7/28/2019 Pd 36's Article

1/4

7/28/2019 Pd 36's Article

2/4

2012 rwfv ygvDrefrSm owWKwGif;0ef}uD;Xme (1) eJ@ (2) tygt0if 0ef}uD;Xme 6 ck pm&if;vdrfr_/ tvGJoHk;pm;vkyfr_awGudk

pm&if;ppfcsKyftpD&ifcHpmrSm wifjyvmwJhudpP aqG;aEG;cJh&+yD; aumfr&SifzGJ@zdk@xd jzpfvmygw,f?6 7

=o*kwfvrSmawmh pm&if;ppfcsKyfAdkvfcsKyfa[mif;vGef;armif &mxl;zwfcH&ygw,f?

urBmrSm a=u;eDtxGufqHk;a'o[m csDvDEdkifiH jzpfygw,f? Zefe)g&D 2011 rSm umuG,fa&;0ef}uD;&mxl;uxGufay;&wJhudpP[m csDvDppfwyfudk EdkifiHydkifa=u;eDrdkif;u 0ifaiG&J@ 10 &mE_ef; yHhydk;&wJhOya'eJ@ EdkifiHjcm;u ppfvufeufypPnf;0,f,lwifoGif;wJh yrm%udk v#dK@0SufzHk;uG,fr_awGa=umifhyg? wkwfu 0,ftm;vdkufvdk@ urBmha=u;eDaps;wuf+yD; csDvDEdkifiH&J@

a=u;eDu&wJh 0ifaiG[m 2010 rSm 434 &mE_ef;xd xdk;wufoGm;wmrdk@/ 2006 - 2009 ESpfaemufydkif;rSm umuG,fa&;bwf*sufudka':vm 43 bDvsH v$Jay;EdkifcJhw,f?

9

Armppftm%m&Sifacwf rdkif;vkyfief;wdk;csJ@zdk@ a'ocHawmifolawGxHu trdef@tm%meJ@ t"rRtEdkifusifhodrf;,lcJhwJh 26 &Gmuajr,mrsm; {uaygif; 7800 udk xdkufoifhwJhajrwefzdk; avsmfa=u;ray;bJ 3 ESpfpm oD;ESHwGufomay;cJh+yD; aemufawmhajrtwGuf

ay;wmygvdk@ avoHajymif;oGm;ygw,f?10 11

2012 Edk0ifbm 29 rSm vufyHawmif;oydwfpcef;udk t=urf;zufzcGJcJhjcif;[m jynfolvlxktusdK;pD;yGm;udk vHk;0rsufuG,fy+yD;

wdkif;wyg;tusdK;pD;yGm;eJ@ wyfrawmfydkif tusdK;pD;yGm;udkom umuG,fjcif;jzpfw,fvdk@ nD!Gwfaomwdkif;&if;om;vlrsdK;rsm;zuf'&,faumifpD (UNFC) u qdkygw,f? a':atmifqef;pk=unfudk vufyHawmif;aumfr&SifOuUXwm0ef ay;vdkufwmqdk&ifvnf;

tpdk;&&J@ rw&m;wJhvkyf&yfwckvdk@ ajymygw,f?12

a':pkudk AdkuftiSm;eJ@ "m;xdk;cHcdkif;wmygyJ?a':pkudk AdkuftiSm;eJ@ "m;xdk;cHcdkif;wmygyJ?a':pkudk AdkuftiSm;eJ@ "m;xdk;cHcdkif;wmygyJ?a':pkudk AdkuftiSm;eJ@ "m;xdk;cHcdkif;wmygyJ?

cufwmu a':atmifqef;pk=unfudk,fEd_ufu =unf=unfjzLjzL toHk;cscHHkru tpD&ifcHpmxGufvmawmh bufpHkatmifoufaoouUm,&SmazGaphikxm;wm r[kwfbJ/ cHkorm"dtvkyfr[kwfwJh EdkifiHawmfzGH@z;wdk;wufa&; OD;wnfcsufudk ta=umif;jy+yD;rsufESm}uD;&m [if;zwfygxm;wmjzpfaevdk@ vufyHawmif;u jynfolvlxkcrsmrsm;rSm vkyf&ufavjcif;vdk@

