parametric studies to determine the effect of compliant ... · pdf filenasa technical...

14
NASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix Composite Systems J.J. Caruso and C.C. Chamis National Aeronautics and Space Administration _ Lewis Research Center Cleveland, Ohio ........ and H.C. Brown Sverdrup Technology, Inc. NASA Lewis Research Center Group Cleveland, Ohio Prepared for the 35th Symposium and Exhibition sponsored by the Society for the Advancement of Material and Process Engineering _ Anaheim, California, April 2±5, 1990 (NASA-T_,-IO2G65) PARAMeTrIC eIUOIES TU NgO_I4Zc_ DETERMINE TN__I E_F_CT nF COMPLrA_,T LAYEb, S ON MF_AL ,MATPIX COMPOSIT_ SY_TrMS (NASA) 13 p CS, CL 11_ Unc1_s G3/24 0254450 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19900004978 2018-04-23T22:46:52+00:00Z

Upload: vonhu

Post on 06-Feb-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

NASA Technical Memorandum 102465

Parametric Studies to Determine the

Effect of Compliant Layers on MetalMatrix Composite Systems

J.J. Caruso and C.C. Chamis

National Aeronautics and Space Administration _Lewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio

........ and

H.C. Brown

Sverdrup Technology, Inc.

NASA Lewis Research Center GroupCleveland, Ohio

Prepared for the35th Symposium and Exhibition

sponsored by the Society for the Advancement of

Material and Process Engineering _Anaheim, California, April 2±5, 1990

(NASA-T_,-IO2G65) PARAMeTrIC eIUOIES TU NgO_I4Zc_DETERMINE TN__I E_F_CT nF COMPLrA_,T LAYEb, S ON

MF_AL ,MATPIX COMPOSIT_ SY_TrMS (NASA) 13 p

CS, CL 11_ Unc1_s

G3/24 0254450

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19900004978 2018-04-23T22:46:52+00:00Z

Page 2: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix
Page 3: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

PARAMETRIC STUDIES TO DETERMINE THE EFFECT OF COMPLIANTLAYERS ON METAL MATRIX COMPOSITE SYSTEMS

J.J. Caruso and C.C. Chamls

National Aeronautics and Space AdministrationLewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohlo 44135

H.C. Brown

Sverdrup Technology Inc.NASA Lewis Research Center Group

Cleveland, Ohlo 44135

L_

Lr_I

LLJ

ABSTRACT

Computational Slmulatlon studies are conducted to Identify compliant layers

to reduce matrix stresses which result From the coefficient of thermal

expanslon mismatch and the large temperature range over which the current

metal matrix composltes wlll be used. The present study includes varla-

tlons of compllant layers and their properties to determine thelr Influence

on unldlrectlonal composite and constituent response. Two slmulation meth-

ods are used For these studies. The First approach Is based on a three-

dimensional linear Finite element analysls of a nlne-Fiber unldlrect|onal

composlte system. The second approach Is a mlcromechanlcs based nonllnear

computer code developed to determine the behavior of metal matrix composite

system For thermal and mechanlcal loads. The results show that an eFFec-

tlve compliant layer For the SCS 6 (SiC)/TI-24AI-1INb (TI3A1+Nb) and SCS 6

(SIC)/TI-15V-3Cr-3Sn-3AI (TI-15-3) composlte systems should have a modulus

15 percent that of the matrix and a compllant layer coeFFIclent of thermal

expanslon roughly equal to that of the composite system without the CL.

The matrix stress In the 1ongltudinal and the transverse tangent (hoop)

dlrectlon are tensile For the TI3AI+Nb and Ti-15-3 composlte systems upon

cool down From Fabrication. The Fiber longltudinal stress Is compresslve

From Fabrlcatlon cool down. Addition of a recommended compllant layer

will result In a reduction In the composlte modulus.

