ontario superior court of justice attorney general …
TRANSCRIPT
CAN: 23323287.1
Court File No.: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
B E T W E E N:
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Applicant
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Applicant
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THE SALE THEREOF (IN REM)
Respondent
MOTION RECORD OF EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
December 8, 2016 DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X 1E2 Bruce Darlington (LSUC# 25310K) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3529 Fax: 416-369-5210 Jennifer A. Whincup (LSUC# 60326W) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3425 Fax: 416-369-5240 Lawyers for Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.
- 2 -
CAN: 23323287.1
TO: ATTACHED SERVICE LIST
SERVICE LIST (as at October 7, 2016)
TO: THORNTON GROUT FINNIGAN LLP 100 Wellington Street West Suite 3200 P.O. Box 329, Toronto-Dominion Centre Toronto ON M5K 1K7 Fax: (416) 304-1313
Leanne M. Williams Tel: (416) 304-0060 Email: [email protected]
Asim Iqbal Tel: (416) 304-0595 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for BDO Canada Limited
AND TO: BDO CANADA LLP, BDO CANADA LTD 150 Caroline St. S., Suite 201 Waterloo, ON N2L 0A5 Fax: 1 (905) 570-0249 Michael Hanson Tel: 1 (519) 578-9610 Email: [email protected] Brad Newton Tel: 1 (905) 524-1008 Email: [email protected] The Court Appointed Receiver
- 2 -
AND TO: BENNETT JONES LLP Suite 3400 One First Canadian Place P.O. Box 130 Toronto ON M5X 1A4 Fax: (416) 863-1716
Lincoln Caylor Tel: (416) 863-1200 Email: [email protected]
Alan Gardner Email: [email protected]
Jonathan Bell Email: [email protected]
Joseph N. Blinick Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for the Plaintiffs in Court File No. CV-10-8597-00CL
AND TO: DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X IE2 Fax: (416) 365-7886
Bruce Darlington Tel: 416-365-3529 Email: [email protected]
Jennifer A. Whincup Tel: (416) 365-3425 Email: [email protected]
Kim Hamill Tel: (416) 369-5295 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for the Applicant/Respondent
- 3 -
AND TO: TORKIN MANES Barristers and Solicitors 151 Yonge Street Suite 1500 Toronto ON MSC 2W7 Fax: 1-888-587-9143
Jeffrey J. Simpson Tel: (416) 777-5413 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for HMT Holdings Inc. and Harbour Mortgage Corp.
AND TO: MINISTRY OF FINANCE Legal Services Branch 33 King Street West 6th Floor Oshawa ON LIH 8H5 Fax: (905) 436-4510
Kevin O’Hara Tel: (905) 433-6934 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: MINISTRY OF NATIONAL REVENUE c/o Department of Justice Canada Ontario Regional Office The Exchange Tower 130 King Street West Suite 3400, Box 36 Toronto ON M5X IK6 Fax: (416) 973-0810
Diane Winters Tel: (416) 973-3172 Email: [email protected]
Peter Zevenhuizen Tel: (416)952-8563 Email: peter [email protected]
Lawyers for Canada Revenue Agency
- 4 -
AND TO: RETIREMENT HOMES REGULATORY AUTHORITY Office of the Registrar 160 Eglinton Avenue East Fifth Floor Toronto ON M4P 3B5 Fax: (416) 487-1223
Heather Hogan Email: [email protected] John Risk Email: [email protected] Tel: (416) 440-3570
AND TO: RCAP LEASING INC. 5575 North Service Road Suite 300 Burlington ON L7L 6Ml Fax: (905) 639-1363
Tel: 1-866-239-1290 Ext. 7 Email: [email protected]
Secured Party
AND TO: GOLDMAN, SLOAN, NASH & HABER LLP Suite 1600 480 University A venue Toronto, ON MSG 1V2 Fax: (416) 597-3370 R. Brendan Bissell Tel.: (416) 597-6489 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for Sure Mortgage Capital Inc.
- 5 -
AND TO: KRONIS, ROTSZTAIN, MARGLES, CAPPEL LLP 1100 – 25 Sheppard Avenue West Toronto ON M2N 6S6 Fax: (416) 225-7214 Onofrio Ferlisi Tel: (416) 225-8750 Ext. 262 Email: [email protected] Solomon Khan Tel: (416) 225-8750 Ext. 358 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for The Bank of Nova Scotia
AND TO: MADORIN, SNYDER LLP 55 King Street West, 6th Floor P.O. Box 1234 Kitchener, ON N2G 4G9 Tim J. McGowan Tel: (519) 744-4491 Email: [email protected] Dawn E. Phillips-Brown Tel: (519)-744-4491 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: GOVERNMENT OF ONTARIO Legislative Bldg Queens Park Toronto, ON M7A 1A1 Lori Blaskavitch Tel: (416) 212-8888 Email: [email protected]
- 6 -
AND TO: MINISTRY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL Civil Law Division Civil Remedies for Illicit Activities Office (CRIA) 720 Bay Street 8th Floor Toronto ON M7A 2S9 Fax: (416) 314-3714 Gary Valiquette Tel: (416) 214-5881 Email: [email protected] Jennifer Malabar Tel: (416) 327-2932 Email: [email protected] Ronald Carr Tel: (416) 326-2704 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for the Attorney General of Ontario
AND TO: OLDFIELD, GREAVES, D’AGOSTINO P.O. Box 16580 172 King Street South Waterloo ON N2J 4X8 Fax: (519) 576-0131 Edward L. D’Agostino Tel: (519) 576-7200 Email: [email protected] Proposed Representative Counsel of EVH Residents
AND TO: GOWLINGS WLG LLP 50 Queen Street North Suite 1020, P.O. Box 2248 Kitchener ON N2H 6P4 Fax: (519) 571-5025 Ross F. Earnshaw Tel: (519) 575-7525 Email: [email protected]
- 7 -
AND TO: GOODMANS LLP Bay Adelaide Centre 333 Bay Street, Suite 3400 Toronto ON M5H 2S7 Fax: (416) 979-1234 Joe Latham Tel: (416) 597-4211 Email: [email protected] Jason Wadden Tel: (416) 597-5165 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for Revera Inc.
AND TO: PROUSE, DASH & CROUCH LLP 50 Queen Street West Brampton ON L6X 4H3 Fax: (905) 866-5165 Dalkeith Palmer Tel: (905) 451-6610 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for Simarjeet Singh
AND TO: CITY OF KITCHENER Revenue Division 200 King Street West Ground Floor Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 Tel: (519) 741-2450
AND TO: 1459671 ONTARIO INC. Ajinderpal Bajaj 10 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4T5
AND TO: 1459672 ONTARIO INC. Rajesh Chowdhry 26 Daleridge Crescent Brampton ON L6P 2X6
- 8 -
AND TO: 1459673 ONTARIO INC. Inderpal S. Bajaj 97 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4P8
AND TO: Ajindrapal Singh 12 Celestial Court Brampton ON L7A 3R8
AND TO: Rajesh Chowdhry 26 Daleridge Crescent Brampton ON L6P 2X6
AND TO: Inderpal S. Bajaj 97 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4P8
Email Service List
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
CREDITOR SERVICE LIST
TO: Riepert Salt & Supplies Inc. 66 Schaefer St. Waterloo, ON N2L 4C5 Shelley Riepert Tel: (519) 747-2708 Fax: (519) 747-5810 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Kitchener-Wilmot Hydro Inc.
