nuclear forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/ishii.pdflattice qcd...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
(1)
Nuclear Forces on the latticeNoriyoshi Ishii
(Univ. of Tokyo)for
PACS-CS Collaborationand
HAL QCD Collaboration
S.Aoki (Univ. of Tsukuba),T.Doi (Univ. of Tsukuba),T.Hatsuda (Univ. of Tokyo),Y.Ikeda (RIKEN), T.Inoue (Nihon Univ.), K.Murano (KEK),H.Nemura (Tohoku Univ.)K.Sasaki (Univ. of Tsukuba)
![Page 2: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
(2)Background Realistic nuclear force
Large number of NN scattering data is used to consturuct realistic nuclear force
Once it is constructed, it can be conveniently used to study nuclear structure and nuclear reaction equation of state of nuclear matter supernova explosion, strucuture of neutron star
NN scattering data(~4000 data)
Realistic nuclear potential(18 fit parameter χ2/dof ~1[AV18])
![Page 3: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
(3)Nuclear Force Long distance (r > 2 fm)
OPEP [H.Yukawa(1935)](One Pion Exchange)
Medium distance (1 fm < r < 2fm)multi-pion,Attraction essential for bound nuclei
Short distance (r < 1 fm)Repulsive core [R.Jastrow(1950)]
reg rm
NN
4
2
,"",,
Crab nebula
![Page 4: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
(4)Lattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadron potential)There are several methods: Method which utilizes the static quarks
D.G.Richards et al., PRD42, 3191 (1990).A.Mihaly et la., PRD55, 3077 (1997).C.Stewart et al., PRD57, 5581 (1998).C.Michael et al., PRD60, 054012 (1999). P.Pennanen et al, NPPS83, 200 (2000), A.M.Green et al., PRD61, 014014 (2000).H.R Fiebig, NPPS106, 344 (2002); 109A, 207 (2002).T.T.Takahashi et al, ACP842,246(2006),T.Doi et al., ACP842,246(2006)W.Detmold et al.,PRD76,114503(2007)
Method which utilizes the Bethe-Salpeter wave functionIshii, Aoki, Hatsuda, PRL99,022011(2007).Nemura, Ishii, Aoki, Hatsuda, PLB673,136(2009).Aoki, Hatsuda, Ishii, CSD1,015009(2008).Aoki, Hatsuda,Ishii, PTP123,89(2010).
Strong coupling limitPh. de Forcrand and M.Fromm, PRL104,112005(2010).
![Page 5: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
(5)Nuclear force by lattice QCD Method which utilizes BS wave function
[Ishii,Aoki,Hatsuda,PRL99,022001(2007)]
Advantages An extention to the Luscher’s finite volume method for scattering phase shift. Asymptotic form of BS wave function (r large)
is used to construct NN potentials, which can reproduce the NN scattering data. Scattering data is not needed in constructing hadron potentials. It is usable to experimentally difficult objects such as
hyperon potentials (YN and YY) and three nucleon potentials (NNN).
Schr
odin
gere
q.
BS wave func. nuclear potential
latt
ice Q
CD
( ) sin( ( ))0 | ( ) (0) | ( ) ( ), i kN
kr kN x N N k N k ink
eZr
![Page 6: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
(6)Plan of the talk
General Strategy and Derivative expansion Central potential How good is the derivative expansion ? Tensor potential 2+1 flavor QCD results Hyperon potential Summary and Outlook
![Page 7: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
(7)
Comments:(1) Exact phase shifts at E = En
(2) As number of BS wave functions increases,the potential becomes more and more faithful to (Luesher’s) phase shifts.
(3) U(x,y) does NOT depend on energy E.
(4) U(x,y) is most generally a non-local object.
General Strategy Bethe-Salpeter (BS) wave function (equal time)
An amplitude to find (quite naïve picture)3 quark at x and another 3 quark at y
desirable asymptotic behavior as r large.
Definition of nuclear potential (E-independent non-local)
U(x,y) is defined by demanding(at multiple energies En) satisfy this equation simultaneously.
