national assembly of pakistan · 2015. 6. 11. · srth in the last 67, 68 years srth eqc9jqxqlu...

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY OF PAKISTAN ASSEMBLY DEBATES

----------------------- Friday, the 29th August, 2014

----------------------- The National Assembly of Pakistan met in the National Assembly Hall (Parliament House), Islamabad, at 11:35 of the clock in the morning. Mr. Speaker

(Sardar Ayaz Sadiq) in the Chair. -----------------------

RECITATION FROM THE HOLY QUR’AN ]456 789:: ;<= 6>6? =@AB

C D CE= EFGFH BI 49JCKLM NOP< QR JH SRTUC V6? 6WQ9JX QYZ [X

\] VG \9 M 4_ `

9 M ;<aC b BI = EFGFH BI cQd cQd CEQR J6: <8X BG ;<= )F6 ? eL Kf g= SRTh CEQR J6: =Fij Bkj( BI = SRTU

C M ]<QL JlL 7 BG F9 D EFmC M= BC D g= OUn FX oLD 9>pqL D r=st

QR ut ;<= g= BX BH O6 u vs;Fl9 M \w 9>xRVy rFz< [H8X@{F| 4R u CE= [X 9>m6M \ i} v86 : v;=OR u8

C? Bkj@ ~ LW�= Bq�D = �FH FX ai � C8G ) 9WQ6 �CM B

C D QL u �=<( rQR JC? 4C u SR:8X F6 ? \

C VL:= EFR �C:Q9JI;Q� 8L : pgFC? Bkj ;Fij SRTi� ;<= 4C u Nt8X rQ5n= 8L : \ 6 M \

C VL:= �R D��9D BX poij=FC? OCJ� SRTi�@ ~)N;Q6 u<t OR JXQ9u BX B] �H QR uQh��( oLD LW�= SRTU

C M= ai � C8G 6W= COP BI 9WQ6 �CM

BC D QL u �=< 4C u SRT�6 ��

w ;<= CE= BX B] �H �QCut;t 6W= COP {Bkj ;<= 6>I EF

C DQ5w�= ;<= CSRTh C; [X \ i}Q p�tQ6 u =@A\i} B] �H BX Bkj ;<= =@Aai � CaR �L� 8L : ;tQ� Bkj@{)F| `

9 M QCJL:= CEQR J�t ;<= ��F9 D \w= 8L : Flf;({[

2

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : �CtF�Z�= �A=Q�6 u � CS�� CS��R T�p H= {� R V�6?��8H= �`¡�6 D �A= CS� x7�8�H=

{� R V�?�8�H=Leave applications{

LEAVE OF ABSENCE

Mr. Speaker: Sardar Kamal Khan Chang, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 25th to 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Ms. Aisha Syed, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 28th and 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Ms. Sabiha Nazir, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 7th and 8th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.)

3

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Saeed Ahmed Khan Manais, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.)

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Bhawan Das, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 18th to 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Ms. Shahjehan Muneer Mangrio, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 1st to 9th September, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Makhdoom Syed Ali Hassan Gillani, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 18th, 19th and 20th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.)

4

Mr. Speaker: Mian Muhammad Rasheed, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Ms. Shazia Mubashar, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 25th to 29th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Mr. Isphanyar M. Bhandara, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 27th till conclusion of the Session. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Mr. Iftikhar-ud-Din, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 18th to 28th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Motion under rule 259. Further discussion on the motion moved by Mr. Zahid Hamid,

5

Minister for Science and Technology on 18th August, 2014 regarding prevailing political situation in the country.

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Iftikhar-ud-Din.

FURTHER DISCUSSION ON A MOTION REG:

PREVAILING POLITICAL SITUATION IN THE COUNTRY

6WQCJ6? ;QC�9V= CSR:O®= : {� R V�?�8�H=@ CS� x7�8�H=@ �A=@�`¡�6 D 4R u8�p� 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� 4R u R u= CEQ9JqXQL u

SRTh F6 ? eL Kf B°�±�LM <t EF9 �²ij BI Fij Qi �; Bkj 4R u F9 D a³6 M [

] ´QU9 VC:= �QCJIFq= F6 ? 4µ °�

�L¶ Qi �; Bkj SRTh F9 D 6M ³rQ¶a g= FX condemn EFijQ9u8X 4_ R u= established democratic order BX c·C¶ F6 ? eL Kf B

C D 8�t Fij Bkj ; SRTi� 4R u F

9 D 6M ³rQ¶a mob politics FX CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh promote BC D 8X [H=< 9WQ6 u Bkj

a RT¹<8L : as �_=st ai �Qº ;tQ»H=v 6>?Qd N< F9 D aR �C� CE= [X [

] ´FX elected 9>R�pTRJ? Bkj

SRTUC M ;<= 6>°Y� 4R u L¼

CMQL u ;=Cai � gt ;=Cai � E<OCJ6: FX BH 8X LW�= s>C �xRVH;QL u g]<Qi � Q� ]<=aR ��½ QCu8X Bkj QR u 9>�F�¶ FX B

C D Q6¶ [X 9WQ6 u QCu8X Bkj QR u `] M=8L : as �

CTh FX EQR J�5¾t QCJR:t ;<= o6? ¿�À [X ÁÂQÃH= sleek SRTh rQ5�

9T�= B��X B] �G SRTi� 4R u [] ´QU9 VC:= SRTh

Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ condemn BC D 8X [H=< 9WQ6 u Bkj �ÄHQ6 u g= FX i} 9>�C�Å B

9 D 8X SRTi� ÆFÇC KÈ6 u g= 9WQ6 u 4L u v;FL D [

C ´Q9JqXQL u ÉFy v;Q� O�9V� Bkj 4_ almost two-third F6 ? �FH SRTi� F6 ? \ 6 M= gallop survey \ 6 M QR u�= 4_ g= `

s VqI FX N< continue QCu8X B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd F6 ? SRTi� g= FX F6 ?

6

undemocratic F6 ? BË�D �À BI F6 ? demands CE= BX c·C¶ SRT]u�= SRTi� F9 D

CE= �Q 6>°Y� 4_ EFGFH BC D OCJqL D SRTU

C M QR JX �ÄHQ6 u 4R u 6¿�= BI [] ´FX eL ? e9 MQ� BC ��TUÅ

B°U±M [X 9WQ6 u Bkj 4_ 8�t= \ i} Ì;Q5i} eL Kf 9>I<t Bl9 M PTI BX N< ;Q6 u ;Q6 u 4R u

B9 �mf Bl9 M 4_ \67 g= ¿�À Q� [

] ´FX Q p�Q59M B

C D Fij �=< Bkj BC ��TUÅ OÍ6 D QR u <t BC ��TUÅ OÍ6 D QR u CSRT9u BC ��TUÅ OÍ6 D F9 D eL Kf EFGFH BX ÉQCu B��H Q6¶ Bkj ; Bl

9 M 4_ N< `] M=8L : as �

CTh BC �CTÎu BX

poij=FC? OCJ� SRTi� ;<= eL Kf EFGFH BX ÉQCu B��H Q6¶ Bkj ; Bl9 M 4_ N< 6WQ6 �

CVL: BX �R �L? as � CTh BC �

CTÎu SRTi�{BH =< a³6 MrQ¶ CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh in the last 67, 68 years SRTh F6 ? political Qp�Q5

9M EQURM 8L : Q9J°L¶ Qi �; Bkj F9 D SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh

military interventions QR u rQpJ� BX ;FÀ 8L : g= ¿�À [X E<CaR �L� [X po]DQ6 �CVG

ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh g= 21st Century SRTh `

9 V C? \ÐL¶Fij SRTi�@ {;<= EQU67 9u development [X 9WQ6 u Bkj F9 D g= BI ¯µh Q� development derail

=Fij Bkj for instances SRTh Bq�D = district BI =aR �Ï Ñ°Í9D Bkj F6 ? 4_ BX [L´

BX SRTh 6>I BI =s86 : sÒXsaÓst Bkj ;<= 4R u \ 6 M R u= 9>ËR�Ô? Bkj 4_ Chitral used to remain cut off from the almost six months a

year ;<= raC �6� cap ¸� [X [s ´;QL u BI SRTh elect Fij BX QR u�= EFij ;<= SRTh 4R u

�ÄHQ6 u ;=FÖ p�FC? ÁÂQÃH= SRTh R u= 6>I FX QCuQ9J6: Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ we are for democracy SRTh \

C VL:= [9 ´=Ct B

] D =; [X 9WQ6 u SRTh 8X Qi �; EFij 4_ ¯µh SRTh democratic order F6 ? Bkj g= FX �ÄHQ6 u derail SRTU

C M QCuFij B��kj QL¶ ;FL Dv Islamic QR JC:t SRTh LW�= SRT�ÐR ut kj QL¶B N< ×=�n Bkj kj QL¶B N< ÉQp� Bkj 80 rQ�

BX dictatorship BX OÍ6 D Egypt SRTh democratic forces BC D

s>C �xRVH;QL uelect 8X BX BG �= �B] D F9 D g= FX \¡X @FX L¼

CMQL u eL ? BC ��TUÅ 9>pI=t86 : BC D 8X

[X 9WFy SRTUC M \

9 M@{a³6 MrQ¶ `i} R u= Bq�D =~ area BI =aR �Ï Ñ°Í9D Bkj F6 ? 4_ R u=

7

5¡L DQNOCu 4�·P Bkj =aR �Ï QCJL:= O®=< 6>?Qd Q� Ñ°Í9D `È � ØR JH) CE( BI Q�9 M CS�R JH \9 Vx¡yO6 u

BI BC �9TÎ¶ \ 6 M successive governments B

] D �= SRTi� CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh EFmC M= BC D

F6 ? Ì;Q5i} Bq�TÎ¶ NOCuQ5¡L D EFGFH Q� \ 6 VX \ 6 M rQR JC? SRTU

C M QR JX SRTh EQURM 4L u OCJL? R u= CE=a6 �5Å SRTi� NtQR u

C; 89: House empty Bkj CS�R JH r=a9 �L� 9u context SRTh LW�= FX QCJ9:= QCuQ9J6: E<t 4_ r=a9 �L� SRTh F6 ? 9W·Äpq� [

9 ´Fij SRT�9 M v;Q5i} eL ? eL ? BC ��TUÅ

ì} rQ� SRTh ¯µh BI cut off B9 �kj ; Bl9 M F9 D Ì;Q5i} B��H raC �6� cap ¸� B

C D R u= ÉQ� QR JX v;=FH �

CJs :@ {g= O¶ 9u a³6 MrQ¶ everybody knows 4_ g= BC D [

] ´FX Q�L 7= ÉQ� g= BÙ ·P SRTh QR JX{ CS�R JH EQU67 9u v;Fm�67 EF9 DFy [X 9WQ6 u Bkj F9 D SRT5i} expectation 4R u

Bkj 4_ Ì;Q5i} EFy·P Q� \ 6 M = s;Fl9 M rQR JC? Q�f; B

] D Q6¶ `] M=8L : as �

CTh 6>?Qd Q� SRTh ;F� p � EFij 4_ EFmC M= B

C D recently BC �9: = crisis BX situation SRTh \ 6 M EFmC M= B

C D 9ÒÙ< ÄCDQr BX r=a9 �L� SRTh EFmC M= BC D B

C D �= �Q EFmC M= BC D É=8G<8L : QR uQCJ6:

;<= aR �Ïe9 MQ�@Ì v;Oi �FL ? CSq?= rQ6 Jy= 6>?Qd BC D e6 KÅ BI 4Y6 D=; \ 6 M QR JX Q�

9 M ;<= =ÚQ p CD=@Aì} B

C D CE= XF receive BC D 8X Q� R u= Bl±7 = BË�D �À BI CE= Q� ;=OCuQ p�

rQ6 JÔ9T�= B

C D 8X Q� ì} BC D É=8G<8L : \ 6 M QR uQCJ6: Q�9 M CS�R JH \9 Vx¡yO6 u BI `wF� 6W=8

C? QR JGFij \67{

EQURM 4L u \67 ap �_= 9WQ6 u BC D 8X Q� ÛyF� SRTU

C M Q9J°h CS�R JH pg;=C8G 4R u QCu8X NQL¶ Qi �; EFij 4_ eL ? e9 MQ� BC ��TUÅ BI 4R u SRT

9uQ6 u ;Q6 u ;Q6 u Fij \ i}; \9 M 4_ [

] ´FX Q p�Q59M qXQL u 9J CEQ

SRTh BC �CTÎu Q6¶ Qi �; Bkj as �_=st ai �Qº v;tQ»H= 6>?Qd ai � ÌaÓ<t CEt@~ÌaÓ<t rQ� ai �Q6 u BI B

9 D Q6¶�= SRTi� ;<= 49JL: SRTUC M oX BX E<;Q p�= 4L u oX BX BC �mf 4L u 4R u B

C D 8�t QÜH B9 ��: t SRTi� EQURM 8L : s>C �xRVH;QL u BX BC �� Q�@{B°�±�LM R u= rQ� B°U±M \ 6 M EQURM [

] ´FX ÝQ6 JR:�Ë9D

8

eighteen, twenty months back 6>6? 4R u CaC � p �R JH= BC D Fij [X SRT

9uQ6 u Fij \ i}; SRT�

9 M F9 D g= democratic process FX derail BC D 8X Q� g= 9ÒÙ<

\ 6 M R u= Q p�Q59M a³6 MrQ¶ =s�lf QR JX Q�

9 M CS�RJH anyway g= 9ÒÙ< g= FX o6? ¿�À BI 4R u CSq?= BË�D �À BI g= FX �¶ QR JX QR JG CS�R JH BlÎ�Å gFq= g= 9WQ6 u Q� Bkj 4_

CE==��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd BÎD Fz SRTh particularly BX [L´ BX SRTh change[X SRT9uQ6 u B

9 D 8X Bl9 M ;<= SRT5i} OR J�= \

9 M 4_ 4R u R u= political party Bkj R u= emerging political Bkj R u= B] �

C: L¿F| BH =< �FH SRTi� progressive SRTi� F9 D 4R u g= BÙ ·P SRTh [

] ´FX \Ù89: [X SRT9uQ6 u SR:8X {BG

SRTh LW�= FX 4R u QCuQ9J6: Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ `f C;= `f B°�±�LM <t F| rQ� [X vas � ij SRTh r=a9 �L� SRTh BC �9: = CSR:8

9:O6 u sOµ¹ SRTUC M B

] D �= BC �9TÎ¶ 4_ B°�±�LM rQ� B

] D �= ;<= ì} OR J�= 8X Bkj ; Bl

9 M 4_ �R �L? as � CTh 6>?Qd Ì;Q5i} gQL u SRT

]u�=@BG@~eL Kf Ì;Q5i} t;t Q� =<=Oh SR:8X BG{4ÞCuFR �X a6 �RJ

C? N=FC KCMF9 �CKLM SRTh oRT6u OßR� =;Q5i} QR u8R := Bkj District, it is

the largest district in the province CS�R JH \9 Vx¡yO6 u BI �R �L? as � CTh

6>?Qd QCJI 4R u Bkj 4_ = CE FX [] ´Fij �àI B

C D 8X SRTh [] ´FX v;=Fp|t [

9 ´Fij Bkj{ CS�R JH \9 Vx¡yO6 u v;Q5i} 4R u Bkj 4_ ì} ¯µh BX tail Island SRTh SRTi� ;<= Ì;Q5i} 9>m6M Ì;Q� �]uQ � SRTi�@ {\È6 �6M BX Ì;Q5i} B°]Jq� SRTi� ;<= `¡y BX B°]Jq� SRTi�@ ~v;Q5i} 9Ò�;<Oh�= Q� 4µ]Jq� Bkj@ ~ì} \

C VL:= dead bodies FX BC �±: = �l½ SRTUC M BH Q6¶

B9 ��{SRTh \C V9T 6¶ \ 6 M democratic forces SRTi� SRTh CE= FX 6¿=8

C? CSRT K9M poRTLu

Q9u8X EFij 4_ EQURM 4L u EFmC M= BC D R u= Bl±7 = BË�D �À BI@ ~ CSq?= BË�D �À BI

negotiate BC D 8X [X po

p|FX [X@{ CS�R JH BlÎ�Å gFq= Fij Qi �; Bkj g= 9WQ6 u 4L u 4_ CE=��n CEQC¶ F6 ?B

C D democratic political order Bkj@ ~F6 ? democratic

9

elected leadership Bkj CE= [X EFmC M= BC D 9WQ6 u SRTU

C M \C VI ;<= EFmC M= B

C D intervention BX B] �H \Å;�= FX involve B

C D 8X [X pop|FX [X Bkj{

BlÎ�Å g= 9WQ6 u 4L u 9>R�

pTRJK6M F6 ? R u= democratic R u= QR u8R := BX ÌOCJ]:Q5CM

[X 9>R�pTRJ? BI BlÎ�Å gFq= Q9uFij Bkj 4_ g= ¯µh SRTh QR JX CEQ¹FÀ �= QR JG Bkj 4_ o6? [X 46 ¶< BI LW�= R u= s>C �xRVH;QL u Q� F6 ? á

CKp¡9D Bkj@ ~ s>C �xRVH;QL u [X F6 ? 9>R�

pTRJ? Bkj g= FX LW�= [

] ´Q6 u gQL u 8X BX You know, you are going to the Army, I think this is not the right way ;<= 4R u [

] ´FX Q�L 7= precedent create SRTUC M =Fij@{rQ¶a³6 M F6 ? \ 6 M ÑRD�À ;Q� Bkj SRTh CE= BI 4R u

cab Q9Jmf EFij 4_ BC �9: = Ìs86 : CE=; sOR JH LW�= BX gQL u B] D �= SRTi�@ ~BC �9: = EF

C Dt BI LW�= [X SRTâ

CuQs u s8�L u Bkj ; SRTi�@ ~ LW�= [X SRT9JCTh SRT

9J6?Q5w 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@ { CS�R JH v;=t; C; 6>?Qd FX SRTh 6¿=8

C? CSRT K9M poRTLu Q9u8X EFij@~\w= ¿�À EQR J� 6>?Qd FX \ 6 M 4_ \È�L �LM

46 J9:�Å@ ~B°�±�LM tenure SRTh~4ÞCuFR �X <t vs86 : \wQR JI SRT

9uFy ~SRT�9 M EFmC M= B

C D tQ�9M= Q�

Nai �Q ÁY� QR JX ;<= g= [X 46 ¶< BI B°�±�LM 46 J9:�Å \È6 Jxw= FX BC �

sT�JLT® FX F6 ? SRT9uQ6 u Fij \ i};

SRT�9 M QR u democratic system FX derail B

C D 8X [X F6 ? SRT9uQ6 u Fij \ i}; SRT�

9 M F9 D `f C;= `f EFmC M= B

C D unity show [X@ {o6? [X 46 ¶< 9ÒR:;Fm�67BI [X �Ru; vsas �Lu 8L : Bkj ;<= \ 6 M= \ 6 M tF6 ?F� Bkj@{ C �

9TÎ¶B \ 6 M \wQR JI CE=; sOR JH SRTi� Ì;Q5i} BC �� Q� Bls V�T6u SRTi�@ ~tFx�Å CEQC¶ [

] C8�L¶= 6>?Qd@~aR �p� ]<QL u 6>?Qd B

C D \ 6 M EQURM 8L : SRT9uQ6 u {SRT_

ÝQ6 JR:�Ë9D [

] ´FX 9WQ� es M�= CEt B°U±M Ì;Q5i} r=a9 �L� BX end SRTh CEQ9Jq�6¶Q9 u BX ;st;Q6 u BX gQL u R u= CS

p qÖCJ Fij Qi �; Q�9 M F9 D g= 9ÒÙ< vaR �Ï commitment \

9 M@ {g= 9ÒÙ< SRTh EQURM 8L : tF6 ?F� SRTU

C M Q�9 M@{ CS�R JH `i} =;Q� FR D sOR u; 4L u B9 �CT� Bl

9 M QR u EQU67 4L u T.V. available Q9uFij Q�9 M F9 D 8�t= BI SRT5i} 49JL: Q9J°L¶ Q�9 M 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh QR JX

10

4Ï=;st �L¶ Qi �; Bkj@{\L7=8X �QsJI 6¼CVRTL�¡�R u= SRTh F6 ? CEQßÔ

CD =Fij N< 6>I BX BC �� Q� Bkj ;<= `f C;= `f L¼

CMQL u QR u eL ? F| 6W;= B±D <; Q� CEQßÔCD Fij QR JG Bkj@ ~F

9 D 4R u oX Q� CEQßÔ

CD =Fij Bkj{ \ 6 M= �� ì} B

C D [s ´ v< 8L : Q�ÐR ut Bkj 4_ CE=��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd BC �9: = pgFC?