INTRODUCTION

Metal matrix composite (MMC) are prime candldates For hlgh temperature

applications. They present a unique challenge to today's researchers. The

Page 4: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

large operatlng temperature range (greater than 2000°F) and the mismatchbetweenthe thermal expansion coeffIclents (CTE)of the fiber and the

matrix pose great difficulties in fabrication and low thermal cycling resls-tance. Both of these increase the matrix stress to critical proportionsand often lead to falIure. Manysolutions to this problem have been pro-posed (e.g., matching CTEfor fiber and matrix) with little success. One

suggestion is to use a compliant layer (CL) as a buffer between the fiberand the matrix. Thegoal of this CL Is to reduce the matrix stress without

degrading the fiber, the matrix, or the composite. Finding a material todo thls, however, mayprove to be quite a challenge.

In an attempt to flnd such CLs, a parametric study is a natural first

step. It is essential to assemblea working knowledgeof which and/or howcharacterlstlc parameters of the constltuent material effect compositebehavior.

Twocomputatlonal simulation approachesare used in this study to evaluateCLs In MMCsystems for high temperature applications under thermal loads.The first is a three-dimensional linear finite element method. The otheris a nonllnear mIcromechanlcsbasednumerical method.

In attempt to identify characterlstics for suitable compliant layers, com-pTiant layers are evaluated with two commonbut very different metal matri-ces. They are (I) Ti-15V-3Cr-3Sn-3Al (Ti-15-3) and (2) Ti-24A1-11Nb

(Ti3AI+Nb) reinforced with SiC (SCS6) fibers. The SiC/Ti-15-3 compositesystem has beenprocessedwithout matrix cracks (I-3). SiC/TI3AI+Nb, how-ever, does develop matrix cracks durlng processlng (5,6), maklng It a candi-date for a CL. There wlll be somedlscusslon on the Ti-15-3 system;but, the maJorlty of the effort will concentrate on the Ti3Al+Nb system.

The developmentof matrix cracks maybe related to tenslle stresses In spe-clflc dlrectlons. Large tensile hoopstresses in the matrix can cause thetransverse tangent (hoop) cracks observed by Mackay(1) and Ghosn& Lerch

(2). Similarly, large tensile longitudlnal stresses maycause matrix crack-ing perpendicular to the fibers. Thesecracks have not beenobserved. Acompliant layer should reduce the stress in all directions to be an effec-tive methodfor preventing cracks during the fabrication and the thermalcyc11ngof these systems. If the goal Is to ellminate matrix cracklng, acompromlsemayhave to be madebetweenstresses to elimlnate matrix crack-Ing.

METHODS

The FEM calculates the linear composite response at many locations In the

constltuents of the composlte system that cannot be determined through

2

Page 5: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

experiments (6-8). The general purpose finite element code MSC/NASTRAN (9)

is used to perform the analysls. The model uses elght-noded hexahedron and

sIx-noded pentahedron elements to form a nlne-cell nlne-flber unidirec-

tlonal composite system (Fig. I). The model provides constituent displace-

ments, stresses, and forces due to thermal loadlng condltlons.

__i"<-.!,! ...-._

Z_X I

C-m

n : ,

y '- ,

ZX_

Z

FIGURE I. - MULTICELL 3-D FINITE ELEMENT MODEL

FOR LOCAL DETAILS.

//

\\

FINITEELEMENT_

COM PONENT

_ _ FINITEELEMENT

GLOBAL STRUCTURAL jANALYSIS

\

LAMINATE /// LAMINATE 1LAMINATE_ MINATE 1

I THEORY / THEORY I I

- METCAN

pl.y___/ _'_ __" PLY I

COMPOSITE / _ ,_ COMPOSITE......... _ _ _ J¢" MICROMECHANICS /

\ MICROMECHANIC5 _THEORY /__ n u '_. THEORY /\ " _ .,-.. PI.._.." /

\ ./UPWARD _ CONSTITUENTS t / TOP-DOWN

INTEGRATED _ _ MATERIAL PROPERTIES / "/ TRACEDP (_,T, t) / OROR _

"SYNTHESIS" --- ....... _ "DECOMPOSITION"

FIGURE 2. - HIGH TEMPERATURECOMPOSITE BEHAVIORCOMPUTATIONALLYSIMULATED.

