october 21, 2013(marked)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

1/15

21 October 2013 Agenda Page1

Republic of the PhilippinesSANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD

City of Baguio

REGULAR SESSION, 21 OCTOBER 2013, 2:00 P.M.SESSION NR. 11

A. OPENING OF THE SESSION1. Opening Prayer

HON. PETER C. FIANZAshall lead the opening and closing prayers.

2. Pambansang AwitBaguio MarchPCL Creed

HON. FRED L. BAGBAGENshall lead in reciting the PCL Creed.

3. Roll Call

B. ORDER OF BUSINESS

1. Minutes of the Regular Session/s:R-09 Regular Session on September 23, 2013

2.

INVITATIONS:

Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-019Resolution Numbered 07, series of 2013, of Camp 7 Barangay "Presenting for information thesurvey plan (ground survey) which excludes ancestral lands prepared by J.R. Fernandez Surveyingand Engineering Service."

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends that the matter be

noted.(Item 2, 30 September 2013 Agenda)(NOTE: [a] There is no attached copy of said survey plan;[b] The following personalities were requested to be present in todays meeting to be one of the resourcepersons relative to the survey plan (ground survey) prepared by their office which excludes ancestral lands:

1. Hon. CLARENCE L. BAGUILAT, Regional Executive Director, DENR-CAR;2. Engr. PHILIP P. PILUDEN, Geodetic Engineer, Pinget Barangay;3. Engr. JOE RAYMUND E. FERNANDEZ, Geodetic Engineer, J.E. Fernandez Surveying and

Engineering Service; and4. Engr. JOSE E. FERNANDEZ, Geodetic Engineer, J.E. Fernandez Surveying and Engineering Service.5. Punong Barangay CONSTANCIO F. DANAO, Camp 7 Barangay)

3. Committee Report Nr. TOURISM-2013-009Letter dated 16 April 2013 of Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan, forwarding for appropriateaction the request of Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association Inc., seeking among others support for thecrafting of a national measure or law delineating under their management the Ibaloy HeritageGarden at Burnham Park, Baguio City. Attached to said letter are the following:

[a] Letter dated 05 April 2013 of Mr. Michael G. Aguinaldo, Deputy Executive Secretary for

Legal Affairs, Office of the President of the Philippines to Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G.Domogan, requesting submission to their office on or before 17 April 2013 of His Honor'scomments and recommendation regarding the request of Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association Inc.;and

[b] Letter dated 16 April 2013 of Regional Executive Director Clarence L. Baguilat,DENR-CAR, Baguio City to Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan, requesting commentregarding the request of Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association Inc.

The Committee on Tourism, Special Events, Parks and Playgrounds recommends to furnishthe Office of the President of the Philippines and the DENR-CAR the minutes of the meetingwhen Resolution No. 182, series of 2010 dated August 16, 2010 entitled, "DESIGNATINGTHAT PORTION OF BURNHAM PARK BETWEEN THE CHILDREN'S PLAYGROUNDAND THE CITY ORCHIDARIUM AS SITE FOR THE MATEO CARIO MONUMENTAND AS AN IBALOI HERITAGE GARDEN" was approved.

The minutes of the meeting is clear as to the intent of the Council in approving the saidresolution. The intent is for the portion of Burnham Park between the Orchidarium andChildren's Park to be designated as Ibaloi Heritage Garden with a Mateo Cario Monument.It will be part of the Burnham Park Master Development Plan as conceived by the Universityof the Cordilleras. The construction and management of the garden and monument will bedone by the City Government of Baguio.

May it be stated that the City Government of Baguio recognizes the indispensable contributionmade by the Ibalois and being the original and indigenous inhabitants of the City of Baguiohence the city government institutionalized the Ibaloi Day and made it a regular activity of thecity government.

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

2/15


The application therefore of Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association, Inc. with the Office of the Presidentto delineate the Ibaloi Heritage at Burnham Park under their management and control maynot be in consonance to the approved resolution. The intent is clear that the designated areashall be to give honor and recognition to the Ibaloi through the installation of the MateoCario Monument and designating the same as Ibaloi Heritage Garden and the citygovernment is to maintain that area of Burnham Park.

The committee suggest that the Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association, Inc. instead submit anapplication to adopt the park under the adopt-a-park program of the city subject to rules andregulations as implemented by the city government. (Item 3, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

(NOTE: [a] Ordinance No. 09, s. 2013 institutionalized the Ibaloi Day and making it a regular activity of theCity of Baguio.[b] Resolution No. 182, s. 2010 designated that portion of Burnham Park between the Children's Playgroundand the City Orchidarium as site for the Mateo Cario Monument and as an Ibaloi Heritage Garden.[c] Resolution No. 395, s. 2009 declared February 23 of every year as Ibaloi Day in the City of Baguio, incommemoration of the recognition of the United States Supreme Court of Nati ve Title for Ibaloy Leader MateoCario.)[d] The following personalities were requested to be present in todays meeting to be one of the resourcepersons relative to the above request:

1. Mr. JACKSON P. CHIDAY, President, Onjon Ni Ivadoy Association Inc.; and2. Arch. ROBERT V. ROMERO, University of the Cordilleras.)

4. Committee Report Nr. EGAP-2013-027Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 074-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. and Hon. Fred L.

Bagbagen entitled, "Inviting the Human Resource Management Officer and the Local FinanceCommittee to explain and to give details on whether or not Executive Order No. 80 can apply toofficials and employees of the City Government of Baguio."

The Committee on Ethics, Governmental Affairs and Personnel recommends APPROVAL ofthe foregoing resolution.(Item 4, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

(NOTE: Executive Order No. 80 reads, "Directing the adoption of a Performance-Based Incentive System for

government employees was signed by His Excellency President Benigno Simeon C. Aquino III on 20 July2012 which establishes and implements a Performance-Based System that will motivate higher performanceand greater accountability in the public sector and secure the accomplishment of commitments and targets".[b] The following personalities were requested to be present in todays meeting to be one of the resourcepersons relative to the above proposed resolution:

1. The MEMBERS of theLocal Finance Committee; and2. Dr. ESTRELLA V. BISQUERA, City Human Resource and Management Officer.)

5. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2013-008Letter dated 04 October 2012 of Ms. Lourdes S. Santos, regarding Stall No. 75, Fish Extension, City

Market, Baguio City.

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce recommends to adopt the recommendationsof the Hon. Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan, Chairperson of the Baguio City Market (BCMA) ascontained in his letter dated November 9, 2012 denying all the herein letters of requests forreconsideration. The Committee further recommends to UPHOLD the validity of the awardof the subject stalls at the City Market, Baguio to the respective winning bidders and thelatter's right to peacefully occupy the same.

Hon. Peter C. Fianza, Member of the Committee signified, "To file a corrective proposedordinance."(Item 4, 23 September 2013 Agenda)

(NOTE: The above matter is related to the following:[a]Letter dated 18 September 2012 of the heirs of Agustina Dizon represented by Ms. Remedios Dizon-Castillo,praying that a resolution be rendered granting their appeal for the declaration as null and void the award of Stall No.

