23!

&*$.&9$%&!32*!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8!3*29!:PD!6%5$$5M!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!(+!%2&!&#$!3(*+&F1(%$!&#$*.>,!

32*! :P! .%5! 2&#$*! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+D! <#$! e.&(2%.1! 6%+&(&0&$! 32*! g$.1&#! .%5! ;1(%(/.1!

Hd>$*($%/$! ae6;HV! =.+$5! (%! &#$! 'iM! #.+! &#$! 32112K(%8! 80(5$1(%$+! 2%! &#$! 0+$! 23! .%&(F<e-!

&#$*.>,! (%! :PA! .%&(F<e-! .8$%&+! +#2015! =$! *$+&*(/&$5! &2! >.&($%&+!K#2! #.)$! 3.(1$5! &*$.&9$%&!

K(&#!&K2!@(+$.+$FW25(3,(%8!P%&(F:#$09.&(/!@*08+!a@WP:@+V!.%5!K#2!/2%&(%0$!&2!#.)$!#(8#!

5(+$.+$! ./&()(&,D! <#$! P9$*(/.%! ".+&*2$%&$*2128(/.1! P++2/(.&(2%! 2*! P"PM! 2%1,! *$/299$%5+!

.%&(F<e-! &#$*.>,! 32*! (%50/&(2%! 23! *$9(++(2%! (%! >.&($%&+! K(&#! 925$*.&$1,! +$)$*$! ;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$!K#2!#.)$!%2&! *$+>2%5$5! &2! &*$.&9$%&!K(&#! +&$*2(5+!2*! (990%$!92501.&2*+D!Q%$!23!

&#$!9.(%!*$.+2%+!K#,!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!.*$!%2&!&#$!3(*+&!/#2(/$!23!>#,+(/(.%+!(+!50$!&2!&#$!#(8#!

/2+&+D!e6;H!.5)(+2*+!0+$!&#$!*01$!23!&#09=!&#.&!.!5*08!(+!23!).10$!&2!+2/($&,!K#$%!(&+!/2+&!3.11+!

=$%$.&#! .! >.*&(/01.*! &#*$+#215M! 0+0.11,! 0%5$*! }p[D[[[! >$*! ?0.1(&,F.5G0+&$5! 1(3$! ,$.*DZ[q!

P1&#208#!$)(5$%/$!(+!%2&!.1K.,+!8225!2*!/29>1$&$M!e6;H!.112K+!&#$!/#2(/$!32*!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!

(%!:PM!=0&!%2&!32*!&*$.&(%8!$.*1,!+&.8$+!23!&#$!5(+$.+$D!P192+&!&K2!5$/.5$+!23!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!

#.)$! >.++$5! .%5! =2&#! >#,+(/(.%+! .%5! >.&($%&+! #.)$! $d>$*(9$%&$5! K(&#! &#$! 0+$! 23! <e-!

(%#(=(&2*+M!$(&#$*!(%!/29=(%.&(2%!K(&#!2&#$*!&#$*.>($+!+0/#!.+!W<O!2*!.12%$D!<(9$!#.+!&.08#&!

0+!&#.&!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!/.%!=$!)$*,!$33$/&()$!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$M!=0&!9.,!

.1+2!#.)$!.!5.*J!+(5$D!<#$(*!5(+.5).%&.8$+!.*$!+#2K%!(%!.!+/#$9.&(/!2)$*)($K!a-(80*$!mV!.%5!

K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!=$12K!(%!5$&.(1D!

Page 41: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 28 of 237

IJLJI+D516<33.+06+!"#+5&>5;5102.+

XOYOXOZ&[*8;&+"$)$&/(7&*(+5%/$%7&$#$+%4)*L*.*)9&)"&*(-%+)*"($&

<#$!#(8#! /2+&! 23!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+!K.+!9$%&(2%$5! (%! &#$!>*$)(20+! +$/&(2%M!K(&#! .!>.&($%&!2%!

.%&(F<e-!/2+&(%8!.*20%5!~ZYD[[[!.%5!~jjD[[[!a�ZnD[[[!.%5!�ZqD[[[V!>$*!,$.*!a$+&(9.&$5!(%!

j[[m!=,!;$%&2/2*! 6%/DVDZ[m!'%32*&0%.&$1,M! (&+!#(8#!/2+&! (+!%2&! &#$!2%1,!5(+.5).%&.8$D!C.&($%&+!

*$/$()(%8! <e-! =12/J(%8! .8$%&+! #.)$! .%! (%/*$.+$5! *(+J! 23! 5$)$12>(%8! (%3$/&(2%+D!W.%,! /.+$+!

#.)$! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! K#$*$! ).*(20+! =./&$*(.1! .%5! 2>>2*&0%(+&(/! (%3$/&(2%+! 2//0**$5! 50*(%8!

.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&Z[oD!"*.9F>2+(&()$!=./&$*(.!.*$!>.*&(/01.*1,!3$.*$5M!+(%/$!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!!

!

?'Q3*%(\D(F4&&4<(:'25#88=(45(9>?(#<2#Q4<'=2=(

e$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!(+!)$*,!$33$/&()$!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!=0&!50$!&2!(&+!12%8F&$*9!*$?0(*$9$%&!(+!.!)$*,!$d>$%+()$!&*$.&9$%&D!6&+!0+$!(+!.1+2!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!+(5$!$33$/&+!+0/#!.+!(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!9(/*2=(.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!(%/*$.+$5!*(+J!23!9.1(8%.%/($+M!7%&("="!(%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+! .%5! 4EHD! Q)$*! &(9$! >.&($%&+! /.%! .1+2! =$/29$! *$+(+&.%&! &2! .%&(F<e-M! &$*9$5! %2%F*$+>2%5$*+D!!

!

K.+! (%(&(.11,! 5$)$12>$5! &2! &*$.&! +$>+(+! .%5! &#$+$! 5*08+! ./&0.11,! $%#.%/$5! 92*&.1(&,! 3*29!

"*.9F>2+(&()$! +$>+(+D! 70&! .1+2! *$./&().&(2%! 23! 1.&$%&! <0=$*/012+(+! a<7V! (%3$/&(2%+! #.+! =$$%!

*$>2*&$5! .+! .! +(5$! $33$/&! 23! =12/J(%8! <e-M! 32*/(%8! >#,+(/(.%+! &2! /#$/J! &#$(*! >.&($%&+! 32*! <7!

=$32*$! >*$+/*(=(%8! .%&(F<e-! 5*08+DZ[Y! <#(+! (%/*$.+$5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! (+! *.&#$*! $d>$/&$5! .%5!

2//0*+! 32*! .11! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+M! +(%/$! <e-! >1.,+! .! 9.G2*! *21$! (%! 3(8#&(%8! 233! (%3$/&(2%+DZZ[!

<#$*$32*$M! >.&($%&+! .*$! /12+$1,! 92%(&2*$5! 32*! (%3$/&(2%+! .%5! 23&$%! (%/105$5! (%! ).//(%.&(2%!

>*28*.9+D!g2K$)$*M!.+!9$%&(2%$5!=$32*$M!&#$!5(33$*$%&!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!.11!5(33$*!(%!5$+(8%!.%5!

!"#$%&'%()&*+'+$,*-.)/*%0$*&12-3)&+$

")&4.2+5)&62.+$

,%0*(&%&-*2+$

7*(8$-)+'+$

92$&):)$*&6;-3)&$)1$

%;')*<<;&2$

6*+2%+2+$

Page 42: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 29 of 237

.1+2!(%!$33$/&D!-2*!(%+&.%/$M!$&.%$*/$>&!(+!&#208#&!&2!=$!1$++!$33$/&()$!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!;*2#%!

5(+$.+$! &#.%! .5.1(909.=M! /$*&21(R09.=! 2*! (%31(d(9.=M! =0&! (+! .1+2! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! .! 12K$*!

(%/(5$%/$! 23! (%3$/&(2%+! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! 2&#$*! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+D! <#(+! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! 12K!

(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-!(+!+033(/($%&!&2!.112K!$33(/($%&!*$+>2%+$+!23!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9DjqMZZZMZZj!

XOYOXOD&,(+5%/$%7&0/.*8(/(+*%$&

Q&#$*! +(5$! $33$/&+! K$*$! 1$++! $d>$/&$5! .%5! /.0+$5! 92*$! /2%/$*%+! 2)$*! &#$! 0+$! 23! <e-!

(%#(=(&(2%D!<#$!>*2/$++!23!&092*!+0*)$(11.%/$!#.+!2%1,!*$/$%&1,!=$$%!(%)$+&(8.&$5!.+!&#$!1(%J!

=$&K$$%!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!.%5!/.%/$*!#.+!8*2K%!+&*2%8$*!2)$*!&#$!,$.*+D!<#$!*21$!23!<e-!

.%5! (&+! *$/$>&2*+! (%! &#(+! >*2/$++! #.+! =$$%!#(8#1(8#&$5! =,! ;.1R.+/(.! .%5! /211$.80$+! +#2K(%8!

&#.&! .=+$%/$! 23! <e-! +(8%.1(%8! (9>.(*+! &092*! +0*)$(11.%/$! .+! <e-l<e-:Z! 9$5(.&$+! PC;!

+(8%.1(%8! .%5! <e-l<e-:j! 9$5(.&$+! +(8%.1(%8! 23! <! /$11+DZZp! 72&#! .*$! *$?0(*$5! 32*! $33$/&()$!

>*(9(%8M!*$/*0(&9$%&!.%5!>*21(3$*.&(2%!23!&092*F+>$/(3(/!<!/$11+M!+088$+&(%8!&#.&!12%8&$*9!0+$!

23! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! /2015! 1$.5! &2! &092*! 5$)$12>9$%&D! <#$*$! $d(+&! .! +(8%(3(/.%&! .920%&! 23!

*$>2*&$5!/.+$+!K#$*$!>.&($%&+!2%!.%&(F<e-!5*08+!5$)$12>$5!9.1(8%.%/($+M!=0&!.++2/(.&(2%!.%5!

*(+J!+&05($+!.*$!+&(11!2%82(%8!&2!5$&$*9(%$!K#$&#$*!<e-!(%#(=(&(2%!/.%!./&0.11,!1$.5!&2!&092*!

5$)$12>9$%&DZrMZZnwZZo!

XOYOXOX&U()*FAVW&*(7#+%7&/#)"*00#(%&7*$%/$%$&

P! 92*$! >.*.52d(/.1! +(5$! $33$/&! 23! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! (+! &#$! (%50/&(2%! 23! .! %2)$1! .0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$M!2&#$*!&#.%!&#$!2%$!&#$!>.&($%&!(+!&*$.&$5!32*D!-2*!(%+&.%/$M!+29$!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$! a;@V! .*$! &*$.&$5! K(&#! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+! $d>$*($%/$! &#$! 2%+$&! 23! >+2*(.+(+M! K#$*$.+!

&#$+$!>.&($%&+!#.5!%2!#(+&2*,!23!>*$F$d(+&(%8!+J(%!/2%5(&(2%+D!6%!3./&M!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!1$+(2%+!

.*$! &#$! 92+&! 3*$?0$%&! 5$*9.&2128(/.1! .5)$*+$! $)$%&+! 2=+$*)$5! (%! >.&($%&+! 2%! .%&(F<e-!

&#$*.>,!.%5!K(&#5*.K.1!23!&#$!&#$*.>,!(+!0+0.11,!+033(/($%&!&2!*$)$*+$!&#$+$!+(5$!$33$/&+DZZYwZjj!

C.*.52d(/.11,M! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! #.+! =$$%! 0+$5! +0//$++3011,! 32*! &*$.&(%8! >+2*(.+(+D! 4(9(1.*!

3(%5(%8+! K$*$! 9.5$! 32*! +,+&$9(/! 10>0+! $*,&#$9.&2+0+! a4EHVM! .! 901&(3./&2*(.1! .%5!

#$&$*28$%20+! 5(+$.+$! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! &#$! =*$.J52K%! 23! +$13&21$*.%/$M! #,>$*./&()(&,! 23! 7!

Page 43: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 30 of 237

/$11+M! >*250/&(2%! 23! .0&2.%&(=25($+M! 32*9.&(2%! 23! (990%$! /29>1$d$+! .%5! &#$! +0=+$?0$%&!

(%31.99.&(2%!23!).*(20+!2*8.%+DZjp!Hd/$++!1$)$1+!23!<e-!K$*$!.1+2!*$>2*&$5!(%!4EHM!(%5(/.&()$!

&#.&! .%&(F<e-! &#$*.>,! K2015! =$! =$%$3(/(.1D! g2K$)$*M! .%! 2>$%F1.=$1! +&05,! +#2K$5! &#.&!

.1&#208#!<e-!(%#(=(&(2%!+0>>*$++$5!12/.1!&(++0$!5$+&*0/&(2%!(%!4EHM!(&!.1+2!1$5!&2!&#$!32*9.&(2%!

23! .0&2.%&(=25($+DZjn! P! +0=+$&! 23! >.&($%&+! 5$)$12>$5! 10>0+F1(J$! +,9>&29+! 50*(%8! .%&(F<e-!

&*$.&9$%&M!&$*9$5!`.%&(F<e-F(%50/$5!10>0+_!aP<6EVD!4(9(1.*1,M!<e-!1$)$1+!>$.J!.&!&#$!#$(8#&!23!

5(+$.+$!(%!9(/$!K(&#!HPH!+088$+&(%8!(&!9$5(.&$+!&#$!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!/$*$=*2+>(%.1!310(5!a;4-VM!

9(**2*(%8!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!5(+$.+$DZjr!6&!#.+!=$$%!+#2K%!&#.&!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!>*$)$%&+!&#$!

5$)$12>9$%&! 23! HPH! *(& =*="! .+! (&! 9$5(.&$+! (%G0*,! .%5! .>2>&2+(+! 23! 21(825$%5*2/,&$+! .%5!

5$+&*0/&(2%!23!9,$1(%! *(&=*)5"!.%5! *(&=*="DZjqwZjo!70&!2%!&#$!2&#$*!#.%5M!2%1,!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!

.*$! *$+(+&.%&! &2! HPHM! K#$*$.+! <e-:j! iQ! 5$)$12>! 92*$! +$)$*$! 5(+$.+$! &#.%! K(15! &,>$!

1(&&$*9.&$+DZjYwZpZ!g2K$)$*M! .&! &#.&! &(9$M! *$+01&+! 3*29!.%(9.1!925$1+!K$*$! $%/20*.8(%8! .%5!

1$%$*/$>&M!.!5(9$*(/!<e-:Z!$d&*./$1101.*!529.(%!30+$5!&2!.!#09.%!68"Z!#$.),!/#.(%!3*.89$%&M!

K.+!$).10.&$5!(%!W4!>.&($%&+D!<#$!&*(.1!#.5!&2!=$!#.1&$5!50$!&2!(%/*$.+$5!W4!.&&./J!3*$?0$%/,M!

50*.&(2%! .%5! +$)$*(&,D! <#$+$! $)$%&+! K$*$! 52+$F5$>$%5$%&D! P1&#208#! &#$! $d./&! 9$/#.%(+9!

K.+!%2&!J%2K%!=./J! &#$%M!%2! 30*&#$*! &*(.1+!K$*$!/2%50/&$5! &2!$).10.&$! &#$!$33(/./,!23!.%&(F

<e-l<e-:! &#$*.>,! (%!W4D! �$&! .8.(%M! &#$! 2//0**$%/$! 23! 5$9,$1(%.&(%8! 5(+2*5$*+! a@@+V! #.+!

=$$%!*$>2*&$5!50*(%8!0+$!23!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+DZjrMZpjMZpp!6&!(+!0%/1$.*!K#$&#$*!&#$*$!(+!./&0.11,!.!

/.0+.&()$! .++2/(.&(2%! =$&K$$%! &#$! 0+$! 23! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+! .%5! &#$! 2%+$&! 23! @@+M! +(%/$!9.%,!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! +#.*$! /2992%! >.&#2128(/.1! 9$/#.%(+9+! .%5! 9.,! >*$+$%&! .+!

901&(3./&2*(.1!5(+$.+$+D!!

XOYOXOY&U()*FAVW&("(F5%$4"(7%5$&

P1&#208#! 9.%,! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! #.)$! =$%$3(&$5! 3*29! <e-!

%$0&*.1(R.&(2%M! .! +0=+$&! 23! >.&($%&+! 52! %2&! *$+>2%5! &2! &#$! &*$.&9$%&M! /.11$5! >*(9.*,! %2%F

*$+>2%5$*+M!2*!12+$!*$+>2%+()$%$++!2)$*!&(9$M!*$3$**$5!&2!.+!+$/2%5.*,!%2%F*$+>2%5$*+DZpn!6%!

&#$! 1.&&$*! /.+$M! (3! 2%$! <e-! (%#(=(&2*! #.+! 12+&! $33$/&()$%$++M! >#,+(/(.%+!K(11! 23&$%! +K(&/#! &#$!

Page 44: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 31 of 237

>.&($%&! &2! .%2&#$*!<e-! (%#(=(&2*D! 40*>*(+(%81,M! &#(+! 23&$%! +$$9+! &2! +033(/$! 32*! &#$!>.&($%&! &2!

*$+>2%5! &2! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! .8.(%M! =0&! 0%32*&0%.&$1,! %2! +>$/(3(/! 80(5$1(%$+! .*$! .).(1.=1$! &2!

5$/(5$! &2! K#(/#! <e-! (%#(=(&2*! +#2015! =$! +K(&/#$5! .%5! &#$! &(9(%8! =$&K$$%! =2&#! .%&(F<e-!

&*$.&9$%&+D!'+0.11,M!.!K.+#!20&!>$*(25!(+!.112K$5!&2!$%+0*$!&#$!(%$33$/&()$!(%#(=(&2*!(+!/1$.*$5!

3*29! &#$!=25,!=$32*$! &#$!%$d&!<e-! (%#(=(&2*! (+! .59(%(+&$*$5D!'%32*&0%.&$1,M! &#$*$!52$+!%2&!

+$$9!&2!=$!$%208#!$)(5$%/$!&2!+0>>2*&!+K(&/#(%8!23!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+!&2!=$!#(8#1,!$33$/&()$M!.+!

9.%,! +&05($+! #.)$! +#2K%! &#.&! 12K$*! $33$/&()$%$++! (+! *$./#$5! K(&#! &#$! +$/2%5! (%#(=(&2*M!

/29>.*$5! &2! &#$! 3(*+&! (%#(=(&2*DZ[q! e2%F*$+>2%5$*+! *$>*$+$%&! .%! .+&2%(+#(%8! p[Fn[\! 23! ;@!

.%5! :P! >.&($%&+! 2)$*! &#$! 3(*+&! ,$.*! 23! &#$*.>,DZprMZpq! 6%! >+2*(.+(+M! &#(+! (+! >*2=.=1,! 1$++M!

.>>*2d(9.&$1,! ZZ\M! .1&#208#! .//0*.&$! %09=$*+! .*$! %2&! .).(1.=1$DZpm! ;0**$%&1,M! &#$*$! .*$!

+&05($+!2%82(%8!&2!(5$%&(3,!=(29.*J$*+!(%!2*5$*!&2!+&*.&(3,!>.&($%&+!(%&2!*$+>2%5$*+!.%5!%2%F

*$+>2%5$*+M! >*$3$*.=1,!9.*J$*+! &#.&! /.%! =$! 5$&$/&$5! =$32*$! &#$! +&.*&! 23! &*$.&9$%&! 2*! $.*1,!

.3&$*! &*$.&9$%&D! 6%! .! /2#2*&! 23! :P! >.&($%&+M! :eP! K.+! $d&*./&$5! 3*29! >$*(>#$*.1! =1225!

92%2%0/1$.*!/$11+!=$32*$!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!$&.%$*/$>&!.%5!mj!#20*+!.3&$*D!;1(%(/.1!+/2*$+!.%5!

O! *.,+! K$*$! 0+$5! &2! $).10.&$! &#$! >.&($%&+c! *$+>2%+$! &2! &#$! &*$.&9$%&M! K#(1+&! +0>$*)(+$5!

1$.*%(%8!9$&#25+!K$*$!.>>1($5!&2!P33,9$&*(d!g09.%!"$%29$!'Zpp!9(/*2.**.,!5.&.!.%.1,+(+D!

@(+/*(9(%.&2*,! 8$%$!>.(*+! 2*! &*(>1$&+!K(&#!>2&$%&(.1! >*28%2+&(/! ).10$!K$*$! +$1$/&$5!K#$%! .!

5$/1(%$!23!joFG2(%&F/20%&!@(+$.+$!P/&()(&,!4/2*$!23!ZDj!K.+!2=+$*)$5D!H.*1,!52K%*$801.&(2%!23!

8$%$+!(%)21)$5!(%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!+0/#!.+!AVWU,\X!.%5!VW]6,U!ae-Ft7!5$>$%5$%&VM!43TY6!ae-F

t7F(%5$>$%5$%&VM! \\\Z>ZHUM! 33,AYM! ?>^\M! U70! .%5!!(M^3! a/$1101.*! .%5! 2d(5.&()$! +&*$++!

*$+>2%+$V! K$*$! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! 5(+&(%/&! /1(%(/.1! *$+>2%+$+! .+! 2)$*.11! 5(+$.+$! ./&()(&($+!

/#.%8$5!p!92%&#+!.3&$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!$&.%$*/$>&D!P!9.G2*(&,!23!&#$!n[!>*2=$!+$&+!(5$%&(3($5!

(%! &#$! +&05,!K$*$! 320%5! &2!=$! *$50/$5! (%! *$+>2%5$*+! /29>.*$5!K(&#!%2%F*$+>2%5$*+DZprD!P!

>2+&F#2/!.%.1,+(+!>$*32*9$5!=,!W.)*.8.%(!$&!.1D!*$)$.1$5!.!>2&$%&(.1!9.*J$*!(%!>1.+9.!23!:P!

>.&($%&+M! K#(/#! /2015! >*$5(/&! &#$! 20&/29$! &2! .%&(F<e-! =$32*$! &*$.&9$%&DZpo! <#$! .0&#2*+!

9$.+0*$5!&,>$!6!6%&$*3$*2%+!a6-e+VM!.!/,&2J(%$!9.(%1,!J%2K%!32*!(&+!.%&()(*.1!./&()(&($+M!.+!&#$!

Page 45: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 32 of 237

*.&(2! 23! &K2! 6-e! 1(8.%5+A! 6-eulvD! <#$,! 320%5! &#.&! .! #(8#! =.+$1(%$! 23! 6-e! ./&()(&,! K.+!

.++2/(.&$5! K(&#! .! 8225! *$+>2%+$! &2! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&D! <#$+$! 3(%5(%8+! 9.,! (%5(/.&$! &#.&!

>1.+9.! >.*.9$&$*+! /.%! =$! 0+$301! &2! 5$3(%$! /1(%(/.11,! *$1$).%&! +0=8*20>+! 23! >.&($%&+! K(&#!

>*$5$&$*9(%$5!*$+>2%+$+!&2!<e-!(%#(=(&2*+D!6&!+#2015!=$!%2&$5M!#2K$)$*M!&#.&!&#$!9.G2*(&,!23!

&#(+! /2#2*&!K.+!g(+>.%(/! .%5! &#$! +&05,! +#2015!=$! *$>$.&$5! (%! .! 1.*8$*!>2>01.&(2%! &2! *$)$.1!

K#$&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e+!./&()(&,!/.%!>*$5(/&!&#$!20&/29$!&2!<e-!=12/J(%8!.8$%&+D!e2%$&#$1$++M!&#$!

%$$5!32*!92*$!$33(/($%&!.%5!12KF/2+&!&*$.&9$%&+!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!

*$9.(%+D!

XY0(7#2'4<#8%(24(G84"J(9>?7-(

<#$! +$/&(2%! .=2)$!5$+/*(=$5! &#$! +(5$! $33$/&+! .++2/(.&$5!K(&#!<e-! (%#(=(&(2%D!g2K$)$*M! <e-!

.%&.82%(+&+! *$9.(%! &#$! 3(*+&! /#2(/$! 23! =(2128(/! &2! &*$.&! .0&2(990%$! 5(+2*5$*+! +0/#! .+! :PM!

;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!6&!+&(11!#.+!.!#(8#!+0//$++!*.&$!.%5!.3&$*!.192+&!&K2!5$/.5$+!23!

0+$M!>#,+(/(.%+!#.)$!8.(%$5!).10.=1$!$d>$*($%/$!K(&#!&#$+$!5*08+D!6%!2*5$*!&2!0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!

+(5$!$33$/&+!23!<e-!=12/J.5$M!2%$!%$$5+!&2!5(++$/&!&#$!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!23!<e-M!K#(/#!+(8%.1+!

&#*208#! &K2! 5(33$*$%&! *$/$>&2*! /29>1$d$+U! &$*9$5! <e-:Z! .%5! <e-:jD! P1&#208#! <e-!

(%#(=(&(2%!(+!K(5$1,!0+$5M!&#$!$d./&!/2%&*(=0&(2%!23!$./#!*$/$>&2*!/29>1$d!+&(11!*$9.(%+!1.*8$1,!

0%J%2K%D! P+! <e-:Z! (+! K(5$1,! 5(+&*(=0&$5! .%5! /2%+&(&0&()$1,! $d>*$++$5M! (&! (+! $.+($*! &2!

/#.*./&$*(R$!(&+!$33$/&+D!<#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!*$31$/&$5!(%!&*.%+8$%(/!J%2/J20&!

9(/$D! W(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! <e-! 1./J! +>1$%(/! >*(9.*,! 7! /$11! 3211(/1$+! .%5! 3.(1! &2! 32*9! 8$*9(%.1!

/$%&$*+!.%5!2*8.%(R$5!3211(/01.*!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!%$&K2*J+M!K#(/#!(+!.1+2!2=+$*)$5!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!

9(/$D!<e-:j!52$+!%2&!+$$9!&2!=$!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!2*8.%(R.&(2%!23!&#$!.5.>&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9M!

.+!&#$,!52!%2&!+#2K!&#$+$!.=%2*9.1(&($+D!P1&#208#!&#$!*21$!23!<e-:j!(+!1$++!J%2K%M!23&$%!(&!(+!

*$3$**$5! &2!.+! &#$!`>*2&$/&()$!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!23!<e-_!K#$*$.+!<e-:Z! (+!*$8.*5$5!.+! &#$!

>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!>.&#K.,M!1$.5(%8!&2!8$%$!(%50/&(2%!.%5!/$11!5$.&#!.%5!#$%/$!&2!5$1$&$*(20+!

$33$/&+! (%! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+D! 4$1$/&()$! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! #.+! =$$%! >*2>2+$5! .%5!

Page 46: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 33 of 237

%2K.5.,+M! <e-:Z! .%&.82%(+&+! .*$! .).(1.=1$! .%5! &#$! 3(*+&! +&05($+! K(&#! &#$+$! (%#(=(&2*+! .*$!

$%/20*.8(%8D! 6%! 9(/$! K(&#! ;6PM! =12/J.5$! 23! <e-:Z! K.+! /29>.*$5! &2! =12/J.5$! 23! =2&#!

*$/$>&2*+! <e-:Z! .%5! <e-:jDZpY! 6%! &#$! 1.&&$*M! (%/*$.+$5! ./&()(&,! 23! $33$/&2*! <! /$11+! K.+!

2=+$*)$5M! K#(/#!K.+! %2&! +$$%!K#$%! 2%1,! <e-:Z!K.+! =12/J$5D! <#(+! +&*2%81,! +088$+&+! &#.&!

<e-:j! ./&+! (990%2*$801.&2*,D! 6%! .55(&(2%M! <*$8+!K$*$! 2%1,! $d>.%5$5! .%5! ./&().&$5!K#$%!

<e-:Z! K.+! =12/J$5U! .55(&(2%.1! =12/J(%8! 23! <e-:j! .=21(+#$5! &#(+! >#$%2&,>$! /29>1$&$1,D!

Q&#$*!K2*J!#.+!/2%3(*9$5!&#$!.5).%&.8$!23!+$1$/&()$1,!=12/J(%8!<e-:Z!2)$*!<e-!2*!<e-:jM!

*$)($K$5!=,!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!$&!.1Djq!4$)$*.1!<e-!90&.%&+!K$*$!/*$.&$5!=,!>#.8$!5(+>1.,M!

*.%5291,!+0=+&(&0&(%8!.9(%2!./(5+M!&#$*$=,!5$)$12>(%8!.!<e-!90&.%&!K(&#!+$1$/&()$!=(%5(%8!

32*!<e-:Z!2*!<e-:jD!P!0%(?0$!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()$!.%&.82%(+&!K.+!/*$.&$5!K#(/#!5(5!%2&!+#2K!

(%/*$.+$! 23! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%M! .! 9.G2*! +(5$! $33$/&! 23! <e-! (%#(=(&2*+M! (9>1,(%8! &#.&! <e-:Z!

(%#(=(&(2%!52$+!%2&!.33$/&!#2+&!5$3$%+$!30%/&(2%!)(.!<e-:jD!P55(&(2%.11,M!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!

K2015! .112K!92*$! $33$/&()$! &*$.&9$%&! 32*! 5(+$.+$+! (%! K#(/#! <e-:j! +(8%.1(%8! (+! =$%$3(/(.1M!

+0/#! .+! W4M! (%! K#(/#! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! $d./$*=.&$+! &#$! 5(+$.+$DjpMZn[! P! &#$*.>$0&(/! +&*.&$8,!

K#$*$! 2%1,! <e-:Z! (+! &.*8$&$5M! K#(1+&! +>.*(%8! <e-:jM! /.%! >2&$%&(.11,! =2&#! (%#(=(&!

(%31.99.&(2%! .%5! >*292&$! <*$8! ./&()(&,M! K#(/#! 9(8#&! =$! +0>$*(2*! &2! /0**$%&! .%&(F<e-!

&#$*.>($+D!

.(9):%(;(;?>=(#<$(26%'*(*%"%:24*=(

.Y-(S'=24*)(

<,>$! 6! 6-e+!K$*$!9.(%1,!J%2K%! 32*! &#$(*!.%&()(*.1!./&()(&($+M!=0&!.*$!%2K.5.,+! *$8.*5$5!.+!

>1$(2&*2>(/! /,&2J(%$+! K(&#! (990%292501.&2*,! 30%/&(2%+D! 6%! ZYrmM! 6+../+! .%5! E(%5$%9.%%!

5$+/*(=$5!.!3./&2*!(%&$*3$*(%8!K(&#!)(*.1!*$>1(/.&(2%M!*$>2*&(%8!6-e!./&()(&,!32*!&#$!3(*+&!&(9$DZnZ!

<#$,!320%5!&#.&!+0>$*%.&.%&!3*29!)(*.11,!(%3$/&$5!/$11+!/2015!/2%3$*!*$+(+&.%/$!&2!2&#$*!/$11+!

0>2%! /#.11$%8$! K(&#! .! )(*0+D! P&! &#.&! &(9$M! (&+! >0*(3(/.&(2%! >2+$5! .%! (99$%+$! /#.11$%8$M! .+!

Page 47: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 34 of 237

>0*(3(/.&(2%!&$/#%(?0$+!(%!&#$!ZYr[+!K$*$!%2&!0>!&2!,($15!Z[[M[[[!F!3215!>0*(3(/.&(2%!23!.!*.*$!

>*2&$(%D!4(5%$,!C$+&J.M!.%!P9$*(/.%!=(2/#$9(+&M!&*($5!&2!(+21.&$!(%&$*3$*2%+!3*29!*.==(&+M!=0&!

&#$! 6-ec+! ./&()(&,! K2015! 5(+.>>$.*! .192+&! (99$5(.&$1,D! 6%+&$.5M! C$+&J.! .%5! /211$.80$+!

5$/(5$5!&2!32/0+!2%!9:eP!.%5!(%!/211.=2*.&(2%!K(&#!C*23D!N.%!I(1/$JM!&#$,!+0//$$5$5!&2!(+21.&$!

6-e!9:eP!.%5!&2!>*250/$!.%5!/#.*./&$*(R$!&#$!>*2&$(%!+&.*&(%8!3*29!9:ePDZnj!H)$*!+(%/$M!&#$!

(%&$*$+&!(%!6-e+!K.+!*.(+$5!.%5!#(8#F>$*32*9.%/$!1(?0(5!/#*29.&28*.>#,!/2109%+!K$*$!0+$5!

(%! 2*5$*! &2! >0*(3,! &#$! >*2&$(%+D! <#(+! 1$5! &2! &#$! 5(+/2)$*,! &#.&! 1$0J2/,&$! (%&$*3$*2%M! &25.,!

J%2K%!.+!6-evM!8.)$!Z[!5(33$*$%&!>$.J+!1$.5(%8!&2!Z[!5(33$*$%&!>$>&(5$!9.>+D!<#(+!+088$+&$5!

&#.&!1$0J2/,&$!6-e!/2%+(+&$5!23!/12+$1,!*$1.&$5!,$&!(%5()(50.11,!/25$5!>*2&$(%+M!+29$&#(%8!&#.&!

/2015!%2&!=$!$d>1.(%$5!=,!&#$!+/($%&(3(/!/2990%(&,!.&! &#.&! &(9$D!P!+$/2%5!&,>$!23! 6-eM! 6-eu!

K.+! .1+2! 5(+/2)$*$5! .%5! +$)$*.1! 1.=+! +&.*&$5! K2*J(%8! 2%! /12%(%8! =2&#! 6-e+D! ;299$*/(.1!

(%&$*$+&! (%! &#$+$! 921$/01$+! (%/*$.+$5! .%5! %2&! 90/#! 1.&$*M! C$+&J.c+! 1.=! K.+! /2%&*./&$5! =,!

"$%$%&$/#! &2! $d>*$++! 6-e+! (%! .! 9.&0*$! 32*9! &2! 0+$! &#$9! (%! &#$! /29=.&! .8.(%+&! )(*.1!

(%3$/&(2%+DZnp! P1&#208#! 6-e+! .*$! 0+$5! &2! &*$.&! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+! .%5! /$*&.(%! 9.1(8%.%/($+M!

2>&(9(+.&(2%!(+!+&(11!2%82(%8D!

.Y+(F6#*#"2%*'=2'"=(#<$(='Q<#8'<Q(

6%&$*3$*2%+! .*$! >*250/$5! )$*,! $.*1,! (%! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! )(*0+$+! .%5! ./&! .+! &#$! 3(*+&! 1(%$! 23!

5$3$%+$!9$/#.%(+9!.8.(%+&!&#$+$!9(/*2=(.1!2*8.%(+9+D!<#$,!32*9!.!+0>$*3.9(1,!&#.&!/.%!=$!

5()(5$5!(%!&#*$$!/1.++$+!=.+$5!2%!&#$!&,>$!23!*$/$>&2*!&#*208#!K#(/#!&#$,!+(8%.1A!&#$!&,>$!6M!66!

.%5! 666! 6-e+D! <#$,! .*$! %2&! %$/$++.*(1,! +&*0/&0*.11,! *$1.&$5M! =0&! .11! `(%&$*3$*$_!K(&#! &#$! )(*.1!

(%3$/&(2%D!<#$!=$+&FJ%2K%!(%&$*3$*2%+!.*$!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e+!/2%+(+&(%8!23!6-e!.1>#.M!=$&.M!$>+(12%M!

J.>>.! .%5! 29$8.D! <#$*$! .*$! Zp! #09.%! .1>#.! 8$%$+M! =0&! 2%1,! 2%$! =$&.M! $>+(12%M! J.>>.! .%5!

29$8.!8$%$D!<#$!92+&!+&05($5!&,>$! 6! 6-e+!.*$! &#$! 6-ev!.%5!6-euD!P1&#208#! (&! (+!>2++(=1$! &2!

5(+/*(9(%.&$! =$&K$$%! 6-ev! .%5! 6-eu! =,! ?C;:! .%5! .%&(=25($+M! &#$! =(2128(/.1! 5(33$*$%/$!

=$&K$$%!=2&#!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225A!&#$*$!(+!.!+(8%(3(/.%&!2)$*1.>!23! (%50/$5!8$%$+!.%5!

Page 48: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 35 of 237

/$1101.*!$33$/&+!.3&$*!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!+(8%.1(%8D!<#$,!.11!+(8%.1!&#*208#!&#$!6-eP:Z!.%5!6-eP:j!

*$/$>&2*M!.!#$&$*25(9$*(/!/29>1$dD! 6-eP:Z! (+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!<�ij!.%5!6-eP:j!K(&#! NPiZD!

<#$! +$/2%5! /1.++! 23! 6-e+M! &#$! &,>$! 66! 6-e+M! /2%+(+&+! 23! 2%1,! 2%$! 1(8.%5M! %.9$1,! 6-eyM!K#(/#!

+(8%.1+! &#*208#! 6-e":Z! a;@ZZYVD! <#(+! 6-e! (%50/$+! .%2&#$*! +$&! 23! 8$%$+M! .1&#208#! 2)$*1.>!

K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+!(+!>2++(=1$D!<#(+!5$>$%5+!2%!&#$!$1$9$%&+!>*$+$%&!(%!&#$!>*292&$*!23!&#$!6-eF

+&(901.&$5!8$%$!a64"VD!<#$!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!K(11!%2&!=$!5(+/0++$5! (%!5$&.(1! (%! &#(+!/#.>&$*U!

&#$*$32*$!&#$!*$.5$*!(+!5(*$/&$5!&2!.%!$d/$11$%&!*$)($KDZnn!<#$!&#(*5!.%5!1.+&!/1.++!(+!/.11$5!&#$!

1.9=5.!(%&$*3$*2%+D!<#(+!/1.++!(%/105$+!6-e1.9=5.ZM!j!.%5!pM!J%2K%!.+!6EFjYM!6EFjoP!.%5!6EF

jo7M! *$+>$/&()$1,D!<#$+$! (%&$*3$*2%+!.1+2!#.)$! &#$(*! +>$/(3(/! *$/$>&2*! /29>1$d! /29>*(+$5!23!

6EFZ[:j! .%5! 6EFjo:P! 32*! +(8%.1(%8M! =0&! .8.(%! &#$,! ./&().&$! +(9(1.*! (%&*./$1101.*! >.&#K.,+M!

2)$*1.>>(%8!K(&#! &#$!$33$/&+!23! &#$!2&#$*! (%&$*3$*2%! /1.++$+D! 4(%/$! &#(+! &#$+(+! 32/0+$+!2%! &#$!

&,>$!6!6-e+M!&#$!2&#$*!&K2!&,>$+!K(11!%2&!=$!5(+/0++$5!30*&#$*D!

'>2%!=(%5(%8!23!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e!1(8.%5+M!6-eP:Z!.%5!6-eP:j!K(11!5(9$*(+$!.%5!*$.**.%8$!&#$!

+0=0%(&+! &2! ./&().&$! &#$! .++2/(.&$5! NPi+! a-(80*$! oVD! <#$! #$&$*25(9$*(/! /29>1$d!

6-eP:Zl6-eP:j! 1./J+! (%&*(%+(/! J(%.+$! ./&()(&,! .%5! &#$*$32*$! *$1($+! 2%! N.%0+! J(%.+$+! aNPiZ!

.%5!<,JjV!&2!>#2+>#2*,1.&$!&#$! (%&*./$1101.*!>.*&+!23! &#$!*$/$>&2*!.%5!4<P<!>*2&$(%+D!'>2%!

&,*2+(%$! >#2+>#2*,1.&(2%M! 4<P<Z! .%5! 4<P<j! K(11! &*.%+12/.&$! &2! &#$! %0/1$0+! .3&$*! 32*9(%8!

&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! /29>1$d$+D!Q%$! 23! &#$+$! /29>1$d$+! (+! 6-eF+&(901.&$5! 8$%$! 3./&2*! p! a64"-pVM!

/29>2+$5!23!>#2+>#2*,1.&$5!4<P<ZM!4<P<j!.%5!6-e!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*!Y!a6:-YVD!<#(+!/29>1$d!

/.%! =(%5! +>$/(3(/! $1$9$%&+! J%2K%! .+! 6-eF+&(901.&$5! *$+>2%+$! $1$9$%&+! a64:HV! &#.&! .*$!

>*$+$%&! (%!&#$!>*292&$*+!23!>.*&(/01.*!8$%$+D!Q%$!23!&#$+$!8$%$+! (+! 6:-mM!K#(/#!(%(&(.&$+!&#$!

&*.%+/*(>&(2%!23!.!+$/2%5!K.)$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<#(+!.0&2/*(%$!.%5!>.*./*(%$!>2+(&()$!3$$5=./J!

1$.5+! &2! .! &,>$! 6! 6-e+F9$5(.&$5! .%&()(*.1! +&.&$! (%! +0**20%5(%8! /$11+M! .)2(5(%8! +>*$.5! 23! &#$!

)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%D!g2K$)$*M!4<P<Z!/.%!.1+2!32*9!#2925(9$*+M!J%2K%!.+!6-eFvF./&().&$5!3./&2*!

aPP-Vl6-eyF./&().&$5! 3./&2*! a"P-V! /29>1$d! &#.&! K(11! =(%5! &2! 6-ey! ./&().&(2%! +(&$! $1$9$%&!

>*$+$%&!(%!92+&!6-eyF(%50/(=1$!8$%$+D!

Page 49: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 36 of 237

P1&#208#!4<P<Z!+$$9+!&2!=$!/$%&*.1M!+(8%.1(%8!/.%!.1+2!2//0*!(%5$>$%5$%&1,!3*29!4<P<Z!)(.!

4<P<jD!64"-p!/.%!=$!+0=+&(&0&$5!=,!.!/29>1$d!32*9$5!=,!4<P<j!#2925(9$*+!(%&$*./&(%8!K(&#!

6:-Y!a4<P<jF6:-YV!&2!./&().&$5!64:H+!/2%&.(%(%8!6-eF+&(901.&$5!8$%$+!0>2%!./&().&(2%!K(&#!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+DZnr! 6%! *$+>2%+$! &2! 6-evM! 4<P<Z! .%5! 4<P<j! /.%! 32*9! .! #$&$*25(9$*(/! /29>1$dM!

=(%5(%8!&2!"P4!$1$9$%&+!23!6:-ZM!K#(/#!1$.5+!&2!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!23!64"ZrM!64"rn!.%5!6-6qD!P+!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+!9$5(.&$! &#$(*! 2K%!>2+(&()$! 3$$5=./J! 122>M! .!9$/#.%(+9!#.+! $)21)$5! &2! *$>*$++!

8$%$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!9$5(.&$5!=,!6:-j!.%5!4Q;4!>*2&$(%+DZnqMZnm!P1&#208#!&,>$!6!6-e+!#.)$!=$$%!

+&05($5!$d&$%+()$1,!.%5!.*$!0+$5!(%!/1(%(/+!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!W4M!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+!.%5!+29$!

/.%/$*+M!&#$(*!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!(+!+&(11!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225D!6&!(+!%2&!/1$.*!#2K!&,>$!6!6-e+!

/.%!#.)$! +2!9.%,!2)$*1.>>(%8! 30%/&(2%+! =0&! +(901&.%$20+1,! #.)$!5(+&(%/&! $33$/&+DZnoMZnY!Q%$!

9$/#.%(+9!/2015!=$! &#$!.33(%(&,!23!$./#! 6-e! 1(8.%5!&2K.*5+! (&+!=(%5(%8!*$/$>&2*M!=0&!*$/$%&!

5(+/2)$*($+!+#$5! 1(8#&!2%!.!%2)$1!9$/#.%(+9D!@$!L$$*5!$&!.1D!5$92%+&*.&$! &#.&! 6-eP:Z!/.%!

./&! (%5$>$%5$%&1,! 3*29! 6-eP:j! (%! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! 6-euDZr[! <#(+! 0%(?0$! 6-eP:ZF6-eu!

(%&$*./&(2%! /.%! &*.%+50/$! +(8%.1+! K(&#20&! &#$! %$$5! 32*! &#$! NPiF4<P<! /.+/.5$! .33$/&(%8! &#$!

$d>*$++(2%! 23! .! 5(+&(%/&! +$&! 23! 8$%$+D! <#$! $33$/&! #.+! /1(%(/.1! *$1$).%/$! $)(5$%/$5! =,! (%! )()2!

$d>$*(9$%&+! K#$*$! 6-eP:Z! iQ! .%5! 6-eP:j! iQ! K$*$! $./#! /#.11$%8$5! K(&#! EC4M! .! <E:n!

.82%(+&! (%50/(%8! +$>+(+D! Q%1,! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! +#2K$5! .9$1(2*.&(2%M! K#$*$.+! 6-eP:j! iQ!

9(/$! K$*$! .+! +$%+(&()$! &2! EC4! .+! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$D! <#$+$! 3(%5(%8+! (%5(/.&$! &#.&! 20*!

0%5$*+&.%5(%8!23!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!(+!+&(11!(%/29>1$&$D!

.YX(;&:8'"#2'4<('<($'=%#=%=(

Q)$*! &#$! ,$.*+! (&! #.+! =$/29$! (%/*$.+(%81,! /1$.*! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 52! %2&! 2%1,! >1.,! .! *21$! (%!

.%&()(*.1!(990%(&,M!.+!&#$,!/.%!.1+2!=$!(%50/$5!=,!=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%+D!72&#!=./&$*(.1!.%5!)(*.1!

>.&#28$%+!.*$!+$%+$5!&#*208#!<E:+M!K#(/#!/.%!(%50/$!&,>$!6!6-e+!0>2%!./&().&(2%D!<E:+!.*$!

>.*&! 23! &#$! (%%.&$! +0*)$(11.%/$! 32*! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! >.&#28$%+M! *$.5,! &2! ./&! *.>(51,! 0>2%!

(%).+(2%D!<E:pM!<E:nM!<E:m!.%5!!

Page 50: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 37 of 237

<E:Y!.*$!+>$/(.1(R$5!(%!*$/28%(+(%8!9(/*2=(.1!>*250/&+!.%5!.*$!.11!>2&$%&!!

!

?'Q3*%(]D(96%("#<4<'"#8(2):%(;(;?>(='Q<#8'<Q(:#26K#)(

'>2%!=(%5(%8!23!&,>$!6!6-e!1(8.%5+M!6-eP:Z!.%5!6-eP:j!K(11!./&().&$!&#$!.++2/(.&$5!J(%.+$+!NPiZ!.%5!NPijD!C#2+>#2*,1.&(2%!K(11!&*(88$*!&#$!*$/*0(&9$%&!23!4<P<!>*2&$(%+M!K#(/#!0>2%!>#2+>#2*,1.&(2%!K(11!5(9$*(R$!.%5!&*.%+12/.&$!&2!&#$!%0/1$0+D!<#$!64"-p!/29>1$dM!K#(/#!(+!/29>2+$5!23!4<P<ZM!4<P<j!.%5!6:-YM!=(%5+!&2!64:H!+$?0$%/$+!&2!./&().&$!/1.++(/.1!.%&()(*.1!8$%$+D!4<P<Z!#2925(9$*+!K(11!=(%5!&2!"P4!$1$9$%&+! &2! (%50/$! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! 8$%$+D! 4<P<p! #2925(9$*+! (%5(*$/&1,! +0>>*$++! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%M!>*2=.=1,!=,!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!0%J%2K%!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!*$>*$++2*+D!<,>$!6! 6-eF./&().&$5! 4<P<p! (+! =20%5! =,! &#$! /2F*$>*$++2*! /29>1$d! 46epPM!K#(/#! +0>>*$++$+! (%50/&(2%! 23!5(*$/&!4<P<p!&.*8$&!8$%$+!=,!>*292&(%8!5$F./$&,1.&(2%!23!4<P<p!.%5!#(+&2%$+D!P5.>&$5!.%5!925(3($5!3*29!6).+#J()!B!@2%1(%DZnm!

!

(%50/$*+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<E:p!.%5!<E:n!0+$!.%!.5.>&2*!>*2&$(%!/.11$5!<6:F529.(%F/2%&.(%(%8!

.5.>&2*!>*2&$(%! (%50/(%8!6-eu!a<:6-V! &2!2*/#$+&*.&$! &#$! (%50/&(2%!23! &,>$!6! 6-e+! (%!.!=*2.5!

*.%8$! 23! /$11! &,>$+M! K#$*$.+! <E:mM! <E:o! .%5! <E:Y! 0+$! 9,$12(5! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! >*(9.*,F

*$+>2%+$! >*2&$(%! oo! aW,@ooV! &2! (%50/$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! a-(80*$! YVD! <#$! 1.&&$*! .*$! *$+&*(/&$5! &2!

5$%5*(&(/! /$11+M! 9.(%1,! >1.+9./,&2(5! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11+! a>@;+VD! Q&#$*! >.&&$*%! *$/28%(&(2%!

*$/$>&2*+!/.>.=1$!23!(%50/(%8!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%/105$!:6"F6!.%5!W@PrM!=2&#!/,&2>1.+9(/!+$%+2*+D!

<#$+$! 3(%5(%8+! +088$+&! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! (9>1(/.&$5! (%! &#$! (%%.&$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$! &2!

).*(20+!9(/*2=(.1!.%&(8$%+D!

Page 51: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 38 of 237

<2! $10/(5.&$! &#$! *21$! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! +/($%&(+&+! #.)$! 0+$5! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! (%! .! ).*($&,! 23!

5(+$.+$! 925$1+D! 6%! 2*5$*! &2! 0%5$*+&.%5! K#.&! $33$/&+! .*$! 9$5(.&$5! =,! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 50*(%8!

=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!6-eP:Z!iQ!K$*$!(%3$/&$5!K(&#!5(33$*$%&!=./&$*(.D!S*$)%5*/&0"("+9)"8%(%$!

(%50/$+! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! )(.! 6:-pD! I(.! 6-e+M! &#$! =./&$*(.! (%#(=(&! #2+&! (990%(&,! =,! 0>*$801.&(%8!

.>2>&2&(/!8$%$+!(%!+>1$%(/!9./*2>#.8$+DZrZ!<,>$!6!6-e+!.1+2!+$$9!&2!9$5(.&$!&#$!5$1$&$*(20+!

$33$/&+!(%!?;./097*/&0#5*7/5#0!.%5!<7!(%3$/&(2%+M!K#$*$.+!(&!/2%3$*+!*$+(+&.%/$!&2&W5/(+*$%../&

)#./5%($*$! &#.&!/.0+$+!.! 1$&#.1!32*9!23!>%$092%(.!.%5!2&#$*!(%3$/&(2%+!+0/#!.+!M)5%4)"+"++#$&

4(%#0"(*/%M!T$+;%5*+;*/&+".*!.%5!S%8*"(%../&4(%#0"4;*./DZrjwZrr!<#(+!50.1!%.&0*$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!

(+!+&(11! (%/29>1$&$1,!0%5$*+&225M!=0&!+29$!9$/#.%(+9+!#.)$!=$$%!>*2>2+$5D!<#*208#!&,>$!6!

6-e+M! =./&$*(.! 0+$! .! +&*.&$8,! &2! (%50/$! .>2>&2+(+! (%! 1,9>#2/,&$+! .%5! #$*$=,! +0>>*$++! &#$!

.5.>&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!P%2&#$*!>2++(=(1(&,!(+!&#$!+0>>*$++(2%!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!=,!&,>$!6!6-e+D!

g$%*,! $&! .1D! 5$92%+&*.&$5! &#$! /2%+&*.(%(%8! $33$/&+! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 2%! 6EFZmPl-M! K#(/#! .*$!

/*0/(.1! 32*! /1$.*(%8! WO& )#./5%($*$! =,! $33$/&()$1,! *$/*0(&(%8! %$0&*2>#(1+D! <#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+!

/1$.*1,!+#2K!&#$!(990%292501.&2*,!.%5!>1$(2&*2>(/!30%/&(2%+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+M!$d>.%5(%8!20*!

)($K!&#.&!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!52!%2&!+21$1,!30%/&(2%!.+!.%&()(*.1!3./&2*+D!

LJIJ8+!,-*+%+%#".+<&'+.>0)E+.,&'20@*.+

4$>+(+! (+! .! +$*(20+! /2%5(&(2%! &#.&! #.+! .! #(8#!92*&.1(&,! .%5! (+!K2*15K(5$! &#$!92+&! /2992%!

*$.+2%! 32*!.59(++(2%! &2! (%&$%+()$! /.*$!0%(&+! a6;'+VD!<#$! *21$!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! +$>+(+! (+! +&(11!

5$=.&$5M! .1&#208#! (%/*$.+(%8! $)(5$%/$! +088$+&+! &#$+$! .%&()(*.1! /,&2J(%$+! 9$5(.&$! &#$!

(%31.99.&2*,! /.+/.5$! 2=+$*)$5! (%! +$>+(+! >.&($%&+M! .&! 1$.+&! >.*&1,D! Q0*! 8*20>! #.+! *$/$%&1,!

>*2)(5$5! +&*2%8! $)(5$%/$! 32*! .!9$5(.&2*,! *21$! .+! >#.*9./2128(/.1! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!

$%#.%/$5! +0*)().1! *.&$! 23! 9(/$! (%! ;ECM! .! 925$1! 32*! >21,9(/*2=(.1! +$>+(+D! W2*&.1(&,! K.+!

*$50/$5! .3&$*! .59(%(+&*.&(2%! 23! .! 92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25,! &.*8$&$5! .8.(%+&! 6-eP:ZM! .112K(%8!

=$&&$*! %$0&*2>#(1(/! *$/*0(&9$%&! .%5! $%#.%/$5! =./&$*(.1! /1$.*.%/$Doj! 6%! /2%&*.+&M! i$11,F

4/09>(.! .%5! /211$.80$+! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! K.+! $++$%&(.1! &2! +0*)().1! (%! ;ECM! =0&! &#$(*!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!+$&F0>!5(33$*$5!(%!9.%,!.+>$/&+!+0/#!.+!90*(%$!=./J8*20%5M!925$1!+$)$*(&,!.%5!

Page 52: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 39 of 237

K#$&#$*!2*!%2&!.%&(=(2&(/+!K$*$!.59(%(+&$*$5DZrq!P!*$/$%&!>0=1(/.&(2%!+#$5!1(8#&!2%!&#$!*21$!23!

&#$! +210=1$! 32*9+! 23! 6-e! *$/$>&2*! (%! EC4F(%50/$5! +#2/JU! +#2K(%8! &#$! 9$5(.&2*,! $33$/&! 23!

+210=1$! 6-eP:j! a+6-eP:j.VM!K#(/#! (+! 8$%$*.&$5!=,! .1&$*%.&()$! +>1(/(%8! 23! &#$! ,-(/5D!9:eP!

8$%$DZrm!<#(+! +210=1$! 32*9! (+! $1$).&$5! (%!>.&($%&+!K(&#! /#*2%(/! (%31.99.&(2%M! (%3$/&(2%+! .%5!

/.%/$*! +0/#! .+! #.(*,! /$11! 1$0J.$9(.ZroMZrY! .%5! 9(/$! 2)$*$d>*$++(%8! +6-eP:j.! +#2K$5!

$d./$*=.&$5!5(+$.+$! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2!EC4! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$!K(15! &,>$!9(/$M! &#*208#!.9>1(3($5!

&,>$! 6! 6-e! *$+>2%+$+! .%5! (%5$>$%5$%&! 23! 6EFq! .%5! <e-! 1$)$1+D! i.*.8#(2+233! $&! .1D! >*2)(5$5!

.55(&(2%.1!$)(5$%/$! 32*!.! *21$!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%!$%52&2d$9(.!=,! &*$.&(%8! 6-eu!iQ!9(/$!K(&#!

EC4D!<#$+$!9(/$!K$*$!*$+(+&.%&!&2!#(8#!52+$+!.%5!>*250/$5!1$++!<e-M!eQ!.%5!6-ey!/29>.*$5!

&2!&#$!/2%&*21!8*20>DZq[!Q15$*!$)(5$%/$!23!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!+#2/J!#.+!=$$%!

*$)($K$5!(%!20*!8*20>!.%5!&#$!(%&$*$+&$5!*$.5$*!(+!*$3$**$5!&2!&#(+!/29>*$#$%+()$!*$)($K!=,!

W.#($0!.%5!E(=$*&DZqZ!P1&#208#!+$>+(+!(+!.!/2%5(&(2%!/#.*./&$*(+$5!=,!./0&$!(%31.99.&(2%M!(&!(+!

23&$%! .//29>.%($5! =,! .! +$/2%5! >#.+$! &$*9$5! /29>$%+.&2*,! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$!

a;P:4V!K#$*$! &#$!>.&($%&+! 3.(1! &2! $1(/(&! .%!.>>*2>*(.&$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$!.8.(%+&! +$/2%5.*,!

(%3$/&(2%+D!6&!(+!/#.*./&$*(+$5!=,!.%!(9>.(*$5!.5.>&()$!<!/$11!(990%(&,M!0%.=1$!&2!/2%&*21!)(*.1!

.%5! =./&$*(.1! (%3$/&(2%+M! 23&$%! 3.&.1! &2! &#$! >.&($%&DZqjwZqn! <,>$! 6! 6-e+! +$$9! &2! >1.,! .! >.*&! (%!

;P:4!=,!&.*8$&(%8!+$1$/&()$1,!@;+!.%5!+0>>*$++(%8!/*2++F>*$+$%&.&(2%M!#$*$=,!>.*.1,R(%8!&#$!

.5.>&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9DZqr!

P%2&#$*!925$1!23!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+!(+!&#$!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!9.%,!./&2*+!#.)$!=$$%!

(5$%&(3($5! (%!<e-F(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,!+0/#!.+!&#$!>*2&$/&()$!eQM!80.%1,.&$!/,/1.+$+!a+";+V!.%5!

WiCZU!.%5!&#$!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!6EFq!.%5!6EFZmDZqqwZqY!Q0*!8*20>!#.+!(5$%&(3($5!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e!

+(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,! .+! .%2&#$*! >()2&.1! 9$5(.&2*! 23! <e-F(%50/$5! &2d(/(&,DZm[! 6%&*.>$*(&2%$.1!

(%G$/&(2%!23!<e-!1$5!&2!.%!64:H!+(8%.&0*$!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!(%!1()$*M!+088$+&(%8!.!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!

6-e+D!6%5$$5M!5$3(/($%/,!(%!6-eP:Z!*$+01&$5!(%!$%#.%/$5!+0*)().1!*.&$!(%!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JM!

.//29>.%($5!K(&#! *$50/$5! (%31.99.&(2%!.%5!2*8.%!5.9.8$D!<#(+! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!

9$5(.&$!.%5!$%#.%/$!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!<e-D!<#$!/1(%(/.1!*$1$).%/$!23!&#$+$!3(%5(%8+!

Page 53: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 40 of 237

*$9.(%+! #2K$)$*! 0%/1$.*! .%5! .%&(F&,>$! 6! 6-e! &#$*.>,! (+! %2&! ,$&! .>>1($5! (%! /*(&(/.11,! (11!

>.&($%&+DZmZ!

!

?'Q3*%(^D(1"6%&%(45(9C7('<$3"2'4<(45(2):%(;(;?>=(

W(/*2=(.1!>.*&(/1$+!.*$!*$/28%(R$5!=,!<E:+!.%5!K(11!+&(901.&$!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<E:n!(+!$d>*$++$5!.&!&#$!/$11!9$9=*.%$M!K#$*$.+!<E:pM!<E:mM!<E:o!.%5!<E:Y!*$+(5$!.&!$%52+29$+D!<,>$!6!6-e+! /.%! =$! (%50/$5! (%! .! <:6-F! 2*!W,@ooF5$>$%5$%&!K.,D! <:6-F9$5(.&$5! (%50/&(2%! 0+$+! 6:-p! &2!(%(&(.&$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%M!K#$*$.+!W,@oo!*$1($+!2%!6:-mD!!

!

LJIJK+!,-*+%+%#".+5&+<(105@@(&*+'5.*<.*.+

6%!#09.%!>.&($%&+M!+>$/(3(/!$d>*$++(2%!>.&&$*%+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!*$801.&$5!8$%$+M!23&$%!&$*9$5!.+!

.!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.&0*$M!#.)$!=$/29$!.>>.*$%&!(%!9.%,!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!+,+&$9(/!

10>0+! $*,&#$9.&20+M! >+2*(.+(+M! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+M! ;*2#%c+! 5(+$.+$! .%5! 901&(>1$!

+/1$*2+(+DZmjwZoj!L#$&#$*!&,>$!6! 6-e+!+&*(/&1,!>1.,!.!>.&#2128(/.1!*21$! (%!&#$+$!5(+$.+$+! (+!+&(11!

5$=.&$5M!=0&!(&!#.+!/$*&.(%1,!.&&*./&$5!&#$!.&&$%&(2%!23!2%$!/$11!>2>01.&(2%!J%2K%!.+!&#$!>@;+D!

<#$+$! /$11+! .*$! J%2K%! .+! >*23$++(2%.1! 2*! %.&0*.1! (%&$*3$*2%Fv! >*250/(%8! /$11+! a6C;+V! .%5!

=$12%8! &2! &#$! (%%.&$! (990%$!+,+&$9M! &#208#! &#$,!.*$!5(33$*$%&! 3*29!/2%)$%&(2%.1!5$%5*(&(/!

/$11+! 2*! 92%2/,&$+D! P1&#208#! >@;+! .*$! J%2K%! .+! .! >2&$%&! +20*/$! 32*! &,>$! 6! 6-e+U! &#$+$!

/,&2J(%$+!/.%!=$!>*250/$5!=,!.192+&!.11!/$11+!0>2%!$%/20%&$*!K(&#!.!)(*0+D!

Page 54: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 41 of 237

'>2%! +&(901.&(2%! .%5! +0=+$?0$%&! ./&().&(2%M! >@;+! >*250/$! 1.*8$! .920%&+! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D!

'%5$*! %2*9.1! /(*/09+&.%/$+M! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! 6-e+! (+! &(8#&1,! *$801.&$5! K(&#! %$8.&()$!

3$$5=./J!&2!$%+0*$!2%1,!.!=*($3!>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!63!%$8.&()$!*$801.&(2%!3.(1+M!&#(+!/2015!

1$.5!&2!+0+&.(%$5!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%M!.%5!/#*2%(/!./&().&(2%!.%5!+$/*$&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e!(%!

&#$!.=+$%/$!23!(%3$/&(2%!/.%!>*292&$!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+DZopD!@$>1$&(2%!23!>@;+!*$+01&$5!(%!

$d>.%+(2%! 23! 9,$12(5F5$*()$5! +0>>*$++2*! /$11+! aW@4;+VM! #.1&(%8! &#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23!

.0&2(990%(&,! (%! .!925$1! 23! HPHDZon! <#(+! (9>1($+! &#.&! >@;+!9$5(.&$! .0&2(990%(&,! &#*208#!

&,>$!6!6-e+M!.1&#208#!&#(+!(+!(%!+#$$*!/2%&*.+&!K(&#!2=+$*).&(2%+!(%!W4D!;2%5(&(2%.1!5$1$&(2%!23!

6-eP:Z!(%!9,$12(5!/$11+!+0/#!.+!92%2/,&$+M!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!@;+!$%#.%/$5!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!

&#$! /$%&*.1! %$*)20+! +,+&$9M! +088$+&(%8! 6-eP:ZF5$>$%5$%&! .0&2(990%(&,D! -011! 6-eP:Z! iQ!

5$)$12>$5! $d./$*=.&$5! HPH! +,9>&29+M! 9.*J$5! =,! (%/*$.+$5! (%31.99.&(2%M! 5$9,$1(%.&(2%!

.%5!1$&#.1(&,D!4>$/(3(/!.=1.&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!(%!7!2*!<!1,9>#2/,&$+!*$+01&$5!(%!/29>.*.=1$!HPH!

+,9>&29+!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!<#$+$!*$+01&+!(%5(/.&$!.!5(+&(%/&!>*2&$/&()$!*21$!32*!&#$!

&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!;e4!.0&2(990%(&,DZorwZom!6%(&(.11,M!&#$!$&(2128,!23!W4!K.+!&#208#&!&2!=$!)(*.1M!+2!

>.&($%&+! K$*$! &*$.&$5! K(&#! 6-euM! K#(/#! .9$1(2*.&$5! &#$! 5(+$.+$D! e2K.5.,+M! (&! (+! +&(11! .%!

$33$/&()$!&*$.&9$%&M!.1&#208#!&#$!$&(2128,!23!W4!*$9.(%+!0%J%2K%D!!

W(/*2.**.,!.%.1,+(+!+#2K$5!.%!64:H!+(8%.&0*$!(%!>$*(>#$*.1!=1225!92%2%0/1$.*!/$11+! (%!4EH!

>.&($%&+M! +088$+&(%8! .! /2%&(%020+! (%50/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e! +(8%.1(%8DZooMZoY! 4EH! (+! &#208#&! &2!

*$+01&! 3*29! 5$3$/&()$! /1$.*.%/$! 23! .>2>&2&(/! /$11+M! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$! /#*2%(/! >*$+$%/$! 23!

.0&2.%&(8$%+D! <#$! 0%/2%&*211$5! *$1$.+$! 23! %0/1$(/! ./(5+! 3*29! 5$.5! /$11+! ./&! .+! +$13F.%&(8$%+!

.%5!.*$!>(/J$5!0>!=,! (%&*./$1101.*! +$%+2*+! &#.&! *$+>2%5!K(&#! &#$!>*250/&(2%!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D!

<#(+! (+!.1+2!2=+$*)$5!.+! &#$!.=(1(&,!23!+$*09!3*29!4EH!>.&($%&+! &2! (%50/$! 6-ev! (+!/2**$1.&$5!

K(&#!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!.%&(=25($+!.8.(%+&!%0/1$(/!./(5+DZY[!L#$&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e+!>*(9.*(1,!>1.,!.!

>.&#2128(/.1! *21$! (%! :P! (+! %2&! /$*&.(%M! =0&! (%/*$.+$5! 64:H! +(8%.&0*$+! (%! +,%2)(.1! 310(5! K.+!

320%5! (%!>.&($%&+! .%5! .! *$/$%&! +&05,!=,!Ef==$*+! $&! .1D! ).1(5.&$5! &#$!>*$+$%/$!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e!

+(8%.&0*$!.+!=(29.*J$*!&2!>*$5(/&! &#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!:P! (%!>*$5(+>2+$5! (%5()(50.1+DZYZ!<#$!

Page 55: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 42 of 237

+&*2%8$+&! 1(%J! =$&K$$%! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 2%+$&! 23! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$! (+! 320%5! (%! >.&($%&+!

&*$.&$5!K(&#!6-e+D!@0$!&2!&#$(*!>2&$%&!.%&()(*.1!./&()(&($+M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!K(5$1,!0+$5!&2!&*$.&!

g$>.&(&(+! 7! .%5! ;! .%5! #09.%! >.>(1129.)(*.1! agCIV! F(%50/$5! K.*&+D! <#$(*! 0+$! #.+! =$$%!

.++2/(.&$5! K(&#! .0&2(990%$F1(J$! +,9>&29+! +0/#! .+! .0&2(990%$! &#,*2(5(&(+M! >+2*(.+(32*9!

+J(%!1$+(2%+!.%5!:PDZmqMZYjMZYp!<#$+$!+(5$!$33$/&+!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!(%!5$>&#!(%!&#$!%$d&!+$/&(2%D!!

.Y.(9):%(;(;?>=('<(26%*#:'%=(

<#$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! 23! 8*$.&! (%&$*$+&! =$/.0+$! 23! &#$(*! ).1(5.&$5! &#$*.>$0&(/! ).10$! 32*! &#$!

&*$.&9$%&! 23! ).*(20+! 5(+$.+$+! .%5! &#$*$! (+! 8*2K(%8! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! &#$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$!

(9>1(/.&$5!.&!901&(>1$! 1$)$1+!23! &#$! (990%$! +,+&$9!50*(%8!>.&#2128($+D!L$!K(11!5(+/0++! &#$!

&#$*.>$0&(/! .*$.+! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 5(+/0++! &#$! +(5$! $33$/&+M! K#(/#! K(11! (110+&*.&$! &#$!

(990%292501.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+D!

LJLJ8+!,-*+%+%#".+5&+1>*+12*<1@*&1+06+M52<3+5&6*)150&.+<&'+@<35=&<&)5*.+

<,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!K$11!J%2K%!32*!&#$(*!.%&()(*.1!$33$/&+M!3(*+&!>0=1(+#$5!=,!6+../+!.%5!E(%5$9.%%D!

Q)$*!&#$!1.+&!5$/.5$+M!&#$!.%&()(*.1!9$/#.%(+9+!23!(%&$*3$*2%+!#.)$!=$$%!$d&$%+()$1,!+&05($5M!

1$.5(%8! &2! &,>$! 6! 6-e! .+! .! &#$*.>,! 32*! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+! +0/#! .+! g$>.&(&(+! 7! .%5! ;D! P&! 3(*+&M!

*$/29=(%.%&!v!(%&$*3$*2%+!K$*$!0+$5!&2!&*$.&!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!/#*2%(/!#$>.&(&(+!;M!#.(*,F/$11!

1$0J$9(.!.%5!2&#$*!9.1(8%.%&!5(+$.+$+D!70&!2%$!23!&#$!5(+.5).%&.8$+!23!&#$!*$/29=(%.%&!32*9!

K.+! &#$! /1$.*.%/$! &(9$A! &#$! >*2&$(%! 2%1,! 1.+&$5! 32*! m! &2! Zj!#20*+DZYn! C.&($%&+! %$$5$5! &#*$$!

(%G$/&(2%+!>$*!K$$JM!K#(/#!>1./$5!.!=0*5$%!2%!&#$(*!?0.1(&,!23!1(3$D!<2!(%/*$.+$!&#$!#.13F1(3$!23!

6-eF.jM! >#.*9./$0&(/! /29>.%($+! +208#&! &2! 1(%J! (&! &2! .%2&#$*!921$/01$D!P+!5$+/*(=$5! .=2)$M!

>21,$&#,1$%$! 81,/21! aCH"V! (+! .%! (%$*&M! %2%F&2d(/!921$/01$! &#.&! /.%! *.%8$! (%! +(R$! .%5! /.%!=$!

/2).1$%&1,! =20%5! &2! ).*(20+! &#$*.>$0&(/.1! >*2&$(%+M! K(&#20&! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! .1&$*(%8! &#$(*!

/2%32*9.&(2%D! 6%5$$5M! >$8,1.&$5! (%&$*3$*2%+! #.5! .! &$%F3215! 12%8$*! +$*09! #.13F1(3$! &#.%! &#$!

%2%F>$8,1.&$5!32*9D!

Page 56: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 43 of 237

9#G8%(.D(9):%(;(;?>/G#=%$(26%*#:'%=(

!

M"#5+%$N&W3U:&V[M&/(7&!M=*%J$O"58&

!

;0**$%&1,M! >$8,1.&$5! 32*9+! 23! (%&$*3$*2%! +0/#! .+! C$8.+,+<W! .%5! C$86%&*2%<WM! .*$! &#$! 92+&!

$33$/&()$!5*08+!&2!&*$.&!g$>.&(&(+!;!(%!/29=(%.&(2%!K(&#!2*.1!*(=.)(*(%M!.!%0/1$2+(5$!(%#(=(&2*D!

Q&#$*! 6-eF&#$*.>($+! 2%! &#$!9.*J$&! .*$! 1(+&$5! (%! <.=1$! nD! C.&($%&+! *$1,! 2%! 2%$! (%G$/&(2%! >$*!

K$$J! K(&#! &#$! >$8,1.&$5! 32*9D! 70&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! 0%32*&0%.&$1,! %2&! +21$1,! =$%$3(/(.1A!

g$>.&(&(+!;!>.&($%&+!K#2!*$/$()$!6-ev!&*$.&9$%&!5(+>1.,!.!).*($&,!23!+(5$!$33$/&+!+0/#!.+!310F

1(J$! +,9>&29+! .%5! 3.&(80$M! .0&2(990%$! &#,*2(5(&(+! .%5! >+2*(.+(+DZmqMZYrwZYm! W2*$2)$*M!

%$0*2>+,/#(.&*(/!5(+2*5$*+!#.)$!.1+2!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!6-ev!&#$*.>,DZYo!<#$!5$)$12>9$%&!

23! 6-eF(%50/$5!:P!K.+!*$)($K$5!.+!K$11M!.1&#208#!&#(+!+(5$!$33$/&!K.+!0%/2992%D!<#(+!K.+!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! .%&(%0/1$.*! .%&(=25($+! .%5! *#$09.&2(5! 3./&2*! (%! mj\!.%5!pn\!23! >.&($%&+M!

*$+>$/&()$1,D!'>2%!K(&#5*.K.1! 23! 6-e! &#$*.>,M! *$9(++(2%!23! .*&#*(&(+!K.+! 2=+$*)$5! (%!92*$!

!"#$% !&'(")*"'% +&)*%*,,*-.'%

!"#$%&'(%)*%$+,-./0-1)2$34$$

5! 2!67)0/&%8/9$:%'-;<=;$;%0>-?%$

5! @(0-1<>$?A/&-B/1-C;$&/CD/?<%$

5! E%<0A$>/&&$&/CD%/?<%$

5! F/18%&$(/%&8($'0-G&/?;$

5! E/%08$'0-G&/?;$

5! H&--9$'0-G&/?;$

!"#$%&'(%)*G$$

5! 2!67)0/&%8/9$(/'%8<8<;$@$

5! F%&<B1%18$?/&%1-?%$

5! @-19A&-?%8%$%>C?<1%8%$

5! @(0-1<>$(/'%8<8<;$H$

5! E%<0A$>/&&$&/CD%/?<%$

5! 6/'0/;;<-1$

5! 6<.I<>C&8$G0/%8(<1B$

5! 7J/&&<1B$-0$'C.I<1/;;$-.$8(/$.%>/$

5! K<B(81/;;$<1$8(/$>(/;;$

5! L/<B(8$&-;;$

!"#$%&'(%)*G$

!"#$%&'(%>-1)M$+!1./0B/1$34$

N/BA&%8/9$!"#$%&'(%)*G$

N/BA&%8/9$!"#$%&'(%)*%$

5! !1$>-?G<1%8<-1$J<8($,<G%O<0<1$.-0$>(0-1<>$

(/'%8<8<;$@$

5! #/C0-';A>(<%80<>$/?/0B/1></;$

5! 2C8-<??C1/$0/%>8<-1;$

5! !;>(/?<%$

5! !1./>8<-1;$

!"#$G/8%)MG$+H/8%;/0-1$34$

!"#$G/8%)M%$+2O-1/P$34$

5! FC&8<'&/$;>&/0-;<;$ 5! E/%08$'0-G&/?;$

5! !1Q/>8<-1$;<8/$'0-G&/?;$

5! "&C)&<D/$;A?'8-?;$

5! 7/<RC0/;$

5! F/18%&$(/%&8($'0-G&/?;$

5! S<O/0$'0-G&/?;$

!"#$%&'(%)1T$+2&./0-1)#$34$ 5! U/1<8%&$%19$'/0<%1%&$J%08;$>%C;/9$GA$

(C?%1$'%'<&&-?%O<0C;$

5! S-;;$-.$%''/8<8/$

5! "&C)&<D/$;A?'8-?;$

5! 78-?%>($'%<1$-0$O-?<8<1B$

5! !1Q/>8<-1$;<8/$'0-G&/?;$

Source: FDA, NHS, MSviews.org!

Page 57: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 44 of 237

&#.%!m[\!23!&#$!/.+$+D!4(d&,F&#*$$!>$*/$%&!23!&#$!>.&($%&+!5$)$12>$5!.8.(%!:PF1(J$!+,9>&29+!

K#$%!6-e!&#$*.>,!K.+!*$+&.*&$5DZYY!4(9(1.*1,M!(&!(+!&#208#&!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!9$5(.&$!&#$!2%+$&!

23! 4EHM! .+! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! 32*! /#*2%(/! (%3$/&(2%+! 2*! 9.1(8%.%/($+! 5$)$12>$5! 10>0+F1(J$!

+,9>&29+!K#(/#!K$*$! )$*,! +(9(1.*! &2! +>2%&.%$20+! 4EHDj[[Mj[Z! 6%(&(.11,M! 67@!K.+! &#208#&! &2!

=$%$3(&!3*29!&,>$!6!6-e!&*$.&9$%&!.+!$d>$*(9$%&+!(%!.%(9.1!925$1+!23!67@!+#2K$5!.!*21$!32*!

6-e+! (%! (%&$+&(%.1!#29$2+&.+(+!.%5!*$+01&+!K$*$!$%/20*.8(%8D!'%32*&0%.&$1,M! &#$!0+$!23! 6-ev!

.%5!6-eu!5(5!%2&!+#2K!.%,!+(8%(3(/.%&!=$%$3(/(.1!$33$/&+! (%!/1(%(/.1!&*(.1+M!.1&#208#!&*$.&9$%&!

K.+!K$11!&21$*.&$5D!W2*$2)$*M!/2%&*.+&(%8!*$+01&+!/2%/$*%(%8!67@!+,9>&29+!K$*$!2=+$*)$5!(%!

>.&($%&+!&*$.&$5!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+!.+!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+!$d./$*=.&$5!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!g$>.&(&(+!;!

50*(%8!6-e!&#$*.>,Dj[jMj[p!<#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+!*.(+$!&#$!?0$+&(2%!(3!&,>$!6!6-e+!>1.,!.!50.1!*21$!

(%!&#$!=2K$1!+,+&$9D!!

W$1.%29.c+!#.)$!.1+2!=$$%!&*$.&$5!K(&#!&,>$!6! 6-e+M!92*$!+>$/(3(/.11,! 6-evj=!K#$*$! (&!./&+!

(990%$92501.&2*,! .%5! .%&(.%8(28$%(/D! <#$,! /.%!>*292&$!9$1.%29.! /$11! 5$.&#! 5(*$/&1,! 2*!

(%5(*$/&1,! &#*208#! @;+M! >@;+! .%5! <! /$11+Dj[nwj[o! '%32*&0%.&$1,M! (&+! 0+$! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#!

+0=+&.%&(.1! +(5$! $33$/&+! +0/#!.+!%$0*2>+,/#(.&*(/!5(+2*5$*+! .%5!#$>.&(/! &2d(/(&,D! 6%! .55(&(2%M!

&#$!925$+&!$33(/./,!23!12K!52+$!&*$.&9$%&!9.J$+!/1(%(/(.%+!*$10/&.%&!&2!0+$!&#(+!&*$.&9$%&!(%!

>.&($%&+D!:.&#$*!#(8#F52+$! *$8(9$%! *$9.(%+!2>&(2%.1! 32*!>.&($%&+! .&!#(8#! *(+J!23!5$)$12>(%8!

5(+&.%&!9$&.+&.+$+Dj[YMjZ[! 6%5(*$/&! (%50/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! #.+! .1+2! =$$%! 0+$5! .+! .! &#$*.>,D!

"$%(&.1! K.*&+! .*$! /.0+$5! =,! &#$! #09.%! >.>(1129.)(*0+! .%5! >.&($%&+! .*$! &*$.&$5! K(&#!

(9(?0(925!a6WsVM!.%!(990%$!*$+>2%+$!925(3($*!&#.&!/.%!=$!.>>1($5!&2>(/.11,!.+!.!/*$.9D!6Ws!

(+! &#208#&! &2! 3(8#&!)(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+!=,!+&(901.&(%8!&#$! (990%$!+,+&$9D! 6Ws!&*(88$*+! &#$!<211F

1(J$! *$/$>&2*+! <E:m! .%5! <E:o! &#.&M! K#$%! ./&().&$5M! (%50/$! +$/*$&(2%! 23! >*2(%31.99.&2*,!

/,&2J(%$+D!<#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!32*9!>*$529(%.%&1,!.!<#Z!>*23(1$!*$+>2%+$M!(%/105(%8!<e-M!6-evM!

6-ey! .%5! 6EFqM! 6EFZ.M! 6EFZ=M! 6EFo! .%5! 6EFZjD! P! =25,! 23! $)(5$%/$! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! &#$! 6WsF

9$5(.&$5!>*250/&(2%!23!6-ev!(+!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!*$8*$++(2%!23!&#$!(%3$/&(2%!&#*208#!./&(2%+!23!

>@;+DjZZwjZn! 4(5$! $33$/&+! /.%! $9$*8$! .&! &#$! +(&$! 23! .>>1(/.&(2%! +0/#! .+! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+M! =0&!

Page 58: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 45 of 237

92*$!+&*(J(%81,!&#$+$!1$+(2%+!/.%!.1+2!5$)$12>!.&!5(+&.%&!+(&$M!(%5(/.&(%8!&#$!5*08!#.+!+,+&$9(/!

./&(2%+D!<#$! *$+$9=1.%/$!23! &#$!>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! .*$! )$*,! +(9(1.*! &2! +>2%&.%$20+!>+2*(.+(+M!

+088$+&(%8!&#$!9$/#.%(+9+!.*$!)$*,!+(9(1.*!.%5!.*$!>2&$%&(.11,!9$5(.&$5!=,!$d/$++!&,>$!6!6-e!

+(8%.1(%8D!

Q)$*.11M! &#$*$! (+! .%! 2=)(20+! >.&&$*%! 23! 7%& ("="! (%50/&(2%! 23! .0&2(990%$F1(J$! +,9>&29+!

50*(%8!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+M!+088$+&(%8!+29$!>.&#2128(/.1!*21$!=,!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e+D!P%5!

&#208#! >.&($%&+! +033$*! 3*29! ).*(20+! +(5$! $33$/&+M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! *$9.(%! .! )$*,! >2&$%&! .%&()(*.1!

&#$*.>,! .%5! 9.%,! /1(%(/.1! +&05($+! +&(11! 32/0+! 2%! (9>*2)(%8! &#$! /0**$%&! &#$*.>,! K(&#!

(%&$*3$*2%+D!

LJLJK+!,-*+%+%#".+<&'+12*<1@*&1+06+@(315-3*+.)3*20.5.+

W01&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+M!.1+2!J%2K%!.+!5(++$9(%.&$5!+/1$*2+(+!2*!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+!5(++$9(%.&.M!(+!

.%! (990%$F9$5(.&$5! (%31.99.&2*,! 5(+$.+$! K#$*$! &#$! 9,$1(%! +#$.&#+! .*$! .&&./J$5! =,! &#$!

(990%$!+,+&$9D!<#(+!*$+01&+!(%!5.9.8$!23!&#$!%$*)$!/$11+!(%!&#$!=*.(%!.%5!+>(%.1!/2*5M!1$.5(%8!

&2! 1$+(2%+! 2*! >1.?0$+! (%! &#$! /$%&*.1! %$*)20+! +,+&$9! a;e4VD! 6&! #.+! %2! J%2K%! $&(2128,M! =0&!

+/($%&(+&+! &#(%J! (&! *$+01&+! 3*29! .! /29=(%.&(2%! 23! $%)(*2%9$%&.1! 3./&2*+! +0/#! .+! (%3$/&(20+!

.8$%&+!.%5!8$%$&(/!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,D!P1&#208#!W4!(+!.!#$&$*28$%(/!5(+$.+$!>*$+$%&(%8!5(33$*$%&1,!

(%! $./#! >.&($%&M! 3()$! &,>$+! .*$! 5(+&(%80(+#$5A! /1(%(/.11,! (+21.&$5! +,%5*29$M! +$/2%5.*,F

>*28*$++()$!W4M! >*(9.*,F>*28*$++()$!W4M! >*28*$++()$F*$1.>+(%8!W4! .%5! *$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!

W4! a::W4VD! 6%! &#$! 1.&&$*M! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! 6-eu! #.+! +#2K%! /1(%(/.1! $33(/./,M! 5$/*$.+(%8! &#$!

%09=$*!23!*$1.>+$+D!!

C.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! K(&#! 6-eu! #.)$! 3$K$*! .*$.+! 23! 1$+(2%+! 2%! W:6! +/.%+! 23! &#$! =*.(%! .%5!

$d>$*($%/$! 1$++! 5(+.=(1(&,! .%5! 5(+$.+$! >*28*$++(2%+! +$$9+! 5$1.,$5DjZrwjZo! g2K$)$*M!

5$)$12>9$%&! 23! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! K.+! *$>2*&$5! #$*$! .+! K$11A! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! 32*! W4!

+033$*$5!7%&("="!(%50/&(2%!23!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+M!*$.33(*9(%8!&#$!2=+$*).&(2%+!23!6-ev!&*$.&9$%&!

5$+/*(=$5! .=2)$Dj[jMjZY! E(J$K(+$M! +$)$*$!K2*+$%(%8! 23! /0&.%$20+! >+2*(.+(+! .%5! ./&().&(2%! 23!

>+2*(.&(/! .*&#*(&(+! 50*(%8! 6-eu! &*$.&9$%&! #.+! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! .+!K$11Djj[! 4,9>&29+! *$+21)$5!

Page 59: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 46 of 237

.3&$*!&#$*.>,!5(+/2%&(%0.&(2%M!+088$+&(%8!.!>.&#2128(/.1!,$&!*$)$*+(=1$!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!

&#$! (%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! (%!W4D!P! 3$K!/.+$+!23!5*08F(%50/$5!4EH!.%5!:P!#.)$!=$$%!

*$>2*&$5! .+! K$11DZYpMjjZMjjj! g2K$)$*M! +29$! >.&($%&+! 52! %2&! *$+>2%5! &2! 6-eu! &*$.&9$%&M!

+088$+&(%8!&#$!$d(+&$%/$!23!.%!6-euF(%5$>$%5$%&!9$/#.%(+9!(%!W4D!

.Y0(7#2'4<#8%(24(G84"J(;?>!7-(

<#$!2=+$*).&(2%+! 1(+&$5! .=2)$! /$*&.(%1,! *$)$.1! .! *21$! 32*! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! &#$!>.&#28$%$+(+! 23!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! .%5! $)$%! .!9$5(.&2*,! *21$! (%! +#2/J! +,%5*29$+D! P1&#208#! &#$,! $d$*&!

&#$*.>$0&(/! ./&(2%+! (%! W4! .%5! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+M! +29$! 5(+$.+$+! 9.,! ./&0.11,! =$%$3(&! 3*29!

=12/J(%8! &#$(*! +(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,D! P+! &#(+! /,&2J(%$! 3.9(1,! /2%+(+&+! 23! 5(33$*$%&! 1(8.%5+! K(&#!

9.G2*!2)$*1.>>(%8!$33$/&+M! (&!K2015!=$!5(33(/01&! &2! 3(%5!.%! (%#(=(&2*! &#.&!/.%!=12/J!.11! 1(8.%5+!

+(901&.%$20+1,D!!P+!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!.*$!&#$!92+&!/#.*./&$*(R$5!1(8.%5+M!%$0&*.1(R(%8!.%&(=25($+!

#.)$!=$$%!5$)$12>$5!.8.(%+&!&#$+$!&K2M!1$.)(%8!+(8%.1(%8!3*29!6-e�M!6-et!.%5!6-e�!(%&./&D!P+!

&#$+$!.*$!%2&!K$11!+&05($5M! (&! (+!%2&!/1$.*! (3! &#$+$! 1(8.%5+!/.%!&.J$!+29$!30%/&(2%+!2)$*! 3*29!

6-ev! 2*! 6-euM! .%5! *$50%5.%/,! (+! %2&! *01$5! 20&D! <#$*$32*$M! =12/J(%8! 5(*$/&1,! &#$! *$/$>&2*!

/29>1$d!(+!92*$!$33(/($%&M!.=*28.&(%8!&#$!$%&(*$!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,D!Q0*!8*20>!#.+!

>*2)(5$5! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! .=*28.&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e! +(8%.1(%8! &#*208#! 6-eP:Z! /.%! /2%3$*!

*$+(+&.%/$! &2!<e-F!.%5!;ECF(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,D!<#$!?0$+&(2%!*$9.(%+!K#$&#$*!K$!/.%!./#($)$!

+(9(1.*! *$+01&+! (%! 2&#$*! +#2/J! .%5! .0&2(990%$! 925$1+D! "()$%! &#$(*! *21$! (%! &#$! .%&()(*.1!

5$3$%+$M! &#(+! /$*&.(%1,! *$>*$+$%&+! .! /2%/$*%! 32*! /1(%(/.1! 0+$D! P+! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! #.+! =$$%!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! &2! (%3$/&(2%+M! (&! (+! %2&! 0%/2992%! &2! 3$.*! (%/*$.+$5!

*(+J!23!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+D!g2K$)$*M!=12/J(%8!6-eP:Zl6-eP:j!+(8%.1(%8!+>.*$+!&,>$!66!.%5!666!6-e!

.%5! 30*&#$*! +&05($+! +#2015! (%)$+&(8.&$! (3! &#$+$! >.&#K.,+! /.%! >*2)(5$! +033(/($%&! .%&()(*.1!

5$3$%+$D!

Page 60: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 47 of 237

0(96%('&&3<%(=)=2%&(432(45("4<2*48(

0Y-(164"J(=)<$*4&%=(

NJ8J8+O*&*2<3+<.-*)1.+

;(*/01.&2*,! +#2/J! +,%5*29$+! /.%! =$! 5()(5$5! (%! n! /.&$82*($+A! ! /.*5(28$%(/M! #,>2)21$9(/M!

2=+&*0/&()$!.%5!5(+&*(=0&()$!+#2/JMjjp!=0&!2%1,!5(+&*(=0&()$!+#2/J!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5! (%!5$>&#!

=$/.0+$!23!20*!(%&$*$+&!(%!(&+!(%31.99.&2*,!.+>$/&+D!!

<#(+!/.&$82*,!/.%!=$!/1.++(3($5!(%&2!320*!&,>$+!(%/105(%8!.%.>#,1./&(/!+#2/J!K#$*$!.%!.11$*8(/!

*$./&(2%!(+!$d.88$*.&$5!=,!&#$!=25,!.%5!*$+01&+! (%! (&/#,!*.+#M! &#*2.&!+K$11(%8!.%5!12K!=1225!

>*$++0*$D! 6%+$/&! =(&$+! 2*! +&(%8+M! 3225+! .%5!9$5(/.&(2%+! .*$! /2992%! /.0+$+! 23! +0/#! +$*(20+!

.11$*8(/! *$./&(2%+D!Q3&$%M! &#$!>*(9.*,! &*$.&9$%&! (+! &#$!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!$>(%$>#*(%! &#*208#!

(%G$/&(2%D!P!+$/2%5! &,>$!23!5(+&*(=0&()$!+#2/J! (+!J%2K%!.+!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!g$*$M!.%!0%5$*1,(%8!

(%3$/&(2%! *$+01&+! (%! ).+25(1.&.&(2%M! K#(/#! 1$.5+! &2! #,>2&$%+(2%M! 5$+>(&$! .5$?0.&$! 310(5!

*$+0+/(&.&(2%! &2! (%/*$.+$!=1225!>*$++0*$D! 6%3$/&(2%+! /.%!=$!50$! &2!=./&$*(.!2*!)(*0+$+! (%! &#$!

=1225! +&*$.9M! J%2K%! .+! =./&$*(.! .%5! )(*$9(.M! *$+>$/&()$1,! 1$.5(%8! &2! +$>+(+D! '+0.11,! &#$+$!

(%3$/&(2%+! .*$! J%2K%! 2*! .&! 1$.+&! +0+>$/&$5! &2! =$! >*$+$%&D! e$d&! &2! .%! a>2&$%&(.1V! (%3$/&(2%M!

+$>+(+!(+!/#.*./&$*(+$5!=,!5(+*0>&(2%+!23!&#$!#$.*&!.%5!*$+>(*.&2*,!*.&$M!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!.%5!

L7;!/20%&+jjnwjjqD! 6%!.! 1.&$*!>#.+$M!$%5F2*8.%!5,+30%/&(2%!/.%!2//0*M!K#$*$!2*8.%+!+0/#!.+!

1()$*M!J(5%$,+!.%5!#$.*&!/.%!=$!5.9.8$5!.%5!3.(1! &2! 30%/&(2%D!<#(+!/2%5(&(2%! (+!/.11$5!+$)$*$!

+$>+(+D! L#$%! (%&*.)$%20+! 310(5+! /.%! %2! 12%8$*! 9.(%&.(%! =1225! >*$++0*$M! &#$! >.&($%&c+!

/2%5(&(2%!K2*+$%+!.%5! &#$!>.&($%&!82$+! (%&2!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!g2K$)$*M! +29$&(9$+!%2! (%3$/&(2%!

/.%! =$! 320%5M! =0&! .11! 2&#$*! +,9>&29+! *$9.(%D! <#(+! 9$5(/.1! /2%5(&(2%! (+! *$3$**$5! &2! .+!

4,+&$9(/! 6%31.99.&2*,! :$+>2%+$! 4,%5*29$! 2*! 46:4M! /12+$1,! *$1.&$5! &2! +$>+(+Djjm! -(80*$! Z[!

5(+>1.,+! &#$! +$)$*.1! +&.8$+! K(&#! &#$(*! *$+>$/&()$! +,9>&29+! .%5! /.+$! 3.&.1(&,! *.&$Djjo! <#$!

*$9.(%(%8! &K2! &,>$+! 23! 5(+&*(=0&()$! +#2/J! .*$! /.11$5! %$0*28$%(/! +#2/JM! K#$*$! #(8#! +>(%.1!

(%G0*($+! 1$.5(%8! &2! #$925,%.9(/! (%+&.=(1(&,! .%5! &#$! 2&#$*! (+! &$*9$5! .5*$%.1! /*(+(+M! K#(/#!

Page 61: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 48 of 237

*$+01&+!3*29!(%.5$?0.&$!+&$*2(5!#2*92%$!=.1.%/$D!<#$+$!K(11!%2&!=$!5(+/0++$5D!6&!(+!/2992%1,!

=$1($)$5!&#.&!+#2/J!*$+01&+!3*29!.%!2)$*./&().&$5!(990%$!+,+&$9D!6%!%2*9.1!/(*/09+&.%/$+M!

&#$!3$$5=./J!122>!=$&K$$%!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!(990%$!/$11+!(+!J$>&!&(8#&1,!*$801.&$5M!.112K(%8!.%!

.5$?0.&$! (990%$!*$+>2%+$D!g2K$)$*M! (3! &#(+!=$/29$+!5,+*$801.&$5M! &#(+! /2015! *$+01&! (%! &22!

9.%,! ./&().&$5! /$11+D!W(/*2=(.1! 2*! +&$*(1$! +&(901(!K(11! ./&().&$! &#$! /29>1$9$%&! +,+&$9! a;p.!

.%5!;r.VM!(990%$!/$11+!+0/#!.+!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!%$0&*2>#(1+M!.%5!&#$!/.+/.5$!23!/2.801.&(2%D!

<#$+$! $)$%&+! K(11! 1$.5! &2! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! 9$5(.&2*+! +0/#! .+! >*2&$.+$+! a$1.+&.+$+M!

/211.8$%.+$+! .%5! /.&#$>+(%VM! *.5(/.1! 2d,8$%! +>$/($+M! 1(>(5! 9$5(.&2*+! a1$0J2&*($%$+M!

>*2+&.81.%5(%$+M!>1.&$1$&!./&().&(%8!3./&2*VM!).+2./&()$!3./&2*+!aeQM!$%52&#$1(%V!.%5!/,&2J(%$+!

a<e-M! 6EFZ.l=M! 6EFq! .%5! 6EFoVD! ;,&2J(%$! +&2*9+! /.%! *$+01&! (%! +(8%(3(/.%&! 5.9.8$! (%! 2*8.%+M!

>2&$%&(.11,! 1$.5(%8! &2! 901&(>1$F2*8.%! 3.(10*$! aWQ-V! .%5! $)$%&0.11,! 5$.&#D! <#$*$! .*$! %2!

(99$5(.&$! /0*$+! 32*! 5(+&*(=0&()$! +#2/J! .%5! /0**$%&1,M! 2%1,! +0>>2*&()$! &*$.&9$%&+! .*$!

.).(1.=1$D! <#$!9.(%! 82.1! (+! &2! ./#($)$!#$925,%.9(/! +&.=(1(R.&(2%D! C.&($%&+! .*$! &*$.&$5!K(&#!

310(5! *$+0+/(&.&(2%! .%5! ).+2./&()$! 5*08+! &2! *$)$*+$! #,>2&$%+(2%D! 63! &#$+$! 52! %2&! K2*JM!

#,5*2/2*&(+2%$+!.*$!.59(%(+&$*$5D!63!.%!(%3$/&(2%!(+!320%5M!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$>+(+M!+$)$*$!+$>+(+!

2*!+$>&(/!+#2/JM!.*$! &*$.&$5!K(&#!.%&(9(/*2=(.1!5*08+D!W2*$2)$*M! &#$! (%3$/&(2%!9(8#&!*$?0(*$!

+0*8(/.1! (%&$*)$%&(2%! &2!$1(9(%.&$! &#$!2*(8(%!23! (%3$/&(2%D!P%.>#,1./&(/! +#2/J! (+! &*$.&$5!K(&#!

$>(%$>*(%$M!.!#2*92%$M!K#(/#!K(11!*$F2>$%!&#$!.(*K.,+!.%5!&(8#&$%!=1225!)$++$1+!&2!(%/*$.+$!

=1225!>*$++0*$D!'%32*&0%.&$1,M!2)$*!#0%5*$5!&*(.1+!#.)$!3.(1$5!&2!*$+01&!(%!%$K!&*$.&9$%&+!32*!

+$>+(+! .%5! %2K! *$10/&.%/$! $d(+&! &2! &./J1$! &#(+! /1(%(/.1! /#.11$%8$M! (%/105(%8! &#$! 0%$d>$/&$5!

K(&#5*.K.1!23!5*2&*$/28(%!v!a./&().&$5V!=$&&$*!J%2K%!.+!O(8*(+D!jjYMjp[!<#(+!*$/29=(%.%&!32*9!

23! #09.%! ./&().&$5! >*2&$(%! ;! J%2K%! 32*! (&+! .%&(F&#*29=2&(/M! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! .%5!

>*23(=*(%21,&(/!>*2>$*&($+!K.+!0+$5!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8!3*29!+$)$*$!+$>+(+D!

'%32*&0%.&$1,M!.3&$*!.!5$/.5$!2%! &#$!9.*J$&M!.!;2/#*.%$!*$)($K!5(+$%/20*.8$5! (&+!0+$M!.+! (&!

5(5!%2&!.1&$*!92*&.1(&,!(%!+$)$*$!+$>+(+!>.&($%&+D!

Page 62: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 49 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(-,D(BM4832'4<(45(=)=2%&'"('<58#&&#2'4<(

46:4!(+!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!(%/*$.+$5!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$M!&./#,/.*5(.!a(%/*$.+$5!#$.*&!*.&$V!.%5!.=$**.%&!K#(&$!=1225! /$11! /20%&D! 63! .%! (%3$/&(2%! (+!>*$+$%&!2*! +0+>$/&$5M! &#(+! /2%5(&(2%! (+! /.11$5! +$>+(+D! 4$)$*$!+$>+(+!2//0*+!K#$%!2*8.%+!+033$*!3*29!5.9.8$D!L#$%!(%&*.)$%20+!310(5+!/.%!%2!12%8$*!9.(%&.(%!=1225!>*$++0*$! .%5!#,>2&$%+(2%! +0+&.(%+M! &#$! >.&($%&! 82$+! (%&2! +$>&(/! +#2/JM!K#(/#! $)$%&0.11,! /.%! 1$.5! &2!5$.&#D!H./#!/2%5(&(2%!#.+!.!5(33$*$%&!/.+$!3.&.1(&,!*.&$D!!

!

6%! j[ZZM! &#$! 9.%03./&0*$*! H1(! E(11,! K(&#5*$K! O(8*(+! 3*29! &#$! 9.*J$&D! ! g2K$)$*M! .+! &#$!

92*&.1(&,! *.&$! (+! jrFm[\! .%5! (&+! (%/(5$%/$! (+! (%/*$.+(%8! .%5! /2%/29(&.%&1,! &#$! $/2%29(/!

=0*5$%!23!+$>+(+M!&#$*$!(+!.!%$$5!32*!$33$/&()$!&*$.&9$%&+DjpZ!6%!2*5$*!%2&!&2!*$>$.&!&#$!3.(10*$+!

23! &#$! >.+&M! +/($%/$! (+! 3./(%8! .! %$K! /#.11$%8$! &2! 0%*.)$1! &#$! 9$/#.%(+9! 0%5$*1,(%8! +#2/J!

+,%5*29$+D! <#$! %$$5! 32*! (9>*2)$5! &#$*.>($+! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &#$! %$$5! 32*! .//0*.&$!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+D!

NJ8JK+%&+M5M0+@0'*3.+

C*$/1(%(/.1!*$+$.*/#!(+!>*(9.*(1,!/2%50/&$5!(%!+9.11!1.=!.%(9.1+!+0/#!.+!9(/$M!*.&+!.%5!*.==(&+D!

<#$! 0+$! 23! 90*(%$!925$1+! 32*! +$>+(+! .%5! 46:4! (+! #2K$)$*! *$/$()$5! K(&#! 8*$.&! +J$>&(/(+9M!

!"#!$

!!"#$%&'()*(+,'-+(&,.#/(&0123&#+&.(4#5&0623&

!!7(,+'&+,'(&,.#/(&89&.*)&

!!:;<'(&.4##$&=(44&=#->'&,.#/(&?@&999&#+&.(4#5&A&999&

!%&'('$

!!BCDB&E&<>F(=G#>&

!%)%*%$'%&'('$

!!B(*H<H&E&I>$&#+J,>&$,),J(&

!%&+,$'-.,/$

!!B(/(+(&H(*H<H&E&;%*#'(>H<#>&

01234$=,H(&F,',4<'%&+,'(&=,>&+(,=;&-*&'#&09K&F#+&H(*H<H&

& & & & & &L9K&F#+&H(/(+(&H(*H<H&

& & & & & &19K&F#+&H(*G=M&H;#=M&

Page 63: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 50 of 237

+(%/$!9(/$! 52! %2&! $%&(*$1,! 9(9(/! &#$! #09.%! +(&0.&(2%D! 4$2J! $&! .1D! 5$+/*(=$5! #2K! 8$%29(/!

*$+>2%+$+! (%! 9(/$! K$*$! %2&! +(9(1.*! &2! &#$! *$+>2%+$+! 2=+$*)$5! (%! #09.%+! =,! /29>.*(%8!

&*.09.F(%50/$5! /#.%8$+! (%! 8$%$! $d>*$++(2%! =$&K$$%! #09.%! +0=G$/&+! .%5! /2**$+>2%5(%8!

920+$!925$1+Djpj! 6%5$$5M!9(/$!.%5!9$%!5()$*8$5!.=20&!Yq!9(11(2%!,$.*+!.82M!.112K(%8!&#$(*!

*$+>$/&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9+!&2!.1&$*!.+!K$11Djpp!g2K$)$*M!.+!;.0K$1+!$&!.1D!G0+&1,!>2(%&$5!20&!(%!

.! *$>1,! &2!4$2J!$&! .1DM!90*(%$!925$1+! .*$! +&(11! )$*,!).10.=1$! &221+! &2!>*$5(/&! &#$!20&/29$!23!

+29$!5*08+!(%!5(+$.+$+DjpnMjpr! 6%!.55(&(2%M!&#$!.0&#2*+!5$%20%/$!9(+F!.%5!2)$*(%&$*>*$&.&(2%!

23!*$+01&+!K(&#!90*(%$!925$1+M!K#(/#!(+!+21$1,!&#$!*$+>2%+(=(1(&,!23!+/($%&(+&+D!e2%$&#$1$++M!(%!

2*5$*! &2! $%+0$! /1(%(/.1! &*(.1+M! $d>$*(9$%&+! +#2015! =$! /2%50/&$5! 2%! %2%F#09.%! >*(9.&$+! .+!

K$11D! P1&#208#! +9.11! .%(9.1! 925$1+! +0/#! .+! 9(/$M! /.&+! .%5! 528+! .*$! 92*$! /2%)$%($%&! 32*!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!0+$M!+29$!921$/01.*!5(33$*$%/$+!.*$!)$*,!.>>.*$%&!=$&K$$%!&#$+$!.%(9.1+!.%5!

#09.%+D!-2*!(%+&.%/$M!./&().&$5!>*2&$(%!;!(%!#09.%+!./&().&$+!&#$!/29>1$9$%&!+,+&$9M!K#(/#!

(+!%2&!2=+$*)$5!(%!*.&+D!4(9(1.*1,M!+$%+(&()(&,!&2K.*5+!$%52&2d(%+!).*($+!.92%8+&!+>$/($+U!2%1,!

&#$!/#(9>.%R$$!#.+!=$$%!*$>2*&$5!&2!=$!.+!+$%+(&()$!&2!$%52&2d(%+!.+!#09.%+Djpq!W2*$2)$*M!

50$! &2! &#$(*! 1.*8$*! =25,! +(R$! .%5! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5M! %2%F#09.%! >*(9.&$+! *$+$9=1$! &#$!

#09.%!>#,+(2128,!92*$!/12+$1,D!P59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!./&().&$5!>*2&$(%!;!*$50/$5!/2.8012>.&#(/!

.%5!#$>.&2&2d(/!$33$/&+!(%50/$5!=,!HD!/21(!.+!.!+$>+(+!925$1!(%!=.=22%+Mjpm!K#(/#!32*9$5!&#$!

*.&(2%.1$!&2!0+$!./&().&$5!>*2&$(%!;!(%!/*(&(/.11,!(11!>.&($%&+D!g2K$)$*M!&#(+!5*08!K.+!K(&#5*.K%!

3*29! &#$!9.*J$&! .3&$*! .!;2/#*.%$! *$)($K! (%!j[ZZDjpo! 429$!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+!#.)$!=$$%!

9$%&(2%$5! .1*$.5,M! =0&! #$*$! K$! K(11! 5(+/0++! &#$9! 92*$! (%&2! 5$&.(1D! <#*$$! /.&$82*($+! 23!

3*$?0$%&1,! 0+$5! .%(9.1! 925$1+! 32*! +$>+(+! /.%! =$! 5(+&(%80(+#$5A! .59(%(+&*.&(2%! 23! .%!

$d28$%20+! &2d(%! +0/#! .+! EC4U! .=*28.&(2%! 23! $%528$%20+! =.**($*+! =,! (%50/(%8! 1$.J.8$U! .%5!

(%30+(2%! 2*! (%+&(11.&(2%! 23! $d28$%20+! =./&$*(.D! <.=1$! r! 1(+&+! >$*! 925$1! &#$! .5).%&.8$+! .%5!

>(&3.11+DjpY! 6&!90+&!=$!>2(%&$5!20&! &#.&!).*(20+! /.0+$+! 32*! +$>+(+!$d(+&M! +0/#!.+! +$)$*$!=0*%+M!

>%$092%(&(+!.%5!9$%(%8(&(+!+$>+(+!.1&#208#!&#$+$!K$*$!%2&!5(+/0++$5D!<#$!32112K(%8!925$1+!

*$>*$+$%&!$(&#$*!+&$*(1$!925$1+!2*!>$*(&2%$.1!+$>+(+D!

Page 64: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 51 of 237

HOZODOZ&A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5&1AVW2&

<e-! (+! .! )$*,! >2&$%&! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$M! K#(/#! (+! >*250/$5! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! 9.%,!

+&(901(M! +0/#!.+!=./&$*(.1M!)(*.1!.%5! 30%8.1! (%3$/&(2%+D! 6&! (+!.1+2!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!*$8*$++(2%!23!

&092*+M!#$%/$! (&+!%.9$D!g2K$)$*M! (&+!0+$! (%! &#$! &*$.&9$%&!23! /.%/$*! (+!#.9>$*$5!50$! &2! (&+!

&2d(/! +(5$! $33$/&+! +0/#! .+! #,>2&$%+(2%M! 2d(5.&()$! .%5!%(&*2+.&()$! +&*$++M! #$>.&(&(+! .%5!=2K$1!

%$/*2+(+M! 01&(9.&$1,! *$+01&(%8! (%! 46:4Djn[wjnj! 7.0++! $&! .1D! /29>.*$5! &#$! $33$/&+! =$&K$$%!<e-!

.%5!EC4!.%5!92+&!$33$/&+!+0/#!.+!#,>2&#$*9(.!K$*$!/29>.*.=1$Djnp!

9#G8%(0D(!<'&#8(&4$%8=(54*(=)=2%&'"('<58#&&#2'4<(

!M"#5+%N&/7/4)%7&/(7&%_)%(7%7&-5"0&3"*&%)&/.ODXC&

!

<e-!(+!/2%+(5$*$5!&2!=$!.!+&$*(1$!925$1M!.+!&#$!+&(9010+!52$+!%2&!9.J$!0+$!23!9(/*22*8.%(+9+D!

g2K$)$*M!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!<e-!1$.5+!&2!12++!23!(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*M!K#(/#!/.0+$+!&*.%+12/.&(2%!

23!/299$%+.1!312*.Djnnwjnq!<#(+!=./&$*(.1!&*.%+12/.&(2%!(+!&#208#&!&2!.55!0>!&2!&#$!5$1$&$*(20+!

$33$/&+!23!<e-D!P59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!<e-!(+!*$8.*5$5!.+!.!+(9>1(3,(%8!925$1!.+!2%1,!2%$!/,&2J(%$!

(+!(%!$d/$++M!K#(/#!52$+!%2&!*$31$/&!&#$!/29>1$d(&,!23!&#$!/,&2J(%$!%$&K2*J!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4!

>.&($%&+D!'+0.11,!+(%81$!/,&2J(%$!925$1+!.*$!2%1,!0+$5!&2!.55*$++!&#$!*21$+!23!&#$+$!>.*&(/01.*!

!"#$%&'$()*&+' ,()*'(-'%./#("' !)0%"/%1*' 2#+%)0%"/%1*'

!"#$%&'()*%+&$ ,&'()*%+&$+-$.$)/*+0%&($ 1! 2%33()*%+&$+-$!"#$4.*56./$

1! 2+3.7($

1! 8*(9%:($

1! 8+;($3%;%:.9%*%(3$6%*5$

5<;.&$3(43%3$

4.*5+45/3%+:+7/$

1! =>(93%;4:%?%).*%+&$

1! @(9/$.)<*($%&$)+;4.9%3+&$*+$

5<;.&$3(43%3$

AB8$%&'()*%+&$ ,&'()*%+&$+-$.&$(C+7(&+<3$

*+C%&$

1! 8%;4:($

1! 2+3.7($

1! 8*(9%:($

1! 8%;%:.9%*%(3$6%*5$5<;.&$

3(43%3$4.*5+45/3%+:+7/$

1! !+C%)%*/$D(4(&D(&*$+&$E.)*(9%.:$

34()%(3$

1! F.9:/$.&D$*9.&3%(&*$%&)9(.3(3$%&$

%&?:.;;.*+9/$;(D%.*+93$;+9($

%&*(&3($*5.&$%&$5<;.&$3(43%3$

GAB$+9$GH8B$ H:*(9.*%+&$+-$*5($.&%;.:I3$

(&D+7(&+<3$49+*()*%>($

E.99%(9J$3<)5$.3$%&*(3*%&.:$

:(.0.7($

1! F.9:/$3%:(&*$4(9%+D$

1! K+D(9.*($.&D$D(:./(D$4(.0$

+-$;(D%.*+93$

1! K<*%4:($E.)*(9%.:$?:+9.$

1! H7($.&D$3*9.%&$>.9%.E%:%*/$

1! 2%-?%)<:*$*+$.&.:/L($

4.*5+45/3%+:+7%).:$4.*56./3$

1! 8(>(9%*/$:.EMD(4(&D(&*$

1! F.9:/$5(;+D/&.;%)$4(9%+D$%&$

3+;($;+D(:3$

1! 8<DD(&$D(.*5$N35+9*(9$D<9.*%+&$

+-$D%3(.3($*5.&$%&$5<;.&3O$

,3)5(;%.P

9(4(9-<3%+&$

%&'<9/$

,&D<)*%+&$+-$%3)5(;%)$4(9%+D$

-+::+6(D$E/$9(*<9&(D$E:++D$

?:+6$

1! 8*(9%:($

1! Q(3(;E:.&)($*+$5<;.&$

3*9+0($

1! A(33$49+&+<&)(D$)+;4:(;(&*$

.)*%>.*%+&$

,&-<3%+&$+9$

%&3*%::.*%+&$HD;%&%3*9.*%+&$+-$(C+7(&+<3$

E.)*(9%.$$

1! F.9:/$5/4(9D/&.;%)$3*.*($ 1! "+$)5.&7($%&$%&*9.9(&.:$

;%)9+)%9)<:.*%+&$

Adapted and extended from Doi K, 2009, JCI !

Page 65: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 52 of 237

/,&2J(%$+M!=0&!2%$!90+&!&.J$!/.0&(2%!(%!(%&$*>*$&(%8!*$+01&+!.+!901&(>1$!/,&2J(%$+!2)$*1.>!(%!

30%/&(2%+!.%5!$)$%!$%#.%/$!$./#!2&#$*Djnm!

HOZODOD&S*4"4".9$/++;/5*7%&1S\M2&

EC4! (+! .! <E:n! .82%(+&M! .%5! (+! .! /29>2%$%&! 23! "*.9F%$8.&()$! =./&$*(.M! K#(/#! $1(/(&+! .%!

(%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$D! 6&! (+! *$8.*5$5! .+! .%! $%52&2d(%M! .%5! &#208#&! &2! =$! (%)21)$5! (%! &#$!

>.&#28$%$+(+!23!+$>+(+D!6%G$/&(2%!23!EC4!9(9(/+!9.%,!$.*1,!3$.&0*$+!23!46:4!+0/#!.+!(%/*$.+$5!

1$)$1+! 23! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+U! &,>(/.11,! <e-! .%5! 6EFZD! 6&! (+! .! +&$*(1$! 925$1M! (D$D! (&!

(%50/$+! +$>+(+F1(J$! +,9>&29+! K(&#20&! &#$! ./&0.1! >*$+$%/$! 23! =./&$*(.! (%! &#$! =1225! +&*$.9!

a=./&$*$9(.VD! EC4! (%50/$+! .1+2! *$%.1! (%G0*,M! 5$/*$.+$5! 8129$*01.*! 3(1&*.&(2%! *.&$M! $1$).&$5!

=1225! 0*$.! %(&*28$%! .%5! (%/*$.+$5! %$0&*2>#(1! (%3(1&*.&(2%! (%! &#$! J(5%$,+DjnoMjnY! EC4! #.+! &#$!

.5).%&.8$!&#.&!(&!./&().&$+!/$*&.(%!>.&#K.,+M!+(9>1(3,(%8!&#$!/29>1$d!(9.8$!23!+$>+(+M!=0&!%2&!

&2! &#$! +.9$! $d&$%&! .+! <e-D! <#$! 52+$! /.%! =$! .5G0+&$5! 2*! &(&*.&$5M! K#(/#! .112K+! +&05,(%8!

+,+&$9(/!.%5!*$%.1!*$+>2%+$+!50*(%8!&#$! (%(&(.1!>#.+$+!23!+$>+(+!.+! 12K!52+$+!23!EC4! 1$.5!&2!

5$/*$.+$5!8129$*01.*!>$*30+(2%!=0&!%2!+,+&$9(/!#,>2&$%+(2%D!70&!(&+!&2d(/(&,!/.%!5$>$%5!2%!

K#(/#!=./&$*(.1!+>$/($+!(&!(+!5$*()$5!3*29!.+!K$11!.+!K#(/#!90*(%$!=./J8*20%5!(+!0+$5!(%!&#$!

