OX

}O

RI)

(‘I)’S

tIIEiiaiIs

JfI,

1.I

131

((((1

3,5

hrr,

jrs

InI,

usI

ship

InvestmentP

rotectionI

,,‘rl5,5

1,3

‘‘3’

5,,5

,I’,

3sS

flS

.3.3

kl.l...S

‘.r1r..rr

A1’(.;L

s1klç

i‘(

li

,.,

..

,,;l

3,,j,j

I,:.

i’,,r

arrIs

r,,,rj’’.rI,

II

‘ss1

551

II

ISN

,,

ss,L

k,m

,ti,

_,)rlh

5,5

531sf113

uris,,rIs,,

istr

55

%‘515<1

‘‘155

)5Is(lsas

‘I,

,l.

,sst

‘(11)1)10

<I)ssni,

II,fl’

IIII

1(5«SI

OI’SI

,,,jhs

I,)I’

515(515:5

SS

551535t1

5,5

5I11

,,{)n

I,,,dI

ss5

51

,53

5155

“‘

3.,:‘

‘‘3SI,

‘‘I,

.51555155,1

5lt[’F

’StiS

ttrtI.

.1I

55(55’51

1Il’

.1I

3,.,.,

‘IlV

Il5

3,

5..

•,,,

r,,r,,I353(3

st,:,

.1,,,,),

,I,,,,1

1r1’ls

s)srlJ

lc

SI,

5,3‘‘,

./,5

1,’

’,

i5S

)lsI55,s

,’lI.S

’IIl.5

rS

l5hS

jllttlS’fl

‘5

_,C

h(t,5

iIl

i<rtrss!)cj’airr,ssrtt

.5,5

5,55.5

5.3

55

51

‘515,153,3

.5,

‘(51

.1115’

53551

flS’’’l’’5

.555.

.155)51513

I

I”,

13

.3,,,

),,,sI‘ss1’,s,I’,sI,Irr,l,,,rsI)ll,,

I15

15«5151,11

5,3,

I,

I3,31,

‘)

IS‘531115

5(55555

1)51,I

sI,I,Is

‘35

511

SStsr

,i’

3,1I

sinn,,

ItslsaI

51,

In1

,1,3

1

1355115It

I,‘sIs

N,,IIk

Si,’

5,

,5”,

‘—

[)r’k‘‘‘Is,

,.

I1

k

OX

FO

RD

UN

1V

1’R

S1

IY

PI{

Æ’s

-7/

FullProtection

andSecuritv

(;iu

1/z

rtl

(O

ï(/CO

ÅIoy.

A.

I flt[Odtk

tiOfl

Ihiseliapter

svillanalyse

receittIn

vestn

en

iarhiirat

Inn

ne

inin

pn

iif

i

standard

niin

vestm

ent

proie( tinnInnoss

nds

ullprnten

i innand

st

iiiit

nattem

ptof

identihing

apossible

enteigingn n

nsn

sus

onus

sogn

ofappiiatinn

andinterpretarion.

Ibestandard

ofbul

rteIn

nnd

senurit

isles’

iletlu

ent h

appied

ihanother

st-andacds.henee

arbitratuntipraetice

nnnt

nnimnn

andihe

inudI ii.erai

Lure

israrher

seare.’Iratlitionaliv.

ireiiin

vs

an

undis

pute

dsn

np

uni

applinat

sinin

ihif

nini

phvsicalproleetion

nithe

asnetsaud

induniduals

nontuented

with

aninnen

mcnt

as

WlIl

beseen

iflseetton

I).lIie

protenriunhat

tittlegal

ssstcin

auids

inin

preventni

proseeutean

iionstinn

hunaten

iurlm

pd

irtbe

pbysinal

saletni

i

investmnnt

ianbe

naunsideredds

anex

tetislonsuf

ifinust

ment tonn

djunsnal

seettrulv:both

thepoluce

hares

.undilie

tidkualnu

aduistinsurannn

in’

niin

innit.u

tecan

hengaged

insen

uru

ligdi

phestnalsantu

ni

ato

rstu

ti.:iu

rS

iil

.1.

as

ssiii

hseen

nsen

tunn

1..?\tore

reennuly,

thestandard

hanheen

invoktditi

on

inti

toll

SS

IIha

nnad

i

seopethatg

es

bevondihn

phvsut.alproten

tn

ingiam

edh

pOIR

enr

inn[arlot

ien

anw

ellan

titt.isaulabilit

nitlw

j udutm

ls

sk

inn

,arni

uxpandsIla

nininahst

tdtt

kmd

utntn

turutu.‘i

henchn

socurniii

an

uneis

im

en

t‘s

iiiut

inuendeni

as

[insi

dsaie

tliii

is

scearlisihe

.ppinJuuluni

tittf1

liu

utn

tinntid

utti

sL

tt.d.iiC

‘\d

’

us

tradittonalsnpn

ofapplicatlon.

[inn,ingal

sn

nliiIt\

uasat

tinin’in

ni

nk

din

sanntinn

Iti;ulaiors.n

iionsnr

niherbc

hantonn

ihathan

vlnldtnd

i[in

Ini

ilti

iinn

i]t

•,,.

...,.‘,:S

fl.

fl

iii

i..

,.,

-

Iinn

i...

dIs

in’

i-.‘

‘ss

.0

....

-,

NI

i\1

),1,

.:“

‘ou,.‘

)s’,r

.i

‘-

/i

Nu

ias.it

onalesum

uiti

oin

sfor

iI

pr

.1I

ii

i

Iii

/O

(ti

111)11i/I

ii’i

UP

I!/3.

I/iiSou

i’e

I

ssht

hI

1tn

sst

mot

ssis

undettakei

01

liasaffeeted

thestability

ofihe

l(,tItt,tttts

sso

tklot

litelts

tStiiie

tti,d

sssill

ltuJtl1lyse(l

III%

CC

tiotl

I\pand

titlss

s&

tpe

ot

ullplotve

11011aud

secutto

thisL

i ndof

legalpro

:01

ind

Istlss

staitdVud

strtLtngl

sunihuo

atother

well-know

nand

more

sG

eSptl’adsi,

iI m

lot

piotse11011

ihatut

airaude1uita

hle

Irratment.

Recent

Viii

10

1Id(

iCv

lt.ote

tonii

dih

isaspee

taud

uhas

attim

eseonsidercd

.1LIV

v:Iin

sC

euritI

Jsh5o

ibed

livL

iviair

audequitahle

treatment,

vn

-Ihus.

tilelilatlis

IjtlU

StI

OIid

[)

1Cto

ssiia

iextent

titestan

di

lV

IIIIV

hu

ll.II1

dsuu.ttrtt

sta

sa

nean

tgihat

guuesevond

rhetrad—

Vi::

;iiissi

Ji:iIitc

hu

naud

vetnot

osen,

ppu

with

otherstandards

of

1ilt

t.Lt

iItjiis

sonicitiles

Jcbat1U

iii,

hitta1

p1iL

IL

e,

althoughnot

i.j

uti

VpL

’I

ii

att

audeljuttable

Iie

atH

eO

l,ts

whether

thestandard

i’,u

:tidegn

11111ut

statt,latdIII

(tiS

tOtild

tilu

en

tattotial

idV

uor

ratherhas

tobe

iuitrpt

dtitide

itiL

iru

mstane

esaud

be

applivabieireatv.

Seetion(V

will

aia-inptto

identI

,iuseluelgtug

tendenetesin

atbittationprau

ieeas

tothe

vo

nsi.

(ta

es,

il.ttis

ofousdeting

fullproteetioli

ad

sce

ut

ityas

astandard

ofeu

stO

n.I

Sitis

stnatt

mal

lass01

,tsa

standatel basedon

theapplicable

treaty.lii

isq

usibo

hasu

et

i.u

ssto

ns

on

i hek

udot

obligationstltat

tisestandard

itt.1ls:seettou

Isstil

i.ttiiu

ctrbutariou

iraLIL

:s

positionas

tosh

ether

itis

anss

il‘t

kl

itilutjitsLO

,uii

ihlii.ationltased

onthe

exerelseufdiligenve.

.0.1

1.

Iniii.

I.utk

asi..

ssi,e

tler

illedili’eiis

eespes

tedis

asuheetive

standardI

iIL-IL

Lh

sta

lL

es

ol,

ratite

i.att

ohieelive

Vtandald.

us

latterdistinetion

tids

.uIu

oId

critlhil

illes.u

up

CO

l.u

pp

rcu

.iatiu

ufl

ihat,i

Statelias

inthe

exerciseofits

sis

eiL

lut]

pIC

IOL

,htS

es.

.isssil

beseen

inS

IC[1

uIIi

I

B.

liteS

ources

liti.Iii.

iungt

ittiissm

dihat

hasedealt

ssnuta

questionol

fullprotectlon

ttil

stssutus

ssbass

don

akw

itiscstment

tretites,

listedbelow

andg

ro

up

ed

leutdu

uoIii.

soti.ltogss

ititsslttch

thep0

icett

mstandaid

isexpressed.

As

tisees

shss

Iss1so

dit

iiissltftlt

illesiatid.

idoffull

plo

teerio

naud

secu

r

Ii-

5’

i.S

S(d

i.0

.01.

botliiii

lespei.I

ot

beI

ruiulationuselfand

iniespevt

ItL

Sl

1Viii

hu

llliii

ittttl.itliv

in

iullro

tee

tiotiand

seu.urirs.

flis

i.IV

SI

olis

talli

P°

hio

llO

lIfl1

Ilpioteettoll

audsevtlnirv’

‘V

II

.uol

tili.u.!

s

•1,

leS

iIt

1-L

Ji

scr1

po

siluitttie

[usstandard

no1c

bei

iin5

Isi

i,s

i.alt

.isidtiti

toIlle

ottltgitionu

taceord—

dlik

iV

Ihull

urto

iii.o

ilig

atv

iiti

ahsiaiuiiigrom

arbiirarv0V

-I

flitatt

il

oil

•O

tti

nuasV

tC

Jl

asp

ihu.aiionof

iheitrier

obli&

Vil

i‘o

nts

ihti

litesta

usi .11(1

5so

tiet

10115m

entionedalon

so

metim

es

inaddition

torhe

rcq

uir

em

vm

s[tv

inte

rnatio

nal

lass, or,is

spetfted[w

internationallaw

.

Overv

iewof

the

Differen

tF

orm

ulatio

ns

‘[bepreeise

formularions

1)1full

proteetiontils

iseettiit

ehiusesin

hil.ttetaltusest

ment

treanies(B

il’s)dith

rm

arked

l.ilos

shaptervill

providea

bnietm

elass

ofd

ilErent

kindso

ffuli

proteetionaud

seu.uritvelauses

togeihers

itliIII

tusik

atitu

ofinvestm

enteases

insvitieh

thevhave

beenins

oLed.

Aitum

berof

BIT

sprovide

thatu

tV

estm

entsshall

bedu.

i,ordedlatt

audesu

it—

ahierreatm

entm

dshaii

enjovfull

pro

ietion

audses

uros.