( ) 0 | ( ) ( ) ( )( ,)|x y N x N k ky N N in
30( ) ( ) ( , ) ( )E EE H x d yU x y y
( ) sin ( )( ) i k
N
kr kr Z e
kr
)(xE
C.-J.D.Lin et al., NPB619,467(2001)CP-PACS Coll., PRD71,094504(2005).
Aoki,Hatsuda,Ishii, PTP123,89(2010).
![Page 8: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
(8)General Strategy: Derivative expansionWe construct U(x,y) step by step.
Derivative expansion of the non-local potential
Leading Order:Use BS wave function of the lowest-lying state to obtain
Next to Leading Order:Include another BS wave function to obtain
Repeat this procedure to obtain higher derivative terms.
}),({)()()(),( 212 rVSLrVSrVrVxV DLSTC
)()()()( 0
xxHErV
E
EC
12( , ) ( ) ( ) ( )C TV x V r V r S O
)(),(),( yxxVyxU
212
2112 /))((3 rrrS
Example (1S0): Only VC(r) survives for 1S0 channel:
( ), (( ), )C T LSr VV V rr
)()()()( 0 xrVxHE ECE
212( , ) ( ) ( ) ( )· (· )C T LSV x V r V r S V r L OS
212
3( , ) ( ) ( ) ( ) { ( ), ( )}C T LS DV x V r V r S V r L S V r O
( ), ( )C TV r V r
![Page 9: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
(9)Numerical Setups Quenched QCD
plaquette gauge + Wilson quark actionmpi = 380 - 730 MeVa=0.137 fm, L=32a=4.4fm
2+1 flavor QCD (by PACS-CS)Iwasaki gauge + clover quark actionmpi = 411 – 700 MeVa=0.091 fm, L=32a=2.9 fm
PACS-CS@Tsukuba T2K@Tsukuba
BGL@KEK
![Page 10: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
(10)BS wave function
0
0
0( )
( )
0 | [ ( , ) ( , ) ( )] | 0
0 | ( ) ( ) | | | 0
( )
n
n
t t E
nt t E
n nn
T N x t N y t NN t
N x N y n e N
y A e
n N
x
BS wave function is obtained in the large t region of nucleon four point function.
( ) 0 | ( ) ( ) |x y N x N y NN
5( C )) (dTabc a b c xp x u u
We adopted
5( C )) (dTabc a b c xn x u d
Comments
As far as the proper asymptotic form is satisfied, any interpolating fields can be used.
They lead to phase equivalent potentials.
Good choice potentials with small non-locality and small E dependence.Bad choice highly non-local potential or highly E dependent potential.
![Page 11: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
(11)Central potential (leading order) by quenched QCD
Repulsive core: 500 - 600 MeVAttraction: ~ 30 MeV
Ishii, Aoki, Hatsuda, PRL99,022001(2007).
Qualitative features of the nuclear force are reproduced.
)()()()( 0
xxHErV
E
EC
![Page 12: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
(12)Quark mass dependence
1S0
In the light quark mass region,
The repulsive core grows rapidly.
Attraction gets stronger.
Aoki,Hatsuda,Ishii,CSD1,015009(2008).
![Page 13: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
(13)How good is the derivative expansion ?
The non-local potential U(x,y) is faithful to scattering datain wide range of energy region (by construction) Def. by effective Schroedinger eq.
Desirable asymptotic behavior at large separation
The local potential at E~0(obtained at leading order derivative expansion)
is faithful to scattering data only at E~0 (scattering length).However, it is not guaranteed to reproduce the scattering data at different energy.
Convergence of the derivative expansion has to be examinedin order to see its validity in the different energy region.
)(}),({)()()(),( 212 yxrVSLrVSrVrVyxU DLSTC
)(),()()( 30 yyxUydxHE EE
( ) sin ( )( ) i k
N
kr kr Z e
kr
![Page 14: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
(14)
Strategy: generate two local potentials at different energies
Difference truncation error (of derivative expansion) = size of higher order effect (= non-locality)
How good is derivative expansion ?
