notion press ind ia singapor e mala ysi...
TRANSCRIPT
-
M A L AY S I AS I N G A P O R EI N D I ANotion Press
No.8, 3rd Cross Street, CIT Colony, Mylapore,
Chennai, Tamil Nadu – 600004
First Published by Notion Press 2020Copyright © Ganesh Swaminathan 2020
All Rights Reserved.
ISBN 978-1-64850-731-1
This book has been published with all efforts taken to make the material error-free after the consent of the author. However, the author and the publisher do not assume and hereby disclaim any liability to any party for any loss, damage, or disruption caused by errors or omissions, whether such errors or omissions result from negligence, accident, or any other cause.
While every effort has been made to avoid any mistake or omission, this publication is being sold on the condition and understanding that neither the author nor the publishers or printers would be liable in any manner to any person by reason of any mistake or omission in this publication or for any action taken or omitted to be taken or advice rendered or accepted on the basis of this work. For any defect in printing or binding the publishers will be liable only to replace the defective copy by another copy of this work then available.
-
7
Contents
Acknowledgments 9
I. The Puranas
An Introduction 12
II. The Sun
The Birth of Martanda and the Marriage of Vivasvan 20
Samvartakaditya and the End of a Kalpa 31
III. Units of Measure
Pramana: A Yojana and a Kalpa 46
IV. The Planet Earth
Jambudvipa of the Puranas 66
The Spherical Earth and Gravity 83
V. The History of the Earth
The Early Period 98
The Submergence of Bharata 113
The Descent of Ganga 128
VI. The Cosmic Egg
The Brahmanda and the Bhumandala 144
The Loka and the Patala 159
-
8
Contents
VII. The Moon
The Birth and Marriage of Chandra 178
The Churning of Kshiroda Sagara 194
The Tarakamaya War 209
VIII. The Great Flood
The Story from an Upapurana 224
The Narrative from the Mahapuranas 233
IX. The Puranic Universe
A Summing up 248
A Timeline of Events in the Varaha Kalpa 262
X. Maharishi Vyasa
Sage, Poet and Teacher 280
Bibliography 289
-
I. the PurAnAs
-
12
An IntroDuCtIon
The Puranas are one of the three sacred texts of the Hindu faith, the other two being the Vedas and the Itihasas. The Vedas are a collection of hymns to deities, with passages that are complex and
multi-layered in their meaning. The Vedic hymns, or sloka, are recited
during significant rituals, including births and weddings. The Vedas are
considered the cornerstone of the sacred texts of the Hindu faith.
The Itihasas are considered a narration of history. The word itihasa
is a compound of Sanskrit words, which together mean ‘this happened.’
The accounts carry with them the names of people and places. They also
come with date stamps of the universal calendar, which is the position
of stars and planets in the sky. The Itihasas consist of the two epics—
the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. They have both been translated,
widely read, and analyzed. The Puranas, however, are unique as a text.
The Puranas are Smriti, meaning ‘that which is remembered.’ They
are distinct from the Vedas that are Sruti, meaning ‘that which is heard.’
The Itihasas, as mentioned earlier, are considered a record of what
happened. The word purana in Sanskrit means ‘ancient.’ The Puranas
describe events from a time well before what the Itihasas chronicle.
The stories are less specific, mentioning only the epoch in which the
incident occurred.
The Puranas remain something of an enigma. The Bhagavata Purana,
for example, describes the solar system as being flat when seen from
-
The Puranas
13
an edge. This is a unique insight from a text that is over 2,000 years
old. The same document, however, describes the earth represented by
Jambudvipa as an island surrounded by oceans. This is a description
that does not resonate with our understanding of the planet.
One could view the Puranas as comprising passages of great insight,
interspersed with verses of poetic imagination. This does not seem
to stand up to scrutiny. The Puranas, as a body of work, appear to be
characterized by extreme brevity. For example, a story in the Devi
Purana describes Rama performing Navratra puja, which enabled him
to be victorious in his fight against Ravana. Passages in the Devi Purana
paraphrase almost the entire Ramayana of about 25,000 verses in less
than 200.
