odi pe of regionalism in wa.pdf

8/14/2019 ODI PE of regionalism in WA.pdf

1/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *23(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.%

"#$%&'( )*+,- .', %/&$/&*&).*&$'

0&11& 23.456/)7 8./*. 9$/6)*& .', :.'&6; 8./#3 ?>@?


2/36

7.8$*9&(:4(0($+5

"#$ %&'#()* +(&,- ,./$ '( %0/1(+,$-2$ '#$ 0(1').3&'.(1* (4 5(4. 6%))%# %1- 7)%10.* 8%,$9$-&).12 '#$ 4.$,-+()/ 0(:;(1$1' (4 '#$ ;)(.'#(&' '#$.) +.,,.121$** '( *#%)$ '#$.).1*.2#'* '#$ )$;()' +(&,- 1(' #%?$ 3$$1 ;(**.3,$= @*$4&, 4$$-3%0/ (1 ;)$?.(&* -)%4'* +%*)$0$.?$- 4)(: A%?.- B(('#C D%/(3 E12$, %1- 8$1. >.,- %1- '#$ A7FA ;)($*':.1*'$) B).-2$ I(%-8(1-(1 JEH KDAC @5

"$,L MNN OPQRP KSRR PTPP7%UL MNN OPQRP KSRR PTSS+++=(-.=()2=&/

A.*0,%.:$)L "#$ ?.$+* ;)$*$1'$- .1 '#.* ;%;$)%)$ '#(*$ (4 '#$ %&'#()O*Q %1- -( 1('1$0$**%).,9 )$;)$*$1' '#$ ?.$+* (4 GAF () (&)

;%)'1$)*=


3/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; *$+($+5

!"#$%#$& ()**+%,(-$("#& ((./%01$(,% &122-+3 (((45&125 ,((

6 7-089+"1#: 6; )ZJW+.-$ KT=] ")%1*;()' .14)%*')&0'&)$ OI%.,+%9* %1- -)9 ;()'*Q ]T=S I$2.(1%, $1$)29 .14)%*')&0'&)$ ST=HP Z2).0&,'&)$ %1- 4((- *$0&).'9 HPA B+("+($(&%: "ZJ HKN=N ^#%1% H]N=X >$*' Z4).0%1 ;()' $44.0.$109 O"$:% %1- Y('(1(&Q RP.Q "#$ \()' (4 Y('(1(&L 1$2('.%'.12 )$4(): RH..Q "#$ \()' (4 "$:% )$4():* RHC 4%D%+%#0%& ;>


4/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJ ')%-$ ,.3$)%,.*%'.(1 *0#$:$E@7"Z

E&)(;$%1 @1.(17)$$ ")%-$ Z)$%

^Y1$'8ZJAE8

V"B

^#%1% Y(::&1.'9 V$'+()/ J$)?.0$* 8.:.'$-8%3()%'(.)$ -bE'&-$* $' -$ I$0#$)0#$ *&) ,$* A91%:.c&$* J(0.%,$* $' ,$Aa?$,(;;$:$1' 8(0%,V(1W'%).44 3%)).$)

GAF G?$)*$%* A$?$,(;:$1' F1*'.'&'$\Y@IEYII""7\

\)(Z^\ >$*' Z4).0%1 ^%* \.;$,.1$>Z6d >$*' Z4).0% 6(1$'%)9 d(1$>Z\\>Z"e

>$*' Z4).0%1 \(+$) \((,>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3


5/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; $*'

Z4).0%1 )$2.(1%,.*: .* .:;()'%1' 4() 3('# -(:$*'.0 %1- $U'$)1%, *'%/$#(,-$)* .1 >$*'Z4).0%1 -$?$,(;:$1'C +#$'#$) '#$ :%.1 4(0&* .* (1 '#$ .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$** .'*$,4 () (1;)(2)$** .1 ;%)'.0&,%) 0(&1').$*= F1 ;%)'.0&,%)C %''$1'.(1 1$$-* '( 3$ ;%.- '( '#$.1'$)$*'*C .10$1'.?$* %1- 0#(.0$* +#.0# *#%;$ '#$ 3$#%?.(&) (4 :%$*' Z4).0%1 )$2.(1%,.*:=

"#.*C #(+$?$)C .* % ,%)2$ *&3$*' Z4).0%1 0(&1').$* .1 '#$

%&'&:1 (4 RPHH= \).().'.f%'.(1 %:(12 '#$*$ .**&$* +%* 3%*$- (1 4(&) :%.1 0).'$).%)$4,$0'.12 '#$ -$2)$$ '( +#.0# %--.'.(1%, ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 )$*$%)0# 0(&,- %-- ?%,&$C.10,&-.12L

. G).2.1%,.'9 \).().'.*%'.(1 *#(&,- %?(.- -&;,.0%'.(1 (4 $U.*'.12 /1(+,$-2$ ())$*$%)0# %,)$%-9 0(::.**.(1$-g

.. J&.'%3.,.'9 \).().'.*%'.(1 *#(&,- .-$1'.49 .**&$* +#$)$ 0#%,,$12$* %).*$ 4)(:;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 4%0'()* )%'#$) '#%1 '$0#1.0%, ;)(3,$:*g

... 7$%*.3.,.'9 \).().'.*%'.(1 *#(&,- .-$1'.49 .**&$* +#$)$ $U'$)1%,,90(::.**.(1$- )$*$%)0#$)* :.2#' $44$0'.?$,9 0%))9 (&' % *'&-9g %1-C

.? F1'$)$*' \).().'.*%'.(1 *#(&,- .10,&-$ %1 %**$**:$1' (4 )$2.(1%,*'%/$#(,-$) .1'$)$*'C %* +$,, %* +#%' .* ;('$1'.%,,9 (4 2)$%'$*' .1'$)$*' '(A7FA ;)(2)%::.12 .1 '#$ )$2.(1=

-'#*'#+#(5 2*' %::#+#*$%& )*+#.%& (.*$*01 %$%&15#5

G1 '#$ 3%*.* (4 '#$ 0).'$).% 2.?$1 %3(?$C 4.?$ .**&$* +$)$ ;).().'.*$- 4() %--.'.(1%,;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 %1%,9*.*= V(' %,, 4.?$ .**&$* 1$$- '( 3$ -$%,' +.'# *.:&,'%1$(&*,9C1() -($* '#$ ()-$) (4 '#$.) ;)$*$1'%'.(1 *&22$*' % )%1/.12 %:(12 '#$:= I%'#$)C4&)'#$) -.*0&**.(1 %:(12 A7FA ;)(2)%::$ *'%44 0(&,- ,$%- '( -$0.*.(1* %* '( +#%' '(;).().'.*$ %:(12 '#$*$ 4.?$ 2.?$1 '#$ (12(.12 )$-$*.21 (4 '#$ J>ZIF\=