3

Page 6: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

The second approach, the METCAN computer code (Fig. 2), is used to

determine the nonlinear average composite response of unidlrectional and

Iamlnate composite systems (lO). The code's computatlonal simulation

begins wlth the coo] down of the consolidation process and includes any

thermal and/or mechanlcaI processes which occur after consolidation. The

changes In constituent materials resultlng from environmental variations

are taken Into account. In this study a unidlrectiona] MMC system Is evalu-

ated to determine the fiber, matrix, and CL stress. These stresses are

used to determine whether the composite system will survive fabrication

and, if so, the thermal cycles to failure of the system. METCAN also com-

putes composite properties In an attempt to determine the effect of a CL on

them.

EG

C_

Soxxt

TABLE l ROOM TEMPERATURE CONSTITUTIVE

MATERIAL PROPERTIES

pslpsi

In.lln. °Fksl

SIC

Fiber

62.0xi0623.8x106

0.3002.70x10-6

TI3AI+NbMatrix

I].OxlO 6

4.23xl06

0.3006.50xi0-6

65.0

TI-15-3Matrix

14.5x106

5.50x106

0.3204.72x10-6

130.0

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Finite Element Method The first phase of this study Is to find, using

the FEM, the longitudinal stresses in the SiC/Ti31+Nb (Table l) for

selected CL's. The first selected CL (2) has a CTE of 4.67 ppm/°F and a

modulus that varies from 1.1 to 22 Msi. Figures 3(a) and (b) shows that

the CL stress Is lower than the matrix stress throughout the range of CL

modulus. In Flg. 3, the stress is normalized per degree Fahrenheit.

(Table 2 summarizes the figures for the readers' benefit). The fiber Is In

compression for the composite system In a fabrlcatlon cooi down through the

range. The longltudlnal stress In the matrix is low on the surface

(Figs. 4(a) and (b)) and Increases as the X/D ratio Increases, where X

is the distance from the free surface of the composlte and D Is the fiber

dlameter. As X/D increases, the matrix stress does not decrease untlI the

compliant layer modulus has decreased to 40 percent of the matrix modulus.

In a11 cases the matrix stress does not significantly decrease until the CL

modulus is 15 percent of the matrix modulus. For the Ti3Al+Nb system the

CL modulus would be 1.7 Msi.

Page 7: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

40

---o---- FIBER.__A___ CL (CVR .20)..... O..... MATRIX

20

0(

-20

-40

=_ -60

o"1=. -80

-1000

[,,,lJ

...,-

20/

=: 0

2°l-40

-80

- 100

0 .4 .8 1.2 1.6 2.0

Ec I/Era

FIGURE 3. - ROOM TEMPERATURELONG-

ITUDINALCONSTITUENTMICROSTRESS

(0_iI) FOR A 20 PERCENTFVR SC26/Ti3-AI + Nb AT L/D = 2.21.

35

Ecl/E m

•-..-o--.- 2.0-..in.._ .5..... "_..... .1

---we--- 1.0

30

25,

20{

u. 15

0- 10'

.........i;°7" A_.

, (b)"..

0_- - ;':'_--.-* ....... ,, ....... ,,4.................._ ............. -_...............

_4L 7 ''_ 'T ":--'4 ..................t _0 .5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

x/D

FIGURE 4. - RT LONGITUDINALCON-

STITUENT MICROSTRESS(0/,11)FOR20 PERCENT FVR, 20 PERCENTCVR

SCS-6/Ti3-AI + Nb,

The second specific CL has a higher CTE of 7.5 ppml°F but the same range

for the modulus (l.l to 22 Msl). Figure 5 shows the longltudlnal stress In

the constltuents of the SIC/TI3Al+Nb composite system. At a hlgh CL modu-

lus, the CL stress Is much larger than the matrix stress. As the CL modu-

lus decreases, the compliant layer stress decreases. The matrix stress

Page 8: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

Fig- I FVRure

3(a) 0.20

3(b)

4(a)

4(b)

5

6 '.'46

7 .20

8

9

lO

TABLE 2 TEST MATRIX

[Stresses are due to thermal loadln, (excluding Fig. g).]

