parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/fulltext01.pdf · parametric...

46
Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks Växjö, 2013-05-31 Mechanical Engineering Authors: Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson and Linu Kuttikal Joseph Supervisor, LNU: Andreas Linderholt Examiner: Andreas Linderholt Semester: Spring 2013, 15 credits Course code: 4MT01E

Upload: dotruc

Post on 17-Mar-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a

transfer case for trucks

Växjö, 2013-05-31

Mechanical Engineering

Authors:

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson and Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Supervisor, LNU: Andreas Linderholt

Examiner: Andreas Linderholt

Semester: Spring 2013, 15 credits

Course code: 4MT01E

Page 2: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

II

Organization /Organisation Författare/Authors

Linnaeus University, Växjö, Sweden Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson and

School of Engineering Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Linnéuniversitetet, Växjö, Sverige

Institution för teknik

Dokumenttyp/Type of Document Handledare/Tutor Examinator/Examiner

Examensarbete/Master thesis Andreas Linderholt Andreas Linderholt

Title and subtitle Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks

Summary

This thesis work consists of an investigation of design changes of a dog clutch. The dog clutch

studied is being used in the transfer case of trucks having four wheel drives.

Normally the trucks with four wheel drive option will be running in rear wheel drives and the

front wheels will be rotating freely. In extreme tough driving conditions, the risk for slipping of

the rear wheels or getting stopped in mud is high. By using four wheel drives, which makes all the

wheels drive the vehicle, the traction and the maneuverability of the vehicle will be high. When

the driver tries to engage the four wheel drive option, due to the difference in relative rotational

speed of the dog clutch parts, there is a risk for slipping off or bouncing back of the dog clutch.

Therefore it is inevitable to improve the dog clutch design to increase the performance while

engaging the four wheel drives when the vehicle is running. Here, the gear geometry and a few

parameters of the dog clutch is modified. The efficiency of the new design found satisfactory

when simulated in MSC ADAMS.

Keywords

Dog Clutch, Four wheel drive, MSC ADAMS, Multibody dynamics, Latin Hypercube,

SolidWorks.

Page 3: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

III

Abstract

Normally the trucks with four wheel drive option will be running in rear wheel drives and the

front wheels will be rotating freely. In extreme tough driving conditions, the risk for getting

stopped or slipping the rear wheels in mud is high. When the driver tries to engage the four wheel

drive option and due to the difference in relative rotational speed of the dog clutch parts, there is a

risk for slipping off or bouncing back of the dog clutch.

After studying the importance of gear geometry and a few parameters, the team ended up with a

new design and the performance of the design found satisfactory when simulated in MSC

ADAMS.

Utgivningsår/Year of issue Språk/Language Antal sidor/Number of pages

2013 Engelska/English 41

Page 4: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

IV

Acknowledgement

This thesis work would not have been possible without the guidance and the help of

several individuals who in one way or another contributed and extended their valuable

assistance in the preparation and completion of this study.

First and foremost, our utmost gratitude to our lecturer Andreas Linderholt (School of

Engineering, Linnaeus University, Växjö, Sweden) for supervising this thesis work.

Second, Mr. Hans Hansson and Ms. Karolina Årdh, technical engineers working for

SwePart Transmission AB, Liatorp, Sweden for giving the opportunity to conduct this

thesis work and explaining the concern moreover to provide us with the necessary

information.

Page 5: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

V

Table of contents

1. Introduction ......................................................................................................1

1.1 Background ...................................................................................................................................... 1

1.2 Problem description ....................................................................................................................... 2

1.3 Purpose and goals ........................................................................................................................... 3

1.4 Limitations ........................................................................................................................................ 4

2. Theory .............................................................................................................. 5

2.1 MSC ADAMS2, the multi body simulation software .......................................................... 5

2.2 SolidWorks ....................................................................................................................................... 6

2.3 System engineering......................................................................................................................... 7

2.4 Product development ..................................................................................................................... 8

2.5 Structural Dynamics ...................................................................................................................... 9

2.6 Global and Local coordinate system ...................................................................................... 10

2.6.1 Global Coordinate system9 .................................................................................................. 10

2.6.2 Local coordinate system9 ..................................................................................................... 11

2.7 Latin Hypercube ........................................................................................................................... 12

3. Literature review ............................................................................................ 13

4. Method ............................................................................................................ 14

4.1 The main methods ........................................................................................................................ 14