R E#D"+2-F $+-:% -F"#9 $=% ?(9%+(-@7%#(# *"+:%+G Z1 .10)$%*$ .1 .1')%W)$2.(1%,')%-$ ?(,&:$* .* % /$9 -).?$) %1- $?.-$10$ (4 :()$ $44$0'.?$ )$2.(1%, $0(1(:.0.1'$2)%'.(1= e(+$?$)C -$*;.'$ '#$ $*'%3,.*#:$1' (4 4)$$W')%-$ %)$%* O7"ZQ %1-0(::(1 $U'$)1%, '%).44 OYE"Q )$2.:$* +.'#.1 3('# @E6GZ %1- EYG>ZJC.:;,$:$1'%'.(1 (4C %1- 0(::.':$1' '( '#$*$ %2)$$:$1'* #%* 3$$1 *,(+ %1-


6/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


7/36

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

.1'$)$*' %4'$) % 1&:3$) (4 9$%)* (4 *&*'%.1$- 2)(+'# (1 '#$ $0(1(:.0 4)(1' %1-.1 '#$ )&1W&; '( :%ZJ .1 ;%)'.0&,%)Q=

[ J%&$ )D+(0-#


8/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; $ #%?$ %-(;'$- %3)(%- ?.$+ (4 )$2.(1%,.*: '#%' %''$:;'* '( 0%;'&)$ '#(*$ .**&$* %1- ;)(0$**$* '#%'

3$*' %--)$**$- '#)(&2# '#$ 4():%, )$2.(1%, ()2%1.*%'.(1*= >$ 4$$, '#%' J>ZIF\ +(&,-3$1$4.' 4)(: % *.:.,%),9 3)(%- 0(10$;'&%,.f%'.(1 (4 *&;;()' '( )$2.(1%,.*: .1 >$*'Z4).0%=


9/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


10/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZIF\=

H !"22%+0% (#D"+2%F F% F"#9 :% F- D+"#$(K+% %#$+% F% ?(9%+(- %$ F% 75#(# G@1$ %&2:$1'%'.(1 -& ?(,&:$ -$* a0#%12$* .1')% )a2.(1%&U $*' &1 :('$&)$**$1'.$, $' ,% ;)$&?$ -b&1$ .1'a2)%'.(1 a0(1(:.c&$ )a2.(1%,$ ;,&* $44.0%0$=Y$;$1-%1'C :%,2)a ,ba'%3,.**$:$1' -$ f(1$* -$ ,.3)$Wa0#%12$ O!"# %& '&()'*+Q $'-$ )a2.:$* -$ '%).4 $U'a).$&) 0(::&1 O"EYQ %& *$.1 -$ ,b@E6GZ $' -$ ,% $' .1a2%&U $1')$ ,$* ;%9*= E1 0(1*ac&$10$C ,b%&2:$1'%'.(1 %''$1-&$ -& ?(,&:$-$* a0#%12$* .1')% )a2.(1%&U 4():$,* 1b% ;%* $& ,.$&= 8$* %0'.?.'a* 0(::$)0.%,$*.14():$,,$* ;%)W-$,j ,$* 4)(1'.i)$* 1%'.(1%,$* -%1* ,% )a2.(1 -$ ,% YEAEZGC 3.$1c&$ 1b%;;%)%.**%1' ;%* -%1* ,$* -(11a$* (44.0.$,,$*C 0(1'.1&$1' j h')$ ,$ :('$&)-$* -91%:.c&$* 0(::$)0.%,$*= 8&''$) 0(1')$ -$* %0'.?.'a* 0(::$)0.%,$*.14():$,,$* -$ 0$ '9;$ 1a0$**.'$)%.' -.44a)$1'$* %;;)(0#$* ;(,.'.c&$*C '%1' %&

1.?$%& 1%'.(1%, c&bj 0$,&. -& *(&'.$1 %;;()'a ;%) ,$* 3%.,,$&)* -$ 4(1-* j,b.1'a2)%'.(1 )a2.(1%,$C $' &1$ a'&-$ -ba0(1(:.$ ;(,.'.c&$ ;(&))%.' 2&.-$) ,$-a?$,(;;$:$1' -b&1$ '$,,$ %;;)(0#$=

8% 4)(1'.i)$ $1')$ ,$ Ba1.1 $' ,$ V.2$).% *$:3,$ 4(&)1.) &1 $U$:;,$;%)'.0&,.i)$:$1' .1'a)$**%1' -$* -a4.* -%1* 0$''$ )a2.(1 $' ;(&))%.' *$ ;)h'$) j&1$ %1%,9*$ -ba0(1(:.$ ;(,.'.c&$= Y$,% ;$):$'')%.' $1 ;%)'.0&,.$) -$ 0(1*.-a)$),$* 4,&U .,,a2%&U -%1* ,$* -$&U -.)$0'.(1* $' -%1* ,$* -.44a)$1'* *$0'$&)* -$ 4%`(1 ;)(2)%::$ (& -$ ;(,.'.c&$ $U.*'$ ;$&'Wh')$= @1$ '$,,$ %;;)(0#$ 0(:;,a'$)%.'a2%,$:$1' ,$* ')%?%&U $1 0(&)* *&) ,% ;(,.'.c&$ 0(::$)0.%,$ 1.2a).$11$=

R 45:1(+% F%& 0"L$& :%& $+-#&-0$("#& 0"22%+0(-F%& +59("#-F%& G 8$* $44()'*;(&) ,b%&2:$1'%'.(1 -& ?(,&:$ -$* a0#%12$* .1')% )a2.(1%&U *(1' *a).$&*$:$1'0(:;)(:.* ;%) ,$* 0(l'* a,$?a* -$* ')%1*%0'.(1* O0(:;)$1%1' ,$* 0(l'*'$:;()$,* $' ,$* 0(l'* 4.1%10.$)*Q %**(0.a$* j ,% 0.)0&,%'.(1 -$* :%)0#%1-.*$* $1Z4).c&$ -$ ,bG&$*'= J. &1$ %:a,.()%'.(1 c&%,.'%'.?$ $' c&%1'.'%'.?$ -$,b.14)%*')&0'&)$ ;#9*.c&$ O;%) $U= )(&'$* $' %&'()(&'$*Q $*' &1 -$* 3$*(.1*$**$1'.$,* -$ ,% )a2.(1C ., $*' ;$& ;)(3%3,$ c&b$,,$ *(.' *&44.*%1'$ ;(&) )a-&.)$$44.0%0$:$1' ,$* 0(l'* $' ,$&) ;$):$'')$ -b%''$.1-)$ ,$* 1.?$%&U -a*.)a*= Y$,% $*'-l $1 2)%1-$ ;%)'.$ j ,% ;)a?%,$10$ ;$)*.*'%1'$ -$* -a,%.* $' -$* 0(l'* $10(&)&*%&U 3%))%2$* )(&'.$)* (44.0.$,* $' 1(1 (44.0.$,* ,$ ,(12 -$* ;).10.;%&U 0()).-()* -$