301 Victoria St. S. Kitchener, ON N2G 4L2
Tel: (519) 745-4771 Fax: (519) 745-3631 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Culligan Water 427 Gage Avenue Unit 1 Kitchener ON N2M 5E1
Tel: (519) 744-2248 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Shoppers Home Health Care 1 Hespeler Road Cambridge ON N1R 8L4
Trisha Ward Tel: (519) 624-6020 Fax: (519) 624-0906 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Commercial Kitchen Repairs 92 Talbot Street Kitchener, ON N2M 2B1
Tel: (519) 588-4213 Email: [email protected]
- 2 -
AND TO: Fresh Start Foods Canada Ltd. 2705 Durante Way Milton ON L9T 5J1
Tel: (905) 878-9000 Fax: (905) 878-9010
AND TO: The Home Depot PO Box 675, Station D Scarborough ON M1R 5T4
Tel: 1-800-439-1523 Fax: 1-866-671-5926
AND TO: Information Network Systems 75 Northland Road Waterloo ON N2V 1Y8
Tel: (519) 746-0631 Fax: (519) 746-0854 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Nextsys Networking Inc. 668 Trillium Drive Unit 4 Kitchener ON N2R 1J3
Tel: (519) 885-8494 Fax: (519) 254-4386 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: On-Hold Marketing Inc. 2 East Beaver Creek Road Building 4a Richmond Hill ON L4B 2N3
Tel: 1-888-466-4653 Email: [email protected]
- 3 -
AND TO: Orkin Canada Corporation 5840 Falbourne Street Mississauga ON L5R 4B5
Krystle Russell Tel: (519) 623-5752 Fax: (519) 621-7435 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Progressive Waste Solutions Canada Inc. 139 Ardelt Avenue Kitchener ON N2C 2E1
Debbie Scheer Tel: (519) 745-8080 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Rogers P.O. Box 4100 Don Mills ON M3C 3N9
Tel: 1-888-764-3771 Fax: (647) 439-1419
AND TO: Share Canada Box 2212, 100 City Centre Drive Mississauga ON L5B 3C7
Tel: 1-800-665-7692 Fax: 1-800-563-8453 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Sweet Signatures Division of Shock-O-Lot Inc. 225 Labrador Dive Unit 2 Waterloo ON N2K 4M8
Samia Chalhoub Tel: (519) 747-4261 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Tara Romain
Email: [email protected]
CAN: 23323287.1
Court File No.: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
B E T W E E N:
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Applicant
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Applicant
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THE SALE THEREOF (IN REM)
Respondent
INDEX
1. Notice of Motion returnable December 14, 2016
2. Affidavit of Bruce E. Darlington, sworn December 7, 2016
3. Affidavit of Tim McGowan, sworn December 7, 2016
4. Draft Order
Tab 1
Court File No.: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
B E T W E E N:
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Applicant
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Applicant
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THE SALE THEREOF (IN REM)
Respondent
NOTICE OF MOTION
OF EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc. (“EVR”) will make a Motion to the court on
Wednesday, December 14, 2016 at 10:00 a.m. or as soon after that time as the Motion can be heard
at the court house, 330 University Avenue, 8th Floor, Toronto, Ontario, M5G 1R7.
PROPOSED METHOD OF HEARING: The Motion is to be heard orally.
THE MOTION IS FOR:
1. An order approving the professional fees and disbursements of DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
and Madorin, Snyder LLP; and
-2-
2. Such further and other relief as to this Honourable Court may seem just.
THE GROUNDS FOR THE MOTION ARE:
Background
(a) EVR is the owner and operator of Emmanuel Village in Kitchener, Ontario.
Emmanuel Village is a retirement community that houses between 110 and 130
residents and employs approximately 50 individuals.
(b) On or about June 10, 2016, EVR commenced an application to appoint a receiver
for the limited purpose of completing a going concern sale of EVR’s business and
the assets, undertaking and property used in relation to the business, including all
proceeds thereof (collectively, the “Business”) to a purchaser who is licensed to
carry on the Business as a retirement home at the Commercial List in Toronto under
Court File No.: CV-16-11424-00CL (the “Toronto Application”).
(c) On or about June 10, 2016, the Attorney General of Ontario (the “AGO”)
commenced a civil forfeiture application in Kitchener, Ontario under Court File
No.: C-636-16 (the “Kitchener Application”) in respect of the property
municipally known as 1250 Weber Street East, Kitchener, Ontario, a portion of
which is owned by EVR (the “EVR Property”). Pursuant to the Kitchener
Application, the AGO sought and obtained a temporary preservation order under
the Civil Remedies Act that placed a “No Dealings” notation on title to the EVR
Property on an ex parte basis (the “Preservation Order”).
-3-
(d) The Preservation Order was subsequently amended by the Order of Justice Broad,
dated June 23, 2016, and extended to August 8, 2016 by the Order of Mr. Justice
Hainey on July 15, 2016.
(e) On June 24, 2016, EVR obtained an order appointing the Receiver in the Toronto
Application (the “Appointment Order”).
(f) On June 22, 2016, the Kitchener Application was transferred to Toronto by the
Order of Justice Newbould, and subsequently consolidated with the Toronto
Application by the Orders of Justice Conway in each of the Kitchener Application
and the Toronto Application to proceed as a single application on the Commercial
List.
(g) Pursuant to the Order of Justice Pattillo dated July 27, 2016, the parties obtained a
permanent preservation order under the Civil Remedies Act that continued the “No
Dealings” notation on title to the EVR Property.
(h) On or about Friday, August 12, 2016, EVR entered into the Sale Agreement with
the Purchaser. The Transaction was approved by the Order of Justice Hainey, dated
August 26, 2016.
(i) On or about September 6, 2016, Justice Newbould ordered that the Appointment
Order be amended to require the passing of accounts of EVR’s counsel, being DLA
Piper (Canada) LLP and Madorin, Snyder LLP, among other things.
-4-
(j) On September 26, 2016 EVR brought a motion to pass the accounts of EVR’s
counsel, being DLA Piper (Canada) LLP and Madorin, Snyder LLP, up to August
30, 2016 and September 16, 2016, respectively.
(k) By the order of Justice Newbould, dated November 21, 2016, the fees and
disbursements of DLA Piper (Canada) LLP and Madorin, Snyder LLP were held to
be reasonable and approved.
(l) The fees and disbursements of DLA Piper (Canada) LLP and Madorin, Snyder LLP
are reasonable in the circumstances.
(m) Such further and other grounds as the lawyers may advise.
3. The following documentary evidence will be used at the hearing of the application:
(a) The affidavit of Bruce E. Darlington, sworn December 7, 2016;
(b) The affidavit of Tim McGowan, sworn December 7, 2016; and
(c) such further and other evidence as the lawyers may advise and this Honourable
Court may permit.
-5-
December 8, 2016
DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X 1E2 Bruce Darlington (LSUC# 25310K) Tel: 416-365-3529 Fax: 416-369-5210 [email protected] Jennifer A. Whincup (LSUC# 60326W) Tel: 416-365-3425 Fax: 416-369-5240 [email protected] Lawyers for Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.
TO: Attached Service List
SERVICE LIST (as at October 7, 2016)
TO: THORNTON GROUT FINNIGAN LLP 100 Wellington Street West Suite 3200 P.O. Box 329, Toronto-Dominion Centre Toronto ON M5K 1K7 Fax: (416) 304-1313
Leanne M. Williams Tel: (416) 304-0060 Email: [email protected]
Asim Iqbal Tel: (416) 304-0595 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for BDO Canada Limited
AND TO: BDO CANADA LLP, BDO CANADA LTD 150 Caroline St. S., Suite 201 Waterloo, ON N2L 0A5 Fax: 1 (905) 570-0249 Michael Hanson Tel: 1 (519) 578-9610 Email: [email protected] Brad Newton Tel: 1 (905) 524-1008 Email: [email protected] The Court Appointed Receiver
- 2 -
AND TO: BENNETT JONES LLP Suite 3400 One First Canadian Place P.O. Box 130 Toronto ON M5X 1A4 Fax: (416) 863-1716
Lincoln Caylor Tel: (416) 863-1200 Email: [email protected]
Alan Gardner Email: [email protected]
Jonathan Bell Email: [email protected]
Joseph N. Blinick Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for the Plaintiffs in Court File No. CV-10-8597-00CL
AND TO: DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X IE2 Fax: (416) 365-7886
Bruce Darlington Tel: 416-365-3529 Email: [email protected]
Jennifer A. Whincup Tel: (416) 365-3425 Email: [email protected]
Kim Hamill Tel: (416) 369-5295 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for the Applicant/Respondent
- 3 -
AND TO: TORKIN MANES Barristers and Solicitors 151 Yonge Street Suite 1500 Toronto ON MSC 2W7 Fax: 1-888-587-9143
Jeffrey J. Simpson Tel: (416) 777-5413 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for HMT Holdings Inc. and Harbour Mortgage Corp.