Suu.Is.t

lot

Inu

lationein

befound

litA

rtiele2t21(ii

(ieu.h

Repiibhu.uSlos

akR

eptib

aBl

1HA

rtiele2(2)

United

Kingdontil’

g>pt

BI1.1

udA

rticieli

2gbi.‘nited

Kngdoiti

SniL

ankaB

l’lA

fewB

ITs

providethat

investments

shallenjov

fulllegal

EO

ii.i.1100

,uidfull

legalseettnity

likeA

rticle4(1)

(Jermanv/A

rgentinaB

li,V

,

BIT

provisionsthat

investments

shallbe

aseordedfait

ane!equtiable

iteattiientaud

shalinot

beim

pairedby

unreasonableor

diseniminatoty

rneasures.1

ssl, more

particularly,that

theyshali

beaveotded

fullproteulon

,ttislse

uritru.an

belound

inA

rticie3.1

andA

rtiele3.2

ofthe

Netherlands!(

ieehaud

SlosiL

Repuhlic

BI’1’6

isveli

isA

rtiele3.1

andA

rtide3.2

Nctiterlands,Poland

Bli

An

ex-ample

ofaB

ITproviding

thattn

vestn

len

tssltall

beaeu.orded

twl

piotec—tion

andseeunitv

inaceordanu_e

with

thepnineiple

ol

hunand

equitabletre

atlite

nt

einbe

seenin

Artiele

5. II:rinee/A

rgeniinaB

il’!1

Bli’s

providingthat

investments

shallbe

aeeordedfull

proieetiouaud

seCtHus

iii aCC

CrdanvC

with

international1.1w

anelound

in[‘5

praeticesueh

is

,-\rt,Je

(1

United

States/M

exieoB

1’i’.9

liteire

aly

heisveinthu

(‘/es

h,tnd

iheSiosak

Ri.’ptthli1

11151’t,tilL

11110liii

-11

\‘V1S

li

(‘eskoslovenskaobi-hodm

haukai/.

((508,)

v.S/ova/

Ru-ptib/zc,11.-SII)

(.ise

Nu

.\Ri)

Sss4

20t)esem

bei(>

04V

ihet nibuual

fouttdth

at

tittpar

ti’sbad

lIKotporated

1111110lik

libli.

Sibli

-

iherefonein

rsspesiof

r1wappliu.auon

utihe

siatidtuduf

tolll1

i1r

uon,ud

si’s0

11

ili

tidrefers

iiiihew

oidingo

ftim

etre

atv

,pnas62

ii

tqm

dlo

tet

q.

11wsso

rd1:

n’t

Ir4

IsI

1111115

taketufro

rn

rheA

ward

pana.6

i.O

enaH

ot1

/sItnIttd

i-1-ab

Repuhltca//gij&

,Il

Slitt

,usi’

NI.

5k

1.6)5O

siii

SI)

20011.A,i

1iz

,‘1ir,bL&

tfluI!

I(/m

i,/

0/

•.i,liI-

Il,fii0

0il

St

I-

11.S

Ii,

i-

SIS

t’s

Aw

ard,2”

1mw

iflflO.

,Slu.m’n

4,.

iIiu

i-l1i)eu

Ittnu

Ru,1

L/n

h,.

il.til

liii,

Nuir\k

bul,

5iss,u

id(V

LV(.IE

R-n/u/

li’i

-16,

V,ti

eL/IL

:I

.,,

‘R

,‘:i

i1,1

bO

Si’..1

IS

V-IL

VilIb

Juni

,uid,Salii

&si

IflIi’,IllIu’li

i,I

-li’s

.Vziss;,,’

-‘V

’;

LV

,,-‘.

.50.0

:‘

200o-

biiii’kiih.’i

-i

RI7V

UL

/0/

i’JiY&

dP

iitti.5

va:ii,

i-\ut’,s

t2uu’

(‘ofrIp

a;n

a515

du!V

’lVV

O/L/iIl7a

5il

iv/ti

1111fl

iiti

5-i

-I,V

:1

.V

I‘V

[(‘Slit

1.ase

Nu.

AR

BiQ

”!.i.A

wa

nd,20

AItg

is-

(til

I/’’nicas!tfsrlzoam

bie,:ti/i-,

1550105.

4I

OiL

/V1

lItI

liiit/

SitS

IVI

StI

l/V11

SJj)

IN

u.A

RB

AF

)/00/2

,A

ward,

20M

m’

21>0

i:.

SitlO

:

V-

ut

Io

n/L

ut

I’,,

./;j

B.ho

ouie

hiI

nkl

015’

II,IIlItt

[1k

lii5

sh,iIIlIt

Rt

OtIk

iIJ

11JU

LI

eqU

itJble

treatIL

,0.

.1\

liiipoR

t11011

.01

11

‘et

1/lit’

.1011511.111

IIIIII>

CJS

Cb

eautorded

ihan

ihu

tqulIc

d1)5

imt

111.11

(linil

.11Vall,

for

ista

uce,

\rtkle

111k

LIN

ao(

ie

liR

puhiaBI

IA

nitL

Il.

2()

mw

dStates!

i’,,I

\iiijtli

.,

111ktjt’s

iu,id

oi

tII,

Artile

litita

i111

t1

1,it

Roiiitn

i,,hI

Ititie

iI)

11111dN

tats

i1urL

c1Ii,l)

Or

\itiL11

iIIIII

dItt

/aiie

hIl.

lrt.iii

1iietitbliip.(

Illu

erte

antt

Nas

lgatu

inpriavldilig

.0ot

1;:l1

NIji,iL

I1\L

ilwIm

otIdiit

pioteetiotiaud

secutilvfir

their

pezoO

sInti

roptnls.aud

sliillcnos

intliis

tIspIll

tiiefull

pio

teuten

andsecu

rr

‘•ilit

iia

uio

ai

last\i

i.\

r01

IIIVIIU

.IILbetw

eenthe

nited‘k

ii.i

1 niporta

iwc

ott lii.

[orillu

latIW

is

Ss

KL

11110

Sta

lliaid

otfull

pltlw

tlion

andct

1101515

cxptcssedin

avarier>

otiurm

uLu

1011n

tlwL

iltilitU

tifl\C

’110(1

11

fIat

(5.

[hus,il

no

tildbe

teasoiiab

leto

ii!l.1

1I

1111111)1

1\O

ldH

i0ot

the1

11

.11

k’

ivadsto

ditlerentinterpretatiotls

ih

i mdi

idi!

tOtil

irivat

toIla

itho10

isi

ipbi.t

weeu

fullp

ro

tettio

naud

1111115n

itil

t1)11

hiiiti.aud

ini

audI’q

IILtJ

leIR

atmeu

ton

rheother

hand,at

Ilo

.llilis

lipIt

unel

I lii.lre

.ih.ised

obligationatlI

tliestandard

oflitt

iltilti

Los,1

att’

.L

I,iII)II1

.ItlOIi

[1Jt

11I

ilOet

not

seem

toanaeb

asigniti

(aril

itpi

Ik

iith

ssoid

iiigcl

tIka

iplit ,ihltIreatY

intIie

trnerp

retatiofl

of

1111R

itfl

I.1

.oalil

ii’

11111p1ttetloIl

.itidte

tul

11V.

Iiii.

svordin

gof

thetreat

(ilO

illi.

Nt

illlil

[11)11)1tit

1111’tri[itin

.ilre,is

otiitig

,bot

itdoesnot

seeluto

plavIL

itt151K

111I

IilIIII

1151111‘ni

Ilii.

st(Idii

1Ili.

IIu

.iIV

eL

’l1i

Il)Itit

Cpiaed

Jil

i’‘

0115

0.

1111.1

10

‘\ts

lit.1151

spp

IiabL

tteat\

desiates

trom

li11

1IL

ili

10

1ti

tIlIli

1111111111I

illit

Vil)

tint

ilS

ptJ

LS

of‘legal

I.‘

IIt

‘sotdi

III.i

i la’t r.’.ii

i511

iii)to

protidea

eltarhasts

for

1(1:1

.old

ui.u

[iI

11,1

I,s

si.J

tltil)

dii.tle

Jt

god

hi.v0tid

niI

1i

iIL

l0iL

t111)11

Ilki

(Iti

5LIk

1115eS

tnit

lituiviroltm

entaud

i1i

itti

iI),i»lLI

ci

thi

is,a

ing

.Ila’

issardev

eliquestio

iistila

tliii.

511

iI

Ll)

lli

Ini 211(1

I.(

‘I(

N.kR15

1112.

‘\sv,iid,li

iilt21100.

.0‘‘

‘ni.

II’.

UssIli,

i (1k

(Jo

1V

iI

kl(I

Ssud

I(1

tobtr2

i0i

ni

i’

Sol’n

I!s

,f.ii/.s,f

ltd

IZ

V’Jf

‘.

1/

.11

1II

5111

io

‘V

traditio

nal

ph

vsa’al

securitv

isco

vcred

.1

I Ioweset.

tlietrih

ittiald

oes

not

oisid

erihe

formulat

enofthe

standardat

dett’riiitii,.ntm

dcotnes

11)I

til’14)111

lUsi

fl111,11

ibevery

defitutionofititestniem

tnadein

ila’trt’aty..ts

Ititluditig

alsoin

taug

hles,

speak

shar

tilegal

prolettionrath

ertltan

fol

.tph5

sii.aIptotetlloll)

tki

far

liii.!e),in

’nJ

trihunal

seen

isto

haverem

atnedJlO

llIn

i.oitsid

eritip

111.11Ihi.LII

ti11

il0

0iO

iiivestm

em

determint

5h

it.S

tope0!

ipplaai1011

if

Ille1)1)1

Igal

011

ol11111

l0

teet

jon

audsetu

rity

,even

ifnio

st

tle.&

tiCs

eaintn

edliert’III

havea

diIII

1110110!

invesIrnenttbat

dire

i.tIvor

itidir

ettlv

ini.1

tid1

stn

tiittib

k’

5.Ilie

lsiemi’ns

tnih

un

al,lu

rth

er,

do

esnot

.ittai.h[0

1110

ular11)11)1)1

1JU

lInI

tiii.w

ord

ng

of

thctreaty

when

iti.o

nsid

ersihe

stind

aid

sof

legalp

loletIlo

nat

ilkgal

securttv

and

of[air

JULI

equ

itahle

tteal

ment.

resp

ect

ivels

,d

s(4111

sitiglest

despiteIlle

t’acttInnthe

treaty[lsts

iliema

to

sep

arate5tan

datd

s.’A

.Iso,iheA

zurix

2°aud

tbeO

ilidentabIaxards

otisid

er11)1111 l}

dit

obllg

allo

n

rek

alin

gto

[airaudel

1utta

hle

treatnien

tan

dto

t’tillprotel

troll

.11111‘(‘1

mils

ut

sptteof

thei ircum

stani.ethat

thetesp

ei.tlse

tt’etltlesIii

tlietli

a’

isso

ss’pdt

dii.

obligations.‘I be

Azurix

award

openly’reeo

gnh

/i’sthat

tlietw

ostand,ttds

pp

t.irin

tbe

treatsas

separate

ob

itgatio

ns.

butpro

1eeds

ne\e

rtllele

ss

ti)appli

ihetri.15

Ifth

evtvere

.1tititt

t.

Anoihei

example

of

an

award

tbat(lot’s

1)1)1seeiti

toattai.h

Spii.Ila

iniponianee

tohe

wording

olthe

lteatv

isthi.

deetsionreletitir

renderedIII

ti ild!li.

liii.trihtiit,tliiolds

that

thesta

nda

rdci

i’tilIl

i[1e

1111)11

.11111ti,’

tilItt

exte

nds

hey

on

dthe

pro

tei.

tjon

Iromphy

sii.ali tite

rliren

li..