')%1*;()'= V(&* *&22a)(1* -(10 -$&U ;(.1'* -b$1')a$ ;('$1'.$, ;(&) &1$ %1%,9*$-ba0(1(:.$ ;(,.'.c&$ L .Q ,&''$) 0(1')$ ,$* -a,%.* $' ,% 0())&;'.(1 %&U ;(*'$*4)(1'.i)$* g ..Q )a-&.)$ ,$* -a,%.* $' ,$* 0(l'* O%.1*. c&$ ,$ #%)0i,$:$1'C ,%0())&;'.(1 $' ,b$U'()*.(1Q %&U ;(*'$* -$ 0(1')k,$ ,$ ,(12 -$* 0()).-()* -$')%1*;()'=

A%1* &1$ '$1'%'.?$ -b%:a,.()%'.(1 -$ ,% 2(&?$)1%10$ ,$ ,(12 -$* 2)%1-* 0()).-()*)(&'.$)*C &1 1(:3)$ -$ ;)(


11/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


12/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


13/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJQ %1- @1.(1 E0(1(:.c&$ $' 6(1a'%.)$ G&$*'WZ4).0%.1 O@E6GZQC +$#%?$ %-(;'$- % 3)(%- ?.$+ (4 )$2.(1%,.*: '#%' %''$:;'* '( 0%;'&)$ '#(*$ .**&$* %1-;)(0$**$* O4():%, %1- .14():%,Q '#%' .10,&-$ % )$2.(1%, -.:$1*.(1C $?$1 +#$)$ *&0# J&;;()' '( >$*'Z4).0%1 I$2.(1%, F1'$2)%'.(1 \)($*' Z4).0%=

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f $' %,=C RPPSQ=

F' .* 0,$%) '#%' -$?$,(;.12 % 3$''$) &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 '#$ ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 (4 >$*'Z4).0%1 )$2.(1%,.*: .* .:;()'%1' 4() 3('# -(:$*'.0 %1- $U'$)1%, *'%/$#(,-$)* .1 >$*'Z4).0%1 -$?$,(;:$1'C +#$'#$) '#$ :%.1 4(0&* .* (1 '#$ .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$** .'*$,4 () (1;)(2)$** .1 ;%)'.0&,%) 0(&1').$*= e(+$?$)C ;).().'.$* 1$$- '( 3$ $*'%3,.*#$-= "#$)$ .*'#$)$4()$ % 1$$- 4() % *0(;.12 *'&-9 '( #$,; ;).().'.*$ %:(12 '#$ ?%).(&* '(;.0* +#.0#:.2#' 3$ '#$ 4(0&* (4 &*$4&, ;(,.'.0%,W$0(1(:9 +()/=


14/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


15/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


16/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJ %)$ ;).:%).,9 0(10$)1$- +.'#;(,.09:%/.12C '#$ .:;,$:$1'%'.(1 (4 )$2.(1%, ;(,.0.$* )$:%.1* '#$ )$*;(1*.3.,.'9 (41%'.(1%, 2(?$)1:$1'*= Z )$%, 0(::.':$1' (1 '#$ ;%)' (4 1%'.(1%, 2(?$)1:$1'* '( '#$)$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$** .* $**$1'.%, .4 2)$%'$) )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 .* '( 3$%0#.$?$-= r$' ?$)9 ,.'',$ .* /1(+1 %3(&' '#$ .10$1'.?$* 4%0$- 39 1%'.(1%, 2(?$)1:$1'*'( *&;;()' () (;;(*$ )$2.(1%,.*: .1 .'* ?%).(&* 4():*=

J=-$ Q% 8#"QG %0)(** '#$ )$2.(1 *$$:* &10,$%)= V%'.(1%, 2(?$)1:$1'* 4%0$ /$9 0(1*')%.1'* '( '#$

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

H=% ,%+:(0$G "#.* .* % #.2#,9 )$,$?%1' ;)(3,$: %1- % 2)$%'$) &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 '#$1%'.(1%, ,$?$, .10$1'.?$* '( )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$**$* +(&,- 3$ %)2&%3,9 &*$4&, 4()%,, 0(&1').$* +.'#.1 '#$ )$2.(1= e(+$?$) 0%))9.12 (&' %1 EYG>ZJW+.-$ %**$**:$1'+(&,- 3$ &1)$%*(1%3,$ .1 '$):* (4 '#$ )$c&.)$- )$*(&)0$*= A$;'# (4 &1-$)*'%1-.12#$)$ +(&,- #%?$ '( 3$ 3%,%10$- +.'# '#$ 3)$%-'# (4 0(&1')9 0(1'$U'* .1 '#$ *&3W)$2.(1= "#$)$4()$ '#.* .**&$ +%* 1(' ;).().'.*$- 4() 2$1$)%,C EYG>ZJW+.-$ ')$%':$1'O3&' *$$ *$0'.(1 N=N (1 ^#%1% 3$,(+Q=

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c&%,.4.$- %1- &1$?$1= *'%'$ #%* .'* ;%)'.0&,%) .**&$* +.'# '#$ .:;,$:$1'%'.(1 (4 EYG>ZJ %2)$$:$1'*C '#$


17/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; #.,$ .' .* (1$ (4 '#$ :(*' 0,$%),9 ?.*.3,$ 4():* (4 )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1C '#$$*'%3,.*#:$1' (4 % >$*' Z4).0%1 :(1$'%)9 &1.(1C .1'$1-$- '( )$-&0$ ')%1*%0'.(1 0(*'*.1 0)(**W3()-$) ')%-$ %1- ;)(:('$ 2)$%'$) $%*$ .1 0)(** 3()-$) .1?$*':$1'*C )$:%.1*%1 %)$% (4 4)&*')%'.(1 4() *&;;()'$)* (4 )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1=