AND TO: MINISTRY OF FINANCE Legal Services Branch 33 King Street West 6th Floor Oshawa ON LIH 8H5 Fax: (905) 436-4510
Kevin O’Hara Tel: (905) 433-6934 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: MINISTRY OF NATIONAL REVENUE c/o Department of Justice Canada Ontario Regional Office The Exchange Tower 130 King Street West Suite 3400, Box 36 Toronto ON M5X IK6 Fax: (416) 973-0810
Diane Winters Tel: (416) 973-3172 Email: [email protected]
Peter Zevenhuizen Tel: (416)952-8563 Email: peter [email protected]
Lawyers for Canada Revenue Agency
- 4 -
AND TO: RETIREMENT HOMES REGULATORY AUTHORITY Office of the Registrar 160 Eglinton Avenue East Fifth Floor Toronto ON M4P 3B5 Fax: (416) 487-1223
Heather Hogan Email: [email protected] John Risk Email: [email protected] Tel: (416) 440-3570
AND TO: RCAP LEASING INC. 5575 North Service Road Suite 300 Burlington ON L7L 6Ml Fax: (905) 639-1363
Tel: 1-866-239-1290 Ext. 7 Email: [email protected]
Secured Party
AND TO: GOLDMAN, SLOAN, NASH & HABER LLP Suite 1600 480 University A venue Toronto, ON MSG 1V2 Fax: (416) 597-3370 R. Brendan Bissell Tel.: (416) 597-6489 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for Sure Mortgage Capital Inc.
- 5 -
AND TO: KRONIS, ROTSZTAIN, MARGLES, CAPPEL LLP 1100 – 25 Sheppard Avenue West Toronto ON M2N 6S6 Fax: (416) 225-7214 Onofrio Ferlisi Tel: (416) 225-8750 Ext. 262 Email: [email protected] Solomon Khan Tel: (416) 225-8750 Ext. 358 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for The Bank of Nova Scotia
AND TO: MADORIN, SNYDER LLP 55 King Street West, 6th Floor P.O. Box 1234 Kitchener, ON N2G 4G9 Tim J. McGowan Tel: (519) 744-4491 Email: [email protected] Dawn E. Phillips-Brown Tel: (519)-744-4491 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: GOVERNMENT OF ONTARIO Legislative Bldg Queens Park Toronto, ON M7A 1A1 Lori Blaskavitch Tel: (416) 212-8888 Email: [email protected]
- 6 -
AND TO: MINISTRY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL Civil Law Division Civil Remedies for Illicit Activities Office (CRIA) 720 Bay Street 8th Floor Toronto ON M7A 2S9 Fax: (416) 314-3714 Gary Valiquette Tel: (416) 214-5881 Email: [email protected] Jennifer Malabar Tel: (416) 327-2932 Email: [email protected] Ronald Carr Tel: (416) 326-2704 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for the Attorney General of Ontario
AND TO: OLDFIELD, GREAVES, D’AGOSTINO P.O. Box 16580 172 King Street South Waterloo ON N2J 4X8 Fax: (519) 576-0131 Edward L. D’Agostino Tel: (519) 576-7200 Email: [email protected] Proposed Representative Counsel of EVH Residents
AND TO: GOWLINGS WLG LLP 50 Queen Street North Suite 1020, P.O. Box 2248 Kitchener ON N2H 6P4 Fax: (519) 571-5025 Ross F. Earnshaw Tel: (519) 575-7525 Email: [email protected]
- 7 -
AND TO: GOODMANS LLP Bay Adelaide Centre 333 Bay Street, Suite 3400 Toronto ON M5H 2S7 Fax: (416) 979-1234 Joe Latham Tel: (416) 597-4211 Email: [email protected] Jason Wadden Tel: (416) 597-5165 Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for Revera Inc.
AND TO: PROUSE, DASH & CROUCH LLP 50 Queen Street West Brampton ON L6X 4H3 Fax: (905) 866-5165 Dalkeith Palmer Tel: (905) 451-6610 Email: [email protected] Lawyers for Simarjeet Singh
AND TO: CITY OF KITCHENER Revenue Division 200 King Street West Ground Floor Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 Tel: (519) 741-2450
AND TO: 1459671 ONTARIO INC. Ajinderpal Bajaj 10 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4T5
AND TO: 1459672 ONTARIO INC. Rajesh Chowdhry 26 Daleridge Crescent Brampton ON L6P 2X6
- 8 -
AND TO: 1459673 ONTARIO INC. Inderpal S. Bajaj 97 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4P8
AND TO: Ajindrapal Singh 12 Celestial Court Brampton ON L7A 3R8
AND TO: Rajesh Chowdhry 26 Daleridge Crescent Brampton ON L6P 2X6
AND TO: Inderpal S. Bajaj 97 Professor’s Lake Parkway Brampton ON L6S 4P8
Email Service List
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
CREDITOR SERVICE LIST
TO: Riepert Salt & Supplies Inc. 66 Schaefer St. Waterloo, ON N2L 4C5 Shelley Riepert Tel: (519) 747-2708 Fax: (519) 747-5810 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Kitchener-Wilmot Hydro Inc.
301 Victoria St. S. Kitchener, ON N2G 4L2
Tel: (519) 745-4771 Fax: (519) 745-3631 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Culligan Water 427 Gage Avenue Unit 1 Kitchener ON N2M 5E1
Tel: (519) 744-2248 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Shoppers Home Health Care 1 Hespeler Road Cambridge ON N1R 8L4
Trisha Ward Tel: (519) 624-6020 Fax: (519) 624-0906 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Commercial Kitchen Repairs 92 Talbot Street Kitchener, ON N2M 2B1
Tel: (519) 588-4213 Email: [email protected]
- 2 -
AND TO: Fresh Start Foods Canada Ltd. 2705 Durante Way Milton ON L9T 5J1
Tel: (905) 878-9000 Fax: (905) 878-9010
AND TO: The Home Depot PO Box 675, Station D Scarborough ON M1R 5T4
Tel: 1-800-439-1523 Fax: 1-866-671-5926
AND TO: Information Network Systems 75 Northland Road Waterloo ON N2V 1Y8
Tel: (519) 746-0631 Fax: (519) 746-0854 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Nextsys Networking Inc. 668 Trillium Drive Unit 4 Kitchener ON N2R 1J3
Tel: (519) 885-8494 Fax: (519) 254-4386 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: On-Hold Marketing Inc. 2 East Beaver Creek Road Building 4a Richmond Hill ON L4B 2N3
Tel: 1-888-466-4653 Email: [email protected]
- 3 -
AND TO: Orkin Canada Corporation 5840 Falbourne Street Mississauga ON L5R 4B5
Krystle Russell Tel: (519) 623-5752 Fax: (519) 621-7435 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Progressive Waste Solutions Canada Inc. 139 Ardelt Avenue Kitchener ON N2C 2E1
Debbie Scheer Tel: (519) 745-8080 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Rogers P.O. Box 4100 Don Mills ON M3C 3N9
Tel: 1-888-764-3771 Fax: (647) 439-1419
AND TO: Share Canada Box 2212, 100 City Centre Drive Mississauga ON L5B 3C7
Tel: 1-800-665-7692 Fax: 1-800-563-8453 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Sweet Signatures Division of Shock-O-Lot Inc. 225 Labrador Dive Unit 2 Waterloo ON N2K 4M8
Samia Chalhoub Tel: (519) 747-4261 Email: [email protected]
AND TO: Tara Romain
Email: [email protected]
CAN: 23323147.1
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC. and
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO and
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Court File No: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE COMMERCIAL LIST
Proceeding commenced at Toronto
NOTICE OF MOTION OF EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X 1E2 Bruce Darlington (LSUC# 25310K) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3529 Fax: 416-369-5210 Jennifer A. Whincup (LSUC# 60326W) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3425 Fax: 416-369-5240 Lawyers for Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.
Tab 2
Court File No.: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIOSUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN:
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THESALE THEREOF (IN REM)
AFFIDAVIT OF BRUCE E. DARLINGTON(Sworn December 7, 2016)
Applicant
Applicant
Respondent
I, BRUCE E. DARLINGTON, of the City of Toronto, in the Province of Ontario, MAKE
OATH AND SAY:
1. I am a partner of the law firm of DLA Piper (Canada) LLP, lawyers for Emmanuel Village
Residences Inc. Accordingly, I have personal knowledge of the matters to which I hereinafter
depose, save and except where I have been provided with information by others. In the latter
case, I have indicated the source of the information and I believe it to be true, unless I state
otherwise herein.
-2-
2. I was called to the bar of the Province of Ontario in 1985, and specialize in the practice of
insolvency law and banking law. My standard hourly rate is $650.00. I am identified on the
invoices as BYD.
3. Jennifer A. Whincup (JQW) was called to the bar of the Province of Ontario in 2011 and
practices in the area of commercial litigation. Her standard hourly rate is $400.00.
4. Rose Meffe (RXM) is a paralegal employed by DLA Piper (Canada) LLP who practices in
the area of insolvency and restructuring. Her standard hourly rate is $250.00.