MeV46CM E
Potential at is constructed by anti-periodic BC0E
fm4.4L
)(}),({)()()(),( 212 yxrVSLrVSrVrVyxU DLSTC
( ) at E ~ 0MeVCV r
( ) at E ~ 46MeVCV r
![Page 15: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
(15)How good is the derivative expansion ? (cont'd)[K.Murano@Lattice2009]
Small discrepancy at short distance.(really small)
Derivative expansion works.
Local potential is safely usedin the region ECM = 0 – 46 MeV
Non-locality may increase,if we go close to the pion threshold.
(NNNNπ)
ECM ~ 530 MeV. (in our setup)
BS wave functions
Potentials
E ~ 0 MeV E ~ 46 MeV
![Page 16: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
(16)
Tensor Potential
![Page 17: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
(17)Tensor potentialBackground
Phenomenologically important for
Nuclear saturation density and stability of nuclei.
Huge influence on the structures of nuclei
Mixing of s-wave and d-wave deuteron
In OBEP picture, it is obtained from a cancellation between π and ρ.
Tensor force at short distance is important forShort Range Correlated (SRC) nucleon pairand cold dense nuclear systemsuch as neutron star[R.Subedi et al., SCIENCE320,1476(2008)]
fromR.Machleidt,Adv.Nucl.Phys.19
![Page 18: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
(18)d-wave BS wave functionBS wave function for JP=1+ consists of two orbital components:
s-wave (l=0) and d-wave (l=2)
On the lattice, we prepare T1+ state (JP=1+), and decompose it as
(1) s-wave (Orbitally A1+)
(2) d-wave (Orbitally non-A1+)
Og
S rgrPr )(241)]([)( 1)(
)()()]([)( )()( rrrQr SD
The cubic group
Up to higher order (l ≧ 4), s-wave and d-wave can be separated.
![Page 19: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
(19)d-wave BS wave function
)ˆ()ˆ(6
2
)ˆ(6
2)ˆ(
)()()()(
1,20,2
0,21,2
)()(
)()(
rYrY
rYrY
rrrr
DD
DD
d-wave “spinor harmonics”
Angular dependence Multi-valuedAlmost Single-valued
is dominated by d-wave.(l ≧ 4 contamination is small)
JP=1+, M=0
)(Dde
vide
it by
Ylm
and
by C
G fa
ctorBS wave func. for T1
+(total) state
![Page 20: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
(20)Tensor force (cont'd)
Qualitative feature is reproduced.
Ishii,Aoki,Hatsuda,PoS(LAT2008)155.
)()()()( 120 rErSrVrVH TC
)()()()()(
)()()()()(
012
012
rQHErQSrVrQrVrPHErPSrVrPrV
TC
TC
(s-wave)
(d-wave)
![Page 21: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
(21)Tensor potential (quark mass dependence)
Tensor potential is enhanced in the light quark mass region
![Page 22: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
(22)Energy dependence of tensor force
)(13
13 rVDS T )(1
3 rVS C
Energy dependence is weak for JP=1+
Small energy dependence implies Derivative expansion works.
These local potentials are safely usedin the energy region ECM = 0 – 46 MeV.
E~46 MeV E~0 MeV
MeV46CM E
fm4.4L
![Page 23: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
(23)
2+1 flavor QCD
Gauge configurations by PACS-CS Collaboration
![Page 24: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
(24)2+1 flavor PACS-CS gauge configurationPACS-CS coll. is generating 2+1 flavor gauge configurations in significantly light quark mass region on a large spatial volume 2+1 flavor full QCD
[PACSCS Coll. PRD79(2009)034503].
Iwasaki gauge action at β=1.90 on 323×64 lattice
O(a) improved Wilson quark (clover) actionwith a non-perturbatively improved coefficient cSW=1.715
1/a=2.17 GeV (a~0.091 fm). L=32a~2.91 fm
PACS-CS
L=2.9 fmMpi=296 MeVκud=0.13770κs =0.13640
L=2.9 fmMpi=156 MeVκud=0.13781κs =0.13640
L=2.9 fmMpi=384 MeVκud=0.13754κs =0.13660
L=2.9 fmMpi=411 MeVκud=0.13754κs =0.13640
L=2.9 fmMpi=570 MeVκud=0.13727κs =0.13640
L=2.9 fmMpi=701 MeVκud=0.13700κs =0.13640
Available through ILDG/JLDG
PACS-CS Coll. is currently generating2+1 flavor gauge config's with physical mpi
on L~6 fm lattice.super computer T2K
![Page 25: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
(25)NN potentials
Comparing to the quenched ones,
(1) Repulsive core and tensor force become significantly stronger.Reasons are under investigation.(Discretization artifact is another possibility)
(2) Attractions at medium distance are similar in magnitude.