13, Entrails Section, Baguio City Market to the winning bidder and ordering the lease rights be reverted back to them.[b] Letter dated 02 July 2012 of Ms. Remedios Castillo, requesting action on her appeal for the awarding of Stall 13,Entrails Section, Baguio City Public Market. This was forwarded to the Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce

on 04 July 2012.[c] Letter dated 29 May 2012 of Ms. Corazon S. Gonzales, Atty-In-Fact/daughter of Ms. Teresita Santos-Gonzales,following up their appeal that the lease right over Stall No. 74, Fish Extension Section, City Market be reverted back toher mother. This was forwarded to the Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce on 30 May 2012.[d] Letter dated 12 April 2012 of Ms. Remedios Dizon Castillo and Ms. Corazon Gonzales, reiterating their letter datedMay 24, 2011 regarding their appeal for the awarding of different stalls at Fish and Entrails Sections, Baguio PublicMarket. This was forwarded to the Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce on 16 April 2012.[e] Letter dated 11 April 2012 of Ms. Remedios Dizon Castillo and Ms. Corazon Gonzales requesting clarificationregarding the 3rd Indorsement dated 08 June 2011 of the Sangguniang Panlungsod ng Baguio forwarding to theBaguio City Market Authority (BCMA) for comment the following:

a. Letter dated 24 May 2011 of Ms. Lourdes Santos to Mr. Policarpio Tamayo, Baguio City Market Authority:

1. appealing reconsideration on the implementation of Resolution 001-09 of the Baguio City Market Authority[cancellation of lease contract of Lourdes Santos for stall numbered 75 Fish Extension]; and

2. praying that the award of Stall No. 75, Fish Extension, City Market, Baguio City be declared null and void andthe lease rights be reverted back to her.

b. Letter dated 24 May 2011 of Ms. Corazon S. Gonzales, Atty-in-Fact of Teresita Santos Baltazar to Mr.Policarpio Tamayo, Baguio City Market Authority:1. appealing reconsideration for the awarding of Stall 74, Fish Extension Section, Baguio City Public Market; and

2. praying that the awarding of said stall be declared null and void and the lease rights be reverted back to thecomplainant.

c. Letter dated 24 May 2011 of Ms. Remedios Castillo, representative of the heirs of Agustina Dizon to Mr.

Policarpio Tamayo, Baguio City Market Authority:1. appealing reconsideration for the awarding of Stall 13, Entrails Section, Baguio City Public Market; and2. praying that the awarding of said stall be declared null and void and the lease rights be reverted back to the

complainant.)

[f] The following personalities were requested to be present in today's meeting to be one of the resourcepersons relative to the appeal for reconsideration on the awards of stalls in the Baguio City Public Market:

[1] Ms. ALICIA L . ONOZA, City Treasurer;[2] Ms. LOURDES S. SANTOS[Stall No. 75, Fish Extension Section];[3] Ms. CORAZON S. GONZALES[Stall No. 74, Fish Extension Section]; and[4] Ms. REMEDIOS DIZON-CASTILLO[Stall No. 13, Entrails Section].)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

3/15


6. Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0103-13 of Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Hon. Elmer O. Datuin andHon. Joel A. Alangsab entitled, "Inviting in aid of legislation Atty. Crizaldy M. Barcelo, Regional

Technical Director for Land Management Service, DENR-CAR, Edgardo S. Flor, OIC, CENRO-CAR, Atty. Guerrero A. Felipe, Register of Deeds, Baguio City and Atty. Melchor Carlos R.

Rabanes, OIC-City Legal Officer, Baguio City, to shed light on the status of all unvalidated 211titles in the City of Baguio." (Item 66, 16 September 2013 Agenda)

(NOTE: [a] The above proposed resolution was approved during the 16 September 2013 Regular Session;[b] The following personalities were requested to be present in todays meeting to be one of the resourcepersons relative to the above proposed resolution:

1. Att y. CRIZALDY M. BARCELO, Regional Technical Director, Land Management Service, DENR-CAR;2. Engr. EDGARDO S. FLOR, Officer-in-Charge, CENRO, DENR-CAR;3. Att y. GUERRERO A. FELIPE, Register of Deeds; and4. Att y. MELCHOR CARLOS R. RABANES, Officer-in-Charge, City Legal Office.)

7.

UNFINISHED BUSINESS 16 SEPTEMBER 2013 REGULAR SESSION:

Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-010Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 046-09 of Hon. Nicasio M. Aliping Jr. Establishing livelihood andtraining program in the City of Baguio.

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD) recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution.

Further, the members of the committee adopt to be the authors of the said resolutionconsidering that the proponent is no longer a member of the City Council. (Item 5, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

8. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-011Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 183-09 of Hon. Vice Mayor Daniel T. Farias Temporarily convertingthe Irisan dumpsite to a livelihood facility for the constituents of Irisan Barangay.

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD) recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution.

(Item 6, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

9. Committee Report Nr. PUTTL-2013-042Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 082-13 introduced by Hon. Joel A. Alangsab entitled, "Requesting theCity Engineer's Office in coordination with the Department of Public Works and Highways toimplement Section 6, Ordinance No. 7, series of 2010 "The King of the Road Ordinance",particularly those that have no signal lights."

The Committee on Public Utilities, Transportation and Traffic Legislation recommendsapproval of the proposed resolution.(Item 7, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

10. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-023Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 077-13 introduced by Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen entitled, "Requesting theSenate and the House of Representatives to conduct a congressional inquiry and investigation on the

issuance of titles by the DENR pursuant to the free patent law and issuance of Certificates ofAncestral Land Title (CALT) by the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP)."

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends APPROVAL of theabove proposed resolution.(Item 8, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

11. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-024SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTINGProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0049-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot, Jr. and Hon. Karminn

Cheryl Dinney D. Yangot, entitled, "Prohibiting the putting up of residential, institutional,educational, or any vertical structure within identified danger zones or high risk areas in the City ofBaguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 19 August 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 63]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of an

ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends APPROVAL ONSECOND READING AND FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING of the above proposedordinance.

Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Member of the Committee signified, "What will happen to structuresalready built on such identified danger zones."(Item 9, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

4/15


12. Committee Report Nr. PWORKS-2013-018Resolution No. 87-13 of Hillside Barangay, Baguio City, "A Resolution approving the realignmentof a barangay project entitled, 'Rehabilitation and repair of damaged flood control located along the

creek of Puroks 3 & 5 between Miras and Flores families' into 'Purchase and installation of CloseCircuit Television (CCTV) for Hillside Barangay' in the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Pesos

(Php200,000.00)."

