pain in post-polio patients anne c. gawne md director post-polio clinic roosevelt warm springs...
TRANSCRIPT
Pain in Post-Polio Pain in Post-Polio PatientsPatients
Anne C. Gawne MDAnne C. Gawne MD
Director Post-Polio ClinicDirector Post-Polio Clinic
Roosevelt Warm Springs Roosevelt Warm Springs IntsituteIntsitute
Post-Polio Syndrome (PPS)Post-Polio Syndrome (PPS)
New Weakness New Weakness Pain in Muscles and JointsPain in Muscles and Joints FatigueFatigue Shortness of BreathShortness of Breath
Pain in Polio SurvivorsPain in Polio Survivors
Most Prevalent Complaint in Many Most Prevalent Complaint in Many StudiesStudies
80% of all Polio Survivors Complain 80% of all Polio Survivors Complain of Painof Pain
Types of Pain in PPSTypes of Pain in PPS
Post-polio Muscle Post-polio Muscle PainPain
Overuse PainOveruse Pain Biomechanical Biomechanical
PainPain FibromyalgiaFibromyalgia
Post-Polio Muscle PainPost-Polio Muscle Pain
Occurs in muscles affected by polioOccurs in muscles affected by polio Deep aching pain, with cramps and Deep aching pain, with cramps and
fasciculationsfasciculations Occurs in the evening or at nightOccurs in the evening or at night Exacerbated by physical activity, Exacerbated by physical activity,
cold and stresscold and stress
Overuse PainOveruse Pain
Occurs in muscles, tendons bursa Occurs in muscles, tendons bursa and ligamentsand ligaments
Common in the shoulder) rotater Common in the shoulder) rotater cuff Tendonitis), back (Myofascial cuff Tendonitis), back (Myofascial pain)pain)
Worse with overuse, poor body Worse with overuse, poor body mechanicsmechanics
Biomechanical PainBiomechanical Pain
DJD DJD Low Back PainLow Back Pain Nerve Nerve
Compression Compression SyndromesSyndromes
Caused by poor Caused by poor BiamechanicsBiamechanics
FibromyalgiaFibromyalgia
8/11 Tender points8/11 Tender points Widespread pain in 4 quadrants X Widespread pain in 4 quadrants X
3 mo3 mo FatigueFatigue Sleep disorderSleep disorder Numbness and tinglingNumbness and tingling HeadachesHeadaches
Fibromyalgia Less Fibromyalgia Less CommonCommon
Jaw Pain/TMJJaw Pain/TMJ Irritable Bowel SyndromeIrritable Bowel Syndrome HeadachesHeadaches Cognitive or Memory ImpairmentCognitive or Memory Impairment Dizziness or Impaired CoordinationDizziness or Impaired Coordination PMSPMS
Treatment for PPMPTreatment for PPMP
RestRest Heat Heat StretchingStretching Medication (elavil, Medication (elavil,
Trazadone,Ultram)Trazadone,Ultram)
Treatment for Overuse Treatment for Overuse PainPain
Modalities (Ice Heat, US)Modalities (Ice Heat, US) TENSTENS NSAIDS, Celebrex, VioxxNSAIDS, Celebrex, Vioxx Injections (trigger point, ,joint, Injections (trigger point, ,joint,
bursa)bursa) RestRest
Treatment for Biomechanical Treatment for Biomechanical PainPain
RestRest Change in PostureChange in Posture Assistive Device (cane, crutch, Assistive Device (cane, crutch,
wheelchair)wheelchair) NSAIDs, Vioxx, CelebrexNSAIDs, Vioxx, Celebrex InjectionInjection
Treatment for Treatment for FibromyalgiaFibromyalgia
Rest?/ Heat /Stretch/RelaxationRest?/ Heat /Stretch/Relaxation Medications to Improve SleepMedications to Improve Sleep SSRIs (Paxil, Effexor, Zoloft)SSRIs (Paxil, Effexor, Zoloft) Muscle Relaxants***Muscle Relaxants*** NSAIDSNSAIDS Long Lasting NarcoticsLong Lasting Narcotics
Purpose of This StudyPurpose of This Study
To Clearly Define PPMPTo Clearly Define PPMP To Differentiate PPMP from Non-To Differentiate PPMP from Non-