J=-$ Q% 8#"QG "#$ :(?$ '(+%)-* % 0(::(1 0&))$109 #%* 3$$1 '#$ #$%-,.1$ 4(0&*.1 '#$ IEY*= Y(1?$)2$10$ 0).'$).%C .10,&-.12 % +.-$ ?%).$'9 (4 :%0)($0(1(:.0.1-.0%'()*C #%?$ ,(12 3$$1 *$'= r$'C -$*;.'$ '#$ '$0#1.0%, /1(+,$-2$ (4 '#$ .**&$-$:(1*')%'$- 39 *'%44 :$:3$)* .1 @E6GZ %1- '#$ >$*' Z4).0%1 6(1$'%)9 d(1$O>Z6dQC ;)(2)$** %2%.1*' '#$*$ 0).'$).% #%* )$:%.1$- ,.:.'$- +#$)$ .' #%* (00&))$- %'%,,C +.'# -$%-,.1$* 4() &1.(1 ;&*#$- 3%0/ )$;$%'$-,9= 7() :%19C -.*0&**.(1* (4 %:(1$'%)9 &1.(1 %)$ ,.'',$ :()$ '#%1 % -.*')%0'.(1 4)(: 2)$%'$) ;)(2)$** (1 % :()$,.:.'$- %2$1-% .10,&-.12C 4() $U%:;,$C -$?$,(;:$1' (4 $44$0'.?$ )$2.(1%, *9*'$:* 4()1(1W0%*# ;%9:$1' O>(),- B%1/C RPPKQ=

H=% ,%+:(0$G A$*;.'$ '#$ .1'$)$*' .1 '#.* .**&$ %:(12 )$2.(1%, .1*'.'&'.(1* O$=2= '#$

>$*' Z4).0% 6(1$'%)9 F1*'.'&'$QC '#.* .**&$ .* 1(' )$0(::$1-$- 4() ;).().'.*%'.(1= "#.*-$0.*.(1 )$4,$0'* '#$ ?.$+* (4 '#$ *0(;.12 '$%: '#%' '#$ ,%0/ (4 ;(,.'.0%, ')%0'.(1 %' '#$1%'.(1%, ,$?$,C )$4,$0'$- .1 '#$ 4%.,&)$ '( :%/$ ;)(2)$** '(+%)-* %2)$$- &;(10(1?$)2$10$ 0).'$).%C )$:%.1* % 4.): 3%)).$) '( 4&)'#$) .1'$2)%'.(1 (1 '#.* 4)(1'= "#$*0(;.12 *'&-9 -.- 1(' .-$1'.49 %19 )$0$1' 0#%12$* '#%' +(&,- *&22$*' %1 $U'$)1%,,90(::.**.(1$- ;.$0$ (4 ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 %1%,9*.* +(&,- .-$1'.49 4$%*.3,$ +%9*4()+%)-= F4 %19'#.12C 2.?$1 '#$ $U'$1' '( +#.0# '#$ E&)(;$%1 @1.(1 OE@Q )$:%.1* '#$;)$W$:.1$1' :(-$, 4() )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 .1 '#$ :.1-* (4 :%19 >$*' Z4).0%1*OA)%;$)C RPHPQC $1'#&*.%*: 4() :(1$'%)9 .1'$2)%'.(1 %;;$%)* '( #%?$ )$0$1',9 3$$14&)'#$) -%:;$1$- 39 '#$ E@ 0).*.* *'.,, &14(,-.12=

=DC E$'F.%%;.*&$' $H %/$*$#$;)J K2LMN"FO&,6


18/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


19/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJ .*2$1$)%,,9 )$2%)-$- %* '#$ ,$%-.12 $U%:;,$ (4 % )$2.(1%, ()2%1.*%'.(1 '#%' .* $44$0'.?$


20/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJ :$:3$) *'%'$* 3&' )%'#$) 4)(: 0(&1').$* (&'*.-$ (4 '#$ )$2.(1= e(+$?$)

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g-&).12 '#$ ;(,.'.0%, *'%,$:%'$ .1 '#$ F?()9 Y(%*' '#$ >$*' Z4).0%1 Y$1')%, B%1/ .1Z3.-$*' Z4).0% )$2.(1 .* 0(*',9 %1- ')%1*;()'$)* %)$ &1%3,$

1$'+()/ %)$ '#&* % /$9 ;).().'9 4() )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 O"$)%?%1.1'#()1 %1-I%3%,,%1-C RPP]g @VEYZC RPHPQ= 7&10'.(1.12 )%.,+%9 1$'+()/* +(&,- -( :&0# '()$0'.49 '#$ &1-$)W;)(?.*.(1 (4 ')%1*;()' .14)%*')&0'&)$ %1- .:;)(?$ '#$ 2)(&1-')%1*;()' 1$'+()/= 7&)'#$):()$ '#$ $U.*'$10$ (4 )%., 0(11$0'.(1* 4)(: *$%;()'* +(&,-$1%3,$ '#$ &*$ (4 -)9 ;()'* +#.0# 0(&,- (;$)%'$ %* 0$1')$* 4() ')%1*#.;:$1' (4 0%)2('( .1,%1- -$*'.1%'.(1* %1- 0(&,- 3$ &*$- '( )$-&0$ .))$2&,%) 0&*'(:* %0'.?.'9=e(+$?$)C -$*;.'$ .1.'.%'.?$* +.'#.1 '#$ )$2.(1 (?$) '#$ ,%*' 4$+ 9$%)* '( .1')(-&0$ -)9;()'* %1- )$#%3.,.'%'$ %1- 0(1*')&0' )%.,+%9 1$'+()/* '#$*$ #%?$ 3$$1 ;)(2)$**.12*,(+,9=

J=-$ Q% 8#"QG Z1 .1.'.%'.?$ '( )$#%3.,.'%'$ %1- $U'$1- '#$ Y('(1(& OB$1.1Q \%)%/(& OV.2$)Q )%.,+%9 ,.1$ '( A(**( OV.2$)Q %1- '( 0(1*')&0' -)9 ;()'* .1 3('# V.2$)%1- B$1.1 #%* 3$$1 .1 '#$ ;.;$,.1$ 4() *$?$)%, 9$%)*= e(+$?$)C -$*;.'$ '#$ (44$) (4 %;&3,.0W;%)'1$)*#.; .1 RPHPC +#.0# ;)(;(*$- '( ;%)',9 4.1%10$ '#$ .14)%*')&0'&)%, +()/


21/36

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

0(1*')&0'.(1 %1- %,,$2%'.(1* (4 .:;)(;$) ;%9:$1'* '( (44.0.%,* 4() ;.;$,.1$$U;,(.'%'.(1 ).'$* %)$


22/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;

"#$ >$*' Z4).0% \(+$) \((, O>Z\\Q ;)(Z\\= 7() $U%:;,$C .1 '#$ 4)%:$+()/ (4 '#$>$*' Z4).0% \(+$) \((, ;)(


23/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; #.,*' '#$ J%#$,.%1 0(&1').$*C +#.0# %)$ :(*' %44$0'$-39 ')%1*.'.(1%, 4((- *#()'%2$*C #%?$ % 2)$%'$) .10$1'.?$ '( 0((;$)%'$ '( (?$)0(:$'#$*$ 3%)).$)*C 0((;$)%'.(1 #%* :()$ (4'$1 '#%1 1(' '%/$1 '#$ 4(): (4 %))%12$:$1'*%,(12 '#$ ,.1$* (4 .14():%, *&3W)$2.(1%, 3,(0*= 7() '#$ 0(%*'%, %1- $0(1(:.0%,,9 :()$;(+$)4&, 0(&1').$* *&0# %* V.2$).%C ,$** 4)$c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