The Committee on Public Works regretfully DENIES the above request realignment for thefollowing reasons, to wit:

Under Item No. 3.0 of Joint Memorandum Circular No. 2011-1, of DILG-DBM dated April 13,2011, provides specifically the programs and projects to which the 20% development fundshall be utilized. Purchase of Close Circuit Television (CCTV) does not fall to any of theprojects mentioned.

Further, under Item No. 4.6 of the said Joint Memorandum Circular, which mentions theexpenditure items not covered by the 20% Development Fund, Close Circuit Television(CCTV) falls under administrative office equipment, thus, realignment for the purchase of thesame is not allowed.(Item 10, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

13. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-045SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTINGProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0022-13 introduced by Hon. Daniel T. Farias entitled, "AmendingSection 5 of Ordinance Nr. 023, series of 2006 [Establishing the guidelines on solicitations, requestson sponsorships, advertising and other related activities where the support on the public will besolicited]."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 20 May 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 51]; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.")[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING - 19 August 2013

- Posted in the bulletin boards of City Hall, Public market, Post Office, City Library and the HealthServices Office starting 20 August 2013.)

The Committee on Laws recommends that the above proposed ordinance be approved on

SECOND READING AFTER POSTING.(Item 11, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

14. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-046Memorandum of Agreement dated 20 August 2013 entered into by and between the CityGovernment of Baguio represented by Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan and Kosmos

Energies-Ke represented by Associate Director and Founder Ms. Beatrice De Lippe, relative to thelatter's conduct of feasibility study on the implementation of the valorization in electricity of thewaste of the Local Government Unit.

The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Memorandum ofAgreement.(Item 12, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

15. Committee Report Nr. SSWUP-2013-008SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0052-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B Yangot, Jr. and Hon. KarminnCheryl Dinney D. Yangot entitled, "The Poverty Alleviation Ordinance through substantial jobgeneration in the City of Baguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 19 August 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 63]; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Social Services, Women and Urban Poor recommends APPROVAL ONSECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION of the above proposed ordinance.(Item 13, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

16. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-025Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 078-13 introduced by Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen entitled, "Requesting theOffice of the Solicitor General for its legal opinion as to whether R. A. 10023 or the Free PatentLaw is applicable in the City of Baguio considering that it is governed by its City Charter."

Considering the urgency of the matter, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housingrecommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 14, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

5/15


17. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-026Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 079-13 introduced by Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen entitled, "Requesting HisExcellency Benigno Simeon C. Aquino III, President, Republic of the Philippines, to order theDepartment of Environment and Natural Resources, Cordillera Administrative Region (DENR-

CAR) to stop and hold in abeyance the processing and issuance of titles under RA 10023 (FreePatent Law) and the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP) as regards the issuance of

certificates of ancestral land title under RA 8371 (IPRA Law of 1997) pending request of MayorMauricio G. Domogan for investigation by the Baguio and Boracay Redevelopment Committee-Technical Working Group over the titling of critical government reserves and other related issues."

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends the following:

1. With respect to the issue on Free Patent, that the resolution be addressed to the DENRSecretary Ramon Paje instead of the Office of the President considering that it was the DENRCentral Office which acted on the denial of the city's request for free patent special guidelinesfor the City of Baguio.

2. As to the second request addressed to His Excellency President Benigno S. Aquino III tostop and hold in abeyance the processing and issuance of titles under RA 10023 (Free PatentLaw) and the NCIP pending request of Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan for investigation by theBaguio Boracay Redevelopment Committee - Technical Working Group (TWG) over thetitling of critical government reserves and other related issues, the committee recommends

approval.(Item 15, 30 September 2013 Agenda)18. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-027

Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 086-13 introduced by Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen entitled, "Requesting

the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Cordillera Administrative Region(DENR-CAR) to stop and hold in abeyance the processing and issuance of titles under RA 10023(Free Patent Law) pending request of the City of Baguio for the legal opinion of the Office of theSolicitor General as to whether or not RA 10023 is applicable in the city considering that it isgoverned by its own charter."


19. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-028Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 080-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. and Hon. KarminnCheryl Dinney D. Yangot entitled, "Respectfully appealing to His Excellency President Benigno S.

Aquino III, President of the Republic of the Philippines to intercede and intervene in resolving themost serious problem of the City of Baguio which is the indiscriminate and unscrupulous titling byway of Certificates of Ancestral Land Titles (CALTS) by the National Commission on IndigenousPeoples (NCIP) of our remaining government parks, playgrounds, roads, reservations, forest andlands owned by the Government."

Considering the urgency of the matter and in order to space the city's remaining parks,playgrounds, roads, reservation, forests as well as other government owned lands within theCity of Baguio from being titled in favor of private applicants, the Committee on UrbanPlanning, Lands and Housing recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution.

Let copy of this resolution be immediately forwarded to His Excellency President Benigno S.Aquino III for his information and consideration.(Item 17, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

20. Committee Report Nr. WAYSC-2013-059Letter dated 08 July 2013 of Punong Barangay Bonifacio A. Bustos, Padre Burgos Barangay,

submitting their Ordinance No. 01, series of 2013 entitled, An Ordinance enacting a comprehensivebarangay tax ordinance imposing taxes on retailers or entrepreneurs engaged in business within thebarangay, Baguio City, Philippines and for other purposes.

In view of the foregoing compliance with Sections 186 and 187 of the Local Government Codemandating that ordinances levying taxes, fees, or charges shall be the subject of a publichearing prior to its enactment, as could be evidenced by the hereto attached minutes ofmeeting and attendance to the general assemblies, the Committee on Ways and Means andFinance, Cluster C, recommends FAVORABLE REVIEW of the subject barangay taxordinance.(Item 18, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

21. Committee Report Nr. EGAP-2013-030Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 093-13 of Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. and Hon. Karminn CherylDinney D. Yangot entitled, "Granting incentives to certain personnel and volunteers in recognitionof their efforts and achievements which contributed to the successful implementation of the plans,

programs and activities of the City Government of Baguio."

The Committee on Ethics, Governmental Affairs and Personnel recommends APPROVAL ofthe foregoing proposed resolution.

Hon. Faustino A. Olowan, Member of the Committee signified, "Why certain employees only?Is this not selective? Can we not include all employees of the City of Baguio? For discussion."

Hon. Rocky M. Aliping, Member of the Committee signified, "to include also brgy tanods andbrgy utility workers (st. sweepers) for discussion."(Item 19, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

6/15


22. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-009SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0025-13 introduced by Hon. Daniel T. Farinas entitled, "Empowering

the various barangays in the City of Baguio to establish their 'Baguio is Beautiful, Brigada BarangayProject', a community-based venture purposely to attain the objective of making Baguio City a

beautiful, clean and green, safe, liveable, and resilient city."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 27 May 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 52]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends for SECOND READING andPUBLICATION of the said ordinance.

Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Member of the Committee signified, "upon approval of this ordinance,would it mean that the funding is also approved? refer to Section 6."(Item 20, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

23. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-010Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 056-13 introduced by Hon. Joel A. Alangsab entitled, "Requiring thebarangay officials to implement existing laws pertaining to the prevention of water pollution."