IbesL

ittingix

1111for

rhisreasoning

isthe

wotding

ol

Illetre

ats,

whiili

dtos1)01

iflefll

11)1)Illt

itordi‘phystcal

tuterfereticeii.1

thusdoes

not

restii1t

ihe

SIid

oi

1111’O

hIlg

al

cli

ti)prote

uto

nfram

plly

siealin

teri’e

renee.

2’2‘liii

tribun

altheti

reh’rsV

XL

etisi5

l’lto

arbitraljurisprudence

insu

pp

ort

of

itsopinion

onIlie

eVlended

scc[,cl

ha

1’p

rote

etm

on

,V

I11111)111

co

lnm

entin

go

ntb

el.1

’Itli.tt

1111’urisprudeia

i.Ietu

redto

inhats

connet.tiouis

based

on

treatie

sth

aipiesen

ttis1triet}

ot

fotin

nla

tto

ll’s:

pro

teetjO

nJ5

.1sp

ecific

atio

no

ftaii

audqtn

tablei real

11Ic

’lit,1

fullplott’t

11011at

.1sep

aratesta

ndard

,24

audfull

pro

teetio

nat

asep

aratesta

ndard

.11)11re

tt’riIIti.

li)publie

inte

rnatio

nal

iats’It

tnayt h

us

be

toneludedt hat

JIbnial

praltae

does111)1

dt’em

IIxssoud

ing

of

ihetreatS

atdecisis

efor

tbe51

0V

of

applii..itjonol

lItesta

ndatd

utm

li

i’dl1(11

ii’n.i,

,ihosI

i.‘

p.i sa.

Sc

i.°

IhollO

rd..50-i,

.1(1’)I1ft1

’iXu

içefl/sn

d,

,iI,sw

t’li.

IIp.s

li.4

18i.),,d

e,n.il

il1

,’li,IåaI’,

.4111)51’i.

12.1111.4

5i

115)11/1i’.‘liY

s’uhln.l..1115)11’

Il.5

p.ir.s

“i

IV

Netltr1ands/(

21111R

cpuhI1511

.isol‘V

1101

I1.1Ild”Ici

11111Ol

21(‘het

0R

epublit/SlcvakR1’puhlis.

111I

,ilid1

liltIdIs

ullg

d,illi

l’

pi

liiI

“I.!nited

kta

ti.sclA

rnersi.al’k[C

flt115.1

BIL

511111S

nstt’

s,I‘5

I1II51.5

I’,snill,

15.I

us

i1

i,,’i.Li

NI

til’scl’

kn

ss,’ric,s/Italv011

ifl

,.

/‘L

,i

lonu

‘frilt

[kIsfil’.

111!! I>ie

no

etiii”

e:ir,i

(.In

tern

aIlO

,Ia/

Sldni/arlIii’

)tu

kl!

aud

iiiiv

1k)!

c\

ettsV

ileil

divC

IIIV

SISut

Ute

qu

estio

nstarts

tromIik

tOtIU

JICit

uit

utthe

tiejts.

(.In

ternatio

nal

Standard

pro

tevtio

n.

2ihe

trihunaleom

tnues

notiiiig

.ltu)SSe\ ei.

liiai

iiis

not

nin

iov

iCil

significanecw

hetberinternational

[assis

illinornr

aveiling,

hvuC

nis

tlasa

nd

idof

internationallaw

evolves,and

ihecunte

not

beobligations

isibstaiiiualis

similar

whether

interpretedaveording

toihe

ord

inat

meaning

nithc

ireauys

wording

oraccording

tothe

standardnnder

interliauionCiIlass,

\ttiui.uIIss.t

dCufltCtjliiCS

dis

US

S55

tetlietthe

standardot

tullp

ro

teerio

nis

an

;;hepr

ndeiIsttid

oJ

toh

ided

onh

bast,sut

tbcapplivable

rreatyand

oftheian

nistauucis

olla

casenr

whet ber

v ustottars

internationalIaw

playsa

roletn

deteimtitint;

ussontent

svenCulioss

rheappi

edtueat ies

li iveariet

vol

fot tnularionsregarding

ute

teLituuid

ii1u

betsseetitlte1urotes

tinnac

orutedlw

iltetrearv

andrhe

stand

iln

ipiote.

tinn

e\isuiitgunder

geilelalinternational

law.

lidoes

notseem

ihatitu

ese

ninuttlut

tons

at

vgisett

ades

usuvem

lvin

arhirrattonpraetice.

Inanv

vise.

iiiat hu

iat innprac

1kV

tbeva

rietsol

a pprnavbestaken

doesnot

seemto

hasc

subsuuiuu

iiionsc

qnenuesin

tespusi

nitbe

v oncreteapplication

ofthe

standard.Iluca

.tietb

iviiie

ote

tidl

apptt.teltesru

uhequestion:

tbatibe

standaidot

ustu

nu

arv

iie

rnat

ktid

lussreptesenis

illesviling

turthe

obligationseontained

iiiiLe

tiens,

tbauit

repieselitsdiv

tlnut,nrtlu.tt

itis

equtvalcnt.

Intern

ational

Iaw

asa

Ccilin

g

Ibe

sttnda

aini

nuiern.ttioitjllass

issven

asa

veilittgin

theinrerpretative

noteusstied

to.i

tideItSu

liut

ilte\A

1’l\

bythe

FreeIrade

Com

mis

sio

nin

2001:ibe

notesiaw

sihat

tbeobligation

toprovids

htllsevurity

andproreution

inthe

si

I\

dncs

notreciutte

iI reatm

entin

asdition

toor

heyondthat

whieh

isre

ciu

tiecib

ilaustntn,irv

tnternatinnallaw

min

itnu

instandard

ofrreatment

otti

iens

‘lit

inier1uretatinn

liasheen

deemed

tobe

bindingby

tribunalsapplying

tlivN

;\iI

[titt0

isnot

nceessarilvrelevant

inother

disp

utes.

28

internationalL

awas

aF

loer

Is1

il’uinI

iniv

inis

iviroent,

iii,tppls

ina

trett vtbat

requiresa

treatment

toles

tasi

ttbl

thattditt

tegniredby

inteinationallaw

.aiE

rms

rhatthe

nd.uni

IIn

tetil

tiiO

it.t ilissis

tobe

understood

dsti

tloor

forrhe

treaty—based

iI

urI

(on

insunt

ion

J uuls0O

I(us

tulihirti hrip:?/w

ww

dfaur.muesi.gvcII

i:i

“s\

lii

ip

uin

0,

s.i

ni:

iI:O

isiitu

.\.i i0

Il)

toher

00

pa

ruI0

I’,!1

J1,’tI’C

ui

Il.5,

,tiliiins

iiii)!).

Ot

dt.ti

iii’liii

15

0t)ttO

flo

lihe

NA

FI

Ait,

s:c

udrii

laiu

krp

is1ttIitfl

ni

Ow

sr.tuudard

undero

ther

ireatle

s.ee

alsoI

iI.’

)IT.t

InternationalI.aw

asE

quivalent

‘Ihetrihunal

ofA

API.

ti,S

’riIenke,

applying,t

treaty

tbtt

dncs

tiotnientiuun

tberelarionship

bctween

thestandard

ofintetnattonal

laand

treatsproies

tinn,affirm

edthat

thetreatv-hased

proteuttuutiis

tbsam

eprotevtiun

alinudssi

underinternational

lutw,audw

ouldbe

applieableesen

iiidiv

ahsettueiii

isp

eta

sLiuse

inthe

treats.ih

etribunal

analvsesthe

wording

otlite

treatand

aifirms

tliatthe

wording

fil

proteetionpussibly

suggestsi

itigberdegree

niresp

itsiiuilutthan

thecttstom

arvstandard,

itN

evertiteless,the

trihutnalends

upC

il5ing

thvm

inimum

statidardof

vustomary

internationallaw

,Ihe

trihunalin

AM

liZ

airc,applving

siriestivtbat

eunsidetsilite

ilitilu

nuas

aFloor

forrhe

treatvproteetion.

assum

esIbut

litetteu

obligitinnhas

inbe

vonsistentw

iththe

minim

umrequired

byinternational

Iasv.ii

Also,

ehetribunal

inN

obleV

enture.’i’

Rom

a,i,a,applving

atreaty

ditt

provides

fortreatm

entno

lessfavourable

thanrequtred

byit

attnational

iass,alit

ms

thatit

isdoubtful

wherher

thetreaty

obligationis

largerthan

litegenviil

duuyto

providefor

fullprotection

andseu

riivin

eusiu

ntar

iilteFnttiofl.ili.u

ss.lite

arbitraltribunal

renderedits

decisioitin

respeu

tni

iltesiolattnn

utibe

inI

tectionaud

securitystandard

exclusivelvbs

reierenveto

thel(

Is

desisiotu

inE

LSI

andcom

paringthe

setof

hiutsin

tbetw

ovases,

altbougbtlie

aoudiiugin

rheapplicable

BIIs

was

quitedilferent

—respevtiveh,

fullP

rotevttoitand

syvur—

ityand

noless

than

internationallaw

’in

thetreaty

hetwc’en

tbeI

nutedN

tatesand

Rom

ania,aud

them

ost

co

nsta

nt

prote

elio

ttan

lsu

eurii

md

tbeiull

pin—teution

audseeurirv

requiredby

internationaliass

iiitbe

tie.itht

5seilt

Unired

States

audItaly.

Even

Ifnotin

thecontext

ofa

treatyon

investtnentp

rntec

tinn,iut,

Iti‘otunm

itribunal

recentlyvonfirm

edtlw

generalattiltale

ttkenliv

arbitiitunn

ptistitt

accordingto

wbich

liteappli.ation

nithc

standardunder

intertiatitutuallass

ssnuldnot

addrnuch

tothe

proteutionaccorded

bylIte

.tpplisablu

rett’

..

.‘A

.oartsv

‘1uuruu.una,ab)

st’n

1pa

ut0

Iu

bud.para

s6’i

nueq.

A.41’I

vSu,

len/ca,.thost’

n.i

pris

tOS

i..‘

Ibid.,p1as

(i(0).

u4

ti‘li

Zaurc. above

n.iS.paras

k.IU

,.ut...

‘‘

“jo//i’I‘‘,i1ur,’,,

i’Rom

ania.abovt

i.I

5.i’a

uI(,i.

°Ib

(l’iuin

e/l’u,inu’/

(rou4fi

gfrutit)cl./t,iu

,(i

I,‘

:1I

iu

ll/

A;s

:’n

iin

:.,

oJl’u’atice(Furuutn,i,u

I),P

artni

Aw

aid..11)I aiutua

rs(1

‘p,ti.’‘i

Iu/

I;tnt:in

im

o1).

!!‘1

’itii/

i/i[i

1).P

hysical

a1cty

Ila(iIo

l00

10

çI1

SU

Rull

piuruon

andsi

ni

us

Lo

inundisputed

sipe

0500

siiii

piusual

atrI

nipersotisand

insiallationsIii

til

issi

ulL

Ei

.ispi

beassord

rciuderedin

ubed.

