needs analysis: a valuable tool for designing and maintaining effective esp curriculum

Needs Analysis: A Valuable Tool for Designing and Maintaining Effective ESP Curriculum

Abdeslam Badre 1

Needs Analysis: A Valuable Tool for

Designing and Maintaining Effect ive ESP

Curriculum

By

Abdeslam Badre

May, 2005


Abdeslam Badre 2

Table of Content

I - Introduction:

II - What is Needs Analysis

III - Types of needs assessment

IV The importance of needs analysis implementation

V - Steps in implementing needs analysis:

1 - Who Will Conduct the Study?

2 - What Kind of Information Needs to Be Collected?

3 - How Will the Information Be Collected?

4 - The interpretation of Findings

VI - Approaches to needs analysis

VII - Components of needs analyses

VIII - Techniques used in needs analysis

IX - Conclusion:

X - Bibliography


Abdeslam Badre 3

I - Introduction:

With the advent of the communicative approach, views on language

teaching started to incorporate communicative features into syllabus design.

Accordingly, a central question has been raised: what does the learner need/want

to do with the target language? Rather than, what are the linguistic elements the

learner needs to master? This movement has led in part to the development of

English for Specific Purpose. Thus, the focus has no more been only on

language function but also on experiential content.

In order to cater for the learners specific purpose, it has become urgent to

collect information about the learners: their needs and wants. For so doing,

relevant techniques as well as procedures have been developed by needs

analysts. These techniques have been borrowed and adopted from other areas of

training, particularly, those associated with industry and technology.

In this respect, the present paper attempts to shed light on the field of

needs analysis as a method of not only analyzing the needs of given individuals

(learners) or communities; but also as a tool that can help in predicting future

decisions about a targeted population. And before indulging in the hows and

whats of needs assessment, a clear and well-rounded definition of the concept

has to be provided.

II - WHAT IS NEEDS ASSESSMENT?

The word "assess" comes from the Latin term "assidere," which means to

"sit beside." Process-minded and participatory-oriented adult educators "sit

beside" learners to learn about their proficiencies and backgrounds, educational

goals, and expected outcomes, immersing themselves in the lives and views of

their students (Auerbach, 1994).


Abdeslam Badre 4

The needs assessment process can be used as the basis for developing curricula

and classroom practice that are responsive to these needs.

The research to date has considered the concept through various

perspectives and proposed various interpretations accordingly. In this regard,

the concept of needs is viewed as irrevocably value laden and felt and

prescribed needs are considered within this concept. Learner needs assessment

encompasses both what learners know and can do (learner proficiencies) and what they want

to learn and be able to do. Richterich (1983: 2) notes the difficulty of reaching an

agreed on definition of needs analysis is in that The very concept of language

needs has never been clearly defined and remains at best ambiguous. Berwick

(1989: 52) offers a simplified conventional definition of need as the discrepancy

between a current state of affairs and a desired future state. If this controversy

is meant to reveal anything, it should be the ambiguity loaded within the phrase

needs assessment.

III - Types of needs

Berwick (1989: 55) views perceived needs as those that the educators

make judgments about in other peoples experience, while felt needs are viewed

as the ones that the learners have. Brookfield (1988: 221) defines felt needs as

wants, desires and wishes of the learner. Brindley (1989) and Robinson (1991)

consider all factual information about the learner (language proficiency,

language difficulties, use of language in real life) as means to collect data about

objective needs; whereas cognitive and affective needs of the learner in language

learning (such as confidence, attitudes, expectations) are considered as data

about subjective needs. Hutchinson and Waters (1993: 54) define target needs

as the ones the learner needs to do in the target situation, these are necessities,

lacks, and wants. What the learner needs to do in order to learn is referred to

learning needs. Peck (1991) categorizes the concept in terms of academic,

social, and emotional needs.


Abdeslam Badre 5

Richterich and Chancerel (1987: 3) ague that experience shows that in

general the learner is little aware of his needs and, in particular, he is unable to

express them except in very vague terms. Kopp (1986) and Pennington (1980)

(quoted in Knox, 1997: 56) maintain that adults may be unaware of some of

their educational needs, which may be implicit in their attitudes and choices, and

may be aware of other educational needs, which they can state explicitly in

response to some questions. Accordingly, it would be helpful to use needs

assessment procedures to confirm and discover both implicit and explicit needs

important to adult learners.

