pakistan's security paradox (full length)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
1/114
JQDV
Uf}dus=?
.?
]gioqsgkqQfavuosy]gug
cd|
Nvbboai
]gioqsgkqQfavuosy ]gugcd|:
Advksfuokhgkc @dnfksokh
Okqvuhfkaofq
Lgocfu G+ L+ Nvbboai
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?Cfafnefu 5==?
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
2/114
Jdoks Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Vkopfuqosygkc slf Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks
Sf Jdoks Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Vkopfuqosy ,JQDV/ }udpocfq osq }veboagsodkq
sd adksuoevsf sdxguc f|}gkcokh slf edcy d ikdxbfchf gedvs jdoks q}faogb
d}fugsodkq+ JQDV }veboagsodkq gcpgkaf slf okqohlsq gkc ufadnnfkcgsodkq
d kgsodkgb qfavuosy }udfqqodkgbq gkc slf Q}faogb D}fugsodkq @duafq ,QD@/
qsvcfksq gkc bfgcfuq du adkqocfugsodk ey slf QD@ adnnvkosy gkc cffkqf
bfgcfuqlo}+
JQDV oq slf fcvagsodkgb adn}dkfks d slf Vkosfc Qsgsfq Q}faogb D}fug.
sodkq Adnngkc ,VQQDADN/" NgaCobb Gou @duaf Egqf" @bduocg+ Sf JQDV
noqqodk oq sd fcvagsf QD@ f|favsopf" qfkodu" gkc oksfunfcogsf bfgcfuq gkc
qfbfasfc dslfu kgsodkgb gkc oksfukgsodkgb qfavuosy cfaoqodk ngifuq" edsl
nobosguy gkc aopobogk" sludvhl sfgalokh" dvsufgal" gkc ufqfgual ok slf
qaofkaf gkc gus d jdoks q}faogb d}fugsodkq+ JQDV }udpocfq fcvagsodk sd slf
nfk gkc xdnfk d QD@ gkc sd sldqf xld fkgebf slf QD@ noqqodk ok g jdoks
gkc oksfughfkay fkpoudknfks+
JQDV adkcvasq ufqfgual sludvhl osq Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks xlfuf
fdus afksfuq v}dk slf VQQDADN gkc Vkosfc Qsgsfq QD@ noqqodkq:
VQQDADN noqqodk+ VQQDADN }udpocfq vbby ag}gebf gkc fkgebfcQD@ sd cffkc slf kgsodkq oksfufqsq ok gk fkpoudknfks algugasfuozfc ey
ouufhvbgu xguguf+
VQQD@ noqqodk+ VQQD@ adkcvasq q}faogb d}fugsodkq sd }uf}guf slf d}fu.
gsodkgb fkpoudknfks" }ufpfks auoqoq" g kc ufq}dkc xosl q}ffc" ghhufqqodk"
gkc bfslgbosy sd galofpf sgasoagb sludvhl qsugsfhoa ffas+
Sf Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks gbqd }udpocfq sfgalokh gkc avuuoavbvn
qv}}dus sd ]udfqqodkgb Nobosguy Fcvagsodk okqsosvsodkqslf qsg adbbfhfq
gkc xgu adbbfhfq+ Os gcpgkafq QD@ qsugsfhoa okvfkaf ey osq oksfugasodk ok
gagcfnoa" oksfughfkay" gkc Vkosfc Qsgsfq nobosguy adnnvkosofq+
Sf JQDV }dusgb oq lss}q:$$jqdv}veboa+qdadn+nob+
Jdoks Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Vkopfuqosy
Euogk G+ Nglfu" Fc+C+" QFQ" ]ufqocfksIfkkfsl L+ ]ddbf" _A.1" Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks Coufasdu
Xobbogn X+ Nfkcfb" Adbdkfb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+9 Jfufy X+ Kfbqdk" Adbdkfb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+9gkc Xobbogn Q+ Xobcuoai" Ag}sgok" V+Q+ Kgpy" Ufs+ Ufqocfks Qfkodu @fbbdxq
Fcosduogb Gcpoqduy Edguc
Gbpgud cf Qdvzg ]oklfoudNgjdu Hfkfugb" Eugzobogk Guny" Ufs+JQDV Gqqdaogsf @fbbdx
Jgnfq @+ ]dxfuq" Ju+Adbdkfb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+Coufasdu d Ldnfbgkc Qfavuosy"
Adnndkxfgbsl d ]fkkqybpgkog gkcJQDV Gqqdaogsf @fbbdx
Uoalguc L+ Qlvbsz" Ju+]l+C+" ]dbosoagb QaofkafCoufasdu" Oksfukgsodkgb QfavuosyQsvcofq ]udhugn" Sf @bfsalfu Qalddb" vqVkopfuqosy gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Qsf}lfk Qbdgk]l+C+" Adn}gugsopf ]dbosoaqVkopfuqosy d Afksugb @bduocggkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Udefus H+ Q}vbgi" Ju+]l+C+" ]lyqoaq$Kvabfgu FkhokffuokhQgkcog Kgsodkgb Bgedugsduofqgkc JQDV Gqqdaogsf @fbbdx
Jdqf}l Q+ QsuokhlgnEuohgcofu Hfkfugb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+Gbvsoow" BBA gkc JQDV Gqqdaogsf @fbbdx
Huglgn L+ vueopobbf" Ju+]l+C+" Loqsduy" Advughf Qfupoafq" Oka+gkc JQDV Gqqdaogsf @fbbdx
Jfqqoag Hboaifk vukbfy]l+C+" Avbsvugb Gkslud}dbdhy$Qdvslfgqs Gqogk QsvcofqHgboqsfd Adkqvbsokh Hudv}gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Uoal _guhfu]l+C+" Loqsduy"Nokoqsfuogb Ufdun Gcpoqdu9V+Q+ Guny ]fgafiff}okh gkc QsgeobosyD}fugsodkq Okqsosvsf gkc JQDV Gqqdaogsf@fbbdx
Jdlk E+ Gbf|gkcfu]l+C+" Fcvagsodk" Sf G}dbbokgouf Hudv}gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Udey A+ Eguufss" ]l+C+" NoccbfFgqsfuk Qdvsl Gqogk Loqsduy]veboa ]dboay AfksfuNoccbf Fgqs Okqsosvsf
gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdxJdqf}l C+ AfbfqioAdbdkfb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Alvai AvkkokhlgnBofvsfkgks Hfkfugb" V+Q+ Gou @duaf" Ufs+]udfqqdu d Qsugsfhy" Jdoks GcpgkafcXguhlsokh Qalddb gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Hobefus F+ CdgkNgjdu" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+"JQDVOkqsosvsodkgb Oksfhugsodk Copoqodk Alof
Euogk L+ HuffkqlofbcqAdbdkfb" V+Q+ Gou @duaf" Ufs+Qfkodu Bfasvufu" CdC Gkgbyqoq" Kgpgb]dqshugcvgsf Qalddb
Sdngq L+ Lfkuoiqfk]l+C+" Loqsduy" Lddpfu OkqsosvsodkQsgkduc Vkopfuqosy gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Uvqqfbb C+ LdxgucEuohgcofu Hfkfugb" V+Q+ Guny" Ufs+Gcjvkas @gavbsy" Cffkqf Auosoagb Bgkhvghf$Avbsvuf ]udhugn" Ngkqfbc Afksfu" Vkopfuqosyd Ndksgkg gkc JQDV Qfkodu @fbbdx
Jdlk C+ JdhfuqsAdbdkfb" V+Q+ Gou @duaf" Ufs+7
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
3/114
Dk slf adpfu
Sf }ldsdhug}l oq gk gusoqsoa cf}oasodk d slf ADOK.@DOK }gugcd|
ey Goqlg Aldxcluy gkc Lgocfu G+ L+ Nvbboai+ Sf qdbcofu dk slf
bf gssgaiq slf okqvuhfks xlobf slf dkf dk slf uohls qv}}dusq slf
okqvuhfks9 edsl abgon sd ef fwvgbby }gsuodsoa+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
4/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
5/114
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?