Composite CVR Compliant Testsystem layer

0.20 TI3AI w/ Longltudinal constituent _icros:r_s_var. Eel CL CTE - 4.57 ppm. X/O . 1.47

SCS61TI3AI

SCS6/TII5

SCS6/Ti3AI

.16

TII5 wl

var. Ecl

Longitudinal _ "",_ns_tuen: ,_Icrostres_

CL CTE = 4.67 ppm, ×ID - 2.21

Longitudinal matrix mlcrostressas X/O increases

Longitudinal CL mlctrostrassas X/O Increases

Longitudinal constltuen: _icros:ressCL CTE - 7.55 ppm, X/D = 2.2l

Longitudinal constltuent mlcrostress,Jar. CL CTE X/D . 2.g4

0.20

Repeat CL

From Flg. 7

GdNbZrTest

0.20 GdNbZr

0

.05,.I,.2

Test

Carbon

Gd

Maximum constituent hccD microstresldue to CL type

Maximum Iongltud!nal constituentmicrostress due to CL type

Change in composite modulus dueto CL type

Thermal cycles to failure asCTE mismatch increases

remalns constant throughout thls range of the CL moduli. The longitudinal

matrix stress does not vary with the two CL CTEs shown In Figs. 3 and 5.

Constituent longltudlna] stresses are predicted from the FEM for a compos-

Ire system that contains several CLs for which the CTE varies inversely

wlth the modulus. For example, when the CL modulus Is halved, the CTE is

doubled. As the CTE decreases and the modulus increases, the CL stress

grows unti] It is slgnlflcantly larger than the matrix stress (Fig. 6).

The CL, even with a high CTE, does not slgnlflcantly reduce the matrix

stress untll the modulus Is 15.percent that of the matrix. Unfortunately,

the CL stress Is very hlgh at th|s polnt. Since the CL stress is large the

CL strength must also be hlgh. A good rule of thumb for the SIC/TI-IS-3

composite system is to have the CL strength twice the matrix strength.

Flndlng a CL that meets thls Is obvlously not very practical since It may

be impossible to Find a material wlth a low modulus and high strength.

Next, the effect of select CL materlals on the SiC/TI3AI+Nb system Is exam-

Ined. Four of the many CL materlals evaluated by Ghosn and Lerch (2) were

6

Page 9: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

=.-u_ -40u3

-80

-120E

-160

---o--- FIBER---_-- CL (CVR.20).....[].....MATRIX

80LI0_ _ ....o.O..O°o°..o .°. o.O.O--°'"°""

O_ _ ........

CL CTE = 4.67PPM

•i [ __--=L { {

0 .4 .8 1.2 1.6 2.0

Ecl/Em

FIGURE5. - ROOMTEMPERATURELONGITUDINALCONSTITUENTMIC-

ROSTRESS(0J,ll ) FORA 20 PER-CENTFVRSCS6/Ti3-AI + Nb ATL/D = 2.21.

CVR .01

----0-----FIBER

---c}--- MATRIX

...._ .....CL

,, 992 -_ 80

496 - _. qO6- =vl, e._

_" 0-_ 00 0

-496 -

CVR .16

---4--- FIBER

---m--- MATRIX

-.-A--- CL

_A !

:y ....._..7....._::.._.::._,_.... ----._.