If we can rule out any form of dilation in the text, we must assume
that the passages that describe cosmic events are built on an underlying
narrative of the universe. Without this perspective, different verses
come across as flashes of brilliance that seem disconnected from one
another. It is this underlying view of the universe in the Puranas that
this book seeks to uncover.
The Puranas describe the various cosmic phenomena, either
factually or allegorically. They represent the events factually as
they are observed. This may be how an elementary textbook would
characterize the topic. An example of this would be the description of
the moon’s progress through its various phases. The moon marrying
the 27 daughters of Daksha, the 27 nakshatra, is an example of the use
of allegory. Every morning at dawn, the moon is seen near a new star, a
new nakshatra and, therefore, a new wife.
Most of the stories are repeated across the various Puranic texts,
but the level of detail varies. Some Puranas may refer to the story in
just a verse or two, while others go into much greater detail. But often,
each Purana adds some significant and unique element to the same
account. If we compile all the references to a specific topic, across the
Puranas, we can aggregate a significant volume of information on the
subject. This collection of material can be used to build a narrative for
the topic.
-
14
From the Beginning of Time
This book explores the universe of the Puranas in five parts—
the sun, the moon, the earth, the heavens (planets and stars), and
the netherworlds. For each of these five parts, as many references as
possible are taken from each of the Puranas. The account constructed
for each component incorporates the vast majority of references to it.
The narrative that emerges is tested in a couple of ways.
The first test is to see if the narrative constructed is close to the
current scientific framework. Many are, as this book will reveal.
The narrative is built as close to the current scientific context as an
interpretation of the texts will allow. Any differences are allowed to
stand.
This book, therefore, presents three separate narratives. The first
view is informed by science and the second, as inferred from the texts.
Often the two are not very different from each other. The third, of
course, is the Puranic story, such as the sun’s marriage; that in itself
makes for absorbing reading.
The second test is to confirm if the narrative constructed is internally
consistent. The account developed should be coherent, representing a
plausible sequence of events. For example, the sun’s story covers all the
stages of the lifecycle of a star in a clear and concise narrative.
The third is to see if the description developed for one part works
well with those for the other parts. This book, at the end, examines two
stories that cut across more than one of the component narratives—
to test for this consistency. The story of the descent of Ganga is an
example of this. Ganga originates in Milky Way and then comes into our
solar system. It then comes down to the earth, all the way to the patala.
The story, therefore, cross-references and draws from the individual
narratives of the heavens, the earth, and the netherworlds.
As a final validation, the various events that have been inferred
from the narratives are pulled together in a timeline of events. These
events are compared with what is known to modern science to see if
they corroborate.
The Puranas are considered the most extensive collection of
mythology in the world. The Purana Samhita, or Puranic collection,
-
The Puranas
15
consists of 18 Mahapuranas, or major Puranas, and 18 Upapuranas
or subsidiary Puranas. Besides these, there are Sthala Puranas, which
describe the stories regarding a particular place.
The list of the 18 Mahapuranas is mentioned in a few of the
Puranic texts. Here is the list from the Bhagavata Purana: Brahma,
Padma, Vishnu, Shiva, Linga, Garuda, Narada, Bhagavata, Agni, Skanda,
Bhavishya, Brahmavaivarta, Markandeya, Vamana, Varaha, Matsya,
Kurma and Brahmanda.
The list of the Upapuranas varies quite a bit across different texts.
The Skanda Purana has a list of Upapuranas, where some of them are
seen as being subsidiary to specific Mahapuranas. One of the Upapuranas
referred to in this book is the Kalika Purana. This text is described as
being subsidiary to the Brahmanda Purana. The book also references
the Nilmata Purana, a Sthala Purana from the region of Kashmir.
The Puranas are considered an essential part of the learning of the
scriptures. The Skanda Purana declares thus:
93. A Brahmana who knows all the four Vedas along with their
Angas and the Upanisads, but who does not know the Purana is not
learned.