2+1 flavor results quenched results
![Page 26: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
(26)NN potentials (quark mass dependence)
With decreasing quark mass,interaction range becomes wider.
Repulsive core grows. Attraction becomes stronger Tensor force gets stronger
![Page 27: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
(27)NN (phase shift from potentials)
They have reasonable shapes.
![Page 28: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
(28)NN (phase shift from potentials)
We have no deuteron so far.
They have reasonable shapes. The strength is much weaker.(Similar behavior is seen in the scattering length.)
![Page 29: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
(29)
NN scattering length
![Page 30: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
(30)Scattering length of NN
Attractive scattering lengthparticle physics convensiona > 0 attractive
This is in conflict with NPLQCD results:Repulsive scattering length.
S.R.Beane et al., PRL97,012001(2006).S.R.Beane et al., arXiv:0912.4243.
wave function k2 Luscher's formula
Very weak scattering length comparing to the experimental values
a0(1S0) ~ 20 fm, a0(
3S1) ~ -5 fm
The reason seems to be
(1) quark mass dependence(2) slow convergence at long distance region
![Page 31: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
(31)Reason 1: Quark mass dependence of scattering length There are several opinions against quark mass dependence of scattering length.
It is agreed that the physical quark mass point is in the unitary region,where the scattering length shows a rapid increase near a bound state generation.
Because our quark mass is heavy and far from the unitary region,the scattering length is small.
Y.Kuramashi, PTPS122(1996)153. S.Beane et al., PRL97,012001(2006).
![Page 32: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
(32)Reason 2: Slow convergence at long distance (0)
700 MeVm
Convergence of this part seems to be quite slow.
It tends to go up.2 21 ( ) ( )
( ) CN N
x kV xm x m
Since the contribution at long distance comes with volume element,even a small deviation may lead to a large uncertainty.
t evolution of
![Page 33: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
(33)Reason 2: Slow convergence at long distance (1)We use different starting points (source) attempting to boost the convergence.
Luescher’s formula indicates
2
1 to 3 MeVN
km
0 0.1 0.3 fma
This may not be the main reasonfor the small scattering length.
Statistics has to be improved.
cos( ) cos( ) cos( ) wit( , , ) 1 h 2 /px py pz p Lf x y z
t evolution of2 21 ( ) ( )
( ) CN N
x kV xm x m
![Page 34: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
(34)
Hyperon Potentials
![Page 35: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
(35)
J.Schaffner-Bielich, NPA804(’08)309.
Important for structure of hyper nuclei
equation of state of hyperon matter hyperon matter generation in neutron star core.
Limited number of experimental information(Direct experiment is difficult due to their short life time)
Hyperon potentials J-PARCExploration of multi-strangeness world
![Page 36: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
(36)N-Xi potential (I=1) by quenched QCDRepulsive core is surrounded by
attraction like NN case.
Strong spin dependence
quark mass dependence
Repulsive core grows with decreasing quark mass. No significant change in the attraction.
Nemura, Ishii, Aoki, Hatsuda,PLB673(2009)136.
![Page 37: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
(37)NΛ potential (quenched QCD)
Repulsive core is surrounded by attractive well.
Spin dependence of the repulsive core is large.
Spin dependence of the attraction is small.
Weak tensor potential
[Nemura@lattice2009]
MeV514m
![Page 38: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
(38)NΛ potential (2+1 flavor QCD)
MeV701m
[Nemura@lattice2009]
Repulsive core is surrounded by attractive well.
Large spin dependence of repulsive core
Weak tensor force
Net interaction is attractive.