$d>$*(9$%&D! <#(+! /29>1(/.&$+! +&.%5.*5(R.&(2%! (%! &#$! +/($%&(3(/! /2990%(&,D! ! W2*$2)$*M! .+! .!

+$>+(+!925$1M!EC4!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!+0(&.=1$!.+!(&!/.0+$+!90/#!$.*1($*!.%5!#(8#$*!>$.J!1$)$1+!23!

/,&2J(%$+!/29>.*$5!&2!K#.&!(+!2=+$*)$5!(%!#09.%!+$>+(+!.%5!(+!*$8.*5$5!.+!.%!2)$*+(9>1(3($5!

925$1!23!K#.&!(+!./&0.11,!#.>>$%(%8!(%!+$>+(+Djr[!

HOZODOX&?%+/.&S*8/)*"(&\#(+)#5%&1?S\2&

;$/.1!1(8.&(2%!>0%/&0*$!(+!.!+0*8(/.1!>*2/$50*$!(%)21)(%8!(+21.&(2%M!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$!23!&#$!

/$/09!*(8#&!=$12K!&#$!(1$2/$/.1!).1)$D!6%&$+&(%.1!/2%&$%&!/.%!1$.J!&#*208#!&#$!%$$51$F(%50/$5!

>0%/&0*$!.%5!>21,9(/*2=(.1!=./&$*$9(.!.%5!+$>+(+!$%+0$+D!7,!.5G0+&(%8!&#$!1$%8&#!23!1(8.&$5!

/$/09! .%5! &#$! +(R$! 23! %$$51$! >0%/&0*$M! .! ).*,(%8! 5$8*$$! 23! +$)$*(&,! /.%! =$! ./#($)$5DjrZMjrj!

I.*(20+!=./&$*(.1! +>$/($+! .*$! 320%5! (%! &#$!=1225! +&*$.9!.%5! &#$! (%50/$5! /,&2J(%$!>*23(1$! (+!

+(9(1.*! &2! &#.&! (%!#09.%!+$>+(+D!<#$!>*28*$++(2%!23!46:4!.%5!901&(>1$!2*8.%! 3.(10*$!.*$!.1+2!

Page 66: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 53 of 237

/29>.*.=1$! .%5! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&! 3.(1+! &2! .9$1(2*.&$! &#$! 5(+$.+$! (%! ;ECF.%(9.1+! .+!K$11M!

.%2&#$*! *$+$9=1.%/$! &2! &#$! #09.%! 5(+$.+$jrpD! P%2&#$*! +(9(1.*(&,! /29>*(+$+! &#$! &K2F+&.8$!

(990%2128,!23!+$>+(+D!P&!3(*+&!.!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!>#.+$!(+!2=+$*)$5M!K#(/#!(+!32112K$5!=,!.!

/29>$%+.&2*,! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! >#.+$U! ;EC! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! .>2>&2+(+! 23!

1,9>#2/,&$+! 9(9(/J(%8! &#$! (990%2+0>>*$++()$! >#.+$! 23! #09.%! +$>+(+D! P1&#208#! (&! (+! .!

K(5$1,! 0+$5! 925$1M! &#$! &$/#%(?0$! /.%! =$! >$*32*9$5! (%! ).*(20+! K.,+! .%5! &#0+! #.9>$*+!

+&.%5.*5(R.&(2%! .%5! 1$.5+! &2! 1.=F5$>$%5$%&! ;EC! >*2/$50*$+D! <#$! +$)$*(&,! 23! ;EC!9.,! &#0+!

+(9>1,! 5$>$%5!2%! &#$! #.==(&+! 23! &#$! *$+$.*/#! 8*20>DjrZ! 6%! .//2*5.%/$M! &#$! 32112KF0>!23! &#$!

$d>$*(9$%&! /.%! .1+2! ).*,! .92%8+&! 1.=2*.&2*($+! +0/#! .+! 8()(%8! +0>>2*&()$! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#!

310(5+!.%5!.%&(=(2&(/+DjpYMjrZMjrn!

HOZODOY&?"."(&/$+%(7%($&$)%()&4%5*)"(*)*$&

;P4C!(+!.!+0*8(/.1!(%&$*)$%&(2%!.+!K$11!K#$*$!.!+&$%&!(+!(%+$*&$5!(%&2!&#$!.+/$%5(%8!/212%!*(8#&!

%$d&!&2!&#$!/$/09U!1$.J!3*29!&#$!+&$%&!(%&2!&#$!>$*(&2%$.1!/.)(&,M!K#(/#!1$.5+!&2!>21,9(/*2=(.1!

>$*(&2%(&(+!.%5!+0=+$?0$%&1,!+$>+(+Djrr!;P4C!(+!.!925$1!32*!5(330+$!>$*(&2%(&(+!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!

.!+&*2%8!.%5!+&$.5(1,! (%/*$.+(%8!#,>$*(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$M!K#$*$.+!;EC!(+!/2%+(5$*$5!&2!

=$!.!925$1! 32*!.%!.=+/$++! (%! &#$!.=529$%! 1$.5(%8!&2! 12K$*! 1$.J.8$!23!/299$%+.1! 312*.!.%5!

/2%/29(&.%&!/,&2J(%$+D!72&#!925$1+!.*$!*$8.*5$5!.+!/29>1$9$%&.*,Djrn&

HOZODOH&,$+;%0*/`5%4%5-#$*"(&*(K#59&

L#$%! =1225! /(*/01.&(2%! (+! #.9>$*$5M! %0&*($%&+! .%5! 2d,8$%! .*$! %2&! >*2)(5$5! &2! &#$! /$11+M!

/.0+(%8!(+/#$9(.!(%!&(++0$+!.%5!2*8.%+D!:$>$*30+(2%!(%G0*,!*$+01&+!3*29!*$+&2*.&(2%!23!=1225!

312KM! K#(/#! 1$.5+! &2! (%31.99.&(2%! .%5! 2d(5.&()$! 5.9.8$! (%+&$.5! 23! *$+&2*.&(2%! 23! %2*9.1!

30%/&(2%D!4$)$*.1!&,>$+!23!(+/#$9(.!925$1+!.*$!>*$+$%&!.%5!+29$!*$>*$+$%&!).10.=1$!&221+!(%!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!+&*2J$!*$+$.*/#D!P!)$*,!K$11!J%2K%!32*9!23!(+/#$9(.l*$>$*30+(2%!925$1!(%!9(/$!

(+! /.11$5! ./0&$! J(5%$,! (+/#$9(.! aPi6VM! K#(/#! /.%! =$! *$>*250/$5! (%! &#$! J(5%$,!

(+/#$9(.l*$>$*30+(2%!925$1! =,! *$%.1! /1.9>(%8D! g2K$)$*M! &#$!925$1! (+! 1$++! +&.=1$M! ,($15(%8!

).*(.=1$!*$+01&+jrqMjrm!

Page 67: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 54 of 237

HOZODOa&,(-#$*"(&"5&*($)*../)*"(&"-&%_"8%("#$&L/+)%5*/&

4$>+(+!52$+!%2&!%$/$++.*(1,!*$+01&! 3*29!>21,9(/*2=(.1! (%3$/&(2%U!.!+(%81$!>.&#28$%!/.%!/.0+$!

&#$! $d.88$*.&$5! (990%$! *$+>2%+$! .+! K$11D! '+(%8! (%30+(2%! 2*! (%+&(11.&(2%! 925$1+M! 2%$! /.%!

(%&*250/$!.!+(%81$!>.&#28$%!(%!.!/2%&*211$5!9.%%$*M!K#(/#!.55+!0>!&2!&#$!*$>*250/(=(1(&,D!<#(+!

(+!$+>$/(.11,!0+$301!&2!9(9(/!%2+2/29(.1!(%3$/&(2%+!+0/#!.+!>%$092%(.D!6%!.55(&(2%M!&#$!*$+01&+!

8.(%$5! 3*29! &#$+$! $d>$*(9$%&+! .*$! >.&#28$%F+>$/(3(/! &#.&! .112K+! &#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23!

+>$/(.1(R$5!&*$.&9$%&+D!

NJ8JI+A03*+06+!"#A8+<&'+%#"BA8+5&+.>0)E+.,&'20@*.+

EC4! (%50/$+! <e-! .%5! 6-eu! 50*(%8! &#$! /,&2J(%$! +&2*9D! <#$*$! #.)$! =$$%!9.%,! +&05($+! &#.&!

*$)$.1!&#$!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!*21$!23!=2&#!/,&2J(%$+!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,M!5$+/*(=$5!$.*1($*!

(%! &#(+!/#.>&$*D! 6-eu!>*250/$5!=,!EC4F+&(901.&$5!9./*2>#.8$+! (+! &#208#&! &2!+,%$*8(+&(/.11,!

.089$%&! &#$! $d>*$++(2%! 23! (eQ4! .%5! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! eQU! &#(+! K.+! %2&! .33$/&$5! =,!

9./*2>#.8$F5$*()$5! <e-Djro! -0*&#$*92*$M! EC4F./&().&$5! 92%2/,&$+! *$+>2%5! &2! 6-eu! =,!

$%#.%/(%8!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&+!23!<e-!.%5!6EFZu!(%5(/.&(%8!.!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!6-e!

+(8%.1(%8! (%! EC4DjrY! P+! 5$+/*(=$5! .=2)$M! &#$! 6-eul6-eP:Z! (%&$*./&(2%! (+! &#$! 5$&$*9(%(%8!

3./&2*!32*!+0*)().1!(%!EC4M!=0&!&#$!$33$/&+!2%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8M!.%2&#$*!(9>2*&.%&!9$5(.&2*!23!EC4!

&2d(/(&,! .*$! %2&! J%2K%DZr[MZq[Mjq[! 6%! &#$! >*$)(20+! +$/&(2%+M! .*809$%&+! 32*! =2&#! +(8%.1(%8!

>.&#K.,+!K$*$!8()$%!&2!$%32*/$!&#$(*!*21$+!(%!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+M!*.(+(%8!&#$!?0$+&(2%!K#$&#$*!

&#$+$!>.&#K.,+!(%&$*./&!K(&#!$./#!2&#$*D!<*$.&9$%&!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+!32*!W4!2*!g;I!)(*0+!#.+!

=$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! <e-:Z! 1$)$1+M! (%310$%/(%8! &#$! 2)$*.11! $33$/&! 23! <e-!

+(8%.1(%8DjqZ! 4,%$*8(+&(/! $33$/&+! =$&K$$%! <e-! .%5! 6-eu! #.)$! =$$%! *$>2*&$5DZm[Mjqjwjqm! <#$+$!

*$>2*&+!+#2K$5!&#.&!<e-!.%5!6-eP:Z!/.%!./&!(%!/2%/$*&!&2!$%#.%/$!(%31.99.&(2%!1$.5(%8!&2!.!

3.&.1!/2%5(&(2%D!g2K$)$*M! &#$!$d./&! (%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!=2&#!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,+!#.+!%2&!=$$%!

.55*$++$5!(%!+$>+(+!,$&D!

Page 68: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 55 of 237

0Y+(!324'&&3<%($'=%#=%=(

NJKJ8+O*&*2<3+<.-*)1.+

P0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! *$>*$+$%&! .! /1.++! 23! /#*2%(/! 5(+$.+$+! (%)21)(%8! $d.88$*.&$5! (990%$!

*$+>2%+$+! /.0+$5! =,! /,&2J(%$! 5,+*$801.&(2%D! <#(+! 1$.5+! &2! ./0&$! 23! /#*2%(/! (%31.99.&(2%M!

*$+01&(%8! (%! 5(+.=(1(&,D! 6&! (+! $+&(9.&$5! &#.&! K2*15K(5$! o! \! 23! &#$! >2>01.&(2%! +033$*+! 3*29!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+U!(%!L$+&$*%!/20%&*($+!&#$!(%/(5$%/$!(+!rFm!\D!W2*$!&#.%!mr\!23!>.&($%&+!

.*$!K29$%M!+088$+&(%8!.!+&*2%8! 1(%J!=$&K$$%!#2*92%$+M!5(>12(5,!23! &#$!O!/#*292+29$!.%5!

&#$! (990%$! +,+&$9! .1&#208#! &#$! $d./&! 9$/#.%(+9! #.+! %2&! ,$&! =$$%! $10/(5.&$5Djqowjm[!

P0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!/.%!>*$+$%&!(%!5(33$*$%&!32*9+!.%5!(%/105$!.!).*($&,!23!(11%$++$+M!+0/#!.+!

;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!a;@VM!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+!a';VM!>+2*(.+(+M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!a:PV!.%5!901&(>1$!

+/1$*2+(+! aW4V!.+! +#2K%! (%!-(80*$!ZZD!e2%$!23! &#$+$!#.)$!.! /1$.*!$&(2128,M!=0&! .11! +#.*$! &#$!

&,>(/.11,!2)$*./&().&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!>.&#K.,+!+088$+&(%8!.!/2992%!0%5$*1,(%8!5*()$D!!W2*$!

(9>2*&.%&1,M! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! .*$! 23&$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! 92*=(5(&,! +0/#! .+!

/.*5(2).+/01.*!5(+$.+$+M!9$&.=21(/! +,%5*29$!.%5!5$>*$++(2%D!<#$*$! .*$! +$)$*.1!#,>2&#$+$+!

.=20&! &#$! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23! .0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D! P0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!9.,!>2++(=1,! *$+01&!

3*29!921$/01.*!9(9(/*,!K#$*$!.!9(/*2=(.1!>$>&(5$!*$+$9=1$+!.!`+$13!>$>&(5$_M!*$+01&(%8!(%!.!

/2%30+$5! .&&./J! 23! &#$! #2+&c+! (990%$! +,+&$9DjmZ! P%2&#$*! $d>1.%.&(2%! (+! &#$! #,8($%$!

#,>2&#$+(+A! &#$!L2*15! g$.1&#! Q*8.%(R.&(2%! >*2)(5$+! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! 5(+$.+$+! +0/#! .+! &,>$FZ!

5(.=$&$+!.%5!W4!.*$!0%/2992%!(%!92+&!P3*(/.%!.%5!P+(.%!>2>01.&(2%+M!=0&!/1$.*1,! (%/*$.+$!

K#$%! &#$+$! >2>01.&(2%+! 9(8*.&$! &2! 925$*%! +$&&(%8+DjmjMjmp! P! &#(*5! >2++(=(1(&,! >0&+! &#$!

$%)(*2%9$%&! .&! 3.01&D! P1&#208#! 8$%$&(/+! .%5! $>(8$%$&(/+! >1.,! .! *21$M! $%)(*2%9$%&.1! &*(88$*+!

+0/#!.+!(%3$/&(2%+M!).//(%$+M!$d28$%20+!3$9.1$!.%5!3,&2#2*92%$+M!3$&.1!=1225!/$11+M!+&*$++M!'IF

7! *.5(.&(2%M! )(&.9(%! @! 5$3(/($%/,M! 5*08+M! >2110&.%&+! .%5! &2d(%+! 9.,! (%50/$! .0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+! (%! >*$5(+>2+$5! >2>01.&(2%+D! -2*! +29$! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+M! .! +&*2%8! .++2/(.&(2%!

K(&#!(%3$/&(20+!.8$%&+!#.+!=$$%!320%5M!1(+&$5!(%!<.=1$!qDjqoMjmnwjmq!W2+&!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!

Page 69: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 56 of 237

=$%$3(&! 3*29!<e-! (%#(=(&(2%M!K#(/#! /1$.*1,! (%5(/.&$+!<e-! (+! .! /2992%!5*()(%8! 32*/$M! =0&! .+!

5(+/0++$5!=$32*$M!(&+!0+$!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!+(5$!$33$/&+M!2*!+0=>2>01.&(2%+!52!%2&!*$+>2%5!&2!

&#$!&#$*.>,D!e$K!&*$.&9$%&+!.*$!=$(%8!5$)$12>$5!.%5!$).10.&$5!+0/#!.+!(%#(=(&(2%!23!&#$!6EF

jpl6EFZm!.d(+D!P0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!K$*$!>*$)(20+1,!*$8.*5$5!.+!.!*$+01&!3*29!5,+*$801.&$5!

<#ZF<#j!=.1.%/$M! =0&! (&! #.+! =$/29$! /1$.*! &#.&! &#$! 6EFjpl6EFZm! .d(+! 2*! <#Zm! (990%(&,! .1+2!

>1.,+!.!>.&#2128(/.1!*21$!(%!+$)$*.1!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!

!

?'Q3*%(--D(I'55%*%<2(4*Q#<=(#*%(#55%"2%$('<(#324'&&3<%($'=%#=%=(

H./#! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$! (+! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! .%! 2*8.%! &#.&! (+! 9.G2*1,! .33$/&$5! =,! &#$! #2+&c+!#,>$*./&()$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!67@!9.%(3$+&+!(&+$13!9.(%1,!(%!&#$!=2K$1M!K#$*$.+!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+M!&,>(/.11,!&#$!G2(%&+!.*$!.&&./J$5!=,!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!C+2*(.+(+!(+!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!*$5!+/.1,!>.&/#$+!2%!&#$!+J(%!.%5!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!(+!>2*&*.,$5!.+!1$+(2%+!5$&$/&$5!(%!&#$!=*.(%D!!

NJKJK+D.025<.5.+P=*&*2<3Q+

C+2*(.+(+!)018.*(+!(+!.!/#*2%(/!(%31.99.&2*,!+J(%!5(+$.+$!K(&#!.!>*$).1$%/$!(%!.501&+!*.%8(%8!

3*29![MYZFoMr\!.%5!(%!/#(15*$%!3*29![FjMZ\D!'%1(J$!92+&!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M! (&!52$+!%2&!

.>>$.*! &2! #.)$! .! 8$%5$*! >*$5(1$/&(2%M! =2&#! 9.1$! .%5! 3$9.1$! +$$9! $?0.11,! .33$/&$5Mjoo! =0&!

&#$*$! (+! .%! .>>.*$%&! 8$28*.>#(/! 1(J$1(#225! 23! #.)(%8! >+2*(.+(+A! (&+! >*$).1$%/$! &$%5+! &2!

(%/*$.+$!K(&#! &#$! 5(+&.%/$! 3*29! &#$! $?0.&2*DjoYMjY[! <#$! $&(2128,! (+! >*$+09$5!901&(3./&2*(.1M!

(%)21)(%8!.%!(%&(9.&$!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!8$%$&(/!.%5!$%)(*2%9$%&.1!3./&2*+D!

Page 70: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 57 of 237

9#G8%([D(!324'&&3<%($'=%#=%=("#<(G%(#==4"'#2%$(K'26(=:%"'5'"('<5%"2'4<=(

!I'=%#=%( !==4"'#2%$('<5%"2'4<=( 7%5%*%<"%=(

W01&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+! • H>+&$(%F7.**!)(*0+!aH7IV!• W$.+1$+!)(*0+!

• jmm!• jmo!

<,>$FZ!5(.=$&$+! • ;2d+./J($!)(*0+!7n!• :0=$11.!)(*0+!• ;,&29$8.12)(*0+!a;WIV!• W09>+!)(*0+!

• jmY!• jo[!• joZ!• joj!

:#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+! • H+/#$*(/#(.!/21(!• W,/2=./&$*(.!• H7I!• g$>.&(&(+!;!)(*0+!ag;IV!

• jop!• jon!• jor!• joq!

"0&&.&$!>+2*(.+(+! • 4&*$>&2/2//0+!>,28$%$+! • jom!

C+2*(.+(+! .%5! >+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+!

• g09.%! (990%25$3(/($%/,! )(*0+!ag6IV!

• jmn!

!

!

C+2*(.+(+! (+!233(/(.11,!/.&$82*(R$5! (%!r! &,>$+A!>1.?0$!a)018.*(+VM!80&&.&$M! (%)$*+$M!>0+&01.*!.%5!

$*,&#*25$*9(/! >+2*(.+(+M! .%5! >+2*(.&(/! .*&#*(&(+! K#(/#! .33$/&+! &#$! G2(%&+! .+! K$11D! C1.?0$!

>+2*(.+(+! (+! &#$! 92+&! /2992%! .%5! =$+&F/#.*./&$*(R$5! &,>$D! C+2*(.+(+! (+! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,!

*.(+$5M! 5$9.*/.&$5M! $*,&#$9.&20+! 2).1! >1.?0$+! K(&#! .5#$*$%&! +(1)$*,! +/.1$+M! K#(/#! *$+01&!

3*29! #,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%! 23! &#$! $>(5$*9(+D! <#$+$! >.&#28$%(/! /#.%8$+! *$+01&! 3*29!

5,+*$801.&(2%! (%! &#$! +J(%D! 7.+(/.11,M! &#$! +J(%! /.%! =$! 5()(5$5! (%&2! &#*$$! 1.,$*+A! $>(5$*9(+M!

5$*9(+!.%5!#,>25$*9(+D!<#$!1.&&$*!(+!.1+2!*$3$**$5!&2!.+!&#$!+0=/0&.%$20+!.5(>2+$!1.,$*!.%5!

9.(%1,!30%/&(2%+!.+!.!&#$*9.1!(+21.&2*D!6&!.1+2!>*2)(5$+!>*2&$/&(2%!.+!.!`/0+#(2%_!.%5!$%+0*$+!

.&&./#9$%&! &2! &#$!90+/01.*! &(++0$+! =$%$.&#D! <#$! 5$*9(+! (+! &#$! +$/2%5! 2*! (%%$*! 1.,$*D! <#$!

5$*9(+!/2%+(+&+!23!.!>.>(11.*,!.%5!.!*$&(/01.*! 1.,$*!.%5!/2%&.(%+!=1225!.%5!1,9>#!)$++$1+D! 6&!

.1+2!8()$+!*(+$!&2!&#$!#.(*!3211(/1$+M!=0&!(+!9.(%1,!>2>01.&$5!=,!3(=*2=1.+&+D!6&!5(*$/&+!$>(5$*9.1!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! &#*208#! %0&*($%&+! .%5! 2&#$*! +(8%.11(%8! /0$+D! 6&! (+! .1+2! *$+>2%+(=1$! 32*! &#$!

>*250/&(2%! 23! +K$.&! .%5! +$=09! &#*208#! 81.%5+D! 4$=09! (+! .%! 2(1,! +0=+&.%/$! &#.&! >*$)$%&+!

5$#,5*.&(2%D!72&#!+0=+&.%/$+!*$./#!&#$!+0*3./$!)(.!>2*$+D!<#$!&#(*5!+J(%!1.,$*M!&#$!$>(5$*9(+M!

(+!&#$!20&$*!1.,$*!&#.&!(+!(%!/2%&./&!K(&#!&#$!$d&$*%.1!$%)(*2%9$%&D!6&!(+!.).+/01.*!.+!(&!52$+!%2&!

/2%&.(%! .%,! =1225! )$++$1+D! g$.1&#,! $>(5$*9.1! &(++0$! /.%! =$! 5(+&(%80(+#$5! (%! n! 1.,$*+M! (%!

.+/$%5(%8!2*5$*A!(D!+&*.&09!=.+.1$l8$*9(%.&()09!(+!&#$!=.+.1!1.,$*D!6&!(+!&#$!>*21(3$*.&(2%!R2%$!

Page 71: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 58 of 237

.%5!>*2)(5$+! 3(*9!.&&./#9$%&!23! &#$!$>(5$*9(+! &2! &#$!=.+.1! 1.9(%.D! ((D! +&*.&09!+>(%2+09!2*!

+>(%20+! 1.,$*M! J%2K%!.+! &#$! (%(&(.1!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!R2%$D! (((D! +&*.&09!8*.%012+09!2*!8*.%01.*!

1.,$*U! >*250/$+! /2*%3($15! $%)$12>$! >*2&$(%+M! /*2++1(%J(%8! $%R,9$+! .%5! 1(>(5+D! ()D! +&*.&09!

/2*%$09!2*! /2*%3($15! 1.,$*U!K#(/#! (+! /29>2+$5!23!5$.5! 31.&&$%$5!J$*.&(%2/,&$+M! /*2++1(%J$5!

>*2&$(%+! .%5! $d&*05$5! 1(>(5+! &2! 32*9! &#$! 3(%.1! $>(5$*9.1! =.**($*D! 4(9(1.*1,! &2! &#$! $>(&#$1(.1!

1(%(%8! 23! &#$! 8.+&*2(%&$+&(%.1! &*./&M! &#$! +J(%! *$%$K+! /2%+&.%&1,A! 2%! .)$*.8$! &#$! #09.%!

$>(5$*9(+! &0*%+! 2)$*! $)$*,! n[Frq! 5.,+DjYZ! <#(+! (9>1($+! .! /2%&(%020+! %$$5! 32*! %$K! /$11+!

>*2)(5$5!=,! &#$!=.+.1!J$*.&(%2/,&$+! (%! &#$!+&*.&09!8$*9(%.&()09D!<#$,!5()(5$!/2%&(%020+1,!

.%5!32*9!.!%$K!1.,$*M!>0+#(%8!&#$!/$11+!.=2)$!0>K.*5+D!<#$!5$.5!/$11+!(%!&#$!/2*%3($15!1.,$*!

+#$5! 233D! <#(+! >*21(3$*.&()$! >2&$%&(.1! (+! *$+&*(/&$5! &2! &#$! =.+.1! 1.,$*! 50$! &2! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23!

.501&!+&$9!/$11!>2>01.&(2%+D!<#$+$!+&$9!/$11+!*$+(5$!(%!&#$!(%&$*3211(/01.*!$>(5$*9(+!.%5!(%!&#$!

=018$!*$8(2%!23!#.(*!3211(/1$+DjYj!<#$,!.*$!901&(>2&$%&!.%5!8()$!*(+$!&2!).*(20+!/$11!&,>$+!K#(/#!

K(11! =0(15F0>! &#$! $>(5$*9(+M! (%/105(%8! .11! 1.,$*+M! #.(*! 3211(/1$+! .%5! +$=./$20+! 81.%5+D!

P+,99$&*(/.1!5()(+(2%!J$$>+!&#$!$>(5$*9.1!+&$9!/$11+!/2%+&.%&D!-2112K(%8!9(&2+(+M!2%$!23!&#$!

5.08#&$*!/$11+!K(11!K(&#5*.K!3*29!&#$!/$11!/,/1$!.%5!82!(%&2!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%M!K#$*$.+!&#$!2&#$*!

/$11! *$9.(%+! >*21(3$*.&()$D! <#$! =.1.%/$! =$&K$$%! >*21(3$*.&(2%! .%5! &$*9(%.1! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!

/#.%8$+!K#$%!&#$!+J(%!(+!+&*$++$5!50$!&2!K20%5(%8!2*!(%31.99.&(2%D!-2*!(%+&.%/$!K20%5(%8!

K(11!32*/$!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!&2!3.)20*!>*21(3$*.&(2%!.%5!9(8*.&(2%!2)$*!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%M!3(11(%8!.%5!

/12+(%8!&#$!+(&$!23!(%G0*,D!P3&$*!/12+0*$M!&#(+!>*21(3$*.&()$!/.>./(&,!90+&!+K(&/#!&2!&#$!&$*9(%.1!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!>*28*.9!(%!2*5$*!&2!*$F$+&.=1(+#!&#$!&(++0$F+>$/(3(/!.*/#(&$/&0*$DjYp!

H>(5$*9.1!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!32112K+!.!+&*(/&!>*28*.9M!K#$*$!$./#!1.,$*!#.+!(&+!0%(?0$!$d>*$++(2%!

>*23(1$! a-(80*$!ZjVD! 6&!=$8(%+! 3*29!&#$!9(&2&(/.11,!./&()$!=.+.1! 1.,$*!K#$*$!901&(>2&$%&!/$11+!

5()(5$D! Q%$! 23! &#$! 5.08#&$*! /$11+! K(11! K(&#5*.K! 3*29! &#$! /$11! /,/1$! 32112K(%8! 9(&2+$+! .%5!

0%5$*82!&$*9(%.1!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D!Q%$!8*20>!23!&,>(/.1!+J(%!>*2&$(%+!(+!/.11$5!J$*.&(%+M!K#(/#!

.*$!+&*0/&0*.1!>*2&$(%+!&#.&!/2%3(%$!+&*$%8&#!&2!+J(%M!#.(*!.%5!%.(1+D!<#$(*!$d>*$++(2%!(+!1.,$*F

+>$/(3(/!.%5!(%/2**$/&!J$*.&(%!5(+&*(=0&(2%!.%5!30%/&(2%!*$+01&+!(%!12++!23!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!

Page 72: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 59 of 237

%$(8#=20*(%8!/$11+D!ir!(+!*$+&*(/&$5!&2!&#$!9(&2&(/!=.+.1! 1.,$*M!&28$&#$*!K(&#!iZn!.%5!iZrDjYn!

<#$,! $%+0*$! .! 3(*9! .&&./#9$%&! &2! &#$! +0=+&*.&09D! ir! .%5! iZn! .*$! >*250/$5! =,! =.+.1!

J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!K#(/#!K(11!32*9!.!3(1.9$%&20+!%$&K2*JD!Q%/$!/$11+!+&2>!5()(5(%8M!(%&$8*(%+!.*$!

52K%*$801.&$5! .+! .! /299(&9$%&! &2! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D! <#$! /$11+! .+/$%5! (%&2! &#$! +>(%20+! 1.,$*!

K#$*$!&#$(*!92*>#2128,!.%5!$d>*$++(2%!>*23(1$!/#.%8$+D! 6%! &0*%M!iZ!.%5!iZ[!.*$!$d>*$++$5!

.%5! .+! &#$,! 5(33$*$%&(.&$! 0>K.*5+M! ij$! (+! $d>*$++$5! .+! K$11D! 7$+(5$+! J$*.&(%+M! G0%/&(2%.1!

>*2&$(%+!.*$!.1+2!>*250/$5!%2KA!5$+92/211(%M!5$+9281$(%+!Z!.%5!pM!>1.J2>#(1(%M!HF/.5#$*(%M!

ujF/2%%$d(%M! 2//105(%! .%5! (%)210/*(%D! P&! &#$! 8*.%0120+! 1.,$*M! +>(%20+F5$*()$5! /$11+! K(11!

$d>*$++!.%2&#$*!+$&!23!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!9.*J$*+M!.92%8+&!K#(/#!>*23(1.88*(%!.%5!12*(/*(%D!<#$!

1.&&$*!K(11!=$/29$!&#$!9.G2*!/29>2%$%&!23!&#$!/2*%$.1!1.,$*D!W0&.&(2%+!(%!&#$!$%/25(%8!*$8(2%!

23!S"5!.*$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!/2%8$%(&.1!+J(%!.=%2*9.1(&($+DjYrwjYm!<#$!/2*%(3($5!1.,$*!/2%+(+&+!23!

0>!&2!p[!1.,$*+!23!5$.5!/$11+D!<#$!/2*%(3(/.&(2%!>*2/$++!(+!+29$K#.&!1(J$!.>2>&2+(+M!.1&#208#!

5(33$*$%&!>.&#K.,+!+$$9!(%)21)$5DjYo!C*2&$(%+!+0/#!.+!(%)210/*(%!.%5!12*(/*(%!.*$!/*2++1(%J$5!

32*9(%8!&#$!/2*%(3($5!$%)$12>$M!K#(/#!32*9+!.!*(8(5!+/.33215!K(&#!1(>(5+!.&&./#$5!&2!&#$!20&$*!

+0*3./$D!<#(+!$+&.=1(+#$+! &#$! 3(%.1!=.**($*!23! &#$! +J(%!>*2)(5(%8!>*2&$/&(2%! &2! &#$!#2+&D! 4(%/$!

$)$*,! 1.,$*!#.+! (&+!2K%!+>$/(3(/!$d>*$++(2%!>*23(1$M! (&! .112K+!0+! &2! (5$%&(3,!9.*J$*+! &#.&!.*$!

+>.&(2F+>$/(3(/.11,!$d>*$++$5!(%!&#$!$>(5$*9(+D!<#$!$>(5$*9(+!/2%&.(%+!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!=0&!.1+2!

9$1.%2/,&$+! .%5! (990%$! /$11+! +0/#! .+! E.%8$*#.%+! /$11+! .%5! <! 1,9>#2/,&$+M! >*2)(5(%8!

(990%(&,! &2! &#$! 1.*8$+&! 2*8.%D! i$*.&(%2/,&$+! /.%! *$./&! &2! (%).5$*+! &#*208#! &#$(*! C::+! (%!

*$+>2%+$! &2! CPWC+D! 63! <E:+! .*$! ./&().&$5M! &#$+$! /$11+! *$1$.+$! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D! 70&!

&#*$.&$%$5! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! .1+2! ./&! =,! +$/*$&(%8! .%&(F9(/*2=(.1! >*2&$(%+! +0/#! .+! /.&#$1(/(5(%!

aEEFpmVM!5$3$%+(%+!.%5!4Z[[!3.9(1,!>*2&$(%+D!6%!.55(&(2%M!./&().&$5!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!K(11!>*250/$!

/,&2J(%$+! .%5! /#$92J(%$+M! +&(901.&(%8! &#$! (%3(1&*.&(2%! 23! %$0&*2>#(1+M!9./*2>#.8$+! .%5! &#$!

*$/*0(&9$%&!23!<!/$11+D!E.%8$*#.%+!/$11+!.%5!<!1,9>#2/,&$+!*$+(5$!(%!&#$!$>(5$*9(+M!K#$*$.+!

&#$!5$*9(+!(+!$?0(>>$5!K(&#!5$*9.1!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+M!vlu!<!/$11+M!yl�!<!/$11+M!%.&0*.1!J(11$*!/$11+M!

7! /$11+M!9.+&! /$11+! .%5!9./*2>#.8$+D! P3&$*! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11+! (%! &#$! +J(%! #.)$! &.J$%!0>! 32*$(8%!

Page 73: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 60 of 237

.%&(8$%+M! &#$,!&*.33(/J!&2!+J(%F5*.(%(%8! 1,9>#!%25$+! 32*!.%&(8$%!>*$+$%&.&(2%!.%5! (%(&(.&$!.%!

.5.>&()$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!<#$!+J(%!>*2)(5$+!>*2&$/&(2%!.&!).*(20+!1$)$1+!.+!.!=.**($*!.%5!/.%!

*$./&! K(&#! (%%.&$! .%5! .5.>&()$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$+! &2! /#.11$%8$+D! '%32*&0%.&$1,M!9.%,! +J(%!

5(+$.+$+!*$+01&!3*29!.=$**.%&!30%/&(2%(%8!23!&#$!+J(%!+0/#!.+!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!.&2>(/!5$*9.&(&(+D!

<#(+!/#.>&$*!K(11!2%1,!(%&*250/$!>+2*(.+(+M!.+!K$!5(5!%2&!(%)$+&(8.&$!.%,!2&#$*!+J(%!5(+$.+$+!(%!

&#(+! C#@! &#$+(+D! P1&#208#! &#$! $d./&! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23! >+2*(.+(+! (+! %2&! 3011,! 0%5$*+&225M! (&! (+!

J%2K%!&#.&!J$*.&(%2/,&$!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!(+!5,+*$801.&$5!.%5!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!(+!./&().&$5D!

-(*+&M! 5,+*$801.&(2%! 23! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! #.+! =$$%! 320%5! (%! >+2*(.+(+M! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!9.*J$*+!.%5!2)$*./&()$!>*21(3$*.&(2%!1$.5(%8!&2!9.*J$5!$>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.!

.%5! +/.1(%8D! -2*! (%+&.%/$M! &#$! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!9.*J$*! (%)210/*(%M! .! 9.G2*! /2%+&(&0$%&! 23! &#$!

/2*%(3($5! $%)$12>$M! (+! 320%5! (%! $d/$++! (%!>+2*(.&(/! +J(%DjYY!i$*.&(%!>*2&$(%+! .*$!5(+*0>&$5! (%!

>+2*(.+(+!.+!K$11!.%5!iq!.%5!iZq!K$*$! 320%5!0>*$801.&$5! (%!>+2*(.&(/!$>(5$*9(+Dp[[!iq!.%5!

iZq!.*$!*$8.*5$5!.+!9.*J$*+!32*!.=$**.%&!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%D!iZ!.%5!iZ[!K$*$!320%5!&2!=$!

52K%*$801.&$5! (%! >+2*(.+(+M! K#$*$.+! &#$(*! %2*9.1! $d>*$++(2%! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &$*9(%.1!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D!<*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!.%5!>*2&$(%!$d>*$++(2%!23!/2*%(3$1(%M!.1+2!.!/29>2%$%&!23!&#$!!

!

?'Q3*%(-+D(I'55%*%<2(8#)%*=(45(26%(=J'<(#<$(G'4&#*J%*=(45(%:'$%*&#8($'55%*%<2'#2'4<(

E.,$*!23!#09.%!$>(5$*9(+!.*(+(%8! 3*29!+J(%!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D! 6%/*$.+(%8!5(+&.%/$! 3*29!&#$!/2%%$/&()$!&(++0$! ;<! (+! /2**$1.&$5!K(&#! (%/*$.+(%8! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D! a7V! 4/#$9.&(/! >*2&$(%! =(29.*J$*! $d>*$++(2%!>.&&$*%+D!;21FZ!�!/211.8$%FZM!6%&F.q!�!(%&$8*(%!.1>#.!qM!@C!�!5$+92>1.J(%M!iZlZ[!�!J$*.&(%!iZlZ[M!6%)!�!(%)210/*(%M!-(1!�!3(1.88*(%D!!U7/4)%7&/(7&0"7*-*%7&-5"0&\"00%5%(+B%&%)&/.Op[Z!

!

Page 74: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 61 of 237

/2*%(3($5! $%)$12>$M! (+! .1+2! $1$).&$5! (%! 0%(%)21)$5! .%5! (%)21)$5! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! 23! >+2*(.+(+!

>.&($%&+Dp[j! 4$/2%51,M! $)(5$%/$! +088$+&+! (%! .55(&(2%! &2! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! 23! J$*.&(%2/,&$+M! .%!

.=$**.%&! *$+>2%+$! 23! &#$! (%%.&$! (990%$! +,+&$9! (%! >+2*(.+(+D! 6%31.99.&2*,! /$11+! +0/#! .+!

%$0&*2>#(1+M!9.+&!/$11+!.%5!9./*2>#.8$+!(%3(1&*.&$!&#$!+J(%!.%5!.*$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!(%/*$.+$5!

).+/01.*(R.&(2%D! <#(*51,M! $1$).&$5! /,&2J(%$! +(8%.&0*$+! #.)$! =$$%! 320%5! .+! K$11! (%! >.&($%&+c!

+J(%!.%5!=1225!+0/#!.+!6-evM!<e-!.%5!6EFZmD!P+!5$+/*(=$5!.=2)$M!&#$*.>,!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!

(%50/$! >+2*(.+(+! .%5! $d>$*(9$%&.1! $)(5$%/$! >2(%&! .&! >@;F5$*()$5! 6-ev! .+! &#$! (%50/$*! .%5!

./&().&2*! 23! $.*1,! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+D! 6&! (+! &#208#&! &#.&! >@;+! .*$! ./&().&$5! 0>2%! &*(88$*(%8! 23!

<E:Y! &#*208#! /29>1$d$+!23! EEFpm!.%5!@ePD!EEFpm! (+! .%! .%&(9(/*2=(.1!>$>&(5$M!K#(/#!0>2%!

(%&$*./&(2%!K(&#!@eP!&0*%+!(%&2!.!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!+&(9010+D!6&!(+!&#208#&!&#.&!&#(+!/29>1$d!

/.%! (%50/$! .%! $d.88$*.&$5! (990%$! *$+>2%+$! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$! =*$./#! 23! +$13F&21$*.%/$! (%!

>+2*(.+(+Dp[p! EEFpm! (+! >*250/$5! =,! J$*.&(%2/,&$+M! K#(/#! .1+2! >*250/$! uF5$3$%+(%+! .%5!

>+2*(.+(%M! J%2K%! .+! 4Z[[PmD! <#$+$! >*2&$(%+! ./&! .+! .%&(9(/*2=(.1! >$>&(5$+M! =0&! .1+2! $d$*&!

/#$92&./&(/!30%/&(2%+!*$/*0(&(%8!(990%$!/$11+D!i$*.&(%2/,&$+!52!%2&!2%1,!>*250/$!+(8%.1+!&2!

&#$! (990%$! +,+&$9M! =0&! .1+2! *$+>2%5! &2! /,&2J(%$+! +0/#! .+! 6-e+M! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm! .%5!

+0=+$?0$%&1,! (%50/$! 2&#$*! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+! .%5! /#$92J(%$+! +0/#! .+! 6EFZM! 6EFqM!

;;Ej[M!;O;EY!.%5!;O;EZ[D!<#(+!1$.5+!&2!.!+$13F+0+&.(%(%8!(%31.99.&2*,!122>M!*$+01&(%8!(%!&#$!

&,>(/.1!(&/#,!.%5!+29$&(9$+!>.(%301!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!P1&#208#!(%31.99.&(2%!9.,!+$$9!12/.1!.%5!

2%1,!.33$/&(%8!&#$!+J(%M!>+2*(.+(+!#.+!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!(%/*$.+$5!*(+J!23!/292*=(5(&($+!+0/#!

.+!/.*5(2).+/01.*!5(+$.+$+!.%5!9$&.=21(/!+,%5*29$D!W2*$2)$*M!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$)$*$!>+2*(.+(+!

#.)$!.!&K2F3215!(%/*$.+$5!*(+J!&2!5$)$12>!<,>$Fj!5(.=$&$+Dp[n!7.+$5!2%!&#$!1(+&$5!2=+$*).&(2%+M!

K$!/.%!/2%/105$!&#.&!>+2*(.+(+!(+!.!)$*,!/29>1$d!5(+$.+$!&#.&!.33$/&+!&#$!>.&($%&!%2&!+21$1,!(%!

&#$! +J(%M! =0&! +,+&$9(/.11,D! Hd&$%+()$! *$+$.*/#! (+! 2%82(%8! &2! $10/(5.&$! &#$! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23!

>+2*(.+(+!.%5!&2!(%%2).&$!&#$*.>,D!P%(9.1!925$1+!.*$!)$*,!0+$301!(%!&#$!*$+$.*/#!23!>+2*(.+(+!

.%5!K$!K(11!30*&#$*!5(+/0++!+29$!925$1+D!

Page 75: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 62 of 237

NJKJI+%&+M5M0+@0'*3.+602+-.025<.5.+

4$)$*.1!.%(9.1!925$1+!$d(+&!K#$*$!.=$**.%&!+J(%!/2%5(&(2%+!5$)$12>M!#2K$)$*!+29$!3$.&0*$+!

%$$5!&2!=$!>*$+$%&!&2!9(9(/!>+2*(.+(+D!e$+&1$!.%5!e(/J21233!5$3(%$5!&#$!(5$.1!>+2*(.+(+!925$1!

.+! 32112K+A! (D! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! .*$! #,>$*>*21(3$*.&()$! .%5! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! >*28*.9! (+! .1&$*$5U! ((D!

&#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23! *$&$! *(58$+! 90+&! =$! >*$+$%&M! +$>.*.&$5! =,! $12%8.&$5! 5$*9.1! >.>(11.$!

a>.>(1129.&2+(+VU! (((D! (%31.99.&2*,! (%3(1&*.&$+! /2%+(+&(%8! 23! <! /$11+M! @;+! .%5! %$0&*2>#(1+U! ()D!

30%/&(2%.1! *21$! 32*! <! /$11+U! )D! $d&$%+()$! ).+/01.*! %$&K2*J! .%5! )(D! 925$1! 90+&! *$+>2%5! &2!

/0**$%&! .%&(F>+2*(.&(/! 5*08+D! ;*(&$*(2%! j! (+! %2&! .1K.,+! 2=+$*)$5M! +(%/$! 90*(%$! .%5! #09.%!

+J(%+!5(33$*!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!(%!&#$!5(+&*(=0&(2%!23!#.(*!3211(/1$+U!#09.%!+J(%!(+!1$++!/2)$*$5!(%!#.(*!

3211(/1$+D!P&!&#$!#(+&2128(/.1!1$)$1M!&#$!#09.%!$>(5$*9(+!(+!&K(/$!.+!&#(/J!.+!920+$!$>(5$*9(+D!

P1+2!&#$!12/.1(R.&(2%!23!+>$/(.1(R$5!/$11+!5(33$*+A!9$1.%2/,&$+!(%!#09.%!+J(%!.*$!12/.1(R$5!.&!&#$!

G0%/&(2%! 23! 5$*9(+! .%5! $>(5$*9(+! .%5! (%! .501&! 90*(%$! +J(%! &#$,! .*$! *$+&*(/&$5! &2! &#$! #.(*!

3211(/1$+D! P55(&(2%.11,M! &#$! $//*(%$! 81.%5+! .*$! 5(+&*(=0&$5! 2)$*! &#$! K#21$! =25,! (%! #09.%+M!

K#(1+&!&#$,!.*$!*$+&*(/&$5!&2!81.=*20+!+J(%!(%!9(/$M!$D8D!322&>.5+D!-(%.11,M!&#$!>$*9$.&(2%!23!&#$!

+>$/($+F+>$/(3(/! 9$9=*.%$+! 5(33$*+M! &22Dp[r! -(80*$! Zp! /29>.*$+! #09.%! .%5!90*(%$! +J(%! (%!

#$.1&#,!.%5!^>+2*(.&(/c!/2%5(&(2%D!6%!<.=1$!mM!.).(1.=1$!90*(%$!925$1+!.*$!1(+&$5!(%!/.&$82*($+M!

=0&!2%1,!&#$!P15.*.!a(9(?0(925V!925$1!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!(%!5$>&#D!

HODOXOZ&M4"()/(%"#$&0"7%.$&

W.%,!90*(%$!90&.&(2%+!1$.5!&2!.!>+2*(.+(32*9!>#$%2&,>$!+0/#!.+!$>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.!.%5!

+/.1$!32*9.&(2%D!g2K$)$*M!&#$,!52!%2&!.1K.,+!9(9(/!>+2*(.+(+!(%!.11!(&+!/29>1$d(&,!.+!92+&!3.(1!

&2!>*$+$%&!K(&#!<F/$11!>.&#28$%$+(+!.%5!52!%2&!*$+>2%5!&2!&#$!2&#$*K(+$!$33(/./(20+!&*$.&9$%&!

K(&#! /,/12+>2*(%$! P! a/*(&$*(2%! qVD! 4&(11M! &#$+$! 925$1+! .*$! 0+$301M! =0&! *.&#$*! &2! +&05,! &#$!

+$>.*.&$!>.&#2128(/.1!$)$%&+!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%D!!

Page 76: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 63 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(-XD(S'=2484Q'"#8(5%#23*%=(45(63&#<(#<$(&3*'<%(=J'<(

_#`( g(+&2128(/.1! 3$.&0*$+! 23! #09.%! #$.1&#,! .%5! >+2*(.&(/! +J(%! a�j[! 9.8%(3(/.&(2%VD! P/.%&#2+(+!a$>(5$*9.1! &#(/J$%(%8VM! $12%8.&$5! $>(5$*9.1! *$&$! *(58$+M! #,>$*J$*.&2+(+! a/2*%(3($5! 1.,$*!&#(/J$%(%8VM! >.*.J$*.&2+(+! a>*$+$%/$! 23! %0/1$(! (%! /2*%(3($5! 1.,$*V! .%5! +/.1$+! .*$! #(8#1(8#&$5D! <#$!.**2K! (%5(/.&$+! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! (%31.99.&2*,! /$11+! agBH! +&.(%(%8VD! aGV! g(+&2128(/.1! 3$.&0*$+! 23!90*(%$!#$.1&#,!.%5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!a�j[!9.8%(3(/.&(2%VD!P/.%&#2+(+M!$12%8.&$5!�*$&$F1(J$�!*(58$+M!#,>$*J$*.&2+(+M! 9(/*2.=+/$++$+! 23! (%31.99.&2*,! /$11+! a%$0&*2>#(1+VM! >.*.J$*.&2+(+! .%5! +/.1$+! .*$!#(8#1(8#&$5D!<#$!.**2K!(%5(/.&$+!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!(%31.99.&2*,!/$11+!agBH!+&.(%(%8VD!!P5.>&$5!.%5!925(3($5!3*29!L.8%$*!$&!.1Dp[q!

HODOXOD&T(8*(%%5%7&0"7%.$&

"$%$&(/.11,! $%8(%$$*$5!925$1+! (%/105$! 2)$*$d>*$++(2%! .%5! J%2/J20&!9(/$!K#$*$! 8$%$+! .*$!

$%8(%$$*$5!0%5$*! &#$!/2%&*21!23!.!+J(%F+>$/(3(/!>*292&$*!a<.=1$!mVD!ir!.%5!iZn!.*$!+>$/(3(/!

32*! &#$! =.+.1! 1.,$*! 23! &#$! $>(5$*9(+M! K#(1$! iZM! iZ[! .%5! (%)210/*(%! >*292&$*+! 1$.5! &2! &#$!

+0>*.=.+.1F+>$/(3(/! *$8(2%! (%! &#$! $>(5$*9(+D! ;,&2J(%$+! .%5! .5#$+(2%! 921$/01$+! .*$! &,>(/.1!

8$%$+!23! (%&$*$+&! &2!=$!9.%(>01.&$5! (%!2*5$*! &2! (%)$+&(8.&$! &#$(*! *21$! (%! &#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!

>+2*(.+(+M!.1&#208#!<F/$11!>.&#28$%$+(+!.%5!/1$.*!#(+&2>.&#2128(/.1!>.&&$*%+!.*$!23&$%!.=+$%&D!

Page 77: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 64 of 237

HODOXOX&b%(")5/($4./()/)*"(&0"7%.$&

O$%2&*.%+>1.%&.&(2%! 925$1+! .112K! (%&*250/(%8! &#$! .0&#$%&(/! >+2*(.&(/! 9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&!

3*29!#09.%!+J(%!&2!&#$!90*(%$!+J(%D!6990%2+0>>*$++$5!9(/$!.*$!)$*,!).10.=1$!&221+!.+!&#$,!

.112K! &*.%+>1.%&$5! &(++0$M! #$*$! #09.%! +J(%M! &2! =$! (%/2*>2*.&$5! (%! &#$(*! +,+&$9! K(&#20&!

*$G$/&(2%!23!&#$!&(++0$D!6990%2+0>>*$++$5!9(/$!.*$!(D$D!.&#,9(/!%05$!9(/$M!+$)$*$!/29=(%$5!

(990%25$3(/($%/,! a4;6@V! 9(/$! 2*! P":ZjY! 9(/$D! P&#,9(/! %05$! 9(/$! 2*! -2d%Z%0! #.)$! %2!

&#,90+!.%5!%2!<!/$11+M!K#$*$.+!4;6@!9(/$!1./J!<!.%5!7!/$11+!=0&!+#2K!%2*9.1!%.&0*.1!J(11$*!

/$11! ./&()(&,Dp[m! P":ZjY!9(/$!K$*$! 0+$5! (%! 2*5$*! &2! .)2(5! *$G$/&(2%! 23! &#$! #2+&! +J(%! 50$! &2!

%.&0*.1! J(11$*! /$11+D! <#$+$! 9(/$! .*$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! &,>$! 6! .%5! 66! 6-e! +(8%.1(%8! 2%! .! :P"j! iQ!

=./J8*20%5M!K#(/#!1$.5+!&2!%.&0*.1!J(11$*!/$11+!K(&#!.=*28.&$5!/,&2&2d(/!./&()(&,!.%5!.!1./J!23!

<!.%5!7!/$11+D!P1&#208#!d$%2&*.%+>1.%&.&(2%+!.*$!.%!$1$8.%&!K.,!&2!9(9(/!#09.%!>+2*(.+(+M!(&!

*$1($+!2%!&#$!.//$++(=(1(&,!23!>.&($%&c+!+J(%M!K#(/#!(+!%2&!.1K.,+!*$.5(1,!.).(1.=1$!.%5!*$?0(*$+!

&$/#%(/.1!$d>$*&(+$D!

HODOXOY&,(7#+%7&0"7%.$&

P1&#208#! &#$! .32*$9$%&(2%$5! 925$1+! #.)$! &.08#&! 0+! 9.%,! 921$/01.*! .+>$/&+! (%! &#$!

>.&#28$%$+(+! 23! >+2*(.+(+M! &#$,! .11! #.)$! 1(9(&.&(2%+M! #.9>$*(%8! &#$! +/($%&(3(/! /2990%(&,! &2!

0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!$d./&!9$/#.%(+9D!<#$!*21$!23!>.*&(/01.*!8$%$+!/.%%2&!.1K.,+!=$!(%)$+&(8.&$5!

(%! 8$%$&(/.11,! $%8(%$$*$5! 9(/$! 50$! &2! &#$! *$?0(*$9$%&! 23! $d&$%5$5! =*$$5(%8! +/#$9$+D! 6%!

.55(&(2%M! +/*$$%(%8! 23! >2&$%&(.1! 5*08+! +#2015! =$! *.>(5! .%5! /2+&! $33$/&()$D! 6%&*.5$*9.1!

(%G$/&(2%+! 23! 6EFjpM!K#(/#! #.+! *$/$%&1,! 8.(%$5! .! >()2&.1!9$5(.&2*,! *21$! (%! #09.%! >+2*(.+(+M!

*$+01&+! (%! ./.%&#2+(+! .%5! 5$*9.1! (%31.99.&(2%! .%5! (+! +29$&(9$+! 0+$5! .+! .! 925$1! 32*!

>+2*(.+(+Dp[Y!g2K$)$*M! &#$!>*2&2/21! (+!jZ!5.,+! 12%8!.%5!*$?0(*$+!*$/29=(%.%&! 6EFjpD!<2>(/.1!

&*$.&9$%&! K(&#! #.R.*520+! .8$%&+! +0/#! .+! &$&*.5$/.%2,1>#2*=21FZpF./$&.&$! a<CPV! #.+! =$$%!

0+$5!(%!&#$!>.+&!&2!(%50/$!.!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!>#$%2&,>$!(%!9(/$DpZ[!P!92*$!*$/$%&!925$1!(%50/$+!

>+2*(.+(+! (%! .! <E:mF! 5$>$%5$%&!9.%%$*! =,! .%! (9(5.R2?0(%21(%$! 5$*().&()$! /.11$5! 6WsD! 6&! (+!

0+$5!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!8$%(&.1!.%5!>$*(.%.1!K.*&+M!/2992%1,!/.0+$5!=,!gCID!

Page 78: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 65 of 237

9#G8%(\D(!<'&#8(&4$%8=(54*(:=4*'#='=(

!M"#5+%N&/7/4)%7&/(7&%_)%(7%7&-5"0&'#7K"($$"(&%)&/.Op[o&

!

I.%!5$*!-(&+!$&!.1D!>*2>2+$5!&#$!$d>$*(9$%&.1!0+$!23!6Ws!&#*208#!*$>$.&$5!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!

2%! &#$!+#.)$5!=./J!23!9(/$! &2! (%50/$!>+2*(.+(+D! 6&! (+! 3.+&M! *$1.&()$1,!/#$.>M! *$>*250/(=1$!.%5!

92*$! (9>2*&.%&1,M! (&! K2*J+! 2%! 5(33$*$%&! 90*(%$! +&*.(%! =./J8*20%5+D! 6WsF(%50/$5!

>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!*$+$9=1$+!#09.%!>+2*(.+(+!.+!(&!(+!.1+2!5$>$%5$%&!2%!&#$!6EF

jpl6EFZm!.d(+!.%5!<F/$11!5$>$%5$%&D!W2*$2)$*M!/1(%(/.1!&2>(/.1!0+$!23!6Ws!#.+!$1(/(&$5!>+2*(.+(+!

.+! .! +(5$! $33$/&! (%! >.&($%&+D! P+!9$%&(2%$5! $.*1($*M! 6Ws! >*$+09.=1,! ./&().&$+! >@;+! &#*208#!

<E:m!.%5!+&(901.&$+!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+M!K#(/#!.*$!J%2K%!&2!(%50/$!>+2*(.+(+D!6Ws!

#.+!=$$%!(%/*$.+(%81,!+&05($5!(%!).*(20+!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$!&2!.++$++!&#$!*21$!23!).*(20+!8$%$+!(%!

>+2*(.+(+D! '%32*&0%.&$1,M! &#$! $d./&! 9$/#.%(+9! 23! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%!

(%31.99.&(2%!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225!.%5!*$>2*&+!#.)$!+088$+&$5!.55(&(2%.1!(%8*$5($%&+!(%!

!"#$%&'$()*&+' ,-%$.&*+' !)/%"0%1*+' 2#+%)/%"0%1*+'

!"#$%&$'#()*+(%&%,#$)* -! .%/0)$1.%/0)$*

-! !2&3",$/"4+1!2&3",$/"4+**

#3*523#$,/*"3#6,0'3&%,7'*4'3+&%,%,)*859:;*

-! <6&=>*)=,$*+#4'6*80)$;*

-! ?#+#@>A#()*&)'B,&*8!/4C&B1!/4C&B;*#3*&B1&B*

-! !,+,6&3*/2&3&/%'3,)%,/)*%#*2(+&$*")#3,&),)*

-! D$6,+,%'4*$(+B'3*#0*&$,+&6)*8)%&%,)%,/);*

-! <&,6'4*.*/'66*"&%2#A'$'),)*-! E'3>*6,+,%'4*/#+"6'F,%>*,$*&00'/%'4*

B,#6#A,/&6*$'%G#3=)*-! <&,6'4*,++($#)(""3'))&$%)*

-! !#+'*+#4'6)*&//#+"&$,'4*B>*

&$'+,&*#3*&6#"'/,&*

H'$'%,/&66>*'$A,$''3'4* -! ICJ*)"'/,K,/LMIIN*IO*

-! ICJ*)"'/,K,/*'F"3')),#$*#0*EPH<**

-! ?QRLSNT*83&%;*-! 5>"CRCL43,7'$*'F"3')),#$*#0*

99RUB14*

-! MU<N*IO*

-! !,+,6&3*/2&3&/%'3,)%,/)*%#*2(+&$*")#3,&),)*

-! D$6,+,%'4*$(+B'3*#0*&$,+&6)*8)%&%,)%,/);*

-! M$*)#+'*+#4'6)*86,+,%'4;*.*/'66*"&%2#A'$'),)*

-! M$*)#+'*+#4'6)*3')"#$)'*%#*,++($#)(""3'))&$%)*

M++($'*%3&$)0'3*&$4*F'$#%3&$)"6&$%&%,#$* -! 5:JVUS?,*5:NVL*.*/'66*,++($'*

%3&$)0'3*

-! ?(+&$*")#3,&%,/*)=,$*%3&$)"6&$%'4*#$*&%2>+,/*$(4'W*!5M:*#3*RHUCNX*

+,/'*

-! U')"#$),7'*%#*,++($#)(""3'))&$%)*

-! .*/'66*4'"'$4'$%*8$#%*5:YZ;*-! E'3>*),+,6&3*%#*2(+&$*")#3,&),)*

-! M$4'"'$4'$%*#0*)#+'*')%&B6,)2'4*")#3,&),)L+'4,&%,$A*/>%#=,$')*

-! E'3>*6,+,%'4*&7&,6&B,6,%>*#0*2(+&$*")#3,&%,/*)=,$*8)%&%,)%,/);*

-! :'"'$4'$%*#$*A'$'%,/*B&/=A3#($4*

M$4(/%,#$*-! M+,[(,+#4*8M\]^*%#",/&6;*-! CNLOL%'%3&4'/&$#>6"2#3B#6LC_L

&/'%&%'*8.9R^*%#",/&6;*-! MQLN_*8,$%3&4'3+&6;*

-! U')"#$),7'*%#*,++($#)(""3'))&$%)*

-! .*/'66*4'"'$4'$%*-! R""6,/&B6'*,$*7&3,#()*+(3,$'*

B&/=A3#($4)*

-! P&)>W*3&",4*,$4(/%,#$*&$4*/2'&"*-! D$6,+%'4*$(+B'3*#0*&$,+&6)*

8)%&%,)%,/);*

-! R//#+"&$,'4*B>*/&/2'F,&*-! `#*&))#/,&%'4*/#+#3B,4,%,')*

-! `#%*/23#$,/*

Page 79: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 66 of 237

&#$! r\! 6Ws! /*$.9! J%2K%! .+! P15.*.! /2%&*(=0&$! &2! (%31.99.&(2%! &#*208#! (%31.99.+29$!

./&().&(2%DpZZ! (

Page 80: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 67 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! C0%/#.*5!ePM!L#$1.%!;NM!P5/2/J!6D!<#$!N20*%.1!23!6%31.99.&(2%D!c&,(-./00&1S"(72D!j[[nUZaZVAZD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmqFYjrrFZFZD!

jD!! <.J$0/#(!QM!PJ(*.!4D!C.&&$*%!*$/28%(&(2%!*$/$>&2*+!.%5!(%31.99.&(2%D!?%..D!j[Z[UZn[aqVAo[rFj[D!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/$11Dj[Z[D[ZD[jjD!

pD!! E.%($*!EEM!Qc-.112%!4M!4292R.!;M!$&!.1D!;@o[!a7mV!.%5!;@oq!a7m[V!>*2)(5$!+(9(1.*!/2+&(901.&2*,!+(8%.1+!32*!<!/$11!>*21(3$*.&(2%M!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%M!.%5!8$%$*.&(2%!23!;<ED!c&,00#(".D!ZYYrUZrnaZVAYmFZ[rD!

P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKDG(990%21D2*8l/2%&$%&lZrnlZlYmD.=+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!YM!j[ZnD!

nD!! I.%!i22&$%!;M!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;@n[F;@n[!1(8.%5D!c&S%#B"+&6*".D!j[[[UqmaZVAjFZmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[qnmYYjD!P//$++$5!N01,!Z[M!j[ZnD!

rD!! W(,.G(9.!PM!i(&.90*.!<M!g.*.5.!eM!�2J2&.!<M!P*.(!iD!;,&2J(%$!*$/$>&2*+!.%5!+(8%.1!&*.%+50/&(2%D!U((#&>%=&

,00#(".D!ZYYjUZ[AjYrFppZD!52(AZ[DZZnql.%%0*$)D(,DZ[D[n[ZYjD[[ZnrrD!

qD!! ;.9$*2%!WNM!i$1)(%!@ND!;,&2J(%$+M!;#$92J(%$+!.%5!<#$(*!:$/$>&2*+D!j[[[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l=22J+le7iqjYnlD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!pM!j[ZnD!

mD!! Qc4#$.!NNM!W0**.,!CND!;,&2J(%$!+(8%.1(%8!92501$+!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$+D!,00#(*)9D!j[[oUjoanVAnmmF

omD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[[oD[pD[[jD!

oD!! ;,&2J(%$!*$/$>&2*!3.9(1,M!+(8%.1(%8M!.%5!5(+$.+$!&#$*.>$0&(/!&.*8$&(%8D!M*("&6*".&,(+D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD+(%2=(2128(/.1D/29l;,&2J(%$F:$/$>&2*F/1.++(3(/.&(2%F+(8%.1(%8F5(+$.+$F&#$*.>$0&(/F

&.*8$&(%8F.FZpZZD#&91D!

YD!! i2%&2,(.%%(+!@M!C.+>.*.J(+!WM!C(R.**2!<<M!;29(%$11(!-M!i211(.+!"D!69>.(*$5!2%l233!*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!=(2+,%&#$+(+!(%!9(/$!1./J(%8!<e-!P'F*(/#!$1$9$%&+A!(9>1(/.&(2%+!32*!G2(%&!.%5!80&F.++2/(.&$5!(990%2>.&#2128($+D!,00#(*)9D!ZYYYUZ[apVApomFYoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[j[nnYnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jpM!j[ZnD!

Z[D!! ;$**$&&(!@CM!i2R12+J,!;NM!W2+1$,!7M!$&!.1D!W21$/01.*!/12%(%8!23!&#$!(%&$*1$0J(%FZ!=$&.!/2%)$*&(%8!$%R,9$D!M+*%(+%D!ZYYjUjrqar[rpVAYmFZ[[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZpmprj[D!

P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

ZZD!! W.*&(%2%!-M!<+/#2>>!ND!6%31.99.&2*,!/.+>.+$+A!1(%J(%8!.%!(%&*./$1101.*!(%%.&$!(990%$!+,+&$9!&2!

.0&2(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+D!?%..D!j[[nUZZmarVArqZFmnD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/$11Dj[[nD[rD[[nD!

ZjD!! 4#(=.&.!NM!"2&2!gM!P*(+.K.!<M!$&!.1D!:$801.&(2%!23!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!(%50/$5!.>2>&2+(+!=,!+210=1$!<e-!*$/$>&2*+!(%!g$1(/2=./&$*!>,12*(!(%3$/&(2%D!'#)D!ZYYYUnraZVAjnFpZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZmjmrojB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!

ZpD!! i2#%2!<M!7*$K$*!W<M!7.J$*!4EM!$&!.1D!P!+$/2%5!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!8$%$!>*250/&!/.%!+#$5!.!%.&0*.11,!2//0**(%8!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%#(=(&2*D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!ZYY[UomajZVAoppZFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�rnYnYB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&*

./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

ZnD!! 70/J1$,!;!.M!:20#.%(!-eM!i.1$*!WM!P5.9(J!7M!g.K.*(!-6M!E$)(%$!4ND!P9(%2F&$*9(%.1!<P;H!>*2529.(%!.&&$%0.&$+!<e-:j!/1$.).8$!(%5$>$%5$%&1,!23!&#$!/,+&$(%$!+K(&/#D!U0&c&\;9$*".&S#(8&?%..&!".&\;9$*".D!

j[[rUjooaqVAEZZpjFoD!52(AZ[DZZrjl.G>10%8D[[njYDj[[nD!

Page 81: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 68 of 237

ZrD!! P*5$+&.%(!4M!E(!7M!@$+J(%+!@EM!L0!gM!W.++(2%!CCM!�20%8!CCD!W$9=*.%$!)$*+0+!+210=1$!(+232*9+!23!<e-Fv!$d$*&!2>>2+(%8!$33$/&+!2%!&092*!8*2K&#!.%5!+0*)().1!23!&092*F.++2/(.&$5!9,$12(5!/$11+D!?/(+%5&>%$D!

j[ZpUmpaZpVApYpoFr[D!52(AZ[DZZrol[[[oFrnmjD;PeFZpF[[[jD!

ZqD!! E$)(%$!4ND!W$/#.%(+9+!23!4210=1$!;,&2J(%$!:$/$>&2*!"$%$*.&(2%D!c&,00#(".D!j[[nUZmpaYVArpnpFrpnoD!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZmpDYDrpnpD!

ZmD!! C$&$*+!WM!W$,$*!R09!7f+/#$%3$15$!igM!:2+$FN2#%!4D!<#$!30%/&(2%!23!&#$!+210=1$!6EFq!*$/$>&2*!(%!)()2D!,00#(".&S%))D!ZYYqUrnajFpVAZmmFonD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lY[rjomnD!

P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

ZoD!! W/;.*&#,!H-D!<#$!&2d(%+!23!L(11(.9!7D!;21$,!.%5!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!=2%$!.%5!+23&F&(++0$!+.*/29.+D!,"J/&^5);"4&cD!j[[qUjqAZrnFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZooorYYB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

ZYD!! ;.*+K$11!HPM!Q15!ENM!i.++$1!:EM!"*$$%!4M!-(2*$!eM!L(11(.9+2%!7D!P%!$%52&2d(%F(%50/$5!+$*09!3./&2*!&#.&!/.0+$+!%$/*2+(+!23!&092*+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!ZYmrUmjaYVApqqqFm[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�npp[rmB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&

*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!ZrM!j[ZnD!

j[D!! 7$0&1$*!7M!W.#2%$,!NM!E$!<*.%8!eM!C$J.1.!CM!;$*.9(!PD!C0*(3(/.&(2%!23!/./#$/&(%M!.!1(>2>*2&$(%!1(>.+$F+0>>*$++(%8!#2*92%$!+$/*$&$5!=,!$%52&2d(%F(%50/$5!:PL!jqnDm!/$11+D!c&T_4&!%7D!ZYorUZqZarVAYonFYrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jZomqZrB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

jZD!! 7*$9$*!HD!<.*8$&(%8!23!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+0>$*3.9(1,!32*!/.%/$*!(990%2&#$*.>,D!,M>V&

^(+".D!j[ZpUj[ZpApmZornD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[ZplpmZornD!

jjD!! E(!NM!�(%!sM!L0!gD!4&*0/&0*.1!=.+(+!23!+(8%.1!&*.%+50/&(2%!(%!&#$!<e-!*$/$>&2*!+0>$*3.9(1,D!U7=&,00#(".D!

j[ZpUZZYAZprFrpD!52(AZ[DZ[Zql7YmoF[FZjFn[mm[mFjD[[[[rFYD!

jpD!! W0J.(!�M!4#(=.&.!gM!e.J.90*.!<M!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*$F30%/&(2%!*$1.&(2%+#(>!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*!(%&$*./&(2%!=.+$5!2%!p@!+&*0/&0*.1!.%.1,+(+!23!.!3011,!./&()$!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()$!<e-!90&.%&D!c&

!".&6*".D!j[[YUporanVAZjjZFYD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG9=Dj[[oDZZD[rpD!

jnD!! "0(//(.*5(!WHM!"2*$+!"ND!E(3$!.%5!5$.&#!=,!5$.&#!*$/$>&2*+D!WUMT6&cD!j[[YUjpaqVAZqjrFpmD!

52(AZ[DZ[Yql3GD[oFZZZ[[rD!

jrD!! L.G.%&!gM!C3(R$%9.($*!iM!4/#$0*(/#!CD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!+(8%.1(%8D!?%..&3%/);&3*--%5D!j[[pUZ[aZVAnrF

qrD!52(AZ[DZ[pol+GD/55Dnn[ZZoYD!

jqD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!E(=$*&!;D!<*$.&9$%&!23!<e-!9$5(.&$5!5(+$.+$+!=,!+$1$/&()$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!+210=1$!<e-!2*!<e-:ZD!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[ZZUjjarFqVApZZFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&283*Dj[ZZD[YD[[nD!

jmD!! W./HK.%!@ND!<e-!*$/$>&2*!+0=&,>$!+(8%.11(%8A!5(33$*$%/$+!.%5!/$1101.*!/2%+$?0$%/$+D!?%..&M*8(/.D!j[[jUZnaqVAnmmFYjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZoYmnooD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jpM!

j[ZnD!

joD!! e.05X!CNLM!5$%!72$*!N!.M!E0(&$%!C"WM!H(+$1!'EWD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!/*2++F&.1JD!WT6M&cD!

j[ZZUjmoaqVAoooFYoD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZmnjFnqroDj[ZZD[o[ZmDdD!

jYD!! �.%!CM!E(0!eM!i(9!"FWM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&#$!&,>$!Z!.%5!&,>$!j!*$/$>&2*+!32*!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.3&$*!&*.09.&(/!+>(%.1!/2*5!(%G0*,!(%!.501&!*.&+D!T_4&V%#5".D!j[[pUZopajVAjoqFYmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZnrrjom[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

Page 82: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 69 of 237

p[D!! g(G5*.!@M!I2*+$1..*+!P@M!"*0&&$*+!N;M!;1.$++$%!PWM!:(GJ$*+!"<D!@(33$*$%&(.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!<e-:Z!a;@Zj[.V!.%5!<e-:j!a;@Zj[=V!2%!+0=>2>01.&(2%+!23!#09.%!92%2/,&$+D!c&,(-./00D!j[ZjUYaZVApoD!

52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmqFYjrrFYFpoD!

pZD!! 4/#01R!:M!g$0+/#!"D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!Z!.%5!jA!�(%!.%5!�.%8!(%!9,2/.*5(.1!

(%3.*/&(2%S!?*5+#./)*"(D!j[[YUZZYaZ[VAZprrFmD!52(AZ[DZZqZl;6:;'EP<6QePgPDZ[oDonqZ[rD!

pjD!! I$*2%(!;M!".=*($1$!EM!;.%(%(!6M!$&!.1D!P/&().&(2%!23!<e-!*$/$>&2*!j!(%!9(/*281(.!>*292&$+!(%50/&(2%!23!.%&(F

(%31.99.&2*,!>.&#K.,+D!!".&?%..&V%#5"$+*D!j[Z[UnrapVAjpnFnnD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD9/%Dj[Z[D[qD[ZnD!

ppD!! @2>>!NWM!W./J$%R($F"*.#.9!PM!Q&$*2!";M!W$**(11!NHD!@(33$*$%&(.1!$d>*$++(2%M!/,&2J(%$!92501.&(2%M!.%5!+>$/(3(/!30%/&(2%+!23!&,>$FZ!.%5!&,>$Fj!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*+!(%!*.&!81(.D!c&V%#5"*00#(".D!ZYYmUmraZFjVAZ[nFZjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYZnpjnpD!P//$++$5!P080+&!

joM!j[ZnD!

pnD!! @$3$*!eM!PR*2,.%!PM!C$/J$*!-M!C.)2(%$!;D!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!+(8%.1(%8!(%&$*>1.,!(%!/.*5(./!9,2/,&$+D!c&6*".&

?;%0D!j[[mUjojanYVAprrqnFmpD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/DWm[n[[pj[[D!

prD!! W./HK.%!@ND!<e-!1(8.%5+!.%5!*$/$>&2*+FF.!9.&&$*!23!1(3$!.%5!5$.&#D!65&c&\;/50/+".D!j[[jUZpranVAorrFmrD!

52(AZ[DZ[pol+GD=G>D[m[nrnYD!

pqD!! <2**$FP9(2%$!"M!i.>.5(.!4M!E$$!NM!7($+!:@M!E$=2)(&R!:M!W.%%!@ED!Hd>*$++(2%!.%5!-0%/&(2%.1!4(8%(3(/.%/$!23!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!:$/$>&2*+!(%!g09.%!W,2/.*5(09D!?*5+#./)*"(D!ZYYrUYjaqVAZnomFZnYpD!

52(AZ[DZZqZl[ZD;6:DYjDqDZnomD!

pmD!! :R,9+J(!CM!Q>.1.!<M!L(1/R.J!WM!L2�%(.J!NM!4.G5.J!4D!4$*09!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.!*$/$>&2*+!>rrl>mr!*.&(2!.%5!2).*(.%!/.%/$*!5$&$/&(2%D!,()&c&'9(/%+".&^L$)%)D!j[[rUooapVAjYjFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(G82Dj[[nDZjD[ZrD!

poD!! H+>$)(J!<D!@(+&(%/&!:21$+!23!&#$!<K2!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!a<e-V!:$/$>&2*+!(%!W2501.&(%8!<e-!.%5!

E,9>#2&2d(%!.1>#.!H33$/&+D!c&6*".&?;%0D!ZYYqUjmZaZqVAYmmoFYmonD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/DjmZDZqDYmmoD!

pYD!! :(/#&$*!;M!W$++$*+/#9(5&!4M!g21$(&$*!"M!$&!.1D!<#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+&.1J!*$8(2%+!5$3(%$!*$+>2%+()$%$++!&2!+210=1$!)$*+0+!9$9=*.%$F=20%5!1(8.%5D!!".&?%..&6*".D!j[ZjUpjaZpVAjrZrFjYD!52(AZ[DZZjolW;7D[qnroFZZD!

n[D!! :.%5.11!<@M!;.**.8#$*!@WM!:.%8$1FW2*$%2!ND!@$)$12>9$%&!23!+$/2%5.*,!1,9>#2(5!2*8.%+D!U((#&>%=&,00#(".D!j[[oUjqAqjmFr[D!52(AZ[DZZnql.%%0*$)D(990%21DjqD[jZq[mD[Y[jrmD!

nZD!! i*0812)!PPM!i0/#9(,!PM!"*()$%%(J2)!46M!<09.%2)!P!IM!i0>*.+#!@!IM!e$52+>.+2)!4PD!C#,+(2128(/.1!30%/&(2%+!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%5!&#$!/2%+$?0$%/$+!23!(&+!>.&#2128(/!2)$*$d>*$++(2%!2*!=12/J.5$A!920+$!925$1+D!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[[oUZYapFnVAjpZFnnD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&283*Dj[[oD[nD[Z[D!

njD!! -0*&.52!";M!C./$*!WHM!72%8$*+!"M!$&!.1D!<e-vF5$>$%5$%&!5$)$12>9$%&!23!1,9>#2(5!&(++0$!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!:Q:y&x!1,9>#2(5!&(++0$!(%50/$*!/$11+D!!#+"$/.&,00#(".D!j[ZnUmapVAq[jFZnD!52(AZ[DZ[pol9(Dj[ZpDmYD!

npD!! W.&+092&2!WD!:21$!23!<e-!1(8.%5!.%5!*$/$>&2*!3.9(1,!(%!&#$!1,9>#2(5!2*8.%28$%$+(+!5$3(%$5!=,!8$%$!&.*8$&(%8D!c&!%7&,(=%$)D!ZYYYUnqapFnVAZnZFr[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[qomp[oD!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

nnD!! W099!N7M!Q3&!WD!;,&2J(%$F=.+$5!&*.%+32*9.&(2%!23!(990%$!+0*)$(11.%/$!(%&2!&092*F>*292&(%8!

(%31.99.&(2%D!^(+"8%(%D!j[[oUjmanrVArYZpFYD!52(AZ[DZ[pol2%/Dj[[oDjmrD!

nrD!! ;#.*1$+!iPM!i01=$!gM!42>$*!:M!$&!.1D!<#$!&092*F>*292&(%8!./&(2%+!23!<e-F.1>#.!(%)21)$!<e-:Z!.%5!6EFZm!

(%!2).*(.%!/.%/$*!(%!9(/$!.%5!#09.%+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[YUZZYaZ[VAp[ZZFjpD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pY[qrD!

nqD!! -*0#!:M!7109!7M!W2++9.%%!gM!@295$,!gM!)2%!4>$/#&!7D!<gZ!/$11+!&*(88$*!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.F9$5(.&$5!#,>$*+$%+(&()(&,!&2!C+$05292%.+!.$*08(%2+.!.3&$*!.52>&()$!&*.%+3$*!(%&2!4;6@!9(/$D!,(-%+)&

Page 83: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 70 of 237

,00#(D!ZYYrUqpapVAZZ[mFZZZjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>All(.(D.+9D2*8l/2%&$%&lqplplZZ[mD.=+&*./&D!P//$++$5!

P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

nmD!! g$*%.%5$RFC.%52!:M!:22J!"PD!<#$!*21$!23!<e-F.1>#.!(%!<F/$11F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&(2%!5$>$%5+!2%!&#$!<#Zl<#j!/,&2J(%$!=.1.%/$D!,00#("."89D!ZYYnUojanVArYZFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZnZnYjpB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

noD!! 4$&#(!NiM!g2&.9(+1(8(1!"4D!<#$!*21$!23!<e-!.1>#.!(%!.5(>2/,&$!9$&.=21(+9D!M%0*(&?%..&3%=&6*".D!

ZYYYUZ[aZVAZYFjYD!52(AZ[DZ[[ql+/5=DZYYoD[jmpD!

nYD!! 4&*.0+!@4D!<e-v!.%5!6EFZm!/22>$*.&()$1,!+&(901.&$!810/2+$!9$&.=21(+9!.%5!8*2K&#!3./&2*!>*250/&(2%!(%!

#09.%!/212*$/&.1!/.%/$*!/$11+D!!".&?/(+%5D!j[ZpUZjaZVAmoD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmqFnrYoFZjFmoD!

r[D!! :2&#$!NM!E$++1.0$*!LM!Ez&+/#$*!gM!$&!.1D!W(/$!1./J(%8!&#$!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!.*$!*$+(+&.%&!&2!<e-F9$5(.&$5!&2d(/(&,!=0&!#(8#1,!+0+/$>&(=1$!&2!(%3$/&(2%!=,!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+D!V/)#5%D!

ZYYpUpqnaqnn[VAmYoFo[jD!52(AZ[DZ[polpqnmYo.[D!

rZD!! "�9$R!W6M!E$$!PM!:$55,!7M!$&!.1D!4&.>#,12/2//0+!.0*$0+!>*2&$(%!P!(%50/$+!.(*K.,!$>(&#$1(.1!(%31.99.&2*,!

*$+>2%+$+!=,!./&().&(%8!<e-:ZD!V/)&!%7D!j[[nUZ[aoVAonjFoD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%9Z[mYD!

rjD!! W22&22!PM!4&,1(.%20!HM!P*(.+!W!.M!:$1G(/!:D!<e-F.1>#.!(%!&0=$*/012+(+A!.!/,&2J(%$!K(&#!.!+>1(&!>$*+2%.1(&,D!,(-./00&U..%589&35#8&A/58%)$D!j[[YUoaZVArpFqjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZYjmrqYpD!

rpD!! N./2=+!WM!7*2K%!eM!P11($!eM!:,33$1!7D!-.&.1!W,/2=./&$*(09!=2)(+!7;"!(%3$/&(2%!(%!<e-FE<F.1>#.F5$3(/($%&!

9(/$D!?.*(&,00#(".D!j[[[UYnapVAZYjFYD!52(AZ[DZ[[ql/1(9Dj[[[DnoprD!

rnD!! H#1$*+!4M!7$%(%(!NM!i0&+/#!4M!H%5*$+!:M!:($&+/#$1!H<M!C3$33$*!iD!-.&.1!8*.%0129.!%$/*2+(+!K(&#20&!$d./$*=.&$5!9,/2=./&$*(.1!8*2K&#!(%!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!>rr!8$%$F5$3(/($%&!9(/$!(%&*.)$%20+1,!(%3$/&$5!K(&#!W,/2=./&$*(09!.)(09D!,(-%+)&,00#(D!ZYYYUqmamVAprmZFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZZqrnqB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&

*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

rrD!! C.+>.*.J(+!WM!P1$d2>20120!EM!H>(+J2>20!IM!i211(.+!"D!,00#(%&/(7&,(-./00/)"59&>%$4"($%$&*(&AVW&U.4;/F3%-*+*%()&!*+%N&U&?5*)*+/.&>%d#*5%0%()&-"5&AVW&U.4;/&*(&);%&W"50/)*"(&"-&\5*0/59&6&?%..&W"..*+.%$:&W"..*+#./5&

3%(75*)*+&?%..&V%)J"5B$&/(7&'%50*(/.&?%()%5$:&/(7&*(&);%&!/)#5/)*"(&"-&);%&[#0"5/.&,00#(%&>%$4"($%DU!ZYYqAZpYmFnZZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jZYjojnB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!W.,!oM!j[ZnD!

rqD!! L.%8!�M!L.%8!NM!40%!�M!L0!sM!-0!�OD!;29>1$9$%&.*,!$33$/&+!23!<e-!.%5!1,9>#2&2d(%!2%!&#$!32*9.&(2%!23!8$*9(%.1!/$%&$*!.%5!3211(/01.*!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[ZUZqqaZVApp[FmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZZjpp[YD!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

rmD!! <.%(80/#(!<M!<.J.&.!WM!6J$5.!PM!W292&.%(!HM!4$J(J.K.!iD!-.(10*$!23!8$*9(%.1!/$%&$*!32*9.&(2%!.%5!(9>.(*9$%&!23!*$+>2%+$!&2!$%52&2d(%!(%!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.F5$3(/($%&!9(/$D!S/L&,(=%$)D!ZYYmUmmaqVAqnmFroD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYnjqn[pD!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!

j[ZnD!

roD!! W(1(�$)(�!eWM!i1.>$*+J(!iM!e2#*205(!iM!$&!.1D!<e-!*$/$>&2*FZ!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!&#$!32*9.&(2%!23!+>1$%(/!/29>.*&9$%&+!50*(%8!.501&M!=0&!%2&!$9=*,2%(/!1(3$D!c&,00#(".D!j[ZZUZoqapVAZnoqFYnD!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZ[[[mn[D!

rYD!! <(+2%/(J!N:M!i2*&#!WNM!4(992%+!;CM!-.**.*!NM!W.*&(%!<:M!i.&R$!W"D!6%&2!&#$!$,$!23!&#$!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9D!

!*+5"L*".&!".&6*".&>%=D!j[ZjUmqaZVAZqFpjD!52(AZ[DZZjolWW7:D[r[ZrFZZD!

Page 84: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 71 of 237

q[D!! "282+!;PM!@*2+20!HM!7.++.*(+!gCM!4J20&$1(+!PD!C*2F!)$*+0+!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$!>*23(1$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$)$*$!+$>+(+A!.!9.*J$*!32*!>*28%2+(+!.%5!30&0*$!&#$*.>$0&(/!2>&(2%+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[[[UZoZaZVAZmqF

o[D!52(AZ[DZ[oqlpZrjZnD!

qZD!! "2*52%!P;M!E.8.%!PEM!P8.%%.!HM!$&!.1D!<e-!.%5!<e-:!>21,92*>#(+9+!(%!+$)$*$!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JA!.!

>*2+>$/&()$!901&(/$%&*$!+&05,D!'%(%$&,00#(D!j[[nUraoVAqpZFn[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol+GD8$%$DqpqnZpqD!

qjD!! i2&#.*(!eM!728*.!NM!P==.+!gM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9!*$+01&+!(%!#(8#!<e-!1$)$1!(%!

+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!?9)"B*(%D!j[ZpUqZajVAqmqFoZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&2Dj[ZjDZZD[ZqD!

qpD!! i2&#.*(!eM!728*.!NM!P==.+!gM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9!*$+01&+!(%!#(8#!<e-!1$)$1!(%!

+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!?9)"B*(%D!j[ZpUqZajVAqmqFoZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&2Dj[ZjDZZD[ZqD!

qnD!! C$5$*+$%!7iM!-$==*.(2!WPD!W0+/1$!.+!.%!$%52/*(%$!2*8.%A!32/0+!2%!90+/1$F5$*()$5!(%&$*1$0J(%FqD!\;9$*".&

>%=D!j[[oUooanVAZpmYFn[qD!52(AZ[DZZrjl>#,+*$)DY[Z[[Dj[[mD!

qrD!! L..8$!PM!g.1+&$%+$%!PM!H+>$)(J!<D!P++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%!+$*09!.%5!3.&.1!20&/29$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!9$%(%82/2//.1!5(+$.+$D!S/(+%)D!ZYomUZaorjYVAprrFmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5ljoo[ZqpD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jqM!j[ZnD!

qqD!! W(/#($!g:M!W.%280$!i:M!4>*(88+!@:M!$&!.1D!@$&$/&(2%!23!/(*/01.&(%8!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.3&$*!$%52&2d(%!

.59(%(+&*.&(2%D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!ZYooUpZoajpVAZnoZFqD!52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNWZYoo[q[YpZojp[ZD!

qmD!! <*./$,!iNM!-2%8!�M!g$++$!@"M!$&!.1D!P%&(F/./#$/&(%l<e-!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25($+!>*$)$%&!+$>&(/!+#2/J!

50*(%8!1$&#.1!=./&$*.$9(.D!V/)#5%D!ZYomUpp[aqZnYVAqqjFnD!52(AZ[DZ[polpp[qqj.[D!

qoD!! 4.K,$*!:"D!P%&(�<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!P%&(=25,!:$50/$+!W2*&.1(&,!(%!&#$!C*$+$%/$!23!P%&(=(2&(/F6%50/$5!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!:$1$.+$D!U5+;&M#58D!ZYYpUZjoaZVAmpD!

52(AZ[DZ[[Zl.*/#+0*8DZYYpD[Znj[Zp[[oZ[ZpD!

qYD!! -($51$*!I7M!E223!6M!4.%5$*!HM!I2$#*(%8$*!IM!".1.%2+!;M!-20*%$1!WPD!W2%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*FF.1>#.!>*$)$%&+!1$&#.1!$%52&2d(%!+$>+(+!(%!.501&!*#$+0+!92%J$,+D!c&S/L&?.*(&!%7D!ZYYjUZj[anVArmnF

ooD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZn[jpppD!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

m[D!! 7$0&1$*!7M!W(1+.*J!6M!;$*.9(!PD!C.++()$!(990%(R.&(2%!.8.(%+&!/./#$/&(%l&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!>*2&$/&+!9(/$!3*29!1$&#.1!$33$/&!23!$%52&2d(%D!M+*%(+%&1RGF&2D!ZYorUjjYanmZqVAoqYFomZD!

52(AZ[DZZjql+/($%/$DpoYrnpmD!

mZD!! L.1+#!;NM!408$*9.%!gNM!W011$%!C"M!$&!.1D!W2%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.!.&&$%0.&$+!/.*5(2>0192%.*,!5,+30%/&(2%!(%!>2*/(%$!8*.9F%$8.&()$!+$>+(+D!U5+;&M#58D!ZYYjUZjmajVAZpoFnnU!5(+/0++(2%!ZnnFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZrn[[Y[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

mjD!! -(+#$*!;NM!P82+&(!NWM!Q>.1!4WM!$&!.1D!<*$.&9$%&!23!+$>&(/!+#2/J!K(&#!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*A-/!30+(2%!>*2&$(%D!<#$!4210=1$!<e-!:$/$>&2*!4$>+(+!4&05,!"*20>D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!ZYYqUppnajqVAZqYmFm[jD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNWZYYq[qjmppnjq[pD!

mpD!! 42%8!�M!42%8!�M!�(%!NM!$&!.1D!"$%$&(/!).*(.&(2%!(%!&#$!<e-!8$%$!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!+$)$*$!+$>+(+M!=0&!%2&!K(&#!92*&.1(&,D!L0*3$1!WWM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZjUmaYVA$nqZZpD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[nqZZpD!

mnD!! E)!7M!g0.%8!NM!�0.%!gM!�.%!LM!g0!"M!L.%8!ND!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*Fv!.+!.!5(.8%2+&(/!9.*J$*!32*!%$2%.&.1!

+$>+(+A!.!9$&.F.%.1,+(+D!M+*&e"5.7&cD!j[ZnUj[ZnAnmZnqpD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[ZnlnmZnqpD!

mrD!! E$2%!E:M!L#(&$!.!.M!i108$*!WND!:21$!23!6EFq!.%5!<e-!(%!&#$*92*$801.&(2%!.%5!+0*)().1!50*(%8!+$>+(+!(%!9(/$D!U0&c&\;9$*".D!ZYYoUjmraZ!C&!jVA:jqYFmmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYqooYooD!

Page 85: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 72 of 237

mqD!! H=./#!@:M!:($#1!<HM!4&$%+2%!L-D!Q>>2+(%8!H33$/&+!23!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!:$/$>&2*!Z!.%5!j!(%!4$>+(+!@0$!<2!;$/.1!E(8.&(2%!.%5!C0%/&0*$D!M;"+BD!j[[rUjpanVApZZFpZoD!

52(AZ[DZ[Yml[ZD+#JD[[[[Zrmp[ZDom[rZDmmD!

mmD!! g(15$=*.%5!-M!C.>$!gF;M!g2$)$1!CM!i*$&&$J!;M!).%!"*($%+)$%!WD!<#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!+,+&$9(/!/,&2J(%$+!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!.%5!5$#,5*2$>(.%5*2+&$*2%$!&*$.&9$%&!(%!.!*25$%&!925$1D!

M;"+BD!j[[pUj[anVAppoFnqD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml[ZD+#JD[[[[[oZn[oDrmYrjDjjD!

moD!! H/#&$%./#$*!7M!-.1J!LM!W�%%$1!@eM!i*.99$*!CgD!:$?0(*$9$%&!23!$%528$%20+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*l/./#$/&(%!32*!*$/2)$*,!3*29!$d>$*(9$%&.1!>$*(&2%(&(+D!c&,00#(".D!ZYY[UZnraZZVApmqjFqD!P).(1.=1$!

.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5ljjnqrZjD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!rM!j[ZnD!

mYD!! H+J.%5.*(!WiM!72182+!"M!W(11$*!;M!e80,$%!@<M!@$-2*8$!EHM!:$9(/J!@"D!P%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%&(=25,!&#$*.>,!3.(1+!&2!>*$)$%&!1$&#.1(&,!.3&$*!/$/.1!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$!2*!$%52&2d$9(.D!c&,00#(".D!ZYYjUZnoaYVAjmjnFp[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKDG(990%21D2*8l/2%&$%&lZnolYljmjnD.=+&*./&D!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!Z[M!j[ZnD!

o[D!! :$9(/J!@M!W.%2#.*!CM!72182+!"M!:25*(80$R!NM!W215.K$*!EM!L211$%=$*8!"D!712/J.5$!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$50/$+!1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$!1$&#.1(&,M!=0&!%2&!&#$!1$&#.1(&,!23!/$/.1!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$D!M;"+BD!ZYYrUnajVAoYFYrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lmnYqY[pD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!rM!

j[ZnD!

oZD!! 4$/#$*!<M!I.++$0*!IM!C2(++2%!@WM!$&!.1D!;*0/(.1!*21$!23!<e-!*$/$>&2*+!Z!.%5!j!(%!&#$!/2%&*21!23!

>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaZjVAmorrFqnD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[n[[oD!

ojD!! @$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$),)$*!4M!7.11$8$$*!WM!$&!.1D!C#.*9./2128(/.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!

>*2&$/&+!9(/$!.8.(%+&!1$&#.1!+$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZpUj[YaqVAYq[Fm[D!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%35(+lG(&q[[D!

opD!! i2)./#!WPM!4&.%5(32*5!<ND!<#$!30%/&(2%!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!(%!+$>+(+D!?#55&^4*(&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZjUjrapVApjZFmD!

52(AZ[DZ[Ymls;QD[=[Zp$pjoprjo/Y=D!

onD!! i.++(2&(+!"M!i211(.+!"D!<e-!.%5!*$/$>&2*+!(%!2*8.%F+>$/(3(/!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$A!901&(F1.,$*$5!30%/&(2%(%8!

9(**2*$5!(%!.%(9.1!925$1+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[ZUZ[maZjVAZr[mFoD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6ZppqjD!

orD!! ;.90++(!"M!E0>(.!HD!<#$!30&0*$!*21$!23!.%&(F&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!>*250/&+!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!35#8$D!ZYYoUrrarVAqZpFj[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYrororYD!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

oqD!! L(11(.9+!:QM!-$159.%%!WM!W.(%(!:eD!P%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.9$1(2*.&$+!G2(%&!5(+$.+$!(%!90*(%$!/211.8$%F(%50/$5!.*&#*(&(+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!ZYYjUoYaj[VAYmonFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�r[jZmB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&*

./&D!

omD!! L(11(.9+!:QM!"#*.,$=!NM!-$159.%%!WM!W.(%(!:eD!40//$++301!&#$*.>,!23!/211.8$%F(%50/$5!.*&#*(&(+!K(&#!<e-!*$/$>&2*F68"!30+(2%!>*2&$(%!.%5!/29=(%.&(2%!K(&#!.%&(F;@nD!,00#("."89D!ZYYrUonapVAnppFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZnZrZjYB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!joM!j[ZnD!

ooD!! @$=.%5&!WM!I(&&$/2?!QM!@$+/.9>+!IM!E$!E2�&!OM!W$,$*!QD!P%&(F<e-F.1>#.F(%50/$5!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!

+,%5*29$D!?.*(&>;%#0/)".D!j[[pUjjaZVArqFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[[qmF[[jF[qrnFrD!

oYD!! P192.11(9!gM!P1F"#.95(!�M!P19.8#*.=(!gM!P1,.+(!QD!P%&(F<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*Fv!6%50/$5!4,+&$9(/!

E0>0+!H*,&#$9.&2+0+D!^4%(&>;%#0/)".&cD!j[ZjUqApZrFYD!52(AZ[DjZmnlZomnpZjY[Zj[q[Z[pZrD!

Y[D!! �#0!EFNM!�.%8!OM!�0!OFsD!P%&(F<e-F.1>#.!&#$*.>($+!(%!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!c&6*"0%7&6*")%+;(".D!

j[Z[Uj[Z[AnqroYoD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[Z[lnqroYoD!

Page 86: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 73 of 237

YZD!! �#.%8!sM!;0(!-M!-.%8!EM!g2%8!NM!�#$%8!7M!�#.%8!N�D!<e-Fv!(9>.(*+!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!.%5!30%/&(2%!23!<"-FuF(%50/$5!<*$8!/$11+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!&#*208#!PJ&!.%5!49.5p!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,D!c&!".&?%..&6*".D!

j[ZpUrajVAorFYoD!52(AZ[DZ[YplG9/=l9G+[qpD!

YjD!! e($!gM!�#$%8!�M!E(!:M!$&!.1D!C#2+>#2*,1.&(2%!23!-QOCp!/2%&*21+!*$801.&2*,!<!/$11!30%/&(2%!.%5!(+!(%#(=(&$5!

=,!<e-Fv!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!V/)&!%7D!j[ZpUZYapVApjjFoD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%9Dp[orD!

YpD!! e.8.*!WM!N./2=Fg(*+/#!NM!I$*%(&+J,!gM!P9.*(81(2!eM!:$/#.)(!"M!"215+&$(%!6D!<e-l<e-:j!+(8%.1(%8!(%!<!*$801.&2*,!a<*$8V!/$11+!(%50/$+!.!5(+&(%/&()$!e-FJ7F5$>$%5$%&!/$1101.*!>*28*.9!&#.&!92501.&$!&#$(*!+0>>*$++()$!/.>./(&,D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaW$$&(%8!P=+&*./&+!ZVAoYDjmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKDG(990%21D2*8l/8(l/2%&$%&l9$$&(%8�.=+&*./&lZojlZ�W$$&(%8P=+&*./&+loYDjmD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

YnD!! �2+#(5.!gM!i2&.%(!gM!i2%52!<M!$&!.1D!;@i!(%#(=(&2*+!+0>>*$++!<#Zm!.%5!>*292&$!(<*$8!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%M!.%5!.9$1(2*.&$!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.0&2(990%$!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+!(%!9(/$D!6*"+;%0&6*"4;9$&>%$&?"00#(D!j[ZpUnprapVApmoFonD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD==*/Dj[ZpD[nD[YqD!

YrD!! @$G./2!;M!@03&%$*!;M!"*0=$/JFE2$=$%+&$(%!7M!4/#(*9$*!WD!69=.1.%/$!23!*$801.&2*,!<!/$11+!(%!#09.%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!,00#("."89D!j[[qUZZmapVAjoYFp[[D!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFjrqmDj[[rD[jpZmDdD!

YqD!! I$%J$%!iM!g$11(%8+!eM!E(=1.0!:M!4&(%(++$%!CD!@(+&0*=$5!*$801.&2*,!<!/$11!#29$2+&.+(+!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!A5%(7$&!".&!%7D!j[Z[UZqajVAroFqoD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD9219$5Dj[[YDZjD[[pD!

YmD!! H1.#(!WWM!P+2&*.!iM!W.&.&.!7WM!W.+&.%.!44D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.!�p[o!8$%$!12/0+!>*292&$*!>21,92*>#(+9A!P%!.%.1,+(+!23!.++2/(.&(2%!K(&#!#$.1&#!.%5!5(+$.+$D!6*"+;*0&6*"4;9$&U+)/&F&!".&6/$*$&3*$D!j[[YUZmYjapVAZqpFZmjD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD==.5(+Dj[[YD[ZD[[mD!

YoD!! �#0!NM!s0!gM!;#$%!OM!L.%8!gM!E(!ND!4(%81$!%0/1$2&(5$!>21,92*>#(+9+!(%!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!8$%$!>*292&$*!*$8(2%!.1&$*!&#$!*(+J!23!>+2*(.+(+!)018.*(+!.%5!>+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+A!.!9$&.F.%.1,+(+D!\S"M&

^(%D!j[ZpUoarVA$qnpmqD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[qnpmqD!

YYD!! :$(/#!iM!gf339$($*!'M!iz%(8!6:M!$&!.1D!<e-!>21,92*>#(+9+!(%!>+2*(.+(+A!.++2/(.&(2%!23!>+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+!K(&#!&#$!>*292&$*!>21,92*>#(+9!<e-�Form!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!&#$!C4Q:4Z!*(+J!.11$1$D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!

j[[mUrqaqVAj[rqFqnD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DjjrY[D!

Z[[D!! :.(!HM!L.J$1.%5!HiD!"$%$&(/!>*$5(+>2+(&(2%!&2!.0&2(990%(&,FFK#.&!#.)$!K$!1$.*%$5S!M%0*(&,00#(".D!

j[ZZUjpajVAqmFopD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD+9(9Dj[ZZD[ZD[ZrD!

Z[ZD!! <#2*+=,!HM!E($!7PD!gEP!.++2/(.&$5!8$%$&(/!>*$5(+>2+(&(2%!&2!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+A!"$%$+!(%)21)$5!.%5!

>2++(=1$!9$/#.%(+9+D!A5/($4.&,00#(".D!j[[rUZnapFnVAZmrFojD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD&*(9Dj[[rD[pD[jZD!

Z[jD!! ;2**$.!CPM!"29$R!EWM!;.5$%.!NM!P%.,.!NFWD!P0&2(990%(&,!.%5!&0=$*/012+(+D!Q>>2+(&$!.++2/(.&(2%!K(&#!<e-!>21,92*>#(+9D!c&>;%#0/)".D!j[[rUpjajVAjZYFjjnD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKDG*#$09D2*8l/2%&$%&lpjljljZYD.=+&*./&D!P//$++$5!N01,!mM!j[ZnD!

Z[pD!! H11(2&&!WNM!W.(%(!:eM!-$159.%%!WM!$&!.1D!<*$.&9$%&!23!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!K(&#!/#(9$*(/!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25($+!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!ZYYpUpqaZjVAZqoZFY[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lojr[YomD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

Z[nD!! 4#$.1,!@NM!;.(!PM!4&.?0$&!iM!$&!.1D!;#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!821(909.=M!.!#09.%!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!+>$/(3(/!32*!#09.%!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!vD!!UL$D!j[Z[UjanVD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�pZo[[oYB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!N01,!oM!j[ZnD!

Z[rD!! i$,+&2%$!H;M!L.*$!;-D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%5!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>($+D!c&>;%#0/)".&

M#44.D!j[Z[Uora[VAjmFpYD!52(AZ[DpoYYlG*#$09D[YZnqpD!

Z[qD!! 4/2&&!@EM!4&$$*!4D!e6;H!80(5$1(%$+!2%!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,!32*!:PD!V/)&?.*(&\5/+)&>;%#0/)".D!

j[[YUraZVAZqFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/>*#$09[YqnD!

Page 87: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 74 of 237

Z[mD!! ;211()$*!ID!C*(/$5!20&!23!>.(%!*$1($3!l!6%+0*$*+!=.1J!.&!#(8#!/2+&+!23!>*29(+(%8!%$K!&*$.&9$%&+D!M/(&W5&?;5"(D!j[[mD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD+38.&$D/29l=0+(%$++l.*&(/1$lC*(/$5F20&F23F>.(%F*$1($3F6%+0*$*+F

=.1JF.&F#(8#FjrYqp[pD>#>D!

Z[oD!! 4/.%R$112!;:M!-(88($!WCM!e$+&2*!7NM!"2259.%!4WD!C$*(2>$*.&()$!9.%.8$9$%&!23!9$5(/.&(2%+!0+$5!(%!&#$!

&*$.&9$%&!23!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D![MM&cD!j[[qUjajVAZnZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+ZZnj[F[[qFY[ZjFrD!

Z[YD!! i$.%$!NM!"$*+#2%!4M!L(+$!:CM!$&!.1D!<0=$*/012+(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!(%31(d(9.=M!.!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.F

%$0&*.1(R(%8!.8$%&D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!j[[ZUpnraZrVAZ[YoFZ[nD!52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW2.[ZZZZ[D!

ZZ[D!! W2#.%!ICM!4/.%8.!;PM!�0!iM!$&!.1D!H33$/&+!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.1>#.!2%!#2+&!(990%$!*$+>2%+$!(%!/#*2%(/!>$*+(+&$%&!&0=$*/012+(+A!>2++(=1$!*21$!32*!1(9(&(%8!>.&#2128,D!,(-%+)&,00#(D!j[[ZUqYapVAZonmFrrD!

52(AZ[DZZjol6P6DqYDpDZonmFZorrDj[[ZD!

ZZZD!! -0*+&!@HM!L.11(+!:M!7*25$*!WM!7$$%#20K$*!@QD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%&.82%(+&+A!5(33$*$%&!J(%$&(/+!.%5l2*!9$/#.%(+9+!23!./&(2%!9.,!$d>1.(%!5(33$*$%/$+!(%!&#$!*(+J!32*!5$)$12>(%8!8*.%0129.&20+!(%3$/&(2%D!

M%0*(&U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[[qUpqapVAZrYFqmD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD+$9.*&#*(&Dj[[qD[jD[[ZD!

ZZjD!! g2*(0/#(!<M!W(&29.!gM!g.*.+#(9.!4M!<+0J.92&2!gM!4#(925.!<D!<*.%+9$9=*.%$!<e-F.1>#.A!+&*0/&0*$M!30%/&(2%!.%5!(%&$*./&(2%!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.8$%&+D!>;%#0/)"."89&1^_-"572D!j[Z[UnYamVAZjZrFjoD!

52(AZ[DZ[Ypl*#$09.&2128,lJ$?[pZD!

ZZpD!! ;.1R.+/(.!<M!C$11$8*(%(!WM!g.11!gM!$&!.1D!<e-F.1>#.!(+!/*(&(/.1!32*!.%&(&092*!=0&!%2&!.%&()(*.1!<!/$11!(990%(&,!

(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[mUZZmaZjVApoppFnrD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pjrqmD!

ZZnD!! E.J.&2+!CM!W(#$11$*!CD!6+!<#$*$!.%!6%/*$.+$5!:(+J!23!E,9>#29.!.%5!W.1(8%.%/($+!'%5$*!P%&(F!<e-!

<#$*.>,!(%!67@S!?#55&35#8&A/58%)$D!j[Z[UZZajVAZmYFZoqD!52(AZ[DjZmnlZpoYnr[Z[mY[p[YoqmD!

ZZrD!! ;1.*J!@PD!@2!.%&(F<e-Fv!5*08+!(%/*$.+$!/.%/$*!*(+J!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!>.&($%&+S!

,(-./00"4;/50/+"."89D!j[ZpUjZajVAZjrFmD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[momF[ZjF[ZroF[D!

ZZqD!! 7$,.$*&!:M!7$.08$*($!EM!I.%!P++/#$!"M!$&!.1D!;.%/$*!*(+J!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!

a6W6@VD!!".&?/(+%5D!j[ZpUZjaZVAYoD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmqFnrYoFZjFYoD!

ZZmD!! @(d2%!L"M!L.&+2%!i@M!E0%&!WM!W$*/$*!EiM!g,*(/#!iEM!4,992%+!@CWD!6%310$%/$!23!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,!2%!/.%/$*!(%/(5$%/$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!K#2!#.)$!#.5!.!>*(2*!9.1(8%.%/,A!*$+01&+!3*29!&#$!7*(&(+#!42/($&,!32*!:#$09.&2128,!7(2128(/+!:$8(+&$*D!U5);5*)*$&?/5%&>%$&1["L"B%(2D!j[Z[UqjaqVAmrrFqpD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl./*Dj[ZjYD!

ZZoD!! Q%$1!i7M!Q%$1!iD!P%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,!.%5!/.%/$*!*(+J!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!.0&2(990%$!

5(+2*5$*+D!U5);5*)*$&?/5%&>%$&1["L"B%(2D!j[Z[UqjamVAZ[jnFoD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl./*Dj[jjoD!

ZZYD!! e($++!NgM!@.%$+$!4D!P%&(F<e-!.%5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!67@A!.!%$K!>.*.52d!(%!8.+&*2$%&$*2128,S!'#)D!

j[ZpUqpanVArppFrD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&G%1Fj[ZpFp[nqopD!

Zj[D!! <(11./J!;M!H#9.%%!EWM!-*($5*(/#!WM!$&!.1D!P%&(F<e-!.%&(=25,F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!1$+(2%+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!(%31.99.&2*,!=2K$1!5(+$.+$!.*$!/#.*./&$*(+$5!=,!(%&$*3$*2%FyF$d>*$++(%8!<#Z!/$11+!.%5!6EFZmPl6EFjjF$d>*$++(%8!<#Zm!/$11+!.%5!*$+>2%5!&2!.%&(F6EFZjl6EFjp!.%&(=25,!&*$.&9$%&D!'#)D!j[ZnUqpanVArqmFmmD!

52(AZ[DZZpql80&G%1Fj[ZjFp[jorpD!

ZjZD!! 6=2**.!WM!7$1&*�%!7M!7.+&(5.!"M!P80.+!WM!e2+!CD!6%31(d(9.=!.%5!.5.1(909.=F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$A!.!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&D!c&?5";($&?".*)*$D!j[ZZUrajVAZrmFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/*2#%+Dj[Z[DZZD[[ZD!

ZjjD!! 7.*&#$1!;M!7($5$*9.%%!EM!-*$(!CM!$&!.1D!6%50/&(2%!2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!0%5$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.%&(=25($+D!3*8%$)*"(D!j[ZnUoYapVAj[YFZrD!

52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[projooD!

ZjpD!! <+2J2+!";D!4,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!j[ZZUpqrajjVAjZZ[FjZD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW*.ZZ[[prYD!

Page 88: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 75 of 237

ZjnD!! P*(%8$*!WM!4&$(%$*!"M!"*.%(%8$*!L7M!gz31$*!HM!4&$(%$*!;LM!4921$%!N4D!H33$/&+!23!+#2*&F&$*9!(%31(d(9.=!&#$*.>,!2%!.0&2.%&(=25($+!(%!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[[mUrqaZVAjmnFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DjjpjmD!

ZjrD!! -(%+$%!7M!P%&$1!NM!QK$%+!<D!<e-.1>#.A!J(11!2*!/0*$!32*!5$9,$1(%.&(%8!5(+$.+$S!!".&\$9+;*/)59D!

j[[jUmaoVAoj[FZD!52(AZ[DZ[pol+GD9>Dn[[ZZj[D!

ZjqD!! ;.99$*!LD!P>2>&2+(+!23!21(825$%5*2/,&$+!(%!+$/2%5.*,!/01&0*$+!3*29!%$2%.&.1!*.&!=*.(%+D!V%#5"$+*&S%))D!j[[jUpjmajVAZjpFmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZj[YoqrZD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!

j[ZnD!

ZjmD!! gz)$19$,$*!eM!g.2!�M!i*.%(5(2&(!iM!$&!.1D!P>2>&2+(+!23!21(825$%5*2/,&$+!)(.!-.+!.%5!<e-F:Z!(+!.!J$,!$)$%&!(%!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.0&2(990%$!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[rUZmraYVAromrFonD!

P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZqjpm[o[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

ZjoD!! <+0J.92&2!<M!6+#(J.K.!WM!�.9.92&2!<D!40>>*$++()$!$33$/&+!23!<e-F.1>#.!2%!9,$1(%!32*9.&(2%!(%!)(&*2D!U+)/&V%#5".&M+/(7D!ZYYrUYZaZVAmZFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lmmpjmo[D!

P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

ZjYD!! H08+&$*!gCM!-*$(!iM!7./#9.%%!:M!710$&#9.%%!gM!E.++9.%%!gM!-2%&.%.!PD!4$)$*(&,!23!+,9>&29+!.%5!5$9,$1(%.&(2%!(%!WQ"F(%50/$5!HPH!5$>$%5+!2%!<e-:ZD!T#5&c&,00#(".D!ZYYYUjYajVAqjqFpjD!52(AZ[DZ[[jla46;6VZrjZFnZnZaZYYY[jVjYA[jB�q[UqjqAAP6@F6WW'qjqB�qjUpD[D;QUjFPD!

Zp[D!! C*2=$*&!ED!<e-:Z!+(8%.11(%8!(+!/*(&(/.1!32*!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!5$9,$1(%.&(2%!.%5!&#$!1(9(&.&(2%!23!<F/$11!*$+>2%+$+!50*(%8!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!;e4!5(+$.+$D!65/*(D!j[[[UZjpaZ[VAj[[rFj[ZYD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl=*.(%lZjpDZ[Dj[[rD!

ZpZD!! L(11(.9+!4iM!W.($*!QM!-(+/#$*!:M!$&!.1D!P%&(=25,F9$5(.&$5!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.&&$%0.&$+!5(+$.+$!(%!.!920+$!925$1!23!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!E(%J$*!:PM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZnUYajVA$Y[ZZmD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[Y[ZZmD!

ZpjD!! <(&$1=.09!@4M!@$8$%#.*5&!PM!i(%J$1!:CD!P%&(F<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!P1>#.FP++2/(.&$5!W01&(>1$!4/1$*2+(+D!UcV>&U0&c&V%#5"5/7*".D!j[[rUjqaqVAZrnoFZrr[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD.G%*D2*8l/2%&$%&ljqlqlZrnoD3011D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

ZppD!! 4$*2*!:M!:(/#$R!;M!42*5$&!;M!$&!.1D!C.&&$*%!23!5$9,$1(%.&(2%!2//0**(%8!50*(%8!.%&(F<e-Fv!&#$*.>,A!.!-*$%/#!

%.&(2%.1!+0*)$,D!>;%#0/)"."89&1^_-"572D!j[ZpUrjarVAoqoFmnD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl*#$09.&2128,lJ$+pmrD!

ZpnD!! �.%.(!gM!g.%.0$*!47D!P++$++(%8!*$+>2%+$!.%5!12++!23!*$+>2%+$!&2!=(2128(/.1!&#$*.>($+!(%!67@D!U0&c&

'/$)5"%()%5".D!j[ZZUZ[qanVAqorFYoD!52(AZ[DZ[pol.G8Dj[ZZDZ[pD!

ZprD!! i2/R.%!@M!@*,%5.!4M!g$/J$*!WM!$&!.1D!W21$/01.*!5(+/*(9(%.&(2%!23!*$+>2%5$*+!.%5!%2%*$+>2%5$*+!&2!.%&(F<e-!.1>#.!&#$*.>,!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!=,!$&.%$*/$>&D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[[oUZ[apVA:r[D!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*jnZYD!

ZpqD!! C.%.//(2%$!:D!7(2128(/!<#$*.>,!32*!;*2#%c+A!Hd>$*($%/$!(%!C.&($%&+!L(&#!<e-!Hd>$*($%/$A!;1(%(/.1!Hd>$*($%/$!(%!C.&($%&+!C*$)(20+1,!:$/$()(%8!P%&(F<e-!<#$*.>,D!!%7$+/4%D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD9$5+/.>$D2*8l)($K.*&(/1$lrmonnn�pD!

ZpmD!! @(!E$*%(.!IM!:(//(!;M!E.11.+!PM!-(/.*$11(!HD!;1(%(/.1!>*$5(/&2*+!23!%2%F*$+>2%+$!&2!.%,!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!=12/J$*+A!.!*$&*2+>$/&()$!+&05,D!c&3%50/)"."8&A5%/)D!j[ZnUjraZVAmpFnD!

52(AZ[DpZ[Yl[YrnqqpnDj[ZpDo[[ZonD!

ZpoD!! W.)*.8.%(!;CM!E.!@<M!4&2#1!LM!;*2K!WiD!P++2/(.&(2%!23!&#$!*$+>2%+$!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%&.82%(+&+!K(&#!>1.+9.!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!./&()(&,!.%5!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.l.1>#.!*.&(2+!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!>.&($%&+A!.!>2+&!#2/!.%.1,+(+!23!.!>*$529(%.%&1,!g(+>.%(/!/2#2*&D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[Z[UqjajVApYjFn[ZD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DjmjjqD!