5. Jamie Mendelovitch (JIM) is a student-at-law at DLA Piper (Canada) LLP. His standard
hourly rate is $250.00.
6. Attached as Exhibit "A" to my affidavit is a copy of invoice number 1657146. The invoice
was issued on September 30, 2016 and covers fees and disbursements from August 31, 2016 to
September 29, 2016. The fees itemized on the invoice total $28,745.00 (exclusive of taxes and
disbursements). The total amount of the invoice, including disbursements and HST, is
$34,198.05.
7. Attached as Exhibit "B" to my affidavit is a copy of invoice number 1663794. The invoice
was issued on October 31, 2016 and covers fees and disbursements from September 1, 2016 to
October 29, 2016. The fees itemized on the invoice total $33,730.00 (exclusive of taxes and
disbursements). The total amount of the invoice, including disbursements and HST, is
$38,494.04.
8. Attached as Exhibit "C" to my affidavit is a copy of invoice number 1670989. The invoice
was issued on November 30, 2016 and covers fees and disbursements from September 30, 2016
to November 27, 2016. The fees itemized on the invoice total $13,550.00 (exclusive of taxes and
-3-
disbursements). The total amount of the invoice, including disbursements and HST, is
$15,327.74.
9. The total of the fees of the attached invoices is $76,025.00 exclusive of taxes and
disbursements, and $88,019.83inclusive of taxes and disbursements.
10. The average hourly rate of DLA Piper (Canada) LLP timekeepers on these invoices is
$481.17.
1 1. All of the time recorded on the Invoice and all of the disbursements were in fact incurred. I
believe that the Invoices are fair and reasonable in all of the circumstances.
12. To the best of my knowledge, the rates charged by DLA Piper (Canada) LLP throughout
the course of these proceedings are comparable to the rates charged by other law firms in the
Toronto market for the provision of similar services, and the rates charged by DLA Piper (Canada)
LLP for services rendered in similar proceedings.
13. I swear this affidavit in support of a motion for an order approving the fees and
disbursements of the Applicant's counsel and for no other or improper purpose.
SWORN BEFORE ME at the City of Toronto,in the Province of Ontario on December2016
ComMissid ier for Taking Affidavits, etc.\11
This is Exhibit "A" referred to in the Affidavit of Bruce Darlington, sworn December7, 2016
Comtnissioner for Taking Affidavits
DLA PIPER
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.Private and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastKitchener, ON N2A 4E1 Canada
Attention: Judy Hunking, Manager
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPSuite 6000, 1 First Canadian PlacePO Box 367, 100 King St WToronto ON M5X 1E2www.dlapiper.comT 416.365.3500F 416.365.7886
INVOICE NUMBER:FILE NUMBER:BUSINESS NUMBER:FROM THE OFFICE OF:DIRECT LINE:
September 30, 2016
165714618275-00001REG # 110 152 824Bruce E. Darlington416.365.3529
For Professional Services rendered and disbursements advanced through September 30, 2016.
Our Fees:
Total Disbursements:
Total HST:
Total Current Invoice Due: CAD $
28,745.00
1,547.16
3,905.89
34,198.05
Please note that this account is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
Remittance Advice:Cheque Payments To:DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Canadian dollar Wire Payments To:DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Invoice No: 1657146
Suite 6000, 1 First Canadian Place Bank: Royal Bank of Canada File No: 18275-00001PO Box 367, 100 King Street West Main Branch - 200 Bay Street, Main FloorToronto ON M5X 1E2 Canada Toronto ON M5J 2J5 Canada
Account: 1423136 Amount: CAD $ 34,198.05Transit #: 00002Institution #: 003Swift #: ROYCCAT2
Please return remittance advicewith cheque.
ABA #: 021000021Please Indicate Invoice Number
DLA PIPEREmmanuel Village Residence Inc.Private and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastKitchener, ON N2A 4E1 Canada
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPSuite 6000, 1 First Canadian PlacePO Box 367, 100 King St WToronto ON M5X 1E2www.dlapiper.comT 416.365.3500F 416.365.7886
Attention: Judy Hunking, Manager
Our File No: 18275-00001
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.Re: Revera Inc., Harbour Equity Capital Date: September 30, 2016
Invoice Number: 1657146
For Professional Services rendered and disbursements advanced through September 30, 2016.
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
08/31/16 BYD Reviewing email message from J. Malabar; 0.40 260.00discussing response and factum with J.Whincup;
08/31/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails re 8.90 3,560.00sealing bank records; engaging in call with J.Malabar and G. Valiquette re request to sealbank records; drafting and revising factum readministration charge; reviewing research of J.Mandelovich re administration charge;engaging in call with J. Wadden re inadvertentmissing schedule in approval and vestingorder;
08/31/16 BYD Reviewing and replying to email message from 0.40 260.00J. Latham; reviewing email message from L.Williams; reviewing email message from D.Phillips-Brown;
09/01/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowan 3.30 2,145.00re factum; reviewing email message from L.Blaskavitch re amended application; draftingemail message to J. Whincup re fees;engaging in discussions with J. Whincup refactum; reviewing email messages from J.Whincup and L. Williams re broker's fees;exchanging email messages with A. lqbal;reviewing email message from G. Jaffe;reviewing email message from L. Blaskavitchand memorandum of law; reviewing emailmessage from G. Valiquette; reviewing emailmessage from B. Bissell and Sure factum;reviewing email message from A. lqbal andreceiver's report;
09/02/16 BYD Engaging in discussions with J. Whincup; 1.90 1,235.00engaging in telephone conference with J.
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1657146
Page: 2
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
Malabar, G. Valiquette, L. Williams, M.Hanson, E. D'Agostino and J. Whincup;engaging in telephone call with M. Hanson;
09/02/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conversation with J. 0.20 130.00Bell;
09/02/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Williams re 0.20 130.00closing agenda; reviewing email message fromH. Hogan;
09/02/16 JIM Reading, summarizing and charting cases 2.80 700.00cited in the Attorney General's Book ofAuthorities in preparation for administrationcharge motion;
09/03/16 J1M Reviewing and summarizing case law cited in 2.00 500.00Attorney General Memorandum of Law;
09/05/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L. 0.40 260.00Blaskavitch, B. Bissell, L. Williams, J. Bell andG. Valiquette;
09/06/16 BYD Preparation for and attendance in court re 3.50 2,275.00various motions;
09/06/16 BYD Reviewing draft closing agenda; 0.40 260.00
09/07/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowan 0.40 260.00re letter to Justice Newbould; drafting emailmessage to T. McGowan re message to AGand outstanding accounts;
09/08/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowan 3.40 2,210.00re EVH; Reviewing email message from T.McGowan; reviewing letter from E. D'Agostino; engaging in telephone conferencewith G. Jaffe, J. Ehrlich, S. Moore, I. Barkin, L.Williams, T. McGowan, and J. Whincup;drafting email message to J. Malabar and G.Valiquette re EVH; engaging in telephone callwith T. McGowan and J. Whincup; engaging intelephone call with L. Williams re distributions;
09/08/16 BYD Reviewing email message from G. Jaffe and L. 0.40 260.00Williams; reviewing email messages from T.McGowan and D. Phillips-Brown and amendedletter to Justice Newbould; providingcomments;
09/09/16 BYD Reviewing email message from G. Jaffe re 0.80 520.00RHRA: exchanging email messages with J.Malabar re EVH; reviewing email messagefrom E. D'Agostino; Exchanging emailmessages with G Valiquette re timing;reviewing email message from J. Erlich;
OLA PIPER•
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1657146
Page: 3
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
exchanging email messages with L. Williams;
09/12/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with G.Valiquette; reviewing endorsement reSeptember 6 motion; exchanging emailmessages with T. McGowan and D. PHillip-Brown; reviewing email message from J.Whincup re scheduling motion;
0.60 390.00
09/12/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conference with L.Williams, B, Newton, M. Hanson and J.Whincup; engaging in telephone conferencewith T. McGowan and J. Whincup;
1.60 1,040.00
09/13/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Williamsand payout statements from HMT and Sure;