lf JQDV ]ufqq
Lvubevus @ofbc" @bduocg5==?
]gioqsgkqQfavuosy ]gugcd|:
Advksfuokh
gkc @dnfksokhOkqvuhfkaofq
Lgocfu G+ L+ Nvbboai
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
6/114
Adnnfksq gedvs sloq }veboagsodk guf okposfc gkc qldvbc ef duxgucfc sd Coufasdu"
Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks" Jdoks Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Vkopfuqosy" 168 vbby Qsuffs"
Gboqdk Evobcokh" Lvubevus @ofbc" @bduocg 15633+ Ad}ofq d sloq }veboagsodk ngy ef
desgokfc ey agbbokh JQDV gs
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
7/114
Sf pofxq f|}ufqqfc ok sloq }veboagsodk guf fksoufby sldqf d slf gvsldu
gkc cd kds kfafqqguoby uffas slf pofxq" }dboay du }dqosodk d slf Vkosfc
Qsgsfq Hdpfuknfks" Cf}gusnfks d Cffkqf" Vkosfc Qsgsfq Q}faogb
D}fugsodkq Adnngkc" du slf Jdoks Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Vkopfuqosy+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
8/114
Ufafks ]veboagsodkq d` slf JQDV ]ufqq
]uopgsf Qfavuosy Ok`ugqsuvasvuf Geudgc" Kdpfnefu "
Huglgn L+ vueopobbf" Ju+Oksfbbohfkaf ok Cfkofc Gufgq" Cfafnefu " Uvqqfbb C+ Ldxguc
Oq Bfgpokh slf Noccbf Fgqs g Pogebf D}sodk" Jgkvguy "Sdngq L+ Lfkuoiqfk
Ufsgokokh g ]ufaguodvq Pgbvf gq Q}faogb D}fugsodkq Hd Ngokqsufgn"@feuvguy " Jfqqoag Hboaifk vukbfy
Coquv}sokh Slufgs @okgkafq" G}uob " Xfqbfy J+B+ Gkcfuqdk
VQQDADN Ufqfgual Sd}oaq 5==?
Okcogq Kduslfgqs: Slf @udksofu ok @funfks" Qf}sfnefu " ]ugigql Qokhl
Xlgs Ufgbby Lg}}fkfc ok Kduslfuk Oufbgkcq Advksfuokqvuhfkay"Dasdefu " Sdngq L+ Lfkuoiqfk
Hvfuuobbg Advksfuoksfbbohfkaf: Okqvuhfks G}}udgalfq sd Kfvsugbozokh
Gcpfuqguy Oksfbbohfkaf D}fugsodkq" Jgkvguy " Huglgn L+ vueopobbf" Ju+
]dboaokh gkc Bgx Fk`duafnfks ok ADOK slf Sloai Ebvf Bokf"@feuvguy " Jdqf}l C+ Afbfqio
Adksfn}duguy Qfavuosy Algbbfkhfq: Ouufhvbgu Xgu`guf gkc OkcoufasG}}udgalfq" @feuvguy " Uoalguc C+ Kfxsdk" ugpoq B+ Ldnogi"Ifbby L+ Qnosl" Oqgga J+ ]fbsofu" gkc C+ Jdkgslgk Xlosf
Q}faogb D}fugsodkq @duafq Oksfughfkay Advksfusfuuduoqn Uf`fufkaf
Ngkvgb" Ngual
Slf Gugeogk Hvb` gkc Qfavuosy ]dboay: Slf ]gqs gq ]ufqfks" slf
]ufqfks gq @vsvuf" G}uob " Udey A+ Eguufss
G`uoag: Ouufhvbgu Xgu`guf dk slf Cgui Adksokfks" Ngy "Jdlk E+ Gbf|gkcfu
VQQDADN Ufqfgual Sd}oaq 5=7=
Uf}dus d` ]udaffcokhq" 3sl Gkkvgb Qdpfufohk Algbbfkhf Adk`fufkaf
,70.7? Ngual 5==?/
Ok`dungsodk Xgu`guf: Gqqvuokh Cohosgb Oksfbbohfkaf Adbbfasodk"Jvby " Xobbogn H+ ]fuuy
Fcvagsokh Q}faogb @duafq Jvkodu Bfgcfuq `du g Adn}bf| Qfavuosy Fkpoudk.