Page 89: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 76 of 237

ZpYD!! W/;.%%!-HM!C$*2/#$.0!@CM!:0+>(!"M!$&!.1D!4$1$/&()$!<e-:Z!=12/J.5$!(+!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!.%5!*$)$.1+!.%!

(990%2*$801.&2*,!*21$!32*!<e-:jD!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0/)".D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DpomrrD!

Zn[D!! e290*.!<M!P=$!�M!i.9.5.!gM!$&!.1D!;*$.&(2%!23!.%!(9>*2)$5!90&.%&!<e-!K(&#!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()(&,!.%5!.%&.82%(+&(/!./&()(&,!=,!>#.8$!5(+>1.,!&$/#%2128,D!\;/50/f*%D!j[Z[UqrajVAYpFqD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lj[jjrqr[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!ZoM!j[ZnD!

ZnZD!! 6+../+!PM!E(%5$%9.%%!ND!I(*0+!(%&$*3$*$%/$D!6D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%D!\5"+&>&M"+&S"(7&6&6*".&M+*D!ZYrmUZnmaYjmVAjroFqmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZpnqrmj[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!

jYM!j[ZnD!

ZnjD!! C$+&J.!4M!W/6%%$+!NM!g.)$11!HPM!I(1/$J!ND!;$11F3*$$!+,%&#$+(+!23!#09.%!(%&$*3$*2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!ZYmrUmjaZ[VApoYoFY[ZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�nppZ[pB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&

*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jYM!j[ZnD!

ZnpD!! 72/.*+1,!C-FD!<#$!g(+&2*,!23!6%&$*3$*2%�A!P%!6%&$*)($K!K(&#!4(5!C$+&J.D!j[[nAZFpqD!

ZnnD!! :.0/#!6M!Wf11$*!WM!@$/J$*!<D!<#$!*$801.&(2%!23!(%31.99.&(2%!=,!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!&#$(*!4<P<+D!cU]FMAUAD!

j[ZpUjaZVA$jpoj[D!52(AZ[DnZqZlGJ+&Djpoj[D!

ZnrD!! 7�.+R/R,J!iM!Q1$G%(J!PM!;#9($1$K+J(!4M!$&!.1D!4<P<j!.%5!6:-YF5$>$%5$%&!6-eF6!+(8%.1(%8!*$+&2*$+!64:HF9$5(.&$5!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!.%5!.%&(F)(*.1!./&()(&,!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!4<P<ZD!?9)"B*(%D!j[ZpUqpapVAjnoFjnYD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&2Dj[ZpD[qD[joD!

ZnqD!! g2%5.!iM!�.%.(!gM!<.J.2J.!PM!<.%(80/#(!<D!:$801.&(2%!23!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e!(%50/&(2%A!.!/0**$%&!)($KD!,()&

,00#(".D!j[[rUZmaZZVAZpqmFmoD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%&(99l5d#pZoD!

ZnmD!! 6).+#J()!E7M!@2%1(%!E<D!>%8#./)*"(&"-&A94%&,&,()%5-%5"(&>%$4"($%$O!e.&0*$!C0=1(+#(%8!"*20>U!j[ZnApqFnYD!

52(AZ[DZ[pol%*(proZD!

ZnoD!! N.J+!HM!".)0&(+!WM!'RX!"M!W.*&.1!NM!C($#1$*!ND!@(33$*$%&(.1!*$/$>&2*!+0=0%(&!.33(%(&($+!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!

82)$*%!5(33$*$%&(.1!+(8%.1!./&().&(2%D!c&!".&6*".D!j[[mUpqqajVArjrFpYD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG9=Dj[[qDZZD[rpD!

ZnYD!! "(==$*&!iM!4/#1..J!N-M!�.%8!@M!@(&&9$*!'D!6-eFv!+0=&,>$+A!5(+&(%/&!=(2128(/.1!./&()(&($+!(%!.%&(F)(*.1!&#$*.>,D!

65&c&\;/50/+".D!j[ZpUZqoarVAZ[noFroD!52(AZ[DZZZZl=>#DZj[Z[D!

Zr[D!! @$!L$$*5!ePM!I()(.%!NCM!e80,$%!<iM!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*.1!=.+(+!23!.!0%(?0$!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!+(8%.1(%8!.d(+!

9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!*$/$>&2*!6-eP:ZD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[ZpUZnaYVAY[ZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(DjqqmD!

ZrZD!! Qc;2%%$11!:WM!4.#.!4iM!I.(5,.!4!.M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!>*250/&(2%!$%#.%/$+!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!E(+&$*(.!

92%2/,&28$%$+!(%3$/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[nUj[[anVAnpmFnrD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[n[mZjD!

ZrjD!! e.8.*.G.%!'WM!C*.%&%$*!@M!4(J$+!N@M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!$d./$*=.&$+!;#1.9,5(.!90*(5.*09!

8$%(&.1!(%3$/&(2%!(%!.!90*(%$!925$1D!,(-%+)&,00#(D!j[[oUmqaZ[VAnqnjFoD!52(AZ[DZZjol6P6D[[qjYF[oD!

ZrpD!! @2*#2(!PM!�$*$9$$)!IM!e20.(11$+!"M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!&*(88$*+!(990%2>.&#2128,!(%!&0=$*/012+(+F+0+/$>&(=1$!9(/$!=,!92501.&(%8!10%8!>#.82/,&$!5,%.9(/+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[ZnUnnaoVAjpo[FYpD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[ZpnnjZYD!

ZrnD!! g$%*,!<M!i(*(9.%G$+K.*.!"4M!:0=,!<M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!6-e!4(8%.1(%8!;2%+&*.(%+!6EFZmPl-!4$/*$&(2%!=,!<!;$11+!

50*(%8!7./&$*(.1!6%3$/&(2%+D!c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZonamVApmrrFpmqmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[j[qrD!

ZrrD!! "2%R�1$RFe.).G.+!NM!E$$!ND!6990%292501.&2*,!30%/&(2%+!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+D!V/)&>%=&gD!j[ZjUZjajVAZjrF

ZprD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%*(pZppD6990%292501.&2*,D!

Page 90: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 77 of 237

ZrqD!! i$11,F4/09>(.!iWM!4/09>(.!CQM!@$1.%2!WNM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!(%!#$9.&2>2($&(/!/$11+!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!+0*)().1!(%!920+$!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!=,!*$801.&(%8!;O;EZ[D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[Z[Uj[majVApZYF

jqD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[YZYrYD!

ZrmD!! 4.9.*.G(K.!4!.M!W.%8.%!eHM!g.*5,!WCM!$&!.1D!M".#L.%&,WV&>%+%4)"5&\")%()*/)%$&,(&@*="&A94%&,&,WV&M*8(/.*(8&

/(7&T_/+%5L/)%$&AS>YF!%7*/)%7&M%4)*+&M;"+BOU!j[ZnAnnjrFprD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZp[jpooD!

ZroD!! e2)(/J!@M!;2#$%!7M!:0=(%+&$(%!WD!4210=1$!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!*$/$>&2*!921$/01$+!.*$!>*$+$%&!(%!=25,!310(5+D!WT6M&S%))D!ZYYjUpZnapVAnnrFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZnqorojD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

ZrYD!! P9=*0+!NEM!;#.5#.!4M!e2)(/J!@M!$&!.1D!W$/#.%(+9a4V!23!(%&$*3$*2%!(%#(=(&2*,!./&()(&,!(%!=1225!3*29!>.&($%&+!K(&#!P6@4!.%5!>.&($%&+!K(&#!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!K(&#!).+/01(&(+D!>%$&?"00#(&!".&\/);".&\;/50/+".D!ZYYmUYqapVAjrrFqrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYjqZoorD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

Zq[D!! i.*.8#(2+233!WM!4&$(%=2*%!:M!i2).*(J!CM!$&!.1D!;$%&*.1!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!<,Jj!(%!

1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F(%50/$5!$%52&2d(%!+#2/JD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[[pUnarVAnmZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(YZ[D!

ZqZD!! W.#($0!<M!E(=$*&!;D!4#2015!K$!(%#(=(&!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!(%!+$>+(+S!,(-%+)&,00#(D!j[[mUmraZVAjjFYD!

52(AZ[DZZjol6P6D[[ojYF[qD!

ZqjD!! ;2#$%!ND!<#$!(990%2>.&#28$%$+(+!23!+$>+(+D!V/)#5%D!j[[jUnj[aqYZmVAoorFYZD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%.&0*$[ZpjqD!

ZqpD!! g2&/#J(++!:4M!i.*1!6HD!<#$!>.&#2>#,+(2128,!.%5!&*$.&9$%&!23!+$>+(+D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!j[[pUpnoajVAZpoFr[D!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW*.[jZpppD!

ZqnD!! g2&/#J(++!:4M!;22>$*+9(&#!;WM!W/@0%%!NHM!-$*80+2%!<PD!<#$!+$>+(+!+$$+.KA!&(1&(%8!&2K.*5!

(990%2+0>>*$++(2%D!V/)&!%7D!j[[YUZrarVAnYqFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%9[r[YFnYqD!

ZqrD!! 4/#K.%5&!<M!4/#09.J!7M!"($1$%!"gM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!=,!+>1$%(/!9./*2>#.8$+!

+0>>*$++$+!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!T!6^&cD!j[ZjUpZaZVAj[ZFZpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol$9=2GDj[ZZDpo[D!

ZqqD!! ;.0K$1+!.M!I.%!W211$!LM!N.%++$%!7M!$&!.1D!C*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1!+#2/J!=,!+210=1$!80.%,1.&$!/,/1.+$!(%#(=(&(2%!*$?0(*$+!30%/&(2%.1!(%50/(=1$!%(&*(/!2d(5$!+,%&#.+$D!,00#(*)9D!j[[[UZpajVAjjpFpZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[YoZYqrD!P//$++$5!P080+&!jqM!

j[ZnD!

ZqmD!! I.%!W211$!LM!L($12/Jd!7M!W.#($0!<M!$&!.1D!g4Cm[!C*2&$/&+!.8.(%+&!<e-F6%50/$5!E$&#.1!6%31.99.&2*,!

4#2/JD!,00#(*)9D!j[[jUZqarVAqorFqYrD!52(AZ[DZ[Zql4Z[mnFmqZpa[jV[[pZ[FjD!

ZqoD!! <.J.#.+#(!eM!I.%1.$*$!6M!5$!:,/J$!:M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!>*250/$5!=,!C.%$&#!/$11+!5*()$+!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JD!c&T_4&

!%7D!j[[oUj[raoVAZmrrFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[o[rooD!

ZqYD!! I.%5$),)$*!4M!@$G.8$*!EM!I.%!728.$*&!<M!$&!.1D!"10/2/2*&(/2(5!*$/$>&2*!5(9$*(R.&(2%!(%50/$+!WiCZ!&2!

>*2&$/&!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!(%31.99.&(2%D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjaqVAjZp[Fn[D!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6q[[[qD!

Zm[D!! g0,+!EM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!@$G.8$*!EM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!5*()$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1!+#2/JD!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[YUj[qaYVAZompFojD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[Y[jZpD!

ZmZD!! L$=$*!"-M!4K(*+J(!-iD!6990%2>.&#28$%$+(+!23!.=529(%.1!+$>+(+D!S/(8%(L%+B$&U5+;&M#58D!j[ZnUpYYaZVAZF

YD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+[[njpF[ZpFZZjYFmD!

ZmjD!! Ez)8*$%!<M!H12*.%&.!WFEM!7�)$!'M!P19!"!IM!:z%%=129!ED!6%50/&(2%!23!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%!(%!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!=,!(990%$!/29>1$d$+!/2%&.(%(%8!%0/1$(/!./(5!*$1$.+$5!=,!%$/*2&(/!2*!1.&$!

.>2>&2&(/!/$11+!.%5!10>0+!68"D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[[nUr[aqVAZoqZFmjD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&Dj[jrnD!

Page 91: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 78 of 237

ZmpD!! ;2%(81(.*2!CM!C$**(/2%$!;M!7$%+2%!:PM!$&!.1D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!+,+&$9!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!U#)"*00#(*)9D!

j[Z[UnpapVAjj[FrD!52(AZ[DpZ[Yl[oYZqYp[Y[prZ[YZnD!

ZmnD!! :z%%=129!EM!H12*.%&.!WFED!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.&0*$!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!?#55&^4*(&>;%#0/)".D!

j[ZpUjrajVAjnoFrpD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml7Q:D[=[Zp$pjopr/m$pjD!

ZmrD!! <2#,.9.!WM!�.%8!EM!g.%.J.K.!�M!@.(!OM!4#(*.J.&.!�M!4.,.9.!iD!,WVFh&T(;/(+%$&,SFDD&>%+%4)"5&T_45%$$*"(&

*(&]%5/)*("+9)%$N&U&\"$$*L.%&>".%&*(&);%&3%=%."40%()&"-&\$"5*/$*$OU!j[ZjAZYppFrD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDnqoD!

ZmqD!! P3+#.*!WM!W.*&(%$R!P@M!".112!:EM!g.&.!<:D!6%50/&(2%!.%5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;A!.!*$)($K!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!pq!/.+$+D!c&T#5&U+/7&3%50/)".&@%(%5%".D!j[ZpUjmaqVAmmZF

oD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqoFp[opDj[ZjD[nrojDdD!

ZmmD!! 62%$+/0!;M!W(/0!EM!;2%+&.%&(%$+/0!6M!g2*&2>.%!WM!'*+./(0/!;M!I2(/01$+/0!WD!C*212%8$5!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%!.1>#.!.%5!>$8(%&$*3$*2%!(%50/$+!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!+,%5*29$!.%5!$*,&#$9.!%252+09D!c&'/$)5"*()%$)*(&S*=%5&3*$D!j[[oUZmajVAjZZFjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZorqoZnrD!

ZmoD!! :.&$*9.%!g"M!I2++1.9=$*!4M!5$!:(55$*!4M!$&!.1D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!&,>$!6!+(8%.&0*$!&2K.*5+!>*$5(/&(2%!23!%2%F*$+>2%+$!&2!*(&0d(9.=!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!>.&($%&+D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[ZjUZnajVA:YrD!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*poZYD!

ZmYD!! 7.%/#$*$.0!NM!C.+/0.1!ID!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!(%!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!.%5!2&#$*!.0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+D!,00#(*)9D!j[[qUjrapVApopFYjD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[[qD[oD[Z[D!

Zo[D!! g.8=$*8!eM!7$*88*$%!QM!E$2%.*5!@M!$&!.1D!6-eFv!>*250/&(2%!=,!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!+&(901.&$5!K(&#!:ePF/2%&.(%(%8!(990%$!/29>1$d$+!(+!>*292&$5!=,!ei!/$11+!)(.!W6CFZu!.%5!E-PFZD!c&,00#(".D!

j[ZZUZoqaYVAr[orFYnD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZ[[ppnYD!

ZoZD!! <+/#0*&+/#$%&#.1$*!WM!L.%8!NM!-*(/J$!;M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.11(%8!(%!&#$!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09!.33$/&+!C.%$&#!/$11+M!9(/*2=(.1!$/2128,!.%5!$>(&#$1(.1!*$8$%$*.&(2%D!'#)D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&G%1Fj[ZpFp[roqpD!

ZojD!! i.&.J0*.!iM!E$$!NM!:./#9(1$K(&R!@M!E(!"M!H/J9.%%!EM!:.R!HD!<211F1(J$!*$/$>&2*!YF(%50/$5!&,>$!6!6-e!>*2&$/&+!9(/$!3*29!$d>$*(9$%&.1!/21(&(+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[rUZZrapVAqYrFm[jD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6jjYYqD!

ZopD!! 4K($/J(!WM!;212%%.!WD!'%*.)$1(%8!&#$!30%/&(2%+!23!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!50*(%8!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!.0&2(990%(&,M!.%5!&21$*.%/$D!,00#(".&>%=D!j[Z[UjpnaZVAZnjFqjD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGD[Z[rF

joYqDj[[YD[[ooZDdD!

ZonD!! 62.%%20!WM!P1(++.3(!<M!722%!EM!7209>.+!@M!I$*8(%(+!CD!6%!)()2!.=1.&(2%!23!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%#(=(&+!.0&2(990%(&,!&#*208#!$d>.%+(2%!23!9,$12(5F5$*()$5!+0>>*$++2*!/$11+D!c&,00#(".D!

j[ZpUZY[aqVAjqpZFn[D!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZj[ZoYmD!

ZorD!! 7*25!4PM!70*%+!@iD!40>>*$++(2%!23!*$1.>+(%8!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.0&2(990%$!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+!(%!&#$!4NElN!920+$!=,!2*.1!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+D!V%#5"."89D!ZYYnUnnaqVAZZnnFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5loj[onZpD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

ZoqD!! C*(%R!WM!4/#9(5&!gM!W(15%$*!PM!$&!.1D!@(+&(%/&!.%5!%2%*$50%5.%&!(%!)()2!30%/&(2%+!23!6-eP:!2%!9,$12(5!/$11+!1(9(&!.0&2(990%(&,!(%!&#$!/$%&*.1!%$*)20+!+,+&$9D!,00#(*)9D!j[[oUjoarVAqmrFoqD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[[oD[pD[ZZD!

ZomD!! "02!7M!;#.%8!H�M!;#$%8!"D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!(%50/&(2%!>.&#K.,!/2%+&*.(%+!<#ZmF9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!

(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[oUZZoarVAZqo[FY[D!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pppnjD!

ZooD!! 7.$/#1$*!H;M!7.&1(K.11.!-WM!i.*,>(+!"M!$&!.1D!6%&$*3$*2%F(%50/(=1$!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!+(8%.&0*$!(%!>$*(>#$*.1!=1225!/$11+!23!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$)$*$!10>0+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[pUZ[[arVAjqZ[FrD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[ppmqmYZ[[D!

Page 92: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 79 of 237

ZoYD!! 7$%%$&&!EM!C.10/J.!PiM!P*/$!HM!$&!.1D!6%&$*3$*2%!.%5!"*.%012>2($+(+!4(8%.&0*$+!(%!4,+&$9(/!E0>0+!

H*,&#$9.&2+0+!71225D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[pUZYmaqVAmZZFmjpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[jZrrpD!

ZY[D!! -2*+=./#!PM!Wf11$*!;M!W2%&(%2!;M!$&!.1D!V%8/)*=%&>%8#./)*"(&"-&);%&A94%&,&,()%5-%5"(&M*8(/.*(8&\/);J/9&L9&

M9();%)*+&A"..F.*B%&>%+%4)"5&E&S*8/(7$OU!j[ZnAjrnFqoD!52(AZ[DZ[oYlG(*Dj[ZZD[[YZD!

ZYZD!! Ef==$*+!NM!7*(%J!WM!).%!5$!4&.5&!EPM!$&!.1D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.&0*$!.+!.!=(29.*J$*!23!>*$/1(%(/.1!

*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!U((&>;%#0&3*$D!j[ZpUmjarVAmmqFo[D!52(AZ[DZZpql.%%*#$095(+Fj[ZjFj[jmrpD!

ZYjD!! <29$*!�M!W$%/2%(!-D!6%&$*3$*2%!(%50/$5!&#,*2(5(&(+D!6%$)&\5/+)&>%$&?.*(&T(7"+5*(".&!%)/LD!

j[[YUjpaqVAm[pFZjD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD=$$9Dj[[YD[mD[[nD!

ZYpD!! C.++2+!5$!420R.!HM!H).%8$1(+&.!4$80%52!C<M!N2+X!--M!E$9.(*$!@M!4.%&(.82!WD!:#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!(%50/$5!=,!.1>#.F(%&$*3$*2%!&#$*.>,D!?.*(&>;%#0/)".D!j[[ZUj[anVAjYmFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZrjYqnnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

ZYnD!! L.%8!�F4M!�20%8+&$*!4M!"*./$!WM!7.0+/#!NM!72*5$%+!:M!L,++!@-D!4&*0/&0*.1!.%5!=(2128(/.1!/#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!>$8,1.&$5!*$/29=(%.%&!(%&$*3$*2%!.1>#.Fj=!.%5!(&+!&#$*.>$0&(/!(9>1(/.&(2%+D!U7=&35#8&3%.*=&>%=D!

j[[jUrnanVArnmFrm[D!52(AZ[DZ[Zql4[ZqYFn[YOa[jV[[[jmFpD!

ZYrD!! W.%%+!WCM!L$5$9$,$*!gM!;2*%=$*8!WD!<*$.&(%8!)(*.1!#$>.&(&(+!;A!$33(/./,M!+(5$!$33$/&+M!.%5!/29>1(/.&(2%+D!

'#)D!j[[qUrraYVAZpr[FYD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&Dj[[rD[mqqnqD!

ZYqD!! e.5$$9!PM!P+1.9!WD!P++2/(.&(2%!23!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!.%5!*(=.)(*(%F(%50/$5!&#,*2(5!5,+30%/&(2%!K(&#!+$)$*(&,!23!5(+$.+$!.%5!*$+>2%+$!&2!&*$.&9$%&!(%!>.J(+&.%(!.+(.%!>.&($%&+!23!/#*2%(/!#$>.&(&(+!;D![%4/)&>%$&

A5%/)D!j[ZjUj[ZjAoqnpZrD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[ZjloqnpZrD!

ZYmD!! L.*5!@EM!7(%8F�20!:"D!P0&2(990%$!&#,*2(5!5,+30%/&(2%!(%50/$5!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&*$.&9$%&!32*!/#*2%(/!#$>.&(&(+!;A!+/*$$%(%8!.%5!92%(&2*(%8!*$/299$%5.&(2%+D!T(7"+5&\5/+)D!j[[ZUmaZVArjFoD!

52(AZ[DnZrolHCDmDZDrjD!

ZYoD!! s0.*.%&(%(!E;M!7*$++.%!:!.M!".1)�2!PM!7.&(+&.Fe$)$+!4M!C.*.%�!:M!W(*.%5.F4/(>>.!PD!6%/(5$%/$!23!>+,/#(.&*(/!+(5$!$33$/&+!50*(%8!>$8,1.&$5!(%&$*3$*2%F!.1>#.!*$&*$.&9$%&!(%!%2%*$+>2%5$*!#$>.&(&(+!;!)(*0+F

(%3$/&$5!>.&($%&+D!S*=%5&,()D!j[[mUjmaoVAZ[YoFZ[jD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnmoFpjpZDj[[mD[ZrpjDdD!

ZYYD!! e$+#$*!"M!:0/#1$9$*!:D!P1>#.F(%&$*3$*2%F(%50/$5!.*&#*(&(+A!/1(%(/.1!>*$+$%&.&(2%!&*$.&9$%&M!.%5!>*$)$%&(2%D!M%0*(&U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!ZYYoUjmaqVApq[FrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYqqjmrnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[[D!! :z%%=129!EHM!P19!"!IM!Q=$*8!iHD!P0&2(990%(&,!.3&$*!.1>#.F(%&$*3$*2%!&#$*.>,!32*!9.1(8%.%&!/.*/(%2(5!&092*+D!U((&,()%5(&!%7D!ZYYZUZZrapVAZmoFopD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lj[roomjD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[ZD!! 4�%/#$R!:29�%!NM!;.+&(112!C.19.!WNM!".*/�.!@�.R!HM!-$**$*!Q*5�%$R!NPD!�4,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!(%50/$5!=,!*$/29=(%.%&!.1>#.!(%&$*3$*2%!&*$.&9$%&�D!!%7&?.*(&16/5+2D!ZYYnUZ[jarVAZYoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5loZjmZmnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[jD!! L.&.%.=$!<M!g(*2%2!gM!g.+$8.K.!iM!428.!iM!4#(=.+.J(!iD!E(&$*.&0*$!*$)($K!(%!/.+$+!K(&#!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+!(%50/$5!=,!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%!.%5l2*!*(=.)(*(%D!c&'/$)5"%()%5".&[%4/)".D!

j[ZZUjqaZjVAZm[YFZqD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnn[FZmnqDj[ZZD[qoY[DdD!

j[pD!! 4>*$%8$*!:M!4.89$(+&$*!WM!Q33%$*!-D!P/0&$!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+!50*(%8!+0//$++301!(%&$*3$*2%l*(=.)(*(%!&*$.&9$%&!32*!/#*2%(/!#$>.&(&(+D!'#)D!j[[rUrnapVAnpoFYU!.0&#2*!*$>1,!npYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�Zmmnn[YB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[nD!! -0$*&$+!W7M!i./#.!PiM!i1(%$!NM!$&!.1D!g2+&!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1+!.*$!*$?0(*$5!32*!.%&(&092*!;@ox!<!/$11!*$+>2%+$+!&#*208#!;@o�.1>#.�x!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[ZZUj[oaZ[VAj[[rFZqD!

52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[Z[ZZrYD!

Page 93: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 80 of 237

j[rD!! @*2=(&+!7M!g21/9.%%!WM!P9=$*8!eM!$&!.1D!69(?0(925!/1$.*+!&092*+!(%!9(/$!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!=,!/2%)$*&(%8!>@;+!(%&2!&092*FJ(11(%8!$33$/&2*!/$11+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjajVArmrForD!

52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZ[pnD!

j[qD!! '>*$&(!WM!i22%/$!ePM!g$%%(%8+!EM!;#.9=$*+!<;M!"*(33(%!:ND!C$8,1.&$5!6-eFv!+$%+(&(R$+!9$1.%29.!/$11+!&2!/#$92&#$*.>,!.%5!/.0+$+!>*$9.&0*$!+$%$+/$%/$!(%!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+!=,!6:-FZ!9$5(.&$5!+(8%.1(%8D!?%..&

3%/);&3*$D!j[Z[UZA$qmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol/55(+Dj[Z[DnpD!

j[mD!! �.%8!OM!�#.%8!OM!-0!WEM!$&!.1D!<.*8$&(%8!&#$!&092*!9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!=*(58$+!(%%.&$!

.%5!.5.>&()$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$+D!?/(+%5&?%..D!j[ZnUjraZVApmFnoD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD//*Dj[ZpDZjD[[nD!

j[oD!! ;#.K1.F4.*J.*!WM!E$.9.%!@LM!72*5$%!H;D!C*$3$*$%&(.1!(%50/&(2%!23!.>2>&2+(+!=,!(%&$*3$*2%!a6-eVF=$&.!/29>.*$5!K(&#!6-eF.1>#.jA!/2**$1.&(2%!K(&#!<:P6ElP>2jE!(%50/&(2%!(%!9$1.%29.!/$11!1(%$+D!?.*(&+/(+%5&>%$D!j[[ZUmaqVAZojZFpZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZnZ[rjrD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[YD!! C.,%$!WNM!P*8,*2>20120!iM!E2*(8.%!CM!$&!.1D!C#.+$!66!>(12&!+&05,!23!(%&*.)$%20+!#(8#F52+$!(%&$*3$*2%!K(&#!2*!K(&#20&!9.(%&$%.%/$!&*$.&9$%&!(%!9$1.%29.!.&!#(8#!*(+J!23!*$/0**$%/$D!c&?.*(&^(+".D!j[ZnUpjapVAZorFY[D!52(AZ[DZj[[lN;QDj[ZpDnYDomZmD!

jZ[D!! W/P*&#0*!"!.D!P5G0).%&!(%&$*3$*2%!(%!9$1.%29.A!(+!50*.&(2%!23!&#$*.>,!(9>2*&.%&S!c&?.*(&^(+".D!j[ZnUpjapVAZmZFpD!52(AZ[DZj[[lN;QDj[ZpDrpDrZmYD!

jZZD!! @*2=(&+!7M!g21/9.%%!WM!P9=$*8!eM!$&!.1D!69(?0(925!/1$.*+!&092*+!(%!9(/$!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!=,!/2%)$*&(%8!>@;+!(%&2!&092*FJ(11(%8!$33$/&2*!/$11+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjajVArmrForD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZ[pnD!

jZjD!! g21/9.%%!WM!@*2=(&+!7M!4(=(1(.!WD!g2K!(9(?0(925!1(/$%+$+!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!&2!J(11!&092*+D!^(+"*00#("."89D!j[ZjUZaYVAZqqZFZqqpD!52(AZ[DnZqZl2%/(Djj[ppD!

jZpD!! ;*.3&!eM!7*0#%!iLM!e80,$%!7@M!$&!.1D!<#$!<E:m!P82%(+&!69(?0(925!H%#.%/$+!&#$!P%&(FW$1.%29.!H33$/&+!23!.!:$/29=(%.%&!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+!I.//(%$D!c&,00#(".D!j[[rUZmrapVAZYopFZYY[D!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZmrDpDZYopD!

jZnD!! N(9X%$RF7.*.%5.!4M!4(1).!6CM!7#.*5K.G!eD!C1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!1$.5!&#$!/#.*8$!.8.(%+&!&092*+D!c&

?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjajVAnoZFnD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZpnrD!

jZrD!! C.&,!@LM!E(!@i7D!6%&$*3$*2%!=$&.FZ=!(+!$33$/&()$!(%!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+A!66D!W:6!.%.1,+(+!*$+01&+!23!.!901&(/$%&$*M!*.%529(R$5M!520=1$F=1(%5M!>1./$=2F/2%&*211$5!&*(.1D!V%#5"."89D!ZYYpUnpanVAqqjF

qqjD!52(AZ[DZjZjlLeEDnpDnDqqjD!

jZqD!! W21,%$0d!C@M!i.>>2+!EM!C219.%!;M!$&!.1D!<#$!$33$/&!23!(%&$*3$*2%!=$&.FZ=!&*$.&9$%&!2%!W:6!9$.+0*$+!23!/$*$=*.1!.&*2>#,!(%!+$/2%5.*,!>*28*$++()$!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!H0*2>$.%!4&05,!"*20>!2%!6%&$*3$*2%!=$&.FZ=!(%!+$/2%5.*,!>*28*$++()$!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!65/*(D!j[[[UZjp!aC.*&!AjjrqFqpD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZ[r[[jrD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jZmD!! 42*9.%(!WCM!@$!4&$3.%2!eD!@$3(%(%8!.%5!+/2*(%8!*$+>2%+$!&2!6-eFu!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!V/)&>%=&V%#5".D!

j[ZpUYaYVAr[nFZjD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%*%$0*21Dj[ZpDZnqD!

jZoD!! :05(/J!:PM!:.%(!W:4M!O0!�M!$&!.1D!Hd/$++()$!=(2128(/!*$+>2%+$!&2!6-eu!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!>22*!&*$.&9$%&!*$+>2%+$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!N./2=+2%!4M!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZZUqarVA$ZYjqjD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[ZYjqjD!

jZYD!! :25*(80$+!4M!W.8*2!-M!42.*$+!NM!$&!.1D!;.+$!+$*($+A!01/$*.&()$!/21(&(+M!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+M!.%5!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!

Z.D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!j[Z[UZqaZjVAj[[ZFpD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl(=5DjZjnjD!

jj[D!! E.!W.%&(.!EM!;.>+2%(!-D!C+2*(.+(+!50*(%8!(%&$*3$*2%!=$&.!&*$.&9$%&!32*!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!V%#5".&M+*D!

j[Z[UpZapVAppmFYD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[[mjF[[YF[ZonFdD!

Page 94: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 81 of 237

jjZD!! 72%./(Fe(J21(/!7M!N$*$9(/!6M!P%5*$G$)(/!4M!4$3(JF70J(1(/.!WM!4&2G+.)1G$)(/!eM!@*012)(/!ND!P%&(F520=1$!+&*.%5$5!@eP!.%5!10>0+!+,%5*29$!(%50/$5!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!&#$*.>,!(%!.!>.&($%&!K(&#!901&(>1$!

+/1$*2+(+D!S#4#$D!j[[YUZoaZVAmoFo[D!52(AZ[DZZmml[YqZj[pp[o[Yprr[D!

jjjD!! 41.5J2).!IM!W.*$+!NM!E0=$%2).!7M!g10+&(J!CM!i.%2)+J,!CD!@*08F(%50/$5!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!(%!(%&$*3$*2%!=$&.FZ=!&#$*.>,D!V%#5"&T(7"+5*(".&S%))D!j[ZZUpjaZVAnFqD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5ljZn[mZqjD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jjpD!! <(%&(%.11(!NHM!4&.>/R,%+J(!NM!W.!QNM!;1(%$!@M!;,501J.!:M!W$/J1$*!"D!T0%58%(+9&!%7*+*(%N&U&?"045%;%($*=%&

M)#79&'#*7%&1T0%58%(+9&!%7*+*(%&1A*()*(/..*22D!e$K!�2*JA!W/"*.KFg(11U!j[Z[AZqrFZmjD!

jjnD!! g2*%(J!;CM!7$%G.9(%!@iM!7$/J$*!i;M!$&!.1D!'+$!23!&#$!/29>1$&$!=1225!/$11!/20%&!(%!$.*1,F2%+$&!%$2%.&.1!

+$>+(+D!\%7*/)5&,(-%+)&3*$&cD!j[ZjUpZaoVAmYYFo[jD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml6e-D[=[Zp$pZojrqY[r/D!

jjrD!! �(.G.!WD!4$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!$%/$>#.12>.&#,A!/#.*./&$*(+&(/+!.%5!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+D!W".*/&V%#5"4/);".D!

j[ZjUpAjpZFjpYD!52(AZ[DrZZnl3%Dj[ZjDp[rjpD!

jjqD!! -.(*/#(15!i@M!Qc4#$.!<WD!g$.*&!*.&$!/#.*./&$*(+&(/+A!>#,+(29.*J$*+!32*!5$&$/&(2%!23!1.&$F2%+$&!%$2%.&.1!

+$>+(+D!?.*(&\%5*(/)".D!j[Z[UpmapVAroZFYoD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/1>Dj[Z[D[qD[[jD!

jjmD!! C.&$*+2%!:EM!L$=+&$*!e:D!4$>+(+!.%5!&#$!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!+,%5*29$D!c&>&?"..&M#58&T7*(LD!j[[[UnrapVAZmoFojD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[ooZnorD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!

j[ZnD!

jjoD!! N.K.5!6M!E0J�(�!6M!:.3%++2%!47D!P++$++(%8!.).(1.=1$!(%32*9.&(2%!2%!&#$!=0*5$%!23!+$>+(+A!812=.1!$+&(9.&$+!

23!(%/(5$%/$M!>*$).1$%/$!.%5!92*&.1(&,D!c&'."L&[%/.);D!j[ZjUjaZVA[Z[n[nD!52(AZ[DmZoYlG28#D[jD[Z[n[nD!

jjYD!! '112.!EM!7*0%%$*!WM!:.92+!EM!@$(&/#!HPD!4/($%&(3(/!.%5!/1(%(/.1!/#.11$%8$+!(%!+$>+(+D!?#55&\;/50&3%$D!j[[YUZraZqVAZYZoFprD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�p[Yorp[B&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jmM!j[ZnD!

jp[D!! W.*+#.11!N;D!L#,!#.)$!/1(%(/.1!&*(.1+!(%!+$>+(+!3.(1$5S!A5%(7$&!".&!%7D!j[ZnUj[anVAZYrFj[pD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD9219$5Dj[ZnD[ZD[[mD!

jpZD!! P*&$*2!PM!�.*.82R.!:M!e280$(*.!NWD!M%=%5%&M%4$*$&/(7&M%4)*+&M;"+B&F&<(7%5$)/(7*(8&/&M%5*"#$&]*..%5D!

a-$*%.%5$R!:M!$5DVD!6%<$/#U!j[ZjApFjrD!52(AZ[DrmmjlZpZZD!

jpjD!! 4$2J!NM!L.**$%!g4M!;0$%/.!P"M!$&!.1D!"$%29(/!*$+>2%+$+!(%!920+$!925$1+!>22*1,!9(9(/!#09.%!

(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[aYVApr[mFZjD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZjjjomoZZ[D!

jppD!! e$(!WM!"1.RJ2!"!ID!<#$!L(1#$19(%$!HD!i$,!j[[Z!6%)(&.&(2%.1!E$/&0*$D!H+&(9.&(2%!23!5()$*8$%/$!&(9$+!32*!.!3$K!9.99.1(.%!.%5!+$)$*.1!>*(9.&$!+>$/($+D!c&[%5%7D!j[[jUYpapVAZrmFqnD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZjZYr[jYD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jpnD!! ;.0K$1+!PM!I.%5$%5*($++/#$!7M!7*20/J.$*&!CD!Q3!9(/$M!9$%M!.%5!(%31.99.&(2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!

j[ZpUZZ[apnVAHpZr[D!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZp[opppZZ[D!

jprD!! ;.0K$1+!PM!7*20/J.$*&!CD!e(&*(&$!*$801.&(2%!23!+#2/JD!?/57*"=/$+&>%$D!j[ZZUoYapVArrpFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[Ypl/)*l/)?pZmD!

jpqD!! I.%!5$*!C211!<M!E$)(!WM!).%!@$)$%&$*!4NM!$&!.1D!@(33$*$%&(.1!$33$/&+!23!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25($+!2%!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$+!(%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!$%52&2d$9(.!(%!/#(9>.%R$$+D!6.""7D!ZYYnUopajVAnnqFrZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lojoqmnjD!P//$++$5!Q/&2=$*!jpM!

j[ZnD!

jpmD!! <.,12*!-7M!;#.%8!PM!H+92%!;<M!@cP%8$12!PM!I(8.%2F@cP%8$12!4M!71(/J!iHD!C*2&$(%!;!>*$)$%&+!&#$!/2.8012>.&#(/!.%5!1$&#.1!$33$/&+!23!H+/#$*(/#(.!/21(!(%30+(2%!(%!&#$!=.=22%D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!ZYomUmYapVAYZoF

jrD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6ZZjY[jD!

Page 95: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 82 of 237

jpoD!! 4(%8#!NPM!L$11+!"PM!;#*(+&$%+$%!:M!$&!.1D!P5)$*+$!$33$/&+!23!=(2128(/+A!.!%$&K2*J!9$&.F.%.1,+(+!.%5!;2/#*.%$!2)$*)($KD!?"+;5/(%&7/)/L/$%&M9$)&>%=D!j[ZZUajVA;@[[omYnD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jlZnqrZoroD;@[[omYnD>0=jD!

jpYD!! @2(!iM!E$$1.#.).%(/#J01!PM!�0$%!C4<M!4&.*!:PD!4/($%/$!(%!9$5(/(%$!P%(9.1!925$1+!23!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>+(+F

(%50/$5!J(5%$,!(%G0*,D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[YUZZYaZ[VAjoqoFmoD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pYnjZDjoqoD!

jn[D!! <*./$,!iNM!L$(!gM!W.%280$!i:M!$&!.1D!;./#$/&(%l&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%50/$+!/./#$d(.M!.%$9(.M!.%5!(%31.99.&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!ZYooUZqmapVAZjZZFjmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jZoooopB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jnZD!! I.++.11(!CD!<#$!>.&#2>#,+(2128,!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*+D!U((#&>%=&,00#(".D!ZYYjUZ[AnZZFrjD!

52(AZ[DZZnql.%%0*$)D(,DZ[D[n[ZYjD[[jjZZD!

jnjD!! ;.0K$1+!PM!N.%++$%!7M!L.$,&$%+!PM!;0)$1($*!;M!7*20/J.$*&!CD!;.+>.+$!(%#(=(&(2%!/.0+$+!#,>$*./0&$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!+#2/J!)(.!2d(5.&()$!+&*$++!.%5!>#2+>#21(>.+$!PjD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[[pUnanVApomF

YpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(YZnD!

jnpD!! 7.0++!-M!@*z8$!LM!W�%%$1!@eD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!9$5(.&$+!$%52&2d(/!$33$/&+!(%!9(/$D!,(-%+)&,00#(D!ZYomUrramVAZqjjFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jq[rqoB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=+&

*./&D!

jnnD!! "2159.%!"M!4233$*!@M!g$11$*!EM!P5$*J.!@M!E.#.&!PM!i1.0+%$*!NWD!<0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!9$5(.&$+!=./&$*(.1!&*.%+12/.&(2%!.3&$*!#.$92**#.8(/!+#2/J!.%5!$%52&2d.$9(.D!T#5&c&M#58D!j[[ZUZqmanVAjYYFp[nD!

52(AZ[DZ[o[lZZ[jnZr[Zp[[[YZrnpD!

jnrD!! -*.%/X+!:M!;#().!WM!4�%/#$R!HM!$&!.1D!7./&$*(.1!&*.%+12/.&(2%!(+!52K%*$801.&$5!=,!.%&(F<e-F.1>#.!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!(%!*.&+!K(&#!/(**#2+(+!.%5!.+/(&$+D!c&[%4/)".D!j[[mUnqarVAmYmFo[pD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG#$>Dj[[qDZZD[ZoD!

jnqD!! ;1.*J!H;M!C.&$1!4@M!;#.5K(/J!C:M!L.*#0*+&!"M!;0**,!PM!;.*1+2%!"ED!"10&.9(%$!5$>*().&(2%!3./(1(&.&$+!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%50/$5!=./&$*(.1!&*.%+12/.&(2%!(%!;./2Fj!/$11+!=,!5$>1$&(2%!23!$%&$*2/,&$!30$1!+0=+&*.&$D!'#)D!j[[pUrjajVAjjnFp[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZmmnYnoB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!N01,!ZZM!j[ZnD!

jnmD!! 4/#9(5&!;M!gz/#$*1!iM!4/#K$5.!-M!70/#$*!WD!C*2(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!/.0+$!52K%F*$801.&(2%!23!*$%.1!/#12*(5$!$%&*,!>.&#K.,+!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!?5*)&?/5%&!%7D!j[[mUpraYVAjZZ[FYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZmorrojnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jnoD!! 4/#K.*&R!@M!W$%52%/.!WM!4/#K.*&R!6M!$&!.1D!6%#(=(&(2%!23!/2%+&(&0&()$!%(&*(/!2d(5$!+,%&#.+$!aeQ4V!=,!%(&*(/!2d(5$!8$%$*.&$5!=,!(%50/(=1$!eQ4!.3&$*!1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!>*2)2J$+!*$%.1!5,+30%/&(2%!(%!*.&+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!ZYYmUZ[[ajVAnpYFnoD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6ZZYrrZD!

jnYD!! i%2&$J!WM!:28./#$)!7M!L.%8!LM!$&!.1D!H%52&2d$9(/!*$%.1!3.(10*$!(%!9(/$A!:21$!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!(%50/(=1$!%(&*(/!2d(5$!+,%&#.+$D!]*7(%9&,()D!j[[ZUrYaqVAjjnpFYD!52(AZ[DZ[nqlGDZrjpF

ZmrrDj[[ZD[[mn[DdD!

jr[D!! :(&&(*+/#!@M!g2$+$1!EWM!L.*5!CPD!<#$!5(+/2%%$/&!=$&K$$%!.%(9.1!925$1+!23!+$>+(+!.%5!#09.%!+$>+(+D!c&

S%#B"+&6*".D!j[[mUoZaZVAZpmFnpD!52(AZ[DZZoYlG1=D[o[qrnjD!

jrZD!! @$G.8$*!EM!C(%#$(*2!6M!@$G2%/J#$$*$!HM!E(=$*&!;D!;$/.1!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$A!&#$!8215!+&.%5.*5!925$1!32*!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+S!A5%(7$&!*+5"L*".D!j[ZZUZYanVAZYoFj[oD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD&(9Dj[ZZD[ZD[[ZD!

jrjD!! :(&&(*+/#!@M!g0=$*FE.%8!W4M!-1($*1!WPM!L.*5!CPD!6990%25$+(8%!23!$d>$*(9$%&.1!+$>+(+!=,!/$/.1!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$D!V/)&\5")"+D!j[[YUnaZVApZFqD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%>*2&Dj[[oDjZnD!

Page 96: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 83 of 237

jrpD!! H/#&$%./#$*!7M!W�%%$1!@eM!gf1&%$*!ED!;*(&(/.1!>*2&$/&()$!*21$!23!9.+&!/$11+!(%!.!925$1!23!./0&$!+$>&(/!

>$*(&2%(&(+D!V/)#5%D!ZYYqUpoZaqrmmVAmrFmD!52(AZ[DZ[polpoZ[mr.[D!

jrnD!! 4/#.==.0$*!"D!C21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!925$1+A!;EC!)$*+0+!;P4CD!35#8&3*$+"=&A"7/9&3*$&!"7%.D!

j[ZjUYaZVA$ZmF$jZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD55925Dj[ZZDZ[D[[jD!

jrrD!! <*.$8$*!<M!i2$*%$*!CM!i$++1$*!LM!$&!.1D!;212%!.+/$%5$%+!+&$%&!>$*(&2%(&(+!a;P4CVFF.!+&.%5.*5(R$5!925$1!

32*!>21,9(/*2=(.1!.=529(%.1!+$>+(+D!c&@*$&T_4D!j[Z[UanqVD!52(AZ[DpmYZljjYYD!

jrqD!! 7*.$0%(%8$*!4M!i1$(%+/#%(&R!;D!:25$%&!925$1+!23!32/.1!/$*$=*.1!(+/#$9(.A!>*2/$50*.1!>(&3.11+!.%5!

&*.%+1.&(2%.1!>*2=1$9+D!T_4&A5/($.&M)5"B%&!%7D!j[[YUZaZVAoD!52(AZ[DZZoqlj[n[FmpmoFZFoD!

jrmD!! L$(!sM!@2%8!�D!W20+$!925$1!23!(+/#$9(/!./0&$!J(5%$,!(%G0*,A!&$/#%(/.1!%2&$+!.%5!&*(/J+D!U0&c&\;9$*".&

>%(/.&\;9$*".D!j[ZjUp[paZZVA-ZnomFYnD!52(AZ[DZZrjl.G>*$%.1D[[prjDj[ZjD!

jroD!! -0G(#.*.!WM!6&2!eM!C./$!NEM!L.&.%.=$!�M!:0++$11!4LM!40R0J(!<D!:21$!23!$%528$%20+!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!(%!1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F&*(88$*$5!./&().&(2%!23!&#$!(%50/(=1$!%(&*(/F2d(5$!+,%&#.+$!8$%$!(%!.!920+$!9./*2>#.8$!/$11!1(%$M!NmmnD!c&6*".&?;%0D!ZYYnUjqYaZmVAZjmmpFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lmrZpqYnD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jrYD!! W21%.*3(!eM!"*0.R!EM!@.,$*!NFWM!70*8$*!@D!Q>>2+(&$!$33$/&+!23!6-e!=$&.!2%!/,&2J(%$!#29$2+&.+(+!(%!EC4F!.%5!<!/$11!/2%&./&F./&().&$5!#09.%!92%2/,&$+D!c&V%#5"*00#(".D!j[[nUZnqaZFjVAmqFopD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZnqYoonYD!P//$++$5!N01,!ZZM!j[ZnD!

jq[D!! W.#($0!<M!C.*J!NWM!:$)$&+!gM!$&!.1D!<#$!K(15F5$*()$5!(%=*$5!920+$!+&*.(%!4C:H<lH(!(+!*$+(+&.%&!&2!EC4!.%5!5$3$/&()$!(%!6-eF=$&.!>*250/&(2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[qUZ[pamVAjjYjFmD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[rZ[omnZ[pD!

jqZD!! ;0=(11.+!:M!i(%&%$*!iM!C#(11(>+!-M!i.*.%5(J.*!eNM!<#($1$!@EM!7*2K%!":D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!$d>*$++(2%!(+!0>*$801.&$5!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!g;I!K#2!*$+>2%5!&2!&#$*.>,D![%4/)&

>%$&A5%/)D!j[Z[Uj[Z[AnjYjnpD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[Z[lnjYjnpD!

jqjD!! :2&2%5(!WM!4&03.%2!-M!E.82%(8*2!W4M!$&!.1D!6%&$*3$*2%Fu!=0&!%2&!"1.&(*.9$*!./$&.&$!+&(901.&$+!;O;EZ[!+$/*$&(2%!(%!>*(9.*,!/01&0*$+!23!&#,*2/,&$+A!.!/10$!32*!0%5$*+&.%5(%8!&#$!5(33$*$%&!*(+J+!23!&#,*2(5!5,+30%/&(2%+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!&*$.&$5!K(&#!$(&#$*!23!&#$!&K2!5*08+D!c&V%#5"*00#(".D!

j[ZZUjpnaZFjVAZqZFnD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG%$0*2(9Dj[ZZD[ZD[ZpD!

jqpD!! Q%2R.J(!iM!'*.K.!gM!<.9.&.%(!<M!$&!.1D!4,%$*8(+&(/!(%&$*./&(2%+!23!(%&$*1$0J(%!ZM!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.M!.%5!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%!&$*9(%.11,!5(33$*$%&(.&(%8!.!920+$!9,$12(5!1$0J$9(/!/$11!1(%$!aWZVD!H)(5$%/$!&#.&!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!(+!.%!.0&2/*(%$!5(33$*$%&(.&(%8!3./&2*D!c&,00#(".D!ZYooUZn[aZVAZZjFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lpjmrmZqD!P//$++$5!N01,!ZZM!j[ZnD!

jqnD!! -(%J!iM!W.*&(%!EM!W0J.K$*.!HM!$&!.1D!6-eul<e-v!+,%$*8(+9!(%50/$+!.!%2%F/.%2%(/.1!4<P<jl6:-YF5$>$%5$%&!>.&#K.,!&*(88$*(%8!.!%2)$1!@'QOj!eP@Cg!2d(5.+$F9$5(.&$5!.(*K.,!.%&()(*.1!*$+>2%+$D!?%..&

>%$D!j[ZpUjparVAqmpFY[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol/*Dj[ZpDnmD!

jqrD!! <+0G(92&2!WM!-$(%9.%!:M!I(1/$J!ND!@(33$*$%&(.1!$33$/&+!23!&,>$!6!6-e!.%5!6-eF8.99.!2%!&#$!=(%5(%8!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&2!*$/$>&2*+!(%!&K2!#09.%!/$11!1(%$+D!c&,00#(".D!ZYoqUZpmamVAjjmjFqD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKDG(990%21D2*8l/2%&$%&lZpmlmljjmjD.=+&*./&D!P//$++$5!N01,!ZZM!j[ZnD!

jqqD!! ;2$*+!NM!I.%/$!:HM!-2%&.%.!W-M!@($&*(/#!L-D!:$+&*(/&(2%!23!E$8(2%$11.!>%$092>#(1.!8*2K&#!(%!9./*2>#.8$+!*$?0(*$+!&#$!/2%/$*&$5!./&(2%!23!/,&2J(%$!.%5!e.(>rl6>.3!+(8%.11(%8!>.&#K.,+D!?%..&

!*+5"L*".D!j[[mUYaZ[VAjpnnFrmD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqjFrojjDj[[mD[[YqpDdD!

jqmD!! 4#$9$*FP)%(!�M!L.11./#!@M!4.*2)!6D!:$)$*+(2%!23!&#$!.%&(/#1.9,5(.1!$33$/&!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!=,!&*,>&2>#.%!.%5!.%&(=25($+!&2!=$&.!(%&$*3$*2%D!,(-%+)&,00#(D!ZYoYUrmaZZVApnonFpnY[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>All(.(D.+9D2*8l/2%&$%&lrmlZZlpnonD!P//$++$5!N01,!ZZM!j[ZnD!

Page 97: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 84 of 237

jqoD!! -.(*K$.&#$*!@M!:2+$!e:D!L29$%!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!T0%58&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[[nUZ[aZZVAj[[rFZZD!

52(AZ[Dpj[Zl$(5Z[ZZD[n[pqmD!

jqYD!! @.!4(1).!NPD!4$d!#2*92%$+M!810/2/2*&(/2(5+!.%5!.0&2(990%(&,A!3./&+!.%5!#,>2&#$+$+D!U((&>;%#0&3*$D!ZYYrUrnaZVAqFZqD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�Z[[rr[[B&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jm[D!! E(=$*&!;M!@$G.8$*!EM!C(%#$(*2!6D!<#$!O!/#*292+29$!(%!(990%$!30%/&(2%+A!K#$%!.!/#*292+29$!9.J$+!&#$!

5(33$*$%/$D!V/)&>%=&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZ[aoVArYnFq[nD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%*(joZrD!

jmZD!! H*/21(%(!PWM!W(11$*!4@D!W21$/01.*!9(9(/+!/.%!(%50/$!%2)$1!+$13!>$>&(5$F*$./&()$!;@nx!<!/$11!/12%2&,>$+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$D!c&,00#(".D!j[[mUZmYaZ[VAqq[nFZjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZmYoj[r[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jmjD!! QJ.5.!gM!i0#%!;M!-$(11$&!gM!7./#!NF-D!<#$!`#,8($%$!#,>2&#$+(+_!32*!.0&2(990%$!.%5!.11$*8(/!5(+$.+$+A!.%!

0>5.&$D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZq[aZVAZFYD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFjjnYDj[Z[D[nZpYDdD!

jmpD!! -1$9(%8!NM!-.=*,!�D!<#$!#,8($%$!#,>2&#$+(+!.%5!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!U((&V%#5".D!j[[mUqZajVAorFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.%.DjZ[YjD!

jmnD!! P*%$&&!-;M!:$)$(11$!N@M!@0)(/!WD!C+2*(.+(+!.%5!>+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!#09.%!(990%25$3(/($%/,!)(*0+!(%3$/&(2%D!>;%#0&3*$&?.*(&V"5);&U0D!ZYYZUZmaZVArYFmoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lj[nZooYD!P//$++$5!N01,!ZjM!j[ZnD!

jmrD!! i.*.=05.J!P=0.3!QM!@28.%!7D!W.%.8$9$%&!23!80&&.&$!>+2*(.+(+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!.++2/(.&$5!+&*$>&2/2//.1!

(%3$/&(2%D!\$"5*/$*$&A/58%)$&A;%5D!j[ZjUj[ZjAjAoYFYnD!52(AZ[DjZnmlC<<D4jrjZZD!

jmqD!! H*/21(%(!PWM!W(11$*!4@D!<#$!*21$!23!(%3$/&(2%+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!j[[YUZrraZVAZF

ZrD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFjjnYDj[[oD[popnDdD!

jmmD!! C.J>22*!NM!"(2).%%2%(!"M!:.9.82>.1.%!4!ID!H>+&$(%F7.**!)(*0+!.%5!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+A!.++2/(.&(2%!2*!

/.0+.&(2%S!T_4%5)&>%=&V%#5");%5D!j[ZpUZpapVAjomFYmD!52(AZ[DZroql$*%DZpDqD!

jmoD!! Q#.*.!�D!W01&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!.%5!9$.+1$+!)(*0+D!c4(&c&,(-%+)&3*$D!ZYYYUrjarVAZYoFj[[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[qo[[orD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!YM!j[ZnD!

jmYD!! g2*K(&R!W4M!7*.51$,!EWM!g.*=$*&+2%!NM!i*.#1!<M!E$$!NM!4.*)$%%(/J!eD!@(.=$&$+!(%50/$5!=,!;2d+./J($!)(*0+A!6%(&(.&(2%!=,!=,+&.%5$*!5.9.8$!.%5!%2&!921$/01.*!9(9(/*,D!V/)&!%7D!ZYYoUnamVAmoZFmorD!

52(AZ[DZ[pol%9[mYoFmoZD!

jo[D!! W$%+$*!WPM!-2**$+&!NWM!7*.%+=,!:@D!:0=$11.!(%3$/&(2%!.%5!5(.=$&$+!9$11(&0+D!S/(+%)D!ZYmoUZao[rrVArmFq[D!

P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lmnrqnD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!YM!j[ZnD!

joZD!! C.J!;�M!H0%!gWM!W/P*&#0*!:"M!�22%!NLD!P++2/(.&(2%!23!/,&29$8.12)(*0+!(%3$/&(2%!K(&#!.0&2(990%$!&,>$!Z!5(.=$&$+D!S/(+%)D!ZYooUjaoq[ZVAZFnD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5ljoYoqj[D!

P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!YM!j[ZnD!

jojD!! :$55,!;WM!;*09>!HCD!@(.=$&$+!9$11(&0+!32112K(%8!909>+D!c&V/).&!%7&U$$"+D!ZYmqUqoaqVAnrYFq[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jq[Ym[mB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!YM!j[ZnD!

jopD!! e$KJ(*J!WWM!�=.*!PM!7.*2%!WM!W.%8$+!P:D!@(+&(%/&!=./&$*(.1!/212%(R.&(2%!>.&&$*%+!23!H+/#$*(/#(.!/21(!+0=&,>$+!.++2/(.&$!K(&#!*#$09.&2(5!3./&2*!+&.&0+!(%!$.*1,!(%31.99.&2*,!.*&#*(&(+D!>;%#0/)"."89&1^_-"572D!

j[Z[UnYamVAZpZZFqD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl*#$09.&2128,lJ$?[ooD!

jonD!! :22J!"M!E,5,.*5!CM!4&.%32*5!ND!W,/2=./&$*(.!.%5!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!ZYY[UppapVAnpZF

nprD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DZmo[pp[pZYD!

Page 98: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 85 of 237

jorD!! ;2+&$%=.5$*!igM!i.*1+2%!HLD!H>+&$(%F7.**!)(*0+!.%5!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+A!(+!&#$*$!.!1(%JS!U5);5*)*$&>%$&

A;%5D!j[[qUoaZVAj[nD!52(AZ[DZZoql.*ZoYpD!

joqD!! -$**(!;M!4$=.+&(.%(!WM!P%&2%$11(!PM!;21./(!WM!W.%3*$5(!PM!"(088(21(!@D!;0**$%&!&*$.&9$%&!23!#$>.&(&(+!;F

.++2/(.&$5!*#$09.&(/!5(+$.+$+D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[ZjUZnapVAjZrD!52(AZ[DZZoql.*poqrD!

jomD!! I(11$5.F".=*($1!"M!4.%&.9.*�.F;282112+!E;M!CX*$RFE2*$%R2!:M!$&!.1D!:$/28%(&(2%!23!4&*$>&2/2//0+!>,28$%$+!.%5!+J(%!.0&2.%&(8$%+!(%!80&&.&$!>+2*(.+(+D!U5+;&!%7&>%$D!ZYYoUjYajVAZnpFoD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lYqr[pjYD!P//$++$5!e2)$9=$*!YM!j[ZnD!

jooD!! "0>&.!WPM!"0>&.!PiD!P8$!.%5!8$%5$*!5(33$*$%/$+!(%!&#$!(9>./&!23!>+2*(.+(+!2%!?0.1(&,!23!1(3$D!,()&c&3%50/)".D!ZYYrUpnaZ[VAm[[FpD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lorpmZrmD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

joYD!! C.*(+(!:M!4,992%+!@CWM!"*(33(&#+!;HWM!P+#/*23&!@WD!"12=.1!$>(5$9(2128,!23!>+2*(.+(+A!.!+,+&$9.&(/!

*$)($K!23!(%/(5$%/$!.%5!>*$).1$%/$D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZpUZppajVApmmForD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZjDppYD!

jY[D!! :./#.J2%5.!<@M!4/#0>>!;LM!P*9+&*2%8!PLD!C+2*(.+(+!>*$).1$%/$!.92%8!.501&+!(%!&#$!'%(&$5!4&.&$+D!c&U0&

U+/7&3%50/)".D!j[ZnUm[apVArZjFqD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG..5Dj[ZpDZZD[ZpD!

jYZD!! g.1>*(%!iWD!H>(5$*9.1!`<0*%2)$*!<(9$_!F!P!:$F$d.9(%.&(2%D!65&c&3%50/)".D!ZYmjUoqaZVAZnFZYD!

52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFjZppDZYmjD&=[ZooqDdD!

jYjD!! 71.%>.(%!;M!-0/#+!HD!H>(5$*9.1!+&$9!/$11+!23!&#$!+J(%D!U((#&>%=&?%..&3%=&6*".D!j[[qUjjAppYFmpD!

52(AZ[DZZnql.%%0*$)D/$11=(2DjjD[Z[p[rDZ[nprmD!

jYpD!! 40&$*!WWM!4/#01R$!iM!7$*89.%!LM!L$11$!WM!:22+G$!CM!Wf11$*!HND!<#$!J$*.&(%2/,&$!(%!$>(5$*9.1!*$%$K.1!

.%5!5$3$%/$D!@%)&3%50/)".D!j[[YUj[arFqVArZrFpjD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFpZqnDj[[YD[[oZYDdD!

jYnD!! -0/#+!HM!"*$$%!gD!;#.%8$+!(%!J$*.&(%!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!50*(%8!&$*9(%.1!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!23!&#$!J$*.&(%2/,&$D!?%..D!ZYo[UZYanVAZ[ppFnjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lqZrrjZnD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jYrD!! W$#*$1!<M!g2#1!@M!:2&#%.8$1!NPM!$&!.1D!65$%&(3(/.&(2%!23!.!9.G2*!J$*.&(%2/,&$!/$11!$%)$12>$!>*2&$(%M!12*(/*(%D!?%..D!ZYY[UqZaqVAZZ[pFZjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5ljZY[qYZD!P//$++$5!

P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

jYqD!! 4/#90&#!WM!-10#*!NLM!;*09*(%$!@;M!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*.1!.%5!30%/&(2%.1!/2%+$?0$%/$+!23!12*(/*(%!90&.&(2%+!(%!#09.%!12*(/*(%!J$*.&25$*9.!aI2#K(%J$1!+,%5*29$!K(&#!(/#&#,2+(+VD!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[[nUZjjanVAY[YF

jjD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGD[[jjFj[jODj[[nDjjnpZDdD!

jYmD!! i(9!7HM!g2K$11!W@M!"0&&9.%F�.++J,!HM!$&!.1D!<e-Fv!52K%*$801.&$+!3(1.88*(%!.%5!12*(/*(%!&#*208#!/FN0%!eF&$*9(%.1!J(%.+$A!*21$!32*!<e-Fv!.%&.82%(+&+!&2!(9>*2)$!+J(%!=.**($*D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZZUZpZaqVAZjmjF

YD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDjnD!

jYoD!! E(>>$%+!4M!@$%$/J$*!"M!Q).$*$!CM!I.%5$%.=$$1$!CM!@$/1$*/?!LD!@$.&#!>$%.1&,!32*!J$*.&(%2/,&$+A!.>2>&2+(+!

)$*+0+!/2*%(3(/.&(2%D!?%..&3%/);&3*--%5D!j[[rUZj!40>>1!jAZnYmFr[oD!52(AZ[DZ[pol+GD/55Dnn[ZmjjD!

jYYD!! 6+#(5.F�.9.92&2!PM!6(R0J.!gD!@(33$*$%/$+!(%!(%)210/*(%!(990%21.=$1(%8!K(&#(%!/2*%(3($5!/$11!$%)$12>$+!(%!%2*9.1!.%5!>+2*(.&(/!$>(5$*9(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!ZYYrUZ[napVApYZFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lmoqZ[[oD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

p[[D!! <#$K$+!WM!4&.51$*!:M!i2*8$!7M!W(+/#J$!@D!e2*9.1!>+2*(.&(/!$>(5$*9(+!$d>*$++(2%!23!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%F.++2/(.&$5!J$*.&(%+D!U5+;&3%50/)".&>%$D!ZYYZUjopamVAnqrFmZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZmjnoYmD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

p[ZD!! C299$*$%/J$!<M!4&$(%=$*8!<M!@(/J#.0+!gM!<29.J(5(!CM!"*.=$!eD!e0/1$.*!+&.(%(%8!.%5!*$1.&()$!5(+&.%/$!32*!?0.%&(3,(%8!$>(5$*9.1!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!(%!=(29.*J$*!$d>*$++(2%!>*23(1(%8D!6!?&6*"*(-"50/)*+$D!

j[[oUYaZVAnmpD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmZFjZ[rFYFnmpD!

Page 99: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 86 of 237

p[jD!! W(/#(=.&.!gM!;#(=.!gM!L.J(92&2!iM!$&!.1D!65$%&(3(/.&(2%!.%5!/#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!.!%2)$1!/29>2%$%&!23!&#$!/2*%(3($5!$%)$12>$M!/2*%(3$1(%D!6*"+;%0&6*"4;9$&>%$&?"00#(D!j[[nUpZoanVAo[pFZpD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD==*/Dj[[nD[nDZ[YD!

p[pD!! e$+&1$!-QM!i.>1.%!@gM!7.*J$*!ND!C+2*(.+(+D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!j[[YUpqZarVAnYqFr[YD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW*.[o[nrYrD!

p[nD!! PR3.*!:4M!4$9(%.*.!eWM!4#(%!@7M!<*2d$1!P7M!W.*821(+!@NM!"$13.%5!NWD!6%/*$.+$5!*(+J!23!5(.=$&$+!9$11(&0+!.%5!1(J$1(#225!23!*$/$()(%8!5(.=$&$+!9$11(&0+!&*$.&9$%&!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+D!U5+;&3%50/)".D!

j[ZjUZnoaYVAYYrFZ[[[D!52(AZ[DZ[[Zl.*/#5$*9.&21Dj[ZjDZn[ZD!

p[rD!! "#2+#!7M!:$55,!EgM!i01J.*%(!:!IM!i#.%.9!ND!;29>.*(+2%!23!+J(%!>$*9$.=(1(&,!23!5*08+!(%!9(/$!.%5!#09.%!/.5.)$*!+J(%D!,(7*/(&c&T_4&6*".D!j[[[UpoaZVAnjFrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZjpp[opD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

p[qD!! L.8%$*!H-M!4/#2%&#.1$*!g7M!"0(%$.FI(%($8*.!NM!<+/#./#1$*!HD!C+2*(.+(+A!K#.&!K$!#.)$!1$.*%$5!3*29!

920+$!925$1+D!V/)&>%=&>;%#0/)".D!j[Z[UqaZjVAm[nFZnD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%**#$09Dj[Z[DZrmD!

p[mD!! :.,/#.05#0*(!4CM!@0&&!4M!:.,/#.05#0*(!4iM!4.%,.1!WM!-.*=$*!HWD!4$)$*$!/29=(%$5!(990%25$3(/($%/,!920+$F#09.%!+J(%!/#(9$*.+A!.!0%(?0$!.%(9.1!925$1!32*!&#$!+&05,!23!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!/0&.%$20+!(%31.99.&(2%D!65&c&3%50/)".D!j[[ZUZnnarVAYpZFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZprYpmmD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

p[oD!! "05G2%++2%!NHM!N2#%+&2%!PM!@,+2%!WM!I.15(9.*++2%!gM!H15$*!N<D!W20+$!925$1+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!j[[mUZjmaqVAZjYjFp[oD!52(AZ[DZ[pol+GDG(5Drm[[o[mD!

p[YD!! ;#.%!N:M!7109$%+/#$(%!LM!W0*>#,!HM!$&!.1D!6EFjp!+&(901.&$+!$>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.!)(.!<e-!.%5!6EFj[:jF5$>$%5$%&!9$/#.%(+9+!K(&#!(9>1(/.&(2%+!32*!>+2*(.+(+!>.&#28$%$+(+D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[qUj[paZjVAjrmmFomD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[q[jnnD!

pZ[D!! "0>&.!PiM!-(+#$*!"NM!H15$*!N<M!$&!.1D!<2>(/.1!;,/12+>2*(%$!P!6%#(=(&+!&#$!C#2*=21!H+&$*!6%50/$5!g,>$*>1.+&(/!6%31.99.&2*,!:$+>2%+$!=0&!%2&!C*2&$(%!i(%.+$!;!P/&().&(2%!(%!W20+$!H>(5$*9(+D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!ZYoYUYpapVApmYFpoqD!52(AZ[DZZZZlZrjpFZmnmD$>Zjjo[jmYD!

pZZD!! L.1&$*!PM!4/#�3$*!WM!;$//2%(!IM!$&!.1D!P15.*.!./&().&$+!<E:mF(%5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!5$3$%/$D!V/)&?"00#(D!

j[ZpUnAZrq[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/299+jrqqD!!

! (

Page 100: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 87 of 237

[(748%(45(9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-('<(:=4*'#='=(

!<('<58#&&#24*)(2*'#<Q8%('<(:=4*'#='=D(9>?N(2):%(;(

;?>=(#<$(;C/-\(!E,%5.!"*(%$ZMjM!E($%!@$G.8$*ZMjM!;1.05$!E(=$*&ZMj!.%5!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$ZMj�!!Z,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6:&';%():&6%.8*#0&D3%4/5)0%()&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&';%():&6%.8*#0&

!!�;2**$+>2%5(%8!.0&#2*A!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$M!>""$0/5*K(O@/(7%(L5"#+B%i*5+O=*LF<'%()OL%!

;2%31(/&!23!6%&$*$+&A!<#$!.0&#2*+!5$/1.*$!&#.&!%2!/2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&!$d(+&+D!

!/(#$+5*4)&/++%4)%7&-"5&4#L.*+/)*"(&*(!?9)"B*(%&j&'5"J);&W/+)"5$&>%=*%J$O&&

F4<2*'G32'4<=!E,%5.!"*(%$!K*2&$!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&!.%5!5$+(8%$5!8*.>#(/+U!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$!5*$K!&#$!8*.>#(/+!0+(%8!4$*)($*!W$5(/.1!P*&D!

! !

Page 101: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 88 of 237

!"#$"%&'((')*+,#)+$'"-&.#$"#/0*+$'0$01#

!"#$%&'()%*%*#"+%,-.%*/F!"#!

!G=2*#"2(

C+2*(.+(+! (+! .! +J(%! 5(+$.+$! K#$*$! ).*(20+! /,&2J(%$+! >1.,! .! 5$&*(9$%&.1! *21$M! ,$&! 20*!

0%5$*+&.%5(%8!23! &#$!5(+$.+$! (+! +&(11! 1(9(&$5D!<e-! (+! .! ).1(5.&$5!5*08! &.*8$&! (%!>+2*(.+(+! .%5!

2&#$*!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!=0&!(&+!0+$!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!+(5$!$33$/&+D!429$!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!

$33$/&+! 23! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&! .*$! +0>>2+$51,! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! K#(/#! .*$! .1+2!

(9>1(/.&$5!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!:$/$%&1,M!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!#.+!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!

K(&#! >+2*(.+(+! .+! K$11M! .%5! %$K! 5*08+! &.*8$&(%8! &#(+! .d(+! #.)$! .1*$.5,! =$$%! 5$)$12>$5D!

-(%5(%8+!+088$+&!&#.&!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!(%&$*K2)$%D!L$!5(+/0++!*$/$%&!3(%5(%8+!*$(%32*/(%8!

&#$! *21$! 23! <e-M! <,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 6EFZm! (%! &#$! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23! >+2*(.+(+! .%5! &#$! .>>.*$%&!

(%31.99.&2*,!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!&#$+$!&#*$$!/,&2J(%$+D!

! !

Page 102: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 89 of 237

;<2*4$3"2'4<(

C+2*(.+(+! (+! .! /#*2%(/! (%31.99.&2*,! 5(+$.+$! .33$/&(%8! j!p\! 23! &#$!K2*15! >2>01.&(2%! .%5! (+!

/2%+(5$*$5! .%! (990%$F9$5(.&$5! (%31.99.&2*,! 5(+$.+$! a6W6@+VD! <#$! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! .*$!

/#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! $*,&#$9.M! $>(5$*9.1! #,>$*>1.+(.! .%5! +/.1(%8D!g(+&2128(/.1! .%.1,+(+! *$)$.1+!

(%31.99.&2*,!(%3(1&*.&$+!.%5!/.>(11.*,!.%8(28$%$+(+D!C+2*(.+(+!#.+!=$$%!$d&$%+()$1,!+&05($5!(%!

&#$!>.+&M!,$&!&#$!9$/#.%(+9!0%5$*1,(%8!&#$!5(+$.+$!*$9.(%+!1.*8$1,!0%J%2K%D!"$%$&(/!+&05($+!

#.)$!*$)$.1$5!+$)$*.1! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! 12/(!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+M!=0&! &#$!>.&#2128,!*$+01&+!

3*29!.%!(%&(9.&$!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!$%)(*2%9$%&.1!3./&2*+!.%5!&#$!(990%$!/$11+!23!8$%$&(/.11,!

+0+/$>&(=1$!(%5()(50.1+D!!

<#$*$! (+! %2! /0*$! 32*! >+2*(.+(+M! =0&! +$)$*.1! &*$.&9$%&+! #.)$! =$$%! 5$)$12>$5D! <*$.&9$%&+!

5$>$%5!2%!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!&#$!5(+$.+$!.+!.++$++$5!=,!&#$!C+2*(.+(+!P*$.!4$)$*(&,!6%5$d!aCP46V!

+/2*$DZ! ;1(%(/(.%+! 0+0.11,! +&.*&! K(&#! .! 9(15! &*$.&9$%&M! +0/#! .+! &2>(/.1! /*$.9+! /2%&.(%(%8!

/2*&(+2%$+! 2*! 0+$!>#2&2&#$*.>,M! $d>2+(%8! &#$! +J(%! &2! /$*&.(%! &,>$+! 23! 01&*.)(21$&! a'IV! 1(8#&D!

<#$+$! &#$*.>($+!/.%!=$!/29=(%$5!&2! (%/*$.+$!$33$/&()$%$++D!g2K$)$*M!+29$!>.&($%&+!*$?0(*$!

92*$!5*.+&(/! (%&$*)$%&(2%+M! (%/105(%8!5*08+! .59(%(+&$*$5!$(&#$*!2*.11,! 2*! &#*208#! (%G$/&(2%D!

e2%F=(2128(/.1! 5*08+! (%/105$!9$&#2&*$d.&$M! /,/12+>2*(%! .%5! ./(&*$&(%D! 7(2128(/.1! 5*08+! #.)$!

=$$%! 5$)$12>$5! 2)$*! &#$! >.+&! 5$/.5$! .%5! .>>*2)$5! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! 23! ).*(20+! 5(+$.+$+M!

+0/#!.+!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+M!.%J,12+(%8!+>2%5,1(&(+!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!<#$!92+&!

>*$+/*(=$5! 23! &#$+$! 5*08+! .*$! <092*!e$/*2+(+! -./&2*! a<e-VF.%&.82%(+&+D! <#$!92+&! >2>01.*!

<e-F.%&.82%(+&+! .*$! $&.%$*/$>&M! (%31(d(9.=! .%5! .5.1(909.=M! .%5! &K2! %$K! .%&(F<e-! 5*08+!

#.)$!=$$%!.55$5! &2! &#$! 1(+&A! /$*&21(R09.=!.%5!821(909.=D!P11! &#$+$! .%&(F<e-!5*08+!=$#.)$!

5(33$*$%&1,! (%!>.&($%&+!.%5! (%!5(33$*$%&!5(+$.+$+M!9.J(%8! &#$!/#2(/$!23!<e-F.%&.82%(+&!*.&#$*!

/29>1$dD! 63! >.&($%&+! 52! %2&! *$./&! K$11! &2! 2%$! <e-F.%&.82%(+&M! /1(%(/(.%+! 23&$%! >*$+/*(=$!

.%2&#$*!.!5(33$*$%&!2%$M!.1&#208#!&#$*$!.*$!%2!+>$/(3(/!80(5$1(%$+!32*!&#(+D!!

<#$!K(5$+>*$.5!0+$!23!<e-F.%&.82%(+&+!#.+!).1(5.&$5!<e-!.+!.!5*08!&.*8$&M!=0&!&#$(*!+0//$++!

#.+!(&+!1(9(&.&(2%+D!P+!<e-!.1+2!#.+!(990%2*$801.&2*,!30%/&(2%+M! 12%8F&$*9!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!

Page 103: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 90 of 237

<e-! /.%! =$! 5.%8$*20+D! C.&($%&+! /.%! =$/29$! 92*$! +0+/$>&(=1$! &2! =./&$*(.1! .%5! 30%8.1!

(%3$/&(2%+!2*!=$!.&! *(+J!23! *$./&().&(2%!23! 1.&$%&! &0=$*/012+(+! (%3$/&(2%D!Q&#$*!.5)$*+$!$)$%&+!

(%/105$!(%G$/&(2%!+(&$!*$./&(2%+M!(%30+(2%!*$./&(2%+M!%$0&*2>$%(.M!5$9,$1(%.&(%8!5(+$.+$M!#$.*&!

3.(10*$M!/0&.%$20+!*$./&(2%+M!.%5!9.1(8%.%/,Djwr!C.*.52d(/.11,M!&#$!0+$!23!.%&(F<e-!5*08+!#.+!

.1+2! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5!K(&#! 7%&("="! (%50/&(2%! 23! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! +0/#! .+! >+2*(.+(32*9!

1$+(2%+!.%5!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+DqwY!<#$!92+&!/2992%1,!2=+$*)$5!+(5$!$33$/&!(+!&#$!(%50/&(2%!

23! /0&.%$20+! >+2*(.+(32*9! 1$+(2%+! (%! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! K(&#! <e-F.%&.82%(+&+! 32*! ;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$! 2*! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+D! 4&05($+! +088$+&! &#(+! $33$/&! (+! 50$! &2! .%! (9=.1.%/$! =$&K$$%!

<e-!.%5!.%2&#$*!/,&2J(%$A!&#$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!a&,>$!6!6-e+VD!<,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!9.(%1,!J%2K%!

32*! &#$(*! .%&()(*.1! ./&()(&,M! =0&! $1.=2*.&$! +&05($+! #.)$! +#2K%! &#$(*! >2&$%/,! .+!

(990%2*$801.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!.+!K$11D!<#$!*21$!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+! (+!%2&!

$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225M!=0&!+$)$*.1!2=+$*).&(2%+!+088$+&!&#.&!&#$,!.*$!(%)21)$5!K(&#!<e-!(%!&#$!

5$)$12>9$%&!23!.0&2(990%(&,D!!

<2!2)$*/29$!&#$!>(&3.11+!23!<e-F.%&.82%(+&+M!%$K!=(2128(/.1!.8$%&+!#.)$!=$$%!5$)$12>$5M!+0/#!

.+! .%&(=25($+! .8.(%+&! 6%&$*1$0J(%! a6EVFZm! .%5! 6EFZj>n[M! =2&#! 23!K#(/#! #.)$! =$$%! +#2K%! &2!

>1.,!(%&*(/.&$!*21$+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+DZ[wZn!'+&$J(%09.=M!.%!.%&(=25,!.8.(%+&!6EFZj>n[!

(+!.1*$.5,!2%!&#$!9.*J$&!.%5!.%&(=25($+!&.*8$&(%8!&#$!6EFZm!.d(+!.*$!.1*$.5,!(%!/1(%(/.1!&*(.1+M!

&#208#!&#$(*!12%8F&$*9!0+$!(+!,$&!&2!=$!$).10.&$5D!

C+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!/#*2%(/!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!+$$9!&2!*$+01&!3*29!.%!2)$*./&()$!(990%$!

+,+&$9M! K(&#! <e-M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! &#$! 6EFjpl6EFZm! .d(+! >1.,(%8! (%&$*K2)$%! *21$+D! 6%! &#(+!

*$)($KM! K$! 5(+/0++! &#$! (%&(9.&$! (%&$*>1.,! =$&K$$%! &#$+$! /,&2J(%$+! (%! >+2*(.+(+! .%5! &#$!

(%+(8#&+!&#.&!9.,!=$!23!>2&$%&(.1!).10$!32*!30&0*$!&*$.&9$%&+!32*!>+2*(.+(+D!

748%(45(9>?('<(:=4*'#='=(

<e-!(+!.!#292&*(9$*(/!/,&2J(%$!&#.&!(+!9.(%1,!>*250/$5!=,!(990%$!.%5!$>(&#$1(.1!/$11+D!<e-!

/.%! =$! 9$9=*.%$F=20%5! .%5! 9$5(.&$! /$11!/$11! +(8%.1(%8M! =0&! (&! /.%! .1+2! =$! /1$.)$5! =,!

Page 104: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 91 of 237

<P;HlP@PWZm!.%5!./&!.+!.!+210=1$!32*9D!<e-!$d$*&+!(&+!30%/&(2%+!=,!=(%5(%8!&2!&K2!5(33$*$%&!

*$/$>&2*+A!<e-:Zl>rr!.%5!<e-:jl>mrD!<#$!1.&&$*!$d#(=(&+!.!1(9(&$5!$d>*$++(2%!.%5!(+!320%5!

2%!/$11+!23!&#$! (990%$!+,+&$9!+0/#!.+!;@n!.%5!;@o!<!/$11+M!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+!.%5!%$0*2%.1+!

/$11+M! (%/105(%8! %$0*2%! +0=&,>$+D! <e-:Z! (+! $d>*$++$5! 0=(?0(&20+1,! .%5! /2%+&(&0&()$1,D! <e-!

52$+!%2&!2%1,!(%50/$!(%31.99.&(2%!=,!./&().&(%8!).+/01.*!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+!.%5!(990%$!/$11+M!

=0&!.1+2!./&+!.+!.%!(9>2*&.%&!*$801.&2*!23!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!1,9>#2(5!&(++0$!=,!/2%&*211(%8!

.>2>&2+(+D! W(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! <e-! 52! %2&! 5$)$12>! 8$*9(%.1! /$%&$*+M! +(9(1.*1,! &2! <e-:ZF

5$3(/($%&!9(/$DZrMZq! 6%/*$.+$5! 1$)$1+!23!<e-!.*$! 320%5!.&! &#$! +(&$+!23! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! +$)$*.1!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! .%5! 0>2%! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%M! (%31.99.&2*,! +,9>&29+! .*$! 8$%$*.11,!

*$50/$5D! <#(+! 1$5! &2! &#$! *.&(2%.1$! 23! =12/J(%8! <e-! (%! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29! .0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+!&#.&!.*$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!$d/$++()$!.920%&+!23!<e-D!g(8#$*!1$)$1+!23!<e-M!<e-:Z!.%5!

<e-:j! .*$! 2=+$*)$5! (%! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+DZmwj[! i$*.&(%2/,&$+! $d>*$++! <e-:Z! .%5! .*$! &#0+!

*$+>2%+()$! &2! <e-D! 4&(901.&(2%! K(&#! <e-! (%50/$+! %2&! 2%1,! (990%$! .%5! (%31.99.&2*,!

*$+>2%+$+!2*/#$+&*.&$5!=,!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!=0&!.1+2!&(++0$!*$925$1(%8M!/$11!92&(1(&,M!/$11!/,/1(%8M!

.%5! .>2>&2+(+DjZ! P55(&(2%.11,M! ./&().&$5! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! .1+2! >*250/$! 9.%,! /#$92J(%$+!

*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!*$/*0(&9$%&!23!%$0&*2>#(1+M!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!+J(%F+>$/(3(/!9$92*,!<!/$11+DjZ!

<e-! (+! >*250/$5! =,! .! ).*($&,! 23! /$11+! (%)21)$5! (%! &#$! >.&#2>#,+(2128,! 23! >+2*(.+(+M! +0/#! .+!

J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!a@;+VM!.%5!ei<M!<#ZM!<#Zm!.%5!<#jj!/$11+D!<#(+!(9>1($+!&#.&!<e-!

9(8#&! =$! (%)21)$5! (%! =2&#! &#$! (%(&(.1! >#.+$! .%5! &#$! /#*2%(/! >#.+$! 23! >+2*(.+(+D! <#$*$32*$M!

%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!/.%!.33$/&!+$)$*.1!+&.8$+!23!&#$!5(+$.+$!=,!(%&$*3$*(%8!K(&#!&#$!./&().&(2%!

23! 5(33$*$%&! /$11! +0=&,>$+D! P1&#208#! <e-F.%&.82%(+&+! .*$! $d&$%+()$1,! >*$+/*(=$5! &2! >.&($%&+M!

&#$!$d./&!9$/#.%(+9!0%5$*1,(%8!>+2*(.+(+!(+!%2&!/29>1$&$1,!0%5$*+&225!.%5!&#$!>*$/(+$!*21$!

23!<e-!(+!,$&!&2!=$!$10/(5.&$5D!!

Q%$!>1.0+(=1$!9$/#.%(+9!(+!$d.88$*.&$5!<e-!+(8%.1(%8M!>2++(=1,!50$!&2!8$%$&(/!>21,92*>#(+9!

(%! >*$5(+>2+$5! (%5()(50.1+D! P! *$/$%&!9$&.F.%.1,+(+! =,! �#0.%8! $&! .1D! *$)$.1$5! .! +(8%(3(/.%&1,!

5$/*$.+$5!*(+J!23!>+2*(.+(+!32*!&#$!<e-!p[o"lP!>21,92*>#(+9!.%5!.%!(%/*$.+$5!*(+J!32*!<e-!

Page 105: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 92 of 237

jpo"lPDjj!<#$+$!+(%81$!%0/1$2&(5$!>21,92*>#(+9+!a4eC+V!/.%!(%310$%/$!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!.%5!

*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!2&#$*!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!8$%$+M!+0/#!.+!4<P<nM!6EFZ[!.%5!)(&.9(%!*$/$>&2*!@D!

g2K$)$*M! &#.&! +&05,! #.+! +29$! 1(9(&.&(2%+M! +0/#! .+! *$1.&()$1,! +9.11! +.9>1$! +(R$! .%5! 1./J! 23!

.5G0+&$5!$+&(9.&$+D!-0*&#$*!*$+$.*/#!+#2015! (%)$+&(8.&$!8$%$!8$%$! (%&$*./&(2%+D! 6%!.55(&(2%M!

$)(5$%/$! .1+2! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! <e-P6CplPj[! .33$/&+! &#$! *$+>2%+$! &2! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&D! Pj[!

/.%!1(9(&!e-Ft7F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&(2%D!P!>2+(&()$!*$+>2%+$!&2!$&.%$*/$>&!K.+!320%5!92+&1,!

(%!>2>01.&(2%+!/.**,(%8!&K2!/2>($+!23!&#$!.11$1$!K(&#!&#$!"!.11$1$!23!4eC!*+qZ[q[n!12/.&$5!(%!

&#$!AVWU,\X!8$%$Djp!<#(+! (%32*9.&(2%!/2015!#$1>!/1(%(/(.%+! &2!9.J$!.%! (%32*9$5!5$/(+(2%!&2!

+$1$/&!&#$!.>>*2>*(.&$!<e-!.%&.82%(+&!&#$*.>,D!

<#$!>.+&!,$.*+M!%$K!+$&+!23! /,&2J(%$+!#.)$!=$$%!.55$5! &2! &#$!>.&#2>#,+(2128,!23!>+2*(.+(+M!

$d>.%5(%8!20*!)($K!23! .%!.1*$.5,! /29>1$d!5(+$.+$D!e$K!>1.,$*+! +0/#!.+! 6EFZYM! 6EFj[M! 6EFjj!

.%5! 6EFjn! #.)$! .1+2! =$$%! (9>1(/.&$5! (%! >+2*(.+(+Djnwjq! 6&! #.+! .1+2! =$$%! >2+&01.&$5! &#.&! <e-!

9(8#&!=$!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+D!-2*!$d.9>1$M!&#$!8*20>!23!g..+$!0+$5!.!

90*(%$! +>2%&.%$20+!>+2*(.+(+!925$1! &2!0%*.)$1! &#$! *21$!23!<e-! (%! &#$! (%50/&(2%!23! 6EFjnDjm!

<*.%+8$%(/! $d>*$++(2%! 23! &#(+! /,&2J(%$! K.+! +033(/($%&! &2! (%50/$! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%M! .%5!

0>*$801.&$5! 1$)$1+! 23! 6EFjn! K$*$! 320%5! (%! >+2*(.&(/! $>(5$*9(+DjoMjY! '+(%8! iZnF;*$! 6iij31l31!

5$3(/($%&!9(/$M!g$!.%5!E(.%8!320%5!&#.&!$.*1,!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFjn!5$>$%5+!2%!<e-D!<#$!.0&#2*+!

+088$+&$5!&#.&!6EFjn!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!&#$!(%(&(.&(2%!>#.+$!23!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!&#.&!&#(+!$.*1,!$)$%&!

5$>$%5+!2%!<e-l<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8Djm!<#$!9$/#.%(+9!0%5$*1,(%8!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+!

(+!+&(11!0%5$*!+&05,D!<#$!5(+$.+$!>(/&0*$!(+!=$/29(%8!(%/*$.+(%81,!/29>1$dM!=0&!(&!(+!/1$.*!&#.&!

<e-!(+!(%)21)$5!(%!9.%,!>*2/$++$+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!!

748%(45(2):%(;(;?>=('<(:=4*'#='=(

<,>$! 6! (%&$*3$*2%+! .*$!K$11! J%2K%! 32*! &#$(*! .%&()(*.1! $33$/&+M!K#(/#!K$*$! 3(*+&! 5$+/*(=$5! (%!

ZYrm!=,!6+../+!.%5!E(%5$9.%%!.+!.!3./&2*!(%&$*3$*(%8!K(&#!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+Dp[!<#$,!.*$!>.*&!23!

&#$!+0>$*3.9(1,!23!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!/2%+(+&!23!&,>$!6M!66!.%5!666!(%&$*3$*2%+D!6%!#09.%+!&#$*$!.*$!

Page 106: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 93 of 237

Zp!8$%$+!32*!6-e.1>#.!a6-evV!.%5!+(%81$!8$%$+!32*!6-e=$&.!a6-euVM!6-e$>+(12%M!6-eJ.>>.!.%5!

6-e29$8.D!<#$,!+(8%.1! &#*208#!.!#$&$*25(9$*(/!/29>1$d!/29>2+$5!23! 6-eP:Z!.%5! 6-eP:jD!

Q)$*!&#$!1.+&!5$/.5$+M!(%/*$.+(%8!(%+(8#&!(%&2!&#$(*!.%&()(*.1!9$/#.%(+9+!#.)$!1$5!&2!&#$!0+$!23!

&,>$!6!6-e!.+!.!&#$*.>,!32*!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+!+0/#!.+!g$>.&(&(+!7!.%5!;DpZMpj!P1&#208#!&#$!.%&()(*.1!

./&()(&($+!23! (%&$*3$*2%+! 32*9!.%! (%&$*$+&(%8! &2>(/M! &#(+! *$)($K!K(11!%2&! 32/0+!2%! &#(+!./&()(&,D!

<,>$!6!6-e+!#.)$!.1+2!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!&#$!*$+>2%+$!&2!=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!(%31.99.+29$!

./&().&(2%M!(%&$+&(%.1!#29$2+&.+(+M!/.%/$*!.%5!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!

.+! /2$1(./!5(+$.+$M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!901&(>1$! +/1$*2+(+D!<,>$! 6! 6-e+!.*$! &#208#&! &2!>1.,!.!

9.G2*!*21$! (%! &#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+!.+!K$11D!C.&($%&+! &*$.&$5!K(&#! 6-eu!.%5!6-ev!32*!

901&(>1$! +/1$*2+(+! 2*! #$>.&(&(+! ;M! *$+>$/&()$1,M! #.)$! *$>2*&$5! 7%& ("="! (%50/&(2%! 2*!

$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>*$F$d(+&(%8!>+2*(.+(+Dpp!P3+#.*!$&!.1D!+&05($5!.11!>0=1(+#$5!/.+$+!23!#$>.&(&(+!;!

>.&($%&+! K#2! 5$)$12>$5! >+2*(.+(+! 50*(%8! 6-ev! &*$.&9$%&D! <#$,! *$>2*&$5! 2%! pq! /.+$+! K#2!

+033$*$5! 3*29! 7%& ("="! 5$)$12>9$%&! 2*! .88*.).&(2%! 23! >*$F$d(+&(%8! >+2*(.+(+Dpn! '>2%!

5(+/2%&(%0.&(2%! 23! 6-ev! &#$*.>,M! Yp\! 23! &#$! >.&($%&+! *$>2*&$5! *$+210&(2%! 23! &#$! /0&.%$20+!

5(+$.+$D!W2*$2)$*M!e$+&1$!$&!.1D!+#2K$5!&#.&!6-ev!5*()$+!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!3011F=12K%!<F/$11!

5$>$%5$%&! >+2*(.+(+D! <#$,! 0+$5! .!920+$! d$%28*.3&!925$1! (%!K#(/#! >1.+9./,&2(5! 5$%5*(&(/!

/$11+! a>@;+V! (%3(1&*.&$! &#$!+J(%!)$*,!$.*1,!.%5M!2%/$!./&().&$5M!>*250/$! (99$%+$!.920%&+!23!

6-evDpr! 712/J(%8! 6-ev! ./&()(&,! K(&#! .%! .%&(=25,! 5(*$/&$5! .8.(%+&! 6-eP:j! >*$)$%&$5! &#$!

5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+D!6%!.55(&(2%M!8$%$&(/!+&05($+!*$)$.1$5!&K2!8$%$+!23!*(+J!32*!>+2*(.+(+!

&#.&!.*$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+A!>VWZZY!.%5!33bHRk&&#$!1.&&$*!.1+2!J%2K%!.+&>,'F,D!72&#!

.*$! (%)21)$5! (%! +$%+(%8! )(*0+$+! .%5! &#$! +0=+$?0$%&! (%50/&(2%!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+DpqMpm!P55(&(2%.1!

+&05($+! 2%! &#$! *21$! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! &#$! >.&#2>#,+(2128,! 23! >+2*(.+(+! 320%5! .55(&(2%.1!

$)(5$%/$D!6-e!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*Fj!a6:-jV!(+!.!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!(%#(=(&2*!23!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8D!

W(/$!1./J(%8!&#(+!8$%$!#.)$!#(8#$*!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!23!&,>$!6!6-eF(%50/(=1$!8$%$+!.%5!5$)$12>!

.%!(%31.99.&2*,!+J(%!>#$%2&,>$!&#.&!+&*2%81,!*$+$9=1$+!>+2*(.+(+M!+088$+&(%8!&#.&!$d/$++()$!

&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!(+!+033(/($%&!&2!(%50/$!.!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!>#$%2&,>$Dpo!!

Page 107: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 94 of 237

g2K$)$*M!*$+01&+!3*29!=.+(/!+/($%/$!+&05($+!2%!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!/2%&*.5(/&2*,D!4(%/$!

I.%!5$*!-(&+!5$+/*(=$5!P15.*.!.+!.!).1(5! (%50/(=1$!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1! 32*!>+2*(.+(+! (%!9(/$M!

9.%,!*$+$.*/#!8*20>+!#.)$!0+$5!&#(+!925$1!&2!(%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!921$/01.*!=.+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+DpY!

P15.*.!/2%&.(%+!r\!23!(9(?0(925!a6WsVM!K#(/#!(+!.!<E:m!.82%(+&!&#.&!./&().&$+!>@;+!.%5!&#0+!

./&+! .+! .! >2&$%&! (%50/$*! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D!@.(1,! .>>1(/.&(2%! 23! P15.*.! (+! +033(/($%&! &2! (%50/$! .!

>+2*(.+(+F1(J$! >#$%2&,>$! (%! 9(/$D! P15.*.! /*$.9! (+! 0+$5! .8.(%+&! =.+.1! /$11! /.*/(%29.+! .%5!

8$%(&.1!K.*&+!.%5!/.%! (%5$$5! (%50/$!>+2*(.+(+! (%!>.&($%&+!.+!.! +(5$!$33$/&D!<#$!*21$!23! &,>$! 6!

6-e+! (%! P15.*.F(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! #.+! .1+2! =$$%! +&05($5! (%! 6-eP:ZF

5$3(/($%&!9(/$!0+(%8!&#$!P15.*.!925$1D!<K2!+&05($+!+088$+&!&#.&!P15.*.F(%50/$5!+J(%!1$+(2%+!

.*$!(%5$>$%5$%&!3*29!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8Dn[MnZ!W(/$!1./J(%8!6-eP:Z!K$*$!%2&!>*2&$/&$5!3*29!

P15.*.F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%! (%31.99.&(2%M!.1&#208#!&#$,!>*250/$5! 1$++! 6-evM! 6EFq!.%5!

6EFjj!K#(1$! 6EFZmP! 1$)$1+!K$*$!%2&!.33$/&$5D!Q%!&#$!/2%&*.*,M!20*!5.&.!*$)$.1$5!.!>*2&$/&()$!

>#$%2&,>$!(%!6-eP:Z!J%2/J20&!9(/$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!P15.*.M!K(&#!*$50/&(2%!23!6EFZj>n[!.%5!

6EFZm-!+$*09!1$)$1+!a0%>0=1(+#$5!*$+01&+VD!6%!.55(&(2%M!(&!#.+!=$$%!+#2K%!&#.&!6-ev!/.%!./&!(%!

+,%$*8,!K(&#!(9(?0(925!&2!9$5(.&$!(%31.99.&(2%D!P15.*.!.12%$!(+!.!K$.J!(%50/$*!23!6EFjpM!6EF

qM! .%5! <e-M! =0&! 0>2%! +(901&.%$20+! +&(901.&(2%! K(&#! 6-evM! (%50/&(2%! (+! 3.*! +&*2%8$*Dnj! 6%!

.55(&(2%M!&#$!.0&#2*+!+#2K$5!&#.&!6-ev!(%/*$.+$+!<E:m!1$)$1+M!+$%+(&(R(%8!&#$!$%)(*2%9$%&!&2!

<E:m!.82%(+&+!+0/#!.+! (9(?0(925D!<#$,!$d>1.(%$5!&#$!5(+/*$>.%/,!.=20&!&#$!*21$!23!6-ev!(%!

>+2*(.+(+!=,!>2(%&(%8!20&!&#.&!P15.*.!/2%&.(%+!).*(20+!/29>2%$%&+!&#.&!/.%!./&!(%5$>$%5$%&1,!

3*29! <E:m! .%5! 6-eP:ZD! <#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! +0>>2*&! .! *21$! 32*! &,>$! 6! 6-e! +(8%.1(%8! (%! &#(+!

/#*2%(/! +J(%!5(+$.+$M! 1$.5(%8! &2! &#$!/2%/$>&!23!=12/J(%8! &#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!.+!K$11D! 6%5$$5M! &#$!

/29>.%,!W$56990%$!/2%50/&$5!.!>#.+$!6!&*(.1!2%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+!&2!(%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!

$33$/&+! 23! WH@6FrnrM! .%! .%&(F6-ev! 92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25,Dnp! 6%! &#(+! &*(.1M! &#$,! $).10.&$5! &#$!

+.3$&,!>*23(1$!23!&#$!.%&(=25,M!.%5!(&+!$33$/&!2%!&#$!=(2128(/.1!./&()(&,!23!6-ev!(%!+J(%!=(2>+($+!

.%5!2%!5(+$.+$!./&()(&,D!P1&#208#!&#$!5*08!K.+!320%5!&2!=$!K$11!&21$*.&$5!.%5!+.3$M!WH@6Frnr!

5(5!%2&!.>>$.*!&2!.33$/&!&#$!$+&.=1(+#$5!>+2*(.+(+!>1.?0$+!(%!&#$!+0=G$/&+D!<#$!+.9$!.%&(=25,!

Page 108: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 95 of 237

#.5!.1*$.5,!+#2K%!/1(%(/.1!=$%$3(&!(%!.!&*(.1!32*!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!a4EHVM!.%2&#$*!

5(+$.+$! /#.*./&$*(R$5!=,! (%/*$.+$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e!./&()(&,D!<#$! .0&#2*+! *01$5!20&! &#.&! 2=+$*)$5!

5(33$*$%/$! =$&K$$%! &#$! &*(.1+! K$*$! 50$! &2! .%&(=25,! 52+$! 5(33$*$%/$+D! g2K$)$*M! &#$! +&05,!

32/0+$5!2%1,!2%!6-ev!&#208#!6-eu!(+!0>*$801.&$5!(%!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+!.+!K$11M!.%5!=2&#!1(8.%5+!

+(8%.1! &#*208#!&#$!6-eP:Zl6-eP:j!/29>1$dD!W2*$2)$*M! &#$,!2%1,!+&05($5!&#$!$33$/&!23! 6-ev!

(%#(=(&(2%!(%!$+&.=1(+#$5!>+2*(.&(/!>1.?0$+M!K#$*$.+!5.&.!+088$+&+!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!9.(%1,!#.)$!

.!*21$! (%! (%(&(.&(%8!>+2*(.+(+D!<#$,!/2015!2%1,!/2%/105$!&#.&!=12/J(%8!6-ev!K(&#!WH@6Frnr! (+!

%2&! +033(/($%&! &2! *$50/$! &,>$! 6! 6-eF(%50/(=1$! 8$%$+! (%! $+&.=1(+#$5! >+2*(.&(/! >1.?0$+D! 6%!

/2%/10+(2%M!&#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+!+0>>2*&!&#$!(%(&(.&(%8!*21$!23!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!

748%(45(;C/+XW;C/-\('<(:=4*'#='=(

Q)$*! *$/$%&! ,$.*+M! .%2&#$*! +$&! 23! /,&2J(%$+! #.+! $9$*8$5! .+! 9.G2*! >1.,$*+! (%! ).*(20+!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+A! &#$! 6EFjpl6EFZm! .d(+D! <#$+$! &K2! /,&2J(%$+! /#.*./&$*(R$! .! +0=+$&! 23!

#$1>$*! <! /$11+! /.11$5! <F#$1>$*! Zm! a<#ZmVM! K#(/#! >1.,! .! 9.G2*! *21$! (%! >+2*(.+(+! .%5! 2&#$*!

(%31.99.&2*,! 5(+2*5$*+D! C+2*(.+(+! 0+$5! &2! =$! *$8.*5$5! .+! .! <#ZF5*()$%! 5(+$.+$M! =0&! 20*!

0%5$*+&.%5(%8!23!&#$!5(+$.+$!#.+!8*$.&1,!/#.%8$5!2)$*!&#$!,$.*+!.%5!%2K!(&!(+!*$8.*5$5!.+!.!

<#Zm!5(+$.+$D!<#Zm!/$11+!.*$!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!>*250/&(2%!23!6EFZmM!6EFjZM!.%5!6EFjjD!<#$,!/.%!

>*250/$!<e-!.%5! 6EFq!.+!K$11! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2!/$*&.(%!+&(901(Dnn!<#Zm!/$11+!5(33$*$%&(.&$! 3*29!

%.()$!;@nx!<!/$11+!(%!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!<"-FuM!6EFZu!.%5!6EFqD!6EFjp!K.+!>*$)(20+1,!.++09$5!&2!

=$!$++$%&(.1!32*!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!.+!K$11M!=0&!(+!%2K!&#208#&!&2!+&(901.&$!+0*)().1!.%5!$d>.%+(2%!

23!<#Zm!/$11+D!<#$!6EFZm!/,&2J(%$! 3.9(1,!/2%+(+&+!23!+(d! 1(8.%5+A! 6EFZmPM!7M!;M!@M!H!.%5!-D!<#$!

92+&!+&05($5!1(8.%5+!.*$!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-D!<#$+$!/.%!32*9!#2925(9$*+!.%5!#$&$*25(9$*+M!

=2&#!23!K#(/#!+(8%.1!&#*208#!.!/2992%!*$/$>&2*!+0=0%(&!6EFZm:PD!6EFjp!(+!92+&1,!J%2K%!32*!

(&+!(9>2*&.%&!*21$!(%!+0*)().1!.%5!$d>.%+(2%!23!&#$+$!/$11+Dnr!6EFjp!+#.*$+!.!/2992%!+0=0%(&!

K(&#!6EFZjM!/.11$5!6EFZj>n[M!K#(/#!32*9+!.!#$&$*25(9$*!K(&#!6EFjp>ZYD!6EFZj!(+!.!#$&$*25(9$*!

23! 6EFZj>n[!.%5! 6EFZj>prM!K#(/#! &28$&#$*! 32*9!6EFZj>m[D! 6EFZj!.%5! 6EFjp!+#.*$!.!/2992%!

Page 109: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 96 of 237

*$/$>&2*!+0=0%(&M!6EFZj:uZM!K#(/#!&28$&#$*!K(&#!6EFjp:!32*9+!&#$!+(8%.1(%8!*$/$>&2*!/29>1$d!

32*!6EFjpD!!

6%! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+M! &#$! 6EFjp! >.&#K.,! (+! ./&().&$5! .%5! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! #(8#! 1$)$1!

>*250/&(2%! 23! 6EFjp! =,! @;+! .%5! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! .%5! (%/*$.+$5! %09=$*+! 23! <#Zm! /$11+Dnq!

6%/*$.+$5!9:eP! 1$)$1+!23! 6EFjp>ZY!.%5! 6EFZj>n[M!=0&!%2&! 6EFZj>prM!#.)$!=$$%!5$&$/&$5! (%!

).*(20+! +&05($+M! >2(%&(%8! &2! .! +>$/(3(/! *21$! 32*! 6EFjp! =0&! %2&! 6EFZjnmD! "$%$&(/! .++2/(.&(2%!

+&05($+!#.)$!*$)$.1$5!>21,92*>#(+9+!(%!&#$!6EFZj>n[!.%5!6EFjp:!8$%$+!&#.&!(%/*$.+$!&#$!*(+J!

23! 5$)$12>(%8! >+2*(.+(+D! Q&#$*! (%&*(80(%8! 2=+$*).&(2%+! (%/105$! &#$! 32112K(%8A! *$>$.&$5!

(%&*.5$*9.1! (%G$/&(2%+! 23! 6EFjp! .*$! +033(/($%&! &2! (%50/$! ./.%&#2+(+! (%! +J(%M! K#$*$.+! 9(/$!

1./J(%8! &#$! 6EFjp>ZY! +0=0%(&! 52! %2&! 5$)$12>! 3011F=12K%! >+2*(.+(+F1(J$! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! 0>2%!

&*$.&9$%&!K(&#! (9(?0(925DpY! <#$+$!9(/$! .1+2! /.%%2&! (%50/$! 6EFZmP! .%5! 6EFZm-D!L2#%! .%5!

/211$.80$+! +#2K$5! &#.&! &#$! 6EFjp! >*250/$5! =,! E.%8$*(%F%$8.&()$! /2%)$%&(2%.1! @;+! (+!

(9>2*&.%&!32*!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+!(%!9(/$DnZ!g2K$)$*M!&#$!(%(&(.1!*.&(2%.1$!&2!

&.*8$&!6EFjp!K.+!%2&!=.+$5!2%!&#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+D!g(8#!6EFZj!.%5!6EFjp!1$)$1+!K$*$!5$&$/&$5!

(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%! 1$+(2%+M!,$&! (%#(=(&(2%!23!2%1,! &#$!>n[!+0=0%(&! (9>*2)$5!/1(%(/.1!+,9>&29+M!

K#$*$.+!(%#(=(&(2%!23!6-eyM!K#(/#!(+!*$8.*5$5!.+!&#$!J$,!/,&2J(%$!(%!6EFZjl<#Z!+(8%.1(%8M!5(5!

%2&D!712/J(%8!6EFZj>n[!*$50/$5!<#Z!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!6EFZjl6EFjp!1$)$1+!(%!>+2*(.+(+!>.&($%&+D!!

;29>.*$5! &2!#$.1&#,!/2%&*21+M!>+2*(.+(+!>.&($%&+!#.)$!#(8#$*! 1$)$1+!23! 6EFZm! (%! 1$+(2%.1!+J(%!

.%5!(%!>$*(>#$*.1!/(*/01.&(2%D!<#$!1$)$1+!23!6EFZm!.1+2!/2**$1.&$!K(&#!5(+$.+$!+$)$*(&,D!4$)$*.1!

/$11! &,>$+! 2&#$*! &#.%! <#Zm! /$11+! /.%! >*250/$! 6EFZmM! (%/105(%8! %$0&*2>#(1+M! 9.+&! /$11+M!

9./*2>#.8$+M!%.&0*.1!J(11$*!/$11+M!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!.%5!</Zm!/$11+!a;@oxVD!P%2&#$*!&,>$!23!/$11+M!

y�!<!/$11+M!>*250/$+!92*$!6EFZm!&#.%!<#Zm!/$11+D!6%!3./&M!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1M!6EFZm!>*250/(%8!

y�!<!/$11+!.%5!:Q:y<x!(%%.&$!1,9>#2(5!/$11+!.*$!%$/$++.*,!.%5!+033(/($%&!&2!(%50/$!>+2*(.&(/!

>1.?0$+Dno! 6%! &#$! +.9$! +$&&(%8M! 6EFZm-! >1.,+! .! 92*$! >*29(%$%&! *21$! &#.%! 6EFZmPD! 6EFZm-F

>*250/(%8!1,9>#2/,&$+!.*$!320%5!(%!#(8#$*!%09=$*+!(%!P15.*.F&*$.&$5!+J(%!&#.%!6EFZmP!.%5!

6EFjj! >*250/(%8! /$11+M! .%5! +(9(1.*1,M! 6EFZm-FJ%2/J20&! 9(/$! +#2K$5! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 1$++!

Page 110: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 97 of 237

(%31.99.&(2%! /29>.*$5! &2! 6EFZmPFJ%2/J20&!9(/$D!P1&#208#! (&! (+!J%2K%! &#.&! 6EFZmP!.%5! 6EF

Zm-! 5(33$*! (%! $33$/&+! .%5! (%! *$801.&(2%M! 1(&&1$! (+! J%2K%! .=20&! &#$(*! 5(+&(%/&! *21$+! (%! #09.%!

>+2*(.+(+D! 6%!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M! 6EFZmP!.%5! 6EFZm-!>1.,!5(33$*$%&! *21$+D!<#$! 1.&&$*! (+!.&&*(=0&$5!

+21$1,! .! >.&#2128(/.1! *21$! 32*! 5*()(%8! (%31.99.&(2%M! K#$*$.+! &#$! *21$! 23! 6EFZmP! (+! 5$=.&$5D!

72&#! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! $33$/&+! #.)$! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! 32*! 6EFZmP! (%! ;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$DZZMnYwrZ! g2K$)$*M! 50.1! =12/J.5$! 23! =2&#! 1(8.%5+! #.+! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! =,! L$5$=,$F

4/#9(5&! .%5! /211$.80$+! .+! 92*$! $33$/&()$! &#.%! =12/J.5$! 23! $(&#$*! /,&2J(%$! .12%$! (%! .%!

$d>$*(9$%&.1!/21(&(+!925$1Dr[!<#(+!9(8#&!$d>1.(%!K#,!+$/0J(%09.=M!.!3011,!#09.%!92%2/12%.1!

.%&(=25,!.8.(%+&!6EFZmPM!>*2)(5$5!.192+&!%2!/1(%(/.1!=$%$3(&!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!

.%5!K.+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!.%!(%/*$.+$5!%09=$*!23!.5)$*+$!$)$%&+!&#.%!&#$!>1./$=2D!'%&(1!%2KM!

&K2!92%2/12%.1! .%&(=25($+!.8.(%+&! 6EFZmP!.%5!2%$!.8.(%+&! 6EFZm:P!#.)$!=$$%!$).10.&$5! (%!

/1(%(/.1! &*(.1+! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! 23! >+2*(.+(+D! 72&#! +$/0J(%09.=! ae2).*&(+V! .%5! (d$J(R09.=!

aE(11,V! &.*8$&! 6EFZmPM! .%5! =*25.109.=! aP98$%V! &.*8$&+! 6EFZm:PD! H./#! .%&(=25,! #.+! =$$%!

/29>.*$5! &2! $&.%$*/$>&! .%5! 5.&.! 3*29! &#$+$! &*(.1+! .*$! $%/20*.8(%8D! 4&(11M! &#$! ?0$+&(2%! (+!

K#$&#$*!(&!(+!=$+&!&2!&.*8$&!&#$!1(8.%5!2*!&#$!*$/$>&2*D!Q%!&#$!2%$!#.%5M!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!*$.5(1,!

.//$++(=1$!&2!&#$!%$0&*.1(R(%8!.%&(=25($+!(%!/(*/01.&(2%M!=0&!*$/$>&2*+!.*$!$d>*$++$5!(%!&(++0$+!

.%5! 9(8#&! =$! (%.//$++(=1$D! Q%! &#$! 2&#$*! #.%5M! 92+&! /,&2J(%$! 3.9(1($+! /2%+(+&! 23! 5(33$*$%&!

1(8.%5+!.%5!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!23&$%!*$50%5.%&D!6%!&#$!/.+$!23!6EFZmM!+>$/(3(/!(%#(=(&(2%!23!6EF

ZmP!9.,!%2&!=$!+033(/($%&M!.+!6EFZm-!*$9.(%+!./&()$M!+2!=12/J(%8!&#$!/2992%!*$/$>&2*!0%(&!6EF

Zm:P! 9(8#&! =$! 92*$! $33$/&()$D! �$&! .%2&#$*! >2++(=(1(&,! (+! &.*8$&(%8! 6EFZmP! .%5! 6EFZm-!

+(901&.%$20+1,M!K#(/#!K.+!$d>12*$5!=,!"$%$%&$/#!.%5!e2)6990%$D!:"mqjn!a"$%$%&$/#V!.%5!

e6FZn[Z! ae2)6990%$V! .*$! =2&#! (%! /1(%(/.1! >#.+$! 6! &*(.1+Drj! -0&0*$! +&05($+! K(11! *$)$.1! &#$!

=$%$3(/(.1!$33$/&+!23!&.*8$&(%8!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!(%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!6W6@+D!

!

Page 111: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 98 of 237

96%('<2%*:8#)(G%2K%%<(9>?(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=('<(:=4*'#='=(

W2+&!%0/1$.&$5!/$11+!$d>*$++!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e!*$/$>&2*+!.%5!/.%!&#0+!*$+>2%5!

&2!=2&#!/,&2J(%$! 3.9(1($+D!<#$!=.1.%/$!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (+! /*0/(.1! 32*!.!#$.1&#,!

(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!6%(&(.11,M! (&!+$$9$5!&#.&!<e-!9.(%1,!*$801.&$5!*$+>2%+$+!.8.(%+&!=./&$*(.1!

(%+01&+!K#$*$.+! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! a.%5! &,>$! 66! .%5! 666V!K$*$! &#208#&! &2! 30%/&(2%!2%1,! .+! .%&()(*.1!

/,&2J(%$+D! �$&M! $1.=2*.&$! +&05($+! *$)$.1$5! &#.&! %$(&#$*! /,&2J(%$! (+! $d/10+()$1,! (%)21)$5! (%!

$1(/(&(%8! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! $(&#$*! =./&$*(.1! 2*! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%M! =0&! #.)$! 92*$!

>1$(2&*2>(/!30%/&(2%+!.%5!&#.&!(%&$%+()$!/*2++&.1J!$d(+&+!=$&K$$%!=2&#!>.&#K.,+D!

!

?'Q3*%(-D(9>?(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=(#55%"2(%#"6(426%*(#2(26%(8%M%8(45(:IF=Y(

<E:mF./&().&$5!>@;+!>*250/$!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<,>$!6!6-e+!$%#.%/$!&#$(*!2K%!>*250/&(2%!.%5!23!<e-M!K#$*$.+!<e-!+(1$%/$+! &,>$! 6! 6-e!>*250/&(2%D!<28$&#$*!K(&#!>@;+M! &#$,!5*()$! &#$! (%31.99.&2*,!$)$%&+!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!

!

<e-!/.%!$(&#$*! (%50/$!2*! (%#(=(&! &#$!>*250/&(2%!23! &,>$!6! 6-e+D!�.*(1(%.!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!#2K!

>*(9.*,! 9./*2>#.8$+! +&(901.&$5! K(&#! <e-! *.>(51,! >*250/$5! 6:-ZF9$5(.&$5! 6-euDrp! <#(+!

