october 8, 2015 ieee clas & aiaa modern communication can prevent fatal air crashes sy levine 1...

46
October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s Real-Time’s Proactive Use Of Streamed Flight Recorder Data Sy Levine age: www.safelander.com email: sylevine1@sbcglob

Upload: brianne-dorsey

Post on 29-Jan-2016

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1

Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s Real-Time’s

Proactive Use Of Streamed Flight Recorder Data

Sy Levine web page: www.safelander.com email: [email protected]

Page 2: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 2

MAKES ITMAKES ITVIABLE AND DESIREABLE TO UTILIZEVIABLE AND DESIREABLE TO UTILIZE

ONE ONBOARD PILOTONE ONBOARD PILOT AND A REMOTELY LOCATED COPILOT FOR:AND A REMOTELY LOCATED COPILOT FOR:

SAFETYSAFETY SECURITYSECURITY

RELIABILITYRELIABILITY COST REDUCTIONCOST REDUCTION

Page 3: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 3

"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security & Reliability While Reducing Cost"

Reduce piloting costs by permitting a single onboard pilot and a remote copilot (that can safely provide the backup control for a plurality of aircraft).– A single remote-pilot can concurrently provide the backup for and safely

fly a plurality of airplanes using well known aircraft spacing/separation.– Utilizes highly-qualified remote-pilot to safely fly an aircraft in congested

air space, via ciphered radio telemetry to the aircraft and air traffic controllers.

– Permits the remote-pilot/copilot to control/fly/land an operational aircraft just as if he/she were the onboard pilot.

Reduce 9/11, Helios (FLT. 522-2005,121 fatality,B-737)/Payne Stewart(1999,Lear Jet, 5 fatality) Decompression crashes, etc.– When a plane substantially deviates from its approved flight plans, it is

presently possible to have a remote-pilot/copilot located in a secure, high-fidelity, virtual-reality aircraft simulator fly the plane to a safe landing at a sparsely populated airfield. The cost reduction by eliminating a 9/11 type crash would more than pay for the entire system and its operation for ten years.

– Planes that deviate onto potentially fatal runways can be stopped.

Page 4: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 4

"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security & Reliability While Reducing Cost“ (continued)

Reduce costly runway expansion programs.­ Provides enhanced tarmac visibility and situation awareness aboard the

aircraft and to the traffic controllers.­ Unifies and simplifies air traffic control and pilot displays and makes them

more comprehensive. Eliminates the present half cup full system where neither the controllers or

the pilots have shared the necessary information to prevent crashes. Reduces delays and permits higher traffic density on existing runways. Enhances tarmac safety.

Reduce aircraft operating costs. Decreases fuel utilization. Increases aircraft payload (reduced weight). Decreases avionics maintenance (less avionics and mechanical interfaces).

Page 5: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 5

Reduce the costs and problems associated with the recovery and utilization of onboard flight data via real-time telemetry of the digital flight data.

– Digital flight data is safely stored, in real-time on the ground computer’s memory for post flight analysis.

– Digital Flight Data recorder aboard the aircraft can provide data redundancy.– Permits Recorders to be used for automatic checkout of the aircraft prior to takeoff

during a flight, and post flight.– Gets safety personnel quickly to a crash site for possible triage and the saving of lives.– Reduces the anguish of crash victims families.

Reduce FOQA costs and its latency period;– All data is automatically telemetered to the ground in real-time for processing and

distribution. Provides the necessary real-time digital-data to open the door to knowledge based 4-dimenstional trajectory Air Traffic Management (ATM), aeronautics and navigation.

– Minimizes scheduled engine maintenance by real-time tracking of engine utilization. Reduce insurance costs by making the plane and airports safer and securer. Reduces LRU costs by eliminating TCAS hardware and performing that function in the air

and on the tarmac/ground via software (standard TCAS doesn’t function on the ground and can’t prevent ground incursions).

"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security & Reliability While Reducing Cost“

(continued)

Page 6: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 6

"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security & Reliability While Reducing Cost“ (continued)

Has many advantages over the current day onboard-only dual pilots approach, since the remote-pilot/copilot isn’t subject to loss of oxygen/decompression, extreme G forces, temperature, smoke, passenger disturbances and terrorists. – The ground-based cockpit virtual-reality simulator minimizes

problems associated with pilot disorientation, poor visibility, weather, runway selection and ground incursions, which have resulted in numerous fatal accidents.