Skanda Purana, Book VII, Section i, Ch. 2
The Puranas are also considered the source of the scientific knowledge
in the scriptures. They are encyclopedic, covering a wide range of
topics, from the science of music to medicine. Here is a verse from the
Padma Purana that speaks to this notion.
50. The Four-faced one (i.e. Brahmadeva) having heard it (from
Kesava) narrated the Vedas to the sages. Then Purana became the
source of all the sciences.
Padma Purana, Section I, Ch. 1
Many scholars date the Puranas to between 500 CE and 500 BCE.
This period of Indian history has its name derived from the texts and
is called the Early Puranic Period. Others date the Samhita to many
centuries earlier, from around 1,500 BCE to about 2,500 BCE.
-
16
From the Beginning of Time
The dating of the Puranas is carried out using two key markers. The
first looks at events mentioned in the Purana, the dates of which we
have a good handle on. The Purana was likely written after this event.
Second, the text was probably written before other works of literature
that make a reference to it. Some parts of the Puranas seem to have
been rewritten, further complicating the task. That said, for most of
this book, the Purana Samhita will be referenced as a text that is about
2,000 years old, conforming to the conservative dating of 500 BCE to
500 BC.
The last major translation of the Puranas into the English language
was in the 1950s, more than half a century ago. This task was undertaken
by a Board of Scholars, supported by the Government of India and
the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
(UNESCO). This book, for the most part, uses this set of translations.
These translations of the Sanskrit texts are works of high scholarship.
There has been no attempt to ‘re-interpret’ the original Sanskrit text to
fit a proposed narrative.
The language used in the translations reflects the sensibilities of
the translators and the conventions of the time. Also, any parentheses
within the translated texts are those of the translators. The author has
not edited these English translations of the Sanskrit texts in any way.
As mentioned earlier, the book looks at the Puranic universe in five
parts. These five parts also define the overall structure of the book. Each
part, or section, begins with the current scientific view, summarized in
simple terms. This view is used as a framework to interpret the Puranas
in as much detail as possible. Verses are cited from one or more of the
Puranas to validate this interpretation
The first section following this introduction describes the life of
the sun as a star across two chapters. It outlines the Puranic narrative
relating to the lifecycle of the sun from its birth through its youth, its
mature phase, and, finally, its death as a white dwarf star. Following
this is a brief section that describes the measures of distance
and time. It concludes with a discussion on a large unit of time, the
kalpa.
-
The Puranas
17
After this is a section of two chapters that describes our home
planet. The first chapter demonstrates that the earth of the Puranas
was, indeed, spherical. It then goes on to outline the size and geography
of the earth. This is followed by an account from the Surya Siddhanta
validating these conclusions. This chapter also discusses the concept of
gravity from the Puranic times.
The next section, of three chapters, outlines a brief history of
the earth as recorded in the Puranas. This includes significant events
in the earth’s past, such as volcanic eruptions and mass extinctions.
These events go back to the beginning of the current kalpa, about two
billion years ago. The third chapter describes the descent of Ganga. It
describes the path of the celestial river from the heavens and the earth
as it was filled up with the waters of Ganga.
Then there is a section consisting of two chapters that describes the
Brahmanda (cosmic egg). The first chapter describes the Bhumandala
with a brief discussion of the various dvipa. The second outlines the
loka above the earth, along with a short description of the patala.
With the Puranic description of the earth, the sun, and the
surrounding regions understood, we get to an elaborate story, that
of the moon. The first chapter describes the origin of the moon and
its disappearance, while the second talks about the reappearance of
the moon during the churning of the ocean. The third chapter talks
about the passage of the moon to our Brahmanda, in the context of the
Tarakamaya War.
The next section talks about the Great Flood, a story found in many
cultures. The most widely known version is the story of Noah and his
ark. The Puranas have two renditions of this story, which are recounted
in two chapters. The first version is from an Upapurana, which is quite
similar to the flood stories from elsewhere in the world. The second
is the narrative from the Mahapuranas, one that suggests a radically
different perspective of the earth and the solar system.
