october 2007 minutes

Strategic Plan Goal: 2 Support policy development related to educator preparation, conduct and professional growth.

November 2007

2A Action

General Session

Approval of the October 2007 Minutes

Executive Summary: The Executive Director will recommend that the Commission approve the minutes of the October 2007 meeting of the Commission. Recommended Action: Approve the minutes of the October 2007 meeting. Presenter: None.

October 4, 2007 Commission Meeting Approved Minutes

Commission on Teacher Credentialing Minutes of the October 2007 Meeting

Commission Members Attending P. David Pearson, Faculty Member, Chair Caleb Cheung, Teacher Representative, Vice Chair Catherine Banker, Public Representative Josie Calderon, Public Representative Paula Cordeiro, Public Representative Karen Symms Gallagher, Ex-Officio, Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities Margaret Gaston, Public Representative Gloria Grant, Teacher Representative Leslie Littman, Designee, Superintendent of Public Instruction Marilyn McGrath, Ex-Officio, California Postsecondary Education Commission Aida Molina, Administrative Services Representative Lillian Perry, Teacher Representative Leslie Peterson Schwarze, School Board Member Jon Stordahl, Teacher Representative Tine Sloan, Ex-Officio, University of California Loretta Whitson, Non-Administrative Services Credential Representative Beverly Young, Ex-Officio, California State University State Board Liaison Alan Bersin, Member, State Board of Education (absent) Commission Members Absent Guillermo Gomez, Teacher Representative General Session Chair Pearson convened the October 4, 2007 General Session of the Commission on Teacher Credentialing. Roll call was taken and the Pledge of Allegiance was recited. 2D: Chair’s Report Chair Pearson introduced Dr. David Long, California’s Secretary of Education, to the Commission and invited him to the table to speak about the Office of the Secretary of Education. Secretary Long gave a speech on the activities of the Office of the Secretary of Education and the work completed toward the Year of Education. Chair Pearson also sent condolences on behalf of the Commission to Commissioner Gomez and his family for the loss of his mother.


2A: Approval of the August 2007 Minutes Commissioner Littman moved approval of the August 2007 Minutes. Commissioner Whitson seconded the motion. The motion passed without dissent. 2B: Approval of the October 2007 Agenda Commissioner Littman moved approval of the Commission’s October 2007 Agenda with an agenda insert for item 2C. Commissioner Cheung seconded the motion. The motion passed without dissent. 2C: Approval of the October 2007 Consent Calendar Commissioner Gaston moved approval of the Consent Calendar. Commissioner Littman seconded the motion. The motion passed without dissent. 2E: Executive Director’s Report Executive Director Janssen gave a brief budget report for the FY 2007-08. Mr. Janssen also welcomed Dr. Terry Janicki back to the Commission as a Consultant in the Professional Services Division after a six year hiatus. 2F: Commission Member Reports Commissioner Schwarze reported on the Committee on Accreditation (COA) meeting. She expressed her appreciation for their hard work and stated that the group was well structured and managed. Commissioner Gallagher reminded everyone about the 50th anniversary of the launching Sputnik which had an enormous impact on education. She also reported on her work with the National Science Board. 2G: Liaison Reports There were no reports. Professional Services Committee Committee Chair Paula Cordeiro convened the Professional Services Committee. 3A: Program Approval and Initial Institutional Approval Teri Clark, Administrator, Helen Hawley and Karen Sacramento, Consultants, Professional Services Division, presented the following programs for Commission approval: Initial Institutional Approval Bay Area School of Enterprise (BASE) Single Subject Matter Program California Polytechnic University, Pomona: Music


Induction Programs High Tech High Charter Schools Professional Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment

Induction Program The Irvine Unified School District (IUSD) Professional Beginning Teacher Support and

Assessment Induction Program REACH Professional Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment Induction Program San Mateo-Foster City School District (SMFCSD) Professional Beginning Teacher Support

and Assessment Induction Program SIATech Charter School Professional Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment

Induction Program Washington Unified School District (WUSD) Professional Beginning Teacher Support and