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends APPROVAL of the said resolution andfurther requires all the barangays to follow the same and not only those who are consideredcontributors to the pollution of the Balili River. (Item 21, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

24. Letter dated 22 August 2013 of Mr. Bien C. Mateo, Vice President for Operations, SM Malls,confirming receipt of Resolution Numbered 216, series of 2013 and suggesting among others thatthe following improvements be studied and if found feasible, implemented:

1. Installation of appropriate traffic regulatory and directional signs;2. Removal of old/not applicable traffic signs as a result of the new one-way traffic scheme

implemented by the city government; and

3. Removal and/or conversion of the existing traffic signals that are not operational toflashing traffic signals.

(NOTE: [a] With marginal notation dated 03 September 2013 of Hon. Vice Mayor Daniel T. Farias "To SP

include in SP Agenda for discussion."

[b] Res. No. 216, s. 2013 urged the SM City Baguio to redesign its main entrance presently passing throughSession Road and existing at the Upper Session or U.P. Drive as further solution to the traffic congestion at

Session Road Rotunda, Baguio City.) (Item 22, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

25. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-019SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0048-13 introduced by Hon. Rocky M. Aliping, Hon. Joel A. Alangsab,and Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Amending Ordinance Number 78, series of 2009moving the yearly celebration of Barangay Day from 2nd Saturday of December to the 10th day ofOctober of this year and every year thereafter to coincide with the Local Government Day.

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 19 August 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 62]; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING.(Item 23, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

26. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-018SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 00117-11 of Hon. Joel A. Alangsab "Designating barangay officials as

city officials for a day in the month of December of every year."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 28 November 2011 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 40] and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedure states, "On second reading before publication of anordinance, the ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or notthe proposed ordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior topublication.")

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends APPROVAL of the said ordinance,however, an amendment as to the date, from December to October to be simultaneous with thecelebration of the Local Government Day.(Item 24, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

27. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-016SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTINGProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0114-12 of Hon. Joel A. Alangsab "Institutionalizing the 'Gulayan saBarangay' project and appropriating funds therefor."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 03 December 2012

[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedure states, "On second reading before publication of anordinance, the ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or notthe proposed ordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior topublication.")

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends for the APPROVAL of the said ordinancefor SECOND READING and PUBLICATION.(Item 25, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

7/15


28. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-013Letter dated 25 February 2013 of Mr. Cristio A. Lagyop, Licensing Officer IV, Office of the CityMayor, forwarding the result of their inspection at the back of the Barangay Hall, Sto. Nio,Slaughterhouse Compound on February 25, 2013.

(NOTE: The above matter is in reply to the letter dated 21 February 2013 of the City Secretary to Mr. Cristio

A. Lagyop, Licensing Officer IV, Permits and Licensing Division, City Mayor's Office, requesting their office toverify the persons who are renting out the stalls at the back of the barangay hall at Sto. Nio, SlaughterhouseCompound Barangay.)

The Committee on Barangay Affairs requests the Office of the Permits and Licensing Divisionfor the CLOSURE or any appropriate action on the businesses located at the back of Sto. NioSlaughterhouse Compound Barangay, as per records submitted after the inspection andinquiry done by Mr. Cristio A. Lagyop and after verifying to the same office, it was found outthat among the list submitted, only Ms. Joanna Geromo has the permit and/or license tooperate a business in the said area.(Item 26, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

29. Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0105-13 introduced by Hon. Joel A. Alangsab entitled, "Requesting theDepartment of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) to repair the brick flooring installed along thesidewalks of the Central Business District specially Session Road which is considered as nationalroad to avoid accident and for protection and safety of the citizens of Baguio."


30. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2013-029Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 094-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. and Hon. KarminnCheryl Dinney D. Yangot entitled, "Calling on the Cordillera Administrative Region (CAR) jointRegional Steering Committee under the Joint Memorandum Circular No. 08-12 of the DAR, DENR,LRA and NCIP to take into consideration the condition of Baguio City in the titling of governmentlands by the NCIP in favor of ancestral land claimants."


31. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-053Ordinance No. 01, series of 2012 of Trancoville Barangay entitled, "An Ordinance prohibiting theuse and sale of plastic bags or containers which could not be recycled or reused in all business

establishments within the territorial jurisdiction of Barangay Trancoville, Baguio City providingpenalties for violation thereof."

(NOTE: Resolution No. 079, S. 2012 recommended a massive information dissemination campaign for theeffective and efficient implementation of City Ordinance Numbered 26, series of 2007 [Promulgating the useof paper bags, buri bags and other biodegradable bagging containers in all supermarkets, groceries and otherrelated retail business establishments in the City of Baguio by Year 2012].)

The Committee on Laws recommends favorable review of the above stated barangayordinance.

Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen, Member of the Committee signified, "Invite proponents forclarification."(Item 29, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

32. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-021Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 120-09 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda Urging the Congress of thePhilippines, through Hon. Congressman Mauricio G. Domogan, to sponsor legislation to give the

benefits due to the barangay officials as mandated by Section 393 of RA 7160.

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends for the amendment of the title of theproposed resolution to read as, "Urging the Congress of the Philippines, through Hon. NicasioM. Aliping Jr., to sponsor the legislation to give the benefits due to the barangay officials asmandated by Section 393 of RA 7160."(Item 30, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

33. Committee Report Nr. WAYSB-2013-017Audit observations and recommendations of the Commission on Audit-Cordillera AdministrativeRegion (COA-CAR) requesting the Sangguniang Panlungsod (SP) to:

a. revisit and review the original rental rates and consider fast tracking and prioritizing theissuance of a new Tax Ordinance amending or increasing the lease rates provided in Section37 of Tax Ordinance No. 2000-001 based on their own research/study and therecommendation of the General Services Office (GSO)/City Mayor to generate more incomefor the city government to fund more beneficial projects and services for its constituents (page

101, 14b); andb. revise the Tax Code (page 102, 14d).

(NOTE: [a] Section 37 of Tax Ordinance No. 2000-001- Lots/Building rentals on city-owned/administeredproperties; and

[b] Item 6, Section 37 of Tax Ordinance No. 2000-001 reads "The lessee shall not sublease the lot without theprior written consent of the Sangguniang Panlungsod".)

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster B recommends DISCUSSION ENBANC of the foregoing matter.(Item 31, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

8/15


34. Committee Report Nr. YWSD-2013-004SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION AND POSTINGProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0097-12 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda "Regulating theparticipation of children during parades in the City of Baguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 22 October 2012 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 86]; and

[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedure states, "On second reading before publication of an ordinance,the ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed

ordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication."[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION AND POSTING - 21 August 2013- Published in the Baguio Reporter issue of 11 August 2013 and posted in the bulletin boards of City Hall, Public

Market, Post Office, C ity Library and the Health Services Office starting 20 August 2013.)