� Á�CD B

] D �= 4_ �= \Å; intervention solution [X c�À BH Q6¶ \ i}; Bkj{�ÄHQ6 u ì} B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� 4_ F6 ? �ÄR �

sTRJHFL D Q p�Q59M 8�t= ai �Q6 u B

C D 8�t BÖ® B] D Fij SRTi� CE= Q� [

] ´FX solution QCJ°ÄCD B] �kj QL¶@{ CS�R JH ÌaR �Ï rQR J

C? SRTh a9 �U6M 4R u Q9uFij ;<= É=Fy= `äQP FX ì} BC D [

] ´FX message QCJR:t Bkj@~8G= international community FX i} BC D

[] ´FX message QCJR:t Bkj 4_ We are able to resolve our

problems internally through democratic process. ;<= BC �±: = g]<Qi � BX ;OCu= es VRT6u BX@~g= g]<Qi � Q� �lL M QR JX á

CKp¡9D N; B

] D Q6¶ Qæ@{�FH SRT5i} QR JC:t

SRTh oX � Á�CD BI �lL M SRT�ÐR ut BG 4_ 4R u [

C ´Q9JqXQL u 4p R T5i} \Å;�= [X c�À B9 �lÐR ut SRTi� 4_ F6 ? \ 6 M solution Bkj N< SRTU

C M= [X c�À BI B] D �=@{ CS�RJH SRTh QCJL:= t;t ;<=

eXt ;<= F6 ? BlÎ�Å gFq= Fij Qi �; Bkj 4_ 4R u QR JX situation �L¶ \ i}; Bkj 4_ F6 ? v;Q5i} F6 ? ; sOR JH L>

pI Bkj@ ~[L´ [s ´ [

]�=@ ~F6 ? 4_ BC �±: = LW�= FX R u= 9>m6M vs86 :

progressive party \9 Vl6 ��w

Bkj@{Ì;Q5i} QR u8R := SRTh F9 D EFmC M= \ 6 VX <t Bq�T±u Q�@~B°�±�LM Q� r \ 6 M F6 ? 6W·RJI QR u�= Q�

9 M g= 8L : R u= 4C u�= \ 6 M \ 6 M= 9u L¿8C? SRTU

C M =Fij ;<= 4R u SRT

9uQ6 u Fij \ i}; SRT�9 M 4_ i} reforms SRT

]u� BG@{SRTh CSRT»R D BI LW�= FX 4Uf Qi �; EFij 4_ \ 6 M= 9u R u= 4C u�= \ 6 M F6 ? \ 6 M Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh C; sOµ¹ B

] D �= Bl9 M

;<= EF6 D;= B±D <; Q� =;Q5i} CEQßÔCD =Fij Bkj@ ~R u= 4C u�= \ 6 M \ 6 M= 9u EFmC M= B

C D Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh L¿8

C? SRTUC M QR JX{4C u �R �L? as �

CTh BC D 8�t= sW C;< B

C D 8X [X 9>x7 C;

11

=;=FG [X@~4C u \ i} \¡X ;<= 8R : C;< BC D EQi �< 4L u �= 8X BÙ ·P SRTh EFGFH Q� eXt ;t t Q�

=<=Oh BC D 8X [X 9>x7 C; [X{ `i} F9 D 4R u expect 8X Bkj ; Bl

9 M 4_ Bq�TÎ¶ CEQC¶ 6>?Qd B9 �mf SRTi� 4_ `i} ai � CSRTCuFR D �

CDFX SRTh BX Q6¶ R u= osD;FL T� RM sOR J

sT� SRT]uQCJ6: BG QR u sÒ� rQ6 u sOCu]<=8G QR u

sÒX8X sOCu]<=8G SRT]uQCJ6: BG@{N< F9 D ;<t [X 9WQ6 u Bkj@ ~Ì;Q5i} `f C;= `f <t CSRT

9u Ìs86 : events SRTi� Ì;FL D a6 �RJ

C? N=FC KCMF9 �CKLM SRTh 6>I BI Ìs86 : F6 ?events SRTi�@ ~FHFL D Q�

s>C ��QCu;Fs D Q9uFij Bkj r=a9 �L� SRTh@~g= BX `f C;= `f oRT®QL¶ gQL �LM ;=Cai � Q� crowd

BÙ ·P SRTh Ûx67 Q9uFij Bkj@~g= ¿�À poH;Q� Q� rFs T R T¹ Bkj@~;<OCJI Q� rFs T R T¹ Bkj@~4R u <t Ìs86 : a6 �RJ

C? N=FC KCMF9 �CKLM BX 6>I BI Ìs86 : events SRTi� ;<= CE= <t events FX

B°�±�LM <t rQ� BI \ 6 VX R u= BC D �= [X financing SRTU

C M \Èh@ {rQ¶a³6 M 4R u [] ´QU9 VC:=

gFq= Q� ÉQ»� Bkj@{F6 ? eL Kf �L¶ Qi �; Bkj@{v;tQ»H=ai �Qº 6>?Qd QCJL:= OßÔ�~F6 ? \ 6 M QÄCD= OßÔ� Bkj@ ~4R u �� FX oLD=< = sOR J

CTRJX B°±¶ SRT]uQ6¶ BG@ { CS�R JH ¯µh SRTh EFmC M= B

C D F6 ? Q p�Q59M QR uQCJ6: =Fij Bkj@{SRTh R u= BÙ ·P Q� NOCJ]:Q5

CM EFij ;<= g= [GOCJ]:Q5CM [X 9>R�

pTRJ? BI SRTh g= FX condemn Q9u8X EFij ;<= CE=��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd BI \ 6 M v;Q5i}

pg;=C8G Bkj 4_ F6 ? eL Kf Q p�Q59M EFmC M= B

C D Q�Ì; ¯µh SRTh QR uQCJ6: =Fij Bkj@ ~8G= LW�= democratic \Åt�= SR Ti� ;<= LW�= FX 8G= democracy Q� ×Fp| Bkj F9 D `f C;=

`f LW�= \ L 7= performance SRT]uQ�ft@ {a6 �RJ

C? N=FC KCMF9 �CKLM SRTh [

] ´FX \ L 7= performance SRT

]uQ�ft 4_Q9u LW�= FX EQR J� C;=FC D �R Da

p Ó 6>?Qd BX e9 MQ� compare QR JX B

] D Q6¶ 4_ CEFX Q�L 7= Bkj 4_ CEFX =86 : Bkj@{N< BC D 8X BX B] �H LW�=

;QR J9 : SRTU

C M SRTi�@{ LW�= short cuts rQ5�9T�= 8X Bkj ; SRTi� ;<= SRTh SRTU

C M Q9Jl6 ��w 4_ democracy SRTh \¡X `¡y BX short cuts Fij B9 �� SRTi�@{¯µh SRTh F6 ? `

s VqI

12

�L¶ Qi �; Bkj g= FX BC �°±¶ SR:t ;<= F6 ? ;Fm�67 9ÒR: Bkj g= FX \C VL:= vas �Lu SRTh BC �kj ;

SR:t ;<= ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh BC �

9TÎ¶ \ 6 M Ì;Q5i} [] ´Q�6 M SRTi� EQURM 8L : Everyone is

on the same page 4_ democracy FX BG �= QCJ°L¶ B] �kj QL¶@{g= \çF6 �CÇ�FX BI BG �= QCJ°L¶ B] �kj QL¶ ;<= We have to strengthen the Prime

Minister hands. 4ÞCuFR �X Any system , any change which is instigated from outside the Assembly, simply not

acceptable to the nation. rQ¶a³6 M GALLOP Poll [X SRTh BC D 9WQ6 u

[X 4_ GALP poll SRTh B°U±M \ i} 4R u 8XCt �= QÄL ? Bkj 4_ `f

C;= `f 2/3 of Pakistanis do not want the system to be derail in any

case. `i} \êRM @OR J�=B

9 D 8X SRTi� ;<= CE=��n CEQC¶ BI \ 6 M 9>I=FC?;t 4R u Bkj 4_ `f C;=

`f BÙ ·P BX 8L :<= eL Kf `7; SR:8X ;<= =;Q5i} particularly 4�·P R u= 9>x¡yO6 u 4�·P Bkj@ ~NOCuQ5¡L D 4�·P Bkj@ ~Ì;Q5i} \È6 �6M BX �]uQ � SRTi�@ ~=;Q5i} v;=FH �

CJs : Q� for instance 4µ]Jq� Bkj ;<= `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd Q� �ÄHQ6 u SRTh 4R u8�

p� =t= Q9u8X EFij 4_ EFmC M= B

C D C �9: =B crisis situation SRTh \ 6 M EQURM 4L u BC D �= Q� ;<= Ì;Q5i} @EQi �Q�

sW C;< BC D 8X Q� É=8G<8L : EFmC M= B

C D QR uQCJ6:@{g= BI NtQR uC; SRTh LW�= Q� `

] MQs u SRTUC M EFH

Qæ@ { CS�R JH `f C;= `f Everybody in the country knows. 4_ v;Q5i} \ÅFC DQ�= FX CE= EF

C D8�t BI QR JX NO]uQ¹ =Fij@~QR JX CEQßÔCD =Fij ;<= \w= ¿�À ai �Q6 u [X QR J

C:t BX BC �� Q� `i} B

C D BC �±: = LW�= FX Qp�Q59M QR uQCJ6: =Fij Bkj 4_ `f C;= `f oRT6u s;<8X É=FZ

Q� F6 ? mandate BH 8X 4R u \È6 Jxw= 8�t= []�= Bkj~g= \È6 Jxw= BX e9 MQ� R u= ×= COh

QR uQCJ6: QR JG Bkj{ L¼CMQL u ;=Cai � OCJ6:Ì 8G= LW�= [X \È6 Jxw= FX s>R�LT® tSR: QR u LW�= BX

13

democratic order FX 8G= 6W=8C? 8XSR: F9 D ÌaÓ<t CEt oRT6u ;=Cai � BH 8X

NOCJ6: �= Q9uQ6¶ Bkj@~g= BX c·C¶ NOCJ6: gQL �LM ;=Cai � BH 8X �= B] D Q6¶ QR u eX� ÌOCJ6: BH

8X �= B] D Q6¶@ ~gt eX� ÌOCJ6: BH 8X@ ~4R u [

] ´FX 4»R D�À SRTUC M Bkj@ {g= BË�D �À BI

chaotic politics FX promote ì} SR:8X BG{ Egypt FX SRT�ÐR ut~ Syria FX SRT�ÐR ut@ ~×=�n FX ~SRT�ÐR ut BC �

9TÎ¶ \ 6 M QR JC:t SRTh ¯®Q5Å SRTi� ÆQC¶ ;FÀ 8L : \Å·�=

¯®Q5Å@~v;FL D \Å·�= QR JC:t SRTh R u= ��= \ë® [

] ´Fij Bkj ;<= CEQ9JqXQL u FX `f C;= `f CE= ��= @BXEF°Í pI SRTh BC �°�J�ìt [X ÌaR �Ï rQR J

C? SRTh 4R u F6 ? �FH new entrance SRTi�~ into politics BlÎ�Å SRTU

C M 49JL: 4_ 8G= 6¿�= CSp q�R JH= Fij Q9uQ6¶ Bkj F9 D CE= Q�

a6 �RJC? N=FC K

CMF9 �CKLM SRTh QR JX ap ¸? Fij Qæ{4R u LW�= 6>I SRTi�B9 �C: Q6¶@ {

C V9T 6¶\ \ 6 M political leadership Bkj a6 �RJ

C? N=FC KCMF9 �CKLM BI ap �_= EQURM 4L u absent SRTi�{

4R u R u= gFq= [X 9WQ6 u Bkj 4_ i} BC �±: = F6 ? B°]Jq� SRTi� CE= FX sÒR:as �� SRTh

BH Q6¶ 8X �¶ BC �H QÄCD [X pop|FX 8X Bkj ; SRTi� ;<= ì} g]<Qi � BX gO»9D FX rQhQL u

BC D 8X [X po

p|FX 8X Bkj ; SRTi� ;<= third forces CS6 ? CaÓ;F Q� g= g]<Qi � BI Ñ°Í9D SRTU

C M Bkj CE= FX ì} FZOh BC D 8X [X po

p|FX 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@{R Jls M Bkj `¡6 D A=

Bl±7 = solution [X c�À SRT]uQ6¶ F9 D ì} 6>I g= FX sW;FL T� B

9 D 8X SRTi�{ CS�R JH F6 ? 9WQR u=<; `

] MQ� [X Q6¶ \ i}; SRTi�@ ~BlÎ�Å SRTUC M Q9JÖ® 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh g= `¡y XB @ 9WQh=O�=

BI [] ´FX \ L 7= i} 9WQR u=<; `

] MQ� 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@{;<= CEQ9JqXQL u BC D 8G= \Ù89: [X vsas �Lu

8L : QCuQ6¶ Bkj QR u democratic N=; FX 8G= ì} BC D QCuQCJL:= Bkj F9 D SRT5i} ;Q6 u ;Q6 u

question marks� Á�CD SRT

]u�= BG 4_ 4R u oX 4»R D�À QR uQCJL:= QR JG Bkj 4_ Mob FX BH 8X LW�= ai �Q6 u �= 8X SRT

]uQ�s V6:@{ap �_= �FH EQURM 4L u SRT9uQ6 u B

9 D 8X Bl9 M 4_ 4R u 4µ °�

BC D Fij Q6¶ Qi �; Bkj ;<= \9 Vx¡yO6 u 4_ 4R u 4µ °� Fij QR JG Bkj{E<;Q� B

C D e�R ut QR JH Bkj 4_

14

B°�±�LM 9WQ� es M�= EFC �RTUÅ BI F6 ? SRT9uQ6 u Fij \ i}; SRT�

9 M 4_ 4R u Fij Qæ QCu·¹ Fij Qæ ;<= 49JL: SRTUC M 6WQ6 �

CVL: SRTh CEFX �R �L? as � CTh BC �Î: Qæ@ ~`

] M=8L : as � CTh [X s>RT� Q� CSRT�Fp | NOCJ6:

CEFX Bkj@{F9 D rQ¶a³6 M ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh 4R u [

] ´FX \ L 7= SR:CaR �L� SRTUC M Bkj ;<= SRT5i}

future generations BX B] �H ;<= ¯µh SRTh 9ÒR:;Fm�67 [X Q»6 D ;<= g= ¯µh ÉQÄK9VI=BX BX B] �H democratic process 4L u `

] MQ� QCJ ij; B] �kj QL¶ ;<= SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd \¡X 9W;Fz SRTh resign B

C D 8X [X [] ´FX 9W;<aC b

SRTUC M Bkj ;<= \¡X `¡y Q� political pressureF6 ? 4_ non-democratic

BË�D �À BI �= Qi �; Bkj g= FX �ÄHQ6 u 9>pI=t86 : BC D 8X [X 9W;<aC b SRTU

C M Bkj@{4C u;< ai � ÌaÓ<t CEt EQURM 4L u B

C D 8�t í<ap Ó EFij BG@~ai � ÌaÓ<t CEt EQURM 4L u ¯µh BX e9 MQ� Q p�Q5

9M BC �Î: Qæ ;<= CEQ9JqXQL u Q� `i} [] ´FX Q�L 7= ÉQCu ai �Q6 u [X QRJ

C:t SRTh SRTUC M 6¼ RVl6

M SRTÞ� BG ;<= EQU67 4L u \ 6 M SRT

]uQ6¶ BG F9 D CEQ9JqXQL u F9 D CEQ9JqXQL u 4p R T5i} \9 VCK6MO6 u BI

terrorism BX ÉQCu BI QCuQL �êLM Q9uQ6¶ Bkj ;<= 49JL: SRTUC M CSX CSX EF�=;st BI i}

;C8G Bkj ; SRTi�{

CEQ9JqCDQCÍ= SRTh R u= political transition Fij Qi �; Bkj@ {g= political

transition FX \ 6 M LW�= SRT�ÐR ut@{Ì;Q5i} CEQ9JI8R : C;< SRTh vas �µh CSp q�R u= Fij Qi �; Bkj@{

g= SRTh \Å;�= BC D R u= vs86 : \ L 7= poRTLu \ÅO� [X Bkj ;<= R u= \ L 7= performance Ì;Q5i} BC �� Q� �= \ i}; {Bkj SRT5i} g= CaR �L� BX 8L :<= oXF QCu8X

B] �kj QL¶{SRT5i} \C VL:= \ÅF

C DQ�= FX a9 �U6M 9>xw SRTh@~R u8s :a9 �U6M 4L u B

C D Qìs8L ? F6 ? EQR JqR T®QL u {SRTi� CSq?= rQ6 Jy= 6>?Qd EQURM 4L u Bl

s V�T6u B] D Fij SRTi� ;<= SRTh CE= ;F� p �Q� EFij 4_ EFmC M=

BC D 9>m6M 9>It86 : C; R u= vision poRTLu QR JX 2025 Q� ;<= `i} 6>I B

C D g= SRTh Q6¶ 8X BC �±: = in puts B

] D t 4_ Ì;Q5i} oX BÙ ·P SRTh QR JX potential Bkj ;<=

15

QR JX \�f Bkj ;<= QR JX \p ¡R T6u Bkj{F9 D rQ¶a³6 M 46 ¶=FC? �z�= 6>?Qd \ 6 M EQURM 8L : Bl

s V�T6u B] D Fij SRTi�@{ CE= BI SRTh R u= <t 46 J

9:�Å CE= BI B°U±M �h QÄL ? EFij@{B°U±M QR u ÌaÓ<t CEt 6>6? \È6 Jxw= Q� CS

p qR T� Fij Qi �; Q�9 M ;<= SRTh 4R u 6>I FX QCuQ9J6: Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ SRTh

BC D EQR J� 6>?Qd FX sW<< QR ut Bkj ;<= SRTh B

C D LW�= FX \ 6 M sW<< QR ut Bkj@{g= B] �H 4_ Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh [

] ´FX \Ù89: Fij ;<= g= B] �H 4_ 4R u continuity F6 ? Bkj@~4R u democracy F6 ? ;Q6 u ;Q6 u g= ¯µh SRTh derail [

9 ´Fij \ i}; Bkj@~g= BI \¡X \ 6 M `¡y BX 8G= 9WQ»6 �À FX NO]uQ¹ =Fij Bkj F9 D N< non-democratic �FH

CS6 ?Bl9 M FX g= 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX derail B

C D Fij SRTh 8G= [] ´FX NO]uQ¹ QL �

CVmLM Bkj{ÌaR �Ï O®=< 6>?Qd tFC? 1999 EQRJ� 6>?Qd BX e9 MQ� \È6 Jxw= SRTh Bl

9 M ;<= 6>6? g= \È6 Jxw= [X ÂQ 6 D \s VRTLJH \] VG F9 D 6>I BI NtQR u

C; ì} �FH EQi �< 4L u affect B] D Fij SRTi�

;<= SRTh N;Q6 u<t 4R u 9WQ6 u QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ 4_ �FH Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh B9 �lÐR ut SRTi� 4_ 4R u F6 ? v;Fm�67 aÓ;F SRTi� 4R u QR JX BÙ ·P BX B] �H 8X \ i}; SRTi� ;<= F6 ? non-

democratic set ups EQURM 4L u SRT�9 M@~EFmC M= B

C D QR JX BÙ ·P BX B] �H QR JX {QR JX SRTh cab 4R u pg;=C8G LW�= FX QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd 4_ SRTh CE= Q�

;F� p � EFij 4_ R u= F9 D BÙ ·P Q� EFmC M= BC D sW C;< CE·L u QR JX B°�±�LM B9 �²kj SRTh@ ~ CS�R JH

\9 Vx¡yO6 u BI N< sW C;< SRTUC M 8X B��@{vaR �Ï CE= BI pg;=C8G Bkj 4_ LW�= SRT

]u�= ì} LW�= Q� 4C uQUä=< rQ6 JÔ

9T�= SR:8X BG ;<= ì} \¡X \ 6 M 9W;Fz SRTh CE= EFp| C;Q� Q� 4ß? BC �CTÎu BX B] �H �ÄHQ6 u ;QR J

9 : SRTUC M SRTi� ;<= o6? ¿�À BI SRTh B

C D LW�= FX CÆ�n QR JX 4_ strongest possible terms SRTh SRTh condemn Q9u8X EFij 4_ F6 ? eL Kf ai �Q6 u B