The exploration of the Puranic universe ends with a summing up in
a section of two chapters. The first touches briefly on the origin of the
waters. The second chapter pulls together the various events described
-
18
From the Beginning of Time
in the Puranas in a consolidated timeline, starting from the beginning
of the current Varaha kalpa. This timeline of events is also explored for
its correlation with the geological records.
No mention of the Puranas would be complete without
acknowledging Sage Vyasa, who compiled the Purana Samhita. The
book offers homage to the great sage, in the form of an epilogue at the
end of the book. The section on Vyasa begins with the fascinating story
of his birth. It then goes on to describe his many contributions to the
texts of the Hindu faith.
One final thought as we move forward. The Puranas are
acknowledged as a great source of knowledge. That said, the import of
many of the Puranic stories is not immediately apparent. And yet the
Puranic texts are alive and available to us, even as they are around two
millennia old. This is because of the deep reverence and sanctity the
Puranic texts are held in.
The Puranas, as we will see, have room to accommodate both
reverence and rationality. It is this spirit of rationality in the Puranas
that this book seeks to build upon. It is my earnest prayer that this
spirit of rationality is not seen as diminishing the reverence for this
treasure of knowledge bequeathed to us.
-
II. the sun
-
20
the BIrth of MArtAnDA AnD the MArrIAGe of VIVAsVAn
There is probably no celestial body that is as fundamental to our existence on this planet as the sun. The sun provides us with light and warmth during the day, and its light reflected by the moon
brightens up our nights. The heat of the sun drives the winds, such as
the monsoons, and the water cycle. This causes rainfall, which fills up
our rivers and irrigates our crops. Rainfall and sunshine help plants
make carbohydrates through photosynthesis, thus enabling life as we
know it.
The Puranas acknowledge the importance of the sun in our very
existence, as seen in this verse from the Brahmanda Purana.
52-54. The entire universe including the Devas, Asuras and human
beings originate from the Sun, O leading Brahmanas.
The Sun alone is at the root of the three worlds. He is the highest
Deity. It is from him everything is born and everything gets merged
into him alone.
Brahmanda Purana, Book I, Section ii, Ch. 24
The Puranas speak of a sect of sun-worshippers, the Saura, from the
Sanskrit word surya, meaning ‘sun.’ Hymns to the sun are part of the
Rig Veda, the foremost of the scriptures of the Hindu faith.
-
The Sun
21
This chapter talks about the sun through the framework of its life.
Current science describes the life of the sun as spanning five stages:
its birth, its life as a young star, its mature phase that we see today, its
stage as a red giant, and its final collapse as a white dwarf. The Puranas,
though it may be hard to believe, speak to each of the five stages of the
sun’s life.
In this chapter and the next, each of these five stages of the sun’s life
has been explored. The description of each stage starts with a view as
informed by current science. The corresponding passages that describe
each of the five stages from the Puranas are cited. The first chapter
talks about the birth of the sun and its life as a young star. The sun’s
current mature stage and its final two stages as a red giant and a white
dwarf are described in the next. We begin with a scientific perspective
of the sun.
The sun that we see today is one of the billions of stars in the
universe. It is the closest star to our planet and our host star. The earth
seems to be situated in a ‘Goldilocks’ region in relation to the sun. The
earth is at a distance where it is neither too hot, as Mercury and Venus
are, where water boils off the surface, nor too cold, as is the case of the
planets beyond Mars, where water freezes over. Water can stay liquid
on the earth’s surface, enabling life on our planet.
In spite of being the star closest to the earth, the sun is difficult
to study. This is because of the vast amounts of heat and radiation
that it emits. With more resilient probes in the future, the increased
volume of data that will be available should significantly improve our
understanding of our parent celestial body.