,uun

an•h

Iianon

ropreserve

iheptibhe

:Ue1

ut

UL

l1

urouS

us0!

polaaud

puhli

puwers,Js

repeatediv

undeiil

urit

ini la

Inu

uutu

nui/

\ssatd.li

nuudjs

1>u

ted

scopeot

opp!ation

e1r

iis

iniiolI

11)i

15ilst

IIiia

sipits

tialsuoienee

as

arn

icd

inthe

i as

ud

(aiisa

iit

iisi0115

stil

1LI

100e

Icutu

st

ssIn

nhe

ploeLl

on

isduceted

mav

beau

ed

bylu

leI.i

ti

li

o.u

notite

ris

ise

1w.ittrilutalule

toi be

Store,nr

m.iv

becaused

toilinu

pdrtu

i5

.

hentli

piussi

ild

.nu

uap

eis

dncto

i hiri

partle

s,

ildoes

notseem

rhatarb

iiro

tin

npu

ii

iu

pliri

s0

Oi

tauhir

connecjo

nol

causa

liryto

ccn.sidcithe

Store

IuuhIhus

ihi/

ntn

lan,u

/i

ubunalalhi nu

withotit

fnrrherado,

thatdisorder

isii

i ruulutd

iii

uiIt

ati

°ihe

tiibuni

utna

i’E

vjt

sirnplynot ices

thatthe

ni

iO

liol

ihih.

nilul.ituotis

takt.

,l0ainstIlle

inv

esto

r.”

iru[u

iitaliii

/um

sd

i.110501)

siiI

li51(1

,i51i1

iW.1

iCrtillil

cO

lliiectiO

Ii

Ol

,iU.iii

teiS

siL

litlte

iuarnuuilis

ufils

III!tlue

Stites

hla

sin

ur.

inthat

itiists

itIt

t lieaut

torras

ii

noten

iita

eo

supportthe

adverseinovem

entsas

ouau

tila

tiaso

ns

lot

not

orls1

dcrIn

Vis

leS

tatelj

0hic

intisat

oflfle

Ct1

Oi1

.°

Iliss

ruur

i ruhuni I

niuglil

IIivem

ci i1io

idthe

absericeofru

isei

lium

sta

flce

us

iresp

on

si

to

ihrelaum

anialiegation

i hatthe

Storebad

playedthor

role.ilini e.

uts

tiki

tar

inthr

issaidis

not

nressarilv

anargum

entfor

alhrming

theL

nle

iliii

la.IU

I horut lesene

nur,teniC

ntIs

arrerequislte

forthe

State’s

iti

lu

re\.u

Ur

ni

0Iii

oiis.lite

nto

lee\piaiiued

inlighi

otihe

obligationi

tisin

idird

nitoll

protertiti

andsesu

ritv

:the

obligationis

noti,

iII

lii10111

utsu

iigdaunagi

botti

eeiise

duediligcncc,

nr

takeihe

necesat

iiU

r05111

isut

uVula nri,

inorder

nupies

ein

damage.

1hus,lite

obligationrnay

loisdiii

itu

rS

pi

siis

ini

ilaou

ugnuni

ihedanuage.

Whenever

itfalis

within

tite

giliL

tUl

Ito

Iliot

nuin

utulirfirinri, 1junito

rioso

isa

breah

ofiheobliga

in

uI ull11511C

r111111

nsl

ser nii,

‘5/

i’,,‘,

‘I’sI

Ii’.iL

i..0’’

Oss.

jUS

liiiI1S

:0,

I‘

0.:01

ti’

ii.

p.ira.i.

In‘n

i,’

,i,

.uhs

iI

i0

‘ili

s051’

itsos

uuip

uuu$)

Form

sofB

ehaviour

Iherhreshoid

iiironsidering

thestandaud

055

lolatrulis

itilsii

luughslik

t05

stiiibe

seenbelow

,Ille

obligitionto

provideiull

pro

tes

11(111in

isrin

int

isus

hathril

ifrhe

Storehos

taken

some

measlir

es

ni

sigiiita

iihat

Jotu

ni

sem

utu

rruso’Iable

md

thernom

forsovereig

n.uppIeeiatlon

usuluuite

ssde.

Ihus.tribunals

tendto

OeriI)i

ritem

asut

istakt

tibs

beS

tate

sus

ssllii

liii

to

meet

iheobhgation.

As

ssiiibe

seeluheiosi

tiis

ihela

kot

me,is

iure

sti

to’.

cmharm

tuieseuts,

thelaek

nim

eastirestO

101

01.

Illesutuatiun

plin

tto

Illetiauflutrui

event,or

rhelaek

olim

posutinnni

sani tionsi hat

ieadto

asunlatinn

nudir

staudord,

asin

thel’hna

aard

.Il

measures

havrbren

taken,thr

thiesluoldlot

riuis

tioningihem

seems

tobe

quiielngh

‘Ihi/

uio

tun

nu

’/assord,ss

ssiIlbe

sresh

loss,assum

esthat

them

easurestalen

ma

seetiesi tonen

rilvti

ibus

h,uviauused

intolerableeonsequenees.

Anotab

ieex

cep

tion

tothe

triburtalsgeneral

Iluellilarlon1

1)1

toju

st

sitt

tbequalitv

ottiw

measu

restaL

enis

thein

aoiiv

iiiil1’1

r.SI.a

,in/.

\sss

iiibe

seell.

however,

tIispart

niihe

award

svisnriiiiie

dby

titeif

lhiliiu

irni

liiiuiis

unai

l)ur

ål/Igene

Arhitral

i ribunolsolten

diseussiL

’quesu

innil

liiiita

ture

<ilube

oblugti

ois

itusing

ou

rof

thnstandard

olfull

proteetionm

dser

itt’iis.lite

ihatIpu

is,iihu

1’sin

tude,

asssiii

beseen

beloss,is

i hatthe

siandard

reujud

es

iS

otato

XC

i sii

tur

dih

genee

donto

ensure

the

safe

tvol

ilieu

tvis

ttH

eO

ls.

IliIs

usut

tiirett

kU

liiis

beiogan

obligatdinat

mea

fl snr

ohiig

atio

llot

india

1.O

sp

10

isedi

.11blia

-

tion

ofre

su

ir,also

refdrred10

Os

stri,

ilahiliiIhis

means

tht.uute

Stu

edcim

iito

havediseharged

us

obligationeven

illiii’

iiueasuues1,1ken

topiotre!

liiitilsist

ment

havenot

a.hievedthe

desiredplnteri

inn,

asking

asil

hosarted

dihugestls

While

thequalitv

ofthe

ohligaiionat

noenfeonduet

.uudnot

otri sult

isixplu

eitly.tfiirm

edin

mosi

awards,

inuebtem

aIns

tobe

spenilid

beinielite

omtO

r’eO

fltentol

thnohligation

isidr’nrifiable.

.\sille

.155ord

inille

1:,usufluuiin

i.u

scp

uus

it.th

egenera

lla

ssih

atio

nol

oblig.iiioiisinn

ohlmgatioius

oIresnll

iii

oiltio

ns

ofconduet,useful

as

itm

avbe

tor

sal

toits

plim

pose

sis

10suhist

11111rlItt

applie

atio

nin

theeoncrete

eireumsian.cs

ota

gis’nis.

\Vhai

seems

tobe

esiabhisluedis

thata

Staieis

tatudetto

ohigal nuru

ut

‘iIu

o.

md

does

not

gram

anln

suran

ce.Igainst

dam.ugr

thaim

asifici

ttlurtilsisrm

rIsl,°

nra

warranty

rhatproperty

shalincvcu

In00v

iurnm

stuilrs

hr’uo

uiptrrinr

distu

rbed,

44

iheStutte

isnot

undera

stilu

tIiaiailuu

v

IU

?,)1I)llli

i.6

Si.

li15.

tor

lIIl?,.

il:1

/it.ib

i’

ni.

p1

.u5

I

1’)SI..ibo

liti)

par..

01.ihus

po

ni

LI)’)

uIn

1.iii/a,

.ihsr’

ii

p,,,,

10“fl

0:u

ni

ii

fl‘1

0’

si

n6

par..

484;Iiirn

r/iiIi

sio

ahiusei

0,p

su.

tI

11111‘sSI’

11‘u

rii

Isini

ili

/nil

Prnif/im

atu

/ ,Seurny

i),l1ht;’i/

Sa/d

iii

5tle

ut

Ut

1/aiic

dues:0

.i,tr

dseetli

ti)have

assumed

astrid

\i:nIlle

IIiI100JI

iniirtnedtilege

tara

liiess

thatthe

Stateis

underbl

itiu

iini

tigilante0’

Inundtlin

thohhatto

nw

asviolated

by

mere

ttagn

liin

ni

ihr’es

ni ing

t’altt

niihe

damagi

eausd’.Ihis

lineni

reasoningos

insuppni

ii

sto

rt

Iiahiliti be

tribrinalaliirtncd

thatit

didnot

intendta

li,je

io,ie

on

sshethetiie

Sta

teis

inu

iJil

)IiOatit)ll

of

reslilt

nr

of

OslO

si.

liti

tiinund

ihatdir

Nia

tessa

tesionsihle1kr

us

unabilitvto

pre

ven

t

stiii

teqlle

flset

ni

erein

t.it

iiri ribrinril

Ltd

IIIIied

tLit

theitb

lianot

niilie

N1tt

isa

durhiipetie

obligattoti.il

ssnuldL

isebeen

mote

dorre

ct

toir

fiu

tihat

tiwState

ssis

iesponsihlefo

tnot

hit

ingtaken

sulfieientnieasures

for

beprnter

ion

ni

ibensestnient,

u,iu heri

tattnu

not

havitugbeen

abieto

pre

Ven

t

toett

ut

ute

titt

ilinsta

nte

sut

ubease.

lorverern

isdtiu

ltto

on

ddeitb

tteite

nle

tli’.n

Ilerpulsuralirtu

pp

irtiu

igihe

vie

svo

lastridt

liability;5

iiiou

rI li

‘silit

badie

tnrii iied

i beex

Isteticeni

thedam

agea nu

badip

pa

ir

111kli

I.iu

uedihat

itbad

taLen

.inv

nte

asln

et

totC

VC

tltii.

fattn

siallisitt

tii hat

ihrsiandaid

nifull

ptniedon

md

securityis

notan

big

.atiu

n.n

ulp

eu

lsate

abilam

ageiii.

in

i.iaert

an

inv

estu

tten

t.but

attobli

to\e’sle

siiie

duligetitein

tereu

ttun

atis

suh

damage,

iLre

nia

Ln

sto

be

Iss

Ia

1i

el

tiilit

tpet

lita II.

ritt

ni

0/i/i

tror

rtdfltJatd

‘\

artis

tin

init

rrgiitdeliuies

as

toi be

tnnt’

nt

ni

ihednc

diligenreobligation,

il‘s

i;ltt

inru

.isu

teuhligatuitt

tot,ike

.iIntejsures

neressarto

ensureihe

tdts

t\u

tIlle

lirt’

\tllietlt.

inpartustulat.

ubetei’

nurlearlv

prevaulungview

asto

thet.ii

ure

iir I;,

ittd.t

i!.

sshet

lierit

isuhiet u

tenr

subjective.lite

latterview

seems

ii e

takti

[iibe

i ruhti mii

iiiI

mdi

i(

an

JrRrpuh/i

ihatsiated

thatute

meas

rirts

inb

tatn

stelli huse

reasnutableunder

theeircu

mstan

(eS)

8li

s,hu

Os

tti

rot

leir

ttitt

sshet brut h

Stat e

hatarted

ingm

udfaith

nrn0t.