&ifxkremjzpf=u&awmhw,f?13

OpPmodkufrsm;[m usdefpmwdkufxm;wwfw,fvdk@ a&S;vl}uD;olrawG ajym=uwm =um;zl;=urSmyg? 18 &mpkacwfabm*aA'ynm&Sif t'rfprpf (Adam Smith) wdk@ vufxufup+yD; o,HZmwu,f0r_qdkwm aumif;usdK;ray;wJhtjyif

qdk;usdK;&wwfa=umif; a[mudef;&SdcJhzl;ygw,f?14

o,HZmwusdefpm (o,HZmwusdefpm (o,HZmwusdefpm (o,HZmwusdefpm (Resource Curse) qdkwJhpum; ay:vmcJhw,f?) qdkwJhpum; ay:vmcJhw,f?) qdkwJhpum; ay:vmcJhw,f?) qdkwJhpum; ay:vmcJhw,f?

ckacwfrSmawmh *sufz&Dqufpf (Jefferey Sachs) eJ@ tif'l;0gem (Andrew Warner) wdk@u 97 EdkifiHudk 1971 - 89umvtwGif; oHk;oyfxm;wJh pmwrf;rSm o,HZmwu,fwJh EdkifiHawGu ru,fwJhEdkifiHawGxuf zGH@z;wdk;wufr_rSmaemufususefaecJhwm awG@&w,f? 2007 rSmawmh 'ifeD,,fvD'grif (Daniel Lederman) eJ@ 0DvsHrvdkeD (William Maloney)wdk@u o,HZmwqdkwm usdefpmvnf;r[kwf a&S;qkawmif;jynfhwmvnf;r[kwf/ aumif;usdK;qdk;usdK; ESpfrsdK;vHk;ay;Edkif+yD; wEdkifiHcsif;&J@

udkifwG,fr_ay:vpDtay:rSmwnfa=umif; oHk;oyfjyygw,f?14

urBmhb%fu xkwfjyefwJh EdkifiHtpdk;&rsm;tkyfcsKyfr_eJ@wm0ef,lr_pHrsm; (governance and accountability) ppfwrf;rSm

o,HZmwu,fwJh EdkifiHrsm;[m tqifhedrfhusaewm axmufjyxm;ygw,f? EdkifiHa&; r+idrfoufr_/ t=urf;zufr_/ wm0efrJhr_/w&m;Oya'pdk;rdk;a&; tm;enf;r_/ jcm;vmbfpm;r_awG ayGvdrf_yfaewm awG@&w,f? jynfwGif;tcGefaiGaumufcHr_udkawmh

=uyf=uyfrwfrwf rvkyfEdkifbJ a&eHowWKodkufu 0ifaiGudk t"dutm;xm;ae&wJhtjyif tm%m&tkyfpdk;ol vlwef;pm;eJ@pD;yGm;bufawGomv#if 'Dvkyfief;}uD;awGudk tkyfpD;+yD; EdkifiHa&;t&/ w&m;Oya't& t[ef@twm;tuef@towfr&SdtusdK;tjrwfawGudk cGJa0cHpm;=uavawmh wdkif;jynfrSm csrf;omolawGu }ud}udwuf rw&m;csrf;om/ usefwJhjynfol

trsm;pk}uD;rawmh qif;&JwGif; eufoxufeufvmwJh om"uawG jzpfygw,f?14

jyifopfEdkifiHuawmh Oa&myEdkifrsm;rS 'DpD;yGm;a&;vkyfief;ukr%DawGudk EdkifiHjcm;tdrf&SifEdkifiHtpdk;&rsm;tm;

ay;acswJhaiGa=u;yrm% b,fa&G@b,fr#qdkwm ydk*sufwckcsif; xkwfjyefa=unmzdk@ wGef;tm;ay;vmygw,f?