:,,.,=-"'"__-L:._-_......."""'"_:'-I./

-40 " _'_='_'---T--_--,..... i- -'J

0 .2 .4 .6 .8 1.0

Ecl/E m

FIGURE 6, - ROOM_ERATURE CONSTITUENT

M[CROSTRESS0_11 WITH VARYING CL CI'EFOR 46 PERCENTFVR SCS6_i-lS-3 AT

L/D = 2.9q.

chosen for this study (Table 3). Three of the CLs are actual materials, Gd

(gadollnlum), Nb (niobium), and Zr (zlrconlum). One is a fictltlous mate-

rlal deslgned to flnd optlmum CL propertles (called the test case in the

present study). This test case has a CTE of 4.67 ppm/°F and a modulus

varying Form 1.1 to 2 Ms1. The composite systems contalnlng CLs are com-

pared to a reference case of SCS 61TI3AI+Nb having no CL, both at a fiber

volume ratio (FVR) of 20 percent. In this study the FVR Is the Fiber

volume ratlo of the flber without the CL.

The FEN Is used to predlct the hoop microstress SiC/Ti3AI+Nb system. For

most CLs the matrix hoop stress Is less (about 20 percent) than the matrix

stress of the reference case with no CL (Fig. 7). A CL of Zr, however,

increased the stress in the matrix slightly; while the CL stress went into

compression. The CL stresses are slgnlflcant for the fabrication cool down

and, because of thls, the CL strength may need to be close to that of the

matrix or larger.

The longitudinal mlcrostresses in the SIC/Ti3AI+Nb system are determined

from the FEM and plotted per degree Farenhelt. The results show that the

CLs examined Increase (about II percent) the longltudinal matrix stress

From the reference case wlth no CL (Fig. 8). This Increase In 1ongitudlnal

matrix stress may Induce matrix cracklng during fabrication and thermal

cycling. The increase in matrix stress may also reduce Fatigue life, pro-

vided the composite system survives fabrlcatlon.

Page 10: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

TABLE3 ROOMTEMPERATURECOMPLIANTLAYERMATERIALPROPERTIES

E psiG pslV

in./in. °F

Gd Zr Nb

8.30xi063.30xi06

0.2605.60xi0-6

13.6xlO65.10xlO 6

0.3322.90xi0 -6

14.9xi065.31x106

0.4024.40xi0-6

496 -

248 -IJ.

O-

-248 -

CL

E_ MATRIX40

IO - --

WICL NO CLCVR = 20

FVR : 20-20

TEST Gd Zf Nb FVR20

COMPLIANT LAYER TYPE

FIGURE 7. - MAXIMUM CONSTITUENT HOOP MICRO-

STRESS ((JO)DUE TO CL TYPE FOR SCS6/

Ti3-AI + Nb.

496 40

248 20

O _ 0

o'-

-248 --20

-q96 -40

CL

MATRIX

....--'-_ i_

_W/CL NO CLCVR = 20

r- ""_FVR= 20

TEST Gd Zr Nb FVR20

COMPLIANT LAYER TYPE

F[GURE 8. - MAXIMUM LONGITUDINAL CONSTITUENT

MICROSTRESS (0_iI) DUE TO CL TYPE FOR SCSG/

Ti3-AI + Nb.

The composite modulus may be affected by the use of CLs. The five systems

from the FEM study have a very small decrease in the longitudinal modulus.

Hence, the composlte modulus variation is small (±4 percent) (Fig. 9). The

two compllant layers that performed the best in this study (Gd, Test) have

a sllghtly lower modulus than the reference. The change in composite modu-

lus could be slgnifIcant when using the recommended CL with a modulus

15 percent that of the matrix.

METCAN

The thermal cycllng resistance Is critical because of the large temperature

envelopes in which MMC systems operate. The multifactor interaction rela-

tionship (MFI) is used to calculate the thermal cycles to fallure. The MFI

is shown for the SIC/TI3AI+Nb composite system. The exponents are deter-

mlned from monolithic matrix experimental data. The matrix material is

fabricated as a composite system Is fabricated.

z ]O-o o.oo

Page 11: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

Where S/SF Is the remalnlng ultimate tensile strength of the composite

after thermal cycling over the original ultlmate strength of the composite,

Tm is the melting temperature (2730 °F), Tu is the maximum temperature of

the thermal cycle (1200 °F), TO is the reference temperature (70 °F), SO

Is the room temperature reference ultimate tensile strength of the matrlx

(65 ks|), Op is the longitudlnal residual matrix stress at the end of

cycllng, ac Is the longitudlnal residual matrix stress at the end of con-

solldatlon, N Is the number of cycles at which there Is lO percent remain-

Ing strength, and NF is the number of cycles to fallure. -This equation

is evaluated For the number of cycles to fallure with a lO percent

remaining strength S/SF.