The Committee on Youth Welfare and Sports Development recommends that the aboveproposed ordinance be approved on SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BYPOSTING.Hon. Peter C. Fianza, Member of the Committee signified, "It is suggested that the guidelinesconsider parents' consent or permission, every parade/program defining children'sparticipation and specific identification of the offenses." (Item 32, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

35. Committee Report Nr. TOURISM-2013-018Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0109-13 introduced by Hon. Roberto C. Ortega entitled, "Bestowingappreciation and indebtedness to SM Prime Holdings Inc. for financing and turning over a

rehabilitated children's playground to the City Government of Baguio."

The Committee on Tourism, Special Events, Parks and Playgrounds recommends that theabove proposed resolution be APPROVED.Hon. Richard A. Cario, Member of the Committee signifies, "I suggest that we omit the word'indebtedness'." (Item 33, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

36. Committee Report Nr. HUMAN-2013-003SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0063-13 introduced by Hon. Roberto C. Ortega entitled, "AmendingSections 1 and 2 of Ordinance Numbered 029, series of 1996 (Appropriating the amount ofPhp150,000.00 from the Unappropriated Account of the General Fund for the current Fiscal Year toserve as a fund for rewards to informers (person or group of persons) who give information leadingto the arrest, prosecution and conviction of any drug pusher, any of the authors of heinous crimescommitted in the city, or any of the ten most wanted criminals in the City of Baguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 09 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 64]; and

[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinance

will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication.'')

The Committee on Human Rights, Justice, Public Protection and Safety, Peace and Orderrecommends approval on SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION.(Item 34, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

37. Committee Report Nr. PUTTL-2013-045Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0106-13 introduced by Hon. Robert C. Ortega entitled, "Requesting SM

City Baguio to construct a pedestrian overpass to alleviate traffic congestion within its vicinity."

The Committee on Public Utilities, Transportation and Traffic Legislation recommends toapprove the resolution and to forward a copy to SM, Baguio. The management is tasked togive its written reply as basis for the Council to act further.Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Member of the Committee signified, "Technical recommendation& study from our CBAO is in order; public consultation/hearing pursuant to the mandate ofRA 7160 should also be complied with." (Item 35, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

38.

COMMITTEE REPORT/S:

Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-055Resolution Number 001, series of 2013 of the Barangay Peace and Order Advisory Council(BPOAC) entitled, "A Resolution authorizing and allowing the conduct of fund raising activity thrua bingo social within the jurisdiction of Rizal Monument Barangay for the purpose of raising fundsin connection with the project of the 13 barangays within the jurisdiction of Station 1 to purchaseand acquire four (6) units of motorcycles for the maintenance and monitoring of peace and orderwithin the 13 barangays under Station 1."

The Committee on Laws recommends to invite the officer and members of the Barangay Peaceand Order Advisory Council (BPOAC) to explain their Resolution Numbered 001, series of2013 on the next City Council Regular Session.(Item 36, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

39. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-056

1st Indorsement dated 12 September 2013 of the Office of Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding for information and appropriate action the Memorandum of Understanding dated 09 July2013 entered into by and among the City Government of Baguio represented by Honorable MauricioG. Domogan, the University of the Philippines Baguio represented by Chancellor, Dr. RaymundoD. Rovillos, and ICLEI-Local Governments for Sustainability Southeast Asia represented by

Regional Director, Mr. Victorino E. Aquitania, relative to the establishment of Knowledge TrainingResource Center (KTRC) for Climate Change and Disaster Risk Reduction and Management.

The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Memorandum ofUnderstanding.(Item 37, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

9/15


40. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-014Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0113-13 introduced by Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. entitled,"Supporting and acknowledging the transfer of venue of the Regional Cooperative Month

Celebration from the Province of Abra to Baguio City and adopting it as part of the citygovernment's activities."

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD) recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution.(Item 38, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

41. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-015Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 169-09 (letter form) of then City Councilor Galo D. Weygan entitledToward a Baguio Basura Free thru the cooperative way.

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives, Handicapped and Persons WithDisabilities (PWD), recommends that the above matter be NOTED and the same beFORWARDED to the City Solid Waste Management Board for their appropriate informationand consideration.(Item 39, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

42. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-057

Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0107-13 of Hon. Faustino A. Olowan entitled, "Supporting andadopting in the City of Baguio the implementation of Resolution No. 03-2012 of the GovernmentProcurement Policy Board approving and adopting BID securing declaration in lieu of the existingforms of BID security."

The Committee on Laws recommends approval of the above stated proposed resolution. (Item 40, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

43. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-058Letter dated 19 September 2013 of Mr. Dan Ricky Ong, Local Legislative Staff Officer IV, noted byMs. Maria Remedios C. Agranzamendez, Local Legislative Staff Officer V, SangguniangPanlungsod, submitting a status report on the legislative tracking and analysis on the implementationof Ordinance Nr. 54, series of 1988, as amended and their suggestions/recommendations/commentsfrom the respondents.

(NOTE: Ordinance No. 54-88 reads, An Ordinance penalizing illegal disposal of refuse, excrement andegesta; removal or destruction of receptacles for refuse; and illegal construction of waterways and dumpinginto bodies of water; requiring certain persons, institutions and establishments to provide for receptacles forrefuse, to keep surroundings clean, and to pick up litters; providing for amnesty from prosecution; andfurthermore amending, or the purpose, Sections 472, 475 and 479 of Ordinance Numbered 500, s. 1934, asamended by Ordinance Nrs. 252, 264, 572 and 601.)

The Committee on Laws recommends that the above stated matter be referred to theCommittee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection considering thatit is within the Committee's ambit, as stipulated under the general jurisdiction of the StandingCommittees in the Sangguniang Panlungsod's Resolution Numbered 254, series of 2004.(Item 41, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

44. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-059Memorandum of Agreement entered into by and between the City Government of Baguiorepresented by City Mayor, Honorable Mauricio G. Domogan and SM Prime Holdings, Inc.

represented by its President, Hans T. Sy, regarding the offer of SM to finance and implement therehabilitation of Childrens Playground at Burnham Park.

The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Memorandum ofAgreement.(Item 42, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

45. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-060Proposed Tax Ordinance Nr. PO 0026-13 introduced by Hon. Edison R. Bilog entitled, " AmendingSection 136, Chapter XVIII and Deleting Section 147 (a) 16, Chapter XIX of Tax OrdinanceNumber 2000-001.

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 27 May 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 53]; and

[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Laws recommends that the above proposed ordinance be referred to the

Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce.(Item 43, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

46. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2013-013Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0108-13 introduced by Hon. Faustino A. Olowan entitled, "Requiringthe City Market Superintendent to install temporary portable toilets (portalets) for use during theallowable vending time for night market goers and vendors along the vending area."