HYF8JJ O'#$ ;$):%1$1' )$2.(1%, 0(::.''$$ .1 '#$ *')&22,$ %2%.1*' -)(&2#' .1 '#$ J%#$,Q #%* 3$$1 ;)$*$1' .1 '#$ 0(?$).12 F?()9 Y(%*'C ^&.1$% B.**%&C ^&.1$%C B&)/.1% 7%*(C ^%:3.%C Y%;$ s$)-$CJ$1$2%,C V.2$)C 6%,.C 6%&).'%1.% %1- Y#%-


24/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJC .:;,$:$1'%'.(1 (4C %1- 0(::.':$1' '( '#$*$ %2)$$:$1'* #%* 3$$1*,(+ %1- &1$?$1 %0)(** 0(&1').$* %1- '#$ %1'.0.;%'$- .10)$%*$ .1 .1')%W)$2.(1%, ')%-$?(,&:$ #%* 1(' ')%1*;.)$- OA&;%.2)$ $' %,=C RPPKQ= r$' .1 :%19 0%*$*C '#.* ;)$*$1'* %4%,*$ ;.0'&)$ (4 '#$ :(?$:$1' (4 2((-* %0)(** 1%'.(1%, 3()-$)*= Z' '#$ )$2.(1%, ,$?$,C,(+ ,$?$,* (4 (44.0.%, 0)(**W3()-$) 4,(+* %)$ 0,(*$,9 ,.1/$- '( '#$ 0(1'.1&$- O%1- .1:%19 0%*$* .10)$%*.12Q ;)$?%,$10$ (4 &1W(44.0.%, 0)(** 3()-$) 4,(+*= "#.* ;#$1(:$1(1

#%* 3$$1 #.2#,.2#'$- %* (1$ (4 '#$ /$9 (3*'%0,$* '( '#$ 4():%, .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$** .1>$*' Z4).0% O@VEYZC RPHPg A&;%.2)$ $' %,=C RPPKg >(),- B%1/C RPPKQ=

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

J=-$ Q% 8#"Q -#: %#$+3 ZJ YE" '#$ V.2$).% ')%-$ )$2.:$ )$:%.1* &1*'%3,$ %1-;)('$0'.(1.*' OA&;%.2)$ $' %,=C RPPKQ .:;(*.12 #.2# ,$?.$* %1- 3%1* (1 .:;()'* +#.0#0%1 0#%12$ 4)$c&$1',9C ;)(?.-.12 % *')(12 .10$1'.?$ 4() 0())&;'.(1 %1- *:&22,.12=I$,%'$- '( '#.*C #.2# ,$?$,* (4 .14():%, ')%-$ $:$)2$- %* % #.2#,9 )$,$?%1' 0(1*')%.1''( )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1=R

"#$ 3()-$) 3$'+$$1 B$1.1 %1- V.2$).% %;;$%)* '( ;)(?.-$ % ;%)'.0&,%),9 ).0# $U%:;,$(4 '#$ 0#%,,$12$* .1 '#.* %)$% '#%' :%9 3$ %:$1%3,$ '( ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 %1%,9*.*="#)$$ *;$0.4.0 '9;$* (4 .14():%, ')%-$ %0)(** '#$ B$1.1WV.2$).% 3()-$) +$)$ .-$1'.4.$-L'#$ .,,.0.' ')%-$ .1 ;$')(, 4)(: V.2$).% '( B$1.1g '#$ .,,$2%, .:;()'%'.(1 (4 V.2$).%1:%1&4%0'&)$- 2((-* .1'( B$1.1g %1- '#$ O)$WQ$U;()'%'.(1 (4 ;)(#.3.'$- ;)(-&0'* '(V.2$).% 4)(: B$1.1= "%0/,.12 '#$*$ /.1-* (4 .14():%, ')%-$ %0)(** 3()-$)* +(&,-)$c&.)$ -.44$)$1' ;(,.09 %;;)(%0#$*C 3('# %' '#$ 1%'.(1%, ,$?$, 3&' %,*( %* ;%)' (4-(1()* *&;;()' '( )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1C %1- % ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 *'&-9 0(&,- #$,; '(.14(): '#$ -$?$,(;:$1' (4 *&0# %1 %;;)(%0#= e(+$?$)C +$ *&22$*' '#%' '#$)$ :%9%,*( 3$ *(:$ 0#%,,$12$* .1 -$?$,(;.12 % 4$%*.3,$ (;$)%'.(1%, )$*;(1*$ %--)$**.12*(:$ 0(:;(1$1'* (4 .14():%, ')%-.12 -&$ '( ;(,.'.0%, .10$1'.?$* .1 3('# 0(&1').$*= "#.*.* -.*0&**$- 3$,(+C 4.)*' +.'# )$*;$0' '( '#$ *;$0.4.0 .**&$ (4 .,,.0.' ')%-$ .1 ;$')(, %1-

R"#$ ;)$?%,$10$ (4 .14():%, ')%-$ .* ,./$,9 '( 3$ *#%;$- 39 % 1&:3$) (4 4%0'()*C .10,&-.12C 3&' 1(' ,.:.'$- '( '#$)$,%'.(1* 3$'+$$1 1$.2#3(&).12 0(&1').$* %' '#$ ,(0%, ,$?$, +#$)$ 0)(**W3()-$) ')%-$ '%/$* ;,%0$= B('# &1-$)*'%1-.12;&);()'$- -).?$)* O$=2= ,(0%, ,$?$, -91%:.0*Q %1- .-$1'.49.12 ('#$) ;('$1'.%, 4%0'()* %1- %**$**.12 '#$.) )$,%'.?$ +$.2#'+(&,- 3$ % /$9 ;).().'9 4() '#$ ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 %1%,9*.*=


25/36

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


26/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; .,,.%:* (1 '#$ ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 (4 V.2$).%1 ')%-$ ;(,.09 O%* :$1'.(1$- .1 *$0'.(1 TQ=