METCAN Is used to investigate the thermal cycles to Failure of FVR 20

SIC/TIAI+Nb and variations of this system. In Four of the composites the

protective carbon coating Is removed From the Fiber, three flbers have the

coating replaced wlth a CL of Gd of different thlcknesses and one without a

coating or CL. The fiber without a coating was assumed to have the same

strength as one with a coatlng (I.e., SCS 6). One addltional composite sys-

tem Is analyzed with the coating. As the CTE mismatch between the Fiber

and the matrix grows, the composlte system became less tolerant of the

cycllng (Fig. lO). The worst case is the composite system that contalns

the flber with the coatlng. The CL sllghtly delayed the Failure as the CTE

mlsmatch increased.

4

I2 2Z

M- -2zw

e,-

_. -{I

MODULUS

TEST Gd Zr Nb FVR20

COMPLIANT LAYER TYPE

FIGURE 9. - CHANGE IN COMPOSITE

MODULUS FOR VARIOUS COMPLIANT

LAYER MATERIALS FOR SCS-6/

Ti3-AI + Nb.

Z

Z

1.0

.8

.6

.4

.2

Gd CVR .20

---o--- Gd CVR .I0

.....A.....Gd CVR .05

- _-- CVR .00----m--- COATING .03

- I!,

r

.21 I . t

.4 .6 .8 1.0

af/am

FIGURE I0. - EFFECT OF CTE MISMATCH

ON THERMAL CYCLES TO FAILUREOF

20 PERCENT _ SICfFI3-AI+ NbWITH DIFFERENTCOATINGS.

9

Page 12: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

CONCLUSION

The compliant layers studied appear to be Ineffectlve in reduclng the 1ongl-

tudlnal stress in the Ti3Al+Nb composite system except with very low CL

modull (on the order of 15 percent of the matrix modulus). The reduction

in hoop stress may eliminate the cracking In the hoop direction. It does

not significantly Increase the thermal cycles to failure of the system.

The fiber stress is in compresslon and Is currently not considered the weak

link in thls type of failure.

The best performing compliant layer has a low modulus (around 15 percent of

the matrix) and a CTE lower than the matrix but higher than the fiber.

High CTE CLs cause high stresses in the CL which require high CL strengths.

Low modulus and high strength are not compatible properties for a materlal

to have. The reduction in matrix stresses due to high CTE are not realized

until the CL modulus is 15 percent that of the matrix

modulus.

The compliant layer generally reduces the modulus of the composite but not

by an appreciable amount. If a low modulus compliant layer (15 percent of

the matrix) were used, the reduction could be much greater.

REFERENCES

I. McKay, R.A., "Effect of Fiber Spacing on Interracial Damage in a Metal

Matrix Composlte," submitted to Scripta Metallurgica, 1989.

2. Lerch, B.A., Hull, D.R., and Leonhardt, T.A., "As Received

MIcrostructure of a SIC/TI-15-3 Composite," NASA TM-I00938, 1988.

3. Lerch, B.A., Personal Communication, NASA Lewis Research Center,

Cleveland, OH, 1989.

4. Brlndley, P.K., Bartolotta, P.A., and KIIma, S.J., "Investigation of a

SiC/Ti-24Al-llNb Composite," NASA TM-I00956, 1988.

5. Brlndley, P.K., Bartolotta, P.A., and Mackay, R.A., "Thermal and

Mechanical Fatigue of SIC/Ti3AI+Nb," Hltemp Review 1989, NASA CP-IOO3g,

1989, paper 52.

6. Caruso, J.J., "Application of Finite Element Subststructurlng to

Composite MlcromechanIcs," NASA TM-83729, 1984.