(%50/&(2%!K.+!+$13F+0+&.(%(%8!.%5!./&$5!(%!+,%$*8,!K(&#!52K%+&*$.9!$33$/&+!23!<e-D!<#$,!.1+2!

+#2K$5! &#.&! (%! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! <e-M! 9./*2>#.8$+! .*$! >*(9$5! .%5! &#$(*! *$+>2%+$+! &2!

+0=+$?0$%&! <E:mFo! .%5! FY! +&(901.&(2%! .*$! $%#.%/$5! 50$! &2! (%/*$.+$5! >*250/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6!

6-e+D! 4(9(1.*! *$+01&+! K$*$! 2=&.(%$5! (%! 3(=*2=1.+&F1(J$! +,%2)(2/,&$+! 3*29! >.&($%&+! K(&#!

*#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+Drn! W2*$2)$*M! K$! +#2K$5! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 9$5(.&$! +29$! 23! &#$! &2d(/!

$33$/&+!23!<e-!=,!9$5(.&(%8!&(++0$! (%3(1&*.&(2%!=,!K#(&$!=1225!/$11+!.%5!/$11!5$.&#Drr! 6%!&#$+$!

+$&&(%8+M!<e-!(+!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!=2&#!23!&#$9!./&!(%!/2%/$*&!

&2!$%#.%/$! (%31.99.&(2%D! 6%!2&#$*!/2%5(&(2%+M!<e-! (%#(=(&+! &#$!>*250/&(2%!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!=,!

Page 112: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 99 of 237

./&(%8!2%!&#$!>@;+!a-(80*$!ZVD!>@;+!82!&#*208#!+&.8$+!23!9.&0*.&(2%!.%5!<e-!/.%!.//$1$*.&$!

&#(+! >*2/$++D! P/&().&(2%! .%5! 9.&0*.&(2%! 9.*J$*+M! +0/#! .+! ;;:mM! ;@op! .%5! gEPF@:M! .*$!

(%/*$.+$5!K#$%!>@;+!.*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!$d28$%20+!<e-Drq!40*>*(+(%81,M!0>2%!+&(901.&(2%M!>@;+!

>*250/$!=2&#!6-ev!.%5!<e-D!<e-!*$./#$+!.!9.d(909!=$32*$!6-ev!.%5!32*/$+!>@;+!&2!9.&0*$D!

W.&0*$! >@;+! /$.+$! &2! >*250/$! 6-evD! e$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-! +0+&.(%+! &#(+! 6-ev! >*250/&(2%M!

+088$+&(%8! &#.&! <e-! (+! &#$! +21$! ./&2*! (%! &#(+! %$8.&()$! 3$$5=./JDrm! g2K$)$*M! ./&().&$5! >@;+!

5$>$%5!2%!6-ev!32*!2%82(%8!+$/*$&(2%!23!<e-M!=$/.0+$!=12/J(%8!6-eP:Z!5$/*$.+$+!<e-!1$)$1+D!

<#(+!/*2++*$801.&(2%!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!6-ev!K(&#!3$$5=./J!122>+!(+!9$5(.&$5!=,!;@p[[.l/Dro!

W2*$2)$*M!<e-:ZF5$3(/($%&!9(/$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!P15.*.!5(+>1.,!.%! (%/*$.+$5!.%5!+0+&.(%$5!

&,>$! 6! 6-e! *$+>2%+$M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&!<e-! (+! (%)21)$5! (%! +(1$%/(%8! &#$! &,>$! 6! 6-e! *$+>2%+$! &2!

<E:m!&*(88$*(%8!=*/!<e-:Z!a0%>0=1(+#$5!*$+01&+VD!6&!#.+!=$$%!>2+&01.&$5!&#.&!%$0&*.1(R(%8!<e-!

=,! .%&(=25($+! (%#(=(&+! &#(+! 9.&0*.&(2%! >*2/$++! .%5! (+! *$+>2%+(=1$! 32*! $d/$++()$! 6-ev!

>*250/&(2%M! K#(/#! /2015! 1$.5! &2! 7%& ("="! (%50/&(2%! 2*! $d./$*=.&(2%! 23! >*$F$d(+&(%8!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!>+2*(.+(+DrmMrY!<#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!#.+!

.1+2!=$$%!>2+&01.&$5!(%!+.*/2(52+(+M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!

$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!!

<#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+!+0>>2*&!&#$!#,>2&#$+(+!5$>(/&$5!(%!-(80*$!jA!>.&($%&+!2%!.%&(F<e-!5*08+!

.*$!92*$!*$+>2%+()$!&2!>@;F&.*8$&$5!+&(901(!+0/#!.+!K20%5+!.%5!(%3$/&(2%+!.%5!K(11!>*250/$!

$d/$++()$!.920%&+!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! (%50/(%8!.%!$d.88$*.&$5!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,! 122>D!C2&$%&(.1!

#.R.*520+! +&(901(!9(8#&! /29$! 3*29! &#$! /0&.%$20+!9(/*2=(29$M! 2)$*./&().&(%8! &#$! (990%$!

+,+&$9!50*(%8!K20%5+!.%5! (%3$/&(2%+! (%! &#$+$!>.&($%&+D!:$+$.*/#$*+! (%)$+&(8.&$5!&#$!*21$!23!

&#$! +J(%! 9(/*2=(29$! (%! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+M! .%5! &#$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! 23! "*(/$c! *$+$.*/#! 8*20>!

+088$+&!.%!(%&(9.&$!(%&$*>1.,!K(&#!&#$!+J(%!9(/*2=(29$M!K#(/#!&*(88$*+!&#$!+$%+(&(R$5!(990%$!

+,+&$9!(%!&#$+$!>.&($%&+M!1$.5(%8!&2!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+!a-(80*$!jVDq[wqj!W2*$2)$*M!.%.1,+(+!23!&#$!

/0&.%$20+! 9(/*2=(29$! 3*29! %2%F*$+>2%5$*+! &2! .%&(F<e-! 2*! 3*29! >.&($%&+! K(&#! .! +&*2%8$*!

64:H!+(8%.&0*$!K2015!.112K!0+! &2!$d&*.>21.&$! &#$!5.&.! 3*29!/,&2J(%$! 1$)$1+! &2! &#$!>2&$%&(.1!

Page 113: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 100 of 237

&*(88$*+!*$+(5(%8!2%!&#$!+J(%!23!>.&($%&+D!

!

?'Q3*%(+D(1J'<(45(:#2'%<2=(4<(#<2'/9>?(&#)(*%#"2($'55%*%<28)($3*'<Q(=2*%==(*%=:4<=%=($3%(24(26%(

='8%<"%$(<%Q#2'M%(5%%$G#"J(45(9>?(4<(2):%(;(;?>=Y(

6%!%2*9.1!+J(%M!>@;+!.*$!./&().&$5!.%5!>*250/$!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!./&!2%!>@;+!.%5!+&(901.&$! &#$(*!2K%!>*250/&(2%!.%5!23!<e-!aZVM!K#$*$.+!<e-!>*292&$+!>@;!9.&0*.&(2%!.%5!#$*$=,!+(1$%/$+! >*250/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e! ajVD! P55(&(2%.1! <E:m! .82%(+&+M! >2++(=1,! *$+(5(%8! 2%! &#$! +J(%! /.%!&*(88$*! >@;+! 50*(%8! +&*$++! *$+>2%+$+M! =0&! &#(+! (+! +&*(/&1,! /2%&*211$5U! &#$! (%31.99.&(2%! *$+21)$+D! <#(+!%$8.&()$! 3$$5=./J! =,! <e-! (+! 12+&! 0>2%! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! K(&#! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+M! K#$*$! /2%&(%020+!>*$+$%/$!23!<E:m!.82%(+&+!1$.5+!&2!0%/2%&*211$5!&,>$!6!6-e+!>*250/&(2%!.%5!+0=+$?0$%&!5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+D!

!

6%&*(80(%81,M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 9.,! .1+2! =$! *$8.*5$5! .+! >*28%2+&(/! 9.*J$*+! 32*! *$+>2%+()$%$++!

&2K.*5!.%&(F<e-!5*08+D!<K2!+&05($+!(%)$+&(8.&$5!&#(+!9.&&$*!32*!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!a:PVD!6%!

j[Z[M!W.)*.8.%(! .%5! /211$.80$+! +&05($5! &#$!.++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!>1.+9.! &,>$! 6! 6-e!./&()(&,!

.%5! &#$! 6-eulv! *.&(2D! <#$,! 320%5! &#.&! &#(+! *.&(2M! &28$&#$*! K(&#! 6EFZ*.M! /2015! >*$5(/&! &#$!

&#$*.>$0&(/!*$+>2%+$!&2!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+Dqp!<#$!.0&#2*+!>*2>2+$!&#.&!(%/*$.+$5!6-eu!1$)$1+!(%!

:P! >.&($%&+! *$+01&! (%! .%&(F>*21(3$*.&()$! $33$/&+! &#.&! +,%$*8(R$! K(&#! &#$! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!

$33$/&+! 23! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%M! *$+01&(%8! (%! (9>*2)$5! $33(/./,D! P%2&#$*! +&05,! /2%50/&$5! =,! &#$!

8*20>! 23! I$*K$(G! (%)$+&(8.&$5! &#$! &,>$! 6! 6-e! +(8%.&0*$! =$32*$! .%5! .3&$*! &*$.&9$%&! 23! :P!

>.&($%&+! K(&#! $&.%$*/$>&Dqn! <#(+! &*$.&9$%&! (%50/$5! .! +(8%(3(/.%&! (%/*$9$%&! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-eF

*$801.&$5! 8$%$+! (%! .! +0=+$&! 23! >.&($%&+D! :$9.*J.=1,M! &#$+$! >.&($%&+! #.5! .! >22*! /1(%(/.1!

20&/29$! 32112K(%8! $&.%$*/$>&! &*$.&9$%&D! 6&!90+&! =$! >2(%&$5! 20&! &#.&! (%! &#$! 3(*+&! +&05,! &#$!

Page 114: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 101 of 237

+0=G$/&+!K$*$!>*$529(%.%&1,!g(+>.%(/!.%5!&#.&!=2&#!+&05($+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!2%!*.&#$*!+9.11!

>.&($%&!>2>01.&(2%+D!�$&M!&#$!*$+01&+!K.**.%&!*$>$&(&(2%!23!&#$!+&05($+!2%!.!1.*8$*!+/.1$D!63!&#$+$!

*$+01&+!/.%!=$!/2%3(*9$5M!(&!K2015!=$!0+$301!&2!9$.+0*$!&,>$!6!6-e!./&()(&,M!6-eulv!*.&(2!.%5!

&,>$! 6! 6-eF*$801.&$5! 8$%$+! =$32*$! .%,! &*$.&9$%&! &2! >*$5(/&! &#$! >.&($%&c+! *$+>2%+$! &2!

&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!5*08+D!6%5$$5M!.!%$K!/1(%(/.1!+&05,!K(11!(%)$+&(8.&$!K#$&#$*!&#$*$!(+!.!

/2**$1.&(2%! =$&K$$%! &#$! (9>*2)$9$%&! 23! >+2*(.+(+! (%! >.&($%&+! *$/$()(%8! $&.%$*/$>&! .%5! &#$!

1$)$1+!23!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+Dqr!<#(+!K2015!.112K!/1(%(/(.%+!&2!+&*.&(3,!>+2*(.+(+!>.&($%&+!.%5!

>*$+/*(=$!.%&(F<e-!5*08+!&2!&#2+$!K#2!.*$!92*$!1(J$1,!&2!=$%$3(&!3*29!&#(+!&,>$!23!&*$.&9$%&D!

96%('<2%*:8#)(G%2K%%<(9>?(#<$(;C/+XW;C/-\('<(:=4*'#='=(

<e-!(+!.!)$*,!>2&$%&!/,&2J(%$A!+,+&$9(/!(%G$/&(2%!23!<e-!/.%!1$.5!&2!1$&#.1!+#2/JDrr!<#$!$33$/&!

23! (%&*.5$*9.1! (%G$/&(2%! 23! *$/29=(%.%&! <e-! *$+$9=1$+! &#$! $33$/&! 23! $d&$%+()$! $d>2+0*$! &2!

+21.*!'IA!6;PWFZM!I;PWFZ!.%5!HF+$1$/&(%!.*$!0>*$801.&$5M!&#$!1.&&$*!2%!5$*9.1!9(/*2).+/01.*!

$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+D!;@nn!(+!(%/*$.+$5!.+!K$11M!K#(/#!.112K+!1$0J2/,&$+!&2!=(%5!&2!&#$!$%52&#$1(.1!

+0*3./$+Dqq!6%&*.5$*9.1!(%G$/&(2%!23!<e-!.1+2!(%50/$+!(%310d!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!.%5!1,9>#2/,&$+M!.+!

K$11!.+!9(8*.&(2%!23!$>(5$*9.1!E.%8$*#.%+!/$11+!aE;+V!(%!.!;.+>.+$FZ!5$>$%5$%&!9.%%$*DqmMqo!

:$>$.&$5! (%&*.5$*9.1! (%G$/&(2%! 23! 6EFZm! *$+01&+! (%! $5$9.M! 6EFZu! >*250/&(2%! .%5! %$0&*2>#(1!

*$/*0(&9$%&! (%! &#$! +J(%M! >.*&(.11,! 9$5(.&$5! =,! ;.+>.+$FZ! .+! K$11DqY! g2K$)$*M! 6EFZm! (+! %2&!

.1K.,+!.!>2&$%&! &*(88$*!2%! (&+!2K%D!W.(2%$!$&!.1D! $1$8.%&1,!+#2K$5! (%! &K2!920+$!925$1+!23!

(%31.99.&(2%! &#.&! 6EFZm! /.%! $d$*&! (&+! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! 30%/&(2%+! 2%1,! (%! .! >*$5(+>2+$5!

$%)(*2%9$%&M!=0&!%2&!2%!(&+!2K%Dm[!<#$!9.(%!./&(2%!23!6EFZm!#$*$!+$$9+!&2!=$!*$/*0(&9$%&!23!

%$0&*2>#(1+! &2! &#$! +(&$! 23! (%31.99.&(2%D! <#208#! 6EFZm!9.,! +$$9! .!K$.J! (%50/$*M! $)(5$%/$!

+088$+&+!&#.&!(&!/.%!$%#.%/$!(%31.99.&(2%!&#*208#!+,%$*8,!K(&#!<e-!.%5!6-eyD!-2*!$d.9>1$M!

6EFZm! .33$/&+! J$*.&(%2/,&$! ./&().&(2%! =,! 6-eyD! '>2%! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! 6EFZmM! J$*.&(%2/,&$+!

>*250/$! "WF;4-! (%! #(8#$*! ?0.%&(&($+! &#.%! .3&$*! +&(901.&(2%! K(&#! 6-ey! .12%$D! g2K$)$*M!

/29=(%$5!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!6EFZm!.%5!6-ey!*$)$.1+!&#$(*!+,%$*8(+&(/!$33$/&!(%!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!

Page 115: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 102 of 237

"WF;4-DmZ!E(J$K(+$M!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!;O;EZ!=,!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!(+!$%#.%/$5!=,!.!/29=(%.&(2%!

23! 6EFZm! .%5! 6-ey! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! $(&#$*! /,&2J(%$D! 4(9(1.*! 3(%5(%8+! K$*$!

2=+$*)$5!K(&#!6EFnA!"WF;4-!.%5!;O;EZ!>$.J$5!K#$%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6EFZmM!

6-ey!.%5!6EFn!+(901&.%$20+1,Dqm!70&!.+!9$%&(2%$5!.=2)$M!6EFZm!/.%!.1+2!+,%$*8(R$!K(&#!<e-D!

<#$!92+&!3*$?0$%&1,!5$+/*(=$5!$)$%&!(+!&#$(*!+,%$*8(+&(/!*$/*0(&9$%&!23!%$0&*2>#(1+!a-(80*$!pVM!

K#$*$!=2&#!<e-!.%5!6EFZm!(%50/$!;O;EZM!;O;EjM!;O;ErM!6EFoM!CF+$1$/&(%!.%5!HF+$1$/&(%Dmjwmn!6%!

.55(&(2%M! =2&#! /,&2J(%$+! $%#.%/$! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! ;;Ej[M! W;CFZM! W6CFjM! 4Z[[Po! .%5! uF

5$3$%+(%!p!+,%$*8(+&(/.11,DmpMmrwmo!4Z[[Po!(+!(%50/$5!=,!<e-!%2&!2%1,!(%!#09.%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!

.%5! 6EFZmM! =0&! .1+2! (%! +,%2)(.1! &(++0$M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! &#$! +,%$*8,! =$&K$$%! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm!

$d(+&+! (%!>+2*(.+(+M!:P!.%5!>2++(=1,!2&#$*!5(+$.+$+D!<#$!8*20>!23!i*0$8$*!>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!

&#.&!6EFZm!.%5!<e-!/22>$*.&$!&2!+0>>*$++!9$1.%28$%$+(+!(%!%2*9.1!#09.%!9$1.%2/,&$+M!.%5!

&#(+!K.+!.1+2!2=+$*)$5!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%M!K#$*$!=2&#!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!2)$*$d>*$++$5Dmp!C+2*(.+(+!

#.+!(%5$$5!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!5,+*$801.&(2%!23!>(89$%&.&(2%A!./&()$1,!(%31.9$5!+J(%!(+!23&$%!

/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!#,>2>(89$%&.&(2%M!K#$*$.+!*$+21)$5!1$+(2%+!5$)$12>!#,>$*>(89$%&.&(2%D!!

!

?'Q3*%(XD(9>?(#<$(;C/-\(=)<%*Q'a%('<(26%(*%"*3'2&%<2(45(<%32*4:6'8=Y(

I.*(20+! /$11! &,>$+! (%!>+2*(.&(/! +J(%!>*250/$!<e-!.%5! 6EFZmD!<e-!.%5! 6EFZm! /.%! +&(901.&$!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&! 2%! &#$(*! 2K%M! =0&! .1+2! &28$&#$*! (%! .! +,%$*8(+&(/! 9.%%$*M! 1$.5(%8! &2! $%#.%/$5!(%31.99.&(2%D!!

!

6%! 2*5$*! &2! 0%5$*+&.%5! &#$! $.*1,! /29=(%$5! ./&(2%+! 23! 6EFZm! .%5! <e-M! +J(%! =(2>+($+! 3*29!

#$.1&#,! )210%&$$*+! K$*$! 0+$5! &2! 9.J$! .%! $1$8.%&! &#*$$F5(9$%+(2%.1! 925$1M! K#(/#! &#$,!

&*$.&$5! K(&#! 6EFZm! .%5! <e-DmY! 7,! .55(%8! =2&#! >()2&.1! /,&2J(%$+! +(901&.%$20+1,M! &#$,!

9(9(/J$5!&#$!9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2=+$*)$5!&#.&!&#$!(%%$*!>*21(3$*.&()$!1.,$*!

Page 116: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 103 of 237

K.+! (%#(=(&$5! $.*1,! .%5! &#.&! &#$! 2//105(%! $d>*$++(2%! >.&&$*%! K.+! .33$/&$5D! @2%$&&(! $&! .1D!

/2%/105$5! &#.&!<e-!.%5! 6EFZm!#.)$!5(*$/&!$33$/&+!2%! &#$!#29$2+&.+(+!23! &#$!$>(5$*9(+D! 6&! (+!

&#$*$32*$! %2&! +0*>*(+(%8! &#.&! 50.1! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm! #.+! .1*$.5,! =$$%! >*2>2+$5D!

i2$%5$*+! .%5! /211$.80$+! 5$+/*(=$5! #2K! +(901&.%$20+! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm! 8*$.&1,!

*$50/$5! +,9>&29+! (%! $d>$*(9$%&.1! .*&#*(&(+Dmm! <#(+! /2015! .1+2! =$! .! +&*.&$8(/! &#$*.>,! 32*!

>+2*(.+(+D! ;2).8$%! #.+! 5$)$12>$5! .! =(+>$/(3(/! (%#(=(&2*! /2%+(+&(%8! 23! .! &*.5(&(2%.1! .%&(=25,!

.8.(%+&!<e-!.%5!.%! 6EFZmP!%$0&*.1(R(%8!-,%29$*M! .! +9.11! =(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!5$*()$5! 3*29! &#$!

#09.%! -,%! 4gp! 529.(%D! <#(+! `-,%29P=_! *$/$%&1,! $%&$*$5! >#.+$! 67l66P! &*(.1+! 32*! +.3$&,M!

&21$*.=(1(&,! .%5!>#.*9./2J(%$&(/+M! .+!K$11! .+! 32*! (9>*2)$9$%&! 23! >+2*(.&(/! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! .%5!

=(2128(/.1! *$+>2%+$+Do[! P1&28$&#$*M! &#$! +,%$*8(+&(/! ./&(2%+! *$+01&(%8! 3*29! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm!

+(8%.1(%8!9.,!*$>*$+$%&!.%!$33$/&()$!&#$*.>$0&(/!&.*8$&!&2!&*$.&!>+2*(.+(+D!

96%('<2%*:8#)(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(;C/+XW;C/-\('<(:=4*'#='=(

72&#!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!#.)$!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!%09$*20+!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!+0/#!.+!

901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!6%!&#$!1(&$*.&0*$M!&,>$!6!

6-e+!.*$!9.(%1,!*$>2*&$5!&2!1(9(&!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%M!=0&!.!5(*$/&!1(%J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!

6EFZm! (%! >+2*(.+(+! #.+! %2&! =$$%!5$+/*(=$5D! 6%!901&(>1$! +/1$*2+(+! aW4VM!K#(/#! (+! &*$.&$5!K(&#!

6-euM!<#Zm!/$11+!>1.,!.!*21$!.55(&(2%.1! &2! &#$!*21$!23!<#Z!/$11+D! 6EFZm!9:eP!.%5!>*2&$(%!.*$!

(%/*$.+$5! (%! ./&()$! W4! =*.(%! 1$+(2%+DoZMoj! H1$).&$5! 1$)$1+! 23! 6EFZm! .*$! .1+2! 320%5! (%! =1225F

5$*()$5! 92%2%0/1$.*! /$11+! .%5! /$*$=*2+>(%.1! 310(5! 23! W4! >.&($%&+! /29>.*$5! &2! #$.1&#,!

/2%&*21+Dopwor! <#$! K(5$1,! 0+$5! 90*(%$! 925$1! 23! W4M! $d>$*(9$%&.1! .0&2(990%$!

$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+!aHPHVM!>*2)(5$+!$)(5$%/$!32*!&#$!>*2(%31.99.&2*,!*21$!23!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjpM!

=0&!&#$!$d./&!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!(%!W4!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225D!e09$*20+!+&05($+!

>2+&01.&$5!&#.&!&#$!=$%$3(/(.1!$33$/&!23!6-eu!&#$*.>,!(+!&#$!*$50/&(2%!23!6EFZm!1$)$1+D!72&#!6EFZ[!

.%5! 6EFjm! #.)$! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! &2! (%#(=(&! 6EFZmDoqMom! @$%5*(&(/! /$11+! +&(901.&$5! K(&#! 6-euM!

>*250/$! 6EFZ[M! 6EFjm! .%5! 6EFZj>prM! K#(/#! (+! 9$5(.&$5! =,! $1$).&$5! <E:m! 1$)$1+D! 6-eu! .1+2!

Page 117: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 104 of 237

=12/J+! 6EFZuM! <"-uM! 6EFjp! .%5! 6EFZj>n[M! &#$*$=,! (%#(=(&(%8! *(& =*)5"! .%5! *(& =*="! <#Zm!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%DooMoY! 70&! /2%31(/&(%8! *$+01&+! +088$+&! &#.&! &#$!9$/#.%(+9! 23! 6-eu! &*$.&9$%&! (+!

90/#!92*$! /29>1$dD! 6%! .!<#ZF5*()$%!HPH!925$1M! .59(%(+&*.&(2%!23! 6-eu!K.+!>*2&$/&()$! .+!

$d>$/&$5M! =0&! K#$%! <#Zm! /$11+! 9$5(.&$5! &#$! 5(+$.+$M! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! 6-eu! .88*.).&$5! &#$!

+,9>&29+DY[!4(9(1.*1,M!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8!3*29!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!W4!a::W4V!52!%2&!.1K.,+!

*$+>2%5! &2! 6-euD! 6%! .! +&05,! /2%50/&$5! =,! 7�1.�.! $&! .1DM! pmDr\! 23! &#$! >.&($%&+! K$*$! %2%F

*$+>2%5$*+! .%5! #.5! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! (%/*$.+$5! +$*09! 6EFZmP! 1$)$1+! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2! &#$!

*$+>2%5$*+M!K#$*$.+!Pd&$11!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!#$(8#&$%$5!1$)$1+!23!6EFZm-!(%!&#2+$!K#2!5(5!%2&!

*$+>2%5!&2!6-euDYZ!!

6%!/2%&*.+&!&2!W4M!%2!5(*$/&!1(%J!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!(%!>+2*(.+(+!#.+!=$$%!5$+/*(=$5!

+2!3.*M!.1&#208#!=2&#!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!*$50/$5!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!1$+(2%+!23!>.&($%&+!&*$.&$5!K(&#!

%.**2K!=.%5!'IF7!+088$+&(%8!&#$,!./&!(%!/2%/$*&!(%!>+2*(.+(+DYj!@0*(%8!+J(%!(%G0*,M!>@;+!.*$!

./&().&$5! =,! &#$! *$1$.+$! 23! %0/1$(/! ./(5+! .%5! >*250/$! 6-ev! (%! *$+>2%+$M! K#(/#! >*292&$+!

$>(5$*9.1! *$8$%$*.&(2%! .%5! K20%5! #$.1(%8D! @0*(%8! &#(+! >*2/$++M! 6EFZm! .%5! 6EFjj! .*$!

>*250/$5! .+!K$11! .%5! (&! #.+! =$$%! +#2K%! &#.&! 5$>1$&(2%! 23! >@;+! (9>.(*+! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23!

&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+D!4(9(1.*!$33$/&+!K$*$!2=+$*)$5!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!.%5!&#(+!K.+!.//29>.%($5!

=,!.!5$1.,!(%!K20%5!*$$>(&#$1(R.&(2%M!K#(/#!+088$+&+!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!5*()$!&#$!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!

23! 6EFZmF! .%5! 6EFjjF>*250/(%8!<! /$11+! 50*(%8!K20%5! *$>.(*DYp! 6EFjjM! .!9$9=$*! 23! &#$! 6EFZ[!

3.9(1,! #.+! .1+2! =$$%! (9>1(/.&$5! (%!W4! .%5!>+2*(.+(+M! .%5! (+! 23&$%! .++2/(.&$5!K(&#! &#$!<#Zm!

.d(+D! 6&! +(8%.1+! &#*208#!.!#$&$*25(9$*(/! *$/$>&2*! /29>1$d! /2%+(+&(%8!23! 6EFZ[:j!.%5! 6EFjj:!

.%5!(%50/$+!+$)$*.1!8$%$+!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!+0/#!.+!uF5$3$%+(%+!.%5!4Z[[!3.9(1,!>*2&$(%+M!=2&#!

.%&(9(/*2=(.1!>*2&$(%+!&#.&!.*$!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!W2*$2)$*M!6EFjj!+&(901.&$+!&#(/J$%(%8!

23! &#$! $>(5$*9(+! )(.! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! &$*9(%.1! J$*.&(%2/,&$! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! &#*208#! 6EFjj:D!

Hd>*$++(2%! 23! 6EFjj:! (+! $%#.%/$5! K#$%! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! .*$! &*$.&$5! K(&#! 6-evM! *$+01&(%8! (%!

(%/*$.+$5! >#2+>#2*,1.&(2%! 23! 4<P<p! .%5! (%/*$.+$5! 6EFjj! +(8%.1(%8DYn! <#(+! +088$+&+! &#.&!

$1$).&$5!&,>$!6! 6-e+!9.,!./&! (%5(*$/&1,!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!&#*208#!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjj:!+(8%.1(%8!

Page 118: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 105 of 237

a-(80*$! nVD! 6EFZm! .%5! 6EFjj! #.)$! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! &2! ./&! (%! +,%$*8,! .%5! /.%! $%#.%/$! +J(%!

(%31.99.&(2%!&28$&#$*DjrMqYMYr!6%!K20%5!#$.1(%8M!6EFZml6EFjj!+(8%.1(%8!(+!+(1$%/$5!&2K.*5+!&#$!

$%5M! =12/J(%8! J$*.&(%2/,&$! 9(8*.&(2%M! >*21(3$*.&(2%! .%5! .%&(9(/*2=(.1! >*2&$(%! >*250/&(2%D!

40+&.(%$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! ./&()(&,! K(11! (9>.(*! &#(+! +#0&52K%! .%5! 1$.5! &2! &#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23!

>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+DYpMYnMYq!g2K$)$*M!;#*(+&2>#$*+!$&!.1D!+088$+&$5!&#.&!(990%$!./&().&(2%!=,!&,>$!

6! 6-e+!.%5! 6EFZm! (+!=(925.1! (%!>+2*(.+(+A!<E:!./&().&(2%!.%5! 6EFZ!+$/*$&(2%!=,!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!

./&().&$! .%5! *$/*0(&! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11+M! (%/105(%8! >@;+DYm! 40=+$?0$%&1,M! >21,92*>#2%0/1$.*!

%$0&*2>#(1+! .%5! 6EFZm! >*250/(%8! /$11+! .*$! *$/*0(&$5D! 6%! &#(+! >#.+$M! 5*()$%! =,! 6EFZmM! >@;+!

+$/*$&$!1.*8$!.920%&+!23!6-evM!+J$K(%8!&#$!(990%$!.d(+!&2K.*5+!&#$!/1.++(/.1!<#ZF9$5(.&$5!

(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!Q0*!2=+$*).&(2%+M!#2K$)$*M!+#2K!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!.33$/&!6EFZm-!1$)$1+!

(%!+$*09!0>2%!+&(901.&(2%!K(&#!P15.*.!a0%>0=1(+#$5!*$+01&+VD!6%5$$5M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!52!

%2&! .1K.,+! /20%&$*./&! 2%$! .%2&#$*M! =0&! ./&! (%! /2%/$*&D! <#(+! (+! $1$8.%&1,! (110+&*.&$5! (%! .%!

.0&2(990%$! 925$1! (%! K#(/#! 7O@j! 9(/$! 5$)$12>! 8129$*012%$>#*(&(+M! >*2&$(%0*(.M!

+>1$%29$8.1,M!.%5!.0&2.%&(=25,!>*250/&(2%D!<#$+$!9(/$!$d#(=(&!(%/*$.+$5!1$)$1+!23!=2&#!6EFZm!

.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+M!.%5!+&05($+!#.)$!*$)$.1$5!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!.%5!.%&(=25,!>*250/&(2%!

.*$! .089$%&$5! =,! 6EFZmDYo! 6%! /2%/10+(2%M! =2&#! /,&2J(%$+! #.)$! =$$%! +&05($5! +$>.*.&$1,! (%!

>+2*(.+(+M!,$&!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!9.,!=$!*$1$).%&!32*!%$K!&#$*.>($+!

.%5!&#0+!>2+$+!.%!(%&$*$+&(%8!3($15!23!(%)$+&(8.&(2%D!

!

?'Q3*%(.D(;C/-\(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=("#<(#"2(4<(26%(=J'<($'*%"28)(#<$('<$'*%"28)N(*%=:%"2'M%8)Y(

6EFZm!/.%!./&!5(*$/&1,!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!=0&!.1+2!(%5(*$/&1,!&#*208#!0>*$801.&(2%!23!6EFjj:D!<,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!.33$/&!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!23!6EFZm!.%5!/.%!.1+2!+&(901.&$!6EFjj:!$d>*$++(2%M!#$*$=,!./&(%8!(%5(*$/&1,!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+D!

!

Page 119: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 106 of 237

F4<"83='4<D('&:8'"#2'4<=(54*(26%(2*%#2&%<2=(45(:=4*'#='=(#<$(426%*($'=%#=%=(#<$(

"3**%<2(#<$(5323*%($*3Q=(

P%!(%/*$.+(%8!%09=$*!23!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!.*$!=$(%8!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!$d/$++()$!<e-M!&,>$!

6! 6-e+! .%5! 6EFjpl6EFZm! +(8%.1(%8D! P%&(F<e-! 5*08+M! .+! K$11! .+! 6-ev! .%5! 6-euM! .*$! $33$/&()$!

&#$*.>($+!32*!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!.%5!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!*$+>$/&()$1,M!=0&!&#$(*!+(5$!$33$/&+!23!

7%&("="! (%50/&(2%!23!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!10>0+!#.)$!5*()$%!*$+$.*/#!&2!3(%5!%2)$1!

5*08!&.*8$&+D!<25.,M!9.%,!/1(%(/(.%+!32/0+!2%!&#$!0+$!23!5*08+!&.*8$&(%8!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!

=,!%$0&*.1(R(%8!6EFZmPM!6EFZm-M!6EFZm:M!6Ejp>ZY!.%5!6EFZj>n[D!g2K$)$*M!.+!K$!>2(%&!20&M!&#$!

&*(.%801.*!(%&$*>1.,!=$&K$$%!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!(+!23!8*$.&!(9>2*&.%/$!.%5!&.*8$&(%8!

2%$! 23! &#$9!9.,! .33$/&! &#$! 2&#$*+D! <#$! &#*$$! /,&2J(%$+! +$$9! &2! =$! &#$! /2*%$*+&2%$+! 23! .%!

(%31.99.&2*,! &*(.%81$! &#.&! >1.,+! .! /$%&*.1! *21$! (%! &#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! .%5! 9.(%&$%.%/$! 23!

>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!/#*2%(/! (%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!a-(80*$!rVD!<#$!/*2++!*$801.&(2%!=$&K$$%!

<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(+!?0(&$!/29>1$dM!=0&!(&!+$$9+!&2!5$>$%5!2%!&#$!9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&D!<e-!

/.%! (%50/$! 6:-FZ!9$5(.&$5!>*250/&(2%!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%!9./*2>#.8$+rpM!=0&!/.%!.1+2!./&!=*/!

<e-:Z! .+! .! %$8.&()$! *$801.&2*! 23! 6-ev! >*250/&(2%! (%! >@;+DrqMrmMrY! 6%! &0*%M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! /.%!

9$5(.&$! (%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$+!$1(/(&$5!=,!<e-rr!.%5!/.%!.1+2!./&!.+!.%!$%#.%/$*! 32*!<e-!

>*250/&(2%!=,!>@;+M!&#$*$=,!(%5(*$/&1,!+&(901.&(%8!(&+!2K%!+#0&52K%Dro!6%!>+2*(.+(+M!&#$!$d./&!

(%&$*>1.,! (+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225!.&! &#$!921$/01.*! 1$)$1M!=0&! (&! (+!/1$.*! &#.&! &.*8$&(%8!<e-!

2%1,! (+! %2&! .1K.,+! +033(/($%&D! e$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-! *$+01&+! (%! 12++! 23! /2%&*211$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e!

+(8%.1(%8! .%5! 1$.5+! &2! (%/*$.+$5! 6-ev! +$/*$&(2%! .%5! 7%& ("="! (%50/&(2%! 23! >+2*(.+(+! 2*!

.88*.).&(2%!23!&#$!>*$F$d(+&(%8!/2%5(&(2%D!6&!+$$9+!&#.&!>@;+!.*$!&#$!/$%&*.1!/$11!>2>01.&(2%!(%!

&#(+! /*2++! *$801.&(2%D! Q%! &#$! 2&#$*! #.%5M! <e-! .1+2! (%&$*./&+! K(&#! &#$! 6EFjpl6EFZm! .d(+M!

*$+01&(%8! (%! +,%$*8(+&(/! *$/*0(&9$%&! .%5! ./&().&(2%! 23! %$0&*2>#(1+D! 6&! (+! &#$*$32*$! %2&!

+0*>*(+(%8! &#.&! /$*&.(%!>21,92*>#(+9+! (%! &#$! ,SFDX>! 8$%$! /.%!.33$/&! .!>.&($%&c+! *$+>2%+$! &2!

.%&(F<e-!.8$%&+DYY!'%32*&0%.&$1,M!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!!

Page 120: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 107 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(0D(96%('<58#&&#24*)(2*'#<Q8%(45(9>?N(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(;C/-\('<(:=4*'#='=Y(

Q)$*./&().&(2%! 23! <e-! /.%! 1$.5! &2! (%31.99.&(2%M! =0&! (&! /.%! .1+2! +,%$*8(R$!K(&#! 6EFZm! =,! $%#.%/(%8!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&D!6EFZm!.1+2!9$5(.&$+!>+2*(.&(/!(%31.99.&(2%!5(*$/&1,!.%5!(%5(*$/&1,!=,!./&(%8!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+D!>@;F5$*()$5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!a3011!.**2KV!.%5!(+!%2*9.11,!+(1$%/$5!=,!<e-M!K#(/#! (+! 12+&! 50*(%8! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&+! a52&&$5! .**2K+VD! <,>$! 6! 6-e+! /.%! ./&! 2%! J$*.&(%2/,&$+!(%5(*$/&1,!&28$&#$*!K(&#!6EFZm!&#*208#!(%/*$.+$!23!6EFjj:D!<#(/J!.**2K+!(%5(/.&$!+,%$*8,D!

!

.d(+!#.)$!*$9.(%$5!1.*8$1,!0%5$*+&05($5M!.1&#208#!&#$(*!(%&$*>1.,!(%!W4!#.+!=$$%!5$+/*(=$5D!

<,>$!6!6-e+!9(8#&!./&!(%!.!%2*9.1!(990%$!+,+&$9!9.(%1,!=,!+0>>*$++(%8!&#$!<#Zm!.*9!23!&#$!

(990%$! +,+&$9D!g2K$)$*M! (&! (+!>1.0+(=1$! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!.%5! 6EFZm!9.,!./&! (%! /2%/$*&! (%! .!

=(925.1!9.%%$*!&2!$%#.%/$!.0&2F(%31.99.&(2%M!=0&!&#(+!#.+!,$&!&2!=$!(%)$+&(8.&$5D!

7.+$5! 2%! &#$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! 5$+/*(=$5! .=2)$M! >.&($%&+! K(&#! >+2*(.+(+! 9.,! =$! +&*.&(3($5! (%&2!

>2>01.&(2%+M!=.+$5!9.(%1,!2%!K#$&#$*!&#$!>+2*(.+(+!(+!9$5(.&$5!=,!6EFZmM!<e-!2*!&,>$!6!6-e+M!

.%5!5(.8%2+$5!.//2*5(%8!&2!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!&*(.%81$!5$>(/&$5!(%!-(80*$!rD!<#(+!(%31.99.&2*,!

&*(.%81$! (9>1($+! &#.&! (%! 2*5$*! &2! ./#($)$!9.d(9.1! &#$*.>$0&(/! $33(/./,M! 2%$! /2*%$*! /2015! =$!

0+$5!&2!>*$5(/&!.!>.&($%&c+!20&/29$!(%!.!&#$*.>,!&.*8$&(%8!.%2&#$*!/2*%$*M!2*!K#$&#$*!=12/J(%8!

&K2! /2*%$*+! 23! &#$! &*(.%81$! /2015! *$+01&! (%! 8*$.&$*! /1(%(/.1! =$%$3(&+D! 6%! &#$! /.+$! 23! .%&(F<e-!

&#$*.>,M! >.&($%&+! K#2! .*$! >*2%$! &2! .%! (%/*$.+$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e! *$+>2%+$! .%5! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23!

Page 121: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 108 of 237

>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! /2015! =$%$3(&! 3*29! +(901&.%$20+! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! &#(+! >.&#K.,! =,! =12/J(%8!

6-eP:Z! a0%>0=1(+#$5! *$+01&+VD! E(J$K(+$M! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29! >+2*(.+(+! 50$! &2! +,%$*8,!

=$&K$$%! <e-! .%5! 6EFZm! /.%! =$! &*$.&$5! =,! +(901&.%$20+! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! =2&#! <e-! .%5! 6EFZmM!

K#(/#!9.,!*$+01&!(%!+,%$*8(+&(/!/1$.*.%/$!23!+,9>&29+D!!

6%! .%! $*.!K#$*$!>$*+2%.1(R$5!9$5(/(%$! (+! /29(%8! /12+$*M! &#(+! J(%5!23! (%+(8#&+! /.%! &.J$!0+! .!

+&$>!/12+$*!&2!+0=+&.%&(.11,!&*$.&!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8!3*29!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!6W6@+D!

!

!

!"J<4K8%$Q%&%<2(

L$!K2015!1(J$!&2!&#.%J!P9(%!7*$5.%!32*!$5(&(%8!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&D(

! (

Page 122: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 109 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! -*$5*(J++2%!<M!C$&&$*++2%!'D!4$)$*$!>+2*(.+(+FF2*.1!&#$*.>,!K(&#!.!%$K!*$&(%2(5D!3%50/)"."8*+/D!ZYmoUZrmanVAjpoFnnD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lprmjZpD!P//$++$5!N01,!ZpM!

j[ZnD!

jD!! W20+&20!PFHM!W.&$J2)(&+!PM!@$++(%(2&(!;M!P%&2%(20!;M!43(J.J(+!CCM!4&*.&(82+!PND!;0&.%$20+!+(5$!$33$/&+!23!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!=(2128(/!&#$*.>,A!.!/1(%(/.1!*$)($KD!c&U0&U+/7&3%50/)".D!j[[YUqZapVAnoqFr[nD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG..5Dj[[oDZ[D[q[D!

pD!! P%&2%(!;M!7*.0%!ND!4(5$!$33$/&+!23!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,A!/0**$%&!J%2K1$58$D!?.*(&T_4&>;%#0/)".D!j[[jUj[aq!40>>1!joVA4ZrjFmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZjnqpnqoD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!

j[ZnD!

nD!! 7.1.J09.*!CM!4(%8#!WD!P%&(F&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!(%!#$.*&!3.(10*$A!30&0*$!5(*$/&(2%+D!6/$*+&

?.*(&\;/50/+".&A"_*+".D!j[[qUYYaqVApYZFmD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZmnjFmonpDj[[qD>&2�r[oDdD!

rD!! i$*=1$+J(!N-M!"2&&1($=!P7D!@$*9.&2128(/.1!/29>1(/.&(2%+!.%5!+.3$&,!23!.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&+D!'#)D!

j[[YUroaoVAZ[ppFYD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&Dj[[oDZqpqopD!

qD!! P192.11(9!gM!P1F"#.95(!�M!P19.8#*.=(!gM!P1,.+(!QD!P%&(F<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*Fv!6%50/$5!4,+&$9(/!

E0>0+!H*,&#$9.&2+0+D!^4%(&>;%#0/)".&cD!j[ZjUqApZrFYD!52(AZ[DjZmnlZomnpZjY[Zj[q[Z[pZrD!

mD!! @$=.%5&!WM!I(&&$/2?!QM!@$+/.9>+!IM!E$!E2�&!OM!W$,$*!QD!P%&(F<e-F.1>#.F(%50/$5!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!

+,%5*29$D!?.*(&>;%#0/)".D!j[[pUjjaZVArqFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[[qmF[[jF[qrnFrD!

oD!! 6=2**.!WM!7$1&*�%!7M!7.+&(5.!"M!P80.+!WM!e2+!CD!6%31(d(9.=!.%5!.5.1(909.=F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$A!.!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&D!c&?5";($&?".*)*$D!j[ZZUrajVAZrmFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/*2#%+Dj[Z[DZZD[[ZD!

YD!! 7.*&#$1!;M!7($5$*9.%%!EM!-*$(!CM!$&!.1D!6%50/&(2%!2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!0%5$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.%&(=25($+D!3*8%$)*"(D!j[ZnUoYapVAj[YFZrD!

52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[projooD!

Z[D!! C.*.52K+J.F"2*,/J.!PM!L2G&$/J.FE0J.+(J!HM!<*$31$*!NM!L2G/($/#2K+J.!7M!E./J(!NiM!W.+1(%+J(!4D!P++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!6EFZm-!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9+!.%5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!.%5!+$)$*(&,!23!*#$09.&2(5!

.*&#*(&(+!a:PVD!M+/(7&c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UmjajVAZpnFnZD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFp[opDj[Z[D[jnZZDdD!

ZZD!! 4$(5$*$*!NM!H1=$%!6M!@($8$19.%%!NM!$&!.1D!:21$!23!&#$!%2)$1!<#Zm!/,&2J(%$!6EFZm-!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!=2K$1!5(+$.+$!a67@VA!0>*$801.&$5!/212%(/!6EFZm-!$d>*$++(2%!(%!./&()$!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!&#$!6EZm-!

>Dg(+ZqZP*8!>21,92*>#(+9!(%!67@D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!j[[oUZnanVAnpmFnrD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl(=5Dj[ppYD!

ZjD!! 4>.5.*2!PM!E0=*.%2!HD!7$,2%5!.%&(F<e-Fv!.8$%&+!(%!>+2*(.&(/!.*&#*(&(+D!T_4%5)&>%=&?.*(&,00#(".D!

j[ZpUYaqVAr[mFYD!52(AZ[DZroql$/(DZpDpjD!

ZpD!! ;1.*J$!PLM!C201&2%!EM!L.(!g�M!$&!.1D!P!%2)$1!/1.++!23!.%&(F6EFZj>n[!.%&(=25($+A!>2&$%&!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!)(.!

(%#(=(&(2%!23!6EFZjF6EFZj:uj!.%5!6EFjpF6EFjp:D!!UL$D!j[Z[UjarVArpYFnYD!52(AZ[DnZqZl9.=+DjDrDZp[oZD!

ZnD!! <2(/#(!HM!<2**$+!"M!W/;2*9(/J!<4M!$&!.1D!P%!.%&(F6EFZj>n[!.%&(=25,!52K%F*$801.&$+!&,>$!Z!/,&2J(%$+M!/#$92J(%$+M!.%5!6EFZjl6EFjp!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[qUZmmamVAnYZmFjqD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZqYojYpnD!P//$++$5!W.,!jjM!j[ZnD!

ZrD!! C.+>.*.J(+!WM!P1$d2>20120!EM!H>(+J2>20!IM!i211(.+!"D!,00#(%&/(7&,(-./00/)"59&>%$4"($%$&*(&AVW&U.4;/F3%-*+*%()&!*+%N&U&?5*)*+/.&>%d#*5%0%()&-"5&AVW&U.4;/&*(&);%&W"50/)*"(&"-&\5*0/59&6&?%..&W"..*+.%$:&W"..*+#./5&

3%(75*)*+&?%..&V%)J"5B$&/(7&'%50*(/.&?%()%5$:&/(7&*(&);%&!/)#5/)*"(&"-&);%&[#0"5/.&,00#(%&>%$4"($%DU!ZYYqAZpYmFnZZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

Page 123: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 110 of 237

#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�jZYjojnB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!W.,!oM!j[ZnD!

ZqD!! E$!g(*!WM!710$&#9.%%!gM!i2+/2FI(1=2(+!WgM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*FZ!+(8%.1(%8!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!23!3211(/01.*!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+M!8$*9(%.1!/$%&$*!32*9.&(2%M!.%5!3011!.%&(=25,!*$+>2%+$+D!c&,(-./00D!nmaZFjVAmqFo[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5loYZpYpjD!P//$++$5!P080+&!

p[M!j[ZnD!

ZmD!! H&&$#.5(!CM!"*$.)$+!WLM!L.11./#!@M!P5$*J.!@M!;.9>!:@D!H1$).&$5!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!a<e-F.1>#.V!=(2128(/.1!./&()(&,!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!ZYYnUYqaZVAZnqFrZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZrpnrpqB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jjM!j[ZnD!

ZoD!! E$K!LM!72K/2/J!PWM!i*0$8$*!N"D!C+2*(.+(+!)018.*(+A!/0&.%$20+!1,9>#2(5!&(++0$!+0>>2*&+!<F/$11!./&().&(2%!.%5!`<,>$!Z_!(%31.99.&2*,!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%D!A5%(7$&,00#(".D!j[[nUjraqVAjYrFp[rD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(&Dj[[nD[pD[[qD!

ZYD!! 72%(3.&(!;M!P9$81(2!-D!;,&2J(%$+!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!,()&c&3%50/)".D!ZYYYUpoanVAjnZFrZD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[pjZYpoD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

j[D!! i*(+&$%+$%!WM!;#0!;sM!H$5,!@NM!-$159.%%!WM!7*$%%.%!-WM!7*$.&#%./#!4WD!E2/.1(R.&(2%!23!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!a<e-F.1>#.V!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!(%!%2*9.1!.%5!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%A!$>(5$*9.1!/$11+!$d>*$++!&#$!rrFJ@!=0&!%2&!&#$!mrFJ@!<e-!*$/$>&2*D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!ZYYpUYnajVAprnFqjD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�ZrpnjnmB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!jjM!j[ZnD!

jZD!! 7.%%2!<M!".R$1!PM!7109$%=$*8!WD!H33$/&+!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!a<e-!.1>#.V!(%!$>(5$*9.1!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!*$)$.1$5!0+(%8!812=.1!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!>*23(1(%8D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[[nUjmYapZVApjqppFnjD!

52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/DWn[[qnjj[[D!

jjD!! �#0.%8!EM!W.!LM!;.(!@M!�#2%8!gM!40%!sD!U$$"+*/)*"($&L%)J%%(&A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5Fh&\".90"54;*$0$&/(7&>*$B&"-&\$"5*/$*$N&U&!%)/FU(/.9$*$O!ae2)$11(!"M!$5DVD!C0=1(/!E(=*.*,!23!4/($%/$U!j[ZpA$qoojmD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[qoojmD!

jpD!! <$G.+)(!<M!4&0.*&!CHM!;#.%5*.%!IM!$&!.1D!<e-P6Cp!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9+!.*$!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!*$+>2%+$!&2!

<e-!=12/J.5$!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZjUZpjap!C&!ZVArYpFq[[D!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDpmqD!

jnD!! 4.!4WM!I.15$R!C!.M!L0!NM!$&!.1D!<#$!$33$/&+!23!6EFj[!+0=3.9(1,!/,&2J(%$+!2%!*$/2%+&(&0&$5!#09.%!$>(5$*9(+!+088$+&!>2&$%&(.1!*21$+!(%!/0&.%$20+!(%%.&$!5$3$%+$!.%5!>.&#28$%(/!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&

,00#(".D!j[[mUZmoanVAjjjYFn[D!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZmjmmZjoD!

jrD!! <2#,.9.!WM!g.%.J.K.!�M!4#(*.J.&.!�M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjj!9$5(.&$!6EFj[!+0=3.9(1,!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%!(%!/01&0*$5!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!)(.!(%/*$.+$5!6EFjj!*$/$>&2*!$d>*$++(2%D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[[YUpYaZ[VAjmmYFooD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[[YpYnmpD!

jqD!! i0%R!4M!L21J!iM!L(&&$!HM!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%!a6EVFZYM!6EFj[!.%5!6EFjn!.*$!>*250/$5!=,!.%5!./&!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!.%5!.*$!5(+&(%/&!3*29!/1.++(/.1!6E+D!T_4&3%50/)".D!j[[qUZraZjVAYYZFZ[[nD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZq[[F[qjrDj[[qD[[rZqDdD!

jmD!! i09.*(!4M!72%%$&!W;M!'1)9.*!WgM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+(8%.1(%8!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!&*(88$*+!(%&$*1$0J(%FjnF5$>$%5$%&!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!,00#(*)9D!j[ZpUpYarVAoYYF

YZZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpDZ[D[[YD!

joD!! :�9$*!NM!g.++$1.8$*!HM!e�*=,!CEM!4&$(%(/#$!<M!<#2*%!;1.0+$%!NM!i*.8=.11$!iD!H>(5$*9.1!2)$*$d>*$++(2%!23!(%&$*1$0J(%FZY!.%5!Fj[!9:eP!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!5(+.>>$.*+!.3&$*!+#2*&F&$*9!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!/,/12+>2*(%$!.!

2*!/.1/(>2&*(21D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[[pUZjZaqVAZp[qFZZD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZrjpFZmnmDj[[pDZjqjqDdD!

jYD!! g$!WM!E(.%8!CD!6EFjn!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$A!(%!)()2!$)(5$%/$!23!2)$*1.>>(%8!30%/&(2%+!32*!6EFj[M!6EFjjM!.%5!6EFjn!

(%!&#$!$>(5$*9(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZonanVAZmYpFoD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[ZojYD!

Page 124: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 111 of 237

p[D!! 6+../+!PM!E(%5$%9.%%!ND!I(*0+!(%&$*3$*$%/$D!6D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%D!\5"+&>&M"+&S"(7&6&6*".&M+*D!ZYrmUZnmaYjmVAjroFqmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZpnqrmj[D!P//$++$5!P080+&!

jYM!j[ZnD!

pZD!! N.$/J$1!HM!;2*%=$*8!WM!L$5$9$,$*!gM!$&!.1D!<*$.&9$%&!23!./0&$!#$>.&(&(+!;!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%!.13.Fj=D!V&T(8.&

c&!%7D!j[[ZUpnraj[VAZnrjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW2.[ZZjpjD!

pjD!! C$**(112!:D!7$%$3(&+!.%5!*(+J+!23!(%&$*3$*2%!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!7D![%4/)"."89D!j[[YUnYar!40>>1VA4Z[pFZZD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl#$>DjjYrqD!

ppD!! E.!W.%&(.!EM!;.>+2%(!-D!C+2*(.+(+!50*(%8!(%&$*3$*2%!=$&.!&*$.&9$%&!32*!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!V%#5".&M+*D!

j[Z[UpZapVAppmFYD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[[mjF[[YF[ZonFdD!

pnD!! P3+#.*!WM!W.*&(%$R!.!@M!".112!:EM!g.&.!<:D!6%50/&(2%!.%5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;A!.!*$)($K!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!pq!/.+$+D!c&T#5&U+/7&3%50/)".&@%(%5%".D!j[ZpUjmaqVAmmZF

oD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqoFp[opDj[ZjD[nrojDdD!

prD!! e$+&1$!-QM!;2%*.5!;M!<0%Fi,(!PM!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!>*$5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!&#*208#!

(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[jaZVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[r[r[[D!

pqD!! <+2(!E;M!4>.(%!4EM!i%(8#&!NM!$&!.1D!65$%&(3(/.&(2%!23!Zr!%$K!>+2*(.+(+!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!12/(!#(8#1(8#&+!&#$!*21$!23!

(%%.&$!(990%(&,D!V/)&'%(%)D!j[ZjUnnaZjVAZpnZFoD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%8DjnqmD!

pmD!! 7(G19.J$*+!WFNM!i.%%$8.%&(!4iM!7.*J$*!NeM!<*$9=.&#!:;M!;.>2%!-D!-0%/&(2%.1!.%.1,+(+!23!&#$!:e-ZZn!>+2*(.+(+!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!8$%$!(9>1(/.&$+!(%%.&$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$+!&2!520=1$F+&*.%5$5!:eP!(%!5(+$.+$!

>.&#28$%$+(+D![#0&!".&'%(%)D!j[ZZUj[aZqVApZjYFpmD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl#98l55*jZrD!

poD!! g(5.!4M!Q8.+.K.*.!iM!4.&2!iM!$&!.1D!;@oaxV!<!/$11F9$5(.&$5!+J(%!5(+$.+$!(%!9(/$!1./J(%8!6:-FjM!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!.&&$%0.&2*!23!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.l=$&.!+(8%.1(%8D!,00#(*)9D!j[[[UZparVAqnpFrrD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!

#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZZZZnpmmD!

pYD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!W20*(&+!4M!I2$*9.%!N4!.M!$&!.1D!69(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$!

(+!9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaYVAropqFnrD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[jYYYD!

n[D!! L.1&$*!PM!4/#�3$*!WM!;$//2%(!IM!$&!.1D!P15.*.!./&().&$+!<E:mF(%5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!5$3$%/$D!V/)&?"00#(D!

j[ZpUnAZrq[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/299+jrqqD!

nZD!! L2#%!;M!Q=$*F71z=.09!NEM!g..J!4M!$&!.1D!E.%8$*(%a%$8V!/2%)$%&(2%.1!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!>*250/$!6EFjp!&2!5*()$!>+2*(.&(/!>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[ajqVAZ[mjpFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZp[mrqYZZ[D!

njD!! '$,.9.!PM!�.9.92&2!WM!<+0G((!iM!$&!.1D!W$/#.%(+9!23!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!(9(?0(925F(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!&#$!920+$A!.!*21$!32*!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!./&().&(2%!=,!(9(?0(925D!c&

3%50/)".D!j[ZnUnZajVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZZZZlZpnqFoZpoDZjpqmD!

npD!! 7(++2%%$&&$!:M!C.>>!iM!W..*(!;M!$&!.1D!P!*.%529(R$5M!520=1$F=1(%5M!>1./$=2F/2%&*211$5M!>#.+$!6!+&05,!23!WH@6FrnrM!.%!.%&(F(%&$*3$*2%F.13.!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,M!(%!+0=G$/&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!>+2*(.+(+D!c&U0&U+/7&3%50/)".D!j[Z[UqjapVAnjmFpqD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG..5Dj[[YD[rD[njD!

nnD!! E.%8*(+#!;EM!;#$%!�M!7109$%+/#$(%!LWM!$&!.1D!6EFjp!5*()$+!.!>.&#28$%(/!<!/$11!>2>01.&(2%!&#.&!(%50/$+!.0&2(990%$!(%31.99.&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[ZajVAjppFn[D!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[nZjrmD!

nrD!! s0!eM!O0!WM!W(R280/#(!6M!$&!.1D!\*=")/.&>".%$&"-&AF[%.4%5&ZEF>%./)%7&?9)"B*(%$:&,SFZE:&,SFDD:&/(7&,SFDX:&*(&,(-./00/)"59&3*$%/$%$DU!j[ZnD!

nqD!! -(&/#!HM!g.*>$*!HM!4J2*/#$).!6M!i0*&R!4HM!71.0)$1&!PD!C.&#2>#,+(2128,!23!>+2*(.+(+A!*$/$%&!.5).%/$+!2%!6EFjp!.%5!<#Zm!/,&2J(%$+D!?#55&>;%#0/)".&>%4D!j[[mUYaqVAnqZFmD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�joYpjjZB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

Page 125: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 112 of 237

nmD!! E$$!HM!<*$>(//#(2!LEM!Q$+&*$(/#$*!NEM!$&!.1D!6%/*$.+$5!$d>*$++(2%!23!(%&$*1$0J(%!jp!>ZY!.%5!>n[!(%!1$+(2%.1!

+J(%!23!>.&($%&+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+!)018.*(+D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[nUZYYaZVAZjrFp[D!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[p[nrZD!

noD!! C.%&$1,0+#(%!4M!g..J!4M!6%8215!7M!$&!.1D!:2*y&x!(%%.&$!1,9>#2/,&$+!.%5!y�!<!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(32*9!

>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjaqVAjjrjFqD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZoqjD!

nYD!! "02!OM!N(.%8!OM!O(.2!�M!$&!.1D!6EFZmP!+(8%.1(%8!(%!/212%(/!$>(&#$1(.1!/$11+!(%#(=(&+!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%!=,!$%#.%/(%8!&#$!./&()(&,!23!H:i!.%5!C6piD!W(R280/#(!HM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZnUYajVA$oYmZnD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[oYmZnD!

r[D!! L$5$=,$!4/#9(5&!H"M!E.*+$%!gEM!i*(+&$%+$%!eeM!$&!.1D!<gZm!/$11!(%50/&(2%!.%5!$33$/&+!23!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!=12/J.5$!(%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!/21(&(+D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!j[ZpUZYaoVAZrqmFmqD!

52(AZ[DZ[YmlW67D[=[Zp$pZojoq3.Z/D!

rZD!! W/E$.%!ECM!;*2++!:iM!4#$.F@2%2#0$!<D!;29=(%$5!=12/J.5$!23!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!9.,!>*$)$%&!&#$!

5$)$12>9$%&!23!$d>$*(9$%&.1!/21(&(+D!,00#(");%5/49D!j[ZpUraYVAYjpFrD!52(AZ[DjjZml(9&DZpDomD!

rjD!! <+$!W<D!,SFZE&U()*L"7*%$&'/*(&!"0%()#0O!e.&0*$!C0=1(+#(%8!"*20>U!j[ZnAoZrFqD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%*5nZrjD!

rpD!! �.*(1(%.!PM!6).+#J()!E7D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!%$K!>1.,$*!(%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8D!?#55&3*5&U#)"*00#(D!

j[Z[UZZAYnFZ[nD!52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[joYZYYD!

rnD!! :2+$%8*$%!4M!;2**!WM!-(*$+&$(%!"4M!72,1$!@ED!<#$!NPi!(%#(=(&2*!;CFqY[Mrr[!a&23./(&(%(=V!(%#(=(&+!<e-F(%50/$5!/#$92J(%$!$d>*$++(2%!(%!3(=*2=1.+&F1(J$!+,%2)(2/,&$+A!.0&2/*(%$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%D!U((&

>;%#0&3*$D!j[ZjUmZapVAnn[FmD!52(AZ[DZZpql.*5Dj[ZZDZr[jonD!

rrD!! g0,+!EM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!@$G.8$*!EM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!5*()$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1!+#2/JD!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[YUj[qaYVAZompFojD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[Y[jZpD!

rqD!! P%8$12&!-M!4$(11h+!HM!7((/#1X!4M!$&!.1D!H%52&#$1(.1!/$11F5$*()$5!9(/*2>.*&(/1$+!(%50/$!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!9.&0*.&(2%A!>2&$%&(.1!(9>1(/.&(2%+!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+D![/%0/)"."8*+/D!j[[YUYnaZZVAZr[jFZjD!

52(AZ[Dppjnl#.$9.&21Dj[[YD[Z[YpnD!

rmD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

roD!! N0!OM!�$%J$!WM!g.*&!@eNM!;1.*J!"ND!;@p[[.l/!*$801.&$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!.%5!<e-F.1>#.!+$/*$&(2%!=,!#09.%!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!+&(901.&$5!K(&#!<E:m!.%5!<E:Y!1(8.%5+D!6.""7D!j[[oUZZjanVAZZonFYnD!

52(AZ[DZZojl=1225Fj[[mFZjFZjmYrZD!

rYD!! @0&R!NCD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.!(%#(=(&(2%!.%5!>.192>1.%&.*!>0+&012+(+A!N.%0+F3./$5!&#$*.>,S!c&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[mUpnajVAjnmFYD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZmp[nqnqD!

q[D!! P1$J+$,$%J2!P!IM!C$*$RFC$*$R!"6M!@$!420R.!PM!$&!.1D!;2990%(&,!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!23!&#$!/0&.%$20+!

9(/*2=(2&.!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!!*+5"L*"0%D!j[ZpUZaZVApZD!52(AZ[DZZoqlj[nYFjqZoFZFpZD!

qZD!! <*()$5(!7D!W(/*2=(29$A!<#$!+0*3./$!=*(8.5$D!V/)#5%D!j[ZjUnYjamnjYVA4q[FZD!52(AZ[DZ[polnYj4q[.D!

qjD!! ;.+&$1(%2!WM!H,*$!4M!'>&2%!WM!g2!CM!7.*&2%!PD!A;%&6/+)%5*/.&MB*(&!*+5"L*"0%&*(&\$"5*/)*+&U5);5*)*$:&/(&<(%_4."5%7&S*(B&*(&\/);"8%(%$*$N&?;/..%(8%$&/(7&^44"5)#(*)*%$&^--%5%7&L9&>%+%()&A%+;("."8*+/.&U7=/(+%$OU!

j[ZnAmmmFonD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl*#$09.&2128,lJ$&pZYD!

qpD!! W.)*.8.%(!;CM!E.!@<M!4&2#1!LM!;*2K!WiD!P++2/(.&(2%!23!&#$!*$+>2%+$!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.%&.82%(+&+!K(&#!>1.+9.!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!./&()(&,!.%5!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.l.1>#.!*.&(2+!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!>.&($%&+A!.!>2+&!#2/!.%.1,+(+!23!.!>*$529(%.%&1,!g(+>.%(/!/2#2*&D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[Z[UqjajVApYjFn[ZD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DjmjjqD!

Page 126: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 113 of 237

qnD!! :.&$*9.%!g"M!I2++1.9=$*!4M!5$!:(55$*!4M!$&!.1D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!&,>$!6!+(8%.&0*$!&2K.*5+!>*$5(/&(2%!23!%2%F*$+>2%+$!&2!*(&0d(9.=!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!>.&($%&+D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[ZjUZnajVA:YrD!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*poZYD!

qrD!! i$$1$,!iM!7$11!ND!A;%&,00#("."8*+/.&6/$*$&-"5&A5%/)0%()&>%$*$)/(+%&)"&U()*FAVW&A5%/)0%()$DU!j[ZpD!

P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>All/1(%(/.1&*(.1+D82)l+#2Kle;<[ZYmZpnqD!

qqD!! "(./292%(!C'D!6*"4;9$*+/.&/(7&\;9$*"."8*+/.&T--%+)$&"-&M"./5&>/7*/)*"(&"(&[#0/(&MB*(D!a"(./292%(!C'M!

$5DVD!;.9=*(58$A!:2,.1!42/($&,!23!;#$9(+&*,U!j[[mD!52(AZ[DZ[pYlYmoZonmrrmYrmD!

qmD!! g.(8!@WM!g0&/#(+2%!"M!"*$$%!6M!4.*8.%!@M!:$(5!gLD!<#$!H33$/&!23!6%&*.5$*9.1!6%G$/&(2%!23!"WF;4-!.%5!<e-Fv!2%!&#$!P//0901.&(2%!23!@$%5*(&(/!;$11+!(%!Q)(%$!4J(%D!@%)&3%50/)".D!j[[oUqanVAjZZFjj[D!

52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFpZqnDZYYrD&=[[[qmDdD!

qoD!! P%&2%2>2012+!;M!;09=$*=.&/#!WM!@$.*9.%!:NM!@.%($1!:NM!i(9=$*!6M!"*2)$+!:LD!W#(+)*"(/.&?/$4/$%FZ&,$&>%d#*5%7&-"5&S/(8%5;/($&?%..&!*85/)*"(&/(7&^4)*0/.&?"()/+)&M%($*)*f/)*"(&*(&!*+%D!P9$*(/.%!P++2/(.&(2%!23!

6990%2128(+&+U!j[[ZApqmjFpqmmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZqqDqDpqmjD!

qYD!! ;#2!iFPM!40#!NLM!E$$!igM!i.%8!NEM!L22!4F�D!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjj!$%#.%/$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!=,!+&(901.&(%8!&#$!+$/*$&(2%!23!6EFZu!=,!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!)(.!&#$!:Q4FeE:CpF/.+>.+$FZ!>.&#K.,D!,()&,00#(".D!j[ZjUjnapVAZnmF

roD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%&(99l5d*ZZ[D!

m[D!! W.(2%$!-M!C.+/#.1(5(+!eM!W.+/212!eM!@03&2%!eM!C$**$&&(!WM!@cP/?0(+&2!-D!6%&$*1$0J(%!Zm!+0+&.(%+!*.&#$*!

&#.%!(%50/$+!(%31.99.&(2%D!6*"+;%0&\;/50/+".D!j[[YUmmarVAomoFomD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD=/>Dj[[oDZZD[ZZD!

mZD!! P1=.%$+(!;M!4/.*>2%(!;M!;.).%(!PM!-$5$*(/(!WM!e.+2**(!-M!"(*21292%(!"D!6%&$*1$0J(%FZm!(+!>*250/$5!=,!=2&#!<#Z!.%5!<#j!1,9>#2/,&$+M!.%5!92501.&$+!(%&$*3$*2%F8.99.F!.%5!(%&$*1$0J(%FnF(%50/$5!./&().&(2%!23!

#09.%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[[[UZZraZVAoZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[nqlGDZrjpFZmnmDj[[[D[[[nZDdD!

mjD!! "*(33(%!"iM!e$K&2%!"M!<.**(2!WEM!$&!.1D!6EFZm!.%5!<e-Fv!+0+&.(%!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&!50*(%8!(%31.99.&(2%!&#*208#!+,%$*8(+&(/!$33$/&+!2%!$%52&#$1(.1!./&().&(2%D!c&,00#(".D!j[ZjUZooaZjVAqjomFYYD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZj[[porD!

mpD!! L.%8!;s-M!PJ.10!�<M!40.*$RF-.*(%.+!WM!$&!.1D!6EFZm!.%5!<e-!+,%$*8(+&(/.11,!92501.&$!/,&2J(%$!$d>*$++(2%!K#(1$!+0>>*$++(%8!9$1.%28$%$+(+A!>2&$%&(.1!*$1$).%/$!&2!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!

j[ZpUZppaZjVAjmnZFrjD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZpDjpmD!

mnD!! :055,!WNM!4#$%!-M!49(&#!N7M!4#.*9.!PM!".33$%!4ED!6%&$*1$0J(%FZm!*$801.&$+!$d>*$++(2%!23!&#$!;O;!/#$92J(%$!E6Ol;O;Er!(%!2+&$2=1.+&+A!(9>1(/.&(2%+!32*!(%31.99.&(2%!.%5!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&D!c&S%#B"+&

6*".D!j[[nUmqaZVAZprFnnD!52(AZ[DZZoYlG1=D[j[n[qrD!

mrD!! e2%.J.!WM!Q8(#.*.!eM!-0J092&2!PM!$&!.1D!M9(%58*$)*+&,(7#+)*"(&"-&!/+5"4;/8%&,(-./00/)"59&\5")%*(FXlk`??SDG&\5"7#+)*"(&L9&,()%5.%#B*(FZEU&/(7&A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5Fhk&*(&V/$/.&\".94&W*L5"L./$)$OU!

j[[YAjZoFjpD!52(AZ[DZ[YmlLQOD[=[Zp$pZoZ=55jZYD!

mqD!! 6,25.!WM!4#(=.&.!<M!i.K.80/#(!WM!$&!.1D!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!+&(901.&$!/#$92J(%$+!)(.!WPCi!>.&#K.,+!aH:iZlj!.%5!>po!=0&!%2&!NeiV!(%!920+$!/01&0*$5!9$+.%8(.1!/$11+A!+,%$*8,!K(&#!<e-F.1>#.!.%5!6EFZ=$&.D!

U0&c&\;9$*".&>%(/.&\;9$*".D!j[Z[UjYoapVA-mmYFomD!52(AZ[DZZrjl.G>*$%.1D[[ZYoDj[[YD!

mmD!! i2$%5$*+!W6M!W.*(G%(++$%!:NM!@$)$+.!6M!$&!.1D!A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5F,()%5.%#B*(FZE&,()%54./9&,(7#+%$&MZGGUR:&,()%5.%#B*(FZm:&/(7&!/)5*_&!%)/.."45")%*(/$%$:&/(7&35*=%$&,55%=%5$*L.%&?/5)*./8%&3%$)5#+)*"(&*(&

!#5*(%&U5);5*)*$N&>/)*"(/.%&-"5&?"0L*(/)*"(&A5%/)0%()&7#5*(8&U5);5*)*$OU!j[ZZAjpjYFpYD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&Dp[nZoD!

moD!! W2+$!WM!i.%8!�M!:..=,!EM!6)$*+$%!EM!N2#.%+$%!;D!<e-vF!.%5!6EFZmPF9$5(.&$5!4Z[[Po!$d>*$++(2%!(+!

*$801.&$5!=,!>po!WPCiD!T_4&3%50/)".D!j[ZpUjjamVAnmqFoZD!52(AZ[DZZZZl$d5DZjZomD!

Page 127: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 114 of 237

mYD!! @2%$&&(!HM!;2*%.8#(!EM!"0.1$*R(!PM!7.*033.15(!C*$(+!-LM!C*(8%.%2!-D!P%!(%%2).&()$!&#*$$F5(9$%+(2%.1!925$1!23!%2*9.1!#09.%!+J(%!&2!+&05,!&#$!>*2(%31.99.&2*,!>+2*(.&(/!$33$/&+!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F

.1>#.!.%5!(%&$*1$0J(%FZmD!?9)"B*(%D!j[ZnUqoaZVAZFoD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&2Dj[ZnD[pD[[pD!

o[D!! ;2).8$%D!;2).8$%!6%(&(.&$+!C#.+$!6=l66.!4&05,!23!7(+>$/(3(/!.%&(F<e-l6EFZmP!-,%29P=!;QIPpjjD!>%#)%5$D!#&&>All/2).8$%D/29l/2).8$%F(%(&(.&$+F>#.+$F(=((.F+&05,F=(+>$/(3(/F.%&(F&%3(1FZm.F3,%29.=F/2).pjjlD!

C0=1(+#$5!W.,!j[ZnD!P//$++$5!W.,!YM!j[ZnD!

oZD!! E2/J!;M!g$*9.%+!"M!C$52&&(!:M!$&!.1D!"$%$F9(/*2.**.,!.%.1,+(+!23!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!1$+(2%+!,($15+!%$K!&.*8$&+!).1(5.&$5!(%!.0&2(990%$!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+D!V/)&!%7D!j[[jUoarVAr[[FoD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%9[r[jF

r[[D!

ojD!! <R.*&2+!N4M!-*($+$!WPM!;*.%$*!WNM!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%FZm!>*250/&(2%!(%!/$%&*.1!%$*)20+!+,+&$9F(%3(1&*.&(%8!<!/$11+!.%5!81(.1!/$11+!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!./&()$!5(+$.+$!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!U0&c&\/);".D!j[[oUZmjaZVAZnqF

rrD!52(AZ[Djprpl.G>.&#Dj[[oD[m[qY[D!

opD!! 7*0/J1./#$*FL.15$*&!IM!4&0$*%$*!iM!i21+&$*!WM!L21&#.0+$%!NM!<212+.!HD!C#$%2&,>(/.1!.%5!30%/&(2%.1!/#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!<!#$1>$*!Zm!/$11+!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!65/*(D!j[[YUZpjaC&!ZjVAppjYFnZD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl=*.(%l.K>joYD!

onD!! i2+&(/!WM!@R2>.1(/!<M!�().%2)(/!4M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!.%5!810&.9.&$!$d/(&2&2d(/(&,!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!M+/(7&c&,00#(".D!j[ZnUmYapVAZoZFqD!52(AZ[DZZZZl+G(DZjZnmD!

orD!! W.&0+$)(/(0+!@M!i()(+�JJ!CM!g$!7M!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%FZm!9:eP!$d>*$++(2%!(%!=1225!.%5!;4-!92%2%0/1$.*!/$11+!(+!.089$%&$5!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!!#.)&M+.%5D!ZYYYUrajVAZ[ZFnD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD%/=(D%19D%(#D82)l>0=9$5lZ[pprrZoD!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

oqD!! W0*08.(,.%!"M!W(&&.1!PM!E2>$RF@($82!:M!W.($*!EWM!P%5$*+2%!@HM!L$(%$*!gED!6EFjm!(+!.!J$,!*$801.&2*!23!6EFZ[!.%5!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%!=,!#09.%!;@nx!<!/$11+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZopanVAjnprFnpD!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[[rqoD!

omD!! "0!�M!�.%8!NM!Q0,.%8!OM!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%!Z[!+0>>*$++$+!<#Zm!/,&2J(%$+!+$/*$&$5!=,!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!<!

/$11+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[[oUpoamVAZo[mFZpD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[[opoppZD!

ooD!! �#.%8!OM!W.*J2)(/FC1$+$!4D!6%&$*3$*2%!=$&.!(%#(=(&+!&#$!<#Zm!/$11F9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!*$+>2%+$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!?.*(&V%#5".&V%#5"$#58D!j[Z[UZZjamVAqnZFrD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/1(%$0*2Dj[Z[D[nD[j[D!

oYD!! P1$d.%5$*!N4M!g.**(+!WiM!L$11+!4:M!$&!.1D!U.)%5/)*"($&*(&M%5#0&!!\FR:&!!\FC:&,SFZD4YG&/(7&,SFDX&*(&!#.)*4.%&M+.%5"$*$&\/)*%()$&A5%/)%7&J*);&,()%5-%5"(FL%)/ZLOU!j[Z[Ao[ZFYD!

52(AZ[DZZmmlZprjnrorZ[pm[mYZD!

Y[D!! Pd&$11!:;M!5$!N2%8!7!.M!72%(3./$!iM!$&!.1D!<!#$1>$*!&,>$!Z!.%5!Zm!/$11+!5$&$*9(%$!$33(/./,!23!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!.%5!$d>$*(9$%&.1!$%/$>#.129,$1(&(+D!V/)&!%7D!j[Z[UZqanVAn[qFZjD!

52(AZ[DZ[pol%9DjZZ[D!

YZD!! 7�1.�.!:M!7.GJ2!�M!g0 .%0!PD!4$*09!1$)$1+!23!6EFZmP!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!

&*$.&$5!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%FuD!!#.)&M+.%5D!j[ZpUZYamVAoorFY[D!52(AZ[DZZmmlZprjnrorZjnqonYmD!

YjD!! :�/R!HM!C*$%+!HCM!i0*$J!@M!$&!.1D!H33$/&()$!&*$.&9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!%.**2KF=.%5!'I7!>#2&2&#$*.>,!(+!1(%J$5!&2!+0>>*$++(2%!23!&#$!6-e!.%5!<#Zm!>.&#K.,+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZZUZpZamVAZrnmFroD!

52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDrpD!

YpD!! "*$82*(2!NM!W$11$*!4M!;2%*.5!;M!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!+$%+$!+J(%!(%G0*,!.%5!>*292&$!K20%5!

#$.1(%8!&#*208#!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[Z[Uj[maZpVAjYjZFp[D!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[Z[ZZ[jD!

YnD!! <2#,.9.!WM!�.%8!EM!g.%.J.K.!�M!@.(!OM!4#(*.J.&.!�M!4.,.9.!iD!6-eFv!$%#.%/$+!6EFjj!*$/$>&2*!$d>*$++(2%!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+A!.!>2++(=1$!*21$!(%!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZjUZpjamVAZYppFrD!

52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDnqoD!

Page 128: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 115 of 237

YrD!! "0(112&$.0!iM!C.*(+!6M!C$5*$&&(!eM!$&!.1D!4J(%!6%31.99.&(2%!6%50/$5!=,!&#$!4,%$*8(+&(/!P/&(2%!23!6EFZmPM!6EFjjM!Q%/2+&.&(%!WM!6EFZ�.1>#.�M!.%5!<e-F�.1>#.�!:$/.>(&01.&$+!429$!-$.&0*$+!23!C+2*(.+(+D!c&,00#(".D!

j[Z[D!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[jnqnD!

YqD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!).%!5$*!L$1!E6M!E.9.%!N@M!C*$%+!HCM!I$*+/#0*$%!W;WD!6%!>+2*(.+(+!1$+(2%.1!+J(%!&#$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,!(+!./&().&$5M!K#$*$.+!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!+$%+(&()(&,!(+!0%.1&$*$5D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!j[[nUZjjaZVArZFq[D!52(AZ[DZ[nqlGD[[jjFj[jODj[[pDjjZZpDdD!

YmD!! ;#*(+&2>#$*+!HM!W$&R1$*!"M!:z/J$%!WD!7(925.1!(990%$!./&().&(2%!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!65&c&3%50/)".D!

j[ZnUZm[aZVArYFqrD!52(AZ[DZZZZl=G5DZjqpZD!

YoD!! W20%&R!N@M!L.%8!NgM!O($!4M!g+0!gF;D!;,&2J(%$!*$801.&(2%!23!7F/$11!9(8*.&2*,!=$#.)(2*!3.)2*+!32*9.&(2%!23!8$*9(%.1!/$%&$*+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$D!3*$+"=&!%7D!j[ZZUZZarqVAmqForD!P).(1.=1$!.&A!#&&>AllKKKD>0=9$5/$%&*.1D%(#D82)l.*&(/1$*$%5$*D3/8(S.*&(5�pjnYnZoB&221�>9/$%&*$RB*$%5$*&,>$�.=

+&*./&D!P//$++$5!P080+&!p[M!j[ZnD!

YYD!! ".112!HM!;.=.1$(*2!<M!:29�%!WM!$&!.1D!<#$!*$1.&(2%+#(>!=$&K$$%!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-VFv!>*292&$*!.%5!6EZj7l6EFjp:!8$%$+!>21,92*>#(+9+!.%5!&#$!$33(/./,!23!.%&(F<e-Fv!&#$*.>,!(%!>+2*(.+(+A!.!/.+$F/2%&*21!+&05,D!65&c&3%50/)".D!j[ZpUZqYanVAoZYFjYD!52(AZ[DZZZZl=G5DZjnjrD!!

Page 129: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 116 of 237

!"#$%&'())(F!!"#$(

?4"3=(45(26%(:*4T%"2(

<e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! =2&#! >1$(2&*2>(/! /,&2J(%$+M! K#(/#! #.)$! =$$%! .&&*(=0&$5! >*2F

(%31.99.&2*,!./&(2%+! (%!./0&$!.%5!/#*2%(/!5(+$.+$+D!<e-! (+!92+&1,!J%2K%! 32*! (&+!9$5(.&2*,!

*21$!(%!&#$!9.(%&$%.%/$!23!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!&#$!0+$!23!

<e-!.%&.82%(+&+!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M!.%J,12+(%8!+>2%5,1(&(+!.%5!>+2*(.+(+D!

'%32*&0%.&$1,M! +29$! >.&($%&+! 52! %2&! *$+>2%5! &2! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-! .%5! 2&#$*! >.&($%&+!

+033$*!3*29!+(5$!$33$/&+!+0/#!.+!(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!(%3$/&(2%+!2*!$)$%!7%&("="!(%50/&(2%!

23! 2&#$*! .0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D! <#(+! *$+&*.(%+! &#$! 0+$! 23! <e-! (%#(=(&(2%! .%5! 0%5$*1(%$+! 20*!

1(9(&$5! /29>*$#$%+(2%! 23! &#$! ./&(2%+! 23! <e-! (%! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+D! W2*$2)$*M! .1&#208#!

<e-! (+!J%2K%! 32*! (&+!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!./&(2%+M!K$!52!%2&! 3011,!0%5$*+&.%5! (&+! *21$! (%!./0&$!

(%31.99.&(2%!.+!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!3.(1$5!&2!>*2&$/&!(%!46:4!.%5!+$>+(+!>.&($%&+D!4(9(1.*1,M!20*!

0%5$*+&.%5(%8!23!&#$!&,>$!6!6-e+!(+!*$+&*.(%$5!.1&#208#!&#$(*!0+$!(+!K(5$+>*$.5!(%!&#$!/1(%(/D!

<,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! 0+$5! (%! &#$! /29=.&! 23! /#*2%(/! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+! +0/#! .+! g$>.&(&(+! ;M! =0&! .*$!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!.+!K$11D!P%5!1(J$!<e-M!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!

.1+2!+$$9!&2!>1.,!.!50.1!*21$!(%!+#2/J!+,%5*29$+D!W2*$2)$*M!(&!#.+!=$$%!+>$/01.&$5!&#.&!=2&#!

+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,+!9.,!(%&$*./&!.%5!.33$/&!2%$!.%2&#$*M!K#(/#!9.,!(%310$%/$!&#$!20&/29$!(%!

./0&$! .%5! /#*2%(/! (%31.99.&(2%D! <#(+! *.(+$5! 20*! (%&$*$+&! (%! &#$! (%&(9.&$! (%&$*>1.,! =$&K$$%!

<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M!K#(/#! (+! &#$!=.+(+! 32*! &#(+! &#$+(+D!L$!#,>2&#$+(R$! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!.*$!

(9>1(/.&$5! (%! &#$! (%$33(/./,! 23! <e-! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! (%! %2%F*$+>2%5$*+! .%5! #$%/$M! .%&(F<e-!

*$+(+&.%&!>.&($%&+!9.,!=$%$3(&!3*29!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!L$!+088$+&!&#.&!(%#(=(&(2%!23!

=2&#! >.&#K.,+!9.,! 1$.5! &2! 12K$*! 52+$! &*$.&9$%&M! +(901&.%$20+1,! 12K$*(%8! .++2/(.&$5! +(5$!

Page 130: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 117 of 237

$33$/&+D!<#$+$!.*809$%&+!32*9$5!&#$!*.&(2%.1$!&2!+&05,!&#$!$33(/./,!23!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-!

.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!(%31.99.&(2%D!

<#$!.(9+!23!&#(+!&#$+(+!/.%!=$!5()(5$5!(%!320*!>.*&+D!

-(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%(*48%(45(2):%(;(;?>=('<(9>?/'<$3"%$(

=64"J(

<#$*$!#.+!=$$%!+29$!(%&$*$+&!(%!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!32*!.!K#(1$D!W2+&!

5.&.!*$+01&+!3*29!*(&=*)5"!$d>$*(9$%&+!K#$*$!<e-!(%50/$+!6-eu!>*250/&(2%!(%!9./*2>#.8$+Z!

.%5!(%!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+M!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!K$*$!*$?0(*$5!32*!&,>$!6!6-e!(%50/&(2%jD!6:-Z!

K.+!320%5!&2!=$!&#$!/$%&*.1!*$801.&2*!23!<e-F(%50/$5!6-euD!,(&=*="!(%50/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!=,!

<e-!#.+!%2&!=$$%!(%)$+&(8.&$5!(%!5$&.(1M!.1&#208#!+29$!$)(5$%/$!+088$+&+!&#.&!&#(+!9.,!#.)$!

+$*(20+! (9>1(/.&(2%+! 50*(%8! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&M! .+! <e-! K2015! %2&! =$! .=1$! &2! +&(901.&$!

.>>*2>*(.&$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! >*250/&(2%! .%,92*$DpMn! W./*2>#.8$+! +&(901.&$5! *(& =*)5"! K(&#! <e-!

+$/*$&$!&,>$!6!6-e+M!=0&!(&!*$9.(%+!0%/1$.*!K#$*$!&,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!>*250/$5!$d./&1,!(%!&#$!=25,!

.3&$*!<e-!+&(901.&(2%D!W2*$2)$*M!K$!K2%5$*!K#.&!*21$!&#$+$!(%50/$5!&,>$!6!6-e+!9.,!>1.,!(%!

<e-!&2d(/(&,S!P1&#208#!g0,+!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!.!>*2&$/&()$!>#$%2&,>$!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!6-eu!

iQ!9(/$! (%! .! 1$&#.1! <e-!925$1! .//29>.%($5! K(&#! *$50/$5! >*250/&(2%! 23! /#$92J(%$+! .%5!

K#(&$! =1225! /$11! (%3(1&*.&(2%rU! &#$! $d./&! 9$/#.%(+9! *$9.(%+! &2! =$! $10/(5.&$5D! P*$! *$50/$5!

1$)$1+! 23! /#$92J(%$+! .%5!K#(&$!=1225! /$11+! +033(/($%&! &2! *$9.(%!=$12K! &#$! 1$&#.1! &#*$+#215S!

<e-! (%50/$+! 5.9.8$! (%! ).*(20+! 2*8.%+M! K#(/#! (+! 5$/*$.+$5! (%! 6-eP:Z! iQM! =0&! K$! .(9! &2!

$d>12*$!&#$!>2++(=(1(&,!&#.&!+>$/(3(/!&(++0$+!2*!2*8.%+!5$&$*9(%$!K#$&#$*!<e-!(+!1$&#.1!&#*208#!

6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8D!6%!&#(+!>.*&!23!&#$!&#$+(+M!K$!.(9!&2!+#$5!1(8#&!2%!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!

6-e+!.3&$*!<e-!.%5!2%!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!&#$!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,!(%!<e-!=,!0+(%8!3011!

.%5!/2%5(&(2%.1!6-eP:Z!iQ!&2!*$)$.1!#2K!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%310$%/$!<e-F(%50/$5!(%31.99.&(2%D!

>%$#.)&$%+)*"(&ZN&AVWF,(7#+%7&A94%&,&,WV$&?"()5".&M%+5%)*"(&"-&,SFZE&

Page 131: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 118 of 237

+(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(

9>?('<(=64"J(=)<$*4&%=(

P1&#208#! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-! 5(5! %2&! +0//$$5! (%! #09.%! /1(%(/.1! &*(.1+! 32*! /*(&(/.11,! (11!

>.&($%&+M! &#$! (%&$*$+&! &2! 0%5$*+&.%5! #2K! <e-! /2%&*(=0&$+! &2! +#2/J! +,%5*29$+! *$9.(%+D! P!

+(9>1$!925$1!&2!9(9(/!+#2/J!(%!9(/$!(+!&#$!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!EC4M!.!<E:n!.82%(+&!&#.&!(%50/$+!

&#$!&,>(/.1!/#.*./&$*(+&(/+!23!.!"*.9F%$8.&()$!=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%!K(&#20&!&#$!./&0.1!(%3$/&(20+!

.8$%&D! 72&#! <e-! .%5! <e-:Z! iQ! 9(/$! .*$! *$+(+&.%&! &2! EC4U! .%5! 6-eP:Z! #.+! .1+2! =$$%!

.>>2(%&$5!.%! (%31.99.&(2%F9$5(.&(%8!*21$! (%!EC4F(%50/$5!+#2/JDqwY!<#208#! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!.%5!

<e-! >1.,! >*29(%$%&! *21$+! (%! +#2/J! +,%5*29$+M! &#$(*! (%&$*./&(2%! #.+! %2&! =$$%! &#2*208#1,!

(%)$+&(8.&$5D! 6&! #.+! .1*$.5,! =$$%! 5$92%+&*.&$5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! /.%! 9$5(.&$! <e-F

(%50/$5! (%31.99.&(2%M! (%5(/.&(%8! .! 5(*$/&! /*2++&.1J! =$&K$$%! =2&#! >.&#K.,+Dr! L$! .(9! &2!

(%)$+&(8.&$!K#$&#$*!=2&#!>.&#K.,+!9.,!*$(%32*/$!$./#!2&#$*!&2!$%#.%/$!EC4F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,M!

+088$+&(%8!&#.&!50.1!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!9.,!*$>*$+$%&!.!%2)$1!+&*.&$8,!(%!

"*.9F%$8.&()$!(%3$/&(2%+D!

>%$#.)& $%+)*"(& DN& !"#$%&' (&)*+*&,+-' *,' ./0' 1,(' 2-3&' 4' 40/' 5*6,1%*,6' %&1(5' 2"' &,71,+&('

!"#$%&$'#()'()%(*#$#+%,'-&

X(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(

9>?('<(:=4*'#='=(

E#*2(XY-(;=(26%*%(#("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(9>?(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=('<(#324'&&3<%(

$'=%#=%=c((

P0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!>2+$!.!#$.),!=0*5$%!2%!>.&($%&+!=,!(9>$5(%8!&#$(*!92=(1(&,!.%5!+2/(.1!

1(3$D!P1&#208#!9.%,!&*$.&9$%&+!.*$!.).(1.=1$M!&#$*$!.*$!%2!/0*$+D!W2*$2)$*M!23&$%!>.&($%&+!52!

%2&! *$+>2%5! &2! &#$! /0**$%&! &*$.&9$%&+! 2*! +033$*! 3*29! +(5$! $33$/&+M! 9.J(%8! &#$! /#2(/$! 23!

Page 132: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 119 of 237

&*$.&9$%&!)$*,!5(33(/01&D! 6%!.55(&(2%M!&#$!+0=+$?0$%&!/2+&+!23!&#$!&*$.&9$%&+!23!&#$+$!/#*2%(/!

5(+$.+$+!.*$!)$*,!#(8#!.%5!&#$!%$$5!32*!>*$5(/&()$!=(29.*J$*+!.%5!92*$!$33$/&()$!&*$.&9$%&+!

.*$! 0*8$%&D! '%32*&0%.&$1,M! 20*! 0%5$*+&.%5(%8! 23! .0&2(990%(&,! (+! 1(9(&$5! &2! .55*$++! &#$+$!

9.&&$*+D! 6%! 20*! 8*20>M! K$! .(9! &2! 0%5$*+&.%5! K#$&#$*! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! (+! .%!

.1&$*%.&()$!&2!<e-!(%#(=(&(2%!.%5!+(901&.%$20+1,M!0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!

(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!K#$*$!<e-!>1.,+!.!9.G2*!*21$D!C+2*(.+(+!>2+$+!.%!(%&$*$+&(%8!&2>(/!(%!

&#(+!9.&&$*M!+(%/$!=2&#!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!Hd/$++!1$)$1+!23!<e-!

.*$! 320%5!(%!>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+!.%5!>.*.52d(/.11,!/.%! (%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-!(%!+29$!>.&($%&+!K(&#!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!1$.5!&2!7%&("="!(%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+DZ[w

Zj! 4(9(1.*1,M! .%! (%/*$.+$5! 64:H! +(8%.&0*$! /.%! =$! 320%5! (%! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! +0/#! .+! WdPM!

9.*J(%8! &#$! ./&().&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! &#$+$! 1$+(2%+DZpMZn!W2*$2)$*M! &*$.&9$%&!K(&#! &,>$! 6!

6-e+! #.+! 1$5! &2! &#$! 5$)$12>9$%&! 23! 7%& ("="! >+2*(.&(/! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! (%! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! 32*!

901&(>1$! +/1$*2+(+! 2*! #$>.&(&(+! ;DZrwZm! 6%! &#(+! &#$+(+M! K$! K(11! .55*$++! &#$! (%&$*>1.,! =$&K$$%!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!0+(%8!&#$!P15.*.!925$1!32*!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!.%5!

$).10.&$!&#$!>2&$%/,!23!+(901&.%$20+!&.*8$&(%8!23!=2&#!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,+D!

>%$#.)&$%+)*"(&XOZN&!"#$%&'(&)&*&+'%+,%-./01%!"#$%&'()*$+"$+,+-.+,/#F!"#$%&#'()*+!,)!!"#$%

!"#$%#$&'())(*#+$%#$%)#,-&

XY+(S4K(%55%"2'M%('=(#"2'M#2'4<(G)(!8$#*#N("4<2#'<'<Q(26%(9C7\(#Q4<'=2(;@dN(#=(

%H:%*'&%<2#8(&4$%8(54*(:=4*'#='=('<(&'"%c((

C+2*(.+(+! (+! .! /29>1$d! 5(+$.+$! &#.&! %2&! 2%1,! .33$/&+! &#$! +J(%M! =0&! .1+2! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#!

(%/*$.+$5! /292*=(5(&($+! +0/#! .+!5(.=$&$+M! /.*5(2).+/01.*!5(+$.+$+M!9$&.=21(/! +,%5*29$!.%5!

%$0*2>+,/#(.&*(/! 5(+2*5$*+! &#208#! &#$! $d./&! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23! >+2*(.+(+! (+! (%/29>1$&$1,!

0%5$*+&225DZowjZ!W2+&!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+!0+$5!&2!9(9(/!>+2*(.+(+! 32/0+!$d/10+()$1,!2%!&#$!

+J(%! >#$%2&,>$M! (8%2*(%8! K#$&#$*! /292*=(5(&($+! .*(+$! (%! &#$! 90*(%$! 925$1D! P15.*.! (+!

(%/*$.+(%81,!=$(%8!0+$5!.+!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1!&2!(%50/$!>+2*(.+(32*9!1$+(2%+!(%!9(/$M!=0&!

Page 133: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 120 of 237

2%/$!92*$M!+&05($+!2%1,!32/0+!2%!&#$!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!&#$!+J(%DjjMjp!L$!.(9!&2!$).10.&$!P15.*.!

.+! .! >+2*(.+(+F1(J$! 925$1! =,! +&05,(%8! >2&$%&(.1! 233F&.*8$&! $33$/&+! =,! &2>(/.1! .>>1(/.&(2%! 23!

P15.*.D!

>%$#.)&$%+)*"(&XODN&!"#"$%"&%&' #"(%)$#*"'*+' !"#$%&'( $)$*+$)",( $-(./#.0$).-!&'(#1"0$&1$1F!"#$%

!"#$%#$&'())(*#+$!!"#$%&'($)'%*+,%&

! (

Page 134: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 121 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! �.*(1(%.!PM!6).+#J()!E7D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!%$K!>1.,$*!(%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8D!?#55&3*5&U#)"*00#(D!j[Z[UZZAYnFZ[nD!52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[joYZYYD!

jD!! I$%J.&$+#!@M!H*%.%5$R!<M!:2+$&&(!-M!$&!.1D!H%52&#$1(.1!<e-!*$/$>&2*!j!(%50/$+!6:-Z!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*F5$>$%5$%&!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!.0&2/*(%$!+(8%.1(%8!&2!>*292&$!92%2/,&$!*$/*0(&9$%&D!,00#(*)9D!

j[ZpUpoarVAZ[jrFpmD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpD[ZD[ZjD!

pD!! ;.%&.$*&!<M!7.$&$%!@M!<.J!CCM!).%!7..*+$%!E"WD!<,>$!6!6-e!.%5!<e-v!/*2++F*$801.&(2%!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$A!=.+(/!/2%/$>&+!.%5!/1(%(/.1!*$1$).%/$D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[Z[UZjarVAjZYD!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*pZr[D!

nD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

rD!! g0,+!EM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!@$G.8$*!EM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!5*()$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1!+#2/JD!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[YUj[qaYVAZompFojD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[Y[jZpD!

qD!! i.*.8#(2+233!WM!4&$(%=2*%!:M!i2).*(J!CM!$&!.1D!;$%&*.1!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!<,Jj!(%!

1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F(%50/$5!$%52&2d(%!+#2/JD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[[pUnarVAnmZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(YZ[D!

mD!! W.#($0!<M!C.*J!NWM!:$)$&+!gM!$&!.1D!<#$!K(15F5$*()$5!(%=*$5!920+$!+&*.(%!4C:H<lH(!(+!*$+(+&.%&!&2!EC4!.%5!5$3$/&()$!(%!6-eF=$&.!>*250/&(2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[qUZ[pamVAjjYjFmD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[rZ[omnZ[pD!

oD!! :2&#$!NM!E$++1.0$*!LM!Ez&+/#$*!gM!$&!.1D!W(/$!1./J(%8!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!.*$!*$+(+&.%&!&2!<e-F9$5(.&$5!&2d(/(&,!=0&!#(8#1,!+0+/$>&(=1$!&2!(%3$/&(2%!=,!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+D!V/)#5%D!

ZYYpUpqnaqnn[VAmYoFo[jD!52(AZ[DZ[polpqnmYo.[D!

YD!! C3$33$*!iM!W.&+0,.9.!<M!if%5(8!<WM!$&!.1D!W(/$!5$3(/($%&!32*!&#$!rr!J5!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!.*$!

*$+(+&.%&!&2!$%52&2d(/!+#2/JM!,$&!+0//09=!&2!ED!92%2/,&28$%$+!(%3$/&(2%D!?%..D!ZYYpUmpapVAnrmFqmD!

Z[D!! i*(+&$%+$%!WM!;#0!;sM!H$5,!@NM!-$159.%%!WM!7*$%%.%!-WM!7*$.&#%./#!4WD!E2/.1(R.&(2%!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!a<e-F.1>#.V!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!(%!%2*9.1!.%5!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%A!$>(5$*9.1!/$11+!$d>*$++!&#$!rrF

J@!=0&!%2&!&#$!mrFJ@!<e-!*$/$>&2*D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!ZYYpUYnajVAprnFqjD!

ZZD!! 6=2**.!WM!7$1&*�%!7M!7.+&(5.!"M!P80.+!WM!e2+!CD!6%31(d(9.=!.%5!.5.1(909.=F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$A!.!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&D!c&?5";($&?".*)*$D!j[ZZUrajVAZrmFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/*2#%+Dj[Z[DZZD[[ZD!

ZjD!! 7.*&#$1!;M!7($5$*9.%%!EM!-*$(!CM!$&!.1D!6%50/&(2%!2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!0%5$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.%&(=25($+D!3*8%$)*"(D!j[ZnUoYapVAj[YFZrD!

52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[projooD!

ZpD!! "(11($&!WM!;2%*.5!;M!"$(8$+!WM!$&!.1D!C+2*(.+(+!&*(88$*$5!=,!&211F1(J$!*$/$>&2*!m!.82%(+&!(9(?0(925!(%!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!5$*9.1!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!>*$/0*+2*+D!U5+;&3%50/)".D!j[[nUZn[aZjVAZnY[FrD!

52(AZ[DZ[[Zl.*/#5$*9DZn[DZjDZnY[D!

ZnD!! e$+&1$!-QM!;2%*.5!;M!<0%Fi,(!PM!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!>*$5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!&#*208#!

(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[jaZVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[r[r[[D!

ZrD!! E.!W.%&(.!EM!;.>+2%(!-D!C+2*(.+(+!50*(%8!(%&$*3$*2%!=$&.!&*$.&9$%&!32*!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!V%#5".&M+*D!

j[Z[UpZapVAppmFYD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Z[[mjF[[YF[ZonFdD!

Page 135: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 122 of 237

ZqD!! P3+#.*!WM!W.*&(%$R!P@M!".112!:EM!g.&.!<:D!6%50/&(2%!.%5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;A!.!*$)($K!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!pq!/.+$+D!c&T#5&U+/7&3%50/)".&@%(%5%".D!j[ZpUjmaqVAmmZF

oD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqoFp[opDj[ZjD[nrojDdD!

ZmD!! @2K%+!PWM!@0%%(11!W"D!Hd./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;D!?.*(&T_4&

3%50/)".D!j[[[UjranVAprZFjD!

ZoD!! "2&&1($=!P7M!;#.2!;M!@.%%!-D!C+2*(.+(+!/292*=(5(&($+D!c&3%50/)"."8&A5%/)D!j[[oUZYaZVArFjZD!

52(AZ[DZ[o[l[Yrnqqp[m[ZpqnmqoD!

ZYD!! e(G+&$%!<M!L.JJ$$!WD!;29>1$d(&,!23!&#$!.++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!/292*=(5(&($+D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!j[[YUZjYamVAZq[ZFpD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[[YDrrD!

j[D!! e(!;M!;#(0!WLD!C+2*(.+(+!.%5!/292*=(5(&($+A!1(%J+!.%5!*(+J+D!?.*(&?"$0%)&,(=%$)*8&3%50/)".D!j[ZnUmAZZYF

pjD!52(AZ[DjZnml;;6@D4nnonpD!

jZD!! "*2R5$)!6M!i2*9.%!eM!<+.%J2)!eD!C+2*(.+(+!.+!.!+,+&$9(/!5(+$.+$D!?.*(&3%50/)".D!j[ZnUpjapVApnpFr[D!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/1(%5$*9.&21Dj[ZpDZZD[[ZD!

jjD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!W20*(&+!4M!I2$*9.%!N4!.M!$&!.1D!69(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$!

(+!9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaYVAropqFnrD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[jYYYD!

jpD!! -10&&$*!7M!e$+&1$!-QD!<E:+!&2!/,&2J(%$+A!9$/#.%(+&(/!(%+(8#&+!3*29!&#$!(9(?0(925!920+$!925$1!23!

>+2*(.+(+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[ZpUnpaZjVApZpoFnqD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[Zpnpo[ZD!!

!! !

Page 136: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 123 of 237

!"#$%&'()))(F!!"#$%&#!

-(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%(748%(45(9):%(;(;?>=('<(9>?/;<$3"%$(164"J(

<e-F6%50/$5!<,>$!6!6-e+!;2%&*21!4$/*$&(2%!23!6EFZm!,(&45%4/5/)*"(&

!+(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(9>?('<(=64"J(=)<$*4&%=(

@20=1$! @$3(/($%/,! (%! <e-! .%5! <,>$! 6! 6-e! 4(8%.1(%8! E$.5+! &2! H%#.%/$5! C*2&$/&(2%! (%!H%52&2d$9(.!\5%.*0*(/59&7/)/&

!X(!"#$%&'("#)"*+',$+-%.&&'(/0+1$'2$$"+'34$+5+567&+("#+876+)"+4&.%)(&)&(

!"#$!"#$%&'&#(#)'*""$(+,#-&$.&&/#012#(/3#$45&#!#!21"#6/#(7$*6887/&#36"&("!"#$+

@0.1!6%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!69(?0(925F6%50/$5!C+2*(.+(32*9!4J(%!6%31.99.&(2%!(%!W(/$!M#L0*))%7&)"&\."$&^(%&

!IJK+!"#$%&&%'()*%$)+$,'()*,()"-$./$0123$,4"-)+($567$,+$%89%:);%-(,<$;"=%<$&":$9+":),+)+$)-$

!"#$%&+

'%(%&$%5$5!6%8$+&(2%!23!<2>(/.1!69(?0(925!(%!Hd>$*(9$%&.1!C+2*(.+(+F1(J$!4J(%!6%31.99.&(2%!/.%!4J$K!:$+01&+!,(&45%4/5/)*"(&/$&L5*%-&5%4"5)&

! !

Page 137: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 124 of 237

!

-(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%(*48%(45(2):%(;(;?>=('<(9>?/'<$3"%$(=64"J(

!

9>?/;<$3"%$(9):%(;(;?>=(F4<2*48(1%"*%2'4<(45(;C/-\((

E,%5.!"*(%$ZMjM!!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$ZMjM!E($%!@$G.8$*ZMjM!:($&!@$!:,/J$ZMjM!W.*1($+!7.11$8$$*ZMjM!4&$3.%!E($%$%J1.0+pM!W.*(2!iz+&$*nM!'1*(/#!i.1(%J$rM!E$2!N22+&$%qM!;1.05$!E(=$*&ZMj!!Z,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6:&';%():&6%.8*#0&D3%4/5)0%()&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&';%():&6%.8*#0&X3%4/5)0%()&"-&!".%+#./5&,00#("."89:&[%.0;".)f&?%()%5&W"5&,(-%+)*"(&>%$%/5+;:&65/#($+;J%*8:&

'%50/(9&Y3%4/5)0%()&"-&'%(%&>%8#./)*"(&/(7&3*--%5%()*/)*"(:&[%.0;".)f&?%()%5&-"5&,(-%+)*"(&5%$%/5+;:&

65/#($+;J%*8:&'%50/(9&H,($)*)#)%&-"5&T_4%5*0%()/.&,(-%+)*"(&>%$%/5+;:&AJ*(?"5%:&?%()%5&-"5&T_4%5*0%()/.&/(7&?.*(*+/.&

,(-%+)*"(&>%$%/5+;:&65/#($+;J%*8:&'%50/(9&a3%4/5)0%()&"-&,()%5(/.&!%7*+*(%:&>/7L"#7&<(*=%5$*)9&!%7*+/.&?%()%5:&V*K0%8%(:&A;%&

V%);%5./(7$&&&

!!;2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&A!<#$!.0&#2*+!5$/1.*$!&#.&!%2!/2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&!$d(+&+D!!!/(#$+5*4)&*(&45%4/5/)*"(O&

!F4<2*'G32'4<=D(

E,%5.!"*(%$!>$*32*9$5!2*!80(5$5!.11!$d>$*(9$%&.1!K2*J!.%5!K*2&$!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&D!@*D! 4&$3.%! E($%$%J1.0+! (%G$/&$5! 10/(3$*.+$! *$>2*&$*!9(/$! .%5! >$*32*9$5! *(& =*="! .%5! %_& =*="!5$&$/&(2%!23!10/(3$*.+$!./&()(&,!32*!-(80*$!ZPM!7M!;!.%5!H!.%5!40>>1$9$%&.1!-(80*$!ZPFHD!@*D! :22+9.*(G%! HD! I.%5$%=*20/J$! 8.).8$5! 9(/$! K(&#! -6<;F5$d&*.%! 32*! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.++.,!(%!-(80*$!j@D!!E,%5.!"*(%$! (%G$/&$5!9(/$!K(&#!<e-!.%5! (+21.&$5! (1$09! 32*!HW!>#2&28*.>#,U!:($&!@$!:,/J$!.%5!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$!?0.%&(3($5! 6EFZmP!.%5!8*.%01$+! (%!C.%$&#!/$11+! (%!HW!>(/&0*$+!32*!-(80*$!qD!!W.*1($+!7.11$8$$*!>$*32*9$5!&#$!1$&#.1(&,!&$+&+!(%!6EFjo:.!iQ!9(/$D!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$M!@*D!E($%!@$G.8$*!.%5!C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!+0>$*)(+$5!&#$!5$+(8%!.%5!>$*32*9.%/$+!23!&#$!$d>$*(9$%&+D!!

! (

Page 138: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 125 of 237

!"#F!"#$%&#'()*&'!'!"#$%&'()*'+%!!"#!$%&'(&)(*+F!"!

!G=2*#"2(

<e-! (+! .! >2&$%&! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$! .%5! $d/$++! 1$)$1+! 23! <e-! /.%! *$+01&! (%! +#2/JM!

901&(>1$! 2*8.%! 3.(10*$! .%5! 5$.&#D! <e-! #.+! .1+2! =$$%! (9>1(/.&$5! (%! ).*(20+! .0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!.%5!(+!J%2K%!32*!(&+!>2K$*301!.%&(&092*!

./&()(&,D! C*$)(20+1,M! (&! #.+! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! 9$5(.&$+! K#(&$! =1225! /$11!

(%3(1&*.&(2%!.%5!.>2>&2+(+!(%!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JD!g$*$M!=.+$5!2%!$d>$*(9$%&+!0+(%8!10/(3$*.+$!

*$>2*&$*!9(/$!.%5!?:<FC;:M!K$!*$>2*&!&#.&!<e-!(%50/$+!12/.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!+$)$*.1!&,>$!6!6-e!

1(8.%5+!.%5! 64:H!8$%$+M!9.(%1,! (%! &#$! 1()$*! .%5!=2K$1D!P1&#208#! &#$! 1()$*! +#2K$5! &#$!92+&!

>*2320%5!6-eu!.%5!Wdj!>*250/&(2%M!+>$/(3(/!.=1.&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!1()$*!5(5!%2&!

/2%3$*! *$+(+&.%/$! &2! <e-M! .+! 6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!9(/$! 5(5! %2&! +#2K! (%/*$.+$5! +0*)().1! (%! &#$! <e-!

925$1D!6%!&#$!80&M!<e-!(%50/$5!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$M!K#(/#!K.+!9$5(.&$5!=,!&,>$!6!6-e+M!.%5!12++!

23!(%&$+&(%.1!(%&$8*(&,M!K#(/#!K.+!(%5$>$%5$%&!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!6%!.55(&(2%M!(%!1()$*!.%5!(%&$+&(%$M!

5$3(/($%/,! (%! 6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!*$+01&$5! (%!*$50/$5!6EFZmP!$d>*$++(2%M!K#(/#!>*$)(20+1,!#.+!

=$$%!+#2K%!&2!5*()$!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,D!L$!5$92%+&*.&$!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!./&!0>+&*$.9!23!

6EFZmP! =$/.0+$! %$0&*.1(R(%8! .%&(=25($+! .8.(%+&! 6EFZmP! /2%3$**$5! >*2&$/&(2%! .8.(%+&! <e-! (%!

L<!9(/$M! =0&! %2! .55(&(2%.1! >*2&$/&(2%! /2015! =$! 2=+$*)$5! (%! 6-eP:Z! J%2/J20&!9(/$D! <#$+$!

5.&.! (110+&*.&$! &#.&! 12/.1! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!$d$/0&$! &#$! 1$&#.1! $33$/&+!23!<e-! &#*208#! 6EFZmP! (%! &#$!

1()$*!.%5!(%&$+&(%$M!*$+01&(%8!(%!1$&#.1(&,D!

!

! (

Page 139: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 126 of 237

;<2*4$3"2'4<(

6%31.99.&(2%!(+!.%!(990%$!*$./&(2%!3*29!&#$!#2+&!&2!(%&*05$*+!2*!>.&#28$%(/!+&(901(!+0/#!.+!

9(/*22*8.%(+9+!2*!(%G0*($+D!6&!(+!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!&#$!./&().&(2%!23!).*(20+!>.&#K.,+!(%)21)(%8!

/$11! 5()(+(2%M! 9(8*.&(2%! 23! /$11+! .%5! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! +(8%.1+D! ;,&2J(%$+! .*$!

9$++$%8$*+!2*/#$+&*.&(%8!+0/#!$)$%&+!&2!$%+0*$!.!>*2>$*!*$+>2%+$!&2!/$*&.(%!+&(901(D!<092*!

e$/*2+(+!-./&2*!a<e-V!.%5!&,>$!6!6%&$*3$*2%+!a6-e+V!.*$!>1$(2&*2>(/!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!*$8.*5$5!.+!

)$*,! >2&$%&! (%50/$*+! 23! (%31.99.&(2%D! <e-! /.%! =$! 320%5! (%! +210=1$! .%5! 9$9=*.%$F=20%5!

32*9! .%5! /.%! =(%5! &2! &K2! *$/$>&2*+! /.11$5! <e-:Z! a>rrV! .%5! <e-:j! a>mrVDZwp! W2+&! >*2F

(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!.*$!&#208#&!&2!*$+01&!3*29!<e-:Z!./&().&(2%D!<e-!(+!9.(%1,!J%2K%!.+!&#$!

5*()(%8! 32*/$! 23! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+M! $)(5$%/$5! =,! &#$! +0//$++! 23! <e-!

(%#(=(&(2%! &#$*.>($+M! .%5! (&+! *21$! (%! &#$!5$3$%+$!.8.(%+&! (%3$/&(20+!>.&#28$%+DnwY!<,>$! 6! 6-e+!

.*$! 92+&1,! J%2K%! .+! .%&()(*.1! 3./&2*+M! =0&! (&! #.+! =$/29$! (%/*$.+(%81,! /1$.*! &#.&! &#$,! .1+2!

$d#(=(&!+$1$/&()$!.%&(=./&$*(.1!$33$/&+D!<#208#!+$)$*.1!8$%$+!=$12%8!&2!&#$!/1.++!23!&,>$!6!6-e+M!

+0/#! .+! 6-e! =$&.! .%5! Zj! 6-e! .1>#.! /25(%8! 8$%$+M! &#$,! .11! +(8%.1! &#*208#! &#$! +.9$!

#$&$*25(9$*(/! /29>1$d! /29>2+$5! 23! 6-eP:Z! .%5! 6-eP:jDZ[! 72&#! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$!

(%5(+>$%+.=1$! 32*! .%! .>>*2>*(.&$! (990%$! *$+>2%+$M! =$/.0+$! 5,+*$801.&(2%! 23! $./#! 1$.5+! &2!

5$1$&$*(20+!$33$/&+D!Hd/$++!23!<e-!1$.5+!&2!0%/2%&*211$5! (%31.99.&(2%!+0/#!.+!.0&2(990%(&,!

2*!$)$%!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!+,%5*29$!a46:4V!.%5!+$>+(+MqMZZwZq!K#(1+&!$d28$%20+!

&*$.&9$%&! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! #.+! .1+2! 1$5! &2! &#$! 2%+$&! 23! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! (%! >.&($%&+! .%5!

$d>$*(9$%&.1! 925$1+! #.)$! +#2K%! &#.&! &#$,! 9$5(.&$! (%31.99.&2*,! +#2/J! .+! K$11DZmwjp!

W2*$2)$*M! .=1.&(2%! 23! 6-eP:! 1$.5+! &2! >*2&$/&(2%! (%! <e-F(%50/$5! 46:4M! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,!

*$50/$5! /#$92J(%$! >*250/&(2%! .%5! 1$++! K#(&$! =1225! /$11! (%3(1&*.&(2%! (%! 2*8.%+DZpMjnMjr! <#(+!