![Page 39: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
(39)Quark mass dependence of NΛ potential0
1S 13
13 DS Central Central & Tensor
With decreasing u and d quark masses,
Repulsive core is enhanced.
Attractive well moves to outer region.
Small quark mass dependence of tensor potential
![Page 40: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
(40)Hyperon potential in flavor SU(3) limit
For detail, see T.Inoue et al, arXiv:1007.3559 [hep-lat]
Aim: A systematic study of short range baryon-baryon interactions
Strong flavor dependence All distance attraction for flavor 1 representation. Strong repulsive core for flavor 8S representation. Weak repulsive core for flavor 8a representatin.
This behaviors at short distance are consistent with quark Pauli blocking picture.
10S
31S
u d u d s
![Page 41: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
(41)Summary
Realistic potentials with physical quark mass in a large spatial volume (L ~ 6 fm)by using PACS-CS gauge configuration [planned]
Higher derivative terms (LS force and more), p-wave.More hyperon potentials including coupled channel extension [work in progress]
Three-baryon potential. [work in progress]
Origin of the repulsive core [work in progress]Flavor SU(3) limit and its breaking (a systematic study of short range BB interaction)Short distance analysis by Operator Product Expansion
Applications:Nuclear physics based on lattice QCDEq. of states of nuclear/hyperon matter for supernovae and neutron stars
Outlook
General strategy (NN potentials from BS wave functions) We introduced the non-local potential, which is faithful to phase shift data by constuction.
Numerical results (based on derivative expansion) Central potential, tensor potential, hyperon potentials (NXi [I=1] and NLambda) Derivative expansion of (E-independent) non-local potential works well [ECM = 0-46 MeV] 2+1 flavor QCD results (by PACS-CS gauge config.)
NN and NΛ (central and tensor potentials) [L ~ 3 fm] Phase shift and scattering length are weaker than empirical ones.
Improvements in quark mass and convergence at long distance are needed. (Give us time)
![Page 42: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
(42)
END
![Page 43: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
(43)
Backup Slides
![Page 44: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
(44)
qrsqrZex si
q)(sin)( 0)(0
Asymptotic form of BS wave functionFor simplicity, we consider BS wave function of two pions
( ) 0 ( ) (0) ( ) ( ),q x N x N N q N q in
3
3 0 ( ) ( ) ( ) (0) ( ) ( ), ( )(2 ) 2 ( )N
d p N x N p N p N N q N q in I xE p
3
3
1 ( ; )(2 ) 2 ( ) 4 ( ) ( ) ( )N N
iq x ip
N
x
N
d p T p qZ e eE p E q E p E q i
qree
ieZ
iqrsixqi )1
21 )(2 0
[C.-J.D.Lin et al., NPB619,467(2001)]
xpieZ2/1
1/2
22 2
( ; ).2 ( ) ( )N N N
T p qdisc Zm E q E p p i
3
31 ( ) ( )(2 ) 2 ( )N
d p N p N pE p
complete set
1)(2
)()( )(2)( 0 siwaves eiqqEsT
Integral is dominated by the on-shell contribution T-matrix becomes the on-shell T-matrix
( ) ( )N NE p E q
(s-wave)This is analogousto a non-rela. wave function
The asymptotic form
![Page 45: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
(45)Effective Schrodinger equation with E-independent potential
2 2( ; ) ( ; )K x E k x E (localized object: propagating d.o.f. is filtered out)
We would like to factorize3( ; ) ( , ) ( ; )NK x E d x Eym U y y
2 22 NE m k
Factorization:
(1) Assumption: ψ(x; E,α) for different E and α is linearly independent with each other.
(2) ψ(x; E,α) has a “left inverse” as an integration operator as
(3) K(x; E,α) can be factorized as
(4) We are left with an effective Schrodinger equation with an E-independent potential U.
(α is to distinguish states with same E.)
3,( ; ', ) ( ; , ) 2 ( )d x x E x E E E
3
3
'; , ) ( ; , ) ( ; , ) ( ; , )2
(
( ; , )( ; , ) ( ; , )2
dEx E
dE K x E y
K K x E d y y E y E
yEd y E
( , )Nm U x y
2 2 3( ; ) ( , ) ( ; )Nx E m d yU x y yk E
(※) U(x,y) is obtained by integrating over E. It does not have E dependence.