– From a safety standpoint, the remote-pilot/copilot can communicate directly with flight operations, emergency and security personnel, ATC/ATM as well as with the aircraft manufacturer’s design/engineering experts on how best to handle an aircraft operation problem thereby preventing the loss of life.

Utilizes present state-of-the-art communication security, communication technology, and data storage to make flying safer, securer and more economical.

Provides a safety and security technology bridge to the future use of unmanned cargo aircraft (UCA).

Page 7: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 7

FIGURE 1. COMMUNICATION SYSTEM OVERVIEW

AIRCRAFT THAT CAN BE REMOTELY CONTROLLED

GLOBAL SATELLITE TWO WAY CIPHERED DIGITAL DATA

COMMUNICATION LINK

REMOTE COPILOT IN A SECURE AIRCRAFT

SIMULATOR (VIRTUAL REALITY COCKPIT)

ATC/M, WEATHER, MAP, TERRAIN & SECURITY DATA TWO WAY SECURE GROUND CIPHERED DIGITAL DATA LINK

SIMULATORPROCESSOR

Page 8: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 8

Sensor Multiplexer Transceiver Video DataAcoustic Data

Advisory System

GPS/GLONASS Receiver

Performance and Control Sensor Data

GPS/GLONASS Navigation Satellite

Global Satellite Two-Way Secure Ciphered Digital Data Communication Link

Aircraft That Can Be Remotely Piloted

Remote Pilot Electronic Interface (FCU, ILS, AUTOPILOT INTERFACES)

FIGURE 2. AVIONICS SYSTEM

Page 9: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 9

FIGURE 3. TWO-WAY CIPHERED DIGITAL DATA & VOICE COMMUNICATION LINK

CGBSCentral Ground-Based Processing Station

Page 10: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 10

COM. SATELLITE CAPABILITY/ YEAR 2008 2006 2004 2000

NUMBER FLTS/DAY (GROWTH 2.5%/YR.) 38,896 37,944 35,280 33,600

AVERAGE FLIGHT TIME IN MINUTES 95 95 95 95

DFDR DATA RATE IN WORDS/SEC/AIRCRAFT 128 128 128 64

DFDR DATA WORD LENGTH IN BITS 12 12 12 12

DFDR DATA RATE (BITS/SEC/AIRCRAFT) 1,536 1,536 1,536 768

TOTAL DATA RATE FOR ALL OPERATIONAL AIRCRAFT (NOTE: LESS THAN 8000 AIRCRAFT IN OPERATION – SKY OR TARMACK) IN MEGA-BAUD

12.288 12.288 12.288 12.288

USING 2X (SHANNON) MULTIPLICATION YIELDS THE TOTAL DATA RATE IN MEGA-BAUD­

25 25 25 25

DAILY STORAGE FOR ALL AIRCRAFT EASILY FITS ON A SINGLE PC DISC. IN GIGA-BYTES

100 100 100 100

TABLE 1.BASIC DATA STORAGE AND RATES25 MEGA-BAUD AND STORAGE 100 GIGA-BYTE/DAYNote: In 2014 PCs Have 1 Terabyte (1000 Gigabytes) of Storage

Page 11: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 11

Aircraft Warnings and

Cautions

Antenna Control & RF and UHF Interface

(Cipher, Anti-Jam &

Anti-spoof Controller)

Aircraft Simulation

ProcessorData

Storage

Air Carriers and Aircraft

Manufacturers Communication

Module

ATC Module

REMOTE PILOT

SECURE

AIRCRAFT SIMULATOR

ENHANCED SAFE AND SECURE

“BLACK BOX”DATA

GROUND BASED

DISPLAY & CONTROL

FIGURE 4. CENTRAL GROUND-BASED PROCESSING STATION (CGBS)