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce recommends APPROVAL of the abovestated proposed resolution.(Item 44, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

10/15


47. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2013-014SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION AND POSTINGProposed Tax Ordinance Nr. PO 0042-13 introduced by Hon. Peter C. Fianza entitled, "Prescribingthat stalls or booths in the City Public Market being offered for occupancy to new applicants shallfirst be vacated and/or cleared of any obstruction or occupancy, amending for the purpose certain

provisions of Section 148 and Section 157 of Title 4, Chapter X1X of Ordinance 2000-001."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 29 July 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 46]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.''[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION - 09 September 2013

- Published in the Sunstar Baguio issue of 14 and 15 September 2013 and posted in the bulletin boardsof City Hall, Public Market, Post Office, City Library and the Health Services Office starting 11 September2013.)

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce recommends APPROVAL of the abovestated proposed ordinance on SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION.(Item 45, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

48. Committee Report Nr. PWORKS-2013-025Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0055-13 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Changing the titleof the project 'Improvement of Senior Citizens Building' at San Luis Village Barangay, Baguio Cityunder 2009 AIP to 'Construction of water tank with stand and fixtures' with a project cost of

Php50,000.00."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 02 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 11]; and

[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Public Works recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed ordinanceDISPENSING WITH THE SECOND and THIRD READINGS.(Item 46, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

49. Committee Report Nr. PWORKS-2013-0241st Indorsement dated 04 June 2013 of the Office of Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding for information and appropriate action the letter dated 29 May 2013 of Mr. AbelardoPoclis, Pokles Construction, praying that the amount allotted for the project entitled, "Constructionof barangay hall at South Central Aurora Hill, Baguio City", be reverted back and be released in hisfavor.

(NOTE: Ordinance No. 018, s. 2012 Realigned the amounts of P150,000.00 for the project "Construction ofbarangay hall" and P100,000.00 for the project "Construction of a multipurpose building/hall" bothappropriated in the 2010 Annual Investment Plan (AIP) of the City of Baguio to the "continuation of theimprovement of barangay hall" at South Central Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City.)

Considering the fact that the project entitled, "construction of barangay hall at South CentralAurora Hill, Baguio City" was already 100% completed as of July 10, 2012 as certified by theCity Buildings and Architecture Office and the Punong Barangay of South Central AuroraHill Barangay, it is just and proper to grant the above request.

The Committee on Public Works recommends APPROVAL of the above request for reversionof fund to its original project title and be released to Mr. Abelardo Poclis.

Further recommends approval of the hereto attached Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0076-13 onTHIRD and FINAL READING DISPENSING WITH THE FIRST and SECONDREADINGS.(Item 47, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

50. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-016SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0066-13 introduced by Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. entitled,"Designating the last week of the month of October and every year thereafter as Baguio CityBarangay Livelihood Promotions Week, creating a committee and providing funds therefor."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 16 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.60]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD) recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION of the aboveproposed ordinance.(Item 48, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

51. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-017Resolution No. 02, series of 2010, of Kias Multipurpose Cooperative, Kias Barangay entitled, A

resolution requesting financial assistance from the Office of the Honorable Nicasio S. Palaganas,City Councilor, purposely to augment the revolving capital of the cooperative livelihood programfor women.

(NOTE: Ordinance No. 092-1995 provides guidelines for financial assistance extended to cooperatives in theCity of Baguio.)

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD) recommends that the above matter BE RETURNED to the requesting cooperativetogether with the hereto attached copy of Ordinance No. 092, series of 1995 to comply withSection 3 of said ordinance, should the Cooperative still want to pursue the said request. (Item 49, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

11/15


52. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2013-018Letter dated 04 January 2010 of Ms. Gigi B. Soriano, Shabach Marketing to Hon. Vice MayorDaniel T. Farias, requesting His Honor to formally grant them exemption or reduction from localtax in relation to the benefits and incentives of Barangay Micro Business Enterprise under Republic

Act 9178.(NOTE: RA 9178 Article III Section 9 states that the Local Government Units are encouraged either to reducethe amount of local taxes imposed or to exempt the Barangay Micro Business Enterprise (BMBE) from local

taxes, fees and charges.)

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities(PWD), recommends that the above matter BE RETURNED to Ms. Gigi B. Soriano togetherwith the herein attached 4th Indorsement dated September 17, 2013 of Alicia L. Onoza, Asst.City Treasurer, to comply with paragraph 2 of said 4th Indorsement prior to further action.Hon. Edison R. Bilog, Member of the Committee signified, "Why is there a need to requirethem to provide their 2009 and 2010 assessment. We could already grant the exemption asprovided for by law. The law does not require the presentation of the assessment beforeexemptions may be granted.

What we need is an ordinance in order to implement equally and uniformly the provisions oflaw to all BMBE." (Item 50, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

53. Committee Report Nr. WAYSC-2013-067a. Supplemental Budget of Santo Tomas Proper Barangay for Calendar Year 2013 amounting to

Php989,314.28.b. Supplemental Budget of Malcolm Square Barangay for Calendar Year 2013 amounting toPhp55,200.00.c. Supplemental Budget of Upper Quezon Hill Barangay for Calendar Year 2013 amounting toPhp304,198.70.d. Supplemental Budget of East Modernsite Barangay for Calendar Year 2013 amounting toPhp539,256.99.

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster C, recommends FAVORABLEREVIEW of the above mentioned barangay budgets and that the same be returned to theconcerned barangays through the City Budget Officer for implementation. (Item 51, 30 September 2013 Agenda)

54. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-026Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0187-12 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda "Urging the adoption ofthe People's Congress style in the conduct of the barangay assemblies, in implementation ofparticipative governance."

The Committee on Barangay Affairs submits for the APPROVAL of the above and furtherrequests the City Council to allocate a fund for the conduct of the orientation seminar for thePeople's Congress style in barangay assemblies in the implementation of participativegovernance and to invite the proponent or any appropriate speaker as a resource person toexplain and discuss the conduct of the People's Congress style in the barangay.

55. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2013-016SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0027-13 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda, entitled"Institutionalizing the conduct of night market in the City of Baguio and setting the guidelines forthe conduct thereof."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING- 10 June 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.47]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance, the ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not

the proposed ordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior topublication."[c] Attached is the list of related matters forwarded to the Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce.)

(Item 17, 29 July 2013 Agenda)

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce reiterates its recommendation to approvethe proposed ordinance on SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION and POSTING.

Hon. Peter C. Fianza, Member of the Committee signified, "Discussion on the proposal issuggested to consider earlier manifested concerns."

56. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2013-015Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0112-13 introduced by Hon. Elaine D. Sembrano entitled, "Calling forthe conduct of an updated inventory of satellite markets established outside the Central BusinessDistrict in Baguio City."

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce recommends APPROVAL of the above

stated proposed resolution.

57. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2013-009Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 063-13 of Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan, Jr. "Designating a portion ofWright Park, Lualhati Village Barangay, Baguio City as site for a biogas digester/facility."