4.4 Drawings in SolidWorks ............................................................................................................ 19

4.5 Analysis in MSC ADAMS .......................................................................................................... 19

5. Result ............................................................................................................. 20

5.1 Simulation results ...................................................................................................................... 20

5.2 Simulation procedure ............................................................................................................... 21

5.3 Result summary ......................................................................................................................... 22

6. Discussions and Conclusions ......................................................................... 25

7. References ...................................................................................................... 26

8. Appendix........................................................................................................ 28

Page 6: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

1

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

1. Introduction

1.1 Background

This thesis work is carried out in collaboration with SwePart Transmission AB at

Liatorp, Sweden as a partial fulfillment of the master program in mechanical

engineering at Linnaeus University in Växjö, Sweden.

In the year of 1945, the two brothers Bertil Bengtsson and Axel Bengtsson

started the engineering workshop Mekan AB, at Hultaberg in the southern part of

Sweden. The business was to manufacture screw-vices, brass-spindles and

hydraulic equipments. Later in the year 1995 Mekan AB changed its name to

SwePart Transmission AB; an ISO 9001 engineering company which designs

and manufactures most precised gears, shafts, cross joints, gear boxes according

to the customers’ specifications. In 2008 Swepart Transmission AB had a

turnover of around 350 million SEK.

This thesis work consists of the investigation of a transfer case used in trucks

with four wheel drives. Usually the trucks with four wheel drive option will be

running in rear wheel drives and the front wheels will be rotating freely. In

extreme tough driving conditions, the risk for slipping of the rear wheels or

getting stopped in mud is high. By using four wheel drives, which makes all the

wheels drive the vehicle, the traction and the maneuverability of the vehicle will

be high. The four wheel drive is engaged by a shift lever which is positioned near

to the gear lever in the drivers’ cabin, see figure 1. When it is engaged, the front

wheels also have driving torque from the engine through the dog clutch which is

positioned inside the transfer case. The location of the transfer case is between

the transmission and the rear differential, see figure 2.

Figure 1. Position of 4x4 shift lever14

Page 7: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

2

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

1.2 Problem description

Generally the trucks have rear wheel drives whereas the front wheels are rotating

freely. This can be changed into four wheel drives using a dog clutch which is

positioned inside a unit called a transfer case, see figure 2. The engagement and

disengagement of the dog clutch inside the transfer case is controlled by the

driver from the drivers cabin using a shift lever mechanism, see figure 1. If the

truck is forced to stop or get stuck on a slippery surface with full pay load, it may

be hard to move the vehicle from rest even after engaging the four wheel drives.

Moreover, while trying to engage the four wheel drives without stopping the

truck, at times, the dog clutch will bounce back which often makes metallic noise

without engaging. This is happening because the angular velocities between the

two dog clutch halves are not equal.

Figure 2. Location of Transfer case1

One solution is to first design a transfer case with a synchronizer and then to use

sensors for the wheels for measuring the rotation continuously. The data from the

sensors calculate the slip of the rear wheels thus engaging the four wheel drives

automatically if required. Since the solution involve high manufacturing cost, our

team was challenged to come up with another solution.

That solution is to make necessary design change of the dog clutch.

Page 8: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

3

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

1.3 Purpose and goals

The purpose of this thesis work is to evaluate the importance of the gear

geometry, mass, rotational speed, material stiffness and engagement force in the

dog clutch being used in four wheel drives trucks and to investigate whether the

existing design can be improved or not.

For the simulations, MSC ADAMS is utilized.

Page 9: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

4

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

1.4 Limitations

A ten week thesis period is insufficient for a bigger project like the parametric

study of a dog clutch.

In MSC ADAMS, simplification of a real truck is used. This truck model is

made rigid and not flexible. However in reality, the vehicle parts behave like

flexible bodies.

Lack of knowledge in parameters like mass moment of inertia of rotating shafts,

stiffness of the material and mass of the parts ended up with simplifications.

The parameters such as friction and engagement acceleration of the dog clutch

have a constants value.

The team is lacking knowledge in the simulation program, MSC ADAMS.

Moreover the testing will be carried out in a later stage, this is outside the scope

of this thesis work.

Page 10: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

5

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2. Theory

2.1 MSC ADAMS2, the multi body simulation software

Automated Dynamic Analysis of Mechanical Systems, MSC ADAMS, was

developed in the year 1963 by MSC Software Corporation in Santa Ana,

California, U.S.A.