0.20 130.00
09/14/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowanand amended letter;
0.20 130.00
09/14/16 BYD Reviewing email message and draft letter fromT. McGowan re related company obligationsand providing comments; reviewing emailmessage from J. Whincup; exchanging emailmessages with T. McGowan; exchangingemail messages with L. Williams;
0.70 455.00
09/15/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre conference call; engaging in telephoneconversation with J. Latham re EVH;discussions with J. Whincup;
0.50 325.00
09/16/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre agenda call;
0.20 130.00
09/18/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with L. Williamsre fees approval motion;
0.20 130.00
09/19/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with E.D'Agostino and G. Valiquette re EVH call;
0.30 195.00
09/19/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Whincup,L. Williams and T. McGowan;
0.30 195.00
09/20/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Ehrlich, L.Williams, R. Weber, S. Moore and T.McGowan; reviewing BDO motion record;
0.50 325.00
09/21/16 BYD Reviewing AGO motion record re BennettJones motion; reviewing AGO motion record reEVR motion; drafting email message to J.Whincup; reviewing email message from G.Jaffe;
0.50 325.00
09/21/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupand swearing fees affidavit;
0.30 195.00
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1657146
Page: 4
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
09/21/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from T. McGowanand S. Moore;
0.10 65.00
09/22/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowan;reviewing email message from J. Ehrlich andupdated agenda; engaging in telephoneconference call with Goodmans, TGF andMadorin Snyder re closing agenda; reviewingstatement of fact and law from AGO; engagingin telephone conversation with L. Williams;engaging in telephone conversation with T.McGowan;
1.30 845.00
09/23/16 BYD Exchanging email messages and engaging intelephone conversation with J. Latham;
0.30 195.00
09/23/16 BYD Reviewing email message from J. Malabar reletter to Justice Newbould; discussingmessage with J. Whincup; reviewing emailmessages from J. Whincup, L. Malabar, D.Phillips-Brown and T. McGowan; reviewingemail message from G. Jaffe and reply from T.McGowan; engaging in telephone call withCommercial List office and J. Whincup;reviewing draft factum;
1.10 715.00
09/25/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conversation with J.Latham re AG's motion; engaging in telephoneconference with T. McGowan, D. Phillips-Brown and J. Whincup re AG's motion;
0.90 585.00
09/25/16 BYD Reviewing AG's amended motion material reamendment to Forfeiture Application;exchanging email messages with L. Williams;drafting email message to J. Latham;
0.40 260.00
09/26/16 BYD Attending on motion re fees, amendment toPreservation application, distribution toBennett Jones clients and claims process;engaging in telephone conversation with D.Phillips-Brown and J. Whincup re courtappearance;
4.80 3,120.00
09/27/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from G. Valiquette,A. lqbal, E. D'Agostino and L. Williams re EVHcall; reviewing email message from L.Blaskavitch and consent re PreservationOrder; exchanging email messages with J.Whincup; reviewing email messages from L.Latham; reviewing email message from L.Williams; reviewing email message from H.Hogan; reviewing email message from D.Phillips-Brown; reviewing email message fromA. lqbal;
0.80 520.00
DLA PIPER
Date Professional Description
09/28/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre AGO request for consent; discussing 9:30appearance with J. Whincup;
09/28/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L.Blaskavitch, J, Latham, L. Williams, T.McGowan, 0. Ferlisi re request for consent toPreservation Order; reviewing email messagesfrom G. Jaffe, L. Williams and T. McGowan repost-closing adjustments; reviewing emailmessage from G. Jaffe re non-competeagreement;
09/29/16 BYD Attending 9:30 conference re HMT and Surecounsel fees; discussing distribution processand need for Preservation Order with G.Valiquette; exchanging email messages with T.
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1657146
Page: 5
Hours Amount
0.20 130.00
0.40 260.00
4.10 2,665.00
McGowan; reviewing email message from T.McGowan re J. Hunking's position; reviewingand replying to email message from L.Blaskavitch; engaging in telephoneconversations with J. Latham; engaging intelephone conversations with A. lqbal;reviewing email message from G. Valiquette;engaging in telephone conferences with T.McGowan, D. Sullivan-Brown and J. Whincup;engaging in telephone call with J. Latham;engaging in telephone conferences with J.Hunking, T. McGowan, D. Sullivan-Brown andJ. Whincup; engaging in telephone call with J.Latham; engaging in telephone call with A.lqbal; drafting email message to J. Latham;
09/29/16 BYD Participating in telephone conference with G. 0.20 130.00Valiquette, E. D'Agostino, T. McGowan and M.Hanson;
09/29/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Latham; 0.30 195.00exchanging email messages with T.McGowan;
09/29/16 BYD Reviewing email message from G. Jaffe and 0.20 130.00updated closing agenda; reviewing andreplying to email messages from T. McGowanre closing mechanics;
Total Taxable Hours and Fees: 50.60 $ 28,745.00
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES SUMMARY
Professional Rate Hours Amount
Bruce E. Darlington 650.00 36.90 23,985.00
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1657146
Page: 6
Professional Rate Hours Amount
Jennifer A. Whincup 400.00 8.90 3,560.00
Jamie Mendelovitch 250.00 4.80 1,200.00
Total Fees: 28,745.00
DISBURSEMENTS
Non-Taxable Disbursements
Description
Filing Fees 120.00Minister of Finance 127.00Total Non-Taxable Disbursements: 247.00
Taxable Disbursements
Description
Postage 19.39Binding 47.76Courier 317.46Filing Fees 90.00
Long Distance Telephone 35.95
Photocopying 609.60
Computer Search - WestlaweCarswell 180.00
Total Taxable Disbursements: 1,300.16
BILL SUMMARY
REG # 110 152 824
This is our account.
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Per:
Our Fees: $ 28,745.00
Total Disbursements: $ 1,547.16
Total HST: $ 3,905.89
Total Current Invoice Due: CAD $ 34,198.05
Bruce E. Darlington
Please note that this account is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
This is Exhibit "B" referred to in the Affidavit of Bruce Darlington, sworn December7, 2016
mairssioner for Taking Affidavit
DLA PIPER
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.Private and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastKitchener, ON N2A 4E1 Canada
Attention: Judy Hunking, Manager
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPSuite 6000, 1 First Canadian PlacePO Box 367, 100 King St WToronto ON M5X 1E2www.dlaplper.comT 416.365.3500F 416.365.7886
INVOICE NUMBER:FILE NUMBER:BUSINESS NUMBER:FROM THE OFFICE OF:DIRECT LINE:
October 31, 2016
166379418275-00001REG # 110 152 824Bruce E. Darlington416.365.3529
For Professional Services rendered and disbursements advanced through October 30, 2016.
Our Fees:
Total Disbursements:
Total HST:
Total Current Invoice Due:
$ 33,730.00
335.49
4,428.55
CAD $ 38,494.04
Please note that this account is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
Remittance Advice:
Cheque Payments To:DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Canadian dollar Wire Payments To:DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Invoice No: 1663794
Suite 6000, 1 First Canadian Place Bank: Royal Bank of Canada File No: 18275-00001PO Box 367, 100 King Street West Main Branch - 200 Bay Street, Main FloorToronto ON M5X 1E2 Canada Toronto ON M5J 2J5 Canada
Account: 1423136 Amount: CAD $ 38,494.04Transit #: 00002Institution #: 003Swift #: ROYCCAT2
Please return remittance advicewith cheque.
ABA #: 021000021Please Indicate Invoice Number
DLA PIPER
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.Private and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastKitchener, ON N2A 4E1 Canada
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPSuite 6000, 1 First Canadian PlacePO Box 367, 100 King St WToronto ON M5X 1E2www.dlapiper.comT 416.365.3500F 416.365.7886
Attention: Judy Hunking, Manager
Our File No: 18275-00001
Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.Re: Revera Inc., Harbour Equity Capital Date: October 31, 2016
Invoice Number: 1663794
For Professional Services rendered and disbursements advanced through October 30, 2016.