C D 8�t BC D �Å Fij Bkj ; SRTi�@{ CS�RJH `f C;= `f v;Q5i} \ 6 M 9WC�n Q� rQR J

C? SRT�f;@{Ì;Q5i} NOCuQ5¡L D BÙ ·P SRTi�{ì} \

C VL:= dead bodies FX winters SRTh BC �±: = �l½ SRTUC M BH Q6¶ B9 �� o6?;<= ¯µh SRTh R u= Q R D= sÒXas ��st Fij EQU67 4L u BÎD Fz Q� oRT6u

16

OßR� QR u8R := Bkj@{`f C;= `f Ì;Q5i} 8L :<= eL Kf `7; SR:8X@{Fs �l6 M 6>?Qd BC D Lowari

tunnel BX 8L :<= ÉQ� í<ap Ó QR JX ;<= raC �6� cap ¸� BC D g= 4R uQL uFX �RJxÐ

9u 9u BC D QL �CVmLM [X po

p|FX [X CS�R JH still 9>ËR�Ô? 4R u Bkj 4_ cab oRT®QL¶ OßR� 8�t= ÉQ� =Fij ;<=Bkj es MQ� OßR� ÉQ� \ 6 M= \ 6 M Q9J ij; Bkj@{`

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd FX SRTh pg;=C8G

E<8X Qæ 4_ 6>6? 4R u �ÄR �sTRJHFL D 4p�Q5

9M Bkj@ ~F6 ? \ 6 M 9W·Äpq� LW�= FX BC �� Q� � Á�CD \ i};�=

SRTi�@ ~4R u 6>6? `9 VC? EFij F9 D Q6 ua³Å [

C ´ SR:8X ;<= r=a9 �L� Q� R u= sW C;< SR:8X@{v;Q5i} \ 6 M 4µdF? [

] ´=C��= [GFij@{`f C;= `f �FH SRTUf BG 4_ 4R u F6 ? democratic set up BH =< �FH SRTi�’ 4R u `f

C;= `f R u= BÙ ·P [X [GOCuQ5¡L D FX Oh � Á�CD B9 �lf; B

] D Fij 8�t= B

] D �=@ {o6? ¿�À Fs �l6 M Q� ÉQCu Bl±7 = BË�D �À BI EQi �< 4L u QR JH Q9uQ6¶ Bkj@ {raC �6� cap ¸� Q� \ 6 M ’ SRTh R u= 9>ËR�Ô? 9WQ6 u 8X EFijQi �; ’ \¡X 4_ OCJqL D Fij QR u 4C u Fij

’g= BC D R u= BÙ ·P BX R u= 4CJR:8R :t BÎ�H QY� FX =;FL D QR JX@ {4R u QCuFij B��kj QL¶ Q�9 M@ {4R u SR:CaR �L� \¡X democratic set up SRTh [

C ´Fij SRTRJ ijQL¶ SRT�9 M{

SRTh LW�= [X CS

p qR Th;QÃCD= B] �H BX Q9J6: E<t 4_ EFGFH B

C D Fs �l6 M 6>?Qd BI Q�L 7FL D 4_ LW�= 8�O_’ r=a9 �L� \

C V9:= vs86 : vtQ6 u�= Q� 4�·P SRTUC M Bkj ’ LW�= 8�t= Q6¶ 8X QR JX

�CJs : [X SRT

9uQ6 u 8X SRTi�Bkj ; F9 D EFmC M= BC D QUf 4_ 8G= g= ;QL u R u= \Åt�= \ 6 M

CEQ9JqXQL u Q� Q9J ij; F9 DBkj g= ÌOCJ6: B] �H BX SRT5i} 4R u �CJs : QCuQCJ6: Ìs8L : Qæ@ {vaR �Ï

pg;=C8G \êRM [GFij 4_ Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh ’ 46 ¶=FC? 6>?Qd EQURM 4L u Bl

s V�T6u B] D Fij SRTi�

’ `f C;= `f N;Q6 u BI N;OCJL: ;=Cai � QÜR �� sW=< [X Ì;Q5i} BÙ ·P SRTh potential Bkj{ CE= E<CaR �L� BX 8L :<= oXF SR:8X@{`i} LW�= FX A=ÚQ p

CD= fully support SR:8X BG{

)B] D �@�R Dap ¸

9D@SR Th@ CE=FR D=@ CEQ9JqXQL u@`ÁîZ=8R : C;<@ 6WQCJ6?@ CE=;<t@\w=(

17

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�: \67 continue {SR:8X

6WQCJ6? ;QC�9V= CSR:O®=: \67 aÓ@{aÓ `] M=8L : as �

CTh 6>?Qd FX ì} g]<Qi � SRTh `ÐµR u< SRTi�B9 D 8X@{SRTh EQURM 4L u 4Uf Qi �; Q�

9 M 4_ tFx�Å CEQC¶ [] Ć8�L¶= 6>?Qd B

C D EQURM 4L u Ìs�lf Fij BX Ìs86 : ¼

Cï=< ÁÂQÃH= SRTh 8R:;Q»9D SRT_@~\w= ¿�À aR �p� ]<QL u 6>?Qd Bl

9 M ;<= Ì;Q5i} [s ´;QL uC8°L JRTLu BX CE=; sOR JH 6>?Qd SRTi� ’OR J

pI;FC? NQ p� 6>?Qd BC D’Ì;Q5i} 9>ZQ56 7 \Å·�=

BX aR �Ï= 6>?Qd BC D g= crisis FX resolve B

C D 8X BX B] �H~g= FX solve 8X B

C D BX B] �H =s86 : Q�L 7= role play QR JX@{a³6 M rQ¶ SRTh CE= FX g= 9WQ6 u BX B] �H 6¿=8

C? CSRT K9M poRTLu EFijQ9u8X 4_ F6 ? v;Fm�67 CSijCt BX F6 ? �FH SRTi� EFmC M= B

C D R u= ÌaÓ<t SRTâ

CuQs u BC �±KCVRT�f [X po

p|FX SRTUC M [X@{EFmC M= B

C D democracy BX 8L :<= believe QR JX ;<= EFmC M= B

C D g= CaR �L� ~FX g= `s VqI FX strengthen

BC D 8X B] �H F6 ? negotiation B

C D 8X [X pop|FX [X F9 D N< 6>I BX BC �� Q� Bkj@{

a³6 M rQ¶ CE= FX BC �9TÎ¶ \ 6 M Ìa³C VI ÁÂQÃH= SRTh 6¿=8

C? CSRT K9M poRTLu QR JX B

] D Q6¶ SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ `f Fij Qæ{

SRTh EQR J� 6>?Qd FX CSRT»R D QCu�t EFijQ9J ijQL¶ 4_ ì} LW�= [X sW;FL T� 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@ {=aR �Ï R u= 6ÒR:�

Cn 4�·P Bkj@ { LW�= \¡X 9ÒÙ< �R Dap ¸9D SRT

]u� ;<= SRTh LW�= Q� 4R u8�p� \ 6 M =t= EFijQ9u8X 4_ LW�= \

C V9:= crisis [X situation SRTh LW�= BC D r=a9 �L�

�R Dap ¸9D B

C D � Q� É=8G<8L : {QR uQCJ6: g= B] �H BX SRTh [H=a9 �L� ÉFy [X c�À BI LW�= Q� 4R u8�p� =t= EFijQ9u8X{EQURM 4L u \

C V9T 6¶ \ 6 M political forces SRTi� ’SRTh CE= FX \ 6 M 6¿=8C? CSRT K

9M poRTLu EFijQ9u8X 4_ EFmC M= BC D g= g]<Qi � gO»9DBX BX B] �H F6 ?

united stand QR JH ;<= �� Q� F6 ? Gallop pole Bkj ’ SRTh `] M=8L : as �

CTh

18

6>?Qd [X 9>�O C¶ SRTh 4R u pg;=C8G E<8X 4_ already the poles are in front of us that almost two third of the country CE= [X F6 ?

majority Bkj@ ~g= democratic system BX � ° 9D B] �H BX EFmC M= B

C D sW<< QR JX ;<=Bkj EFmC M= B

C D \C VL:= B

] D =; Q� ;QU Áç= QR JX {Bkj ì} `f C;= `f F6 ? two third �FH SRTi�@ ~ CE= [X B

] D =; FX Oh � Á�CD BC �lf; BX SRT5i} g= `

s VqI FX strengthen QCu8X B��kj QL¶ ;<= \¡X \ 6 M Bq�D = É=C8H= BI SRT5i} C8R :8G QCu8X B��kj QL¶ o6?

[X 46 ¶< BI Ì;Q5i} ¯µh SRTh question marks SRT]uQ6¶�= 4_ ai � L¼

CMQL u ;=Cai � gt ;=Cai � E<OCJ6: [X 9ÒXap Ó [X 46 ¶< BI ’ L¼

CMQL u gt ;=Cai � s>C �xRVH;QL u BX ai �Q6 u Bls VX= 8X

BX ì} R u= ÌaÓ<t FX EQURM BI BC �ÎKRVl6 M [X pop|FX SR:8X@{o6? ¿�À Ì;Q5i} tFx�Å

CEQC¶ [] Ć8�L¶= 6>?Qd B

C D 9WQ6 u 4_ oRT6u s;<8X É=FZ BX mandate BX Ì;Q� ÌOCJ]:Q5

CM g= g]<Qi � SRTh Bls V�T6u SRTi� ;<=mob [X o�

sJRT®FL D FX sWF�<8L : 8X Bkj ; SRTi�{ mob [X o�

sJRT®FL D SRTh Egypt BC D QR JX NO]uQ¹ �dQ¶ QR JX~ mob[X o�

sJRT®FL D SRTh ÌaÓ<t EF�µh B

C D@~\Å·�= EF�µh BC D@~v;FL D QR J

C:t SRTh EQU67 4L u 4R u mob politics �L¶ \ i}; Bkj{ instigated by F6 ? \ 6 M CE= FX instigate 8X Bkj Qi �; CS�R JH

v;Q5i} v;FL D \Å·�= QR JC:t SRTh ��= \ë® [

] ´Fij Bkj ;<= g= mob politics FX SRT5i} �ÄHQ6 u rF6 �y SRTU

C M QCu8X B��kj QL¶ ;<= SRT5i} O�9V� Fij BX undemocratic 4»R D�À ;Q� BI @F6 ?EF9 ��F�¶ FX �RuO6 J

9: BC D 8X [X po

p|FX SRTi�B9 D 8X SRT5i} CE= Q� 4µ6 uQ»� QCu8X B��kj QL¶@{

A=ÚQ p CD= ì} `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd e9 MQ�BX SRTi� ;<= CE= e9 MQi �BX ÂF6 �CÇ� SR:8X BG{

Thank you very much.

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�: v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP CEQC¶ { 6>?Qd

19

4µ C¶=t@8R : C;<)v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP CEQC¶(: {� R V�?�8�H=@ CS� x7�8�H=@�A=@�`¡�6 D 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� ! SRTh LW�= Q� ;F� p � EFij@{SRTh B

C D 49J pIC8G oRT9u EFHQ� SRTh OR uQ p� EQURM ’ OR uQ p� SRTU

C M 4Þµ6 u ÝQCJRT»R D ’ SRTh B°æ = CEt 6WQ ? QÜH Qi �; Q�

9 M 4_ E<s8�CJRT� 6WQ ?BX BI 8R:;Q»9D [X SRTi�@{\ 6 VX CE=FR D= g=BX c�À es VRT6u =BX ;< \ 6 VX CE=FR D= g=BX c�À es VRT6u BX@{Ìs86 : `i}= Ûy=F� 8L : SRTh B

C D \C VL:= [

s ´;QL u [X c�À BI CSp qR D C;FL D= QR u 9>�F�¶ [X [

C ´Q56 789: [X Bkj

F6 ? \ 6 M aR �Ï v [s ´;QL u Q� �yòF� raC �6�{Q�9 M cap ¸� L¼

CMQL uBX 4®Q� ;<t SRTh 2002 BI 2008 9u ’ eL Kf CE=a6 �5Å EQURM tF6 ?F� SRTi�@{ CE= EFs �RT� 4L u es VRT6u BX aR �Ï QR JX=

�yòF� Qi �; Bkj@{OR uQ p� CEQ9JqXQL u [X C¼ RM;Q9u SRTh CE= oRT9u EFHQ� SRTh ;<= 9>m6M BI Ûy=F�

B] D �= EFij F6 ? 6¿�= BX g= 9W;Fz rQ¶ BI \ 6 M NtQR u

C; aR �6Jx^½ Bl9 M@{SRTh B

C D QCJL:= �yòF� ;<= \

C VL:= [s ´;QL u Q� �yòF� CEQR J6: QR JX@{8Öh 6¿�= 6>6? EQURM EFij=s�lf ;<= CEQ9JqXQL u

`È � ØR JH ) CE( ;<= 9>�F�¶ Q� �yòF� CEQRJ6: 8X EFijQi �; F9 D BlÎ�Å 4R u gQ ?= Bkj 4_ 4R u R u= [

] ´QU9 VC:= `i}= 9ÒÙ< cab g= s>C �xRVH;QL u ;<= 9>�F�¶ BX BH =F? BI SRTU

C M Bkj 4Þµ6 u CEQ9JqXQL u BX BH =F? BI Bkj@{ CEQ9JqXQL u BX �6JÔ

9T � BH =F?BX BI Bkj ;<= s>C �]:=FL D =s86 : clear Bkj{

g= ¯µh [X 6>

C K9VCTh s>C �xRVH;QL u BqÎ? ¯µh BX É=FZ B

C D 6>C K9VCTh QR JX Bkj@{o6?

SRTh ÉQ59M \wQR JI CaR �su;QL u ;<= ÉQ5

9M international and internal public opinion, media \Å=FZ B

] D =; ~4ÏQP rF| \s V]:Q�F| Q� �5Ðh tQ59VZ= Q�9 M{ 6WQCJ6?

8�R JLT�! \w= CE=FR D= SRTh Ìs�lf Fij BX R u= R u= vas �CJxRVHQL u sOR JH; BC D ÉQP Q6 uQ

C�9VC:= 9W

4L u tQ59VZ= Q� ;QU Áç= QR JX ;<= 6>C K9VCTh 8R : C;< `

ÁîZ= FX tQ6 JX;Q6 J� vt{g= SRTh N< R u= LW<8G \ 6 M �hQ p� Bkj@{R u= [

s ´;QL u \ 6 M �hQ p� Bkj F6 ? 6¿�= g= CE=FR D= SRTh SRTUC M {\

s VRT6u F6 ? g= 9ÒÙ< 49JI=; Bkj@~F6 ? g= 9ÒÙ< CEQ9JqXQL u BX BC �� Q� R u= Qi �=;<t =s�lf 8X QR ut QR JG

20

Bkj’N< �ÄHQ6 u ¼Cï=< Bkj ;<= g= B] �H SRTh B

C D B°U±M OR Jm�9 M \¾OCuQ6 u Bkj@ {R u= c�À

CEQ9JqXQL u [X 6>C K9VCTh s>C �xRVH;QL u Bkj@{4R JHOP BX F6 ? 6W= 9u B°ß�� B�±¶ �=BC �� Q� SRTi� ’ Q6 u

; ;Q6 u R u= 9WQ6 u Q� NtQP= Q9uFij 4_Bkj CSRT]u�=@~ CEF

C DQ� <= ; 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX N<·P [] ´FX ;<=

49JI=; �6uQ� rF6 �y SRTUC M Bkj@{ CEQ9JqXQL u Q� CS

p q�R JH= CSp qR T5f@~ CEQ9JqXQL u [X ÉQ5

9M \wQR JI EQR Js :;QL u

4Þµ6 u CSp qR D C;FL D= EQRJ

s :;QL u’ [] ´FX \¡R D= [

] ´Q6 uFz �CJ6KRM; CaR �su;QL u \ 6 M SRTi� F6 ? ×Q¹< SRTh SRTU

C M 8Öh CS6 ? [X EF6 DFz SRTh representation {Bkj CEQ9JqXQL u [X É=FZ@ ~ CEQ9JqXQL u Q�

QR usOR J� ’ t= C;�= QR u

sOR J� R u= c�À Bkj ;<= R u= QR u <t N<8G R u= c�À SRTi� ;<= N< ÉFy BC �� Q�BX 49JI=; 4R u eX; Bkj ; SRTi� 4_ OCJL? ;=Cai � �FH R u= N<8G [X �Ä

pI SRTh \C VL:= v;Fm�67 vt= C;�= B

] D =; Q� NtQ6 JH ós;<= BX 4_ `i} BC D R u= v;Fm�67 6¿Q6 �

9V?= QCu8X Bkj’g= Q� NtQ6 JH s;<= ó BX s>C �xRVH;QL u BX s>R�G 4L u L¼

CVmLM SRT]uQ6¶ ;<= SRTUf 4_ 6>6?

9u 4R u s>C �xRVH;QL u s>R�LT® SRTUC M vt [

9 ´Q6¶@~ 6>6? 6>C K9VCTh 8R : C;< `

ÁîZ= �\àô9T�= SRTU

C M ~B9 ��: t Ú=; C;< �\àô

9T�= SRTUC M B9 ��: t ’ÉQ ÁY

CD �RuO6 J9: SRTU

C M Q9uFij F9 D `i} EQURM SRTUC MBI SRT

]uQ6¶ 6>6?{BG SRTU

C M= QUf Q9uQ6¶ Bkj 4_ 4R u v8C?�= O¶ Bkj ;<= g= BI BG �= LW�= SRTU

C M B9 ��= F9 D �lL M N< \w= s>C �xRVH;QL u BX BC �� Q� SR:a6 �� B

C D tFlf Ø® B9 D Q6¶ SRTi� N< CSàX

CSmLM B9 ��T® SRTi� CSRT9u=FC? ;<= EFL K6M [X rQìst QCJ6: B

9 ��T® SRTi� 4_Q9u BC �±: = g= h COÉF� = sOCJ6KRM= F6 ? Bkj ’ 4R u cab v;Fm�67aR �

Cõ SRTUC M Bkj 4R u g= ¯µh BX c·C¶ Bkj g= CSÀ<

BX c·C¶ Bkj g= [X ÉQ59M v;Fm�67 ;=O9Jy= BX c·C¶ Bkj@{F9 D 6>6? CE= BI QUf

Q9uQ6¶ Bkj 4_ LW�= g= BI BG �= SRTUC M �= B9 �� F9 D CEF

C DQ� LW�= Q� 4µ6 uQ»� Ì8X Qæ@{F9 D

�lL M N< BG �= BI g= `¡y Q� t; �5n B9 D 8X SRTi�@ { CE= Q� OßÔ� 4R u Bkj 4_ OR uC�Å

v�à9D=��= B°�JlL M@{49 JI=FC KCM=O C¶ 49JI=F

C KCM=O C¶ SRT

p�� SR:8G ;<= 4R u ¯µh v�à9D=��= Q� ;QÄ pI Fij@{4R u N< 49JI=; Bkj@{SRTh B

C D B°æ = CEt \ 6 M R u= oRD8L : oCD�àCDQ� SRTh Q�9 M 8G= 6¿�= 4R u 49JI=;

CEQh QR JH QR JG F9 D �� QR JX 9Ò

C :Q5Cï Bkj 4_ CE= BI NtQR u

C; R u= ÂF6 �CÇ� N<8G EQURM 45R VC?