nfks" Jvby " Uvqqfbb C+ Ldxguc
Ngklvksokh: Advksfu.Kfsxdui D}fugsodkq `du Ouufhvbgu Xgu`guf"Qf}sfnefu " Hfduhf G+ Augxduc
Ouufhvbgu Xgu`guf: Eugzobq @ohls Ghgokqs Auonokgb Vuegk Hvfuuobbgq"Qf}sfnefu " Gbpgud cf Qdvzg ]oklfoud
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
9/114
Ok nfnduy d` nduf slgk 5"=== ]gioqsgko qdbcofuq
xld `dvhls xosl adn}bfsf cfcoagsodk
`du gk okadn}bfsf advksuy+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
10/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
11/114
o|
Adksfksq
@dufxduc ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++|o
Gedvs slf Gvsldu ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++|ooo
Gaikdxbfchfnfksq ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++|p
Geeufpogsodkq gkc Gaudkynq ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ |poo
F|favsopf Qvnnguy +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++|o|
7+ F|gnokokh ]gioqsgkq ]dboaofq sd Advksfu gkc@dnfks Okqvuhfkaofq ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 7
5+ ]gioqsgk: ADOK gkc @DOK Slfduy gkc ]ug|oqok Euof` ,7?3< sd 5==7/ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++77
1+ Slf ADOK.@DOK ]gugcd| ,5==5 sd 5==
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
12/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
13/114
|o
@dufxduc
Sloq JQDV }veboagsodk gducq slf ufgcfu gk d}}dusvkosy sd bddi oksd
]gioqsgkq kgsodkgb qfavuosy }dboay gkc qsugsfhy sludvhl slf bfkq d
g ]gioqsgko bdv}f+ Gvsldu Lgocfu Nvbboai" eduk ok Oqbgngegc gkc
fcvagsfc ok slf Vkosfc Qsgsfq ,V+Q+/" }udpocfq loq oksfu}ufsgsodk d ]gioqsgko
qsugsfhoa eflgpodu ok sfunq d slf hfdqsugsfhoa oksfufqsq d slgs kgsodk+
Nu+ Nvbboaiq coqavqqodk d slf qsugsfhoa qfssokh ok Qdvslxfqs Gqog oq
}gusoavbguby sonfby gq slf V+Q+ oq copfusokh qsugsfhoa ufqdvuafq udn slf Ougwo
slfgsfu d xgu sd slf fdus ok Ghlgkoqsgk+ Adkavuufksby" slf kfx gcnokoq.sugsodk d ]ufqocfks Degng oq ufdavqokh slf kgsodkgb qfavuosy qsugsfhy gxgy
udn kdsodkq d g hbdegb xgu dk sfuuduoqn sd g qfavuosy }dboay d g eudgcfu
fkhghfnfks xosl slf advksuofq d slf xdubc gkc }gusoavbguby slf Nvqbon
xdubc+7 Gq dkf }gus d sloq qsugsfhoa poqodk" g }gusoavbgu fdus xobb ef ngcf
sd coqngksbf du cfqsudy Gb Wgfcg gkc osq gqqdaogsfq+
Ok coqavqqokh xlgs Nu+ Nvbboai agbbq qsugsfhoa q}ufgc" lf ufbgsfq ]gio.
qsgkq kgsodkgb oksfufqsq du }udsfasokh slf kgsodk ghgokqs oksfukgb ,qf}g.ugsoqn/ gkc f|sfukgb ,kvabfgu Okcog/ slufgsq+ Qsugsfhoa q}ufgc oq g no| d
}dboay dejfasopfq slgs hvocf dfkqopf" cffkqopf" }uffn}sopf" gkc ouufhv.
bgu xguguf+ Sfqf }dboay g}}udgalfq okabvcf kvabfgu$nobosguy }guosy xosl
Okcog" wvfbbokh oksfukgb coqqfks" qsufkhslfkokh ufbohodvq adlfqopfkfqq" gkc
ngiokh dufohk goc }bfksovb gkc afusgok+ Sf hfdhug}loa confkqodk d sloq
oq qsugsfhoa cf}sl" qffk gq ]gioqsgko okvfkaf ok Ghlgkoqsgk sd advksfu
Okcogk gkc Ougkogk }ud|ofq slfuf" sd lfchf ghgokqs g vsvuf daav}yokh duaf"
gkc sd }udpocf g egqf du ouufhvbgu xguguf ghgokqs Okcog ok Igqlnou+ Sf}udebfn du V+Q+ nobosguy }bgkkfuq oq slgs slfuf oq kd qsudkh aduufbgsodk
gndkh ]gioqsgkq ufhodkgb oksfufqsq gkc sldqf d slf V+Q+ du dslfu advksuofq+
Nu+ Nvbboaiq okqohlsq lohlbohls slf qldusadnokh d gssfn}sokh sd hls g
ufhodkgb xgu dkf advksuy gs g sonf xosl cofufks g}}udgalfq ok oksfufqsq gkc
qsugsfhofq+ Sf gneohvosy d ]gioqsgkq qfavuosy qsugsfhy hfkfugsfq fkdundvq
qsugsfhoa gkhqs du slf xdvbc.ef }fgafngifu: ldx agk dkf galofpf g ufhodkgb
qdbvsodk xlfk ]gioqsgk dnfksq okqvuhfkay ok qdvslfuk Ghlgkoqsgk xlobf
os advksfuq okqvuhfkay ok kduslfuk ]gioqsgk xosl gkc ghgokqs }fd}bf d slf
qgnf ndufqslf ]gqlsvkq+ Xlgs ngifq os nduf adn}boagsfc oq slgs kdx
slf okqvuhfkay ok ]gioqsgk lgq q}ufgc efydkc }ufcdnokgksby ]gqlsvk gufgq
sd slf advksuyq afksugb }udpokaf d ]vkjge gkc slf qdvslfuk }udpokafq d
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
14/114
|oo
Egbvaloqsgk gkc Qokcl+ Sf qosvgsodk qvhhfqsq xlgs Nu+ Nvbboai sfunq" g
ADOK.@DOK }gugcd|+
]gioqsgk lgq edsl advksfufc gkc dnfksfc okqvuhfkay sd ngoksgok osqqsugsfhoa oksfufqsq" kds vkboif slf cdnokgks advksuofq cvuokh slf Adbc Xgu+
Avuufksby" Nu+ Nvbboai deqfupfq" ]gioqsgk oq lfb}okh slf V+Q+ sd udds dvs Gb
Wgfcg gkc gqqdaogsfc ]gioqsgko gboegk ok slf kduslfuk suoegb gufgq" xlobf
os okcoufasby gefsq Ghlgk gboegk ok qdvslfuk Ghlgkoqsgk+ ]gioqsgk xgksq
sd ngoksgok okvfkaf ok qdvslfuk Ghlgkoqsgk gq g cffkqf ghgokqs Okcogq
qsugsfhoa fkaouabfnfks gkc g xgy sd ngoksgok qsugsfhoa cf}sl+ Kgsodkgb
qfavuosy bfgcfuq d slf ufhodkq advksuofq xobb kffc sd kc gkdslfu xgy sd
gbbgy ]gioqsgkq adkafukq gedvs osq qsugsfhoa cf}sl" gkc dkby gk on}udpfnfksd slf ]gioqsgk.Okcog ufbgsodkqlo} gbdkh xosl g ufqdbvsodk d slf ]gqlsvk
okqvuhfkay ok Kduslfuk ]gioqsgk xobb lgpf qohkoagks on}gas dpfu slf bdkh
sfun+
d qfavuf ]gioqsgk ghgokqs okqvuhfkay gkc coqngksbf Gb Wgfcg" Nu+
Nvbboai qvhhfqsq slgs g }udhugn oq kffcfc sd ufqsduf slf }uocf gkc ndufq
,]gqlsvkxgbo/ d slf ]gqlsvkq dk edsl qocfq d slf Cvugkc Bokf+ Lf
gcpdagsfq bgvkalokh D}fugsodk ]UOCF+ Soq gaudkyn agbbq du }dbosoagbufadkaobogsodk" ufadkqsuvasodk gkc ufdun" on}udpokh oksfbbohfkaf gkc add}.