CD? X6,+#&'( */.').#*&$' #$)*) &' /6(&$'.; */.,6H=% (&&1%G E44()'* '( .10)$%*$ '#$ ?(,&:$ (4 .1')%W)$2.(1%, ')%-$ %)$ *$?$)$,9#%:;$)$- 39 '#$ #.2# ')%1*%0'.(1 0(*'* O.10,&-.12 3('# '.:$ -$,%9* %1- 4.1%10.%,0(*'*Q %**(0.%'$- +.'# :(?$:$1' (4 2((-* '#)(&2#(&' >$*' Z4).0% O"$)%?%1.1'#()1%1- I%3%,,%1-C RPP]Q= >#.,$ %1 .:;)(?$:$1' .1 '#$ c&%,.'9 %1- c&%1'.'9 (4 ;#9*.0%,.14)%*')&0'&)$ O$=2= )(%-* %1- #.2#+%9*Q .* % 0).'.0%, 1$$- .1 '#$ )$2.(1C .' .* &1,./$,9 '(3$ *&44.0.$1' '( $44$0'.?$,9 )$-&0$ 0(*'* '( -$*.)$- ,$?$,*= F1 1( *:%,, ;%)'C '#.* .* -&$'( '#$ 0(1'.1&$- ;)$?%,$10$ (4 '#$ -$,%9* %1- 0(*'* .10&))$- %' )(%-3,(0/* %,(12 :%.1')%1*;()' 0()).-()*=

"(2( %1- B$1.1 '( V.2$).%= Z


27/36

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

J=-$ Q% 8#"QG I$0$1' %1- (1W2(.12 3()-$) ;(*' )$4(): .1.'.%'.?$*C *&0# %* '#$.:;,$:$1'%'.(1 (4 *.12,$ +.1-(+ 0&*'(:* ;(.1'* %1-


28/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; Z"eQ +()/O@JZFA_@E6GZC RPHHQ 0(1'%.1 % +$%,'# (4 .14():%'.(1C ')%0/.12 '#$ 1&:3$) (40#$0/;(.1'*C -$,%9 '.:$* %1- 3).3$)9 %0)(** HH :%.1 ')%1*;()' 0()).-()*= e(+$?$)C%,'#(&2# '#$ .14():%'.(1 ;)(?.-$- 39 '#$*$ ?%).(&* .1.'.%'.?$* .* &*$4&, .1 (3*$)?.12%1- ')%0/.12 0#%12$* .1 )(%- 2(?$)1%10$C 0(1*&,'%'.(1* +.'# >Z"e *'%44 %1- ('#$)-(1()* .1 '#$ )$2.(1 *&22$*' '#$)$ .* *.21.4.0%1' *0(;$ 4() 4(0&*$- ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9%1%,9*.* '( %-- ?%,&$ '( '#.* $U.*'.12 +()/C 0(:;,$:$1'.12 c&%1'.'%'.?$ .14():%'.(1 c&$*'.(1* $:$)2.12

4)(: '#$ ')%0/.12 .1.'.%'.?$= "#.* +(&,- %,*( #$,; '( .-$1'.49 ;(**.3,$ .10$1'.?$* 4()0#%12$C 3$9(1- %1 %1%,9*.* (4 '#$ *'%'&* c&(= F1 ('#$) +()-*C 0(:;,$:$1'%)9 \E%1%,9*.* #%* '#$ ;('$1'.%, '( #$,; %2$10.$* -$?$,(; %1 .:;)(?$- &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 '#$&1-$),9.12 .10$1'.?$* -).?.12 '#$ ;)$*$10$ %1- ;$)*.*'$10$ (4 *&0# 0#$0/;(.1'* +#.0#%;;$%)* '( 3$ 0&))$1',9 ,%0/.12= F1 % 3$*' 0%*$ *0$1%).(C '#$ \EZ +(&,- %,*( #$,; '(

NFI"^ 0(?$)* '#$ 4(,,(+.12 *.U :%.1 0()).-()*L "$:%WG&%2%-(&2(&C G&%2%-(&2(&WB%:%/(C 8(:aWG&%2%-(&2(&CB%:%/(WA%/%)C Z3.-


29/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJ :$:3$) *'%'$* '#$)$ #%* 3$$1 %'$1-$109 '( 0(10$1')%'$ (1 EYG>ZJ +#$1 0(1*.-$).12 '#$ .**&$ (4 )$2.(1%,.1'$2)%'.(1 .1 >$*' Z4).0%= e(+$?$) @E6GZ .* *'.,, % *.21.4.0%1' )$2.(1%, %0'() %1- (1$+#.0# #%* 3$$1C %)2&%3,9 :()$ *&00$**4&, '#%1 EYG>ZJ %' (?$)0(:.12 '#$0(()-.1%'.(1 ;)(3,$:* 0).'.0%, '( .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$**$*= 7&)'#$):()$ '#$)$ %)$ 4$+*.21* '#%' 0(1*(,.-%'.(1 &1-$) EYG>ZJ +.,, #%;;$1 .1 '#$ *#()' '$):= G1 '#$0(1')%)9C )$0$1' :(?$* 39 @E6GZ '( -$?$,(; .'* )$2.(1%, ;(,.09 0(()-.1%'.(10(:;$'$10$* .1-.0%'$ .' .* :(?.12 %+%9 4)(:C )%'#$) '#%1 '(+%)-*C 2)$%'$) .1'$2)%'.(1

'( $U.*' 4() '#$ 4()$*$$%3,$ 4&'&)$=

Z,'#(&2# .' .* .:;()'%1' '( 0(1*.-$) @E6GZ .1 )$,%'.(1 '( *&3W)$2.(1%, )%'.(1%,.*%'.(1;)(0$**$*C '#$ 0&))$1' EYG>ZJW0$1').0 %;;)(%0# :$%1* '#%' '#$ ;(+$) *')&0'&)$*C '#$ )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$**$* %)$ .21()$-= "#.* ,%0/ (4 /1(+,$-2$ .* ;)(3,$:%'.0%1- ;(*$* ;('$1'.%, 0(1*')%.1'* '( .:;)(?$- )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1= "#$ .:;,.0.'%**&:;'.(1 '#%' '#$ F?()9 Y(%*' %1- J$1$2%, %)$ '#$ :(*' ;(+$)4&, +.'#.1 '#$2)(&;.12 3$0%&*$ '#$9 %)$ '#$ *')(12$*' $0(1(:.$* +.'#.1 @E6GZC .* %1 $U%:;,$ (4'#.*= e(+$?$)C )$;()'* .1-.0%'$ '#%' .' .* .1 4%0' '#$ '#)$$ ,%1-W,(0/$- 0(&1').$*OB&)/.1% 7%*(C 6%,. %1- V.2$)QC +#(*$ *(,.-%).'9 .* *')$12'#$1$- 39 0(::(1 0&,'&)%,%1- #.*'().0%, 3(1-*C +#( 3$'+$$1 '#$: 4(): '#$ :(*' .:;()'%1' %1- ;(+$)4&,O.14():%,Q *&3W)$2.(1%, 3,(0 %1- %)$ $U$)0.*.12 .10)$%*.12 ;(,.'.0%, %1- $0(1(:.0;(+$) +.'#.1 @E6GZ= Z1 &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 '#.* '9;$ (4 *&3W)$2.(1%, -91%:.0 .* .1 '&)1