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
09/01/16 JQW Reviewing fourth report of the Receiver; 2.70 1,080.00reviewing factum of Sure Mortgage CapitalInc.; engaging in extensive email exchangewith counsel to the purchaser re motions forSeptember 6, 2016; reviewing memorandum oflaw of the Attorney General for Ontario;drafting and revising factum re administrationcharge increase; conducting legal research readministration charge increase; consideringtreatment of broker's charge; drafting andrevising motion materials;
09/02/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails re 5.20 2,080.00upcoming motion on Tuesday, September 6,2016, including from RHRA, purchaser, andreceiver; reviewing motion materials ofplaintiffs in civil action; reviewing extensivebrief of authorities of the Attorney General ofOntario;
09/06/16 JQW Preparing for and attending motion sealing of 7.10 2,840.00transcript and banking record of J. Hunking,motion of the Plaintiffs in the civil action,payment of Sure Mortgage on closing,increasing administration charge andamending approval and vesting order;reviewing and responding to emails re closingagenda update and closing items;
09/07/16 JQW Engaging in email exchange re dealing with 0.60 240.00property;
09/08/16 JQW Engaging in call with parties to closing agenda; 1.20 480.00reviewing and responding to emails re letter toreport details of payments to Aldis consultingto Newbould, J.; engaging in call with D.Phillips Brown, T. McGowan and B. Darlington
DLA PIPER
Date Professional Description
re payments to Aldis; engaging in emailexchange re interest in EVH and impact onclosing of the sale of EVR;
09/09/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to emails from G.Valiquette and J. Malabar re lack ofinstructions on the part of the Attorney Generalfor Ontario, and the concerns about the lack ofinstructions; reviewing closing agenda items;
09/11/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails reclosing agenda calls and materials;
09/12/16 JQW Preparing for and attending motion beforeJustice Newbould; reporting on results ofmotion to D. Phillips Brown and T. McGowan;engaging in conference call with D. PhillipsBrown and T. McGowan re claims process;engaging in discussions re payments to Aldisand return of September payments; engagingin call with A. lqbal, L. Williams and B.Darlington re claims process in receivership ofEVR;
09/13/16 JQW Reviewing account statements re mortgagestatements; reviewing and responding toseveral emails re outstanding accounts andother charges owing to EVR;
09/14/16 JQW Reviewing and commenting on letter to L.Williams re indebtedness of related companiesof EVR; considering issues of indebtedness;reviewing and responding to several emails reinformation for letter to receiver's counsel reindebtedness of related companies;
09/15/16 JQW Engaging in conference call with all parties reclosing agenda and outstanding items;
09/16/16 JQW Providing update to B. Darlington re closingagenda call; reviewing and responding toemails re closing agenda;
09/19/16 JQW Drafting and revising order re endorsement ofNewbould J.; reviewing affidavit from T.McGowan re motion record for fee approval;revising materials on fee approval motion;engaging in email exchange re treatment ofEVH and its relationship to EVR; reviewingdraft closing documents;
09/20/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to emails reconfirmation of payments to Aldis consulting;confirming that payments to Aldis consultinghave ceased and the September payment
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 2
Hours Amount
0.80 320.00
0.50 200.00
5.20 2,080.00
1.60 640.00
2.70 1,080.00
0.80 320.00
0.60 240.00
2.80 1,120.00
3.40 1,360.00
DLA PIPER
Date Professional Description
returned; reviewing motion record of thereceiver; reviewing and responding to emailsre closing agenda items;
09/21/16 JQW Reviewing affidavit of B. Darlington; reviewingthe responding motion record, book ofauthorities and factum of the Attorney Generalfor Ontario; reviewing and responding toseveral emails re responding motion materials;reviewing emails re service of materials on allparties;
09/22/16 JQW Revising and finalizing motion record forservice;
09/23/16 JQW Engaging in email exchange with J. Malabar reinquiries related to time entries subject of thefee approval motion; requesting time entriesthat the Crown identified as problematic fromJ. Malabar; drafting factum re approval of fees;conducting research re factors courts use toassess the reasonableness of fees in the caseof a receiver and its counsel and how thatmight be applied to a debtor company who hasdriven the sale process; reviewing statement oflaw of the crown re fee approval motion relatedto time spent in the course of the sale of EVR;
09/25/16 JQW Preparing for motion to amend notice ofapplication in forfeiture application rearguments related to the impediment that theamendments would cause to closing of thesale; preparing for motion to approve fees ofcounsel to EVR; engaging in teleconferencewith D. Phillips-Brown, T. McGowan and B.Darlington re implications of amendments tonotice of application to the closing of the sale;
09/26/16 JQW Preparing for motion to amend notice ofapplication in forfeiture application and makingarguments related to the impediment that theamendments would cause to closing of thesale; preparing for motion to approve fees ofcounsel to EVR; attending several motions andmaking arguments before Justice Newbould reapproval of fees related to the sale of EVR andimpact of amendments to notice of applicationon the closing of the sale transaction;engaging in teleconference with D. Phillips-Brown re update on motions; arranging forissuance and entrance of order fromSeptember 6, 2016 motion; engaging indiscussions with L. Williams and A. lqbal resale process; arranging for delivery of order to
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 3
Hours Amount
0.80 320.00
1.20 480.00
3.80 1,520.00
4.10 1,640.00
8.50 3,400.00
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 4
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
the service list; considering outcomes ofmotions and potential next steps;
09/27/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails re 2.90 1,160.00email from L. Blaskavitch enclosing draft orderfor amendments to Notice of Application andconsidering the implication of said order on theclosing of the sale of EVR; considering draftpreservation order and impact on the closing ofthe sale of EVR; engaging in telephone callwith H. Hogan re issues relating to trust fundsof EVH residents, if they exist; receivingconfirmation from D. Phillips-Brown that nosuch trust funds exist; reviewing andresponding to emails from 0. Ferlisi reoutstanding legal fees owing to securedcreditors of EVR; considering impact ofpreservation order on closing of the sale;
09/27/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails;
09/29/16 JQW Engaging in several conference calls with B.Darlington, J. Latham, D. Phillips-Brown, andT. McGowan re results of motion, closing ofthe sale and other issues arising in advance ofclosing; reviewing and responding to emails represervation motion for ancillary property anditems; considering whether a decision will beforthcoming from Newbould, J.; engaging inconference call with D. Phillips-Brown, B.Darlington and J. Hunking re non-compete andother closing documents to be signed by J.Hunking;
09/30/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conversation with J.Hunking, T. McGowan and D. Phillips-Brown;drafting email message to J. Latham andreviewing reply; drafting email message to A.lqbal;
09/30/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conference with allparties re final closing matters;
09/30/16 BYD Reviewing email message from J. Hunking reEVH; exchanging email messages with J.Hunking and T. McGowan re alternativesolutions re EVH; drafting email message toAGO and E. D'Agostino for J. Hunking'sreview; reviewing email messages from G.Jaffe L. Williams and M. Hanson re status ofclosing; exchanging email messages with J.Hunking re AGO request for waiver;
10/03/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Blaskavitch
0.20 80.00
2.10 840.00
0.50 325.00
0.40 260.00
1.20 780.00
0.40 260.00
DLA PIPER
Date Professional Description
re service list; reviewing J. Newbould decision;discussing with J. Whincup; exchanging emailmessages with L. Williams;
10/03/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowanre EVH; reviewing email message from J.Hunking re EVH; reviewing email messagefrom L. Williams re confirmation of closing;
10/03/16 JQW Review and respond to emails from L.Blaskavitch re preservation motion;considering impact of preservation in thecontext of the larger sale closing and postclosing obligations; engaging in extensiveemail exchange with B. Darlington re serviceissues; arranging conference call with D.Phillips Brown and T. McGowan re next stepsin closing sale; reviewing endorsement ofJustice Newbould and arranging fortranscription of endorsement; consideringoutstanding motion as to the approval of fees;
10/04/16 JQW Engaging in conference call with D. PhillipsBrown and T. McGowan re claims process andpost-closing obligations; review and respond toemails from J. Malabar and G. Valiquette recontinued representation;
10/04/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conference with J.Whincup, T. McGowan and D. Phillips-Brownre AGO requests for consent to PreservationOrder and releases, closing matters andaccounts;
10/04/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Malabar;exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre replies;
10/04/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with M. Hansonand T. McGowan re creditor lists;