Page 12: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 12

FIGURE 5.GROUND-BASED DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM

ProcessorProcessor

ATC/M Module

Air Carriers and Aircraft

Manufacturers Communication

Module

MapDatabase

WeatherDatabase

TopographicDatabase Air Carrier and Aircraft

Manufacturer Facility

Emergency & Maintenance

Warnings/ Cautions

Simulations

Air Carrier &Aircraft Manufacturer Facility

1

N

En - route ATC/M

TRACON ATC/M

1N

1N

SAFELANDER(REMOTE PILOT CAPABILITY)

SECURE AIRCRAFT SIMULATOR

Page 13: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 13

COLOR CODE TRANSLATOR AIRCRAFT GREEN RED BLUEFUSELAGE PLANE MOVING STOPPED -------ENGINE HIGH THRUST OFF LOWBRAKE ------ ON ------- ESTIMATED

COLLISION POINT

COLLISION TRAJECTORY

PROJECTION

TRANSLATOR

DOWN UP

­­­­LANDING GEAR --

LANDING GEAR DOWN- BRAKE ON­­­­­

Note: The 583 fatality Tenerife crash was head on. This pictorial is a generic representation and shows aircraft orthogonal on the runway.

FIGURE 6. GENERIC REPRSENTATION OF THE 583 FATALITY TENERIFE CRASH & OTHERS

SAFELANDER PROVIDES AUTOMATED COLLISION AVOIDANCE ALERTS ATC/M & CAS ENHANCED CAPABILITY DISPLAY

Page 14: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 14

FIGURE 7. TENERIFE, ET AL., NO MORE

COLOR CODE TRANSLATOR AIRCRAFT GREEN RED BLUEFUSELAGE PLANE MOVING STOPPED -------ENGINE HIGH THRUST OFF LOWBRAKE ------ ON -------

PROJECTION SAFE TRAJECTORY

PROJECTION SAFE TRAJECTORY

TRANSLATOR

DOWN­­­­­­­­­­­­UP

­LANDING­GEAR ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­--­

­LANDING­GEAR­DOWN-­BRAKE­ON

Note: The 583 fatality Tenerife crash was head on. This pictorial is a generic representation and shows aircraft orthogonal on the runway.

SAFELANDER­PROVIDES­A­SAFE­TRAJECTORY­DISPLAY­­ATC/M­&­CAS­ENHANCED­­CAPABILITY

Page 15: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 15

A FATAL CRASH IN THE GROUND INCURSION FAMILY IS THE 79 FATALITY 10/31/00 SINGAPORE AIRLINE’S FLIGHT 006

The 21st Century Aviation System controller and the pilot would have full visibility display of the plane going onto the wrong hazardous runway way long before the fatal accident occurred. The controller would then provide manual and automatic alerts to the pilot of the problem. These alerts would have probably prevented the needless loss of lives. If these alerts to the pilot failed, the controller would shut the plane down to prevent the fatal accident.

The system, not the pilot’s error, killed these passengers. We have allowed ignorance and a dark age autopsy mode to solely exist. Most errors or problems need not result in fatal accidents.

CLEARED FOR RUNWAY 05L

FATAL

RUNWAY 05R TAKEN

FIGURE 8. FATAL TARMAC CRASHES ARE SIMPLY UNNECESSARY AND ARE PREVENTABE

Page 16: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 16

Flt 5191 should have gone down the 7003 foot Runway 22

Flt 5191 erroneously went down the 3500 foot Runway 26

FIGURE 8-A. Comair Flight 5191 Fatal Crash On Aug. 27, 2006 Killing 49 People (First Officer James Polehinke Was The Sole

Survivor)

SAFELANDER would have prevented this crash by displaying to the pilot in real-time the safe trajectory

This is a recurring tarmac crash that was readily preventable. It was due to a fatal flaw in the traffic control shared information system and not pilot error.