MSC ADAMS is a software with which engineers can investigate and simulate

mechanical systems regarding dynamics, statics and kinematics.

MSC ADAMS can simulate how a vehicle will perform for different road

conditions. Before using MSC ADAMS, many automobile manufactures

conducted real tests on test tracks to study the performance as a function of

different parameter settings.

Page 11: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

6

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.2 SolidWorks

SolidWorks 3

was created in the year 1993 in Waltham, Massachusetts, U.S.A.

SolidWorks is a 3D CAD ( Computer Aided Design) that contains three different

modes such as, part, assembly and drawing. Part is used to make both 2D and 3D

drawings. Assembly is used to assemble several parts into one model. The last

mode is used to prepare the drawings.

SolidWorks has over 1.4 million users in more than 165 000 companies all over

the world.

SolidWorks4 is being used in several businesses, such as mechanical industries,

educations, medical, scientific etc. Every year Dassault Systèmes, the owner of

SolidWorks, releases a new version of the program with new functionalities.

Finite element analysis can be made using SolidWorks simulation. Calculations

can be made of component stresses, displacements and strains under internal and

external loadings such as;

Pressures

Forces

Temperatures

Accelerations

Contact between components

Page 12: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

7

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.3 System engineering

Figure 3. Life cycle approach in system engineering6

System engineering is a tool assisting in product development. To use system

engineering as a tool, the lifecycle procedure can be utilized, see figure 3. It has

eight different steps describing how to develop a new product. System

engineering 4MT014, is a course given at Linnaeus University in Växjö.

These steps in the lifecycle approach may be iterated if required and some may

be eliminated.

The philosophy of the lifecycle approach can be useful in any system at all

levels.

Page 13: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

8

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.4 Product development

The goal of product development7 is to bring something new that satisfy the

customers need and preferably surpasses their need.

Product development is about finding a balance between four different subjects.

These subjects are technology, environmental effects, production and economy.

The eight stages used for product development are13

1) Idea Generation.

- Making SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities

and Threats).

- New ideas are created around the new product , some of these

ideas are implemented.

2) Idea Screening.

- Will this satisfy the customers?

- Will this be gainful when manufactured and supplied at the aim

price?

3) Concept Development and Testing.

- Improve both engineering and marketing details.

- How can this product be manufactured most cost effectively?

- What profits will the product incorporate?

4) Business Analysis.

5) Beta Testing and Market Testing.

6) Technical Implementation.

- Supply estimation.

- Requirement publication.

- Announce technical communications such as data sheets.

- Contingencies – what – if planning.

7) Commercialization.

- Introduction the product.

8) New Product Pricing.

- Impact of new product on the entire product portfolio.

- Product cost.

These stages can be iterated if needed and some can even be eliminated.

Page 14: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

9

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.5 Structural Dynamics

Dynamics8 deals with the study of bodies using tests and mathematical models.

In the field of engineering, structural dynamics use the principle of virtual

displacements which eliminates the necessity of using interaction forces directly.

Even though this can be used to derive the equations of motion for multi degree

of freedom (MDOF) system, it is much more convenient and simpler to use the

Lagrange’s equation shown in equation (1).

(

)

[Equation 1]

17

T: Kinetic energy

V: Potential energy

L = T – V [Equation 2]

The equations of motion are used to describe the behaviors of physical systems.

It describes the physical system behavior in terms of time and displacements at

spatial coordinates.

In general the equation can be written in the form:

( )

M: Mass matrix

C: Damping matrix

K: Stiffness matrix

f(t): Force vector

u: Displacement response vector

This will allow the use of scalar quantities such as work, potential energy and

kinetic energy instead of vector quantities such as force and acceleration.

Moreover this can be derived from principle of virtual displacements or extended

Hamilton’s principle.

Page 15: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

10

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.6 Global and Local coordinate system

2.6.1 Global Coordinate system9

The global coordinate gives the frame in which the model is based. To filter the

useful information from this environment, it is inevitable to study from the

multiple phased arrays. These arrays denote the location from its own local

coordinate system. In order to arrange this kind of information from each phased

array into a global coordinate, it is necessary to know the position and location of

each array in global coordinate system.

For example in figure 4 shown below, the object is the black sphere. The thick

black axes represent the coordinate axes of the global coordinate system.