Assessment Induction Program Page Tompkins, REACH Professional Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment Teacher Induction Program, gave a brief description on the background of the program and the role of the faculty. Chair Pearson moved approval of the application for initial institutional approval, the single subject matter program and the six induction programs. Commissioner Perry seconded the motion. The motion carried without dissent. 3B: Approval of Knowledge, Skills and Abilities (KSAs) for the CSET: Bilingual Methodology and Bilingual Culture Examinations, and Review of Draft Bilingual Program Standards Jo Birdsell, Consultant, Professional Services Division, presented this two-part item which provided the final KSAs for the CSET: Bilingual Methodology and Bilingual Culture examinations for approval and also the draft Bilingual Program Standards developed by the Bilingual Certification Design Team for initial review by the Commission. Marty Karlin, NCS Pearson, gave information on the respondents rating process for the content validation survey. Gini Natali, California State Parent Teacher Association, requested clarification on the use of the term “demonstrate” in Domain 2 Intercultural Communication 004 School, Home, and Community Collaboration. Charles Zartman, Chair, Bilingual Certification Design Team, commended his colleagues on the quality work done on the KSAs. Dr. Magaly Lavadenz, California Association for Bilingual Education (CABE), thanked the Commission staff and the rest of Bilingual Certification Design Team for their effort on the work of the KSAs. Commissioner Gaston moved approval of the proposed Knowledge, Skills, and Abilities required of a bilingual teacher for California public schools. Commissioner Molina seconded motion. The motion carried without dissent.


The Commission also directed the staff to release the draft Bilingual Program Standards to obtain stakeholder input and bring the item back for Commission consideration and action at the December 2007 meeting. 3C: Proposed Approval of an Alternative Teaching Performance Assessment, the Performance Assessment for California Teachers (PACT) Teri Clark and Mike McKibbin, Administrators, Professional Services Division presented this item which provided a description of the PACT assessment system and the review process of the assessment conducted by an expert review panel in relation to the Commission’s adopted Assessment Design Standards. Anne Jones, UC Riverside, voiced her support for the PACT assessment. Robert Calfee, representing himself, echoed support of the PACT assessment. Ray Pecheone, Stanford University, gave a brief presentation supporting the PACT assessment. Commissioner Whitson moved approval of the recommendation from the expert panel to approve the Performance Assessment for California Teachers (PACT) as an alternative teaching performance assessment pursuant to Education Code Section 44320.2(d)(3). Commissioner Gaston seconded the motion. The motion carried without dissent. 3D: 2006-2007 Annual Accreditation Report by the Committee on Accreditation Teri Clark, Administrator, Professional Services Division and Lynne Cook, Co-Chair of the Committee on Accreditation presented this item which provided background information on the Committee on Accreditation (COA) and presented its 2006-2007 Annual Accreditation Report which summarizes the COA’s accomplishments, activities and plans for future work. 3E: Draft Standards of Quality and Effectiveness for Health Services: School Nurse Credential Programs Teri Clark, Administrator, Professional Services Division presented this item which provided the draft Standards of Quality and Effectiveness for Health Services: School Nurse Credential Programs for initial Commission review. Susan Westbrook, California Federation of Teachers, thanked the staff and the panel for their work on the draft standards. She also suggested an induction program be developed for school nurses. The Commission directed staff to invite representatives from the school nurse association to discuss on what is going on in the field when the item is presented at the November 2007 meeting. It was also clarified that staff would provide information on the differences between the previous standards and draft standards. 3F: Report on the Reading Instruction Competence Assessment (RICA) Validity Study and Review of the Draft RICA Content Specification


Yvonne Novelli, Assistant Consultant, Professional Services Division presented this item which provided information regarding the RICA validity study process and results including a comparison of the draft RICA content specifications with those currently used. Kathy Harris, California Teachers Association, raised concerns in the draft on the lack of language to meet the needs of English learners, the focus on beginning reading strategies and lack of skills needed for advanced learners. Susan Westbrook, California Federation of Teachers, voiced the same concerns as Ms. Harris. 3G: Alternative Subject Competency Assessment for Additional Less Commonly Taught Languages Other Than English (LOTE) Jo Birdsell, Consultant and Mike McKibbin, Administrator, Professional Services Division presented this item which provided a proposed plan for an alternative subject matter competency assessment process to meet candidate needs in the less commonly taught languages other than English for which there is no CSET: LOTE subject matter examination and no single subject matter preparation program available. Derrek Ramage, LAUSD, voiced his support for an alternative subject matter competency assessment process plan. Legislative Committee Committee Chair Margaret Gaston convened the Legislative Committee. 4A: Status of Legislation Marilyn Errett, Administrator, Office of Governmental Relations, provided an update on the status of bills the Commission has taken a position and on Commission sponsored bills. 4B: Other Legislative and Policy Items No items to report at this time. Reconvene General Session Chair Pearson reconvened General Session. 2I: Report of the Executive Committee Chair Pearson moved to approve the Executive Committee of August 2007 meeting minutes. The Executive Committee directed staff to return with an action item in accordance with Committee discussion to establish new procedures for the interview selection process for the Committee of Credentials and Committee on Accreditation which would involve appointment of members of the Commission to an ad hoc sub committee.