tvm;wltar&duefrSmvnf; u;yrf;vmolawG &Sdygw,f?14

7/28/2019 Pd 36's Article

3/4

orRwuvifwef&J@ twdkifyifcHeJ@ urBmhb%fabm*aA' OD;pD;csKyfa[mif; abm*aA'Edkb,fqk&Sif *sdK;qufpwpf*vpfZf(Joseph Stiglitz) u wGufjywJh o,HZmwusefpmoifhr_&J@ vuQ%moHk;&yfrSm -1? ol@t&SdefeJ@ aiGaps;wufr_a=umifh EdkifiHjcm;0,foltwGuf tjcm;xGufukefypPnf;rsm; aps;}uD;+yD; ta&mif;usjcif;?2? a&eHowWKxkwfazmfa&;vkyfief;rsm; obm0t& a'ocHawGudk tvkyfr,fr,f&& ray;Edkifjcif;?3? urBmhaps;uGuf rwnf+idrfr_a=umifh wuf;aps;rSm b%frsm; aiGtvHk;t&if;eJ@ 0ifcsvm+yD; usaps;rSmawmh

uokwfu&ufjyefxGufoGm;wwfjcif;?15

ajratmufo,HZmwypPnf;ujzpfwJh bmpD;yGm;udk ajray:ukefxkwfvkyfa&; pdkufysdK;a&;uawGrSm &if;ESD;jrKyfESHr_r&SdbJay,smvuefycJh&if trsm;pkvlxk qif;&Jzdk@ygyJ? 'DxJrSm tm%mydkifrsm;u oldk@rdarGzarGvdk atmufarh&if oldk@csif;pm;cGufvk=ur,fhtjyif/ EdkifiHhpnf;pdrftvGJoHk;pm;vkyfwJh tpdk;&eJ@ 'Drdkua&pD rxGef;um;EdkifwJh wdkif;jynfb0rSm w0Jvnfvnf

jzpfae&OD;rSmyg?15

ajr}uD;xJu o,HZmwqdkwm b,frSxGufrajy;ygbl;? jznf;jznf;csif; vufvDpdwf+yD; xkwfpm;aevdk@vnf; jzpfwJhudpPyg?

tcGeftwkwfudkvnf; aoaocsmcsmxdkufoifhatmifaumuf+yD; wdkif;jynf&J@ vrf;yef;qufoG,fa&; tajccHtaqmufttHk/vlxktwGuf usef;rma&;/ ynma&;eJ@ jynfwGif;pD;yGm;a&; (v,f,meJ@pufr_/ ukefacsma&m vufeufud&d,myg)

xkwfvkyfr_xGef;um;a&;awGrSm &if;ESD;jrKyfESHoifhw,fqdkwm tus,fw0ifh&Sif;jyzdk@awmif rvdkyg?15

'ghtjyif aiGvJE_ef;rjrifhzdk@/ pD;yGm;a&;wnf+idrfr_ ta&;ay:&efyHkaiGxm;zdk@/ wEdkifiHvHk; au;jrDrsm; txdef;tuGyf&Sdzdk@eJ@vufrSwfxdk;+yD; uefxdkufawGudk jyefvnf!dEd_if;zdk@ ta&;qdkcGifhvnf; udk,fhrSm&Sdoifhygw,f? 'grSom wzufapmif;eif; olomudk,fem

udkvdkeDyHkpH jyefra&mufrSmyg? u|efb0uvnf; ckvdk wdkif;jynf&J@o,HZmw opfawmutp qefpyg;tv,fa&eHausmufoHywWjrm;tqHk; xkwf,lwJhpepf xGef;um;cJhygw,f? 'g[m udkvdkeDpHepf&J@ tajccHtkwfjrpfyg? a&vrf;omru&xm;vrf;um;vrf;azmuf/ wHwm;aqmuf/ a=u;eef;oG,fwmawG[m Armjynfolvlxkudk apwemarwWm&SdvGef;vdk@ vkyfay;cJhwm

r[kwfygbl;? pnf;pdrfukefo,f,l uJh,lEdkifatmif/ wmoGm;Edkifor# xda&mufwGifus,fr_&Sdatmif pHepfwusvHk;yef;oGm;wmyg?15

tckvnf; EdkifiHjcm;ukr%DawGtaeeJ@ p&dwfpu tcGeftoufomqHk;eJ@ tjrwftrsm;qHk; olwdk@zdk@usefatmif aps;ESdrfEdkifor#