Page 17: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 17

FIGURE 9. SAFELANDER CAS DISPLAY

PROJECTED COLLISION TRAJECTORY BASED ON AIRCRAFT TRACK

VECTORS

• VELOCITIES ( Vn,Ve, Vh)

• PRESENT POSITIONS

• PROJECTED POSITIONS

TRANSLATOR

DOWN­­­­­UP

LANDING­GEAR ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­--­­­­­­­

NOTE: ONE LANDING GEAR IS DOWN

ESTIMATED COLLISION POINT

COLLISION

PROJECTION

SAFE

TRAJECTORIES

LANDING GEAR

15 MINUTES OF FUEL REMAINING

FLASHING PROBLEM ICONS

Page 18: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 18

FIGURE 10. SAFELANDER PROVIDES AN AIRCRAFT DATA SUPERHIGHWAY (SIMILAR TO THE INTERNET)

THAT RESPECTS AN AIR CARRIER’S PRIVILEGED DATA

GPS SATLEO DATA LINK SAT

CGBSONLY AC1 DATA ONLY AC2 DATA

A B C D

A,B,C,D,... DATA

PRIVILEGED AIR CARRIER CIPHERED DATA

ATC/M &CAS DATA

AC1/P1

AC2/P1

P1 P2 P1 P2

AC# = AIR CARRIER (1,2,...) P# = PLANE (1,2,...)

Page 19: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 19

0.00

200.00

400.00

600.00

800.00

1000.00

1990 1992 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008

AVERAGE $ COST PER PLANE PER AVERAGE FLIGHT(AVG. FLT. TIME = 95 MIN.)

$cost/plane/avg.flt.

2008 ESTIMATE $9.1/FLT.

YEAR

FIGURE 11. CHRONOLOGY OF SATELLITE PER FLIGHT COMMUNICATION COSTS

Page 20: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 20

RAFT RAFT RAFTTotal Total US Operators US Operators Total Total US Operators

FATAL ACCIDENT TYPE/QTY Fatalities %Fatalities Fatalities %Fatalities Fatalities %Fatalities FatalitiesControlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT) 2396 32.01% 312 19.68% 479 17.04% 62 - CFIT Only On Approach 957 12.79% 0.00% 191 6.81% 0Loss of Control In Flight 2228 29.77% 482 30.41% 1114 39.62% 96In Flight Fire 760 10.15% 340 21.45% 152 5.41% 68Sabatage 607 8.11% 254 16.03% 546 19.43% 229Mid-air Collision 506 6.76% 0 0.00% 101 3.60% 0Hijack 306 4.09% 38 2.40% 275 9.79% 34Ice and/or Snow 162 2.16% 57 3.60% 32 1.15% 11Landing 128 1.71% 3 0.19% 26 0.91% 1Windshear 119 1.59% 37 2.33% 36 1.27% 11Fuel Exhaustion 113 1.51% 0 0.00% 23 0.80% 0Other Unknown 111 1.48% 17 1.07% 22 0.79% 3Runway Incursion 45 0.60% 45 2.84% 5 0.16% 5Rejected Take Off (RTO) 3 0.04% 0 0.00% 1 0.02% 0

TOTAL FATALITIES 7484 100% 1585 100% 2812 100% 521% REDUCTION IN FATALITIES 62% 67%

RAFT RAFT RAFTFatal % Fatal US Fatal US % Fatal Fatal % Fatal US Fatal

FATAL ACCIDENT TYPE/QTY Accidents Accidents Accidents Accidents Accidents Accidents AccidentsControlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT) 36 26.47% 4 11.76% 7 15.32% 1Loss of Control In Flight 38 27.94% 11 32.35% 19 40.43% 2In Flight Fire 4 2.94% 2 5.88% 1 1.70% 0Sabatage 5 3.68% 1 2.94% 5 9.57% 1Mid-air Collision 2 1.47% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0Hijack 8 5.88% 1 2.94% 7 15.32% 1Ice and/or Snow 5 3.68% 3 8.82% 1 2.13% 1Landing 9 6.62% 1 2.94% 2 3.83% 0Windshear 3 2.21% 1 2.94% 1 1.91% 1Fuel Exhaustion 7 5.15% 0 0.00% 1 2.98% 0Other Unknown 14 10.29% 6 17.65% 3 5.96% 1Runway Incursion 4 2.94% 4 11.76% 0 0.00% 0Rejected Take Off (RTO) 1 0.74% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0