The Commission approved the recommendation from the Executive Committee. 2J: New Business Chair Pearson noted that the Quarterly Agenda is presented for information.


The Commission directed staff to add the General Science Credential authorization to the Quarterly Agenda. Susan Westbrook, California Federation of Teachers, said that Linda Plack, United Educators of San Francisco (UESF), will represent the California Federation of Teachers at the November Commission meeting. Chair Pearson recessed the General Session in order to convene Closed Session. Upon completion of Closed Session business, Chair Pearson reconvened General Session. Report of Closed Session Items Chair Pearson reported that the Commission denied the Petition for Reinstatement in the matter of Cindy Pate. The Commission rejected the Proposed Decision and called for the transcript in the matter of Shirley Broney. The Commission took action to reject the Administrative Law Judge’s Proposed Decision and action to issue findings to grant any pending applications in the matter of Gwendolyn Lawrence-Harrison and then revoke the credential granted and stay the revocation and place her on probation with conditions. The findings would be submitted at the November 8, 2007 Commission meeting for adoption. Adjournment There being no further business, Chair Pearson adjourned the meeting.

GS 2A-7 November 2007

APPENDIX

October 2007

CONSENT CALENDAR


Consent Calendar

Division of Professional Practices For your approval, the following items have been placed on the Consent Calendar for the October 4, 2007 meeting of the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing:

RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE COMMITTEE OF CREDENTIAL Education Code section 44244.1 allows the Commission to adopt the recommendation of the Committee of Credentials without further proceedings if the individual does not request an administrative hearing within a specified time.

1. AGUILAR, Vivian V. Los Angeles, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of seven (7) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

2. ANDERSON, Gebel T. San Diego, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of seven (7) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421, effective immediately.

3. AVELINO, Reyna Reedley, CA She is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44420. 4. AYRES, Ryan R. Modesto, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fifteen (15) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

5. BAILEY, Dennis M. Atascadero, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 6. BAMBICO, Jesus P. Victorville, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of forty-five (45) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

7. BARDEN, Judith M. Long Beach, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fourteen (14) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.


8. BENSON, Scott A. Palo Alto, CA

All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing are suspended for a period of seven (7) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

9. BOAZ, Scott A. San Luis Obispo, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


10. BOIVIN-Wilkinson, Debra A. Vacaville, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are revoked and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

11. BOND, Mary L. Klamath Falls, OR All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of thirty (30) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

12. BRICKNER, Jeremy C. Sacramento, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


13. BRINKMAN, James S. Indio, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of thirty (30) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

14. BROTHWELL, Eric M. Rancho Santa Margarita, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 15. BUFANO, Joseph Rolling Hills, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of sixty (60) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

16. BULL, Anthony J. Atlanta, GA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 17. BUSCH, Vicki J. Riverside, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher



18. CARROLL, Gerald A. Orosi, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


19. CASTANEDA, Maria P. Planada, CA She is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 20. CLARK, Stephen E. Placentia, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


21. COLDREN, David L. San Bernardino, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of twenty-one (21) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

22. COLEMAN, Steven A. Fresno, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 23. COOK, Ursulo Running Springs, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


24. CORNER, Scott T. Monterey, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 25. CORNWALL, Joseph C. Palmdale, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 26. DE LOS SANTOS, Alex Fresno, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 27. FACKLER, Mark E. Sunland, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


28. FLORES, Francisco, L. San Francisco, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher



29. FREEMAN, Byron J. Redondo Beach, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


30. GANGLE, Francis J. Bakersfield, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


31. GOMEZ, Darin H. Tulare, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


32. GOODEYON, Nakoma G. San Diego, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 33. GOODIN, Robin M. Bakersfield, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


34. GROSSMAN, Douglas S. Encino, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


35. HAN, Jennifer Brea, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of five (5) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

36. HARRISON, Karen D. Salida, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


37. HASKELL, Michael S. Garden Grove, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 38. HAYES, Este’ban R. Long Beach, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421.