7. Caruso, O.J. and Chamls, C.C., "Superelement Methods Applications to

MlcromechanIcs of High Temperature Metal Matrix Composites," 29th

Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, Part 3,

AIAA, 1988, pp. 138B-1400.

10

Page 13: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

8. Caruso, J.J., Trowbrldge, D., and Chamls, C.C., "Flnlte Element

Applications to Explore the EFfects of Partlal Bondlngon Metal MatrixCompositeProperties," 30th Structures, Structural Dynamics, and

Materials ConfereDce, Part l, AIAA, I9B9, pp. 140-154.

9. GockeI, M.A., ed., MSC/NASTRAN: Handbook for Superelement Analysis:

MSC/NASTRAN Verson 61, The MacNeal-Schwendler Corp., Los Angeles, CA,

19B2, p. ].]-l.

IO. Hopkins, D.A. and Chistos, C.C., "A Unique Set of Micromechanics

Equations For High Temperature Metal Matrix Composites," NASA TM-B?I54,

19B5.

It

Page 14: Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant ... · PDF fileNASA Technical Memorandum 102465 Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant Layers on Metal Matrix

Report Documentation PageNational Aeronautics andSpace Administration

1. Report No. 2. Government Accession No.

NASA TM- 102465

4. Title and Subtitle

Parametric Studies to Determine the Effect of Compliant

Layers on Metal Matrix Composite Systems

7. Author(s)

J.J. Caruso, C.C. Chamis, and R.C. Brown

9. Performing Organization Name and Address

National Aeronautics and Space AdministrationLewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio 44135-3191

12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Washington, D.C. 20546-0001

3. Recipient's Catalog No.

5. Report Date

6. Performing Organization Code

8. Performing Organization Report No.

E-5252

10. Work Unit No.

505-63-1B

11. Contract or Grant No.

13. Type of Report and Period Covered

Technical Memorandum

14. Sponsoring Agency Code

15. Supplementary Notes

Prepared for the 35th Symposium and Exhibition sponsored by the Society for the Advancement of Material and

Process Engineering, Anaheim, California, April 2-5, 1990. J.J. Caruso and C.C. Chamis, NASA Lewis

Research Center; H.C. Brown, Sverdrup Technology, Inc., NASA Lewis Research Center Group, Cleveland,Ohio 44135.

16. Abstract

Computational simulation studies are conducted to identify compliant layers to reduce matrix stresses which result

from the coefficient of thermal expansion mismatch and the large temperature range over which the current metal

matrix composites will be used. The present study includes variations of compliant layers and their properties to

determine their influence on unidirectional composite and constituent response. Two simulation methods are used

for these studies. The first approach is based on a three dimensional linear finite element analysis of a 9 fiber

unidirectional composite system. The second approach is a micromechanics based nonlinear computer code devel-

oped to determine the behavior of metal matrix composite system for thermal and mechanical loads. The results

show that an effective compliant layer for the SCS 6 (SiC)/Ti-24AI'-I 1Nb (Ti3AT + Nb) and SCS 6(SiC)/Ti-15V-3Cr-3Sn-3AI (Ti-15-3) composite systems should have modulus 15 percent that of the matrix and a

coefficient of thermal expansion of the compliant layer roughly equal to that of the composite system without the

CL. The matrix stress in the longitudinal and the transverse tangent (hoop) direction are tensile for the Ti3A! + Nband Ti-15-3 composite systems upon cool down from fabrication. The fiber longitudinal stress is compressive

from fabrication cool down. Addition of a recommended compliant layer will result in a reduction in the

composite modulus.

17. Key Words (Suggested by Author(s))

Compliant layer

Metal matrix compositesMicromechanics

18. Distribution Statement

Unclassified - Unlimited

Subject Category 24

19. Security Classif. (of this report) 20, Security Classif. (of this page) 21. No. of pages

Unclassified Unclassified 12

NASAFORM1628OCT86 *For sale by the National Technic_#lInformation Service, Springfield, Virginia 22161

22. Price*

A03