(%5(/.&$+! .%! (%&$*./&(2%! =$&K$$%! =2&#! +(8%.1(%8! >.&#K.,+! (%! (%31.99.&(2%D! P1&#208#! (&! (+!

J%2K%!&#.&!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+!>*250/$!6-eu!32112K(%8!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!<e-M!(&!

*$9.(%+! 0%/1$.*! K#$*$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! >*250/$5! (%! &#$! =25,! .3&$*! <e-! +&(901.&(2%DjrMjq!

Page 140: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 127 of 237

W2*$2)$*M! (&! (+! +&(11!%2&!0%5$*+&225!#2K! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!$%#.%/$!<e-F(%50/$5! (%31.99.&(2%M! .+!

2>>2+(%8!*21$+!#.)$!=$$%!5$+/*(=$5!+088$+&(%8!.!=.1.%/$!=$&K$$%! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!.%5!<e-! 1(J$!

&#$!<#Zl<#j!.d(+Djm!

g$*$M!K$!*$>2*&!&#.&!<e-!(%5(+/*(9(%.&$1,!(%50/$+!12/.1!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%!(%!&#$!).*(20+!

2*8.%+! &$+&$5M!K#(/#! *$+01&+! (%! 12/.1! 64:H! *$+>2%+$+D! 6%! .55(&(2%M!K$! >*2)(5$! $)(5$%/$! &#.&!

1()$*F5$*()$5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!5(+>$%+.=1$!32*!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,D!-(%.11,M!K$!+#2K!&#.&!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+! /.%! $d$*&! .! >.*&! 23! &#$(*! <e-F./&().&$5! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! ./&(2%+! &#*208#! &#$!

*$1$.+$!23!6EFZm!(%!&#$!80&M!=0&!52!%2&!./&!(%!/2%/$*&!&2!9$5(.&$!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,D!!

7%=382=(

9):%(;(;?>=(#*%('<$3"%$(84"#88)(G)(9>?(

P1&#208#!<e-!/.%!(%50/$!6-eu!(%!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!$%52&#$1(.1!/$11+M!&#$!*(&=*="!$33$/&+!23!<e-!

2%!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!#.)$!%2&!=$$%!+&05($5!(%!5$&.(1DjrMjq!g0,+!$&!.1D!>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!

6-eu! (+! (%50/$5! (%! 1()$*! 32112K(%8! (D>D! (%G$/&(2%! 23! <e-DZp!L$!K$*$! (%&$*$+&$5! &2! (%)$+&(8.&$!

K#$&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e+!K$*$!>*250/$5!+,+&$9(/.11,!2*!12/.11,!.%5!K#$*$!&#$,!$d$*&!&#$(*!$33$/&+D!

<2!.55*$++!&#(+M!K$!0+$5!6-euF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$!&#.&!K$*$!(%G$/&$5!(D>D!K(&#!$(&#$*!p[!

¡8!23!<e-!2*!K(&#!C74Djo!L(&#(%!p!#20*+M!9(/$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!<e-!+#2K$5!$%#.%/$5!10/(3$*.+$!

$d>*$++(2%! (%! &#$! .=529(%.1! *$8(2%! a-(80*$! ZPM! 0>>$*! >.%$1V! .%5! %_&=*="! .%.1,+(+! *$)$.1$5!

6-eu!(%50/&(2%!(%!1()$*!.%5!(%&$+&(%$M!K#(/#!K.+!.=+$%&!(%!C74!(%G$/&$5!9(/$!a-(80*$!ZPM!12K$*!

>.%$1VD!!

<2!(%)$+&(8.&$!K#$*$!&,>$!6! 6-e+!$d$*&!&#$(*!$33$/&+M!K$!+&05($5!<e-F5$>$%5$%&! (%50/&(2%!23!

Wdj! )(.! 10/(3$*.+$! ./&()(&,DjY!WdjF10/(3$*.+$! *$>2*&$*!9(/$!K$*$! .59(%(+&$*$5! C74M! <e-! 2*!

EC4D!EC4!K.+!0+$5!.+!.!>2+(&()$!/2%&*21!.+!(&!(%50/$+!6-eu!+,+&$9(/.11,DjjMp[!EC4F&*$.&$5!WdjF

10/(3$*.+$! 9(/$! 1(&! 0>! $%&(*$1,! p! #20*+! .3&$*! +&(901.&(2%! a-(80*$! Z7VD! ;2%/29(&.%&1,M! 6-eu!

1$)$1+! K$*$! $1$).&$5! (%! +$*09! 23! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$! n#! .3&$*! (%G$/&(2%! 23! EC4! a-(80*$! Z;VD! 6%!

Page 141: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 128 of 237

/2%&*.+&M!<e-!+&(901.&(2%!2%1,!(%50/$5!WdjF10/(3$*.+$!(%!&#$!0>>$*!>.*&!23!&#$!.=529$%!.%5!

%2!6-eu!(%/*$.+$!K.+!5$&$/&$5!(%!+$*09!a-(80*$!Z7!.%5!;VD!H_&=*="!.%.1,+(+!23!2*8.%+!*$)$.1$5!

&#.&!WdjF10/(3$*.+$!K.+! (%50/$5! (%! 1()$*M!J(5%$,M! (1$09!.%5!=*.(%M!=0&!%2&! (%! +>1$$%! a-(80*$!

Z@VD!

!

!?'Q3*%(-D(9>?('<$3"%=(2):%(;(;?>=(84"#88)('<(&4=2(4*Q#<=N(G32(&#'<8)(8'M%*(#<$('8%3&(

W(/$!K$*$!(%G$/&$5!K(&#!C74M!<e-!2*!EC4!(%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,D!a!N(3::%*(:#<%8V!6-euF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$!K$*$! (9.8$5! .&! [! .%5! p! #20*+! .3&$*! C74! 2*! <e-D! a!N( 84K%*( :#<%8V! Q*8.%+!K$*$! (+21.&$5! .%5!(9.8$5D!aRV!WdjF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$!K$*$!(9.8$5!=$32*$!.%5!p!#20*+!.3&$*!+&(9010+D!aFV!4$*09!K.+! (+21.&$5! .&! [M! Z! .%5! n! #20*+! .3&$*! <e-! 2*! EC4M! .%5! 6-eu! K.+!9$.+0*$5! K(&#! HE64PD! aIV! WdjF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!<e-!.%5!n!#20*+!1.&$*!2*8.%+!K$*$!(+21.&$5M!#2928$%(+$5!.%5!*$1.&()$!109(%$+/$%/$!0%(&+!K$*$!9$.+0*$5!(%!>*2&$(%!1,+.&$+D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!pFnVD!<#A!&#,90+U!4>A!+>1$$%U!4&A!+&29./#U!6%A!(%&$+&(%$U!i(A!J(5%$,U!E(A!1()$*!

!

4(%/$!Wdj!/.%!=$!(%50/$5!&#*208#!6-eP:Z!.%5!6EFjo:.!+(8%.1(%8M!(&+!(%50/&(2%!.3&$*!+&(9010+!

K.+!.++$++$5!2%!.%! 6-eP:Z!iQ!=./J8*20%5!.%5!/29>.*$5! &2!K(15! &,>$!9(/$D!L$!2=+$*)$5!

12K$*!=.+.1!1$)$1+!23!Wdj!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!=0&!32112K(%8!+&(901.&(2%!K(&#!<e-M!+(9(1.*!3215!

(%/*$.+$+!23!Wdj!K$*$!2=+$*)$5!(%!1()$*M!J(5%$,!.%5!(1$09!+088$+&(%8!.%!.55(&()$!(%50/&(2%!23!

0 1 4 1 40

10

20

30

40

50

Time after stimulus (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

TNF LPS

*

!"#

$"#

%&'###(%'#)*+#

0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 40

1

2

3

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

1010

1/g

)

Spleen Liver Kidney Ileum Brain****

**

**

**

$"#

%&'###)*+##

%&'###)*+##

!"#

!"# !"#

!" #"

$" %"

Page 142: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 129 of 237

6-eP:Z!.%5!6EFjo:.!a40>>1$9$%&.*,!-(80*$+!ZPFH!.%5!+0>>1$9$%&.*,!<.=1$!ZVD!:$9.*J.=1,M!

&#$*$! K.+! %2! (%50/&(2%! 23! WdjF10/(3$*.+$! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%! &#$! =*.(%M!

+088$+&(%8! (&! (+! /29>1$&$1,! 5$>$%5$%&! 2%! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! %2&! &,>$! 666! 6-e+D! <2! (%)$+&(8.&$!

K#$&#$*!6EFjo:.!/2%&*(=0&$+!&2!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,M!K$!&*$.&$5!9(/$!1./J(%8!6EFjo:.!K(&#!

).*(20+! 52+$+! 23! <e-M! =0&! &#$(*! +0*)().1! *.&$+! a40>>1$9$%&.*,! -(80*$! Z-! .%5! "V! .%5! =25,!

&$9>$*.&0*$+! a5.&.! %2&! +#2K%V! K$*$! /29>.*.=1$! &2! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$D! <#(+! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&!

6-eP:Z!.%5!%2&!6EFjo:!9$5(.&$+!&#$!1$&#.1!$33$/&+!23!<e-!.%5!(+!./&().&$5!(%!+$)$*.1!2*8.%+!

=0&!%2&!+,+&$9(/.11,D!

;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q('<(8'M%*($4%=(<42(:*4&42%(9>?/'<$3"%$(24H'"'2)((

6-ev! .%5! 6-eu! .*$! &#$! =$+&F/#.*./&$*(R$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D! <#208#! &#$,! 2%1,! +#2K! n[Fr[\!

#292128,! .&! &#$! %0/1$2&(5$! 1$)$1M! &#$,! +(8%.1! &#*208#! &#$! +.9$! *$/$>&2*! /29>1$d! .%5! &#$!

9.G2*(&,!23!64:HF8$%$+!.*$!(%50/$5!=,!=2&#!6-ev!.%5!6-euD!<e-!#.+!=$$%!*$>2*&$5!&2!(%50/$!

6-euM!K#(/#!K$!/2%3(*9$5!K(&#! 10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$D!g2K$)$*M! (&! (+!%2&!J%2K%!K#$&#$*!

<e-!/.%!.1+2!(%50/$!6-ev!*(&=*="D!<#$*$32*$M!K$!(+21.&$5!:eP!3*29!1()$*+!23!<e-F&*$.&$5!9(/$!

.%5!>$*32*9$5!?C;:!32*!+$)$*.1!6-ev!8$%$+D!L$!2=+$*)$5!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!,-(/DM!,-(/ZZ!.%5!

,-(/ZX!K(&#!&#$!0+$!23!+>$/(3(/! 6-ev!>*(9$*+D!'+(%8!?C;:!>*(9$*+!&#.&!.112K!5$&$/&(2%!23!.11!

6-ev!8$%$+M!K$!K$*$!.=1$!&2!2=+$*)$!<e-F5$>$%5$%&! ^/2992%c!,-(/.4;/&0>*$801.&(2%!(%!&#$!

1()$*!.%5!(%50/&(2%!23!,-(L!=,!?C;:!a-(80*$!jPVD!<#(+!+088$+&+!&#.&!<e-!52$+!%2&!+21$1,!(%50/$!

6-eu! .+! *$>2*&$5! =,! �.*(1(%.! $&! .1Djr! C*$)(20+1,M! 20*! 8*20>! +#2K$5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! 9$5(.&$+!

/#$92J(%$! >*250/&(2%! .%5! K#(&$! =1225! /$11! (%3(1&*.&(2%! (%! &#$! 1()$*! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! <e-D!

;2%/29(&.%&1,M! 1./J! 23! 6-eP:Z! *$50/$5! 1()$*! 5.9.8$! .3&$*! <e-! +&(901.&(2%M! $)(5$%/$5! =,!

*$50/$5!+$*09!1$)$1+!23!PE<!.%5!P4<DZp!6%!&#(+!+&05,M!K$!5$&$/&$5!&#.&!6-eP:Z!./&().&(2%!(%!

&#$!1()$*!#.+!(99$5(.&$!52K%+&*$.9!$33$/&+M!$)(5$%/$5!=,!&#$!*.>(5!(%50/&(2%!23!64:H!8$%$+!

+0/#!.+!,-*)DM!?_+.ZG&.%5!<$4ZR!a-(80*$!j7VO!

Page 143: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 130 of 237

4(%/$!<e-!(%50/$+!*.>(5!.%5!).+&!.920%&+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!&#$!1()$*M!K$!K2%5$*$5!K#$&#$*!

&#$! 1()$*! 9(8#&! =$! &#$! $.*1,! 5*()(%8! 32*/$! =$#(%5! <e-F(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,D! <2! .55*$++! &#(+!

?0$+&(2%M!K$!0+$5!9(/$!K(&#!+>$/(3(/!.=1.&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!#$>.&2/,&$+!=,!/*2++(%8!

312d$5! 6-eP:Z! 9(/$! a6-eP:Z31l31V! K(&#! .1=09(%! ;*$! &*.%+8$%(/! 9(/$M! /*$.&(%8! 6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!

9(/$M!K#(/#!1./J!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!+>$/(3(/.11,!#$>.&2/,&$+DpZ!

!

?'Q3*%(+D(9>?('<$3"%=(G426(;?>e(#<$(;?>f('<(26%(8'M%*N(G32(;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q('<(26%(8'M%*($4%=(<42(

$*'M%(8%26#8'2)(

a!V!?:<FC;:!.%.1,+(+!23!9:eP!(%!&#$!1()$*!23!,-(/D:&,-(/ZZ:&,-(/ZX:&,-(/.4;/:&,-(L!.%5!aRV!64:H!+(8%.&0*$!23!,-*)D:&?_+.ZG!.%5!<$4ZRD!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!aF!.%5!IV!-011!6-eP:Z! iQ! .%5! 1()$*! +>$/(3(/! J%2/J20&! 9(/$! 6-eP:ZP1=FiQ! .%5! *$+>$/&()$! K(15! &,>$! 1(&&$*9.&$+!a6-eP:Z! L<U! 6-eP:Z312dl312dV! K$*$! (%G$/&$5! K(&#! p[! ¡8! 23! <e-! (%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,D! aFV! 725,!&$9>$*.&0*$!.%5!aIV!1$&#.1(&,!K$*$!92%(&2*$5!32*!9.d(9.1!q[!#20*+D!71./J!3011!/0*)$A!6-eP:Z!iQ!a%!�!Z[VU!=1./J!52&&$5!/0*)$A!6-eP:Z!L<!a%!�!ZpVU!8*$,!3011!/0*)$A!6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!a%!�!oVU!8*$,!52&&$5!/0*)$A!6-eP:Z312dl312d!a%!�!rVD!

!

63! &,>$! 6! 6-e! +(8%.1(%8! .%5! (&+! 52K%+&*$.9! $33$/&+! 5$&$*9(%$! &#$! &#*$+#215! 32*! 1$&#.1(&,M!

.=*28.&(2%! 23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%! &#$! 1()$*! +#2015! +033(/$! &2! >*2&$/&! .8.(%+&! <e-F(%50/$5!

!"

#"$"

0 1 60

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fna2 * *

0 1 60

5000

10000

15000

20000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fna1

1

*

0 1 60

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fna1

3

*

0 1 60

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fnb

*

0 1 60

2

4

6

8

10

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fit2

*

0 1 60

5

10

15

20

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18

**

0 1 60

1000

2000

3000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl1

0

*** **

0 1 60

200

400

600

800

1000

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fn-a

lpha

s

* *

%"

0 6 12 18 24 30 36 42 4820

25

30

35

40

Time after TNF (hours)

Bod

y te

mpe

ratu

re (°

C)

0 20 40 600

20

40

60

80

100

Time after TNF (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

IFNAR1flox/flox

IFNAR1Alb-KO

*****

ns

Page 144: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 131 of 237

1$&#.1(&,! +(9(1.*1,! &2! 3011! =25,! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$D! <2! &$+&! &#(+M! K$! &*$.&$5! 3011! 6-eP:Z! .%5!

6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!9(/$!K(&#!p[!¡8!23!<e-!.%5!32112K$5!1$&#.1(&,!.%5!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!32*!+$)$*.1!

5.,+D! ;2%&*21! 6-eP:Z312dl312d!9(/$! .%5!K(15! &,>$!9(/$!K$*$!0+$5! .+! /2%&*21! 8*20>M!K#(/#! .11!

5($5!K(&#(%!no!#20*+!.3&$*!<e-!(%G$/&(2%!a-(80*$!j;!.%5!@VD!<#$!6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!9(/$!+#2K$5!.!

+(9(1.*! 5*2>! (%! =25,! &$9>$*.&0*$! .+! &#$! /2%&*21! 8*20>+M! =0&! 5(5! %2&! .11! +0//09=! &2! <e-!

a-(80*$!j;!.%5!j@VD!<#$*$!K.+!%2! +(8%(3(/.%&!5(33$*$%/$! (%! +0*)().1!=$&K$$%! 6-eP:Z31l31! .%5!

6-eP:ZP1=FiQ!9(/$!=0&!3011!6-eP:!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!>*2&$/&$5!/29>.*$5!&2!L<!9(/$M!

.+!>*$)(20+1,!5$+/*(=$5DZp!6%!.55(&(2%M!K$!&$+&$5!=1225!>.*.9$&$*+!+0/#!.+!6EFq!.%5!PE<lP4<!

1$)$1+!.+!K$11M!=0&!320%5!%2!+(8%(3(/.%&!5(33$*$%/$+!=$&K$$%!/2%5(&(2%.1!iQ!.%5!/2%&*21!9(/$!

a5.&.!%2&!+#2K%VD!<#$+$!5.&.!(%5(/.&$!&#.&!+>$/(3(/!.=1.&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!1()$*!(+!

%2&!+033(/($%&!&2!>*2&$/&!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!46:4D!

;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q(#<$(*%=:4<=%('<(26%(Q32('=(2'==3%/=:%"'5'"((

-(80*$!Z7!+#2K$5!&#.&!&#$!(1$(.1!>.*&!23!&#$!(%&$+&(%$+!.1+2!+#2K$5!9.G2*!6-eP:Z!./&().&(2%!

32112K(%8!<e-!+&(901.&(2%D!P1&#208#!g0,+!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!&#$!$33$/&+!23!<e-!2%!&#$!(%&$+&(%$!

.%5!&#$!*21$!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8MZp!(&!(+!%2&!/1$.*!K#(/#!(%&$+&(%.1!/$11+!.*$!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!&#$!

>*250/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!K#(/#!2%$+!.*$!*$+>2%+()$D!!

-(*+&M! &#$! (%50/&(2%!>*23(1$!23!&,>$!6! 6-e+!.%5!52K%+&*$.9!64:H!+(8%.&0*$+!K$*$!.++$++$5!(%!

K#21$!(1$09!=,!?C;:D!P1&#208#!K$!2=+$*)$5!.!&*$%5!&2K.*5+!(%/*$.+$!23!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!.3&$*!

<e-! (%!K(15! &,>$!9(/$M! &#$*$!K.+!.! 12&!23! ).*(.&(2%!=$&K$$%! +.9>1$+! a-(80*$!pPVD!P! +(9(1.*!

).*(.&(2%! (%! *$+>2%+$! 23! 64:H! 8$%$+! K.+! %2&$5! (%! &#$! +9.11! (%&$+&(%$+! 0>2%! <e-! (%G$/&(2%!

a40>>1$9$%&.*,!-(80*$!jPVD!L$! &#$%!5$/(5$5! &2!$%*(/#! 32*! (1$(.1! $>(&#$1(.1! /$11+!=,! +/*.>(%8!

&#$!(1$09!+0*3./$!.+!5$+/*(=$5Dpj!6%!=*($3M!&#$!(%&$+&(%$!K.+!/0&!2>$%!12%8(&05(%.11,M!)(11(!K$*$!

+/*.>$5!233!0+(%8!.!/2)$*+1(>!.%5!:eP!K.+!(+21.&$5D!P1&#208#!%2!(%50/&(2%!23!,-(/.4;/&2*!,-(L!

K.+!2=+$*)$5M!K$!320%5!.!+(8%(3(/.%&!0>*$801.&(2%!23!,-*)DM!?_+.ZG!.%5!<$4ZR!+088$+&(%8!&#.&!

&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!1(%(%8!23!&#$!(1$09!*$+>2%5$5!&2!&,>$!6!6-e+!a-(80*$!p7VM!=0&!52!%2&!>*250/$!&#$!

Page 145: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 132 of 237

6-e+! &#$9+$1)$+D! C*$)(20+1,M!W0%.J.&.! .%5! /211$.80$+! >$*32*9$5! *(& $*)#! #,=*(5(R.&(2%! .%5!

(990%2#(+&2/#$9(+&*,!2%!&#$!(%&$+&(%$!.%5!*$>2*&$5!&#$!5$&$/&(2%!23!$d>*$++(2%!23!,-(/.4;/!

(%!C.%$&#!/$11+Mpp! +2!K$! (%)$+&(8.&$5! &#$!$d>*$++(2%!23! ,-(L! .%5! ,-(/.4;/! (%! (1$.1! /*,>&+!.3&$*!

+&(901.&(2%! K(&#! <e-D! <2! $%*(/#! 32*! (1$.1! /*,>&+M! &$*9(%.1! (1$09! K.+! (+21.&$5! .%5! /0&! (%&2!

+9.11$*!>($/$+!K#(1$!J$>&!/215D!P3&$*!*$>$.&$5!+$5(9$%&.&(2%!.%5!/$%&*(308.&(2%!+&$>+M!+0>$*F!

!

?'Q3*%( XD( 9>?( '<$3"%=( #( 84"#8( ;17B( ='Q<#23*%( #<$( '<$3"%=( '<2%=2'<#8( :%*&%#G'8'2)( #<$( ;?>!7-/

&%$'#2%$($#&#Q%('<(26%(Q32(

L(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!p[!¡8!23!<e-!.%5!(1$09!.%5!>1.+9.!K$*$!(+21.&$5!.&!&#$!(%5(/.&$5!&(9$!>2(%&+D!?:<FC;:!.%.1,+(+!K.+!>$*32*9$5!(%!(1$(.1!+.9>1$+!32*!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!&,>$!6!6-e! 1(8.%5+! .%5! 64:H! 8$%$+D!9:eP!K.+! $d&*./&$5! 3*29! a!V!K#21$! (1$09! 1,+.&$+M! aRV! (%! +/*.>$5! (1$(.1!1,+.&$+! .%5! aFV! (%! (+21.&$5! /*,>&+D! 7.*+! *$>*$+$%&! *$1.&()$! $d>*$++(2%! 1$)$1+! a9$.%! ¢! 4@U! %! �! nVD! aIV!6%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!K.+!9$.+0*$5!&#*208#!(%/*$.+$!(%!>1.+9.!3102*$+/$%/$!.3&$*!2*.1!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!n!J@.!-6<;F5$d&*.%!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!�$*2!&(9$!>2(%&!5.&.!3*29!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!K$*$!>221$5D!7.*+! *$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4HW!a%!�!oFj[VD! aBV! 6%/*$.+$5!/(*/01.&(%8! 1$)$1+!23! 6EF-P7C!K$*$!0+$5!.+!.!9.*J$*! 32*! (%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$!.3&$*!<e-! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15! &,>$!9(/$D!�$*2!&(9$!>2(%&!5.&.!3*29!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!K$*$!>221$5D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!rFoVD!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQD!

!

%.&.%&! K.+! $%*(/#$5! K(&#! /*,>&! /$11+M! .+! 5$+/*(=$5Dpn! :eP! K.+! (+21.&$5! 3*29! &#$! (+21.&$5!

/*,>&+! .%5! ?C;:! 32*! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 64:H! 8$%$+!K.+! >$*32*9$5M! 5$>(/&$5! (%! -(80*$! p;D!e2!

!"

#

$"

0 1 6 80

100

200

300

400

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fn-a

lpha

s

0 1 6 80

50

100

150

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fnb

0 2 4 80

50

100

150

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fit2

**

*

0 2 4 80

500

1000

1500

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl1

0

**

*

0 2 4 80

100

200

300

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18 **

%"

&"

0 2 0 20

500

1000

Time after TNF (hours)[IL

-FA

BP

] (pg

/ml)

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

******

0 8 0 80

1

2

3

4

5

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e in

test

inal

per

mea

bilit

y

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO *

*

ns

0 20.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fn-a

lpha

s

0 20

1

2

3

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fnb

0 20

1

2

3

4

5

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fit2

0.0761

0 20

5

10

15

20

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl1

0

**

0 20

2

4

6

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18

*

Page 146: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 133 of 237

/1$.*! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! 0>*$801.&(2%! 23! ,-(/.4;/& 2*! ,-(L! K.+! 2=+$*)$5! (%! /*,>&! /$11+! .%5! &#$!

(%50/&(2%! 23! 64:H! 8$%$+! K.+! *.&#$*! 1(9(&$5D! P1&#208#! K$! K$*$! 0%.=1$! &2! 0%.9=(8020+1,!

(5$%&(3,! &#$! +20*/$! 23! <e-F(%50/$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! K$! K$*$! .=1$! &2! 5$&$/&! 64:H! *$+>2%+$+!

+>$/(3(/.11,!(%!&#$!)(11(!.%5!/*,>&+D!!

;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q('<(26%(Q32(&%$'#2%=(9>?/'<$3"%$($#&#Q%N(G32(<42(84==(45(

G#**'%*('<2%Q*'2)(

<e-!/.0+$+!&(++0$!5.9.8$M!K#(/#!1$.5+!&2!12++!23!2*8.%!30%/&(2%D!<#$!$33$/&!23!<e-!2%!&#$!80&!

#.+! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! 12++! 23! +&*0/&0*.1! (%&$8*(&,! 1$.5(%8! &2! 1$.J.8$! 23! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1!

/2%&$%&M! .+! *$>2*&$5! =,! 20*! 8*20>DprMpq! <#(+! *.(+$5! &#$! ?0$+&(2%! K#$&#$*! &#$! 2=+$*)$5!

>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,!23!&#$!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!K.+!1(%J$5!&2!*$50/$5!<e-F

(%50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,D! <2!9$.+0*$! 12++! 23! (%&$+&(%.1! (%&$8*(&,!K$!0+$5! 3102*$+/$(%!

(+2&#(2/,.%.&$!a-6<;VF5$d&*.%!K(&#!.!921$/01.*[email protected]!K#(/#!(%!#$.1&#,!>#,+(2128(/.1!

/(*/09+&.%/$+!/.%!2%1,!1(9(&$51,!/*2++!&#$!(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*!K#$%!.59(%(+&$*$5!2*.11,D!'>2%!

<e-! +&(901.&(2%M! (%8$+&$5! -6<;F5$d&*.%! (+! 320%5! (%! &#$! =1225! /(*/01.&(2%! (%! K(15! &,>$! .%5!

6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$! a-(80*$!p@V! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! 6-eP:Z!5$3(/($%/,!52$+!%2&!>*2&$/&! 3*29!<e-F

(%50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,D! <#(+! (+! 0%$d>$/&$5M! .+! 6-eP:Z! #.+! =$$%! *$>2*&$5! &2! =$!

(%5(+>$%+.=1$! 32*! 3011! 30%/&(2%.1(&,! 23! &#$! >0192%.*,! =.**($*! (%! (%&*.%.+.1! (%3$/&(2%! K(&#!

M)5%4)"+"++#$&4(%#0"(*/%pm!.%5!#(+&2128(/.1!.%.1,+(+!23!6-eP:ZF5$3(/($%&!(1$09!*$)$.1$5!1$++!

<e-F(%50/$5!5.9.8$!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!(1$09DZp!<2!9$.+0*$!&#$!5.9.8$!23!&#$!(%&$+&(%$!

.3&$*! <e-! .&! &#$! 921$/01.*! 1$)$1M! K$! .&&$9>&$5! &2! 5$&$/&! (1$.1! 3.&&,! ./(5! =(%5(%8! >*2&$(%M!

J%2K%!.+!6EF-P7CM!K#(/#!(+!*.>(51,!*$1$.+$5!=,!5.9.8$5!/$11+!50$!&2!(&+!+9.11!+(R$!.%5!/.%!=$!

320%5! (%! &#$!=1225!/(*/01.&(2%D! 6%/*$.+$5!/(*/01.&(%8! 1$)$1+!23! 6EF-P7C!#.)$!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!

K(&#! ./0&$! (%&$+&(%.1! (+/#$9(.! .%5! (%31.99.&(2%! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! $.*1,! /$11! 5$.&#! 23!

$%&$*2/,&$+! .+! (&! *$31$/&+! &#$! #(+&2128(/.1! +&.&0+! 23! &#$! $>(&#$1(09DpoMpY! <2! /2%3(*9! K#$&#$*!

6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$! #.5! 1$++! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$M! 6EF-P7C! 1$)$1+!K$*$!9$.+0*$5! (%! +$*09! .3&$*!

Page 147: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 134 of 237

<e-D!;2%+(+&$%&!K(&#!&#$!#(+&2128(/.1!.%.1,+(+!>$*32*9$5!=,!g0,+!$&!.1DM!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!#.5!

*$50/$5! 6EF-P7C! 1$)$1+! .%5! &#0+! 1$++! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$M! /2%3(*9(%8! &#$(*! >*2&$/&()$!

>#$%2&,>$! (%! <e-F(%50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$! a-(80*$! pHVD! ;1$.*1,M! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (+! %2&!

(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!12++!23! (%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*!.3&$*!<e-M!=0&!52$+!9$5(.&$!(&+!5.9.8(%8!$33$/&+!2%!

&(++0$+D!!

1%"*%2'4<(45(;C/-\('=(&%$'#2%$(G)(;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q(

Q)$*!&#$!,$.*+M!).*(20+!>()2&.1!9$5(.&2*+M!+0/#!.+!eQ!.%5!6EFZmM!#.)$!=$$%!(5$%&(3($5!%$d&!&2!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! <e-F(%50/$5! &2d(/(&,DZjMn[MnZ! Q0*! *$+$.*/#! 8*20>! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! C.%$&#! /$11F

5$*()$5! 6EFZm! (+! (9>2*&.%&! (%! .9>1(3,(%8! <e-F(%50/$5! +,+&$9(/! (%31.99.&(2%D! 4(9(1.*1,! &2!

6-eu!.%5! 6-evM! 6EFZm! (+! (%50/$5!)$*,!$.*1,!.%5!2%1,! 12/.11,!=,!<e-D!<,>$! 6! 6-e+!#.)$!=$$%!

.>>2(%&$5! .%! (%#(=(&2*,! *21$! (%! 6EFZm! +(8%.1(%8! .%5! <#Zm! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%M! >0=1(+#$5! (%!

%09$*20+!*$>2*&+Dnjwnr!P+!6EFZm!>1.,+!.!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!*21$!(%!&#(+!925$1M!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!

>2&$%&(.11,! (%#(=(&! 6EFZm! +(8%.1(%8M! K$! K2%5$*$5!K#$&#$*! 6EFZm! (+! .33$/&$5! (%! <e-F(%G$/&$5!

6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$D!e2&$K2*&#,M! &#$! *$+01&+! >0=1(+#$5!=,!<.J.#.+#(! $&! .1D! 32/0+$5! 2%! 6EFZmPM!

K#$*$.+!6EFZm-!#.+!.1+2!8.(%$5!(%&$*$+&!(%!&#$!3($15!23!(%31.99.&(2%!.+!K$11Dnq!L$!(%)$+&(8.&$5!

6EFZm!(%!=2&#!1()$*!.%5!(%!(1$09!)(.!?C;:!.%5!(990%2#(+&2/#$9(+&*,D!40*>*(+(%81,M!,.ZE/!.%5!

,.ZE-! $d>*$++(2%! 1$)$1+!K$*$! *$50/$5! (%! 1()$*+! 23! 6-eP:Z! iQ!9(/$M! +088$+&(%8! &#.&! 6-eP:Z!

+(8%.1(%8!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!.3&$*!<e-!+&(901.&(2%!a-(80*$!nPVD!

6990%2#(+&2/#$9(/.1! +&.(%(%8! *$)$.1$5! .! +(9(1.*! >.&&$*%! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQ! 1()$*! +$/&(2%+!K(&#!

1$++! 6EFZmP! +&.(%(%8! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2!K(15! &,>$! +$/&(2%+! .3&$*! <e-M! .+! +#2K%! (%! -(80*$! n7D!

?C;:!2%!K#21$! (1$09!+.9>1$+!*$)$.1$5!%2!+(8%(3(/.%&! (%50/&(2%!23! ,.ZE/!.%5! ,.ZE-!.3&$*!<e-!

a5.&.!%2&!+#2K%VD!<2!(%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE&(%!C.%$&#!/$11+!.+!5$+/*(=$5!=$32*$M!K$!

(+21.&$5!:eP!3*29!(%&$+&(%.1!/*,>&+D!:$9.*J.=1,M!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-!K$*$!=2&#!0>*$801.&$5!)$*,!

$.*1,!.3&$*!<e-!(%!&#$!6-eP:Z!iQF5$*()$5!/*,>&+M!=0&!%2&!(%!K(15!&,>$!a-(80*$!rPVD!

Page 148: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 135 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(.D(;?>!7-(&%$'#2%=(9>?/'<$3"%$(;C/-\(2*#<="*':2'4<(#<$(=%"*%2'4<('<(26%(8'M%*(

6-eP:Z!K(15!&,>$!.%5!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!(%G$/&$5!(%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,!K(&#!p[!¡8!23!<e-!.%5!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZmP! .%5! 6EFZm-! K$*$! .++$++$5! K(&#! ?:<FC;:! .%5! (990%2#(+&2/#$9(+&*,D! a!V! <*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-!1$)$1+!(%!1()$*!23!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!aRV!6990%2#(+&2/#$9(/.1!+&.(%(%8!23!6EFZmP!(%!1()$*!+$/&(2%+!23!6-eP:Z! iQ! .%5!K(15! &,>$!9(/$! =$32*$! a0>>$*! (9.8$+V! .%5! .3&$*! <e-! a12K$*! (9.8$+U! j[dVD! 7*2K%!/212*.&(2%! (+! &#$!/#*2928$%!.%5!#$9.&2d,1(%!K.+!0+$5!.+! /20%&$*+&.(%D!:$>*$+$%&.&()$! (9.8$+!.*$!+#2K%D!4/.1$!=.*!�!r[!£9D!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQD!

!

6%!/2%&*.+&M!(990%2#(+&2/#$9(+&*,!*$)$.1$5!1$++!6EFZmP!>2+(&()$!/$11+!(%!&#$!)(11(!.%5!/*,>&+!23!

6-eP:Z!iQ! (1$09M! /29>.*$5! &2!K(15! &,>$!9(/$! a-(80*$!r7VD!H1$/&*2%!9(/*2+/2>,!/2%3(*9$5!

&#$+$! 3(%5(%8+U!-(80*$+!qP!.%5!7!+#2K!&#$!?0.%&(3(/.&(2%!23! 6EFZmPF(990%28215! (%!8*.%01$+!

.%5! C.%$&#! /$11+! .%5! *$>*$+$%&.&()$! (9.8$+D! 4(d! #20*+! .3&$*! +&(9010+M! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$!

$d>*$++$5!1$++!6EFZmP!(%!8*.%01$+!.%5!C.%$&#!/$11+M!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!.%(9.1+D!W2*$2)$*M!

!"

!"#$%&'() ' '' '''!"#$%&'*+'#"

0 1 6 0 1 60

20

40

60

80

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

ress

ion

of Il

17a

* *

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

0 1 6 0 1 60

100

200

300

400

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

ress

ion

of Il

17f * **

,'-'

''

'

'

'

&'-'

Page 149: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 136 of 237

(%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8M! C.%$&#! /$11+! /2%&.(%$5! 92*$! 8*.%01$+! &#.%! K(15! &,>$!

C.%$&#!/$11+D!<#(+!+088$+&+!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%#(=(&!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!./&().&(2%!23!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-!

(%! &#$! /*,>&+M! =0&! 9.,! =$! *$?0(*$5! 32*! &#$! $d>*$++(2%! .%5! +$/*$&(2%! 23! >*2&$(%! 6EFZmP! (%!

*$+>2%+$!&2!<e-D!!

!

?'Q3*%(0D(;?>!7-(&%$'#2%=(9>?/'<$3"%$(;C/-\(=%"*%2'4<('<(26%(Q32N(G32('&:#'*=(2*#<="*':2'4<#8(

3:*%Q38#2'4<('<("*):2=(

6-eP:Z!K(15!&,>$!.%5!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!(%G$/&$5!(%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,!K(&#!p[!¡8!23!<e-!.%5!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZmP! .%5! 6EFZm-! K$*$! .++$++$5! K(&#! ?:<FC;:! .%5! (990%2#(+&2/#$9(+&*,D! a!V! <*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-!1$)$1+!(%!/*,>&+!23!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!aRV!6990%2#(+&2/#$9(/.1!+&.(%(%8!23!6EFZmP!(%!(1$(.1!+$/&(2%+!23!6-eP:Z! iQ! .%5! K(15! &,>$!9(/$! n! #20*+! .3&$*! <e-! a1$3&! (9.8$+M! j[dVD! E$3&! (9.8$+! *$>*$+$%&! K#21$!+$/&(2%+! .%5! *(8#&! (9.8$+! .*$! rd! 9.8%(3(/.&(2%! 32*! 5$&.(1D! 7*2K%! /212*.&(2%! (+! &#$! /#*2928$%! .%5!#$9.&2d,1(%!K.+!0+$5! .+! /20%&$*+&.(%D!:$>*$+$%&.&()$! (9.8$+! .*$! +#2K%D! 4/.1$! =.*! �! r[!£9D!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQD!

!

0 2 0 20

1

2

3

4

5

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

l17f **

*

!"#$%&'()' ' ''''' '!"#$%&'*+'

!"

!"#$%&'()' ' ''''' '!"#$%&'*+'#"

0 2 0 20

2

4

6

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

l17a **

*IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

Page 150: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 137 of 237

E*%/2*%#2&%<2(45(;?>!7-(OZ(K'26(#<2'/;C/-\($4%=(<42(:*42%"2(#Q#'<=2(9>?/

'<$3"%$(8%26#8'2)(

L$!%$d&!K2%5$*$5! (3! 6-eP:Z!.%5!6EFZm!+(8%.1(%8!./&! (%!/2%/$*&! &2!2*/#$+&*.&$!<e-F(%50/$5!

(%31.99.&(2%D!Q0*!9.(%!>0*>2+$!K.+! &2! (%)$+&(8.&$! (3!K$!/2015!$%#.%/$!+0*)().1! (%! 6-eP:Z!

iQ!9(/$!=,!%$0&*.1(R(%8!6EFZmP!.+!*$>2*&$5!=$32*$!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!=,!<.J.#.+#(!$&!.1DZj!L(15!

&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!>*$&*$.&$5!K(&#!%$0&*.1(R(%8!.%&(F6EFZmP!.%5!/2%&*21!+$*09!j!

#20*+! =$32*$! <e-D! -2112K(%8! +&(901.&(2%!K(&#! <e-M!9(/$! K$*$!92%(&2*$5! 32*! 1$&#.1(&,! .%5!

=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$D!L(15!&,>$!9(/$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!.%&(F6EFZmP!+#2K$5!(%/*$.+$5!+0*)().1!.%5!

!

?'Q3*%([D(d3#<2'5'"#2'4<(45(;C/-\!('<(;?>!7-(OZ(#<$(K'8$(2):%(&'"%(#52%*(9>?(

61$09!K.+!(+21.&$5!3*29!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!q!#20*+!.3&$*!p[!¡8!<e-!.%5!$d.9(%$5!=,!HWD!4$/&(2%+!K$*$! +&.(%$5! 32*! 6EFZmP!K(&#! (990%28215F1.=$1(%8D! a!V!s0.%&(3(/.&(2%!23! 6EFZmP! (%! +$/*$&2*,!8*.%01$+!.%5!C.%$&#!/$11+M!.%5!/20%&+!23!8*.%01$+!>$*!C.%$&#!/$11D!aRV!:$>*$+$%&.&()$!HWF(9.8$+!3*29!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!C.%$&#!/$11+D!6990%28215!1.=$1(%8!(%!&#$!(%+$&+!(+!(%5(/.&$5!K(&#!.**2K+D!4/.1$!=.*!!�!j!£9D!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!i[!

!

*$50/$5!5*2>!(%!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!&#$!/2%&*21!8*20>D!g2K$)$*M!K$!5(5!%2&!

2=+$*)$!.55(&(2%.1!>*2&$/&(2%! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$! &*$.&$5!K(&#! .%&(F6EFZmPM!K#(/#! (%5(/.&$+!

&#.&! 6EZmP! (+! (**$1$).%&! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8M! +088$+&(%8! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! ./&+!

0>+&*$.9!23!6EFZmP!a-(80*$!mP!.%5!m7VD!4(9(1.*1,M!6EFq!1$)$1+!K$*$!*$50/$5!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!

!"

#" !"#$%&'() ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '!"#$%&'*+'

0

10

20

30

6 hours after TNF

IL-1

7A/g

ranu

le ***

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

0

100

200

300

6 hours after TNF

IL-1

7A/P

anet

h ce

ll

**

0

5

10

15

20

6 hours after TNF

Gra

nule

s/P

anet

cel

l*

Page 151: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 138 of 237

&#.&! *$/$()$5! .%&(=25($+! .8.(%+&! 6EFZmP! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2! &#$! /2%&*21! 8*20>M! K#$*$.+! %2!

5(33$*$%/$! K.+! 2=+$*)$5! (%! &#$! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 8*20>+! a-(80*$! m;VD! P1&28$&#$*M! &#$+$! *$+01&+!

+088$+&! &#.&! 6EFZmP! (+! (%50/$5! =,!<e-! &#*208#! 6-eP:Z! ./&().&(2%M! .%5! &#.&! 6EZm!9.,! =$! .!

9$5(.&2*!23!&,>$F6!6-e+!(%!&#$!<e-!925$1D!!

!?'Q3*%(\D(!$$'2'4<#8(G84"J'<Q(45(;C/-\!($4%=(<42('<"*%#=%(=3*M'M#8('<(;?>!7-(OZ(&'"%(

a!!.%5!RV!W(/$!K$*$!>*$&*$.&$5!K(&#!Z[[!¡8!23!.%&(=25($+!.8.(%+&!6EFZm!2*!/2%&*21!68"j.!&K2!#20*+!=$32*$!<e-!(%G$/&(2%!.%5!92%(&2*$5!32*!9.d(9.1!o[!#20*+!32*!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!.%5!1$&#.1(&,!a%!�!nFZoVD!aFV! 6EFq! 1$)$1+!K$*$!5$&$*9(%$5!K(&#!E09(%$d! (%!+$*09!j!#20*+!.3&$*!<e-D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!nFoVD!?)5N&+"()5".&71./JM!K(15!&,>$!x!.%&(F6EFZmPM!=1./J!52&&$5l8*.(%$5M!K(15!&,>$!x!/2%&*21U!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQ!x!.%&(F6EFZmPU!8*$,!52&&$5l8*.(%$5M!6-eP:Z!iQ!x!/2%&*21!

I'="3=='4<(

<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!#.)$!=$$%! *$>2*&$5! &2!./&! (%! +,%$*8,! &2!2*/#$+&*.&$! (%31.99.&(2%M!=0&!

<e-! (+! .1+2! J%2K%! &2! (%#(=(&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! =,! >@;+DjrMnmwnY! g0,+! $&! .1D! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z!

+(8%.1(%8!9$5(.&$+!<e-F(%50/$5!(%31.99.&(2%M! 1$.5(%8!&2!K#(&$!=1225!/$11! (%3(1&*.&(2%M! &(++0$!

5.9.8$!.%5!$)$%!5$.&#DZp!

!" #"

$"

0 4 8 11 22 25 28 32 48 5420

25

30

35

40

Time after TNF (hours)

Bod

y Te

mpe

ratu

re (°

C)

0

5

10

15

20

2 hours after TNF

[IL-6

] (x

103

pg/m

l)

* **

IFNAR1 WT + anti IL-17AIFNAR1 WT + ctrIFNAR1 KO + anti IL-17AIFNAR1 KO + ctr

0 20 40 60 800

25

50

75

100

Time after TNF (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

IFNAR1 WT + anti IL-17AIFNAR1 WT + ctrIFNAR1 KO + anti IL-17A

IFNAR1 KO + ctr

*

*

Page 152: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 139 of 237

6%! &#(+! +&05,M!K$! +#2K! &#.&! <e-! (%50/$+! 12/.1! >*250/&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! +$)$*.1! 2*8.%+M!

K#(/#!1$.5+!&2!(%/*$.+$5!$d>*$++(2%!23!64:H!8$%$+!+0/#!.+!Wdj!9.(%1,!(%!=2&#!(1$09!.%5!1()$*M!

=0&! .1+2! J(5%$,! .%5! =*.(%D! P1&#208#! &,>$! 666! 6-e+! .1+2!9$5(.&$! &#$! (%50/&(2%! 23! &#$+$! 64:H!

8$%$+!&#*208#!6EFjo:!+(8%.1(%8M!K$!>*2)(5$!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!&#$+$!6-e+!.*$!%2&!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!

<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,!+(%/$!6EFjo:!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!%2&!>*2&$/&$5!.8.(%+&!<e-D!L$!+&05($5!&#$!

1$&#.1(&,!23!<e-!(%!9(/$!1./J(%8!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!1()$*M!=0&!5(5!%2&!2=+$*)$!+(8%(3(/.%&!

+0*)().1!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!&#$!/2%&*21!8*20>D!<#(+!(%5(/.&$+!&#.&!.1&#208#!/(*/01.&(%8!1$)$1+!23!

P4<lPE<!1$)$1+!K$*$!*$50/$5!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!5$1$&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!(%!#$>.&2/,&$+!52$+!%2&!

/2%3$*!*$+(+&.%/$!&2!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,D!<#$!(%&$+&(%.1!&*./&!.1+2!*$./&+!+&*2%81,!&2!<e-!.%5!

.+!20*!8*20>!>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!*$50/$5!<e-!+(8%.1(%8! (%!&#$!80&! (+!+033(/($%&!&2!/2%3$*!

*$+(+&.%/$! &2! <e-! .%5! &#.&! <e-! 1$&#.1! *$+>2%+$! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! &#$! (%50/&(2%! 23! 80&!

>$*9$.=(1(&,Mr[! K$! .1+2! 32/0+$5! 2%! &#$! (%&$+&(%$D! <e-! (%50/$+! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,! .%5!

&(++0$!5.9.8$M! .+! 5$+/*(=$5! $.*1($*DprMpq!@$1$&(2%!23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! 1$.5+! &2! .11$)(.&(2%!23!

(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$!.+!$)(5$%/$5!=,! 12K! 6EF-P7C! 1$)$1+! (%!/29>.*(+2%! &2!K(15! &,>$!9(/$M!=0&!

52$+!%2&!.33$/&!12++!23!&#$!(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*D!P1&#208#!K$!5(5!%2&!.55*$++!#2K!&(8#&!G0%/&(2%+!

K$*$!.33$/&$5!=,!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8M!K$!/.%!/2%/105$!&#.&!<e-F(%50/$5!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!

52$+!%2&!%$/$++.*(1,!1$.5!&2!5$.&#D!Q%$!>2++(=1$!$d>1.%.&(2%!(+!&#.&!&#$!+0=+$?0$%&!=./&$*(.1!

&*.%+12/.&(2%!(+!92*$!$33(/($%&1,!/1$.*$5!(%!6-eP:Z!iQM!+(9(1.*1,!&2!K#.&!#.+!=$$%!*$>2*&$5!(%!

.!;EC!925$1!23!+$>+(+!=,!20*!8*20>jZD!P1&#208#!&#(+!9$/#.%(+9!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!$d/105$5M!K$!

#.)$!%2&!.55*$++$5!&#(+!(%!&#(+!+&05,D!!!

6%!&#$!+$.*/#!23!1(%J(%8!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!&2!2&#$*!).1(5.&$5!9$5(.&2*+!23!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JM!

K$!320%5!&#.&!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%!K.+!(9>.(*$5!(%!1()$*!.%5!(1$09!23!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!=2&#!.&!

&#$! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! 1$)$1! .%5! +$/*$&(2%D! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%! &#$! 1()$*! (+! $++$%&(.1! 32*!

&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-&.%5!.&!&#$!&*.%+1.&(2%.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE/D!6%!&#$!

+9.11!(%&$+&(%$M!&#(+!*$801.&(2%!+$$9+!92*$!/29>1$dD!P1&#208#!6-eP:Z!+&(901.&$+!+$/*$&(2%!23!

6EFZmP!.&! &#$!>*2&$(%! 1$)$1M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! +$$9! &2! /2%+&*.(%! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! (%50/&(2%!23! ,.ZE/!

Page 153: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 140 of 237

.%5!,.ZE-!.3&$*!<e-D!<2!20*!J%2K1$58$M!&#$*$!#.+!2%1,!=$$%!2%$!*$>2*&!K#$*$!&,>$!6!6-e+!K$*$!

/*0/(.1!32*!+$/*$&(2%!23!6EFZmP!=,!<!/$11+DrZ!P1&#208#!K$!/0**$%&1,!1./J!HWF5.&.!3*29!&#$!R$*2!

&(9$!>2(%&M!20*!5.&.!(%5(/.&$!&#.&!6-eP:Z!9.,!*$801.&$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!./&().&(2%!.%5!*$1$.+$!

23! 6EFZm! (%! .! +>.&(.1!9.%%$*! =,! (%#(=(&(%8!9:eP! (%/*$.+$! (%! &#$! /*,>&+M! =0&! $%#.%/$! 6EFZm!

+$/*$&(2%!(%!&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!1(%(%8!23!&#$!+9.11!(%&$+&(%$D!6%!2*5$*!&2!+&05,!K#$&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e+!

.%5! 6EFZmP!9$5(.&$!<e-F(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,! &28$&#$*M!K$!=12/J$5! 6EFZmP!+(8%.1(%8! (%! 6-eP:Z!

iQ!9(/$M! =0&! K$! 5(5! %2&! 2=+$*)$! .55(&(2%.1! >*2&$/&(2%D! <#(+! +088$+&+! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! ./&!

0>+&*$.9! 23! 6EFZmPM! *$801.&(%8! (&+! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! $d>*$++(2%! .%5! +$/*$&(2%D! P1&#208#!

%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23! 6EFZmP!5(5!%2&! .33$/&! +0*)().1! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!K$! /.%%2&! $d/105$! &#.&!

=12/J(%8!6EFZm-!2*!6EFZm:P!9(8#&!=$!92*$!$33$/&()$!.+!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!/.%!5(33$*!(%!./&(2%+!

.%5!./&!(%!/2%/$*&!K(&#!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<#(+!*$9.(%+!&2!=$!(%)$+&(8.&$5D!!

P1&28$&#$*M!K$!+#2K!&#.&!<e-!*.>(51,!.%5!12/.11,!(%50/$+!&,>$!6!6-e+!1!(%!+$)$*.1!2*8.%+M!=0&!

&#.&!&#$! 1()$*!.%5!+9.11! (%&$+&(%$!.*$!&#$!9.(%!&.*8$&$5!2*8.%+!23!<e-!32*!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8M!

K#(/#!(+!*$31$/&$5!(%!*$50/$5!80&F!.%5!1()$*F+>$/(3(/!5.9.8$!9.*J$*+D!6%!.55(&(2%M!<e-!(%50/$+!

&,>$!6! 6-e+!(%!.!+(9(1.*!K.,!.+!6EFZmP!.1&#208#!$)(5$%/$!+088$+&+!&#.&!6EFZmP!$d>*$++(2%!(%!

1()$*!.%5!(1$09!(+!5$>$%5$%&!2%!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8D!

<#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+!9(8#&! =$! )$*,! (9>2*&.%&! 32*! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5!K(&#! <e-! =12/J$*+M! +(%/$!

%$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-!9.,! #.)$! (9>2*&.%&! /2%+$?0$%/$+! 2%! &#$! (%50/&(2%! >*23(1$+! 23! =2&#!

&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZmD!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!#.)$!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!

./0&$! (%31.99.&(2%! +0/#! .+! 46:4! .%5! +$>+(+! .%5! .*$! /1$.*1,! (%&(9.&$1,! (%&$*K2)$%D! 6&! #.+!

.1*$.5,!=$$%!>*2>2+$5!&2!&.*8$&!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4DrjwqZ!P1&#208#!

K$! .%5! 2&#$*+! #.)$! >*2)(5$5! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 6EFZm! .*$! >()2&.1!9$5(.&2*+! 23!

<e-F(%50/$5! &2d(/(&,M! &.*8$&(%8! 2%$! 23! &#$+$! >.&#K.,+! +#2015! =$! 52%$! K(&#! 8*$.&!

/2%+(5$*.&(2%M!.+!&#$,!+$$9!&2!(%&$*./&!/12+$1,D!

Page 154: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 141 of 237

@#2%*'#8=(#<$(&%264$=(

@'"%(

6-eP:Z!J%2/J20&!a6-eP:Z!iQV!9(/$!K$*$!2=&.(%$5!3*29!@D!72%.>.*&$!a"01=$%J(.%!6%+&(&0&$!

23! 4/($%/$M! C2*&08.1VD! <#$+$! 9(/$! K$*$! =./J/*2++$5! 32*! 92*$! &#.%! Z[! 8$%$*.&(2%+! (%&2! .!

#2928$%20+!;rm7EqlN!=./J8*20%5!.%5!K(15!&,>$!1(&&$*9.&$+!K$*$!+$1$/&$5!.+!/2%&*21!8*20>D!

6EFjo:.! iQ! 9(/$! K$*$! .! 8(3&! 3*29! 4$.%! @2,1$! a�,92"$%$&(/+M! 4$.&&1$M! '4PVD! E()$*F+>$/(3(/!

6-eP:ZP1=FiQ! 9(/$! .%5! *$+>$/&()$! K(15! &,>$! 1(&&$*9.&$+! K$*$! J(%51,! >*2)(5$5! =,! '1*(/#!

i.1(%J$! a<K(%/2*$M! g.%%2)$*M! "$*9.%,VD! 4&$3.%! E($%$%J1.0+! .%5! W.*(2! iz+&$*! ag$19#21&R!

g�6M!"$*9.%,V!J(%51,!>*2)(5$5!0+!K(&#!6-euF!.%5!WdFjF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$M!*$+>$/&()$1,D!

P11!.%(9.1+!K$*$!9.(%&.(%$5!(%!/2%)$%&(2%.1!&$9>$*.&0*$F/2%&*211$5M!.(*F/2%5(&(2%$5!.%(9.1!

#20+$+! K(&#! .! ZnF! &2! Z[F#20*F1(8#&l5.*J! /,/1$! .%5! *$/$()$5! 3225! .%5! K.&$*! .5! 1(=(&09D!

Hd>$*(9$%&+! K$*$! >$*32*9$5! (%! .! +>$/(3($5! >.&#28$%(/! 3*$$! .%(9.1! #20+$! K(&#! .8$F+$d!

9.&/#$5! 9(/$! =$&K$$%! oFZj! K$$J+! 215D! P11! .%(9.1! $d>$*(9$%&+! K$*$! .>>*2)$5! =,! &#$!

(%+&(&0&(2%.1!$&#(/+!/299(&&$$!32*!.%(9.1!K$13.*$!23!&#$!-./01&,!23!4/($%/$+M!"#$%&!'%()$*+(&,M!

7$18(09!32112K(%8!&#$!H0*2>$.%!80(5$1(%$+D!!

@'"%(%H:%*'&%<2=(

:$/29=(%.%&!920+$!<e-!K.+!>*250/$5!(%!T$+;%5*+;*/&+".*!.%5!>0*(3($5!&2!#2928$%$(&,!(%!20*!

1.=2*.&2*($+!K(&#! <e-! +>$/(3(/! ./&()(&($+! 23! ZDj! �! Z[o! 6'l!K(&#20&! .%,! 5$&$/&.=1$! $%52&2d(%!

/2%&.9(%.&(2%D! P! 1$&#.1! 52+$! 23! p[! ¡8! 23! <e-M! 5(++21)$5! (%! j[[! ¡1! C74M! K.+! (%G$/&$5!

(%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,! >$*! 920+$D! -2*! &#$! $d>$*(9$%&+! K(&#! 6EFjo:.! iQM! 9(/$! K$*$! /#.11$%8$5!

K(&#!Zr!.%5!p[!¡8D!M/.0"(%../&/L"5)#$&%d#*F5$*()$5!EC4!K.+!>0*/#.+$5! 3*29!4(89.!P15*(/#!

.%5! K.+! .1+2! .59(%(+&$*$5! (%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,! .&! .! /2%/$%&*.&(2%! 23! jr[! ¡8! >$*! 920+$D!

6%&$+&(%.1! 1$.J.8$! K.+!9$.+0*$5! &#*208#! 5$&$/&(2%! 23! (%/*$.+$5! >1.+9.! 3102*$+/$%/$! .3&$*!

2*.1! .59(%(+&*.&(2%!23! r!98!n!J@.!-6<;F5$d&*.%! a4(89.!P15*(/#V!>$*!920+$!r!#20*+!=$32*$!

=1225! +.9>1(%8D! W2%2/12%.1! .%&(F6EFZm! a:B@M! W(%%$.>21(+M! '4PV! .%5! /2%&*21! a68"j.V!

.%&(=25($+!K$*$! .! 8(3&! 3*29!E$2! N22+&$%! a:.5=205!'W;M!e(G9$8$%V! .%5!K$*$! (%G$/&$5! (D>D! j!

Page 155: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 142 of 237

#20*+!=$32*$!<e-!/#.11$%8$!.&!Z[[!¡8!>$*!920+$D!-2*!*(&=*="&(9.8(%8M!9(/$!K$*$!+$5.&$5!K(&#!

(+2310*.%$!.%5!(9.8$5!32*!+$)$*.1!&(9$!>2(%&+!.3&$*!+&(9010+D!W2*&.1(&,!.%5!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!

K$*$!92%(&2*$5!32*!mj!#20*+!.3&$*!&*$.&9$%&D!4$*09!.%5!&(++0$!+.9>1$+!K$*$!/211$/&$5!.&!&#$!

(%5(/.&$5! &(9$! >2(%&+! .3&$*! (%G$/&(2%! 32*! 30*&#$*! (%)$+&(8.&(2%D! -2*! $%*(/#9$%&! 23! (%&$+&(%.1!

$>(&#$1(.1! /$11+M! (1$09!K.+! (+21.&$5! .%5! /0&! 2>$%! 12%8(&05(%.11,D!L(&#! .! +#.*>! /2)$*+1(>M! &#$!

+0*3./$! K.+! +23&1,! +/*.>$5pj! .%5! /211$/&$5! (%! uF9$*/.>&2F$&#.%21! /2%&.(%(%8! :E<F=033$*!

as(.8$%VD! 6%&$+&(%.1! /*,>&+! K$*$! (+21.&$5! .+! >*$)(20+1,! 5$+/*(=$5Dpn! 6%! +#2*&M! (1$09! K.+!

(+21.&$5!.%5!/0&!(%!+9.11$*!>.*&+!(%!/215!C74D!-2112K(%8!+$5(9$%&.&(2%!+&$>+M!+0>$*%.&.%&!K.+!

>.++$5!&#*208#!.!/$11!+&*.(%$*M!&2!$%*(/#!32*!/*,>&!/$11+!.%5!/$%&*(308$5!.&!p[[!8!32*!Z[!9(%!.&!

n¤;D!:eP!K.+!5(*$/&1,!>*$>.*$5!3*29!&#$!*$+01&(%8!>$11$&!.%5!>0*(&,!K.+!)$*(3($5!K(&#!/*,>&!

9.*J$*+!+0/#!.+!!!\E!.%5!S9$"f90%&?!)(.!?:<FC;:D!!

;&&3<46'=24"6%&'=2*)(

<(++0$!+.9>1$+!K$*$!3(d$5!(%!n\!>.*.32*9.15$#,5$!.%5!$9=$55$5!(%!>.*.33(%D!@$>.*.33(%(R$5!

r!£9!+$/&(2%+!K$*$!+&.(%$5!32*!6EFZmPD!6%!+#2*&M!.%&(F6EFZm!.%&(=25,!.%5!g:CF1.=$1$5!*.==(&!

.%&(F82.&! .%&(=25,! a+/Fq[mm! .%5! +/FjYjjU! 4.%&.! ;*0R! 7(2&$/#%2128,M! 6%/DV! K$*$! 0+$5! .%5!

5$)$12>$5!K(&#!pMpcF5(.9(%2=$%R(5(%[email protected]>.&&+VD!g$9.&2d,1(%!K.+!0+$5!.+!.!/20%&$*+&.(%D!

C(/&0*$+! K$*$! &.J$%!K(&#! .%! Q1,9>0+! 7OrZ! 1(8#&! aZ[d! 32*! 1()$*! +$/&(2%+! .%5! j[d! 32*! (1$(.1!

+.9>1$+VD!

;&&3<4$%2%"2'4<(45(;C/-\!(G)(B@(

'1&*.&#(%! +$/&(2%+! 23! 8215! (%&$*3$*F$%/$! /212*! K$*$! /0&! 2%! .%! 01&*.9(/*2&29$! a'1&*./0&! HU!

:$(/#$*&FN0%8V!.%5!/211$/&$5!2%!32*9).*F/2.&$5!/2>>$*!+12&!8*(5+D!712/J(%8!+210&(2%!K.+!0+$5!

&2! 312.&! 8*(5+M! K#(/#! K.+! 32112K$5! =,! (%/0=.&(2%! K(&#! .%&(F6EFZmP! .%&(=25,! 2*! /2%&*21!

.%&(=25,! a+/Fq[mm! 2*! +/Fj[joU! 4.%&.! ;*0R! 7(2&$/#%2128,VD! <#$! 8*(5+!K$*$! 1.=$1$5!K(&#! &#$!

+$/2%5.*,! .%&(=25,M! .%&(F82.&! 68"+! /20>1$5! &2! ZjF%9! 8215! aN./J+2%! 6990%2*$+$.*/#!

E.=2*.&2*($+VD! Ei7!01&*.+&.(%$*!K.+!0+$5! &2!>2+&+&.(%! &#$! +$/&(2%+M!K(&#!0*.%,1! ./$&.&$! .%5!

1$.5!+&.(%D!"*(5+!K$*$!)($K$5!=,!0+(%8!.! NHQE!Z[Z[!<HW!2>$*.&(%8!.&!o[!JID!s0.%&(3(/.&(2%!

K.+!>$*32*9$5!=,!&K2!(%5$>$%5$%&!+/($%&(+&+D!!

Page 156: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 143 of 237

I%2%"2'4<(45(?;9F/$%H2*#<N(;?>fN(;C/-\!W?(#<$(;C/?!RE(

W(/$!K$*$! (%G$/&$5!K(&#! <e-! 2*! EC4! .%5! $0&#.%(R$5! 32*! =1225! /211$/&(2%! .&! (%5(/.&$5! &(9$!

>2(%&+D!71225!K.+! (+21.&$5! &#*208#! /.*5(./!>0%/&0*$! .%5! /211$/&$5! (%! .>>*2>*(.&$! )(.1+D! -2*!

>1.+9.!>*$>.*.&(2%M!=1225!K.+!&*.%+3$**$5!&2!H@<PF/2.&$5!&0=$+!.%5!/$%&*(308$5!.&!9.d(9.1!

+>$$5! 32*! Zr!9(%! .%5! +0>$*%.&.%&!K.+! /211$/&$5D! 4$*09!K.+! /211$/&$5! 32112K(%8! 2)$*%(8#&!

/12&&(%8! .&! n¤;M! /$%&*(308.&(2%! .&!9.d(9.1! +>$$5! .%5! +&2*$5! .&! Fo[¤;! 0%&(1! .++.,$5D! C1.+9.!

3102*$+/$%/$!K.+!9$.+0*$5!.+!¥$dl¥$9!�!noolrj[!%9D!@$&$/&(2%!23!(%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!

>*2&$(%+!K.+!.++.,$5!K(&#!6F-P7C!HE64P!a;0+.=(2!7(2&$/#VD!W20+$!6-eF=!J(&!aC7E!7(29$5(/.1!

E.=2*.&2*($+V!K.+!0+$5!32*!&#$!5$&$/&(2%!23!6-euD!-2*!&#$!5$&$/&(2%!23!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-M!&#$!

E09(%$d! &$/#%2128,! a7(2F:.5V! K.+! 0+$5D! <#$! .32*$9$%&(2%$5! &$/#%(?0$+! K$*$! >$*32*9$5!

.//2*5(%8!&2!&#$!9.%03./&0*$*c+!(%+&*0/&(2%+D!

g79/gEF7(

<(++0$!+.9>1$+!K$*$!/211$/&$5!(%!:eP!E.&$*!aP9=(2%V!.%5!+&2*$5!.&!Fo[¤;D!:eP!K.+!(+21.&$5!

K(&#! &#$! :e$.+,! W(%(! i(&! as(.8$%V! .//2*5(%8! &2! &#$! 9.%03./&0*$*�+! (%+&*0/&(2%+D! :eP!

/2%/$%&*.&(2%!K.+!9$.+0*$5!K(&#!&#$!e.%25*2>Z[[[!a<#$*92!4/($%&(3(/VM!.%5!Z!¡8!:eP!K.+!

0+$5!&2!>*$>.*$!/29>1$9$%&.*,!@eP!K(&#!40>$*4/*(>&!66!a6%)(&*28$%VD!s0.%&(&.&()$!*$.1!&(9$!

C;:! K.+! >$*32*9$5! 0+(%8! 4$%+(-.+&<W! 4,=*! eQF:QO! i(&! a7(21(%$V! .%5! &#$! E(8#&;,/1$*! no[!

a:2/#$VD!Hd>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!K$*$!%2*9.1(R$5!&2!&#$!$d>*$++(2%!23!&#$!j!92+&!+&.=1$!*$3$*$%/$!

8$%$+M!K#(/#!K$*$!5$&$*9(%$5! 32*!$./#! /2%5(&(2%!0+(%8!8$e2*9!a?7.+$M!7(28.R$11$VD!I.10$+!

.*$! *$>*$+$%&$5! .+! *$1.&()$! $d>*$++(2%!%2*9.1(R$5! &2! &#$! 8$29$&*(/!9$.%! 23! &#$! j! +$1$/&$5!

92+&!+&.=1$!*$3$*$%/$!8$%$+D!C*(9$*!+$?0$%/$+!.%5!*$3$*$%/$!8$%$+!/.%!=$!320%5!(%!<.=1$+!Z!

.%5!jD!

12#2'=2'"#8(#<#8)='=(

:$+01&+! a9$.%xF! 4@! 2*! 4HWV! K$*$! /29>.*$5! K(&#! .! jF&.(1$5! 4&05$%&�+! &! &$+&D! 4&.&(+&(/+! 2%!

+0*)().1! /0*)$+! K$*$! >$*32*9$5!K(&#! E28F*.%J! aW.%&$1F;2dV! &$+&+D! C! ).10$+! 1$++! &#.%! [D[r!

K$*$!/2%+(5$*$5!+(8%(3(/.%&D!�!>!¦![M[rM!��!>!¦![M[ZM!���!>!¦![M[[ZM!����!>!§![M[[[Z!

!"J<4K8%$Q%&%<2=(

<#$! P8$%/,! 32*! 6%%2).&(2%! =,! 4/($%/$! .%5! <$/#%2128,! a6L<VM! &#$! :$+$.*/#! -20%5.&(2%!

Page 157: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 144 of 237

-1.%5$*+!a-LQ!I1..%5$*$%V!.%5!&#$!6%&$*0%()$*+(&,!P&&*./&(2%!C21$+!C*28*.9!23!&#$!7$18(.%!

4/($%/$! C21(/,! a6'PCV! 30%5$5! &#(+! K2*JD! L$! K2015! 1(J$! &2! &#.%J! N2J$! I.%5$%! 7$*8#$! 32*!

&$/#%(/.1!.++(+&.%/$!(%!920+$!=*$$5(%8D!!

9#G8%=((

9#G8%(-D(1%g3%<"%=(45(:*'&%*=(54*(g79/EF7

(!9#G8%(+D(ZM%*M'%K(g79/EF7(*%5%*%<"%(Q%<%=(#<$("4<$'2'4<=(

!

(13::8%&%<2#*)(9#G8%=(#<$(?'Q3*%=(

(13::8%&%<2#*)(9#G8%(-D(?48$('<$3"2'4<(45(@H+/83"'5%*#=%(#"2'M'2)('<(*%=:4<=%(24(9>?('<(@H+/

83"'5%*#=%(*%:4*2%*(&'"%(4<(#(K'8$(2):%(#<$(;?>!7-(OZ(G#"JQ*43<$(

(

(

!"#"$ %&'()'*$+',-"'$ ."/"'0"*$+',-"'$

!"#$ !!"#!"#!"!"!$$##""% "##""#"!$!"#!!"!#"$!""%

%&'$ $##"!$$$!$##$$#$!$#$!#"$% "!$!$!!!$$#$$!$$#!$!$%

()"*+$ "#$$#!$##!$"!"#$###% !#$$##"##$$#$#"###$#%

,-.)/$ #$$!!"!"#$!!!$##$$% ##"$!$!$#"#$"!!"#"##$$$"$%

,-.)00$ !"#%#!$%$#$%""#%$#"%#$$%#$#%

$$#%#!"%

$"$%$$!%$$$%!$$%$"$%$$"%$$!%

$$$%"$#%#"#%!#%

,-.)01$ $#$!"!"!!!!"!"""!!"#"% "###"!$#!"!$"#$$!$$$%

,-.2)#"+)3$ "!"#$"#!$#!$##"###% $###!"!"!!$#$!""!"#!"!"#%

,-.&$ "!$#$$"#$#"##"##""#!% #$!!"""!$$$"#!$#"$#$""!$%

,456/$ $"!"!"!!!"$!"!"#!!!"!!"$% %%#!#"$"$$$"!$#!$$"!!!""!$%

78'#09$ !!$$#"#!"#!!#"!$""""!% ##!"!#!$###$"#$"""!$$%

%3"0:$ $#!!!"!$"##"!"##""##""% #!$!"!!#$##!$!"#""$"!!%

,#0;)$ !$##$!#!#!$$$!$"#$% #!$$!$#!$"!$#$#$!$!$#$"%

,#0;-$ !$$#$$$"!!"##"!!""!#% #$#!$"!""!"!!$$!!"#$$%

!"#$%&'(&)%*+%,-%.&/0&1234%2.&$3.5%6&3,&7"5%23"$.&",6&7%58/6.&

!"#$%&'(&)*%+*,%-&./01&+%2%+%34%&5%3%6&"37&4837,9836&

!"#$%& '(%)*+*(%& ,-.-"-%/-&#-%-0&

!"#$%& &'()*$& !!"#$!+!%&#'(!

,*$-.& &'()*$& "#$&+&%&#'(!

,*$-.& &"/0$10"/2*&13%24"/5& "#$!+&%&#'(!

,*$-.& &3%6401& "#$!)!*+,!

!"#$%&'$()*&"'%"+%,-./#()&+01230% 4&501% 6#0(7% 8&$'09% :12&'% ;<#00'%

!"#$%&'()% *+*,% -+-,% .+/,% .+0,% ,+0*%

12345.%67% 8+/,% -+,,% .+/,% .% ,+09%

!"##$%&%'()*+,-).$%,/0,12$3,4'3"562',27,89:;$"547%*)<%,)56=4(+,4',*%<#2'<%,(2,

->1,4',89:;$"547%*)<%,*%#2*(%*,&45%,2',),?4$3,(+#%,)'3,@1>AB/,CD,.)5EF*2"'3G,

Page 158: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 145 of 237

!13::8%&%<2#*)(?'Q3*%(-D(9>?/'<$3"%$(@H+/83"'5%*#=%(#"2'M'2)(*%=382=(5*4&(;?>!7-(#<$(;C/+]7#(

='Q<#8'<Q(

!a!/BV!WdjF10/(3$*.+$!9(/$!2%!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!=./J8*20%5!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!<e-!2*!C74U!2*8.%+!K$*$!(+21.&$5!p!#20*+!.3&$*!+&(9010+!.%5!#2928$%(R$5D!E0/(3$*.+$!./&()(&,!K.+!5$&$/&$5!(%!a!V!+>1$$%M! aRV! 1()$*M! aFV! J(5%$,M! aIV! (1$09! .%5! aBV! =*.(%D! a?/AV! 6EFjo:.! iQ! 9(/$! K$*$! (%G$/&$5! K(&#!+$)$*.1!52+$+!23!<e-!&2!+&05,!&#$(*!*$+(+&.%/$!.8.(%+&!1$&#.1(&,D!W(/$!K$*$!92%(&2*$5!32*!9.d(9.1!o[!#20*+D!<e-!K.+! (%G$/&$5! .&! a?V! Zr!¡8! .%5! aAV! p[!¡8!>$*!920+$D!71./J! 3011! /0*)$A! 6EFjo:.!iQU!=1./J!52&&$5!/0*)$A!6EFjo:.!L<!a%!�!oFZ[VD(

(

(

(

!13::8%&%<2#*)( ?'Q3*%( +D( g79/EF7( #<#8)='=( 45( &7>!( %H2*#"2%$( 5*4&( K648%( '8%3&( 54*( 26%(

$%2%"2'4<(45(;17B(Q%<%=(#52%*(9>?(

L(15! &,>$!9(/$!K$*$! &*$.&$5!K(&#! <e-! .%5! .&! [M! Z! .%5! q! #20*+! .3&$*! /#.11$%8$M! (1$09!K.+! (+21.&$5D!W$++$%8$*!:eP!K.+!$d&*./&$5! 3*29!K#21$! (1$09!.%5!?C;:!K.+!>$*32*9$5! 32*! &#$!5$&$/&(2%!23! 64:H!8$%$+D! a!V! ?_+.ZG! K.+! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 0>*$801.&$5! 2%$! #20*! .3&$*! <e-M! =0&! %2&! ,-*)D! .%5! <$4ZRD! 7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!

!

(

!"

0 4 0 40

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

106

1/g)

Spleen

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

0 4 0 40

1000

2000

3000

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

107 1

/g)

Liver

****

****

******

#"

0 4 0 40

2000

4000

6000

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

106 1

/g)

Ileum

**

*

**

$"

0 4 0 40

100

200

300

400

500

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

106 1

/g)

Brain

*****

*

%"

0 4 0 40

500

1000

1500

Time after TNF (hours)

RLU

/tiss

ue (x

106 1

/g)

Kidney

**

*

******

&" '"

("

0 10 20 30 400

20

40

60

80

100

Time after TNF (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

0 20 40 60 80 1000

20

40

60

80

100

Time after TNF (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

IL-28Ra WTIL-28Ra KO

0 1 60

50

100

150

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl1

0

*

0 1 60

20

40

60

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fit2

0 1 60

10

20

30

40

Time after TNF (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18

!"

Page 159: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 146 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! e.05X!CNLM!5$%!72$*!N!.M!E0(&$%!C"WM!H(+$1!'EWD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!/*2++F&.1JD!WT6M&cD!j[ZZUjmoaqVAoooFYoD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZmnjFnqroDj[ZZD[o[ZmDdD!

jD!! :(/#&$*!;M!W$++$*+/#9(5&!4M!g21$(&$*!"M!$&!.1D!<#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+&.1J!*$8(2%+!5$3(%$!*$+>2%+()$%$++!&2!+210=1$!)$*+0+!9$9=*.%$F=20%5!1(8.%5D!!".&?%..&6*".D!j[ZjUpjaZpVAjrZrFjYD!

52(AZ[DZZjolW;7D[qnroFZZD!

pD!! W0J.(!�M!4#(=.&.!gM!e.J.90*.!<M!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*$F30%/&(2%!*$1.&(2%+#(>!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*!(%&$*./&(2%!=.+$5!2%!p@!+&*0/&0*.1!.%.1,+(+!23!.!3011,!./&()$!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()$!<e-!90&.%&D!c&

!".&6*".D!j[[YUporanVAZjjZFYD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG9=Dj[[oDZZD[rpD!

nD!! P%&2%(!;M!7*.0%!ND!4(5$!$33$/&+!23!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,A!/0**$%&!J%2K1$58$D!?.*(&T_4&>;%#0/)".D!j[[jUj[aq!

40>>1!joVA4ZrjFmD!

rD!! i.++(2&(+!"M!i211(.+!"D!<e-!.%5!*$/$>&2*+!(%!2*8.%F+>$/(3(/!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$A!901&(F1.,$*$5!30%/&(2%(%8!

9(**2*$5!(%!.%(9.1!925$1+D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[ZUZ[maZjVAZr[mFoD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6ZppqjD!

qD!! i211(.+!"M!i2%&2,(.%%(+!@D!:21$!23!<e-l<e-:!(%!.0&2(990%(&,A!+>$/(3(/!<e-!*$/$>&2*!=12/J.5$!9.,!=$!.5).%&.8$20+!&2!.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&+D!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[[jUZpanFrVApZrFpjZD!

52(AZ[DZ[Zql4ZprYFqZ[Za[jV[[[ZYFYD!

mD!! E.%&$*%($*!-M!<0=./#!-M!:.).05!CM!$&!.1D!6%/(5$%/$!.%5!*(+J!3./&2*+!23!E$8(2%$11.!>%$092>#(1.!>%$092%(.!50*(%8!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,A!.!>*2+>$/&()$!-*$%/#!+&05,D!?;%$)D!j[ZpUZnnapVAYY[FoD!

52(AZ[DZpmol/#$+&DZjFjoj[D!

oD!! 4&(5#.9!:LM!E$$!<;gM!g(88(%+!C@:M!$&!.1D!4,+&$9.&(/!*$)($K!K(&#!%$&K2*J!9$&.F.%.1,+(+A!&#$!$33(/./,!23!.%&(F<e-!.8$%&+!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$D!U.*0%()&\;/50/+".&A;%5D!j[ZnUpYaZjVAZpnYFqjD!

52(AZ[DZZZZl.>&DZjmnYD!

YD!! P&R$%(!-M!<0*($1!WM!;.>+2%(!-M!@2*(.!PM!W$*2%(!CM!4.*R(FC0&&(%(!CD!P0&2(990%(&,!.%5!.%&(F<e-F.1>#.!

.8$%&+D!U((&V&n&U+/7&M+*D!j[[rUZ[rZArrYFqYD!52(AZ[DZZYql.%%.1+DZpqZDZ[[D!

Z[D!! @$!L$$*5!e!.M!4.9.*.G(K.!4!.M!g$*&R28!CND!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!*$/$>&2*+A!=(2/#$9(+&*,!.%5!=(2128(/.1!

30%/&(2%+D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[[mUjojajoVAj[[rpFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/D:m[[[[qj[[D!

ZZD!! <+.2!eM!g+0!gCM!L0!;WM!E(0!;;M!E$(!g�D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!/.0+$+!.%!(%/*$.+$!(%!=1225F=*.(%!

=.**($*!>$*9$.=(1(&,!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!c&!%7&!*+5"L*".D!j[[ZUr[aYVAoZjFjZD!

ZjD!! <.J.#.+#(!eM!I.%1.$*$!6M!5$!:,/J$!:M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!>*250/$5!=,!C.%$&#!/$11+!5*()$+!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JD!c&T_4&

!%7D!j[[oUj[raoVAZmrrFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[o[rooD!

ZpD!! g0,+!EM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!@$G.8$*!EM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!5*()$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1!+#2/JD!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[YUj[qaYVAZompFojD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[Y[jZpD!

ZnD!! i2&#.*(!eM!728*.!NM!P==.+!gM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9!*$+01&+!(%!#(8#!<e-!1$)$1!(%!

+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!?9)"B*(%D!j[ZpUqZajVAqmqFoZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&2Dj[ZjDZZD[ZqD!

ZrD!! i25.9.!4M!@.)(+!WM!-.0+&9.%!@ED!<#$!&#$*.>$0&(/!>2&$%&(.1!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!32*!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$A!.!9$/#.%(+&(/.11,!=.+$5!#,>2&#$+(+D!?%..&!".&S*-%&M+*D!j[[rUqjaZqVAZor[FqjD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+[[[ZoF

[[rFr[jjFqD!

ZqD!! �#.%8!sM!;0(!-M!-.%8!EM!g2%8!NM!�#$%8!7M!�#.%8!N�D!<e-Fv!(9>.(*+!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!.%5!30%/&(2%!23!<"-FuF(%50/$5!<*$8!/$11+!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!&#*208#!PJ&!.%5!49.5p!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,D!c&!".&?%..&6*".D!

j[ZpUrajVAorFYoD!52(AZ[DZ[YplG9/=l9G+[qpD!

Page 160: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 147 of 237

ZmD!! ;2%(81(.*2!CM!C$**(/2%$!;M!7$%+2%!:PM!$&!.1D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!+,+&$9!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+D!U#)"*00#(*)9D!

j[Z[UnpapVAjj[FrD!52(AZ[DpZ[Yl[oYZqYp[Y[prZ[YZnD!

ZoD!! ;#20=$,!@M!W2058(1!i@D!6%&$*3$*2%+!(%!.0&2(990%$!.%5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+A!*$801.&(2%!.%5!*21$+D!c&

,()%5-%5"(&?9)"B*(%&>%$D!j[ZZUpZaZjVAormFqrD!52(AZ[DZ[oYlG(*Dj[ZZD[Z[ZD!

ZYD!! ;2%*.5!7D!C2&$%&(.1!9$/#.%(+9+!23!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!(%50/$5!.0&2(990%(&,D!U#)"*00#(*)9D!

j[[pUpqaoVArZYFjpD!

j[D!! :z%%=129!EM!H12*.%&.!WFED!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.&0*$!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!?#55&^4*(&>;%#0/)".D!

j[ZpUjrajVAjnoFrpD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml7Q:D[=[Zp$pjopr/m$pjD!

jZD!! @$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$),)$*!4M!7.11$8$$*!WM!$&!.1D!C#.*9./2128(/.1!6%#(=(&(2%!23!<,>$!6!6-e!4(8%.1(%8!C*2&$/&+!

W(/$!.8.(%+&!E$&#.1!4$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZnAZFpjD!

jjD!! i.*.8#(2+233!WM!4&$(%=2*%!:M!i2).*(J!CM!$&!.1D!;$%&*.1!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!<,Jj!(%!

1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F(%50/$5!$%52&2d(%!+#2/JD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[[pUnarVAnmZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(YZ[D!

jpD!! 4/#K.%5&!<M!4/#09.J!7M!"($1$%!"gM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!=,!+>1$%(/!9./*2>#.8$+!

+0>>*$++$+!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!T!6^&cD!j[ZjUpZaZVAj[ZFZpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol$9=2GDj[ZZDpo[D!

jnD!! �.*(1(%.!PM!C.*JFW(%!iFgM!P%&2%()!<M!g0!OM!6).+#J()!E7D!<e-!./&().&$+!.%!6:-ZF5$>$%5$%&!.0&2/*(%$!122>!1$.5(%8!&2!+0+&.(%$5!$d>*$++(2%!23!/#$92J(%$+!.%5!4<P<ZF5$>$%5$%&!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%F*$+>2%+$!8$%$+D!

V/)&,00#(".D!j[[oUYanVApmoFomD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(ZrmqD!

jrD!! �.*(1(%.!PM!6).+#J()!E7D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!%$K!>1.,$*!(%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8D!?#55&3*5&U#)"*00#(D!

j[Z[UZZAYnFZ[nD!52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[joYZYYD!

jqD!! I$%J.&$+#!@M!H*%.%5$R!<M!:2+$&&(!-M!$&!.1D!H%52&#$1(.1!<e-!*$/$>&2*!j!(%50/$+!6:-Z!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*F5$>$%5$%&!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!.0&2/*(%$!+(8%.1(%8!&2!>*292&$!92%2/,&$!*$/*0(&9$%&D!,00#(*)9D!

j[ZpUpoarVAZ[jrFpmD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpD[ZD[ZjD!

jmD!! ;.%&.$*&!<M!7.$&$%!@M!<.J!CCM!).%!7..*+$%!E"WD!<,>$!6!6-e!.%5!<e-v!/*2++F*$801.&(2%!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$A!=.+(/!/2%/$>&+!.%5!/1(%(/.1!*$1$).%/$D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[Z[UZjarVAjZYD!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*pZr[D!

joD!! E($%$%J1.0+!4M!;2*%(&$+/0!WM!�($&.*.!eM!$&!.1D!e2)$1!*$>2*&$*!920+$!*$)$.1+!/2%+&(&0&()$!.%5!(%31.99.&2*,!

$d>*$++(2%!23!6-eF=$&.!(%!)()2D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZoparVApjjYFpqD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[njmmD!

jYD!! C01)$*$*!NHM!:.%5!'M!E($%$%J1.0+!4M!$&!.1D!<$9>2*.1!.%5!+>.&(.1!*$+210&(2%!23!&,>$!6!.%5!666!(%&$*3$*2%!

*$+>2%+$+!(%!)()2D!c&@*5".D!j[Z[UonaZmVAoqjqFpoD!52(AZ[DZZjolNI6D[[p[pFZ[D!

p[D!! W.#($0!<M!C.*J!NWM!:$)$&+!gM!$&!.1D!<#$!K(15F5$*()$5!(%=*$5!920+$!+&*.(%!4C:H<lH(!(+!*$+(+&.%&!&2!EC4!.%5!5$3$/&()$!(%!6-eF=$&.!>*250/&(2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[qUZ[pamVAjjYjFmD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[rZ[omnZ[pD!

pZD!! E($#1!CM!�0R.*&$FE0�+!IM!;#.%!NM!$&!.1D!g2+&F/$11!+$%+2*+!32*!C1.+925(09!./&().&$!(%%.&$!(990%(&,!.8.(%+&!

1()$*F+&.8$!(%3$/&(2%D!V/)&!%7D!j[ZnUj[aZVAnmFrpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%9DpnjnD!

pjD!! I.1$%&(%FI$8.!�PM!QJ.%2!gM!E2R.%2!"D!<#$!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09!/29>$%+.&$+!32*!>rpF9$5(.&$5!/$11!5$.&#!

.%5!80.*.%&$$+!2*8.%(+9.1!+0*)().1D!?%..&3%/);&3*--%5D!j[[oUZraZZVAZmmjFoZD!52(AZ[DZ[pol/55Dj[[oDZ[YD!

ppD!! W0%.J.&.!iM!�.9.92&2!WM!P%G(J(!eM!$&!.1D!69>2*&.%/$!23!&#$!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!+,+&$9!(%!90*(%$!1.*8$!(%&$+&(%$!(%5(/.&$5!=,!9(/*2.**.,!.%.1,+(+!23!/299$%+.1!=./&$*(.F(%50/$5!(990%2128(/.1!/#.%8$+D!6!?&

'%("0*+$D!j[[oUYAZYjD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmZFjZqnFYFZYjD!

pnD!! 4.&2!<M!I*($+!:"M!4%(>>$*&!gNM!$&!.1D!4(%81$!E8*r!+&$9!/$11+!=0(15!/*,>&F)(110+!+&*0/&0*$+!(%!)(&*2!K(&#20&!.!

9$+$%/#,9.1!%(/#$D!V/)#5%D!j[[YUnrYamjnnVAjqjFrD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%.&0*$[mYprD!

Page 161: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 148 of 237

prD!! I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!@$G2%/J#$$*$!HM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!$&!.1D!W.&*(d!9$&.112>*2&$(%.+$!Zp!92501.&$+!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(.1!=.**($*!(%&$8*(&,!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!=,!./&().&(%8!<e-D!T!6^&!".&!%7D!

j[ZpUramVAYpjFnoD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$999Dj[Zj[jZ[[D!

pqD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!P*9.J.!WM!i.*.8(.%%(!eM!$&!.1D!4.3$!<e-F=.+$5!.%&(&092*!&#$*.>,!32112K(%8!

>rr<e-:!*$50/&(2%!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZpUZjpaqVAjrY[Fq[pD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qrqjnD!

pmD!! E$W$++0*($*!i4M!g�/J$*!gM!;#(!EM!<029.%$%!HM!:$5$/J$!ID!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!>*2&$/&+!.8.(%+&!>%$092/2//.1!(%).+()$!5(+$.+$!=,!(%#(=(&(%8!=./&$*(.1!&*.%+9(8*.&(2%!./*2++!&#$!10%8D!\S"M&\/);"8D!

j[ZpUYaZZVA$Z[[pmjmD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>>.&DZ[[pmjmD!

poD!! "211(%!"M!W.*J+!;M!W.*J+!LgD!6%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!(%!+$*09!.%5!0*(%$!*$31$/&+!$.*1,!

(+/#$9(/!(%G0*,!&2!&#$!+9.11!=2K$1D!M#58%59D!ZYYpUZZparVArnrFrZD!

pYD!! @$*(Jd!NCD!e2%F(%).+()$!9.*J$*+!23!80&!K.11!(%&$8*(&,!(%!#$.1&#!.%5!5(+$.+$D!e"5.7&c&'/$)5"%()%5".D!

j[Z[UZqanjVArjmjD!52(AZ[DpmnolKG8D)ZqD(njDrjmjD!

n[D!! ;.0K$1+!PM!70,+!H4M!<#22%$%!:M!$&!.1D!e(&*(&$!>*2&$/&+!.8.(%+&!92*=(5(&,!.%5!92*&.1(&,!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!<e-F!2*!EC4F(%50/$5!+#2/J!(%!.!+210=1$!80.%,1.&$!/,/1.+$F5$>$%5$%&!9.%%$*D!c&T_4&!%7D!

j[[YUj[qaZpVAjYZrFjnD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[YZjpqD!

nZD!! ;.0K$1+!.M!I.%!W211$!LM!N.%++$%!7M!$&!.1D!C*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!<e-F(%50/$5!1$&#.1!+#2/J!=,!+210=1$!80.%,1.&$!/,/1.+$!(%#(=(&(2%!*$?0(*$+!30%/&(2%.1!(%50/(=1$!%(&*(/!2d(5$!+,%&#.+$D!,00#(*)9D!

j[[[UZpajVAjjpFpZD!

njD!! g$%*,!<M!i(*(9.%G$+K.*.!"4M!:0=,!<M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!6-e!4(8%.1(%8!;2%+&*.(%+!6EFZmPl-!4$/*$&(2%!=,!<!;$11+!

50*(%8!7./&$*(.1!6%3$/&(2%+D!c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZonamVApmrrFpmqmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[j[qrD!

npD!! :.9821.9!I4M!4#.!�M!N(%!NM!�#.%8!OM!W.*J2)(/FC1$+$!4D!6-eF=$&.!(%#(=(&+!#09.%!<#Zm!/$11!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D!c&

,00#(".D!j[[YUZopaoVArnZoFjmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[pjjmD!

nnD!! ;0(!-M!W$%8!NM!E02!CM!;#$%!CD!6-eF!.1>#.!=12/J+!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%!=,!>$*(>#$*.1!=1225!92%2%0/1$.*!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!./&()$!#$>.&(&(+!7!6%3$/&(2%D!6!?&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZnUZnArrD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmZFjppnF

ZnFrrD!

nrD!! "02!7M!;#.%8!H�M!;#$%8!"D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!(%50/&(2%!>.&#K.,!/2%+&*.(%+!<#ZmF9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!

(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[oUZZoarVAZqo[FY[D!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pppnjD!

nqD!! C.%&$1,0+#(%!4M!g..J!4M!6%8215!7M!$&!.1D!:2*y&x!(%%.&$!1,9>#2/,&$+!.%5!y�!<!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(32*9!

>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjaqVAjjrjFqD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZoqjD!

nmD!! "2*52%!:PM!"*(82*($)!"M!E$$!PM!i.11(21(.+!"@M!6).+#J()!E7D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.&0*$!.%5!4<P<Z!$d>*$++(2%!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!+,%2)(.1!310(5!9./*2>#.8$+!.*$!(%50/$5!=,!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!v!.%5!/20%&$*F*$801.&$5!=,!&#$!+,%2)(.1!310(5!9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[ZjUqnaZ[VApZZYFjoD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DpnrnnD!

noD!! -(%J!iM!W.*&(%!EM!W0J.K$*.!HM!$&!.1D!6-eul<e-v!+,%$*8(+9!(%50/$+!.!%2%F/.%2%(/.1!4<P<jl6:-YF5$>$%5$%&!>.&#K.,!&*(88$*(%8!.!%2)$1!@'QOj!eP@Cg!2d(5.+$F9$5(.&$5!.(*K.,!.%&()(*.1!*$+>2%+$D!?%..&

>%$D!j[ZpUjparVAqmpFY[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol/*Dj[ZpDnmD!

nYD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

r[D!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!"*(%$!EM!$&!.1D!<e-:ZF(%50/$5!1$&#.1!(%31.99.&(2%!(+!9$5(.&$5!

=,!82=1$&!.%5!C.%$&#!/$11!5,+30%/&(2%D!!#+"$/.&,00#(".D!

rZD!! s(%!gFNM!-$%8!sFWM!-.%8!�M!4#$%!ED!<,>$F6!(%&$*3$*2%!+$/*$&(2%!(%!&#$!./0&$!>#.+$!>*292&$+!;*,>&2/2//0+!%$232*9.%+!(%3$/&(2%F(%50/$5!<#Zm!/$11!>21.*(R.&(2%!(%!)(&*2D!T_4&A;%5&!%7D!j[ZnUmanVAoqYFomjD!

52(AZ[DpoYjl$&9Dj[ZnDZrZmD!

Page 162: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 149 of 237

rjD!! @$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$),)$*!4M!7.11$8$$*!WM!$&!.1D!C#.*9./2128(/.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!

>*2&$/&+!9(/$!.8.(%+&!1$&#.1!+$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZpUj[YaqVAYq[Fm[D!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%35(+lG(&q[[D!

rpD!! L..8$!PM!g.1+&$%+$%!PM!H+>$)(J!<D!P++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%!+$*09!.%5!3.&.1!20&/29$!

(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!9$%(%82/2//.1!5(+$.+$D!S/(+%)D!ZYomUZaorjYVAprrFmD!

rnD!! W(/#($!g:M!W.%280$!i:M!4>*(88+!@:M!$&!.1D!@$&$/&(2%!23!/(*/01.&(%8!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.3&$*!$%52&2d(%!

.59(%(+&*.&(2%D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!ZYooUpZoajpVAZnoZFqD!52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNWZYoo[q[YpZojp[ZD!

rrD!! 7$0&1$*!7M!W.#2%$,!NM!E$!<*.%8!eM!C$J.1.!CM!;$*.9(!PD!C0*(3(/.&(2%!23!/./#$/&(%M!.!1(>2>*2&$(%!1(>.+$F

+0>>*$++(%8!#2*92%$!+$/*$&$5!=,!$%52&2d(%F(%50/$5!:PL!jqnDm!/$11+D!c&T_4&!%7D!ZYorUZqZarVAYonFYrD!

rqD!! W.#($0!<M!E(=$*&!;D!4#2015!K$!(%#(=(&!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!(%!+$>+(+S!,(-%+)&,00#(D!j[[mUmraZVAjjFYD!

52(AZ[DZZjol6P6D[[ojYF[qD!

rmD!! <*(%/#($*(!"D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!3*($%5!2*!32$S!c&T_4&!%7D!j[Z[Uj[maZ[VAj[rpFqpD!

52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[Z[ZqqnD!

roD!! 72+9.%%!WM!L.*5!CPD!<#$*.>$0&(/!>2&$%&(.1!23!&.*8$&(%8!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjp!(%!+$>+(+D!?.*(&A5/($.&!%7D!

j[ZjUZaZVAnD!52(AZ[DZZoqlj[[ZFZpjqFZFnD!

rYD!! -1($*1!WPM!:(&&(*+/#!@M!".2!gM!$&!.1D!P5)$*+$!30%/&(2%+!23!6EFZmP!(%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!+$>+(+D!WUMT6&cD!

j[[oUjjamVAjZYoFj[rD!52(AZ[DZ[Yql3GD[mFZ[rjjZD!

q[D!! O0!:M!L.%8!:M!g.%!"M!$&!.1D!;29>1$9$%&!;r.!*$801.&$+!6EFZm!=,!.33$/&(%8!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!@;!.%5!8.99.5$1&.!<!/$11+!(%!;ECF(%50/$5!+$>+(+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[Z[Un[anVAZ[mYFooD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[[Yn[[ZrD!

qZD!! E)!4M!g.%!WM!�(!:M!iK2%!4M!@.(!;M!L.%8!:D!P%&(F<e-Fv!&#$*.>,!32*!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$>+(+A!.!+,+&$9.&(/!9$&.F

.%.1,+(+D!,()&c&?.*(&\5/+)D!j[ZnUqoanVArj[FoD!52(AZ[DZZZZl(G/>DZjpojD!!

!

! !

Page 163: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 150 of 237

+!b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(9>?('<(=64"J(=)<$*4&%=!!

I43G8%(I%5'"'%<")('<(9>?(#<$(9):%(;(;?>(1'Q<#8'<Q(

C%#$=(24(B<6#<"%$(E*42%"2'4<('<(B<$424H%&'#((

E,%5.!"*(%$ZMjM!!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$ZMjM!E($%!@$G.8$*ZMjM!@$1>#(%$!@$9$$+&$*$ZMjM!;1.05$!E(=$*&ZMj�!!Z,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6:&';%():&6%.8*#0&D3%4/5)0%()&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&';%():&6%.8*#0&

!�!;2**$+>2%5(%8!.0&#2*A!;1.05$!E(=$*&M!/1.05$D1(=$*&¨6*/DI(=F'8$%&D=$!!;2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&A!<#$!.0&#2*+!5$/1.*$!&#.&!%2!/2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&!$d(+&+D!!\5%.*0*(/59&7/)/O&

!F4<2*'G32'4<=A!E,%5.!"*(%$!>$*32*9$5!2*!80(5$5!.11!$d>$*(9$%&.1!K2*J!.%5!K*2&$!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&D!@$1>#(%$!@$9$$+&$*$!>$*32*9$5!&#$!<e-:Z!HE64P!32*!-(80*$!j@!.%5!&#$!E09(%$d!.++.,! 32*!6EFZm-!.%5!6EFjp>ZY!(%!40>>1$9$%&.1!-(80*$!Z7D!@*D! :22+9.*(G%! HD! I.%5$%=*20/J$! 8.).8$5! 9(/$! K(&#! -6<;F5$d&*.%! 32*! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.++.,!(%!-(80*$!p7D!!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$M!@*D!E($%!@$G.8$*!.%5!C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!+0>$*)(+$5!&#$!5$+(8%!.%5!>$*32*9.%/$+!23!&#$!$d>$*(9$%&+D!

!

! !

Page 164: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 151 of 237

!"#$%&'(&)*+*&,+-'*,'./0'1,('2-3&'4'40/'

!"#$%&"$#'&(%)!'*+'($,%$-()'./+*(-*"+$'"$'

!"#$%$&!'()!

!G=2*#"2(

4$>+(+! *$+01&+! 3*29! &#$! #2+&! #,>$*(%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$! &2! +,+&$9(/! (%3$/&(2%M! /.0+(%8!

901&(>1$! 2*8.%! 3.(10*$! .%5! #(8#! 92*&.1(&,D! L$! >*$)(20+1,! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! (9>.(*$5! 6-eP:Z!

+(8%.1(%8! 1$.5+! &2! >*2&$/&(2%! .8.(%+&! 1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$! aEC4V! .%5! /$/.1! 1(8.&(2%! >0%/&0*$!

a;ECVD!<#$!*21$!23!<e-:Z!(%!&#$+$!925$1+!#.+!=$$%!+&05($5!.+!K$11!.%5!*$>2*&$5!=,!2&#$*+D!6%!

&#(+!+&05,M!K$!5$92%+&*.&$!&#.&!EC4!(+!0%.=1$!&2! (%50/$!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!

6-eP:ZM! 9$.+0*$5! =,! 6EF-P7C! 1$)$1+! (%! /(*/01.&(2%M! K#$*$.+! 6EF-P7C! 1$)$1+! (%! <e-:Z!

J%2/J20&!aiQV!9(/$!K$*$!/29>.*.=1$!&2!K(15!&,>$D!'+(%8!3102*$+/$%&1,!1.=$1$5!-6<;F5$d&*.%M!

K$!320%5!&#.&!EC4!/.0+$5!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!=0&!%2&!(%!

<e-:Z! iQD! <2! (%)$+&(8.&$! /*2++! &.1J! =$&K$$%! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! 520=1$! J%2/J20&! 9(/$!

1./J(%8! =2&#! 6-eP:Z! .%5! <e-:Z! K$*$! $+&.=1(+#$5! .%5! K$*$! 320%5! &2! 5(+>1.,! (9>*2)$5!

+0*)().1!.8.(%+&!EC4M!=0&!%2&!;ECD!40>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1!K.+!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!

1$++!#,>2&#$*9(.M!%2! (%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$!2*! 1$.J.8$M! .%5! 12K$*!+,+&$9(/!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%!

+0/#!.+!W6CFZuM!"WF;4-M!6EFZuM!6EFZ[!.%5!6EFZmPD!-0*&#$*92*$M!K$!5$92%+&*.&$5!&#.&!<e-:Z!

+(8%.1(%8! 52$+! %2&! .33$/&! &,>$! 6! 6-e! >*250/&(2%! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! EC4! .%5! (9>.(*$5! 6-eP:Z!

+(8%.1(%8!5(5!%2&!.33$/&!EC4F(%50/$5!+$*09! 1$)$1+!23!<e-!.%5!+210=1$!<e-:ZD!<#$*$32*$M!K$!

/2%/105$!&#.&!6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!/.%!.33$/&!+$>.*.&$1,!&#$!(%&$8*(&,!23!&#$!80&M!=0&!.1+2!/.%!./&!

(%!/2%/$*&!&2!$%#.%/$!EC4F(%50/$5!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!&#*208#!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%D!

Page 165: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 152 of 237

;<2*4$3"2'4<(

7./&$*$9(.! (+! &#$! >*$+$%/$! 23! =./&$*(.! (%! &#$! =1225M! K#(/#! /.%! &*(88$*! .! #2+&c+!

#,>$*(%31.99.&2*,! *$+>2%+$DZ! <#(+! 9.,! 1$.5! &2! +$)$*$! +$>+(+M! *$+01&(%8! (%! 901&(>1$! 2*8.%!

3.(10*$! aWQ-V! .%5! #(8#!92*&.1(&,DjMp! <#$! *$/28%(&(2%! 23! =./&$*(.! =,! &#$! #2+&! (+!9$5(.&$5! =,!

+$)$*.1! >.&&$*%F*$/28%(&(2%! *$/$>&2*+! aC::VM! +0/#! .+! <211FE(J$F:$/$>&2*Fn! a<E:nVDn! <E:n!

*$/28%(R$+!.!921$/01$!2%!&#$!"*.9F%$8.&()$!=./&$*(.1!+0*3./$!/.11$5!1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$!aEC4VM!

K#(/#! (%! &0*%! ./&().&$+!<E:nD! 6%! +29$! /(*/09+&.%/$+! $d/$++()$!<E:n!./&().&(2%! /.%! 1$.5! &2!

2)$*./&().&(2%! 23! (990%$! /$11+M! *$+01&(%8! (%! $d/$++()$! (%31.99.&(2%! .%5! $)$%! 1$&#.1(&,D!

7$/.0+$!23! (&+!>2&$%&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!./&()(&,! .%5! (&+! .=0%5.%/$! (%! &#$! /$11!K.11! 23!"*.9F

%$8.&()$! =./&$*(.M! EC4! (+! 23&$%! 0+$5! .+! .! 925$1! 32*! /1(%(/.1! +$>&(/! +,%5*29$! (%50/(%8! .!

#,>$*(%31.99.&2*,!+&.&$M!/.11$5!$%52&2d$9(.D!6%5$$5M!(%&*.>$*(&2%$.1!(%G$/&(2%!23!EC4!(%!9(/$!

/.%!1$.5!&2!5$.&#!50$!&2!(&+!&2d(/(&,Dr!P59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!EC4!(+!.!+&$*(1$!925$1M!K#(/#!9(9(/+!

$.*1,!+,9>&29+!23!"*.9F%$8.&()$!+$>+(+!K(&#20&!&#$!./&0.1!>*$+$%/$!23!.%,!=./&$*(.1!(%3$/&(2%D!

6&!(+!J%2K%!&#.&!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!).*(20+!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!+0/#!.+!<092*!e$/*2+(+!

-./&2*!a<e-VM! 6%&$*1$0J(%!a6EVFZuM! 6EFq!.%5!6%&$*3$*2%+!a6-e+V!9$5(.&$! &#$!&2d(/(&,!23!EC4DqwY!

g2K$)$*M!2&#$*!925$1+!#.)$!=$$%!5$)$12>$5!2)$*!&#$!,$.*+!&2!9(9(/!&#$!5$1$&$*(20+!$)$%&+!

(%!+$>+(+!+0/#!.+!/$/.1!1(8.&(2%!>0%/&0*$!a;ECVM!K#(/#!#.+!=$$%!*$)($K$5!.+!.!+$>+(+!925$1!=,!

20*!8*20>DZ[!<#*208#!.!+0*8(/.1!>*2/$50*$M!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!(+!(%50/$5!.%5!1$&#.1(&,!/.%!

2//0*DZZ!P1&#208#!92*$! /12+$1,! *$1.&$5! &2!#09.%! +$>+(+M! (&! (+!90/#!92*$! /29>1$d! &#.%!EC4!

.%5!*$?0(*$+!+&*(/&!/2%+(+&$%/,!(%!#.%51(%8D!

<e-!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*+!<e-:Z!a>rrV!.%5!<e-:j!a>mrV!#.)$!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!(%31.99.&(2%!

.%5!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!#.+!=$$%!320%5!.+!.!+0//$++301!+&*.&$8,!(%!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!).*(20+!

/#*2%(/!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+DZjwZo!P59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!#(8#!52+$+!23!<e-!(+!1$&#.1!.%5!(&+!*21$!(%!

./0&$!(%31.99.&2*,!/2%5(&(2%+!+0/#!.+!+$>+(+!#.+!=$$%!$d&$%+()$1,!+&05($5D!e$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!

<e-! K.+! >*2>2+$5! .+! &*$.&9$%&! 32*! +$>+(+ZYMj[! .%5! (%(&(.1! $d>$*(9$%&+! (%! .%(9.1+! K$*$!

Page 166: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 153 of 237

$%/20*.8(%8!.+!<e-!=12/J.8$!+#2K$5! (%/*$.+$5!+0*)().1!*.&$+M!=0&! (&+!$33$/&! (%!#09.%!&*(.1+!

.*$!5(+.>>2(%&(%8jZwjn!g2K$)$*M!.!*$/$%&!9$&.F.%.1,+(+!+088$+&+!&#.&!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8!3*29!

+$)$*$!+$>+(+!.%5!#(8#!6EFq!1$)$1+!9.,!=$%$3(&!3*29!(990%2&#$*.>,!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.%&(=25($+!

=,! 12K$*(%8! 2)$*.11!92*&.1(&,Djr! <#$! 5(+/*$>.%/,! .%5! /29>$d! *21$! 23! <e-! (%! +$>+(+!9.,!=$!

.&&*(=0&$5! &2! &#$! 50.1(&,! 23! (&+! *$/$>2*+D! <e-:Z! (+! 0=(?0(&20+1,! $d>*$++$5! (%! .! /2%+&(&0&()$!

9.%%$*M! K#$*$.+! <e-:j! (+! (%50/(=1$! .%5! *$+&*(/&$5! &2! (990%$M! $%52&#$1(.1! .%5! %$0*2%.1!

/$11+Djqwjo!<e-:j!(+!&#208#&!&2!>1.,!.%!(990%2*$801.&2*,!*21$!=,!./&(%8!2%!*$801.&2*,!<!/$11+M!

K#(1+&! <e-:Z!9.(%1,! +$$9+! &2!9$5(.&$! &#$! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! $33$/&+! 23! <e-DjoMjY! 7.+$5! 2%!

&#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+M!+$1$/&()$! (%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!&2!/20%&$*!&#$!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!

<e-!#.+!=$$%!>*2>2+$5!.%5!>2&$%&!<e-:Z!.%&.82%(+&+!.*$!%2K.5.,+!.).(1.=1$!.%5!&$+&$5!(%!

+$)$*.1! 925$1+DjoMp[wpn! g2K$)$*M! ./0&$! (%31.99.&(2%! 52$+! %2&! +21$1,! *$1,! 2%! 2%$! >.*&(/01.*!

/,&2J(%$!+0/#!.+!<e-D!P!).*($&,!23!/,&2J(%$+!(+!(%50/$5!32112K(%8!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&(2%!.%5!

./&!(%!/2%/$*&!&2!$1(/(&!.%!.5$?0.&$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!Q%$!23!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$!3.9(1($+!.*$!&#$!

&,>$!6!6-e+!&#.&!+(8%.1!&#*208#!.!#$&$*25(9$*(/!/29>1$d!/29>*(+$5!23!6-eP:Z!.%5!6-eP:jDpr!

<#(+!/,&2J(%$! 3.9(1,!/2%+(+&+!23!+$)$*.1! 6-e!.1>#.!8$%$+!.%5!+(%81$! 6-e!=$&.M!$>+(12%M!J.>>.!

.%5!29$8.!8$%$+D!<,>$! 6! 6-e+!.*$! (%50/$5!)$*,!*.>(51,!.%5! &*.%+($%&1,M! (%50/(%8!%09$*20+!

52K%+&*$.9!8$%$+!/2%&.(%(%8!6-eF+&(901.&$5!*$+>2%+$!$1$9$%&+!a64:HVM!23&$%!*$3$**$5!&2!.+!

&#$! 64:H! +(8%.&0*$D! 40*>*(+(%81,M! 5$+>(&$! &#$! ).*(20+! &,>$! 6! 6-e! 1(8.%5+M! &#$,! +#.*$! .! 8*$.&!

+(9(1.*(&,!(%!&#$!(%50/$5!64:H!+(8%.&0*$!*$%5$*(%8!(&!5(33(/01&!&2!5(+&(%80(+#!=$&K$$%!+(8%.&0*$!

>*23(1$!23!$./#!&,>$!6!6-e!1(8.%5D!P1&#208#!&#$,!.*$!9.(%1,!J%2K%!32*!&#$(*!.%&()(*.1!30%/&(2%M!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+! #.)$! .1+2! =$$%! +#2K%! &2!9$5(.&$! ./0&$! (%31.99.&(2%M! &#208#! $)(5$%/$! /29$+!

92+&1,!3*29!.%(9.1!$d>$*(9$%&+!0+(%8!9(/$!&#.&!.*$!5$3(/($%&!(%!6-eu!2*!(%!6-eP:ZDpqwpY!!

<#$!9$5(.&2*,!*21$!23!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!#.+!.1*$.5,!=$$%!).1(5.&$5!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1M!

=$/.0+$!.=+$%/$!23!$(&#$*!*$/$>&2*!+#2K+!*$+(+&.%/$!&2!EC4F(%50/$5!$33$/&+DZqMpmMn[wnq!Q0*!2K%!

2=+$*).&(2%+! 23! &#$!9$5(.&2*,! *21$! 23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%!<e-! &2d(/(&,! *.(+$5! &#$! ?0$+&(2%!

K#$&#$*! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! <e-! /*2++&.1J! (%! &#$! (%31.99.&(2%! (%50/$5! =,! EC4! .%5! (3! &#(+!

Page 167: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 154 of 237

/*2++&.1J!*$+01&+!(%!$%#.%/$5!(%31.99.&(2%D!6%!&#$!/0**$%&!+&05,M!K$!+#2K!&#.&!9(/$!5$3(/($%&!

(%! =2&#! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:ZM! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! +(%81$! 5$3(/($%&! 9(/$M! 5(+>1.,! (%/*$.+$5!

>*2&$/&(2%! .8.(%+&! EC4M! /#.*./&$*(R$5! =,! *$50/$5! /#$92J(%$! .%5! /,&2J(%$! >*250/&(2%!

&,>(/.11,!32*!9./*2>#.8$+!.%5!%$0&*2>#(1+D!<#(+!>*2&$/&(2%!(+!%2&!2=+$*)$5!(%!&#$!;EC!925$1M!

#2K$)$*D!6%!&#$!EC4!925$1M!K$!>*2)(5$!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!.*$!*$?0(*$5!

32*!3011!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZm!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4M!.%2&#$*!>()2&.1!>1.,$*!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4Dnm!<#(+!

(%5(/.&$+!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!./&!0>+&*$.9!23!6EFZm!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!#,>$*(%31.99.&(2%D!

7%=382=(

9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-($%5'"'%<")(8%#$=(24(=3:%*'4*(:*42%"2'4<(#Q#'<=2(CE1/'<$3"%$(

8%26#8'2)("4&:#*%$(24(='<Q8%($%5'"'%<"'%=(

C*$)(20+1,M!K$!.%5!2&#$*+!#.)$!*$>2*&$5!&#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!

&2d(/(&,! +(%/$! 9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! a6-eP:Z! iQV! +#2K$5! *$+(+&.%/$! &2! #(8#!

52+$+!23!EC4Dn[MnZMno!6%!.!>*$)(20+!+&05,!23!20*!8*20>M!6-eP:!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!0+$5!2%!.!ZjYl4)H)!

=./J8*20%5Dno!W$.%K#(1$M!K$!=./J/*2++$5! &#$! 6-eP:!iQ! &2!;rm7ElqNM!K#(/#!>*29>&$5! &#$!

?0$+&(2%!(3!&#$(*!*$+(+&.%/$!/2015!=$!*$>*250/$5D!6%!.8*$$9$%&!K(&#!20*!$.*1($*!3(%5(%8+M!&#$+$!

9(/$!K$*$! *$+(+&.%&! &2! EC4M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (+! 5$&*(9$%&.1! (%! EC4F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1(&,M! (%5$>$%5$%&! 23! &#$(*! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5! a-(80*$! ZPVD! 6-eP:Z! J%2/J20&! .%5!K(15!

&,>$! 9(/$! K$*$! (%G$/&$5! K(&#! EC4! (%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,! .%5! 92%(&2*$5! 32*! +$)$*.1! 5.,+D! L$!

2=+$*)$5! .! +(8%(3(/.%&! *$50/&(2%! (%! 1$&#.1(&,! (%! &#$! &*.%+8$%(/! 8*20>! /29>.*$5! &2!L<!9(/$!

+088$+&(%8! 6-eP:!9$5(.&$+! &#$! 1$&#.1! $33$/&+!23!EC4D!;29>.*.=1$! 3(%5(%8+!K$*$!2=+$*)$5! (%!

9(/$! K(&#! .=*28.&$5! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! a<e-:Z! iQVU! &#$,! .1+2! $d#(=(&$5! *$50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,!

/29>.*$5!&2!EC4F(%G$/&$5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!a-(80*$!Z7VD!72&#!6-eP:!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,!>*2&$/&$5!.8.(%+&!EC4!/29>.*$5!&2!&#$(*!K(15!&,>$!1(&&$*9.&$+M!K#(/#!>*29>&$5!

&#$!?0$+&(2%!K#$&#$*!520=1$!8$%$&(/!5$3(/($%/,!/2015!1$.5!&2!+(8%(3(/.%&!>*2&$/&(2%!/29>.*$5!

Page 168: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 155 of 237

&2! &#$!+(%81$!iQ! 1(&&$*9.&$+D!<2! &$+&! &#(+M!K$!/*2++$5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K(&#! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!