TOTAL FATALITIES 136 100% 34 100% 47 100% 8% REDUCTION FATAL ACCIDENTS 65% 78%

THE YEARS 1987 THROUGH 1996 (NOTE: DOESN’T INCLUDE 3000 DEATHS IN 9/11/2001)

TABLE 2. WORLDWIDE AIR CARRIER FATALITIES AND FATAL ACCIDENTS

Page 21: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 21

US AIRLINE SAFETY3 YR. ENSEMBLE SLIDING AVERAGEFATALITIES PER 100 MILLION MILES

0.005.00

10.0015.0020.00

YEARS

FATA

LITI

ES

INCLUDES ALL 9/11 FATALITIES

Average = 1.73 Median = 1.89

Average = 4.02 Median = 1.89

Page 22: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 22

WITHOUT SAFELANDER IT WILL RECUR

Page 23: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 23

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 24: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 24

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 25: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 25

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 26: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 26

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 27: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 27

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 28: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 28

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 29: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 29

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 30: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 30

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 31: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 31

WITH SAFELANDER WE HAVE A COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY

Page 32: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 32

Table 3. Back-up Material 9/11/2001

Notice that the departure and crash times would have permitted a single remote pilot in a ground-based simulator to take real-time control of each aircraft and sequentially land them at sparsely populated landing sites:

On September 11, 2001 the following occurred:

AIRCRAFT_ CAR. FLT­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­DEPARTURE­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­CRASH SITE ­FATALITIES

­­­­­­­­­­­BOEING 767 AAL 11 7:59 AM 8:46 AM WTC 92 BOEING 767 UAL 175 7:58 AM 9:03 AM WTC 65

BOEING 757 AAL 77 8:10 AM 9:43 AM PENTAGON 64 BOEING 757 UAL 93 8:44 AM 10:10 AM PA. 44

A total of 265 died aboard aircraft and about 2700 died on the ground.

The cost of the disaster was estimated at over 10 billion dollars which is more than five times the estimated 2 billion dollars required to make SAFELANDER operational.

As bad as 9/11 was, the terrorists could have inflicted much worse damage by using the aircraft as a guided bombs and flown/crashed into some nuclear plants.

Page 33: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 33

Sensor Multiplexer Transceiver Video DataAcoustic Data

Advisory System

GPS/GLONASS Receiver

Performance and Control Sensor Data

GPS/GLONASS Navigation Satellite

Global Satellite Two-Way Secure Ciphered Digital Data Communication Link

RAFT sends the digital flight data and cockpit voice information to the ground to provide real-time safe storage, timely retrieval, expert system

alerts, & to enhance safety, security, reliability and reduce cost . June 1, 2009, AirFrance, Airbus A330, Flight 447, 228 fatalities took two

years to find the flight recorders. Safelander would have found the problems with the pitot tubes and could have prevented the cash.

Aircraft’s Flight Data Safely Stored On Ground and Available For Real-Time Utilization

Aircraft Black Boxes Only For Redundancy

Page 34: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 34

On October 21, 2009 Northwest, Airbus A320, Flight 188, flew past its destination with no FAA communication for an hour and 18 minutes.

(Flt between San Diego, CA to Minneapolis, MN) In all that time no fighter plane took off to intercept Flight 188. This period is

longer than either AAL Flight 11 or UAL Flight 175 needed to take-off and crash into the World Trade Center on 9/11/2001.

SAFELANDER PREVENTS 9/11 RECURRENCE Without It We Depend On Luck

Page 35: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 35

March 8, 2014, 0041: Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 departs from March 8, 2014, 0041: Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 departs from Kuala Lumpur International Airport and is due to land in Beijing at Kuala Lumpur International Airport and is due to land in Beijing at

0630 the same day. On board the Boeing 777-200ER are 227 0630 the same day. On board the Boeing 777-200ER are 227 passengers and 12 crew.passengers and 12 crew.

The scandal is that, as of September 2015 and extensive/expensive searches, no one knows where the plane is or what caused the tragedy.

The critical flight data was locked up in the DFDR recorder aboard the plane and never effectively data streamed its information to the ground for safe retrievable storage and possible used in real-time for crash avoidance.