However, two phased arrays 1 and 2 in figure 4, represent their own coordinate

system within the global coordinates which is represented by dashed line. While

specifying a global coordinate system, it designates any point as the origin and

the coordinate axes must be orthogonal.

Figure 4. Defining global coordinate system

Page 16: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

11

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.6.2 Local coordinate system9

Local coordinates are expressed by phased arrays placed within the global

coordinate system. The local origin may be defined anywhere in the global

coordinate system and need not be stationary.

For example the figure 5 illustrates a local right-handed coordinate system:

Figure 5. Defining local coordinate system

Page 17: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

12

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

2.7 Latin Hypercube

The Latin hypercube10

method generates combinations of parameter values,

using stratified samplings. This is to generate samples of combinations of

parameter values from a multidimensional distribution and is normally used for

uncertainty analysis.

This method was first described by McKay in 1979. In this type of sampling, a

square grid containing sample positions is a latin square if and only if there is

only one sample in each row and column. For example when sampling X

variables, the range of each variable is divided into Y equally intervals. Then Y

sample points are fixed to satisfy the Latin hypercube requirement which

determines the number of divisions, Y, which should be equal to each variable.

Choose the number of simulation tests required, maximum and minimum values

for each parameter. Finally inserting these values in Matlab gives output for

making the simulations in MSC ADAMS.

Page 18: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

13

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

3. Literature review

This thesis work sets out from previous work, here referred to, made at Linnaeus

University, Växjö.

In the first thesis work made by two former students at Linnaeus University, the

dog clutch geometry was analyzed using the FEM code Abaqus. In their thesis12

work, analyses of how the contact pressure acts on the clutch teeth and how that

changed as a result of parameter changes such as chamfer distance, chamfer

angles, teeth angle and number of teeth was made.

In second thesis11

the dog clutch engagement was analyzed with help of MSC

ADAMS instead of Abaqus, including these parameters.

By determining the moment of inertia and stiffness of the rotating drive shafts

they made a model in MSC ADAMS see in figure 6. The dog clutch was

connected with a torsion spring to a cylinder (number 3) with a mass moment of

inertia, finally the dog clutch (number 1 and 2) is engaging through an

engagement force.

Figure 6. Dog clutch engagement in MSC ADAMS

This thesis work investigated a new design idea from Swepart Transmission AB.

Here the geometry of the teeth for dog clutch was analyzed and compared to the

existing design.

Page 19: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

14

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

4. Method

4.1 The main methods

The parameter combinations studied in this thesis work stem from a Latin

hypercube sampling using Matlab. SolidWorks is used for designing the dog

clutch and MSC ADAMS, is used for dynamic simulation.

4.2 Defining gear terminology15

Figure 7. Gear terminology

Page 20: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

15

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Definition of terms15

:

Top land: Top land is the (sometimes flat) surface of the top of a gear tooth.

Bottom land: The bottom land is the surface at the bottom of a gear tooth space

adjoining the fillet.

Face width: It is the length of teeth in an axial plane. For double helical, it does

not include the gap.

Face: The Face of a gear tooth is the upper half of the gear tooth contact area.

Flank: The Flank of a gear tooth is the lower half of the gear tooth contact area.

Circular pitch: Distance from one face of a tooth to the corresponding face of an

adjacent tooth on the same gear, measured along the pitch circle.

Circular thickness: Length of arc between the two sides of a gear tooth, on the

specified datum circle.

Chordal pitch: Distance from one face of a tooth to the corresponding face of an

adjacent tooth on the same gear, measured straight from one point to another.

Pitch circle: Circle centered on and perpendicular to the axis, and passing

through the pitch point. A predefined diametric position on the gear where the

circular tooth thickness, pressure angle and helix angles are defined.

Axis: Axis of revolution of the gear; center line of the shaft.

Pitch surface: In cylindrical gears, cylinder formed by projecting a pitch circle in

the axial direction. More generally, the surface formed by the sum of all the pitch

circles as one moves along the axis. For bevel gears it is a cone

Addendum ( a )Radial distance from the pitch surface to the outermost point of

the tooth.

Dedendum ( b ) Radial distance from the depth of the tooth trough to the pitch

surface.

Base circle: In involute gears, where the tooth profile is the involute of the base

circle. The radius of the base circle is somewhat smaller than that of the pitch

circle.

The addendum circle: It coincides with the tops of the teeth of a gear and is

concentric with the standard (reference) pitch circle and radially distant from it

by the amount of the addendum.