.%5!8$%$*.&$5!#292R,820+!520=1$!J%2/J20&!9(/$!a@iQVD!<#$+$!9(/$!K$*$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!.!

+(9(1.*! 52+$! 23! EC4! .%5!92%(&2*$5! 32*! =25,! &$9>$*.&0*$! .%5! +0*)().1! (%! >.*.11$1! &2! +(%81$!

J%2/J20&!9(/$D!L$! 320%5! &#.&! @iQ!9(/$! K$*$! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! >*2&$/&$5! .8.(%+&! EC4F(%50/$5!

5*2>!(%!=25,!&$9>$*.&0*$!.%5!1$&#.1(&,!/29>.*$5!&2!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!a-(80*$!

Z;! 1$3&! .%5! *(8#&VD! <#$! 5*2>! (%! =25,! &$9>$*.&0*$!K.+! 1$++! >*2%20%/$5! (%! <e-:Z! iQ!9(/$!

/29>.*$5!&2!6-eP:Z!iQM!=0&!+&(11!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!&#.%!@iQD!

!

?'Q3*%( -D( 9>?7-( 4*( ;?>!7-( $%5'"'%<")( :*42%"2=( #Q#'<=2( CE1/'<$3"%$( 8%26#8'2)( #<$( $3#8(

$%5'"'%<")(8%#$=(24(=3:%*'4*(*%='=2#<"%(

a!!.%5!RV!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!.%5!*$+>$/&()$!K(15!&,>$!1(&&$*9.&$+!K$*$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!pr[!£8!23!EC4!.%5!1$&#.1(&,!K.+!32112K$5!50*(%8!Z[[!#20*+!a%!�!mFZZVD!aFV!@20=1$!J%2/J20&!a@iQV!.%5!+(%81$! iQ! 9(/$! K$*$! /#.11$%8$5! K(&#! pr[! ¡8! 23! EC4! .%5! 1$&#.1(&,! .%5! =25,! &$9>$*.&0*$! K$*$!92%(&2*$5! 50*(%8! Z[[! .%5! no! #20*+M! *$+>$/&()$1,! a%! �! mFpnVD! E28F*.%J! aW.%&$1F;2dV! &$+&+! K$*$!>$*32*9$5! 2%! &#$! +0*)().1! /0*)$+D! 71./JM! K(15! &,>$U! 5.*J! 8*$,M! 6-eP:Z! iQU! 1(8#&! 8*$,M! 6-eP:Z! iQU!(%&$*9$5(.&$!8*$,M!@iQ!!

(

!"

#"

$"!"#$%&'('

0 20 40 60 80 1000

25

50

75

100

Time after LPS (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

TNFR1KOTNFR1WT

*

0 20 40 60 80 1000

25

50

75

100

Time after LPS (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

DKOIFNAR1KOTNFR1KO

***

*

ns

0 20 40 60 80 1000

25

50

75

100

Time after LPS (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

IFNAR1KO

IFNAR1WT

**

0 8 16 24 32 40 4824

32

40

Time after LPS (hours)

Bod

y te

mpe

ratu

re (°

C)

DKOIFNAR1KOTNFR1KO

***** *

******

Page 169: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 156 of 237

:$/$%&1,M!K$!*$>2*&$5!&#.&!=12/J(%8!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!*$+01&$5!(%!$%#.%/$5!%$0&*2>#(1!(%310d!

(%!&#$!;EC!925$1!.%5!=$&&$*!+0*)().1!&#.%!&#$!/2%&*21+D!L$!K2%5$*$5!(3!5$3(/($%/,!(%!<e-:Z!

/2015! $%#.%/$! &#(+! >*2&$/&(2%D! g2K$)$*M! @iQ! 9(/$! K$*$! %2&! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! >*2&$/&$5! .%5!

+#2K$5!.!+(9(1.*!+$%+(&()(&,!.+!K(15!&,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!/20%&$*>.*&+!a40>>1$9$%&.*,!-(80*$!

ZPVD! <#$+$! *$+01&+! +#2K! &#.&! =2&#! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! .*$! 5$&*(9$%&.1! (%! EC4F

(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,D! 6%! /2%&*.+&M! ;ECF(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,! /.%! =$! >*$)$%&$5! (%! 6-eP:Z! 5$3(/($%&!

9(/$M!=0&!%2&!(%!<e-:Z!2*!@iQ!9(/$D!

9>?7-(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=($4(<42(#55%"2(%#"6(426%*h=(%H:*%=='4<(8%M%8=('<(=%*3&(#52%*(

CE1("6#88%<Q%(

e$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!<e-!#.+!=$$%!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e!>*250/&(2%! (%!>.&($%&+!

&*$.&$5! 32*! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+DnYMr[!@*+%&=%5$/M! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29!#$>.&(&(+! ;! &*$.&$5!

K(&#! 6-ev! #.)$! 0>*$801.&$5! <e-:Z! $d>*$++(2%! 2%! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11+DrZ! 7.+$5! 2%! &#$! +0>$*(2*!

>*2&$/&(2%!2=+$*)$5!(%!&#$!@iQ!9(/$M!K$!K2%5$*$5!(3!<e-:Z!.33$/&+!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%!(%!

*$+>2%+$!&2!<e-!.%5!(3!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!/(*/01.&(%8!1$)$1+!23!+210=1$!<e-:ZD!

<2!.55*$++!&#(+M!9(/$!K$*$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!EC4!.%5!=1225!K.+!/211$/&$5!.&!+$)$*.1!&(9$!>2(%&+D!

6-eu!K.+!>*250/$5!*.>(51,!.3&$*!EC4M!.+!5$+/*(=$5!$.*1($*DnZMno!72&#!<e-:Z!.%5! 6-eP:Z!iQ!

9(/$! +#2K$5!.! +(9(1.*! (%/*$.+$! (%! +,+&$9(/! 6-eu! a-(80*$!jPVD! 4(d!#20*+! .3&$*!EC4! (%G$/&(2%M!

+$*09! 6-eu! 1$)$1+!5*2>>$5! (%!K(15! &,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$M!=0&!%2&! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQM!K#(/#!

9(8#&! =$! 50$! &2! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! %$8.&()$! 3$$5=./J! *$801.&(2%! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! 6-eP:Z!

+(8%.1(%8D!6-ev!K.+!(%50/$5!(%!=2&#!K(15!&,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$M!=0&!%2&!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!

.+! 5$>(/&$5! (%! -(80*$! j7D! <#(+! (+! /2%+(+&$%&! K(&#! $.*1($*! 3(%5(%8+! &#.&! EC4F(%50/$5! 6-eu!

>*292&$+! >*250/&(2%! 23! 6-evDrjMrp! g$%/$M! 20*! 5.&.! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! 52$+! %2&!

.33$/&!+$*09!1$)$1+!23!6-evlu!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!<E:n!./&().&(2%D!!

6&! (+!J%2K%!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!.33$/&!<e-!.%5!<e-:Z!1$)$1+D!W2%2/,&$+!./&().&$5!K(&#!EC4!

K(11!>*250/$!92*$!<e-!(%!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!6-eu!.%5!>.&($%&+!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6-ev!+#2K!.%!!

Page 170: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 157 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(+D(9>?(#<$( =483G8%(9>?7-( 8%M%8=(#*%(<42(#55%"2%$(G)( ;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q(#<$( 2):%( ;( ;?>(

8%M%8=(#*%(<42(#55%"2%$(G)(9>?7-(='Q<#8'<Q(%'26%*(

EC4!K.+!(%G$/&$5!(D>D!.&!pr[!£8!>$*!920+$!32*!5$&$/&(2%!23!<e-M!<e-:Z!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+D!a!!.%5!RV!6-eu!.%5!6-ev!K$*$!9$.+0*$5!K(&#!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!(%!K(15!&,>$M!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!.&![M!jM!q! #20*+! .3&$*! /#.11$%8$D! aFV! <e-! K.+! 9$.+0*$5! K(&#! E09(%$d! &$/#%2128,! (%! +$*09! 23! K(15! &,>$M!6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!@iQ!9(/$!.&![!.%5!o!#20*+!.3&$*!/#.11$%8$D!aIV!+<e-:Z!K.+!5$&$/&$5!K(&#!HE64P!(%!K(15! &,>$! .%5! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$! =$32*$! .%5! jM! q! #20*+! .3&$*! EC4D!L(15! &,>$!9(/$! *$>*$+$%&$5! #$*$!/2%+(+&!23!=2&#!6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!.&!1$.+&!q!9(/$!>$*!8*20>VD!

!

(%/*$.+$!23!+210=1$!<e-:Z!a+<e-:ZVDrnMrr!L$!K2%5$*$5!K#$&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e+!*$801.&$!<e-!.%5!

+<e:Z!$d>*$++(2%! *(&=*="!0>2%!/#.11$%8$!K(&#!EC4D!L$!9$.+0*$5!=2&#!>*2&$(%+! (%!+$*09!23!

K(15! &,>$! .%5! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! .3&$*! EC4! +&(901.&(2%D! <e-! K.+! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! .%5! $?0.11,!

(%50/$5! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2!EC4! (%!=2&#! 8*20>+! a-(80*$!j;VD! 4(9(1.*1,M! EC4! (%50/$5! .! +(8%(3(/.%&!

(%/*$.+$!23!+<e-:Z!(%!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$D!:$9.*J.=1,M!.=+$%/$!23!=2&#!6-eP:Z!

.%5!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!*$+01&$5!(%!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!1$++!<e-!+$*09!1$)$1+!a-(80*$!j;M!K#(&$!=.*V!.%5!

+<e-:Z! =.+.1! 1$)$1+! K$*$! #(8#$*! (%! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! .&! =.+.1! &(9$! >2(%&M! =0&! %2&! .3&$*!

+&(901.&(2%!K(&#!EC4!a-(80*$!j@VD!

!" #"

$" %"

!"#$%&'('

0 2 2 2 6 6 60

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

********

****

****

Wild typeTNFR1 KOIFNAR1 KO

0 2 2 2 6 6 60

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml) ****

*****

0 2 6 0 2 60

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

Time after LPS (hours)

[sTN

FR1]

(pg/

ml)

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

*****

****

0 8 8 80

200

400

600

800

1000

Time after LPS (hours)

[TN

F] (p

g/m

l)

*

********

***

*

IFNAR1 WTIFNAR1 KO

DKO

Page 171: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 158 of 237

;?>!7-(&%$'#2%=('<2%=2'<#8($#&#Q%N(K6%*%#=(9>?7-(:*4M4J%=('<2%=2'<#8(

:%*&%#G'8'2)('<(*%=:4<=%(24(CE1(

EC4F(%50/$5!$%52&2d$9(.!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!901&(>1$!2*8.%!5.9.8$M!K#(/#!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!

&#$! *$1$.+$! 23! /$1101.*! /2%&$%&! (%&2! &#$! =1225! +&*$.9D! H1$).&$5! 1$)$1+! 23! 3.&&,! ./(5! =(%5(%8!

>*2&$(%!a-P7CV!#.)$!=$$%!>*2>2+$5!.+!.!=(29.*J$*!32*!2*8.%!(%G0*,D!"0&!$>(&#$1(.1!5.9.8$!(+!

.++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! (%&$+&(%.1! -P7C! a6EF-P7CV! (%! +$*09DrqMrm! L(15! &,>$! 9(/$! &*$.&$5!

K(&#!EC4!5$92%+&*.&$!.!jF3215!(%/*$.+$!23!6EF-P7C!$(8#&!#20*+!.3&$*!(%G$/&(2%!a-(80*$!pPVD!P!

+(9(1.*!+(8%(3(/.%&!(%/*$.+$!K.+!2=+$*)$5!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!=0&!%2&!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$D!E(J$K(+$M!

6EF-PC7C!1$)$1+!K$*$!%2&!$1$).&$5!(%!@iQ!9(/$D!<#(+!(%5(/.&$5!&#.&!6-eP:!iQ!.%5!@iQ!9(/$!

+033$*!1$++!3*29!EC4F(%50/$5!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$D!!

!

?'Q3*%( XD( ;?>!7-( #<$( 9>?7-( $%5'"'%<")( 8%#$=( 24( 8%==( '<2%=2'<#8( $#&#Q%( #<$(

:%*&%#G'8'2)N(*%=:%"2'M%8)(

W(/$!K$*$!.59(%(+&$*$5!pr[!£8!>$*!920+$!.%5!=1225!K.+!/211$/&$5!&#*208#!/.*5(./!>0%/&0*$!.&!&#$!(%5(/.&$5!&(9$!>2(%&+D!a!V!4$*09!1$)$1+!23! 6EF-P7C!K$*$!9$.+0*$5!K(&#!HE64P!(%!K(15!&,>$M!+(%81$!iQ!.%5!@iQ!9(/$!o!#20*+!.3&$*!(%G$/&(2%!K(&#!EC4D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!nFoVD!aRV!H33$/&!23!<e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! 2%! EC4F(%50/$5! (%/*$.+$! 23! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,D! 4,+&$9(/!/2%/$%&*.&(2%!23!n!J@.!-6<;F5$d&*.%!K.+!9$.+0*$5! (%!>1.+9.!=$32*$!.%5!q!#20*+!.3&$*!EC4D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!rFoVD!L(15!&,>$!9(/$!*$>*$+$%&$5!#$*$!/2%+(+&!23!=2&#!6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!!!

!

6%!.55(&(2%!&2!&(++0$!5.9.8$M!EC4!.+!K$11!.+!<e-!(%50/$!.!12++!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*!(%&$8*(&,Drow

qZ! <2! +&05,! &#$! 9$5(.&2*,! *21$! 23! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%! EC4F(%50/$5! 12++! 23!

(%&$+&(%.1! (%&$8*(&,M!K$! .59(%(+&$*$5! n! J@.! 3102*$+/$%&F1.=$1$5! 5$d&*.%! 2*.11,! &2!9(/$! .3&$*!

(%G$/&(2%! K(&#! EC4D! P+! $d>$/&$5M! .! +(8%(3(/.%&! (%/*$.+$! (%! 3102*$+/$%/$! K.+! 2=+$*)$5! (%!

!" #"!"#$%&'('

0 6 6 6 60

1

2

3

4

Time after LPS (hours)

Rel

ativ

e in

test

inal

per

mea

bilit

y

***

**

0 8 8 8 80

200

400

600

800

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-F

AB

P] (

pg/m

l)

******** *

**

Wild typeIFNAR1 KO

TNFR1 KODKO

Page 172: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 159 of 237

+,+&$9(/!/(*/01.&(2%!(%!K(15!&,>$!.%(9.1+!q!#20*+!.3&$*!EC4M!(%5(/.&()$!32*!(%/*$.+$5!(%&$+&(%.1!

>$*9$.=(1(&,! a-(80*$! p7VD! P1+2! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! 5(+>1.,$5! .%! EC4F5$>$%5$%&! (%/*$.+$! (%!

(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,M!K#(/#!(+!/2%+(+&$%&!K(&#!K#.&!K$!2=+$*)$5!(%!<e-F&*$.&$5!6-eP:Z!iQ!

9(/$! a>*$)(20+! *$+01&! +$/&(2%VD! 6%! /2%&*.+&M! (%! <e-:Z! iQ! 9(/$M! EC4F(%50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1!

>$*9$.=(1(&,!K.+! 1$++!>*2%20%/$5! /29>.*$5! &2!K(15! &,>$!9(/$D! 6%&$*$+&(%81,M! .=*28.&(2%!23!

=2&#! *$/$>&2*+! >*$)$%&+! =2&#! EC4F(%50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,! .%5! 5.9.8$M! K#(/#!

>.*&(.11,!$d>1.(%+! &#$!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!2=+$*)$5! (%!@iQ!9(/$D!<#$+$!*$+01&+! (%5(/.&$! &#.&!

6-eP:ZM! =0&! %2&! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8!9$5(.&$+! EC4F(%50/$5! &(++0$! 5.9.8$! (%! &#$! 80&M!K#$*$.+!

2%1,!<e-:Z!>1.,+!.%!$++$%&(.1!*21$!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,D!!

I43G8%($%5'"'%<")(8%#$=(24(&#*J%$8)(*%$3"%$(")24J'<%=(#<$("6%&4J'<%=(8%M%8=(

'<(=%*3&(

<2! +&05,! K#$&#$*! .=+$%/$! 23! 6-eP:Z! .%5! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! .33$/&+! +,+&$9(/! 1$)$1+! 23! EC4F

(%50/$5! /,&2J(%$+M! K$! +.9>1$5! =1225! 3*29!K(15! &,>$M! +(%81$! iQ! .%5! @iQ!9(/$! =$32*$! .%5!

.3&$*!EC4D!4$*09!.%.1,+(+!=,!7(2FC1$d!.++.,!+#2K$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,! (%/*$.+$5! 1$)$1+!23!).*(20+!

/,&2J(%$+! .%5! /#$92J(%$+! $(8#&! #20*+! .3&$*! EC4! =2&#! (%! K(15! &,>$! .%5! 6-eP:Zl<e-:Z!

5$3(/($%&!9(/$M!*$31$/&(%8!&#$!+&.&$!23!2)$*./&().&$5!(990%$!/$11+Dqj!P11!5$>(/&$5!>*2&$(%+!K$*$!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,!0>*$801.&$5!(%!K(15!&,>$M!+(%81$!J%2/J20&!.%5!520=1$!J%2/J20&!9(/$!a-(80*$!nPF

;VD!g2K$)$*M!W6CFZu!.%5!6EFZ[!1$)$1+!K$*$!12K$*!(%!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!/29>.*$5!&2!

K(15!&,>$!a-(80*$!nPVD!W2*$2)$*M!@iQ!9(/$!#.5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!1$)$1+!&#.%!=2&#!+(%81$!iQ!

.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$M!+#2K(%8!.%!.55(&()$!*$50/&(2%!23!W6CFZu!.%5!6EFZ[D!W6CFZvM!i;M!:.%&$+M!

"WF;4-M!6EFZvM!6EFnM!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZp!K$*$!(%/*$.+$5!(%!.11!8*20>+!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4!.+!K$11M!

5$>(/&$5! (%!-(80*$!n7D!4$*09!1$)$1+!23! &#$+$!>*2&$(%+!K$*$!%2&!*$50/$5!(%!$(&#$*!6-eP:Z!2*!

<e-:Z!iQM!=0&!.11!K$*$!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!*$50/$5!(%!@iQ!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$D!@iQ!9(/$!.1+2!

+#2K$5!+(8%(3(/.%&!12K$*!.920%&+!23!"WF;4-M!6EFZv!.%5!6EFZmP!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!=2&#!+(%81$!

J%2/J20&+D!i;!1$)$1+!(%!@iQ!K$*$!/29>.*.=1$!&2!6-eP:Z!iQM!=0&!+&(11!1$++!(%/*$.+$5!&#.%!!

Page 173: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 160 of 237

!

?'Q3*%( .D( CE1/'<$3"%$( "6%&4J'<%( #<$( ")24J'<%( =%*3&( 8%M%8=( '<(K'8$( 2):%N( ='<Q8%( #<$( $43G8%(

9>?7-(;?>!7-(J<43"J432(&'"%(

W(/$! K$*$! /#.11$%8$5! K(&#! pr[! ¡8! 23! EC4! .%5! =1225! K.+! /211$/&$5! o! #20*+! .3&$*! +&(901.&(2%D!;2%/$%&*.&(2%!23!a!V!W(>FZuM!6EFZ[M!aRV!W6CFZvM!i;M!6EFnM!:.%&$+M!6EFZpM!"WF;4-M!6EFZvM!6EFZmPM!aFV!6EFZuM!6EFZj>n[M!6EFj!.%5!6EFY!K$*$!5$&$*9(%$5!K(&#!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,D!L(15!&,>$!9(/$!*$>*$+$%&!#$*$!>221$5!8*20>+!3*29!6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!.&!1$.+&!q!9(/$!>$*!8*20>VD!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!1(8#&!8*$,M!<e-:Z!iQU!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQU!K#(&$M!@iQ!

!

<e-:Z!iQ!1$)$1+D!EC4!(%50/$5!6EFZu!(%!.11!9(/$M!.1&#208#!1$)$1+!K$*$!12K$*!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!

@iQ!9(/$!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!a-(80*$!n;VD!4(9(1.*!*$+01&+!K$*$!2=&.(%$5!32*!6EFZj>n[M!

K#(/#!*$./#$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!1$)$1+!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!@iQ!9(/$D!P1&#208#!@iQ!+#2K$5!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,!1$++!6EFZu!/29>.*$5!&2!.11!2&#$*!8*20>+M! 1$)$1+!23!6EFZj>n[!K$*$!/29>.*.=1$!&2!

<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$D! 72&#! .=+$%/$! 23! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! 1$5! &2! #(8#$*! 1$)$1+! 23! 6EFj! .%5! 6EFYM!

*$+>$/&()$1,D! <#208#! 1$)$1+! 23! =2&#! (%&$*1$0J(%+!K$*$! 12K$*! (%!@iQ! /29>.*$5! &2! +(%81$!iQ!

0 8 8 8 80

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Time after LPS (hours)

[MIP

-1!

] (pg

/ml)

****

**** ****

****

*****

****

********

Wild typeTNFR1 KO

IFNAR1 KODKO!"

0 8 8 8 80

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1

0] (p

g/m

l)

****

**** ****

****

*****

***

0 8 8 8 80

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Time after LPS (hours)

[MIP

-1!

] (pg

/ml)

****

****

********

****

***

#"

0 8 8 8 80

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Time after LPS (hours)

[KC

] (x

103

pg/m

l)

****

**** ****

****

*

*

0 8 8 8 80

10

20

30

40

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-4

] (pg

/ml)

**** ******** ****

**

0 8 8 8 80

20

40

60

80

100

Time after LPS (hours)

[Ran

tes]

(x 1

03 pg

/ml)

****

********

****

*

0 8 8 8 80

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1

3] (p

g/m

l) **

*******

**** ***

0 8 8 8 80

200

400

600

800

1000

Time after LPS (hours)

[GM

-CS

F] (p

g/m

l) **** **** ********

******

***

0 8 8 8 80

500

1000

1500

2000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1!

] (pg

/ml)

********

****

****

*****

**

0 8 8 8 80

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1

7A] (

pg/m

l)

********

****

****

***

*

0 8 8 8 80

2000

4000

6000

8000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1!

] (pg

/ml)

****

****

****

****

0.0592

****

****

**

$"

0 8 8 8 80

20

40

60

80

100

120

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1

2p40

] (x

103

pg/m

l)

****

****

****

****

****

**

0 8 8 8 80

50

100

150

200

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-2

] (pg

/ml)

****

********

****

* **0.0554

0 8 8 8 80

200

400

600

Time after LPS (hours)[IL

-9] (

pg/m

l)

* ***

*****

****

Page 174: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 161 of 237

9(/$M!&#$,!K$*$!+(9(1.*!&2!K(15!&,>$!1$)$1+D!6EFr!.%5!6-ey!K$*$!.1+2!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!(%50/$5!(%!.11!

8*20>+M! =0&! &#$*$! K.+! %2! +(8%(3(/.%&! 5(33$*$%/$! (%! +(%81$! .%5! 520=1$! J%2/J20&! 9(/$!

a40>>1$9$%&.*,! -(80*$! jPVD! Q)$*.11M! 9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! =2&#! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! 5(+>1.,$5!

*$50/$5!(%50/&(2%!23!).*(20+!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!/#$92J(%$+M!K#(/#!.11!9$5(.&$!2*!.&!1$.+&!*$31$/&!

&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!EC4F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,D!!

I'="3=='4<((

<#$! *$+>2%+$! &2! >.&#28$%+! *$1($+! 2%! >.&&$*%! *$/28%(&(2%! *$/$>&2*+! aC::+V! +0/#! .+! <E:nM!

K#(/#!+>$/(3(/.11,!*$/28%(R$+!EC4D!<#$! 1.&&$*! (+!.%!$++$%&(.1!/29>2%$%&!23! &#$!20&$*! 1.,$*!23!

"*.9F%$8.&()$!=./&$*(.M!.%5!.+!.%!$%52&2d(%!0+$301!(%!(%50/(%8!(%31.99.&(2%D!C*$)(20+!K2*J!

>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!>1.,!.!*21$!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,DZYMjZMjjMpqMpmMn[Mno!

6&! #.+! =$$%! >2+&01.&$5! &#.&! <e-! .%5! 6-eu! 9.,! #.)$! +,%$*8(+&(/! $33$/&+! >*292&(%8!

(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$+Dqpwqr!<#$!K2*J!5$+/*(=$5!#$*$!+0>>2*&+!&#$!#,>2&#$+(+!&#.&!<e-!)(.!

<e-:Z! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! )(.! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! &28$&#$*! /2%&*(=0&$! $%#.%/$5! (%31.99.&(2%D!

"$%$&(/!5$1$&(2%!23!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!1$.5+!&2!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!&#$!

+(%81$! iQ! .%5! K(15! &,>$!9(/$D! @iQ!9(/$! +033$*$5! 1$++! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$! .%5! >$*9$.=(1(&,!

/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!L#(1$!8$%$&(/!5$1$&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!*$+01&$5!(%!%2!(%/*$.+$!23!6EF

-P7C!1$)$1+M!<e-:Z!5$3(/($%/,!K.+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!%2!(%&$+&(%.1!1$.J.8$!23!-6<;F5$d&*.%D!<#(+!

(9>1($+! &#.&! EC4! (%50/$+! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,! .%5! /$1101.*! 5.9.8$! )(.! &K2! +$>.*.&$!

>.&#K.,+D! P+! 5$+/*(=$5! $.*1($*M! 6EF-P7C! (+! *$1$.+$5! 0>2%! 5.9.8$! &2! &#$! 80&! $>(&#$1(09D!

6%/*$.+$5! >$*9$.=(1(&,! /2015! *$+01&! 3*29! (9>.(*$5! &(8#&! G0%/&(2%+! 2*! 5,+*$801.&$5! /$1101.*!

&*.%+>2*&M!.112K(%8!921$/01$+!+0/#!.+!-6<;F5$d&*.%!&2! 1$.J! (%&2!&#$!=1225!+&*$.9D!<#$!$d./&!

9$/#.%(+9M! #2K$)$*M! *$9.(%+! &2! =$! $10/(5.&$5D! e2%$&#$1$++M! =2&#! >*2/$++$+! .*$! (%#(=(&$5!

K#$%!./&().&(2%!23!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(+!(9>.(*$5M!1$.5(%8!&2!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!(%!&#$!

@iQ!9(/$!&2!EC4D!P//2*5(%81,M!.11!9$.+0*$5!/,&2J(%$+!K$*$!1$++!(%50/$5!(%!+$*09!3*29!@iQ!

9(/$M!$d/$>&! 6-eyM! 6EFrM! 6EFZm-!.%5!6EFjp>ZYD!<#$+$!*$+01&+!+088$+&!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!/.%!

Page 175: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 162 of 237

&28$&#$*! .33$/&! &#$! $d>*$++(2%! 1$)$1+! 23! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! 9$++$%8$*+D! 429$!

2=+$*).&(2%+! K$*$! *.&#$*! +0*>*(+(%8D! -2*! $d.9>1$M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 0+0.11,! /2%+&*.(%! &#$!

>*250/&(2%!23!i;M!&#$*$=,!>*$)$%&(%8!%$0&*2>#(1!9(8*.&(2%MqqMqm!K#(/#!9.5$!&#$!2=+$*).&(2%!

23! *$50/$5!i;! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQ! +$*09!.3&$*!EC4! /#.11$%8$! *$9.*J.=1$D!W6CFZ! /#$92J(%$+! .*$!

(9>1(/.&$5!(%!1$0J2/,&$!&*.33(/J(%8!.%5!#.)$!=$$%!>*2>2+$5!.+!9.*J$*+!(%!>$5(.&*(/!+$>+(+Dqow

m[! <,>$! 6! 6-e+! #.)$! =$$%! +#2K%! &2! >*292&$! 2*! (%#(=(&! W6CFZ! >*2&$(%+M! 5$>$%5(%8! 2%! &#$!

/2%&$d&DmZwmn!<#$!*21$!23!<e-:Z!2%!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!W6CFZ!/#$92J(%$+!#.+!%2&!=$$%!+&05($5!

$1.=2*.&$1,M!=0&!20*!5.&.!(%5(/.&$!&#.&!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!1$.5+!&2!*$50/$5!EC4F(%50/$5!W6CF

Zv!.%5!W6CFZuD!<28$&#$*!K(&#!<e-M!6EFZu!(+!J%2K%!&2!=$!.!>2&$%&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$!

(%!).*(20+!+$&&(%8+!23!(%31.99.&(2%D!g$*$M!K$!*$>2*&!&#.&!5$3(/($%/,!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!52$+!

%2&! .33$/&! (%50/&(2%! 23! 6EFZu! =,! EC4M! K#$*$.+! 3011! (%50/&(2%! 23! 6EFZu! K.+! (9>.(*$5! (%! &#$!

.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!./&().&(2%D! 4(9(1.*1,M! (%! &#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:ZM! 3011! (%50/&(2%!23! 6EFZj>n[!

K.+!%2&!*$./#$5!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4M!=0&!K.+!%2&!.33$/&$5!=,!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8D!Q)$*!&#$!,$.*+M!

9.%,!>()2&.1!>1.,$*+!#.)$!=$$%!(5$%&(3($5!(%!&#$!>.&#2128,!23!EC4F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,M!.92%8+&!

K#(/#!6EFZmDmr!72+9.%%!$&!.1D!#.)$!+#2K%!&#.&!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!23!6EFZm!(9>*2)$+!&#$!+0*)().1!

20&/29$!23!9(/$!(%!.%!$%52&2d(%!925$1Dmq!6%!&#(+!+&05,M!K$!320%5!&#.&!8$%$&(/!5$1$&(2%!23!=2&#!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!1$.5+!&2!+(8%(3(/.%&!*$50/&(2%!23!6EFZmPM!=0&!%2&!6EFZm-D!<#(+!2=+$*).&(2%!

(%5(/.&$+! &#.&!<e-!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! &28$&#$*!2*/#$+&*.&$! &#$! (%50/&(2%!23! 6EFZmPD!<#$!+$*09!

>*23(1$!23!&#$!@iQ!9(/$!+088$+&+!&#.&!1$++!%$0&*2>#(1F*$1.&$5!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!>*250/$5M!K#(/#!(+!

.! >2++(=1$! 9$/#.%(+9! 32*! +0>$*(2*! >*2&$/&(2%! (%! &#$+$! 9(/$D! 4$>+(+! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#!

(9>.(*$5! 30%/&(2%(%8! 23! %$0&*2>#(1+D! Q%$! >2++(=1$! $d>1.%.&(2%! (+! &#$! 5$1.,$5! .>2>&2+(+! 23!

%$0&*2>#(1+M!&,>(/.11,!2=+$*)$5!(%!+$>+(+DmmwmY!e2*9.11,M!%$0&*2>#(1+!#.)$!.!*$801.*!&0*%2)$*D!

@0*(%8! (%31.99.&(2%M! %$0&*2>#(1+! .*$! /*(&(/.1! 32*! .%! $.*1,! (%%.&$! *$+>2%+$M! =0&! >*212%8$5!

./&()(&,! /.%! 9(+&.J$%1,! *$+01&! (%! 2*8.%! (%G0*,D! 6EFZvluM! 6EFjM! <e-! .%5! "WF;4-! #.)$! =$$%!

+#2K%!&2!(%#(=(&!.>2>&2+(+!23!%$0&*2>#(1+DmmMmoMo[MoZ!P1&#208#!K$!#.)$!%2&!.55*$++$5!&#(+!(++0$!

Page 176: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 163 of 237

(%!&#(+!+&05,M!(&!(+!>2++(=1$!&#.&!%$0&*2>#(1+!(%!@iQ!#.)$!.!3.+&$*!(%)210&(2%!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1!

50$!&2!12K$*!/,&2J(%$!1$)$1+M!*$+01&(%8!(%!1$++!2*8.%!5.9.8$D!

P59(%(+&*.&(2%! 23! 6EFj! (%50/$+! #,>2&$%+(2%M! >0192%.*,! ).+/01.*! 1$.J! .%5! 901&(>1$! 2*8.%!

3.(10*$M!+(9(1.*1,!&2!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!#(8#!52+$+!23!<e-M!+&*2%81,!*$+$9=1(%8!+$>+(+D!g2K$)$*M!

(&+!*21$!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/J!(+!/2%30+(%8M!.+!1$)$1+!.*$!5$/*$.+$5!.%5!(%/*$.+$5!(%!+$>+(+!

.%5!+$>&(/!+#2/JM!*$+>$/&()$1,D!6%!.55(&(2%M!6EFj!(%50/$+!<e-M!K#(/#!/0**$%&1,!#.9>$*+!&#$!0+$!

23!6EFj!(%!/.%/$*!&*$.&9$%&Dojwon!:$9.*J.=1,M!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!1$.5+!&2!12K$*!1$)$1+!23!6EFj!(%!

*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4M!.1&#208#!<e-!(&+$13!(+!&#208#&!&2!9$5(.&$!6EFj!(%50/$5!10%8!(%G0*,D!4(9(1.*1,M!

K$! 2=+$*)$5! (%/*$.+$5! 6EFY! >*250/&(2%! (%! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$M! /29>.*$5! &2! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$D!

P1&#208#!(&!#.+!=$$%!5$+/*(=$5!>*$)(20+1,!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!>*292&$!6EFY!>*250/&(2%!.%5!<#Y!

5(33$*$%&(.&(2%M!�.%8!$&!.1D!*$>2*&!1(J$!0+M!.%!(%#(=(&2*,!$33$/&!23!6-eu!2%!6EFYDorwom!!

;1$.*1,M!<e-:Z!.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!=2&#!9$5(.&$! &#$!>*250/&(2%!23!>*2F! .%5!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!

/,&2J(%$+D! 70&! &2! 20*! +0*>*(+$M! &#$,!52!%2&! .33$/&! $./#! 2&#$*c+! >*250/&(2%! *(&=*="D! <#(+! (+! (%!

/2%&*.+&!K(&#!K#.&!#.+!=$$%!320%5!*(&=*)5"D!W21%.*3(!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!$%#.%/$5!>*250/&(2%!23!

<e-!(%!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!6-eu!=,!EC4F+&(901.&$5!92%2/,&$+D!4(9(1.*1,M!+$*09!1$)$1+!23!<e-!.%5!

+<e-:Z!K$*$!%2&!.33$/&$5!=,!&,>$!6!6-e+!&#*208#!6-eP:ZD!6%(&(.11,M!K$!#,>2&#$+(R$5!&#.&!.%&(F

<e-! 3.(10*$! (%! +$>+(+! >.&($%&+! *$+01&$5! 3*29! 0%2>>2+$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! .+! +088$+&$5! (%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+DnYMr[!7.+$5!2%!&#$!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!23!&#$!@iQ!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1M!K$!

$d>$/&$5!.!+(9(1.*!*$+(+&.%/$!&2K.*5+!;ECF(%50/$5!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+D!W0/#!&2!20*!+0*>*(+$M!

@iQ! 9(/$! K$*$! .+! +$%+(&()$! .+! K(15! &,>$! .%5! <e-:Z! iQ! 9(/$D! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! K$*$!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,! >*2&$/&$5M! .+! K$! *$>2*&$5! >*$)(20+1,Mqm! =0&! +(901&.%$20+! 5$1$&(2%! 23! <e-:Z!

2=1(&$*.&$+!&#(+!>#$%2&,>$D! !<#$!*21$!23!<e-!.%5! (&+!*$/$>&2*+! (%!;EC! (+!%2&!+&*.(8#&32*K.*5M!

=.+$5!2%!&#$!/2%&*.+&(%8!*$+01&+!*$>2*&$5!(%!1(&$*.&0*$D!4(9(1.*1,!&2!20*!*$+01&+M!g(15$=*.%5!$&!

.1D! +#2K$5! &#.&! <e-:Z! (+! $++$%&(.1! 32*! +0*)().1! (%! ;ECM! .1&#208#! %2! .%&(=(2&(/+! K$*$!

.59(%(+&$*$5!(%!&#$(*!$d>$*(9$%&.1!+$&F0>Doo!

Page 177: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 164 of 237

P1&28$&#$*M! &#$+$! *$+01&+! (9>1,! &#.&! 50*(%8! ./0&$! (%31.99.&(2%M! (%50/$5!=,!EC4M! &#$*$! (+! .%!

(%&$*./&(2%! =$&K$$%! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! .%5! &#$,! $./#! /2%&*(=0&$! &2! $%#.%/$5!

(%31.99.&(2%! &#*208#! +$>.*.&$! .%5! /2992%! &.*8$&+!K#(/#! 1$.5! &2!>*250/&(2%!23! /,&2J(%$+M!

+0/#!.+!6EFZuM!6EFZ[!.%5!6EFZmD!

<#$+$!3(%5(%8+!0%5$*1(%$!&#$!/29>1$d!=(2128,!&#.&!.//29>.%($+!/29>1(/.&$5!/2%5(&(2%+!+0/#!

.+! $%52&2d$9(.!.%5!.112K!0+! &2!5(++$/&!>()2&.1!>.&#K.,+! (%!2*5$*! &2! (5$%&(3,!>0&.&()$!5*08!

&.*8$&+D!

@#2%*'#8=(#<$(&%264$=(

@'"%(

;rm7EqlN! 9(/$! K$*$! >0*/#.+$5! 3*29! N.%)($*! aE$! "$%$+&F4&! 6+1$M! -*.%/$VD! <e-:Z! J%2/J20&!

a<e-:Z!iQV!9(/$!8$%$*.&$5!=,!WD!:2&#$!K$*$!.!8(3&!3*29!gD!71$0&#9.%%!ag2339.%%FE.!:2/#$M!

7.+$1M!4K(&R$*1.%5VDnp!<#$,!K$*$!J$>&!2%!.!;rm7EqlN!=./J8*20%5D!6-eP:Z!J%2/J20&!a6-eP:Z!

iQV!9(/$!K$*$!>*2)(5$5!=,!@D!72%.>.*&$! a"01=$%J(.%! 6%+&(&0&$!23! 4/($%/$M!C2*&08.1VD!<#$+$!

9(/$! K$*$! =./J/*2++$5! 32*! 92*$! &#.%! Z[! 8$%$*.&(2%+! (%&2! .! #2928$%20+! ;rm7EqlN!

=./J8*20%5DoY! g292R,820+! <e-:Zl6-eP:Z! 520=1$! J%2/J20&! 9(/$! K$*$! 8$%$*.&$5! =,!

/*2++(%8! #292R,820+! <e-:Z! iQ! K(&#! #292R,820+! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$M! 32112K$5! =,!

(%&$*/*2++(%8! .%5! +$1$/&(%8!@iQ!9(/$D!P11! .%(9.1+!K$*$!9.(%&.(%$5! (%! .%!4C-! &$9>$*.&0*$F

/2%&*211$5M!.(*F/2%5(&(2%$5!.%(9.1!#20+$!K(&#!.!ZnF!&2!Z[F#20*F1(8#&l5.*J!/,/1$!.%5!*$/$()$5!

3225!.%5!K.&$*!/7&.*L*)#0D!Hd>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!2%!3$9.1$!9(/$!o!Zj!K$$J+!215D!P11!

.%(9.1!$d>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!.>>*2)$5!=,!&#$! (%+&(&0&(2%.1!$&#(/+!/299(&&$$!32*!.%(9.1!K$13.*$!

23!&#$!-./01&,!23!4/($%/$+M!"#$%&!'%()$*+(&,M!7$18(09!.%5!32112K$5!&#$!H0*2>$.%!80(5$1(%$+D!

@43=%(%H:%*'&%<2=(

E(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$! aEC4V! K.+! 5$*()$5! 3*29! M/.0"(%../& /L"5)#$& %d#*! a4(89.! P15*(/#V! .%5!

(%G$/&$5! (%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,!.&!pr[!¡8!>$*!920+$!.%5!9(/$!K$*$!92%(&2*$5!50*(%8!9.d(9.11,!

Z[[! #20*+! .3&$*! +&(901.&(2%! 32*! =25,! &$9>$*.&0*$! .%5! 1$&#.1(&,D! -2*! ;ECM! 9(/$! K$*$!

Page 178: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 165 of 237

.%$+&#$&(R$5!K(&#!(+2310*.%$D!<#$!/$/09!K.+!$d>2+$5!&#*208#!.!Z!/9!(%/(+(2%!(%!&#$!.=529$%!

.%5! 1(8.&$5D! <K2! >0%/&0*$+! K$*$! 9.5$! &#*208#! &#$! /$/09! 0+(%8! .! jZF8.08$! %$$51$D! <#$!

.=529(%.1!90+/01.&0*$!K.+!/12+$5!K(&#!*0%%(%8!+0&0*$+!.%5!&#$!+J(%!K(&#!9$&.11(/!/1(>+D!W(/$!

K$*$!(%G$/&$5!(%&*.>$*(&2%$.11,!K(&#!/$3&*(.d2%$!ajr!98lJ8U!4(89.V!.%5!9$&*2%(5.R21$!aZjDr!

98lJ8U! 4(89.V! Z[! .%5! jn! #20*+! .3&$*! ;EC! >*2/$50*$! .%5! 92%(&2*$5! 32*! *$/&.1! =25,!

&$9>$*.&0*$!.%5!1$&#.1(&,D!!

I%2%"2'4<(45('<2%=2'<#8($#&#Q%(#<$(:%*&%#G'8'2)N(#<$(")24J'<%(8%M%8=(

W(/$!K$*$! &*$.&$5!K(&#!EC4!.%5!$0&#.%(R$5! 32*!=1225!.%5!2*8.%! /211$/&(2%!.&! &#$! (%5(/.&$5!

&(9$!>2(%&+D!71225!K.+!(+21.&$5!&#*208#!/.*5(./!>0%/&0*$!.%5!/211$/&$5!(%!.>>*2>*(.&$!)(.1+D!

-2*! >1.+9.! >*$>.*.&(2%M! =1225! K.+! &*.%+3$**$5! &2! H@<PF/2.&$5! &0=$+! .%5! /$%&*(308$5! .&!

9.d(9.1! +>$$5! 32*! Zr! 9(%! .%5! +0>$*%.&.%&! K.+! /211$/&$5D! 4$*09! K.+! /211$/&$5! 32112K(%8!

2)$*%(8#&! /12&&(%8! .&! n¤;! .%5! /$%&*(308.&(2%! .%5! +&2*$5! .&! Fo[¤;! 0%&(1! .++.,$5D! C1.+9.!

3102*$+/$%/$!K.+!9$.+0*$5!.+!¥$dl¥$9!�!noolrj[!%9D!@$&$/&(2%!23!(%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!

>*2&$(%+!K.+!.++.,$5!K(&#!6F-P7C!HE64P!a;0+.=(2!7(2&$/#VD!!-2*!&#$!5$&$/&(2%!23!<e-:Z!1$)$1+M!

s0.%&(J(%$!+>rr<e-:!i(&!a:B@!4,+&$9+V!K.+!0+$5D!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!K.+!0+$5!&2!5$&$/&!

<e-M!W6CFZvM!W6CFZuM!"WF;4-M!i;M!W;CFZM!6EFZvM!6EFZuM!6EFjM!6EFrM!6EFYM!6EFZ[M!6EFZj>n[M!6EFZpM!

6EFZmPM! 6EFZm-M! 6EFjp>ZY! .%5! 6-ey! ajpF>1$dM! 7(2*.5VU! .%5! 6-ev! .%5! 6-eu! aW20+$! 6-e!

.1>#.l=$&.!C1.&(%09!aC*2/.*&.VD!P11!.=2)$F9$%&(2%$5!&$/#%(?0$+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!.//2*5(%8!

&2!&#$!9.%03./&0*$*+c!(%+&*0/&(2%+D!

12#2'=2'"=(

:$+01&+! a9$.%xF! 4@! 2*! 4HWV! K$*$! /29>.*$5! K(&#! .! jF&.(1$5! 4&05$%&�+! &! &$+&D! 4&.&(+&(/+! 2%!

+0*)().1! /0*)$+! K$*$! >$*32*9$5!K(&#! E28F*.%J! aW.%&$1F;2dV! &$+&+D! C! ).10$+! 1$++! &#.%! [D[r!

K$*$!/2%+(5$*$5!+(8%(3(/.%&D!�!>!¦![M[rM!��!>!¦![M[ZM!���!>!¦![M[[ZM!����!>!§![M[[[Z!

!"J<4K8%$Q%&%<2=(

L$!K2015!1(J$!&2!&#.%J!N2J$!I.%5$%=$*8#$!32*!&$/#%(/.1!.++(+&.%/$!(%!9(/$!=*$$5(%8D!

(

(

(

Page 179: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 166 of 237

13::8%&%<2#*)(?'Q3*%=(

!13::8%&%<2#*)(?'Q3*%(-D(;?>!7-(OZN(G32(<42(9>?7-(#<$(IOZ(&'"%(#*%(='Q<'5'"#<28)(:*42%"2%$(

'<(FCE/'<$3"%$(:48)&'"*4G'#8(=%:='=(

_PV!L(15! &,>$M! 6-eP:Z!iQM! <e-:Z!iQ! .%5!@iQ!K$*$! +0=G$/&$5! &2! /$/.1! 1(8.&(2%!>0%/&0*$! a;ECVF(%50/$5!+$>+(+D!40*)().1!K.+!92%(&2*$5!0%&(1!%2!30*&#$*!5$.&#+!2//0**$5!a%!�!.&!1$.+&!Zp!9(/$!K$*$!0+$5!>$*!8*20>VD!71./J!2>$%! &*(.%81$+M! 6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!K(15! &,>$U! 1(8#&! 8*$,M!<e-:Z!iQU!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQU!(%&$*9$5(.&$!8*$,M!@iQ(

(

(

(

!13::8%&%<2#*)(?'Q3*%(+D(9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-($4(<42(#55%"2(=%*3&(8%M%8=(45(;?>iN(;C/0N(;C/-\?(

#<$(;C/+X:-^(#52%*(CE1(

W(/$!K$*$!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!pr[!¡8!23!EC4!.%5!=1225!K.+!/211$/&$5!o!#20*+!.3&$*!+&(901.&(2%D!a!V!;2%/$%&*.&(2%+! 23! 6-eyM! 6EFrM! 6EFZm-! .%5! 6EFjpF>ZY!K$*$! 5$&$*9(%$5!K(&#! E09(%$d! &$/#%2128,D!L(15! &,>$! 9(/$! *$>*$+$%&! #$*$! >221$5! 8*20>+! 3*29! 6-eP:Z! .%5! <e-:Z! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$D! 7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!.&!1$.+&!q!9(/$!>$*!8*20>VD!71./JM!K(15!&,>$U!1(8#&!8*$,M!<e-:Z!iQU!5.*J!8*$,M!6-eP:Z!iQU!K#(&$M!@iQ(

(

! (

!"!"##$%&%'()*+,-./"*%,0,

0 50 100 150 200 2500

25

50

75

100

Time after CLP (hours)

Sur

viva

l (%

)

DKO

IFNAR1KO

TNFR1KO

IFNAR1WT

TNFR1WT

*

!"

0 8 8 8 80

1000

2000

3000

Time after LPS (hours)

IL-5

(pg/

ml)

****

****

****

****

!"##$%&%'()*+,-./"*%,0,

0 8 8 8 80

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-1

7F] (

pg/m

l)

********

********

0 8 8 8 80

100

200

300

400

Time after LPS (hours)

[IL-2

3p19

] (pg

/ml)

*

****

**

****

****

0 8 8 8 80

10

20

30

40

50

Time after LPS (hours)

[IFN!]

(x 1

03 pg

/ml) ***

****

****

****

Page 180: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 167 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! E29=.*5(!@CM!H%81$=$*8!e;D!P%.$*2=(/!=./&$*$9(.A!(%/(5$%/$M!>.&($%&!/#.*./&$*(+&(/+M!.%5!/1(%(/.1!+(8%(3(/.%/$D!U0&c&!%7D!ZYYjUYjaZVArpFq[D!

jD!! g.8$1!4M!C1$&R!WLM!7*0%J#2*+&!-WM!4$(3$*&!gM!i$*%!L!ID!�7./&$*$9(.!.%5!+$>+(+�D!,()%5(*$)&16%5.2D!

j[ZpUrnanVApYYFn[mD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+[[Z[oF[ZjFpZorFnD!

pD!! C(&&$&!@M!<#(X)$%&!7M!L$%R$1!:CM!E(!eM!P0/J$%&#.1$*!:M!40&$*!CWD!7$5+(5$!>*$5(/&(2%!23!92*&.1(&,!3*29!=./&$*$9(/!+$>+(+D!P!5,%.9(/!.%.1,+(+!23!6;'!>.&($%&+D!U0&c&>%$4*5&?5*)&?/5%&!%7D!ZYYqUZrpajVAqonFYpD!

52(AZ[DZZqnl.G*//9DZrpDjDorqnZZoD!

nD!! C21&2*.J!PM!g$!OM!49(*%2).!6M!$&!.1D!@$3$/&()$!EC4!+(8%.1(%8!(%!;pglg$N!.%5!;rm7ElZ[4/;*!9(/$A!

90&.&(2%+!(%!<1*n!8$%$D!M+*%(+%&1RGF&2D!ZYYoUjojarpYqVAj[orFoD!

rD!! @2(!iM!E$$1.#.).%(/#J01!PM!�0$%!C4<M!4&.*!:PD!4/($%/$!(%!9$5(/(%$!P%(9.1!925$1+!23!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>+(+F

(%50/$5!J(5%$,!(%G0*,D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[YUZZYaZ[VAjoqoFmoD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pYnjZDjoqoD!

qD!! @$!"*22&$!@M!�.%8$*1$!C-M!"$).$*&!�M!$&!.1D!@(*$/&!+&(901.&(2%!23!/,&2J(%$+!a6EFZ!=$&.M!<e-F.1>#.M!6EFqM!6EFjM!6-eF8.99.!.%5!"WF;4-V!(%!K#21$!=1225D!6D!;29>.*(+2%!K(&#!(+21.&$5!C7W;!+&(901.&(2%D!?9)"B*(%D!

ZYYjUnapVAjpYFnoD!

mD!! 71.%/#.*5!@iM!@G$0!N�M!i1$(%!<LM!-*($59.%!gM!4&$K.*&!LHD!6%&$*3$*2%F8.99.!(%50/&(2%!=,!

1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$A!5$>$%5$%/$!2%!(%&$*1$0J(%!j!.%5!9./*2>#.8$+D!c&,00#(".D!ZYoqUZpqapVAYqpFm[D!

oD!! I.*9.!<iM!E(%!;�M!<21()$*Fi(%+J,!<HM!4#$*K225!H:D!H%52&2d(%F(%50/$5!8.99.!(%&$*3$*2%!>*250/&(2%A!

/2%&*(=0&(%8!/$11!&,>$+!.%5!J$,!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*+D!?.*(&3*/8(&S/L&,00#(".D!j[[jUYapVArp[FnpD!

YD!! -0G(#.*.!WM!6&2!eM!C./$!NEM!L.&.%.=$!�M!:0++$11!4LM!40R0J(!<D!:21$!23!$%528$%20+!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!(%!1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F&*(88$*$5!./&().&(2%!23!&#$!(%50/(=1$!%(&*(/F2d(5$!+,%&#.+$!8$%$!(%!.!920+$!

9./*2>#.8$!/$11!1(%$M!NmmnD!c&6*".&?;%0D!ZYYnUjqYaZmVAZjmmpFoD!

Z[D!! @$G.8$*!EM!C(%#$(*2!6M!@$G2%/J#$$*$!HM!E(=$*&!;D!;$/.1!1(8.&(2%!.%5!>0%/&0*$A!&#$!8215!+&.%5.*5!925$1!32*!

>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+S!A5%(7$&!*+5"L*".D!j[ZZUZYanVAZYoFj[oD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD&(9Dj[ZZD[ZD[[ZD!

ZZD!! :(&&(*+/#!@M!g2$+$1!EWM!L.*5!CPD!<#$!5(+/2%%$/&!=$&K$$%!.%(9.1!925$1+!23!+$>+(+!.%5!#09.%!+$>+(+D!c&

S%#B"+&6*".D!j[[mUoZaZVAZpmFnpD!52(AZ[DZZoYlG1=D[o[qrnjD!

ZjD!! �.%!CM!E(0!eM!i(9!"FWM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&#$!&,>$!Z!.%5!&,>$!j!*$/$>&2*+!32*!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!.3&$*!

&*.09.&(/!+>(%.1!/2*5!(%G0*,!(%!.501&!*.&+D!T_4&V%#5".D!j[[pUZopajVAjoqFYmD!

ZpD!! I$%J.&$+#!@M!H*%.%5$R!<M!:2+$&&(!-M!$&!.1D!H%52&#$1(.1!<e-!*$/$>&2*!j!(%50/$+!6:-Z!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*F5$>$%5$%&!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!.0&2/*(%$!+(8%.1(%8!&2!>*292&$!92%2/,&$!*$/*0(&9$%&D!,00#(*)9D!

j[ZpUpoarVAZ[jrFpmD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpD[ZD[ZjD!

ZnD!! <*./$,!iNM!L$(!gM!W.%280$!i:M!$&!.1D!;./#$/&(%l&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!(%50/$+!/./#$d(.M!.%$9(.M!.%5!

(%31.99.&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!ZYooUZqmapVAZjZZFjmD!

ZrD!! E$2%!E:M!L#(&$!.!.M!i108$*!WND!:21$!23!6EFq!.%5!<e-!(%!&#$*92*$801.&(2%!.%5!+0*)().1!50*(%8!+$>+(+!(%!

9(/$D!U0&c&\;9$*".D!ZYYoUjmraZ!C&!jVA:jqYFmmD!

ZqD!! C.+>.*.J(+!WM!P1$d2>20120!EM!H>(+J2>20!IM!i211(.+!"D!6990%$!.%5!(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$+!(%!<e-!.1>#.F5$3(/($%&!9(/$A!.!/*(&(/.1!*$?0(*$9$%&!32*!<e-!.1>#.!(%!&#$!32*9.&(2%!23!>*(9.*,!7!/$11!3211(/1$+M!3211(/01.*!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!%$&K2*J+!.%5!8$*9(%.1!/$%&$*+M!.%5!(%!&#$!9.&0*.&(2%!23!&#$!#092*.1!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!c&

T_4&!%7D!ZYYqUZonanVAZpYmFnZZD!

Page 181: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 168 of 237

ZmD!! 42%8!�M!42%8!�M!�(%!NM!$&!.1D!"$%$&(/!).*(.&(2%!(%!&#$!<e-!8$%$!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!+$)$*$!+$>+(+M!=0&!%2&!K(&#!92*&.1(&,D!L0*3$1!WWM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZjUmaYVA$nqZZpD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[nqZZpD!

ZoD!! P&R$%(!-M!<0*($1!WM!;.>+2%(!-M!@2*(.!PM!W$*2%(!CM!4.*R(FC0&&(%(!CD!P0&2(990%(&,!.%5!.%&(F<e-F.1>#.!

.8$%&+D!U((&V&n&U+/7&M+*D!j[[rUZ[rZArrYFqYD!52(AZ[DZZYql.%%.1+DZpqZDZ[[D!

ZYD!! 7$0&1$*!7M!W(1+.*J!6M!;$*.9(!PD!C.++()$!(990%(R.&(2%!.8.(%+&!/./#$/&(%l&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!>*2&$/&+!9(/$!3*29!1$&#.1!$33$/&!23!$%52&2d(%D!M+*%(+%&1RGF&2D!ZYorUjjYanmZqVAoqYFomZD!

52(AZ[DZZjql+/($%/$DpoYrnpmD!

j[D!! <*./$,!iNM!7$0&1$*!7M!E2K*,!4-M!$&!.1D!4#2/J!.%5!&(++0$!(%G0*,!(%50/$5!=,!*$/29=(%.%&!#09.%!/./#$/&(%D!

M+*%(+%D!ZYoqUjpnanmmrVAnm[FnD!

jZD!! <*./$,!iNM!-2%8!�M!g$++$!@"M!$&!.1D!P%&(F/./#$/&(%l<e-!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25($+!>*$)$%&!+$>&(/!+#2/J!

50*(%8!1$&#.1!=./&$*.$9(.D!V/)#5%D!ZYomUpp[aqZnYVAqqjFnD!52(AZ[DZ[polpp[qqj.[D!

jjD!! -($51$*!I7M!E223!6M!4.%5$*!HM!I2$#*(%8$*!IM!".1.%2+!;M!-20*%$1!WPD!W2%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,!&2!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*FF.1>#.!>*$)$%&+!1$&#.1!$%52&2d(%!+$>+(+!(%!.501&!*#$+0+!92%J$,+D!c&S/L&?.*(&!%7D!ZYYjUZj[anVArmnF

ooD!

jpD!! :$(%#.*&!iM!i.*R.(!LD!P%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,!(%!+$>+(+A!0>5.&$!2%!/1(%(/.1!&*(.1+!.%5!1$++2%+!

1$.*%$5D!?5*)&?/5%&!%7D!j[[ZUjYam!40>>1VA4ZjZFrD!

jnD!! -(+#$*!;NM!P82+&(!NWM!Q>.1!4WM!$&!.1D!<*$.&9$%&!23!+$>&(/!+#2/J!K(&#!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*A-/!30+(2%!>*2&$(%D!<#$!4210=1$!<e-!:$/$>&2*!4$>+(+!4&05,!"*20>D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!ZYYqUppnajqVAZqYmFm[jD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNWZYYq[qjmppnjq[pD!

jrD!! E)!4M!g.%!WM!�(!:M!iK2%!4M!@.(!;M!L.%8!:D!P%&(F<e-Fv!&#$*.>,!32*!>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$>+(+A!.!+,+&$9.&(/!9$&.F

.%.1,+(+D!,()&c&?.*(&\5/+)D!j[ZnUqoanVArj[FoD!52(AZ[DZZZZl(G/>DZjpojD!

jqD!! e.05X!CNLM!5$%!72$*!N!.M!E0(&$%!C"WM!H(+$1!'EWD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!/*2++F&.1JD!WT6M&cD!

j[ZZUjmoaqVAoooFYoD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZmnjFnqroDj[ZZD[o[ZmDdD!

jmD!! g(G5*.!@M!I2*+$1..*+!P@M!"*0&&$*+!N;M!;1.$++$%!PWM!:(GJ$*+!"<D!@(33$*$%&(.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!<e-:Z!a;@Zj[.V!.%5!<e-:j!a;@Zj[=V!2%!+0=>2>01.&(2%+!23!#09.%!92%2/,&$+D!c&,(-./00D!j[ZjUYaZVApoD!

52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmqFYjrrFYFpoD!

joD!! W/;.%%!-HM!C$*2/#$.0!@CM!:0+>(!"M!$&!.1D!4$1$/&()$!<e-:Z!=12/J.5$!(+!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!.%5!*$)$.1+!.%!

(990%2*$801.&2*,!*21$!32*!<e-:jD!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0/)".D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DpomrrD!

jYD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!E(=$*&!;D!<*$.&9$%&!23!<e-!9$5(.&$5!5(+$.+$+!=,!+$1$/&()$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!+210=1$!<e-!2*!<e-:ZD!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[ZZUjjarFqVApZZFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&283*Dj[ZZD[YD[[nD!

p[D!! L(11(.9+!4iM!W.($*!QM!-(+/#$*!:M!$&!.1D!P%&(=25,F9$5(.&$5!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.&&$%0.&$+!5(+$.+$!(%!.!920+$!925$1!23!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!E(%J$*!:PM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZnUYajVA$Y[ZZmD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[Y[ZZmD!

pZD!! @$3$*!eM!PR*2,.%!PM!C$/J$*!-M!C.)2(%$!;D!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!+(8%.1(%8!(%&$*>1.,!(%!/.*5(./!9,2/,&$+D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[[mUjojanYVAprrqnFmpD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/DWm[n[[pj[[D!

pjD!! N(%!gM!�.%8!:M!W.*+&$*+!4PM!$&!.1D!C*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!*.&!$%52&2d(/!+#2/J!=,!>rr!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!*$/$>&2*!(990%2.5#$+(%A!/29>.*(+2%!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!

ZYYnUZm[arVAZpjpFqD!

ppD!! W0J.(!�M!4#(=.&.!gM!e.J.90*.!<M!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*$F30%/&(2%!*$1.&(2%+#(>!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!a<e-V!.%5!(&+!*$/$>&2*!(%&$*./&(2%!=.+$5!2%!p@!+&*0/&0*.1!.%.1,+(+!23!.!3011,!./&()$!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()$!<e-!90&.%&D!c&

!".&6*".D!j[[YUporanVAZjjZFYD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG9=Dj[[oDZZD[rpD!

Page 182: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 169 of 237

pnD!! e290*.!<M!P=$!�M!�2+#(2J.!�M!e.J.8.K.!4M!<+0%25.!4M!<+0&+09(!�D!�;*$.&(2%!23!<e-:ZF+$1$/&()$!

.%&.82%(+&!.%5!(&+!&#$*.>$0&(/!$33$/&+�D!c&\;/50&M"+&c/4/(D!j[Z[UZp[aZVAqpFoD!

prD!! @$!L$$*5!e!.M!4.9.*.G(K.!4!.M!g$*&R28!CND!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!*$/$>&2*+A!=(2/#$9(+&*,!.%5!=(2128(/.1!

30%/&(2%+D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[[mUjojajoVAj[[rpFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/D:m[[[[qj[[D!

pqD!! <*(%/#($*(!"D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!3*($%5!2*!32$S!c&T_4&!%7D!j[Z[Uj[maZ[VAj[rpFqpD!

52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[Z[ZqqnD!

pmD!! W.#($0!<M!E(=$*&!;D!4#2015!K$!(%#(=(&!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!(%!+$>+(+S!,(-%+)&,00#(D!j[[mUmraZVAjjFYD!

52(AZ[DZZjol6P6D[[ojYF[qD!

poD!! 4/#K.%5&!<M!4/#09.J!7M!"($1$%!"gM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!=,!+>1$%(/!9./*2>#.8$+!

+0>>*$++$+!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!T!6^&cD!j[ZjUpZaZVAj[ZFZpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol$9=2GDj[ZZDpo[D!

pYD!! g$%*,!<M!i(*(9.%G$+K.*.!"4M!:0=,!<M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!6-e!4(8%.1(%8!;2%+&*.(%+!6EFZmPl-!4$/*$&(2%!=,!<!;$11+!

50*(%8!7./&$*(.1!6%3$/&(2%+D!c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZonamVApmrrFpmqmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[j[qrD!

n[D!! @$!L$$*5!ePM!I()(.%!NCM!e80,$%!<iM!$&!.1D!4&*0/&0*.1!=.+(+!23!.!0%(?0$!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!+(8%.1(%8!.d(+!

9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!*$/$>&2*!6-eP:ZD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[ZpUZnaYVAY[ZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(DjqqmD!

nZD!! i.*.8#(2+233!WM!4&$(%=2*%!:M!i2).*(J!CM!$&!.1D!;$%&*.1!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!<,Jj!(%!

1(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$F(%50/$5!$%52&2d(%!+#2/JD!V/)&,00#(".D!j[[pUnarVAnmZFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(YZ[D!

njD!! C.(%R!:M!L.1&$*!6M!i21=$!<M!$&!.1D!Q*8.%F+>$/(3(/!.%5!5(33$*$%&(.1!*$?0(*$9$%&!23!<�ij!.%5!6-eP:Z!32*!EC4F(%50/$5!(eQ4!$d>*$++(2%!(%!)()2D!,00#("L*"."89D!j[[mUjZjaYFZ[VAoqpFmrD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(9=(2Dj[[mD[YD[ZmD!

npD!! :2&#$!NM!E$++1.0$*!LM!Ez&+/#$*!gM!$&!.1D!W(/$!1./J(%8!&#$!&0920*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!.*$!*$+(+&.%&!&2!<e-F9$5(.&$5!&2d(/(&,!=0&!#(8#1,!+0+/$>&(=1$!&2!(%3$/&(2%!=,!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+D!V/)#5%D!

ZYYpUpqnaqnn[VAmYoFo[jD!52(AZ[DZ[polpqnmYo.[D!

nnD!! C$+/#2%!NNM!<2**.%/$!@4M!4&2/J(%8!iEM!$&!.1D!<e-!*$/$>&2*F5$3(/($%&!9(/$!*$)$.1!5()$*8$%&!*21$+!32*!>rr!

.%5!>mr!(%!+$)$*.1!925$1+!23!(%31.99.&(2%D!c&,00#(".D!ZYYoUZq[ajVAYnpFrjD!

nrD!! ;0%%(%8#.9!CeM!@,.%2)!gWM!C.*J!CM!L.%8!NM!e$K$11!i!.DM!s0(88!:ND!P/0&$!:$%.1!-.(10*$!(%!H%52&2d$9(.!6+!;.0+$5!=,!<e-!P/&(%8!@(*$/&1,!2%!<e-!:$/$>&2*FZ!(%!i(5%$,D!c&,00#(".D!j[[jUZqoaZZVAroZmFrojpD!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZqoDZZDroZmD!

nqD!! W.*(%2!WLM!@0%%!.M!"*.(1!@M!$&!.1D!;#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F5$3(/($%&!9(/$D!\5"+&V/).&

U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!ZYYmUYnaZrVAo[YpFoD!

nmD!! E(!NM!�#.%8!�M!E20!NM!$&!.1D!e$0&*.1(+.&(2%!23!>$*(&2%$.1!6EFZmP!9.*J$51,!(9>*2)$+!&#$!>*28%2+(+!23!+$)$*$!+$>&(/!9(/$!=,!5$/*$.+(%8!%$0&*2>#(1!(%3(1&*.&(2%!.%5!>*2(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+D!:,33$1!7M!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!

j[ZjUmaZ[VA$nqr[qD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[nqr[qD!

noD!! W.#($0!<M!C.*J!NWM!:$)$&+!gM!$&!.1D!<#$!K(15F5$*()$5!(%=*$5!920+$!+&*.(%!4C:H<lH(!(+!*$+(+&.%&!&2!EC4!.%5!5$3$/&()$!(%!6-eF=$&.!>*250/&(2%D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[qUZ[pamVAjjYjFmD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[rZ[omnZ[pD!

nYD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

r[D!! @0&R!NCD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.!(%#(=(&(2%!.%5!>.192>1.%&.*!>0+&012+(+A!N.%0+F3./$5!&#$*.>,S!c&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[mUpnajVAjnmFYD!

Page 183: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 170 of 237

rZD!! ;0=(11.+!:M!i(%&%$*!iM!C#(11(>+!-M!i.*.%5(J.*!eNM!<#($1$!@EM!7*2K%!":D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!$d>*$++(2%!(+!0>*$801.&$5!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!g;I!K#2!*$+>2%5!&2!&#$*.>,D![%4/)&

>%$&A5%/)D!j[Z[Uj[Z[AnjYjnpD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[Z[lnjYjnpD!

rjD!! g2%5.!iM!�.%.(!gM!e$8(+#(!gM!$&!.1D!6:-Fm!(+!&#$!9.+&$*!*$801.&2*!23!&,>$F6!(%&$*3$*2%F5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!

*$+>2%+$+D!V/)#5%D!j[[rUnpnam[pnVAmmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%.&0*$[pnqnD!

rpD!! P+.%2!WM!g.,.+#(!WM!�2+#(5.!HM!i.K.5$!�M!6K.J0*.!�D!6%50/&(2%!23!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.M!

=0&!%2&!23!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.M!(%!&#$!920+$D!@*5"."89D!ZYY[UZmqaZVAp[FoD!

rnD!! W21%.*3(!eM!"*0.R!EM!@.,$*!NFWM!70*8$*!@D!Q>>2+(&$!$33$/&+!23!6-e!=$&.!2%!/,&2J(%$!#29$2+&.+(+!(%!EC4F!

.%5!<!/$11!/2%&./&F./&().&$5!#09.%!92%2/,&$+D!c&V%#5"*00#(".D!j[[nUZnqaZFjVAmqFopD!

rrD!! <(18!gM!I28$1!LM!@(%.*$112!;!.D!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!(%50/$+!/(*/01.&(%8!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!>rr!(%!

#09.%+D!6.""7D!ZYYrUorajVAnppFrD!

rqD!! "211(%!"M!W.*J+!;M!W.*J+!LgD!6%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!(%!+$*09!.%5!0*(%$!*$31$/&+!$.*1,!

(+/#$9(/!(%G0*,!&2!&#$!+9.11!=2K$1D!M#58%59D!ZYYpUZZparVArnrFrZD!

rmD!! @$*(Jd!NCD!e2%F(%).+()$!9.*J$*+!23!80&!K.11!(%&$8*(&,!(%!#$.1&#!.%5!5(+$.+$D!e"5.7&c&'/$)5"%()%5".D!

j[Z[UZqanjVArjmjD!52(AZ[DpmnolKG8D)ZqD(njDrjmjD!

roD!! I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!@$G2%/J#$$*$!HM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!$&!.1D!W.&*(d!9$&.112>*2&$(%.+$!Zp!92501.&$+!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(.1!=.**($*!(%&$8*(&,!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$+!=,!./&().&(%8!<e-D!T!6^&!".&!%7D!

j[ZpUramVAYpjFnoD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$999Dj[Zj[jZ[[D!

rYD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!P*9.J.!WM!i.*.8(.%%(!eM!$&!.1D!4.3$!<e-F=.+$5!.%&(&092*!&#$*.>,!32112K(%8!

>rr<e-:!*$50/&(2%!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZpUZjpaqVAjrY[Fq[pD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qrqjnD!

q[D!! "02!4M!P1F4.5(!:M!4.(5!gWM!W.!<�D!E(>2>21,+.//#.*(5$!/.0+$+!.%!(%/*$.+$!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!&(8#&!G0%/&(2%!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!)(&*2!.%5!(%!)()2!=,!(%50/(%8!$%&$*2/,&$!9$9=*.%$!$d>*$++(2%!.%5!12/.1(R.&(2%!23!<E:Fn!

.%5!;@ZnD!U0&c&\/);".D!j[ZpUZojajVApmrFomD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD.G>.&#Dj[ZjDZ[D[ZnD!

qZD!! "0!EM!E(!eM!"2%8!NM!E(!sM!�#0!LM!E(!ND!7$*=$*(%$!.9$1(2*.&$+!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(.1!&(8#&FG0%/&(2%!5.9.8$!.%5!52K%F*$801.&$+!9,2+(%!1(8#&!/#.(%!J(%.+$!>.&#K.,+!(%!.!920+$!925$1!23!$%52&2d(%$9(.D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!

j[ZZUj[paZZVAZq[jFZjD!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%35(+lG(*ZnmD!

qjD!! <(+2%/(J!N:M!i2*&#!WNM!4(992%+!;CM!-.**.*!NM!W.*&(%!<:M!i.&R$!W"D!6%&2!&#$!$,$!23!&#$!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9D!

!*+5"L*".&!".&6*".&>%=D!j[ZjUmqaZVAZqFpjD!52(AZ[DZZjolWW7:D[r[ZrFZZD!

qpD!! <+0G(92&2!WM!-$(%9.%!:M!I(1/$J!ND!@(33$*$%&(.1!$33$/&+!23!&,>$!6!6-e!.%5!6-eF8.99.!2%!&#$!=(%5(%8!23!

&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&2!*$/$>&2*+!(%!&K2!#09.%!/$11!1(%$+D!c&,00#(".D!ZYoqUZpmamVAjjmjFqD!

qnD!! -(%J!iM!W.*&(%!EM!W0J.K$*.!HM!$&!.1D!6-eul<e-v!+,%$*8(+9!(%50/$+!.!%2%F/.%2%(/.1!4<P<jl6:-YF5$>$%5$%&!>.&#K.,!&*(88$*(%8!.!%2)$1!@'QOj!eP@Cg!2d(5.+$F9$5(.&$5!.(*K.,!.%&()(*.1!*$+>2%+$D!?%..&

>%$D!j[ZpUjparVAqmpFY[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol/*Dj[ZpDnmD!

qrD!! ;2$*+!NM!I.%/$!:HM!-2%&.%.!W-M!@($&*(/#!L-D!:$+&*(/&(2%!23!E$8(2%$11.!>%$092>#(1.!8*2K&#!(%!9./*2>#.8$+!*$?0(*$+!&#$!/2%/$*&$5!./&(2%!23!/,&2J(%$!.%5!e.(>rl6>.3!+(8%.11(%8!>.&#K.,+D!?%..&

!*+5"L*".D!j[[mUYaZ[VAjpnnFrmD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqjFrojjDj[[mD[[YqpDdD!

qqD!! 4$2!4F'M!iK2%!gFNM!i2!gFNM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!*$801.&$+!E,q;a#(V!92%2/,&$+!.%5!%$0&*2>#(1+!50*(%8!./0&$!)(*.1!>%$092%(.!(%!9(/$D!\S"M&\/);"8D!j[ZZUmajVA$Z[[Zp[nD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>>.&DZ[[Zp[nD!

qmD!! @$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$),)$*!4M!7.11$8$$*!WM!$&!.1D!C#.*9./2128(/.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!

>*2&$/&+!9(/$!.8.(%+&!1$&#.1!+$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZpUj[YaqVAYq[Fm[D!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%35(+lG(&q[[D!

Page 184: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 171 of 237

qoD!! Qc"*.5,!eCM!<*2>$.!WM!C*$.+!gEM!$&!.1D!@$&$/&(2%!23!9./*2>#.8$!(%31.99.&2*,!>*2&$(%!aW6CVFZ.1>#.!.%5!W6CFZ=$&.!50*(%8!$d>$*(9$%&.1!$%52&2d$9(.!.%5!#09.%!+$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!ZYYYUZmYaZVAZpqFnZD!

52(AZ[DZ[oqlpZnrrYD!

qYD!! L2%8!g:M!4#.%1$,!<CM!4.J&#()$1!7M!$&!.1D!"$%29$F1$)$1!$d>*$++(2%!>*23(1$+!(%!>$5(.&*(/!+$>&(/!+#2/J!(%5(/.&$!.!*21$!32*!.1&$*$5!R(%/!#29$2+&.+(+!(%!>22*!20&/29$D!\;9$*".&'%("0*+$D!j[[mUp[ajVAZnqFrrD!

52(AZ[DZZrjl>#,+(218$%29(/+D[[[jnDj[[mD!

m[D!! e2K.J!NHM!L#$$1$*!@4M!g.*92%!iiM!L2%8!g:D!P59(++(2%!/#$92J(%$!a;F;!92&(3V!1(8.%5!n!1$)$1+!>*$5(/&!+0*)().1!(%!>$5(.&*(/!+$>&(/!+#2/JD!\%7*/)5&?5*)&?/5%&!%7D!j[Z[UZZajVAjZpFqD!

52(AZ[DZ[YmlC;;D[=[Zp$pZoZ=o[mq/D!

mZD!! -.%&0RR(!EM!;.%(%(!6M!7$1.*5$11(!-M!"$++.%(!4D!6-eF=$&.!+&(901.&$+!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!=$&.F/#$92J(%$+!(%!#09.%!>$*(>#$*.1!=1225!92%2/,&$+D!69>2*&.%/$!23!9./*2>#.8$!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D!T#5&?9)"B*(%&V%)JD!

j[[ZUZjanVArYmFq[pD!

mjD!! 4.1.R.*FW.&#$*!<CM!E$K(+!;PM!7(*2%!;PD!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!*$801.&$!(%31.99.&2*,!/$11!&*.33(/J(%8!.%5!9./*2>#.8$!(%31.99.&2*,!>*2&$(%!Z.1>#.!5$1()$*,!&2!&#$!1()$*D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[jUZZ[apVApjZFp[D!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6ZrpmqD!

mpD!! -0G(&.!gM!P+.#(%.!PM!<.5.!�M!-0G(K.*.!gM!<.9.J(!iD!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!(%#(=(&!9.&0*.&(2%!.%5!./&().&(2%!23!920+$!E.%8$*#.%+!/$11+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[[rUZjraZVAZjqFppD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGD[[jjFj[jODj[[rDjpo[pDdD!

mnD!! �.%8!�;M!g.15$*!N7M!4.9.%&.!PiM!g2%8!NM!:()$*.!IWM!�#.%8!N�D!:$801.&(2%!23!/#$92J(%$!*$/$>&2*!;;:r!.%5!

>*250/&(2%!23!:Pe<H4!.%5!W6CFZ.1>#.!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F=$&.D!c&V%#5"*00#(".D!j[[ZUZZjaZFjVAZmnFo[D!

mrD!! 72+9.%%!WM!L.*5!CPD!<#$*.>$0&(/!>2&$%&(.1!23!&.*8$&(%8!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjp!(%!+$>+(+D!?.*(&A5/($.&!%7D!

j[ZjUZaZVAnD!52(AZ[DZZoqlj[[ZFZpjqFZFnD!

mqD!! 72+9.%%!WM!4.*9.!NIM!P&$3(!"M!�$&20%$!-4M!L.*5!C!.D!H)(5$%/$!32*!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!;r.!2%!&#$!

(%%.&$!6EFZmPl6EFjp!.d(+D!WUMT6&cD!j[ZjUjqanVAZqn[FrZD!52(AZ[DZ[Yql3GDZZFZYYjZqD!

mmD!! i$$1!WM!'%8$&#f9!'M!4&$/J#21R$*!'M!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%FZ[!/20%&$**$801.&$+!>*2(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$F

(%50/$5!(%#(=(&(2%!23!%$0&*2>#(1!.>2>&2+(+!50*(%8!+$)$*$!+$>+(+D!6.""7D!ZYYmUY[aYVApprqFqpD!

moD!! Q&&2%$112!EM!-*09$%&2!"M!P*50(%2!eM!$&!.1D!@(33$*$%&(.1!*$801.&(2%!23!+>2%&.%$20+!.%5!(990%$!/29>1$dF(%50/$5!%$0&*2>#(1!.>2>&2+(+!=,!>*2(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+D!:21$!23!2d(5.%&+M!7.d!.%5!/.+>.+$FpD!c&S%#B"+&6*".D!j[[jUmjaZVAZjrFpjD!

mYD!! -(.1J2K!EM!-2/#$+.&&2!-(1#2!EM!72RR$&&(!W;M!$&!.1D!e$0&*2>#(1!.>2>&2+(+A!.!9.*J$*!23!5(+$.+$!+$)$*(&,!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!+$>+(+F(%50/$5!./0&$!*$+>(*.&2*,!5(+&*$++!+,%5*29$D!?5*)&?/5%D!j[[qUZ[aqVA:ZrrD!52(AZ[DZZoql//r[Y[D!

o[D!! L.&+2%!:LM!:2&+&$(%!Q@M!C.*252!NM!$&!.1D!<#$!6EFZ!=$&.F/2%)$*&(%8!$%R,9$!a/.+>.+$FZV!(%#(=(&+!.>2>&2+(+!23!(%31.99.&2*,!%$0&*2>#(1+!&#*208#!./&().&(2%!23!6EFZ!=$&.D!c&,00#(".D!ZYYoUZqZajVAYrmFqjD!

oZD!! C$*(/1$!-M!E(0!NgM!@(.R!N6M!$&!.1D!6%&$*1$0J(%Fj!>*$)$%&(2%!23!.>2>&2+(+!(%!#09.%!%$0&*2>#(1+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!ZYYnUjnajVAnn[FnD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(DZop[jn[jjqD!

ojD!! :.=(%2)(/(!:M!-$0$*+&$(%!"M!P=5011.#!-M!$&!.1D!E2/.11,!C*250/$5!<092*!e$/*2+(+!-./&2*F!W$5(.&$+!6%&$*1$0J(%Fj!6%50/$5!E0%8!6%G0*,D!?*5+&>%$D!ZYYqUmoajVApjYFppqD!52(AZ[DZZqZl[ZD:H4DmoDjDpjYD!

opD!! E2**X!iM!-*.%+$%!EM!;$0>>$%+!NED!6%&$*1$0J(%Fj!(%50/$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%!=,!./&().&$5!#09.%!<!/$11+!)(.!.!/,/12+>2*(%F+$%+(&()$!>.&#K.,D!T#5&?9)"B*(%&V%)JD!ZYYjUpapVApjZFp[D!

onD!! 4&$>#$%+!iHM!6+#(R.J.!PM!E.**(/J!NLM!:.33(%!<PD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!/.0+$+!(%/*$.+$5!>0192%.*,!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.%5!$5$9.D!;29>.*(+2%!&2!+$>&(/!./0&$!10%8!(%G0*,D!U0&>%=&>%$4*5&3*$D!ZYooUZpmaqVAZpqnFm[D!52(AZ[DZZqnl.G*//9lZpmDqDZpqnD!

Page 185: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 172 of 237

orD!! L2%8!W<M!�$!NNM!P12%+2!WeM!$&!.1D!:$801.&(2%!23!#09.%!<#Y!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!=,!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!.%5!6EFjZD!

,00#(".&?%..&6*".D!j[Z[UooaqVAqjnFpZD!52(AZ[DZ[pol(/=Dj[Z[DrpD!

oqD!! 7129!EM!C201+$%!7;M!N$%+$%!7WM!g.%+$%!PM!C201+$%!EiD!6EFpp!(%50/$+!6EFY!>*250/&(2%!(%!#09.%!;@nx!<!

/$11+!.%5!=.+2>#(1+D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZZUqamVA$jZqYrD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[jZqYrD!

omD!! �.%8!�M!@0!EM!40%!WM!i(G1+&*.!PM!�.%8!CD!6-eFu!(%#(=(&+!&#$!(%/*$.+$5!$d>*$++(2%!23!6EFY!50*(%8!$d>$*(9$%&.1!.0&2(990%$!0)$2*$&(%(&(+D!;#.&$%205!EM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZjUmaZ[VA$norqqD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[norqqD!

ooD!! g(15$=*.%5!-M!C.>$!gF;M!g2$)$1!CM!i*$&&$J!;M!).%!"*($%+)$%!WD!<#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!+,+&$9(/!/,&2J(%$+!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!.%5!5$#,5*2$>(.%5*2+&$*2%$!&*$.&9$%&!(%!.!*25$%&!925$1D!

M;"+BD!j[[pUj[anVAppoFnqD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml[ZD+#JD[[[[[oZn[oDrmYrjDjjD!

oYD!! Wf11$*!'M!4&$(%#233!'M!:$(+!E-M!$&!.1D!-0%/&(2%.1!*21$!23!&,>$!6!.%5!&,>$!66!(%&$*3$*2%+!(%!.%&()(*.1!5$3$%+$D!

M+*%(+%&1RGF&2D!ZYYnUjqnarZqmVAZYZoFjZD!!

!

! !

Page 186: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 173 of 237

XY-(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%(*48%(45(2):%(;(;?>=('<(9>?/&%$'#2%$(:=4*'#='54*&(8%='4<=(

!

I3#8(;<6'G'2'4<(45(9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-('<(;&'g3'&4$/

;<$3"%$(E=4*'#='54*&(=J'<('<58#&&#2'4<('<(&'"%((

E,%5.!"*(%$ZMjM!E($%!@$G.8$*ZMjM!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$ZMjM;1.05$!E(=$*&ZMj�!!Z,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6:&';%():&6%.8*#0&D3%4/5)0%()&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&';%()&<(*=%5$*)9:&';%():&6%.8*#0&

!�!;2**$+>2%5(%8!.0&#2*A!;1.05$!E(=$*&M!/1.05$D1(=$*&¨6*/DI(=F'8$%&D=$!!;2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&A!<#$!.0&#2*+!5$/1.*$!&#.&!%2!/2%31(/&!23!(%&$*$+&!$d(+&+D!!!/(#$+5*4)&$#L0*))%7&)"&\."$&^(%O!!F4<2*'G32'4<=A!E,%5.!"*(%$!>$*32*9$5!.11!$d>$*(9$%&.1!K2*J!.%5!K*2&$!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&D!E,%5.!"*(%$!5$+(8%$5!&#$!8*.>#!(%!40>>1$9$%&.1!-(80*$!ZU!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$!5*$K!&#$!8*.>#!0+(%8!4$*)($*!W$5(/.1!P*&D!@*D!:22+9.*(G%!HD!I.%5$%=*20/J$M!@*D!E($%!@$G.8$*!.%5!C*23D!@*D!;1.05$!E(=$*&!+0>$*)(+$5!&#$!5$+(8%!.%5!>$*32*9.%/$+!23!&#$!$d>$*(9$%&+D!!

!

!!!

! (

Page 187: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 174 of 237

!"#$%&'()*)+),'%,-%./012%#'3%&0/41!"#$"

!"#$%#"&'F!"#$%&#'()*+,-),.*+/'01,"'!"#$%&&%'()"*("*+(,-!

!G=2*#"2(

!"#$%&"%"' %"' &' ()$#*%(' %*+,&--&.#$/' "0%*' 1%"2&"2' &++2(.%*3' 4F!" #$%&$'(" )*" (+$" ,)%-."

!"!#$%&'"()%(*)'+),%'($-)./%0%.&10'21*)3-)1!'*10,%$)/-!10!$%+'%4)+.%$'(5)%(*)10-&/1,%6)7)

!"#$%&'&() "#*') +#") ,-.) %&) (/') !0(/#1'&'2%2) #+) !2#"%02%2) /02) 3''&) 2/#4&) 0&5)

!"#$%&'%!"#$% &'()*+,% "$-.,% */% 012% '!"'3*!),",% ,+45% ',% ."'!.(4.-"% '!6% )!/#)7)8'9% 5'&.%

!""#$%&"'$ &%(("&&)%**+,$-"("#.*+/$ 0#$ 1#(2"0&1#3$045%#.$5)$'0.0$ &%33"&.&$ .60.$ .+7"$ 8$ 89:&$

!"#$ !%&'$ (")(*!%$+#,*!-'"&$ '.$ /&'"*!&*&0$ 1'$ *23#&-*4!-#$56#-6#"$ 7%'(8*24$ -6#*"$ "#&/#(-*3#$

!"#"$%&!'( )&*+,( -"( *'".*+/( 01234F! !"#$ %&'()*F!"#$%$"&'( )$%"( *"+"( %,-.."&/"!( *$',(

!"#$%$&'()*+)'+,-.$*-/'!"!#$!"%&'()*+,-!!"#$%&$'&(#$!&!!"#$%&$'()$"*!+#),-$+#*,#!"#$%&!

!"#$%&"%"F!"#$% &#"'% !$&"('&! !"# $!%&'# ()*+# *,-"./&"!%# $!%&# .+)0&1# 2-,*!-3# 2,)*&%*!)"#

!"#$!"#$!"#$%$F!"#$%&#' !"()*++*,!-"' %-+.*/&#' ,-' %-",/-)' 0/-$.12' 3##!,!-"*))45' 6789:'

!"#$!#%&' ()$*' +,#-*.' +%+&/)"*.' &01*' 2' 234' 15#.%$&)#"' )"' 5*+1#"+*' &#' !"#$%$!" #$%&'("

!"#$!#%&' ()$*' +,$!)"-' .#&/' 0*$*1&#02' 2/#3*4' 2%1*0)#0' 10#&*$&)#"' &#' !"#$%$! !"#

!"#$%&'(")*+',-* !"#$%&'()#$*'+,*+-!$.&,#$/'0$0&%1)/2#0$3#0-,#0$ )#4#)%$+5$ 67F!"#$%&' ()F

!"#$%&'$(!))*+,$-&'-.%/-&0$/1%/$/12$3!"#$%&#'()*#+#+"!#)$',-$(#./%'0123'*#415%161.$%'7(#

!"# $%&'())(!$"%!!"#$% &'()&*($&%+,&-%!"#$%$!" #$%" &'()'(*+" %,-,./" 01.0" )$./" '(1'2'0'3("3&"

!"#$%&'()&!"#$%&'()*'+,-+,.,/0')'!"#$%#&'()!"#$%&'()*($+,-&()$*(.$!(&"/&0'"),*','1!

! !

(!( (

Page 188: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 175 of 237

;<2*4$3"2'4<(

C+2*(.+(+! (+! .! /#*2%(/! (%31.99.&2*,! +J(%! 5(+$.+$! .33$/&(%8! j!p\!23! &#$!K2*15! >2>01.&(2%DZMj!

@$+>(&$!$d&$%+()$!+&05($+M!5$&.(1+!23!&#$!5(+$.+$!9$/#.%(+9!*$9.(%!&2!=$!$10/(5.&$5D!6%(&(.11,M!

>+2*(.+(+!K.+!5$+/*(=$5!.+!.!5(+$.+$!(%)21)(%8!$d/$++()$!>*21(3$*.&(2%!23!J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!K#(/#!

&#$%!&*(88$*!(%31.99.&(2%D!<25.,M!(&!(+!J%2K%!&#.&!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9!(+!(%)21)$5!.&!901&(>1$!

+&.8$+! 23! &#$! 5(+$.+$D! 6%(&(.&(%8! $)$%&+M! %O8O! K20%5+! 2*! (%3$/&(2%+M! /.0+$! J$*.&(%2/,&$+! &2!

*$1$.+$! +&*$++! +(8%.1+M!K#(/#!.*$!>(/J$5!0>!=,! *$+(5$%&! (990%$!/$11+! +0/#!.+!5$%5*(&(/! /$11+!

a@;+VD! 40=+$?0$%&1,M! 6%&$*1$0J(%! a6EVFZj! .%5! 6EFjp! .*$! *$1$.+$5! .%5! &*(88$*! <! /$11+! &2!

5(33$*$%&(.&$! (%&2! <#Z! .%5! <#Zm! /$11+! >*250/(%8! /,&2J(%$+! +0/#! .+! <092*! e$/*2+(+! -./&2*!

a<e-VM! 6%&$*3$*2%! y! a6-eFyV! .%5! 6EFZmM!K#(/#! +&.*&! .! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,! /.+/.5$Dpwm! <#(+!K(11!

*$/*0(&! .%5! ./&().&$! 92*$! (990%$! /$11+! .%5! .&! &#$! +.9$! &(9$! ./&! 2%! &#$! J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!

(%/*$.+(%8!+&*$++!*$+>2%+$+!.%5!/.0+(%8!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%!23!&#$!$>(5$*9.1!1.,$*D!(

<#$!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!<e-!.*$!=$1($)$5!&2!9$5(.&$!).*(20+!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!.+!

(%/*$.+$5!.920%&+!23!<e-!.*$!>*250/$5!(%!+$)$*.1!23!&#$+$!5(+$.+$+M!(%5(/.&(%8!.%!(9>2*&.%&!

*21$!32*!&#(+!/,&2J(%$D!4$)$*.1!%$0&*.1(R(%8!.%&(F<e-!.8$%&+M!+0/#!.+!$&.%$*/$>&!.%5!(%31(d(9.=M!

#.)$! =$$%! +0//$++3011,! .>>1($5! (%! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+M! (%/105(%8! (%31.99.&2*,! =2K$1!

5(+$.+$M! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+! .%5! >+2*(.+(+Do! 6%5$$5M! &#$! .9$1(2*.&(2%! ./#($)$5! K(&#! <e-!

.%&.82%(+&+! /2%3(*9+! &#.&! <e-! (+! .! >()2&.1! >*2F(%31.99.&2*,!9$5(.&2*! (%! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+D!

<*$.&9$%&!K(&#!$&.%$*/$>&!*.>(51,!*$50/$+!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!(990%$!/$11!(%310d!a@;+M!<!/$11+!

.%5!9./*2>#.8$+V!(%!1$+(2%!+J(%!.%5!(9>.(*+!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjj!=,!<#Zm!/$11+DY!

g2K$)$*M!<e-! (%#(=(&2*+!.*$!.1+2!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! +(5$!$33$/&+M! +0/#!.+! *$./&().&(2%!23! 1.&$%&!

&0=$*/012+(+M! #$>.&2+>1$%(/! <F/$11! 1,9>#29.M! 1()$*! &2d(/(&,! .%5! (%/*$.+$5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! &2!

2>>2*&0%(+&(/!(%3$/&(2%+M!+0/#!.+!S*$)%5*/!.%5!S%8*"(%../&(%3$/&(2%+DZ[MZZ!<e-!+(8%.1(%8!(+!/1$.*1,!

/*0/(.1!32*!&#$!3011!30%/&(2%.1(&,!23!&#$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!P+!<e-!+(8%.1+!&#*208#!&K2!*$/$>&2*+M!

<e-:Z!a>rrV!.%5!<e-:j!a>mrVM!.%5!(&!(+!.++09$5!&#.&!92+&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!<e-!

Page 189: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 176 of 237

.*$!9$5(.&$5!9.(%1,! =,! <e-:ZMZj! 20*! /2%/$>&! (+! &2! +>$/(3(/.11,! =12/J! &#(+! *$/$>&2*M! 1$.)(%8!

<e-!+(8%.1(%8!&#*208#!<e-:j!(%&./&D!!

P%2&#$*!(9>2*&.%&!3.9(1,!23!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!&#$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+!a6-e+V!&#.&!.*$!9.(%1,!J%2K%!

32*!&#$(*!.%&()(*.1!./&(2%+D!g2K$)$*M!(%!.55(&(2%M!&#$!>1$(2&*2>(/!&,>$!6!6-e+!>1.,!.!/*0/(.1!*21$!

(%!2&#$*!(%%.&$!.%5!.5.>&()$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$+D!<#(+!3.9(1,!/2%+(+&+!23!5(33$*$%&!.1>#.!8$%$+!

a,-(/VM!Zp!(%!#09.%+!.%5!Zn!(%!9(/$M!.%5!2%$!=$&.!(%&$*3$*2%!8$%$!a,-(LVM!=2&#!23!K#(/#!+(8%.1!

&#*208#!&#$!#$&$*25(9$*(/!*$/$>&2*!/29>1$dM!/2%+(+&(%8!23!6-eP:Z!.%5!6-eP:jD!<,>$!6!6-e+!

#.)$! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! .0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+! =$/.0+$! &,>$! 6! 6-eF(%50/(=1$! 8$%$+! .*$!

0>*$801.&$5!(%!+29$!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!5(+>1.,(%8!.!+2F/.11$5!`6-e!+(8%.&0*$_DZpwZr!<#(+!(+!

.%! 0>*$801.&(2%! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-eF(%50/(=1$! 8$%$+! 2*! 8$%$+! /2%&.(%(%8! 6%&$*3$*2%F+$%+(&()$!

*$+>2%+$!$1$9$%&+!a64:HV!320%5!(%!&(++0$+!+0/#!.+!+J(%!1$+(2%+!(%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!&#$!(%31.9$5!

G2(%&+! 23! *#$09.&2(5! .*&#*(&(+! >.&($%&+DZqwZY! 4(9(1.*1,M! &*$.&9$%&! 23! >.&($%&+! .33$/&$5! =,!

#$>.&(&(+!;!2*!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!K(&#!6-ev!2*!6-euM!*$+>$/&()$1,M!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!(%50/&(2%!

2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+M!(%5(/.&(%8!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!/.%!=$!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!

>+2*(.+(+Dj[wjj! C.*.52d(/.11,M! <e-F=12/J(%8! .8$%&+! /.%! .1+2! (%50/$! /0&.%$20+! >+2*(.+(+F1(J$!

1$+(2%+! (%! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! 32*! 2&#$*! .0&2(990%$! 5(+2*5$*+D! <#(+! +(5$! $33$/&!9.,! =$! 50$! &2!

(%/*$.+$5!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%!=,!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!a>@;+V!32112K(%8!*$50/&(2%!23!

<e-! 1$)$1+M! =$/.0+$! <e-! +&(901.&$+! >@;! 9.&0*.&(2%! .%5! +0=+$?0$%&1,! 6-ev! *$1$.+$Djpwjq!

P15.*.M! K#(/#! /2%&.(%+! (9(?0(925! a6WsVM! .! <E:mlo! .82%(+&M! #.+! =$$%! (%/*$.+(%81,! 0+$5! .+!

$d>$*(9$%&.1! 925$1! (%! 9(/$! .+! (&! (%50/$+! >+2*(.+(32*9! 1$+(2%+! &#.&! *$+$9=1$! #09.%!

>+2*(.+(+Dq!

6%! &#(+! +&05,M! K$! +#2K! &#.&! 9(/$! 1./J(%8! <e-:Z! 2*! 6-eP:Z! .*$! 925$+&1,! >*2&$/&$5! 3*29!

P15.*.F(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D! @20=1$! J%2/J20&! 9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! =2&#!

*$/$>&2*+! .*$! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! =$&&$*! >*2&$/&$5! 3*29! >+2*(.+(+! 1$+(2%+! (%50/$5! =,! P15.*.D! L$!

+#2K!&#.&!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!9$5(.&$+!.!%$8.&()$!3$$5=./J!2%!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!0>2%!<E:m!

./&().&(2%M! .%5! &#.&! 6-eP:Z! (%50/$+! +,+&$9(/! 6EFZj>n[! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! P15.*.D!L$! >*2>2+$!

Page 190: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 177 of 237

50.1! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! .+! .! %2)$1! &#$*.>$0&(/! +&*.&$8,! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! 23!

>+2*(.+(+D!(

7%=382=(

9>?7-(='Q<#8'<Q(:#*2'#88)(&%$'#2%=(;@d/'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<(

'<58#&&#2'4<(

6%!j[[YM!I.%!5$*!-(&+!$&!.1D!>*2>2+$5!&#$!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!&#$!<E:mlo!.82%(+&!6Ws!(%!&#$!

32*9!23!P15.*.!/*$.9!.+!.!925$1!32*!>+2*(.+(+Dq!<2!(%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!*21$!23!<e-:Z!(%!&#$!<e-F

9$5(.&$5!5(+$.+$M!K$!&*$.&$5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!5.(1,!K(&#!P15.*.M!#$*$.3&$*!&$*9$5!6WsM!2%!&#$!

=./J! 32*! 320*! /2%+$/0&()$!5.,+! .%5! 122J$5! .&! &#$! J(%$&(/+! 23!<e-! .%5!<e-:Z! (%! +$*09!.%5!

K#21$!+J(%!1,+.&$+D!'>2%!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!6WsM!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-!K$*$!(%50/$5!2%!5.,!&K2!.%5!

320*M! *$+>$/&()$1,! a-(80*$! ZPVD! L$! &#$%! ?0$+&(2%$5! K#$&#$*! (%#(=(&(%8! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (+!

+033(/($%&! &2! .9$1(2*.&$! &#$!P15.*.F(%50/$5! +,9>&29+D!<#$*$32*$M!K$! &*$.&$5!K(15! &,>$! .%5!

<e-:Z!J%2/J20&!aiQV!9(/$!32*!+$)$%!/2%+$/0&()$!5.,+!K(&#!6WsD!:$5%$++!.%5!+/.1(%8!K$*$!

+/2*$5!5.(1,!.+!5$+/*(=$5!>*$)(20+1,Dq!6%(&(.11,M!.11!9(/$!+/2*$5!R$*2!2%!$*,&#$9.M!+/.1(%8!.%5!

&#(/J$%(%8D! @0*(%8! 6Ws! &*$.&9$%&M!K(15! &,>$!9(/$! +#2K$5! (%/*$.+$5! $*,&#$9.M! +/.1(%8! .%5!

$>(5$*9.1! &#(/J$%(%8! a-(80*$! Z7VD! <e-:ZF5$3(/($%&! 9(/$! K$*$! 925$*.&$1,! >*2&$/&$5! 3*29!

=2&#!+/.1(%8!.%5!$*,&#$9.!50*(%8!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&D!<#$*$!K.+!%2!5(33$*$%/$!(%!&#$!6WsF(%50/$5!

$>(5$*9.1! #,>$*>1.+(.M! +088$+&(%8! &#.&! <e-:Z! (+! %2&! (%)21)$5! (%! &#$! #,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%! 23!

J$*.&(%2/,&$+!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1!a-(80*$!Z;!.%5!Z@VD!C.*.J$*.&2+(+M!&#$!*$&$%&(2%!23!%0/1$(!(%!

&#$!/2*%$.1!1.,$*M!K.+!%2&!=12/J$5!=,!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!a5.&.!%2&!+#2K%VD!6Ws!#.+!=$$%!

*$>2*&$5!&2!/.0+$!+>1$%29$8.1,Mjm!K#(/#!K$!.1+2!2=+$*)$5!(%!&#$!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!a-(80*$!ZHVD!

6%! /2%&*.+&M! <e-:Z!iQ!9(/$! +#2K$5! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 1$++! +>1$%29$8.1,! a-(80*$! ZHVD! <2! .++$++!

&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1! 5(33$*$%/$+! =$&K$$%! K(15! &,>$! .%5! <e-:ZF5$3(/($%&! +J(%M! 9.*J$*+! &#.&! .*$!

8$%$*.11,!0>*$801.&$5!(%!>+2*(.+(+!K$*$!9$.+0*$5!=,!?:<FC;:D!Q%!5.,!q!23!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&M!!

Page 191: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 178 of 237

!?'Q3*%(-D(9>?7-(OZ(&'"%(#*%(:#*2'#88)(:*42%"2%$(#Q#'<=2(;@d/'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='=/8'J%(=J'<(8%='4<=((

L(15! &,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$! &*$.&$5!K(&#!P15.*.! 32*!.!9.d(909!23! +$)$%!5.,+!.%5! a#V!>*2&$(%!1$)$1+!23!<e-!(%!+$*09!a1$3&V!.%5!<e-:Z!(%!+J(%!a*(8#&V!K$*$!9$.+0*$5!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!

9$.%!¢!4@!a%!�!nVD!aGV!H*,&#$9.!.%5!+/.1(%8!K$*$!+/2*$5!2%!5.,+!n!.%5!mD!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!+/2*$+!a[!nV!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!qFoVD!a"V!H>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.!(%!+J(%!+$/&(2%+!23!6WsF&*$.&$5!9(/$!&.J$%!2%!5.,+![M!n!.%5!mM!?0.%&(3($5!K(&#!I212/(&,!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nFrVD!a$V!:$>*$+$%&.&()$!gBH!+J(%!+$/&(2%+!2%!5.,!mD!4/.1$!=.*!�!Z[[!¡9D!a%V!4>1$%29$8.1,!m!5.,+!.3&$*!5.(1,!/2%&*21!/*$.9!2*!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&!23!9(/$U!/.1/01.&$5!.+!&#$!*.&(2!23!+>1$$%!K$(8#&!&2!&2&.1!=25,!K$(8#&D!a5V!?:<FC;:!.%.1,+(+!23!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!23!?(-(M!,=.M!S"5M!]5)aL!.%5!4ZGG/R!(%!K#21$!+J(%!1,+.&$+!a5.,+![!.%5!qVD!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!&*.%+/*(>&!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!71./JA!K(15!&,>$!9(/$U!1(8#&!8*$,A!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$D!

!

!$d>*$++(2%! 23! ).*(20+! 8$%$+! K.+! (%/*$.+$5! (%! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$! a-(80*$! Z-VD! :$9.*J.=1,M!

9.*J$*+!+0/#!.+!/2*%(3$1(%!a?(-(V!.%5!(%)210/*(%!a,=.V!K$*$!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!+&*2%8$*! (%50/$5!(%!

<e-:Z!iQ!+J(%M!K#(1$!2&#$*+M!J$*.&(%q=!a]5)aLVM!.%5!4Z[[Po!aMZGG/RV!K$*$! 1$++! (%50/$5!(%!

&#$!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$D!<#$!(%50/&(2%!23!12*(/*(%!aS"5V!$d>*$++(2%!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!K.+!

#(8#$*!&#.%!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!

13=2#'<%$(9):%(;(;?>(='Q<#8'<Q('<(9>?7-(OZ(&'"%(

6Ws!(%50/$+!1.*8$!.920%&+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!=,!+&(901.&(%8!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!a>@;+VM!

.%5!&#$+$!/,&2J(%$+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+DZm!L$!K2%5$*$5!(3!<e-:Z!(+!92501.&(%8!&#(+!>*2/$++!(%!

&#$!P15.*.!925$1D!L$!&*$.&$5!K(15!&,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K(&#!6Ws!.%5!(+21.&$5!+J(%!.%5!

!"#$%&!''''!"#$%()'

!' "'

0

5

10

15

20

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

vl

****

*

****

0 6

#'

0

1

2

3

4

Erythema Scaling

**

***TNFR1 WTTNFR1 KO

Day 4

Sco

re

0

1

2

3

4

Erythema Scaling

*

Day 7

Sco

re

$'Serum

0 2 40

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

Time after IMQ (days)

[TN

F] (p

g/m

l)

*

%'Skin

0 2 40

2000

4000

6000

8000

Time after IMQ (days)

[TN

FR1]

(pg/

mg

tota

l pro

tein

)

**

0

25

50

75

100

Time after IMQ (days)

Epi

derm

al th

ickn

ess

(µm

)

***

0 4 7

1

10

100

1000

10000

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

S10

0a8

****

0 6

****

!"#$%&'!&

&'

0

20

40

60

80

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

nfn

*

**

***

0 6

0

50

100

150

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of L

or

0 6

**0.0618

*

Control IMQ Control IMQ0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Day 7

Rat

io w

eigh

t spl

een

to b

ody

(x 1

0-3) ***

*ns

1

10

100

1000

10000

100000

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of K

rt6b

0 6

0.1103*

*

ns

Page 192: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 179 of 237

+$*09!$.*1,!.3&$*!&#$!3(*+&!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&!.%5!$)$*,!2&#$*!5.,!50*(%8!&#$!32112K(%8!&*$.&9$%&!

5.,+D!P3&$*!*$>$.&$5!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!6WsM!1$)$1+!23!6-ev!(%!&#$!+J(%!+#2K$5!.!&$%5$%/,!&2!=$!

5$/*$.+$5!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$M!=0&!&#(+!5(33$*$%/$!5(5!%2&!*$./#!+&.&(+&(/.1!+(8%(3(/.%/$!a-(80*$!

jPVD!<#(+!(+!(%!1(%$!K(&#!&#$!2=+$*).&(2%+!23!L.1&$*+!$&!.1D!.%5!(+!>*$+09.=1,!50$!&2!$d#.0+&(2%!

23!9,$12(5!>*$/0*+2*!/$11+!.%5!*$50/$5!>@;!%09=$*+Djo!<2!9$.+0*$!&#$!>2&$%&(.1!(%50/&(2%!23!

6-evM!K$!9$.+0*$5!(&+! 1$)$1+! (%!+$*09!.&!5(33$*$%&!&(9$!>2(%&+!=.+$5!2%!&#$!2=+$*).&(2%+!23!

L.1&$*+!$&! .1DM!K#2! *$>2*&$5! &#.&! 6-ev!K.+! (%50/$5! &#*$$!#20*+!.3&$*!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!P15.*.D!

6%5$$5M!=2&#!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!K$*$!(%50/$5!(%!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!p!#20*+!.3&$*!6Ws!.>>1(/.&(2%M!=0&!

5$/*$.+$5!*.>(51,!a-(80*$!j7VD!P%.1,+(+!23!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!(%!+J(%!1,+.&$+!*$)$.1$5!&*.%+($%&!

0>*$801.&(2%!23! 64:HF8$%$+!+0/#!.+!?_+.ZGM! ,-*)D!.%5!<$4ZRM!K#(/#!*$31$/&! 6-evlu!./&()(&,M!.+!

$.*1,!.+! &K2!#20*+!.3&$*! &2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23! 6Ws!a-(80*$!j;VD! 6%!/2%&*.+&M!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!

5(5!%2&!5(+>1.,!&#(+!&*.%+($%&!$d>*$++(2%!23!=2&#!&,>$!6!6-e!1(8.%5+!.%5!64:H!8$%$+A!6-ev!.%5!

6-eu!$d>*$++(2%!*$9.(%$5!+&*2%8!(%!&#$!+$*.!nMr!#20*+!.3&$*!6Ws!.>>1(/.&(2%!.%5!(%!&#$!+J(%!n!

5.,+! 1.&$*! a-(80*$! jP! .%5! 7VD! E(J$K(+$M! .=*28.&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! 1$.5+! &2! +0+&.(%$5!

&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!$d>*$++(2%!23!?_+.ZGM!,-*)D!.%5!<$4ZR!+(d!#20*+!.3&$*!6Ws!/#.11$%8$!a-(80*$!j;VD!

<#$+$! 5.&.! /1$.*1,! (%5(/.&$! &#.&! <e-:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (+! (%)21)$5! (%! +(1$%/(%8! &#$! &,>$! 6! 6-e!

*$+>2%+$!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1D!

9):%(;(;?>=(#<$(;?>!7-("4<2*'G32%(24(%:'$%*&#8(26'"J%<'<Q($3*'<Q(;@d/'<$3"%$(

:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<('<58#&&#2'4<(

<2!30*&#$*! (%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6! 6-e!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1M!K$!$d.9(%$5!&#$!

*$+>2%+$! &2! 6Ws! (%!9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! &#$! *$/$>&2*! Z! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! a6-eP:Z! iQ!9(/$VD!L$!

&*$.&$5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!.%5!6-eP:!ZiQ!9(/$!32*!+$)$%!/2%+$/0&()$!5.,+!K(&#!6Ws!.%5!+/2*$5!

&#$!*$+>2%+$+!.+!5$+/*(=$5!.=2)$D!7$32*$!.%,!6Ws!K.+!.>>1($5M!.11!9(/$!+/2*$5!R$*2!32*!$./#!

>.*.9$&$*D!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!$d#(=(&$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!1$++!$*,&#$9.!2%!5.,!320*!=0&!&#(+!!

Page 193: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 180 of 237

!?'Q3*%(+D(I%5'"'%<2(9>?7-(='Q<#8'<Q(8%#$=(24('<"*%#=%$(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(;17B/='Q<#23*%(

L(15!&,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!32*!n!/2%+$/0&()$!5.,+!.%5!+J(%!.%5!=1225!K$*$!(+21.&$5!.&! &#$! (%5(/.&$5!&(9$!>2(%&+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!a#V!i(%$&(/+!23! 6-ev!>*2&$(%! 1$)$1+! (%!K#21$!+J(%! 1,+.&$+! 2)$*! 320*! 5.,+D! aGV! i(%$&(/+! 23! 6-ev! a1$3&V! .%5! 6-eu! a*(8#&V! >*2&$(%! 1$)$1+! (%! +$*09D! a"V!s0.%&(&.&()$! ?:<FC;:! .%.1,+(+! 23! &,>(/.1! 64:H! 8$%$+! a?_+.ZG:& ,-*)D! .%5!<$4ZRV! (%!K#21$! +J(%! 1,+.&$+D!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!*$1.&()$!&*.%+/*(>&!1$)$1+!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!nVD!71./JA!K(15!&,>$!9(/$U!1(8#&!8*$,A!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$D!

!

!>*2&$/&(2%!K.+! 12+&!2%!5.,!+$)$%D!72&#!920+$!+&*.(%+!#.5!+(9(1.*!+/.1(%8!.&!$./#!&(9$!>2(%&!

a-(80*$!pPVD!P%.1,+(+!23!gBHF+&.(%$5!+$/&(2%+!3*29!.33$/&$5!=./J!+J(%!+#2K$5!&#.&!$>(5$*9.1!

#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%!2%!5.,!m!K.+!9.*J$51,!1$++!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!/29>.*$5!&2!L<!9(/$M!.+!

5$>(/&$5!(%!-(80*$!p7!a?0.%&(3(/.&(2%V!.%5!-(80*$!p;!a*$>*$+$%&.&()$!gBH!(9.8$+VD!

4(9(1.*1,!&2!&#$!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$M!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!5$)$12>$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!1$++!+>1$%29$8.1,!

(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!6-eP:Z!L<!.3&$*!6Ws!a-(80*$!p@VD!P55(&(2%.11,M! 6-eP:Z!.=*28.&(2%! 1$5!&2!

*$50/$5!$d>*$++(2%!23!/2*%(3$1(%!a?(-(VM!(%)210/*(%!a,=.VM!12*(/*(%!aS"5V!.%5!J$*.&(%q=!a]%5aLVM!

=0&!(&!5(5!%2&!.33$/&!&#$!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!23!4Z[[Po!aMZGG/RV!a-(80*$!pHVD!!

6&!#.+!=$$%!*$>2*&$5!&#.&!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!6-ev!2*!6-eu!/.%!.33$/&!<e-:Z!.%5!<e-:j!1$)$1+DjYMp[!

<2!&$+&!K#$&#$*!6-eP:Z!(+!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!0>*$801.&(2%!23!<e-:Z!2=+$*)$5!(%!-(80*$!ZPM!K$!

9$.+0*$5!<e-:Z!>*2&$(%!1$)$1+!(%!K(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:ZF5$3(/($%&!+J(%!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6WsD!P+!

+#2K%!(%!-(80*$!p-M!&#$!(%/*$.+$!(%!<e-:Z!>*2&$(%!1$)$1!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!6Ws!K.+!/29>.*.=1$!

(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!.%5!K(15!&,>$!9(/$D!!

0 2 6 0 2 60

30

60

90

120

Time after IMQ (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl1

0

*

*

ns

0,0571

0 2 6 0 2 60

10

20

30

*

0,0571

* *

*

Time after IMQ (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

fit2

0 2 6 0 2 60

10

20

30

*

**

* *

Time after IMQ (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18 *

!!

"!

0 3 4,5 0 3 4,51

10

100

1000

10000

Time after IMQ (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

Serum

**** ***ns

**

0 3 4,5 0 3 4,51

10

100

1000

10000

Time after IMQ (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

Serum

**** **

*

*

0 2 4 0 2 41

10

100

1000

10000

100000

Time after IMQ (days)

[IFN!

] (pg

/mg)

Skin

****ns

TNFR1 WTTNFR1 KO

#!

Page 194: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 181 of 237

!?'Q3*%(XD( ;?>!7-(OZ(&'"%(#*%(:*42%"2%$(#Q#'<=2( ;@d/'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<( '<58#&&#2'4<(

"4&:#*%$(24(K'8$(2):%(&'"%(

a#V!L(15!&,>$!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!32*!.!9.d(909!23!+$)$%!5.,+!.%5!+/2*$5!32*!

$*,&#$9.!.%5!+/.1(%8!2%!5.,+!n!.%5!mD!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!+/2*$+!a[!nV!a9$.%!¢!4@U!%!�!qVD!aGV!H>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.! 3*29! +J(%! +$/&(2%+! 2%! 5.,+! [M! n! .%5! mM! ?0.%&(3($5! K(&#! I212/(&,! a9$.%! ¢! 4@U! %! �! qVD! a"V!:$>*$+$%&.&()$!+J(%!+$/&(2%+!2%!5.,!m!+&.(%$5!K(&#!gBHD!4/.1$!=.*!�!Z[[!¡9D!a$V!4>1$%29$8.1,!.3&$*!m!5.,+!K(&#!/2%&*21!/*$.9!2*!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&U!/.1/01.&$5!.+!&#$!*.&(2!23!+>1$$%!K$(8#&!&2!&2&.1!=25,!K$(8#&D!a%V!?:<FC;:!.%.1,+(+!23!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!23!?(-(M!,=.M!S"5M!]5)aL!.%5!MZGG/R!(%!K#21$!+J(%!1,+.&$+!a5.,+![!.%5! qVD! 7.*+! *$>*$+$%&! *$1.&()$! &*.%+/*(>&! 1$)$1+! a9$.%! ¢! 4@U! %! �! nVD! a5V! <e-:Z! /2%/$%&*.&(2%! K.+!9$.+0*$5!(%!K#21$!+J(%!1,+.&$+!3*29!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!K(&#!HE64P!a%!�!rVD!71./JA!K(15!&,>$!9(/$U!5.*J!8*$,A!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$D!