30/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; ZJC @E6GZ .*0&))$1',9 $U;%1-.12 .'* 0%;%0.'9 .1 '#$ %)$% (4 *$0&).'9 %1- ;$%0$/$$;.12 %1- :(?.12'(+%)-* '#$ 0)$%'.(1 (4 % *$0&).'9 0(::.**.(1= "#$)$ %)$ *$?$)%, 4%0'()* -).?.12 '#.*

3&' (1$ (4 '#$ /$9 .**&$* .* '#$ *$).(&* *$0&).'9 *.'&%'.(1 4%0.12 '#$ 6%,.WV.2$)WB&)/.1%7%*( 3,(0 .1 '#$ J%#$, O$=2= .1'$)1%'.(1%, '$))().*:C '#$ 4%,,W(&' (4 '#$ 8.39%1 0).*.*C'#$ "&%)$2 )$3$,,.(1C -)&2 *:&22,.12Q=

7)%10(;#(1$ >$*' Z4).0%1 0(&1').$* .* 1(' *')(12= A7FA.* 1(' ;)$*$1' .1 '#$ :%$*' Z4).0%= ^.?$1 '#$ .:;()'%10$ (4 @E6GZ .1 '#$ )$2.(1 %1-.'* 0(1'.1&$- )(,$ %* % *.21.4.0%1' ;,%9$) .1 '#$ .1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$**C % -$'%.,$- %1%,9*.*(4 @E6GZ %1- '#$ )$,%'.(1 3$'+$$1 .' %1- .'* :$:3$) *'%'$*C 39 $U'$)1%,,9

0(::.**.(1$- )$*$%)0#$)*C +(&,- 3$ &*$4&, 2(.12 4()+%)- %* +$,, %* 3$.12 :()$;)%0'.0%, '#%1 .1W#(&*$ +()/=

A$?$,(;.12 % 3$''$) &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 @E6GZ %1- (4 7)%10(;#(1$ >$*' Z4).0% :()$2$1$)%,,9 +(&,- 3$ 2((- 4() A7FA ;)%0'.0$= 6(*' 3%*.0%,,9C '#.* &1-$)*'%1-.12 (44$)* %:$%1* (4 $1*&).12 A7FAA($* V( e%): #$,; '( .-$1'.49 % 1$+ )%12$ (4 ;%)'1$)* .1 0(&1').$* +#$)$ .'* 4((';).1' .* 0&))$1',9,.:.'$-= 7&)'#$)C '#.* &1-$)*'%1-.12 0(&,- ;)(?.-$ '#$ 3%*.* 4() .:;)(?$- -(1()0(()-.1%'.(1 .1 '#$ )$2.(1C #$,;.12 '( 3)$%/ -(+1 ,.12&.*'.0 *.,(*=

G3'%.1.12 /1(+,$-2$%3,$ 7)%10(;#(1$ .1*.2#'* (1 '#$*$ .**&$* +.,, -$;$1- (1 %1&:3$) (4 4%0'()*= 7&1-%:$1'%,,9C '#$ 0(::.**.(1$- )$*$%)0#$)*C .1 %--.'.(1 '( '#$&*&%, )$c&.)$:$1'* )$2%)-.12 *')(12 )$,%'.(1*#.;* +.'# /$9 .14():%1'* O'#%' .*C 2((-1$'+()/*Q %1- %1%,9'.0%, 0%;%0.'9 +(&,- %,*( )$c&.)$ 7)$10# ,%12&%2$ 4,&$109= 8(0%,)$*$%)0# .1*'.'&'.(1* O,./$ 8ZJAE8Q %* +$,, %* ()2%1.*%'.(1* +.'# $U;$).$10$ .10(1-&0'.12 \EZ .1 7)%10(;#(1$ Z4).0% O,./$ GAFQ +(&,- ;)(?.-$ % 2((- 4.)*' ;(.1' (40%,,C '#(&2# 0(,,%3()%'.(1 +.'# -(1()* ;)$*$1' .1 0(&1')9 O$=2= Z7AQ 0(&,- %,*( #$,;+.'# '#$ .-$1'.4.0%'.(1 (4 ;('$1'.%, 0(1*&,'%1'*=

CDC \3.'.H=% (&&1%G A$?$,(;.12 % 3$''$) &1-$)*'%1-.12 (4 '#$ .1'$)$*'*C )$,%'.(1*#.;* %1-;)(0$**$* +.'#.1 '#$ ?%).(&* *'%'$* (4 EYG>ZJ )$,%'.12 '( )$2.(1%, .1'$2)%'.(1 .* %1.:;()'%1' ;).().'9 4() A7FA %1- ('#$) %0'()* *$$/.12 '( 0(1').3&'$ '( )$2.(1%,.1'$2)%'.(1 ;)(0$**$*= e(+$?$)C %* 1('$- %3(?$C %1 EYG>ZJ +.-$ *'&-9 %;;$%)* '(3$ '(( 3)(%- '( %,,(+ 4() '#$ '9;$ (4 .1W-$;'# *'&-9 )$c&.)$- '( ;)(-&0$ &*$4&,0(10,&*.(1* 0%;%3,$ (4 .14():.12 -(1() $12%2$:$1'= >$ *&22$*' % ,.:.'$- 1&:3$) (4.1-.?.-&%, 0(&1')9 0%*$ *'&-.$* 0(&,- ;)(?.-$ % 3$''$) +%9 4()+%)- %1- '#%' ^#%1%0(&,- 3$ % 4$%*.3,$ ;,%0$ '( 3$2.1 *&0# %1 $U$)0.*$=

J=-$ Q% 8#"Q -#: %#$+3 #.,$ '#$)$ .* *(:$ ,.:.'$-)$0(21.'.(1 (4 )$2.(1%, -.:$1*.(1* O$=2= %:(12 *'%44 .1 '#$ \).?%'$ J$0'()

A$?$,(;:$1' '$%:Q .1 '#$ A7FAW^#%1% 0(&1')9 (44.0$C %' ;)$*$1' '#$ 0(&1')9 (44.0$%;;$%)* '( ,%)2$,9 ?.$+ A7FAW >#.,$ V.2$).%.* +.-$,9 ?.$+$- %* '#$ -(:.1%1' ;(+$) .1 >$*' Z4).0%C '#$)$ .* % ).*/ '#%' %1