10/04/16 BYD Drafting email message to G. Valiquette and E.D'Agostino re EVH; reviewing reply from E.D'Agostino;
10/05/16 JQW Reviewing materials from L. Blaskovitchregarding preservation motion; engaging inemail exchange with D. Phillips Brownregarding J. Hunking; sending documents to L.Scott re representation of J. Hunking; receivingand considering email from R. Williams atcommercial list;
10/06/16 JQW Engaging in calls to commercial list reupcoming motion date; engaging in extensive
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 5
Hours Amount
0.40 260.00
0.10 40.00
2.10 840.00
0.40 260.00
0.30 195.00
0.30 195.00
0.20 130.00
2.10 840.00
0.90 360.00
DLA PIPER
Date Professional Description
email exchange with parties re motion datesand orders for next motion date; engaging inemail exchange with D. Phillips Brown and T.McGowan re personal representation of J.Hunking;
10/06/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre status;
10/06/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Lathamand J. Whincup re October 11th motion;
10/07/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L.Blaskavitch, E. D'Agostino, G. Valiquette andJ. Whincup re October 18th motion;exchanging email messages with J. Whincup;
10/07/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from D. Phillips-Brown, J. Whincup L. Blaskavitch and T.McGowan re October 11th motion; reviewingemail message from L. Blaskavitch re EVHorder; reviewing email message from E.D'Agostino;
10/07/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to email from L.Blaskavitch re motion not proceeding onOctober 11; reviewing and responding toseveral emails re draft orders circulated by L.Blaskavitch; reviewing draft orders;considering position on draft orders;
10/11/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L. Blaskavitchand J. Whincup; discussing October 18thmotions with J. Whincup;
10/11/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L.Blaskavitch, L. Williams, D. Phillips-Brown;exchanging email messages with J. Whincup;reviewing email message from G. Valiquette;reviewing email messages from J. Whincupand D. Phillips-Brown and reply from G.Valiquette;
10/11/16 RXM Receiving fax from Prouse Dash & Crouch LLPwith Notice of Appearance, scanning andsaving same; attending to prepare and sendemail to B. Darlington, J. Whincup and K.Hamill with fax from Prouse Dash & CrouchLLP and Notice e of Appearance;
10/12/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L.Blaskavitch, J. Whincup. T. McGowan, D.Phillips-Brown and L. Williams; reviewing emailmessage from M. Hanson and replying;
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 6
Hours Amount
0.10 65.00
0.20 130.00
0.40 260.00
0.30 195.00
0.70 280.00
0.40 260.00
0.40 260.00
0.20 50.00
0.30 195.00
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 7
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
10/13/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincup, 0.20 130.00D. Phillips-Brown and T. McGowan;
10/13/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from L. Blaskavitch 0.30 195.00and L. Williams; exchanging email messageswith J. Whincup;
10/14/16 BYD Reviewing email message from D. Naymark; 1.00 650.00engaging in telephone conference with T.McGowan, D. Phillips-Brown and J. Whincupre October 18th motions; reviewing emailmessages from D. Phillips-Brown and T.McGowan;
10/14/16 BYD Reviewing email message from G. Valiquette 0.20 130.00and L. Blaskavitch;
10/14/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Hunking; 0.20 130.00
10/17/16 BYD Reviewing email message from J. Whincup 0.20 130.00and draft preservation order' reviewing CivilRemedies Act and replying to J. Whincup;
10/18/16 BYD Attending at court re AGO's motions; engaging 1.80 1,170.00in telephone conference with T. McGowan andJ. Whincup;
10/18/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Whincup 0.30 195.00and T. McGowan re court appearance;reviewing email messages from A. lqbal, J.Malabar, L. Williams, M. Hanson and G.Valiquette;
10/21/16 BYD Reviewing email message L. Blaskavitch and 0.30 195.00amended notice of application; reviewing emailmessage from A. lqbal; exchanging emailmessages with J. Whincup;
10/26/16 BYD Reviewing email message from T. McGowan 0.90 585.00re waiver and mediation; engaging intelephone conference with M. Hanson, L.Williams, A. lqbal, T. McGowan, D. Phillips-Brown and J. Whincup re mediation; reviewingemail messages from A. lqbal re Harbour legalfees; reviewing email message from D.Phillips-Brown re mediation;
10/28/16 BYD Reviewing email message from E. 0.20 130.00D'Augostino;
10/29/16 BYD Drafting email message to T. McGowan re 0.20 130.00court appearance on November 1;
Total Taxable Hours and Fees: 76.90 $ 33,730.00
DLA PIPER
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES SUMMARY
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1663794
Page: 8
Professional Rate Hours Amount
Bruce E. Darlington 650.00 12.00 7,800.00
Jennifer A. Whincup 400.00 64.70 25,880.00
Rose Meffe 250.00 0.20 50.00
Total Fees: $ 33,730.00
DISBURSEMENTS
Taxable Disbursements
Description
Binding
Courier
Long Distance Telephone
Photocopying
Total Taxable Disbursements:
BILL SUMMARY
REG # 110 152 824
This is our account.
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Per:
30.00
250.31
46.18
9.00
335.49
Our Fees:
Total Disbursements:
Total HST:
Total Current Invoice Due:
Bruce E. Darlington
CAD $
33,730.00
335.49
4,428.55
38,494.04
Please note that this account is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
This is Exhibit "C" referred to in the Affidavit of Bruce Darlington, sworn December7, 2016
Commissioner for Taking Affidavits
Emmanuel Viliace Residence IncPrivate and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastKitchener, ON N2A 4E1 Canada
Attention: Judy Hunking, Manager
DLA Piper iCanadal LLP
Suite 6000, 1 First Canadian PlacePO Box 367, 100 K,no St W
Toronto ON M5X 1E2www.dlapiper.comT 416.365 3500F 416 365 7886
INVOICE NUMBERFILE NUMBER!BUSINESS NUMBERFROM THE OFFICE OFDIRECT LINE
November 30, 2016
167098918275-00001REG # 110 152 824Btuce E Dar ington416 365.3529
For Profess Dial Serv4es rendered and d'sb-Jrsements advanced throuon November 29. 2016.
Our Fees
Total Disbursements:
Total HST:
Total Current Invoice Due:
S 13:550 00
S 14.38
S 1.763.36
CAD S 15,327.74
Please note that this account is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
Remittance Advice:Cheque Payments To:
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPCanadian dollar Wire Payments To: Invoice No:
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP1670989
Suite 6000. 1 F tst Canadian Race Bank. Royal Bank of Canada File No 18275-00001PC Box 367 100 King Street West Main Branch - 200 Bay Street, Main FloorToronto ON M5X 1E2 Canaca Terontc ON M5J 2J5 Canada
Account. 1423136 Amount. CAD $ 15,327.74Transit # 00002I nstitution # 003
DLA Piper (Canada) LLPSuite 6C00, 1 First Canadian PtacePO Box 367. 100 Kira STToronto ON M5X 1 E2www,diapiper.comT 416.365.3500F 416.365.7886
Emmanuei Village Residence Inc,Private and Confidential1250 Weber St. EastK:',.c'nener ON N2A 4E1 Canada
Attention: Judy plunking, Manager
Our File No: 18275-00001
Emmanuel Wage Residence IncRe: Revere Inc.. Harbour Equity Cap tai Date: November 30. 2016
Invoice Number: 1670989
For Professional Services rendered and disbursements advanced through November 29, 2016
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
Date Professional Description
09/30/16 JQW Reviewing and considering endorsement ofJustice Newbould regarding payment ofsecured creditors: engaging in extensive emailexcnange regarding the same andconsideration of secured creditors not inattendance; engaging in extensive emailexchange regarding closing: reviewing wireinformation aid transaction approvals:reviewing waivers provided by J. Malabar;
10/11/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to several emails redraft orders for use on subsequent motion;reviewing orders; discussing orderamendments with B Darlington, D. PhillipsBrown and T. McGowan;
10/13/16 JQW
10/13!15 JQVV
10/14/16 JQW
Reviewing and responding to several emails rerevisions to orders for use on October 18motion date:
Rev:ewino andlres:pono:ng to several ernailsrevisions to enders 'or ..se on October
ca:e
Reviewing motion record and orders of theAttorney General, engaging in email exchangewith D. Phillips-Brown re payroll examinationby the Canada Revenue Agency; engaging incall with J. Latham re payroll examination andmeeting with CRA; reviewing and consideringvarious amendments to orders; engaging in
conference call with D. Phillips Brown, T.McGowan and B. Darlington:
10/18/16 JCAN Preparing for and attending motion beforeJ ustice Newbould: arranging for issuing and
Hours Amount
2.40 960.00
1.50 600.00
1.20 480.00
0.80 320 CO
4 70 1,880.00
3.60 1,440.00
PERrLADate Professional Description
entering of court orders; pulling materials fromthe Court file for use on motion to approvefees;
10/20/16 JQW Engaging 'n emai, exchange re consent toforfet..re appications and results on claimsprocess.
10/21/16 JQW - Reviewing and responding to several emails:
10/27/16 JQW Engaging .n conference call re court orderedmediation :nciudng 6VR's role rn any claimsprocess
10/31/16 JQW Engaging in call with T. McGowan and B.Darlington re claims process participation ofEVR and cooperation moving forward; makingnotes re the same, receiving message fromCommercial List re change of time formediation; sending email to service list rechange of time:
10/31/16 BYD Engaging in telephone conference with T.McGowan and J. Whincup re attendancetomorrow; exchanging email messages with L.Williams.