39. HODGES, Kristin D. Modesto, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of ten (10) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44420.

40. HOKANSON, Steven L. Redondo Beach, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of seventy-five (75) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

41. HUBBARD, La Cole L. Los Angeles, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


42. JEFFERY, Gary E. Rocklin, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fourteen (14) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

43. JUSTICE, Heather L. Fresno, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


44. KLEIN, Jill M. Lancaster, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


45. LOPEZ, Alma G. Riverside, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of seventy-five (75) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44420 and 44345.

46. LOPEZ, Jesus P. Sacramento, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of seven (7) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421, effective immediately.

47. LUBIN, Lorri K. Chevy Chase, MD All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


48. LUCIDO, Edward T. Oakley, CA


All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44345.

49. LUNA, Nancy D. Long Beach, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


50. LYTLE, Tim A. Salida, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of one hundred eighty (180) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

51. MADISON, Elzie L. Los Angeles, CA She is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 52. MARTINEZ, Marcia R. Bakersfield, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


53. MARTINEZ, Reyna H. Ukia, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 54. MATILDA, Anitha Los Angeles, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


55. MISTRETTA, Lori M. West Covina, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fifteen (15) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

56. MONAHAN, Michael A. Vallejo, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of forty-five (45) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

57. MOSLEY, Caprice D. Upland, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


58. NGUYEN, Chinh D. Santa Ana, CA


All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing are suspended for a period of thirty (30) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

59. PHAM, Hung M. Agoura Hills, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


60. PHILLIPS, Richard B. Camarillo, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of sixty (60) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

61. POMPA, Maria D. Pixley, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


62. POMROY, Tina B. Oakland, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


63. POTEET, Shannon H. Modesto, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


64. RAMEY, Isaac J. Ukiah, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


65. RAMOS, Frances C. Bermuda Dunes, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


66. REDICK, Cornelius Jr. Castaic, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of ninety (90) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

67. REMY, Michael S. Visalia, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421, effective immediately.


68. RODRIGUEZ, Ricardo Davis, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


69. RUEZGA, Ivan S. South Gate, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 70. RUIZ, Jose E. Sacramento, CA He is the subject of public reproval for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44421. 71. SANCHEZ, Maria E. Compton, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of twenty-one (21) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

71a. SANDERS, Sherwin B. Riverside, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fourteen (14) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421, effective immediately.

72. SKINNER, Leigh S. Menlo Park, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of twenty-one (21) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

73. SOLA, Lori S. Corona, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fourteen (14) days and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345, effective immediately.

74. TAULUA, Simeta E. Hawthorne, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 75. TENNEY, James K. Glendora, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


76. THOMPSON, Holly F. Elizabeth Lake, CA


All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing are revoked and any pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code sections 44421 and 44345.

77. TRIMBLE, Allan E. Davis, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


78. TYKS, Thomas F. Highland, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


79. VALLES, Carlos Fresno, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


80. VAN ANDEL, Ines K. Hanford, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


81. VOLLMER, Thomas L. Tehachapi, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


82. WATERS, Jennifer M. Angelino Heights, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


83. WHEELER, Karen E. Cayucos, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of ten (10) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

84. WILLIAMS, Doris M. Palo Alto, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


85. WINGERT, Nathan T. Visalia, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher



86. WINSLOW, Deannah M. Redlands, CA All pending applications are denied for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section

44345. 87. YOUNG, Allen V. Sacramento, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher

Credentialing are suspended for a period of fourteen (14) days for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421, effective immediately.

88. ZAMBRANO, Zenon R. San Diego, CA All certification documents under the jurisdiction of the California Commission on Teacher


CONSENT DETERMINATIONS

The following consent determinations are adopted: 89. BISHOP, Neva M. Twenty-Nine Palms, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that her application will be granted and

revoked; however, the revocation is stayed, and she is placed on probation for a period of three (3) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

90. BLACK, Scott D. Tracy, CA The Attorney General’s Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification

documents are suspended for a period of twenty-one days; however, the suspension is stayed, and he is placed on probation for a period of two (2) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

91. BROWN, Benjamin L. San Francisco, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, allows him to withdraw his application, for

misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421. 92. DUARTE, Luis A. Chula Vista, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

suspended for a period of twenty-two (22) days, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

93. FLANIGAN, Duane E. Santa Barbara, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

suspended for a period of one hundred fifty (150) days, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

94. JENNINGS, Eric E. Clovis, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

revoked; however, the revocation is stayed, and he is placed on probation for a period of three (3) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.