21

CE C; SRTUC M Fij Qæ ;<= Bmf Qæ 4_ LW�= SRT

sJ ij ;<= `i} SRT]u�= BG@{4R u F

9 D g= ¯µh FX g= BX ÉQ ÁY

CD FX distort QCu8X \ i} SRTUC M 6¿�= BI E<s8�CJRT� rQ� Bl±�RVL: BH QCuQ6¶

Bkj@{ 6>6? 6>I eL Kf 8� p H \p ¡X BI Q9J°L¶ Q�9 M@{o6? Q� 8�p H NtQR u

C; ÂF6 �CÇ� Q9uFij Q�9 M N< g= ¯µh BX B� ·C�ä=;t BX ai �Q6 u �= 8X 45R V

C? CE C; Q9uFij Q�9 M ;<= g= 9ÒÙ< BX NQ p�tQ6 u FX Q9Jmf Q�9 M 4_ QR u =;Q5i} 4µ6 uQ»� <8X E<;F°9u BI QR u EFy<OCJ6: BI QR u 4R u [HQ

C¶ <8X i} g= 8L : Cá6 DQ� B

9 D Fij SRTi�@{F9 D QR JX 6¿�= BX g= ;<t SRTh 6>6? 4R u ¯µh g= ÉQ»� 8L : QL �CVmLM

Bkj F9 D 6¿�= g= `¡y [X L¿F| g= `¡y BX ÌsOCJ6KRM= ;<= g= `¡y BX É=8G<8L : Q� \C Vx9 V� Fij Q9J�� Bkj{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! SRTh v;FL D 4ÏCt v;=< BI 4Uf Q9J�� EFij g= 9ÒÙ< ÝQ6 JR:�Ë

9D [] ´Qì s;=

;=Cai � oRT]uQ6 u F| ’ <t CSRT

9u F| 8L :<= B±�RVC: B

9 D Fij B9 �kj ; SRTi�@ {g= 9ÒÙ< [] ´Qì s;= ;=Cai �

CSRT9u=FC? R u= ;Qß? SRTh \

s VRT6u SRTi� CE= BX e9 MQ� <t F| B±�6M \ 6 M SRTi�@{ ÝQ6 JR:�Ë9D 20

toddlers SRTi� F6 ? �ÄHQ6 u Bs D FlL 7 SRTi� ;<= 180SRTi� F6 ? Ìs;Fl9 M Ìs86 : SRTi� <t F|

B±�6M SRTi� F6 ? �ÄHQ6 u EFL K6M BX Ì�Å C; SRTh B9 D �= SRTi�@ { 9>�F�¶ B

C D [] ´QU9 VC:= ö6 � Cz Q�

Nai �Q ÁY� QR JX@ {vaR �Ï \C VL:= B

] D =; g= BI �ÄHQ6 u �°9JCKÅ \

9 M ;F�6 D 4µ C¶=t8R : C;< 8Öh 8C?�·6 u

4µßR� N< Q9uFij Bkj F6 ? 9>�F�¶ Q� Fij@ {=aR �Ï rQR JC? Bkj ÆQC¶ ;FÀ 8L : CE= SRTh BI

R u= LW<8G BC D F6 ? B°�±�LM ;<t SRTh C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u BX ;<t SRTh o6? ¿�À \w= `¡y [X 8� p H \p ¡X [X \

9 M g= FX BC �� Q� B9 �lf; B] D Fij ÌaR �Ï OR uO p� 9WQ ÁY²K

9M Bl9 M B°U±M CEt

BI{4_ ;Fij� BI 6>6? 4R u Bls VX= Fij 8X SRT

]u�= BG ;<= EQURM 9u SRTL�CVmLM BG ;<=

gt eX� Q� NOP< F9 D vs86 : ;<t [H=< 9WQ6 u Fij Fm6M EFmC M= BC D C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u BX ;<t SRTh \ 6 M Bq�D = \ i} QR JX@ {gt eX� [H=< F9 D ;<t [H=< 9WQ6 u 8G= gt ;=Cai � \ 6 M �FH EQURM Bls VX= Fij B

9 D Q6¶ SRTi� F9 D ’ ÆQC¶ ;FÀ 8L : F6 ? ;Fij� SRTh 4Íy=< =Fij Bkj F6 ? 6W= EFmC M=

22

BC D ;QR Jl

9 V ij QCJ6: QR JH Bkj@{8Öh rQ¶a³6 M [s ´;FR ��R JI Ì;=t= g= BH =F? BI ÂQ9JKÅ SRTi�@ {F9 D

gt ;=Cai � N;OCJL: ;=Cai � ;<= oRT6u ;=Cai � Q� R u= 8� p H EQURM É·�= tQ6 u�= SRTh L¼CVmLM Q9uQ6¶ Bkj

F9 D oRT®FL D oX ¿�À g= FX defuse Ì8X [G QR u g= FX ap ¸9TCJ� Ì8X [G

short of taking some strong action? rQ¶a³6 M g= SRTh ÝQ6 JR:�Ë9D ÉQ5

9M �ÄR �sTRJHFL D [

s ´;QL u N=FC? Ì;Q5i} e9 MQ� \s VRT6u SRTi� N=FC? g= c�À \

s VRT6u SRTi� 6>I Q� 4R u 4»²9�� yF� Q�9 M 4Þµ6 u \] VX F6 ? ai �Q6 u \ 6 M \

s VRT6u SRTi� N< R u CEQ6 uC; Bl

9 M 4_ \¡X [X v;Fm�67 C;=<�= 8L : CS

C ZO� SRTUC M [

C ´QÜH B��kj QL¶@{ C;=<�= BC D Q�s M= Q� \ 6 M Ñ? Bkj 6¿Q6 �

9V?= BC D 8X Q�

\ 6 M Ñ? Bkj@{v;Q5i} \C VL:= 9>ZQ56 7 BX ;OCu= R u= ¼

Cï=< 9ÒR:ap �_= \9 M 4_ 6 uQ8

C?�� 4R u QR JX SR:8X BG@{8G= eL Kf SR:8X BG 6>I eL Kf CEQh 8X F9 D �lL M =;Q� e6 ?F6 D CE= 8L : Ìs8L : Qæ@{

vaR �Ï g= 9ÒÙ< \ 6 M pg;=C8G \

9 M ;<= SRTh BC D 4R u OR Jm�

9 M g= B��H \¾OCuQ6 u 4_ SRTh g= CE=FR D= BX BC �� Q� E<8X@{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! e6 ?F6 D CE= 8L : Q9us8L : Bkj CS6 ? FX gQ ?= Fij 4_ 4R u v;Fm�67 ;FÀ BË�D �À SRTi� 4R u c=Oi �= SRTi� CE= BI BG �= B� s86 : F9 D =;Q� lash

pack `i} 8L : Ìs8L : Qæ@{ C8°L JRTLu [s ´;QL u Bkj N=FC K

CMF9 �CKLM \Èh \Å=FZ [s ´;QL u Bkj 9>ZQ56 7 \Å·�=

SRTi� g= c�À QR u g= c�À Ì;Q5i} e9 MQ� BÎ7 FR D []�= Bkj 9W; COÍ� Bkj SRTh 6>I

Q� ÉQCu SRTUC M BH QÄI@{\¡R D= EF9 �ZQ56 7 FX 4R u CÆ=a9 �õ= Fij Q9J�� Bkj QR u 4R u BC �±: = ;OCu=

R u= accountability QR u 6WQ 9T¶= Q� 4R u<=C; Bkj 4_ i} R u= aR �

Cõ v;Fm�67 9ÒX8? SR:8X BG F9 D É=FZ g= 8L : �5nt; Q� ;QU Áç= SR:8X BG 4_ 4R u Bq�T_ �FH SRTi�

v;Fm�67aR �CõF6 ? \ i} SRTi� 4Þµ6 u aR �

Cõ 4ÏCt 4C u=;t 9>IQR JI 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@{[HFG [X 9>IQR JI 8X Bkj ; SRTi� \

s M� [X 9>IQR JI 8X Bkj ; SRTi�@{ CS6 ? Q� = sOCJ6KRM= \ i} 4R u Bkj 4_ EFmC M= BC D

ÉQ ÁYCD FX QCJsTRJLT® Bkj v�à9D=��= [

C ´QL �Å Bkj@ { s>C �xRVH;QL u BX BC �� Q� \nQ59V6?= SR:a6 �� [C ´tFlf

SRTi�@{ CSàX CSmLM BC ��T® SRTi� BC �±: = EFGFH [X SRTp�� [

C ´=8G SRTi� ;<= CE= EFp|� [X tQR JCT6u QCJ6:

23

8X R u= v�à9D=��= [C ´QL �Å Bkj CE= BX BC �� Q� F9 D 4R u sW<Q�; SRTU

C M Bkj@ {v;Fm�67 [HQ9u EFC D<t c=�À= BI \9 VLK6M Bkj@{rQ¶a³6 M 9>�F�¶ B

C D BC �±: = ;OCu= \ 6 M ¼Cï=< 9ÒR:ap �_= [X

46 ¶< BI v;Q5i} 9>m6M C8ÖCJsTRJ� [

] ´Fij SRTi� g= SRTh ¼Cï=< 9ÒR:ap �_= v;Q5i} ;OCu= \ 6 M \

9 M’ SRTh NtQR u

C; \ÅQ ÁY9�C:= BI BH =F? Q9JL?F| Q�9 M@{Ì;Q5i} ;OCu= [X L¿F| v;Fm�67 ;<= \wQR JI \

9 M@{g= BI ós86 : 8X ÉQ5

9M CaR �su;QL u ;Q6 u ;Q6 u `] M=8L : as �

CTh 6>?Qd BI ;<= Ì;Q5i} a] �RJCT�

C;; sOR JH BX e9 MQ� vt=�àCD= 9WQ�·h SRTh \ 6 M ;<= \nQ59V6?= 9WQ�·h SRTh \ 6 M ;<=

BC �±: =public statements SRTh \ 6 M \9 Vmf \9 M 4_ 9>�F�¶ CE= BX B9 T� =; SRTh

[] ´FX sW<Q�; 4C u BH =st CE= FX Bq°Î¶ gF°6¶ B

C D 8X SR:t N=FC? N< É·�= tQ6 u�= \ i} EFR �X 4C u SRT]u�=@{

;Q6 u ;Q6 u rQpJ� vt [

9 ´Q6¶ \9 M 4_ C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u BC D \ 6 M SRTU

C M= sOR u; CE< C; SRTh Bq°Î¶ BC D 8X QR ut F

9 D LW�= \ 6 M BC D 8X SR:t@{;Fij� BI BH 8X 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! g= 8L : \9 V�F�¶

[Gt8X;Q� 8L : [] ´FX oXF SRTU

C M Q9u�=@{ 6>6? 4R u 4µßR� =Fij EQi � g= SRTh v;Q5i} [s ´;QL u [X

<t B] D =; SRT�

9 M 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u R u8K9M cQß

C D= R u= \wQR JI entity Bkj R u= \wQR JI LW<8G Bkj o6? Q� s>C �xRVH;QL u SRTh ’[

] ´QU9 VC:= 4ÏCt ;=t [

s ´;QL u Bkj@ { CE= FX ;F�6 D \wQR JI 9>ZQ56 7 ì} 4 °6¶ B

C D 8X SR:t{[L´ Ì= [s ´ R u= \wQR JI 9>ZQ56 7 SRTU

C M Bkj@{R u= \wQR JI LW<8G SRTU

C M Bkj@{ 6>I BI ós86 : 8X CE= BX F6 ? �d= ;<= a9 � p R T6u 9WQ6 JHQY� SRTi� N< aR �Cõ \

C VRT]u�= SRTi� [C ´FC DQ�aR �Cõ SRTi� CE= FX 4 °6¶ 4C u B

C D 8X QR ut B] D Q6¶@ {8Öh �lL M 4R u `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd B

C D 4R u 4µßR � QR JX F6 ? v8C?�= ØCJsTRJ� [

] ´Fij 4_ SRTUC M@{8G= ì} B

C D R u= B°�f CSijCt ;<= B°�f rt BI 9WQ6 u [

C ´8X Bkj F9 D �lL M EFC D<t EF9 �ZQ56 7 FX ì} g= BX

e9 MQ� e9 MQ� SRTh ;F�6 D vaR �Ï F6 ? R u= 9W;= C;< [X 4ÏCt v;=t Bkj@ {F6 ? security threats Bl9 M ;<= N< security threats Ì;Q5i} CSRT®F| E<;=t= BI SRTU

C M

24

Bl9 M@{i}= CSR:8

9: vas �µh E<;=t= BI Bl9 M \ÈR J

sTCu= oCT6¶ E<;=t= BI Bl

9 M@{\ÐµhaR �Cõ [X CS6 ?

[X EQURM ;stQ6 u BX g= c�À CE= EFy·P SRTh L¼CVmLM Bkj QR u CE= [X \ÈsJ

C:= oCT6¶ [

9 ´Fij Bkj CE= [X c�À BI `i}= CSR:8

9: intelligence excerpts SRT]u�= NOPQ�Q6 u C;st;QÄR D;

B] D �={

F9 D EQU67 9>�F�¶ [X 4ÏCt v;=t \

9 M ;<= 4R u 4ÏCt v;=t =aR �Ï rQR J

C? Bkj <t QCJG Fij \] VG \

9 M 6>6? 4_ g= CE=FR D= [X ’ g= CE=FR D= [X \ i} SRTUC M 4Þµ6 u CE=FR D= BI ai �Q6 u

\ 6 M rQ¶a³6 M vtQR JCT6u 4ÏCt v;=t g= CE=FR D= [X Bkj F6 ? \wQR JI 9WtQR Jy Bkj v;Q5i}

9>ZQ56 7 BX N<·P EFmC M= BC D Qi �;Q6 u QUf 4_ 4C u cab CE= FX 9W C;Q6¶= vt B

] D Q6¶ 4Þµ6 u CE= FX [

s ´;FR ��R JI `i}=�� [X B] D Q6¶@{F9 D N< Bq�D < \ 6 M 9>�F�¶ [X 4ÏCt v;=t Bkj 8Öh N<

<t QCJG Fij \] VG Bkj 4ÞCuFR �X ;Q6 u ;Q6 u intelligence excerpts BI 4R u \ 6 M 8p:Q9 u

QCJ°R JlL M í<ap Ó Fij QR JG 4_ Qp� R uO 9>�F�¶ CE= Q� =;QUw BH 8X CE= FX QCJX<; \9 V ijQL¶ Bkj@{g= Q� sW sOR u8X =aR �Ï rQR J

C? Bkj CEQ9JqXQL u [X oRT®FL D 6WQ6 �CVL: [X oRT®FL D É·�= tQ6 u�= [X

oRT®FL D Ì;Q5i} \ÈR JsTCu= o

CT6¶ Ì;=t= N=FC? N< vas �µh SRTi� N=FC? N< CSR T®F| SRTi�@{8G= N< vs;Fl9 M 9>m6M N; [

9 ´Q6¶ Bkj F9 D 4R J�Q ÁY9�C:= FX 6WQ6 �

CVL: [X 4R J�Q ÁY9�C:= ;<= É·�= tQ6 u�= [X

4R J�Q ÁY9�C:= 4_ E<;=Cai � �FH ;Fij� BI B°±¶ <t CEt QR u ós8R :st CEt B9 T� =; SRTh QÜH ;<= 8

C?��Q6 u N< EQURM B±�

CVmLM ;<= R u= 4â6¶ EFmC M= BC D ]<=s8L : QR JX@{ 6>I eL Kf AO5�ä= aR �

C�Q6 u [6´FC? ÉQ6 �

CM= 8L : QL �

CVmLM ;<= N< \C VL:= \

C VL:= 4â6¶ E<;=Cai � [X t=OÍ9D SRTh L¼CVmLM B] �G{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! B9 T� =; SRTh R u= 4Íy=< =Fij SRTh g= Q� \ 6 M ;QU Áç= QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij

;<= N< 4®=FC D=86 ?FG SRTh {=Fij 9>ZQ56 7 B

C D ÑR�ÔK9M \ 6 M SRTU

C M [X ;<= [s ´;QL u 9WtQR Jy [X

c�À BI 4R u 4µßR� =Fij 4_ CS6 ? 8L : R u8K9M cQß

C D= [X 9WtQR Jy BC D @É=C8H=QR uQÜH Bkj@~

25

v;Q5i} [s ´;QL u SRTh g= BH =F? BI c·9J

C?= Q�9 M 4_ 9WQ»R �ÔK9M [X B

] D Q6¶ 4_ provoke oX B

C D QR JX@ ~�ULM oX [X c�À BI ] ´Fij[@{8Öh [

s ´;QL u 9WtQR Jy BC D 4µßR� QR JX 4_ 4R u

\wQR JI [s ´;QL u [X 4ÏCt v;=t SRTU

C M Bkj 4Þµ6 u 9>�F�¶ [X 4ÏCt ;=t Bkj ;<= �lL M <t B°ß�� B] D Fij 4_ v;Q5i} [

s ´;QL u [X c�À BI o6? BC D \ 6 M 4R u ÉO� QR uQ�

s M= ;<= N< �RJ6? QR JG ;<= \w= CEt �RJ6? {QR JG =aÓ<t 4_ 4®=F

C D=86 ?FG BI BH 8X É·�= tQ6 u�= 9u ÉQ59M B9 T� =;

SRTh EQU67 `È � ØR JH) CE( BX a9 �¹t SRTi� N< �5Ðh ;FÀ 8L : OCJ6: BC D Fij B��kj QL¶ Q9u 4_

\¡X `¡y [X provocation 4C u {Fij g= BI NtQR uC; ;QU Áç= ;<= eL Kf SRTU

C M Fij Q9J�� Q�9 M@{EQi �@~ 6>6? ;Fij� sW;F�R J

] :Qi � Q� 4µßR� QR u�= 4_ F6 ? CE= BX aR �Cõ \

C VRT]u�= ;<= aR �Cõ [

C ´FC DQ�

BÎ�H QY� SRTi� N< F9 D �6uQ� rF6 �y SRTUC M SRTi�@{ CS�R JH 8G= 4R u ØCu� L¿;Qh Bkj QL¶ N< PAT

[X Bkj QR u PTI [X Bkj N< CSRT]u�= ;<= CEF

C DQ� BX Ì8]:=t SRTh Fij F9 D g= [X 9W C;Q6¶= \

C VR:t B��kj QL¶{F9 D g= SRTh SRTh BC D ;F�6 D g= 6>Ç

C �� BX EFC D<t EF9 �ZQ56 7@~4ÞCuFR �X

<t CEt B°U±M 9u EFC D<t EF9 �ZQ56 7 [X c�À BI 9WC;Q6¶= 4ÏQCu SRTU

C M QR u�= {Q�9 M F9 D sW;F�R J

] :Qi � BX B°ß�� BC D \ 6 M vaR �Ï CS

p qR D C;FL D 8p:F� [X QR u 4R J�Q ÁY9�C:= [X CS

p qR D C;FL D 8p:F� [X ;<= vaR �Ï 4ÏCt v;=t \ 6 M \

9 M{ì} BC D EF

C D<t EFR �s :;QL u FX QUf 4_ 6>6? 9u LW�= CEFC DQ� ;<= B�ÎD QCd BX Ñ6DQY� 9>I=FC?;t SRTU

C M SR:t BG F9 D N=FC? LW�= E<;=Cai � SRTh SRT]u�= ì} É·�= tQ6 u�= SRTh �

C¶=t SRTUC M B

C D Fij SR:t BG{

14 C¼ RM;Q9u 9u EFmC M= BC D 4R u 9>I=FC?;t SRTU

C M vt@{4R u �ÄHQ6 u 9>I;t Bkj ;<= [s ´ v< SRTh =s86 : QR u�= ;<= SRTh B

C D 9>?QCd< BC D 8X [X po

p|FX [X ;<= \¡X BC D SRTU

C M \C VI@{F6 ? KPK gF°6¶ Bkj ;�= Bl

9 M F9 D ì} BC D CE= FX Q�<;@{R u= gF°6¶ <t ;=Cai � Q�

Q�9 M ;<= R u= [] ´Qìst ;= Cai � Q� Q�9 M ;<= ì} B

C D eL ? Bs �CT�½ [X<; {Q�f; R u= gF°6¶

KPK BX Chief Minister lead 8X Bkj ; Bl9 M CE= Q� gF°6¶ \ 6 M <t s;=[

] ´Qì

26

;=Cai � Q� {Q�9 M g= FX ;QL¶ Bs �CT�½ Ì<8s :F� 8L : X <;B Q�f; ;<= E<aÓ<t FX aR �

C� tQ6 u�= �Lu 8L : X <;B Q�f;{ KPK BX �R �L? as �

CTh g= 8L : CÆ=;QCu \ 6 M B] D Fij@ ~ÌaR �Ï 9>I<t

\ 6 M SRTi� 8Öh =;Q5i} �yF� 4R u Q�9 M 4_ ì} B

C D \ 6 M= 9u 9W C;Q6¶= SRTUC M vt@{ 6>6? 9u

LW�= 9W C;Q6¶= SRTUC M SRT® BG F9 D BG �= 9WQ6 u SRTU

C M B°±¶ {[G g= BX OÍ6 D 6>6? CE= BX B°¹ Q� BX ; Bl

9 M F9 D SRT5i} PTI [X c�À BI \ 6 M 9>I=FC?;t [

]�= ;<= PAT [X c�À BI \ 6 M 9>I=FC?;t [

]�={ PAT [X c�À

BI <8R : C; s>C �]:=FL D BX B��H 9>I=FC?;t \9 M~ PTI [X 9>I=FC?;t \

9 M aR �5p¡X [

] ´Qi � Ì< {8L : g= 8L : eL Kf security apprehensions \ 6 M SRT�

9 M ;<= ÆQC¶ ;FÀ 8L : R u= N;=t= Bkj F6 ? aR �5

p¡X [] ´Qi � Ì< BX e9 MQ� e9 MQ� Bkj ;<= EFmC M= B

C D tFC? 4Y6 DQCdQ6 u ;FÀ 8L : a] �RJ

CTRJI ì}= CSR:89: rFR �H 8L : QUf@ ~rQ¶a³6 M CE= Q� \ 6 M R u= 49J�Cu � Á�

CD Q�9 M{= g BX tF6 ?<Q6 u F6 ?PTI B

C D QUf Q�9 M g= BX Ñ6DQY� SRTUC M= aR �5

p¡X [] ´Qi � Ì< 8L :@ ~ CE= [X

9>I=FC?;t \ 6 M ÌaR �Ï gQL u Bkj ;<= 9W C;Q6¶= 4ÏQCu \ 6 M ÌaR �Ï gQL u {Bkj aR �5p¡X [