Richterich and Chancerel (1987) point out that due to the fact that needs

vary too much from person to person, the system should be continually adapted.

Porcer (1983: 129) emphasizes the fact that speaking of a need (language or

other) is not the same as speaking in general of what is lacking. A need does not

exist prior to a project; it is always constructed. The researcher also believes

that the process of learning is obviously affected by the attitude of the learner

towards the teaching itself. Therefore, the relationship between the learner and

the content of learning should be considered as a prerequisite in specifying and

analyzing the needs of a learner.

IV The importance of implementing a needs analysis

Learners and teachers may have different needs. This why needs analysts

should be cautious in collecting information from various sources due to the

multiplicity and diversity of the views on prerequisites for an ESP. Hutchinson

and Waters (1993) hold that the relationship between necessities as perceived by

a sponsor or an ESP teacher, and what learners want or feel can be at extreme

poles. They suggest that learners perceived wants and wishes should be

considered carefully, and due to objective and subjective reality of needs, each

learning situation should be considered uniquely and systematically.


Abdeslam Badre 6

Bearing in mind a wide range of needs due to the influence of different

social and cultural factors on students learning (Peck, 1991), a needs analysis is

considered as a prerequisite in any course design (Richterich and Chancerel,

1987). According to Knox (1997: 56), needs assessment enables researchers to

justify their assumptions as to whether or not potential educational needs are

sound, to design a program in terms of topics, materials so as to be responsive to

the needs of participants. "The curriculum content and learning experiences

should be negotiated between learners, teacher, and coordinator at the

beginning of the project and renegotiated regularly during the project" (p. 20).

At the beginning of the program, needs assessment might be used to determine

types of appropriate program and course content. During the program, it

assures that learner and program goals are being met, and allows for necessary

program changes. At the end of the program, it can be used for assessing

progress and planning future directions for learners and the program. This can

maximize the likelihood of students' participation. Finally such focus on

satisfying learners needs will help the learners to insist on learning and applying

what has been learnt.

Richards (1990) deals with this issue from the point of curriculum

development, and he thinks that the data to be collected from learners, teachers,

administrators, and employers in the planning process will help to identify

general and specific language needs and content of a language program. Besides,

it will provide data to review and evaluate the existing program.

Yet, it is recommended that needs analysis should be carried out during

the life of each course (Richterich and Chancerel, 1987), because as students

become more involved with the course, their attitudes and approach may

change (Robinson, 1991: 15). Therefore, identification and analysis of needs

should be a continuous process (Richterich and Chancerel, 1987; Knox, 1987).

This can help both administrators and teachers to adapt necessary changes.


Abdeslam Badre 7

IV.1. A needs assessment serves a number of purposes:

It aids administrators, teachers, and tutors with learner placement,

developing materials, curricula, skills assessments, teaching approaches, and

teacher training. It assures a flexible, responsive curriculum rather than a

fixed and linear curriculum determined ahead of time by instructors.

It provides information to the instructor about what the learner brings to the

course (if done at the beginning), what has been accomplished (if done

during the course), and what the learner wants and needs to know next.

When learners know that educators understand and want to address specific

needs and interests, the former are motivated to continue learning.

V Steps in implementing a Needs Assessment

To undertake a needs assessment study, one must plan ones strategy. The

four steps to the needs assessment process require that one should determine

who will conduct the study, what kind of information needs to be collected, how

the information will be collected, and how the information will be used.

V.1. Who Will Conduct the Study?

The first step in performing a needs assessment is to decide who will conduct the

study. A needs assessment study can be carried out by needs analysts, outside

consultants, practitioners, or educational members, such as teachers. Needless to

say that available resources, time frame, and comfort level with performing

research may influence decisions.

V.2. What Kind of Information Needs to Be Collected?

The second step in performing a needs assessment is to decide what you hope to

learn about your community and what kind of information you plan to collect.