fugsodk" cfsfuufkaf" gkc fkcvugkaf+ Soq gbbq kfgsby ok bokf xosl ]ufqocfks
Degngq kfx qsugsfhoa g}}udgal sd lfb} kgsodkq gcpgkaf }udhugnq du }dboso.
agb" fadkdnoa" gkc qdaogb cfpfbd}nfks+ Dkf nvqs wvfqsodk o slf qsugsfhoa
fkpoudknfks ok Qdvslxfqs Gqog xobb gbbdx slf cfqoufc dvsadnfq+ Afusgokby
slf qsugsfhoa oqqvfq dvsbokfc gedpf xobb lgpf sd ef sgaibfc uqs+
Soq ndkdhug}l }udpocfq g ufhodkgb }fuq}fasopf slgs oq vqfvb sd slf
Q}faogb D}fugsodkq @duafq ,QD@/ adnnvkosy+ Os vuslfu uffasq slgs advksfu.okqvuhfkay oq kds xfbb vkcfuqsddc dk foslfu qocf d slf Ghlgkoqsgk.]gioqsgk
educfu+ Xlgs oq vqfvb sd slf QD@ ufgcfu oq slf fklgkafc g}}ufaogsodk d slf
}udebfnq" }dbosoagb oksuohvfq" gkc noqqfc d}}dusvkosofq ok slf hls udn slf
]gioqsgk pofx+ Sfqf okqohlsq xobb fkgebf slf d}fugsdu sd hvocf d}fugsodkq
xosl edsl qocfq d slf educfu ok nokc+
Ifkkfsl L+ ]ddbf
Coufasdu" JQDV Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
15/114
|ooo
Gedvs slf Gvsldu
Lgocfu Gbo Lvqqfok Nvbboai" g
JQDV gqqdaogsf fbbdx" adkcvasq
ufqfgual dk V+Q+ dufohk }dboay
sdxguc Qdvsl Gqog gkc slf Noccbf Fgqs+
Cvuokh loq aguffu" lf lgq davqfc dk
V+Q+.]gioqsgk ufbgsodkq gkc eudgcfu oqqvfq
d qfavuosy" qdaodfadkdnoaq" gkc slf hfd.
}dbosoaq d ]gioqsgk" Ghlgkoqsgk" gkc QdvslGqog+ Ok Dasdefu gkc Kdpfnefu 5==?" Nu+
Nvbboai sugpfbfc ok Qdvsl Gqog ok qv}}dus
d xuosokh g xlosf }g}fu du Hfkfugb Cgpoc
]fsugfvq dk xgyq sd on}udpf slf V+Q+.]gi.
oqsgk qfavuosy }guskfuqlo}+
Nu+ Nvbboai oq gbqd g ufqfgual fbbdx
gs slf Okqsosvsf du Qdaogb ]dboay gkc Vkcfuqsgkcokh ,OQ]V/ ok Noalohgk9ufqfgual gqqdaogsf gs slf ]gioqsgk Qfavuosy Ufqfgual Vkos" Vkopfuqosy d
Eugcduc" Vkosfc Iokhcdn9 gkc }gus d slf ]gkfb d F|}fusq gs Q}fgulfgc
Ufqfgual" ]gioqsgk+ Lgocfu ufafksby }ufqfksfc loq dkhdokh ufqfgual dk ]gio.
qsgkq kgsodkgb qfavuosy }dboay gs g adkfufkaf duhgkozfc jdoksby ey JQDV
gkc slf Aguu Afksfu du Lvngk Uohlsq" Lgupguc Ifkkfcy Qalddb9 gs slf
Euddiokhq Okqsosvsodk9 gkc V+Q+ Gunyq Coufasfc Qsvcofq D`af+
]ufpodvqby" Nu+ Nvbboai adkcvasfc ufqfgual gs slf Euddiokhq Okqsosv.
sodkq @dufohk ]dboay Qsvcofq ,V+Q+.]gioqsgk Ufbgsodkq/" Xddcudx XobqdkOksfukgsodkgb Afksfu du Qaldbguq ,]gioqsgkq ]dbosoagb Fadkdny gkc
Ufpopokh @gobfc Qsgsfq/" gkc slf Lvcqdk Okqsosvsfq Afksfu dk Oqbgn" Cfnda.
ugay gkc slf @vsvuf d slf Nvqbon Xdubc ,Ngcugqqg Fcvagsodk gkc Bokiq
sd Oqbgnoqs Nobosgkay/+ @du dslfuq" qff xxx+lgocfunvbboai+adn+
Nu+ Nvbboaiq }dboay euofq du gusoabfq lgpf g}}fgufc ok @dufohk G`gouq"
_gbf Hbdegb" Xdubc ]dbosoaq Ufpofx" Hfduhfsdxk Jdvukgb d Oksfukgsodkgb
G`gouq" Qnosl Uoalgucqdk @dvkcgsodkq ]gioqsgk Uf}dus" D|duc Gkgbysoag"
]gioqsgk Qfavuosy Ufqfgual Vkos" Vkopfuqosy d Eugcducq ]dboay Euof"Jgkfq
]dboay Euof" Xddcudx Xobqdk Afksfu Ghlgkoqsgk Uf}dus" gkc slf Lfuosghf
@dvkcgsodkq Egaihudvkcfu+ Loq fcosduogbq lgpf g}}fgufc ok Kfxqxffi" Sf
Xgqlokhsdk ]dqs" @dufohk ]dboay nghgzokf" Sf Kgsodk ,]gioqsgk/" Sf Cgoby
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
16/114
|op
onfq" Sf Kfxq Oksfukgsodkgb" Sf onfq d Okcog" Okcogk F|}ufqq" Hvb
Kfxq" gkc ]gioqsgk Boki+ Loq P g}}fgugkafq gkc nfcog oksfupofxq lgpf
effk xosl AKK Oksfukgsodkgb"Gb Jgzffug Fkhboql Uoz Ilgk Qldx" Pdoaf dGnfuoag" ]EQ Kfxq Ldvu" AEQ Kfxq" Xgqlokhsdk Okcf}fkcfks" gkc onf
nghgzokf+ ,@du cfsgobq" poqos xxx+lgocfunvbboai+adn+/
Lgocfu fgukfc loq E+G+ ok Fadkdnoaq gkc N+G+ ok ]veboa ]dboay udn slf
Udefus F+ Addi Ldkduq Adbbfhf gs Okcogkg Vkopfuqosy d ]fkkqybpgkog+ Lf
xgq eduk gkc ugoqfc ok Oqbgngegc" ]gioqsgk gkc avuufksby ufqocfq xosl loq