![Page 46: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
(46)Finite size artifact is weak at short distance. Finite size artifact on the potential is weak at short distance !
(Example)L~3 fm [RC32x64_B1900Kud01370000Ks01364000C1715]L~1.8fm [RC20x40_B1900Kud013700Ks013640C1715]
central(1S0)_ tensor force
Central force has to shift by E=24~29MeV.
However, due to the missing asymptotic region, zero adjustment does not work.(Central force has uncertainty in zero adjustment due to the finite size artifact.)
Tensor force is free from such uncertainty.
Multi-valuedness of the central force is due to the finite size artifact.
Finite size artifacts of short distance part of these potentials are weak !
)()(1)(
2
C xx
mErV
N
(for 1S0)
fm9.0
fm9.0
O
![Page 47: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
(47)BackgroundLuscher’s method
two paritle scattering spectrum in finite box
scattering phase shift2
( )2
2cot 1; kLk ZL
k
Luescher’s zeta function
Method, which utilizes temporal correlation(from two particle spectrum)
Method, which utilizes spatial correlation(from asymptotic behavior of BS wave function)
2( ) / ( )(
~ xp
)
'eNN NR t C t C t
A Et
2 22( )k m k mE
) 0 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ),(k r N x N y N k N k in
asymptotic momentum |k|
asympototicmomentum |k|
![Page 48: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
(48)Temporal correlation v.s. spatial correlationAsymptotic form of BS wave function at long distance
0
3
3
3· ·
3
2 ( )·
) 0 ) (0) ( ) ( ),
0 ( ) ( ) · ( ) 0 ( ) ( ), ( )(2 ) 2 ( )
1 , )(2 ) 2 ( ) )· ) ( )
( (
(
1
)
(4
1 (a2
( (
q
iq x ip x
iqri siq x
x x N N q N q in
d p N x N p N p N q N q in I xE p
d p p q
N
N
Z eE p q
TeE E q E q i
i re e eZ
q
t long distance)
At sufficiently long distance (beyond therange of interaction), BS wave functionsatsifies the Helmholtz equation:
2 2 ( ) 0q xq
2 2( )q mE q
Energy of the state E(q) [temporal correlation]has to be consistent with
BS wave function at large distance [spatial correlation].
This is related toT-matrixby the reduction formula
cf) C.-J.D.Lin et al.,NPB619,467(2001).CP-PACS Coll., PRD71,094504(2005).
![Page 49: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
(49)ground state energy BS wave function [wall source]
The information is contained in the long range part,which, however, is not sufficiently converged yet.
R(t) [wall source]
plateaux seem to appear in the region t >= 10 for N(t) and D(t),where R(t) is too noisy to extract any information.
(( ,) )NNx
N t xG t
2
(( ) , )Nx
x tD t G
effective mass plot
(()
) )(
N tRD
tt
effective mass plot
![Page 50: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
(50)ground state energy(2) R(t) [smeared source]
It is possible to make the appearance of the pleatau at earliear stageby arranging a suitable value of the smearing size.
denominator numerator
common plateau in the rgion t ≧ 7.R(t) in this region ΔE~ -15 MeV
The identification of the plateauxin the numerator and the denominatormay have uncertainty of about5MeV.
ΔE~-15 MeV (± 10 MeV)
![Page 51: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
(51)
2( ; )( ) ); (NN NC t R CR t tR ( ; )NNC t R
ground state energy (3) Naïve identification of the plateau
may involves a serious systematic uncertainty.
1 2 3, ,( ; ) ( ; )NN NN
R x x x RC t R C x t
Which plateau is better ? black data (R=8) v.s. purple ones (R=7) ?
They are going to converge to a single energy at very large t region. (t/a ~ 100 ?)
![Page 52: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
(52)Time evolution of △ψ(x)/ψ(x)
They are going to converge to the wall source result.
ρ(smearing size)~L
![Page 53: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
(53)Time evolution of 4pt func.
(8 source pt.) (4 source pt.)