ESdrfay;csifovdk/ udk,fhbufuvnf; aps;aumif;aumif;&csifwm[m obm0yg? wdkif;jynftwGuf taumif;qHk;jzpfzdk@qdk&ifvufodyfxkd;+yD; vufoifh&mpm;awmfac:wmrsdK; rvkyfbJ avvHtyifqGJcdkif;zdk@eJ@ pm&if;tif;rSmvnf; b,fol@udk b,fa&G@b,fr#ay;&w,fqdkwm yGifhvif;=unfvifr_&Sdzdk@/ pmcsKyfpmwrf;rsm;vnf; xdk@twl/ urBmhaygufaps;wufwJhtcgrSmvnf; ukr`%Dwckwnf;

r[kwfbJ vlxkw&yfvHk; tusdK;tjrwfcHpm;Edkifatmif csnfxm;+yD; jzpfoihfygw,f?15

wcg ypPnf;dkif;ukef=urf;oufoufcsnf; a&mif;pm;r,fhtpm;/ ukefacsmtqifhxd jynfwGif;rSm xkwfvkyfEdkifzdk@/ wl;azmfa&;

,EW&m;wpdwfwydkif; tenf;qHk; jynfwGif;rSm xkwfvkyfEdkifzdk@qdkwmudk pOf;pm;pDrHoifhw,f? 'grSomv#if wdkif;jynftwGuf wu,fwrf;a&&SnftusdK; jzpfxGef;r,f?

o,HZmwo,HZmwo,HZmwo,HZmwusdefpmudk ewfok"usdefpmudk ewfok"usdefpmudk ewfok"usdefpmudk ewfok"mjzpfvmapr,fmjzpfvmapr,fmjzpfvmapr,fmjzpfvmapr,f

qdkwmudk *sdK;ZufpwpfuvpfZfu tus,fw0ifha&;om;xm;ygw,f?15

a':atmifqef;pk=unfudk,fwdkifu wEdkifiHvHk;tusdK;&Sdzdk@ awmifawGawmh aysmufrSmyJqdkvmawmh

obm0ywf0ef;usifysufokOf;r_/ a'ocHawmifolawG tdrfaysmuf,maysmuf tdk;vHk;arSmufjzpf&r_/ aomufa&oHk;a& tqdyfjzpfr_/v,fwDq&mawmfausmif;eJ@ apwDvnf; zsuf&r,fqkdwmawG tm;vHk;[m pGef@v$wfxdkufwJh ta&;ryg t&mra&mufwJhtEknmwudpPrsm;om jzpfoGm;ygw,f? eufeufeJeJrpOf;pm;bJeJ@awmif wEdkifiHvHk;tusdK;qdkwm [kwfrSvnf;vkyfyg

AdkvfcsKyf}uD;a':pk&,fvdk@ ar;csifp&m jzpfaeygw,f?csDvDEDkifiHu a=u;eDrdkif;}uD;[m tESpfw&meD;yg;rSm rufx&pfwefcsdef 29 oef; xGufcJh+yD; tvsm; 43 uDvdkrDwm/ teH 3

uDvdkrDwm/ 850 rDwm teuf&Sdygw,f?16

urBmht}uD;qHk;uawmh tar&duefjynfaxmifpk ,lwm;e,f (Utah) u bif*rfcsdKifh}uD; (Bingham Canyon) a=u;eDwGif;yg?

4 uDvdkrDwmywfvnf us,f0ef;+yD; 12 uDvdkrDwmxdatmif eufd_if;wJh {&meEWwGif;}uD;yg?17

'Dvdkqdk&if rHk&Gma=u;eDrdkif;&J@ yrm%udk rSef;qvdk@&Edkifrvm;? aemuf 10 ESpfrSm anmifyif}uD;uae zdk;0if;awmifxd&SdaerSmvm;? 'De,fole,fom;awG b,fqDoGm;vdk@ bmvkyfpm;=urvJ? ,kZewdk@ aZurBmwdk@ ydk*sufawGvnf; ol&if;iSm;rsm;rsm; rvkd?0rfaygifOD;ydkifowWKodkuf}uD;uvnf; ae@pm;rsm;rsm;rvdk? csif;wGif;jrpf}uD;xJ woGifoGifpD;aewJha&uaum aomufvdk@oHk;vdk@

7/28/2019 Pd 36's Article

4/4