9

ii.e:tiP

tit,i

lii.1,’!

ti1

iiiiatfu

tits

lIse

eX

lstU

nd

eut

dsliduitg

su,alei .l.t

orur.

ta

iti.ii0

il5tiie

si ihigensth

oti

.111old

suhjeeiivetriterlon

toan

rik

1,5taid

ut

iglia

ns

e“

I)u

ue

1Itgetire

nsaid

intO

OS

lSt

of

uhereason

aisletiasiiir

ni

pi eseuttinn

ssbih

astell

alu

nin

uste

red

gosern

tfleflt

couldbe

t’

perat

1in

t\t

I titt

undtt

sim

ilat

tittum

sta

nres.

Ihem

ijotuty

ofthe

tribunaliho

iit

5’rin

ui

tii

ulo

tU

flSuuniu

sersu

ilssa

,questionung

titeprocedtire

il’.5

,,

ut

ii.

selilittet

itu

tN

uiI

.1i’ La

ut.u n

arniedacu

ion

undertakento

ritt.0

0!

Iu

t.lr

:lsa

ustlip

leil

hirstiurgetits.

All

tupnuallagers

ofA

APL

s‘i’’

‘i

.tis

lnis

tIin

titearea

0ss Ititli

theg

ov

ern

tllen

tbad

lostcontrol.

I)

Ii

;‘_

‘5.

i,,

‘.il..

NI’

.10,1I

liii

I,iit.i,

hivt

il.4

,10101.

were

susp

erred

of partueipat ungin

ibem

iiite

r111)11.

ibeiarnt

ss ardest

i-ii’ed

duin

grhe

armed

ad

tion

;ute

trubunal

innnr 1

ihatiite

ress

.istti)

Ilittliis

ite

er

st.ll

5e

at

tow

hatefT

eetiv

ely

causedlite

destrurtio

tt,ilossever,

titt’tiihu

naltnnsideird

ihatthe

government

shouldhave

tiiedpearehul

rnm

nllln

lcatin

nto

gei

tittsus

peet

eie

ments

exdudedfront

theinesunu

ssta

llhelore

underuakini,a

nnlitavsco

un

ter—

insu

rgencr

.1—

urther.tiw

tribuu

sa1ioutnd

th.utIlle

gitterut

metri

,buuldhave

institutedjudteual

investugationsagainst

tisesusperted

persouts.Il

buld

haveuurderuaken

necessarym

easuuesto

getib’un

iidthieidrutt,

)uIlle

Par

ithi

reasoning,ute

State’sresponsibihity

isdeem

edestab

ltsbed

,51

Aconsidered

dissentingopinion

pnint sottu

thatute

dispiuuedar.in

nssat

astraregie

ausdhighlv

setssitivesecttruu

opeiat iltutto

regalnroitim

lni

tittatea

of’unsurgenev.

takingp

iacin

asituau

not

nitta

tnin

a1

eu

tlerg

eut

5.A

.surt1inr

tothe

dissenringopinion,

tlsegovernuneuti

svas

under

asuunpeli

ittgsut

eieitt

tinn

toundertake

am

iliraryn

pera

uion

toutga

nrom

rolni

i beare,u.

litt,Im

oo

gan

dm

odalitues<il’Lise

operation,ihus

ihenuinotitv

nilise

iributsal,tnust

haistithin

thegoverusm

ent’sexelusuve

dittrei inn,and

theassattl

shouIdnot

qutsi hinlik

exerciseby

thesta

teol

ursown

sovereigulpuerogat

iset.

30vere

ign

ap

precla

rio

11

Iflite

exerciseof

duedihgence

isa

qu

esu

iousni

vem

tfitig

ubeabiltis

nititt’

meas

urestaken

torear,h

theairn,

astlse

unajolitsus

ibe,IA

I/rase

due’,iht

eis

tiserisk

of

inte

rhere

nce

with

sovere

ign

appre

iatin

n..is

poimed

not

iiititt’

tii

stilt

lulg

opin

ion.

liteprevailiutg

.uppuoaeitifl

;jrI)itrjtuo)u

lpuarulte

seeu

ttsin

betore

ti,lite

tuil)

examine

wherher

thcm

easurestaL

en[ix’

illeS

tate

obvln

usi

devu,uu.tio

iit.1

ni

soutahlestausdard,

rathertisan

suggesting.uhuernat

ter,

more

eflei.liten

teasurr

liselntertsarioutal

Court

of

Justuce(I(

J)rnuthm

nssdt,

ihe

Smaie

tnjo

ys

a

nseasiureofsovereign

.uppretuai.innin

utdecisu

ituu

inI

L,SI.I ,sen

ililie

autitn

rluit

sw

ereIkiuusd

tohave

toleratedthe

otru

patio

ttol

titt’b

ssorkers.be

pit’

teetinnaccorded

rou

teiu

tvesu

menu

wa

ulli

iutuutdtil

beh

iuts

ute

st..i,i.ird.

Furtherm

ore,even

ufthelegal

systemit,ud

tearted.itter

.iuuundiun1tiettis

ii

time,

rheproteetiots

stasnot

deentedto

bebeloss

liii’suattdaid,

hetaust’ila

i’sta

t

am

echanisntits

pla

te.

54

‘litetribu

nalin

.Salukav

(.zt’cltR

i’

1’n/’1iu’intind

thaiute

nbhigatinn55.1k

1111

hreachedif

theState’s

hehavinnr\S

JS

nottnualiv

iuuireasutiableau

drin

itistinab

leby

turn

erational

legalpoliev;

ibatnte

,utiu

l’es

i,tketistud

liol

ii.itl%s

cm

iille

li:i,is

ola

legislatnu‘sdusereuuun

ifu

huev

weu

eitit

intalisdevnid

utlegal

tIllitt

mIl’.

‘115s1

sibid.,

tr

-II

SI,abostn

tOp

ila.

106tid..

ui.i..

tii,s.

•Ibid.,

pa

.Iti

I‘‘I’

I?j’uOO

..111,

i1.

li.i..

i’‘I

ili’;

‘..‘

.uti’.

..:

‘.

‘:

lrashin

inlitt

IllitrIls

il,Iit’rar

nilt

i,u

nsn

,hi.i.it

IL

t.i’ia

nrir

,5

iiii

,‘‘s

I:

/ot

/00

jul‘O

.I!(

i’.A

pploztinn

buv,ul/i

alS

/ct

fll1

lliTl

1li,

lufilk

I’oIl

otk

O,

SU

fL

Itd

lildililL

si

/V

11Ih

ilIldi

iotmd

thti

c111

1115so

scrcg

nfip

pro

cia

tion

Ok

flh

din

1111t,l1

L5

Idi

[[ILIII

d1

dill

likpU

i)lICm

dcihuonw

s11

Ifl

IlV

‘f/V

VJ’

V.

tou

od

tttt

iiL

o,lo

Th

orItIcs

had0110001V

1s

V(I\

V

‘Ifl)

\om

I11

1is

Osti0

00

land

tlicir

rcaIV

I’V

t1IS

0,t

10111V

Il/li

1l1

1r

Ii1

ti5h

ou

id,&ve

boco,th

rcss

is

fl

V

[[[Ith

slidi

rsdcl

‘JS(

hall

111101

t)Idd

il(0

with

paratnetershL

1111i

I11101

dlii

51TIL

V

N,

1111ru

VI

[IL11

I1OtIIJI

111,\iqnt

1//1

(0k

ioi

ni

lmm

dhull,

V0

Il

iltia

it,

.u

-d1u

JIL

mc.o

oic

sto

p101

U1,11

iIIscstm

cnl

trom

unlasv

tul

i’,II

ILV

,0

\\Il’

,k\

i0

1,1IIL

II10

0\0l

1,0

000

1111[41

l10C

.0Iii

thisdV

SO

,thotiL

Itil

.110

iIl)

pI

pL

IisIld

,I

Is)IC

pI’JII’L

IIn

hipahiLIns1110

elilpioS

cos,heat

1110ti

InlflI/4

111111lik

li[Ild

au

ot

1111illIld

alto

1V

:ppIIe

aL

i0II

bevondIh

slealS

afe

t

10

ns

k[

IIii

IIII’\L

IIOIL

1111’1

Ilddisi

I)ull

pl0

00tlu

lland

sceu

rilv

101110

t011

tIllulri

pik

50

fl iS,IIO

Itt

ITo

11150511110111,

WI10I

OdS

othersp1

Ildjtltt

fl1111

ItIlilOS

ItOV

LV

1sthct

flSS

dl(l5L

I)1101

taLe

ati0\1

0S

50S

lti011

00

tU

ILiiIO

oil111111111051)11

applilahiond

tlicstandird.

Ihei

,iO’1

oti

itillO

t0

11

11

0)

SI

51.11,pl

IlLi L

IIII

oottsidcicdto

C1

1101w

ithcl

0‘

hc

sli

iIis

sIflh

l,l{Id

,iildI

To

‘1

1k

(4110otlir

,iiudeq

uitah

lcL

.II11101

1

VV

ViV

VV

VV

VI

,jO

IV

I,1

1IV

V,

1111V

‘111)1)0,

.0to

llol

Ili,sia

iIJald

.bui

V,V

,,,L

,V

•V

V’,V

IV

l

VV

VV

.V

IV

U.V

‘‘

V

•V

V..

5V

IV

lV

Vl,

‘ii.f

iI

I.lp

)sal1

51S

s)

IiiIII’

VV

VlI,,V

iL

IV

IsLo

tiI

isV

.1tI1dttd

lU

ll1)1(110511011

,i1I,I

Vib

nsil

,I1l\s

111111lI

ti11(15

111,11(1IS

1101based

onan

lnv

,’slV

Vi

I1V

11lii

lio

lot

IlV

Isi

1.1(H

VIl

sta

tdailn

otild

not

11,01’addodaiirh

inV

VV

V,V

V.[lI,

10I

VI)

I,

.1.,,s

,’.O.t

tio‘I

tOL

lI))’tI

VI.1

,5

5i

V,

V

V,,,

•j,,,O

j,

1.tO

II’,5

V,,

V•

V

VC

VI

IIII

VI1

15

1V

,i,C

si

Oil)

,il,

‘iI

ii’so

’ol

iloII1

\C5IlIlL

iIItor

1110V

VV’

VV

•V

V1.

liV

SV

1515

itils

I.1

)10

Illt./L

.Old

.hit,

511‘I

I‘.

5i

Iil

1,1

IIIIC

IIII

ot

IIIin

ssiin

t’ni, ibtd

V

5I

Ili

01

1I

551

511llII

prIlp

olIlo

ns

andII

OdS

iI

OL

III

I151

II1

(11

11

,1L[IS

111and

nw

as

dueTo

flV

15

VI

111.111,1II

11

11

11

1,1

11

15

tiII,

111)1,11511

111115.ind

piiblis(IIdL

VI

Scope

ofApplication

Restricted

toP

hvsicalS

afet

In501110

assa rds,

SU

Lhas

iflS

a/til

ai’

1xod

Rty1uh/zL

,°ti

10

trihu

itaisL

II

rhatthe

standarddu’s

noti t’fer

10

110(1

1011

.ldtf

l5t

,l11’

Liudni

itnidli

0k

111,

botoniv

totho

npai11110111

agatnsttho

ph

sicdlIn

tegl

us

nItn

ius

(sto

loril

andag

.tilIstIfliU

rters

lloC

by

1150o

tto

rc.