(4 source pt.) (32 source pt.)
These are changing to the shape of the wall source wave function.
0
, ) 0 | [ ( , ) (0, ) (0) (0)] | 0
( )· exp( )
(
n n
NN
nn
x t T N x t NC t N N
x A E t
![Page 54: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
(54)eff ’mass plot of four pt function
Variation of t-dependence among different spatial points is small for the wall source result.
ρ~L
0
, ) 0 | [ ( , ) (0, ) (0) (0)] | 0
( )· exp( )
(
n n
NN
nn
x t T N x t NC t N N
x A E t
![Page 55: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
(55)Luescher’s Zeta function2
( )2
2cot 1; kLk ZL
k
Luescher’s zeta function
![Page 56: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
(56)
The most general (off-shell) form of NN potential: [S.Okubo, R.E.Marshak,Ann.Phys.4,166(1958)]
where
★ the terms up to O(p) the convensional form of the potential
General form of NN potential★ Imposed constraints:• Probability (Hermiticity):• Energy-momentum conservation:• Galilei invariance:• Spatial rotation:• Spatial reflection:• Time reversal:• Quantum statistics:• Isospin invariance:
))())((21
},{21)})((,{
21},{)()(
)(
122112
122112210
210
LLLLQ
QVppVSVSLVVVV
VVV
iQ
ip
iT
iLS
iii
ipLprVV i
jij ),,,( 222
).()()()()()( 212210
OSrVSLrVrVrVV TLS
)(rVC
![Page 57: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
(57)Tensor potential (E v.s. T2 representation)d-wave E-rep + T2-repWe may play with this "1 to 2" correspondence.
1. The simplest choiceRegard E-rep as d-waveUnobtainable pt.: (pt. where Ylm vanishes)
2. Cubic group friendly choice
Maximum # of unobtainable pt., z-axis, xy-plane
3. Angle-dependent combination of E and T2-rep. to achieve Minimum # of unobtainable pt.
(0,0,0)[SO(3) sym must be good.]No significant change
except for sizes of statistical errors
)(&)()( )()( 2 rVrVrV TT
ETT
nnn ,,
nnn ,,
![Page 58: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
(58)Four point nucleon correlator to BS wave function
00 0
( , ) 0 T ( , 0) ( , ) (0) (0) 0
0 ( ) (
( ) exp( )
) (0) (0) 0m
NN
t
m
E
E
C x y t p x t n y t p n
p x n y m e m p
t
n
A x y E
yx
t
Ground state saturation around t ~ 8 (?).
![Page 59: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
(59)Exploding behavior at r > 1.5 fm is due to contamination from excited state
dominant(ground state)
contamination(excited state)
+
~1 %
t=5t=9t=10
There are spatial regions where this excited state contamination is reduced.If we restrict ourselves to this region, the results become improved.
![Page 60: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
(60)Exploding behavior at r > 1.5 fm is due to contamination from excited state
t=5t=9t=10
work in progress by K.Murano
![Page 61: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
(61)Tensor force (cont'd) Derivative expansion up to local terms
Schroedinger eq for JP=1+(I=0)
Solve them for VC(r) and VT(r) point by point
)()()()( 120 rErSrVrVH TC
}),({)()()(),( 212 rVSLrVSrVrVxV DLSTC
)()()()()(
)()()()()(
012
012
rQHErQSrVrQrVrPHErPSrVrPrV
TC
TC
)()(
)()()(
)()()()(
012
12
rQrP
HErVrV
rQSrQrPSrP
T
C
(s-wave)
(d-wave)
![Page 62: Nuclear Forces on the latticetheor.jinr.ru/~readings/2010/presentation/23sept/Ishii.pdfLattice QCD approaches to nuclear force (hadronpotential) (4) There are severalmethods: Method](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022071605/6141ec052035ff3bc76256ce/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
(62)NN potentials (quark mass dependence)
With decreasing quark mass,interaction range becomes wider.
Repulsive core grows. Attraction becomes stronger Tensor force gets stronger
Limit of Luescher’s conditionis reachedby mπ=411 MeVin L~2.9 fm lattice.