Our galaxy, the Milky Way, is home to billions of stars, and there
are billions of galaxies in the universe. Some of the stars in the Milky
Way are less than a hundred light-years away, while many galaxies are
billions of light-years away. A light-year is a measure of length and
represents the distance that light travels in one year.
The light from some of the nearer stars reaching us today would
have left them less than a hundred years ago. One of the farthest galaxies
is estimated to be a little over 13 billion light-years away. The light from
-
22
From the Beginning of Time
the stars in this galaxy would have left them about 13 billion years ago,
just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. By observing a
large number of stars, scientists can gain a good understanding of their
lifecycle.
It seems inconceivable that we can find passages in the Puranas that
speak to the stages in the life of the sun. The study of the sun is at the
cutting edge of science today. Let us think about this for a moment.
The likelihood of the science of the sun having anything to do with a
2,000-year-old text could stretch the limits of credibility. But this sense
of incredulity may need to be set aside as we try to understand what the
Puranic texts contain.
Many of the Puranas have passages relating to the sun. These
passages could be read without discerning much by way of science.
Each set of verses sounds like an interesting description or a charming
story. It is like trying to appreciate a single piece of a jigsaw puzzle,
without reference to any of the other parts or the complete picture.
In this case, the overarching view is provided by our knowledge of the
lifecycle of a star.
Of the two stories in this chapter, the first is relatively brief and
outlines the birth of a star such as our sun. We begin with an overview
of the science of the origin of stars.
The most widely accepted mechanism for star formation is called
the nebular hypothesis. According to this hypothesis, stars are formed
in massive clouds of molecular hydrogen, called ‘giant molecular
clouds’ (GMC). GMCs could be anything between 15 to 600 light-years
in diameter. They are large enough to cover a big part of a constellation
and are referred to by the constellation’s name, such as the ‘Orion
molecular cloud’ (OMC). They are not very dense, but given their
immense size, they carry a lot of mass. As stars are born within them,
they are also called ‘stellar nurseries.’
These giant clouds are unstable but can stay unchanged for long
periods of time. However, as a result of some perturbation, the mass
in these clouds starts to coalesce into smaller denser clumps. These
clumps then begin to rotate, collapse and form a giant sphere of gas.
-
The Sun
23
This ball of gas starts to collapse in on itself by the force of its own
gravity.
Just before becoming a star, it is a large sphere of gas that emits
neither heat nor light. For all external purposes, it is inert and lifeless.
The Puranas have verses that describe the stage of a proto-star as an
inert ball of gas.
The Puranas describe the sun as the son of Sage Kasyapa, born of
his wife, Aditi. The sun is called by many names, one of them being
Martanda. The story here describes how the name ‘Martanda’ came
to be. The story is mentioned in a few of the Puranas. Here is an
extract from the Brahmanda Purana describing the birth of the sun
from Aditi.
276-278. In the beginning the holy lord created an egg within her
belly. The powerful foetus was within the egg.
It goes on to describe the egg as it was born.
284-288. When it was taken out of the belly it resembled a dead
lump … Since he was born dead (Mrta) as an egg (Anda), Savitr
(the sun) is called Martanda by the learned men.
Brahmanda Purana, Book II, Section iii, Ch. 7
The word ‘Martanda’ is a compound of the two Sanskrit words—mrta
meaning ‘dead’ and anda meaning ‘egg.’ These verses, thus, succinctly
describe two events. First that everything in the cosmic egg originated
from the fetus of the egg, which is the sun. And second that the sun was
not this bright an orb at its inception. It was an inert ball of gas, which,
over time, became the sun we are all familiar with.
The second story relates to the sun in its youth and its transition to
a mature star. As before, we begin with the science.
The process of gravitational collapse of the star continues, and the
ball of gas starts to radiate heat and then light. It then gets to the second
stage of its life, that of a young star, and is known as a ‘young stellar
object.’ But the core is still not hot enough to initiate hydrogen fusion,
the source of energy of our sun. The young star generates heat and light
from the pressure of gravitation.
-
Enjoyed reading this sample?Purchase the whole copy at