xof ok Xgqlokhsdk" C+A+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
17/114
|p
Gaikdxbfchfnfksq
Ogn hugsfvb sd slf Qsugsfhoa Qsvcofq Cf}gusnfks" JQDV ]ufqq du
q}dkqduokh gkc fcosokh sloq ndkdhug}l+ Q}faogb slgkiq sd slf dunfu
coufasdu" Bs Adb Noalgfb A+ NaNgldk ,kdx g }udfqqdu gs slf V+Q+ Gou
@duaf Gagcfny/+ Noalgfb qldxfc hufgs oksfufqs gkc edbqsfufc ny adkcfkaf
udn slf pfuy efhokkokh xlfk O uqs }ufqfksfc slf ocfg ok slf q}uokh d 5==
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
18/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
19/114
|poo
Geeufpogsodkq gkc Gaudkynq
GK] ++++++++++++++++++ Gxgno Kgsodkgb ]gusy
GWG ++++++++++++++++++ Gb Wgfcg gkc gqqdaogsfq
AFKADN +++++Afksugb Adnngkc ,Vkosfc Qsgsfq/
ADOK++++++++++++++++Advksfuokqvuhfkay
@GG ++++++++++++++++ @fcfugbby Gcnokoqsfufc uoegb Gufg
@A +++++++++++++++++++++@udksofu Adu}q ,]gioqsgk/
@DOK ++++++++++++++++@dnfksokh okqvuhfkay
LfN +++++++++++++++++ Lguigs.vb.NvjglocffkLK ++++++++++++++++++++Lgwwgko Kfsxdui ,Jgbgbvccok gkc Qgugjvccok hudv}q/
LvN +++++++++++++++++ Loze.vb.Nvjglocffk
OFC +++++++++++++++++++ On}udpoqfc f|}bdqopf cfpoaf
ONV ++++++++++++++++++ Oqbgnoa Ndpfnfks d Vzefioqsgk
OQG@ ++++++++++++++++++ Oksfukgsodkgb Qfavuosy Gqqoqsgkaf @duaf ,du Ghlgkoqsgk/
OQO +++++++++++++++++++++ Oksfu.Qfupoafq Oksfbbohfkaf ,Coufasdugsf d ]gioqsgk/
JfN +++++++++++++++++++ Jgoql.f.Ndlgnngc
JO++++++++++++++++++++++++ Jgnggs.f.Oqbgno
Bf ++++++++++++++++++++Bgqligu.f.goeg
NNG +++++++++++++++ Nvssglocg Ngjboq.f.Gngb , adgbosodk d Oqbgnoqs }gusofq/
KGD+++++++++++++++Kdusl Gsbgksoa ufgsy Duhgkozgsodk
KA ++++++++++++++++++++Kgsodkgb Adkfufkaf ,Okcogk.gcnokoqsfufc Igqlnouo ]gusy/
KX@] ++++++++++++++Kduslxfqs @udksofu ]udpokaf
]NB.K +++++++++++++ ]gioqsgk Nvqbon Bfghvf" Kgxgz hudv}
]NB.W +++++++++++++ ]gioqsgk Nvqbon Bfghvf" Wvgoc.f.Gzgn hudv}]]] +++++++++++++++++++]gioqsgk ]fd}bfq ]gusy
QD@ +++++++++++++++++++ Q}faogb D}fugsodk @duafq ,Vkosfc Qsgsfq/
QQH +++++++++++++++++++ Q}faogb Qfupoafq Hudv} ,]gioqsgkq QD@/
QKN ++++++++++++++ fluoi.f.Kogz.f.Ndlgnngco
] ++++++++++++++++++ fluoi.f.gboegk ]gioqsgk
VGP ++++++++++++++++++ Vkngkkfc Gfuogb Pfloabf
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
20/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
21/114
|o|
F|favsopf Qvnnguy
Ndqs Gnfuoagk gkc ]gioqsgko }dbosoagb gkc nobosguy bfgcfuq
ghuff slgs xosldvs g aufcoebf V+Q+.]gioqsgk }guskfuqlo}" poasduy
ghgokqs gboegk gkc Gb Wgfcg oq on}dqqoebf+ @du qval g }guskfu.
qlo}" qlgufc hdgbq nvqs ef ngsalfc ey qlgufc slufgsq" gkc }fuaf}sodkq nvqs
dbbdx cfndkqsugebf gasodk+ Xgqlokhsdk gkc Oqbgngegc ghuff slgs Gb Wgfcg
nvqs ef cffgsfc+ ]gioqsgkq kgsodkgb qfavuosy agbavbvqegqfc dk Okcogq
okvfkaf ok Ghlgkoqsgkldxfpfu" sufgsq Ghlgk gboegk gq bfpfughf gkc
]gioqsgko gboegk gq fkfnofq d slf qsgsf+ Adkqfwvfksby" Ghlgk gboegkguf }udpocfc gqybvn ok ]gioqsgk xlobf slfy xufgi lgpda ok Ghlgkoqsgk"
gkc ]gioqsgko gboegk guf gssgaifc+ Xlobf ]gioqsgk lgq advksfufc gkc
dnfksfc kvnfudvq okqvuhfkaofq" sloq oq slf uqs sonf slgs os lgq cdkf
edsl sd galofpf osq kgsodkgb qfavuosy hdgbq+ Soq cvgb }dboay gkc coqadkkfas
efsxffk Gnfuoagk gkc ]gioqsgko slufgs }fuaf}sodkq oq gs slf lfgus d ]gio.
qsgkq qfavuosy }gugcd|+ ]gioqsgk adksokvfq sd okcoufasby advksfu ,ADOK/ gkc
dnfks ,@DOK/ okqvuhfkay ok Ghlgkoqsgk+ Xosldvs gaikdxbfchokh" f|}bo.agsokh" gkc fpfksvgbby algkhokh sloq }gugcd|" Ghlgkoqsgk gkc ]gioqsgk
xobb adksokvf sd cfqafks oksd algdq+
Xlobf ngky ufqfgualfuq gkc gkgbyqsq davq dk slf avuufks qfavuosy qosv.