11

11V

’iindispiiiol

so

c))t.ip

1l5ari

tIL

refers.essentiallv.to

enti

strtfc.111d

pilsieaI

VIt1

Ic.ik

0V

tV

Ihus,lit

Ilt’mi’tI

1.t.Ie

xuo

ihetrib

tin.tI

tou

nl

ihatihe

tV

lu

oL

,it

11)111)1

.idniin—is

tratlv

e0

11

1its

at,

a00

0se(ltIL

’IKe

ni,td

vers

enl(

ketf

lLnis

d[4

.11t1

51

likifil

I51

01

5

acilv

ityW

aS

aviolatioti

by

1110State

of

uS

0)ll.itl0

flto

,iootoi

tait

andt

l4llltd

lfll(

treatn

ient,1m

dnot

asio

laon

ciiilie

staridatdJV

IVT

I1Ipio

leetio

n.iiisl

50(0

111

Slm

ilariv

V[110

tribllfla

iin

V

J05

lusseolfllO

asllre

stluat

1c1lit

t1tatlure

roensure

stabluand

predietable1111

00

51

.0115

Il)111110110

tIul,l[1

IStil

1ll1

1\

0

han

ges,

arht ratv

1nc)dthC.at

no

to

fret4ltlalot

5it

tililesS

IIrkvtctlal

iOg

[‘lii111db

eX

pt’C

tdtio

fls,

i11

000

SiS

tCflt

ad

min

istr

ativ

e,11 ts.

c onhlnuingiegisiatis

liangt’sundor

theoN

igationo

auord

ing

iaii

.111(10(4

0itahie

tue.tl ment,

indnot

[Ilt.0

0

neettunw

itluthe

standardof

fullpluteoticln

audS

Os1

Itlt\.°

’

.\lso

Illeirihunal

111JV

jJV

))

i’I’O

/d?/d11)111101

111,11.1

stabie1115

OsI

lbbc’111L

IlllldlO

’

ispart

011111’obligatiun

otta

lt.nud

0(4

IlltflhiC

Ite

dtllle

ilt,lo

tiii!

t’ti‘1

01

11

1)1

1,l’)o

I

seeuruty

,65

‘illeitubunal

toundthat

1110IttV

estO

rsrig

hts

had11(011

1.ioia

d,

Iludtfl

WaS

ahundanr1ele

ar

thattis

etr

eatm

ent

aoord

ed1(1

11s5ts

itnfati

dik

t111(41111-

ahie,that

itsco

iltractu

al

i ughis55/O

tObroi1,h

ed

atb

itrarik

,111c1for

pIliltiL

di

tldtlu

naliS

ti

rcaScln

s.that

the1115

stur11.111

hull

0\p

(Seo

l0

)fl

11I)1

1i1

.ifli’t)LlS

.1011shueking

eo

lldU

et;”

°bot

00110

utthis

50.11.outtstdt’rs’dto

be

.ihreaeli

ut

11111fl

teetio

naud

seeUrity

.‘Ille

0I1

lreiireu

uee

111.101010

11115standard

uttlis’

,issaro

i

relatesto

alle

gatio

ns

olhara

ssnaent

th.utiie

tribu

nal,

Inuses

eriound

110111)

besuhstantiau,d.

li11)0

aliegeditarassm

euit

hadheen

repeated,tin

nth),

ILoould

possibivhave

beeniiabuluty

underIlle

standardut

full

piu

ieuio

n.itid

s&cu

ruls

forfailure

toprevent

ti.

As

alreadv50011

IIIrespeet

ol

tlierelat

cnshupbetsveeti

illeIle

al

prules11011

,i1ii

inte

rnatio

nal

iass,.1151)

li)(O

lbn

eetio

flw

ttliihe

nulle

Ot

.tIlplII

.11to

llni

Itlo

tuon,

thew

ordingof

ibe

treatv(10(5

not50

(111

tophw

aetiti.i1

rule.Ihus,

ssiuikth

en

lajority

ofthe

treatiesapplied

inthe

,aS

eS

nie

titiotn

dabost’

(onId

luk

1111oblu

gatio

nto

en

su

re

kI

Iprote

uIn

nfl Ild

seo10

11

5.15

.1S

I’pJ ratt’

111)1ig

at

1011.

1111.’Il

L’,lls

applied111

Illelast

mentio

ned

easeeo

tusid

erstle

St,111d,1ldu

thull

pro

le5

11

01

).

specJhcatio

ul

LIt

IlleO

hli[4atiutlIl).10

10d

t.ttr,tiid

UO

ILIII.1l1l1’Ile

Jtf

llufli.

Sa/uk

1,I

,(//1’1jti,b

/i,a

itosl

IV(

)li

I45

I

Ihid..pari

ISt

1(1)/J

,/I

/1/1

510.

.11105)

1.‘4

ptr

Isi

1/I.

il.

/‘SJ’ti’

/U

IA

VIi

.11)1

)1il

i,

t5ii.

jV

urt

III1’

i’n/d

Uhi,

.thI

50

i..

a’

.1fit

VV

,iS

.1“1

I.i

.1ihid.,

pai,1

1.120.2)1

lhld..para

2L

V_

V,1V

VII

VV

VV

itI

i.,ii

110.

14/‘u//

/o11

aw

ni,it/

Secu

rtiyF.

/lpp/lLarion

beyondP

Ilys1cz/Sil/efy

Ii

Seope

ofA

pplieatio

nbcyond

Physk

alS

afety

assaidsdeem

utestam

laidut

fullpiote

Hun

audsesuriuv

toextend

heyondhe

mci

ph

skalsalet

utbe

i msi

ment.

\arious

degreesm

ay

bedetected

inhis

C\is

nsloiiut

tItC55

utapplisat ton

li4

JLZ

()1/1

()o/

liteh

çi/

Itlem

Iheaditiot

alscopt

utalis

auunItas

some

tantifisationsthat

goheyond

them

eresSeis

ds

utpoii

sseu

s.Ihis

sunseins,pai tisulark,

theavailahility

oftheudis

iaI audadniinist

at isess

stemto

prutest

theintetests

utthe

investor.Ihus,

hsrtbuual

inna

iIept

lound

ihatone

ofthe

violationsofthe

obli

gat

mils

so

nite

sted

ssuli

fullprotestiun

audsesurity

was

thesir<um

stancethat

theStaie

badnot

imposed

an

sanstiu

ns

ag

ain

st

chosew

hohad

unlawfully

seiicd

\lsoin

Im

uli

JI(xuotbs

riibuitalatlirt

tedthat

theavailability

oftbe

jud

islal

sssisin

ssasan

slenientut

i befull

piotestion

audses urity

tobe

enjøyedby

ihejuss slui

Ini his

spes itisase,

howes

er,in

telationto

tbeinvestor’s

attemp

tto

isei se

ih5adm

miiIsimat

ise

measures

thatatlested

thcin

set,ument,

thetrihunal

louudthat

ile

lsgalssstem

ssassuffisteutls

asatlableaud

thestandard

badthere

forsnot

heei sio

late

dt5

Sunilaiisbom

theargum

entatiunof

ihedes

isio

nin

F’S

Iil

seems

thatthe

Intsruational(

omt

uttistise

sonsideredth

asailabilttyof

alegal

meehanism

tossitt

i hlass

Iuluessut

ulteiequisttion

utihe

plantas

anelem

entof

thefull

pioti

ion

andss

uiutsto

beeutjoed

h5the

it vestot.Ilow

eser,in

thespeeific

cirum

sta

us

es

tbe

i.ourt

thuudthat

thelegal

msshanisrn

was

presentandthat,even

titbe

tinie

taL

en

toobtatn

ads

sis

ion

16m

otibs

was

undoubtedlym

olong

itsould

no

th

Isemed

asa

denialutjustiss

audihe

obligationw

asnot

breaehed:’°A

lsoths

iibunal

inisnu/et

i(

zt/1R

spubiieafhrm

edthatthe

Statehas

aduty

toksep

thstidis

talss

sie

masatlable

audto

pruperlvexam

ineclaim

sand

decideassurding

ndoins

stis

audintetnational

law.

Ibetribunal

fhundthat

titarduty

badnot

besusiolaisd

intltus

spesitissase

imiL

tiIsbe

tiibttnalin

Ssi!ukai

(iih

Repuh/zc

aflirmed

tbeobligation

tom

akcasailabls

appsalm

eshantsm

sagaiust

polisesearebes,

andadm

inistrativedes

tstuus

allestingi be

tusestment,

Italsu

hatid

t hati he

obligationbad

notbeen

iolatsdin

tU

s5lW

uss ase,

2

iÇJslI

su

nt

Isli

stilIt1

(//’tute/iu

t

sumssau

sgo

bsmd

tlteiesiuirentent

ihattIts

Statem

akesavailahle

itsjudi

sialaud

sdiiim

tiatm

sess

stsut

sotltat

theinsestur

sanpro

testits

interests,

and

955

15/f

labos

mmli

i

/515

‘15555(5,iboss’

.9p

u,

I‘I./

5/,.5

1)0

55

fl1(5

9.0

I1.

lai/

Iispuh/isIhoss

ss0

psss.Sli.

expresslyaffirm

thatthe

standardoff

ullpr

testionand

seeuuttyes.teuds

tothe

srahilityoftbe

investrnentelimate

andthe

Iet.altrainew

ork,A

salready

seenabove,

theaw

ardin

5i

5uns’u

vA

rs’utu

,iahas

,tspes

ialbasis

fuiafhrm

ingtbattbe

standardutprotestion

mteuds

toihe

legalsesuut5ut

theius

est—

mentaud

means,substam

ially,tbe

ss’rtaitltsut

tbelegal

system.

Inparttsular,the

wording

oftbeapplicable

treatyexplienly

rete

rsto

/eg

su

/sesurit),

as

oppu5sdto

thsotber

treatiesapplied

intbe

urisprudeneeibat

isexam

inedhere,

Anothcr

award

thatatfirm

stbis

largeondtrstandiug

uttbe

standaidis

MI

i

(zechR

epuh/zc.‘Ihem

ajorityof

tbetrihtinal

af{irmesl

ihattbe

Suateis

underthe

obligationro

ensurethat

neitherby

amendrnent

utus

lasssnor

baet tons

utits

administrative

hodiesis

theagreed

audapproved

sesuritvaud

puotestioiut

ilseinvestm

entwuthdraw

nur

dev

alued

,74

Itm

ustbe

temem

bered,hossessi,

ilsst

thisaw

ardis

aeeom

pan

iedby

ad

issemin

gopinion.

Also,

itniust

benottsed

ihatthe

CM

Etrib

un

alcom

esto

adesisio

nopposits’

toihe

des isiontaL

en,on

i besam

efacts

and

substan

tiallyb

etween

thesam

t’p

artie

s,

bytfse

tribunalin

ihsi

azu/si

i

czechR

epuhlicsase.

