peritoneal dissection and intraperitoneal chemotherapy ... · peritoneal dissection and...
TRANSCRIPT
Peritoneal dissection and
intraperitoneal chemotherapy under
hyperthermic conditions. If you select
the right patients long-term survival
can be achieved.
Chirurgia Avanzata Del Carcinoma Ovarico – Nuove Strategie A Confronto
Ovarian Cancer Advanced Surgery – New Strategies in Comparison
Bergamo, Italy
5-6 May 2011
Paul H. Sugarbaker, MD, FACS, FRCS
Program in Peritoneal Surface Malignancy
Washington Cancer Institute
Washington, DC, USA
Alternative Title:
Discussion regarding the poor long-term
results with CRS and HIPEC:
1. High PCI (concept of extent of disease)
2. Extensive prior surgery (concept of the
peritoneum as the first line of defense
against carcinomatosis)
3. Extensive prior systemic chemotherapy
(concept of natural or acquired drug
resistance)
Discussion regarding the poor long-term
results with CRS and HIPEC:
4. Inadequate perioperative hyperthermic
chemotherapy (concept of pharmacologic
drug selection).
5. Imperfect cytoreduction (concept of CRS
requiring visceral resections and
peritonectomy)
6. Lack of application to ovarian tumors of
low malignant potential (concept of
favorable tumor biology)
Bristow et al., 2007
Extent of disease and survival
Tentes et al., 2009
PCI <13 vs. >13
Are there modifications in patient
management that will result in a reduced
PCI at the time of CRS and HIPEC?
1. CRS + HIPEC as primary management
2. CRS + HIPEC after neoadjuvant
chemotherapy
3. ?
CONCEPT
The peritoneum is the first line of defense ofthe host against peritoneal dissemination ofcancer. If this barrier is disrupted in thepresence of cancer cells, fibrin entrapment atthe wounded site will cause progression deepto the peritoneum. Subsequent efforts totreat carcinomatosis by cytoreductive surgeryand peritonectomy with perioperativeintraperitoneal chemotherapy will bejeopardized.
Prior Surgical Score
Regions dissected
PSS-1 1
PSS-2 2-5
PSS-3 6-9
Tumor cell entrapment as seen on pelvic CT
Effect of prior systemic chemotherapy
Helm et al., 2010
Inadequate perioperative hyperthermic chemotherapy
requires pharmacologic engineering of drugs with
established cytotoxicity
Heat synergized chemotherapy:
Melphalan
Cyclophosphamide
Ifosfamide
Heat augmented chemotherapy:
Cisplatin, oxaliplatin
Doxorubicin
5-fluorouracil
Mitomycin C
Etoposide
No heat effects:
Paclitaxel
Docetaxel
Bidirectional chemotherapy (intraperitoneal
and intravenous)
Application to low malignant potential
(LMP) ovarian tumors with carcinomatosis
that have a less aggressive natural history
1. Low grade papillary serous
2. Mucinous ovarian
3. Granulosa cell
4. Gliomatosis peritonei
5. Pseudomyxoma from ruptured dermoid
cyst
Conclusions
1. The low perceived benefit from CRS
and HIPEC derives from poor patient
selection and suboptimal treatments.
2. Meticulous cytoreduction combined
with perioperative multidrug therapy
are needed in continuing phase II
explorations.
Cytoreductive Surgery and Perioperative
Intraperitoneal Chemotherapy for
Prevention and Treatment of Peritoneal
Surface Malignancy 2011
I. Basic Principles
II. Recent results of treatment
A. Appendiceal
B. Mesothelioma
C. Colorectal
D. Gastric
E. Ovarian
www.peritonealconference2012.com
Pharmacologic concept of bidirectional (IV and IP)
chemotherapy for peritoneal tumor nodules
Outer Layer
Inner core
Intraperitoneal 5-fluorouracil
Intravenous 5-fluorouracil Given in the
Operating Room
Intraperitoneal Gemcitabine
Intravenous Ifosfamide Given in the
Operating Room
Intraperitoneal Doxorubicin Given in the Operating
Room with Heat in Patients with Mucinous Cancer
0.01
0.1
1
10
100
Perit. Fluid
Plasma
Tumor nodules
0 15 30 45 60 90 120
Time (minutes)
Do
xo
rub
icin
(
g/m
L)
Area Under the Curve (IP/IV) for
Chemotherapy Agents Used for HIPEC
Drug Molecular Wt. (Da) AUC ratio
5-fluorouracil 130 250
Mitomycin C 334 75
Doxorubicin 580 230
Cisplatin 300 20
Paclitaxel 808 1000
Gemcitabine 263 500
Melphalan 305 93
Advantages of moderate hyperthermic
intraoperative intraperitoneal chemotherapy
General
Reversal of systemic hypothermia from long surgery
Normalization of blood clotting
Minimal toxicity for normal tissue (<43ºC)
Potentiation of other therapies
Stimulation of host immune system
With chemotherapy
Increased cytotoxicity of chemotherapeutic agents
Increased drug penetration into tissue by increasing membrane permeability
Inhibition of chemotherapy repair mechanisms
Reversal of drug resistance
With manual distribution
Mechanical debridement of cancer cells from tissue surfaces
Uniform treatment of hyperthermia and chemotherapy solution
Absence of unexposed surfaces
Absence of suture line recurrence
Credits and debits of two different technologies for hyperthermic intraperitoneal chemotherapy
Open abdomen manually distributed Closed abdomen
EfficiencyAllows continued cytoreduction of bowel and
mesenteric surfacesNo surgery possible during chemotherapy
Environmental hazard No aerosols detected Perception of increased safety
Distribution
Uniform distribution of heat and chemotherapy
solutions, tissues close to skin edge not
immersed
Possible poor distribution to dependent sites and
closed spaces
Pressure No increased intraabdominal pressureIncreased intraabdominal pressure may increase
chemotherapy penetration into tissue
PharmacologyAllows pharmacokinetic monitoring of tumor and
normal tissueTissue uptake of chemotherapy cannot be determined
Abdominal incision and suture lines Treated prior to performing the suturingRisk of recurrence in abdominal incision and suture
lines
Diaphragm perforation with
peritonectomy
Pleural space treated by hyperthermic chemotherapy
may prevent seeding of pleural space
Diaphragm closed prior to hyperthermic
intraperitoneal chemotherapy so pleural space
is not treated
Intestinal perforation Detected by observing immersed bowel loops Not detected
Hyperthermia Increased heat necessary to maintain 42°C Less heat required to maintain 42°C
The peritoneum is the “First Line of Defense” for
cancer spread in the abdomen and pelvis.