The communication system on commercial carrier aircraft is a low bandwidth technically obsolete system that wouldn’t be tolerated by the military for UAVs/RPVsUAVs/RPVs (drones).

Page 36: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 36

March 24, 2015, Germanwings, Flight 9525, Airbus A320-200 March 24, 2015, Germanwings, Flight 9525, Airbus A320-200 Started to Descend @ 9:31 & Crashed at 9:41 into the French Started to Descend @ 9:31 & Crashed at 9:41 into the French

AlpsAlps On board the were 144 passengers and 6 crew. On board the were 144 passengers and 6 crew.

The Co-pilot, Andreas Lubitz Deliberately Caused The Fatal CrashThe Co-pilot, Andreas Lubitz Deliberately Caused The Fatal Crash

The planes altitude dropped from an altitude of 36,000 feet to 6000 feet (the height of the mountain) in 10 minutes time.

The last ten minutes the copilot didn’t respond to ATC. There was plenty of time for Safelander to prevent this crash. Lubitz’s suicide isn’t the first case of suicidal pilots.Note: The BEA, Bureau d'Enquêtes et d'Analyses pour la sécurité de l'aviation civile, is the French equivalent

to the NTSB

Page 37: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 37

Some Other Examples of Pilot Suicide Crashes

Commercial Flights of Carrier Aircraft•August 1994 – 44 fatalities Royal Air Maroc ATR-42

•December 1997 – 104 fatalities Silk Air Flight 185, Boeing 737

•October 1999 – 217 fatalities Egypt Air Flight 990, Boeing 767

•November 2013 – 33 fatalities LAM Flight 470, Embraer ERJ 190 

•Suicide?March 2014? - 239 fatalities Malaysian Air Flight MH-370, Boeing 777

Military Aircraft Also Have Crashes Due to Pilot Suicide April, 1997 – 1 fatality  A-10 Thunderbolt II Attack Aircraft

Flew 100’s of miles without radio contact. It took 3 weeks to find the crash site in a Colorado mountain. The pilot’s body recovered, but the four, 500-pound Mk-82 bombs it carried are still missing.

Page 38: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 38

Number of Commercial Airline Fatal Accidents by Decadesand their Causes – It Hardley Changes

The table above was for 19 or more passengers per plane Compiled from the PlaneCrashInfo.com accident database

Causes 50s 60s 70s 80s 90s2000

sAvg.

Total Pilot Error 58 63 44 57 55 57 56Pilot Error 42 36 25 29 29 34 32

 Pilot Error  (weather related)

10 18 14 16 21 18 16

 Pilot Error (mechanical related)

6 9 5 2 5 5 5

 Other Human Error 3 8 9 5 8 6 6 Weather 16 9 14 14 8 6 12

 Mechanical Failure 21 19 20 21 18 22 20 Sabotage 3 5 11 12 10 9 8

 Other Cause 0 2 2 1 1 0 1

Page 39: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 39

In Conclusion "Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security &

Reliability While Reducing Cost"

Aircraft payload and fuel economy by reducing aircraft weight and avionics; (eg: does TCAS function better in the air & adds that function on the ground without having the present TCAS hardware on planes)

Homeland security of the public and its edifices; – Prevents the recurrence of 9/11 type disasters;– Prevents unauthorized aircraft from flying into

restricted airspace and their potential destruction; Airport efficiency, utilization and automation by

automatically providing all of the data necessary for enhanced safe visibility;– Through-put (the number of daily takeoffs and

landings an airport; can safely accommodate)– Prevents ground incursions.

Increases:

Page 40: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 40

In Conclusion (continued)"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security

& Reliability While Reducing Cost"

Situation awareness to the pilot/s and controllers using simple unified real-time displays that show all of the necessary data required for aircraft safety;

ADS-B utility and economical justification; The real-time digital-data required for safe and secure 4-

dimensional ATC/M and free-flight; Safety of flight;

– Prevents decompression disasters (eg: Payne Stewart Learjet/5 fatliites/1999, Helios/Flt 522/Boeing 737/121 fatalities/2005 etc.), hijacking, rogue pilot and pilot error crashes;

– Allows for the use of simulations and expert systems to prevent aircraft problems from turning into fatal crashes;