] ´Qi � Ì< 8L : EQU67 8L : EFmC M= B

C D QUf Q�9 M SRTUC M= ]<=s8L : B

C D 8X [X 9W C;Q6¶= Ìt vt ;<=PAT FX <8R : C; s>C �]:=FL D 8L : 4 °6¶ B

C D 8X [X 9W C;Q6¶= Ìt {vt OCJL? EFs �CT�½ BX OÍ6 D PAT [X R u= \] V

C: 9>I=FC?;t []�= � i} EQi �< SRTU

C M PTI BX e9 MQ� CEQ6 uQR JC?

vt;<a³w st<; N;QL J6:�= BI BG �=@~EQi �< ì}8L : QCu�= B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� ;<= ;F�6 D 8R: C;< 4µ C¶=t BlÎ�Å g= 8L : OR uO p� 9WQp�O C¶ Bl

9 M ;<= SRTh g= BX Ñ? SRTh �ÄHQ6 u SRTUC M {Q�9 M 4ÞCuFR �X v;Q5i}

g;F Bq�D < \ 6 M limited \9 M@ ~8Öh e9 MQ� e9 MQ� <t Bq°Î¶ EFij F9 D N< sOR u; CE< C; FX

security threat BX N<·P ;<= security threats BX N<·P@~8Öh �lL M 9>�F�¶ BC D 4R u 4µßR� QR JX ;<= NOCJ C? [

C ´Q p R TLu BI large heartedness BI 4_ st;QÄR D; 8L :

27

v;Q� CaR �L� \] VG�= SRTi� F9 D BC D 8X SR:t@{ì} B

C D CE= [X \] VC: 9>I=FC?;t BX Ñ6DQY� CE=

FX \ 6 M EQi �< BC D 8X [X 9W C;Q6¶= Ìt vt{

<t CEt ~OÍ6 D SRTh ö°CP Fij Q9J�� EFij R u= CEt BG �= ;<= Bl±�RVL:@ ~BlÎ�Å PTI [X c�À BI R u= ;<= 9>I=FC?;t [

]�= 4_ ì} BG �= QCu8X B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi�@ {F9 D ì} g= BX

B��H ;QR J9 : SRTU

C M Bl9 M@~4ÞCuFR �X CE�= st;QÄR D; Q�9 M@{�lL M BlÎ�Å CE=��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd [X c�À BI

R u= written []�= ;<= 4R u ÁÂQÃH= SRTi� You have my commitment that

we will not move forward from this position, ;<= SRT5i} BG �= 4µæ;Qh �suF� 9u ;<= SRTh B

C D CE= FX 6W=F6 ? SRTh Q�Ð® 4_ without a moments hesitation I will allow them whoever has

written. g= BX OÍ6 D F6 ? eL Kf =Fij SRTh g= [X �RJÇ²9D SRTh SRTU

C M QCuQ6¶ Q9J ijQL¶ ;<= 8C?��Q6 u 4R u Ì;Q� �FH sOR u; CE< C; 8L : B] �G �=@{ 9>�F�¶ [X B°�±�LM OCJL? EF

C Dt SRTh 4R u pop|FX

\ i}; Bkj 4_ 9W·hQÍ� FX \w= C;=OCu= BI F6 ? i} BC D B°U±M CEt BI QR uQCJL:= Q�9 M pgFC?

[6´F°�= BI �¶ QRJX B] D Q6¶@{g= SRTh 9>m6M Ì;Q� Û

] D=;Ct BI 9WQ6 u 9>R�L? [9 ´Fij \ i};@~

s>�Ru8]:=st \ 6 M [9 ´Fij \ i}; ;<=indirectly\ 6 M [

9 ´Fij i};\@{Ì;Q5i} EQURM 8L : \] VX �ÄR �sTRJHFL D

C;; sOR JH Bls V�T6u B

] D Fij SRTi�@~ CE= BX B��D ;Ct \ 6 M [9 ´Fij {\ i}; R u= c�À ì} B

C D ¼Cï=< ;FÀ

8L : 4R u 4Uf QR ut 4_ 6W= F6 ? [s ´;F�R JI Q� ;Qß? Bkj N< B°U±M oRT®FL D Q� Bkj N=FC? s>C �xRVH;QL u

ØCu sOµ6 u Bkj@~R MaL �� sW;FX Bkj@~4Þµ6 u F6 ? Foreign Missions SRTi� g= BI BH 8X sÒR:8s :8�R JI 9u B°U±M ;Qß? SRTh oRT®FL D Bkj@~g= BX OÍ6 D FC Bkj@~g= BX OÍ6 D

C;86 KCVR:; Bkj ;<= g= BX OÍ6 D 6¿F {Bkj F| v;Q5i} c�À BI R u= \ i} 9WQ6 u ¼

Cï=< ;FÀ 8L : [X \] VG 4_ g= BI BG �= QCu�= ;<= R MaL �� sW;FX SRTh C;<; g= BH =F? BI

28

C;C�� 6¼ 67 CEQ6 J?Qd BX ÁÂQÃH= SRTi� N< LW�= BX BC �� Q� SRTi� ;<= �yF� Q9u�= Bkj N< \ 6 M LW�= BX BC �� Q� {Bkj

9>�F�¶ \wQR JI B°h QÍ� SRTh ai � 9WQ6 u 9>R�L? B

C D 8X BX B��H ;QR J9 : Bkj ;<= g=

FX \¡X 9W;Fz SRTh \ 6 M \C VL:= QCu= Q� 4µ]Jq� SRTU

C M B] D QCJ6: {[G 8Öh g= BI BG �= SRT

]u�= BG F9 D �lL M CEQ9JqXQL u Banana Republic CS6 : QR JG@{ì} B

C D CE= FX ;Q6 u ;Q6 u 4R u \ 6 M ;<Q6 u B

C D =8X [X pop|FX [X 4_ g= BI BG �= QCu�= LW�= CE= [

s ´;F�R JI CaR � CT6�RM= FX

SRTUC M 6¿F FX R u= 9>m6M \ i} �Ä

pq� rQ�9M;Fz BI ;QL¶<t SR:8X {BG SRTh B

C D CE= FX 4R u QUf 4_ 6¿F BX gQL u F9 D = sOCust SRTU

C M Q9uFij~ anti-riot [] ´FX equipment

SRTUC M [

9 ´Fij@{8G= 4R u 8�t= BI BH 8X 8�t= 9u 4�·P 6¿F BX ;Qß? SRTh Bkj F9 D 6¿F Q� É=a9 ��= {SR:8X SRTh rQpJ� Ìt Qi �; EFij 4_ 8G= LW�= 4R u 6>I s;F9 D 8X 6¿F BX

BC �� = BC �� Q� 8X�= Ìs�lf Fij B] �G F9 D SRTh 49JI=FC KCM=FC? 4Uf Qi �; EFij 4_ 6¿F 49 JI=F

C KCM=O C¶

[HFG [9 ´·L¶ Bkj F9 D N< \ 6 M OR uQ p� ö°CP Fij Qæ QR u g= 8L : Ìs86 : r=F| SRT�

s M= BG{8G= EFmC M= B

C D LW�= FX 4C u Q�<; F9 D LW�= 6¿F FX R u= vs86 : �Äpq� rQ�

9M;Fz BI ;QL¶<t <8X BG{

F| 4R u 4µhQÍ� Q�L 7= Q9J°L¶ Qi �;@~ 9W=8X= COh \ 6 M B

] D Fij ;<= 6>I =Fij@~Q9 u 4ÞRJ9T�< 4_ Bl±7 =

B°�ÎM 9W=8X= COh B9 �°±¶ B] D Fij PAT BX N=86 :aÓ B

C D CuQL¶=@~N;Q6 u BÎ�6M Q� `] MQs u CSRTÍ

9�� Q�9 M CS�R JH EFmC M= B

C D 4s JCT�½ B°U±M 8X�= CE·P= 8X QR ut 4_ ì} BG �= SRT

]uQ6¶ BG@~ì} CSàX SRTCJmLM

BG@~Ì;Q5i} B��H SRT9utQUpw ;QR J

9 : SRTi� ;<= F6 ? eL Kf EFmC M= BC D QUf SRTh g= [X �RJÇ²

9D SRTh SRTU

C M QCuQ6¶ Q9J ijQL¶@{g= 9ÒÙ< 9u 9W=8X= COh SRTh 9>�F�¶ [X c�À BI lowest common denominator EF

C D<t sOR J] :Q� BI F6 ? QR ut QR JG Q�

9 M N< 4R u Q�9 M@~4R u ;QR J

9T C¶=

29

cab s>C �xRVH;QL u BC D SRTU

C M@ ~ÉQ59M \wQR JI CaR �su;QL u B

C D SRTUC M@ ~ CEQ9JqXQL u [X É=FZ B

C D QR ut Bkj@ ~ CEQ9JqXQL u BX CSR T

]u�= BC D QR ut Bkj 4_ 6>

C K9VCTh `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< QR u �\ÈP=8R : C;< Q� resignation Q� \¡X N<8G@ ~\¡X LW<8G QR u \¡X \ 6 M \wQR JI 9WFy BX ;< C; BX

B��D ;Ct BI �\àô9T�= QCJR:t This is out of the question, 4R u Fij \ i} SRTU

C M Q9J��@{g= BX N<·P ai � CaR �L� 8L : 9WQ6 u Fij \9 V�� Bkj@~EQi � OÍ6 D SRTh 4R u \ 6 M 9WQ6 u [X \] VG ;<= `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< 6>?Qd BC D meetings \ 6 M SRT_ ;<= g= Q� ;QU Áç= 8R : C;< ØCJC:·L u

R u= BI NtQR uC; 4Ít 8X B�±¶ SRTi� 4_ 8G= CS

p q�R JH= SRTh ~[HOCuQìt R MaL �� sW;FX Q� R u= CSp qR T5f@ ~R MaL �� sW;FX BI ós86 : 8X F9 D [

] ´FX N;=t= SRTUC M Bkj@ ~N< 9WQ»R �ÔK

9M 8X BX 4R u BÀ 8X BH 4_ massive,;<= directions Ìt Ìt 4_ massive

rigging [] ´Fij Bkj F9 D `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< v;Q5i} \C VL:= ØCJsTRJ� SRTh 4Uf B�±¶ SRTi� ;<= v;Oi�FL ?

6>?Qd g= Q� ;QU Áç= 8X B�±¶ SRTi� ;<= SRTh LW�= [X 9W C;Q6¶= BI s>C �xRVH;QL u SRTh QCJmf Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ LW�= [X 9W C;Q6¶= BI 4_ R u= `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< F9 D QR JX �lL M 6>I s>C �xRVH;QL u FX �l½ Ìs8L :QCuQ6¶ v;Q5i}{Qæ 9>�F�¶ �l½ \ÈL¶ B

] D Q6¶ 8G={[G CEQ9JqXQL u BX R MaL �� sW;FX Q� R u= CS

p qR T5f 4R u 4µßR� Q9u8X Bkj 4_ B°�±�LM CSp q�R JH= SRTh rigging[

] ´Fij `i}{Bkj R u= s>C �� SRTU

C M SRT]uQÜH {BGMassive rigging [

] ´Fij 8G=Bkj 4R u 4µßR� �lL M~B] D Q6¶Fij

F9 D [] ´FX C;=F6 ? \ i} SRTU

C M {Q9J ij; \w= BË�D �À BI R u= �R D= [

]�= ;�= stas � 6 ?; B

C D 8X BI LW�= \¡X FX SRTUC M 4Uf

B9 �� 4_ 4R u F9 D accusedBkjsorryÉ86 KÅ Bkj 4C u;< 4R u F

9 D R u= 6>R�6Kn 9ÒR:; B] D Q6¶s8L :

[G 4_ o6? FX \wQR JI ;FÀ 8L : QCuQsJ ij Bkj F9 D g= BX c·C¶ R u= aR �6Jx^½ `¡y [X �R D= [

]�= ;�= 6¿;t SRT

]u=8X 4R u F9 D CEQ��= CSR:8

9: 4»R D�À BC D =8L :{Bkj B

C D Qh C; SRTh 58(2-b)\ 6 M Q9uFij Q�9 M 4R u F

9 D g= BI \ 6 M CEQ��= \¡X{Bkj �\ÈP=8R : C;< FX QCuQsJ ij \¡X~Fij 8R : C;< FX

30

QCuQsJ ij \¡X~Fij `ÁîZ=8R : C;< FX QCuQsJ ij �R D={Fij [

]�= ;�= 6¿;t <t=<8X ;<= �lL M SRTUf 4_ �\àô

9T�= Ìt SR:t g= ¿�À QR J

C:t SRTh SRTUf SRTUC M �lL M{Q9uFij QR JX B

9 �mf SRTi� 4_ 4C u=t= C;�= ÑR�ÔK9M

SRTUC M ÌaR �Ï{[GFij [

] ´Q�6 M 8G= \w= ;<t SRTh R u= �R D= []�= ;�= `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< BI 8�R JH �\ÈP=8R : C;< ;<= \ÙQ¹< Ú=; C;< BX c·C¶ 6¿;t \ÐL¶Fij {Bkjone member[

] ´Qi � sW;FX BX CS

p qR T5f BC D 9>�F�¶ 9ÒÙ< BX c·C¶ B°ß�� B�D t R MaL ��{SRTi� sW;FX BX \] VX

B°ß�� 9>�F�¶ 9ÒÙ< BX c·C¶ B9 D �= Bkj ; 4R u{SRTi� F9 D LW�= 9>m6M 9>C Kw ¿<86 KÅ Bkj ;8X

SRTi� tQ59VZ= CEQ9JqXQL u [X �\ÈP= 4R JHOP R u={8L : c�À \êC M= BX B°ß�� 8L : B9 �mf 9ÒH=OP~SRTi� BC D 4µßR� QR ut8X 4_ �R D= [

]�= ;�= 6¿;t SR:8X F9 D F6 ? LW�= BX Ñ? SRTh Q9uQ6¶ Bkj N<

Q�s VRTh Q�s VRTh F6 ?~ L>ij CE= Q� 4µßR� LW�= BX c·C¶ Q9uQ6¶ Bkj N< =<s8X =<s8X {Fl9 M

RMaL �� sW;FX 4R u ;Q6 u ;Q6 u 4Uf \ i}; Bkj 4_ LW�= 4R u Constitution Avenue[HQ C¶ SR:8X F9 D g= BX B��H LW�= ;QR J

9 : SRTUC M R u={SRTi� [

] ´Qi � sW;FX Q� 4µßR� �R D= [

]�= Q�;�= LW�= BX Ñ? SRTh Q9uQ6¶ Bkj F9 D N< 9>�F�¶ rF6 �y [

9 ´8X LW�={Bkj B9 �mf SRTi� 4_ 4R u 9>m6M Q�L 7= 4µßR� Bkj F9 D g= Ì;Q� rF?Qh SRTh SRTh 8X�= 9WQ6 u g=

BH =F? BI EFH8X 4_ F6 ? ÌaR �Ï 9W=8X= COh B] D Fij PTI [X c�À BI eL ? 9WQ6 JHQY�

L¼CMQL u~Bl9 M 8L : ÝQ6 JR:�Ë

9D �5Ðh ×QÃ9D= QÄL ?Fij {Q�9 Melectoral reform, judicial commissionN< Ì;Q� \ÙQ6 u R u= F6 ? �\àô

9T�= BX BH =F? BI =;Q5i}{Q�9 M �yF� N< \ i} Q�9 M F6 ? SRTh B

C D CE=FR D= BX BC �� Q� poRTLu 4R u~QR JX F9 D \¡X BX B��H a9 �U6M SRTUC M

Bkj 4_ R u= 6>C K9VCTh `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< R u= [HOCuQìt BX 9WQh=C8H= 8L : ;<= CSp q�R JH= \ 6 M N< F6 ?

g= 9>�F�¶ BC D SRTU

C M N<{B] D =8X R u= \¡R D= 4R J�Q ÁY9�

C:= ;<= Bq�D = CSp q�R JH= CS

p qR T5f BC D

B] D =8X F6 ? g= 9ÒÙ< [X 9>�F�¶ ;<= CSRT

]u�= BX Ñ6DQY� F6 ? ÉQCu poRTLu Ì;Q5i}~B��X ÉQCu F9 D R u= \ 6 M g= SRTh SRTU

C M QR u�= care-takerR u={SRTh ÉQCu g= 9>�F�¶ F6 ? g=

31

9ÒÙ< CSp qR D C;FL D= SRTh \

9 M N< approve=Fij ;<= N< �R �L? CSp q�R JH= Q�9 MQ�aC �

p xf ;<= SRTh 4R u ;Q6 u ;Q6 u 4Uf QÄL ? EFij 4_ �R �L? CS

p q�R JH= aC � p xf Q� ÉQCu BlÎ�Å CE=��n CEQC¶ BC D QR ut ;<= \w=

FX 8�R JH `i} BC D CSRT

9u ÉQCu short listB��X ;<= [s ´;QL uC8°L JRTLu [X 9>�F�¶ B

C D g= 8L : ×QÃ9D= 8Öh{QR JX 8CK� CSR:O®= R V ij=86 := Q� ÉQCu O¶=< g= Ì;Q� set upSRTh R u= á

CKpw

Q�9 M F6 ? CSp qR D C;FL D= Q� NOCJ]:Q5

CM 8Öh{QR u�= CSp qR D C;FL D= Q� NOCJ]:Q5

CM \ 6 M CE=��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd BC D

propose{QR JX

vaÓ<t c�À PAT BX e9 MQ� \ 6 M B] D =F| �\ÈP=8R : C;< BX Bàô

9T�= BX 9WQ6 u BG �= \¾s86 : ;<= g= O¶ 9u BG �= \¾s86 : 4_ `i} B

C D QUf 4_ F6 ? LW�= Q� vtQR JCT6u

�yF� Bkj 4_ 4R u F6 ? 9WQ»R �ÔK9M [

C ´Fij N< LW�= BI �h 8X Ñ²9�� 8XFij R u= t= C;�=

[9 ´Q»R �ÔK

9M \s VRT5f Fij ;<= N< 9WQ»R �ÔK9M Ì8X ;<= g= 9WQ»R �ÔK

9M Q� 4µßR� 8G= Ì;Q5i} c·C¶ Q9uFij Bkj F9 D LW�= FX BC �mf [X 9W;<aC b SRTU

C M g={Bkj 8L : i} tFC? N< \ i} 4µßR� SR:8X BG F9 D 4R u 9W·hQÍ� BG �= ós86 : Bkj ; �lL M{Bl

9 M CSàX QCJCTULM í<ap Ó SR:a6 ��{B] �G Fij

QCutFlf í<ap Ó SRT]JGFij ;<= g= rF?Qh SRTh 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�!F6 ? ¯µh [X \

pwQÍ� rQ�9M;Fz

Bkj F6 ? C;<86 : C;<; [9 s8Ö6 u \ i};Q6¶ Bkj@ {4â 6¶ 4â6¶ ;=st 6>?Qd C;<; C;<; g= Q� 8XCt B

9 D 8X <t{SRTi� N=86 :aÓ 9>�µ5Å B

C D BC �±: = Ì;<t C¿FqCTh B�D t8X SRTi� N< LW�= BX BC �� Q�

QRJC:t{SRTi� SRTh F6 ? Ø6 ¶ [

] ´Q CTi� \ i};Fij {Bkj

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! SRTh 4R u ¼

Cï=< QCu8X EFijQ9J ijQL¶ 4_ 4R u people’s movement SRTUC M Bkj N< gt eX� BC �mf BH =< g= 9ÒÙ< \ 6 M ÌaR �Ï e9 MQ� SRT

]uQ6¶ N< �Äpq� BI

gt ;=Cai � CE={SRTi� SRTh ap �_= R u= LW<8G BX ÚQ6 J°º CE=~SRTi� BX C;8L KRVs : CE=~SRTi� BX