The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protectionrecommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution.

Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda, Member of the Committee signified, Suggest refer toCEPMO first."

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

12/15


58. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2013-010Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0098-13 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Requesting theJapan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) to provide assistance in the upgrading of the SewerTreatment Plant (STP) located at North Sanitary Camp, Baguio City."


59. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2013-011Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 083-13 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled,"Requesting the Department of Health (DOH) - CAR to include the health centers in Baguio City inthe JICA project of strengthening of the Local Health System for effective and efficient delivery ofmaternal and child health services."


60. Committee Report Nr. SSWUP-2013-010SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0054-13 of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Identifying theUrban Poor in Baguio City for entitlement to basic services."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING- 02 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 10]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of an

ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.''[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING 23 September 2013

- Posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, Public Market, Post Office, City Library and the Health

Services Office starting 25 September 2013.) (Item 44, 23 September 2013 Agenda)

The Committee on Social Services, Women and Urban Poor recommends APPROVAL onSECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION of the above proposed ordinance.

61. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2013-061Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0070-12 of Hon. Erdolfo V. Balajadia "Amending Ordinance No. 08,series of 2008 'An ordinance prohibiting the use, sale, distribution and advertisement of cigarettesand other tobacco products in certain places, imposing penalties for violations thereof and providingfunds therefor, and for other purposes'."

(NOTE: The above matter is related to the following matters:

[a] Ordinance No. 08, s. 2008 is the Comprehensive Anti-Smoking Ordinance of Baguio City.[b] Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0079-11 of Hon. Erdolfo V. Balajadia "Amending Ordinance Numbered 5,series of 1990."

(NOTE: [a] Sections 2 and 3 of Ordinance Numbered 08, series of 2008 [The Comprehensive Anti-SmokingOrdinance of Baguio City] provides for the coverage and definition of terms, respectively].[b] FIRST READING - 08 August 2011[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION AND POSTING - 22 August 2011

- Published in the Baguio Reporter issue of 04 September 2011 and was also posted on the bulletinboards of City Hall, City Public Market, Post office, City Library and the Health Services Office starting 23August 2011.

[d] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedure states, "On second reading before publication of an

ordinance, the ordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not theproposed ordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication."[e] Returned to the Committee on Laws on 14 October 2011 for further study and to coordinate with Atty. PatrickL. Mariano on points he wants to raise in relation to the proposed ordinance)

[c] Letter dated 17 October 2011 of Mr. Patrick L. Mariano, Manager, Local Regulatory Fiscal and SalesRelations, PMFTC, Inc. to Hon. Richard A. Cario, submitting among others their recommendations relativeto the Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0065-11 of Hon. Erdolfo V. Balajadia [Forwarded to the Committee onLaws on 20 October 2011 in relation to the Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0065-11 of Hon. Erdolfo V.Balajadia.][d] Letter dated 08 April 2011 of Mr. Emmanuel Deogracias H. De Luna, Manager, Local Regulatory Fiscaland Sales Relations, PMFTC, urging the Honorable Members of the City Council to issue a resolutiontempering and aligning the enforcement of Ordinance No. 08 so that only provisions consistent with theTobacco Regulation Act of 2003 or Republic Act No. 9211 would be implemented. [Returned to Mr.Emmanuel Deogracias H. De Luna, with the information that during the 14 May 2012 Regular Session of theSangguniang Panlungsod, the matter was noted, per recommendation of the Committee on Health andSanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection.])[e] FIRST READING - 03 September 2012 Regular Session [Agenda Item r. 86]


The Committee on Laws recommends to adopt the above stated proposed ordinanceconsidering that the Honorable Erdolfo V. Balajadia is no longer a member of theSangguniang Panlungsod and that the committee members be co-authors with the originalproponent.

The committee further recommends to refile the attached Proposed Ordinance Nr.PO 0078-13 for approval on FIRST READING in view of some amendments submitted forconsideration by Dr. Donnabel L. Tubera of the City Epidemiology and Surveillance Unit ofthe City Health Services Office.

62. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2013-012Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0127-13 introduced by Hon. Edison R. Bilog entitled, "Inviting in aidof legislation, Mr. Michael Bengwayan, the Barangay Captain of Bakakeng Central and a

representative of Moldex Corporation to shed light regarding the cutting of trees by MoldexCorporation along Marcos Highway, Baguio City."

The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protectionrecommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution but invite also the RegionalExecutive Director of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) - CARand the Department Head of the City Environment and Parks Management Office.

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

13/15


63. Committee Report Nr. TOURISM-2013-020Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0126-13 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled"Expressing the deepest sympathy and condolences of the City Government of Baguio on the demise

of its outstanding citizen Dr. Charles L. Cheng on September 28, 2013 at age 81 at Baguio City.

The Committee on Tourism, Special Events, Parks and Playgrounds recommends that theabove proposed resolution be APPROVED.

64. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-027Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0239-11 of Hon. Peter C. Fianza and Hon. Vice Mayor Daniel T.Farias "Urging the barangays to adopt and implement a comprehensive solid waste management

system in their respective barangays." (Item 11, 07 January 2013 Agenda)

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends that the said resolution be NOTEDconsidering that this program is already being implemented by the Solid Waste ManagementCommittee of the respective barangays.

65. Committee Report Nr. WAYSA-2013-033a. Resolution No. 043-2013, series of 2013 of Pacdal Barangay entitled, "A Resolution requestingHonorable Vice Mayor Daniel T. Farinas to allocate fund for the improvement of sidewalk and

drainage from Virgo's residence to waiting shed at St. Francis Xavier Seminary amounting toPhp200,000.00 and to endorse to Engr. Evelyn Cayat of the City Planning Office for a barangaypriority project located at Liteng."b. Resolution Numbered 20, series of 2013 of Camp 7 Barangay entitled, "Resolution respectfullyrequesting Honorable Councilor Edison R. Bilog the amount of Five Hundred Thousand Pesos(Php500,000.00) for concreting of road at Purok 2 Monticello, Camp 7, Baguio City, near Mrs.Elena Gambulao."

c. Resolution No. 24, series of 2013 of Santo Tomas Proper Barangay entitled, "Resolution ofBalacbac Santo Tomas Proper Barangay Council requesting the Honorable Councilor Edison Bilogfor an additional amount of Two Hundred Thousand Pesos (Php200,000.00) for the construction ofbox culvert leading to Adiwang Elementary School."d. Resolution Numbered 19, series of 2013 of Camp 7 Barangay entitled, "Resolution respectfullyrequesting Honorable Councilors Faustino A. Olowan, Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. and Edison R. Bilogthe amount of Six Hundred Thousand Pesos (Php600,000.00) for drainage canal at Purok 4 LowerEast Pias, Camp 7, Baguio City."

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster A, recommends that the abovementioned barangay resolutions be forwarded to the City Development Council for possibleinclusion in the listing of priority projects of the city.