95. MORENO, Juan M. Chula Vista, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

suspended for a period of forty-five (45) days, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

96. ROGERS, Keith E. Stockton, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

suspended for a period of ninety (90) days; however, the suspension is stayed, and he is placed on probation for a period of three (3) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

97. ROSE, Lawrence R. Danville, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

revoked; however, the revocation is stayed, and he is placed on probation for a period of two (2) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

98. SPENCER, Bridget L. Oakland, CA The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that Ms. Spencer’s application will be

granted upon submission of proof that court ordered restitution has been paid in full and the application will be immediately revoked; however, the revocation will be stayed, and she will be placed on probation for a period of three (3) years, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

99. VANFOSSEN, John F. Ridgecrest, Ca The Proposed Consent Determination, stipulates that all certification documents are

suspended for a period of ten (10) days, for misconduct pursuant to Education Code section 44421.

RECONSIDERATION CONSENT

(Deny--no new information)

100. CUEVAS, Delia Los Angeles, CA At its June 27-28, 2007 meeting, the Commission adopted the Committee of Credentials’ recommendation to revoke all credentials, life diplomas or other certification documents under the jurisdiction of the Commission and deny any pending applications. Ms. Cuevas submitted a letter received on July 12, 2007, requesting reconsideration. No new information was provided.

101. UPHAUS, Elizabeth Evanston, IL

At its June 27-28, 2007 meeting, the Commission adopted the Committee of Credentials’ recommendation to revoke all credentials, life diplomas or other certification documents under the jurisdiction of the Commission and deny any pending applications. Ms. Uphaus submitted a letter received on July 18, 2007, requesting reconsideration. No new information was provided.

PRIVATE ADMONITION


Pursuant to Education Code section 44438, the Committee of Credentials recommends one (1) private admonition for the Commission’s approval.

DECISION AND ORDER

102. ENGEMANN, Noelle F. Burlingame, CA

In accordance with the default provisions of Government Code section 11520, Ms. Engemann’s credentials are hereby revoked.

REQUESTS FOR REVOCATION

The following credentials are revoked pursuant to the written request of the credential holder pursuant to Education Code sections 44423 and 44440.

103. BEERS, Lois A. San Diego, CA Upon her written request, pursuant to Education Code section 44423, all certification

documents are revoked. 104. COULSON, Gregory L. Santa Paula, CA Upon his written request, pursuant to Education Code section 44423, all certification

documents are revoked. 105. DE FORGE, John J. Riverside, CA Upon his written request and pursuant to Education Code section 44423, his supplemental

authorization of Social Science on his Professional Clear Single Subject Teaching Credential is revoked.

106. DUNNING, Melissa C. Berkeley, CA Upon her written request and pursuant to Education Code section 44423, all certification

documents are revoked. 107. LEACH, Mark D. Chico, CA Upon his written request and pursuant to Education Code section 44423, his supplemental

authorization of Health Education on his Clear Single Subject Teaching Credential is revoked.

108. RILEY, Timothy J. Lincoln, CA Upon his written request and pursuant to Education Code section 44423, his supplemental

authorization of Biology on his Clear Single Subject Teaching Credential is revoked.

DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICES

MANDATORY ACTIONS

All certification documents held by and applications filed by the following individuals were mandatorily revoked or denied pursuant to Education Code sections 44346, 44346.1, 44424, 44425 and 44425.5, which require the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing to mandatorily revoke the credentials held by individuals convicted of specified crimes and to mandatorily deny applications submitted by individuals convicted of specified crimes.