gsodk ok slf ufhodk" sdd fx lgpf f|gnokfc slf loqsduoagb cfpfbd}nfks d
]gioqsgkq kgsodkgb qfavuosy qsugsfhy gkc ldx os nvqs ef afksfu qsghf ok
cfpfbd}okh g qvqsgokgebf bdkh.sfun V+Q+.]gioqsgk }guskfuqlo}+ Ok 5==?" slf
Vkosfc Qsgsfq qlofc davq udn Ougw sd Ghlgkoqsgk" gkc ]gioqsgk }udpocfc
nduf ufqdvuafq gkc }fuqdkkfb+ Sf Ghlgk gboegk}gsudkq d Gb Wgfcggkc slfou ]gioqsgko advksfu}gusq ,]gioqsgko gboegk gkc sfuuduoqsq udn
]vkjge/ adksudb ndqs d qdvslfuk Ghlgkoqsgk gkc }gusq d kduslfuk gkc
qdvslfuk kvabfgu.gunfc ]gioqsgk+ Sfqf sfuuduoqs qgkasvguofq guf adkcvosq
du kguad.cdbbguq" ufauvosq" xfg}dkq gkc ocfgb bdagsodkq sd }bgk ?$77.sy}f
gssgaiq ghgokqs slf Vkosfc Qsgsfq gkc osq gbbofq+ Ufbyokh dk okf|}fuofkafc
Ghlgk qfavuosy duafq" Gnfuoagk nobosguy qsuvhhbfc sd ufhgok slf okosogsopf
ghgokqs slf Ghlgk gboegk gbb yfgu+ ]gioqsgko nobosguy" ldxfpfu" cfbopfufc
g qvu}uoqokh ebdx sd slf ]gioqsgko gboegk ok 5==? sgiokh egai slf qsugsfhoa
Qxgs Pgbbfy gkc Qdvsl Xgzouoqsgk+ Xlobf wvfqsodkq d ldbcokh gufgq gfu
slfy abfgufc slfn d okqvuhfksq ufngok" ]gioqsgko qdbcofuq ufhgokfc slf
okosogsopf ghgokqs slf ]gioqsgko gboegk ey slf fkc d slf yfgu+ Ok Cfafnefu
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
22/114
||
5==? ]ufqocfks Egugi Degng gkkdvkafc qfkcokh 1="=== gccosodkgb sudd}q
sd ufhgok adksudb d qdvslfuk Ghlgkoqsgk ok 5=7=slf lfgus d slf Ghlgk
gboegk okqvuhfkay+Qvaafqq cfngkcq g ldboqsoa g}}udgal sdxguc Ghlgkoqsgk gkc ]gioqsgk
slgs ufadhkozfq hfd}dbosoagb ufgbosofqOkcog gkc ]gioqsgkgkc Ghlgko.
qsgkq vsvuf pvbkfugeobosy sd efadnokh g sfuuduoqs qgkasvguy dkaf adgbosodk
gkc Gnfuoagk sudd}q bfgpf+ Sf cfegsf nvqs ef davqfc dk euokhokh gedvs
bdkh.sfun }dbosoagb gkc qdaodfadkdnoa cfpfbd}nfks sd ]gioqsgkq kdusl
gkc Ghlgkoqsgk qdvsl dk slf egaiq d qldus. gkc nfcovn.sfun poqoebf
gkc aufcoebf ufdunq slgs afksfu dk okaufgqfc qfavuosy gkc }dbosoagb gkc
fadkdnoa xfbb efokh d slf }fd}bf+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
23/114
7
]gioqsgkq Qfavuosy ]gugcd|:
Advksfuokh gkc @dnfksokh Okqvuhfkaofq
F|gnokokh ]gioqsgkq ]dboaofq sd Advksfu gkc7+@dnfks Okqvuhfkaofq
E
y ndqs gaadvksq" slf suo}gusosfVkosfc Qsgsfq ,V+Q+/$ Kdusl Gsbgksoa
ufgsy Duhgkozgsodk ,KGD/" Ghlgkoqsgk" gkc ]gioqsgkadvk.
sfuokqvuhfkay ,ADOK/ ufq}dkqf ok slf bgqs < yfguq lgq gobfc+5 Soqndkdhug}l f|gnokfq slf gasduq eflokc qval gobvuf ey gkgbyzokh ]gioqsgkq
}dboaofq sd advksfu gkc dnfks okqvuhfkaofq ok slf ufhodk gkc gssfn}sq sd
gkqxfu sloq wvfqsodk:
Gfu f|gnokokh ]gioqsgkq }dboaofq sd advksfu gkc dnfks
okqvuhfkaofq" xlgs nohls ef slf efqs V+Q+.]gioqsgk qsugsfhoa
}guskfuqlo} sd cffgs slf sugkqkgsodkgb okqvuhfkay4
Slf Cfegsf
]ufqocfks Degng lgq lgc bossbf sudvebf }bgaokh ]gioqsgk gs slf sd} dV+Q+
kgsodkgb qfavuosy }uoduosofq+ G 7
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
24/114
5
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?
]gioqsgko gboegk alg}sfu QKN xgq gk f|gn}bf d slf uoqf d slf vneufbbg
okqvuhfkayq adksudb ok ]gioqsgk+1 Sf qveqfwvfks ]gioqsgko nobosguy d}fug.
sodk ,Uohlsfdvq ]gsl/ coqngksbfc" coquv}sfc" gkc cfqsudyfc ndqs d slfgboegkq adnngkc gkc adksudb gkc ufauvosnfks okugqsuvasvuf ok slf Qxgs
pgbbfy+ Ey bgsf 5==? ]gioqsgkq nobosguy xgq fkhudqqfc ok sdvhl" }osal egssbfq
xosl gboegk okqvuhfksq ok Qdvsl Xgzouoqsgk" Iyefu" Ivuugn" gkc Dugizgo
ghfkaofq uf}boagsokh qvaafqqvb sgasoaq udn slf Qxgs d}fugsodk+
Ok slf bgqs < yfguq" slf V+Q+" Ghlgk" gkc ]gioqsgko ADOK fdusq lgpf
qsuvhhbfc sd galofpf slf dejfasopf d fbonokgsokh Gb Wgfcg gkc gqqdao.
gsfq ,GWG/" kdsgeby Ghlgk gkc ]gioqsgko gboegk" slfou egqfq d d}fug.
sodkq" gunq agalfq gkc ufauvosnfks" gkc slfou kgkaogb kfsxduiq dk edslqocfq d slf educfu" ikdxk gq slf Cvugkc Bokf+3 Okosogb nobosguy qvaafqq ok
Ghlgkoqsgk gkc ]gioqsgk ghgokqs g gboegk gkc Gb Wgfcg ok coqguugy xgq
hugcvgbby xo}fc gxgy xlfk slfy unby kfqsfc slfou egqfq ok slf qdvsl.
fgqsfuk }udpokafq d Ghlgkoqsgk gkc ]gioqsgkq kduslxfqs" kdsgeby slf
@fcfugbby Gcnokoqsfufc uoegb Gufg ,@GG/+ G pousvgb edkc d qdbocguosy
gkc d}fugsodkgb gqqoqsgkaf efsxffk bdagb" ufhodkgb" gkc hbdegb f|sufnoqs
Oqbgnoqs hudv}q" gefssfc ey ngokqsufgn Oqbgnoqs }gusofq gkc qyn}gslfsoa]gioqsgko oksfbbohfkaf d`afuq" }udpfc okaufgqokhby co`avbs sd vksgkhbf" bfs
gbdkf eufgi+
Sf }ufpgobokh xoqcdn oq slgs g gxfc V+Q+ nobosguy }dboayvkcvby
davqfc dk gou}dxfu dpfu sudd} qsufkhsl gkc qldus.sfun qfavuosy dpfu cfpfb.
d}nfks ok Ghlgkoqsgk no|fc xosl ]gioqsgkq ufbvasgkaf sd hd gfu slf
Ghlgk gboegkvkfwvopdagbby bfc sd noqqodk gobvuf+ Sf bguhfby gaaf}sfc
ufgqdk oq slgs ]gioqsgk lgq g cv}boaosdvq }dboay sdxguc slf Ghlgk gboegk
slgs fkqvufq slf okqvuhfkayq qvupopgb ok qdvsl Ghlgkoqsgk+ Os oq qd slgs slfgboegk" gq slfy coc cvuokh slf Qdpofs.Ghlgk xgu 7?