Increases (Continued):

Page 41: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 41

In Conclusion (continued) "Emerging Technology Revolutionizing Aircraft Safety, Security, Reliability & Cost Reduction "

The cost of flying; The need for expensive runway expansion programs; Aircraft crashes; Hijacking and Suicide; The number of aircraft that fly unauthorized into

restricted airspace; Aircraft weight; Piloting and maintenance personnel costs; Aircraft avionics costs; Aircraft purchase costs; Insurance costs; The need to recover flight data recorders;

Decreases:

Page 42: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 42

In Conclusion (continued)"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security

& Reliability While Reducing Cost"

The time and money spent on flight recorder recovery and recorder maintenance (sometimes the recorder isn’t recovered or has problems in the data it is supposed to record);

The time to get to a crash site for possible triage and the saving of lives FOQA costs and its latency period;

– All data is automatically telemetered to the ground in real-time for processing and distribution;

The number of and ambiguity of avionics and ATC/M displays;– Position, heading, attitude, breaking status, engine status, landing

gear status, fuel remaining, etc. are now available & clearly displayed;

Voice communication bandwidth and the speech comprehension ambiguities that have led to crashes;– Provides a good portion of the safety related data automatically in

Usable display and alert forms;

Decreases (Continued):

Page 43: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 43

In Conclusion (continued)"Emerging Technology Can Increase Safety, Security

& Reliability While Reducing Cost"

Costly runway expansion programs by providing enhanced tarmac visibility;

Flight delays by safely decreasing aircraft separation; Aircraft fuel cost per pound of payload by eliminating

items unrelated to payload; The maintenance costs for aircraft avionics and

mechanical systems by having less of them; Aircraft purchase costs by eliminating items unrelated

to payload; and Insurance costs and liability claims.

Decreases (Continued):

Page 44: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 44

Some References & URL’s Safelander (see http://www.safelander.com for China Patent (CN101093617 B) and Dutch Magazine Article

– The Remote Aircraft Flight Recorder and Advisory Telemetry System, RAFT (Patented),­And It's Ability to Reduce fatal Air Accidents By 78%­While Enhancing Air Space Capacity, Operational Efficiency and Aircraft Security ­

– http://www.ntsb.gov/events/symp_rec/proceedings/authors/levine.pdft US PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE (PATENT NUMBER SEARCH):

– http://patft.uspto.gov/netahtml/PTO/srchnum.htm “Safelander” 7,099,752 Lenell & Levine August 29, 2006 “Remote, aircraft, global, paperless maintenance system”­­­­­­5,974,349 Levine October 26, 1999 “Remote, aircraft, global, paperless maintenance system” RE39,618 E Levine May 8, 2007

“Remote aircraft flight recorder and advisory system” 5,890,079­ Levine March 30, 1999

AIEE/IEEE/SAE Digital Avionics Conference (DASC) Nov. 1998 “The Remote Flight Recorder …” *

– htpp://www.ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel4/5955/15955/00739808.pdf?arnumber=739808 ­AIEE/IEEE/SAE Digital Avionics Conference (DASC) Oct. 2007 “An Onboard Pilot & Remote …” *

– htpp://www.ieeexplore.ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpls/abs_all.jsp?arnumber=4391923 Advanced Aerospace Manufacturing Conference April 23-24, 2009

– “Emerging Technology Enhances Aviation Safety, Security While Providing Cost Reduction”

NOTE: * Both DASC papers won the best session paper awards.

Page 45: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 45

“Thanks to commercial aircraft I got over my fear of flying.”

“Although you know that flying is:twenty-five times more lethal than travel on the international

space station & five times more lethal than train travel.”

Lucky Flight 777

Check In

Page 46: October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 1 Prevention of Fatal Aircraft Crashes By Modern Communication’s

October 8, 2015 IEEE CLAS & AIAA Modern Communication Can Prevent Fatal Air Crashes Sy Levine 46

"Emerging Technology Revolutionizing Aircraft Safety, Security, Reliability & Cost

Reduction /The New Paradigm "

CONCLUDING REMARKS

QUESTIONS AND OPEN DISCUSSION OF THE ISSUES & PRESENTATION