!

!!!

P1&28$&#$*M! &#$+$! *$+01&+! +088$+&! &#.&! 5$1$&(2%! 23! $(&#$*! <e-:Z! 2*! 6-eP:Z! /.%! .9$1(2*.&$!

6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%! 1$+(2%+D!W2*$2)$*M!20*!5.&.! (%5(/.&$!&#.&!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!

(%)21)$5! $.*1,! (%! &#$! P15.*.! 925$1M! (%! .55(&(2%! &2! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! K#(/#! #.)$! .1*$.5,! =$$%!

5$+/*(=$5!.+!&#$!(%(&(.&(%8!/,&2J(%$+!23!>+2*(.+(+DZm!!

!"#$%&'()))!"#$%&*+)

!) ") #)

$)

0

20

40

60

80

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

nfn

*

********

0 60

50

100

150

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of L

or 0.0701 *

0 60

5

10

15

20

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of I

vl

0 6

*

0

1

2

3

4

Erythema ScalingDay 7

Sco

re

0

1

2

3

4

Erythema Scaling

IFNAR1 WT IFNAR1 KO

***

Day 4

Sco

re

Skin

0 0 2 20

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

Time after IMQ (days)

[TN

FR1]

(pg/

mg)

**

*** ns

1

10

100

1000

10000

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

S10

0a8

***

0 6

0.0744

0.0501

%)

!"#$%&'()' !"#$%&'()'

&)

1

10

100

1000

10000

Time after IMQ (days)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of K

rt6b 0.0588 0.0599

0 6

ns

0

25

50

75

100

Time after IMQ (days)

Epi

derm

al th

ickn

ess

(µm

)

*******

0 4 7

*

Control IMQ Control IMQ0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Day 7

Rat

io w

eigh

t spl

een

to b

ody

(x 1

0-3)

****ns

Page 195: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 182 of 237

I%5'"'%<")('<(G426(9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-(8%#$=(24(=3:%*'4*(:*42%"2'4<(#Q#'<=2(;@d/

'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<('<58#&&#2'4<(

e$d&M! K$! K2%5$*$5! K#$&#$*! .=*28.&(2%! 23! =2&#! *$/$>&2*+! +(901&.%$20+1,! /2015! $%#.%/$!

>*2&$/&(2%D!<#$*$32*$M!K$!/*2++$5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!K(&#!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!&2!8$%$*.&$!520=1$!

J%2/J20&! a@iQV!9(/$!5$3(/($%&! 32*!=2&#! *$/$>&2*+D!<#$! +.9$!>.*.9$&$*+!K$*$!9$.+0*$5! &2!

.++$++! &#$! *$+>2%+$! 23! &#$! @iQ! 9(/$! &2! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D! 6%!

/29>.*(+2%! &2! &#$! +(%81$!J%2/J20&!.%5!K(15! &,>$!9(/$M!@iQ!9(/$!#.5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,! *$50/$5!

$*,&#$9.! .%5! +/.1(%8! 2%! 5.,! 320*! .%5! %2! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! =,! 5.,! +$)$%! a-(80*$! nPVD!

P=*28.&(2%! 23! =2&#! *$/$>&2*+! 5(5! %2&! *$+01&! (%! 1$++! +>1$%29$8.1,! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! +(%81$!

J%2/J20&+! a-(80*$! n7VD! @iQ! 9(/$! .1+2! 5(+>1.,$5! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 1$++! 6WsF(%50/$5! $>(5$*9.1!

&#(/J$%(%8! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! +(%81$! J%2/J20&+! .%5! K(15! &,>$! 9(/$! 2%! 5.,! mM! =0&! %2&! (%!

/29>.*(+2%! &2! /2%&*21! /*$.9! a-(80*$! n;! .%5! n@VD! Q)$*.11M! @iQ!9(/$! 5(+>1.,$5! *$50/$5! 2*!

(%&$*9$5(.&$!3215! (%50/&(2%!23!+$)$*.1!9.*J$*+! (%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!

9(/$! a40>>1$9$%&.*,! <.=1$! ZVD! P1&28$&#$*M! 20*! 5.&.! +088$+&! &#.&! +(901&.%$20+! 5$1$&(2%! 23!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!1$.5+!&2!=$&&$*!/2%&*21!23!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!

9>?7-(#<$(;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q(#<$(26%(;C/+XW;C/-\(#H'=('<(;@d/'<$3"%$(

:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<('<58#&&#2'4<(

I.%!5$*!-(&+!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!&#$!(9>2*&.%/$!23!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!(%!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F

1(J$! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! 0+(%8!9(/$! 5$3(/($%&! (%! $(&#$*! 6EFjp>ZY! 2*! 6EFZm:PDq! <2! .++$++! &#$! *21$! 23!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+M!+$*09!K.+!(+21.&$5!.&!5(33$*$%&!&(9$!>2(%&+!50*(%8!

6Ws!.>>1(/.&(2%D!6Ws!(%50/$5!6EFZj>n[!$d>*$++(2%!(%!+$*09!23!K(15!&,>$!9(/$!K(&#!.!>$.J!no!

#20*+! .3&$*! .>>1(/.&(2%! a-(80*$! rPVD! 6EFZj>n[! (+! .! +0=0%(&! (%! =2&#! 6EFZj! .%5! 6EFjp! .%5! (+! .!

%2)$1! 5*08! &.*8$&! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! 23! >+2*(.+(+DpZwpp! <#$! (%50/&(2%! K.+! .1+2! 2=+$*)$5! (%!

+$*09! 23! <e-:Z! iQ! 9(/$! a-(80*$! rPVM! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! &#$! (%50/&(2%! 23! 6EFZj>n[! 52$+! %2&!

*$?0(*$!<e-:Z!./&().&(2%D!g2K$)$*M!&#$!(%/*$.+$!23!6EFZj>n[!K.+!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!1$++!>*2%20%F!

Page 196: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 183 of 237

!

?'Q3*%( .D( I43G8%( Q%<%2'"( $%5'"'%<")( 45( 9>?7-( #<$( ;?>!7-( %<6#<"%=( :*42%"2'4<( #Q#'<=2( ;@d/

'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='=/8'J%(=J'<(8%='4<=(

@20=1$!J%2/J20&!a@iQV!9(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!32*!.!9.d(909!23!+$)$%!5.,+!.%5!/29>.*$5!&2!<e-:Z!iQM! 6-eP:Z!iQ!.%5!K(15! &,>$!9(/$D! a#V!H*,&#$9.!.%5!+/.1(%8!K$*$! +/2*$5!2%!5.,+!n!.%5!mD!7.*+! *$>*$+$%&! +/2*$+! a[FnV! a9$.%! ¢! 4@U! %! �! oFqFqFoV! aGV! 4>1$%29$8.1,! .3&$*! m! 5.,+! K(&#! /2%&*21!/*$.9! 2*! 6Ws! &*$.&9$%&U! /.1/01.&$5! .+! &#$! *.&(2! 23! +>1$$%! K$(8#&! &2! &2&.1! =25,! K$(8#&D! a"! .%5! $V!H>(5$*9.1! #,>$*>1.+(.!K.+! 5$&$*9(%$5! (%! gBH! +J(%! +$/&(2%+D! C(/&0*$+!K$*$! .%.1,R$5!K(&#! I212/(&,!.%5!$>(5$*9(+!K.+!?0.%&(3($5!a%!�!oFqFqFoVD!4/.1$!=.*!*$>*$+$%&+!Z[[!¡9D!:$>*$+$%&.&()$!>(/&0*$+!.*$!5(+>1.,$5D!@.*J!8*$,A!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$U!1(8#&!8*$,A!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$U!K#(&$A!@iQ!9(/$D!

!

/$5! (%! +$*09!23! 6WsF&*$.&$5! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$! .%5!@iQ!9(/$! a-(80*$!rPVD!P+! 6EFZj>n[! (+! .!

/2992%!+0=0%(&!23!6EFjp!.%5!6EFZjM!K$!9$.+0*$5!&2&.1!6EFZj!a6EFZj>m[V!.%5!6EFjp>ZY!1$)$1+!

(%!+$*09D!L$!5(5!%2&!2=+$*)$!.!/#.%8$!(%!/(*/01.&(%8!6EFZj!1$)$1+!.%5U!+0*>*(+(%81,M!6EFjp>ZY!

1$)$1+!K$*$!%2&!5$&$/&.=1$!(%!+$*09!a5.&.!%2&!+#2K%V!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1D!e$d&M!K$!9$.+0*$5!

6EFZmP! .%5! 6EFZm-! +$>.*.&$1,! (%! +$*09D! C.%&$1,0+#(%! $&! .1D! 320%5! &#.&! 6EFZm-! #.+! .! 92*$!

(9>2*&.%&! *21$! (%! &#$! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! 925$1! &#.%! 6EZmPM! =,!

/29>.*(%8! &#$! *$+>2%+$!23! 6EFZmP!.%5! 6EFZm-!J%2/J20&!9(/$Dpn! 6EFZm-!J%2/J20&!9(/$!K$*$!

=$&&$*! >*2&$/&$5! .8.(%+&! /#.11$%8$! K(&#! *$>$.&$5! 6Ws! &*$.&9$%&+! /29>.*$5! &2! &#$! 6EFZmP!

J%2/J20&!9(/$D! 6%!=1225M!K$!5$&$/&$5!.%! (%/*$.+$!23! 6EFZm-! 1$)$1+!a-(80*$!r7V!=0&!%2&!23! 6EF

ZmP! 1$)$1+! a5.&.! %2&! +#2K%VD! <#(+! (%50/&(2%!K.+! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 1$++! 20&+>2J$%! (%! <e-:Z!iQ!

9(/$M!K#$*$.+! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!#.5! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! *$50/$5! 6EFZm-! +$*09! 1$)$1+! /29>.*$5! &2!

K(15!&,>$!.%5!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$D!<#$!@iQ!9(/$!+#2K$5!%2!+(8%(3(/.%&!5(33$*$%/$! (%!+$*09!6EF

!!

Control IMQ IMQ IMQ IMQ0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Day 7

Rat

io w

eigh

t spl

een

to b

ody

(x 1

0-3)

****

****

*****

0

1

2

3

4

Day 7

Sco

re

Erythema Scaling

*******

*******

***

*

Wild typeTNFR1 KOIFNAR1 KODKO

"! #!

0

1

2

3

4

5

Day 4

Sco

re

Erythema Scaling

*****

****

*****

**

0.05050.0628

*****

$!

"#$%!&'()!!!*+,-.!/0!!!!1,+2-.!/0!!3/0!

Control IMQ IMQ IMQ IMQ0

25

50

75

100

125

150

Day 7

Epi

derm

al th

ickn

ess

(µm

)

**

*********

****

Page 197: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 184 of 237

Zm-!1$)$1+!.3&$*!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&M!.%5!1$)$1+!K$*$!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!.%5!

<e-:Z!J%2/J20&!9(/$M!=0&!%2&!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!6-eP:Z!iQD!<#$+$!5.&.!>*2)(5$!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!

<e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! .33$/&! &#$! +,+&$9(/! 1$)$1+! 23! 6EFjpl6EFZm! .d(+F.++2/(.&$5!

/,&2J(%$+!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1D!

!

?'Q3*%(0D(?388('<$3"2'4<(45(;C/-+:.,(#<$(;C/-\?('=(#55%"2%$(3:4<(Q%<%2'"($%8%2'4<(45(9>?7-(#<$(

;?>!7-Y(

W(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!32*!320*!/2%+$/0&()$!5.,+!.%5!=1225!K.+!(+21.&$5!.&!5.,+![M!j!.%5!nD!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!K.+!0+$5!&2!9$.+0*$!6EFZj>n[!.%5!6EFZm-!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@!a.&! 1$.+&! n!9(/$! >$*! 8*20>VD! 71./JA! K(15! &,>$!9(/$U! 1(8#&! 8*$,A! <e-:Z! iQ!9(/$U! 5.*J! 8*$,A!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$U!K#(&$A!@iQ!9(/$D!

I'="3=='4<(

69(?0(925! a6WsV! (+! .! <E:mlo! .82%(+&! 0+$5! &2! &*$.&! =.+.1! /$11! /.*/(%29.M! +?0.920+! /$11!

/.*/(%29.M! ./&(%(/! J$*.&2+(+! .%5! 8$%(&.1! .%5! >$*(.%.1! K.*&+! .%5! (+! 0+$5! (%! &#$! 32*9! 23! .!

&2>(/.11,! .>>1($5! /*$.9! /.11$5! P15.*.D! 6&+! 9$5(/(%.1! 0+$! #.+! =$$%! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! 7%& ("="!

(%50/&(2%!2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+Dprwpm!<#(+!1$5!&2!&#$!0+$!23!.!/*$.9!/2%&.(%(%8!6Ws!2%!

9(/$!&2!9(9(/!&#$!(%31.99.&2*,!+J(%!5(+$.+$DqMjoMpnMpo!

<#$! P15.*.! 925$1! #.+! =$$%! (%/*$.+(%81,! 0+$5! .+! .! 925$1! (%! 9(/$! &2! (%50/$! >+2*(.+(+F1(J$!

1$+(2%+! (%! 9(/$D! 6&! (+! .%! $.+,! 925$1M! .+! (&! 52$+! %2&! *$?0(*$! .%,! +0*8(/.1! $d>$*&(+$! +0/#! .+!

d$%28*.3&! 925$1+M! .%5! (%50/$+! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! .11! 90*(%$! =./J8*20%5+M! .1&#208#!

+$)$*(&,! /.%!5(33$*D! P1&#208#! (&+! ./&()$! (%8*$5($%&! (+! (9(?0(925M! 2&#$*! (%8*$5($%&+! 23!P15.*.!

9.,!.1+2! .33$/&! &#$! +J(%D! 6&+!9.(%!5(+.5).%&.8$! (+! &#$! 1./J!23! /#*2%(/(&,! &2! /12+$1,! *$+$9=1$!

>+2*(.+(+M! =0&! 2)$*! &#$! ,$.*+! (&! #.+! =$$%! +#2K%! &#.&! 92+&! *$1$).%&! >.&#K.,+! (%! #09.%!

0 2 0 2 0 2 0 20

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

Time after IMQ (days)

[IL-1

2p40

] (pg

/ml)

**** ***

*** **

ns *****

****

**

0 4 0 4 0 4 0 40

200

400

600

800

1000

Time after IMQ (days)

[IL-1

7F] (

pg/m

l)

****

***

*ns

****

****

****

ns

Wild typeTNFR1 KOIFNAR1 KODKO

!"#"

Page 198: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 185 of 237

>+2*(.+(+!.*$!.1+2!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!&#$!>.&#2128,!23!6WsF(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%M!G0+&(3,(%8!(&+!

0+$!.+!$d>$*(9$%&.1!*(&=*="!925$1D!

6%! &#$! >*$+$%&! +&05,M! K$! #.)$! +#2K%! &#.&! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! $./#! >.*&(.11,!9$5(.&$! &#$!

5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$! 1$+(2%+!0>2%!5.(1,!&*$.&9$%&!23!&#$!+J(%!K(&#!P15.*.M!=,!0+(%8!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!5$3(/($%&!9(/$D!6%!.55(&(2%M!K$!*$>2*&!&#.&!+(901&.%$20+!5$1$&(2%!23!=2&#!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!$%#.%/$+!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!&#(+!(%31.99.&(2%D!6%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!

2*! 6-eP:ZM!P15.*.! /.%%2&! (%50/$! 3011F=12K%! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D!W2*$2)$*M!9(/$!5$3(/($%&! (%!

=2&#!*$/$>&2*+!a@iQV!+#2K$5!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!P15.*.!$33$/&+D!<e-!(+!0>*$801.&$5!

(%!#09.%!>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%.1! +J(%! .%5! (+! &#208#&! &2!9.(%&.(%! &#$! (%31.99.&2*,! 122>! (%! &#$+$!

1$+(2%+Dp!<#$!/1(%(/.1!=$%$3(&+!23!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+!#.)$!/2%3(*9$5!(&+!>*2F!(%31.99.&2*,!*21$!(%!

>+2*(.+(+!.%5!2&#$*!.0&2F!(990%$!5(+$.+$+M!+0/#!.+!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!.%5!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$D!

g2K$)$*M!&#$+$!5*08+!#.)$!+(5$!$33$/&+!*.%8(%8!3*29!(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!(%3$/&(2%+M!&2!

7%&("="!(%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+M!.+!9$%&(2%$5!.=2)$D!P1&#208#!<e-!(+!9.(%1,!J%2K%!.+!.!)$*,!

>2&$%&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$M!(&!(+!$++$%&(.1!32*!$1(/(&(%8!.%!.>>*2>*(.&$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$D!

Q0*!8*20>!*$.+2%+! &#.&! &#$!/0**$%&!+&*.&$8,!23!<e-! (%#(=(&(2%! (+!%2&!2>&(9.1!=$/.0+$!23! &#$!

5(33$*$%&! .d$+! (%)21)$5! (%! <e-! +(8%.1(%8DZj&429$! +&05($+! +088$+&! &#.&! +>$/(3(/! (%#(=(&(2%! 23!

+210=1$!<e-!2*!<e-:Z!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!9(8#&!=$!+033(/($%&!&2!./#($)$!=$%$3(&+!+(9(1.*!

&2!&#2+$!23!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+M!=0&!K(&#20&!/.0+(%8!+(5$!$33$/&+D!P1&#208#!K$!5(5!%2&!.55*$++!&#(+!

(++0$M!K$!52!+#2K!&#.&!8$%$&(/!5$1$&(2%!23!<e-:Z!(+!+033(/($%&!&2!>.*&(.11,!>*2&$/&!9(/$!3*29!

&#$! 3011F=12K%! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! 0>2%! 6Ws! &*$.&9$%&D! -0*&#$*92*$M! K$! *$>2*&! +>$/(3(/!

0>*$801.&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! (%! &#$! +J(%! &*$.&$5! K(&#! 6WsU! 5*.K(%8! .%2&#$*! >.*.11$1! &2! #09.%!

>+2*(.+(+M! (%! K#(/#! <e-:Z! $d>*$++(2%! (+! .1+2! (%/*$.+$5DpYMn[! <#(+! 3(%5(%8! +#2K+! .%2&#$*!

+(9(1.*(&,!=$&K$$%!&#$!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!920+$!925$1!.%5!#09.%!

>+2*(.+(+D!!

<2!$10/(5.&$!&#$!*21$!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!1$+(2%+M!K$!(%)$+&(8.&$5!

&#$! (%50/&(2%!23! &,>$! 6! 6-eF*$+>2%+()$!8$%$+D!L$! 320%5!$1$).&$5! 1$)$1+!23! 6-evM! 6-eu!.%5!.!

Page 199: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 186 of 237

+(8%(3(/.%&! 64:H!+(8%.&0*$!$.*1,!.3&$*! &2>(/.1! .>>1(/.&(2%!23! 6WsM!K#(/#! *.>(51,!5$/*$.+$5! (%!

K(15! &,>$!9(/$! .3&$*! &#$(*! (%50/&(2%! >$.JD!L$! #$*$=,! /2%3(*9! &#$! )$*,! $.*1,! .%5! &*.%+($%&!

./&(2%+!23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%!>+2*(.+(+!>*2>2+$5!=,!e$+&1$!$&!.1DZm!:$9.*J.=1,M! (%! &#$!.=+$%/$!23!

<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8M!=2&#!6-e+!>*250/&(2%!.%5!64:H!8$%$!$d>*$++(2%!K.+!+0+&.(%$5!(%!+$*09!.%5!

+J(%M!*$+>$/&()$1,D!<#(+!9(8#&!=$!50$!&2!(%$33(/($%&!9.&0*.&(2%!23!>@;+!.%5!$%#.%/$5!*$1$.+$!23!

6-ev!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!=12/J.5$!23!<e-!+(8%.1(%8M!.+!>*$)(20+1,!*$>2*&$5!=,!C.10/J.!$&!.1Djr!<#(+!

/2**$1.&$+!K(&#!&#$!2=+$*).&(2%+!&#.&!>.&($%&+!2%!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!&2!&*$.&!2&#$*!.0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+!/.%!#.)$!(%/*$.+$5!&,>$!6!6-e!1$)$1+!.%5!5$)$12>!/0&.%$20+!1$+(2%+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(32*9!

92*>#2128,DnZMnj! 6&! #.+! =$$%! +088$+&$5! &#.&! .! =.1.%/$! =$&K$$%! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (+! 12+&!

0>2%! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+M! 1$.5(%8! &2! 0%2>>2+$5! (%/*$.+$+! (%! 6-e! 1$)$1+D! L$!

#,>2&#$+(R$!&#.&!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!2*!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!2%!.%&(F<e-!5*08+!.*$!

92*$!)01%$*.=1$!&2!5$)$12>(%8!>+2*(.+(+!0>2%!<E:m!./&().&(2%!.%5!K(11!>*250/$!$d/$++()$!.%5!

+0+&.(%$5!.920%&+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!W2*$2)$*M!'$,.9.!$&!.1D!5$+/*(=$5!#2K!&#$!$33$/&+!23!6Ws!

.*$! $%#.%/$5! (%! &#$!>*$+$%/$!23! 6-evM! 1$.5(%8! &2!>*250/&(2%!23! 6EFZuM! 6EFqM! 6EFjpM! (eQ4leQ!

.%5! <e-Dpo! P1&#208#! <e-! /.%! =$! (%#(=(&$5! =,! .%&(F<e-! &*$.&9$%&M! &#$! .32*$9$%&(2%$5!

/,&2J(%$+! /.%! 1$.5! &2! (%/*$.+$5! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! &#$+$!>.&($%&+M! $+>$/(.11,!K#$%! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!

.*$! .1*$.5,! (%/*$.+$5! (%! &#$+$! >.&($%&+D! 6&! (+! &#$*$32*$! *$/299$%5$5! &2! $).10.&$! K#$&#$*!

&#$+$!>.&($%&+!K2015!=$%$3(&!3*29!.%&(F6-eP:Z!&*$.&9$%&!(%!2*5$*!&2!.)2(5!>+2*(.+(+!.+!.!+(5$!

$33$/&D!!

6%!&#(+!+&05,M!K$!$).10.&$5!+J(%F+>$/(3(/!9.*J$*+!&2!.++$++!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!>+2*(.+(32*9!1$+(2%+D!

:$9.*J.=1,M!K#$%!=2&#!6-eP:Z!.%5!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!.*$!(9>.(*$5M!$./#!9.*J$*!32112K+!2%$!

23! &#$! +(%81$! J%2/J20&! >#$%2&,>$+M! $d/$>&! 32*! MZGG/RM! K#(/#! (+! 1$++! (%50/$5! (%! @iQ!9(/$!

/29>.*$5!&2!&#$!+(%81$!iQ!9(/$M!(%5(/.&(%8!&#.&!(&+!(%50/&(2%!(+!5$>$%5$%&!2%!=2&#!>.&#K.,+D!

g2K$)$*M!<e-!.%5! 6EFZm!#.)$!=$$%! *$>2*&$5! &2! (%50/$!MZGG/R! +,%$*8(+&(/.11,DnpMnn! 4(%/$! 6EF

Zm-!(+!*$50/$5!(%!=2&#!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!&#(+!*.(+$+!&#$!?0$+&(2%!K#$&#$*!&#$!

Page 200: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 187 of 237

*$50/$5!6EFZm-!1$)$1+!.33$/&!&#$!$d>*$++(2%!23!MZGG/R!(%!@iQ!9(/$!.+!K$11D!<#(+!*$9.(%+!&2!=$!

(%)$+&(8.&$5!(%!92*$!5$>&#D!

I.%!5$*!-(&+!$&!.1D!.%5!9.%,!2&#$*+!#.)$!>*2)(5$5!+21(5!$)(5$%/$!32*!.!>*29(%$%&!*21$!32*!&#$!

6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+! (%!>+2*(.+(+DqMpnMnrMnq!P1&#208#! &#$! 6EFZm!/,&2J(%$! 3.9(1,! /2%+(+&+!23!901&(>1$!

1(8.%5+M! 6EFZmP! (+! &#$!92+&!/#.*./&$*(R$5! 1(8.%5!.%5! (+!23&$%!*$3$**$5!&2!.+! 6EFZmD!�$&M!9.%,!

+&05($+!#.)$! *$)$.1$5!.%! (9>2*&.%&! *21$! 32*! 6EFZm-!.+!K$11M! (%/105(%8!.! +&05,!>$*32*9$5!=,!

C.%&$1,0+#(%! $&! .1DM!K#$*$! &#$,! *$>2*&$5!92*$! 6EFZm-F>*250/(%8! /$11+! (%! 6WsF(%31.9$5! +J(%!

&#.%!6EFZmP!+$/*$&(%8!/$11+Dpn!4(9(1.*1,M!K$!2=+$*)$5!%2!/#.%8$+!(%!6EFZmP!+$*09!1$)$1+!50*(%8!

6Ws!&*$.&9$%&M!K#$*$.+!6EFZm-! (%/*$.+$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,D! 6%!=2&#!+(%81$!.%5!@iQ!9(/$M! 6EFZm-!

K.+!1$++!(%/*$.+$5!&#.%!(%!K(15!&,>$!/2%&*21!9(/$D!P1&#208#!&,>$!6!6-e+!#.)$!=$$%!*$>2*&$5M!(%!

+29$!925$1+M!&2!(%#(=(&!6EFZmPl-!&#*208#!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZ[!2*!6EFjmMnmMno!K$!+#2K!#$*$!

*$50/$5! 6EFZm-! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$!23! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8D! 4(9(1.*1,M! <e-:Z!5$3(/($%/,! *$+01&$5! (%!

5$/*$.+$5! 6EFZm-! =1225! 1$)$1+D! <#$*$! (+M! #2K$)$*M! %2! .55(&()$! $33$/&! 23! =2&#! +(8%.1(%8!

>.&#K.,+M!.+!50.1!5$1$&(2%!23!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!*$+01&$5!(%!6EFZm-!1$)$1+!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!

6Ws! &*$.&9$%&! /29>.*.=1$! &2! &#2+$! (%! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$D! W2*$2)$*M! 6EFZj>n[! 1$)$1+! K$*$!

.33$/&$5! .+! K$11D! 6EFZj>n[! (+! .! +0=0%(&! +#.*$5! =,! 6EFZj! .%5! 6EFjp! .%5! #.+! *$/$%&1,! =$$%!

).1(5.&$5! .+! .! &#$*.>$0&(/! &.*8$&! 32*! >+2*(.+(+DpZwpp! <#208#! 6EFZj! .%5! 6EFjp! .*$! %2&! +&*(/&1,!

J%2K%!.+! &,>(/.1! &,>$! 6! 6-eF(%50/$5! 8$%$+M! &#$!>*$+$%/$!23! 64:H! $1$9$%&+! (%! &#$!>*292&$*!

*$8(2%+! 32*! 0%(&! >prM! >n[! .%5! >ZY! #.)$! =$$%! 5$+/*(=$5DnYwrp! 6&! (+! *$9.*J.=1$! &#.&! &#$! >n[!

+0=0%(&!K.+!5$&$/&$5!=0&!/29>1$&$!6EFZj!2*!6EFjp!K$*$!%2&!320%5!(%!/(*/01.&(2%D!<#$!+0=0%(&+!

23!6EFZj!.%5!6EFjp!52!%2&!+#.*$!+(9(1.*!>*292&$*+M!=0&!.*$!2%1,!32*9$5!K#$%!&#$!*$+>$/&()$!

+0=0%(&+! .*$! /2F$d>*$++$5! (%! &#$! +.9$! $%)(*2%9$%&DrnMrr! <#(+! +#2015! .112K! &#$! (990%$!

+,+&$9!&2!+&$$*!&#$!(990%$!*$+>2%+$!(%!.!5$1(/.&$!.%5!+0=&1$!K.,!5$>$%5(%8!2%!&#$!+(&0.&(2%D!

g2K$)$*M!&#$!*21$!23!+,+&$9(/!6EFZj>n[!(%!>+2*(.+(+!*$9.(%+!0%/1$.*D!

!

Page 201: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 188 of 237

6%! /2%/10+(2%M! 20*! *$+01&+! 5$92%+&*.&$! &#$! /29>1$d(&,! 23! &#$! (%&$*./&(2%+! 23! &K2! /,&2J(%$+M!

<e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! .%5! &#$(*! *$/$>&2*+M! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:ZM! *$+>$/&()$1,! .%5! &#$(*!

*$+>$/&()$!$33$/&+!2%!2&#$*!/,&2J(%$+!.%5!.%&(9(/*2=(.1!>*2&$(%+!.+!5$>(/&$5!(%!.!+/#$9.&(/!!

!

?'Q3*%([D(F4<<%"2'4<=(G%2K%%<(9>?7-N(;?>!7-(;C/-+:.,(#<$(;C-\?('<(26%(;@d(:=4*'#='=(&43=%(

&4$%8(

<2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!6Ws!1$.5+!&2!>*250/&(2%!23!).*(20+!/,&2J(%$+!+0/#!.+!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<e-!&*(88$*+!<e-:ZM!K#(/#!K(11!1$.5!&2!>*250/&(2%!23!.%&(9(/*2=(.1!>*2&$(%+!=,!J$*.&(%2/,&$D!<28$&#$*!K(&#!6-eP:ZM! <e-! .1+2! >*292&$+! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! 6EFZm-M! .! J%2K%! 9$5(.&2*! (%! &#$! >.&#28$%$+(+! 23!>+2*(.+(+D!C2++(=1,!<e-!.%5!6EFZm-!./&!&28$&#$*!&2!+&(901.&$!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!>*2&$(%+!+0/#!.+!4Z[[Po!.%5!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&!a?0$+&(2%!9.*JVD!P/&().&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!1$.5+!&2!&#$!>*250/&(2%!23!6EFZj>n[!.+!K$11M!.!%2)$1!5*08!&.*8$&!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!!!

!

2)$*)($K! a-(80*$! qVD!L$! +#2K! &#.&! .1&#208#! &#$,! =2&#!9$5(.&$! >.*&+! 23! &#$! (%31.99.&2*,!

>.&#28$%$+(+!23!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%M!+(901&.%$20+!(%#(=(&(2%!23!=2&#!

>.&#K.,+! &28$&#$*! .9$1(2*.&$! 6WsF(%50/$5! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D! <#$! >.*.52d(/.1! +(5$! $33$/&+!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!&#$!/0**$%&!<e-F.%&.82%(+&+!/2015!>2++(=1,!=$!*$+21)$5!=,!.55(&(2%.11,!&.*8$&!

&#$!6-eP:Z!>.&#K.,D!W2*$2)$*M!=12/J(%8!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!*$50/$+!./&().&(2%!23!&#$!

6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!50*(%8!6WsF9$5(.&$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!&#*208#!*$50/&(2%!23!6EFZj>n[!.%5!

6EFZm-!1$)$1+M!&K2!%2)$1!5*08!&.*8$&+!(%!>+2*(.+(+M!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!:PDpjMrqwqZ!Q0*!3(%5(%8+!

Page 202: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 189 of 237

K.**.%&! &2! +&05,! &#$! >2&$%&(.1! +&*.&$8(/! .5).%&.8$+! 23! /29=(%$5! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! &#$! /,&2J(%$!

*$/$>&2*+!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!32*!&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+D!

@#2%*'#8=(#<$(&%264$=(

@'"%(

;rm7EqlN! 9(/$! K$*$! >0*/#.+$5! 3*29! N.%)($*! aE$! "$%$+&F4&! 6+1$M! -*.%/$VD! <e-:Z! J%2/J20&!

a<e-:Z!iQV!9(/$!8$%$*.&$5!=,!WD!:2&#$!K$*$!.!8(3&!3*29!gD!71$0&#9.%%!ag2339.%%FE.!:2/#$M!

7.+$1M!4K(&R$*1.%5VD!<#$,!K$*$!J$>&!2%!.!;rm7EqlN!=./J8*20%5D! 6-eP:Z!J%2/J20&! a6-eP:Z!

iQV!9(/$!K$*$!>*2)(5$5!=,!@D!72%.>.*&$! a"01=$%J(.%! 6%+&(&0&$!23! 4/($%/$M!C2*&08.1VD!<#$+$!

9(/$! K$*$! =./J/*2++$5! 32*! 92*$! &#.%! Z[! 8$%$*.&(2%+! (%&2! .! #2928$%20+! ;rm7EqlN!

=./J8*20%5D!g292R,820+!<e-:Zl6-eP:Z!520=1$!J%2/J20&!9(/$!K$*$!8$%$*.&$5!=,!/*2++(%8!

#292R,820+! <e-:Z! iQ!K(&#! #292R,820+! 6-eP:Z! iQ!9(/$M! 32112K$5! =,! (%&$*/*2++(%8! .%5!

+$1$/&(%8! @iQ! 9(/$D! P11! .%(9.1+! K$*$! 9.(%&.(%$5! (%! .%! 4C-! &$9>$*.&0*$F/2%&*211$5M! .(*F

/2%5(&(2%$5!.%(9.1!#20+$!K(&#!.!ZnF!&2!Z[F#20*F1(8#&l5.*J!/,/1$!.%5!*$/$()$5!3225!.%5!K.&$*!

/7&.*L*)#0D!Hd>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!(%!&#$!4C-!.%(9.1!#20+$!2%!9.1$!9(/$!o!Zj!K$$J+!

215D!P11!.%(9.1!$d>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!.>>*2)$5!=,! &#$! (%+&(&0&(2%.1!$&#(/+!/299(&&$$! 32*!.%(9.1!

K$13.*$! 23! &#$! -./01&,! 23! 4/($%/$+M! "#$%&! '%()$*+(&,M! 7$18(09! .%5! 32112K$5! &#$! H0*2>$.%!

80(5$1(%$+D!!

;&'g3'&4$/'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='=/8'J%(=J'<(8%='4<=(#<$(="4*'<Q(45(=)&:24&=(

W(/$!K$*$!=*($31,! +$5.&$5!K(&#! (+2310*.%$!.%5! &#$!=./J! +J(%!23!9(/$!K.+! +#.)$5D!<K2!5.,+!

1.&$*M!.!52+$!23!qjMr!98!23!P15.*.!/*$.9!ar\!6WsU!pW!C#.*9./$0&(/.1+V!K.+!.>>1($5!5.(1,!2%!

&#$!=./J! 32*!n!m! /2%+$/0&()$!5.,+D!W(/$!K$*$! +/2*$5!5.(1,! =.+$5!2%! .!925(3($5!CP46! +/2*$!

+,+&$9! .+! 5$+/*(=$5! >*$)(20+1,Dq! 6%! =*($3M! &2! 5$+/*(=$! &#$! +$)$*(&,! 23! >+2*(.+(+M! $*,&#$9.!

a*$5%$++! 23! &#$! +J(%V! .%5! +/.1(%8!K$*$! +/2*$5! `=1(%51,_! 2%! .! +/.1$! 3*29! [! &2! nA! [M! %2%$U! ZM!

+1(8#&U!jA!925$*.&$U!pA!9.*J$5U!nA!)$*,!9.*J$5D!<#(/J%$++!23!&#$!+J(%!K.+!9$.+0*$5!2%!gBH!

+&.(%$5!+J(%!+$/&(2%+!.+!5$+/*(=$5!=$12KD!!

Page 203: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 190 of 237

S%&#24H)8'<(V(%4='<(_SVB`(=2#'<'<Q(

<(++0$!+.9>1$+!K$*$!3(d$5!(%!n\!>.*.32*9.15$#,5$!.%5!$9=$55$5!(%!>.*.33(%D!@$>.*.33(%(R$5!

rF£9!+$/&(2%+!K$*$!+&.(%$5!K(&#!#$9.&2d,1(%!.%5!$2+(%D!C(/&0*$+!K$*$!&.J$%!K(&#!.%!Q1,9>0+!

7OrZ!1(8#&!9(/*2+/2>$!an[dV!.%5!$>(5$*9.1!&#(/J%$++!K.+!?0.%&(3($5!K(&#!I212/(&,!+23&K.*$!

aC$*J(%H19$*VD!

I%2%"2'4<(45(9>?7-N(9>?N(;?>(8'Q#<$=N(;C/-\!W?N(;C/-+:.,W:\,(#<$(;C/+X:-^(

W(/$! K$*$! &*$.&$5! K(&#! 6Ws! .%5! $0&#.%(R$5! 32*! =1225M! +>1$$%! .%5! +J(%! /211$/&(2%! .&! &#$!

(%5(/.&$5! &(9$+D! 71225! K.+! /211$/&$5! &#*208#! /.*5(./! >0%/&0*$! .%5! .112K$5! &2! /12&! .&! n¤;!

2)$*%(8#&D! 4$*09! K.+! /211$/&$5! .3&$*! *$92).1! 23! &#$! /12&! .%5! /$%&*(308.&(2%! .%5! +&2*$5! .&!

!o[¤;! 0%&(1! .++.,$5D!L#21$! +J(%! +.9>1$+! K$*$! #2928$%(R$5! (%! (/$F/215! =033$*! aC74M! [Dr\!

;gPC4M! :2/#$! ;29>1$&$! >*2&$.+$! (%#(=(&2*VD! g2928$%.&$+! K$*$! /$%&*(308$5! 32*! p[! 9(%! .&!

j[M[[[! 8! .%5! n¤;M! .3&$*! K#(/#! &#$! +0>$*%.&.%&! K.+! /211$/&$5! .%5! +&2*$5! .&! !j[¤;D! C*2&$(%!

/2%/$%&*.&(2%!K.+!5$&$*9(%$5!=,!&#$!7*.532*5!9$&#25!a7(2:.5VD!-2*!&#$!5$&$/&(2%!23!<e-:Z!

1$)$1+M!s0.%&(J(%$!+>rr<e-:!i(&!a:B@!4,+&$9+V!K.+!0+$5D!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!K.+!0+$5!&2!

5$&$/&!<e-M!6EFZj>n[M!6EFZj>m[M!6EFjp>ZYM!6EFZmPl-!a7(2*.5VM!.%5!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!aW20+$!6-e!

.1>#.l=$&.!C1.&(%09!aC*2/.*&.VD!P11!.=2)$F9$%&(2%$5!&$/#%(?0$+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!.//2*5(%8!

&2!&#$!9.%03./&0*$*+c!(%+&*0/&(2%+D!

79/gEF7(

4J(%! +.9>1$+! K$*$! /211$/&$5! (%! :eP! E.&$*! aP9=(2%VD! :eP! K.+! (+21.&$5! K(&#! &#$! :e$.+,!

-(=*20+!<(++0$!i(&!as(.8$%V!.//2*5(%8!&2!&#$!9.%03./&0*$*�+!(%+&*0/&(2%+D!:eP!/2%/$%&*.&(2%!

K.+!9$.+0*$5!K(&#!&#$!e.%25*2>Z[[[!a<#$*92!4/($%&(3(/V!.%5!?0.1(&,!K.+!/#$/J$5!0+(%8!&#$!

P8(1$%&! jZ[[! 7(2P%.1,R$*M! .%5! Z! ¡8! :eP! K.+! 0+$5! &2! >*$>.*$! /29>1$9$%&.*,! @eP! K(&#!

40>$*4/*(>&!66!a6%)(&*28$%VD!s0.%&(&.&()$!*$.1F&(9$!C;:!K.+!>$*32*9$5!0+(%8!4$%+(-.+&<W!4,=*!

eQF:QO!i(&!a7(21(%$V!.%5!&#$!E(8#&;,/1$*!no[!a:2/#$VD!Hd>*$++(2%!1$)$1+!K$*$!%2*9.1(R$5!&2!

&#$! $d>*$++(2%! 23! &#$! &K2! 92+&! +&.=1$! *$3$*$%/$! 8$%$+M! K#(/#! K$*$! 5$&$*9(%$5! 32*! $./#!

/2%5(&(2%! 0+(%8! 8$e2*9! a?7.+$M! 7(28.R$11$VD! I.10$+! .*$! *$>*$+$%&$5! .+! *$1.&()$! $d>*$++(2%!

%2*9.1(R$5! &2! &#$! 8$29$&*(/!9$.%!23! &#$! &K2! +$1$/&$5!92+&! +&.=1$! *$3$*$%/$! 8$%$+D! C*(9$*!

Page 204: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 191 of 237

+$?0$%/$+!.%5!*$3$*$%/$+!8$%$+!/.%!=$!320%5!(%!<.=1$!Z!.%5!jM!*$+>$/&()$1,D!40>>1$9$%&.*,!

<.=1$!Z! 1(+&+! &#$! 3215! (%50/&(2%+!23! &#$! &*.%+/*(>&! 1$)$1+! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQM!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!@iQ!

+J(%!32*!&#$!(%5(/.&$5!8$%$+!3*29!5.,![!&2!5.,!q!.3&$*!6WsD!!

12#2'=2'"#8(#<#8)='=(

:$+01&+!a9$.%xF!4@!2*!4HWV!K$*$!/29>.*$5!K(&#!.!&K2F&.(1$5!4&05$%&�+!&!&$+&D!C!).10$+!¦![D[r!

K$*$!/2%+(5$*$5!+(8%(3(/.%&D!�!>!¦![D[rM!��!>!¦![D[ZM!���!>!¦![D[[ZM!����!>!§![D[[[Z!

!"J<4K8%$Q&%<2=(<#(+!K2*J!K.+! 30%5$5!=,! &#$!P8$%/,! 32*! 6%%2).&(2%!=,! 4/($%/$! .%5!<$/#%2128,! a6L<VM! &#$!

:$+$.*/#! -20%5.&(2%! -1.%5$*+! a-LQ! I1..%5$*$%V! .%5! &#$! 6%&$*0%()$*+(&,! P&&*./&(2%! C21$+!

C*28*.9!23!&#$!7$18(.%!4/($%/$!C21(/,!a6'PCVD!L$!K2015!1(J$!&2!&#.%J!N2J$!I.%5$%!7$*8#$!32*!

&$/#%(/.1!.++(+&.%/$!.%5!P9(%!7*$5.%!32*!9.%0+/*(>&!$5(&(%8D!

9#G8%=((9#G8%(-D(E*'&%*(=%g3%<"%=(54*(g79/EF7(#<#8)='=(

!

A%<%( ?4*K#*$(:*'&%*( 7%M%*=%(:*'&%*(

[45)& P"<"<<""P<P;P"";;P"P;! ;"<"P<<;PPP<;;;<"PP"<!

>4.& !!;;<";<";<;<;PP""<<! <""<<"<;P;<";;<;"<P;<<!

<L+& P""<;PPP;P""PP"P;P"P;"<P! <;P;P;;;PP"PP;PP";P;P!

?(-(! <<";<"P<"";;""<;<<P<<! ";;P"<;<<<;;PP<"P"P;PP!

,=.& P<"<;;;P<;PP;P;P;P;<"! <""P"<<""<<";<<<";<<"!

S"5! ;P;P<;P";P<;P;;<;;<<;;! ;;<;;<;;P;;P"P""<;<<<;!

]5)aL! ;;P<;PP"P"<;PPP;<P";;P;! ";<;PPP;P<P"";<;;P""<<!

MZGG/R! !!PPP<;P;;P<";;;<;<P;PP"! ;;;P;<<<<P<;P;;P<;";PP!

,-*)D& P<;<;<;;;<P;<;<";;;<;;<P! ";"<P<PPP<;P";PP<;;;<<;P!

?_+.ZG& ;;PP"<";<";;"<;P<<<<;! "";<;";P"""P<"P<<<;PP!

<$4ZR& P";;;<;P<""<;<""<<""<<! ";P;<;;"P"";P;<"<<P<;;!

!

Page 205: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 192 of 237

(

9#G8%(+D(7%5%*%<"%(Q%<%=(:%*("4<$'2'4<(

!

F4<$'2'4<( 1#&:8%=( 7%5%*%<"%(Q%<%=(

GFDFYFa&7/9$&o&,!p& <e-:Z!x!6-eP:Z!iQ!x!/2%&*21!8*20>+! &&>4.&x&[45)!

GFDFYFa&7/9$&o&,!p& @iQ!!! >4.&x!<L+!

GFDFa&;"#5$&o&,!p& <e-:Z!iQ!x!/2%&*21!8*20>! >4.&o&[45)&

(!13::8%&%<2#*)(9#G8%(-D(9*#<="*':2'4<#8(548$('<$3"2'4<(45(&#*J%*=('<(=J'<(

!

@#*J%*=( ;?>!7-(OZ( 9>?7-(OZ( IOZ(

;2*%(3$1(%!a?-(V! pMZ!¢!ZM[! ZqMj!¢!pMm! jMp!¢!ZMp!

6%)210/*(%!a,=.V! [Mp!¢![MZ! mMY!¢![MY! pMY!¢!ZMo!

E2*(/*(%!aS"5V! [Mr!¢![MZ! ZrMj!¢!rMY! qMr!¢!rMp!

i$*.&(%q=!a]5)aLV! jMZ!¢!jMr! pZqM![!¢!ZqmMr! ZMj!¢!ZMY!

4Z[[Po!aMZGG/RV! Z[noMq!¢!momMn! jprMr!¢!ojMo! ZMo!¢![Mo!!

(

! (

Page 206: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 193 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! 4&$*%!:4M!e(G+&$%!<M!-$159.%!4:M!W.*821(+!@NM!:21+&.5!<D!C+2*(.+(+!(+!/2992%M!/.**($+!.!+0=+&.%&(.1!=0*5$%!$)$%!K#$%!%2&!$d&$%+()$M!.%5!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!K(5$+>*$.5!&*$.&9$%&!5(++.&(+3./&(2%D!c&,(=%$)*8&3%50/)".&

M904&\5"+D!j[[nUYajVAZpqFYD!52(AZ[DZ[nqlGDZ[omF[[jnDj[[pD[YZ[jDdD!

jD!! i0*5!4iM!"$13.%5!NWD!<#$!>*$).1$%/$!23!>*$)(20+1,!5(.8%2+$5!.%5!0%5(.8%2+$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!'4!.501&+A!*$+01&+!3*29!egPeH4!j[[pFj[[nD!c&U0&U+/7&3%50/)".D!j[[YUq[ajVAjZoFjnD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGDG..5Dj[[oD[YD[jjD!

pD!! H&&$#.5(!CM!"*$.)$+!WLM!L.11./#!@M!P5$*J.!@M!;.9>!:@D!H1$).&$5!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.1>#.!a<e-F

.1>#.V!=(2128(/.1!./&()(&,!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!?.*(&T_4&,00#(".D!ZYYnUYqaZVAZnqFrZD!

nD!! P/J$*9.%%!EM!g.*)(9.!6<M!C$1J2%$%!NM!$&!.1D!W.+&!/$11+!(%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!.*$!+&*2%81,!>2+(&()$!32*!

(%&$*3$*2%F8.99.D!65&c&3%50/)".D!ZYYYUZn[anVAqjnFppD!

rD!! N2#.%+$%!;M!-0%5(%8!P<M!Q&JG.$*!iM!$&!.1D!C*2&$(%!Hd>*$++(2%!23!<e-F!!(%!C+2*(.&(/!4J(%!6+!:$801.&$5!.&!.!C2+&&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!E$)$1!=,!WPCiFP/&().&$5!C*2&$(%!i(%.+$!jD!c&,00#(".D!j[[qUZmqapVAZnpZFZnpoD!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZmqDpDZnpZD!

qD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!W20*(&+!4M!I2$*9.%!N4!.M!$&!.1D!69(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$!

(+!9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaYVAropqFnrD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[jYYYD!

mD!! ;#(*(/2RR(!PM!"0&&9.%F�.++J,!HM!40�*$RF-.*(©.+!WM!$&!.1D!6%&$8*.&()$!*$+>2%+$+!&2!6EFZm!.%5!<e-Fv!(%!#09.%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!.//20%&!32*!J$,!(%31.99.&2*,!>.&#28$%(/!/(*/0(&+!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!

j[ZZUZpZapVAqmmFomD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[Z[Dpn[D!

oD!! 7*.51$,!N:D!<e-F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$D!c&\/);".D!j[[oUjZnajVAZnYFq[D!52(AZ[DZ[[jl>.&#DjjomD!

YD!! �.=.!E;M!;.*5(%.1$!6M!"(11$.05$.0!CM!$&!.1D!P9$1(2*.&(2%!23!$>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>1.+(.!=,!<e-!(%#(=(&(2%!(+!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!*$50/$5!<#Zm!*$+>2%+$+D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[mUj[naZpVApZopFYnD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[mZ[YnD!

Z[D!! C$©.F4.8*$52!NEM!g$*%�%5$R!W!IM!-$*%.%5$RFE1.%(2!eM!$&!.1D!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+!(%3$/&(2%!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*#$09.&(/!5(+$.+$+!2%!<e-F.1>#.!.%&.82%(+&!&#$*.>,A!&#$!4>.%(+#!4&05,!"*20>!$d>$*($%/$D!?.*(&T_4&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[oUjqarVAornFYD!

ZZD!! E.%&$*%($*!-M!<0=./#!-M!:.).05!CM!$&!.1D!6%/(5$%/$!.%5!*(+J!3./&2*+!23!E$8(2%$11.!>%$092>#(1.!>%$092%(.!50*(%8!.%&(F&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!&#$*.>,A!.!>*2+>$/&()$!-*$%/#!+&05,D!?;%$)D!j[ZpUZnnapVAYY[FoD!

52(AZ[DZpmol/#$+&DZjFjoj[D!

ZjD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!E(=$*&!;D!<*$.&9$%&!23!<e-!9$5(.&$5!5(+$.+$+!=,!+$1$/&()$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!+210=1$!<e-!2*!<e-:ZD!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[ZZUjjarFqVApZZFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&283*Dj[ZZD[YD[[nD!

ZpD!! 7.%/#$*$.0!NM!C.+/0.1!ID!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!(%!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+!.%5!2&#$*!.0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+D!,00#(*)9D!j[[qUjrapVApopFYjD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[[qD[oD[Z[D!

ZnD!! :z%%=129!ED!<#$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+,+&$9!(%!&#$!$&(2>.&#28$%$+(+!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!<4$&c&!%7&M+*D!

j[ZZUZZqanVAjjmFpmD!52(AZ[DpZ[Yl[p[[YmpnDj[ZZDqjnqnYD!

ZrD!! :z%%=129!EM!H12*.%&.!WFED!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.&0*$!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!?#55&^4*(&>;%#0/)".D!

j[ZpUjrajVAjnoFrpD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml7Q:D[=[Zp$pjopr/m$pjD!

ZqD!! 4/#9(5!CM!6&(%!CM!;2d!@M!W/W.+&$*!"iM!g2*(+=$*8$*!WPD!<#$!<,>$!6!6%&$*3$*2%!4,+&$9!6+!E2/.11,!P/&().&$5!

(%!C+2*(.&(/!E$+(2%+D!c&,()%5-%5"(&>%$D!ZYYnUZnarVAjjYFjpnD!52(AZ[DZ[oYlG(*DZYYnDZnDjjYD!

Page 207: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 194 of 237

ZmD!! e$+&1$!-QM!;2%*.5!;M!<0%Fi,(!PM!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!>*$5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!&#*208#!

(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[jaZVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[r[r[[D!

ZoD!! 7#.*5K.G!eM!4.%&#.%.9!'M!E.0!EEM!$&!.1D!6EFql6-eF=$&.!j!(%!+,%2)(.1!$330+(2%+!23!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!.%5!2&#$*!.*&#*(&(5$+D!65$%&(3(/.&(2%!23!+$)$*.1!(+232*9+!.%5!+&05($+!23!/$1101.*!+20*/$+D!c&

,00#(".D!ZYoYUZnpamVAjZrpFYD!

ZYD!! "2*52%!:PM!"*(82*($)!"M!E$$!PM!i.11(21(.+!"@M!6).+#J()!E7D!<#$!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.&0*$!.%5!4<P<Z!$d>*$++(2%!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!+,%2)(.1!310(5!9./*2>#.8$+!.*$!(%50/$5!=,!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!v!.%5!/20%&$*F*$801.&$5!=,!&#$!+,%2)(.1!310(5!9(/*2$%)(*2%9$%&D!U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[ZjUqnaZ[VApZZYFjoD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DpnrnnD!

j[D!! @2K%+!PWM!@0%%(11!W"D!Hd./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!=,!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;D!?.*(&T_4&

3%50/)".D!j[[[UjranVAprZFjD!

jZD!! ;(&*2!IM!-*(+&./#(!:M!<.*.%&(%2!"D!Hd&$%+()$!>+2*(.+(+!(%50/$5!=,!>$8,1.&$5!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!/.+$!*$>2*&D!c&!%7&

?/$%&>%4D!j[[mUZaZVAoqD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZmrjFZYnmFZFoqD!

jjD!! P3+#.*!WM!W.*&(%$R!P@M!".112!:EM!g.&.!<:D!6%50/&(2%!.%5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;A!.!*$)($K!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!pq!/.+$+D!c&T#5&U+/7&3%50/)".&@%(%5%".D!j[ZpUjmaqVAmmZF

oD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqoFp[opDj[ZjD[nrojDdD!

jpD!! @0&R!NCD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.!(%#(=(&(2%!.%5!>.192>1.%&.*!>0+&012+(+A!N.%0+F3./$5!&#$*.>,S!c&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[mUpnajVAjnmFYD!

jnD!! N0!OM!�$%J$!WM!g.*&!@eNM!;1.*J!"ND!;@p[[.l/!*$801.&$!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!.%5!<e-F.1>#.!+$/*$&(2%!=,!#09.%!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!+&(901.&$5!K(&#!<E:m!.%5!<E:Y!1(8.%5+D!6.""7D!j[[oUZZjanVAZZonFYnD!

52(AZ[DZZojl=1225Fj[[mFZjFZjmYrZD!

jrD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

jqD!! ;.%&.$*&!<M!7.$&$%!@M!<.J!CCM!).%!7..*+$%!E"WD!<,>$!6!6-e!.%5!<e-v!/*2++F*$801.&(2%!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$A!=.+(/!/2%/$>&+!.%5!/1(%(/.1!*$1$).%/$D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[Z[UZjarVAjZYD!52(AZ[DZZoql.*pZr[D!

jmD!! ;*.3&!eM!7*0#%!iLM!e80,$%!7@M!$&!.1D!<#$!<E:m!P82%(+&!69(?0(925!H%#.%/$+!&#$!P%&(FW$1.%29.!H33$/&+!23!.!:$/29=(%.%&!E(+&$*(.!92%2/,&28$%$+!I.//(%$D!c&,00#(".D!j[[rUZmrapVAZYopFZYY[D!

52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZmrDpDZYopD!

joD!! L.1&$*!PM!4/#�3$*!WM!;$//2%(!IM!$&!.1D!P15.*.!./&().&$+!<E:mF(%5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!5$3$%/$D!V/)&?"00#(D!j[ZpUnAZrq[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/299+jrqqD!

jYD!! :$0++!:M!C2#1$!4M!:$&R1.33!iM!g$9=$*8$*!NM!Q+/#9.%%!CD!6%&$*3$*2%!=$&.FZ.!(%50/$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!=0&!5$/*$.+$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!j!1$0J2/,&$!9:eP!1$)$1+!(%!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!

901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!V%#5"*00#("0"7#./)*"(D!j[[YUZqapVAZmZFqD!52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[j[njp[D!

p[D!! ;0=(11.+!:M!i(%&%$*!iM!C#(11(>+!-M!i.*.%5(J.*!eNM!<#($1$!@EM!7*2K%!":D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!$d>*$++(2%!(+!0>*$801.&$5!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!g;I!K#2!*$+>2%5!&2!&#$*.>,D![%4/)&

>%$&A5%/)D!j[Z[Uj[Z[AnjYjnpD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[Z[lnjYjnpD!

pZD!! i.0339.%!;EM!P*(.!eM!<2(/#(!HM!$&!.1D!P!>#.+$!6!+&05,!$).10.&(%8!&#$!+.3$&,M!>#.*9./2J(%$&(/+M!.%5!/1(%(/.1!*$+>2%+$!23!.!#09.%!6EFZj!>n[!.%&(=25,!(%!+0=G$/&+!K(&#!>1.?0$!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!

j[[nUZjpaqVAZ[pmFnnD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGD[[jjFj[jODj[[nDjpnnoDdD!

pjD!! <2(/#(!HM!<2**$+!"M!W/;2*9(/J!<4M!$&!.1D!P%!.%&(F6EFZj>n[!.%&(=25,!52K%F*$801.&$+!&,>$!Z!/,&2J(%$+M!

/#$92J(%$+M!.%5!6EFZjl6EFjp!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[qUZmmamVAnYZmFjqD!

Page 208: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 195 of 237

ppD!! ;1.*J$!PLM!C201&2%!EM!L.(!g�M!$&!.1D!P!%2)$1!/1.++!23!.%&(F6EFZj>n[!.%&(=25($+A!>2&$%&!%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!)(.!

(%#(=(&(2%!23!6EFZjF6EFZj:uj!.%5!6EFjpF6EFjp:D!!UL$D!j[Z[UjarVArpYFnYD!52(AZ[DnZqZl9.=+DjDrDZp[oZD!

pnD!! C.%&$1,0+#(%!4M!g..J!4M!6%8215!7M!$&!.1D!:2*y&x!(%%.&$!1,9>#2/,&$+!.%5!y�!<!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(32*9!

>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjaqVAjjrjFqD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZoqjD!

prD!! "(11($&!WM!;2%*.5!;M!"$(8$+!WM!$&!.1D!C+2*(.+(+!&*(88$*$5!=,!&211F1(J$!*$/$>&2*!m!.82%(+&!(9(?0(925!(%!&#$!>*$+$%/$!23!5$*9.1!>1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!>*$/0*+2*+D!U5+;&3%50/)".D!j[[nUZn[aZjVAZnY[FrD!

52(AZ[DZ[[Zl.*/#5$*9DZn[DZjDZnY[D!

pqD!! :.G.%!eM!E.%8&*,!NPPD!"$%$*.1(R$5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!(9(?0(925!/*$.9!&*$.&9$%&!23!+0>$*3(/(.1!=.+.1!/$11!/.*/(%29.+D!?.*(&T_4&3%50/)".D!j[[qUpZaZVAZn[FZD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrF

jjp[Dj[[rD[ZYpoDdD!

pmD!! I(%&$*!gM!6)$*+$%!EM!4&$(%(/#$!<M!i*.8=.11$!iM!N2#.%+$%!;D!P15.*.F(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!F!+&05($+!23!

>+2*(.+(+!>.&($%&+D!65&c&3%50/)".D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZZZZl=G5DZpjpqD!

poD!! '$,.9.!PM!�.9.92&2!WM!<+0G((!iM!$&!.1D!W$/#.%(+9!23!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!(9(?0(925F(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!&#$!920+$A!.!*21$!32*!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!./&().&(2%!=,!(9(?0(925D!c&

3%50/)".D!j[ZnUnZajVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZZZZlZpnqFoZpoDZjpqmD!

pYD!! i*(+&$%+$%!WM!;#0!;sM!H$5,!@NM!-$159.%%!WM!7*$%%.%!-WD!S"+/.*f/)*"(&"-&A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5FU.4;/&

1AVWFU2&/(7&,)$&>%+%4)"5$DU!j[ZnAprnFpqjD!

n[D!! i09.*(!4M!72%%$&!W;M!'1)9.*!WgM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+(8%.1(%8!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!&*(88$*+!(%&$*1$0J(%FjnF5$>$%5$%&!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!,00#(*)9D!j[ZpUpYarVAoYYF

YZZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpDZ[D[[YD!

nZD!! I.%!7..*+$%!E"M!L(G=*.%5&+!;PM!:0+&$%=0*8!-M!$&!.1D!:$801.&(2%!23!6-e!*$+>2%+$!8$%$!./&()(&,!50*(%8!(%31(d(9.=!&*$.&9$%&!(%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!/1(%(/.1!*$+>2%+$!&2!&*$.&9$%&D!U5);5*)*$&

>%$&A;%5D!j[Z[UZjaZVA:ZZD!52(AZ[DZZoql.*jYZjD!

njD!! 6=2**.!WM!7$1&*�%!7M!7.+&(5.!"M!P80.+!WM!e2+!CD!6%31(d(9.=!.%5!.5.1(909.=F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$A!.!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&D!c&?5";($&?".*)*$D!j[ZZUrajVAZrmFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/*2#%+Dj[Z[DZZD[[ZD!

npD!! i2$%5$*+!W6M!W.*(G%(++$%!:NM!@$)$+.!6M!$&!.1D!A#0"5&V%+5"$*$&W/+)"5F,()%5.%#B*(FZE&,()%54./9&,(7#+%$&MZGGUR:&,()%5.%#B*(FZm:&/(7&!/)5*_&!%)/.."45")%*(/$%$:&/(7&35*=%$&,55%=%5$*L.%&?/5)*./8%&3%$)5#+)*"(&*(&

!#5*(%&U5);5*)*$N&>/)*"(/.%&-"5&?"0L*(/)*"(&A5%/)0%()&7#5*(8&U5);5*)*$OU!j[ZZAjpjYFpYD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&Dp[nZoD!

nnD!! W2+$!WM!i.%8!�M!:..=,!EM!6)$*+$%!EM!N2#.%+$%!;D!<e-vF!.%5!6EFZmPF9$5(.&$5!4Z[[Po!$d>*$++(2%!(+!*$801.&$5!=,!>po!WPCiD!T_4&3%50/)".D!j[ZpUjjamVAnmqFoZD!52(AZ[DZZZZl$d5DZjZomD!

nrD!! L2#%!;M!Q=$*F71z=.09!NEM!g..J!4M!$&!.1D!E.%8$*(%a%$8V!/2%)$%&(2%.1!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!>*250/$!6EFjp!&2!5*()$!>+2*(.&(/!>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[ajqVAZ[mjpFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZp[mrqYZZ[D!

nqD!! �2+#(J(!:M!i.=.+#(9.!iM!g2%5.!<M!$&!.1D!6EFjp!3*29!E.%8$*#.%+!/$11+!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!(9(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!5$*9.&(&(+!=,!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFZmPF>*250/(%8!y�!<!/$11+D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!j[ZnUZpnamVAZYZjFjZD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZnDYoD!

nmD!! 4K$$%$,!;WM!E2%$*8.%!:M!7.+5$2!4!.M!$&!.1D!6EFjm!9$5(.&$+!&#$!*$+>2%+$!&2!6-eFu!&#$*.>,!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!>.&($%&+!=,!(%#(=(&(%8!<#Zm!/$11+D!65/*(&6%;/=&,00#(D!j[ZZUjraqVAZZm[FoZD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD==(Dj[ZZD[pD[[mD!

noD!! �#.%8!EM!�0.%!4M!;#$%8!"M!"02!7D!<,>$!6!6-e!>*292&$+!6EFZ[!>*250/&(2%!3*29!<!/$11+!&2!+0>>*$++!<#Zm!/$11+!.%5!<#ZmF.++2/(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!(%31.99.&(2%D!W2++9.%!iEM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZZUqaZjVA$jonpjD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[jonpjD!

Page 209: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 196 of 237

nYD!! W.+09(!PM!<.9.2J(!4M!L.%8!6WM!QR.&2!iM!i290*2!iD!6:-Fol6;47C!.%5!6:-FZ!/22>$*.&()$1,!+&(901.&$!

920+$!6EFZj!>*292&$*!./&()(&,!(%!9./*2>#.8$+D!WT6M&S%))D!j[[jUrpZajVApnoFrpD!

r[D!! W.*0,.9.!4M!409(&.!iM!4#$%!gM!$&!.1D!65$%&(3(/.&(2%!23!6-e!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*FZ!=(%5(%8!+(&$!(%!6EFZj!>n[!

8$%$!>*292&$*D!c&,00#(".D!j[[pUZm[ajVAYYmFZ[[ZD!

rZD!! "2*($1,!4M!W211$!;M!e80,$%!WM!$&!.1D!6%&$*3$*2%!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*!p!(+!(%)21)$5!(%!<211F1(J$!*$/$>&2*!n!a<E:nVF!.%5!<E:pF(%50/$5!6EFZj>pr!8$%$!./&().&(2%D!6.""7D!j[[qUZ[mapVAZ[moFonD!52(AZ[DZZojl=1225F

j[[rF[qFjnZqD!

rjD!! 4#$(J#!4�M!i2=.,.+#(!<M!W.&+02J.!iM!Q%,(.#!N;M!C1$),!4HD!;#.*./&$*(R.&(2%!23!.%!(%&$*3$*2%F+&(901.&$5!*$+>2%+$!$1$9$%&!a64:HV!(%!&#$!61jp.!>*292&$*D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[ZZUjoqajVAZZmnFo[D!

52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/DWZZ[DZnmoonD!

rpD!! �#.2!OM!:2++!HNM!L.%8!�M!g2*K(&R!7gD!e3J=Z!(%#(=(&+!EC4F(%50/$5!6-eFu!.%5!6EFZj!>n[!>*250/&(2%!(%!9./*2>#.8$+!=,!5(+&(%/&!9$/#.%(+9+D!".11,.+!-M!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZjUmapVA$pjoZZD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[pjoZZD!

rnD!! 49(&#!4M!".=#.%%!NeM!g(88+!:M!$&!.1D!H%#.%/$5!(%&$*3$*2%!*$801.&2*,!3./&2*!p!=(%5(%8!&2!&#$!(%&$*1$0J(%Fjp>ZY!>*292&$*!/2**$1.&$+!K(&#!$%#.%/$5!(%&$*1$0J(%Fjp!$d>*$++(2%!(%!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!

U5);5*)*$&>;%#0D!j[ZjUqnarVAZq[ZFYD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl.*&DppnYnD!

rrD!! ;#2(!6FiM!E(!�M!Q#!HM!i(9!NM!�0%!;FQD!Q%/21,&(/!.5$%2)(*0+!$d>*$++(%8!6EFjp!.%5!>pr!$1(/(&+!6-eFyF!.%5!<e-FvF/2F>*250/(%8!<!/$11F9$5(.&$5!.%&(&092*!(990%(&,D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZpUoamVA$qmrZjD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[qmrZjD!

rqD!! -0G(+#(9.!4M!L.&.%.=$!gM!i.K.80/#(!WM!$&!.1D!6%)21)$9$%&!23!6EFZm-!)(.!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!6EFq!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!

U5+;&3%50/)".&>%$D!j[Z[Up[jamVAnYYFr[rD!52(AZ[DZ[[ml+[[n[pF[Z[FZ[ppFoD!

rmD!! g2&!PM!W(2++$/!CD!H33$/&+!23!(%&$*1$0J(%!a6EVFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!(%!#09.%!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!+,%2)(2/,&$+D!

U((&>;%#0&3*$D!j[ZZUm[arVAmjmFpjD!52(AZ[DZZpql.*5Dj[Z[DZnpmqoD!

roD!! C.*.52K+J.F"2*,/J.!PM!L2G&$/J.FE0J.+(J!HM!<*$31$*!NM!L2G/($/#2K+J.!7M!E./J(!NiM!W.+1(%+J(!4D!P++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!6EFZm-!8$%$!>21,92*>#(+9+!.%5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!.%5!+$)$*(&,!23!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!a:PVD!M+/(7&c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UmjajVAZpnFnZD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZpqrFp[opDj[Z[D[jnZZDdD!

rYD!! -0++!6NM!7$/J$*!;M!�.%8!�M!$&!.1D!72&#!6EFZj>m[!.%5!6EFjp!.*$!+,%&#$+(R$5!50*(%8!./&()$!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!.*$!52K%F*$801.&$5!=,!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F6EFZj!>n[!92%2/12%.1!.%&(=25,D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!

j[[qUZjaZVAYFZrD!

q[D!! L$5$=,$!4/#9(5&!H"M!E.*+$%!gEM!i*(+&$%+$%!eeM!$&!.1D!<gZm!/$11!(%50/&(2%!.%5!$33$/&+!23!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!=12/J.5$!(%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!/21(&(+D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!j[ZpUZYaoVAZrqmFmqD!

52(AZ[DZ[YmlW67D[=[Zp$pZojoq3.Z/D!

qZD!! 4$(5$*$*!NM!H1=$%!6M!@($8$19.%%!NM!$&!.1D!:21$!23!&#$!%2)$1!<#Zm!/,&2J(%$!6EFZm-!(%!(%31.99.&2*,!=2K$1!5(+$.+$!a67@VA!0>*$801.&$5!/212%(/!6EFZm-!$d>*$++(2%!(%!./&()$!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!&#$!6EZm-!

>Dg(+ZqZP*8!>21,92*>#(+9!(%!67@D!,(-./00&6"J%.&3*$D!j[[oUZnanVAnpmFnrD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl(=5Dj[ppYD!!

Page 210: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 197 of 237

XY+(S4K(%55%"2'M%('=(#"2'M#2'4<(G)(9C7\(#Q4<'=2(;@d(#=(%H:%*'&%<2#8(&4$%8(54*(:=4*'#='=(

'<(&'"%c((

b<'<2%<$%$(;<Q%=2'4<(45(94:'"#8(;&'g3'&4$('<(

BH:%*'&%<2#8(E=4*'#='=/8'J%(1J'<(;<58#&&#2'4<(F#<(

1J%K(7%=382=((

E,%5.!"*(%$ZMjM!:22+9.*(G%!I.%5$%=*20/J$ZMjM!4&$3.%!E($%$%J1.0+pM!e($J!4.%5$*+nM!;1.05$!E(=$*&ZMj!!

Z,(-./00/)*"(&>%$%/5+;&?%()%5:&@,6:&';%():&6%.8*#0&D3%4/5)0%()&6*"0%7*+/.&!".%+#./5&6*"."89:&<(*=%5$*)9&';%():&';%():&6%.8*#0&X3%4/5)0%()&"-&!".%+#./5&,00#("."89:&[%.0;".)f&?%()5%&-"5&,(-%+)*"(&>%$%/5+;:&65/#($+;J%*8:&

'%50/(9&YS/L"5/)"59&"-&'%(%&A;%5/49:&<(*=%5$*)9&';%():&!%5%.L%B%:&6%.8*#0&

&

!/(#$+5*4)&*(&45%4/5/)*"(&/$&L5*%-&5%4"5)O&

!F4<2*'G32'4<=A!E,%5.!"*(%$!>$*32*9$5!.11!$d>$*(9$%&.1!K2*J!.%5!K*2&$!&#$!9.%0+/*(>&D!@*D! :22+9.*(G%! HD! I.%5$%=*20/J$! 8.).8$5! 9(/$! K(&#! -6<;F5$d&*.%! 32*! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.++.,!(%!-(80*$!Z@D!!@*D! :22+9.*(G%! HD! I.%5$%=*20/J$! .%5! C*23D! @*D! ;1.05$! E(=$*&! +0>$*)(+$5! &#$! 5$+(8%! .%5!>$*32*9.%/$+!23!&#$!$d>$*(9$%&+D!!

! !

Page 211: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 198 of 237

!"#!"#!$#$% &!'#("&)!% )*% ")+&,-.%

!"!#$!"%&' !(' )*+),!")(-./' +0%,!.0!0F!"#$%!"#$%#$&'())(*#+$!!"#$%&'($)'%*+,%!

!G=2*#"2(

<2>(/.1! (9(?0(925!&*$.&9$%&! (+!0+$5!.+!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!>+2*(.+(+!925$1M!=0&!K$!K2%5$*$5!

K#$&#$*! (9(?0(925! #.+! +,+&$9(/! $33$/&+D! <2>(/.1! 6Ws! (%/*$.+$5! (%&$+&(%.1! 6-eu! .%5!

>$*9$.=(1(&,! 50$! &2! 2*.1! 0>&.J$! =,!9(/$D! C*$)$%&(%8! (%8$+&(2%! 50*(%8! &*$.&9$%&! K(&#! 6Ws!

8*$.&1,! *$50/$5! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+D! <#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! +#2K! &#.&! >*2&$/&()$! 9$.+0*$+! .*$!

%$$5$5!(3!(%&.J$!23!(9(?0(925!(+!&2!=$!*$+&*(/&$5!&2!&#$!+J(%D!

!

!

! !

Page 212: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 199 of 237

94:'"#88)(#::8'%$('&'g3'&4$('=(4*#88)('<Q%=2%$($3*'<Q(

%H:%*'&%<2=(#<$(#55%"2=(26%(Q32(

<*$.&9$%&!K(&#!P15.*.M!/2%&.(%(%8!r\!(9(?0(925!a6WsVM! (+!0+$5!.+!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!90*(%$!

925$1!23!+J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! &2!9(9(/! &#$!>+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! (%!>.&($%&+D! 6&+!.>>1(/.&(2%!2%! &#$!

=./J!+J(%!32*!+$)$*.1!/2%+$/0&()$!5.,+!(%50/$+!/#.%8$+!&#.&!(%/105$!(%/*$.+$5!1$)$1+!23!<e-M!

6EFZm! .%5! 6EFjp! .%5! .=$**.%&! $d>*$++(2%! 23! 5(33$*$%&(.&(2%! 9.*J$*+DZMj! <#$! *21$! 23! &,>$! 6!

6%&$*3$*2%+!(%!#09.%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!6WsF(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!1$+(2%+!#.+!=$$%!5$=.&$5A!

+29$!+&05($+!+088$+&$5!.%!(%(&(.&(%8!*21$!32*!&,>$!6!6-e+!K#$*$.+!2&#$*+!320%5!%2!$)(5$%/$!32*!

&#.&Dpwm!6%!2*5$*!&2!12/.&$!&#$!+20*/$!23!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%U!K$!.>>1($5!6Ws!&2!&#$!+#.)$5!

+J(%!23!&*.%+8$%(/!9(/$!/.**,(%8!.!10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!8$%$!/2%&*211$5!=,!&#$!6-eu!>*292&$*D!

P3&$*!&*$.&(%8!9(/$!K(&#!6WsM!K$!2=+$*)$5!.!/1$.*!+(8%.1!23!6-euF.++2/(.&$5!10/(3$*.+$!./&()(&,!

(%!&#$!.=529$%!a-(80*$!ZPM!1$3&!(9.8$+VD!<2!(%)$+&(8.&$!&#$!2*(8(%!23!&#(+!+(8%.1M!2*8.%+!K$*$!

(+21.&$5!.%5!(9.8$5!32*!10/(3$*.+$!./&()(&,D!40*>*(+(%81,M!K$!5$&$/&$5!.!+&*2%8!10/(3$*.+$!+(8%.1!

(%! &#$! (%&$+&(%$!=0&!%2&! (%! &#$! +J(%M! 1()$*M! 1,9>#!%25$+!.%5! +>1$$%! a-(80*$!ZPM! *(8#&! (9.8$VD!

P55(&(2%.11,M! 6-eu! 1$)$1+! K$*$! (%/*$.+$5! (%! +$*09! .%5! .! &,>(/.1! (%&$*3$*2%F+&(901.&$5!

*$+>2%+$!$1$9$%&+!a64:HV!+(8%.&0*$M!+0/#!.+!?_+.C!.%5!<$4ZRM!K.+!5$&$/&$5!(%!&#$!80&!a-(80*$!

Z7! .%5!;VD! <*$.&9$%&!K(&#! )$#(/1$! 5(5! %2&! (%50/$! &#$+$! 8$%$+M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! &#$+$! $33$/&+!

K$*$!&*(88$*$5!+21$1,!=,!6Ws!a5.&.!%2&!+#2K%VD!!

L$!.1+2!2=+$*)$5!9./*2+/2>(/!/#.%8$+! (%! &#$! (%&$+&(%$! (%5(/.&()$! 32*!80&! (%31.99.&(2%A! &#$!

80&! K.+! +K211$%! .%5! 3(11$5! K(&#! 310(5D! <2! (%)$+&(8.&$! K#$&#$*! &#(+! K.+! 1(%J$5! &2! 12++! 23!

(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*!(%&$8*(&,M!K$!0+$5!n!J@.!-6<;F5$d&*.%!&2!.++$++!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,D!6Ws!

(%50/$5! *.>(5! 12++! 23! &#$! (%&$+&(%.1! =.**($*! (%&$8*(&,M! .+! $)(5$%/$5! =,! (%/*$.+$5! 1$.J.8$! 23!

(%&$+&(%.1!-6<;F5$d&*.%! (%&2! &#$!=1225!/29>.*$5!&2!/2%&*21!9(/$! &*$.&$5!K(&#!)$#(/1$!/*$.9!

a-(80*$!Z@VD!4$*09!1$)$1+!23!(%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!a6EF-P7CV!K$*$!/29>.*.=1$M!

(%5(/.&(%8!&#.&!6Ws!5(5!%2&!(%50/$!*$1$.+$!23!/$1101.*!/2%&$%&!a-(80*$!ZHVD!!

Page 213: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 200 of 237

P!3$K!>.>$*+!*$>2*&!2%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!5$*9.&2128(/.1!/2%5(&(2%+!K#2!+033$*$5!3*29!1$.J,!80&ow

ZZD! W2*$2)$*M! +$)$*.1! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+! +#2K$5! .=%2*9.1(&($+! (%! &#$! +9.11! (%&$+&(%$M! .%5!

>.&($%&+!K(&#!+$)$*$!>+2*(.+(+!$d#(=(&$5!.!+9.11$*!(%&$+&(%.1!+0*3./$!.*$.ZjMZpD!P55(&(2%.11,M!

!

?'Q3*%(-D(1J'</#::8'%$(;@d('<$3"%=(;?>f('<(26%(Q32(#<$(#55%"2=(Q32('<2%Q*'2)(

a!V!,(&=*="!.%5!%_&=*="!(9.8(%8!23!6-euF10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$!=$32*$!.%5!.3&$*!6Ws!&*$.&9$%&D!aRV!@$&$/&(2%!23!6-eu!=,!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!(%!+$*09!=$32*$!.%5!.3&$*!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!6WsD!aFV!?:<FC;:!.%.1,+(+!23! (%&$+&(%.1!:eP!.3&$*! 6Ws! 32*!?_+.C! .%5!<$4ZRD!7.*+! *$>*$+$%&! *$1.&()$!$d>*$++(2%! 1$)$1+D!aIV! :$1.&()$! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,M! 5$&$*9(%$5! )(.! 3102*$+/$%/$! 9$.+0*$9$%&! (%! &#$! >1.+9.! j! #!.3&$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!)$#(/1$!/*$.9!PIP!a=1./J!=.*V!2*!6Ws!a8*$,!=.*VM!32112K(%8!2*.1!.59(%(+&*.&(2%!23!-6<;F5$d&*.%D!aBV!71225!1$)$1+!23!6EF-P7C!9$.+0*$5!j!#!.3&$*!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!)$#(/1$!/*$.9!)$#(/1$!/*$.9!a=1./J!=.*V!2*!6Ws!a8*$,!=.*VD!7.*+!*$>*$+$%&!9$.%!¢!4@D!

!

(%/*$.+(%8! $)(5$%/$! +088$+&+! .! +&*2%8! 1(%J! =$&K$$%! (%31.99.&2*,! =2K$1! 5(+$.+$! .%5!

>+2*(.+(+ZnMZrM! (%5(/.&(%8!.!*21$!32*!(%&$+&(%.1!#$.1&#!(%!/#*2%(/!+J(%!/2%5(&(2%+D!P+!K$!%2&(/$5!

&#.&! 6WsF&*$.&$5!9(/$! K$*$! 1(/J(%8! &#$(*! =./J+M! K$! (%)$+&(8.&$5! K#$&#$*! (%8$+&(2%! 23! 6Ws!

!"#$%&%'()*+%

,-./*01 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%2(*+01% % %%34%565(% %

% %%

7%'()*+%

!"

#"

!"#$%8%'()*+%

0 2 40

200

400

600

800

Time after IMQ (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of C

xcl9

*

0 2 40

200

400

600

800

Time after IMQ (hours)

Rel

ativ

e ex

pres

sion

of U

sp18

**

$"

0 2 20

100

200

300

400

500

Time after topical application (hours)

[IL-F

AB

P] (

pg/m

l)

0 2 20

2

4

6

Time after topical application (hours)

Rel

ativ

e in

test

inal

per

mea

bilit

y

*

ns*

Control or AVAIMQ

0 30

50

100

150

200

Time after IMQ (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

****

%" &"

Page 214: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 201 of 237

.33$/&$5!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!&2>(/.11,!(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!9(/$D!L$!0+$5!H1(R.=$&#.%!/211.*+!aH;V!

&2!>*$)$%&!9(/$!3*29!1(/J(%8!&#$(*!=./J!+J(%M!0+(%8!9(/$!K(&#20&!.!/211.*!.+!/2%&*21D!!

!

!

?'Q3*%( +D( B8'a#G%26#<( "488#*=( _BF=`( :*%M%<2( 5388( G84K<( ;@d/'<$3"%$( :=4*'#='54*&( =J'<(

'<58#&&#2'4<(#<$(;?>f('<(=%*3&(

W(/$!K$*$!&*$.&$5!K(&#!6Ws!.%5!+/2*$5!32*!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+!.+!5$+/*(=$5!>*$)(20+1,ZD!Q%$!8*20>!K2*$!H;+M!>*$)$%&(%8!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!6WsD!a!V!H*,&#$9.M!+/.1(%8M!&#(/J$%(%8!.%5!CP46!K$*$!+/2*$5!.+!5$+/*(=$5!

>*$)(20+1,! a+/2*$+! [!nVD! aRV! '+(%8! E09(%$d! &$/#%2128,M! 6-eu! K.+! 9$.+0*$5! p! #! .3&$*! 6Ws! (%! 9(/$!K(&#20&!H;!a=1./J!=.*+V!.%5!K(&#!H;+!a8*$,!=.*+VD!aFV!4>1$%29$8.1,!(+!+#2K%!.+!+>1$$%!&2!=25,!K$(8#&!*.&(2D!71./J!/0*)$l=.*A!K(&#20&!H;U!8*$,!/0*)$l=.*A!K(&#!H;D!T?N&T.*f/L%);/(&+"../5!

!

W(/$!K$.*(%8!H;+!+#2K$5!1$++!6WsF(%50/$5!$*,&#$9.!.%5!&#(/J$%(%8!.+!+#2K%!(%!-(80*$!jPD!

<#$! &2&.1! +/2*$! 23! $*,&#$9.M! +/.1(%8! .%5! &#(/J$%(%8! +/2*$+M! 5(+>1.,$5! #$*$! .+! .! 925(3($5!

C+2*(.+(+! P*$.! 4$%+(&()(&,! 6%5$d! aCP46VM! K.+! .1+2! +(8%(3(/.%&1,! 12K$*! (%! 9(/$! K(&#! H;+!

/29>.*$5! &2! &#$!/2%&*21!8*20>D!-0*&#$*92*$M! 6WsF(%50/$5! (%/*$.+$! (%!/(*/01.&(%8! 6-eu!K.+!

>*$)$%&$5!=,!0+(%8!H1(R.=$&#.%!/211.*+M!+088$+&(%8!&#.&!6-eu!(%!+$*09!K.+!5$*()$5!3*29!6WsF

&*(88$*$5!80&!a-(80*$!j7VD!P55(&(2%.11,M!+>1$%29$8.1,!K.+!1$++!+$)$*$!(%!9(/$!K$.*(%8!/211.*+!

&#.%! (%! 9(/$! &#.&! /2015! (%8$+&! 6Ws! 2*.11,! a-(80*$! j;VD! <#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! (%5(/.&$! .!

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

1

2

3

4

Time after IMQ (days)

Sco

re

Scaling

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

1

2

3

4

Time after IMQ (days)

Sco

re

Erythema

ECNo EC

****

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

1

2

3

4

Time after IMQ (days)

Sco

re

Thickening

***

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

2

4

6

8

10

12

Time after IMQ (days)

Sco

re

PASI

***

No IMQ IMQ + no EC IMQ + EC0.000

0.005

0.010

0.015

Day 7

Re

lativ

e w

eig

ht s

ple

en

/bo

dy

Splenomegaly

****

*

**

!"

#" $"

0 3 0 30

50

100

150

200

Time after IMQ (hours)

[IFN!

] (pg

/ml)

********

No ECEC

Page 215: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 202 of 237

>*29(%$%&!1(%J!=$&K$$%!&#$!#$.1&#!+&.&0+!23!&#$!(%&$+&(%$!.%5!&#$!+J(%D!P1&#208#!(&!(+!+&(11!%2&!

/1$.*!#2K!+J(%!.%5!80&!(%&$*./&MZqwZo!20*!2=+$*).&(2%+!(%5(/.&$!&#.&!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!6Ws!

K(&#20&!>*2&$/&(2%!*$+01&+!(%!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!6WsM!1$.5(%8!&2!6-eu!>*250/&(2%!(%!&#$!80&!.%5!&2!

80&!>$*9$.=(1(&,M!K#(/#!.33$/&+!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!+J(%!1$+(2%+D!!

L$! *$/299$%5! &#.&! /.0&(2%!90+&!=$! &.J$%!K#$%! 6Ws! (+!0+$5! &2>(/.11,! .+! .%! $d>$*(9$%&.1!

925$1!32*!>+2*(.+(+M!=,!0+(%8!H1(R.=$&#.%!/211.*+!&2!>*$)$%&!9(/$!3*29!(%8$+&(%8!6Ws!(3!2%$!(+!

+21$1,!(%&$*$+&$5!(%!&#$!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,+!(%!&#$!+J(%D!g2K$)$*M!2%$!/.%!.1+2!.*80$!&#.&!&#$!

.55(&(2%.1! $33$/&+! 2%! &#$! 80&! *$>*$+$%&! .! 92*$! #21(+&(/! 925$1! 23! >+2*(.+(+! &#.&! *$31$/&+! &#$!

+,+&$9(/! +,9>&29+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! >+2*(.+(+! +0/#! .+! 1$.J,! 80&D!

<2!20*!J%2K1$58$M!%2!2&#$*!>+2*(.+(+!925$1!.&&$9>&+!&2!9(9(/!=2&#!&#$!&,>(/.1!+J(%! 1$+(2%+!

.%5! &#$! +,+&$9(/! +,9>&29+! +0/#! .+! (%/*$.+$5! (%&$+&(%.1! >$*9$.=(1(&,! .%5! /292*=(5(&($+M!

(%/105(%8! /.*5(2).+/01.*! 5(+$.+$+D! 6%! &#(+! *$+>$/&M! 6Ws!9(8#&! *$>*$+$%&! .! =$&&$*!925$1! .%5!

#$%/$!>*2)(5$!92*$!(%32*9.&(2%!.=20&!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!W2*$2)$*M!&#$+$!*$+01&+!

.1+2! *.(+$! /2%/$*%! .=20&! 2&#$*! >*250/&+! .>>1($5! &2>(/.11,! (%!920+$!925$1+! (3! &#$!9(/$! /.%!

(%8$+&! &#$! >*250/&! .+! K$11M! +0/#! .+! <CP! .%5! ./$&2%$M! .%5! #2K! &#$! 80&! .33$/&+! &#$! +J(%!

>#$%2&,>$D!

@#2%*'#8=(#<$(&%264$=(

@'"%(

W.1$! ;rm7EqlN! 9(/$! K$*$! >0*/#.+$5! 3*29! N.%)($*! aE$! "$%$+&F4&! 6+1$M! -*.%/$V! .%5! 6-euF

10/(3$*.+$! *$>2*&$*! 9(/$! K$*$! J(%51,! >*2)(5$5! =,! @*D! 4D! E($%$%J1.0+! a7*.0%+/#K$(8M!

"$*9.%,VD! P11! .%(9.1+! K$*$! 9.(%&.(%$5! (%! /2%)$%&(2%.1! &$9>$*.&0*$F/2%&*211$5M! .(*F

/2%5(&(2%$5!.%(9.1!#20+$+!K(&#!.!1(8#&l5.*J!/,/1$!23!ZnlZ[!#!.%5!*$/$()$5!3225!.%5!K.&$*!/7&

.*L*)#0D!Hd>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!>$*32*9$5!2%!9(/$!.8$5!o!Zj!K$$J+D!P11!.%(9.1!$d>$*(9$%&+!K$*$!

.>>*2)$5!=,!&#$!(%+&(&0&(2%.1!$&#(/+!/299(&&$$!32*!.%(9.1!K$13.*$!23!&#$!-./01&,!23!4/($%/$+M!

"#$%&!'%()$*+(&,M!7$18(09!.%5!32112K$5!&#$!H0*2>$.%!80(5$1(%$+D!

Page 216: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 203 of 237

%&+M5M0('&#Q'<Q(#<$(;@d/'<$3"%$(:=4*'#='54*&(=J'<('<58#&&#2'4<(#<$(="4*'<Q(45(

:=4*'#2'"(=)&:24&=(

-2*! *(&=*="& (9.8(%8M!9(/$!K$*$! +$5.&$5!K(&#! (+2310*.%$! .%5! (9.8$5! 32*! +$)$*.1! &(9$! >2(%&+!

.3&$*!/#.11$%8$!K(&#! 6WsD!-2*!+/2*(%8!$d>$*(9$%&+M!=./J!+J(%!K.+!+#.)$5!.%5!j!5.,+! 1.&$*!.!

5.(1,!52+$!23!qjDr!98!23!P15.*.!ar\!6Ws!/*$.9U!pW!C#.*9./$0&(/.1+V!K.+!.>>1($5!2%!&#$!=./J!

32*! m! /2%+$/0&()$! 5.,+D! H1(R.=$&#.%! /211.*+! aH;+V!K$*$! >0*/#.+$5! 3*29!g.*).*5! P>>.*.&0+!

a-*.%/$VD! W(/$! K$*$! +/2*$5! 5.(1,! =.+$5! 2%! .! 925(3($5! CP46! +/2*$! +,+&$9! .+! 5$+/*(=$5!

>*$)(20+1,DZ!6%!=*($3M!+$)$*(&,!23!>+2*(.+(+!K.+!.++$++$5!=,!=1(%51,!+/2*(%8!$*,&#$9.!a*$5%$++!

23!&#$!+J(%V!.%5!+/.1(%8!2%!.!+/.1$!3*29![!&2!n!a[M!%2%$U!ZM!+1(8#&U!jA!925$*.&$U!pA!9.*J$5U!nA!

)$*,!9.*J$5VD!!

I%2%"2'4<(45(?;9F/$%H2*#<N(;C/?!RE(#<$(;?>f(

P&! &#$! (%5(/.&$5! &(9$!>2(%&+!.3&$*! 6Ws!2*! /2%&*21! &*$.&9$%&M!=1225!K.+! /211$/&$5!=,! /.*5(./!

>0%/&0*$!.%5!.112K$5!&2!/12&!.&!n¤;!2)$*%(8#&D!4$*09!K.+!/211$/&$5!.3&$*!/$%&*(308.&(2%!.%5!

+&2*$5!.&!!o[¤;!0%&(1!.++.,$5D!<2!+&05,!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,M!9(/$!K$*$!8.).8$5!K(&#!r!98!

-6<;F5$d&*.%!5(++21)$5!(%!C74!.%5!&*$.&$5!K(&#!&2>(/.1!6Ws!j!#!1.&$*D!71225!K.+!/211$/&$5!(%!

H@<PF/2.&$5! &0=$+! a4.*+&$5&V! j! #! .3&$*! 6Ws! .%5! >1.+9.! K.+! >*$>.*$5D! E$.J.8$! 23! -6<;F

5$d&*.%!(%&2!&#$!=1225!+&*$.9!K.+!5$&$*9(%$5!=,!9$.+0*(%8!>1.+9.!3102*$+/$%/$!a¥$dl¥$9!�!

noolrj[!%9VD!I.10$+!K$*$!%2*9.1(R$5!&2!&#$!9$.%!).10$D!!

6EF-P7C! .%5! 6-eu!K$*$! .++$++$5!=,!HE64P! a;0+.=(2!7(2&$/#V! .%5!C*2/.*&.C1$d!W20+$!=$&.!

4(9>1$d!a$7(2+/($%/$VM!*$+>$/&()$1,M!.//2*5(%8!&2!&#$!9.%03./&0*$*+c!(%+&*0/&(2%+D!

79/gEF7(

6%&$+&(%.1!+.9>1$+!K$*$!/211$/&$5!(%!:eP!E.&$*!as(.8$%VD!:eP!K.+! (+21.&$5!K(&#!&#$!:e$.+,!

W(%(! i(&! as(.8$%V! .//2*5(%8! &2! &#$! 9.%03./&0*$*�+! (%+&*0/&(2%+D! :eP! /2%/$%&*.&(2%! K.+!

9$.+0*$5!K(&#! &#$!e.%25*2>Z[[[! a<#$*92! 4/($%&(3(/VM! .%5! Z! ¡8!:eP!K.+! 0+$5! &2! >*$>.*$!

/@eP! K(&#! 40>$*4/*(>&! 66! a6%)(&*28$%VD! s0.%&(&.&()$! *$.1F&(9$! C;:! K.+! >$*32*9$5! 0+(%8!

4$%+(-.+&<W! 4,=*! eQF:QO! i(&! a7(21(%$V! .%5! &#$! E(8#&;,/1$*! no[! a:2/#$VD! Hd>*$++(2%! 1$)$1+!

K$*$! %2*9.1(R$5! &2! &#$! $d>*$++(2%! 23! &#$! &K2! 92+&! +&.=1$! *$3$*$%/$! 8$%$+M! K#(/#! K$*$!

Page 217: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 204 of 237

5$&$*9(%$5! 32*! &#$! $d>$*(9$%&.1! /2%5(&(2%! 0+(%8! 8$e2*9! a?7.+$M! 7(28.R$11$VD!>4.! .%5!<L+!

K$*$!+$1$/&$5!.+!&#$!92+&!+&.=1$!8$%$+D!!

12#2'=2'"#8(#<#8)='=(

:$+01&+! a9$.%!¢! 4@V!K$*$! /29>.*$5! =,! .! &K2F&.(1$5! 4&05$%&�+! &! &$+&D! C! ).10$+! ¦! [D[r!K$*$!

/2%+(5$*$5!+(8%(3(/.%&D!�!>!¦![D[rM!��!>!¦![D[ZM!���!>!¦![D[[ZM!����!>!¦![D[[[ZD!

!"J<4K8%$Q&%<2=(<#(+!K2*J!K.+! 30%5$5!=,! &#$!P8$%/,! 32*! 6%%2).&(2%!=,! 4/($%/$! .%5!<$/#%2128,! a6L<VM! &#$!

:$+$.*/#! -20%5.&(2%! -1.%5$*+! a-LQ! I1..%5$*$%V! .%5! &#$! 6%&$*0%()$*+(&,! P&&*./&(2%! C21$+!

C*28*.9! 23! &#$! 7$18(.%! 4/($%/$! C21(/,! a6'PCVD! L$! K2015! 1(J$! &2! &#.%J! P9(%! 7*$5.%! 32*!

9.%0+/*(>&!$5(&(%8D!

! (

Page 218: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 205 of 237

7%5%*%<"%=((

ZD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!W20*(&+!4M!I2$*9.%!N4!.M!$&!.1D!69(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$!(+!9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaYVAropqFnrD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[jYYYD!

jD!! g.!gFEM!L.%8!gM!C(+(&J0%!CM!$&!.1D!6EFZm!5*()$+!>+2*(.&(/!(%31.99.&(2%!)(.!5(+&(%/&M!&.*8$&!/$11F+>$/(3(/!

9$/#.%(+9+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZnAZFZ[D!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZn[[rZpZZZD!

pD!! e$+&1$!-QM!;2%*.5!;M!<0%Fi,(!PM!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!>*$5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!&#*208#!

(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[jaZVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[r[r[[D!

nD!! L.1&$*!PM!4/#�3$*!WM!;$//2%(!IM!$&!.1D!P15.*.!./&().&$+!<E:mF(%5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!5$3$%/$D!V/)&?"00#(D!j[ZpUnAZrq[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/299+jrqqD!

rD!! L2#%!;M!Q=$*F71z=.09!NEM!g..J!4M!$&!.1D!E.%8$*(%a%$8V!/2%)$%&(2%.1!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!>*250/$!6EFjp!&2!5*()$!>+2*(.&(/!>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[ajqVAZ[mjpFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZp[mrqYZZ[D!

qD!! '$,.9.!PM!�.9.92&2!WM!<+0G((!iM!$&!.1D!W$/#.%(+9!23!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!(9(?0(925F(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!&#$!920+$A!.!*21$!32*!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11!./&().&(2%!=,!(9(?0(925D!c&

3%50/)".D!j[ZnUnZajVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZZZZlZpnqFoZpoDZjpqmD!

mD!! "*(%$!EM!@$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!E(=$*&!;[email protected]!6%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!69(?0(925F

6%50/$5!C+2*(.+(+!H%#.%/$+!;2%&*21!23!&#$!@(+$.+$D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZrD!

oD!! g.9(1&2%!6M!-.(**(+!"WM!:2&#K$11!NM!;0%1(33$!LNM!@(d2%!W-M!Pd2%!P<:D!49.11!6%&$+&(%.1!C$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!

@$*9.&2128(/.1!@(+$.+$D!p&c&!%7D!ZYorUrqapFnVArrYFrqmD!

YD!! g09=$*&!CM!7(5$&!PM!<*$33$1!CM!@*2=./#$33!;M!P8./#$!CD!6%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+D!c&

3%50/)".&M+*D!ZYYZUjanVApjnFqD!

Z[D!! -.+.%2!PD!E$.J,!80&!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!?.*(&>%=&U..%589&,00#(".D!j[ZjUnjaZVAmZFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Zj[ZqF[ZZFojYZFdD!

ZZD!! -.+.%2!PM!4#$.F@2%2#0$!<D!W$/#.%(+9+!23!5(+$.+$A!&#$!*21$!23!(%&$+&(%.1!=.**($*!30%/&(2%!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!8.+&*2(%&$+&(%.1!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!V/)&?.*(&\5/+)&'/$)5"%()%5".&[%4/)".D!

j[[rUjaYVAnZqFjjD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/>8.+&#$>[jrYD!

ZjD!! W/9(11(%!@EM!:(/#.*5+!@"M!W$(%!HPM!e$1+2%!;@D!4,+&$9(/!.+>$/&+!23!>+2*(.+(+A!P%!(%&$8*.&()$!925$1!=.+$5!

2%!(%&$+&(%.1!$&(2128,D!,()%85&!%7D!j[[[UjajFpVAZ[rFZZpD!52(AZ[DZ[Zql4Z[YqFjZY[a[[V[[[Z[FOD!

ZpD!! 7.**,!:HM!4.192%!C:M!:$.5!.!HM!L.*(%!:CD!W0/2+.1!.*/#(&$/&0*$!23!&#$!+9.11!=2K$1!(%!/.+$+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!

'#)D!ZYmZUZjaZZVAompFmD!

ZnD!! e.G.*(.%!@NM!"2&&1($=!P7D!;2%%$/&(2%+!=$&K$$%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$D!c&U0&U+/7&3%50/)".D!

j[[pUnoaqVAo[rFjZU!?0(R!ojjFnD!52(AZ[DZ[qml9G5Dj[[pDrn[D!

ZrD!! 4J*2R.!eM!C*2($&&(!6M!C.9>$%.!:M!$&!.1D!;2**$1.&(2%+!=$&K$$%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!(%31.99.&2*,!=2K$1!5(+$.+$+D!

6*"0%7&>%$&,()D!j[ZpUj[ZpAYopY[jD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[ZplYopY[jD!

ZqD!! P*/J!CM!g.%5G(+J(!7M!g.8$%!HM!$&!.1D!6+!&#$*$!.!`80&F=*.(%F+J(%!.d(+_S!T_4&3%50/)".D!j[Z[UZYarVAn[ZFrD!

52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZq[[F[qjrDj[[YD[Z[q[DdD!

ZmD!! 72K$!LCM!E28.%!P;D!P/%$!)018.*(+M!>*2=(2&(/+!.%5!&#$!80&F=*.(%F+J(%!.d(+!F!=./J!&2!&#$!30&0*$S!'#)&

\/);"8D!j[ZZUpaZVAZD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZmrmFnmnYFpFZD!

Page 219: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 206 of 237

ZoD!! 4..*(.1#2Fi$*$!'D!<#$!80&F+J(%!.d(+D!c&\%7*/)5&'/$)5"%()%5".&V#)5D!j[[nUpY!40>>1!paN0%$VA4mpnFrD!!

!

! (

Page 220: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 207 of 237

!"#$%&'()*(F!!"#$%##"&'!

!

<e-!(+!.!>2&$%&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$M!K(&#!+&*2%8!.%&(F&092*.1!$33$/&+D!6&+!0+$!(%!/.%/$*!

&*$.&9$%&!(+!#2K$)$*!#.9>$*$5!=,!(&+!&2d(/(&,D!6&+!*21$!(%!./0&$!.%5!/#*2%(/!(%31.99.&(2%!#.+!

=$$%! /1$.*1,! 5$92%+&*.&$5! .%5! 32*9$5! &#$! *.&(2%.1$! &2! =12/J! <e-! (%! ).*(20+! 5(+$.+$+D! 6%!

+$>+(+! .%5! 46:4! >.&($%&+M! .%&(F<e-! &#$*.>($+! K$*$! %2&! +0//$++301M! K#$*$.+! (&! =$%$3(&$5!

>.&($%&+!K(&#!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!+0/#!.+!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+M!.%J,12+(%8!

+>2%5,1(&(+! .%5! >+2*(.+(+DZ! 4(9(1.*1,M! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! (990%292501.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+! .%5!

9$5(.&$! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! $33$/&+DjMp! 6&! #.+! =$$%! >*2>2+$5! &2! =12/J! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%!

5(+$.+$+!.+!K$11D!P1&#208#!g0,+!$&!.1D!>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!9$5(.&$!+29$!<e-F

(%50/$5! $)$%&+! *(&=*="Mn!92+&! *$>2*&+! 23! &#$! (%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!<e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!#.)$!

=$$%!+&05($5!*(&=*)5"DrMq!<#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!+$)$*.1!(%31.99.&2*,!

+(&0.&(2%+!32*9$5!&#$!=.+(+!23!&#(+!52/&2*.1!&#$+(+D!L$!.(9$5!&2!0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!*$1$).%/$!23!

<e-F(%50/$5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! &#(+! &2d(/(&,! 925$1! .+! K$11! .+! &#$! >2++(=1$! (%&$*>1.,! =$&K$$%!

<e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! (%! 2&#$*! 1$&#.1! 925$1+! +0/#! .+! EC4! .%5! ;ECD! e$d&! &2! <e-F

9$5(.&$5! &2d(/(&,! 925$1+M! K$! K$*$! (%&$*$+&$5! (%! 1$++! ./0&$! 925$1+! +0/#! .+! .0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+D!7.+$5!2%!&#$(*!9$5(.&2*,!*21$!(%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%!1$+(2%+!

.+!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&!23!.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&+!.%5!&,>$!6!6-eF=.+$5!&#$*.>($+!32*!901&(>1$!

+/1$*2+(+! .%5! )(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+MmwZZ! K$! K$*$! (%&$*$+&$5! (%! &#$! >2&$%&(.1! (%&$*./&(2%! =$&K$$%!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!<#$!/#2(/$!23!(9(?0(925!a6WsV!.+!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!>+2*(.+(+!

925$1!K.+!=.+$5!2%!(&+!/2%)$%($%&!.>>1(/.&(2%!.%5!(%5$>$%5$%/$!2%!90*(%$!=./J8*20%5DZjMZp!!

<#$!*$+01&+!2=&.(%$5!50*(%8!&#(+!C#@!.%5!&#$(*!(%&$*>*$&.&(2%!K(11!=$!5(+/0++$5!=$12KD!

Page 221: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 208 of 237

-(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%(*48%(45(2):%(;(;?>=('<(9>?/'<$3"%$(

=64"J(

<e-!(+!.!&2d(/!/,&2J(%$M!K#(/#!/.%!=$!1$&#.1!(%!$d/$++()$!.920%&+D!P1&#208#!&#$!0+$!23!<e-!.+!.!

925$1! 32*! +$>+(+! (+! %2&! $%&(*$1,! /2**$/&M! .59(%(+&*.&(2%! 23! #(8#! 52+$+! 23! <e-! *$+01&+! (%!

#,>2&$%+(2%M! #,>2&#$*9(.M! +,+&$9(/! (%31.99.&(2%! K(&#! 901&(>1$! 2*8.%! 3.(10*$M! +#2/JM! .%5!

01&(9.&$1,!*$+01&(%8!(%&2!5$.&#DZn!<#(+!.112K+!0+!&2!5(++$/&!+29$!/2992%!+(8%.1(%8!>.&#K.,+!

K(&#!#09.%!46:4!.%5!+$>+(+M!.%5!(5$%&(3,!&#$!5$1$&$*(20+!$)$%&+!.%5!>2&$%&(.1!5*08!&.*8$&+!2*!

5(.8%2+&(/!9.*J$*+D!!

Q0*!8*20>!#.+!.1*$.5,!(5$%&(3($5!6-eP:Z!.+!.%!(9>2*&.%&!9$5(.&2*!23!<e-F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,!.+!

6-eP:Z! iQ! 9(/$! +#2K$5! *$+(+&.%/$! (%! &#(+! 925$1Dn! L$! 30*&#$*! (%)$+&(8.&$5! &#$! (%50/&(2%!

>.&&$*%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!0+(%8!10/(3$*.+$!*$>2*&$*!9(/$M!HE64P!.%5!?:<FC;:!&$/#%(?0$+D!!

,(! .%5! %_& =*="! (9.8(%8! *$)$.1$5! &#.&! 1()$*! .%5! (%&$+&(%$! K$*$! 9.(%1,! >*250/(%8! 6-eu! (%!

*$+>2%+$!&2!<e-D!4(9(1.*1,M!WdjM!.%!64:H!8$%$!>*250/&M!(%50/&(2%!K.+!&#$!#(8#$+&!(%!&#$!1()$*!

.%5!(%&$+&(%$D!L(&#!&#$!0+$!23!?:<FC;:M!K$!K$*$!.=1$!&2!5$&$/&!&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!,-(/.4;/!8$%$+!

.+!K$11D!P+!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!#.5!1$++!PE<!.%5!P4<!1$)$1+!(%!&#$(*!/(*/01.&(2%Mn!K$!#,>2&#$+(R$5!

&#.&!+>$/(3(/!.=1.&(2%!23! 6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8! (%!#$>.&2/,&$+!/2015!/2%3$*!*$+(+&.%/$! &2!<e-D!<2!

20*! +0*>*(+$M! %2! >*2&$/&(2%! K.+! 2=+$*)$5! (%! 6-eP:ZP1=FiQ! 9(/$D! L$! 5(5! %2&! *01$! 20&! &#.&!

(%/29>1$&$! $d/(+(2%! 23! ;*$! (%! &#$! 1()$*!9.,! #.)$! 1$3&! +0=+&.%&(.1! 6-eP:Z! $d>*$++(2%! (%&./&D!

g2K$)$*M!(%!>.*.11$1!&2!20*!(%)$+&(8.&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+M!20*!1.=!*$>2*&$5!&#.&!&#$!$33$/&!23!<e-!

2%! &#$!80&!K.+! &#$!9.(%!5*()(%8! 32*/$!23! 1$&#.1(&,DZrMZq!<#$!$33$/&!23!<e-!2%! &#$!80&! (%/105$+!

12++!23!(%&$+&(%.1!(%&$8*(&,!1$.5(%8!&2!(%/*$.+$5!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.%5!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$D!L$!320%5!

&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!9$5(.&$!<e-F(%50/$5!(%G0*,M!=0&!(+!%2&!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,D!

P1&#208#!20*!(%(&(.1!(5$.!&2!0+$!/2%5(&(2%.1!90&.%&!9(/$!K#$*$!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!.=*28.&$5!

+>$/(3(/.11,!(%!&#$!$>(&#$1(.1!1(%(%8!23!&#$!80&Zm!#.+!%2&!/29$!(%&2!*$.1(R.&(2%!,$&M!20*!*$+$.*/#!

2%!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(%!&#$!80&!1$5!0+!&2!.!+0*>*(+(%8!3(%5(%8D!L$!320%5!.!1(%J!K(&#!.!>*$)(20+1,!!

Page 222: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 209 of 237

!

?'Q3*%(-D(9>?('<$3"%=(2):%(;(;?>=('<(M#*'43=(4*Q#<=N(G32(<42(=)=2%&'"#88)(

<e-!(%50/$+!=2&#!6-ev!.%5!6-eu!(%!J(5%$,+M!=*.(%M!1()$*!.%5!(%&$+&(%$+M!=0&!%2&!(%!/(*/01.&(2%D!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8! (%! &#$! 1()$*! .%5! (%&$+&(%$+! >*292&$+! 6EFZmP!>*2&$(%! $d>*$++(2%D!@2&&$5! 1(%$+! .%5! 3011! 1(%$+!(%5(/.&$!&#$!1$)$1!23! (%50/&(2%M! (D$D! 3011! 1(%$+!*$>*$+$%&!92*$!>*2%20%/$5!$33$/&!23!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!&#.%!52&&$5M!=.+$5!2%!Wdj!5.&.D!

!

(5$%&(3($5!>()2&.1!>1.,$*!6EFZmDZo!L$!2=+$*)$5!&#.&!(%+&$.5!23!./&(%8!&28$&#$*M!6-eP:Z!*.&#$*!

./&+! 0>+&*$.9! 23! 6EFZm! (D$D! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 9$5(.&$! +$/*$&(2%! 23! >*2&$(%! 6EFZmP! .%5! *$801.&$!

$d>*$++(2%!23!,.ZE/!.%5!,.ZE-!.&!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!1$)$1!(%!/*,>&+D!<#(+!(+!*$9.*J.=1$!.+!&,>$!6!

6-e+!23&$%!>1.,!.%!.%&.82%(R(%8!*21$!&2K.*5+!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%!.%5!<#Zm!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%DZYwjj!

P9=*2+(!$&!.1D!+088$+&!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!9.,!>*292&$!.%5!(%#(=(&!6EFZmPl-!+(8%.1(%8!5$>$%5(%8!

2%! &#$! /.%2%(/.1! +(8%.1(%8M! K#$*$! 4<P<ZF4<P<jF6:-Y! #$&$*2&*(9$*+! .%5! 4<P<ZF4<P<Z!

#2925(9$*+! .*$! 32*9$5U! 2*! &#$! 1$++! J%2K%! %2%F/.%2%(/.1! 6-eP:! +(8%.1(%8! K#$*$! 4<P<pF

4<P<q!#$&$*25(9$*+!.*$!32*9$5Djp!4(%/$!4<P<p!(+!/*0/(.1!32*!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!<#Zm!/$11+M!

&#$!%2%F/.%2%(/.1!>.&#K.,!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!9.,!>*292&$!<#Zm!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%Djn!W2*$2)$*M!&,>$!

6! 6-e+!9.,!>*292&$! 6EFZm-!>*250/&(2%! (%5(*$/&1,!=,!9$5(.&(%8! &#$!>*250/&(2%!23! /,&2J(%$+!

+0/#!.+!6EFq!&#.&!.*$!(9>2*&.%&!32*!<#Zm!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%Djr!<e-!(%G$/&(2%!52$+!%2&!(%50/$!6EFZm!

.%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! (%! /(*/01.&(2%M! K#(/#! #.9>$*+! &#$! 0+$! 23! &#$+$! /,&2J(%$+! .+! =(29.*J$*+M!

.1&#208#! &#$,! >1.,! .! /*0/(.1! *21$! (%! <e-F(%50/$5! +#2/JD! 6%! $++$%/$M! &#*$$! )$*,! (9>2*&.%&!

/,&2J(%$+!(%!./0&$!.%5!/#*2%(/!(%31.99.&(2%!+0/#!.+!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZm!+$$9!&2!./&!(%!

!"#$%&%&'()%

!('%

&*+,-.%&*+,-.%

Page 223: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 210 of 237

.! 1(%$.*! 925$1! K#$*$! <e-! (%50/$+! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! K#(/#! (%! &0*%! +&(901.&$! >*250/&(2%! .%5!

+$/*$&(2%!23!6EFZm!1(8.%5+!a-(80*$!ZVD!!

+(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(

9>?('<(=64"J(=)<$*4&%=(

4$>+(+!.%5!46:4!.*$!3.&.1!/2%5(&(2%+!&2!K#(/#!%2!/0*$!(+!/0**$%&1,!.).(1.=1$D!72&#!5(+$.+$+!.*$!

/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!.!/,&2J(%$!+&2*9!(%!K#(/#!(990%$!/$11+!.*$!2)$*./&().&$5!.%5!=2&#!>*2F!.%5!

.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,! /,&2J(%$+! .*$! $d/$++()$1,! >*250/$5D! <#$+$! .*$! /29>1$d! 5(+$.+$+! .%5! &#$!

$d./&!9$/#.%(+9+!.*$!+&(11!0%5$*!(%)$+&(8.&(2%D!6%!&#(+!&#$+(+M!K$!0+$5!(%G$/&(2%!23!#(8#!52+$+!

23!<e-!.+!.!)$*,!925$1!23!46:4M!K#(/#!(+M!.1&#208#!+(9>1$M!(%32*9.&()$!&2!0%*.)$1!.&!1$.+&!>.*&!

23!&#$!/29>1$d(&,!23!46:4M!.%5!$++$%&(.1!&2!0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!&2d(/!$)$%&+!(%!<e-!/.%/$*!&#$*.>,D!

P! K$11FJ%2K%! 46:4! 925$1! a$%52&2d(/! +#2/JV! (+! &#$! 0+$! 23! $%52&2d(%! 2*! EC4M! .%! .=0%5.%&!

/29>2%$%&! 23! &#$! /$11! K.11! 23! "*.9F%$8.&()$! =./&$*(.! .%5! .%! .82%(+&! 23! <E:n! .%5! .! 92*$!

/29>1$d!925$1!23! +$>+(+! (+! .! +0*8(/.1!>*2/$50*$! /.11$5! /$/.1! 1(8.&(2%!>0%/&0*$!2*!;ECD!72&#!

925$1+!#.)$! &#$(*!.5).%&.8$+!.%5!5(+.5).%&.8$+D! 6%(&(.11,M!K$!K$*$! (%&$*$+&$5! (%! &#$!0+$!23!

6-eP:Z! .%5!<e-:Z!iQ! &2! 5$&$*9(%$! &#$(*! >#$%2&,>$! (%! =2&#!925$1+D! 72&#! +(%81$!iQ!9(/$!

K$*$! J%2K%! &2! =$! *$+(+&.%&! &2! EC4! /#.11$%8$+M! =0&! 2%1,! 6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!K$*$! 320%5! &2! =$!

>*2&$/&$5!(%!&#$!;EC!925$1M!.+!*$>2*&$5!=,!20*!8*20>Djq!7.+$5!2%!&#$!9$5(.&2*,!*21$!23!<e-!

.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!./0&$!(%31.99.&(2%M!K$!(%)$+&(8.&$5!&#$!$33$/&!23!EC4!2%!520=1$!J%2/J20&+D!

@0.1!8$%$&(/!5$3(/($%/,!1$.5+!&2!.!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!EC4F(%50/$5!1$&#.1(&,M!K#(/#!(+!

50$! &2! 12K$*! >*250/&(2%! 23! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!9$++$%8$*+! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! =2&#!

<e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8D! 429$! 23! &#$+$! 2=+$*).&(2%+! K$*$! *$9.*J.=1$! +0/#! .+! &#$!