The root circle: It coincides with the bottoms of the tooth spaces.

Page 21: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

16

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Defining the terms in dog clutch12

:

Figure 8 shows teeth angles (marked as 9º & 4.5º) and the chamfer distance ‘b’.

Figure 8. Teeth angle and the chamfer distance

Figure 9, shows term chamfer angles (marked as 30º, 60º and 45º) and the

chamfer distances (marked1.5 and 1). Furthermore the term top land (marked

‘A’) and the bottom land (marked ‘B’) are shown in the figure below.

Figure 9. Defining the chamfer angle, distance, top land and bottom land

Page 22: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

17

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 10 shows different possibilities that can occur when engaging the dog

clutches.

The first risk is that the clutch halves bouncing off each other, see (1) in figure

10.

The second is slipping off each other, see (2) and (3) in figure 10.

The third is engaging the first time without any problem, see (4), (5) and (6) in

figure 10

Figur 10. Possibilities during engagement of dog clutch.

Figure 11. Before engaging the dog clutch.

Page 23: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

18

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

When the dog clutch is not connected to any mass (flywheel) nor any torsional

stiffness see figure 11, the dog clutch is engaging without or with few bouncing.

When one end of the dog clutch is fixed mimicking a connection to an infinite

mass (flywheel) or an infinite torsional stiffness the dog clutch see figure 12, is

not engaging, but bouncing.

Figure 12. Before engaging, when connected to larger mass or torsional stiffness.

Page 24: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

19

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

4.4 Drawings in SolidWorks

The drawings are made in SolidWorks. The first step is to sketch a 2-D drawing

of the dog clutch. This is converted into a 3-D model by using revolve option in

SolidWorks. Other settings such as fillet, extrude, circular pattern, chamfer and

cut-revolve are used for making the required design. The drawings are imported

into MSC ADAMS by changing the format to parasolid (x. t).

4.5 Analysis in MSC ADAMS

To analyze the real world problems, the mathematical representations are more

or less simplifications. In this case simplifications are made regarding the

geometry, engagement force and material property

Simplifications of the material properties are made according to the previous

thesis12

work.

Page 25: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

20

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

5. Result

Figure 13. Model YY 18

5.1 Simulation results

Figure 14. Showing the method for studying of the dynamics as a function of parameter values

To achieve the best results, the simulation process should be automated, since

that it is less time consuming and can avoid human error. The process shown in

figure 13, starts with a Latin hypercube sampling using Matlab. After inserting

the lower and upper limits of each parameter in Matlab, combinations of

parameter values are extracted. This thesis work uses ten parameter

combinations for simulations in MSC ADAMS. For controlling the simulations,

the models have been exported from SolidWorks and imported to MSC

ADAMS.

18: Model YY is our own dog clutch design

Page 26: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

21

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

5.2 Simulation procedure

In this thesis, the design is simulated with two different starting positions. The first

starting position is teeth to teeth and the second is teeth to gap, see figure 15 A) and

B) respectively. To find the best result using both starting positions, analysis of the

designs is carried out.

Figure 15. A) Starting position teeth to teeth B) Starting position teeth to gap

The female part, see figure 16, is fixed in the x- y- and z-axis, but is free to rotate

around the x-axis. The male part can move along the x-axis and is free to rotate

with the female part but it is fixed in both y- and z-axis. After one second of

simulation, the male part starts to move along the x-axis due to a prescribed

force. During the engagement the male part bounces off at times or slides over

the female part because of the difference in the angular velocity. During this

process the male part may get a small amount of angular velocity from the

female part. However, it engages before or after a couple of trials.

Figure 16. A picture showing the difference between a female part and a male part

Page 27: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

22

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 17 shows how the dog clutch looks after the complete engagement.

5.3 Result summary

In the figures 1 to 30 in appendix 2, the x- axis represents the time of

engagement of the dog clutch in seconds and the y- axis represents the distance

between the centers of the male and the female dog clutch.

The red line represents the starting position of the male dog clutch is, teeth to

teeth, with respect to the female and the blue dashed line in the graph represent

the starting position of the male dog clutch, teeth to gap, with respect to the

female.

After engagement, the distance in y-axis will vary for different models because

of the difference in the designs and parameter combinations.

This thesis work considered four different parameters such as mass [kg], rotation

[degree/second], material stiffness [newton-meter/degree] and the engagement

force [newton], see table 1 in next page.