109. BAILEY, Brent W. Fullerton, CA 110. CARDOZA, Julio A. Pasadena, CA 111. CASE, Gregory F. El Centro, CA 112. CLIVAZ, Aurelie C. Boulder Creek, CA 113. DIAL, John W. Bakersfield, CA 114. GARCIA, Mario S. Simi Valley, CA 115. HERNANDEZ, Carlos San Diego, CA 116. IRIGOYEN, Marco A. West Covina, CA 117. JOHNSON, Alyssa A. Santa Ana, CA 118. LARIOS, Nancy J. San Pedro, CA 119. LYLE, Cortelyou Jr. Long Beach, CA 120. MENESES, Gabriel L. Porterville, CA 121. NORTON, Allen H. Barstow, CA 122. OLSEN, Eric N. Ontario, CA 123. PALUMBO, Frank P. San Diego, CA 124. PLATA, Miguel A. Huntington Park, CA 125. RAMSERRAN, Tarisa J. Reseda, CA 126. ROBINSON, Lanny B. Tustin, CA 127. STONE, Euna J. Sacramento, CA 128. STONE, Matthew M. Fontana, CA 129. THOROSSIAN, Rafik Glendale, CA 130. VANDERBERG, Larry A. Garden Grove, CA 131. WOLF, Jonathan S. Los Angeles, CA

AUTOMATIC SUSPENSIONS


All certification documents held by the following individuals were automatically suspended because a complaint, information or indictment was filed in court alleging each individual committed an offense specified in Education Code section 44940. Their certification documents will remain automatically suspended until the Commission receives notice of entry of judgment pursuant to Education Code section 44940(d) and (e).

132. ALBRECHT, Adam G. Pacifica, CA 133. AXTELL, Daniel D. Dana Point, CA 134. CORRAL, Martin C. Ventura, CA 135. FERNANDEZ, Fernando F. Salida, CA 136. HERRERA, Daniel T. Alameda, CA 137. PRAY, Edward J. San Jose, CA 138. SANTOS, Martin B. Irvine, CA 139. SORG, Kay L. Berkeley, CA 140. SPARKS, William R. Oakland, CA 141. SWANNER, Israel R. Stockton, CA 142. THEOBALD, Brad J. Upland, CA

NO CONTEST SUSPENSION

All credentials held by the following individual were suspended, pursuant to Education Code section 44424 or 44425, because a plea of no contest was entered to an offense specified in the above sections of the Education Code. The credentials will remain suspended until final disposition by the Commission.

143. DEER, Mitchell A. Rocklin, CA

TERMINATION OF PROBATION

144. ABBAGE, Marshall Marina Del Rey, CA Having successfully complied with the terms and conditions of probation contained in the

Consent Determination and Order, which was adopted by the Commission on June 3, 2004, the stay order has been made permanent and his credential is fully restored.

145. GAUMER, Gregory R. Downey, CA Having successfully complied with the terms and conditions of probation contained in the

Consent Determination and Order, which was adopted by the Commission on May 6, 2004, the stay order has been made permanent and his credential is fully restored.


146. LOVE, Thomas A. Big Bear City, CA Having successfully complied with the terms and conditions of probation contained in the

Consent Determination and Order, which was adopted by the Commission on October 7, 1999, the stay order has been made permanent and his credential is fully restored.

147. ROTHSCHILLER, Donald Fair Oaks, CA Having successfully complied with the terms and conditions of probation contained in the

Consent Determination and Order, which was adopted by the Commission on July 16, 1993, the stay order has been made permanent and his credential is fully restored.

VIOLATION OF PROBATION

148. HUBBARD, Lee Daly City, CA Having violated the conditions of probation set forth in the Consent Determination and

Order, which was adopted by the Commission on December 1, 2004, his probation is terminated, the stay is lifted, and his credentials are revoked.

Certification, Assignment and Waivers Division

VALIDATION OF SERVICE RENDERED WITHOUT A CREDENTIAL The service rendered by the following persons is approved pursuant

to the provisions of the California Education Code, Section 45036.

Name

School District

County

Period of Service

Marianne Antonio Oxnard School District Ventura 07/01/07-07/12/07

Cindy Crawford Irvine Unified School District Orange 06/01/07-06/21/07

Kathleen O’Neill Fanucchi

Millbrae School District San Mateo 06/01/07-06/05/07

Debra A. French Adelanto School District San Bernardino 03/01/07-03/22/07 *Sharon L. Kamberg Burton School District Tulare 05/01/07-05/21/07

Shaunta Montalvo Richgrove School District Tulare 07/02/07-07/12/07 Edward Pacula, Jr. Ventura Unified School

District Ventura 07/01/07-07/09/07

*David D. Schrag Belmont-Redwood Shores San Mateo 05/01/07-05/31/07 Judith Swick Fresno Unified School

District Fresno 06/01/07-06/18/07

*Two Credentials: Multiple Subject and Administrative Services Credentials *Two Credentials: Multiple Subject and Administrative Services Credentials

october 2007 minutes

Documents