PPMP in Polio SurvivorsPPMP in Polio Survivors To Develop Tools to Diagnose and To Develop Tools to Diagnose and
Treat PPMPTreat PPMP
HypothesisHypothesis
There is a unique group of patients There is a unique group of patients who will meet the following criteria who will meet the following criteria for PPMP: Cramping, aching, for PPMP: Cramping, aching, fasciculating pain in their fasciculating pain in their extremitiesextremities
Their pain profile will be distinct Their pain profile will be distinct from patients without PPMP and from patients without PPMP and from non polio patientsfrom non polio patients
SubjectsSubjects
175 Polio Survivors from RWSIR175 Polio Survivors from RWSIR 94 Fibromyalgia Patients from UM94 Fibromyalgia Patients from UM 114 Rheumatoid Arthritis 114 Rheumatoid Arthritis
Patients from UMPatients from UM
MethodsMethods
Post-Polio Pain Questionnaire Post-Polio Pain Questionnaire McGill Pain QuestionnaireMcGill Pain Questionnaire MANOVA AnalysisMANOVA Analysis
ResultsResults
AgeAge SexSex Relieving FactorsRelieving Factors Exacerbating FactorsExacerbating Factors McGill Pain MANOVA AnalysisMcGill Pain MANOVA Analysis
AgeAge
GroupGroup NN MeanMean MaxMax MinMin
No No PainPain
3131 54.154.1 8282 4444
PPMPPPMP 6464 56.256.2 7878 3333
No No PPMPPPMP
8080 58.758.7 8585 4040
FMFM 9494 46.146.1 7676 3333
RARA 114114 57.857.8 8383 2525
SexSex
GroupGroup Male % Female Male % Female % %
No PainNo Pain 1616 52% 52% 1515 48%48%
PPMPPPMP2323 36% 36% 4141 64%64%
No PPMPNo PPMP 3636 45% 45% 4444 55%55%
RARA 61 61 54% 54% 5353 46%46%
FMFM 10** 11% 10** 11% 848489%89%
nificantnificant
Relieving FactorsRelieving Factors
Group Massage Brace Sleep Heat Ice Weightloss
Stretch Rest Exercise Injection
PPMP 47% 23% 47% 78% 1% 33% 36% 90% 1% 1%
NoPPMP
50% 16% 34% 58% 6% 16%* 27% 84% 6% 11%*
*significant p<.001
Exacerbating FactorsExacerbating Factors
Group Cold Rest Exercise
Weight Gain Stress Activity
PPMP68% 3% 61% 39% 53% 78%
NO PPMP 56% 10% 51% 32% 46% 78%
ResultsResults
80% Of Polio Survivors Had Pain 80% Of Polio Survivors Had Pain ComplaintsComplaints
44% Met Criteria for PPMP44% Met Criteria for PPMP Polio Survivors were Similar to Polio Survivors were Similar to
Patients with Fibromyalgia on McGill Patients with Fibromyalgia on McGill Pain QuestionnairePain Questionnaire
Polio Survivors were Different than Polio Survivors were Different than Patients with Rheumatoid ArthritisPatients with Rheumatoid Arthritis
ResultsResults
No significant differences between No significant differences between polio groups with respect to age, polio groups with respect to age, sex relieving and exacerbating sex relieving and exacerbating factorsfactors
There were significantly more There were significantly more woman with fibromyalgiawoman with fibromyalgia
ConclusionConclusion
Post-Polio Muscle Pain is Common Post-Polio Muscle Pain is Common in Polio Survivorsin Polio Survivors
Many Polio Survivors May also Many Polio Survivors May also Have FibromyalgiaHave Fibromyalgia
There is a need for Further Study There is a need for Further Study of Fibromyalgia in Polio Survivorsof Fibromyalgia in Polio Survivors
AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements
Scott Richards, PhDScott Richards, PhD Greg Petrosky, MSGreg Petrosky, MS Research Enrichment Program for Research Enrichment Program for
PhysiatristsPhysiatrists NIDDRNIDDR University of MissouriUniversity of Missouri