>*292&(%8!$33$/&!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!2%!i;!.%5!6EFZmP!1$)$1+D!6EFZmP!#.+!=$$%!>*2>2+$5!.+!.!

5*08!&.*8$&!(%!+$>+(+!.%5!92+&!(9>2*&.%&1,M!&#(+!/,&2J(%$!.%5!%2&!6EFZm-M!K.+!+,%$*8(+&(/.11,!

*$50/$5! (%! &#$! +$*09!23!@iQ!9(/$Djm!P1&#208#!92+&!9$.+0*$5! /,&2J(%$+!K$*$! +(8%(3(/.%&1,!

Page 224: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 211 of 237

1$++! (%50/$5! (%! &#$! @iQ!9(/$M! &#$! (9>2*&.%/$! 23! /(*/01.&(%8! /,&2J(%$+! (%! &#$! >.&#2128,! 23!

+$>+(+!(+!%2&!$%&(*$1,!0%5$*+&225D!P1.R.K(!$&!.1D!#.)$!+#2K%!&#.&!4<P<j!J%2/J20&!9(/$!#.)$!.!

#(8#$*! +$%+(&()(&,! &2! EC4F(%50/$5! 1$&#.1(&,M! K#(1+&! #.)(%8! .! 12K$*! (%50/&(2%! >*23(1$! 23!

/(*/01.&(%8! /,&2J(%$+Djo!<#(+! (%5(/.&$+! &#.&! +(9>1,!2=+$*)(%8! *$50/$5! (%50/&(2%!23! /,&2J(%$+!

.%5!/#$92J(%$!52$+!%2&!+033(/$!&2!.++$++!&#$!+$)$*(&,!23!>.&($%&+D!<#$!.=+$%/$!23!.!/,&2J(%$!

+&2*9! (+! %2&! /*(&(/.1! 32*! 5$.&#! (%! +$>+(+U! /$1101.*! 9(8*.&(2%! /.%! .1+2! 9$5(.&$! 1$&#.1(&,Djo!

g2K$)$*M!+29$!/,&2J(%$+!.*$!)$*,!(9>2*&.%&!9$5(.&2*+!(%!+$>+(+D!6EFZv!.%5!6EFZu!.*$!92+&1,!

J%2K%!32*!&#$!(%/*$.+$!23!./0&$F>#.+$!+(8%.1(%8!.%5!+$/2%5.*,!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%!(%!2*5$*!

&2! &*.33(/! (990%$!/$11+! &2! &#$!+(&$!23! (%3$/&(2%M!K#$*$.+! &#$*.>$0&(/!0+$!23! 6EFj! (+!.++2/(.&$5!

K(&#!901&(>1$! 2*8.%!5.9.8$!50$! &2! /.>(11.*,! 1$.J.8$! *$+01&(%8! (%! #,>2)21$9(.D! <#$+$!K$*$!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,! 12K$*! (%! &#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&!=2&#!<e-!

.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!./&!&28$&#$*!)$*,!$.*1,!.%5!/22*5(%.&$!./0&$!(%31.99.&(2%M!K#(/#!K(11!*$+01&!(%!

(%G0*,!.%5!12++!23!30%/&(2%!(%!&(++0$+!.%5!2*8.%+D!

Q%$! 9.G2*! ?0$+&(2%! K.+! K#$&#$*! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .33$/&$5! $./#! 2&#$*c+! 1$)$1+D! <#(+!

?0$+&(2%! .*2+$! .+! K$! 2=+$*)$5! +0+&.(%$5! 6-ev! .%5! 6-eu! >*250/&(2%! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! <E:m!

./&().&(2%! (%!<e-:ZiQ!9(/$! (%!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!>+2*(.+(+!925$1D!<#(+! 1$5! &2! &#$!#,>2&#$+(+!

&#.&! .%&(F<e-! (%! /*(&(/.11,! (11! >.&($%&+!K.+! 0%+0//$++301! 50$! &2! %$0&*.1(R.&(2%! 23! <e-M!K#(/#!

>*$+09.=1,! *$+01&$5! (%! $d/$++()$! &,>$! 6! 6-e! 1$)$1+M! 1$.5(%8! &2! (%/*$.+$5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! &2!

(%3$/&(2%+DjYMp[! 7.+$5! 2%! &#$! +0>$*(2*! >#$%2&,>$! 23! @iQ! 9(/$! (%! EC4! .%5! &#$! (%3$*(2*!

>#$%2&,>$!23!<e-:Z!iQ!(%!;ECM!&#(+!#,>2&#$+(+!K.+!).1(5D!g2K$)$*M!.55(&(2%.1!.=*28.&(2%!23!

6-eP:Z! (%! <e-:Z!iQ! 5(5! %2&! $%#.%/$! +0*)().1! (%! &#$! ;EC!925$1D!W2*$2)$*M! .=*28.&(2%! 23!

<e-:Z! /29>1$&$1,! .=21(+#$5! &#$! >#$%2&,>$! (%! 6-eP:Z! 5$3(/($%&! 9(/$M! +088$+&(%8! &#.&!

=12/J(%8!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!%2&!+033(/($%&!&2!>*$)$%&!92*&.1(&,!(%!&#(+!925$1D!<#$+$!3(%5(%8+!

.*$!/2%+(+&$%&!K(&#!&#$!3(%5(%8+!23!).%!"*($%+)$%c+!8*20>D!!

P55(&(2%.11,M!K$!/2015!%2&!/2%3(*9!20*!#,>2&#$+(+! (%! &#$!EC4!925$1M!.+!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!5(5!

%2&!#.)$!(%/*$.+$5!=1225!1$)$1+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!4(9(1.*1,M!/(*/01.&(%8!1$)$1+!23!<e-!.%5!+<e-:Z!

Page 225: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 212 of 237

K$*$!%2&!.33$/&$5!(%!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$D!<#(+!(+!(%!/2%&*.+&!K(&#!>*$)(20+!2=+$*).&(2%+D!,(&=*)5"!

5.&.! 3*29! =2%$F9.**2K! 5$*()$5! 9./*2>#.8$+! a7W@W+V! 5$3(/($%&! (%! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8!

+#2K$5!(%/*$.+$5!<e-!>*250/&(2%!/29>.*$5!&2!K(15!&,>$!7W@W+!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!#(8#!52+$+!23!

EC4! .%5! 6-ev! &*$.&9$%&! *$+01&$5! (%! +>$/(3(/! 0>*$801.&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! 2%! 5$%5*(&(/! /$11+DjoMpZ!

4(9(1.*1,M!K$!$d>$/&$5!5(33$*$%&!1$)$1+!23!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$!+(%/$!<e-!/.%!(%#(=(&!

.%5! (%50/$! &,>$! 6! 6-e+M! 5$>$%5(%8! 2%! &#$! /2%&$d&DnMpjMpp! e2! +0/#! 2=+$*).&(2%+! K$*$! 9.5$M!

K#(/#!9(8#&!=$!50$!&2!&K2!>2++(=(1(&($+D!,(&=*)5"!5.&.!(+!90/#!92*$!+$%+(&()$!.+!9$.+0*$9$%&+!

.*$!9.5$!(%!&#$!5(*$/&!+0>$*%.&.%&!23!/$11+M!K#$*$.+!9$.+0*$9$%&!23!/,&2J(%$+!(%!+$*09!3*29!

*(& =*="! 925$1+! 9.+J+! +9.11$*! 5(33$*$%/$+D! <#$! +$/2%5! >2++(=(1(&,! (+! &#.&! &#$+$! 5(33$*$%/$+!

/.%%2&!=$!/.>&0*$5!(%!+$*.!.+!&#$!/$11+!9.,!=$!&*(88$*$5!(%!&(++0$+!&2!>*250/$!<e-!2*!&,>$!6!

6-e+M!K#(/#!+#2015!=$!9$.+0*$5!12/.11,D!L#$&#$*!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!>*250/$!92*$!

2*! 1$++! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 2*! <e-l<e-:Z! +>$/(3(/.11,! (%! 2*8.%+! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! EC4M! *$9.(%+! &2! =$!

$10/(5.&$5D!!

P%2&#$*!*$+$.*/#!?0$+&(2%!K.+!K#$&#$*!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!(+!0+$301!(%!./0&$!(%31.99.&(2%D!

P%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&!(%!/*(&(/.11,!(11!>.&($%&+!K.+!*.&#$*!5(+.>>2(%&(%8!.%5!.+!$d>1.(%$5!(%!&#$!

(%&*250/&(2%M!20*!8*20>!>*2>2+$+!+$1$/&()$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!2)$*!<e-!(%!2*5$*!&2!=12/J!&#$!

92+&!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!.+>$/&!23!<e-Dpn!L#$&#$*!<e-:Z!(%#(=(&(2%!(+!$33$/&()$1,!92*$!0+$301!

&#.%!<e-!2*!<e-:jM!K.+!%2&!.55*$++$5!#$*$D!g2K$)$*M!K$!#.)$!/1$.*1,!+#2K%!&#.&!<e-:Z!iQ!

9(/$!.*$!*$+(+&.%&!&2K.*5+!EC4M!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!*$50/$5!/#$92J(%$!.%5!/,&2J(%$!>*23(1$!(%!

&#$(*!=1225!.%5!*$50/$5! (%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,D!g2K$)$*M! (1$(.1!5.9.8$!K.+!/29>.*.=1$! &2!

K(15! &,>$! 9(/$M! +088$+&(%8! &#.&! 2&#$*! >.&#K.,+! 9$5(.&$! 2*! /2%&*(=0&$! &2! &#$! 5$).+&.&(%8!

$33$/&+!23! EC4D! 4(9(1.*1,M!K$!?0$+&(2%$5! (3! (%#(=(&(2%!23! 6-eP:Z! (+!0+$301! (%! +$>+(+! .%5!46:4D!

6-eP:Z! (%#(=(&(2%! #.+! =$$%! +#2K%! &2! *$%5$*! >*2&$/&(2%! &2K.*5+! EC4M! =0&! &#(+! #.+! =$$%!

5$+/*(=$5!=$32*$Djq!6%!.55(&(2%M!K$!5$92%+&*.&$!&#.&!&#$+$!9(/$!52!%2&!2%1,!5(+>1.,!*$50/$5!

/#$92J(%$!.%5!/,&2J(%$!(%50/&(2%M!.+!<e-:Z!iQ!9(/$M!=0&!.1+2!#.)$!*$50/$5!6EF-P7C!1$)$1+M!

*$31$/&(%8! 1$++! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$D! 6%! &#$! <e-! 925$1M! &(++0$! 5.9.8$! K.+! .++$++$5! =,!

Page 226: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 213 of 237

#(+&2128(/.1! .%.1,+(+! 23! gBH! +$/&(2%+! 23! &#$! 80&! .%5! 5$&$/&(2%! 23! 6EF-P7CU! &#$! 1.&&$*! (+!

.++2/(.&$5!K(&#! %$/*2&(/! $%&$*2/,&$+Dprwpm! P+! =2&#! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .*$! .++2/(.&$5!K(&#!

:6CiZl:6CipF5$>$%5$%&! %$/*2>&2+(+MpownZ! K$! #.)$! +&05($5! &#(+! (%&2! 92*$! 5$&.(1D!

'%32*&0%.&$1,M! 50$! &2! &$/#%(/.1!>*2=1$9+M!K$!K$*$!0%.=1$! &2! (%&$*>*$&!K#$&#$*! &,>$! 6! 6-e+!

9$5(.&$! 6EF-P7C! *$1$.+$! =,! +&(901.&(%8! <e-F(%50/$5! /$11! 5$.&#D! <#(+! *$9.(%+! &2! =$!

(%)$+&(8.&$5D!

!

?'Q3*%(+D(CE1/(#<$(9>?/'<$3"%$($#&#Q%(#*%('&:#'*%$('<(26%(:*%=%<"%(45(;?>!7-(='Q<#8'<Q('<(

26%(Q32(

4&(901.&(2%!=,!EC4!.%5!<e-!1$.5!&2!5.9.8$!.%5!(%/*$.+$5!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!&#$!80&D!6%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8M! =2&#! EC4! .%5! <e-! /.%%2&! (%50/$! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$M! K#$*$.+! (%/*$.+$5!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(+!(9>.(*$5!(%!<e-:ZF5$3(/($%&!9(/$D!

!

<#$! *21$! 23! 6-eP:Z! (%! ;EC! (+! 50.1D! Q0*! 8*20>! +#2K$5! &#.&! 6-eP:ZF5$3(/($%/,! .%5!

%$0&*.1(R.&(2%!1$.5+!&2!+0*)().1!(%!+$)$*$!;ECM!K#$*$.+!i$11,F4/09>(.!.%5!/211$.80$+!*$>2*&$5!

&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!%$/$++.*,!32*!#2+&!>*2&$/&(2%!(%!;ECDnj!6%5$$5M!&#$!5(+/*$>.%/,!=$&K$$%!

=2&#!5.&.+$&+!#$*$! (+!>2++(=1,!50$! &2!).*(20+! 3./&2*+D! -(*+&!23! .11M! =2&#!;EC!>*2/$50*$+!).*,!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,U!K#$*$!i$11,F4/09>(.!$&!.1D!0+$5!.!9(15!32*9!23!+$>+(+M!@$G.8$*!$&!.1D!5$>12,$5!.!

)$*,! +$)$*$! 925$1! 23! ;ECD! 6%! .55(&(2%M! =2&#! 8*20>+! 0+$5! 5(33$*$%&! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5+D!

@$G.8$*! $&! .1D! 0+$5! &#$! ;rm7Elq! .%5! i$11,F4/09>(.! $&! .1D! >$*32*9$5! ;EC! 2%! 9(/$! K(&#! .!

ZjY4ql4)H)!=./J8*20%5M!K#(/#!/.%!/$*&.(%1,!.33$/&! &#$!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!23!9(/$! &2! (%G0*,D!P%5!

1.+&! =0&! %2&! 1$.+&M! +0>>2*&()$! &*$.&9$%&! /.%! .1+2! .33$/&! &#$! 92*&.1(&,D! @$G.8$*! $&! .1D!

!"#$"%&'(')*+

,%$%-"+

./0+ 123+12345+

632745+ 632745+

Page 227: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 214 of 237

.59(%(+&$*$5! .%&(=(2&(/+! &K(/$! &2! 9(/$M! K#$*$.+! i$11,F4/09>(.! >*2)(5$5! %2%$D! 40>>2*&()$!

&*$.&9$%&! *$+$9=1$+! &#$! /1(%(/.1! +$&&(%8!92*$! .+!>.&($%&+! .*$! *$+0+/(&.&$5! .%5! &*$.&$5!K(&#!

.%&(=(2&(/+D!6%!&#(+!&#$+(+M!;EC!K.+!>$*32*9$5!(%!&#$!+.9$!K.,!.+!@$G.8$*!$&!.1D!.%5!20*!*$+01&+!

.*$!+(9(1.*! &2!K#.&!@$G.8$*!$&!.1D! *$>2*&$5M! (&! (+! *.&#$*!/29>1(/.&$5! &2!/29>.*$! &2!K#.&!#.+!

=$$%!5$+/*(=$5!=,!i$11,F4/09>(.!.%5!/211$.80$+D!6%!.55(&(2%M!&#$!80&!312*.!9(8#&!>1.,!.!*21$!.+!

K$11M! K#(/#! /.%! 5(33$*! 50$! &2! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5! 2*! .%(9.1! #20+$! 3./(1(&($+D! <#(+! 9.J$+!

(%&$*>*$&.&(2%!23!20*!*$+01&+!*.&#$*!/29>1(/.&$5D!

6%!/2%/10+(2%M!.=+$%/$!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(9>.(*+!(%&$+&(%.1!5.9.8$!=,!EC4!.%5!<e-M!=0&!%2&!

(%/*$.+$5!>$*9$.=(1(&,M!K#(/#! (+!%2&!2=+$*)$5!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1!.+!

+#2K%!(%!-(80*$!jD!6%!.55(&(2%!&2!&#$!6-eP:Z!iQ!>#$%2&,>$M!20*!8*20>!#.+!>*2)(5$5!$)(5$%/$!

&#.&!>#.*9./2128(/.1! (%#(=(&(2%!23! 6-eP:Z!$)$%!.3&$*! &#$! (%(&(.&(2%!23! +$>+(+M! +&(11!$33$/&()$1,!

=12/J$5!92*&.1(&,!.3&$*!;ECDjq!<#$*$32*$M! 6-eP:Z!*$>*$+$%&+!.%!.&&*./&()$! &.*8$&! &2!=12/J! (%!

&#$!&*$.&9$%&!23!+$>&(/!+,%5*29$+D!6+!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!0+$301S!g$*$M!K$!

#.)$! 5$92%+&*.&$5! K(&#! 520=1$! J%2/J20&+! &#.&! &#$,! $d#(=(&! 1$++! (%&$+&(%.1! 5.9.8$M! 12K$*!

/,&2J(%$!.%5!/#$92J(%$!1$)$1+!(%!/(*/01.&(2%!.%5!=$&&$*!+0*)().1!*.&$+!(%!EC4F(%50/$5!&2d(/(&,D!

P1&#208#! &#$!@iQ!9(/$!+#2K$5!.! ^5(+.>>2(%&(%8c!>#$%2&,>$! (%!;ECM! &#$! (%&$*$+&! *$9.(%+! &2!

+&05,!&#$(*!>#$%2&,>$!(%!2&#$*!925$1+!23!+$>+(+!.%5!46:4!+0/#!.+!;P4CM!!(+/#$9(.l*$>$*30+(2%!

(%G0*($+!.%5!=0*%!.%5!&*.09.!925$1+D!

X(b<$%*=2#<$'<Q(26%("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(

9>?('<(:=4*'#='=(

XY-(;=(26%*%(#("*4==2#8J(G%2K%%<(9>?(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=('<(#324'&&3<%($'=%#=%=c((

<#$! *21$! 23! <e-! (%! >+2*(.+(+! (+! .9=(8020+U! >.&($%&+! +033$*(%8! 3*29! &#$! +J(%! 5(+$.+$! 0+0.11,!

=$%$3(&! 3*29! .%&(F<e-! &#$*.>,M! K#$*$.+! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5! K(&#! <e-! .%&.82%(+&+! 32*! 2&#$*!

.0&2(990%$! 5(+$.+$+!9.,! 5$)$12>! 7%&("="! >+2*(.&(/! +J(%! 1$+(2%+DmMY! <*$.&9$%&!K(&#! &,>$! 6!

Page 228: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 215 of 237

6-e+!#.+!.1+2! 1$5! &2!7%&("="! 5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+! (%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!901&(>1$! +/1$*2+(+!2*!

)(*.1! (%3$/&(2%+DZ[MZZ! 6%5$$5M! e$+&1$! $&! .1D! >*2)(5$5! $)(5$%/$! 32*! &#$! (%(&(.&(%8! *21$! 23! >@;F

5$*()$5!6-ev!(%!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+!(%!.!#09.%!+J(%!d$%28*.3&!920+$!925$1Dnp!!

6%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-!(%!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+!(+!)$*,!+0//$++301M!=0&!%2&!K(&#20&!+(5$!$33$/&+!+0/#!

.+!(%/*$.+$5!+0+/$>&(=(1(&,!&2!(%3$/&(2%+!.%5!&#$!>.*.52d(/.1!(%50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+D!L(&#(%!20*!

8*20>M! K$! #,>2&#$+(R$5! &#.&! +$1$/&()$! (%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! (+! =$&&$*! (%! /29>.*(+2%! &2! <e-!

=12/J.5$!.+!(&! 1$.)$+!<e-:j!+(8%.1(%8!(%&./&Dpn!<#(+!+#2015!>*$+$*)$!&#$!(990%292501.&2*,!

30%/&(2%+! 23! <e-l<e-:j! >.&#K.,! .%5! 2)$*/29$! &#$! (%/*$.+$5! +0+/$>&(=(1(&,! &2! 9(/*2=(.1!

>.&#28$%+D! P1&#208#!K$! 5(5! %2&! /29>.*$! &#$! >#$%2&,>$! 23! <e-:Z! iQ!9(/$!K(&#! <e-! .%5!

<e-:j!iQ!9(/$!(%!P15.*.F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(32*9!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%M!K$!K$*$!.=1$!&2!2=+$*)$!

*$50/$5!+J(%!1$+(2%+!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!+(8%.1(%8D!<#(+!+088$+&+!&#.&!P15.*.!$d$*&+!+29$!

23! (&+! (%31.99.&2*,! $33$/&+! )(.! &#$! <e-:Z! >.&#K.,D! W$.+0*$9$%&! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 6-eF

*$+>2%+()$!8$%$+!=,!E09(%$d!.%5!?:<FC;:!&$/#%2128,M!*$+>$/&()$1,M!*$)$.1$5!&#$!*$801.&2*,!

*21$! 23! <e-:Z! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! P15.*.D! 6%! &#$! .=+$%/$! 23! <e-:ZM! =2&#! 6-ev! .%5! 6-eu!K$*$!

(%/*$.+$5!(%!/(*/01.&(2%M!.+!K$11!.+!&#$!&*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!0>*$801.&(2%!23!64:H!8$%$+!(%!&#$!+J(%D!

<#(+!(+!(%!.8*$$9$%&!K(&#!$.*1($*!+088$+&(2%+!&#.&!=12/J.5$!23!<e-!*$+01&+!(%!$d/$++()$!&,>$!6!

6-e! (%50/&(2%DpjMppMnn! 6&! (+! *$9.*J.=1$! &#.&! <e-l<e-:Z! %$8.&()$1,! *$801.&$! &,>$! 6! 6-e!

>*250/&(2%!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!<E:mF./&().&(2%!=,!6Ws!(%!&#$!P15.*.M!=0&!%2&!&2!<E:nF./&().&(2%!=,!

EC4M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! &#$! %$8.&()$! 3$$5=./J! 9$5(.&$5! =,! <e-l<e-:Z! (+! +>$/(3(/! 32*! >@;+!

a-(80*$! pVD! :$8.*5(%8! &#$! ).*(20+! &,>$! 6! 6-e! 1(8.%5+M!K$! /.%%2&! $d/105$! &#.&! 6-etM! 6-e�! 2*!

6-eª! .1+2! >1.,! .%! .55(&(2%.1! *21$D! i$*.&(%2/,&$+! .*$! J%2K%! &2! >*250/$! 6-etM! =0&!K$!K$*$!

0%.=1$! &2!5$&$/&!.%,! &*.%+/*(>&(2%.1!>*$+$%/$!23!.%,! &,>$! 6! 6-e! 1(8.%5! (%! &#$!+J(%D!L$!K$*$!

2%1,! .=1$! &2! 5$&$/&! (%/*$.+(%8! 1$)$1+! 23! 6-ev! .%5! 6-eu! (%! &#$! +$*09! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! P15.*.D!

g2K$)$*M! &#$! *21$! 23! 6-et! (+! 0%5$*+&05($5! (%! >+2*(.+(+D! 429$! +&05($+! +088$+&! &#.&! 6-et! (+!

(%/*$.+(%81,! $d>*$++$5! (%! >+2*(.&(/! >.&($%&+M! K#$*$.+! 2&#$*+! 52! %2&! +#2K! &#(+! &*$%5D! -2*!

(%+&.%/$M!e.*5$11(!$&!.1D!+#2K$5!&#.&!>+2*(.&(/!1$+(2%+!/2%&.(%$5!6-etF>2+(&()$!92%2/,&$+!.%5!

Page 229: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 216 of 237

5$%5*(&(/! /$11+M! K#(1+&! 4/.*>2%(! $&! .1D! 2%1,! 5$&$/&$5! 6-et! (%! j[! 20&! 23! r! >.&($%&+DnrMnq! '+(%8!

"$%$)$+&(8.&2*M!K$!320%5!&#.&!6-et!K.+!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!0>*$801.&$5!(%!1$+(2%.1!+J(%!/29>.*$5!&2!

%2%F1$+(2%.1!+J(%M!=0&!%2&!(%!/29>.*(+2%!&2!%2*9.1!+J(%!3*29!#$.1&#,!/2%&*21+Dnm!e2%$&#$1$++M!

+(%/$!6-et!.1+2!+(8%.1+!)(.!&#$!6-eP:!/29>1$d!+#.*$5!=,!6-ev!.%5!6-euM!K$!=12/J$5!.11!&,>$!6!

6-e!+(8%.1(%8!0+(%8!6-eP:ZF5$3(/($%&!9(/$D!@2(%8!+2M!K$!/.%!$d/105$!&#.&!.%,!2&#$*!&,>$!6!6-e!

1(8.%5!.33$/&$5! &#$! +J(%!>#$%2&,>$! (%! &#$!P15.*.!925$1M!0%1$++!K$!#.)$! &2! /2%+(5$*! +210=1$!

6-eP:!*$/$>&2*+!(%!&#(+!925$1D&!

!

?'Q3*%(XD(F*4==*%Q38#2'4<(45(9>?(#<$(2):%(;(;?>=('=(9C7/=:%"'5'"(

P/&().&(2%! 23! <E:n! .%5! <E:m! 1$.5+! &2! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! <e-! .%5! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D! 6%! >1.+9./,&2(5!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+M!<E:mF(%50/$5!<e-!K(11!%$8.&()$1,!*$801.&$!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%!)(.!<e-:Z! *(&=*="!a*$5!.**2KV:!K#(/#!K.+!%2&!2=+$*)$5!0>2%!./&().&(2%!23!<E:n!=,!EC4D!!

!

P=*28.&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!.1+2!1$5!&2!*$50/$5!>+2*(.&(/!+,9>&29+!(%!&#$!P15.*.!925$1M!

.1&#208#! &#(+! 3(%5(%8! (+! (%! /2%&*.+&!K(&#! 2&#$*! *$>2*&+DnoMnY! <#$! (%/*$.+$! (%! <e-:Z! 1$)$1+! (%!

+J(%!K.+!%2&! .33$/&$5! (%! &#$+$! J%2/J20&!9(/$M! (%5(/.&(%8! &#.&! &#$!0>*$801.&(2%!23!<e-:Z! (%!

*$+>2%+$! &2! P15.*.! (+! (%5$>$%5$%&! 23! &,>$! 6! 6-e+D! 4(%/$! >+2*(.+(+F*$1.&$5! +,9>&29+! .%5!

9.*J$*+!=$#.)$5!5(33$*$%&1,!(%!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$M!K$!K2%5$*$5!K#$&#$*!(&!K.+!

>2++(=1$! &2! /29=(%$! &#$+$! $33$/&+! (%! 520=1$! J%2/J20&! 9(/$D! 6%5$$5M! @iQ! 9(/$! 5(+>1.,$5!

+0>$*(2*! >*2&$/&(2%! .8.(%+&! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D! @$3(/($%/,! (%!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!*$)$.1$5!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!/(*/01.&(%8!1$)$1+!23!6EFZm-!.%5!6EF

Zj>n[D!72&#!/,&2J(%$+!#.)$!=$$%!(9>1(/.&$5!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+!.+!K$11!.+!>.*&!23!

!"#$%

!"#&%

!'()!'(#*% !+,-%.%.('/).('0#*%

Page 230: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 217 of 237

&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+!.%5!.*$!(5$%&(3($5!.+!%2)$1!5*08!&.*8$&+!(%!>+2*(.+(+DZjMr[MrZ!P1&#208#!&,>$!6!

6-e+!0+0.11,! (%#(=(&!>*250/&(2%!23! 6EFZm!.%5!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!23!<#ZmMZYMjZMrjwrq!#$*$!K$!*$>2*&!

32*!&#$!&#(*5!&(9$!.!+&(901.&2*,!$33$/&!23!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!2%!6EFZmPl-!(%50/&(2%D!L$!#.)$!%2&!

(%)$+&(8.&$5!&#(+!(%!30*&#$*!5$&.(1!(%!&#(+!&#$+(+M!=0&!(3!2%$!K2015!>*2/$$5!&2!>#.*9./2128(/.1!

(%#(=(&(2%!23! 6-eP:Z! (%!>+2*(.+(+M! 3011! /29>*$#$%+(2%!23! 6-eP:ZF(%50/$5! 6EFZm-!>.&#K.,! (+!

*$?0(*$5D!W2*$2)$*M! (&! (+! >2++(=1$! &#.&! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! .%5! 6EFZm-! ./&! (%! /2%/$*&! 2%! 6EFjj:M! =,!

(%/*$.+(%8! (&+! (%50/&(2%M!.+! *$)($K$5!=,!20*!8*20>!.%5!5$>(/&$5! (%!-(80*$!nDrmMro! 6EFjj:!/.%!

=(%5!&2!6EFjjM!=0&!.1+2!&2!6EFjnM!K#(/#!=2&#!./&!5(*$/&1,!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+DrY!6%&$*$+&(%81,M!<e-!

(+!*$?0(*$5! 32*! &#$! (%50/&(2%!23! 6EFjn! (%!>+2*(.&(/!+J(%Dq[!P+!<e-!/.%!.1+2!+,%$*8(R$!K(&#! 6EF

ZmPM!(&!(+!K$11!>2++(=1$!&#.&!&,>$!6!6-e+M!6EFZm!.%5!<e-!.11!./&!5(*$/&1,!2*!(%5(*$/&1,!2%!&#$!6EF

jjl6EFjnl6EFjj:! .d(+M! K#(/#! (+! $++$%&(.1! 32*! $>(&#$1(.1! (990%(&,DqZ! L$! #.)$! %2&! >*2)(5$5!

$)(5$%/$! 32*! +0/#! (%&$*./&(2%+M! =0&! (&! (+! .! >1.0+(=1$! 9$/#.%(+9M! K#(/#! *$9.(%+! &2! =$!

(%)$+&(8.&$5D!

<#$!5.&.!(%!&#(+!+&05,!+088$+&!&#.&!<e-l<e-:Z!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e!+(8%.1(%8!./&!0>+&*$.9!23!&#$!

K$11F/#.*./&$*(R$5!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+! (%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5M!=,! (%#(=(&(%8!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:ZU!

(%5(*$/&1,! &#$! 6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+! (+!#.9>$*$5!.+!K$11D! 4&*(J(%81,M! 6EFZmP!K.+!%2&! (%/*$.+$5! (%!

/(*/01.&(2%! (%! *$+>2%+$! &2! 6WsM! (%! /2%&*.+&! &2! 6EFZm-D! L#$*$.+! .11! iQ! 9(/$! +#2K$5! 12K$*!

>*250/&(2%!23!6EFZm-M!<e-:Z!2*!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!5(5!%2&!.33$/&!1$)$1+!23!6EFZmPD!<#(+!(+!?0(&$!

+0*>*(+(%8! .+!K$! 2=+$*)$! &#$! 2>>2+(&$! (%! &#$! EC4!925$1!K#$*$! ./&().&(2%! 23! <E:n! 1$.5+! &2!

+(8%(3(/.%&!(%50/&(2%!23!=2&#!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-M!=0&!2%1,!6EFZmP!(+!.33$/&$5!(%!&#$!.=+$%/$!23!

<e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! ./&()(&,D! <#$+$! *$+01&+! *$)$.1! &#$! $d>1(/(&! 5(33$*$%/$+! (%! J(%$&(/+! .%5!

*$801.&(2%!23!&K2!6EFZm!3.9(1,!/,&2J(%$+!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!+$)$*.1!&*(88$*+D!<#(+!(+!30%5.9$%&.1!

+(%/$!32/0+!23!/0**$%&!*$+$.*/#!(+!+J$K$5!&2!6EFZmPM!K#$*$.+!6EFZm-!#.+!=$$%!+#2K%!&2!=$!.!

J$,!>1.,$*!(%!(%31.99.&(2%!.+!K$11Dqj!6&!.1+2!(9>1($+!&#.&!&#$!(%&$*./&(2%!=$&K$$%!<e-:Z!.%5!

6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!(+!90/#!92*$!/29>1$d!&#.%!.%&(/(>.&$5M!.+!(&!5$>$%5+!2%!&#$!+&(9010+!.%5!

925$1D! ! 6%! #09.%! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+M! .! +$&! 23! rm! 8$%$+! K.+! (5$%&(3($5! &#.&! K$*$! &,>(/.11,!

Page 231: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 218 of 237

.++2/(.&$5! K(&#! .%&()(*.1! 5$3$%+$! .%5! &$*9$5! `4<P<ZFrm_Dqp! <#$+$! 8$%$+! K$*$! *$>*$++$5!

32112K(%8!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!=(2128(/+D!<#$+$!8$%$+!K$*$!$%*(/#$5!32*!64:HF+$?0$%/$+!.%5!&#0+!

(%50/(=1$!=,!&,>$!6!6-e+M!=0&!(%&$*$+&(%81,!.1+2!=,!6-e"M!6EFZ#M!6EFpq"M!Q4W!.%5!<e-D!C2++(=1,M!

<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!/29$!&28$&#$*!.&!&#$!1$)$1+!23!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*+M!.1&#208#!K$!

#.)$!%2&!122J$5!(%&2!&#(+D!!

!

?'Q3*%(.D(E#264Q%<%='=(45(:=4*'#='=($*'M%<(G)('<2%*#"2'4<=(G%2K%%<(9>?N(2):%(;(;?>=(#<$(;C/-\(

I.*(20+!/$11!&,>$+!>*250/$!<e-M!6EFZm!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+D!<e-!.%5!6EFZm!/.%!./&!5(*$/&1,!2%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+M!=0&!.1+2!(%5(*$/&1,!=,!%$0&*2>#(1!*$/*0(&9$%&!.%5!0>*$801.&(2%!23!6EFjj:!.%5!(&+! 1(8.%5+D!<,>$!6!6-e+!.*$!9.(%1,!>*250/$5!=,!>@;+!.%5!/.%!$%#.%/$!&#$(*!2K%!>*250/&(2%M!K#(/#!(+!%$8.&()$1,!*$801.&$5!=,!<e-D! <,>$! 6! 6-e+! /.%! ./&! (%! /2%/$*&! K(&#! 6EFZm! 2%! 6EFjj:! $d>*$++(2%! .%5! #$*$=,! (%5(*$/&1,! .33$/&+!J$*.&(%2/,&$+D! i$*.&(%2/,&$+! *$+>2%5! =,! &#$! >*250/&(2%! 23! .%&(F9(/*2=(.1! >*2&$(%+! +0/#! .+! 4Z[[!>*2&$(%+!.%5!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%M!1$.5(%8!&2!$>(5$*9.1!&#(/J$%(%8D!

!

<#208#!K$!5(5!%2&!&$+&!&#$!#,>2&#$+(+!23!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!(%!2&#$*!>+2*(.+(+!925$1+!.%5!K$!1./J!

(%32*9.&(2%! 3*29! /1(%(/.1! +&05($+M! *$+01&+! 3*29! &#(+! 52/&2*.1! &#$+(+! +0>>2*&! 20*! >*2>2+.1! &2!

$).10.&$! K#$&#$*! =12/J(%8! =2&#! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! (%! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+! 9.,! ./#($)$!

/1(%(/.11,!+0>$*(2*!*$+01&+!/29>.*$5!&2!<e-!.%&.82%(+&+D!-(*+&1,M!=,!+(901&.%$20+1,!(%#(=(&(%8!

Page 232: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 219 of 237

&#$!*$/$>&2*!32*!&,>$!6!6-e+M!6-eP:ZM!2%$!K2015!>*$)$%&!&#.&!+0+&.(%$5!&,>$!6!6-e!>*250/&(2%!

50*(%8! =12/J.5$! 23! &#$! <e-l<e-:Z! .d(+! K(11! 1$.5! &2! &#$! >.*.52d(/.1! 7%& ("="! (%50/&(2%! 23!

>+2*(.+(+D! 4$/2%51,M! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! #.)$! 5(33$*$%&! &.*8$&+M! >*292&(%8! (%31.99.&(2%!

&#*208#! 5(33$*$%&! >.&#K.,+! (%! >+2*(.+(+D! @0.1! (%#(=(&(2%! *$+01&+! (%! .55(&()$! .%5! +,%$*8(+&(/!

*$50/&(2%!23!>+2*(.&(/!+,9>&29+!=,!+(1$%/(%8!).*(20+!>.&#K.,+D!<#(+!(+!)$*,!(%&$*$+&(%8M!+(%/$!

&#$!/29>1$d!=(2128,!0%5$*1,(%8!.!5(+$.+$!(+!23&$%!901&(3./&2*(.1M!K#(/#!*$?0(*$+!.!901&(3./$&$5!

.>>*2./#M!K#(/#!/.%!=$!./#($)$5!=,!/29=(%.&(2%!&#$*.>($+D!P! &#(*5!.5).%&.8$!#.+!%2&!=$$%!

>*2)$%! (%! &#(+! &#$+(+M! =0&! (+! =.+$5! 2%! +$)$*.1! >.>$*+! >*292&(%8! /29=(%.&(2%! &#$*.>,Dqnwqm!

C+2*(.+(+!(+!.!/#*2%(/!5(+$.+$!.%5!.1&#208#!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!9.,!*$1($)$!+,9>&29+M!(&!K(11!%2&!

/0*$! &#$! 5(+$.+$D! <#$! /#*2%(/(&,! 23! .! 5(+$.+$! (+! >*2=1$9.&(/! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! .+! 12%8F&$*9!

&*$.&9$%&!9.,!*$+01&! (%! (%/*$.+(%8!*$+(+&.%/$! &2K.*5+! &#$! &*$.&9$%&!2*! (%! (%50/&(2%!23!+(5$!

$33$/&+M!K#(/#!.*$!23&$%!52+$F5$>$%5$%&[email protected]! (%#(=(&(2%M!#2K$)$*M!9.,!*$50/$! &#$!*$?0(*$5!

52+$!%$$5$5! 32*! $33$/&! .%5!#$%/$! &#$! .++2/(.&$5! +(5$! $33$/&+!K#(1+&! ./#($)(%8! =$&&$*! *$+01&+!

&#.%! +(%81$! &*$.&9$%&+D! EX#.*! $&! .1D! $1$8.%&1,! +#2K$5! &#.&!901&(&.*8$&$5! +,%$*8,! *$+01&+! (%!

(%/*$.+$5! &#$*.>$0&(/! +$1$/&()(&,M! K#(/#! K2015! 1$.5! &2! 3$K$*! +(5$! $33$/&+Dqm! P%5! 1.+&1,M! &#$!

+(8%(3(/.%&1,! 12K$*! 1$)$1+! 23! 6EFZj>n[! .%5! 6EFZm-! *$)$.1! &#.&! =,! (%#(=(&(%8! =2&#!<e-:Z! .%5!

6-eP:ZM!K$!+(901&.%$20+1,!&.*8$&!&K2!23!&#$!9.(%!9$5(.&2*+!(%!&#$!>.&#28$%$+(+!23!>+2*(.+(+D!!

XY+(S4K(%55%"2'M%('=(#"2'M#2'4<(G)(9C7\(#Q4<'=2(;@d(#=(%H:%*'&%<2#8(&4$%8(54*(

:=4*'#='=('<(&'"%c((

C+2*(.+(+!(+!.!/29>1$d!5(+$.+$!&#.&!9.%(3$+&+!(&+$13!.+!.!/#*2%(/!+J(%!5(+$.+$M!/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!

+/.1,!*$5!+J(%!1$+(2%+Dqo!Q)$*!&#$!,$.*+M!9.%,!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1+!#.)$!=$$%!0+$5!&2!9(9(/!

&#$! &,>(/.1! /#.%8$+! (%! >+2*(.&(/! +J(%! (%! .%(9.1+M! (%/105(%8! 8$%$&(/.11,! $%8(%$$*$5! .%5!

d$%2&*.%+>1.%&.&(2%! 925$1+DqY! g2K$)$*M! >+2*(.+(+! (+! .++2/(.&$5! K(&#! (%/*$.+$5! *(+J! 23!

/292*=(5(&($+! +0/#! .+! /.*5(2).+/01.*! 5(+$.+$+M! 2=$+(&,! .%5! >+,/#(.&*(/! 5(+2*5$*+Dm[MmZ! <#$+$!

+,+&$9(/! $33$/&+! .*$! %2&! $%&(*$1,! 0%5$*+&225! (%! #09.%! >+2*(.+(+M! .%5! 0%32*&0%.&$1,M! 92+&!

Page 233: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 220 of 237

.%(9.1! 925$1+! 1./J! &#$+$! .++2/(.&$5! 5(+$.+$+D! 69(?0(925M! 9.*J$&$5! .+! .! r\! /*$.9! /.11$5!

P15.*.M! (+! (%/*$.+(%81,! 0+$5! .+! $d>$*(9$%&.1! 925$1! (%! 9(/$! &2! (%50/$! >+2*(.&(/! 1$+(2%+! =,!

*$>$.&$5!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%D!7$+(5$+!(&+!$.+,!.>>1(/.&(2%M! (&! (%50/$+!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+,9>&29+!

(%5$>$%5$%&1,! 3*29! 8$%$&(/! =./J8*20%5M! (+! *$1.&()$1,! /#$.>! .%5! 52$+! %2&! *$?0(*$! +0*8(/.1!

$d>$*&(+$D! I.%! 5$*! -(&+! $&! .1D! #.)$! 5$+/*(=$5! &#$! +(9(1.*(&,! 23! 6WsF(%50/$5! +J(%! 1$+(2%+! &2!

#09.%!>+2*(.+(+M!>*2)(5(%8!$)(5$%/$!&#.&!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!6Ws!(+!.!*$1(.=1$!925$1DZj!!

Q0*! *$+$.*/#! 2%! &,>$! 6! 6-e+! 1$5! 0+! &2! &#$! ?0$+&(2%! K#$*$! &#$+$! (%&$*3$*2%+! K$*$! $d./&1,!

>*250/$5D!e2*9.1!+J(%!52$+!%2&!#.*=2*!9.%,!>@;+!(%!#$.1&#,!+&.&$M!=0&!.!+(%81$!&*$.&9$%&!23!

6Ws!1$.5+!&2!.!+(8%(3(/.%&! (%50/&(2%!23! &,>$!6! 6-e+! (%!/(*/01.&(2%D!L$!K2%5$*$5!K#$&#$*!&#$!

3$K!>@;+!*$+(5(%8!(%!%2*9.1!+J(%!K$*$!*$+>2%+(=1$!32*!&#$!(99$5(.&$!>*250/&(2%!23!6-ev!.%5!

6-euD!<2!.55*$++! &#(+!?0$+&(2%M!K$!0+$5! 6-euF10/(3$*.+$! *$>2*&$*!9(/$D!<2!20*! +0*>*(+$M!K$!

5$&$/&$5! .! +&*2%8! 10/(3$*.+$! +(8%.1! (%! &#$! 80&M! =0&! %2&! (%! &#$! +J(%M! +>1$$%! 2*! 1,9>#! %25$+D!

-0*&#$*! (%)$+&(8.&(2%! *$)$.1$5! &#.&! &2>(/.1! .>>1(/.&(2%! 23! 6Ws! *$+01&$5! (%! .! +K211$%! 80&M!

/#.*./&$*(R$5!=,!(%/*$.+$5!(%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,D!P1&#208#!*$>2*&+!+088$+&!&#$!$d(+&$%/$!23!

.!+J(%F80&!.d(+Mmjwmn!,$&!/12+$!92%(&2*(%8!23!9(/$!.3&$*!&2>(/.1!&*$.&9$%&!23!6Ws!*$)$.1$5!&#.&!

&#$,! 1(/J$5! &#$(*! =./J! +J(%! .%5! &#0+! (%8$+&$5! &#$! 6WsF/2%&.(%(%8! /*$.9D!<#(+! 1$5! 0+! &2! 0+$!

`H1(R.=$&#.%!/211.*+_!&2!>*$)$%&!9(/$!3*29!(%8$+&(%8!6WsD!40*>*(+(%81,M!6WsF(%50/$5!6-eu!(%!

/(*/01.&(2%!K.+!.=+$%&D!6%!.55(&(2%M!*$>$.&$5!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!6Ws!K.+!1$++!+,9>&29.&(/!(%!&#$!

8*20>!K$.*(%8!&#$+$!/211.*+!/29>.*$5!&2!&#$!8*20>!&#.&!/2015!2*.11,!&.J$!0>!6WsD!e2&$K2*&#,M!

6-ev!#.+!%2&!=$$%!(9.8$5!*(&=*="M!=0&!5$&$/&(2%!K(&#!E09(%$d!&$/#%2128,!*$)$.1$5!.!+(9(1.*!

>.&&$*%!(%!/(*/01.&(2%M!(D$D! (%/*$.+$!K.+!5$&$/&$5!(%!/2%&*21!9(/$M!(%!/2%&*.+&!&2!9(/$!K$.*(%8!

/211.*+D!<#(+!5.&.!K.+!%2&!+#2K%!#$*$!.+!(&!(+!0%J%2K%!K#$&#$*!6-ev!(+!(%50/$5!(%!&#$!80&D!

L(&#!&#(+!+&05,M!K$!K2015!1(J$!&2!32/0+!.&&$%&(2%!2%!&#*$$!.+>$/&+D!-(*+&M!6Ws!(+!%2&!&#$!2%1,!

925$1!23! +J(%! &2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!23!.! /#$9(/.1D!<CP!.%5!./$&2%$!#.)$!=$$%!0+$5!.+!K$11! &2!

9(9(/! >.&#2128(/.1! /#.%8$+! (%! &#$! +J(%! =,! &2>(/.1! .>>1(/.&(2%UmrMmq! .%5! (%! &#$! 1(8#&! 23! 20*!

/0**$%&!3(%5(%8+!K$!K2015!1(J$!&2!>2(%&!20&!&#$!>2&$%&(.1!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!9(/$!(%!&#$+$!925$1+!

Page 234: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 221 of 237

.+!K$11! .%5! &#$! +0=+$?0$%&!>2++(=1$! $33$/&! 2%! &#$! 80&! 23!<CP!.%5! ./$&2%$D!P! +$/2%5! .+>$/&!

(%/105$+! 20*! 3(%5(%8+! &#.&! 6Ws! /2015! %2&! (%50/$! 3011F=12K%! >+2*(.+(+! (%! 9(/$! K$.*(%8!

H1(R.=$&#.%!/211.*+D!<#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+!(%5(/.&$!&#.&!&#$!#$.1&#!+&.&0+!23!&#$!80&!/.%!.33$/&!&#$!

+J(%!>#$%2&,>$D!'%&(1!%2KM!%2!*$>2*&+!0+(%8!6Ws!.+!>+2*(.+(+!925$1!#.)$!9$%&(2%$5!$d>1(/(&1,!

K#$&#$*! 2*.1! 0>&.J$! K.+! 2=+$*)$5! 2*! >*2#(=(&$5D! <#0+M! (%&$*>*$&.&(2%+! 23! *$+01&+! 90+&! =$!

9.5$!K(&#!8*$.&!/.0&(2%D!<#$!&$+&$5!8$%$+!23!(%&$*$+&!(%!&#$+$!6WsF=.+$5!*$>2*&+!9.,!>1.,!.!

*21$!(%!&#$!+J(%!=0&!.1+2!(%!&#$!80&!2*!(%!=2&#!&(++0$+D!'%32*&0%.&$1,M!&#$+$!2=+$*).&(2%+!K$*$!

9.5$! (%! &#$! 1.+&! &#*$$! 92%&#+! 23! &#(+! 52/&2*.1! &#$+(+D! <#$*$32*$M! 20*! +&05,! 23! <e-:Z! .%5!

6-eP:Z! (%! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! #.+! =$$%! K*(&&$%! K(&#20&! &#$!

J%2K1$58$!23!&#$!$33$/&!23!(%8$+&(2%!23!6Ws!.%5!(&+!$33$/&!2%!&#$!80&D!g2K$)$*M!(&!(+!/1$.*!&#.&!

+(%/$!6-eu!(+!>*250/$5!(%!&#$!80&!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!6WsM!K$!90+&!*$>$.&!20*!$d>$*(9$%&+!K(&#!

6Ws! (%! 6-eP:Z!iQM!<e-:Z!iQ!.%5!@iQ!K$.*(%8!H1(R.=$&#.%! /211.*+! &2! 5$&$*9(%$!K#$&#$*!

&#$+$!*$/$>&2*+!>1.,!.! *21$! (%! &#$!+J(%!2*! (%! &#$!80&!.%5!K#$&#$*! &#$!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!23!

@iQ!9(/$!*$9.(%+!2*!5(+.>>$.*+!K#$%!2*.1!0>&.J$! (+!>*$)$%&$5D!P%2&#$*!2>&(2%! (+! &2!+&05,!

&#$! >#$%2&,>$+! 23! +(%81$! .%5! 520=1$! iQ! 9(/$! (%! 2&#$*! 925$1+M! +0/#! .+! &*.%+>1.%&.&(2%!

d$%28*.3&! 920+$! 925$1+D! <#(*51,M! 1(&$*.&0*$! +088$+&+! .! +0=+$&! 23! >.&($%&+! K(&#! >+2*(.+(+!

$d>$*($%/$! 1$.J,!80&! +,%5*29$Mmmwo[!K#(/#! (+! *$31$/&$5! (%! &#(+!925$1!=,! (%/*$.+$5! (%&$+&(%.1!

>$*9$.=(1(&,!50$!&2!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!6WsD!6%!&#(+!/2%&$d&M!&2>(/.1!.>>1(/.&(2%!.%5!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!

6Ws!9(9(/+!=2&#!+J(%!.%5!80&!>#$%2&,>$!23!>.&($%&+!+033$*(%8! 3*29!>+2*(.+(+!.%5! 1$.J,!80&!

.%5!&#$*$32*$!9(8#&!*$>*$+$%&!.!92*$!#21(+&(/!$d>$*(9$%&.1!925$1!23!>+2*(.+(+D!!

:$/$%&1,M!I(%&$*!.%5!/211$.80$+!&$+&$5!&#$!$33$/&+!23!6Ws!50*(%8!+$)$*.1!5.,+!(%!.+,9>&29.&(/!

+J(%! 23! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+! &2! 5$&$*9(%$! K#$&#$*! 6Ws! /2015! (%50/$! >+2*(.+(+! +(9>1,! =,!

./&().&(%8! <E:m! (%! %2%F1$+(2%.1! +J(%DoZ! 7,! +$1$/&(%8! >+2*(.+(+! >.&($%&+M! &#$,! .++0*$5! &#.&!

8$%$&(/! >*$5(+>2+(&(2%! K.+! >*$+$%&D! P1&#208#! &,>(/.1! >+2*(.+(+! K.+! %2&! 2=+$*)$5M! >.&($%&+!

+#2K$5! >+2*(.+(+F1(J$! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%! K(&#! 0>*$801.&(2%! 23! 6-evM! 6EFZuM! 6EFqM! 6EFZ[M! 6EF

Zj>n[M! 6EFZmPM! 6EFjjM! 6EFjp>ZY! .%5! <e-D! <#$! .0&#2*+! 5(5! %2&! (%/105$! .%,! 5.&.! .=20&! &#$!

Page 235: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 222 of 237

8$%$*.1!#$.1&#!+&.&0+!23!&#$+$!>.&($%&+!+0/#!.+!80&!>*2=1$9+!2*!/.*5(2).+/01.*!5(+$.+$+D!<#(+!

+&05,!.55+!&2!&#$!).10$!23!6Ws!.+!.%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!>+2*(.+(+!925$1M!.1&#208#!K$!+#2K!&#.&!&#(+!

+#2015!=$!52%$!K(&#!8*$.&!/.0&(2%D!!

!

<#(+!&#$+(+!#.+!+#2K%!&#.&!<e-!.%5!&,>$!6!6-e+!(%&$*./&!(%!).*(20+!(%31.99.&2*,!+$&&(%8+!.%5!

/.%!$%#.%/$! (%31.99.&(2%D!L#(1$!5$3(/($%/,! (%!=2&#!/,&2J(%$!*$/$>&2*+!K.+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!

+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!.8.(%+&!EC4!.%5! 6WsM! (&! (+!0%1(J$1,! &#.&! .! +#.*$5!9$/#.%(+9! (+!=$%$.&#!

=2&#!>#$%2&,>$+!.+!6EFZmPM!6EFZm-!.%5!6EFZj>n[!+#2K$5!5(33$*$%&!>.&&$*%+!(%!&#$!+(%81$!iQ!

9(/$M! 5$>$%5(%8! 2%! &#$! +&(901.&(2%D! g2K$)$*M! K$! 52! >*2)(5$! $)(5$%/$! &#.&! +(901&.%$20+!

(%#(=(&(2%! 23! <e-:Z! .%5! 6-eP:Z! (+! .! ).1(5! &#$*.>$0&(/! +&*.&$8,! (%! #,>$*(%31.99.&2*,!

/2%5(&(2%+!+0/#!.+!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&(2%!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!

7%5%*%<"%=(

ZD!! P&R$%(!-M!<0*($1!WM!;.>+2%(!-M!@2*(.!PM!W$*2%(!CM!4.*R(FC0&&(%(!CD!P0&2(990%(&,!.%5!.%&(F<e-F.1>#.!.8$%&+D!U((&V&n&U+/7&M+*D!j[[rUZ[rZArrYFqYD!52(AZ[DZZYql.%%.1+DZpqZDZ[[D!

jD!! H1J2%!i7M!4&2%$!I!ID!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!.%5!+,+&$9(/!10>0+!$*,&#$9.&2+0+D!c&,()%5-%5"(&?9)"B*(%&>%$D!

j[ZZUpZaZZVAo[pFZjD!52(AZ[DZ[oYlG(*Dj[ZZD[[nrD!

pD!! "2%R�1$RFe.).G.+!NWM!E$$!NM!@.)(5!WM!:.R!HD!6990%292501.&2*,!30%/&(2%+!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%+D!V/)&>%=&

,00#(".D!j[ZjUZjajVAZjrFprD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%*(pZppD!

nD!! g0,+!EM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!@$G.8$*!EM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!5*()$+!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F(%50/$5!

1$&#.1!+#2/JD!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[YUj[qaYVAZompFojD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[Y[jZpD!

rD!! �.*(1(%.!PM!6).+#J()!E7D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!%$K!>1.,$*!(%!<e-!+(8%.1(%8D!?#55&3*5&U#)"*00#(D!

j[Z[UZZAYnFZ[nD!52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[joYZYYD!

qD!! I$%J.&$+#!@M!H*%.%5$R!<M!:2+$&&(!-M!$&!.1D!H%52&#$1(.1!<e-!*$/$>&2*!j!(%50/$+!6:-Z!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!3./&2*F5$>$%5$%&!(%&$*3$*2%Fu!.0&2/*(%$!+(8%.1(%8!&2!>*292&$!92%2/,&$!*$/*0(&9$%&D!,00#(*)9D!

j[ZpUpoarVAZ[jrFpmD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpD[ZD[ZjD!

mD!! 7.*&#$1!;M!7($5$*9.%%!EM!-*$(!CM!$&!.1D!6%50/&(2%!2*!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$!0%5$*!&*$.&9$%&!K(&#!.%&(F<e-!.%&(=25($+D!3*8%$)*"(D!j[ZnUoYapVAj[YFZrD!

52(AZ[DZZrYl[[[projooD!

oD!! e($++!NgM!@.%$+$!4D!P%&(F<e-!.%5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!67@A!.!%$K!>.*.52d!(%!8.+&*2$%&$*2128,S!'#)D!

j[ZpUqpanVArppFrD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&G%1Fj[ZpFp[nqopD!

Page 236: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 223 of 237

YD!! 6=2**.!WM!7$1&*�%!7M!7.+&(5.!"M!P80.+!WM!e2+!CD!6%31(d(9.=!.%5!.5.1(909.=F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+!(%!;*2#%c+!

5(+$.+$A!.!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&D!c&?5";($&?".*)*$D!j[ZZUrajVAZrmFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/*2#%+Dj[Z[DZZD[[ZD!

Z[D!! P3+#.*!WM!W.*&(%$R!.!@M!".112!:EM!g.&.!<:D!6%50/&(2%!.%5!$d./$*=.&(2%!23!>+2*(.+(+!K(&#!6%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!&#$*.>,!32*!#$>.&(&(+!;A!.!*$)($K!.%5!.%.1,+(+!23!pq!/.+$+D!c&T#5&U+/7&3%50/)".&@%(%5%".D!j[ZpUjmaqVAmmZF

oD!52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZnqoFp[opDj[ZjD[nrojDdD!

ZZD!! ;(&*2!IM!-*(+&./#(!:M!<.*.%&(%2!"D!Hd&$%+()$!>+2*(.+(+!(%50/$5!=,!>$8,1.&$5!(%&$*3$*2%A!.!/.+$!*$>2*&D!c&!%7&

?/$%&>%4D!j[[mUZaZVAoqD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZmrjFZYnmFZFoqD!

ZjD!! I.%!5$*!-(&+!EM!W20*(&+!4M!I2$*9.%!N4!.M!$&!.1D!69(?0(925F(%50/$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$!

(+!9$5(.&$5!)(.!&#$!6EFjpl6EFZm!.d(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[YUZojaYVAropqFnrD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[jYYYD!

ZpD!! -10&&$*!7M!e$+&1$!-QD!<E:+!&2!/,&2J(%$+A!9$/#.%(+&(/!(%+(8#&+!3*29!&#$!(9(?0(925!920+$!925$1!23!

>+2*(.+(+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[ZpUnpaZjVApZpoFnqD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[Zpnpo[ZD!

ZnD!! <*./$,!iNM!7$0&1$*!7M!E2K*,!4-M!$&!.1D!4#2/J!.%5!&(++0$!(%G0*,!(%50/$5!=,!*$/29=(%.%&!#09.%!/./#$/&(%D!

M+*%(+%D!ZYoqUjpnanmmrVAnm[FnD!

ZrD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!P*9.J.!WM!i.*.8(.%%(!eM!$&!.1D!4.3$!<e-F=.+$5!.%&(&092*!&#$*.>,!32112K(%8!

>rr<e-:!*$50/&(2%!(%!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZpUZjpaqVAjrY[Fq[pD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qrqjnD!

ZqD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!"*(%$!EM!$&!.1D!P%&(+$%+$!21(82%0/1$2&(5$+!.8.(%+&!<e-:Z!>*$)$%&!&2d(/(&,!23!<e-l6-ey!&*$.&9$%&!(%!920+$!&092*!925$1+D!,()&c&?/(+%5D!j[ZnUZprapVAmnjFr[D!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl(G/Djom[nD!

ZmD!! <+/#0*&+/#$%&#.1$*!WM!L.%8!NM!-*(/J$!;M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.11(%8!(%!&#$!(%&$+&(%.1!$>(&#$1(09!.33$/&+!C.%$&#!/$11+M!9(/*2=(.1!$/2128,!.%5!$>(&#$1(.1!*$8$%$*.&(2%D!'#)D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZZpql80&G%1Fj[ZpF

p[roqpD!

ZoD!! <.J.#.+#(!eM!I.%1.$*$!6M!5$!:,/J$!:M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!>*250/$5!=,!C.%$&#!/$11+!5*()$+!<e-F(%50/$5!+#2/JD!c&T_4&

!%7D!j[[oUj[raoVAZmrrFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[o[rooD!

ZYD!! g$%*,!<M!i(*(9.%G$+K.*.!"4M!:0=,!<M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!6-e!4(8%.1(%8!;2%+&*.(%+!6EFZmPl-!4$/*$&(2%!=,!<!;$11+!

50*(%8!7./&$*(.1!6%3$/&(2%+D!c&,00#(".D!j[Z[UZonamVApmrrFpmqmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[Y[j[qrD!

j[D!! 7�1.�.!:M!7.GJ2!�M!g0 .%0!PD!4$*09!1$)$1+!23!6EFZmP!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!

&*$.&$5!K(&#!(%&$*3$*2%FuD!!#.)&M+.%5D!j[ZpUZYamVAoorFY[D!52(AZ[DZZmmlZprjnrorZjnqonYmD!

jZD!! :.9821.9!I4M!W.*J2)(/FC1$+$!4D!6%&$*3$*2%F=$&.!(%#(=(&+!<#Zm!/$11!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!

901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!T(7"+5&!%)/L&,00#(%&3*$"57&35#8&A/58%)$D!j[Z[UZ[ajVAZqZFmD!

jjD!! �#.%8!OM!W.*J2)(/FC1$+$!4D!6%&$*3$*2%!=$&.!(%#(=(&+!&#$!<#Zm!/$11F9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!*$+>2%+$!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!*$1.>+(%8F*$9(&&(%8!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+D!?.*(&V%#5".&V%#5"$#58D!j[Z[UZZjamVAqnZFrD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/1(%$0*2Dj[Z[D[nD[j[D!

jpD!! P9=*2+(!PM!H+>(%2+.!PM!L.#*$%Fg$*1$%(0+!WD!6EFZmA!.!%$K!./&2*!(%!6-eF5*()$%!+,+&$9(/!.0&2(990%$!

5(+$.+$+D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[ZjUnjaYVAjjmnFonD!52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[ZjnjqrpD!

jnD!! �.%8!OQM!C.%2>2012+!P@M!e0*($).!:M!$&!.1D!4<P<p!*$801.&$+!/,&2J(%$F9$5(.&$5!8$%$*.&(2%!23!

(%31.99.&2*,!#$1>$*!<!/$11+D!c&6*".&?;%0D!j[[mUjojaZpVAYproFqpD!52(AZ[DZ[mnlG=/D;q[[pjZj[[D!

jrD!! iK2%!WFNM!W.!NM!@(%8!�M!L.%8!:M!40%!�D!C*2&$(%!J(%.+$!;F«!>*292&$+!<#Zm!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%!)(.!0>*$801.&(2%!

23!4&.&pD!c&,00#(".D!j[ZjUZooaZjVAroomFYmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21DZZ[jYnZD!

jqD!! @$G.8$*!EM!I.%5$),)$*!4M!7.11$8$$*!WM!$&!.1D!C#.*9./2128(/.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!

>*2&$/&+!9(/$!.8.(%+&!1$&#.1!+$>+(+D!c&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZpUj[YaqVAYq[Fm[D!52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%35(+lG(&q[[D!

Page 237: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 224 of 237

jmD!! 72+9.%%!WM!4.*9.!NIM!P&$3(!"M!�$&20%$!-4M!L.*5!C!.D!H)(5$%/$!32*!.%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!$33$/&+!23!;r.!2%!&#$!

(%%.&$!6EFZmPl6EFjp!.d(+D!WUMT6&cD!j[ZjUjqanVAZqn[FrZD!52(AZ[DZ[Yql3GDZZFZYYjZqD!

joD!! P1.R.K(!LM!g$.&#!gM!L.&$*+!NPM!$&!.1D!4&.&j!12++!1$.5+!&2!/,&2J(%$F(%5$>$%5$%&M!/$11F9$5(.&$5!1$&#.1(&,!(%!

EC4F(%50/$5!+$>+(+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[ajZVAoqrqFqZD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZjjZqrjZZ[D!

jYD!! 4/#K.%5&!<M!4/#09.J!7M!"($1$%!"gM!$&!.1D!Hd>*$++(2%!23!&,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!=,!+>1$%(/!9./*2>#.8$+!

+0>>*$++$+!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!50*(%8!+$>+(+D!T!6^&cD!j[ZjUpZaZVAj[ZFZpD!52(AZ[DZ[pol$9=2GDj[ZZDpo[D!

p[D!! -(+#$*!;NM!P82+&(!NWM!Q>.1!4WM!$&!.1D!<*$.&9$%&!23!+$>&(/!+#2/J!K(&#!&#$!&092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*A-/!30+(2%!>*2&$(%D!<#$!4210=1$!<e-!:$/$>&2*!4$>+(+!4&05,!"*20>D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!ZYYqUppnajqVAZqYmFm[jD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNWZYYq[qjmppnjq[pD!

pZD!! ;0=(11.+!:M!i(%&%$*!iM!C#(11(>+!-M!i.*.%5(J.*!eNM!<#($1$!@EM!7*2K%!":D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!Z!$d>*$++(2%!(+!0>*$801.&$5!(%!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!g;I!K#2!*$+>2%5!&2!&#$*.>,D![%4/)&

>%$&A5%/)D!j[Z[Uj[Z[AnjYjnpD!52(AZ[DZZrrlj[Z[lnjYjnpD!

pjD!! C.10/J.!PiM!71.%/J!NFCM!7$%%$&&!EM!C.+/0.1!IM!7.%/#$*$.0!ND!;*2++F*$801.&(2%!23!<e-!.%5!6-eF.1>#.!(%!

.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[[rUZ[jaYVAppmjFmD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+D[n[or[qZ[jD!

ppD!! @0&R!NCD!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*F.!(%#(=(&(2%!.%5!>.192>1.%&.*!>0+&012+(+A!N.%0+F3./$5!&#$*.>,S!c&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[mUpnajVAjnmFYD!

pnD!! I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!E(=$*&!;D!<*$.&9$%&!23!<e-!9$5(.&$5!5(+$.+$+!=,!+$1$/&()$!(%#(=(&(2%!23!+210=1$!<e-!2*!<e-:ZD!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[ZZUjjarFqVApZZFYD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD/,&283*Dj[ZZD[YD[[nD!

prD!! "211(%!"M!W.*J+!;M!W.*J+!LgD!6%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5!=(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!(%!+$*09!.%5!0*(%$!*$31$/&+!$.*1,!

(+/#$9(/!(%G0*,!&2!&#$!+9.11!=2K$1D!M#58%59D!ZYYpUZZparVArnrFrZD!

pqD!! @$*(Jd!NCD!e2%F(%).+()$!9.*J$*+!23!80&!K.11!(%&$8*(&,!(%!#$.1&#!.%5!5(+$.+$D!e"5.7&c&'/$)5"%()%5".D!

j[Z[UZqanjVArjmjD!52(AZ[DpmnolKG8D)ZqD(njDrjmjD!

pmD!! I$*9$01$%!L(%5+.%&!6;M!g$11$%&#.1!-PM!@$*(Jd!NCWM!$&!.1D!;(*/01.&(%8!(%&$+&(%.1!3.&&,!./(5F=(%5(%8!>*2&$(%!.+!.%!$.*1,!9.*J$*!23!(%&$+&(%.1!%$/*2+(+!.3&$*!.2*&(/!+0*8$*,A!.!>*2+>$/&()$!2=+$*).&(2%.1!/2#2*&!+&05,D!

U((&M#58D!j[ZjUjrranVAmYqFo[pD!52(AZ[DZ[Yml4EPD[=[Zp$pZojn=Z$ZqD!

poD!! :2=(%+2%!eM!W/;29=!4M!W011(8.%!:M!@05.%(!:M!i*(+#%.%!EM!4.5!4D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!(%50/$+!%$/*2>&2+(+!(%!9./*2>#.8$+!50*(%8!(%3$/&(2%!K(&#!4.192%$11.!$%&$*(/.!+$*2).*!<,>#(90*(09D!V/)&,00#(".D!

j[ZjUZpaZ[VAYrnFqjD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%(DjpYmD!

pYD!! W/;29=!4M!;$++32*5!HM!P1&0*J(!ePM!$&!.1D!<,>$F6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!&#*208#!64"-p!/29>1$d!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!+0+&.(%$5!:(>p!./&().&(2%!.%5!%$/*2>&2+(+!(%!9./*2>#.8$+D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*D!j[ZnUZZZapZVAHpj[qF

ZpD!52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZn[m[qoZZZD!

n[D!! @0>*$R!EM!<.J.#.+#(!eM!I.%!g.0K$*9$(*$%!-M!$&!.1D!:6C!J(%.+$F5$>$%5$%&!%$/*2+(+!5*()$+!1$&#.1!+,+&$9(/!

(%31.99.&2*,!*$+>2%+$!+,%5*29$D!,00#(*)9D!j[ZZUpraqVAY[oFZoD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZZD[YD[j[D!

nZD!! <.J.#.+#(!eM!@0>*$R!EM!"*22&G.%+!4M!$&!.1D!e$/*2+&.&(%FZ!.%.1280$+A!/*(&(/.1!(++0$+!2%!&#$!+>$/(3(/(&,M!./&()(&,!.%5!(%!)()2!0+$!(%!$d>$*(9$%&.1!5(+$.+$!925$1+D!?%..&3%/);&3*$D!j[ZjUpaZZVA$npmD!52(AZ[DZ[pol/55(+Dj[ZjDZmqD!

njD!! i$11,F4/09>(.!iWM!4/09>(.!CQM!@$1.%2!WNM!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%!+(8%.1(%8!(%!#$9.&2>2($&(/!/$11+!(+!*$?0(*$5!32*!+0*)().1!(%!920+$!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+!=,!*$801.&(%8!;O;EZ[D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[Z[Uj[majVApZYF

jqD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[YZYrYD!

npD!! e$+&1$!-QM!;2%*.5!;M!<0%Fi,(!PM!$&!.1D!C1.+9./,&2(5!>*$5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(+!&#*208#!(%&$*3$*2%F.1>#.!>*250/&(2%D!c&T_4&!%7D!j[[rUj[jaZVAZprFnpD!52(AZ[DZ[onlG$9Dj[[r[r[[D!

Page 238: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 225 of 237

nnD!! ;.%&.$*&!<M!7.$&$%!@M!<.J!CCM!).%!7..*+$%!E"WD!<,>$!6!6-e!.%5!<e-v!/*2++F*$801.&(2%!(%!(990%$F9$5(.&$5!(%31.99.&2*,!5(+$.+$A!=.+(/!/2%/$>&+!.%5!/1(%(/.1!*$1$).%/$D!U5);5*)*$&>%$&A;%5D!j[Z[UZjarVAjZYD!

52(AZ[DZZoql.*pZr[D!

nrD!! e.*5$11(!7M!�.*(&+J.,.!EM!4$9$%0J!WM!$&!.1D!:$801.&2*,!$33$/&!23!6-eFJ.>>.M!.!%2)$1!&,>$!6!6-eM!2%!/,&2J(%$!

>*250/&(2%!=,!/$11+!23!&#$!(%%.&$!(990%$!+,+&$9D!c&,00#(".D!j[[jUZqYaYVAnojjFp[D!

nqD!! 4/.*>2%(!;M!e.*5$11(!7M!E.31$0*!@LM!$&!.1D!P%.1,+(+!23!6-eFJ.>>.!$d>*$++(2%!(%!>.&#2128(/!+J(%!/2%5(&(2%+A!52K%*$801.&(2%!(%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!.&2>(/!5$*9.&(&(+D!c&,()%5-%5"(&?9)"B*(%&>%$D!j[[qUjqapVAZppFn[D!

52(AZ[DZ[oYlG(*Dj[[qDjqDZppD!

nmD!! �.2!�M!:(/#9.%!EM!W2*$#20+$!;M!$&!.1D!<,>$!6!(%&$*3$*2%A!>2&$%&(.1!&#$*.>$0&(/!&.*8$&!32*!>+2*(.+(+S!\S"M&

^(%D!j[[oUpamVA$jmpmD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[[jmpmD!

noD!! L.1&$*!PM!4/#�3$*!WM!;$//2%(!IM!$&!.1D!P15.*.!./&().&$+!<E:mF(%5$>$%5$%&!(990%$!5$3$%/$D!V/)&?"00#(D!

j[ZpUnAZrq[D!52(AZ[DZ[pol%/299+jrqqD!

nYD!! L2#%!;M!Q=$*F71z=.09!NEM!g..J!4M!$&!.1D!E.%8$*(%a%$8V!/2%)$%&(2%.1!5$%5*(&(/!/$11+!>*250/$!6EFjp!&2!5*()$!>+2*(.&(/!>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!\5"+&V/).&U+/7&M+*&<&M&UD!j[ZpUZZ[ajqVAZ[mjpFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[mpl>%.+DZp[mrqYZZ[D!

r[D!! <2(/#(!HM!<2**$+!"M!W/;2*9(/J!<4M!$&!.1D!P%!.%&(F6EFZj>n[!.%&(=25,!52K%F*$801.&$+!&,>$!Z!/,&2J(%$+M!

/#$92J(%$+M!.%5!6EFZjl6EFjp!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,00#(".D!j[[qUZmmamVAnYZmFjqD!

rZD!! E2K$+!W!.M!40�*$RF-.*(©.+!WM!i*0$8$*!N"D!6990%2128,!23!>+2*(.+(+D!U((#&>%=&,00#(".D!j[ZnUpjAjjmFrrD!

52(AZ[DZZnql.%%0*$)F(990%21F[pjmZpFZj[jjrD!

rjD!! �#.%8!EM!�0.%!4M!;#$%8!"M!"02!7D!<,>$!6!6-e!>*292&$+!6EFZ[!>*250/&(2%!3*29!<!/$11+!&2!+0>>*$++!<#Zm!/$11+!.%5!<#ZmF.++2/(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!(%31.99.&(2%D!W2++9.%!iEM!$5D!\S"M&^(%D!j[ZZUqaZjVA$jonpjD!

52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[jonpjD!

rpD!! "02!7M!;#.%8!H�M!;#$%8!"D!<#$!&,>$!6!6-e!(%50/&(2%!>.&#K.,!/2%+&*.(%+!<#ZmF9$5(.&$5!.0&2(990%$!

(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[[oUZZoarVAZqo[FY[D!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6pppnjD!

rnD!! 4K$$%$,!;WM!E2%$*8.%!:M!7.+5$2!4!.M!$&!.1D!6EFjm!9$5(.&$+!&#$!*$+>2%+$!&2!6-eFu!&#$*.>,!(%!901&(>1$!+/1$*2+(+!>.&($%&+!=,!(%#(=(&(%8!<#Zm!/$11+D!65/*(&6%;/=&,00#(D!j[ZZUjraqVAZZm[FoZD!

52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD==(Dj[ZZD[pD[[mD!

rrD!! :.9821.9!I4M!4#.!�M!N(%!NM!�#.%8!OM!W.*J2)(/FC1$+$!4D!6-eF=$&.!(%#(=(&+!#09.%!<#Zm!/$11!5(33$*$%&(.&(2%D!c&

,00#(".D!j[[YUZopaoVArnZoFjmD!52(AZ[Dn[nYlG(990%21D[o[pjjmD!

rqD!! ;0(!-M!W$%8!NM!E02!CM!;#$%!CD!6-eF!.1>#.!=12/J+!6EFZm!>*250/&(2%!=,!>$*(>#$*.1!=1225!92%2%0/1$.*!/$11+!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!/#*2%(/!./&()$!#$>.&(&(+!7!6%3$/&(2%D!6!?&,(-%+)&3*$D!j[ZnUZnArrD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZnmZFjppnF

ZnFrrD!

rmD!! <2#,.9.!WM!�.%8!EM!g.%.J.K.!�M!@.(!OM!4#(*.J.&.!�M!4.,.9.!iD!6-eFv!$%#.%/$+!6EFjj!*$/$>&2*!$d>*$++(2%!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+A!.!>2++(=1$!*21$!(%!&#$!5$)$12>9$%&!23!>+2*(.+(+D!c&,(=%$)&3%50/)".D!j[ZjUZpjamVAZYppFrD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[ZZDnqoD!

roD!! "*(%$!EM!I.%5$%=*20/J$!:HM!@$G.8$*!EM!E(=$*&!;D!P%!(%31.99.&2*,!&*(.%81$!(%!>+2*(.+(+A!<e-M!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!6EFZmD!?9)"B*(%&'5"J);&W/+)"5&>%=D!j[ZnD!

rYD!! <2#,.9.!WM!g.%.J.K.!�M!4#(*.J.&.!�M!$&!.1D!6EFZm!.%5!6EFjj!9$5(.&$!6EFj[!+0=3.9(1,!/,&2J(%$!>*250/&(2%!(%!/01&0*$5!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!)(.!(%/*$.+$5!6EFjj!*$/$>&2*!$d>*$++(2%D!T#5&c&,00#(".D!j[[YUpYaZ[VAjmmYFooD!

52(AZ[DZ[[jl$G(Dj[[YpYnmpD!

q[D!! i09.*(!4M!72%%$&!W;M!'1)9.*!WgM!$&!.1D!<092*!%$/*2+(+!3./&2*!*$/$>&2*!+(8%.1(%8!(%!J$*.&(%2/,&$+!&*(88$*+!(%&$*1$0J(%FjnF5$>$%5$%&!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!,00#(*)9D!j[ZpUpYarVAoYYF

YZZD!52(AZ[DZ[ZqlGD(990%(Dj[ZpDZ[D[[YD!

Page 239: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 226 of 237

qZD!! 4.!4WM!I.15$R!C!.M!L0!NM!$&!.1D!<#$!$33$/&+!23!6EFj[!+0=3.9(1,!/,&2J(%$+!2%!*$/2%+&(&0&$5!#09.%!$>(5$*9(+!+088$+&!>2&$%&(.1!*21$+!(%!/0&.%$20+!(%%.&$!5$3$%+$!.%5!>.&#28$%(/!.5.>&()$!(990%(&,!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!c&

,00#(".D!j[[mUZmoanVAjjjYFn[D!

qjD!! C.%&$1,0+#(%!4M!g..J!4M!6%8215!7M!$&!.1D!:2*y&x!(%%.&$!1,9>#2/,&$+!.%5!y�!<!/$11+!(%(&(.&$!>+2*(.+(32*9!

>1.?0$!32*9.&(2%!(%!9(/$D!c&?.*(&,(=%$)D!j[ZjUZjjaqVAjjrjFqD!52(AZ[DZZmjlN;6qZoqjD!

qpD!! 4K(%5$11!L:M!N2#%+&2%!PM!O(%8!OM!I22*#$$+!NNM!H15$*!N<M!"05G2%++2%!NHD!W2501.&(2%!23!$>(5$*9.1!&*.%+/*(>&(2%!/(*/0(&+!(%!>+2*(.+(+A!%$K!1(%J+!=$&K$$%!(%31.99.&(2%!.%5!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%D!\S"M&^(%D!

j[ZpUoaZZVA$mYjrpD!52(AZ[DZpmZlG20*%.1D>2%$D[[mYjrpD!

qnD!! L(11(.9+!:QM!"#*.,$=!NM!-$159.%%!WM!W.(%(!:eD!40//$++301!&#$*.>,!23!/211.8$%F(%50/$5!.*&#*(&(+!K(&#!<e-!

*$/$>&2*F68"!30+(2%!>*2&$(%!.%5!/29=(%.&(2%!K(&#!.%&(F;@nD!,00#("."89D!ZYYrUonapVAnppFYD!

qrD!! :22*5!4<M!C*.JJ$%!7NM!P1=.%(!4D!C*$+$%&!.%5!30&0*$!23!/29=(%.&(2%!&#$*.>,!23!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!W#)&

>;%#0/)".D!j[[qUZaqVAqnYFqrrD!52(AZ[DjjZmlZmnq[oZqDZDqDqnYD!

qqD!! 72R(/!6M!:$(&$*!N"M!P11$%!7M!$&!.1D!H)210&(2%.*,!5,%.9(/+!23!/.%/$*!(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!&.*8$&$5!/29=(%.&(2%!

&#$*.>,D!T.*-%D!j[ZpUjA$[[mnmD!52(AZ[Dmrrnl$E(3$D[[mnmD!

qmD!! E$#�*!NM!i*0$8$*!P4M!P)$*,!LM!$&!.1D!4,%$*8(+&(/!5*08!/29=(%.&(2%+!&$%5!&2!(9>*2)$!&#$*.>$0&(/.11,!

*$1$).%&!+$1$/&()(&,D!V/)&6*")%+;(".D!j[[YUjmamVAqrYFqqD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%=&DZrnYD!

qoD!! e$+&1$!-QM!i.>1.%!@gM!7.*J$*!ND!C+2*(.+(+D!V&T(8.&c&!%7D!j[[YUpqZarVAnYqFr[YD!

52(AZ[DZ[rqleHNW*.[o[nrYrD!

qYD!! L.8%$*!H-M!4/#2%&#.1$*!g7M!"0(%$.FI(%($8*.!NM!<+/#./#1$*!HD!C+2*(.+(+A!K#.&!K$!#.)$!1$.*%$5!3*29!

920+$!925$1+D!V/)&>%=&>;%#0/)".D!j[Z[UqaZjVAm[nFZnD!52(AZ[DZ[pol%**#$09Dj[Z[DZrmD!

m[D!! "2&&1($=!P7M!;#.2!;M!@.%%!-D!C+2*(.+(+!/292*=(5(&($+D!c&3%50/)"."8&A5%/)D!j[[oUZYaZVArFjZD!

52(AZ[DZ[o[l[Yrnqqp[m[ZpqnmqoD!

mZD!! e(G+&$%!<M!L.JJ$$!WD!;29>1$d(&,!23!&#$!.++2/(.&(2%!=$&K$$%!>+2*(.+(+!.%5!/292*=(5(&($+D!c&,(=%$)&

3%50/)".D!j[[YUZjYamVAZq[ZFpD!52(AZ[DZ[polG(5Dj[[YDrrD!

mjD!! P*/J!CM!g.%5G(+J(!7M!g.8$%!HM!$&!.1D!6+!&#$*$!.!`80&F=*.(%F+J(%!.d(+_S!T_4&3%50/)".D!j[Z[UZYarVAn[ZFrD!

52(AZ[DZZZZlGDZq[[F[qjrDj[[YD[Z[q[DdD!

mpD!! 72K$!LCM!E28.%!P;D!P/%$!)018.*(+M!>*2=(2&(/+!.%5!&#$!80&F=*.(%F+J(%!.d(+!F!=./J!&2!&#$!30&0*$S!'#)&

\/);"8D!j[ZZUpaZVAZD!52(AZ[DZZoqlZmrmFnmnYFpFZD!

mnD!! 4..*(.1#2Fi$*$!'D!<#$!80&F+J(%!.d(+D!c&\%7*/)5&'/$)5"%()%5".&V#)5D!j[[nUpY!40>>1!paN0%$VA4mpnFrD!

mrD!! g)(5!gM!<$(8$!6M!i)(+&!CgM!4)$%++2%!EM!i$9>!iD!<CP!(%50/&(2%!1$.5+!&2!.!<#ZmF1(J$!*$+>2%+$!(%!&*.%+8$%(/!iZnlIH"-!9(/$A!.!%2)$1!(%!)()2!+/*$$%(%8!925$1!23!>+2*(.+(+D!,()&,00#(".D!j[[oUj[aoVAZ[YmFZ[qD!

52(AZ[DZ[Ypl(%&(99l5d%[qoD!

mqD!! :(++9.%%!:M!Q05+#22*%!WgWM!g$%%(%J!LHM!C2%$/!WM!720K+&*.!NPD!4J(%!=.**($*!5(+*0>&(2%!=,!./$&2%$A!2=+$*).&(2%+!(%!.!#.(*1$++!920+$!+J(%!925$1D!U5+;&3%50/)".&>%$D!j[[YUp[ZaoVAq[YFZpD!

52(AZ[DZ[[ml+[[n[pF[[YF[YnqFqD!

mmD!! g09=$*&!CM!7(5$&!PM!<*$33$1!CM!@*2=./#$33!;M!P8./#$!CD!6%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!(%!>.&($%&+!K(&#!>+2*(.+(+D!c&

3%50/)".&M+*D!ZYYZUjanVApjnFqD!

moD!! W/9(11(%!@EM!:(/#.*5+!@"M!W$(%!HPM!e$1+2%!;@D!4,+&$9(/!.+>$/&+!23!>+2*(.+(+A!P%!(%&$8*.&()$!925$1!=.+$5!

2%!(%&$+&(%.1!$&(2128,D!,()%85&!%7D!j[[[UjajFpVAZ[rFZZpD!52(AZ[DZ[Zql4Z[YqFjZY[a[[V[[[Z[FOD!

Page 240: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 227 of 237

mYD!! i2*2&J,!eM!C$+1,.J!WD!C+2*(.+(+!.+!.!/2%+$?0$%/$!23!(%/2*>2*.&(2%!23!=$&.F+&*$>&2/2//(!(%&2!&#$!9(/*2=(2/$%2+(+!23!#(8#1,!>$*9$.=1$!(%&$+&(%$+!a.!>.&#28$%(/!/2%/$>&VD!:0++(.%!$5(&(2%D!@%$)(&3%50/)".&

@%(%5".D!j[ZZUZAZqD!

o[D!! -.+.%2!PD!E$.J,!80&!.%5!.0&2(990%$!5(+$.+$+D!?.*(&>%=&U..%589&,00#(".D!j[ZjUnjaZVAmZFoD!

52(AZ[DZ[[ml+Zj[ZqF[ZZFojYZFdD!

oZD!! I(%&$*!gM!6)$*+$%!EM!4&$(%(/#$!<M!i*.8=.11$!iM!N2#.%+$%!;D!P15.*.F(%50/$5!+J(%!(%31.99.&(2%!F!+&05($+!23!

>+2*(.+(+!>.&($%&+D!65&c&3%50/)".D!j[ZnD!52(AZ[DZZZZl=G5DZpjpqD!!

Page 241: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 228 of 237

!"#$%&'()(w!!"#"$%&'()#(&*+,)#'-'.*/*$"'!"#$%"&'()"$!

9):%(;(;?>=(#<$(9>?/&%$'#2%$('<58#&&#2'4<(

6%!&#(+!52/&2*.1!&#$+(+M!K$!.(9$5!&2!0%5$*+&.%5!#2K!&,>$!6!6-e+!.%5!<e-!(%&$*./&!(%!).*(20+!

(%31.99.&2*,!+$&&(%8+D!L$!#.)$!5$&$*9(%$5!&#.&!<e-!/.%!>2+(&()$1,!.%5!%$8.&()$1,!*$801.&$!

&#$!(%50/&(2%!23!&,>$!6!6-e+D!6%!).*(20+!+$&&(%8+!+0/#!.+!EC4!.%5!6WsM!K$!2=+$*)$5!&#.&!<e-:Z!

.%5! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(%8! &28$&#$*! 2*/#$+&*.&$+! &#$! (%50/&(2%! 23! >*2F! .%5! .%&(F(%31.99.&2*,!

/,&2J(%$+M!=0&!23&$%!.1+2!>1.,!+212D!-2*!$d.9>1$M!(%!&#$!80&!=2&#!>.&#K.,+!.*$!(%)21)$5!(%!&#$!

812=.1!#$.1&#!+&.&0+D!@$3(/($%/,!23!<e-:Z!(9>.(*$5!EC4F(%50/$5!>$*9$.=(1(&,!K#$*$.+!1./J!23!

6-eP:Z!+(8%.1(%8!>*$)$%&$5!EC4F(%50/$5!2*8.%!5.9.8$D!4(9(1.*1,M!6Ws!(%50/$5!1$++!*$5%$++!

.%5! +/.1(%8! (%! &#$! .=+$%/$!23!<e-:Z!.%5! *$50/$5!$>(5$*9.1!#,>$*>*21(3$*.&(2%! (%! 6-eP:ZF

5$3(/($%&!+J(%D!Q0*!2=+$*).&(2%+!&#0+!+088$+&!&#.&!=2&#!>.&#K.,+!#.)$!+$>.*.&$!.%5!/2992%!

&.*8$&+D!g2K$)$*M!&#$!>#$%2&,>$!23!520=1$!5$3(/($%&!9(/$!K.+!*$9.*J.=1$A!92+&!$33$/&+!K$*$!

.55(&()$!2*!+,%$*8(+&(/D!-2*! (%+&.%/$M!@iQ!5(+>1.,$5!1$++! (%&$+&(%.1!>$*9$.=(1(&,!.%5!5.9.8$!

(%!*$+>2%+$!&2!EC4!.%5!5$)$12>$5!1$++!*$5%$++M!+/.1(%8!.%5!&#(/J$%(%8!K#$%!/#.11$%8$5!K(&#!

6WsD!6%!.55(&(2%M!@iQ!+#2K$5!2)$*.11!+(8%(3(/.%&1,!12K$*!1$)$1+!23!>*2F(%31.99.&2*,!/,&2J(%$+!

+0/#!.+!6EFZj>n[M!6EFZmP!.%5!6EFZm-!/29>.*$5!&2!+(%81$!iQ!9(/$D!6&!+$$9$5!&#.&!&#$!=$+&!23!

=2&#!K2*15+!K.+!/2%+$*)$5!(%!&#$+$!9(/$D!!

96%*#:%32'"(*%8%M#<"%(

6%!$++$%/$M!&#$!.(9!23!&#(+!+&05,!K.+!%2&!2%1,!&2!0%5$*+&.%5!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!<e-!.%5!

&,>$! 6! 6-e+M! =0&! .1+2! &2! 5$&$*9(%$! K#$&#$*! 50.1! =12/J.5$! 23! =2&#! >.&#K.,+! K2015! #.)$!

/1(%(/.1!=$%$3(&!(%!925$1+!23!(%31.99.&(2%D!6%5$$5M!@iQ!9(/$!5(+>1.,$5!.!+0>$*(2*!>#$%2&,>$!

(%! 6WsF(%50/$5! >+2*(.+(32*9! +J(%! (%31.99.&(2%D! "()$%! &#$! %09=$*! 23! >.&($%&+! &*$.&$5!K(&#!

Page 242: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 229 of 237

.%&(F<e-!=0&!+033$*(%8!3*29!(&+!>.*.52d(/.1!+(5$!$33$/&+M!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!23!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!

9.,! >2+$! .%! (%&$*$+&(%8! .1&$*%.&()$! &2! ).1(5.&$! .+! &#$*.>,D! Q%$! 9.,! .*80$! &#.&! >.&($%&+!

&*$.&$5! K(&#! .%&(F<e-:Z! .%5! .%&(F6-eP:Z! 9.,! =$! $)$%! 92*$! )01%$*.=1$! &2! 2>>2*&0%(+&(/!

=./&$*(.1!.%5!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!=0&!K$!.*80$!&#.&!&#$!%$$5!32*!12K$*!52+$+!32*!+(9(1.*!$33(/./,!

K(11! +(9(1.*1,! 12K$*! &#$! *(+J! 23!9(/*2=(.1! (%3$/&(2%+D! 6%! .55(&(2%M! <e-l<e-:j! +(8%.1(%8!K(11!

*$9.(%!(%&./&M!(%!/2%&*.+&!&2!&#$!/1.++(/!.%&(F<e-!&*$.&9$%&D!-011!6-eP:Z!iQ!9(/$!.*$!(%5$$5!

92*$!+0+/$>&(=1$!&2!)(*.1!(%3$/&(2%+M!=0&!&#$!+$%+(&()(&,!23!5*08F9$5(.&$5!(%#(=(&(2%!23!6-eP:Z!

*$9.(%+! &2! =$! 5$&$*9(%$5D! 6%! .55(&(2%M! W$56990%$! #.+! $).10.&$5! .! 5*08! .8.(%+&! 6-ev! (%!

>+2*(.+(+!.%5!320%5!(&!&2!=$!K$11!&21$*.&$5!.%5!+.3$D!!

P+! 32*! &#$! &*$.&9$%&! 23! +$>+(+! .%5! 46:4! >.&($%&+M! 20*! *$+01&+! (%! &#$! EC4! 925$1! .*$! )$*,!

$%/20*.8(%8M!=0&!2)$*+#.52K$5!=,!&#$!>#$%2&,>$!23!&#$!@iQ!9(/$!(%!;ECD!g2K$)$*M!K$!.*80$!

&#.&!;EC!(+!.!32*9!23!>21,9(/*2=(.1!+$>+(+M!.!+$&&(%8!K#$*$!50.1!(%#(=(&(2%!9.,!(%5$$5!%2&!=$!

*$1$).%&D!g2K$)$*M!&#$!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!23!@iQ!9(/$!.8.(%+&!EC4!*$?0(*$+!&2!=$!&$+&$5!(%!

2&#$*!925$1+!23!+,+&$9(/!(%31.99.&(2%!&#.&!.*$!92*$!+&$*(1$!+0/#!.+!=0*%!.%5!&*.09.!925$1+D!!!

?323*%(E%*=:%"2'M%=(

P1&#208#!&#$!@iQ!9(/$!+#2K$5!.%!(%&$*$+&(%8!>#$%2&,>$!(%!&#$!EC4!925$1M!K$!%$$5!&2!*$>$.&!

&#(+! &,>$! 23! +&05($+! (%! 2&#$*! 925$1+! 23! +,+&$9(/! (%31.99.&(2%M! .+! &#$! EC4! 925$1! 9.,! =$!

9(+1$.5(%8D!<#$!5.&.!+#2K%!#$*$!(+!>*$1(9(%.*,M!+2!30*&#$*!(%)$+&(8.&(2%!(%&2!&#$!9$/#.%(+9!

(+!*$?0(*$5D!70&!8()$%!&#$!/,&2J(%$!>*23(1$!23!&#$!@iQ!9(/$M!K$!&#(%J!&#.&!5$1.,$5!.>2>&2+(+!23!

%$0&*2>#(1+!9(8#&!=$!.%!(%&$*$+&(%8!#,>2&#$+(+!&2!(%)$+&(8.&$5!(%!&#$!30&0*$D!

P+! 32*! 20*! *$/$%&! 3(%5(%8! &#.&! (9(?0(925! .33$/&+! &#$! 80&U! &#(+! %$$5+! 30*&#$*! $d>12*.&(2%M!

(%/105(%8! &#$! *21$! 23! 6-eu! (%! &#$! 80&! .%5! 0%5$*+&.%5(%8! #2K! &#$! 80&! .33$/&$5! &#$! +J(%c+!

*$+>2%+$! &2! (9(?0(925D! 6%!.55(&(2%M! (&!K2015!=$! (%&$*$+&(%8! &2!+&05,! &#(+!2=+$*).&(2%! (%! &#$!

@iQ!9(/$!.%5!&$+&!K#$&#$*!&#$(*!+0>$*(2*!>*2&$/&(2%!(+!.++2/(.&$5!K(&#!&#$!80&D!70&!32*$92+&M!

Page 243: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 230 of 237

20*!.(9! (+! &2!5*.K! &#$!.&&$%&(2%!23! &#$! +/($%&(3(/! /2990%(&,! &2! &#$!>2&$%&(.1!2*.1!0>&.J$!23!

&2>(/.11,!.>>1($5!.8$%&+!=,!9(/$!.%5!&#$!>2++(=1$!+(5$!$33$/&+D!

<#$!*$+01&+!3*29!&#$!@iQ!(%!&#$!6Ws!925$1!+$$9!&2!=$!&#$!92+&!>*29(+(%8!+0=G$/&!32*!30*&#$*!

+&05,D!L(&#!&#$!>2++(=(1(&,!23!%$K!=(2128(/+!&2!=$!92*$!+>$/(3(/M!(&!K2015!=$!$d/(&(%8!&2!$d>12*$!

&#$!>2++(=(1(&,!&2!9.J$!/$11F+>$/(3(/!=(2128(/+M!+0/#!.+!>@;F&.*8$&$5!=(2128(/+D!P1&#208#!9.%,!

/$11! &,>$+! #.)$! =$$%! (5$%&(3($5! .+! J$,! 9$5(.&2*+! 23! (%31.99.&(2%! (%! >+2*(.+(+M! +>$/(3(/.11,!

=12/J(%8!=2&#!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:Z!2%!&#$!*$+>$/&()$!/01>*(&+!/2015!1$.5!&2!1$++!.+>$/(3(/(&,!.%5!

&#$*$32*$! 3$K$*! +(5$! $33$/&+D! e.%2=25,! &$/#%2128,! *$>*$+$%&+! #$*$! .%! (99$%+$! %09=$*! 23!

>2++(=(1(&($+D! P1&#208#!K$!#.)$! 2%1,! .55*$++$5!>+2*(.+(+F1(J$! 1$+(2%+! .+! .0&2(990%$!925$1!

32*!&#$!/*2++&.1J!=$&K$$%!<e-:Z!.%5!6-eP:ZM!2&#$*!$d>$*(9$%&.1!5(+$.+$!925$1+!+#2015!=$!

(%)$+&(8.&$5!.+!K$11!+0/#!.+!;*2#%c+!5(+$.+$M!*#$09.&2(5!.*&#*(&(+!.%5!.%J,12+(%8!+>2%5,1(&(+D!

P1&#208#! 50.1! =12/J.5$! 9(8#&! %2&! .1K.,+! =$! .+! $33$/&()$! (%! &#$+$! 5(+$.+$+! /29>.*$5! &2!

>+2*(.+(+M! >2++(=1,! %$K! =(29.*J$*+! /.%! =$! (5$%&(3($5! .%5! &#$! >2&$%&(.1! 23! <e-:Z! =12/J.5$!

2)$*!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>,!90+&!=$!$).10.&$5D!!

! !

Page 244: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 231 of 237

!""#$%&'()*)w!!"#$%$$&'($)"*+,'-'!"#$"%&'(#)&(#*'+#,#-!

9):%(;(;?>%<(%<(9>?/Q%&%$'%%*$%('<58#&&#2'%(

6%! 5(&! >*2$3+/#*(3&! &*./#&&$%! K$! &$! =$8*(G>$%! #2$! &,>$! 6! 6-e! $%! <e-! (%&$*.8$*$%! (%!

)$*+/#(11$%5$!(%31.99.&2(*$!/2%&$d&$%D!L$!#$==$%!).+&8$+&$15!5.&!<e-!5$!(%50/&($!).%!&,>$!6!

6-e$%!R2K$1!>2+(&($3!.1+!%$8.&($3!J.%!*$801$*$%D!6%!)$*+/#(11$%5$!925$11$%M!R2.1+!EC4!$%!6WsM!

#$==$%!K$! 8$/2%+&.&$$*5! 5.&! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:Z! +(8%.1(+.&($! +.9$%!5$! (%50/&($! ).%! >*2F$%!

.%&(F(%31.99.&2(*$!/,&2J(%$+!=$8$1$(5$%M!9..*!)..J!22J!+212!+>$1$%D!7(G)22*=$$15M!(%!5$!5.*9!

R(G%! =$(5$! +(8%.1(+.&($K$8$%! =$&*2JJ$%! =(G! 5$! .18$9$%$! 8$R2%5#$(5++&.&0+D! "$=*$J! ..%!

<e-:Z! +(8%.1(+.&($! )$*+&22*5$! EC4F8$k%50/$$*5$! >$*9$.=(1(&$(&! &$*K(G1! 5$! .3K$R(8#$(5! ).%!

6-eP:Z! ./&().&($! EC4F8$k%50/$$*5$! +/#.5$! ..%!2*8.%$%! )22*JK.9D!L$! R.8$%! 8$1(GJ..*5(8$!

$33$/&$%!(%!#$&!6Ws!925$1!K..*M!(%!5$!.3K$R(8#$(5!).%!<e-:ZM!9(%5$*!*225#$(5!$%!+/#(13$*(%8!

8$k%50/$$*5!K$*5!$%!8$%$&(+/#$!5$1$&($!).%!6-eP:Z!5$!$>(5$*9.1$!)$*5(JJ(%8!)$*9(%5$*5$D!

Q%R$!K..*%$9(%8$%! +088$*$*$%! 5.&! =$(5$! *$/$>&2*$%! R2K$1! .>.*&$! $%! 8$9$$%+/#.>>$1(GJ$!

52$1$%!#$==$%D!g$&!3$%2&,>$!).%!50==$1!5$3(/(�%&$!90(R$%!K.+!$/#&$*!2>9$*J$1(GJA!5$!9$$+&$!

$33$/&$%! K.*$%! .55(&($3! 23! +,%$*8$&(+/#D! 7(G)22*=$$15M! 5$! @iQ! 90(R$%! #.55$%! 9(%5$*!

5.*9>$*9$.=(1(&$(&!$%!+/#.5$!(%!*$./&($!2>!EC4!$%!2%&K(JJ$15$%!9(%5$*!*225#$(5M!+/#(13$*(%8!

$%!)$*5(JJ(%8!K.%%$$*!R$!8$+&(901$$*5!K$*5$%!9$&!6WsD!72)$%5($%!&22%5$%!5$!@iQ!90(R$%!

(%! )$*8$1(GJ(%8!9$&! 5$! $%J$1)205(8$! iQ!90(R$%! (%! &2&..1! +(8%(3(/.%&! 1.8$*$! 1$)$1+! ).%! >*2F

(%31.99.&2(*$! /,&2J(%$+! R2.1+! 6EFZj>n[M! 6EFZmP! $%! 6EFZm-D!g$&! 1$$J! $*2>! 5.&! #$&! =$+&$! ).%!

=$(5$!K$*$15$%!K$*5!=$K..*5!(%!5$R$!90(R$%D!

Page 245: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 232 of 237

96%*#:%32'="6%(*%8%M#<2'%(

g$&!52$1!).%!5$R$!+&05($!K.+!%($&!.11$$%!5$!(%&$*./&($!&0++$%!<e-!$%!&,>$!6!6-e$%!&$!=$8*(G>$%M!

9..*!22J!29!&$!=$>.1$%!23!50==$1$!=12JJ.5$!).%!=$(5$!*$/$>&2*$%!J1(%(+/#$!)22*5$1$%!R20!

2>1$)$*$%! (%! (%31.99.&2(*$!925$11$%D! 6%5$*5..5M!5$!@iQ!90(R$%!)$*&22%5$%!$$%!+0>$*($0*!

3$%2&,>$!(%!6WsF8$k%50/$$*5$!>+2*(.+(+./#&(8$!1.$+($+D!"$R($%!#$&!8*2&$!..%&.1!>.&(�%&$%!5.&!

=$#.%5$15! K2*5&! 9$&! .%&(F<e-M! 9..*! &$)$%+! 1(G5$%! ..%! 5$! >.*.52d.1$! =(GK$*J(%8$%M! R20!

50==$1$! (%#(=(&($! ).%! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:Z! $$%! (%&$*$++.%&$! .1&$*%.&($)$! >(+&$! )22*! )$*5$*!

2%5$*R2$J!J0%%$%!=$&$J$%$%D!W$%!J.%!$)$%&0$$1!+&$11$%!5.&!5$R$!>.&(�%&$%M!8$50*$%5$!$$%!

=$#.%5$1(%8!9$&! .%&(F<e-:Z! $%! .%&(F6-eP:ZM! %28! JK$&+=..*5$*! R(G%! )22*! 2>>2*&0%(+&(+/#$!

=./&$*(�1$!$%!)(*.1$!(%3$/&($+M!9..*!K(G!.*809$%&$*$%!5.&!$*!K$11(/#&!1.8$*$!52+$+!%225R.J$1(GJ!

R(G%! )22*! $$%! +22*&8$1(GJ$! K$*JR..9#$(5M! $%! 50+! 2>! 5($! 9.%($*! #$&! *(+(/2! 2>! 9(/*2=(�1$!

(%3$/&($+!)$*1..8&D!72)$%5($%!=1(G3&M!(%!&$8$%+&$11(%8!&2&!5$!J1.++($J$!.%&(F<e-!=$#.%5$1(%8M!5$!

<e-l<e-:j! (%&$*./&($! #($*! (%&./&D! g2$K$1! 6-eP:Z! iQ! 90(R$%! $$%! )$*#2285$! ).&=..*#$(5!

)$*&2%$%! &$%! ..%R($%! ).%! )(*.1$! (%3$/&($+M! 92$&! 5$! 8$)2$1(8#$(5! 522*! 5*08+F8$k%50/$$*5$!

*$99(%8! ).%! 6-eP:Z! ./&().&($! %28! K2*5$%! =$>..15D! @..*%..+&! #$$3&! W$56990%$! $$%!

8$%$$+9(55$1!8$&$+&!K$1J$!6-ev!%$0&*.1(+$$*&!(%!>+2*(.+(+D!@$R$!5*08!K$*5!82$5!)$*5*.8$%!$%!

)$(1(8!=$)2%5$%D!!

g2$K$1! 2%R$! *$+01&.&$%! ).%! 5$! @iQ! 90(R$%! (%! #$&! EC4! R$$*! =$92$5(8$%5! R(G%! )22*! 5$!

=$#.%5$1(%8!).%!+$>+(+!$%!46:4!>.&(�%&$%M!K2*5$%!R$!&2/#!2)$*+/#.50K5!522*!#$&! 3$%2&,>$!

).%! 5$!@iQ!90(R$%! (%! ;ECD! ;EC! (+! $/#&$*! $$%! )2*9! ).%! >21,9(/*2=(.1$! +$>+(+! $%! +&$1&! 50+!

.11(/#&! $$%! +$&&(%8! )22*!K..*! 50==$1$! *$99(%8! ).%! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:Z! %($&! *$1$).%&! (+D! @$!

+0>$*($0*$! =$+/#$*9(%8! ).%! 5$!@iQ!90(R$%! (%! EC4! 5($%&! 2%5$*R2/#&! &$!K2*5$%! (%! .%5$*$!

925$11$%! ).%! +,+&$9(+/#$! 2%&+&$J(%8! 5($! +&$*($1$*! R(G%M! R2.1+! =*.%5K2%5F! $%! &*.09.F

925$11$%D!!

Page 246: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 233 of 237

94%J4&=2:%*=:%"2'%M%<(

g2$K$1!5$!@iQ!90(R$%!$$%!(%&$*$++.%&!3$%2&,>$!(%!#$&!EC4F925$1!)$*&2%$%M!5($%$%!K$!5$R$!

2=+$*).&($! (%! .%5$*$! 925$11$%! ).%! +,+&$9(+/#$! 2%&+&$J(%8! &$! #$*#.1$%M! ..%8$R($%! EC4! &$!

+(9>1(+&(+/#!(+!)22*!+$>+(+!$%!46:4D!@$!8$&22%5$!5.&.!(+!>*$1(9(%.(*M!R25.&!)$*5$*!2%5$*R2$J!

%..*!#$&!./#&$*1(88$%5$!9$/#.%(+9$!)$*$(+&!(+D!W..*!%..*!..%1$(5(%8!).%!#$&!/,&2J(%$!>*23($1!

).%!5$!@iQ!90(R$%M!5$%J$%!K$!5.&!5$!)$*&*..85$!.>2>&2+$!).%!%$0&*23($1$%!$$%!(%&$*$++.%&$!

#,>2&#$+$!)22*+&$1&!$%!2%5$*R2/#&!5($%&!&$!K2*5$%!(%!5$!&2$J29+&D!

Q%R$!*$/$%&$!=$)(%5(%8!K..*(%!(9(?0(925!5$!5.*9!=$k%)12$5&M!5($%&!22J!)$*5$*!=$+&05$$*5!

&$!K2*5$%M!9$&!(%=$8*(>!).%!5$!*21!6-eu!(%!5$!5.*9!$%!#2$!5$!5.*9!5$!*$./&($!).%!5$!#0(5!2>!

(9(?0(925!J.%!=$k%)12$5$%D!72)$%5($%!)(%5$%!K$!#$&!$++$%&($$1!29!#$&!3$%2&,>$!).%!5$!@iQ!

90(R$%! #($*(%! &$! =$&*$JJ$%! $%! &$! 2%5$*R2$J$%! 23! #0%! +0>$*($0*$! =$+/#$*9(%8! 928$1(GJ+!

8$.++2/($$*5! (+! 9$&! 5$! 5.*9D! W..*! K$! K$%+$%! )22*.1! 5$! K$&$%+/#.>>$1(GJ$! 8$9$$%+/#.>!

$*2>!&$!K(GR$%!5.&!2*.1$!2>%.9$!).%!&2>(/..1!&2$8$5($%5$!.8$%&(.!%$)$%$33$/&$%!J.%!#$==$%!

2>!5$!5.*9!$%!5.&!)22*R(/#&(8#$(5!29&*$%&!*$+01&.&$%!$%!(%&$*>*$&.&($+!).%!8*22&!=$1.%8!(+D!

@$!*$+01&.&$%!).%!5$!@iQ!90(R$%!(%!#$&!6Ws!925$1!1(GJ$%!)22*!)$*5$*!2%5$*R2$J!#$&!9$$+&!

)$$1=$12)$%5D!W$&!5$!J29+&!).%!=(2128(/+!$%!#0%!+>$/(3(/(&$(&M!R20!#$&!0(&$*+&!(%&$*$++.%&!R(G%!

29! 5$! 928$1(GJ#$(5! )22*! /$1+>$/(3($J$! =(2128(/+! &$! )$*J$%%$%D! g2$K$1! *$$5+! )$1$! /$1&,>$+!

..%8$50(5! R(G%! .1+! =$1.%8*(GJ$! 9$5(.&2*$%! )22*! 5$! 2%&+&$J(%8! (%! >+2*(.+(+M! R205$%!

/$1+>$/(3($J$! (%#(=(&2*$%! )22*! R2K$1! <e-:Z! $%! 6-eP:Z! J0%%$%! 1$(5$%! &2&! )$*1..85$!

.+>$/(3(/(&$(&!$%!=(G8$)218!9(%5$*!=(GK$*J(%8$%M!R2.1+!>@;F+>$/(3($J$!=(2128(/+D!@$!e.%2=25,F

&$/#%2128($!+&$1&!#($*!$$%!(99$%+!..%&.1!928$1(GJ#$5$%!)22*D!!

g2$K$1! K$! (%! 5$R$! +&05($! 2%+! $%J$1! #$==$%! 8$*(/#&! 2>! >+2*(.+(+./#&(8$! 1.$+($+! .1+! .0&2F

(9900%!925$1!)22*!5$! (%&$*./&($! &0++$%!<e-:Z!$%! 6-eP:ZM!92$&$%!.%5$*$!R($J&$925$11$%!

22J! 2%5$*R2/#&! K2*5$%! R2.1+! 5$! R($J&$! ).%! ;*2#%M! *$09.&2k5$! .*&*(&(+! $%! +>2%5,1(&(+!

.%J,12>2$&(/.D!g2$K$1!#$&!928$1(GJ! (+!5.&!$$%!50==$1$!=12JJ.5$!).%!<e-:Z!$%!6-eP:Z!%($&!

Page 247: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 234 of 237

>$*! +$! $)$%! $33$/&($3! (+! =(G! 5$R$! R($J&$%! .1+! (%! >+2*(.+(+M! =$+&..&! 5$!928$1(GJ#$(5! 5.&!K$! 5$!

>2&$%&(�1$! =(29$*J$*+! (5$%&(3(/$*$%M! .1+22J! 5.&! K$! 5$! *$1$).%&($! ).%! <e-:Z! =12JJ.5$! &$%!

2>R(/#&$!).%!.%&(F<e-!&#$*.>($!=$+&05$*$%D!

! !

Page 248: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 235 of 237

!"#$%&'()*(w!!""#$"%&!

F3**'"383&(L'2#%(

Lynda Grine(

Date of birth: 22nd of February 1987

Nationality: Belgian

Personal address: Hertstraat 4, 9000 Gent, - Belgium

Tel: +3249/28.00.59

E-mail: [email protected]

Experience

Scientific Researcher - VIB, University of Ghent (Zwijnaarde) January 2011-until present

PhD in Biochemistry and Biotechnology under supervision of Prof. Dr. Claude Libert and Dr.

Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke at the Laboratory of Mouse Genetics in Inflammation, Inflammation

Research Center

Scientific coworker - Reliable Cancer Therapies (Strombeek-Beveren) September-December 2010

Freelance scientific coworker, managing database and website content at Reliable Cancer Therapies

Education

PhD in Biochemistry and Biotechnology – University of Ghent January 2011-until present

Doctoral thesis: Profound study of the role of type I Interferons in Tumor Necrosis Factor-mediated

pathologies

Master in Biochemistry and Biotechnology – University of Ghent 2005-2010

Master thesis: Rho GTPase signaling in basal and suprabasal keratinocytes, performed at Biotech

Research & Innovation Centre, University of Copenhagen, Denmark (February-June 2010)

Science and Math (8 hours) – Sint-Lambertusinstituut, Ekeren 1999-2005

Additional courses

Le Français Médical, Ghent 2014

20-hours course by UCT-Ugent

Medical and Scientific Writing, Ghent 2014

Page 249: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 236 of 237

3-day course by Hugin Mugin Research

Drug Discovery Anno 2014, Leuven 2014

2-day course by Flemish Training Network Life Sciences

Basic course Promotion of Health, Brussels 2013

5-day course by the Flemish Institute for Health Promotion and Prevention of Disease

Clinical studies: study design, implementation and reporting, Leuven 2013

2-day course by Doctoral Schools of University of Ghent

Belgian Laboratory Animal Science Course, Ghent 2009

80-hours course for FELASA category C by University of Ghent

First Aid Certificate, Ghent 2009-until present

3-day course by the Red Cross with regular training sessions until present

Fire prevention/fighting course, Ghent 2008

1-day course by the Fire Brigade in cooperation with University of Ghent

Competences and awards

Languages

Dutch: Native proficiency

French: Fluent

English: Fluent (IELTS score: 8.5/9; 2010)

IT skills

Operating systems: MacOSX, Linux (Ubuntu) and Microsoft operating systems

Programming Language: HTML

Software: Microsoft Office and OpenOffice (Word, Excel, Power Point), Adobe Photoshop, Graphpad

Prism, LateX, ImageJ, Mendeley

Life sciences techniques

In vivo work including breeding and genotyping of transgenic mice, handling of animals in various

disease models, protein manipulation (purification, concentration analysis), SDS-PAGE, ELISA,

Western blot, Immunohistochemistrty, Immunofluorescence, Microscopy work, PCR and qPCR

Presentation and communication skills

Posters and talk presentations at national and international meetings

Cytokines, 2012 – Geneva (Switzerland)

Pecha Kucha, 2013 - Zwijnaarde

World Immune Regulation Meeting, 2014 – Davos (Switzerland)

VIB Seminar, 2014 – Blankenberge

Page 250: PhD dissertation Lynda Grine 2014 - Ghent University · =.! =(%+.+1-!! ! ’"!! ! ("!! !)"!

Page 237 of 237

Publications of research articles and reviews

“Dual Inhibition of TNFR1 and IFNAR1 in Imiquimod-Induced Psoriasis Enhances Control of the

Disease.”

Lynda Grine, Lien Dejager, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, and Claude Libert

Plos One - submitted

“An Inflammatory Triangle in Psoriasis: TNF, Type I IFNs and IL-17.”

Lynda Grine, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, Lien Dejager, and Claude Libert

Cytokine & growth factor reviews – accepted for publication

“Unintended Ingestion of Topical Imiquimod in Experimental Psoriasis Can Skew Results.”

Lynda Grine, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, Stefan Lienenklaus, and Claude Libert

In preparation

“TNF-Induced Type I IFNs Control Secretion of IL-17.”

Lynda Grine, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, Lien Dejager, Riet De Rycke, Marlies Ballegeers, Stefan

Lienenklaus, Mario Köster, Ulrich Kalinke, Leo Joosten, and Claude Libert

In preparation

“Antisense Oligonucleotides against TNFR1 Prevent Toxicity of TNF/IFN! Treatment in Mouse

Tumor Models.”, 2014

Filip Van Hauwermeiren, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, Lynda Grine, Leen Puimège, Elien Van

Wonterghem, Hong Zhang, and Claude Libert

International journal of cancer

“TNFR1-Induced Lethal Inflammation Is Mediated by Goblet and Paneth Cell Dysfunction.”, 2014

Filip Van Hauwermeiren, Roosmarijn E. Vandenbroucke, Lynda Grine, Sofie Lodens, Elien Van

Wonterghem, Riet De Rycke, Natalie De Geest, Bassem Hassan, and Claude Libert

Mucosal immunology

Reports and data presentation during strategic meetings

Awards

Innovation by Science & Technology Grant for Doctoral project (Brussels, December 2010)

Pecha Kucha presentation award by Inflammation Research Center (Zwijnaarde, 2013)

Lynda GRINE – +32499/28.00.59 – [email protected]

!!!!