66. Committee Report Nr. WAYSA-2013-034a. Barangay Resolution No. 21, series of 2013 of Campo Filipino Barangay entitled, "Resolution

respectfully requesting Honorable Lourdes F. Tabanda to allocate funds for the construction ofcomfort room for the daycare children and put iron grills at the terrace of the second floor."b. Resolution No. 37-13, series of 2013 of Fairview Barangay entitled, "A Sangguniang BarangayResolution requesting Honorable Councilor Edison R. Bilog for funding rehabilitation of pathwayswith riprap from Peter Yosayos to Josephine Garwageo at Purok 7 the amount of Two HundredThousand Pesos (Php200,000.00)."c. Resolution No. 13-09-023, series of 2013 of South Sanitary Camp Barangay, entitled,"Requesting Hon. Councilor Elmer O. Datuin to appropriate from his Local Development Fund forthe second phase and onwards of the project 'improvement/expansion of multipurpose hall', this

barangay."d. Resolution No. 34-13, series of 2013 of Fairview Barangay entitled, "A Sangguniang BarangayResolution requesting Honorable Vice Mayor Daniel T. Farinas for funding stepway with railings atLower Sunnyside Fairview Purok 2 the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Pesos (Php200,000.00)."

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster A, recommends that the abovementioned barangay resolutions be forwarded to the City Development Council for possibleinclusion in the listing of priority projects of the city.

67. Committee Report Nr. EGAP-2013-034Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0123-13 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. and Hon. Fred L.Bagbagen entitled, "Supporting the passage into law of Senate Bill No.1645 introduced byHonorable Senator Vicente C. Sotto III."

(NOTE: Senate Bill No. 1645 introduced by Honorable Senator Vicente C. Sotto III reads, "An act requiringemployers to pay 14th month pay that will cover all government and non-government rank and file employeesregardless of their employment status, designation and irrespective of the method by which their wages arepaid provided that they have worked at least one month during the calendar year.")

The Committee on Ethics, Governmental Affairs and Personnel recommends APPROVAL ofthe foregoing proposed resolution.

Hon. Faustino A. Olowan, Member of the Committee signified, "Let the Senators do theirhomework. Eh tayo nga di kayang magbigay ng employees bonus."

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

14/15


68. Committee Report Nr. WAYSB-2013-018Letter dated 19 September 2013 of GM Briton Aposaga, Movie Director, DreamworldEntertainment Productions, EBA International Entertainment Productions to Hon. Vice Mayor

Daniel T. Farinas, requesting exemption from amusement tax for the film showing "Sa IsangMunting Parangal" at SM Cinema (1,2,3,& 4) on September 21, 22 and 28 and 29.

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster B, recommends APPROVAL of theforegoing request and that the necessary ordinance in relation thereto be APPROVED onFIRST READING DISPENSING WITH THE SECOND AND FINAL READINGS inaccordance with the Local Government Code.

Hon. Edison R. Bilog, Member of the Committee signified, "The amount should be refundedconsidering that the showing has been made and the taxes were already paid."

69. Committee Report Nr. WAYSB-2013-020SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION:Proposed Tax Ordinance Nr. PO 0071-13 introduced by Hon. Richard A. Cario entitled, "AnOrdinance amending Sub Sections (c), (d), (e), (g), (j), and (l) of Section 23 Secretary's Fees of TaxOrdinance Numbered 2000-001 entitled, 'An Ordinance providing a set of rules and regulations

governing the administration, appraisal, assessment, levy and collection of realty taxes, business

taxes, permit fees, building and lot rentals in the City of Baguio and such other fees and chargestherefor pursuant to the provisions of the Local Government Code of 1991'."

(NOTE: a] FIRST READING - 23 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 66]; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')


The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster B, recommends that the abovementioned proposed tax ordinance be APPROVED on SECOND READING BEFOREPUBLICATION.

70. Committee Report Nr. BRGY-2013-028SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0035-13 introduced by Hon. Joel A. Alangsab entitled, "Establishing abarangay database information system." (Item 17, 22 July 2013 Agenda)

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 22 July 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 17; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.")

The Committee on Barangay Affairs recommends for the APPROVAL on SECONDREADING (POSTING) with the following recommendations:

1. To endorse the proposed ordinance for comments and recommendations toDOST-ICTO;

2. In the implementation of the Barangay Information System (BIS), to take intoconsideration Presidential Administrative Order 39 dated July 12, 2013[MANDATING GOVERNMENT AGENCIES TO MIGRATE TO THEGOVERNMENT WEB HOSTING SERVICE (GWHS) OF THEDEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY - INFORMATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY OFFICE (DOST-ICTO)] and ExecutiveOrder No. 55, dated September 6, 2011 [DIRECTING THE INTEGRATION ANDAUTOMATION OF GOVERNMENT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS];

3. To expand the coverage of the Barangay Information System by incorporatingfeatures found in existing similar information systems;

4. To see the possibility to have the project funded under the government-wide MITHI.

Hon. Rocky M. Aliping, Chairman of the Committee signified, "and for publicationalso."

71.

NEW MATTER/S:

FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0077-13 introduced by Hon. Roberto C. Ortega entitled, "Appropriating

the amount of P100,000.00 for the construction of the Protection of Dignified Human Rights(PDHR) Office."

72. FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0079-13 introduced by the Committee on Ethics, Governmental Affairsand Personnel entitled "Transferring the total amount of Php196,000.00 from Account Code No. 701for the wages and other emoluments of the eighteen (18) casual employees of the SangguniangPanlungsod (City Council) for the period October 2013 to December 2013."

7/23/2019 October 21, 2013(Marked)

15/15


comsecelordua

73. FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0080-13 introduced by Hon. Roberto C. Ortega entitled, "Appropriatingthe amount of Php200,000.00 for the construction of footbridge connecting the residents of New

Lucban Barangay and Alfonso Tabora Barangay situated at Purok 3 northwest side of SagudinRiver."

74. FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeLetter dated 16 October 2013 of Atty. Leticia O. Clemente, City Budget Officer, submitting forconsideration, review and approval the 2014 Executive Budget in the amount of One Billion ThreeHundred Ninety Five Million Eight Hundred Twenty Two Thousand Pesos (Php1,395,822,000.00).

75. FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0081-13 introduced by Hon. Richard A. Cario entitled, "Imposingannual charges and fees on the installation and operation of cell sites and antenna towers fortelecommunication relay stations.

76. FIRST READING: Referral to CommitteeProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0082-13 introduced by Hon. Roberto C. Ortega entitled "Allocating

fund to entitle the DPS Compound Barangay waiting shed to the late Rowel Corpuz Aguilar as asign of gratitude for his commitment in public service and heroic act in saving the life of hisneighbor."

C. CITIZENS' FORUM

D. BAGUIO HYMNCLOSING PRAYER

october 21, 2013(marked)

Documents