Forth

csake

ofcom

plemeness,

hossever,it

must

bepututed

outthat

theL

auderaw

ardis

decidedon

beIds’ts,aud

thatit

sannotbe

taktitas

i

positio

nin

prtns.ipleut’the

tribunalagainst

tbeextenston

utths’

smandaidut

isillpro

tection

aud

securiryto

thelegal

sceurity.‘lite

itibunalfound

inlaudu

rthat

theam

endntenrsm

adeto

the

med

ialeg

islation

wete

nota

tbreatto

thelusest

men

t.7’

Itrem

ainsopen

wbetber,

badthe

amendm

entsbeen

des’med

astuallsto

affectthe

investmenr,

thetrihunal

would

hasesonsideied

de

standardd

fullpro

tection

and

security

hreashed.A

lso,in

(.‘,SOB

vSlovak

Repubii

tbe

trihunal

foundibat

the

Stats

sondsist

ut

theinterpretation

uttheterm

softhe

sontlastdeprived

thein

sesto

rut

ausm

eaningful

proteetionf’dr

itsloan

audtitsis

hieasbedtItt’

soiuumiim

entto

giantfull

proteetionand

security

.76

Recently,

rbetrihunal

inl/vendi

vtlrentuua

Ilrendeted

anassamd

thatestsrm

sivelyexam

ninesthe

seopeofapplisation

ofthefull

protestiouaud

ss’suritstansi

ard.A

salready

mentiorm

edin

sestionB

above,th

etribunal

metetresi

topus’s ious

arbitralpraetice

andm

adean

antith

etisin

terpletatio

nut

thettsat5

baseslon

itsw

ord

ing

tosu

pport

usopin

ion

thatthe

standamsl

applyto5m

nyai

utm

easure

which

deprivean

investor’sinvesim

entut

protestiouau

dt’uII

sessiru

s.‘susli

aetionsur

measures

neednot

ibreatenphvsical

possesstonur

lIteisgallv

piums’stsl

terms

ofo

peratio

nof

the

investm

em.”

Assording

touhe

tuihunal,the

staudaidcan

apply

tom

ore

than

ph

ysisal

sesurity

utan

iitss’sts>ioi

uspiopsu

ts,s.ause

either

cou

ldbe

subjeet

tohaiassm

ent

witb

ou

tbs’titg

pltssmsalls

baiuu,dut

ssijsd,‘lite

Aw

arddoes

notid

entify

an>furihei

tbespes

ifissuutent

uiiltis

siaiidamsl

Iii

‘

Su’rns’nsi’

ligsntiim

,ibost

fl5

saSi.)

I

(lvii’i’

(ass/i

Rs’pu/s/zsahsss<

ssti

pir

a(il

“.

IsjiS

(/5’7i

(ass/i

1/spiSs/i,ahost

ss1(1

s,sma

ilI

6(

,5QJ

v5/om

sil’Rspmsh/u,,iIii,c

ss,

s,st,i

I‘

ISvs’ndmi

.4tssm

ustm

a,.iho

ss5

pas,s.

aI’s

/all Jro

h1w

ian

iarttt

IA

pp/icattonIn

3vm1

PI’yiani

Sa/ity

14

:0v

sut

rot.ft

livti

ihunai

div!iu

nrvntloiiut

siola

tten

etL

ii.’,

Oil

sv.

1,1li

st.lnd,IId

,an

id

mv

d.ih

ihedotltin

sand

Omis—uoro

dl

iOt

.Ib

LV

ruliv

tijrv

as

aviolatren

ilKpr

im.Iple

etfatt

andev]u

itablety

ar

mer

Ihov

arg

(Vd

sv01k

of

liviblig

ionrchning

tofull

proteetlonaud

syv(1

1115,

(j1

V

\%%

Otlirnivd

hsmliv

trrhuiialbyi

00

tpp!wd

lethe

favtsof

thecase,

r0nu

V uIts

50

on

,il

itu’

11111vn

ett

md

vby-

hroadlvdehited

asan

Irrtiu

sardsv/e

111to

ipplivdrhv

standardut

fullpie

tevtie

naud

seu.ur.ts

XtO

nosvis

.isthose

lovnr

orivdR

bese,O

svit

i hougitthey

make

noexpress

dlca

nv:V

rt

itrunnv

toll,

i hesous

.iid.tpplicd

drostandard

as

iti

was

m{l\

.11vit

tou

rO,id

Jtv

t.uitl

liau

d1tni.tblv

([uR

tI000t.

liws

sviiibe

exainlO

vVyl

ivkuss

V

airo

isobsv

ied

iv

Vvtron

IIah

uv,

how

erdrirg

vnihe

t reatle

sapplied

v.

tItI

mil

(tis

forvin

mo

hase

plaVv

Ii

srg

nitiv

an

irele

inthe

dclinitien

irvp:

om.ippln

.uiruiiui

uteuandard

iiiiau

ardren

dered

in.Sanit’ns

i’

VII

‘ull

VIs

assud

i hargis

v’sPR

ivular

nu

deratio

nto

thew

ord

Ingvil

tltvti

ar,

\invvIllu

lUI

betssevn(

rman

.undA

rgemina

provides,as

mv

nro

irr(IV

trorlvg.ui

syv

ulit

VI liv

werd

rng

vdiv’

ei hertreaties

uponw

hichthe

VIS

di:ro:t

1011vvi borv.umv

based.u

vnei

venipat.ubl.

\X’h

ileibe

treatiesapplied

:nir

iE

uro,!tur

uiuvl5

nv.’

jjr’vls

v(lIV

Sid

Cf

ihutsso

ob

liatiens

assepar

11

vi

vnivauv

sll

kv!

111iho

‘i1iand

inliv

‘trond,Il

awards

v,onsiderthe

11.t

tnO

tfull

pr

otv

4to

iiiis

asjiO

vdiv

at

lot

oftbe

eblig

ation

toavv

ordlV

airaudL

(U1

ldi

ivr

vrtrrrv

nr’

V

()‘verlapV

Inuotlw

rS

tand

ards

ilivrirg

itiii

roranr

fulltn

0v

vtr

on

audsov

inits

hasan

uneertarnborder

i,

ru)thv

ple

srs

iuns

irsrIaiis

ven

iauilv

’vl

innvvsln

ldnt

treatie

s.

By

tarihe

mest

.rnpor

1,1111IV

Iro,nisiv’

ihar

rvv

Iulriu

sa

,1reitil

vil

itdtii.iiio

uIS

thatujt-

biirau

dequit

,ibtvilvatrruv

i,A

lsu,u

tepr

srsIeils

onrv

irnbrirsetn

cnel

dam

ages

dncto

aetion

siii

voirthati

Sv0v

vasrotirlls

hvertvonsrdered

aso

verlap

pin

gw

ithtise

ob

ligatjo

nIl!

toi

pmoit

vutena

rrdSO

v11111

V

liiiull

mr/lit

J,V

SV

tilfllt)11

ithas

by

vn

pi

ivttis

i finruivd

ininbli

rat

et

I r.tvrive,

idrexaniple

bythe

irihtrnaiIII

ilit

i(I

1111ltd

11111I liv

Ih1tgitlu

at

off

ullpie

tevtjo

n,iud

sovitrity

may

bev

ntv

v’,

:fil

jlsSiv.ll

selv’iivv

etdam

.geevvurrv’d

andgees

bevendpoliee

Om

‘lvr

mlv

IldIS

nmivdintil)

svnr’v’lite

mvvstirm

v’tri

vliV

IiO

llIlte

ltt,80

Simultaneouslv.

tv

ViS

S.sivllv

et’ nr‘vd

audvn

vnmphasiivd

ti.11

iheteis

anim

erV

reia

tionsh

ipw

it hlt(

iIn,

ut

‘I

ti)‘ti

.ltOf,rii

.urdt’v

1ttitablv

’treatnlv’tlt,aud

fou

nd

rhaiihe

StateL

uled

lepro

vid

elair

audeq

ttttable

treatn

iv’m

tt.i

idthv’i’vluo,’.

ssli

liii5,11)1v

lvIlO

tIS,

alsebreavhed

tlreeb

hg

atienet

iiii

pruutev[O

il.111v!

sOv

iltit5

.111v

iriflU

rLuu

thatthe

two

standard

sdro

oloselvin

terrelated,

audreferivd

recailier

ti ibunalsthat

hadfound

thatthe

obhgationet

fullproteuron

audsov

ni

insvas

hrvavliei

hecaun’i be

iuvestm

en

tss

as

suhevi

tonuniarr

.tlldIn

ov

1tiitable

tieatm

viin,ts

ull

iIlvO

cczvIenia/i’

L’utlul(/O

r0,1

50.

til’,veliv

ers

yis’.

teund

i1,11

bi(‘,lv

ivil

ItiliIrie

vin

’n

aud

seeu

ritv

cau

ses

abreavlu

etih

eta

:raud

equtiabletle

atln

erll

si,irivlatvl,is

111W

enai

I’ypi.

Ihetribunal

inA

zu,,xtu

rther

potlite

vi

Ottn

i hatru

ilIvapplivahiv

trearyhetsseen

rheU

uttedS

tate

sau

dA

rgv’trtuuailie

tssoo

bIiatiu

ns

ei(ull

piu

teetionaud

seeurltvaud

tattaudev1uiia

bie

ite.lilile

nt

arv’

sup

.0.llv

’.ds

livi

uSv’rv’III

tbetreats

apphedin

thalo

renreu

lioned

()cidinial

aw

ard

.Ibe

iribnitu,rluuutrved

thar,neveriheless,

div

viulaijensof

thefri li

pte

tdon

arrdsev

ur

ttsstand.iid

is

utnsi&red

absorbedin

dsv’u

ufair

audiurquiiablv

tlv’arm

elit

iniliv

0:11v’ilal

award.

IheAzurzxasvard

alsedues

so,ag

din

111s1iite

eithe

werduug

ettiiv

’trydis,

which

consadersibe

wo

sta

uv

lards

.issep

drate

.5

‘iheline

oftlioughiut

tlieatureineuttriuvd

0’

Idt

lltlijWarvi

Isili.t

ito,

stahtliivef

theIegal

aud

hu.siues.sl’rarnesserk

isan

essetuial

element

oftitt

oblrgatiertto

avcordro

theinvesim

cmi,tatr

and

vvjuitabletreatm

vni.