OR u�Å SRTi� F9 D gt eX� 8�O_ ;<= R u= ÆQC¶ ÆFÇC KÅ LW<8G BX gt ;<=~8�O_;=Cai �

32

N=FC KCV9 : ;=t É C;·h~ CSR:OR u�Å~F9 D~ CSR T

9u=FC?~B±�6M 8G= [] ´FX people’s movementQ9uFij F9 D

ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh 9>�F�¶ FX \ 6 M OR uQ p� [

] ´FX 4µßR� SRTUC M QCu8X 6>I{Q9us8L : 8�µh B9 �mf 4_

CE= Q� ~É=a9 ��=people’s movement, people’s opinionÉ=a9 ��=Q� SR:8X 4R u R u= N<8G 8Öh{Bkj \9 Vx¡yO6 u BI CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh g= BI Ìs86 : N<8G g= BI {NtQR u

C; )g= 4ÍyF� 8L : 4Íx67 CE=Ct�= [

] ´Fij(

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�: \67 v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP { CEQC¶

v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP CEQC¶:4R u8�p� 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�!g= Ì;Q� oLD � Á�C�� SRTh eL Kf N; QR JG

Bkj 8Öh SRTh g= BI NtQR uC; �RJÇ²

9D [X ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh 9W;<aC b SRTU

C M 9W=8X= COh{Bkj v;Q6¶ Bl

9 M ;<= Bl±7 = C;=OCu= BI �L¶ Bkj ; Bl9 M ;<= Bq�TÎ¶ SRTh B

C D QUf 4_ eL ? SRTh BI L¼

CMQL u PTI [X C8R :<Q6 �9M 8L : ÝQ6 JR:�Ë

9D ×QÃ9D= QÄL ?Fij Bs �l±7{Q�9 M 8L : 49JI=; pg·9u o6?{Q�9 MQi �;Q6¶QR JX 8L : vaÓ<t c=�À= 8L : \ 6 M CEQCJRT5ç= Q�9 M 4_ g= Q� [

] ´FX 49JI=; ;<= B] D Q6¶�QÄCD ;<= SRTh 4R u ¼

Cï=< QCu8X EFijQ9J ijQL¶ 4_ g= SRTh v;Q5i} [s ´;QL u Q� \ 6 M �yF�

8Öh{Q�9 M o6? �yF� 8L : `ÁîZ=8R : C;< EQURM 8L : \ 6 M 4Uf B�±¶ ai �Q6 u~SRTi� \ 6 M 4Uf B�±¶ SRTi�

;<= v;FL D s>C �xRVH;QL u 4Uf \ÐL¶ Bkj 4_ \¡X R u= N<8G BX BC �mf 8L : QR u g= BX ]<Q6 ut 8L : QR u g= BX ;< C; 8L : 6>

C K9VCTh `

ÁîZ=8R : C;< FX �\àô9T�= SRTU

C M v;FL D{Q9J��Q6¶QR ut ÉFy 4R u 4Uf \ i}; v;FL D~Bkj s>C �xRVH;QL u 4R u 4Uf \ i}; 4R JHOP~Bkj 4R u 4Uf \ i}; CEQ9JqXQL u~Bkj [X rF| \s V

]:Q�F| 4R u 4Uf \ i}; Bkj@~;<= �lL M F6 ? 6>I BI vs86 : 9WQ6 u Bkj 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! F6 ? 6>R�6Kn 9WQ6 u Bkj 4_ N< B9 �mf SRTi� 4_ =;Q� óOCJI~ÉQ ÁY

CD SRTh F9 D `È � ØR JH) CE( [X F9 D 9>�F�¶ \ i} SRTUC M CEQ9JqL ?F°6 u{Bkj SRTh `È � ØR JH) CE( [X 9>�F�¶ SRTU

C M N<{Bkj tFC? BX [L´ BX SRTh �\àô

9T�= BC ��: t BX B��H ;QR J9 : \ i} SRTU

C M SRTi� F9 D 4R u CJ9T_Q rFy �Í< SRTh tQCß

9 D Bkj

33

F9 D g= rF?Qh SRTh <t EFC Dt SRTh Ìs86 : Bl±7 = 9W=8X= COh �L¶ Bkj ; g={Bl

9 M rF?Qh SRTh 6>6? EFmC M= B

C D CSàX CSmLM 8X ;<= 9>m6M Ì;Q� ;<= 9WQh=C8H= EFmC M={8XQÜH BC D CE·P=

QR ut8X 4_ 6W= SRT9utQUpw EFij SRT÷ F9 D ;F�6 D R u= 4ÏCt ;=t 9>�F�¶ 4R u~BX v;Q5i} 4ÏCt

v;=t \9 M 4_ F6 ? �FH ai � 9W;Fz SRTh g= N=ai �Q p� FX CEFC? SRTh 9ÒH 9ÒL: QCu8X B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� BC �±: = `

] M=C�n [X BC �±: =~�ÀQ C¶ \wQR JI `] M=C�n [X ì}{�ÀQC¶ B

C D F6 ? 4»6 DQ� Nai �Q ÁY� QR JX Bkj a6 �d Q� ;<= 4ÏCt v;=t Q� ì} \w= FX BG �= 8�R JH SRTìs86 : BG{

;<= 6W= SRTh v8

C?�= ;<= 4R u CaR �L� SRTh ¼Cï=< QCu8X ì}{EFijQ9J ijQL¶ B

C D R MaL �� CE=F6 ?~ sW;FX BI v;Q5i} [

C ´<;OCu= 9WQ6 u 9>R�L? �L¶ \ i}; ì}{\9 M B

C D 4R u QUf 4_ 9>�F�¶ Q� SRTU

C M CSp qR D C;FL D= Q� R u= 4÷86 ? `

] MQ� B9 ��T®8X SRTi� ì} BC D CE= BI CS

p qR D C;FL D={QUf [X EF9 �ZQ56 7 Q� 4÷86 ? 4_Q9u CS6 ? Ìs86 : t<O�Å 9WQÄCD 8L : c·9J

C?= B] D =; Bkj N< [

s ´;QL u ;<= 9>�F�¶ SRTh ×QÃ9D= B

] D Q6¶Fij@{g= 8L : N< \Cï=; SRTUC M B

] D Fij{�lL M ì} BC D QUf 4_ Bl

s VX= R MaL �� sW;FX XF gQL u B9 �°±¶ SRTi� ;<= Bq�D = C86 K67 CS6 ? 8L : LW�= FX tQ59VZ= Bkj g= 8L : \ 6 M N< \Cï=; SRTU

C M B] D Fij@{ì} B

C D g= BI s>ij 8X 9WQ6 u [X 4_ LW�= SRT]uQ9J6: 4_

Q CDFX Q R D= CS

p qR T5f \¡CDFX \¡R D= \s VRT5f LW�= FX oX 8L : tQ59VZ= Bkj{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� ;Q6 u ;Q6 u g= c�À BI 9WQ6 u [

] ´�= 4_ SRT5i} 6¿F 8L : tQ59VZ= Bkj@{ì} cab 6¿F BX B��D ;Ct 9WQ6 u SR:8X BG@{ 6>6? R u= N<8G QR u R u= [

s ´;QL u QR u <t LW<8G 4R JHOP 8L : tQ59VZ= BI ;QÄCD= SR:t8X@ ~BC �±: = e9 MQ� F6 ? CE= BX s>C �xRVH;QL u SRThcolleagues 4Þµ6 u CS

p qR D C;FL D= SRTh F6 ?colleagues Bls V�T6u SRTi�@~F6 ? OR uQ p� \wQR JI FÀ

8L :; CE= BI ós86 : 8X Ì;Q5i} �HQC�Å EFij@ ~SRTh c·9JC?= B

] D =; [X 9WQ6 u Qi �;8X EFij@~[] ´FX [

9 ´=Ct 9>àHQC�Å [X 9WQ6 u SRTUC M Qi �;8X@ { CE= 8L : tQ59VZ= 4C u SR:8X@ ~Ú·�< 8L : tQ59VZ= 4C u

34

SR:8X@{ 6>°Y� N< \¡X LW<8G 8L : tQ59VZ= 4C u SR:8X F9 D �lL M 9>�F�¶ BX gQL u QR JX 49 JI=; N; Q9uQ6¶ Bkj@{R u= c�À ì} \

C VL:= [9 ´=Ct QCu= [X �RJÇ vs�lf B9 ��: t8X@~ì} \

C VL:= [9 ´=Ct QCu=

[X ;=FR Dt vs�lf B9 ��: t8X F9 D ì} B9 �mf 4_ 4R u 6>I aR �Cõ \

C VRT]u�= ;<= aR �Cõ [

C ´FC DQ� Bkj@{8Öh

BC �±: = [9 ´=Ct QCu= [X �RJÇ vs�lf B

C D 8X [X B] D Q6 �6M ì} B

C D R u= 49JI=; �QÄCD ;<= SRTh 4R u ¼Cï=< E<t8X 4_ ØCJsTRJ� F9 D v;Q5i} <ap �_= a9 � p R T6u [

9 ´Fij SRTi� 6¿F BI@{vt=�àCD= ;FÀ 8L :

\ 6 M [9 ´Fij SRTi�@~8R : C;< `

ÁîZ= 6>?Qd [X [GtF6 ?F� SRTh \ 6 M [9 ´Fij SRTi�@{N< vas �µh CS

p qR D8L :�= < EQi � Qi �;Fij Bkj g= BH =F? BI \ 6 M \ i};Fij SRTi� ;<= g= BH =F? BI g= B] �H \ i};Fij SRTi�{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� 4_ F6 ? last line Bkj 6¿F Bkj{ sOR u; CE< C; R u=BX B

C D FX BI 8�R JH ÌaÓ<t B

C D FX 9u F6 ? last line Bkj N< 6¿F Bkj@{F9 D v;Q5i} ;F�6 D 9>�F�¶ pop|FX \

9 M 4_ ì} 6¿F FX CEQ�9V�= SRTh 4C u SRT®=st@{ pgQ� 4R u 46 uCO6¶ F6 ? B9 �mf SRTi� 4_ SRT5i}

6¿F 8L : tQ59VZ= Bkj@{ pgQ� 4R u 46 uCO6¶ vaÓ<t c�À \ 6 M tF6 ?F� Q9uFij@{N< F9 D ;Q6 u ;Q6 u 6¿F

FX rQ5�9T�= Bkj ;8X SRTi�@ {8G= CE= BX rt SRTh 46 u

CO6¶ Q9uFij F9 D 6¿�= 4R u 6¿F EQURM 4C u [9 ´Fij@{ 6¿�= 4R u 6¿F e9 M;QCu CEQ9JI8R : C;< SRTh [

9 ´Fij@~v;Q5i} E<O¶aÓ 8L : [9 ´Fij@{8Öh R u= c�À

EFmC M= BC D 6¿F Q� ÉQCu rQ5�

9T�= QR JX@{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� SRTh 4R u v;FL D 4ÏCt v;=t BI Q9Jmf EFij 4ÞCuFR �X =aR �Ïinternal security BX BH =F? BI vas �µh CS

p qR D8L :�= BX BH =F? BI@ ~g= BI B°U±Mdialogue BX BH =F? BI 9>m6M v;Q� C8ÖCJ

sTRJ� `] M=8L : as �

CTh [X v;F Á�C�� BI [

9 ´Fij SRTi�@{�R �L? c�= \Å;�= cQsJI BX rFR �H 8L : \ 6 M [9 ´Fij SRTi� ;<= B±�RV

C: rFR �H 8L : \ 6 M ÝQ6 JR:�Ë

9D Q59M É hierarchy BI [

9 ´Fij SRTi�@{Bq�TÎ¶ SRTh BC D oRD8L : FX \ 6 M

QUf 4_ 4R u [] ´FX a6 �

C� SRTUC M Bkj@ {4R u institutional ÉQ� Q9uFij Bkj@ {SRTh LW�= FX

Ì;FL D ×Fp D< BI ;<= 4R u SRTh BC D oRD8L : o

CD�àCDQ� SRTh \ 6 M QUf 4_ g= SRTh 6¿F [X

35

4C u [] ´FX poij=FC? \

9 M r<; =t= BC D 8X [X@{4C u EFmC M= B

C D [] ´FX R u= 49J�Cu Q R D= QR uQ�

s M= o6? BI [

] ´FX Q R D= 8p:Q9 u QR u�= Fij@~o6? ¿�À QR usOR J� SRTh Q9u�= Bkj aR �

Cõ v;Fm�67@{F9 D N< aR �Cõ

v;Fm�67 QR u aR �Cõ \

C VRT]u�= F6 ? SRT9uQ6 u \ i};Fij SRTi� N< CE= N<8G BX BH =F? BI \ i};Fij SRTi�

F6 ? 6¿F FX pWF°h QCu8X B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� CE= v;Q� E<CaR �L� SRTh@{F9 D 6>6? g= O¶ 9u ÚQU9 VC:=

\L�CVmLM ;<= vaÓ<t c�À QUf QR JG 4_ 9>�F�¶ F6 ? \Cï�Å Ì8X@~ì} B

C D EQURM SRT9utQUpw QR u

SRTp�� [

C ´=8G SRTi�@{F9 D 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� g= 8L : EF|8L : N;Fp q� =Fij ;<= i} BC D QL¶F| 4_ g=

O¶ 9u v;Q6 ut86 : BI B°ß�� B] D Fij SRTi�@~ì} ORuC�Å rQ�

9M;Fz FX aR �6Jx^½ 4C u SR:8X ;<= F6 ? N< B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� g= BX BI BH =F? [

] ´FX 4�]M� �5n SRT

]uQCJ6: F9 D �� [X ØCJsTRJ� BX BI BH =F? SRTh R u= 4Ít �lL M 4R u ¼

Cï=< QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ 4C u 6¿F [X c�À BI \¡X `¡y [X poij=FC? [

]�= QR u N;Fp q� QR u�= QR u \p VHQpu [X [

] ´FX po�p R TLu [

] ´Fij{ SRTh 4R u \ 6 M ¼

Cï=< E<t8X 4_ �� [X ØCJsTRJ� BX BH =F? BI ;<= g= BH =F? BI F6 ? \ 6 M 4µßR� =Fij SRTh g= [X 9>?QCd< Q9u8X EFij@{4R u CE= [X R u= [

9 ´QÄCD poij=FC? \9 M F6 ? ÌaÓ<t <t N<8G SRTi� 4_ ì} cab 6¿F BX B��D ;Ct 9WQ6 u SR:8X BG QR u

6¿F BX B] D Q� SRTh 9WQ6 u SR:8X BG F9 D 4R u SRTh ¼

Cï=< E<t8X 4_ �� [X ØCJsTRJ� 4C u [9 ´Fij ;<= 4R u F6 ?directions 6¿F FX 4C u B

9 D Q6¶ F9 D 6¿F [X �lL M \ 6 M 4ÏCt v;=t \9 M

4ÞCuFR �X 6¿F EQURM tF6 ?F� Bkj@{v;Q5i} oRT®FL D 4R J�Q ÁY9�C:=@ ~4ÞCuFL ? oRT®FL D tF6 ?F� Bkj@ ~oRT®FL D

interact [9 ´8X Bkj PTI BI \ 6 M ;<= PAT BI \ 6 M@ {v;Q5i} �

p R TLJI L¼CM=86 :

[s ´;FR ��R JI BX BH =F? BI \ 6 M ;<= BG �= \ 6 M 6>6? [

] ´FXthreat [9 ´Fij Bkj N< B9 �mf

SRTi� 4_ i} g= 8L : react SR:8X BG@{45Ð�Å 4µ C¶=t CE= BI interact [9 ´8X Bkj@{

6¿F [X EQURM [GtF6 ?F� ;<= 4R u 6¿F 9>�F�¶ Q� 4ß? [9 ´Fij Bkj 8Öh 4R u `È � ØR JH) CE(

[X 6¿F SRTUC M Bkj@{g= BH =F? BI 4C u 4R u PAT [X 6¿F Bkj 4C u PTI [X 6¿F

36

Bkj@{4R u CEQ9JqXQL u [X \ÅFy 6¿F Bkj@{;<= 6¿�= 4R u e9 M;QCu CEQ9JI8R : C;< SRTh SRTUC M Bkj EQURM

É·�= tQ6 u�= BX \Èæ EFL ?FX Q� Áö²K9M B

C D 8X B] �H BX vs�lf Bkj@{g= ÉQ»� 8L : CE= FH EFG B

C D CE= FX QR uQL �CVmLM Bkj@{ 6¿F FX g= SRTh pWF°h B

C D 8X QR u R u= r<; =t= BC D 8X

QR u 9WQ6 u 9>R�L? SRThfacilitatorQ� r<; =t= BC D 8X Q� CE= Q� 46 JHQY� Bkj@ {F9 D 9>�F�¶

Bq�TÎ¶ SRTh BC D QUf 4_ \

C VL:= [9 ´=Ct \ 6 M SR: s;FlL 7@~ CEF

C DQ� ;<= CSRT]u�=@~8Öh CEF

C DQ� ;<= CSRT]u�= BI

[] ´FX Ú=a6 �Ï 9WQ6 u SRTU

C M [X \] VG@{;<= g= BH =F? BI F6 ? �� ØCJsTRJ� [] ´Fij@~g= SRTh

9>�F�¶ BC D 4R u 4µßR� QR JX 4_ LW�= tF6 ?F� SRTi�@{ LW�= ;<aC binteract SR:8X CE= BI 4_

N< QR JX B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi�{8G= N< ;<= \¡X BI 9WQ6 u SRTUC M B9 �kj QL¶QCu8X F9 D 6¿F 9W=8X= COh SRTU

C M \ i};8X@{4R u \ 6 M 4µßR� =Fij 4_ 6¿F background SRTh Bkj ; [G ;<= 4R u 6¿F Q� QCJL:= 4µßR� Q�9 M{background SRTh N; 8X@ ~SRTh 4R u \ 6 M ¼

Cï=< E<t8X 4_ 4ÞCuFL ? �� BlÎ�Å 9W=; FX ;Fij� QCuQ6¶ =s8L :@{SRTh B

C D [s ´ v< 8L : SRTU

C M Q�ÐR ut CS�R JH BlÎ�Å 9WQ6 u [] ´QL �CVmLM \] VG

4_ EQURM QUf QR JG 4_ R u= [s ´;QL u ; sOR JH B

C D QUf Bkj 4_ BlÎ�Å 6¿F [X c�À BI =<·6 u QR u�= Bkj@~�R �L? c�= \Å;�= QsJI c [X c�À BI =<·6 u QR u�= Bkj~F

9 D 4R u �ÄHQ6 u ö°CP Bkj@{SRTh 9WQ6 u BX 8X QR u�= EFij 4R u CE= EF

C D<t EFR �s :;QL u [X 9>I=FC?;t 8L : �R �L? c�= \Å;�= QsJI c [X ØCJsTRJ� [

] ´Fij ;<= SRTh 4R u \ 6 M ¼Cï=< E<t8X 4_ `i} ;Fij� SRTh Bl

9 M R u= 4�9MQ¹ [

C ´=FC? BX B° °� SRTh@~R u= a] �CJRT� CSR:89: a RT¹�= Q� BlÎ�Å CEF QR u�= ;<= 4R u QUf QR JG 4_

4R u 9>I=FC?;t []�= Bkj `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd BI g= [X 9W C;Q6¶= B��kj QL¶@ {`

] M=8L : as � CTh

6>?Qd BC D QUf 4_ �ÄHQ6 u LW�= SRTµh@ {EFmC M= B

C D 9>I=FC?;t [X 4_ N< EFC D<t QCJ°h

B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi�@{BC D Q6¶ BI B°U±M ;<= B

C D Q6¶ BX OÍ6 D g= FX o6? C;=OCu= BI poRTLu QR JX QR JG@~4R u SRTh LW�= 8L : Q9u s;FlL 7 EFij ;<= v;FL D ÉFy 8L : Q9u s;FlL 7 EFij 4_ 4R u �FH 6¿F BX e9 MQ� \¡X `¡y Q�interaction 9WQ�·h@ ~ 9>�F�¶ BX e9 MQ� 9WQ6 u 9>R�L? FX oX ¿�À BI

rQ5�9T�= Bkj ;8X SRTi�@ {4R u SRTh LW�= 8L : Q9u s;FlL 7 EFij@{EQi � 4R u �� 4µßR� =Fij 4_ N< 4R u

37

B9 �lÎ��w SRTi� 4_ RMaL �� sW;FX 8L : \ 6 M tQ59VZ= SRTUC M Bkj@ {SRT5i} s>C �xRVH;QL u 8L : tQ59VZ=

SRTUC M Bkj@ {SRT5i} CS

p qR D C;FL D= EFR �s :;QL u 8L : \ 6 M tQ59VZ= SRTUC M Bkj@ {SRT5i} CS

p q�R JH= CSp qR T5f 8L :

tQ59VZ= SRTUC M Bkj@{SRT5i}election tribunals 8L : tQ59VZ= SRTU

C M Bkj{SRT5i} \¡X \C VRT]u�=

;<= [C ´FC DQ� Ì;=t= 8L : tQ59VZ= SRTU

C M Bkj@{`i} CE= BX B��D ;Ct 9WQ6 u SR:8X BG F9 D CE= BX B��D ;Ct 9WQ6 u SRTU

C M [GFij g= SRTh condition ¼Cï=< Bkj@{g= 8L : 9WQ6 u 9>R�L?