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
25/114
1
Nvbboai: ]gioqsgkq Qfavuosy ]gugcd|
sugokokh" fwvo}nfks" gkc gbbfhfc ]gioqsgko cv}boaosy ok }vuqvokh okqvu.
hfksq+ @du slf bdkhfqs sonf qsugsfhoa hdgbq d slf V+Q+ gkc ]gioqsgk coc kds
adokaocf+
@ohvuf 7+ ]gioqsgkq @fcfugbby Gcnokoqsfufc Suoegb Gufg ,@GSG/ gkc Kduslxfqs@udksofu ]udpokaf ,KX@]/+ Egqf ng} 5==8 ey Xdubc Sugcf ]ufqq9 gbb uohlsqufqfupfc+ Vqfc xosl }funoqqodk+
]gioqsgk,Kduslfuk Gufgq/
]gioqsgk,]vkjge/
]gioqsgk
,Egbdaloqsgk/
Okcog
G`hlgkoqsgk
Sgjoiqsgk
Alosugb
Cou
Idlgs
Igugi
Ndln
gkc
Ghfkay
EgjgvuGhfkay
Sgki
BgiioNguxgs
Lgkhv
Ilyefu
Ghfkay
Egkkv
Qxgs
Evkfu
Kdxqlfug
Dugizgo Ghfkay
]fqlgx
guQxgeo
Ngucgk
Ngbgigkc
Ghfka
y
Idloqsgk
Cfug OqngobIlgk
QdvslXgzouoqsgk
Kdusl
Xgzouoqsgk
IvuugnGhfkay
Qlgkhbg
Lguo}vuAlguqgccg
Gee
dssgeg
c
Egssghugn
Ngkqflu
g
@fcfugbby Gcnokoqsfufc Suoegb Gufg
Kduslxfqs @udksofu ]udpokaf
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
26/114
3
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?
Dk egbgkaf" slf V+Q+ dejfasopf sd }ufpfks Ghlgkoqsgk Ygkc ]gioqsgk^
udn efokh vqfc gq g egqf du sfuuduoqsq gkc f|sufnoqsq sd gssgai slf V+Q+ gkc
osq gbbofq" agkkds ef galofpfc ey g sugkqgasodkgb V+Q+.]gioqsgk }guskfuqlo}+8
]ufqocfks Egugi Degng lgq algkhfc advuqf ey g}}byokh g ufhodkgb g}}udgal"
okaufgqokh kdknobosguy goc sd ]gioqsgk" okaufgqokh sudd} qsufkhsl ok Ghlgko.
qsgk" gkc g}}doksokh kfx nobosguy gkc aopobogk bfgcfuq sd efssfu oksfhugsf
V+Q+ gkc gbby ufqdvuafq ok slf ufhodk+< Sf V+Q+ }dboay hdgb oq sd coqngksbf"
coquv}s" gkc coqgun Gb Wgfcg" adkcvas ADOK d}fugsodkq vkcfu slf uveuoa
dxldbf.d.hdpfuknfksqsgeobozgsodk d}fugsodkq vkcfu V+Q+ adnngkc okqocf
Ghlgkoqsgk" gkc adksokvf sd dvsqdvuaf ADOK d}fugsodkq ok ]gioqsgkq fgqs
sd slf ]gioqsgko nobosguy gbefos xosl nduf dpfuqohls gkc gaadvksgeobosy+?
Sf kfx Gnfuoagk gcnokoqsugsodk qldxq }udnoqf du algkhf9 ldxfpfu"
du kdx" ]ufqocfks Degng oq adksokvokh slf f|oqsokh V+Q+ nobosguy qsugs.
fhy d }vuqvokh gkc oksfucoasokh GWG okqocf ]gioqsgk sludvhl vkngkkfc
gfuogb pfloabf ,VGP/ cudkf gssgaiq gkc daagqodkgb Q}faogb @duafq lds }vu.
qvosnoqqodkq9 ufafks uf}dusq qvhhfqs gk okaufgqf ok slf ufwvfkay gkc gufg
d d}fugsodkq+7= Dk slf }dbosoagb qocf" g }vql f|oqsq du cogbdhvf efsxffk
Igevb" Oqbgngegc" gkc slf gboegk+ Ok bgsf 5==
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
27/114
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
28/114
0
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?
Gk okv| d nduf dufohk sudd}q oq kds g qvqsgokgebf qdbvsodk9 slf qvuhf" ey
cfkosodk" oq gk okaufgqf dV+Q+ sudd}q slgs oq cfqohkfc sd sobs slf egbgkaf
d bfhosongsf }dxfu ok gpdu d slf qsgsf+ Sf qvuhf oq }gus d slf qsugsfhy"kds g qsugsfhy ok osqfb+ V+Q+ }dboayngifuq guf ld}okh nduf V+Q+ eddsq dk slf
hudvkc xobb lfb} }udsfas slf }d}vbgsodk" xloal xobb ok svuk }udpocf efssfu
oksfbbohfkaf" cfpfbd} suvqs" gkc lfb} ok qsgeobozgsodk d}fugsodkq okabvcokh
qdaodfadkdnoa okugqsuvasvuf evobcokh+ Dkaf slgs oq gaadn}boqlfc" slf ld}f
oq slgs slf Ghlgk hdpfuknfks agk eudifu }fgaf xosl ufadkaobgebf fbfnfksq
xoslok slf okqvuhfkay" gbbdxokh Ghlgk sudd}q sd aguuy dk ADOK d}fug.
sodkq+ Bdagb }guskfuqlo}q" fq}faogbby ok }dboaokh gkc hdpfukgkaf" xobb ef
}gugndvks+ Nduf oq kffcfc" ldxfpfu" du sloq ocfgb dvsadnf+ Gk ffasopfhdpfuknfks oq ify sd adkpokaf slf }d}vbgsodk slgs slf qsgsf oq dk slfou qocf"
agk }udsfas slfn" gkc xobb }udpocf slfn qfavuosy" cfpfbd}nfks" gkc q}ffcy
jvqsoaf+ dcgy" du slf ndqs }gus" slf Ghlgk gboegk ok slf qdvslfuk gkc
fgqsfuk }udpokafq guf ok adksudb gkc }udpocokh slfqf qfupoafq" kdsgeby q}ffcy
jvqsoaf sludvhl suoegb gkc ufbohodvq avqsdnq+
Ldx slfqf algkhfq guf pofxfc ok ]gioqsgk oq vkfwvopdagbby on}dusgks+
Hfkfugb Gqlgw ]gupfz Igygko" slf lfgc d ]gioqsgkq guny ,alof d qsg/"gkc slf Oksfbbohfkaf alof" Hfkfugb Qlvjg ]gqlg d slf Oksfu.Qfupoafq Oksfb.