Figure 17. Dog clutch completely engaged

Page 28: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

23

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Table 1. Ten different parameter combinations from Latin hypercube.

Simulation test Parameters

Mass Rotation Material stiffness Engagement force

1 3 584 45115 182

2 9 665 98470 112

3 10 614 51660 86

4 7 499 27642 170

5 4 453 12617 97

6 6 386 67228 148

7 7 410 89433 64

8 8 539 81441 198

9 3 718 33340 65

10 5 564 59832 127

The figures in the appendix 2 give a clear picture of the bouncing and

performance of the dog clutch for different parameters and different starting

positions. The simulations were carried out with three different models, such as

XX, a dog clutch with patent, the second model by Swepart Transmission AB

and the last model YY, by the thesis team. The tests were carried out for ten

parameter value combinations, see table 1.

Out of these results, simulation number 8 shown in figures 18, 19 and 20, have

much better performance for XX, Swepart Transmission AB and YY. These

results are with the parameter combinations, mass of propeller shaft 8 kg,

rotational speed of the dog clutch 90 rpm, material stiffness 81441 Nm/degree

and engagement force of the male dog clutch 198 N.

Page 29: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

24

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 18. XX design combination 8

Figure 19. Swepart Transmission AB combination 8

Figure 20. YY design combination 8

Page 30: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

25

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

6. Discussions and Conclusions

The goal of this thesis work was to analyze three different dog clutch designs using

MSC ADAMS. The first dog clutch was designed by XX, the second by Swepart

Transmission AB and the third by us. We simulated these models in MSC ADAMS

to see which of these models have the best engagement result. The result will be

presented to Swepart Transmission AB.

We consider that this thesis was very interesting since this was a real engineering

concern for Swepart Transmission AB.

We believe in team work and gained a lot of knowledge in MSC ADAMS. It was

interesting to work with classmates from different countries and cultures.

During this tenure we had good communication with our supervisors both at

Linnaeus University and Swepart Transmission AB.

Unfortunately, this ten week thesis period made us to finish off the course early

before seeing the final result, however we look forward to hear from Swepart

Transmission AB about the progress of our result. We believe that we did our best to

achieve our goal and succeeded to get the required result.

The next thesis could be to make the rigid body flexible because, having a flexible

body makes the simulation process more realistic than having a rigid body.

Additionally to continue the designs and simulations by modeling the whole truck as

much as possible in MSC ADAMS.

We believe that Swepart Transmission AB consider this as a fruitful result to

continue with their further development of existing dog clutch.

Page 31: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

26

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

7. References

1. http://www.smartmotorist.com/car-accessories-fuel-and-maintenance/four-

wheel-drive.html (2nd

of may 2013 at 13:39)

2. http://www.mscsoftware.com/product/adams (8th

of March 2013 at 15:06)

3. http://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solidworks (8th

of March 2013 at 16:12

4. http://www.solidworks.se/sw/6453_SVE_HTML.htm (8th

of March 2013 at

16:03)

6. Life cycle in System engineering, Jackson, Peter L.(2010) Getting Design

Right: a system approach, Taylor and Francias Group.

7. Qvanström, Klas, Product development – a life cycle approach, 4MT014, term

1, 7.5 credits at Linnaeus University in Växjö, Sweden.

8. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equations_of_motion (23rd

of may 2013)

9. http://www.mathworks.se/help/phased/ug/global-and-local-coordinate-

systems.html (2nd

of May 2013) kl 16:20

10. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_hypercube_sampling (3rd

of may 2013 at

14:33)

11. Nyagolov, Nelkov, Dimitar, Bashir, Abbas and Genovski, Valentinov, Filip,

(2010) Simulation of the Geometry Influence on Curvic Coupled Engagement,

Master thesis work in Mechanical engineering at Linnaeus University

12. Andersson, Mattias and Kordian, Goetz (2010) FE analysis of a dog clutch

for trucks with all-wheel-drive, Master thesis work in Mechanical engineering at

Linnaeus University

13. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_product_development#The_eight_stages

(10th

of April 2013 at 16:01)

14. http://www.4xforum.com/four-wheel-drive/6-4x4-recovery/using-fwd-

transmission/ (5th

of may 2013 at 15:27)

15. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gear (16th

of may 2013)

Page 32: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

27

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

16.

http://www.google.se/imgres?imgurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ericsonyachts.org