�lL M \ 6 M 9>�F�¶ [X ;<= CSp qR D C;FL D= [X [GFij ;<= SRTh 4Íx67 BX OÍ6 D@ ~SRTh tFC? 9W;<Q p �

E<8X Qæ{

9W=8X= COh @ B] ��T®@ BX\9 V�F�¶ F6 ? dialogue [X RVs : Bkj ×Q�w= ;=st 6>?Qd g=

FXlead Bkj ;8X SRTi� ;<= <t BÎ�6M R u= [s ´;QL u BX e9 MQ� Bkj ;QL¶ BÎ�6M vaÓ<t BX

e9 MQ�@ { 9W=8X= COh EFC D<t c=�À= BI BÖCu Fij ;<= N< \wQR JI BÖCu Fij ;<= SRTh g= c�À

Bls V�T6u colleagues FX \ 6 M CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij ;<= g= c�À Bl

s V�T6ucolleagues FX \ 6 M CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij ;<= v;FL D ÉFy FX CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij ;<= F6 ? SRTU

C M B9 �CT� CE= FX

\ 6 M CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij 4_ 4R u 9W=8X= COh g= Resolution [X \C V pI<; SRTh BÖCu Fij F6 ?

g= CE=FR D= BC D gQL u QR JX Bkj@{g= SRTh [

] ´FX ¯p� < 46 JpI SRTU

C M QCuFij B��kj QL¶@{SRTh g= ÛyF� 8L : 4R u8�

p� =t= QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij ;<= ÌaR �Ï rQR JC? SRTh 4R u CEQ9JqXQL u SRThpolitical

and democratic maturityQ� 46 �RV9TCu Bkj 4_ 6¿�= OR uQ p� PTI ;<= PAT BI

ós86 : 8X SRT9JZQ56 7 g= c�À \

s VRT6u SRTi�@ ~F6 ? 9>�F�¶ BI v;Fm�67 ;<= \wQR JI c·9JC?=

B] D =; \9 Vlf; EFij@{N< PTI BI \ 6 M NtQR u

C; OR uO p�~ PAT BI NtQR uC; OR uO p�@{8Öh R u=

v;Fm�67 Q»6 D [X �ÀQ C¶ s>C �xRVH;QL u [X v;=O�QL u BX B] �H ;<= g= ¯µh SRTh �ÜC�6? BX

CEFC DQ� FX BC �X <; BX B] �H =aR �Ï rQR J

C? Bkj 4_ g= Resolution BX 9>K9M F6 ?

�5Ðh ×QÃ9D= B] D =; =Fij Bkj 4R u CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh R u= \

C �RM;Q9u 4Íy=< Bkj ;<= =aR �Ï rQR JC? Bkj

38

4_ R u= message ·L¶ QR JG Bkj@ {QR JC:t SRTh message ·L¶ Bkj QR JG 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u

�d=Q� Na³L7 QR JX Bkj N< SRTUC M F6 ? OCJL? EFGFH B

C D EQi �< Constitution Avenue 4L u QR uQCJ6: =Fij Bkj �d= Na³L7 CEQ9JqXQL u Q� 4R u Resolution Bkj F6 ? g=

CE=FR D= SRTh \wQR JI 9>àHQC�Å FX B] D �Q6 u ×Qº eX; 8X 9>�F�¶ BX Ñ? SRTh SRTU

C M v;Fm�67 ÉQ ÁYCD BX Ñ? SRTh QR ut Bkj F

9 D SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij ;<= SRTh 6>I FX CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij F6 ? CSRT»R D SRTU

C M \ 6 M QCJlf; B9 �kj QL¶ g= CE=FR D= BI ai �Q6 u 4_ 9>�F�¶ 9W=8X= COh SRTh R u= L¼CM=

\ 6 M g= resolution BI Bl±�RVL: SRTUC M Bs �kj [G ÚQ p

CD= =@{A4R u 9ÒC :Qh= Bkj g= CE=FR D=

[X{4R u \ 6 M= 9ÒC :Qh= Bkj ;<= 6¿�= BI =F| rQ� B°U±M 4_ 9>�F�¶ FX F6 ? 6>

C K9VCTh QR JX QR JG

{Q�9 M CEQ9JqXQL u [X 6¿F \C VRT]u�= ;<= [

C ´FC DQ� Ì8]:=t SRTh N; BX ÉQ� 8X \ i}; {SRTi�

NtF6 ?F� \Å;�= �R �L? 4ÞCuFL ? `

] M=8L : as � CTh 6>?Qd BX e9 MQ� \ 6 M ;<= \] VX 4Ít CE=

[X 9W C;Q6¶= BI vaR �Ï \C VL:= 4R u internal security Bkj SRT

9uQ�·h [9 ´Fij \9 V ij;

SRTi�{SRTh 4R u ¼Cï=< ;FÀ 8L : QCJmf Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ EFmC M= B

C D eL ? BC ��TUÅ SRTh@~g= BI B°U±M F6 ? 4»6 DQ� �R �L? Bl

9 M i} g= 9ÒÙ< 9>�F�¶ SRTh SRTUC M Bl

9 M ;<= NtF6 ?F� �R �L? N< 6¿F FX �5Ðh apolitical EFmC M= B

C D Q�f; Bkj ;<= apolitical QCJlf; B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi�@{¯µh FX g= aR �6Jx^½ 9W;Fz rQ¶ BI BC �H QÄCD BX B] �H 4R u ·ULM ÛyF� SRTU

C M Bkj 4R u ·ULM ÛyF� SRTUC M Bkj 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�@{SRTh g= 4L u QCuQ6¶ SRTU

C M Q9J ijQL¶{ 1977Ú BI BH 8X 6¿�= 9u 6¿F B

C D 9>�F�¶ 9ÒÙ< QR u CSp qR D C;FL D= BX BC �mf 4L u 9W�Q¶ FX = sOCJl

s M 8X BC D track 4L u

BC �H =st BX B] �H ;=t8X =t= QR JX Bkj@{ CSRT9u ;QL¶ Ûy=F�Bq�D = \ 6 M B

] D Fij SRTi� 6>6? CSRT]u�= ;<=

CEFC DQ� BI s>ij BX ÉQ� QR JX QR JG Bkj N< �

p�;Qh Ú� Q�9 M g= BH =F?BX BI F9 D v;FL D ÉFy Ñ²

9�� Bkj 4_ N< 4µßR� aR �Cõ \

C VRT]u�= Bkj 8Öh \] VX Ûy=F� 4L u EQU67 \wQR JI temperature 8L :<= ·L¶ QR JG 6¿=F= B

C D 9W·hQÍ� FX sOCJls M = QR JX~4R u F6 ? po

]DQ6 �CVG vt

39

][G Bkj 6¿F FX F6 ? space vt \] VG Bkj F6 ? directions vt ][G SRTi� N< �5Ðh ;FÀ 8L : CSRT

]u�= ;<= CEFC DQ� BX@ ~SRTh LW�= FX CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij N< CSRT

]u�= ;<= CEFC DQ� BX

Ñ6DQY� SRTi�@ {F| SRTh g= BH =F? BI R u= 4Ít �lL M LW�= FX CSRT»R D Q9u�t EFij 4_ 9>�F�¶ [

] ´FX Q R D= ÉQ� SRTUC M Ì8X [G F6 ? CSRT

]u�= ;<= CEFC DQ� BX �HQC�Å Fij 49 JI=F

C KCM=O C¶

QR u g= FX =;Ct \ 6 M 6WaC b \9 VLK

CVmLM Fij CEQ9JqXQL u [X 6¿=F= �ÄHQ6 u apolitical SRTi� ;<= N< \w= Ì8]:=t BX ;OCu= ÉQ� 8X \ i}; SRTi� ;<= 4R u F6 ? �� Q� 4µßR� Bkj 4R u \ 6 M

CSRT]u�= ;<= CEF

C DQ� BX Ì8]:=t SRTh QæFij under 245 g= 9ÒÙ< 6¿F red zone BX ;OCu= Bkj \

C VL:= [s ´;F�R JI a9 �U6M B

C D 8X BX B] �H red zone [X [s ´;F�R JI a9 �U6M

BC D 8X BX B] �H R MaL �� sW;FX BX B°ß�� [X v;=O�QL u BX B] �H F6 ? interaction QR u facilitation N< 8X \ i}; Bkj N< ÝQ9JÇHQ C¶ CE= <t CaR �su;QL u [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u Bkj

9>�F�¶ BC D g= facilitation [X 9WC;Q6¶= vt Bkj g= FX g= BI NtQR u

C; 4C u Q�6 ��w B] D Q6¶ 4Þµ6 u g= FX support QR JX B

] D Q6¶ SRTh LW�= 6>I Q� 9>m6M NtQR uC; ;F� p � EFij{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : \67 OR JI ORJ

pI;FC? NQ p� 6>?Qd ; sOR JH c�= vt CSp qR D C;FL D=@ {NQ p�

6>?Qd R u= BÎ�6M 9>ZQ56 7 vs�lf Fij B] D Q6¶ [G{

O]uQ� 6WC8? c·9J

C?= )O�R JI OR JpI;FC? O57= NQ p�:( 4R u8�

p� as � � 8�R JLT�! BlÎ�Å gQ ?= Bkj 4_ C;Q5

CM Q� 9ÒÙ< Bkj SRTh \C VL:= OCJL? 9WQp�;=C8G OCJL? aù9�

CKÅ SRT9J?QCd< QCJR:t \ 6 M

Q9J ijQL¶ EFij F6 ? SRT9J?QCd< [X RT

]JGS g= 8L : 9WQ6 u \ 6 M QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ {EFij BlÎ�Å =@ A[X 9W=Ct 4L u QCJ9 := CSRT»R D Bkj QCJ9T 6¶ ai � CEQ

CD= ;<= CEQ5È � FX {Bkj F6 ? \ 6 M Statement vt \] VG Bkj 4_ g= g<Qi � SRTh F6 ? Resolution gQL u QR JX ~QR JG ÚQ p

CD= =@ A4R u 9>�F�¶~4R u CE=FR D= g= 8L : `

] MQ� SRTi�; BG \w= spirit BX {e9 MQ� 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! \C V9T 6¶

40

\ 6 M political parties g= CEQ9JqXQL u [X C¼ RM;Q9u ~SRTh SRTh Q9Jmf EFij \ÈULM 46 J9:�Å Q R D=

ÛyF� QR u�= Bkj o6? SRTh 4R u QUf QR JG v;Q� EFR �s :;QL u BC D 4_ `i} CEQ9JqXQL u BX CSRT

]u�= CEQ9JqXQL u [X 9ÒR:;Fm�67 ;<= g= s>C �xRVH;QL u BX e9 MQ� 4 R T� [

] ´·L u ;=FR Dt [X ¿�À Ìs�lf EFij {BG 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! F6 ? \ 6 M NtFL ? 9>qG= BI 6¿�= 9u 9WQÍy=< B

] D Fij SRTi� CSp qR D C;FL D= [X \

C V9T 6¶ \ 6 M SRT9JZQ56 7 SRTi� QR u g= s>C �xRVH;QL u BX ;OCu= \

C V9T 6¶ \ 6 M vas �CJRT5R VH;QL u CaR �su;QL u SRTi� 9>�F�¶ BI Ø®= \

C VL:= 9ÒR:;Fm�67~g= ~ s>C �xRVH;QL u g= CSR T]u�= [X 9>R�xäQ�

BX B] �H oLD�= SRTh \9 V°h \ i}; SRTi� 8Öh F6 ? �� BI R u= impressionQR u�= O6 u \9 Vx¡y Bkj Interior MinisterB

C D g= CaR �L� [X 9>?QCd< [X Bkj F9 D SRTh OR uC�Å p>K6M BC D 8X BX B

] D Q6 �6M cab QCJ9:= QCJmf Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ CEQ9JqXQL u BX oRT6u s;<8X É=FZ BX CSijCt BI 4R u e6 ?F6 D [

C ´Q6 ua³Å BX 8X ;Q9u= tSR: F6 ? <t CSRTCuFR D �

CDFX BX �suFs D �FH EQURM ai �Q6 u 9ÒR:;Fm�67 FX ;<= CSRT

]u�= rQ5Cn8R :FX QCJ6: 8X Bl

s V�T6u B] D Fij SRTi� 4_ ISPR[X c�À

BI 4R u 9>?QCd< F9 DB] D Q6¶�= CE= democraticBX ;=ta6 �5ÈP F6 ? 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX ÉQCu 4L u

vt8Ö9Jpqijt Q� �RJlf �RJlf Bkj ; SRTi� CE= [X 9>?QCd< B

] D Q6¶�= 4_ CE= [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u 4ÞCuFR �X SRT5i} \L�w 9WQ6 u Bkj 9W=; BI CEQ5R M= v;=t [X 9WQ6 u 4_Bkj SR T5i} BC �

9TÎ¶ \ 6 M democraticSRTi� CE= FX OCJRTCu SRTU

C M {[]�=

Ì;Q5i} eL Kf CEaR �sJ

CT5R VH;QL u B] D <; SRTi� 4_ 4R u QR JX QR JGFij 4_ 8R : C;< `

ÁîZ= BC D

Chief of the Army Staff FX 4Uf QR ut 4_ vaR �Ï \p VHQpu {]<=<8X \C V9:=

misunderstanding=OR JL: BC D 8X [X po

p|FX [X {\] VG 6¿F Q� N;=t= Ì;Q5i} B] �H 9>m6M �6uQ� É=a9 ��= ~Bkj 4R u N< N;=t= Bkj F6 ? g= ¯µh [X E<O¶aÓ [X 9> ÁÀQÃ? Q9u8X Bkj ;<= CSRT

]u�= BX Ì8]:=t SRTh B9 �kj ; B] D Fij civil forces[X tOh \ 6 M Q9u8X Bkj ;<=

245BX 9>K9M LW�= B

C D CE= FX QR u·6 u \ 6 M Bkj 8Öh 4R u F6 ?8p:Q9 u \ 6 M= Interior

41

MinisterBC D

C VL:=\ 8R :�Ë9D SRTh g= [X 9>?QCd< [X 4_Bkj CE= [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u CE=

[X 9WQ�·h [] ´Fij Bkj F9 D =;=O C¶ g= 8p:Q9u FX Û

] DQCd SR:8X ;<= QR uQ9J6: B] D Q6¶ 4_ 4R u CE= [X

9>I=FC?;t 4L u =Fij Bkj F9 D CE= Q� CEQ9JqXQL u BX oRT6u s;<8X É=FZ BX BC �� Q� Na³L7 ¼

Cï=< B] D Q6¶Fij 4_ N< s>C �xRVH;QL u ;<= CSRT

]u�= [X \9 VIt�Q6 u SRTUC M B9 �kj QL¶ N< 9ÒR:;Fm�67 SRTU

C M B9 �kj QL¶ SRTh OR uC�Å 8R :�Ë

9D OÍ6 D SRTh E<8X Qæ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! SRTh g= O¶ 9u \ 6 M BG �= QCuQ6¶ Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 4_ i} democraticSRTi� ì} Ìs;FX Q�f BX 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX B] �H EQURM B±�

CVmLM SRTi� ì} 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX B] �H 9>C K

9M ;=t 4L u \ 6 M ós8L ? BX EQURM B±�CVmLM SRTi� ì} B

C D \C VL:= R V

Á�Z ; sOR JH FX@~aR �ÁYC�RT6u Fs �l6 M ; sOR JH FX g= RV

Á�Z ; sOR JH FX ì} BC D Flf 8X 9ÒR:;Fm�67

FX QL �6M QR u 8G=Bkj 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX ÉQCu 4L u 4R u �FHchallenge8X B9 D SRTi� SRTh EQR J�

6>?Qd EFmf Qæ LW�= sWst SRT]uQ6¶ ;<= [

] ´FX 9WQ6 u SRTUC M [

C ´Fij B] ��Tk�QL¶ 9ÒR:;Fm�67 ;<= CSRT]u�=

4L u ÌtF| v C;Q6 u 4C u SR:8X 8G= N< B9 D �= SRTi� LW�= B9 �lÎ��w SRTi� 4_ ÉFÇô� B±�6M F6 ?

ÌaR �Ï B±�6M ~SRTi� 4R u SRT]uQh CS6 ? FX QR uQÄm6M QR JG ÌaR �ÏBkj QCuQCu BX CSR:t BX ÉQCu 4L u

QR uQÄm6M QR JG Bkj CE= ~FX [s ´Fl6 7 SRT

9uQ6 u BX 8X QR uQÄm6M Q9uQ6¶ {Bkj 9ÒR:;Fm�67 BX ÉQCu 4L u [s ´Fl6 7 QCu= BX ÉQCu 4L u QR uQÄm6M QR JG Bkj LW�= 4C u SRT

]u·L¶ CE= BX 8L :<= ~[HFG 4C u CE= FX �9Jy SR:8X B

C D �= SR:t QCu·6¶ B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� ·6¶ SR:t s>C �xRVH;QL u FX QCu·6¶ B9 �kj QL¶ É·�= tQ6 u�= FX ·6¶ SR:t ;<= CE= FX CEQ9JqXQL u BX \Èæ EFL ?FX SRTh Q9uQ6¶ Bkj@{4R u CEQ9JqXQL u [X É=FZ@~N<

É=FZ Bkj CS6 ? BX EFG;C86 : BC D CEQ9JqXQL u BC �

CTÎu BX B] �H QCJL:= CEFC? QR ut Q�9 M@~\

C VL:= SRTCuQ6¶

vt SRT�9 M{ 6¿F g= 9ÒÙ< SRTU

C M \9 M@~4C u 4R u QR u

sOR J� ~Q�9 M 4C u sÒC :8L : QR u

sOR J� Q�9 M@~8Öh Ì;Q5i} EFG;C86 : B

C D 4R u CEQ9JqXQL u QR uQCJ6:@{ì} vCt ;Fô pI ÉFy SRTi�@{ì} BC D s8H s8H BX g= ¯µh

SRTh 9ÒR:;Fm�67 `] MQ� [

] ´=<8X Bkj{F9 D SRTh 4R u EFmf Qæ LW�= BI 4_ 6¿�= \ i} []�= oRD=

[L´ ;�= [X c�À BI 9WQ6 u ¼Cï=< Fij B

] D Q6¶ 4_ CE= [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u N< B] �G SRTi�@{ L¼

CMQL u s>C �� BX ;OCu= B9 �G Q�6 M B9 �G Q�6 M@~o

CDQ� [HFlL M [] ´Fij@~EQi �< L¼

CVmLM B] �G@{SRTh Q9Jmf EFij 4_ g=

42

Q� v;Fm�67 �¶ \êRM Bkj \C VRT]u�= �¶ \êRM Bkj 4_ ì} BC �±: = E<;=t= FX \¡X CS

p qR TsJXst BX BG �= BC ��6 7 4C u SR:t@ {ì} SRTU

C M SRTÞ�6 7 BG@ {SRT9J�F�¶ [

C�= [

C ´Q6¶ SR:CaR �L� SRTi�@ {8G= [] ´FX

9ÒÙQº BX �6u B9 D F6 D 4L u 9>�F�¶ CSRT�L 7 Q9JRT® Bkj F9 D N< Q9u�Å SRTU

C M Bkj N< NOCu C; Q9J ij; Bkj@{ C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u BX O]uQ� FX 8G= 1977 SRTh QR uQsJ ij QR JG ;<= �lL M OR Jmpw QR JX QR JG@~F

9 D QR JX C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u `9 V C? [

] ´Fij@{ 6¿�= \ 6 M i} Ìs�lf SRTi�@{F9 D 4R u 9WQ6 u SRTUC M Bkj@{ C¼ RM;Q9u SRTh