Abdeslam Badre 8

For example, do you hope to perform a broad-based study or one that is focused

on a particular area? A needs assessment for use with adult learners of English is

a tool that examines, from the perspective of the learner, what kinds of English,

native language, and literacy skills the learner already believes he or she has; the

literacy contexts in which the learner lives and works; what the learner wants

and needs to know to function in those contexts; what the learner expects to

gain from the instructional program; and what might need to be done in the

native language or with the aid of an interpreter. The categories of information

one might be interested in collecting include: Demographic Data, Social, Cultural,

Educational and Recreational Organizations.

V.3. How Will the Information Be Collected?

After deciding on the types of information the institution wants to collect about

its community, it needs to determine how to collect that information. Data can

be collected by: 1) interviewing key informants (also known as "gatekeepers"):

these are people who hold socially responsible positions, such as educators, 2)

holding a community forum, 3) researching social indicators, 4) consulting

demographic information from public records and reports, 5) and performing

field surveys. It is best if the needs analysts can use more than one of these data

collection methods in combination.

V.4. Interpretation of Findings

In order to make use of the information collected, the results have to be

interpreted. To interpret the data, some statistical analyses are often applied to

identify the most important needs for the majority of the informants. An

important feature of the results should be a reflection of whether or not the

current goals of the given institution do meet (and will continue to meet) the

needs of the community. Crucial to be covered in the finding also is the question


Abdeslam Badre 9

as to whether the institution has collected information about the present or the

past needs of the community. When the data analysis is completed, it should be

possible to produce a rank-ordered list of the most important changes identified

by the community. This ranking can be used to set budget priorities. At the end

of this process, it is a good idea to share the findings with the community in

some way: holding a group meeting, creating displays at the institution, or

writing articles to appear online or in the local newspapers, or through teachers

seminaries.

VI - Approaches to Needs Analysis

A careful needs analysis should involve Present Situation Analysis

(PSA) and Target Situation Analysis (TSA). PSA aims at finding out the

students English proficiency level and their existing language requirements at

the beginning of a language program, whereas learners language requirements

regarding the target situation are identified through TSA (Robinson, 1991: 8-9).

Bloor (1984) defines the former type of analysis as a learner-centered needs

analysis, and the latter one as a target-centered analysis. Bloor emphasizes that

operation of both analyses during a term is certainly desirable. Robinson (1991)

also holds that TSA and PSA are complementary and form an efficient form of

needs analysis.

Jordan (1997) proposes a tri-chotomy of needs analysis which

comprises: 1) deficiency analysis, 2) strategy analysis, 3) and means analysis.

Deficiency analysis is concerned with the necessities that the learner lacks;

strategy analysis seeks to establish the learners preferences in terms of learning

styles and strategies, or teaching methods; means analysis examines the

constraints - local situation - to find out the ways of implementation of a

language course.

Furthermore, various analyses and approaches to needs assessment were

put forward: analytic view of needs analysis which examines expert opinion, and


Abdeslam Badre 10

diagnostic approach which examines the learners needs to be used in social

services (Berwick, 1989); discrepancy analysis which attempts to examine what

people know and what they ought to know, and democratic approach which is

based on learner points of view (Stufflebeam et al, 1985, quoted in Berwick,

1989).

VII - Components of Needs Analyses

Many needs assessment tests are available for use in different employment

contexts. Sources that can help you determine which needs analysis is

appropriate for your situation are described below.

Context Analysis. The important questions being answered by this

analysis are who decide that a given training should be conducted, why a

training program is seen as the recommended solution to a business

problem, what the history of the organization has been with regard to

employee training and other management interventions.

User Analysis. Analysis dealing with potential participants and instructors

involved in the process. The important questions being answered by this

analysis are who will receive the training and their level of existing

knowledge on the subject, as well as what is their learning style, and who

will conduct the training?

Work analysis. Analysis of the tasks being performed. This is an analysis

of the job and the requirements for performing the work. Also known as a

task analysis or job analysis, this analysis seeks to specify the main duties

and skill level required. This helps ensure that the training that is

developed will include relevant links to the content of the job.

Content Analysis. Analysis of documents, laws, procedures used in the job.