IIhe

tinbumr.iIv’stahlislsed

thatthcre

badbeen

.iV

aelationtil

[hota

llaudev1uit.ab

leire.li

111cm

ellilgateie

.undaihrm

edrilat

libecom

es01001

toelrqum

ressIretlier

to.tddii

toll

tirery’SS

dS

.1bre

av

iotm

ilpretevtion

audseL

ti ruy, as

atreat

Iueniih

atis

mo

r1,11r

audev

vrrtaile

,itttri—

maticaliy

entaiisan

abseuve

etfull

pretevdon

audS

tv11111

ei

the1115v

sirst

nt

Aceording

totbe

tiibunalin

Ou’utv

/et:full

l’I

, n,tdur’,.rItvration

utdiv

’iya

i,uiyj

busiuessens

trolim

eut

inssltkli

ute

1115estin

eilt

55,15111,1(1v’

tsas

i,dai

nu

llel

liv’ike

-

tCv

tiun

stanvIrd

s,as

boditan

aud

equ

itaio

lctl’v

aru

rem

ii.itid

idl

p11

11evi

en

driv

!secu

riryreq

uire

rbat

the

State

providesstability

andprv

divtahilin

Inl!/’r

iL

’t<

3p1

,55

liserw

esiau

vlaid

sof

protiotturuthaul

alrtavlsby1

utdv

iiiw

itbC

Oliv

ut:eitrlv

audb11

ttds’ioiatd,

5511111

tilsl)o

is

ing

sslilv

ii.1v

ilu

rt’(1

...v

viw

iiiehobhgatious.

litedeseiip

iieuvii

hr,tav

t.slIt

111.11v,,,e

vu

fll.lln

VhV

huS0

.0relatiug

rophvsica

isecuti

t,

5’ie

avail.uhnlti’t

trli

e,alss

sivirr

trtry1.

trr0l

Iprevention

erprost

iutto

nei

ll)sk

a1via

mag

v’.’

ds

syvil

asn

ygila

flI

i115vW

hiiethe

ft’rmer

1551)to

rms

etbv’hay

mur

ichtten

eIlle

tiavhr tinui,il

ti[I

Avalie

not

fitluple

teutio

ll.untd

5v’v

’LlritI’

tliel(i[lvn

ialIssitlu

n1

0’

,tfvd

rrlI is

hv,\v

meu

riou

edv.sp.tudevl

Svo

pe

ihattu

hu

ll,userlaps

5511t

rio.‘l’tiy

dllit

v”

t,,risn

Ivi

equttahiei ic

atnie

ni,

Aj,so,

i byiro

mby

isy

vto

rti

Insrt5’d

Siro

sm

iv!1’

Isi1v’

treativsap

plied

is

Lu

tisattd

()u’kiuO

tarpres

rvlesivin

iittrshin,sttv

ntrtv

runv

iti

‘‘

Ihu

,pu

uis

Ila,

uari

/Vr

V’

jv

‘

I

V10,1.,

‘II

‘V

I

i‘1

V5

1.0,

.0‘i

.11

i‘us

-i,

1stri

i1

’\

iI

,p

aris

e}n,in

lS.

iiS

I’n/I Iiott

rioanå

Seclirity

la.App/zcaiio;i

invond

Phyzcal Safetyi 4

9

protestto

iaudxxiii

iiiaud

toasxotd

fairaud

cqtmahle

iteatmeu

tastw

ose

para

te

itittda

dsI1t

s losetcLit

ishiphstsscen

ihecx

i‘udcd

itaudatclof

fullp

rote

t.tion

audss’s

ut

tiattd

ht.o

ltitgatio

ttto

at.s otdla

i1

klequttable

i reatmeni

ispointed

(titta R

oiti

iht.I

iI6

iIn

lay

assard,ihat

liids

thatonly

exceptionallyw

illthe

standatdix

islatt.dto

ahroads’r

attihitthan

tht.phvsical

set.uritas

iheafore

metitiotis

d(

idiparttal assatd

hadpostuL

itsdaud,

insush

ase,therew

ouldbe

ss’ii

st.slattoti

tothe

lattaud

squiuble

treatmeut

ob

ligatio

n.

89

‘Iheaw

ardalL

iitis’dili is

inpent.tal

terussaud

didnot

seemto

attachparticuhir

import

ant.cx

ihs

dflerettse

inssoidiiig

hetweeu

ihetreaty

appliedin

theC

/vl[aw

ard(sshen.

Itil

g0k

stm

iiaud

seur

iiiis

isp

es

iRat ton

offair

audequitable

treatm

ent)a tid

iLetieats

appltsabktti

i be

I’I’6

case(w

hersthe

two

standardsare

sepatatsobhpations).

Ilit.uitits

dii

todtstttiguisht

ixlw

eeum

ctw

ostaudards

isevidern

a6oin

titeahxads

tnenttonedassard

itiis

nuu

ti

Aii’,ir,n

aihat,

alsobased

onthe

word

ingol

iti

u,

s xplis1tI

appitesi be

ilauda

idof

proteetionto

thelegal

securiii

iatusriL

into

i be

ilissisal

sesutiti

ofihe

tnvestment,

Renegotiat

ion

of

thet,o

ntl

at.Is

loititt.

soLputpose

oltedusiug

iheprise

audw

ithoutany

declar-atx

nof

puititstu

tets

st,delaied

ga>

ment

wi

houtauy

basison

thecontract

ortitt.

applisaLle

ispiilattott.ot

dstiiaiof

assessto

administrative

filesfor

fihingan

appealall

tixse

lotmi

olbehaviour

att.’deeiued

toviolate

boththe

standardof

fairaud

squ

tabletit.atm

eutaud

ihatol

fullg

otectionaud

securityY°

‘Thetreaty,

hovvesst

ptoidt.

ilot

lati

audequitahle

trentment

audfull

protectionaud

legales

urtii

istss

xpatats’

taudamds;

ihetithttt

nifa

iisto

elaborateon

thedistinc

tioiiii

ihislic

at

lxtiiss’tI

tlietw

ostandatds,

\lso,ih

s’(

SOl1

asvaidutade

nefe

teu

se

toI.

iiaud

equitabletieatm

entandfull

gii ite

siton

tid

ses

ut

iti ogs’tlx

idtin

spilt.’

oft be

appi icabletre

aty

ihatpro

vid

es

lottiso

spatut.

obhigatmous.

litt.pat

tiilassitd

issmts’t.iin

(‘mil

i(

IR

cpubliclailed

todistitsguish

ilietimli

piotssti

inaud

ss’sutitilioni

otlxistaitdirds,

audsaw

tbesam

eastiotis

andin

is tionstitt

stedto

t eniose

tIme isstinn

audIegal protestion

ofthe

investmentas

i basislot

thsslatin

lotexpropi

lamaud

equitahletreatrn

ent,

9discrim

’inatt.

nim

s’asut.

iaud

lithlplots’s

imonaud

sesitntty’t5

‘liteoverlap

between

thest,nsl,iisi’,

igossihhs

s’xplaiueslin

viessof

titt.’applisabie

Bl’l’that

considersthe

ibli‘attoti

tostisuts’

Itmllgiolesim

onaud

5sst

ty,ts

aspecific

atio

nofthe

standardit

lattaud

s’1itti,iblstts’atm

s’nt

6i

,tt

t,‘

Ifl!

ilti

fl6

tidO

S4$)

5a

i/

bt.

ti

i/‘

i,tlsj’,s

tt,i

6I’)

i’i

iI

pi

ththi

soiis’t,tm

,s’ni

tPsl

Ini

md

s’qsttt,thIsin

arm

eni.

‘iheV

ivendivArgenrina

llaward,finally,suhoidiuated

tbesiaudaid

olliii!gro

tectionand

securityto

tbeprinsipie

offiii

andequm

tabietieatm

eut.lhe

standardis

saidto

applyto

auyast

on

measitre

sshit.lidepnisss

aniusestor’s

i nyeIm

t.in

ofprotection

audsesunity,

providedmi

son

.slitittes

alsouulaii

audmmit.t.i uiablc

ireatmen

t.9

6‘Ihis

isexphisitly

hast.don

utespesilis

siotdingof

thseticaty,

whit.b

suhjecin

theobligation

togiovide

fullprotes

t monaud

set.u

tiii

totitt.

gitts ipit.

olIdirand

equitabietreatinent.

Aften

haviugaisesset.ItIiis

iutenielatiouship[sstsses’n

thetw

ostandards,

theassard

ignotedthe

standardol

fullp

tote

slio

naud

st.’surttyaud

nteasuredthe

State’shehaviour

i.xc lusisel>agam

nstibe

gi ineipls’

olfai

iaud

equitabietreatm

ent.

9’‘Ihe

ovenlapof

tbei w

osta

ndard

s,in

50115lusmon,

fiudsa

justifit.attotiin

lite

wording

oftbe

ireatyouly

inille

(All’

audin

titt.ienende

lIsan.

Ilit.otbsn

awards

havesim

plydisregarded

thatute

respesiRe

i teatieslisted

lItem

ostand—

ardini

two

separateobligatton

iandhast.

tie,iiedi bent

aset.iu

ivaie

nt,”

As

alreadyseen,

soineaw

ard

sopenly

alhrmi hat,

iltite

ttitt.iple

olLiii

audequitable

treatment

basheen

violated,ubers’

isuo

ued

tot. stablisb

inat.it.iim

tona

violationof

tIteprovision

onfull

gimiles

tion

audse

sunimy.(‘Itbei,mnands

donot

statethis

expressiybut

neide,frc’ro

inassordause

witb

thisappioat.It,

iatlmug

aspectfic

elaborationm

ittwhat

exat.ml>diiim

npuisbesomie

stattdatdftoum

liteotbsn

rnakestbe

standardoffuli

pro

testio

naiit.Isecuiity

tedutidaut,as

itis

imot

imis

tbie

toidentify

whish

asnonsor

ontissioims

uta>sonslitu

tt.v

iolatm

oii

ilteneI

on,in

indepetidentbasis.

Aiio

nen

combai

Anorher

situationw

hcreoscaslonally

awatds

basesbossn

tmnsc’nt,tint

inlite

choiceof

wbich

treaty’provision

toapply,

isw

henube

pbysisaldam

tiagsto

thein

vesto

ris

dncto

armited

action.In

tbesssast.’s,

ihert.’m

aybe

ahnl,

tothc

piosi

sionsthat

thctreaties

rnaycontain

ondam

agesdutc

toat.

iion

int.om

bau.‘lhuis,

them

ajorityin

AM

I’n/a,re’

afhrntt.’dthat

tltehahihts

olR

is,Si,us

bada

basiseirher

inthe

provisionot

fullprotestlon

audst.’sittm

t’,otin

titt.pitvision

onnot

amidcom

hat,or

inh

oth

d9

Iheseaiiei uatist.’

basessin

rssn

ttmsm

leslni

ute

separareopinion

byA

rbitrator(dolsong,

wbo

considt.’tesllitt.

io

sision

onnot

andcom

batas

a/ex

ipecea/e

ailmau

ni

susbahsorhs

ibetuic

onIull

giotsst

mon

audsesunmuy.le’

U1Zi

‘lit,!,ttl,td

,dhti’,!

n8

na

iI

Ihid..pam

as.7

+18i,+6

aiisl,‘i

AIso

I’N(

IAD

,m

htsm

i.I

Vi,

lt

sit

iiiI

6ti

trti,

iiii

tii

il

ttitdsr

rhcsann

hsading

,tsi hi’

tail

mrmlmcliil

il,)li

ii

iI

I)I’

pi

Ititt

I,t

i

tHU

lamSs!tps

niths

siattdatdin

isl,tuttrta

pittI

tim&

ii

iti

st

ti

iih

distuih,tnsc’but

1111(1555,tko

lhi’(insit,ii

ili

iisI

ii

iIpis

i,ttn

tI

i

ihid.,nu,

+0i’!

q.

11wpapt

iI milsittsl

thort

stihr

I.i

Oil

1111) hsis”c

iiilisin)

Im

iii

iis)

sssnttrv

,mnslrIttD

ii,titd

sslutiihltiisairic

iii

iIfI

i’s’titt,

ihossn

Isp

imi

li