31/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; #%' .* 1$$-$- 1(+ .* %1 &;W'(W-%'$ %**$**:$1' (4 '#$ *$'* (4 .1'$)$*'* '#%'$U.*' +.'#.1 ^#%1% %1- '#$ ^#%1%.%1 *'%'$ +.'# )$*;$0' '( )$2.(1%, .**&$*=

;)$?%.,.12 ;(,.'.0%, $0(1(:9 %4'$) % 1&:3$) (4 9$%)* (4 *&*'%.1$- 2)(+'# (1 '#$$0(1(:.0 4)(1' %1- .1 '#$ )&1W&; '( :%


32/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;

CDI M6)* NH/.' %$/* 6HH&6'#- WG64. .', 2$*$'$+YH=% (&&1%G Z* 0(1-&.'* 4() .:;()'$- %1- $U;()'$- 2((-*C 1%'.(1%, ;()'* .1 >$*' Z4).0%%)$ /$9 0$1')$* (4 $0(1(:.0 %0'.?.'9 +#.0# %)$ 0).'.0%, 4() .10)$%*$- ;)(-&0'.?.'9 (4;).?%'$ .1?$*':$1' %1- '#&* 2)(+'# %1- -$?$,(;:$1' .1 '#$ )$2.(1= e(+$?$)C ;(()$44.0.$109 (4 ;()' (;$)%'.(1*C 0#%)%0'$).*$- 39 ,(12 -$,%9* %1- #.2# (44.0.%, %1-&1(44.0.%, 4.1%10.%, 0(*'*C -$;).?$* '#$ :$:3$) *'%'$* (4 /$9 *(&)0$* (4 )$?$1&$ %1-0(1').3&'$* '( '#$ #.2# 0(*' (4 .:;()'* %1- ,(+ .1')%W)$2.(1%, ')%-$ ?(,&:$*O\u,**(1$' %,=C RPPKQ=

J=-$ Q% 8#"Q -#: %#$+3 (),- B%1/W4&1-$- Z8""7\C *.12,$+.1-(+ 0&*'(:* ;(.1'* 4() $U'$)1%, ')%-$ %)$ 3$.12 0)$%'$- .1 4.?$ ;()'* %,(12 '#$Z3.-


33/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


34/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ;


35/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; %).?:%&0J\(,.09 B).$4.12* (1 A).?$)* (4 Y#%12$ .1 ^#%1% X= Z00)% %1- 8(1-(1L YAA %1- GAF=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHP%QB&)/.1% 7%*( ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$")%-$ Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vTN=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHP3Q^#%1% ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$ ")%-$Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vT[=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHP0Q V.2$).% ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$")%-$ Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vTK=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHP-Q J$1$2%, ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$")%-$ Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vT]=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHP$Q J 7)$$")%-$ Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vNP=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHH%Q 6%,. ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$ ")%-$Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vNT=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHH3Q "(2( ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$ ")%-$Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vNN=

B)(0/C 8=C G:(,&%3.C G=C %1- ?%1 A&*$1C V= ORPHH0QB$1.1 ^%; Z1%,9*.*L EYG>ZJ 7)$$ ")%-$Z)$%>$*' Z4).0% ")%-$ e&3 "$0#1.0%, I$;()' vNX=

A)%;$)C \= ORPHPQ I$'#.1/.12 '#$ OE&)(;$%1Q 7(&1-%'.(1* (4 J&3WJ%#%)%1 Z4).0%1 I$2.(1%,E0(1(:.0 F1'$2)%'.(1L Z \(,.'.0%, E0(1(:9 E**%9J GEYA A$?$,(;:$1' Y$1')$ >()/.12\%;$) V(= RST= \%).*L GEYA=


36/36

"#$%& '()*'+, -*+#.%& /.*$*01 *2 3(4#*$%2 #$ 6(5+ 72'#.% ; %*#.12'(1 AYL >(),- B%1/= Z?%.,%3,$ (1,.1$ %'L#'';L__*.'$)$*(&)0$*=+(),-3%1/=()2_Ew"^GsZV"FYGII_I$*(&)0$*_TPTX][TWHR][TSX[RSTNK_\^\EW^((-\)%0'.0$7)%:$+()/HRWRPPS=;-4=

5#%-.%2%,%C ^= 6= ORPHHQ F1*'.'&'.(1 B&.,-.12 4() Z4).0%1 I$2.(1%,.*:J ZAB >()/.12 \%;$)J$).$* (1 I$2.(1%, E0(1(:.0 F1'$2)%'.(1 V(= ]X= 6%1.,%L Z*.%1 A$?$,(;:$1' B%1/=

6(,,$)C B ORPPSQ I$2.(1%, %1- ^,(3%, ZU$* (4 Y(14,.0' W)$2.(1%, ()2%1.*%'.(1*LJ$%:,$** +$3 () ;%'0#+()/x Y).*.* J'%'$* I$*$%)0# Y$1')$ >()/.12 \%;$) VyX[=8(1-(1L 8JE=

V.1*.1C 5= Z= ORPPSQ @'0*.&A(),- B%1/=

I(,,%1-C D=W\=C %1- Z,;(),- B%1/=")a:(,.i)$*C 6=C %1- Z3-(&,C 6= W3()-$) %)$% 0((;$)%'.(1 3$'+$$1 V.2$) %1-

V.2$).%L "#$ 0%*$ (4 '#$ 6%)%-. 6.0)(W :C 7=C %1- "%9,()C F= $-*=ORPPKQ O*6/.A5%(*.&')*+: *& E%+0 #C/*6' 3>*1%&6% C/.: "P. B'+% ()/.12 \%;$) *$).$*= >%*#.12'(1L >(),- B%1/=
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTGOVANTICORR/Resources/3035863-1286395629347/PGPE-GoodPracticeFramework12-2009.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTGOVANTICORR/Resources/3035863-1286395629347/PGPE-GoodPracticeFramework12-2009.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTGOVANTICORR/Resources/3035863-1286395629347/PGPE-GoodPracticeFramework12-2009.pdfhttp://www.watradehub.com/sites/default/files/111219%2016th%20IRTG%20Report_en.pdfhttp://www.watradehub.com/sites/default/files/111219%2016th%20IRTG%20Report_en.pdfhttp://www.watradehub.com/sites/default/files/111219%2016th%20IRTG%20Report_en.pdfhttp://www.watradehub.com/sites/default/files/111219%2016th%20IRTG%20Report_en.pdfhttp://www.watradehub.com/sites/default/files/111219%2016th%20IRTG%20Report_en.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTGOVANTICORR/Resources/3035863-1286395629347/PGPE-GoodPracticeFramework12-2009.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTGOVANTICORR/Resources/3035863-1286395629347/PGPE-GoodPracticeFramework12-2009.pdf

odi pe of regionalism in wa.pdf

Documents