This analysis answers questions about what knowledge or information is

used on this job; and the sources of the information ( does it come from

manuals, documents, or regulations.) It is important that the content of


Abdeslam Badre 11

the training does not conflict or contradict job requirements. An

experienced worker can assist (as a subject matter expert) in determining

the appropriate content.

Training Suitability Analysis. Analysis of whether a training is the desired

solution. Training is one of several solutions to employment problems.

However, it may not always be the best solution. It is important to

determine if training will be effective in its usage.

Cost-Benefit Analysis. Analysis of the return on investment (ROI) of

training. Effective training is expected to result in a return of value to the

organization that is greater than the initial investment to produce or

administer the training.

VIII - Techniques used in needs analysis

Several basic Needs Assessment techniques include:

Direct observation

Questionnaires

Consultation with persons in key positions, and/or with specific

knowledge

Review of relevant literature

Interviews

Focus groups

Tests

Class discussions

Records & report studies

Work samples

1. Surveys


Abdeslam Badre 12

Surveys are usually in the form of a questionnaire. A comprehensive

survey of the information needs of your institution would seek information on

the types of information users (physician, nurse, administrator, etc.), the types of

information sought (factual, reviews, in-depth, clinical, research,

administrative), the frequency of the need (daily, monthly, annually), and where

the information is currently found (hospital library, other library, personal

library, consultation with colleague, not found, et c.).

Other surveys may be on a more narrow aspect of service. Recent surveys

at Dartmouth have assessed 1) satisfaction with the current awareness service,

2) the desirability of a change in Sunday hours, 3) and satisfaction with the

Learning Resources Center. Satisfaction with and the need for additional

educational workshops are regularly assessed after each workshop.

2. Interviews

Interviews may be formal or informal. Formally, you may visit department

chairs, administrators, and/or managers annually to ask if the library, for

example, is currently meeting their needs and how things could be better.

Informal interviews are often done as you greet people entering the library or

check materials out, and ask them if they have found what was needed. If you

take it a step further, making a note of the conversation and any action taken in

response. This way, you've already initiated done a needs assessment.

3. Analysis of statistics, records

Libraries have always been faithful record keepers, gathering statistics on

every aspect of their operations - circulation, reference, acquisitions, interlibrary

loan, etc. Analyze these records regularly to see what they tell you about the

needs of your institution. You probably already analyze interlibrary loan

requests to determine titles to which you should subscribe.


Abdeslam Badre 13

5. Suggestion box

A suggestion box is a very basic needs assessment tool. Complaints -

whether received through a suggestion box or not - can fall into this category of

needs assessment tool.

6. Meetings, Reports, Newsletters

Attending meetings, reading newsletter, and getting on as many

distribution lists as possible are all useful ways to find out about the level of

efficacy of new programs and services, and the new direction is heading to.

Any of the aforementioned tools may be used in the continuous quality

improvement process to uncover areas in need of improvement and to measure

progress toward improvement. With all of the above needs assessment tools, it is

important to document how you measure need for knowledge-based information

and how you respond to the measured needs.

IX - Conclusion

An ongoing needs analysis should be a prerequisite for any

program/course design in order to achieve effective instructional outcomes.

Besides this, it can help educators and administrators to gain awareness of the

context variable (Chaudron, 1990) and program designers - to provide

appropriate instructional input to foster effective learning. Needs of

administrators /educators and students generally vary across time, instructional

contexts, the requirement of an ongoing needs assessment for any educational

institution becomes crucial in order to promote effective teaching and learning

environments.


Abdeslam Badre 14

Bibliography

Weddel, Kathleen Santopietro - Van Duzer, Carol Adjunct ERIC Clearinghouse

for ESL Literacy Education.

Van House, Nancy A. and Thomas A. Childers (1993). The Public Library Effectiveness

Study: The Complete Report, Chicago: American Library Association.

Copyright 1998, 1999 hr-guide.com All Rights Reserved.

Send questions or comments to [email protected]

Sitkiye KUTER. AN ACADEMIC ENGLISH NEEDS ANALYSIS IN EFL

CLASSROOMS.

needs analysis: a valuable tool for designing and maintaining effective esp curriculum

Documents