%2Finfoexchange%2Fattachment.php%3Fattachmentid%3D9143%26d%3D130

9610052&imgrefurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ericsonyachts.org%2Finfoexchang

e%2Fshowthread.php%3F10136-Orienting-a-2-speed-winch-for-Load-

Direction&h=185&w=348&sz=49&tbnid=mX0ym7mCN2YkAM%3A&tbnh=6

8&tbnw=127&zoom=1&usg=__8k_-NC8ZvuonEmn2F-

HVkaVeYLs%3D&docid=Pl3FddG8gbCqJM&sa=X&ei=8zZAUd_QIubh4QTI

_YGABA&ved=0CFEQ9QEwBQ&dur=1829

(13th

of march 2013 at 09:38)

17.

http://www.core.org.cn/NR/rdonlyres/Aeronautics-and-Astronautics/16-

61Aerospace-DynamicsSpring2003/644258CA-E401-4F96-A505-

E4863A9BBE05/0/lecture7.pdf (27th

of may 2013 at 15:22)

Page 33: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

28

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

8. Appendix

Appendix 1: Results from the simulations

Appendix 2: The tests with different parameters from MSC ADAMS

Appendix 3: Time schedule for thesis work

Page 34: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

29

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Appendix 1

Implementation

After making the required sketch in SolidWorks, the files were converted to

Parasolid (x. t) format.

The first model in MSC ADAMS is shown in figure 1. In this, a blue cylinder

which is marked as (1) is made. One end of the blue cylinder (1) is attached to

the engine and the other end to the transfer gear, marked (2). Transfer gear (2),

rear propeller shaft (3) and front propeller shaft (8) are attached to the ground

using revolute joint. When the dog clutch is not engaged, the power from the

engine will go only to the rear propeller shaft (3) and then to the black rear drive

axle (4). Finally to the rear wheel (5) with the help of cylindrical joint, connected

between rear drive axle (4) and rear wheel (5).The rear wheels (5) can move

along the road because of the contact between the wheel (5) and road (6). The

road (6) is locked with a fixed joint to the ground and the rear drive axle (4) is

connected with translation joint. Now the rear wheel (5) moves because of the

friction. However the middle parts remain stationary.

When the dog clutch (7) is engaged, the front propeller shaft (8) rotates and

finally the front wheel (10). The front transfer gear (11) is to make the same

rotation speed as in the rear wheel (5).

Figure 1. Modeling the truck

Page 35: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

30

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

In the second model, we made the middle part moving. This is solved by using a

T-frame block above the dog clutch shown in figure 2. The T-frame and the

cylinders are then connected through a revolute joint.

Figure 2 Second model

Page 36: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

31

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Appendix 2

Figure 1. XX combination 1

Figure 2. Swepart Transmission AB combination 1

Figure 3. YY Design combination 1

Page 37: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

32

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 4. XX combination 2

Figure 5. Swepart Transmission AB combination 2

Figure 6. YY Design combination 2

Page 38: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

33

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 7 . XX combination 3

Figure 8. Swepart Transmission AB combination 3

Figure 9. YY Design combination 3

Page 39: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

34

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 10. . XX combination 4

Figure 11. Swepart Transmission AB combination 4

Figure 12. YY Design combination 4

Page 40: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

35

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 13. . XX combination 5.

Figure 14. Swepart Transmission AB combination 5

Figure 15. YY Design combination 5

Page 41: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

36

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 16. . XX combination 6

Figure 17. Swepart Transmission AB combination 6

Figure 18. YY Design combination 6

Page 42: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

37

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 19 . XX combination 7

Figure 20. Swepart Transmission AB combination 7

Figure 21. YY Design combination 7

Page 43: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

38

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 22. . XX combination 8

Figure 23. Swepart Transmission AB combination 8

Figur 24. YY Design combination 8

Page 44: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

39

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 25 . XX combination 9

Figure 26. Swepart Transmission AB test 9

Figure 27. YY Design combination 9

Page 45: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

40

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

Figure 28 . XX combination 10

Figure 29. Swepart Transmission AB combination 10

Figur 30. YY Design combination 10

Page 46: Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case ...632773/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Parametric study of a dog clutch used in a transfer case for trucks ... the dog clutch design

41

Amanuel Mehari, Fredrik Eriksson, Linu Kuttikal Joseph

School of Engineering 351 95 Växjö

tel 0772-28 80 00, fax 0470-76 85 40