;=O9Jy= Q9u�= \ 6 M Bkj@~Q9 uQ6¶ \ 6 M Bkj{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : 9>ZQ56 7 vs�lf Bkj{ ORJI ORJ

pI;FC? O57= NQ p�: 8Öh 6¿�= SRTh cab EQR J� 6>?Qd BI QCJ9:= EFmf Qæ 4_ BlÎ�Å gFq= BI QCJmf Q9us8L : Bkj 4_ �� LW�= [X 9>IQR JI FX =s86 : Cí=t B

C D QÜH [X pop|FX

[X \] VG Bkj ;<= CE= EFC D<t E<; sOR JH B

C D EQi �< 4R u 9WQ6 u [X Bkj@{as � � 8�R JLT�! \ 6 VX \ 6 VX C;Q5

CM QCßy [X [9 ´Q6¶ Bkj ØCJ6? [X 9W;Fz SRTh@{ 6>6? SRTâ

CJ6? [9 ´Fij SRTi� F9 D SR: C;Q5

CM QCßy 8X BX \¾s8L : [

9 ´Q6¶ SRTi�{[] ´FX 4µ]Jq� SRTU

C M Bkj{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : F9 D �lL M NQ p� 6>?Qd vaR �Ï �lL M pg;=C8G Fij [G 4_ g= BX OÍ6 D R u= ;<= 9>ZQ56 7 =8X SRT®{

ORJI ORJ

pI;FC? O57= NQ p�: SRTh 4R u QCJmf Q9J ijQL¶ EFij 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! 4_ �� 8p:Q9 u QR ut QR JG Bkj Ìs�lf N< BX 4_ SRT5i} SRT

9JCTh [X \] VG SRTi� ;<= QR u·6 u QR JG Bkj@{\¡X B

C D QUf 4_ SRTh B

C D ós8R :st 4s JCT�½ 9WQ�·h [X@{\¡X B

C D QUf B� s;Q� CSRT9u Bs �

CT�½ SRT9uQ�·h SRT

]uFij ì} B

C D 4R u 4R u QUf Bkj@{[] ´Q�6 M F6 ? eL Kf B9 �mf Fij SRT5i} 9>�F�¶ FX B

C D QL �6M Q� [] ´FX t;t

43

SRTUC M Bkj@ {SRT5i} g= s>C �xRVH;QL u FX B

C D QL �6M Q� t;t Bkj@ ~g= CSRT]u�= FX B

C D QL �6M Q� t;t Bkj ;<= ì} 4R u QCuQ9J6: B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� 4_ C8°L JRTLu [

s ´;QL u ;<= \C V9T 6¶ \ 6 M democratic

SRT9JZQ56 7 SRTi�@~8G= 9>�F�¶ ¯�6 7 \ 6 M B

] D Q6¶ [G F9 D ì} SRTUC M SRTÞ�6 7 BG@{ì} 9ÒR:;Fm�67

BX B] �H SR:s8H BG@{B9 �lÐR ut SRTi� 6W= CEFX v;Q5i} 9ÒR:;Fm�67 g= ÂQ 6 D FX `9 VC? B

C D 8X [X po

p|FX Q9u8X Bkj ;<= i} B] D Qh C;�= B

] D Fij �FH SRTi�{ 6W= es T R D89: rQ� [GOCu C; Bkj@~4R u \6VC: [X [GOCu C; \

9 M@{�FH F9 D B9 �mf Bl9 M EQCu 4_ vaR �Ï es T R D89: rQ� BX OÍ6 D BG �= SRTU

C M Bkj@~4ÞCuFR �X 4R u \6V

C: [X [GOCu C; Bkj@~ 9W;Q p 6 D [] ´Fij Bkj{ 6W= N< es T� s;= rQ� 8L : \ 6 M L¼

CVmLM B] �G {SRTi� 8Öh es T R D89: rQ� BX OÍ6 D �� Q� BlÎ�Å 49JL: SRTU

C M Bkj@{8Öh BC �±: = EFL K6M FX@~\C VL:= EF°

CD FX ì} eL Kf Ìt BX SRT]uQ6¶@ {ì} [

] ´FX compromise 4C u SR:8X@ {QCu�= B9 �kj QL¶ Fij ]<�=@{N< SRT

]u·L¶ BG EQR JHFG@~·6¶ <t g= g]<Qi � FX@~·6¶ <t R MaL �� sW;FX FX@~·6¶ <t sÒR:8s :8�R JI FX@~·6¶ <t É·�= tQ6 u�= FX@~8Öh g= CSRT

]u�= BX R u= COCPQ� FX \ 6 M BC D ·6¶ [X

9W C;Q6¶= SRTUC M SR:t BG{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : tFx�Å CEQC¶ [] C8�L¶= 6>?Qd{aù9�

CKÅ {CaR �µL u

6WQCJ6? tFx�Å CEQC¶ [] C8�L¶= : 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! SRTh cab R u= s>C �� EFH Qæ@{

cab R u= s>C ��{ supporting each and every word F6 ? OR JpI;FC? NQ p�

BC D QUf@~F| ~OßR� F6 ? eL Kf EFmC M= B

C D QUf We support it.{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! SRTh LW�= BI 9>I=FC?;t E<8X Qæ 4_ v;Q5i}discussion ÆQC¶ B°¶ �Å SRTh �

C¶=t Fij \ i}; Bkj{Do not prorogue the Session. One and No.2 6¿�= 9W=; 9u oRT6uFL ? Bs �

CT�½ Ì;FL D Fij SRT]uQ6¶ BG F6 ? 9W=8X= COh í<ap Ó B

] D Fij {SRTi� R u= 9WQ6 u Q� eXt Bkj 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! 4_ EQR J� 6>?Qd FX vaR �Ï 9WQ6 u Q� eL Kf SRTU

C M QCu8X

44

B] �kj QL¶@ ~EFmC M= BC D eL Kf SRTU

C M QCu8X@ { 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! g= `¡y [X EQR J�°C P 8G= \¡X ;<=

s>C �xC M;FG SRTh SRT

9uFij F9 D CS6?;t �l6 M 8R: C;< would have been sacked.@~ CS6 ?;t �l6 M FX rQÄCD QR ut Q9uQ6¶@{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! 4R u s>C �xRVH;QL u QR u 4R u F6 ? LW�= B

C D 9W=tF�� v;Q6¶ B] �X SRTi� �� EFR �X SRTU

C M B] �X LW�= BC D@~EFR �X p;FR �²

C�X Q�f; Ì;Q� oRT6u s;<8X EFC DQ CD=

FX ;<= Ì;Q5i} 8R : C;< 49JL: SRTUC M QR JX 8X Bkj ; B

9 D Fij SRTi�@{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! �� 9W=; FX [s ´ v< 4L u ;Q6 u ;Q6 u QR u�= Bkj �°9J

CKÅ C8C:8p:FR �°R Js : 4L u@~SRTh \¡X BI \

C Vxpwt SRTU

C M Q9Jlf;@{8R: C;< `ÁîZ= [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u@ ~ 9>I=FC?;t Q� Áö²H Bkj 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! 4_ 8R: C;< `

ÁîZ= [X 9>I=FC?;t 4L u \Å;�= �R �L? B

C D CEQR J�;t SRTh CS�QCd ;<= pÒHQpu BC �CTÎu BX B] �H QUf Bkj@{

eL Kf Q�ÐR ut SR:8X CE8p:FR �°R Js :@~\w= CEt@~\w= 9ÒÙ< LW�= Q� reaction QCu�= B] �kj QL¶{I am

frank Mr. Speaker N;Q6 u BÎ�6M EQR J� 6>?Qd [X R u= statement []�= 4_

\¡X `¡y [X resignation [X 9WQ6 u vaR �Ï c�À BI SRTUC M Bkj@ { 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�!

=O C¶ FX SRTCuQh@~ 6WQCJ6? ;QpJC: \ 6 M Ì;Q5i} 9>I<t SRTi�@{4R u statement �� EQURM �z�=

4Uf Q9JR:t =;Q5i}F9 D O� es MQ� =s86 : Fij Q9uQ6¶ s>C �xRVH;QL u Q� ;<= oRT6u s;<8X CEQ

CD= LW�= t8G Ûx67 Fij B

9 D Q6¶{rQ¶a³6 M eL KfF6 ? =Fij N< =Fij SRT�ÐR ut {BG F6 ? EQR J�°C P [

] ´Fij SRTi�@ ~SRTp�C�C�H [

] ´Fij SRTi� CE= 4L u `i} 46 uF

9 D 8X SRT® BG@ { 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! We are with the Parliament, we are with the Constitution, we are with the

democratic system. [C ´Q6 ua³Å SR:8X Do not prorogue ;<= 8G= v;<aC b

SRT�6 ��w

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! F9 D s>C �]:=F6 ? ØCJsT� \ 6 M ·6 u SRT® 4_Q9u 4µhQÍ� Q9J°L¶ Bkj ; ;<= 4R u ØCJ6? BC �±: = v8

C?�= \Ë�C�� BÎ�RV

9TCu 9u L¼CVmLM B

] D Q6¶@{ 9>m6M 9>m6M 4R u8�p�{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT� : 4R u8�

p� \67@{R u= sOCJ�R JI \67 �6JR:8C:�= `] M=8L : as �

CTh c�= CEQ9JqXQL u{

45

`ÁîZ=8R : C;< CEQ9JqXQL u ) 6WQCJ6? O5�Å C;=F

C D �R Dap Ó:( [

s ´FlL 7 \w R u= 9WQ6 u@ { 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! \ 6 M= ÌaR �Ï [

] ´Q�6 M tFx�Å CEQC¶ [] C8�L¶= 6>?Qd B

C D F6 ? 9WQ6 u [X@~SR Th cab g= 4L u vs;Fl9 M \w 9>?QCd< QCu8X Q9J ijQL¶ EFij{ Leader of the Opposition [X

8R:�Ë9D vs86 : inspiring \

9 M ;<= SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ EFmC M= BC D CS6 ? 9WQ6 u

CO6¶ Q� ;QU Áç= QR JX Bkj LW�= CSRT»R D B] �

C: Qh @ 4_ÌaR �Ï rt BX 9WQ6 uCO6¶ [X [

C ´Q56 789: [X Bkj@ { 6WQCJ6?

8�R JLT�! ì} BC D vs86 : struggle [X Bkj democracy BX B] �H~4Ïa9 ��Å B

C D struggle [X@ ~SRT5i} g= Q� =;FL D =;FL D c=a9 �õ= Bkj@ {4Ïa9 ��Å BX e9 MQ� �h 8X ì}

BC D 4R u OUn QR JX Q�

9 M 4_ ì} \ 6 M democracy BX B] �H ÚQ p CD= A= CEQ9JqXQL u SRTh

9ÒR:;Fm�67 [X [HQ�6M~ rule of law ;<= Constitution [X supremacy BX B] �H �h 8X OU67<O6¶ SR:8X BG@{ 6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! o6? FX B9 �mf SRTi� 4_ F6 ? �Ä

pq� 9ÒÙ< BI B

C D ;C8G BX OÍ6 D \C VôR D o6? SRTh exile \ 6 M �hQ p� Fij@~o6? SRTh SRTµR J6? \ 6 M �hQ p�

EFij ;<= o6? SRTh ØCu� L¿;Qh \ 6 M �hQ p� Fij@~QR JX [] ´FX 4R u ÛyF9 D 8X Q9J�� Bkj 4_ SRTh

[] ´FX 49JI=F

C KCM=O C¶ \¡X `¡y Q� FR D CE8s : HEF Qæ@{r=F| \ i} =OR JL: SRTU

C M Q9uFij{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! 4R u 6>ÇC �� B

C D �= BC D Q6¶ SRTi�@ ~4R u SRT

9J�F�¶ [C�= [

C ´Q6¶ SRTi�@{=O� \¡X [X 9>�F�¶ g= QRJ

C:t BX ;OCu= SRTUC M \ i}; Bkj@{ 6>I B

9 D �= SRTi� ;<= B°±¶ SRTi�B9 D Q6¶@{

CS�R JH R u= principle Bkj F6 ? SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ o6? FX CEQ6 u�Ù SRTUC M QR JX Q6¶

Q9J��@ {SRT9J�F�¶ CEQ6 u�Ù@ ~ÌaR �Ï B] ��: � Á�

CD SRTi�@ ~ÌaR �Ï rFz= SRTi�@ ~O5�ä= A CS6 ? FX SRTh CEQ6 u�Ù \¡X 9W;Fz SRTh SRTU

C M 8X Q9J��@ {49J6T®= R u= 9>�F�¶ SRTUC M gt SRT

9J�F�¶ \ 6 M SRTµh F9 D SRTh CEQ6 u�Ù 8X Q9J�� EFij@ ~BC �±: = B] ��: � Á�

CD FX CEQ6 u�Ù SRTUC M 8X Q9J��@ {;<= �lL M

v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP CEQC¶ BC D 9>m6M �RJÇ²

9D BX e9 MQ� v;Q� 9WQ6 u [] ´Q9J6: Bkj@{EFmC M= B

C D 4R u QUf Bkj 4_ \¡X `¡y Q� \p VHQpu Q� ;=t8X 4C u 6¿F B

C D QÜCDQh Bkj@ ~4C u ì} BC D [

] ´FX

46

9>I=FC?;t [X Bkj{4R u 49JL: SRTUC M Bq�T_ L>lL7 QR JG@~EFR �X L>lL7 QR JG ;<= LW�= B9 �

C: Q6¶ SRTi� 4_ F6 ? ai �Q6 u Ûx6�Å QÜH BX Bl

s V�T6u B] D Fij SRTi� N< C;<; BC �

9T_ L¼w B9 �H F6 D SRTi� ;<= BC �9T_

sWFl6 7 B9 �H F6 D SRTi�@{8G= CE= [X CEQ6 uC; BI 4R u QUf QR JG Bkj F

9 D �lL M LW�= CEQ6¶ SRT® 4_ g= BX ;OCu= \

C V9T_ [] ´QL �w Bkj ;<= QCJ9T_ sWFl6 7 Bkj@{r=F| \ i} =OR JL: SRTU

C M Q9uFij@{�ÄHQ6 u ~ R Jl

s M 6ÒX BI SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij ;<= e�R ut Qi �; EFij 4_ 4R u ¿�À ¿�À BI ai � ¿�À BI threaten B

9 D 8X SRTi�@ {8G= �� 6¿F BX N=86 :aÓ [X QR u 6¿F [X RVs : [X

v;Q5i} 9WQ�·h 4C u \ 6 M [9 ´Fij 6Ò

9 : \ 6 M SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ EFmC M= BC D 4R u ;=t8X =t=

QCu8X Q�9 M@~4ÞCuFR �X EQURM [X protection F6 ? Bkj N< 6¿F [X 4ÏCt v;=t Bkj ;<= 6¿F �ÄR �s :;�= 245 SRTh 4ÏCt ;=t Bkj 4_ N< g= [X protection Ì8X@{F9 D SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ 6¿F B

C D �lL M \ 6 M 4R u ;=t8X =t= QCu8X Bkj{ 6¿F BC D OCJL? CEt B°U±M 4R u QUf Q�

9 M ’ [

]�= oRD= [L´ ;�= [X c�À BI 4R u QR u�= Q�

9 M 4_ CE= ÉQ59M buildings [X 9> ÁÀQÃ?

6¿F BÅ CtBX 4R u{Bkj CE= FX messageQ�9 M 4_ 8�t= Q� C¿; 9>� QCu8X ;<= g=

tF6 ?<Q6 uBX 8G= N< g= c�À C¿; B9 D 8X SRTi� F9 D �lL M 6¿F \

C VL:= 4ÏCt v;=t B] D Q�6 V

C: ~[G oRT®FL D \


C: [G ;<= �lL M C;86 KCVR:; \


C: {[G 8G= �� [X v;Q5i} ØCJsTRJ� 4C u \ 6 M [

9 ´Fij F9 D SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ \¡X \ 6 M [] ´=<;;Q� BI

B°U±M QR u CE= [X c�À BI [] ´FX 9Ò�ap R TLu Q� 6¿F FX 4p�O C¶ Q�9 M F6 ? Q9J�s86 : Q6¶ Qi �; Q�

9 M QR u 6¿F [X c�À BI 8G= [

] ´FX g= ¿�À [X [] ´=<;;Q� SRTh’o6? ¿�À BI N< FH �

B9 �kj QL¶ SRTi� @ 4_tO p 9D QR JX B

] D Q6¶ ;<= Bq�TÎ¶ EFL K6M FX BG �= QR JX =Fij Bkj@ ~EF9 D;FZ FX BG �= QR JX Fij Bkj =@~ CE= [X human shield BX BH =F? BI CE= BI ÉQ� QR JH Bkj Qi �;Q6¶ F9 D SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ 6¿F B

C D �lL M \ 6 M CE= BI 4R u 9WQ6 u [C ´8X \

9 M 4_ Q R D= �lL MF9 DQæFij Q R D= QæFij F9 D g= BI B°U±M B°U±M a9 �U6M Bkj 4_ `i} QCJL:= 4µhQÍ� resolve SR:8X{

47

4R u 9WQ6 u �ÄHQ6 u L¼w Bkj’ v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: 6>?Qd BC D QUf Bkj@{SRTh tFC? tF6 ?F� Q�9 M

’ \ÈR Js : CEF QR u�= 4_ v;tQ� 6>?Qd ;<= CE=��n CEQC¶ 6>?Qd Chief of Army

StaffBI QCJ°h B9 �kj QL¶ {SRTi� v;Oi �FL ? 6>?Qd ×QÃ9D= BI \ i} ÌaR �Ï gQL u @ \ i}Bls V�T6u

B] D Fij Bl

9 M{EFmC M= BC D BlÎ�Å QUf Bkj 4_ N< eL ?FL D SRTi�Bkj ; 4_ `

] M=8L : as � CTh BI 9W C;Q6¶=

BH BX SR:t 4_ 8G= N< QCJ°h NQL¶ SRTi�Bkj ; F9 D 9W C;Q6¶= SR:t 4_ Chief of Army Staff �h SRT®@{SRTh B

C D R u= sOCJ�R JI SRTh 4Uf QR ut 4_ 8G= N< QCJ°h SRTi�B9 �kj QL¶@~ 9>I=FC?;t CE= [X c�À BI Bkj F9 D CE= FX �R �L? ;<aC b �h SRT®@{4R u v;Q� 9WQ6 u Bkj ’\

C V9:= 9WQ6 u Bkj ;<= g= FX Qìs86 : Qìs8L ? BX 4R u poRTLu 8X SRTi�Bkj ; 4_ 8R : C;< `

ÁîZ= BC D 6¿F

FX beg QR JX Bkj 4_ g= BI v;Q5i} CEQ6¶ SRT]u=s�lL 7 ;<= SRT5i} [

] ´FX 49JI=; SR:t{

6WQCJ6? 8�R JLT�! F6 ? Resolution pass [] ´Fij Bkj’ v;Oi �FL ? ;QpJC: \ÈP CEQC¶

BC D QUf {Bkj SRTh B

C D R u= CSRT]u�= Q� �°¶ QR JH =Fij {Bkj =aR �Ï QCJL:= 4R u�

Á�CD Bkj ;<= SRTh Q9Jl6 ��w EFij 4_ tFx�Å CEQC¶ Q� 4R u�

Á�CD =s86 : ÂF6 �CÇ� Bkj@ ~; sOR JH c�= vt CSp qR D C;FL D�= Q�

4R u�Á�CD =s86 : ÂF6 �CÇ� Bkj’g= B°h QÍ� SRTh ;<= C;; sOR JH Q� 4R u�

Á�CD =s86 : ÂF6 �CÇ� Bkj g=;<= B°h QÍ� SRTh \¡X \ 6 M ÂF6 �CÇ� BI ÂF6 �CÇ� B�D � Á�

CD BI =aR �Ï 4R u�Á�CD `f SRTU

C M {Bkj F6 ? Resolution pass QR JX QR JG Bkj ’R u= R u= c8? [X v;=O�QL u QCu8X =aR �Ï CÆ��

Bkj ;<= 4ÏCt v;=t Bkj ;<= SRTh A=ÚQ p CD= QCJL:= CÆ�� <= 4ÏCt; v;=t E]<Q�6 V

C: Qæ{ Mr. Speaker: The House is adjourned to meet again on Monday, the 1st of September at 5 p.m.

48

(The House was adjourned to meet again on Monday, the 1st September, 2014 at 5:00 p.m.)

national assembly of pakistan · 2015. 6. 11. · srth in the last 67, 68 years srth eqc9jqxqlu...

Documents