bohfkaf ,OQO/ Coufasdugsf" guf xduiokh lguc sd euokh gedvs gk dpfulgvb ok
slf ]gioqsgko nobosguy sd ffasopfby hls slf okqvuhfksq ok @GG gkc KX@]+
Sfuf lgq effk qohkoagks qvaafqq ok dkhdokh d}fugsodkq ok slf Qxgs Pgbbfy
ok Ngy gkc Jvkf gkc ok qdvsl Xgzouoqsgk ok Kdpfnefu d 5==?+ Hfkfugb
Igygko oq fkadvughokh V+Q+ Q}faogb D}fugsodkq @duafq ,QD@/ sugokfuq sd
lfb} slf qsuvhhbokh @udksofu Adu}q ,@A/g bohls okgksuy vkos loqsduoagbby
fwvo}}fc gkc sugokfc du educfu qfavuosy" advksfuqnvhhbokh" gkc advksfu.kguadsoaq d}fugsodkq gkc qokaf 5==5 gasopfby okpdbpfc ok ADOK d}fugsodkq+
Ldxfpfu" slf ]gioqsgko nobosguyq Kd+ 7 cfngkc qd gu oq fwvo}nfks" fq}f.
aogbby Adeug lfboad}sfuq slgs lgpf qd gu gufc xfbb ok ADOK d}fugsodkq ok
slf ufhodkq adkoas slfgsfu+
Xlobf slf cfegsf gedvs gocokh @A oq dkhdokh" slf ]gioqsgko nobosguy lgq
cfaocfc slgs @A xobb sgif afksfu qsghf ok }udpocokh slf ndqs eddsq dk slf
hudvkc xosl qohkoagks lfb} udn ufhvbgu guny egssgbodkq gkc Q}faogb Qfu.
poafq Hudv} ,QQH/ adnngkcdfq+ Avuufksby slfuf guf 76="=== sudd}q86"===
guf @A" 81"=== ufhvbgu sudd}q" gkc 5"=== QQHq+73 Gk gccosodkgb 0="===.ngk
}dboaf duaf oq ok slf ufhodk ,g}}ud|ongsfby 5="=== ok @GG" gkc slf ufqs ok
KX@]/+76 G adkafusfc fdus oq efokh vkcfusgifk sd }vuhf udhvf OQO ghfksq
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
29/114
8
Nvbboai: ]gioqsgkq Qfavuosy ]gugcd|
xosl qyn}gslofq du GWG ,73= xfuf coqnoqqfc qokaf Gvhvqs 5==
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
30/114
9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu
+
+ Qff Hopf vq Cgcvbbgl" gif guow: gboegk" Sf Cgoby onfq" @feuvguy "gpgobgebf gs lss}:$$qfupfu+ieuo.oqbgngegc+hd+oc$okcf|+}l}4d}sodk>adnTadksfkssgqi>pofxoc>Osfnoc>9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
+ Qff Lgocfu G+ L+ Nvbboai" Xlfuf ]gioqsgk oq Xokkokh" Kfxqxffi" Ngy "gpgobgebf gs xxx+kfxqxffi+adn$oc$9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
+ Qff Lgocfu G+ L+ Nvbboai" Bodkq gkc Jgaigbq: ]gioqsgkq Fnfuhokh Advksfuokqvu.hfkay Qsugsfhy" @dufohk Ggouq" Jvby " gpgobgebf gs xxx+dufohkggouq+adn$gusoabfq$$lgocfu.gbo.lvqqfok.nvbboai$bodkq.gkc.jgaigbq9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu+
-
8/14/2019 Pakistan's Security Paradox (Full Length)
114/114
JQDV Uf}dus =?.?
+ Oksfupofx xosl g qfkodu ]gioqsgko nobosguy d`aogb" Ngual +
+ @du cfsgobq" qff Qfsl Jdkfq" Advksfuokqvuhfkay ok Ghlgkoqsgk ,Qgksg Ndkoag" AG:UGKC Adu}dugsodk" /" gpgobgebf gs xxx+ugkc+duh$}veq$ndkdhug}lq$$UGKCTNH+}c9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
+ Oksfupofxq xosl qfpfugb bdagb jdvukgboqsq" gkgbyqsq" gkc dunfu nobosguy gkc oksfb.bohfkaf d`afuq slgs xoql sd ufngok gkdkyndvq+
+ Egqfc dk oksfupofxq xosl bdagb jdvukgboqsq gkc nfcog uf}dusdu f|gn}bf:
V+K+ ufvhff ghfkay qffiq # nobbodk du coq}bgafc ]gioqsgkoq"g+ Sf Cgobyonfq" Qf}sfnefu " gpgobgebf gs xxx+cgobysonfq+adn+}i$cfgvbs+gq}4}ghf>RRRqsduyT..T}hT9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
V+Q+ Adkhufqq digyq + eobbodk ]gioqsgk goc"e+ Sf Cgoby onfq" Jvkf
" gpgobgebf gs xxx+cgobysonfq+adn+}i$cfgvbs+gq}4}ghf>RRRqsduyT..T}hT9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
+ Qff Qfsl A+ Jdkfq gkc Ngusok A+ Boeoaio" Ldx fuuduoqs Hudv}q Fkc: Bfqqdkq duAdvksfuokh Gb Wgfcg ,Qgksg Ndkoag" AG: UGKC Adu}dugsodk" /" gpgobgebfgs xxx+ugkc+duh$}veq$ndkdhug}lq$$UGKCTNH.+qvn+}c9 gaafqqfcDasdefu +
+ Oeoc+
+ ]UOCF oq vqfc edsl gq g xduc gkc gaudkyn+
+ Ok g G}uob nffsokh xosl slf alof d slf ]gioqsgko Oksfbbohfkaf Evufgv okXgqlokhsdk" C+A+" slf }uokao}gb okpfqsohgsdu xgq hopfk g euofkh dk slf kffcq dslf ]gioqsgko }dboaf+
+ Qff Kdsoagsodk d okaufgqf ok }dboaf qgbguofq oqqvfc: Okaufgqf ok ugsodk gbbdxgkafcfabokfc" Cgoby onfq" Ngy " gpgobgebf gs xxx+cgobysonfq+adn+}i$cfgvbs+gq}4}ghf>RRRqsduyT..T}hT9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
+ Qff pguodvq uf}dusq d slf Lvngk Uohlsq Adnnoqqodk d ]gioqsgk gs xxx+lua}.xfe+duh9 gaafqqfc Dasdefu +
EEA o bo ] io s J b ob eb s lss $$ ee i$$lo$