Surgical interventions in the presence of free
intraperitoneal cancer cells can promote deep
implantation and jeopardize benefit from CRS
(Cytoreductive Surgery) and PIC (Perioperative
Intraperitoneal Chemotherapy).
Survival by Histopathology in Appendiceal Cancer: DPAM vs. PMCA
All Patients – A; Patients with complete cytoreduction – B
Extent of Disease as Measured by the
Peritoneal Cancer Index
Survival by Peritoneal Cancer Index in Appendix Cancer:
1-20 vs. 20-39 -- DPAM and PMCA
Survival by Extent of Prior Surgery in Appendix Cancer:
DPAM and PMCA
Survival by Completeness of Cytoreduction:DPAM and PMCA
Cytoreductive surgery and hyperthermic intraperitoneal
chemotherapy for malignant peritoneal mesothelioma:
multi-institutional experience
Tristan D. Yan, Marcello Deraco, Dario Baratti, Shigeki Kusamura, Dominique Elias, Olivier
Glehen, Francois N. Gilly, Edward A. Levine, Perry Shen, Faheez Mohamed, Brendan J.
Moran, David L. Morris, Terence C. Chua, Pompiliu Piso, and Paul H. Sugarbaker
J Clin Oncol 27:6237-6242, 2009
Survival after CRS and HIPEC in 401
Patients with Peritoneal Mesothelioma
Peritoneal Colorectal Carcinomatosis Treated With
Surgery and Perioperative Intraperitoneal Chemotherapy:
Retrospective Analysis of 523 Patients From a
Multicentric French Study
Dominique Elias, François Gilly, Florent Boutitie, François Quenet, Jean-Marc Bereder,
Baudouin Mansvelt, Gérard Lorimier, Pierre Dubè, Olivier Glehen
J Clin Oncol 28:63-68, 2010
Peritoneal carcinomatosis from gastric
cancer: a multi-institutional study of 159
patients treated by cytoreductive
surgery combined with perioperative
intraperitoneal chemotherapy
Olivier Glehen, Francois Gilly, Catherine Arvieux, Eddy Cotte, et al.
Annals of Surgical Oncology (in press)
Survival and Disease-Free Survival of 159 Gastric
Cancer Patients with Carcinomatosis Treated with
CRS and HIPEC
Survival of Gastric Cancer Patients by
Completeness of Cytoreduction
Survival of Gastric Cancer Patients by
Peritoneal Cancer Index
A Systematic Review and Meta-
analysis of the Randomized
Controlled Trials on Adjuvant
Intraperitoneal Chemotherapy for
Resectable Gastric Cancer
Tristan D. Yan, Deborah Black, Paul H. Sugarbaker, Jacqui Zhu, et al.
Ann Surg Oncol,14:2702-2713, 2007
Forest Plot of Overall Survival at 3 Years
Hyperthermic intraperitoneal
chemotherapy in ovarian cancer.
First report of the HYPER-O Registry
Cyril W. Helm, Scott D. Richard, Jianmin Pan, David Bartlett, et al.
Int J Gynecol Oncol, 20:60-61, 2010
Kaplan-Meier Curve Survival Probability by
Platinum Response
Kaplan-Meier Curve Survival Probability by
CC Score
Kaplan-Meier Curve Survival Probability by
Time Point HIPEC Used
Conclusions
1. A strong rationale from tumor biology
and the pharmacologic advantages of
local-regional chemotherapy combine to
recommend treatments to manage
carcinomatosis.
2. When treatments are available at
experienced centers CRS and PIC are
reasonable treatment options for
appendiceal cancer, mesothelioma and
low volume carcinomatosis.
3. Adjuvant perioperative intraperitoneal
chemotherapy has been found beneficial
in numerous single institution phase III
trials.
4. The standard of care for peritoneal
surface malignancy varies greatly around
the globe form experimental to standard
of care.