11/01/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with J. Whincupre call from D. Naymark:
11/0.2/16 JQW Reviewing draft forfeiture order circulated by L.Blaskavitch: engaging in email exchange withB. Darlington and L. Williams re impact on saleand transfer of assets:
11/02/16 BYD Reviewing email messages. draft orders andendorsements from L. Blaskavitch;
11102116 BYD Exchanging email messages with T.McGowan.
11/02/16 BYD Reviewing email messaae from L. Blaskavitchand draft order; drafting email messages to L.Williams, A. lqbal. M. Hanson. B. Newton. T.McGowan and J. Whincup:
11/02/16 JQW Attending chambers appointment before J.Newbould: retrieving materials for his Honourrelated to the approval of fees anddisbursements:
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1670989
Page: 2
Hours Amount
1.40 560.00
0 10 40.00
0.50 200.00
0.80 320.00
0.50 325.00
0.20 130.00
0.30 120.00
0.20 130.00
0.10 65.00
0.30 195.00
4.10 1,640.00
1 1/03/16 JQW Reviewing and responding to order provided 0.90 360.00by L. Blaskavitch and concerns it raises withsale process;
',1/03/16 BYD Reviewing email message from J. Whincup 0.60 390 00
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001Invoice: 1670989
Page: 3
Date Professional Description Hours Amount
and proposec response to AGO: providingcomments re proposed response to AGO-reviewing reply from G. Valiquette; exchangingemail messages with A. lqbal; reviewing emailmessage from M. Hanson;
11/04/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Biaskavitch 0.20 130.00and Order re EVH;
11108/16 BYD Reviewing email message from G. Jaffe re 0 10 65.00dosing adjustments-
11/15/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Williams, J. 0.20 130.00Bell and J. Malabar:
11115/16 JQW Engaging :n emal exchange re settng data t- 0 40 160.00next motor.
11/16/16 JQW Engaging .n emal exchange with B Darlington 2 10 840.00re issues raised by order for forfeiture in lightof sale close period, drafting response to allparties re the same;
11/16/16 BYD Reviewing email messages from J. Malabar 0.20 130.0Cand L. Williams;
1 1/16/16 BYD Reviewing draft email message from J. 0.50 325.00Whincup; engaging in telephone conversationwith L. Williams; engaging in discussions withJ. Whincup re court attendance: reviewingemail message from J. Bell and G. Valiquette;
11/22/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with M. Hanson 0.20 130.00re Administration Charge;
1122116 BYD Exchanging erne messages voth L. Williams: 0_30 195.00
11/23/16 BYD Reviewing email message from L. Williams 0.30 195.00and preliminary summary of claims;
1 1/23116 JQW Re:rievirg letter to RHRA for J. Erlich re final 0.30 120.00closing rnatena:s.
1 1/25/16 BYD Attending in Chambers re claims process; draft 0.60 390.00email message re court appearance to T.McGowan and D. Phillips-Brown;
1 -./25i16 BYO Drafting ema I message re court attendance: 0.60 390.00reviewing email messages from. J. BVmck. JMalabar and M. Hanson:
11/27/16 BYD Exchanging email messages with T 0 30 195.0C
McGowan;
Total Taxable Hours and Fees: 30.50 S 13,550.00
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES SUMMARY
DLA PIPER
Matter: 18275-00001IrNote: 1670989
Pace: 4
Professional Rate Hours Amount
Bruce E. Darlington 650.00 5.40 3,510.00
Jern;fer A Wrjrcup 400.00 25 10 10.040.00
Total Fees: 13,550.00
DISBURSEMENTS
Taxable Disbursements
Description
Long Distance Telephone 14.38Total Taxable Disbursements: S 14.38
BILL SUMMARY
REG # 110 152 824
This is our account.
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP
Pe-
Our Fees:
Total Disbursements:
Total HST.
Total Current Invoice Due:
S 13,550 00
S 14.38
S 1,763 36
CAD S 15,327.74
Please note that this ccount is payable on receipt. If not paid within 30 days from the invoice date, interestat the rate of prime plus 2% per annum will be charged from the invoice date.
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
and
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
and
1250 WEBER STREET EAST
Cou
rt Fil
e No
:CV-
16-1
1424
-00C
L
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
COMMERCIAL LIST
PROCEEDING COMMENCED AT
TORONTO
AFFIDAVIT OF BRUCE DARLINGTON
(SWORN DECEMBER 7, 2016)
DLA PIPER (CANADA) AL
P
Bar
rist
ers & Solicitors
1 First Canadian Place
100 King Street West, Suite 6000
P.O. Box 367
Toronto ON M5X 1E2
Bruce Dar
ling
ton (LSUC# 25310K)
bruce.darlington@dlapipercom
Tel
: 416-365-3529
Fax:
416-369-5210
Jennifer A. Whincup (LSUC# 60326W)
jenn
ifer
whin
cup@
dlap
iper
com
Tel
: 416-365-3425
Fax
: 416-369-5240
Lawyers for Emmanuel Vil
lage
Residence Inc.
Tab 3
Tab 4
Court File No. CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
COMMERCIAL LIST
THE HONOURABLE
JUSTICE NEWBOULD
)
)
)
WEDNESDAY, THE 14th
DAY OF DECEMBER, 2016
B E T W E E N:
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Applicant
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Applicant
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THE SALE THEREOF (IN REM)
Respondent
ORDER
THIS MOTION made by Emmanuel Village Residence Inc. (“EVR”) for an order
approving the fees of counsel to EVR, being DLA Piper (Canada) LLP and Madorin,
Snyder LLP was heard this day at 330 University Avenue, Toronto, Ontario.
ON READING the Motion Record of EVR, including the fee affidavits of Bruce
Darlington and Tim McGowan, each sworn December 7, 2016, and on hearing the
submissions of counsel for the Company, the Receiver, Plaintiffs in Court File No. CV-
10-8597-00CL, and the Attorney General of Ontario (“AGO”), no one appearing for any
other person on the service list, although properly served as appears from the affidavit
of Jennifer Whincup sworn December 12, 2016 filed,
SERVICE
1. THIS COURT ORDERS that the time for service of the Notice of Motion and the
Motion is hereby abridged and validated so that this motion is properly returnable today
and hereby dispenses with further service thereof.
APPROVAL OF FEES
2. THIS COURT ORDERS that the fees and disbursements of DLA Piper (Canada)
LLP, in the amount of $76,025.00 exclusive of taxes and disbursements, and
$88,019.83 inclusive of taxes and disbursements for the period of August 31, 2016 to
November 27, 2016 as set out in the Affidavit of Bruce Darlington, sworn December 7,
2016, are hereby approved.
3. THIS COURT ORDERS that the fees and disbursements of Madorin, Snyder,
LLP, in the amount of $27,229 exclusive of taxes and disbursements and $31,841.05
inclusive of taxes and disbursement for the period of September 19, 2016 to December
7, 2016 as set out in the Affidavit of Tim McGowan, sworn December 7, 2016, are
hereby approved.
___________________________________
EMMANUEL
VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
- and -
1250 WEBER STREET EAST, KITCHENER, ONTARIO OR THE PROCEEDS OF THE SALE
THEREOF (IN REM)
Court File No. CV-16-11424-00CL
Applicant Applicant Respondent
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
COMMERCIAL LIST
Proceeding commenced at Toronto
ORDER (September 26, 2016)
DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadain Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 Toronto, ON M5X 1E2
Bruce Darlington LSUC#: 25310K [email protected] Tel: 416.365.3529 Fax: 416.369.5210
Jennifer A. Whincup LSUC#: 60326W [email protected] Tel: 416.365.3425 Fax: 416.369.5240
Lawyers for the Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.
CAN: 23323287.1
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC. and
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO and
EMMANUEL VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
Court File No: CV-16-11424-00CL
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE COMMERCIAL LIST
Proceeding commenced at Toronto
MOTION RECORD OF EMMANUEL
VILLAGE RESIDENCE INC.
DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP Barristers & Solicitors 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 6000 P.O. Box 367 Toronto ON M5X 1E2 Bruce Darlington (LSUC# 25310K) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3529 Fax: 416-369-5210 Jennifer A. Whincup (LSUC# 60326W) [email protected] Tel: 416-365-3425 Fax: 416-369-5240 Lawyers for Emmanuel Village Residence Inc.